<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Bill Hulseman on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Bill Hulseman on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@billhulseman?source=rss-a9dfa35229fa------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 03:45:50 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@billhulseman/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“Words are useless, especially sentences”: Bill’s Top 10 Madonna Albums]]></title>
            <link>https://billhulseman.medium.com/words-are-useless-especially-sentences-bills-top-10-madonna-albums-9164c69d1340?source=rss-a9dfa35229fa------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9164c69d1340</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[top-10]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pop-culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[madonna]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Bill Hulseman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 17 Feb 2024 20:01:47 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-02-17T20:01:47.887Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*tePJPvfIMJtNWtahoBZocA.jpeg" /></figure><p>In my life, there are few events I’ve ever been as excited about as I have been for The Celebration Tour. The tour was originally scheduled to begin in Vancouver, BC, and make Seattle its second stop. That would’ve given <em>this</em> Madonna fan and scholar an early glimpse at her only retrospective tour, a journey through forty years of Madonna’s career, a gift to fans and a reminder to everyone else that she has always been an unstoppable force in popular culture. But a sudden illness forced her to postpone the American leg of the tour. Hoping to immerse myself in the concert and avoid spoilers from the thousands of videos posted to social media from previous stops, I’ve been focused calligraphing a shirt with my favorite lyrics with the persistence of a Buddhist monk creating a sand mandala, revisiting her studio albums, and, revealing one at a time to friends via social media, creating my list of the Top 10 Madonna albums. Here’s the list (and my increasingly long reflections…because with each album, there’s just more and more to say).</p><h4>Number Ten: <em>American Life</em></h4><p>Madonna took on the system, or really all the systems — government , Hollywood, families, relationships, gender dynamics — by bringing social critique to the dance floor and serving up a mix of lovely, innovative, and introspective ballads with a dash of James Bond.</p><h4>Number Nine: <em>Like A Virgin</em></h4><p>Nearly every track on the album is iconic, either essential to the development of Madonna’s persona or a perfect reflection of this corner of the 80s. Hype around it typically focuses on the more, dare I say, “material” aspects of the album’s aesthetic, but too many listeners miss the artistic experimentation happening in the album which were among the early successes in bridging more mainstream pop and underground or alternative scenes. The accompanying videos, too, are pioneering in developing the then-new medium of the music video: “Material Girl” blended homage and irony, and “Like A Virgin” was 80s fantasy perfection. I can see the imprint of these tracks and videos today on performance and production across genres.</p><h4>Number Eight: <em>Madonna</em></h4><p>Madonna’s self-titled debut album introduced a new kind of female pop star and inspired a generation of Madonna Wannabes who adopted her eclectic, layered, irreverent style. Most of the songs are known so well that folx don’t stop to notice the earnestness of the lyrics. I can’t listen to “Borderline” without imagining a deeper, harder story — maybe it’s a painful reflection of a relationship impacted by mental illness — or the anthemic “Holiday” as a youthful plea for peace. “You can turn this world around…” And the song’s video infuses Martha Graham-inspired modern dance with dance music, one of the earliest of countless transgressions across the boundaries of different media and influences.</p><h4>Number Seven: <em>Confessions on a Dance Floor</em></h4><p>Confessions both capped an era of significant output (1998’s <em>Ray of Light</em>, 2000’s <em>Music</em>, 2003’s <em>American Life</em>) and signaled an artistic shift. I think it’s an extraordinarily revealing album, pointing directly to lifelong and more recent influences (among them: disco, electropop, punk, Yemeni Jewish mysticism, girl power anthems), but more than referents, the tracks excavate the raw joy and anger that more saccharine homages fail to tap. It’s a no-skip, seamless album that features some of her loveliest melodies. The album inspired my favorite of her tours, and the image that she sculpted (including and especially <em>that</em> flattering pink leotard for the dance studio solo in “Hung Up”) was a middle finger to the industry and public who thought the 47 year old creamy-smooth pop icon goddess should hang up her tights and retreat into old ladyhood.</p><h4>Number 6: <em>True Blue</em></h4><p>True Blue is the penultimate of what I think of as the “foundational albums.” If <em>Madonna</em> and <em>Like a Virgin</em> opened the door, True Blue marked Madonna’s entrance and secured her place at the table. It also hinted at the mastery she’d serve with <em>Like A Prayer</em> and “Vogue” a few years later. She’d already carved a niche with her sound and her image, but in <em>True Blue</em>, the songs lean into bolder storytelling, like the misty “La Isla Bonita,” the provocative “Papa Don’t Preach,” and the enigmatic “Live To Tell.” Her innovation in storytelling extended to the videos accompanying the album, like the deceptively powerful “Open Your Heart,” a stylized dismantling of the male gaze. <em>True Blue</em> is also what drew academics in various disciplines to recognize that Madonna wasn’t just a flash-in-the-pan reflection of pop culture and the music industry but a major player, creating something new, and defying conventional categorization.</p><h4>Number 5: <em>Madame X</em></h4><p>Her most recent studio album, <em>Madame X</em> is impressive, sophisticated, and forward-thinking. The name, a nod to her most recent reinvention (she added Madame X to Madonna Louise, Veronica, Dita, Esther, and the countless layers she’s peeled back over the years), is both provocative (summoning the image of an international woman of mystery) and sentimental (a callback to the nickname Martha Graham presciently gave her to reflect her capacity for identity-shifting). The music is ambitious, reflecting smart collaborations (Maluma, Anitta, Quavo, Swae Lee), new influences (like her years in Portugal and contemporary socio-political crises), and experimental. The videos accompanying the album are among the best she’s produced, including the rattling “God Control” (inspired by the Pulse nightclub shooting), the moving “Batuka” (which features the Batukadeiras Orchestra and contemplates the history and ongoing impact of the slave trade), and the stunning “Dark Ballet” (a nonlinear meditation on Joan of Arc, transgender — and by extension any transgressive — identity, and institutional oppression; in my mind the most powerful video she’s made since “Like A Prayer”).</p><h4>Number 4: <em>Like A Prayer</em></h4><p>If you’ve ever been near me when the video for “Like A Prayer” plays, God bless you. You’ve probably been subjected to my mini-lecture about the innovations of the video, about its dialogue between medieval mysticism and modern injustice, about the controversial and canceled Pepsi deal, and about why this was a ground-shifting moment in popular culture. Beyond that monumental video and the song that inspired it, the album in its entirety is top tier and cemented Madonna’s status in the upper echelons of culture-makers. The album features one of my favorite collaborations: “Love Song” marked the intersection of two geniuses of the era, Madonna and Prince. Even the mostly-forgotten tracks later in the album constitute a trove of hidden gems that, if nothing else, perfectly capture the end of the 80s. Her team was on a roll with videos, too, like “Express Yourself,” which invoked <em>Metropolis</em> and inspired one of the sleekest, sexiest videos ever made, and the Herb Ritts-directed video for “Cherish,” which seemed to birth a whole genre of sexy black &amp; white frolicking on the beach that dominated everything in print media from perfume ads and Abercrombie catalogs to senior portraits. Paired with the phenomenon that was “Vogue” (released a year later as a single and then with <em>I’m Breathless, </em>which accompanied the film <em>Dick Tracy</em>), it marks a moment in pop culture: there was life before <em>Like A Prayer</em>, and life after.</p><h4>Number 3: <em>Erotica</em></h4><p>1992 was a very good year for music, and Madonna was ready to flex. Riding high on the successes of <em>Like A Prayer</em>, “Vogue,” and The Blond Ambition Tour, Madonna’s approach shifted from shocking provocation (her explicit sexuality and casual Catholicism inspired most of the pearl clutching) to bold assertion (stymying the critics who’d hoped to shame her into conformity). Criticism spiked with the sublime “Justify My Love,” whose accompanying video depicted a highly stylized series of sexual fantasies. For journalists and concerned parents everywhere who couldn’t figure out how to criticize “Vogue” without sounding homophobic, “Justify” was an easier target.</p><p>Some celebs bow to that kind of pressure and reform their images. Madonna responded by publishing the infamous <em>Sex</em> book and dropped the Erotica album. To some, it was a stunt, a middle finger to prudish critics. To others, it was a bold political statement or artistic experiment. To a closeted kid in an all-boys Catholic high school, I was empowered and reassured — not by the <em>Sex</em> book (I never read it until grad school) but by Madonna’s <em>response</em> to criticism about it. Madonna was badgered by interviewers hoping for some confession or relenting, but her replies were consistent: she was presenting reality — people’s desires, needs, and feelings. HER desires, needs, and feelings. And for me, though deep in the closet, I could hear in the album that she was presenting MY desires, needs, and feelings. The rest of her queer following, out and closeted alike, must’ve felt the same — it invited loyalty and enthusiasm from LGBTQ fans who saw our desires, needs, and feelings being celebrated (not just tolerated, in the don’t-ask-don’t-tell era). Every track in some way explores owning one’s own sexuality, power, desires, and needs. It’s a message we needed in 1992 and still need today.</p><p>On top of all that, the music is just really fucking good: Her cover of “Fever” is sexy as hell and revives an old standard with new beats. There aren’t many songs in the pop canon better than “Deeper and Deeper” and “Rain.” And “In This Life” is a poignant snapshot of the pain and grief that came as the AIDS epidemic was peaking in the US.</p><h4>Number 2: <em>Ray of Light</em></h4><p>At this point, you might be wondering, <em>Why is Bill so obsessed with Madonna?</em> It’s a fair question. In part, it’s an OGT (obviously gay trait), along with my youthful devotions to Angela Lansbury, Bernadette Peters, musical theater, and <em>The Golden Girls</em>, those quirks that developed long before I understood what “gay” was and yet told the world who I was. I was 7 when Madonna released her first studio album, and, growing up in a house without cable, it was only on the 4pm music video hour on channel 44 that I could see her early videos. Despite such limited and sporadic glimpses, something deep in my soul told me that she was my girl. My obsession started early…and quietly. Just as I couldn’t explain my obsession, I couldn’t explain why I knew to keep it secret.</p><p><em>Ray of Light </em>was released in the spring of my senior year of college, and as I prepared for a move to start divinity school in Boston, it provided a soundtrack for my life. Inspired by a major change in her life (parenthood) and infused with insights gleaned from her increasingly diverse spirituality (this was the peak of her engagement with Hindu practice and anticipated her deep dive into Kabbalah), the album felt like a gift particularly to me. Always immersed in her native Catholic symbolism, now Madonna was a spiritual traveler and a touchstone for me as I struggled to understand religious diversity and embody pluralism.</p><p>In a course on the intersection of eroticism and mysticism, I decided <em>Ray of Light</em> would be the focus of my independent research. I had no idea what kind of wormhole I was about to slide into or that on the other side I’d arrive in the magical land of Madonna Studies, the interdisciplinary academic dialogue among theologians, sociologists, feminist theorists, anthropologists, philosophers, media critics, and others that explored Madonna’s art and impact. My final product was a 28-page paper with a title paraphrasing a key lyric, “Traveling Down Her Own Road:” — because every legit academic essay had a colon and subtitle — “A close reading of Madonna’s <em>Ray of Light</em>.” My professor loved it, and that A meant that I could say I have a master’s degree because of Madonna.</p><p>Since then, though I’ve lost the original paper to a hard drive I can’t access anymore, I’ve built on that research and spun it into lessons for my high school classes, professional development workshops for colleagues, a 5-week symposium, and last summer a one-hour keynote focusing on the evolution of Madonna’s queer allyship to launch the Pride observances in a division of Microsoft. I’m buoyed not just by my personal passions but by the fact that Madonna has moved and continues to move the needle in American and global culture. That’s just a fact, and, whatever your attitude to her artistically or personally, it means she’s worth paying attention to. I like to explore <em>how</em> she moves the needle, how her music and the videos and tours spawned from it demonstrate social commentary, cultural parasitism (actually, “mutualism,” to be precise), reinvention, and her role as a catalyst for postmodernism. And it all began with <em>Ray of Light</em>.</p><p>My own personal history aside, <em>Ray of Light</em> is a perfect pop album. Her partnership with William Orbit produced a sound that dominated the era and others chased to recreate. Each track stands alone, but I enjoy listening to the album most in a single sitting.The heart of the album isn’t a dance single or mega hit — it’s an obscure Hindu prayer, preceded by “Sky Fits Heaven,” which is as much a theological treatise as it is a pop track. The transition between these tracks is so sublime it gives me chills every time.</p><h4>Number 1: <em>Bedtime Stories</em></h4><p>Now, when it comes to the top albums, I’m splitting hairs. If I were stranded with only one album to listen to, as the ice breaker goes, I’d happily bring <em>Madame X</em>, <em>Like A Prayer</em>, <em>Erotica</em>, <em>Ray of Light</em>, or my #1. Each demonstrates the mastery of the collaborative collective of musicians, choreographers, producers, stylists, and others who are fueled by and rely on Madonna’s talent and vision. And I should note that this hasn’t been a list of her “best” albums springing from some technical rubric. If you’ve disagreed with any of my rankings, well, as Dorian Corey might say, “hooray for you,” but I don’t really care. Make your own list, and I’ll gladly cheer you on. These rankings reflect not just the artistic merit of each album but also where and how I met it, how it impacted and continues to reveal itself to me, and good old-fashioned gut instinct.</p><p>I came late to <em>Bedtime Stories</em>. Sure, a few tracks always stood out. “Take a Bow” was one of those songs you played at moments that needed closure. The opening guitar strums and melodies of “Secret” are iconic and distinctive. “Human Nature” is one of her most effective (what I think of as) “bitch ballads,” those autobiographical songs that not-so-subtly let her haters know (to borrow a later lyric), “Bitch, I’m Madonna.” And that “Human Nature” video…it was released at the end of my first year in college, and let’s just say, it was an awakening. I even dressed in the style of the video for my “A Very Madonna New Year’s Eve” party to ring in 2001.</p><p>Yes, I hosted a Madonna-themed party and even awarded prizes for my guests’ amazing costumes which reassured me that I wasn’t alone in my fascination. The only criterion was that the outfit was inspired by Madonna, someone in Madonna’s life, or or some aspect of her career. What were the winning looks, you ask? Third prize went to friends who arrived as Guy Ritchie and “Don’t Tell Me” Madonna, cowgirl chic and all. Second prize went to a friend who arrived in a full Dick Tracy costume. And the Grand Prize to a friend who arrived as Dennis Rodman, donning an enormous wedding dress, hair sprayed green, and skin covered in tattoos.</p><p>Over time I came to appreciate the blend of styles throughout the album (R&amp;B, hip hop, electropop, dub), a reflection both of her collaborators on the album (Nellie Hooper, Babyface, Dallas Austin, Björk) and the swirl of sounds in the mid-90s. Amid my research in grad school, deep analysis allowed me to notice the subtle innovations and layers in each track. But it wasn’t until my mid-30s that I started to really hear and internalize the core messages of the album, captured in two key lyrics from the album: “express yourself, don’t repress yourself,” and (my favorite lyric from her entire oeuvre) “words are useless, especially sentences.” In Madonna-ese, I faced a moment for my own reinvention. After the end of an 8-year relationship and uprooting from Boston to NYC and then DC, <em>Bedtime Stories</em> gave me vocabulary to identify who I’d been and explore who I could be. Those lyrics became frequently recited mantras and played no small part in a personal and professional overhaul that has shaped my path to this moment.</p><p>In many ways, <em>Bedtime Stories</em> fulfilled the promise of <em>Erotica</em>, delivering the sensuality and eroticism many expected. If there’s a hint of anger underlying <em>Erotica</em>, <em>Bedtime Stories</em> is built on a foundation of “fuck it” that gave her (and countless female artists that followed her) the freedom she deserved. The result is an album of honesty, mystery, and recognition that some things are well beyond the world of words and human capacities. To me, the album is a pivot enabled by that freedom. <em>Bedtime Stories </em>both captures the growth and mastery that she’d experienced as a performer and as a producer up to that point and plants the seeds that would become <em>Ray of Light</em> and later masterpieces.</p><p>My favorite part of the album is the transition from “Sanctuary” to “Bedtime Story.” Like the pairing of “Sky Fits Heaven” and “Shanti/Ashtangi” on <em>Ray of Light</em> a few years later, this is the heart of the album. “Sanctuary” blends Christian spirituality with erotic and sensual beats and language. Like “Like A Prayer,” it stands at the intersection of mysticism and eroticism and is a reminder of the deep hunger for both in the human heart. The music fades but doesn’t break before transforming into the dub beats of the title track. Part manifesto, part make-out-on-the-dance floor music, it’s a gorgeous, restrained, ambient, and uplifting piece of music.</p><p>But let’s talk about the video. The most expensive video produced up to that point, it explores Jungian psychology through the art of female surrealist painters. It also employed early CGI animation. Though you can tell on the HD screens of today, in 1995 it was seamless and magical. In all the contexts I’ve shared the video (lessons with students, professional development workshops, symposia, impromptu lectures to unwitting guests in my living room) it’s the one I look forward to most because the combination of Madonna’s music (with a heavy helping of Björk), surreal art, Jungian psychology, and the sheer of beauty of the video inspires the best reactions — from surprise and delight to shock to awe.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9164c69d1340" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[art]]></title>
            <link>https://billhulseman.medium.com/art-18e97c23194?source=rss-a9dfa35229fa------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/18e97c23194</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[drag-queens]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lgbtq]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[queer]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Bill Hulseman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 25 May 2023 19:41:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-05-25T19:41:26.209Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*uzpdFVNRlafQIH81ALEhMQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>Lola LeCroix and the contestants of the 2023 Drag Queen of the Year Pageant Competition Award Contest Competition</em></figcaption></figure><p>At some point during each episode of Las Culturistas, Matt Rogers and Bowen Yang ask their guests, “What was the culture that made you say culture was for you?” It’s a delightful and revealing question, sometimes excavating in their guests long-forgotten memories or helping them recognize that something was more significant in the shaping of their worldview than they’d previously thought. Frequently, while fantasizing making the rounds as a guest on my favorite podcasts, I try to answer the question for myself. Would I cite my earliest visits to the Art Institute of Chicago with my sister? Would I invoke <em>Murder by Death</em>, Neil Simon’s detective parody whose screenplay I could recite (but couldn’t necessarily interpret) by the time I was 7? Would it be watching my dad sitting at the piano, or watching his mother’s made-for-TV movies? Or playing Scrabble with my mom on her bedroom floor while watching <em>The Golden Girls</em>?</p><p>I could go on…through hundreds of intersections like these as a kid, I was lucky to be exposed to a wide range of cultural and artistic influences. Thinking back, it was a more diverse array of artists, media, and experiences than one might expect for a cis white kid in the suburbs. I didn’t become an expert in any particular art form, but I gained a kind of vocabulary, a rudimentary semiotic lens, to be able to encounter and appreciate people and experiences that I didn’t necessarily “understand.” Growing up, I wasn’t in frequent communication with people of color, people outside my family’s socio-economic bubble, or with queer folx, but when I finally did enter those spaces and meet those people, I didn’t face the kind of culture shock that many people experience. That’s not to say that I navigated those spaces flawlessly, but I think I was better equipped than many of my peers.</p><p>Through their media, artists shape the way we see the world, but it’s the subversive ones who make the longest lasting impact on our culture. Subversive artists — the ones who, through their art, challenge, overturn, and undermine conventions, institutions, structures, and systems of authority — innovate and see their media in ways that others before didn’t (or couldn’t). I’m not thinking of protest or political art (well, not necessarily or exclusively): I’m thinking of the ones who <em>transform</em> the way people see the world.</p><p>For example: Martha Graham. The great mother of modern American dance, as a young dancer she was excluded from ballet, the dominant and the only acceptable form of dance in the “high arts” of the early 20th century. Success for women in ballet depended on a body that, despite the incredible feats of strength required to dance gracefully and en pointe, communicated fragility, a body that Graham didn’t have. It’s hard to ignore how this contributed to the unrealistic beauty standards of the late 20th and early 21st centuries. Though Graham didn’t have that body, she understood something deeper about how the body moves and communicates, something ignored or stifled by conventional ballet. Starting with the nuances of her own body, its limitations, its power, she developed not just a technique but a distinctly American art form.</p><p>Today, we enjoy an entire industry of modern dance that grew from Graham and a few others (notably, many women like Ruth St. Denis and Isadora Duncan), but we can also see her influence on particular artists. Bette Davis trained with Graham, and we can see Graham’s distinctive and constant flow between contraction and release of her core in the way Davis moves across a screen and delivers a line. Graham opened the door for choreographers like Bob Fosse to build organic vignettes from bodies (not cram bodies into abstracted forms), and of course we see Fosse’s influence on contemporary Broadway, jazz, and even hip hop. Madonna, who trained with Graham when she first arrived in NYC in the 1970s, developed her own signature dance styles with Graham’s technique at the core.</p><p>It’s not just an industry that demonstrates Graham’s impact: look at the broader (if not completely inclusive) range of bodies in contemporary dance companies. Sure, the majority of dancers are still lean and sinewy, but broad shoulders, thick thighs, and a full belly are no longer ejectable characteristics. Also, “fragility” is a word we can no longer associate with women in modern dance. Look at Pilobolus, whose innovations build on the foundations of Graham and others to highlight the grace and beauty that come with strength, power, flexibility, and sensuality.</p><p>Often subversive art is only subversive because of its origins. Art that emerges from marginalized groups is often labeled primitive, degenerate, basic, freakish…the derogation depends on who is in power. The rise of the Nazis in Germany was accompanied by a movement to denigrate and eliminate “degenerate art,” a category designated for art by Jews, undesirable (to the Nazis) ethnic minorities, and homosexuals and for art whose forms or style broke out of the narrow Nazi worldview. Abstract expressionism was dangerous because it demonstrated the limitations of “acceptable” forms to communicate the modern condition, including the devastation of World War I, the emerging insights of psychoanalysis, and the crumbling yet persistent hold on power by aristocracies. The designation of “degenerate art” was but one thread in the Nazis’ efforts to convince the wider population that Jews, ethnic minorities, homosexuals, and dissenters were unworthy of recognition and, eventually, existence. The label intended to defuse and disempower their art, to silence these artists and limit their contribution to the ways we see the world.</p><p>In the US today, we see queer people being targeted, and art that emerges from queer people’s experience is being used as a proxy for heterosexist violence. Drag is one of those art forms. It’s subversive because it plays with and explodes our constructions of gender, because it magnifies and camps up our faults and assumptions, but mostly because it’s queer. And because it’s impactful. Drag artists push the boundaries of performance and challenge institutional norms for gender and expression. They blur the lines between distinct art forms and in so doing create new vocabularies. Like other subversive art forms that came before (modern dance, jazz, beat poetry, abstract expressionism, surrealism…) they draw from multiple sources to create something new, something that transcends our current categories, something that reflects, responds to, and challenges the cultural context.</p><p>I’m not sure when I first saw a drag artist. Of course, I remember Tony Curtis and Jack Lemon in <em>Some Like It Hot</em> and Tom Hanks and Peter Scolari dragging it up on <em>Bosom Buddies</em>, but I wouldn’t think of them as drag artists, and in those scenarios drag is only a comedic device that gives cis straight white men a layer of protection or access they didn’t enjoy before. Of course, I remember <em>To Wong Foo</em>, but I cringe today when I see Patrick Swayze and Wesley Snipes in overly affected gender performances (though John Leguziamo was pretty good, in my humble opinion). They’re all great performers, but they were playing a part, akin to any other role they inhabited. I’m talking about a drag artist. I think my first encounter was in a bar in Chicago’s Boystown. I was underage and mustering the courage to order a drink when a queen in a sparkling blue dress and boa slowed in front of me, turned and read my whole history on my face, and gave me a wink and a smile before floating across the room.</p><p>On visits home from college, I’d stumble across drag shows in the clubs in Boystown, and when I moved to Boston, I was in awe when club security would clear a path for Mizery to cross the dance floor in a series of high kicks. I’d venture into Jacques Cabaret and ignore the seedy old men by the bar, just focusing on the talent on the stage. It wasn’t all glamorous. It wasn’t all even very good. But they were doing it, and they took bigger risks than I’d ever taken as a performer, so I respected it and shelled out my singles when given the privilege.</p><p>In my first year with the Boston Gay Men’s Chorus, I was cast in a trio for our Rodgers &amp; Hammerstein show to sing “I Enjoy Being a Girl.” In my audition, I was asked, “Would you be comfortable doing drag?” Betraying the 99% of my body that wanted to run back to the suburbs, I said, “Sure.” A month later, I was being fitted for a purple frock and overlay. I’d be the redhead in the trio, and when I finally slipped into my wig and costume, I felt like Endora (from <em>Bewitched</em>).</p><p>The number was brilliant — starting “backstage” with three half-dressed drag queens, we sang the opening lines like burnouts, but midway a mylar fringe curtain dropped, we quickly finished putting on our drag, and burst onto the stage with all the confidence and tempo of the Dreamgirls. We revived the act a year later. The chorus did a tri-city tour with our brother choruses in New York and Washington DC, and after our final concert at Carnegie Hall each group submitted an act for the after party at Splash. I rushed from Carnegie to the club and was shuttled downstairs. As our faces were being painted, people kept bringing us drinks and we chatted with increasing confidence (did I mention the steady flow of booze?) with the gogo boys who were changing and, um, fluffing all around us. When it was time for the acts to begin, we were led upstairs. There’s something about being in drag — people just clear the way for you and want you to drink. As I moved, the crowd opened Red Sea-style, and strangers just handed me drinks as I walked. The power. Oh, the power.</p><p>When a friend was turning 30, he requested a “dragapalooza,” so a group of us acquired outfits and gathered in a friend’s apartment where a couple of friends with considerable make-up skills did our faces. As a group, we slowly and deliberately transformed ourselves. When I turned to consider my finished face in the mirror, I expected to be shocked or frightened or confused. Instead, I felt like I was looking at an old friend. I suddenly saw myself in a different way. We bar hopped the whole night, bumping into and surprising (and delighting and horrifying) friends who didn’t recognize us, but at some point we split into smaller groups with a plan to reconvene and de-drag at the apartment. On the way, I’d had enough of heels and walked in hose-lined feet for about a quarter of a mile on a crumbly Boston sidewalk. Crossing Berkeley, we all noticed it at once: a car turning in front of us, the windows rolling down, passengers spewing hate-filled slurs at us, and, when we didn’t react to their words, beer bottles flying at our heads. When we got home, we learned that another friend who’d been on his own had been jumped, insulted with a series of slurs, and mugged. We de-dragged in a quiet and dim-lit apartment, each taking turns to weep a little.</p><p>My husband and I went to our second DragCon this year, and we got to see <em>a lot</em> of drag, both from famous performers launched by <em>RuPaul’s Drag Race</em> and other soon-to-be-legendary types at the Drag Queen of the Year Pageant Competition Award Contest Competition (yes, that’s the real name of the event). The drag we saw ranged from classic high fashion and devotion to haute couture to avant garde performance, and it all both titillated and humbled me. I so enjoy particular artists and delight in being surprised by new ways the queens communicate and perform, but I don’t always understand what I’m seeing. It’s precisely those moments that I’m grateful for the vocabulary I developed as a young person. Instead of relegating it or walking away, I seek to appreciate the way it challenges my notions of beauty, humor, politics, or communication. What’s the point of art, I’ve always thought, if I can understand it at first glance? What’s the point of art if I don’t see something different (about the art, about the world, about myself) every time I approach it? When I’m lucky enough to encounter drag that pushes my boundaries, I’m reminded to ask better questions, not to seek easier answers or definitions. I can’t, or rather, I won’t try to capture the ways that drag has transformed the way I see the world, both experiencing it behind the mascara and as an audience member. I want to let drag continue to shape me and the way I see the world, the way I understand gender and performance, the way I understand myself and others.</p><p>Thanks to RuPaul, a self-proclaimed “mother fucking marketing genius,” drag is ascendant, but with visibility comes vulnerability. Right now, drag artists are under attack as a proxy for everything that doesn’t conform to the attackers’ worldview. They’re being labeled as degenerate, as satanic, as pedophilic. State legislatures are passing bans on drag performance at a rapid rate, trampling the First Amendment with theocratic aspirations. The goal — and I don’t say this lightly or hyperbolically — is, like the Nazis’ derogation of “degenerate art,” eradication of not just the art form but the people who create it. At one level, that’s a sign that, like other subversive artists before them, drag artists are doing something right. On another, though, it’s a call to action to straight, cis people, to people who actually value democracy and the Constitution, and to Christians who subscribe to love and justice, not power (don’t you think the drag queens would be hanging with Jesus, the prostitutes, and the tax collectors?). <br>If those people don’t move to protect drag artists and the spaces they need to innovate, create, and shape our world, then say goodbye to the fabulous world they’ve been creating for us.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=18e97c23194" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[lessons & carols]]></title>
            <link>https://billhulseman.medium.com/lessons-carols-718a728be99?source=rss-a9dfa35229fa------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/718a728be99</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[reflections]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[new-year-resolution]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lgbtq]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[meaning]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Bill Hulseman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 30 Dec 2022 00:47:19 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-01-03T18:51:31.758Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*jtv3yhbDIUvUY1lkgFYk8g.jpeg" /><figcaption>Somewhere over Canada. Photo by the author.</figcaption></figure><blockquote><strong><em>Whatever it is, coronavirus has made the mighty kneel and brought the world to a halt like nothing else could. Our minds are still racing back and forth, longing for a return to ‘normality’, trying to stitch our future to our past and refusing to acknowledge the rupture. But the rupture exists. And in the midst of this terrible despair, it offers us a chance to rethink the doomsday machine we have built for ourselves. Nothing could be worse than a return to normality.</em></strong><em><br></em>from <a href="https://www.ft.com/content/10d8f5e8-74eb-11ea-95fe-fcd274e920ca">Arundhati Roy, “The pandemic is a portal”</a></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>Life is not an error, even when it is. That is to say, whatever faith you emerge with at the end of your life is going to be not simply affected by that life but intimately dependent on it, for faith in God is, in the deepest sense, faith in life — which means that even the staunchest life of faith is a life of great change. It follows that if you believe at fifty what you believed at fifteen, then you have not lived — or have denied the reality of your life.</em></strong><em><br></em>from Christian Wiman, <em>My Bright Abyss: Meditations of a Modern Believer</em></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>A pair of wings, a different mode of breathing, which would enable us to traverse infinite space, would in no way help us, for, if we visited Mars or Venus keeping the same senses, they would clothe in the same aspect as the things of the earth everything that we should be capable of seeing. The only true voyage of discovery, the only fountain of Eternal Youth, would be not to visit strange lands but to possess other eyes, to behold the universe through the eyes of another, of a hundred others, to behold the hundred universes that each of them beholds, that each of them is…</em></strong><em><br></em>from Marcel Proust, <em>Remembrance of Things Past</em></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>…I reach what I might call a philosophy; at any rate it is a constant idea of mine; that behind the cotton wool [of daily life] is hidden a pattern; that we — I mean all human beings — are connected with this; that the whole world is a work of art; that we are parts of the work of art. Hamlet or a Beethoven quartet is the truth about this vast mass that we call the world. But there is no Shakespeare, there is no Beethoven; certainly and emphatically there is no God; we are the words; we are the music; we are the thing itself.<br></em></strong>from Virginia Woolf, <em>Moments of Being</em></blockquote><p>What to make of 2022? What will we make of 2023?</p><p>It’s not the <em>year </em>that impacts us or spurs evolution or destruction. It’s us. See, I’m a constructivist, which means I’m that guy who chimes in unnecessarily to say, “Well, that’s a construct.” It’s not just intellectual posturing — I really believe that we construct our reality, that, to navigate life, we impose structures on what we encounter to understand them, to engage and benefit from them, to protect ourselves from them, and (most illusorily) to control them. We thrive when we find and maintain resonance with the world we encounter, and, because the mysteries of the universe endlessly unfold (or because we figure out how to peel back another layer of it), we constantly negotiate that resonance, we adapt. We regress when we <em>assume</em> that we’ve figured it out — the source of that <em>hubris</em> the ancient Greeks were warning us about through their narratives — but we risk our survival when we act on that assumption, when we impose that assumption on others and on the world around us. Language, cultural norms, laws, religion, economics, art…these are all systems that our ancestors created, that we maintain and adapt, and because of which future generations will look back at us with disgust and disappointment.</p><p>I enjoy using the darkest time of the year to look back at what we made of 2022 (what else is there to do in all this darkness?) and to envision (or gird our loins) for what we’ll do on our next lap around the sun. I think this is what “new year resolutions” aim to do, but when it boils down to short-term goal setting, the practice lacks imagination (and guarantees self-disappointment by March). In recent years, I’ve shifted to reflecting on the voices, the experiences, the insights, and the patterns that have emerged over the past year and considering how I might engage them to shape myself and the people and world around me. I’m not interested in goal-setting (the road to self-disappointment) but in setting a tack, weaning myself from worrying about potential destinations, and preparing to engage a wondrous journey. Looking back on what I’ve experienced in 2022 and forward to how we might shape the world in 2023, here are six takeaways that have emerged for me. Sharing them this way is both a practice of accountability for me and offering unsolicited advice to you.</p><p><strong>Stick to the itinerary.</strong></p><p>If I’ve learned anything from <em>The White Lotus</em>, it’s this.<strong> </strong>This has always been a no-brainer for me. As a Virgo, an INFJ, and a 1w9 who lives with mild OCD, clearly articulated itineraries that collate relevant information and non-negotiables into one place have served as tools for my own physical and emotional self-regulation and for making sure experiences with others go as smoothly as possible while traveling.</p><p>Folx who resist committing to them claim that clinging too tightly to an itinerary diminishes the chance for spontaneity and enlivening a trip, but I somewhat-firmly disagree. When I don’t have to constantly navigate hard boundaries like flights, safety considerations, and anxiety triggers, a thoughtful itinerary actually encourages spontaneity, makes room for it. It lets you enjoy that whimsical afternoon, that surprise late-night out that requires a heavy sleep-in the next day, or that impromptu need for a haircut or ice cream. It also keeps you from getting on that boat to Palermo.</p><p>Of course, the benefits that I get from itineraries aren’t limited to travel — really they’re just one outgrowth of boundaries, and greater attention to boundaries could be a game-changer in 2023. What would happen if people showed up to social, communal, or professional events, whether in-person or on-screen, on time? What if events ended by the time promised, and people actually stayed the whole time? What would happen if we recognized and took responsibility for the shared boundaries we inhabit — you know, neighborhoods, municipalities, states — instead of hiding within the walls of our constructed privacy and tribes? What would happen if we actually respected the boundaries that marginalized and minority groups establish for their own safety and ability to thrive? or stopped imposing boundaries like labels and stereotypes on others and used the names people call themselves?</p><p><strong>Educators deserve better.</strong></p><p>Maybe you’ve always known this because you grew up with teachers in your family or because you worked in schools yourself. Maybe, more recently, you got (justifiably) hooked on <em>Abbott Elementary</em> and are coming to the realization that, despite what they do, how well they do it, and how long they do it each day, teachers are paid and treated like shit. Have you noticed how educators have been treated the last few years?</p><p>When a global pandemic happened, a once-in-a-generation experience that would have a profound impact on us as people, as communities, as nations, and as a species, families blamed educators because students were “falling behind”…though the question remains, <em>falling behind whom?</em> Did they think returning them to school, without considering that their teachers and school staff were humans confronting the same pandemic, would buffer kids from the economic and emotional fallout of the pandemic? from the immense and overwhelming grief that hung over all of us? Did they think kids could actually learn in the same ways and to the same ends while the world was quite literally crumbling around them?</p><p>When the murders of George Floyd, Breonna Taylor, and Ahmaud Arbery tore back the curtain on systemic racism and injustice, the not-so-latently-racist “right” steered a hammer back on the heads of educators, questioning everything from their competence to their patriotism in a quest to root out Critical Race Theory. Funny thing, though, as with most myths rooted in fascist longing, the foot soldiers in the war against “wokeness” aren’t equipped with an understanding of what they’re attacking. I’ve yet to hear an attacker of CRT actually articulate what that means beyond “making White kids feel bad about themselves” or how and where it appears in curricula. That’s too bad, because, if they had even a basic grasp of what they’re talking about, those attackers might actually recognize that the lens that CRT provides would actually benefit all people in the long run, including those little White snowflakes they’re so concerned about.</p><p>After nearly three years of constant barrage on educators, how is anyone surprised by the current shortage of teachers? Relative to their impact on the world, the expertise required by their work, and the hours they devote to it, teachers have never been paid equitably. Compared to contemporaries in other industries, their salaries have always suggested “glorified babysitter” rather than “highly skilled neurosculptor and holistic caregiver.” I’ve never met a teacher who confessed to making too much, but I’ve met hundreds who will readily complain about compensation <em>if, and only if,</em> their complaint is attached to an affirmation of their enthusiasm for the craft and their love for students.</p><p>Maybe that’s got to stop. While the rest of the populace considers how they can do better for the people who quite literally and directly shape the future, educators should stop justifying low wages and minimal benefits with classic, self-effacing, and humble retorts like “but I feel like I’m making a difference” or “at least I get my summers off.” It’s unfortunate and uncomfortable, but if educators are going to be treated as skilled professionals, they need to embrace their expertise, shed (or at least repress) the imposter syndrome that haunts too many, and clearly articulate to their family, friends, and neighbors that yes, they deserve better, and it’s about time that all those people in their orbit elect leaders and policy makers who might actually pave the way to a world in which teachers are prized, not pummeled.</p><p><strong>Success is the best lotion.</strong></p><p>From the all-winners season of <em>RuPaul’s Drag Race All Stars</em> (did we ever imagine a world where Jinkx’s runways would gag us? where Trinity could win a comedy challenge? where half the cast qualified as the “trade of the season”?) to the star bakers of <em>The Great British Bake Off </em>(I’m surprised I can peel my eyes away from Sandro’s Instagram to write this), success begets success. I’m used to seeing the glow-up for pop singers and actors who enter their <em>moments </em>in the spotlight, those bubbles of fame and opportunity propelled by teams of publicists, stylists, trainers, and tacticians whose sole ambition is to channel ever-increasing attractiveness into ever-increasing profits through award-winning performances and lucrative runs. This year, though, I’ve noticed that the principle applies to an ever-expanding range of industries, and at this point, the majority of social media content depicts people trying to find their moments and successful people channeling their success into beauty and back again into (even-greater) success.</p><p>The only real threat to this bubble is the pin-prick of “cancel culture,” which can and will deflate an individual’s success at any revelation of imperfections, no matter their actual impact, no matter their relevance to the industry at hand. Is this trend a bad thing? Does it augur the end of civilization? Perhaps…but, is it possibly a good thing? Is it some clever social-psychological evolutionary mechanism that has emerged to cull those members of the herd whose influence was protected by now-vulnerable facades (like Whiteness, maleness, affluence…)? Maybe it’s not just internet trolls and progressive activists at work to unplug Kanye’s mic and to keep JK in her lane.</p><p>For both success begotten by success and the quick deflation of cancel culture, the thing to pay attention to is the role of <em>image</em>. It’s not just about the impossible, unreachable physical and cosmetic ideals that drive the photoshopped imposition of skinny chic onto our natural diversity. It’s about the whole image, or rather the holistic image — the external image (celebrity sheen) is now linked to and assessed with its underlying structure and the tangle of experiences, identities, and values that prop it up. The <em>art</em> is inextricably intertwined with the <em>artist</em>, and once the curtain’s pulled back and we get a more comprehensive look at our most popular icons, suddenly we want to keep Dorian Grey <em>and</em> his portrait locked in the attic. I’m not much of a fan of this “cancel culture,” but the optimist in me thinks this might be the start of a renewed understanding of (or at least a prompt for nuanced conversations about) aesthetics, and maybe even a path that leads us away from the bond (or bondage) between art and capitalism.</p><p><strong>“Best” is dead.</strong></p><p>In 1882, Nietzsche proclaimed that God is dead. The philosopher’s insight is typically misunderstood and misappropriated — it wasn’t a declaration or even an affirmation of atheism but a holistic social critique. The “god” that European Christianity constructed was dead, destabilized and dismantled by the very institutions responsible for sustaining it (religion, imperialism, capitalism) and irrelevant in the face of the modern world. His solution was for each to drop the quest for divine union and aspire to ubermensch enlightenment instead. Well, we see how that’s worked out, from Adolf Hitler and Ayn Rand to a century of authoritarian dictatorships filling the vacuums left by receding colonialism and Donald Fucking Trump.</p><p>Well, here’s the 2022 update: Hulseman is telling you, <strong>“best” is dead.</strong> A long time ago, I was introduced to the idea of “the myth of monotheism,” a metanarrative mixed into the foundation of “Western” culture about the power, potential, and possibilities of radical unity, of one-ness. One god. One crown. One winner. That myth, though, ignores other instincts in our physical, emotional, and social DNA, instincts that bend toward collaboration and mutuality instead of competition and exclusivity. We’ve seen the cycles of rising and falling that come with the myth of monotheism: commitment to one — one god, one crown, one nation, one winner, one trophy, one whatever-the-outcome — drives people to horde, to deprive, even to kill.</p><p>Frankly, I’m bored by the quest for superlative status. Sure, Argentina won the World Cup, but I was more riveted by the journey of Morocco’s team, fascinated by the ways the Iranian team tried (and sort of failed but also sort of succeeded) to protest their government’s violent repression, and the broad attention to human rights abuses that came with the construction of the tournament’s stadiums. When the Olympics return, we’ll have the chance to stand in awe of the world’s greatest athletes…so who (beyond their sponsors, managers, publicists, and tacticians #capitalism) really cares about the negligible difference between gold, silver, and bronze medals? A moment from watching the 1988 Olympics comes to mind: when it was clear that Debi Thomas wasn’t getting the gold, the camera caught her muttering something like, “Well, back to medical school.” She earned a bronze medal, but <em>not </em>winning the gold was enough to end her skating career. Wasn’t she more than that to her competitors, to fans, to the sport? Did Katie Ledecky’s <em>silver</em>-winning performance in the 400m freestyle suggest that she wasn’t in peak form?</p><p>I don’t think I’m alone in my boredom, but it’s difficult to conceive of any other way to do it. If each of us makes small and concerted efforts, I’m confident that we can change the nature of human competition within two or three hundred years. How to do this, you ask? We can stop celebrating single winners and spread our admiration and respect out for all who demonstrate excellence. We can stop using superlatives to describe our and others’ abilities, aspirations, and impact. And we can stop beating ourselves and others up for failing to reach superhuman potential.</p><p><strong>Fusion is the future</strong>.</p><p>Nuclear fusion made big headlines because…well, I’m not sure. I’m not a scientist. But it was something about being able to replicate what powers the sun or something like that, which opens all sorts of new possibilities for energy production. Cool. Here’s what I do understand about fusion: juxtaposing differences doesn’t have to lead to conflict and destruction. It can also lead to something new, something powerful, and something transformative. I submit as evidence the best song of the year, <a href="https://open.spotify.com/track/4DukzQv7lF6DXe6Un7lghr?si=27d491e45d7c46a7">“Break My Soul (The Queens Remix).”</a> (What did I just say about superlatives? Oh…ok, that starts <em>next </em>year.) Beyoncé released “Break My Soul” in June, right in the middle of LGBTQ Pride season. It was the first single that Queen Bey gifted to the world from <em>Renaissance</em> and the first affirmation that the album would be a monumental love letter to her LGBTQ fans. Beyoncé and her producers brilliantly wove her new anthem with Robin S’ “Show Me Love” and Big Freedia’s “Explode.” Throughout the album, she pays homage to the Harlem Balls and highlights multiple queer artists, but the seamless blend in “Break My Soul” opened a door to the future.</p><p>And then, just when I thought life couldn’t get any better, “The Queens Remix” emerged in August. At first, I thought I hit play on the wrong song. It opens with a distinctive opening, the strings sustaining a soft, high pitch, the beginning of Madonna’s “Vogue,” and <em>then</em> Bey’s voice enters with “Ooh la la…” My jaw dropped, and I stood still in the center of my living room, awed by the magic streaming from my phone. Beyoncé’s lyrics now floated over the bassline of “Vogue,” peppered by Big Freedia’s samples and Madonna’s original vocals. With the bridge, Beyoncé departs from her original track entirely and, as both homage to and critique of Madonna’s original celebration of Hollywood glamourpusses, she unspools a litany of Black female artists and the legendary Houses of the Ball scene.</p><p>If you’re a fan of Beyoncé, it’s a(nother) stroke of genius. If you’re a fan of Madonna (which, you might know, I am #understatementofthecentury), it is transformative. Though she used her platform to introduce the Harlem Balls and voguing to the world, Madonna never really paid for the sin of appropriating the artistry of Black and Brown queer people who created, innovated within, and continue to sustain and expand the impact of the Balls. Beyoncé sets aside the tired list of White celebrities that every bachelorette party has recited while poorly (and sometimes insultingly) trying to vogue and (re-)introduces the women who created and inspired the best of popular culture, from past luminaries like Rosetta Tharp, Bessie Smith, and Nina Simone to the current pantheon of Lizzo, Santigold, and Janet Jackson.</p><p>Does the track forgive or excuse the sins of appropriation? No. But it does breathe new life and relevance into Madonna’s earnest (if flawed) effort to shine a light on a multiply-marginalized community whose artistic innovations and language now dominate American culture. And it enhances the beauty and impact of Beyoncé’s innovations. For me, that’s the lesson: innovation isn’t <em>ex nihilo</em>. It’s the result of excavating and uplifting the best of our past — even those ideas, practices, and relationships that seem too deeply buried, too broadly forgotten — and juxtaposing it with new experiences, revelations, and insights.</p><p><strong>The <em>Girls </em>reign supreme.</strong></p><p>We may be living in a golden age for scripted television. <em>RuPaul’s Drag Race</em> might currently be dominating the culture (and my screen time). But <strong>the best thing ever on television was, is, and will always be <em>The Golden Girls</em></strong><em> </em>(all seven seasons of which I watched three times in 2022). And <em>Murder, She Wrote </em>(all twelve seasons of which I watched in 2022) is a close second. Prove me wrong.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=718a728be99" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[custom, part five]]></title>
            <link>https://billhulseman.medium.com/custom-part-five-e02c096effc1?source=rss-a9dfa35229fa------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e02c096effc1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[equity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[reflections]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lgbtq]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[weddings]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[meaning]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Bill Hulseman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 15 Aug 2022 22:59:41 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-08-15T23:27:46.491Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*icNVjxleG3QZOMDJ5-hZvw.jpeg" /><figcaption>St. Patrick’s Cathedral and Rockefeller Center, New York City, August 2022. Photo by the author.</figcaption></figure><p>St. Patrick’s Cathedral is legendary not only because of its impressive, Gothic revival structure and liturgical opulence but also because of what it represented to the generations of Irish immigrants and their descendants in New York City who faced ethnic and religious discrimination in the US during the 19th century. Despite the various forms of hardship, social exclusion, and disenfranchisement that immigrants face, some Irish communities thrived and found their kin in positions of authority. From the early days of its construction through its completion, consecration, and status among the grandest monuments of the city, St. Patrick’s embodied survival and success bolstered and proved that Irish Americans had a home, a sanctuary, and surging cultural, economic, and political power.</p><p>My friend Anne’s wedding in 2013 was, for me, a quintessential New York experience. Her ceremony was in the Lady Chapel of St Patrick’s, the smaller sanctuary behind the main altar that hosts daily masses and private ceremonies while the main nave remains a mix of pious worshippers and gawking tourists. When I saw the name of the officiant on the program, I gasped and turned to my friend Christine to ask, “<em>That</em> James Martin?” Martin, a friend of her family, also happens to be a rarity in the postmodern world: a celebrity priest. He’s a prominent editor and author who is very popular on the (Catholic) speaking circuit, always seeking to explore and reflect on the intersection of social justice, communication, and joy in spirituality. In the years after the wedding, he’d expand his focus on building a bridge between LGBTQ folx and the Catholic Church and be painted as a glimmer of hope by some and a danger to the Church by others. To say that I geeked out at the intersection of glorious architecture, Irish American history, and a celebrity priest is an understatement.</p><p>The reception was at a restaurant a few blocks away that Anne’s family had owned for decades but sold a few years before. In that restaurant, her grandfather had created a kind of safe space for Irish folx who didn’t feel (or just weren’t) welcome in other establishments. Even though the new owners shifted the menu to Asian-fusion, a departure from its Irish American roots, returning there felt like a homecoming for Anne’s family and a step into Irish American history for the rest of us. A glorious cathedral, an historic and sentimental restaurant, a celebrity priest…but my favorite part of the whole day was the walk from the cathedral to the restaurant.</p><p>As the ceremony concluded, we were invited to follow the newlyweds out of the church. As we exited the Lady Chapel, tourists and pious worshippers alike took notice of the gleaming couple and looked up from their rosaries and cameras to take in the train of family and friends following them. When we neared the enormous doors, I could hear the loud wheeze of bagpipes — a kilted piper waited on the sidewalk to lead the bride and groom and the rest of us to the reception, piping the whole way. Cars on Fifth slowed, I assumed, to gawk at the spectacle, but various folx rolled their windows down to shout congratulations, good wishes, and compliments for the dashing newlyweds. More than once, I heard a joyful “mazal tov” as people on the sidewalk stopped, stepped aside, and took in Anne’s lovely lace gown. We passed storefronts whose security guards joined in the adulations and restaurant backdoors where cooks and servers, escaping the heat of kitchens, applauded and shouted good wishes. Nobody mocked our little parade. Nobody leered or jeered or did anything unseemly. They were all strangers in a crowded city whose routes were being delayed by a wedding procession on a hot Saturday afternoon, but, it seemed to me, everyone instinctively recognized that something important was happening, something worth stopping for.</p><p>But all those strangers along Fifth Avenue weren’t just passively recognizing a change in someone else’s lives — they all stopped to absorb how this impacted them. What, if any, of their own hopes and dreams, of their own identities and relationships were reflected in our procession? Did seeing us bolster their own joy or reinforce a sense of exclusion? What message were we sending to the world about this couple, about the world they navigated together, about what happiness and joy and love should look like? What moved some strangers to smile with familiarity or to shout out, and what made others look away and hold their tongues? For several years, I treasured the memory of this procession as a uniquely and intensely “only in New York” experience, but as I came to recognize the impact of a wedding (and of any ritual, really) far beyond the couple getting married, I understood the public procession from St. Patrick’s to the reception as evidence that a wedding effects a change in the community formed around a marrying couple and even in the world beyond them, an effect with social, relational, political, ethical, spiritual, and economic consequences. Because of this, wedding-adjacent practices start looking a lot less like fluffy pomp and circumstance and a lot more interesting, both as an insight into who we are and as an opportunity to shape the impact.</p><p>Besides the obvious changes that come with a wedding (a legally recognized shift in the social, material, and economic lives of two people and expanded family ties and friendships) when I think about the <em>effects</em> of a wedding — what’s changed, transformed, crystallized, accomplished… — I also think about a change in <em>perception</em>, a change in how we understand others and ourselves, in how we frame and navigate the world. The perceptions of people who participate in or witness a ceremony are changed in the ritual itself, but wedding customs like public proposals, pronouncements, and processions tell the rest of the world about what’s happening. A restaurant staff conspires with a hopeful romantic to hide an engagement ring and present it at the right moment. A flash mob surprises an unsuspecting partner in a Home Depot with choreography to enhance the moment. <em>The New York Times</em> weddings section publishing the details of couples’ lives and festivities. Processions down Fifth Avenue. The flurry of celebratory posts by newlyweds and their guests on social media in the days after a wedding. These are all seals — tangible, physical and ritualized practices that crystallize a shift in public perception, that enable everyone to recognize that something changed. Because two people shifted their lives and identities, we all have a chance to think about and transform how and how well we know ourselves and each other.</p><h4><em>Sealing a shift in the body politic: Proposals, Pronouncements &amp; Processions</em></h4><p>Over the past month, I’ve been exploring practices included in George Monger’s encyclopedic <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Marriage-Customs-World-Henna-Honeymoons/dp/1576079872"><em>Wedding Customs of the World</em></a>. My goal is to consider what the historical origins, development, and contemporary uses of particular customs tell us not just about their original contexts and about the assumptions about identity and social relationships that they perpetuate. So far, I’ve looked at different ways communities are involved in weddings, the nearly ubiquitous white wedding dress, and the roles of various accessories and jewelry, and last week I turned to practices that ritually, tangibly, and holistically seal a couple’s marriage and a shift in the network of family and friends around them. This week, I’m focusing on proposals, pronouncements, and processions, practices that crystallize a shift in the broader community. These seals take on a much grander, more performative form, in part to match the uniqueness of weddings among other civil rituals and in part to demonstrate the impact of a single wedding on the cultural fabric.</p><p><em>Proposals<br></em>Stephanie Coontz exhaustively describes its evolution in <em>Marriage, A History</em>, but once upon a time, a proposal was a private matter between two families, spurring a period of betrothal for the couple to acquire the material goods required to set up a household and for everyone around them to prepare for a change in status and identities of to-be-weds. As marriage became more about the individuals getting married, related ceremonies and festivities, including the proposal, became more public, more demonstrable events. The image most folx in America conjure when thinking of a proposal includes a man dropping to one knee to “pop the question” and present a diamond ring, but most folx don’t know that the whole scenario is a modern invention. Cele C. Otnes and Elizabeth Peck detail this history, too, in <a href="https://www.ucpress.edu/book/9780520240087/cinderella-dreams"><em>Cinderella Dreams: The Allure of the Lavish Wedding</em></a> and poignantly note that “The tradition of the man ‘on bended knee’ seems to be merely a dramatic flourish in stereopticon pictures and silent films. None of the great suitors in nineteenth-century literature — Mr. Darcy in <em>Pride and Prejudice</em>, Mr. Rochester in <em>Jane Eyre</em>, or Laurie in <em>Little Women</em> — actually fell to their knees.” So the standard image of the proposal actually emerges from the 20th century confluence of various streams of normative sexism, including dominant pop culture projections of gender and romance, with a marketing campaign by Big Diamond. Otnes and Peck also suggest several reasons for the increasing theatricality of the proposal in the last forty years. The proposal, they note, is no longer the <em>beginning</em> of a relationship and the initial prompt to start collecting home goods — it’s the end of the courting phase (Kahneman’s “peak-end” rule applies again!). There’s also a “crude economic calculus” — the lavishness of the wedding, which has expanded in recent generations, is reflected in the lavishness of all wedding-related activities, so…the bigger the wedding, the bigger the proposal.</p><p>As the public and theatrical proposal retains and even builds in popularity, it’s interesting and important to consider what values are being retained along the way. The proposal itself finds its roots in economic negotiations in which women lacked autonomy and seemed to be passed from male (father) to male (suitor) like any of the objects in her dowry. The very notion of a proposal, an ask, implies an uneven power dynamic: even in a same-sex relationship, one is the asker, one the asked, and in every retelling of the event, that role is a key part of understanding and perpetuating gender-based power dynamics in relationships. One solution to this is to eradicate the proposal as a necessary, ritualized step in announcing an impending wedding. When my husband and I made the decision to marry, we avoided any grand gestures and, instead, sustained a dialogue. Neither of us was surprised by any question — it was a mature, adult decision that we made together. That said, the dialogue concluded with a final decision to marry on a moonlit beach in Hawai’i, so we didn’t escape the clutches of romance altogether.</p><p>Another solution is the duplication of roles, something that I’ve seen frequently among same-sex couples but that is also happening more frequently in different-sex couples. We recently attended a beautiful wedding of friends (who happen to be cisgender and straight) who proposed to each other. After they decided to marry, each planned a special moment, complete with a ring, a special location, and carefully crafted words. Duplication of roles didn’t dilute their proposal experience — by sidestepping gender inequities, duplication reframed the proposal not as a contractual betrothal like the olden days or as the end of the courtship phase, the trend that Otnes and Peck identified. Duplication reframed the proposal as another of those peak moments that Kahneman describes, as an intentionally constructed interaction where they revealed deeper layers of themselves and shaped the communication and interactions that characterize their relationship.</p><p><em>Pronouncements<br></em>The pronouncement is of little concern for most people, but the public declaration of commitment (vows) and the public recognition of that commitment by the state (the pronouncement) are the two actions that make a wedding a <em>wedding</em>, that differentiate it from other rituals and, even differentiating it from other types of commitment ceremonies, make it legally binding. Cultural and religious traditions often add a layer of theological texture (for example, some Christian officiants will include “What God has joined together, let no one put asunder”), but the typical formula that officiants use to make it legally binding has three parts: invocation of authority, confirmation, and articulation of a couple’s newly minted social status. Yeah. There’s a lot packed into that tiny little phrase. Let’s break it down.</p><blockquote>By the power vested in me…</blockquote><p>The invocation of authority is a reminder for everyone witnessing a wedding that while anyone can effect a <em>marriage</em>, a relationship characterized by mutual commitment, only the state can effect a <em>Marriage</em> (note the capital M), a <em>legally</em> recognized and <em>binding</em> relationship.</p><blockquote>I now pronounce you…</blockquote><p>And in a wedding, <em>only</em> the officiant wields the power to recognize that change. Oh, suddenly the officiant has a powerful role! This is why, until recently, very few citizens could assume the role of officiant. power was reserved for people who already held a certain amount of legal authority — justices of the peace, judges, and, in the US (but not everywhere), ordained religious clergy. Today, some US states will issue a one-day certification for couples who want to invite a friend who doesn’t wield such legal authority to play the part, but even that adaptation is largely moot in the era of online ordination, which is recognized in most but not all states. Still, each state has its own often complicated regulations for registering officiants, largely to ensure the integrity of the process, and I’ve found that the more complicated the process the less trust the state demonstrates.</p><p>Now the fun part: the final words of the pronouncement, the words that seal the deal, the words that propel a couple into the world with new identities that their friends and family and the state all recognize…</p><blockquote>Man and wife.</blockquote><p>Interesting, eh? The stereotypical phrase isn’t just heteronormative — it’s also wildly disproportionate. One member of a marriage retains a previous status (“man”), but the other is transformed from “woman” to “wife.” More equitably minded officiants and couples adopt “husband and wife,” and, likewise, when Moira Rose concluded the wedding of David and Patrick on <em>Schitt’s Creek</em>, she pronounced them “husband and husband.” Despite its intended equity, I’m still aware of the historical baggage that comes with the monikers “husband” and “wife.” For different-sex couples who value complementarity, parity, and equity, they inject thousands of years of patriarchy into the relationship; for same-sex couples they introduce categories that just don’t apply.</p><p>For me, the function of the pronouncement, of a wedding in general, is to proclaim a new union, a new social unit. This doesn’t necessitate the reframing of each individual — instead, it calls for reframing the <em>couple</em> and emphasizing their new, shared state. Because of this, I prefer to keep it simple, ungendered, and focused on what’s shared: married. By the power vested in me, I pronounce them <em>married.</em></p><p><em>Processions<br></em>Public wedding processions have faded from American weddings. Sure, there are caravans of automobiles to transport a wedding party from home to venue to photo shoot to reception to after party, but processions that both preceded and followed ceremonies had a very specific purpose: to invite the good wishes from the general public, and that alone reinforces a wedding’s role in sealing a shift in the general public. What <em>kind</em> of shift, of course, depends on what kind of procession introduces a marriage to the world. Millions around the world followed Lady Diana’s motorcade through the streets of London to St. Paul’s Cathedral, and millions watched again as Prince and Princess Charles emerged. It wasn’t just a marriage being witnessed — it was the revelation of the next stage of a centuries-old monarchy.</p><p>As Monger describes, the public celebration of a wedding is nearly ubiquitous, and each culture and subculture has its way to mark the occasion. Cars honk their horns in New York City. Folx in England would “fire the anvil,” a boisterous yet wickedly dangerous practice, along the procession’s route. In pre-Taliban Afghanistan, rifles would be fired into the air. Before any party starts, it’s already a noisy affair. “These practices,” Monger writes, “are designed to bring the fact of the wedding to the attention of the whole community, although, in some instances, they may be a part of a belief in warding off evil spirits and malevolent influences with loud noises.” Less (but still playfully) malevolent forces like pranks are often part of the procession. In various parts of Europe and North America, the path to a wedding was traditionally blocked — by everything from children demanding a ransom to felled trees — and it’s still a common practice today to decorate the car that takes a married couple away from their ceremony.</p><p>Processions to a ceremony serve as a kind of meta-symbol of what’s happening with the wedding. Two crowds of people accompany the to-be-weds, but after the ceremony, they travel as a single column behind or around the couple. The message couldn’t be clearer: the entire community is changed because of a single wedding — and everyone should pay attention. While processions like my friend’s up Fifth Avenue are less frequent, I don’t think they’ve totally disappeared. Somewhere along the line, the collective, unconscious “we” accommodated the increasing impracticality of processions by filling the feeds of social media with explosive, ebullient, and expressive photos and messages that do the same as fired anvils and rifles. They overwhelm the senses of even uninterested passers-by. They grab our attention. They let us know that something changed and that, even for the fleeting moment our eye catches it on our feeds, we’re all impacted.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e02c096effc1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[custom, part four]]></title>
            <link>https://billhulseman.medium.com/custom-part-four-2fd2707b309a?source=rss-a9dfa35229fa------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2fd2707b309a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[custom]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tradition]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[weddings]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lgbtq]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[reflections]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Bill Hulseman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 03 Aug 2022 19:36:39 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-08-03T19:36:39.872Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*DjVx6bFQOToDmKx0381JuQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>The author’s wedding ceremony. Photo by <a href="https://www.mikeolbinski.com/">Mike Olbinski</a>.</figcaption></figure><p>Over the past month, I’ve been diving into George Monger’s encyclopedic <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Marriage-Customs-World-Henna-Honeymoons/dp/1576079872"><em>Wedding Customs of the World</em></a>, which collates information about hundreds of practices that make up wedding traditions. My goal is to consider what the historical origins, development, and contemporary uses of particular customs tell us about their original contexts and about the assumptions they reflect about identity and social relationships, but I’m especially interested in thinking about how these practices hold up today. I looked at different ways communities are involved in weddings before turning to the white wedding dress. Last week, I explored the roles of various accessories and jewelry. Next week, I’ll wrap up my reflection, but this week I’m exploring various practices that “seal” a marriage. No, not those magnificent pinnipeds that roam the waters. Seals are actions that signify or formally effect a change.</p><p>From a ritualist’s perspective, seals play a particularly important role in wedding ceremonies. On one hand, <em>how</em> a couple demonstrates their bond tells us something about the world they come from and the world they intend to create, starting with their home and the community surrounding them. In most cultures, the public declaration of marital commitment is demonstrated through some material, tangible, or kinesthetic practice that not only visibly effects a change — it adds layers of meaning from particular cultural contexts and gives the couple a chance to reaffirm, adapt, or even reject those layers. Because seals typically occur in a climactic moment when the community around the couple are paying close attention, how a couple seals their union also impacts the community around them.</p><p>On the other hand, though, seals serve a much more practical purpose. As <a href="https://positivepsychology.com/what-is-peak-end-theory/">Daniel Kahneman’s peak-end theory</a> proposes, we remember the best, the worst, and the final parts about an experience. Because the seal typically concludes the ceremony, how a couple seals their union has a profound impact on what gets remembered (in memories and in photographs) from the moment. Because of a seal’s particular impact, it’s particularly important to be attentive to the explicit and implicit messages it sends, the legacies it carries, and the assumptions it perpetuates. Again, drawing on Monger’s encyclopedia as a starting point, I want to reflect on three relationships that get “sealed” in a wedding ceremony — this week, I’ll focus on a couple’s marriage and the new community around them, and next week I’ll turn to the shift in the body politic in which they live.</p><p><em>Sealing the marriage: Exchange of rings, the Kiss, and Binding practices<br></em>The explicit focus of a wedding is the change in status for two people, and a number of intimate practices demonstrate that change, including the exchange of rings, the kiss, and binding. I’ve already considered the use of rings in ceremonies, but here I’m more interested in their <em>exchange</em>, the ritualized offering and donning of bands. When exchanging rings, an officiant or the couple themselves typically explain what the ring means, from the simplest “With this ring, I thee wed,” to more specific symbolism like the phrase I most often use, “Take this ring: a reminder of my love, a sign of our commitment, a symbol of our life together.” Either way, the ring becomes more than lovely jewelry: it becomes a material signifier of a new status, and wearing it both affirms the verbal vows proclaimed and impacts how both the wearer and anyone who sees it understands something about the wearer’s identity.</p><blockquote>“You may kiss the bride.”</blockquote><p>Most American weddings end with a kiss that serves as a kind of punctuation for the officiant’s pronouncement, but its inclusion in wedding ceremonies is a bit more complicated. Monger gets anthropological when exploring the role of the kiss in wedding ceremonies, citing theories about the origin and function of kissing. As a physical act, kissing, he notes, derives from maternal care and that its erotic prominence appears to be a European export (outside of Europe and North America, he suggests, kissing wasn’t treated as an erotically charged action until the 20th century). In some regions, like medieval France, kissing was explicitly associated with marital intimacy, and “a woman kissing or being kissed by a man other than her husband was guilty of adultery.”</p><p>On the other hand, a kiss might be (in part) stripped of its erotic edge and bolster various power dynamics. “The nuptial kiss delivered at the altar, with permission of the officiant at the legal marriage ceremony,” Monger explains, “is said to be symbolic of religious permission to have sexual intercourse. However, there may be, in this practice, remnants of the Church of Rome practice of bestowing a benediction kiss, for which the priest kissed the bridegroom, who then passed the kiss on to his bride.” At either end of this spectrum, though, from a kiss’ explicit association with marriage to its reinforcement of social and religious hierarchies, “we” (the abstract collective, not royal, we) have wrenched the kiss from its maternal origins and used it as a subtle tool to subjugate women and to submit sexual activity to religious and civil authorities.</p><p>The inclusion of a kiss as the final seal of a ceremony is a relatively recent phenomenon that doesn’t just reflect the changes in attitudes toward public displays of affection. It also reflects the role of sex in marriage. Sex. Fucking. Copulation. Doing it. Whatever you want to call it. Here, I’m not talking about the importance of a healthy, mutually fulfilling sex life. I’m talking about sex as a requirement for a couple to be considered “wed.” Historically and nearly universally, completion of a marriage required much more than public avowal. The wedding wasn’t complete until the newlyweds’ first proverbial roll in the hay, and in many contexts, the wedding party, family members, or social and religious authorities gathered around the marital bed to witness its consummation. In other contexts, particularly societies in which a woman’s virginity is prized over anything else about her, evidence of a bride’s broken hymen (usually a bloodied sheet) is publicly displayed both to prove the marriage’s consummation and to highlight the bride’s virtue. Of course, despite some cultural expectations of male chastity, no one ever sought to publicly prove a groom’s virginity.</p><p>At some point, folx recognized that such public demonstrations were, to say the least, intrusive, and the kiss appeared in the ceremony with the officiant’s pronouncement as a proxy for sexual consummation. Because <em>permission</em> to kiss at that moment is delivered by a representative of the state or a religious figure, it’s also a reminder that permission to fuck is granted (and may be rescinded) by the state. This might not strike heterosexual and cisgender people as alarming, but remember that, through <a href="https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/478/186/"><em>Bowers v. Hardwick</em></a>, the Supreme Court of the United States upheld states’ rights to criminalize oral and anal sex, even between consenting adults, in 1986. And remember that <em>Bowers</em> was the authoritative precedent until 2003 when the Court overturned it with <a href="https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/539/558/"><em>Lawrence v. Texas</em></a>, informed by the right to privacy guaranteed in <a href="https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/410/113/"><em>Roe v. Wade</em></a>. Oh, and remember that Justice Thomas’ concurring opinion for <a href="https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/597/19-1392/"><em>Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization</em></a> encouraged litigants to dismantle the rights built on the foundation of the right to privacy, including equal marriage. So when you hear the old “You may kiss the bride,” or even Moira Rose’s conclusion to the wedding of David and Patrick on <em>Schitt’s Creek</em>, “You may kiss each other,” remember that the language of permission reinforces the state’s authority to regulate your sex life.</p><p>As a side note, I’ve always found the kiss to be awkward. Even in public, surrounded by family and friends, it’s an intimate encounter. I love that sex and sexuality can be affirmed in the ritual context as essential ingredient in a marriage, but, especially when I’m reminded that it’s a proxy for sex, the burst of applause that typically comes from witnesses always feels intrusive, even perverse. The community behaves the same way a gaggle of royals surrounding a bed might when a newly wed princess is deflowered under their gaze or when onlookers in an orgy might when someone is getting gangbanged. For our own ceremony, my husband and I wanted to affirm the role of sex and sexuality and to avoid any hint of perverse voyeurism or chance to applaud. Our vows, exchange of rings, and signing of our marriage certificate were in the middle of the ceremony, not the end. For the final portion, we invited everyone to stand and to affirm their support for us. Instrumental music vamped underneath the officiant’s voice as he said, “surrounded by your family and friends and by the power vested in me, I pronounce you married and invite you to begin our celebrations with your first dance.” Within a few bars, everyone grabbed a partner and joined in.</p><p>Binding is another practice that appears in different forms to signify marital union, with all the physicality but without the sexual baggage. In some parts of northern Europe, “handfasting,” the binding of hands together, alone constituted a wedding ceremony. As legal and religious requirements were placed on weddings, handfasting became a sign of betrothal or even as the start of a trial marriage that could be easily dissolved without stigma for either party. Because of its ancient, pre-Christian origins, handfasting was also suppressed or banned in various regions. Today, neopagan traditions have revived the practice as central to marriage rites, and others integrate it into modern practices, treating it as a connection to ancient heritage, such as Celtic, Irish, or Scottish roots. Binding appears in the form of a lasso in Hispanic and Spanish-influenced practices, including Spanish, Mexican, and Filipino weddings. A lasso or large rosary is tied around the couple by their godparents, parents, or the officiant, signifying both their union and the encompassing support of their community and traditions.</p><p><em>Sealing the community: Eating &amp; Dancing<br></em>With attention focused on the couple at the center, the most overlooked aspect of a wedding is its impact on the rest of the people present. The ritual and its surrounding festivities are designed not just to bring a couple together; they also effect a shift in the community. It might be a shift in perceptions (the community sees the couple in a new light), a shift in relationships (the people around the couple are now directly connected to each other through the shared experience of the wedding), or a shift in values (the new community formed in the wedding goes out into the world with reinforced, adapted, or changed assumptions about what a wedding is and all the values connected to it). Those shifts are often cemented with food and frivolity.</p><p>There’s a reason that people talk about the food at weddings (and that people getting married obsess over delivering a perfect menu and the best cake imaginable to their guests): sharing food is a fundamental practice in all cultures, and more than any other aspect of a wedding it connects strangers and rekindles (and even repairs) old friendships. For Monger, the wedding meal is the most obvious and demonstrable example of how weddings invite active, embodied participation. It gives “guests a chance to be part of the celebrations,” he writes, but I think it’s more powerful and more nuanced than that. <em>How</em> a couple feeds their guests shapes those relationships. Strict seating plans and plated meals afford a couple the opportunity to engineer particular connections (and avoid landmines) and control the flow of a meal, but they also echo the stiff formality of royal and aristocratic banquets and limit people’s chances of interacting with other guests. Open seating plans, or providing no table seating at all encourages more choice and flexibility for guests to find their own connections and to eat at their own pace, but they often leave less gregarious folx untethered and anxious about where to go and with whom to talk.</p><p>What a couple chooses to serve also has an impact on guests. Today, the food options for most American weddings are driven by the catering industry’s standards. Catering teams know what can be prepared and served to various sizes of groups, but most menus defer to the lowest common denominators for food preferences. Any variation from the LCD sometimes incurs significant cost. At our own wedding, we dropped any ambition of trying to satisfy all of our guests’ tastes, but we also used food to lean into our values and experiences and to demonstrate radical welcome to our guests. Except for one salmon dish and one chicken option at the pasta bar, our buffet was vegan, and items were clearly labeled with allergens. This not only reflected our own food preferences and sensitivities; it reflected our commitment to a more equitable buffet.</p><p>Food also carries cultural significance, and the inclusion or exclusion of various dishes communicates something about how the couple at the center connects with their heritages. Monger explores the variety of cultural staples that are adapted for wedding celebrations. In regions where bread is both practically and symbolically central to diets, biscuits and breads are common. These items require advanced preparation and benefit from multiple hands — it’s an easy way for a wedding party, a family, or a community to directly participate in festivities — and they’re often decorated with culturally specific symbolism. In other regions where rice is the dominant starch, rice and rice-based delicacies dominate the symbolic buffet.</p><p>With the global influence of the American nuptial customs, the wedding cake has become a recognizable and distinctive aspect of the wedding feast, but the elaborate versions reflect a recent innovation. Beyond providing a decadent dessert worthy of celebrations, cakes served a more practical purpose, such as the bridegroom cake in 19th century Virginia. “The dark bridegroom cake,” Monger writes, “was, according to one recipe book writer in 1897, cut by the bridegroom and given to the bridesmaids, with a glass of wine, before going to the church. In Virginia, if both cakes were prepared, they were stacked, with the groom’s cake on top, but it was the lighter bride’s cake that was cut at the reception, with the bride and groom giving each other a piece to eat.” Somewhere along the line, the cake detached from the feast, and a ritualized cake-cutting by newlyweds drew on old aristocratic traditions (the highest ranking people in the room are the first to eat, and witnessing them eat was a privilege for witnesses) and became an expected moment to witness and photograph.</p><p>Dancing is another practice that seals the bonds of a community formed around a newly wed couple. Except in regions where political or religious mores ban it, dancing is a pretty ubiquitous way that people express joy during wedding festivities. While some cultures incorporate dancing along the way, most American weddings start the dance party after dinner. Whether guided by a live band, a DJ, or a playlist on the bride’s iPhone, selected songs tell you something about the couple getting married and the world they want to live in and profoundly impact the mood of the community gathered. The selection of songs for first and last dances (remember the Kahneman rule?) also play a major part in what people remember of weddings.</p><p>As Monger describes, “Dance can also be used to initiate one or both of the couple into their new role in society, be an opportunity for those at the function to help the couple set up home or help pay for the celebrations, or be part of the competition between males and females.” In Zulu weddings, dance plays a ceremonial and ritual role — the bride’s party dances to show the groom’s ancestors that she is joining the family — but most American weddings reserve dancing for the post-ceremony celebrations. The tradition of the “first dance” emerged from the confluence of two traditions. First, in European royal courts, the highest ranking royals present would be the first to…well, to do everything. They’re the first to eat, before plates would be passed to guests; first to drink, before wine would be poured; first to dance, to set the mood for the evening. A couple’s “first dance,” then, reinforces the sense that they are royalty for the day. Second, the waltz was a radical innovation that emerged from 17th century Vienna that replaced social choreography, the norm for celebrations at the time, with a partner dance that both emphasized individuality and afforded more direct intimacy for a dancing couple. Because it was a two person dance, it provided an isolated performance for the community to watch, admire, and cheer.</p><p>Etiquette manuals from the 19th and early 20th century instructed the couple’s first dance to be followed by dances featuring the bride and her father, less for sentiment and more to honor the guy who paid for the party. Today, these practices have evolved. Some couples make their first dance a real performance with surprise choreography and a good sense of humor. Since ballroom dancing is passé, others take lessons and show off their new, if rudimentary moves, earning applause and encouragement for even the simplest turns and dips. The father-daughter dance has become an emotionally-engaging moment that has spun off the mother-son dance to highlight the relationship between a groom and his mother.</p><p>For these moments, the community around a newly wed couple are passive viewers, meant to “take in” the beauty and sentiment on display, so it’s important to consider what messages are being conveyed. In addition to the perpetuation of royal and upper class standards, these customs also perpetuate often damaging ideas about gender roles. Ever see a groom dance with his father, or a bride with her mother? Or all three together? Of course not, because such displays rattle our sense of convention and normalcy.</p><p>When the rest of the community is invited to the dance floor, though, that’s when the rest of the community seals its bond. Formal group dances like the Jewish hora, the Irish reel, or the Greek Kalamatianos bring the community together with the physical vocabulary of particular inherited traditions, but for most American weddings the dancefloor is a “free-for-all,” giving guests the chance to show off, to get ridiculous, to get lost in the moment, and, alongside friends and strangers, shed inhibitions. Post-wedding gossip often includes who danced with whom, who disappeared from the dancefloor with whom, who showed up to breakfast with…well, you get the idea. It’s not just tantalizing information — it’s evidence that the newly formed community grew from transgressing old boundaries and differences.</p><p>Of course, we all know that dessert and dancing come <em>after</em> dinner, but in recent decades the cake cutting and first dance have been absorbed into a moment earlier in most festivities. Here’s how it typically goes: guests take their seats; an emcee or DJ introduces members of the wedding party and the newly married couple; the couple proceed to the dance floor for their ceremonial first dance (even though no one else can dance until after dinner), followed by other sentimental dances; then they go to the corner of the dance floor to cut and feed each other a piece of their cake (even though they haven’t eaten dinner yet) before they sit down to be toasted by their witnesses. It makes for a tight sequence, but this pattern doesn’t serve the couple or their celebrations: it serves the Wedding Industrial Complex. Once upon a time, they served to punctuate and move celebrations along, but now they’re compressed to maximize efficiency. See, the first dance, the cake cutting, and toasts are prime photo opportunities, but photographers are on the clock. So are caterers, and early first dances and toasts give them more time to prep and deliver food. The cake needs to be cut and plated, too, which can be most efficiently done while guests are eating dinner. This way, by the time the dancing starts, caterers and event staff can start to clear dishes, clean up, and maybe even be released early from work.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2fd2707b309a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[custom, part three]]></title>
            <link>https://billhulseman.medium.com/custom-part-three-a25a9c43eb16?source=rss-a9dfa35229fa------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a25a9c43eb16</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[change]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[weddings]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[custom]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lgbtq]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tradition]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Bill Hulseman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 22 Jul 2022 02:32:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-07-22T02:32:44.697Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*pCT9_hBT0wiBPKTD-0PrKA.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>Cufflinks designed by </em><a href="https://f69e.engage.squarespace-mail.com/r?m=62da0a3c40d46c20a088ef92&amp;u=https%3A%2F%2Flambrechtsjewelers.com&amp;w=5eee34827315ad5ff7c6c0e1&amp;e=2022-07-23T02%3A24%3A19.914398Z&amp;l=en-US&amp;s=xNQEnHHUyCmXBf68ZpmrcVK0Swg%3D"><em>Beth Lambrecht</em></a><em>. Photo by </em><a href="https://f69e.engage.squarespace-mail.com/r?m=62da0a3c40d46c20a088ef92&amp;u=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.mikeolbinski.com&amp;w=5eee34827315ad5ff7c6c0e1&amp;e=2022-07-23T02%3A24%3A19.914398Z&amp;l=en-US&amp;s=IKW4kC2a7nwPAcYSgeTiXVruUJY%3D"><em>Mike Olbinski</em></a><em>.</em></figcaption></figure><p>Soon after we shared the news of our engagement with family and friends, my sister started plotting a surprise for us, a surprise that came with a story.</p><p>When she died, my grandmother, my father’s mother, left behind a really extraordinary collection of jewelry. My parents were tasked with appraising and dividing it among her children and grandchildren, and I sat at the table, rapt, as they unwrapped, laid out, and photographed every piece. Because she refused to get on an airplane (or maybe just to get some time away from him), my grandfather went on long trips to “exotic” locales without her, and he’d return with unique pieces of jewelry. In the distribution, my mom inherited a few really interesting pieces, including an intricate and dazzling diamond brooch. Because it was truly, truly fabulous, Mom only wore it on <em>very</em> special occasions, like black-tie events or Tuesday sojourns to the grocery store.</p><p>When Mom died, my sister inherited that brooch, but she quickly recognized that she and her daughters would never need such a piece, unless they’re summoned for a ball at Buckingham with Her Majesty. She worked with a jeweler to break the original brooch apart to make smaller pieces for her kids, but there were a few small stones left, including eight tiny baguette-cut stones. She imagined cufflinks for my then-fiancé and me, but when she couldn’t decide between silver and gold, my other sister wisely advised her to consult us. That’s when my sister called and explained her plan. When I stopped crying, all I could say was, <em>thank you</em>.</p><p>The next time we were in town, we met with a jeweler to look at the stones and settle on a design. I’d been in this shop a hundred times before — my parents were loyal customers to her parents for decades. I accompanied my mom countless times to get a watch fixed or to resize a ring. I also accompanied my dad countless times to pick a birthday present for Mom, an anniversary present for Mom, a Christmas present…he loved doting on my mom through jewelry, but for him it wasn’t all about the glitz and glam. He picked pieces that told a story. For one anniversary, he gave her a ring with ten diamonds, one for each of their children. For another, he picked a gold brooch in the shape of a tree with fifteen or twenty tiny pearls, one for each year since they married.</p><p>Though she opened each box with exaggerated exasperation, saying, “Bob — <em>where</em> am I going to wear this? To the grocery store?” She’d self-deprecate a bit more and, highlighting the plain white sneakers she wore most days, say with a smirk, “Do you think they’ll go with my Keds?” Inspired by <em>The Will Rogers Follies</em>, we shared a little laugh every time she opened a box when one of us would sing, “Diamoooonds…for Mis-sus Rogers…” Even after a stroke debilitated him, he sent my sister to the shop, knowing that the jeweler would know exactly what he intended. My mom opened the box, seated in a chair next to his hospital bed, and, fighting back very uncharacteristic-for-her tears, gasped, “Bob — how did you…well, where am I going to wear these?” She might’ve been embarrassed by the extravagance, but she wore them — yes, to the grocery store — with pride.</p><p>Crowded around her desk, my sister, my then-fiancé, and I considered her sketches, settled on a design, and looked at the batch of tiny baguettes. Because of the shape of the brooch from which they came, they were all slightly different sizes. I found myself getting misty thinking about that imperfection. At one level, it felt very <em>wabi sabi</em>, purposefully and humbly imperfect. At another, it seemed especially appropriate for a queer couple, a classic accessory with a playful twist. And more, because of the imperfections, the unique source, and the stories they carried, the cufflinks we’d eventually wear could never be replicated.</p><p>When we dressed for our wedding and put the links into our cuffs, I was poignantly aware of their history. They took on a kind of sacred status for me — though ordinary jewelry, they were different, distinct from other things on the dresser. It may be too strong to suggest that they’re talismanic or horcruxes, but at the very least they’re first class relics that link multiple generations of my family. When we wore them in our ceremony, we were surrounded by our family and friends and photos of my parents, my sister, and my husband’s father, all of whom died a few years before we married. They became a tangible link to my history and all of the stories, generosity, and relationships they touched.</p><p>Maybe I associated attachment to ritual objects with superstitions and outdated sentiment, but in that moment I came to understand the power of material traditions. Had the brooch stayed intact, it would’ve been a lovely but rarely used object. My sister’s generosity and creativity resulted in an innovation that preserved a tradition but also made room for expanding and adapting it.</p><p>This month, I’ve been diving into George Monger’s encyclopedic <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Marriage-Customs-World-Henna-Honeymoons/dp/1576079872"><em>Wedding Customs of the World</em></a>, which collates information about hundreds of practices that make up wedding traditions. My goal is to consider what the historical origins, development, and contemporary uses of particular customs tell us about their original contexts and about the assumptions they reflect about identity and social relationships, but I’m especially interested in thinking about how these practices hold up today. First, I looked at different ways communities are involved in weddings, and last week, I turned to the white wedding dress. This week, I’m exploring the roles of various accessories and jewelry that, though not as visually prominent in a ceremony, profoundly, if subtly, shape the experience of a wedding ritual and communicate much about the values that are perpetuated, reinforced, or challenged through their use.</p><p><em>Accessories: wedding belts, garters, and crowns. Oh, my.<br></em>Beyond the wedding dress, there are other sartorial elements that play an important symbolic and functional role in weddings in multiple cultural contexts. For example, Monger describes the variety of “wedding belt” practices. In ancient Rome, a bride wore a kind of chastity belt which would be undone by her groom before they, um, you know, consummated their union. The belt and its undoing are a transparent metaphor for a woman’s virginity, but, while its sexual connotations go well with other wedding practices, such belts were not used exclusively in this context. The belt held medical and magical qualities and was worn for protection or as a love charm.</p><p>The practice spread throughout Europe and the Middle East with aesthetic and cultural variations — one can imagine such a practice traveling with the spread of the Roman Empire and adapting to or absorbing regional customs and layers of interpretation — but its basic form, function, and symbolism remain consistent. In the Turkish iteration, a groom’s family provides a belt of red and white ribbons to the bride. Her father ties it around her waist and instructs “her to ‘keep her waist tight,’ which is a way of telling her to control the couple’s sexual life.” This magnifies the families’ authority in the marriage, and it also clearly puts a woman’s sexuality at the center of the marriage, of the ritual, and of the community. That’s an interesting contrast to Jewish tradition early in the Common Era which included the gift of an ornate sash or girdle from the groom to the bride as a symbol of betrothal (a very different precedent to the engagement ring). The bride reciprocated with a gift of a tallis, or prayer shawl. In later Jewish tradition, a couple exchanged marriage belts as part of an increasingly elaborate series of gifts preceding their marriage. Unlike the Turkish version, the practice seems to intensify the focus on the relationship at the center with mutual, if differing, responsibilities.</p><p>We don’t see many marriage belts in contemporary American weddings, but a practice with similar implications (binding a woman’s body until a groom undoes her virginity) survives: the removal of the garter. Today, a bride’s garter is typically an extraneous elastic and ruffled band that sits above the knee to hold up her stockings, but it originated as a bunch of ribbons tied just below the knee. In 17th &amp; 18th century Britain, men would pull ribbons from the bride’s garter to wear in their hats for luck. “Bridal garters,” Monger explains, “were prized as love tokens with magical properties” and distributed as prizes during wedding festivities. In France, one custom included an auction whose highest bidder won the right to remove the bride’s garter. American weddings today sometimes (though decreasingly) include a variation of this practice — it’s been a while, but I witnessed this multiple times as a kid! At one reception, the bride, a close friend of our family, sat on a chair in the middle of the dance floor, and the groom walked around her, postured and joked with guests, and then dramatically fell to one knee, lifted her skirt, and slowly pulled the garter from her leg. He then tossed it to a group of unmarried men waiting for the prize, and the one who caught it, some might believe, was destined to be the next bachelor to marry.</p><p>However one spins it, the tying and untying of a wedding belt and the removal of the garter are unquestionably a demonstration of sexual power. While the Jewish practice evolved into something slightly more equitable, historically, there aren’t complementary practices that give women a controlling role. The tradition of tossing of the bouquet, one of the last actions a bride takes before she leaves the reception (and heads to the bridal chamber), doesn’t include her stripping flowers from her groom — even as she tosses the bouquet to a group of unmarried women, she remains in a passive role, quite literally leaving her virginity behind. Throw in a white gown to highlight the connection between virginity and moral purity, and the practice delivers a serious commentary on gender roles that is seriously out of step with modern and postmodern values.</p><p>The use of crowns to adorn a marrying couple is a widespread historical practice, too, that continues to frame the couple as “king and queen” for a day. Sometimes, crowns are purely aesthetic, part of an elaborate outfit or headdress, but in Greek weddings, like rings in contemporary American weddings, crowns serve an important ritual function — once donned, a bride and groom become husband and wife. Monger draws a parallel to a practice in Indonesia, a Mingangkabau bride’s horned headdress. Their name (Mingangkabau) itself means ‘victorious buffalo,’ and the bride’s horns evoke those of a buffalo. Bridal headdresses are passed from mothers to their daughters to, as Monger describes, symbolize “the position of women in this matrilineal society where land is held by the women who pass it from mother to daughter.” A few days later, brides don gold crowns to mark their new status, but only after the days of the buffalo headdress which mark her assumption to the matriarchal lineage.</p><p>Considering these practices side by side, an important insight about ritual practice in general and about weddings in particular emerges. In the context of a ritual, an ordinary item or action takes on new dimensions. A belt or girdle might be a functional accessory any other day, but on her wedding, it becomes a symbolic distillation of the bride’s role in the wedding and in her ensuing life. A crown projects wealth and authority any other day, but amid wedding festivities it also communicates the transference of power and authority. Because people are paying attention in a different way, precisely how they are juxtaposed and used can perpetuate and reinforce the values baked into those practices and symbols. As societies evolve, weddings provide a space to push back against changes, such as the increasing social power and authority of women, but by juxtaposing things differently, by eliminating or revising those practices, weddings also provide a potent space to innovate and to change the fabric of their broader societies.</p><p><em>Jewelry<br></em>“Jewelry at the wedding,” Monger explains, “therefore fulfilled several functions — as a straight ornament, as part of the bride’s dowry, as part of an exchange of gifts to seal the contract, as a way to protect the bride from malignant spirits, and as an indicator of the status of the wearer.” While grooms are sometimes adorned with jewelry for the ceremony or festivities, jewelry is most frequently associated with and more directly pertinent to brides. Monger doesn’t ask why, but it’s hard to avoid the reality that, until very recently, especially in European and North American cultures, men have been the sole inheritors of major generators of wealth, such as land and legal authority, and women’s wealth was limited to material, transportable goods.</p><p>In <em>The Constant Princess</em>, Philippa Gregory paints a (mostly fictional) portrait of Catherine of Aragon, the first wife of Henry VIII. When she is set aside by the king and cut off from royal resources, Catherine carefully stewards her own dowry and physical possessions to be able to maintain her household. To pay for food and other essentials, she sells off, piecemeal, silver plates and gold jewelry. It’s just one example of Gregory’s commitment throughout her novels to illuminate the “real life” concerns of historical women and to challenge unquestioned traditions like primogeniture, and it, rather starkly, demonstrates both the purpose of dowries and the fragile position of even the most powerful women in history.</p><p>Rings are perhaps the most familiar pieces of jewelry associated with weddings, but what kind of ring and how it was used has varied significantly over time. Roman grooms often sent their brides iron rings ahead of their wedding, and Ancient Greek and Roman rings included inscriptions, a practice that continued into the Renaissance with “posy rings.” Monger also describes “gimmal rings,” interlocking bands that would be broken apart over a bible before witnesses to constitute a betrothal. The rings would be worn by the couple until the wedding, when the rings would be reunited. In late-medieval England, an engagement ring was actually treated as an indicator of the bride’s dowry, a sort of preview to what the bride would bring with her, but rings were also often sent by grooms as gifts to their future brides. In Jewish tradition, rings were so elaborate and ornate that they were unwearable — but they were mostly borrowed for ceremonial use, not worn as a daily indicator of marital status.</p><p>Today, we’re accustomed to seeing a wedding or engagement ring on the fourth finger of the left hand, but that’s a modern innovation. Because the left hand was associated with bad luck or worse (for example, Satan), most wedding rings were worn on the right hand. They were worn on the middle finger because, it was thought, it had a direct connection to the heart. Among the religious and social changes that came with the Reformation, Protestants started wearing wedding rings on their left hands to distance themselves from previous practices; today, in predominantly Christian regions that were not dominated by Protestants, wedding rings continue to appear on the right hand. Under the brief period of an abolished monarchy and Puritan rule in England, the use of wedding rings was banned because of their “heathenish origin,” but even after they returned to regular use, people didn’t continuously wear wedding rings until the19th century.</p><p>And then there’s the diamond ring, the ultimate symbol of modern romance and marriage. Monger writes:</p><blockquote>A separate engagement ring, in the modern sense, given by the prospective groom to his bride-to-be is a fairly recent innovation in the history of marriage, although rings have long been given as love tokens or tokens of a promise to marry. The jewel-encrusted engagement ring was not part of the normal symbol of engagement to marry until a 1938 De Beers advertising campaign to promote the sale of diamonds.</blockquote><p>Not so ultimate in this light, eh? Like Queen Victoria marching down the aisle to musical accompaniment in a white dress, De Beers invented a tradition with global ramifications with a marketing campaign. Unlike imitators of Victoria’s dress, though, diamond buyers have a direct and irreversible impact on the planet and on the lives and livelihoods of entire communities of people. This new burst of demand for diamond rings exacerbated the geological and human rights abuses that had already survived from early colonial times, devastating and sometimes enslaving communities throughout Africa. While alternatives have emerged, including lab-grown gems and responsible sourcing methods, <a href="https://www.hrw.org/news/2018/05/10/diamond-trade-still-fuels-human-suffering">the ongoing demand for diamonds continues to fund a largely unethical and unsupervised industry, at the expense of the lives and liberties of entire communities.</a></p><p>Rings are so much more than indicators of marital status. Like all jewelry used in wedding customs, they reveal both the kinds of values and assumptions that get passed on with traditional practices <em>and </em>the possibility of innovation without losing their core purpose and meaning.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a25a9c43eb16" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“When you love someone a lot, they just look like love.”]]></title>
            <link>https://billhulseman.medium.com/when-you-love-someone-a-lot-they-just-look-like-love-5c5304ced54?source=rss-a9dfa35229fa------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5c5304ced54</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[poetry]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[weddings]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[love]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[literature]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marriage]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Bill Hulseman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 19 Jul 2022 23:48:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-07-19T23:48:13.946Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>how to pick a reading for your wedding</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*VFU4WNdl5xRcaJAvP6aPWg.jpeg" /><figcaption>A reading from the author’s wedding. Photo by <a href="https://www.mikeolbinski.com/">Mike Olbinski</a>.</figcaption></figure><p>One of my favorite aspects of designing a wedding ceremony is identifying and integrating texts. There’s no rule that a couple has to include any readings, but they can enhance the experience of a ceremony by providing a glimpse into a couple’s relationship, their values, and the world they want to live in. It’s also an easy way to manipulate the emotions of participants…er, rather, to calibrate the emotional engagement of a ceremony. Some readings inspire deep reflection, some just make people weep, and some add a welcome dose of levity and even laughter.</p><p>Unfortunately, most online sites that recommend readings for weddings rely on a narrow range of cliché texts about love and romance instead of offering tools for discernment. I can’t blame those sites or their contributors — as a society, we generally lack a capacity for reflection because we’re taught that reflection is basically quiet opinionating. I tend to approach <em>reflection</em> with guidance from the great John Dewey. As <a href="http://c2l.mcnrc.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/8/2013/05/CarolRodgers-Article.pdf">Carol Rodgers summarizes</a>, for Dewey, there are four criteria for authentic reflection: reflection is a <em>meaning-making process</em> that moves us between and helps us see the connections between different experiences; it is a <em>systematic, rigorous, disciplined way of thinking</em>; it happens best <em>in community and in interaction</em> with others; and it requires <em>attitudes that value holistic growth</em>, including whole-heartedness, directness, open-mindedness, and responsibility.</p><p>It’s a little much to expect a couple to dive into Deweyan reflection as part of their preparation for marriage, so I’ve distilled and translated that approach into four criteria for couples to discern texts that will contribute to a ceremony that both reflects <em>them</em>, not just what the Wedding Industrial Complex has made available, and that will function well in a ceremony.</p><ul><li><strong>Criterion 1: The reading is <em>accessible</em>. </strong>It’s not too long, it doesn’t invoke too many big ideas or images, and it doesn’t mix metaphors. It relies on words that you understand, and it <em>sounds </em>good when read aloud.</li><li><strong>Criterion 2: The reading is <em>meaningful</em> to you.</strong> Whether it’s a text you’ve pored over for decades or something you stumbled across last week, it speaks to you in a powerful way, helps you understand an experience, or motivates you to go deeper with an idea. It evokes feelings and ideas that you want to associate with your wedding.</li><li><strong>Criterion 3: The reading reflects your <em>experiences</em>, <em>identities</em>, and <em>values</em>. </strong>It affirms your life and expands your worldview. Its author and original context resonate with your experiences. It projects a world you want to live in.</li><li><strong>Criterion 3.1: The reading reflects <em>your </em>experiences, identities, and values.</strong> It comes from a cultural context with which you are affiliated and isn’t borrowed inappropriately or unknowingly from a cultural or religious source to which you have no claim.</li><li><strong>Criterion 4: The reading opens your eyes to a different way of understanding yourselves. </strong>It’s both a mirror and a window to see yourselves and your relationship in a new light or from a different angle and to imagine the directions that you could grow together.</li></ul><p>With these criteria in mind, here are 11 readings you probably haven’t heard at a wedding. Each offers something new to how we can construct and think about wedding ceremonies. There are <em>thousands</em> more readings that meet these criteria for every couple, and as more couples (and officiants, and wedding planners, and anyone involved in wedding ceremonies) discern and adopt new elements, we’ll all benefit from a richer, more diverse, more authentic, and evolving canon of traditions and practices from which to draw.</p><p><strong>“Relationships are scary and complicated…”<br></strong><a href="https://ariaste.tumblr.com/post/120001324304/relationships-are-scary-and-complicated-only-when">Alexandra Rowland</a></p><blockquote><strong><em>Relationships are scary and complicated ONLY when you start thinking of your partner as some kind of adversary.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>You know how to stop being scared of relationships? Remember that it’s got a goddamn buddy system *built in*. That’s all a relationship IS: “Let’s approach life with the buddy system.”</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>Check on your buddy. Make sure your buddy doesn’t forget their lunch box on the schoolbus. Hold hands with your buddy so you don’t get lost. If your buddy wants to look at the monkey cage, look at the goddamn monkey cage with them. If you are the one looking at the monkey cage, ask your buddy what they want to do next, and when they want to feed the giraffe, help them find a quarter for the little food dispenser. Be a good buddy, and if your buddy isn’t a good one, too, tell the teacher and ask for a new one.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>This isn’t fucking rocket science, people.</em></strong></blockquote><p>I stumbled across this on a Reddit thread and kept returning to it for three days. In one brief rant, Rowland brings down the temperature that often rises with commitment and dismantles myths about the complexity of relationships.</p><p>I’d recommend this to a couple who want to bring a little bit of levity and candor to their ceremony, who don’t want to hide behind traditional and flowery language. The specific instructions, drawing on childhood friendships and responsibilities, is fodder for a couple who want to highlight mutual care and awareness as they build their marriage.</p><p><strong>“Love Poem Without a Drop of Hyperbole In It”<br></strong><a href="https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2018/01/08/love-poem-without-a-drop-of-hyperbole-in-it">Traci Brimhall</a></p><blockquote><strong><em>I love you like ladybugs love windowsills, love you<br>like sperm whales love squid. There’s no depth<br>I wouldn’t follow you through. I love you like<br>the pawns in chess love aristocratic horses.<br>I’ll throw myself in front of a bishop of a queen<br>for you. Even a sentient castle. My love is crazy<br>like that. I like that sweet little hothouse mouth<br>you have. I like to kiss you with tongue, with gusto,<br>with socks still on. I love you like a vulture loves<br>the careless deer at the roadside. I want to get<br>all up in you. I love you like Isis loved Osiris<br>but her devotion came up a few inches short.<br>I’d train my breath and learn to read sonar until<br>I retrieved every lost blood vessel of you. I swear<br>this love is ungodly, not an ounce of suffering in it.<br>Like salmon and its upstream itch, I’ll dodge grizzlies<br>for you. Like hawks and skyscraper rooftops,<br>I’ll keep coming back. Maddened. A little hopeless.<br>Embarrassingly in love. And that’s why I’m on<br>the couch kissing pictures on my phone instead of<br>calling you in from the kitchen where you are<br>undoubtedly making dinner too spicy, but when<br>you hold the spoon to my lips and ask if it’s ready<br>I’ll say it is, always, but never, there is never enough.</em></strong></blockquote><p>I know — this <em>immediately</em> violates my criterion about too many images and mixing metaphors…but all of these really point to one overriding idea, that their shared love “is never enough.” The poem blends melodrama and cheesy gushing into a sweet text that captures those discrete moments when love unexpectedly swells in our hearts. Despite all the cheese, Brimhall’s tongue-in-cheek voice avoids both cliché and cynicism and delivers a relatable and joyful text.</p><p>This is a great selection for a couple who blend humor and sentiment and who want to continually stoke — and celebrate — those moments when all the overwhelming feels rise up.</p><p><strong>from <em>Spirit of the Earth<br></em></strong>Pierre Teilhard de Chardin, SJ,</p><blockquote><strong><em>Love is the most universal, the most tremendous and the most mystical of cosmic forces.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>Love is the primal and universal psychic energy.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>Love is a sacred reserve of energy; it is like the blood of spiritual evolution.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>Love is an adventure and a conquest. It survives and develops, like the universe itself, only by perpetual discovery.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>Love alone is capable of uniting living beings in such a way as to complete and fulfill them, for it alone takes them and joins them by what is deepest in themselves.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>Love is the affinity which links and draws together the elements of the world.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>Love, in fact, is the agent of universal synthesis.</em></strong></blockquote><p>Leave it to a mid-20th century Jesuit paleontologist to connect human love to the evolution of the universe. I’ve reformatted this excerpt to treat this prose paragraph as a litany, both to make it more accessible and to highlight the path to his ultimate insight, that love is “the agent of universal synthesis.” Ok, that might be a phrase that goes over the heads of folx present at the ceremony, but if delivered deliberately all of the phrases leading up to it, the discrete aspects of the transformative and meaning-enhancing power of love, it delivers a profound and powerful message that applies to the couple at the center and to every other person in the room.</p><p>I’d recommend this for philosophically inclined couples, especially those who see not just complementarity but unity in science and spirituality.</p><p><strong>“Love is a place”</strong></p><p><a href="https://poetrysociety.org/poetry-in-motion/love-is-a-place">e.e. cummings</a></p><blockquote><strong><em>Love is a place<br>&amp; through this place of<br>love move<br>(with brightness of peace)<br>all places</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>yes is a world<br>&amp; in this world of<br>yes live<br>(skillfully curled)<br>all worlds</em></strong></blockquote><p>For all his sparseness and lack of punctuation, cummings sure packs a lot into his poems. This one is less popular for weddings than <a href="https://www.poetryfoundation.org/poetrymagazine/poems/49493/i-carry-your-heart-with-mei-carry-it-in">“i carry your heart,”</a> but this one makes love and our commitments to each other tangible. It also frames the experience of the ceremony — all places and all worlds are present in the place where a community gathers around a couple, when they say “yes” to each other and to moving through life together.</p><p>If the poem resonates with a couple, it might also provide an interesting structure that can be extrapolated for the whole ceremony. The first half might be inspired by the first stanza, framing the gathering and highlighting what exactly is happening, and the second stanza might inspire the rites of marriage and the vows that all boil down to a shared “yes,” for the couple and for everyone around them.</p><p><strong>Shir haShirim, Poem 7<br></strong><a href="https://www.marciafalk.com/songs.html">tr. Marcia Falk</a></p><blockquote><strong><em>In sandy earth or deep<br>In valley soil<br>I grow, a wildflower thriving<br>On your love.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>Narcissus in the brambles,<br>Brightest flower -<br>I choose you from all others<br>For my love.</strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>Sweet fruit tree growing wild<br>Within the thickets -<br>I blossom in your shade<br>And taste your love.</em></strong></blockquote><p><strong>Shir haShirim, Poem 28<br></strong><a href="https://www.marciafalk.com/songs.html">tr. Marcia Falk</a></p><blockquote><strong><em>Stamp me in your heart,<br>Upon your limbs,<br>Sear my emblem deep<br>Into your skin.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>For love is strong as death,<br>Harsh as the grave.<br>Its tongues are flames, a fierce<br>And holy blaze.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>Endless seas and floods,<br>Torrents and rivers<br>Never put out love’s<br>Infinite fires.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>Those who think that wealth<br>Can buy them love<br>Only play the fool<br>And meet with scorn.</em></strong></blockquote><p>Among Jewish and Christian scripture, The Song of Songs, or Shir ha’Shirim, is an outlier. Despite its specifically religious context, there’s no mention of God, which prompted centuries of theological gymnastics to justify its place in the canon. Some suggested that it’s a collection of fragments of an ancient wedding ceremony; others that it’s a metaphor for God’s love for the world or for humanity. Marcia Falk bucked that trend and delivered a collection that is distinct in a few important ways. First, she approached it as a collection of discrete love poems, not a single, unified text. Second, she eschewed commitment to literal, word-for-word translation, which most biblical editions adopt. Those translations, like the famous King James version, might be more familiar to modern audiences, but they miss the texture and nuance that are embedded in the original text. Third, she identifies and uplifts the very real possibility that The Song was originally composed, at least in part, by women.</p><p>Both of these selections resonate with a ceremony. Poem 7highlights the role of choice in commitment, and Poem 28, whose more traditional translations are already popular for weddings, speaks to the transformative power of love. Though ancient in origin, Falk’s translation highlights their timelessness and near-universal relevance to human relationships.</p><p><strong>“And I Have You”<br></strong><a href="https://nikki-giovanni.com/">Nikki Giovanni</a></p><blockquote><strong><em>Rain has drops<br>Sun has shine<br>Moon has beams<br>That makes you mine</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>Rivers have banks<br>Sands for shores<br>Hearts have heartbeats<br>That make me yours</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>Needles have eyes<br>Though pins may prick<br>Elmer has glue<br>To make things stick</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>Winter has Spring<br>Stockings feet<br>Pepper has mint<br>To make it sweet</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>Teachers have lessons<br>Soup du jour<br>Lawyers sue bad folks<br>Doctors cure</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>All and all<br>This much is true<br>You have me<br>And I have you</em></strong></blockquote><p><strong>“You Came Too”<br></strong><a href="https://nikki-giovanni.com/">Nikki Giovanni</a></p><blockquote><strong><em>I came to the crowd seeking friends<br>I came to the crowd seeking love<br>I came to the crowd for understanding</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>I found you</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>I came to the crowd to weep<br>I came to the crowd to laugh</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>You dried my tears<br>You shared my happiness</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>I went from the crowd seeking you<br>I went from the crowd seeking me<br>I went from the crowd forever</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>You came, too</em></strong></blockquote><p>Nikki Giovanni is, for many poetry fans, a living legend. As a prominent Black and queer poet, she’s been a trailblazer since she emerged in the Black Arts Movement in the 1960s. “And I Have You” demonstrates the distinctness and unity of pairs — a great metaphor for a couple celebrating a couple that will preserve, not dilute, the individuality of each partner. The series of relationships she invokes deftly highlights the beauty of complementarity without diluting each’s unique and autonomous identities. “You Came Too” celebrates the discovery of love in the bigger context of friendships and community. Thinking about it in the context of a wedding, it almost reads like a series of vows.</p><p><strong>“One Hundred Love Sonnets: XVII”<br></strong><a href="https://www.poetryfoundation.org/poems/49236/one-hundred-love-sonnets-xvii">Pablo Neruda, tr. Mark Eisner</a></p><blockquote><strong><em>I don’t love you as if you were a rose of salt, topaz,<br>or arrow of carnations that propagate fire:<br>I love you as one loves certain obscure things,<br>secretly, between the shadow and the soul.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>I love you as the plant that doesn’t bloom but carries<br>the light of those flowers, hidden, within itself,<br>and thanks to your love the tight aroma that arose<br>from the earth lives dimly in my body.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>I love you without knowing how, or when, or from where,<br>I love you directly without problems or pride:<br>I love you like this because I don’t know any other way to love,<br>except in this form in which I am not nor are you,<br>so close that your hand upon my chest is mine,<br>so close that your eyes close with my dreams.</em></strong></blockquote><p>All of the sonnets that Neruda wrote for his spouse drip with passion, but this one stands out by distinguishing the couple’s love from other loves and provides a roadmap for a life together: loving without problems or pride, staying so close that your eyes close with each other’s dreams. The words seem to leap off the page (or screen) and offer themselves up as language for vows. In fact, that’s exactly what it did for me and my husband — we included this as a reading in our ceremony and integrated the language of the third stanza into the vows we crafted.</p><p><strong>from “Women and Honor: Some Notes on Lying” in <em>On Lies, Secrets, and Silence<br></em></strong><a href="https://wwnorton.com/books/On-Lies-Secrets-and-Silence/">Adrienne Rich</a></p><blockquote><strong><em>An honorable human relationship -<br>that is, one in which two people<br>have the right to use the word “love” -<br>is a process,<br>delicate, violent,<br>often terrifying to both persons involved,<br>a process of refining<br>the truths they can tell each other.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>It is important to do this<br>because it breaks down<br>human self-delusion and isolation.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>It is important to do this<br>because in doing so<br>we do justice to our own complexity.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>It is important to do this<br>because we can count on so few people<br>to go that hard way with us.</em></strong></blockquote><p>Adrienne Rich is remembered as a feminist theorist and as a prolific and trailblazing author, and for queer folx her words captured the sensuousness of queer love that hadn’t made it to wider audiences before. Her insights blended the political, erotic, and personal, and her words still reverberate…and titillate…and enrage (sorry, couldn’t think of another ‘-ate’). This excerpt from a 1975 essay, reformatted to open up the prose for a public reading, is an original meditation on love that recognizes its dark side as part of the process of loving, a process that worlds toward breaking down “human self-delusion and isolation.”</p><p>I’d recommend this reading for queer couples or any couples with feminist conviction — maybe as a preamble to the ceremony to be clear about the goal of the ceremony. It’s not just a chance to get mushy (though that happens); an authentic wedding ceremony does “justice to our own complexity” and makes space to celebrate the “delicate, violent, often terrifying” process that the marriage ceremony crystallizes.</p><p><strong>from <em>Cinderella Liberator<br></em></strong><a href="https://www.haymarketbooks.org/books/1271-cinderella-liberator">Rebecca Solnit</a></p><blockquote><strong><em>[T]here isn’t actually a most beautiful person in the world, because there are so many kinds of beauty.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>Some people love roundness and softness,<br>and other people love sharp edges and strong muscles.<br>Some people like thick hair like a lion’s mane,<br>and other people like thin hair that pours down like an inky waterfall,<br>and some people love someone so much they forget what they look like.<br>Some people think the night sky full of stars at midnight is the most beautiful thing imaginable,<br>some people think it’s a forest in snow,<br>and some people…</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>Well, there are a lot of people with a lot of ideas about beauty.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>And love.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>When you love someone a lot,<br>they just look like love.</em></strong></blockquote><p>There are many things to love about Rebecca Solnit’s novella, <a href="https://www.haymarketbooks.org/books/1271-cinderella-liberator"><em>Cinderella Liberator</em></a>. In Solnit’s reimagination of the classic fairy tale, Cinderella is more hero than damsel-in-distress or maiden-in-waiting. She saves others not with great feats — she speaks the truth. Solnit incorporates all the characters from the original — the abusive step-mother, the vain step-sisters, the prince seeking love — but it’s Cinderella who helps them all to see options to live authentically.</p><p>Just before this excerpt, Cinderella’s step-sisters are competing to be the most beautiful — one believes the trick is having the highest and most fabulous hair, the other obsesses over the number of ribbons and frills on her dress. As a kind of an inner monologue, Cinderella sidesteps the debate and reflects on the relationship between love and beauty</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5c5304ced54" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[custom, part two]]></title>
            <link>https://billhulseman.medium.com/custom-part-two-c857c6016b54?source=rss-a9dfa35229fa------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c857c6016b54</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bride]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gender]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[weddings]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[wedding-dress]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Bill Hulseman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 14 Jul 2022 03:00:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-07-14T03:00:46.169Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ouKZFWOxBB8vqC7CB_I7Kw.jpeg" /><figcaption>My parents, newly wed and walking up the aisle, July 14, 1956.</figcaption></figure><p>A few months ago, my husband and I watched <em>Funny Face</em>. Oh, you haven’t seen it? If you can get past the 30 year age difference between Fred Astaire and Audrey Hepburn, though it’s too often forgotten, it’s one of the best flicks of the century. <em>Funny Face</em> is a for-the-time-unconventional romance between a fashion photographer (Astaire) and a bookish philosophy buff (Hepburn). He lures her out of the bookshop with the promise of fulfilling her desire to walk in the footsteps of Sartre and connect with her intellectual inspirations to Paris as the featured model of a new campaign. As their affection grows and sudden conflicts complicate their romance, we get a delightful satire of two idealized extremes of mid-century culture — the polished and high-powered fashion industry, and the grimy expressionism of Montmartre’s bohemian underground — and a series of delightful Gershwin numbers to show off the dance prowess of Astaire <em>and</em> Hepburn.</p><p>Our screening wasn’t part of my ongoing and surreptitious efforts to catch him up on classic films. I pulled up the film because “I just wanted to rewatch Hepburn’s<a href="https://youtu.be/7FznWwWrOIQ"> iconic dance” through a bohemian café</a> (yeah, that’s it), but, before we knew it, we were sucked in, thinking pink with Kay Thompson and delighting in every step Fred Astaire took. Every moment with Hepburn on screen was mesmerizing, in part because, well, because she’s Audrey Hepburn. But also, and in no small way, because of Hubert de Givenchy’s designs that transformed her Jo Stockton into a runway- and cover-ready model. As each gown appeared, I gasped and gushed about the longtime Givenchy-Hepburn collaboration and about his innovations in mid-century design even and especially beyond the iconic “little black dress” of <em>Breakfast at Tiffany’s</em>. Other people might be irritated by my habit, inherited from my mother, of unprompted, pop-up commentary and trivia, but he knew what he was getting into when he married me.</p><p>I surprised myself, though, when Hepburn appeared in the climactic wedding dress, a Givenchy masterpiece that perfected and elevated all the trends of 1950s — a softened, tea length ballerina skirt, a trim and simple body with cropped sleeves, a long, low neckline, and a veil that framed and illuminated (rather than hid and diminished) the face. It’s mid-century perfection. When she appeared, my heart and breath stopped until I could mutter, “Oh my god. That’s my mom’s dress.”</p><p>No, Givenchy didn’t make my mom’s wedding dress. My mom made it herself to walk down the aisle of St. Juliana’s Church on the northwest side of Chicago for her July 1956 wedding, a solid seven months before Givenchy’s dress floated across the big screen. Reflecting the dominant trends of the era, they shared a silhouette, but Mom’s dress had a sheer overlay with subtle lacework along the hemline, slightly longer sheer sleeves, and a veil that instead of framing her face, was (well, all I can say) perched above it. Both were clearly <em>modern</em>, adopting exposed arms and ankles and rejecting the long skirts, trains, elaborate lacework, frills, and concealing veils that dominated early 20th century bridal fashions.</p><p>My shock in that moment wasn’t just because of the similarity of the dresses. My shock stemmed from a sudden insight into how conventional my mother was, how much she reflected the progress and the limitations of her generation. In life as in her wedding dress, she made <em>some</em> bold choices, but she was never an outlier. Suddenly, too, I saw <em>Funny Face</em> as a kind of primary source, a time capsule that gives us a window into that moment’s shifting attitudes about gender and identity. Audrey Hepburn in a wedding dress isn’t just a piece of art come to life — she’s the embodiment of an ideal. The film introduces her character, Jo, as an independent and intelligent intellectual — an outlier among depictions of women in mid-century film — but, because the patriarchy always has to win, she still needs the love of a man and a proper wedding gown to reveal her best and most essential self. Her face, shoulders, arms, and ankles might be revealed, amplifying her confidence and beauty, but she’s still wrapped in layers of tulle and carrying a bouquet to enhance our delight in the delicacy and fragility of her femininity.</p><p>For many years, Mom’s dress lay hidden in our attic in a cedar trunk, my mother’s hope chest, and as a kid, I’d occasionally creep up to the attic and gently unpack its contents to be able to sneak a peek. I marveled at the idea that she’d made it, but I also imagined the dress to be a portal to a different place and time. Like a theatrical costume, I’d slip the dress on my tiny 8 or 10 year old body (it stopped fitting with a growth spurt when I was 11), and, by piecing together the glimpses of her wedding that I’d had from old photos and stories told, I’d try to see what my mom saw, to feel what she felt walking down the aisle on the arm of her father and back up it on the arm of my father.</p><p>In last week’s reflection, I started to dive into George Monger’s encyclopedic <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Marriage-Customs-World-Henna-Honeymoons/dp/1576079872"><em>Wedding Customs of the World</em></a>, which collates information about hundreds of practices that make up wedding traditions. To make some meaning out of practices in Monger’s tome, I’ve been keeping Stephanie Coontz’s fascinating<em> </em><a href="https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/291184/marriage-a-history-by-stephanie-coontz/"><em>Marriage, a History</em></a> close as a lens to consider how these practices reflected changes in the institution of and attitudes toward marriage. Curiously, while <em>marriage</em> has radically changed from a social institution to a personal one with the modern era, <em>weddings</em> and their associated traditions have not.</p><p>Some might suggest that ritual actions emerge only after cultural shifts are crystallized, but ritual theorists like Catherine Bell have demonstrated the power of ritual and ritual-like practices to <em>shape </em>culture. Ritual can <em>reflect</em> culture, but it also <em>effects</em> it. Through rituals, people can facilitate changes — sometimes radical transformations — in relationships and perceptions, but they can also, quite effectively, reinforce the status quo. With Givenchy and my mom in mind, and putting Monger, Coontz, and Bell in dialogue, my hunch is that communities use wedding ceremonies to both facilitate changes in relationships and to reinforce traditional (and here, I don’t say “traditional” in a pejorative sense — only to mean within the boundaries of a particular cultural or religious tradition) attitudes and beliefs. This extends into depictions of weddings in popular media — depictions of weddings on film and TV do as much as ceremonies themselves to challenge or to bolster those ideas. Think of <em>Funny Face</em>: released in 1957, it uplifts then-new “types” of women — independent, intellectual, employed — but Hepburn still ends up in a white wedding dress with a bouquet of flowers. Sure, the silhouette was innovative, but it still conformed to standards for respectability. My mother’s dress might’ve been modern, but she still marched down a pre-Vatican II Catholic church’s aisle.</p><p>Among all the components of the American wedding, the wedding dress is perhaps the most prominent and most anticipated element, but it’s also the most telling about the attitudes toward gender and class that are woven into it. So this week, again diving into Monger’s encyclopedia with a postmodern ritualist’s insights as one lens and Coontz’s history as another, let’s say yes to more context for the dress (#seewhatIdidthere) and consider:</p><ul><li>What does this tell us about its original cultural and social context?</li><li>What assumptions does this practice reflect or reveal about gender, class, religion, or any other aspect of identity?</li><li>How does this practice hold up today?</li></ul><p><em>The White Wedding Dress</em></p><blockquote>“The one family occasion that became more public in the nineteenth century was the wedding, although it was limited to invited guests. When Queen Victoria broke with convention and walked down the aisle to musical accompaniment, wearing pure white instead of the traditional silver and white gown and colored cape, she created an overnight ‘tradition.’ Thousands of middle-class women imitated her example, turning their weddings into the most glamorous event of their lives, an elaborate celebration of their entry to respectable domesticity.”<br>Stephanie Coontz, <em>Marriage, a History</em></blockquote><p>Before Queen Victoria’s wedding, the standard dress for marrying couples in Europe and North America was their best clothing, what Americans once colloquially called their “Sunday best.” As middle class women started to imitate the monarch, Victoria unwittingly launched an entire industry to outfit brides who would be queen for a day. Of course, we don’t remember Victoria just for her sartorial innovation; as a cultural moniker, “Victorian” evokes prudishness, and the era was characterized by a fierce social and legal crackdown on (among other things designated “deviant”) queer sexualities, the steady dismantlement of home economies and externalization of vital services and resources, and the accompanying erosion of women’s economic authority and social autonomy. The color of her dress didn’t just enhance her royal glow in the sanctuary; it evoked purity and virginity and amplified their importance among women’s virtues. The effect was, perhaps ironically for a queen associated with prim purity, an increased focus on a bride’s sexuality. With the introduction of the white wedding dress, the ceremony became less about the facilitation of social cohesion and more about the transformation of a woman’s body.</p><p>Other aspects of bridal fashion illuminate attitudes toward gender and sexuality, too. Consider the veil. It’s been a hot topic for people interested in the status of women in Islam, but most of the arguments coming from non-Muslims are wildly uninformed about the origins of the practice of veiling. For a thorough study of the role of the veil in the ancient Mediterranean and Middle East, “The Discourse of the Veil” in Leila Ahmed’s remarkable <a href="https://yalebooks.yale.edu/book/9780300257311/women-and-gender-in-islam/"><em>Women and Gender in Islam</em></a> is required reading. What most white Christian hijab-haters forget is that veiling has played and continues to play a crucial role in the development of European and North American attitudes toward women. Until the modern era, women were required to cover their heads in most Christian churches — Catholic women covered their heads until the reforms of the Second Vatican Council in the 1960s! For Muslims, the veil is a tool (sometimes chosen, sometimes imposed) for modesty, but, for European Christians, veiling was a literal application of the apostle Paul’s first letter to the Christian community at Corinth.</p><blockquote>“But I want you to know that Christ is the head of every man, and a husband the head of his wife, and God the head of Christ.<br>Any man who prays or prophesies with his head covered brings shame upon his head. But any woman who prays or prophesies with her head unveiled brings shame upon her head, for it is one and the same thing as if she had had her head shaved. For if a woman does not have her head veiled, she may as well have her hair cut off. But if it is shameful for a woman to have her hair cut off or her head shaved, then she should wear a veil.<br>A man, on the other hand, should not cover his head, because he is the image and glory of God, but woman is the glory of man. For man did not come from woman, but woman from man; nor was man created for woman, but woman for man; for this reason a woman should have a sign of authority on her head, because of the angels. Woman is not independent of man or man of woman in the Lord. For just as woman came from man, so man is born of woman; but all things are from God.<br>Judge for yourselves: is it proper for a woman to pray to God with her head unveiled? Does not nature itself teach you that if a man wears his hair long it is a disgrace to him, whereas if a woman has long hair it is her glory, because long hair has been given her for a covering?” <br><a href="https://bible.usccb.org/bible/1corinthians/11">I Corinthians 11:3–15</a></blockquote><p>Ever wonder why good manners and etiquette manuals dictate that a man remove his hat inside? Or why women at British weddings wear such fancy fascinators? Or why elaborate hats were standard for women in Black churches? Or why people freaked out when Jim Morrison grew his hair out or when Sinead O’Connor shaved hers off? It all comes back to Paul’s fakakta logic to justify structural misogyny. Over the course of Christian history, women covered their heads with whatever head coverings were on trend. Ancient veils gave way to medieval wimples (which became the standard headdress for nuns); wimples gave way to more elaborate Renaissance hats and bonnets, sometimes with long trains for dramatic effect or as a demonstration of affluence. Veils only became standard for wedding dresses when wedding dresses were distinguished from other garments in the 18th century. Veils emerged as a tool to shield women’s faces from modernity, to make sure their bodies and sexual autonomy remained in the Middle Ages, and to reinforce Paul’s instruction on gender hierarchy.</p><p>This is not to say that the white wedding dress <em>only </em>reflected gender and sexuality. It became a potent cultural and political symbol. The adoption of white wedding dresses around the world, such as the trend Walter Edwards explores in <a href="https://www.sup.org/books/title/?id=2597"><em>Modern Japan Through Its Weddings</em></a>, especially in cultures where brides traditionally donned red or other vibrant colors, is just one more data point for tracking the influence of European and North American cultures. Also, as Monger notes, white wedding dresses, associated with Western capitalism, were banned in Stalin’s Russia, but after his death brides wore white dresses as a form of dissident activity. Still, it’s hard to wrest the white wedding dress from the grip of Victorian morality and all the misogyny it perpetuated. When a bride dons the white dress and veil today, she, perhaps unwittingly, also wraps herself in that history and enters a new phase of her life with Paul weighing heavily on one shoulder and Victoria on the other.</p><p>Its perpetuation of harmful and outdated attitudes about gender and sexuality, though, isn’t the only, hmm…let’s say <em>interesting</em> aspect of the traditional white wedding dress. It also perpetuates harmful attitudes about class and socio-economic access. This is best demonstrated in a practice that has been sentimentally reenacted in countless films and TV shows. A bride-to-be, accompanied by a gaggle of besties, arrives for her appointment at a bridal boutique. She tries on a dozen gowns, looking for “the one” while her ladies sip champagne and giggle. When she finds it, she steps before the mirror and they all burst into tears. The practice has become an essential pre-wedding event for many wedding parties who have been convinced by the Wedding Industrial Complex that such an experience is exclusively reserved for blushing brides.</p><p>It’s hard to imagine now, in the world of 5’x5’ department store dressing rooms, but that’s how <em>all</em> dresses used to be made. A woman purchasing a dress would arrive at a dressmaker’s shop, accompanied by friends, family, or a chaperone, to select a pattern, fabrics, and notions and return for lengthy fittings and alterations. Though daily business for tailors and dressmakers, it was often an elegant affair, with comfortable couches for lounging and refreshments served during long sessions. Well, it’s not how <em>all </em>dresses were made. It’s how dresses were made for affluent women during a time in which one’s <em>relationship</em> with dressmakers, haberdashers, and ateliers (not just the labels one could flash) reflected and effected one’s standing in high society. By preserving this method in the creation and consumption of bespoke wedding dresses, the Wedding Industrial Complex has not only enhanced a woman’s access to being “queen for a day;” it has also perpetuated — I’d even say <em>glorified</em> — an elitist practice and the world in which it emerged.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c857c6016b54" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[custom, part one]]></title>
            <link>https://billhulseman.medium.com/custom-part-one-e17fdd80cfd9?source=rss-a9dfa35229fa------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e17fdd80cfd9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ritual]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[reflections]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marriage]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[custom]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[weddings]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Bill Hulseman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 08 Jul 2022 20:37:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-07-08T20:37:40.124Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*cRf2YwzSl15-f-VDu6psGg.jpeg" /></figure><p>As a Virgo, I appreciate a good checklist. When it comes to organizing and preparing an event, I love a color-coded spreadsheet even more, but there’s magic in any pithy roster that breaks a complex idea (like a multipronged, emotionally laden, and culturally significant event…for example, a wedding) down into actionable tasks. By collating all the little details that can clutter and collapse a mind, it brings the temperature down and keeps stressors at bay, permitting everyone involved a little more bandwidth for being present or maybe even enjoying and delighting in the event. As a ritualist whose personal and intellectual passions meet in designing, officiating, or just being invited to weddings, a checklist for planning a wedding is also an artifact, a primary source for understanding the context, subtext, and impact of an event. It’s so much more than a tool for efficiency — a checklist also reveals the assumptions and values that, whether obvious or implicit, shape it.</p><p><a href="https://www.magnetstreet.com/pdfs/Weddings/Wedding-Planning-Checklist_2129.pdf">One such planning checklist</a> includes 115 tasks spread out over the course of 12 months, but, similar to other resources available online and used by event planners for shaping American weddings, only 17 items (below) pertain directly to the thing at the center of it all: the wedding itself.</p><p><em>12 months before the ceremony…</em></p><ul><li>Discover your wedding style. Take our quiz.</li><li>Choose your wedding party: maid of honor, bridesmaids, best man, groomsmen, flower girl and ring bearer.</li><li>Start assembling a team of wedding pros: planner, photographer, videographer, caterer, florist, and musicians.</li><li>Browse wedding dress and veil styles.</li></ul><p><em>10–11 months…</em></p><ul><li>Choose bridal party attire and accessories.</li><li>Reserve ceremony and reception venues.</li></ul><p><em>6–7 months…</em></p><ul><li>Meet with officiant to discuss plans for the ceremony.</li><li>Hire ceremony musicians.</li><li>Purchase wedding bands.</li></ul><p><em>3 months…</em></p><ul><li>Plan ceremony and reception seating.</li><li>Finalize readers, readings, and music for the ceremony.</li></ul><p><em>2 months…</em></p><ul><li>Begin writing vows.</li><li>Review ceremony details with officiant.</li></ul><p><em>1 months…</em></p><ul><li>Pick up wedding rings.</li><li>Confirm final plans with wedding officiant.</li></ul><p><em>1 week…</em></p><ul><li>Give readers their scripts.</li></ul><p><em>Day before…</em></p><ul><li>Attend wedding rehearsal.</li></ul><p>As an officiant, it’s hard to not take offense that, among the team of wedding pros to assemble, “officiant” doesn’t make the A-list, but I digress. It’s obvious that the content of these lists conforms to the logic and economy of event planning — some items require longer planning and advanced orders, some tasks can be done quickly. Setting aside the consideration of lead-times, <em>how</em> items are otherwise prioritized tells us something about the values and assumptions underlying the event — values and assumptions that are rarely excavated and examined in the light of day (or, more specifically, in light of the identities, experiences, and values of the people actually getting married).</p><p>For example (besides the blatant derogation of officiants #pityparty), in a 12 month plan, “Begin writing vows” happens two months ahead of the ceremony. Here’s the thing: the vows, the public declaration of commitment, constitute the only component in a wedding ceremony that distinguishes it from other events. Vows are what make a wedding a wedding. Shouldn’t the vows be the starting point? Shouldn’t a couple start planning their event by considering <em>their</em> particular relationship, <em>their</em> particular commitment, <em>their</em> particular values? Shouldn’t the rest of the ceremony and festivities flow from this starting point? Shouldn’t officiants and event planners be more attentive to matching a couple’s life and the resources available?</p><p>I realize that in this, my typical rant against the Wedding Industrial Complex (WIC), I’m an ant screaming at a juggernaut, but I take people’s identities, experiences, and values seriously, not just as quirks to plug into a sterile template. I also believe that through rituals people can impact their broader culture. The choices that couples make for a wedding can perpetuate old practices (and the values that come with them), but they can also innovate with form, function, and symbolism. They can reinterpret and reconstruct traditional practices to align them with their experiences. That has an impact not only on the couple at the center of the event; it impacts the perceptions of everyone present — witnesses, family members, friends, caterers, photographers, even nosy passers-by peeking into an event space — about what a wedding could be.</p><p>The WIC doesn’t <em>have</em> to recycle familiar practices, but it does. While individual vendors and planners might profess and even earnestly strive to deliver unique experiences, they’re bound by the resources of an industry that is more concerned with profiting from dependable crowd-pleasers than it is about actively reflecting the lived experiences of people getting married. Thanks, capitalism. Of course, “the industry” isn’t a person and capitalism isn’t an autonomous being, so blaming them can only effect so much change. Instead, any change in the industry, in our collective perceptions of what constitutes a wedding, and in our shared cultural values depends on the choices individuals make.</p><p>Given more information about the origins and evolution of particular practices, I think (ok, I would hope) more people would feel dissuaded from perpetuating them, or at least they’d be more critically creative about aligning traditional practices, contemporary expectations, and personal experiences.</p><p>For example, as Stephanie Coontz summarizes in her fascinating<em> </em><a href="https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/291184/marriage-a-history-by-stephanie-coontz/"><em>Marriage, a History</em></a>, many of the components we associate with a typical American wedding find their origins in Queen Victoria’s ceremony at Chapel Royal in St. James’ Palace. ”The one family occasion that became more public in the nineteenth century,” Coontz writes, “was the wedding, although it was limited to invited guests. When Queen Victoria broke with convention and walked down the aisle to musical accompaniment, wearing pure white instead of the traditional silver and white gown and colored cape, she created an overnight ‘tradition.’ Thousands of middle-class women imitated her example, turning their weddings into the most glamorous event of their lives, an elaborate celebration of their entry to respectable domesticity.”</p><p>Victoria’s wedding has been the model for American weddings ever since, but as my mother said, “Don’t you people know we had a revolution?” Her march down a long aisle was, quite literally, a queen’s entrance. Despite the attempts of some families to achieve such status (the Kennedys, the Bushes, the Kardashians…), Americans don’t have a royal family. When middle-class women imitated her wedding, they became “queen for a day” on their path toward — what was Coontz’s phrase? — <em>“respectable domesticity,”</em> the feminine ideal reflected in Victoria’s wedding. Is this the goal of women today? #somuchforfeminism.</p><p>Unfortunately, there aren’t many places that couples can go to discern whether this or that practice or custom resonates with their lives, but George Monger’s <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Marriage-Customs-World-Henna-Honeymoons/dp/1576079872"><em>Wedding Customs of the World</em></a> collates practices encyclopedically and considers their historical origins, development, and contemporary uses. Monger’s project is noble, but, as much as it strives to be global and pluralistic, more details are poured into European and North American (US &amp; Canada) practices than into entries about in indigenous and non-European practices. Still, Monger is careful not to editorialize and mostly avoids imposing assumptions or offering misleading characterizations.</p><p>A few things from Monger’s encyclopedia really jumped out at me…for various reasons. In the next few weeks, I’ll reflect on some of the components that Monger highlights, not only with the lens of a postmodern ritualist but also in dialogue with Coontz’s <em>Marriage, a History</em>. If you read along with me, consider these questions:</p><ul><li>What does this tell us about its original cultural and social context?</li><li>What assumptions does this practice reflect or reveal about gender, class, religion, or any other aspect of identity?</li><li>How does this practice hold up today?</li></ul><p><em>Announcements</em></p><blockquote>“Speak now, or forever hold your peace.”</blockquote><p>You’ve heard the line, right? It’s a useful device for TV shows and movies to escalate tension, reminding viewers of the possibility that a former lover or someone with shocking information might pop up and spoil the whole day. Its origins, though, are much more complicated. In medieval Europe, the Church required “the reading of the banns,” or the announcement of an upcoming wedding as part of Sunday mass, for three weeks before the ceremony. This was to ensure that news about the wedding would spread through the parish, the town, and the region, and to give anyone with crucial information time to travel and stop the nuptials. What kind of information, you wonder? Well, what if the bride and groom are related, but don’t know it? What if one of them is an impostor, in hiding for some egregious crime in a neighboring region? Most importantly, in a region in which polygamy is brutally disdained, what if one of them is already married?</p><p>Until the Modern era, weddings (the formal ceremonies witnessed by an official representative of the state or the Church) weren’t a requirement for getting married. Many folx throughout Europe practiced what we today call “common law marriage,” which made it difficult to track recognized unions and prevent bigamy. It also made it difficult to keep people in those marriages <em>in </em>those marriages. A man might’ve abandoned a wife, family, and farm for greener, um, pastures, or a woman might’ve been already promised by her kin to another man. Announcements and the reading of banns formalized this extreme social paranoia, the original background check.</p><p>Today’s announcements, from Facebook posts to features in the New York Times wedding section, are rooted in this practice, but they’ve also been filtered through particular cultural lenses. We might be familiar with printed invitations with pre-addressed and -stamped response card (or, more recently, a link or QR code for RSVPs), but how a wedding is announced and how guests are invited differs widely and highlights other cultural practices. In Romania, the groom’s friends walk through town and deliver verbal invitations. In Czechia and Iran, the invitation is accompanied with cookies or sweets; in Denmark, the groom delivered the invitation and had a drink at each house. I don’t know about you, but that history makes my husband’s and my clever announcement on social media look pretty dull.</p><p><em>Community involvement<br></em>The history of weddings around the world demonstrates that the ceremonies, and marriages themselves, have not been a matter of two people making a choice. Ubiquitously, a wedding is a social, communal affair. The time and place of weddings typically aligned with local seasonal and agricultural cycles. Weddings were often timed when select foods and wines were available and when a whole-community celebration would be less disruptive.</p><p>Because weddings were fundamentally public events, community members — not just close family and friends — were directly involved in shaping the couple’s transition into marriage. In many cultures, the path to the wedding itself is blocked, and access has to be ransomed. In Poland, the couple offered vodka as a toll; in Thailand, the groom paid at various intervals to remove gold chains blocking his path. In New England, neighbors would lay fallen or felled trees to block the path to church. In Germany, children blocked the path and demanded payment for the couple to pass.</p><p>Even the marriage bed was a social experience. You might’ve seen wedding party members or other friends deck out the car (“Just Married!”) or decorate the honeymoon suite — flower petals strewn on the bed, champagne chilling in a bucket, maybe cute messages left for them to find. These practices, too, are rooted less in playful teasing and more in demonstrating the community’s role in (and power over) a relationship. Priests would bless the bed with the couple in it, praying for fecundity and happiness, and for aristocratic and royal marriages, high ranking folx would surround the bed to witness the marriage’s consummation. That’s right: they’d watch. In some corners, local rulers or lords might exact their first right to the bride to hammer home their authority, but reports of this seem to be, if rooted in reality, widely exaggerated.</p><p>It wasn’t very different for commoners. In England, the wedding party would surround the marriage bed and play “tossing the stocking.” Whomever the balled up bride’s stocking hit would be the next to marry. This practice finds its way into modern receptions and the customs of “tossing the bouquet” (quite literally, the bride throwing away her ‘flower’ — seriously, the symbolism isn’t subtle) or the removal by the groom of his bride’s garter belt (quite literally, undressing his new wife for all to see).</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e17fdd80cfd9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Just what we need: Another cis White man chimes in on Roe v. Wade]]></title>
            <link>https://billhulseman.medium.com/just-what-we-need-another-cis-white-man-chimes-in-on-roe-v-wade-7b1e7a27d687?source=rss-a9dfa35229fa------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7b1e7a27d687</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[reflections]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[roe-v-wade]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[abortion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lgbtq]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[scotus]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Bill Hulseman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 07 Jul 2022 19:24:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-07-07T19:24:23.375Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8REjIVdtkKt1HRuoXGYNgQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><a href="https://www.newyorker.com/cartoons/daily-cartoon/tuesday-june-28th-not-your-business">Brendan Loper, Daily Cartoon: Tuesday, June 28th, <em>The New Yorker</em></a></figcaption></figure><p>It’s been a rough couple of weeks. As if the last three years haven’t been enough, in one term (and largely in the last weeks), the Supreme Court of the United States (SCOTUS) issued, <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2022/07/01/us/supreme-court-term-roe-guns-epa-decisions.html">as the New York Times described it</a>, “far-reaching decisions that will transform American life.”</p><p>They overturned <em>Roe v. Wade</em> and stripped Americans with uteri of autonomy over their own bodies, despite 50 years of established judicial precedent and the beliefs, ethical discernment, and needs of a clear majority of US citizens.</p><p>They stripped the federal government of its authority to address climate change, even though the ruling had to revive a moot case to do so.</p><p>They dramatically expanded the role of religion in public life, brushing aside the First Amendment’s Establishment Clause and the clear evidence of a radical minority’s desire to implement an Evangelical theocracy and laying the foundation for religious apartheid.</p><p>And, in the wake of terrible mass shootings and on the eve of another, they interpreted the Second Amendment to guarantee individuals a right to carry guns, despite the actual original text and context of the Amendment or the history and currently-being-lived experience of the incidence of gun violence.</p><p>Across the board, the vulnerable and marginalized just got more vulnerable, further marginalized. The foundation for legal protections for the poor, for people of color, for queer people, for people with minority political beliefs, for people with physical, developmental, and cognitive disabilities, and for any who find themselves facing a “good guy with a gun” just got shaken, quaken. While all of these rulings regress to some extent, the overturn of <em>Roe</em> is an especially devastating shift, and it demonstrates that “established precedent” is, apparently for six sitting Justices who otherwise (or at least conveniently) deride moral relativism in service of originalist interpretation, a relative and flexible term.</p><p>It certainly is a relative term for five sitting Justices; otherwise, their responses insisting on deference to the Supreme Court’s tradition of <em>stare decisis</em> and the “established precedent” of <em>Roe v. Wade</em> that they articulated during their Senate nomination hearings <a href="https://sentinelcolorado.com/orecent-headlines/under-oath-what-gop-nominated-justices-said-about-roe-to-senate-panel/">were blatant lies</a>. Justices Coney Barrett, Kavanaugh, and Gorsuch echoed now-Chief Justice Roberts’ clear statement that “It’s settled as a precedent of the court.” Alito was more coy, citing a vague commitment to <em>stare decisis</em>, but none of us should be surprised by Thomas’ vote and supporting opinion. When questioned about the precedence of <em>Roe</em>, he cited his empathy and compassion for women “subjected to the agony of an environment” in which women in dire straits only had access to unsafe illegal abortions. “On a personal level,” he explained, “certainly, I am very, very pained by that. I think any of us would be,” but he wouldn’t answer the question of precedence because “I think it would undermine my ability to sit in an impartial way on an important case like that.” At that moment, somewhere in the Senate chamber, Mitch McConnell squirmed with glee, seeing the first brick laid on his road to NeoCon Utopia, or what others might call “fascism.”</p><p>It’s easy for me to process this news by jumping to the “big picture,” to the abstract. I’m eager to identify the cultural ramifications that we can anticipate from these rulings and to wonder how this moment in American history will nurture or poison the generation, but by doing so I’m avoiding the very personal, very direct impact of these rulings. When it comes to <em>Roe</em>, I am twice removed from relevance in the debate. My cisgender male body isn’t going to get pregnant, and I’m not getting anyone pregnant any time soon. Or ever. So, in short and what too many cis men forget, it’s not about me. That said, it does impact and involve me, and it requires my response because it directly impacts — because it has already impacted — people I love.</p><p>When I was 14, a friend confided in me that she’d gotten pregnant in 8th grade and that her boyfriend (a classmate) punched her in the stomach repeatedly to abort it. I fixated with horror on the image of my friend being savagely brutalized and degraded, but after sharing this secret with me her face revealed relief and her shoulders relaxed.</p><p>When I was 16, a friend shared with me that he would be taking his girlfriend to a clinic a few days later. Neither of them felt safe talking to their parents about it or asking other family members for help. They concocted plans that explained their absence for most of the day without prompting questions and that, they hoped, would give her enough time to recover. Explaining the situation, he was stoic and purposeful. Even at 16, he assumed the role of the dutiful partner who was ready to step up and be strong. He asked me if he was doing the right thing, but I couldn’t focus on anything but the pain in his eyes. “I don’t know,” I said as his lip started to quiver, “I’m not even sure that’s the right question to ask right now…but are you ok? Is she?”</p><p>When I was 23, while a handful of us sat around drinking a bottle of wine, a friend described her trip to Planned Parenthood the previous week. “<em>He</em> was great,” she said, looking at and referring to her gay best friend who sat on the couch next to her. “Held my hand the whole time.” I’d always admired their rapport — they’d be gushing about each other one minute and rolling their eyes the next. When one’s mood sank, the other’s lifted. But this time, when she paused and her eyes darkened, he didn’t immediately bubble with quips to bring her back up to the surface. He smiled a bit, maybe embarrassed by this revelation of tenderness. His eyes welled, but before any of us could attempt to affirm or console him, he recovered by brushing it off and cracking a joke. I don’t remember what he said — I only remember the darkness in her eyes, the tears in his, the heaviness in the room, and the awareness that, with ears, a bottle of wine, and a safe space away from the world, the rest of us could help them carry it that night.</p><p>When I was 35, a friend told me about the difficult decision she made to terminate a pregnancy, facing the intersection of a variety of complicating factors and pressure from her medical team. It’s a choice she never imagined she would need to make, but in sharing her experience with me, she wasn’t asking if it was the right thing to do. She was — she is — smart, thoughtful, discerning, and critically conscious of the practical, ethical, and personal impacts of her decision. I was most worried that some people close to her would struggle with it, but I was (delightfully) surprised to hear that she faced no emotional backlash, no direct judgment. Those folx, even the most pro-life among them, recognized that <em>she</em> was not the choice she made and that caring for her in this moment was more important than dropping a package of guilt, remorse, and <em>what ifs</em> in her hands.</p><p>For the record, I don’t open conversations with a prompt like, “So, has anyone terminated a pregnancy lately? Wanna talk about it?” Instead, something about me made these people feel safe. I think it’s my own particular personality, a mix of sometimes-too-much empathy and lots of practice in listening. I don’t discount that my sexual identity was part of why I was invited into these moments — at some level, I think these folx recognized that I had no stake in the game, that I could be more detached because I would probably never find myself with such a choice. It’s a reasonable assumption, too, that a gay man or anyone whose sexual or gender identities are marginalized and degraded by the mainstream (or by a vocal, disproportionately powerful, and radical minority) might understand what it’s like to be forced to make a choice that one shouldn’t have to make, what it’s like to be treated as second class and risk demotion to third or fourth or risk persecution and even prosecution should the truth surface, what it’s like to see your humanity on trial in courts, from pulpits, and on the nightly news.</p><p>Unfortunately, gay men don’t have a great track record for standing up for women. Casual misogyny is an unfortunate component of gay culture, and in moments of social crisis we gays are pretty good at finding our spotlight (and pushing women off stage). I’ve heard lots of buzz in the last few weeks that the overturn of <em>Roe</em> puts a target on other precedents that established rights and protections for marginalized groups. “They’re coming for us next” is the common message, and while that may be true, the jump to worrying about “our” rights once again pushes aside the concerns of women. That’s easy to do when a person doesn’t believe he has a stake in the matter, but here’s the thing: we <em>do</em> have a stake in the matter. We know what it’s like.</p><p>I don’t know what it’s like to be a woman, but I do know what it’s like when others, especially others with authority and power, claim ownership over my identity and tell me what to do and avoid with my body.</p><p>I know what it’s like when my identity is on the ballot.</p><p>I know what it’s like when others invoke psychological or religious arguments against my own self-knowledge and lived experience.</p><p>I know what it’s like when faced with a choice to let go of my dignity or to preserve and nurture it.</p><p>I know what it’s like to be hated just for making the choice to be happy.</p><p>I know what it’s like to be hated or degraded just for being born.</p><p>I know that these experiences lay a foundation for solidarity with women. And I know that when the dignity of women’s lives is degraded, we and the generations that follow suffer. So the opposite must be true, no? When the dignity of women’s lives is uplifted and protected (but not pedestaled), we’re all better off. The goal might be abstract — transforming into a culture that is characterized by peace, justice, equity, and inclusion, that protects instead of denigrates folx on the margins — but the starting point is very, very real: building strong and just relationships, building stronger and more inclusive communities, and cisgender heterosexual White men shutting the hell up.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7b1e7a27d687" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>