<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by British Council Creative Economy on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by British Council Creative Economy on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@britishcouncilcreativeeconomy?source=rss-c19e5d3f505e------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Mon, 16 Nov 2026 18:16:54 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@britishcouncilcreativeeconomy/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Informality in the Audiovisual Sector]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/informal-economy-in-the-global-south/informality-in-the-audiovisual-sector-d36f4ab1c528?source=rss-c19e5d3f505e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d36f4ab1c528</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[British Council Creative Economy]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 11 Oct 2021 09:11:18 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-10-11T09:11:18.157Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Final Report</strong></p><p>Diana Rey, Ph.D.<br>Independent Consultant</p><p>This project is undertaken by the PEC International Council and supported by the British Council. The PEC International Council is a network of leading policy and creative economy practitioners from across the world. The group is convened by The British Council and is an international advisory body to the Creative Industries Policy and Evidence Centre (PEC), which is led by Nesta.</p><p><strong>Acknowledgement</strong></p><p>This research has been supported by Scriptwriters and Screenwriters community and Tingo Agency. Scriptwriters and Screenwriters community brings together amateur writers and professional Spanish-speaking screenwriters, this is promoted by artist David Esteban Cubero.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*w2IYxWP3rJvH8FTSr3EXJg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Tingo Agency is a digital marketing agency based on Montreal, Canada. They were responsible for the animation and edition of the video.</p><p><strong>I. The Project Overview</strong></p><p>Over the last decade, from 2010–2020, the audiovisual industry in Latin America has made important contributions to the economy. Despite this, few studies have been carried out to understand the workings of the informal economy within the audiovisual sector value chain, and less so when it concerns issues relating to the working conditions of one of the key actors in the industry: script writers.</p><p>To better understand the position of scriptwriters in the sector and how they are represented and treated in terms of their employment rights, a detailed survey was conducted interviewing scriptwriters directly and finding out how they view themselves within this informal economy. A total of 74 scriptwriters were approached during the survey, all of whom were selected from a large network of scriptwriters and other participants coming from various social media communities in countries including Argentina, Colombia, and Mexico.</p><p>The key results of the survey are presented in the video titled “Informality in the Audiovisual Sector” which illustrates the extent of the obstacles facing scriptwriters in terms of trying to get regular work and often having to moonlight to sustain themselves.</p><p>It was picked up that the various challenges faced by scriptwriters would change according to the geographical region within which they were based. The survey also provided an opportunity for female scriptwriters to share their experiences unique to them due to the ongoing gender biases and discriminations that take place within the sector.</p><p><strong>II. Research findings/Conclusions</strong></p><p>The survey was able to identify four profiles based on the schemes linked to other types of work and the time dedicated to their creative activity. Script writers, whose sole profession is scriptwriting and don’t rely on any other form of income, represented 21% of those surveyed. Scriptwriters, whose principal profession is creating audiovisual content, but who have another job to cover their costs, represented 22%. Professionals whose second job is to work as scriptwriters. They make up the group who, for the most part, are involved in employment in another sector of the economy and their creative work serves as additional income. This was the largest group representing 39.5% of those surveyed. Lastly, 17 % of those interviewed considered themselves amateurs. This means that they are currently studying or receiving formal training on audiovisual content creation so do not receive any earnings out of this work.</p><p>By analysing these four profiles, problems were encountered which appear to be characteristic of the informal employment environment of the scriptwriters: moonlighting, underemployment and employment instability are equally present issues between those scriptwriters with a second job or with other professionals who scriptwrite as their second job. This is why survey results were analysed between full time scriptwriters and script writers with other jobs.</p><p>In terms of age, it was found that 80% of the full-time script writers are between the ages of 32 and 50 years old. This is where we picked up interesting data: no person in this category was under the age of 32. Amongst those scriptwriters doing other work, the percentage in the age group of 30 to 50 years old, was lower at 59%. Women represent a significantly higher percentage amongst full</p><p>time script writers at 40% in comparison to the 18% who are doing it with an additional job.</p><p>Looking beyond the socio-demographic data, the survey revealed that only 33% of full time script writers are working on agreed contracts with producers or TV channels. 54% of them have had to alternate their jobs shifting from formal to informal working conditions. And 13% of them have always been employed or worked informally. The percentage of informal employment is higher for professional script writers who have had to resort to getting additional work. 53% of them have felt obliged to always work within informal conditions or agreements. The remainder have had to alternate between contracts, become freelancers or receive cash in hand.</p><p>The instability of these professionals has direct consequences on schemes linked to social protection. 60% of full-time scriptwriters today do not have access to health care and pensions schemes. And although this percentage drops to 55% among those with two jobs, their testimonies demonstrate the high degree of uncertainty and social risk they also face. For instance, 33% of those with two jobs openly admitted to not knowing how they were going to live when they retire. 11% of them responded that they are saving for their retirement and the remainder commented that they had no other option but to keep on working.</p><p>The survey also revealed the conditions of moonlighting and underemployment faced by other key players in the creation of audiovisual content. It is no coincidence that moonlighting is a common practice for 61.5% of those interviewed. Of these, 36% have two jobs in the creative sector and 10% are working in another job in the education sector, either as university teachers or secondary school teachers. Multiple employment is linked to another major issue: underemployment. Script writers,</p><p>despite being very qualified, often have to resort to carrying out menial and low-skilled activities for which they are overqualified.</p><p>The informal conditions of Latin American script writers are not exclusive to those who are freelance or paid cash in hand. All writers, despite some having signed formal contracts with producers or local channels, therefore working in formal employment, are having issues usually linked to working in an informal environment.</p><p>The survey also presented an opportunity to have an insight on the situation of the women working in this sector. The most worrying result is that 78% of those interviewed have felt discriminated against at some point in their career. 48% of women have one or more jobs. A total of 52% don’t have access to healthcare and pensions, and 33% have always worked in informal employment.</p><p>Several of the women interviewed elaborated on the types of discrimination they had faced. For example, they highlighted the existence of macho practices at news desks and on film sets, which translates as the constant delegitimization of their knowledge, as well as limiting their access to the same opportunities as their male colleagues. Another striking anecdote was that of Mexican interviewees who expressed their frustration over the fact that producers often expect female scriptwriters to represent the female voice only or to limit themselves to telling love stories in audiovisual production.</p><p><strong><em>Reflections on the rights of the author</em></strong></p><p>Latin America applies the rights of the author on the intellectual property rights which originated in France. Unlike the most understood form of copyrighting, used predominantly to protect the rights of producers, broadcasters, distribution companies and publishers, intellectual property rights pertains specifically to the rights of creators; and therefore, in the case of audiovisual creations, to scriptwriters.</p><p>As such, all scripts generated in Latin America must have a designated person known as the holder of moral rights, someone who has the power to transfer all or some of his or her economic rights to a third party. Despite this regulation, the survey revealed the ongoing problems related to the effective enforcement of intellectual property and remuneration rights.</p><p>For instance, 83% of the scriptwriters with two jobs stated that they had had, at least once during their professional life, problems with insufficient payment of their royalties. This critical situation is even more adverse for full time working scriptwriters. 94% have had a conflict at least once because they were not paid royalties or were paid less than what had been agreed.</p><p>When observing specific cases, several scriptwriters explained that, even though they had signed contracts with channels and production companies, they never received the agreed contractual remuneration because these companies decided to push for a unilateral termination of the contracts. Others talked about the violation of their intellectual property rights during the development of the scriptwriting process where several authors are involved and, at the end of the process, the ownership of the work is given to the most senior scriptwriters.</p><p>In addition to the issues mentioned above, one cannot ignore the fact that given the incipient level of development of the audiovisual market in most countries in the region, royalty payments received by scriptwriters are limited to the amounts received through contracts with production companies and channels. This is the case for two reasons. First of all, unlike musical productions, after the initial presentation of audiovisual works at the cinema or broadcasted on television, the likelihood of production rebroadcasting again is very low, therefore royalty payments for the right of communication to the public are insignificant (with the exception of soap operas). Secondly, in several countries in the region, collective management societies continue to be in the process of consolidation and scriptwriters are not linked to these structures, which makes it even more difficult for these authors to gain access to the royalties generated by their work outside their residential countries.</p><p>In fact, only 25% of the total interviewed admitted that they are part of the collective management societies.</p><p><strong>III. Suggested areas for further research</strong></p><p>• It would be highly recommendable to continue researching the impact of COVID-19 on increasing the levels of underemployment and moonlighting activities for scriptwriters. This could include examples of how, in light of the above, professional and trainee script writers have had to engage in activities completely unrelated to the creative sector to assess how this trend might affect the overall development of the region’s audiovisual industry in the short and medium term.</p><p>• With the rise digital transformation, relationships between local and international producers and script writers are becoming increasingly complex. Local studies produced on this issue in Mexico, Argentina or Colombia could provide an analysis on the challenges of Latin American script writers face regarding the emergence of large content distribution platforms (such as Netflix and Amazon) versus the proposals of the platforms and production companies to promote the formal economy in the audiovisual’s value chain.</p><p>• Equally important is exploring further the gender inequalities existing in the development of the audiovisual content creation, to highlight income disparities and the various forms of discrimination faced by women working in this creative sector. The results of this research would be key in establishing public policy recommendations that promote the visibility and empowerment of women in the audiovisual sector.</p><p><strong>IV. Highlight particular links to policy</strong></p><p>The survey also demonstrated the strong tie between the extent to which the audiovisual industry is developed through its existing policies versus the problematic working conditions of scriptwriters. After going through the various testimonies provided in the survey, it was possible to categorise the</p><p>countries in that geographical region into two different categories based on how developed their audiovisual sectors are.</p><p>Category one includes countries which already have a growing audiovisual sector such as Mexico, Argentina, Colombia and Chile. Category two includes countries with an audiovisual industry which is at its initial stages such as Venezuela, the Dominican Republic, Ecuador, Cuba, Peru and Uruguay.</p><p>Among the problems highlighted by interviewees in the first category, were the difficulties which reside in the concentration of the market where few players currently exist. Some of the problems underlined by the script writers were the monopoly, abuse of dominant positions and standardised contracts which are commonplace in the market.</p><p>In countries with a smaller market, the interviewees emphasised the non-existence or scarce regulation of activity on behalf of the state and a lack of recognition on what scriptwriters bring to the creative industry was the main issue.</p><p>For both groups of countries, working relationships tend to be disproportionate and with little equilibrium existing between the work produced, its value and the time it takes to produce it.</p><p>The problems raised by the interviewees should be considered as a key to addressing and/or leading to a push to strengthen existing public policies in the audiovisual sector.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d36f4ab1c528" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/informal-economy-in-the-global-south/informality-in-the-audiovisual-sector-d36f4ab1c528">Informality in the Audiovisual Sector</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/informal-economy-in-the-global-south">The Relationship between the Informal Economy and the Cultural Economy in the Global South</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Investigating informality in the financing of culture and creative businesses in Kenya: A Case…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/informal-economy-in-the-global-south/investigating-informality-in-the-financing-of-culture-and-creative-businesses-in-kenya-a-case-3286aa072515?source=rss-c19e5d3f505e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3286aa072515</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[British Council Creative Economy]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 14 Jul 2021 07:21:39 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-08-04T12:54:54.466Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>Investigating informality in the financing of culture and creative businesses in Kenya: A Case Study of the Uhuru Textiles Market in Nairobi.</strong></h3><p>Contributors: George Gachara, George Aloo Karanja, Wakiuru Njuguna, Nehemiah Kabugi</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*NsArdupsGrQf6n31ql_lYA.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Section one</h3><p><strong>Case Description</strong>: This paper seeks to understand the nature of financing in the informal sector with a focus on Uhuru Market, an informal market ecosystem in Nairobi.<br><strong>Geographic area of research: </strong>Kenya.<br><strong>Cultural economy sector focus: </strong>Fashion (textile production).</p><p><strong>Methodology for the investigation<br></strong>Desk research of a report generated from a study conducted in 2019 and 2020 at Uhuru Market by HEVA to better understand the financial, infrastructure and governance needs of the traders of the market. A sample size of 220 traders was developed following a process of stratified sampling. Focus group discussions were held to elaborate on the findings of the main study. For the purposes of this report, additional online desk research was conducted to contextualise the findings of the Uhuru Market Report.</p><h3>Introduction</h3><p>Many business commentators and reputable business writers of major business publications often describe informal businesses in the global south, Asia, Latin America and Africa only through the lenses of informality, a concept which has not only become monolithic but the definitive characteristic of businesses in our side of the world.</p><p>In these presentations, among the amiable commentators’ informality is seen as either a euphemism for unregulated businesses which are usually run by people unemployed in the formal sector of the economy, with low specialisation, low capitalization, low productivity, and with few protections on one hand, and unethical and illegal businesses which operate “ under the radar,” always “circumventing the law through loopholes” promoting “chaotic business environments with open secrets, unwritten rules and hidden practices of getting things done.”</p><p>From this vantage point, formalisation is the panacea — that informal businesses van only be motivated by nefarious ends such as tax dodging, rather than enlightened and legitimate business strategy consisting of a cost-benefit evaluation, the difficulty, corruption and inefficiency in formalizing and the harsh time penalty on small ventures.</p><p>These sets of assumptions crystalize into a mainstream suspicion towards informal businesses thereby limiting their interest in investigating and developing prototypes which would help build the necessary understanding and with it, introduce transparency which is critical to the underwriting responsive public policies, encourage investment and growth.</p><p>In this paper, through a case study approach on the Uhuru textiles market in Nairobi, we have attempted to dissuade ourselves from any fixed notions on informality and informal business conditions through asking numerous questions, addressing these questions with a degree of courageous honesty as well as in allowing the insights from this inquiry to confront and testing our assumptions.</p><h3>What does informality look like?</h3><p>Without falling into the self-indulging business school bias that we often and easily resort to — the unthinking transfer and application of western economic epistemic models, it is important to remember to consider the cultural context of businesses in the many global south societies. In Kenya, as in most African societies, informality has been and remains ubiquitous to all human activities and formal engagements are only recently introduced alongside formal governments, religion, schooling and a regulated private sector.</p><p><em>According to Ananya Roy in her publication Slumdog Cities: Rethinking Subaltern Urbanism, informality is ‘the overlapping and intersecting relations between authorised and unauthorised, or between regulated and unregulated activities.’</em></p><p>This paper seems to favor <em>Ananya Roy</em>’s articulation as far as it attempts to acknowledge the complexity of the relations, the range of permissions and impact of location as far as informality is concerned.</p><p>According to the World Bank (January 2016), informal businesses (the Jua Kali sector) make up 95% of all enterprises in Kenya, while contributing 87.2% of all employment according to the Kenya National Bureau of Statistics (2014). This is indicative of the pervasiveness of informality in Kenya and indeed, in most African countries. If the implications of these statistics were to be truly considered, then, the question of informality would not be viewed as a fringe market condition but as the dominant economic epistemology.</p><p><strong>Why Uhuru Market?<br></strong>Since our inception, we recognized the tremendous opportunity for wealth, jobs and dignity in the textiles sector in Kenya. We also accepted that most of the businesses remained small and in their early stage of growth as a result of numerous constraints including competitiveness issues driven by expensive imported fabrics and inputs, as well as shrinking domestic market as a result of the second-hand clothes dumping by western countries.</p><p>After many years of investing in local private fashion brands, it was time to move out of our comfort zone and lead an inquiry into the micro and small garments venture which serve the domestic market and which form a majority of businesses in the sector.</p><p><strong>Complexity of the industry<br></strong>From our vantage point, it was clear that informality was not a uniform experience and that it was important to inquire and build understanding on layers and intersections that constitute the specific type of informality in our sector.</p><p>It is our assumption that informality is caused and sustained by the low level of market sophistication which is symptomatic of low investment appetite leaving the practitioner to remain at the early stage business growth level for a longtime.</p><p>It is also our assumption that low consumer demand as a result of price distortion due to the damping of cheap second-hand clothing from developed nations, on the one hand and on the other, the high cost of inefficiencies which has a negative impact on the competitiveness of the products — limited fabric sourcing, high costs of labor, limited design offering, high costs of production, etc., in the value-chain.</p><p><strong>High cost of formalisation<br></strong>Without a graduated or disaggregated approach to formalization by level of business growth, most early-stage businesses in the textiles sector cannot justify the cost of formalization — which translates to reduction of capital available for business activities, negative impact on set up time, and limited benefits from the investment.</p><p>It is common for a small business to be required to undertake business registration as a limited liability company or a sole proprietorship at the company registry which is a costly endeavor, it exposes the business to additional recurrent expenses for statutory filings and delays set up as it takes more than a month.</p><p>Additionally, this registration comes with statutory tax registration requirements, along with a costly investment in a digital tax register infrastructure, as well as the registration of each employee to the public pension and medical schemes.</p><p>Subsequently, and before setting up the business must buy an annual city license, along with the fire license, as well as the national bureau of standards license for each product line.</p><p>All these are the requirements before operations. A whole set of requirements — legal fillings, contracts, accounting, insurance, etc., continue to increase the cost of doing business and impact on profitability.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*c1iD3wNBT_gdud0bK1gu1w.jpeg" /><figcaption>Trader stall in Uhuru Market</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Demographics<br></strong>According to the World Bank in their report on Gender Equality and Development (2012), 76% of informal businesses are female owned, who at the same time suffer the penalty / burden of care work for their families, as well as facing unequal treatment by markets and institutions.</p><p>It is true that most women are unable to access formal credit due to low access to fixed assets which can be mobilised as security, often resorting to informal lending — which can be limited to own savings or exploitative in its cost.</p><p>It is also true that women often accumulate capital at a slower rate than the men in the same trade, due to the time penalty they have to endure in order to take care of their families and young children.</p><p>These are additional factors that contribute, reinforce and sustain the state of informality in the textiles industry, even for businesses that would like to adopt a level of formalization.</p><h3>Findings: What did we discover in our inquiry?</h3><p>Access to finance remains an important consideration for a majority small and medium businesses and especially those in the creative industries. A majority of businesses in the culture and creative industry are often capitalized by their owners through personal savings, loans from family and leveraging personal assets for informal debt.</p><p>In order for these businesses to take advantage of new business opportunities, they often require additional capital for operations — especially during peak business seasons, as well as to finance growth — new market entry, new product development, machinery, supplies etc. Some businesses with a certain level of formalization can access short term debt but many resorts to retained earnings and informal debt to finance growth. It is clear that without additional capital most of the businesses remain at the precarious early stage.</p><p>Limited enterprise growth (Göttingen, 2013) is a factor of “market forces, social-political factors” but most importantly “finance availability.” As a result of limited possibilities to upgrade operations and scale their productive activities, informal enterprises are unable to improve the returns, and to support overall growth.</p><p>In order to finance their day-to-day operational costs as well as their growth, traders at Uhuru Market have developed the following solutions:</p><p><strong>1. Traders Savings and Credit Cooperative:<br></strong>The traders cooperative is registered by Sacco Societies Regulatory Authority has a membership of 250 traders at Uhuru Market out of the total of about 1,000 traders (25%) at the market.</p><p>The cooperative has an open membership recruitment process and offers numerous benefits to members loans at favourable interest rates, flexible payment periods and are able to meet larger loans relative to members own savings and contributions.</p><p>The members of this cooperative also collectively own assets such as business equipment for lease, and land.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*46N93J8YiOvT9UzMj_FYHQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Trader Health Registration</figcaption></figure><ul><li>This cooperative is a formal financing mechanism in a cooperative model. It is both registered and is regulated.</li><li>To access credit one has to be a member, having saved consistently for 6 months and can only access credit up to 3 times their savings.</li></ul><p><strong>Informal Savings and Credit Groups (Merry go round)<br></strong>Merry go rounds are informal savings and lending groups composed of individual traders / members ranging from 10–20 individuals. These groups form their own savings and lending rules.</p><p>Often, the members are required to save a fixed amount on a daily, weekly or monthly basis. The collected contributions are then either handed out to members as loans with favourable interest rates or revolving grants to each member, without the obligation to pay back.</p><p>The most common practice is the lump sum grant given out to each member at a time, on a rotational basis, on a monthly basis. This approach does not build the capital and does not leverage members’ contributions over time. This mechanism is able to meet the one time, short term financing needs of the members but has a limitation in its capacity due to size of savings and the number of members, as well as how long it takes before a member can be eligible for another grant.</p><p><strong>Notes</strong></p><ul><li>This informal mechanism suffered the limitations of informality as it is dependent on the members’ own social relationships.</li><li>The reliance on social contracts and trust made it easy to access financing but the limitation of the mechanism cannot deliver the benefits of scale, leverage and business integration.</li></ul><p><strong>Mobile Loans<br></strong>Mobile lending digital applications on mobile phones have become an easy source of credit for Kenyans who don’t have accounts with banks and other traditional financial institutions, or the regular income needed to borrow from such establishments.</p><p>According to the Central Bank of Kenya in the report in Financial Access (2019) financial inclusion in Kenya rose from 26.7% in 2006 to 82.9% in 2019 in Kenya, driven largely by the growth of mobile money. According to a digital credit report (FSD 2019) established that 13.6% of Kenyans had borrowed loans from a digital lender, citing their convenience and ease of access.</p><p>At Uhuru Market, 8% of the traders had reported using mobile loans as a source of business and personal finance. Most prefer this source of credit as it provides instant cash — short turnaround time from application to disbursement, often with no requirement to collateralize the facility.</p><p><strong>Note</strong></p><ul><li>These platforms offer the most expensive loans in the market by charging as high as 400% per annum interest rates. This has led to high indebtedness among the users of these platforms.</li></ul><h3><strong>Social political factors affecting access to finance?</strong></h3><p>Since the cooperative model was the favorite and seemed more responsive to the traders in this ecosystem, we sort to investigate which other factors common to the market cluster as a result of their unique financing mechanism:</p><p><strong>1. Social-cultural factors<br></strong>A cooperative movement is a member driven institution which has high returns on the ownership and agency of its members. Similarly, because of these characteristics the cooperative can be vulnerable to numerous perception issues including but not limited to exclusiveness — in this case the main institution is seen by some as being exclusive along tribe, gender and age lines, which limits its appeal to potential members.</p><p><strong>2. Political challenges<br></strong>Since the leadership of the cooperative have been the same group of people who are accused of non-inclusion, along with a lack of effort to change this perception through regular elections, there is general apprehension towards this institution causing many traders to join other cooperatives outside the market. This has a negative impact on the growth of the capital pool for the cooperative.</p><h3><strong>What can be done to improve the prospects of this cooperative model?</strong></h3><p>1. Rebuilding trust, expanding membership and better communication by those in leadership to their members and we as non-members.</p><p>2. Development of competitive financial products to leverage on the understanding of the business cycles at the market as well as to leverage the existing business relationships.</p><p>3. Developing innovative products that can be accessed in groups, to benefit the ‘merry-go-round schemes and collect their savings, increase their pool of resources and leverage their savings for the cooperatives.</p><p>4. Increase efficiency by adopting digital practices and due-diligence for lending to reduce defaults and therefore pass on the efficiency gains to the members.</p><p>5. Leverage formal relationships to increase the available pool of capital available for lending activity to the traders, so that there is enough financing to meet the business needs during peak seasons (school uniform season, holiday season etc.).</p><h3><strong>Acknowledgements</strong></h3><p>HEVA would like to thank The British Council and PEC. This project is undertaken by the PEC International Council and supported by the British Council. The PEC International Council is a network of leading policy and creative economy practitioners from across the world. The group is convened by The British Council and is an international advisory body to the Creative Industries Policy and Evidence Centre (PEC), which is led by Nesta.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3286aa072515" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/informal-economy-in-the-global-south/investigating-informality-in-the-financing-of-culture-and-creative-businesses-in-kenya-a-case-3286aa072515">Investigating informality in the financing of culture and creative businesses in Kenya: A Case…</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/informal-economy-in-the-global-south">The Relationship between the Informal Economy and the Cultural Economy in the Global South</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic on female groups working in the Peruvian and Chilean informal…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/informal-economy-in-the-global-south/the-impacts-of-the-covid-19-pandemic-on-female-groups-working-in-the-peruvian-and-chilean-informal-4fcb91ef3ddc?source=rss-c19e5d3f505e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4fcb91ef3ddc</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[British Council Creative Economy]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 14 Jul 2021 07:21:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-08-04T12:58:48.646Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>The impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic on female groups working in the Peruvian and Chilean informal tourism economy</strong></h3><p>By Dr. Rosa Codina and Dr Daniela Moreno Alarcon<br>Revised and edited by Dr Claire Bunyan</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*QDTUglKFsJB5TDiW" /><figcaption><em>Credit: Rosa Codina, author, © all rights reserved</em></figcaption></figure><h3>Executive summary</h3><p>This report examines the impacts of COVID-19 on women working in the Peruvian and Chilean informal tourism industries, and related sectors. The aim of this study was to obtain an understanding of the nature and scope of the informal tourism economy in Peru and Chile, and to examine the experience of women working in the sector, with a particular emphasis on their experience of the pandemic.</p><p>The results of semi-structured interviews revealed that one of the key motivations for women’s employment in the informal tourism industry, was the degree of time flexibility offered by the sector. For some women in Peru, the informal economy had offered a way into full-time employment, whilst for women from lesser-known tourism destinations, their participation in the sector was mostly on a part-time basis and conditional on male approval.</p><p>In Chile, tourism was seen as a complementary activity to the subsistence economy that most women perform in rural areas. Tourism was also seen as a platform through which to disseminate Indigenous culture. In both Peru and Chile, one of the key barriers to formalisation was related to complex bureaucratic processes and associated costs. In Chile, most women working in the informal economy, especially Indigenous women, could not meet the required standards needed to accomplish formal certification since these did not align with Indigenous socio-cultural conditions.</p><p>In Peru and Chile, the pandemic abruptly stopped women’s main source of revenue. Most interviewed Peruvian women used the transferable skills acquired through work in the informal tourism sector to create alternative entrepreneurial opportunities, albeit earning reduced incomes. One of the main impacts for women living in rural Peru and Chile was the inability to attend artisanal trade fairs, which severely restricted their ability to sell and connect with other artisans. In both Peru and Chile, there was a stark lack of state support directed at women and the informal sector. Most state aid and funding schemes in both countries had been exclusively aimed at formal actors, whilst limited interventions had been developed for the tourism sector. There was scarce evidence of gender-sensitive policies and programmes designed to alleviate the challenges women were experiencing during the pandemic. This was also linked to a lack of sex-disaggregated data for the tourism sector.</p><p>Results of this study indicate a need for increased flexibility in the conditions to be met for formalisation. Tailor-made fiscal mechanisms for informal tourism actors are needed, whilst sex-disaggregated data on the nature of female employment in tourism and the informal sector is also necessary. In the long-term, gender equality should be integrated at all levels and phases of tourism development, particularly when designing and implementing any sort of tourism measure or policy.</p><h3><strong>Introduction</strong></h3><p><strong>1.1 Study aim and objectives<br></strong>Tourism is firmly positioned in the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development (UNWTO, 2019) and has been identified by the United Nations General Assembly as a significant contributor to sustainable development (United Nations, 2012). Its importance as a driver for job creation, the promotion of local economic development, gender equality and more inclusive and peaceful societies is reflected in all the UN’s Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) (Moreno, 2016; Moreno and Cole, 2019; UNWTO, 2019).</p><p>Nevertheless, according to the ILO (2001), work performance by women in tourism is dominated by high levels of informality, high staff turnover, long working hours, subcontracting, the prevalence of casual workers, and seasonal variations in employment. This implies that a greater number of women working in tourism are performing their jobs under unstable working conditions (Moreno and Cañada, 2018), reinforcing marginalisation across the occupational pyramid of tourism.</p><p>The social and economic crisis brought on by the COVID-19 pandemic has further evidenced structural inequalities related to race, gender, and age within tourism economies. Women have been disproportionately disadvantaged by the pandemic due to taking on a greater share of unpaid domestic and caring work, as well as losing jobs at a faster rate than men due to taking on more casual jobs (Cole, 2020). This has been particularly the case for women working within the informal tourism sector in Less Economically Developed Countries of the Global South (Odeku, 2020). In Latin American and Caribbean countries (LAC), where a feminisation of the tourism workforce occurs, the socio-economic impact of the pandemic has been particularly severe for women (Moreno, 2020).</p><p>Given the detrimental impacts of the pandemic on the global tourism industry and the disproportionate effect on female populations in the Global South, this study aims to examine how this crisis has affected women working in the informal tourism industries of Peru and Chile.</p><p>Based on this aim, the following objectives were established:</p><ol><li>Identify the underlying motivations and barriers for women’s participation in the informal tourism sector and the perceived benefits of staying in the informal sector</li><li>Establish an understanding of the links between the formal and informal tourism sectors</li><li>Critically assess the ways in which the pandemic has impacted the livelihoods of women working in the informal tourism sector in Peru and Chile</li><li>Evaluate how the impacts of the pandemic have affected the achievement of the UN’s sustainable development goals 1, 5 and 16 in relation to the informal tourism economy</li><li>Identify and evaluate state aid interventions during the pandemic, and the extent to which females working in the informal tourism sector have been able to access this help</li><li>Provide recommendations for the development of policies, best practices, and strategies to integrate the informal tourism sector into wider economic social and cultural policy making.</li></ol><p>The ILO definition of the informal economy (2002) excludes criminal activities such as the production and distribution of services and goods prohibited by law. According to the ILO (2002), informal actors produce and distribute legal goods and services, albeit their production and employment procedures remain unregistered, and may not adhere to legal norms.</p><p>In line with this definition, this study considers only legitimate activities encompassed within informal institutional boundaries as informal tourism economic phenomena. Therefore, this study does not consider any illegitimate and criminal activities which are “antisocial in intent” (De Soto, 2002, p.11) such as human trafficking, drug dealing, or illegal wildlife trade amongst others.</p><p><strong>1.2 Tourism and the informal economy<br></strong>The informal economy is a complex phenomenon which has attracted scholarly attention from diverse disciplines such as anthropology, sociology, economy and tourism studies (Çakmak et al, 2018; Williams, 2017). Whilst different fields of study and approaches have resulted in a range of definitions to describe the features of the informal sector (Çakmak et al, 2019; ILO, 2002), a set of common defining characteristics have been identified. These include the presence of unregulated trade, easy market entry and low levels of capital investment (Kermath and Thomas, 1992; Mead and Morrison, 1996; Williams, 2017). The International Labour Office (ILO, 2000, p.1) further notes of its members that “they are not captured in official statistical enumeration…and…evade government regulations; they are also, almost inevitably beyond formal systems of labour and social protection”.</p><p>In some destinations such as Peru and Indonesia, informal actors provide important tourism services (i.e., street vendors selling food, souvenirs, transportation, guiding services) and add to the appeal of a destination by selling products or services unique to the place, such as in the case of market vendors or individuals who pose for tourist photographs (Codina et al, 2020; Kermath and Thomas, 1992). Informal actors not only help build the unique character of some destinations by boosting vibrancy and novelty (for instance rickshaw drivers in Asia), but the income from their activities can significantly benefit formal and informal economies (Ketchen et al, 2014; Slocum et al, 2011).</p><p>Informality is a crucial phenomenon in the daily lives of people in the Global South (Çakmak and Cenesiz, 2020), where the informal and formal economies are dynamically linked to each other through production and distribution relations (such as sub-contracting arrangements) (Çakmak and Cenesiz, 2020). The distinction between formal and informal economic practices is further blurred in urban tourism spaces where informal actors routinely share spaces with formal actors and visitors. For instance, in Truong et al’s (2020) study of rickshaw drivers in Hanoi, the authors uncovered that many unregistered rickshaw drivers were sometimes hired by registered rickshaw companies, and similarly registered drivers also attracted tourists on their own outside of company work hours. Their findings confirm the results of earlier studies and suggests a dynamic shift between the informal and formal sectors rather than dualistically opposed segments (Truong et al, 2020; Chen, 2006).</p><p>Although informal economy issues in tourism have been progressively examined in more recent literature, existing research remains modest (Lv, 2020; Williams, 2020). The majority of tourism literature concentrates on the formal tourism economy, with limited studies examining the impacts of policies and crises on informal tourism actors (Rogerson, 2014). Similarly, national governments tend to prioritise the formal sector in policies and development efforts directed towards the tourism industry; with fewer financial and legal actions being offered to informal enterprises (Çakmak et al, 2018; Robson et al, 2009). Common government responses to the informal tourism sector often include prohibition, criminalisation (Vargas, 2016) and licensing (formalisation) (Henderson and Smith, 2009; Dao Truong et al, 2020).</p><p>In the Global South, the marginalised nature of informal tourism enterprises and the neglect of planners to address their needs has been confirmed in several studies (Dahles, 1998; Dahles and Bras, 1999; Dahles, 2001; Dahles and Keune, 2002; Hampton, 2003; Rogerson, 2018). Much of this stems from the erroneous notion that the informal sector and its participants are a temporary phenomenon which will dissipate with economic development (Rogerson, 2018). This contradicts the most recent evidence which suggests that the informal tourism sector should be viewed as a central feature of tourism in Global South contexts, as opposed to a set of deviant activities which will evaporate with modernisation (Rogerson, 2018; Timothy and Wall, 1997). Whereas it may be argued that informal actors have limited access to common pool resources, they possess important resources, attributes, skills and qualities that could be more efficiently exploited to enable them to further contribute to broader economic development goals (ibid).</p><p>Although recent studies on pro-poor tourism have contributed to a greater understanding of the informal tourism sector, research remains limited in scope, particularly in relation to the conditions faced by women working in the informal tourism economy (Hutchings et al, 2020). Given this knowledge gap in the tourism scholarship and the crisis faced by women in the informal tourism sector due to the COVID-19 pandemic, there is a pressing need to examine the role of this stakeholder group in tourism alongside the structural conditions they face.</p><p><strong>1.3 The informal tourism economy from a gender perspective<br></strong>The tourism sector employs a higher share of share of men (63%) than women (58%) in the informal workforce (ILO, 2018). However, this is largely related to the fact that men are over-represented in the workforce (ILO, 2018). In low-income countries, 92% of women are employed in informal jobs compared to 87% of men, whilst in lower middle-income countries this figure stands at 83% of women employed informally and 85% of men. Informal employment encompasses different forms such as wage employment in informal establishments, households, self-employment, unpaid contributory family work, or informal wage employment in formal establishments (OECD and ILO, 2019). In all regions, women constitute the majority of those informally employed as an unpaid family contribution (ILO, 2017).</p><p>Women are highly represented in the most vulnerable employment categories of the informal workforce. As such, women working in the informal economy are more vulnerable to the lack of labour protection and have less control over their working conditions (ILO, 2018). Furthermore, informal workers on average are paid lower wages than formal workers, and women are paid lower wages than men (ibid).</p><p>Globally, more women than men work in the sector (ILO, 2016; UNWTO, 2019) and yet women’s employment in tourism remains poorly understood. Research demonstrates that employment in tourism does not necessarily equate to decent work, strong career prospects or equal wages for women (ILO, 2001). Women working in tourism are also performing their jobs under unstable working conditions (Moreno and Cañada, 2018), reinforcing factors of marginalisation across the occupational pyramid of tourism. The gender pay gap in tourism is 14.7% (UNWTO, 2019) even though the sector employs a majority of female workers. This figure is also problematic in that it does not account for women employed in the informal economy.</p><p>There is a clear need to examine informal employment in tourism through a gender lens, but there is no data available on the informal tourism sector for most countries (UNWTO, 2019). The reasons behind this gap are not clear, but it is likely related to the fact that most tourist institutions and agencies tend to work exclusively with the formal sector. Thus, although women and other marginalised groups are known to have greater participation in the informal tourism economy, their experiences remain invisible.</p><p>Women in the informal tourism workforce tend to work in accommodation, street vending and handicraft production, with roles typically mirroring or extending women’s domestic work (Cave and Kilic, 2010; Del Alonso-Almeida, 2012; Andersen, 2015). These roles may be considered more culturally acceptable in contexts where women generally do not work outside of the home and also permit some home-based working, for example where women open their traditional homes as guest houses or restaurants (Baum, 2013; Newpane, 2020). Whilst employment in general is regarded as empowering for women, the informal tourism economy roles performed by women entail some challenging consequences. Firstly, the phenomenon of the double workload, well-understood and recognised in women’s employment globally, is especially pertinent for women in the informal tourism economy. Women performing childcare and other caring or domestic duties on top of paid work where their workplace is also their home is difficult to manage, with several competing demands to be met (Hutchings et al, 2016). On balance, employment is still considered a net positive for women, providing them with agency to at least partially renegotiate entrenched asocial and gender norms (Duffy et al, 2015).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/739/0*o-lP3CdP1fgIRZ7y" /></figure><p>A further disadvantage lies in geography: women based in rural areas are likely to have fewer educational opportunities, compounded by a lack of reliable infrastructure compared to urban settings (Hutchings et al, 2020). In caste-based societies or other contexts where economic participation is affected by ethnic origin, women of particular ethnicities may find themselves excluded from formal arrangements but able to participate informally (Trupp and Sunata, 2017). This is particularly true of street vendors, who are ubiquitous in LAC and contribute to a destination’s appeal, with implications for the formal and informal economies (ILO, 2017). However, street vendors are subjected to police harassment, demands for bribes, street violence and similar forms of abuse; women workers specifically also face sexual harassment (UN Women, 2020). This group is also forced to contend with inadequate urban infrastructural conditions, such as lack of safe drinking water, toilets, shelter, and storage space (ILO, 2011; 2017), as well as inadequate childcare.</p><p>However, the intersection of gender and ethnicity is not always negative, and as such it is vital that any analysis is context-specific (Moreno and Cole, 2019). Considering the subject of female entrepreneurs in tourism without accounting for women working in the informal sector could encourage gender-harmful policymaking. Since women are more strongly disadvantaged by gender inequalities, they face major challenges when it comes to access to finance, technology, networking, tourist certifications, training and promotional support. The continued dearth of policy instruments designed to support women’s entrepreneurship and employment in the sector, including the formalisation of women’s labour , will likely lead to an expansion of informally employed women whose needs are poorly understood. This would also prove to be a net negative for tourism scholarship as a whole.</p><p><strong>1.4 Methodology<br></strong>This study adopted a qualitative design using in-depth semi-structured interviews. Interviews with male and female informal tourism workers, government stakeholders, and NGO actors took place virtually between the months of January and February 2021. Eight individuals were interviewed for the Peruvian case study and five participants for the Chilean case (see table 1.4 for further participant details).</p><p>In the Peruvian case two of the interviewed women were from the town of Pisac (Cusco region), which in contrast to the rest of rural localities mentioned in this study, is a well-known destination with a mature tourism industry. The town is known for its daily informal handicraft market, which is largely dominated by Mestiza female traders. Most of these women consider themselves artisans and handicraft makers, although they also sell externally produced goods. In the Peruvian case, all interviewed women working in the informal tourism sector were artisans and handicraft makers, as these represent a large part of the informal tourism labour force in rural areas. Throughout the study the words ‘artisan’, ‘informal trader’ and ‘handicraft maker’ are used to refer to these women. The Chilean case study comprises interviews with men and women working in the tourism sector in a variety of roles. All names have been changed to protect the identity of participants.</p><p>All interviews were conducted through digital media platforms and were digitally recorded Following the transcription process, thematic data analysis followed established procedures of familiarisation, reduction, and reordering (Braun and Clarke, 2006).</p><h3>2.0 Findings</h3><p><strong>2.1 Motivations and perceived benefits of informality<br></strong>One of the key motivations underlying Peruvian women’s employment in the informal tourism sector was the degree of time flexibility offered by the sector. This was especially important to them given that women in rural Peru are still expected to meet a greater share of domestic responsibilities than their male counterparts, even if working full time (Codina, 2018). The need for flexible working hours is partially linked to patriarchal socio-cultural expectations, which if not met, may lead to women being ostracised from their own communities (ibid).</p><p>Most interviewed Peruvian female informal workers emphasised being able to take care of their children and associated household responsibilities, such as cooking, as one of the main advantages of working in the informal tourism sector. In Pisac, women sell their products in an informal outdoor handicraft market during the daytime, so they are usually able to bring their children to work with them. The nature of the job also means that family members can take turns to tend stalls:</p><p><strong><em>Maria (female informal artisan)</em></strong><em>: I studied to be a schoolteacher, but I never practised my profession because I had to take care of my children. Then I had my youngest daughter, and so it became more profitable to work here (Pisac handicraft market), I could take care of my children, and it was more profitable than being a teacher, and it was better for my children…it gave me flexibility.</em></p><p><strong><em>Julieta (female artisan working in the informal tourism sector):</em></strong><em> Well, you’re free, right? You see how you use your time, and you have time for your children.</em></p><p>As mentioned by Maria, in the case of Pisac, one of the main motivations for women joining and staying in the informal tourism sector is related to the profit margin they can make in comparison to other professions or industries. It is not uncommon for Pisac women to have completed secondary education or University studies, but they often do not exercise their profession as the wages are lower than what they can make in the informal tourism sector. The profit margin combined with the flexible working conditions, and low-entry barriers offered by the informal tourism sector, made this an appealing option for Pisac women. Thus, in the case of Pisac, being part of the informal sector appears to be partially a choice for women, albeit a limited one since options to work in formal professions are restricted due to reduced financial compensation and the need to attend to domestic duties.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/858/0*Pv7pcFyRHVqT30zZ" /></figure><p>However, interviews revealed that this was not the case consistently in other parts of Peru where tourism is not an established industry. For Indigenous women in the San Martin and Amazon regions, participation in the informal tourism sector was largely related to a lack of formal education and little access to other employment opportunities as a result of structural inequalities (such as limited access to education, poverty, local patriarchal values and norms).</p><p>Similarly, women from less economically developed rural areas in the North of Peru appeared to participate in the informal tourism sector on a part-time basis, generally to supplement household income. These women also opted to sell handicrafts in the informal tourism market due to limited employment opportunities and low entry barriers. As noted by Daniel, most women working in the artisanal informal sector in the north of Peru do so as a part-time occupation:</p><p><strong><em>Daniel (Ministry of Culture official)</em></strong><em>: I think there is feminisation of artisanal activities not just because it is linked to tradition and cultural values or ‘feminine habitus’, the care of textiles, but also it has to do with the precariousness of the market. That means that it is mostly women with a lack of formal education that end up finding refuge in these activities because it gives them the possibility to earn their own revenue, right? But it never quite becomes their main source of income, for their household. The main source of income usually is generated by [the man] and he is the one who ends up going into education.</em></p><p>Unlike the women in Pisac, the female artisans in the North of Peru are generally not informal entrepreneurs, but rather work for third-party owned informal handicraft workshops. This also conditions some women to become dependent on intermediaries for sales and exports of their handicrafts, given that they lack access to resources and key social networks.</p><p>In the case of Pisac, women have become the main breadwinners and selling handicrafts, whether produced by themselves or third parties, has become a means of economic and psychological empowerment:</p><p><strong><em>Maria (informal female handicraft seller):</em></strong><em> with this business of selling handicrafts, we have made money to live very well…I thank that business a lot because I’ve been able to buy my house and educate my children because of it. My older son is a professional person now.</em></p><p><strong><em>Daniel (Ministry of Culture official)</em></strong><em>: The artisanal sector is a refuge of inequities but that at the same time can be a significant source of autonomy, of self-confidence…I mean, it helps them to improve the verbalisation of their ideas, outside the home…and of course when it is well-established as an activity, then it becomes a means of economic empowerment.</em></p><p>Therefore, in the case of Peru, findings suggest that female participation in the informal tourism sector is not a temporary phenomenon, which solely provides cash incomes for marginalised groups. Although for many rural women, work in the informal tourism sector takes place as a result of economic hardship and a scarcity of employment options, for women working in mature tourism destinations, it can be a rational financial choice. In Pisac, women working in the informal tourism sector are rational economic actors who consider both benefits and costs when choosing to enter the informal sector. This also highlights the value that these women place on flexible working hours, independence, and freedom.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/730/0*W93QYiaQb5B8vEuF" /></figure><p>In the case of Chile, findings reflected that one of the main motivations for joining the informal tourism economy was to supplement household income. Tourism is a complementary activity to the subsistence economy performed by the vast majority of women in rural areas. This was the case for the Mapuche Indigenous women from the Kurarewe community who saw tourism as a complementary activity, as opposed to a full-time lucrative business opportunity:</p><p><strong><em>Marisa (informal female artisan):</em></strong><em> For an Indigenous woman or a woman from a rural area who decides to work in tourism, they mainly do so as an alternative to their daily activities, to supplement what they do at home. If she takes care of her plot, cooks, or she’s an artisan, she will see in tourism an opportunity to make an extra income, but she doesn’t think of it as a profitable business to which she can give more of her time. Tourism has always been a supplementary activity in Indigenous communities.</em></p><p>Interview findings revealed that the women in this community viewed their participation in the informal sector as an entrepreneurial activity which facilitated the promotion of their Indigenous culture. For these women, tourism was a platform through which to disseminate the value of their gastronomic and handicraft traditions, whilst concurrently earning much-needed income for their household. Thus, dissemination of their culture was one of the most important motivations for joining the informal tourism sector. This was also related to the fact that diffusion and promotion of Indigenous culture was mainly seen as women’s responsibility, whilst Indigenous men favoured work in the construction sector.</p><p>A further reason that women were eager to promote their cultural traditions through tourism was that most of them had been working as domestic workers outside the community from an early age. The women, now in their forties, had been eager to reinforce their sense of cultural pride since coming back to their communities, and found tourism to be a good vehicle to achieve this aim. As a result, Kurarewe women did not view their work in the informal tourism economy as informal work. They considered the word ‘informal’ to have negative connotations and, instead, framed their work as contributing to the dissemination of Indigenous knowledge.</p><p><strong>2.2 Barriers and challenges of informality<br></strong>Most of the women working in the Peruvian tourism informal economy live in rural or semi-rural areas, as tourism in Peru is largely focused on natural and cultural heritage attractions found in rural settings. Rural communities have historically experienced restricted access to education and training opportunities, as well as limited access to technological infrastructure (Codina, 2018). Such barriers are further compounded by gender and ethnicity given that rural women in Peru commonly face additional limitations when attempting to complete formal education (ibid).</p><p>These structural conditions compel women to find jobs with low entry barriers, such as those commonly found in the informal tourism sector. Informal handicraft production is an attractive proposition since it is an activity that may already be part of women’s daily lives and can be performed from home. Nevertheless, interviews revealed that Indigenous women still experienced gender-based barriers that often made it difficult for them to access training opportunities and expand their entrepreneurial capabilities. As pointed out by Gaby, an NGO manager working with female handicraft makers, Indigenous women who sought to access further training opportunities, could often face opposition from their own communities for seeking to increase their knowledge base. This complicated entry into the formal sector and may prevent these women from moving beyond informal trading opportunities:</p><p><strong><em>Julieta (female handicraft trainer):</em></strong><em> It was very difficult at first because it is a very sexist culture…so to ask for these women to leave for one or two days to get some training, it was difficult to get the husbands’ approval…but slowly they got used to it because they saw that there was also a small income coming in…</em></p><p><strong><em>Gaby (NGO manager): </em></strong><em>In some meetings women have mentioned that when they come up with an initiative to improve their lives, there’s always a ‘comment’…there’s a general discouragement from male counterparts in the community…comments like ‘why are you doing this?…‘why don’t you cook instead?’, ‘why don’t you take care of your children instead?’…they tell me ‘when we want to improve, we always find barriers, from the Mayor to the councillor’…</em></p><p>As noted by Gaby, women often encounter participation barriers in political spheres at a local level. Local political representation is often dominated by male leadership, which often excludes women from decision-making processes or/and complicates bureaucratic processes unnecessarily. Thus, the gender-based obstacles faced by women may manifest though tacit practices and ordinary everyday situations, rather than through open discrimination or aggression. Although these barriers are notable at a community level, they are also present at higher levels of government, as noted by an interviewee who reflected on his experience of working in the MINCETUR:</p><p><strong><em>Manuel (Ex-MINCETUR high ranking official): </em></strong><em>There is still a greater percentage of male leadership, undoubtedly so…this is because of the machismo that clearly still exists in our society and the structural organisation of a lot of enterprises, right? If you look at the tourism guilds and you start looking at the presidents, and the boards of some of these guilds…you will see mostly men in leadership positions…I have seen situations in my position of government agent, in meetings and social acts, where the machista logic is still very present…</em></p><p>Added to gender barriers, Indigenous women particularly may also face additional obstacles related to culture and ethnicity. Language barriers represent a key issue for Indigenous women trying to develop formal enterprise. This is because much of the tourism related legislation and norms are seldom translated from Spanish to Indigenous languages. One interviewed former government official for the Peruvian Ministry of Tourism (MINCETUR) commented on the government’s reticence to translate legislation when she proposed translating some laws relating to the rights of artisans into the Amazonian Indigenous languages:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/766/0*LY9upreM3R15wrUt" /></figure><p><strong><em>Susana (former MINCETUR official):</em></strong><em> I visited Yanesha Indigenous communities, when the “Law of the Artisan” was developed, which by the way has not been published even though it’s ready…. We translated the law into Awajun, Shipibo and Yanesha (Amazonian Indigenous languages). It was a challenge because everybody in the MINCETUR kept telling me “but these communities do not have written languages”, and I would say “yes, but we are not going to sing the laws to them, are we? We need to hand it to them in writing and then they will see whether they read them or what they do with them!</em></p><p>This quote reflects the state inefficiency in releasing legislative information of key interest to the public. It also denotes the assumptions often made by government officials regarding the capabilities and needs of Indigenous communities, such as that these lack the capacity or interest to read printed text. Similar comments regarding the failure of state institutions to facilitate readily available access to public documents, were made by Gaby, an NGO manager working with women in community-based tourism projects:</p><p><strong><em>Gaby:</em></strong><em> there are many bureaucratic barriers relating to really simple things such as how to obtain information about how to create a tourism development plan. These documents are not made available to the population, and they should be because these are public documents. Even if they are publicly available, they are often incomprehensible to the average person…</em></p><p>Several interviewees also denoted that costs did represent a key barrier to formalisation, especially costs associated with bureaucratic procedures to join the formal sector. According to most interviewees, these costs were comparatively high in relation to the fluctuating amount of revenue informal tourism artisans made on a monthly basis:</p><p><strong><em>Gaby (NGO manager):</em></strong><em> In terms of barriers to formality, first there is the issue of high cost and a high amount of revenue that stays within the tourism supply chain, so in the end only a small percentage stays within the actual enterprise…costs are associated with taxes and bureaucratic processes. So, this already demotivates them to become formal, because if they do, the percentage from sales they keep is less than 20%.</em></p><p><strong><em>Julieta (informal female artisan)</em></strong><em>: It’s a cost and for handicrafts, we earn money on a day-to-day basis but it’s not constant… If you are registered with all these state entities, you need an accountant to take care of all the paperwork, right? So, all of that is a cost.</em></p><p>The costs associated with being part of the formal sector were mentioned in conjunction with complex and lengthy bureaucratic processes, as one of the main limitations to formalisation. Additionally, the lack of easy access to public information, the complex language used in tourism development state documents, as well as the lack of assistance from state actors, further de-motivated informal traders from formalisation.</p><p>Several interviewees were critical of the existing governance systems and blamed the inefficiency of the state at different levels (local, regional, national) for poor implementation of plans and policies which ultimately leave large segments of the population, and their needs, unattended. Duplicity of functions, corruption, and lack of collaboration between different Ministries were repeatedly mentioned by interviewees as incapacitating efficient governance. Such circumstances make the sustainable development and implementation of plans and policies extremely difficult.</p><p>In the case of Chile, interview data uncovered that informal female entrepreneurs were afraid to participate in the formal sector due to the complex and expensive procedures associated with formalisation. Women in rural areas preferred to start their business ideas off in the informal economy, as a way to test out the success of their ventures without having to incur as many risks. The complexity characterising the formalisation process was mainly linked to the lengthy bureaucratic process, and the difficulty of meeting standards needed to obtain official state certifications for tourism businesses.</p><p>The tourism certification standards appeared to have been mainly developed with the tourist’s needs in mind. Whilst tourist safety is undoubtedly paramount, standards of cleanliness and safety measures were extremely difficult to meet for Indigenous communities in isolated rural areas, with high levels of poverty and limited state assistance. Most importantly, some governmental requirements compromised Indigenous cultural heritage, potentially diminishing the cultural authenticity of the tourist experience. For instance, the certification standards related to Mapuche hospitality providers do not allow Indigenous women to cook for tourists in their traditional huts (Rucas). This is because sanitary regulations dictate that floors must be paved, and the huts must meet a set infrastructural requirements which traditional Mapuche huts cannot meet:</p><p><strong><em>Marisa (female informal artisan):</em></strong><em> By law, you can’t have a restaurant in a Ruca nowadays because you need to have paved floors, you need to have a lot of things there because of hygiene rules…so you have to find another way, most have the kitchen somewhere else so they can meet the standards, and then they take the food to tourists in the Ruca.</em></p><p>Similarly, certification standards do not consider the unique value of intangible cultural heritage, for instance the ancestral techniques used in the manufacturing of Mapuche handicrafts. Instead, certification standards focus on the quality of the materials used and given that Mapuche handicrafts are foremost elaborated by women working in informal settings, these handicrafts do not meet the state quality certification standards. This in turn is impacting the Mapuche handicraft value chain in relation to access to materials, the need to upgrade materials, and the commercialisation of Indigenous artifacts. For instance, one interviewed accommodation owner mentioned she did not sell handicrafts made by Mapuche women in the informal sector, to avoid being fined due to these artifacts not meeting official government quality standards. She did this despite being aware that these handicrafts had unique cultural value. This reflects the need for tailor-made certification standards that align with Indigenous traditions, values, and structural conditions.</p><p>Even though the Chilean state is reinforcing programmes to support entrepreneurs, most of these are heavily focused on the formal economy. For instance, one of the requirements to establish a formal enterprise is to have at least five or six individuals in a group. In Indigenous networks, such as the Kurarewe community, they do not fill this minimum size requirement given that they are usually small family enterprises and have low levels of sales. Further to this, as was the case in Peru, interview findings revealed that informal traders often stayed in the informal sector due to fear and ignorance of the system. Fear was linked to possibly losing state benefits if they formalised their businesses, and losing profits due to high tax costs:</p><p><strong><em>Teresa (female artisan trainer):</em></strong><em> I have also seen a lot of fear of formalisation because they fear they will lose social benefits from the state. They tell you ‘if I become formal, I will become visible in the tax system and the state will assume I’m selling, that will mean I will lose the bursary for my daughter’…I think there’s also fear of becoming part of the tax system…a fear of losing money or paying too many taxes. So finally, there’s fear due to ignorance as well.</em></p><p>However, one interviewee noted that informal tourism actors in Chile were starting to group together to help each other with the formalisation process. Informal artisans and other tourism-related informal actors recognised the importance of formalisation for their businesses to prosper in the long run:</p><p><strong><em>Teresa (female artisan trainer):</em></strong><em> There are many informal traders that have started to group together out of necessity…that’s when they quickly realise that they need to be part of the formal sector if they want to enter a commercial system…I have seen many associations that naturally are created for a common goal which is to perpetuate the trade, receive orders, and start selling their products in Chile and abroad.</em></p><p>Thus, working as a group proved more viable than attempting formalisation on an individual basis.</p><p>Although there are key differences in the scope and scale of the informal sector between Peru and Chile, actors in the informal tourism industry and associated sectors appear to face similar barriers. Lack of knowledge of the processes and procedures needed for formalisation, limited state support with the formalisation process, as well as inflexible conditions which do not align to the socio-economic circumstances experienced by informal actors, dissuade many informal traders from expanding into the formal sector. Indigenous women in the informal tourism economy may also be further deterred from seeking formalisation out of a fear of state intervention in — and subsequent commodification of — cultural heritage. This ultimately limits their entrepreneurial growth and profits, whilst limiting their rights and protection under law.</p><h3>2.3 Links to the formal sector</h3><p><strong>Links to government institutions<br></strong>Interviewed Peruvian state actors did acknowledge the issues confronting informal tourism actors and although still viewed the informal sector mainly as problematic for the competitiveness of the tourism industry, they recognised that formalisation of the sector could only take place with further collaboration from the state. Government stakeholders also recognised the key role played by tourism-related guilds in further addressing the needs of the informal sector. Although tourism-related guilds represent formal enterprises, they are part of a sector that is largely informal and thus cannot ignore the issues confronting informal actors.</p><p>The disconnect between state entities and the informal sector became even more evident when discussing the state of female participation in the informal tourism sector. Although government actors recognised the key role played by women in the tourism and artisan sector, evidence suggests that to date, there is a lack of sex-disaggregated data regarding female labour. Similarly, although it is estimated that women make up around 76% of the Peruvian tourism sector (Baum, 2013), interview data suggested a scarcity of gender-responsive policies directed at the informal sector or/and the tourism industry; even though state actors are aware of the gender barriers faced by women in Peru:</p><p><strong><em>Manuel (former MINCETUR high ranking officer):</em></strong><em> I mean in all my time working in the MINCETUR, in these last 20 years, I don’t remember the development of any programme specifically targeting women.</em></p><p>In the case of Chile, institutions and tourism experts evidenced a reticence to acknowledge the presence of informality within the tourism sector, or to address gender-related issues associated with the sector. As an example, when SERNATUR (the Chilean governmental institution in charge of national tourism management) was told about this research, their response was “<em>we don’t work with the informal sector”. </em>Tourism for women in the informal economy is considered a casual activity that comes and goes; therefore, women are thought to have minor engagement with the sector although data shows 53% of individuals employed in the Chilean tourism sector are women (Baum, 2013). This is in opposition to the Peruvian case where women in the informal tourism economy are known to play a key role in the sector (Codina, 2018; Del Pozo Loayza, 2018). Many state interventions in tourism and related sectors are limited to the provision of funds or donations of equipment, but there is limited vision as to how these may be used for sustainable development. For instance, one interviewed artisan trainer lamented the lack of training provided by the state in one intervention meant to encourage artisan cheese production:</p><p><strong><em>Teresa (female artisan trainer):</em></strong><em> Many years ago, I went to visit a group of artisans who lived out in the mountains. The SERCOTEC (State Technical Cooperation Service) had financed a project for the manufacturing of artisanal cheeses. They had amazing cheese making facilities, an exquisite space, but they were closed! They were using that space as a storage space…and this is because in the end, there are many schemes of this sort, where they donate machinery, ovens etc… but they do not train people in how to use these…it’s like having a Mercedes but not knowing how to drive it.</em></p><p>Interviews also revealed that in Chile, women are prevented from moving towards the formal sector due to fear, distrust of state institutions, as well as inexperience of dealing with bureaucratic processes. Women working in the informal tourism sector do not know how to deal with taxes, standards, and credentials. As a result, many prefer to remain invisible to state institutions even if this meant preventing the growth of their businesses, since formalisation implies having to confront a regulatory system that often works against the nature of their services and products, which are rooted in cultural heritage.</p><p>In both the cases of Chile and Peru, it appears there is no intention from institutions to further integrate the informal economy into policymaking. The current policies do not identify the main causes leading women to work in the informal tourism economy and associated sectors. Tourism policies and strategies are integrating neither the informal economy nor gender issues. This brings into light the absence of gender-responsive tourism programming focused on the informal tourism economy.</p><p><strong>Links to the private sector<br></strong>As previously mentioned, informal tourism actors routinely interact and work alongside the formal economy. The line between the formal and informal sector is sometimes blurred as it is common for informal female actors to sporadically participate in the formal economy through special events such as ‘ferias’ (trade fairs).</p><p>Handicraft ‘ferias’ are organised by local or national authorities and although the artisans who participate in them are registered as such, they often do not work in the formal sector most of the year. This is the case for artisan women in the North of Peru who rely on ferias for key sales and for expanding their social network with the formal sector. Ferias are usually attended by formal actors from different industries, and thus provide a key space for female artisans to interact with formal producers who may, later, sell their products on a wider commercial scale. However, as noted by Daniel, this can also lead to overdependence on private sector intermediaries, due to these having access to wider networks and further knowledge of digital technologies.</p><p><strong><em>Daniel (Ministry of Culture official):</em></strong><em> the reason why they depend so much on ferias is because they don’t have other places to sell, they don’t really have other ways to sell…this is also why they end up becoming so dependent on intermediaries both for exports and for local sales…they don’t have access to direct selling points….</em></p><p>In the case of Pisac the exploitative relations that tourism may foster between informal traders and formal actors, such as tour guides, are more evident. As is common in many destinations, some formal tourism businesses pay the guides a commission in exchange for directing tourists to their shops (Codina et al, 2020). Informal handicraft sellers refuse to pay guides commission in exchange for sales, and as a result, end up with a lower share of local tourist spending. This arguably creates unequal exchange relations between informal traders and private sector intermediaries, further discouraging female informal traders from joining the formal sector.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/828/0*p-fh_H_8TmNw1BdV" /></figure><p>In the case of Chile, the tourism informal economy is linked to the formal sector mainly through the help of foundations funded through NGOs, the state, or the private sector, that act as intermediaries selling female produced handicrafts. Some study participants expressed concerns about the paternal nature of foundations — a phenomenon well-documented in the cultural heritage literature (Azuela and Cogco, 2016; Rosselló and Cosmelli, 2021). They suggested that the foundations might assume responsibility for the entire handicraft production process and in so doing exclude the very women they purport to assist. Studies suggest that in the long-term these third-party initiatives do not bring about lasting structural change in the informal economy (Moagi et al, 2021; Grobar, 2019).</p><p>In both Chile and Peru, it seems that informal female tourism actors rely on private sector intermediaries to reach a wider consumer set and maximise their product sales. These relationships may sometimes lead to dependency and manipulation and may encourage informal actors to stay in the shadow of informality due to fear and over-reliance on third parties for income.</p><p><strong>2.4 Impacts of COVID-19<br></strong>The tourism industry was one of the sectors worst hit by the COVID-19 pandemic on a global scale (Gössling et al, 2020). In a country like Peru, where most of the economic revenue from tourism is generated by international tourists (World Bank, 2019), economic and social impacts were devastating. The Peruvian state did not provide any targeted financial assistance or programmes for informal enterprises. Instead, the state provided two economic aid bonuses targeted at families living below the poverty threshold, emergency food bundles and ‘JUNTOS’ (conditional cash transfer) targeted at vulnerable groups (Andina, 2020; CARE, 2021).</p><p>Lending and funding programmes were implemented for the tourism and handicraft industries through the ‘Turismo Emprende’ (translated to ‘Enterprise Tourism’) funding scheme and similar credit schemes facilitated by diverse government ministries. However, these schemes were almost exclusively directed towards formal tourism-related enterprises, and thus did not have a significant impact on informal entrepreneurs. Although the criteria to participate in some of these schemes were modified to enable the inclusion of a wider set of participants, the complex application process and need for formalisation evidence still excluded many female informal traders. Most of these competitions, asked participants to hold a RUC (operating licence) and to evidence a certain number of sales, which was difficult to meet for many informal traders with limited assets.</p><p>Although some of the interviewed women participated in ‘Turismo Emprende’, a distinctive distrust of state entities was present amongst most participants, which discouraged several women from applying to these state-funded competitions. Partly this was linked to long-standing distrust of national and local authorities as a result of repeated corruption scandals involving political figures at a national and local level. These issues were further complicated by a lack of coordination and collaboration between Ministries. As noted by a former MINCETUR official, ministries seldom share information and resources, which at times led to some individuals being missed from funding schemes. Thus, funding and lending schemes for informal traders were insufficient in scope, whilst the administration and delivery of these programmes presented several deficiencies which significantly limited the number of beneficiaries.</p><p>Given the importance of tourism for many informal female entrepreneurs in Pisac, several women had taken out bank loans to invest in merchandise. With the arrival of the pandemic and the abrupt halt in earnings, many female traders were also facing mounting pressures to repay their loans and were being charged increasingly higher interest rates due to missed payments.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/815/0*WKcehg_AAb3kkp5s" /></figure><p>Pisac informal handicraft market traders also faced added pressures from public authorities who used the pandemic and confinement measures to attempt to permanently remove market traders from the space of the plaza (see figure 2.4). This particularly affected women, given that most market traders are female. Such measures made women fear for their livelihoods on a long-term basis.</p><p>For the rest of interviewed Peruvian female informal artisans, the pandemic also abruptly stopped their sole source of revenue, particularly their access to handicraft tradeshows known as ‘ferias’, which for most was their main selling venue. Established contracts with NGOs selling female manufactured handicrafts also eventually stopped for many female artisans. Aside from the economic consequences this situation had on female artisans, it adversely impacted their social connectedness.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/552/0*dHVCUcpdJKxWfauN" /></figure><p>Handicraft making workshops, training workshops, and ‘ferias’ provided many women with the opportunity to connect with other women and build networks outside their own households or communities. Access to social networks is essential in the artisanal sector which relies on personal relations for sales, but it also has mental health implications for women who sometimes rely on these connections for emotional and social support.</p><p>In most cases, women also had to cope with a significant increase in domestic responsibilities, including taking care of sick and elderly family/and or community members. As noted in several interviews, both in urban and rural areas, women are largely in charge of organising and managing community support initiatives:</p><p><strong><em>Susana (former MINCETUR official):</em></strong><em> without a doubt women have a heavier domestic burden… they are the ones in charge of ensuring their communities and households get fed, and that takes time away from them. In fact, all around Lima, where you see all the soup kitchens to ensure communities get fed, which is basic, this is led by women. So, that means they have much less time dedicated to artisanal production.</em></p><p><strong><em>Maria (informal female artisan): </em></strong><em>I take care of my parents, they live with me, and my mother has her parents with her too, so I have them as well in my house…yes, I have more domestic chores because I’m home most of the time.</em></p><p>As noted by Susana, these conditions justified the need for the development of economic aid and mental health support programmes specifically targeted at women, given that they face unique barriers and challenges which put them at greater risk of isolation, poverty, and mental health issues during the pandemic:</p><p><strong><em>Susana (former MINCETUR official</em></strong><em>): And yes, it needs to be differentiated (state aid programmes) for women…these are women that face bigger access barriers to even be able to move out of their homes. Because, who takes care of older people? Women. Who takes care of children? Women. Now that children are at home, what are women doing? They are the ones in charge of helping children with online classes…So, there are many justified reasons for which we should boost programmes for women.</em></p><p>Susana further stressed the mental health issues faced by women during the pandemic and the pressing need for the development of further mental health initiatives from the state to support women during these vulnerable times. Despite these challenges, interviews revealed that women in the Peruvian informal tourism sector still found different coping strategies and mechanisms to survive throughout the pandemic.</p><p>Notably, women in Pisac appeared to have used some of the transferable skills learned during their time working in informal tourism (i.e., creativity, negotiation and sales skills, entrepreneurial vision), to develop alternative entrepreneurial initiatives. Most women were used to developing new products and services for a dynamic tourism industry with constantly shifting market demands and trends. Thus, it may be argued that women’s experience of working in the informal tourism sector made them more adaptable and resilient, and in doing so, better prepared them for the uncertain circumstances presented by the pandemic. For instance, Maria, a former informal handicraft seller, engaged in several ad-hoc ventures:</p><p><strong><em>Maria (informal female artisan):</em></strong><em> Due to the pandemic I opened my own liquor store from home…we all participate in it; my children also help…now in Pisac there are more liquor stores than bodegas (small grocery stores) … I even do deliveries, what else did I do during the pandemic? I bought chickens, raised them, and then sold them off, I also did chicken soup and sold it from home…. I mostly sold soup to my family and friends…Really, I did everything! I also sold honey…</em></p><p>Interviewed women in Pisac emphasised they were driven to find alternate ways to earn an income outside of tourism, since they had become used to financial independence:</p><p><strong><em>Maria (informal female artisan):</em></strong><em> Listen, we are independent, we don’t want to have to ask our husbands for money, right? Maybe I only needed 10 soles [approximately £2.00] so I could buy stuff for myself, and I wasn’t going to ask my husband…</em></p><p>Nevertheless, for most women, the alternative income opportunities they developed did not provide significant revenue, especially when compared to their previous tourism-related income. For most female informal traders, these alternative occupations represented subsistence activities that were not always successful. For the rest of interviewed women in other regions of Peru from communities with non-tourism-centred economies, the degree of adaptation was different from that of women in Pisac. The argument could be made that they did not develop the same transferable skills as Pisac female informal traders, given that they did not work in the informal tourism sector on a full-time basis. Most of these women live in rural areas and for many, the pandemic necessitated reverting to traditional subsistence activities, such as agriculture.</p><p>In the case of Chile, women in the Kurarewe community did not receive any tourists since the start of the pandemic. This particularly affected those women who relied on the sale of food and/or ran semi-formal tourist visits to their traditional homes. As was the case with Peruvian Indigenous women, they cultivated their land as a way to survive food shortages brought on by income reduction. Congruent with the situation in Peru, due to lockdown restrictions, women working in handicraft were not able to participate in ‘ferias’, the most important events of the year for selling handicrafts. Consequently, this also impacted their ability to meet with colleagues and build new partnerships. The pandemic also affected women’s ability to buy raw materials for handicraft production in urban centres. This was chiefly related to confinement restrictions which restricted women to their homes, and thus constrained their mobility whilst concurrently increasing their domestic and care responsibilities.</p><p>Chilean women working in the informal tourism economy also reported having problems in accessing the financial aid provided by the government to overcome the socio-economic impacts of COVID-19. This was similarly related to the fact that most relief aid and funding schemes were largely directed at formal actors, and the fact that beneficiaries had to visit urban centres in order to claim funds.</p><p>Interview findings also revealed that there was a feeling amongst informal actors, that the pandemic was going to aggravate the issue of certifications, with standards becoming more difficult to meet post-pandemic. Thereby, Indigenous women working in the informal tourism sector feared they would have to face further barriers if they tried to formalise their businesses.</p><p>A positive consequence of the pandemic was described by women who had been caring for grandchildren and consequently learned to use new technologies for selling thanks to the assistance of young people.</p><p>In both Peru and Chile, there was a stark lack of state support directed at women and the informal sector. Most state aid and funding schemes appear to have been exclusively aimed at formal actors, whilst limited interventions have been developed for the tourism sector. There is scarce evidence of gender-sensitive policies and programs accounting for the barriers women are experiencing during the pandemic, such as increased domestic and caring responsibilities. A lack of sex-disaggregated data for the tourism sector further undermines women’s experiences and needs.</p><p><strong>2.4 Sustainable development goals and the informal tourism sector<br>SDG 1: Tourism sector poverty alleviation<br></strong>Whilst the tourism industries of Peru and Chile were one of the worst hit sectors of the economy due to the closing of borders and confinement measures, findings disclose that informal traders were disproportionately affected by the impacts of the pandemic. Both in the case of Chile and Peru, informal tourism actors abruptly lost their main income source and had not able to benefit from targeted economic aid from the state at any point since the start of the pandemic. Neither the Peruvian nor Chilean governments developed economic relief measures directly targeted at informal workers. Fiscal measures to alleviate the detrimental economic impacts of the pandemic were not responsive to the needs of informal traders nor female workers. Funding and credit schemes in both countries were almost exclusively directed towards formal enterprises who could prove they had been trading as such before the start of the pandemic.</p><p>Government entities did not develop sufficient gender-responsive policies and measures to respond to increased pressures faced by the female population that puts them at greater risk of economic insolvency compared to male counterparts. Without targeted state support, women in the Peruvian and Chilean informal tourism sector and related industries are likely to suffer from higher incidences of poverty as a result of the pandemic. This will undoubtedly have lasting socio-economic consequences for future generations and is likely to increase the feminisation of poverty in Chile and Peru for decades.</p><p><strong>SDG 5: Gender equality and empowerment of all women and girls<br></strong>Although interview data showed that some women were economically empowered through tourism by earning their own wages, most were still expected to maintain their domestic and care roles. This arguably limited their social and economic empowerment, given that women had a “double workload” (Bell, 2006, p. 1181) which consequently also limited the extent to which they could pursue training/educational opportunities, and ultimately develop their businesses. Patriarchal power structures and in some cases, tacit demotivating comments from male family members were also found to limit women’s entrepreneurial growth.</p><p>Gender-based inequalities were also unsurfaced within governmental entities at different levels. Lack of female representation was evident at a local and national level, whilst several interviewed state actors reflected on the lack of gender-sensitive policies within the tourism and handicraft sectors. This was congruently linked to limited data on gender-related issues in tourism, evidenced by a lack of sex-disaggregated data on the nature of female employment in the informal and formal tourism sectors.</p><p>Nevertheless, some women working in the informal tourism sector showed increased economic resilience through the pandemic. This was chiefly linked to the ways in which they were able to maximise the transferable skills developed by working in tourism to create new entrepreneurial opportunities for themselves.</p><p>Therefore, the results of this study highlight the need for governments to acknowledge the existing unequal gender power relations embedded in local communities when planning tourism development (Ferguson and Moreno, 2013; Codina, 2018). Gender equality should also be integrated in the development of existing and future tourism policies and interventions, to create a more inclusive, sustainable, and resilient industry (Moreno and Cole, 2019; UNWTO, 2019). Similarly, the involvement of women in designing and implementing tourism measures is essential to achieve a truly sustainable tourism industry.</p><p><strong>SDG 16: Peaceful and inclusive societies: accountable institutions at all levels<br></strong>The findings of this study highlight the need for governmental institutions at all levels to work alongside informal sector actors, and women, to create a more inclusive and fair tourism industry for all. Interview findings revealed that female informal actors are still dependent on private sector intermediaries for access to tourists, training opportunities, and help with digital technologies. This can sometimes lead to exploitative relationships as highlighted by the case of tour guides in Pisac.</p><p>Study findings thus suggest that state institutions must increase efforts to gather evidence on the structural inequalities affecting the inclusive participation of women and informal actors in tourism. Although in the case of Peru, there is acknowledgement of the scope and scale of the informal sector within tourism, there is limited evidence of efforts being made to integrate informal actors into wider policy-making. In Chile, no such recognition of the sector was evident. Due to a lack of knowledge and understanding of informal actors’ experiences, state stakeholders are also unable to recognise some of the strengths and skills that informal entrepreneurs possess. These skills could be further harnessed to integrate informal actors into the formal sector, through mutually beneficial, collaborative, rather than retaliatory mechanisms. For this to take place, further studies on the participation of women in the informal tourism sector, both from a theoretical and practical point of view, are urgently needed.</p><h3>3.0 Implications for policy and practice</h3><p>Although the tourism sector is known for its ability to adapt and recover from crises, the COVID-19 pandemic has produced unprecedented circumstances, requiring the development of new approaches to accelerate recovery. The pandemic has stressed the need for multi-tiered responses and robust partnerships to address the immediate and long-term impacts of COVID-19 on host communities globally. At the same time, the current crisis provides an opportunity to transform tourism into a more inclusive, sustainable, and resilient global industry. For this goal to be realised, and for tourism to align with all sustainable development goals, gender equality must be at the centre of post-pandemic tourism recovery programs.</p><p>This study highlighted the particularly problematic relationship between the pressure on female informal tourism actors to formalise and their desire to safeguard their cultural heritage. The imposition of government quality standards on Indigenous handicraft is not conducive to the production of authentic artefacts which honour cultural tradition and as such attract higher retail prices. This standardisation of cultural heritage, which in the case of Peru and Chile is considered the province of women, serves only to discourage artisans from engaging with government support.</p><p>The pandemic is likely to exacerbate the existing tension between the safeguarding of traditional craft and the need for women artisans to earn the larger wages promised by government-endorsed formalisation. Without gender-responsive policy instruments to account for this tension, there is a risk that women’s engaging with the formalisation process is detrimental to the preservation of cultural heritage or else that women refuse altogether.</p><p>To this end, gender-responsive fiscal policies are urgently needed to support women working in the Chilean and Peruvian informal tourism industries and related sectors. Such measures could include financial aid and direct cash transfers for informal workers, credit lines and financial support measures for women wishing to establish, formalise or expand their tourism enterprises, fringe benefits, subsidies for childcare to facilitate women’s return to work, and further mentoring and training support for informal workers who wish to formalise their businesses. Based on primary findings which highlighted the pressures women are facing during the current crisis, further funding for mental health services that address the specific needs and concerns of women and girls is also needed.</p><p>In the long-term, gender equality should be integrated at all levels and phases of tourism development in Peru and Chile, particularly when designing and implementing any sort of tourism measure or policy. For gender-responsive policies to be realised, further sex-disaggregated data on the nature of female employment in tourism and the informal sector is urgently needed. At present, there is virtually no data related to the quality and participation of women in tourism employment, and thus their needs remain unaddressed in wider policy developments.</p><p>Similarly, the needs of other vulnerable groups, such as informal workers, which make up a large part of the tourism workforce in the Global South, must be further incorporated into wider policy development in assistance mechanisms. Short and medium term direct financial state assistance is especially needed during the current crisis for informal tourism workers whose livelihoods rely on tourism. Additionally, both the Peruvian and Chilean states must aim to promote increased flexibility in the conditions to be met for formalisation. The creation of tailor-made fiscal mechanisms for informal actors working in rural tourism economies could be one approach to encourage formalisation. This could include further state help with bureaucratic procedures, simplification of some of the conditions to be met to obtain certifications, transparent access to formalisation guidelines, and discounted tax rates to account for tourism’s highly seasonal earnings.</p><p>Furthermore, COVID-19 has accelerated the digitalisation process and has evidenced the digital divide within and between countries. Vulnerable groups such as informal workers, and rural actors in Peru and Chile, are particularly impacted by this divide. State interventions should aim to improve digital literacy amongst these groups. This includes training on how to improve use of digital platforms and tools to streamline their operations, widen their commercial reach, and decrease dependency on third-party intermediaries for the sale and marketing of their products and services.</p><p>Lastly, the Peruvian and Chilean states should foster partnerships with host communities. Current tourism development policies and programmes reflect a centralised, top-down approach to tourism governance. These frequently do not reflect the needs and realities of rural communities, particularly those of actors on the margin, such as women and the informal sector. This approach to tourism development further deters informal actors from formalisation. Therefore, the Peruvian and Chilean states must promote collaborative approaches to tourism planning and governance. These collaborative mechanisms should foster trust-building and dialogue amongst all stakeholders (informal and formal tourism stakeholders, state institutions, NGOs, host community residents), a shared understanding of goals and beliefs, immediate, intermediate and long-term desired outcomes, as well as local leadership support.</p><h3>References</h3><p>Alarcón, D.M. and Cole, S. (2019) No sustainability for tourism without gender equality. <em>Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 27</em>(7), pp. 903–919.</p><p>Al‐Mataani, R., Wainwright, T., &amp; Demirel, P. (2017). Hidden entrepreneurs: Informal practices within the formal economy. <em>European Management Review</em>, <em>14</em>(4), 361–376.</p><p>Andersen, B. (2015) Style and self-making: String bag production in the Papua New Guinean highlands. <em>Anthropology Today, 31</em>(5), 16–20.</p><p>Andina (2020) <em>Peru: Over 2 million additional households to get US$223 grant to tackle COVID-19.</em> [online]. Available at: <a href="https://andina.pe/ingles/noticia-peru-over-2-million-additional-households-to-get-223-grant-to-tackle-covid19-803298.aspx">https://andina.pe/ingles/noticia-peru-over-2-million-additional-households-to-get-223-grant-to-tackle-covid19-803298.aspx</a> (Accessed 8 April 2021).</p><p>Ashley, C., &amp; Roe, D. (2002). Making tourism work for the poor: strategies and challenges in southern Africa. <em>Development Southern Africa</em>, <em>19</em>(1), 61–82.</p><p>Azuela, J., and Cogco, A. (2016) Analysis of Public Policies for Crafts Development in Mexico. <em>International Journal of Arts Management, Spring</em>, 121–130.</p><p>Bah, A., &amp; Goodwin, H. (2003). Improving access for the informal sector to tourism in The Gambia.</p><p>Bell, W. (2006) Eleonora Masini on the empowerment of women. <em>Futures 38</em>(10), 1179–1186.</p><p>Biggs, D., Hall, C. M., &amp; Stoeckl, N. (2012). The resilience of formal and informal tourism enterprises to disasters: reef tourism in Phuket, Thailand. <em>Journal of Sustainable Tourism</em>, <em>20</em>(5), 645–665.</p><p>Biggs, D., Hall, C. M., &amp; Stoeckl, N. (2012). The resilience of formal and informal tourism enterprises to disasters: reef tourism in Phuket, Thailand. <em>Journal of Sustainable Tourism</em>, <em>20</em>(5), 645–665.</p><p>Brata, A. G. (2010). Vulnerability of urban informal sector: Street vendors in Yogyakarta, Indonesia. <em>Theoretical and empirical researches in urban management</em>, <em>5</em>(5 (14), 47–58.</p><p>Çakmak, E., &amp; Çenesiz, M. A. (2020). Measuring the size of the informal tourism economy in Thailand. <em>International Journal of Tourism Research</em>, <em>22</em>(5), 637–652.</p><p>Çakmak, E., Lie, R., &amp; Selwyn, T. (2019). Informal tourism entrepreneurs’ capital usage and conversion. <em>Current Issues in Tourism</em>, <em>22</em>(18), 2250–2265.</p><p>Çakmak, E., Lie, R., &amp; McCabe, S. (2018). Reframing informal tourism entrepreneurial practices: Capital and field relations structuring the informal tourism economy of Chiang Mai. <em>Annals of Tourism Research</em>, <em>72</em>, 37–47.</p><p>CARE. (2021) <em>CARE provides nutritionally balanced meals to some of Peru’s most vulnerable affected by COVID-19</em>. [online] Available at: <a href="https://www.care-international.org/news/press-releases/care-provides-nutritionally-balanced-meals-to-some-of-perus-most-vulnerable-affected-by-covid-19">https://www.care-international.org/news/press-releases/care-provides-nutritionally-balanced-meals-to-some-of-perus-most-vulnerable-affected-by-covid-19</a> [Accessed 8 April 2021].</p><p>Cave, P. and Kilic, S. (2010) The role of women in tourism employment with special reference to Antalya, Turkey. Journal of Hospitality Marketing and Management, <em>19</em>(3), 280–292.</p><p>Chen, M. (2006). Rethinking the informal economy: Linkages with the formal sector and the formal regulatory environment”. In Guha-Khasnobis, B., Kanbur, R., and Ostrom, E. (Eds.). <em>Linking the formal and informal economy: Concepts and policies</em> (pp. 75–92). Oxford University Press.</p><p>Codina, R. (2018) <em>The role of tourism in local power relations: A case study of Pisac, Peru.</em> Unpublished PhD thesis. Oxford Brookes University.</p><p>Codina, R., Lugosi, P., &amp; Bowen, D. (2020). Place, power, and tourism in value-creation: contesting the plaza in Pisac, Peru. <em>Tourism Geographies</em>, 1–23.</p><p>Cole, S. (2020) <em>A global overview of the impact of Covid-19 on women in tourism. </em>London: Equality in Tourism International. [online]. Available at: <a href="https://www.equalityintourism.org/prioritizing-gender-equality-in-post-covid-19-tourism/">https://www.equalityintourism.org/prioritizing-gender-equality-in-post-covid-19-tourism/</a> (Accessed 09 April 2021).</p><p>Crick, M. (1992). Life in the informal sector: street guides in Kandy, Sri Lanka. <em>Life in the informal sector: street guides in Kandy, Sri Lanka.</em>, 135–147.</p><p>Cukier, J. (2002). Tourism employment issues in developing countries: examples from Indonesia. <em>Tourism and development: Concepts and issues</em>, 165–201.</p><p>Cukier, J., &amp; Wall, G. (1994). Informal tourism employment: vendors in Bali, Indonesia. <em>Tourism Management</em>, <em>15</em>(6), 464–467.</p><p>Dahles, H. (1998). Tourism, government policy, and petty entrepreneurs in Indonesia. <em>South East Asia Research</em>, <em>6</em>(1), 73–98.</p><p>Dahles, H. (2001). The politics of guiding: enclosed spaces and controlled discourses. <em>Tourism, heritage and national culture in Java: dilemmas of a local community</em>, 131–176.</p><p>Dahles, H., and Bras, C. H. (1999). <em>Tourism and Small Entrepreneurs. Development, National Policy and Entrepreneurial Culture. Indonesian Cases</em>. New York: Cognizant Communication Corporation.</p><p>Dahles, H., and Keune, L. (Eds.). (2002). <em>Tourism development and local participation in Latin America</em>. New York: Cognizant Communication Corporation.</p><p>Dahles, H., &amp; Prabawa, T. S. (2013). Entrepreneurship in the informal sector. The case of the pedicab drivers of Yogyakarta, Indonesia. <em>Journal of Small Business &amp; Entrepreneurship</em>, <em>26</em>(3), 241–259.</p><p>Damayanti, M., Scott, N., &amp; Ruhanen, L. (2018). Space for the informal tourism economy. <em>The Service Industries Journal</em>, <em>38 </em>(11–12), 772–788.</p><p>Del Alonso-Almeida, M. (2012) Water and waste management in the Moroccan tourism industry: The case of three women entrepreneurs. <em>Women’s Studies International Forum</em>, <em>35</em>, 343–353</p><p>Del Pozo Loayza, C. (2018) <em>Efecto de la Ley General de Turismo en la Informalidad Laboral en el Perú (The impact of the General law of tourism on the informal Peruvian labour force). </em>Lima and Cusco: Consorcio de Investigación Económica y Social (CIES) and Centro Bartolome de las Casas (CBC).</p><p>De Soto, H. (2002) <em>The other path: The economic answer to terrorism</em>. New York, NY: Basic Books.</p><p>Duffy, L.N., Kline, C.A., Mowatt R.A. and Chancellor, H.C. (2015) Women in tourism: Shifting gender ideology. <em>Annals of Tourism Research</em>, <em>52</em>, 72–86.</p><p>Farver, J. A. M. (1984). Tourism and employment in the Gambia. <em>Annals of Tourism Research</em>, <em>11</em>(2), 249–265.</p><p>Ferguson, L. and Moreno, D. (2013) Integrating gender into sustainable tourism projects. Equality in Tourism, London. Available at: <a href="https://www.equalityintourism.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/10/Integrating-gender-into-sustainable-tourism-projects_F_Oct_13.pdf">https://www.equalityintourism.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/10/Integrating-gender-into-sustainable-tourism-projects_F_Oct_13.pdf</a> (Accessed 12 April 2021).</p><p>Ferguson, L. and Moreno, D. (2015) Gender and sustainable tourism: reflections on theory and practice. Journal of Sustainable Tourism, volume <em>23 (3</em>), 401–416.</p><p>Grobar, L.M. (2019) Policies to promote employment and preserve cultural heritage in the handicraft sector. <em>International Journal of Cultural Policy</em>, <em>25</em>(4), 515–527.</p><p>Guttentag, D. (2015). Airbnb: disruptive innovation and the rise of an informal tourism accommodation sector. <em>Current issues in Tourism</em>, <em>18</em>(12), 1192–1217.</p><p>Hampton, M. P. (2013) <em>Backpacker tourism and economic development: Perspectives from the less developed world</em>. Abingdon: Routledge.</p><p>Henderson, J. C., &amp; Smith, R. A. (2009). The informal tourism economy at beach resorts: A comparison of Cha-Am and Laguna Phuket in Thailand. <em>Tourism Recreation Research</em>, <em>34</em>(1), 13–22.</p><p>Hutchings, K., Moyle, C. L., Chai, A., Garofano, N., and Moore, S. (2020) Segregation of women in tourism employment in the APEC region. <em>Tourism Management Perspectives, 34</em>, 100655.</p><p>Hutchings, K., Samaratunge, R., Lu, Y. and Gamage, A.S. (2016) Examining Sri Lankan professional women’s perceptions of their opportunities to undertake international careers: Implications for diversity amongst cross-cultural managers. <em>International Journal of Cross-Cultural Management</em>, <em>16</em>(1), 77–98.</p><p>International Labour Organization (ILO). (2000) <em>Employment and Social Protection in the Informal Sector.</em> International Labour Office: Geneva. Available at: <a href="https://www.ilo.org/public/english/standards/relm/gb/docs/gb277/pdf/esp-1-1.pdf">https://www.ilo.org/public/english/standards/relm/gb/docs/gb277/pdf/esp-1-1.pdf</a> (Accessed 09 April 2021)</p><p>International Labour Organization (ILO). (2001) <em>Human resources development, employment and globalization in the hotel, catering and tourism sector. Report TMHCT/2001.</em> Geneva: ILO. Available at: <a href="https://www.ilo.org/public/libdoc/ilo/2001/101B09_23_engl.pdf">https://www.ilo.org/public/libdoc/ilo/2001/101B09_23_engl.pdf</a> (Accessed 09 April 2021)</p><p>International Labour Organization (ILO). (2002) <em>Women and men in the informal economy: A statistical picture (1st ed.).</em> Geneva: ILO.</p><p>International Labour Office (ILO). (2016). Women at work: trends 2016. Geneva: ILO.</p><p>International Labour Organization (ILO). (2017) Violence and Harassment against Women and Men in the World of Work: Trade Union Perspectives and Action,International Labour Organisation. Geneva: ILO.</p><p>International Labour Organization (ILO). (2018) <em>Women and Men in the Informal Economy: A Statistical Picture (3rd ed.).</em> Geneva: ILO.</p><p>Kermath, B. M., and Thomas, R. N. (1992). Spatial dynamics of resorts: Sosua, Dominican Republic. <em>Annals of Tourism Research</em>, <em>19</em>(2), 173–190.</p><p>Liu, A., &amp; Wall, G. (2006). Planning tourism employment: a developing country perspective. <em>Tourism management</em>, <em>27</em>(1), 159–170.</p><p>Losby, J. L., Else, J. F., Kingslow, M. E., Edgcomb, E. L., Malm, E. T., &amp; Kao, V. (2002). Informal economy literature review. <em>ISED Consulting and Research</em>, 1–55.</p><p>Lv, Z. (2020) Does tourism affect the informal sector?. <em>Annals of Tourism Research</em>, <em>80, </em>102816.</p><p>McElroy, J. L., Tarlow, P., &amp; Carlisle, K. (2007). Tourist harassment: Review of the literature and destination responses. <em>International Journal of Culture, Tourism and Hospitality Research</em>.</p><p>Mead, D.C., and Morrisson, C. (1996) The informal sector elephant. <em>World Development</em>, <em>24 </em>(10),1611–1619.</p><p>Moagi, T.J., Ivanovic, M. and Adinolfi, M.C. (2021) Business Challenges of Arts and Crafts Street Vendors at Key Tourist Attractions in Soweto, South Africa<em>. African Journal of Hospitality, Tourism and Leisure, 10</em>(1), 85–101.</p><p>Moreno, D. (2016) <em>Achieve gender equality and empower all women and girls</em>. Transforming Tourism. Available at: <a href="http://www.transforming-tourism.org/goal-5-gender-equality.html">http://www.transforming-tourism.org/goal-5-gender-equality.html</a> (Accessed 09 April 2021).</p><p>Moreno, D. (2017) <em>ODS, Turismo y Género: fundamentos y recomendaciones para la educación y sensibilización</em>. El Centro de Iniciativas para la Cooperación Batá. Available at: <a href="http://www.cicbata.org/sites/default/files/ODS%20TURISMO-GENERO.pdf">http://www.cicbata.org/sites/default/files/ODS%20TURISMO-GENERO.pdf</a> (Accessed 12 April 2021).</p><p>Moreno, D., and Cañada, E. (2018) <em>Gender dimensions in tourism work</em>. Barcelona: Alba Sud Publishing. Available at: <a href="http://www.albasud.org/publ/docs/81.en.pdf">http://www.albasud.org/publ/docs/81.en.pdf</a> (Accessed 09 April 2021)</p><p>Moreno, D. and Cole, S. (2019) No sustainability for tourism without gender equality. <em>Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 27</em>(7), pp. 903–919.</p><p>Moreno, D. (2020) <em>El impacto de género de la covid-19 en el turismo</em>. <em>Revista Turismo: Estudos e Práticas</em>, <em>9 </em>(Dossiê 2).</p><p>Newpane, S. (2020) Empowering Tharu and Bote Women Through Vocational Skills: A Case of Amaltari Homestay. <em>Journal of Training and Development, 5,</em> 49–59.</p><p>Odeku, K. O. (2020). The plight of women entrepreneurs during covid-19 pandemic lockdown in South Africa. <em>Gender &amp; Behaviour</em>, <em>18</em>(3).</p><p>Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD)/International Labour Organisation (ILO). (2018) <em>OECD Tourism Trends and Policies 2018: Peru. </em>[online]. Available at: <a href="https://www.oecd-ilibrary.org/sites/tour-2018-52-en/index.html?itemId=/content/component/tour-2018-52-en">https://www.oecd-ilibrary.org/sites/tour-2018-52-en/index.html?itemId=/content/component/tour-2018-52-en</a> [Accessed 09 April 2021]</p><p>Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD)/International Labour Organisation (ILO). (2019) <em>Tackling Vulnerability in the Informal Economy</em>. Paris: Development Centre Studies, OECD Publishing. Available at: <a href="https://www.oecd.org/fr/publications/tackling-vulnerability-in-the-informal-economy-939b7bcd-en.htm">https://www.oecd.org/fr/publications/tackling-vulnerability-in-the-informal-economy-939b7bcd-en.htm</a> [Accessed 09 April 2021]</p><p>Robson, P. J., Haugh, H. M., &amp; Obeng, B. A. (2009). Entrepreneurship and innovation in Ghana: enterprising Africa. <em>Small business economics</em>, <em>32</em>(3), 331–350.</p><p>Rogerson, C. M. (2006). Pro-poor local economic development in South Africa: The role of pro-poor tourism. <em>Local environment</em>, <em>11</em>(1), 37–60.</p><p>Rogerson, C.M. (2014) Informal business sector tourism and pro-poor tourism: Africa’s migrant entrepreneurs. <em>Mediterranean Journal of Social Sciences</em>, <em>5</em>(16), 153–161.</p><p>Rogerson, C. M. (2018). Informal sector city tourism: Cross-border shoppers in Johannesburg. <em>GeoJournal of Tourism and Geosites</em>.<em> 22</em>(2), 372–387.</p><p>Rosselló, J.G. and Cosmelli, J.L. (2021) The origin of Chilean pottery-making policies (1930–1990). <em>International Journal of Cultural Policy,</em> 1–17.</p><p>Slocum, S. L., Backman, K. F., &amp; Robinson, K. L. (2011). Tourism pathways to prosperity: Perspectives on the informal economy in Tanzania. <em>Tourism Analysis</em>, <em>16</em>(1), 43–55.</p><p>Sørensen, A., &amp; Babu, S. S. (2008). Tourism and the Informal Sector. <em>Tourism Development Revisited: concepts, issues and paradigms</em>, 88.</p><p>Timothy, D. J., &amp; Wall, G. (1997). Selling to tourists: Indonesian street vendors. <em>Annals of Tourism research</em>, <em>24</em>(2), 322–340.</p><p>Truong, V. D. (2014). Pro-poor tourism: Looking backward as we move forward. <em>Tourism Planning &amp; Development</em>, <em>11</em>(2), 228–242.</p><p>Truong, V. D., Liu, X., &amp; Pham, Q. (2020). To be or not to be formal? Rickshaw drivers’ perspectives on tourism and poverty. <em>Journal of sustainable tourism</em>, <em>28</em>(1), 33–50.</p><p>Trupp, A. and Sunata, S. (2017) Gendered practices in urban ethnic tourism in Thailand. <em>Annals of Tourism Research, 64</em>, 76–86.</p><p>UN (United Nations) (2012). <em>Report of the United Nations conference on sustainable development. [Report].</em> In: RIO+20, United Nations conference on sustainable development. Rio de Janeiro, 20–22 June 2012. New York: UN. Available at : <a href="https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/index.php?page=view&amp;type=111&amp;nr=1358&amp;menu=35">https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/index.php?page=view&amp;type=111&amp;nr=1358&amp;menu=35</a> (Accessed 09 April 2021)</p><p>UN (United Nations) <em>Women. (2020) Sexual harassment in the informal economy: Farmworkers and domestic workers. </em>New York: UN women. Available at: <a href="https://www.unwomen.org/-/media/headquarters/attachments/sections/library/publications/2020/discussion-paper-sexual-harassment-in-the-informal-economy-en.pdf?la=en&amp;vs=4145">https://www.unwomen.org/-/media/headquarters/attachments/sections/library/publications/2020/discussion-paper-sexual-harassment-in-the-informal-economy-en.pdf?la=en&amp;vs=4145</a> (Accessed 09 April 2021)</p><p>UNWTO (2019). <em>Global report on women in tourism: Second edition</em>. Madrid: United Nations World Tourism Organizations<em>. </em>Available at <a href="https://www.e-unwto.org/doi/pdf/10.18111/9789284420384">https://www.e-unwto.org/doi/pdf/10.18111/9789284420384</a> (Accessed 09 April 2021)</p><p>UNWTO (2020). <em>AlUla Framework for Inclusive Community Development through Tourism</em>. Madrid: United Nations World Tourism Organizations<em>. </em>Available at <a href="https://www.e-unwto.org/doi/epdf/10.18111/9789284422159">https://www.e-unwto.org/doi/epdf/10.18111/9789284422159</a> (Accessed 12 April 2021)</p><p>Vargas-Falla, A. M. (2016). <em>Legal empowerment of informal workers: Formalizing street vending as a tool for poverty reduction.</em></p><p>Wahnschafft, R. (1982). Formal and informal tourism sectors: A case study in Pattaya, Thailand. <em>Annals of tourism research</em>, <em>9</em>(3), 429–451.</p><p>Wahnschafft, R. (1982). Formal and informal tourism sectors: A case study in Pattaya, Thailand. <em>Annals of tourism research</em>, <em>9</em>(3), 429–451.</p><p>Williams, C. C. (2017). <em>Entrepreneurship in the Informal Sector: an institutional perspective</em>. Abingdon: Routledge.</p><p>World Bank (2019) <em>International tourism, number of arrivals — Peru</em> [data file]. Available at: <a href="https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/ST.INT.ARVL">https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/ST.INT.ARVL</a> (Accessed 09 April 2021)</p><p>Yotsumoto, Y. (2013). Formalization of Urban Poor Vendors and their Contribution to Tourism Development in M anila, P hilippines. <em>International Journal of Japanese Sociology</em>, <em>22</em>(1), 128–142.</p><p>Ypeij, A. (2012). The intersection of gender and ethnic identities in the Cuzco–Machu Picchu tourism industry: Sácamefotos, tour guides, and women weavers. <em>Latin American Perspectives</em>, <em>39</em>(6), 1</p><h3>Acknowledgements</h3><p>We would like to express our sincere gratitude to all the participants who agreed to take part in this project. Particular thanks go to the women in Chile and Peru who agreed to share their experiences of the covid-19 pandemic and the informal tourism sector with the authors. We would also like to thank Pablo Rosselló de las Casas, Sissi Hamann, and Alejandra Szczepaniak from the British council offices in Buenos Aires, Lima, and Santiago for facilitating access to interview participants.</p><p>This project is undertaken by the PEC International Council and supported by the British Council. The PEC International Council is a network of leading policy and creative economy practitioners from across the world. The group is convened by The British Council and is an international advisory body to the Creative Industries Policy and Evidence Centre (PEC), which is led by Nesta. This project was also supported by Oxford Brookes University.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4fcb91ef3ddc" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/informal-economy-in-the-global-south/the-impacts-of-the-covid-19-pandemic-on-female-groups-working-in-the-peruvian-and-chilean-informal-4fcb91ef3ddc">The impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic on female groups working in the Peruvian and Chilean informal…</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/informal-economy-in-the-global-south">The Relationship between the Informal Economy and the Cultural Economy in the Global South</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The City as a Playground]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/informal-economy-in-the-global-south/the-city-as-a-playground-841aa132ffb7?source=rss-c19e5d3f505e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/841aa132ffb7</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[British Council Creative Economy]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 14 Jul 2021 07:20:33 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-08-04T12:59:27.794Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>By Tita Larasati</strong></p><p><strong>Jalanjajan.bdg as a juncture of informal economy and creative economy in Bandung</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*tQS0RvQL25C3-CZI4L795A.jpeg" /></figure><h3><strong>Section one</strong></h3><p><strong>Description of the case</strong></p><p><strong>Geographic area of Research: Bandung, West Java</strong></p><p>Bandung is the Capital City of West Java Province. Within a year, Bandung has an average temperature of 19–23 degree Celsius. Bandung is currently inhabited by approximately 2.5 million citizens (the Central Statistics Agency/ BPS, 2018), with 1,400 people/km2 density. The main potential of Bandung is its human resources, especially the younger generation, supported by its natural beauty and cool climate. Bandung is dominated by the productive age group (15–64 years), 72.4% of the whole population, reaching up to 1.81 million people. Since 1930s, Bandung has gained a reputation as a popular destination for fashion, culinary and hospitality experiences.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/516/0*ukeDfuW8yVBfXfD9" /><figcaption>ectionFigure 1. City of Bandung, located in West Java Province, Indonesia</figcaption></figure><h3><strong>Bandung City Profile</strong></h3><p><strong>Cultural Economy Sector Focus</strong></p><p>Bandung was selected as a pilot project of creative cities in Asia Pacific by British Council in 2006, and joined UNESCO Creative Cities Network (UCCN) as a City of Design in 2015. Currently, Bandung has 8.3% of creative economy players from West Java province (the second highest) (Bekraf, 2017) and has the highest number of creative economy companies in West Java, totalling up to 126,184 companies (BPS, 2016).</p><p>This success is supported by the existence of human resources in the form of creative communities, who are currently working together in a cross-sector creative forum, such as Bandung Creative City Forum (BCCF), a hub organisation for collaboration, networking and co-creation among communities.</p><p>Through its programmes, BCCF is able to influence the creative communities, society and the government to provide solutions for social and economic issues, including in the informal sector in Bandung.</p><p>Bandung has all these creative economy ecosystem elements;</p><ul><li>Human resources with skills and knowledge in the creative industries</li><li>Products (good and services) in the creative fields</li><li>Market/users with high appreciation of the works</li><li>Research and development platforms.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/514/0*ncVMww2PIUmJdksF" /><figcaption>Figure 2. People, Place, Ideas in Bandung City</figcaption></figure><h3><strong>Ecosystem of Creative Economy and Informal Economy</strong></h3><p>“Creative Economy” was elevated to the world of economic and development agenda by the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD) in 2004; defined essentially as “the knowledge-based economic activities upon which the ‘creative industries’ are based”. It includes all parts of the creative industries that are also considered an important source of commercial and cultural value; including trade, labor and production, “the most dynamic sectors that provide new opportunities for developing countries to leapfrog into emerging high-growth areas of the world economy”.</p><p>United Nations Educational, Science, and Cultural Organization (UNESCO) defines creative economy as bringing together the sectors of the economy “whose main purpose is the production or reproduction, promotion, dissemination and/or the marketing of goods, services and activities that have cultural, artistic or patrimonial content”.</p><p><strong>The Importance of Creative Economy:</strong></p><ul><li>The creative economy is important for the future because it is rooted in creativity, which is a renewable resource based on knowledge and community. Daniel H. Pink (2005) in his book “A Whole New Mind” states that in the future, creative thinking is very important. Six basic creative thoughts from Pink are: Not just function but also DESIGN, not just argument but also STORY, not just focus but also SYMPHONY, not just logic but also EMPATHY, not just seriousness but also PLAY, not just accumulation but also MEANING.</li><li>One of the essences of creativity is a strong idea and it is an important factor in economic growth as stated by John Hawkins in his book on the definition of creative economy, namely “The Creation of Value as a Result of Idea”.</li><li>The creative economy is a sector that can collaborate Indonesia’s wealth (natural, cultural and human resources) driven by creativity and innovation to create added values.</li><li>The creative economy has contributed to the national economic growth. The GDP (Gross Domestic Income) of the creative economy in 2018 increased to Rp.1.105 trillion with a contribution to national GDP of 7.16% (Bekraf, 2019).</li></ul><h3><strong>Informal Economy</strong></h3><p>It is now widely accepted that the informal economy involves income generating activities that fall outside of state regulation. The International Labour Organization (ILO), the international agency that focuses mostly on the informal economy and its statistics, in particular, describes it as referring to “…all economic activities by workers and economic units that are — in law or in practice — not covered or insufficiently covered by formal arrangements” (Brown, D., McGranahan, G., &amp; Dodman, D., (2014). Godfrey (2011) stated that informal economy is identified as business activity that is unregistered or otherwise untracked and thus unregulated, but not otherwise illegal (McGahan, 2012).</p><p>It can be said that the informal business sector is a business sector that is not registered and conforms to formal regulations. Understanding the identification of the informal sector is quite complicated because sometimes it also overlaps with the management which still follows the formal rules, although not completely. There are many different layers of informal types, different explanations for each category and there is no clear statement of comparison between the two different forms (formal and informal).</p><p>While it is generally accepted that the informal economy involves activities that fall outside the purview of state regulation, this definition has gone through a number of subsequent revision to reflect the heterogeneity of the informal economy and its linkages with the formal economy (Chen 2007, 2012; ILO 2002b).</p><p>It defines economic informality around these three concepts (Brown, D., McGranahan, G., &amp; Dodman, D., 2014):</p><ol><li>The informal sector, which refers to production and employment in unregistered enterprises.</li><li>Informal employment, which focuses on employment outside of the labour protection regulations of a given society, whether informal or informal enterprises.</li><li>The informal economy, which covers all enterprises, workers, and activities that operate outside the legal regulatory framework of society, and the output that they generate.</li></ol><p>The informal forms emerged because of poorly designed regulations and formal procedures which made it difficult for certain segments of society.</p><p>The informal economy is now a significant and permanent phenomenon that is growing in most parts of the world in response to the ongoing global economic crises. This is also reinforced by research conducted by Rakowski (1994) and Tokman (1989) that the scale of the informal economy continues to grow due to several factors, including the informal sector being the key to economic growth and poverty reduction. Informality can increase the economic stability of the community and become an important factor in urban resilience. City resilience describes the capacity of cities to function, so that the people living and working in the cities — particulary the poor and the vulnerable-survive and thrive no matter what stresses or shocks they encounter (Arup, 2014).</p><p><strong>Informal Economy as a Support System for Creative Activities</strong></p><p>As a dynamic sector, the creative economy is supported by many actors who form an ecosystem for the continuity of creative activities. One of which is the informal sector. The participation of these various actors has supported the regional development, especially Bandung as one of the creative cities in Indonesia. An ecosystem that involves multiple actors participation is known as the helix concept. The concept of helix continues to develop from the triple-helix, quadruple-helix, penta-helix to the hexa-helix. The triple-helix concept focuses on the relationship between academia, industry and government. The Quadruple-helix concept complements the previous concept with the relationship between academia, industry, government and community. The fourth actor, Community, provides a new approach to economic improvement through socio-cultural values based on the people’s point of view.</p><p>In order for the creative economy to develop more rapidly and equitably, collaboration between academia, business sectors, government, community and media, needs to be implemented to develop the helix concept. ICCN (Indonesia Creative Cities Network) has developed a framework to analyze the role of creative economy stakeholders in an area known as Hexa Helix Creative Economy Stakeholders, by having Financial Institutions as the sixth helix.</p><p><strong>Playing Activities as a Juncture of Creative Economy and Informal Economy</strong></p><p>In JalanJajan.bdg, play activities become the media or creative activities that bring people together with the informal economy sector. With fun and interesting activities, either alone or with family, many people are interested in participating in JalanJajan.bdg activities and provide benefits to increase the economic value of the informal sector.</p><p><strong>Definition of Play</strong></p><p>A free-ranging voluntary activity that occurs with certain time and place limits, according to accepted rules. Play is accompanied by feelings of tension and joy and an awareness that it differs from ordinary life’ (Albon, 2001, p.357). ‘Play is a spontaneous, voluntary, pleasurable and flexible activity involving a combination of body, object, symbol use and relationships. In contrast to games, play behaviour is more disorganised, and is typically done for its own sake (i.e., the process is more important than any goals or end points)’ (Smith, 2013, p.2).</p><p>Apart from being a fun activity, playing has many benefits and it is a foundation in shaping one’s character. Play is also beneficial in improving cognitive abilities; be a medium for children to learn to solve problems. Playing for children is a learning process to interact and understand the environment and objects around them.</p><p>Playing characteristics:</p><ul><li>Active (physically &amp; mentally)</li><li>Meaningful</li><li>Symbolic</li><li>Voluntary or self-chosen</li><li>Pleasurable</li><li>Process oriented</li><li>Intrinsically motivated</li><li>Adventurous and risky</li><li>Self-directed</li></ul><h3><strong>Case description: JalanJajan.bdg</strong></h3><p>ICCN (Indonesia Creative Cities Network) is a hub organization, formed in 2015, that has connected initiatives and communities in up to 210 cities/regencies from all over Indonesia. All ICCN members are committed to implement the 10 Principles of Creative City, which comply to the pillars of Sustainable Development Goals. Some of the characteristics of Bandung as the most prominent creative city are “a compassionate city”, “an inclusive city”, “glorifies the creativity of its people”, and “maintains the wisdom of its history while building the spirit of reform”. With this spirit, Bandung has had several events involving the informal sectors in developing its potential as a creative city, including Airborne.bdg at Linggawastu, Fashion Village Lab at Cigondewah, and JalanJajan.bdg around Braga area.</p><p>Figure 3. The intertwined between informal economy and creative economy</p><p><strong>Why JalanJajan.bdg?</strong></p><ul><li>Bandung’s great potentials, including informal culinary vendors, also its historical and cultural stories.</li><li>Bandung’s demography. Bandung is mostly inhabited by young people especially students whose characteristics are fun, playful, adventurous, etc. It is one of the most popular tourist destinations in West Java. Many people come to Bandung to enjoy the city.</li><li>Mixing culinary experiences, cultural and historical storytelling, and city exploration on foot.</li><li>Become a medium for the creative economy actors to build intimate networks with the food vendors in the informal economy sector.</li></ul><ol><li><strong>Description of JalanJajan.bdg</strong></li></ol><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*ApO8fm0Ng23aCtW8" /><figcaption>Figure 4. JalanJajan.bdg Themes</figcaption></figure><p>JalanJajan.bdg is an initiation of Bandung Creative City Forum in an Urban Game activity to get to know the city through its local culinary and historical approach. The activities are guided by a book that contains a map and 20 challenges, so that the participants can walk and explore the corners of the city, be encouraged to empathize with the environment and various elements surrounding the targeted creative economy actors.</p><p>In JalanJajan.bdg, there are several rules to be followed by the participants, as follows:</p><ol><li>Participants are usually divided into teams with 5–6 members.</li><li>Every team will have a guide book which contains challenges, riddles, and clues; a journey map and cutleries. Participants are not allowed to use digital map from any kind of device.</li><li>Each team is required to finish every mission in the guide book.</li><li>All trip should be on foot.</li></ol><p>This event also included participants from various age and background each year. For example, in 2019 the participants of JalanJajan.bdg are international students from a Summer School program of a university.</p><p>The second Jalanjajan.bdg event in 2019 collaborated with thespecial.id / Widyatama Art Therapy Centre to design merchandises for JalanJajan.bdg with diffable students. During the process, the students were guided with professional product designers from a local merchandise brand, McBlush Gift.</p><p>In 2020, JalanJajan.bdg took part in Helarfest 2020, a community festival held by Bandung Creative City Forum since 2008. Due to the pandemic, the team experimented on a hybrid method to conduct the game. Held as a form of activity during the Placemaker e-Weekend ASEAN with the theme “CureYourCity: Sneaking and Snacking in The City”, the event presented talks and discussion sessions, next to the game itself. Participants joined the game online through Zoom, YouTube, and Kahoot. They ‘walked’ along the recorded journey that was streamed in 360 degree video in YouTube, while simultaneously attending a Zoom meeting, where a facilitator guided the virtual tour and provided short videos and quizzes that contained expert explanations and “fun facts” of the visited spots and related topics.</p><h3><strong>JalanJajan.bdg Activities</strong></h3><p><strong>Strolling around the city</strong></p><p><strong>Warung Kopi Purnama<br></strong>Warung Kopi Purnama is one of the oldest coffee shops in Bandung and is a culinary heritage site in West Java. Purnama Coffee Shop has been operating since 1930. At its inception, the restaurant that was founded by Yong A Thong was named Chang Chong se, which means: Good luck! In line with the policy of the Government of the Republic of Indonesia, in 1966 this restaurant changed its name to Indonesian language “Warung Kopi Purnama”. The interior inside the coffee shop is very thick with historical elements. You can see antiques and a variety of old furniture. The building is in the classical Chinese Malay style.</p><p><strong>Pisang Goreng Simanalagi<br></strong>Pisang Goreng Simanalagi is a legendary shop located at Jalan Dalem Kaum, which specializes in serving various fried bananas such as, fan fried banana, fried plantain banana and <em>gegedoh </em>fried banana. This shop was founded by Mrs. Tjiong in 1948. <em>Pisang Goreng</em> means fried banana fritters. A lot of Indonesian snacks are fried and <em>pisang goreng</em> is one type of traditional food that is usually eaten as afternoon snack.</p><p>Pisang Goreng Simanalagi has been operating for more than 20 years. In terms of hierarchy, Pisang Goreng Simanalagi is the royalty of fried bananas. It is much more expensive than other <em>pisang goreng</em> in general, and it ranks very high in taste and quality. The seller only uses good quality cooking oil and flour and the serving size is also bigger than other <em>pisang goreng</em>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*vtrV32pg9D8r23A9" /><figcaption>Figure 5. <em>Pisang Goreng</em> Simanalagi</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Rumah Makan Linggarjati<br></strong>Linggarjati restaurant has been established since 1960 in Bandung. It sells special menus, namely yamin and avocado ice. <em>Yamin </em>is a typical Bandung culinary food made from noodles which has two flavors, i.e., sweet and salty. The dish is complemented by a wide selection of side dish toppings and a separate chicken stock served in a bowl.</p><p><strong>Mie Ayam Kampung Tjiong Lung<br></strong>Mie ayam Tjiong Lung is a simple shop that has been selling native chicken noodles since 2012. Chicken noodles is a typical culinary food of Bandung. It is a common Indonesian dish of seasoned yellow wheat noodles topped with diced chicken meat. In Indonesia, the dish is recognized as a popular Chinese Indonesian dish, served from simple traveling vendor carts frequenting residential areas, humble street-side <em>warung</em> to restaurants.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*jt2jPNxaIthWI-Dc" /><figcaption>Figure 6. The founder of Mie Ayam Tjiong Lung</figcaption></figure><h3><strong>The Actors</strong></h3><ul><li>Informal Actors</li><li>Participants</li><li>Committee</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*gs6QaYoenMZltTZ6" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*KjXRSi-mhftP0fcy" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*cxT7-KW3KOkaRi1c" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*93LaGluBn3S_N3YQ" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*quY6Nf5nygjCfvju" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/858/0*cCwV7Qgr5llb3RAM" /><figcaption>Figure 7. All the actors of JalanJajan.bdg</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Jalanjajan.bdg and Inclusivity<br></strong>In 2019, Jalanjajan.bdg collaborated with thespecial.id / Widyatama Art Therapy Centre to design merchandises for JalanJajan.bdg with diffable students. During the process, the students were guided with professional product designers from a local merchandise brand, McBlush Gift.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/0*aDGXEZUYUMBoCFux" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*4crOtxHBoNcGB28w" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*2gXPU9mAOydEpO8E" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*FDB1ZDUfe3pOwE0k" /></figure><p>Figure 8. Collaborative project between JalanJajan.bdg and thespecial.id / Widyatama Art Therapy</p><p><strong>Hybrid (Offline and Online) Method of JalanJajan.bdg in 2020</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*ED4Xs-oWMXpOKFEa" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*Fu-ct9sQkoHy8Qmp" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*cYY27_Xqx1vOlqge" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*RqqniDPV2VrxPX6z" /><figcaption>Figure 9. Online activity of JalanJajan.bdg during the pandemic</figcaption></figure><h3><strong>Methodology for the investigation</strong></h3><p>Although the study on “informality” in the creative economy has been numerously conducted, not many have explored deeper into the forms of actual collaboration between informal economy and creative economy actors. With this JalanJajan.bdg research, we attempt to examine how a group of creative economy actors in Bandung City created a game system for the general audience as the game participants, to walk, explore, and buy or taste food that are sold by vendors in the informal economy sector in several locations in Bandung. A great number of participants of JalanJajan.bdg have even returned to the vendors, becoming their regular customers.</p><p>The method used in analyzing JalanJajan.bdg programme is through:</p><p>1. Literature study related to creative economy, informal economy, principles of creative cities, and playing activities.</p><p>2. Data findings on the past activities of JalanJajan.bdg (2016–2020), including documentation and recording analysis, and collecting merchandise.</p><p>3. Tracing back the route of JalanJajan.bdg to experience the vibe of strolling around the city while enjoying the riddles and mission with ethnographic method.</p><p>4. Data analysis using the 10 principles of creative cities.</p><p>5. Findings and Conclusion.</p><h3><strong>Theories and Literature</strong></h3><p><strong>Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) by United Nation</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/728/0*vzkpHkOliqsSQ5PO" /><figcaption>Figure 9. 17 Goals of Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs)</figcaption></figure><p>The development of the creative city concept cannot be separated from the principles agreed upon by world leaders, namely the 17 Agenda for Sustainable Development Goals (SGDs) from the United Nations. Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) are a global action plan agreed upon by world leaders, including Indonesia, to end poverty, reduce inequality and protect the environment.</p><p><strong>10 Principles of Creative Cities by ICCN</strong></p><p>ICCN (Indonesia Creative Cities Network) is a hub organization, formed in 2015, that has connected initiatives and communities in up to 210 cities/regencies from all over Indonesia. All ICCN members are committed to implement the 10 Principles of Creative City, which comply to the pillars of Sustainable Development Goals. Within the organisational structure, all ICCN members are managed by 13 regional coordinators and 20 sub-regional coordinators, next to the 6 deputies and the secretarial/administration team. ICCN is committed to advancing creative cities in Indonesia, by conducting research and development to foster economic development with creativity (the engine of creativity) in the form of creative and innovative ideas, or ideas that are supported by complete institutional infrastructure in the involvement of hexa-helix elements (bureaucracy, academics, business, community, media, financial institution) as well as the support of quality and modern digital infrastructure.</p><p>It is expected that the development program for creative cities in Indonesia will have a concrete impact on the economic sector, such as by increasing income, creating jobs, and opening up new business opportunities. In addition, it also has social &amp; cultural impacts, namely the growth of community pride, the formation of solidarity, togetherness and education for the community. Along with the creation of economic and socio-cultural values, this program can also have an impact on the environment such as developing regional potentials, tourist destinations and enhancing the image of the region.</p><p>ICCN has a representative in the city of Bandung, which focuses on developing experiential tourist destinations; culinary, fashion, shopping through urban scale solution initiatives by creative communities.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*MGvc9su57ZKe9zHE" /><figcaption>Figure 9. ICCN framework (Dwinita Larasati, 2020)</figcaption></figure><p>A creative city is a city that is able to improve the urban environment and create an inspiring city atmosphere. The first parameter of the creative city is the development of the creative economy potential. In the creative economy, we can prioritize the role of community participation and determinants of public policies and good environmental governance.</p><h3>10 Principles of Creative City</h3><p>1. Compassionate city. A city that upholds socio-cultural diversity, which is based on the values of compassion and caring;</p><p>2. An inclusive city. An open city, which glorifies human values and the spirit of togetherness, solidarity and peace;</p><p>3. A city that protects human rights. A city that defends all the economic, social and cultural rights of its people;</p><p>4. A city that glorifies the creativity of its people. Cities that develop intelligence, local wisdom, skills, creativity and ability to reason, science, and technology as a basis for creation and innovation;</p><p>5. A city that grows with a sustainable environment. A city that lives in harmony with the dynamics of the environment and natural surroundings;</p><p>6. A city that preserves historical wisdom while building a spirit of renewal to create a better future for all its people;</p><p>7. A city that is managed in a transparent, fair and honest manner. Cities that prioritize the value of mutual cooperation and collaboration, and open access and participation of the public to be involved in building their cities;</p><p>8. A city that can meet the basic needs of its people. A city that always strives to improve the welfare, happiness and quality of life of its people;</p><p>9. Cities that make use of renewable energy. A city that always strives to fulfil energy needs wisely and sustainably</p><p>10. Cities that are able to provide adequate public facilities for the community, including friendly facilities for vulnerable groups of people and with special needs.</p><p><strong>Hexa Helix of Creative Economy Stakeholders<br></strong>Hexa Helix is an ecosystem that shows collaboration between actors such as the government, academia, mass media, communities and also with the private sector, as an effort to develop the potential for the creative economy in a region; by generating 3 Cs (Connect, Collaborate and Commerce/Celebrate). The Hexa Helix concept can be used in analyzing and mapping the roles of each stakeholder in a creative activity.</p><ul><li><strong>Element A (Academia),</strong> has a significant role in research in the form of research, innovation, testing, and protection of intellectual property rights (IPR) which supports the creative economy.</li><li><strong>Element B (Business)</strong>, namely creative business actors who have an economic contribution and play a role in internal synergy between business people.</li><li><strong>The C (Community) </strong>element opens opportunities for interdisciplinary configuration and networking, and frees the concept of “innovation” from just economic considerations and goals, but also involves creativity as part of the process of production, knowledge and innovation (Yunas, 2019).</li><li><strong>Element G (Government)</strong>, namely actors from the central or regional government ranks who play a role in the provision of superstructure or policy basis, infrastructure or physical / non-physical facilities and infrastructure, and institutions to support creative economic activities.</li><li><strong>The M (Media)</strong> element has a significant role even though it is not directly affected by other elements in carrying out its functions (Satari &amp; Asad, 2016).</li><li><strong>The F (Financial Institution)</strong> element is a support for capital in various forms for the creative economy sector, such as banking and non-banking.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*DDz11cUISCRWMyfQ" /><figcaption>Figure 10. Hexa Helix and the Role of Creative Economy Stakeholders, (Dwinita Larasati, 2020)</figcaption></figure><h3><strong>Section two</strong></h3><p><strong>The Findings</strong></p><p><strong>1.What is the motivation for being in the informal sector?<br></strong>Business activities in the informal sector have different market segments from larger, modern and formal businesses. In the real situation, the informal economy can be formed with the support of strong social infrastructure from the closest social circles such as family and professional colleagues. The similar characteristics of informal economy and creative economy have also become factors that connect the two sectors. For example, the working conditions in creative economy fields are commonly casual, playful, and flexible, and develop its networks based on “family values” (Duffy, 2016; Neff, 2012; McRobbie, 1998; Ross, 2003).</p><p>These conditions are also found within the contexts of informal economy, whose workers generally thrive due to strong family ties among the actors, the sense to help each other in a community, and the strong awareness to build social networks as an “infrastructure” to survive (Mizen and Ofusu-Kusi, 2010; Simone, 2004; Malasan, 2019).</p><p><strong>2.</strong> <strong>What are the benefits of informality for your case?<br></strong>With the existence of informal economy, creative activities become more lively and the participants were excited to know the existence of the informal economy which has so far been missed or not known before. By involving the informal sectors in JalanJajan.bdg, the engagement process was rather very simple, for example to ask their consent as a part of the game, the committee did not have to follow official procedure, instead they approached the food vendors casually. The characteristics of the owners of the food vendors are also very nice and flexible.</p><p><strong>3. How does the informality speak back to some of the other SDGs<br></strong>Related to the SDGs, the JalanJajan.bdg program’s benefits are reflected in the following five goals, namely point 1 (No Poverty): By empowering businesses in the informal economy sector, people who have limitations in capital, work skills, or experience can run a business and earn regular income independently, 8 (Decent Work &amp; Economic Growth): The actors of the informal economy, with the support of social networks formed at this event, can get the attention of wider community so that in the longer term they form bonds with new customers and increase their income, 10 (Reduced Inequalities): In this event, everyone allowed to get equal opportunity to participate. They can participate actively, despite of different economical, educational, or cultural backgrounds. Participants can freely interact with the organizers and informal economy actors in the process of playing., 11 (Sustainable Cities &amp; Communities): By involving various elements of the city, the creative event has created an ecosystem that supports each other to form creative events and communities in a sustainable and flexible manner to improve their quality, through the informal sectors., 17 (Partnership for the Goals): The involvement of the formal and informal sectors in this event builds the exchange of knowledge, expertise, technology, and finance among all stakeholders who are actively involved.</p><p><strong>4. What are some of the challenges experienced from this informality?<br></strong>Difficulty of obtaining capital, the informal economy business model is still marginalized from the government system because it is difficult to detect, there is no standardization of quality (cleanliness, products, work system) and the working character of informal sector actors are considered inconsistent.</p><p><strong>5. What are the links with the formal sector of your case?<br></strong>By supplying the produced foodstuffs, the actors of the informal economy sector maintain a sustainable business ecosystem with the formal sectors such as restaurants, cake shops, etc. In addition, through the creative activities of JalanJajan.bdg, all stakeholders from the formal (professional designers, universities, foundations, etc.) and informal sectors get involved and form a collaborative network.</p><p><strong>6. Impact of Covid-19 on the work<br></strong>The Covid-19 pandemic encourages the new JalanJajan.bdg concept with an hybrid (online and offline) system, so that it has a wider exposure to national and international participants. This has been implemented in 2020 with the theme CureYourCity.</p><h3><strong>Section three</strong></h3><p><strong>Implications from the Case</strong></p><p><strong>1. Extent to which this case is an example of a trend or pattern in your territory.<br></strong>JalanJajan.bdg is a case where we consider as one of example of a trend or pattern of the juncture between informal sectors and the creative economy, especially in Bandung. Bandung is popular as one of culinary tourism destination area in West Java, and the informal sectors contribution in culinary tourism is also quite significant. This can be seen on mass media, such as television variety shows, and also social medias posts. Many of new and favourite culinary spots are basically informal economy sector. JalanJajan.bdg utilizes gamification to expose this potential by linking it to the historical aspects of the city.</p><p><strong>2. Implications for documentation and recording of cultural activity<br></strong>It is important to documenting and recording the whole activity related to this case, because of several things. First, one of the informal sector’s weakness is there is no guarantee that the business will survive for a very long term. This uncertainty become one of the main concerns why this informal sector needs exposure, new customers, and story to be told in order to offer a more sustainable business. The more the community is aware of the sector, the higher the possibility of the business to sustain. By making documentation and recording, not only we can keep the story for a long time, we can also make it accessible to the public and give the business more exposure.</p><p>Second, Indonesia has a huge number of creative cities with various creative potentials and always strive to develop the city with their own unique characteristics. The documentation and recording of creative events, such as JalanJajan.bdg, will become very useful for other city or region who would like to develop a program that can link the informal sectors with their creative activities.</p><p>Third, if only every cultural activity in all over Indonesia is documented and recorded properly, it would become one of the efforts for managing the cultural resources. By having the proper documentation and recording, the future generation can be aware and learn about their own culture better.</p><p><strong>3. Implications for public sector support<br></strong>JalanJajan.bdg is one of case where the Hexa Helix stakeholders are involved. Hexa Helix is an ecosystem that shows collaboration between actors such as the government, academia, mass media, communities and also with the private sector as an effort to develop the potential for the creative economy in a region; by generating 3 Cs (connect, collaborate and commerce/celebrate).</p><p>Government or the public sectors were actively involved in many creative activities in Bandung. The involvement become deeper as many activities or events were held in this city. This Hexa Helix stakeholder involvement in creative activities also has led the city government to ratify the first bottom up initiated local regulation (Perda) about Creative Economy Arrangement and Development in early 2021.</p><p>In this Creative Economy regulation, there are eight scopes that are regulated; creative economy actors, creative economy arrangement, creative economy development, creation centres and creative cities, creative economy structuring and development committee, funding, creative economy information systems and supervision and control. This new regulation is arranged and pushed by the local community, creative economy actors, and the public sector.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=841aa132ffb7" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/informal-economy-in-the-global-south/the-city-as-a-playground-841aa132ffb7">The City as a Playground</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/informal-economy-in-the-global-south">The Relationship between the Informal Economy and the Cultural Economy in the Global South</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Street life in Maboneng: Appearance and Disappearance in Constant Interplay]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/informal-economy-in-the-global-south/street-life-in-maboneng-appearance-and-disappearance-in-constant-interplay-16f0be9089ef?source=rss-c19e5d3f505e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/16f0be9089ef</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[British Council Creative Economy]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 14 Jul 2021 07:19:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-08-04T13:11:03.928Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>By Avril Joffe and Dimakatso Motholo</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*OocEGUC6Pk6ypSUl" /><figcaption>Credit: Dimakatso Motholo, Maboneng Map on entrance to Arts on Main</figcaption></figure><p><em>A project within the broader Informality in the cultural economy of the Global South project. This project is undertaken by the PEC International Council and supported by the British Council. The PEC International Council is a network of leading policy and creative economy practitioners from across the world. The group is convened by The British Council and is an international advisory body to the Creative Industries Policy and Evidence Centre (PEC), which is led by Nesta.</em></p><h3>Section One: Description of the case</h3><p><strong>Geographic area<br></strong>The research area is Maboneng, a Sesotho word meaning ‘Place of Light’, an inner-city area falling within City and Suburban, Jeppestown and New Doornfontein in the City of Johannesburg, South Africa. It was established as a private urban development in the south east of the central city of Johannesburg which attracted cultural organisations and creative enterprises. This previously industrial area known as City and Suburban was renamed Maboneng by the private developer, Jonathan Liebmann, founder of Propertuity, who initiated this property led creative cluster in 2009. The deindustrialisation process of the 1980s led to empty warehouses and factories which Propertuity acquired with a vision for ‘nurturing a creative community in inner-city Johannesburg’ (Gregory, 2016: 163).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/0*c3nQ40X0M2xcc3Xs" /><figcaption>Credit: Avril Joffe, David Krut Projects in Arts on Main</figcaption></figure><p>The first property developed was the Arts on Main complex occupied by one of South Africa’s leading artists, William Kentridge (the largest studio space) and the David Krut bookshop together with a range of artists and creatives in studios, galleries and office spaces (https://www.artsonmain.co.za/). Propertuity went on to acquire 25 (which rose to 42 by 2014) buildings in the area with other developments including Main Street Life building, the Main Change Building and Revolution house. The Main Street clustering many of the commercial businesses and residential components in the precinct remains in Fox Street, although other developments have occurred alongside the streets. The residential components were purposely developed to attract a range of income brackets from units in Artisan Lofts, The Urban Fox, the Rocket Factory, Craftsmanship and Hallmark House to penthouse apartments and single bachelor units.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/550/0*fQPKHuS6DSRNSL8m" /><figcaption>Credit: Dana Gampel, The Rooftop at Arts on Main was home to Salsa</figcaption></figure><p>Under the management of Propertuity the area became a vibrant cultural and entertainment hub attracting people from all over Johannesburg with weekly events (craft and food market at Market on Main, Fashion week, Cinema attractions, Salsa dance parties) hosted to attract people from all over Johannesburg to the precinct. With Propertuity no longer in existence having auctioned off buildings to individual owners and other property developers, the area is no longer managed centrally, although some activities continue. One area of visible creativity is that of the photographers and the street traders who are the focus of this study. Traders report that “things have gone down” since Propertuity left and that “tourists are not coming like before” although the latter is clearly due more to the Pandemic.</p><p>Despite the changes to, and actual absence now of precinct management, Maboneng remains a preferred site for many of these entrepreneurs who had worked previously in other malls or markets and reported difficulties, such as being chased away from Waterfall Mall in Pretoria (Mpho).</p><p>Maboneng is much written about particularly from the perspective of urban cultural development and the role of public policy to support cultural precinct development. There is much less attention given to the people who occupy the spaces, the nature of their engagements, their relationship to authority, to formal structures or the way in which they self-organise and the choices they make within the cultural precinct. The study highlights the constant interplay between what is “visible” and what is “invisible” between appearance and disappearance (Nuttal and Mbembe, 2008:6) as represented in research by Jane Guyer (2004), AbdouMaliq Simone (2004, 2010), Filip de Boeck and Marie-Francoise Plissart (2004), and Rem Koolhaas (2002). This case can be likened to Simone’s work on black urbanism and his effort to tie “together the various situations and tactics that have been at work in the long history of African people moving out, into and around a larger urban world” (2010: 268).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*3N7aIbPvJquh60Tc" /><figcaption>Credit: @eye_media_sa, The three photographers — owning the street and always hustling</figcaption></figure><p>The photography group consists of three friends who met in university residence while studying towards their engineering degrees at the University of Johannesburg. Sbu and Mpho were res mates and X was in the same class. Sbu and X were studying mechanical engineering while Mpho was doing electrical engineering. Between the three of them, Sbu already had an uncle’s camera and Mpho used bursary money to purchase a camera. They started working as photographers in late 2013, early 2014, however they only started working the Maboneng intersection (under the Maboneng sign) in 2016. Their knowledge of business was, in their opinion, very limited but they were driven by the need for fast, accessible cash.</p><p>They were attracted to photography both as an art form and as a potential income source as they developed various business propositions both before and after graduation. They were and remain friends and colleagues. However, each has chosen to manage and run his business slightly differently although given the informality and proximity of their working space (an intersection) as well as the trust between each other, their businesses have been able to coexist in a competitive but collaborative manner. They each need to attract their own customer base. This coopetition is possible given the strong relations of trust they have with one another and respect for each other’s business model. As Bengtsson and Kock (2003) explain, coopetition is “a situation where competitors simultaneously cooperate and compete with each other.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*tGRDmYAjreyetSUP" /><figcaption>Credit: @eye_media_sa, Street trader, working his magic making crafted jewellery</figcaption></figure><p>The street traders in Maboneng are mostly migrants who found that Maboneng had a faster trade than other typical tourist areas in Johannesburg (such as Newtown or Rosebank). They sell handmade crafts, jewellery and clothing as well as imported goods, mostly from the African continent and specifically from Kenya. They too are driven by the need to earn cash amounts that would not be possible in a typical 9–5 job. Some have been there for as long as 7 years while others are more recent (3 years) traders in the area. All of them worked in other markets and tourist areas before coming to Maboneng. Some of them (June, Joe) used to work on the street in Maboneng but now rent shop stores in the area while others (Milka) have worked in shop stores in Maboneng but returned to the streets where she found trade was faster and more agile. Joe works both on the street and from a shared shop space with business partner, Gianni and brother Peter.</p><p><strong>Methodology for the investigation: people as infrastructure</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*p3VFyFd9ZTIVe9Z1" /><figcaption>Credit: eye_media_sa, Milka at her table displaying beads and other wares</figcaption></figure><p>This study was conducted by two researchers as a qualitative exploratory study. The researchers spent time in the streets of Maboneng observing the photographers, visiting the retail stalls and rented spaces, having conversations with people visiting and working in the area, conducting formal interviews (photographers and traders) , focus group (with the photographic team) and photographs of work in process in the streets of Maboneng. The study zooms in on the photographers that occupy the key intersection of Fox and Kruger streets as well as the street traders (craft, fashion, textiles, jewellery) on either side of Fox Street, both sides of the intersection.</p><p>This study, following Simone, sees people as infrastructure which underscores the “economic collaborations among residents seemingly marginalised from and immiserated by urban life” (Simone, 2004: 407) and focuses on their fluid movement in and out of the formal and informal spaces and the informal and formal economy (Valodia and Devey, 2011). In this account, people themselves are, what Simone calls the “stuff of the shifting circuitries of connections” and provides a way to revalue their humanity. Importantly, the study is not about that which is ordered, formal or documented but allows us to redefine the “right to the city” as the “right to be messy and inconsistent, or to look disordered” (2010: 331). By observing, conversing with and interviewing these participants we were able to recognise the innovations which these two groups brought to their way of organising and way of working and, what Nuttal and Mbembe call “the role of calculation and rationality in the everyday tactics of those who inhabit them, and in the way they are made to work” (2008:6). This multidimensional understanding of infrastructure suggests, as Steele and Legacy do, that we need to “extend the lens through which we see infrastructure: as relational: ecological; as everyday practice: as inherently political; as embedded in questions of human and non-human justice and equity, fiscal transparency, institutional accountability” (2017:2).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/0*CkVeVJ559qtDhBLF" /><figcaption>Credit: Avril Joffe, A view of Fox street’s restaurant/ club scene, east side of the intersection</figcaption></figure><p>Treating people as infrastructure in this way, allows for a deeper dive into the constant interplay between the formal and the informal, and recognises the temporal nature of both (Rubin et al, 2020: 172). As this study shows, the working style of the photographers and street traders allows for agile decision-making dependent on both personal and external circumstance and carefully based on a perceptive assessment of need, desire, security, and income potential. Despite the obvious challenges of street life, the benefits of informality become clear when listening to the stories of these remarkably resilient men and women.</p><p><strong>Section two: Improvisation and constant change — the key to thriving in the informal economy?</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/425/1*wiAx9l4TkisETOG3S7JzNA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Credit: @eye_media_sa</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Reconfigured intersections and innovative economic transactions<br></strong>The intersection of Fox and Kruger “belongs’’ to the photographers. Each of the 4 core photography team leaders ply their trade in this intersection. They each have different strategies and different business models as illustrated by the diagramme below.</p><p>There are two groups in this study. They work side by side harmoniously with one group, the traders, relying on the other group, the photographers bring life to the streets which support their businesses. The photographers are predominantly South African, working informally on the streets helping to realise the social media addiction of South Africans to be seen, to be cool, to be spotted in interesting parts of Jozi (the name for Johannesburg) and to show off their latest styles (clothes, hair, shoes, bags, accessories and partners).</p><p>The core photographers see themselves as business people, as entrepreneurs, doing what it takes to support their dreams (which are not confined to the street). Working ‘with’ them, ‘for’ them or renting their equipment is another group of photographers (mostly friends and family) who earn well as photographers as well. The whole group is about 30 photographers. There is only one woman in the entire group. She is employed by one of the photographers. The group is self-organised although one of the photographers, X, plays the role of leader (specifically in terms of discipline, protocol, customer care, security and organiser).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/0*9QfgrqLOZQ8_RCHL" /><figcaption><em>Figure 1: Photographer’s business models outlined</em></figcaption></figure><p>None of the photographers are registered for UIF, pay PAYE or registered their photographic businesses. They base their work on strong relations of trust (friendship and family ties). They form a close social circle which allow forms of finance and non-written contracts distinct from the formal economy. This tight network of photographers and the trust they have in one another highlights the reliance on informal supporting networks based on hidden economy circuits. Their income and earnings remain uncaptured in economic statistics.</p><p>The informality of their business does not mean that they do not invest in their trade. They all use only the best Canon cameras, insist that they and their team are well reimbursed and pay attention to safety and visibility (the jackets with Maboneng official photographer). Mpho for instance invests in cameras which he rents to family members and friends and over time, after paying rent on it, they are able to buy the camera from him. Mpho records that he was able to earn ten times the amount of the camera through this rental structure.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*bPFCAJ5Cve2RGGWG" /><figcaption>Credit: @eye_media_sa, Street trader and his T-Shirts on the fence on Fox Street</figcaption></figure><p>The Street traders rely hugely on the photographers as “they brought life to Maboneng” in Joe’s words. June, who now works inside in a rented space agreed that if it wasn’t for the photographers business would be extremely bad. However street traders have bemoaned the fact that the real foot traffic remains on the east side of the intersection (the club and restaurant area) while the west side of Fox Street is not at all busy (only one restaurant). It is interesting that the street parking for the restaurant and club scene on the west side is targeted for clientele such that traders like Joe keep his stall running “until all the cars are parked — often 9pm” to catch those attending the club scene or patronising the restaurants. When asked about permits to trade on the street, Milkha clarified that while she registered with the municipality and was given tags to trade in the street, no one has ever asked her for these.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/0*QjBmQhJQdhGqUYpu" /><figcaption>Credit Avril Joffe, The Fence Display on the north side of Fox Street (west of the intersection) with current display visible on the south side outside the current shop.</figcaption></figure><p>The current craft and arts street traders are all Kenyan although their numbers are down since the Pandemic. One side of Fox Street used to be filled with traders (approximately 70 according to Milka) and is currently relatively empty (not more than 8). Milkha works next to the entrance of Arts on Main and used to be able to rely on the substantial foot traffic in and out of this property especially during Sunday market day. Joe used to display his goods on the fencing on the other side of the road but now opens his street stall right outside the store he rents with Gianni (through his business Plum Trading). Both these traders as well as June’s shop, Numa Africa are on the west side of the busy Fox/Kruger street intersection.</p><p>Maboneng is a relatively new area for this kind of trade. Both June and Milkha used to trade in Malls — June in the Rosebank Mall and Milkha in Dobsonville Mall. Some of these malls are over-traded with many traders selling similar goods. Milkha explained how she read about Maboneng in magazines and newspapers and in 2015 decided to come through to this new area. The caretaker of Arts on Main at the time, Given, directed her to a website to register as a trader. Some traders (Joe, Peter) still work at other weekend markets such as Victoria Yards in Bez Valley.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/936/0*FGfERO0qyE6c0zJ7" /><figcaption>Credit: @eye_media_sa, Joe displaying his wares at his street stall outside his shop and opposite the fence area where he used to work</figcaption></figure><p>Security is a huge concern for the traders, not only for them but their customers as well. As Milka explains “I feel real bad to sell to a customer whose phone is stolen. I feel so bad and embarrassed”. In terms of their own goods, security is a concern as storage is both expensive and not easily available. Milkha used to use the storeroom at Arts on Main but was apparently stopped from using it even though she was willing to pay. The absence and expense of storage, “the constant packing and unpacking and transporting all the goods away” is the key reason that Joe moved from the street into the shop.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*xZjvnJQrfqk_nkTf" /><figcaption>Credit: @eye_media_sa, Street trading on the fence side of Fox Street</figcaption></figure><p>Even if some of these traders have been in South Africa for up to 20 years, they do not necessarily have the right documentation (some have refugee papers) to work formally. Informal work or informal trading is often the only option open to a foreign national without official papers. It is less of a choice; it is rather a necessity. Obtaining finance is particularly difficult without these papers. As Joe explained, after he lost money on an African indigenous food restaurant in Turfontein, he came to Maboneng to sell Kenyan clothes; as he said, “no one will give you money”.</p><p>Nevertheless, these traders are all earning sufficient cash on the streets to not only survive in Johannesburg, but also to send cash home to Kenya. Joe, for instance, has two children in Kenya and regularly sends funds home and is saving for his dream of owning land in Kenya. When asked about this desire to own land, he responded eloquently, “when you own land, you are liberated”. He explained that in pursuit of this dream he was satisfied with a small dwelling for now (just two blocks to the south of the Maboneng area) so that he could save money to buy land. The reason for trading in South Africa rather than Kenya was simple: “the Rand is stronger!”.</p><p>Whether foreign nationals have papers or not, informal trading is characteristic of African economies. June (sister to Joe and Peter) explains that her understanding of informal business was learnt from her grandmother who ran an informal fruit market in Kenya when she was still in primary school. Her family is originally from Sudan, her grandmother is from the Luo tribe (found in Sudan, Kenya and Tanzania). June watched her grandmother doing business selling fruit to people from the airline (KLM) and sewing baskets with semi-ripe mangoes, bananas and flowers. With crew no longer coming in as much, the market fell and her sales dropped hugely. With her mom’s support they changed their business to sell natural black and white stone chess sets and opened a shop. June learned the need for agility and flexibility from her grandmother.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*obt1U1RerCJe1qG8" /><figcaption>Credit: @eye_media_sa Numa Africa shop with displays of baskets, shoes, cloth and fashion items</figcaption></figure><p>June decided to register her business as a company in 2006 (with her daughter) when she realised that she could earn good money from curating east African cuisine at big events in Mary Fitzgerald square (Newtown) for which registration was required. When she got her shop she wasn’t yet registered but realised that she needed to be registered. Her company is registered as arts and crafts and she uses the same registration for all aspects of her work. She used to also be the only service provider for ‘Back to the City’, a Hip Hop Music Festival that took place in Newtown in Mary Fitzgerald Square, where she curated hot food and beverages. When lockdown started, she started making clothes (on the advice of her brother Joe) and was able to purchase a portable sewing machine. From the proceeds from sewing masks for locals during lockdown, (she stopped as others were also making masks) she invested in her own machine. From her mom she learnt how to make jewellery with amber and Ethiopian silver. Her mom had worked for a Norwegian NGO and received training in jewellery design in Tanzania and Uganda.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/479/1*9gPBns9V8E93ZgHQYwHAJA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Credit: Avril Joffe</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Street trading and shop trading<br></strong>The street traders move somewhat seamlessly from the street to shops and back again depending on their assessment of the trade and the risks and challenges of street trading. Joe used to trade on the other side of the street, using the fencing to hang up his wares but he decided that the problems of storage and transport were too severe, so he relented and now shares a store front with his business partner Gianni. He shows his handmade and bought items on one side of a small 3 by 6 space while Gianni shows his mainly bought items on the other side. Others, like Milkha, continue to dodge rain and struggle with regular storage facilities after having shared June’s shop for a short while.</p><p>June opened her store, Numa Africa in June 2019. Before that she was on the street outside the Market Theatre (Newtown) selling a similar range of products, mainly fabrics from other African countries such as Kente cloth as well as blankets, jewellery and other craft items such as chess sets in natural stone (black and white), mainly from Kenya. June’s mom grew up next to Kissi where the natural stone originates in Kenya. June also had a small shop in a small flat in Newtown but had too many incidents from the nearby taxi rank. Once they built the Newtown Mall, she knew she needed to move (she didn’t feel it was conducive to street trading any longer). From her shop in Maboneng she is also able to use her sewing machine to make items from the cloth as well as outsource to other tailors and seamstresses. Her younger son apparently still feels that the street offers more opportunities. She feels it’s not true but acknowledges that her earning possibilities depend on tourism to the area. June now employs an assistant, Alex (a family relation).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*4D6V-YmeIWelFwLt" /><figcaption>Credit: @eye_media_sa Numa Africa’s interior showing shoes, cloth , fashion items</figcaption></figure><p>When Propertuity was still managing the area, June felt that working on the street was bearable. Their security, she felt was “fantastic. They would throw people out of the streets, didn’t tolerate ganga (marijuana), cell snatches and allowed artists to be on the street with allocated spaces”. Initially June shared her brother, Joe’s store. She was in during the week and he came in on weekends (when he was still working the food cuisine business in Turfontein). As her income increased, she realised she could afford her own shop and now manages to pay between R9000 and R12000 a month and still make a profit. At some point June was finding the rent steep and partnered with Milka (June 2019) to share the rent but after two months Milka wanted to go back to her stall on the street. June is now satisfied on her own, works with tailors and seamstresses for some of her clothes designs but feels she has “become self reliant” having purchased her own equipment.</p><p><strong>Photography on the street<br></strong>Eddie was seen as the first photographer in the area shooting for his own page on Instagram. Photography was, for him, a creative hobby which would also allow his Instagram followers to book him for gigs. However, when the 3 friends came in and he saw that they were making money, Eddie realized that in fact his creative hobby could be lucrative as a business. Eddie now also works the business in the same way but works in other locations as well. While he adopted the other three’s business model, his is not generating equivalent revenue.</p><p>As other people see the possibilities of income generation from the photography group, more want to work the area. The team of 4 realized they needed to both “keep it simple and manage themselves” and also limit the number of photographers working the area. Within the team, X took the responsibility of managing the space, and ensuring the safety of the photographers and telling people who are just hanging around, to move away.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/925/0*r6yGQY8XMyio4IJn" /><figcaption><em>Credit: @eye_media_sa, Offical Maboneng Photographer with his Canon camera</em></figcaption></figure><p>All 4 (and some of their ‘crew’) are now using “Official Maboneng photographer” blue and khaki vests to provide a degree of comfort and security given the escalation of petty crime on the Maboneng streets (smartphones, backpacks, etc). This was agreed to with the official Maboneng security personnel so that the photographers can be more easily identified and previous allegations of photographers doing crime could abate. This level of formality was accepted by the group as it enables them to work with ease on the street and creates a sense of community and solidarity among all 30 photographers.</p><p>Within these business models, the core innovation (as illustrated below) stems from moving away from shooting pictures and printing on the camera itself, or shooting pictures and then going somewhere to download to a PC, Print and emailing the product to the client, to shooting pictures and sending these directly to the smartphone in real time to the client.</p><h3>The motivation for being in the informal sector</h3><p><strong>Alternative financing<br></strong>There are seemingly many diverse and at times contradictory reasons for the decision to work informally. The photographers articulated a reason not often found in the literature; that as black people “we don’t have lot of knowledge about business” so this way of working resonated with them as a way to amass funds in an “accessible, fast” manner and we “realized [we] can quickly make cash here and then can expand and grow as a business”. They had more experience with how informal businesses work having grown up in townships around Gauteng watching family members in informal businesses. They also acknowledged that they had a “lack of understanding [of how] to get credit or funds” and were initially unaware of the importance of recording their business turnover to show a formal financial institution that their business had stability and the potential for growth.</p><p>This agile, flexible, simple and fast way to access cash (whether for the informal business or to amass capital for another business), combined with the paucity of formal sector jobs or a thriving economy for entrepreneurial activities is a core reason for educated, professional and hard-working individuals to remain in the informal economy. Working informally also means hiring of people is simpler (not necessarily more exploitative), training on the job is quick and efficient, and overheads can be kept very low.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*lRvuacZfX-XkakZO" /><figcaption>Credit: @eye_media_sa Three friends working competitively in cooperation: X, Sbu and Mpho</figcaption></figure><p>The photographers (unlike the street traders) have an expedient relationship to their informal business: it is precisely to amass sufficient capital to start and grow their media and communication companies as quickly as possible. The inability to raise this capital or approach the banks for loans has much to do with the large concentrations and assumption of formality of business in South Africa. Many young black entrepreneurs however have no networks, role models or indeed capital to kick start their entry into formal professional work. They also do not necessarily have connections to larger formal enterprises in the economy.</p><p>The photographers spoke with passion about their long term vision which required them “getting as much money as we can to fund other businesses; photography is our cash cow”. The photographers report being able to earn upwards of R40 000 a month (whether raining or shining). This is way beyond the national minimum wage (R3633) or even an entry level position as a young qualified engineer. Each photograph is sold for R20 to the customers.</p><p>Despite the photography business being a “means to an end” the photographers periodically invest (some every year, others wait longer) in their business by buying better cameras — “they change but not as quickly as a cell phone” — to stay competitive. Their strategy of keeping the profits flowing is both a mindset and an action. For instance, if there is little business on the streets, they will take pictures wherever people are “hiding”: in clubs, in restaurants, at live events.</p><p>This need for cash appears to be the key motivation for the informality of the business. As X elaborated: “when [you] come from a background that is disadvantaged — once making money — I need to get money to pay rent , to get transport and eat; so the main focus is basic survival. This is why we ended up focusing on the informal as it was a quick way”.</p><p>Their own experience of witnessing how informal businesses worked meant that “tapping into that it was comfortable, it was informal, day to day things to make cash — so much easier than pitching and waiting for a response”. They had discussed pitching for contracts and tenders but concluded that the time it would take to get actual cash into their pockets would take too long. As they say, this is the “gap between formal — to pitch and the informal [that] gives the bread today”. Plus, they added, the money made was indeed substantial.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/400/1*BI-S5ofenDwhWwI4kqLzMQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Credit: @eye_media_sa Photographers use only the best equipment</figcaption></figure><p>In fact, seeing the potential growth of their informal business, they wanted to consider ways to grow and expand without necessarily entering into the formality of company registration or freelance nor salary contracts. As Mpho explains:</p><p>“We focused on how to manage the demand … and didn’t make it formal. We wanted to bring in more photographers under me [and] give them a platform. They give me R300 every week [rental for the cameras]”.</p><p>The three friends feel that everyone has brought in something (skills, expertise, experience) enabling them to meet the demand. They are now beginning to employ people such as Sbu, who has only recently decided to rent a studio space, just off the main intersection of Fox and Kruger Streets, where he now employs a cashier, a studio manager as well as a photographer. This studio will work in much the same way as the street, same flexibility, same innovation of shoot to What’s App or flash drive, but with the added convenience of dress up, different backgrounds and without the elements (rain or hot weather) keeping customers away.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*dTqudDs7c9d3sBsF" /><figcaption>Credit: @eye_media_sa, The Maboneng sign just off the intersection of Kruger and Fox Streets</figcaption></figure><p><strong>The benefits of informality: collaboration, flexibility and agility<br></strong>The photographers’ experience demonstrates the ease of access to cash flow in this informal way of working. They all feel that they are in charge of their own destinies as their ability to raise this much needed working capital means they are not beholden to formal contracts, tenders or loans from the banks. Maboneng’s vibrant street life and the attraction of the Maboneng Sign for social media enthusiasts has also shown them that the “harder you work the more you earn” and that “working with friends you trust” gives you the agility in responding to need or in moving to alternative spaces. It is also, apart from the purchase of the camera, extremely low cost.</p><p>The more than 30 young people employed or working with the photographers are all able to earn in a day more than an average salary of a qualified professional.</p><p>The photographers recognise the problem of working <em>in</em> the business rather than <em>on</em> the business. They acknowledge that while Mpho can take a holiday and still earn (from rentals), Sbu is more stuck “as people on a salary get lazy”. Sbu agrees, “yes, its true”. He adds that ‘every side has a disadvantage”.</p><p>They ponder the problem of scale. How to scale up the business without being hooked into the day to day running of it. They wander aloud whether the desire by informal sector businesses for sustainability is not a contradiction in terms. Many cultural professionals acknowledge having multiple forms of income generation and the need to constantly hustle and move as opportunities arise. It is no wonder that the impetus to formalise is simply not there as it is not known whether this particular way of earning income will last for long. This is evidenced in that many of the photographers have other work that earns them income both within and outside the cultural economy.</p><p><strong>Entrepreneurial innovations among photographers and traders</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*KkQIwJj3IxebnJ_E" /><figcaption>Credit: @eye_media_sa, Payment transaction using ikhokha device, staying safe during Covid-19.</figcaption></figure><p>The street traders, perhaps since some of them also rent stores, seemingly had a better system of record keeping and financial management. However, access to capital is not an option given their lack of residency status in the country. However two of the traders were able to use technology to stimulate trade without major compliance issues. The Ikhokha and Noko devices enable debit and credit card payments which is so important in South Africa given the strong possibility of cash theft for both consumers and traders. It is also useful, as June says in supporting the growth of her business. It serves also as a record of sales and turnover with repayments for the device taken off the purchases.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/0*ivZHSP8einO2errB" /></figure><p>Digital technology has been the key innovation for the photographers who immediately recognised that they did not want to take pictures and then download them to computer to print out; that they also didn’t want to print them out directly for the customer but rather to deliver the photographers directly onto their smartphones for them to use on their social media. This is a complete change in how street photographers typically work in South Africa.</p><p><strong>Inclusion and exclusion: the gender dimensions</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*Z0T-pkjUMOMQuio6" /><figcaption>Photo: @eye_media_sa One of the only female photographers working the streets in Maboneng</figcaption></figure><p>The 3 friends are all male and most of the 30 photographers are also male. Sbu has recently employed a woman to work in the Studio. This reality of the exclusion of women speaks both to the industry of photography and how these ‘teams’ have developed (friendship circles starting with the 3 men) but also to the lived experience of women in the streets of South Africa — if you don’t feel safe on the streets why would you occupy it as a place of work? This can be contrasted to the very many women working as traders but mostly in ‘safer’ locations such as indoor markets, containing weekly markets or the malls.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*eMq5-q4_HU1sGM3P" /><figcaption>Credit: @eye_media_sa, Milka stays strong and resilient in the face of many challenges facing women street traders</figcaption></figure><p>Women traders such as Milka are seen as particularly strong, resilient and “not to be messed with” by the other men traders who recognise that it is that much more complicated for women to be trading on the streets. It raises the question of whether the collective ownership of street security and safety by the previous precinct management (Propertuity) enabled more women to feel safe to trade on the streets and what other measures are needed to ensure the inclusion of women cultural entrepreneurs. In respect of both the gendered dimensions of our participants as well as the refugee status of many of the traders, it is clear that the impact of informality is felt most keenly where agency and representation is absent. In a study of women informal workers in Durban, for instance, the organisation representing women’s rights in the informal economy (SEWA) was credited as critical to ensuring that the voice of women informal workers was heard and that the resulting local government’s policy outcome was gender neutral (Skinner and Valodia, 2020: 442).</p><h3>The SDGs and informality</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*LwI_97zefvt6VspA" /><figcaption>Credit: @eye_media_sa The second Maboneng street sign facing affordable container housing</figcaption></figure><p>The thematic indicators for culture in the 2030 agenda for sustainable development include</p><ul><li>prosperity and livelihoods (cultural employment and businesses, trade in cultural goods and services, public finance for culture and the governance of culture);</li><li>knowledge and skills (cultural knowledge, multilingual education, cultural training and education);</li><li>inclusion and participation (artistic freedom, access to culture, cultural participation, participatory processes);</li><li>environment and resilience (sustainable management and expenditure on heritage, climate adaptation and resilience, cultural facilities and open spaces for culture).</li></ul><p>The SDGs speak to a world of decent employment, entrepreneurship and innovation, gender inclusion, access to education, participation and inclusive public spaces amongst others. What this study on informality reveals is the distance between these indicators, or intentions, and the lived reality of people working on the streets. These informal cultural professionals and workers demonstrate the absence of not only public finance for culture, but open spaces for culture and indeed the difficulties in building up cultural businesses or ability to participate in decision making. The transversal contribution of women participation and leadership or policies on gender equality are difficult to achieve when women struggle to earn an income unless mediated by physical infrastructure (buildings, transport) and the presence of security and safety measures governing how trade occurs.</p><p>What Maboneng offers as a cultural precinct, despite its private sector nature, are partnerships between public, private and civil society, open spaces for culture, social inclusion and inclusive public spaces with some attempt to mitigate the risks of street trading. The participants in this study indicate their contribution to keeping public spaces open, to ensuring an open space for culture, and for collaboration and partnerships. There is so much more that needs to be done to provide quality infrastructure and equitable access to ensure genuine participation let alone to facilitate and catalyse the entrepreneurial and innovative skills demonstrated by this group of cultural workers.</p><p><strong>The challenges experienced from this informality<br></strong>The major challenges of informality relate to financial issues, in particular a record of stability of the business. The photographers, unlike the traders, were not diligent about their documentation and preferred mobile loans and debt financing for their personal goals.</p><p>A key negative for each of the group of 4 is that, as they said, while they have a very good income, they have no record of that, so that they are not deemed to be creditworthy. They are not able to get a lease agreement to purchase a car, purchase assets on credit — credit makes you grow faster — that’s the disadvantage. This too goes back to the lack of knowledge they had about growing a business and the lack of role models to advise them.</p><p>As Sbu said, learning in an informal way of working is “easy” as the “formal sector is structured to be so complicated”. He added that while they do use bank accounts, this is not sufficiently consistent to show a monthly income. With some regret he referred to a question posed to him “didn’t you put money in one bank so there could be a record” and his explanation to us is “that is knowledge!”. He added, “It’s not as easy as it can side — took a long time to understand”.</p><p>For the three engineers, photography was their way of accessing quick urgent capital both to live on, but also to invest in their respective companies. In the absence of the formal banking sector or other financial institutions providing seed capital for their embryonic companies, they were clear that applying for tenders, waiting for results and waiting to be paid was a poor option when photography provided the immediacy of cash flow. Nevertheless, they also didn’t use this regular income source to prove their viability and credit worthiness for larger loans. In fact, they feel certain that, what they call the “stereotype that informal is a bad thing” has made them “lose out”, in terms of being taken seriously by financial institutions. When asked about applying for government contracts in their professional fields, the four engineers did not view this with any enthusiasm. They explained that they would need to have a longer record of trading, contracts, tax compliance, healthy bank statements and formal structures to secure such contracts.</p><p><strong>Fluidity of movement between informal and formal parts of the economy<br></strong>The photographers of Maboneng, are, on the back of the cash flow realized through photography, pursuing their other interest in having a media company. This would be “mainly focused on everything to do with media — production, advertising, shoot it, design layout, production and media”. They registered their company Eye Media SA with the intention of making it a professional company, with an office and began initially with Sbu and X as Mpho was working for Prasa (a transport company) at the time. The media company was initially called Fruitboom media. They parted ways with Sbu retaining ownership of this company. X started a new company called Oomchenge Solutions (Oomchenge is his clan name referencing a belief in his ancestors and everything that derives from heritage and culture). Mpho has also started a new company called ‘Cactus and Tomatie’ which references something that is between a fruit and vegetable (Skwandele reference).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/451/0*9-ZyREKK8tUzEj_0" /></figure><p>The informality they have chosen for their photography business allows these cultural entrepreneurs to play multiple roles in their media businesses. They work on creation (content production), the production process itself (video, pictures), marketing (discussing vision and visibility with clients). Most of their work is in business to business rather directly with clients. They work as retainers for other companies. They combine their respective skills in various assignments depending on where the emphasis is.</p><p>When asked about the coexistence and duality of this formal way of working with their street photography business they highlighted that this was a fluid movement with both co-existing within a similar cultural value chain of media and communication.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*wgLnc3D23pCgr_eL" /><figcaption>Credit: @eye_media_sa, Milka and her table of beads</figcaption></figure><p>Milkha decided in 2016 to work from inside a shop (she shared with June). They kept the tables on the pavement. Although she did this for two years, she realised that her trade was brisker and more profitable on the street. She found the rent a burden and felt like “this wasn’t me”. One day she decided to give June her key back. She returned to her spot just outside the entrance to the Arts on Main property. She hasn’t looked back.</p><p><strong>Impact of Covid-19 on the work</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/864/0*Nx88PF_A6i4-YccJ" /><figcaption>Credit: @eye_media_sa, Maboneng official photographer, police van behind pedestrian wearing his mask under his chin</figcaption></figure><p>COVID-19 highlighted both the significance and vulnerability of the informal sector, and its close integration with social structures at community level, making this an appropriate moment to think about how it might be integrated into wider economic, social and cultural policy making — especially in developing economies with young populations, high rates of unemployment and fragile welfare structures.</p><p>Even during Covid-19 when many people were hiding in their homes, the photographers’ work attracted traffic. In fact, street traders were quick to point out that their ability to earn during the Pandemic was largely thanks to the photographers who kept foot traffic relatively high. The streets “don’t have seasons” according to the photographers and traders — but there is no doubt that Covid-19 hit the traders very hard since they rely more on international tourists than the photographers do. Malka was particularly insistent about the need for international tourists. She said “I hate just sitting there”.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*ryqJnNTv58HtSkLl" /><figcaption>Credit: @eye_media_sa, Fox Street west of the intersection with cars and not many people</figcaption></figure><p>Before COVID-19 there was a thriving Sunday market held in the parking garage of Arts on Main which was seen as critical to the profitability of the street traders. While there were attempts to relaunch this market over the past two years but it has been slow to take off. Traders also bemoan the absence of events such as the Rooftop Salsa at Arts on Main as it brought a different group of customers to their stalls and shops. It has now returned, not to the rooftop on Arts on Main but to the Cosmopolitan Hotel in Albrecht Street in the Maboneng precinct.</p><p>Market on Sunday in the Arts on Main parking area was very important — now started up again but a skeleton version of what it was. The attempt by June to host a Sunday Artisan market in the Museum of African Design unfortunately didn’t last more than a month. However Salsa has returned to Maboneng, now at the Cosmopolitan Hotel on Sundays.</p><p>COVID-19 was experienced differently by the two key groups in this study. The audience for the photographers is predominantly local (stemming from the need to be seen and recognised by your peers to be living your best life as evidenced by Instagram, Facebook posts) and they kept coming to the area to be photographed. The street traders rely heavily on both domestic and international tourism which resulted in a downturn in their trade during the pandemic.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/736/0*kJEPlcbSobH4ldFY" /><figcaption>Credit: Dana Gampel of 3 of her Salsa dancing friends in celebration of the Rio Carnival at the Cosmopolitan Hotel in early March 2021.</figcaption></figure><p>The street traders are struggling with the absence of international tourists to the area. Milkha added that she now does not have stock and is selling at wholesale prices to keep the product moving. She simply does not have “scarce money to buy stock”. Milkha now feels that she has perhaps been on the street too long. She is not sure what to do moving forward.</p><p>June, on the other hand did not suffer hugely during lockdown as she is always doing different cultural things with most of her customers are local or domestic tourists. She admits that tourists “bring a boost” to the area. She participates in a Gauteng tourism group formed by local traders who are mostly unregistered. The idea was to take the issues to the government which has not yet happened. She recalls that during the Xenophobic attacks, Maboneng became a ghost area with no cars for almost 2 months. The pandemic period never went quite that bad.</p><h3>Section 3: Implications for public policy</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*EkxOz2-8bGQSSuRm" /><figcaption>Credit: @eye_media_sa, A close-up of a beaded rhinoceros</figcaption></figure><p><strong>A trend or pattern?<br></strong>The concentration of cultural economy activity in urban areas and the urban informal economy is growing especially rapidly where formal economic growth has not been commensurate with urban population growth. Cultural practitioners, professionals and artists find working in urban spaces the best opportunity to earn income, despite the difficulties experienced by all in the urban economy. As George Cachara has explained:</p><p>This increasing visibility of the cultural economy in cities across Africa is ‘emblematic of the African renaissance — characterised by the growth of per capita and household incomes, aggressive transformation of urban spaces, rapid adoption of digital communication, growing diaspora remittances and increased foreign direct investment’ (Cachara, 2020).</p><p>As the title of this study suggests, there is a constant interplay between what is “visible” and what is “invisible” between appearance and disappearance as evidenced by trading stalls disappearing into store fronts and back again; between clarity of working relationships and the lack of registration, tax compliance or pay slips; between cash and the absence of cash; between formality and informality, between foot traffic and empty streets, and between thriving and surviving.</p><p>The complexity of the informal and our need to study it to understand how this complexity works in different contexts for different types of people is vital as<em> “</em>it can be very misleading to assume that urban informality can be reduced to a question of registration, taxation and labour relations”. As Brown, McGranahan and Dodman argue “The roots and dynamics of the urban informal economy are typically far more complicated than this’<em> </em>( 2014: 10–11).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*HTZU30k5gg4D5P7w" /><figcaption>Credit: @eye_media_sa, Street trader with sunglasses in the intersection catching the passing foot traffic</figcaption></figure><p>The stories from the photographers and street traders stories are indeed reflective of how the cultural economy operates in our country and that it is often quite distinct from the survivalist characteristics of the broader informal sector. Both the photographers and the street traders showed that they can earn an income far greater than qualified professionals working 9–5 jobs. What is needed is for public authorities to acknowledge the contribution that this informal cultural economy makes to the city’s and to the country’s economy. As a SACO study reveals, forty-three percent (43%) of cultural jobs are informal and more people work on a freelance or contract basis compared to non-cultural jobs — 32.5% compared to 8.3% respectively. However these figures hide and potentially obscure the textured nature of how informality differs according to the various cultural domains and from urban to town to village. Hopefully this type of investigation into a particular group of cultural workers and professionals will help mainstream the concerns of informal economy cultural workers and professionals and also ensure that practical policy solutions can be developed.</p><h3>Implications for public sector support</h3><p><strong>The importance of documentation<br></strong>It is often stated by economists and policy makers that if cultural activities are undocumented, they will be misunderstood. This gives rise to two different problems.</p><p>First, the lack of documentation about the informality prevalent in the cultural economy continues the perception that this part of the cultural economy is predominantly low-tech, unprofessional, unscalable, unchanging and non investible. The research study suggests that at least as far as the photographers and traders in Maboneng are concerned, this is not entirely correct. This research also concurs with that by the South African Cultural Observatory (2020) that there is considerable fluidity in the types of employment, with cultural workers moving seamlessly from the formal to informal sector and back again based on the prevailing economic conditions.</p><p>Second, when much of the output of our cultural economy undocumented and not recorded, governments (such as our own) are unaware of the scale, scope and reach of cultural work in the country. This understanding is necessary so that governments cam fully appreciate how the sector is organised or who its key participants are and construct public policy solutions tailor made to these participants. In addition, public policy needs to support organisations across the Global South such as SACO which is increasingly able to record, in a differentiated manner, both formal and informal work.</p><p>Knowing who works in the informal cultural economy and what their conditions of labour or trade are will facilitate better service provision and support. This requires the maintenance of a database of who is in the cultural economy, occupying which occupations across the value chains of the different cultural domains.</p><p><strong>Informality is not transitory or marginal<br></strong>A key implication then for public policy is to recognise that the informality of the cultural economy is not transitory or marginal, but rather has its own logic as an indigenous authentic economy and one that supports the growth of formality in the cultural economy. It is a multifaceted, complex local<strong> </strong>indigenous<strong> </strong>economy that is as diverse as the people who inhabit it. It is clear that cultural workers (as with many other informal workers) relate to the state and capital not through the wage but through a variety of forms<strong> </strong>of self-employment, own account work, and work as contributing family members. How can these cultural workers be protected in labour law, access unemployment insurance and generally be protected from inequity in contracts, poor and unsafe working conditions or the ubiquitous gender-based violence prevalent among women cultural workers?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*IHVxseQyXbZMYxp4" /><figcaption>Credit: @eye_media_sa, Madiba T-Shirts still sell well with tourists — not the locals, says Joe</figcaption></figure><p><strong>New definitions needed for ‘employee’ and better health and safety standards<br></strong>Perhaps new innovations such as the new status category in labour statistics of ‘dependent contractor’,<strong> </strong>which captures more accurately the situation of the majority of outworkers, home-based workers, and ‘gig’ workers (Wiego, 2020) would be a useful addition to the definition of an employee in South African labour law<strong>. </strong>In fact, in South Africa<strong>, </strong>there have been calls for an amendment to the definition of an employee (the Revised White Paper on Arts, Culture and Heritage (DSAC, 2020) repeated this call, to include self-employment, own account work and freelance work as these are not only typical of those excluded from the forms of social protection offered by employees, but are substantially present in the cultural economy. In the cultural economy, many people occupying occupations throughout the value chain<strong> </strong>would fit into these categories of precarious employment or whose enterprises lack legal recognition. The labour departments need to policies about health and safety standards for informal economy activities.</p><p><strong>Public space and hard infrastructure<br></strong>Informal cultural workers, traders and professionals require access to public space. It would be important to ensure public space is open to all and that there is appropriate provision of relevant physical infrastructure for enterprises, events, markets and trade whether these operate in informal spaces such as backyards in townships, informal settlements or street pavements (Brown, McGranahan and Dodman 2014).</p><p><strong>Contracts and social security<br></strong>Informal cultural workers, freelancers, crew as well as cultural professionals would benefit from legal support and standardised contracts as well as the provision of social security contributions from people not in formal employment (Chant, 2014).</p><p><strong>Participation in local government decision making about trading<br></strong>Local authorities need to include informal cultural sector workers, professionals and entrepreneurs in their consultative processes. Inexpensive and simple solutions to street trading, such as the provision of mobile covers so that informal traders themselves can decide where and when to work, rather than the typical bricks and mortar solutions. Clearly these traders bring life to the streets in the form of domestic and international tourists, so that in contained geographic areas, such as Maboneng, some degree of inexpensive public support can be provided.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*nN07JNoXdRNPYd7F" /><figcaption>Credit: @eye_media_sa, Photographer taking a photo of a man deep in contemplation</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Securing social justice for informal workers<br></strong>There are many broader questions that need to be debated and confronted about whether the larger public policy thrust is to formalise the informal sector or to create policies that recognise its independent (indigenous, authentic) and unique space in and contribution to the cultural economy. Much of the public policy discussion appears to favour the former so that even within the broader cultural economy there are calls to register companies, have certified documentation, enter into long term relationships with the formal financial institutions, insist on written contracts, become tax compliant and make use of lawyers to establish oneself or one’s company as a formally registered entity. This is not only needed to receive any grant funds from the government or its agencies such as the National Arts Council, it was also required to secure basic Covid-19 relief funds. This completely denies the reality of the choice that so many cultural workers and cultural professionals have made.</p><p>It is necessary to consider that informality may have been chosen because the prevailing formal arrangements and regulations that are being applied are poorly designed or discriminate against certain segments of society (such as women, freelancers, migrants, foreigners, the unbanked, crew, young entrepreneurs, risky businesses). So the challenge as Brown, McGranahan and Dodman conclude is “to improve upon the existing informal economy, not to formalize it or to protect it from formalization” (2014:11). A robust debate with evidence by many more such studies would help researchers, policy makers and government officials understand the trade-offs in supporting this informality against the argument that all those occupying positions across the cultural chains formalize, register and become tax compliant.</p><p>Public policy in most countries is based on the premise that all workers need to be drawn into the formal economy so that they can be subject to tax and regulation and are less likely to be victims of illegal and exploitative working conditions. However, in acknowledging the affordances and also challenges facing the informal sector, policy makers can design social protection and labour standards in ways appropriate for securing justice for informal workers. This could be achieved by cultural workers and creative professionals registering on a single database for authentication, or in hyper local areas, such as Maboneng, cultural intermediaries or precinct managers, could provide contract support and ensure unemployment or other social protection payments to cultural workers. These types of laws, regulation and policies for informal cultural workers and cultural professionals will ensure restorative justice to this vibrant, agile, flexible part of the cultural economy.</p><h3>References</h3><p>Bengtsson, M. and S. Kock. 2000. “‘Coopetition’ in Business Networks -To Cooperate and Compete Simultaneously.” <em>Industrial Marketing Management</em> 29 (5): 411–426.</p><p>Brown,D. McGranahan, G. and Dodman, D, 2014. Urban informality and building a more inclusive, resilient and green economy, IIED working paper</p><p>Cachara, G (2020) Safeguarding a creative and cultural moment. Blog for Nesta’s Policy and Evidence Council. Available at <a href="https://pec.ac.uk/blog/safeguarding-a-creative-and-cultural-moment?fbclid=IwAR17a2UZpqFVmGf55CIdqVlz31sxea3vs5HHcnBCk7sui6udI8UZ5WbT-1Q">https://pec.ac.uk/blog/safeguarding-a-creative-and-cultural-moment?fbclid=IwAR17a2UZpqFVmGf55CIdqVlz31sxea3vs5HHcnBCk7sui6udI8UZ5WbT-1Q</a>. Accessed 4/7/20</p><p>Chant, S. 2014 Exploring the “feminisation of poverty” in relation to women’s work and home-based enterprise in slums of the Global South <em>International Journal of Gender and Entrepreneurship</em> 6(3): 296–316</p><p>Chen, M. and Carre, F. 2020 The Informal Economy Revisited: Examining the Past, Envisioning the Future, WIEGO publication, available at <a href="https://www.wiego.org/publications/informal-economy-revisited-examining-past-envisioning-future">https://www.wiego.org/publications/informal-economy-revisited-examining-past-envisioning-future</a></p><p>De Boeck, F. and Plissart, M-F. 2004. <em>Kinshasa: Tales of the Invisible City</em>. Ghent, Belgium: Ludion</p><p>Department of Sports, Arts and Culture, 2020. The Revised White Paper on Arts, Culture and Heritage. Available at <a href="http://www.dac.gov.za/white-papers">http://www.dac.gov.za/white-papers</a></p><p>Gregory, J. 2016. Creative industries and urban regeneration — The Maboneng precinct, Johannesburg. <em>Local Economy</em> 31(1–2): 158–171</p><p>Guyer, J. 2004. Describing Urban ‘No Man’s Land’ in Africa. Africa 81(03):474–492</p><p>Koolhaas R. 2002. ‘Fragments of a lecture on Lagos’ in O. Enwezor et al. (eds), <em>Under Siege: Four African Cities</em> (Documenta 11 Platform 4). OstfildernRuit, Germany: Hatje Cantz Publishers.</p><p>Nuttal, S. and Mbembe, A. 2008 <em>Johannesburg — the illusive metropolis</em>. Johannesburg and Durham, Witwatersrand University Press and Duke University Press</p><p>Rubin, M. Samson, M. Butcher, A. Joffe, S. Merlo, S, Smith, L and Wafer, A. 2020. Investigating Infrastructures of Urban Inequality in Francis, D. and Webster, E. I<em>nequality Studies — an approach from the Global South</em> to be published by Routledge</p><p>South African Cultural Observatory (SACO) (2020) Measuring the impact of the Covid-19 Crisis on the Cultural and Creative Industries in South Africa: an early assessment, May, available at <a href="https://www.southafricanculturalobservatory.org.za/cultural-and-creative-sector-responses-to-covid-19-survey">https://www.southafricanculturalobservatory.org.za/cultural-and-creative-sector-responses-to-covid-19-survey</a>. Accessed 30/5/20</p><p>Simone, AM. 2004 People as Infrastructure: Intersecting Fragments in Johannesburg, in <em>Public Culture</em> 16 (3): 407–429</p><p>Simone, 2010 A Town on its Knees? <em>Theory, Culture &amp; Society</em>, 27 (7–8): 130–154</p><p>Skinner, C. and Valodia, I. 2020. Local Government Support for Women in the Informal Economy in Durban, South Africa. <em>International Journal of Politics, Culture and Society</em>, 16(3): 431–444</p><p>Steele, W. and Legacy, C. 2017. Critical Urban Infrastructure. <em>Urban Policy and Research</em>, 35(1): 1–6</p><p>Valodia, I. and Devey,R. 2011 The Informal Economy in South Africa: Debates, Issues and Policies. <em>The Journal of Applied Economic Research</em>, 6(2): 133–157</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=16f0be9089ef" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/informal-economy-in-the-global-south/street-life-in-maboneng-appearance-and-disappearance-in-constant-interplay-16f0be9089ef">Street life in Maboneng: Appearance and Disappearance in Constant Interplay</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/informal-economy-in-the-global-south">The Relationship between the Informal Economy and the Cultural Economy in the Global South</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Redefining Creative Initiatives through the Formal-Informal Interface]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/informal-economy-in-the-global-south/redefining-creative-initiatives-through-the-formal-informal-interface-178c87bdce9a?source=rss-c19e5d3f505e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/178c87bdce9a</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[British Council Creative Economy]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 14 Jul 2021 07:17:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-08-04T14:16:25.203Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>By Omar Nagati, Amin El-Didi, Maria Suescun</p><p>Two case studies from Cairo</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Xs4c33zjMo3ulr0N2zUeGg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Facade painting workshop in Ard al-Liwa</figcaption></figure><p>CLUSTER: Cairo Lab for Urban Studies Training and Environmental Research</p><h3><strong>Abstract</strong></h3><p>The intersection between creative initiatives and the informal economy is not an abstract hypothesis in cities in the Global South, which are largely dominated by informal practices, and where the organic linkages between the formal and informal processes are manifest in many sectors in the service economy.</p><p>This research highlights this formal-informal continuum through two projects in Cairo by CLUSTER between 2018 and 2021, whereby creative initiatives are redefined beyond the narrow boundaries of art and design, extending to crafts and small workshops within informal areas. The research both contests a clear delineation between the formal and informal sectors and areas, proposing an understanding of the organic and dynamic nature of their interface instead. Further, it argues for rethinking this interface as a generative framework to redefine creative initiatives in cities in the Global South.</p><h3><strong>Part one: Premises and Frameworks</strong></h3><p>This essay is hinged upon two main premises that frame the case studies presented below. The first is redefining creative initiatives and industries beyond the classical definition (Florida, 2002), and the second contesting the dual understanding of cities in the Global South through a formal-informal divide.</p><p><strong>Redefining the creative economy<br></strong>Creative cities and creative economy are discursive terms that emerged in the 1990s to characterize the transformation of cities in Europe and North America from an industrial to post-industrial economy as part of a global neo-liberal turn. In Cairo, as in many other cities in the Global South, the response to deregulations and the dismantling of welfare programs has been largely manifest in the informal economy. Left on their own, communities developed creative solutions to their daily needs and challenges, developing a parallel sector in absence of state’s provision. From that perspective, it could be argued that informality <em>is </em>creativity, which calls for a revision of the Euro-centric definition of a white-collared, formally-educated and globally-connected “creative class” towards a more inclusive understanding of creative initiatives. Having said that, it has become too fashionable to romanticize urban informality as an alternative to regulated economy, arguably enabling communities to pursue their own interests, while absolving the state of its own responsibility towards its citizens and as the guardian of public good. Informality is about private actors pursuing private interest and should not be advocated as a long-term progressive agenda, but rather as an interim condition until a strong democratic state is redeemed.</p><p>This strategic agenda raises important questions concerning the tactical role of creative actors in cities dominated by informal economy and urban practices. The question of how to stay relevant through meaningful engagements with a prevailing condition of informality, embracing neither an outright dismissal nor uncritical romanticization, is a pragmatic position actualized through multiple approaches: a) by carving out an independent position between the state’s and real-estate market forces; b) by developing creative solutions, while maintaining an advocacy position towards inclusion and urban justice; and c) through negotiating a diversified scope of practice including reflective observations, critical mapping and interventions on the ground through pilot projects to validate broader hypotheses.</p><p><strong>Formal-informal interface as a spectrum<br></strong>In Cairo, and cities of the Global South at large, the term ‘informal’ is often used to describe the methods through which people access land, housing and services. This informality, of course, is positioned next to its corollary, formality. Assumed to be a binary, this duality informs how cities are understood and how policies to address informality are constructed and implemented. While understanding informality is vital to understanding Southern — and particularly African cities — understanding the formal/informal as a binary does not do justice to the complexity of dynamics which exist in African cities (McGee 1978; Roy 2005).</p><p>The concepts of formal and informal constructs should be seen as analytical categories rather than discrete conditions with clear boundaries. This essay supports a view of formality as a continuum, wherein “formal” and “informal” activities are intertwined across this spectrum. In addition, informality exists within formal structures and vice versa, both geographically and institutionally. This position echoes authors who argue that informality and formality exhibit “strong, complex, and dynamic complementarities and interrelationships” (Arfvidsson et al. 2016:101; see also: Groenewald et al. 2013).</p><p>To further demonstrate this organic linkages and integrated ecosystem, the remainder of this essay presents two case studies based on CLUSTER’s projects in both the historic city center and outlying informal areas, critically maintaining a delicate balance within the formal-informal interface at different scales, while creatively engaging communities of practice along this spectrum. Sites and journeys below are illustrative of the intertwined nature of the formal-informal interface as a generative mode of creative initiatives.</p><h3><strong>Part Two: Sites and Communities</strong></h3><p><strong>A. ALFABRIKA Creative Lab: Site of formal-informal encounter and knowledge exchange</strong></p><p>ALFABRIKA was launched by CLUSTER in 2019 to address the gap between formal training and practical/grounded knowledge. It is located in Ard al-Liwa, which is one of the most vibrant informal neighborhoods to the west of Cairo, an area having an extensive network of small industries and craft workshops, from carpentry and upholstery, to metal and glass work, in addition to hosting the second largest garbage recycling communities in Cairo (fig. 1).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4towf-O8Fy-OvaDPJsqaOQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>ALFABRIKA is envisioned as a space of encounter, bringing art students and young designers together with craftspeople and owners of small workshops. Through a series of thematic workshops: around upcycling, palm reeds craft and social furniture, the teams engage in intensive knowledge exchange using manual and high-tech tools through a process of research, design, manufacturing and branding. While students, on the one hand, learn how to manufacture products outside their university labs and abstract modes of knowledge, craftspeople, on the other hand, can gain insights into the latest design directions and the use of high-tech machines (laser cutter, 3D printer, CNC, etc.), through a complementary design-make exercise. ALFABRIKA thus not only challenges the boundaries between formal and informal modes of knowledge production, it also contributes to redefining the role of creative actors in a city awash in a sea of informality (fig. 2).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xryNDf3FzPT1ZGYcopkjkA.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>B. Urban backstage: Art houses and artisan workshops<br></strong>A second site of interface between formal and informal modes of production is manifest in CLUSTER’s interest and previous track record in art and culture as catalysts for urban regeneration, in both the historic city center and outlying informal areas where emerging art spaces interact with a network of local crafts and workshops. Two interrelated projects, developed and implemented in 2020–21, may best illustrate this linkage.</p><p>In the neighborhood of Ard al-Liwa, the project focused on enhancing the visual identities of a number of businesses around ALFABRIKA, creating attractive and contemporary landmarks in an otherwise monotone urban fabric. With DUCO public art initiative as implementing partner, the contribution of artists Ibrahim Ahmed and Ibrahim Khattab, and the participation of art and design students from various universities, a workshop was organized aiming at the redesign and implementation of three storefronts: ALFABRIKA’s own shutters, the shutter of al-Ibrahimayn Art Studio, and the exterior walls of the Nour al-Quran nursery. The workshop emphasized enhancing the visibility of these locations, the quality of the streetscape, and training students while engaging with craftspeople who in turn acquire new skills while passing on their expertise.</p><p>In the provincial capital al-Mansoura, the site in question offered a different historic and cultural context of a derelict Greek cafe built in the early 1900s. This required a more sensitive approach and allowed for an opportunity to consider traditional signage techniques that are no longer in use. With Cairopolitan art house as implementing partner, the design process involved an array of skill sets and crafts, both traditional and digital, including calligraphy, metal making, laser engraving, silkscreening and more. This part of the project entailed working through a complex web of different contributors with different degrees of formality, with CLUSTER as the main designer and mediator, constantly negotiating the design through dialogues with the respective parties.</p><p><strong>C. Urban Journey: Through formal-informal transfer points<br></strong>The design and implementation process, which is further detailed below, entailed a direct collaboration between designers and craftsmen, whose studios and workshops are located between the city center and informal areas at its periphery. The journeys between these sites traverse the boundaries of official districts and their lines of demarcation. Using multiple modes of transportation, in themselves a combination of formal and informal systems, each journey offers a lense to the intertwined nature of these systems. In 2018, CLUSTER developed a research project interrogating these points of interface and traffic junctions, using a typical transportation journey from an informal area at the city edge to its center as both an analytical framework and experiential narrative.</p><p>Transportation is one of the city’s systems that best represents this continuum and the overlaps between formality and informality (fig. 3).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gJ32Q1tUgYwn7tT5NGqaEg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Transportation serves as the mediator and actor as it is the means by which diverse areas of the city are interconnected. Social transformations often occur at a higher pace than infrastructural changes in the city, so transportation is the mechanism by which the city can function “cohesively” even through rapid and abrupt shifts. The formally planned parts of the city are in constant exchange of labor and goods with the informal neighborhoods and vice versa, and it is through transportation that both realities come together. Informal communities’ ability to develop solutions to address the lack of public transportation in their neighborhood is an example of a creative answer to a very tangible problem.</p><p>In order to illustrate the nuances of transportation in such a unique context, CLUSTER’s research team adopted a methodological approach which includes a flow, or a pathway (from a source, through a transition, and to a destination). These stages are then analyzed through specific variables (quantifiable, mutually exclusive, spatially manifest) to weigh the interface between absolute values of formality and informality. Using definitive values of ‘actors’, ‘economy’, and ‘organization’, it becomes possible to move from abstract concepts to substantive and measurable units with which to weigh the interface. The following diagram illustrates such exchange between formal and informal areas of Cairo, and makes visible the nature of transportation as a spectrum by assigning red and blue to informal and formal respectively, and assessing degree of formality of the respective modes of transportation (fig. 4).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*VnKJuoAXijfHRf_GbdOHSQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>While the spectra can be delineated through categorical variables as previously shown, a typical commute from Cairo’s informal periphery to the formal city center can be more accurately described through the following animation, which attempts to capture the different manifestations of both formal and informal presences at each step of the way</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FpUGRrAqZkHA%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DpUGRrAqZkHA&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FpUGRrAqZkHA%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/a84c4c2ee1ea95cf24810a062cfcdd17/href">https://medium.com/media/a84c4c2ee1ea95cf24810a062cfcdd17/href</a></iframe><h3><strong>Part three: Process and Engagement</strong></h3><p>Within the above three sites of encounter, the following sections outline the main stages of the design, production and installation processes, each engaging the creative interface between actors, tools and economies for both the formal and informal sectors (fig. 5).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*OWrIrb6LzM1cqmxu3HZwVg.jpeg" /></figure><p>The rather detailed narrative below highlights the blurred boundaries between the various modes of creative production with varying degrees of formal education, training and regulations.</p><p><strong><em>Design phase<br></em></strong>The design process of ALFABRIKA’s shutters began with the CLUSTER team holding internal competitions and reviews to determine a design direction. The agreed-on final iterations drew inspiration from ALFABRIKA’s design-craft workshops, creating a unified color palette, and aiming to reflect both the fabrication lab and the urban lab’s purview through a transition of scales from the dense to the scattered periphery. Such a process was largely limited to the design team inside CLUSTER’s studio.</p><p>Conversely, the proposals for Nour al-Quran nursery and al-Ibrahimayn Art Studio went through different iterations where the input by each space owner in the informal area of Ard al-Liwa entailed rethinking the design strategy. For example, initially the team debated whether the nursery could have ancient Egyptian motifs on its wall, but it became clear that those illustrations might not be comprehensible to the local context or, worse, viewed as of pagan connotation in such conservative milieu of a rather orthodox religious interpretation. A more neutral design was thus suggested treating the wall as a child’s art sketchbook, incorporating scanned illustrations by children, and adding a colour scheme that was colorful and bright in the otherwise heavily shaded area. Similarly, for al-Ibrahimayn Art Studio, having an unclear legal status within an informal area, the artists preferred a rather minimalistic and subdued approach, opting to not stand out within their urban block. In short, both the design philosophy and community engagement had to be delicately positioned at the borderline between an artistic vision and abstract ideals, on the one hand, and priorities and concerns of neighbors on the other, in such a legally precarious business environment (fig. 6).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*utYrzvxZOzArGSne17vffw.jpeg" /></figure><p>As for Mansoura’s Andrea Cafe, the process began with determining how best to intervene with the facade in order to achieve a contemporary yet historically representative signage system. This was done by researching precedents and the equivalent local artisans available for the tasks ahead. As the storefront provided three bays with their respective signage spaces in each language (Arabic, Greek and English), this presented an opportunity to experiment with traditional displays made with contemporary methods.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2Fs1yChTbBVIY%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3Ds1yChTbBVIY&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2Fs1yChTbBVIY%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/eb399381b80c88ba6267acfcc7cdeac2/href">https://medium.com/media/eb399381b80c88ba6267acfcc7cdeac2/href</a></iframe><p>Gold leaf is produced by hammering gold into extremely thin sheets, the application of those sheets to wood, metal, glass, or ceramic is gilding. In Egypt, the technique was commonly used until the middle of the 20th century. People started to lose interest when new printing technologies started to appear until it almost became a dying craft. With the historical integrity of Andrea Cafe and the possibility of reviving the perishing technique on the glass bays, the team started by looking for artisans practicing this method, and soon realized that none of the master craftsmen were still alive. Luckily, the team was guided to Ahmed Hefnawy, an artist and co-founder of Cairopolitan who is knowledgeable of the technique and has been part of the process of Cairopolitan’s own gilded sign’s production. The design process was then reconfigured, engaging master calligraphers in Cairo, Alexandria and Mansoura, while consulting Ahmed Hefnawy as an interlocutor to bridge the gap between design and production processes.</p><p>In addition to the frontal glass signage, the team experimented with the design of a metal cantilever sign perpendicular to the facade, that would allow for more visibility for passersby along the street (fig. 7).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Ut_ltHspzwvXeEJZtanMLw.jpeg" /></figure><p>This provided an opportunity to add to the cafe’s visual identity in the way of a branding logo that could also be used with the cafe’s associated paraphernalia, from menus to cups and coasters. The process of developing an abstract visual language as holistic branding had to be repeatedly negotiated with the owner who insisted on drawing inspiration from Greek mythology, utilizing reference material from vintage design heirlooms found in the cafe. Further, the team supplemented the facade’s metal sign with custom-made ambient wall lights and their wrought iron supports, following the established design language. This could have only been done through an informal assemblage process whereby many artisans were consulted, given that formal markets only held limited catalogs of prefabricated typical light fixtures, and thus being less imaginative.</p><p>While the design process involved a number of iterations and revisions through a fluid exchange of design concepts, sample materials and prototypes, it was only after the project was completed that a reflective moment was possible. In retrospect, one could revisit these milestones and critically examine the formal-informal boundaries through actors, materials, capital, and most importantly modes of creativity and knowledge production. The following section continues this investigation of abstract versus grounded knowledge through the manufacturing and installing processes.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FG-TLHOfywrE%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DG-TLHOfywrE&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FG-TLHOfywrE%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/5da217ff27c3a90bbefe9178440469f5/href">https://medium.com/media/5da217ff27c3a90bbefe9178440469f5/href</a></iframe><p><strong><em>Production phase<br></em></strong>During the production phase, the role of the manufacturer in the design process was prominent and visible. In a more European setting, the demand for the type of signage designed (the cantilevered sign) is higher and the industry for it already exists. In Cairo, the informal sector offers an ecosystem providing alternative solutions to what is not otherwise available in the market. Given these gaps in the established industry, design houses seek the craftspeople that are up to the job, even if sometimes it is the first time they engage in such a venture. Compared to formal contracts, the design and production process are less clearly delineated as design decisions are hinged on available sections and details are negotiated back and forth with local craftsmen to attain a design that is constructible and within availability of resources.</p><p>During the production phase of Andrea Cafe signage in Mansoura, both formal and informal production processes were intricately intertwined. The more formal production process took place at Cairopolitan art house, where they led the reproduction of gold leaf glass signs through a mix of traditional calligraphy and contemporary techniques, including digital design, silkscreening and cutter plotter. Accordingly, the team produced a plan for the production of gold sticker signage, outlining the steps with each to achieve three glass signs using a mixture of contemporary and traditional methods (fig. 8).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*wAJQ3s7HssgRs1gUUvQfNw.png" /></figure><p>From a heritage point of view, to revive a dying craft is very significant, as one of the biggest challenges within emerging economies is to preserve their undocumented traditions. This became evident when talking to the calligrapher as he explained that the artistic decisions he was making regarding the positioning of the “kashida” (a type of justification in Arabic cursive scripts, elongating letters at certain points) were decisions a computer algorithm cannot make, only an expert.</p><p>On the other hand, the less formal production process took place for the metal signage and the lighting components (fig. 9).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/540/1*onKK5hiFjZ3nVN-yF4B8Xg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Based on its existing network , CLUSTER contacted the metalworkers in one of Cairo’s informal neighborhoods, al-Marg, to fabricate the metal signage. During this process, the design/production boundary also became blurred as there was a constant exchange between the art house and the craftspeople. Many of the decisions took place at the craftsman’s workshop, with a designer’s presence and/or communicating through digital application for review and approval. The availability of certain materials and specifications informed the viability of the design, limiting choices while offering opportunities to rethink on-paper schemes.</p><p><strong><em>Implementation and Installation Phase<br></em></strong>While the design and production phases involved a mix of formal and informal processes of knowledge exchange and manufacturing techniques, the implementation phase was entirely embedded in informal settings in Ard al-Liwa and thus subject to local forces: strong community engagement and low presence of authorities. In contrast, the site of Cafe Andrea was at the city center, half a block away from the central police directorate, which resulted in an overwhelming presence from their part during the installation phase. The contrast between both sites and contexts could not be more indicative of the formal-informal interface thesis.</p><p>During the Ard al-Liwa implementation phase, the team ran into a series of challenges, creating a certain degree of uncertainty during the process, especially with the production and the implementation of the round cantilevered sign at the Nour al Quran nursery: available materials and accessories, competence of some of the craftsmen and committing to concrete deadlines during the Covid19 precarious business environment. Secondly, given that the project was being implemented in an informal neighborhood, what mattered most was the community’s concession rather than formal approval by the local authorities. In Ard al-Liwa, communities have a high capacity to self-organize and therefore any spatial decisions or transformations must be approved by them as their opinion will ultimately determine the fate of the project and end result (fig. 10).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*wZM3DCe-4r39c4ie4FYN0Q.jpeg" /></figure><p>This was also evident in the possibility to extend the implementation workshop time frame due to external contingencies without needing formal approvals or permits, which was diametrically opposite to the situation in Cafe Andrea in Mansoura (fig. 11–13).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*X_CFZwt_HZFdX7AsoQ3Ehw.jpeg" /></figure><p>For the signage at Andrea Cafe, the installation phase involved a certain degree of coordination between different actors at different locations. On one hand, the glass had to be transported from Cairo in a special truck fitted with shock absorbers. The metal signage and the light fixtures were also transported from Cairo. On the other hand, coordination with the local stakeholders had to be preplanned through a local design associate on the ground. It involved synchronizing installation with the Cafe owner and recruiting a local installation crew, namely for the glass, as well as wood workers and electricians (fig. 14).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hRIhpTY6ld-uP50ufwX0bw.jpeg" /></figure><p>During the three-day workshop, a number of unexpected issues were raised that needed immediate on-the-ground resolution. A case in point was an error in the dimension of one of the glass signs produced in Cairo that could not be returned nor replaced. The glass workers demonstrated their resourcefulness and immediately proposed a practical solution; to carve out part of the woodframe’s interior in order for the glass to fit comfortably and still maintain the facade intact on the outside — an inventive solution outside the bounds of the design team who would generally have opted for a reproduction with the correct dimensions — not a viable option in this case. Numerous other examples demonstrated the capacity of craftsmen to find quick fixes within their available tools and resources.</p><p>Conversely, there was another undeniable presence of the police during the workshop Andrea Café is located right next to the police headquarters in Mansoura, which has very high security measures, and this proved to be a major constraint rather than an asset. The police were concerned about the implementation’s documentation because they did not want any photographs of the headquarters to be taken. Consequently, the team was constantly interrupted and many times questioned on the intentions of the project. Instead of facilitating the implementation process, they were a distractor and an obstacle. The police had also parked their cars in front of the café which made it difficult to upload materials, and impossible to get a complete picture of what the facade looked like, only allowing side pictures of the final result from the narrowing sidewalk (fig. 15).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*oCQ1cb_XKbq8kWVExuLGCA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Once again, the dialogue between formal forces and informal ones became apparent with the police, being the ultimate representation of the formal authorities, requesting permits and enforcing restriction while the team was able to dissuade their questioning by engaging in an informal manner: through colloquial talk and cultural courtesy. In summary, it was during the implementation phase that the interplay between formal and informal systems were most apparent, having sites and communities in different parts of the city offering for a comparative outlook on the nuances of the different processes necessary to create an architectural intervention in public space, from the formal city core to the informal periphery.</p><h3><strong>Part four. Conclusion and Lessons Learned</strong></h3><p>This essay, which is based on an empirical experience and practical knowledge, may nevertheless offer a number of reflections on the intersection of creative initiatives and the formal-informal interface. The presented research and design projects criss-cross the city’s formal and informal boundaries, both geographically and institutionally, while their actors, economies and modes of knowledge are organically linked via a complex web of networks and flows. A number of themes could be discerned that are relevant to other cities and regions in the Global South.</p><p><strong>1. Informality as creativity<br></strong>Informal responses to the absence of state’s provision of urban services are based on grounded creative solutions. Rather than being chaotic and unstructured, these initiatives offer a pool of creative solutions to academics and practitioners alike. The projects above highlight the need to rethink urban informality as a generative process, and develop creative modes of engagement towards more comprehensive and integrated solutions for our cities.</p><p><strong>2. Modes of knowledge and communication<br></strong>The projects illustrate an interplay and exchange between two modes of knowledge and creative production. The first is based on formal training and hinged upon abstract mode of representation, by artists and designers, while the second is embedded in grounded experience and practical tools of production, by artisans and craftspeople. The exchange between both requires creative modes of communication using unconventional techniques, such as volumetric representations, mockups and prototypes through multiple iterations.</p><p><strong>3. Dual agency of creative actors: practical and reflective<br></strong>The role CLUSTER assumes in these projects as mediator and negotiator between the modes described above is representative of emerging creative practices over the past decade or two. Their practical position engages projects in which the boundaries between formal and informal economies and initiatives are blurred and are only recognized in financial and contractual documents. As thoroughly discussed, each project involves an array of actors, markets and techniques that are intermingled with each at every stage in both the design and production processes. Their distinction may be discerned at a later (post-production) stage, when a more reflective position could be afforded, and where analytical categories and constructs could be projected back on the formal-informal continuum.</p><p><strong>4. Inhabiting the interface as a <em>modus operandi</em>, that is interstitially generative and often subversively creative. <br></strong>Viewing the formal-informal interface as a complex web and a continuum, including loopholes within, implies a tactical approach to inhabit as sites of creative interventions. Unlike political and spatial strategies of wholesale changes, operating on a small scale within the interstices, which is genetically informal, offers an opportunity for incremental, yet more sustainable approach to cities in the Global South.</p><p><strong>List of figures</strong></p><p>Fig 1. Ard al-Liwa as situated within Greater Cairo<br>Fig 2. Design-craft workshops by ALFABRIKA<br>Fig 3. Routes traversing the formal-informal divide<br>Fig 4. Formal-informal spectra along a typical transportation journey<br>Fig 5. Network of project stakeholders and their different levels of formality<br>Fig 6. Designs of the sites in Ard al-Liwa, reflecting their disciplines while prioritizing context sensitivity <br>Fig 7. Andrea Cafe’s cantilever sign design, experimenting with contemporary graphics alongside traditional metalworking<br>Fig 8. Gilded signage process incorporating Arabic calligraphy<br>Fig 9. Metal-forging process is predominantly carried out by informal workshops<br>Fig 10. ALFABRIKA’s shutters after the community workshop’s completion<br>Fig 11. Shutter painting workshop in Ard al-Liwa<br>Fig 12. Local community participation during the implementation project in Ard al-Liwa <br>Fig 13. Facade painting workshop in Ard al-Liwa<br>Fig 14. Craftsmen involved in the installation of Andrea Cafe’s signage<br>Fig 15. Combination of gilded glass signage and branded cantilever sign</p><p><strong>References<br></strong>Arfvidsson, H., Anand, G., Bazaz, A., Fenna, G., Foster, K., Jain, G., Hansson, S., Evans, L.M., Moodley, N., Nyambuga, C., and Simon, D., 2016, Developing and testing the Urban Sustainable Development Goals targets and indicators–a five-city study. Environment and Urbanization, 28(1), pp.49–63.</p><p>CLUSTER, 2017, Creative initiatives: economic impact assessment on Downtown Cairo, unpublished report submitted to the British Council, Egypt.</p><p>CLUSTER, 2018, Formal-informal interface: comparative analysis between three Egyptian Cities, unpublished report submitted to AURI (African Urban Research Initiative).</p><p>Florida, R., 2002, The rise of the creative class: And how it’s transforming work, leisure, community and everyday life, New York: Basic Books.</p><p>Groenewald, L., Huchzermeyer, M., Kornienko, K., Tredoux, M., Rubin, M. and Raposo, I., 2013, “Breaking down the binary: Meanings of informal settlement in southern African cities” in: S. Bekker and L. Fourchard, eds., Politics and policies governing cities in Africa. Capetown: HSRC Press, pp.93–116</p><p>Kostourou, F., Karimnia, E., Chua, C., Cetrulo, A., Bingham-Hall, J. &amp; Tribillon, J., 2020, Urban Backstages Fieldwork Journal: London. 10.13140/RG.2.2.19344.43521.</p><p>McGee, T. G., 1978, “An invitation to the `ball’ : Dress `formal’ or `informal’ ?.” In: P. J. Rimmer, D. W. Drakakis-Smith and. T. G. McGee, eds., Food Shelter and Transport in Asia and the Pacific, Department of Human Geography Monograph 12, The Australian National University, Canberra, pp.3–28.</p><p>Nagati, O., Jean-Baptiste N., Siame, G., and Vokouma Boussari, J., 2021/Forthcoming, “Formal-informal interface: comparative analysis between four African cities”.</p><p>Roy, A., 2005, “Urban Informality: Toward an Epistemology of Planning”. Journal of the American Planning Association, 71(2), pp.147–158.</p><p><strong>Websites<br></strong>CLUSTER: <a href="http://clustercairo.org/">clustercairo.org</a><br>CUIP: <a href="http://cuipcairo.org/">cuipcairo.org</a></p><p><strong>Videos<br></strong><a href="https://youtu.be/pUGRrAqZkHA">Objects in Mirror are Closer than they Appear as part of the study “Formal-informal interface: comparative analysis between three Egyptian Cities”</a></p><p><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s1yChTbBVIY">Enhancing Visual Identity — Ard al-Liwa as part of the Ard al-Liwa part of the project “Creativity in Action”</a></p><p><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G-TLHOfywrE">Restoring Signage Traditions as part of the Mansoura part of the project “Creativity in Action”</a></p><p><strong>List of initiatives and partners<br>Andrea Cafe </strong>is one of the oldest cafes in the city of Mansoura, and was once a gathering place for intellectuals which has now become a favorite place for the young generation. It was established by the Greek Khawaja, Costasius Andrea in 1907, to be the first café and meeting place for Greeks in Mansoura.</p><p><strong>AURI </strong>(African Urban Research Initiative) was initiated in 2013 to support existing and future Africa-based research centres to inform and enhance the policy actors and networks responsible for sustainable urban policy and management in different African contexts.</p><p><strong>Cairpolitan </strong>is a design concept store and art gallery based in Garden City, Cairo, driven by the practical details of contemporary life in modern day Cairo, designing product lines that document everyday life with an aim of branding the city.</p><p><strong>DICE </strong>(Developing Inclusive and Creative Economies) is a programme developed by the British Council that seeks to support the development of creative and social enterprises in the UK and five key emerging economies: Brazil, Egypt, Indonesia, Pakistan, and South Africa.</p><p><strong>DUCO </strong>is a creative agency, production house and future platform dedicated to urban art and outdoor luminous hand-painted wallscapes powered by a commercial approach while contributing towards an urban cosmetic development by operating at the intersection of lifestyle, construction and media industries.</p><p><strong>Ibrahimayn Studio </strong>was founded by artists Ibrahim Khattab and Ibrahim Ahmed, who are both mid-career artists with extensive local and international experience, who have decided to locate their studio in Ard al-Liwa to engage in current themes and develop grounded practice outside mainstream galleries.</p><p><strong>Nur al-Quran Nursery </strong>is a local nursery in a small dead-end street in Ard al-Liwa. The nursery serves the local community’s children, catering to different age groups and offering a range of art, reading and basic math classes in addition to regular Quran reading sessions.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=178c87bdce9a" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/informal-economy-in-the-global-south/redefining-creative-initiatives-through-the-formal-informal-interface-178c87bdce9a">Redefining Creative Initiatives through the Formal-Informal Interface</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/informal-economy-in-the-global-south">The Relationship between the Informal Economy and the Cultural Economy in the Global South</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Informal Work by Young Entrepreneurs from the Peripheries of Rio de Janeiro]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/informal-economy-in-the-global-south/informal-work-by-young-entrepreneurs-from-peripheries-of-rio-de-janeiro-f31588722452?source=rss-c19e5d3f505e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f31588722452</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[British Council Creative Economy]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 14 Jul 2021 07:17:33 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-08-04T13:14:36.120Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>By Leandro Valiati, Veruska Delfino, Paul Heritage</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/778/1*OmnRmFs2Nc6W5-MxsH2EmA.png" /><figcaption>Credit: still from film</figcaption></figure><h3><strong>Section one: Description of the case</strong></h3><p>This investigation, delivered in partnership with <em>Agência de Redes para Juventude</em>, consists of ten in-depth interviews with young arts entrepreneurs from the periphery of Rio de Janeiro focusing on their informal strategiesto deliver artistic projects, embracing schemes of funding, production, advertisement, exhibition, sustainability, barriers, opportunities, impacts, training, dialogues with formal structures, among other elements.</p><p>Rio de Janeiro is a city of contrasts. For one side, a rich, well connected, and glamorous metropolis, for other a town in which 22% of the population live in unregulated, improvised neighbourhoods lacking any sort of formal state policies.</p><p>Considering the positioning of these areas in Rio de Janeiro, there is a big difference between the factors that make up the human development index. There are, within the same city, the realities of Switzerland (0.930) and Venezuela (0.760) or Libya (0.720) and Norway (0.944) coexist. Noble neighbourhoods like Gávea, Leblon and Ipanema, consider themselves “micro countries”, for example, have a higher HDI than any country in the world.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FhHqyVdXSWcs%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DhHqyVdXSWcs&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FhHqyVdXSWcs%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/6ee9af0281110025061ac5946924ebe2/href">https://medium.com/media/6ee9af0281110025061ac5946924ebe2/href</a></iframe><p>Locating this research in the vulnerable areas of the city allowed the contextualization of the investigation in a territory where inhabitants are structurally subject to multiple stress factors (socioeconomic exclusion, high levels of violence, limited access to cultural networks and institutions, etc.) and face the absence of funding or state structures that can develop, evaluate, and maintain formal work relations. There are significant challenges for periphery residents to be included in the legal labour market, which generates an inherent need for innovation in their practices and strategies to produce art and culture. Necessarily, they use non-formal channels to build their resilience towards liveability and socioeconomic progress.</p><p>The methodology used consisted of semi-structured interviews with the selected young people with a questionnaire composed of open questions on central themes on the object of the research (experience with formal work (opportunities and limitations), trajectory in the art world, views on government and the public sector, needs, plans, dreams and pandemic). Each of the interviewees produced their path, not directed to create their narrative about the suggested macro issues. The raw recording material was approximately 300 minutes, which was reduced to around 35 minutes for the ten videos. The edition was based on close connections between the themes in the ten interviews, consistency and proximity to the proposed macro themes and clarity in presenting the thoughts. All respondents signed the terms of use of the image.</p><p>The young arts entrepreneurs interviewed, and their territories are:</p><p><strong>Carol Dupré, 26 years old<br></strong>A resident of Vila Kennedy, she leads the Saaf project. Since 2013, the project has developed educational and cultural projects with children in the Vila Kennedy favela.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FL1wb6DN44Y4%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DL1wb6DN44Y4&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FL1wb6DN44Y4%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/f9b355970620302d02a13eeab005835e/href">https://medium.com/media/f9b355970620302d02a13eeab005835e/href</a></iframe><p>Vila Kennedy is a neighbourhood in the West Zone of the City of Rio de Janeiro. It consists of the Vila Kennedy slum and a large housing estate. It is located on the banks of Avenida Brasil. Itsstreets are named after African, Asian and musician countries. Before being an official neighbourhood, it was a sub-neighbourhood belonging to Bangu. In July 2017, the law that makes it official as a community was enacted.</p><p><strong>César Varella, 21 years old<br></strong>A resident of Pavuna, he is an actor and leads the Coletivo Via Light. The collective brings together black artists from Zona Norte and Baixada Fluminense.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FdvFDx_0QVVY%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DdvFDx_0QVVY&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FdvFDx_0QVVY%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/1d56c7a9912231bf351f20e109078ff4/href">https://medium.com/media/1d56c7a9912231bf351f20e109078ff4/href</a></iframe><p>Pavuna is a neighbourhood located on the outskirts of Rio de Janeiro, which borders municipalities in the Baixada Fluminense and has several favelas. Complexo do Chapadão and Complexo da Pedreira are part of the neighborhood.A resident of Pavuna, he is an actor and leads the Coletivo Via Light. The collective brings together black artists from Zona Norte and Baixada Fluminense.</p><p>Pavuna is a neighbourhood located on the outskirts of Rio de Janeiro, which borders municipalities in the Baixada Fluminense and has several favelas. Complexo do Chapadão and Complexo da Pedreira are part of the neighborhood.</p><p><strong>Elaine Rosa, 32 years old<br></strong>A resident of Complexo do Lins, she is the creator of Feira Crespa, a social entrepreneur and DJ.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2Fe75Otpsf5WY%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3De75Otpsf5WY&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/e75b6cc756a99f9183d33d4eae386287/href">https://medium.com/media/e75b6cc756a99f9183d33d4eae386287/href</a></iframe><p>Complexo do Lins, a cluster of eleven favelas: Barro Preto, Barro Vermelho, Encontro, Base, Amor, Arvore Seca, Cachoeirinha, Cachoeira Grande, Gambá, Cotia and Boca do Mato. It constitutes one of the largest and most violent clusters of slums in Rio de Janeiro, with a population of 150,000 inhabitants, in a territorial extension of approximately 300 thousand square meters.</p><p><strong>Isabella Silva, 28 years old<br></strong>Borel resident, leads the Boreart project — Art collective at Borel Hill.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2Ffg_Ahw4BE_g%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3Dfg_Ahw4BE_g&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2Ffg_Ahw4BE_g%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/ced100510d734b929c03967899bd3d4d/href">https://medium.com/media/ced100510d734b929c03967899bd3d4d/href</a></iframe><p>Morro do Borel is a slum located in the neighbourhood of Tijuca, in the north of the city of Rio de Janeiro. Its occupation began in 1921, after the demolition process of Morro does Castelo, in downtown Rio de Janeiro. The population that lived in that place was forced to migrate to other regions of the city, and the region that today is Morro do Borel was one of the most received residents. Like all slums in the town, Borel’s constitution begins as a solution to a housing crisis at that time. Before being occupied by the population searching for housing, it was owned by the French family Puri Borel, who lived on timber extraction.</p><p><strong>Big Jaum (João), 22 years old<br></strong>Guadalupe resident, humorist, independent artist and director of audiovisual content.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2F9zmjZ2Vbp8w%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3D9zmjZ2Vbp8w&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2F9zmjZ2Vbp8w%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/a4499925f274638ad231ee721c1625ad/href">https://medium.com/media/a4499925f274638ad231ee721c1625ad/href</a></iframe><p>Guadalupe is a neighbourhood in the North Zone of the municipality of Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. It borders Anchieta, Deodoro, Marechal Hermes, Ricardo de Albuquerque, Barros Filho, Costa Barros and Pavuna. Located away from the Zones South and West beaches, Guadalupe is situated on the corridor Avenida Brasil. The neighbourhood has numerous corridors to various areas of Rio de Janeiro, including expressways. The community already had an industrial park very significant, with Pimaco, Brasvit and Eternit. Today, these industries are giving way to large commercial enterprises, supermarkets and shopping malls.</p><p><strong>Juliana Mello, 31 years old<br></strong>Resident of Providência, Co-founder and artistic director of the Instituto Método Urbano.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FEACSC769Ap0%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DEACSC769Ap0&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FEACSC769Ap0%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/216fd0783efafc67e831910841bc3c1f/href">https://medium.com/media/216fd0783efafc67e831910841bc3c1f/href</a></iframe><p>The Morro da Providencia is a hill located in the neighbourhood of Gamboa, in the Central Zone of the city of Rio de Janeiro. Its slopes have located a favela with the same name, highlighted for being the oldest favela in Brazil. The hill’s settlement began effectively in the 1890s by residents evicted from a tenement and by soldiers who participated in historical the Canudos War.</p><p><strong>Luciano Pimenta, 25 years old<br></strong>Resident of Pavuna, founder of Coletivo Vira Lata. The collective brings together peripheral communication and cultural production professionals for causes and movements.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FhHqyVdXSWcs%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DhHqyVdXSWcs&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FhHqyVdXSWcs%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/6ee9af0281110025061ac5946924ebe2/href">https://medium.com/media/6ee9af0281110025061ac5946924ebe2/href</a></iframe><p>Pavuna is a neighbourhood in the North Zone of Rio de Janeiro, in the state of Rio de Janeiro, in Brazil. It borders the neighborhoods of Anchieta, Guadalupe, Costa Barros, Coelho Neto, Acari, Irajá, Jardim América and Parque Colúmbia, and also with the municipality of São João de Meriti, in the neighborhoods Parque Araruama (Parque Analândia and Parque Juriti), Centro, Engenheiro Belford and São Mateus. The area has one of the largest populations among the neighbourhoods in Rio.</p><p><strong>Matheus Araújo, 23 years old. <br></strong>A resident of Maré, he is a writer and poet.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2F7IFWSslTRJs%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3D7IFWSslTRJs&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/b7aa8d4bb99e83073c55e263824b56c1/href">https://medium.com/media/b7aa8d4bb99e83073c55e263824b56c1/href</a></iframe><p>The Complexo da Maré, or simply Maré, its official name, is a neighbourhood located in the North Zone of the Capital Fluminense. The region is made up of a conglomerate of small areas, neighbourhoods, slums and micro-. Within this complex, there are several subdivisions, consisting of commercial establishments and housing estates. With about 130,000 residents (2010), it has one of the largest community complexes in Rio de Janeiro, resulting from low social development indicators that characterize the region.</p><p><strong>Felipe Salsa, 30 years old<br></strong>Resident of the Fumacê favela, dancer and cultural articulator.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2Fmob1Mr4BEWA&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3Dmob1Mr4BEWA&amp;image=http%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2Fmob1Mr4BEWA%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/91975985fdd2be57a1684e99eef44831/href">https://medium.com/media/91975985fdd2be57a1684e99eef44831/href</a></iframe><p>Jardim Batan or Batan is a sub-neighbourhood of Realengo, in the West Zone of Rio de Janeiro, close to Avenida Brasil. It is considered by many to be a slum.</p><p><strong>Sara Ferreira, 20 years old<br></strong>Resident of Pavuna. Trancista, flea market and creator of the Ori Bojumu enterprise.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FK3BnM6KRCOk%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DK3BnM6KRCOk&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FK3BnM6KRCOk%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/5e7d5743ef439c92c82db7edc89cb3c3/href">https://medium.com/media/5e7d5743ef439c92c82db7edc89cb3c3/href</a></iframe><p>Pavuna is a neighbourhood in the North Zone of Rio de Janeiro, in the state of Rio de Janeiro, in Brazil. It borders the neighborhoods of Anchieta, Guadalupe, Costa Barros, Coelho Neto, Acari, Irajá, Jardim América and Parque Colúmbia, and also with the municipality of São João de Meriti, in the neighborhoods Parque Araruama (Parque Analândia and Parque Juriti), Centro, Engenheiro Belford and São Mateus. The community has one of the largest populations among the areas in Rio.</p><h3><strong>Section Two: The Findings</strong></h3><p>The research produced relevant information to address the following SDGs:</p><ul><li>Co-develop sustainable cultural and creative economy initiatives that provide the means for individuals and organizations from peripheral and fragile communities to develop their potential as active agents in improving social and economic resilience and reducing poverty (SDG1).</li><li>Engage and influence policymakers from government and non-government agencies to design, implement, monitor and evaluate effective policies for the development of the creative economy as a means of increasing decent work opportunities and nurturing economic growth (SDG8).</li><li>Engage artists and cultural practitioners from marginalized communities in constructive dialogues with representatives from across all aspects of civil society (SDG17).</li><li>Identify and learn from territorially-specific creative economy initiatives and experiments that maximize and strengthen local cultural resources towards eliminating poverty and reducing inequalities (SDG1 and SDG10).</li></ul><p>The most relevant common findings are:</p><ul><li>The young entrepreneurs in art and culture placed at vulnerable areas rely their work strategy on informal supporting networks based on hidden (not accounted for in formal statistics) economic circuits.</li><li>The role of family, friends and trust are essential to allow some forms of non-written contracts apart from the formal job market system.</li><li>The hidden economic circuits sometimes have contact zones with the formal course of work. Mainly it is connected to a “favour-retribution” system relying on a friend or familiar integrated into the formal circuit.</li><li>They prefer alternative arrangements to deliver innovation instead of stability with a chain of routine activities.</li><li>The young entrepreneurs in art and culture won’t be inserted in a formal job even if it is not connected to art and culture. There is a view on having more rights and benefits (health care, furlough systems). The lack of perspectives and stability make them less hopefully with the stands.</li><li>The government is significant in their vision, but they feel invisible to the institutions. In general, they tend to see art as a second job or the desired position to be accumulated with a formal instrumental career in any sector.</li><li>There are symbolic and instrumental components in having a formal job (whatever it may be), which is the possibility of having a document that in Brazil is called Carteira de Trabalho (Worker Identification Card).</li><li>This document is handy on two levels: <br>a) instrumental: in peripheral areas as it is shown in police approaches as an indication that the young person is not involved in the trafficking but works and is, therefore, a “good citizen”.<br>b) symbolic: being formally working signals to the family that the young person is on the right path to bring money into the home regularly.</li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f31588722452" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/informal-economy-in-the-global-south/informal-work-by-young-entrepreneurs-from-peripheries-of-rio-de-janeiro-f31588722452">Informal Work by Young Entrepreneurs from the Peripheries of Rio de Janeiro</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/informal-economy-in-the-global-south">The Relationship between the Informal Economy and the Cultural Economy in the Global South</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Cultural Feasts and Festivals: between the formal and the informal economy Final Report]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/informal-economy-in-the-global-south/cultural-feasts-and-festivals-between-the-formal-and-the-informal-economy-final-report-49b5d4c51565?source=rss-c19e5d3f505e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/49b5d4c51565</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[British Council Creative Economy]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 14 Jul 2021 07:17:08 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-08-04T13:50:38.711Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>By Diana Rey, Ph.D.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/812/1*YZF3xyvvM19DjSjn0US3TQ.png" /></figure><h3><strong>The Project Overview</strong></h3><p>In Andean countries, the analysis of the relationship between the informal economy and the intangible heritage is a theme to be addressed in the public agenda and the academics of the region. To promote this discussion, this exploratory study focused particularly on two topics.</p><p>First, the economist Javier Machicado has been invited to think of the informality of the intangible sector, considering that he has been responsible for analyzing the economic effects of the cultural heritage for the Ministry of Culture of Colombia. Machicado’s paper “<em>Facets of self-management and informality in the Colombian heritage sector” </em>shows how heritage practices embedded in territories and communities tend to adopt non-formal schemes and focused on self-management. As for the experiences oriented to present the heritage in front of the public (museums and some festivals), adopt defined management schemes, with more formal budgets and models for administration.</p><p>Second, this exploratory study sought to learn from the voice of the promoters of the feasts and festivals, how the practices of formality and informality are related to the process of documenting, recognizing, promoting, transmitting, enjoying and financing their heritage manifestations. From this perspective, three case studies of the Andean countries were selected.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*tQJ7kB4dCHQVp96oDyPpqw.jpeg" /></figure><p>From Ecuador, it was selected the experience of “Octaves of Mocha”. This celebration is held by the community of the Mocha municipality, every year on June 24 to commemorate the birth of San Juan Bautista, through traditional games, the use of costumes of mythological characters and the</p><p>production of vegetables grown just for that occasion, which was prepared and shared among the participants of the celebration. In Colombia, it was decided to focus the other two case studies in the city of Ibague. Municipality located in the center of the country, known as the musical capital of Colombia, which has an extensive program of events, of which two cases were selected.</p><p>The video “<em>Cultural Festivals: between the formal and the informal economy</em>” compiles the most emblematic moments of interviews achieved, allowing to identify how the Mocha experience is a heritage manifestation outside of the formal economy; meanwhile the festivals of Ibague, despite having predominantly formal economic and institutional organization schemes, have also problems related to the informal economy.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*qJtSeOwQtZ48lz7qHBSO2A.jpeg" /></figure><h3><strong>Research findings/Conclusions</strong></h3><p>The review of the state of the art on informality in the Andean cultural heritage revealed that since the 90’s, when the theme was incorporated as a relevant theme in the academic and political agenda of the region, the research on the sector has focused on two lines of analysis.</p><p>The first line research focus has been on describing the vicissitudes of the financing schemes for the feasts and festivals, as well as highlighting the structural problems in its value chain. For example, from the Ministry of Culture of Colombia, the research has advanced significantly in investigating the sustainability schemes of the organizations and people involved in the heritage manifestations.</p><p>Faced with the second line of analysis, the economic research on cultural heritage has been oriented towards the generation of monetary data with the objective of assessing its contributions to employment, dimensioning the related public and private spending, and highlighting the percentage of participation of the exports of heritage goods, especially of handicrafts. Regarding those objectives, Bolivia, Chile, Colombia, Ecuador, and Peru have implemented the Cultural Satellite Accounts to offer quantitative information about it.</p><p>The thesis presented by Machicado, according to which the degree of self-management of the celebrations and festivals depend on the level of roots in the communities to their territory, make visible why in municipalities with predominantly Afro or indigenous communities, the dynamics of organization, enjoyment and transmission of intangible heritage have stronger degrees of self-management.</p><p>In this regard, Machicado highlights the case of the Festival of Drums and Cultural Expressions. This celebration takes place in the municipality of San Basilio of Palenque, Colombia, recognized in the Intangible Heritage list such as cultural space encompasses social, medical and religious practices as well as musical and oral tradition. The other emblematic case is the Octaves of Mocha, for its promoters, self-management is the axiom to safeguard their heritage. For them, organizing and celebrating the octaves by putting their own resources (food, time, space and even today money to pay for what they need) is a form of maintaining alive their cosmovision. Therefore, self-management is at the same time a heritage practice of living the celebration in their community.</p><p>The Octaves are an emblematic case of how in Andean countries there exists cultural heritage practices through which all the safeguarding processes are developed totally outside the formal economy. For instance, for the use of public space, no special permission is requested to the municipality. The house in which the meeting prior to the octaves develop and where they cook is the home of a member of the community. The costumes, instruments and games are acquired directly by the participants own account. In the same way, the musical bands that participate in the celebration receive financing from individuals naturally external to the municipality. As the organizers highlighted, there is no direct monetary transaction in the name of the Octaves, work or formal structure established.</p><p>The two festivals of Ibague demonstrate that when the celebrations and festivals are legally legitimized and financed primarily by the State, the payment to the providers of creative services is not made in any case outside of the banking system. Since the responsible organizations must render financial reports that allow them to legalize the public resource they receive. Regardless, in both festivals, those who are in charge of the central tasks of the festivals are obliged to accept contracts as freelancers for three months when they support the processes continuously.</p><p>Consistent with this, Machicado demonstrates how despite that there exists a legally constituted institutional framework to support the organization of the festivals, the creation of employment is reduced to sporadic jobs for the local cultural sector. For example, in the case of the Colombian Folkloric Festival, the artisans in charge of making the floats for the parades must work for months in their design and elaboration, without receiving a remuneration throughout the production, but instead they obtain one single final payment at the end of the process. This situation puts at risk a valuable human capital for the safeguarding of the festivals and leaves it adrift from situations like moonlighting employment and underemployment.</p><p>Likewise, the Ibague festivals revealed that despite counting on legally organized structures and boards of directors with public-private representation, the labor informality of the directors of both festivals puts them at risk. In both cases, the women who have led the festivals have worked for decades voluntarily and have been able to do so thanks to their own resources derived from other economic activities.</p><p>In fact, Machicado reflects on the function of the Objective of Sustainable Development, number 8 and invites us to have a broader look to think about measures in favor of respectable work. His proposal is to overcome the conditions of intermittence of many heritage activities and advocate for the strengthening of capacities for the sustainable management of heritage use projects.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*lMFTpfLMbQ_ovQPIq80Dcg.png" /></figure><h3><strong>Suggested areas for further research</strong></h3><p>• Analyze from an interdisciplinary point of view how the degree of economic, legal and political formality and informality has an impact on each of the processes of safeguarding the intangible heritage: identification, documentation, preservation, transmission, dissemination, and enjoyment.</p><p>• Investigate how the direct effects of public and private spending that are generated through the heritage celebrations and festivals impact and/or correlate with the formal and informal economy circuits of the territories where the events are held. For example,</p><p>for the financing of the gastronomic, hotel and transportation industries (formal and informal), and even, for prostitution and illegal markets of psychoactive substances.</p><p>• It is necessary to explore the schemes of voluntary work related to the heritage celebrations and festivals of the region to identify their associated risks.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*Su7BY7DqkYcryDGPr6XWHw.jpeg" /></figure><h3><strong>Highlight particular links to policy</strong></h3><p>The case students make it possible to identify that the relationship between the informal economy and intangible heritage, apart from describing itself through underemployment, moonlight employment and instability, acquires other characteristics related to the legal and political recognition of the celebrations and festivals. When it has been asked in the interviewed of the Octaves of Mocha and Ibague their concern about their relationship with the formal and informal economy, they emphasized three aspects about the relationship between the informality, the public politics and the communication to the public.</p><p>First, the recognition of their celebration or festival by the State. In this regard, Mochanos highlighted their decision to remain informal to prevent their heritage being recognized legally by the local government and this would lead to a loss in autonomy over how their celebration is organized. While both the Festivals of Ibague underlined that thanks to their legal recognition both in part from local and national government, they do not suffer the scourges of the informal economy.</p><p>The second aspect refers to the capacity they have in determining autonomously or not the programming of the activities developed within the framework of their celebration or festival. Both the representatives of the Octaves of Mocha and those of Ibague, related the degree of formality with the possibility of making decisions about the activities to be developed. For the members of Mocha, being in the world of informality guarantees them independence over how to define and delimit their heritage (which member of the community will be selected as representative in each edition, who will make the decisions over the organization of the process and what activities will be carried out). In turn, the festivals highlighted that in depending on public resources for their financing and having been recognized by the state, implies that key decisions over what activities to develop must be made based on the local government in power.</p><p>Third, the interviewed correlated their link to the formal and informal economy, with formal and informal practices of communication. In the case of the Octaves of Mocha, how the image is defined and presented to the Ecuadorian population, is an autonomous decision from the organizers which they do not want to renounce regardless of the sponsorship of natural persons they obtain. The National Festival of Colombian Music highlighted a medium degree of autonomy to define the use of its image in mediums of communication. In contrast, the Colombian Folk Festival, as highlighted by Greis Cifuentes, the Secretary of Tourism in this municipality, faces changes in image every time the local government changes.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*636jKWEyuFq1BOct5TVqnQ.jpeg" /></figure><h3><strong>Reflections on the covid-19 pandemic and affect on the research</strong></h3><p>It was notable that all those interviewed, as a result of the pandemic, identified key aspects for the safeguarding of their heritage to be restructured. The members of the Mocha community wish to generate peasant associations to bring a more stable employment option for creators of costumes and handicrafts since with the pandemic, various people are in high degree of social vulnerability because they can no longer sell their products during the days of celebrating the Octaves, and they require finding other online avenues for marketing.</p><p>In the case of the Colombian Folk Festival, there exists an evident concern because given its high degree of dependence on public resources, a possible contraction in public spending towards the cultural sector puts the development of the festival at risk. Additionally, considering that in Colombia the regulation on public procurement processes require that in order to receive and administer resources from the State, the organizations must demonstrate that the immediately preceding year had a budget equal to or greater than the amount they receive, the Colombian Folk Festival in not having been able to celebrate the 2020 version and in being unable to do so in 2021 due to the rules of social distancing, fears that once the situation is normalized, it will not be able to demonstrate financial capacity to develop the Festival, since it does not have its own resources.</p><p>Likewise, the National Festival of Colombian Music managed to identify only as a result of the pandemic that they have practices of the informal economy that put in danger their continuity. The linking scheme of the director of the festival as a voluntary worker had not been inconvenient in the last two decades. The problem now is that given her imminent retirement due to the impossibility of continuing to develop Festival activities that require high social contact, the Foundation cannot find a person to replace her as a volunteer. Strictly speaking, the pandemic highlighted the degree of labor informality with which this key position for the Foundation was handled.</p><p>Finally, it should be emphasized that various aspects related to the informality of the Andean intangible heritage that are not resolved following epistemological frameworks exist in the region. Extrapolating these territorial barriers and at the same time recognizing that the analysis of the correlation between the formal and informal practices is an incipient issue in the cultural economics, the proposal of the French economist Christian Barrè, allows us to better interpret how informality of the intangible practices based on three key processes: its definition, delimitation and legitimation.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*jBRG1Zf58CZReXtMlRQh4w.jpeg" /></figure><h3><strong>Acknowledgements</strong></h3><p>This project is undertaken by the PEC International Council and supported by the British Council. The PEC International Council is a network of leading policy and creative economy practitioners from across the world. The group is convened by The British Council and is an international advisory body to the Creative Industries Policy and Evidence Centre (PEC), which is led by Nesta.</p><p>This research has been supported by the IPANC (Latin American Heritage Institute)</p><p>Luis Javier Armendariz — Octaves of Mocha Festival<br>Noe Mayorga Ortiz — Octaves of Mocha festival<br>Valentina Brevi Martínez — Researcher<br>Betty García — Director of the Colombian Folk Festival<br>Doris Morera — Director of the National Festival of Colombian Music<br>Greis Cifuentes — Secretary of Culture of Ibague<br>Efrain Valencia — Manager Centro Comercial La Estación</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=49b5d4c51565" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/informal-economy-in-the-global-south/cultural-feasts-and-festivals-between-the-formal-and-the-informal-economy-final-report-49b5d4c51565">Cultural Feasts and Festivals: between the formal and the informal economy Final Report</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/informal-economy-in-the-global-south">The Relationship between the Informal Economy and the Cultural Economy in the Global South</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Cultural Kasi’preneurs of Daveyton: looking through the lens of informality]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/informal-economy-in-the-global-south/cultural-kasipreneurs-of-daveyton-looking-through-the-lens-of-informality-7d50eeb5dcd2?source=rss-c19e5d3f505e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7d50eeb5dcd2</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[British Council Creative Economy]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 14 Jul 2021 07:16:27 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-08-04T13:49:45.562Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4><strong>By Dimakatso Motholo and Avril Joffe</strong></h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/608/0*evwMY0Wbb4yX6ATB" /><figcaption><em>Caption: Dimakatso Motholo, a collage made of images taken of the entrance of Daveyton.</em></figcaption></figure><p><em>A project within the broader Informality in the cultural economy of the Global South project funded by the British Council.</em></p><h3><strong>SECTION 1: Description of the Case Study</strong></h3><p><strong>Geographic Area<br></strong>Location, kasi or township can be defined as areas that were designed under the apartheid regime for cheap labour workers that were mainly classified as ‘African’ (Department of Co-Operative Governance and Traditional Affairs (COGTA), 2009: 6). Spatially, Africans were located far enough to have a clear distinction of social differences (Mahajan, 2014: 3). Unlike many other countries (Brazil to India), the marginalised, the poor, the working class, the informal, and in South Africa, black population, have been excluded from urban development by being located in geographically distinct areas at a distance from economic and commercial activity. Many of the townships in South Africa are still characterised by the apartheid geography and legacy; they still currently serve the dual purpose of providing cheap labour to cities (McGaffin et al., 2015: 10). The history of the townships has shaped the socio-economic status of those that live and operate in them (COGTA, 2009: 6), because of this displacement job seeking and access to economic opportunities is excessively expensive (Mahajan, 2014 and McGaffin et al., 2015).</p><p>Due to South Africa’s unique political history, townships are exclusive to South Africa and therefore the emergence of the township economy resonates only with this country. As a result, there is little literature that focuses on the township economy. However, recent scholars and government officials in South Africa have shown great interest in understanding and supporting the growth of the townships and of the township economy in particular through commissioned research. For example, a significant study by the World Bank on Diepsloot shows that this township has a R2 billion economy, most of which is spent in the suburbs of Sandton and Fourways; only an estimated 25% of money generated in the townships is spent in the township (Mahajan, 2014). The impact of this World Bank study emphasises the potential the township economy has on the entire economy. However, there are more complex aspects that influence the economies of townships such as the health, cultural experiences and well-being of its residents.</p><p>Although the township economy is unique to South Africa, other parts of the world have economies that exist in similar informal complexities. In the study of Diepsloot, Mahajan (2014) uses the concept of the township economy and urban informal economy intertwined; they are characterised as similar to each other, from a global stance the township economy can be referred to as the urban informal economy.</p><p>Inspired by the Diepsloot study, the geographical focus of this study is Daveyton, a township located in the Ekurhuleni Metropolitan Municipality, east of Johannesburg, South Africa. It has a total population of 127 967 and 14.45 km² in size (StatsSA, 2011). It was established in 1952 but only achieved municipal status in 1983. The racial make-up is 98.5% of black African people (StatsSA, 2011). From a cultural perspective, Daveyton is home to iconic artists such as Lebo Mathosa, Lerato ‘Lira’ Molapo, Victor Ndlazilwane, Rhoo Hlatshwayo, and Percy Mtwa. In 1986 Mtwa wrote and staged a play titled Bopha! It was later adapted to film, directed by Morgan Freeman and shot in Daveyton. One of South Africa’s ground-breaking television drama series, Yizo Yizo was set and based in Daveyton.</p><p><strong>The Case Study<br></strong>The study focuses on cultural kasi’preneurs in Daveyton, highlighting how informality is used to activate their businesses. The identified cultural kasi’preneurs have either lived in Daveyton most of their lives or came to Daveyton at a very young age. They are identified as black, male, and between the ages of 25 years and 40 years. Their qualifications range between a matric and a degree, they are mostly solely founders or started the business with friends and the businesses have been operating between 5 years and 15 years. The businesses are located in the various sectors of the cultural and creative industries such as music, fashion, events, graphic design, e-commerce, and the visual arts.</p><p>The term cultural kasi’preneur emerges from using Thomas Aageson’s definition of cultural entrepreneurs as “<em>are risk takers, change agents and resourceful visionaries who generate revenue from innovative and sustainable cultural enterprises that enhance livelihoods and create cultural value for both creative producers and consumers of cultural services and products</em>” (2008: 96) and fusing it with the circumstances of the townships. Cultural entrepreneurs in the townships navigate the space from ideation to production and deliver to a market under oppressive conditions. This makes them a different breed of the cultural entrepreneur that is non-confirming, unapologetic, adapting and constantly embracing their situation.</p><p><strong>Research Methods<br></strong>This study continues from a research study titled <em>Cultural Kasi’preneurs of Daveyton: Cultural entrepreneurs and their processes of creating cultural value in the township.</em> The data collected from the research study was relooked from an informality perspective. Further research was conducted to understand how the informality of networks and spaces allow the cultural kasi’preneurs to produce cultural and creative products and services. Furthermore, this study focuses on understanding the benefits and challenges of informality in the cultural and creative industry.</p><p>The study was conducted using the qualitative approach to the study in conversation with another researcher. The methods used to conduct the study were semi-structured interviews with eleven participants that are founders or co-founders of the business, as well as participant observation whereby the researcher spent time observing the cultural kasi’preneurs’ during their work.</p><p>Observation was not only limited to cultural events but also included following the cultural kasi’preneurs on their social media platforms.</p><p>One of the researchers is a resident of Daveyton and selected cultural kasi’preneurs through observation; selection was made through the visibility of invitations (physical and digital posters) to the cultural events hosted by the cultural kasi’preneurs. Although this proved to be effective, the researcher also made use of snowball sampling to identify and select additional cultural kasi’preneurs that were not as visible. The snowball sampling technique is often used to find other research participants through the researcher’s current participants (Atkinson and Flint, 2001: 1). This technique served a dual purpose in this study; as a link-tracing method (Spreen, 1992), which connects participants and their links to each other, to the larger effect of a network</p><p>Throughout the period of conducting this study, digital posters were collected from various cultural events hosted by five different businesses, of which all founders are participants of this study. The analysis of the posters was not based on their effectiveness as a marketing tool nor for creativity but rather to find connections amongst the cultural kasi’preneurs. This data generates an overview of collaborations and networks amongst participants.</p><h3><em>Cultural Kasi’preneur Profiles</em></h3><p>The section below are short profiles of each cultural kasi’preneur and their business. Throughout this study, the real names of cultural kasi’preneurs are used and referred to by their last names. However, one cultural kasi’preneur requested to remain anonymous therefore the pseudonym Richard Rich is used and Richard Rich (Pty) Ltd to refer to the company.</p><p><strong>Studio 6546.<br></strong>Bhekuyise Charles Magangane, known as BMA, was the founder of Gas Chamber Productions, a music company that BMA decided to close because he felt that the industry rules hindered the advancement of upcoming artists that could not afford resources such as booking recording sessions at a professional recording studio. With Gas Chamber Productions no longer active, BMA started Studio 6546 in 2005 which is an informal recording studio in the living room of his residential home. Studio 6546 refers to the physical address of BMA’s home in Daveyton. BMA is the studio manager, producer, graphic designer and sound engineer for the studio. Studio 6546 provides experiences, services and opportunities that are usually accessed outside the township in the settings of a professional studio. The studio’s main purpose is to serve new and aspiring hip hop artists from the townships; however, the studio has received attention from established artists outside of Daveyton. BMA was influenced to start a recording studio in the township by his own personal journey in the music industry:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*mCnvRx3VFjjjKydeTx-eBg.png" /></figure><p>Growing up I was in need for it (recording studio) and most places were in Johannesburg and that meant travelling expenses. I had to go through my schooling without being in a professional recording studio. It delayed my process of growing and working in the industry and I wanted to change that. I think I contributed to that because now there are quite a few studios in the hood (BMA, 2018).</p><p>Studio 6546 is made of a combination of new and old equipment but prioritizing on the necessary equipment to create good quality music, which also maintains a minimalistic look to the studio. Studio 6546 also hosts a networking event titled Weekend Jumpstart, which is a platform whereby artists from the music industry, the hip hop genre specifically, in the township come together to build on their networks.</p><p><strong>Richard Rich (Pty) Ltd*<br></strong>Richard Rich started his own graphic design company Richard Rich (Pty) Ltd in 2017. Rich offers unlimited graphic design services such as graphics for digital magazines, branding, illustrations, digital invitations to events, marketing packages such as logos, posters, flyers, and visuals for social media. Although Richard Rich (Pty) Ltd is based in Daveyton, Rich has worked for clients such as Kelloggs South Africa and Phillips Kenya and South Africa. Rich states that his business depends on his creativity and working from home within time frames that best suit him:</p><p>The idea was always in my head since I figured out that I can actually turn this graphic thing into a business. So, I’ve always had that idea in my head, I wanted to like start something of my own. The problem is I’ve never loved working a 9 to 5 in my life. I don’t see myself doing a 9 to 5, unless a situation pushes me into doing a 9 to 5. But I don’t see myself, so I’ve always had that thing that I want to do something of my own, that maybe at some point, or years go by its going to helps somebody from the hood or any child. It’s going to employ them. This is my own baby and I know if things don’t work out, I’m responsible and I’m comfortable with it (Rich, 2020).</p><p><strong>Retrofontein Apparel</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*JAi_I7iPpAgsnjG211uhJQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>As you drive down Mocke Street towards Sinaba stadium in Daveyton, you will find a blue shipping container in the front yard of a residential home. This is the home of Kabelo Tsoka’s flagship store, Retrofontein Apparel. Retrofontein, a retrospective fountain of creativity and design, was established in 2012 by Tsoka and his friend who unfortunately left the brand in 2014. Tsoka started the brand by collecting early 1990’s retro clothing, customise with African print and then resell the customised denim jackets. The brand later shifted and focused on narrating township stories through urban street wear. Tsoka’s brand is popular for the statement ‘Valid Dreams’, he elaborates how the idea came to him:</p><p>In late 2015, early 2016, I had applied to have a shelf at this big chain store. They replied this thing is not trendy enough and not what we looking for. I was depressed and thought maybe my brand doesn’t meet the standards. And then same week I was watching the BET Awards and I think Black Coffee had just won an award and part of his acceptance speech, he said Lupita Nyongo said “your dreams are valid”. And then light bulb! Ayi vele maan [expression of agreeing] who are they to validate what I’m doing because this is my dream, not theirs. Then I started with just writing it and thought hey man this would look dope on a t-shit (Tsoka, 2019).</p><p>Retrofontein is associated with validating the dreams of those in the township; the brand wants people from the township to know that their dreams are important and only they can make them a reality.</p><p>Tsoka also hosts an event called the Street Fair which promotes Retrofontein as a brand and other local brands that are similar to Retrofontein. The event is a platform for local brands to interact with each other and sell to their customers.</p><p><strong>Chant Nation<br></strong>Born in Limpopo, Kholofelo Dennis Mashilo, popularly known as Mochene, is a hip-hop artist and the founder of Chant Nation. Chant Nation is a music and events company that was established in 2018. The company also acts as the representative of Mochene in terms of bookings, content ownership, and general management. Mashilo started Chant Nation as a means to house Mochene’s music in the form of a record label and still have the artist own the rights to the music. Mochene raps in Sepedi, which is his mother tongue. As an artist, Mochene uses his mother tongue because he wants to inspire children to be creative and express themselves in their own language:</p><p>When I create music, it’s for people overseas. In my head, I’m thinking this music is for London, and Berlin. It’s an ambition thing. But it’s also for rural kids. I have this picture of a kid in a remote area listening to my music through one ear piece because the other one doesn’t work but still wants to listen to the music because we share the same language. And he hears every word and he tells himself that he is going to do this one day and bigger than the guy he is listening to (Mashilo, 2018).</p><p>Mochene refers to his rap style as chantrap, he draws his lyrical content from what surrounds him, which often reflects on working hard every day to achieve your goals. The combination of the content and the language creates music that the rural child can access, is able to relate to and be inspired to create their own world through their own means.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*Zj_1-lrN861u6BHT3TY5LQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>Credit: Dennis Mashilo, A digital poster marketing a listening session hosted in Maboneng by Mochene</em></figcaption></figure><p><strong>The Jamshack SA<br></strong>“For the love of the music” is a phrase that has been used by artists in the music industry. This is no exception to deep house movement Jamshack SA. In 2015 Nkosana Monyemangena and six of his friends became the co-founders of the movement Jamshack SA. Imagine a place that only plays deep house music and appreciates the DJs that contributed to the genre. This is the concept behind Jamshack SA, the movement is a platform for both established and upcoming DJs in the genre of deep house:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*8t0NSMIZFrTbP5g2yZuu7w.jpeg" /></figure><p>We were out with a group of friends and came back in the early hours of the morning and were discussing how we didn’t like the music. Our close friends were DJs and they agreed. We started playing music at one of the co- founder’s house. We then invited a DJ who played the same genre called deep house. They were locally based and they have helped Jam Shack to grow in terms of their support. We always gave them the platform to play and they would never reject this. The music comes from the DJs that we would hire (Monyemangena, 2019).</p><p>Jamshack SA is an event for a niche market, whereby deep house lovers come to appreciate the music and be in good company. The six co-founders all have a role in the conceptualisation of the movement and ensuring that the events are a success. The responsibilities are shared according to their strengths and portfolios such as technical, production management, marketing and brand awareness, and finance.</p><p>Jamshack SA has opened up a different cultural experience in the township by also creating opportunities for local business through stalls, this allows the experience to be holistically food, fashion and music (offer music and lifestyle). Although the movement began with a focus on Daveyton, co-founders of JamShack SA are now focusing on the entire Ekurhuleni district, bringing together all the townships of the East Rand through music. JamShack SA places deep house music at the forefront of the movement, the purpose of the movement is to make the subgenre attractive.</p><p><strong>1520 Online<br></strong>1520 Online is an online business that started in 2015 by Zuko Soyizwaphi, who is originally from the Eastern Cape but moved to Daveyton in 2006. Soyizwaphi is assisted in running the business by his wife, son and friend and colleague Brian Dubazana. 1520 Online has three streams of income generation; firstly, it sells watch and sunglass boxes online, secondly Soyizwaphi offers online marketing services such as web design, online business profiles, and the creation and maintenance of a company’s online presences, thirdly there is automation, whereby Soyizwaphi finds retired automated parts from various suppliers upon request. The naming of the business 1520 is two dimensional; 1520 is Daveyton’s postal code which marks that the business’s location. 1520 is a number, there is no gender or race attached to it, unfortunately being a black business owner from the township comes with negative connotations such as lack of trust, thus with a number no identity is attached to it:</p><p>Sometimes one had to hide their identity because when white people find out that you’re black and from the township, they don’t want to do business with you. 1520 is a number and took the race thing away and was just a business that is online (Soyizwaphi, 2018).</p><p><strong>Thato Molele (Pty) Ltd.<br></strong>French fashion designer Christian Louboutin once said “Shoes transform your language and body. They lift you physically and emotionally”. As people we make connections with each other and objects that bring meaning into our lives, including our shoes. Thato Molele started his business from customising his own shoes:</p><p>I was lazy to wash my shoes then I decided to paint my all-stars instead. People saw my shoes and I asked me to do a pair for them which they were willing to pay for them. The same day when I delivered the pair another person wanted to give me two pairs to customize. So that’s how I started without the knowledge of drawing. Regardless of the request, even when they request was a Flintstones themed shoe. I was forced into a situation of having to draw but I surprised myself and managed to do so (Molele, 2018).</p><p>Thato Molele established his business Thato Molele (Pty) Ltd in 2015. Thato Molele (Pty) Ltd houses two brands; TM Customs and TM Sneaks. TM Customs believes in reimaging your old shoes and re-establishing the bond you formed when you first bought them. Having started with one yellow fabric paint and one paint brush, TM Customs customises new and old shoes with painted designs that range from African prints, logos and even cartoon characters. People can bring their old shoes or purchase already customised shoes. TM Sneaks is in the process of designing its first boat shoe but will also focus on designing sneakers and heels.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*ZwGc5_I3lhhagkfu6XbpFA.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>Credit: Thato Molele, Molele using fabric paints to customise a client’s sneakers</em></figcaption></figure><p><strong>Igumbi Art Room and Tourism</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/670/0*dJdXjJYwQ3E-BZWY" /></figure><p>Brian Dubazana started Igumbi Art Room and Tourism as a platform that acts as a coordinator, curator and consultant offering the hiring of a mobile art gallery. The concept behind Igumbi was to find many different ways of creating a room that is filled with artworks, rejecting the formal gallery language. Furthermore, the platform organises cultural events that include live performances, poetry, musicians and dancers. The business aims to educate, grow, and create employment whilst putting Daveyton on mainstream tourism. They also offer 10km cycling tours of Daveyton, whereby you can either attend with your own bicycle or rent one from them.</p><p><strong>Capture and Release Visuals<br></strong>Street photographer, videographer, and artist Sibusiso Ncwana started his business in 2013 with a partner who later left the business. Ncwana called his business Capture and Release Photographer but later diversified and called it Capture and Release Visuals. In the naming of the business, Ncwana was inspired by the concept of fishing as a hobby, the act of capturing and releasing the fish, the fishers are more intrigued by the experience of fishing rather than the fish itself:</p><p>Sharing the art with people and sharing information is important. Art needs to breath, it needs to be seen, take the centre of attraction at any given moment, it sparks conversations. The concept of fishing as a hobby, capture and release of the fish gave me the idea. The experience is priceless. Sharing is more important than the actual price of the art. The art and content come first (Ncwana, 2018).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/639/1*Nk3AmouxSknmc3UH8kCMrg.jpeg" /></figure><p>For Ncwana being a photographer is about capturing moments and sharing the art; the art and the content are prioritized; he values the process of meaning making. Capture and Release Visuals offers services in photography, videography, and the making of industrial furniture such as rondavel chairs, wine racks and bar tables. Rondavel chairs are designed from old tyres and rope, whilst the wine racks and bar tables are made from palates wood. Ncwana also has a hire and maintenance element to the industrial furniture aspect. As a photographer, Ncwana photographs social events and private shoots. However, the work that he cherishes the most is his series works such as his most recent titled The Skill Trade Series. The work focuses on ordinary people in Daveyton making a living from their own hands often on the side of the street such as the man that repairs shoes or the ladies selling clothes. Ncwana is inspired by photographer Fhatuwani Mukheli from I See A Different You, which focuses on changing the world’s negative view of Africa into a positive one through telling our own African experiences through an African lens.</p><p><strong>Centre Creation<br></strong>Growing up in Daveyton, Floyd Masuku was influenced by the fashion and recycling industries. With no leisure money for the movies or arcade games, Masuku and his friends would collect cans and sell them to recycling companies. Masuku used the money to buy clothes for himself. His interest in fashion was intrigued by fashion magazines such as Vogue which his aunt would bring from work. Masuku was inspired by the clothes in the publication and wanted to dress like the models:</p><p>So looking at those magazines, I was inspired by the clothing those people were wearing. At the time, I didn’t think of making the clothes but rather that I want to dress like them and look good like them. But as time progressed the desire to make the clothes came (Masuku, 2018).</p><p>In 2007, Masuku started his own brand called Centre Creation. Centre Creation alters, designs and makes most forms of clothing. Masuku is popular for creating shirts and dresses for people attending events such as weddings and parties. He also creates garments from off cut material, making the garment unique as it cannot be reproduced.</p><p><strong>Shokcoll</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/639/1*OVa_LndscXaHsdwTmS8sJQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Thabo Collen Shoko began as a stylist, styling himself and posting different clothing combinations on his personal Facebook account, through this he was able to style musicians for their music videos:</p><p>I’ve always loved clothes but I never loved crowds. I had a lot of friends but was always the odd on out. I was working on my profile of being a stylist, it was easy because I already had a number of people who thought that I was a designer. It was easy to agree with them and say yes I am a designer. I sold people dreams that I made come true (Shoko, 2018).</p><p>Shoko’s love for fashion grew when he became a designer, wearing clothes that he made himself. In 2014 Shoko began his own clothing brand called Shokcoll. Shokcoll focuses on custom designs such as dresses and suites for high class events. The brand also has a ready to wear collection that Shoko releases yearly. Shoko describes his designs as functional, eco-friendly, cultural and timeless. The brand also celebrates individuals that have survived being ill-treated by society because of their gender, race, disability or religion.</p><h3><strong>SECTION 2: Resourceful visionaries creating sustainable livelihoods through informality</strong></h3><p>The environment of the townships has provoked cultural kasi’preneurs to be concerned with new ideas and production processes that can emerge from the environment for positive change. Mbaye (2011) highlights that cultural entrepreneurs in Africa explore opportunities for the sake of adapting to a challenging environment and economic development. Their innovations are more based on problem solving in their community rather than being profit driven. The following sections highlight the findings of this study through the four identified themes: the experience of learning: learning and unlearning, multiple income streams through multiple skill sets, friends and family as networks, and the transformation of spaces: creating productive work spaces.</p><p><strong>Theme 1 |The experience of learning: learning and unlearning.<br></strong>Many people in the township struggle to go study at a tertiary institution because of the financial situation at home (the average cost of tuition and accommodation per year is R60 000), and of those that manage to go, some drop out because of the debt that is being accumulated. Without a bursary or scholarship, the financial capacity in a household determines whether the individual furthers their studies or finds a job to help support the family. Although access to higher learning has such financial implications, it is still viewed as pivotal to a successful narrative of the black child from the township. Cultural kasi’preneurs found it necessary to explore other means of learning.</p><p>Magangane was studying music but felt that the curriculum emphasised history and theory rather than music production:</p><p>I dropped out</p><p>I felt that I had the basics of everything. I started feeling that formal schooling wasn’t working out for me. Especially the fact that we were coming into the information age, whereby technology was advancing. Things that you can learn at school are available online and are advanced and directed to your needs because you are learning in your own time and at own pace. I could create my own online programme (Magangane, 2018).</p><p>Although Magangane’s reasons for leaving a higher learning institution are not related to financial circumstance, he suggests online learning as another form of learning and experience that is beyond what formal institutions are able to provide. For individuals without the support of a formal structure to acquire knowledge, other means of acquiring knowledge becomes necessary. Self-teaching becomes the access point for knowledge for the cultural kasi’preneur. They take initiative by finding means of learning through online platforms, from people with experience or in the simple efforts of trial and error. Although during the COVID-19 pandemic, online learning has now become the new norm, cultural kasi’preneurs saw the potential and opportunities in this form of learning way before. The internet has offered a lot of self-teaching tools in various skills, from graphic design to business management and finance.</p><p>The informality of learning online allowed Magangane to learn at his own pace, learning the skills he wanted to learn when he wanted to learn them. This is also viewed as an easy and affordable way to acquire knowledge. Magangane expresses how he was able to design his own curriculum that attended to his needs and those of the business. He further explains how there is a quick turnaround in applying the skills learnt online in the business as he tends to make use of them immediately. However, this informal way of learning is not without its challenges, the skills learnt are not supported or recognized by accredited institutions and as a result potential clients, competitors, and other businesses underestimate the credibility of the business and the cultural kasi’preneur.</p><p>Another informal way of acquiring skills is through observation and practice. Self-teaching becomes the access point for knowledge for the cultural kasi’preneur. They take initiative by finding people with experience to learn from or in the simple efforts of trial and error. Ncwana learnt his skills by using different software without prior knowledge:</p><p>I started playing around with software, there was a studio at the mall called Parasol. From the visits to the studio I learnt Software: Picasso (editing of the pictures), pricing, props for photo shoots (Ncwana, 2018).</p><p>Ncwana learnt his photography skills through observing how other photographers worked in the studio. He further used this technique of observation to learn how to make industrial furniture. Ncwana learnt to make rondavel chairs and industrial furniture such as bar tables and wine racks through observing a fellow craftsman.</p><p>The difficulties in learning through observation is the constant need to access someone’s process of working and often professional settings do not accommodate this informally. Ncwana was fortunate enough to have relationships with people working at the photographic studio and his fellow craftsman. It is because of these relationship dynamics that there is a willingness to share knowledge. The skills learnt during observation are tested through a trial-and-error processes which requires a space that allows you to work through material and be open to failure as part of learning. This also results in extra costs as some material is wasted during this learning phase. Trial-and-error is time consuming and repetitive; the individual becomes both student and teacher at the same time, constantly correcting and practicing till until the skill is mastered.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*6nAZlajr_IkSc0mY-rvw6w.jpeg" /></figure><p>With the art form such as graphic design, new trends are constantly emerging, therefore, the skills set needs to be regularly developed. When a graphic designer is constantly working on their skills set allows them to be diverse and be able to be competitive in the market space. The trial-and-error way of learning is not without risks, the business can fail in some aspects because of the lack of experience and incorrect knowledge, this is where mentorship offers assistance; learning from someone with experience and expertise provides access to knowledge.</p><p>Mentorships or job shadowing are learning strategies used both formally and informally. Shoko describes how he learnt to make clothes from working for local designer Masuku (cultural kasi’preneur who is also part of this study), referred to below as Floyd:</p><p>At the time I was working on being a stylist and didn’t know that I could be a designer. I helped Floyd with alterations and that’s when I learnt how to sew, how pants are made from undoing and putting them back together. After Floyd I went to Transnet for a year and six months. I was good at welding but my heart wasn’t in it. I woke up on day and decided that I couldn’t do this anymore and that I wanted to do fashion (Shoko, 2018).</p><p>This informal mentorship offers direct access to an experienced individual and expertise. Shoko’s desires to learn motivated him to use reverse engineering as a process to examine and analyse the detail of making a garment through deconstruction to discover and be able to reconstruct the garment. This form of learning exposes you to the reality problem solving and how things are made, it is not a hypothetical situation. Shoko describes how during this process he felt empowered and was able to develop his knowledge and directly fill the knowledge gaps he felt he needed to.</p><h3><strong>Theme 2: Multiple income streams through multiple skill sets</strong></h3><p>As a result of these alternative forms of learning and to the extent of being easily accessible, affordable, circumstantial, and imbedded within the everyday lives of what the cultural kasi’preneur is exposed to or who they are in contact with or who they are rel90ated to, they are able to have a diverse skill set, they are able to master more than one skill. These skill sets provide opportunities to have multiple forms of income by translating these skills and using them within their businesses. Within these business practices they are able to have diversified revenue streams. For example, Igumbi Arts Room provides a number of products and services which translate to multiple income streams; it hosts events such as the backyard market and the township tours, as well as selling industrial furniture.</p><p>The need to have multiple skills that translate into multiple income streams when used in the business is a circumstantial agenda as one income stream is not sufficient to maintain both the livelihood and the sustainability of the business of the cultural kasi’preneur. There is a core business activity that is either supported or supplemented by other activities from these other skills within the business.</p><p>In the formal structure of the business there is often the need to be categorized in a certain manner and there is an expectation to follow certain protocols. Depending on how the business is registered, it is often then limited within those parameters, the business must be conducted in a certain manner. The informal structure would allow the business to navigate and go beyond these limitations. The business is able to diversify its revenue streams.</p><p>Capture and Release Visuals offers services in photography, videography, and the making of industrial furniture such as rondavel chairs, wine racks and bar tables. Rondavel chairs are designed from old tyres and rope, whilst the wine racks and bar tables are made from pallets wood. Ncwana also has a hire and maintenance element to the industrial furniture aspect. As a photographer, Ncwana photographs social events and private shoots.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*t4EU3H6xaELBraEtNDQgew.jpeg" /></figure><p>Ncwana works as a photographer and visual artist. He has diversified his business based on his skills and capabilities. Through his business, Ncwana has created multiple jobs for himself that support his series photography; this is possible through sales and services rendered income (maintaining and hiring) from industrial furniture and part-time Deejaying:</p><p>The business is not yet structured but mostly I have become a consultant in a way. I’m breaking down the business into smaller businesses that can stand on their own but also can feed into each other (Ncwana, 2018).</p><p>Often the other activities within the business are linked to the core activities and extend the business. The need to diversify is a response to the possibility of an income stream suffering, diversifying income streams creates income streams that support one another. It can also be viewed as a strategy to overcome financial issues that occur in the business in the efforts of protecting the business. For one to be able to diversify, they need to seek opportunities outside what they are already offering or seek opportunities for expansion of the business within their skills set.</p><p>Magangane is the studio manager, producer, graphic designer and sound engineer for the studio. Studio 6546 provides experiences, services and opportunities that are usually accessed outside the township in the settings of a professional studio. Magangane’s multiple skill set allows him to have a holistic approach to music production, he is able to group his services together and offer a full package or an experience and still offer a single service depending on his client’s needs. Magangane offers a different perspective to the motivation of having multiple skills; for him, having all these various skills is cost efficient and allows him to offer his clients the best services and quality music at an affordable price. This also allows him to align with the purpose of the business which is to offer musicians from the township with affordable music production that produces quality music that can compete with well-established recording studios.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*lVT7lwwl6wuaTCVy6qLaCQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Jamshack SA offers a different example to Studio 6546, as for this business multiple skills are sourced from various individuals that share the same passion and love for creating or providing a certain cultural product or services. For Jamshack SA, the multiple skills through the co-founders doesn’t translate to multiple income streams, however, the co-founders alternatively finance the business through their personal finances. Each co-founder is either employed or running another business. Their personal finances are mostly used to hire good quality sound equipment. Monyemangena emphasises that the experience of the music is crucial to the brand thus having bad sound is not an option, throughout his interview he constantly supports his strategies with the phrase “music stays winning”.</p><h3><em>Theme 3 |The transformation of spaces: creating productive work spaces</em></h3><p>Cultural kasi’preneurs have found ways to transform unconventional spaces into working and productive environments. The lack of infrastructure in the townships has not stopped the start and growing of businesses.</p><p>To be able to cut costs in the creation of cultural products and services is a major priority. Working from home allows cultural kasi’preneurs to not bear the costs of travelling every day to a workspace, rather the money that would have been spent on commuting can be spent on the business such as material costs, paying suppliers, contributing to salaries and any travelling costs that may occur during distribution. Financial support is very limited for businesses in the township therefore being able to run a cost-effective business allows opportunities for the business to be sustainable. Many residents of the township spend most of their time commuting to and back from work, not only is this time consuming but a large portion of salaries and wages is spent on transport. When this travelling cost is cut, the money can be saved and invested into the business.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*yoCq9xkpMj1z5AGXHfJXIQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Most of the cultural kasi’preneurs work from home because of the circumstance and not necessarily by choice. Often the circumstance is a result of the lack of finance. The assumption that is usually made is that life is affordable in the townships, however, for small businesses trying to grow, this is not the case. Office space or retail stores for rental are expensive and as a result the cultural kasi’preneur finds themselves working from home to avoid this cost. This also removes the pressure of a rental fee every month from the business, allowing the business to focus on its core activities. Working from home can be convenient for the cultural kasi’preneur in that they have more time to focus on ideation and producing content for their business. The cultural kasi’preneur is not subjected to specific time frame to work, instead they are able to work at a time that is convenient to the cultural kasi’preneur.</p><p>During the COVID-19 pandemic ‘working from home’ became a norm and a safety measurement for many businesses, however, this did not shift the perception people have around businesses in homes in the township. In many cases people make conclusions about businesses based on its physical environment. Although working from home has advantages that assist to overcome financial constraints, it is not without challenges. One of the major disadvantages about working from home is that clients may view the cultural kasi’preneur as not professional or do not trust that the product or service will be delivered within the requested time frame, Shoko describes his difficulties:</p><p>Some of the challenges of working from home is that people don’t always take you seriously and the environment can hinder your creativity. Where is the fitting room? Some people judge you based on the machine that you have so they tend to want to see the machine (Shoko, 2018).</p><p>As a result, one can lose clients without being given the opportunity to provide the product or service. This also highlights that working from home, the product or service offered needs to work harder to prove its value in the market space. Clients can easily misinterpret the value of the product or service based on the environment it is created in.</p><p>Working from home requires discipline as there are more distractions. Time can easily be wasted on matters that do not concern the business. With the lack of separation between home time and work time the boundaries are not clear and focus is easily lost. One aspect can easily get lost in the other as a result there is a lack of balance. The cultural kasi’preneur can easily lose confidence in their own product and services as they feel that their business is not growing beyond the home environment. A lack of confidence within the cultural kasi’preneur can slow down the process of creating value. Rich highlights how working informally can be stressful and emotionally straining because of the irregular source of income and the need for the business to constantly prove its value.</p><p>Creative block is a big setback. I tend to meditate. It relaxes and it helps me block out the unnecessary noise. And think of what I want to think of. I start thinking of ideas for the work, I use little things to create big ideas (Rich, 2018).</p><p>The creation of cultural and creative businesses within the township leads to the transformation of spaces within the township. For example, a simple backyard is transformed into an outdoor gallery that offers a different experience to the consumer. The format of the gallery is challenged yet the space is transformed and redefines itself.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*Nd7bq0k1EvGUnfEcc6BKzQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>The idea of the workspace at home can also be viewed as the reason for these businesses to be located in the township of Daveyton. Businesses are forming in the homes of cultural kasi’preneurs and working from home has proved to have advantages and disadvantages.</p><p>Other spaces such as abandoned buildings are able to house the needs of a cultural and creative business. An abandoned bus factory is turned into a co-working space for various organisations and enterprises located in the township. The space is transformed into a production house for industrial furniture and future streetwear brands:</p><blockquote>Working at Bus Shed, you meet people in the same line of work as you and sometimes have more experience. They offer help by referring technicians to fix the machine. In a crisis you can call the technician and they come to you to fix the problem (Masuku, 2018).</blockquote><p>Co-working spaces foster collaborations, these can be viewed as intentional or unintentional. Within a co-working space, resources, information as well as expertise are shared amongst those that cohabit the space. From this sharing experience, people become connected and a network emerge.</p><h3><em>Theme 4 |Friends and family as networks.</em></h3><p>In the township, business support from formal structures and access to financial assistance is scarce. This is often due to a lack of record and documentation about the business. Although all the businesses of the cultural kasi’preneurs in this study are registered at the point of the study, this was not the case when some of the businesses were starting. As a result, cultural kasi’preneurs have had to seek other forms of support for their businesses.</p><p>Friends and family have become informal support structures to various aspects of the business. Cultural kasi’preneurs refer to a network of “friends” rather than acquaintances to gain access to relevant information, collaboration or human resources in the form of offering skills set to the business. The cultural kasi’preneur’s social capital (Bourdieu, 1984) is reflected in the amount and value of these personal relationships and how they contribute to the survival of the business (Lizé, 2016: 45). The core idea of social capital is that social networks have value and this affects the productivity of individuals (McLean, Schultz, &amp; Steger 2002: 4). These influential relationships form strong networks that cultural kasi’preneurs are able to draw on during the process of creating cultural products and services. During the interviews, cultural kasi’preneurs referred to establishing their networks through their childhood friends or meeting other influential people through people they grew up with. Through these friendships, there is a sharing of resources and collaborating with each other on big projects. Whilst working on certain projects together, consumers begin to affiliate certain products and services with each other. In most cases, the affiliation has had positive effects for the businesses.</p><p>In the process of production, the cultural kasi’preneur’s network is crucial to assess possible resources, partnerships, collaborations, customers and employees (Scott, 2012: 244). Their network reflects their social capital and when this alternative form of capital (Bourdieu, 1985) is mobilized and converted into the needed resource, cultural kasi’preneurs are able to access resources they did not possess, increase their use-value as well as exchange-value (Scott.,2012: 246). Working informally, the cultural kasi’preneurs rely heavily on their networks to conduct their businesses.</p><p>Rich describes how he gained access to resources he needed to start his company:</p><p>I started with a laptop, with nothing. I had no money. They had just bought me a laptop here at home, I got software from my homies. They taught me how to use most of them. I was like you know what I’m going to change this nothing into something (Rich, 2018).</p><p>It is through his family and friends that he was able to start his business. His ‘friends’ shared information, skills and knowledge without requesting a monetary exchange but rather shared with him based on their friendship. This also reflects that within these networks, cultural kasi’preneurs do not see themselves as competition but rather as support structures with opportunities for future collaborations. For cultural kasi’preneurs such as Rich, networks are the foundation of their businesses and are able to create sustainable livelihood because of their networks. This unconventional system of sharing knowledge is based on trust and the willingness to teach and learn (self-development).</p><p>Furthermore, strong networks have the ability to support the growth of the business. During his interview, Ncwana emphasises how most of his big orders for his rondavel chairs were the result of his existing network. This suggests that the links formed amongst cultural kasi’preneur is beneficial in that it provides access to a market. The referrals brought more clients, more revenue, and assisted in building a reputation for the business. Referrals can also be viewed as ‘word of mouth’, which is a marketing strategy based on trust and personal recommendations amongst clients.</p><p>A niche market has influence, in contrast to the belief that large enterprises focus on investing in cultural and creative products whose conventions are widely shared, whilst small enterprise are left to focus on genres that seem to be less appealing (Dubios, 2012). However, there is no doubt that it is also constrained by the social relations and institutional trusts, networks, norms and beliefs. All the cultural kasi’preneurs indicated that their market is mostly from the township. Their businesses receive a large support from the residents of Daveyton but they also promote their business outside the township and find that they are supported by residents from other townships such as Soweto, Voslorus, Katlehong, Thembisa and even Pretoria. Markets can therefore be understood as embedded within existing broader society conditions; they cannot exist in isolation, rather they are within a specific context (Lee, 2006: 301).</p><p>Marketing is viewed as a human exchange of relationships (Lee, 2006: 302). This idea of marketing as a human interaction allows cultural kasi’preneurs to understand and think differently about the marketing strategies they employ. The interaction with consumers is facilitated by the cultural kasi’preneur’s ability to tell their story. Lounsbury and Glynn define cultural entrepreneurship as the process of storytelling that mediates the access to resources and capital in order to create wealth (2001: 545). Storytelling is viewed as a form of identity creation and legitimacy for new businesses (Lounsbury and Glynn, 2001: 546), stories are important symbols that make use of verbal, visual and written language.</p><p>The identity of the business becomes the key element to attract investors, providing a competitive advantage, access to consumers and new market opportunities (Lounsbury and Glynn, 2001: 545). It is through these stories that cultural kasi’preneurs are able to communicate the value of their products and services. The story becomes the link between the cultural entrepreneur’s business and the rest of the world. The data from this study suggests that cultural kasi’preneurs combine personal and the business’ stories to assist the consumer to connect with their offering, this contributes to the running of a successful marketing campaign. Retrofontein Apparel and Mochene’s personal stories are linked to the business to market their products and services. The link between the business and personal story is embedded in the cultural value of the products and services.</p><p>The friendship between Tsoka (Retrofontein Apparel) and Mashilo (Mochene) has brought their brands together, supporting each other through association:</p><p>He (Tsoka) started doing clothes and one day he asked if he could take pictures of me in his clothes. I’ve been wearing his clothes ever since; I perform and go to events wearing Retro most of the time. Both our brands just seemed to align well (Mashilo, 2018).</p><p>The two brands indirectly endorse one another. Mashilo as a local hip hop artist and a local clothing brand bring together two niche markets to create a bigger market to share. Based on their friendship and trust, Mashilo is the ambassador for Retrofontein; there is no official contract that binds them but the contract of friendship (network). Mashilo’s fans purchase the Retrofontein brand to relate to the artist, whilst supporters of the Retrofontein brand are also likely to be introduced to or know of Mashilo’s music. This is also made possible because of the geographical space they share within the township. Tsoka and Mashilo’s relationship can also be viewed as the formation of a network.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/639/1*SDGaqQCk6ntt2bB-2Zh4lw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Cultural kasi’preneurs have found ways to align their brands together in the efforts of sharing a market and take advantage of social media platforms for storytelling. Storytelling by cultural kasi’preneurs plays a critical role in enabling growth of the business, and possible opportunities and resource flow towards the business, as well as the creation of wealth.</p><p>Sometimes resources and knowledge are acquired through inheritance, from one generation to the next. Shoko received his first domestic machine as an inheritance from his great grandmother. His grandmother owned a number of sewing machines. Although he never learnt to make clothes directly from her, this inheritance gave Shoko his first opportunity to make clothes. This machine gave him one of his first experiences of learning to make garments from a sketch, he was able to elevate his skills from being a fashion stylist to fashion designer.</p><p>Shoko expanded on equipment through buying 2nd hand equipment from his mentor’s client. A good quality industrial machine costs between R10 000 and R30 000 depending on the brand. The client had an industrial machine in her home but desperately wanted to get rid of it and was willing to part with it for R2 000. This offer was initially made to Masuku but he already had a machine and no space. Although Shoko didn’t have the money, he still managed to get a loan from family members to purchase the industrial machine. He received a loan worth R1 000 from his grandmother and the other R1 000 from his sister but the terms of loan from the sister was that Shoko’s father would pay her back. He describes the favour his father did for him to be helpful but also as spoiling him as he didn’t feel pressured to work hard to pay off the loans as he was only paying back the first half to his grandmother.</p><p>Shoko highlights the impact of the pressure to pay back the loan:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*LzRsucoZw8exxuZkPp-b-Q.jpeg" /></figure><ul><li>You work harder and seek more opportunities.</li><li>Motivated to succeed as your success is not only your own but also everyone who supported you.</li><li>You want to pay back the money to maintain the relationship for future support, building the trust.</li><li>Building a reputation for the business and yourself as an entrepreneur.</li></ul><p>The system of access to finance through family members is based on trust, relations, and the need to be supportive towards each other. There is no contract, however the agreement between the two parties can be verbal. There is often no deadline or interest charged on the initial money borrowed.</p><h3><strong>SECTION 3: Access and flexibility afforded by informality</strong></h3><p>Despite the South African government’s ongoing efforts, in the form of initiatives set up by the Department of Arts and Culture, such as the Cultural Industries Growth Strategy (1997), Mzansi Golden Economy (2013), South African Cultural Observatory (SACO) (2014), and the Cultural and Creative Industries Federation of South Africa (CCIFSA) (2015), there is insufficient direct support to cultural entrepreneurs in the townships. During interviews with the cultural kasi’preneurs, none of the government initiatives were mentioned as providing support to cultural entrepreneurs and their businesses. They also had no knowledge that these initiatives existed to understand and provide support to the cultural and creative industries in South Africa. Molele’s response to his lack of engagement with government initiatives is that his independence and survival requires action and waiting for the government to provide assistance is not an option.</p><p>The cultural kasi’preneur offers a different definition of success for the black child in the township; their stories inspire and influence children from the township to know that opportunities and dreams can exist within the township landscape; there are dreams being realised in the township, cultural kasi’preneurs are transforming their townships through their own visions, cultural value and moving between formality and informality. Working primarily informally gives access to new learning experiences, access to resources and flexibility within the business. Cultural kasi’peneurs are driven by the need to succeed and make a difference, they constantly find themselves reimaging how they operate their businesses because of their environment.</p><p>Cultural kasi’preneurs make use of informal networks to access information and resources. The system of the network is embedded in friendships formed over the years; therefore, the relationships are based on trust and are reciprocal. The cultural kasi’preneur also recognises the power of affiliation. Affiliating the business and the brand with other local businesses and brands allows cultural kasi’preneurs to share a market. This also reflects that survival is sometimes dependent on sharing rather than competing. To be able to share this market, the cultural kasi’preneurs ensure that their stories are relevant but also different from one another. Storytelling through online platforms is one of the most popular and cost-effective way for the cultural kasi’preneur to communicate the values of their cultural products and services.</p><p>Townships are a major consumer space because of the populations, however, despite their huge potential, businesses in the township struggle to attract the attention and the investors needed to grow the business because of their geographical location and how informal and formal methods are fused together in the business. Public policy needs to move towards making townships attractive and sustainable for both livelihood and businesses. Townships are unique to South Africa and in reality, are growing. The cultural and creative industries in the township have the potential of making our townships attractive for these investments.</p><p>Cultural kasi’preneurs provoke us to think of the township as a space capable of existing and recreating itself beyond the boundaries of its historical formation (Mbhele, 2020). The township is more than just a place that we constantly dream of escaping but rather is part of the dream and the success we aspire to have. Unlike their cultural predecessors that reiterate the need to leave the township, cultural kasi’preneurs are finding alternative forms of existing, creating meaning, seeing, surviving and thinking about the township. They have a sense of appreciation for the potentialities of the township which are outside the norm that anything that tries to find life is already dead (Mbhele, 2020). The cultural kasi’preneur understands that there is no other option but to create cultural value and redefine success.</p><p><strong>References<br></strong>AAGESON, T.H. 2008. Cultural Entrepreneurs: Producing cultural value and wealth In: H. Anheier &amp; Y,R. Isar (eds) Cities, Cultural Policy and Governance. The Cultures and Globalization Series. Vol 2. London: Sage Publications Ltd, pp. 93–107</p><p>BOURDIEU, P. 1984. Distinction: a social critique of the judgement of taste. Harvard University Press</p><p>BOURDIEU, P. 1985. “The Forms of Capital.” Handbook of Theory and Research for the Sociology of Education. Ed by J Richardson. 241–258. New York: Greenwood Press, pp.246–258.</p><p>BROMLEY, R. 1978. Introduction-The Urban Informal Sector: Why is it worth discussing? World Development (6)10. pp. 1033–1039.</p><p>BROWN, D. &amp; McGranahan, G. 2015. The Urban Informal Economy, Local Inclusion and Achieving a Global Green Transformation. Habitat International 53, November: 97–105.</p><p>CHARMAN, A. 2016. The South African township economy and informal micro-enterprises: What are the prospects for youth employment and entrepreneurship? Prepared for Development Policy Research Unit A Policy Brief commissioned for the World Bank Group Jobs. University of Cape Town.</p><p>Department of Co-Operative Governance and Traditional Affairs. 2009. Township Transformation Timeline.</p><p>FORBES AFRICA, 2015. I Speak as a Businesswoman in Music. Available at: <a href="https://www.forbesafrica.com/life/2015/12/01/i-speak-as-a-businesswoman-in-music/">https://www.forbesafrica.com/life/2015/12/01/i-speak-as-a-businesswoman-in-music/</a> [Accessed 1st April 2021].</p><p>LEE, H. 2006. When arts met marketing. International Journal of Cultural Policy (11) 3.</p><p>LIZÉ, W. 2016. Artistic work intermediaries as value producers. Agents, managers, tourneurs and the acquisition of symbolic capital in popular music. Journal of Poetics Vol 59, pp.35–49</p><p>LOUNSBURY, M &amp; GLYNN, M. A. 2001. Cultural Entrepreneurship: Stories, Legitimacy, and the Acquisition of Resources. Strategic Management Journal 22: 545–564.</p><p>MAHAJAN, S. 2014. Overview. In S. Mahajan (ed.) Economics of South African Townships. Special focus on Diepsloot. Washington, D.C: The World Bank, 1–29.</p><p>MBAYE, J.F. 2011. Reconsidering Cultural Entrepreneurship: Hip Hop Music Economy and Social Change in Senegal, Francophone West Africa. PhD Thesis. London</p><p>MBENDENI, A. Remembering iconic Kwaito star Lebo Mathosa 14 years after her death. DRUM (Online) Available at: <a href="https://www.news24.com/drum/celebs/news/remembering-iconic-kwaito-star-lebo-mathosa-14-years-after-her-death-20201023">https://www.news24.com/drum/celebs/news/remembering-iconic-kwaito-star-lebo-mathosa-14-years-after-her-death-20201023</a> [Accessed 1st April 2021].</p><p>MBHELE, M. 2018. Artists must strive to reimagine ways of portraying and inhabiting ikasi. Mail &amp; Gaurdian [online] Available at: <a href="https://mg.co.za/article/2020-04-18-artists-must-strive-to-reimage-ways-of-portraying-and-inhabiting-ikasi/">https://mg.co.za/article/2020-04-18-artists-must-strive-to-reimage-ways-of-portraying-and-inhabiting-ikasi/</a> [Accessed 18th April 2020]</p><p>MCGAFFIN, R., NAPIER, M. &amp; KARURI-SEBINA, G. 2015. South African Township Economies and Commercial Property Markets: A Conceptualisation and Overview. South African Cities Network</p><p>MCLEAN, S.L. &amp; STEGER, M.B. 2002. Introduction. In: S.L. McLean., D.A. Schultz. &amp; M.B. Steger (eds) Social capital: critical perspectives on community and “Bowling Alone”. (eds) by New York University Press: London and New York, pp.1–17</p><p>SCOTT, M. 2012. Cultural entrepreneurs, cultural entrepreneurship: Music producers mobilising and converting Bourdieu’s alternative capitals. Poetics (40)3: 237–255.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7d50eeb5dcd2" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/informal-economy-in-the-global-south/cultural-kasipreneurs-of-daveyton-looking-through-the-lens-of-informality-7d50eeb5dcd2">Cultural Kasi’preneurs of Daveyton: looking through the lens of informality</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/informal-economy-in-the-global-south">The Relationship between the Informal Economy and the Cultural Economy in the Global South</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Business of Handmade]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/informal-economy-in-the-global-south/business-of-handmade-670f63efc740?source=rss-c19e5d3f505e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/670f63efc740</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[British Council Creative Economy]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 14 Jul 2021 07:14:27 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-08-04T13:52:08.380Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4><strong>The Role of Craft-led Enterprises in ‘Formalising’ India’s Artisan Economy </strong>By 200 Million Artisans (200M)</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*NrlGaKJKs7OAGoMQAQ7pBA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Credit: rangSutra</figcaption></figure><p><em>India’s 200 million strong artisan economy showcases the vital role played by the informal sector in bringing creativity in conversation with sustainable development in the Global South. 200 Million Artisans’ (200M) Business of Handmade Report explores this relationship through the eyes of 12 formal enterprises, from diverse geographies and scale, that work with India’s artisan communities.</em></p><p><strong>Business of Handmade is available as a downloadable digital report on </strong><a href="http://www.businessofhandmade.com./"><strong>www.businessofhandmade.com</strong></a></p><h3><strong>Making the Case for the Artisan Economy</strong></h3><p>Post COVID-19, concerned stakeholders are keen on rebuilding broken economies and reversing deep-rooted mindsets that perpetuate inequities. To do so, we need to acknowledge that historically marginalised communities operate in the shadows i.e. within the greys of the informal economy that accounts for over 60% of the global workforce. Nearly 90% of India’s workforce is in the informal sector with no minimum wages or any kind of social security.</p><p>In India, the artisan economy is a primarily rural, informal, and creativity-led landscape with a high concentration of low and differently skilled population. Despite that, it already meets 11 out of the 17 Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). With over 200 million livelihoods directly or indirectly linked to the artisan sector, along with 50% participation of women, the handmade sector also continues to be one of the primary means of dignified employment among rural communities.</p><h3><strong>Role of Craft-Based Enterprises</strong></h3><p>Formal enterprises in India’s artisan economy are key to greater inclusion since they employ undocumented rural communities and deploy necessary social protections — thereby formalising artisans.</p><p>The research reveals that in India, businesses in the informal cultural economy have a unique growth trajectory. Instead of centralising operations (a hallmark of most formal enterprises), craft-based formal enterprises decentralise.</p><p>They take the work to the doorstep of informal artisan communities. This is significant because more than 50% of artisans in India are women who often cannot step out of their homes and communities owing to patriarchal or cultural norms.</p><p>Social and creative enterprises also bring in social protections, streamline the farm-to-consumer pipeline via decentralised grassroots collectivising like cooperatives and producer companies. Enterprises recognise and respond to the informal nature of craft-based work and plan around it.</p><p>With 90 million new jobs needed in the non-farm sector by 2030, it is time to recognise such enterprises — usually micro, small and medium in size — as the next frontier of impact.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*AevEGhsGXfN747pWr9oWBQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Credit: Fab Creation</figcaption></figure><h3><strong>About Business of Handmade</strong></h3><p>The research documents the role of craft-based enterprises in formalising India’s artisan economy. 200M documented 12 social and creative enterprises from diverse geographies, of varying sizes, and legal structures to understand how they navigate challenges posed by informality and culture.</p><p>There is a growing tribe of small businesses and micro, small, and medium enterprises (MSMEs) — formal enterprises in India’s handmade sector, often women-led, who play a pivotal role in bridging the language and resource gaps for dispersed artisan communities. Such enterprises are adapting to local needs and contexts to create long-term value. Findings also confirm that context-specific entrepreneurial action can catalyse inclusion of informal and traditionally marginalised creative communities.</p><h3><strong>Overview of Findings</strong></h3><ol><li><strong>‘New Formal’ The New Normal in the Artisan Economy<br></strong>The New Formal is a dynamic continuum wherein Informal modes of work among rural creative cultures inform business models of creative enterprises who adapt to local contexts to drive productivity, profits, and innovation. Anchored by entrepreneurial creativity and livelihood generation, the New Formal co-opts the flexibility and complexity of cultural interactions in the informal economy along with metrics from the formal economy like education, policy, and finance.</li></ol><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/701/1*J6vN0wvyYbUak1uTtLKCLw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Business of Handmade: The New Formal as a framework to understand entrepreneurial action / formal-informal interplay in the artisan economy (Original: Krishnamoorthy &amp; Kapur, 2021)</figcaption></figure><p><strong>2. Misunderstood and Undermapped<br></strong>The informal nature of India’s artisan sector is not one of its own doing or choosing. What isn’t mapped or measured remains sidelined as informal. The 200 million strong landscape of craft-based work remains underrepresented as a priority focus area in policy and investment in the absence of reliable census data. Plus, fractured information networks exclude dispersed rural communities from existing schemes on infrastructure, credit, and education.</p><p>The State and private actors need to invest in formal research — numbers-led mapping of artisans and craft-led enterprises — as well as incentivise documentation of intangible processes, relationships, and generational knowledge of communities instead of relying only on self-reportage. Intermediaries, social enterprises, and networks aggregating such information will also facilitate upward mobility among artisan communities.</p><p><strong>3. One Size Does Not Fit All<br></strong>A homogenised and monolithic approach perpetuates systemic bias without addressing the true aspirations and needs of rural communities and small businesses. Most investment approaches, even those striving for impact, are rooted in market-rate returns with inflexible investor expectations. High interest rates, bureaucracy, language barriers, inflexible investor expectations, and mandatory collateral make access to credit untenable for formal enterprises as well as for informal artisan communities. This excludes many enterprises with great product-market fits; it also leads to mission drifts among scalable impact enterprises.</p><p>Enabling access to alternate forms of financing — catalytic capital, high-risk debt and equity, impact-first investment is an untapped opportunity.</p><p><strong>4. Challenges of Language, Discourse, and Knowledge<br></strong>Conversations around informality and creative economies, rooted in Global North contexts, pose barriers to organic inclusion of differently organised, creative cultures and craft-led enterprises. To engineer systemic reform, the artisan economy must be seen as a site of agency, “[i]nstead of seeing people as patients that need to be treated or objects that need to be changed, they need to be empowered…” (UNDP, 2020). Future conversations on policy and investment can benefit by building on the idea that artisan communities are ‘differently organised’ and by recognising that the New Formal is the new normal.</p><p><strong>5. The Great Indian Policy and Language Gap<br></strong>It is time to recognise the artisan economy as an ‘industry’ that is India’s global comparative advantage, especially in low and differently-skilled sustainable production. Policies need to address challenges around taxation, transparency, traceability, and authenticity of products and raw materials, and ultimately investment through public-private partnerships. India needs to promote the artisan economy as the go-to hub for Creative Manufacturing and Handmade (CMH) (PoweredByPeople, 2020) to meet the growing demand for collaborative supply chains and to serve the needs of sustainable marketplaces.</p><p>Further, in a country that boasts 22 official languages, linguistic diversity needs to be celebrated and accommodated in business, policy, investment and education. Social protection tools should be regional and hyper-local.</p><p><strong>6. Decentralisation Enables Inclusion and Scale<br></strong>Enterprises in the artisan sector are differently motivated and cannot be retrofitted to meet traditional definitions of growth. Scale is no doubt possible through decentralised collectivisation. A decentralised approach significantly lowers entry barriers for differently skilled communities; especially women. Using technology as an enabler and choosing governance models rooted in co-creation, co-ownership, and transparency, elicits deeper engagement from artisans and improves quality in processes / products.</p><p>Thus, innovation ecosystems need to meet the artisans where they are.</p><p><strong>7. COVID-19 as the Game Changer<br></strong>Suspension of in-person exhibitions and craft bazaars, during both waves of COVID-19, caused many artisans and enterprises to shut shop and scale down. However, there has been an unprecedented rise in community-collaboratives and public-private networks that are building critical connected ecosystems that facilitate linkages between people, enterprises, and countries. Most importantly, accelerated digitisation and new approaches for artisan inclusion through channels like video-conferencing, mobile and social media apps, and digital payment gateways are disrupting traditional engagement strategies. This offers an immense opportunity for impact actors to step in and help close the participation gap among informal rural communities.</p><h3><strong>Way Forward: Taking The Collaborative, Ecosystem Approach</strong></h3><p>Global supply chains are turning to local and regional players for context-specific sustainable innovation that also creates shared value and shared learning. The artisan economy has an innate ability to drive socio-economic mobility, conscious production, and mindful consumption. Thus, facilitation of global-local, formal-informal partnerships anchored in collaboration and co-creation is an immense opportunity.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/701/1*vU2PIXK9yOW1_RO8o5bbog.jpeg" /><figcaption>Business of Handmade: The core approach to sustainable scale in the artisan economy</figcaption></figure><p>There is an urgent need to support intermediaries and ecosystem enablers who take a systemic view and build mutually beneficial linkages. Promoting ‘Handmade as an Ethos’ (as a global call to action) is necessary because it encourages an intentional and actionable shift that transfers agency, power, and capital to local and indigenous communities and represents a slower, pro-people, and pro-nature approach that transcends geographies and definitions.</p><p><strong>Business of Handmade </strong>is an attempt to bridge the information gaps by taking stock of the diverse attempts made by enterprises in the artisan economy to navigate informality and the models that have found success or failed. The study includes scalable worker-ownership approaches, co-created solutions addressing sustainable production, models that ‘emote’ to those that want to resist the “McDonaldization” of craft. It also presents a uniquely Global South perspective by offering pathways to embed the logic and systems of informal creative cultures into more formal pipelines. Ultimately, it attempts to propose a conceptual reframing of inclusive business practices for the new economy by drawing from the experience of India’s artisan sector.</p><p><strong>Business of Handmade is available as a downloadable digital report on </strong><a href="http://www.businessofhandmade.com./"><strong>www.businessofhandmade.com</strong></a><strong>.</strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=670f63efc740" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/informal-economy-in-the-global-south/business-of-handmade-670f63efc740">Business of Handmade</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/informal-economy-in-the-global-south">The Relationship between the Informal Economy and the Cultural Economy in the Global South</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>