<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Betty Lilly on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Betty Lilly on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@bettylilly26?source=rss-15f7bf7b5ec3------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 15:08:36 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@bettylilly26/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Manufacturing Justice: Project Veritas and My Son]]></title>
            <link>https://bettylilly26.medium.com/manufacturing-justice-project-veritas-and-my-son-89e8660f972c?source=rss-15f7bf7b5ec3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/89e8660f972c</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Betty Lilly]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 29 Oct 2020 16:20:41 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-11-03T02:39:53.706Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Manufacturing Justice: Project Veritas and my son</p><p>Dear sisters,</p><p>Late in the morning of January 20, 2017, my son, your nephew, phoned home from Washington, DC, to tell us he feared he was about to be arrested. Then his phone died. We would not hear or speak to him during the following thirty-six hours, but that phone call bifurcated our lives. There was life before that call; there is life after the call. There is disjunction between the two eras of our lives. For me, his called moved me from innocence to experience. The experience was an immersion into the justice system, a system I now know as corrupt and built upon a set of interlocking institutions that reinforce each other, all leading to what feels like an inevitable conclusion of incarceration All that I saw that was wrong with the justice system, seems to be intensifying under the current administration. These institutions are coming to be more and more controlled by fascist power.</p><p>Our cousins have been posting propaganda as truth on Facebook. It has been created by the right-wing conspiracy theory group Project Veritas. This group is especially hateful to me because that group presented false evidence to the prosecuting attorney about my son after he was arrested during a protest on January 20, 2017, the day of Trump’s inauguration. Project Veritas’s “evidence” led to seven felony counts against my son and threatened him with seventy years in jail for walking down the street with a sign.</p><p>Our cousins’ attitudes did not matter so much when a white supremacist was not in the WH. When we did not have a fascist leading the national government, it did not matter that people who are superficially nice have reprehensible political views and take reprehensible political positions. We could get along with them anyway. We could be “nice” and chat. Of course, while our cousins may exude a certain warmth, they are not really “nice” to their African American relatives, that is my husband and children. I have been invited to their homes and brought my children with me only to walk into rooms where they were finishing n*gger jokes. That is not hospitable or nice or at all loving. Do you remember this incident, my dear younger sister? You were with me that day. Perhaps you do not remember because, after all, you do not have mixed-race children who were being dehumanized while they were guests in our cousins’ home.</p><p>Our cousins’ promotion of Project Veritas propaganda makes clear that our cousins are straight-up Nazis. They are white supremacists; they are fascists. They would have supported my son’s incarceration, to his spending seventy years in jail for exercising his Constitutional right to protest. They are a dire threat to my family. I hope you both understand this. Unless you actively work against their fascist ideology, you are supporting that ideology and the violence that comes with it. There is no middle ground.</p><p>Trump, a white supremacist, leads the national government, and many people’s lives have been taken and many more are at risk. The more than 200,000 deaths thus far caused by COVID, deaths primarily of Brown and Black bodies are evidence this is not a culture of life party. The party is gleefully risking the lives of my interracial family, our eldest sister’s interracial family and many, many more people of color who are now protesting. I need you to understand the stakes in the upcoming election.</p><p>Let me get a bit more specific so you understand my concern about the propaganda being spread by our cousins, relatives with whom you happily consort. Project Veritas was founded in 2010. Affiliated with Erik Prince, Secretary of Education Betsy DeVos’s brother and founder of Blackwater, the private mercenary organization working throughout the world, Project Veritas regularly targets and infiltrates and then secretly records organizations working toward a more just society. One of its first sting operations was against a group called ACORN, a group that registered the poor to vote. Using deceptive video editing, the group created a false narrative that ACORN was promoting prostitution and tax evasion. These accusations led Congress to defund ACORN, thereby suppressing the votes of the poor, disproportionately Brown and Black people across the nation. Another of its sting operations was against Planned Parenthood. In that operation, they created a false narrative of Planned Parenthood profiting off the sale of fetal tissue. Planned Parenthood also lost funding, a group that provides healthcare primarily for poor women.</p><p>In each of these instances, Project Veritas functioned as an extra-governmental hit team for right-wing legislatures and legislators. It went undercover and then created “evidence” that provided false narratives to lead to unequivocal losses for poor people and people of color, obviously most of whom are women. It has now expanded its realm of operations to “aiding” the police. It infiltrates organizations, videotapes them, and tampers with that evidence to ensnare, prosecute, and imprison protesters of resistance to an authoritarian system. They pose a real and increasing threat to the nation as a whole.</p><p>Project Veritas’s vast resources targeted my son. In the months between the 2016 election and Inauguration Day, <a href="https://psmag.com/social-justice/j20-defendants-and-the-crackdown-on-protest">Project Veritas and another right wing group, Oath Keepers</a>, began recording meetings of an organization planning protests during inauguration. Project Veritas’s recordings were made available to police, indeed, led to police targeting certain protests on January 20, 2017. The police gleefully planned a crackdown on these protesters. Reporting of the event shows the language of police in planning documents to be ghastly. It reveals that for the police, the force to be used against protesters, the non-lethal force of tear gas and flash bombs, was exciting: the day would be a sort of carnival, a day of freedom on which sadism could be unleashed.</p><p>While my son, your nephew, had no contact with the group Project Veritas was targeting, he and several college friends had decided to go to anti-Trump protests on Inauguration Day. They had chosen a couple of groups to protest with but could not find them among the crowds. He and his friends marched along with the first protest they found. The DC police, who had been fed information by Project Veritas, surrounded the protest my son and his friends had joined. The police thereby separated the group of the friends: about half of them were outside the circle of police; three of them were inside the police ring. Our boy was inside that ring. He and the others within the perimeters of the police line were unsure of what to do. One wanted to run, but older people marching alongside them suggested that they hang tight, that the police would not arrest the hundreds of people within the police line. The three of them discussed it. One decided to try to break free. He cut through the line of police and ran. He was followed for several blocks before the police gave up the chase.</p><p>The other two remained inside the police line and continued marching until the police pushed them into a confined space, up against a building, at the corner of 12th and L Streets. This way of surrounding protesters, disabling their ability to disperse, is called kettling. It was at this point that these two young men saw that they were going to be arrested. Our son called home and told us what he was afraid of — then his phone charge died. After conferring, the two young men decided to make a run for it. One of them, a small, compact young fellow, pushed his way out under the arms of the cordon while my son, a tall gangly fellow, was smashed to the ground by police and remained inside the police circle. He was then left without friends among the protesters whom he had just met. All of this took place by noon on January 20, 2017.</p><p>While held within the kettle, the protesters were heavily tear-gassed, soaked to the skin with the chemical irritant. It burns the skin, but it is also wet. The temperatures that day were in the thirties Fahrenheit and it rained off and on (despite Trump’s lie of steady sunshine). Some protesters shared dry clothing with my son to protect him from the cold. Teargas was sprayed into protesters’ eyes, temporarily blinding them. My son did not know this was temporary. Luckily there were medics embedded in the protest who treated his eyes with milk of magnesia, alleviating the effects of teargas. The kindness of strangers is a wonderful thing.</p><p>The folks were kettled for hours. They had no access to restrooms. They had to use the street, the sides of the building. After many hours, protesters were handcuffed with zip ties, hands behind their backs. The zip tie they used on my son was so tight that his wrists bled. The protesters were then forced into vans, ostensibly to be transported to various precinct jails. But they weren’t all transported. My son was placed in a van with several other people. They were left in that van between three and four hours. When I heard that my son had been left in a van for that long, I collapsed; my legs gave out. My body, not my conscious mind, made the connection to Freddie Gray, whose death was sealed in the back of a police van. I learned in that moment the terror every African American knows all their lives. Suddenly.</p><p>My terror was sudden, dear sisters, because we are white, our family is white. While we grew up on the fringe of acceptable society in our small town, while we were poor and ashamed, children of a schizophrenic woman and an alcoholic father, we were by and large given the benefit of the doubt by teachers and others. We had a hard growing-up, but we were not routinely suspected of wrongdoing. The good will toward us was due to accidents of birth: we were white, and we were bright. Let me repeat, the presumption of innocence that we were blessed with was an accident of birth.</p><p>When I married a Black man, that presumption of innocence changed. I confronted the daily indignities of being Black by proxy: the first indignity was that the man I was dating could not get us a taxi during the rain after a date at the theater; the second, more egregious, was that we were denied access to an apartment that I wanted to rent when upon arrival, the landlady saw my fiancé. By the time we had children, I found myself unsurprised but frightened to learn from a friend that while the family was shoe shopping, he saw my husband had been watched, suspected of shoplifting by his fellow employees. I have come to expect these indignities. Despite these experiences, I did not believe that my sons would suffer, as their father has and does from racism, because they are biracial. Their skin tone and hair color mark them as “white” at first glance. I thought my love could protect them, and did not feel the onerous weight of daily fearing for their lives if they put a foot out of line or if they were stopped for a traffic violation.</p><p>Until I heard my son was held inside of a van between three or four hours because the police “forgot” him. (I have since heard similar stories from those arrested in protests. It is an intimidation tactic, standard in police departments across the country.) Until that moment, I had never felt the weight of law enforcement as deadly threat. I do now. I fear the police with fear I had only known during our father’s violent rages. I see that to be African American is to be subject as we were as children in our family to a capricious and unreasonable rage. Except that of course, the threat for the African American community does not allow any relaxation. All police are threats. All might kill. And police are everywhere in Black communities. The police threat is all-pervasive: cops are and can be daily inexplicably and dangerously angry. You cannot recover from a threat that is ongoing. That is the police threat to all African Americans.</p><p>But back to my story, inside the van, the protesters, after having been soaked with tear gas and left in the cold, now began to sweat. The tear gas left on their skin and hair dripped back into their eyes. They could not wipe any of this tear gas away, however, because their hands were behind their backs. They were once more in pain and unable to see. For hours. Again, with no bathrooms.</p><p>My son was taken to one precinct jail after another all night. I know because I spent the entire night calling for him at each of the precincts across the city. They told me he had been arrested, but they did not, could not tell me where he was. He was not able to sleep because he was moved about all night. He was held for about 36 hours before his arraignment. During that time, he was given no water; he was never given the opportunity to call me and his father; he was deprived of sleep. He was brought to court in chains around his ankles and his wrists with a chain linking the two late on the day after the inauguration, Saturday evening.</p><p>At that arraignment, he was charged with one felony that carried with it a sentence of up to ten years in prison. He was finally released without bail (DC has a no cash bail system). He kept with him only the clothes on his back. His backpack, his wallet, his keys, his phone had all been seized. He was released at 10 in the evening without a dime on him, without his phone, in the middle of a city he did not know. Luckily, he had made that single call before his phone went dead to his father. Otherwise, we would not have known where he was. Luckily, our other sister lives in striking distance of DC. He was met by her at the courthouse when he was released. He went to her home and spent the night. After some consultation, he returned to college where he finished his semester.</p><p>Within a few months, a superseding indictment by Assistant US Attorney Jennifer Kerkoff would charge him with seven felonies, all conspiracy related rioting charges, based primarily on the evidence collected by Project Veritas. We hired a lawyer, at considerable expense. His case was first heard by a Judge Lynn Lebovitz. He, and by extension, we were required to attend three status hearings before his trial began. Lebovitz allowed the Project Veritas footage as evidence despite clear evidence of tampering, despite Project Veritas’s terrible track record of deception, despite clear collusion between police and Project Veritas. This corrupt organization became an arm of the state’s oppression against my son.</p><p>The period from the time of arrest to the time of our son’s scheduled trial lasted about eighteen months. Our son was deeply affected. While he managed to finish two semesters at college during this period, he tried to commit suicide on his twentieth birthday, just as the first trial began, and we realized that he needed to take a leave of absence from college, to be home while the trials were ongoing.</p><p>Ours is not an impoverished family. We are not a family without resources. We are middle class. We have benefits and vacation time. Yet we had to borrow money to hire the attorney. We used all of our vacation days travelling back and forth to DC from our home state for case status hearings. We spent thousands on therapy. Keeping up his spirits and our own while managing the minutiae of the trial was exhausting. It was all so terrifying.</p><p>You know I had no relevant personal history to help me navigate the maze of this experience. I could not speak to my son’s experience in these moments because I had never lived through such an enormous threat. Feeling the weight of the federal government bureaucracy arrayed against my son was humbling. My boy, my first-born, a child into whom I had poured love and affection and for whom I dreamed the world, was facing seventy years in prison. And it was all my doing. As an outgrowth of my Christian roots, I had led him to peaceful civic engagement to defend and aid the oppressed. For acting on the beliefs I had taught, he was facing life in prison. The experience was surreal, Kafkaesque, a nightmare from which I could not wake. Yet my sense of the surreal is another mark of privilege. African Americans have always lived in a Kafkaesque world in which the Justice Department is a contradiction in terms, an oxymoron. As a white American, I thought it worked. I thought it worked. I am so ashamed of my naivete.</p><p>No, I knew about the oppression under which Black folks live. I had been part of BLM protests in the small city where my sons grew up, because police shot and killed Black men here. I knew my son’s friends Black friends were regularly harassed by police. I knew about Freddie Gray, about Sandra Bland, about Trayvon Martin and Eric Garner and so many others. I knew about case after case of Black folks lost because of law enforcement. I went to protests and wrote to my representatives. There are two systems of justice in this nation, one that is for Black folks and one for white folks. I had hoped that my sons would never be subjected to a system reserved for Black people. I had hoped they would continue to be protected by their fair skin. Indeed, I counted on it. I never anticipated that the weight of a corrupt system of laws and law enforcement would impact my precious son. I wanted him to be seen as white so that he would not suffer oppression. But as MLK said, “Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere.”</p><p>During that time in our lives, in my son’s life, I needed a story to help him hope, to give him strength. As you know, my sisters, I had no relevant personal or family history to draw upon. The only help I could offer came from his father’s family history, a history of deep oppression. I found myself relying on the reality that my son’s great-grandfather, the man who raised his father and for whom he is named, had older siblings and parents born into slavery. My son’s namesake was raised on the plantation where his siblings and his parents had been enslaved and had fled North at the age of ten. My son needed them and their faith during those terrible months. The history of my whiteness and my privilege could not help him. He needed to be reminded of his father’s family. If they could endure slavery, survive Jim Crow, he could endure prison should it come. If they could hope, who was he to despair? He needed to remember that their blood runs through his veins and that he owed it to their memory to persevere.</p><p>Most of the people arrested with my son were white. And whiteness helps get attention. Our son’s prospects changed dramatically when Judge Liebovitz was taken off the case and Judge Morin took it over. The Project Veritas “evidence” that had been spliced and diced in such a way that it led to a false narrative of a conspiracy of violence was eventually thrown out of court. Judge Morin ruled that the prosecuting attorney, Assistant US Attorney in the District of Columbia Jennifer Kerkoff, who brought that case knew the video evidence was false, had withheld exculpatory evidence. Morin’s rebuke led to Kerkoff dropping all charges levelled against your nephew.</p><p>We had a happy ending but not before eighteen months passed; not before a suicide attempt; not before the loss of a semester of schooling; not before spending tens of thousands of dollars; not before we were on our way to Washington DC for the fourth time to attend the trial. Our son’s case was dismissed because they had no evidence, because it was frivolous.</p><p>Before Kerkoff took this case she was a prosecuting attorney for murder cases in the District. One cannot but wonder how often she cooked the evidence in those cases. One cannot but wonder if our case had not been so large, if so many of the defendants had not been white, if good lawyers had not been hired, one cannot but wonder how a single defendant would have had a chance against the power of the federal government, a racist right-wing police force, and Project Veritas, a corrupt and deeply funded organization that actively works against democracy — all working hand in glove — would ever have had a chance. How many of her convictions were achieved by creating false evidence?</p><p>Our happy ending occurred because of a single judge. With the number of new judges put on the bench by Trump and McConnell, it is unclear if this favorable result will be repeated for protesters who follow. Project Veritas, and now Trump’s Attorney General Bill Barr (installed since this case ended), will be responsible for the imprisonment of more and other protesters across the nation. The protesters will be charged and imprisoned on false pretenses. This is the exact sort of thing that the Nazis did. They stacked the courts and made up evidence.</p><p>I used to believe there were two systems of justice in this country, one for white people and one for Black people, and that we needed to expand the better one, the one for white people, to everyone. Perhaps there is a single justice system that treats Black much worse than white folks, but also that the justice system is any case mostly unfair and stacked against defendants, and is a system with which most white middle-class people never interact.</p><p>That force of that system is coming to apply as much to white folks as Black folks. What my son experienced was an industry with its own logic and inertia. Project Veritas, the police, the prosecuting attorney, and the judges function as elements in a supply chain in manufacturing false justice. Project Veritas creates false evidence; feeds it to police; the police bring that evidence and those arrested to the prosecuting attorneys; the prosecuting attorneys bring it to the judges; and because the attorneys have gravitas and authority, the judges declare it admissible. People are arrested, charged, tried, convicted. What broke the chain in J20 for my son was one judge.</p><p>A close friend of mine said it this way: “As a people, white Americans want to believe that the police and the legal system are doing the right thing — that they can be trusted with the lives of all citizens. We cling to this fallacy based on authority rather than the preponderance of evidence. We cling to the fallacy because should we come to the understanding that our entire national justice system is manufactured, that a few bad cops are not the problem, we cannot escape the reality that the whole system needs a massive overhaul. Habits of thought are hard to break, especially when they define our identities. The identity on the line here is the identity of America itself.”</p><p>Trump, McConnell, and Barr are expanding this justice system, one that has long marred the lives and livelihoods, and caused the deaths, of untold Black folks. Even now, the pace of political arrests, charges, and imprisonments has picked up. This robust industry and its right-wing allies have gained strength. The production of evidence no longer affects primarily Black folks. The manufacture of justice is expanding to prosecute advocacy organizations across the country, journalists who have called out this system, and all political opponents of this regime.</p><p>Our cousins support this agenda. So when you hang out with people who would put my family and me in prison for life, remember who they are. Your comradery with our cousins gives them a pass. They are only nice superficially. Their sensibility is allied with serious political power. It can kill us. Literally. Just as it has been killing Black people for hundreds of years. Shouldn’t they pay a price for their murderous politics?</p><p>Love,</p><p>Your sister</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=89e8660f972c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>