<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Brendan McGuirk on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Brendan McGuirk on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@brendan-mcguirk?source=rss-30558b07bbbe------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 17:29:24 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@brendan-mcguirk/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Alchemy: How the Spirit of Karaoke Shapes These Unforgettable Cover Songs]]></title>
            <link>https://brendan-mcguirk.medium.com/the-alchemy-how-the-spirit-of-karaoke-shapes-these-unforgettable-cover-songs-50a44ba5822b?source=rss-30558b07bbbe------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/50a44ba5822b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[cover-songs]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[favorites]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[karaoke]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[music-list]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Brendan McGuirk]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 04 Jan 2021 16:10:09 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-01-04T16:10:09.830Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Digging into the Magic of Singing Another’s Song, and a List of the Best</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Svtc0_qRvAQyA4ZiOPvpUA.jpeg" /><figcaption>The author has a penchant for borrowing the lyrical works of others to curry public attention for himself. Audience approval not mandatory.</figcaption></figure><p><em>First composed June 2014, but left in a neglected songbook to age half-a-dozen years.</em></p><p>There’s something magical about the perfect cover.</p><p>Generally, when appreciating art, it’s originality we hold sacrosanct. Be original, be the first. But it’s not like originality is all that big a deal. After all, isn’t our favorite thing to do with beloved works of art to inspect them closer, finding our own intellectual satisfaction by sussing out the various inspirations to each artistic flourish and celebrating ourselves for appreciating its inspirational genealogy? Don’t we love finding the treasure map to creativity, so we can claim it as our own?</p><p>But nothing has ever been born without inspiration. It’s our most sharable commodity.</p><p>I’ve always found that there’s something pure about attempting to recreate something already recognized as great. It takes a damn-near inconceivable balance of naivete, hubris and humility to look at someone else’s output and say, “Sure, but let me try.” It’s like trying to raise someone else’s kids. While they and all their closest friends watch.</p><p>Interpreting other people’s work, I think, comes down to concessions. Audiences love an admittance — like the way the ultimate concession at the heart of every covered song is “We all know I am but tourist, borrowing time on this tune.” Copping to this affords the interpreter the opportunity to toy with the audience’s relationship to the song, and maybe their perception of the one doing the interpreting. It frees up space for commentary.</p><p>Creatively birthing something is usually judged as an individual achievement: I did this, this is of me. But remaking something is to claim it for yourself, which you could say creatively frees it up for everyone. The art of the nostalgic tribute is democratically inclusive in a way originality can never be, because it hinges on a preexisting relationship between audience and art that exists outside the tyranny of an individual performer.</p><p>When your favorite musician plays your favorite hit, say as a swelling conclusion to a live show, your cheers for the artist — the creatives themselves. When someone unexpected plays a song we love, though, we then cheer for the art of the song itself, while also cherishing the specific and individual joy it awakens in us, from our lives. We love it with a collective intensity accrued through each and every time each of us has ever loved that song before. It is a powerful sensation, especially to share as a crowd. If there’s a reason crowds wait their turn for karaoke, that’s it.</p><p>Not too deep down, many music lovers want not to listen to the song, but to belt it out, as they would in a car or a shower or in the privacy of their own home or mindlessly in public (if they’re one of those assholes who can be found crooning in the streets, mid-commute, headphones deadening them to the surrounding world… like me).</p><p>A great cover is like playing a certified hit from a decade past at a busy bar; a surefire bring-the-house-down bullet. Ear candy #TBT. Part of me wonders if — for a generation weaned on hip-hop’s sample-oriented, sound-collage, did-you-catch-that culture, and taught a citational brand humor most evident by an affinity for quoting jokes from The Simpsons (presuming that means all of us) — covers tap into our collective eagerness to broadcast cultural preferences in ways things like Facebook Likes, Favorites, Reddit +1s and upvotes and everything else constantly aspire to. Is there anything mass media reinforces stronger than our desire to share and participate in things? Is there any more bonding glue for community across life’s boundaries than cultural nostalgia?</p><p>In the present, we’re all over the map. But in the past? We tend to share that. And that’s what covers can highlight.</p><p>Of course, this mostly rides on the cover being good. Interpretations can all fall on a range of scale. Some songs are straight karaoke versions, risking little while emulating every lilt of the beloved original recording. The best these versions can hope to do is satisfactorily hit their marks. But the greatest covers are the ones that take the biggest leaps, and risks. The songs I find most resonant are the ones that remind me how goddamn good the original song is while engaging me with the artist doing the reimagining in ways I could never predict. Sometimes that quality comes from who is performing what song, sometimes it’s how they’re doing it, sometimes it’s that same undefinable pixie dust that’s always had the mysterious power to transform a song into a hit. Like most creative art, though, the performer’s most pressing task is to make choices. What choices singers make about how to negotiate an original relationship with an unoriginal song is what decides the best covers.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CvvKj-aC6RnAseRX1Qe8nw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Last thing I’ll say before we dive into a presentation and justification for a highly subjective Greatest Covers of All Time List — do me a favor and indulge me this fantasy scenario: You’re in a medium-sized bar, maybe by yourself, and it’s karaoke night. You’re not inclined to participate — maybe your throat is sore. So you sit at the back of the bar, sipping a drink or three. In an hour, you’ll leave, but first, you decide, you’re going to make the time, and listen to see what tonight’s batch of wannabe crooners has to offer.</p><p>You sit back, and, by some cosmic stroke of luck, it is these songs, by these performers, that you find yourself hearing.</p><p>You know those kinds of nights — where everyone within earshot is a star.</p><p><strong>1) </strong><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w829VZR1e4c"><strong>The Chain<br>Res<br>Made famous by Fleetwood Mac</strong></a></p><p>“If you don’t love me now/ You will never love me again.”</p><p>The thing about the phrase “now or never” is that it’s just an inquiry. It suggests, but ultimately the sentiment is a passive one; the person asking the question is not the one doing the deciding. The brilliance of The Chain, though, is how it flips it, using the conditional nature of “now or never” as fuel for a transformation from deferential inquiry into pleading ultimatum. The shift is subtle but vital, because as that inversion tilts, so does the power dynamic of the relationship in question.</p><p>It’s a battle cry for the lover that is in the middle of deciding to assume command of an imbalanced relationship. It’s a goddamn declaration, albeit with a caveat. No more. No, more.</p><p>Stevie Nicks knew what the fuck she was doing back in the day when Fleetwood Mac let Rumours fly. And what Nicks knew then, about pain and neglect and the power that’s born through impassioned surrender, Philadelphia neo-soul vocalist Res proves to know now with her agonized 2013 cover of The Chain.</p><p>Res channels Nicks with requisite flair, despair and immediacy on her Refried Mac EP, a five-track Fleetwood tribute that recasts the classic pop-rock group’s biggest crossover hits into the modern world’s ascendent alt-R&amp;B milieu. The Chain is a standout, with Res’ swelling, uptempo interpretation carrying every bit of the pained confusion and accusatory scorn that the original did 40 years ago.</p><p>Spurned lovers are the furthest thing from untrodden ground in music, pop especially. But isn’t what forges The Chain its classically-cast feminine outrage? We only hear her voice, but we know exactly who this singer is yelling at (and I don’t mean all the side-eyeing that was going on when the members of Fleetwood Mac were writing it). Some man has done done her wrong and has rejected her unconditional love that she offered freely and now she’s in hysterics but she’ll be damned if you’re gonna call her hysterical because she knows she’s right (and without dispute is). And now it’s shape-the-fuck-up-while-you-ship-the-fuck-out o’clock. But also maybe stay. Because damn your love. Damn your lies.</p><p>The song has a universal shape to it, and Res’ cover outlines by snugly fitting the classic arena rock song peg into an urban contemporary shaped-hole without strain. The Chain’s emotional truth holds familiar form across generations, class and culture, and even works if you only know it from that one episode of Glee.</p><p>When the five members of Fleetwood Mac wrote The Chain, they created something timeless. They’re a great band to cover because their songs are familiar, emotive, singable, and play to the back of the room. But what Res does, with force, scale, and ambition, is just about a full-on revival. On her Refried Mac album, she almost inhabits Stevie Nicks like a character, a role made famous by someone else on Broadway (or, to be more accurate to today’s landscape, an updated Hollywood remake). She’s honoring the previous performer, who defined and shaped the character, while also modernizing it into something distinctly her own. She really seems to have a relationship with the song, and delivers the lyrics with such stirring conviction you’re sure its richness could only have been born of her own perspective.</p><p>Res’ personal recontextualization unearths links that reveal The Chain to be even more broad and anthemic that was already apparent. When she mourns the breaking of The Chain, you mourn it too — if not hers, than your own. Listen to the wind blow.</p><p><strong>2) </strong><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U8JHP1wo-R4"><strong>Iron Man<br>The Cardigans<br>Made famous by Black Sabbath</strong></a></p><p>It was going to happen eventually, so perhaps it’s for the best if this sort of confession is out of the way early: I’m pretty positive that this version of this song is flat-out better than the original. Some may call naming a cover to be better than its progenitor sacrilege, but for them I can only offer a challenge; play the Black Sabbath song and then The Cardigans’ version, take a truth serum, and tell me anything other than that the one they’d prefer to hear again is the latter. Maybe it’s owed to my hardwiring, but the molasses-crawl chords and honeyed vocals are just so goddamn pleasant that I cannot fathom being disagreed with.</p><p>If any of this sounds irrational, it’s probably due to the fact that we are talking about pretty much the sexiest song in human existence, whose eroticism may even cause temporary insanity, but eroticism is subjective so what do I know. Except that I know where Ozzy beckoned darkness itself, lead singer Nina Persson goes all-out ScarJo in Her with cooing pillow talk that instead beckons into darkness, inviting the lumbering Iron Man to bed with her flirtatious doot-doot-doot-doos.</p><p>A million years before Robert Downey Jr. happened, “Iron Man,” stood tall as one of Black Sabbath’s most recognized songs by the less informed masses. The accidental and incidental connection to the Marvel character made it at least a curiosity in nerd circles, but it was that instantly recognizable riff, fantastic imagery and epic inventiveness that solidified the song as a cult favorite.</p><p>The transmutation of “Iron Man” from heavy metal to pop lust lemonade is an accomplishment in alchemy of the highest lead-to-gold degree. Its basic cleverness is inescapable for the song’s four minutes. The slowing of the tempo, Persson’s delicately employed voice, the heaviness of it; everything works to strip away the testosterone of the song, leaving a husk of pure, irrepressible attraction (again, whatever, if you’re into that sort of thing). The Cardigans summon a sensation out of “Iron Man” that is simply not there to begin with. What they make is wholly original, despite being inarguably derivative.</p><p>Calling The Cardigans’ Iron Man “magnetic,” is the shortest, surest path to being dismissed as a hack, but what can you do; this version absolutely ends up stuck, in heads and on fridges and to bedsheets and whatever.</p><p><strong>3) </strong><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ejQ08ddAdQU"><strong>Rolling In The Deep<br>John Legend<br>Made famous by Adele</strong></a></p><p>A central component of both covers and karaoke is the pact performers make with audiences; the promise to give them something they know. The most trodden path towards that common familiarity is through nostalgia, digging into the historical archives a bit to find that universal gem.</p><p>But there are multiple pathways to familiarity. You can get there by going contemporary, too, which is the exact direction John Legend takes with his version of Rolling In The Deep.</p><p>It was just months after soul-revival-pop contemporary Adele’s original release when Legend dropped this stripped-down, a capella take. Whittling the song down to nothing but Legend and a loop of his own backup harmonies makes for a purposeful and immersive channeling of Adele’s accusatory scorn.</p><p>“We could have had it all.”</p><p>Legend works theatrically, ratcheting his voice to its fullest blast while taking the abandoned lover’s dive off the cliff of defiant surrender Adele erected. It takes power to surrender freely to someone with the full knowledge of the risk involved, and Legend celebrates that soft power by wielding it in its original writer’s honor.</p><p>When young people perform songs that were released decades before their birth, there’s a statement being made; “Look what I know about. I’m culturally educated enough to appreciate the significance and timeless relevance of this song.” The statement may be trivial, but the bargaining for credibility is a firmly entrenched aspect of song-singing ritual.</p><p>Here, Legend is saying something different with this song and the way he performs it. The spare rawness exposes him as imminently vulnerable.</p><p>Legend and Adele’s voices are both such powerful instruments, and a large part of what makes them each so resonant is that the higher they crank up, the more nakedly vulnerable they feel. On the right song, like here, it makes them overwhelmingly affecting. And Legend’s performance makes a strong case that heightened vulnerability can come with no cost to masculinity. His brand of sensitivity is no more or less emotive than the bellowing femininity of Adele’s, and no less a celebration of the universal bravery it takes to put oneself on the line.</p><p>Some covers are about the distance between iterations; some are about bridges. The Rolling In The Deep cover shows that Adele and John Legend both have quite impressive sets of lungs, sure, but I think it makes an important case for gender-balance, too. When tears are gonna fall, we still hold an expectation that they will be on a woman’s face, those resilient cultural crocks of shit. It’s not like she was the only one that could have had it all.</p><p>Legend tells us of a bridge between genders with truly equal footing. It might be a legend worth pursuit.</p><p><strong>4) </strong><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k-NWxX15OqE"><strong>Private Eyes<br>The Bird and the Bee<br>Made famous by Daryl Hall &amp; John Oates</strong></a></p><p>The 1980s just seemed kind of embarrassing.</p><p>Even at the time, people seemed awful embarrassed to be involved with the 1980s. Maybe there was just a self-awareness saturation point that tipped people off to the fact that their hair, styles, and music videos would begin to induce cringes the very second the clock struck midnight on Jan. 1, 1990.</p><p>Hokey, garish, put-on; a cynic could call upbeat songmen Hall &amp; Oates all of those things. But The Bird and the Bee renounced all cynicism when they made Interpreting The Masters Volume 1: A Tribute to Daryl Hall and John Oates. Another instance of an act investing themselves wholly in the portfolio of another, the Bird and the Bee honor the greatest-hits of the 80’s crooners with relatively simple, subdued renditions.</p><p>Like all Hall &amp; Oates hits, Private Eyes is as catchy as a mitt, but it also has the most weirdly specific imagery. I mean, it’s a song about a girl being followed by a series of investigative dicks, and for the video, in case we weren’t sure who they meant, the guys wore goddamn fedoras. Subtlety was no strength of the 1980’s music video scene, and these guys were as guilty of the mile-wide grin as anybody.</p><p>But they were authentic as hell.</p><p>No matter what any douchebag hipster strawman will tell you, there’s no irony to how much fun it is to listen to Hall &amp; Oates songs. They swing; they’re broad; they stand the test of time.</p><p>TB&amp;TB clearly recognized that core strength and authenticity when they decided to make an entire album that would potentially educate a conceivably-H&amp;O-ignorant generation.</p><p>It was a simple formula; sweeten the songs just a touch with a hint of synthy-sexy-voice-laser showiness, play it straight, and let the songs do the work.</p><p>Taking the song seriously allowed simple elegance to emerge. It cut through all the stilted, corny, 80s trappings, all the affectations and trying-to-be coolness, and basks guilelessly in the unwavering devotion the song celebrates.</p><p>The Bird and the Bee are also probably aware that they’re capitalizing on an underlying cultural sexism, and that audiences could be seduced by the beautiful voice of a woman in the place of Daryl Hall’s beautiful voice into finding the work to be a little less goofy. And also, somehow, less creepily stalkerish?</p><p>So if there was a degree of cynicism in the project, it would be aimed at the audience, not the music.</p><p>It’s tantalizingly easy to look back at things like the work of Hall and Oates as uncool jokes. Lazy dismissiveness is always the clearest path to a laugh. The way The Bird and the Bee clear the clutter away from this song, though, makes it impossible to deny the sheer craftsmanship of the source material, and the mastery of its authors.</p><p>The Bird and the Bee play the hits, make them sound like new hits, and in so doing, reaffirm Hall &amp; Oates’ basic greatness.</p><p>Besides, those guys couldn’t have been any more right about Members Only jackets.</p><p><strong>5) </strong><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7jVi0-sP0rU"><strong>Unbreak My Heart<br>Weezer<br>Made famous by Toni Braxton</strong></a></p><p>We live in an enlightened time.</p><p>Relative to the past, at least.</p><p>In the 1990’s, skinny white dudes like James Blake, Autre Neu Veut and Rivers Cuomo didn’t sing R&amp;B songs. Skinny white dudes, if they were the sensitive types, sang in alternative-rock bands. The perception was that there existed a wide cultural chasm between the music and markets of Weezer and Toni Braxton. History has been unkind to this fallacy, but at the time there was no denying the segregation of the radio dial.</p><p>While we’re still obsessed with categorization, we can’t hold a candle to the tyranny of radio’s heyday. Weezer was a ROCK band. Unbreak my Heart was R&amp;B. THEY GOT PLAYED ON DIFFERENT RADIO STATIONS, said the caveman into his Dictaphone.</p><p>That context makes this cover a pretty special recording, with regard to the 90s, because the two acts were total peers. Weezer’s self-titled Blue album came out in 1994, Toni Braxton dropped Unbreak My Heart in 1996. The 2005 cover was, of course, a Rick Rubin suggestion, because that man sees the musical bridges that society needs built the way Neo saw the Matrix. Rubin had to recognize the commonality between the capacities for pleading heartbreak of Braxton and Cuomo when he made the suggestion.</p><p>Weezer plays Unbreak My Heart like such a Weezer song that you’d think it had been a b-side to the Suzanne b-side, or at least that you’d heard it once at the end of a Kevin Smith movie.</p><p>While part of what makes this song stand out is how unexpectedly gamely the very white, alternative-pop-rock band covers Toni Braxton’s R&amp;B smash, it’s basically a conversation only exists outside the song. Within the listening, there’s nothing to do but take Rivers Cuomo at his word when he demands you “Say that you love me, say that you love me.”</p><p>His wanly staked claim to hurt is as arresting as Ms Braxton’s sultry appeal for a romantic fortune-reversal. There’s nothing put-on about the performance, there’s no winking at the kitsch of the thing. Their devastation has everything in common.</p><p>That the musicians and the song are so much a part of the popular culture, so disconnectedly, makes this one of the great covers to play for unsuspecting audiences. It takes a minute to realize they know the song, and then another to place the band. When they do, it blows minds. It strikes a remarkably decisive blow against inclinations towards compulsive categorization and the many weirdly coded truisms about genre and race that has historically pervaded the recording industry and broader society.</p><p>It shouldn’t matter that Weezer can play the hell out of a Toni Braxton song. It shouldn’t have mattered that Run-DMC played a song with Aerosmith, either. But it still kind of does. Maybe it’s just a generational thing, but entrenchment makes this song hard to expect and easy to appreciate.</p><p>Today, somewhere, a Rivers Cuomo-type will grab the mic at karaoke night and bring the house down with Unbreak My Heart, or something similar. So maybe time isn’t SO unkind.</p><p><strong>6) </strong><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UT0EiORz_LQ"><strong>D.D. (Dirty Diana)<br>The Weeknd<br>Made famous by Michael Jackson</strong></a></p><p>The Weeknd specializes in a unique brand of druggy, vaguely sadomasochistic, isolationist contemporary R&amp;B. His are all love songs, but that they’re of the tortured, paranoid and claustrophobic variety makes it pretty niche, as fetishes go.</p><p>But no, before you go blocking all fans of his from your various social media streams- he’s really talented at making songs that, y’know, sound good. He just deals in some pretty conflicting messaging. His dark, exploitative fascination with celebrity culture and lust makes for consistently gripping storytelling.</p><p>So yeah, sure, The Weeknd can sometimes seem pretty near-misogynist, which can be off-putting, but on D.D., off his 2011 Echoes Of Silence mixtape, you can’t blame him. He didn’t write this song. Michael Jackson did.</p><p>Michael isn’t afraid to dabble in a bit of dark paranoia. The powerless victimization in Dirty Diana historically fit neatly within our messy understanding of MJ. Being cornered and trapped by an adoring but predatory groupie was a sufficiently specific fear to convince listeners that this was Jackson’s actual nightmare. His voice fights off the lick of the electric guitar with the same teetering imbalance as he uses his unfathomable fame to stop the mounting fear from constricting him.</p><p>It’s no surprise that The Weeknd finds his access point via groupie angst. Stylistically and thematically, its dystopian-bent is very in keeping with the majority of the Toronto product’s work. Diana’s tractor-beam pull, her fierce determination and meticulous trap-setting, and the entire affair’s teeming sense of inevitability are exactly his brand of emotional components. The walls are closing in, which is what Weeknd grasps onto when he transforms his take into an echo-chamber.</p><p>Sunken atmospherics are as much a Weeknd trademark as the sweet spot between tragedy and seduction. There’s something interestingly revealing about this cove; while it does fit very comfortably in his milieu, the powerlessness of Michael’s song strongly contrasts the power dynamic of the majority of The Weeknd’s original work. It’s a pretty significant inversion, so much so that it calls some of the baseline assumptions about Weeknd’s music into question.</p><p>Is this a man whose only desire is to conquer? Or is this someone who has erected massive walls of defense, power-fantasy armor, to protect himself from the Dirty Dianas of the world? Is his strike-first tactic an admittance of vulnerability?</p><p>Consideration strongly suggests that The Weeknd’s positioning is a means to make victims lest he become one. But we need the degree of exposure revealed in this song to find the empathetic tether we can grasp onto.</p><p>D.D. is an amazing cover. Not only does it revive one of the more-slept-on Michael Jackson hits, but it better informs us about the artist doing the covering. By identifying, and thereby empowering his work’s nemesis, it becomes a kind of anti-Weeknd song. It’s tells us something by showing something else.</p><p><strong>7) </strong><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q8HzawCKgrQ"><strong>Maps<br>Anderson .Paak<br>Made famous by the Yeah Yeah Yeahs</strong></a></p><p>Interpretive choices are what dictate the success of a song’s reimagining. Sometimes these choices are big, bold, and unmistakable. Other times, though, the subtlest shift is what proves to make all the difference.</p><p>At first pass, it might seem that Anderson .Paak’s most distinct choice with his cover of the Yeah Yeah Yeahs’ Maps is to rearrange it into a funky R&amp;B tune. The song’s jilted begging certainly sounds vastly different coming from the voice of Karen O than it does that of this tender young man. The undeniable sexiness of his take on the pop masterpiece certainly stands out. But it’s not the genre trappings of his cover that make it so sexy; it’s the perspective.</p><p>Maps is a song about loss. The sentiment, “Wait… They don’t love you like I love you.” is one born of delirium, disbelief inspired by one’s partner jumping ship. Urgent, desperate and wounded, it’s a beautifully specific portrait of mourning. The Yeah Yeah Yeahs’ original is confessional, resigned, and, at its core, defeated. She’s singing to an empty room, to a ghost of her lover.</p><p>.Paak’s, though, is more alluring. It’s alluring because, through his theatrics and the essential urgency of his performance, he’s actively trying to lure his ex back. He’s battling to make his case. He’s still directly propositioning his abandoning lover, and bargaining with her.</p><p>They’re singing the same song, but .Paak and Karen O are at different stages of grief.</p><p>Again, the dexterity of Maps, and how well it lends itself to a cross-genre rearrangement, speaks volumes to the song’s fundamental soundness. Anderson .Paak capitalizes on the flexibility of its universality by tapping the dial just enough that it tips from “denial” to “bargaining.” Maybe the actor is in just as pitiful a state, but as any screenwriter will tell you, we root for people that do* things, and .Paak is trying to take action. He’s chasing.</p><p>We have words like “bittersweet” because of our compulsive need to describe the tragedy of being in love with someone who is no longer in love with us. We know there is pain that is inextricably leashed to happiness, even in retrospect. We appreciate the universality of those sensations, but only academically. In life, as the narcissists we know ourselves to be, we are chained to our own lives and experiences. Our perspective is a fixed point.</p><p>It’s that selfsame narcissism, that complete and total self-assurance, that motivates this song’s “Wait…” Of course we can’t know how “they… love you,” only how we do. An intimate connection, severed, puts us in what feels like our most unnatural state. We recognize that universally, but in execution and in our lives, it manifests itself differently in each instance.</p><p>Maps is about a hole we’re familiar with, but the space between the Yeah Yeah Yeahs and Anderson .Paak shows how differently we can respond to that vacuum. There’s art in that pain, and while there’s beauty in that surrender, there’s beauty in the fight, too.</p><p><strong>8) </strong><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3jOzuLsJIUE"><strong>Womanizer<br>Lily Allen<br>Made famous by Britney Spears</strong></a></p><p>I’m not going to sit here and intellectualize the merits of Britney Spears as a recording artist. I won’t say that Toxic makes some profound statement about female sexuality in our modern world in any sophisticated way. I don’t need to make Britney Spears sophisticated, because sophistication plays essentially no part in what made Britney such a big deal.</p><p>I could certainly, however, tell you exactly where I was the exact second of the …Baby One More Time video premiere. I won’t, since it occurred in the early days of my adolescence, making it a story equal parts awkward and obscene. But I could.</p><p>In a primal way, Britney Spears was the prism through which a generation came to understand celebrity and sexuality. From the second of her arrival, she was a paragon of vice. While she was celebrated for it, the way vice informed her demise was also celebrated. Maybe she wasn’t the musician Madonna was or the icon that Marilyn Monroe was, but she was in the conversation with them both, if only because, at her height, she shared with them a similarly scaled relationship with America.</p><p>She came in as a purported ‘virgin,’ teasing this desire to be hit. With her blossoming came the blosso’ming of her power and seeming sexual control. When she appeared to buy in too hard, and spiraled from hedonism’s herald to its victim, America’s fascination with her mutated into something sinister. It was like “Middle America” had some perverse desire to prove that the vice she represented had led to the inevitable endpoint in a way that somehow spoke to our collective virtuousness. Which it might have, but that I’m preeeetttty sure in the opposite way they meant.</p><p>Mass market media moralizing is a trickily ubiquitous thing. Most of the time it manifests itself in some benign way- a newscaster segues from an entertainment story to weather with a single casually smarmy and dismissive aside- but the barbs imply this vast sense of superiority over the figures we spend our collective energy inspecting and celebrating. We demand everything from them, then mock them for coming to rely on our attentions, and cheer when they experience failure. It’s a Coliseum mentality, and when someone like Britney Spears finally gets eaten by that fame lion, our cheer can only be called for what it is; bloodlust.</p><p>And everybody knows America been lusting for Britney’s blood since day one.</p><p>Lily Allen is a Brit, so maybe that’s all moot, but I’m pretty sure they’ve got their own take on celebrity and fame and all that. I’m certain that they were as fascinated by Britney over there as we were here. Lily Allen is also casually considered a somehow more authentic recording artist, and a more virtuosic talent. She might not have the chops to dance like Britney in her prime, but she might have the better voice and stronger individual songwriting skills.</p><p>That’s the rub with Britney; it’s not like we hold her musical abilities in any particularly high esteem. From that first video, it wasn’t about her being the best singer or dancer. You just couldn’t deny her command of sensuality and its resonance. She was a vessel for pop hits that spoke to a perversion embedded not-too-deeply within our sexual subconscious.</p><p>And as she made hits, dug deeper, and got more raw, or capacity for empathy waned. We never cared if she was a person.</p><p>I never bought a Britney Spears album, or gave one a full listen-through, but from the second I saw that first music video, she mattered. She was relevant, from then on.</p><p>Womanizer is late-era Britney, of the post-Blackout Circus, when her shine had begun to dull and she seemed not to be having any fun. It can’t be easy to sell sex without joy, and it couldn’t be easy on someone. The song flips Britney’s traditional roles a bit, allowing her to focus more on a foul-acting adversary than herself. Without the burden of playing the bad girl, she can just playfully recognize and call out this douchebag running game. This time, he’s the object.</p><p>Allen strips away the overwrought production that permeates every song in the Spears catalog, and plays simply, with a modest band. It’s like she’s seeking to avoid any direct competition with the original, and thereby Britney, so she just kind of honors the song like it were any standard.</p><p>Not-competing does sort of feel like the sisterly thing to do. There’s no irony to this performance; Allen isn’t mocking a fallen icon. It just feels like she’s sort of big-upping a musician who made a lot of music a lot of people loved.</p><p>You could make the case that Britney Spears has been getting punished since day one, when, probably incapable of knowing any better, she explicitly asked for it. Performers like Lily Allen, who are also constantly sexualized and objectified but are perhaps afforded the opportunity to have operated in Spears’ wake, must have some well of sympathy for Britney.</p><p>I think Lily Allen doing this song is a public declaration of admiration for Britney Spears. Or maybe she, too, has known some womanizers.</p><p><strong>9) </strong><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Om-0rLWOgzw"><strong>Come As You Are<br>Yuna<br>Made famous by Nirvana</strong></a></p><p>Performing a Nirvana song, whether as a cover or even in karaoke, is a mildly courageous act. Few bands have mattered to their fans as much as Nirvana. The band’s substance and mythology is just broad enough to be generational, but tragic enough to remain personal. They are so closely associated with the world and era it inhabited that it’s like it makes them a time capsule of ‘90s cynical ambivalence. Singing Kurt Cobain’s lyrics just always feels dangerous, even when you’re not hollering “Rape me!”</p><p>It’s haunting to sing Cobain’s lyrics. I don’t care what he was really talking about, it’s weird to sing along with a depressed dude saying “No, I don’t have a gun,” when you know his tragic ending. But the songs are masterpieces and, as Malaysian pop singer Yuna so capably proves here, ripe for revisiting.</p><p>Was Nirvana the most important musical group of the 1990s? Who else is even in the conversation? A Tribe Called Quest? The Spice Girls? If they were, wasn’t Come As You Are their most important song? Sure, Smells Like Teen Spirit charted higher, but the omnipresent popularity it enjoyed in its day may actually hold its ranking back in the eyes of many. By the very nature of ‘90s Generation X malaise, there’s no way any self-respecting music fans could cite the most popular Nirvana song as their favorite Nirvana song without sacrificing all credentials and bona fides with the Coolluminati. But, due to the intricate matrices of fandom and authenticity, you might have been able to get away with loving their second most famous song most of all with credibility intact.</p><p>While Nirvana didn’t invent suburban depression, in the way they inhabited and represented it they found perfection, and their arc’s closed-storytelling nature preserved a memory of that perfection. Being struck down made them more enduring than they could’ve possibly imagined, Obi-Wan-style.</p><p>Their legacy is probably best by this truism: by the latter half of the ‘90s, the two direct-most paths to ruin were either to be called the next Michael Jordan, or the next Nirvana.</p><p>Yuna reclaims the depressiveness of Generation X in the name of the Millennials, melting Come As You Are’s original pleading grunge-rock into syrupy, mellow synth-pop. She slows things so far down that she ends up making Nirvana seem downright upbeat. The despondent quivers of her voice are as fascinating in their similarities to Cobain as their differences. Both are weary, but where Cobain seems to be searching, confusedly, the regretful precision Yuna strikes with suggests knowingness. It’s not hard to project something profound about the wisdom of younger generations, and fundamental lessons learned with time.</p><p>There’s an ethereal quality to her version. It’s a haunted dream that’s just a hint too sweet to be a nightmare. Its unrelenting repetitiveness gives it the quality of a depression lullaby, which, in the historical context, is probably how the Youts will have come to know the now twenty-three-year-old song. Anyone around that age, or younger, had to have been introduced to Nirvana in the crib, by parents who knew better than to invest in Yanni tapes.</p><p>Kurt Cobain could very well have hated this version of his song, and wished it didn’t exist. The man had a very fraught relationship with fame, obviously. But you know what? The guy was sick. We know that better now than we did then.</p><p>Teenage surliness was such a defining characteristic for Generation X, but there was a capacity for empathy at their core, too. People who were affected by bands like Nirvana have the luxury of living in, and by their nature creating a world where mental illness awareness is much higher, and more sophisticated. Schools, if they are not better equipped, are at least better prepared.</p><p>Of course kids are still sad, they’re all fucked up inside from the world within and without, but we’re at least a little better about talking to them, right? Kids are bullied; it makes them feel like shit; we foster a culture where bullying’s not, y’know, a thing. Ipso muthfuckin’ facto. We got that long arc of history bending howevermuch towards progressive justice.</p><p>Is that imbuing too much power into a girl covering a pop rock song? It’s gotta depend. It’s gotta depend on the song, and whether hearing it makes you feel anything or not.</p><p><strong>10) </strong><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3A8FK3C2OOk"><strong>Across the Universe<br>Fiona Apple<br>Made famous by The Beatles</strong></a></p><p>The aforementioned Rock Coolluminati have this whole notion that the Rolling Stones are history’s actual greatest rock band. Having never been a part of a garage band (although I did, once, front a middle school talent show trio and belt out a pretty raw Metallica Nothing Else Matters cover), I’ll cop to being underqualified to disprove the experts, but the way I figure, at the bare minimum there should be no question that the Beatles were history’s greatest recording band. The richness of their catalogue is peerless. I mean, it was Michael Jackson’s greatest treasure, and that dude collected enough shit that he ended up with an amusement park and a monkey. Their music is an artifact of the Indiana Jones order.</p><p>Since it isn’t on Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band (and you must, by now, have realized that I’m nothing if not a rampantly subjective sentimentalist), Across the Universe is not one of my ten favorite Beatles’ songs, but Fiona Apple plays it like it’s one of hers, and the loving, tender care she plays it with compels me to fall for it, too. Fiona is one of those singular artists; there’s something about the power and presence she’s commanded, from her first album to her latest, that always leaves me feeling sprinkled with Lilith-Fairy dust. She is a musician whose willingness to bare her everything gives her a connective depth far greater than the majority of her pop contemporaries.</p><p>I find Fiona Apple to be completely undeniable. Which gives her something in common with the Beatles.</p><p>The imagery of Across the Universe is impossibly immense and the scope of that imagery suggests it may be one of the Beatles’ most aspirational songs, like it’s the shape of an idea whose form can only be conceived by those whose cosmic consciousness has been forged through testing the outermost boundaries of terrestrial fame. Guys like Bono, whose lives have evidenced, at least to themselves, that their power is only limited by their imagination, are forever cursed with the burdening desire to make songs with the scale of Across the Universe. They want to Heal the World.</p><p>John Lennon called it one of the best lyrics he’d written.</p><p>With recordings of songs made famous by Buddy Holly, Frank Sinatra, Danny Elfman and Gene Wilder under her belt, Fiona Apple has shown herself to be something of a covers-mastermind over her career. Her takes exhibit confidence of perspective and musicality. She covered Across the Universe in an official capacity for the soundtrack to 1998’s underrated (and maybe even kinda seminal? [RIP Paul Walker]) Pleasantville, nostalgically aching her way through the track, and making the lyrics’ mysticism feel as immediate and personal as a freshly-triggered memory.</p><p>At the time of release, Apple was dating acclaimed filmmaker Paul Thomas Anderson, who directed the music video. Shot on set and in the style of the Pleasantville movie, the camera remains trained on Apple throughout the video while, echoing the movie’s climax, the infusion of color in a black-and-white world inspires an explosive riot in the town’s quaint malt shop. Her intensity smolders amidst the chaos, and Anderson keeps the shots lingering, despite all the periphery’s goings-on, never looking away from her. “Nothing’s gonna change my world,” she repeats, and her meaning is explicitly laid out before us; no bullshit, no matter its proximity, will be permitted to penetrate her dreams.</p><p>In an incredibly prescient flourish for 1998, the headphones she wears throughout the video serve as her insulation from the pandemonium. Citizens of the modern world are inundated with evidence of the power of headphones and the devices they plug into to unplug listeners from their surroundings in a way like never before. In so many ways, people are more inclined than ever to block out all voices around them besides those they choose to hear, be that on the subways, streets, or the general national discourse. We’re simultaneously connected and disconnected, contradicting as we intuitively know only real life can.</p><p>Fiona Apple sings this Beatles song like a hazy memory. All covers may have some hint of nostalgia among their ingredients, but the context of this one, as a side piece to a film whose focus is on the dangers of nostalgia and stagnancy and over-simplification, threatens to make it a pretty heavy flavoring of messiah complex. Apple sidesteps, though, reigning in its heady far-out lessons about love and the cosmos and thanks to heavenly teachers through the filter of dream, which humbles its headiness. Dreams can be illogical but still ring “true,” they can be more than the pieces that make them up would suggest.</p><p>For me, the song and video and piece as a whole works as a clever and imaginative restating of the original’s central dare; to dream big. It’s about our desire to seek, identify and celebrate beauty, despite all obstacles and limitations. It’s a theme that’s big enough to span all art, which is something only the very fewest artists even attempt to articulate. And it’s even more special for being celebrated in the pop form, because it gives it a universality that can only come with the biggest audience. It’s a love tent, meant to be built large enough for all of us.</p><p><strong>11) </strong><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nq7XmWSbXqA"><strong>Don’t Let Me Be Misunderstood<br>The Animals<br>Made famous by Nina Simone</strong></a></p><p>Don’t Let Me Be Misunderstood is a Nina Simone song, but it was British Invasion band The Animals that made it a smash hit, and might’ve even cemented it as a standard for the High Priestess of Soul.</p><p>In 1964 Don’t Let Me Be Misunderstood, a song not written by Simone but for her, was released as the lead track on Broadway-Blues-Ballads, a record whose colorful cover sported the smiling singer with her straightened hair in a bob. The song’s lyrics begged for understanding and compassion while swearing well-placed intentions.</p><p>Whether it’s the cooing backup singers or the sweeping orchestral accompaniment, a fan, whose casual notion of Simone is that of the fiery, outspoken and iconic diva, might find something uncharacteristically broad, and perhaps even “commercial,” to the sound of the original cut. While Simone is as raw and virtuosic as ever, I can’t help but find the song’s direct appeal for acceptance, from either the figure she’s singing to or the listening audience, to be needy in a way that feels vaguely out of sync for Simone, who never seemed to need anything but a piano and a microphone for her truth.</p><p>This is all one big conjecturcise, to be sure, but maybe there was a reason for the song’s confessional play at sympathy. Maybe it really wanted to be a hit.</p><p>Simone was known to be tempestuous onstage and forthright in her beliefs, especially with regards to civil rights, and had pissed off a shitload of white people earlier in 1964 when, fed up following the Birmingham church bombings and the murder of Medgar Evers, she released Mississippi Goddamn, an incendiary testimony to the shameful state of racial and civil injustice that managed to galvanize many and alienate many more. You’re not going to believe this, but while her masterfully personal distillation of righteous societal outrage was affecting enough to become an anthem of The Movement, that same resonance simultaneously distanced Simone from the quarters of her audience/America that would’ve rather not thought too much of such things. It was a polarized time and she was a polarized figure.</p><p>Nina Simone would later admit that the song and her status as an iconoclast of Black disillusionment did profound damage her career (although full disclosure that interview was in the ‘80s so she was probably just forced to jump onbort that money train where in order to get your ticket punched you had to pretend like the ‘60s hadn’t happened since Alex P. Keaton and Teddy Ruxpin had already solved racial and financial inequities by inventing Reaganomics. Unless I’m misremembering).</p><p>Could Don’t Let Me Be Misunderstood have been an expertly crafted appeal for sympathy from an audience that was, at the time, particularly disinclined to afford it to an outspoken, artist-activist?</p><p>Maybe. But while it got Simone her first whiff of the Billboard charts in five years, it was not a big enough hit to cross Simone back into the good graces of the mainstream.</p><p>Scant months later, in January 1965, The Animals released their bluesy rock and roll version of the song. They wailed away, fully embracing the lyrics’ desperation, manically toying with its highs and lows by alternating maximal and minimal sounds. Their electric guitars, organs and histrionics got the song as high as #3 in the UK and #15 in these here United States, making it a pretty massive hit. It was, in fact, a bigger hit than Simone ever charted in her career. Covers, amirite?</p><p>Again, conjecturcise, but what if Simone really had recorded DLMBM as an attempt at a crossover hit, only for a British, white rock and roll band to ride it to glory? On the one hand, it was tremendous exposure, on the other, wouldn’t it highlight some of the commercial disadvantages inherent to being young, gifted and black?</p><p>Wouldn’t she have to wonder why The Animals got to be understood, but she didn’t?</p><p>Simone went on her first European tour later that same year, and would be moved by the gracious and respectful reception she received from international audiences. Already renowned, The Animals’ adaptation only elevated her profile. She found great comfort in their acceptance, and the song became a mainstay to her live performances.</p><p>It’s not fair to project all of this intent. But I’m not going to let that stop me.</p><p>I find her live cuts of the song, from the time following, to be sparse, jazzy, stylized, sultry and even personal in all the ways the original wasn’t. It sounds more like her song, like she found power in the success it had outside of her. Instead of being frustrated or paralyzed by the discrepancy between her career and theirs, it was like she took it as a challenge. Like she saw that what it proved was that there was a power to the song, The Animals’ faith in her and it and proved it, and its success cemented it. The song was great, and she was great, and from then on, no one would ever sing the song with the greatness that she did. It’d been proven to be a hit, so she went out and proved that it was her hit. Every goddamn time.</p><p>It’s one of the rarest things in songs, right? It’s like if a songwriter was anonymously attending a karaoke night, and heard someone nail her song, to huge response, only to be invigorated by it.</p><p>Look, full disclosure; I’ve always found culture’s most difficult needle to thread to be the one that distinguishes participation from appropriation by majorities in minority culture. The throughline that threads the impact of categorization within the music recording industry is woven pretty deeply into racial politics and conversation in American culture. So that needle, I believe, exists, hidden in a vast and treacherous haystack that lay under the close watch of a Smaug-like sentinel. And I believe that songs and successes like The Animals cover of Nina Simone’s Don’t Let Me Be Misunderstood help teach the lessons that allow us to at least begin to approach sifting through that stack.</p><p>Appropriation is such a loaded word, but we can safely draw some pretty broad and fundamental distinctions; where appropriation is invasive, participation is communal. But is it just intent that makes that distinction? Is it the way it is received, by either the minority or majority parties? Is it something that can only be defined in the macro, a pain only realized after thousands of minor cuts? Is it only appropriating if and when Macklemore beats Kendrick?</p><p>From today’s vantage point, it is easy to look back and wonder what the Instagram note The Animals would’ve publicly posted to Nina had they defeated her for some sort of arbitrary award might have said. Probably something like:</p><p>“Just a soul whose intentions are good.”</p><p>So while it’s hard to look at this song and not be reminded of the appropriation at the bedrock of the American music recording industry, only Nina Simone could really decide whether or not The Animals’ version of her song constituted appropriation of any sort. I suspect she wouldn’t, if only because, if anything, she seems to have been inspired to appropriate it right back. She played that song on her own terms, and when audiences would crackle as she began to play the song they thought they could recognize so well, and then she’d play like they’d never heard it before. She had nothing and everything to prove.</p><p>Lifetimes later, a pop band’s decision to give shine to one of the baddest in the game gives listeners a traceable musical genealogy. It’s a gift that finds both artists on the right side of history.</p><p>Today, this song gets covered all the time. It’s pretty near a jazz standard. I think what’s so fascinating about the song is how, at its heart, its building a case for compassion. Then it suggests that the reward for the compassion is clarity.</p><p>And sure, that’s what the words of the song say, but the stuff that happened with the song might have proved it.</p><p>As a guy searching for clarity, it’s nice to know you’re not alone in the pursuit.</p><p><strong>12) </strong><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PZv_w_L0Rh0"><strong>Fire and Rain<br>The Isley Brothers<br>Made famous by James Taylor</strong></a></p><p>There’s a truism that goes on pretty regularly in sports. When players are compared, notably black football quarterbacks and white basketball players, the comparisons drawn are very often hilariously color-coded. Daunte Culpepper was a Randall Cunningham-type. Dirk Nowitski reminded NBA broadcasters of Larry Bird. The list goes on, but the grating thing is not even so much that the skin-deep comparisons are wrong-minded or inaccurate, although they very often are; it’s that they’re so watch-settingly predictable. Sports fans know to see them coming a million miles away.</p><p>Music categorization has similar failings. Categorization is a tricky thing, it springs from our minds’ laziest corners, and preys on our desire to recognize patterns. Take away color and cultural signifiers and defining the line between modern R&amp;B and pop becomes near-impossible. The same was once true of blues and early rock. And I personally am still mystified by whatever the fuck the Academy means when they call music “Urban Contemporary,” their Grammy category camouflaged in a name befitting a fashion collection. Categorical defiance is what defined Michael Jackson and what drives Kanye West, artists seemingly caught in pathological pursuits of universal, caveat-free acceptance.</p><p>Those acts tend to not want for titles like “best R&amp;B artist” or “greatest rapper,” because culturally what those titles tend to side-mean is “Best [Black] Musician.” That’s what makes the “King of Pop” crown so attractive; it’s qualifier-free. These guys want no part of Intercontinental or middleweight belts, they wanna be Heavyweight Champions of the Worrllllllld.</p><p>Point being, on the outside, contemporaneous artists are not always recognized as contemporaries. And while, awards season aside, they’re not in direct competition like athletes are, recognition and acceptance certainly has its winners and losers. That recognition is not always earned through virtuosity. Recognition is often meted out on sliding scales. Often disproportionately. Black music is often perceived to be a subcategory of music, a non-vital appendage, or an adjacent participant.</p><p>Singer-songwriter James Taylor is undoubtedly a folk musician, but as much as he saw himself coming from the tradition of folk and country, he, like most actualized American musicians, cited diverse influences from soul to blues, along with a “strong dose of Ray Charles,” in describing the origins of his sound and songwriting. His “Sweet Baby James,” album earned a spot in that same pantheon of characteristically 70’s dreamy pop neo-spiritualism as Stevie Wonder’s “Innervisions” and (though it was later) Paul Simon’s “Graceland.”</p><p>—</p><p><em>The final two entries of this overlong musical indulgence were, in years past, slated to be the 2006/07 viral sensation </em><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=57ta7mkgrOU"><em>“Hurt” as made famous by Johnny Cash and performed by Sad Kermit</em></a><em>, and a version of the </em><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l9UA40Cwv0c"><em>Beatles’ “Something” performed by James Govan</em></a><em>, a soulful old relic I discovered via an NPR segment spotlighting a collection of his lost tracks. I’d saved the entries as a final task if and when the above assemblege of words found a reputable home, but now that I’ve completed the inventory review of all the above words, I’m not sure I can truly recapture the thrust of my earlier efforts. The songs are phenomenal, make no mistake, and worthy of your time and attention. But perhaps they speak for themselves, at this point. The circuit between these songs and these performances, the wiring they each and collectively all light up, this is the stuff that makes me, the impressions that defined me by their marking. So maybe they don’t need to be explained, even if they seek to be understood. Perhaps, at the close of things, we needn’t be so loud in our listening.</em></p><p><em>Or maybe everything just feels significant and profound at the night’s end, when you’ve spent what you can on time, company, and in song.</em></p><p><em>Ah, the elegance of a fade out.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=50a44ba5822b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[DIRECTOR’S CUT: Brendan’s Globe Dinner With Cupid]]></title>
            <link>https://brendan-mcguirk.medium.com/directors-cut-brendan-s-globe-dinner-with-cupid-fb8a56ef8873?source=rss-30558b07bbbe------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fb8a56ef8873</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[dating]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Brendan McGuirk]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 15 Jan 2019 16:42:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-01-15T16:42:40.186Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*WAYurrM9itcY1-o8f2fyJg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Yeah, so.</p><p>I don’t think I ever intended to become the bachelor I am, but I’m 34 now and all my friends are married or coupled up, and I am, y’know, not. I could list anecdotal observations as to why I think this is, but the ultimate fact of it is I haven’t yet settled into anything that works for me and a prospective partner.</p><p>Which opens one’s world up to certain possibilities.</p><p>Actually, let me be a little more honest: I suspect a big part of what’s led me down the path I’m on is that I, in my heart, want to be loved by everyone. I have the kind of illness where part of me even dares to think it’s possible. Even with exes, I hope to be their favorite. Or at least their mom’s favorite. But mostly I just want attention and approval and validation. Which is why I write (also karaoke but that’s a whole ‘nother thing).</p><p>And the thing is, at best my career in writing would have to be described as “a mixed bag.” I’m a pretty fluid writer, I think, and I can do a decent job of observing and holding attention. But mine is the common struggle with output. I joke with some peers that they lucked into the preferable varieties of mental illness, that allow for them to be productive, whereas I all too often just shut down, my confidence fatally pierced by the first brushback pitch. Still, I’ve been able to accomplish some of my goals — I worked for DC Comics out of college and got to do a bunch of entertainment press work as a result; held a job at a major metropolitan newspaper daily for the better part of a decade, covering everything from the first Obama inauguration to sports-nerd stuff and a bunch of music; and got to do a bunch of fun freelancing for another daily that gave me freedom to do everything from hip cultural nightlife stuff to interviews with sports heroes like Pedro Martinez and Rob Gronkowski.</p><p>But more than that, I’ve struggled. I’ve struggled to develop the habits and relationships it takes to sustain in the work. I have my wins, and I have my regrets. And my romantic life has been similar. I’ve been lucky enough to have a lot of love in my life. And while none of it has yet resulted in a lasting pairing, I’m largely proud of how I’ve prosecuted my romantic dealings. I like all of the girls I’ve seen, still. I like the love stories we’ve written together, such as they were. I’m glad for it all. But I hold out hope that the lasting magic will come in the next one.</p><p>So, of course, when a friend let slip that the Globe’s dating column was lacking for male candidates, I couldn’t help myself. I did no research about how the column worked, but understood it to be a blind date wherein the paper foots the bill, and your respective responses end up in print. So even if the Globe hadn’t yet seen fit to hire me to write for them, I could turn my personal exploits into content fodder under their mashead. If anything, it felt like too fitting a way to finesse my way to the town’s most respected paper, so I went for it.</p><p>Best case I meet the girl of my dreams and we end up with a tale worthy of a screenplay, worst case I channel my need for approval and clout into some compelling social media content. Either way, I become the story.</p><p>I probably should have known how things would go when I finalized my intake form and smugly realized my responses constituted my favorite writing of the year. (Which, I was aware, would come as surprise to no one that knows me.) I was hopeful that I’d be paired with someone I dug, and if nothing else, I’d get a free meal, a bit of exposure, some funny fodder, and my name would be in the papers. It was either a backdoor into an editor’s good graces or a backdoor pilot to my upcoming season of “The Bachelor.”</p><p>It took a few weeks to pull together, but the editor working on the story found a candidate and set up the blind date and we were on our way. It was only when we had a date set that it occured to me that the meeting could go awry, with her not enjoying my company and the subsequent article damaging my reputation, such that it is. And again, let’s not read too deeply into this, but there’s probably something to be gleaned from the fact that I was cognizant of how I could look bad, but never even considered the possibility that I could meet someone that I was uninterested in, but would still want to impress, for the press.</p><p>Well, friends, once more it’s always the eventuality you least expect. Or maybe the one you deserve. It didn’t take long. By the time I’d sat down with my date, I had already observed that this was not a person I was terribly interested in, romantically. Through no fault of her own, in the parlance of our vulgar times, this was a swipe-left for me, dog.</p><p>So if it wasn’t going to be a love match, it would just have to make for good copy. And in that event, we’d need to have a good time. Which we did! She was good company and we had a spirited discussion. And while it might have been a blend of alcohol and vanity, I got the impression she was enjoying my company. Which, of course, only made me more regretful and self-conscious about not being more interested.</p><p>Below, if for no reason than it’s got to go somewhere, I’m going to publish my intake responses and my exit interview with the date, Caroline. The real reason I went on the adventure was to write about it, after all, and of course when the Globe article eventually hit all I could think about was how much went unsaid. I tried to be delicate in my responses, both for her sake and because I’m not a monster, but as a result I felt like the writing, on my end, wasn’t particularly dynamic or representative of what I was aiming for. And because the only solution I’ve ever been comfortable with is more words, I’ve added some annotations.</p><p>Hope you’re entertained.</p><p>*******</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/621/1*IfuhLVo7YVldPJdbXd1sTQ@2x.jpeg" /><figcaption>It was not a good sign that at first glance I assumed this pull-quote was her words, not mine.</figcaption></figure><h4>DATING INTAKE SURVEY</h4><p><strong>Where are you from originally?</strong></p><p>I grew up in Concord, where my father was also raised, and spent a lot of time around Cambridge growing up.</p><p><strong>Do you have pets? If so, what kind?</strong></p><p>Well, I would say I don’t have any pets but my roommate has a moribund cat whose tragic suffering has yet to end. So, y’know — kinda.</p><p><strong>How would you describe your race/ethnicity? (If you’d prefer to be matched with someone of a specific background, let us know.)</strong></p><p>Oh, I’m white. I definitely don’t have any particular preferences as to the race or ethnicity of girls I date, but I like people who can hang in multicultural social environments.</p><p><strong>Describe your idea of a perfect Saturday, from morning ’til night.</strong></p><p>Hopefully I’m reading a book I like better than Twitter so my day can start with coffee and that, make some breakfast, get some writing done (you did say “perfect”), maybe catch a matinee or go for a bike ride otherwise meet up with friends to hang and have some beers, see some music or watch a game, go out dancing, get pizza, maybe hang out late night to listen to music and chill, go to bed. Something like that.</p><p><strong>What’s the last thing you read (book, story, Web site, magazine) and enjoyed?</strong></p><p>Not to flatter anyone at Globe HQ, but I thought the Aaron Hernandez Spotlight series was excellent and really justified itself, quelling any concerns that it was sensationalism for sensationalism’s sake. I also just read the latest installment of Luke O’Neil’s “Hell World” newsletter and found it to be a rare showing of hope in our daily deluge. Last book I loved was “On Beauty.” Other than that, I’d say Tuesday’s congressional returns* were my favorite read of the week.</p><p>*<em>Aren’t I SO TOPICAL?!</em></p><p><strong>You’re stranded on a desert island. What three things (other than food, water, shelter — and sunscreen!) could you not live without?</strong></p><p>I think my answer is another person, because my three things are conversation, hope, and entertainment, and you can only get those things socially.**</p><p>**<em>This I meant, and realized as I was filling out the form I am glad for. But it’s probably just TV.</em></p><p><strong>Who plays you in the movie on your life?</strong></p><p>All the Hollywood guys who’d play me are either a little too pudgy or they lose all of the weight and look weird and uncomfortable. I’ve gotten Cory Feldman before, and Ben Affleck’s dentist once told me we looked alike, but probably I’d just have to go with <em>Parks and Rec</em>-era Chris Pratt. Or Jake Johnson. Maybe Donald Glover, he’s got nerd-range.</p><p><strong>What’s the first thing people notice when they walk into your home?</strong></p><p>Because of my loyalties, I have been gifted a great deal of Thor and Kanye West paraphernalia over my life, and many of them are displayed in my home. So usually I have to justify that.</p><p><strong>When are you happiest?</strong></p><p>In good company.***</p><p>***<em>Also a true thing I realized in the answering.</em></p><p><strong>What makes you a good catch? (Here’s your chance to brag!)*</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/173/1*GXebwoO89p-hCL4UcP-0_Q@2x.jpeg" /><figcaption>*It was exactly as Admiral Ackbar foretold.</figcaption></figure><p>Oh, I don’t know. I like to think I’m a solid conversationalist**. I’m passionate about things both consequential and trivial. I can make people laugh. I’ve been told I’m a good kisser. I’m a person who loves, whether that’s family or the game or craft or a partner, and I value and strive for authenticity. Which is probably all a long way of saying I’m an irredeemable romantic*. I don’t know that I’m a catch but I know I’m looking to be made to feel, and to make someone else feel, like one. But probably the kisser thing.***</p><p>**<em>These were what was used for the eventual article, and I don’t think anyone who knows me will ever let me live it down (exes even moreso).</em></p><p>***<em>Again, insufferable, I know, but you’ve gotta play the hand that’s dealt to you.</em></p><p><strong>What other interests, hobbies, preferences (specific music, movies, TV shows, studies, games, sports, activities, etc.) and/or notable qualities, talents, and life experiences do you have that might help us in finding a match for you?</strong></p><p>No shade but I hate questions like these, because I don’t like sorting strictly by commonality — it feels limiting and without imagination. But that said, I like everything my demographic would indicate I do: <em>Arrested Development</em>, the Patriots &amp; Celtics &amp; Red Sox, <em>Star Wars</em>, Marvel shit, the Ringer, pop rap, Beyoncé, Fiona Apple, Cohen brothers and Wes Anderson movies, Pod Save America, Madden and NBA 2k, Ta-Nehisi Coates, Chuck Klosterman, ASOIAF, karaoke (okay maybe especially karaoke).</p><p>I like creative people. I like making things and giving my energy to people who make things, and helping them feel seen. I’ve lived in New York, San Francisco, and Hawaii. I take pride in not living a monochrome life.</p><p><strong>If your match’s height matters to you, please tell us how tall you are and what height you’re looking for in your date.</strong></p><p>I generally date girls taller than 5&#39;5, but that’s more circumstantial than anything. I have heard that my height is something I should be advertising on my dating app profiles more, though. I’m 6&#39;1.**</p><p>**<em>BASICALLY!</em></p><p><strong>Describe your idea of the perfect date. (This could be a description of the best date you’ve ever had, or one you’d love to have.)</strong></p><p>I’ve been on a couple perfect first dates*** in my life, and the common thread of them all is that they’ve gone long. But again, the distinguishing thing wasn’t the activity, it was the chemistry. So to do a composite I’d say, start with casual drinks, if we’re having fun maybe have a few extras and go see some music. If it’s gone perfect up to then, probably make out somewhere in there (break the ice). Depending on circumstances, one of us introduces the other to their world a little bit, whether that be friends or a friendly locale or just something personal. Maybe we retire together, maybe we leave it at desperate to see each other again. The perfect date is a memory you’ve made together, that you value.</p><p>(Also the perfect date is like the perfect airplane landing — as long as it leads to another one it’s doing the work.)</p><p>***<em>Hopefully they know who they are.</em></p><p><strong>If I got all of your exes in one room and asked them about you, what would they agree drove them nuts about you? What would they agree is wonderful about you?</strong></p><p>Oh my god this is the perfect question and also somewhat how I’ve envisioned my wake*. I think they’d all positively cite my caring and that we had fun together. I think I’d make various top-3 lists of theirs. I think they’d appreciate the social worlds we got to enjoy and share together. And I think they’d probably all say they wished I was a little easier on and better to myself. And also they’d all complain about my terrible interruption habit because they just don’t appreciate active listening! X-P</p><p>*<em>This is big facts and likely contradicts all my protests about not being a monster.</em></p><p><strong>What comedian’s sense of humor most mirrors your own?</strong></p><p>[don’t say Louis CK don’t say Louis CK don’t say Louis CK…]**</p><p>Maybe Desus?</p><p>** <em>“See it’s funny because I’M the butt of the joke you so — no you’re right I’ll leave.”</em></p><p><strong>If technology allowed you to create the perfect mate, what celebrity would he/she look like and what would he/she do for a living?</strong></p><p>This is such a friggin’ trap!** There are a million directions to go here but I’m going to say Zazie Beetz and she’d either be in a boring and successful field where she could support my creative stay-at-home-dad-ness and appreciate and benefit from my joie de vivre or, like, an arts therapy teacher and we were cute creativty nourishers together. But this question is terribly unfair.</p><p>**<em>Pt. 2 On the Run</em></p><p><strong>Would you say you are looking for your Mr./Mrs. Right, or just Mr./Mrs. “Right Now”?</strong></p><p>I would say I’d never let my pursuit of one get in the way of finding the other.*</p><p>*<em>This was my favorite answer, settling the debate that am in fact a monster.</em></p><p><strong>Have you ever been convicted of a crime or accused of domestic violence? (If so, please provide details)</strong></p><p>I have not.</p><p><strong>What kind of food do you love to eat? Any cuisines you really don’t like? Do you follow any special diets (vegan, vegetarian, etc.)?</strong></p><p>I’m not great with difficult-to-navigate international meals where I don’t know how to plate my food (which makes Indian tricky), but other than that no dietary restrictions. Pizza’s a food group, right?</p><p>*******</p><p>So yeah, I got some LOLs out of that. Then came the date, which I describe at length below. As you’ll see, my answers were extensive. And of course as I was sussing out these responses, I got a text from the date asking if I’d like to go out again. The thing was, I’d been expending so much energy trying to manage my underwhelmed experience with reflections and seeking to be kind in my answering, I got myself all twisted. So I agreed to go out again, despite having not really been interested during the actual. evening.</p><p>Then, as you’ll see, I submitted my thousands of words to the story’s editor, who I’m sure was managing me with kindness when she called them “the most thoughtful responses” she’d gotten for the column series. Was it a distaster? A horrible mistake to subject myself and others to? Not that big a deal that I should have just been done with and moved on from? Decide for yourself below.</p><h3>Dinner with Cupid: The Exit Interview</h3><h4>“When you’re so bad at dating it makes the news”</h4><h4>BEFORE THE DATE</h4><p><strong>What made you sign up for Dinner with Cupid?</strong></p><p>A friend familiar with both the column and my misadventures in dating thought I’d make an entertaining candidate and recommended I sign up for it. I figured, it’s no less random than a Tinder date. If anything, it’d make a novel enough origin story that I thought it might give the prospective relationship an advantage.</p><p>Which is all to say — nothing else has quite worked out yet, so what the hell.</p><p><strong>What did you do to prepare for the date? (Down a beer to calm the nerves, exercise to flatten the tummy?)</strong></p><p>I just leaned into my usual pre-date grooming habits, which mostly consists of getting my beard a little trimmer like I wish I were, and going back-and-forth about what to wear for long enough to nearly make myself late. And I’d gotten a haircut not long before, although I told myself it was in preparation of the holidays, and not because I wanted to look snazzy for the date (which was a lie).</p><p>I was also a little worried about getting woozily hungry so I ate a little something.</p><p><strong>What was your state of mind/attitude before the date? How did you feel (nervous, calm, a mixture)?</strong></p><p>I was excited! A truly blind date is such a classic rom-com setup that I was hopeful that I’d meet somebody and we’d start writing a cute holiday love story together. In the last week I’d gotten a little nervous about it all, after if finally dawned on me that the date could go awry and all my worst foibles would end up making literal headlines. But I haven’t gone on enough bad first dates to feel like that was the most likely scenario. I don’t usually get nervous until after I’ve decided I like the person, when I start trying to wrangle expectations. Which isn’t until, like, date two or three.</p><p><strong>Were you both on time?</strong></p><p>Well, yes. But she was MORE on time. I was proud to be a couple minutes early, because I’m often the worst about punctuality, but Caroline was already seated when I got there, so she had me beat.</p><h4>FIRST IMPRESSIONS</h4><p><strong>What happened when you got to the restaurant? How did you know which person was your date?</strong></p><p>I checked the reservation and they showed me our table, where Caroline was already seated. So that made for a sort of awkward meet-cute, where we did the uncertain hug-or-handshake dance. And because the reservation was made under a different name for either of us, I immediately started wondering what the staff might think of the whole arrangement.</p><p><strong>What was your first impression of your date physically? Be specific.</strong></p><p>I was… thrown, to be honest. This girl is quantifiably pretty, I thought**, pretty face and a nice build, but in some ephemeral way not my type. Maybe I brought unreasonable expectations (wouldn’t be the first time), but my initial reaction was this was not someone I’d usually end up on a date with. And while I might be managing my good-guy self-image here***, I think it was less about her attractiveness than her style and energy, which seemed kind of distant from my own.</p><p>**<em>This is a gentle untruth in that it’s true, but was not my first thought.</em></p><p>***<em>Way more truthful.</em></p><p><strong>How at ease did your date seem (a little nervous? mostly calm?)?</strong></p><p>I think we were both a little nervous and finding our footing. Caroline seemed to have a calm demeanor, as a person, but I think I sensed a little bit of excitement on her end that I wasn’t really experiencing. But it was also obvious from the start that I was the more extroverted* one, so I sort of started playing that part and being high energy. That personality contrast was probably the most obvious thing from early on, although whether that was a decisive distinction was what I was going to most curious to figure out over the evening.</p><p>*<em>This was true but it was also that I felt like the more experienced dater (which is obviously not the most desirable quality).</em></p><p><strong>What did you talk about before ordering drinks? Be specific.</strong></p><p>We talked about our familiarity with the restaurant. She’d worked in the area previously, I learned, and had walked by a million times but never come in. I was familiar with the bar upstairs. More or less we were doing our best to pretend this was a totally normal way to be meeting, but I can’t imagine either of us felt that way. But yeah we talked a little about her working in library archives nearby.</p><h4>DURING THE DATE</h4><p><strong>What did you discover about your date during dinner? What did you talk about?</strong></p><p>I learned she was into <em>Buffy</em> and <em>Buffy</em>-related podcasts, she was from Maine and liked the quiet life. We talked about a lot of things, it was a pretty expansive and enjoyable conversation. She’d gone to grad school landlocked near Pittsburgh, and it sounded like that was the last time she wanted to live that far from the beach, which she’d grown up near to. My love of karaoke also came up, which she’d dabbled in but wasn’t an addict of to my level. She had the right take on it, though, and got why it was such dopamine hit for attention lovers.</p><p>I am too much of a loudmouth for things not to turn to politics pretty quickly, because it was another day in Trump’s America and there were 15 distinct crises that one couldn’t talk with a stranger for more than a few minutes before mentioning. That took a sidewinding turn to me wanting to admit to some of my regrettable contrarian tendencies, which was probably partially a way to share insight into who I am but also might’ve been kind of flashing the caution sign in her direction.* Because for as much as we were talking I was still trying to figure out if my initial reaction that this wasn’t going to work out was going to hold up.</p><p>*<em>Among my most honest responses. In my defense, it wasn’t a dare — it was a signal.</em></p><p><strong>What did you order? How would you rate the food and service? What stood out?</strong></p><p>I got a tequila cocktail and a bourbon one. We split a cheese plate to start. It was funny — we were talking about entrees and I said was eyeing the pork loin, and she was thinking the same but was about to reconsider, so as to not double up. But that inspired me to bring up something a social scientist friend of mine had pointed out to me — that the instinct not to order the same thing as someone you’re with, as if it indicated a lack of creativity (instead of good taste) is a total backwards false choice and mental trap. So that led to us both ordering the pork, and I think we were both satisfied with it. We took a while to eat, though. We took our time between orders, largely because we were having good back-and-forth and kept neglecting to check our menus, which might have been kind of a way to navigate the awkwardness.</p><p>The service was good but I’ve also probably never given it less thought or been more preoccupied.</p><p><strong>What did you and your date have in common?</strong></p><p>I think we shared outlooks about modern politics and social challenges, and we’re both invested in writing, although in pretty different ways. She seemed like a deep thinker, which I really enjoyed and kept enjoying more. And her sense of humor was solid, which is important to me. And while we had different experiences our backgrounds seemed pretty similar. We spoke the same language.</p><p>We both like leaning into the comforts of television, but I found myself focusing on how that came in different ways. She likes <em>British Bake Off</em> and all those cooking shows, and I have never been able to warm to any reality TV competitions, least of all kitchen ones. I like punchy, scripted TV stories. Which completely should not matter and if the chemistry felt different probably wouldn’t have, but things like that felt like evidence that I should try and be careful not to send mixed signals. We did have plenty in common, though.</p><p><strong>How comfortable did you feel with your date? Did you get more or less comfortable as the date went on? Why?</strong></p><p>I felt very comfortable but I wonder whether that’s because I had so few expectations. And it was a really enjoyable conversation, as was getting to know each other. At a certain point in the date, we sort of approached the topic of each of our individuality and life as single people. And that’s a pretty intimate thing, especially as life goes on and more people in your life are increasingly distant from your experiences. And while everyone knows it can sometimes be easier to confide in a stranger, doing it with a prospective romantic partner had its own kind of freedom. But yeah, I felt very at ease with Caroline. And things like her sense of humor and timing definitely helped. (As did the aforementioned cocktails, no doubt.)</p><p><strong>Did he/she seem more attractive as the night went on? How so?</strong></p><p>She definitely did. Like I said, I kept approaching issues I knew to be delicate, just to get into their nuance and explore how complicated it feels like it can be to care about literally anything in our world at this current moment of never-ending explosions of cultural disruptions and realignments. And at every turn, Caroline was totally game and ready to try and understand and roll her eyes with. So I dug that, and there was a distinct moment where I looked at her again and it was like with fresh eyes* and thought maybe I’d been wrong all along. I got a good vibe from her, and after noticing that it felt like there was some potential. But I was still really cautious, because again after that initial reaction at the beginning of the night my instinct was to be polite and not give someone too much of a reason to feel let down.</p><p>*<em>So yeah there was a moment, but mostly I just wasn’t feeling it.</em></p><p><strong>Did either one of you say or share anything that seemed to be a deal breaker? If yes, can you tell us about it?</strong></p><p>I think I kept trying to, explaining how it is I often find myself drawn to the defense of cultural outcasts who in all likelihood do not need it and trying to reconcile that with morals and values, but Caroline was too reasonable to be alienated, it seemed.</p><p>I kept coming back to that contrast of our introversion and extroversion. That’s something that has caused problems in otherwise promising relationships for me in the past, so it’s something I take particular note of, especially in instances that feel otherwise compatible. You hope you’re learning as you move along in life, right? So I had a hard time getting past that.</p><p>Something I think about a lot in dating is, will this person and I have fun at the same parties? Are we going to be at ease in the same situations? That’s where the way you socialize is so important, when the relationship is outside the bubble of the two of you. And that was something I had reservations about with Caroline.</p><p><strong>At what point did you think: “I really like this person,” or “This is not going to work.” Why? What triggered it?</strong></p><p>Caroline told a story about how she’d been asked about what kind of people she surrounds herself with, like what characteristics they shared. It was an awesome question. Considering it, I remember wanting to be careful about how I answered, because I didn’t want to alienate her and I think it underscored why I was feeling the way I did. For me, the answer is probably something like, I like people who make as good of an audience as they are entertainers. People who are engaging and engage with me and worlds I enjoy. I was unsure if we’d keep the same pace.*</p><p>*<em>If you know, you know.</em></p><p><strong>Was there any romantic chemistry at any point in the evening? When? What happened?</strong></p><p>Like I say, there definitely was on my end at one point. After a great conversation and a nice meal, when I knew Caroline better, she was much more striking to my eyes. So that was where my brain was like “Oh right I totally want to make out with this pretty girl I am on a date with.” But by that point, so much of the night for me had been figuring out why I wasn’t warming to this girl more, so I had kind of gotten into my own head. And crucially, that moment came when we were still at dinner, and not later when we were actually at the point in the date in which you either will or won’t make out.</p><p><strong>Was there a point when you wanted to leave? Why?</strong></p><p>Not like “Okay, I’ve got to get out of here,” no. After the meal as we were winding down our last drink, when it kind of became that time to sort out what was to become of us once our “Dinner With Cupid” was over, I got anxious to wrap things up neatly. It had been a great time, but I was worried that I’d start laying it on thick, like a “Bachelor/Bachelorette” candidate or something. That route felt disingenuous at that point, for me. And I had the impression (rightly or wrongly) that Caroline was feeling the vibe, which wasn’t a turn-off or anything but didn’t feel like something that would be, I don’t know, honest if I pursued in the moment? So much of our conversation had been about exploitation I think I was just hypersensitive about putting myself in position to be guilty of it. (Again, it is not the world’s biggest surprise that I remain single.)</p><p>I wonder whether those rom-com expectations I’d had coming in made put me in that reductive mindset that the options were either act like a good guy or a creep, like in all those terrible patriarchal, anti-feminist, familiar and beloved movies. I’ve seen a lot of them, so I wouldn’t doubt that some of that crap’s creeped in.</p><h4>AFTER DINNER</h4><p><strong>Did you do anything together after the meal? Whose idea was it? Were you reluctant or excited to continue to the date? Why?</strong></p><p>It wasn’t until we were actually leaving that I realized that Caroline might have been hoping to make another stop, but by that point I didn’t see a natural extension and didn’t bring it up. I guess I was reluctant and didn’t really give that a chance. Reflecting on it, I wonder if that was a misstep — if after the “Dinner With Cupid” portion of our evening if I’d have been more at ease and free of expectations, and could have enjoyed the rapport we’d developed. But in the moment, I’d kind of run out of charm and was just trying to help us both navigate potential awkwardness.</p><p><strong>How did the date end? Be specific.</strong></p><p>As soon as we left the restaurant, things went sorta sideways. She was ordering an Uber or going to take the T, I was figuring out the bus schedule, it was still vaguely up in the air whether we wanted to make another stop. For me, I think all the uncertainty I’d kind of been harboring even during our spirited conversation finally manifested when it became clear (to both of us maybe) that I had no specific ambition for us as we left. It wasn’t, “I can’t imagine not keeping this date going,” which is what you’d hope for.</p><p><strong>How did you say goodbye? Any good night hug or kiss? Why or why not?</strong></p><p>She decided to take the train and I, recognizing the moment said, “Well this was fun, I’d love to do it again.” Which is true. I’d love to hang again and see what things feel like when the expectations have died down. Anyway she responded that she’d like it too but we didn’t have the means, and we exchanged numbers. As we parted I sent her a BitMoji, the personalized yet impersonal text things, and she responded a funny gif that winked at all the bull I’d been talking about. Which left me like, am I crazy for not being more gung-ho about this?</p><p><strong>Give your date a grade. Was it an A+ or a C-?</strong></p><p>I’d give the conclusion of the date a B- or C+, because at a minimum we could’ve handled the exit strategy better, but overall I’d say a B. It was notably fun and worthwhile, and hey there’s no beating a free meal. But the pressures and matters fundamental to a blind date — I mean, I didn’t even know how tall she was until we left — made it hard to trust that any of one’s reactions were natural. And looking back I think it’s crazy that we enjoyed ourselves as much as we did but didn’t kiss.* I blame the Globe!</p><p>*<em>At this point, while I was writing up my answers, I recieved a text from Caroline, asking if I’d like to go out again. So eager was I to be universally adored that despite basically having known from the moment we met that there was no there there between us, and so unsure of my own prognosis was I, and so in knots had I tied myself in the composing of the answers, that I said sure, I’d love to meet for a drink that didn’t come with homework attached. Looking back, I think more than anything I just wanted this contrived excercise to pay off, somehow. For the risk of embarassment to prove worth it. My fool heart indeed.</em></p><p><strong>Do you think you’ll go out on another date? Why or why not?</strong></p><p>I think we might. But to be honest, I have to imagine we’re both very curious to see how this story turns out. I mean, we’re a pair of writers and we’re going to be the story — I imagine we’ll both have some notes**. But yeah I think I’d like to maybe try and figure out a good time to see if we do, in fact, enjoy the same kind of parties.</p><p>**<em>Again, I just really wanted good copy to come of all this.</em></p><h4>FOR THE WRITEUP</h4><p><strong>Have you had a job change or birthday since you filled out your Cupid application? Please list your job title (customer service representative, product manager, education administrator, nursing assistant, etc.) and your age:</strong></p><p>Nah I’m the same as I’ve been — 34, copywriter and freelance journalist focusing on arts and culture.</p><p><strong>Nicknames vs. long version of your first name: When we refer to you by your first name, what should we call you (Katherine or Katie, Robert or Rob, etc.)?</strong></p><p>I go by Brendan.</p><p>*******</p><p>When it was all said and done, my Dinner With Cupid wasn’t even my most exciting date of its week. And that was fine, but once I realized as much my silly hopefulness about it all began its slow transformation into dread. This story wasn’t going to become a nifty little testament to my lighthearted love hijinx, it would be evidence that I’m a total reckless mess with no idea what he’s doing (who, yes, at least knows how to make the tailspin fun to be around).</p><p>That dread crystalized when the story went live online. As had been my plan all along, I worked up a cute little self-effacing promotional social media post, the only part of the whole affair that went according to my plans, and came to realize how many people in my world still read the newspaper.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/576/1*kbYLe6VwKr47S4scwrI56g.png" /><figcaption>This was the tone I was hoping for with it all.</figcaption></figure><p>Ultimately, it was fine. The story was fine, my concerns were overblown and self-aggrandizing. Friends pointed out which of my tics most strongly made it through the edit. Acquaintences wondered whether it had been a love connection (no one who knows me well needed to ask). I got flack for grading the date a B, in comparison with Caroline’s A. I got wind of a few exes duly rolling their eyes at it all.</p><p>The comments were amazing. A few of them left the impression that these people knew me better by reading 300 words than Caroline had in our 3 hours together (“He’s got a big ego”; “Kanye West paraphernalia — run!”). That was the spin cycle I was aiming for — the one where we all share a laugh at how ridiculous everything is. I didn’t get that satisfaction from it all, but seeing that others did came pretty close to scractching the itch. Until I decided I’d have to wrest control of things and say it all on my terms. Because of course I did.</p><p>You can read the article as it ran <a href="https://www.bostonglobe.com/magazine/2019/01/11/there-was-distinct-moment-where-thought-maybe-been-wrong-all-along/xMGw2f5tFCcJ0NbDfvClfI/story.html">here</a>. But now you know the story.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fb8a56ef8873" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Womanized: On Britney Spears and that Lily Allen cover]]></title>
            <link>https://brendan-mcguirk.medium.com/womanized-on-britney-spears-and-that-lily-allen-cover-b59ad883f99?source=rss-30558b07bbbe------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b59ad883f99</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[britney-spears]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lily-allen]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cover]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Brendan McGuirk]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 02 Dec 2016 16:34:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-12-02T18:41:10.569Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/914/1*HsQlolh0B3H4RviA8CYXEA.png" /><figcaption>You never forget your first.</figcaption></figure><p><em>[Note: this piece is excerpted from a sprawling and incomplete series of essays I did on classic pop covers a few years back that never found a home. In honor/opportunity of Britney Spears’ 35th birthday, I thought I’d share this segment, on Lily Allen’s cover of Britney’s “Womanizer.” Cheers.]</em></p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2F3jOzuLsJIUE%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3D3jOzuLsJIUE&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2F3jOzuLsJIUE%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=d04bfffea46d4aeda930ec88cc64b87c&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/463defc089520d224f418396e5b13bd0/href">https://medium.com/media/463defc089520d224f418396e5b13bd0/href</a></iframe><p>I’m not going to sit here and intellectualize the merits of Britney Spears as a recording artist. I won’t say that “Toxic” makes some profound statement about female sexuality in our modern world in any sophisticated way. I don’t need to make Britney Spears sophisticated, because sophistication plays essentially no part in what made Britney such a big deal.</p><p>I could certainly, however, tell you exactly where I was the exact second of the “…Baby One More Time” video premiere. I won’t, since it occurred in the early days of my adolescence, making it a story equal parts awkward and obscene. But I could.</p><p>In a primal way, Britney Spears was the prism through which a generation came to understand celebrity and sexuality. From the second of her arrival, she was a paragon of vice. While she was celebrated for it, the way vice informed her demise was also celebrated. Maybe she wasn’t the musician Madonna was or the icon that Marilyn Monroe was, but she was in the conversation with them both, if only because, at her height, she shared with them a similarly scaled relationship with America.</p><p>She came in as a purported virgin, teasing this desire to be hit. With her blossoming came the blossoming of her power and seeming sexual control. When she appeared to buy in too hard, and spiraled from hedonism’s herald to its victim, America’s fascination with her mutated into something sinister. It was like “Middle America” had some perverse desire to prove that the vice she represented had led to the inevitable endpoint in a way that somehow spoke to our collective virtuousness. Which it might have, but that I’m preeeetttty sure in the opposite way they meant.</p><p>Mass market media moralizing is a trickily ubiquitous thing. Most of the time it manifests itself in some benign way — a newscaster segues from an entertainment story to weather with a single casually smarmy and dismissive aside — but the barbs imply this vast sense of superiority over the figures we spend our collective energy inspecting and celebrating. We demand everything from them, then mock them for coming to rely on our attentions, and cheer when they experience failure. It’s a Coliseum mentality, and when someone like Britney Spears finally gets eaten by that fame lion, our cheer can only be called for what it is; bloodlust.</p><p>And everybody knows America’s been lusting for Britney’s blood since day one.</p><p>Lily Allen is a Brit, so maybe that’s all moot, but I’m pretty sure they’ve got their own take on celebrity and fame and all that. I’m certain that they were as fascinated by Britney over there as we were here. Lily Allen is also casually considered a somehow more authentic recording artist, and a more virtuosic talent. She might not have the chops to dance like Britney in her prime, but she might have the better voice and stronger individual songwriting skills.</p><p>That’s the rub with Britney; it’s not like we ever held her musical abilities in any particularly high esteem. From that first video, it wasn’t about her being the best singer or dancer. You just couldn’t deny her command of sensuality and its resonance. She was a vessel for pop hits that spoke to a perversion embedded not-too-deeply within our sexual subconscious.</p><p>And as she made hits, dug deeper, and got more raw, our capacity for empathy waned. We never cared if she was a person.</p><p>I never bought a Britney Spears album, or gave one a full listen-through, but from the second I saw that first music video, she mattered. She was relevant, from then on.</p><p>“Womanizer” is late-era Britney, of the post-“Blackout” “Circus,” when her shine had begun to dull and she seemed not to be having any fun. It can’t be easy to sell sex without joy, and it couldn’t be easy on someone. The song flips Britney’s traditional roles a bit, allowing her to focus more on a foul-acting adversary than herself. Without the burden of playing the bad girl, she can just playfully recognize and call out this douchebag running game. This time, he’s the object.</p><p>Allen strips away the overwrought production that permeates every song in the Spears catalog, and plays simply, with a modest band. It’s like she’s seeking to avoid any direct competition with the original, and thereby Britney, so she just kind of honors the song like it were any standard.</p><p>Not-competing does sort of feel like the sisterly thing to do. There’s no irony to this performance; Allen isn’t mocking a fallen icon. It just feels like she’s sort of big-upping a musician who made a lot of music a lot of people loved.</p><p>You could make the case that Britney Spears has been getting punished since day one, when, possibly incapable of knowing any better, she explicitly asked for it. Performers like Lily Allen, who are also constantly sexualized and objectified but are perhaps afforded the opportunity to have operated in Spears’ wake, must have some well of sympathy for Britney.</p><p>I like to think Lily Allen doing this song is a public declaration of admiration for Britney Spears. Or maybe she, too, has known some womanizers.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b59ad883f99" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Cynical Premise Made Geoff Johns’ ‘Flashpoint’ A False Restart]]></title>
            <link>https://brendan-mcguirk.medium.com/cynical-premise-made-geoff-johns-flashpoint-a-false-restart-c81cabd6ff41?source=rss-30558b07bbbe------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c81cabd6ff41</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[dc-comics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[comics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Brendan McGuirk]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 27 Jun 2016 22:46:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-06-27T22:46:26.657Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>On the DC Comics march to ‘The New 52’ and its difficulties</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*XP1YJbwQngiuj01khNYhFA.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>(First published in review of “Flashpoint #4” from DC Comics on August 8, 2011 at </em><a href="http://www.newsarama.com/8154-best-shots-comic-reviews-flashpoint-x-23-more.html">Newsarama.com</a><em>)</em></p><p>By a hair past its midpoint, the purpose of DC’s <em>Flashpoint</em> miniseries is pretty clear. While there are particulars to be sorted out, we know where this race ends. By its conclusion next issue, nothing — as comics’ readers have so often been told — will ever be the same again.</p><p>But I am struggling to recall the last time a story of such great consequence resonated so little. And made such little effort to.</p><p>By stripping away all the familiar trappings of the DC Universe, <em>Flashpoint</em> makes one thing extraordinarily apparent— it is not a love letter to the comics of old. Sure, the publisher has addressed that very need in an obvious and perfunctory way with the nostalgia-leaning <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DC_Retroactive"><em>DC Retroactive</em></a> specials, but this story is cut from entirely new cloth, where nothing that has come before in any way informs the present.</p><p>This is noteworthy for a few reasons. Stories that reflect on past glories and enrich them with neat thematic bindings and modern sensibilities have long been the trademark of writer Geoff Johns. Nearly all of his high-profile successes have, in some way, looked backwards as they marched forwards. And historically, DC’s game-changing series have also been reflective in nature. Every <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crisis_(DC_Comics)"><em>Crisis</em></a> has been comics about comics; comics that were an appreciation of the past, and that addressed the particular foibles of the genre.</p><p>The drawbacks of this approach have been made obvious; it has proven difficult to draw new readers through conversations about things with which they are unfamiliar. Like jazz, the audience with a full appreciation of the nuanced creativity that hearkens to the past grows smaller and smaller. And perhaps ever more troubling, the core audience that has stuck around has grown numb to the grand promises. DC has become the brand that cried “<em>CRISIS</em>!”</p><p>So it makes sense that <em>Flashpoint</em> would reject parallel world out-clauses for a fresher, less tried approach. With the first issue, in a blink of an eye, the world of DC’s ongoing story changed. It came without a harbinger’s warning. Everything was different, fine, but <em>why</em> was it different? Not because of Professor Zoom, the plot’s agent of change — why were Wonder Woman and Aquaman re-purposed to be totalitarian dictators? How does the supposition that, had a bullet’s trajectory been altered, Bruce Wayne’s father could have proven generally just as capable a Dark Knight do anything but cheapen Batman? What are the creators trying to tell us about the characters, or about we the readers’ relationship with them?</p><p>Despite feeling like one, this is not an <em>Elseworlds</em> story. The better of those generally give a novel perspective and appreciation for the familiar. Alterations, both cosmic and cosmetic, remind readers of the core iconic strength of these characters. The ones where the changes are arbitrary feel like just that.</p><p>So <em>Flashpoint</em> is neither a story about DC Comics as a whole nor an <em>Elseworlds</em>. If it is not a nostalgic commentary, that means it is instead — clumsily or not — a preview of the new DC. Not the DCnU, the cohabited world that will house these future <em>New 52 </em>stories, but for the new method by which things will be created, or, perhaps, abandoned.</p><p>Maybe the failure here is with my own expectations. Maybe by looking at <em>Flashpoint </em>as a ending, I am failing to see the new beginning it portends to. Maybe the fact that things are and will be different are enticement enough to usher in a new dawn of creativity.</p><p>Barry Allen has spent the majority of this miniseries trying to convince Thomas Wayne’s Batman that this world matters, that these actions are consequential. This message seems an awful lot like an attempt to convince the readers of that same point.</p><p>But comics don’t matter simply because a publisher decides they do. They matter when they resonate. They matter when the audience finds that they have discovered a new way to appreciate something they already loved. <em>Flashpoint’s </em>Superman is a caged, enfeebled, and scared experiment. Maybe that means that the powers-that-be think that as the company’s flagship icon, a bastardized Superman speaks more to its current state and current readership than a stately and powerful one would. Or maybe it means nothing beyond a plot-driven need to remove an influential piece from the playing board.</p><p>Stuff happens in <em>Flashpoint #4</em>. An innocent character is struck down by a harsh world full of cruelty and arbitrary violence. Sometimes that means something. It’s rendered as capably as any commercial comics.</p><p>There seems to be a lot of excitement and opportunity awaiting once <em>Flashpoint </em>crosses the finish line. Maybe amidst the rush we’ll find out why we’re going there.</p><p><em>DC Comics’ </em>Flashpoint #4 <em>was written by Geoff Johns, drawn by Adam Kubert, Jesse Delperdang &amp; Adam Sinclair, and lettered by Nick J. Napolitano. The series was Kate Durré and Rex Ogle.</em></p><p><em>This essay contains minor edits.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c81cabd6ff41" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Case for Reading Ta Nehisi Coates’ ‘The Case for Reparations’ Cover Story in ‘The Atlantic’]]></title>
            <link>https://brendan-mcguirk.medium.com/a-case-for-reading-ta-nehisi-coates-the-case-for-reparations-cover-story-in-the-atlantic-e7ef2a33196a?source=rss-30558b07bbbe------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e7ef2a33196a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[white-privilege]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[reparations]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[discrimination]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ta-nehisi-coates]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[blacklivesmatter]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Brendan McGuirk]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 23 Jun 2016 23:50:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-07-02T17:34:25.987Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>A personal appeal in support of a painful piece of journalism</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*q6qU2kuHVRCQqUTLg16sIw.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>(The following was first published to </em><a href="https://www.facebook.com/bpmcguirk/posts/10102032651906172"><em>Facebook</em></a><em> then at </em><a href="http://www.1point21jiggawhatts.com/2014/05/a-case-for-reading-ta-nehisi-coates.html">1point21jiggawhatts.com</a><em> on Saturday, May 24, 2014)</em></p><p>Ta-Nehisi Coates’ June, 2014 <em>Atlantic</em> cover story, “<a href="http://www.theatlantic.com/features/archive/2014/05/the-case-for-reparations/361631/">The Case for Reparations</a>,” is probably the most affecting piece of journalism I’ve ever read.</p><p>It is as long as it is upsetting.</p><p>Privilege and discrimination are not issues that are exclusive to black-and-white America, obviously, but they do have a unique and fundamental role in our national origin story. And equivocation is a lie we tell ourselves intended to pacify, whether due to feelings of helplessness, or internalized guilt.</p><p>Words like “reparations” are divisive, in every sense. As a result, we shy away from them, thinking that, like Voldemort, if we fail to mention them they will lose their power, and that politeness alone can power us to become a better union, as if by default. That’s bullshit. Kids who read “Harry Potter” know that’s bullshit. The only way to reconcile divisive issues is to acknowledge them, in full.</p><p>I don’t find racism to be any more malicious a sin than -isms relating to gender, or sexuality, or class. But institutionally, it has a different role in American history. We didn’t invent misogyny. Or homophobia. Or even racism, in the broadest sense.</p><p>But there are practices that were invented by this country that had very specific repercussions. The long tail of those developments is what Coates explores.</p><p>I’ve been a white guy for basically my whole life. Despite conflicting reports, I’ve never aspired to be anything different. But one thing that has never sat well with me was the idea that conversations about race and institutions in America were limited, “minority issues,” as if only the underserved had either cause or qualification to engage in the discussion. It’s the ultimate manifestation of privilege, right? That since *we* didn’t engage in the historic deplorable practices, since *we* aren’t to blame, we have no obligation, no skin in the game.</p><p>The problem with this line of thinking is it puts all the responsibility to solve and overcome historic injustices on the historically underprivileged. Which only exacerbates things. Which only leads to a culture of increasing division, but a mutating one, that evolves and simmers and only boils to the surface in explosive and obvious moments. It fosters resentment on both sides of the coin, even as both sides wish to move on, beyond. “Don’t characterize me as a racist, I’m not Sterling, or Zimmerman.” “Don’t talk to me about empathy if the upper limits of your identification is the rejection of slumlords and murders.” It can be insidious, alienating and cyclical.</p><p>There’s no way to read Coates’ reportage without coming away outraged. We’re supposed to be better than this. That aspiration is what we pledge to, and how we define ourselves. For me, actualization is a core tenet to self improvement. And I thought this piece could have just as appropriately been titled “The Case for American Actualization.”</p><p>I believe it is vital to read the <a href="http://www.theatlantic.com/features/archive/2014/05/the-case-for-reparations/361631/">piece in its entirety</a>. If you’re not a sociopath, it’ll hurt, quite a bit at times. But it will bring truths to the surface. A scar heals easier than a cancer.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e7ef2a33196a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Ye, Bey, Sees: Understanding the obnoxious insistence of Kanye West]]></title>
            <link>https://brendan-mcguirk.medium.com/ye-bey-sees-understanding-the-obnoxious-insistence-of-kanye-west-9bdbafbb9a3f?source=rss-30558b07bbbe------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9bdbafbb9a3f</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Brendan McGuirk]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 10 Feb 2015 06:16:34 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-02-10T19:04:23.004Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Notes from the KanYeHive following the 2015 Grammys</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*yaJ6F92vgv4PVaafJ8EPyA.jpeg" /><figcaption>The world was shocked to learn that Kanye West had reservations about the Academy’s choice for Album of the Year during Sunday night’s Grammy Awards.</figcaption></figure><p>I believe Kanye West. I believe a day will come when he says exactly what he means, and does not get in trouble for it. But it ain’t today.</p><p>Making waves out of emotional truths have always been a part of West’s brand. Few lyrics in music have proved more prophetic than his when he rapped that “<a href="http://genius.com/124624/Kanye-west-bring-me-down/Everybody-feel-a-way-about-k-but-at-least-yall-feel-something">Everybody feel a way about K but at least you feel something</a>.” There have been no shortage of opinions in the career of Kanye West. He’s got an argumentative quality that seems to suit him perfectly to the needs of today’s Internet fame machine‘s tailoring. Like all modern debates, everything with West is binary. Greatest or worst. Genius or buffoon. I’d go so far as to suggest that Kanye was formative to the very way we think about “Trending” in the twenty-first century, and of the volatility of modern celebrity and conversation. He makes it really hard to be bored. Kanye in a headline is a link you click. I do, anyway. He’s always got my attention, and when he loosens his most inarticulate outbursts and the world begins to tut-tut, I find myself agreeing with him. I kind of think he’s always right, and when he says everything all wrong, it only makes me agree with him more.</p><p>Sunday night’s biggest Grammy surprise came when Beck beat out Beyoncé for Album of the Year, and its least biggest came when Kanye West usurped the moment and began marching to the stage, presumably to protest the grave injustice that had just been committed against Queen Regent Beyoncé, First Of Her Name, by the occasionally out-of-touch recorded music industrial complex. It was amazing. It was as if, the second Prince announced the unexpected victory for Mr. Odelay, Kanye was the only person alive who knew exactly how to act. Whether in jest or nah, he Bey-lined his way up there, mulled grabbing the mic, visibly reconsidered, and returned to his seat before the scene he almost made went critical. He hadn’t even been onscreen for FourFiveSeconds, but he’d managed to make a <a href="https://vine.co/v/OUvAvAYQm6I">moment</a>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/630/1*xiHNfa2hXTar-1CWok29iw.jpeg" /><figcaption>He cares way too much about Beyonce’s place in the cultural hierarchy but so do a lot of people.</figcaption></figure><p>Now, Kanye critics, nay-Ye-sayers if you will, will look at that series of events as another in a long line of empty self-promotional tactics by the opinionated, emotional, boundary-free rapper. They look at the ranting would-be fashion mogul who hitched his wagon to an image-obsessed reality TV family and see nothing but a reckless opportunist that refuses to be grateful just to have a skill set the world so handsomely rewards. They see what President Obama did in his famous shade-throwing hot-mic moment.</p><p>I don’t. I look at Kanye and see an artist who recognizes culture’s forest from its trees, who is flabbergasted at the rest of the world for not seeing the same, and who, once frustrated, effortfully stammers and babbles to make his case. I see Kanye as someone whose biggest commitment is to his ideals, often over his better senses, and whose music argues for his values in a way his words never quite can.</p><p>Yes, it was rude of him to interrupt Taylor Swift during one of the biggest moments of her young career. And Fmr. President George W. Bush’s handling of Hurricane Katrina did not present hard proof or even direct evidence that the man was a bigot. But all I can tell you is that I still remember the “Single Ladies” video and am totally oblivious to which of Taylor’s even won (was it for <a href="https://soundcloud.com/hollywood-hamilton/black-and-troubled-taylor">this mashup</a>?). And the outrage that Kanye was channeling as he personalized his anger towards the president in 2006 represented a feeling that was not merely his alone, that was not unheard of in many American communities, and in some ways presaged the #BlackLivesMatter movement that left such an obvious imprint on Sunday night’s entire Grammy production.</p><p>Which brings us to why I think Kanye was right.</p><p>When Prince made his proclamation that albums mattered “Like books and black lives,” the reference felt subversive. But it really wasn’t. Sure, it was a stuffy environment on a stuffy channel, but Prince’s words were not so far from Pharrell’s stark performance of “Happy” with Hans Zimmer, or Common and John Legend’s charged performance of “Glory,” from the “Selma” soundtrack. Or Beyoncé’s eventual gospel finale.</p><p>It was a night when a lot of <a href="http://www.mediaite.com/tv/pharrell-pays-tribute-to-hands-up-dont-shoot-in-grammy-performance/">hands were raised</a>, imploring for compassion. It was a night where people had things to say. That artists wanted to take the opportunity to not just sell records but to advocate their beliefs and experiences seemed notable. If there was a unifying statement at the core of those performances, it was that some struggles are and remain undeniable.</p><p>When Beck was awarded that prestigious trophy in lieu of Mrs. Carter-Knowles, it was hard to escape the sense that there was a denial happening.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*JMsBalx3D8rexG6x1MPuSQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Superfans could tell you the differences between Kanye’s vocal inflections during his Grammy performance of “Only One” and the recorded version but those guys are nerds.</figcaption></figure><p>Personally, I thought the most interesting thing Kanye did that night was sing “Only One,” a song in which his mother reassures him of his worth from her heavenly perch, and admires his budding family. I thought blacking out the room and gesticulating over a laser’s single source of light while dressed in a velour adidas sweatsuit and fresh Yeezy 750 Boosts made for really memorable television. I even enjoyed the outfit as a subtle nod to host LL Cool J. I thought his use of autotune continued to be an innovation of instrumentation and live performance. But I understand if I am in the minority. It didn’t make as good of a video-loop.</p><p>It wouldn’t have been fair of Kanye to take the microphone from Beck and tell the world that Beyoncé had only lost the award because she is black, or because the Academy holds hip-hop in low regard. It wouldn’t have been the right thing to say. But that nagging feeling that certain people’s creativity was taken for granted was one I shared, and thought it was worth pointing out. The Grammys hadn’t relied on Beck and his spouse to kick off last year’s awards with a still-unforgettable performance, nor would he be closing this year’s show. “Morning Phase” may have deserved accolades, but the incorporeal entity known as “The Grammys” had drawn all kinds of value from the cache of Beyoncé — the name, the self-titled work, the brand — and then failed to duly celebrate the difficulty of that feat. Sorry, it all suggested, your music’s all well and good to keep the lights on, but this other kind of music is what really deserves our respect.</p><p>It also seemed like a rule-change. After all, when Macklemore won last year’s Rap Album of the Year, the argument went that he had sold a lot units, and that even if his work had not been the consensus favorite among rap fans, the Academy felt compelled to reward his so-called crossover industry success. Drake, Kendrick Lamar, Jay Z and Kanye West had all put out albums that would have easily taken the award in this year’s substantially weaker class, but they were put in the back seat because it was the year of “Thrift Shop” and “Same Love.” Even if he wasn’t being recognized as the greatest rapper, he was the one the Grammys had deemed to be The Most Important. Blockbuster-dom was their metric.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*--H_icmGdSxCo-WT2X_5VA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Rated Compelling</figcaption></figure><p>Well, when Beyoncé dropped her album with no notice, the world stopped. She and her team infused energy into the music-buying business unrivaled until Taylor Swift kept “1989” off Spotify. She did all the work of the album, the music videos, and staged a massive tour, and had been tabbed to close down the night’s celebration. In a remarkable career as a music professional, the year marked a high-point. Her recognition and reward from the industry that relied so much on her came in the form of Best R&amp;B Song — best of a genre, not Best of a Best. Perhaps a sense of marginalization was not wholly unwarranted.</p><p>There’s no use in looking at the Grammys as a scorecard for artistic virtue, but it has to represent something. And to Kanye West, and really to a lot of people that identify themselves as part of the hip-hop community, it represents injustice. Moreover, it represents institutional injustice, and worse still, predictable institutional injustice. That it’s so trivial a cultural battleground doesn’t diminish the fact that the climb for recognition can feel so insurmountably steep.</p><p>There’s nothing about a pop star losing an award to an aging rocker that presents an ironclad case about the realities of cultural supremacy in even the most liberal-minded communities, but there’s something that hints at it. Plenty of black artists have received their just-dues, but if you’re inclined to see it, instances like this only reinforce what you already believe to be true. Just like how, if you’re inclined to see Kanye as a jerk, you’re inclined to dismiss what it is he had to say had he said it. It was fascinating to try and read Kanye’s whole thought process in <a href="https://twitter.com/BrendanMcGuirk/status/564631800249864193">those short seconds</a>. “Did they REALLY just…? After this year? Do I need to? You know what? They’re not worth it.” He had the entire conversation that would fuel all the day’s “Beyoncé Wuz Robbed” thinkpieces, and encapsulated it in one perfectly digestible, meme-ready moment. It was a rant as an eye-roll.</p><p>Of course Kanye took it too far when he suggested Beck should give Beyoncé his award in the name of “artistry.” Overstatement is the only currency with the power to move the middle in today’s debates. People react to volatility, and so Kanye was gonna belabor Beconcé’s album over Beck’s until he’d made the world understand. Which could literally take forever. Being a rapper makes him a natural hype-man. And sure, as a guy that made his first million by repackaging musical loops recorded by others into new in-demand commodities, Kanye has a unique perspective on the nuances of artistry in the commercial space. He’s a producer, so when he describes himself or his peers as “products,” it’s the massive machinery being cultivated and guided to such great effect that he’s alluding to. And while it’s not the same sort of effort as goes into humble songcrafting, it’s not a lesser one — it’s a different one. And more to the point, the format is largely the creative and commercial lifeblood of the music industry.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*yKKngR3FIWjwD3ffA_vd4g.jpeg" /><figcaption>“Wait’ll I tell Nori about you.”</figcaption></figure><p>Kanye didn’t mean Beck sucks, the same way he didn’t mean Taylor sucked. He just meant it sucks that Beyoncé didn’t win. It sucks to feel that way, again. And if Taylor wins next year after Beyoncé didn’t win this one it’ll kind of suck, even though it absolutely shouldn’t.</p><p>“Y’all know what it meant when ‘Ye walked on the stage,” is what West said to E! as the evening’s dust settled. Once again, he was right. I knew exactly what it would mean. It meant that tomorrow I would wake up, log onto Facebook, and see everyone I know opine at the merits and shortcomings of my favorite artist’s latest statement. People would see his other <a href="http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/style-blog/wp/2015/02/09/kanye-wasnt-joking-tells-e-that-beck-needs-to-respect-artistry-and-he-should-have-given-his-award-to-beyonce/">quote to E!</a>, “When you keep on diminishing art and not respecting the craft and smacking people in the face after they deliver monumental feats of music, you’re disrespectful to inspiration,” and think he was just being self-serving, or at best coming to the aid of a friend. They would rage and laugh at his histrionics, and his seeming ignorance of Beck’s talent and accomplishment. Even those who agreed with him would have to weigh in on the worthiness of his expression. Everybody would feel something. A conversation would be had.</p><p>People would find it all terribly unimportant, banal even. And I would feel otherwise.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9bdbafbb9a3f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>