<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Jonah Sahn on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Jonah Sahn on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@blasianFMA?source=rss-fe11fba75301------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 03:49:46 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@blasianFMA/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[MIDNIGHT REVIEW: 8 Years Later, We’re Still Having the Same Conversation.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@blasianFMA/i-interviewed-todrick-hall-in-2018-35a84199b573?source=rss-fe11fba75301------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/35a84199b573</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[lgbtq]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[musical-theater]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[todrick-hall]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[interracial-relationships]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[off-broadway]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jonah Sahn]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 07 Oct 2026 06:53:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-16T15:14:01.926Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Eight years after our conversation about reverse racism, structural power and Forbidden, Hall’s new slavery musical returns to the same thought experiment on a much bigger stage.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*47wP_tHpo5NulRGDRhCwjQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>My interview with Hall in 2018.</figcaption></figure><p>I saw Todrick Hall’s <em>Midnight</em>, and I knew going in that I was probably going to have complicated feelings about it. I had already read enough about the premise to know that this was a musical about slavery, gay love and a racial role reversal in which Black and white characters effectively switch places. I had also seen how enthusiastically the show had been received by some of Todrick’s fans overseas, and my immediate thought was that bringing this particular story to the United States was going to be the real test. American audiences, and Black American audiences in particular, are going to bring a very different historical relationship to this material.</p><p>Now that I have seen it, I think my initial instinct was right, although not necessarily for the reasons I expected. There is a lot about <em>Midnight</em> that works. Todrick’s ability to put on a show has never really been in question for me. I remember watching him years ago on YouTube, and the video that first made me really pay attention was the Domino’s Pizza video. The camera kept moving, the frame kept filling with more people and the choreography kept expanding. I remember thinking that he clearly had an eye for scale and staging. I eventually stopped following him closely during what I jokingly call his “ghetto Disney” period, and I missed most of the reality television years, but I never thought the man lacked creative talent.</p><p>That matters to me now even more than it did then because I produce things myself. Nothing I am doing is on the scale of <em>Midnight</em>, but once you have coordinated performers, rehearsal schedules, venues, musicians, sound, lighting, budgets, ticketing and all the other nonsense that comes with getting something in front of an audience, you develop a different respect for the act of actually making something. The version of me from five years ago probably would have been more unforgiving. The version of me now can sit in a theater, disagree with a lot of what I am seeing and still appreciate the amount of work, risk and passion it took to get there.</p><p>That is where I want to begin, because there is plenty of Todrick Hall discourse on the internet that has nothing to do with this musical. I am not interested in turning this into a retrospective on every controversy attached to his name. I want to talk about the show he made, the ideas inside it and the fact that, without realizing it at first, I had already discussed some of these ideas with him eight years ago.</p><p>Even before <em>Midnight</em> began, I was very conscious of how the production was framing itself. Negro spirituals were playing before the show. During intermission, music from <em>Sinners</em> was playing. The show is surrounded by Black American cultural language before you even get into the plot, and then the score itself leans heavily into gospel, R&amp;B and contemporary Black vocal language. The audience around me, which was overwhelmingly white from where I was sitting, loved it. Every riff landed. Every big vocal moment got a reaction. At one point I wrote in my notes that the show felt made for white people who would have voted for Obama a third time if they could.</p><p>That is obviously a joke, but it gets at something real about the tone. <em>Midnight</em> does not feel like it is trying to convince openly racist people that slavery was wrong. It seems aimed at the kind of audience that already sees itself as progressive, empathetic and culturally open. They are ready to cheer Black excellence. They are ready to respond to gospel runs. They are ready to agree that racism and homophobia are bad. The question for me became whether the show was actually challenging that audience or giving them a very comfortable way to feel good about agreeing with it.</p><p>The theater experience itself did not always help. I was in the third row and still had sightline problems because of the way the rows were configured. The chairs were packed closely enough that watching people squeeze into the row made me write “fire hazard?” in my notes, although I am obviously not making a legal declaration about the building. More important was the fact that I could not always understand what was being sung.</p><p>That is a serious issue because <em>Midnight</em> is essentially sung through. There is very little spoken dialogue, so the songs are not just songs. They are carrying exposition, plot, character development and historical information almost constantly. I was paying attention. I was taking notes. I was sitting close to the stage. I still walked out feeling like I had missed things. Sometimes the lyrics were simply difficult to understand. Other times I understood the information but felt like the show had dropped something significant into one section of a song and moved on before I had time to process it.</p><p>The score also lives at a very high level of intensity for a very long time. The cast can sing, and I mean really sing, but there comes a point where another huge riff stops feeling like an event because the previous five people also gave you huge riffs. Emotional contrast matters. If everything is a climax, the climax has less room to climb. By the second act, there were moments when I found myself appreciating the technical ability while feeling strangely detached from what the song was supposed to be doing dramatically.</p><p>The central relationship involves Rail, an enslaved Black man played by Todrick, and a young white man from the slaveholding family. The white character is gay and under pressure to marry a woman. The show gives him a sympathetic history, including the death of his mother and his relationship with a Black nanny who essentially became a mother figure to him. That woman turns out to be Rail’s mother.</p><p>The show seems to use that relationship to explain some of his racial progressiveness. He grew up close to a Black woman, he loved her as family and therefore he has a level of empathy for Black people that other white members of his family do not. I understand what the show is doing, but there is something a little too familiar about the “I grew up around Black people, so I understand Black people” construction. Then there is the additional wrinkle that the woman he considered a mother figure is the mother of the man he loves. They are not biologically related, so I am not calling it incest, but it creates an odd family-adjacent dynamic that the story did not seem particularly interested in exploring.</p><p>What matters more is how much work the show does to make us feel for this white character. He is gay. He is closeted. He is being pressured into a heterosexual marriage. He has family expectations he cannot escape. He thinks of himself as being on the right side of history. None of this is inherently a problem. A white gay man in the nineteenth century could absolutely be oppressed by homophobia while still benefiting from racial privilege and slavery. People can occupy more than one social position at the same time.</p><p>The problem comes when the show starts moving toward mutual empathy between him and Rail as though their circumstances are variations of the same trap. One man is pressured to marry a woman. The other man is property. Both can suffer, but those are not equivalent relationships to power.</p><p>That becomes even more complicated once the show reaches the role reversal in Act II. Black and white characters effectively switch racial positions. The Black performers now occupy the white social roles, while the white performers occupy the Black enslaved roles. The show asks the audience to accept the reversal and keep moving, which I was willing to do. My issue was that I never fully understood what the characters themselves retained after the switch.</p><p>Sometimes they clearly know who they are. The show makes jokes and references that only work if the characters are conscious of the reversal. At other times, they seem to have absorbed the behavior and conditioning associated with their new social position. The white characters placed into enslaved roles suddenly behave much more like people who have lived their entire lives under slavery. The Black characters placed into white roles seem able to function within plantation society almost immediately.</p><p>That never made sense to me. If a white person from this family wakes up in the social position of an enslaved person but still remembers who they are, why would that person simply become subservient? They know the house. They know where things are kept. They know how the family works. They know which people have authority and how that authority is exercised. They know that yesterday they were free. Likewise, an enslaved person suddenly placed in the body and position of a white master would not automatically acquire the social habits, confidence and institutional knowledge that come from a lifetime of occupying that status.</p><p>The show can use magic. I am fine with magic. It just needs enough internal logic that I understand what the magic actually changed. Instead, the rules sometimes seem to bend toward whatever image or lesson the scene needs next.</p><p>And some of those images are exactly where my biggest problem with the show begins.</p><p>Near the end, Todrick’s character, now occupying the white master role while still physically being a Black man, is forced to whip his lover, who is physically a white man occupying the enslaved Black role. The sequence is technically excellent. Todrick raises the whip, the strike happens, the lights cut perfectly with the sound, a Black woman remains visible above the stage singing and then the scene resets for another strike. It is carefully timed and visually striking.</p><p>But I could not stop thinking about what I was literally looking at: a Black man whipping a white man.</p><p>The story tells me that the Black actor represents the white enslaver and the white actor represents the Black enslaved man, but theater works through bodies. The visual image matters. In fact, the entire reversal depends on us noticing the race of the bodies. If the bodies did not matter, there would be no reason to reverse them.</p><p>That same device allows the show to put a noose around a white body representing a Black person and to stage the physical pain of slavery through white performers. The brutality is still present in the story, but some of the most historically charged images have been displaced. I found myself wondering whether the role reversal was making those images easier for the audience to absorb.</p><p>I cannot say that was Todrick’s intention. I do not know that. I can only say that it was the effect the staging had on me. Watching a Black actor whip a white actor simply does not carry the same visual history as watching a white master whip a Black enslaved person, even when the script tells us that the identities inside those bodies have been reversed.</p><p>That question followed me into other parts of Act II. The white family learns that the son is gay after the racial reversal has happened, so Black performers are now physically delivering some of the harshest homophobic reactions in the show. There are threats, religious condemnation and panic about the family being exposed. Meanwhile, the people occupying the enslaved roles, now physically white actors, are more sympathetic and at points encourage the young man to escape.</p><p>The obvious defense is that the Black performers are still playing white characters and the white performers are still playing Black characters. I understand that. But the visual consequence is still that Black bodies are delivering the most vicious homophobic dialogue while white bodies are associated with sympathy and victimhood. Todrick chose when the reversal happened, and that means the physical distribution of those moments is part of the construction whether it was consciously intended as commentary or not.</p><p>This is also where the show’s treatment of Black excellence and power started bothering me. If everybody is supposed to learn something from the reversal, what exactly is the lesson for the Black audience? Obviously Black people can be prejudiced, discriminatory, cruel or abusive. Blackness does not make somebody morally pure. But Black Power is not simply White Power with the colors switched, and Black pride is not the mirror image of white supremacy.</p><p>Those concepts come out of different historical circumstances. Black Power emerged in response to a society that denied Black people political power, safety, dignity and control over their own communities. White supremacy developed to preserve racial domination. A Black individual abusing power can be wrong without proving that Black liberation and white domination are equivalent forces.</p><p>And that is where my history with Todrick becomes relevant, because this fascination with reversal did not begin with <em>Midnight</em>.</p><p>In 2018, I interviewed him about <em>Forbidden</em>, a feature-length visual album built around an inverted society. Black people hold racial power. White people experience racial oppression. Gay people are the social norm. Straight people are marginalized. America itself becomes Nacirema, which is America backward. Todrick filled the project with reversible imagery, palindromes and mirrored concepts because he liked the idea of flipping the world around and seeing what remained recognizable.</p><p>There is even an invented racial slur directed toward white people. In one scene, Sheryl Lee Ralph’s character uses it against a white waitress. The point is clear: take familiar anti-Black behavior, reverse the target and ask the audience how it looks when someone else is subjected to it.</p><p>Todrick explained the philosophy behind that to us directly. During the interview, he described a frightening encounter with police in which an officer pulled a gun on him and forced him to the ground. He talked about realizing that his accomplishments did not protect him in that moment. Broadway, television, fame, white friends and a verified account did not matter. The officer still saw a Black man.</p><p>He said that part of the way he processed experiences like that was through art. Rather than simply going online and arguing with people who thought Black people were “playing the victim,” he wanted to create something that might make them imagine what the world would feel like if everything were flipped and they were standing in our shoes.</p><p>That is basically the philosophy behind <em>Forbidden</em>, and after seeing <em>Midnight</em>, it is difficult not to see the connection. Todrick’s artistic instinct is to take an injustice, reverse the identities and let the person who normally occupies the dominant position imagine being subjected to it.</p><p>There is a real emotional logic to that. “Put yourself in somebody else’s shoes” is one of the oldest ways people explain empathy. The problem is that social power does not always survive a simple identity swap intact.</p><p>That was something we actually discussed during the 2018 interview. Near the end, Todrick brought up reverse racism and said he had recently been talking about it with Franchesca Ramsey. She had apparently been explaining why the concept was more complicated than he had understood it to be, particularly when racism is defined through structural power rather than individual prejudice.</p><p>I joined that conversation and tried to explain the distinction. A Black person can absolutely be prejudiced against a white person. A Black person can discriminate against a white person in a situation where they have authority. A Black person can be hateful. But when people talk about racism as a system, they are talking about more than one person insulting another. They are talking about institutions, law, housing, employment, policing, wealth and the ability of prejudice to shape somebody else’s life through power.</p><p>I also gave Todrick my copy of Ijeoma Oluo’s <em>So You Want to Talk About Race</em>. He said he wanted to understand the argument, that he wanted to be the most educated version of himself he could be and that he was willing to rethink his use of the phrase “reverse racism.”</p><p>I have no idea whether he ever read the book. Maybe he did. Maybe he read it and disagreed with parts of it. The interesting thing is that eight years later, the artistic framework we were discussing is still very much present. <em>Midnight</em> takes the reversal experiment and applies it to slavery, where the difference between personal prejudice and structural power becomes almost impossible to ignore.</p><p>That continuity is also visible in Todrick’s obsession with form. During the <em>Forbidden</em> interview, he talked about palindromes and reversible words like “noon” and phrases such as “step on no pets.” Nacirema itself is America reversed. He likes the idea of something being flipped while retaining a recognizable structure. That same instinct is all over <em>Midnight</em>, although now it is organized around twelve rather than just linguistic reversal.</p><p>There are twelve central characters. Midnight is twelve o’clock. The ending goes into a series of dates and historical events built around twelve years or multiples of twelve. One of the examples involves the Supreme Court ruling that invalidated sodomy laws and the later ruling establishing same-sex marriage nationwide, which really were decided exactly twelve years apart to the day. The number becomes almost numerological by the end.</p><p>There is also a Cinderella motif that becomes increasingly obvious. A lyric earlier in the show is repeated enough that it seems designed to make you hear “Cinderella,” and then Rail ultimately runs away, never to see his lover again, leaving a shoe behind. The story is moving toward midnight, the magical deadline arrives and somebody disappears while leaving footwear behind. That is not subtle, but I do not think it is meant to be.</p><p>Knowing Todrick’s older work actually made me appreciate this part more. He has been fascinated by mirrored structures for a long time, so <em>Midnight</em> starts to look less like a random collection of symbols and more like another version of an artistic language he has been developing for years.</p><p>The problem is that the history does not always cooperate with the symbolism.</p><p>The show gives us 1863 in connection with the construction of the house and says it took two years to build. Unless I misunderstood the lyric, that potentially puts us in 1865. There is also a character who has returned injured from “the war,” apparently the Civil War. If the intended setting is 1865 and the war has ended for that character, I need to know where this plantation is because the characters are still openly enslaved.</p><p>I initially thought about Watch Night during the show, although the famous Freedom’s Eve services were actually December 31, 1862, going into January 1, 1863, when Black Americans gathered awaiting the Emancipation Proclamation. The larger timeline issue remains. The Confederacy collapses in 1865. Juneteenth marks emancipation being enforced in Galveston that June. The Thirteenth Amendment is ratified in December.</p><p>There are absolutely historical circumstances in which people remained enslaved well into 1865. Emancipation did not instantly become reality everywhere just because Lincoln signed a document. That is exactly why location matters. I actually started wondering whether the story might be set in Texas, especially because Todrick is from Texas, but I could not find a specific location in the program. If the chronology has a historical explanation, the show needs to establish it clearly enough that an audience member is not sitting there wondering whether slavery has simply been turned into a generic nineteenth-century backdrop.</p><p>The ending also makes a historical claim about letters that I want more information about. The show talks about boxes or collections of letters revealing gay male relationships during the slavery era. I am completely open to that history. Queer people obviously existed long before modern gay identity, and historians have recovered many relationships and forms of intimacy that older scholarship either ignored or deliberately erased.</p><p>But “boxes of letters found all over the South” is specific. I want to know which letters. Who wrote them? Where are they archived? Were these men enslaved, free Black, white or interracial couples? How are historians interpreting the language? Nineteenth-century men sometimes wrote to male friends in extremely affectionate terms that modern readers can easily interpret through a sexual lens, so context matters.</p><p>That claim also made me think about what else queer history under slavery contains. It is not only a story of forbidden consensual love. Slavery created enormous sexual power imbalances. Enslaved women were routinely vulnerable to sexual violence, and enslaved men could also be sexually abused and coerced. There is a popular narrative around the term “buck breaking” that needs more historical caution than it often gets online, because the claim that there was a standardized, widespread plantation ritual formally known by that name is disputed. The broader reality of sexual violence against enslaved men, however, does not depend on that particular claim being true.</p><p>That matters because a story about gay love under slavery cannot completely separate sexuality from ownership. A white man connected to the family that owns a Black man may genuinely love him, but the relationship exists inside a system where one person does not have the same freedom to leave. Love can exist inside an unequal structure without making the structure disappear.</p><p>The show pushes this even further when Rail becomes willing to sacrifice himself so that his white lover can live his life. That is where the emotional burden started feeling familiar in a way I did not love. The Black character’s suffering becomes part of the white character’s awakening and survival. American storytelling has used Black suffering as a vehicle for white moral development for a very long time, and <em>Midnight</em> comes dangerously close to that pattern even while centering a Black protagonist.</p><p>That brings me back to the audience and the phrase Todrick has used in interviews about not wanting to hit people over the head with a “woke stick.” He has also talked about not wanting the show to feel like it was written by an angry Black man because he wants people to feel invited into the conversation. I understand the instinct. Nobody wants to spend years creating a musical only to make the people you hope to reach defensive before they have even heard what you are saying.</p><p>But once you choose slavery as your setting, comfort becomes part of the critique. How much of the history is being softened in order to keep the audience receptive? Does transferring the physical imagery of Black suffering onto white bodies make the violence easier to watch? Does the focus on the white lover’s pain make the audience feel that everybody was simply trapped by the same terrible society? Does the role reversal turn a specific structure of racial ownership into a general lesson about how anybody can become cruel if given power?</p><p>This is where the origin story Todrick has given for <em>Midnight</em> becomes especially revealing. He has talked about developing the idea during the pandemic while navigating an interracial relationship and families with sharply different political perspectives. That makes a lot of sense when you look at the finished show. He began with a contemporary problem in which people from different backgrounds needed to understand one another, then traced the racial division backward historically.</p><p>The difficulty is that a framework built for contemporary family conflict does not map neatly onto slavery. Two families divided by politics may genuinely need mutual understanding. Two partners in an interracial relationship may need to listen to experiences they do not share. An enslaved person and an enslaver do not stand in the same kind of relationship. The enslaved person does not need to achieve sufficient empathy for the emotional pressures facing the person who participates in owning them before their claim to freedom becomes legitimate.</p><p>That is the wall I keep hitting with <em>Midnight</em>. Todrick’s empathy project makes sense until the show starts treating asymmetrical power as though it can be understood through symmetrical suffering.</p><p>And I think that is why my 2018 interview keeps coming back to me. At the time, I thought I was talking to Todrick about <em>Forbidden</em>, race and some criticism of his older YouTube work. I had no idea that years later I would be sitting in the third row of a theater watching him take the same reversal mechanism and apply it to slavery.</p><p>I do not regret seeing <em>Midnight</em>. I am glad I saw it. There are performances I enjoyed, theatrical choices I admired and ideas I am still thinking about. Todrick made something ambitious enough to argue with, which is more interesting than making something forgettable.</p><p>But I left the theater feeling that the very device he uses to create empathy also limits how deeply the show can deal with the history it invokes. Swapping the bodies makes for striking theater. It does not automatically swap the meaning of power.</p><p>That was the question underneath <em>Forbidden</em> when I interviewed him in 2018, and it is still the question underneath <em>Midnight</em> now.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=35a84199b573" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Who is “Allowed” to sing Negro Spirituals?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@blasianFMA/who-is-allowed-to-sing-negro-spirituals-eedde8c07bfd?source=rss-fe11fba75301------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/eedde8c07bfd</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[choir]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[blacklivesmatter]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[choral-music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[negro-spiritual]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[choral-conducting]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jonah Sahn]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 16 Aug 2026 04:56:43 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-08-16T04:56:43.146Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I’ve been thinking a lot lately about Negro spirituals in the international choral world, particularly because I’ve been watching Japanese choirs perform them and thinking about repertoire I might one day take to Japan. That train of thought caused me to search my Gmail for a phrase I hadn’t thought about in years: “Negro Spirituals in White Churches.” And there it was. A record I had apparently emailed to myself years ago because some part of me already knew, “You need to save this somewhere because one day you’re going to wonder if this shit really happened.”</p><p>May 2011. I was 26 years old and nearing the end of my first choir director job at Asbury United Methodist Church on Mendenhall in Memphis. I had actually been hired around September 2008, so I was even younger when I started, and from the beginning there was a fundamental disagreement between me and the pastor about what he thought I was there to do. I think he hired this young Black choir director imagining that I was going to come in and Sister Act-ify the place. He wanted more contemporary Christian music, more material from The Faith We Sing and more of what he imagined would modernize the church. There was just one problem: the choir didn’t particularly want that. They liked anthems. They liked hymns. They liked doing cantatas around the holidays. Once I actually started working with them, I sided with the choir on a lot of those decisions. That did not make the pastor particularly happy.</p><p>These were the people I had to rehearse every week, though, and I was learning very quickly that there is a difference between a theoretical vision for what a church “should” become and the actual human beings sitting in the choir room. This particular church also had a very theoretical relationship with diversity. They prided themselves on being diverse, but in reality the congregation was maybe 120 people and overwhelmingly older and white. There was one Black family, a white man married to an Indian woman and in leadership there were basically two Black people: me and an older Black woman who served as the youth pastor. Meanwhile, the surrounding neighborhood had changed dramatically from the church’s glory years. Memphis white flight had done what Memphis white flight did, and by the late 2000s the surrounding community was much more Black and Hispanic than the church itself.</p><p>There were people at Asbury who desperately remembered the era when the church had been booming. I know this because three older women at the church once decided that I needed to “understand the traditions of the church better” and had my PART-TIME EMPLOYEE ASS coming in on Tuesdays for something like three hours at a time so they could take me through old church materials and photographs from the 1970s and 1980s. And because I was in my 20s and had not yet developed anything resembling the professional boundaries I have today, I DID IT. Eventually one of the younger, hipper choir members, and by younger I mean probably around 50, found out. He was basically like, “You’re a part-time employee. They’re not paying you for this. I’m talking to somebody.” Suddenly my weekly unpaid Asbury United Methodist Church History Seminar came to an end. Forty-two-year-old me would have smiled at those ladies and said, “Well, this has been fascinating. See you at choir rehearsal.” But I wasn’t 42. I was 26.</p><p>Which brings us to the Negro spiritual. I programmed Moses Hogan’s arrangement of “I Got a Home in-a Dat Rock.” It was appropriate for where we were liturgically. It is good repertoire. And my little choir could actually sing it. There were about 16 of them, mostly elderly white folks, and one thing I will absolutely give that generation of church singer is that those people could SIGHT READ. You could tell that many of them grew up during an era when music education was simply expected to be part of a well-rounded education. Put notes in front of them and they could read the notes. They were sweet, well-meaning people. Politically, think the sort of white liberals people joke would have “voted for Obama a third time.” Funny enough, I was working at the church when Obama was actually elected in 2008 and I don’t remember us discussing it at all.</p><p>So we’re preparing Moses Hogan and the pastor emails me. His stated concern is that he is uncomfortable hearing white choirs perform old Negro spirituals because they often don’t sound “authentic.” He brings up white singers performing Porgy and Bess and compares the issue to blackface. Now, there is actually a serious conversation buried somewhere inside that. How should choirs outside a particular cultural tradition approach that tradition’s music? How should a predominantly white choir approach Black dialect? At what point does stylistic interpretation become caricature? What historical knowledge should singers have before performing spirituals? Those are legitimate questions. I still think about those questions today.</p><p>But then this man took a HARD LEFT. He informed me that in his time living in Memphis, he hadn’t exactly heard Black people longing for “dem good ol’ days” on the plantation, where happy enslaved people sang songs of Zion while working for “de massa.” And then he asked me how a hypothetical young Black family from the surrounding neighborhood might receive the choir singing this music.</p><p>Sir.</p><p>I AM THE BLACK PERSON IN THIS CONVERSATION.</p><p>Not only that, I had formally studied Black American music as an undergraduate. The reason I had enough conducting experience to take a choir director position at such a young age in the first place was that I had spent four years as a student conductor at Rust College. An HBCU. So I had historical knowledge AND practical experience. Here I am receiving an email from this white pastor explaining to me how some imaginary Black family might interpret a Negro spiritual while simultaneously demonstrating that he fundamentally misunderstood what Negro spirituals represented.</p><p>Nobody was nostalgically singing about how wonderful slavery was. The spiritual is the artistic, theological and cultural product of people surviving an atrocity. The suffering is not an unfortunate historical footnote to the music. The suffering is part of what gives the music its meaning. And yet somehow the imagined Black family who might one day wander through the church doors had become more authoritative than the actual Black musician the church had already hired to run its choir.</p><p>I was LIVID. But something else jumped out at me while rereading this fifteen years later: I was so young. My original post to a choral forum literally says that I was upset but was giving myself 24 hours before responding because I wanted to approach the situation without reacting emotionally. People responded from all over. Most of them understood immediately why the email bothered me, and there were thoughtful conversations about cultural ownership, dialect, Black musical history and whether a choir has to share the ethnicity of the people who created a piece of music in order to perform it.</p><p>And then there was Ed.</p><p>Ed decided my real problem was apparently that I had an ATTITUDE. He told me that I should remember that the music director answers to the pastor. He criticized me for writing “this reverend” instead of “my pastor.” He warned me not to argue with the pastor about his music history. And then he signed off his advice with: “Be Sweet.”</p><p>I paid Ed dust then and I pay Ed dust now. Even 26-year-old me could identify crazy when crazy walked through the door.</p><p>But 26-year-old me did not have 42-year-old me’s boundaries. Ultimately, I pulled the Hogan. We did not sing it. The choir asked me why and I told them. From what I remember, they were NOT happy with the pastor, and I am pretty sure he received a stern talking-to from some of them. It may even have been part of the end of his time there because by Christmas 2011, if my memory is right, we had another pastor. Then, in May 2012, I left Memphis entirely.</p><p>This is where I have a little more compassion for that 26-year-old version of myself than I expected to have. Knowing everything I know now, if I could walk into that church office in 2011 and give him advice, I don’t think I would tell him, “QUIT! DON’T LET THESE PEOPLE DISRESPECT YOU!” I’d tell him: You’re not crazy. You’re not wrong about what you’re seeing. You need much better boundaries. But also remember what this job is doing for you.</p><p>Because in June 2011, shortly after all of this, I visited New York City and decided that within one year I was moving there. That part-time church paycheck became part of the money that allowed me to do it. Eleven months later, I moved to NYC. Sometimes the younger version of you tolerates something the older version of you would never tolerate again. That doesn’t necessarily mean younger you was a coward. Sometimes younger you knew, consciously or unconsciously: I’m getting what I need from this place and then I am GOING. And I went.</p><p>Which brings me all the way back to why I found this fifteen-year-old conversation in the first place. I was thinking about Japanese choirs singing Negro spirituals, and I realized that after all these years my answer to the question of who “gets” to perform whose music has become incredibly simple: everybody.</p><p>I would absolutely love to fly fourteen hours to Japan, sit down in a concert hall and hear a Japanese choir absolutely destroy a Negro spiritual. I would be PROUD. Because think about what that means. People on the other side of the planet, people who did not grow up inside American racial politics and did not inherit our particular historical relationship to this music, encountered something created by Black Americans and thought: This is worth studying. This is worth rehearsing. This is worth getting right. This is worth singing. That is cultural reach.</p><p>We talk constantly about Black influence when we discuss global pop music. We can hear the blueprint in K-pop. We can hear Black American music moving through popular culture all over the planet. But spirituals are part of that inheritance too. Our CHORAL music traveled. Our sacred music traveled. Our ancestors made something under conditions designed to destroy them, and generations later somebody in Tokyo can open a score by Moses Hogan and decide that this music matters enough to spend months learning. How could I possibly look at that and think our culture has somehow been diminished?</p><p>Now let me be clear about something else. There IS something Black people bring to Black music. I hear it. I feel it. I’ve sung Black repertoire in predominantly non-Black professional choral environments, including Dessoff, and it has been beautiful. But there are certain instincts, sounds, relationships to rhythm, language and expression that Black singers may bring because the tradition exists inside a larger cultural inheritance. I don’t expect a Japanese choir to reproduce that. I don’t expect a white American choir to reproduce that. More importantly, I don’t WANT them trying to manufacture it.</p><p>Please do not perform an impression of Black people for me.</p><p>Be Japanese. Be white. Be Korean. Be whoever the hell you are. Study the music. Know where it came from. Understand what those words meant to the people who first sang them. Learn the style. Take the craft seriously. Respect the people whose tradition you are entering. And then? SING. Sing the absolute shit out of it.</p><p>Culture is not protected by building a fence around it and allowing only people with the correct ancestry to touch it. Culture survives because people care enough to carry it. And fifteen years after somebody asked the young Black choir director at a little white Methodist church in Memphis whether white people should be singing Negro spirituals, I think I finally have my definitive answer:</p><p>Absolutely.</p><p>Just do our shit right.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=eedde8c07bfd" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Very Sudden, Very Loud Wasian Wave]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@blasianFMA/the-very-sudden-very-loud-wasian-wave-8be181b612bf?source=rss-fe11fba75301------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8be181b612bf</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[wasian]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[biracial]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mixed-race]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hapa]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[blasian]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jonah Sahn]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 12 May 2026 14:58:06 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-05-12T14:58:06.041Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>What’s happening right now with these Wasian gatherings is fascinating to me, not because mixed people gathering is new, but because this is maybe the first time I’ve seen white-Asian mixed identity publicly and unapologetically branded at mass scale in real life.</p><p>Not online. Not buried in niche Reddit threads. Not hidden inside Tumblr discourse from ten years ago. Real life. Central Park. Thousands of people. Viral videos. Coordinated meetups across multiple cities. People openly calling themselves Wasians and building events around that identity specifically.</p><p>And judging by the reactions online, a lot of people are feeling something about it, including white-Asian mixed people themselves.</p><p>Some people think it’s wholesome. Some people think it’s cringe. Some people think it’s empowering. Some people think it feels vaguely exclusionary. Some people are asking whether it’s “celebrating whiteness.” Some people are confused why this particular mixed identity suddenly became so visible so quickly.</p><p>Meanwhile, a lot of us who have existed in mixed-race online spaces for years are sitting here watching everybody else catch up to conversations we’ve already been having forever.</p><p>Because this discourse is not new.</p><p>What’s new is that it escaped containment.</p><p>For years, there have been online communities centered around mixed Asian identity: Hapa Facebook groups, Reddit communities, mixed-race Discord servers, subtle traits groups, TikTok creators, all of it. And within those spaces, one recurring tension kept surfacing over and over again:</p><p><strong>white-Asian mixed people often spoke as though their experience represented the definitive mixed Asian experience.</strong></p><p>Not always intentionally. But consistently.</p><p>You would see someone talking about “the mixed Asian struggle,” but what they really meant was the experience of navigating whiteness while also being Asian. Feeling not white enough for white spaces and not Asian enough for Asian spaces. Questions about proximity to whiteness. Ambiguous presentation. Being fetishized. Having one immigrant parent and one white parent. Certain family dynamics.</p><p>Again, none of this is fake. None of this is invalid. These are real experiences.</p><p>But they are not universal.</p><p>And if you were Black and Asian, Latino and Asian, Indigenous and Asian, South Asian mixed, Pacific Islander mixed, or literally any other combination, you learned very quickly that “mixed Asian discourse” often defaulted toward one particular demographic and one particular racial framework.</p><p>So when I first saw these gatherings explicitly labeled as Wasian gatherings, honestly? Part of me respected it.</p><p>Good. Name it directly. Claim your own experience directly.</p><p>I would actually much rather people say “this is a white-Asian mixed space” than vaguely gesture toward “mixed Asian identity” while unconsciously centering whiteness anyway.</p><p>At least that’s honest.</p><p>At least everybody understands what conversation is actually being had.</p><p>But then almost immediately, the messaging started wobbling.</p><p>Because once criticism and questions started rolling in, suddenly some people associated with these gatherings started saying things like “well everybody was welcome” or “it was for all mixed Asians too.”</p><p>And that’s where a lot of us started getting that familiar feeling again.</p><p>Because you really do need to pick a lane here.</p><p>If this was specifically a Wasian-centered gathering, then stand on that. There is absolutely nothing wrong with people organizing around a specific identity experience. Every demographic does this. Black people do it. Asians do it. Queer people do it. Mixed people do it. Diaspora communities do it constantly.</p><p>But if you suddenly expand the definition after the fact to mean “all mixed Asians,” then you are recreating the exact thing that has frustrated many non-Wasian mixed Asians in digital spaces for years: one specific experience quietly becoming the assumed default for everybody else.</p><p>And I think that’s the part a lot of people are struggling to articulate.</p><p>Because contrary to what some people online seem to believe, I don’t think most people are upset that white-Asian mixed people gathered in a park.</p><p>I think what people are reacting to is the self-centering.</p><p>The feeling that many of us have spent years already participating in broader mixed Asian conversations where white-Asian mixed identity occupied most of the oxygen in the room, consciously or unconsciously.</p><p><strong>And now suddenly that dynamic has physically manifested in real life.</strong></p><p>The irony is that many of the cultural markers being used in these videos aren’t even specifically Wasian.</p><p>“Do you take your shoes off in the house?”</p><p>“Did your family save plastic bags?”</p><p>“Did your parents do this?”</p><p>People of color have been making those jokes collectively forever. Asians have been making those jokes forever. Immigrant communities have been making those jokes forever. Mixed people have been making those jokes forever.</p><p>So watching these clips sometimes feels less like watching the birth of a new identity space and more like watching one demographic arrive loudly to conversations that have already existed for decades.</p><p>And yes, before somebody jumps in, I understand that white-Asian mixed people are still mixed people of color. That’s not the point.</p><p>The point is specificity.</p><p>Because if the entire premise is “our experience is unique and deserves its own naming,” then what exactly is uniquely Wasian about the examples being presented?</p><p>That’s where the confusion starts kicking in for a lot of observers, including other mixed Asians.</p><p>And honestly, I think part of why this exploded now has less to do with sudden racial awakening and more to do with modern internet infrastructure.</p><p>Apps like Partiful make hyper-specific organizing incredibly easy now. Algorithms reward identity-based visibility. TikTok encourages people to rapidly aestheticize themselves into communities. Niche identity categories become social scenes almost overnight.</p><p>And yes, I absolutely think mainstream visibility plays a role too.</p><p>Artists like Laufey becoming massively popular while openly discussing feeling “not Asian enough” and “not white enough” probably resonated with a generation of young white-Asian mixed people who suddenly saw themselves reflected publicly in a way they hadn’t before.</p><p>That matters. Representation matters. Visibility matters.</p><p>But visibility also changes scale.</p><p>A conversation that once existed quietly among niche online mixed-race communities is now happening in front of millions of people who have never engaged with mixed-race discourse before. Which means all the unresolved tensions inside those spaces suddenly become public too.</p><p>And for me personally, that’s actually why I’m glad these gatherings happened.</p><p>Because now the conversation is finally honest.</p><p>Now we can actually distinguish between “mixed Asian” as a broad category and “Wasian” as a specific identity experience. <strong><em>Those are not automatically interchangeable terms no matter how often internet culture blurred them together over the years.</em></strong></p><p>And I genuinely think that distinction is healthier for everybody.</p><p>But I also want to say something specifically to my fellow Blasians and other non-Wasian mixed Asians watching all this unfold.</p><p>If people start organizing Black-Asian gatherings in response to this, understand something right now:</p><p>the numbers will not look the same, and that’s okay.</p><p>White-Asian mixed people are probably one of the largest mixed Asian demographics in America. Maybe second only to Black-white mixed people overall. The visibility and scale are simply different.</p><p>So if a Blasian meetup happens and it’s smaller, that does not mean it failed. It does not mean the community is weaker. It does not mean the identity is less real.</p><p>Also, let’s be honest.</p><p><strong>The food will probably be better anyway.</strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8be181b612bf" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Kamala Harris is not discussing her race, and I think I know why.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@blasianFMA/kamala-harris-is-not-discussing-her-race-and-i-think-i-know-why-7e46e982fca2?source=rss-fe11fba75301------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7e46e982fca2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[kamala-harris]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[blasian]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[donald-trump]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[biracial]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jonah Sahn]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 04 Aug 2024 22:50:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-08-05T00:06:51.078Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Like Harris, I am a Black/Asian (Blasian) individual who was born in the Bay Area, moved around, attended an HBCU, and am continually affirmed, denied, embraced, and rejected by both sides of my cultural heritage — a heritage I embrace fully and wholeheartedly.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Ts25tMBX-CAAcdYECrN56Q.jpeg" /></figure><p>America is unique in that it comprises a tapestry of people and cultures, all woven together to form a single nation. Many families can trace their lineages back generations, to times before America existed as a country. They can recount stories of parents or grandparents who emigrated, arriving in the United States with a hundred dollars and a suitcase, fleeing war, or seeking new opportunities in the land of the free. Some have been here for generations, descending from long lines of indigenous peoples, while others possess limited records due to ancestors forced into bondage.</p><p>However, for those of us who are biracial, tracing our lineage is often twice as challenging. Our cultural heritage spans across multiple backgrounds, each with its own distinct history and narrative. This complexity is further compounded by our phenotypic appearance, which often sets us apart, making us appear “culturally ambiguous” and complicating our connection to these rich histories. In a way, we embody the American Dream, a blend of diverse cultures and identities. Yet, this very ambiguity sometimes stands in the way of our right to fully claim and celebrate those histories.</p><p>I particularly felt the weight of my cultural heritage when I visited Japan for the first time in the summer of 2023. Here, I found myself among millions of people simply living their everyday lives — walking, shopping, laughing, exercising, managing, selling, guiding, yelling — essentially running their country. These people were not the Japanese Americans I had come to know in the United States. They were Japanese people in Japan, living in their country. This experience made me realize that while they are vastly different, Japanese Americans can still trace their lineage, if they wish, back to this place.</p><p>Meanwhile, someone like me — an American with multiple marginalized identities — can never fully claim the United States of America as “my country.” Not only because I’m not white and because that’s who everyone pictures when they think of a “typical American” (and no, this is not a cry for help or a desire to be white), but because I belong to multiple marginalized identities that have been ravaged by the actions of the United States.</p><p>As a Black American, my history is clear. My ancestors were brought over in chains, forced into slavery, and held in bondage for hundreds of years. Even after slavery ended, the government continued to ensure that my ancestors faced restrictions on where they could live, work, and eat through state-sanctioned laws. The system created scenarios where education was limited, yet literacy was required to vote and shape policies that affected all Americans. My people were sent to war, only to be excluded from financial benefits like the G.I. Bill when the US was building its middle class. When my ancestors attempted to build communities for themselves, those communities were burned to the ground or flooded into lakes.</p><p>As a Filipino American, my heritage is marked by colonization and resilience. The Philippines was under Spanish rule for over 300 years before becoming a U.S. territory after the Spanish-American War in 1898, leading to the brutal Philippine-American War. Under U.S. control, the Philippines faced significant discrimination and exploitation. Independence finally came in 1946, but economic and social challenges persisted, prompting many Filipinos, including my family, to seek opportunities abroad.</p><p>My own family’s journey to America began when my aunt moved to the U.S., petitioning for her sisters and mother to join her. They sought a new life away from the remnants of colonization and conflict, hoping to build a better future. Filipino immigrants faced racial discrimination but persevered, contributing to the diverse tapestry of American society. Their resilience is a testament to the strength and determination that define the Filipino American experience.</p><p>But we live in a country where my father’s side of the family — African Americans, Black people — is often intentionally misunderstood by those who claim we live in a post-racial society. These are the people who insist they “don’t see color” and that it doesn’t matter if you’re “Black, white, purple, or polka-dotted.” They focus on the content of your character, attempting to simplify what is inherently complex. By doing so, they overlook the nuanced history and lived experiences of marginalized communities. They label those who highlight this complexity as being “too woke.”</p><p>In this context, how can someone like myself, or Kamala Harris, for that matter, explain to these people that she is indeed both Black and South Asian American? How do we convey the richness of our identities to those who prefer to see the world in the binary, ignoring the vibrant spectrum of experiences that make up our reality?</p><p>The world is vast and full of possibilities, and within the United States, its 330 million people hold at least 330 million opinions. Growing up as a Blasian person in Southern California and later in the Southern United States exposed me to a wide variety of opinions — opinions on everything from food, cars, and TV shows to who the best-looking actor is, the best pop artist, music genre, and even presidential leaders. The list is endless. I also learned that when you’re an ethnically ambiguous person, everyone seems to have an opinion on who or “what” you are.</p><p>Like Kamala Harris now, and I’m certain back when she was at Howard University, I have been accepted, rejected, affirmed, and denied by both Black and Asian communities.</p><p>I’ve heard it all:</p><blockquote>“You must be mixed with something…”</blockquote><blockquote>“Yeah, I can tell you’re Filipino, it’s in the face structure!”</blockquote><blockquote>“Psst! The way he’s standing. It’s Filipino.”</blockquote><blockquote>“You ain’t Black.”</blockquote><blockquote>“Why do you call yourself Asian? You’re not Asian.”</blockquote><blockquote>“Hopefully your top half is Asian and your lower half is Black…”</blockquote><blockquote>“Blasian? I swear you biracials do anything to run away from Blackness.”</blockquote><blockquote>“You’re Asian, sure, but not Asian Asian. You know what I mean?”</blockquote><blockquote>“Blasians wake up in the middle of the night and scream ‘I’M BLASIAN’ and go back to sleep.”</blockquote><blockquote>“Tiger Woods ass nigga.”</blockquote><p>These and countless other utterances are familiar to Blasians of a particular age, who grew up in the land of the free and the home of the brave. In a world so binary, so Black and White, we are constantly questioned about which side we’re on. And when we embrace both equally, we’re told that’s impossible. “The child is always whatever the father is,” some say. “The child is always what the mother is,” others insist. We are told we’re Black, and then told we aren’t Black but biracial. It all depends on whose opinion you’re listening to at that particular moment.</p><p>This constant questioning and invalidation of identity is something Kamala Harris also faces. As both Black and South Asian American, she embodies the complexity of multiracial identity in a society that often demands simplicity. Her journey highlights the challenges and triumphs of embracing a multifaceted identity, resonating with those of us who navigate these same waters.</p><p>So why should she even attempt to talk about her identity when so many people are willfully obtuse? With countless opinions on who and what she is, no answer is simple enough, and every response is likely to face opposition from someone with an agenda.</p><p>In the case of Kamala Harris and every other Blasian person who identifies as such, you would think that acknowledging all sides of one’s identity would demonstrate that this person not only embodies both but also believes in, represents, and authentically lives as both. Kamala Harris and many others have the phenotypic appearance to live as both. Every day, she and others like her are reminded of what they already know: “You’re Black” (thanks, we know, and it’s great) and “You’re not all the way Black” (thanks, we know).</p><p>This acknowledgment of dual identity is not about fitting into preconceived boxes but about embracing the richness and complexity of being. It’s about understanding that identity is not static or singular but a dynamic and multifaceted experience. Kamala Harris embodies this complexity, challenging the notion that she must conform to one identity or the other. Her presence and success highlight the beauty of embracing all parts of who we are, even when others struggle to understand it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/650/1*OE0VhvQBaz6RZIBmBh5QtQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Trust and believe: it’s not just Donald Trump out here with his record of birtherism and weirdly postured attacks, claiming that Kamala Harris suddenly “turned Black” one day after supposedly claiming to be Indian her whole life. To be honest, there’s no way Trump could have come up with that idea himself. His team likely consulted with the same people who, like many of the individuals we encountered growing up, negated our lived experiences with the utterances mentioned above.</p><p>The internet is rife with those denying Blasianness, berating biracial people, and attacking anyone who explores the intersectionality of their identities beyond the binary that comforts most. The online sphere becomes a battleground where identities are challenged, and the complexities of being both Black and Asian are often dismissed. This pervasive denial and criticism create an environment where individuals like Kamala Harris — and Blasians everywhere — must constantly defend their right to be multifaceted.</p><p>In a world where simplicity is preferred, and identities are expected to fit neatly into predefined categories, those who embrace their full spectrum are often misunderstood. The struggle to navigate this complex landscape is not just personal; it reflects a broader societal issue where ignorance and prejudice overshadow the beauty of diverse identities.</p><p>Given the attention this entire debacle has garnered, I believe Kamala Harris should address the orange elephant in the room and explain to Americans why she represents just one possibility of what America is supposed to be: a place where people from various cultures and backgrounds come together. Like my own experience growing up as a Blasian person in America, Harris embodies the complexity and richness of multiple identities. Her presence on the national stage challenges the simplistic narratives that often dominate public discourse, highlighting the beauty and strength found in our diversity.</p><p>Harris’s story is a testament to the potential of an America that embraces its many shades and voices. It reminds us that identity is not confined to binary definitions, but rather thrives in the intersections of culture, race, and experience. By addressing these issues head-on, Kamala Harris can further solidify her role as a trailblazer who not only represents the true spirit of America but also inspires those of us who navigate similar paths. Her journey affirms that embracing every facet of our identities is not only possible but essential in building a more inclusive and understanding society.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7e46e982fca2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Frozen 2: Disney’s Attempt at being Woke will Undoubtedly Piss off Folks on both the Left and the…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@blasianFMA/frozen-2-disneys-attempt-at-being-woke-will-undoubtedly-piss-off-folks-on-both-the-left-and-the-2f4b51cbf234?source=rss-fe11fba75301------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2f4b51cbf234</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[disney]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[movies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[racism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[white-supremacy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jonah Sahn]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 22 Nov 2019 05:07:37 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-11-22T05:53:31.323Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Frozen 2: Disney’s Attempt at being Woke will Undoubtedly Piss off Folks on both the Left and the Right.</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*T9NDqthteurAsomQe7NFyw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Oftentimes, those of us who are aware of the social injustices around us; the people who sympathize with others and are continually mastering the art of being as inclusive as possible with our language, the ones who put their pronouns in their Twitter bios, and the ones labeled “SJWs” are accused of looking too hard into things. We’re told that we read too deeply into a meaning or a bias that does not exist. We’re “too woke.” We’re “one of those” because we’re able to clock the fallout, legacy and dynamic of white supremacy in seemingly every little action, depiction, note and narrative. We see “the big scary R word” in every little thing. PC culture has seemingly invaded our collective left leaning psyches and seeks to punish every one for every thing they’ve ever thought. We’re policing thoughts now.</p><p>Personally, I don’t want to make others feel oppressed. All I want is for people to be more mindful of the ramifications of their words and actions on other people. For some, being called out becomes a matter of discomfort while for others it becomes a moment of reflection and thankfulness. Where one feels like they’re being attacked by the PC police the other apologizes and commits to doing better. I like the latter and behave as such with others who are less privileged than I am.</p><p>But the arguments, the criticism, the disdain for being aware, for being mindful of others, for being able to see an insidious message or white supremacy in every little thing; that gets tiresome and sometimes I do just want to mentally check out and enjoy a thing.</p><p>What better way to do that but with Disney’s <em>Frozen 2</em>?</p><p>I arrived at the Downtown Brooklyn Alamo Drafthouse shortly before the 6pm showing. Finding my way to my seat and plopping down in the comfortable little cushioned chair, I breathed a sigh of relief as I settled in to enjoy our entertainment overlord’s latest installment in the Frozen line up. Previously, I had only seen a trailer for the movie over the Summer. Elsa on the beach, looking determined to cross the ocean. She sets down her cloak and sprints toward the water, using her powers to freeze waves into ice and advance across a seemingly endless obstacle, but ultimately failing, trying again, and failing again.</p><p>That was literally all of the context I had for this movie. I had no idea what the plot could be about. Typically… Well, ever since <em>The Return of Jafar</em> Disney sequels have been direct to VHS/DVD/Non Theatrical releases made with a lower budget and yielding far less success than their origin point movies. Sure, “He Lives in You” from <em>The Lion King 2: Simba’s Pride </em>is an amazing piece that transcended this curse and found its way to the Broadway production, but that’s about it as far as the success of Disney sequels goes. Did you know there’s a Pocahontas 2 where she goes to Europe? That’s all I know about that movie. Apparently it didn’t work out (Justice for Kocoum!).</p><p>The theater was packed with little kids and their parents. Typical setting for 6pm on a Thursday evening. There were kids dressed as Elsa, kids running up and down the aisles, kids doing cartwheels down in front of the screen. There was a lot of excitement for this movie. The pre trailer theater screen even had videos (surely procured by Disney) of kids singing songs from the first <em>Frozen</em> movie.</p><p>As I began to decompress from the work week, I told myself: “Johnathan, whatever this is about, just enjoy the movie for what it is.” The Universe sure has a way of getting me ready for things. Why would I think to tell myself that before seeing <em>Frozen 2</em> of all things? Had the internet really been bogging my thoughts down, making me think that I’ve been “too woke” lately? Whatever it was, I promised myself I’d just marvel at the latest in animation and indulge in what was sure to be an amazing soundtrack and stay on the lookout for the next big “Let it Go”-Like hit.</p><p>What I got was 1 hour and 43 minutes of a direct challenge to the promise I made to myself right before the first song was sung. Jesus. Where to start? Let me just say this at the beginning: Whether you lean left or you lean right, you’re going to have something to say about this movie. Folks who think the main stream media (MSM) have gone too far will find validation in <em>Frozen 2 </em>while people who are on the lookout for messaging of systemic and institutionalized racism and white supremacy will also be sorely disappointed by the story.</p><p><em>Frozen 2 </em>is about Elsa and Anna’s journey to unlock the Mystic Forest to the North of their Kingdom Arendelle. When the two sisters were younger, their father, the king, told them of the Mystic Forest and how fighting between its Indigenous people and the people of Arendelle (white people) caused the Forest to become sealed off from the outside world. The Elements of Fire, Water, Air and Earth went to sleep and trapped all who were in the Mystic Forest locked away for (seemingly) the rest of eternity.</p><p>Our story begins as Elsa begins hearing voices in her head; a sort of singing. A calling. Eventually she gives in to the call and rushes outside in the middle of the night, accepting the call from far beyond the kingdom’s walls, not knowing who or what could be beckoning for her and why. This causes the elements of Earth, Air, Fire and Water to reawaken and wreak havoc on the Kingdom of Arendelle. Its citizens are evacuated and Elsa, Anna and Company decide that they must travel to the Mystic Forest to find out what is going on.</p><p>This is where things start getting interesting.</p><p>Upon entering the Mystic Forest, Elsa and Co. meet with the Native people of the lands just North of Arendelle. They’re clearly modeled after and play the role of Indigenous folks… Even though they lean heavily toward being White Appearing. Flag number one, but I ignored it and told myself “no no… I’m here to just enjoy the movie.” After their initial encounter, which also includes soldiers of Arendelle who have been locked in the Mystic Forest for 6 or so years, Anna meets and “tames” the spirits of Air and Fire. It’s worth mentioning, and you may have assumed, that the spirits mentioned here are very much tied to the White Appearing Indigenous Mystic Forest People who live just North of Arendelle.</p><p>After settling a small conflict between the Soldiers and the Native people, and after Olaf gives a brief but hilarious retelling of the first movie to catch everyone (both the folks who have been stuck in the Mystic Forest and the audience) up on the events of the original <em>Frozen</em> movie, Elsa decides that she should continue heading north and follow the mystery voice that calls out to her. The Native people tell her it would be better to leave in the morning because the Earth Spirits roam at night. We get to see one of these titans walking around shortly thereafter. They are huge, just as the titans in Disney’s <em>Hercules</em>.</p><p>At some point Anna, Elsa’s sister, and her boyfriend Kristoff see a dam along the river in the Mystic Forest. This is important to remember and the writing makes it very obvious that this dam will play a larger role in the movie later (“If this dam were to ever break, all of the land on this fjord (which includes the Kingdom of Arendelle) would be decimated.”)</p><p>Elsa and Co. continue northward and eventually find their dead parents’s wreck ship. What is it doing up here though? They weren’t traveling this way when they died at sea! A quick search reveals a map: Elsa and Anna’s mother and father were heading north to a place mentioned in a lullaby (known to both the Indigenous people and Elsa’s family) to find an answer to why Elsa possesses magical icy powers. They died in that pursuit. Elsa decides that she must make the rest of the journey alone and forces Anna and Olaf away on a magical ice boat of her creation (Kristoff has, by this time, already been separated from the main group because shenanigans).</p><p>Elsa stands at the northern most part of the continent. This is the part from the trailer. After trying to cross the ocean and failing multiple times, she comes across the Spirit of the Water which takes the form of a horse. Eventually, after much work, she “tames” this spirit with an ice lasso and it gives her a ride to a glacier far, far away. Within this icy floating structure all is revealed to Elsa, but not before Disney attempts a follow up to the insanely popular <em>Let it Go. </em>Spoiler alert: It’s not nearly as good (as a matter of fact, none of the songs are as memorable as the first movie’s score and that’s disappointing).</p><p>The truth: Elsa’s grandfather was a racist white supremacist.</p><p>Of course Disney doesn’t just come out and say it like that. Instead, they explain that the aforementioned fighting that caused the Mystic Forest to close was started when the King of Arendelle, at the time Elsa’s Grandfather (Grand Wizard of this narrative), became upset when the Indigenous people of the Mystic Forest would not allow Arendelle to build a dam in their woods (or something like that, tbh I was checking out at this point because I just wanted to enjoy some good animation and instead I got this story). Elsa’s grandfather offers the Indigenous folks’s leader a cup of tea, and as the Indigenous folks’s leader’s back is turned, the king murders him with a sword. Thus, the Spirits of Air, Fire, Water and Earth become pissed and seal off the forest.</p><p>Elsa, seeing all of this, is in shock. How could her own family member b̵e̵ ̵a̵ ̵r̵a̵c̵i̵s̵t̵ be a murder!? The lullaby that I mentioned earlier, the one that both the Indigenous people as well as the people of Arendelle know, was all about this glacier of knowledge and it also warns that if you get in too deep, you could drown. Upon learning all of this, Elsa is not only in shock, but is also physically frozen by the environment. Before she becomes completely immobile, she uses her powers to transmit an icy message to Anna and Olaf who are now lost in a cave deep in the forest. Elsa’s ice text message reaches Anna and Olaf and takes the shape of their grandfather and the Indigenous folks’s leader; their Grandfather’s sword drawn and the Indigenous man completely unaware. Somehow Anna deduces that, yes, their grandfather was a racist and that the only way to repay the debt is to destroy the dam and quell the rage of the spirits.</p><p>“But that would mean the complete eradication of their own kingdom Arendelle!” you might say, because the movie foreshadowed it. So here we are. Anna, understanding the deeds of her ancestors, the sins of their family’s past, must make the decision to destroy their homeland and free these poor Indigenous folk who are stuck in the Mystic forest, because nature is so pissed at the white people for what they have done and they <em>must</em> atone for it.</p><p>By now I’m in my seat just looking.</p><p><em>Of course </em>this is what Disney came up with for <em>Frozen 2.</em></p><p>Anna cleverly uses the titanic Spirits of the Earth to do the work for her. She uses herself as bait and has the Earth Titans chase her to the dam where they lob boulders at her position, causing the dam to rupture and then fall. Immediately, the curse is broken, the Mystic Forest is unlocked and Elsa is free from her icy prison on the glacier. Somehow Elsa knows exactly what is going on (I’m sure it was explained but my eyes were rolled so far back into my skull at this point that it is very much possible that I wasn’t looking at the screen) and rushes to Arendelle on mystic spiritual watery horseback where she is able to get in front of the destructive wave just in time to save the kingdom.</p><p>It is explained that because Anna was willing to give it all up to atone for the sins of her forefathers, the Spirits decided to let them keep their kingdom. Ok.</p><p>Elsa, realizing that she is the bridge between worlds, a Woman and a God, assigns Anna to be the new queen of Arendelle as she keeps watch over the Mystic Forest and its Indigenous inhabitants. The end.</p><p>Yikes.</p><p>Of course, those who believe that the MSM has “gone too far” will view <em>Frozen 2 </em>as yet another example of liberals pushing their leftist agenda on children. They’ll view the plot line of Elsa and Anna realizing their grandfather did something horrible to a people of color (but barely of color and we’ll get into that in a minute) as SJW propaganda, people not being able to “get over it”, and (the horror) white genocide.</p><p>Those on the left, like myself, will view the movie as an attempt at playing the middle of the road while using very important and very real unresolved issues as a way to virtue signal some kind of kumbaya/ We Shall Overcome “we all have skeletons in our closet but let’s do our best and things will be okay” narrative.</p><p>Elsa and Anna’s grandfather, the King, wanted to build a structure on the sacred grounds of the Indigenous people of this universe’s land, and when they opposed him, he began a slaughter. Anna and Elsa are the White people of today, reckoning with the sins of their fathers. The White men who enslaved, raped and lynched African people. The White men who sailed across the sea and decimated an entire continent’s worth of people to build their own nation. This is American history and <em>Frozen 2</em> attempts to tell that story and present a solution to something that has <em>yet</em> to be resolved and reckoned with in our every day lives.</p><p>Their solution, burn the kingdom you built to the ground (or wash it away in this case) and all will be forgiven; and I have to give the story credit, because when Anna decided that destroying Arendelle was “the next right thing” (a through line in this movie) I was here for that decision. But the cop out at the very last second!? Elsa swoops in and is able to save A̵m̵e̵r̵i̵c̵a̵ the kingdom and all is forgiven by the Spirits? NAH.</p><p>On top of that, Elsa ascends to god status, and becomes the overseer of the white appearing Indigenous folks. BYE DISNEY.</p><p>I really wanted to just go out and see a new animated feature with some great songs. I got what I asked for with a side of faux woke narrative that didn’t manage to teach anybody anything. What are kids supposed to learn from this? “Your grandparents might have been racists/ done some horrible things to people who don’t look like you a long time ago and you need to think about that”? Just yikes. I do appreciate the attempt, but with something as complex and unresolved as our county’s history, perhaps Disney should have just steered clear of this one altogether. <em>Frozen 2 </em>should have taken place on a cruise ship to the new world or something. At least then we could have had a Pocahontas Easter egg or something.</p><p>EDIT:</p><p>I have learned, since publishing this, that Disney went to great lengths to avoid “cultural appropriation” of the Sámi people, or indigenous Nordic people. I read <a href="https://insidethemagic.net/2019/11/disney-frozen-2-cultural-appropriation-indigenous-people-ba1/">this article</a> which explains the process Disney went through to respect these indigenous folks. Having learned this, the main point of Frozen 2’s “pay for the sins of your ancestors but nvmd b/c it’s ok you’re sorry” still stands for me.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2f4b51cbf234" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>