<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by John Walker on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by John Walker on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@botherer?source=rss-a45bdfe26889------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 20:04:55 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@botherer/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[You Can Support Labour This Election Without Supporting Corbyn, And You Can Win]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@botherer/there-are-some-arguments-circulating-about-how-with-an-election-imminent-now-is-not-the-time-to-671d35273d01?source=rss-a45bdfe26889------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/671d35273d01</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[John Walker]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 14 May 2017 10:46:21 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-05-14T11:02:23.278Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>There are some arguments circulating about how, with an election imminent, now is not the time to criticise Jeremy Corbyn. Lifelong Labour supporters should, were implored, put aside their issues, and just get behind the leadership in the name of beating May and the Conservatives. It sounds noble.</p><p>Yet it’s infantile and dishonest, and there are perfectly valid ways of earnestly supporting Labour in this election without hypocritically endorsing a man as utterly awful as Corbyn. Now is the time to recognise this isn’t a presidential race, this ISN’T May vs Corbyn. We live in a local democracy with the choice to vote for the MP who will represent where we live. And here, wherever it is possible, we should be vociferously fighting for our Labour (or Liberal Democrat) candidate.</p><p>Corbyn does not deserve support. He will unquestionably lose this election, and it’s frankly childish to delude ourselves otherwise. May and the Conservatives are going to win, and if anything it’s BECAUSE we’ve spent so long focusing on the personalities of two entirely disposable leaders. (Of the last three Prime Ministers, only one has been democratically elected.)</p><p>The emphasis that Labour = Corbyn, so if we want Labour we should get behind Corbyn, is complete nonsense, and absolutely guarantees the Conservatives’ victory. As much as *you* may worship at the altar of Corbyn, as furious as you might be with anyone who dares question his infallibility, you must accept that a massive, unscalable majority of people disagree with you and aren’t ever going to be convinced, let alone in the next five weeks. Corbyn will lose, and good, because he’s a stupid and nasty man who would be a terrifying prospect as a leader.</p><p>“Oh, but that sort of language doesn’t help!” Yes! Yes it does — in fact, it’s utterly essential. What we need as Labour supporters (and if you’re a fervent Lib Dem as I was all my life until their despicable betrayal in 2010, or even bloody Green supporter, you get included in this “Not The Conservatives” group) who are willing to be honest, to say the truth that Corbyn is a terrorist-sympathising simpering fool, and agree with people that he’s unacceptable. And then, with that common ground, make the argument that this is irrelevant when fighting for their own community, for their own schools and hospitals, for the terrifying climb in homelessness seen over the last seven years, for the poorest and the suffering nearest to them. They need to not have a Conservative representing them, representing those in need, speaking for their friends and neighbours. That they’re not voting against Corbyn by voting Conservative, but only against themselves.</p><p>My local MP is Jacob sodding Rees-Mogg, a lazily drawn cartoon of a Tory toff, a man who always looks like he’s wearing a top hat even when he’s not. He turns up to our local church Summer fête, his cartoon Tory children wearing strangling cartoon Tory miniature suits, an imaginary yet undeniable monocle adorning each of their faces. He’s a truly terrible man, possessing a wretched voting record, a virulent climate change denier, locally endorsed by (and unwilling to denounce) chilling far-right groups. So dominant is he here that election guides show a 95% chance that he’ll win in June. Labour oppositions are shipped in, then abandon the area when he wins again.</p><p><a href="https://twitter.com/hrtbps/status/842522925441925120">https://twitter.com/hrtbps/status/842522925441925120?s=09</a></p><p>Our Labour candidate is Robin Moss. He has <a href="http://twitter.com/robinmossfornes">92 followers on Twitter</a>, and I’ve never heard of him before. It’s going to be hard work…</p><p>He’s a good guy. A local councillor, who spends his days running a youth and community project in Radstock. His wife is a primary school teacher, he works on boards supporting fostering, community projects, and special needs.</p><p>Jacob Rees-Mogg went to Eton, Oxford, then worked in the City in icky emerging market financial gunk. His father was William Rees-Mogg, former editor of the Times, and life peer.</p><p>If you care about the people who live in North East Somerset, <em>it’s really not a difficult choice</em>.</p><p>For so long as North East Somerset’s election discussion is “I don’t want Corbyn as leader” and “Labour supporters must rally around Corbyn at this time”, Mogg is OBVIOUSLY going to win. There’s no doubt about that. No one is going to convince a traditionally Conservative area to vote for Corbyn! Not least if they bloody lying when they try.</p><p>BUT, I think it could be possible to convince people to vote for themselves, for their families, for those they see struggling or suffering, for those in need. No, that’s not going to convince NES’s shotgun-wielding farmers. But this is a wildly complicated region comprising the poverty and struggles of places like Keynsham, Radstock and so on.</p><p>And YOU live in a wildly complicated region. They all are! And in not one of them will you find a meaningful majority that wants to see Corbyn as PM, and in not one of them will you convince people by lying to them, pretending it’s meaningful or sensible to put aside horror and support Corbyn. But if you show them how THEIR Labour (or otherwise) local candidate would protect THEM, then there’s a chance.</p><p>The funny thing being, if that happened enough, the Conservatives could be defeated. They won’t, because for some reason the whole country isn’t going to read this and agree and do it — inexplicable, I agree. But they could be. And when they aren’t, maybe what there could realistically be are a few more areas with non-Conservative representation. It’s worth a try.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=671d35273d01" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Peculiar Similarities Of Online Mobs]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@botherer/the-peculiar-similarities-of-online-mobs-9818637a1ac8?source=rss-a45bdfe26889------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9818637a1ac8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[labour-party]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jeremy-corbyn]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gamergate]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[John Walker]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 05 Aug 2016 10:11:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-08-05T12:39:51.054Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>There’s a pattern of behaviour I’ve noticed that two very different internet campaign groups have in common. On the surface GamerGate and Jeremy Corbyn’s <em>enthusiastic</em> social media followers have very little in common. GamerGate is a misogynist and bigoted right-leaning movement that seeks to limit or destroy any notions of progressiveness within the gaming industry, while purporting the only really care about an elusive understanding of “ethics in games journalism”. The Corbynites, Corbynistas, or whatever awkward name is pasted upon them, is a far-left movement that seeks to see the current leader of the Labour party accepted and endorsed at all costs, including the cost of elections. They are, undoubtedly, extremely different. And yet, I think there’s value in exploring just how peculiarly similar they are.</p><p>(I must first express my confusion and gratitude to the Corbyn gang, because while I was in the process of planning this article, they made things suddenly an awful lot easier by going and getting themselves a hashtag! So alongside #gamergate, we now comparatively have #wearehismedia, making the comparison so much easier.)</p><p>I have had the dubious displeasure of being on the receiving end of abuse and furious hostility from both groups, although by far my predominent experience has been of GamerGate (GG). Where #wearehismedia (WAHM) have entered my timelines has usually been as a consequence of my retweeting a Labour MP, or an article that’s not positive about Corbyn, and been given a brief taste of what incessantly bombards the retweeted. I also have an unhealthy habit of looking at the replies other people get, and then at the timelines of those sending the replies — it’s a fascinating anthropological horror that I can’t look away from. And in doing this, I’ve seen the same behaviours cropping up for both, again and again.</p><h4>There Is No Abuse!</h4><p>GG, from day one two years ago, has been an exercise in outrageous denial. Beginning (as it unequivocally did) as an attack on a lone female games developer, in response to a frighteningly unhinged blog post from an ex-boyfriend that suggested this woman had been in a relationship with a games journalist, it was born of the horror of the doxxing, and life-destroying boiling hate that descended upon her. It became a crusade, and every last iota of dirty business in games journalism was going to be stamped out, just so long as there was a woman’s life to destroy in the process. And central to this tidal wave of venom was the absolute belief that there was no tidal wave of venom.</p><p>I would receive hundreds and hundreds of insulting, cruel, or threatening tweets in a single day, mention this — even retweet them — and then receive a hundred more telling me they hadn’t happened. “Show us a single threatening tweet!” they’d demand in their dozens, suspiciously at once, often threateningly. So I’d show them one, and the rules would change. “That person has nothing to do with us!” “Anyone can put ‘#gamergate’ in their tweet!” And so on. People could post walls of the awfulness they’d received, and by mystical means none of it would count, or even exist. Jpegs with red lines all over them would be produced to demonstrate… well, to demonstrate the curling madness in the mind of the creator, but then be widely distributed to discredit the attacked individual no matter how nonsensical, usually accompanied by cruel, abusive messages. There were plenty of red-scribbled jpegs made in my honour. And I stress that I got it way more easy thanks to being a guy.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/720/1*zDcwar_gjf3TOOY51KnuGQ.png" /></figure><p>Anyone who ever mentioned on their social media that they’d been targeted would immediately be <a href="http://wondermark.com/1k62/">sealioned</a>.</p><p>Any undeniable proof would be immediately assigned a conspiratorial origin, most likely written by “anti-GG”, their imagined enemy that actually consisted of everyone else on Earth. False flag! FALSE FLAG!</p><h3>Dave Adams on Twitter</h3><p>@jessphillips how do you know they&#39;re @jeremycorbyn supporters . Wouldn&#39;t put it past some people to call out so it looks like JC supporters</p><p>Would you look at that. This was a vice chair of a union responding to those pointing out Corbyn supporters were heckling at the Labour leadership debate. And this happens endlessly. It’s not Corbyn’s fans! It’s people pretending to be Corbyn’s fans to make Corbyn’s fans look bad!</p><p>But this is as nothing compared to the most extraordinary incident. Unite General Secretary Len McCluskey <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/entry/len-mccluskey-some-posting-abuse-jeremy-corbyn-opponents-mi5-agents_uk_57922face4b0e3583c791e8e">announced a couple of weeks back</a> that the abuse of Corbyn’s opponents was most likely to be coming from MI5. From spies. Immediately people with volumes of abusive messages sent from their accounts were confirming that yes, of course, it had to be MI5! There was no other possible explanation. A government espionage organised false flag! (Corbyn’s team are no fan of MI5, it should be noted. Last year John McDonnell <a href="http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/politics/labour/12005431/John-McDonnell-signed-letter-calling-for-MI5-and-armed-police-to-be-disbanded.html">signed a letter</a> calling for MI5 to be disbanded, the next day <a href="http://www.theguardian.com/politics/2015/nov/19/john-mcdonnell-denies-backing-call-to-end-mi5-and-disarm-police">denying that he’d signed it</a>, then <a href="http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/john-mcdonnell-insists-he-did-not-read-leaflet-he-signed-calling-for-mi5-to-be-disbanded-a6740821.html">claiming he hadn’t read it</a> before signing it, then one day later <a href="http://www.thetimes.co.uk/tto/news/politics/article4618872.ece">finally admitting</a> that yes, he’d signed it but <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/2015/11/21/john-mcdonnell-mi5-letter_n_8616022.html">thought it was about something else</a>.)</p><h4>The Whole Media’s Against Us!</h4><p>The core of the success of GamerGate was not a desire for arbitrary cruelty. That was unquestionably the motivation for various ringleaders within the ragtag group, but these few were taking advantage of a disenfranchisement felt by the masses in its numbers. Cruelty was the result, but it wasn’t felt to be arbitrary — it was this poor, maligned underclass finally fighting back against a world and a gaming press that had turned on them. These were (mostly) young straight white men (you have never seen a group flag-waving its few non-straight-white-male membership quite so wretchedly) who saw an industry that predominantly serves their every desire as somehow turning away from them, replacing their desire for bloodthirsty man-shooting with games about brushing hair or going for a nice walk. It didn’t matter that 90% of the mainstream games being released were bloodthirsty man-shooters, and that the games they saw as tearing down all that was holy were minor indie projects — it was the end of things, and the gaming press only cared about minorities now because of political correctness. (Women are still, amazingly, considered to be included by the term “minorities” by this lot.) For them, GG was about standing up against the evil media for the few remaining scraps of rights afforded to the poor downtrodden white straight man, and if the only way to do that was to burn down the lives of people who had different tastes to them, then so be it. And why? Because they were representing the masses, standing up for the real gamers, daring to be the ones to speak out and stop the invasion of the minority. And no, the walloping contradictory irony of this has never been even noticed. The cruelty isn’t arbitrary — it’s utterly delusional.</p><p>Turning to #WAHM, while the motivations are completely different, the same batshit sense of delusional downtrodden status while believing they’re representing a majority, is a massive driving factor.</p><p>Using another technique in common that we’ll get onto below, WAHM have latched onto a wildly unscientific and never peer-reviewed <a href="http://www.lse.ac.uk/media@lse/research/Mainstream-Media-Representations-of-Jeremy-Corbyn.aspx">study from the LSE</a> that “proves” Corbyn receives far more negative coverage in the nation’s newspapers than any other leader. 75% of the coverage was negative! (This figure has mysteriously risen to 85% via the whispers of the internet.) There! Proof!</p><p>This is a study of the two months following Corbyn’s surprise win as Labour leader, during which time he was primarily refusing to speak to the press, that astonishingly doesn’t compare his coverage to that of any other political leader, either now, or at a comparative time in history. In other words, it’s a study that shows that the press is negative about the leader of the Labour party, which, well, yes — not exactly a surprise with a predominantly right-wing press. But somehow concludes from its findings that Corbyn is treated “well beyond the normal limits”, and has “arguably reached new heights”. Except that’s not argued, nor demonstrated, in <em>any way</em> by the study. It’s as if they’d declared they’d proved that cars are more dangerous than motorbikes, but exclusively looked at deaths caused by cars. It’s woefully unscientific in its design, and wildly unsupported in its conclusions. And it, on its own, is demonstrative of nothing beyond what we already knew: the press is negative about politicians. (I think the press is definitely very negative toward Corbyn, and I think it’s unquestionably more positive about politicians far more abhorrent than he could ever be, like Theresa May — it’s just this study doesn’t prove it.)</p><p>(It’s worth adding that this study is so dreadful that in its forward it states,</p><blockquote>“Even more problematic, the British press has repeatedly associated Corbyn with terrorism and positioned him as a friend of the enemies of the UK.”</blockquote><p>This would be the press <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pGj1PheWiFQ">literally quoting Corbyn</a>. A statement he <em>repeatedly</em> refused to recant when asked to by the press over the two months studied.</p><p>So the press is against them. They’ve got proof! The media is maligning them and only them! The LSE study states, “He was also systematically treated with scorn and ridicule in both the broadsheet and tabloid press in a way that no other political leader is or has been.” This study took place at the time when it was erroneously reported by the press that David Cameron had once <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Piggate">stuck his dick in a dead pig’s mouth</a>. I really can’t add to that.</p><p>But no, it’s different when it’s Jeremy! It’s unfair when he’s maligned by people stating things he said! This is proof that they’re scared! They’re the majority the press is too scared to sell its newspapers to!</p><h4>Obsessing On A Single Graph</h4><p>One of GG’s favourite tricks is to find a study, a poll, or best of all, a graph, that “proves” one of their themes to be true. It doesn’t matter where the study comes from, how poorly the poll is conducted, and most of all, how wildly out of context the graph is taken: this is solid gold! And they’re going to tell you about it.</p><p>Some batshit weirdo far-right organisation puts out a press release announcing that freedom of speech is being suppressed by the liberal media, and they plaster the internet with it like they’re trying to wallpaper the place. A D-list celebrity will tweet something about how they hate SJWs, and it’ll be retweeted into the ground, then made into a jpeg and tweeted alongside a jpeg of a yucky ew-cooties woman saying something different. There will be a specious chart that “proves” Kotaku and Polygon give extra coverage to games about haircuts, and they’ll use it like a weapon for months and months, obsessively coming back to it in every argument, wrapping it around their shoulders like their flag.</p><p>And oh boy is this prevalent in the WAHM-bammers. And it’s one particular graph, and it’s so woefully misunderstood.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/634/1*Sx2b5fjCCFUtsH16-h4jqg.jpeg" /></figure><p>This, here, you see, is the proof that Jeremy Corbyn was basically Prime Minister until the attempted coup by the Parliamentary Labour Party. He was a point ahead! That he’s eight trillion points behind now is entirely because people who weren’t him didn’t manage to stop him from being the leader of the party.</p><p>Except this poll is, of course, a significant outlier. If you look at every other poll published after this, but before the sacking of Hillary Benn that initiated the vote of confidence, he’s behind in <em>every single one</em>. But it doesn’t matter! It’s not important! Proooooooooof! It doesn’t matter that polls of Labour voters show that more of them would want Theresa May as a leader over Corbyn. It doesn’t matter that poll after poll keeps showing “anyone other than Corbyn” as preferable to Labour voters than Corbyn. Because he was ahead in that one poll that one time!</p><p>And look at all the people at the rally! That’s, what, 3,000 people! How can you say that he’s going to get the party obliterated in the next election when they represent 0.03% of the total number of people who voted Labour in 2015?! LOOK AT THE GRAPH!</p><h4>They Have Some Weird Obsession With The Jews</h4><p><em>This article is not quite finished — there are a couple of other examples, including obsession subservience to a deeply flawed individual, the invention of an imagined “anti-” organised group that actually includes everyone who isn’t them, and the actual “anti-” organised groups who end up being just as revolting as those they oppose. But I’ve got to go out.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9818637a1ac8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How Jeremy Corbyn Could Have Saved The Labour Party]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@botherer/how-jeremy-corbyn-could-have-saved-the-labour-party-6cfa1bb139ec?source=rss-a45bdfe26889------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6cfa1bb139ec</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[jeremy-corbyn]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[labour-party]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[John Walker]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 21 Jul 2016 23:25:38 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-07-22T10:25:58.943Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>There’s an assumption that seems to have been accepted by all sides of Labour’s present turmoil: that the 2020 election was inevitably lost from the moment Corbyn won the leadership in 2015.</p><p>Those against him argued that he was unelectable, that the broader Labour electorate would never get behind him, that a far-Left party could never gain wide support. Those with him, as has become extremely clear in the last few weeks, saw the possibility of winning in 2020 as not only unlikely, but — astonishingly — undesirable. And yet the truth is, were Corbyn the man we are so vociferously assured he is by his colleagues, backers and followers, then I believe a 2020 win would not only have been possible, but even likely.</p><p>There is a scenario in which a bemused, dizzied Jeremy Corbyn, suddenly finding himself in charge of the party with which he has fought and which he has fought for over the previous 32 years, became a leader that mesmerised the nation. A version of history that would see the enthusiastic young, and embattled veterans, of the UK left rising up with a voice of optimism and hope. An alternative timeline where the party isn’t split into three bitterly divided factions (roughly, the few genuine Blairites, the Corbynites, and the socialists who do not believe Corbyn represents them), each supported by minorities of furious shit-flinging supporters, spiraling itself into a sub-Liberal Democrat oblivion.</p><p>I believe that Labour really doesn’t have a positive outcome at this point. Each future scenario appears to end in some form of evisceration. The most explosive outcome is currently the most likely: Corbyn wins this latest leadership contest, is incapable of forming a front bench — let alone a full shadow cabinet— 80% of his MPs refuse to cooperate with him, and the party splits into two, three parts, each as ineffective as the other, none providing an opposition to the most terrifying Conservative government since Thatcher’s ‘80s heyday. The party collapses and perhaps one of the remaining factions manages to assemble itself into a new opposition.</p><p>The less explosive option is no more comforting. Smith wins, a bland and unknown man who has MPs reluctantly work with him, but voters are alienated and unsure, and turn toward safer, known options. Perhaps the Lib Dems have a minor recovery, find their way to double-digits, Ukip regains some of its losses after their protest voters decamped back to the Tories, useless entities like the Greens and other minor players get a useless boost. The Tories gain hugely, because that Mrs May seems like she knows what she’s doing at least, eh. Labour begins a slow fade into translucence and eventually nothingness.</p><p>In short, things are pretty screwed. But they didn’t need to be.</p><h3>What could have been</h3><p>12th September 2015. Jeremy Corbyn assumes office as the Leader of the Labour Party. There is shock throughout the party at this serial maverick, the most rebellious MP within the party, a staunch opponent of Blairism before it even had such a name. Only really known for his participation in protests, his association with organisations like Stop The War, his outspoken criticism of nuclear weapons, and some concerning remarks regarding various terrorist organisations and despotic leaders over the years, no one is sure what’s going to happen. Many are very upset at his appointment, and plans to unseat him have already been whirring into motion in the last few weeks.</p><p>But people are shocked when he uses his first few days to meet with the media he might once have stormed past, arm held up, lips snarled. Instead he stops in the street, greets the journalists, and uses these opportunities to let the UK know what his plans are, his intentions, his hopes for a new left-wing Labour party with socialism at its core. When he’s interrupted with questions about his associations with <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JJDPV7hEsdc">prominent anti-Semites</a>, his <a href="http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3191393/Jeremy-Corbyn-defended-controversial-vicar-banned-social-media-promoting-clearly-anti-Semitic-material.html">defence of the repulsive Rev. Stephen Sizer</a>, his calling <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pGj1PheWiFQ">Hamas and Hezbollah his “friends”</a>, he stops and says, “There are comments I’ve made in the past that have perhaps not properly conveyed my beliefs, and I will be addressing them shortly.” He then goes on to speak of his intentions, his goals.</p><p>Corbyn goes on to accept invitations to prominent news programmes, The Today Programme, Sunday Politics, Marr, and even more breezy coverage like PM. He wants his message of an anti-austerity, hope-driven future to reach people, to let the electorate know that Labour is once again a party that intends to represent the working classes, the struggling middle, the environmentalists, the technophiles, the young and the disenfranchised. After years of Conservatives targeting the poorest, the weakest, the least, he will be their voice in the fight back. And he will not need to worry about this being derailed by the issues of his previous associations, because he’ll refer to the statement he made just days ago. An excerpt from that statement:</p><blockquote>“As you will have seen on the television, in the newspapers, and most commonly on social media, there are comments I’ve made in the past that do not put me in a flattering light. I am deeply proud of how hard I have fought for the matters in which I believe, how I fought against the invasion of Iraq, how I have campaigned against the cruel, punitive taxation of Britain’s poorest, my fighting for the trade unions, for LGBT rights, for the re-nationalisation of Britain’s public services. Along the way I’ve made mistakes. One such mistake was referring to the groups Hamas and Hezbollah as ‘friends’ — I regret this language now, and recognise how hurtful and upsetting it is to the Jewish people of Britain and the world, against whom these organisations hold such abhorrent views. It is my fervent belief that only by working with all sides of a conflict can resolution be found, and as such it is important that these groups be heard and understood, but this does not excuse the language I used at the time…”</blockquote><p>His shadow cabinet, many reluctant but willing to try working alongside him, are invited to join Corbyn and his core team to discuss their concerns, to raise their own desires for the party. It’s tricky, but there’s a greater sense of unity starting to form, the beginnings of some trust. John McDonnell remains a pain in the arse, but people are willing to work around him.</p><p>Corbyn’s getting a bit of a reputation for his television appearances. He doesn’t behave like other politicians, he doesn’t evade questions, nor talk in circles. He talks like a person, and people start listening. He cares about things they care about: fairness, taxing the rich to help the poor, ending austerity, not wasting billions on Trident. In Cameron’s increasingly elitist Britain, Corbyn is the man talking about the horrors of increasing homelessness, about the increasing reliance on food banks, on the struggles regular people are facing while the Conservative rich prosper. And he’s not just talking about it to crowds of activists, but to the whole nation, on television and radio, connecting with people in a way that the population had forgotten politicians could do. There’s a groundswell of support, and Labour creeps ahead of the Conservatives in the polls for the first time in many years.</p><p>The newspapers react angrily. Corbyn is treated abysmally by the majority of the printed press, and there’s a backlash from the public Right, but it feels manageable, and papers find themselves on the wrong side of key issues. They don’t back down, they fight harder for Cameron’s government, but a savvy Corbyn uses the more neutral online areas of the press, and social media, to calmly counter their claims.</p><p>The centre-right of the Labour is deeply unsettled, and there are talks of coups, attempts to end this movement, but ultimately they don’t have the numbers. The centre-left are willing to ally with Corbyn, recognising that many of their own aims can be met by this coalition between centre and far left. The new intake of socialist Labour MPs are recognising that Corbyn can be part of the new guard as well as the old guard, and get behind him.</p><p>The centre-right of Labour, the remains of the Blairites, are anachronistic in the party, and either soften or defiantly bluster until their time is up. (When the Chilcot report is later published, they’re done for.)</p><p>Corbyn’s now famous every-man approach to media interviews is also seen in Parliament, his refusal to engage with Cameron’s pantomime at PMQs making the prime minister look foolish when he attempts his toffish barbs. Corbyn’s willingness to wittily deflect such insults without resorting to his own disarms his opponent, and his cutting questions see a formerly reluctant Labour back bench roar in approval. Cameron, for the first time since 2010, starts to look weakened.</p><p>The EU referendum is approaching, and the Conservatives are split over the matter. Turning on themselves they divide into Leave and Remain, Cameron and Osborne heading up Remain while Gove and Johnson step up to front Leave. The government looks fractured, and is polarising the issue. But Corbyn sees an opportunity. A life-long skeptic of the European Union, he has a unique perspective of the matter, realising that he can reach both sides in the debate. As the leader of Labour, he is obviously seeking a Remain vote, but as an EU agnostic, he’s able to understand and speak to those who are unsure, those concerned by what they’ve heard from an unrelentingly anti-EU newspaper industry.</p><p>His impassioned statements on the subject, making clear his concerns about the EU and his plans to see those matters addressed and changed by Britain’s remaining within the union, reach a significant proportion of voters. His ability to skewer the arguments made by Farage becomes notorious, and when Britain narrowly votes to remain in the EU by 56%, Corbyn is given a significant proportion of the credit. The nation sees him as a leader, someone willing to listen to and understand voter concerns, and despite Cameron’s success in the referendum, the divided Conservative party is left badly weakened. In-fighting remains, and Cameron’s cabinet has to undergo a significant reshuffle after prominent resignations from the defeated Leave MPs.</p><p>Despite there being four years to go, people are already talking about 2020 as the year Labour will return to power, the Conservatives embroiled in internal scraps that give Corbyn’s shadow cabinet repeated opportunities to score significant victories. Cameron’s position is increasingly uncomfortable, and rumours of a vote of confidence keep bubbling up in the political media.</p><h3>What is</h3><p>Yes, of course this is a rather idealistic fantasy scenario. But it wasn’t impossible. Something like it, something close to it, is imaginable. At least, it would be if Corbyn were really the leader his supporters tell us he is.</p><p>Instead he is a leader who only expressed regret at his “friendship” with terrorist organisations when <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=72VBOYFoWzU">pinned down by the home office select committee</a>, and even then told outrageous lies that mean he will be hauled in front of them once again to find out why. He is a leader who doesn’t seem to have even the most <a href="https://twitter.com/JonnElledge/status/756076411606228992">basic grasp of how government works</a>. He is a leader who, <em>alongside only Nigel Farage</em>, called for Article 50 to be initiated immediately after the Brexit vote. He is a leader who has alienated his entire Parliamentary Labour Party by refusing to work with them, listen to them, even be bothered to tell them when <a href="http://www.newstatesman.com/politics/staggers/2016/07/thangam-debbonaire-mp-why-i-have-no-confidence-jeremy-corbyn-s-leadership">he’s colossally fucked up</a>.</p><p>Yes, absolutely, many will respond to this by saying that these were MPs who were determined to oust him before he’d even sat down — what chance did he ever have of working with them? The imagined scenario above is an attempt to respond to this, to suggest that a true leader could have attempted to address this, rather than resign to it in an embittered bunker. But it’s in fact the opposite. MPs are <a href="http://www.liliangreenwood.co.uk/lilian_s_speech_to_nottingham_south_labour_party_members">coming forward</a> to explain that they tried so hard to work with him, despite their hesitation, but his ineptitude and arrogance made it impossible for them to do their jobs. Currently the Labour party still has a shadow minister for a department abolished over a week ago, despite not having even close to enough shadow ministers for the positions that <em>do</em> exist. It is shambolic, and when you’re the opposition to a genuinely despicable and cruelty-driven government, shambolic is utterly unacceptable.</p><p>His is a leadership that, incredibly, takes on board <a href="https://www.buzzfeed.com/jimwaterson/labour-leader-in-the-lords-to-corbyn-stop-taking-credit-for?utm_term=.pxQJ6AK2o">the complete rubbish made up by cultish followers</a> and then declares it in parliament as fact! We really are in the terrifying position of the factless, furious and deeply abusive followers that police social media for dissent seeming to actually be the people working with this leader.</p><p>And it’s too late. The Corbyn That Could Have Been never was, and instead a <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hOZZF5XCDBM">bitter, spiteful and apparently deeply uninformed man</a> has his hands around the throat of the Labour party, determined to cling on and throttle it until he can finally preside over its rotting corpse like some mad king. Labour can only either implode or fade away, and Theresa May now strides confidently toward 2020 (hell, if Corbyn wins, even call an election next year knowing she can slaughter the party far sooner) safely aware she can shred Britain’s human rights, privacy, and the lives of the poorest and weakest, unopposed.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6cfa1bb139ec" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>