<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Brandon Zicha on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Brandon Zicha on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@brandonzicha?source=rss-9d874078287b------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 05:34:50 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@brandonzicha/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[In Defense of Vaccine Hesitancy, Critical Thinking, and Credible Science]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/parallel-republic/in-defense-of-vaccine-hesitancy-critical-thinking-and-credible-science-36c0772b2120?source=rss-9d874078287b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/36c0772b2120</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[science-communication]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[polarization]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[vaccination]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[covid19]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[vaccine-hesitancy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Brandon Zicha]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 06 Aug 2021 15:14:55 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-09-10T11:56:00.003Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>This polarization is literally gonna kill us.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/780/1*FMZJwsPRdheURe0GzGFGMw.png" /></figure><p>I got vaccinated against Covid-19. I think you probably should too.</p><p>That said, I think you have plenty of reason to be hesitant, frustrated, and annoyed. I was and am. I am pretty unhappy that I feel this way, because I shouldn’t have to. An open self-governing society should and in times past has done better than this. But, alas. Navigating our current era is all we have. So, I am going to do some critical thinking so as to provide a long defense of the vaccine hesitant and some apologetics for some covid denialists from the position of someone who is informed about, trained in, and very much pro science.</p><p>I want to write about this because I think the railing against people as selfish, stupid, deranged, or just evil for being unvaccinated is probably wrong and definitely unhelpful. Too often the memes and slogans deployed are simply untrue (“mRNA vaccines aren’t new technology being deployed at this scale” or recently “We would have herd immunity by now if only there were no hestiants”), dissembling (“vaccines have nothing to do with politics or freedom”), manipulative slurs (“you sound like an antivaxxer”), or simply vapid sloganeering (“This house believes science is real” or “follow the science”!) This isn’t helpful.</p><p>Lying, manipulation, dissembling, and vapid sloganeering is unbefitting and dangerous for a public health campaign in a free society, and can only help realize the outcomes that the anti-hesitant vaccine enthusiasts fear most: A complete collapse of trust in scientific authority while threatening all of our rights for an imagined smidgeon of long-run safety in the process.</p><p>Current pro-vaccination attitudes and tactics in the community are running an extreme risk. This isn’t to say that aggressive vaccine denialists who refer to mandatory masking as ‘muzzling’ and who compare lockdowns to the Holocaust aren’t extraordinarily worrying. They are. Even if they are probably about <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2021/05/18/opinion/covid-19-vaccine-hesitancy.html">13% of of the unvaccinated eligible for vaccination. But, to characterize all vaccine hesitancy as selfish anti-vaxxers when they objectively aren’t</a>, is a great way to create more people talking (accurately) about ‘muzzling’. Worse, once untruths and exaggerations are exposed, it further erodes any credibility of public health science and official discourse, which is hanging by a thread as it is.</p><p>To stress again (because I have to for many to read further) I think that everyone who can should choose among the vaccines available and get the one most risk mitigating for them, but I don’t think they should be happy about it or comfortable. Getting one of these vaccines shouldn’t feel like a gamble with unknown risks, but our current approach in the West demands it. But just because we are being offered a less pleasant gamble than we have good reason to expect, does not mean that we should take over-reactive postures as Covid denialists and the covid era generation of anti-vaxxers have done — even if it is an understandable reaction.</p><p>In these polarized times it is too easy to polarize from hesitancy to reactionary paranoia, or from reasoned confidence to certain ideological vaccine enthusiasm. And, of course, these two tendencies feed off each other. As people move from hesitancy to reactionary paranoia loudly and in public spaces, the “reasoned confident”,concerned about the implications and appalled by the extreme unsubstantiable claims of the paranoid, actively fear any information that might differ from that which support their preferred choice, and build an entirely fictional ideological and rhetorical artifice to which they ever more worriedly police the boundaries.</p><p>In this ideological universe “the science” and vaccination is not political (as they engage in political speech to make the point) and textbook in its operation, regulators are altruistic and concerned exclusively with ‘good science’ (except when Monsanto,GMOs, or government regulation of nearly any other industry are involved), ‘experts’ are nearly infallible (so long as they are the ‘right’ experts), and thus one must ‘follow the science’ or be a flat earther who should be denied any right to participate in society if they reach a different conclusion from the once reasoned confident, and now strict ideologue. The once reasoned confident becomes the ideological enthusiast. Of course, this messaging is now as extreme and full of holes as the ‘paranoid’s’, and serves only to make the ‘hesitant’ feel justified that they are in a groupthink conspiratorial situation and, yup, polarize to a more ‘paranoid’ position. This feeds the fear among the ‘reasoned confidents’ to become more ‘technocratic in their ideological enthusiasm’ and the polarization is in a positive feedback loop. Truth and critical thought are the first casualties. But, in the long run it is the common good that will suffer.</p><p>Moreover, there is now a media surge in whipping up these tribal boundaries, to dangerous conclusions. <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2021/07/vaccinated-america-breaking-point-anti-vaxxers/619539/">David Frum makes a great example here of scientifically illiterate vaccine tribalism</a>, implying that the vaccinated are getting angry at the unvaccinated because if the unvaccinated had gotten vaccinated we would have herd immunity and the ‘pandemic would be over’ by now. <a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-021-00728-2">Of course, this in all likelihood isn’t true</a>. It is only true in a mythical world where some of the following claims hold true: America is the world, pandemic are about one country, we know the duration of immunity from recovery or immunization, current vaccines provide low transmissibility of new variants. None of those hold. Moreover, huge swaths of the population (children) still don’t even have a viable approved vaccine yet, and some <em>just</em> got approval. But, most importantly, this ‘impatience’ isn’t something that just emerges. It’s framed by the media. And people like Frum are all into that game (as are many others suspiciously all at once in a phenomenon known as ‘pack journalism’). But the result is an environment that probably makes all of us less safe. Particularly if the panic induced creates yet more<a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2021/07/29/opinion/covid-vaccine-hesitancy.html"> illiberal faithlessness in persuasion and our ability to self-government, as Ezra Klein</a> has recently terrifyingly signaled.</p><p>So, charting a middle and sober path through such a firestorm is challenging. But, I think people need to try if we are going to keep the benefits of science, public health, and the free society going.</p><h3>Myth and Reality of Science and Vaccines</h3><p>Somewhat weirdly, it is very often the same people who uncritically push the 100% obvious science-certified safety of the Pfizer, Moderna, and other Covid vaccines, and the clear necessity of mass vaccination who also tend to be convinced that Monsanto is an evil company for whom a network of profits and regulatory capture leads to routine lies about the science and safety of grocery-store vegetables for which we have had decades to study. In one instance the FDA, industry, and public implementation authorities (the CDC or the Department of Agriculture) are a perfect system of public accountability, while in the other they are a perfect system of rank corruption. I am going to go out on a limb and argue that the truth is somewhere in between our public health processes here being a <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9mSvsSLPtLo">unicorn </a>or a <a href="https://cdna.artstation.com/p/assets/images/images/003/387/898/large/limkuk-art-demogorgon-alta.jpg?1473169485">demogorgon</a>.</p><p>The picture portrayed or inferred about ‘The Science’ by the ideological narrative of vaccine enthusiasts seems to go something like this: Scientists are dedicated truth seeking scholars, who apply “the scientific method”. Any deviation from purity of purpose or accuracy is caught by a tight system of peer review, replication, and open criticism. Any serious problem will be found. This is because scientists submit research findings for publication and other random anonymous scientists evaluate the research with high integrity and concern for truth in an unbiased fashion. After, those findings are rigorously tested on the basis of new data and the result reported. Thus, over time, we develop accurate pictures of truth, and accumulate ever more knowledge that is absorbed and disseminated by experts. This expert knowledge strongly implies what one should do with it. Indeed, science not only develops the ‘is’ but the ‘ought’, because eliminating a problem identified by scientists or recognized generally is self-evidently good. Science doesn’t care what you believe (or about trade-offs, it turns out)!</p><p>The resultant scientific truths describe reality, rather than endorsing some theoretical stories offering a partial view of all the issues under consideration, as philosophers of science and — indeed — most serious practicing scientists would assert. Thus, those who deny the claims of scientists are not merely denying scientists arguments, but reality itself.</p><p>Experts grasp more about the situation than non-experts in any situation, including an individual’s situation. This is why vaccine mandates are a trade-off-free no-brainer for enthusiasts. If there was a danger for you and your particular health given your particular situation, the experts would know. The notion that someone hanging out on the internet could outperform experts is a laughable, meme-able notion. Scientists in industry and in government (from the CEO of Pfizer to Dr. Fauci) are more or less beacons of integrity unmoved by politics or profit by a concern for truth, science, and helping others. (Unless they work for Monsanto, or other industries at different times, where the politics are different… then they aren’t… because vaccines aren’t political!).</p><p>Basically, the perspective asks one to read the tale of the emperor’s new clothes, and dismiss the child pointing out the nude emperor as merely another case of the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunning%E2%80%93Kruger_effect#Mathematical_critique">Dunning-Krueger effect</a> (<a href="https://www.mcgill.ca/oss/article/critical-thinking/dunning-kruger-effect-probably-not-real">which is not what people think it is and is probably not real, and if it is is such a small effect that we probably shouldn’t be using it to shame non-experts or exaggerate the confidence of experts</a>, by the way);’ That child needs it’s Twitter account banned and any youtube channel upon which he appears post-haste.</p><p>The paranoids, on the other hand, see only the failures of medical science, historically, and seem to believe most actors involved in the production of vaccines specifically, covid policy more generally, and sometimes just science more generally are not merely negligent or self-interested actors, but malevolent. ‘They’ have a plan, and it is very bad. The paranoids see attempts to silence critics as further evidence of an elaborate cover-up, hiding motives ranging from ‘simple’ totalitarian tendencies, to elaborate transnational pedophile conspiracies aimed at global domination. They cling to principles like ‘freedom’ as totemically as their opponents to ‘science’ and seek to apply it to justify any old nonsense. This group confuses the freedom to make poor uninformed choices as a moral directive to do so. But often, this view is motivated by a profound distrust in their sources of information more than an overwhelming confidence in themselves. How reasonable is their distrust? More on that later.</p><p>There are so many interesting aspects to this juxtaposition, such as how one side seems obsessed with centralization of authority and a requirement of rigid conformity to one view of the common good, while the other seems to want total decentralization and seem to only believe that they are exercising freedom if they are as difficult to live with as possible in their hackneyed decision-making. One side demands a prudish respectability on the matter of vaccination, while the other encourages total chaotic rebellion against norms of propriety or even good order.</p><p>But the reality of science, issues with vaccine production, and covid response generally are the casualties of these dominant delusional camps sucking all the air out of the public deliberative room.</p><p>Back on earth, science looks totally different. That’s because politics is exactly like Jesus when Jesus said in the Gospel of Matthew 18:20 of the King James “For where two or three are gathered together in my name, there am I in the midst of them.“ When two or three scientists are gathered together in the name of science, there is politics in the midst of them. And, the ‘midst of them’ get ever thicker with politics the greater in size the congregation, and the pandemic provides a mighty congregation indeed.</p><p>Indeed, when people speak about ‘experts’ with singular authority it sounds alot to me like how people used to talk about priests and bishops (and I take it about as seriously). People are people. People are flawed. No human enterprise under the sun has ever escaped this reality in the history of mankind. I think most people know from experience that reality never works according to the ideal; They just forget in heated conflicts. It’s intellectually dishonest to just assume that somehow this wouldn’t apply to science and technology, and particularly during a pandemic when everything has to happen at speed and there are billions of dollars and votes to be earned.</p><p>This is not to say that science is not to be trusted so much as ‘science’ not really being ‘a thing’ at all. It is a way of discovery composed of and latched into a variety of socio-political-economic systems that affect both its course, and the implications of its discoveries in a myriad of ways. Some scientific knowledge is more certain and complete than other scientific knowledge for a given purpose or decision. The challenge is sorting the wheat from the chaff. What knowledge is the best knowledge for this problem, and what other knowledge matters from other experts needs to be taken into account as well. That’s the difficult and uncertain part. <a href="https://brandonzicha.medium.com/experts-are-not-enough-liberal-arts-and-sciences-the-university-college-movement-and-the-corona-b92de893f640">That’s why there is no such thing as a meaningful ‘expert’ in pandemic policy</a>.</p><p>The science itself is less certain than is usually advertised. Scientists usually know this. Though, they routinely overestimate confidence in themselves and more often over communicate confidence to the general public in my experience with scientists in academia. Scientists ‘<a href="https://www.wired.com/story/were-all-p-hacking-now/">p-hack</a>’ which is to say engage in a variety of practices to inflate the reported confidence of findings. There are strong incentives for them to do so a the level of their immediate professional success and prestige. This, combined with other elements here has led to a widespread<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Replication_crisis"> replication crisis</a> in multiple disciplines, where we discover that foundational robust findings upon which other research has built was absolutely false, and all following research built on a foundation of sand. And, mind you, this is just talking about general factors. When we get into the institutionally specific domains of universities and major pharmaceutical and other tech companies things get murkier.</p><p>The institutional practice of science does not look like what science is meant to look like, and it looks less like it all the time. Rather than a large group of independent and loosely aligned scholars chafing against each other, the bureaucratic constraints of corporations, and government as we might imagine the scientists of the Manhattan Project, Science today selects for more corporate types. Team players. And the structure of scientific production has become massively bureaucratic and depersonalized. This matters, because the successes of science of the past are built on the basis of a totally different institutional structure of scientific knowledge production today, and the independent error correction of many different scientific scholars is a big part of the secret sauce that made the Big Science Burger so delicious. If most scholars writing in a given field are co-authoring in large groups with whom they are professionally mutually reliant (for grants, publication, and thus promotion and prestige), independent checks go way down.</p><p>Let’s talk about peer review as an example. It’s gotten more play in the public than probably ever in history since Trump was elected. 50 years ago that enthusiasm might have been more justified than it is today. What is peer review and why is it not the truthmaking elixir the March for Science placards promise? Peer review, basically, is the practice of sending potential publications to other scholars for their review. If those reviews are negative, editors won’t publish the piece. So, the gold standard is blind or double blind review, those being models where the reviewer and author don’t know each other’s identities, or one where no one including the editor knows their identities. The idea is that if a panel of one’s colleagues don’t believe the paper is up to a requisite level of quality, it’s better safe than sorry.</p><p>Unfortunately, there are many known issues with peer review, and some less well known that deviate from this model. So, if people are arguing in good faith about their confidence in science being not a statement of blind faith but a reasoned conclusion based on a particular model of science, these revelations should reduce their confidence.</p><p>So what are some of these issues?</p><p>Peer review procedures are not regulated or even strongly normative across scientific disciplines and sub-disciplines. Each journal determines its own policy. Now for a variety of reasons this has led to situations where editors send articles from senior scholars to easier reviewers, small fields often make blind review impossible, and in many specialized subfields blind review is abandoned entirely. Authors suggest their own reviewers. The grounds for that is that science is so specialized that finding adequate reviewers is too costly for editorial teams. Perhaps. But obviously, doing so means that trustworthiness of integrity has been sacrificed for convenience. In the Netherlands, for instance there are exactly two research groups that study key questions in environmental science. That’s not a robust ground for independent checking of results. Moreover, team competitive pressures create incentives to defend the group’s claims, because to allow doubt could be extremely costly to all.</p><p>There are varied standards about what constitutes sufficient grounds for rejecting or accepting a paper. Some editors blindly follow the reviewers. If one says ‘I don’t like the font. reject’, the editor will reject. Other editors read and treat reviews as advice. Still others have specific grounds upon which reviewers are required to comment. This patchwork bears little resemblance to the peer review of our model.</p><p>Most scholars I know have encountered situations where their papers are rejected for less than entirely above-board science-preserving reasons. Sometimes, they can be downright corrupting. For instance, one paper was rejected because I didn’t use a data set that the reviewer possessed but which was not accessible. This blocked findings differing from theirs. I found out the identity of the reviewer only accidentally.</p><p>In industry things are even more complicated. Serious mainstream medical scientists like <a href="https://www.badscience.net/">Ben Goldacre</a> made a career fighting for good science against both pseudoscientific quacks in the nutrition industry and seriously unbecoming scientific practice in the pharmaceutical industry — which are widespread. Indeed, this is the reason why there have been so many cases of drugs being approved and then pulled off the market. So why are these new vaccines so obviously perfect and safe for long term use, and above any question?</p><p>I have no idea.</p><p>Then, finally, there is the issue of scientific knowledge itself which is grounded in something I know quite a bit about: statistics. A little known secret is that medical journals are well known well beyond just ‘geeky docs’ like Ben Goldacre, but among statisticians and statistical methodologists more generally as hotbeds of malpractice in both inference (how strong the result is) and interpretation (how important it is, in terms of the magnitude of the effect). Indeed, in advanced graduate courses we used the New England Journal of Medicine as a source for replication and critical evaluation studies to demonstrate what <em>not to do </em>in our — I must sadly confess — far less important social science research.</p><p>There are at least two big problems with statistical studies of vaccine safety and efficacy even under the best of practices.</p><p>Firstly, is the impossibility of getting long term studies on a short term basis. Without a time machine we can only study short run side effects of these vaccines. And, despite what might be implied, mRNA based vaccines have never been used at this scale before. The long run implications for different subpopulations is difficult to know.</p><p>Secondly, is the problem of analysis itself. Analysis comes from the greek root ἀνάλυσις meaning to unbind, split, or divide. We break up processes and systems into pieces via analysis such that we can understand them. We do this in statistics too. We break up causal processes and evaluate one ‘effect’ or ‘dependent variable’ at a time. Usually, studies of vaccines don’t study side effects as the ‘dependent variable of interest’ until much later, if at all. Rather, they study the ‘big concerns’, like ‘does the vaccine prevent disease’, ‘does the vaccine prevent transmission’, and ‘how long does immunity last’?<br>To get an idea of side-effects (read: safety) we can do a rough cut of data, and just look for associations between vaccine interventions and lots of observed symptoms versus those receiving a placebo. But, of course, we have no idea if those associations are real and if they apply particularly to any subgroups. Knowing that requires further study with those side effects as dependent variables. A new ‘lysis’ or ‘cut’ of the issue.</p><p>Whenever I say ‘further study’ I actually mean ‘tons of money and more time’. That matters, of course, because the general inference from these ‘side effect studies’ is basically the risks for ‘the average person’; not ‘you’. So, if you are someone who suffers from a very poorly understood chronic ailment like auto-immune disease there is a good chance that your likelihood of certain potentially dangerous side effects is quite high at worst or unknown at best if there are only a handful of people with that ailment in the study (as is likely the case).</p><p>So, if you tell someone that ‘the science says that the vaccine is safe for you and you should take it’ to someone with one of these disorders you are not following ‘the science’ you are going well beyond it. That is, assuming we even accept the fiction that <a href="https://unherd.com/2021/05/how-science-has-been-corrupted/">science is a thing that ‘leads’ to any one place.</a> When you suggest a mandate, you are saying that people who have rare conditions for which no link has been yet established for serious chances of side-effects should operate as human guinea pigs so you can hope to go maskless to the store. It might be good to hold that thought in mind the next time you criticize those not getting vaccinated as a group definitionally lacking civic virtue on the basis of their hesitance. You aren’t so hot on that score yourself.</p><h3>My Vaccine hesitancy…</h3><p>… is therefore not a disbelief in “science”, per se, as it is a belief in a disembodied ideal social process by which we would pursue knowledge, and where ‘peer review’ actually is some sort of marker of perfect confidence as opposed to ‘better than nothing’. I have a disbelief that our current system of science even loosely approximates the story enthusiasts and the establishment media suggest to us because we know <em>for a fact</em> that they aren’t being truthful when they do so.</p><p>But it also springs from things more directly in my wheelhouse as a political economist. It springs from the realization that the number of steps between that scientific process and a vaccine jab in my arm is orders of magnitude longer and containing an awful lot of non-ideal science, embedded in a political and social institutional structure with incentives pressuring outcomes to deviate dramatically from what an idealized process would permit, and a recognition that a solid authoritative public scientific system requires a healthy civic culture to support it with checks and independent informational feedback loops.</p><p>Indeed, my biggest bailiwicks are largely political and economic and spans the entirety of the pandemic response (but that is a topic for another long post). I think that the political and economic context of this virus makes all the problems I have discussed above <em>worse</em> with respect to this pandemic, and why the social context of our tribalized debate I highlighted at the outset gives us all reason to be less confident in the process itself.</p><p>The core of the problem is a simple matter of asymmetric information and incentives between vaccine producers (broadly defined), the state, and the population. Ultimately, to trust vaccines, we need to trust vaccine producers and government regulators and each other to help hold them to account.</p><p>Now, there are two ways to look at trust, basically. One is a type of emotional affect. This is the type that boosters for vaccines go for by trying to connect a vaccine to trusted things. It’s the ephemeral trust that we offer on sentiment. The other type is rational. This notion of trust suggests that trust is based on that which is reasonably assessed as being trustworthy based on logic and evidence. So far, most of our attention, socially, has been focused on manufactuing consensus with the emergency vaccination regime through centralized and decentralized PR tapping into emotional sources. Are you a good person? You don’t want to be stupid, do you? Do you not believe in science? Hey, you trust me and I got the shot, you should too? These are all attempts to leverage emotion to drive trusting action.</p><p>Very little has been talking about whether it is <em>reasonable to trust. </em>Is the process, on its face, <em>trustworthy</em>? How would we know?</p><p>So let’s lay out the situation as I see it.</p><p>Vaccine producers exist to make money by making drugs. We have government regulators because we realize that vaccine producers, like makers of sausage or GMOs, have incentives to not necessarily poison us, but to maximize profits and externalize costs. Our safety is not their <em>first</em> concern. This can lead to a combination of corner cuts and ‘little fudges’ that can add up to dead rats in your SPAM without anyone conspiring maniacally to do so. No demogorgons per se. So, recognizing this, we created a government agency to aid in oversight of the making of sausage</p><p>The FDA was born because so long as product quality is difficult to assess ex ante, consumers will have difficulty determining quality and people can have very bad things happen to them before someone finds the obvious rat tail in their SPAM and writes the papers. Hopefully, this creates a national scandal and leads people to abandon the SPAM en masse (I actually love SPAM for the record). So, without some government oversight, the only protection we have is market discipline, albeit probabilistic and delayed. But both direct oversight by the FDA and your ability to flee the product create incentives for producers to prioritize things they would not otherwise do.</p><p>Now let’s look at the government. Who guards the guardians? We can largely trust the FDA most of the time because, ultimately, the government doesn’t have a strong interest in one or two particular producers of processed chopped meat filling American bellies, and they don’t want to get blamed for poisoning people. They are perfectly happy to discipline firms knowing full well there are a million producers in the sea. Moreover, for the most part, we citizens are perfectly happy for them to do so.</p><p>Of course, <em>we know</em>, that as pharmaceuticals and (Ahem) the science (TM) has gotten more sophisticated and expensive with massive economies of scale, that this has led to fewer viable independent producers of both knowledge and vaccines. We have seen plenty of examples of worrying revolving door issues between regulators, politicians and the industry.</p><p>This worries us. Democrats have criticized Republicans since the Reagan Administration for politicizing basic health and safety regulation, and easing the creation of revolving doors between partisan politicians, regulators, and the firms they are meant to regulate.</p><p>How do we deal with this problem? It’s difficult to see how to solve this problem without fundamentally changing how science and industry are organized, and with massive reform (none of which has happened, for all you enthusiasts out there).</p><p>But, thankfully, there is one last part of the picture, right? Us! A big component keeping industry and government more vigilant is the threat of a panic about the safety of drugs leading to a precipitous loss of sales and votes! More on that soon. Not a great picture. (<a href="https://parallelrepublic.substack.com/p/democide-by-disunion">foreshadowing</a>)</p><p>Now, vaccines are obviously a pretty important pharmaceutical. It would be great if human organization was such that we could all just trust the entire process to be a holy and good unicorn in much the same way that people thought ‘the church’ was for a very long time. But, in both cases, the tragedy of human political economy gets in the way of the so tempting technocratic/theocratic goal.</p><p>Unfortunately, there probably is no viable path to high quality vaccine with high levels of inoculation without doing the hard work of building trust, persuasion, and genuine education (As opposed to indoctrination — which is fragile to the first sign of falsification). There is no ‘lazy strategy’ that gets us there. Everything has trade-offs and we don’t know the magnitudes of the costs or the probability of them being realized. Systematic risk sucks, and just like with the financial regulatory disasters that made risk assessment of assets woefully incorrect before the financial crisis, we have the same problem in the realm of pharmaceuticals. And when we look at our current situation, I fear the picture is a little more bleak.</p><p>In this pandemic we have global capital, business, political leaders in democratic nations, and a population that is overwhelmingly motivated to get back to “normal” as soon as humanly possible, and vaccine manufacturers are looking at the largest demand for any medical product over a short time period in the history of the planet. This is not an exaggeration.</p><p>This strikes me as an incentive structure that is far more ill-suited to collective disaster than the situation established that led to the financial crisis in 2008. Quite literally, everyone directly involved is motivated to be overly optimistic and dismissive of evidence that suggests we might best off stay in our dancing lockdown situation of the last year and a half. In this pandemic, you don’t have to be a politician in a revolving door with big pharma to have an incentive to move it along. Yet, those forces are still there too. They are now just less scrutinized than before, not least because people are terrified to create ‘vaccine reluctance’. In other words, there is a direct incentive to hide potential problems, and there is suggestive evidence that this is happening given attack on supposed ‘disinformation’ (which assumes that the information we have is of the highest most unassailable quality, which I hope I have convinced you is at least very possibly a conceit).</p><p>And, to make matters worse, getting back to the ‘us’ in the regulatory story above, the recent polarization in the country has apparently created what in some quarters look like a cult of science and authority worship on much of the left, and a cult of science denial on much of the right, that spurs much of the left, big media, capital, and most institutions to react by engaging in more lax oversight of potential issues with the vaccine and to turn a blind eye to genuine attempts to curtail the flow of information in exactly the same way as occurred with regard to the Wuhan Lab Leak hypothesis and in deed, the Chinese initial response to that outbreak. Further, worrisome signs will not drive massive swings in votes or support (as we have seen in public opinion polls across everything over which we see polarization, which is why Trump’s approval rating was the flattest in presidential polling history), thus reducing the pressure on all those in industry and government to fear dire consequences for anything but the most dramatic crises.</p><p>Unfortunately, the degree to which we are being overconfident is unknown and probably unknowable. It might be, in practice, tiny or not even matter. The vaccines might be just that good, just by luck. But it may also be large. Systematic risk is really hard to measure. All we can be sure of is that it is positive and that our risk estimates are underestimates.</p><p>And the final elephant in the political economic room is the media, which I touch upon at the outset but don’t want to belabor. But everything I have said about industry and government applies to the media as well. And, frankly, we have good reason to be suspicious given the persistently lack of interest in investigating claims deemed ‘unfit’ in our new culture war, be it the actual story about the<a href="https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-57418753"> dispersal of protestors around the White House ‘for Trumps photo op’</a> (How is it possible this wasn’t discovered before a few months ago, did no one call the park service?),<a href="https://theconversation.com/the-covid-19-lab-leak-hypothesis-is-plausible-because-accidents-happen-i-should-know-162430"> the source of the outbreak</a>, or stories about effective treatments for Covid-19 because they happen to be suggested by the wrong people even if the people in question invented the mRNA technology in the current vaccines, or evaluating whether pharmaceutical companies are suppressing research on existing treatments because they have a fiduciary incentive to do so if that research would endanger emergency approval of new drugs to fight covid — including vaccines. (Somehow, mRNA vaccines in some minds are based on such flawless and pristine science that we must ignore the concerns of the technology’s inventor because he is clearly an antivaxxer crackpot. This contradiction between flawless tech invented by someone you deem a ‘crackpot’ seems unworrying to those advancing this argument.)</p><p>How is everyone not absolutely flabbergasted that the reaction and claims that the notion of a Wuhan lab leak was fantastical and debunked last year? Everyone,<a href="https://nymag.com/intelligencer/article/lab-leak-hypothesis-covid-liberal-media-science-biden-trump-china.html"> but especially my more vaccine enthusiastic leaning friends should be nervous</a> I would think about what that portends. How were we so convinced, that just because Donald Trump first popularized the theory that it was inconceivable that one of China’s highest security Viral Research Lab was a less likely source for a weirdly behaving virus than bats at a ‘wet market’? We should really be chastened, not proud and confident. How does<a href="https://youtu.be/sSfejgwbDQ8?t=211"> Jon Stewart need to mainstream that skepticism</a>, and still be subject to weird Pravda-esque handwringing about how comedians shouldn’t speculate on the cause of the outbreak, but should be left to medical professionals?</p><p>The same publications that cared not one whit about comedians roasting any public figure who echoed Trump’s claim about the Wuhan lab, and the same mental health professionals like Fauci who’s public statements on the plausibility of the leak trail rather than lead the broader critical discussion should not inspire the level of confidence that they do in some but it goes some way to paint a picture of where trust in authority has gone? It’s largely dying the altar of media malpractice and political polarization. But any objective assessment is clear. We have a bias in our media system in favor of overconfidence.</p><p>This is not a system that I can deem trustworthy, and thus it is a bit foolish, in my view, to trust it’s fruits. It’s a calculated risk I had to make to get the vaccine. And, honestly, I probably wouldn’t have taken it now if I didn’t need to get back to my parents in case something happens and there is increasing danger of vaccination being required to travel or work (which makes me more nervous).</p><p>There is simply no substitute for long-term panel studies for novel treatments, because side effects simply take time to manifest. These unknowable unknowns can only be caught by careful long running observation. Even then, they won’t be caught perfectly. And, routinely, scientists across fields cut corners due to practical limits in research funds or time.</p><p>The ‘masks are muzzles’ people are clearly unhinged as well, but I am not sure they are more irrational than dire hard vaccine enthusiasts. Both are making arguments that are driven almost entirely by emotional affect and either preponderances or absences of trust based on little more than that. That, on balance, I think that enthusiasts get closer to the right choice is an accident not due to the quality of their reasoning.</p><h3>Creating Social Conditions for Good Science</h3><p>Last February I gave my last in-person lecture for our general first year interdisciplinary course called ‘prosperity’, and I was giving a lecture on governance. This was right before ‘the science’ and ‘the public health experts’ let us sleepwalk into the end of our pre-pandemic world and miraculously earned the trust and loyalty of all right thinking people according to most of the mainstream media.</p><p>In response to a student’s question (which I can’t recall) I argued that there would be no worry about a pandemic if the outbreak had occured in the Netherlands rather than China because free media and rule of law meant that it would be easy for doctors detecting the virus to speak out and sound an alarm generally compared to China, where information is centrally controlled in order to protect the population from panics, and whistle-blowers silenced if speaking out might unwittingly disrupt the progress the CCP is trying to make in China. Indeed, the facts around China’s forced silencing of the now deceased Doctors who did try to alert the authorities and the public has since come to light.</p><p>Thus, information flows more freely and in a decentralized manner in the West, I argued, because gate keeping is harder and because the disincentive to dissent is much lower. So, we may not have ‘police patrols’ monitoring from a central authority willy nilly, but we have ‘fire alarms’ distributed around society for anyone to pull in the event of danger.</p><p>I could not give that lecture today. It has become<a href="https://www.wsj.com/articles/americas-covid-groupthink-functioned-like-chinas-repression-11623085417"> pretty clear that while better than a totalitarian police state like China, the West is not open as the ideal openness</a>. Social media bans constricted media access, and strong partisan incentives to build narratives and enforce them reduce the free flow of decentralized information, as do decentralized ‘calling out’ and ‘holding to account’ by the paranoid and the highly enthusiastic.</p><p>But theoretically potential problems<a href="https://www.icsi.org/covid-19-vaccine-faq/do-the-mrna-vaccines-cause-infertility/"> affecting female fertility</a> which could only be accurately assessed over long time horizons would be the kind of thing that should give a decision-maker pause, as a source of risk. The primary person concerned about this is the same doctor who invented the mRNA vaccine technology. He has been banned from LinkedIn and youtube channels he has been on have been demonetized. He is widely attacked for spreading vaccine disinformation, one concern being the manner in which spike proteins produced by the vaccine lodge in women’s ovaries. And, while there is no evidence that female fertility is necessary hampered, <a href="https://nltimes.nl/2021/08/03/thousand-reports-menstrual-changes-covid-vaccine">just a few days ago the side-effects monitoring agency in the Netherlands reported a worrying number of changes in menstruation after receiving the vaccine</a>. It could be nothing. But it certainly is worth investigation. But so much of the necessary pieces have to fight through increasing amounts of formal and informal censorship one can only guess what else is being missed.</p><p>The classic media method for dismissing this is to say that ‘there is no evidence of problems’. But of course there aren’t. There can’t be. You need more time to pass in controlled testing environments to have that evidence. But this statement violates a basic tenet of scientific inference: Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence. It’s up there with ‘correlation is not causation’ in the canon of scientific maxims to live by. Some of those ‘following the science’ could use a refresher on this one.</p><h3>Critical Honesty Is Bedrock</h3><p>It is a seriously risky and short sighted gambit to exaggerate our confidence about the safety of vaccines or other treatments when they are being deployed at scale and with such attention, because if we end up wrong while doing so, and it comes out that risks were downplayed it seriously harms the deserved legitimacy of good scientific knowledge. And, we <em>need </em>science to to be credible in informing, even if not actually drive, our decision-making. This goes double when things go wrong.</p><p>And, in this pandemic, the entire globe is watching, listening, picking sides, and vaccinating on a mass scale. So, if this goes sideways such that, for instance even in a moderate but dramatic manner (think 10% increases in infertility among 20–40 year olds globally) it could irrevocably destroy the legitimacy of medical science for a generation or more. It would make our current know-nothing anti-Vaxx movement something we look back at with misty eyed nostalgia.</p><p>Truthful communication of risks, uncertainty, and real costs is more important when stakes are high than when marketing SPAM. The PR-ified nature of our thinking about how to promote vaccination is built on a logic deriving from the art of self-serving manipulative communication. So, if you have a trustworthy system, good PR is just a good idea. But if you have an untrustworthy system or unreported risks, good PR is a risky gambit best played by companies making sausage rather than companies making life saving pharmaceuticals. People hate feeling played for fools. But, they really hate it when the health of themselves or loved ones hangs in the balance.</p><p>But<a href="https://freddiedeboer.substack.com/p/orange-cheeto-man-bad"> the middle class liberal freak out</a> following the election of Donald Trump has seemingly convinced many of the aforementioned freaking out people that the primary mode of dealing with people is<a href="https://parallelrepublic.substack.com/p/reaching-out-persuasion-vs-conversion"> not persuasion</a>, but a combination of PR-informed communication, and decentralized vigilance where everyone is a cop screaming at unmasked joggers in parks and smearing PhDs trying to independently check the authorities as anti-Vaxx Covid denialists. This is not the best way to ensure reasonable vaccination rates long term. It’s difficult to exaggerate how dangerous these arguments against persuasion are, and I will address it another time and place.</p><p>I kind of think that this PR and enforcement of the enthusiastic confident is uncritically backing up a pretty untrustworthy and rotten infrastructure, populated by individuals acting collectively to “PR” and cajole their desired outcomes into existence. I think that our denialist movements are reflective (if exaggerated reflections) of real underlying issues of trustworthiness of our institutions of scientific learning, industry, government, and media that are being dismissed at our peril. I don’t think that anti-mask paranoids are more deluded than the ‘March for Science’ crowd who ‘believes and follows the science’ and views each new announced discovery with uncritical enthusiasm. Both are deluded about the reality of our situation, and both are doing so for ultimately self-involved and emotional rather than rational reasons.</p><p>So, playing people you think are fools for fools, and then being wrong (which is always possible) is potentially devastating not merely to the credibility of the medical science to the polity, but the polity to each other. So, it isn’t going to be just trust in the scientific and government that would be sullied if something goes wrong. It will be the foundations of the trust and unity required for democracy to work at all that could be damaged.</p><p>So, the more ‘realistic’ people become about the need to convince people that vaccines are safe by downplaying or outright suppressing contrary information, whether they be from random Qanon cultists or Biology professors talking with the inventor of the vaccine technology itself, the less comfortable I get. Because, I don’t know what I don’t know, but I know that there are things that ‘the experts’ are missing and that the entire information system and scientific institution is far more biased against locating them than our ideal model of the self-correcting science leads us to believe.</p><h3>Bottom Line</h3><p>Get vaccinated, but do your best to choose the best one for you, if you can. Push for your governments to stop waiting to approve new vaccines. Novavax has been waiting in line for a long time, and is based on similar technologies as the flu vaccine, and is likely to for that reason trigger less reluctance. Covid is almost certainly worse than the most cautious assessment of the risks, but those risks are certainly greater than current reports would suggest due to systemic risks. If you have a poorly understood disease, you have a tougher choice ahead of you. I know this well. But know that it not an irrational reason for hesitance and irritation with browbeating scolds who would present simplistic black and white views on vaccines and vaccine hesitancy.</p><p>Those with a low appetite for risk and an awareness of the facts deserve honest encouragement, not manipulation. If the improbable does happen, we will need an aggressive response from scientists and pharmaceuticals to deal with it, so it would be good not to have all trust and confidence understandably fall out of the bottom of medical science. That means being honest about risks we know, risks we don’t, and the trade-off we are making. Science works best in a free society dedicated to values of honesty, self-governance, and a concern for the common good.</p><p>When that third goal overrides the first two and demands to rest on lies, dissembling, or manipulation, and when we threaten to take away the choice of individuals over what they put in their bodies for the common good, you risk fundamentally weakened science and public health in the long run while magnifying confusion and ignorance. You are no friend of scientific knowledge by being uncritical, unskeptical, overoptimistic, or dishonest in its service.</p><p>Far more valuable than pushing vaccines, if the common good is really our concern, is keeping measures up like masking, distancing, and reducing certain high risk associations, <em>until</em> a sufficiently high vaccination rate is achieved, currently underinvested in treatments are available, and the global south where lockdown and social distancing is harder if not impossible has higher vaccination rates. We are working against vaccinations with our intuition that vaccination equals immunity from Covid, and the only barrier to ‘a return to normal’ is attaining some magic percentage of vaccination. Each variant that mutates risks raising that number or even rendering herd immunity an impossibility, and likely has already done so if the<a href="https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/70/wr/mm7031e2.htm?s_cid=mm7031e2_w"> CDC report is right</a> (but not if the <a href="https://nltimes.nl/2021/08/05/vaccines-work-well-reducing-transmission-coronavirus-health-institute">Dutch RIVM report</a> more or less the same day is to be believed #TrustTheExperts). More active infections being allowed among the unvaccinated and vaccinated by reducing measures does <em>immeasurably</em> more harm to the cause of ending the pandemic than hesitant vaccinators — many of whom already carry antibodies presently.</p><p>There’s a middle path founded on critical thinking, respect for one another, reason, and a sober look to the common good. That path involves recognizing the lack of control we have over this pandemic, the nature of the tools we have to work with, and a recognition that at the end of the day we only have each other, and so we may want to heap a little less judgement and be a little more compassionate and charitable.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=36c0772b2120" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/parallel-republic/in-defense-of-vaccine-hesitancy-critical-thinking-and-credible-science-36c0772b2120">In Defense of Vaccine Hesitancy, Critical Thinking, and Credible Science</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/parallel-republic">Parallel Republic</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Democide by Disunion]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/parallel-republic/democide-by-disunion-49413aeeed91?source=rss-9d874078287b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/49413aeeed91</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[moderate-democrats]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[moderate-republicans]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[centrism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[constitution]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[polarization]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Brandon Zicha]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 25 Jun 2021 14:24:11 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-06-25T14:24:11.571Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/840/0*7Pb0IW9ThGaDobWr.png" /><figcaption><a href="https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2020-12-30/san-francisco-grapples-with-abraham-lincoln-legacy">Credit: Christopher J. Beale, as posted in the Los Angeles Times</a></figcaption></figure><p>Who is ‘Us’ and who is ‘Them’?</p><blockquote>It is … for us to be here dedicated to the great task remaining before us, that from these honored dead we take increased devotion to that cause for which they gave the last full measure of devotion; that we here highly resolve that these dead shall not have died in vain; that this nation, under God, shall have a new birth of freedom, and that government <strong>of the people, by the people, for the people, shall not perish from the earth.</strong></blockquote><p>Abraham Lincoln The Gettysburg Address, 1863 <em>[emphasis added]</em></p><p>A staple of grade school President’s Day pageants, the Gettysburg address distills key principles and values standing at the center of the experiment in self-government that was at that time, and still is, relatively rare in the world. Specifically, he laid out that the unique task of self-governing peoples was to maintain a government that was composed <em>of the people </em>themselves, rather than a foreign class of monarchs; a government that was directed <em>by the people </em>to operate in some ways and not in others, and in so operating did so <em>for the people</em> in that it acted on behalf of the interests and well-being of that people rather than through the corrupt self-dealing of selfish political elites. That’s the task of self-government laid out in the Gettysburg address.</p><p>Thus, we might see that the government <em>of the people</em> needs to be secured before one can truly have a government <em>for the people</em>. And government<em> for the people</em> needs to be secured before government<em> by the people</em> is possible. The three elements are in dynamic tension and mutually dependent. We need to have our government composed of people from our political community (of the people) before we can trust rulers to rule in the interests of the people (for the people). And, we need to believe that rulers will rule in the interest of the people at all before we can hope to direct the specific choices or ruling (by the people). Unfortunately, only a government of the people proves easily established in the long term. States, once organized, appear rather good at repelling a foreign warlord from attempting to set up control (though bribery and other forms of leverage are still a concern as the panic over Trump being under the thumb of Russian intelligence illustrated).</p><p>However, a fundamental conflict underlies a challenge between maintaining a government for the people and by the people. The fundamental conflict in maintaining that Lincolnian system is this:</p><p>As much as it may be one side (say, side A) and their preferred leaders, versus the other side (say, side B) and their preferred leaders for control of the state, it is also sides A and B versus their respective preferred leaders (The governed versus the governors).</p><p>We need the fight between different visions and camps if we have any hope of government by the people. After all, how can we direct the direction of the government if we don’t have options among which to choose? But, at the same time, we need to remember that ultimately this whole game rests on us keeping our leaders firmly in our crosshairs as the ultimate threatening ‘them’. Because, if those leaders stop being very concerned about us, then we really aren’t in control, and the chance of them doing corrupt, inappropriate, or generally terrible things goes up — limited only by the quotient of angelicness in their character.</p><p>So, there is a conundrum at the center of the task Lincoln sets before us. The ‘mischief of faction’, as James Madison called it, is something to which humanity is well predisposed. Our divisive and tribal nature provides ample opportunity for ambitious entrepreneurial political elites to turn us against each other. They are good at convincing us, and we are all too willing to be convinced, that the fundamental conflict is not between us and they who are promising us that which we desire, but those neighbors of ours who would cast their votes for those desiring a path away from your personal view of paradise! But once they succeed, and the ‘us’ versus ‘them’ division divides the public too strongly, the government will eventually not be <em>for</em> the people. It will mostly be government for those in government. This means that the government also won’t be by the people, either. Political elites will only give their people what benefits them and what is minimally needed to maintain the loyalty of their partisans (which as we will see we can expect to be minimal indeed). Too much hating your neighbor and you don’t get paradise. There is an inverted ‘U’ shaped relationship between divisiveness and the outcomes you can expect from ‘winning’ in this game. Eventually, you hate the other side so much you will agree to whatever your co-hating leaders want.</p><p>We have, in America and increasingly across the West, forgotten why divisiveness is so deadly for a democracy, and our elites have noticed.</p><blockquote><a href="https://youtu.be/LIVEsa2g4ag?t=1156"><em>“If you say you’re a unifier, you expect and usually get applause. I’m a divider. Politics is division by definition, if there was no disagreement there would be no politics. The illusion of unity isn’t worth having, and is anyways unattainable”</em></a></blockquote><p><a href="https://youtu.be/LIVEsa2g4ag?t=1156">- Christopher Hitchens</a></p><p>Pundits like the late Christopher Hitchens are all too comfortable to blithely discuss the inevitable necessity of conflict and divisiveness as though it was an all or nothing choice rather than a plane upon which certain forms of divisiveness are less inevitable and necessary for democracy than others. Disagreement and conflict are necessary, but we can all make the distinction between the conflicts within our families that lead to progress and conflicts within other families that lead to murder suicides.</p><p>In what follows I want to explain why this problem is so fundamental to what we commonly call democracy, and why it is so destructive, before concluding with implications this has for responsible political choices.</p><h3>Constitutional Republican Democratic Suffragism (CRDS) and Its Possibility</h3><p>If you support a system in your own country where the people are the ultimate sovereign engaged in self rule rather than rule by an aristocracy or other privileged group/individual (republican), where the direction of public policy is endorsed and driven by the public’s choice (democratic) and where the public is minimally restricted (“No babies or foreigners voting, but <em>everyone</em> else yes!” say the suffragist!), all framed within a set of rules that coordinate political action in defense of those first three principles (constitutional), you are a constitutional republican democrat suffragist (CRDS); a mouthful of a designation I made up just now to help provide more conceptual clarity than calling all these attributes ‘liberal democracy’ that compose the elements of Lincoln’s Gettysburg school of self-government. Taken together CRDS principles all point to a government of, for, and by the people! But what is not necessarily appreciated, is that maintaining a CRDS is extraordinarily difficult, and only specific kinds of societies tend to thrive with them. Those societies that don’t tend to thrive are characterized by deep, persistent, divisions: ethnically divided societies, for instance, or those deeply divided on deep economic and thus social and political grounds, such as America on the eve of its Civil War.</p><p>If we understand the challenges of maintaining a CRDS-certified political system, we should better understand why they are particularly ill-suited and oft unsuccessful in such societies.</p><p>Being a good CRDSist involves keeping two streams of democratic theory in dynamic tension: William H. Riker called these elements ‘Liberalism’ and ‘Populism’, broadly. “Liberalism” was the stream Riker associated with the democratic theoretical tradition of Madison and Montesquieu (ultimately under the intellectual sway of Thomas Hobbes). For this tradition voting, and thus ‘democracy’, is about controlling overweening majorities and preventing tyranny. Domestic peace and liberty from interference by the state are the goals. The people rule, in that they themselves can form the governing authority and they can “throw the bums out” if they don’t like how things are going. The people don’t steer, but they do say ‘no’.</p><p>“Populism”, beginning with Rousseau (ultimately most close to the sway of John Locke) and the tradition which followed him assumes voting is about empowering majorities to make authoritative choices upon which they consent. The people really do govern, or at least they help a good deal. Majority rule is key to the people steering the state.</p><p>This is the distinction that is being referenced when someone who believes themselves to be a Very Clever Individual on the Internet (VCII) informs you that ‘America is a Republic and not a Democracy’. The VCII is coming down on the side of <em>Liberalism </em>against<em> Populism.</em> America, or the Very Clever Individual is <em>really actually truly</em> about “Liberal Republicanism”, he claims, rather than “Liberal Democracy”.</p><p>In Riker’s book, he was basically on board with our VCII, and he even titled his book <em>Liberalism Against Populism</em>. In it, Riker tightly and convincingly argued that given what we had learned over the 30 years prior to his writing about the problems of collective choice, democracy could really only be about what he calls ‘Liberalism’ and could not be about ‘Populism’. Simply put, in a country of millions of people with diverse preferences and ideals, the potential political choices a society might take could easily be of equal number to the voting population (one unique preference ordering over different ideals per individual), rendering assembling of a meaningful ‘majority will’ that could meaningfully coordinate and steer governance through the election of representatives or via plebiscite impossible. We could get a result, of course, but it won’t meaningfully reflect the will of the people.</p><p>Given the complex interrelations of those ideals and the range and scope of questions the government could address when compared to the capacities of voters to coordinate on a particular set of choices, the plausibility that genuine popular control is possible was clearly zero. So, using our parlance above, Riker says “no CDRS’ for you. Only a CRS is possible”. You can try to be a CDRS, and you might be able to get a governance decision or two to meet its criteria, but mostly it can’t reflect any meaningful democratic popular governance most of the time. Government ‘by the people’ is a pipe dream.</p><p>To give you a sense of the social choice problem Riker is referencing I’ll use the analogy I use when teaching it in the classroom: ‘the dinner out problem’. In this scenario (quite typical among college students, conference attendees, or folks leaving work in a clump), a group of, say, 5–9 people agglomerate in front of a building and decide to go get a bite to eat. Now, the group needs to decide where to go. As anyone who has experienced this knows, this decision can take a long time and feels like it is going around in circles. Some people prefer pizza to Indian. Others prefer Chinese to Indian and hate pizza, and so on. The reason why this goes around and around is because while there is a majority choice when comparing any pair of options among all the group members, there isn’t among all the options. Indeed, any choice beat by one alternative (Say, pizza) can be beat by another alternative (Say, Chinese) that can be beat by another alternative (Say, Indian) that can (hold on to your butts) be beat by a different alternative (Say, pizza). P &gt; I &gt; C &gt; P. So, while totally crazy for an individual, the collective preference may actually be: pizza is preferred to Indian which is preferred to Chinese which is preferred to pizza! This is what social choice scholars call an ‘intransitive preference ordering’ and the phenomena you experience during the dinner out problem causes the choice that a majority will support to ‘cycle’. So, we often call this ‘the cycling problem’ in the academic literature. Usually, in normal life, we resolve this problem by altering suffrage. The most intransigent group member on the question of where to go to dinner gets their way because they exhaust the rest into giving up their say. We might also construct some alternative decision rules that force a result. But that result will not be a function of the group but of the decision rule chosen. For many collectives of voters, you can get any result using the one mainstream voting rule rather than another so long as voters’ preferences are diverse enough.</p><p>So, Riker suggests, given that choosing a government for a number of years has far more than three potential choices, and there are more than 6–7 citizens, the potential for cycles that destroy the meaning of any result you could force via inference with the rules as totally arbitrary. It will reflect the constitutional rules bending to your will, or altering suffrage to narrow the diversity or voters.</p><p>Consequently, the potential for unique socially determined choices that guide the collective choice non-arbitrarily is low. The best we can hope for from voting, and thus what democracy is all about, is ‘throwing the bums out’ in a game of public versus elected elites, says Riker. It isn’t about popular control, but prevention of tyranny and establishing minority protections for those who might be targeted by a majority. Anything else is mathematically and logically impossible fantasy. We might not agree on what <em>to do, </em>but we can usually make clear determination of bad performance and malfeasance.</p><p>Or can we? More on that as we go on.</p><p>Unsurprisingly, Riker’s argument provoked many responses to explain why and how he was wrong, moving scholarship forward immeasurably in political science No one wants to let the Very Clever Individual win with his ‘America is a Republic not a Democracy’ schtick.. Obviously, people wanted to rescue the theory that a democratic government, to go back to Lincoln may be <em>by the people</em>, rather than merely <em>for the people</em>. CRSism just didn’t have the appeal of CRDSism. This work has been broadly successful. We now have reason to believe that voters steer policy in a rational fashion. At least, they clearly did. It is yet to be seen if this persists for reasons we discuss shortly. But, ultimately, few studies looking at systemic representation exist for the current decade, but there is reason to believe that it has gotten worse.</p><p>But what we do know from the work of political scientists like <a href="https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/degrees-of-democracy/CCFD6A2271BA1E5C7C9D02ADB3E4A409">Christopher Wlezien and Stuart Soroka</a> is that at least until recently, public support for parties and politicians that push for certain types of spending changes or policy actions tend to drop as that spending occurs. That is to say, the public and thus voting outcomes appear(ed) rationally reactive in a panel of countries including the United States, Canada and the UK. This bolsters the findings of <a href="https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/macro-polity/1D9BFE5AC38B7387A9FB3FA073BA90BB">Erikson, Mackuen and Stimson in their book on the United States, <em>Macropolity</em></a><em>,</em> where they find that American aggregate partisanship and public opinion moves from left to right in response to real world events. This all suggests that the populace collectively <em>is</em> able to participate in governance so long as the policy space provides a set of policy choices in the form of different political parties and basic safeguards remain to preserve free access to those choices (the constitutional regime).</p><p>On average, over time, we get responsiveness. How? Well, <em>polarization</em>! That’s how! Riker’s democracy-wide dinner out problem is only likely problematic if the preference orderings are so diverse as to be approaching the appearance of randomness. But, if people tend to have only a handful of common preference orderings, or if they really loathe a particular option and despise all those who dare suggest it (like abortion for a pro-life voter, or dinner out at a raw-food bar for a sane person) most voting rules will give you similar results, and there is no underlying incoherance of group preferences. If team Italian can exploit team Pizza and team Burger by their serious distaste for Chinese, Indian, or Sushi, then two blocks can emerge where Italian always wins.</p><p>So, constructing political debates and discourses that tend to divide us us (gosh, what do you think political parties are <em>for</em>, anyway?) is key for making CDRS work! We need some polarization to have meaningful choices that are meaningfully supported by electorates so we can have government by the people. So, Hitchens wasn’t wrong that division is essential, but that doesn’t mean that more is always better.</p><h3>Polarization Saves Democracy, Right (Or does it)?</h3><p>So, we can take some comfort in the notion that LIncoln’s hope that government both <em>by </em>and<em> for the people</em> are both possible and not necessarily mutually exclusive.We can establish that popular government <em>by the people</em> is possible and has happened in the past and likely is happening now to some degree. We aren’t crazy to feel that political ideas and pledges matter for the direction government policy goes in the future, and thankfully we can be assured that the democratic politics that we are polarized over is about a substantive fight that is won or lost at the ballot box with real policy implications. We aren’t all upset over something that ultimately isn’t consequential for the direction of our public and private lives. Our fights with each other across tribal lines do matter.</p><p>So far, so good. Remember, though, that I said we needed to keep Liberalism and Populism in dynamic tension if we wanted to have a CRDS-certifiable democracy. So, there is a <em>but…</em>.</p><p><em>But </em>it’s also worth remembering that in order to have government <em>by </em>the people, you need to have government <em>for</em> the people as a prerequisite. You need politicians who are faithful, talented and skilled representatives and leaders who will respond to and try to faithfully implement according the rules to which we have all effectively assented. You need people who will offer only their best ideas because they will bear the brunt of the consequences when it clearly goes bad in a way that everyone agrees is bad (corrupt, illegal, norm violating); the kind of thing no one would want done to them and which is ultimately bad for everyone needs to be off the table. Self-dealing by our politicians needs to be off the table, and particularly when it comes at the expense of the constitutional rules of the game that keep our elites under control. In short, you really <em>do</em> need to be able to credibly throw the bums out.</p><p>But, if we are <em>too</em> strongly polarized, if we <em>really</em> hate the other side since we are as or more concerned about defeating the others as we are getting what we want from our own politicians, throwing the bums out gets difficult. We will vote for them even when they fail, or when they are corrupt, or when they erode norms, and we will do all that with some measure of glee if the corruption, norm erosion, or failure hurts the other side too. Consequently, too little polarization and government by the people is impossible to render coherent. But, too much polarization and the incentives for elites to give two figs about what you actually want and need of them goes down radically, and the space for them to worry about themselves radically expands.</p><p>Political scientists, economists and legal scholars have only in the last few decades put serious intellectual attention towards these questions of ‘how is the rule of law maintained’ and ‘how are norms and institutional constraints enforced in government’. It turns out that most of the ‘common sense’ explanations like ‘cultural proclivity’ or ‘checks and balances’ don’t pass the test logically or empirically.</p><p>Without a combination of the impartial rule of law, the reliability of rules of procedure to constrain political action of elites to whom we delegate tremendous power, and norms to constrain malfeasance that might by impossible for us to detect or which might do lasting damage, democracy cannot deliver nor remain stable or the promises of elected elites believable. If we are too polarized, elites can collude and shatter rules and norms that ultimately keep us safe, because there will be little consequence. Indeed, it might be celebrated to engage in such vandalism. However, if we are too divided and atomized we can’t articulate or coordinate any response for the government to follow, including with regards to directing political leaders to address problems.</p><p>Let’s spin this out a bit. One of the most widely accepted analyses of the question of how we keep political elites respecting the law, institutions, and norms that allow for self-governance to happen is <a href="https://www.researchgate.net/publication/247201258_The_Political_Foundations_of_Democracy_and_the_Rule_of_Law">Barry Weingast’s model of ‘The Political Foundations of Democracy and the Rule of Law’ published in 1997 in the most prestigious political science Journal in the world: <em>The American Political Science Review</em></a><em>.</em></p><p>In this paper he builds a game theoretical model that yields predictions and claims that explain a great deal of the data and studies done before and after this paper, and remains in surveys of the literature among the most pivotal arguments to date on the question.</p><p>It’s logic runs something like this. We have laws, rules, or norms that constrain elites and protect us from their self dealing. Things like, l<a href="https://scholarship.law.columbia.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=3601&amp;context=faculty_scholarship">aws against the executive branch undoing regulations passed by Congress</a> or inciting mobs,<a href="https://www.legbranch.org/neither-republicans-nor-democrats-respect-senate-rules/"> rules governing Senate procedure to protect those in the minority</a>, and <a href="https://www.rollcall.com/podcasts/political-theater/the-transition-trumps-norm-busting-let-us-count-the-ways/">norms governing the transition of power</a>.</p><p>Now in each case, these rules have the ability to <em>transgress</em> against the rights and expectations of those not benefitting from the law, rule, or norm violation. Thus, when a GOP Congress and POTUS transgress the laws, rules, or norms to benefit their team, they transgress against Democrats and vice-versa. But, note, we rely on those things to prevent needing the use of arms to enforce an election result, to prevent voter intimidation, and to otherwise disturb the peace.</p><p>So, in order for a prohibition on transgressing a law, rule, or norm to be something that elites would want to respect they need at least one of two qualities to be true: (1) Elites are intrinsically motivated to be angelic good non-transgressing elites and/or (2) Violating the rules must be much more risky than following them. Restating in modified form our constitutional conundrum, <em>The Federalist </em>in his 51st installment tells us that reliance on (1) makes very little sense:</p><blockquote><em>“If men were angels, no government would be necessary. If angels were to govern men, neither external nor internal controls on government would be necessary. In framing a government which is to be administered by men over men, the great difficulty lies in this: you must first enable the government to control the governed [so that government might be by the people in the majority]; and in the next place oblige it to control itself [such that we can have government for the people].”</em></blockquote><p>Therefore, barring angels, enough people need to be sufficiently serious about opposing transgressions against the rules even if those transgressions appear to benefit your side of the political divide seeking to be the people by which policy is made. To be even more specific, it means that the supporters of the current majority need to in sufficient numbers be prepared to abandon their elites if they break the common rules upon which <em>government for the people</em> stands.</p><p>This is why ‘divisiveness’ in a state of high polarization is bad, regardless of who does it and in what amounts. That the other side may be ‘worse’ is, sadly, from the perspective of democidal concerns, of little consequence. Absolute nominal non-relative levels of divisiveness is what counts here. This helps explain why we have seen a massive increase in elite norm violation as polarization has continued apace. And it implicates us in our willingness to treat our fellow citizens on the other side with dismissive contempt, to attack the supporters of other elites directly rather than attacking the offending elites, and to generally see victory and the realization of our view of ‘justice’ as more important than maintain the ‘peace’ and civility required for social cohesion: We are destroying the foundations of the very norms that allow us to realize our visions at all.</p><p>Summing up, the best understandings we have currently suggest that the laws, institutions, and norms that stabilize democracy as rule for the people, suggests that democracy is threatened whenever too many people in that democracy think defeating their fellow citizens’ opposing candidates is more important than following the rules that allow either side their opportunity to shape policy. But of course, once one side signals that this is true, pressure for the other side’s elites to abandon laws, norms, and constraints and ‘go big’ (sound familiar?) regardless of the rules (Just change them. Elections have consequences). The threat to the rules by one side, incites the partisans supporting the opposing elites to ‘fight fire with fire’, with the long term risk being — obviously — burning the house down. Worse, our non-angelic elites know that in this situation the ability of voters to credibly signal that they will defect to another candidate or not turn out at polls to ensure that their enemy partisans don’t win. So, they have a much reduced incentive to deliver at all, but rather to break rules in ways that primarily benefit themselves, but in ways that can be sold as helping their partisans.</p><p>This is why as polarization has increased, we have seen a decline in congressional and parliamentary productivity and an increase in attention to cultural debates that aren’t legislatable. Virtue signalling is something that works extraordinarily well for politicians who don’t want to do much, while keeping voters inextricably divided.</p><p>Obviously, once we are here, it’s a game that only the elites themselves can win, and as asserted earlier the collapse of government <em>for the people</em> presages the collapse of government <em>by the people</em>.</p><p>So in order to have the ability to have ‘populism’ as we are using it here, you need both to control who gets to govern as a collective people, but you need those who govern to follow the rules that make that possible now and over time. They need to be a bulwark over things that are collective bads such that mistakes are punished. In order for that to happen, you need to be in a position where you can punish failures on your own team, and you need to be able to ensure that the game keeps going and both sides respect the rules, and the rules for how we change the rules (via constitutional amendment or other due process). These are collective goods that can only be provided by the collective willingness of a people to engage in them in sufficient numbers.</p><p><strong>Ethnic Wars and You</strong></p><p>For some, this might all seem highly theoretical. However, we have many cases around the world to look at of the dysfunctions that can be wrought through disunion among the public: Ethnically divided societies.</p><p>Ethnically divided societies are probably not what you think. When one thinks about sectarian violence, they tend to think about objective categories such as those that go to different Churches, or people of different visible characteristics. And, this isn’t wrong. It’s just that it can be that or anything else. Sects or Ethnic groups that are politically salient rarely emerge from a bottom up organizational concern, but they can easily in small groups. Social scientists have been able to generate emergent tribal behavior easily, and most famously and dramatically in the <a href="https://www.simplypsychology.org/robbers-cave.html">Robbers Cave Experiment in the 1950’s</a>, where a group of young boys were taken to a opposite ends of a camp and given mild cooperative tasks with each other before initiating escalating conflicts over control of resources (from baseball field to water supplies), escalating within weeks to actual violence with only minimal intervention of the experimenters (posing as camp counselors).</p><p>At scale, political entrepreneurs are usually required to help construct the imagined community (at camp the boys saw each other, whereas no Republicans know even 10% of Republicans). This is true in other societies as well. Belgium is an interesting example. It surprises most people familiar with the linguistic political divide in Belgium to learn that for half of that country’s history as a democracy, the single most important organizing cleavage in that country today — the Language divide between the French-speaking south and the Flemish speaking north — was virtually non-existent in Belgian politics. It wasn’t until the 60’s after the previous primary cleavage issue was solved dealing with religious versus secular education and social foundations, that we see the language divide spring to prominence. Why? Because politicians need issues over which they can generate conflict to get attention for votes. Once they find it, they fan the flames, the media reports on it, and voters may or may not take it up. In Belgium, voters did and eventually the entire party system in that country had to split into French Speaking versus Flemish speaking parties. Before this period, there was one liberal party, one socialist party, one christian democratic party, etc. Now, ethnic division and constant instability and governance problems.</p><p>Such divided societies are categorized by political scientists Alvin Rabushka and Kenneth Shepsle as possessing cultural diversity, politically organized cultural communities, and a salience to those communities.</p><p>And, before we assume that this has nothing to do with America today, you may want to check out <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2021/04/19/us/democracy-gop-democrats-sectarianism.html?action=click&amp;module=Top%20Stories&amp;pgtype=Homepage&amp;fbclid=IwAR2taSsd-mefja3eedhv8k9Fr70MpHIDfsiEnSZ-S2-5xBfo8qoeq-MYK-I">a recent column in the New York Times</a> highlighting research (<a href="https://pcl.stanford.edu/research/2020/finkel-science-political.pdf">for example</a>) that suggests that America is looking increasingly very much like an ethnically divided society. The column begins thusly:</p><p>“New limits on voting rights. The corrosive effect of misinformation. The rise of domestic terrorism. Foreign interference in elections. Efforts to subvert the peaceful transition of power. And making matters worse on all of these issues is a fundamental truth: The two political parties see the other as an enemy.”</p><p>But by now you might see the problem with this opener. It isn’t that the two political parties see each other as making these problems worse; for the most part our disunion <em>is very likely the cause</em> driving much of the problems in the first place.</p><p>And, contrary to the tone of this piece, there are good reasons to think that the degree of ethnic politics is roughly equivalent if different on left and right. Democrats are less likely to desire secession (“only” one-in-five to the Republicans one-in-three), but as <a href="https://johnmcwhorter.substack.com/p/stop-dissing-the-woke-are-the-alt">John McWhorter has pointed out</a> (and why he has to point out this obvious fact so ignored in our debates I couldn’t tell you) Democrats and particularly progressives are currently winning the game of controlling most of the important social institutions of society from corporations, to schools, to Hollywood, and recently even, increasingly, the U.S. Military. No kidding, they are less likely to desire secession. They have more to lose. However before the 2020 election Democrats and Republicans were roughly equal in their willingness to tolerate violence, and Democrats — due to their institutional dominance — engaged in transgressions against the rights of non-conformist daily in the form of utterly condoned cancelling, bullying, ostracism, and even riots. And, despite recent polls cited in the NYT piece taken after the 2020 election showing high support for violence to advance political goals among Republicans, <em>before</em> the election the support for violence among Democrats and Republican in the lead up to the election <a href="https://www.politico.com/news/magazine/2020/10/01/political-violence-424157">was a virtual statistical dead heat</a>.</p><p>And, it bears remembering that on the eve of the election <a href="https://eu.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/elections/2020/10/28/election-day-violence-voter-concern-trump-biden-exclusive-poll/3702477001/">a supermajority of the American public feared violence at the polls</a>, and<a href="https://www.brookings.edu/blog/fixgov/2020/10/27/why-the-risk-of-election-violence-is-high/"> top think tanks warned </a>that the threat level was high. It’s well known now among American political scientists that<a href="https://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2017/09/05/negative-partisanship-explains-everything-215534/"> negative partisanship (loathing the alternative) rather than positive partisanship (approving your own side and elites) is driving voting behavior</a> (and much else). We tend to vote against who we hate more than who we love. Indeed, true to our declining government of and for the people a majority of both Democrats and Republicans believe their government serves mostly the wealthy and the powerful. Turns out, having the public at each other’s throats plays well for the wealthy and the powerful. Go figure.</p><p>Moreover, we have the non-acceptance of election results. A majority of Republicans deem Biden’s election illegitimate on the grounds of election fraud. Now, the legacy media seems to be pushing the somewhat amnesia-ridden narrative that this is novel and a newly threatening sign from the particularly dangerous Republican voters. But while it is true that the Gallup polls taken days after the election showed robust support, this was all but eradicated by the first 100 days with <a href="https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/majority-young-americans-view-trump-illegitimate-president-poll-n735426">a majority of young voters</a> and by <a href="https://thehill.com/homenews/administration/334972-poll-dems-dont-accept-trump-as-legitimate-president">May 69% of Democrats</a> didn’t believe that they had accepted the legitimacy of the Trump Presidency. We will note that by May in the Trump Presidency, Democrats had already succeeded in launching an investigation aimed — in the minds of Democrats — to find evidence of collusion between Trump and Russian operatives so that his election could be deemed illegitimate and the President himself impeached. It doesn’t seem like false equivalency to suspect that progressive Democrats would be no more enthused than Republicans are currently at the loss of the 2020 Presidential election. So contrary to the optimistic legacy media, there is little reason to suspect that America’s problems are an insurgent right, so much as radically polarizing partisan sectarianism on both sides of the aisle.</p><p>People often refer to data that shows that the Republican Party has moved farther to the right than the Democrats. This is true on economic issues and other ‘older’ issues that these data sources use to track party policy positions. However, newer cultural issues aren’t included here. In those question the GOP largely represents the consensus of 10–20 years ago, while Democrats and ever more ideological and radical set of goals and issues. Fundamentally altering the legal and social infrastructure of the gender system from binary to fluid is, by any objective standard, a radical demand that is ever more mainstream among Democrats and which exists in exactly no metrics that I have seen of partisan ideology. So, I find that evidence unconvincing on examination (And I know that data extraordinarily well)</p><p>But, I admit, if it were simply a problem of an emergent autocratic sectarian Right it would be an easier problem to solve.</p><h3>Calling the CRDS Fire Department.</h3><p>So, what does one do?</p><p>So chances are, when you sit back and reflect, you would self-identify as a CRDS. I would too. But as I’ve laid out there are challenging logical implications to these different concepts that should shape our understanding and behavior about how we do this whole living-in-a-full-suffrage-constitutional-democratic-republic thing</p><p>Unfortunately, polarization and the practice of ‘breaking ties’ with those from the ‘other side(s)’ of politics work directly against concerns about these collective goods, because the idea of the ‘other side’ winning is so horrible that you must win at any cost, or the idea of doing nothing is so horrible that the idea of defending the common rules by which we self govern doesn’t appear worthwhile, relative to defeating your opponents. You identify more with ‘your side’ and it’s elites than the well being of ‘the other side’ and you will tolerate far greater transgressions that you would not tolerate being made against you towards your opponents. They can violate norms, and rewrite the rules with impunity, engage in scandal and misdemeanors, outrageous behavior, and move rules to defeat them later.</p><p>In this situation — if we are lucky — we will get alternation of government into a downward cycling sequence of power grabs and declining public quality and behavior. If we are unlucky, we will get no more alternation in government, and power grabs will get ever more absolute and minority protection will evaporate. The spectre of illiberal tyranny will return and the minority’s sphere of freedom will narrow, and they will face conformity or marginalization if lucky, or imprisonment/death if unlucky. Declining public quality and behavior will likely occur as they do in most large autocracies. .</p><p>This is one of those situations where the more aggressively you fight the less effective it is, and the worse your problems become. Instead, you need to do the opposite. You need to relax a bit and fight less aggressively. You need to remember that cooperation over these issues matters more in the long run. Our ability to govern is contingent on our cooperation and willingness to let others govern — for a while. This is part of the deal. And polarization works against it. But so do attitudes that fail to recognize that it really is much worse than you imagine *in the long run* to weigh immediate political victory as weightily as you do.</p><p>Thus, this is all about time horizons and the *real value* of constitutional self-government and all the future benefits of maintaining that good over the long term. We need to fight for the rules at all costs. We need to fight for ‘our side’ at any cost that <em>does not endanger</em> the rules of the game and the common good.</p><p>So, practically, if we genuinely care about the future and the rule of the people and in the governance of society, we need to be institutionalists far more than we are now. We need to be someone that stewards our institutions as resources of the common good, that establishes the structure of rules and opportunities that makes up the context in which we have disagreements, and fights like hell within them and through them to attain our particular goals. We need to remember that our institutions are meant to serve a common good and settlement rather than to forward any particular outcome, and remember the importance of protecting a domain for that dissent. We musn’t seek to dominate institutions ‘for our cause’, but dominate institutions to secure them as the structures within which we can advocate for our cause against others. And, obviously, we need to punish any politician that is anti-institutionalist for the cause. Politics that is all about fundamentally draining the swamp by obliterating the civil service or fundamentally dismantling and disrupting institutions needs to be opposed no matter who is shopping it or how much one agrees with the cause within which they are doing it.</p><p>We need to put Riker’s liberalism <em>before </em>populism if populism is to have any hope at all.</p><p>This is why I worry so much about the culture of social isolation for enemies, bullying, dehumanization, over-caricaturization, and the myriad of other polarization reinforcing habits. Constitutional Democratic Republican Suffragism doesn’t survive and provide the blessings of self governance by itself. It has obligations we need to accept. It has an ‘operators manual’ that requires us to hold commitments a little less tightly. This is why democracy is so unstable in the face of religious sectarianism or ethnic strife. These social arrangements make it difficult to scale our outrage as losing to a level compatible with the survival of democracy and self-government.</p><p>But as scholars are noting, America is looking more and more like an ethnically divided society, but one driven by our choices. Where we choose to live. How we choose to engage with each other politically online and in our offices.</p><p>I think we all need to scale our outrage to a reasonably morally informed and frank assessment of where we are, what is the worst that can happen if we lose a fight against our fellows as opposed to what we lose if we lose a fight against elites of either tribe. We need to keep sight of the primacy of the reality that we have far more interest in commons with other non-elites than we do with our elites by the simple fact of the power they wield.</p><p>Democratic collapse will not help the white or black working class. Democratic collapse won’t help women, or the marginalized. Democratic collapse will empower those able to mobilize power and win fights. That way is the failure of the experiment in self-government Lincoln celebrated in his address.</p><p>A Republic, if you can keep it, indeed Dr. Franklin. Indeed.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=49413aeeed91" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/parallel-republic/democide-by-disunion-49413aeeed91">Democide by Disunion</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/parallel-republic">Parallel Republic</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The next phase of Parallel Republic]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/parallel-republic/the-next-phase-of-parallel-republic-b0a910da90ce?source=rss-9d874078287b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b0a910da90ce</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[welcome]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[updates]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Brandon Zicha]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 25 Jun 2021 14:19:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-06-25T14:19:20.778Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/393/0*36WvlsFVabxZafjk.jpeg" /></figure><p>Parallel Republic is moving into its new phase. Now that the startup is over, the basic bugs of the platform worked out, and a core team assembled we will be moving to a schedule of at least one major post per week by one of our writers, and extras from writers and the community as they arrive. Each major post will be part of a series associated with a theme centered on the different authors who will act as editors and ‘heads’ of their respective themes. If contributions get more than two per week, the Friday newsletter will be a summary of the week’s publications on the website.</p><p>A key element of this new phase is the creation of columns and series headed by one of our regular authors.</p><h3>Politics, Society and Education: <br>The Parallel Republican and The Friendly Professor</h3><p><em>The Parallel Republican</em> and <em>The Friendly Professor </em>will be written by our founding editor Brandon C. Zicha, a liberal arts college professor of philosophy, politics and economics. The <em>Republican </em>will focus on politics and society, developing and discussing the core political themes outlined in the welcome post of Parallel Republic. The <em>Professor </em>will focus on issues of education and the university in our divided society.</p><p>But, political culture and society are essential to any political movement — and getting more essential all the time. As such we are expanding our range of topics and contributions as promised from the very beginning!</p><h3>Art and Culture:<br>Glory Days</h3><p>Art and culture compose the stories we tell ourselves, and are a major element of how we construct a shared sense of meaning. But who writes those stories? Who are those stories about? And who gets to decide? <em>Glory Days </em>is our art and culture series, written by Michael Wagner. It’s initial theme will focus on working class aesthetics and what that means, the existence (and subsequent loss) of a popular monoculture in America, and why it’s important to cultivate art that speaks to and for the experiences that shape the lives of most of our fellow citizens.</p><h3>Religion in Public Life, Praxis:<br>Living Orthodoxy</h3><p>Too much of the centrist political space has an exclusionary hard-atheistic hyper-rationalist component which both pushes people of faith to the fringes, and also denies us the unique perspectives and heritage that they bring to our collective lives. People of faith remain a plurality in America and any healthy mainstream American political culture needs to engage with it both the health of religion and the health of our politics. <em>Living Orthodoxy</em> will be the series, written by Rosemary Zimmermann.</p><h3>Personal Political Transition, Women’s Issues, Literature and Publishing: Alumna</h3><p>As polarization continues apace many have found their political identities shifting, and women in particular have seen huge changes in how they live in society since the mid 20th century. Shifting identities, rebirth, and the challenges of navigating it are by Therese Neumann in this column, which adds a concern for the role of literature and publishing for helping us to reflect upon and navigate our identities and place in society.</p><h3>Totalitarianism and Statistics:<br><em>Normalization</em></h3><p>A great deal of our discussion about polarization suffers from an asymmetry. Americans and Westerners generally are far more educated about and more sensitive to the forms, crimes, and horrors of right wing radicalism and authoritarianism while being far less educated on the forms, crimes, and horrors or left wing radicalism and totalitarianism. Likewise, proper use of data and inference lead to other forms of bias. <em>Normalization</em> is a column reflecting on American political life from the perspective of an Americanophile data scientist and statistics professor who grew up in a dissident family in late totalitarian Communist Czechoslovakia. Lucie Zicha will be the beating heart of this series, bringing in additional themes focusing on social science, data, and sociology.</p><h3>The Future:</h3><p>We are hoping to attract at least two more writers to head up columns with the working title of ‘X’ in dealing with issues of race and reconciliation, and ‘Precautionary Principle’ dealing with science, judgment,and the environment in public policy.</p><p>Most importantly we hope that with regular content coming at you from our core team here at Parallel Republic, you readers will become more engaged with your comments, stories, and suggestions so that we can grow our community.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b0a910da90ce" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/parallel-republic/the-next-phase-of-parallel-republic-b0a910da90ce">The next phase of Parallel Republic</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/parallel-republic">Parallel Republic</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Who Are We, Even?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/parallel-republic/who-are-we-even-9dd5d8f9c33f?source=rss-9d874078287b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9dd5d8f9c33f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[centrism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[political-culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[american-identity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[liberalism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Brandon Zicha]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 16 Mar 2021 21:18:31 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-03-16T21:18:31.525Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*qGW0vbce1ySGXnxG" /></figure><p>Who are we, as Americans? When you live in Europe for any length of time, you learn that — at least among those democracies — America has a very peculiarly contested identity. In Europe, it is still a concept clearly connected to ethnic groups; classical nations tied <em>at least</em> by language (Switzerland being a notable exception). My daughter could be born in the Netherlands, have a perfect Dutch accent, and never be totally received as Dutch. This is still a point of social tension that makes the universalization of the ‘but where are you from really’ question that Americans of Asian or sub-continental Asian descent experience just universal to all outsiders. My Czech wife on the other hand was basically considered American within about 6–10 months of living in America by everyone she met.</p><p>Now America has its issues too, as it’s impossible not to know, but this is still striking. It was something I noticed right away when I lived abroad for the first time. National identity, for most countries, is wrapped up in ancient myth, symbols, ethnicity, language and soil. A former professor of mine called this the ‘old testament’ view of identity. The Israelites were a people, promised a homeland deeply connected to them. The blessings of this status were uniquely held by these people. To join was not open to all. Following the Law was not required to be part of these people. A performed way of life was an act of fidelity to that identity, but not essential to it. You can be a Czech person, and not perform as Czech and still be Czech. Treason cannot end your Czechness in the eyes of Czechs. One is ‘of that people’. Like the Israelites, they are united by a mythology, a history, one largely lost to the mists of time.</p><p>By contrast, America is one of very few countries that has ‘birthright citizenship’ where being born here is the most solid ground of citizenship that exists. All one needs to do is step across the Rio Grande, like the Israelites crossing the Jordan, and have children on U.S. soil and they are citizens. People criticize it, but I think that’s beautiful. And, I think the people that criticize it do so from a particular view of what America is.</p><p>But like other settler societies (like Australia or New Zealand) the United States can’t rely on appeals to soil or a misty mythological past united by an unbroken chain of parents begetting children. And unlike most settler societies, America was, from the beginning, a mixed bag of different nationalities from different colonial powers and (often noncomforming) religious communities. America became united around a way of living and self-governing, and developed a sense of some commonly appreciated values and ideas. Indeed, it was on this foundation of Edmund Burke’s support that American independence was laid: The unique character, outlook, and way of living so differed from the home country, that imperial rule had grown so obnoxiously at odds with the values and way of life of those people that the Crown could not effectively govern it in his eyes. To Burke, Americans had a peculiar character.</p><p>So, there are many lenses by which Americans have reflected upon what America is and who Americans are. But I am going to posit as a back-of-the-napkin exercise 4 main streams of thinking about the American project and identity.</p><p>Yet I worry that one of these key elements of our identity has lost a major voice in our politics.The destruction of any identifiable sensible and imaginative conservatism in the GOP and liberalism in the Democratic Party, have been replaced by some hobgoblins of American history that come oh-so-naturally to Europeans, but have only popped up sporadically in American history: The ethno-nationalists, and nativists, and the radical ideologues.</p><p>I would summarize the four approaches that I see to American political identity thusly.</p><p>1.) America is an unrealized ideal.</p><p>2.) America is a defiled ideal.</p><p>3.) America is a way.</p><p>4.) America is a people.</p><p>Now to a different extent, over time, the different political parties and factions have given voice to these different voices in varying measure.</p><p>However, to speak in generalities and central tendencies (and applying all the usual and appropriate caveats thereto) mainly I think it’s fair to say that the current American centrist liberal tends to see America as an unrealized ideal. On the other hand, those further left see it as a defiled ideal from which we must purge the Clearly Wrong ideals from being discussed, and rip up branch and root, all evidence of the defilement and purge it<a href="https://blog.ayjay.org/katharsis-culture/"> Kathartically</a> in the belief that doing so will cleanse and improve society.</p><p>This sentiment is perhaps typified by the New York Times 1619 project, which seeks to recast the entirety of the American Project as ‘really about’ slavery and little else. Liberals have often been confused into thinking that those to their left are actually liberals, due to the sharing of similar sounding ideals. However, this confusion is an error. A gulf separates a liberal from a fundamentally radical position, though it is one consistently and historically unrecognized even in retrospect. The New York Times’ rather rosy coverage of<a href="https://www.nytimes.com/column/red-century"> the 100th anniversary of the Bolshevik Revolution</a> provides another testimony to this stubborn <em>no-enemies-to-our-left </em>blind spot. It’s hard to imagine coverage even remotely similar in tone about Pinochet’s Chile, Franco’s Spain, or Hitler’s Germany.</p><p>But we need our ideals. These become the modus for change and growth, and that’s important. It needs to be kept in balance with the practical demands of the moment, but if we focus too much on maintaining our current gains, we never achieve new ones. However, Democrats are currently in an often unrecognized war between two groups that largely differ on what America is, who we are in reference to that, and thus how we must proceed. Should we care about equality or equity, for instance? Are civic foundations essential to maintain even if they slow progress on other issues?</p><p>On the other side, the current push and energy on the far right seems increasingly channelling the hobgoblin of nativism, where America is seen as ‘a people’ in an ethno-nationalist sense. This view with connections to ‘blood and soil’ reasonings and instincts has almost entirely purged any other view from the Republican mainstream. The raw interests of ‘the people’, however defined, trumps any ideal, norm, or process.</p><p>Centrists, conservatives, and most of the old parties of American political history before the rise of the Republicans in the run-up to the Civil War, (and excluding the Jacksonian Democrats in the second party system) I would argue, tended to see America as ‘a way’. It was a system and an approach to self-government where living together in peace, liberty, and co-developed prosperity mattered. It was a politics of what John Gray referred to as a <em>modus vivendi</em> school of liberalism as embodied by thinkers like Thomas Hobbes, Edmund Burke, David Hume, and Michael Oakeshott. Adhere to those norms and ways — whatever they may be at the time (though often anchored by the constitutional story and ‘civic religion’) — and you are an American. Americans were distinguished by the profession of and adherence to ‘the way of the American’.</p><p>What constituted the essential elements of ‘the way’ was the core object of negotiation in the American project from the perspective of ‘Americaness as way’. Does it require one to live in a certain type of house? What about one who engages in different kinds of protest? But core domains were about fidelity to political processes and participation. Civics, commitment to enhancing and investing in institutions, fair play, law abidingness, and basic patriotism were key stalwart elements of this perspective. Being able to fully participate in ‘the way’ was a key element and frame of progress, such as it was, for those of this view. But, the core question guiding its reform was ‘what is necessary for citizens to live together in prosperity, freedom, and peace’ rather than the realization of a very specific moral programme or the enshrinement of a particular ethnicity.</p><p>But as the center empties and (real) conservatives and moderate liberals see their space in the political discourse dry up, we see ‘America as defiled ideal’ and ‘America as a people’ become the dominant and clearly most blisteringly mutually hostile visions motivating much of our discourse. It’s hard to imagine a more incendiary possible clash than one between the camp of ‘the defiled ideal’ and the camp of ‘blood and soil’.</p><p>Where ‘the defiled’ and ‘the unrealized’ can easily mistake each other as like-minded friends, there is no mistaking the zero-sum conflict between the world of faux-intellectualized radical ideal-driven change, and faux-emotionalist base-interest driven blood-and soil reactionism. The bonds of tribal affection both have their own clear idols of ‘the ideology’ and a common image of ‘the Volk’.</p><p>Likewise, to the extent that an ethno-nationalist movement can paint a picture of its group as merely a robust approach to enforcing a highly restrictive ‘way’, ‘America as way’ folks can easily mistake ‘America as people’ for more mildly misguided purveyors of an overly restricted approach to ‘the way’ than they are. They can have a ‘no-enemies-to-our-right’ problem, and fail to realize the danger, until it’s too late, of flirting with those forces for votes. This is why in the early period of the insurgency, the GOP old-line conservatives opposed Trump and didn’t take him seriously, and now are mostly outside power within the GOP or out of the GOP as NeverTrumpers.</p><p>But the natural pairing for effective governance are those who see “America as way” and “American as unrealized ideal”. Both are able to compromise, and these two views compliment each other nicely. “America as way” folks can get a little too enthusiastic about their norms and normalcy. An America-as-unrealized-idealer can get a little too enthusiastic about reform, but both have the common good at heart, rather than a separate idol where only those of appropriate parentage or ideological conformity need apply for full consideration in the brave new world.</p><p>Unfortunately, I feel we hear very little from ‘old liberals’ and ‘old conservatives’ with their optimism for context driven, fact based (rather than ideology based), reform and greater concern with harmony than moral victory. I think they are missed, and I would hope that a robust centrist political culture would want to welcome these visions of “who we are” back into the mainstream.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9dd5d8f9c33f" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/parallel-republic/who-are-we-even-9dd5d8f9c33f">Who Are We, Even?</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/parallel-republic">Parallel Republic</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[About the Styling: What’s the Deal with the Armadillo and all the Yellow?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/parallel-republic/about-the-styling-whats-the-deal-with-the-armadillo-and-all-the-yellow-1f62f5954c31?source=rss-9d874078287b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1f62f5954c31</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[armadillos]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[about-us]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[logo-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[centrism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Brandon Zicha]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 08 Mar 2021 14:57:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-03-08T14:57:58.995Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Basically It’s all about Matthew McConaughey.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/750/0*urrzMLG6wqU52krK.jpg" /><figcaption>McConaughey at a Willie Nelson Concert (Fun fact: One of his first jobs was killing Armadillos)</figcaption></figure><p>So what’s the deail with the logo?</p><p>For reasons I genuinely can’t recall, I have always liked armadillos. I know I bought a small black onyx armadillo when I was 12 and dreamed of putting it on my dream car as a hood ornament, which at the time was a 1992 purple Ford Mustang (I was 12. It was the early 1990’s). But, this is more like a sign pointing to the real rationale.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*vnNHEdHeJetoEHuyi65bfg.png" /><figcaption>Purple 1992 Ford Mustang (desired Armadillo hood ornament mod not pictured)</figcaption></figure><p>When I was in high school, I was (very) left-wing, liked Armadillos, and picked up a book by Democratic Party Populist and former Texas Secretary of Agriculture Jim Hightower who famously quipped (and attractively — to me — titled a book) that “<em>here is Nothing in the Middle of the Road But Yellow Stripes and Dead Armadillos</em> (armadillos in a leftist book title? “Buy!”, said high school me!). His was a clear argument for more left populism, and possessed of the familiar disdainful attitude towards moderation by the political wings with a long pedigree (and <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HLNhPMQnWu4">a great comedy bit by Monty Python’s John Cleese in 1975</a>). It’s not entirely undeserved. Much of moderation has been mushy milquetoast — a deeply unimaginative arithmetic mean between the wings or a ‘least common denominator’ blandness designed to be as inoffensive as possible.</p><p>But, right now we see a situation where what could conceivably constitute ‘the middle’ is large and diverse. It contains Never Trumpers, Christian democrats, classical conservatives, classical liberals, old school American liberals, the centrists in both parties The centers of gravity in American political discourse heavily favor the wings of the GOP and Democratic Party, and we know that the political parties themselves are nearly as far apart as they have ever been. Thus, on our metaphorical political road, there are very few cars coming anywhere near the middle. They are way off barely staying out of the ditches on either side. At times it can feel like I am going a little crazy. Are my choices really Trumpian anti-immigration and blatant discrimination or open borders and muscular equity (as opposed to equality) programs? Is it Medicare for all or Bust or pretty much no medical plan? Is it really a choice between unrestrained oil companies or unrestrained big tech companies? Between seering hostility to all institutional elites, to blind loyalty to traditional institutions that are seen as ‘on your side’? There is an awfully wide and productive gulf there where an entire political culture and programme could live!</p><p>This point was aptly made by one of my new favorite celebrities — Matthew McConaughey. In promoting his <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Greenlights-Matthew-McConaughey/dp/0593139135">new book</a> (which I recommend as an example of the kind of masterwork of integrity and wisdom in approaching life and politics) he has been giving interviews from various rooms in his house with his hair in various states of disrepair.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/938/1*o0N0AZrOuWQ8q8bdDMvbPg.png" /></figure><p>In at least two interviews, McConaughey, declaring himself ‘aggressively centrist’ exclaims something to the effect that “‘I’m walking down the yellow line right now, and the armadillos are running free having a great time.’ I said, ‘You know why?’ I said, ‘The other two sides, the two vehicles on either side of the political aisle are so far apart, their f****** tires aren’t even on the pavement anymore.” This particular phrasing came from his interview with <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cOkIHQ326JU">Russell Brand</a>, though I originally saw this on <a href="https://youtu.be/xdaBuncsxoE?t=1043">a different British Russell’s show, Russell Howard</a>. (Get more names Brits.)</p><p>I like the idea of being an Armadillo running free.</p><p>McConaughey notes that both extremes are serving up unprecedented threats towards the way of life and values of many if not a majority of Americans. This view is not out-of-step with research examining the views and identifications of Americans (as soft as these studies can be). Hidden tribes find the wings comprise <a href="https://hiddentribes.us/#the-wings">no more than 30% of the voting population</a>. In December, <a href="https://news.gallup.com/poll/15370/party-affiliation.aspx">Gallup found</a> that 41% of American Identified as independent, 25% Republican, and 31% Democratic. Gallup’s slightly more variegated analysis finds that Independents are a mixed bag, the Democratic Party just barley majority self-declared ideologically “liberal” rather than moderate or conservative, and Republicans overwhelmingly describe themselves as “conservative”, but as we have seen battling over the soul of what exactly “conservative” even means is a major element of what is roiling the Republican Party. When we look at polarization within Congressional Chambers, <a href="https://voteview.com/static/articles/party_polarization/party_polarization_files/figure-html/unnamed-chunk-8-1.png">it’s never been higher</a>. Nevertheless, McConaughey’s observation is not incompatible with what we know.</p><p>Moreover, there is some nice symbolism. The yellow lines in the center of the road is the guide upon which traffic is governed. It’s what keeps cars out of the ditch and from running into each other. They sit at the median of a two lane road, and just as the median should guide politics in a representative majoritarian democracy, so should it in our political culture and discourse. While it seems now the middle has to desperately grasp to moderate the wings, in a well run democracy, it should be the wings trying to pull the middle. Indeed, there is good reason to believe that the hostility of political extremists to moderates that resurfaces every time they are in ascendents is a vengeful triumphalism of having to curry the favor of the middle for so long.</p><p>And Aesthetically yellow lines have lots going for them. And armadillos are cute. And all of it can be turned into great merch or movement iconography if anyone reads this and takes seriously a commitment to a parallel republican lifestyle. And then, whenever anyone asks ‘what’s with the armadillo and all the yellow’ when looking at your Parallel Republic mug, you can start a fine conversation about what it’s all about.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1f62f5954c31" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/parallel-republic/about-the-styling-whats-the-deal-with-the-armadillo-and-all-the-yellow-1f62f5954c31">About the Styling: What’s the Deal with the Armadillo and all the Yellow?</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/parallel-republic">Parallel Republic</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Query: Why does the center fail to organize in America]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/parallel-republic/query-why-does-the-center-fail-to-organize-in-america-861b5c27f51d?source=rss-9d874078287b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/861b5c27f51d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[centrist-project]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[query]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[centre-parties]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[centrism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Brandon Zicha]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 19 Feb 2021 00:17:59 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-02-19T00:17:59.704Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*cKUncBOxb_DhmPpvegNtvQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Question for <em>all</em> my Readers — Why Do You Think Centrist Political Movements Fail?</p><p>So every now and again, I want to ask readers for some of their thoughts and questions. And now, since I have &gt;checked dashboard&lt; nearly 10 readers, I thought I might do this. You can answer and discuss in the comments, or email me at <a href="/service/mailto:parallel.republic@gmail.com">parallel.republic@gmail.com</a> and I really do hope to hear from you.</p><p>With that said, I want to write a long read in the coming weeks putting together my thoughts on centrist political movements, and what I think they tend to miss and how I think they could win in the short, medium, and long term. But, I am curious about <em>your </em>thoughts on this question or what you hear from others on these issues. You can easily roll this in with concerns about third parties generally, but I am particularly interested in your thoughts on moderate political movements.</p><p>Let’s try havin a discussion!</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=861b5c27f51d" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/parallel-republic/query-why-does-the-center-fail-to-organize-in-america-861b5c27f51d">Query: Why does the center fail to organize in America</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/parallel-republic">Parallel Republic</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“Reaching Out”: Persuasion vs. Conversion Snobbery.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/parallel-republic/reaching-out-persuasion-vs-conversion-snobbery-6b67b0262428?source=rss-9d874078287b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6b67b0262428</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[outreach]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[persuasion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[polarization]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[centrism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Brandon Zicha]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 15 Feb 2021 11:07:36 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-02-15T11:07:36.537Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>The Long Read</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/0*bQ1jANEpqm_-Roaa.jpg" /><figcaption>Bigstock/Khakimullin</figcaption></figure><p>As I noted in the <a href="https://parallelrepublic.substack.com/p/of-ostriches-and-armadillos-a-welcome">welcome post</a> at Parallel Republic, the motivation to start this publication was driven in no small part by the feeling that either I am going crazy or nearly everyone I know is. So I thought I would start with charting a particularly prominent kind of crazy and briefly suggest some things we might do in our own lives to address it.</p><p>The kind of crazy I want to discuss is so common it ends up in the New York Times and goes viral. It’s the kind where you forget basic stuff that you know, selectively. It’s the kind that can be exceedingly, cruelly hurtful to others and dangerous in our collective lives. Specifically, the crazy involves the way too many people I know are coming to deal with each other across divides in worldview and the the expectations we have of persuasion in light of what we are doing to bring it about in others. Let’s start with the thing you already know about dealing with people; that thing that tends to be forgotten particularly when discussing political or other close morally important issues:</p><p><em>Persuasion is almost never something that happens in one encounter exclusively by means of reasoned argument</em></p><p>You know this. This is obvious. To make it less obvious I could add..</p><p><em>…with the possible exception of purely intellectual exercises (Sure 1+1–2 — but honestly even then, have you seen a toddler encounter math for the first time. They need to really spend some time with these more advanced arithmetic relationships before they start really running with the implications of those hard fought conversation events to the reality of mathematical isomorphism with objects in our reality!)</em></p><p>But, let’s stick to the obvious, and examine the evidence around you!</p><p>We ‘plant seeds’ with our loved ones to get them to reconsider how they do one thing or another (often involving household chores or remembering to put down the toilet seat). We ‘work on people’ with regards to the holiday destination we want to take. We ‘establish rapport’ with colleagues before making requests of a weighty nature. We understand in dating that person we fancy may take more than one encounter. We also often accept invitations for dates with people whom most reason suggests is probably a waste of time but some <em>feeling </em>suggests it is a risk worth taking. Generally, we know that getting your parents to recognize the genius of your favorite song — if effective at all — will usually take time. Argument won’t do the trick. Similarly with major life decisions, or changing them. You might be persuaded to abandon your commitment to your fiancé, but it usually won’t be based purely on one encounter, and if it is, it will probably not be an argument that got you there in that encounter!</p><p>But, when discussing politics and other far more morally weighty commitments (relative to a date or putting down the toilet seat), people often suddenly seem to think that if we have a conversation with our uncle Ted at a family holiday dinner and he doesn’t see the genius of your Clearly Right™ viewpoint on the issue that (a) Ted is unreachable and (b) conversing with Ted is futile and possibly ‘harmful’. You leave frustrated and if the person’s prior view is sufficiently distant from the domain of acceptability to have decided upon, you may leave enraged.</p><p>You are engaged in what I am going to call <em>conversion snobbery</em>. Anyone who fails to respond to the charms of your efforts is clearly <em>not worth the time, darling! </em>I have noted countless times now that my students, acquaintances, and friends reach these kinds of conclusions on social media and in real life when making political arguments. Many pieces are written on this theme.</p><p>I, personally, was *very* into this during my first five years or so on social media, and pretty much since graduate school began, really. I was <em>an authority</em> you see, in possession of Clearly Right™ views! Your <em>ignorance</em> should be no barrier to <em>my knowledge</em>, you see? I was also a <em>conversion snob.</em>(I had to make amends. It was like a 12-step programme)</p><p>Recently, I saw this ubiquitous habit amplified in cruel and potentially dangerous ways by<a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2020/11/19/opinion/trump-supporters.html?action=click&amp;module=Opinion&amp;pgtype=Homepage&amp;fbclid=IwAR3-_E02dYhjZ6mb_VjEg8TToJlJ3aElwPf845sV44uUIjF0-OaQSkm0OBI#after-story-ad-3"> Mr. Wajahat Ali’s viral op-ed in the New York Times</a> before the holidays; a near perfect example of this pernicious implicit and clearly wrong view of persuasion, which is contributing mightily to tearing the social fabric of democracy across much of the rich democratic and (for now) free world.</p><p>The title of this piece was: ‘Reach Out to Trump Supporters,’ They Said. I Tried.: I give up”.</p><p>So, what did he try?</p><h3>Mr. Ali’s Experience</h3><p>Before getting into how this threatens democracy (which is a bit more of an academic topic and upon which more posts will have to be written to fully address), let’s first look at this exemplar of this implicit, pernicious and clearly wrong context-specific view of persuasion.</p><p>First, though, I want to point out that<a href="https://www.aacu.org/wajahat-ali-biography"> Wajahat Ali is a very successful and impressive person. He is, by all appearances the kind of person I tend to admire: The liberal artsy type who does everything from write plays to work with the State Department and engage with important issues with care and sincerity.</a> He’s, honestly, my kind of guy. So, out of the gate, I have favorable priors here.</p><p>So, why is this person appearing to misunderstand the very basis of persuasion and decide to advise the NYT’s millions of readers (eager to hate on an enemy in the most tribal period of American politics in living memory) to ‘give up’ on reaching out to voters who disagree with him and his co-partisans on the wisdom and morality of voting for Trumpism?</p><p>What experience could justify promoting such a conclusion?</p><p>Looking at his experience, I begin by finding only more to like about our good Mr. Ali! Deeply concerned by Trump’s election in 2016, he — drawing on his Islamic faith — set out to speak to Trump voters and help them understand that he and his were not only not dangerous, but in possession of important truths. He nobly asked his speaking agency to send him to places where Trump won in 2016. Since, he had given “more than a dozen talks to universities, companies, and a variety of faith-based communities” to reach out on important issues like</p><p>“how to “build a multicultural coalition of the willing.” My message was that diverse communities, including white Trump supporters, could work together to create a future where all of our children would have an equal shot at the American dream. I assured the audiences that I was not their enemy. I reminded them that those who are now considered white, such as Irish Catholics, Eastern European Jews, Greeks and Italians, were once the boogeyman. I warned them that supporting white nationalism and Trump, in particular, would be self destructive, an act of self-immolation, that will neither help their families or America become great again.”</p><p>Here,our hero sets out on a mission of dialogue, he tells us, motivated by deep moral and religious conviction. As a person of faith myself, more and more to like! Indeed, that middle part sounds a lot like the ethos I would want to further here in the Parallel Republic!</p><p>Even while I would probably have somewhat different specific arguments than Mr. Ali on some of these themes, I can’t deny supporting the entire thrust of the message he was selling in Trump country. Moreover, bringing it to those areas more than a dozen times and places for a few hours each, and having long car rides with voters who vote differently is just a good use of any American’s time if they are concerned that their neighbors err. <em>That’s the right attitude!</em></p><p>So far. So good. So, What happened? Mr Ali tells us:</p><p>In Ohio, I spent 90 minutes on a drive to the airport with a retired Trump supporter. We were cordial to each other, we made jokes and we shared stories about our families. But neither of us changed our outlook. “They’ll never take my guns. Ever,” he told me, explaining that his Facebook feed was filled with articles about how Clinton and Democrats would kill the Second Amendment and steal his guns. Although he didn’t like some of Trump’s “tone” and comments, he didn’t believe he was a racist “in his heart.” I’m not a cardiologist, so I wasn’t qualified to challenge that.</p><p>In 2017, I was invited by the Aspen Institute — which hosts a festival known for attracting the wealthy and powerful — to discuss racism in America. At a private dinner after the event, I was introduced to a donor who I learned was a Trump supporter. As soon as I said “white privilege,” she began shooting me passive aggressive quips about the virtues of meritocracy and hard work. She recommended I read “Hillbilly Elegy” — the best-selling book that has been criticized by those living in Appalachia as glorified poverty porn promoting simplistic stereotypes about a diverse region.</p><p>I’ve even tried and failed to have productive conversations with Muslims who voted for Trump. Some love him for the tax cuts. Others listen only to Fox News, say “both sides” are the same, or believe he hasn’t bombed Muslim countries. (They’re wrong.) Many believe they are the “good immigrants,” as they chase whiteness and run away from Blackness, all the way to the suburbs. I can’t make people realize they have Black and brown skin and will never be accepted as white.</p><p>I did my part. What was my reward? Listening to Trump’s base chant, “Send her back!” in reference to Representative Ilhan Omar, a black Muslim woman, who came to America as a refugee.</p><p>I am befuddled. Without trying to be uncharitable, it really does seem to me that Mr. Ali is basically saying “I talked to Trump supporters and they didn’t immediately change their worldview in response to my Clearly Right™ arguments. They did this even while thanking me for being a good speaker and appreciating that I came or offering my hospitality! Better to forget they exist and watch Netflix.”</p><p>Our author goes from outreach, to total erasure for 70 million Americans and 48% of voters from the American moral community after a series of 90 minute to 2 hour encounters with people who disagree on deep and complex issues. Why would one move from <em>that</em> experience to <em>that </em>conclusion?</p><p>It seems that after talking at audiences for a handful of hours and taking some questions (and as a professor at a liberal arts college, I have some experience with this kind of thing), maybe having a dinner, or even a car ride, he was very disappointed that their experience with him did not immediately yield <em>conversion experiences</em> — where, one might hyperbolically imagine- an audience member trades their MAGA cap for a sustainably sourced knit pussy hat. Let it be said, that anyone with teaching experience could have told him that this was a ludicrous expectation.</p><p>- Alternatively, perhaps, an experience where some Muslim Trump voters do not “realize” that they should abandon all notions they hold that they might be equally valued because they “will <em>never </em>be accepted as white” to our Clearly Right™ Seer-of-Future-Social-Trends-With-A-Gods-Eye-View-Of-What-You-Are-Really-Up-To. Because, you, dear Muslim Trump supporter, may think that you are independently working to decide what is best for you and your family and where you place yourself in the American political space, but what you didn’t know was that you were really chasing whiteness. That this goal might have never crossed your mind should be no barrier to you accepting the arguments of this person who has no interest in your Clearly Wrong™ view of your situation. It does take nerve, I suppose to reject a prophet with absolute knowledge of How Things Are and Ever Will Be on incredibly important and apparently simple issues like American race relations (we just need to think as Mr. Ali does!).</p><p><strong>Persuasion Doesn’t Work that Way</strong></p><p>Perhaps worse than the conversion snobbery is the expectation that he should see conversion experiences as ones that in a moment’s reflection, can immediately be seen as ludicrous. Didn’t we all agree at the beginning that it was obvious that persuasion does work immediately on the basis of intellectual argument? And didn’t we also agree that you don’t persuade anyone by not talking to them?</p><p>Mr. Ali is hardly alone. Many hundreds of people I have interacted with on social media, in classrooms, in lectures, or on the street seem to expect and demand that ‘reaching out’ should lead to immediate conversion experiences if we are to deem the attempt to ‘reach out’ worthwhile and those with whom we speak not an absolute waste of our time. Nearly all the pieces explaining how people should not be open to the other side make this point: You are deaf to the Clearly Right™ truth, and are cast to be cast to outer darkness beyond the boundaries of our moral community. You are, in essence, voted off the island.</p><p>Let’s start think about those who think about persuasion with the most intense practical concern: Advertisers. Each advertisement placed is paid for, and they want something for their money. What do they want? They want to persuade you to use their product.</p><p>When was the last time you sat down to watch a television show and an advertisement tried to persuade you to buy their product or service by giving you a rational deductive evidence-based argument? Is it true that during the entire course of your programme the same commercial never repeated. That is, do the advertisers say ‘well, I told them once. If they aren’t persuaded, it must be futile. Best not throw good money after bad’? Of course not. That would be a fantastically bad idea! Have you even <em>seen</em> television, to say nothing of the ad bars on your favorite websites. You’ve <em>heard </em>of Calvin Klein ads, yes? Any rationality or even intelligible content communicated in those efforts of persuasion repeated 3–4 times during your show? So, if those with the most skin in the game of persuasion recognize that we don’t persuade only with argument, or evidence in a single encounter why do we?</p><p>Well, we don’t.</p><p>At least, we don’t, when we are talking about persuading and reaching out to plenty of others on plenty of other issues.</p><p>And, when it’s about ourselves, we usually can recognize that even on the issues we expect others to have an immediate conversion, we don’t have one ourselves. When we recount our own changes of mind or heart in the past, we can usually admit that it was a series of experiences that eventually were required for the change itself to occur. We recognize that in our own lives, when we have found religion, or lost religion, taken on a new perspective or abandoned one, this persuasion process leading to a different perspective was usually a cumulative effect of many experiences and arguments. I was an agnostic or atheist my whole life, and it was many years before I eventually became Anglican. There wasn’t one argument that suddenly said: Oh, thanks for that. Christ is real. <em>Why didn’t anyone just say so!?</em></p><p>It often takes a village to change your mind.</p><p>As a personal anecdote, I have experienced and have been told (usually by frustrated partners over the years) that I change my mind on the basis of new information atypically quickly. And, let me confirm, that people who do convert quickly are often extremely annoying to others. It apparently can be frustrating to see people who have committed to something that annoys you and that costs you in other ways, suddenly just change their mind and become an ally at the drop of a hat. I can’t explain it, but it’s been my experience, my wife’s experiences, some friends and even a colleague or two.</p><p>But even in the domain of our political campaigns, people often hold candidates to standards they apparently don’t hold themselves. Biden supporters would have been horrified to learn he pursued Mr. Ali’s strategy during the campaign. Something like:</p><p>“We are going to put media buys for ads for one week, and will release one video explainer. There is no reason for more. If we didn’t convince them the first time there is no need to waste any of our resources getting more.”</p><p>Or consider, in romance, when out and about we see a person to whom we are attracted (remember those halcyon pre-Covid days? sigh.). Is it considered wise to walk up to them, give them the rational explanation for why they should go out to dinner with you, and, once rejected, never talk to this person again? Of course not! With friends and partners we ‘plant seeds’ that we hope will germinate into ‘a preferred conclusion’. Most long running partnerships are built on systems of long running mutual persuasion and growth.</p><p>Why should this be different in the democratic body politic? There we too are in a long running partnership, built on systems of literally intergenerational mutual persuasion and growth. What else is social and political progress, if not the fruit of that process?</p><p>Regress can certainly be the fruit of that process if those seeking progress choose to give up. It’s worth remembering how often Trump was criticized for repeating the same falsehoods over again at rallies, to which supporters might somehow see multiple times. Claims about various ‘hoaxes’ dismissed at first, became points to which supporters were persuaded. But, ultimately both parties’ leaders clearly understand the importance of persistence and emotion and if anything relegate rational argument as one of the last pieces of their toolkit for shaping public opinion.</p><p>A quick summary of the topic (much less the literature in media effects that I am familiar with professionally) of persuasion quickly reveals that it is <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Persuasion">complex</a>, and not well understood. But, no one disagrees that in most instances it will take time. Moreover, persuasion seems to have both time and emotional components. Not merely computational and rational components. Why are we being so very selectively strange in our expectations?</p><h3>I Tolerate Everyone Except… THEM.</h3><p>It’s always dangerous to try to make statements about the motivations for the choices of others. So, while I wouldn’t want to explain the provenance of Mr. Ali’s specific choices, I can — I think — explain why something this unhinged was published by the NYT and shared all over social media.</p><p>But I think Susan Harding’s essay “<a href="https://www.jstor.org/stable/40970650">Representing Fundamentalism: The Problem of the Repugnant Cultural Other</a>” and Scott Alexander’s famed <em>Slatestarcodex.com </em>article “<a href="https://slatestarcodex.com/2014/09/30/i-can-tolerate-anything-except-the-outgroup/">I can tolerate anything except the outgroup</a>” can help paint a picture.</p><p>As many have noted, humans have a tribalism problem. Or, rather, humans have a tribalism adaptation, and that adaptation is pretty maladapted to life in a liberal democracy where the tolerance and forgiveness required to have conversations across disagreement is limited by tribal animus. For reasons I’ll touch on a little later, when these tribal lines are drawn down partisan lines in a democracy, things can get very bad indeed, and relatively quickly.</p><p>The problem is that tribalism is built primarily on external threats and challenges. It’s tightness comes from a sense of embattlement. Tight, highly costly policing of one’s own relations — as is the mode of tribal politics — is only worthwhile and sustainable if loss of the group leaves one in a quite poor place, ‘out there’ in a palace of danger or defiement. It is extremely important to demonize a group in order to maintain coherence in the absence of strong natural threats to a community (like during the pleistocene when humans were very much at risk from being killed by all that nature out there).</p><p>It’s a great tactic for elites in political organizations to use, and the power of those techniques very much increased when strong in-group, out-group dynamics exist between their tribes. We see this tactic used in war, for example, to increase unit coherence and ease acts against the enemy through dehumanization.This view of ‘the other’ as threatening or repugnant makes it very easy to overlook the repugnant cultural other, and oppress them, which for the record, is what Mr. Ali and those like him are arguing to do. They are arguing to treat 47% of Americans in the same way classist bullies argue the futility of engagement with workers, the educated to the uneducated, whites to non-whites, colonizers to the colonized, etc. It also, as Susan Harding argues at the end of her piece, makes any detailed engagement with the specifics of disagreements impossible.</p><p>I mean, Mr. Ali and half of my social media feed has literally written off 47% of Americans as futile to talk to due to their irredeemability. In our culture, we literally routinely counsel a more charitable attitude to people to who murder our children today than we do very often members of the outgroup. If I had a nickel for every time I was told ‘such and such’ right wing person ‘shouldn’t be allowed to reproduce,’ I could open my own eugenics institute and double my money! Just think about that again: It’s become normal in civil discourse and common among friends to discuss eugenics, so long as the ‘joke’ is about someone from ‘the other’. This is, to all those with an elementary education, not a new phenomenon. Moreover, I am confident these are the very same people who were wringing their hands about people’s relief at the death of Osama Bin Laden or will cheer at the death of Donald Trump or Mitch McConnell. There are plenty of examples going the other direction as well.</p><p>It follows then, that if if you have this kind of dynamic towards a group, and you spend even a little bit of time being charitable, tolerant, and forgiving — say 2 hours in a lecture or a 90 minute car ride- the psychological burden on you is very high, and when you don’t get satisfaction from your lessers — deplorable, repugnant, others — after all you endured for them, it’s not beyond comprehension why you might forget that this is how persuasion works. I think this is particular once we mix in the mental and emotional taxation of living with an administration hell-bent on trolling half the public, and a media system keen to whip up those trolling attempts into a narrative communicating deeply threatening emergencies for kicks and clicks. But, it’s problematic if we start forgetting basic skills necessary for self-government, such as persuasion (or tolerance, or forgiveness) of those that we don’t already mostly agree with.</p><p>This, as they say… is not good.</p><h3>And this is not only cruel, it is also an example of something incredibly destructive for democracy</h3><p>When I first told a dear friend of mine that I was going to write my first blog post on the topic of persuasion and outreach because of this column being the final straw for me the in genre of ‘don’t invite Trump voters to dinner’ articles in the mainstream press, she was surprised by the strength of my negative response to Mr. Ali’s piece in the New York times . She knew of my frustration with intolerance across ideological grounds of the type that Mr. Ali was performing, but she still recognized it as out of character. It took too long to realize, but..</p><p>I was reacting and my attention was drawn to what felt like supreme cruelty.</p><p>My first thought upon reading this was that now all these people he was talking about in the piece will read about what he really thought about them the whole time. They would see that, for him, it was never the authentic conversation <em>they</em> thought it was. He was always trying to convert them and seeing their thoughts and arguments as obstacles to his purpose. It was a one way ‘reach out’ session that turned out to be a test. And in that session they failed his test and the whole country got the report card. The comment beneath the ‘F’ reads: “You and people like you are contemptibly not worth talking to”.</p><p>I next wondered if any of those people he mentioned in the piece actually did have a change of heart down the line, in part grown from the seeds of his own outreach attempt? How would they react to his characterization, and would it change their mind back? It was for this reason that it was hard not to picture Mr. Ali — and a disturbing number of people like him with whom I am friends (perhaps until I fail a similar test) — as something like a gardener stomping up and down on his germinating vegetable garden complaining about the futility of trying to plant vegetables in such poor soil with such contemptibly poor plants. If one is clear headed it is hard to take such a person too seriously. If one is clear hearted you probably feel something for the poor plants being denied opportunities to grow and change through more productive engagement with the gardener. Unfortunately, in our current crossroads those plants are people.</p><p>Ultimately, the belief that people ‘aren’t worth reaching out to’ is cruel, ugly, and bad for democracy or a flourishing community. It’s a dehumanizing discourse used in war, not within a nation. In any other relationship of mutual dependence we would call the withholding of such regard abusive, and it bears remembering that in a democratic society, we are in a relationship of mutual dependence.</p><p><strong><em>And now some political science.</em></strong></p><p>Republics are a lot like families. We are, in a way, married to every other person in a democracy. Much like in a marriage, it’s your right to withhold regard and be rude to your spouse, but they are still there the next day. And, while you were within your rights, the consequences make it an unwise strategy. Likewise, after you ‘fight to win’ an election for some political candidate running for office, the people you attack, condescend to, or sneer at? <em>yeah, those people still get to vote</em>. And, guess what? Like the people who went to Mr. Ali’s talks — any goodwill that was there you have very much damaged. The long term consequence is the opposite of persuasion but repulsion. It enhances polarization. This is one of the reasons that ‘negative partisanship’ drives so much of the political and voting behavior we now see. People appear to increasingly be motivated in their voting behavior not by love for their candidate or party, but contempt for those in the other camp. When you troll the libs, or ‘call out’ conservatives, it turns out they can hit back in the most consequential of ways. And, after being treated contemptably, favor those even further from your preference.</p><p>If we ‘stay married’ in such an unhappy union of disunity, democracy itself is threatened. This is a big point that I will draw out in a future post in greater detail, but to put it basically, the ultimate check on tyrannical government isn’t ‘checks and balances’ between elements of that government, it’s a game between the public and the elite. The reason we had legitimate fears in America about Trump not leaving office as norms dictated, and the reason why so many unprecedented norm violations happened over the past years, and the reason why so many actually illegal matters went without justice was because — increasingly — our two poles care about winning more than they do about the norms and rules that protect all of us and keep our democratic system — which is how we resolve governance disputes non-violently — break down. This is why a record percentage of voters in both parties saw violence as an acceptable response to losing.</p><p>We can step back and look at one less dramatic example. Obama radically expanded executive power and did a great deal of governing via executive order. This leaves the Presidency dangerously and increasingly overpowered. But then, it was this very weakening of the rules that protect us all. Democrats, like me, didn’t want Obama to stop governing. It was more important that we win the things we wanted that we couldn’t get through Congress than to say ‘these are the rules by which we govern ourselves for the good of all’. Then, this power passed to Trump, and his supporters felt equally keen with a greater expansion. Biden has increased this tendency still further, breaking all records in the first days of his presidency on executive orders. Today, Americans are more vulnerable to the personal attitudes and character of the U.S. President than at any time in the history of the Republic. It’s a slow motion constitutional crisis happening at our own behest, and driven by our antipathy for the other.</p><p>When Obama violated norms, Democratic voters didn’t stand up and say ‘no’. When Trump violated norms, Republican voters didn’t stand up and say ‘no’. Without that possibility democratic constitutional order is on fragile ground indeed. Because, while it is often forgotten, ultimately constitutional democracy is <em>not</em> a game played by citizens against each other, but ruled against the rulers. Republican democracy is primarily about self-governance through the contestation of elites who wish to rule, and only secondarily about how we organize that contestation. We must never forget it’s a system intended to empower <em>us</em> over <em>them.</em> When <em>we</em> are divided, <em>they</em> can get away with things that are bad for <em>us</em> and good for <em>them</em>.</p><p>Perhaps divorce, then? That was bandied about plenty over the last months! Divorce, in a nation state, is exceedingly expensive. The bills are measured, usually, in human lives as different factions fight over the houses, kids, businesses, and other resources. As in real divorce, both sides pay a large cost but unlike real divorce the bounce-back will never be quick. It’s generally a lose lose in the near and medium term, so you better be <em>really</em> unhappy before going down that road. And, it is probably worth taking a look at how objectively <em>good</em> things are, even if we need to work on making things more <em>subjectively</em> good.</p><h3>This is Not a Game that We Have to Play or Encourage.</h3><p>We don’t have to play this game. It’s just some effort not to. It’s becoming counter-cultural to try to stand apart from the totalizing tribal forces of polarization in our discourse. Most people that don’t fit, exhaustedly seem to simply disengage. They are the exhausted majority, according to Hidden Tribes.</p><p>That’s not a healthy strategy for us as individuals or citizens. But if countercultures that now underpin the poles of our great divides were able to begin humbly, so can an alternative. We can strive to participate and grow a counter-cultural habit that is more moderate in disposition, where we remember that we are not our politics, and we are not our statistical descriptors or our ethnicity. But rather where we remember that we are flawed people in multiple overlapping communities with distinctive histories and experiences and chosen allegiances who are prone to error, often slow to learn, and where if the big questions appear simple, it is probably because we are also prone to hubris and self-aggrandizement. More things, I think most people know, but seem to have forgotten, or rationalized away as ‘impractical at times as threatening as these’. But in this case, our politics are constructing the threat. We are the problem.</p><p>We are going to have to try to focus on working and living in what we can puzzle out in good faith to be right and true. <em>And That means always reaching out, always trying to teach, and doing one’s best to always forgive one’s neighbor. </em>Mostly, it requires the patience and forbearance that are necessary side ingredients of successful persuasion. A nation is a big family, and we are all in it together, ultimately. We need to start acting like it, even if we must begin doing it in a Parallel Republic that exists only in our own hearts and minds.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6b67b0262428" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/parallel-republic/reaching-out-persuasion-vs-conversion-snobbery-6b67b0262428">“Reaching Out”: Persuasion vs. Conversion Snobbery.</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/parallel-republic">Parallel Republic</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Of course, Puerto Rico (No, not the others)!]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/parallel-republic/of-course-puerto-rico-no-not-the-others-3ab6270982cc?source=rss-9d874078287b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3ab6270982cc</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[constitutional-law]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dc-statehood]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[centrism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[puerto-rico]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Brandon Zicha]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 15 Feb 2021 07:00:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-02-16T10:37:11.535Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*FpnhyFULsUNSuLeT.jpg" /><figcaption>E. de La Barrera, Wikimedia Commons</figcaption></figure><p>So, in light of last week’s discussion of D.C. Statehood, I have been (wisely) told that I should discuss whether Puerto Rico should become a state. I see no reason why Puerto Rico is not a perfectly acceptable candidate for statehood as soon as possible.</p><p>I say this both because it’s true and because, in these times, you sometimes have to ‘just get on the record’ about things because if you don’t, people might say ‘but what you really mean…’ Two readers wondered if my opposition to D.C. statehood wasn’t due to lurking hostility to Democrats getting more seats in the Senate, because they most likely will if Puerto Rico gains statehood. I <em>really</em> meant what I wrote last week about D.C. Statehood and I really mean this too. What I don’t really understand is why Democrats are even talking about, much less leading with, D.C. statehood in the first 100 days, particularly since, in many respects. statehood for Puerto Rico is likely an easier lift, politically.</p><p>First, both Democrats and Republicans have affirmed publicly for decades that Puerto Rico has every right to apply for statehood, and that the U.S. should admit it (despite weasley comments by some, recently, to the contrary), and it has higher levels of support among GOP and right leaning voters. There are Senators among the GOP who would have a difficult time back home explaining why they blocked PR statehood (I am looking at you, Florida) making it far more likely to find a defector, creating the ability to pass it.</p><p>Second, there are no major constitutional issues to consider, as opposed to D.C. Statehood. Moreover, despite numerous attempts to have an unmarred referendum for statehood, the most recent one on November 3, 2020, Puerto Rican voters were clearly in favor of joining the United States and turnout was high. On its face, this would be a ‘pure vanilla’ accession to the Union.</p><p>There are only three credible arguments I have heard against statehood for Puerto Rico (please feel free to send others).</p><p>The first concerns the idea that there is a part of Puerto Rican society that is <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Independence_movement_in_Puerto_Rico">very much against statehood</a>, and that it is imprudent to admit a state with an active seperatist movement. But, this is, relatively speaking, rather small beer. A number of states were admitted to the Union with active separatist movements existing at the time such as <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alaskan_Independence_Party">Alaska</a>, <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Republic_of_Texas_(group)">Texas</a>, <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_Vermont_Republic">Vermont</a>, and in Hawaii, where<a href="https://www.westhawaiitoday.com/2019/08/16/opinion/my-turn-unsettling-truths-about-the-1959-statehood-vote-in-hawaii/"> Anti-statehood sentiment</a><a href="https://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-34680564"> is still quite</a> <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hawaiian_sovereignty_movement#Hawaiian_sovereignty_activists_and_advocates">mainstream</a>. The movement in Puerto Rico would be expected in any fraught constitutional fight. Unless we are suggesting that states should never be admitted without unanimous support from the populace of that potential state, or that admitting Texas, Vermont, Alaska, and Hawaii was in some sense disastrous for the well-being of the rest of the Union, I can’t see how this matters. Puerto Rican independence is routinely less than 6% of the vote in the many referenda Puerto Rico have held on the subject.</p><p>The second argument deals with the margin voting to approve statehood. This margin was indeed more narrow than we might like, but not historically very narrow: 52.52% in favor and 47.48% opposed. This one seems more pressing to me, but it also seems like a question that is best answered by Puerto Rican’s and their delegates than the U.S. Congress. It’s also worth noting that the 2012 referendum also showed a strong majority (60% in favor of statehood and less than 6% favoring independence). This seems, overall, to be a strong signal in favor of statehood by the majority of Puerto Rico’s population and for a substantive period (ignoring the much contested 2017 referendum with very low turnout and more than 90% favoring statehood).</p><p>Finally, there is concern about the shape of Puerto Rico’s economy and infrastructure. I think this is the most serious concern, but it is also a complicated one. It is true that Puerto Rico would be the poorest state in the country were it to be admitted (and D.C. the richest in per capita terms, btw). But it’s poverty has a good deal to do with the colonial dependence of its economy on the U.S. <a href="https://www.cnbc.com/2017/09/26/heres-how-an-obscure-tax-change-sank-puerto-ricos-economy.html">Attempts to help develop the economy were repealed before the great recession tanking an economy and the public financing dependent on it.</a> Were Puerto Rico a state, it’s two Senators and House Representative would certainly have had more sway and the country greater interest in developing more sustainable growth strategies, with greater mutual adjustment and cooperation in the process. This also plays into the story about infrastructure. The destruction of the power grid by hurricane Maria and recovery following was hampered by a sluggish federal response that would not have occurred for a U.S. state. The collapsing public finances were due to a colonial development regime. Puerto Rico is probably just too big an economy to be run this way.</p><p>So, while it is certain, as with all things, that the issue of statehood for Puerto Rico is complicated and complex, it need not be from the perspective of constitutional politics or good governance. Regardless of my personal feelings about Puerto Rican statehood versus Independence, it seems clear that procedurally, in terms of the stated views of both major parties over years, and in terms of practical benefit to the U.S. and Puerto Rico materialy, that there is no reason why Puerto Rican statehood has to wait. This is in contrast to statehood for D.C. where it should wait for a constitutional conversation and an <a href="https://law.justia.com/constitution/us/article-1/59-seat-of-the-government.html">amendment amending the requirement for a federal district in such a way as to address the arguments and concerns motivating the initial provision for the district on substantive constitutional and political (as opposed to legal) grounds</a>.</p><p>While less prominent in the discussion, there is also a desire in some quarters to see the other U.S. territories made into states, such as Guam, the U.S. Virgin Islands, the Northern Mariana Islands, and American Samoa. However, these economies are tiny, and where there is an economy of any size, it is mostly Federal government spending. For these outlying territories, there are good arguments for special voting rights and representation, but little grounds for admission to statehood.</p><p>So, the big question is: Why didn’t Democrats go for Puerto Rican statehood before going for D.C. Statehood? The fact is that D.C. statehood is an issue over which voters are more divided, and has clear constitutional quandaries. Indeed, why pick the one that <em>looks</em> like a power grab to their opponents (correctly, I think, by the way)? I could imagine many possible lines of thought:</p><p>D.C. Statehood advocates were just more proximate with their demands, and perhaps the capitol riot increased that volume? As a friend also notes, D.C. is basically 40% black and 40% well-to-do white, so maybe it’s also about fundraising?</p><p>Maybe they think expending political capital on D.C. first — if it succeeds paves the way for Puerto Rico? This seems risky to me. Going for the constitutionally-fraught power grab of D.C. Statehood and having it go badly in a high profile way could color any attempt to admit Puerto Rico (but, then, why not the reverse?).</p><p>Perhaps the economic and governance concerns are worse than I understand them to be. If so, opening the issue of PR statehood could very well reveal this to the embarrassment of all. D.C. clearly looks better economically in terms of having the most wealthy per capita of any U.S. state or territory. Moreover, there is some weak evidence that in wake of the capitol riots more Democrats favor statehood for D.C. than before, so this may be attempting to capitalize on that event. Or, perhaps Democrats now favor decolonizing Puerto Rico with independence as has been the balance of opinion in the United Nations for some time? It’s hard to say in our polarizing times. What is clear is that regardless of the times, Puerto Rico is a far better candidate from a constitutional and governance perspective than statehood for D.C.</p><p>Bottom line: It’s wrong and unwise to admit our constitutionally provisioned federal district as a state without a constitutional amendment, even if you can swing it on a legal technicality. It’s right and not at all imprudent to admit Puerto Rico as a state after the November 3rd referendum. It’s a bad idea to risk the legitimate requests of Puerto Ricans who have inhabited their island long before the U.S. acquired it. D.C. residents however, with a handful of possible exceptions, have all moved to the district with full knowledge of its political and governance status.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3ab6270982cc" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/parallel-republic/of-course-puerto-rico-no-not-the-others-3ab6270982cc">Of course, Puerto Rico (No, not the others)!</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/parallel-republic">Parallel Republic</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Dividing the Question on D.C. Statehood.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/parallel-republic/dividing-the-question-on-d-c-statehood-284c9e8b30c5?source=rss-9d874078287b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/284c9e8b30c5</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[centrism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dc-statehood]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[constitutional-reform]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hot-takes]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[compromise]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Brandon Zicha]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 29 Jan 2021 17:17:29 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-01-29T20:00:24.201Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*EKXWMF6cXjNuGy5m.jpg" /><figcaption>Owen Byrne | Flickr</figcaption></figure><h3>A Hot Take</h3><p>This week Democrats in the House have (again)<a href="https://thehill.com/homenews/campaign/536052-senate-democrats-reintroduce-dc-statehood-bill"> introduced a legislative resolution to extend statehood to D.C</a>. I thought I would briefly lay out my initial thinking on this question based on my reading of the discussion in recent years. Given that constitutional political economy is my academic subfield, I thought that there might be a kernel of insight novel to some readers that might be a contribution. Maybe not. Do let me know in the comments on substack or <a href="https://www.facebook.com/ParallelRepublic">facebook</a>! <br> <br>The debate that I’ve seen falls unsurprisingly (and over-time increasingly) along the following party lines:</p><p>Democrats and ‘liberal’ commentators overwhelmingly approve of the measure granting D.C. statehood, citing principles of representation (as per the D.C. license plate) and less often (though critical) issues of self-government. They use elegant arguments on important values that cannot be lightly dismissed. They believe it to be the best idea conceivable to make D.C. a state.</p><p>Republicans and ‘conservative’ commentators tend to raise lots of arguments against it by either combing through fine points of constitutional law or procedure, or — more rarely — discussing some of the rationale’s that were originally used to justify D.C. as a state. They conclude (shock!) that it’s a terrible idea.</p><p>The problem is that the egregious partisanship that we have today makes it exceedingly difficult to discern good faith arguments from bad. Compromise becomes impossible in such a situation because ultimately the specific arguments are seen as <em>really</em> nothing more than cynical cover for what is essentially a zero sum political power game. It is <em>clear</em> that given the voting history and demography of D.C. that it will send exclusively Democratic congressional representatives. If Democrats win, they get 2 Senate Seats and 1 House seat and Republicans are disadvantaged relative to the status quo. If Republicans win they retain the size of advantage they claim due to the malapportionment relative to population in the U.S. Senate (where each state gets 2 Senate seats) and Democrats retain their disadvantage under the status quo.</p><p>Given that so much of the debate is actually a rhetorical flourish of the <em>real</em> underlying power-game between increasingly polarized partisan elites, the issues we might want to think about beyond who gets what in (mainly) The U.S. Senate becomes rather obscured. The best interests of residents of D.C. balanced against the good of the Union and its residents is largely lost. Thinking tends to follow pure tribal response: If you are a Democrat, Republican arguments must be bad and or wrong because they come from a desire to maintain power, and if a Republican than Democratic arguments must be bad or wrong because they come from a desire to increase power and if you are really neither and non-tribally aligned you look at all this and say something like ‘I hate this politics stuff’, ‘it doesn’t matter’, or something a Libertarian would say.</p><p><em>But I tend to think both sides are mostly right</em>. The lack of representation for D.C. residents <em>is</em> a big problem. “Taxation without representation” is very uncool. Can one even be American and think otherwise? But, there is something extraordinary about changing the nature of a federal jurisdiction constitutionally provisioned independence of non-Federal control without a Constitutional Amendment. It is, after all, <em>our</em> capital. Not, the D.C. resident’s capital, and they knew it when they moved there or were born there. It’s 10 miles wide. You can walk somewhere else. Moreover, this special status is for good reason as the district is meant for the Federal government’s immediate provision and maintenance. Independence of sectional sovereign control is something that matters. This is not merely implied, but stated clearly in <a href="https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/fed43.asp">section 2 of <em>Federalist 43</em></a>. It’s hardly akin to the Electoral College in its peculiarity. Such a need for special independence and status is recognized in the capital districts of other federations like Brazil and Australia.</p><p>Why this independence matters has never been clearer to me than it is today. Whether you agree it was a right or not (I enjoyed it), Donald Trump and his family were harassed and targeted by the city and state government in my home state of New York. The State Attorney General put incredible scrutiny on Trump, a NYS resident, because of his job and his politics. City officials painted taunting “Black Lives Matters” murals on the street in front of Trump tower. The entire Trump clan has complained about and thus moved away from the treatment they received in NYS. There is a much larger list of examples of the City and State government using their sovereign independence of Federal control to do it. In short they did everything they could get away with legally within the purview of a sovereign state within the Union. As we see across our politics, informal norms no longer hold in much sway in partisan fights, but merely what one can get away with legally.</p><p>We saw Trump use multiple times the narrow powers at the Federal government’s disposal to retaliate against New York for these shenanigans (My own parents got caught up in one of these retaliations when they were prevented from reapplying as NYS residents for expedited foreign entry under Nexus). But, it would be politically disastrous if it occurred in Washington D.C. Currently, the local government of D.C. getting up to such hijinks is fraught with peril for its leaders, because they essentially operate at the pleasure of the U.S. Congress (this exaggerates it somewhat, but it is non-trivial the degree of oversight). No matter the animus for members of one party or another by the D.C. government they know full well that it is only a matter of time before those members control the Congress. This Congress can far more aptly punish harassment than the U.S. President can regarding the government of New York State. Combined with the reliable alternation in Congressional control, hijinks are unlikely.</p><p>What kind of hijinks beyond those we saw with Trump in NYC might I worryingly imagine? Perhaps, the closing of roads or using selective policing to prevent certain partisans from getting to a key vote on time, everything we saw regarding the use of security forces around the Capitol attack, and so much more. And, the problem from a political perspective is that this would be solidly partisan. Democrats would have a far easier time than Republicans for the foreseeable future in a Statehood-granted DC engaged in partisan hijinks. These kinds of things can create dangerous perceptions and thus politics that are even more divisive.</p><p>We should remember that last Autumn much ink was earnestly spilled about whether or not the Republic would survive the election to transition of power. I shudder to think how that would go if a Governor, States Attorney, and city officials had been harassing the President, conservative protesters, and other officials for the last four years.</p><p>Perhaps what is most striking to me about the conversation I have seen about this, is that despite the claim by D.C. Delegate Del. Eleanor Holmes Norton, that “[t]here’s never been a time when statehood for the District was more likely” there was another time when there was a constitutional amendment put to the States on the question of representations for the citizens of DC. An Amendemnt that received the necessary two-thirds vote in both chambers of Congress: District of Columbia Voting Rights Amendment of 1978. It read:</p><p>“SECTION 1. For purposes of representation in the Congress, election of the President and Vice President, and article V of this Constitution, the District constituting the seat of government of the United States shall be treated as though it were a State.</p><p>“SEC. 2. The exercise of the rights and powers conferred under this article shall be by the people of the District constituting the seat of government, and as shall be provided by the Congress.</p><p>“SEC. 3. The twenty-third article of amendment to the Constitution of the United States is hereby repealed.</p><p>“SEC. 4. This article shall be inoperative, unless it shall have been ratified as an amendment to the Constitution by the legislatures of three-fourths of the several states within seven years from the date of its submission.”</p><p>This amendment therefore essentially <em>divided the question </em>of representation and independence, and served the good faith argument of both of our current partisan tribes. D.C. residents would have representation to go with that taxation, and would have their voices heard in the Federal government. However, it’s continued independence would be preserved by maintaining the current relationship between Congress and the District (save for elements rendered irrelevant in the 23rd Amendment managing the District’s Electoral Votes).</p><p>If we truly care nothing for D.C.’s status as a federal seat requiring some measure of independence — which would be the Democrats’ reply to this argument I imagine — than it is unnecessary and weird to render as independent a territory that the State of Maryland ceded to the Federal government to form the district. Rather, it would be more logical to simply return it to Maryland as has already been done with the portions of the district that Virginia retroceded (yes, I looked up the word) in 1847. I can see why it benefits Democrats to gain ‘voice’ for D.C. residents in the form of a bonafide U.S. State with a House member and two Senators, but it being ‘good for Democrats’ is not exactly sound constitutional reasoning.</p><p>But clearly there are options that can balance the principles that Democrats (genuinely or cynically) correctly put forth, and the prudence that Republicans (genuinely or cynically) correctly put forth. Besides merely reintroducing the 1978 Amendment, one might modify it any number of ways to deal with other concerns. But, to do so, we need to think beyond the question of statehood, retrocession to Maryland, or the status quo. To do this we need to divide the question of sovereignty and representation. Unfortunately and suspiciously, it seems this is <em>exactly</em> the acknowledgement neither side really wants us to see.</p><p>If, that is, I haven’t just missed this part of the discussion. You tell me.</p><p>Bottom line:</p><ol><li>It’s <em>our</em> Federal District and its status should be modified by Constitutional Amendment (even if a legal argument can be found that it is permissible to do so without such an amendment)</li><li>Representational concerns are absolutely valid, but so is the need for independence of the District from non-Federal control.</li><li>This question can be split, if only we can actually talk about the actual issue from the perspective of the common good of the Republic and the residents of D.C. and not merely the best interests of the two tribes fighting for dominance.</li></ol><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=284c9e8b30c5" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/parallel-republic/dividing-the-question-on-d-c-statehood-284c9e8b30c5">Dividing the Question on D.C. Statehood.</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/parallel-republic">Parallel Republic</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Of Ostriches and Armadillos: A Welcome to Parallel Republic]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/parallel-republic/of-ostriches-and-armadillos-a-welcome-to-parallel-republic-555cad4cfee5?source=rss-9d874078287b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/555cad4cfee5</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[introduction]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[welcome]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[centrism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Brandon Zicha]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 26 Jan 2021 14:22:16 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-01-26T14:22:16.023Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Where the center holds and we remember who we are.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/435/1*K7LaUdQpmEcZbY41EquXuA.jpeg" /></figure><blockquote><em>“Things fall apart; the center cannot hold”</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>“The best lack all conviction, while the worst are full of passionate intensity”</em></blockquote><blockquote>from “The Second Coming” by W.B. Yeats</blockquote><p>In 1977 a resistance organization was formed in communist Czechoslovakia called Charter 77. The group and its spokesman Václav Benda faced the challenge of building the resistance in a regime where all quarters of public life were subject to its control through force and lies; from universities, to arts, culture, and entertainment to how one addressed people. His solution, he wrote in his 1978 essay “Parallel polis” was to develop parallel conversations, commentary, organization and community that rejected the use of force and lies. As direct confrontation with institutionalized elites was impossible, Benda suggested that the only way to overthrow the regime was to build a new society from within that remembered who they were.</p><p>As a political scientist (and a concerned citizen), I am alarmed by the polarization and intensifying radicalism on both sides of our current political spectrum. Tolerance for political violence on both left and right is increasing; reports of self-censorship are accumulating amongst partisans of every stripe; conspiracy theories once relegated to the margins of society are entering the mainstream. Few, if any, of our institutions, from the universities (once aspiring bastions of free and uncensored exchanges of ideas) to our media outlets, to our social media channels have been exempt from radicalization and colonization by strange political cultures. These cultures come bearing yet stranger terms and aggressive postures where conversation is not fun or nourishing and authentic sentiment can be dangerous. It’s not an oppressive state (yet), but an increasingly oppressive state of affairs.</p><p>At times like these, any of us could be forgiven for practicing the way of the ostrich. Keeping busy. Heads in the sand. But now, more than ever I think, it’s time to practice the way of the armadillo: tough, resilient, aggressively running free right down the middle of the road. Afterall, you won’t get hit if the cars are on the edges of the road! Particularly if you roam in numbers!</p><p>My ambition for this publication and newsletter is, at a minimum, for it to serve as a platform where I can share ideas fit for self-governance. In my greatest ambition a great many of us will do it together here, where we genuinely explore the importance of our arts and institutions and how they are vital to our political culture and share tips and stories of us building parts of the parallel republic in our own lives, workplaces, and communities. Where we create a moderate self-aware community building a parallel republican culture where self-governance and free thought can flourish.</p><p>Yet, polarization creates more opportunity for creativity in between the poles. It is the center that makes things work! Parallel Republic embodies the space opened up in an increasingly polarized discussion for a spirit of ‘aggressive centrism’ at levels intellectually high and beautifully common. This newsletter hopes to facilitate building a parallel republic among those practicing ‘the way of the armadillo’ where we run free in an ever more wide open center in the middle of the road, where yellow lines anchor the domain in which the only productive sustainable future can feasibly be written in a democratic republic, if we can keep it.</p><p>My friends, welcome to my “parallel republic”. With your subscription and creative contributions, I hope you will make it <em>our </em>parallel republic.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=555cad4cfee5" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/parallel-republic/of-ostriches-and-armadillos-a-welcome-to-parallel-republic-555cad4cfee5">Of Ostriches and Armadillos: A Welcome to Parallel Republic</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/parallel-republic">Parallel Republic</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>