<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Benn Harvey-Walker on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Benn Harvey-Walker on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@bennhw?source=rss-68b1fb8dec36------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 09:30:49 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@bennhw/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[8 tips to help you be a more thoughtful gift-giver (Part 2)]]></title>
            <link>https://bennhw.medium.com/8-tips-for-thoughtful-gift-buying-part-2-c91496e0b305?source=rss-68b1fb8dec36------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c91496e0b305</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[gifting-tips]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[oneupmanship]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gift-psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[how-to-choose-gift]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[companionising]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Benn Harvey-Walker]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 09 Dec 2021 03:17:59 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-12-17T00:19:02.805Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong><em>If you find some of your gift choices aren’t hitting the mark, these tips might help you get back on track.</em></strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zjI1ekTrqNkPQTr9GE9_Zg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Image sourced from <a href="https://www.canstockphoto.com.au/">www.canstockphoto.com.au</a> / olenayemchuk</figcaption></figure><p>In Part 1 of this very short series about how to be a more thoughtful gift-giver, I explored four interesting psychological insights into gift-giving and how you can use them to improve your gift selections for the people you care about.</p><p>If you’ve already read it, you’ll recall we explored the <em>averaging effect</em>, how multiple gifts can be a bad idea, how some gifts can be bad for anxious people, and how gift <em>practicality</em> is often underrated. (If you haven’t read it yet, you can find <em>Part 1</em> <a href="https://bennhw.medium.com/8-tips-to-help-you-be-a-more-thoughtful-gift-giver-part-1-245e404e5bca?sk=7841949a38644cbd5b0be5aad23fc850">here</a>.)</p><p>Now, true to my word, here are the other four research gems I picked up while exploring the world of gift psychology.</p><p>Enjoy …</p><h3>Tip #5: Don’t let “one-upmanship” drive your gift choices</h3><p>Just how prevalent one-upmanship is in the gift-giving universe is hard to quantify, but suffice to say it’s a common enough occurrence for psychologists to want to study it.</p><p>And to quickly define “one-upmanship”, what we’re talking about is the rivalry between gift-givers where they try to outdo each other in terms of the value or ‘impressiveness’ of the gift or gifts they’ve chosen.</p><p>I’d speculate that this rivalry usually barely registers in our consciousness, but it almost certainly spills over into deliberate behaviour in some people.</p><p>A 2021 study<a href="#_ftn1"><strong>[1]</strong></a> by two researchers, Associate Professors Galek and Olivola from Carnegie Melon University, uncovered some interesting insights that back this up.</p><p>They demonstrated that when a gift-giver is aware of what other gifts are being purchased, some will become competitive, increasing their spend in an effort to outdo their rivals.</p><p>If you find yourself making gift-buying decisions that are more about ‘outdoing your rivals’ than they are about the gift recipient, guess what, one-upmanship is a thing for you.</p><p>But here’s the kicker, Galek and Olivola also demonstrated that gift-givers are often far more concerned about the relative value of the gift they give than the recipient ever is.</p><p>What that means is if your objective is to score more brownie points with someone by giving them a more elaborate and expensive gift than your ‘rivals’ have, your strategy probably isn’t going to work. (Of course, if your main objective is to annoy the people you’re competing with, you’re almost certainly on the right track.)</p><p>But bringing this back to the perspective of thoughtful gift buying, the good news is your gift doesn’t have to be more expensive than everyone else’s to be impactful. A truly thoughtful present will beat an expensive, thoughtless gift every day of the week (not that it should be a competition anyway).</p><h3>Tip #6: The ‘Wow Factor’ shouldn’t be your motivation</h3><p>This one is a bit counterintuitive.</p><p>Very often we choose a gift for a family member or friends because we hope it will surprise and delight them.</p><p>Totally normal right?</p><p>But here’s the thing, what may actually be driving your choice then and there is how much enjoyment <strong><em>you</em></strong> expect to get from the recipient’s<em> </em>reaction rather than how much pleasure the gift will actually deliver to the person who receives it.</p><p>The researchers who identified this behaviour, Adelle Yang from the University of Singapore and Oleg Urminsky from the University of Chicago, speculated that the emotional responses we anticipate from the person we’re giving a gift to could play a big role in our gift choice decisions<a href="#_ftn2"><strong>[2]</strong></a>.</p><p>Yang and Urminsky gave a name to the behaviour. It’s what they called the ‘smile-seeking hypothesis’ where they surmised <em>“… people […] gravitate towards the gifts that they anticipate will elicit the most enthusiastic emotional responses, rather than those that the recipients themselves would prefer or would derive the most satisfaction from.”</em></p><p>The message here is: If your main motivation for choosing a particular gift for someone is that you think it will generate a big display of emotion, you need to ask yourself: “Who is this gift really for? Me or them?”</p><h3>Tip #7: Be careful not to over-personalise a gift</h3><p>First of all, let’s define what I mean by a ‘personalised’ gift.</p><p>No, I’m not talking about having the gift recipient’s name engraved on a pen or giving someone monogramed handkerchiefs. I’m talking more nuance than that.</p><p>What I’m referring to is the kind of item or experience that the person would normally only choose for themselves because the qualities or functionality they prefer in that item or experience are very personal to them.</p><p>The main problem with highly personalised gifts is they are not as versatile as the recipient might need them to be, especially if they can’t be readily changed or adapted to suit the recipient’s peculiar wants or needs.</p><p>A wallet is a good example.</p><p>Should you really be making that kind of fashion (as well as practical) choice on someone else’s behalf — even if you know them well? A wallet can make a real statement about the user, and its’ preferred functionality can also be very personal.</p><p>Should you really be making choices about how many card slots there are, where and how personal identification is displayed (if at all) and how cash is contained, alongside things like colour, material and style — without consultation?</p><p>I’d say no, particularly if the person you’re buying for is old enough and has enough life experience to form their own opinions about such things.</p><p>If you know the person you’re buying for has a need for a new ‘personal’ item, rather than try and choose it for them, a better idea might be to give a gift voucher to an appropriate retailer or on-line vendor. Or if you don’t want to do that, ask the person what they want specifically, and get them exactly that.</p><p>Always err on the side of caution when it comes to personalised gifts, and don’t let your ego get in the way if you don’t know exactly what the person you’re buying for wants.</p><p>Like it or not, it’s not really your choice to make when it comes to very personal things for other people.</p><h3>Tip #8: Giving and receiving at the same time can be a good thing</h3><p>This curious bit of research that comes out of the University of Wisconsin-Madison and the University of Toronto, Scarborough<a href="#_ftn3"><strong>[3]</strong></a>. I say curious because it seems to run contrary to the notion of <em>social projection bias</em>.</p><p>To quickly explain, <em>social projection bias</em> is the assumption held, often by very self-confident people, that just because they value something, everyone around them will too. That is, they project their values onto other people.</p><p>This is not normally regarded as being particularly healthy.</p><p>Yet, in certain circumstances, it would seem that your own positive experience with an item can add to the perceived value of that thing.</p><p>A 2017 study, conducted by Professors Evan Polman and Sam Maglio, found that gift recipients were more favourably disposed towards a gift that the giver also got for themselves.</p><p>The professors termed the phenomenon “companionising”.</p><p>It appears that a gift recipient will feel closer to the gift giver when the giver likes the gift enough to want one for themselves as well. Presumably it’s a form of endorsement and an expression of confidence in the value of the gift?</p><p>The original research was inspired by the idea of friendship bracelets, but the researchers report that the <em>companionising</em> affect works with people who aren’t close friends or family too.</p><p>From my perspective, I’d use this strategy very carefully and sparingly.</p><p>Whether or not you value an item or experience should not be used as the sole reason for choosing that item or experience as a gift for another person. Doing so takes no account of the other person’s wants, needs and preferences.</p><p>If, however, you find yourself thinking; “That’s a perfect gift for so and so. In fact, I like it so much I’ll get one for myself while I’m at it.”, then you might be on to something.</p><p>Putting the other person first is always the best strategy when choosing a gift.</p><p>That might sound painfully obvious. But it’s not always that easy to do.</p><p>.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref1"><strong>[1]</strong></a> <strong>Source:</strong> <a href="https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2021/02/210201115952.htm"><em>Don’t let pressure of one-upmanship dictate your gift selection</em></a>: Assoc. Prof. J. Galek and Assoc. Prof. C. Olivola, Carnegie Mellon University, 2021.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref2"><strong>[2]</strong></a> <strong>Source: </strong><a href="https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2014/12/141222111553.htm"><em>People pick gifts that will ‘wow’ rather than satisfy recipients</em></a>; A. Yang and O. Urminsky, 2014</p><p><a href="#_ftnref3"><strong>[3]</strong></a> <strong>Source:</strong> <a href="https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2017/07/170728111325.htm"><em>To pick a great gift, it’s better to give AND receive</em></a>; Prof. E. Polman and Prof. S. Maglio, 2017</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c91496e0b305" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[8 tips to help you be a more thoughtful gift-giver (Part 1)]]></title>
            <link>https://bennhw.medium.com/8-tips-to-help-you-be-a-more-thoughtful-gift-giver-part-1-245e404e5bca?source=rss-68b1fb8dec36------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/245e404e5bca</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[gift-guide]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[averaging-effect]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gift-giving]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gift-psychology]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Benn Harvey-Walker]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 01 Dec 2021 04:42:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-12-01T05:01:13.954Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*RbZYyED-j3VMtZvrPFWVKQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Image purchased from: <a href="https://www.canstockphoto.com.au/">https://www.canstockphoto.com.au</a>/Melpomene</figcaption></figure><p>Heads up, if you’re hoping I’m about to make your life a whole lot easier with a bunch of ‘life hacks’, that’s sort of where I’m going, but not quite.</p><p>What I do have for you is a small collection of gift-related, psychology ‘stuff’ I hope you’ll find as interesting and useful as I did.</p><p>You see, right now I’m in process of writing a book about the art of choosing the right gift for people you care about. And as I’ve been researching the subject I’ve turned up a whole host of research gems that reveal some interesting quirks of human nature.</p><p>Given the book is a ways away from being finished, in the meantime I thought I’d share some of these gems with you because, even on their own, they will help you make <em>better</em> gifting choices. Choices that will help you enhance your relationship with the people you care about.</p><p>And on top of that, Tips #1, #2 and #4 could easily wind up saving you time and money as well — which is kinda nice.</p><p>By the way, spoiler alert. I’ve only presented four of the eight promised tips in this ‘Part 1’ of the article.</p><p>That’s because each of the insights I’ll walk you through here take a bit of explaining, and rather than have you go all TLDR on me, I’ve chunked the article down into two parts so it’s more digestible.</p><p>So, with that, let’s get started …</p><h3>Tip #1: Beware the ‘averaging effect’</h3><p>Here’s a question for you: When it comes to major gift-giving events like Christmas or birthdays, how often do you find yourself receiving little extra gifts that are pretty much pointless; things that you neither wanted nor have any particular use for?</p><p>I’m going to hazard a guess and say it probably happens a lot more often than you’d like.</p><p>I’m also going to go out on a limb and suggest you’ve not only been a ‘victim’ of this phenomenon, but you’ve probably also been a perpetrator yourself from time to time.</p><p>I certainly plead guilty to this one. I know only too well the dialogue that goes on in my own head, especially around Christmas time … “That’s not enough things for so and so. I’d better get something extra.”</p><p>So, I do. (Or at least I used to!)</p><p>When you think about it, it’s a bit weird.</p><p>Even when the main gift we’ve bought is a thoughtful one, for some reason we feel compelled to buy additional things.</p><p>It’s hard to say why we do it. Perhaps it’s because we want to create feelings of prosperity so we feel better about ourselves? Or maybe we want to create a more favourable impression with the person or people we’re buying for? After all, more is better, right?</p><p>Otherwise it might be because we feel a need to ‘balance things out’ — buying extra items so we wind up spending around about the same amount of money on each person on our shopping list?</p><p>Whatever the reason, the research says we might not be doing ourselves any favours by adding to the gift pile.</p><p>The problem is something called the <em>averaging effect</em>.</p><p>As much as we’d like to have the person we’re giving gifts to put all of their focus and appreciation on the ‘main event’ item and treat the other things as incidental, psychologists who’ve studied these interactions have determined it doesn’t work that way.</p><p>Rather than be thrilled by the main gift and largely ignore the rest, we tend to average out our feelings across all the gifts we’ve received.</p><p>In other words, the delight we feel about the really thoughtful gift is diluted by the relatively ‘thoughtless’ add-on gifts.</p><p>The message: Don’t buy extra knick-knack gifts to make up the numbers — especially when you’ve already found the perfect gift. All that does is increase the likelihood of everyone being that little bit less happy than they otherwise would be.</p><h3>Tip #2: One gift is better than multiples</h3><p>There is another reason why we’re sometimes inclined to buy multiple gifts for the same person, and that’s to hedge our bets.</p><p>This is more likely to happen when we don’t really know what the person we’re buying for might actually want. So, in an effort to spread the risk, we buy several items and hope that at least one does the trick.</p><p>The problem is, even if you get it right with one of the gifts, it won’t create the ‘delight’ you hoped for because of the <em>averaging effect</em> I mentioned in Tip #1.</p><p>Another downside of giving multiple gifts is you can set unreasonably high expectations.</p><p>Presenting someone with multiple gifts can create an expectation that, amongst that bounty, there will be something that’s truly wonderful. And when that expectation isn’t met, the disappointment is even greater.</p><p>It’s a bit like being gifted lottery tickets.</p><p>Get one ticket and your expectation of winning is probably going to be low. But with half a dozen tickets your expectations will be multiplied — even though the odds of winning are pretty much the same.</p><p>Instead of multiplying the enjoyment by giving a number of gifts, you’re probably just going to multiply the disappointment.</p><p>This is why one thoughtful gift is better than several, not-so-thoughtful ones. You avoid the averaging effect, and you don’t risk setting unrealistic expectations.</p><h3>Tip #3: Too much choice can be anxiety-inducing</h3><p>If you’ve ever considered buying a gift voucher for someone that will require them to choose from a menu of alternatives, especially within a range of products or experiences they’re not familiar with, you might want to rethink that. Especially if the person you’re buying for is prone to anxiety.</p><p>Let me give you an example.</p><p>Imagine walking into an ice cream parlour that’s fresh out of your go-to favourite flavours. You really, really want ice cream and there’s nowhere else to go, so now you have to choose from a list of flavours you’re not familiar with.</p><p>Not only might that make it difficult for you to make a decision in the first place, but what if it ends up with you not really liking what you picked?</p><p>All of that pent up anticipation could easily result in disappointment.</p><p>Now imagine it’s not your money you’re spending, but someone else’s. Not only that, but they’re right there with you eagerly waiting to hear how much you’re enjoying the ice cream they bought you.</p><p>Let’s crank up the pressure even more. What if you had to buy $50 worth of ice cream in that one purchase — and no takebacks?</p><p>All of a sudden the decision about what to choose becomes a whole lot riskier. We’re not talking just a few dollars that might be wasted. And on top of that, not only might you be disappointed, but you might also disappoint your ice cream benefactor.</p><p>This is what it’s like for people prone to anxiety. The risks associated with making a bad choice can even cause ‘paralysis by analysis’. That is, they become unable to make a decision because there are too many choices.</p><p>This is one of those instances where understanding the personality of the person you’re buying for can be very helpful in choosing the right gift.</p><p>It’s often quipped; “You can never have too much choice.” This is not true for people who get stressed easily. So, it’s best to avoid gifts that force them to make choices, especially among things unfamiliar to them.</p><h3>Tip #4: Practicality matters more than you’d think</h3><p>To put it bluntly, if a gift isn’t very practical for a someone to use, it isn’t a very good gift — no matter how much thought you put into it and how much money you spent on it.</p><p>When two gifts have essentially the same features, despite a perceived or real difference in quality, the one that is more practical to use will usually generate more positive feelings towards the giver than the less practical one<a href="#_ftn1">[1]</a>.</p><p>In other words, a lower quality gift that is practical will usually be considered more favourably than one that is of higher quality but is difficult to use.</p><p>An example given in one of the studies I read exploring this idea compared the difference between a gift voucher for a local, run-of-the-mill restaurant versus a gift voucher for a prestigious one that is relatively difficult or inconvenient to get to.</p><p>Whilst the gift to the higher quality restaurant might seem better, the impracticality of actually using the gift voucher detracts a lot from the experience, making the local experience relatively more enjoyable. In turn this can reflect more positively on the giver.</p><p>Another example might be the difference in practicality between, say, a simple stick-mixer versus a multi-function food processor.</p><p>The food processor might be able to deliver a lot more capability in terms of all the different things it can do, but its size, complexity and the ‘inconvenience’ of using and cleaning it might make it much less useful that a stick mixer that is easy to wash and can be kept in a handy drawer.</p><p>In other words, more ‘bells and whistles’ doesn’t necessarily make for a better gift.</p><h3>Stay tuned …</h3><p>And there you have the first four tips I promised.</p><p>They may not be what you’d call Earth-shattering, but I hope they’ve given you some useful strategies for choosing more thoughtful gifts for the people you care about.</p><p>Thoughtful gift giving isn’t about quantity, and it isn’t necessarily about quality either. What it is about is enhancing the life of the person you’re giving the gift to. Achieve that and you’re well on the way to building stronger relationships.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref1">[1]</a> <strong>Source:</strong> <a href="https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/0146167218784899"><em>The gift of psychological closeness: How feasible versus desirable reduces psychological distance to the giver</em></a><em>.</em> So Yon Rim et al., Personality and Psychology Bulletin, 2018</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=245e404e5bca" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[‘Average at best’ when it comes to wrapping presents?]]></title>
            <link>https://bennhw.medium.com/average-at-best-when-it-comes-to-wrapping-presents-4ed3e9400438?source=rss-68b1fb8dec36------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4ed3e9400438</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[gifts]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[wrapping]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[personal-growth]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gift-guide]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Benn Harvey-Walker]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 15 Nov 2021 02:04:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-11-15T02:27:31.213Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4><strong>Relax. You might be doing yourself a favour.</strong></h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*sofFpqf0H_yWZCPteteYKQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Image sourced from <a href="http://www.canstockphoto.com.au/gift-wrapping-made-of-ecologically-clean-1041217.html">www.canstockphoto.com.au/N</a>atika</figcaption></figure><p>If you’re one of those people who doesn’t particularly enjoy wrapping gifts, welcome to the club.</p><p>For a bunch of reasons I’m not a big fan of gift wrapping either, but whether I like it or not, and thanks to a whole lot of societal pressure<em>(1)</em>, I feel I’m pretty much obligated to wrap the presents I give to other people.</p><p>Of course, the glossy advertisements, perfect Instagram posts and store window displays set the bar is pretty high when it comes to what a gift-wrapped present <em>should</em> look like. All those matching colours, neat, crisp folds, and perfectly positioned ribbons and bows …</p><p>Seriously?</p><p>It’s not like I don’t have other stuff to do.</p><p>Of course, it’s fine if you have the skills and you’re a bit ‘crafty’ and like that kind of thing. Who am I to judge? You do you.</p><p>But for those of us with a distinct lack of patience and a low tolerance for waste, wrapping presents is a chore we could do without.</p><p>That said, I will admit I can wrap presents in a half-decent fashion when I have to. I’m a little obsessive when it comes to symmetry and neatness, so I have that on my side. But if that’s not you and your gifts always seem to wind up looking like they were wrapped by a disgruntled four-year-old who’d rather be finger painting, don’t despair. It really isn’t the end of the world.</p><h4>But don’t people like their presents nicely wrapped?</h4><p>The short answer is yes. Yes they do. But it’s not as mission critical as you might think — especially amongst family and friends.</p><p>Proponents of gift wrapping (in particular, those who sell gift wrapping supplies), often refer to a 1992 study by the Professor of Marketing at Southern Methodist University, Daniel Howard<em>(2)</em>.</p><p>In that study, Professor Howard explored how wrapping contributes to gift ‘approval’ by comparing wrapped with unwrapped gifts, and fancy wrapping<em>(3)</em> <em>vs</em> plain wrapping <em>vs</em> no wrapping.</p><p>Howard’s research showed that not only did gift recipients rate a gift more highly when it was wrapped as opposed to when wasn’t, but on top of that, the same gift with fancy wrapping rated higher than plain wrapping. (Both rating higher than no wrapping at all.)</p><p>In short, fancy wrapping: <em>Good</em>. Plain wrapping: <em>Better than none</em>.</p><p>Howard hypothesised that this is because people tend to relate nicely wrapped presents with happy events in their lives. He supposed the positive mood created by the presentation of a nicely wrapped gift may create a bias within the recipient that causes them to rate the gift more highly than if it was wrapped plainly.</p><p>So, doesn’t this suggest getting a bit fancy with your gift wrapping is the right thing to do?</p><p>Well, yes, Howard’s study does suggest that. But he’s not the only person who has researched this subject, and not only that, his research is now almost 30 years old.</p><p>A lot has changed in the world since 1992.</p><p>At the very least, Howard’s research predates mainstream concerns about waste, recycling, and climate change. And I think it’s fair to say that most people didn’t give much thought to the environmental cost of wrapping paper, ribbons, bows, microplastics and glitter back in 1992.</p><p>Things are a little different nowadays (gladly) … but that’s a subject for another day.</p><p>In the meantime, let’s look at some more current research into the psychology underpinning gift wrapping and gifting experiences.</p><h4>Are you setting an unrealistic expectation?</h4><p>Much more recently (in 2019), a study by Jessica Rixom, Erick Mas and Brett Rixom, published in the <em>Journal of Consumer Psychology(4)</em>, demonstrated that when it comes to gift wrapping, it’s not as clear cut as fancy = <em>good</em>, plain = <em>adequate</em>. In fact, often, the opposite might be true.</p><p>The research published by Jessica Rixom and her colleagues indicated that fancy wrapping could set up high expectations on the part of the gift recipient. In turn this increases the likelihood they might be disappointed if the gift doesn’t live up to those elevated expectations.</p><p>The same study also revealed that plain, or even careless gift wrapping resulted in more overall enjoyment as the gift typically exceeded the expectation set by the low quality of wrapping.</p><p>“Ah Ha!” I hear you exclaim gleefully. “My dodgy wrapping efforts really are okay after all!”</p><p>Sorry to burst your bubble, but you’re not entirely off the hook.</p><h4>The relationship matters</h4><p>In that same study, Rixom, Mas and Rixom also determined that the less well-known the gift recipient is to you, the more important the quality of the gift wrapping becomes — assuming, of course, you want to make a good impression.</p><p>In situations where you are not close to the gift recipient, they may be inclined to judge you (and your gift) based on how well your gift is wrapped.</p><p>Going to some effort to wrap a gift nicely can be taken as a sign of care and respect towards the person you’re giving the gift to. In turn, this can imbue your gift with a higher perceived worth than if it were presented in plain (or no) wrapping.</p><p>What this means is, if you want to create a good impression with someone you don’t know well, not only does your gift have to be thoughtful, but you also have to make sure it’s wrapped nicely<em>(5)</em>.</p><p>When it comes to family and friends however, you can probably stop stressing about your wrapping being a bit wonky. In fact, your sub-standard wrapping may actually be doing you some favours. At least you’re not setting unrealistic expectations!</p><p>That being said, if you are a big fan of fancy gift wrapping, just remember one thing:</p><h4>You can’t make a silk purse out of a sow’s ear</h4><p>It seems fairly conclusive that wrapping a present beautifully will, in many circumstances, increase the enjoyment the recipient gets from that gift, certainly, <strong><em>before</em></strong> they open it. It may even cause them to value your gift more highly once it’s opened because it’s so nicely presented.</p><p>However, there’s a big caveat. If your gift is a bit rubbish, don’t expect fancy wrapping to make up for its shortcomings. All you’re going to do is make things worse — by setting unrealistic expectations that will probably result in disproportionate disappointment.</p><p>On the other hand, a thoughtful gift will always overcome any initial reservations about your amateurish wrapping efforts.</p><p>Thoughtful gifts, those that surprise and delight (and meet the needs and wants of the people you care about), will always leave a much longer lasting and more positive impression than how well you wrapped them.</p><p>It’s important to remember that next time you’re giving yourself a hard time for being ordinary at wrapping.</p><p><em>(1) The custom of wrapping gifts has been around a very long time and shows no sign of ending anytime soon. It’s thought to have originated in China around 2,200 years ago, about the same time paper was invented.</em></p><p><em>(2) </em><strong><em>Reference:</em></strong> <a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S1057740808800368"><em>Howard, D. (1992). Gift-Wrapping Effects on Product Attitudes</em>:</a> A Mood-Biasing Explanation. <em>Journal of Consumer Psychology, 1</em> (3), 197–223</p><p><em>(3) In the research, ‘fancy’ meant colourful paper and the gift wrapped with a ribbon. ‘Plain’ was brown paper.</em></p><p><em>(4) </em><strong><em>Reference:</em></strong><em> Jessica M. Rixom, Erick M. Mas, Brett A. Rixom.</em> Presentation Matters: <a href="https://myscp.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1002/jcpy.1140"><em>The Effect of Wrapping Neatness on Gift Attitudes</em></a>. <em>Journal of Consumer Psychology, 2019</em></p><p><em>(5) In many cultures it’s customary that gifts are opened later in private rather than at the moment they are received — lest disappointment with the gift should show on the face of the recipient. If you want to create a good impression in that kind of face-to-face situation, you’ll need to bring your A-game when it comes to wrapping.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4ed3e9400438" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How understanding personality types can help you make better gift choices]]></title>
            <link>https://bennhw.medium.com/how-understanding-personality-types-can-help-you-make-better-gift-choices-1fbd17b48c87?source=rss-68b1fb8dec36------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1fbd17b48c87</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[personality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gift-ideas]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[personality-types]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gifts]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Benn Harvey-Walker]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 05 Nov 2021 06:45:06 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-11-05T06:45:06.251Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>As we rapidly approach the holiday gift-giving season, anxiety levels are rising as people struggle with the “What should I get for ….?” question. A lot of that anxiety stems from not wanting to make bad gift choices. Here’s how you can use an understanding of </em>personality type<em> to help you avoid buying dud gifts. (Bonus — you can use it all year round, not just at Christmas time!)</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-Z8Sw1ROkAOtYTv1-NPlrA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Image sourced from <a href="https://www.canstockphoto.com.au/">www.canstockphoto.com.au</a> / BrunoWeltmann</figcaption></figure><p>As a human being yourself, you’ve probably noticed that other human beings have different personalities and that their personalities tend to correlate with the things they like to do and own.</p><p>But unless you’re a research psychologist, it’s unlikely you’ve taken the time to categorise those different personality types, much less consider how personality might, or could influence your choice of gifts for other people.</p><p>The good news is the hard work has already been done — at least when it comes to describing personalities. It takes a little more effort to extrapolate how to match gifts to different personalities.</p><p>This article is about bridging that gap.</p><h4>How do we describe or categorise a person’s personality?</h4><p>We all have our own ways of describing personality. We might refer to ourselves or others as reserved or outgoing, organised or random, hard-nosed or a ‘soft touch’. But these aren’t very universal terms and they’re often circumstantial.</p><p>In the psychology world, those in the know define personality in terms of how people tend to <em>think</em>, <em>feel,</em> and <em>behave</em>. And rather than try and put people in discrete boxes — for instance, describe people as an <em>X</em>, <em>Y</em> or <em>Z — </em>instead, psychologists talk in terms of independent ‘traits’ or characteristics that, in combination, make up the whole.</p><p>Each of these traits exist on a spectrum –rated from high to low. It’s a bit like a cake recipe where you change the quantities of the different ingredients. Change the ratio of ingredients and you change how the cake turns out.</p><p>In other words, you can’t really fit a group of people into a neat little box that defines their personality. Instead, what each of us has is a multi-dimensional ‘cloud’ of personality traits that is unique to the individual.</p><p>“Doesn’t that make personality type a blunt instrument when it comes to matching people to gifts?”; I hear you ask.</p><p>Well, yes and no.</p><p>An understanding of personality won’t necessarily point you to a specific gift item, but it will most certainly help steer you away from bad ideas and guide you towards safer ones.</p><p>Also on the plus side, there aren’t many personality traits that you need to wrap your head around.</p><h4>The ‘Big Five’ personality traits</h4><p>It’s generally accepted within the discipline of psychology that there are five key personality traits — known as <em>The Big Five</em><a href="#_ftn1">[1]</a>.</p><p>These traits (which can be remembered using the mnemonic; OCEAN) are:</p><blockquote>Openness</blockquote><blockquote>Conscientiousness</blockquote><blockquote>Extraversion</blockquote><blockquote>Agreeableness</blockquote><blockquote>Neuroticism</blockquote><p><strong>Openness</strong> refers to a person’s willingness to engage with new ideas or experiences. People who score high on the openness scale tend to enjoy new things and are often regarded as creative. People who score low on the openness scale prefer familiarity and routine and are less likely to try new things. Less open people also have a strong sense of right and wrong and tend to be conservative in their thinking.</p><p><strong>Conscientiousness</strong> is very much as it sounds. Highly conscientious people are well organised, dependable, and usually very motivated to achieve. Less conscientious people are more easily distracted, less reliable and much less predictable.</p><p><strong>Extraversion.</strong> We’re all familiar with how we describe people as extraverts and introverts. Extraverted people are ‘social butterflies’ who draw energy from other people. They enjoy relatively short interactions with a large variety of people, that is, they’re very sociable and don’t enjoy isolation. Introverted people prefer more prolonged or ‘meaningful’ interactions with a small number of people, avoid crowds and are much more comfortable with isolation. This doesn’t mean introverts are not sociable. It’s just that they’d typically prefer to go to a quiet dinner rather than a big party.</p><p><strong>Agreeableness</strong> is about a person’s relative warmth, ability to empathise and preparedness to cooperate. Agreeable people are more likely to be trusting, helpful and compassionate. Disagreeable people tend to be suspicious of others, more egocentric and more inclined to “rock the boat”.</p><p><strong>Neuroticism</strong> relates to a person’s emotional stability. Those who score high on the neurotic scale tend to be anxious and spend a lot of time worrying about things unnecessarily. People who are calm, self-assured and contented score low on the neuroticism scale.</p><h4>Be mindful of the extremes</h4><p>So, what does all this psychology stuff mean when it comes to choosing a gift for someone?</p><p>The main take-away from this is to be mindful of those people who <strong>trend towards the extremes</strong> in any of these personality traits. The more a person is an outlier in the expression of a <em>Big Five</em> trait, the more careful you will need to be (or not) in your selection of an appropriate gift.</p><p>To give you an idea of what I mean, let’s take a look at each trait and the implications of scoring high or low in any of them.</p><p><strong>Openness (to new things)</strong></p><p>People who score low in terms of openness are more likely to enjoy material gifts and experiences that are already familiar to them — things they are already comfortable with. In other words, don’t try and ‘shake up’ their world. It’ll probably go over like a lead balloon.</p><p>High-scoring <em>open</em> people enjoy the opportunity to try new things. That means you can be more experimental with the gifts you give them. Open people also tend to be creative and often appreciate art.</p><p><strong>Conscientiousness</strong></p><p>If you know someone who scores low in terms of conscientiousness, it’s probably best to avoid gifts that are time sensitive (like concert tickets) or things that require a lot of focus to enjoy. For instance, a 1,000-piece jigsaw puzzle probably isn’t a good present for someone who scores low on conscientiousness because they’re easily distracted and can have difficulty completing tasks.</p><p>Conscientious people, on the other hand, like to achieve things and are typically very organized. Gifts that help them achieve and be more organized — or challenge them in some way — are likely to be well received.</p><p><strong>Extraversion</strong></p><p>When people score low on this trait, we refer to them as introverts. Strong introverts probably won’t enjoy a gift that will draw attention to them. Nor are they likely to enjoy an experience that requires them to interact with strangers or otherwise takes them out of their ‘comfort zone’. (For example, a karaoke experience would be a very poor gift choice for an introvert.)</p><p>People who are very extraverted thrive on lots of interaction with other people. If a gift grabs attention and is a positive conversation-starter, it will be well received. Avoid gifts and experiences that require relative isolation to be properly enjoyed.</p><p><strong>Agreeableness</strong></p><p>People who score low when it comes to agreeableness are likely to be very picky. If you’re unsure about what to get them, either get a gift that is very versatile (like a cash-equivalent gift card) or ask them what they want — and don’t deviate from their request.</p><p>Very agreeable people are easy to buy for as they’re likely to enjoy almost anything you get them.</p><p>That said, I’d suggest going the extra mile and try to choose the ‘perfect’ gift for this kind of person. They will appreciate it more than you can imagine.</p><p><strong>Neuroticism</strong></p><p>Calm, self-confident people score low on the neuroticism scale, so they’re unlikely to read much into the gift you get for them. They’ll most likely enjoy it for what it is.</p><p>Very neurotic people, however, worry about way too many things, so you need to mindful about what a neurotic person might ‘read into’ a gift you give them. What you see as a practical gift might be perceived as some kind of judgement.</p><p>Keep unintended consequences in mind and consider asking what a person you know to neurotic might want as a gift if you want to reduce their anxiety.</p><h4>Don’t confuse ‘interests’ with ‘personality’</h4><p>When researching how personality type can influence gift selection, I took time to check out several gift-oriented, on-line stores.</p><p>What quickly became apparent was that when those sites referred to <em>personality</em>, what they really meant was ‘interests’ — at least most of the time.</p><p>I found categories like ‘traveler’ and ‘fitness freak’ right alongside ‘romantic’ and ‘creative’ — all under the heading <strong><em>Personality</em></strong>.</p><p>Though these terms are familiar and make categorising gifts on a website relatively easy, few of them actually relate directly to personality traits in anyway at all.</p><p><em>Personality</em> adds another dimension to interests, or hobbies, occupation, gender, age, relationship status or any number of other aspects of an individual’s life. An interest or occupation does not make someone who they are. Their personality does.</p><p>Knowing someone’s interests will help with suitable categories for gift buying, but appreciating the nuances of their personality will help you be a more thoughtful gift-giver.</p><h4>A parting thought …</h4><p>Before you get too carried away with your new-found appreciation of personality traits, when it comes to gift choices, do not underestimate the importance of needs and wants.</p><p>Personality considerations should not override what someone expressly wants or needs. Rather, when you don’t have a specific gift request to guide you, an understanding of personality can be a useful tool in helping you work out how best to satisfy that want or need.</p><p>After all, thoughtful gift-giving isn’t about how clever you are. Indeed, it isn’t about you at all. What it is about is bringing happiness to the people you’re close to, and often that means letting go of what we <em>think </em>they’d like and actually getting them something they want or need.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref1"><strong>[1]</strong></a> <em>The Big Five were developed in the 1970s by two psychology research teams. These teams were led by Paul Costa and Robert R. McCrae of the National Institutes of Health and Warren Norman and Lewis Goldberg of the University of Michigan and the University of Oregon respectively. Source: </em><a href="https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-big-five/"><em>Scientific American</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1fbd17b48c87" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why choose recycled precious metals for your jewellery?]]></title>
            <link>https://bennhw.medium.com/why-choose-recycled-precious-metals-for-your-jewellery-52fce4558b4c?source=rss-68b1fb8dec36------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/52fce4558b4c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[climate-change]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[recycling]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jewellery-ethics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sustainability]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[responsible-sourcing]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Benn Harvey-Walker]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 22 Feb 2021 04:38:31 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-03-03T22:31:02.708Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*uibZjqq4zMwrcj-qUPhY1w.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Recycled precious metals are the most responsible and sustainable choice for jewellery making. Here’s why …</h3><h4>If you’re concerned about the climate crisis and what difference your purchasing decisions can make, there’s a really strong argument to prefer jewellery makers who only use recycled precious metals.</h4><ul><li>Recycled gold produces up to 99.8% fewer greenhouse gas emissions than mined gold<a href="#_ftn1">[1]</a>;</li><li>Recycling platinum produces about one-twentieth the emissions that mining for platinum does. (That’s a 95% reduction.); and</li><li>Recycling silver produces around 14% of the emissions that silver mining does.</li></ul><p>These are huge savings, but what does that mean when it comes to jewellery?</p><p>To give you an example, for an average sized, plain wedding band or stacking ring, the numbers look like this<a href="#_ftn2">[2]</a>:</p><ul><li>A ring made with newly mined gold with a carbon cost of up to 64kgs in greenhouse gas emissions might produce as little as 100 grams when made with recycled gold;</li><li>The same ring made using mined platinum would have a carbon cost upwards of 236kgs in greenhouse gases, whereas recycled platinum would only have emitted around 12kgs; and</li><li>A ring made with primary silver that produces around 300 grams of greenhouse gases would have carbon footprint of only 4 grams when made using recycled silver.</li></ul><p>These are really encouraging figures. But as it is with just about every other kind of recycling, realising the power of these numbers doesn’t come from the efforts of one or two concerned people. It comes from widespread adoption of ‘recycled’ as the preferred source.</p><p>Unfortunately we’re not there yet, but the upside is there’re plenty of room for improvement.</p><h3>How big is the problem?</h3><p>In the grand scheme of things, mining precious metals like gold, silver and platinum doesn’t produce anywhere near the quantity of greenhouse gas emissions that minerals like bauxite, iron ore, copper and nickel do. But the numbers are still significant …</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*llk4UxaDno9oRL1Y.jpg" /></figure><p>When you apply the numbers from row 1 above to the quantity of each of these metals that are mined each year, the emission amounts start to get scary.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/840/0*dQph5kyLPcuiwjPB.jpg" /></figure><p>(Note, that’s <strong><em>tonnes </em></strong>in Table 2. Nearly 60 million tonnes of greenhouse gas emissions added to the atmosphere every year just from gold mining!)</p><p>Gold mining is by far the largest polluter in terms of sheer volume when it comes to precious metals. But if we want to get specific about the impact of the jewellery industry, we need to break the numbers down a bit further.</p><h3>What part does the jewellery industry play?</h3><p>The jewellery industry is a big consumer of precious metals, especially of gold and silver. Of all the gold produced in the world each year, approximately 51% goes into jewellery making. 27% of the platinum produced each year goes into jewellery. And around 21% of all silver production goes to jewellery with another 6% going into silverware. <em>(See Table 4 below.)</em></p><p>But of course, not all of the precious metals used in the jewellery industry are freshly dug out of the ground. Recycling already contributes a meaningful amount to the global supply of each <em>(see Table 3 below)</em>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/657/0*HEqXHVWUNgowZ975.jpg" /></figure><h3>Where does the recycled metal go?</h3><p>How recycled and primary metals get distributed across different industries is difficult to say. To get some idea, it’s worth taking a look at current demand for these precious metals by industry sector.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/766/0*Z1ECom3Ez4ed9dsx.jpg" /></figure><p>As you can see from Tables 3 &amp; 4 above, even if 100% of the recycled gold, platinum and silver produced each year was devoted exclusively to jewellery production, there would still be a shortfall.</p><ul><li>Gold jewellery manufacturing consumes 51% of the gold produced each year — approximately 2,200 tonnes, but recycling only delivers a little over half that quantity;</li><li>Platinum is a lot closer. Platinum jewellery making consumes around 63 tonnes of total production. Recycling delivers an average 59 tonnes to the market; and</li><li>Manufacturing silver jewellery uses up around 6,000 tonnes of silver each year with recycling only delivering around 4,800 tonnes to the total supply.</li></ul><p>But of course, not all recycled precious metals go towards jewellery making. Technology, industrial and finance industry consumers of precious metals are going to purchase from wherever is most convenient and cost-effective.</p><p>In other words, there is still plenty of scope for jewellery manufacturers to switch to recycled as their preferred option.</p><h3>Why does all this matter?</h3><p>About 15 or so years ago, supporters of recycling argued that if recycled precious metals (especially gold) became the norm for jewellery, that would depress demand for primary metals, thereby reducing the destructive impacts of mining.</p><p>In hindsight it’s easy to see why that wasn’t going to happen. Mining of valuable metals like gold makes too big an economic contribution for governments to discourage it. Also, the price keeps trending up, and with it the incentive to dig for more.</p><p>So, if mining is going to happen anyway, the question is: Why does it matter where the metal in your jewellery comes from?</p><p>It’s a good question. And it all comes back to personal responsibility.</p><p>Why do we use our recycling bins when the handful of aluminium cans, plastic and glass bottles we send back are a relative drop in the ocean?</p><p>We do it because we have that choice and it’s in the best interests of the planet as a whole.</p><p>Your decision to throw that plastic bag into a recycling bin and not landfill makes only a tiny difference, but we still know it’s the right thing to do.</p><p>With precious metals it’s even more important we recycle them because they’re essentially irreplaceable, they’re extremely rare and, most important of all, they come at a big initial environmental cost.</p><blockquote>“… why would you actively choose a product option that’s known to be very damaging to our environment when there’s a much more environmentally friendly alternative available that is literally identical?”</blockquote><p>And, if you really want to get hard-nosed about it, jewellery is not necessary for us to live. Unlike food, shelter and water, it’s a discretionary purchase. That being the case, why would you actively choose a product option that’s known to be very damaging to our environment when there’s a much more environmentally friendly alternative available that is literally identical?</p><h3>You get to choose</h3><p>As we’ve already mentioned, a big percentage of the precious metals consumed around the planet each year go into things like investment, technology and industry.</p><p>They could turn up in your X-ray images, your mobile phone, in the coins in your pocket or in your new car. But the reality is you have zero say in where the metals that went into those products came from.</p><p>With your jewellery it’s different. With your jewellery you get to choose.</p><p>You can seek out jewellery made using recycled precious metals. There are plenty of small jewellery companies out there (like our own) dedicated to using only recycled precious metals.</p><p>There are larger ones too. For instance, Pandora has committed to switching entirely to using only recycled gold and silver by 2025<a href="#_ftn3">[3]</a>.</p><h3>Made using some recycled metal is not good enough</h3><p>Just because a jewellery company says they use recycled metals, don’t assume that <strong><em>all</em></strong> the metal they use is recycled in origin.</p><p>Most jewellery makers use at least some recycled precious metals. At the very least they recycle their own scraps and waste. But that’s a far cry from ensuring all of the metal they use to make new pieces comes from a reputable recycler.</p><p>Remember the huge difference in the carbon cost between mined precious metals and recycled ones? Using <em>some</em> recycled metal doesn’t cut it when trying to minimise the carbon footprint of a jewellery product. It helps, but given the easy availability of recycled metals and the fact that they’re the same price as the primary product, there’s no reasonable justification for not going 100% recycled.</p><blockquote>To put it in context, for the same carbon cost of producing one ring made with primary gold, you could produce up to 630 rings using recycled gold. 630 to 1 … Think about that. Any jewellery business can radically reduce their carbon footprint, at zero cost to them, simply by switching to recycled precious metals.</blockquote><blockquote>So why don’t they?</blockquote><h3>Is ‘recycled’ an ethical choice?</h3><p>This is a question you’ll see almost nowhere else other than in the jewellery industry. And almost always it’s only ever asked in relation to Fair Trade gold.</p><p>Fair Trade (or fair mined) gold comes from a small number of certified artisanal mining communities dotted around the world. At this stage they contribute about 1% of global supply annually.</p><p>The communities in question benefit from higher prices, safer working conditions and more environmentally friendly processes. All of which are good things.</p><p>The pro-Fair Trade gold argument goes along the lines that if gold mining is going to happen anyway — which it is — purchasing anything other than Fair Trade (or fair mined) is unethical. Apparently this is because, by buying recycled, you’re not doing anything to improve the efficiency of the millions of artisanal gold miners in developing nations. Thus, you’re not helping to reduce the overall carbon output of gold mining activities.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/420/1*FHiSAPm-ycuDEyfUjRzB5g.png" /></figure><p>From our perspective we don’t have any issue with the human rights aspect of this argument. Artisanal miners deserve a fairer go. But the problem is artisanal mining is no better than large scale mining when it comes to greenhouse gas emissions. <em>Source: (d)</em></p><p>By increasing the demand for Fair Trade gold and silver, the most likely outcome is an increase in mining activity simply because it’s more rewarding for the miners who benefit.</p><p>In other words, choosing Fair Trade (or fair mined) gold and silver means we’re likely to see even more mining and more damage to the environment. Albeit the trade-off will be better conditions for the miners fortunate enough to be a part of the program. (And perhaps a small reduction in relative emissions for the output of Fair Trade mining derived gold and silver?)</p><h3>It’s all about what’s ethical to you</h3><p>Coming full circle, whether you choose recycled or Fair Trade gold or silver becomes a question of how much responsibility you want to take for the generation of greenhouse gases that will wreck our planet if left unchecked. That against how much you want to help a relatively small number of artisanal miners in developing countries?</p><p><strong><em>Is recycled an ethical choice?</em></strong> We say yes.</p><p><strong><em>Is Fair Trade gold and silver an ethical choice?</em></strong> We also say yes, but for very different reasons.</p><p>It’s human rights for a few versus reducing your immediate contribution to the climate crisis (which, ultimately, affects everyone). Realistically, that’s the choice that has to be made.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref1">[1]</a> <em>The recycling source is important. Gold recycled from old jewellery, jeweller’s waste and the like achieves a 99.8% reduction in emissions. Recycled gold from E-waste reduces emissions by about 94%. (See Table 1.)</em></p><p><a href="#_ftnref2">[2]</a> <em>The method for deriving these numbers is detailed later in this article. Note, the figures are for metal production only and exclude the ring manufacturing processes.</em></p><p><a href="#_ftnref3">[3]</a> <em>In </em><a href="https://www.jewelleryworld.net.au/2020/07/06/all-pandora-jewellery-to-be-made-from-recycled-silver-and-gold/"><em>this article</em></a><em>, Pandora reveals plans to switch wholly to recycled metal for their silver and gold jewellery.</em></p><h3>What’s the carbon cost of a wedding ring?</h3><p>To try and makes things a bit more real, instead of talking in kilograms, let’s have a look at the differences for something we’re all a bit more familiar with — an ordinary wedding ring.</p><p>For simplicity, we’ll work with a plain, half-round, 3mm wide band in a US size 6 (Aust L3/4) — which is a fairly average size.</p><p>Of course, rings made with different metals will weigh differently even when they’re exactly the same size and profile because each metal type has a different specific gravity.</p><p>Table 5 below shows how the various numbers play out for emissions from a standard sized ring made with different metals coming from different sources.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*OhF9ji5-cJXWJkVD.jpg" /></figure><p>In short, it doesn’t matter which precious metal you prefer, choosing recycled in origin means your jewellery will have a radically smaller carbon footprint than if the metal comes wholly from mining. (This is especially true for gold.)</p><p>From a climate change perspective, it really is that simple.</p><h4>Sources/References:</h4><p>(a) <a href="https://www.gold.org/about-gold/gold-supply/gold-mining/how-much-gold">World Gold Council, 2020. Gold Production Statistics</a></p><p>(b) <a href="http://www.platinum.matthey.com/services/market-research/may-2020-pgm-market-report">Johnson Matthey PGM Market Report, 2020</a></p><p>© <a href="https://www.silverinstitute.org/silver-supply-demand/">The Silver Institute, Silver Supply &amp; Demand, 2020</a></p><p>(d) Edalmetall Blog, November 2019: <a href="https://blog.c-hafner.de/ecological-footprint-what-is-more-sustainable-gold-mining-or-gold-recycling/">Sustainability of Mined vs Recycled Gold</a></p><p>(e) Platinum production GHG emissions: <a href="https://www.researchgate.net/publication/332132616_Closing_the_loop_on_platinum_from_catalytic_converters_Contributions_from_material_flow_analysis_and_circularity_indicators">Journal of Industrial Ecology, April 2019</a></p><p>(f) GHG emissions from silver production: <a href="https://www.researchgate.net/publication/298235548_Greenhouse_Gas_Emission_in_Jewelry_Industry_A_Case_Study_of_Silver_Flat_Ring">A Case Study — Silver Ring Manufacturing, 2015</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=52fce4558b4c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Natural or lab-created diamonds — which is best in your engagement ring?]]></title>
            <link>https://bennhw.medium.com/natural-or-lab-created-diamonds-which-is-best-in-your-engagement-ring-508378b2ce12?source=rss-68b1fb8dec36------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/508378b2ce12</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[engagement-ring]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[diamonds]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ethical-consumerism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lab-created-diamonds]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ethical-jewelry]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Benn Harvey-Walker]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 09 Jan 2020 05:02:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-01-09T06:20:28.867Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hKRX_xUI27F6oxc9KGnE4g.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Natural or lab-created diamonds — which is best in your engagement ring?</h3><p>A few short years ago lab-created diamonds weren’t even on people’s radar, much less considered a serious option for engagement ring buyers.</p><p>That situation is rapidly changing.</p><p>Since about 2017, they’ve become readily available in the general diamond jewellery market and are now making serious inroads into the bridal and engagement ring space.</p><p>Of course, the natural diamond world isn’t very happy about this development. Lab-created diamonds are starting to eat into their previously exclusive marketplace. But what does this mean to you if you’re thinking about buying an engagement ring?</p><h3>Lab-created diamonds are diamonds</h3><p>​Before we go too far, let’s make sure we’re on the same page. When we talk about lab-created diamonds, we’re not referring to things that look like diamonds (simulants like cubic zirconia — CZs) or diamond alternatives (like lab-created moissanite).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*S2nfp8z2qyR8U6_3Wpivqg.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>This engagement ring features a 9mm lab-created moissanite (silicon carbide) with natural diamonds in the shoulders. Moissanite is a popular diamond alternative as it has the looks, is almost as hard (at 9.5 on Mohs scale) and is quite a bit less expensive than both lab-grown and natural diamonds.</em></figcaption></figure><p>Lab-created diamonds, or man-made, synthetic or lab-grown diamonds as they’re variously called, are made of … well … diamond.</p><p>They have the same chemical structure, the same optical qualities, the same specific gravity and the same hardness as diamonds that come out of the ground.</p><p>What that means is, when it comes to the purely physical properties of lab-created versus natural (or mine-origin) diamonds, there is no material difference between the two. It takes very advanced detection equipment to tell them apart.</p><p>From a consumer’s perspective, man-made diamonds behave in exactly the same way as do natural stones. But once you get past the purely physical properties, things get a little more complicated.</p><p>Some of those complications relate to intangible things like perceptions of origin and ‘tradition’. Others relate to more tangible considerations like environmental costs, social costs (or benefits), rarity and value for money.</p><h3>The intangible differences</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*tXi_i4JsfISLxSkcj9AMrw.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>This gorgeous engagement ring features a trio of natural diamonds from one of the most environmentally conscious large-scale diamond mining operations on the planet, Rio Tinto’s West Australian-sited Argyle mine. The center stone weighs 1.0 carat and the ring is made with recycled platinum</em></figcaption></figure><p>Let’s start with perceptions about <em>natural</em> versus <em>man-made</em>.</p><p>There’s no disputing the fact that natural diamonds were created as a result of natural volcanic actions whereas lab-created diamonds are manufactured in an artificial environment in factories.</p><p>What’s important in relation to these two basic facts is how you <em>feel</em> about those different processes.</p><p>Does it matter to you?</p><p>Maybe it does? Maybe it doesn’t?</p><p>Whether the diamonds are removed from an incubator or dug out of the ground, the reality is both are produced on an industrial scale. One involves big factories. The other involves big pieces of earthmoving and processing equipment creating big holes in the ground. Neither method is particularly pretty or what you’d call ‘romantic’.</p><p>And when it comes to the notion of <em>tradition</em>, there’s no question natural diamonds have been around a lot longer than their factory-produced alternative.</p><p>The first documented use of diamonds in matrimonial jewellery was in Austria in the late 1400s, but they didn’t really become the ‘must have’ option until the 1930s — thanks to a very successful advertising campaign by De Beers. Before then, coloured gemstones were the go-to choice.</p><p>I think it’s fair to say that diamonds are now the preferred option for many people getting engaged because that’s what the advertisers have been telling us for the past 90 years, but I wouldn’t go so far as to say they’re traditional.</p><h3>Tangible differences between lab-created and natural diamonds</h3><p>Put two similarly graded and sized lab-created and natural diamonds side by side and it’s virtually impossible to tell them apart by eye. And yet there are some meaningful differences between the two once you look beyond their physical characteristics and the processes by which they were formed.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/723/1*5hK6EQFb1WFYAD5dNUOrng.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>Alrosa’s massive diamond mining pit in the town of Aykhal, Yakutia, Russia. (Image via iStock Getty Images.)</em></figcaption></figure><h4>Diamonds and the environment</h4><p>Regardless of whether you dig them out of the ground or create them in a factory, diamond production has a negative impact on the environment. There’s no escaping that fact.</p><p>The difference is that natural diamond mining has a large, direct physical impact on the local environment. The pursuit of diamonds has resulted in the creation of some of the biggest holes on Earth and almost all diamond mines are located in environments vulnerable to run-off, dust, noise, light and other forms of pollution from human activity. Not to mention the physical displacement of millions of tonnes of rock and other tailings.</p><p>The direct environmental impact of man-made diamond production is, however, significantly smaller — being limited to factory buildings in urban areas. Of course, human activity still has an impact on those local urban environments and there are things like water consumption (for cooling) to be considered, but on the whole, lab-created diamond production does less direct damage to the environment — especially to what might be called more fragile ecosystems.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*r495hcQAOgEPseBw3fGN_w.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>Without knowing specifically which mine or factory your diamond comes from, it’s impossible to say whether its carbon footprint is big or small. Diamond production is a big energy consumer, and its where the electricity comes from and how efficient the facility is that matters. (This engagement ring features US-produced lab-created diamonds in a recycled platinum band.)</em></figcaption></figure><h4>The carbon cost of diamond production</h4><p>You can’t have any discussion about the environment without considering carbon emissions.</p><p>Both diamond mining and factory production yield carbon emissions. How big those emissions are varies from mine to mine and factory to factory.</p><p>Most of the carbon produced is a function of the energy sources used. It doesn’t matter whether it’s a mine or a factory, the more access they have to renewable energy, the fewer the carbon emissions.</p><p>The reality is, some mines have a really small carbon footprint and some are disturbingly bad. The same can be said when it comes to factory production. It’s all about how efficient they are and where the energy comes from.</p><p>In other words, what really matters is specifically which mine or which factory an individual diamond came from.</p><p>You can’t compare factory-produced and mine-origin diamonds side by side and say one is inherently better than the other because of their method of production. You can only make that judgement when you know specifically who the producer is and where their mine or factory draws its energy from.</p><p>If you care about the impact your purchase is having on the environment, then you need to seek out a supplier who cares about those things too and can provide you with diamonds of known origin.</p><h4>The social impacts of diamond production</h4><p>Both mining and manufacturing are big economic drivers that, more often than not, deliver meaningful economic benefits to localities, regions and countries.</p><p>Both take relatively inaccessible and/or low-value raw materials and turn them into products worth a lot more, creating wealth along the way.</p><p>The downside is many people are negatively affected by diamond production — most often in politically volatile developing counties or in exploitative diamond cutting factories, also usually sited in developing nations.</p><p>Historically, the diamond mining industry has a very poor record when it comes to human rights abuses and in certain parts of the world there are still very real problems with conflict funding, smuggling, slavery, exploitation, corruption and all kinds of criminal activity.</p><p>Most of this is confined to the artisanal small-scale mining (ASM) sector, though it’s also true that some larger scale operations are less than humane when using security forces to protect their mining interests.</p><h4>Conflict diamonds are still a ‘thing’</h4><p>In places where the rule of law is questionable, the flow of money connected with diamond production often brings out the worst in people.</p><p>How big the problem is is difficult to say, but with some 15–20% of diamonds originating from ASM operations, the likelihood is a meaningful percentage of suspect diamonds make their way into the mainstream supply chain.</p><p>My advice would be, if the reseller can’t show you (via a reputable certificate) exactly where a diamond originated from — and you consider yourself a socially responsible person — don’t touch it.</p><p>It might cost a little more to find a diamond of known origin, but there is peace of mind in knowing where it came from.</p><h4>Lab-created diamond production is (typically) socially responsible</h4><p>To the best of our knowledge, issues of exploitation and criminal corruption are essentially non-existent in the man-made diamond sector, but that doesn’t mean you should be careless.</p><p>It’s probably safe to say that diamonds grown in Singapore, Europe or the US are free of human rights abuses, but we can’t be quite so sure about all those grown in India, China and Russia.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*dbK0wm93pB_OAqV44xpxAw.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>This diamond cutting and polishing operation in India is relatively low-tech but nonetheless a safe and clean environment. Some are much more sophisticated and then there are those that are like sweat shops. (Image via Alamy.com)</em></figcaption></figure><h4>Don’t overlook cutting and polishing</h4><p>Where diamonds are cut is important too.</p><p>About 90% of the world’s diamonds are cut in India — including lab-created diamonds — and sometimes the working conditions of those diamond cutters and polishers are extremely poor and exploitative, with the use of child labour being all too common.</p><p>Workers are often paid by the piece and have little or no job security.</p><p>Again, if you care about these things, choose your supplier carefully.</p><h3>The value in diamonds</h3><p>When it comes to discussing <em>value</em>, probably the two biggest issues are:</p><ul><li>How much bang you get for your buck now; and</li><li>What might your purchase be worth sometime in the future, i.e., how much value might it retain.</li></ul><p>At the moment, natural diamonds larger than tiny accent stones (called melee) are typically around 30% more expensive than equivalent lab-created diamonds — but this is only true of colourless (sometimes called white) diamonds.</p><p>What this means is, if you’re comfortable with the idea of buying a diamond made in a factory, you can get a lot more bang for your buck — either saving a significant amount of money up-front or enabling you to purchase a larger and/or higher graded stone for the same money.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*CSEfEMHT3dstH7z8LEXc_A.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>The lab-created blue diamond in this embrace-style engagement ring wasn’t what most people would call ‘cheap’, but it was far more affordable and much easier to get than an equivalent natural diamond.</em></figcaption></figure><h4>Coloured diamonds are a different ballgame</h4><p>Once you start talking about coloured natural diamonds — especially the pinks, blues and reds — the gap between man-made and natural gets much wider because these fancy natural colours are incredibly rare and sought after.</p><p>However, if you like the idea of a pink or blue diamond, lab-created options, whilst not cheap, they are still hugely more affordable than an equivalent natural diamond — by a very, very wide margin.</p><h3>Let’s talk finances</h3><p>Now, supposing you choose to save money up-front by going lab-created, there’s a financial benefit to that decision because you can use the money you saved to do other things — maybe avoid some debt, put it towards your wedding, save it for a holiday or whatever — but there is a potential downside.</p><p>The possible downside is that man-made diamonds probably won’t retain their value as much as natural diamonds are likely to.</p><p>What this means is, were you to try and resell your engagement ring sometime in the future you’ll probably get less for it than you would if it featured natural diamonds.</p><p>How much less? Well, that’s really hard to say because that would mean predicting the future and I don’t have a crystal ball, much less one that works.</p><p>Of course, here in Australia the issue of resale value is much less important for most people because we tend to buy (or give) one ring and it’s kept, hopefully, forever. This makes the whole idea of resale value little more than an academic exercise.</p><p>In places like the US however, where it’s much more common for engagement ring diamonds to traded in or upgraded at a later date, the issue of retained value is much more hotly debated.</p><p>Still, if retained value is something you want to seriously weigh up, here are some key points you might want to consider:</p><ul><li>Natural diamonds are a finite resource, and as the decades pass, they will inevitably become more and more scarce. In any other situation you might expect this to increase prices over time if there were no alternative — but the advent of lab-created diamonds is changing the market dynamics;</li><li>In most instances, the resale value of diamonds, lab-created or natural, will be determined by the wholesale value of ‘new’ equivalents, not what you paid retail. Generally, you’re far more likely to lose money when reselling a diamond ring than you are to make a profit;</li><li>As newly mined diamonds become more scarce, it’s possible that natural diamond resellers will start to tap into an obvious alternative source — secondhand diamonds — of which there are tens of millions around the world. This may result in an increase in prices for pre-owned diamonds as a more formal market develops;</li><li>As time goes by, it’s likely man-made diamonds will become much more common as production volumes go up. They’re also likely to get cheaper — particularly if they’re unbranded. That said, there will always be a meaningful minimum production cost, especially for quality stones, so they’re unlikely to ever be really ‘cheap’. (Not like diamond simulants such as CZs.); and</li><li>Lab-created diamonds are also highly valued in technology applications. What that means is the really high-quality product that would be ideal for high-end jewellery is also prized in industry because of its purity, reliable supply and low cost relative to suitable natural diamonds. This may prop up prices of quality man-made diamonds due to growing demand in industry and technology.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*r495hcQAOgEPseBw3fGN_w.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>There is a third option when it comes to diamonds, and that’s to choose a recycled or vintage stone. The vintage rose cut diamond in this sweet engagement ring is an amazing performer in real life, it ticks all of the ethical boxes and it was very affordable.</em></figcaption></figure><p>All this said, unless you’re buying investment diamonds or jewellery (which is not what this article is about), resale value is a bit of a side issue, especially in the Australian market. But it is something you should be aware of.</p><p>The harsh reality is, just like when you drive a new car out of the showroom and it decreases significantly in resale value, the same is true for diamonds leaving a jewellery shop.</p><p>There are exceptions of course. Some cars go up in value, as do some diamonds. However, both are usually very rare and expensive to begin with and out of reach of the average buyer.</p><h3>So, which do you choose — man-made or natural?</h3><p>In summary, the big decision points are:</p><ol><li><strong>“Authenticity”:</strong> Lab-created diamonds are, by definition, not natural. Natural diamonds are a natural product. Physically they’re the same but it’s up to you decide whether this difference makes one better than the other or is relatively meaningless;</li><li><strong>Up-front cost:</strong> Lab-created diamonds are, like for like, significantly less expensive than equivalent natural diamonds — by up to 30–40% for relatively common sizes, cuts and grades;</li><li><strong>Retained value:</strong> Natural diamonds are more likely to retain at least some resale value over time, probably more than equivalent man-made stones;</li><li><strong>Environmental concerns:</strong> Man-made diamond production does less direct physical harm to the environment compared with diamond mining. But when it comes to carbon cost it’s a matter of production efficiency and the source of the energy used in the specific mine or factory that determines which is better; and</li><li><strong>Social concerns:</strong> Lab-created diamonds of unknown origin are less likely to be tainted by human rights abuses than mine-origin diamonds, but the only way to be sure either way is to choose traceable stones from a reputable supplier.</li></ol><p>Like so many things, choosing between man-made and natural diamonds is not a simple decision — at least not for most people. (Of course, if neither feels quite right, recycled and vintage diamonds are another very responsible and affordable option.)</p><p>Ultimately, whether you choose lab-created or natural is a personal thing because it’s not just about the chemistry and the money. I can’t direct you one way or another, other than to say I’d hope you’d choose the most environmentally and socially responsible option available — the one that limits harm as much as possible and does the most good.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=508378b2ce12" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The diamond industry is lying to you …]]></title>
            <link>https://bennhw.medium.com/the-diamond-industry-is-lying-to-you-faa2e8d65b81?source=rss-68b1fb8dec36------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/faa2e8d65b81</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ethical-jewelry]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lab-diamonds]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[diamond-jewellery]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[diamonds]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jewelry-industry]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Benn Harvey-Walker]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 03 Dec 2019 05:19:24 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-12-04T23:47:26.184Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-I69JUXxxo4WXaQYQz6UYw.jpeg" /></figure><h3><strong>The diamond industry is lying to you …</strong></h3><p><strong>… and here’s why they can’t afford not to</strong></p><p>First up, I must admit to feeling a little conflicted when making this statement (only a little), because, in the interests of full disclosure, I am part owner of a business that, among other things, sells diamonds.</p><p>Knowing that you’d be right to wonder why I’m now in the process of raising a red flag about the diamond industry.</p><p>The reason is, it comes down to ethics. And as an advocate for consumers and all things ethical in the jewellery industry, I feel strongly about calling out some of the BS that’s being flung around in the diamond retail space right now.</p><p>There are three deeply embedded lies I want to challenge and, because I’m fair-minded, you’ll see that two of them are addressed to the mined diamond industry and the third is directed at the lab-created diamond sector.</p><p>Also, in fairness, “lying” is a really strong word and it might be more correct to say you’re not being told the whole truth, or you’re being misled or misdirected. At the very least you’re being left to draw conclusions that aren’t really there.</p><p>Whatever the case, to avoid being too inflammatory, I’m going to call them ‘half-truths’ rather than lies …</p><h4>Half-truth #1: “Real is Rare”</h4><p>This little marketing gem (pun intended) was created by the Diamond Producers Association a few years back and (obviously) it’s intended to communicate to consumers that diamonds that come out of the ground — natural diamonds — are rare.</p><p>This is not untrue, but let me ask you this: What meaning does the word ‘rare’ convey to you when used to describe a product you might want to buy?</p><p>To my mind, rare means there’s not many of them around and that, by inference, because of their rarity, they’re valuable, or unique, or special.</p><p>But when it comes to diamonds, do they really meet this standard?</p><p>Well, as a mineral in the Earth’s crust, diamonds are rare compared with things like iron ore, bauxite, copper, lead and a bunch of other things we dig out of the ground.</p><p>So, to that extent, diamonds as a mineral group are rare relative to other minerals. But I don’t think that’s the intended message.</p><p>If you do happen to think diamonds are rare, let me share some sobering numbers with you from <a href="https://www.bain.com/contentassets/a53a9fa8bf5247a3b7bb0b10561510c2/bain_diamond_report_2018.pdf">Bain &amp; Company’s 2018 Diamond Industry Report</a>.</p><p>The report details that in the period 2013 to 2018, the total rough diamond output for the industry was approximately 806 million carats. On average that’s about 134 million carats per annum.</p><p>By any standard, that’s a lot of diamonds.</p><p>But of course, a good portion of those diamonds are industrial quality, not suitable for use in jewellery. Only about 30% of all diamonds produced are what you’d call jewellery grade. (Gemmological Institute of America, 2015.)</p><p>So, our 134 million carats per annum comes down to a “mere” 40 million carats of jewellery-grade rough diamonds produced each year.</p><p>Take out the waste from cutting and polishing and that comes down 20 million carats of polished diamonds.</p><p>Let me ask, does 20 million of anything sound rare to you? Let alone something that’s produced at the rate of 20 million per year?</p><p><strong>“Yes, but some diamonds are extremely rare.”</strong></p><p>When faced with the reality of the production data, many mine-origin diamond enthusiasts will point out that some diamonds, especially the fancy pink, yellow and blue (and other coloured ones), as well as some of the large flawless colourless diamonds are extraordinarily rare — and this is true.</p><p>No question about it. Diamonds like this represent only a very small percentage of the total jewellery-grade diamond production — but that still does not translate to <strong>all</strong> diamonds being rare.</p><p>In other words, the argument that because some natural diamonds are rare, all of them are rare, is a fallacy.</p><p><strong>“Yes, but no two diamonds are the same.”</strong></p><p>This is also true. But to some extent, so what?</p><p>It is undoubtedly true that because of the random nature of the way in which diamonds were created in the natural world, the inclusions they contain and the discrete colour of each one means that no two diamonds are identical.</p><p>By the same standard, you can walk onto a beach, pick up a grain of sand and be quite confident that there is not another one exactly like it on that beach or, quite probably, anywhere else in the world.</p><p>Does that mean that grain of sand is valuable just because it’s the only one like it in existence?</p><p>Short answer: No.</p><p>Now, I appreciate I am taking this argument to the point of the ridiculous. Diamonds are nowhere near as common as grains of sand, but ask yourself, is the average diamond you see in a jewellery shop window really all that rare?</p><p>I would argue that because there are millions out there very much like it, no, it’s not.</p><h4>Half-truth #2: Natural diamonds retain their value</h4><p>This is a common argument used to convince consumers that natural diamonds are a better buy than the new kid on the block, lab-created diamonds.</p><p>But let’s examine this claim a little more closely.</p><p>What does “retain their value” mean to you, especially in the context of a product you’d want to purchase?</p><p>On the face of it you might assume it means the diamond you buy now will still be worth some money in the future. But how much money?</p><p>Does ‘retain its value’ mean you’ll get <strong><em>all</em></strong> of your money back were you to resell it?</p><p>Does it mean you’ll get <strong><em>most</em></strong> of your money back when you resell it?</p><p>Or does it mean you’ll get <strong><em>some</em></strong> of your money back when you try to resell it?</p><p>Most of us are optimists, and when we really want something, we tend to be even more optimistic. So, when an expert tells us the thing we want to buy “retains its value”, I expect most people will want to believe they’ll get <strong>most</strong> of their money back were they to sell. Some really optimistic people might even hope to make money on their purchase.</p><p>Heads up, this is not the reality. Not for the vast majority of diamonds anyway.</p><p><strong>Diamonds are a commodity and (mostly) resell at a global commodity price</strong></p><p>Diamonds are a commodity traded on world markets every single day. And because diamonds are graded such that the quality of one can be directly compared with the quality of another diamond that’s materially the same, it’s the wholesale price that determines the value of a diamond.</p><p>What that means is, when you take your diamond along to the nearest diamond dealer, pawnbroker or jeweller, the most they’re going to pay is whatever the going wholesale price is for an equivalent stone.</p><p>After all, why on Earth would they pay more?</p><p>As a consumer, you probably paid retail, so straight up you’ve lost whatever the retailer’s mark-up was.</p><p>If that mark-up was 100%, then you might get back 50% of what you paid depending where diamond prices are at that point in time.</p><p>As the end-consumer, does that sound like your purchase “retained its value”?</p><p><strong>What about diamond jewellery?</strong></p><p>In the real world, not many people trot around with loose diamonds for sale. It’s more likely you’ll have a piece of diamond jewellery you want to turn into cash.</p><p>This complicates things somewhat because we’re now talking about the potential value of the finished piece and not necessarily the individual bits of it.</p><p>If it’s a no-name diamond ring, then its value will probably just be a function of whatever the wholesale price of the diamond is plus whatever the going rate is for the metal in the ring.</p><p>If, however, the jewellery piece is by a prestige brand or flavour-of-the-month designer, then you might do better, but don’t bank on it.</p><p>Depending on whom you talk to, dealers in used jewellery will usually only pay something like 10–35% of retail.</p><p>That’s the harsh reality. Dealers are buying your goods to resell them and they need to make a profit. That means they’re not going to pay any more than they absolutely have to.</p><p><strong>“Yes, but it’s still more than you’ll get back on a lab-diamond piece!”</strong></p><p>This is probably true. Though it’s a little early to tell because lab-created diamond jewellery hasn’t been around in quantity long enough for a second-hand market to develop.</p><p>The thing is, with lab-created diamonds selling for around 40% less than mine-origin diamonds, you have to ask yourself what might you do with the money you would save up-front rather than wonder how much you might get back sometime in the future. Especially on a piece of jewellery you might never want to sell anyway.</p><h4>Half-truth #3: Lab-created diamonds are ‘eco-friendly’</h4><p>If there’s one thing the lab-diamond industry has done really well, it’s to allow the average consumer to believe their product is generally more eco-friendly than mine-produced diamonds.</p><p>Whether or not this is actually true depends on two things. One, what ‘eco-friendly’ means to you. And two, which producer you’re buying from.</p><p>If your definition of eco-friendly means not digging great big holes in the ground, then yes, lab-created diamonds do less direct physical harm to the environment. No question about that.</p><p>But if your definition of ‘eco-friendly’ includes greenhouse gas emissions in the context of climate change, then lab-created diamonds don’t stack up nearly so well — at least not at an industry level.</p><p>The problem is, no one really knows how well, or how badly the majority of lab-diamond producers perform in terms of their carbon footprint.</p><p>A few producers, most notably, Diamond Foundry, can rightly claim a low or zero carbon footprint, but most others keep their numbers well away from public scrutiny.</p><p>By keeping quiet and using vague terms like ‘eco-friendly’, the lab-created diamond industry has benefited from consumers’ apparent willingness to believe that if some are good, all are good.</p><p>Yet this probably isn’t true — especially for those producers sited in countries that rely heavily on fossil-fuel powered electricity generation.</p><p>If you care about such things, it’s probably best to assume that most lab-created diamonds do not have a remarkably low carbon footprint.</p><p>In other words, be very careful about who you choose as your supplier. Just because it’s lab-grown, that does not automatically mean it is clean and green.</p><h4>Why do these “lies” persist?</h4><p>The answer to this is really simple — it’s to maintain prices.</p><p>At this point in time, neither the mine-origin nor the lab-created sectors can afford for consumers to lose faith in their respective products.</p><p>In November this year, De Beers, the world’s largest natural diamond producer, <a href="https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-11-04/de-beers-cuts-diamond-prices-by-about-5-as-crisis-deepens">dropped its prices by 5%</a> in the face of slow global demand.</p><p>What this did, effectively, was to devalue almost all diamond inventories around the world by about the same amount.</p><p>Remember what I said about the resale value of diamonds being tied to the current wholesale price? This applies to unsold diamond inventories just as much.</p><p>Were the buying public to lose faith in the value of diamonds such that confidence and demand dropped significantly, wholesale prices and the value of diamond inventories would drop along with it. The effect on the diamond industry could be catastrophic.</p><p>Likewise, the lab-created diamond sector can’t really afford for their eco-friendly bubble to burst either because that would destroy one of their perceived key selling points.</p><p><strong>So, why not give up on diamonds?</strong></p><p>Let me put it this way, just because many diamond marketers stretch or obscure the truth when promoting their products, that does not mean diamonds — mine-origin or lab-created — aren’t worth every cent we pay for them.</p><p>It just means that the marketers in question are too lazy, too committed to their own misinformation or too financially compromised to come up with more compelling, verifiable reasons why their product is better.</p><p>I hate that so many people in the diamond world try to fool us with half-baked arguments that don’t stand up to even cursory examination.</p><p>You should resent it too because they’re playing you.</p><p>But none of this is the fault of the diamonds themselves. It’s important to recognise that diamonds are, nonetheless, truly remarkable.</p><p>It’s remarkable that they’ve been created through natural processes. And, to me at least, it’s also remarkable that we humans have been able to replicate those processes such that mine-origin diamonds and lab-created ones are almost indistinguishable.</p><p>But their beauty and the wonder of their creation (natural or technological) is only part of the story.</p><p>Diamonds are an important part of our cultures and our economies. They deliver value way beyond their wholesale price.</p><p>And whether they come out of the ground or are produced in a factory, it’s an expensive exercise to make them available to you, the consumer.</p><p>Every legitimate business involved in this enterprise, or any other, has a right to earn a reasonable profit. And if we want our beautiful diamonds and other things, we have to pay a reasonable price for them.</p><p>But it’s also fair that we’re told the truth about what we’re buying. That’s all I want, and I don’t think that’s too much to ask. Do you?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=faa2e8d65b81" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“Ethical Jewellery” — what does that even mean?]]></title>
            <link>https://bennhw.medium.com/ethical-jewellery-what-does-that-even-mean-713fce8b15ec?source=rss-68b1fb8dec36------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/713fce8b15ec</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[sustainability]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-responsibility]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[responsible-sourcing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ethical-jewelry]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ethical-business]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Benn Harvey-Walker]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 24 Oct 2019 00:36:10 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-10-24T00:36:10.867Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*W2ElZEe7RpRc9_008pSITw.jpeg" /><figcaption>All of these rings have been made with recycled metals and feature traceable gems and diamonds — but is that enough to rate them as ethical jewellery?</figcaption></figure><h3>“Ethical Jewellery” — what does that even mean?</h3><p>Over the past couple of decades, we’ve witnessed what might be described as a tectonic shift in consumer’s attitudes towards concepts like sustainability, environmental responsibility, human rights, Fair Trade and the like.</p><p>Let’s face it, last century hardly anyone knew what these things meant, much less actively sought them out as desirable qualities in a business or product.</p><p>On top of that we’re now witnessing rapidly escalating concerns about climate change and the negative affects humans, through agriculture, industry and consumption, are having on the planet.</p><p>Gladly this change in consumer awareness and concern is causing positive change in the business world, but it is proving to be a bit of a rough ride.</p><p>One area of friction is how companies are going about communicating their commitment to improvement when promoting themselves to the buying public.</p><p>Very often businesses trying to behave responsibly and address the issues I just mentioned bundle those broad concepts together under one catch-all label, namely, “ethical”.</p><p>This bundling of ideas is convenient when it comes to conveying a simple message to consumers. The problem is however, the all-encompassing nature of the term leaves it open to misuse and abuse.</p><p>At the same time, it can mean everything and nothing, and the jewellery industry is a prime example of where this can happen. In our world, the jewellery industry’s relationship with the word ethical would probably be best described as ‘complicated’.</p><p>There are a lot of conflicting ideas about what behaving ethically (as a member of the jewellery industry) means. There are all kinds of grey areas and compromises with the only certainty being that no one business can be all things to all people. It just doesn’t work that way.</p><h4>The problem is, it’s difficult to define ‘ethical’</h4><p>A week or so ago I read a definition of ‘Ethical Jewellery’ that described it as “<em>jewellery that has no negative impact on the people who make it, or the environment it’s produced in</em>.” (1)</p><p>The problem with this is how do you define ‘no negative impact’?</p><p>Is the consumption of energy and resources to make a piece of jewellery on its own a ‘negative impact’ — given that jewellery is not one of life’s necessities like water, food and shelter?</p><p>Is digging a hole in the ground to recover diamonds, gemstones and precious metals a negative impact when the economic development afforded by such activities can lead to all sorts of local benefits including education, health and infrastructure?</p><p>And, what about displacement activities or negative consequences of change? For example, if not mining, we must ask what else might the local people do instead? They might choose activities that are even more dangerous for them or worse environmentally. Perhaps they might resort to becoming involved in criminal enterprise simply to survive. Ethically, is that in everyone’s best interests?</p><p>Another more useful definition of ‘ethical (products)’ I found was in essence:</p><p>‘<em>Products that are produced and traded in ways that avoid or lessen social, environmental, economic, cultural and/or political harm OR produce benefits to same on a local, regional, national or global scale</em>.’(2)</p><p>I think the notions of <em>lessening harm</em> and <em>increasing benefits</em> are central to the idea of operating an ethical business, in the jewellery industry or any other for that matter.</p><p>I also think the best we can do is continually strive to be better and educate those around us to be more thoughtful and considerate in their consumption habits.</p><h4>Is there an ethical ‘tipping point’?</h4><p>Doing something is almost always better than doing nothing, but surely there must be a tipping point, a point at which a business or product ceases to be simply ‘run-of-the-mill’ and can justifiably be described as ‘ethical’?</p><p>To illustrate what I mean, let me share a recent experience. I was approached by a potential supplier promoting their product. In their initial pitch I zeroed in on one word they used to describe themselves — ‘ethical’.</p><p>At first I was excited because I’m always keen to learn about new suppliers who share the same values. Sadly though, I was very quickly disappointed.</p><p>It turned out that business’s definition of <em>ethical</em> only extended to how they literally describe their business-to-business dealings. In other words, they consider that by simply obeying commercial law, they can call themselves an ethical business.</p><p>I don’t know about you, but in the context of the jewellery industry and the attention being paid to things like sustainability, eco-friendliness and so on, using the word ethical<em> </em>in a commercial context<em> </em>brings with it an expectation of a whole lot more than simply obeying the law.</p><p>Technically this business hasn’t done anything wrong, but it’s easy to see how consumers less diligent in their research might be misled.</p><h4>What else doesn’t qualify?</h4><p>Here I want to bring to the table the ideas of <em>eco-friendliness</em> and <em>sustainability</em>. Not because I don’t think they are good things, they are. I’m just not sure that, in isolation, they automatically imbue ethical status upon a business or product.</p><p>Let me give an extreme example. A manufacturer could, theoretically, use renewable energy and sustainably sourced materials to make their product, thereby ticking the eco-friendliness and sustainability boxes. Yet at the same time they could be treating their employees badly or even be using slave labour.</p><p>No reasonable person would consider that business or its products to be ethical, yet if you didn’t look past their green credentials it would be easy to rate them as a good company to do business with.</p><blockquote>“… just because something is legal, that doesn’t make it right.”</blockquote><p>Just as you can’t be half pregnant, you can’t be half ethical. You can’t do some things right and expect that to outweigh obvious wrongdoing.</p><p>In the same vein, just because something is legal, that doesn’t make it right.</p><p>In some places it may be perfectly legal to dump toxic waste into the nearest river. To my mind you can’t use legality as an excuse for immoral behaviour and still call yourself ‘ethical’.</p><h4>What’s the difference between ‘acting in good faith’ and greenwashing?</h4><p>First up, what is greenwashing?</p><p>Broadly, greenwashing describes any activity that might be seen a distraction from (or compensation for) any kind of business activity that most people would consider to be either socially or environmentally undesirable.</p><p>Greenwashing has negative connotations and the term is commonly used to denigrate certain types of business activities, but it is not always a deserved criticism.</p><p><em>Distraction</em> I have a problem with, but not compensation — provided the reason for and intent of that compensation is clearly disclosed.</p><p>For example, suppose a business does not have access to renewable energy, so to compensate they purchase carbon credits and otherwise do the best they can to be environmentally and socially responsible.</p><p>I can get behind this kind of compensatory behaviour and see it as acting in good faith.</p><p>A business however that does nothing to source and produce products responsibly or be socially responsible in its day-to-day activities but then claims to be ethical because they throw money at some vaguely related charity, well, to my mind that falls into the greenwashing category.</p><p>The distinction between acting in good faith and greenwashing, in my opinion, should be assessed in terms of intent, relevance, disclosure and actual benefit.</p><h4>Is it enough to be an ethical business?</h4><p>The point I’m making here is there’s a difference between an ethical product and an ethical business.</p><p>In practice it would be quite possible for a business to be ethical — to recycle, upcycle, use renewable energy, support relevant charities and so on, plant trees, treat staff really well and generally go above and beyond — and yet still sell products that are not produced in a particularly environmentally or socially responsible manner.</p><p>Here it’s important to recognise that if there’s no better option, then that’s as good as it gets. It’s still better than not doing anything that might be considered environmentally or socially responsible. But consumers should be aware that whilst they’re buying from an ‘ethical business’, that does not mean the product they’ve purchased is, in and of itself, an ethical one.</p><p>It’s then up to the consumer to decide whether they’re making a purchasing decision that aligns with their personal values.</p><h4>Is it enough to sell an ethical product?</h4><p>We’ve all heard of instances where high profile businesses loudly and proudly claim to be producing eco-friendly products only to discover they’re manufacturing them in sweatshops somewhere or are otherwise behaving unethically or illegally.</p><p>One does not compensate for the other.</p><p>Somewhat better than that are those businesses that sell ethical products but otherwise simply operate within the local law, not doing anything wrong, but not doing anything that might be considered ‘good corporate citizenship’ either.</p><p>Consumers might feel good about the product, but one must wonder just how committed the business owner is to the principles of environmental and social responsibility. Perhaps they’re cynically exploiting the business opportunity afforded by the ‘green shift’ in society — or maybe they’re just lazy or tight-fisted?</p><p>Either way, it’s not ideal and thoughtful consumers might do well to seek out a better alternative.</p><h4>Is there such a thing as ‘ethical jewellery’?</h4><p>Short answer: Yes, but the reality is there are degrees of being ethical ranging from ‘not very’ to ‘in, boots and all’.</p><p>Another problem in deciding whether a business and/or product is ethical is that <em>behaving ethically</em> means different things to different people.</p><p>I think most people would agree that things like exploitation, slavery, pollution, smuggling, animal cruelty, fraud and wanton environmental destruction are all unethical. That’s the baseline.</p><p>But beyond that there are many conflicting ideas and opinions about what is and isn’t ethical when it comes to things like primary industry revenue vs. habitat destruction, economic development vs. grinding poverty, recycling vs. Fair Trade, technology vs. natural, frivolous personal decoration vs. cultural necessity. Like I said earlier, it’s complicated.</p><p>Whatever your standpoint, you are free to plead your case. But ultimately, it’s up to the consumer to decide what’s important to them (outside the boundaries of what is and isn’t legal).</p><h4>How might we categorise businesses and products?</h4><p>What we need to recognise is ethics can be a very personal thing, and because of that it’s virtually impossible for a business or product to be ethical by everyone’s standards.</p><p>But if we come back to the second definition of <em>ethical</em> I cited earlier — about the general principles of lessening harm and/or producing benefits — it is possible to rank businesses and products by both your own and general societal standards.</p><p>If we evaluate businesses and products in terms of whether they lessen harm and/or deliver benefits to the community at large — be that locally or globally — you can come up with a grid where both could be categorised as follows:</p><ol><li>Unethical — they increase harm and have a negative effect on society;</li><li>Neutral — they operate within the law having no <strong>unusual</strong> net effect, good or bad; and</li><li>Ethical — they lessen harm/produce societal benefits.</li></ol><p>Combine these ideas and you get something that looks like this:</p><figure><img alt="Grid with Business Behaviour on one axis and Product Attributes on the other, each graded less to more ethical." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*56u4lohFP6NqNSVjaazFJw.jpeg" /></figure><p>From this, it’s easy to see that what we should be striving for is a situation where we’re in the ‘green zone’, operating an ethical business that sells ethical products.</p><p>To my mind, this is the ideal.</p><p>To get in the green zone though, it should be reasonable to expect that the ethical behaviour of the business is <strong>relevant</strong> to the broad impact the industry has on the environment and society. That is, we should exclude businesses from the green zone if they are obviously greenwashing.</p><h4>It is, and should be a process of continual improvement</h4><p>An important thing to recognise is that not everyone is there yet. Many businesses are working towards improving their ethical performance and we shouldn’t be too critical of them if they’re not quite there yet.</p><p>We should applaud every step in the right direction because if we don’t, it’ll all be too hard, too unrewarding and there’s a risk business owners won’t even try.</p><p>By the same token, we also need to call out lip-service and misleading or deceptive conduct for what it is.</p><p>If we don’t there’s a real risk consumers will give up and stop caring too, and no one can afford for that to happen.</p><p>References:</p><ol><li>Evening Standard, October 10, 2019 — <a href="https://www.standard.co.uk/fashion/jewellery-brands-eco-friendly-sustainable-jewellery-a4258531.html">These eco-friendly brands are seriously cool … And good for the planet</a></li><li>Bario Neal News, January 30, 2010 — <a href="https://bario-neal.com/blog/definitions-of-ethical-fair-trade-green-and-sustainable-pertaining-to-the-jewelry-industry/">Definitions of Ethical, Fair Trade, Green and Sustainable, pertaining to the Jewellery Industry</a></li></ol><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=713fce8b15ec" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Recycle | Re-make | Repair | Re-use — Jewellery and the Circular Economy]]></title>
            <link>https://bennhw.medium.com/recycle-re-make-repair-re-use-jewellery-and-the-circular-economy-aafb3a6db2?source=rss-68b1fb8dec36------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/aafb3a6db2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ethical-jewelry]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[circulareconomy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jewelry]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sustainable-business]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[recycled-jewelry]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Benn Harvey-Walker]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 18 Sep 2019 22:18:17 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-09-18T22:18:17.819Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*cxJjiTMDIhhuTFJEt0t41A.jpeg" /><figcaption>Remade entirely using materials from the owner’s collection of old family jewellery, this beautiful embrace-style ring features a Queensland sapphire set in (recycled) white gold.</figcaption></figure><h3>Recycle | Re-make | Repair | Re-use — Jewellery and the Circular Economy</h3><p>If you’re a fan of the circular economy philosophy, when it comes to jewellery, you might be wondering how you can participate.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/433/0*IAbbaAWf4W0tMFi4.jpg" /></figure><p>The idea behind a circular economy is all about creating closed loops where both waste and new inputs are minimised and existing items/materials get re-purposed, repaired or recycled.</p><p>At first glance it doesn’t seem to marry up well with the jewellery industry. After all, the jewellery world is all about sparkly new diamonds and gemstones and, if you’re that way inclined, fair-mined gold and now ‘salmon gold’ — all of which are new inputs. New inputs that many people around the world rely upon heavily for their economic well-being.</p><p>There’s no denying that (almost) the entire jewellery retail scene is geared towards ‘new’. New designs, new fashions, new designers, new mines, new sources, new technology. And there are strong justifications for allowing this to continue — particularly the positives that can flow from responsible economic development.</p><p>On top of that, to meet the demands of growing populations and increasing global consumerism, it doesn’t seem likely that the jewellery industry is ever going to be an ideal circular system.</p><p>On a side note, you could argue that if consumers adopted a ‘buy once, buy well’ philosophy there’d be relatively little jewellery available to re-enter the loop so the opportunity to create a circular system would be minimal anyway.</p><p>The reality is though, there will always be unwanted and obsolete jewellery so the principles of a circular economy can be applied. And there’s no reason at all why you can’t participate.</p><h3>How does the circular economy idea work when it comes to jewellery?</h3><p>The good news about jewellery, particularly fine jewellery, is most of the components that go into making it are entirely recyclable.</p><p>Precious metals like gold, silver and platinum can be recycled over and over again with no loss of quality. Diamonds and gemstones, of course, don’t wear out or ‘go off’ either. (They might suffer some damage over time, but they can often be re-polished or even re-cut to make them like new again.)</p><p>It’s a different story with costume jewellery unfortunately. Many of the elements that go into making cheap jewellery don’t have enough intrinsic value to make recycling economically viable. But that doesn’t mean it has to sit in your jewellery box forever, or worse still, wind up in landfill.</p><p>So, all that said, how can you do your bit?</p><p>Here are four ways you can start acting ‘circular’ when it comes to your jewellery.</p><h3>1) Cash out first (that is, put it back in the system)</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/433/0*tj3Lj6umCh444gzE.jpg" /></figure><p>Leaving jewellery lying around the house that you no longer wear doesn’t do anyone any good, so why not cash out?</p><p>Take it to a second-hand dealer, put it on Ebay, Gumtree, Facebook Marketplace or the like, add it to your next garage sale, take it to a precious metals refiner or, at the very least donate it to a charity shop. Just don’t let it gather dust.</p><p>If you can’t recycle or re-purpose it, that doesn’t mean someone else can’t.</p><p>By the way, if your jewellery includes gold, silver or platinum, it could be worth a surprising amount just for the metal. Take a look at the ‘What metal is it?’ panel to identify what you’ve got.</p><p>Once you’ve cashed out, or have at least made room in your jewellery box, then start looking at what comes next.</p><h3>2) Recycle or re-purpose</h3><p>Missing an earring? Perhaps the other one could be pulled apart and turned into something else?</p><p>Maybe that pendant you don’t wear anymore could become a key ring, go on a charm bracelet or maybe your pet dog or cat could use a bit of bling on their collar?</p><p>Perhaps the diamonds in that ring you inherited from Grandma could be made into earrings?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/433/0*1Nr4j2hPVuCPbnVC.jpg" /></figure><p>If you’re starting with something that has some reasonable value — a small collection of old gold rings, maybe a pendant and some earrings with nice stones in them, you could easily turn those into something you could cherish.</p><p>It wouldn’t be the first time old family jewellery went into something special like a dress ring, an ‘in memoriam’ pendant or even an engagement ring.</p><p>You do need to start with something of value (or high sentimental value) to make it worthwhile though. The labour cost of a custom make can be high. Depending on what you’re wanting to do, labour alone could easily start at five hundred dollars and go up a lot from there.</p><p>Of course, if you’re supplying most or even some of the materials, it could still be cheaper than buying an equivalent new piece off the shelf. Plus you’ll have something that’s handmade and uniquely yours.</p><h3>3) Start with second-hand</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/433/0*NNLUY1l8rf22oQbM.jpg" /></figure><p>The harsh reality of jewellery retail is the moment a piece leaves the store, it drops considerably in value — sometimes by as much as 60–80%. But as a buyer that means you can get some real bargains.</p><p>The first step is to find yourself a friendly manufacturing jeweller who enjoys re-making and repairing jewellery. Someone who’ll work with you to re-size, modify or maybe even completely rebuild a piece.</p><p>Then you need to go and find yourself something that has the potential to be given a new lease on life.</p><p>Of course, it’s not quite as easy as it sounds, but if you take some time to educate yourself, there’s no reason at all why you can’t take something old and make it spectacularly new again.</p><h3>4) Prefer recycled and vintage</h3><p>If you don’t have old jewellery to begin with and the whole idea of trawling through antique shops and car boot sales looking for a bargain fills you with dread, that doesn’t mean you can’t do your bit.</p><p>Recycled precious metals are readily available to the average jeweller, so there’s no reason why you can’t have it in your jewellery. Likewise, vintage and recycled diamonds and gemstones are available commercially.</p><p>The trick is to seek out a jeweller who has taken the time to establish relationships with the right suppliers. (One way to find them is to start with a small-scale precious metal refiner or a reseller of vintage jewellery, loose diamonds and gemstones and go from there. It’s likely they’ll be able to direct you to someone you can work with.)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/433/0*DekmuFKWiITdOr3s.jpg" /></figure><p>The right jeweller will probably even have a relationship with a gem cutter who could re-cut and polish a gemstone if you found one you liked but needed a touch-up.</p><p>Unfortunately, when it comes to recycled and vintage diamonds and gemstones, one challenge is you may not always be able to get exactly what you want.</p><p>Until recycling diamonds and gemstones becomes more mainstream in the jewellery world, you just can’t get the variety and depth of selections available on the new market. But where there’s a will there’s a way. It’s just a matter of being a bit flexible in your design and budget.</p><h3>Don’t forget the ‘sunk cost’</h3><p>Every piece of jewellery has a sunk cost of some kind. The cost of digging raw materials out of the ground. The cost to the environment in terms of habitat destruction and greenhouse gas emissions. And the cost to people — in the worst of cases in the form of exploitation, slavery and conflict.</p><p>To not re-use those materials for which many people (and the planet) have already paid a price — often a hefty one — is, at the very least, wasteful. You could even say disrespectful if you feel strongly enough about these things.</p><p>In this day and age of dwindling resources, re-using, repairing, re-purposing and recycling are not only the right things to do, they can be very rewarding as well — especially when it comes to jewellery.</p><p>At the very least it just makes good sense, economically and morally, to do it.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=aafb3a6db2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The diamond world is at war. Whose side are you on?]]></title>
            <link>https://bennhw.medium.com/the-diamond-world-is-at-war-whose-side-are-you-on-a8ea6fa64186?source=rss-68b1fb8dec36------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a8ea6fa64186</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[diamond-industry]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[diamonds]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ethical-jewelry]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jewelry-industry]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lab-created-diamonds]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Benn Harvey-Walker]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 16 Aug 2019 01:01:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-08-16T01:01:13.981Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*irLETOgpUdTjoRJVKpOfTA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Lab-created or mine-origin … which diamonds are right for your business?</figcaption></figure><blockquote>As demand slumps and prices drop, the diamond industry looks to be heading into a crisis phase — at least that’s what industry insiders are saying. Couple that with increasing competition between mine-origin and lab-created producers and you have a recipe for uncertainty, stress and finger-pointing. But as a jeweller or jewellery retailer, is picking a side a good idea?</blockquote><p>If the idea of ‘war’ and ‘picking sides’ sounds a bit melodramatic, that may be so, but now more than ever those at the consumer-end of the diamond supply chain need to pay close attention to what’s going on.</p><p>In a recent article published by <em>Diamond AnalyticsTM</em>, Paul Zimnisky reported that the mine-origin diamond industry is considered by many to be in crisis. With the perfect storm of a global economic slowdown, a trade war between the US and China, tightening bank financing, and, as it turns out, over supply from the mine producers themselves, mine-origin diamond prices are dropping and the dealers and a bunch of other middlemen are getting very nervous as cash flow grinds to a halt.</p><p>Meanwhile, mine-origin diamond industry heavyweights are blaming lab-created diamond producers for many of their woes, calling foul on what they feel is unfair competition. At the same time, lab-created producers are taking advantage of the mine-origin Achilles heels — questionable ethics and higher pricing for, arguably, an identical product.</p><p>For those of us on the receiving end of all this turmoil — as diamond buyers close to, or at the customer interface — it’s time to take stock and decide who deserves our loyalty.</p><p>Of course, it should go without saying our customers should come first, but there’s still a choice to be made. The problem is the diamond industry (mine- and factory-origin) is spinning biased and selectively edited information that makes both sides look really good and really bad at the same time.</p><h4>No one buys from an industry</h4><p>Before I start picking things apart, I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again, <em>no one buys from an industry</em>. Jewellers and jewellery retailers buy from a selected group of diamond wholesalers or dealers.</p><p>And, importantly, what might be broadly true for the industry as a whole, might not be true for a specific producer, wholesaler or dealer. This cuts both ways — good and bad.</p><p>If your primary concern is looking after your customers (which is how I think it should be), then you need to look past the industry bluster, hype and generalisations and focus on whether your chosen suppliers are worthy of your loyalty.</p><p>Just because they’re aligned with either the mine-origin or lab-created camp does not automatically make them the good guys or the bad guys.</p><p>You need to work with suppliers who reflect your values and the values of your customers by the way they conduct their business.</p><p>That said, let’s take a look at the arguments lab-created and mine-origin pundits are presenting to defend their various positions.</p><p>Let’s start with the headline act …</p><h4>Which is more ethical — mine-origin or lab-created?</h4><p>Whilst there are many nuanced and detailed arguments under the heading of ‘ethical’, I’m going to broadly describe diamond industry ethics as covering two key considerations:</p><ol><li>Environmental issues; and</li><li>Human rights issues (including conflict funding and other criminal activity).</li></ol><p>Fortunately for the mine-origin sector, public discussion about the relative environmental responsibility of mine-origin versus lab-created has centered around their respective carbon footprints.</p><p>It might sound counter-intuitive to say the mine-based producers have benefited. After all, lab-created producers were able to grab a lot of media attention by claiming much smaller carbon emissions per carat produced. But that may yet turn around and bite them hard.</p><p>As time goes by it’s becoming apparent that the lab-grown sector has been riding on the coattails of few high-performers whilst the majority may, in fact, perform abysmally.</p><p>The problem is no one really knows. The lab-created industry is unyielding when it comes to publishing verifiable information about their actual carbon cost of production.</p><p>Let’s just say trust levels relating to lab-created diamond industry claims are rapidly being eroded. Meanwhile the mine-origin industry is happily pushing a recent <em>Diamond Producers Association</em>-funded report that claims mine-origin diamonds have a much smaller carbon footprint (by supposedly two-thirds) than lab-created.</p><p>On this, call me cynical but I have a lot of trouble trusting any industry-funded report. There are simply too many ways to slice and dice the data to support your argument.</p><p>Take for example a similar report published by the <em>International Grown Diamond Association</em> in 2014. It claimed lab-created diamonds had carbon footprint 1.5 billion times smaller than mine-origin.</p><p>It was hard to believe back then. These days that claim is laughable.</p><p>The other thing that has been to the benefit of the mine-origin industry is that all the attention being given to carbon emissions has drawn the focus away from other important environmental issues like habitat destruction, pollution and ecosystem disruption.</p><p>I’m sure as far as the mine-origin industry is concerned, the less said about these things the better.</p><p>Mine-origin supporters have been vigorously attacking dubious claims made by lab-created producers, calling those claims unethical. But let’s be clear, the mine-origin sector lost the right to claim the ethical high ground long ago.</p><h4>Not just mining companies</h4><p>Importantly, the mine-origin industry isn’t just made up of mining companies. Sitting in between them and the consumer are a bunch of middlemen with their fingers in the pie, including the bourses, financiers, the cutting and polishing industry, dealers, wholesalers and other assorted hangers-on.</p><p>This is important because the ethical credentials of a product don’t rest solely on what happens at the mine site or in the factory.</p><p>You can’t ignore the behaviour of all those who sit between the producer and the retailer. And, let’s be frank, throughout history the diamond industry supply chain has been remarkably adept at turning a blind eye when it comes to environmental concerns, human rights and criminal conduct.</p><h4>Who demonstrates more humanity — mine-origin or lab-created?</h4><p>Once again I must stress that it is not right to tar everyone in one sector or the other with the same brush. Just because a diamond came out of a mine does not mean it has been tainted by anything resembling human rights abuses.</p><p>Similarly, just because a diamond has been grown in a factory, that does not automatically mean someone or some thing hasn’t suffered for its creation somewhere along the line — potentially in cutting factories or somewhere else in the supply chain.</p><p>You need to examine your suppliers case by case and if they can’t or won’t disclose the origin and production history of the diamonds you’re looking at, it’s time to find another supplier. (Or if that’s not practical, take the burden of making good upon yourself.)</p><p>But let’s get back to human rights and humanity in the industry generally.</p><p>Again, there’s no escaping the fact that the diamond mining industry has a sordid history involving slavery, exploitation, child labour and general skulduggery from the present day going back decade upon decade.</p><p>Just as bad are the intermediaries who have, and often still ignore the fact that a percentage of diamonds on the market today are untraceable. Such diamonds could have come from conflict areas, have been smuggled, been used to launder money in some criminal enterprise or have otherwise been sourced via illegal mining. But that possibility is often conveniently ignored.</p><p>Let’s face it, where large amounts of money are involved, particularly when associated with a highly desirable, untraceable and very portable product it’s not surprising that human rights get violated, laws get broken and the truth gets stretched beyond redemption.</p><p>On the question of more or less humanity at a broad, industry level, based on current information you’d have to place lab-created ahead of mine-origin — because of the issues of conflict-funding, child labour, other human rights abuses and so on.</p><h4>What about economic development?</h4><p>Supporting economic development, particularly in developing nations, is a strong argument in favour of the mine-origin sector.</p><p>But whether or not this a valid argument depends a lot on who actually benefits.</p><p>No question the extractive industries generate a lot of wealth in countries fortunate enough to have mineral wealth to exploit, but who actually benefits the most?</p><p>You’d have to be Pollyanna to think that mining companies go into a country with the benevolent intent of solely boosting the local economy. Of course they don’t.</p><p>Much of the wealth gets created on foreign shores.</p><p>This is also true in the lab-created sector. Most of their factories are sited in India and China where real estate, electricity and life is cheap. The real money gets made elsewhere.</p><p>The good news is there are exceptions in both camps.</p><p>If you want to do the right thing by your customers, these are the companies you need to seek out. Remember, you’re buying from a business made up of people, not a faceless industry.</p><p>Don’t be misled into believing one industry sector is, by default, more ethical than the other. You need to do your homework and look for the shining stars.</p><h4>Which is better value?</h4><p>There are two things I want to pick up on here — changing consumer priorities and retained value.</p><p>Let’s start with retained value.</p><p>Mine-origin promoters commonly claim that their product is a much better store of value than their lab-created competitor’s product, but is this really true?</p><p>Part of the pro-mine-origin argument rests on the fact that (theoretically) lab-created diamonds could be produced in unlimited quantities whereas mine-origin stones are a finite resource and will become more rare as time goes by.</p><p>This claim is backed up by the following:</p><ul><li>There is no resale market for lab-created diamonds — not yet anyway;</li><li>Some mine-origin diamonds (especially rare coloured gems) retain, and even increase in value over time; and</li><li>There is a market for secondhand diamonds, so they are somewhat liquid.</li></ul><p>But here’s the thing, not all diamonds are equal.</p><p>It’s absolutely correct that some mine-origin diamonds are a great investment, but that does not mean all diamonds are a good store of value. That simply isn’t true.</p><p>And here’s a sobering fact, in the past 10 years alone, some 350 to 400 million carats of jewellery grade diamonds have been extracted from the ground. Annual production currently sits at around 35 to 40 million carats per annum.</p><p>Does that sound like a rare product to you?</p><p>Unquestionably there are some incredibly unique and valuable diamonds scattered amongst those 30–40 million carats produced each year, but that does not make every diamond special. Investing in diamonds is a very different exercise than simply buying a piece of diamond jewellery, so don’t let your customers be misled by the glitz and glamour.</p><h4>Are mine-origin diamonds a good store of value?</h4><p>Ignoring the investment diamond space (because that’s a whole different ballgame), if you’re of the opinion that buying diamond jewellery is a safe place for your customers to park their money, then you should think again. The reality is they will most likely be very disappointed when they go to cash out.</p><p>You only need to take a look at the recycled and vintage diamond market to know that to be true.</p><p>In an apples-with-apples comparison, it’s highly unlikely you’ll find a recycled or vintage diamond selling at the same price as a newly mined one. At best it might go for 80% of the price of a ‘new’ stone.</p><p>But that’s the resellers price. They’re not going to pay an owner anything like 80% of retail. More likely they’ll pay something like 35–40% of retail for a secondhand diamond so there’s some margin in it when they go to resell it.</p><p>In other words, the average diamond drops in value by about 60–70% the moment it leaves the store and is unlikely to ever do much better than that — unless sold privately. Selling privately might see a customer recover 70–80% of their initial outlay — if they’re a good negotiator.</p><p>So, does this make mine-origin diamonds a good store of value? You be the judge.</p><p>It’s probably true that mine-origin diamonds will retain more value than lab-created equivalents, but in reality that remains to be seen.</p><h4>Are consumers’ priorities changing?</h4><p>Recently the CEO of DeBeers, Bruce Cleaver, expressed that he thought Millennials would continue to covet mine-origin diamonds in the same way their parents and grandparents do (or did).</p><p>I suspect this statement is designed to reassure a jittery diamond market during tough times, but I don’t believe it myself.</p><p>With much better access to information and better protections from misleading advertising, alongside concerns about climate change and exploitation of our fellow humans, Millennials and Gen Z don’t view the world with the same naivety and blissful ignorance their parents and grandparents did.</p><p>They ask questions their forebears didn’t even think to ask, so you cannot expect the same marketing approaches will work for them as did previous generations.</p><h4>As a retail jeweller, which is better for your business?</h4><p>There are a couple of ways to look at this question.</p><p>One consideration is whether lab-created or mine-origin diamonds are going to help you generate more profit. The other is which aligns best with the ethics of your business.</p><p>In terms of profitability, whether you choose to sell lab-created diamonds is not just about margins, it’s also about how your business is positioned in the market.</p><p>If you’re selling at the top end of town where perceived prestige is more important than almost anything else, then your customers might think it incongruent for you to sell anything other than what many regard as “real” diamonds. In which case, selling lab-created alongside mine-origin might harm your business.</p><p>If, however, your customer base is more value conscious and less tied in to the so-called ‘tradition and romance’ of mine-origin diamonds, then lab-created could be a boon for you.</p><p>Whilst lab-created diamonds sell for about 35–40% less than equivalent mine-origin stones, the margins are still good, so that’s appealing. And many customers will still spend up to their budget rather than keep the savings. (Choosing lab-created means they can afford larger and/or higher specification diamonds.)</p><p>Being able to offer a more affordable product may also help with your conversion rate.</p><p>Selling lab-created diamonds might result in the average value of a sale going down, but it’s likely that will be off-set by more sales and sustained margins.</p><h4>All that said, which side do you pick: lab-created or mine-origin?</h4><p>To a large extent, whether you go mine-origin, lab-created or both depends (as I said earlier) on the positioning of your business.</p><p>All else aside, if operating an ethical business is a primary driver, then there’s a strong argument to offer both — provided you carefully select your suppliers.</p><p>There’s no denying mining does a lot of harm, but it also does a lot of good — particularly in many developing nations — so writing off mine-origin indiscriminately doesn’t necessarily help make things better.</p><p>Likewise, there are still questions to be answered about the true carbon footprint credentials of lab-created diamonds. There’s no denying they have less direct impact on the environment and their human rights record is significantly cleaner, but we should not yet regard lab-created diamonds as environmental knights in shining armour.</p><p>For now at least, there is no reason why both products can’t be sold side by side to satisfy the needs and wants of your customers. All you need to do is be responsible and transparent about what you’re doing and why you’re doing it.</p><p>Ultimately though, whether you’re making things better or worse as a whole comes down to, as I’ve said several times already, your choice of supplier.</p><p>Forget about the industry. You don’t owe either the lab-grown or mine-origin sector anything. But do look out for the suppliers who do the right thing. They deserve your loyalty.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a8ea6fa64186" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>