<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Azdiff on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Azdiff on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@azdiff?source=rss-8424cf63b043------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 07:08:41 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@azdiff/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Dance, Fight, Spin Around: The Music of Bayonetta]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@azdiff/dance-fight-spin-around-the-music-of-bayonetta-07113c90291e?source=rss-8424cf63b043------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/07113c90291e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[bayonetta]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[video-game-music]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Azdiff]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 03 Dec 2023 23:50:06 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-12-03T23:50:06.205Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="Album cover of Bayonetta’s offical soundtrack" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*z-qEgInrRhg1Wqk9.jpeg" /></figure><p>Revisiting the original <em>Bayonetta</em> — which celebrates its 15th birthday next year — it’s startling just how fully-formed it arrived. It’s a little rough around the edges with some quality of life stuff that later games would address (in ways that arguably made them less interesting), but all-in-all it came swinging out the gate as a complete and singular artistic statement. The fundamentals of the combat are still what PlatinumGames used in 2022 for <em>Bayonetta 3</em> (as well as many games in between), and the titular character’s campy extravagance was tuned perfectly from the get. It makes sense, though; this was Platinum’s debut after splitting from Capcom, formed by people who had worked together on several classic games with a <em>lot</em> of personality. Platinum formed with a clear idea of the kinds of games they wanted to make — namely, technical and flashy action games brimming with personality — and those kinds of games were a natural progression from the things they had worked on as Clover Studio under Capcom. The lines from <em>God Hand</em> and <em>Ōkami </em>to <em>Bayonetta</em> are not difficult to trace (to say nothing of the first <em>Devil May Cry</em>, which <em>Bayonetta</em> director Hideki Kamiya led even before Clover Studio’s existence), and you can feel the excitement that Platinum must have felt in making the kind of game <em>they</em> wanted to make, built upon lessons from previous games.</p><p>What I <em>can’t</em> really trace a lineage back to, though, is <em>Bayonetta</em>’s music, which arrived just as fully-formed despite not having a really clear precedent. The music was primarily composed by Hiroshi Yamaguchi, Masami Ueda, and Rei Kondoh, all of whom had previously worked on <em>Ōkami</em>; a clear precursor to <em>Bayonetta</em>’s combat, but less so in its personality and music. <em>Ōkami</em>’s music is great (and, along with the visuals, is the main appeal of an otherwise clunky game), but its atmosphere is entirely different from <em>Bayonetta</em>’s. It was a game inspired by Japanese mythology, and as such used traditional Japanese instrumentation; <em>Bayonetta</em> is rooted in European <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XRbbTqxxHVI">religion</a> and <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jiKaphN8R-o">fashion</a>, and the music draws upon those two ideas. The religious music pulls from the obvious source — European, particularly Christian, classical music — and that music is less surprising, partially because most video game (and film) scores come from that tradition, so while this religious bent is a <em>little </em>off the beaten path, you can still <em>see</em> the path from there. (There is also a little bit of precedence there with Masami Ueda’s work on <em>Devil May Cry</em>.) I’ll talk about that music, but what’s a lot more interesting is the music that’s lines up with European fashion and Bayonetta’s femininity.</p><p>After all, that fashion and femininity is where the heart of the game truly is. The main appeal for most people is not the idea of fighting grotesque, gray, Biblical angels. (Though there certainly <em>is</em> an appeal there.) The main highlight is the protagonist herself: domineering, flashy, effortlessly cool. The music that represents that part of the game — in its improvisational, joyful elegance and exuberance — is the true highlight of the game. Not only do I not see a clear precedent for it in any of the composers’ previous work, I don’t see much precedent for it in general, a hybrid of nu jazz, house, J-pop, and a consortium of other things. <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20090908003847/http://platinumgames.com/2009/05/29/the-music-of-bayonetta/">Lead composer Hiroshi Yamaguchi said</a> that he wanted to make music that was “both indicative of Bayonetta” and “could only appear in Bayonetta”, and on that front I think he succeeded.</p><h3>Theme of Bayonetta</h3><p>Crucial to understanding how the music in <em>Bayonetta</em> works is understanding how the gameplay functions. Bayonetta’s character action gameplay is derived with one goal in mind: you want to look as cool as possible, playing out flawless action sequences where Bayonetta dominates her opponent. In order to do this, you have to execute a variety of combos in a certain rhythm, using your entire arsenal of moves to keep things fresh, while also using dodges to avoid attacks in the middle of your combo. Essentially, there are basic static rhythm blocks that the combat is built around, but you need to improvise and deviate in order to keep things fresh and prevent interruptions. There’s an interplay between rigidity and fluidity that’s constantly at play; a key element in any character action game, but made even more important in <em>Bayonetta</em> because the “dodge offset” mechanic allows you to dodge and still continue your combo. A dodge isn’t an interruption, it’s an improvisation.</p><p>The game’s music has to match these rhythms, to offer structure while also feeling loose enough to feel like it’s opening up along with player expression. I get the sense that this was one of the composer’s initial considerations, just as important as matching who Bayonetta was as a character. We can get a glimpse of this through the game’s official soundtrack release, which comes with a series of demos called “Bayonetta Image Songs (Prototype)” that were presumably created as Platinum’s composers were figuring out the direction they wanted to take the music. The jazz instrumentation was evidently an obvious direction to match the fluidity; you can hear lots of upright bass, piano, and vibraphone in these early concepts. But it doesn’t seem like they had the rigidity down quite yet; Hiroshi Yamaguchi’s contribution, the first demo, feels a little <em>too</em> loose, driving its rhythm with an acoustic guitar of all things and letting the vibraphone take the lead. It sounds good (and I’d be interested to see what would’ve happened if he’d pursued that acoustic guitar further), but it doesn’t quite have enough personality, nor does it ground you in the heat of the rhythm enough.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2F7BSVKbmYsdA%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3D7BSVKbmYsdA&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2F7BSVKbmYsdA%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/109c8d303904bce7b76c083214f49a01/href">https://medium.com/media/109c8d303904bce7b76c083214f49a01/href</a></iframe><p>It sounds like a rough sketch of what would eventually become the magnificent “Riders of the Light”, one of the game’s main battle themes that, alongside “Fly Me to the Moon (∞ Climax Mix)” and Masami Ueda’s “Theme of Bayonetta — Mysterious Destiny”, form the trio of songs that the rest of the game’s music seems to flow from. These perfectly encapsulate the push and pull of the gameplay by mixing in dance rhythms with the airy jazz. Drum machines that hearken back to disco and early house set a stage that could easily set the stage for an NYC queer ball that Bayonetta would fit right in with. Synthesizer whistles and colourful vibraphones scatter through the music with whimsical grace. Yet the divisions between what’s static and what’s not are never that clear, with different instruments often jumping between roles at a whim.</p><p>Key example: the upright bass in “Riders of the Light” jumps around all over the place like a true jazz bassline, and the plucks on it sound different from moment to moment (the deep thud of the buzzes around 0:35 sound <em>heavy</em>), but there’s also a mechanical precision to its rhythm that keeps it in line with the drum machines and house piano. Likewise, the drum programming (which could be plucked straight from any ’80s house track) have jittery, yet consistent patterns. The piano effortlessly blends its ‘lead’ piano lines with its blocky ‘backing’ chords in a way where it never feels more like a lead than any other instrument, which could be vibraphone, synthesizer, or vocals at any given moment. Every instrument flows as part of the same musical idea, distinctly identifiable but never truly separate.</p><p>Just as important, however, are the songs where the vocals <em>are</em> given a distinct lead. Belgian singer Helena Noguerra (not to be confused with Bayonetta’s original voice actress, Hellena Taylor) provides the vocals in the game’s other two central themes, Masami Ueda’s “Mysterious Destiny” and Yamaguchi’s arrangement of “Fly Me to the Moon”. Neither track really slows down on any of the attributes that I mentioned with “Riders of the Light”; all of the instruments in both tracks are doing a <em>lot</em>, constantly busy with colour and action, but Noguerra’s vocals are also the unambiguous lead, especially in “Fly Me to the Moon”. It’s a difficult task to work in your own singing against all of that delicately-crafted instrumentation, especially since you’re working in the melody of an already-existing song <em>and</em> you have to do it in a way that works <em>with</em> the music instead of fighting <em>against</em> it.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FEV6E13xODyA%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DEV6E13xODyA&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FEV6E13xODyA%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/685a6c05c2b3bffeda3f456c74b1604a/href">https://medium.com/media/685a6c05c2b3bffeda3f456c74b1604a/href</a></iframe><p>But Yamaguchi’s arrangement and Noguerra’s singing work perfectly in tandem. Her inflection on every single line has an air of flirtatious confidence, at once sophisticated and playful, pristinely clear yet with an obscuring French accent inviting you to listen just a <em>little</em> closer. Yamaguchi’s arrangement works with that singing, carefully deploying backing vocals in varying moments that either match her singing, provide connective tissue between phrases, or drop out entirely at key moments to let her be the focus. The song essentially plays twice in a row with different arrangements (a great choice that constantly keeps the song sounding fresh), and the second time everything drops out but the drums and some sweeping strings, suddenly switching the song to something more intimate without dropping a beat in the action. Except that only truly lasts for a moment, as other instruments quickly and subtly pop into the arrangement before everything explodes back into the chorus.</p><p>“Riders of the Light” and “Fly Me to the Moon”, both the work of Hiroshi Yamaguchi, present such a seemingly specific and careful creative vision that I would’ve thought only one person could have nailed it. But I actually get the sense that this soundtrack was a very collaborative process. For one, I expect that much credit for the game’s sound can be given to industry veteran Masami Ueda, whose work dates back to the first <em>Resident Evil</em> and previously worked with Yamaguchi on <em>Ōkami</em>; only there, the roles were flipped, with Ueda in the lead composer role and Yamaguchi supporting. I imagine that these two worked together pretty closely on defining <em>Bayonetta</em>’s sound. Ueda also composed the game’s other excellent vocal theme, “Mysterious Destiny”, which has its own “Prototype” version containing many pieces of the full track in place, even leaning a little more into dance music than Yamaguchi’s demo. It makes me wonder if that demo came along a little further into the process, or if Ueda was a lot closer to the game’s final direction than the rest of the team at that point.</p><p>Still; Yamaguchi <em>is</em> credited as lead composer, and I think it’s no coincidence that his two main songs (“Riders of the Light” and “Fly Me to the Moon”) are undoubtedly the best in the game. My guess is that those songs functioned as a guidepost for the rest of the composers to work from, who he could direct appropriately. Because a <em>lot</em> of people worked on this game. Aside from Yamaguchi and Ueda, there are two other PlatinumGames composers (Erina Niwa and Takayasu Sudeoka) who provided significant contributions; Rei Kondoh came from T’s Music, after having already assisted Yamaguchi and Ueda on <em>Ōkami</em>; Sega loaned out a couple of people to rearrange some tracks from their classic arcade games to use in some minigame sections; GEM Impact was hired to compose some incidental music for cutscenes (as well as a few other things). All told, there’s eleven different composers who worked on this game, but in spite of that there’s an enormous amount of unity in how this game sounds. Nothing else sounds <em>quite</em> like the three main themes, but each track takes the pieces it needs, changes them based on that composer’s strengths, and brings them back into a soundtrack that sounds surprisingly unified.</p><p>I love how Ueda trades out the piano for organ and translates the jazzier elements away from dance music into rock for “The Heavies” and “In Trouble!”; how Kondoh finds the midway between dance and orchestral music in “Battle for the Umbra Throne” and “Climatic Battle”; how Niwa strips everything back to ambience in “Chapter Start” or a downtempo jam in “Driving With Mr. Enzo”; how Sudeoka’s “Crash of the Transport Plane” translates nearly every single element of the style into something that’s simultaneously lighter and more dramatic than the main themes; how Mitsuharu Fukuyama translates the main theme from <em>OutRun</em> into vibraphone and upright bass. Even the GEM Impact folks, whose contributions here are largely unmemorable, take a stab at a funky kind of <em>Shaft</em> thing for “Sexy Battle”. Every piece has its own unique style, yet I also imagine that most people wouldn’t clock how many composers actually worked on these pieces.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FcYdejg0dEqM%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DcYdejg0dEqM&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FcYdejg0dEqM%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/685287db6c965a2fe34d54e2b8e74ca1/href">https://medium.com/media/685287db6c965a2fe34d54e2b8e74ca1/href</a></iframe><p>Yet I really think that it is Yamaguchi who ties it all together. His involvement in subsequent <em>Bayonetta</em> games was drastically decreased — especially for the third one, where he only contributed a single (boring) song — and it really feels like no one else understood how the music worked the way he did. Neither game has a singer as mysteriously alluring as Helena Noguerra (<em>Bayonetta 2</em>’s Keeley Bumford sounds downright <em>bratty</em> in “Tomorrow Is Mine”); a gradual gravitation towards rock rhythms makes the songs plod instead of dance; elements of the jazz instrumentation gradual filter out in ways that make the songs pop less. They often sound good, and there’s good elements present in both sequels’ music that isn’t in the first games; Ueda’s electric pianos glimmer with majestic sheen as lead composer of <em>Bayonetta 2</em>, while Naofumi Harada let <em>Bayonetta 3</em>’s various composers run freer with their own styles to mixed but interesting results. But none of them have ever felt like Bayonetta, the character, in quite the same way. The character never changed, at least not in a meaningful or purposeful way, but the music did, starting to not quite match her personality in quite the same way.</p><h3>Angelic Hymns</h3><p>If I’m being honest, though, what I like least about the following games’ music is how they lean into the original game’s <em>worst</em> tendencies. Because the music I’ve just described is certainly not the whole of the game’s identity. It’s what I, and likely most people, associate with the series; the music that perfectly represents what Bayonetta herself is all about. But a core part of the series’ appeal is in how Bayonetta’s elegance contrasts with the grotesque, <em>drab</em> seriousness of the angels, demons, and (<em>sigh</em>) homunculi she fights. That contrast is reflected in the music, which matches those enemies with very serious, dramatic music that draws from the angels’ religious origins.</p><p>The thing is, though, is that while the game’s religious settings and characters are surprisingly well-researched and depicted, and are very important to Bayonetta’s character and design, they never feel like where the game’s heart is. They’re the elements that inform Bayonetta’s greatness, but they’re not what bring people to the game. And while the artists and writers may have had more interesting in how these angels are depicted, I’ve never felt that from most of <em>Bayonetta</em>’s musical team.</p><p>It’s not that Yamaguchi and Ueda aren’t capable of Western orchestral music, as they proved on <em>Ōkami</em>; even though its aesthetic focus was classical Japanese instrumentation, pieces like “Hana Valley” and “Ryoshima Coast” often used Western-style strings as the backdrop and framework in which to present the Japanese instruments that form the lead of the pieces. (Even Yamaguchi’s mostly silly superhero opera music in follow-up project <em>The Wonderful 101</em> showed some creativity in Western classical styles.) But I get the sense that they weren’t as interested in this <em>kind</em> of Christian classical music, especially in a context that doesn’t allow much room for playfulness; the angels are supposed to be the ugly, stodgy enemy that contrasts with Bayonetta’s creativity, and you want the music to reflect that difference. So Yamaguchi and Ueda’s few orchestral compositions — only three in all — feel a little out of place. (Though I will note that Ueda’s stage theme “The Old City of Vigrid” uses a low, faded choir to meld some of the instrumentation from the main themes and find a middle ground for a very pretty result; it sounds very similar to a lot of the excellent town and field themes he did in <em>Ōkami</em>. You can even hear a bit of the Gothic ambience from <em>Devil May Cry</em> and ominous beauty from <em>Resident Evil 2</em> in there.)</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2Fab7wLzVkA1s%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3Dab7wLzVkA1s&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2Fab7wLzVkA1s%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/d38c5194ed0f98e3d975343c9d4a34ab/href">https://medium.com/media/d38c5194ed0f98e3d975343c9d4a34ab/href</a></iframe><p>Ueda’s “Temperantia” theme is a complete wash (too slow, too loud, too cheaply dramatic), while Yamaguchi’s “Blood &amp; Darkness” has enough of the Bayonetta house style that it feels like it’d be better off at least ditching the choir and timpanis. (One piano line from it also shows up in “Climatic Battle”, and it sounds much better in that context.) Then there’s “One of a Kind”, which is the very first theme heard in the game as we’re introduced to Bayonetta’s past. Of the three, it’s definitely the best, but there’s also surprisingly little going on there; the song is basically variations on the same cyclical string pattern and very similar choir chants, which isn’t a bad idea, but one that doesn’t prove fruitful when Yamaguchi doesn’t actually showcase many interesting ideas in the arrangement. (There’s an 8-bit arrangement tucked away at the end of the fifth disc that I honestly think sounds better.) I get the sense that “One of a Kind” was more useful as a kind of guidepost for other composers to work from, an example of what the orchestral music should sound like tonally.</p><p>Ueda also seems to have had a hand in defining that sound; he made short arrangements of music from real classical composers, which are scattered throughout the game as ‘Angelic Hymns’. I imagine that these served as a reference for the game’s orchestral music. Holst’s <em>The Planets</em> and Wagner’s <em>Die Walküre</em> inform the aggressive chaos the game’s orchestral music can bring, while Handel’s <em>Messiah</em> serves as the magnificent reference for the religious choirs. Ueda’s arrangements even on the orchestral pieces are on piano (and there are some interesting multi-handed Schubert and Mozart piano pieces included as well), but the pieces chosen aren’t accidental; there’s a direct comparison between those pieces and the music you hear in this game.</p><p>So Yamaguchi and Ueda provided important reference points, then let other composers take the lead on the orchestral music, most notably Rei Kondoh (from a separate company, T’s Music), who had worked with them previously on <em>Ōkami</em>. Kondoh shows a bit more of a knack for that kind of dramatic music, and had already proven that on <em>Ōkami</em> with tracks like “Kushi’s Ride” and “Rising Sun”. Whereas Yamaguchi and Ueda’s choirs could sound a bit obnoxious, and drowned out by the orchestra, Kondoh is able to let melodies and rhythms come through a little clearer. But it’s not just that; it’s also that Kondoh seems to understand the Christianity of the music better, making the music sound more spiritual than his co-composers. You can even hear him making use of some specific reference points: the muted church sounds at 2:33 of “The Greatest Jubilee” evoke the “Hallelujah” section of <em>Messiah</em>, and the marching rhythms in “You May Call Me Father” are similar to “Trois marches militaires” and the “Mars” section of <em>The Planets</em>. I also like how “Sapientia” devolves into a chaotic mess of strained, muted trumpets before leading into the most euphoric, reverent choir in the whole soundtrack.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2F4tfnUfZZ6jw%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3D4tfnUfZZ6jw&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2F4tfnUfZZ6jw%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/bee3055fbd6bcbf3496168608ccc38fc/href">https://medium.com/media/bee3055fbd6bcbf3496168608ccc38fc/href</a></iframe><p>Yet if I were making a playlist to showcase <em>Bayonetta</em>’s music to someone uninitiated (<em>and I did</em>, as you’ll see down below), I wouldn’t bother including any of the orchestral music on there. Because it’s only ever good in flashes, and those flashes are never as good as (sorry to put it like this) the real thing. When they’re out here showing their homework like that, it doesn’t feel like there’s any <em>real</em> point to listening to any of these on their own; why <em>wouldn’t</em> you just listen to <em>Messiah</em> instead? (And the music’s never done much for me in-game, either; boss fights too often feel like clumsy uphill battles where it’s difficult to get any real flow going, and the plodding music only accentuates that. I’m fully willing to admit that might just be a literal skill issue, though.)</p><p>There continues to be a <em>lot</em> of orchestral music throughout the series (especially in <em>Bayonetta 2</em>), and no one ever really got better at it. Kondoh is the only artist who made significant contributions to all three games, and his orchestral themes are sometimes the closest tie to the original game’s music (even if it’s not the <em>kind</em> of music I’d like to see ties to). By <em>Bayonetta 3</em>, though, there wasn’t even any <em>reason</em> for it to stick to its religious roots, since the creatures you fight are just manmade blobs of goo. This often means that the music retreats to the original game’s <em>truly</em> basic instincts, which was usually to just slap some strings over a generic electronic beat and call it a day. This was the case for a lot of GEM Impact’s cutscene music in the first game, but some of the core staff did it for their stage music too, and it always sounded lazy and cheap. But it’s easy background music, a precious commodity if your soundtrack is over 250 songs in length (as <em>Bayonetta 3</em>’s soundtrack is). You need <em>some</em> filler in there at that rate.</p><p>It’s just that it feels like it’s nearly <em>all</em> filler now. Sure, new games hit the consistent checkboxes well enough: you get one vocal character theme, one cover of a jazz standard with ‘moon’ in the title, sequels to a bunch of the first game’s main themes (that are never as good)… And then a bunch of junk. There’s just no <em>reason</em> for these games that you can finish in 15 hours to also have 15 composers producing 7 hours of music in them! This has been a problem ever since the first game, but there was a vibrant heart to that game where the most important music truly shined. Meanwhile, I can barely scrape together an hour of music I’m passionate about from both sequels <em>combined</em>.</p><p>I guess my point in going on about the sequels is that not only was there no real precedent for <em>Bayonetta</em>’s music, there was also no real successor. The end result is that this game’s soundtrack feels even more precious, reinforcing just how marvelous it is that it exists in the first place, highlighting the sharpness of the craft. After the mess of <em>Bayonetta 3</em>’s release, I’m not sure what the future of the franchise looks like; to be honest, I’m not even sure what the future of Platinum looks like, whose best work in recent years has been supporting other studios and creators. But as Platinum’s defining mission statement, I’m glad this still stands tall.</p><h3>The Playlist Corner</h3><p>Part of “listening” to many video game soundtracks is sifting through the hours of material to find the stuff that’s actually worth listening to. This is especially true of <em>Bayonetta</em>, which has some true gold hidden among a lot of trash. So I’ve done the work for you here. I’ve got three lists:</p><ul><li>The Album — A single CD-length album that highlights the game’s musical strengths. If you were to only listen to one set of music from the game, this is what I’d recommend. This is also what I usually listen to!</li><li>Bonus Tracks — A series of tracks that are of interest, some of which are quite good, but don’t quite fit in the album.</li><li>Related Works — A selection of tracks from other games in the series, or other games that these composers have worked on. If you’re interested!</li></ul><h3>Bayonetta: The Album</h3><p>[Note: I’m using the titles on streaming services here, which seem to be the most official translations, but you might find other translations out in the wild. Also, “Fly Me to the Moon” isn’t present on streaming services, presumably due to licensing issues.]</p><ol><li>1.1 “Opening Demo” (Hiroshi Yamaguchi)</li><li>1.3 “GM01 Chapter Start” (Erina Niwa)</li><li>1.7 “Riders of the Light” (Hiroshi Yamaguchi)</li><li>1.8 “Fly Me to the Moon (∞ Climax Mix)” (Hiroshi Yamaguchi)</li><li>1.14 “The Gates of Hell” (Hiroshi Yamaguchi)</li><li>1.16 “ST02 Vigrid Station Platform” (Masami Ueda)</li><li>1.17 “Theme of Bayonetta — Mysterious Destiny” (Masami Ueda)</li><li>1.18 “ST03 The Old City of Vigrid” (Masami Ueda)</li><li>1.21 “The Heavies” (Masami Ueda)</li><li>1.22 “Summoning the Infernal Demon” (Masami Ueda)</li><li>1.24 “GM02 Chapter Clear” (Erina Niwa)</li><li>1.28 “Battle for the Umbra Throne” (Rei Kondoh)</li><li>1.35 “In Trouble!” (Masami Ueda)</li><li>2.15 “Red &amp; Black” (Hiroshi Yamaguchi)</li><li>2.11 “Let’s Hit the Climax!” (Masami Ueda)</li><li>4.22 “Let’s Dance, Boys!” (Hiroshi Yamaguchi)</li></ol><p><strong>Length: 49 min</strong></p><h3>Bayonetta: Bonus Disc</h3><p>I ordered them roughly in order of styles: orchestral, more Bayonetta action, rearrangements of old SEGA themes, promo materials and demos.</p><ul><li>1.2 “One of a Kind” (Hiroshi Yamaguchi)</li><li>2.6 “Angelic Hymns I” (Rei Kondoh)</li><li>2.7 “Angelic Hymns II” (Rei Kondoh)</li><li>2.10 “Climatic Battle” (Rei Kondoh)</li><li>3.28 “Blood &amp; Darkness” (Hiroshi Yamaguchi)</li><li>3.21 “Sapientia — In the Choice Between Good and Evil” (Rei Kondoh)</li><li>4.10 “You May Call Me Father” (Rei Kondoh)</li><li>4.17 “The Greatest Jubilee” (Rei Kondoh)</li><li>4.23 “Memory” (Takayasu Odeoka)</li><li>1.9 “EV03–1 Driving With Mr. Enzo” (Erina Niwa)</li><li>1.30 “EV09 Luka Appears” (Masami Ueda)</li><li>1.34 “EV09–5 Bayonetta, Ready to Fight II” (Masami Ueda)</li><li>2.3 “EV12–2 Action!” (Masami Ueda)</li><li>2.20 “EV16 Sexy Battle” (GEM Impact)</li><li>3.18 “ST11 Save Cereza!” (Takayasu Sodeoka)</li><li>2.24 “Splash Wave (∞ Climax Mix)” (Mitsuharu Fukuyama)</li><li>2.25 “After Burner (∞ Climax Mix)” (Masami Ueda)</li><li>2.26 “Magnificent 7 (∞ Climax Mix)” (Hiro)</li><li>3.23 “Space Harrier (∞ Climax Mix)” (Hiro)</li><li>5.22 “2008 Tokyo Game Show Trailer” (Hiroshi Yamaguchi)</li><li>5.23 “Bayonetta Image Song (Prototype A)” (Hiroshi Yamaguchi)</li><li>5.24 “Mysterious Destiny (Prototype)” (Masami Ueda)</li><li>5.25 “Bayonetta Image Song (Prototype B)” (Erina Niwa)</li><li>5.26 “Bayonetta Image Song (Prototype C)” (Erina Niwa)</li></ul><h3>Related Works</h3><ul><li>“Save Room” (Masami Ueda, <em>Resident Evil 2</em>)</li><li>“Hana Valley” (Masami Ueda, <em>Ōkami</em>)</li><li>“Rising Sun” (Rei Kondoh, <em>Ōkami</em>)</li><li>“Ryoshima Coast I” (Hiroshi Yamaguchi, <em>Ōkami</em>)</li><li>“Moon River (∞ Climax Mix)” (Naofumi Harada, <em>Bayonetta 2</em>)</li><li>“Theme of Bayonetta 2 — Tomorrow Is Mine” (Hiroshi Yamaguchi, <em>Bayonetta 2</em>)</li><li>“Time for the Climax!” (Masami Ueda, <em>Bayonetta 2</em>)</li><li>“Moonlight Serenade (Eternal Climax Mix)” (Seiji Hotta, <em>Bayonetta 3</em>)</li><li>“Theme of Bayonetta 3 — Al Fine” (Naofumi Harada &amp; Hitomi Kurokawa, <em>Bayonetta 3</em>)</li><li>“GH()ST” (Tomoki Kameyama, <em>Bayonetta 3</em>)</li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=07113c90291e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Game Music Diary — Aug 2022]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@azdiff/game-music-diary-aug-2022-a1480f98a48c?source=rss-8424cf63b043------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a1480f98a48c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[nier-automata]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[multiversus]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[doom]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[video-game-music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[unpacking]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Azdiff]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 10 Sep 2022 17:13:39 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-09-11T03:51:43.936Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Game Music Diary — Aug 2022</h3><p>Another round of me writing about music from every game I play this year. You can find previous entries if you click to my page. The roundup this time is:</p><ol><li><em>MultiVersus</em></li><li><em>NieR: Automata</em></li><li><em>Unpacking</em></li><li><em>Kirby’s Adventure</em></li><li><em>Doom</em> (2016)</li></ol><h3>Edouard Brennstein — “Sky Arena”</h3><h4>MultiVersus (2022)</h4><figure><img alt="Garnet and Gizmo vs. double Shaggy. What a world." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*6mko_0Pt3hhpXCuvLtUUEg.png" /></figure><p>Do none of these publishers recognize how important the music is to <em>Smash</em>? Part of what make <em>Smash</em> so great as a celebration of games is how it takes these pieces from each franchise’s history and recontextualizes them, and part of that is the music. With <em>MultiVersus</em>, this admittedly poses more of a challenge; films and TV series are not known for their music as often as games are, and typically film scores don’t focus as deep on the melodies. But they’ve still got some recognizable stuff to work with, some of which they’ve used (Danny Elfman’s <em>Batman</em> theme, songs from both <em>Adventure Time</em> and <em>Steven Universe</em>), with many more to potentially grab.</p><p>The problem is that they have no interest in rendering these dynamically. Warner Bros. have their own in-house guys to do these arrangements, and that kind of corporatism comes through in the music. There’s no sense of whimsy or adventure in these arrangements, and in many cases it seems like any uniqueness was deliberately <em>avoided</em>. “Sky Arena” draws from <em>Steven Universe</em>’s main theme <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PfKUdmTq2MI">“We Are the Crystal Gems”</a>, a cute song in a show with a lot of diverse styles. Here, though, it’s just smoothed over into a glossy series of strings that sound like they could be thrown in any random-ass mobile game. You can catch the melody, sure — although it’s worth noting that said melody is literally just David Bowie’s “Space Oddity” — but it’s not <em>doing</em> anything with it. There’s nothing exciting, nothing new; actually, it feels like there’s stuff being taken away. They made such a big deal of making sure the characters had their proper voice actors, that they captured the elements that made those characters unique; I just wish that character had carried over into the music.</p><p>This was the piece of music that the <em>MultiVersus</em> team chose to highlight before the release of the game’s open beta, which was <em>not </em>a promising sign moving forward. They’re doing a bit more now — some stages have multiple music tracks, and they’re uploading some tracks to YouTube with full credits and everything — but it still feels like the bare minimum. <em>MultiVersus</em> has kept a lot of momentum going by virtue of being free-to-play in a genre where the lack of options is embarrassing, but if they want to really keep a lot of people hooked for years they’ve gotta put in a bit more effort here. Scrap the orchestras, or at least put a little edge into the arrangements; let the music stand out. (And not simply by blasting it loudly, like how “Get Schwifty” is a million times louder than any other music in the game for some reason.) Hell, even just slot some of the original theme songs in there; anything’s better than those.</p><h3>Keiichi Okabe — “Song of the Ancients (Atonement)”</h3><h4>NieR: Automata (2017)</h4><figure><img alt="Devola and Popola atoning for their sins." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*QM8W-yx9p7c5iSZo2mhqrQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>I already talked about parts of this game’s soundtrack elsewhere — covering pieces like <a href="https://medium.com/@azdiff/nier-automata-ending-a-26d5905b6df2">“City Ruins”, “Amusement Park”,</a> and <a href="https://medium.com/@azdiff/nier-automata-endings-c-d-and-e-db20f977b18b">“Weight of the World” </a>— so I won’t linger on it here. Instead, let’s talk about the soundtrack to the original <em>NieR</em>, which gets referenced in <em>Automata</em> quite a bit. Several tracks in <em>Automata</em> (“Grandma (Destruction)”, “Dark Colossus (Kaiju)”, “Emil (Despair)” are rearrangements of pieces from the first game, while others (“Memories of Dust”, “Forest Kingdom”, “Wretched Weaponry”) call back to previous pieces indirectly. The presence of the original game lingers in this game’s soundtrack.</p><p>I think it’s fair to call <em>Automata</em>’s soundtrack a tad better than <em>NieR</em>’s, simply because it has more original pieces in a wider variety of styles. But the original <em>NieR</em> soundtrack (and I mean the original, not <em>ver. 1.22</em>, which adds extra details to the arrangements that mostly feel unnecessary) is so foundational to <em>Automata</em>’s soundtrack, and its best tracks are so damned good, that it feels unfair to say. “Song of the Ancients”, “Kainé”, and “Emil” still feel like the classics of the series, with “City Ruins” and arguably “Weight of the World” being <em>Automata</em>’s only real additions to that canon. And even though I’d say the arrangements in <em>Automata</em> are better than the original <em>NieR</em>’s, I still find myself reaching for arrangements from the first game. “Song of the Ancients”, in particular, already had so many arrangements in the first game that this new one feels superfluous; we already have a bombastic arrangement very similar to this “Atonement” arrangement; why do I need another?</p><p>But this does fit with the soundtrack as a whole more. <em>Automata</em>’s arrangements generally have <em>more</em>, probably as a result of a larger budget but also because the game itself just feels bigger. And this fight in particular is also very big; instead of a direct fight <em>against</em> Devola and Popola, here they help you fight off a literally endless horde of enemies as the camera pans out to show off the mass carnage happening. So it makes sense that the strings and drums are a little tighter, that the brass section hops in to dramatically punctuate the gravity of the battle at hand. “Atonement” isn’t as inventive as the dreamy percussion of <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5FaEtvA_11A">“Song of the Ancients / Fate”</a> from the original game, which blended its drama with a rhythm that made it feel the melody feel like an elegant, at times <em>intimate</em> dance. (I love the acoustic guitar strumming!) But “Atonement” <em>does</em> suit the purposes of that scene more than “Fate” would have. For <em>NieR: Replicant ver. 1.22</em>, Kuniyuki Takahashi did <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i9lZDYzcSRE">a new version of the “Fate” arrangement</a> that combines both approaches, blending the original’s elegance with the orchestral pounding of “Atonement”, and while at times it feels like it’s doing <em>too</em> much, there’s also something magical about how MONACA (the studio who does <em>NieR</em>’s music, and many other games) found themselves able to revisit the same track so many times to find new ways to make it sound good.</p><h3>Jeff van Dyck — “Infatuation”</h3><h4>Unpacking (2021)</h4><figure><img alt="A kitchen that our main character also has to use as an office." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*aFdgMFBOLOOcaQlRRmkwwA.jpeg" /></figure><p>The coolest thing about this game is showing how much detail of a person’s life you’re able to piece together by the things that they own and the space that they have. The game has you unpacking a character’s things in eight different parts of their life, and the game gives you few details about their situation until after you’ve already finished unloading their things in their proper spots. But it’s easy to put together based on what things they have, what things they got rid of, and what they’re allowed to get rid of.</p><p>The most interesting chapter on this front comes when the character moves in with her boyfriend. His home is slick and modern in a very male kind of way, all greys and smooth countertops. It’s a stark contrast from every other location she lived in (and will later live in); it’s a space that never quite feels like <em>hers</em>, even though you’re free to rearrange his things as much as you like. Everything feels a little uneasy, like she’s invading somewhere that she doesn’t quite belong in, and it doesn’t feel like it’s accommodating her, either. It’s even the only point in the story where she doesn’t have her own working area for her art career; even when she was 11 in the first chapter, she had a desk under her bunk bed to work. Here, it feels like her boyfriend is letting her live in <em>his</em> home, not like they’re building a life together.</p><p>Topping this off is Jeff van Dyck’s “Infatuation”, a piece of music that feels very different from the rest of his score. Most of it is a kind of cute indie folktronica that feels on par with what you’d expect for this kind of style, but here the music slows down to a cooler groove. It’s driven by some great muted funk guitar, occasionally slipping into some cool blues licks but never letting go of that groove. Even when the muted guitar opens up into some chickenscratch strumming, the vibe is still very reserved; steady, but never quite sure how to fully open up. It always feels like it’s testing the waters a bit, never really sure on how to be comfortable.</p><p>Once you complete the chapter, the protagonist’s caption reads that ‘it feels like such a big deal moving into his place!’, which to me conveys she’s more interested in the <em>act</em> than the <em>person</em>. As time goes on, this reading proves correct. In the next level, she moves back home after breaking up with her boyfriend. (She still has his picture, but you’re <em>not</em> allowed to hang it up; you have to stuff it in a drawer.) Eventually she lives together with another partner who is most certainly <em>not</em> male, and it feels like a much more natural fit. The captions with her new partner read much more personal and adoring, especially as they bring a baby into their life. The music in those sections is much more tender, the kind of stuff that makes you feel warm and cozy inside, indicative of a much more comfortable relationship.</p><h3>Hirokazu Ando — “Sea &amp; Ship Level”</h3><h4>Kirby’s Adventure (1993)</h4><figure><img alt="The first level of Ice Cream Island in Kirby’s Adventure." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*nbapxaahDLm6m1aWxl364g.jpeg" /></figure><p>Jun Ishikawa and Hirokazu Ando are known as the main musical forces behind the <em>Kirby</em> series, but I kind of assumed that Ishikawa was more of a lead, because he composed the music for the first <em>Kirby</em> game <em>Kirby’s Dream Land</em>. But you could argue that <em>Adventure</em> is the first real <em>Kirby</em> game, because it’s the one that brought him into colour and added copy powers, really making the series into what it’s best known for. That soundtrack is composed and arranged entirely by Ando, as it turns out, and I didn’t realize just how much of the <em>Kirby</em> sound comes from this game. Ishikawa’s <em>Dream Land</em> soundtrack delivered the two most iconic <em>Kirby</em> tracks — “Green Greens” and “Mt. Dedede” — but it’s in <em>Adventure</em> where Ando used that as a launching pad to really define what the series’ soundtracks would sound like. <em>Dream Land</em> was limited by the Game Boy’s sonic capabilities, and admittedly the NES wasn’t much better; but this was deep into the life of the NES (and in fact the SNES had already been out for a few years when this was released), and they knew how to get the most of the soundtracks. Arrangements sound smoother, and the hyperactivity that “Green Greens” defined could be explored in more detail, with better harmonies and rhythms. “Sea &amp; Ship Level” (better known as “Ice Cream Island”) and “Castle Level” (better known as “Butter Building”) are the best examples of this, and it’s no surprise that both of them have shown up repeatedly across the <em>Kirby</em> franchise. <em>Super Smash Bros.</em>, too; “Butter Building” is actually quoted in <a href="https://youtu.be/RXs4-M-ZiOg?t=48">the Sheik/Zelda section of the <em>Melee</em> intro</a>, and <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dO5RIdYyUoo"><em>Smash for Wii U</em>’s rendition of “Ice Cream Island”</a> updates the aesthetic from <em>Adventure</em> for fuller sounds.</p><p>That “Ice Cream Island”<em> </em>arrangement (which, incidentally, was done by Yoshihito Yano, whose incredible work on <em>Katamari Damacy</em> I’ve already written about) is a perfect example of where this soundtrack shines. Yano kept most of the original pieces intact — he made the bass and drums thicker, but left the chiptune sounds at the forefront — because that’s just what it sounds like the piece was <em>made</em> for. There’s no approximation of real instruments here, and later attempts to translate them to, for instance, a tropical steel drum arrangement in <em>Kirby’s Epic Yarn</em> don’t really come off. (Though I do quite like the piano arrangement of “Butter Building”.) Ishikawa and Ando both feel like electronic composers at heart, who knew how to make the most of the tools at their disposal to make music that was both charming and exciting.</p><p>(By the way, did you know that they also recorded <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_ZxCOmFK2VQ">a vocal version</a> of the <em>Kirby’s Adventure</em> soundtrack? Sounds utterly bizarre. I would love to know how and why that came about.)</p><h3>Mick Gordon — ”BFG Division”</h3><h4>Doom (2016)</h4><figure><img alt="Blastin’ demons with a plasma rifle." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ehRhLBW_VFuPxDvjm_N7dQ.png" /></figure><p>There are several games that I feel <em>Doom</em> 2016 can be aptly compared to, and while the original <em>Doom</em> is on that list, it’s decidedly <em>not</em> at the top. That’s fair, for the most part; I think in order to update the game for contemporaneous consoles, id Software had to dial back on the goofiness that doesn’t work quite as well when Cacodemons start to look so… Fleshy. There had to be an element of realism that permeated through the entire experience, betraying its roots while still retaining enough of its essence.</p><p>This, of course, means ditching the silly Metallica and Pantera ripoffs for something more genuinely heavy, something that matches the weight of all the blood and guts in hell. Apparently id said at the start that they didn’t want any guitars in <em>Doom</em> 2016’s soundtrack, which is really funny because Bobby Prince initially started out with any guitars for <em>Doom</em> 1993 and moved towards metal there. History repeating itself, and indeed <em>Doom</em> would not be <em>Doom</em> without any guitars. Mick Gordon’s soundtrack is very popular, and I think a lot of that comes down to how he blended the sheen of electronics and ambient with metal to make something not quite like anything else I’ve heard. The closest metal had come to ambient before this was post-metal (or ‘atmospheric sludge metal’ or whatever people are calling it these days, metalheads are freaks about their subgenres), Neurosis and Isis and the like, but those artists brought their ambience through quiet sections and slow speed; <em>Doom</em> 2016 takes the speed and groove of djent and processes it so hard that it all blends into the same shiny, sterile sound, something that can fade into the background just as easily as it fuels some headbanging demonslaying. There are indeed guitars, but they could just as easily be synthesizers; it’s all part of the same sonic palate.</p><p>This has its benefits and tradeoffs. The sound basically eliminates any possibility of something resembling a melody; no matter how many times I hear the <em>Doom</em> 2016’s arrangement of “At Doom’s Gate”, I can barely hear the remnants of the original music in there. It’s all squelch all the time, which means it always basically sounds good but rarely ever makes the effort to stand out. Most differences in the music are defined by tempo (the slow rising of “Hellwalker”), rhythm (the electrifying chug of “BFG Division”), or deviations from electronics (the ridiculous[ly bad] choir in “Cyberdemon”). At first glance it all sounds the same, and while I could see that changing with familiarity, it doesn’t leap out to me. Plus, the dynamics are all over the place in the official soundtrack; even if you cut out the ambient tracks, there are all kinds of useless quiet parts within the metal songs that don’t do anything to build tension. They just kind of detract from the fun.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a1480f98a48c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Nier: Automata — Endings C, D, and E]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@azdiff/nier-automata-endings-c-d-and-e-db20f977b18b?source=rss-8424cf63b043------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/db20f977b18b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[nier]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nier-automata]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Azdiff]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 23 Aug 2022 23:39:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-08-23T23:39:40.683Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Nier: Automata — Endings C, D, and E</h3><p>In my earlier writeups on <em>Nier: Automata</em>’s <a href="https://medium.com/@azdiff/nier-automata-ending-a-26d5905b6df2">first</a> <a href="https://medium.com/@azdiff/nier-automata-ending-b-b257cb979e56">two</a> endings, I suspected that the game would truly come together as its characters developed and came to stand in for larger ideas for the game. I don’t know if that’s quite as true as I thought, but it’s still a good lens to approach the game as a whole from. So here is route C — endings C, D, and E — through the perspective of the game’s central characters.</p><h4>Devola and Popola</h4><figure><img alt="Devola: “Mornin’. Slept well, didn’t ya, 9S?”" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*u_Yle19W3j4UbZAHNHYijA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Heartbroken. These two were among my favourite characters from the first <em>NieR</em>, because they were the only characters left who knew the whole picture. They knew about the history of Project Gestalt, and were tasked with overseeing it to completion; yet they themselves were androids who understood the plight of the replicants. The shades started to lose themselves as the replicants started to gain themselves, and the twins were caught in the middle of it, tasked with defending what this game refers to as the ‘Original Gestalt’: Nier himself, who was the first shade to retain their consciousness during the separation of soul and body, who would theoretically eventually save the world. They played a manipulative role, but they also truly cared for Nier, the replicant, while attempting to defuse Nier, the shade. It was a line they couldn’t truly walk, and their compassion was their end, slain in the face of both Niers’ unrelenting thirst for violence.</p><p>The Devola and Popola in <em>Automata</em> are not the same people as before, one of many models sent to many different areas. But they’re clearly still Devola and Popola, with numerous nods to the previous game: Popola tells 9B not to overdo it, just like she told Nier; Devola’s a heavy drinker, while Popola avoids the stuff because she can’t hold her liquor; they say they’ve been waiting for 9S before the final battle, the same way they told Nier. Only this time, instead of fighting our protagonist, they help him. Helping, they say, in an effort to atone for their sins.</p><p>After the events of the first game, the Devolas and Popolas no longer had any purpose, Project Gestalt officially having failed. They were deemed outcasts, and were actually programmed with feelings of guilt. (By who, I’m not sure; who’s writing all these reports about Gestalt even after humans were wiped out?) They know that they weren’t the same Devola and Popola that caused the collapse of Project Gestalt, but even we can see that they are fundamentally the same people; they would have failed just as easily. Yet <em>Automata</em> takes place several thousands of years after the events of the first game, in an era where most androids believe that there are still humans on the moon; Project Gestalt is entirely unknown to them. Devola and Popola continue to be ostracized, but you get the sense that no one really knows why. That’s just how it’s supposed to be, and even Devola and Popola seem to agree. Even if they wanted to grow, it’s outside of their programming to do so.</p><p>The story you can read that details their history, struggling through life together, reads unbelievably tragic to me. Not only were they not actually responsible for the events of Gestalt’s collapse, it wasn’t even really a bad thing that it happened. The project was always a long shot, and even <em>Automata</em>’s Devola and Popola describe witnessing replicants gaining consciousness in real time, shivering in horror as they realized the chaos that would ensue. As that chaos did unfold, and shades died out, replicants became the new humans. Life carried on; even the replicants themselves were modeled after real humans, so it’s the <em>same humans</em> that lived. To what extend the androids of <em>Automata</em> are connected to replicants isn’t clear (9S discovers that they’re made from machine cores, so they didn’t exists in this form until the alien invasion, but they’re still clearly connected), but it doesn’t matter; the real goal was to preserve consciousness, and thousands of years later, it’s still there. Any of the problems facing the world now are decidedly <em>not</em> the result of any of Devola and Popola’s actions.</p><p>Yet they’re cursed. Cursed with the knowledge of what once was, of how things went to hell, with the feelings of their part in it, feelings that they literally cannot shake. It’s tragic, but I also find it beautiful how connected they are to each other. In their memories, Popola wonders, ‘I couldn’t have done this by myself. I would have descended into madness. I simply couldn’t bear such a burden all alone.’ Yet she also wonders about the cruelty of the humans who made them twin models, to know that would help them survive. Death, it’s suggested, would be the more humane option; and it’s what they finally choose when they help 9S (who resembles Nier himself more and more as he reckons with the truth of YoRHa’s existence and deals with the grief of 2B’s death). Pod 153 asks why they chose death, instead of letting one of them survive; 9S says he hopes the pod never understands.</p><h4>Pascal</h4><figure><img alt="Pascal: “It seems this Nietzsche was quite the profound thinker.”" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*LL8uSdtKE2LzFuuCC76dLQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>In many ways, Devola and Popola’s curse resembles those of the machines more than the androids. We know that androids have free will, up to a point, and what holds them to their endless cycle of death is their societal structure and their reprogrammable nature. In their world, there’s at least <em>someone</em> who knows the whole picture, and they have enough consciousness that they could drop the entire thing if they wanted to. Machines don’t have that luxury; they evolved like replicants did, but tangled with an explicit goal to ‘destroy the enemy’; whoever that enemy may be. After this led them to turn on their creators, they discovered human records and Project Gestalt, and those who managed to form their own societies modeled themselves off of humans they never had any direct lineage to.</p><p>Meanwhile, those still connected to the network locked themselves into endless war by crippling themselves just enough so that they would always continue fighting, so that they could always fulfill their prime directive. With that in mind, it makes sense that Adam and Eve would come away from their research on humanity feeling like the core of human existence is conflict. (And they’re not entirely wrong to think so; in fact, ‘perpetual struggle’ does seem to be the core ethos of capitalism. Marx and Engels are both among the name drops in this game, after all.) With both machines and androids committed to perpetual war, the idea of a self-sustaining community like Pascal’s (which quite literally does operate on socialist principles) a pipe dream. No one can truly isolate themselves from the world surrounding them; even Pascal’s village had to defend themselves from machines and trade with the resistance. Eventually war came to their village; his back to the wall, Pascal turned to fight. (With vigor, I might add.) He commands an Engels goliath for an ultimate kaiju battle, slaughtering dozens of machines in the process, only for his village to be completely destroyed, his children having killed themselves from the fear he taught them to feel.</p><p>He gives the player a choice: to delete his memories, or to kill him. (Or, a hidden third option, to leave him.) There’s no ‘right’ answer here, but this game makes it clear that wiping memories is only ever a temporary solution. In sidequests, we meet an executioner model who wipes their own memories of killing their friends over and over, only to relive the horror when they find out again; we meet a couple, one of whom has their memory wiped by the other until they become a warrior who can keep them both safe. And of course, 9S’s memory is wiped over and over after 2B kills him, only for him to find out the truth again and for 2B to kill her best friend, again and again. Forgetting only traps you in the same cycles, unable to learn for the future.</p><p>Yet, sometimes it feels as though learning only meaningfully leaves you with hardships. If we leave Pascal, what good does that do them? What good did that do for Devola and Popola? All they got out of their experiences with Gestalt was pain and guilt; they lived long enough to eventually crave death. There comes a point where learning just leaves you feeling entirely helpless, where people in control simply don’t care. They plan to keep things how they are, come hell or high water. Pascal pleads for A2 to spare him that cruelty if she leaves him, and he’s right to do so.</p><p>Does that truly leave death as the only option? Maybe — at least for Pascal. Both A2 and 9S learned something from Pascal, have carried Pascal’s existence forward with them, and they <em>do</em> have the power to change things, within the tower. A2 and 9S carry on after their tragedies for the wrong reasons — reasons that could never sustain Pascal — but something from Pascal lingers, bringing them to their next future.</p><h4>Emil</h4><figure><img alt="Emil: “I can’t believe I remembered something so important…right at the end.”" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8MmDph0uSezVp-FSXE0COA.png" /></figure><p>Losing his memories certainly didn’t work out for Emil, who doesn’t play a major part in the main story but instead has his own sidequest chain. Emil, in many ways, felt like the first <em>NieR</em>’s most tragic character; a boy cursed with immortality who is unable to look directly at anyone lest they be turned to stone. His only way out was to merge with his sister, leaving him in a form that looks hostile and deranged no matter which era of the planet he’s in, one that leaves him just as unable to experience intimacy as his cursed human form. (Even more so at the end of the game, where he loses all of his body other than his head. Ending E of <em>NieR Replicant ver. 1.22</em> brings him back in full-bodied form, but in this game we never see anything but heads.)</p><p>What he got up to since then, it’s hard to say; all the Emil we meet knows is that he used his powers to create copies of himself in an attempt to stop the alien invasion. As he split apart, though, he lost more and more of his memories, including those of Nier and Kainé, which he slowly regains as you complete his sidequests. The Emil we’re talking to probably isn’t even the original Emil; he probably doesn’t exist anymore. If you go far enough into the quest — stealing from his home, for some reason, and upgrading all weapons to their max strength — you can eventually fight a whole host of his clones out in the desert. (I came across them prior to this while exploring on my own, and it was a shock to say the least.) The Emil we’ve talked to is very amiable, perhaps because he seems to remember little of the recent past. And we help him to try and remember his best days, those of his closest friends.</p><p>These clones, however, only remember the endless struggles against the aliens. They fought, and they failed, and cycles of violence only repeat forever. They’re angry and exhausted, and it seems like they want to die; and it takes someone as strong as you to finally release them. Our Emil fights against this, finally fully remembering how his old friends always fought against the odds. (Though whether Nier was fighting for something truly good is debatable.) But even he succumbs in the end. As far as I’m concerned, all of the Emils deserve their rest; they’ve sacrificed more than anyone, and now they’ve got nothing left to give.</p><h3>A2</h3><figure><img alt="A2: “How beautiful this world is.”" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*K8kydR6GOesh4yBAmoOBHQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Yet everyone seems to have different points where they’re spent. At the point where we first learn about A2, she seems like she’s been spent; abandoned and betrayed by YoRHa and victim of slaughter by machines, she doesn’t have much to live for. She claims to be fueled by hatred, but almost as soon as she mercy kills 2B and claims her memories, she seems to be different. What might have seemed a waste may still have room for redemption.</p><p>Though truthfully, A2’s prior hatefulness is entirely a suggestion; we barely see her before she acquires 2B’s memories, and even though she does seek to kill every machine she can find, she seems to do so out of aimlessness more than anything. When Pod 042 asks what her primary goal is, she’s just like, I dunno, I kill machines. Even when she kills the Forest King and fights 2B and 9S, she carries herself in a very calm way. That anger, it seems, might be a bit of projection from others and an excuse from herself. (It also calls back to Kainé from the first game, a character who <em>did</em> show her rage at every opportunity, and whose ragtag clothes and wrapped-up leg are very similar to A2’s disheveled appearance.) A2 isn’t angry; she’s just bitter and empty, choosing the easy narrative that still gives her a reason to exist.</p><p>That might be why she’s so quick to do an about-face after gaining 2B’s memories; it’s not that she necessarily learned from 2B. In some ways, she already <em>is</em> 2B, being an early prototype of her model. It’s more that 2B clearly had a purpose, and A2 picking up the pieces of her life means that she’s also getting tangled up with 9S, who <em>is</em> full of hate. I don’t know how committed A2 ever is to the cause — she mostly seems to be simply going through the motions, at least until the very end — but there’s enough inertia there to keep her going, pushed along by her new pod companion.</p><p>This arguably puts her in the same situation as the player, who at this point doesn’t really have a horse in this race. Until you enter the tower and discover its true purpose, there’s no real enemy to point yourself towards; you know that both androids and machines are victims here, and that the reasons for living that both A2 and 9S give themselves are kind of made up. I, at least, was mostly driven by motivation to see what happens, to unravel the mysteries, to hope that our player characters learn and evolve. That’s not much more than A2, so even though we don’t know much about her (and disappointingly, we never really do), she becomes easy to view as the protagonist of this route, in opposition to 9S’s blind hatred.</p><p>It seems like the game expects that of the player, anyway. Her ending, “meaningless [C]ode”, is given precedence over 9S’s D ending, and it feels a little better to get before the reveal in 9S’s ending undercuts it a little. After A2 and 9S spill all the secrets they individually know to each other, bringing each other to the same level of understanding, A2 emerges victorious. However, she has no real quarrel with 9S — he’s really the one attacking her, and he’s so far consumed by the logic virus that there’s no point in trying to talk him out of it. So she tries to remove the virus, at the cost of her own life, and also attempts to save humanity’s data that the tower is positioned to destroy. Somewhere along the way, I think A2 discovered a purpose, and this is her chance to fulfill that purpose. She wants to save what life she can, and I <em>think</em> in her final acts, she wanted to reveal all the world’s secrets to everyone. (Honestly, it’s hard to tell; we see so little into her interior life that it’s hard to gauge her feelings at any point, and I wish that the game spent a little more time developing her.) At any rate, that’s what happens; when you boot up the game again after getting her ending, you can see a report from Jackass detailing all the information that was gleaned from the destruction of the tower, everything from the lie of YoRHa to the true history of the machines.</p><p>It doesn’t matter, though. Jackass’s takeaway from that is that, if everything was and is meaningless, then we might as well just wipe everyone from the earth. A2’s mission failed, because violence is the fastest way for people to reconcile their own meaninglessness… At least according to this ending.</p><h4>9S</h4><figure><img alt="9S: “I’ll tear you apart… Every last one of you!”" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*mqWjOEXQ9Z-RXf8nnmdWzQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>That’s certainly the path that 9S chose, anyway. Hard to blame him, really; his existence was defined by betrayal more than anyone else, because even the one person who really, genuinely cared for him — who he cared for in return — repeatedly killed him over and over again. Yet that didn’t stop him from loving her, and after he learned the truth about humanity, she was his only real reason to live. But she dies right after that, and what does that leave him with? Hurt, pain, and nothing else. On top of that, he is ravaged from a virus within that leaves him with a ticking clock. He has to do something with what little time he has left. All that’s left is to destroy the machines at their source.</p><p>If A2 is meant to stand in for the player in this route, 9S might be the one who truly lies at the heart of the story. He’s the character who, in the end, the player spends the most time controlling, the one who the player processes most of the game’s big reveals through. He sees everything, the lies of the machines and YoRHa and his own best friend, and comes out the other end with enough existential horror that he just shuts down. It’s too much for him to process alone, and the tragedy is that he’s processed it before. It’s just that every time he has, 2B kills him. He can’t process things with her, because if he does, he dies; likewise, she’s <em>also</em> had to process it all on her own. She seems mostly able to function, especially once we see what she’s like without having to keep 9S at arm’s length, becoming a much warmer and more open person when he’s gone. They were both doomed to be alone, but at least 2B knew the circumstances in which she was alone; 9S relived it over and over, and from other sidequests I don’t think it’s unfair to infer that a part of it stuck with him each time. That pain builds up.</p><p>In the final battle with A2, 9S may or may not know whether 2B’s death was a mercy kill. It’s never explicitly brought up, and it doesn’t really matter; killing is his last pleasure (again reinforced by a sidequest, where combat and erotic pleasure are linked in YoRHa units). ‘You killed 2B,’ he says. ‘That’s all we need to kill each other.’ And so he does, in his ending, “childhoo[D]’s end”. (The death of YoRHa and 2B means that this <em>is</em> the first time he gets to live past childhood.) He kills A2, but he also gets impaled and dies there with her. In his final moments, he discovers that the cannon is actually an ark, sending the memories of the machines, including Adam and Eve, to a new world. The player can choose whether 9S joins them, though from my perspective it doesn’t really matter much. What are those memories going to do? No one involved seems really capable of building something new.</p><h3>Pods 042 and Pod 153</h3><figure><img alt="Pod 042: “I must look very silly.”" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*UfDAQrtDWudjZZwJZQIyeg.png" /></figure><p>Yet the game’s final ending, achieved after seeing both A2’s and 9S’s endings, the pods posit that something new <em>is</em> possible. After all their adventures, the pods started to grow consciousnesses of their own, becoming attached to our trio of playable characters and actively making decisions in those characters’ best interests. The pods make a concerted effort to ensure that A2 and 9S avoid each other until the very end, and as A2 and 9S lay dying, the final members of YoRHa eliminated, the pods are ordered to remove all traces of YoRHa’s existence. They defy those orders, though, bringing the playable characters back to life.</p><p>The pods are the real MVPs through the whole game, and I loved that they got the final spotlight. Their burgeoning consciousness is the first time we can see it happening in real time, in this game or the first. That consciousness developed out of friendship and camaraderie, not anything else; their everyday tasks were to support their assigned YoRHa androids, and eventually they did so not because they were supposed to, but because it became a core part of their beings. They were always forced to make logical decisions, not always from simple situations; this was the endpoint of that. At the beginning is hope, a belief in what unites us.</p><p>The game’s final sequence involves shooting down the credits of the game, a long and arduous process for a game with so many people involved. It’s not too hard at the start, but gradually the credits start firing more and more projectiles at you until Square Enix themselves make it practically impossible to proceed. And so you die, and die, and keep going. The pod asks some tongue-in-cheek questions about whether it’s worth going on for a silly game, but you can see messages left by other players encouraging you to continue on. (Well, there are message options that are <em>dis</em>couraging, but I never saw any; I guess reinforcing that people do <em>want</em> to help.) Eventually you acquire the help of others who have completed the game, and every time you get hit, someone’s save file is sacrificed. I don’t know the full logistics of this — the ratio of saves to people who cleared the game without help has to be weighted in favour of the latter, whose saves are sacrificed before someone else uses them anyway — but the intention is clear. Basic shit, really. We’re all in it together. That’s it, full stop. Really is that simple.</p><p>As this all happens, we hear a new version of “Weight of the World”, which plays in different versions over each ending’s credits. I’ll go on record saying that the song is not very good, basic Disney credits nonsense that often felt disappointingly simple in the face of the game’s uneasy endings. But the message of this ending is <em>very intentionally</em> simple, reinforcing a simple truth that becomes easy to forget as you get mired in all the world’s shit. This version patches together all versions of the songs — J’Nique Nicole’s English version, Marina Kawano’s Japanese version, Emi Evans’ made-up-language version — and patches in a choir, full-on “We are the World” shit. “We are the World” sucks, this songs sucks, but I admit it fuckin’ got me. Lines like “even if our words seem meaningless”, “the truth is that I’m only one girl”, “we’re gonna shout it loud”, they hit different when you’re trudging through these long credits with the assistance of literal human beings from around the world. It’s the rare instance where some cheesy shit like this is actually backed up by what you’re doing.</p><p>Once you’re through, Pod 042 and Pod 153 spell it all out. Pod 153 says that life is all about the struggle between the cycle of life and death, that “being alive is pretty much a constant stream of embarrassment” (don’t I fuckin’ know it). As they restore 2B, 9S, and A2, Pod 153 asks whether this collection of the same androids with the same memories won’t simply lead them to the same conclusion. It’s a fair question; the entirety of both <em>NieR</em> games show the same cycle led over and over. But the possibility of a new world exists. So what do we think?</p><h4>2B</h4><figure><img alt="Pod 153: “A future is not given to you. It is something you must take for yourself.”" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0T4P_9az5qx5W35KcTglag.png" /></figure><p>I admit that I feel as hopeless as the next person on any given day. It often feels like we’re too far gone for any meaningful change to happen, where the ostensible good guys are just as dumb and useless as the ostensible bad guys, where the ostensibly smart people have enough of their own issues that it’s hard to be convinced that enough people are going to be able to get together. I know I certainly don’t ever feel like I’m doing nearly enough, but it’s also hard to imagine what ‘enough’ would even be. I don’t feel built for this world, and I look around and I don’t get the sense that <em>anyone</em> is built for this world.</p><p>Even after the moving final ending of <em>NieR: Automata</em>, I don’t really feel any different. That kind of unity is nice, very much appreciated, decidedly comforting. But it’s not real, it’s not meaningful. It’s an assertion that a lot of us want to help each other, but it doesn’t point us to how we can actually do that.</p><p>But it’s still nice to have with you. Because in the end, I have trouble imagining that the world of <em>Automata</em> wouldn’t be a better place. Fundamentally, every one of the core cast seem like fundamentally good people, all of whom have learned a lot, but have been trapped in a spiral of external circumstances and their own programming. Slowly, as the world crumbles, those circumstances start to fade away. The machine war may finally be over, YoRHa is gone. Many friends are gone, too, but some are still left. And that leaves a chance to start anew.</p><p>I get the sense that 2B wanted that more than anything. Despite her position, she seemed like the character that was most comfortable with herself, like she knew who she would be if everything went away, but just.. Couldn’t be. She was always going to be fighting machines, executing 9S, without any real hope of escape. Her posthumous messages say that she wants 9S to become a good person; that her memories with him were like ‘pure light’; that she wants A2 to take care of 9S. She had love in her heart.</p><p>Now’s her chance to build something better. And her example can light the way for 9S, for A2, for the remains of the resistance camp, maybe even for Pascal or Emil, if they’re still alive. Maybe, within the ruins of several apocalypses, there’s still hope. Not for us, not anyone we know, not for anyone we <em>will</em> know. But someone, eventually. For now, we keep with our silly little games, make the most of the small things, and try to picture something better.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=db20f977b18b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[NieR: Automata — Ending B]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@azdiff/nier-automata-ending-b-b257cb979e56?source=rss-8424cf63b043------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b257cb979e56</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[nier-automata]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Azdiff]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 03 Aug 2022 23:00:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-08-03T23:00:04.392Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>NieR: Automata — Ending B</h3><p><em>This contains spoilers up to ending B of </em>NieR: Automata<em>. My review of ending A is </em><a href="https://medium.com/@azdiff/nier-automata-ending-a-26d5905b6df2"><em>here</em></a><em>.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*KO4i9QG8NSlzJCOjDNRekA.jpeg" /></figure><p>How fresh the second playthrough of <em>NieR: Automata</em> feels entirely depends on what you were thinking about and paying attention to in the first playthrough. The big narrative additions here, much like the second playthrough of the first <em>NieR</em>, focus on gaining personal insights into your supposed enemies. The first playthrough already made it clear pretty early on that they weren’t really your enemy, or at the very least that there <em>could</em> be a world where they weren’t, so this isn’t really for thematic purposes; it’s more about understanding who they are, individually. We see how Simone’s quest for beauty was in an attempt to win Jean-Paul’s love (which seems a little unlike the real Simone de Beauvoir, but whatever); how Adam and Eve sought to emulate humans in every possible way, even though their bodies didn’t require it; how the machines in the Forest Kingdom could string together original thoughts long enough to break away from the network long enough to form their own society, but not long enough to understand that a baby machine won’t literally grow like an organic being.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hK_8lVuaAtGTPQy963KXpA.jpeg" /></figure><p>The key takeaway from those scenes, and from various info dumps scattered across this playthrough, locked away in chests that only 9S can access, is that machines (at least those not hyperfocused on combat) are trying to become like humans, but only with a limited understanding of it. 9S finds that they repeatedly attempt the same things over and over. If they try a dictatorship and it fails, they don’t try another form of government; they simply try another dictatorship. (The curious exception, it would seem, is Pascal, who very literally describes a system of communism in their village that works very well for them. In general he seems far more advanced than most machines, and is the only one other than Adam and Eve to boast a fully human voice. At first I thought that might just have been a quick way to set an important character apart, without any actual lore reasoning to back it up, but now I’m not so sure.) Why emulate humans? Well, my personal thoughts at this point is that, as they began to gain consciousness, they had to emulate <em>some</em> kind of society, and it sounds like this happened <em>after</em> they’d killed the aliens who brought them here. And instead, there was still enough evidence of humans lying around to give them something to build off of. Of course, this is several millennia after humans were wiped out, so they can only do so much, especially given their limited processing power.</p><p>This seems to have taken a toll on them. You come across many, many unhappy machines, especially in sidequests. Several machine sidequests you complete (and I completed almost every one that was available to be in this playthrough) end in the machine destroying themselves for one reason or another; some of them felt they had completed their life’s purpose, others felt that their life <em>had</em> no purpose, and it was easier to end it all. (To choose not to [b]e, as the ending title references.) They seem caught in some kind of horrific sweetspot, where they know enough to want to create meaning out of life, but aren’t able to actually do so; all they were designed for is killing, which is the direct opposite of that kind of meaning. The existential horror this brings leads them to end it all.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*PJWLdLMlOtSQcpbQrRirqg.jpeg" /></figure><p>As we learn in this playthrough, androids feared something similar would happen to them. The exact timeline here is still a little fuzzy given the first game’s plot, but it seems like Shades, the last remnants of humanity, finally died out after the events of the first game, and replicants must have discovered at some point that they were androids. (And reconciled with that fact, I guess.) As word got out that humans were extinct, androids still needed a reason to live, since their own identities had been closely tied to humans before that. (Originally, they were meant solely as vessels for human souls to return to, until they started developing their own souls.) So the lie that humans escaped to the human was created, giving androids a false god to fight for. Where the alien invasion comes into this, I’m not entirely sure; the machines they created seem almost too easy of an answer to the androids’ lack of purpose, but I have a hunch that the game doesn’t really elaborate further on that. (Sometimes I’d like a <em>little</em> more concrete worldbuilding in these games.) At any rate, a war that sounds justified can give people purpose, until its horrors become so strong that it becomes more profoundly meaningless than anything else could ever be.</p><p>Thematically, none of these really feel <em>new</em>; they’re just filling in some of the gaps from the first playthrough, especially if you already know the big twist about the extinction of humanity. For me, that on its own doesn’t really justify its own playthrough, but thankfully 9S makes it worthwhile. For one, his gameplay is almost completely different, and his little shmups hacking minigames are pretty fun. A little stale by the end of the game, yes — you start running into the same layouts pretty frequently — and ultimately I found myself missing the straight-up action combat that 9S is not very good at. But it’s a fun enough diversion to make every encounter feel a little different from the first playthrough. The litany of chests with info on the old world that only he could access made for some fun scavenger hunts, too.</p><p>Really, I just liked hanging out with 9S a bit more. They really drive it in that he’s a bit of a whiny brat (contrasted by both 2B and his operator 21O, who are both kinda sticks in the mud), but that also serves as him being someone who isn’t blindly happy to follow orders. He follows them, yes, but only because he’s bought into enough of the Kool-Aid that he feels like he <em>wants</em> to do this; he really does think machines all need to be destroyed. But through this adventure he sees more than anyone, sees the inner thoughts of all the machines and discovers that they’re far more complex than he realized. It takes him a long time to accept and understand the things he sees and hears, but eventually he finally digs in and learns the truth.</p><p>But really, what does the truth change? He immediately goes back to fighting, because 2B is in trouble; whether the war is real or not, it’s still <em>happening</em>, and at this point nothing is going to change without more war. But unlike Adam and Eve, whose bare grasp of humanity leads them to believe conflict as existence is enough on its own, the androids always thought that they had a reason for their conflict. (Though even that reason essentially treated their own lives as lesser.) 9S knows that reason is a lie, but it’s clear at the very least that 2B is an immediate reason for him to keep fighting; and soon, they can hopefully find a greater reason to be.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b257cb979e56" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Game Music Diary Jun-Jul 2022]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@azdiff/game-music-diary-jun-jul-2022-d3107b98324e?source=rss-8424cf63b043------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d3107b98324e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[doom]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[video-game-music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[persona-5-strikers]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[citizen-sleeper]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[resident-evil-4]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Azdiff]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 01 Aug 2022 16:54:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-08-01T16:54:44.159Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>To recap, I’m writing about one piece of music from every game that I play this year. (Although it often turns into a discussion of the entire game’s soundtrack, like my <em>Persona 5 Strikers</em> writeup this go around.) You can see my previous entries about game music <a href="https://medium.com/@azdiff/game-music-diary-may-2022-57c08ea2e6d3">here</a> and <a href="https://medium.com/@azdiff/game-music-diary-jan-apr-2022-c482ed73832a">here</a>.</p><p>This round’s lineup is, arranged in the order that I finished them:</p><ol><li><em>Resident Evil 4</em></li><li><em>Citizen Sleeper</em></li><li><em>Persona 5 Strikers</em></li><li><em>Doom</em></li><li><em>Stray</em></li></ol><p>Not a huge list, but once again I went long on a couple of them! I’ll save <em>NieR: Automata</em> for the next entry, although I did write about it a fair amount already in my review of the game’s <a href="https://medium.com/@azdiff/nier-automata-ending-a-26d5905b6df2">first ending</a>.</p><h3>Misao Senbongi and Shusaku Uchiyama — “Serenity”</h3><h4>Resident Evil 4 (2005)</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Hb-_Doks2gMUX0vnw5AEjw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Jacob Geller described “Serenity” — tied with the <em>RE7</em>’s “Saferoom” for the best <em>Resident Evil</em> save theme — pretty well in the first five minutes of his video on <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6aFfN4HtjEc">beautiful sound in horror games</a>. But I think he could’ve gone deeper into how <em>ethereal</em> it sounds, because in <em>Resident Evil</em> these safe rooms feel far more unnatural than the horrors that lurk outside. When every room is crawling with people too far gone to call human, all of them eager to see your demise, a room that’s quiet and <em>normal</em> feels anything but. Its unearthly music takes you away, like you’ve briefly entered another dimension entirely. “Serenity” commits to sounding alien, not taking the easy way out like many of the series’ other save themes, which tend to cycle in a familiar piano or commit to a dull ambience that doesn’t amount to much of anything. No, “Serenity” pulsates and groans, becoming <em>alive</em>. It gives you something to latch onto, something to connect with in a world where your only true goal is to survive. It means that the room is not defined by the absence of enemies; it’s alive, like a friend, which is so much more powerful.</p><p>Capcom is inconsistent about specifying who composed which piece for the <em>Resident Evil</em> series, so it’s hard to say which of the two credited composers are actually responsible for “Serenity”. But it seems like that it’s Misao Senbongi, who’s credited as the lead sound designer in the credits and presumably would be in charge of one of the few truly important pieces of music in the game. It’d make sense, too. Shusaku Uchiyama is the longstanding musical director of the series since <em>Resident Evil 2</em>, while Senbongi is one of many revolving composers for the franchise (who, like many composers of the era, seems to have completely disappeared after this game). So it stands to reason that this brilliant, alien piece of music, that sounds nothing like anything else from the series, would come from a relative outsider. Granted, this music doesn’t sound like anything Senbongi did, either; the only compositions I can find that were definitively credited to her were a few unimpressive instrumental pieces for the first <em>Devil May Cry</em>. I suppose that in a sense, the mystery only adds to the music’s appeal; not that it needs the help.</p><h3>Amos Roddy — “Possible Futures”</h3><h4>Citizen Sleeper (2022)</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*9cTSwvDd9ev45yLbMI56Ng.jpeg" /></figure><p>The titular <em>Citizen Sleeper</em>, your character, is essentially a machine that had the consciousness of a human copied into it. Not recognized as a citizen and legally owned by a corporation, your sleeper’s very existence as an independent being is met with hostility. Its body is also built with planned obsolescence, requiring rare and expensive medicine to fight against its inherent decay. Surviving as a sleeper from one day to the next is a constant struggle. True respite is rare and fleeting; each day bleeds into the next one as part of the same, continuing, <em>painful</em> existence. Life on the space station Erlin’s Eye is lonely and often hostile, as everyone has to fend for themselves in order to keep their head above water.</p><p>Yet as you play through the game, your character eventually finds themselves more settled on Erlin’s Eye. You find your regular spots for food and medicine, you manage to sever ties to the people who are hostile to you. And so your goals slowly shift from merely surviving to finding your way on the space station. To get yourself settled, you need to have made connections with other people, people who help you as you help them in turn. It’s up to you to decide what those connections mean to you, then. The game essentially has three possible endings, with branches on each of them that ask you to decide: is life on Erlin’s Eye what you want? Are the friendships you’ve formed, the community you’ve discovered, enough to make all of the hardship and pain worth it? Or is it better to start anew, without the promise that anything will actually be better, but maybe with a small group of friends who can stay with you? Each new opportunity means an endless list of missed ones; everyone who you leave behind, or who leaves <em>you</em> behind, will never be seen again, gone to the vastness of space. You can never truly escape the loneliness, because those missed connections will always stay missed; but sometimes, we can still be lonely together.</p><p>I couldn’t tell you what music plays where in <em>Citizen Sleeper</em>, because the game’s events flow together so easily. There isn’t a track for tense moments, a track for triumph, a track for sadness, because all of those things are happening all the time simultaneously. One day on Erlin’s Eye can have you accosted by strangers, meeting a friend, toiling away on your own just to make some money, all of these different things, because life moves independently of you. And while I can guess where tracks like “Yatagan” and “Photosynthetic Skin” play based on their titles, the truth is that they could fit just about anywhere at any time. Peace, sadness, warmth, isolation, unease, all play in equal manner. That’s a difficult balance to land, and every time I revisit Amos Roddy’s soundtrack I’m amazed by how familiar it all sounds, by how much it sums up the feeling of the game.</p><p>This sense of everything leaves it to you to pull out your own feelings from this music. When I finished the game it was the sadness that stuck with me more, despite all of the game’s endings being overtly hopeful. Even as your sleeper launches off to new beginnings, or decides that the life they’ve made on Erlin’s Eye is worth hanging onto, there’s still this <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capitalist_Realism">Fisherian sense</a> that nothing could ever be meaningfully better than it is right now. But as I write this, relistening to the soundtrack a few weeks removed from finishing the game, the sleeper’s sense of peace in those endings is what I really hear in the music; how after seeing all the hardships the world can throw at your character, they feel content in whatever bonds they’ve formed, knowing that it’s all they really get, and that it’s all they really need.</p><p>The final song on the soundtrack, “Possible Futures”, probably plays during one of the endings; I don’t know, I don’t really care to check. All I know is that every time I hear it, I <em>think</em> about my sleeper leaving Erlin’s Eye on a ship to unknown land, their companions being people who they don’t really know but have nevertheless come to trust. I also think of the family who my sleeper helped off of the station, who my sleeper was supposed to accompany, but I wasn’t ready to leave the station; I think of how confused the little girl in that family would have felt. The saccharine melody of “Possible Futures” bleeds emotion, its sweetness echoing out into the lonely silence of space. If I ever need to remind myself of what this game means, this is where to go.</p><h3>Gota Mosuoko — “Mori no Miyako”</h3><h4>Persona 5 Strikers (2020)</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*nn9h8lIaSfAyUZO8qw8fNw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Koei Tecmo has been doing a pretty good job working with other studios to integrate their core Musou format with high-profile game worlds like <em>Breath of the Wild</em> and <em>Three Houses</em>. Not with the gameplay, so much, which is pretty adaptable to whatever other genres you throw at it. What I mean is how they manage to create games that fit in well with their original series’ stories and aesthetics.</p><p><em>Persona 5 Strikers</em>, in particular, essentially feels like a full-on <em>sequel</em>, not a spin-off. There’s obviously not quite as much attention given to it — it’s even more formulaic than the first go around, and without the social links the characters often feel like the most generic versions of themselves — but the general spirit and art direction are pretty much on point. Of course, Atlus was a collaborator on the project, but the central creative teams for the original game had little to do with this, as far as I can tell; you’re essentially getting the Atlus B-team here, which makes it surprising how fleshed out this is. If they were to ever make a proper <em>Persona 5</em> sequel (which, given how they continue to milk the game’s success, wouldn’t surprise me at all), I’d fully expect them to acknowledge this story and count it as canon, which is <em>not</em> something you can say for the convoluted plots of <em>Age of Calamity</em> or <em>Three Hopes</em>.</p><p>This B-team status extends to the composers, as well. Atlus sent over one guy, Atsushi Kitajoh, who mostly composed minigame-type themes across the rest of the <em>Persona</em> series. Here, he’s in charge of almost all of the vocal themes, essentially the centerpieces in <em>Persona 5</em> — so that’s a pretty big step up! But if I’m being honest, it’s not his music that feels like the real connective tissue between games. I’m not really a fan of the new vocal themes for this game, which aren’t as tuneful and generally feel too cluttered. It makes sense that they would be, of course, because they’re scoring battles that are much more frantic than the turn-based battles of the original game; there’s no pauses here that let you really soak in the music, only constant chaos. (You have the option to turn on “Take Over” or the original version of “Last Surprise” as the battle music, and it just doesn’t feel right in this context.) Kitajoh’s most worthwhile compositions, in my eyes, are the main camping theme that gets repurposed throughout the game (the clavier-funk of “Sophia’s Shop” being my favourite arrangement of it) and “You Are Stronger”, the vocal theme that plays during the game’s anime intro. Otherwise, I felt a little disappointed by what they brought to the table, given that they have worked on the same projects as Shoji Meguro for years.</p><p>Instead, it was Koei Tecmo’s sound team that surprised me. As near as I can tell, Koei Tecmo has a pretty large sound team, but typically the music isn’t a huge focus of their games; certainly not to the extent of a <em>Persona 5</em> spinoff. The defining characteristic of <em>Dynasty Warriors</em> soundtracks is straight, dumb heavy guitar, which I figured would be the likely direction for how the battle music of this game would sound. (They did manage to restrain themselves for <em>Age of Calamity</em>, where it really wouldn’t fit. They couldn’t help themselves in <em>Three Hopes</em>, though, where it sounds really silly.) And well, there were no surprises there. Koei Tecmo’s MASA and Gota Masuoka provide new arrangements of the old battle themes that mostly amount to adding distorted guitars wherever possible. The funny thing is that most them <em>were</em> rock songs already, “Last Surprise” excepted, but for <em>Strikers</em> they’re stripped down to their base instincts and rendered as simply as metal could make them. Normally I hate ‘electric guitar’ versions of video game (or any kind of) music, but I have to admit these are solid fun. The songs are more kinetic in this form, which makes sense for an action game that doesn’t have the same kinds of pauses that the original game’s turn-based combat provided. The guitars’ steady chug in “Last Surprise”, or their lumber in the opening of “Blooming Villain”, work really well when you’re fighting off dozens of enemies at once. Plus, the whole band sounds like they’re having a lot of fun; on “Last Surprise” in particular, Lyn seems <em>super</em> into it, which feels nice to hear given how easily I could imagine she might get tired of this stuff.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*lcZ_lJylexZvSvvUT1qlRQ.png" /></figure><p>The battle themes are good, fun, but they mostly certainly do <em>not</em> fit with the music of the original game. Which makes sense; the gameplay they match is significantly different. But outside of battle, the ‘social sim’ aspects of the game, those are pretty much the same. Pared down, sure, but the ideas are pretty similar; and so if you want the game to feel like an extension of <em>Persona 5</em>, you have to capture the same vibe. And that’s where Koei Tecmo’s sound team surprised me, because they <em>did</em> capture that vibe despite having little to no experience otherwise. There’s no mistaking them for Shoji Meguro’s work, of course, but the general vibes are so similar that I was certain they were done by the one Atlus guy they had on staff. But they were mostly done by Gota Masuoka, with a few contributions from Hiromu Akaba and Ayana Hira. (Hira’s contributions aren’t great — actually, most of their dungeon music actively kinda sucks — but Akaba’s “Crossroads” and “Freedom Buzz Dance” are both great town themes.) I mean, damn, listen to “Mori no Miyako”: jazz fusion guitar, Rhodes piano, stabs of strings right out of a disco song. I guess it isn’t all that hard to break the sounds down to their components and repurpose them, but I didn’t think it would still sound this good.</p><p>Maybe it is that simple, I dunno; the parts that <em>don’t</em> really match the <em>Persona 5</em> aesthetic definitely don’t sound as good. When the strings open up it sounds a little cheap, a little more generic than what Meguro would’ve come up with; the triangle that accompanies those sections lays the sweetness on a little too thick, too. Even the jazz fusion guitar, despite fitting in with the aesthetic, seems more like a transition from the metal arrangements that Masuoka ultimately feels more at home with. (“Welcome to the Jail”, “Daredevil”, the new “Keeper of Lust” arrangement; those are where Masuoka’s strengths are, even if I personally like “Mori no Miyako” more.) So maybe it is as simple as just copying the parts that work. But at the same time, my favourite moment in that track is when it <em>loops</em>, when, after 90 seconds of pure summer vacation vibes, the strings <em>hold</em> for a delightful pause, letting you linger in the pleasure of enjoying the city… Before the drums lead you right back into the bustle, actually <em>doing</em> stuff and seeing the sights. That moment is distinctly <em>nothing</em> like Meguro, and so I’ve gotta give credit where it’s due.</p><h3>Bobby Prince — “At Doom’s Gate”</h3><h4><strong>Doom (1993)</strong></h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gP_1zzBCzTYJkhMuGgfGDg.jpeg" /></figure><p>If <em>Doom</em> E1M1 is the <em>Super Mario Bros.</em> 1–1 of first person shooters — a genre-defining tutorial level that set the tone for how to play, what to expect, what the future looks like — then it stands to reason that Bobby Prince’s music plays as important a role as Koji Kondo’s. We all know how the rhythm of Kondo’s overworld theme was meant to match the pace of 1–1 itself, lining up with expected jumps and actions the player would take.</p><p>Now, one might argue that Bobby Prince dare not be even mentioned in the same breadth as Kondo’s deliberately, carefully paced music. You could argue that Prince barely even deserves to be called composer here, as its riff is shamelessly lifted from Metallica’s “No Remorse”, much as other parts of the <em>Doom</em> soundtrack are shamelessly lifted from Pantera and Slayer. It’s a much more blatant ripoff than Kondo supposedly taking the 1–1 theme from Japanese fusion band T-Square’s “Sister Marian”, which is only really a partial match. Kondo used “Sister Marian” as a starting point to create something new entirely; Prince just put his favourite metal songs in <em>Doom</em>.</p><p>But is <em>Doom</em>, as a whole game, not using “No Remorse” as a starting point to create something new? John Romero specifically requested that Prince make metal music (instead of the ambient music that Prince wanted to make, which works for some levels but generally isn’t nearly as fun as metal), meaning that the idea was coming right from the point of the game’s conception. For <em>Super Mario Bros.</em>, the gameplay fed into the music and back into the gameplay; for <em>Doom</em>, the music and the gameplay were all coming from the same place. The pacing of <em>Doom</em> reflects the pacing of metal, particularly slower brands of thrash metal, perfectly: very fast, but requiring enough careful movement and spatial awareness, as well as careful littering of items and hidden secrets, to keep the speed structured. (Indeed, “At Doom’s Gate” is noticeably slower than “No Remorse”.) I don’t know how you could look at the visuals on display in the game, blasting Imps and Cacodemons that could easily be hanging out with Eddie on an Iron Maiden album cover, and <em>not</em> imagine Metallica playing. Hell, soon enough <em>Doom</em> became a scapegoat for real world violence the way that Judas Priest and Ozzy Osbourne had been before. <em>Doom</em> does not simply <em>include</em> heavy metal in its soundtrack; <em>Doom</em>, as a whole, allows you to <em>become</em> heavy metal. And so it deserves the best sounds it can get, and if that meant ripping off Metallica before they became litigious freaks, then it was gonna get what it damn well deserved.</p><h3>Yann van der Cruyssen — “The Notebooks”</h3><h4>Stray (2022)</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*vfRDlffDpAO7kdP6z2WZFA.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>Stray </em>lives and dies by the pure concept of ‘you are a cat.’ Obviously, this is a strong hook. For a couple of hours, I’d say the game <em>delivers</em> on that hook; you do indeed feel very catlike, and ultimately I think that’s all a lot of people (including myself, more or less) wanted. (A lot of cats, too, but unfortunately not mine. She didn’t care at all.) But once that novelty wears off, there’s not much beyond that. Enough people have gone on about how the actual gameplay is kinda boring that I won’t bother relitigating it, but I’d also say that I really don’t like the cyberpunk setting very much. Being a cat in a world completely devoid of any biological life didn’t feel quite right to me, and any story or lore felt secondary to the idea of being a cat. Essentially, the game never really felt like it rose above being a tech demo.</p><p>That said: the music ain’t bad, and whereas I think the music can let down the world in a lot of games, here I think it’s the opposite. There’s a few neat ideas tucked away across this score — the plucky and playful keyboards contrasting the mysterious backing chords in “The Notebooks”, the hurried drums in “Dead End”, the little tweedly melody in “Trash Zone” — and there’s nuance in the percussion and keyboards especially that adds tension and character to settings that otherwise might feel a bit flat. But as it stands, I also know that I wouldn’t give this album the time of day if it were released without any context, just another solid electronic/ambient album with some solid ideas that don’t really go anywhere. Sounds just don’t have a chance to flesh out, and I wonder if that’s because there isn’t much in the game’s setting that the music can bounce off of, while also still requiring the music to support the setting, instead of just doing its own thing. (A quick peek at some of van der Cruyssen’s work as Morusque, a lot of which is not for soundtracks, strikes me as a little more interesting.) If there were places or characters that felt meaningfully distinct, created with a specific thematic meaning in mind, then I feel like this music could go a little further; as it stands, the music <em>is</em> the thing with more character, and it feels like it’s propping those settings up.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d3107b98324e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[NieR: Automata — Ending A]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@azdiff/nier-automata-ending-a-26d5905b6df2?source=rss-8424cf63b043------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/26d5905b6df2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[nier]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[video-game-review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nier-automata]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[video-game-music]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Azdiff]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 23 Jul 2022 18:06:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-07-23T18:06:52.146Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><em>NieR: Automata — </em>Ending A</h3><p><em>This concerns the first playthrough and ending of </em>NieR: Automata<em>. I haven’t played anything beyond that ending, and I’ll be writing something after getting to each ending.</em></p><p><em>Spoilers for ending A of </em>Automata<em>, of course. Also some light spoilers for the original </em>NieR<em>, though if you’ve played </em>Automata<em> I’m pretty sure you know those parts already.</em></p><figure><img alt="2B, without her symbolic blindfold, shouts, “9S!”" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*w_V3aePx70FEe3a-gw4jCQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>The biggest surprise for me in this first playthrough of <em>NieR: Automata</em> was how complete it felt. You can get to this first ending, ignore Square Enix’s plea to continue through multiple playthroughs, and leave feeling like you’ve played a pretty good game. Not a <em>great</em> game, but at least one that felt like it gave you a whole experience. Obviously there are plenty of loose ends, but even the mysteries surrounding A2 or Adam and Eve could be excused as general anime bullshit if you wanted to take them that way, because at the very least this playthrough is thematically coherent.</p><p>That’s the big thing: the first playthrough of the original <em>NieR</em> felt, by contrast, very incomplete because it didn’t fully reveal its themes and ideas until the second playthrough. (While the third and fourth endings felt mostly unnecessary.) It similarly had a lot of unexplained nonsense — most of which <em>never</em> gets resolved in any playthrough — but I found those things far more difficult to write off, because they were missing pieces of a thematic puzzle. But <em>Automata</em>, whew, well, they sidestep that issue by throwing any idea of ‘subtext’ out the window. Yoko Taro’s out here fully naming characters after his favourite philosophers (Jean-Paul [Sartre], [Blaise] Pascal, [Friedrich] Engels) and making his characters say blatant shit like ‘you‘ll lose you, the you that exists at this very moment’ when a character’s about to lose their memories. Whereas the first <em>NieR</em> seemed to start with its setting — or, I suppose, <em>Drakengard</em>’s final setting — and build its themes from there, <em>Automata</em> starts with the existentialism the first game was developing, and creates every piece of its game around that.</p><figure><img alt="2B says, “But you’ll lose you. The you that exists at this very moment.”" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ewMySDMOTIs-NZl6uVo0ow.jpeg" /></figure><p>What I also appreciate is how it fast-forwards to get to the point. The first <em>NieR</em>’s themes didn’t really coalesce until the second playthrough because Nier, the protagonist, is too much of a stubborn asshole to ask even the most obvious questions at any point through the story, insisting on killing every stray Shade in his path in a quest to save his sister. It’s only at the very end, when he’s already killed everyone and it’s too late to do much with this knowledge, that he learns that all the Shades he’s been killing are actually the residual souls of humans, removed in some grave science experiment before disease wiped out humans’ physical forms, leaving only androids like Nier. It’s in the second playthrough that you get to actually see this in action, as you get extra scenes of the Shades conversing with each other, terrified by the impending slaughter from Nier and his crew.</p><p><em>Automata</em> has similar plot beats, but it speeds things up and essentially conflates <em>NieR</em>’s first two playthroughs. Robots are fleeing for their lives and displaying autonomy only a few hours into the game, in the desert; not longer after that you find the brilliant celebration of the machines in the amusement park, and after that, you find an entire village full of machines. If 9S the android screaming to kill everything in sight didn’t set you on edge before that, well, now you <em>know</em> that the machines are every bit as sentient as you and your androids. And so even though <em>Automata</em> actually holds back on revealing <em>NieR</em>’s twist — an interesting move that capitalizes on a large audience who hadn’t played the preceding game — it doesn’t take long to get people up to speed. There’s enough red flags right from the beginning, right down to the central premise of ‘androids killing machines’ essentially being ‘robots killing robots,’ that players become distrustful of all events going on. No need to know that humans died out roughly 9000 years before the setting of <em>Automata</em>; so long as you know enough to start questioning things, that opens up the door for players to be directed to the <em>right</em> questions. Not just about why things seem off, but why we <em>notice</em> that things are off.</p><figure><img alt="2B and 9S admire some fireworks at the amusement park." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*naYoZesTI3htUZ32tOCLUA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Is 2B’s supposed emotionlessness (which is entirely proven false as she bemoans 9S’s impending death at both the beginning and the end of the playthrough, literally weeping android tears at the end) actually a consequence of her programming, or is she just kinda like that, much like some humans are? Is it the memories or the bodies of 2B and 9S that define who they are? What does it mean for a robot to be ‘born’ if they have their consciousnesses programmed, and how does the concept of a robot ‘family’ work in that context? Why does a younger robot have the behaviours of a child, when you could just program in a new ‘adult’ personality? If the forest king supposedly ‘gained’ awareness, is there a point where we can truly consider someone ‘alive’? Why do the robots have a concept of gender? Why are the female robots horny for Jean-Paul when there’s no biological reason for them to experience that kind of attraction? Does human anatomy like an android’s, or Adam and Eve’s, make someone more ‘real’? Is that why 6O had a girlfriend, and why 2B has a blatant shipping sidequest to gather flowers for her? Does the thematically relevant body retrieval mechanic mean that <em>Dark Souls</em> is similarly existential? If the Emil we find regains his memories, is he fundamentally the same as the original Emil?</p><p>These are all good questions, but at the same time, they’re easy questions, arguably <em>leading</em> questions. The game unambiguously points you in the direction of seeing all its characters as fully human, with their own social orders and habits no different from our own, for better <em>and</em> for worse; just with the added complexities given the nature of their birth, or creation. I see a lot of people who act dismissively about <em>Automata</em> say that the game is like science fiction for babies, and I mean, yeah, existential questions about artificial intelligence are hardly new ground. The game doesn’t render those questions in a profound enough way to really transcend that, not yet. And for this first playthrough, those questions are practically all the game really is. 2B and 9S hardly feel developed beyond a few basic characteristics; 2B is quiet and focused on the mission while 9S is more emotional and idealistic, even if they’re not always for the <em>right</em> ideals. Beyond that it feels hard to say much more about them. It feels as though 2B is designed to be a quiet, blank slate to let the player experience things how they want to experience them, to choose when to attack and when to simply observe. (Though this is slightly undercut in the first Adam battle in the desert, where you’re forced to make the first strike even if you’d rather ask a few questions first.) Everything about the central characters is in service to <em>Automata</em>’s existentialism, which is also plastered blatantly everywhere else in the game. For the first playthrough, it’s all the game gives you, and if you’ve seen these themes before, it might not seem like much. And because said playthrough feels fairly contained, I can easily see why someone would think that the game wasn’t going to offer much beyond that. Even I’m not completely convinced, given how I felt a little burned by the first game’s subsequent endings (at least until <em>Replicant ver.1.22</em>’s very good fifth ending).</p><figure><img alt="9S asks, “Kind of deep, really. I mean, where does the wind blow from? What do you think, 2B?”" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5GEQe7R9ujlN44UduIGXtg.jpeg" /></figure><p>The big question that I didn’t ask up top there is: why should anyone care about any of these themes? That’s the big challenge that faces art that’s asking questions like these, of making ideas that might seem obvious come to life in new and unexpected ways, which can then illuminate those ideas in ways that <em>aren’t</em> obvious. That’s why art needs to be engaging on a level beyond rote didacticism; for a video game, that’s often where characters or mechanics allow for direct engagement with the material. There’s elements of that in the mechanics — the <em>Dark Souls</em> chip retrieval mechanic, the fast travel being software uploads between different bodies —but by and large this story seems to be staking its themes on its characters, and by its first ending, <em>Automata</em> isn’t quite there yet.</p><p>Actually, the material I found the most engaging in the first paythrough is in the sidequests. They’re not great sidequests, and even Platinum’s Takahisa Taura admitted they felt a little inferior next to those from <em>The Witcher 3</em>. Moral choices don’t often make a big difference — the rewards are the same, and often the character is gonna do what they’re gonna do regardless of what you say — and a lot of them are generic fetch quests. But they provide more of a chance to meaningfully interact with the game’s world than anywhere else.</p><p>The quest I found most interesting was “Retrieve the Confidential Intel”, where you recover some YoRHa combat chips for an android. As you find them, a bulletin comes from HQ insinuating that not everything is above board with this guy, but you can hand over the chips anyway. Later, you find him in the desert with a YoRHa unit that he secretly repaired from the brink of death. He says he always wanted to start a family, which for a robot could be treated as a tender ending to show the consciousness they had developed. But instead, an unsettling, dissonant piece of music called “The Color of Depression” plays, shuttering the air with a glitchy feedback. As this android and his YoRHa plead for you not to tell, it made me realize that he was essentially treating this YoRHa as a pet, converging consciousness and property in unsettling ways. With programmed consciousness, hierarchy can be routinely and easily controlled in arbitrary ways, and you could argue that what this android was doing is a gross abuse of power. That same piece of music also shows up at the end of a quest to find treasure in the Forest Kingdom, where you actually find the remains of the Forest King. When you return to the machine who tipped you off to this ‘treasure’, they respond with an eerie glee as that music plays.</p><p>As much as I like those quests, I hope they’re not the totality of what to expect from this game, thematically. I’m not expecting much from the second playthrough as 9S, which I gather will largely play out the same with some relatively predictable differences at the beginning and end. (Though since he’s less of a blank slate than 2B, and he’s nominally a secondary support character, I imagine things will <em>feel</em> different through out.) But I imagine things will get much more interesting in the third playthrough, as we continue the story with more context and a focus on A1, who we know very little about in the first playthrough.</p><p>For now, though, I’m still as entranced as anyone with the atmosphere the game lays out for you. This is a game where I don’t mind doing sidequests that run you around the same places over and over again, partially because they provide more worldbuilding than the main story does, but also because you get to spend more time soaking in the visuals and the goddamned <em>music</em>. Every time I wander into the amusement park and see all the machines dancing with their confetti and fireworks, I’m as awestruck as I was the first time. Keigo Hoashi’s dramatic melody in the area’s music lends a sense of fear to the awe, and as always, Emi Evans’ vocals stabilize it with grace and beauty. But it’s the percussion that makes it so great; I’m not always a fan when orchestral soundtracks lean too hard on the drums, but here it adds weight and pomp to match the fireworks and the dancing, like you’re actively particpating in the celebration, even if you don’t understand it. The celebration never stops, even when you leave, even when the world is under threat; and when you return, the music fades in, directly to the percussion, bringing you right back into the fold. I keep expecting the beauty to wear off, but it never does.</p><p>“City Ruins (Rays of Light)” is, of course, the classic. The city ruins are the only space in the game where you can feel a palpable sense of what once was; most other areas are overcome by nature or taken over by the machines, but this still distinctly resembles a city. It stands to reason that the music is more somber than the rest, J’Nique Nicole’s comparatively deeper vocals and Keiichi Okabe’s circular piano melody leaning into the moody reflections of what once was. (Emi Evans’ vocals on the “Shade” version are incredible, too, but I like how Nicole’s vocals are a little less reserved; it makes the peaks, like at 2:22 on the official soundtrack, feel more encompassing of the city’s expanse.) As the game’s central hub and largest area, it’s also the music that reflects the tone of the playthrough as a whole, and no matter where things are, it just feels <em>right</em>.</p><figure><img alt="2B takes in the city ruins." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ja4pWygopI2llpynF5ERkg.jpeg" /></figure><p>And of course, there’s lots of other great ideas in the music throughout: the soothing bagpipe in “Peaceful Sleep”, the blippy synths in “End of the Unknown” (Keiichi Okabe returning to his <em>Tekken</em> roots there), the robotic child’s choir in “Pascal”. Callbacks to the first game in the epic “Grandma (Destruction)” and “Dark Colossus (Kaiju)”, both of which take on even more grandiose proportions than their originals. Even Emil’s theme, the most achingly sad piece of music in <em>NieR</em>, gets reworked into a goofy fanfare as he drives around his golf cart. MONACA, the team behind the music (mostly Keiichi Okabe and Keigo Hoashi), bring so much more variety to this game compared to the first, and there’s still plenty more that doesn’t show up on this first playthrough.</p><p>It’s great that the music and aesthetics are so continually rewarding to revisit, because there’s still got four more endings to grab. (And the gameplay doesn’t really reward you in the same way; the combat is a little boring by Platinum standards. Flashy, but without much depth. Dodge roll’s got invincibility frames for <em>days</em>.) The first game circumvented this by only making you replay half of the game, but here we’ve gotta go through the whole damned thing again, and the abundance of locked chests that I gather only 9S can open means I’ll want to explore all the same nooks and crannies. Only the beginning and the end are going to be substantially different, meaning you have to like the middle enough to enjoy going through the same beats again. And I can soak this in for quite some time.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=26d5905b6df2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Game Music Diary — May 2022]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@azdiff/game-music-diary-may-2022-57c08ea2e6d3?source=rss-8424cf63b043------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/57c08ea2e6d3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[video-game-music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[donkey-kong-country]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[final-fantasy-xiv]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[alan-wake]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[kirby]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Azdiff]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 04 Jun 2022 15:41:18 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-08-12T01:08:08.298Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Game Music Diary — May 2022</h3><p>Hey. To recap, I’m writing about one piece of music from every game that I play this year. I wasn’t planning to publish another one so soon, but I finished six different games in May and wound up writing a lot about most of them, so I figured I’d dump ’em now before the page got too unwieldy. The list this time is:</p><ol><li><em>Donkey Kong Country</em></li><li><em>Kirby and the Forgotten Land</em></li><li><em>Final Fantasy XIV: Stormblood</em></li><li><em>Super Mario World 2: Yoshi’s Island</em></li><li><em>Alan Wake</em></li><li><em>Control</em></li></ol><p>If you missed my last one, with picks from <em>Katamari Damacy</em>, <em>Persona 5 Royal</em>, <em>Elden Ring</em>, and more, you can check it out <a href="https://medium.com/@azdiff/game-music-diary-jan-apr-2022-c482ed73832a">here</a>.</p><h3>David Wise — “Aquatic Ambiance”</h3><h3>Donkey Kong Country (1995)</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*aewKegw0yLAsiY3zjIG5cw.jpeg" /></figure><p>What sets <em>Donkey Kong Country</em> apart as a great game is the atmosphere. People joke about how beautiful tracks like “Stickerbrush Symphony” are in a game starring a cartoon ape, but the game rarely leans into Donkey Kong’s cartoonish aspect. The environments you explore are dark and ominous in comparison to the popping colours of <em>Super Mario World</em> or <em>Sonic the Hedgehog</em>. There aren’t a lot of sound effects, and what is there is muted. Even the character models, blurring the lines between 2D and 3D using technology that still left them a little stiff and uncanny, aren’t super expressive. (The game looks good though!) What results feels more like a sombre journey through the unwelcoming environment of DK Island, with the occasional cheery detour to have Cranky Kong yell at you. So while the ominous soundtrack might be at odds with a broader perception of the series or the character, it really fits perfectly with the game itself.</p><p>Crucially, the influences here are ones that actually sound good on an SNES; music from that era had an upper limit on what it could accomplish if it tried to mimic real instruments, but the stuff that leaned into the electronic nature of the music has aged far better and still sounds good today. David Wise said he was listening to a lot of synth composers while working on this game — guys like Vangelis and Jean-Michel Jarre, influences I was thrilled to hear — and it’s those sounds that actually make these songs still worth listening to. “DK Island Swing” has been reimagined countless times (there’s <em>seven</em> different arrangements of it in <em>Smash Ultimate</em> alone), and given how the main melody that’s obviously meant to be played on a brass instrument, it would seem like a rearrangement would render it obsolete. But the ambient section that it suddenly drops into is never the same without that exact synth sound. Likewise, the sound of the high notes that fade in and out on “Gangplank Galleon” make up for the stilted gallups that don’t quite match their Iron Maiden influence.</p><p>And “Aquatic Ambiance”, well, if it isn’t exactly what I’m talking about. It just doesn’t sound the same without that electronic context, one that Wise apparently worked on for five weeks just to see if he could actually get the sounds that he wanted from the SNES. He later revisited it with a few arrangements, all with more realistic sounds, for <em>Tropical Freeze</em>, and some people understandably call those versions better. But those squelchy bass sounds, the compressed fade of the high synth; those never sounded the same again. His modern versions play the main melody on a saxophone, and to me it sounds unbelievably corny, some Kenny G shit that cheapens the layered majesty of the music at hand. Wise has certainly done good work outside of the 16-bit era, including a lot of his stuff on <em>Tropical Freeze</em>. But the stuff he composed for the SNES sounds the best just as it always was.</p><h3>Yuuga Ogasawara — “Running Through the New World”</h3><h3>Kirby and the Forgotten Land (2022)</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*g2zc1t8DClr76AdaZopCzQ.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>Forgotten Land</em> has four main composers: two veterans who defined the <em>Kirby</em> sound (Jun Ishikawa and Hirokazu Ando) and two relatively new people who have only worked on <em>Kirby</em> for a few years (Yuuga Ogasawara and Yuki Shimooka). <em>Kirby</em> games have seen a lot of different composers pass through, but it was almost always Ishikawa and Ando composing the main games while others handled the spinoffs. Ogasawara’s heavy presence in this game after dipping his toes in on <em>Star Allies</em> (the last main game in the series) suggests to me, though, that there’s a change of the guard happening. That’s not too surprising; Ishikawa and Ando have been doing this for a long time, and when you’re in your 50s doing your 20th rendition of Dedede’s theme, I have to imagine you start thinking about retirement.</p><p>This is something a lot of franchises that started back in the ’80s have started to encounter more and more lately, and it’s interesting to see these franchises with very defined sounds try to evolve in this way. How can the old styles transition into modern composing techniques and technologies? How can the new blood carry on the legacy of the old games without sounding like a pale imitation, or while blending it with their own styles? It’s not an easy thing, and some franchises have pulled it off better than others. <em>Kirby</em>, I would argue, is not killing it out here.</p><p>Jun Ishikawa and Hirokazu Ando carved out a really distinct sound despite working on a series about a pink puffball that rarely shook things up enough to warrant new musical style (unlike <em>Mario</em> or <em>Zelda</em>). That cuteness is important, yes, but he also added a hyperactivity that kept the games peppy and exciting despite them actually being fairly slow-paced games. It’s not just the optimistic melody of “Green Greens” that matters, it’s also the rapid drums and the souped-up arpeggios. As the series progressed, they really developed that hyperactivity and incorporated dance elements into the music that resulted in some of the best-aging stuff from that kind of computer-generated era. <a href="https://www.forbes.com/sites/darrynking/2018/06/20/the-music-of-kirby-still-tickling-gamers-pink/?sh=3b2da5458b04">Ando said</a> that he doesn’t give any thought to whether his music can actually be played by humans, and it’s exactly that mindset that makes his music so unique.</p><p>The new guys seem to have no interest in that mindset. Ogasawara’s “Running Through the New World” is a standard sweeping orchestral arrangement that works as a call to adventure that introduces the player to the expanse of <em>Forgotten World</em>. It’s a nice melody (even with a little callback to “Green Greens”), which is good because you hear it <em>a lot</em> through the game. But despite playing at these orchestral ambitions it’s also composed on a computer — just like every other <em>Kirby</em> game — and trying to pretend otherwise just makes it sound cheap. The mush of sampled strings, the weak flute, overly stiff rhythms; even though I can hear and appreciate what they’re trying to do, those sounds just aren’t good. I won’t act like Ishikawa and Ando have aged into the new era of sound libraries perfectly either, but I think their history composing with worse technology has generally made them better at it. You can often tell which compositions in the game are theirs, because they use electronic or rock sounds that are already processed in real life, so it disguises the artificiality more.</p><p>I’m not out here to make a plea for full orchestras or anything because I get that not every game is going to have the budget for that. What I do want, though, is to make a call for understanding the limits of your tools and making your arrangements to work with that. I actually do think Ando is better at this, too; his “Waddle Dee Town” arrangement for the central hub is flush with instrumental details that sound good in their context. (Though even then, I compare it to something like Lena Raine’s score for a small indie game like <em>Chicory</em> and wonder why a company with Nintendo’s resources can’t pull off something similarly lush.) I can only hope that Ishikawa and Ando are able to pass on what knowledge they have before Ogasawara, or whoever else, takes the lead for good. Or at least that Ogasawara finds his own voice the way that the other folks did. Ain’t no reason for <em>Kirby</em> to be treated so much more cheaply than <em>Mario</em> — it’s got a lot to give, too!</p><h3>Masayoshi Soken (arr. Yukiko Takada) — “Crimson Sunset”</h3><h3>Final Fantasy XIV: Stormblood (2017)</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*LKxBeQtuUktSg2ph0luYdw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Masayoshi Soken has said different things how much of <em>Final Fantasy XIV</em>’s soundtrack is live and how much is taken from a sound library; in a <a href="https://gamerescape.com/2018/03/20/famitsu-talks-to-soken-about-the-music-in-stormblood/"><em>Famitsu </em>interview</a> he says that his team “basically only [uses] music software”, yet while talking to <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-0fguLgOMwY">YouTuber Alex Moukala</a> he said that about 60% of the game’s music is done using an orchestra. I’m not sure what the discrepancy is there (probably a nuance in the process that I’m not understanding, or maybe just a change in approach across expansions), but I will say that it certainly <em>feels</em> like the computer has a heavy presence in the game’s music. You can hear the pieces chopped together in the music software, the strings that sound a little too smooth. Even where the arrangements sound organic, it often feels like there’s pieces missing from the arrangement that could really make it sound full.</p><p>This is to be expected for a game of this size. Each expansion brings hours of new music to the table, and much like the rest of the game there are compromises that must be made when making an online game of this size. The graphics aren’t going to have incredible fidelity, the animations aren’t going to be as dynamic as many AAA games, and the arrangements aren’t going to be as detailed and complex as you might like them to be. And that’s okay, because you’re always given a plethora of things that <em>are</em> incredible, and you can extrapolate from those to fill in the other aspects to their fullest.</p><p>Soken ultimately does realize the limitations in the approach, and he knows how to make the most of the situation. In that <em>Famitsu</em> article he talks about how, for <em>Stormblood</em>, they reduced the number of instruments they used. This works for the aesthetics they’re borrowing for the game’s main areas, based on places like Turkey, China, and Mongolia, but I think it’s also important in minimizing the role of the computer in the process. You start bringing in too many parts together, they start to blend together into a synthetic mush, and there <em>are</em> tracks where you can really hear that. But when you scale back, it lets you focus on the sound of a particular instrument more, which is ultimately real even if it is coming from a sound library. This was something that I noticed even in <em>Heavensward</em>, where my favourite track, “Nobility Obliges”, basically just had different instruments rotating around the same melody, each one giving a change for that particular sound to shine. With the variety of instrumentation used in <em>Stormblood</em> (they really got creative with the Eastern instrumentation for Othard), this particular technique shines through quite a bit. Soken rightfully singles out the kokyu in “A Father’s Pride”; some other personal favourites using this stripped-back approach include “Crimson Sunset”, “Cradle”, and “Beyond the Wall”.</p><p>This approach also works really well in tandem with Soken’s repeated usage of the same themes. Obviously using the same themes over and over is going to save you on time composing new themes, but for <em>FFXIV</em> it also helps bring out the best in what could otherwise feel like lackluster arrangements. Both of the main nations in <em>Stormblood</em> get their own main theme that you’ll hear a lot through the expansion, sometimes with complete disregard for any kind of thematic consistency. (That “The Measure of Our Reach” is used as an anthem for both the Garlean fascists and the Ala Mhigan rebels, as well as calm music and every time you complete a mission, can feel a little jarring at times.) The melodies kind of exist on their own, an approach that actually works for the game. Whenever you hear that theme in a new area, you’re hearing the theme with a new twist on it, and not really in a gimmicky way that reduces it down to a single genre. Instead it brings out details or aspects to that melody that aren’t present in another arrangement, things that make you appreciate the melody more. If these arrangements were given a more generic melody, then the music would often fall completely flat, because the sounds simply aren’t rich enough to sustain a piece on its own. By working with a familiar melody — one that is very good, that I suspect <em>was</em> labored over in a way that the arrangements were not — they can become part of a greater whole.</p><p>In this way, I can hear different things in the same notes. The main theme of Othard, as presented in the trailer theme “Storm of Blood”, is full of optimistic heroism to propel the player on their journey. In different contexts, from different <em>arrangers</em>, I hear different contexts for that pride: the strained strings in the middle of Yoshitaka Suzuki’s “Cradle” arrangement capture the struggle that it takes for the people of Othard to maintain that pride; the string instrument (a pipa?) in Yukiko Takada’s “Crimson Sunset” arrangement makes that pride contemplative; the soaring chorus in Kenichi Kuroda’s “The Worm’s Tail” serves as a reminder of the danger in that pride.</p><p>I have my quibbles with all of those arrangements, and I don’t know if I’d call any of them particular standouts. (The real prizes are the two capital-S Songs, “Beauty’s Wicked Wiles” and “Wayward Daughter”. But that’s a discussion for another time.) But it doesn’t feel like they’re meant to be taken in isolation. When I hear one, I hear the emotions captured in all the others within the melody now. In that sense, I’d say the music of <em>Final Fantasy XIV</em> works extremely well.</p><h3>Koji Kondo — “Athletic”</h3><h3>Super Mario World 2: Yoshi’s Island (1995)</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*XpCSXicCdX9o4GaLqsWVAg.jpeg" /></figure><p>You often see gamers bringing up <em>Cuphead</em> and <em>Persona 5 </em>as Novel Examples of jazz in games — sincerely or as a meme, I do not know, although what the hell is the difference at this point? — and ignoring the fact that <em>Persona 5</em> is more jazz-<em>influenced</em> than actual jazz, it’s silly because Koji Kondo’s been out here giving people jazz music in the most popular video game franchise on Earth right from the very beginning. It’s just that gamers don’t listen to enough music outside of games — certainly not ’20s or ’30s jazz — to recognize the genre in a 16-bit format like this. But I encourage you to listen to, say, <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_2fhRwAFA2Y">Louis Armstrong’s “Cornet Chop Suey”</a> next to the breakdown in “Athletic”. It’s the same thing, just with an SNES sound chip and in service of cutesy pastels!</p><h3>Petri Alanko — “The Well-Lit Room” / Petri Alanko and Martin Suosalo — “Sankarin Tango”</h3><h3>Alan Wake (2010) / Control (2019)</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*6gUWFBJ-Hap-VuWyi45-yQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Two atmospheric games from Finnish studio Remedy (best known for the <em>Max Payne</em> series) that are not really as atmospheric as they’d like you to believe. <em>Alan Wake</em> draws very explicitly from the abstract and terrifying horrors of <em>Twin Peaks</em> and <em>The Shining</em>, yet never seems willing to commit to the weirdness and can feel a little too safe as a result; <em>Control</em> leans into the weirdness a bit more, but its brutalist architecture and fairly standard gunplay, narrative, and protagonist gives it a AAA sheen that makes the game feel like every other Western AAA game. And likewise, Petri Alanko’s soundtracks for them are a bit too familiar, the <em>Alan Wake</em> soundtrack consisting of standard cinematic ambient sounds and <em>Control</em> bringing more electronic darkness to the ambience. They’re fine, they get the job done, but they don’t elevate the games. (Not the way that, to use <em>Twin Peaks</em> and <em>The Shining</em> again, Angelo Badalamenti’s or Krzysztof Penderecki’s music did.) Even the moments where that style <em>does</em> stand out, like “The Well-Lit Room” in <em>Alan Wake</em>, are far too fleeting an devoid and melody to really stick. (Pretty piano, swelling strings that scores a climactic moment of peace and respite in an otherwise harrowing experience, but I also wouldn’t have ever thought about it again were I not doing this project.) The music is disappointingly typical for games that put on a show of being anything but.</p><p>The funny thing is that it’s pretty clear that Remedy recognizes the power of music, because both games have a segment solely devoted to a universal truth: shooting waves of monsters with heavy metal blasting fucking rules. The same band is used in both sequences — Finnish band Poets of the Fall, referred to in-universe as the Old Gods of Asgard and represented in <em>Alan Wake</em> by some old coots who supposedly were popular in the ’70s despite the music sounding nothing like the ‘70s — and the music is, regrettably, not good. (Corny singer, basic-ass riffs, stiff rhythm section.) But as long as you’re blasting shit to loud guitars, it works. Plus, you get some cool choreography in each one: <em>Alan Wake</em>’s section takes place on a literal rock stage where the spotlights and pyrotechnics defeat enemies, while <em>Control</em> guides you through a trippy maze that intentionally syncs up with specific sections of the song. They’re fun segments, especially in <em>Control</em>.</p><p>The best of these songs, however, isn’t a rock song. For <em>Control</em>, game director Sam Lake sought to include a Finnish character in the game. The character, Ahti, is a janitor who acts as a guide through (and perhaps embodiment of) the complexities of the labyrinthian Oldest House. He often appears in strange and confusing places, and wandering through the House you’ll often hear “Sankarin Tango” playing. Sometimes it’s from a radio right beside Ahti; sometimes, Ahti is nowhere to be found. But either way, it’s Ahti’s voice singing on the song, and the way that it plays diegetically in the game, the volume shifting depending on your proximity to its origin, makes it feel like Ahti is everywhere in the Oldest House. The tango makes sense for his Finnish character, since the genre is very big in Finland, but Martin Suosalo (Ahti’s voice actor) is also a confident and charismatic singer that draws you in to his voice, and hearing it often felt very comforting; in a setting where the environment is continually shifting and unreliable, hearing the voice of someone who firmly dances his way through it as a joy is a welcomed presence. Alanko’s lush instrumentation compliments Suosalo’s singing well.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_Il8r3Ki8UGwxgdJk9XNQQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>I like both of these games, but there’s a surface level genericism and repetitiveness that undercuts the actual interesting things they’re capable of. So I look forward to their respective sequels because I feel like Remedy can do a whole lot more with them. Initially set in their own universes, it seems like they plan on building a shared universe between them and maybe even <em>Max Payne</em> (with remakes of the first two games on the horizon), and I think bringing their different brands together could produce something as weird and brilliant as they promise to be. (The <em>AWE</em> DLC for <em>Control</em>, which features Alan Wake in it, makes me think that they have the right ideas in mind for <em>Alan Wake 2</em>.) While I don’t see signs of the music becoming as core a part of that artistic elevation, I do hope it becomes something that isn’t delegated to small bright spots.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=57c08ea2e6d3" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Game Music Diary — Jan-Apr 2022]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@azdiff/game-music-diary-jan-apr-2022-c482ed73832a?source=rss-8424cf63b043------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c482ed73832a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[elden-ring]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[persona-5]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[return-of-the-obra-dinn]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[games]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[video-game-music]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Azdiff]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 29 Apr 2022 21:01:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-04-29T21:02:42.615Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Game Music Diary — Jan-Apr 2022</h3><p>Last year I set out to write something about every game that I played, and doing that was a lot of fun. It was a good way to get my feet wet when it comes to writing about games, and made me appreciate the games I played a lot more. It also wasn’t necessarily a way to produce actual good writing, and while there are <em>some</em> things I wrote that I liked, there was also a lot that wasn’t worth reading. So I’m leaving the broader, holistic writing for games that I really feel like I have stuff to say about, like my writings on <a href="https://medium.com/@azdiff/why-does-nobody-want-change-a-critique-of-persona-5-8ab5f99755b4"><em>Persona 5</em></a><em> </em><a href="https://medium.com/@azdiff/your-goal-your-faith-your-virtue-persona-5-royal-250d1aeed042"><em>Royal</em></a>.</p><p>I still want to keep up that energy, though. So instead, this year I want to write something about the <em>music</em> from every game that I’ve played; specifically, one piece from each game, typically focusing in on how it both connects with the game itself and how it works as its own piece of music. As a result, the pieces of music I choose from each game are not necessarily the best music in the game, or even personal favourites. (Although some of them are!) Just ones that I think are interesting to talk about. Not supposed to be anything too serious, but seeing as I’m still belatedly working my way through a bunch of canonical games, it seems like a good exercise to understand game music better.</p><p>These are arranged chronologically in the order that I finished them. I tried to avoid spoilers, but you still might want to take caution around a few of them if you’re sensitive to that kind of thing. (I marked some of the more egregious ones with spoiler warnings.) Here’s a list, so that you can Ctrl+F and find your way around to the ones you’re most interested in:</p><ol><li><em>Bloodborne</em></li><li><em>Katamari Damacy</em></li><li><em>KID A MNESIAC</em></li><li><em>Persona 5 Royal</em></li><li><em>Pokémon Legends: Arceus</em></li><li><em>Return of the Obra Dinn</em></li><li><em>Elden Ring</em></li><li><em>NORCO</em></li><li><em>Dishonored: Death of the Outsider</em></li><li><em>ABZÛ</em></li><li><em>Shin Megami Tensei IV</em></li></ol><h3>Nobuyoshi Suzuki — “Ludwig, the Holy Blade”</h3><h4><strong><em>Bloodborne: The Old Hunters</em> (2015)</strong></h4><figure><img alt="Ludwig, the Accursed. A hideous beast." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*vdc6SaI7xGAaf3Rc2oUkHw.png" /></figure><p>Ludwig is one of the most tragic characters in <em>Bloodborne</em>, one of the few people in the city of Yarnham that seems to have been a consistent force for good. He led a church of hunters in a real attempt to undo the horrors that humans’ courting of the elder gods had wrought upon the world, perhaps Yarnham’s first leader who recognized that there was nothing but beasthood ahead of them; yet still, he fought hard to deny that future. His reward, blood-drunk in the Hunter’s Nightmare, is to become the most hideous beast of all, a disfigured two-headed horse creature with a mouth made of eyes and appendages spilling out in terrible directions. As your hunter approaches him, a choir bursts out in a cry of terror, before settling into a ritualistic chant that underscores a violin melody as off-kilter and unsettling as Ludwig’s form. In this form, Ludwig is one of the most aggressive bosses in the entire game, ensuring a fast-paced fight where you never get a chance to breathe. Yet the music never matches that pace, instead keeping up the horror of the ugly beast before you.</p><p>At least, not until the second half of the fight. Ludwig may be the most hideous beast in the game, but he’s also the only one who has managed to hold onto a semblance of his humanity; perhaps that’s precisely <em>why</em> he became as horrific as he did. In the second half of the fight, he remembers that last bit of humanity, and rediscovers the Holy Moonlight Blade that kept him true — or at least <em>feeling</em> true — in a world of depravity. (“Aah, you were at my side all along… My true mentor… My guiding moonlight…”) Ludwig cannot change his form, but he regains his poise, begins to look and act almost human again, and the music takes on a sweeping heroism. The choir sings tremendous leaps, the horns are full of bombast. That heroism isn’t for your hunter, though; it’s for Ludwig’s last gasps of humanity, still in service to the beasthood that aims to kill you. The music roots against you, but even it cannot save Ludwig from himself; it’s up to you to free him from eternal misery, and as you do, the music devolves into chaos to remind you of the beast that never left.</p><h3>Radiohead — “You and Whose Army”</h3><h4><strong><em>KID A MNESIA Exhibition</em> (2021)</strong></h4><figure><img alt="A swirl of scary yet cute creatures." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*yHYAHmq03oQL7XDCtHIztg.png" /></figure><p>Perhaps this doesn’t count, given that this wasn’t composed for the game and I knew it long before this exhibition. But playing the game really did change my perception of the song. <em>Kid A</em> and <em>Amnesiac</em> are my two personal favourite Radiohead albums, ones that I’ve spent countless hours imagining a world to accompany them. Seeing how an <em>actual</em> visual representation of these songs was neat, especially for the songs that I’ve listened to the most, like “Pyramid Song” and “How to Disappear Completely”. But what most stunned me in this exhibition was “You and Whose Army”, precisely because I’ve never actually cared for the song all that much. The first two minutes of the song have too much of Thom Yorke moaning and too little of the band doing anything else; it doesn’t really pick up until its entire sonic world explodes in its final minute. I still find this to be true, but the visuals in the <em>KID A MNESIA Exhibition</em> provide a whole new context for the song, as these delightful shadowy creatures swirl and expand as you rise above and around some mysterious dance they perform with the song. Now, I can imagine more than Thom Yorke’s mumbling; I can see the creatures swaying to the sound of his voice, and the rapturousness at the end of the song feels even more incredible as the creatures expand and multiply. The worlds I imagined for other Radiohead songs in the exhibition are by and large unchanged; the exhibit is cool, but ultimately the songs still feel personal to me. But for this one song, my perception is changed entirely.</p><h3>Yoshihito Yano — “LONELY ROLLING STAR”</h3><h4><strong><em>Katamari Damacy </em>(2004)</strong></h4><figure><img alt="A ball of maidens about to become stardust." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*lzHpeludMIzRKJpEwmPktA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Humbling, in a cosmic sense. Like all of the Shibuya-kei music in <em>Katamari</em>, this song provides a perfect walking rhythm as you go along your casual task of rolling up every object in sight to build a star to add to the night sky. From the perspective of the Prince of Cosmos, this is just casual, everyday life, and the beginning of each level matches this easygoing attitude. You start rolling up everyday household objects like erasers, toys, and boxes. Yet as your ball gets bigger and bigger, you eventually start rolling up living things — chickens, dogs, cows; eventually, human beings. You can hear their screams as you roll them up, see them run away from you as you come for them. At points, cops even start (pointlessly) shooting at you. In a game as absurd as this one, where twin sumo wrestlers walk around the park holding hands as your cosmic father chastises you about your 200m star not being big enough, it is kind of funny. But there’s terror in those screams, and in spite of everything it does feel <em>real</em>. One of the levels, where you’re supposed to roll up as many “maidens” as you can to build the Virgo constellation, almost qualifies as horror, where <em>you’re</em> the monster.</p><p>Yet when “LONELY ROLLING STAR” plays, you can’t help but feel you’re in the right. The chorus feels at once casual and endlessly important, like you’re content in what you’re doing precisely because you know the importance of rolling people up to build stars. (A lonely rolling star; almost as though there’s a personal sacrifice that the <em>Prince</em> is making, not the people he rolls up.) You’re not supposed to care; after all, you’re the Prince of Cosmos. The scope of your work is leagues beyond what these ants could ever comprehend. The people you’re rolling up, people like you are in real life, couldn’t begin to comprehend the scope, the <em>magnitude</em> of the world beyond them, just as there’s things smaller than those humans that could never comprehend anything beyond <em>their</em> world. This music reminds me of my place in the world, how small I ultimately am; yet it also reminds me how meaningful the world as a whole can be.</p><h3>Shoji Meguro, Lyn, and Benjamin Franklin — “Colors Flying High (Opening Movie Version)”</h3><h4><strong><em>Persona 5 Royal </em>(2019)</strong></h4><figure><img alt="Yoshizawa springs into action just as the song does." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*mwgA6zBzAW9Fpl8bIGTzXw.png" /></figure><p>I was disappointed to discover that, while I was playing the game, there was no full version of <em>Royal</em>’s main theme. There were so many details to love within the short minute-and–a-half version that every time it finished, I just wanted more of it. (A classic anime problem.) But when a full version coincidentally released shortly after I finished the game, I was surprised to realise that I actually didn’t find much need for it. For one, there’s not much new added by the full version: the same melodies without any new instrumental or vocal flourishes to speak of, with the only notable addition being some new lyrics that, while decent, aren’t exactly revelatory. (Awkward, too; like many video game lyrical themes, it seems like they’re trying to squeeze the lyrics into an existing melody instead of letting them work with each other, and Lyn often seems more occupied on how she’s singing rather than <em>what</em> she’s singing. Lines like “Who to love and who adore” or “What’s your aesthetics, ethics?” feel stilted, even though they very much have thematic resonance with the game.)</p><p>Most importantly, though, I realized the song had become inseparable from the game’s <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vWWy7V9rCrA">opening movie</a>, which I absolutely love. The song’s best moments are scored by visuals at the game’s most stylish: the bursts of melody in the “colours fly” section punctuated by the Phantom Thieves casually swinging their bats at the world; Yoshizawa calmly walking through the song’s quiet moment before both she and the music rapidly slide into glorious dance; the soaring chorus accompanied by the Phantom Thieves majestic wonder at the gems raining down on them. Every one of those moments plays perfectly in my head as I listen to the song, and after those first 90 seconds, I’m ready to coolly walk away just as Joker and Morgana do, their target’s heart in hand.</p><h3>Hiromitsu Maeba — “Disaster Looming (Battle)”</h3><h4><strong><em>Pokémon Legends: Arceus </em>(2022)</strong></h4><figure><img alt="A young Pokémon trainer and a professor in an apocalyptic hellscape." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*1sIPDGAchBJkweCTnSmK7w.jpeg" /></figure><p>I don’t think as much of this game’s music as some — the worlds aren’t detailed enough to make the callbacks to the <em>Diamond and Pearl</em> soundtrack meaningful and the arrangements aren’t rich enough to truly immerse you. Instead, it often feels like exhibit #1986 of the series eating itself alive, even as this game treads new ground. However, I did appreciate the addition of Hiromitsu Maeba to the team, who previously worked on recent Capcom games. The industrial ambient vibes he provided for the literal hellscapes of <em>Devil May Cry 5</em> work perfectly in the climax of <em>Arceus</em>, where the sky has turned purple and the world is on the verge of apocalypse. Ominous synths and bell chimes envelop the atmosphere everywhere you go, wrapping the world in a sense of uncertainty that nothing can break. Even as you fight a Pokémon the atmosphere doesn’t break; the music instead filters in a light industrial beat to match the pace of what’s happening. The beat is nothing but background noise, however, because it can’t ever let you forget why you’re really here. Regardless of whether you’re fighting a Bidoof or a tough trainer, it’s just a distraction; the music won’t let you forget what’s really important.</p><h3>Lucas Pope — “Escape”</h3><h4><strong><em>Return of the Obra Dinn </em>(2018)</strong></h4><figure><img alt="A sailor with a cutlass gets shotgun blasted by a rich lady." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*mRuctAvhqDp9SeILNTtoWg.jpeg" /></figure><p>For those who don’t know, <em>Return of the Obra Dinn</em> is a game where you play as a detective investigating a ship where all of its crew members are either dead or missing. You come equipped with a magic stopwatch that allows you to hear the last moments before a crew member’s death and view the exact moment that they died, frozen in time. It’s a brilliant mechanic for a detective game, but it’s also a great way to create empathy for the people you’re investigating; you can see the pain or sadness in the face of not only the person dying, but their fellow crewmates, whose own deaths you know are soon to come. (The game’s actual <em>plot</em> is not all that interesting, so this goes a long way to make up for it.) With each of those moments comes a short piece of dramatic music that sells the gravity and the sadness of their death, tailored to a specific chapter in the journey of the <em>Obra Dinn</em>. The arrangements aren’t rich, and the simple rhythms and motifs make it clear that this is music programmed on a computer by one guy already doing literally everything else for the game. But Lucas Pope ties enough moving motifs together to make the sound work, and I particularly like the second half of “Escape”, which plays in a scene where some of the surviving crew members try to leave the <em>Obra Dinn</em> having endured countless tragedies and a waning faith in their captain. The brisk strings reflect the remaining bit of agency those potential escapees have, but the muted horn punctuations tell the story of the whole game: a resigned knowledge of the cursed fates that await every single person aboard the ship.</p><h3>Tsukasa Saitoh — “The Final Battle”</h3><h4><strong><em>Elden Ring</em> (2022)</strong></h4><p><em>Spoilers for the final boss here, though in my opinion it’s not really that big a deal.</em></p><figure><img alt="A prisoner dabbing by the corpse of a god." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*VgwqxaDBts-o9qxW25OKvA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Opinions on <em>Elden Ring</em>’s soundtrack tend to fall pretty firmly into two camps, and unfortunately I land in the one that thinks it sounds pretty generic. I’m always sceptical of the epic fantasy shit, which often shoots for vibes above all else, letting the mere idea of brass and choirs do the work without providing the texture or melody that actually makes the music interesting. That’s pretty much how most of <em>Elden Ring</em>’s soundtrack plays out to me, but even I’ll concede that the uplifting energy of the main theme is very rousing, <em>especially</em> in this rendition that plays during the final boss. It’s the roaring percussion that sets this one apart; too often the music in <em>Elden Ring</em> can fade to the background, ready to be forgotten, but the drums demand your attention during “The Final Battle”. The way the choir comes in as Radagon awakens and looks at you, and the horns pounding out the main theme as the battle truly begins. (It’s worth noting that Tsukasa Saitoh is also responsible for the heavy horn blasts from “The Hunter” in <em>Bloodborne</em>.) It all comes to a head in the sudden pause that leads into a tightly focused frenzy of strings, one that actually leads to the second half of the song in the official soundtrack.</p><p>The second half, pitting you against the primal form of god, becomes more quiet and contemplative, a tried-and-true FromSoftware move to score the tragic final moments of their games’ ultimate bosses. (In fact, the first few notes of this section almost directly recall “Gwyn, Lord of Cinder” from the first <em>Dark Souls</em>.) Yet even this second half sets itself apart from other quiet tracks in FromSoft’s history (or even elsewhere in <em>Elden Ring</em>), because it doesn’t play up the tragedy or the mystery; in fact, it’s blissfully calm. It starts off very quietly, piano notes rippling across the waters and soft singing gliding alongside it. Even the climax of the music is a truly beautiful angelic chant that comes in respect of the Elden Beast, even in respect of what your fight against God themselves. It’s arguable that the way your Tarnished character disrupts the world isn’t noble, coming in to create a streak of death in a world that hasn’t known the mere concept of death for a long time; yet the Lands Between are so far past when things truly fell apart that it feels almost normal now. That you’ve made it this far may very well be a blessing.</p><p>Or maybe not. It depends on the ending you get, your interpretation of the lore, and your own sense of morals. The epic resistance of Radagon’s theme and the beautiful embrace of Elden Beast’s theme provide two views of the same idea. I was initially annoyed that these two themes were part of the same track, but the more I listen to it, the harder time I have separating them; after all, they represent the same being.</p><h3>Gewgaly I — “Quarter Rats”</h3><h4><strong><em>NORCO</em> (2022)</strong></h4><figure><img alt="The French Quarter, featuring a sketchy hot dog stand and Santa the drug dealer." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*K1-gWqmFB80H9B2A03UtJA.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>NORCO</em> has gotten a lot of comparisons to <em>Kentucky Route Zero</em>, and that’s a fair comparison in many ways: both are point-and-click games focused on megacorporations taking over small, rural communities in the American South set in the near future where lines between the real and artificial are increasingly blurred by technology. That’s a pretty specific niche, and it’s obvious that <em>Kentucky Route Zero</em> was an influence on <em>NORCO</em>. But playing the game, the games feel very distinctly different. I think you can tell something just by their names alone; <em>Kentucky Route Zero</em> is looking at an entire state while <em>NORCO</em> is named after one specific town. <em>NORCO</em> seems more focused on individuals, or at least communities formed <em>through</em> individuals, while <em>Kentucky Route Zero</em> took on traditions that reached back through the entire history of the state. Both games focus on the large and small, of course, but there are different approaches that change how each are represented, something that you can tell even through the music.</p><p>Both games are largely scored by electronic ambient music. Ben Babbitt’s score for <em>Kentucky Route Zero</em> often put you in another time and place, an inescapable void where you could hear the beauty of everything that once was and maybe, somewhere, still is; in contrast to the spectres of life conveyed through its bluegrass music, the ambient music brings sounds distinctly modern, signifying the confusing decay of the world as it is now. Gewgaly I’s score for <em>NORCO</em>, on the other hand, feels distinctly located in a not-so-distant past. The PR blurb on the official soundtrack’s Bandcamp page specifically evokes game soundtracks from the ’80s and ’90s, and that certainly tracks alongside the game’s pixelated artwork. Even though the game is set in the near future, I found myself hearing the past more, which works for a game that suggests that the town of Norco hasn’t been able to progress as a community in a long time. It’s interesting to keep that in mind as you listen closer, hearing details in the music that give character to each location, with the most interesting example of this being “Quarter Rats”.</p><p>This piece of music plays in the French Quarter, not in Norco but in New Orleans, the birthplace of jazz. You actually go to a few parts of New Orleans in the game, but most of them are places like city halls and abandoned shopping malls. The French Quarter is the only place (aside, perhaps, from the club playing bounce music) that seems like a familiar representation of New Orleans in a cultural sense, at least to an outsider like myself. It makes sense, then, that the piece opens with jazzy drumming, and eventually brings in trumpets. But Gewgaly I doesn’t make the jazz an aesthetic gimmick; in fact, it’s not even jazz music. (Certainly not New Orleans-style jazz.) You have the smooth ride pattern and these film noir punctuations of trumpet, but ultimately it’s the keyboards that take the lead here, leading a muted sound that’s of a piece with the rest of the soundtrack while still having the flourishes to sound like its own thing. (There are some uneasy stops and starts that actually remind me a lot of Chicago footwork like <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZzEK5Z9ALU8">DJ Rashad’s “Feelin”</a>.) The sound never strays from the ’90s computer game ambience of the rest of the soundtrack, and really it <em>shouldn’t</em> feel that distinct given. Despite its real life significance, in the game, it’s just a stopgap location with a few beggars and some sketchy hotdogs as the main character tries to find the building they’re supposed to meet someone in. It feels <em>just</em> interesting and unique enough to feel like a distinct location without breaking the tone or atmosphere of the rest of the game, a place that manages to respect the culture of its locale while recognizing that what you see in front of you is pretty far gone from whatever it once was. I don’t want to oversell how much the soundtrack feels localised to Louisiana — most of the soundtrack is not really like this — but for one track, I think it’s pretty interesting.</p><h3>Daniel Licht — “The Bank Job: Exploration”</h3><h4><strong><em>Dishonored: Death of the Outsider</em> (2017)</strong></h4><figure><img alt="Overlooking the bank." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YNEwBU8ych_ooWrpNxuz7Q.jpeg" /></figure><p>This soundtrack, to a standalone expansion (and seemingly the last entry) for the <em>Dishonored</em> series, was the last thing that Daniel Licht composed for before he died. And, you know, I’m not going to act like a composer whose most famous work is the soundtrack to <em>Dexter</em> is some kind of masterful artist (although <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e2xxizpHuoo">“Blood Theme”</a> is pretty good), but I do think that Licht’s music is pretty important to making <em>Dishonored</em> work. As a stealth-based immersive sim, the game doesn’t really call for a rich soundtrack. The moments of calm need some general ambience, something to fill up the air without distracting from things while you plot your next moves. The moments that erupt into chaos honestly don’t need a lot either, because when a guard spots you and calls over all his buddies, the music is the <em>last</em> thing you should be focusing on. (Especially when the guards won’t stop fuckin’ yelling!) It’s better for the music to be unassuming than to be a main focal point.</p><p>Yet just as crucial for <em>Dishonored</em> is its setting, the fictional cities of Dunwall and Karnaca. It’s not a nice world to live in, where plague-ridden rats have spread sickness across its citizens, religious zealots run the government, and a chaotic god grants shadowy powers to whomever he chooses to reign terror in the streets. (It’s this god that you set out to kill in <em>Death of the Outsider</em>.) The specifics of the game’s setting dovetail into the kinds of environments you explore, and to complete the picture, the music needs to capture the mood. So Licht’s music is never showy, but it does capture the uneasiness of the area around you. You’ll hear a lot of strained violins and hammered dulcimers, weaving in and out in unpredictable ways to ensure that you’re never too comfortable. Licht’s name is the first thing you see when you finish <em>Death of the Outsider</em>, and I’d say the tribute is earned.</p><h3>Austin Wintory — “Delphinus Delphis”</h3><h4>ABZÛ (2016)</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*QlUgv627joGm-9iho5VJyA.png" /></figure><p>Austin Wintory is a composer that’s proven popular with people who aren’t really into games; his soundtrack for <em>Journey</em> got him a Grammy nomination, and it remains the only game soundtrack to be nominated in that category. He also won the games section of the International Film Music Critics Association Awards twice, once for (of all things) <em>Assassin’s Creed Syndicate</em> and once for <em>ABZÛ. </em>It doesn’t really surprise me that this soundtrack is popular with film score folks. The game itself is pretty simple, mostly just swimming through the ocean with some fish past the occasional mysterious ruin. The game takes about 90 minutes to finish, and there are several sequences in the game that are essentially scripted. So Wintory essentially gets to score this like a movie, and listening to it on its own, it often <em>does</em> feel like it could easily be slotted into an animated short film or something, especially in its more whimsical moments.</p><p>The game itself is not as good as <em>Journey</em>, the game that Wintory and many of <em>ABZÛ</em>’s developers are most famous for. The small moments that help build the story in the background are not as powerful in <em>ABZÛ</em> as they were in <em>Journey</em>, and a lot of those details wound up coming through in the music. (<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KeKnkaB0MBE">Game Score Fanfare</a> made a good video unravelling all the details.) So Wintory’s soundtrack suffers a little as a result, but only a little; the moments where the game really does feel exciting are still propelled by the emotion conveyed through Wintory’s music.</p><p>The best musical section comes in the first of a few scripted sequences where your character is barreling through the water alongside schools of fish, scored by “Delphinus Delphis”. (Yes, there are dolphins.) There are a lot of instrumental voices spread through the track that capture the sense of life you see in the dozens of fish bustling around you, and even though there isn’t much for new scenery along your path (save for a tunnel at the end that’s met with a choir and some echo), the different melodies and sounds provide their own sense of newness for your adventure.</p><h3>Ryota Kozuka — “Tokyo”</h3><h4>Shin Megami Tensei IV (2013)</h4><p><em>Spoilers for an early game twist, a vague description of a late game twist, and general theme and setting ideas.</em></p><p>I wasn’t going to include this piece on the list, since it’s not really new to me; I’ve known and loved it since an abandoned playthrough back when the game first game out. (Good game, but it tests your patience a <em>lot</em>.) Revisiting the game, I was waiting for another piece of music that would approach the same level of impact, and while there is a lot of good music to be found — the hazy industrial tones of the battle themes, the casual synth funk that brings life to the underground districts of Tokyo, even the hollow ambience that washes over areas ravaged by destruction — nothing can ever come close to the majesty of “Tokyo”; and in fact, I only ever grew to love it more.</p><p>To set the scene: <em>Shin Megami Tensei IV</em> starts you off by becoming a samurai of the Eastern Kingdom of Mikado, an area based off of feudal Japan. You fight demons attempting to emerge from underground, and eventually events drive you deep into the tunnels that the demons emerge from. On the other side of it is what players will recognize as a post-apocalyptic version of modern Tokyo, ravaged by demons and covered by a steel sky that Mikado lays on top of. It’s a moment that totally upends what you might <em>think</em> the game is about, and the game’s characters —who have never seen a world remotely like the one they just discovered was beneath their feet their entire lives — are even more surprised.</p><p>Cue this incredible piece of music. Deep bass and contemplative, spindly arpeggios convey a sense of awe at the world you (the player) and you (the character) have just discovered. As the song progresses, it tells you more about the world before you’ve even had a chance to meet many people in the city: a lonely piano accompanied by a stilted rhythm emphasizes the broken and lonely nature of the world at hand; it progresses into a strained section of high, heavily processed guitars that seem to be reaching for a sense of hope that’s too difficult to attain; then you get muted, echoing electric piano as you settle into an acceptance of what “Tokyo” is truly like. Then it loops and begins again, repeating this internal journey forever and ever (just as humanity is doomed to repeat itself in and endless struggle, according to the game), playing again and again in the overworld as you explore the ruined city.</p><p>Both humans and demons live in this version of Tokyo after a calamity that was not very long ago, only 25 years; yet no one can seem to remember how they arrived in this situation. Neither humans nor demons are wholly bad species, but the lines in the sand have been drawn, and Tokyo has become increasingly inhospitable. No one is comfortable, everyone is unhappy, but because no one remembers what life was like before. For the inhabitants of Tokyo, this is just life, and the idea of something better is so far beyond the scope of their imagination that they accept it all. Tokyo comes in sharp contrast to Mikado, which isn’t a utopia by any stretch, marked by feudal distinctions between Luxurors and Casualries. But you can see the sun, you can grow vegetables, there’s no demons waiting to accost you. This contrast meant that I was far more inclined to lean into a post-apocalyptic reading of “Tokyo”, viewing the failed hopes and the decaying industry as the sound that embodies the city.</p><p>Yet you spend far more time in Tokyo through the game, and as you play, you begin to discover places far worse than the Tokyo you know, including visions of what the world <em>can</em> look like should you take certain paths. (Worlds that many players will end up in, unless you are a Sophisticated Man of Culture like myself who said the right things and saw the good, neutral ending.) Every time I came back from one of those places (which are, I might add, a pain to move around in), the opening notes of “Tokyo” began to feel comforting. There are still demons there, and the wrecked city is a labyrinth that’s difficult to navigate in its own way. It is by no stretch a <em>good</em> place to be. But in those moments, I could imagine more and more what it means to accept this place as your home, and the entire inner monologue that I described the music through clicked more and more. When I hear this song now, it’s not the bad parts of the game’s city that I see; only the vision of a place I <em>want</em> to be.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c482ed73832a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“Your goal, your faith, your virtue”: Persona 5 Royal]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@azdiff/your-goal-your-faith-your-virtue-persona-5-royal-250d1aeed042?source=rss-8424cf63b043------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/250d1aeed042</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[game-review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[persona-5-royal]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Azdiff]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 16 Mar 2022 23:04:12 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-03-16T23:04:12.464Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*iWyQOU3wuu-MqxuBfZuoRw.png" /><figcaption>Somewhere, these guys are best buds.</figcaption></figure><p><em>This essay contains spoilers for </em>Persona 5 Royal<em>, specifically the new story elements added to </em>Royal<em>. If you’ve played </em>Persona 5 <em>but haven’t played</em> Royal,<em> and you don’t care about spoilers, there’s a healthy amount of plot summary in here. So you should be able to follow along.</em></p><p>In my previous essay on <em>Persona 5</em>, I identified a lot of problems I had with the overall flow of the narrative, the way that the game was too messy to hone in on the themes I felt had a lot of potential. It made its morals too easy while also contradicting them anyway without even trying, coming to a head in a final act that didn’t have much to do with the rest of the game. The game derived a lot of power from its sprawl, and I wouldn’t hesitate for a second to call it a great game; but there’s issues.</p><p>The deluxe rerelease of the game, <em>Persona 5 Royal</em>, comes with new characters and a new story arc (on top of several very welcome quality of life improvements). These changes, to me, show an awareness of the rough edges around the base game’s narrative. It doesn’t fix those problems — the original game is largely intact, and after all, I wrote that first essay based on my playthrough of <em>Royal</em> — but the game’s new content, largely confined to a new arc that functions more or less as a separate story from the rest of the game, functions as a self-contained unit that nevertheless extends and sometimes works in opposition to what the base game was doing. What results is, in my opinion, the best section in the entire game.</p><p>The core of <em>Royal</em>’s new content is centred around a new character, Dr. Takuto Maruki. For much of the game, he’s an unassuming new figure; he’s brought into Shujin Academy after Shiho’s suicide attempt as a councilor to help students talk about any of their problems. He’s young, cute, and eager to provide snacks. He makes every attempt to make students comfortable talking to him, especially the ones like Ryuji who are actively resistant towards him. His attempts at being casual — bribing people with snacks, silly thought exercises — are actually rather awkward, which actually helps disarm the tension. Each member of the Phantom Thieves has a scene alone with Maruki, which usually isn’t all that interesting (especially since the voice acting budget didn’t extend to those scenes), but does at least show that he’s not bluffing; he has the skills to help the people he talks to, and the Phantom Thieves usually walk away from their conversations feeling a little bit better about everything that’s happened.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*FICmBSreMuy2lFFfrEfU0A.jpeg" /><figcaption>Recording of scenes from Maruki’s arc is blocked on the PlayStation and I don’t have a capture card. So concept art is the best I’ve got.</figcaption></figure><p>Eventually, as Joker’s relationship with Maruki develops through confidant conversations, you learn that Maruki has done research into cognitive psience, which of course raises some concern among the Phantom Thieves. But the dude has such a goofy presence that it’s hard to be too worried — certainly not when you’ve got guys like Shido to deal with, who Maruki clearly has no involvement with — and he also seems to really care about the people he’s involved with. He talks often about wanting to be able to treat peoples’ minds in the same way that we can treat their physical bodies, to find ways to be able to fix them and make the pain go away. It’s not hard to predict where this is going, but he also starts talking about this stuff really, really early in the game; far beyond when he actually becomes a major player.</p><p>In <em>Royal</em>’s new arc, right at the start of the new year, you discover that something’s off. Shortly after defeating Yaldabaoth, Joker comes downstairs to the bar to a real shock: Morgana’s a human, and Futaba’s mother is alive. Their two biggest wishes have come true, and they’re acting as if everything is totally normal while Joker’s wondering what the fuck is happening. He very quickly finds out that everyone else has had wishes granted: Ryuji’s still on the track team; Shiho never tried to kill herself; Yusuke is living with a competent, benevolent Madarame; both Makoto’s and Haru’s fathers are alive. They’re living their best lives, and the Phantom Thieves seem to still more or less be friends, although their memories seem foggy in order to make this reality work. But nothing seems to have changed for Joker, and he’s freaked out by the whole situation; so he sets out to figure out what the hell is going on.</p><p>Eventually, Joker discovers that this is Maruki’s doing, who has his own palace and even his own Persona that is able to grant peoples’ wishes. Using information he learned from his private sessions with the Phantom Thieves, he was able to change reality to create their own ideal world. (“Ideal and the Real” is actually the name of his musical theme.) Maruki’s plan is to use the information from Mementos to eventually change the reality of the entire world to one where everyone’s wishes can come true and pain is eliminated entirely. Which raises the question: is this something that Joker wants to stop?</p><p>After all, this seems like the mirror funhouse version of what Yalbadaoth was trying to do only weeks earlier. The God of Control was trying to take away peoples’ agency and desires because, in his view, they were only causing people pain; Maruki is changing reality for that very same removal of pain. It’s a more articulate version of the themes of the Yalbadaoth arc. Maruki’s arc is so much better largely because we’ve actually spent the entire game learning about Maruki in small doses and truly gotten to know him as a character. We know his backstory, we know the world he believes in, and we’ve <em>seen</em> him try to bring that about. He was never telling the full truth, much like Yalbadaoth, but unlike him, Maruki was being <em>emotionally</em> honest; the person that Maruki was presenting was the person he really is. It’s through this that we can see how a kindhearted person can view this incredible distortion of reality. Even when you meet him in his palace and approach him as an antagonist, the game never tries to pull the rug from under you; this is the same guy you met before, and that kindheartedness was never an act. He really wants to help people.</p><p>Through his entire arc, Maruki never wavers in his convictions. He asks Joker his opinion, but regardless of Joker’s answer, Maruki remains firm. He doesn’t want to fight Joker, but repeatedly stands his ground even when faced with confrontation. If Joker disagrees with him, wants to return to the real world, Maruki understands. He’s not disappointed or angry, and in a way I almost feel as though he thinks there’s a chance that Joker may be right; but if that’s so, it’s up to fate, and whoever emerges the victor is the one whose reality deserves to stand tall.</p><p>This talk of ‘final fight’ implies a clear choice: Joker is supposed to fight for peoples’ agency, their right not to be deceived. But <em>Royal</em> also comes with another ending that’s valid in its own way, complete with a credits roll, where Joker accepts Maruki’s reality and the Phantom Thieves live happily ever after. In comparison to the teary drawn-out goodbyes of the regular ending, there’s a definite appeal to this ending. But it also ensures that a piece of the Phantom Thieves is gone forever, and their fates are entirely drawn by one man who’s essentially figured himself a god. It’s not a clear decision, which is something that the main game sorely lacked. Even though <em>Royal</em> presents a ‘right’ decision, it’s not the act of making said decision that feels good; it’s the undercurrent of doubt that lingers through that choice, a thought that never goes away, wondering if you really did the right thing.</p><p>This decision is guided largely on two fronts, by two people who are <em>not</em> Phantom Thieves. The first of them is Akechi, a character that I had problems with in the main game that received an overhaul in <em>Royal</em>. Akechi was an ill-defined character whose, to me, half-baked philosophies were never properly reconciled with the person he <em>truly</em> was, hidden behind a really stupid twist and many layers of deceipt. To my understanding, I wasn’t the only person who had problems with Akechi — aside from the people who love him as their little pancake boy, which I honestly get (something about Robbie Daymond’s voice can be very soothing) — and so <em>Royal</em> set out to try and fix the character a bit. The big difference in the main game is that he has a whole new set of confidant conversations that are in line with how regular confidants work in the game, not based on predefined moments like in the original game.</p><p>These conversations don’t fix the problems with Akechi — nothing can fix how fucking awful that twist is on a basic plot level alone. But they do provide some more context for Akechi as a person, and his confidant is one of the few that really feels like he’s developing a relationship with Joker. As a literal mirror image of sorts, Akechi is continually fascinated by all the ways in which Joker and Akechi — true to their own justice, shunned by the world — are the same, while also being so completely different. Akechi surely feels some guilt over being an assassin full of vengeance, but he’s always rationalized it based on the way the world treated him. But when he sees someone like Joker, who hasn’t had an easy go of it himself, twist those to more evidently virtuous ends, it twists something inside him. Eventually, before the big plot twist, Akechi takes Joker into Mementos and has a real ‘mask off’ (ha!) moment, emotionally, where he admits he sees Joker as a bitter rival, that he actually <em>hates</em> Joker. It doesn’t change the badness of the upcoming twist, but we at least see some context for how he sees Joker and how he views the world.</p><p>Which brings us to Maruki’s arc. In Maruki’s reality, Akechi never died; he lived to take Joker’s place in jail after the fallout with Yalbadaoth, and Maruki brought him back as fulfilment of <em>Joker’s</em> wish. (Though Joker doesn’t know this; Akechi only has a slight inkling.) Akechi, suddenly released from prison without explanation, is also very wary of this new reality, and teams up with Joker to see what’s going on. With nothing left to hide from Joker, this is the first time you get to see Akechi’s true self, who turned out to be a character I found really fascinating.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*TGnh58XPqqoXRbk4U2TIUg.png" /><figcaption>The stripes are working against the edgelord vibes, pancake boy.</figcaption></figure><p>I mean, yes, when he puts on his black mask and starts ranting and raving about how much he wants to tear Shadows from limb to limb, uh, the edgelord stuff is pretty goofy. But how he reconciles his rage and his detective identity in real life is really interesting. By now, Akechi’s been through a lot of shit, and technically he’s not even supposed to exist. Even before the events of the game he had a lot of unresolved shit that festered into every fibre of his being, and his grand scheme resulting in a death that got undone has to fuck you up. What’s left sometimes barely feels human, and he’s at a point where it seems like he doesn’t see the point in resolving loose ends. He doesn’t ever really address the events prior to his resurrection, and I don’t think he really wants to. And I’m sure that once he his existence was contingent on Maruki’s world, he only saw his existence as temporary anyway; why bother?</p><p>Unless, of course, he were to remain in Maruki’s world. But he has no interest in that, because more than anything else, he <em>hates</em> being controlled. He hated how he and his mom were powerless after being discarded by Shido, and he masterminded a whole scheme to enact revenge on his father that was actually working extremely well until he started talking about fucking pancakes. His detective identity — which, as it turns out, <em>isn’t</em> a crock of shit, and he actually does have some skills — is based entirely around being able to find the truth, to see the reality behind the facade. To have his entire existence controlled by someone else once again is something he could never stand. Maruki intends on blending the facade and the reality until they’re one and the same, without the explicit consent of the people it impacts, and Akechi can’t stand for that.</p><p>So we know Akechi’s perspective. The opposing viewpoint is one we get through a great new character, Kasumi Yoshizawa. She is introduced early in the game as an honors student and a talented gymnast who receives special treatment from the school based on her good performances. She befriends Joker after he shoos away a creepy dude, and stays largely outside the Phantom Thieves’ circle (a necessary consequence of being a new character in an existing story) while occasionally hanging out with Joker. This relationship is one of the most purely social in the game for a long time, as she doesn’t join as a party member and she doesn’t have any problems to solve, at least not in Mementos. She gets a lot of story beats largely separated from everything else, and because of that it felt to me like the relationship she and Joker share is very different from any other. Which I think is okay, because she’s a very likeable character! Kasumi is very earnest and friendly, and her commitment to gymnastics seems entirely like a personal goal despite many external pressures to succeed. But she does have trouble navigating those internal and external motivations, which is where Joker’s — the player’s — guidance comes into play; so much so that she feels the need to call him senpai. (It’s not really a weird thing, though, and she shows an abundance of respect to just about everyone.) This relationship comes to a head shortly before Sae’s palace, when there’s a school dance and she insists on dancing with Joker in a full anime FMV; in that moment, the game seems like it’s <em>really</em> pushing for the player to think about a romance with Kasumi. (Which means it’s too bad you can’t lock in a relationship with her until well after the chance for many romantic scenes.)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8S3PFkOLCawK0pGAnZTq6A.png" /><figcaption>Look at her go!</figcaption></figure><p>Eventually, Kasumi stumbles into an unknown palace — which we later find out is Maruki’s palace — and Joker chases after her right as she awakens to her Persona, fueled by frustration at the school’s treatment of her middling gymnastics performances. Joker and Morgana offer her a place with the Phantom Thieves (who, in an earlier conversation with Joker and Akechi, she was concerned people would rely on too much, which seems like a very teenager-y thing to say); she declines, saying she wanted to focus on her gymnastics for the time being. She does, however, sneak into Sae’s palace and save Joker’s ass, and offers to join the Phantom Thieves; only to be turned down, because with Shido and Yaldabaoth, shit was getting real and she didn’t have the same personal stakes in it that the rest of the gang did. The timing is never right — largely, of course, because the game needs Kasumi to be sidelined until Maruki’s arc, but it works to develop her as a character that doesn’t quite fit in with this band of misfits, even though they all like her very much.</p><p>In the new year, after Yalbadaoth is defeated, she joins Joker for an excursion to a shrine and runs into the rest of the Phantom Thieves in their new reality. Even Kasumi, who doesn’t know them as well as Joker does, realizes that something is off. She joins Akechi and Joker in Maruki’s palace, where she learns a terrible truth about herself. Kasumi had mentioned to Joker before that she had a sister that died, but didn’t elaborate on it much. In Maruki’s palace, we see the moments of her sister’s death; only, we discover that the sister <em>is </em>Kasumi. The person we know as Kasumi is actually her twin sister Sumire. Sumire is very different from the eager, joyous Kasumi we know; Sumire was actually very quiet and reserved, and though she was every bit as committed to gymnastics as Kasumi, she could never quite achieve the same results. Though Kasumi (and, I think, their parents) were always supportive of Sumire, this didn’t stop jealousy and a lack of self-confidence from developing. Upset at these feelings while talking to Kasumi, Sumire ran out into the middle of the road, and as Kasumi chased her, she was hit by a car and died. Mixed with her existing feelings, Sumire fell into a borderline catatonic state. Eventually she talked to Maruki in a counselling session, and wished that she could be more like her sister. So Maruki granted her wish, made her <em>become</em> Kasumi, and suddenly all the pain was gone, and she was the superstar she always dreamed of being — not just the gymnast who could get results, but also the sister she admired and envied.</p><p>When Sumire is reminded of this truth, all the pain she felt comes back to her. She can’t take it. Maruki says he can make her forget the pain once again, and she has no doubts about what she wants to do: she wants to remain Kasumi instead of suffering as Sumire. Akechi, of course, protests, but it’s up to Joker; if you stand against Maruki, then Sumire actually summons her Persona to fight you. The pain in her heart grows even deeper as she does this, unable to understand why Joker, her senpai, would betray her wishes like this, would let her pain survive. It’s heartbreaking, and for a second it seems that Maruki and Sumire’s combined powers might be too much for Joker and Akechi. This when the rest of the Phantom Thieves come to save the day. Joker had spent the past week nudging each of them in the direction of realizing that the reality they live in isn’t a real one, and collectively they suddenly break out of it; confused, but resolute that they wanted to choose their own fates. They chase after Joker and save the day, bringing Sumire back to safety.</p><p>At this point, Sumire is out of options; she’s forced to be Sumire, to remember Kasumi’s death. And she struggles through this, but once again relies on Joker to help her. She remembers all the things that Kasumi was great at, but she also remembers the things that <em>Sumire</em> was great at. She eventually not only forgives Joker for forcing her from Maruki’s reality, but thanks him. By the end of their confidant, she out-and-out tells Joker she loves him, the only confidant who has the guts not to beat around the bush about their feelings. (At this point, how could you say no? I’d already hooked up with Makoto, but then she had to go and say she was gonna be a fuckin’ cop. So I was ready to dump her for Sumire.) By the end, Sumire learns to be the best of her old self and Kasumi, being a better person than either of them ever were. It will forever be tragic that Kasumi could never grow like that herself, and you get the sense that Sumire’s ideal version of Kasumi may never truly go away. But Sumire is able to move on, be herself, have grown and learned on her own terms.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5xERoOnu199movAypuhB_w.png" /><figcaption>Sumire and Kasumi, now one and the same.</figcaption></figure><p>So although Joker gets pulled in two directions, suggests that Maruki’s world is a viable alternative, the one where people get to choose themselves is shown to be the best. Even the rest of the Phantom Thieves, ripped from their ideal worlds, each get a scene with Joker where they kick themselves for having betrayed Joker. They said they would always be there for Joker, and they weren’t; they let themselves be whisked away into a fantasyland, leaving Joker in the dust. And they’re grateful for letting Joker bring them back, let them be themselves once again. You also get some of the game’s darkest Phan-Site requests during this period from people that Maruki presumably hasn’t yet reached with his powers. One kid asks for the Phantom Thieves to kill him, because he’s afraid that his festering hatred for his sister will end in him hurting her; another is from a child whose mother is so deep in depression that she’s not even providing meals for herself or her child. Maruki changed a lot, alarmingly fast, and it’s possible that his reach simply didn’t extend to them yet; it’s also possible that his changes caused these problems, or that they’re simply outside of his grasp. We simply don’t know, and depending on your perspective, this may cast some doubts on his methods.</p><p>Yet ultimately, there’s never a single moment where you’re left to conclude that, without a doubt, Maruki’s actions are wrong. Even after you’ve made it to the end of the Palace, with a day before the deadline to steal his heart, Maruki still offers the player one more chance to turn around and let Maruki realize his world, to remove everyone’s pain. Even as deep in as you are, in that moment it still feels like a valid option. Of course, as a <em>player</em>, there’s no point turning back now, and if you weren’t confident about where the rest of the story lies, you surely are by this point. But those doubts linger even as you give Maruki his calling card and head for one final confrontation.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*41BSi1UHZc_Yc16UZ8lglw.png" /><figcaption>Maruki’s lab.</figcaption></figure><p>That confrontation is a tough one. Every time you think you’ve defeated Maruki, that you think he’s finally accepted that fate has decreed the Phantom Thieves the winners, he keeps coming back even stronger. The first fight, against a Persona that’s a literal god from the Lovecraft mythos, is a <em>long</em> fight that takes away different abilities each turn, and requires proper planning every turn to take out a new set of tentacles so the scales don’t tip away from you. You defeat that, and he fuses with his Persona to become something incredibly powerful, seemingly invincible. But Futaba pinpoints his weakness, which becomes exposed as every Phantom Thief staves off his attack to allow for Joker to jump up for the final blow. (The game leaves that gunshot for the player to press, letting you be the one to finally end your journey.) Yet even <em>then</em>, as the cognitive world collapses, Maruki doesn’t give up. He goes for one final battle with Joker as the cognitive world collapses and both of them have lost their Personas, both of them weary and beaten, fighting each other only with their fists. Joker wins, of course, and Maruki almost falls into the abyss. Yet Joker saves him, and Morgana (who pays off an earlier joke by turning into a helicopter) escorts them all safely out.</p><p>This ending is startling, because even though I knew Maruki’s convictions were strong, I didn’t expect they were <em>that</em> strong. Maruki’s calm demeanour even while fighting the Phantom Thieves suggested to me that he would eventually be willing to accept defeat. But he drives things to the bitter end, to nearly being wiped from all of existence, before he’s willing to let his dream die, and it’s a conviction that’s almost a little scary. He <em>really</em> believed in his vision to a degree that no other character in the game did. The Phantom Thieves often had asinine doubts creep in, the villains never had any true beliefs, and even Yaldabaoth seemed more concerned with exerting his power than executing a unified vision for the world. Maruki really cared, and as we went through his palace learning about his history — the girlfriend that he saved with his powers at the cost of his relationship with her, the way he pulled Sumire out of her darkest hour — it reinforced everything positive we’d ever known about him. No twist, no sense that he lost his path like a comic book villain. This was the path he <em>always</em> wanted to go down. And it feels terrible to stop him.</p><p>But you do, and life goes on. The original ending of <em>Persona 5</em> carries on, Joker gets to go on dates, and eventually everyone moves on with their lives, giving each other tearful goodbyes along the way. Unfortunately, we don’t get much from the three characters at the centre of <em>Royal</em>. Sumire doesn’t actually show up in the section where you say goodbye to everyone, and she only gets a passing comment about “keeping your head up” as if they were only casual acquaintances. (Very weird, given how hard it felt like they were pushing the relationship before that. At least Joker’s dates with her are cute.) Maruki becomes a taxi driver who helps Joker escape the feds on his way home, doling out some advice about being willing to start over, like he’s doing now; yet I’d like to know more. And Akechi disappears from existence, just as Maruki said he would, though the game does give a brief (meaningless) tease at the end where we see someone in Akechi’s outfit pass by as Joker looks out the window, simultaneously seeing his Phantom Thief outfit in his reflection. I wish we’d gotten a proper epilogue for those three characters, to see how their experiences changed them the way we got to see it for the rest of the Phantom Thieves, and it stings even more knowing that they don’t even show up in <em>Persona 5 Strikers</em>, which picks up from the original game’s continuity. Not that I expect much narratively from <em>Strikers</em>, being developed largely by a separate team. But the underwhelming goodbye would hurt a little less if I knew that I could still hang out with them a bit longer! (Though at the same time, I hope they don’t try to milk <em>Persona 5</em> any further; unless we get a full-fledged sequel, Atlus is coming real close to the point of over-saturation between all their spinoffs and crossovers.)</p><p>Still; I acknowledge that this is ultimately an expansion of a longer game that they needed to wrap up, and the goodbyes you get to say to everyone else count for quite a bit. I love what P-Studio did with <em>Royal</em>, and I appreciate that it was no small undertaking to rework a massive, popular, acclaimed game and have it come out the other side a significantly better experience. Admittedly, I probably wouldn’t recommend it unless you’re already hankering to replay the original game; it’s just too mammoth to make anything new worth it. But for my first experience with the game, I found <em>Royal</em> to be immensely rewarding.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=250d1aeed042" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why does nobody want change?: A critique of Persona 5]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@azdiff/why-does-nobody-want-change-a-critique-of-persona-5-8ab5f99755b4?source=rss-8424cf63b043------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8ab5f99755b4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[video-game-review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[persona-5]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Azdiff]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 22 Feb 2022 22:17:54 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-04-17T20:03:57.432Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>“Why does nobody want change?”: Persona 5</h3><figure><img alt="The Phantom Thieves." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5nv3HRHqUa-WLabwLoKLwQ.png" /><figcaption>The gang’s all here.</figcaption></figure><p><em>Note: This contains spoilers for </em>Persona 5<em>, but not for </em>Persona 5 Royal<em>. I’ll post some thoughts on </em>Royal <em>another time.</em></p><p><em>Persona 5 </em>is both way too long and the perfect length.</p><p>Yeah, let’s start there. Because this is the game that I most often get cited as an example of a game that grown folk with jobs don’t have <em>time</em> for. It’s not the only long, popular game, of course — I sunk more hours into <em>The Witcher 3</em> and <em>Dragon Quest XI</em> — but it’s one that can feel a lot longer because you don’t have any control over how long it is. Whether you’re the type of player who wants to explore every inch of the game or just wants to play through the story, your playthrough of <em>Persona 5</em> is still going to cover the same number of in-game days. It’s a game where all of the sidequests are effectively a part of the main story, and when you want to get to the end, having it constantly so far away can feel exhausting. (Even for me, it was making my head explode, having these thoughts for a review germinating in my brain for two and a half months before I could finally sit down and confidently write something up.) Some palaces can seem like they go on forever, and there’s some fat in the cutscenes that could’ve been trimmed. The puzzles in the palaces are rarely very interesting — a lot of graph theory — and it feels like they don’t have much new to show you after the first few. The battle system, which altogether is very good and reveals quite a bit of depth, nevertheless starts to feel stale in the middle part of the game, when you’ve learned some good strategies but you haven’t gotten the broken skills that open up new ways to play the game. Most of the boss fights are extremely long, which are sometimes more interesting for their length but can also feel excruciating at times. (The half hour timer during the Okumura fight felt like a taunt.) Some of these things might not feel as bad in a shorter game, but in a game of this length they can really drag at times. By 75 hours, I was a little burnt out, especially when I knew there were still another 50 to go.</p><p>Yet I also can’t really imagine the game any other way, because the game derives all its power from its length. I felt hollow finishing this game, more than the normal feeling you get when finishing a game of this size. Because there were no breaks, no detours that you might get exploring an open world game or most other JRPGs; every single day in the game was a steady onward march towards March 20th, the final day of the game’s calendar when the Phantom Thieves finally go their separate ways. Every character arc had been steadily building for that entire in-game year, every plot point moving towards its final resolution, and on that day it just… Ends. You don’t have any post-game to ease you out of things, no lingering sidequests you can wrap up. That’s it, the game’s over, 125 hours of your life, seemingly countless after-work sessions finally reaching their conclusion. (The game makes a big deal out of it, too, letting you give a drawn-out goodbye to every single character you met along the way.) It hits differently from a boundless world like <em>Xenoblade Chronicles</em> where you can choose how much time you want to invest in exploration and sidequests, and it also hits differently from a similarly-contained but much shorter RPG like <em>Final Fantasy IX</em>. The game forces the max length of the former, while keeping the tighter structure of the latter; it’s a sweetspot that works <em>because</em> you’ve invested so much time in the game and its characters.</p><p>That’s not nothing — actually, it counts for a lot. I have a lot of problems with how the game approaches its loftier themes and overarching plot, but in reality a significant portion of the game is just hanging out with characters and learning about them; and these are characters I really enjoyed spending time with over such a long period of time. Their arcs of personal growth are often convincing, and because they’re usually doled out in small portions across long stretches of the game, it does start to feel like you’re watching them slowly reflect; that you <em>are</em> helping them grow, even if it’s just by selecting the option you think they want to hear. It feels like you’ve made a lot of friends, gotten to understand the world just a little bit better. It even helps Joker out; most of the perks that you get from levelling your confidants are not just window dressing, but actually very helpful within palaces. It suggests that Joker himself is growing in many ways, and there are mechanics built around that as well, as you have to build Joker’s social stats in order to be able to further develop his relationships while also gaining access to better tools. I really like how just about anything you can do in the game gives you some kind of material benefit, with an assertion that just about <em>anything</em> can help you improve yourself if you approach it in the right way. Publicly eating an oversized burger can make you braver; watching a rom-com with a friend can make you more charming; cleaning up the café can make you kinder. No, these activities won’t actually make you a better person, but at the same time it feels kind of encouraging to <em>try</em> to be more well-rounded.</p><p>To call these segments of the game a social sim is, to me, to give the game too much credit. There’s inevitably only so much socializing you can do with an effectively silent protagonist like Joker. Most of the relationships he forms with other characters in the game ultimately feel hollow because he himself is not a real character, nor is he even someone the player can insert themselves into — in fact, the game actively discourages that. In conversations, you’re rewarded by choosing what you think the person you’re talking to would want to hear the most, not what Joker might say. (Which I think the game is fully aware of, and they even nod to this during a puzzle in the <em>Royal</em> palace.) He becomes nothing more than a sounding board for the other characters, a conduit who doesn’t actually have emotions of its own, thereby breaking any attempt at real connection between the player <em>or</em> Joker and the rest of the cast. Every time someone says their life was changed by Joker’s worldview (or God forbid, that they <em>love</em> Joker, and boy do the girls love Joker), I can’t help but think… What worldview?</p><p>Yet ultimately, I didn’t really care about that, because really, the focus was on the characters themselves. Though each confidant concludes with the character profusely thanking Joker for changing their life, the entire journey before that wasn’t <em>about</em> Joker changing their life; it was simply about their life being changed, and usually it’s the character themselves making the changes. All Joker — or, I suppose, the player — is doing is giving them a nudge in the right direction. Ultimately Ann made her own decisions on how to handle her modeling career and her relationship with Shiho, just as Yusuke found his own path as an artist, both commercially and artistically. The writers were also very deft in ensuring that these confidant stories — which are technically optional — don’t interfere with the main story on any level. The characters grow, yes, but the fundamental core of who they are never really changes; they’re just a better <em>version</em> of that person. This way, the main story can continue along with those same characters regardless. (Contrast this with <em>Fire Emblem: Three Houses</em>, which has the characters change so drastically through support conversations that the main story can only accompany the dumbest, most basic characteristics of your team.)</p><p>That story, in a broad sense, also works because of how those characters work. The game’s story was inspired by the adventure of picaresque fiction, which is clear even when you ignore the Personas named after Zorro and Milady. Again, I have my problems with the finer details of the story, but the sense of adventure throughout — sweeping through diverse palace environments, fighting wild and weird monsters, keeping up a roguish attitude the whole time — is sublime, and the game works overtime to make sure those pleasures are in abundance. The game’s sense of style is maintained through even elements as basic as its menus, and so many of the game’s best moments come repeatedly like clockwork: a character awakening to their Persona into a battle scored by “Will Power” (one of the game’s best, most triumphant rock tracks); tearing through the palace at maximum security while the urgent-yet-suave funk of “Life Will Change” always feels impossibly cool; knocking out all of the enemies to hold them up and perform an All-Out Attack; performing one of the Showtime team attacks added to <em>Royal</em>. The game is just so effortlessly cool, which is <em>especially</em> impressive for a JRPG, which can too often feel dorky in their fantasy settings and rigid combat systems.</p><figure><img alt="Makoto awakens to her Persona, which is a fucking motorcycle!" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*qPkxeKp2IdPPV-xKifbA7A.png" /><figcaption>Every Persona awakening is so damned cool!</figcaption></figure><p>But with all that out of the way: yes, the game does suffer for its length. A lot of the problems I mentioned off-handedly come from the game’s sprawl. Ideas that crop up early on are rarely followed up on in a meaningful way as the story changes to make way for new ones, leaving the impression of a game that’s not as focused or committed to its ideals as it’d like you to believe. For example: one recurring idea in the story, essentially, is that the Phantom Thieves are operating in uncharted territory, using methods for which the underlying ethics aren’t very clear; and this is muddied by the fact that the people doing this are teenagers who are still growing, who barely understand themselves, much less the world. Yet this naivete is precisely what gives them the perspective to take on such lofty crimes.</p><p>On its face, this is a great premise. It provides lots of opportunities for these kids to learn and grow while still asserting themselves in the face of an often oppressive world. Yet it often feels as though the game lets them off the hook a little too easily, offering little to suggest that they <em>may</em> not be doing everything right. Almost everyone trying to keep them down is either a villain or horribly misguided, and any doubts that crop up within the team are shot down immediately by a positive affirmation from Morgana or Ryuji (or often the player themselves, who get roped into making Joker band everyone together under his leadership). The Phantom Thieves assuredly <em>do</em> make mistakes along the way, and they see the horrible things that the villains they fight do; yet I’m not always convinced they’ve learned their lesson.</p><p>The only real, consistent ideological opposition that the Phantom Thieves ever run into comes from Goro Akechi. Akechi is introduced as a character with a firm commitment to justice, one which seems more resolute and convincing than many of the game’s supposed other seekers of justice like Sae. He opposes the Phantom Thieves, believing that their insistence on following their own rules, their own justice, is something that cannot go unchecked. (He is essentially the Ganimard to Joker’s Arsène Lupin, to use the game’s own literary references.) There’s truth to those statements, an idea well worth exploring. As a high schooler himself, his reviews are as unrefined as the Phantom Thieves; admirable, but rough around the edges. His constant presence is a reminder that the Phantom Thieves are not an unquestioned force for good.</p><p>Yet the rest of the game doesn’t really support that. Each palace that the Phantom Thieves go into showcase the cognition of a person whose perception of the world has become so undeniably fucked up that they don’t even see it as the same reality everyone else does. We have a clear sign that something is Not Right, that it needs to be changed. Even Futaba’s and Sae’s palaces — stemming from people that everyone agrees aren’t inherently bad — still represent a worldview that isn’t healthy for them or others, that clearly needs to be changed. The rest of them, well, they’re criminals, and if you had <em>any</em> doubts about that, the game makes it <em>extra</em> clear that they’re bad guys. Madarame stealing his artists’ work might seem like small potatoes; so if you have any doubts about it, well, they thrown in some light flavour text about him physically abusing his students (that is mentioned briefly once or twice and never again), and they let you know that one of his students killed themselves. Do you think that Medjed might have some legitimate points about your personal justice? Well, their idea of justice is to just leak random peoples’ bank information, so clearly <em>they</em> don’t know what they’re talking about. Past that, we’ve moved onto literal drug kingpins and murderers. No ambiguity allowed.</p><p>Once you’ve stolen their treasure, their distortions — rendered <em>incredibly</em> literally by viewing the people they oppress as slaves/tools/robots/what have you in ways that don’t even necessarily map to their real life views — fade away and you’re met with some kind of ‘pure’ self free from these distortions. There is some cosmic force out there telling you <em>exactly</em> what is wrong with these people, and you only have to do one simple task to make them into a Good Person. Easy as 1–2–3. Crucially, we don’t ever see what this pure self looks like, at least not for the outright villains; we merely get a tearful apology as they confess what they’ve done, and then they’re locked up never to be seen again. (That weird little scene in the depths of Mementos doesn’t count.) The entire process is rendered such that there’s no way you could <em>possibly</em> think that the Phantom Thieves aren’t just.</p><p>Because of this, any attempt from Akechi to cast doubts onto the Phantom Thieves never feels entirely convincing. (Well, that, and also bundled in is the fact that in practice he mostly seems like a TV celebrity that the police occasionally humour. And that Sae takes completely seriously, for some reason.) And of course, even <em>that</em> gets blown up in the game’s big twist, where he reveals that he’s actually a murder who’s been causing people to have mental shutdowns in the name of a corrupt politician. Not only <em>that</em>, but everything he’s done was in an effort to eventually use the reverse Uno card on said politician, who is actually the father who abandoned him as a bastard child. On every level, this twist fucking sucks. It reduces one of the game’s most potentially interesting characters into a simple, worn-out trope that revolves around one of the game’s many uninteresting villains. (Shido’s plot as the mastermind behind all of the game’s mishaps essentially boils down to “become rich fascist”, and as much as I hate to say it, even our real life aspirational fascists have a little more depth than that.) The scene where he and Shido tell each other the entire history of their relationship — deep into a 90-minute exposition dump with other tangentially related topics — is embarrassing to watch, two poorly mishandled characters giving out some of the most important plot details in the game to no one in particular. And from this point, the game doesn’t seem to know how to handle Akechi. His showdown with the Phantom Thieves in Shido’s palace mostly amounts to him yelling, and it’s hard to gauge what kind of a person he <em>really</em> is; unfortunately giving the Phantom Thieves an easy way out of any of their doubts. Not everything that Akechi said before the grand reveal is a complete lie — the new content in <em>Royal </em>does an admirable job of attempting to connect the two versions of Akechi — but it does take away almost all of the credibility he ever had, and is a complete damper to portraying the Phantom Thieves in a complex way.</p><figure><img alt="Akechi exposition dumps to someone who already knows the plot." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*oLJDCuXWcMmWX53VsbJSIw.png" /><figcaption>Yeah, I think Shido knows his own history, thanks.</figcaption></figure><p>Because the game’s perspective — not even the Phantom Thieves, but the game itself — isn’t willing to cast real doubts on its heroes. This is where I have to bring up — and I I know I’m only the eight millionth person to do so — how fucking <em>pervy</em> the game can get. It’s strong whiplash when the first villain of the game is a literal ephebophile trying to sleep with Ann — who implicitly <em>rapes</em> Shiho after beating her, which alongside her suicide attempt is the darkest moment in the whole game (setting a tone early on that I’m glad they didn’t try to keep up) — only to have Ann similarly blackmailed to pose nude for an artist who quickly becomes a <em>good guy who joins your team</em> without as much as an apology. The game plays this situation for laughs at Ann’s expense, and it’s something the game keeps doing over and over. Ryuji and Joker constantly ogle at Ann — when she awakens to her revealing leather catsuit Persona, in the hot and sweaty desert, all over Morgana’s creepy ‘Lady Ann’ pining — something that Ann is <em>clearly</em> not okay with, but this is never put into conversation with how she felt when Kamoshida was harassing her. It <em>could</em> be turned into good storytelling, much as Ann’s modeling career <em>could</em> be played as a way of her reclaiming her body, but instead the game opts for horny camera angles and plays it off as a ‘boys will be boys’ and ‘girls will be girls’ thing. It felt so weird to me because there really <em>was</em> unexpected pathos and nuance in the Kamoshida arc that just got thrown out the window.</p><p>There’s similar whiplash in the aftermath of Okumura’s palace, where the Phantom Thieves witness firsthand the kind of exploitation and abuses going on under Okumura’s supervision as CEO of a fast food company. Employees are underpaid and overworked, treated as disposable by executives. Yet mere days after seeing this happen, Haru spends her father’s money on an impromptu private trip to Disneyland (or wherever they called it in-game, I don’t care, Ryuji was wearing fucking Mickey Mouse ears) for the Phantom Thieves, renting out the entire fucking park on a whim, to the point where Haru even notes that the people working there couldn’t get the full fireworks show together on such short notice. At no point do any of the Phantom Thieves try to make a connection between the things they’ve just seen.</p><p>Yet it’s clear to me that the entire lens that the <em>game itself</em> views its events through is not willing to connect the larger systems at play. During their Disneyland trip, Okumura begins to make his heartfelt confession about his crimes, and during this confession he says something odd: that he alone was responsible for the abuses in his company. Implying that, if you simply remove him and his twisted desires from the root of the company, all of the problems will be solved. Now, anyone who has a basic understanding of these power structures know that the problems are rooted deep within how the company is organized, that these toxic workplaces can’t be solved by removing one person. And I think the game knows this, too; that line was so inelegant, so ugly, that it almost felt like the game was trying to cast away any doubts, because otherwise the entire premise of the game simply would not work.</p><figure><img alt="Okumura claims sole responsibility for worker abuses in his company." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*73SBQ-_b6SOH46b0JTwyvA.png" /><figcaption>That’s not how it works!</figcaption></figure><p>The Phantom Thieves are only ever able to change the heart of one person at a time. They find a Palace, they steal the treasure, and change that person’s heart. This necessitates a belief that, by changing the right person, you can affect hundreds of others; otherwise, the Phantom Thieves will have too small of an impact for the epic sweep that the game is shooting for to work. It is true that there’s a real impact in changing the hearts of their chosen targets; the students of Shujin Academy affected by Kamoshida and Kaneshiro would surely agree. But it obviously has its limits, because the real way in which the people of the world are oppressed in a broad sense come not through individuals but through the structures that keep them down. Changing Okumura’s heart (or, uh, killing him, I guess) won’t really change anything unless there’s a real commitment to changing the entire way the company operates, but this isn’t something the game is interested in following up on even through Haru’s confidant conversations, which are actually centred around <em>expanding</em> the company’s scope to include coffee shops.</p><p>Now, I’m a reasonable person. I don’t expect every story to align with my personal political ideology, and if the game simply wanted to enact vigilante justice against a bunch of assholes, you wouldn’t catch me complaining. But the Phantom Thieves really <em>do</em> want to change the world, and the model the game gives for that just isn’t rich enough. Ryuji is obsessed with the Phantom Thieves being famous worldwide, and is thrilled when they take a trip to Hawaii to find that even people in another country have heard of them. And Ann says she wants to leverage that level of fame to inspire people to have the courage to stand up for themselves, the way that she feels she didn’t stand up against Kamoshida. There is something admirable about this, and we can actually see this in action at least once with Sae, a person who has some power that lacks the wherewithal to use that power to fight against genuine injustice until her mind is changed by the Phantom Thieves. (With<em>out</em> them stealing her heart, which is a nice twist.) But way more often, we see characters who are left completely helpless in the face of the systems they’ve been put in front of. Hell, it’s even a central game mechanic; the deadline to change someone’s heart is always caused by some situation that the Phantom Thieves would otherwise be helpless against. Without their powers, Joker would have been expelled, sued, imprisoned, and murdered, and while these are extreme examples, we see them crop up all over the game, especially through individual requests in Mementos.</p><p>These Mementos requests, where you change the hearts of people who are less fucked up than those with palaces but are still kind fucked up, are split between random NPCs you’ll never meet and people with a direct relationship with one of your confidants. I don’t really care about the randoms, but the targets connected to your confidants propel some of the most effective stories in the game. For those, your scope is limited: you have one person that you want to help, one person that you’ve gotten to know as a friend, and you’re changing someone’s heart in an effort to help them and them only. If someone else benefits from it, great! But your focus is more personal, and it’s when these changes of heart connect with the game’s strong character-building that the Phantom Thieves’ actions start to feel truly meaningful. (I also think that this is why the Kamoshida arc might be the game’s best, because his actions directly impact three Phantom Thieves, and even some other victims like Shiho and Mishima are characters you get to know quite well.) If you can only affect one person at a time, well, <em>commit</em> to that, and maybe you can change things. But you also have to acknowledge that <em>you’re</em> helping them, and they’re in situations they don’t have power in. Yoshida stood up to the political system but was ultimately helpless; Iwai tried to break ties with the Yakuza but found his past coming back for him; Takemi tried to work around medical bureaucracy to save lives, but was taken down by the corruption within. Just because you took out one person, that doesn’t mean that these problems couldn’t crop up again — and that same person would still be helpless on their own.</p><p>Ultimately, the Phantom Thieves <em>do</em> try to change everyone’s heart. After changing the heart of Shido, the mastermind behind dozens of murders, we see a cutscene where his complicit underlings panic and try to figure out how they can scramble their way out of the situation. They’re still corrupt, looking out for themselves and no one else, and they ultimately succeed in keeping themselves free; even after Shido confesses on national TV, the Phantom Thieves are stunned to realize that the public reception is muted, because those in power are <em>still</em> in power and have successfully suppressed information enough to make this a non-issue for the general populace. (I don’t really find this turn of events very convincing, but I do appreciate the attempt.) And so, deciding that <em>everyone in Japan</em> needs to have their hearts changed, the Phantom Thieves venture into Mementos to destroy the Metaverse once and for all.</p><figure><img alt="“Victory against asingle criminal is meaningless… The true enemy is society itself.”" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*n55GtL0IZRN5JOHirq6Gng.jpeg" /><figcaption>We got there eventually. Sort of.</figcaption></figure><p>The events down in the depths of Mementos feel like an attempt to bring out something that the game <em>should</em> have been pursuing, but the way they do it so late it the game feels disconnected from everything that happened before. It’s an attempt at elevating the Phantom Thieves to a cosmic scope that works for plot reasons but isn’t really convincing on a thematic level; like it’s just there to explain why the Metaverse exists and why Joker, Akechi, and Morgana had their powers. Apparently, the god Yaldabaoth has been enacting the will of the people by draining them of desires, leaving them to a <em>Brave New World</em>-esque reality where they never have to think for themselves. Joker and Akechi’s powers are gifts from the gods that amount to a cosmic betting match, and whoever wins decides the fate of humanity. And so, as one does in a JRPG, the Phantom Thieves must Kill God. (Joker eventually does so by literally summoning Satan, by the way, which is incredibly badass.) This basically has nothing to do with the rest of the game, and is not applicable to real life in any sense the way that the preceding events could be. The concept of humanity desiring a middling existence devoid of any kind of real emotion (basically, that everyone is bluepilled) could be an interesting one, if that was something the game had been pursuing the whole time. And it does relate to the idea that the Phantom Thieves are pursuing their own idea of justice, that despite what the masses may think of them, they know what they <em>believe</em> to be true and will work to achieve those ends. But this conception of the masses doesn’t track with anything in the game prior, and stuck at the end here, it just seems kind of… Random? Am I missing something? Nothing materially changes after you kill God, and the public acts more or less the same before everything happened. You kill God, and, I dunno, everything’s right back where it started? So what was the point of all of that?</p><figure><img alt="“The act of making decisions is accompanied by nothing but pain.”" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*1_nT-x4MEcCkREPI0oIteg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Dude would not shut up about it.</figcaption></figure><p>The only real difference is that the Metaverse is gone (or is it…?), leading Sae to tell the Phantom Thieves that they’ll have to leave the world in the hands of the adults who hold power in the real world. That points to yet another thread that the game pursues. That word — ’adult’ — crops up over and over and over again through the course of the game; there’s a very clear delineation between kids and adults here. I’ve never heard the word so many times in my life, certainly not from teenagers, and part of me wonders if it is, to some degree, a quirk in the translation. (The original version of the game apparently had a spotty and occasionally homogenous translation that was cleaned up for <em>Royal</em>, which is the version I played. This feels like it might’ve been one of those things so central to an enormous body of text that it was impossible to rejig, though, especially considering the costs of revoicing those lines.) The game’s characters are always referring to “rotten adults”, even in situations where there’s more relevant identities at play. (The people who pin Wakaba’s death on Futaba are referred to as adults by both Futaba and even fellow adult Sojiro, and it seems like it would make more sense to refer to them by other roles.) There’s an implication that there’s something inherent about the nature of adulthood that stands in firm opposition to an implied purity of youth. This is well-trodden territory, especially in shonen manga and anime; so much so that the game seems to take that trope for granted, never really bothering to explain why adults are so much worse. The obvious guess is that they’ve been tarnished by the workings of society and the misdeeds of others — hence why you have to change their hearts — but that doesn’t tell the full story. After all, you change the hearts of other kids sometimes, and some of your confidants are adults.</p><p>It’s worth noting that almost all of the Phantom Thieves lack real parental figures; Ryuji and Ann are the only ones whose parents aren’t dead or absent, and even Ann mentions how her parents travel a lot and leave her on her own. This, to me, feels like an attempt to sidestep clarifying the exact nature of this youth vs. adult dichotomy. The ‘good’ adults — namely Sae after her heart’s been changed and Sojiro, who adopts Futaba, houses Joker, and becomes a father figure to the rest of the Phantom Thieves — can be presented as rare exceptions to the rule while the rest of the Phantom Thieves’ parents can be cherished as a faint outline of a memory. (Haru even reflects on her father with a degree of fondness.) So Sae’s insistence that they leave the world to the adults is… Well, it’s not all that promising. The structures haven’t materially changed, and the only adult whose heart that the Phantom Thieves changed that’s actually working to make a material difference in the world is Sae herself. (And technically, her heart changed all on its own!) One person isn’t gonna change the world.</p><p>But then, hey, these things take time. The adults may not change the world, but there’s still room for the Phantom Thieves and their cohorts to change the future. I’m not sold that they know how they’re gonna do that — Makoto saying that she was gonna become a fuckin’ cop the moment I locked Joker into a relationship with her was <em>incredibly</em> disappointing. But like I said: I spent 120 hours with these characters, and I came out the other side still liking them, still wanting to spend <em>more</em> time with them. I’d like to believe that they can do better than the people who nearly ruined their lives, and on my most optimistic days, I’d like to believe that we can do the same.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8ab5f99755b4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>