<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Avram Fechter on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Avram Fechter on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@avramfechter?source=rss-6e2fda3a33e8------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 06:23:27 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@avramfechter/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[2020 Prez/Senate Race: Sept 2020]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@avramfechter/2020-prez-senate-race-sept-2020-b4af1dd58997?source=rss-6e2fda3a33e8------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b4af1dd58997</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[2020-senate-elections]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[presidential-campaign]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Avram Fechter]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 24 Sep 2020 19:14:37 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-09-24T19:14:37.950Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>(charts available at the link below)</p><p><a href="https://www.dropbox.com/s/n6ekshmespiv5l3/Fechter%202020%20Electrion%20Forecast%20Sept%202020.pdf?dl=0">https://www.dropbox.com/s/n6ekshmespiv5l3/Fechter%202020%20Electrion%20Forecast%20Sept%202020.pdf?dl=0</a></p><p>Written Over Several Days — Published on September 24, 2020</p><p>Big Picture</p><p>Biden is ahead by ~6%-~7% in national polling averages while the four major political handicappers (538 forecast, Crystal Ball, Cook Report, and Inside Elections) put enough states in the “leans Biden” column or better (as opposed to TOSSUP or Leans/Likely/Safe Trump) for Biden to win 278 electoral college votes with additional states representing 73 electoral colleges votes rated as “TOSSUP”.</p><p>Summary of key things to watch:</p><p>· Florida. If either candidate wins by more than 0.5% — the state will be called before midnight on election night. Florida reports/counts quickly. Florida should be able to be called by 11pm EST. If Biden wins Florida — he will win the electoral college. If Biden loses Florida — he could still win — but it’ll be a LATE night (at best). PA/WI/MI/MN count slowly.</p><p>· Maricopa County, Arizona. If Biden wins Maricopa by 4%+ (which the Democrat did in 2018 in the US Senate race) — he wins Arizona. If he wins Arizona and 2 out of 3 of MI/PA/WI — and holds the Clinton states — he wins the Electoral College. Maricopa is a good bell weather to see how strong Biden overperforms Clinton among seniors and college-educated white voters (there was a significant shift away from Trump to the Dem Senate candidate in the 2018 midterms). We should be able to call Arizona by 4am EST.</p><p>· Biden % in polling averages for MI/PA/MN/WI. He is getting 48%-50% of the vote in all four states in the polling averages. Clinton never got higher than 45%-46% in those states in the polling averages. Margin between opposing candidates matters less as one candidate gets closer to 50%.</p><p>· Pennsylvania is where things are most likely to go wrong as they count the votes. “Naked” ballots in Pennsylvania might be the 2020 equivalent of “hanging chads”.</p><p>Meanwhile, the “Big 4” rate the battle for control of the Senate as too close to call — placing 49 seats in the “leans D” or better column with 2 seats rated as “TOSSUP”.</p><p>Normally, we would not look at polling data/election forecasts this far ahead of election day. However, this is no ordinary election. 55%+ of the country plans to cast their ballot ahead of election day (either by mail or in person early voting). 154,000 people (as of Sept 22) have already VOTED across the country. The opportunity for late swings in public opinion is dramatically reduced when so many people plan to vote so far ahead of the official “Election Day”.</p><p>Many of you might remember a similar memo that the author published in 2016 forecasting a Clinton victory. It turned out to be wrong (obviously). Despite the author’s clear miss in 2016, please keep reading, this memo will utilize lessons learned from 2016 in its analysis of the current 2020 environment. First, we will analyze the national polling for Biden (and compare to 2016). Second, we will go state by state to assess how the national polls are translating to state level data (and compare to 2016). Last, we will look at the individual Senate races to outline the state of play as we enter October. The author will likely publish 1–2 updates of the memo between now and Election Day.</p><p>National Polling Indicates Presidential Race: LIKELY BIDEN POPULAR VOTE (4%-9% popular vote margin)</p><p>There are several poll aggregators that collect and average multiple polls in a given race to provide a composite polling average. Real Clear Politics (“RCP”) was doing this in the 2016 race AND is also doing so in the 2020 race (at both the national and state level). This memo will utilize the RCP average to compare what we know now to what we thought we knew then.</p><p>The current RCP average has Biden receiving 49.5% of the vote, 6.5% points ahead of Trump’s 43%. Only 7.5% of the electorate is undecided or voting third party. In 2016, on the morning of the election, RCP had Clinton 3.3% ahead with 45.5% to 42.2% — with 12.3% of the electorate undecided. Clinton wound up winning by 2.1%, 48.2% to 46.1% — with 5.7% of the electorate voting third party. Importantly, during the 2016 race Clinton’s vote share in the RCP polling average never got higher than 46.2%.</p><p>Biden’s polling average being at ~49%-~50% is in many ways more important than the margin between Biden and Trump. Biden does not need to win many undecided/third party leaning voters in order to win the popular vote — he just needs to turn out the voters who have already made up their minds.</p><p>Historically, Obama won by 7.2% with 53% of the vote in 2008 and 3.9% with 51% of the vote in 2012 while Clinton won the popular vote by 2.1% with 48.2% of the vote in 2016. The fivethirtyeight.com (“538”) 2020 Presidential forecast (which uses a combination of polling data and recent election results to derive its forecast — so it is not purely a polling average) projects that Biden will receive 52.9% of the vote and will win by 6.8%. This is comparable to Senator Obama’s 2008 win over Senator McCain. Even if the 538 average is overstating Biden’s support by 2% (which would be a greater polling error than in 2016) — this would project Biden winning 50.9% of the vote and winning by ~4.8% — which is comparable to President Obama’s 2012 win over Mitt Romney and consistent with the current RCP polling average (Biden would only need to win ~33% of the remaining undecided/third party voters in order to go from 49.5% to 50.9%). Conversely — if the polls understate Biden’s performance (which is just as likely as overstating) — Biden would win by the popular vote by 8.8% (indicating he split the 5.6% of undecided/thirty party voters).</p><p>Biden’s 49.5% in the current RCP average is 4% better than Clinton’s final 45.5% results in 2016. If Biden uniformly overperforms Clinton by 4% in every state, he wins Michigan, Pennsylvania, Wisconsin, Arizona and Florida while narrowly losing North Carolina and Ohio. Biden only needs three out of the five (MI/PA/WI/FL/AZ) to win the Presidency (assuming he holds all of Clinton’s 2016 states).</p><p>This race at the national level feels like it has a climate that resembles 2008 more than 2012/2016. Author predicts a 5.5%-6.5% popular vote margin for Biden (greater than Obama 2012 — less than Obama 2008).</p><p>State By State Analysis Indicates Electoral College: LEANS BIDEN — — BIDEN WINS 279–320 EC VOTES</p><p>Of course, a 4% shift in Biden’s favor nationally will not perfectly translate to a 4% shift in Biden’s favor in every state (based upon each individual state’s demographics). Biden is doing much better than Clinton among white college educated voters and seniors while improving slightly among white non-college educated voters and doing marginally worse (among smaller sample sizes — so these results should be taken with a grain of salt) among African-American and Latino voters. Only a state by state analysis of voter trends, demographics, and current state level polling can provide an assessment of where the electoral college stands today.</p><p>The Crystal Ball (UVA Professor Larry Sabato) projects 269 electoral votes as “LEANS BIDEN” or better with another 66 electoral votes projected as “TOSSUP”. Crystal Ball projected a Clinton win in 2016 with 322 ECs — incorrectly placing NC/FL/PA/MI as “leans Clinton” and WI as “likely Clinton”. Crystal Ball did not include any “TOSSUPs” in its final forecast — excluding “Leans Clinton” — CB had 232 ECs in the “safe/likely” Clinton category.</p><p>Cook Political Report projects 290 for Biden and a total of 351 as Biden or TOSSUP. In 2016 they had 278 “leans Clinton” and another 46 “TOSSUP” totaling 324 possible Biden ECs on the day before Election Day. They got Wisconsin/Michigan/Pennsylvania wrong (lean Clinton by Trump won them) while Trump swept the TOSSUPs.</p><p>538.com has 278 in the “lean Biden” or better and a total 351 “TOSSUPS/LEAN BIDEN+”. 538’s final forecast on Election Day in 2016 had 262 ECs in the “leans Clinton” category (their version of that is a state with a candidate having between 50%-60% chance to win) with another 50 in the “TOSSUP” column (FL/NC/NV). 538 incorrectly labeled PA/MI/WI in the “leans Clinton” column. 538 puts Biden’s current odds of winning at 77% (with odds depressed to factor in unexpected events between now and Election Day). 538 put Clinton’s odds of winning at 71.4% the morning of the 2016 election.</p><p>Inside Elections has Biden at 319 ECs with another 31 ECs in the TOSSUP category –totaling 350 ECs. IE had 263 ECs in “leans Clinton” or better in their final 2016 forecast. They incorrectly had MI/PA in the “leans Clinton” category.</p><p>The RCP polling averages have 221 electoral votes as being in lean Biden or better with another 210 electoral college votes being TOSSUP. However, RCP is VERY conservative it its forecasting — for example — their average has Biden at 50.1% in Wisconsin and leading by 6%+ — but they still label Wisconsin a TOSSUP.</p><p>It was the state level polling that missed so badly in 2016 in certain states, not the national polls.</p><p>As you see in the table above — the RCP polling average projected margin between the candidates missed the actual margin by 6.5% in Wisconsin, 7% in NE-2 (Nebraska allocates 1 vote per congressional district and 2 votes for the statewide winner), 6.5% in Iowa, 10% in ME-2 (same in Maine). Those, combined with the 2.4% miss in Pennsylvania and the 3.6% miss in Michigan, determined the outcome. If Clinton had won every state where she had a polling lead — she would be President. Two factors make 2020 state polling data more reliable; first — there are less undecided voters than in 2016 (creating less volatility in the data) and second — there is decreased support for third party candidates compared to 2016 (enabling the leading candidate to get closer to 50% of the vote in a state).</p><p>Biden has been consistently polling better than Clinton for months now — both in national polling and in the key battleground states. Clinton never got close to 50% in the PA/WI/MN/MI/AZ or national polls in 2016 — Biden is already there or within striking distance now. The table below shows where the polling averages are in each state (both Biden % and margin between the candidates), compares Biden’s current margin to Clinton’s margin on election day in 2016, and applies the delta to the actual 2016 election results. Last, but not least, it also show’s the author’s current projection of Biden’s margin of victory in each state.</p><p>Arizona: Leans Biden (Fechter forecast)</p><p>· Biden is currently at 49.2% in the RCP average — which is 4.6% better than Clinton’s number on election day in 2016. Apply a 4.6% swing to Arizona — and Biden wins by 1.1% (Biden implied margin column)</p><p>· This is probably understating Biden’s final result. Arizona has a higher percentage of seniors and college educated white voters than the national average. Biden’s improvements among these demographic groups compared to Clinton will have a larger impact in Arizona than the typical US State. Additionally, Biden is showing no loss of support among Arizona Latino voters compared to Clinton’s numbers. The Democratic US Senate candidate (Sinema) carried Arizona in 2018 by 2.4% (defeating an incumbent) with a similar coalition.</p><p>· Maricopa County (Phoenix) represents ~66% of the electorate in Arizona — Trump won it by 2.9% while winning the state by 3.5% in 2016. Sinema won Maricopa by 4.2% while winning the state by 2.4%. Maricopa is where a disproportionate amount of Arizona’s seniors and college-educated voters live — their shift away from Trump between 2016–2018 explains Sinema’s victory. Recent polls have Biden up by as much as 9% in Maricopa — which would translate into a ~6% statewide victory.</p><p>· Even prior to COVID — 75%+ of Arizona’s voters cast their votes by mail before election day. In 2018 — the AP didn’t call the race for Sinema until 6 days after election day as the Board of Elections waited for vote-by-mail ballots to trickle in. However, the state has instituted reforms to their counting procedure since 2018. Now — it is HIGHLY likely that by 1am PST of election night — 94% of Maricopa will be counted and reported (along with 90% of the state). If Biden wins Arizona by 1% or more — it will be clear by 4am EST, Wednesday, November 4.</p><p>· RCP polls in 2016 –4. RCP polls in 2020–6. It should be noted the 2016 polls didn’t miss the mark in Arizona.</p><p>· Cook has Arizona Lean D. 538 has Lean D (as shown in the table) with Biden at 51.1% and winning by 3.6%. Crystal Ball calls the race a TOSSUP. Inside Elections has Tilt D (they have Safe/Likely/Lean/Tilt/Tossup categories).</p><p>· Biden 4.5% — the evidence suggests that the underlying dynamics of the 2020 Presidential race in Arizona are the same or better for Democrats than the 2018 midterm elections in Arizona. (SEE THE SUMMARY OF THE ARIZONA 2020 SENATE RACE). Maricopa County makes Arizona more likely to vote for Biden than PA (raw vote victory — Biden might PA by a higher percentage than AZ in the end — but the cone of uncertainty is wider in PA for reasons discussed below). It is rapidly becoming the Clark County of Arizona statewide politics in the age of Trump (see Nevada below to understand the Clark County reference). Even discounting Biden’s Maricopa lead down to 6% from 9% (to account for MOE in the Maricopa polling) — that still translates to the 4.5% statewide victory projected above.</p><p>Florida: Tossup (Fechter forecast)</p><p>· Biden at 48.6% in RCP average — which is 2% better than Clinton’s number in 2016. Apply a 2% swing to Florida — and Biden wins by 0.6% (Biden implied margin column)</p><p>· Obama won Florida by 2.8% in 2008 and 0.9% in 2012. Dems lost Florida by 1.4% in 2016 and ~0.2% in 2018. There have been over 51 million votes cast for President since 1992 in Florida. Less than 20,000 votes separate Republicans and Democrats during that time period. This is going to be close — don’t expect any accurate poll to show anything else.</p><p>· The greater Tampa region is the swingiest area of the state. Obama won it. Trump won it. Add up the vote margin for the City of Tampa, Citrus County, Hernando County, and Pasco County. If Trump is doing as well (raw vote margin) as he did in 2016 — he probably wins Florida. If he is underperforming by 100,000+ in raw vote margin — he probably loses Florida. For more — read here……….. <a href="http://steveschale.com/">http://steveschale.com/</a></p><p>· Even prior to COVID — 66%+ of Florida’s voters cast their votes by mail before election day. The AP called the race at 10:50pm EST on election night in 2016.</p><p>· RCP polls in 2016 –7. RCP polls in 2020–8. The 2016 polls didn’t miss the mark. Florida is just always within the polling margin of error. 538 projects a 1.2% Biden win with 50.5% of the vote (on par with Obama 2012).</p><p>· All forecasters have Florida as a TOSSUP. If the author had to make a prediction here — author thinks that the dynamics of the 2020 race is closer to 2012 than 2016. Biden has much higher favorability ratings than Clinton (closer to Obama numbers) while Trump is as disliked, if not more so, than in 2016. Biden is doing ~15% better among seniors in Florida than Clinton did in 2016 (which is also an improvement on the 2018 Dem performance in Florida among seniors) — which is consistent with the national polls. Those voters that dislike both Biden and Trump are now favoring Biden (Trump won voters that disliked both Trump and Clinton). Republicans in the past have always won the senior vote (they’ve always won the senior vote in the past; even when Democrats won). If Biden holds his lead among the seniors in the state, he should win. Needless to say, COVID was a major factor in Trump losing support among Florida seniors and those voters that dislike both candidates or voted 3rd party previously.</p><p>· Biden +0.6% (worse than 2012 but better than 2016/2018).</p><p>Michigan: Leans Biden (Fechter forecast)</p><p>· Biden is currently at 48.2% in the RCP average — which is 2.8% better than Clinton’s number on election day in 2016. Apply a 2.8% swing to Michigan and Biden wins by 2.6% (Biden implied margin column).</p><p>· Gretchen Whitmer (D) won the Governor’s race in Michigan by 6.9%. This was before COVID. Michigan has been hit hard by COVID — with 60%+ of Michigan voters approving of Whitmer’s COVID response and disapproving of Trump’s. Obama won the state by 9.5% in 2012 while Trump only won by 0.2% in 2016.</p><p>· RCP polls in 2016 –5. RCP polls in 2020–6. Polls missed by 3.6% in 2016 — which is on the OUTSIDE edge of their margin of error. However, Clinton was polling at 45.4% with a 3.4% lead and 12.6% voting third party/undecided compared to Biden’s current 48.2% and 6.1% lead with 9.5% undecided/third party voters. Biden only needs 20% of the undecided/third party vote to break the 50% mark.</p><p>· Biden’s 6.1% lead in the RCP polling average is consistent with Whitmer’s 6.9% win in 2018.</p><p>· For these reasons and a few more — all 4 major forecasters cited in this memo have MI Lean Biden. 538 projects a 7.9% win for Biden with 53.5% of the vote.</p><p>· MI was called on November 26 when the margin was 0.2% — — if Michigan is close — we won’t know the result of the state on election night.</p><p>· Biden +6.9% (Whitmer 2018 margin). Biden will reassemble Whitmer’s coalition.</p><p>Minnesota: Likely Biden (Fechter forecast)</p><p>· Biden is currently at 51.6% in the RCP average — which is 5.2% better than Clinton’s number in the RCP average on election day in 2016. Apply a 5.2% swing to Minnesota and Biden wins by 6.7% (Biden implied margin column).</p><p>· Clinton only carried Minnesota by 1.5%. This is the state most political analysts believed was most likely to flip Clinton-Trump based upon demographic trends. However, all of the data indicates the state has swung hard to Biden (driven by college educated white voters in the suburbs). Biden is ahead by 10.2% in the RCP average and above 50%. Minnesota voters back Biden over Trump not only on the issue of dealing with COVID, but also “law and order/racial tensions”. Even the RCP website identifies this state as “Leans Biden”.</p><p>· RCP polls in 2016 –5. RCP polls in 2020–5. Minnesota was not a polling miss in 2016.</p><p>· For these reasons and a few more — all 4 major forecasters (538/Cook/Crystal Ball/Inside Elections) cited here have Minnesota Lean Biden or better.</p><p>· Biden +7.7% (Obama 2012 margin)</p><p>· Minnesota was called at 11:00am the day after the election when the margin was 1.5%.</p><p>Pennsylvania: Leans Biden (Fechter forecast)</p><p>· Biden is currently at 48.8% in the RCP average — which is 2.5% better than Clinton’s number in the RCP average on election day in 2016. Apply a 2.5% swing to Pennsylvania from 2016 to 2020 and Biden wins the state by 2.0% (Biden implied margin column).</p><p>· Biden is ahead by 3.9% in the RCP average and close to 49% with ~6% undecided/third party. If Biden wins 33% of the undecided/third party — he receives 51% of the vote. If he wins 50% of the undecided/third party — he receives 52%. Clinton was behind by 0.7% with 4.3% undecided/third party.</p><p>· RCP polls in 2016 –9. RCP polls in 2020–8. Polling average missed final margin by 2.4% in 2016. A 2.4% polling miss against Biden would drop his % of the vote from 51%-52% down to 49.5%-50.5% (depending on how the undecided/third party vote breaks) — still likely a winning percentage in a 3–4 way race.</p><p>· Dems took the Governor’s office in 2018 by 13%. Obama won by 5.4% in 2012 while Trump won by 0.5% in 2016.</p><p>· Pennsylvania was called at 1:15am EST when the margin was 0.5%.</p><p>· All four forecasters have Pennsylvania Lean D.</p><p>· Biden +4.3% (538 forecast — with Biden at 51.8%)</p><p>· WHAT COULD GO WRONG — — NAKED BALLOTS. All of the data/forecasts above are based upon previous elections in Pennsylvania with minimal vote by mail (5% of the electorate). It is projected that 50%+ of the state will vote by mail — increasing the number of vote by mail ballots from 300,000 to 3,000,000. Pennsylvania requires voters to place their ballots in an unmarked “secrecy” envelope before placing that inside another mailing envelope. If they do not — their ballot is rejected. 6.4% of absentee voters in the past forgot to use a “secrecy” envelope — submitting instead a “naked” ballot. That means as many as 190,000+ votes might be invalided because the voter forgot to use the secrecy envelope. Trump won the state by 44,000 votes in 2016. Multiple national and state polls indicate Democrats are much more likely to vote by mail than Republicans (by a 2–1 margin or more). Democrats could lose 65,000+ more votes due to the “naked ballot” issue than Republicans. This represents ~1.25% of the likely electorate. Democrats need to win by more than 3% in order to safely offset this issue. Democrats are challenging this rule in Court as we speak.</p><p>Wisconsin: Likely Biden (Fechter forecast)</p><p>· Biden is currently at 50.5% in the RCP average — which is 3.7% better than Clinton’s number on election day in 2016. Apply a 3.7% swing to Wisconsin and Biden wins by 3.0% (Biden implied margin column).</p><p>· Biden is ahead by 6.4% in the RCP average and above 50% with ~6% undecided/third party. If Biden wins 33% of the undecided/third party — he receives 52% of the vote. If he wins 50% of the undecided/third party — he receives 53%.</p><p>· RCP polls in 2016 –4. RCP polls in 2020–6. Polling average missed final margin by 6%+ in 2016 with Trump winning by 0.7% when the average had him down by 6%+. A 6% miss would drop Biden down to 46%-47% of the vote — which is on par with Trump’s 47.2% result in 2016. It should be noted that Wisconsin was one of the most infrequently polled battleground states in the 2016 election. However, the RCP average in 2016 only had Clinton at 46.8% — her actual result was 46.5%. RCP average did not miss on the % of the vote for Clinton — it missed on the % of the vote for Trump. The RCP average has Biden at 50.5%. If it is accurate (like it was for Clinton in 2016) — then it doesn’t matter what the Trump % is on election day (since Biden is higher than 50%).</p><p>· Dems took the Governor’s office in 2018 by 1.1%.</p><p>· Wisconsin was called at 2am EST when the margin was 0.7%.</p><p>· Cook/538/Crystal Ball — Lean D. Inside Elections — Tilt D.</p><p>· Biden +5.9% (538 forecasts Biden receiving 52.5% and winning by 5.9%). Biden being above 50% in the polling average is a big deal.</p><p>ME 2: TOSSUP (Fechter prediction)</p><p>· Not a ton of polling within the RCP average– four polls over September (not all included in the RCP average) had Biden at ~48%/49% and up by ~3%/4%</p><p>· Obama and Trump both won it</p><p>· Democratic candidate won the seat in 2018 by 1% and is now polling 10%+ ahead in 2020</p><p>· Finger on scale — Biden’s strength with seniors + strong ground game from the Congressional race allow Biden to take the 1 electoral vote</p><p>· Biden +1%</p><p>NE 2: Lean Biden (Fechter prediction)</p><p>· Not a ton of polling — but Biden has been above 50% in the four polls that have been taken since May (including one a week ago)</p><p>· Obama and Trump both won it</p><p>· Suburban district with a heavy concentration of white college educated voters who have abandoned the GOP since 2016</p><p>· Cook/538/Crystal split between Lean R/Tossup/Lean D</p><p>· 538 projects Biden with 50.5% and winning by 2.3%</p><p>· Demographics is destiny — the revolt of the suburbs continues — Biden wins this electoral vote</p><p>· Biden is on air in this District — the Biden campaign clearly is making a run at this electoral vote</p><p>· Biden +1.2% — this is “LEAN” Biden due to his consist polling above 50%</p><p>New Hampshire</p><p>· Biden is currently at 48% in the RCP average — which is 4.7% better than Clinton’s number within the RCP average on election day in 2016. Apply a 4.7% swing to New Hampshire and Biden wins by 5.0% (Biden implied margin column).</p><p>· Biden is ahead by 5.5% in the RCP average with ~9.5% undecided/third party. If Biden wins 33% of the undecided/third party — he receives 51% of the vote. If he wins 50% of the undecided/third party — he receives 52%. Clinton was ahead by 0.3% with 43.7% of the vote and 12.9% undecided/third party.</p><p>· RCP polls in 2016 –7. RCP polls in 2020–2. There was no polling miss in 2016 in New Hampshire.</p><p>· All four have New Hampshire listed as Lean D.</p><p>· Biden +5.5% (Obama’s 2012 margin). 538 forecast has Biden at 52.6% with a 6.3% winning margin.</p><p>· WHAT COULD GO WRONG — — LACK OF POLLING IN 2020. There only have been two polls conducted in New Hampshire on the Presidential race in August/Sept. While both there is a Governor’s race and Senate race on the ballot this year, both races are widely considered to be blowouts (Republican Governor and Democratic Senator both are on cruise control to reelection). If the author was the Biden campaign –the author would commission some private polling just to check the temperature of the state (maybe they’ve done that already). Neither candidate has bought TV/radio ads targeting the state to date — indicating both campaigns do not view the state as competitive.</p><p>Iowa: Leans Trump (Fechter)</p><p>· Biden is currently at 46.3% in the RCP average — which is 5% better than Clinton’s number on election day in 2016. Apply a 5% swing to Iowa from 2016–2020 and Trump wins by 4.4% (Biden implied margin column).</p><p>· Biden is behind by 1.3% in the RCP average with ~6% undecided/third party. If Biden wins 33% of the undecided/third party — he receives 48.3% of the vote (and likely loses). If he wins 50% of the undecided/third party — he receives 49.3% (and likely eeks out a win).</p><p>· RCP polls in 2016 –3. RCP polls in 2020–3. There was a 6% polling miss in 2016. However, the Seltzer poll was within 1.5% of the final result in their final poll of the election (which is not a miss). This race should stay on people’s radar for a bit longer — Seltzer released a poll last week with the race tied. They are the best in the business in the state of Iowa. More polling needs to come out with the race close for this to move from Leans Trump to Tossup — but its worth keeping an eye on — especially in light of the Senate race (more on that in the Senate section).</p><p>· Obama carried this state twice by 9.8% and 5.5% in 2008/2012. Trump won by 9.4%. Republicans took the Governorship by 2.8% in 2018 — but also lost 3 of the 4 Congressional Districts.</p><p>· All four pundits label this “Leans Trump”.</p><p>· Trump +2.8% (GOP 2018 margin). 538 forecast has Biden at 48.0% with a -2.7% winning margin (he loses by 2.7%).</p><p>· WHAT COULD GO WRONG — — LACK OF POLLING IN 2020. Selzter is the only pollster who has gone into the field in Iowa since the conventions. COVID has severely driven down Trump’s approval numbers in the state. The Democratic Senate candidate (Greenfield) is a rock star. Another state that, if the author was running a campaign, a temperature check would be in order. Biden has not gone on TV in the state, yet.</p><p>Nevada: Likely Biden (Fechter)</p><p>· Biden is currently at 46.5% in the RCP average — which is 1.5% better than Clinton’s number on election day in 2016. Apply a 1.5% swing to Nevada and Biden wins by 3.9% (Biden implied margin column).</p><p>· Biden is ahead by 6% in the RCP average with ~8% undecided/third party. If Biden wins 33% of the undecided/third party — he receives 49% of the vote (and likely eeks out a win). If he wins 50% of the undecided/third party — he receives 50.5%.</p><p>· RCP polls in 2016 –5. RCP polls in 2020–2. There was a 2.4% polling error in Nevada — which is not a miss (it’s within the margin of error).</p><p>· Obama carried this state twice by 12.5% and 6.5% in 2008/2012. Clinton won by 2.4%. Democrats took the Governorship by 4% in 2018 — and have both Senate seats.</p><p>· Clark County. The blue wall. There are 140,000 more registered Democrats in Clark County than Republicans. 71% of the statewide vote comes from Clark County. Clinton took a 82,000 vote (10.5% margin) lead out of Clark County and won the state by 26,000 votes. Obama took a 99,000 vote (14.5% margin) lead out of Clark County on his way to winning the state by 65,000 votes. Biden will overperform Clinton in Clark County. Statewide polling doesn’t matter as much in Nevada — if the Democratic candidate can take a 80,000+ lead in Clark County, there simply isn’t enough votes left in the rest of the state for a Republican to overcome that kind of a raw vote margin. The Democratic Party in Clark County has a finely tuned and well-oiled GOTV operation powered volunteers supplied by a number of labor unions — built by Harry Reid over 20+ years (yes — he might be retired — but he’s still the King of the Democratic Party of Nevada). Reid will do everything he can to make sure Biden wins.</p><p>· All four pundits label this “Leans Biden”.</p><p>· Biden +5% (Blend of 2012/2018 Dem margins). 538 forecast has Biden at 52.3% with a 6.4% winning margin.</p><p>· WHAT COULD GO WRONG — — LACK OF POLLING IN 2020. Only one poll in the RCP average for August-September. That being said — Clark County is going to Clark County. Biden is not leaving the castle unguarded — they are airing TV ads in the state.</p><p>· Called at 12:20am EST election night with a 1.5% margin of victory one election night (grew to 2.4% with mail-in ballots post the race being called)</p><p>North Carolina: TOSSUP (Fechter)</p><p>· Every major forecaster calls this state a tossup</p><p>· Obama won in 2008 (0.3%)/lost in 2012 (-2%) and Clinton lost by ~3.5% in 2016</p><p>· RCP average missed final margin by ~2.5% (within the MOE) in 2016</p><p>· RCP has Biden at 47.2% — up by 0.2% — — with 6.2% undecided/third party — with 8 polls done in September — this is as accurate a picture of the race as can be obtained — it is simply too close to call</p><p>· 538 has Biden getting 50% of the vote and winning by 0.8%.</p><p>· Competitive US Senate race also on the ballot (more on that in the Senate section)</p><p>· Democratic Governor should coast to reelection by 8%+</p><p>· Biden +0.3% (2008 Dem margin). Democratic improvement among seniors and college-educated white voters, combined with closer to 2008 than 2016 turnout among the Democratic based, powered by a robust GOTV operation driven by the Gov/US Senate races, enables Biden to eek out a win.</p><p>· Called at 11:11pm EST on election night with a 3.5% margin in 2016.</p><p>Georgia: Lean Trump (Fechter)</p><p>· Disagreement among forecasters — some call it a TOSSUP — some call it Lean Trump</p><p>· Obama lost by 5.2%/8.9% in 2008/2012. Clinton lost by 5.1% in 2016 with 44.4%. Polling average margin was only off by 0.3% — with 6 recent polls in the average.</p><p>· GOP won the state by 1.6% in 2018 (Governor’s race).</p><p>· Biden is at 45.4% and down by 1% in the RCP average with 8.2% undecided/third party — however only one poll included in the RCP average was taken in Sept — and it shows a tie at 47% with 6% undecided/third party</p><p>· Two US Senate races also on the ballot and competitive (more on that in the Senate section)</p><p>· Democrats have not won statewide in 20+ years — however — the gap has narrowed from 2012–2018 as the Atlanta suburbs trend bluer. Democratic turnout set records in the 2020 Presidential primary (higher than even Obama 2008).</p><p>· Biden -0.8% (cuts the 2018 GOP margin in half with increased base turnout and slight improvements among college educated white voters). It’ll be close — but no Democratic candidate has shown what a winning map in Georgia looks like (hence the Lean Trump projection).</p><p>· WHAT COULD GO WRONG — LACK OF QUALITY 2020 POLLS. AND A WRINKLE. Candidates have to get 50%+ of the vote to win outright on election day. Otherwise — the state holds a runoff election in December. If neither Biden or Trump get 50%+ — the race goes to the December runoff. If this goes to a runoff — the author would change the rating of this race to TOSSUP.</p><p>· Called at 11:33pm on election night with a 5.1% margin in 2016.</p><p>Texas: Lean Trump (Fechter)</p><p>· All forecasters label this Lean Trump</p><p>· Obama lost by 11.8%/15.8% in 2008/2012. Clinton lost by 9% in 2016 with 43.2%. Polling average margin was spot on in 2016.</p><p>· GOP won the state by 1.6% in the 2018 US Senate race (Ted Cruz).</p><p>· Biden is at 45% and down by 2.3% in the RCP average with 7.7% undecided/third party — however only one poll in Sept is included in the RCP average.</p><p>· 538 says Biden gets 47.9% and loses by 3.2%.</p><p>· Biden -2.5% (Trump will overperform Cruz among his base voters). It’ll be close — but no Democratic candidate in modern political history has shown what a winning map in Texas looks like (hence the Lean Trump projection). Texas is an expensive state to seriously combat — Biden would have to commit $40M+ to make a serious run at it (which is what O’Rourke spent and came up 1.6% short). Biden doesn’t need Texas to win — the $40M+ is probably better spent on field in FL/PA/AZ/NC (chasing mail-in voters).</p><p>· WHAT COULD GO WRONG — LACK OF QUALITY 2020 POLLS. The lack of recent polls has political prognosticators somewhat flying blind and leaning heavily on past results for data instead of current measures of public opinion.</p><p>· Called at 9pm on election night with a 9% margin in 2016.</p><p>Ohio: Tossup (Fechter prediction)</p><p>· All forecasters label this as Lean Trump</p><p>· Obama won by 4.5%/3.0% in 2008/2012. Clinton lost by 8.1% in 2016 with 42.3%. Polling average margin was off by 4.6% — — but that did not impact which way folks were expecting the state to go</p><p>· In 2018 the Democratic incumbent Senator won by 6.5% while the Republicans won the open seat race for Governor by 3.7%.</p><p>· Biden is at 46.7% and up by 2.4% in the RCP average with 9% undecided/third party — however only one poll in Sept in the RCP average — and it shows Biden at 49% and up by 4% with 6% undecided/third party.</p><p>· Other polls not the in RCP average show Trump up by 3%-5% (taken in Sept) with Trump at or near 50%.</p><p>· 538 predicts a Biden loss by 0.8% (49.9%-49.1%)</p><p>· Obama carried the state twice. Sherrod Brown (the US Senator who won by 6%+ in 2018) is similar to Joe Biden in many, many respects. Biden should win back a big chunk of the union voters who voted for Obama twice but then defected to Trump (roughly 10% of Trump’s voters). Obama would have carried Ohio 48.2% to 46.3% (+1.9%) if he was on the ballot in 2016 and his voters had voted for him a third time. Unlike Georgia/Texas — Democrats have shown what a statewide winning map looks like.</p><p>· However, there are no other competitive statewide races on the ballot in 2020 (though there are a few competitive US House races around the state) — if GOTV is going to happen statewide — it’s on the Biden campaign to do it</p><p>· Biden -3.7%. Biden is spending $$$ on ads in traditional Democratic areas that flipped to Trump in 2016. Even with that, Trump matches Governor DeWine’s GOP performance.</p><p>· WHAT COULD GO WRONG — LACK OF QUALITY 2020 POLLS. Ohio could be anywhere from Biden +2% to Trump +6% right now — without more polls — it is hard to pin down the state of the race at the moment in the state.</p><p>· Called at 10:36pm on Election night in 2016 with a 8%+ margin</p><p>MOST LIKELY PATH TO 270+ ELECTORAL COLLEGE VOTES FOR BIDEN:</p><p>1) Win all Clinton states (so keep an eye on New Hampshire/Nevada/MN)</p><p>2) Win WI/MI/AZ</p><p>3) Win NE 02</p><p>That equals — — EXACTLY 270 EC votes. Biden does NOT need PA/FL/NC/ME2 if he takes MI/AZ/WI/NE 02. In the author’s opinion, based upon the available data — Biden has a better chance of winning WI/MI/AZ/NE 02 than PA or FL. That being said — it is hard to imagine a map where Biden wins MI/WI/MN but loses PA (given the similar demographics of the four states).</p><p>Florida is worth two of the other four states (PA/WI/MI/AZ). Biden gets to 272 with Clinton +FL/AZ (no NE 2).</p><p>WHAT NOT TO WATCH</p><p>· Early voting raw numbers. More Democrats will vote early/by absentee than Republicans — by LARGE margins — in EVERY race. It means nothing. COVID makes comparing these turnout numbers to past elections a pointless exercise. Do pay attention to return rates/acceptance rates (what % of Dems return their ballots v. what % of Republicans return them / what % of Dem ballots are accepted v. what % of Republican ballots are accepted)</p><p>· Individual polls. Until there are 5–6 quality polls in a given area within a 2–3 week timeframe, there isn’t enough data to get a clear, relatively low MOE, picture of what is going on in a given region. And then — watch the trendline in the average — not the exact changes from poll to poll</p><p>· Relative spending. Both sides in the Presidential race have enough $$$$ to get their message across. Biden outspending Trump in a given state doesn’t matter as much if Trump spends enough to mobilize his voters (that being said — you always want to be able to spend more than the other guy). Spending decisions by the campaigns are a decent indicator of which states they think are in play. <a href="https://www.npr.org/2020/09/15/912663101/biden-is-outspending-trump-on-tv-and-just-6-states-are-the-focus-of-the-campaign">https://www.npr.org/2020/09/15/912663101/biden-is-outspending-trump-on-tv-and-just-6-states-are-the-focus-of-the-campaign</a></p><p>US Senate</p><p>DEM SEATS: 50 (Fechter projections) — therefore — — Dem control via wining the Presidency and having the VP break tie votes</p><p>Control of the US Senate will come down to a handful of races. Democrats are generally projected to lose Doug Jones’s Alabama seat and gain seats in Maine/Arizona/Colorado — netting 2 seats and bringing the Democrats to 49 seats in the Senate. NC/Iowa are pure tossups at the moment while Dems have a shot at seats in Georgia and Montana. Kansas and Georgia (SPECIAL) are seemingly out of reach at the moment but are worth watching — while Michigan should be a safe Democratic hold but is also worth keeping an eye on. It should be noted that polling has been relatively light in the Iowa, Kansas, and Montana races — so these projections in those races are more based upon past performance than real-time data.</p><p>Arizona: LIKELY DEM (Fechter)</p><p>Mark Kelly is the Democratic candidate in Arizona — running against Martha McSally — who was appointed to the Senate in 2018 when Senator McCain died — -shortly after losing a run for an open Senate seat to Kyrsten Sinema by 2.5%. Mark Kelly — the astronaut — Gulf War combat pilot — husband of Gabby Giffords — ya — that Mark Kelly. Kelly is at 50% in the RCP average and leading by 6.7% with 6 recent quality polls in the RCP average with only 6.7% undecided/third party. 538.com projects Kelly getting 50.1% of the vote and winning by 6%. An astronaut/combat pilot consistently polling at 50% of the vote with a 6% lead — barring something absolutely crazy happening — this one is done. Kelly +8%.</p><p>Maine: Leans Dem (Fechter)</p><p>Sara Gideon (D) is trying to unseat incumbent Susan Collins (R). Senator Collins is trying to distance herself from President Trump — who is losing Maine by 10%+ in the polls — but is having a hard time doing so largely due to her vote to confirm Judge Kavanaugh. Gideon has led in EVERY poll taken since July — and leads by an average of ~6% with ~47.5% (and Collins averaging ~42%) in the three polls taken in September. Maine has ranked choice voting — so those that vote third party on the first ballot an chose one of the major party candidates on a second ballot. A long-time incumbent (Collins) behind by 6% — in a state that will vote against her party’s Presidential nominee (Trump) by 10%+ — is in serious serious trouble. She would need to win the third party/undecided vote (10% of the electorate) by a 3–1 margin to make the race a coin-toss. That’s not going to happen. 538% says Gideon will win by 1.8% with 50.9% of the vote (after ranked choice voting is complete). Gideon by +3%.</p><p>Colorado: LIKELY DEM (Fechter)</p><p>John Hickenlooper (D), former two term Governor and two term Mayor of Denver, is running to unseat incumbent Cory Gardner (R). Trump will lose Colorado by 10%+. Hickenlooper has led in EVERY poll since May. The five most recent (Aug/Sept) have him at between 48%-53% and winning by 5%-10%. 538.com projects Hickenlooper wins by 4% with 49.6%. Same story as Maine — an incumbent can’t go into the last 45 days of an election losing by 5%-10% with an opponent within striking distance of 50% of the vote in a state where your Presidential nominee is going to lose by 10% and expect to win. Hickenlooper by +7%.</p><p>Michigan: Leans DEM (Fechter)</p><p>Gary Peters (D) defends his Senate seat against a challenge from John James (R). James is running a strong challenge — and in another election year — might have had a shot. But not when running with Trump at the ticket in 2020 in Michigan. RCP average has six Sept polls that show Peters up by 4.5% with 46.3% and 11.9% undecided/third party. Peters needs to win only 33% of the undecided/third party vote to break 50% — and it seems like a disproportionate amount of the undecideds traditionally vote Democratic (which makes them more likely to eventually come “home” to the Dem nominee — especially when they are already planning on voting for Biden at the top of the ticket). 538 projects a 6.7% win for Peters with 51.9% of the vote. 538 is also projecting Biden winning by ~8% with ~53% of the vote. Peters by 4.5%</p><p>Kansas: Leans Rep (Fechter)</p><p>Barbara Bollier (D) is running against BoB Marshall (R) for an open seat. Democrats won the Governorship by 5% in 2018 — but that was against an extreme right wing Republican nominee. Marshall is not nearly as much of a firebrand. There has been no recent polling. Two polls taken in August showed a dead heat but with 10%-15% undecided/third party. Trump should win Kansas by 10%. This should be enough to carry Marshall across the finish line — but until we get some quality polling this is a race to keep an eye on. Marshall by 8%.</p><p>Georgia Regular: Leans R (Fechter)</p><p>Jon Ossoff (D) is challenging the incumbent Senator Purdue (R). Democrats came within 1.5% of winning the Governor’s office in 2018 — the state is becoming bluer by the year. Democrats had record turnout in their Presidential/Senate/Congressional primaries earlier this year — in the midst of COVID and shortly after the George Floyd protests began. The Democratic base in and around Atlanta is clearly energized while white college educated voters in the suburbs are shifting their votes from the GOP to Democratic candidates. The four polls released in September show a coin toss race with Ossoff/Purdue neck and neck with somewhere between 43%-47% of the vote a piece and the remaining 7%-14% undecided/third party. In Georgia, if no candidate receives 50%+1 in November — the top two candidates go to a run off election in December. Ossoff is an underwhelming candidate for the moment and Purdue is not a GOP firebrand. Democrats have not been able to force a runoff in modern Georgia political history. 538 projects a 2.5% point win for Purdue with 50.8% of the vote. Purdue by 1.5% and 50.2%. If this goes to a runoff — no one knows what will happen (is the Presidential also a runoff — is control of the Senate at stake — is control of the Presidency at stake).</p><p>Georgia Special: Leans R (Fechter)</p><p>A dozen+ candidates are running to fill the vacancy. Senator Loeffler (R) was appointed to the Senate and is running for a full term. She is running to quote her ads “to the right of Attila the Hun”. The other candidate in the race, former Doug Collins (R), has some ethics issues in his past. Both candidates would be vulnerable in a runoff election to a strong Democratic challenger. However, three Democrats (Warnock, Lieberman — ya — the son of the older Lieberman, and Tarver) are splitting the Democratic vote three ways. The top two candidates — regardless of party — advance to a runoff. Warnock is ahead of the other Dems in every poll by 9% with ~20% of the vote — however — in half of those polls — that ~20% of the vote puts Warnock in third place and out of the runoff. Loeffler has led every poll with ~24%-26%. It seems to be battle for second between Collins and Warnock. If the other Democratic candidates would drop out — or if the party leadership unifies behind Warnock and consolidates Democratic support behind him — Warnock should advance. If this goes to a runoff with Warnock and either Republican — this probably shifts to a TOSSUP — especially if one of the other statewide races go to a runoff.</p><p>North Carolina: Leans D (Fechter)</p><p>Cal Cunningham (D) is challenging incumbent Senator Thom Tillis (R). Cunningham is running a strong race. RCP average has him at 46.3% and up by 4.4% with 11.8% undecided/third party. Cunningham has led in each of the 10 polls in published in September. Roy Cooper (D) is running for re-election for Governor on the same ticket as Biden/Cunningham. The RCP polling average indicates Cooper would win 50% of the vote if the election were held today with an 8.7% lead over his opponent and 8.7% undecided/third party. RCP averages are Biden at 47.1% with a 0.6% lead/Cooper at 50% with an 8.7% lead/Cunningham at 46.3% with a 4.4% lead. 538 projects Cunningham will win by 2.5% with 49.9% — while Biden will win by 0.7% with 50.0% of the vote. Cunningham only needs to win ~33% of the undecided/third party vote to get to 50% — against an incumbent. The fact that Tillis is at 41.9% in the RCP average with ~45 days left until the election is the canary in the coal mine. Cunningham by 1.5% (riding Cooper’s coattails).</p><p>Iowa: Leans R (Fechter)</p><p>Theresa Greenfield (D) is running a very strong challenge against incumbent Senator Jodi Ernst (R). There has only been one recent poll in the race — but it was done by the gold standard of Iowa polling. It shows Greenfield leading 45%-42% (within the MOE) with 13% undecided/third party. Greenfield would only need to win ~35% of the undecided/third party vote to get above 50% — if the Seltzer poll is right on the money. The same poll indicated the Presidential race was a tie at 47%-47% with 7% undecided/third party. But it’s just one poll. The Presidential/Senate races likely will run within 1%-2% of each other. 538 projects a 1.2% Ernst victory with 49.3% of the vote and a 1.7% Trump victory with 50.7% of the vote. Ernst +2.5% — but with only one recent poll — who really knows.</p><p>SEPT 24 UPDATE: As noted — this memo took several days to write. It is based upon the data as of the morning of Sept 22. Since then — two quality polls have been released in Iowa showing a dead heat in the Presidential race and Greenfield up by 3%. That makes 3 polls in Iowa in a span of a week showing then Presidential race and Senate races within the margin of error. Fechter changes his forecast in the Senate race to TOSSUP — TOO CLOSE TO CALL. Greenfield is running ahead of Biden in Iowa — that much is clear. Ernst can’t break 42%-43% in any poll. For an incumbent that is a very bad place to be within 45 days of election day. Greenfield +1%.</p><p>Montana: Leans R (Fechter)</p><p>Incumbent Governor Steve Bullock (D) is challenging incumbent Senator Steve Daines (R). They are both well liked in the state — they have both won statewide. The only recent poll has Daines up 1% with 45% of the vote and 11% undecided/third party. Trump will win the state by 10%+. Daines is too popular to run more than 10% behind the President. 538 projects a 3.4% win for Daines with 51.7% of the vote. Daines +5.7% — but with only one recent poll — who really knows.</p><p>SQUIRREL (Don’t Be Distracted By These Races)</p><p>· Kentucky. Mitch McConnell (R) will win by 10%+. Amy McGrath (D) has raised over $40M — breaking all kinds of records in Kentucky. However, the Democratic candidate won the Governor’s race in 2019 by less than 1% — running against a very unpopular, extremely conservative, incumbent, in a non-election year. McConnell is popular in Kentucky and Trump will easily carry the state. McGrath could raise $100M — she still would lose by 10%+.</p><p>· Texas. Ted Cruz won by 1.5% — even with his Democratic opponent raising $40M+ (Beto O’Rourke). John Cornyn (R) is more popular as an incumbent than Ted Cruz and his opponent has only raised $6M. Cornyn is running 4% ahead of Trump in the RCP average. If Biden does win Texas –and that is a big if — it won’t be more than 1%.</p><p>· South Carolina. The only poll in September has the race a dead heat between Republican incumbent Lindsey Graham (R) and Jamie Harrison (D) at 48%-48%. The same poll had Trump carrying the state by 6%. Fitz Hollings was the last Democrat to represent South Carolina in the US Senate. “Fitz who?” you ask. “Exactly”, the author answers.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b4af1dd58997" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Lincoln’s First Battle]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@avramfechter/lincolns-first-battle-423e42e28b8f?source=rss-6e2fda3a33e8------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/423e42e28b8f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[american-history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[abraham-lincoln]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[political-science]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Avram Fechter]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 28 Feb 2017 03:04:28 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-05-13T17:02:23.619Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Lincoln’s First Battle</p><p>By: Avram Fechter</p><p>Logrolling is traditionally defined as a legislator agreeing to vote for something he/she probably would not vote for in return for receiving something special for his/her district that he/she would not otherwise receive. For better or worse, logrolling has made the machinery of legislatures move for hundreds of years and was in the tactical tool belt of some of the most effective and popular American politicians throughout history.</p><p>A little known, but illustrative, example of the use of the tactic dates to when Abraham Lincoln was a young member (he was 26) of the Illinois House of Representatives. The early/mid 1830s witnessed the formation of our modern two party system of government. President Andrew Jackson’s Democratic Party championed a small government role in the economy and an expansion of participatory democracy. Jacksonian Democrats expanded the franchise to white males regardless of their property holdings and rewarded their political supporters with government jobs (the most common conduits were via the post office and customs bureaus). The Whig Party formed in opposition to Jackson’s policies and advocated for an expanded government role in promoting infrastructure projects and encouraging the banking/manufacturing industries. The 1832 and 1836 elections were bitterly partisan and battle lines were stark up and down the ballot. State and local elections quickly became proxies for the partisan fights at the national level.</p><p>Lincoln “came of political age” as the two-party system was becoming solidified and entrenched. He idolized the Whig leader Henry Clay and was a supporter of the Whig Party’s efforts to finance canal and railroad projects. The sitting Governor and the vast-majority of Democrats opposed any effort to launch a massive internal improvement program. Despite this opposition, Lincoln would help engineer the passage of the largest state internal improvement program in the nation’s history while at the same time assuring the movement of the state capital from Vandalia in heavily Democratic Fayette County<a href="#_ftn1">[1]</a> to Springfield in Whig Sangamon County<a href="#_ftn2">[2]</a> instead of Jacksonville in Democratic Morgan County<a href="#_ftn3">[3]</a>. This is the story of how he did it.</p><p>Lincoln’s Political Baptism</p><p>The embryonic formation of political parties in Illinois spawned a number of weekly newspapers all around the state. Newspapers before the Civil War had a distinctly political slant. Editors did not pretend to be unbiased in their reporting. The newspapers that were formed in Illinois reflected the two political parties in the state. The newspapers in the northern and central portions of the state were either halfhearted supporters of President Jackson or entirely against the Administration. In the south, the Administration found its strongest support. The Vandalia Free Press, located in the seat of government, was founded in 1831 and would be the party organ for the Democratic Party in Illinois for over thirty years. In the same year the Sangamon Journal was founded in Springfield and was a vocal critic of the Administration. Both papers were weeklies. Both papers focused heavily on national politics, printing entire speeches and debates from the floor of Congress in their columns. State politics was always reported after national politics.</p><p>Into this swirling maelstrom Abraham Lincoln of New Salem, in the county of Sangamon, announced his second candidacy for the state legislature. He had run for office before, announcing his candidacy in a handbill that was distributed to the citizens of Sangamon County on March 9, 1832. The handbill endorsed the building of a canal on the Sangamon River instead of a railroad from the Illinois River to Springfield, citing the high cost of a railroad as a reason for his preference. Lincoln ran eighth out of thirteen candidates; however, Lincoln was away for most of the political campaign fighting the Black Hawk War. He did manage to poll 277 out of 300 votes in his hometown of New Salem. In November of the same year, Lincoln watched New Salem vote 185–70 for President Jackson’s reelection.</p><p>He learned a couple of lessons from his first campaign. The first: his platform had earned few votes by itself. He got votes where people knew him. The second: Jackson was a popular figure and it would be a mistake to buck him. In April 19, 1834 Lincoln announced his candidacy in the Sangamon Journal, but did not lay out a platform. Instead he embarked on a door-to-door campaign, using his popular personality and already finely honed storytelling ability to build his base, one voter at a time. By not issuing a statement of his positions Lincoln was able to gain the support of all three of the factions in the gubernatorial campaign. Lincoln was a closet Whig and secretly helped John T. Stuart, one of the leading Whigs in the state, win against a concerted Democratic attack against his reelection. Lincoln coasted to victory with 1,376 votes, second out of four state representatives elected. Sangamon County elected two other Whigs, Lincoln, and a “milk and cider” Democrat. Sangamon County was rapidly moving into the Whig camp. Lincoln demonstrated his Whig leanings by voting for Rep. Duncan (a moderate Democrat) in the gubernatorial campaign.</p><p>Rep. Duncan won the election. In an important indicator of where Illinois politics was heading, Duncan carried the entire part of the state northeast of the mouth of the Illinois River. Sangamon County and a couple of others returned pluralities for Duncan. The southern part of the state returned majorities for Kinney (a mainline Democrat). The Whigs of Illinois, for the most part, voted for Duncan instead of Adams (the official Whig candidate), hoping to deny Kinney the victory. Duncan won based upon the combined strength of the “milk and cider” Democrats and the Whigs. In the same year a referendum was held as to where the state capital should permanently locate. Alton garnered 8,157 votes, the current state capital Vandalia received 7,730, Springfield (county seat of Sangamon County) received 7,035, Geographical Center received 790, Peoria received 423, and Jacksonville received 273. By law the seat of government should have been transferred to Alton. However, Alton did not garner a majority of the popular vote and certainly could not muster the majority support of the legislature. The issue lay dormant for the totality of the Ninth Session of the Illinois House of Representatives (Lincoln’s first as a legislator).</p><p>Stuart rewarded Lincoln for his assistance in the election, taking Lincoln under his wing, bringing him on as a junior partner in Stuart’s law practice. When the legislature met in Vandalia Stuart was elected leader of the Whig Party in the House. Stuart made Lincoln his right-hand in the House as well. Overnight Lincoln had assumed a leadership role in the fledgling Illinois Whig Party. Less than two years after jumping into politics, Lincoln was one of the few men who were literally building the Whig Party in Illinois from almost scratch. He was, to quote former Secretary of State Dean Acheson about a different situation, “present at the creation”.</p><p>The Whigs in the Ninth House were outnumbered 34–21. However, the Democratic Party in Illinois was still in its infancy. The Democratic Caucus spent most of its time feuding within itself instead of dueling with the Whigs. The Whigs were able to divide the Democrats and win vote after vote. Stuart installed Lincoln as the party whip. It was his job to ensure that every Whig was on the floor for every vote, and ensure that they voted the party line. If it looked like too many Whigs were going to defect, it was the job of the whip to alert the floor leader so that the floor leader could avoid an embarrassing defeat in a floor vote. In order to do this the whip must know where every member is at every moment during the session. The whip should know the mind of his/her caucus at all times. It was a dream role for an up and coming politician. Stuart and Lincoln would need 9 or 10 Democrats to cross the aisle (33% of the Democratic caucus) to win any floor vote (assuming all Whigs were present). Lincoln was being dealt a tough hand to play in his freshman year as a legislator.</p><p>Lincoln spent most of the first session of the legislature learning the ropes and passing relatively minor pieces of legislature that were important to his constituents. The second session of the legislature saw Lincoln back at his post as Whip. The Governor called for legislative redistricting in response to the 1835 census, state support for Illinois and Michigan Canal bonds, continued support for the state bank, and a halt to all other state support for internal improvement projects. The Governor praised President Jackson while denouncing Jackson’s chosen successor Martin Van Buren and his style of patronage politics. Duncan was maintaining his middle of the road political position. Democrats were opponents of banks while tepid supporters of internal improvement schemes. Whigs were enthusiastic supporters of banks and state involvement in the building of internal improvements. Jackson was universally popular while Van Buren was denounced by many even in the Democratic Party. Many Democrats were on the verge of bolting the party if Van Buren came to power.</p><p>Political life was changing rapidly. On the same day that the legislature met the Democratic Party held its first state convention. In December, one year before the election, the Illinois Democratic Party endorsed the nomination of Vice-President Van Buren. Any Democrat present at the convention who failed to do so would lose their job in state/federal government. Party discipline was seeping into the Democratic Party during elections.</p><p>Meanwhile — the Democratic Party in the legislature still had not discovered the unifying effect of strict party discipline. The Whigs, with Lincoln as whip, still were able to use their superior unity to win close floor fights. A battle over the floating of state bonds to pay for the Illinois and Michigan Canal illustrates this point. On December 15, 1836 the bill came to the floor for its second reading. The first vote on the bill to approve its second reading failed 25–29. A Whig member was absent, en route from his home district. Stuart noticed the members’ absence. Without the Whig member the vote would have failed, 27–27. Stuart had two Democrats from Lawrence County, a county in the path of the Canal, to vote against the second reading. The next day, the missing Whig arrived. The two Democrats from Lawrence County moved to reconsider the previous day’s vote. The Democrats were caught by surprise. The bill was approved for its second reading 28–25.</p><p>By December 21 more Democrats had arrived at the session and the bill was rejected for its third reading and final passage by a vote of 26–28. The Governor, Stuart and Lincoln met with the Speaker of the House over that weekend. Some sort of deal was struck. On the 25th the Whigs moved a number of amendments that they had previously rejected. They passed easily. Then they moved to reconsider the vote on final passage. The Speaker switched his vote and the Whigs made sure every member of their caucus was present. The bill passed 29–26 and was signed by the Governor before New Year’s Day.</p><p>During the end of the second session the Illinois census of 1835 was released. It showed that Illinois had a population of 271,727 residents, almost double the Illinois population of 1825. The census of 1835 was also being used to redistrict the seats in the Illinois legislature. The northern and western counties were the areas that had the largest increases in population. They would gain a disproportionate amount of the new seats that were being added to the state legislature. Sangamon County was the second largest county in the state with 17,573 residents. Neighboring Morgan County was the largest with 19,214. The third largest county, in southern Illinois, only had 12,274 residents. Morgan was a swing county and Greene was predominantly Democratic. Sangamon was clearly the base of Whig power in Illinois. And Lincoln was becoming one of the leading Whigs in Sangamon County.</p><p>It was the job of the legislature to reapportion the legislative districts. Drawing district lines is always a politically charged issue. A minority party can gain control of the legislature if they draw the lines to have slim edges in 51% of the district while conceding the other 49%. On the flip side of the coin, a majority party can consolidate its power by drawing the lines a different way. The Whig power base was in the parts of the state that were growing the fastest and in the counties that were more populated then the average Illinois county. It was in their interest to keep each district large so that they could match large Whig counties with small Democratic counties to neutralize the Democratic vote in those counties. If the size of districts were smaller, Democratic counties would gain greater representation in the legislature. Additionally, most large counties that would have more than one representative were Whig counties.</p><p>Control of the legislature was potentially at stake. When the redistricting bill was first introduced the Whigs had it referred to a select committee for markup. It was common for bills to go to a select committee instead of one of the standing committee. The people who would serve on these committees were the ones who were most interested in the bill being considered; these were the only people who would give up multiple evenings of free-time to sit on an additional committee. The select committee was stacked with Whigs, no one wanted to give up their free time.</p><p>The bill was reported out of committee with each district containing 8,000 residents, the same ratio that had been used in the last round of redistricting. It was the precedent. It also benefited the Whig party. Out of 60 Illinois counties, only 8 counties had populations larger than 8,000. Out of those eight counties, only Sangamon and Morgan were large enough to have two districts. The Democrats had been caught off guard. They tried to amend the bill on the House floor. On the 17th of December Democrats moved to amend the bill and replace 8,000 with 7,000. The Whigs knew the amendment was going to be made and had all their members present on the floor. Then the Whig speakers invoked precedent to sustain the 8,000 number. The Democratic caucus split, the amendment failed 24–28.</p><p>The legislature adjourned and Lincoln went home to campaign for reelection. Sangamon County, due to redistricting, had gained 3 more house seats and a state senator. 1836 was an important election year; it was the first Presidential election in Illinois where party lines were clearly drawn between Democrats and Whigs. The Democrats had Vice-President Van Buren at the top of their ticket. Nobody loved him and many hated him.</p><p>Van Buren did not have the grassroots popularity Jackson enjoyed. He had risen to power by building a party machine in New York which had as its base patronage and spoils. Many Americans viewed this form of political organizing, and anyone who came out of such a system, as dirty and unsavory (yet somehow conveniently forget this distaste when it was their party in power). The Whigs were happy to sit back, nominate a bland candidate in the person of General Hugh White, and hope the Democrats would self-destruct. With the Presidential election dominating the attention of the country and the front-page of the newspapers, Lincoln announced on March 19, 1836 in the Sangamon Journal that he was running for reelection. Lincoln favored the internal improvement plan and would be voting for General White in the Presidential election.</p><p>In the same edition of the paper Stuart announced that he was running for Congress. The Congressional seats had not been redrawn; those districts were on the 10 year cycle mandated in the Constitution. The growth in Illinois’ population would not reap additional Congressional seats until after the 1840 Federal census. For the 1836 election Illinois still had only three Congressional seats. The state was cut into roughly thirds, each district running east to west. The northern and southern districts were safe Democratic seats. The 2nd District, containing Sangamon County, was a potential pickup for the Whig Party. As the leader of the Whigs in the House, Stuart was the natural choice to run as the Party’s nominee.</p><p>Other than the one announcement in the Sangamon Journal, Lincoln issued no other press statements or releases. He once again utilized his wit, warmth, and enthusiasm to charm voters one-on-one or in stump speeches to small gatherings. His job as county surveyor enabled him to travel to every corner of the county. Occasionally Lincoln took to the stump to campaign against Van Buren and defend the Whig Party. Lincoln first gained recognition as a stump speaker in this campaign, with the Sangamon Journal reporting every speech he made on behalf of the Whig Presidential candidate. It was in this capacity that Lincoln spread his name. Whigs who read about Lincoln in the papers saw him stumping not for himself, but for his party.</p><p>On August 1st, 1836 the voters of Sangamon County went to the polls and chose who they wanted to be their elected representatives in the Illinois Legislature. They chose nine Whigs out of a field of 17 candidates of both parties. Lincoln received more votes than anyone. In two years Lincoln had become the most popular Whig in Sangamon County. Stuart lost his Congressional race to Democrat John May by a mere 1,000 votes. However, Democrats easily held onto their majority status in the legislature. It was a bad omen for the Presidential race. Despite predictions of a landslide win for White by the Whig papers in Illinois, Van Buren carried Illinois and the nation. The Whigs had solidified control of Sangamon County, but were unable to carry the state.</p><p>Lincoln Emerges</p><p>Lincoln would enter the first half of the 10th Session of the Illinois House of Representatives leading a 28 vote Whig caucus against a 63 vote Democratic one. 39 Illinois counties had voted for Van Buren — only 13 had voted Whig. To win any floor vote Lincoln would once again need to hold the Whig Party together and ~25% of Democrats. Lincoln’s efforts on redistricting meant he had cut the margin — if Lincoln had lost the redistricting vote he would have still needed the 33% of the Democratic caucus to win on the floor.</p><p>The Springfield delegation arrived in Vandalia with two missions: Move the state house to Springfield and pass some sort of system of internal improvements. The Whig Party was ablaze with the demand for more railroads and canals. The Sangamon Journal editorialized that “It is not a party measure, and all our citizens can cordially unite in one rigorous effort to secure the adoption of a system of internal improvements for the state, which is so much needed, so much desired, and so absolutely necessary to its prosperity”. The Democrats only held the Senate by a 22–18 vote margin — if Lincoln could gerrymander a Whig/Democratic coalition behind legislation in the House it probably could also pick up the 3 Democratic votes it would need in the Senate to make it to the Governor’s desk. All eyes would be on Lincoln.</p><p>Lincoln wrote in a letter to Mary Owens — his future wife — on December 13, 1836 that “Our chance to take the seat of Government to Springfield is better than I expected. An Internal Improvements Convention was held here since we met, which recommended a loan of several millions of dollars on the faith of the State to construct Rail Roads. Some of the legislature are for it, and some against it; which has the majority, I cannot tell”. The placement of these two political events so close together in Lincoln’s letter indicates Lincoln saw a potential to exploit the battle over internal improvements to gain leverage for the movement of the state capital to Springfield.</p><p>The Governor’s message called for the expansion of educational opportunties and for the internal improvements of the state to be achieved by the state working with private companies to build railroads and canals in public-private partnerships with the state contributing only 33% of the costs — — he was against the internal improvement program proposed by the Whigs. However, the Governor did not stop there. The Governor declared his neutrality on the central issue that was dominating the politics of the country — he did not have a position on whether there should be a central bank. Here was a registered Democrat who did not denounce the national bank. He was breaking party ranks. Duncan even went further. The majority of Duncan’s address was dedicated to a stringent and ringing denunciation of Van Burenism and partisan politics. It was a smack in the face to the President of his party. The party smacked back. A House Committee stacked full of Democrats issued a report denouncing the Governor’s address. They refused to even schedule any bills sponsored by the Governor for a vote. Duncan was powerless — and the Democratic Party of Illinois was a house divided against itself.</p><p>The managers of the internal improvement bill gave a clinic on legislative logrolling. The bill they sent to the floor contained an unprecedented $10 million worth of loans — — $250 million+ in modern purchasing power — to begin construction on ten different projects all over the state, simultaneously. It even included $200,000 for the counties in which no projects were planned. There was something in the plan for every county in the state. No income would be generated by these projects for at least a decade. If the projects had been completed one at a time, a project could have been completed every year, with the revenue from one railroad paying for the construction of the next. But that would have generated a fight over which projects would be completed first. No one was quite sure how to pay for the interest on the bonds. If the economy slowed down, the whole plan would collapse under its own weight. The legislature, full of relatively young and inexperienced freshman and sophomores due to expansion/redistricting, bulled ahead.</p><p>Lincoln voted for the plan at every step of the way. In fact, as leader of the Whigs he gave the plan bipartisan cover. Lincoln was so involved in the work of the Committee on Internal Improvements, of which he was not a member, that years later a colleague of Lincoln’s remembered that Lincoln actually was on the committee. After its passage Lincoln paid attention to every minor detail related to the project. He was a leading voice in favor of an infrastructure program that had not commissioned a single survey or instituted any system of financing the bonds it was floating. The Governor lobbied to lower the cost to the state and bring in private companies to help carry the burden. Duncan was ignored. Publicly, pro-improvement Democrats in the legislature said they were afraid of private monopolies; privately, the Democrats were getting even with the Governor.</p><p>Friday, February 9th, 1837. A seemingly inconsequential day in American history. However, that is probably the day that propelled Lincoln to the Presidency (more on this later). It is the day that the Illinois House took its test votes on the internal improvement bill. Mainline Democrats made a motion to table the bill. A “motion to table” is the parliamentary equivalent of a motion to kill it. If the pro-improvement forces won this vote — it meant passage for the bill was virtually assured. The motion to table failed on a vote of 29–46.</p><p>Lincoln had held his Whig caucus together — — supporting the plan by 23–6. Democrats split 23–23 in favor — Lincoln had broken off 50% of the Democratic caucus. 18 of the 23 Democrats who voted in favor of the plan had improvements being built in their County. 15 of the 23 Whigs had improvements in their County. Members with improvements in their County voted 35–22 in favor. Members without voted 11–7 in favor. Democrats with improvements in their County split 20–18 in favor. Democrats with nothing in their County voted 14–3 against the plan. Whigs with nothing voted 4–1 in favor.</p><p>Changing 9 votes would have changed the outcome — and a revised redistricting plan would probably have delivered 5 more votes to the Democrats and 5 less to the Whigs. Even then — Lincoln needed ~33% of the Democratic caucus to make up for the handful of defections from his own. Logrolling had worked. Pro-improvement forces had purchased via railroads/canals/roads enough votes to ensure passage. Lincoln was on the brink of achieving the Whig Party’s greatest legislative accomplishment in Illinois history. He wasn’t done yet.</p><p>While the Internal Improvements bill was moving through the legislature, the bill to locate the seat of the state capital (hereafter known as the “Springfield Bill”) was quietly proceeding. Alton seemed to be the front runner, having received the most votes in the statewide referendum a few years before. However, Alton’s plurality had not been a decisive one. Vandalia had been the second highest vote getter, but it seemed inevitable that the seat of government would shift northward with the weight of Illinois’s population. Springfield was a close third, still a threat.</p><p>It was common practice for the House to handle multiple controversial issues over an extended period, meeting for a couple of hours on one issue, tabling that issue for the day, and then moving on to work on another issue for a couple of hours. While the Whigs were outnumbered in the House by almost 2–1, the numbers were even in the Senate. There is where the “Springfield Bill” was passed first. The Senate bill was reported to the House on February 8th, 1837 stating that the permanent seat of the capital would be decided by “the legislators”. Lincoln wrote an amendment, which was introduced by someone else; to require that whichever town hosted the capital must donate $50,000 and two acres for the new building. No small town in the state could afford to do so. The amendment carried 53–26. It was doubtful that Alton could afford the $50,000. Springfield had gained the upper hand.</p><p>Springfield’s opponents had been caught off guard. Now they were alert and ready for battle. A few days later a vote to “table indefinitely” put forward by Vandalia supporters passed 38–37.<a href="#_ftn4">[4]</a> Lincoln only carried his caucus by an 18–7 vote. 4 of the 7 defectors didn’t have any improvements in their County. Lincoln got 14 Democratic votes for Springfield (losing 30) — 12 of them had improvements in their County — the other 2 voted for the internal improvement bill but didn’t have any improvements in their own County (remember the $200,000?). 12 of the 14 Democrats who supported Lincoln in the motion to table also cast their vote for Springfield in early rounds of the ultimate balloting on the location of the state capital. ALL of them had improvements in their County.</p><p>Saturday, February 18, 1837. Springfield’s forces moved to reconsider the motion to table. Springfield wins 42–40. Eight member of the Illinois House flipped their position in less than 24 hours. Lincoln lost 3 but picked up another 5. Lincoln lost 2 Whigs and one Democrat. Both Whigs had improvements in their County and went on to be early Springfield supporters. The one Democrat had an improvement in his County and ultimately was not present for the final round of capital selection voting. Three Whigs and two Democrats flipped to Lincoln’s side. The two Democrats are an enigma — they did not have improvements in their Counties while one supported Springfield and the other did not in the ultimate capital location balloting. The three Whigs all had improvements in their County and went on to support Springfield. Eight legislators voted on the 2nd day who did not on the first — they split 4–4. Only 1 member missed the 2nd vote who attended the first one — he was a Democrat who had voted against Springfield, had an improvement in his County, and would go onto to vote against Springfield in the ultimate selection.</p><p>Nine days after the House passed the internal improvement bill with 46 votes — 42 members voted to bring the legislation moving the capital to Springfield back to life. At this point — 42 members of the House had voted to support Springfield on either Friday or Saturday (not necessarily the same 42). 18 of the 42 were Democrats. 38 of the 42 had an internal improvement in their County. 16 of the 18 Democrats also had an improvement in their County. 42 votes was a majority of the House.</p><p>Springfield’s supporters would go on to win several additional close votes on the state capital bill — and then the House voted 48–34 to send the bill to final passage. The final day of February would be the day that the legislature picked a new state capital.</p><p>Before the legislature turned to the state capital vote it had one other piece of business to attend to. The Governor had vetoed the internal improvements bill. On February 26th, 1837 the state of Illinois became liable for $10 million worth of debt after the legislature overrode the Gubernatorial veto — the House voted 52–20 (with 6 members voting to override the veto after voting against the underlying legislation). Before construction began the nation fell into a deep recession. Not a single project would be completed and the State would spend 30 years repaying the bonds it had issued. The plan was a catastrophe. But it might have helped Lincoln become President.</p><p>On Tuesday, Feb 28th — — Springfield was appointed the State Capital on the 4th round of balloting. It was the House of Representatives that put Springfield over the top. The tables below outline the four ballot rounds.</p><p>The balloting would consist of the combined members of the House and Senate. Springfield would start in the lead with 35 votes on the first ballot — taking ~29% of both the House and Senate. Springfield would finish with 73 votes (an increase of 38 votes) — representing 53% of the total — but propelled to victory by the 28-vote surge in the House — Springfield took 63% of the House. The 28 vote increase in the House would have been sufficient by itself to deliver the capital to Springfield without a single additional vote in the Senate. The table shows that Springfield was unable to take votes from supporters of the other two viable contenders (Jacksonville and Vandalia) — — Springfield carried the day because it consolidated the votes from the rest of the state (support for “favorite son” towns drops from 43 on the first ballot in the House to 12 votes by the 4th ballot — with the biggest fall off being between the decisive 3rd and 4th ballots). The 38 votes Springfield receives on the 3rd ballot in the House are almost identical to the 42 that supported Springfield in the preliminary parliamentary maneuvering. Springfield jumps from getting 34% of the House on the 2nd ballot to 46% on the 3rd ballot — while stagnating at 38% in the Senate. Seven House Whigs voted in the 3rd round for towns other than Springfield/Jacksonville/Vandalia (they all voted for places closer to their County compared to Springfield). Those Whigs alone would be sufficient to put Springfield over the top. The handwriting was on the wall.</p><p>Lincoln Logrolled — It Probably Helped Make Him President</p><p>Despite some historians’ claims that the passage of the internal improvements bill was an almost foregone conclusion, there is considerable evidence that the issue appeared to be in doubt until the very end. Lincoln’s own letter to Mary Owens is the first piece of evidence. As late as February 25th, the Sangamon Journal called the chances for passage of the internal improvements bill and the bill to move the state capital to Springfield as, in both cases, “doubtful”. Per the Sangamon Journal, the Internal Improvements Bill seemed dead in the Senate and Springfield had barely survived a near death experience.</p><p>Simon in his book Lincoln’s Preparation for Greatness contends that there was no “logrolling” by Lincoln in order to secure victory. Modern historians have relied upon Simon’s interpretation for their own analysis of Lincoln’s first major floor fights in a legislative body. Simon bases his contention upon twenty-five roll call votes that took place over the course of the legislative session where he thought logrolling was possible. However, the twenty-five roll calls were listed “excluding the nineteen additional roll calls on internal improvements and the capital relocation”.</p><p>These are the very votes in which you would expect a leader seeking support to trade support for one amendment in return for support for Springfield. It is very easy imagine Lincoln saying to a legislator “Sangamon will support the addition of this trunk line into your county if you support Springfield on the second ballot” or “We’ll support the veto override if you do not actively oppose Springfield Mr. Speaker”. No one has looked at these votes for a pattern. Simon contends that Springfield’s selection was essentially a foregone conclusion and therefore did not need aggressive logrolling for its adoption. This overlooks the fact that Sangamon County was an overwhelmingly Whig county in a heavily Democratic state. The Speaker of the House was from rival Vandalia. The Governor was pushing for Jacksonville — — which was in the single largest County in the state and near the geographic center (like Sangamon County). The House was overwhelmingly Democratic. The Sangamon Journal predicted as late as February 1837 that Springfield would, in the end, fail in its efforts. How did a Whig delegation from a Whig county get a Democratic legislature to ignore a statewide referendum and buck their Speaker to give Springfield the state capital?</p><p>Twelve Democrats voted for the internal improvements bill, had an internal improvement in their County, and then supported Springfield before the penultimate 4th ballot. The other six Democrats that voted for the internal improvements bill started supporting Jacksonville and never wavered. Springfield had consolidated support from 75% of the Whig caucus by the 2nd ballot — but that alone did not make it the front runner. Democratic support for Springfield would go from 15% on the first ballot to 46% on the 4th ballot. The list of Democratic supports of Springfield on the 4th ballot is almost identical to the list of Democratic supporters of the internal improvements bill. The early support of the “logrolled 12”<a href="#_ftn5">[5]</a> was instrumental to making Springfield appear to be the inevitable victory.</p><p>The order of events is also remarkable. First — Lincoln and the Whigs send the internal improvements bill to the Governor’s desk with the help of a significant number of Democrats who were going to receive improvements in their home counties. Roughly a week later, those same Democrats save the bill moving the state capital from certain death. Roughly a week after that, the same coalition overturns the Governor’s veto. Two days later — Springfield wins. The Democrats controlled the House and Senate — they did not have to bring the State Capital bill to the floor — they had taken no action on the issue in the previous Legislature. Something had changed.</p><p>Morgan County Democrats wanted the internal improvements package because it was going to bring a railroad (which is why they narrowly supported it 4–2). The House Speaker knew Fayette County (Vandalia) was not large enough to deserve significant infrastructure investment. The Speaker also knew that Vandalia was too small and couldn’t realistically afford to build a new state capital. The capital was going to move sooner or later. Lincoln and the Sangamon County Whigs wanted the capital. Fayette County and other small, rural Democratic areas wanted railroads, canals, and roads. Rural Democrats agreed to allow Springfield to have the capital if the Whigs would deliver the votes for big ticket infrastructure projects in their backyard. Ten of the twenty-three (43%) House votes on the first ballot supporting Springfield were from Democrats — nine of the ten had an internal improvement in their County. All of them were from counties that were as close if not closer to Jacksonville or Vandalia. All of them were from counties that voted for Van Buren in the general election. There is no other logical conclusion — — no roads, no bridges, no railroads = no capital in Springfield.</p><p>Lincoln’s twin victories put him on the political map. The collapse of the infrastructure program was blamed on the economy and never became a partisan issue (partly because so many Democrats had supported it in the first place). Sangamon County Whigs never forgot who brought them the capital. Lincoln was catapulted to prominence in Whig statewide circles, ultimately landing him in the U.S. House of Representatives. His statewide profile was strong enough to make him an instant leader within the newly formed Republican Party of Illinois in the mid-1850s and the natural selection challenge Senator Stephen Douglass in the 1858 campaign. The 1858 Senate race would in turn lead to Lincoln’s nomination by the Republican Party for President.</p><p>President Lincoln would use the same horse-trading tactics he learned on the floor of the Illinois House to pass legislation that was integral in sustaining the Union war effort and secured the adoption of the 13th Amendment to the Constitution (ending slavery). Lincoln was probably one of the few men in history with the moral compass and political skills to forge and sustain a majority coalition in the North that ultimately both saved the Union and ended slavery.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref1">[1]</a> 70% for the Democratic Presidential candidate Van Buren in 1836 out of 336 voters.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref2">[2]</a> 60% for the Whig Presidential candidate in 1836 out of 2,300 voters.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref3">[3]</a> 52% for Van Buren out of 3,300 voters.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref4">[4]</a> Official record says 39–38 — but counting each individual name gets to 38–37. The author is siding with the Excel spreadsheet.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref5">[5]</a> A phrase coined by the author.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=423e42e28b8f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>