<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Brad on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Brad on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@bradharper94?source=rss-6bcbe759742a------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 00:07:22 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@bradharper94/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[S011 / who knows]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@bradharper94/s011-who-knows-73005bf4dd01?source=rss-6bcbe759742a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/73005bf4dd01</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[sorare]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Brad]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 17 Nov 2024 13:54:22 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-11-17T13:54:22.003Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/864/1*4cY3DP7KT9nGpR2n5XMVqw.jpeg" /><figcaption>three forwards what game are you playing</figcaption></figure><p>If there is an opportunity to write about Sorare it is a three-hour train journey to Nottingham.</p><p>You sit, type and hope someone does not spawn next to you knowing either they judge you grammatically … or on the off chance they try to sell you their latest Korean craft.</p><p>After all it is the land of Clough. Football bleeds through the city here.</p><p>There is an edge to it, a youthful vibrance, an honesty — it is no nonsense, no fluff, and who knows the condition I will frequent in come the early hours.</p><p>Lineups are done. Ronaldo reappears. Even in the land of Sorare you always feel you have a chance when he is around.</p><p>Realistically there is only a handful of gameweeks left where he will feature — maybe that creates a deeper level of appreciation for him being the first name on the team sheet.</p><p>He has an air of immortality about him. You dare not question his captaincy — despite the risk of rotation, limited minutes and a big chance missed. In many ways he still embodies my relationship with the beautiful game, and he remains the only link to a time gone by.</p><p>Despite any risk, any alternative, any negative — he’s in. You would wonder if I was talking about the one they replaced with Weghorst or S05 for a second there.</p><p>I have advocated for a change from S05 since the beginning, so to still see this in the discord servers and social feeds is somewhat amusing — but Erik learned the hard way. You do not replace Ronaldo with Weghorst.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*KW45-9sCPPTefw7hjz6yTw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Weghorst over Ronaldo. What.</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Why?</strong></p><p>Let me keep the original why simple. Fantasy football tends to go beyond the five.</p><p>There are times when I wonder if Marcus Rashford is still on the pitch, but yes in football you play 11 v 11.</p><p>Since the dawn of time we play eleven v eleven. Look I know it is seven a side on a Tuesday and that whittles down to five on your kids 9th birthday party at the local sports centre — but professional, high-level football is 11 v 11. Even in Saudi they play 11 v 11. They have subs and everything.</p><p>This is nothing to do with card prices, collections, classic or in-season. It is merely trying to replicate the authentic experience of being a Football Manager.</p><p>So this is why it was being suggested during a gamecycle where the feasibility of S011 was the equivalent of getting a half-decent initial offer out of PawelTrader. It is just not going to happen.</p><p>Thing is do we actually need it, and have I thought this through? What we want and what we need are two different things.</p><p>I want this train to arrive at its destination at the speed of light, but I do not need it to. Ironically someone on this train is in a hurry, others might want it to breakdown so they can avoid an awkward afternoon meeting, All of us are on the same journey. There is also one fucker on here without a ticket — but realistically it’s not impacting you or your journey.</p><p>To need it would suggest a state of life or death. Like this game, the economy, the environment could not function without S011. Or S07. That is most likely false … and this is from the guy who suggested it before it was cool.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*WO1QpApY1vaqWEXdUyqdbA.png" /><figcaption>Make scouting great again.</figcaption></figure><p>What we can establish is that sentiment is in a place where there is a greater level of appetite for something to change. I know this because in 2022 all you were met with was despair when this was suggested. Now many are open to the conversation about a change. Or to quote a previous article, a patch update.</p><p>S011 is an easy answer to a difficult question. Like has anyone actually thought about how this will all work?</p><p>It is the default factory setting because it has been the default factory setting since Sorare began.</p><p>Let us play more cards that will fix it. Although what are we trying to fix?</p><p>Well, in theory we play S015 currently. 3 teams of 5. A perfectly legitimate response.</p><p>The reality is we are suggesting changing the gameplay experience — and that is for many what we need. Something to combat the week-to-week tediousness that will eventually become tedious before further iteration. Now S011 feels like an experiment worth exploring — but it is a formula that no one has ever explored in depth.</p><p>No one wants S011 beyond those red rare cards alright. Chuck a threshold up there thank you.</p><p>Three hours to Nottingham is not enough time for that formula.</p><p>No one seems to go beyond the surface of well pick 11 and have some subs — but do you realistically see yourself wanting to play S011 across every tournament, every scarcity, every division, every single week. Dare I say that sounds a little excessive.</p><p>Is there ever a correct answer when the default to why is … why not?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/875/1*_uzOrd3YjPwNM-LKg74C0g.png" /><figcaption>Will we get a midseason product / community update?</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Why not?</strong></p><p>Recently Laird spoke about S011. He’s American they only count to 5. I never thought I would hear limited and whale in the same sentence in 2024 — where a Kylian Mbappe sets you back £70 with change.</p><p>(That was British sarcasm.)</p><p>If we have the expectation that an Mbappe would skyrocket under a format where you go 4 4 fucking 2 then that ship has most likely sailed. We can agree on that one Laird.</p><p>Why there is a dismissal on all things 11 is that the insinuation is Sorare would treat it like any other product decision. They would make a full-scale change without thought or nuance to each scarcity. The assumption you would play S011 at Unique is somewhat amusing.</p><p>You know Pransky needs to use those guys for the limited teams.</p><p>Rather than leading with the attitude of dismissing any change, I am always someone who likes to replace ‘no’ with ‘yes if’ — all a bit easy to say no. You do not want to sound like a child refusing to eat peas at the dinner table.</p><p>So is the answer no I do not want S011 or yes if they can find a format that is equally or more engaging?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*M2aWL_smYiLaNHjpjnP1jQ.png" /><figcaption>passion rewarded one arena ticket at a time.</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Where</strong></p><p>There is a school of thought that classic competitions are a bit dead. Cards are hard to sell, rewards feel a bit lacklustre, and cash is hard to accumulate. Then you have the supply doing that supply thing come next season. Compounding.</p><p>That seems the best place to start and the only place to stay. What does classic theoretically look like in 2030 with five times the supply? … and probably seven new users.</p><p>Is S011 ‘the thing’ for a spike in new users? Again, no.</p><p>All this is for is to make things feel a little fresh, reignite some interest in a part of the game where it is not so compelling … and going back to the original pov from 2022, start to feel a bit more like football.</p><p>So to answer the question in your head right now — S011 is not a permanent thing. It’s a DLC for you gaming nerds … and then it disappears again. Then returns again each season after all those shitty little international breaks end. We all get so grumpy on an international break.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0sT7Q068rfk1WdEU_XjACQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>The greatest of all time.</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Stars will be stars</strong></p><p>Ronaldo is the star and we can’t use him alright so just have a bit of respect here.</p><p>One of the arguments around S011 is that you either play all the stars, or the stars disintegrate into the abyss. If everyone has the same lineup then ultimately there is a lack of variance in the results. I get that bit.</p><p>Football is unfortunately a game being played where there are not many world class players. It is also fair to say Shane Warne was a better spinner than Jack Leach. Just because time has moved on is it only an assumption to presume the standard has improved.</p><p>The standard of average has improved — but not the stars. Messi and Ronaldo is peak football. A lot of these guys now are distinctively bland — on and off the pitch.</p><p>Vini Jnr over Ronaldinho? Give me a break.</p><p>When we think about assembling an 11 we subconsciously think about Salah rather than the strikers of Racing Santander. It makes me continually wonder whether S011 has a permanency across the land — but who am I to dismay a K-League manager wanting to drop a 3–5–2 with a hybrid setup of Ulsan, Jeju and hint of Daegu.</p><p>We are literally talking about cards for pennies here. Is this not just about something that is just different to play and nothing more? Occasionally they release new maps on Call of Duty for a reason.</p><p>For the variance … just add a cap innit. You could change the cap week to week.</p><p>Contender is just too messy — but individual leagues. That is where S011 is more likely to sit. You know when they do those Croatia specials and you were like shit who do I have — yeah that’s where S011 goes. Maybe.</p><p>The stars? Well, everyone loves Haaland when it comes to their FPL sides. In fact they bend over backwards to get him in at every opportunity. So the stars are still stars here. You just can’t have all six of them.</p><p>A capped format — a captain that does not contribute to the cap — and a limit of Pep’s soldiers that you can show off. Yeah go on have some subs.</p><p>Now should S011 be week to week, should it be a standalone monthly special, should it bypass getting stuck in division 3, should it rotate on the calendar from one league to the next, should you need essence to enter — what do the rewards look like, and realistically can you make them worth it?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*QbQGeV3x5Ud7gLns2CgMiQ.png" /><figcaption>bit weird innit essence.</figcaption></figure><p>I don’t know. (Just because someone talks about sorare it does not mean they know more than you or have all the answers. Or care that much about all the answers.)</p><p>All this train journey to Nottingham has made me think is that transitioning to S011 is not so much about it being a permanent takeover, but more just something on the calendar.</p><p>Should S011 be seasonal with one fuck-off jackpot prize? Not sure it’s compelling enough for a whole season.</p><p>Does it bring in new users? Probably not (I think seasonal could but again they’ll fade)<br>Does it encourage you to buy more cards? Maybe but nothing drastic.<br>Enough to increase card prices? Probably not.<br>Is there enough in the kitty to offer something meaningful? Who are we to say.<br>Define a meaningful reward …</p><p>For now, S011 in my mind sits as some kind of longer-format monthly &amp; end of season competition with a cash prize. It is not replacing S05.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/853/1*XO8Y3CAVkveXOX4KqeuqXQ.png" /><figcaption>yeah they won’t be giving you half a million.</figcaption></figure><p>You know when they released the Premier League competition last season and it was all a bit new. Yes S011 is just that. It works with S05.</p><p>I think it is limited (not quite literally as the red cards have a place here) to individual leagues with full licenses. I think they move away from this best score nonsense to accumulative scoring over the period.</p><p>On certain special weeks you can add cards to the S011 prize pool but cash, credits, tickets, experiences, essence for the following season, jerseys, strava kudos — these are the things that feel best under the scope of longer-format competition. Why would I want to jump up and down for an in-season card in April? Should I need an in-season something in longer-format S011?</p><p>Oh, and I should stress. You do not need to reward people every week in this type of format.</p><p>You can offer cash for the highest score in each game week — but the prizes can be dynamic. Tickets one month, signed jerseys the next, they could give away some 2025/2026 essence to get you started for next season — the cash prize is the bit at the end of the rainbow. Let the pot build. Let the community excitement build with it.</p><p>See how you get lost in more questions and shit ideas than answers, and you even have to think does this make any real difference to sentiment? Can you really change sentiment to a product at the intersection of these tribal worlds of football and gaming?</p><p>Is all of this S011 stuff actually just too late? How easy are these experiences to obtain? What are sorare’s relationships even like with the leagues — is it against licensee agreements to have a competition close to FPL? Does everything just come down to the bottom line — and is this stuff just a waste of time and resource?</p><p>Brad what am I going to do with all these La Liga 2 players I have stumbling around the gallery? Honestly. Nothing.</p><p>That said — they thought rivals was a good idea.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/806/1*eOgxJpdFbOMUGwl6FalNdg.png" /><figcaption>make card design great again.</figcaption></figure><p><strong>S011 is not replacing S05.</strong></p><p>You offer multiple formations, you innovate the gameplay experience, you remove this 50% captain bonus, you limit stacking, you have subs for the first time, you regularly tweak the criteria for entry through the end of season — but in short it does not feel right as a week-to-week comp in the current classic format, and it does not feel right being accessible to all. It feels only right in those major full licenses.</p><p>After all, stars will be stars — but ironically most of the excess is in contender. Imagine beating McBride at SPL S011 (what a mouthful that is) with a limit on Celtic players. It’s like heaven — I don’t need cash for that.</p><p>I don’t think you can fix the mess of contender with S011. You may as well allow the stars will be stars stuff by giving more utility for those cards in the major leagues.</p><p>When they initially released Ultimate Team, EA added it into the gamecycle later in the year — it was not some Day 1 launch. Ultimately it added fresh impetus to the game (before they worked out that was the money maker) — now S011 can follow that trend. It does not need to be in the game from day one. Let’s say it runs alongside S05 from February — May.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/810/1*5EmdF7gVaLSvVlfeqMLO9Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>gameplay innovation in its purest form.</figcaption></figure><p>This is not replacing S05. Or S015.</p><p>If anything we are taking that 3 teams of 5 — and then we are adding in a mode halfway through the year where the 15 turns into 30 (S011 and subs)</p><p>People always used to say well if you add something in then you need to take something away. Okay, well (if you absolutely have to) for a start take away the cash from classic S05 and add it in to S011 from February.</p><p>Then do not distribute the cash every week. Let the pot build — like the Euromillions which drags you in from time to time on a rollover. You do not need to reward people weekly because they are working to a seasonal prize.</p><p>… and here is where they can make things a little feisty.</p><p>Now S011. It’s new, it’s different, it’s shiny. It is only here from February to May.</p><p>If Sorare says tomorrow. Right, in February we launch S011 for the PL, La Liga &amp; Bundesliga. But there is a catch.</p><p>You need to have a team in S05 classic Division 1 or Division 2 to be eligible to enter. Oh, and here is another catch.</p><p>If you do not enter a lineup in those competitions on a game week — you will be automatically relegated.</p><p>Now that turns classic competition into something with meaning. You are rewarding players who are actively engaging with the product. You are making people strategize. You are thinking about scouting again. You are giving people enough time to get on board and get up the divisions (remember you have 3 teams to attempt landing one in a higher division)</p><p>If you are unable to qualify, maybe attention will turn to the longer-format for those involved and it might make things a little less competitive on the S05 end of things towards an end of season. Divisions should also reset from time to time.</p><p>You have S05 classic for in-season cards (again maybe take away any cash win on the table here if you have to), you have in-season for cash and you have longer-format S011 running for the final few months of a season.</p><p>BUT BUT THE WHALES WILL WIN BRAD. Mate. Bruno Fernandes is like £50 chill out. And you will be capped to prevent a team of stars anyway.</p><p>If you just think S011 is a straight replacement for S05 — that seems a bit lazy. Let’s make them work in parallel.</p><p>I would love to see an S011 in the calendar as a test comp from Jan to May. PL, La Liga, Bundesliga. Cap, subs, limit stacking. Try it out — cash prize.</p><p>Sorry this does not fix the excess of crap you have in contender. Not sure you can actually fix that unless there is a burn mechanism.</p><p>Then maybe down the line do something for the new MLS season. Do you just keep it going for every league? (I don’t think so sorry … but) who am I to suggest the K-League doesn’t deserve some kind seasonal S011 with a half decent prize at the end of it all?</p><p>For now, stick to the major 3 leagues as that focuses the stars will be stars narrative. This is also mainly down to S011 being the fresh experience — if it was there from Day 1 of a season it would be mind-numbing by the end of it all. Probably.</p><p>My fear is that S011 is no more than that — and maybe that is perfectly okay for now. Honestly who knows — and really who cares.</p><p>Just be open to new ideas, new ways to play rather than trying to gaslight your way out of it. Gaslighting is just for people not clever enough to troll. Look at me, gaslighting you.</p><p>Anyway. Someone said something about a pint in the Kean’s Head — and we all know Ronaldo is going to score.</p><p>*edit — so did Weghorst.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=73005bf4dd01" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Sorare / two sizes too small.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@bradharper94/sorare-two-sizes-too-small-10e660c572c1?source=rss-6bcbe759742a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/10e660c572c1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[sorare]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Brad]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 12 Nov 2024 11:49:14 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-11-12T11:49:14.072Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*r8KrxtmEF5L8oDHP6m5gWw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Jacket is the right size.</figcaption></figure><p>There is an irony to Sorare.</p><p>A moment I look back on which symbolises a lot of feeling to the platform and the direction it has taken in recent times.</p><p>Winning a jersey for it to ultimately arrive two sizes too small.</p><p>It is meaningless — but almost poetic.</p><p>Maybe there was a supply problem, a breakdown in communication, mismanaged expectations — ultimately you sell and move on. You can start to picture the irony here.</p><p>This is an international break with no intention of a meltdown. I will save that to the well-seasoned experts.</p><p>We play a game to watch some football, lose a bit of money and (very) occasionally win some. It really is no more than that and nothing to give a fuck about — first world problems.</p><p>Enjoy the vibes and selling shirts two sizes too small for £9 on Vinted.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/686/1*s87XZh80ujiF1s6pObsw8g.jpeg" /></figure><p>Sorare is like any game — it evolves one patch at a time. Iterating into something unplayable, one meta after another, before a trailer and shiny new release tempts you back in several months later.</p><p>This is ultimately not the (version of the) product we fell in love with in 2020-something. Anyone still swallowing that pill needs some fresh air, but it still scratches an itch — just one with less potency than before. Do you still see yourself dedicating time to Sorare in 2030? It is perfectly okay to say probably not.</p><p>Be a European Super League by then anyway. You will also be able to field eight teams per scarcity and you will need to quit work to craft essence for an arena ticket.</p><p>Solutions to the status quo are often ones that add more complexity to the platform. (shit) Ideas are ultimately easy — execution and understanding the right passage combined with the right voices to listen to is the tricky piece.</p><p>A lot of senior leadership / management within Sorare have left during the last few years — so those voices are just as much internal ones than external noise. My assumption is those internal changes have been a major factor in the direction of travel — for good and bad.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/745/1*yjt9nAzy9wksr-DRQYPQeQ.png" /><figcaption>simpler times for many.</figcaption></figure><p>You do not need data to understand where things are heading. One that is the real dream for the sustainability nerds — net zero. There really is an amazing piece of irony in card values dropping to zero in the quest for a “sustainable game.”</p><p>Please name any other product, brand or service you interact with where your primary focus is its sustainability. I can only think of the NHS? If you put Sorare in the same level of importance to our health service — again, fresh air is an amazing antidote.</p><p>As someone who has taken far too much ‘I told you so’ pleasure in being that annoying one in the community who won with an Al Hilal stack before it was cool, I wanted to give some thought to the next patch update of the product. A mix of solutions, statements and questions to a product team for consideration. Or you if you are still reading.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/993/1*OmMmkf-99Xn0hOOLEJWcRw.png" /><figcaption>2024 / £66</figcaption></figure><p><strong>99.99% of the community cares mainly about one thing / card prices.</strong></p><p>That one was a statement. I’d argue a fact.</p><p>You can over complicate a lot of things, but really a lot of any frustration or international break meltdowns boils down to this. Losing coin and not winning enough back in return. When the fun stops, stop.</p><p>It is the equivalent of overlooking how a club performs during the 90 if they win matches. Or overlooking nearly bottling a semi-final against Coventry. Coventry!</p><p>It is perfectly fine to only care about not losing all your money.</p><p><strong>99.99% of the community think through self-interest. Including me.</strong></p><p>So take this into account when you see those meltdown posts.</p><p>Classic is a bit dead though. Sorry.</p><p>Score Saudi. That was sarcasm.</p><p>They also thought you could regularly win in season cards that are half decent without getting your wallet out playing classic competitions. This was cute thinking — community is often wrong when it comes to strategy. Sorry.</p><p>They literally stripped any previous form of accumulating cash and wonder why gallery values continue to take a dive?</p><p><strong>There are multiple games within a game — each need their own line of thinking.</strong></p><p>Pranksy wins £20,000 in a game week. He/they is playing a different game to you or I.</p><p>The game would most likely be completely dead without Pranksy.</p><p>Too many of the product changes are used as a blanket rule (easier innit) rather than any form of nuance to different scarcities and audiences. The biggest culprit to this has been the continual destruction of Super Rare.</p><p>To consider:<br>Remove divisions and essence in SR and above. Simplify this end of the game.<br>Re-introduce a threshold for the two highest scarcities to encourage appetite for progression.<br>Be less intensive when it comes to fitness (if you want to reintroduce that) at this end of the game.</p><p>Keep to S05 at SR &amp; Unique. More on that later.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*oJbBSjQe1yO6ogJ9-UkimQ.png" /><figcaption>nostalgia.</figcaption></figure><p>You could add in some in-season nuance to a threshold. You could even make it really super-duper hard to win regularly to protect the bottom line. Ultimately at this scarcity you are dealing with legacy customers (and those willing to invest will be more self-aware to learn) and so adding complexity here is less threatening.</p><p>It is unfair to make comment on Sorare’s financial position as ultimately we do not know the numbers — so it is unjust on me to suggest taking money out of the lower end and pushing it up the chain.</p><p>Winning £1500 in a game week where a limited Mbappe is like £80? Food for thought.</p><p>I see limited as the scarcity where you ‘learn the game’ and its nuances. It is plug and play.</p><p>Otherwise Sorare is creating a game where people go backwards. Stop making product changes with a blanket rule. All this demonstrates is a lack of internal understanding of the product. That one was an opinion.</p><p>Sometimes in life you have to go backwards to go forwards — but in Sorare terms we have broken down on the M1.</p><p><strong>In short, treat Super Rare &amp; Unique completely differently to Limited &amp; Rare.</strong></p><p><strong>Bring the community together. In the physical world.</strong></p><p>One area of complete mismanagement is community integration.</p><p>To a point where it is genuinely shocking.</p><p>This is someone who runs a community-based business. Where sorare have continually fallen short is the integration of a large group of people.</p><p>Create pop-up events in major cities, even charge for tickets. Chuck some dollar behind the bar and drag a professional footballer along to answer some fan questions. Or get John Nellis to do Karaoke.</p><p>A Q&amp;A with some managers. Do something.</p><p>The format can be low-intensity, require little upfront investment of time or money — but it gets people feeling part of something much larger.</p><p>Going to a running club creates a greater appetite to run.</p><p>The way sorare treats its customers who have spent say £40,000 or more on a game is very different to how a Chanel would treat a customer. Different industries entirely, but some principles of a premium service has no boundaries.</p><p>People have created a loyalty to the product from early adoption but not necessarily those who play the game. Getting people in the same building regularly is something has significant upstream impact.</p><p>Would you enter a tournament to go to Sorare HQ? 3% collection bonus upwards. You see how you can innovate without doing anything THAT complex, adding in a layer of service. Just get some pizzas in it’s not that hard.</p><p>Turn your medium post pitch notes thing into the physical world. Basically.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*J7lPMPAO8y1npUopM7eFsA.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Divisions is flawed — but only down to HOW people play Sorare</strong></p><p>The best way to explain this is. I think.</p><p>To achieve D1 you need to play the meta. The better cards will get you there and naturally that requires a heavier level of investment moreso than skill.</p><p>To do well in D1 you need to play anti-meta. That is down to everyone around you having the better cards and only differentials will cut through the marginal gains.</p><p>That just seems a bit flawed to me?</p><p>To consider:<br>moving to capped competition to prevent higher-level stacking and encouraging skill.<br>making that cap harder as people progress.<br>not relegating people after one game week.</p><p>I think this leads me on to something that upsets the collections brigade.</p><p>If you think stacking is a skillful way of playing sorare then we would happily agree to disagree at a sorare meetup. It’s sorare on autopilot mode, Pep roulette aside.</p><p>It is also a perfectly valid response to question — why should we even reward skill?</p><p><strong>Stacking is boring and is not the way the game should be played.</strong></p><p>Says the guy who wins with Al Hilal. (can’t beat em, join em.)</p><p>I will go one step further. I am unsure whether the game was even designed to be played this way.</p><p>When you load up any other fantasy football (/sports) product, you are hit with a restriction. It could be a budget or a cap on how many you can have from a particular side.</p><p>Collections can be rewarded through exclusive competitions to win signed jerseys, tickets or experiences for respective clubs — rather than exclusively through marginal gains in competition.</p><p>Gameplay innovation is a major component in reducing boredom. Working on changing the stacking meta would re-energise scouting, trading and hopefully everything in between.</p><p>Take or reduce the captain bonus away from those who stack. Do something.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*9xRcROmqzXfOQxXacoa_OQ.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Classic is dead. Change the narrative.</strong></p><p>Classic is dead as ultimately it stops your route to cash.</p><p>Now offer more market credits here as an alternative or use this competition as a means of innovating.</p><p>Here are some things to consider in what could be done for classic competitions at both the limited or rare scarcities.</p><p>Hold up… sorry before I begin.</p><p>Can we also just stop letting people use super rare cards in limited competitions? Who thought that was an idea worth exploring? Okay let’s stop before I go into international break meltdown mode.</p><p>That said, this is where I think classic could be interesting.</p><p>Shifting classic to either S011 and/or longer-format competition.</p><p>Maybe we need a different format for classic competitions?</p><p>What I am trying to say here is just separate the two distinctions from in-season and classic and give them both a unique gameplay experience.</p><p>The supply of cards is so heavy now that I think it is really the time to move away from S05 at this end of the game. Again, sticking to those same anti-stacking principles.</p><p>A supply issue that intensifies with every season. Seriously what is supply looking like in 2030 — based on the assumption that new user growth is continually stale.</p><p>With this current model, what card win looks good in March when the European season is nearing an end? What happens if from February every manager on Sorare stocks up on their essence until the start of the next season?</p><p>Longer-format competition is the backbone of rewarding skill. It encourages people to build broader, larger galleries and it provides attention to cards not considered as stars.</p><p>After all, the stars end up in Saudi anyway.</p><p>By moving to longer-format competition and not rewarding people in classic each game week here you are selfishly sending people to the auctions if they want to play the in-season competitions week to week.</p><p>Just food for thought, there is no perfect one-fits-all solution. If we had jackpot cash prizes month to month in classic, does that make it at least feel more alive? Ultimately this is the part of the game that requires deeper innovation.</p><p>Getting people to change things up week to week is healthy for the game economy. Or just buy another PSV player I don’t know.</p><p><strong>In short, treat classic competitions differently to in-season competitions.</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*nVVxATwQyLYv_5Gjbv9P1A.png" /></figure><p><strong>A global game, remember?</strong></p><p>It looks as if Sorare is going in reverse here.</p><p>I wonder next season whether we will have Austria, Croatia, South Korea?</p><p>Personally think new licenses, new players to scout, new cult heroes to adore are a part of the game. Anyone immersed in the world of Football Manager will adhere to that.</p><p>Difficult to find those folk if you are going to take away those clubs and leagues, equally creating a further indent on supply.</p><p>Making further inroads filling out Portugal, Denmark, Italy, France, this thing called the Saudi League where some of the best players in the world play, the European Super League when it eventually appears. Add the A-League I dare ya.</p><p>I would love to see more updates around licenses and less smoke &amp; mirrors to the community. In my self-interest let’s be honest.</p><p>As this is approaching two thousand words, let’s keep this relatively short.</p><p>Stop making product decisions with no nuance across each scarcity. Think about integrating community at scale and do not be afraid to use classic as your means to innovate gameplay and the structure of competition.</p><p>Otherwise, that Al Ittihad stack going to hit different in the ACL next year. See you then.</p><p>Just make sure the jersey is a large when you get that Saudi license.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=10e660c572c1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Three years on Sorare.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@bradharper94/three-years-on-sorare-2100c722dbb7?source=rss-6bcbe759742a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2100c722dbb7</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Brad]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 28 Mar 2024 13:24:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-03-28T13:24:23.820Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CxwzZjTS8GjClBlBq4Xyiw.jpeg" /><figcaption>San Mamés</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Three years on Sorare.</strong></p><p>Three years. Two wins. One Messi.</p><p>It has been a few months since a Sunday afternoon provided the space to write down a few thoughts — running a business, travel, occasionally trolling the MLS online all taking centre stage as I<strong> wanted some time to digest structures, roadmaps and more corporate ‘transition period’ jargon</strong> that ironically you think Sorare would be the escape from.</p><p><strong>Last week I was reminded of why I still play the game.</strong></p><p>A Saturday evening in Bilbao. Work emails off, socials deleted, bus journeys to Biarritz &amp; San Sebastián part of the getaway.</p><p>Of all the picturesque scenery, incredible food, jaw dropping architecture — it was the cauldron of San Mamés that made the trip an unforgettable experience.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CQiZNQ-M27QYcCpP31QsXA.jpeg" /></figure><p>It is a format that feels a little cloak &amp; dagger, but a few months ago I contacted Sorare about this trip and enquired for two tickets for the Bilbao / Alaves fixture that corresponded with the time in town. This was not the first game I have attended through Sorare, and I must stress the mechanism to get the tickets is pretty seamless.</p><p><strong>The tickets are always fantastic. Communication on point</strong>. There are multiple physical touchpoints that could elevate this from Sorare’s perspective, but the lack of comfort personally comes from the non-existent online clarity to how these tickets are secured — and who are they available to? I genuinely do not know.</p><p>If you can just ask for tickets, why do not they have this as a regular special weekly? Or made available through the Sorare coin economy?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4J8wiSKqgpTwrmoKmePW9Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>#sorareontour</figcaption></figure><p>At the same time, during the week my gallery value dropped to a greater number to what the holiday cost. Silver lining for you.</p><p>So as prices continue to decline, <strong>the route to cash becomes convoluted</strong> and a new structure rips apart the plans made by many — it is now moments and experiences that sit as the pillar to why I think Sorare is still worth the time, money &amp; energy. For now anyway.</p><p><strong>This new structure.</strong></p><p>Like anything, you can only assess through the eyes of your own gallery.</p><p>A lot of community love is effervescent online before a ball has been kicked. Quick look would suggest I will have over 50 lineups to work through, all knowing deep down that I have little interest in reinvesting in new season cards this time next year.</p><p>Old cards do get you new ones. Try selling them.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Wwrkwb0GqvvvwmdpnWELdw.jpeg" /></figure><p>As someone who has prioritised depth, new structural changes make little inroad to gallery composition. That said, the “in season” loop is a tiring one. My view is you can only get away with this once — realistically new users (who do not exist) can stomach it.</p><p>For me, the question I always ask is “is this worth my time?” — sure, you can extract fun whatever way you take it from the game, but for me when an Erling Haaland is a £90 limited card, you can be assured (cash comp aside) this is not worth my time.</p><p>Even adopting a philosophy of ‘not spending big’, the week in Bilbao highlighted that prices have taken a tanking since this new structure announcement.</p><p>Admittedly this has been a bit of a surprise, with most of my hits coming from (starting!) rare keepers. <strong>You would think multi-entry would increase the need for cards?</strong></p><p>No data to support this (go down the mpenn route if you want some data) but these are a few thoughts to why I think there is this recalibration happening — and it is concerning.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*bMHnp3_5oQZihgI_qIKGtw.jpeg" /><figcaption>not every picture goes to plan.</figcaption></figure><ul><li><strong>Managers are winning less £.</strong></li></ul><p>Playing for threshold in my eyes was a little boring, but it was a fundamental component to why many played the game.</p><p>If you remove or tighten the squeeze of the main vehicle in how many build a cash balance, this is only compounded when combined with …</p><ul><li><strong>Managers are reluctant to deposit</strong></li></ul><p>When you look at this yearly in-season cycle, the difficulty in consistently building a cash balance and a card market which is currently race to the bottom, there is a real reluctance to deposit. The cycle continues.</p><p>Sure, some have FOMO’d. That addiction will always be there for some — but I think the excitement of game week ahead will quickly deteriorate by an avalanche of new cards needed in August.</p><ul><li><strong>Legacy managers have been burnt bad.</strong></li></ul><p>Your Celtic guys, Zagreb, Zenit, the stereotypical ‘Sorare’ stack has just become significantly damaged. Finally, the quality of player has equalled to the quality of reward made available.</p><p>That I like, but equally if you have been hit hard it is going to provide an extra layer of distrust to continue to invest.</p><p>Managers leaving the platform can be a good thing in the long run though. I fully expect scores to be less eyewatering.</p><ul><li><strong>Rare Plus.</strong></li></ul><p>This one is a bit of a kicker. Personally, rather than removing I would have preferred to see this stay with a slight tweak to the rules. Only as moving from Rare to Super Rare (a trajectory I am on) has become relatively unachievable with the new structure.</p><p>I thought the idea was about progression, rather than ‘stay in your lane’</p><p>There is an argument that the competition structure in Super Rare upwards should be different to what is below.</p><p>A lot of managers are in a halfway house between these two scarcities, and new format just is not attractive enough to continually deposit and invest.</p><p>More experiences in the prize pools (please)</p><ul><li><strong>New users</strong></li></ul><p>Look, the body of evidence would suggest it is not happening.</p><p>Burning legacy managers with no consistent pipeline of new users is not a healthy position to be in.</p><p>Listening to Nanzo’s POV on the changes is something I am super aligned with, and for someone of that expenditure to say this is pretty damning. Worth a listen when you have a minute.</p><p>I have been critical of treasure hunts, rivals and so on from day one. This stuff just does not land and does not currently justify the time.</p><p>On one hand I am incredibly appreciative of Sorare. The experiences, the memories it creates, but on the other I am a little tired (already) of the direction of travel.</p><p>Is this worth the outlay, to create a cycle where I must buy the same guys every year, and the hard stop they have created in realistically progressing through scarcities.</p><p>The Saudi play now is really the last ‘edge’ you can get from the game in terms of forward planning. It is not gallery defining (for me) if it does not get licensed, but whilst this new format might be sustainable on one hand … the real question is whether it will be as exciting and compelling with the other?</p><p><strong>It is not going to take another three years to find that out.</strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2100c722dbb7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[saudi (silly) season. volume 2.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@bradharper94/saudi-silly-season-volume-2-e6ef3dd4758c?source=rss-6bcbe759742a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e6ef3dd4758c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[saudi-arabia]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sorare]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[football]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Brad]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 02 Jan 2024 15:08:09 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-01-02T15:18:10.402Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*1QKJe8z9i6zeL9-XhfFhAA.jpeg" /></figure><p>January appears.</p><p><strong>A new year dawns.</strong></p><p>A roadmap iterates.</p><p><strong>In a game where “star players” are set to be “star players”</strong> — a land of no Ronaldo, Benzema, Mane, Neymar, Mahrez to name a few feels disingenuous.</p><p>Sorare in 2024 is a poignant moment in the trajectory of the platform — whether this results in resurgence, or a need for complete rehabilitation is something only time will tell.</p><p>Admittedly,<strong> I see 2024 bringing change</strong>. Some for the better, some for the worse. We can talk about that another time.</p><p>My gallery construction has always been around predicting the road ahead, understanding that Sorare in 2021 is not Sorare in 2025.</p><p>So whatever change occurs, I will be ready. <strong>Play the game in whichever way you see fit</strong> — my approach is no more superior than the next … just the way I like to play.</p><p>On a personal level, the last few months on Sorare has been engrossing. Signed shirts, VIP experiences, with significant yield directly from the Premier League Winter Special. An ever-reminder that ‘winning’ is still one of the main mechanisms in finding joy out of the game.</p><p><strong>I would like to personally thank those at Sorare who are involved in the operational side of those experiences — it has been seamless.</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*e_PidgVVtWyr6zo6KjilcA.jpeg" /></figure><p>It has been a couple of months since a previous foray into writing about Sorare on medium.</p><p>If you follow me on X (prev twitter) you will know there is always one consistent analysis / rambling that I share and that is the nuance of the introduction of the Saudi League into Sorare.</p><p><strong>Awkward conversations are never easy</strong>. I want to put the context into one space, as the combination of a January transfer window alongside being halfway through the current season is a perfect moment to reignite things.</p><p>… before we begin, a reminder that any commentary you see on Sorare is littered with self-interest.</p><p>This is no different.</p><p>I have been building teams for some time now for a multitude of reasons. Whether it is scored, or the players slowly integrate back into European / world football. After all, full internationals at major nations for minor prices are of natural interest to me.</p><p>… and yes I do come with a DAZN subscription and enjoy watching the mighty Al Hilal.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/978/1*YxjgwbUvIog5OvLndogelg.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Gallery Construction</strong></p><p>One of the consistent themes of any pushback is why is my focus purely on this league in relation to future scoring.</p><p><strong>You will find players in my gallery from across the globe</strong>, maintaining a theme of ‘buy low, sell not at its lowest’ to avoid a greater dent of gallery value depreciation.</p><p><strong>Football is a global game</strong>; my baseline view is everything should be scored. That should be the aim, working your way back to whether that is achievable. Coverage being the main obstacle combined with how the league perceives Sorare.</p><p>Whether we like it or not, there is a strong gambling heritage to Sorare and its userbase.</p><p>Fans from Greece, Sweden &amp; Australia to name a few should be allowed to experience the beauty of watching your team play and taking a tier 4 reward on Sorare.</p><p>Communication should be consistently given on where things stand with future licenses, filling in the blanks across England, France, Portugal, Brazil, Argentina etc as a priority. As managers, <strong>consistency brings positive sentiment.</strong></p><p>You need to know where things stand in the short &amp; medium term so you can plan ahead accordingly.</p><p>The main reason to why the levels of interest in the Premier League special have been below expectation is not enough time were given to plan accordingly.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*JE51HDB1S9hNvZaekF0ZxA.png" /></figure><p><strong>Game breaking</strong></p><p>We need to be careful as a community by moving into lazy assumptions.</p><p>For what it is worth, I could have grabbed a number of tweets from that time period from many users. <strong>The fear of something new overlays the actual reality.</strong></p><p>At least Nepenthez is someone who sticks to his own convictions, puts money where mouth is and on the whole, rarely complains for the sake of it. I will always respect those managers.</p><p>The assumptions piece is something that litters broadcast commentary, demonstrates a lack of true understanding, and closes the door in a game that should be open to all.</p><p><strong>If we revert to summer, Sorare made the right call.</strong></p><p><em>“We will not cover the Saudi Arabian League for the 2023–24 season and will re-evaluate the situation before the next season starts.”</em></p><p>However, the season is now halfway through. Data is available to assess, the assumptions were just … lazy.</p><p>If we take the use case of <strong>Oscar</strong> as an example at Shanghai Port — <strong>who was used as a yardstick for gamebreaking</strong> — it is inconceivable that he would be able to maintain his level of scoring. As the season closed and form dipped, his scores reflected that he is no more game breaking than Joey Veerman.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*v0RBHmn-yArjpY1UmRWSig.png" /><figcaption>Oscar brought back down to earth in the last 18 game weeks.</figcaption></figure><p><strong>WHY</strong> is it acceptable for Celtic, Inter Miami &amp; PSV to dominate but not Al Hilal? Has there been <strong>ANY</strong> discussion on <strong>Lionel Messi turning Robert Taylor into prime David Villa</strong>. Please understand your own bias.</p><p>Sadio Mane or Carles Gil. Come on, seriously.</p><p><strong>Entering the second half of the Saudi season tells us the league is no more top-heavy than counterparts in Europe</strong>. With each passing window, and the new strategic changes to increase the foreign quotas in squads, this will only become more competitive.</p><p>A team like Al-Shabab that hosts international talents like Yannick Carrasco, Romain Saiss &amp; Habib Diallo are only four points above relegation. <strong>Players that walk into ANY MLS team.</strong></p><p><strong>It is okay for Felipe at Chengdu but not Fashion Sakala at Al-Fayha</strong>. Why? Because it suits you.</p><p>Sadio Mane has 8 goals in 18 matches. Firmino 3 in 17. Benzema 9 in 15. Mahrez 8 in 19. <strong>This is not game breaking in the slightest.</strong></p><p><strong>Do not fear change</strong> — embrace it and adapt your galleries accordingly rather than relying on the status quo.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*TP6eq05zYBsP7sQ_ZKFAdg.png" /><figcaption>Domination that is accepted and adored by the community. (+80 goal difference!!!)</figcaption></figure><p><strong>You need a license for that</strong></p><p>Again, Sorare made their position clear.</p><p><em>“To maintain a more healthy game balance, we will only ever cover leagues when we have licensed clubs in that league (the Chinese Super League will remain as covered as coverage here was introduced before our rule). Cards in non-licensed leagues competing for card rewards from licensed clubs would lead to an unhealthy game balance.”</em></p><p><strong>The goal should be to secure a license</strong>, but I wonder if there is a moment in which that shifts to a change more immediate? Is it Salah in the summer? Kimmich? De Bruyne? Rodri? — or does it have to be folk with Sorare heritage but less reputation on a global scale — Tadic? Almada? Bouanga? Gil? Veerman?</p><p>I suspect the addition of an extra two foreign players will lead into more defensive players joining the league, as well as improving the standard of goalkeeping which will allow for more full stacks in operation. This will also reduce the levels of goals scored across the league.</p><p><strong>There has never been any community complaint about the likes of Davidson or Wu Lei</strong> dominating scoreboards, but for Sadio Mane or Ruben Neves it has seen as somewhat inferior? Players with far less mints across all scarcities and zero stature on the worlds game are accepted?</p><p>Through Sorare’s inconsistency around game changes, <strong>the notion that they NEED a license is false. Within reason they can do whatever they want as long as the levels of Opta coverage is there.</strong></p><p>If the position remains unchanged, <strong>questions need to be asked on HOW they are getting on in achieving the license, and if the decision is not to pursue — WHY?</strong></p><p><strong>It is almost delusional to suggest the riches of Saudi Arabia will not disrupt your gallery over the coming winter and summer windows.</strong></p><p>To have a GLOBAL fantasy football game where you are unable to use Benzema, Ronaldo, Neymar, Salah (Al Ittihad), Kimmich (Al Ahli), Mane, Mahrez, Casemiro (Al Nassr) is just a bit … odd? Are we seriously suggesting the signings to this league are nobodies? <strong>Have we lost touch with football reality because they have a low L15?</strong></p><p>Would Manchester United fans have complained about signing Neves, Mitrovic and Milinkovic-Savic in the summer window?</p><p>As we have said consistently on our podcast <strong>‘Limited to Sorare’ </strong>I wonder if roles reversed and we were looking at MLS scoring post-Messi, would there be any real demand for it, or just a nice to have?</p><p>The human rights piece. <strong>Playing politics is a dangerous game </strong>— we score in Russia, China, we accept foreign ownership from this part of the world in the Premier League. Let’s just be careful when we start going down a political path under the backdrop of Sorare being a global game.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*GtMVKXOkmV_JIrwPpWdTng.png" /></figure><p><strong>Asia needs some love</strong></p><p><strong>The real victims of Sorare in 2023 have been the managers that play solely in the K-League.</strong></p><p>Without coverage (or attributing blame), it is an area of the game that turns into nothing more than an afterthought.</p><p>You would bleed life into the region with the introduction of the star names in Saudi alongside an expanding A-League in Australia.</p><p>Admittedly the J/K-League is an area I have little interest in, but I hope the managers who play in that part of the world get a resolution as soon as possible. <strong>Ultimately we should all be allowed to enjoy the game regardless of where we play.</strong></p><p><strong>Give reasons to play, build broader galleries and invest.</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*mEuYr4nOLLvv8cgPx6PuYA.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>The future of Football</strong></p><p>Pure conjecture, but on a sidenote, <strong>I fundamentally believe the future of football is coming.</strong></p><p>The continual demise of European finances, the diminishing number of truly <strong>STAR</strong> names in world football, the cost impacted on fans in a global financial crisis, the unrivalled riches from this part of the world.</p><p><strong>There is everything to suggest football institutions like Inter Milan or Barcelona could go bankrupt</strong>, a European Super League will find the right formula / messaging, and the Premier League will move into losing its biggest names again (Kane last summer, Salah next) — a power can shift very quickly.</p><p>The calendar will change, the way in which we interact with the game will change, the rules will change — nothing is off the table in relation to the future of football.</p><p><strong>So does Sorare need the Saudi League? No.</strong></p><p>Does it need the MLS? No. Does it need the Peruvian league? No? Austrian? No. Croatian? No.</p><p>When you create a dynamic where you are happy for Karlsruher v SV Elversberg, Altach v WSG Tirol, Shenzhen FC v Dalian Pro, Cadiz v Granada to be scored, you do have to wonder <strong>what is so bad about Al Taawoun v Al Fateh.</strong></p><p>In the meantime, you can continually shift some of your Saudi players in my direction (rare upwards) as this is a strategy I am operating. <strong>Does that give me the right to suggest this should be scored? No chance.</strong> Should I be upset if this does not arrive next season? No chance — you know the risks taken with any strategy.</p><p>… but as the window opens, players look for game time going into major international competitions and contracts continue to run down with major European clubs not prepared to stump up the wages, the pathway the likes of Ronaldo, Neymar &amp; Benzema have legitimised in the minds of fans is not going to slow down anytime soon.</p><p><strong>Sorare</strong> — either get ahead of the game on this with clear communication or cross those fingers that the biggest players in the world do not continually depart in that direction.</p><p>Good luck all — the dreaded red X is entering your gallery this January.</p><p>In the meantime — you can find the podcast ‘Limited to Sorare’ here: <a href="https://open.spotify.com/show/2LW8uWqnlafjCus2Mazytp">https://open.spotify.com/show/2LW8uWqnlafjCus2Mazytp</a></p><p><strong>Thank you.</strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e6ef3dd4758c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[competition time.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@bradharper94/competition-time-79a98e027c66?source=rss-6bcbe759742a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/79a98e027c66</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Brad]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 13 Nov 2023 22:39:53 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-11-14T13:11:20.042Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/828/1*x4ajJOj2U4QemPCnauUQzA.png" /></figure><p><strong>Winter is coming.</strong></p><p>A time where form meets function, squads are stretched, and reality kicks in.</p><p>Did they break out like you thought they would do? Is the manager on borrowed time? Are you still trusting the process?</p><p><strong>In the world of Sorare, a play of the wildcard can be a weekly event.</strong></p><p>All those strategic plans made in the summer is either baring fruit or braced for failure.</p><p><strong>As us managers traditionally look to take stock ahead of an upcoming January transfer window, Sorare has other plans.</strong></p><p>The introduction of longer format competition reaches new heights as they launch a <strong>$500,000 Premier League Winter Special </strong>— a weekly endeavour that for 11 game weeks will redefine how we watch some of the most poignant moments in what continues to be the most superior league in world football.</p><p>Sorry Celtic fans.</p><p>This international break ahead is a time in which managers are all asking the same questions?</p><ul><li><strong>Am I in?</strong></li><li><strong>What do I have?</strong></li><li><strong>What do I need?</strong></li><li><strong>How much is this all going to cost?</strong></li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*LguVK15nhU8Vsop_D2YUEQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>There is an expression often used in certain quarters of the amateur sporting world — <strong><em>“it is the taking part that counts.”</em></strong></p><p>This has been a phrase that encapsulates my approach to playing Sorare. I have no expectations of winning. When it happens, it happens. It is an a constant attempt in finding the healthy balance of taking part, wanting to win, not doing something stupid financially.</p><p><strong>So if you think this is the place to tell you HOW to win, then think again.</strong> Sorry.</p><p><strong>What these longer-format competitions are providing is this constant feeling of something new is around the corner</strong>. Maybe this time it will be my time.</p><p>Now even for me, not every long-format competition makes sense to prioritise. Why look to win Bundesliga tickets, when I would then be hit with stomaching the cost for travel &amp; accommodation?</p><p><strong>Not every competition is for me or should be for me</strong> … but when they are, that new-season feeling is back.</p><p><strong>Am I in?</strong></p><p>Without doubt or hesitation.</p><p>Fresh from an Emi Martinez own goal at home to Luton costing me Premier League tickets in the treasure hunt private league, <strong>it is time to take on the Winter Special.</strong></p><p>Like so many, I know the league. I know the players. I know the positive upside if they ever wish to move, or in the case of Ruben Neves’ move to Newcastle, if they ever wish to return.</p><p>Selfishly tickets &amp; jerseys added in would have been a sweeter prize.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*D-eb38cGBY7HVrSSK6L8qA.png" /></figure><p><strong>What do I have?</strong></p><p>So before any competition,<strong> the early question is always what do I have</strong>?</p><p>Sadly, not what is needed.</p><p>The likes of Son, Silva, Rice, Maddison, Grealish, Mitoma, Szoboszlai, Romero, Trippier, and even the mighty Darwin Nunez will all have to fight for their place as the <strong>requirements of needing 4 new season cards for Limited, and 3 for Rare upwards have taken me from the perfect position to the how much is this all going to cost?</strong></p><p>(3 does seem rather extreme SR upwards …)</p><p>It is important for me to make that clear that whilst I have been building a gallery around this core competition since its inception on the platform, <strong>I understand entirely why Sorare decided to implement this approach — even if it is of a negative impact to me.</strong></p><p>I have over 140 Premier League cards of the previous season.</p><p>You see, <strong>this is a new wave of sustainability</strong>. Old cards win you new rewards. New rewards / new cards enter you in competition. Every card in the gallery still has a core purpose.</p><p>Whilst this makes sense for this season, let’s see how that materialises in years to come.</p><p>Any outrage that your older season cards should give you a prerequisite entry to something new is entirely misguided. <strong>You now know the formula that will naturally follow</strong> for La Liga, Bundesliga, Serie A and so on. Anyone that plays Sorare with a trading angle should be taking note of this based on how Premier League prices have played out over the last week.</p><p>Purchases made over the next window of time will be an overspend — so with that in mind the thinking is to buy a set of players that complement the existing gallery, or a direction you are wanting to take over the next few months. A focus of mine will always be internationals, but also AfCon which ironically will be both a blessing and a curse as we enter January.</p><p>I just <strong>prefer buying players with the maximum amount of utility</strong>, and the foresight that any potential move will unlikely be a negative one.</p><p>I do not anticipate these player prices being consistent over those 11 game weeks. They will calm down after the initial hype. With the lack of marketing that has followed since the launch of this competition, <strong>be assured this will mainly be the current userbase taking part rather than a swarm of new users</strong>. This does make things a lot easier to predict.</p><p>Potentially a different story if we start to see a targeted campaign lambasted all over the socials of Haaland, Rashford, Salah and co.</p><p>There is also the <strong>option to upgrade the previous season cards and pay a small premium to the bots </strong>— satonio is an option if appropriate. Retrospectively, I might start doing this earlier in the new season cycle.</p><p>Previous special weekly wins have also taught me that over 30% of lineups did not have a full team (rare upwards) and lots of the lineups were with throwaway players. I expect this to be a little different this time out so interesting to gauge over the 11 weeks.</p><p><strong>Give some serious thought / consideration to how other managers will play the game</strong>.</p><p>Will you run with two forwards? Is it worth looking at fixture-by-fixture or just buying more broadly? How dependable are your guys when they start to play every few days? Who is going to lose their job in this period? What rotation risks are likely to impact your team? With a tougher stance from the refs, your players will likely pick up suspensions over this period as they reach the yellow card limit.</p><p>We can go all day thinking about the variables.</p><p><strong>This is all a lot more plug &amp; play with limited</strong> but rest assured expensive (even now) rare upwards.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*lWYkc-I1AEe_2n79vXpJBA.png" /></figure><p><strong>What do I need?</strong></p><p>In short, <strong>what you need now might not be what you need towards the end of the competition</strong>.</p><p>For the first time we are allowed to enter <strong>3 teams per week per scarcity</strong>, again further stretching out galleries. So this idea of ‘what do I need’ now needs to be multiplied by 3 (<strong>if you choose to play this way</strong>.)</p><p><strong>The plan is to run the full 3 teams in limited and 3 in rare</strong>. I do have to preface the third rare team will be a little throwaway as not a week goes by without thinking … when is Kompany going to do the right thing and play Muric?</p><p>This is only possible as I have way too many premier league players kicking about.</p><p><strong>Taking an objective view, to really immerse into this you will need a lot.</strong> This idea you can run 5 guys for 11 game weeks is never going to happen. Let alone if you choose to play with 3 full teams.</p><p><strong>At first glance:</strong></p><ul><li>3 x Goalkeeper</li><li>5 x Defender</li><li>6 x Midfielder</li><li>4 x Forward</li></ul><p>Depending on whether you feel the play is to double down on forwards, how much you are willing to spend etc will determine your outlook on what you think is the appropriate call.</p><p>Having that extra card from the previous season in the rare competition does relax those bullet points listed above, and it <strong>is unlikely managers will play more than one team in that scarcity.</strong></p><p><strong>The point here is that we will all need spare parts</strong>. Be mindful that players will be departing for the African Cup of Nations during this window.</p><p>Someone with a greater intention of winning might look deeper into the fixtures, but my primary goal is to <strong>bring guys in that complement existing parts of the gallery.</strong> Really is each to their own of how you construct this — but the <strong>building part of the process is just as captivating and fun as playing</strong>.</p><p>Do you wait for the auction? Do you take that player on the secondary or wait for something to cheaper to come down the road? Do you take the path of least resistance and look to stack?</p><p>List or play has been a nightmare over last few days, but hopefully eases up a little during the international break.</p><p>Introducing this at a <strong>270 cap is also a smart play</strong> to limit the impact of stacking. My Joachim Anderson was suddenly shifted back into all-star, and I suspect one or two others will feel that pinch. This leads to a far more competitive gameplay.</p><p>On a personal note, I really like Chelsea going into this period. They have some favourable fixtures on paper during these months, and without European competition should play with a settled side. Nkunku returning does offer complexity going forward (who does he replace and does not have a ‘23/24 card), but on a good day it is clear they will be picking up a lot of points now they have finally found the back of the net.</p><p><strong>Another approach is to play counter-meta</strong>. One of my early pickups has been Jack Harrison of Everton. Now a forward card, at the time of writing they have only minted 2 rare cards — these types of <strong>differentials can be vitally important</strong> — particularly if he can maintain scoring 60+ in 3 of his first 6 games.</p><p>I would anticipate more differentials will appear as the competition unfolds — plenty of cards including the likes of Cameron Archer &amp; Alex Scott are yet to be minted. <strong>Keep an eye on the auctions</strong>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*y8GdM8x-_fUH88Z0s3eH6A.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>How much is this all going to cost?</strong></p><p>Well, <strong>only you can answer that</strong>.</p><p>It comes down to the core of do you want to take part, do you want to win, do you want to find a healthy balance in between?</p><p>As someone with a really deep gallery, it is very rare you have the opportunity to build from scratch.</p><p><strong>So this next 12–14 days is a really exciting window and one that I do believe is just as captivating as playing</strong>. My squad builder nostalgia is kicking in.</p><p><strong>You can easily put a lineup out, experience the competition with no impact on other lineups for £50–£80.</strong></p><p><strong>If you are going into these competitions with the idea of yield and return of investment, then think again</strong>. However, now you know the formula there are trading opportunities at play that have not existed for some time in the Sorare ecosystem.</p><p><strong>More importantly, just have fun with it.</strong> Is that not what this is all about?</p><p><strong>Creating the new-season feeling continually is a brilliant move by Sorare</strong>, and I am really excited to tackle both supporting Manchester United as well as running the opposition stack simultaneously.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-XwenzUcmL5Cbr0GkI2YLw.png" /></figure><p>You can listen to both myself and Kelwyn Looi talk about the Winter Special on our podcast ‘<strong>Limited to Sorare</strong>’ which was designed not to tell you how to play, but how to sustainably go through the scarcities and enjoy the game we call Sorare.</p><p><a href="https://open.spotify.com/show/2LW8uWqnlafjCus2Mazytp">https://open.spotify.com/show/2LW8uWqnlafjCus2Mazytp</a></p><p><strong>Thank you.</strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=79a98e027c66" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Monday evening.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@bradharper94/a-monday-evening-4ef2c8d0aadb?source=rss-6bcbe759742a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4ef2c8d0aadb</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[sorare]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Brad]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 07 Nov 2023 15:23:59 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-11-07T16:51:39.155Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3rhbcFgZ64aaufgGWAJWmQ.png" /></figure><p>A Monday evening.</p><p>The clean sheet from Alaves, the brace from Bernardo Silva all undone by the rashness of Romero as the projected card moves to coins, and the twice-a-week scenario that captivates your schedule reignites come Tuesday morning.</p><p>Sorare is the beautiful game.</p><p>This is not the article to eulogise, lambast or continue to cover old ground — but to wrap up my perspective of two-and-a-half years on the platform as well as explore a direction of travel.</p><p>This will not be neat, tidy &amp; succinct as that does not reflect my current view of the game. There are too many moving parts &amp; I want to try to reflect that in this.</p><p>1,534 competitions played.<br>1,066 cards in the gallery<br>210 card rewards won<br>1 win.</p><p>Current gallery value: £11,554</p><p>Not the stats or finances to project superiority, but to provide context on the words you are reading.</p><p>I am not an expert in all things Sorare, or ever confess to be. Or want to be.</p><p><strong>Sorare to me is fun</strong>. It is not something I am financially dependent on. It is an escape from work, it allows me to connect to a sport I love whilst providing some freedom in balancing life, running a business, relationships etc. It is an evolution from years gaming into the early hours.</p><p>It is a game I play with clients and friends. You can even find me in my lunch hour assessing the auctions or changing lineups when on route to a meeting. The first manager I referred onto Sorare has a bigger gallery value than me and is the number one Spurs collector on the platform. Not a bad return for the Twhatever I received at the time.</p><p>Numbers that are pocket change to the biggest spenders.</p><p><strong>The way in which you play and extract fun from the game is totally up to you</strong>. This is not the place for you to join me and apply group think to feed my ego — but mainly for me to think through my own take on the game as we reach what feels like a pivotal moment in the route forward.</p><p>Similar articles (I always read with curiosity what you see from the likes of Mpenn as reference) have surfaced in recent times — a sign that the product we love is faced with sustainability challenges. Expect less data wrapped up in an oversimplification of the truth.</p><p><strong>Ultimately, there is no perfect solution</strong>. Not in the short term anyway.</p><p>Constantly iterating and experimenting can get you there. Standing still does not.</p><p>A mechanism that caters all — whether that be traders, casuals, whales and the ones who fall in between does not exist. There is a natural tension that exists across the many different subcategories within the community and even any half-baked opinion here I must be cautious with tailoring something around self-interest.</p><p><strong>The way in which I have played the game is to always think ahead</strong>. <strong>I’ve never subscribed to the view that the current product before our eyes is the one we see in years to come</strong>, so my attempt of structuring a gallery should reflect that.</p><p>A high scorer today is not a high scorer tomorrow — 15+ solid years of watching football religiously globally has taught me about the intricacies of the game. Sorare will continue to iterate, innovate, tinker, tailor to prevent the biggest long-term platform killer — boredom. No, not gallery value.</p><p>I have always thought buying the best players puts an increased pressure to win / yield a return. An even greater financial commitment at any level impacts your love for the twice-a-week regime.</p><p>You should never feel safe or complete when it comes to a game like this — there should always be a path to take, a direction for your gallery to move into, a purchase to make. Sorare has done a great job with this.</p><p>To limit financial pain, my whole philosophy has been around depth &amp; thinking ahead. Zig whilst others zag. As others think about a Champions League midweek, I’m thinking more about an upcoming transfer window, AfCon and the continual if they / won’t they with the Saudi Pro League.</p><p>All of this forward planning is a lot easier with the gallery a size of mine — and time served with many errors made. If you have little patience do not adopt this strategy — <strong>play the game how you see fit</strong>. I guess that is the point I am trying to make here.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*7IuMcuylx2nh2C1kiACtag.png" /></figure><p>One of the interesting conversations that needs to be had is at what point does the continual drop of card prices become irreversible? … and how radical can you be in reversing the trend? Do you even need to be radical?</p><p><strong>Sorare needs an injection of new users</strong> — and a discussion for another day, a different type of new user.</p><p>I do not think needing new users is up for debate, but happy to be challenged / pointed in right path on anything.</p><p>It is a difficult task to build a utopian community under the gaze of financial loss or the constant consumer behaviour / desire for more.</p><p>To get the ultimate joy from the platform, currently you must divorce yourself from the community. Build your own private network away from the fanfare. I think <strong>Sorare could do a much better job harnessing community</strong> — there are simple, low-cost solutions in creating events at a local level. You build better relationships with a community away from shared screens.</p><p><strong>Better experience you have with the community and product, greater trust in platform, more likely to spend</strong>. There is probably a graph of sorts that could explain that loop.</p><p>To me it looks as if <strong>creating a best in class product is the main priority</strong>. A business is also built on high-quality service. Greater investment into community management &amp; customer experience should be the next evolution of hiring internally.</p><p>Self reflecting, it feels slightly strange to even type that sentence out. There are no other brands or businesses I would feel any kind of emotional attachment to give consideration to future hiring (my day job).</p><p>I genuinely believe that digging deeper into creating a high-quality customer experience at all levels should be a strategic priority.</p><p>A recent special weekly win reinforced this. Spending £250+ to plug the holes in the gallery to enter, win but then receive a shirt two sizes too small is just an isolated case of a poorly thought-out plan of action.</p><p>Whilst I will just sell the shirt, take the hit on the cards and move on, <strong>at its core is just poor customer experience wrapped around an immensely captivating product.</strong></p><p>Marketing efforts have been below par. They are not cutting through to the dream of mass adoption– will they ever cut through? As genuine innovators, we do not know. Safe to assume probably not. The gameplay, the product they have built is fantastic (in my biased opinion) — but even a diehard fanatic will have to ask themselves at what point is it just not the same?</p><p>Does that eventually turn people away?</p><p><strong>Retention of customers is equally as important as the attraction of new ones</strong>. Even more so in times like this. Again, sorare is actually doing a decent job of this. The userbase is almost too engaged.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*rKMKWozgFmgWRZJsSKtC6Q.jpeg" /></figure><p>An example to give of marketing efforts is on one hand Sorare is trying to move the company away from something crypto-dependent but then launches a marketing ‘Treasure Hunt’ campaign with the sole ‘win’ being unlocked by an Ethereum key when most of your userbase (as well as a significant portion of future userbase) is looking blankly back at you is again just an isolated case of something without substance or clear narrative.</p><p>Maybe I am just too embedded into the game now to really zoom out when it comes to marketing and attraction of new users … because <strong>entering the game now is completely different to when I entered in 2021</strong>.</p><p>Like anything, we are unaware of internal resource or budgets pressures. The outsider looking in would suggest there is so much more than can be done to maximise the value of such awesome life-changing experiences like the AC Milan one shown above. In short, it can feel a bit lazy.</p><p>Should I even have an opinion on this kind of stuff? Probably not.</p><p>I also wonder how diverse they are being when it comes to user testing/feedback. I digress.</p><p>My hypothetical is always ‘<strong>if a Haaland star limited reward was worth £30, would you still play</strong>?’ or if they removed the CAP240 threshold at all scarcities?</p><p>Something that would really negatively impact you.</p><p>Even if you would, you have to show self-awareness to know a great deal of others would not. What is the detrimental widespread impact on that? <strong>A business can crumble from the bottom just as much as from the top.</strong></p><p>To counteract I think Sorare has done a terrific job on the whole of keeping the higher spenders engaged in a very bleak global economy — and rightly so.</p><p>Whilst new users are achievable, my wonder is HOW often they will need new users to keep an inpatient community content? Are they ever content? When will Sorare push back a little?</p><p>How do you change widespread behaviors of return on investment centric? Too much emphasis on financial freedom over fun? Have I not just completely contradicted myself with that last statement when you look a couple of paragraphs above concerned about an ultra-cheap Erling?</p><p>It is not out of the question that Haaland will be worth &lt;£100 within the next 6 months. Rares (not necessarily of Haaland) have also taken a significant hit.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*pPt7UQU9qYfAF88mOa3PkA.png" /></figure><p><strong>One of the initial pieces of genius was the introduction of collections</strong>. What has translated is something with immense potential but again lacking real substance.</p><p>The problem with collections long-term is that as each season appears, the model is built around continuing to build collections. This is not something even a season ticket holder would do.</p><p><strong>You need to build greater emotional and tangible value to your collection</strong>. I almost see an influx of community managers to see collections as the target area to building greater customer experience.</p><p>I think we can tie in the previous suggestion of bringing in a dedicated army of community managers (call them what you like) who can be tasked to deliver best-in-class customer experience.</p><p>Those community managers should be at the very least league or region specific and your point of reference — but also harnessing those strategic relations with clubs, players, associations etc.</p><p>Let’s take Croatia as an abstract example. Who is on the ground? Who is the point of reference for managers from Croatia? Who are the top collectors of Croatian teams? How well do you know the football community locally (what content do they watch, football teams do they support, how do they interact with football?) Do professional / ex players play the game? Can we tap into those microcommunities? How can we build even stronger relationships with those clubs and governing associations? What types of experiences can that provide?</p><p><strong>To 2.0 collections overnight</strong>, anything north of 3% bonus should allow you to activate tournaments that provide access to the things that create greater emotional attachment — tickets, kits, experiences.</p><p><strong>I see a future where we move away from less card rewards to more coin rewards</strong> — with collections providing this incredible landscape to reward product loyalty on a tailored one-to-one level. You will care significantly less about gallery value with this kind of customer experience.</p><p><strong>Own YOUR game.</strong></p><p>You are also directly incentivising collections long-term rather than its current format of marginal gains. We have already seen how collections can stimulate a market — but in current status quo that only provides a short-term boost which has long gone.</p><p>On the topic of SoCoins. It makes a huge amount of sense as a concept but again I wonder if I am falling into the community trap of just being impatient with its purpose?</p><p><strong>Currently 100,000+ coins are sat in my account</strong>. I am unable to get a jersey quick enough, I see little value of another academy expansion, so am left with the choice of holding for a better day. You instantly create deeper value of socoin by the coins being spent for access — whether that be a tournament, a special weekly, entering competitions.</p><p>Inevitably you will be able to buy socoin. First it just needs a greater purpose.</p><p>My point being is that between collections, socoin, investing deeper into the community <strong>there are potential solutions that on the surface are not totally radical</strong>, but are due experimentation.</p><p>I do not want this to be just a problem, problem, problem exercise. Solutions-driven has always been my way of thinking.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*9DlQd0pKbqus5WmJV7FfqA.png" /></figure><p><strong>What recent weeks have shown us is that there is still spending power within the userbase</strong>. Whether it be Wemby to Endrick, anything new or flashy still captivates the imagination across all scarcities.</p><p><strong>The game economy we are in is not the game economy of when I started in 2021</strong>. A starting limited goalkeeper can now be bought for as little as £7. There is little financial barrier to entry — not even in this economy.</p><p>You could argue <strong>there is a financial barrier to compete</strong> — however this will never change.</p><p>We must have a serious think about card prices in the limited &amp; rare scarcities. When one declines, the other trickles behind. A starting rare keeper for example at £200-£250 is a barrier, but fast forward another 12–24 months and this could significantly slide with the current status quo. You need to get on top of this.</p><p>This will reach a tipping point which will significantly reduce the current userbase if this continues to decline. Again, what is the knock on impact of that?</p><p><strong>One solution that has been consistently sneered at is moving to SO11</strong>. I already know (congrats if you made it this far) some are thinking not this again.</p><p>Ultimately, I stress the game economy now is not the same as what it was in 2021. It is showing no sign of strength, and Sorare is showing little sign of any new users joining the platform so it can only be reactivated from within.</p><p>I understand the concern that are you not just kicking the can down the road? <strong>Sometimes that is not a problem</strong>. Kick the can down the road and in two years the economy could be much stronger. Another two years of brand recognition etc.</p><p>If you want to stimulate a market in one action, this is what achieves it.</p><p>Create the nuance on it that can appease certain objections. Again, there are no perfect solutions.</p><p><strong>Every other fantasy football game is built on an 11-person squad.</strong> The game economy until now has just never been in a position where this is appropriate or accessible.</p><p>That <strong>nuance can be created</strong> through keeping one common, anti-stacking restrictions, capped points, sticking to weekends and not midweeks, not every division and every competition, limited only. Higher the prices at the limited level, the positive impact that has upstream. Try this as a special monthly competition with awesome rewards and see community feedback.</p><p>You can do this in a manner which creates positive sentiment and <strong>greater feeling of progression</strong> (something a lot of managers crave) rather than creates a pressure on smaller galleries. Again, there is no perfect solution.</p><p>Managers need to understand you can not have your cake &amp; eat it. Including me.</p><p>Move S05 into the semi-pro part of the onboarding. Reconsider limited pro.</p><p>Do not drip feed with S07, 8 etc. Sorare need to start stretching out galleries, increasing user spending because the current status-quo does not cut it.</p><p><strong>Whatever route you take, be cutthroat</strong>. Do not diver. If you want to install fitness, install fitness. <strong>Understand the bulk of users look at things through the lens of their own gallery rather than the long-term sustainability of the business.</strong></p><p>Understand you have an incredible product. Something that is very difficult to turn away from. Something that when you leave, eventually sucks you back in.</p><p>Outrage on card design is now no more. Managers with influence thought Al Hilal would break the game — assumptions based on little understanding of world football. <strong>Instant buy will not be a topic of conversation by Christmas.</strong></p><p>SO11 would adopt a similar pathway. Community members of perceived influence can have questionable opinions that should not be treated as fact.</p><p><strong>This would be my direction of trave</strong>l.</p><ul><li>Invest into customer experience and community management</li><li>2.0 collections — let that be the foundation for access (tickets, experiences) via tournaments</li><li>Create greater purpose with the SoCoin economy &amp; prepare to be radical with it</li><li>Move into S011 with added nuance</li><li>Any changes on a roadmap, stick to them. Give them time.</li></ul><p>My closing statement is for anyone to look at this game in the lens of today rather than what we know from time gone by. <strong>This is not going to be the Sorare of 2020 anymore. Be open to new ideas, new directions of travel.</strong></p><p>The product that we have today is genuinely incredible. It is difficult to speak for a new user when you are just so entrenched in the detail. Just please do not turn this game into Ultimate Team.</p><p>Understand why many have moved away from Fifa / EAFC, the microtransaction culture, stale gameplay innovation and toxicity of its community.</p><p>Sorare employ super smart, intelligent people. They understand the problems better than any of us.</p><p><strong>Thank you for making it this far.</strong></p><p>You deserve some SoCoin for making it through. Genuinely.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-XwenzUcmL5Cbr0GkI2YLw.png" /></figure><p>We sometimes talk about things like this on our podcast ‘<strong>Limited to Sorare</strong>’ which was designed not to tell you how to play, but how to sustainably go through the scarcities and enjoy the game we call Sorare.</p><p><a href="https://open.spotify.com/show/2LW8uWqnlafjCus2Mazytp">https://open.spotify.com/show/2LW8uWqnlafjCus2Mazytp</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4ef2c8d0aadb" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>