<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Bob Boiko  on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Bob Boiko  on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@bobboiko?source=rss-02be1be414b2------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 04:37:27 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@bobboiko/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why Write? Why do Anything?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@bobboiko/why-write-why-do-anything-bc0cf6f3ff99?source=rss-02be1be414b2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/bc0cf6f3ff99</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[writing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fame]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[creativity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[popularity]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Bob Boiko ]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 04 Nov 2026 15:16:09 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-11-04T15:21:46.166Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>So, here I am writing something. But do I really want people to read it? I’m not sure.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*VP_F9jz7VfeNpH5xxJqz_Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>Image by AI, text by Bob</figcaption></figure><p>Here’s what I want to want.</p><p>I want a small group of interested people to read this and want to talk about it with me. And if no one ever wants to read it? That’s okay? I write for me, fuck y’all.”</p><p><em>That’s what I want the answer to be, but what is it really? Lemme back up.</em></p><p>I wrote a technical book once. Right place, right time, right subject. It got some attention. In fact, it was considered a foundational book in a new technical area. Doesn’t matter which. Didn’t make a lot of money but, relatively, it did alright. What it did do was spawn a 10 year run of conference keynotes and a well-paying consulting career. I went all around the world, stood on stages, got perks (my favorite was an all-expense-paid week on Ipanema Beach) and was generally wined, dined and admired. It was a very small fame. But it showed me what fame was like. Lots of empty and trivial conversations with people who somehow thought I had the answers they needed in life.</p><p><em>I didn’t like it. Maybe it was me? No, it was definitely me.</em></p><p>By the end, I would give my talk then hide in my room hoping no dinner invitations would come. But they always did. It’s part of the deal. Organizers want their attendees to meet the stars. I get that and I did that, but I never liked it. Why? It’s not that I thought I had no answers to offer these people, I had lots. Years of experience and a glib tongue made me a pretty good dinner guest.</p><p><em>It’s that I’m not a crowd person.</em></p><p>As extroverted as I am on the outside (glib tongue and all that), I’m more of an intimate, or even a solo person. I hate parties cause you are forced to stay on the surface. My party MO is to find a person to talk with and buttonhole them till they get uncomfortable and excuse themselves. I’m also content by myself. I’m good company. I love people, but solitude is awesome too. My favorite times are alone or with just one person who doesn’t mind incessant conversational digging.</p><p><em>Plus, I was already on to the next thing.</em></p><p>My audience just wanted to talk about the last thing. I love the singer/songwriter Joni Mitchell, well her early stuff anyway. I never related to the later stuff. That’s my perspective, hers was:</p><p><em>“I lost a lot of people when I started writing more complex music, but I would have lost myself if I hadn’t.”</em></p><p>I feel ya Joni. Fame is the poison of creativity. By the time anyone cared about what I had done, I was personally done doing it.</p><p><em>Finally, fame is empty.</em></p><p>People want to touch fame, not the famous person. For my generation the epitome of fame was the Beatles running from a mob of screaming teenagers. Why were those kids motivated to humiliate themselves for the slim chance to touch fame? Why do I and everyone else love to tell of our own modest brushes with fame (I took a shower with Jackson Brown once). The best I can come up with is that people want ‘fame by association.’ We want a piece, even a tiny sliver, of the admiration that the famous have. Now, even at its height, my fame was fleeting and feeble. But it was enough to tell me that the admiration of strangers is no admiration at all.</p><p><em>So, that’s my rant about hating notoriety.</em></p><p>You may think me disingenuous; I feel that way myself. Cause, as much as I can rationalize not wanting people to love what I do, I still want them to love what I do. Damn! As much as I might like solitude, I really don’t want to talk just to myself. As much as I hate the taste I had of notoriety, would I turn it down if it came again? Probably not. Are my ideas awesome even if no one ever hears them? They might be. Do I have any proof of awesomeness if no one ever likes what I write? Nope, just my own faith. But is my own faith shaken when I get the message that no one cares? Sure, but I can still say, “If only they read me they would love me.” Is my faith in myself undermined when someone actively does not like my work? Yep.</p><p>I wrote a novel once, wrong place and time, wrong author. I was ambivalent about releasing it, but I did anyway. To try and get some traction, I actually paid to have a few professionals read and review it. They panned it. As much as I told myself, “Whatever,” it definitely bummed me out, drained my confidence, made me think I wasn’t very good.</p><p>I started writing again recently. And with some trepidation, I posted a story on Facebook. I found myself coming back over and over to see if anyone cared. Just enough people did to keep me from feeling like a total failure, but I couldn’t help noticing that my story was not nearly as interesting as your last trip to the beach. And that hurt, of course it did.</p><p><em>And that’s my rant about needing notoriety.</em></p><p>After the decided lack of applause for my novel, I fell back from, “My book is awesome,” to “My book is awesome… to me!” It took me 10 years and a lot of cash to finish it, but it was worth the effort. Hand to heart, living inside my characters and having them in my life to this day, was worth every dime.</p><p><em>So, I guessed I had better get used to writing for me and only me.</em></p><p>And, I’m doing that. I’ll still publish what I write, but more for archival purposes and not to show off to my friends and family. And even though I still check the likes, I am resolved to never get any. If no one ever reads me, I’ll still write cause I’ve got shit to say and even if I’m saying it to only me, it’s still worth saying. Plus, formally saying it, forces me to think it through. I often wonder if what I think about something is better stated in my first or last draft? The first draft plumbs my inchoate opinions, but the act of editing crystalizes them into something solid and real. This essay is a case in point. I’m already feeling more settled on fame even while typing these words.</p><p>Funny, but having edited an opinion to death, I no longer need to hold it. That’s a solid result that has nothing to do with being liked. But what’s really going on and is there a way to reconcile wanting and not wanting fame?</p><p><em>But what if I actually suck?</em></p><p>Van Gogh died thinking he sucked. How many other amazing people died with no recognition only to be redeemed later? How many more thought they sucked and were never redeemed? Did those people actually suck if they were never redeemed? I don’t know and maybe that’s not even the point. If I think I suck, should I give up or keep going?</p><p>I had a company once. I was like the main guy. Every hard issue came to me and I was acknowledged as the best at what we did. My back hurt so I went to a nearby yoga class at lunchtime. I was the worst there. I’m not very bendy. But, know what? I loved sucking! No one expected anything from me so I had the freedom to just enjoy the ride. Plus, at the top I had nowhere to go, while at the bottom I had green fields of progress ahead of me. Of course, I wanted to be awesome at yoga, but sucking was fun too.</p><p><em>Maybe art is a balance between audience and creativity</em>.</p><p>I met a guy once who called himself an artist. He made airbrush paintings of crumpled papers. They were hyper realistic and sold pretty well. In fact, he had ongoing relationships with a number of galleries that consistently sold his stuff. The paintings were interesting but not profound. And I’m guessing that the first of these paintings was an inspired act for him. After a while, and he said as much, they simply paid the rent and fed his kid. He told me that was the only art he did now. Can I fault him? No, I guess not. Should I feel sorry for him? Nah, he was happy enough with his lot, in fact, he was proud that his other artist friends all had day jobs and he could support his family on his work. So, who am I to judge? I just had one conversation with him at a T-ball game like 30 years ago. But I’ve thought about him a lot. I used to fault him for not being a real artist. Now, I just think he turned up the audience knob and turned down the creativity knob.</p><p>Turn up the creativity knob too much and you lose your audience. Just ask Joni! Turn up the audience knob too much and you lose your creativity. The bigger the audience, the more they want the same old shit. There are, of course, the Picassos and Bowies of the world who went through massive creative changes but only grew in popularity, but for the rest of us, its shlock or obscurity.</p><p>If you reduce the audience to one person, yourself, you can go wild. You can write or paint or sculpt or speak the most profound gibberish. You can be like the guy raving to the air on the street. He’s making sense to himself, and he may even be saying something you really need to hear, but you’ll never get near enough to know. If you turn down the creativity to about zero, you can create (or recreate, rather) a lot of very popular stuff. The trick is to find a balance between the two extremes that lets you progress creatively while having enough of an audience that you don’t feel like a failure.</p><p>So yeah, back to a small group of interested people who want to talk about the same stuff I do and are not with me because I’m popular. My knobs are definitely skewed toward creativity, but let’s see if I can still get anyone to listen.</p><p><em>Wait, are we talking just about writing?</em></p><p>What goes for writing goes for life. Am I living for my audience or for me? Am I here to live my most “me” life or am I here to love and serve those around me? Where do I draw the line between pleasing them and pleasing me? Maybe the same ideas apply.</p><p>I can’t pretend that mattering to people doesn’t matter. That’s why at the end of this story, after editing my opinion to clarity, I can’t honestly say “I write for me, fuck y’all.” But I also can’t bring myself to believe that popularity is any kind of end in itself. But I can believe even more strongly that a small group of like-minded people in writing or life is most optimum. I need an audience big-enough to feel that what I do is connected to more than just me. An audience big-enough that I don’t feel like a complete failure. But I need an audience small enough that I can share in what they create too and admire them right back. For now, that’s just me, my faithful wife and one or two friends and family. A few newcomers would be nice too, but only if they love me for who I am ;)</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=bc0cf6f3ff99" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Look at me!]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@bobboiko/look-at-me-0ed66505dece?source=rss-02be1be414b2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/0ed66505dece</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[playground-politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[romance]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[attractiveness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[childhood]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Bob Boiko ]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 30 Oct 2026 15:31:54 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-30T15:31:54.788Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>And there was a beautiful view, but nobody could see, cause everybody on the island was saying look at me look at me look at me look at me!<br> — Laurie Anderson (</em><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1eTSL2kopP4&amp;list=RD1eTSL2kopP4&amp;start_radio=1"><em>link</em></a><em>)</em></p><p>One day a picture popped into my head. It’s a class of kids, say fourth or fifth grade. Maybe on the playground. All the boys are looking at one, admittedly cute, girl. Likewise, all the girls are looking at the same cute boy.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YDWjTuiHVzHxwriBy2g6sQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Image by Google. Text by Bob</figcaption></figure><p>Let’s call them Rosey and Rory. Rosey is cute, but objectively no cuter than many of the other girls. But she is a social hub among the girls and the boys see that. She’s not shy, in fact she is a little precocious and outgoing. Rory is more likely to be a loner or even a bit surly. But he has something that attracts the girls. He’s handsome or rebellious or athletic or even smooth in a 10 year-old kind of way. There were kids like that where I grew up and I’m guessing they were near you as well? Perhaps you even hold a flickering little flame for your own young Rosey or Rory? I kinda do.</p><p>Ever heard of a power law? It’s the 80/20 rule. In this case, 80% of the attention goes to 20% of the kids. In my school, it may have been more like a 90/10 rule!</p><p>I looked at my class picture from age 10 or 11 the other day. My eyes went right to Rosie in the third row, cute as ever. But then, for some reason, I looked a bit harder at the other girls. Why was I so fixated with Rosey while there were so many girls, just as cute but far more friendly than her?</p><p>Then, I found Rory, the boy-equivalent of Rosie. Why did he get so much attention from her while I was left admiring Rosey from afar? What did Rory have that I didn’t? The answers were pretty obvious even back then. He was better looking, more athletic and more self-confident. I was smarter than Rory, but that counted for nothing in those days.</p><p>In my class, and maybe in yours as well, the crushes on Rory, and Rosie, compounded and escalated. Saying you “liked” the wrong person was challenged, while fancying the right person was validated. As you might imagine, very few relationships were formed.</p><p>The adult me thinks I was crazy not to court one of the many non Rosies. The child me would never even think of that. Even into college, the phenomenon persisted. I had a friend who was a recent immigrant. He had so many girlfriends I couldn’t count them. But they were all non Rosies. I thought he was romantically disabled or that his culture had a bizarre notion of attractiveness. I see now that he was simply filling an unexploited niche.</p><p>Clearly, there is some norming going on. As in clothing, food, music, and all other areas where there is choice, Attraction is a style. And as with any other style, conformity is the key to acceptance. But maybe there is more as well? Is the Rosey/Rory phenomenon just a part of our inmate primate social hierarchy? Is attraction to the alpha male or female a way of unifying a tribe? Do we mate with whomever will have us but only truly love our kings and queens?</p><p>And as children, do we naively think we can have the king or queen we truly love? Children, like stem cells, are pluripotent– they might become but are not anyone yet. In primary school, I had a very clear idea of who the Rosies were, but little idea of how Rory I was. I found out eventually, as I was rejected by one Rosie after another. I eventually figured out exactly how Rory I was and adjusted my sights accordingly. But I was a lot older before I recognized the Rosey/Rory game for what it was and stopped playing it.</p><p>I’m so much more enlightened now, or am I? Looking back at my school picture it all comes back. We all liked the same girl and she could be mine. Today, I am left wondering. Did I ever really get past Rosie and Rory? Or are they still embedded deep down influencing me in ways I can no longer detect?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=0ed66505dece" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Lizzie and the Zoomshroom]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@bobboiko/lizzie-and-the-zoomshroom-755c68dd3134?source=rss-02be1be414b2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/755c68dd3134</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[mycology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[short-fiction]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science-fiction]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ecology-and-environment]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sentience]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Bob Boiko ]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 29 Oct 2026 15:00:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-30T15:06:53.564Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*7cZbrC20AWwFPa1rHGtBYw.png" /><figcaption>Image by ChatGPT. Story by Bob</figcaption></figure><p><em>Long ago there was a seeding. Spores rained down on the sterile planet and took hold. The spores bootstrapped evolution then died. Myriad life forms reproduced, proliferated, diversified and filled the planet. Of those forms, only one was considered fully sapient. The sapient form had begun by simply sensing the world around it. It then evolved to perceiving its world, then to conceiving it, then transcending its world entirely by imagining other worlds and its own creation. With a mind too powerful for a small planet, the form reached out across space to a presence it knew must be out there. The galaxy-wide alliance of sapient life forms, called The Community, responded and welcomed the new member.</em></p><p><em>A cosmic instant later came a panicked plea from the new sapient. Extinction was imminent, an upstart life form had gained advantage and threatened to annihilate them. The Community dispatched an adjudicator to observe and, if needed, intervene.</em></p><p><em>***</em></p><p>Lizzie was nobody, not a government geologist, not a university botanist, not one of the dozens of other kinds of scientists scrambling over the crater like ants on candy. They paid her no attention, and that was fine. She erected her own little experimental area on her side of their fence, with a bright red ribbon. She came every afternoon to the impact crater, in a cow pasture, in western Kentucky. Unlike the swarming scientists, she knew the owner of the field. Every morning she served the wiry old goat coffee, two eggs over-hard and white toast. And every afternoon, the 5-foot-two, 53-year-old citizen scientist with a squeaky voice and a gardener’s hat, came with her notebook, jeweler’s eyepiece and a bag of sample containers. She put her sharp nose to the dirt, sketched and took notes. She’d be damned if anyone would stop her from documenting how the scorched soil was being colonized by pioneer organisms.</p><p>The first fungi to hit the soil on the rim of the crater were her old friends: Cladosporium, Alternaria, Aspergillus and Penicillium. She had seen these species germinate through their chitin coatings innumerable times. But there was one she didn’t know. Under the phase contrast microscope she bought with 18 months’ worth of tips, she saw strange oblong spores that seemed to have little fins. Calming her excited hands, and wiping her reading glasses for the third time, she painstakingly separated out some of the crazy spores and dropped them in a petri dish to germinate.</p><p>“Cardamon?,” she asked herself, sniffing the air.</p><p>She had gotten up before dawn, and was tramping through the old goat’s field toward her carefully laid red-ribbon grid. A cloud of bees and wasps got the same scent and buzzed all around. Lizzie followed her nose and the swarm of pollinators back away from the crater. At about 200 yards, the insects were hugging the ground and the smell reached a peak. Lizzie whisked away the bugs, flopped down and drank in the sweet spicy smell. She was never as happy as when she was face-deep in the weeds. At this distance from the crater, fine dust from the impact coated but did not kill the existing vegetation. But close to the ground there was something new. She plucked out a tiny fluorescent green mushroom with tweezers and studied it through her eyepiece. It resembled Peziza, the cup fungus, but it wasn’t that. Peziza grows in moist soil, not this dry stuff, and Peziza didn’t smell.</p><p>On her hands and knees, oblivious to anything taller than a quarter inch, she zig-zagged back and forth toward and away from the crater. The strange mushroom grew in a wide circle all the way around the impact! She carefully removed the soil around a cluster of the tiny mushrooms to uncover the underground network of mycelia. Hours later, filthy and desperately late for work, Lizzie discovered that the mushrooms were at the leading edge of a mycelial network that radiated out from the center of the crater. The tiny mushrooms she had found must be the fruiting bodies of the spores she had collected earlier which were now growing in her lab.</p><p>At 8, Lizzie began sticking her face in the weeds to look at the tiny world so close to the ground. At 16, she got her first microscope and decided that the littlest mushrooms and their stringy underground networks were her biggest thrill. One bored and confused semester at Western Kentucky University was more than enough. The serious students all made fun of her second-hand clothes and know-it-all attitude. She dropped out in a huff and spent the next 30 years reading, thinking and experimenting on her own.</p><p>She spent all her time now on the fungi that mushroom hunters trampled while looking for their Cremini, Shiitake and Oysters. Only once did she try to publish her findings. The journal never even responded to her repeated emails. Her logs, diaries and reports filled her shelves and hard drives, but she never again tried to publish or even speak with academics. Her work was for her not them, thank you very much. She had no need for her family either. They were the first in a long line of teasers who refused to take her seriously. To this day, they wanted her to stop being foolish and get married. No curiosity, the lot of them. Her only connections to the wider world were her friends at the Muhlenberg Mycological Society. But most of them were interested in the same mushrooms as the pickers, or worse, the psychedelics.</p><p>She worked the morning shift at Elmers and spent her afternoons outside collecting data or alone in her lab in the basement of a little house she rented from a master gardener. She traded tending the exotic plants all around the property in return for reduced rent and all the apples she could eat.</p><p>She tried and failed to classify the fungus growing in her petri dish. The crescent-shaped cups, that in other fungi splashed out spores when hit by a raindrop, instead puffed out tiny clouds of the cardamon-smelling spores. There was nothing like it in any taxonomic database she had access to. It was new, it had to be. This little spraying fungus was like nothing on Earth.</p><p>The spores germinated and sent out thousands of snaking tendril-like hyphae. The hyphae interconnected and spread way too quickly. They overflowed the dish in just 15 minutes. She moved the culture to a 50-gallon terrarium, which filled in less than an hour. The mycelia sprouted the cup-shaped mushrooms which, in turn, sprayed a fog of spores into the terrarium. But the spores didn’t hang in the air like they were supposed to. Instead, they zoomed around looking for a way out of the glass container!</p><p>“Zoomshroom!” she said out loud to no one.</p><p>Did the Zoomshroom splash out of the impact crater or did the dust from the impact provide the right environment for it to grow? What on earth could it have evolved from? How did the tiny spores move by themselves? How had no one seen this fungus before? One thing for sure, if she showed this to anyone in established science, they would laugh at her or steal it from her.</p><p>She had no bigger containers, so she moved the terrarium into her back yard, where the mycelium, mushrooms and spores quickly buried the terrarium and overflowed onto the lawn.</p><p>Back at the crater, the Zoomshroom colony had expanded from 200 yards to half a mile. The air was thick with their aromatic compounds which intoxicated and invigorated her. She wanted nothing more than to dig her little nose into the ground and inhale. But instead, she staggered out of the Zoomshroom patch and took out her phone. She connected to the free version of the Operational Land Imager (OLI) satellite system and pulled up aerial images of the crater. In visible light, there was nothing to see, but in the near-infrared wavelengths, the Zoomshroom lit up. And there were other patches of Zoomshroom at 10, 30 and even 100 miles from the crater. Lizzie never jumped to conclusions, she was precise, measured and intentional in her observations and conservative in her conclusions. But no theory fit the facts better than that this organism had come to earth on a meteor and was now reproducing exponentially across the United States.</p><p>The scientists inside the fence had caught up. They coordined-off the whole field and shut Lizzy out. No matter, she had what she needed in her lab and back yard. She prepped and fractionated a sample of the spores and found that they contained hydrazine — rocket fuel. So that’s what their little fins were for. The spores were not passive like other spores, they were rocket-powered flying machines that could choose their own direction!</p><p>She sampled the air above the Zoomshrooms in her yard and found thousands upon thousands of aroma compounds in addition to the spores. Fungi use these compounds as repellents, attractors or to communicate with the plants around them. One species might have as many as 100 different aroma compounds, but never thousands. What was going on with her friend, the Zoomshroom?</p><p>Then, Zoomshroom hit the news. The police were warning people to stay away from the sweet smell which could cause intoxication. The infestation, as they called it, had spread across the country and had now been detected as far away as Siberia. National Guard troops had been called out in every state to eradicate the mushroom, but they could not begin to keep up with its spread. The news said nothing about the Zoomshroom itself or where it had come from. They must know that it was an organism like no other and that it came from the meteor impact. But there is no way they would say that to everyone and risk a panic.</p><p>Lizzie came up from her lab to check on the Zoomshroom patch in her yard. It had stopped growing but had a distinctly different smell, more like mustard now. She took one breath and crumbled to the ground. The Zoomshroom tendrils quickly enveloped her and pushed into her nose, mouth and ears.</p><p>***</p><p>Was she dead? Dreaming? She remembered coming home and walking through the back door, then… nothing. She found herself in a dark passageway with a light in the distance. Dead then. Stroke? Some toxic compound from the Zoomshroom? As she walked toward the light and a clamor of voices, the passage closed behind her. She entered what looked like a giant soap bubble, kilometers across. Shimmering rainbow patterns swirled around on the surface of the undulating sphere. It glowed softly and lit the area from everywhere and nowhere. Outside the bubble was darkness. As she entered, so did innumerable other kinds of plants and animals, all about her size, all taking a place on the inside surface of the bubble.</p><p>Wow, just the afterlife she wanted. Every species together, in a shimmering cosmic bubble. Lizzie was enjoying the thought of it when her scientist’s mind kicked in. No one was falling but they were all pointing in different directions. Where was gravity? The bubble was slowly surging, but why was no one moving with it? How could she hear and understand what a rosebush and an otter were saying to each other? How was that shark breathing? How was she breathing? Why were all these organisms the same size as her? Either heaven was outside of physical law, or she was in some fantasy. She felt for her body. It was there but insubstantial. Her hands penetrated through her overalls and skin. Her jeweler’s loop was still around her neck and her gardener’s hat was still on her head, but they too were not quite solid, more like Jello. She poked the turtle standing next to her and her finger gently penetrated its shell. The turtle pushed her hand away indignantly and said,</p><p>“You? Go away, I will not associate with your kind.”</p><p>The other plants and animals in Lizzie’s vicinity grumbled in agreement and left a wide space between themselves and her.</p><p>“What did I ever do to you?” Lizzie replied to those around them, but neither she nor they were talking. They were thinking!</p><p>She looked toward the center of the bubble. Somehow it was much closer than it should have been, just a few yards away. At dead center, a glowing globule of color with its own rainbow patterns pulsed like it had a heartbeat. The blob of color was flanked by a gnarled old tree and a wispy tufted wheat plant both about twice her size. Their roots dangled below them like tangled hair.</p><p>She was about to speak again to the turtle, when the blob announced in a low authoritative voice,</p><p>“I am the Adjudicator. I came here to listen and then to speak. I have entwined with each life form that is sentient but is not yet sapient. You are representatives of each of those forms. You are here to witness and let the others of your kind know what happens here. Before me are the two sapiens of your planet: The Forest and Grass. I will adjudicate their dispute and my ruling is irrevocable. The Forest will speak first.”</p><p>“What?” she was unsure if she had said it or only thought it or if that even mattered. She heard or discontented grumbling from others in the crowd as well.</p><p>The onlookers quieted as the tree, in old woman’s clear and firm but strained voice said,</p><p>“I am Prometheus, an elder of the Bristlecone Pines and a member of the Forest Confederation. We assert that Grass and its accomplice have conspired to eliminate us. Is Grass truly sapient, or just a voracious life form, able to perceive and conceive, but unable to transcend? We appeal to the Community to intervene on our behalf and stop the slaughter before we are no longer able to resist. We have evolved ourselves and our environment, not to master it, but to serve it. We have been good stewards and deserve to thrive and strive.”</p><p>“Grass will respond,” the Adjudicator said and all present focused on the wheat plant.</p><p>Grass and Forests? Sapients? Talking trees and turtles? This was a bad science-fiction-story of a dream. Or… a hallucination. Yes, the spores in her backyard must have become psychoactive and she was tripping! But, even at the height of her one experience with psychoactive mushrooms, she had never lost touch with reality like this. One of those aromatic compounds being emitted by Zoomshoom must be a very potent hallucinogen.</p><p>Lizzie chuckled for the first time in years. As weird as the whole scene was, she was actually enjoying it. She was not the kind to engage in fantasies, but the hallucinogen must have disinhibited her. Adjudicators? Sapient forests and grasses? Why not? But what about humans, Homo Sapiens? She looked around. She saw mammals and mollusks, birds, bees, reptiles and a lot of plant species. But she was the sole human.</p><p>The tuft of wheat at the center of the bubble said in a high-pitched but powerful voice,</p><p>“I don’t know who you are or why you have invaded my planet and climbed inside my mind, but you don’t belong here and I want you to leave! Slaughter? Was it slaughter when the Forest first decimated the grasslands? Is it slaughter when the frogs eat all the flies? No, it is not slaughter. It is the basic law of ecosystem competition. I am Grass, I don’t know what your transcendence is and I don’t care. The future is mine. I am ascendent. Others serve me or suffer.”</p><p>Voices raised around her in agreement or dissent. Wait, the blobby Adjudicator invaded the planet? Was it the Zoomshroom then? Sure, that made sense in a hallucination-sort-of-way. Zoomshroom had come to save the trees from grass! She chuckled again while the plants and animals around her shied away even further.</p><p>“I am an Adjudicator,” the low voice said and stilled the bubble, “I represent the Community, an alliance of sapient life of which Forest is a member. I have not invaded; I have come to listen and speak. It is within my power to impose whatever solution I decide on your planet. As a demonstration, I will cease your respiration.”</p><p>“I… Please…” Grass gasped, its stalks drooping and leaves beginning to wilt.</p><p>“A demonstration,” the Adjudicator said and Grass perked up, “You are young. You have yet to transcend your base desires and embrace the wider universe. You are still driven by the savage laws of ecosystem competition. When you have transcended you will understand.”</p><p>“I’m happy as I am,” Grass said cautiously.</p><p>“You have no idea,” Prometheus, the knobby tree responded, “The paltry joys of domination are but a spark to the blazing flame of transcendence.”</p><p>“I’m happy as I am,” Grass said more forcefully.</p><p>“You may not remain as you are,” the Adjudicator said, “You are in active attack of a member of the Community, you must cease.”</p><p>“It’s not me who attacks the Forest,” said Grass, “It’s the Humans. I lured them along with other large mammals who gave me an edge over the forests. I made my shoots and seeds more nutritious to pull my primate symbionts from tending wild shoots to farming monocultured crops. The humans burned-off more trees than a lightning strike ever could. Then the dangerous human ability to manipulate the material world and their ability to reliably pass new behaviors to subsequent generations tipped the balance for me. Farming concentrated the Humans and they needed more and more wood to build their cities. Like maggots on a carcass, the humans devoured the Forest. In just the last 100 seasons, they have cut the Forest into tattered islands with no power left to resist. I lure them, Adjudicator, but I do not control them. I simply point the way and the humans make their own path.”</p><p>The crowd was murmuring agreement as Lizzie finally figured out what this hallucination was really about. True-enough, forests were in retreat all over the world and grasslands were expanding. True too, that humans were tipping the balance in favor of grass by farming it and leveling forests. And no wonder all of creation agreed. We are tipping the balance away from all of them. What a cool hallucination! A cosmic community, come to Earth to save the trees!</p><p>“They are nothing, Adjudicator,” Grass continued in a conciliatory tone, “Machines with too much purpose and not enough direction. Clever to be sure, but base in their nature and reckless in the extreme. Do as you will with them before they turn on grass as well.”</p><p>“I have listened,” the Adjudicator said calmly, “Now I will speak.”</p><p>The bubble fell to complete silence, every mind focused on the Adjudicator.</p><p>“Both sapiens must be allowed to continue, and without Humans, they can continue. The Forest can strive for greater wisdom and Grass can, in its own time, find transcendence.”</p><p>The crowd, Lizzie included, murmured in agreement. Lizzie would expect nothing less from her hallucination. But ‘without humans?’ What did that mean?</p><p>“Humans will be eliminated,” the Adjudicator said, “I will circulate agents to eliminate them and prevent any further damage. I have ….”</p><p>Fear exploded like a volcano. This is not how her hallucination should go. Eliminating humans like some reviled invasive species?</p><p>“Waaaait!!!” she shouted with all her might, pausing the Adjudicator in mid-sentence. The entire bubble turned toward her and now, somehow, she was at its center. She felt the tremendous terror of all creation looking in at her, hating her and her kind. But more keenly, she felt the injustice of this snap judgment against her people. Her small ears turned bright red and she clasped her hands tightly to keep them from shaking off her wrists.</p><p>“Now, you wait just a minute here!” she screamed. Then, looking around at the hostile crowd, she realized that anger would only prove them all right.</p><p>“Mr. Adjudicator,” she said in as steady a voice as she could manage, “You can’t honestly mean to kill off us humans as if we don’t count. We count! I count!”</p><p>“You are not a sapient, so you are not part of my consideration,” the Adjudicator said plainly.</p><p>“But we are sapient. We’re even called Homo Sapiens. We think just like you!”</p><p>“That’s the silly name you gave yourselves,” said Prometheus, elder of the Bristlecone Pines, “No one else thinks you are sapient. Then gesturing toward the crowd, she continued, “Every organism here thinks, that’s not enough to be sapient. And by the way, they all think you are the greatest threat to them on the planet!”</p><p>The crowd erupted, pounding their limbs, roots and stems together in wild agreement. Lizzie was truly scared now. Even if this was a hallucination, it was a bad one. She felt panic and rage welling up in her. The whole of creation was against her and her people. She couldn’t run, so she would have to fight. A screaming tirade was rising in her throat when the turtle, who had pushed her away, gently touched her trembling hand. They met eyes and Lizzie felt her warmth of kindness flow over her. She clamed.</p><p>With a deep exhale and a sharp breath in, Lizzie forced herself to speak slowly and softly</p><p>“Then, what is enough?”</p><p>“Sapience requires,” responded the gnarled tree, “A mind powerful enough to understand the universe and a will strong enough to transcend low concerns like dominance and participate in the wider unity of being. We created such a mind in our world wide network when you humans still walked on four limbs. We share the Adjudicator’s desire that Grass will develop such a mind as well. But humans? Not likely.”</p><p>“I have a brain,” Lizzie poked her temple and felt her finger actually touch her brain, “It’s a network plenty powerful enough to do whatever you do. Our brains are, are… amazing!”</p><p>A smattering of the larger mammals in the audience voiced agreement. The tree responded in a gentle but condescending voice,</p><p>“Brains have evolved for corporal maintenance and propagation. They are needed for quick reactions and movement and compensate for the paucity of genes in animals. Brains predict and react. They can support survival and possibly thriving, but they will never be sufficient for transcendence. Our network is the substrate, not only of thought, but of communion between individuals. Your brain is not.”</p><p>Lizzie herself had often thought that the mycorrhizal network that links trees and fungus over vast areas was a network to rival the brain, but this was too much.</p><p>“We commune, sure we do,” she said unsure, “we talk, we sing together, we touch each other. We do lots of communing.”</p><p>“Child, my wild, reckless human child,” the tree said, now with no condescension, “You have no idea.”</p><p>“And we commune on the internet,” Lizzie cut in, “We link all our knowledge together into one big network that anyone can use.” It was a last ditch effort she knew.</p><p>“Of what does this network consist?” asked the Adjudicator, “I accessed all networks and found nothing like that.”</p><p>“Consist?” Lizzie said, “I don’t know, it consists of wires and radio waves and computers and keyboards and data and storage and … and more.”</p><p>“Those are physical, not biological structures. They cannot constitute a transcending network,” the Adjudicator said, “I am entwined in your nervous system. Please think about these physical networks and I will observe.”</p><p>Think about what? She was a Biologist not an engineer. But she thought the best she could. It’s tools, isn’t it?. Yeah, tools. Physical things. Plants use chemical things. They are masters of chemistry, producing inside themselves whatever they need to survive. They also use biology, they ally themselves with other organisms to survive and thrive. Humans are masters of the physical world. We create tools from the world around us to survive and thrive. But did that tree say strive? She took a wild leap,</p><p>“I strive,” she said, “Not all of us do. There’s a lot of lazy people, but I strive. I do. I strive to understand the world, I strive to understand our place in it, I strive every day to get past the petty stuff that stops my family, my town, heck the whole world, from seeing what a wonderful place we have.”</p><p>What else could she say when even grass was smarter than humans? What a disappointing hallucination. Maybe we are an invasive species. It wouldn’t be the first time she had thought it. But she felt exposed and afraid. Fear rose again and she wanted nothing more than to take an ax to that sassy old tree.</p><p>“Very instructive,” the Adjudicator said, “I chose this human to represent the group, but I probed many others. I observe what they think and also what they believe but did not think. Yours is a different kind of intellect. The Community is full of organisms that have linked together biologically to transcend. Those organisms, me included, do not need wires and waves. We have command of nature itself and need no external tools. “</p><p>“Please Adjudicator,” said the gnarled Promethius, “You must neutralize the Humans. They will surely destroy us.”</p><p>The crowd raised voices in agreement. Clearly, there was no great love of humanity in this crowd.</p><p>“We don’t have to destroy you!’ Lizzie cried, “We learn fast, just let us know what you need. We can be different.”</p><p>But even as she said it, she was sure it wasn’t true. When did humans ever change?</p><p>“Yes,” said the Adjudicator, “A conundrum. This human does strive, even if in an infantile way. Her people join together, but in a far too rudimentary way to transcend. Could the Humans use their manipulation of the material world to create a network powerful enough to transcend? In the fullness of time, possibly. Are they a clear and present threat to a member of the Community? Yes. Are they likely to cease that threat voluntarily? No.”</p><p>“Wait, wait, wait!” screamed Lizzie, “Don’t kill us, please. We can learn, we can learn.”</p><p>“I have listened,” the Adjudicator said calmly, “Now I will speak. The Human’s ability to manipulate the material world may or may not represent a new way of transformation — that is yet to be seen. Human manipulation of the physical world emerged an instant ago. Still, it is valuable to see where this ability might lead. On the other hand, humans are a definite threat to the Forest.”</p><p>“And us too!” trumpeted an elephant. The crowd roared in agreement.</p><p>The bubble flashed deep blue, soothing the crowd.</p><p>“I am speaking,” the Adjudicator said flatly and all conversation stopped, “Why are humans such a threat? It is because of fear.”</p><p>The comment stopped all other thoughts in Lizzie’s mind. Fear? She might have expected the answer to be aggression, greed, meanness or even love of family, but fear?</p><p>“Humans fear the dark, so they blot it out with bright lights. They fear other life forms, so they gird themselves in clothes, houses and cities to keep you out. They fear what may lurk in the forest, so they clear the forest. They fear death, so they will do anything to eliminate it. And more than anything, they fear each other. They fear that the anger and aggression they themsleves feel will be directed back at them.</p><p>This human,” the Adjudicator focused all minds on Lizzie, “fears the judgement of others, so she tries to convince herself that she does not need them.”</p><p>“No I …,” Lizzie said, but the truth of it made her trail off.</p><p>“Fear leads to anger which leads to aggression. Fear leads to denial and allows humans to do irreparable harm while believing they are doing good. Humans have always been prey. Like a rabbit, they run zigzags trying to avoid predators that are just one wrong move away. But humans, admittedly impressive, ability to manipulate the material world, has suddenly made them an apex predator. Too quickly, they have gained the ability to dominate every ecosystem on the planet. Every organism here is at their mercy.”</p><p>“It is true,” Grass said, “Humans have been our servants, but they are quickly becoming our masters. They will turn on us too.”</p><p>“Well …,” began Lizzie but found she had nothing to say.</p><p>“Here is my judgement,” the Adjudicator said, “It is final and irrevocable. I will not eradicate humans. I will suppress their fear. With fear removed, they will be free to act like predators and cease reacting like prey. This I will do until human evolution catches up with human ingenuity. Until humans themselves realize that there is nothing to be afraid of.”</p><p>***</p><p>Lizzie woke face-down on her back deck with a sneeze and a coughing fit. On all fours, she spat out the stringy threads in her mouth and sneezed again. She stayed like that for a long time feeling hung-over and trying to recapture the dream she had awakened from. The Zoomshroom was wilting everywhere in the back yard. She began to remember the bizarre delusion. Or was it? The Zoomshroom was beginning to die-back everywhere in the back yard and she felt for her jeweler’s loop to have a closer look. She found a clump of mushrooms that were still alive and leaned in for a closer look. The smell of mustard had been replaced by something more like cloves. She inhaled deeply, forgot her distrust of the world, and considered how best to tell them all what she had seen and learned.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=755c68dd3134" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Cathy is just Bad]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@bobboiko/cathy-is-just-bad-3a7d07c78b90?source=rss-02be1be414b2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3a7d07c78b90</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[tv-adaptation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[john-steinbeck]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[east-of-eden]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[morals-and-values]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[zoe-kazan]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Bob Boiko ]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 15 Oct 2026 21:37:47 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-15T21:37:47.293Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Zoe Kazan’s East of Eden adaptation weakens Steinbeck’s moral structure by recasting Cathy as a victimized, psychologically explained character rather than an embodiment of evil.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/294/1*mPvY6b6XxNmik_P6Y6Jdwg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Have you seen the new Netflix version of John Steinbeck’s East of Eden? Overall it’s pretty good. Unlike many TV adaptations, it sticks pretty close to the book. It covers the full range of the book and the events are all clearly recognizable from the book.</p><p>But then there’s Cathy. About the time she is lured into the brambles, I started to ask myself,</p><p>“Did that happen in the book?”</p><p>By the time she is telling her boss Faye about Alice in Wonderland, I started saying,</p><p>“Something’s off.”</p><p>In the book, Cathy is just bad.</p><p><em>“It is my belief that Cathy Ames was born with the tendencies, or lack of them, which drove and forced her all of her life…She was not like other people, never was from birth. “</em></p><p>Steinbeck does not psychologize, but if he did, he might call Cathy a sociopath or even a psychopath. In the Netflix adaptation, creator Zoe Kazan does psychologize. She wants us to believe that Cathy is bad because she was abused as a child. For Steinbeck, Cathy is a perpetrator; for Kazan, she’s a victim.</p><p>I actually liked actress Florence Pugh’s performance. And if I had never read the book I would have believed it. She totally nailed a Cathy that is both criminally cruel and bottomlessly vulnerable. Her horrified but tender expression upon meeting her ‘good’ son Aron, for example, is deeply affective and effective.</p><p>I don’t fault Kazan or any adapter for reinterpreting, reimagining, or even mincing the original. In the 1955 East of Eden with James Dean, the director, Zoe Kazan’s grandfather, Elia Kazan, takes large liberties with the book. But that’s OK; it’s a great movie.</p><p>Because Zoe Kazan’s TV version is so faithful to the flow and events of the book, when she gives us a very different Cathy, it sticks out like a sore thumb.</p><p>In interviews, Zoe Kazan has justified her interpretation by saying that Steinbeck leaves open the reasons why Cathy is so bad. I’m not so sure of that. I think he is pretty clear about why Cathy is bad. More importantly, the reason for her evil is important to the coherence of the whole book.</p><p><strong>Let’s look at the book.</strong></p><p>Steinbeck is being nothing if not biblical. He works off of the idea of original sin. Because of Eve’s fateful act, humans will be forever born damaged, divided, and vulnerable to evil. East of Eden is the story of how people deal with the good and evil they are born with — Timshel.</p><p><em>But the Hebrew word, the word timshel — ‘Thou mayest’ — that gives a choice. It might be the most important word in the world. That says the way is open. That throws it right back on a man. For if ‘Thou mayest’ — it is also true that ‘Thou mayest not.”</em></p><p>It’s like Steimbeck is saying, “My characters are born good or bad. Let’s watch as they decide what to do with that.”</p><p>Interestingly, the characters born good always make the right choice, while the bad ones can go either way.</p><p>Let’s start with the older brothers, Adam and Charles. Adam is born good and always chooses good. He has other interesting flaws, but evil is not one of them. Charles is born bad. He struggles to be good, but fails first in his cruelty to his brother Adam and second, when he gives in to the seduction of Adam’s wife, who is, of course, Cathy. Neither Adam nor Charles transcends their birth.</p><p>The younger brothers, Aron and Cal, struggle too. Like Adam, Aron is repulsed by evil and always turns toward good. Like his father and uncle, he stays true to his birth.</p><p>Cal is the only brother to transcend his birth. Born bad, he can be cruel and spiteful, but he feels guilt for his transgressions. He turns toward evil, but the love of his father (read God) helps him belly-up and start choosing good. Both Charles and Cal covet their brother’s wife. But while Charles gives in to temptation, Cal waits until his brother is dead to move in on Abra.</p><p>Interestingly, while Cathy, the object of Charles’ desire, tempts him toward evil, Abra, Cal’s beloved, tempts him toward good. She understands the balance of good and evil in herself and guides Cal towards that same balance.</p><p><em>“Pure!” said Abra. “Just absolutely pure. Nothing but pure — never a bad thing. I’m not like that.”</em></p><p><em>“Nobody is,” said Lee.</em></p><p>So, we have the good brothers, who are just good and the bad brothers, one who chooses to stay bad and the other who chooses to be good.</p><p>Then there is Cathy. The bad brothers are not overly evil. They don’t kill or dominate or have naughty sex. They are, you might say, run of the mill bad. Cathy is criminally bad. Cathy does kill, she does dominate and she has very naughty sex. Like Charles and Cal, she is born bad. And not only does she not turn away, she embraces and refines her badness. To be sure, Steinbeck gives wisps of guilt to Cathy near the end of the book. She is haunted by her deeds and she takes her own life. But there is no redemption, no moment like Cal’s where she is redeemed by love. Cathy neither seeks nor receives forgiveness.</p><p><strong>Now let’s look at the TV show.</strong></p><p>As I’ve said, the events are the same. The depiction of the brothers and their struggles with good and evil are also very close to the book. Only Cathy changes.</p><p>In the book she is the anchor of evil, the one who you judge the other characters against. On TC, Kazan blunts every aspect of her evil making her instead misunderstood, sympathetic and a victim of circumstance. When she shoots Adam, her face betrays sadness and regret. It’s almost like he forced her to shoot him. When she meets her sons, her face betrays the same sadness and regret. In the end, she is less haunted by her deeds than regretful of them. She kills herself in an attempt to literally shrink away from her deeds.</p><p>We are led to believe that even as she keeps being bad, there is hope because she recognizes and regrets the impact she has on others. Kazan shows us that Cathy admits her sins even if she never asks for forgiveness.</p><p><strong>So, what’s the problem?</strong></p><p>My problem is not that Zoe Kazan’s interpretation of Cathy is bad or unfaithful, it is that it fundamentally alters the narrative framework of the original story.</p><p>Steinbeck sets out fixed moral goalposts. Cathy is the epitome of evil and Aron is the epitome of good. By putting Cathy somewhere in between good and evil, the moral framework becomes untethered. The book, so morally anchored, becomes the TV show, so morally relative.</p><p>In life, I side with the more relativistic Kazan. I don’t care for moral absolutes, I believe someone can be turned bad, and I believe no one is purely evil. But art is not life. There is a coherence and beauty to a carefully crafted and internally complete fictional world. Whether you like it or not, Steinbeck creates a world where evil and good exist.</p><p>I just don’t think the fictional world built by Steinbeck permits the Cathy built by Zoe Kazan.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3a7d07c78b90" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Truth, Fiction and Stories Told]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@bobboiko/truth-fiction-and-stories-told-397c9f8e30dc?source=rss-02be1be414b2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/397c9f8e30dc</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[biography]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fiction]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nonfiction]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[stranger-things]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[netflix]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Bob Boiko ]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 22 Apr 2026 15:42:37 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-04-22T15:42:37.781Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YHxAjgl_sRgRR1VkZEzFaA.png" /><figcaption>Prompt by Bob, image by ChatGPT</figcaption></figure><p>Seems pretty straight-forward, no? Fiction is made up and non fiction, like by definition, is real. If I start reading too much of one, I start craving the other. Too much Sci-fi and I start wanting a good biography or natural science read. Same thing with video. Too much history or geography or science on YouTube and I start wanting Netflix.</p><p>But the more I poke at this distinction, the shadier it gets.</p><p>I quit consuming a work of fiction when it lacks the ‘ring of the real.’ Just get me saying, “Wait, that would never happen!” or “Who would actually say that!” And, I’m out of there.</p><p>Netflix, and all other media outlets for that matter, are full of fiction that rings false. Strangely, many people don’t seem to notice or care. Look no further than ‘Stranger Things’ to see how a patently absurd plot can still be loved by millions of people. I guess those millions are a lot more credulous than me. Do you know what ‘Jump the shark’ means? It comes from an episode of the TV show ‘Happy Days’ that went too far for fans when a main character jumps over a shark on water skis. Ever heard of ‘the willing suspension of disbelief?’ It’s when you put aside your disbelief and just go with it. Jumping the shark is the point at which consumers are no longer willing to suspend disbelief.</p><p>Don’t get me wrong, I’m all for suspending disbelief. In fact, I love to suspend my disbelief. As long as I don’t spot a shark, I am happy to approach every fictional story with my beliefs in play. The famous double-edged philosopher Ludwig Wittgenstein said we create meaning in play and I believe it.</p><p>For me, fiction has to be ‘real-ish,’ or I won’t play. My favorite fiction goes right up to the edge of plausibility. Then, just when I’m about to stop playing, it all makes sense. In Stephen King’s ‘The Life of Chuck,’ California literally falls into the sea and the stars in the sky wink out of existence as a couple sits on lawn chairs in their backyard. But, in the end, it comes together into a satisfying, entirely believable, conclusion. That’s good fiction.</p><p>Of course fiction has to start with a good story, but so does non-fiction.</p><p>I pick up most non fiction because I’m interested in the subject. I put down non fiction when it has a bad story. The story is the ‘who, what and why.’ Who is this story about, what is the story about and why should I care?</p><p>Bad non fiction can have lots of ‘what.’ I put down ‘Benjamin Franklin: An American Life’ by Walter Isaacson. A whole life’s worth of ‘what’ happened but I got no ‘who’ and no ‘why’. Everyone knows Franklin was a super-interesting guy, but the book gave me no deeper insight into him. And, I never found any bigger message in the book. I’m not saying you can’t find a ‘who’ and a ‘why’ in Isaacson’s book, just that I didn’t.</p><p>Bad non fiction may be fact-filled but it lacks imagination or purpose beyond the facts. The facts may be groundbreaking, I may need to know them. Those facts may even be on the next test. But regardless, my eyes glaze over and I put it down. Just about every nature documentary falls into this category. In fact, what do movie directors do when they want to signal dry and boring? They put a nature show on in the background. For extra effect they throw in an erudite British voiceover.</p><p>On the other hand, have you ever read ‘Team of Rivals,’ by Joyce Kerns Goodwin? It’s about Lincoln and his cabinet. I loved it because of its ‘who’ and ‘why.’ It gets behind the facts to the man himself. Plus, it has a great ‘why.’ It convincingly asserts that managing a diversity of opinion is what made Lincoln great.</p><p>The ’who’ of the narrative doesn’t need to be a person. One of my favorite non fiction movies (also called documentaries) is “My Octopus Teacher.’ The ‘who’ is an octopus, of course. If you have even half a heart, you end up caring more about her than you do about most people. And the movie has an awesome ‘why.’ Octopuses are people too.</p><p>I just finished ‘The Power Broker’ by Robert Caro about the life and legacy of Robert Moses. Man, was there a whole lot of ‘what’ in there. He did a lot. But what kept me reading for well over 1000 pages was not the ‘what.’ In fact, the ‘what’ was totally overwhelming and all started to blur. What kept me reading was the ‘who.’ This was a complicated man, driven beyond measure, disciplined beyond the means of normal men, single-minded to a fault, fantastically brilliant and amazingly visionary. But he was brutal and out of touch. He used any and every means to get his way and left a trail of broken opponents in his wake. I kept reading because I could never figure out if he was a good guy or a bad guy!</p><p>My favorite hard science book is ‘Behavioral Neurobiology: The Cellular Organization of Natural Behavior,’ by Thomas Carew. Geeky, right? I mention it because I loved the ‘what’ of this book, but the reason it’s still on my shelf is because of the ‘who.’ It’s about bats, toads, owls and insects. It put me inside them; it made me feel like I understood them. I could see how they were like and unlike us. It took the dry science and turned it into a compelling story!</p><p>The ‘why’ of ‘The Power Broker’ was icing on an already delicious cake. It gave me a deep perspective on questions such as: ‘Can really big things be accomplished without an asshole in charge?’ ‘How did cars come to dominate transportation so thoroughly?’ and ‘How does a political machine work and what can stop it?’ In short, it really made me think!</p><p>Similarly, in ‘Behavioral Neurobiology,’ there was a point and it was a good one. We (the big, inclusive, all nature we) are wired to perceive the world in similar ways. Owls are amazing at making spatial maps, Bats, of course, use sound exquisitely to locate objects. Their superpowers show us just how perception works for us and them.</p><p>Have you noticed something weird here?</p><p>It’s the made up part, not the facts, that make me want to consume non fiction. And it’s the realness of fiction that compels me. Carew doesn’t know what made Moses tick, He made that part up. Kerns Goodwin doesn’t know what made Lincoln great, she made that up. But the made up part is what made me read. The made-up parts of ‘Stranger Things’ should have been more real, while the made-up parts of ‘The Life of Chuck’ were tantalizingly real.</p><p>So what’s the difference between fiction and non fiction? I have a friend writing a book that stays very close to his own life. Is it fiction or non fiction? After a lot of discussion, the best we can come up with is that you are allowed to make up facts in fiction but you have to stick to what actually happened in non fiction. But even that is shaky. Gore Vidal said, “History is idle gossip about a happening whose truth is lost the instant it has taken place.” He questioned whether there are any real historical facts at all. I wouldn’t go that far, but I would say there is a fuzzy zone, not a line, between the facts in fiction and non fiction. Even a fact you experienced has to go through a transformation from what you sensed, to what you perceived, to what you thought, to what you remember to what you ended up writing. That’s a long journey during which a fact can contort and conform.</p><p>Maybe the difference between fiction and non fiction is in the intent of the author, not in the words. If you intend to create a truthful recreation of the facts as you know them, call it non fiction. If you intend to ignore or subvert the facts as you know them, call it fiction. If you elaborate, enhance, extend or expand the facts, well then you decide.</p><p>So maybe there’s a continuum between fact and fiction. And just like any continuum (good and evil, left and right wing politics, sickness and health), there is no single point where one becomes the other. But there is a thread that runs right through fiction and non non fiction. They are both stories.</p><p>So how about this historical fiction about non fiction;</p><p>In the beginning was the story. People told them constantly to create the threads that bind societies. There were good stories and bad stories. The good ones were about something, they gave you information that sounded plausible. But they were also about someone. You could relate them to yourself and climb inside someone or something outside of yourself. And that felt good. Plus, they had a point. You knew or felt something new after hearing them. Some bad stories were just not plausible. In no universe, real or imagined, could you believe that they happened. Other bad stories were simply boring. They didn’t make you care.</p><p>Much later, people started claiming that certain stories were true and others were made up. But people are smarter than that. They would reply to a purportedly true story, “You just made that up. There are no microscopic animalcules floating around in the air and water! The universe was made by God, not some big bang!”</p><p>Or, to a purportedly made-up story they would say, “I could totally see how that could happen and I’m gonna make sure it doesn’t happen to me! I feel like I know that person you were telling me about! You sure that didn’t really happen? But it could, couldn’t it?”</p><p>And to all stories they would say, “Wow, the truth is stranger than fiction and, you know what? Fiction only tells a deeper truth!”</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=397c9f8e30dc" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[LLMs killed the CMS Core]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@bobboiko/llms-killed-the-cms-core-f3e5390db95c?source=rss-02be1be414b2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f3e5390db95c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[content-management-system]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ai]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[prompt-engineering]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cms]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Bob Boiko ]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 01 Apr 2026 20:27:02 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-04-01T20:27:02.804Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>It’s time to rethink our entire approach to content systems</em></p><p>Twenty-Five years ago, I helped start the field of content management with my book, ‘Content Management Bible,’ That book was way ahead of its time. Now it’s way behind.</p><p>My 1300-page book was written on this premise:</p><ul><li>Data is rows and columns of chopped up snippets of information. It’s boring to read, but it’s the only thing computer programs can work with.</li><li>Content is the MOST interesting stuff to read, watch, and listen to or otherwise consume.</li><li>The job of the content manager is to augment the interesting content with boring data so that dumb computer programs can help us manage and distribute it.</li></ul><p>Back then, computers were really just math machines with no way to deal with the complexity of content. While people have no problem understanding the structure of, say, a story, computers were useless. As everybody knows, texts have sections and subsections, movies have scenes, songs have stanzas. And, of course, that is just the very tip of the structural iceberg. Stories, in text or video have a narrative structure, characters and settings. Spoken or written language has syntactical and semantic structure. Images have compositional and color structure. Computers could easily detect and work with the simple structure of rows and columns in a database, but could do little to detect and work with structures that mean the most to us as people.</p><p>So, to allow dumb computers to deal with smart complex content we augmented it with metadata. The metadata, which could fit into rows and columns, acted like the tag you might attach to your baggage. The bag-tag lists the essential facts about your luggage so the airlines can identify and route it. Metadata lists the essential facts about a piece of content so that the computer can identify and route it. Metadata came in these big forms:</p><ul><li><strong>Content types</strong> that broadly identify a piece of content as, say, an article or product brief.</li><li><strong>Taxonomies </strong>which are lists of words or phrases that further identify what a piece of content is or is about like say fashion or sports.</li><li><strong>Markup </strong>which wraps-around a piece of text within a piece of content and identifies it as, say, a title or a person.</li></ul><p>The job of the information architect (a term that also came into use about the same time) was to figure out the markup and taxonomies and apply them to a corpus of content. The job of a content management system was to collect, manage and publish content based on its metadata.</p><p>A lot of us spent the last 25 years developing content systems based on this approach. Plus an entire industry sprung up with software, jobs, best practices and standardized terminology to accommodate the ever growing need to harness and deliver content to the Web and beyond.</p><p>In 2002, my company created this 2X4 foot poster to try and sort out all the parts and interactions in an enterprise content management system. As you can see, it’s a complex process with lots of people and software involved.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*HTeFtE4Schs8qq2ZBUy9ig.png" /><figcaption>Design by Allen Matsumoto, content by Bob Boiko</figcaption></figure><p>Unfortunately, there are significant problems with this approach:</p><ul><li>We needed hard-to-find talents to figure out and build these systems.</li><li>We needed a lot of effort to augment incoming content with metadata.</li><li>We needed a lot of additional work to make even simple changes to the metadata of the system.</li><li>The amount of metadata you could reasonably add to a corpus was often less than what you needed to customize its delivery to various outlets.</li><li>The systems needed to help automate the process were expensive and needed a lot of customization.</li></ul><p>But we soldiered on even though our goals far exceeded our budgets. Even with all those constraints, we did a lot of awesome work. Unfortunately, we did a lot more barely satisfactory work.</p><p>That was then. How about now?</p><p>In just the last few years, LLM’s have undermined the basic assumption that content has to be augmented with metadata in order to be managed by computers. Systems that use LLMs can now, or will very soon be able to:</p><ul><li><strong>Make content types obsolete</strong>. In some cases it doesn’t matter whether a piece of content is an article or product brief if it is responsive to someone’s need for it. In other cases, a user can decide that they want articles and the system will find them on the fly</li><li><strong>Make classical taxonomies obsolete</strong>. Where once a person was needed to figure out descriptive terms and apply them to content, now the AI system can categorize content by phrase if needed or just find the right content based on a prompt you supply.</li><li><strong>Make markup obsolete</strong>. No one is needed to tag content with identifiers if the AI system can figure out what a title or person is from the context of the content.</li></ul><p>I need do no more than show you a simple ChatGPT prompt and response to illustrate this:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*eIZ0nBXCkSoSGhMz_pe5QQ.png" /></figure><p>I can’t begin to tell you what it would have taken for a content management system to just format this screen, let alone ingest and augment the content it contains, let alone customize the presentation to the user’s request, let alone merge so many separate content sources into such well-structured and organized paragraphs. But more specifically:</p><ul><li>No content types were needed.</li><li>No taxonomies were needed.</li><li>No markup was needed</li></ul><p>The system behind this screen, simply scraped lots and lots of content and then used an LLM to dig through it and format a compelling presentation!</p><p>The writing is clearly on the wall. LLM-based systems will replace classical content management systems and make content management cheaper, more scalable and much more personalized.</p><p>I recently oversaw the creation of a system of this sort. It wasn’t easy, we still needed top-notch programmers and lots of AI expertise. But that will change. But even given the early state of AI, we built the system at a fraction of the cost of building and maintaining a standard CMS.</p><p>So what would an AI-based CMS look like?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hdAZ5CTKgoe4ReYIKpY_Qw.png" /></figure><p><strong>Content Acquisition</strong></p><ul><li>Authors focus on writing or otherwise creating small, well-targeted chunks of content.</li><li>Similarly, existing sources of content are processed to create small, well targeted chunks of content.</li><li>Today, it is best practice to add a small amount of metadata to each content chunk during authoring or transfer, but that may well change soon.</li></ul><p><strong>Content storage</strong></p><ul><li>Each chunk is run through an embedding model, similar to an LLM, that encodes the content as a set of numbers (called a vector).</li><li>The content vectors are stored in a specialized database called a vector database where they are indexed just as they would be in a normal database.</li></ul><p><strong>User experience</strong></p><ul><li>The end user is presented with a normal html page with links, textboxes and content areas filled with content.</li><li>The content areas that are filled by one or more queries that run when the page loads.</li><li>The text boxes allow the user to specify more precisely what they want to see.</li><li>The links take the user to other pages that have their own links, content areas and queries.</li></ul><p><strong>Content retrieval</strong></p><ul><li>Queries are run by some part of an end-user page.</li><li>Queries are turned into embeddings (using the same embedding model as the content) so they can be compared to the vectors in the database.</li><li>The vector database runs a query and retrieves content that matches the query.</li></ul><p><strong>Content augmentation</strong></p><ul><li>The vector results of the query are merged with user information and other standardized text to create a prompt for an LLM.</li><li>The LLM responds to the prompt with text and other media that is ready to be displayed.</li></ul><p><strong>Content Display</strong></p><ul><li>The merged and formatted for the various content areas on the page.</li><li>The text can contain any form of media as well as links to other pages in the system.</li><li>The user clicks a link to begin the process again</li></ul><p>Of course there are a lot of refinements needed to make this a viable production system. Like any system, an AI system has to be secure, scalable, and resource optimized. But I hope you can see that the process above is significantly simpler and much more flexible than a standard CMS. The cost of calls to an LLM is what mostly drives the cost of the system I proposed. So, the cost rises with scale more steeply than a standard CMS. Plus, the cost of LLM calls may actually rise in the short-term as the true cost of AI computing is passed onto consumers. However, as AI methods and tools advance, the cost of calling an LLM, or whatever comes next) will fall.</p><p>We invented the classical approach to content management because there was only one game in town. If you wanted to use computers for content, you needed to dumb-down the complex structure of content and use the simplistic data technologies. But now there is another way. LLMs operate on content in its native form. Little or no effort is needed to prepare content. LLMs can, amazingly, calculate directly on content alleviating most or all of the need for metadata. And LLMs are just the first wave. Other content technologies are bound to follow that further simplify content management. For sure the wisdom we have gained over 25 years of data-oriented content management is still valid. But we would be wise now to recognize that content management possibilities are expanding well beyond what we could have imagined even a few years ago</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f3e5390db95c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Worry less about AI and more about why we invented it]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@bobboiko/worry-less-about-ai-and-more-about-why-we-invented-it-e46028e3f91d?source=rss-02be1be414b2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e46028e3f91d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ai]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[commentary]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[effort]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[automation]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Bob Boiko ]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 29 Mar 2026 15:19:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-03-29T15:19:57.997Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="Generated with no effort by Google Gemini" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*VLUKEklwm4bAjtkYh1VSVQ.png" /></figure><p><em>AI is beside the point. It’s just the latest attempt to automate human effort with machines</em></p><p>Automation is the stuff we do to reduce the need for human effort. There’s no better example than China’s ‘dark factories,’ where no lights are needed because no people are needed to create products. But take a step back and you may notice that dark factories are just the latest salvo in our forever war against human effort.</p><p>Call it toil, exertion, labor, work, energy, drudgery, struggle, travail or drudery. Human effort is all the stuff that takes energy, it’s physical or mental work. We don’t want to do it but we have to do it anyway. Would you like to mow the lawn with your hands? Of course not, it’s too much effort. That’s why we invented push mowers. Don’t like pushing that mower back and forth? That’s why we invented gas ones — less effort. Is any kind of mowing too much effort? Maybe you need a fully automated mower, just tap your phone and the lawn is trimmed. We hate effort and we’ve been at war with it since we invented the first tool.</p><p>Is it a just war? Arguably so, at least so far. With our triumph over toil has come an unprecedented advance in human health, comfort and leisure. I’m relaxed, well fed and able to put my time into writing, not out finding food, because of automation.</p><p>But there’s been significant collateral damage in this war. With each advance in automation, we get more results for less effort but with each step the value of human effort has been diminished. With an automatic lawn mower, I’m not needed at all. But neither are the millions of people who make a living mowing lawns.</p><p>Has the collateral damage been worth the cost? Arguably so, at least so far. The people displaced by automation have always found something else to do. But will that always be the case? And how much automation is too much?</p><p>Imagine a tribe of proto-humans running-down a gazelle, tackling it and killing it with their bare hands. That’s a lot of effort. Even after the kill, half of them have to keep other scavengers away while the other half bite through tough skin, rip away a chunk of meat, chew the gristly meat and choke it down. The gazelle keeps them alive, but it’s not at all sure that the calories from the meat are more than the calories needed to kill and consume it.</p><p>Fast-forward a few millennia and the descendants of these hardy people are a bit more advanced. They don’t run-down their prey, they shoot it from a distance with arrows. They don’t have to protect their kill from predators, fire does that for them. They even get more calories (and better taste) by roasting the meat before eating it. The strongest runners, top-status in the past, have been downgraded and made redundant.</p><p>Fast-forward again, and farming and animal domestication have gotten big. Most people work in the fields. More food through increasing automation but more human labor downgraded by animal labor and tools like the plow.</p><p>Jump again in time and industrialization has taken hold. Ever heard the story of John Henry? He was, as the song goes, a “steel-driving man.” His size and strength made him a king among railroad workers. As with untold generations before him, size, endurance and muscle mass were the coin of his realm. In the story, John Henry beats a steam engine at hammering rail spikes, but works himself to death in the process. John’s muscles won the battle but lost the war against automation. Strong men have been losing ground ever since.</p><p>Automation downgraded physical agility too. Take John Henry’s sister Jane. She was the world’s best weaver, more dexterous and clever with yarn than anyone in the world. Imagine her dying just like her brother in a contest with a mechanical loom.</p><p>Automation conquered physical effort then came for mental effort. Ever seen the movie, “Hidden Figures?” It’s a true story and a good one. On the surface it’s about racism and sexism, but look deeper and the story is about automation. At the beginning of the movie, computers are people. They sit all day and do calculations on rows and columns of numbers. By the end, they are replaced by an actual computer. And even though a human ends up saving the day, the writing is on the wall. Another success for automation, another loss for human effort. Machines automate muscle, computers automate brains.</p><p>But haven’t there always been more new places to put effort than is lost to automation? In “Hidden Figures,” the humans go on to be programmers. There are a lot more programmers now than there were human calculators then. Strong runners, hunters, farm laborers, weavers, even steel-driving men have gone on to other professions where their talent still counts or moved on to other profitable pursuits. They were downgraded and probably a little disgruntled, but at least they had somewhere else to go. But is that always going to be true?</p><p>To date, yeah, the job pie has only gotten bigger. More farmers were needed than gatherers, more factory workers than farmers and more service workers than factory workers. But the automation end-game is not to replace some people, but all people. And that end-game is already in sight. It’s not only the Chinese dark factories that are human-less. Farming, driving, mining, warehousing, construction and even illustration are closing in on that strange golden ring — no people needed.</p><p>Sure, you may say, but aren’t there always going to be jobs building and maintaining automation machines. Yes, but far fewer. Chinese dark factories need 1/10 the number of people that conventional factories do. But haven’t people like me who use their brains, not their muscles, done alright? So far yes, but computers have already come for our brains in fields like calculation, tabulation, tracking, monitoring and customer interactions, and it’s not stopping there.</p><p>Enter AI. It’s new but not different. Like the plow, it saves labor. Like the loom it relieves humans of burdensome, repetitive work. What’s new about AI is not that it’s downgrading humans, but who is being devalued. Strong and agile physical labor has been on the run for centuries from mechanical automation. Menial mental labor has been under attack by computers for 50 years. AI simply targets higher-order mental labor. The goal of AI is the same as all automation: get rid of people.</p><p>So, worry less about AI and more about our relentless pursuit of automation. Sure, it got us to where we are, but where is it taking us now?</p><p>There have been a million tears shed over the “I” in AI. Yes, computers will be smarter than us. But so what? It’s the “A” in AI that we should be more concerned with. Why do we feel the need to have artificial thinking? We have a tremendous surplus of natural thinking. The minds of most of the people of the world lie virtually un-tapped. And don’t we have an equally large surplus of strength and agility. It’s been building up for centuries. So, why exactly do we need to get rid of all those people? You can certainly blame capitalism, science, technology or evolution. I blame the ancient human will to put in less effort. That’s what we have to overcome if we want to truly thrive. I sympathize with the war effort. I’m as lazy as the next guy. Sometimes any effort is too much. But I have another side, the one that feel fulfilled by digging a ditch or struggling for days to write an essay on struggling.</p><p>Somewhere along the line, automation turned from a net positive for humans to a net negative. Fire and arrows were good, maybe even steel-driving machines were good. But dark factories taking away the first stepping stone toward a better future for the poor? Are they good? How about self-driving trucks, killing a thriving trucking culture and pushing the drivers down, not up the economic ladder. And how about automated doctors, actors, artists, priests? We don’t seem to realize that we won the war against effort long ago and now have to make peace with exertion. What’s so bad, after all, with exerting yourself to get what you want? We evolved to equate effort with purpose. “No pain no gain” is built in.</p><p>The kind of AI we have now is pretty basic, but we are only just beginning. Each new advance targets the next level of effort. Imagine 100 years in the future. Can we have a world where we don’t need to put out any effort what-so-ever to survive? Sure. Will it be like the usual dystopian vision of the seething masses in the streets and the elites high above in the clouds? Maybe. But only if the elites have not been downgraded as well by their own automations!</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e46028e3f91d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Names make the world go round]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@bobboiko/names-make-the-world-go-round-f7d8dae2e0eb?source=rss-02be1be414b2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f7d8dae2e0eb</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[information-architecture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[names-and-naming]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Bob Boiko ]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 28 Mar 2026 23:31:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-03-30T14:32:02.068Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Excerpted from <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Information-Architecture-Info-Out-infoOut/dp/1549682768/ref=sr_1_3?crid=3QEBUDZO7S28U&amp;dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.ITiyV1Ir-QeZAji8Np8m2NuwZoeaa2bUdJ7D_zZTLBxmSGz053M1R31SPD5w2M7NUB2je-FJsTyEsJNdTw2ZcEU0qSHyPR2cvQFl3ioXrkc.Pt2l-WxlniogBUofietVfmX32FHUi6k8E157EAp2lSU&amp;dib_tag=se&amp;keywords=boiko+info+out&amp;qid=1774721540&amp;sprefix=boiko+infoout%2Caps%2C162&amp;sr=8-3">Information Architecture from the Info Out</a> by Bob Boiko<br><a href="https://youtu.be/Fc3_ELPlZX0?si=UHZwjT8Rt1snqoxd">Watch the video version</a><br>See a more well-formated <a href="https://storage.googleapis.com/bobboikostuff/names/names.html">version</a></p><p><em>Names are the basis of all information systems. They are the containers that hold meaning and make it useful. Information architects create information structures. Information structures are systems of names.</em></p><p>If you are not a good namer, don’t become an information architect.</p><blockquote><em>Names provide simple, memorable, useful containers in which to collect otherwise disparate knowledge</em></blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*SLEwbkM0KUQQJIVB.jpg" /></figure><p>But let me be begin by being clear about the word “name” itself and how it relates to similar words.</p><p><strong>Names vs. terms</strong>. I could have used the word “term” in this instead of “name.” Both terms and names are one or more words that describe or define a thing. I chose to use “name” because it is less technical and I like its connotations much more. “Term” is a little too dry and technical to elicit the magic and wonder I want to convey.</p><p>“Term” is the “term of art” used in the information discipline for the names in a list. For example, you would say that an index or taxonomy has terms, not names. In speech and writing, “term” fits better than “name” in certain contexts. For example, it is more natural to say “that is not an accepted term,” than “that is not an accepted name.”</p><p>In most cases, the words “term” and “name” are fairly interchangeable. But even where the word “term” is preferred in English, I generally use “name.” However, sometimes “term” is just so right for a sentence that I use it rather than “name.” But you should always see my use of the word “term” as being imbued with all the qualities of a name.</p><p>Here’s how “name,” as I use it, contrasts with similar words:</p><ul><li><strong>Names vs. words</strong>. Names are words for sure, but words are not necessarily names. Words describe and connect. Names are what words describe and connect. You can loosely say that names are the nouns among words. But the notion of names in this book goes beyond that simple definition. A name, of course, need not be a single word.</li><li><strong>Names vs. descriptions</strong>. Descriptions are full-sentence prose narratives that discuss. Names are single words or fragments of sentences that define. While names describe, they also contain what they describe. A typical item of information will have a short name (i.e. title) and a longer description.</li><li><strong>Names vs phrases</strong>. A phrase is a fragment of a sentence. Names can be phrases (stay at home mom, for example) or single words.</li></ul><p>The word “name” is the best I can do to convey the central concept of how information is domesticated and made to do work by information systems.</p><p>The names you create to describe an information system define that system and guide every part of its implementation.</p><p>Names help you capture and contain a vast amount of information and make it simpler to use. Names operate in all walks of life, of course. But names in the wild can be vague and not systematized. Names in an information system are explicit and systematized. They corral and domesticate wild information:</p><ul><li>By constructing a system of names, you show that you understand and can capture wild information and harness it for some use.</li><li>By successfully bringing other people into the system of names, you show that the system makes sense and can be adopted and used.</li><li>By using the names to organize people and processes as well as information, you show that the system you have created can do work.</li><li>By changing the names over time without breaking the system, you show that the naming system is flexible enough to accommodate the evolution of the information system it defines.</li></ul><p>The power of names was pounded into my head once again a while back. We (my team and our client, a major dot-com company) were preparing for the first big presentation to the executive staff on “What We’ve Been Doing.” Lots of good ideas and bits of presentation were floating around, and as the presentation approached, we began to feel pretty good that we had actually been doing something. Still, we had no unity in our approach. Different subgroups had simply merged their slides into a single PowerPoint file. After the last run-through, a half-hour before the big event, someone finally nailed it. “We need a name for this thing!” she said. A collective eyebrow-raise swept the room. Within minutes, we settled on Grace, one of the characters in our user scenarios, as the name of our presentation. Except that it wasn’t just Grace. It was GRACE for Great Relationships And Customer E-tailing. The entire process crystallized, and we all suddenly knew how our individual parts related to the whole project. The name stuck instantly, and we went into that presentation not as a collection of separate projects stuck together by PowerPoint, but rather as a team all working together on GRACE.</p><p>We got lucky in coming up with a concept for all the bits we’d been working on after we had already created them and just before presenting them to our sponsor. A less risky strategy would have been to figure out our concept first so everyone could tailor his or her work to that concept. In either case, however, without that concept, that name, we had an unorganized collection of stuff rather than a system.</p><p>For very good reasons, names have always had a mystical hold on people.</p><blockquote><em>“Words are pale shadows of forgotten names. As names have power, words have power. Words can light fires in the minds of men. Words can wring tears from the hardest hearts. There are seven words that will make a person love you. There are ten words that will break a strong man’s will. But a word is nothing but a painting of a fire. A name is the fire itself.”</em></blockquote><p>In his awesome book <em>The Name of the Wind</em>, Patrick Rothfuss builds an entire fantasy world on the idea that “real” names carry real power. As the hero learns names, he acquires deep wisdom as well as the power to command the things by their names.</p><p>Names have always had a strange and powerful hold on us. To this day, many people refuse to speak the name of a disease lest they contract it. In the Jewish tradition, the name of God may not be spoken. In Native American cultures, a person’s true name is crafted to speak a deep truth about them, and that true name is never used lightly. Plato and Socrates believed there were true names (which they called “forms”) that transcended time and place and stood as the perfect universals behind and before any things we perceive.</p><p>In modern consumer culture, the power of the name is nowhere stronger than in the idea of brands, where a well-recognized and beloved name is valued above all else in a company’s portfolio of assets. The mystique and power of law, medicine, and most other professions derives from the set of names (i.e., professional jargon) the profession uses to uniquely capture meaning. When a community (a cult, a profession, a gang, a generation) has a set of names that no one else understands, it has the glue to hold itself together and a weapon to to use in cultural battle with the rest of society.</p><p>Names are political as well as cognitive. Those who know the name hold power that others lack. For example, prior to the financial crisis of 2008, those who knew the names “over-the-counter derivatives” and “credit default swaps” had the power to make a lot of money.</p><p>I don’t presume to understand the magic of names or why they so powerful in human life. This is not a book on spirituality, linguistics, or cognitive science. It is about information systems. In that realm, I need no more than the following proposition to explain why names are absolutely central:</p><blockquote><em>Names capture, contain, and make useful a potentially vast amount of meaning in a simple form.</em></blockquote><p>Meaning is the sense we make of the world. Names coalesce bits of sense into a solid meaning</p><p>I don’t want to get all philosophical. After all, this is a practical guide to information systems. But I can’t talk about names without talking about meaning.</p><p>Let me take a practical approach to meaning. Meaning, I say, is the sense we make of the world. I imagine a vast, interconnected realm of sense floating around in your mind. The sense is in the form of images, remembered but interpreted experiences, little voices inside your head, snippets of language, and partly or fully formed propositions of truth and falsehood. That’s meaning. A soup of more or less sure, more or less vague, more or less connected bits of sense.</p><p>Names, either the usual ones you find in life or the specialized ones we use in information systems:</p><ul><li>Crystallize meaning, coalescing a lot of sense around a single term.</li><li>Confine meaning, creating a boundary around particular bits of sense and clearly distinguishing them from the rest.</li></ul><p>In information systems, names perform an additional function that is exceedingly useful. Names make meaning into data. Names can be stored, organized, queried, retrieved, and displayed. They are the basis of storing and managing information.</p><p>When you put a name on something, you capture it. Or, more accurately, the thing was not a thing at all until you named it. Once named, the proto-thing becomes a nucleus around which meaning gathers. It acts to contain meaning, to divide your inner world of sense into “is one” and “is not one.” The name itself can be used by computer algorithms. It can be stored, searched on, sorted by, and displayed for users to see. Names gathered and related are a model, which is a system where all the names are arranged in relationship to each other.</p><p>The essence of structuring information is to create a small, easy-to-use set of names to describe and capture a large and hard-to-use set of words, images, motion, and sound (the information you aim to amass and deliver).</p><h3>Names Crystallize Meaning</h3><p>Just like snowflakes crystallize around a speck of dust, meaning crystallizes sky. The dust speck is a sort of base that individual water molecules stick to. New water molecules stick to the old ones at specific sites. A crystal quickly forms with a variable but regular structure. Snowflakes form as a structure around a core.</p><p>For me, snowflakes are a perfect metaphor for the way names work. A name, too, is a core or nucleus onto which information adheres and becomes structured.</p><p>A crystal, by the way, is a substance whose atoms are arranged in a regular pattern. In other words, a crystal is a regularly <strong>structured</strong> piece of matter. Crystallized meaning is sense that takes on a regular structure.</p><p>For example, suppose you are creating a music system for novices. Music experts know that music is organized into genres. However, most of your users have only a vague idea of what genre is. Very few can name more than a few genres, and fewer still could say how one genre is related to another.</p><p>By introducing the concept of a genre to your users, you give them a term that can serve as a core around which their existing knowledge of music can coalesce. By providing a list of genres, you further help users to crystallize their understanding. Imagine a user named Lilia:</p><ol><li>She comes to your system with only a vague notion about how songs relate to each other.</li><li>She sees the genre outline, and <em>click</em> — some pieces fall into place for her. For the first time, she sees that there are tons of categories of music and that some are higher up than others and that the whole system is called “genre.” Immediately, the bits of sense she has made concerning music categories begin to cling to the idea of a genre.</li><li>Lilia clicks on her favorite kind of music, hip-hop. She now has a name for the kind of thing hip-hop is. It is a genre. The name genre picks up meaning as her knowledge about a particular genre adheres to the name.</li><li>The hip-hop genre expands to show the subgenres, such as alternative, battle rap, and crunk. These new names serve as the nuclei for even more crystallization of meaning. Plus, the crystals link up in a parent-to-child relationship.</li></ol><p>Lilia’s thinking is being structured by the names you coded into the information system. But more to the point of this book, the names you use are your best guess at a set of nuclei that will crystallize the information in the way that is most appropriate to the user, the organization, and, importantly, the information itself.</p><p>The act of defining genres is an assertion, not a description. It is an assertion about the set of genres that will meet the needs of the user, the organization, and the information. Furthermore, it is an assertion because there is no “best” way to describe music types. As any taxonomist will tell you, the more experts you put in a room, the less they will agree on any set of categories. That’s why naming is hard. But there is no need to come up with the best description. You need only come up with a description that works for the user, the organization, and the information.</p><p>In the end, a name works if it can serve as a nucleus around which more and more meaning gathers and is connected.</p><h3>Names Contain Meaning</h3><p>Names put boundaries around meaning. They “quantize” it, so to speak.</p><p>In a music system, “genres” are a hierarchy of categories (i.e., names) that describe the music. Inside each category, you list the songs that are examples of that category. The genre hierarchy creates boundaries and containers around the songs:</p><p>Genres or any other set of descriptive names contain music meaning. In minds of your users, “kinds of music” may have been a vague and continuous concept, overlapping and intermingling with other concepts. By creating a genre hierarchy, you make “kinds of music” discrete and contained. You have tried to nail down a specific meaning and use. You contained music meaning by using the name “genre,” a term of art whose meaning is much more contained than “kinds.” You further confined the concept of “kinds” by specifying what the kinds are. You enhanced the containment by defining the relationships between the named kinds in a hierarchy. You completed the containment of songs by putting them into the hierarchy.</p><h3>Names Datatize Meaning and Make Management Possible</h3><p>To be useful to a computer, the wild and continuous world of meaning must be nailed down to simple data.</p><p>Meaning in the wild is continuous and hard to pin down. We don’t really distinguish one bit of sense from another. Names datatize information; that is, they provide a small snippet that can stand in for the larger and less manageable whole chunk of meaning. For example, in the minds of your users, rock and roll is probably a sprawling collection of lyrics, images, tunes and other loosely affiliated memories. The genre name “rock and roll” unites that mass of memories under a single term. More to the point of this book, names can be managed and used by your system. For example, names surrounding the concept of “kinds of music” enable a set of management technologies and procedures including:</p><ul><li>Procedures to tag songs with genres.</li><li>Templates that present genres on the screen.</li><li>Search routines that allow users to search by genre.</li><li>Targeting routines that allow the system to make assumptions about and deliver information to users based on their genre preferences.</li></ul><p>At a more general level, names are the method and outcome of all management in an information system. Management is simply the use of names to originate, tag, maintain, display and retire information.</p><ul><li><strong>Origination</strong> is authoring or acquiring information into the system. In either case, to move an item of information from outside to inside the system means to bring that information into the “namespace” of the system. Specifically, it means dividing the item into the named parts that the system requires (title, id, author, for example) and applying required names as required by the system (choosing the author from the required list of names for example).</li><li><strong>Tagging</strong> is the application of names to items of information. A tag is a piece of metadata. Metadata is a named attribute that contains a value of a prescribed type. In the case where the prescribed type is literally a list of names (for example, a list of valid author names) the connection between tags and names is obvious, but even if the allowed values are more open, they are still names of some sort.</li><li><strong>Maintenance</strong> is the periodic review and revision of information in the system. How does one find items of information to be reviewed? With metadata. For example, you might find all the items whose author is “Siyu Li.”</li><li><strong>Display</strong> is the rendering of an item on a screen. Specifically, it is selecting an item based on its metadata, choosing which of the named attributes of the item to show, and rendering the chosen attributes into named areas and named styles on the screen.</li><li><strong>Retirement</strong> is archiving or deleting items out of the system. As in maintenance, selection of the items to retire is based on the values in metadata fields (for example, you might retire all items with an author of “Siyu Sun” and a createDate more than one year ago.</li></ul><p>Could names be more important to information systems?</p><p>Names stand in for the meaning they contain.</p><p>Just like a soup can contains all the ingredients that go into the soup, a name contains all the bits of sense that are inside it.</p><p>Your name is the best illustration of this idea. Think of a Bob you know (or me, if you don’t know any better Bobs). In reality, your knowledge of him is composed of a set of personal experiences and hearsay. You may have very little real “data” on him, but undoubtedly, Bob is a definite thing to you. He is single and unified. You have somehow been able to synthesize, generalize, and unify all theses disparate bits of sense into a whole. And the whole you have created is Bob. Bob is the sense you have made of the person.</p><p>Names identify. In the case of Bob, this is literally true. The person is literally identified by the name. But it is just as true for any name. The name identifies the thing.</p><p>Once a thing is named, you can often use the name without reference to the bits of sense it contains. The name unifies meaning but also abstracts away from the meaning. Once Bob is an established concept, the details of your interactions fade away and are replaced by abstractions. Broad concepts such as “Bob is lazy” or “Bob is energetic” replace specific instances of laziness or high energy. Once established, these abstractions influence meaning. If Bob is lazy, I might view any new experiences I have of him in this light. So the name not only stands in for meaning, it becomes the locus for generalizations which then act on any new information that is to be contained by the name.</p><p>This is the crazy world of human meaning. Are names the product of a synthesis of meaning or the creator of that synthesis? Well, both. The name describes the thing, but the name also creates the thing.</p><p>Stranger still, names identify the thing, but names are not unique. We have little or no problem when two people have the same name. Or do we? You may or may not confuse one Bob with another but one Bob does often bleed into another. All Claires, no matter how hard I try, are colored by my biggest Claire, my mom.</p><p>By linking an existing name to a new object, the new object can inherit the meaning we ascribed to the old object.</p><p>The non-uniqueness of names is not a problem. In fact, it is a fundamental driver of human meaning. I can think of no more disturbing or convincing example of this than the use of the name “cockroach” by Hutus in Rwanda in the 1990s:</p><blockquote><em>“In Rwanda they referred to Tutsis as cockroaches,” explains Omaar. “They were not human beings. This is very important to understand, [there are] very close parallels to what happened in Hitler’s Germany. [They said], ‘Don’t worry, you’re not killing humans like you. You are killing some vermin that belongs under your shoe. You’re killing cockroaches.’”</em></blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*Z7EA2MI649tSbcfg.jpg" /></figure><p>In plain terms, the name “Tutsi,” which described and contained a group of people, was intentionally changed to “cockroach.” The new name dramatically changed the meaning of all the people it contained.</p><p>All names work this way. They imbue what they contain with meaning. But despite my evil example, the process in general is neither good nor evil. It just is. And it is essential to the way human meaning moves forward. We take the meaning that was cultivated and honed in one realm and apply it in another. That’s metaphor. And it is the foundation of the art of naming. Can you choose just the right name to both capture the essence of the things that are named and imbue those things with new and enriching meaning derived from the other things that carry that name?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*wEzChZqHg-golhkH.jpg" /></figure><p>Is this a flower, a parrot, or strangely both and neither?</p><h3>Names and IDs</h3><p>The unique ID is the quintessential computer-useful name. But it is a pale shadow of a real name.</p><p>Meaning is a messy human thing. It is an ever-changing landscape of bits of sense that we bring together and break apart. The bits of sense themselves are not fixed, and the wider configurations of meaning we make of them are not stable or even accessible to us unless and until they are named. Meaning is so scrambled, so transient, so idiosyncratic, and so interconnected in so many ways that a simple, deterministic computer has no chance of representing it, let alone working with it. So we invented data. Data are small bits of sense. But unlike humans, computers pin down and isolate meaning. If names crystallize meaning, data calcifies it. Meaning is fundamentally dynamic; data is static. Data is the kind of meaning some people strive for. Universal, fixed, and always true. A datum is an atomic unit of meaning for computers. No such unit exists for people. No matter how set in your ways you may be, there is always a chance that one of your most fundamental truths can be moved. Not so with data.</p><p>Because of this, computers often seem silly to people. They lack all the interest and subtlety of people. People compare computers to children. They are about as intelligent as a two-year-old. But I don’t think that is apt. Humans, from before birth, have the capacity to dynamically negotiate meaning on a second-by-second basis. Computers never do. I would rather compare computers to a person with a strange kind of illness. This person is so sick that she has only literal meaning. She has lost all emotive and figurative meaning. Once set in her mind, a proposition will never change by itself. For us, things are never as they seem, but to the computer, things always are — and can only be — as they seem.</p><p>However, even with this drastic simplification of meaning, computers can do a lot. If you can codify meaning into data, then the computer can operate on it 24 hours a day, seven days a week, and do all sorts of useful tasks that people do not have the time, patience or mathematical aptitude to do.</p><p>Names are no less messy than meaning itself. Names identify, but they do not do so uniquely. And strangely, this non-uniqueness is a fundamental and hugely productive quality of names. It is what makes names what they are to us.</p><p>Enter computers into this scary and wonderful world of names. Enter a machine that has no ability whatsoever to deal with subtlety, nuance, abstraction, or the strange loops that names engender. It was way too hard to bring Mohammed to the mountain, so we brought the mountain to Mohammed. Because computers could not deal with the real nature of names, we changed the nature of names so the computer could operate on them. We invented the ID.</p><p>As far as computers and computation are concerned, there are no names, only IDs. An ID uniquely identifies an object. It is a precise and solitary container, not for meaning, but for data. We invented IDs not to reproduce the complexity and subtlety of names, but to replace names with something much, much simpler.</p><p>IDs uniquely identify items of information for computers. They perform the function of names but in the same comically simple way that data does for meaning. While names are at the center of a constantly growing crystal of meaning, IDs are set and never change. Names and IDs both contain, but IDs do so statically. While names work back on the meaning they contain, subtly or dramatically altering that meaning, IDs do not. Names overlap for a good reason: to move meaning from one container to another. IDs never overlap for a good reason: to make sure that you can always definitively distinguish one container from another. You cannot go definitively from the name “Bob” to me because there are a lot of Bobs. But you can go definitively from the ID “user_7683” to the record for my purchases from you.</p><h3>Names Contain Information</h3><p>Names figuratively contain meaning. In a working information system, names literally contain the words, images, sounds, and other information in the system.</p><p>Take the name “Bluegrass.” That name might flow into and through an information system as follows:</p><ol><li><strong>Thought</strong>. “Bluegrass” begins as a name in a taxonomist’s head.</li><li><strong>Creation</strong>. The taxonomist enters “Bluegrass” into the system. Let’s say the taxonomist does this by typing in a text box labeled “Genre Name” in a form on a webpage. The form itself is a named container on the webpage, and the text box is a named sub-container within the form container.</li><li><strong>Storage</strong>. When the taxonomist clicks “submit,” “Bluegrass” is stored in a database table named “taxonomy,” in a field called “title.” The table is a container; each record in the table contains one taxonomy term; and the title field contains the name of the genre (in this case, “Bluegrass”). At this point, other named pieces of information (for example, an ID, the time the record was created, the author’s name, a term status) might be automatically added to database record.</li><li><strong>Access</strong>. In the system code, a function named “processHierarchy” queries the taxonomy table to get back all the terms in the genre taxonomy. Inside the function, the set of database records becomes a new, named data structure. Using named variables, the code processes the data structure to turn it into HTML for display on the screen.</li><li><strong>Display</strong>. The processHierarchy function sends HTML to the user’s browser. The HTML contains a named screen area for the genre hierarchy. Inside the named area are a set of named styles that apply look and feel to the hierarchy. The styles are designed to translate the idea of a hierarchy into a visual representation with indents, fonts, and highlighting to represent the hierarchy’s parent-child relationships.</li></ol><p>It’s names all the way. At every step in every process in an information system, names are needed to contain thoughts, data, code, and display.</p><h3>Names Are Language</h3><p>The names in an information system live at the junction of disciplinary jargon, subject matter terms, and common spoken language.</p><p>The names a team uses to define a system are invented by the team. However, the names do not come out of the blue. They are drawn from the discipline, from the subject matter, and from spoken language in general.</p><p>Over the last 30 years, I have watched and participated in the creation of the language of the discipline of information systems. Words such as user interface, combo box, app, tier, popup, style, along with a host of other new and stolen terms, have come together to create our conversations about the work we do. To be part of the information systems discipline requires that you master these terms and then help to drive their evolution. In fact, you can see this book merely as my attempt to help evolve the words we use to talk about information systems.</p><p>The names we use are also drawn from subject matter language. If the system concerns cinema, for example, the names from the subject of cinema will be part of the names for the system. Screen labels, information types, controlled vocabularies, and many other names will be related to the language of cinema.</p><p>Finally, the names in the system are drawn from within a spoken language, most likely English. I’ve worked in a dozen or more countries whose primary language is not English, but I have never worked in a country whose language of information systems is not English. All the names in a system are also words in some language. These words (and their meanings) are pressed into the service of the system by the team that creates that system.</p><p>Finally, it’s possible that you might coin some names. Names such as ping, email, Facebook, and blog were all invented by teams to describe their systems. But the number of names you coin is dwarfed by the number you borrow from other sources.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*fBW2U7pED2cb0W5L.jpg" /></figure><p>Take the phrase “breadcrumb trail,” commonly used to name a horizontal hierarchy widget (hierarchy and widget are names from information science and UI design, respectively).</p><p>I needed to hear this term only once to understand it and use it forevermore. For me, the term is moored to an existing knowledge of fairy tales. However, a non-native speaker is unlikely to remember the term, because for them, it is not related to anything. If they know the term, it is because they have memorized it (as I have memorized the Dutch term “gezellig” without the benefit of the world of connections the word has for a Nederlander). Without the supporting memory aid and the context of the term, a non-native speaker will always be a bit hesitant to say “breadcrumb trail” (as I am hesitant to say gezellig, except to get a laugh).</p><p>The success of an information system absolutely depends on having a set of names that seamlessly integrates the language of the discipline and the subject matter with the wider meaning embedded in the language spoken or understood by the team.</p><h3>Names Must be Named</h3><p>Coming up with names and getting them accepted by a team requires you to know what a good name is and why being a good name is not enough.</p><p>There is a huge and growing literature on the art of categorization in general. I’m not the one to summarize that literature. I am content to provide you with an overview of the art of naming from the standpoint of information systems, including:</p><h3>Names and Titles</h3><p>For info items, titles are the main and identifying names.</p><p>Some things have names, others have titles. For example, you have a name, but this book has a title. Cities have names, but websites have titles. Titles are names for published items such as books, movies and websites. And since our information systems are in the publishing business, titles are important.</p><p>Imagine yourself in a library, or, better yet, go to one. You are wandering slowly down an aisle with your eyes lingering on or passing over … titles.</p><p>Book Alpha:Mumble, mumble, mumble …</p><p>Book Beta:Hey you! Look at me, look at me!</p><p>You:OK, I’m looking, what?</p><p>Book Beta:I’m “A Field Guide to Toenails” — wanna talk?</p><p>You:Piss off.</p><p>Book Gamma:Hi there, I’m “Where to go on your next vacation.”</p><p>You:Hmm, uh, nah, sorry, no time.</p><p>Book Delta:Yo, I’m “Get your Info System Right.” Let’s chat.</p><p>You:OK, you’ve got 15 seconds to prove that I need you.</p><p>Each title your eyes meet jumps out at you or doesn’t. Why? Why does one book catch your attention and another does not?</p><p>As every publisher knows, the context around the title matters. Color, size, font, backgrounds — they all draw attention. If your eye doesn’t meet the title, the book has no chance. That’s Book Alpha. But just because your eye meets the title doesn’t mean you’ll care. That’s Book Beta.</p><p>A title you do care about still needs to grab you. That’s Book Gamma. You care, just not enough to stop. Book Delta has made it over all the previous hurdles. The prize for that attention-getting power? An instant longer to show that the information behind the title is as interesting as the title itself.</p><p>Titles serve these very important functions in your information system:</p><ul><li><strong>The title identifies</strong>. It is a quality of the item (book, movie, song) that stands in for the item as a whole. That’s what makes the title a name.</li><li><strong>The title labels</strong>. Anytime the item is shown, its title is featured as the predominant label for the item.</li><li><strong>The title is for finding</strong>. If you remember the title of a work, you should easily be able to find it. Systems often have alphabetical indexes by title for just this purpose. Any other navigation (outlines, links, etc.) also features the title as the thing you start with to see if the item is the one you want.</li><li><strong>The title is for deciding</strong>. You use the title itself as a selection criteria. If the title does not indicate what is in the item and why you might want it, you will never go to the item.</li><li><strong>The title attracts or repels</strong>. You look at a title and compare it to what you want. If the title aligns with what you want, it draws you toward the item like a good sign draws you to a restaurant. If the title does not align with what you want, it repels you or changes your mind about what you want.</li><li><strong>The title summarizes</strong>. The item’s title contains the information in the item. Like the soup can, which tells you in big letters what is inside, the item title tells you what to expect from the item.</li></ul><p>Humans use titles to identify items; computers use IDs. That is why the minimum amount of metadata that is applied to items of information is a title (for people) and an ID (for computers).</p><h3>What Is a Good Name?</h3><p>In general, a good name follows simple rules. Unfortunately, following the rules does not ensure your names will be good.</p><p>Although there are many sources on naming techniques that are superior to this book, there are a few points that I must lay out.</p><p>What I have found is that:</p><ul><li><strong>A good name is plain if it can be</strong>. In information systems, clarity and simplicity rule. A simple, transparent name beats all but the most artful non-obvious name. Creating a simple, transparent name means prioritizing the name’s function of summarizing and containing the item. Either your names should plainly describe their contents, or there should be a very good reason why they do not. The other day, I proposed the name “prescriptive report.” It did the job in a straightforward way. Our prescriptive reports, as you can well imagine, are reports that tell you want to do. They prescribe.</li><li><strong>A good name is sticky (memorable)</strong>. You hear the name once and you never forget it. Yahoo! and YouTube have this quality as company names. I rarely remember band names, but I always remember “Ratatat.”</li><li><strong>A good name is apt</strong>. The name “scratches an itch.” As I was beginning this book, I was trying to explain to a colleague where it fits in the literature. Searching for names, I said, “Most IA is front end. I want to write about the back end.” She got the idea immediately, both because “front end” and “back end” are existing names that carry a world of ready-made associations, and because those associations fit with how she sees the world around my book. Back end was an apt name for the subject matter.</li><li><strong>A good name is concise</strong>. Shorter is generally better. The name “product” for the type of information that you will deliver about your products is better than “product information,” or “our products and services.” The word “information” is redundant, and what you lose in descriptiveness when you drop “services” from the name is more than gained in pith and verbal efficiency.</li><li><strong>A good name is descriptive</strong>. On the other hand, if you have an info type called “products” and no one knows that it also covers services, you have a problem. Now the extra word is worth the trouble of fully articulating what the information type contains.</li><li><strong>A good name is accepted</strong>. In a recent design exercise, a colleague proposed the name “set piece” for a kind of exercise that the students should practice and master. He explained that “set piece” is used for that kind of exercise in his daughter’s soccer practice. Everyone around the table (except me) had heard that usage and thought it apt. I had never heard it before, so I thought the term was not apt. But rather than be a baby about it, I accepted the term because they all did.</li><li><strong>A good name is novel</strong> but not too novel. William Shakespeare is the undisputed king of coinage. His new names (like “fancy-free” and “forgone conclusion”) were just novel enough to catch on and claim meaning from other terms. My favorite name is “grock,” coined by Robert Heinlein in “Stranger in a Strange Land.” So far, grock is still pretty obscure. It has not wrestled much meaning from the names around it.</li></ul><p>What should you make of the name “For Colored Girls Who Have Considered Suicide When the Rainbow Is Enuf?” It breaks all the rules I just laid out, yet it worked well as the title of a collection of poems. In fact, that title is a big part of why the collection was so successful. Just when you think you can write down a bunch of cut-and-dried rules, those damn humans come along and mess up your tidy theories. ;)</p><h3>Why Bad Names Work</h3><p>A name’s aptness is not always related to its success.</p><p>There are lots of bad names out there. Most of them do not work because, well, they’re bad. They’re not apt and they are not accepted. Before they were cool, hand-held computers were called Personal Digital Assistants (PDAs) a non-starter of a name. Microsoft, Amazon, and Google all have cloud computing services. I’ll let you decide which has the best name:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*bPwriQF1qDoA712C.jpg" /></figure><p>But not all bad names are created equal. Some are flops from the start, but some become the accepted norms. Take the word “dashboard,” for example. It is a strange and even silly name for the control panel of an automobile. It originally meant the literal board that kept mud from splashing (or dashing) onto a carriage from a horse’s hooves. But it no longer matters where it came from or what it might mean. We all know what it means, and now it could be any word. Or think of the words Xerox or Hoover. Strange names indeed for copiers and vacuums. But again, it does not matter. They work well — even very well — as names. Why?</p><p>Naming is not a rational process. It is an art. Still, in the naming that goes on in information systems, reasonable, clear, descriptive, simple naming wins in the vast majority of cases. But it is the flair for turning phrases that distinguishes a good namer from a great one.</p><p><strong>A good bad name</strong></p><p>One of my favorite examples of a good bad name is “browser.” As you know, the term is applied to Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer, and other applications that allow you to get to webpages. It was originally named for the main innovation of the web, linking (or browsing) from one page to another. The craze over linking from one page to another died down and today, it is not an amazing thing anymore. We search much more than we browse. Moreover, the main thing the browser does is display (or, more technically, render) content. But it doesn’t matter to anyone but nitpickers like me. It’s a browser now and that is that.</p><h3>Names Seriously Matter to People</h3><p>People have a lot of identity wrapped up in the names they use. As you work through to a set of names, you must account for that.</p><p>When I first encountered the phenomenon, I was shocked. I had drastically underestimated what it would take to bring a small group of rational, motivated people on a team at Microsoft to consensus on what the parts of our system should be called. I had naively thought that the simplest, most descriptive name would out, and we could move on quickly. Boy, was I wrong. The whole process reminded me of my favorite aphorism:</p><blockquote><em>When you pour milk on the oatmeal, all the lumps come to the top.</em></blockquote><p>Even people who have worked together closely think of “the same thing” very differently. As long as they talk together in vague terms, they are fine. They go away thinking they agree. But when the stakes are higher and precision in terms is demanded of them, people will become almost religious about the names they use.</p><p>To look more closely at the issue, ask yourself, “Is it a hoagie, a sub, a grinder, a hero, or some other name?”</p><p>There is a rational way to decide. In this example, each term has an etymology, a geographical range of usage, and small but discernible differences in meaning. A team could decide which to use based on these factors. But that is only half the story. I grew up eating heroes. Grinders and hoagies sound dumb to me. But Sanji, to my left, grew up in Pittsburgh. She ate hoagies and had never heard of a hero. “What kind of name is that anyway for a sandwich?” she snickers. “Hero?” We are accustomed to our names. They sound right and other names sound wrong. An “improper” name grinds on the ear. It annoys. It sounds false coming out of your mouth and you are loath to utter it. It may even feel like a betrayal of the community you belong to. If forced to use the “wrong” name, you will simply translate it into the “right” name in your mind. Names are close to our hearts and we are loyal to them. In settling on names, it is extremely important to understand and account for this emotional commitment people have for the names they use.</p><p>As an IA, your job is to see through regionalism and our inordinate desire to hold on to names.</p><ul><li>You can begin by holding your personal opinions on term usage at arm’s length. To what extent are you arguing from a regional or personal bias?</li><li>Continue by stating that “synonym” is a symmetrical relationship. What is the word and what is the synonym may be entirely a matter of dialect and idiosyncratic usage.</li><li>Next, see in someone’s eyes, body language, and vehemence that calm debate is not an option and back off the issue.</li><li>Finally, remind yourself and the team that what you think the name should be matters much less than what the user thinks. For a term the user will never see, whether the term is “right” to everyone matters much less than whether everyone will try to accept and use the term until it proves to be wrong.</li></ul><h3>Names Have Nuance</h3><p>Names are not value-neutral. They always reflect the values of the people who use them. They should represent the values of the system.</p><p>Imagine you are creating a system to track the accomplishments of your staff (as I did one time). Is the info type an accomplishment, an achievement, an output, or an accolade? This time, the issue not so much the emotional commitment people have to one term or the another, but the nuance in meaning between the terms. Which term best fits the spirit of the system? Which term approaches the world of words from the proper angle to create a system that meets the goals set out for you?</p><p>As you can see, the name of the info type reflects the goals of the system. What type of information the system tracks matters to the process of naming. Depending on what you think the goal of the system is, you might fight hard for one term over another. Or, more likely, you might discuss how the various words shine a light on the lack of clarity in the team concerning its goals. And propose that more work be done with the project stakeholders to clarify the system goals.</p><h3>Names Are Adopted</h3><p>New names can slip right into use or be major points of contention in the course of a systems project.</p><p>I’ve witnessed the name adoption process enough times that I’ve begun to see a consistent pattern of ways the process can unfold:</p><ul><li><strong>When proposed, the name is obvious</strong>. It is the accepted way to define the thing the team needs. No one is even aware that they are using a name because its use is so natural. Thankfully, there are a lot of these names in an information systems project. For example, suppose someone says, “We need user account management including security, profiling, validation, and access rights.” That is a mouthful of names that no one will argue with or even notice if they have been around for more than one project. That’s a funny thing about names: once they are adopted, they do a lot of hard work but disappear from view.</li><li><strong>When a name is proposed, there is a brief discussion</strong> before complete adoption. Suppose someone says, “We need the ability to flip a class in this system.” To “flip” a class is to change it so the primary learning happens outside the classroom. If the term is not well known or accepted, there will be discussion. What does the term mean? How is it used? Does that term describe what we are doing in our system, or is what we are doing better referred to by a different term? If the team decides the name fits, they will quickly adopt it. And not only will the team adopt the new name, they might over-adopt it. They can become proud of their new name. They might like “flipping” so much that they start using it far beyond its original intent. They may even want to name the system “Flipper!”</li><li><strong>Adoption is a process but isn’t opposed</strong>. Suppose someone says, “Our system provides insights.” Here, the name “insight” is meant to contain the concept, data, presentation, and functionality of one part of the system. Leaving aside what “insight” means, I suspect you can imagine that the term might not meet with immediate understanding and adoption. A lot of questions will have to be answered about insights. Any other candidate names (conclusion, inference, intuition, etc.) will also have to be dealt with. The name “insight” might take a while to sink in and become a term that “trips off the tongue” in meetings. It may never disappear from view like other names, but eventually it will be<em>the</em> name. There will be insight tables in the database and insight functions in the code; insights will have styles on the screen and a bullet point in the sales pitch for the system.</li><li><strong>Adoption is contested</strong>. What happens when there are two or more competing names for the same thing? Or, maybe more appropriately, two or more competing conceptions of what the thing is? Opposition is a good thing. It ensures that the team considers alternatives. Deadlock is a bad thing. For example, suppose one faction of the team never adopts “insight.” They prefer “intervention,” with all the differences in approach that the term implies. At best, a deadlock over terms comes up again and again until it is resolved. At worst, it turns into a failed system.</li><li><strong>Adoption never closes</strong>. It is all too common for a team to simply run out of time or steam to debate a name to the end. For example, suppose the debate over “insight” happens late in a Friday meeting. The debate never reaches a conclusion, but the team moves on anyway. Each team member is then free to make their own interpretation of the term or not use it at all.</li><li><strong>Adoption is forgotten</strong>. The team might have no problem with a name, but adoption could fail anyway. For example, suppose the name “insight” is happily adopted and then forgotten. One part of the team might inadvertently invent a new term that conflicts with “insight” but never realize it because they had all forgotten “insight” was the accepted term.</li></ul><p>In a successful information system, major debates about names are resolved early in the process. A lot of time is needed for the most important or contested names to be accepted, but even unopposed names need a while to sink in. Of course, naming debates can and will emerge throughout the system’s life. In fact, it’s the little debates (is it a “shopping cart” or a “wish list”?) that drive the concept of the system forward. But a deadlock over naming is bad. When the team has no way to decide between two alternative names, development of that part of the system stops — or, even worse, continues in an incoherent way.</p><p>The accomplishments system I designed floundered on the top-most term: accomplishments. We never agreed on a name for the information we were supposed to collect. By all rights, our sponsors should have been able to tell us. Were we supposed to collect everything the staff did or only the things that carried accolades of some sort? But they never figured out what we were collecting, and neither did we. Instead, we just argued the issue back and forth. Nevertheless, as in so many projects, we went forward anyway. We used “accomplishment” because it could be interpreted either way. Our sponsors passed the problem on to us, and we passed the same problem on to the users. Users never figured out what information they were supposed to enter, and the system failed.</p><p>In my experience, there are a few good ways to break a naming deadlock.</p><ul><li><strong>Authority</strong>. If you are lucky enough to have strong, informed leadership, they can say what the right name or approach is. Usually, you can’t just ask them what the name should be. Rather, you have to explain the alternative names in terms of the wider goals of the system. Also, just because the boss says “A,” it does not mean all is well. Unhappy team members can become passive-aggressive, agreeing in public but asserting the unchosen name in covert ways.</li><li><strong>User perspective</strong>. A winning argument in any information system debate is “the users say …” That argument applies especially well to names that users will see, but it can help you with any name. For example, is it a “shopping cart” or a “wish list?” Maybe it’s the one that the users need most.</li><li><strong>Working out the details</strong>. Many times, I have found that it is easy to argue about what something should be called when considering that thing in the abstract. But if you work through the conceptual and linguistic details, you will often find common ground, or at least a sharp definition of the disagreement. For example, what are the UI, data, function, and marketing details of a shopping cart versus a wish list? The further into the two you dig, the more you will see the similarities, differences, pros, and cons of each name. Which name fits better into the ecosystem of names already in use? Which fits the functionality you already have and want to have?</li><li><strong>Look it up</strong>. When in doubt, a plain old thesaurus can really help. It’s useful for finding terms, yes, but a thesaurus also helps you see the semantic territory around a term.</li></ul><p>Never underestimate how tightly you and everyone else hold on to names. People like to say, “It’s just semantics.” They mean that semantics are not important. I like to say, “It’s just semantics” to indicate that there is nothing other than semantics. Watch yourself as names are introduced in meetings and in documents produced by others, and you will learn all you need to about how people will react when you introduce names of your own. Know why resistance occurs and how to overcome it. More than anything else, allow yourself to playfully adopt the names that others use. Try to see a new name from the inside. Try it on. Give it a chance. If it truly does not fit, ask why. Is it your cultural attachment to another name, or is it a lack of aptness? If the issue is cultural fit, what do the users think? Their culture is more important than yours. If aptness is the issue, chart the details of the bad name to see exactly where the issue lies. Make arguments for one name over the other based on cultural fit and aptness issues. Be explicit about which problem you have. Be prepared to go head-to-head between competing names and be prepared to be convinced that someone else’s name is better.</p><h3>Names Evolve</h3><p>The names a team uses change from above (visionaries and stakeholders) and from below (implementers). The change is natural but disruptive.</p><p>If we needed only to define and implement names, the task would be hard enough. However, the hard task can become impossible if there is names change too much or too rapidly. Every time the system leaders change their minds about what the system is or does, ripples spread through the rest of the system. The implications of each change have to be charted and accounted for in every part of the system.</p><p>Change can come not only from the top but from any team member. Any time a team member finds a terminology conflict, a conceptual dead end, or a better way to think about the terms they use, they change names. The new name and concept then must find their way into other parts of the system. All too often, a small problem noticed by an implementer results in a change at the visionary level, and the entire system of names becomes unstable and has to be adjusted.</p><p>A system of names is not unlike an ecosystem. Under stable conditions, and with enough time and energy, all the concepts, statements, operational terms, and implementation terms will adjust to each other and create a stable system. When change is introduced, the effect may be minimal or drastic: the system might be easily restored to balance, or it might completely fall apart.</p><p>In an information system, restoring balance is not always easy. The longer a term is used, the more entrenched it becomes and the harder it is to change. If the change involves not just one term but rather a cluster of them, the change could be a serious amount of work.</p><p>So, what often happens is that while the vision and key concepts of a system continue to evolve, the terms used at the operational level do not keep up. People are used to the old terms and are slow to adopt new ones (especially after the third or fourth change).</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://storage.googleapis.com/bobboikostuff/names/names.html"><em>https://storage.googleapis.com</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f7d8dae2e0eb" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[AI sucks for them but it’s great for me!]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@bobboiko/ai-sucks-for-them-but-its-great-for-me-6bce5cee72a1?source=rss-02be1be414b2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6bce5cee72a1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ai]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[future-of-work]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[creativity]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Bob Boiko ]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 25 Mar 2026 22:45:37 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-03-25T22:46:43.595Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>AI sucks for people who make their living from creativity, but it’s awesome for people like me with little talent but lots to do.</em></p><p>As you might have heard, visual artists are toast. Copywriters are history. Photographers have been done for a while now. Videographers, writers, musicians, your star is waning. Your creations are just more fodder for AI to consume and imitate. People type prompts now; they don’t pay good money for your creative output.</p><p>But wait… There’s hope!</p><p>Lemme tell you a story about bread.</p><p>Ever wonder why something awesome is “the greatest thing since sliced bread?” Hand-made bread was once the only bread. Then, beginning in the 1920’s, automation in the US made manual bread obsolete. Factory bread that was more expensive but had no “dirty immigrant hands” kneading, baking, slicing and wrapping it became all the rage among rich people. Then, as efficiency increased and prices fell, automated bread became the rage for the entire nation. Manual bread, however, reasserted itself in the 1970s when rich people decided that hand-made did not mean the ‘filthy hands of immigrants,’ but the ‘gifted hands of artisans.’ Today, while automated bread still dominates among the poor, bread bakers, once thought extinct, can again make a living from their creations and charge rich people more than ever.</p><p>AI is today’s “greatest thing since sliced bread.” Could automated content follow a similar trajectory? As AI content proliferates it may mean the extinction of artisans of all stripes, or it may mean that artisanal content becomes more valuable than ever. Automated content could still dominate the lives of people who can’t or won’t pay. But manual content creators, though fewer in number, might once again make a living from their art. AI, like all automation, produces winners and losers. Content creators are, at least for the present, definite losers.</p><p>I, on the other hand, am a winner.</p><p>Why do I win? Because there’s a lot I want to create and I’m good with words. I can’t draw to save my life, I can’t create good sounds, videos or photos, and I’ve finally given up on programming. I can, however, describe stuff well. I am good at saying precisely what I want. In addition I’m happy to restate and refine till what I say is just right.</p><p>For me, generative AI is just the ticket.</p><p>When I was a kid, long before there were computers, I had a big disappointment. We all picked up guitars. Some of my friends got good, but I kinda sucked. I realized that I would never be even a passable musician. But I had original songs running around in my head all the time. So, I dreamed of a machine that would let me make songs without needing the talent to actually play them. I have that now, and much more.</p><p>Everywhere, people with imagination but no skill are using AI to get shit done.</p><p>I worked on a big AI project at my last job, the first of its kind there. It involved automating a huge set of documents so that users could better find answers. I started the project the same way I have for years. I gathered requirements from subject matter experts and wrote specifications for our programmers to meet those requirements with code. But because we were using AI, that’s not where we ended up. The programmers mostly worked on setting up the AI system while the subject matter experts ended up writing their own requirements. I simply told the experts,</p><p><em>Think of the system like a very smart apprentice. She needs to know what you want, but she will figure out how to do it. Be explicit, but open-ended, so that the apprentice has enough latitude to find a solution but enough constraint to create a workable solution. Just like an apprentice, you will have to review her work and revise her instructions until she gives you the results you are looking for.</em></p><p>The subject matter experts wrote down how they wanted to gather the information. They wrote down how they wanted that information processed. They wrote down how they wanted questions answered. They even wrote down how to deal with problems when they might arise. We turned it all into AI prompts. Even our early-stage AI system was very capable of turning the words into a working system. Luckily my subject matter experts were good with words.</p><p>AIs are just getting better. Even now, people are createing viable systems with no programmers at all. People commonly get an AI to write the prompt for another AI.</p><p>Still, there’s no substitute for people with the imagination to come up with an idea and are also articulate enough to explain it precisely. It’s the people with the skill to turn articulated imagination into reality who are quickly being replaced.</p><p>I wrote a novel once. I decided it would be a cross between a good-old text narrative and a graphic novel. It would have lots of words, but they would be broken into few-page scenes, each with a title, a summary, a big illustration and a caption. There were well over 100 of these scenes, so the illustration load was immense. I hired an illustrator. He cost me a bundle, but he turned out to be really good. In fact, most people like his illustrations better than my words. Sad for me, but beside the point.</p><p>As I wrote the novel, I had a vivid picture of each character in my mind and a clearly imagined setting for each illustration. What I wanted was my vision realized. What I got was a fun interaction, but a negotiated vision. I’ve never been a great collaborator. For better or worse, when I create, I want my vision, not our vision.</p><p>I’m in process on another illustration-heavy book. I have the same clear vision of the characters and their settings. But this time, it’s just me and my image generator. A half-hour of prompting and I have a pretty good realization of my vision for a character. I’m a long way from done, and the current state of AI means I have to learn tools and engage my programming skills to get the result I want. But it’s my result, my vision realized. And that’s what I wanted all along.</p><p>That’s why I win with AI. If I know exactly what I want, I can state it and I’m willing to keep revising till I am happy, the machine will do the rest.</p><p>I feel bad for my illustrator and the dozens of other people I know who are being ripped-off and replaced by AI. I really do. I want them to be loved and supported by my society. I’d like to think that the best of them will ride the AI wave rather than be swamped by it. I want them to be the bakers of the future– smaller in number, but more highly valued than ever. For me though, and all the other people who know how to say what they want, AI’s awesome.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6bce5cee72a1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Come on Moby, Lola is an Awesome Song]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@bobboiko/come-on-moby-lola-is-an-awesome-song-9a01da2490f4?source=rss-02be1be414b2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9a01da2490f4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[lola]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[moby]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[the-kinks]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Bob Boiko ]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 25 Mar 2026 17:49:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-03-25T21:46:17.721Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="THE KINKS Lola +3 1970 MEXICO 7&quot; PROMO EP Psych Mod on ebay — https://www.ebay.com/itm/177889794442?var=0&amp;mkevt=1&amp;mkcid=1&amp;mkrid=711-53200-19255-0&amp;campid=5338590836&amp;toolid=10044&amp;loc_physical_ms=67560&amp;customid=59af082c0c911c14fbc761e8121ed5a2&amp;gclid=59af082c0c911c14fbc761e8121ed5a2" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*BvMH4m9SAEE01FoXgELp_w.jpeg" /></figure><p>Moby’s made a whale of a mistake. Maybe you saw this article? I got it on my news feed the other day:</p><p>“‘The lyrics to Lola by the Kinks are gross — I was really taken aback’: Moby’s honest playlist”</p><p>By Rich Pelley, The Guardian. <a href="https://apple.news/AEmbK2UZFQq2g4WtnZoeEUg">https://apple.news/AEmbK2UZFQq2g4WtnZoeEUg</a></p><p><em>The song I can no longer listen to<br>Lola by the Kinks came up on a Spotify playlist, and I thought the lyrics were gross and transphobic. I like their early music, but I was really taken aback at how unevolved the lyrics are.</em></p><p>Oh man Moby, you couldn’t be more mistaken. I looked you up and you are an old guy like me. You should know better.</p><p>First of all, of course, you gotta see the song in its time. I suppose you also blame Washington and Jefferson for having slaves? But do you also blame Paul Robson and Langston Hughes for their naive belief in Russian Communism?</p><p>In 1970, when Lola was released, I was in 5th grade in a New York City public school. We watched while our older brothers attacked the bussed-in black kids, pelting their buses with stones and rocking them till they almost toppled over. Faggot was the worst thing a boy could be called and cross-dressing was so far from my reality that I just didn’t believe it happened. Into this world blasted Lola. I have to admit I didn’t fully get the song at the time. But it stuck like glue in my mind. I went over the words over and over. First it was just funny, but the more years that went by the more I got just how serious it was. Good art makes you think and I have thought a lot about Lola.</p><p>The 70’s were like that for me. I came of age in an era of questioning everything. Lola was just one of many songs that hit me where I think. Another one was Elton and Bernie’s song, “All the Girls Love Alice.” To this day I wonder about Alice and her tragic life. And of course, I’ve never stopped noticing in the Beatles song “Oh Blah Di” that “Desmond stays at home and does his pretty face.”</p><p>35 years later these and other songs still echo in my mind. It’s not that they told me what to think, it’s that they told me <strong><em>to</em> </strong>think.</p><p>Lola and the songs like it, met me half-way. They were not dogmatic or preachy. They were ambiguous enough to take you to the edge but not over. The guy <em>almost</em> falls for Lola. He pushes her away, but clearly attracted and interested. Amazingly for 1970, and far from unevolved, the song treats Lola as a full fledged woman.</p><p>Change is incremental, and even though you have moved along in the last 35 years, it doesn’t mean other people have. I would bet that people “less evolved” than you are still being sucked into thinking by Lola.</p><p>And you know what? Lola is just a good song. “L-O-L-A Lola” is one of the most tongue-satisfying phrases in all of music. The song is infinitely singable, it has an interesting, well told story. It’s funny and the tinkly voice of Ray Davies is just right for the naive boy who left home just a week before.</p><p>Being a good song is maybe the best reason to keep Lola on your playlist. I like the politics of Lola, so maybe a better song to talk about is “Sweet Home Alabama,” by Lynyrd Skynyrd. I’m solidly on Neil Young’s side and his “Southern Man” is yet another one of those thinking songs. <strong><em>But</em></strong>, I honestly like “Sweet Home Alabama,” cause despite its politics, it’s a great song too. And you know what, I reexamine my beliefs every time I hear it. Well done Mr Van Zandt!</p><p>Moby, could you be falling into the all-too-familiar trap of judging the past by <em>your </em>current standards? You did get something right though. The Lola lyrics are unevolved. They are literally from an earlier stage in our culture’s evolution. So, maybe cut the lyrics a little slack and enjoy the song anyway!</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9a01da2490f4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>