<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Michael Carter on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Michael Carter on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@bitsbetrippin?source=rss-fb27c00c9be6------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 22:32:56 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@bitsbetrippin/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[EIP-3368 | A more critical look at GPU Proof of Work Security]]></title>
            <link>https://bitsbetrippin.medium.com/eip-3368-a-more-critical-look-at-gpu-proof-of-work-security-27ea4b79634e?source=rss-fb27c00c9be6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/27ea4b79634e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[mining]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[eip3368]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ethereum]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cryptocurrency]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bitsbetrippin]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Michael Carter]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 16 Mar 2021 22:10:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-03-17T02:58:59.942Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong><em>An understanding</em></strong></p><p>This model write-up is going to consist of a range of potential scenarios that if played out could have a range of effects within a proof of work environment on and around Ethereum. Before I get into the content, I want to provide context of the way I personally approach the formulation of a security risk within a cryptocurrency blockchain that is based in Proof of Work. As a long time GPU miner I have experience with CPU, GPU, ASICs and FPGA mining and risk associated within the space. My perspective remains attentive with brining maximum participation to proof of work mining through multiple mediums and social media, guiding individuals to the tools and starting knowledge on how to <a href="https://www.youtube.com/c/bitsbetrippin">participate</a>.</p><p>When I was reviewing the EIP-1559 set of changes, the majority of the changes are great for Ethereum. Early on, I came out against the Feeburn as a the initial premise presented was ‘this is good for the hodl, it helps the SoV” narrative. I know now it’s more than just a monetary move and by design some of the gaming mechanics indirectly create an environment where the incentive would be to game the new mechanics to always max the blocksize and not change much in the basic behavior within the mechanics. I rescinded my negative opinion to EIP-1559 and started to move on. This was when I started to run some numbers to see how much potentially would bleed off ethereum if the cut was to much, what networks start to get the hashrate if something like a price drop was to occur at the same time this fee burn went in. I put forth a first model attempt at taking 10 various scenarios that could play out, with a majority of them (7 of 10) not affecting ethereum that much at all.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5tB_Yls6Ya55T3ZUStsFHQ.png" /><figcaption>Google Sheet Model published before the ECH Call /w dropdowns showing different Scenario impacts</figcaption></figure><p>I have said, on multiple occasions, these few scenarios are highly unlikely, but still, a larger issue lurks in the background related to total network size and growth; more on that further down below.</p><p>Much of the base calculations in all threat models are from the aspect of a few key variables for an individual mining algorithm, in this case (Ethash), with focus on singular token (ETH) as example. This normally centers around yield (Block Reward + Basefee + Inclusion Reward), respective difficulty on the network (<em>calculation based on total hashrate vs. block target time</em>), in Eth’s case 15 seconds and a spot price rate for the token. Ethereum established early on it wanted to maintain a MNI <a href="https://docs.ethhub.io/ethereum-basics/monetary-policy/">Minimal Necessary Issuance</a>, to ensure token inflation was at a moderate rate (<em>4.5% with 2.0 BR</em>) derived as a ‘security’ budget to maintain best in class Proof of Work incentive. Ethereum’s monetary policy aims to curb excessive emission of new currency while balancing an calculated approach at providing an incentive for security enforcement on the chain through hashpower. To date, Miner’s have not challenged this and while some to be expected grief on twitter, the world has continued to turn without incident.</p><p><strong><em>The excitement and growth</em></strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*mpwfdLipqZ1oqElJc2HdHg.png" /><figcaption>Etherscan.io Ethereum Network Hashrate View</figcaption></figure><p>As Ethereum’s price discovery has found new heights in late 2017, the depth of participation had grown through 2018 as a rolling wave of new miners came online, peaking just under 300TH by mid 2018. The seemingly common cycle of volatility suppressed the need for more miners throughout the remainder of 2018 on through early 2020. During this time Ethereum’s network and many other GPU enabled PoW algos reduced the need of mining through lower market price and additional yield cuts (Ethereum’s Constantinople updated taking issuance from 3 to 2). The bullrun of late 2020 however, coupled with significant increases in total yield due to the success of Defi and NFT space, Ethereum has created a significant opportunity for new participants in nearly all regards.</p><p><strong><em>Extensive Expansion in Mining</em></strong></p><p>Due to Ethereum’s current mining algorithm, Ethash, the newer generations of GPUs higher speed memory and bus width along better efficiency that enables smaller footprints with much higher hashrates. As the global supply chain works to catch up, a significant a range of new participants across the world have joined in the opportunity of expanded yields and price discovery. This modern day gold rush creates organic attention for Ethereum and benefits from the significant uptick in news, stories and social media exposure brought to the chain from these activities (<em>and apparently the negative too</em>). Ethereum success has not only brought nearly 2.5x increase in total nethash, but many other networks now have also increased exponentially their participation and nethash. Ethereum currently rest well ahead, leading the nethash within the shared GPU space by a significant margin.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/589/1*YOb9guG-R3fFB6NRp6rrQA.png" /></figure><p>As the bullrun continues, more are drawn in as participants. This typically is a great thing, more organic growth, more having a one to many connection with other individuals that may partake in mining, or may just take a position in the coin itself. The success of Ethereum’s growth expands its participation and we see that with a 430 Terahash nethash with no sign of slowing down. The expansion at its current rate will continue to grow as there is depth in the price and yield to allow more participants the opportunity. The barrier to entry is low, creating a low friction, easy way to start. Individuals can take their existing hardware or go out and pick up a GPU to become part of the ecosystem. (<em>Yes, easier said than done right now with lack of supply</em>)<br> <br> <strong><em>The sleeping dragon</em></strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/601/1*G-3lV2gTZMpK_6Tzq1-6Fw.png" /><figcaption>Current Total GPU Nethash including Nicehash (Ethash) market by TH Size</figcaption></figure><p>With the extensive growth (measured in total nethash), the excitement around the space generates the discovery on how to participate. That discovery often leads people to various aspects of cryptocurrency, including how to mine. Mining within the Ethereum ecosystem is a low barrier of entry to participate as folks with existing hardware can download open source tools, OS, many online resources including detailed walkthroughs on YouTube across multilingual channels. A few hours of research, (<em>for some people getting lost on the internet for an evening</em>), gets them to a point of starting a miner and earning Ethereum as their participation in adding security to the network results in a small payout. This directly increases the entire size of pie in the category of GPU mining (potential) as once an individual understands how to mine and participate with Ethereum, natural progression is learning about ethereum’s roadmap and how mining will transition to Proof of Stake.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/699/1*L_qbqSpHDKKOfLFcU5diHg.png" /><figcaption>3/16/2021 Current Overall GPU Hashrate Spread across networks (The Ethereum number includes NiceHash)</figcaption></figure><p>This naturally triggers an interest to look for alternatives as a way to understand the landscape. This is the distinct advantage for GPU mining as you are <em>LONG</em> the crypto PoW Proof of Work space, not just one particular token, it comes down to economic incentive to provide hashrate for the other network. This dynamic is both good and can be perceived as bad for any crypto project as the ‘security detail’ is by design naturally selfish for overall profitability. Now, I have always communicated on my channel that there is more to the ecosystem then just mining the ‘most profitable’ coin and one should balance it from a stack of priorities and potential strategies. This includes calculating the likelihood of a project succeeding in the long term, even if it is not the most profitable at the time or is not economically viable, some will operate for the future speculative results. This type of strategy works outside of mining and is the exact rational for someone wanting to become a Proof of Stake recipient too. If you believe in the project and want to support it, you can take a stake in the coin and become part of its validation layer. As part of any calculus, that reality must be accounted for, but not wholesale relied upon if the security risk hits a point of high risk chance of 51%.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/539/1*m7Z1hg4E20w53myMfhh1zA.png" /><figcaption>Collection of top 29 networks (not ranked) of total (GPU) Terahash (Yellow calculated based on typical 3080 performance.) Total network size 506TH, 430TH ETH, 76TH Others; NiceHash 32 TH is included with ETH #</figcaption></figure><p>The paragraph header “<strong><em>The sleeping dragon</em></strong>” refers to this dynamic that is not easily calculated or a model built against. That model includes a series of events and key variables resulting in a fundamental and quick shift in any one network, especially Ethereum. My previous attempt to communicate this at the ECH Ethereum Cat Herders discussion failed to articulate the risk as the scope remained in the existing Ethereum scope of current and range of future price and yields. One of the key scenarios I brought up depicted a <strong><em>LOW</em></strong> Eth Price (sub $700) + Deep cut of up to 50% of the fees (basefeeburn) (resulting in (<em>BR -Burn @ 2.1ETH</em>) could result in a sizable decrease of incentive that would instantly alienate eth miners as the economic viability would be not there to stay on eth’s network. Calculus assumes this may make other networks more viable and/or the hashrate ending up on a brokerage and sold to the highest bidder.</p><p>The reality of what I was trying to convey through a failed attempt was the total size of pie of GPU hashpower now greatly exceeds any previous time in history by a substantial amount, 2.5x at the current press time and that much potential is very susceptible to price and yield elasticity. While the earlier days of GPU mining, the hashrate flowed with the ebb and flow of the market, rescinding as expected when price and yields lowered. Much of that behavior would be expected again if we saw a slowing of the bullish sediment in the ecosystem and price slowly started to decline over several months. Yields are subjective as we live in a reality now that Defi and NFTs are not going anywhere and the activity would remain speculatively high, thus creating additional MEV. Where this concern fully rest is in the unlikely event that a rapid price pullback, coupled with a basefee burn in 1559 provides a one-two punch to participation causing a situation where a would-be nefarious opportunist looks to take advantage of the new exponentially large amount of hashpower providing an competition fee through a brokerage service. While this sounds like an extremely improbable set of circumstances, to discount it as not a potential attack vector is premature. This is exactly how ETC, using the same algorithm was impacted, multiple times. Ethash has no direct protection on a block reorg/double spend event.</p><p><strong><em>Out from left field</em></strong></p><p>These concerns are not just about ethereum’s hashrate, it’s the entire ecosystem of hashrate. The key figure to classify as a ‘class’ of force projection. The classes would be split up across ASIC (by algorithm), FPGA (by bitstream) and GPUs (all). CPUs I am leaving out of this as CPU mining is not an existential threat to specialized devices such as GPU, ASIC or FPGAs. It typically is the other way around, where something that is mined by a CPU (as bitcoin originally was in 2010, which promptly switched to GPUs throughout 2011 and quickly transitioned to FPGA and ASICS by 2012). The GPU scene currently covers PoW for more than 30+ Algorithms (70+ Coins) of which the top 8 have a growing % of the network outside of Ethereums dominance. As many have claimed, not my quote, Bitcoin’s growth raises all boats within the crypto sea. The primary factor here is total network potential and how elastic is the hashrate. The current incentives are supremely aligned right now in Ethereum’s favor meaning there is little to no risk at any double spend/reorg to Ethereum based on the economic incentives greatly out way the nefarious collusion to attack the network; incentives are working as intended. As other tokens grow in popularity and network value, they will continue to shed ethereums PoW participants. This isn’t a discussion on survival of the fittest or what coin is better than another, we can model it in a much more linear way of price * yield vs block time. Due to some coins monetary design, the overall yield amount is significantly higher, coupled with their price has risen (<em>in Ravencoin example, nearly 25x since December</em>) it naturally creates a division of security labor as it were. Make no mistake, I firmly believe Ethereum will remain the primary PoW token until it’s transition to Proof of Stake, however, to dismissed this competition on primary hashing class is another uncalculated risk. As some have said, Ethereum will probably only get in its own way than any other competitor knocking it off the top list. The reality is this potential should be accounted for as part of any calculus when threat modeling.</p><p><strong><em>Cool story and stats, but wtf is up with a EIP about raising the Block Reward?</em></strong></p><p>EIP-3368 was written a few days ago as a potential risk avoidance IF we have one of those bad scenarios play out. I have since corrected the rational to reflect this as an optional path, if negative scenarios started to play out for ethereum. This was created as much of this analysis has been provided to the Ethereum Dev R&amp;D Discord and other mediums, however there was a disconnect on how these type of changes can actually get ‘heard’. Presenting the risk doesnt mean ACD are going to act on the risk and jump in to try to solve everything anyone is concerned about. They rely on the community to put forth a technical proposal and solicit feedback. The further deep dive into the modeling, reviewing total size of pie in the GPU mining space (not fully discounting there could be a significant portion of ASIC miners on ETH either), the risk remains very low, even after EIP-1559 implementation. EIP-3368 is a way to ensure there is a tapered path of hashrate, while keeping the total emission aligned to the same current inflation curve over a two year transition period. This proposal does not make sense IF the low ethereum price and large fee burn scenario do not play out, thus this should not be included immediately after EIP-1559. Nowhere in the EIP does it state it has to, however I have mentioned that if the scenarios look like they are playing out, they may want to consider. There is a high chance this is all a moot point, but to not bring up the risk would be irresponsible at this point. Living through multiple ETC hacks as an example tends to change your perspective. The community feedback is pretty loud on this one, the risk does not look to be clear and present. If this proposal is a non-starter no matter what, accepting full risk of a 51% attack than ever increasing the block reward, then I would suggest as a backup plan<a href="https://medium.com/ethereum-classic-labs/an-elegant-mess-the-fast-solution-to-51-attacks-and-low-hash-rate-4e8f8347bdfe"> MESS</a> is looked at as a viable solution. This would prevent any inflation increase and would inherit the effort already done on other networks. All data associated to this analysis has been sourced and added to the following link. If you are timed out, give it time, someone will eventually leave and let you have access. I am working on transitioning this to a proper website.</p><p><a href="https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/138M4R1-_zS-OLBsl2VJeN_anfTSCRCFc6EguYUVG-yA/edit?usp=sharing">https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/138M4R1-_zS-OLBsl2VJeN_anfTSCRCFc6EguYUVG-yA/edit?usp=sharing</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=27ea4b79634e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[BBT Livestream Recap: PROGPOW in 2020]]></title>
            <link>https://bitsbetrippin.medium.com/bbt-livestream-recap-progpow-in-2020-e659df0db8e2?source=rss-fb27c00c9be6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e659df0db8e2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ethereum]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[progpow]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ethhash]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cryptocurrency]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mining]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Michael Carter]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 26 Feb 2020 21:38:19 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-02-26T21:38:19.837Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>BLUF — PROGPOW is a proposed algorithm change to Ethereum. It is considered contentious, as there is not a consensus of opinions (<em>when you view the online collective, blogs, medium post, twitter</em>) to change the current Ethash algorithm. Why am I discussing this right now, wasn’t this old news? Well…</p><p>· The second approval to move forward was established in Core Devs Meeting #81 on Feb 21st 2020. The implementation is tentatively scheduled for some time in July (roughly 3 weeks after EIP 1962).</p><p><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zSRzlC_dCx8">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zSRzlC_dCx8</a></p><p>o Specific time stamp added in description (Berlin release)</p><p>§ PROPOW Discussion starts — 1:33:00</p><p>§ Proposal to split the Berlin (EIP1962) &amp; PROPOW<br> Key takeaways</p><p>· 0.9.3 mining testnet has been live and tested</p><p>· Ultimately EIP1962 first, set in June, then 3 weeks later PROGPOW</p><p>o Proposal to include in overall Berlin release, but just a switch to enable/disable</p><p>§ I.E less overhead for exchanges and clients to upgrade (triggered later on)</p><p>o Discussion lead to an action by the dev team to reach loudest folks against PROGPOW, Gnosis founder Martin Koppelmann &amp; SpankChain CEO Ameen Soleimani to validate they would not push for a chain split.</p><p>o James Hancock — put his position/name on the line that he felt there would not be a chain split and most of the concern was just that a concern, not real threat to contentions (non-activating, nor chain splitting hard fork)</p><p>Now since the very first discussions started on PROGPOW, there has been a range of community involvement to establish some semblance of a decision, not only if, or if not PROGPOW, but if Ethereum should change ethhash or not. This had been done on Coinvotes (carbon votes) and Miner/Pool signaling. Now what’s the Pro / Con of this type of activity.</p><p>PRO — Democratic use of Ethereum and ETH as a voting mechanism (your keys, your signature)</p><p>- Ironically, requires you to actually vote (do something), click a link, cast a vote</p><p>- While sites were created to make this a simple copy/paste digital signature with a Yes/No Flag, the voting was based on ‘stake’ size, which again exhibits part of the issue with the power in voting comes with he who holds the large amount of eth</p><p>There have been a few attempts at leveraging blockchain based voting to be as democratic as possible.</p><p>- Coin vote of over 3.1 million eth participated in voting. 2.9 million voting YES for PROGPOW and 200k voting no.</p><p>- Miner Hashrate has consistently voted for PROGPOW — <a href="https://www.etherchain.org/charts/progpow">https://www.etherchain.org/charts/progpow</a></p><p>CON — No vote, no voice; no amount of eth, limited exposure</p><p>Why does it matter to GPU miners?</p><p>Let’s take a very simple, easy to understand rationale of why any individual in this world care about the Proof of Work mining algorithm. At its most fundamental level, the ability to participate. There is no argument or discussion around the availability of CPU and GPUs, they available everywhere on this planet.</p><p>The counter argument may go the way of, well, it ultimately comes down to profitability and does not counter situations of centralization of mining. That is only true when the equilibrium of profitability is near the world average cost of operations vs. current price of the coin. In times of speculative rises, the profit opportunity lets loose for more folks to participate, i.e more will naturally have the incentive to join the network. This includes folks that already have sunk cost will turn back on their investments to participate. Again, reinforcing the simple principle, the ability to participate.</p><p>There are active twitter polls and list, having people sign up to say they are against PROGPOW, which is totally cool and fine. They may have their specific reasons and I would venture to propose most of the concern is around the fact a few ‘known’ developers have voiced their particular concern, which makes them concerned. Nothing more, nothing less. That is not to diminish their concern, I believe if enough folks voicing concern that creates a transmission that will reinforce a position. Let me say that again slowly, transmission of a concern, can sometimes be construed to a particular position. The biggest risk in accepting an algorithm change, or (any hardfork) for that matter is a challenge to the chain, which ultimately splits the cryptocurrency into two chains, one ethhash, one progpow. Contentious HF’s do NOT equal Chain Splits, unless miners choose to mine both sides, as was done with Ethereum Classic after the DAO HF.</p><p>The signal to noise ratio that I see from the mining community is not to split the currency, not even in the slightest. The contention risk really is coming from the dApp development community voicing their concern that the effort is taking away from other development and that this particular algorithm may lead to a competitive advantage from one GPU company type to another.</p><p>I will address each concern separately.</p><p>1) The mining algorithm and chain security inherited by Proof of Work fundamentally with respect to dApps is not changing. This is the equivalent in the centralized cloud architecture hat of changing out a mechanism in the infrastructure (IaaS) that the (PaaS,SaaS) participants inherit. Equivalent to an SSL Certificate Type; like swapping DV SSL (domain certificates); not even a type change says moving from a (DV SSL to EV SSL)</p><p>a. One of the research aspects early on after the initial dev calls was to estimate the LOE which resulted in a low impact to the development/other EIPs</p><p>b. Multiple Testnets were launched and tested 0.9.2 &amp; 0.9.3 spec standards and tested how EIP would activate without issues.</p><p>2) The mining advantages around one GPU company vs another (AMD vs nVidia)</p><p>a. To test this assertion, I spent over 200 hours of livestreams on twitch to test nearly 68 different GPUs across AMD &amp; nVidia. Results uploaded to google spreadsheet, and quick recap videos provided on YouTube. The results showed an advantage to nVidia but this was NOT due to programmatic rational within the algorithm, but due to GPU architecture and as in games, scientific applications, or raw compute computational jobs, nVidia GPUs were at that time just outright better. This has nothing to do with PROGPOW, this happens to do with architecture at the GPU core level.</p><p>i. The ironic part about that position was that the current ethhash was for a long time overwhelmingly generous to AMD for years due to amd’s architecture, memory controller and timing related to the I/O bound nature ethhash has. The nvidia 10 series closed the gap and challenged the position on ethhash with the then first 1060 architecture then 1650s.</p><p>ii. AMD has sense made up significant ground on nVidia with its Navi architecture becoming one of the best costs, to power to ethash performance over nVidia cards. Computationally, for the money AMD is beating out nVidia in nearly every category besides the ultra-high end, with nVidia reigning supreme still with the RTX Titan and RTX 2080Ti respectfully. But in a supercar kind of way regarding price and performance.</p><p>b. Bottom line, this argument is no longer around the GPU companies, that argument did have some grounds with regards to possibly disenfranchising existing AMD farms, however many have been retooling to newer RTX, GTX 1650 Tis and 5600 / 5700 XT series. Other larger acquisitions come in the scope of low-cost transference of existing Mining Edition Cards such as the tried and true RX 470’s and 480’s from Sapphire.</p><p>3) Finally, this brings us to the previous discussion around general angst on changing algorithms. Most of the concern is based on general understanding on how actual mining incentives work and don’t go much past limited assumptions and untested game theory.</p><p>- Now that I have covered a general ‘miners view’ Let’s look at the basic situation.</p><p>1) Nobody likes game rule changes mid-course, this could include even changing the algorithm.</p><p>a. If bitcoin has taught us anything is that industry, will build to reinforce if the rules are clear and a level of confidence exist.</p><p>2) The current Ethhash ASICs by and large are actually going to fall off the network, Bitmain devices by mid-April and still unconfirmed reports the A10 will too (4GB of GDDR6) ; so is the existential risk really there for GPUs</p><p>a. What I would submit is as POW continues on Ethash, the epoch continues to increase and in the next few years, many GPUs will fall of the grid for mining due to memory limitations.</p><p>b. PROGPOW brings back a whole range of GPUs that couldn’t mine anymore, including 1060 3GB cards.</p><p>3) Lastly and in closing. Countless cryptocurrencies have changed their algorithms. This is not a high-risk event from a technical challenge. PROGPOW or any other algorithm Ethereum would consider would be done on the behalf to allow more to participate, nothing more, nothing less. It’s not more complicated than that. The dynamics of the way mining incentives then self-correct, this is not a problem for a developer to figure out past that.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e659df0db8e2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Explaining ‘Blockchain’]]></title>
            <link>https://bitsbetrippin.medium.com/explaining-blockchain-6e8f5ea7023c?source=rss-fb27c00c9be6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6e8f5ea7023c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[what-is-cryptocurrency]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[what-is-blockchain]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cryptocurrency]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[enterprise-blockchain]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[blockchain]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Michael Carter]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 04 Dec 2018 16:48:28 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-12-04T16:48:28.360Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xXPFzoOBDSfb-3G1-uflCA.jpeg" /></figure><p>After the past few 7 years threading both the Cryptocurrency scene (personally) and the ‘Enterprise’ Blockchain scene (professionally) I have had the privilege to learned an amazing amount of information, processes, development and architecture. In regards to cryptocurrency I have been actively participating since 2011, mostly in the capacity of POW Mining, but also in regards to purchasing cryptocurrency, trading, spending it on goods and services, such as dApps (Decentralized applications), yes… I own a few Cryptokitties. In 2013 I created BitsBeTrippin on YouTube and felt I would try to help lesson the barrier of entry on mining by showing individuals how to participate. Agnostic to the token, most of the content has been around Proof of Work mining (GPU based), like building a rig, configuring and what it takes to maintain. This approach helped me learn more on optimizations, tips and tricks through a dialog when livestreaming over past years. This information is free and available on YouTube and Twitch. I have chosen the path of no paywalls to ensure access is available to anyone with an internet connect. 5 years later now, 270+ videos, over 4000 hours of content covering everything from mining, to architecture, to value propositions of various decentralized cryptocurrency networks.</p><p>With regards professionally, I take the opportunities I can to educate fellow co-workers, customers and business partners on Enterprise Blockchain’s, while still ensuring the messaging around cryptocurrency networks and their value remains understood. Not just in what something like Hyperledger is or Enterprise Ethereum, but ‘<em>where</em>’ specific requirements I receive when answering technical proposals. Coming from a Solution Architecture, previous to that Technical Program Leader on large development contract(s), I work to help forge approaches on the use of Blockchain within the enterprise stack, that meets and exceeds customer requirements. As I have tried to tailor the message, this is an activity that has proven to be quite challenging.</p><p>I first start explaining the key difference between Cryptocurrencies and what is considered enterprise implementations of Blockchain Technology by itself, without a ‘token’. To understand Blockchain, it is critical to understand the, sometimes fanatical ‘<em>hype</em>’ around Cryptocurrency and at an elementary level what the breakthrough of solving a ‘double spend’ problem through a consensus algorithm reinforced through the proof of “work” &lt;insert your consensus&gt; / Byzantine Fault Tolerance / really brought to us in the way of ‘exchanging’.</p><p>The most fundamental explanation I can give to you is that Cryptocurrency enables us to transact in a ‘trustless’ way between two parties, without the need of a third party. I will say it again, but in another way, “I do not have to trust you to transact with you, anywhere on the planet, for any reason we choose to transact, we do not have to ask for permission and I can transfer you a ‘token’ that effectively has a ‘exchange’ rate for goods and services and this is all handled in a cryptographically secure way”. “It’s been running for 10 years and while the quality of service has had some discoveries and some limited changes it continues to function.” The facilitation of this service rewards the participants to keep it running and even their participation can come and go freely.</p><p>Now if you read through that slowly, understand the power in begin able to independently verify the transaction ledger yourself, get a response of validations from the network that the transaction was valid and ultimately have confidence in the finality of the transaction once posted to the ledger because of the consensus and incentivized activity to facilitate, it’s only natural to think, I see the power in fiduciary purposes, but can I do that with information too? When trying understand ‘Enterprise’ Blockchain, DLT, or just general “Blockchain Technology” is the progression of exploring the idea, “can we have the approach, benefits and processes around what makes Cryptocurrency tick in an information capacity”.</p><p>When trying to explain ‘Enterprise’ Blockchains to individuals you quite often will find yourself circling back to an answer, like a circular reference, effectively explaining a decentralized database. What catches most in this loop is because you effectively end up coming to a conclusion that the ‘initial’ write of any particular record is ultimately a ‘trusted’ transaction. It comes down to the very fundamental structure of what action you are trying to perform with the Blockchain. If it is to use the technology to facilitate ‘information’ then you will have to have some level of established trust with whatever process, service, entity, individual that is creating that first transaction. Once the transaction is posted to the ledger, then any update’s become future transactions in reference to the first transaction in a later block, reinforced by the participants, distribution and consensus of the Blockchain you have chosen. Effectively the enterprise gains the immutability, non-destructive (delete) and cryptographically proof on data after the initial write, of the record in question. From this perspective, the tone that Permission based Blockchains, ultimately falls into a Simi-trustless capacity, as those initial post of transactions come from the outside, thus always keeping a garbage in scenario.</p><p>The story for some unfortunately end there … as most go, “well I might as well go with a database and close the book”. This is where the next level of discussion starts to play a critical part. The story is not over! If you do not play that scenario out, even a bit further, you are doing a disservice to whomever you are providing the analysis to. The initial data transactions are important and yes, as in that scenario, they can take in right, wrong or malicious information, however, the fact they take that data in, record it on a decentralized, distributed participant (permissioned) ledger fundamentally changings everything on the future state of that data. The fact is we record right now information in centralized database architecture that is typically is owned/maintained by a centralized data owner, touched by the system of record administrators. While this data could be federated across multiple participants, the linkage to the original source data is typically held together by an ETL process that potentially change the original meta, logging information associated to that data including original update logs, change history for portions of the full record. Blockchains integrated within that concept of federation of systems of records can play a critical first step on a whole new approach to data quality. This would allow key insights on behavior analysis on information that right now would qualify as an immeasurable data ‘events/metrics’ that often go undetected, non-observed and typically discarded through log cleanup routines. That new level of insight could play a key role in active defense cybersecurity, employee mistakes that are never caught and unauthorized updates, access and changes to original records. To not explorer this as an initial alternative does not help address existing problems with centralized data sources including federated data warehouses.</p><p>Bottom line, the fact I can have a single enterprise database administrator with write access to the ‘highly secure’ database is my ultimate issue. At the leanest minimalist approach, an enterprise Blockchain can be decentralized across multiple sites, including multiple participants at a categorical level of the data scheme provides a quorum of integrity vs a single party that can make ‘changes’ to original records, one must create new reference transactions of the change, not just go into the centralized data store and update the original record. While databases can be setup to ‘track’ the changes, down to the most finite level, if they remain centralized, ultimately the rules and original history (system of record) remains under one roof, creating the very issue of “how valid is that data really?”.</p><p>The next steps in this process is tailoring the message to answer the root problem in business and in our existing infrastructure. Most all approaches to DLT, Blockchain and even cryptocurrencies end up in a detailed data description of how the protocol itself works, or why consensus is important. All valid arguments, but it is the equivalent of explaining to stakeholders the importance of routing tables and business rules within a router facilitating TCP/IP traffic across the internet. The messaging is around the protocol level and needs to move up to direct linkages to the problems we all need to solve around data consistency, ownership of the information being fully centralized and the configuration management around the databases and security can grossly be different between organizations causing countless exposure, risking changes to original records or outright data destruction in the event say a logging VM crashes and looses the history of ‘data’ change activity. The architecture most modern databases sit on just isn’t the raw source record, but the fact the scheme on change history is recorded in another ancillary system that may have IM&amp;R (information management and retention) controls on logging. The fact that the logging history will go away at some point while you keep the original record. These types of situations are throughout businesses commercially and throughout governments, creating a hole when the time calls for a forensic analysis of ‘what happened’ to an original record in data.</p><p>At a minimum set, creating a linkage to the change history of an enterprise system, on chain, sufficiently decentralized with IPFS storage would allow for a measurable, accountable, immutable account of the change history in this example, that would put the source across a quorum of participants. The data engineering, mining and insights that activity would give a level of confidence in the integrity, validity and finality of the original transaction pulls its change history that any counterparty of the information exchange could independently verify as a participant on the enterprise blockchain. Architecture around state channels of that information, group level access would insure their view to the information and the eventuality of that information moving to a public domain to include many more participants through zero knowledge proofs at a future data helps show an innovation path that continues to evolve to a path leveraging existing public, permission less infrastructure.</p><p>In closing, we have all just begun in understanding the power and implementation strategies around Cryptocurrency and Blockchain innovation. While initially, participants may have entered the space in the hype train, there are organizing groups of academics, enterprise participants and excited open source contributors that continue to build out the future state of this 10-year old experiment. I personally have a strong believe every industry in the world will start to inherit the fruits of those labors in the form of multiple public and private implementations of blockchain and cryptocurrency, both financially and in exchange of information.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6e8f5ea7023c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why Ethereum should adjust algo on next planned Hardfork? From a Miner’s perspective]]></title>
            <link>https://bitsbetrippin.medium.com/why-ethereum-should-adjust-algo-on-next-planned-hardfork-from-a-miners-perspective-aa0afeef05b9?source=rss-fb27c00c9be6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/aa0afeef05b9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[asics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bitsbetrippin]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ethereum]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bitcoin]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ethereum-asic]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Michael Carter]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 11 Apr 2018 03:00:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-04-11T03:11:09.783Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Who’s this dude?</strong></p><p>First a brief background. As a miner for nearly 8 years, I got my start in Bitcoin mining in 2010. With a pair of Gigabyte 5970’s and a bleeding edge pair of MSI 6950’s (2011ish), I was hooked nearly instantly. See in that time, bitcoin was not worth a lot and mining was at a net power/hardware cost loss (at the time). The entire concept of a decentralized, PoW incentivized network, of which anyone in the world the a little bit of technical ability building a PC and a few parts could contribute to a global network for a token was mind-blowing to me. The conceptually limitless potential regarding financial transactions, information immutability and things at the time I couldn’t began to understand would be fundamental in disrupting nearly everything. This was before a lot of very popular names in the space talked about any of the financial disruption, concepts of potential revolution of institutions, and well before scaling debates and other cryptos were a thing.</p><p>The simplest use case that I kept trying to get across to people was the finality of the transaction. To me, that was a HUGE and I could see in my regular business dealings that the fact I could trade a token to someone, the second there was a validation on the network, the decentralized consensus that allows for the cryptographic guarantee is fundamentally a game changer. The excitement created from witnessing that activity, along with the fact a lightly configured computer in my basement was one of many enabling the aforementioned protocol (bitcoin), bolstered my commitment on evangelization of the tech. By 2013, I decided to start a YouTube dedicated to helping people get into Mining as, at the time, not a lot of mining specific content, from a technical (YouTube) level was produced. From there, BitsBeTrippin was born. Now while the history is good and all, it’s not the main point of this post. My goal is to raise a core focus of community in the discussion of Ethereum and the ASIC issue.</p><p><strong>OK, but what’s the so what factor?</strong></p><p>The one thing that is lost in the entire discussion with miners is the fact Ethereum has a widely known significant, decentralized and worldwide participating mining community. The influence those miners have on projecting value into the ecosystem (other than a measurable hash power) is an immeasurable network effect of grassroots initiatives that are started by that mining community. Many facilitating education and general evangelization that occurs nearly every day with this robust community.</p><p>Make no mistake, Ethereum’s resurgence of PoW mining in 2015 for mining (GPU, CPU) helped expand thousands, potentially 10’s of thousands into the activity of mining, that had a <strong>one</strong> to <strong>many</strong> effect on educating general masses and pulling family, friends, co-workers and more into the space, if not for mining, as counterparties buying cryptocurrency. See if you are a miner; your friends, family, friends of family, friends of friends, essentially anyone in your immediate circle at some point find out you are mining due to you talking about it, potentially proudly, and indirectly weave much of the activity in your daily activity. From that initial interaction, you may just get someone into understanding what crypto is, forward them over to a YouTuber, Discord or a Forum to get them more familiar with the subject. This has created many instances that those individuals themselves get into mining or forgo to just purchase crypto instead.</p><p>Regarding skeptics on potential numbers (tens of thousands) cited above. The BitsBeTrippin email is filled (over 120k msg since 2016 alone) from individuals, companies, investors, ICOs, general mom and pop shops that discussed some level of mining activity along with the channel having nearly 40k subscribers, 3+ million views and hundreds of thousands of comments of individual miners helping each other with settings etc. There are at least 10+ other channels like ours, some larger now that have 50k to nearly 110k subs with same type of comments citing same questions, providing answers to mining configs. That activity breeds participation, community growth and a range of potential new developers, more content (dApps, wallets, trading tools) and more. A centralized mining provider, such as an ASIC provider will greatly tear down that community that provides so much ancillary benefit into the cryptocurrency space. It’s no simpler than, how many people do you know mine bitcoin? (Not many, for a range of reasons, not to include who wants to own a paperweight after the next gen ASIC comes out) GPU mining and subsequent CPU mining offers the barrier of entry to literally be ANYONE on the planet that can get a CPU / GPU and download some open source software. The proverbial barrier to entry is essentially a local box store or online order from amazon / newegg, about 150 (one card machine) to 3g (moderately nice rig) and a weekend. Pick from a list of YouTubers that show you how to get into the space and you’re off hashing away. ASIC’s centralization is much more of an issue than just a few companies limited/selling the hardware they produce. The missing out on known/known amounts of network effect needs to be weighed.</p><p><strong>But what about graphics cards and hardware for PC’s, lets help the gamers?</strong></p><p>This is a subject that ultimately in the long run needs to be tackled, but not by the Ethereum Developers. This is a market demand issue and should be handled by nVidia and AMD. If mining remains a long term activity, they will ultimately build a market segment around it, period. I attended, and documented my activity at CES2018 around this very subject. I even got to talk to the nVidia CEO and posted it in one of our videos. They are in the business to make products and generate revenue and live in a world of stockholders and boards. The risk profile on mining is centered around a highly volatile demand cycle on their products. When demand is up, they are wiped out, when demand is down, it’s like cash for clunkers and everyone’s trying to trade in the used goods, so significant market saturation happens. A more clear direction from cryptocurrency networks and a roadmap that shows a support level for a period of time may have a better read on this market for those providers, but ultimately price, profitability will always dictate total international supply issues. Bottom line, do not predicate your decision on those factors.</p><p><strong>Cool story, what’s the bottom line for the TL:DR bro’s</strong></p><p>Ok … straight to the point…</p><p><strong>Pros on adding algo change to next hardfork</strong></p><ul><li>Extensive grassroot community support, existing mining hardware ready and supporting and a resurgence of loyalty from an already vibrant and existing community</li><li>Transparency on effect of ASICs (pre-release) ; look no further than the extensive drop in hash rate on the XMR network — point proven; what’s the estimation on how much of the current hash power is actually silent ASICs</li><li>Long game is still Proof of Stake, as one of my fav. Game of Throne characters said, “It is known”, will start with a hybrid PoW/PoS system. This still encourages PoW participation.</li><li>Social Media, YouTube, Twitch creator community that embolden the message, not just mining. If you look at most of the creators showing people how to mine, many cross pollenate that community engagement with stories on “dApps, Use Cases, Functionality and late and breaking news around the technology” ; Yes, these exist for bitcoin, but not at a creativity level and regular on demand basis as the mining channels, most are “Trade Analysis ‘guru’s (cough)” (don’t worry trader bros, it was an easy jab atm)</li><li>Sticking to the original writing in White Paper of “ASIC resistance” … if the first opportunity you’re met with an ASIC and don’t even take the easy road on an already planned HF not to tweak, what was the narrative if not false? At a minimum set, regardless of roadmap, as long as it doesn’t risk main net functionally, should ‘lean in’ on the opportunity to tweak.</li><li>Send a clear message to ASIC producers that the proverbial easy prey, limited to no risk days are over if they choose to tape out a solution and hide from community. This behavior can be corrected with enough impacts on bottom line.</li><li>Show of unity with the strongly loyal community that helped evangelize Ethereum on top of committing time, money on supporting the network. Everyone understand the long game is moving to a Proof of Stake solution, that being said, a little effort here goes a long way.</li></ul><p><strong>Negatives on algo change/adjust</strong></p><ul><li>While more than likely not likely, if the ASIC is in fact a FPGA, could quickly be reprogrammed (highly unlikely due to cost, which would be transparent on initial sales of Batch 1 and 2 pricing)</li><li>More work for Ethereum testers, developers as they now have to prep a fix (even if fast, quick tweak, still work); deploy to testnet, solicit support to validate change doesn&#39;t cause an issue</li><li>All mining software would need to be updated, means folks like ethermine, claymore etc will have to be on point and have notional time to fix/test release; this would have to be coordinated</li><li>Unknown businesses and financial institutions that funded potential off radar ASIC development and other known companies that have put significant investment in development will be directly affected.</li></ul><p>In closing, hopefully this helps augment the already vibrant discussion on the subject. I have no doubt it will. Cheers</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=aa0afeef05b9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>