<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Brian O&#39;Beirne on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Brian O&#39;Beirne on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@brianfromdublin?source=rss-a5434c424cb4------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 22:41:04 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@brianfromdublin/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Chainlink as Social Architecture — Part 2]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@brianfromdublin/chainlink-as-social-architecture-part-2-8579769f5a24?source=rss-a5434c424cb4------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8579769f5a24</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[chain-link]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[4th-industrial-revolution]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[blockchain-technology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[web-3-point-0]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bitcoin]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Brian O'Beirne]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 29 Aug 2020 13:01:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-08-29T17:56:48.131Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Chainlink as Social Architecture — Part 2</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*FG-0jfLF2LBmAij7-EKuBw.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>Introduction</em></p><p>In the previous post, I briefly outlined what blockchain technology is, and how Chainlink represents the latest stage of its evolution. You can access Part 1 of this series of posts <a href="https://medium.com/@brianfromdublin/chainlink-as-social-architecture-501fd88e6f0b">here</a>. In Part 2 of this series, I will explain what “social architecture” is, how it comes in the guise of a variety of different models, and how these models generate meanings that constitute a social reality for agents. In Part 3, I will focus on the normative aspect of these models and explain how these models entail and secure the commitment of agents in a social reality. In Part 4, I will explain what role technology plays in social reality and outline how Chainlink will be the linchpin of a new type of <em>technological</em> social architecture.</p><p><em>Before I begin, thank you for reading. My name is Brian O’Beirne. I am the Community Advocate for Chainlink (</em><a href="https://chain.link/"><em>chain.link</em></a><em>) in Ireland. I’m also the Apprentice Ambassador for Polkadot (</em><a href="https://polkadot.network/"><em>polkadot.network</em></a><em>). I dropped out of a PhD program in legal and political philosophy in Trinity College Dublin back in 2014. I then moved to California where I started researching and writing about blockchain and cryptocurrencies. I sat and passed the California Bar exam in 2016 and became an intellectual property attorney in a Silicon Valley law firm. In that role, I worked closely with some of the newly emergent companies in the blockchain space. This series of articles represents the unlikely intermingling of these two separate currents of my life.</em></p><p><em>If you are looking for a guide to fully understanding what Chainlink ($LINK) is, I refer you to the </em><a href="https://blog.goodaudience.com/chainlink-the-missing-piece-to-the-god-protocol-fd455dde92ab"><em>Chainlink</em> <em>— the Missing Piece to the God Protocol</em></a><em> article. If you’re interested in reading more about the LINK token’s economics (“tokenomics”), I’d encourage you to follow </em><a href="https://medium.com/u/4cd59d0c7c27"><em>Max Sarafin</em></a><em> who’s written some very interesting and enlightening articles on this topic. I’ve included links to all of these articles, as well as links to my social media profiles at the bottom of this article. This article may be modified and updated in future, and I will try to indicate when and where any changes are made. Thanks are due to my friend John Ryan for his edits to this article.</em></p><p><em>Disclosure: Brian holds LINK, ETH and DAG.</em></p><p><em>What is Social Architecture?</em></p><p>Agents always interact within a context, that is, within a social reality. Indeed, the interaction of agents is precisely what makes the reality <em>social </em>in nature<em>. </em>Social reality is thus analytically (<em>a priori</em>) defined in terms of (and coterminous with) any interaction between agents. Note that this is a closed and exhaustive basis for the definition of social reality; social reality is defined on the interactions of agents and this implies closure with respect to those agents and their interaction. Social reality thus includes <em>and</em> <em>is </em>the domain<em> </em>of any and all interactions of agents.</p><p>Interaction implies communication and social reality is therefore communicative in nature. Interaction also implies control as between interacting agents (who, in a sense, mutually control one another through their interactions) and thus social reality involves control. Communication and control are linked because control implies that which is being controlled is communicating feedback to the controller, and communication itself implies control over the means of communication and the message being communicated. Social reality is thus a <em>cybernetic system</em>. Social reality controls and communicates to itself in terms of itself. As we shall see, this control and communication is executed by and through agents that instantiate social architecture in their social reality.</p><p>From an empirical vantage, social reality is the seemingly “manmade” aspects of reality, i.e., it is the physical field of your perception, minus trees, rocks, flowers, waterfalls, and the rest of the natural world. These aspects of social reality are all “interactions amongst agents” insofar as they are the outcome of cooperative endeavors amongst agents — even projects pursued in solitude depend on the work of other agents e.g., the paper or computer you use, the desk you sit at, and even the symbols and language you use to embody and express your lonely endeavor. If an agent truly is hermetically sealed off from the rest of humanity, without ever having any interactions with other agents, direct or indirect, then that agent obviously is not part of a social reality.</p><p>As Sergey Nazarov noted in a recent talk entitled <a href="https://t.co/nPCbjr8n5I?amp=1">The Evolution of Smart Contracts and Crypto-Economic Security</a>, virtually all of social reality is attributable to that enduring form of interaction known as <em>cooperation</em>. Cooperation is what enables the creation of work products and is secured through agreements, i.e., commercial contracts. A contract provides an agent with confidence that counter-parties are committed to a cooperative enterprise, and thus confidence that the labour, time, and money they invest in that project is not invested in vain. Through securing the commitment of counter-parties, agents thereby have time and freedom that they otherwise would not have, which they can use to pursue other things that they find meaningful, e.g., philosophy, literature, and art.</p><p>Note, however, that social reality does not consist only of tangible physical objects created through cooperation, but also language, gestures, signs and symbols. These embody and communicate meanings. Social reality is thus semiotic in nature. Language, gestures, signs and symbols form part of the <em>medium in and through</em> which agents within a social reality interact with one another. This is social reality communicating <em>with itself in terms of itself</em>. A key property of social reality is thus that it is <em>intelligible</em> to the agents within it. If social reality were not to some extent intelligible to its agents, then <em>those agents could not interact with one another</em>. This is where social architecture comes in. It is by virtue of a social architecture that social reality is intelligible to the agents within it. So what exactly is social architecture?</p><p>Social architecture is the <em>syntax </em>that determines the intension — the meaning — of a social reality inhabited by agents and thus governs the behavior of the agents therein. To be clear, this is not just “syntax” in the sense of “the syntax of a natural language” — although natural language is one model of this social architecture — it is a <em>cognitive-perceptual and behavioral</em> syntax that governs the interactions of agents. In order to interact with one another, agents must be able to communicate with one another and interpret each other’s actions — this cannot happen without a shared set of meanings which are rendered intelligible by the syntax of social architecture. As we shall see, there are active and passive phases to agents’ engagement with social reality — agents must <em>passively</em> receive and interpret the behavior and expression of other agents within social reality, and also <em>actively</em> transmit and communicate meanings to other agents.</p><p>A key aspect of social reality is the <strong><em>trustworthy</em></strong> exchange of information amongst agents, i.e., trustworthy communication, including trust that other agents are committed to their cooperative endeavors. Indeed, any <em>de facto </em>act of communication presupposes agents trust that their counterpart can receive and process the information communicated. If they did not trust that this was true, then (a) they <em>would not have any reason to attempt communication</em> with other agents (b) we would have to say that all agents that believed themselves to be communicating were delusional and (c) that any seeming of communication was an accidental coherence in the objective behavior of the agents. As we shall see, trust is actually logically <em>intrinsic</em> to social architecture — that is, trust is not added in by agents, but actually presupposed by the social architecture through which those agents interact.</p><p><em>Models of Social Architecture</em></p><p>There is one unitary social architecture, but it comes in the guise of a variety of different <em>models</em>. Law is one model of this social architecture. Table manners are another. Natural language is another. Nonetheless, social architecture is <em>theoretically univocal </em>— that is, it forms a non-contradictory unity and “speaks in one voice<em>.” </em>But how can this be? There are many different natural languages, many different views on what table manners are, and many different varieties of legal systems out there. What’s more, even in a given culture, in a given model, there are many different views about what constitutes the right or proper way to behave, and these often give rises to heated disputes amongst agents.</p><p>The plurality and competition amongst models actually implies that these models form a univocal framework. Indeed, if there was no unitary model of social architecture, then we would not be able to recognize the similarities amongst all these models — i.e., that they all define the terms of interactions between agents in a social reality. And when we debate about whether something is the “proper” way or the “right” way, we are committed to the presupposition that there is a unitary model and framework in which the debate could be resolved — to the idea that there is a correct answer.</p><p>The fact that social architecture is theoretically univocal goes to the <em>settlement function</em> of social architecture, which must clearly and <em>singularly</em> (non-contradictorily, non-ambiguously) define meanings for agents who interact in terms of those meanings. The meanings must be settled in order for agents to interpret each others’ behavior and expression and in order to interact with one another. If the agents had no shared meanings, then they could not interact with one another. This is not to contradict the existence of the extant variety of terms and meanings through which agents interact, but each instance of this variety is (singularly, self-consistently) defined, and this implies a (singular, self-consistent) syntax through which it is defined, i.e., social architecture. Nor does this contradict the idea that in actual fact social architecture is ambiguous on certain points — this is why I’ve said it is <em>theoretically </em>univocal: in principle, it must operate according to this logic, although sometimes its instantiations in social reality don’t perfectly evince this univocality.</p><p>In the absence of a univocal social architecture, agents are faced with indeterminate states and <em>literally</em> <em>could not interact with one another</em>. To look at it from a different perspective, we could say that what’s happening here is that meaning is being generated by the social architecture. Meaning is information and, as the progenitor of Information Theory Claude Shannon has put it: “Information is the resolution of uncertainty.” This happens at a variety of levels. The meaning of a term or a sentence must be resolved for it to be communicative, and this requires a syntax according to which its meaning is determined. Legal disputes likewise must be resolved, in which case social architecture resolves the uncertainty surrounding which of the agents is at fault.</p><p>The models of social architecture can be ordered in terms of levels of abstraction, with formal languages i.e., languages that are rigorously defined to exclude reference to outside terms or definitions, at the highest level of abstraction. The models at lower levels of abstraction more closely track and correspond to the contexts in which they are instantiated. For instance, the rules of a football match are defined in terms of a field with goalposts on either end, a 90-minute interval, and white lines painted on a pitch. The extent of the correspondence to the domain of application is thus key to determining how abstract a model of social architecture is. But even formal languages which seemingly bear little relation to social reality are defined by reference to <em>excluding or subtracting social reality and its social architecture from their domain</em>,<em> </em>and are thus implicitly defined on the social architecture itself. Even the most determined efforts at exclusion will fail, as Gödel proved with respect to Russel and Whitehead’s <em>Principia Mathematica. </em>Thus social architecture <em>always </em>plays a role in interactions amongst agents, even where they try to exclude it. It is inescapable — that is, agents in social reality are compelled to deal in terms of social architecture. We will return to this in Part 3 when discussing the normative aspect of social architecture.</p><p><em>Instantiation of Social Architecture by Agents — Mapping Social Architecture to Social Reality</em></p><p>Agents are hermeneutic (“interpretive”) operators, i.e., they <em>interpret</em> the intension of (and thus process the information that constitutes the) social reality. To interpret, they map models of social architecture to social reality, thereby generating <em>instances</em> of that social reality. These instances individually encode the models and thus the social architecture. These instances are <em>intelligible</em> to other agents because they conform to the syntax of the social architecture which determines their meaning (through its aforementioned settlement function). While such an instance may not always be intelligible to an agent if it does conform to social architecture (due to noise, confusion, intellectual limitations of agents), it certainly won’t be intelligible if it does <em>not</em> conform to the social architecture. Thus, conforming to social architecture is a necessary but insufficient condition of intelligibility.</p><p>The meaning of a proposition or any observation or observation statement depends on the context in which it is uttered or observed; and the context depends on the social architecture on which it is defined. In other words, <em>meaning is a mapping</em> from social architecture to social reality. Traditionally, philosophy draws a distinction between analytic propositions and synthetic propositions. Analytic propositions are self-contained and thus self-true (“true of themselves”) by virtue of their meaning (“2+2=4”). Analytic information is thus globally and intrinsically true with respect to its own domain of application. Synthetic information is true by virtue of its relation to outside contexts (traditionally, this is construed as a question of whether it maps empirical or experiential aspects of the external world), and thus may or may not be true depending upon its relation to other parts of the social reality.</p><p><em>Analytic/a priori categories</em></p><p>Immanuel Kant addresses the analytic-synthetic distinction in the context of space and time, pointing out that space and time are fundamental analytic <em>a priori</em> categories that are presupposed by all perception and thought. That is, they precede experience and are inescapable. They are in fact the medium of cognition and perception. Leibniz argued this in a similar vein. These views contrast with the Newtonian view of space which regards it as an external dimension which merely contains objects. If you are a part of a social reality (which you are), any time you perceive or think or express or behave, you do so at a particular time and place, and so are actually mapping an instance of social architecture in spacetime. This instance is a distinctive action in spacetime. Thus, while all of this might seem quite abstract, you actually deal in terms of analytic categories all the time.</p><p>While space and time are the abstract a priori medium of thought and perception, other analytic categories have a seemingly empirical or experiential basis. “All bachelors are unmarried men” is one example of an analytic statement that is true regardless of its mapping to the real world, but has an experiential basis, i.e., the phenomenon of bachelors in the external world. Law is another example. Law has an experiential basis, but there is no extant empirical perceivable object or set of objects called “law” — there is instead a set of interactions in which we have agents which understand themselves to be engaged in law; these agents are in fact instantiating the model of law in social reality.</p><p><em>Models of social architecture are analytic in nature.</em></p><p>As we’ve discussed, models of social architecture are what makes social reality intelligible to the agents within it, through resolving otherwise indeterminate and unintelligible states in that social reality. They thus <em>pre-emptively</em> determine the meanings through which agents relate. “Pre-emptively” because if the model is not defined <em>in advance</em>, its instantiations are not defined, and thus it cannot perform (and has not performed) its settlement function. The aspect of social reality to which the model relates would then not be intelligible to agents and agents could not interact in light of it.</p><p>By implication, this means that models of social architecture are analytic in nature. That is, their definition must be closed and self-true, and <em>not</em> <em>invalidated</em> by the particulars of the social reality in which they are instantiated. If the syntax were changeable on an <em>ad hoc </em>basis, then it would not be defined, and it could not be used by agents to communicate with one another. Social architecture thus has a definitional priority (and, as we shall see, a normative priority) over the part of social reality to which it applies. Of course, not all social architecture is immutable, as we know that social architecture changes under certain circumstances (such as when norms or rules change), but these changes always invoke a higher (and unchanged) model of social architecture in terms of which changes in lower models are affected.</p><p>Of course, this does not preclude the formulation and invention of new models which are <em>not yet</em> intelligible to agents, but these new models will be derived and based on prior models through which the agents interact and cooperate to create the new models. Furthermore, this does not mean that existing models of social architecture are finite and closed; new laws (amendments to the model of law) and new words (amendments to the model of natural language) are constantly being created, but they are always <em>related as new laws</em> and <em>as new words in the natural language</em> in question; that is, they are defined on antecedent models of social architecture.</p><p>It is worth here pre-empting the role of Chainlink in the framework of social architecture. Sergey Nazarov relates this as follows: “Generating definitive truth is a unique capability of decentralized computation; while blockchains do this well for transactions, ownership and voting, decentralized oracles provide definitive truth about real world data/events, increasing their usefulness.” The connection here between the intension of social reality and “definitive truth” should be apparent. Decentralized computation generates a singular intension, a parameter, on which contracts (and thus the contractual obligations of contracting agents) are predicated. Whereas this has traditionally been done through the framework of social architecture, Chainlink is a new model of social architecture that can achieve this through decentralized computation.</p><p>In this connection, it’s interesting to note that many (if not all) models of social architecture are, in a sense, decentralized or, we could say, “distributed”— that is, it they not devised by a single agent or set of agents. This immunizes these architectures against the adverse interests of agents (“adverse” because each agent is individually self-interested), who would otherwise resolve the indeterminacy in their own favor. This is most obvious in the case of legal disputes where law is a decentralized model of social architecture that is shared by agents, but not independently controlled by any one agent or set of agents. It therefore can be used a basis by otherwise adverse agents to resolve their dispute.</p><p><em>Analytic Anticipatory Schema</em></p><p>Social architecture is an <em>analytic</em> anticipatory schema. As discussed above, it is anticipatory in the sense that it <em>pre-emptively</em> relates the agent to their social reality. It is also “anticipatory” in a <em>rational sense</em>. This is the sense in which models of social architecture bare on the reasons that agents have for behaving or expressing themselves in one way or another. For example, in any legal dispute between agents, the model of law has an overriding priority. A court will only settle a dispute by reference to legal arguments, and without recourse to non-legal reasons or arguments. They will consider and weigh the strength of any arguments made in terms of their strength as <em>legal arguments</em>. Likewise, any indeterminacy in a language will be settlement reference by reference to the syntax of that language, and not any other linguistic syntax. We could thus say that the settlement function of a model of social architecture is content-independent and inheres in the formal identity of the model in question.</p><p>In the case of law, Joseph Raz formalizes this in his <em>preemption thesis of law</em>, which is the claim that law pre-empts and <em>displaces</em> the reasons that agents have for behaving in a particular way, or reasons that they cite in any legal dispute. This is a substitutive operation — that is, the law through the courts substitutes itself and its conclusion as an <em>independent, decisive and conclusive reason</em> that settles the dispute before it. It also presupposes that the reasons that apply to those agents has been taken into account. This is Raz’s dependence thesis. If law did conform to these two theses, then it could not settle disputes because it would not have priority over the reasons that apply to the agents in any given case, and if it did not have this assumed priority the conclusions of the courts would have the potential to be reprised, reopened, and re-debated <em>ad nauseum</em>. Obviously, social architecture then would not be an efficacious means of resolving disputes and indeterminacy.</p><p>Social architecture is structured in terms of a hierarchy of models, because in any given case, indeterminacy as between different models (and rules) which purportedly apply to that case must be resolved. That is, the application of a rule to a given case, implies a higher rule according to which that rule can be selected and applied. Therefore, we can order the models in terms of normative priority. In the model of law, the constitution trumps other forms of law. Law trumps moral norms, in the sense that moral arguments (“this action was wrong” or “this action was right”), though taken into account in a dispute, are secondary to what the law says, and what the court decides is law. In legal philosophy, the ultimate model that supervenes on all other models, and on which the validity of the lower models depends, has been called the <em>Grundnorm </em>(by Kelsen) or the “Rule of Recognition” (by HLA Hart).</p><p><em>Reflexivity of Social Architecture</em></p><p>Social architecture is reflexively (through self-referential relation and application) related to social reality, insofar as it is applied by agents to their social reality. But there is actually a <em>reciprocal</em> relationship between the agents and the social architecture, insofar as <em>they identify it</em> as their social architecture, and <em>in turn it identifies them</em>, either explicitly, as when a constitution identifies a “People” in its text, or implicitly, as when a set of cultural norms is associated with and to a group. This reciprocal relationship means there is a coupling between each social reality and its social architecture.</p><p>This coupling happens at a number of levels: at a global level, where the models of social architecture purport to apply to all the agents in the social reality, e.g., public law that governs the relationship between agents and their state, and also at a local level, where models govern the relationship amongst agents in a more particularized fashion, e.g., the norms of polite conversation in a given culture. This coupling is often elliptically explained as “acceptance” of the norms by the agents in the social reality in question. But this explanation is enthymeme, i.e., it omits important premises or aspects of the explanation. These premises have been partly elucidated here in terms of how agents need shared meanings in order to interact, but we have yet to explain exactly how or why agents accept these models of social architecture. This will be addressed in Part 3, where we discuss the normative aspect of social architecture.</p><p><em>Freedom From &amp; Freedom To</em></p><p>It’s useful here to relate social architecture to freedom, and ask how the two relate. Isaiah Berlin (and <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naval_Ravikant">Naval Ravikant</a> in a recent <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tim_Ferriss">Tim Ferris</a> podcast) distinguished between two types of freedom: “freedom from” and “freedom to” — the former relates to the right to be free from the interference of third parties (including the State), whereas the latter refers to the freedom to pursue opportunities. It’s natural to ask whether there is a priority between these two freedoms, and what the precise nature of the relation between them is. And here it is: If you do not have freedom from interference, then you are not free to generate or pursue opportunities. That is, “freedom to” presupposes “freedom from” (but “freedom from” does not presuppose “freedom to”). Another thing to note here is that freedom to is meaningless without <em>options </em>— freedom to implies a direct object, an option, that is the object of the freedom of the subject — but also that freedom to thus always implies a constraint in the form of the range of options available to you.</p><p>How does this relate to social architecture? Social architecture affects both of these types of freedom. Social architecture impinges on your freedom from by constraining your expression and behavior. If you attend a dinner, for instance, you are constrained by the norms surrounding table manners and conversation — adherence to these norms inhibits you from behaving in other ways that you otherwise could. However, these norms are also what enable the dinner to occur. For instance, by adhering to a norm like not belching, you avoid alienating the other guests, whose ongoing participation is what essential to the dinner. The norms constrain what happens at the dinner, but thereby enable it to proceed where it otherwise wouldn’t (or couldn’t).</p><p><em>Agents as (Hermeneutic) Operators and Cybernetic Feedback Loops</em></p><p>We have already addressed how agents instantiate models of social architecture in their social reality. But how exactly does this work? Immediately when we ask this question we are in troublesome territory, because we are asking about the minds of agents. This has been a thorny issue in Western philosophy since Descartes, and is made even more difficult in the present context because we are not just asking an abstract question about the nature of mind; we are in fact asking a number of distinct questions. First, how do the subjective minds of agents relate to the objective, external world? Second, how do agents receive meaning from their social reality? Third, how do they convey and communicate meaning to their social reality? There are thus many layers of complexity to this issue.</p><p><em>Intelligibility</em> is the key to addressing all of the above questions — when we speak in terms of the mind of an agent, we are speaking in terms of what is intelligible to them (or not intelligible to them). Interaction amongst agents in a social reality implies that they are intelligible to one another, and intelligibility<em> implies interpretation</em>. That is, for information to be intelligible to an agent implies that it has been subjected to interpretation by an agent. Interpretation means that the information in question has been received, contextualized (necessarily by reference to models), processed, and mapped onto the external reality. In other words, agents are <em>hermeneutic operators. </em>Social reality is a semiotic system that is interpreted by agents by reference to social architecture that settles otherwise indeterminate meanings through which those agents interact with one another.</p><p>As already discussed above, there are active and passive phases to agents’ engagement with social reality — agents must passively receive and <em>interpret</em> the behavior and expression of other agents within social reality, and also <em>actively</em> transmit and communicate meanings to other agents. There is thus a reception-transmission feedback loop passing between agents. This is a process that applies to all communication in social reality and when functioning it generates a social equilibrium, in which agents are mutually intelligible to one another. This happens at a number of levels: natural language, religious observance, compliance with social norms, in commerce, and in many other arenas of social reality.</p><p><em>Natural Language: A Key Model of Social Architecture</em></p><p>Language (its syntax, grammar and vocabulary) is one special <em>foundational</em> example of social architecture because language (to some extent) determines what you can say, when you can say it, to whom you can say it, the way you say it (the how), and also even <em>the why</em> behind your utterance. Natural language <em>literally</em> reflects these constraints within itself in the form of the 5 Ws (who, what, when, where, why). Natural language itself represents the <em>how </em>of linguistic communication. It is one of the protocols through which communication happens in social reality and, like other models of social architecture, it actually <em>orients</em> agents with respect to one another within that social reality.</p><p>Language is a special and foundational model of social architecture for a number of reasons. First, because it defines — and is in fact — the primary medium in terms of which agents communicate. Second, because it features in many other models of social architecture, e.g., the norms of polite conversation. And third, because is often used to formulate and formalize these other models, e.g., where the rules of a game are written down in natural language. A crucial property of language (and social architecture in general) is that it bridges the subjective-objective divide, enabling our internal states that are otherwise inaccessible and imperceivable to other agents to be communicated to those other agents. That is, the intension of a term or state in social architecture reflects a subjective aspect which is amenable to comprehension by other agents.</p><p>Natural language is abstract and theoretic, but also embedded in social reality and thus, to that extent, it is empirical and concrete. The theoretic aspect of natural language implies a high degree of freedom for agents with respect to communication — agents can formulate sentences that are not obviously related to their social reality — but it also implies constraints in terms of which communication happens (syntax, grammar, vocabulary). As we shall see, once of the key constraints is that the language is <em>shared</em> by the agents engaged in communication in that social reality.</p><p>As we shall see, if you try to speak to another person in a language that you do not share with them, you will fail in that attempt. But this doesn’t just apply to natural languages. This is generally true of all social architecture — social reality is meaningful to agents because it embodies the shared social architecture of that social reality. Social architecture thus plays a non-trivial <em>causal role </em>in enabling communication and social interaction between agents and thus in shaping social reality<em>. </em>In theory, if you could somehow determine the natural language spoken by agents, you could control how they behave. This is true of all models of social architecture.</p><p>You can find Part 1 of this series of articles here: <a href="https://medium.com/@brianfromdublin/chainlink-as-social-architecture-501fd88e6f0b">https://medium.com/@brianfromdublin/chainlink-as-social-architecture-501fd88e6f0b</a></p><p>You can follow me on Twitter here: <a href="https://twitter.com/BrianOBeirne1">https://twitter.com/BrianOBeirne1</a>. My DMs are open and I will attempt to respond to everyone.</p><p>Here’s my LinkedIn: <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/brianobeirne/">https://www.linkedin.com/in/brianobeirne/</a></p><p>For a more complete treatment of Chainlink see: <a href="https://blog.goodaudience.com/chainlink-the-missing-piece-to-the-god-protocol-fd455dde92ab">https://blog.goodaudience.com/chainlink-the-missing-piece-to-the-god-protocol-fd455dde92ab</a></p><p>For an explanation of the $LINK token’s use case and why the token is necessary see: <a href="https://medium.com/@maxsarafin/why-the-chainlink-token-is-necessary-14da975354ec">https://medium.com/@maxsarafin/why-the-chainlink-token-is-necessary-14da975354ec</a></p><p>For an explanation of $LINK’s tokenomics see: <a href="https://medium.com/understanding-basic-chainlink-tokenomics/chainlink-tokenomics-the-guide-to-understanding-a-unique-asset-class-link-b766d5a89759">https://medium.com/understanding-basic-chainlink-tokenomics/chainlink-tokenomics-the-guide-to-understanding-a-unique-asset-class-link-b766d5a89759</a></p><p>Chainlink as a linchpin in the blockchain ecosystem: <a href="https://medium.com/@smartcontentpublication/accessing-all-blockchain-environments-through-a-single-chainlink-integration-92c64a2fb541">https://medium.com/@smartcontentpublication/accessing-all-blockchain-environments-through-a-single-chainlink-integration-92c64a2fb541</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8579769f5a24" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Chainlink as Social Architecture]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@brianfromdublin/chainlink-as-social-architecture-501fd88e6f0b?source=rss-a5434c424cb4------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/501fd88e6f0b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ethereum]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[blockchain]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[web-3-point-0]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[4th-industrial-revolution]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[chain-link]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Brian O'Beirne]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 14 Aug 2020 09:28:55 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-09-02T08:02:36.624Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Chainlink as Social Architecture — Part 1</h3><h3><strong>Introduction</strong></h3><p>Chainlink will change your life and the lives of everyone you know, and, believe it or not, this is already happening.</p><p>In this series of articles, I will argue that Chainlink is the linchpin of a new type of social architecture. “Social architecture” is the set of rules, laws and norms that govern inter-personal interactions in a society of agents. Traditionally, these rules and norms were those handed down by tradition and/or created by legal institutions, but this new type of social architecture is primarily <em>technological</em> in nature and is dramatically differentiated from its predecessor in a number of important respects.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*R03DjZ4_UQSNtoOHktlFcg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Bitcoin Traces / Martin Nadal (ES)</figcaption></figure><p><em>Before I begin, thank you for reading. My name is Brian O’Beirne. I am the Community Advocate for Chainlink (</em><a href="https://chain.link/"><em>chain.link</em></a><em>) in Ireland. I’m also the Apprentice Ambassador for Polkadot (</em><a href="https://polkadot.network/"><em>polkadot.network</em></a><em>). I dropped out of a PhD program in legal and political philosophy in Trinity College Dublin back in 2014. I then moved to California where I started researching and writing about cryptocurrencies. I sat and passed the California Bar exam in 2016 and became an intellectual property attorney in a Silicon Valley law firm. In that role, I worked closely with some of the newly emergent companies in the blockchain space. This series of articles represents the unlikely intermingling of these two separate currents of my life.</em></p><p><em>If you are looking for a guide to fully understanding what Chainlink ($LINK) is, I refer you to the </em><a href="https://blog.goodaudience.com/chainlink-the-missing-piece-to-the-god-protocol-fd455dde92ab"><em>Chainlink</em> <em>— the Missing Piece to the God Protocol</em></a><em> article. If you’re interested in reading more about the LINK token’s economics (“tokenomics”), I’d encourage you to follow </em><a href="https://medium.com/u/4cd59d0c7c27"><em>Max Sarafin</em></a><em> who’s written some very interesting and enlightening articles on this topic. I’ve included links to all of these articles, as well as links to my social media profiles at the bottom of this article. This article may be modified and updated in future, and I will try to indicate when and where any changes are made. Thanks are due to my friend John Ryan for his edits to this article.</em></p><p><em>Disclosure: Brian holds LINK and ETH.</em></p><p>The focus of this series of articles is Chainlink. I will therefore provide only a brief primer on blockchain.</p><p><strong>Blockchain Stage 1 — Bitcoin</strong></p><p>In a nutshell, the innovative aspect of Blockchain technology was the use of a decentralized network of nodes that used a “proof of work protocol” to reach consensus about the transactional history of a singular “distributed ledger” (“distributed” because each node has a full copy of the ledger and thus the ledger is literally distributed amongst the nodes). The nodes collect the records of transactions that take place between agents on the network, compile those transactions into blocks, and then <em>chain </em>those blocks to the previous blocks by including in them a cryptographically encoded signature or “nonce” of the previous block in the chain.</p><p>The “proof-of-work protocol” is a consensus mechanism that requires that each node participating in the network use computational resources to crack an algorithm (the SHA-256 algorithm). The use of computational resources is the “work” and basically this work is just <em>proof</em> that the agents operating the nodes have skin in the game. In order to run a node, you need to spend money on electricity and hardware, and this makes it less likely that one agent or set of agents will be able to control the entire network and/or lie about the contents of the ledger.</p><p><strong>Blockchain Stage 2 — Smart Contracts</strong></p><p>The second stage in the evolution of Blockchain was the innovation of smart contracts. Smart contracts are just computer code that is implemented in a blockchain. They are the brainchild of <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nick_Szabo">Nick Szabo</a>. In theory, the instantiation of the smart contract code in the blockchain removes the need for a trusted third party to intermediate the relationship between the contractors. The contract is “smart” because it knows what to do and when to do it, and once instantiated in the blockchain, it does not need the intervention of a third party human agent (beyond the contractors) to accomplish the object of its programming.</p><p>Ethereum is the original smart contracts blockchain network. The innovative aspect of smart contracts in Ethereum was that now, instead of merely recording additive and subtractive operations in the ledger, more complex instructions could be programmed into the blockchain, and those instructions could be executed without the need for oversight or intervention by a third party. Ethereum implements a Turing Complete programming language (Solidity) in which the smart contract code is written. “Turing Completeness” essentially just means that the language is computationally universal and can be used to simulate a <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Turing_machine">Turing Machine</a>.</p><p>It’s worth pausing here to note the sheer pervasiveness of contracts in our lives and society, and thus the far reaching implications of the innovation of smart contracts. Contracts are just agreements, and agreements are ubiquitous, permeating virtually every part of commercial life and our social reality. As <a href="https://twitter.com/SergeyNazarov?ref_src=twsrc%5Egoogle%7Ctwcamp%5Eserp%7Ctwgr%5Eauthor">Sergey Nazarov</a>, the founder of Chainlink <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ufVyX7JDCgg">notes</a>, virtually every part of the man-made world (as opposed to the natural world of trees, rocks, flowers, etc) is a result of cooperation mediated through agreements, and contracts ensure that agents follow through on their agreements by securing their commitment to those agreements.</p><p>In nearly every instance of a contract, you will find a third party who is not a party to the contract itself, but who is being paid by the parties to mediate the contract in some way. For example, if you have purchased something today using your bank account, then you have relied on the bank as a trusted third party to oversee the payment operation with the other contractor (updating its balance, settling payments, etc). This model of third party intermediation is so ubiquitous, that it’s easy to forget it’s there.</p><p>Cutting out the need for trusted third parties thus represents a truly enormous change, leading to massive savings for contracting parties across a wide range of different industries. But removing the often hefty cost of intermediary services from the transaction (e.g., legal fees for lawyers) is not the only category of efficiency gain. By encoding contracts in computer code, we cut down on the exponential cost of redrafting contractual documents. Billions of dollars each year is spent on reprising and redrafting Microsoft Word templates for agreements that are substantially the same in form and content. This happens both with respect to agreements used by a single party, e.g., one party using substantially the same agreement with a number of different counter-parties, but also as between different parties who all use essentially the same agreements (e.g., NDAs). By using computer code in lieu of paper or digital documents, you can simply reiterate a standard agreement through a function call. This represents a large saving of time and energy, and also minimizes the costs that result from human error.</p><p>Now, not all contracts are (or can be… or should be) digitally instantiated. Thus, not all contracts would (or could be… or should be) replaced by smart contracts. The point is that there is nonetheless a huge set of digital <em>and </em>paper “analogue (non-digital) contracts” contracts that could be replaced by smart contracts, and which replacement would benefit all parties to the exchange in the form of the aforementioned efficiency gains. But even for these smart contracts, there was still an outstanding problem. This problem is again subtle in nature and thus amidst all the enthusiasm for the innovation of smart contracts, was easy to overlook.</p><p>Smart contracts could execute trustlessly on-chain (on the blockchain), but many of them still needed to interact with the “analogue”, “non-digital”, real world. In other words, there were still steps in the real world that needed to be taken, and there were still off-chain data that needed to be input into these contracts. There is also a heterogeneity of blockchains in the blockchain ecosystem, and these chains need to be able to communicate data between themselves. If they cannot do this in a trustworthy way, then you lose the putative efficiency gains associated with smart contracts. In other words, smart contracts were only as strong as their weakest link and they therefore needed <strong>operational closure — </strong>they<strong> </strong>needed “end-to-end” validation of every input on which they depended.</p><p><em>Enter: Chainlink</em></p><p><strong>Blockchain Stage 3–Chainlink</strong></p><p>Chainlink is a decentralized oracle network. An “oracle” is software that compiles and feeds external data or data feeds (streams of data) into a smart contract. For example, if there is a derivatives contract that executes on the condition that a derivative reaches a predefined price, then that price is a datum that must be fed into the smart contract. It’s very important that that datum is accurate because there is likely a large amount of money at stake, and, if the contract executes incorrectly, it could be very difficult and costly to rescind it and to restore the parties to their pre-contractual position. Trusted third party oracles provide the valuable service of compiling the price data, and vouching for the accuracy of the data inputs they are providing to smart contracts.</p><p>Trusted third party oracles are useful because two parties to a smart contract can mutually elect a third party oracle that can provide the data inputs to their smart contracts. The problem is that this is not entirely consistent with the nature of the relationship between the parties to a smart contract. In many cases, the whole point of entering the smart contract is to enable the parties to transact at arms length without this level of cooperation. If they have to mutually agree on an oracle, then there is an increase in cost, potential for disagreement and also potential for illicit collusion between the oracle and one of the parties. Further, any mistakes or fraud can be very hard to rectify if the oracles are located in a different jurisdiction (or even if they are not, the legal costs of any dispute can be exorbitant).</p><p>A “<em>decentralized</em> oracle network” is a network where the oracles are operated by agents that are independent of one another. The oracle network enables parties to a smart contract to select a set of oracles to provide them with data for their smart contract (they can in theory select all the oracles in the network that provide the data feed in question, or just a subset of those oracles, thus enabling them to modulate the degree of confidence or certainty they need in the accuracy of the data). The oracles in the network then mutually cross-reference each others data feeds and thereby validate the accuracy of their own data feed. This consensus amongst independent oracles regarding the data is what gives parties to the smart contract confidence that the data feed is accurate. It is through the mutual agreement of independent nodes that a data feed is deemed canonical.</p><p>The contracting parties have other bases for their confidence in the data feed: each oracle has a reputation score, which it has a financial incentive to uphold so that other parties will use their services in future (oracles are paid by the parties in LINK). Also, in the future, nodes will be able to stake LINK as a way of vouching for the accuracy of the data they are providing. This staked LINK operates as a crypto-economic guarantee that the data they are provisioning is accurate. If the data they provide is inaccurate or fraudulent, then these nodes are penalized and lose the LINK that they have staked.</p><p>In software terminology, Chainlink is middleware. Middleware acts as a communication bridge between a software application and other inputs. Here, the software application is smart contracts and the other services are external data inputs. These external data inputs are a) data derived from the analogue “real” world and b) data from other blockchains. Even though LINK started as an ERC-20 token, it is not wedded to the Ethereum network. Chainlink is actually <em>blockchain agnostic</em>, meaning that it is not bound to <em>any</em> specific blockchain, but instead mediates inputs and outputs between different chains. This means that Chainlink not only connects blockchains to the real world, thus providing the end-to-end validation of data that smart contracts have been needing, but also provides interoperability between the <em>full spectrum of blockchains</em> in the blockchain ecosystem. Chainlink is thus the <em>linchpin</em> <em>technology</em> that enables the realization of much of the value associated with blockchain, smart contracts, and all related technology.</p><p>However, the commercial and sociopolitical implications of this technology stretch even farther and deeper than has yet been realized by most people. Chainlink will lead to a revolution in how social orders operate, across both the public and private sectors. But to fully appreciate how this will come about, you will have to stay tuned for future articles.</p><p>Peace.</p><p>Follow me on Twitter: <a href="https://twitter.com/BrianOBeirne1">https://twitter.com/BrianOBeirne1</a> My DMs are open and I will attempt to respond to everyone.</p><p>Here’s my LinkedIn: <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/brianobeirne/">https://www.linkedin.com/in/brianobeirne/</a></p><p>For a more complete treatment of Chainlink and <a href="https://blog.goodaudience.com/chainlink-the-missing-piece-to-the-god-protocol-fd455dde92ab">https://blog.goodaudience.com/chainlink-the-missing-piece-to-the-god-protocol-fd455dde92ab</a></p><p>For an explanation of the $LINK token’s use case and why the token is necessary:<a href="https://medium.com/@maxsarafin/why-the-chainlink-token-is-necessary-14da975354ec">https://medium.com/@maxsarafin/why-the-chainlink-token-is-necessary-14da975354ec</a></p><p>For an explanation of $LINK’s tokenomics: <a href="https://medium.com/understanding-basic-chainlink-tokenomics/chainlink-tokenomics-the-guide-to-understanding-a-unique-asset-class-link-b766d5a89759">https://medium.com/understanding-basic-chainlink-tokenomics/chainlink-tokenomics-the-guide-to-understanding-a-unique-asset-class-link-b766d5a89759</a></p><p>Chainlink as a linchpin in the blockchain ecosystem: <a href="https://medium.com/@smartcontentpublication/accessing-all-blockchain-environments-through-a-single-chainlink-integration-92c64a2fb541">https://medium.com/@smartcontentpublication/accessing-all-blockchain-environments-through-a-single-chainlink-integration-92c64a2fb541</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=501fd88e6f0b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[‘Consensus-Currencies’ in Digital Currency Trading Platforms]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@brianfromdublin/consensus-currencies-in-digital-currency-trading-platforms-723b777f4e01?source=rss-a5434c424cb4------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/723b777f4e01</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[crypto-exchange]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[proof-of-stake]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[proof-of-work]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[blockchain]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cryptocurrency]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Brian O'Beirne]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 07 Jul 2020 10:26:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-07-07T10:26:32.549Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>I published this article on my blog back in October, 2014. The idea was essentially that POS currencies were likely to exhibit greater liquidity than POW currencies. This view has arguably been vindicated by the fact that many blockchain projects have since switched over to POS protocols.</em></p><p>In this short article, I argue that digital currency exchanges should err in favor of including crypto currencies based on “decentralized consensus protocols” in their currency-trading platform. For the sake of brevity, I will refer to these crypto-currencies as “consensus-currencies” (e.g. Stellar, Ripple etc.). My primary argument is that it is, at least in principle, desirable for digital currencies to err in favor of the inclusion of consensus-currencies because they tend to be more liquid than their proof-of-work counterparts (such as Bitcoin and Litecoin), have faster transaction times, and ultimately lead to greater volume in the market. We must, however, keep in mind that this is an argument “in principle”; in other words, there might be other reasons that we might not want to include such consensus-currencies in a digital currency exchange platform. Before launching into this argument, some background.</p><p>The Blockchain is a secure, decentralized public ledger on which all Bitcoin transactions are recorded. Traditionally, transacting involved a trusted third-party overseeing a ledger and verifying the transactional history of the ledger. For example, a bank account is a ledger that is overseen by a third party, the bank, that is trusted not to alter the ledger in any way that is not authorized by the account-holder. If there were no trust, then there could be no confidence in the record of transactions. Trusting the bank thus amounts to “securing their ledger” and thereby makes transactions possible. The Blockchain is “decentralized” in the sense that you are not trusting one “central” third party to secure the ledger, you are, instead, relying on the nodes of the network to secure the ledger. Hence the Blockchain is often described as “trustless” (perhaps “distributed trust” would be better).</p><p>How is the Blockchain secured? Generally speaking, there are three different ideas about how to secure a network: voting, proof of work and proof of stake. The goal of each of these methods is to make it too costly or difficult for nefarious actors to change or fabricate the transaction history of the network, i.e., the ledger. The Blockchain relies on the proof-of-work method to secure the ledger. This works as follows: Individual transactions, when completed, are broadcast to the nodes on the peer-to-peer Bitcoin network. The nodes (which are either individual miners or pools of miners) then collate these transactions into transaction blocks (effectively, “pages” in the Blockchain ledger). They do this by hashing pairs of transactions (i.e. applying the SHA-256 algorithm to the pairs) to obtain a digest — this is a unique identifying number associated with these transactions. Pairs of digests are likewise hashed. This is carried out until the node has encoded all of the transactions it has received (this yields the data structure known as the “Merkle Tree”) and then has a hash that is a representative identifier of all of the transaction history. A challenge that is derived from this hash then must be solved using the hash function. The solution is called the “proof of work”.</p><p>The challenge is essentially to guess a number with a prefix containing a variable number of zeroes. The guesswork is random, meaning that as the number of zeroes increases, the likelihood of guessing it decreases. The difficulty of the challenge is proportional to the number of miners operating on the network and adjusted so that one block is mined around every ten minutes. The “hash rate” is the number of guesses possible per second. Miners use specially designed hardware (application-specific integrated circuits) to engaged in this guesswork (“mine blocks”) and are rewarded with some bitcoin (typically 25 BTC known as the “coinbase”) and transaction fees for their efforts.</p><p>In sum, the “hash rate” equates to raw computing power. And although it is often Bitcoin is often described as “decentralized”, the implication to be drawn here is that Bitcoin (and other similar proof-of-work currencies) is susceptible to centralization. As of the time of writing, the total mining power of the Bitcoin network has been condensed into the hands of about 6/7 mining pools. Recently, the number of nodes in the United States has dropped from 25,000 to 7,000, and there has been a correlative increase in the number of nodes mining in Asia (particularly Mongolia). Whoever accumulates the most computing power at the least cost may acquire the most bitcoin. This is “economies of scale” in operation. And the upshot is that there will be a bifurcation in the bitcoin marketplace, where fewer and fewer people increasingly acquire more and more bitcoin (through mining, that is. Obviously, bitcoin may still be acquired through other means.)</p><p>This proof-of-work method of securing the network also has a large cost associated with it. In fact, as Daniel Larimer argues in the Bitshares X whitepaper, the Bitcoin network is actually operating at a loss of well over $1 Billion USD per year. It also is a time-intensive procedure, making the verification of transactions slower. What does this mean for currency exchanges?</p><p>In short, crypto-currencies that rely on proof-of-work are, in principle, more illiquid than their consensus counterparts: centralization means fewer economic actors, fewer actors means fewer transactions, and fewer transactions means a more erratic spread. This makes the market more volatile and the price of all holdings is driven down by actors’ attempts to overcome this illiquidity. This is deadweight loss/allocative inefficiency. This also cuts against the “same-side network effect”, such that fewer actors possessing the currency in question makes fewer actors seek it as a store of value (we might tentatively point to the slow consumer adoption of bitcoin as evidence to this effect). The proof-of-work method for securing the network thus proves to be, in some respects, an inefficient encumbrance, and, to boot, one that has its source code hard coded into the Blockchain, meaning that it cannot easily be changed anytime soon.</p><p>None of this is an indictment of Bitcoin as a store of value; it is simply a note of caution. Exchanges should diversify, if at all possible, into currencies that do not run up against these same problems. The recent integration of Stellar into a number of digital currency exchanges is thus, on this analysis, a welcome innovation. Likewise, the central role that Ripple has on the some platforms bodes well in this regard. The Ripple and Stellar networks are far more energy efficient, being that they do not rely on the proof of work protocol, and thus avoid much of the deadweight loss mentioned above. Digital currency exchanges would do well to bear all of this in mind.</p><p>My twitter: <a href="https://twitter.com/BrianOBeirne1">https://twitter.com/BrianOBeirne1</a></p><p>Original blog post: <em>(</em><a href="https://brianfromdublin.wordpress.com/tag/brian-obeirne/"><em>https://brianfromdublin.wordpress.com/tag/brian-obeirne/</em></a><em>)</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=723b777f4e01" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>