<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by British Workers&#39; Journal on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by British Workers&#39; Journal on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@britishworkersjournal?source=rss-7e534bff150a------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 18:37:50 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@britishworkersjournal/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Overproduction and Life]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@britishworkersjournal/overproduction-and-life-80e0686a2911?source=rss-7e534bff150a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/80e0686a2911</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[British Workers' Journal]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 04 Feb 2022 05:03:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-02-04T05:03:57.469Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The bachelor is probably one of the more enduring images of the western civilisation. I suppose that in the old days, the image of the bachelor might have been one of a man of some means living in an apartment that felt a bit too empty, but I think that now the same image is of a man with too many things: the image of the bachelor has become the image of the involuntary celibate, or in other words the man whose house is full of empty monster cans and funko pops.</p><p>I think any cursory look at the home of a single man in his twenties reveals, in many cases, the same thing: too little space, too much stuff. In some respect this also mirrors the economic life of the 21st century in general. This is a valuable observation. Today we are focused on how much poorer people are becoming, and how much less stuff they have than their parents, which is fair enough: the cost of living inexorably continues to rise. In Great Britain energy prices alone have doubled over the last year. It seems like capitalism in crisis means less stuff for everyone.</p><p>But actually, as always, the capitalist crisis is a crisis of overproduction. If you think about the amount of stuff you have, rather than its value to you, you might be shocked at how much you could stockpile. This week alone I myself have amassed a fair sum of aluminium in the form of empty beer cans. What will happen to them? I dump them in a box outside the house and some man from the government comes and, allegedly, sends them to a recycling plant, although everyone really knows they go to landfill. But actually, that’s my aluminium. I paid for it. I bought the liquid inside, but I also bought the right to do whatever I want with the metal.</p><p>We had a big supermarket next to our school. One day I saw a two-litre bottle of water for sixteen pence and realised what you’re really paying for is the plastic — and not just the plastic, but the use value of being able to transport two litres of water with it. This is all pretty normal, but think about how much packaging is used for everything that you buy, including stuff at the supermarket, and think about how disposable modern commodities are, and you realise that throughout your life you actually can build up a stockpile of a huge quantity of absolutely useless materials.</p><p>It’s an interesting contradiction that we can really amass so much stuff, of which is absolutely no value to us and has diminishing profitable returns for the companies who sell it, but that the cost of living simultaneously continues to rise and rise with no end in sight.</p><p>I don’t think a socialist system has an answer to this in an immediate term. Existing socialist systems are mostly focused on overproduction to fit social needs, which is manifestly good, but the ideal socialist system would rationalise production. Controlling overproduction is obviously important, not just for ideological reasons, but for reasons of necessity.</p><p>Consider the number of aluminium cans I consume per week. In a pub, the glasses can be washed, but at home this aluminium is all wasted. Consider how much plastic packaging, tins, so on I have to consume to cook at home — and then the plastic washing liquid I have to use to clean them, and the water. If I were to eat out every day, this would be more efficient, but I obviously can’t afford that.</p><p>Let’s go back to the idea of the single person. The single person is obviously an inefficient economic model. There is probably an efficient family size according to the current capitalist model, but nobody knows exactly what it is.</p><p>The answer to this crisis of overproduction is the same answer to the crisis of ecology: we need to use less to achieve more. This is where the socialist system has answers: people should drink together, in public houses. They should eat together, in community restaurants. They should shop together, as families and communities, without the excess packaging that capitalism requires. Two people doing things is easier than one, four is easier than two, and a hundred is easier than ten. This idea offers us also a way out of exploitation of women, who are often condemned to housework, and provides us a route out of isolation.</p><p>The socialist system means, in other words, fewer people eating ready meals at home amongst a horde of funkopops, and more people eating, breathing and living together as obvious communal and familial units. To solve overproduction and social isolation in one go — why not? As usual, socialism has the answers to the problems capitalism provides. The adjustment in social consciousness in other areas may be an unpleasant one, but if here it means people sit and eat together, I think it will be altogether pleasant.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=80e0686a2911" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Red Menace]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@britishworkersjournal/red-menace-7d451071be0d?source=rss-7e534bff150a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7d451071be0d</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[British Workers' Journal]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 27 Jan 2022 14:59:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-01-27T14:59:48.592Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I have a lot of respect for Breht and Alyson of Red Menace, not least because of their mental acuity and both breadth and depth of knowledge, but also the usual objectivity that the show can maintain between left tendencies. However: In the spirit of good-faith and respectful debate between Marxist-Leninists and Maoists I would like to write a reply to one part of their AMA featured on July 25th 2021 — Socialism, Climate Chaos, Pedagogy &amp; Contradictions, relating specifically to the section on “AES” — although I’m sure neither of them will ever see this.</p><p>The question: <em>our [their] thoughts on modern AES, translated to actually existing socialism, and this person asks about Cuba specifically, and they say particularly how Breht and Alyson’s Maoism affect their support for places like Cuba.</em></p><p>Before we begin, we should look at Breht’s summary of the Marxist-Leninist position on AES. He prefaces this description by saying it’s “important to have a principled definition of socialism.”</p><p><em>“Sometimes, the ML position can pretty much be that as long as the Party in charge declares itself to be a Socialist, Marxist or Communist Party, that means that the socialist transition has begun and anything else that is taking place, anything about the social relations of the society at large, are sort of concerns that you get to later in that revolutionary process, but as long as there is a Socialist party in charge, more or less, that can constitute the transition and therefore it can be properly called a Socialist state. I think that is often the ML position on the issue, and that leads them to often saying that China, the DPRK, Cuba is socialist… Correct me if I’m wrong but is that pretty much fair to say that that’s the ML position?”</em></p><p>Alyson hedges a bit and says this is “broadly reflective.”</p><p>It’s not broadly reflective. It’s completely untrue. The developed Marxist-Leninist position differs substantially. I found this description of what Marxist-Leninists believe to be a little jarring, since any developed conversation with a Marxist-Leninist would have informed both Breht and Alyson to the contrary.</p><p>The developed Marxist-Leninist position is — and this is ironic, since both Breht and Alyson recognise this later in the podcast in another question, but decide against applying it to this question — that the revolution is not a simple step-change of one form of property relations to another, but the process of human development between two modes of production which is in constant motion.</p><p>I suppose in one sense it is right to say that there is no actually existing socialism, but only in the semantic sense — all revolutions are always underway everywhere because the revolution is the means by which human social history progresses between mode to mode and between contradiction to contradiction.</p><p>The difference is semantic: the semantic argument is that Marxist-Leninists say that the Communist Parties in government are advancing the power, in some way or another, of working-class forces, and the Maoists say that they are not, or else they are doing it too slowly or inauthentically, or that their revisionist character compromises the revolution, et cetera. In this sense, both Breht and Alyson look to frame the argument as one of Maoist principle against Marxist-Leninist superficiality.</p><p>Words have meanings. When Breht says that it’s important for Marxists to have a principled definition of socialism, he puts the metaphysical into the dialectical. Let me speak metaphorically for a moment: if there was a “principled definition” of either a liquid or solid or a gas, vaporisation would be impossible. Only the principled definition of vaporisation allows us to understand the process of transforming a liquid or solid into a gas.</p><p>Having spoken metaphorically, now I can speak scientifically: all particles in all forms of matter are in constant motion — it is only the laws and processes of the motion of particles and the conversion of the forms of matter that are static.</p><p>There is no definition of either socialism or capitalism that is both useful and principled. There is only the principled definition of <em>revolution</em>, the process of conversion of the phase of the capitalist mode of property relations into the phase of socialist mode of property relations, and <em>counter-revolution,</em> the opposite.</p><p>Actually, I am sure that both Breht and Alyson know this, which makes their assessment of the Marxist-Leninist position even more concerning. Anyway, developed Marxism-Leninism does not examine the static properties of a state or its property relations and declare that it is “genuine socialism” by some means or another, whether that be the name of the Party in power or how well that Party meets the social needs of its people.</p><p>The developed Marxist-Leninist position is to factually examine the processes underway in the country in a given place — be that a country or a Party — and to support the working class forces in their revolutionary struggle. <strong>On the basis of the facts,</strong> it is materially obvious that in the Peoples Republic, the working-class forces are led by the Communist Party, even though internal class struggles take place inside the Communist Party. We will return to this later.</p><p>Alyson’s reply to the question focuses around what the western left should do, which is an infinitely more helpful response than a mischaracterisation of the Marxist-Leninists. In her reply she makes clear that she thinks the task of the western left is to oppose imperialist interventions in all countries even if they don’t like their revolutions because all people have the right to self-determine their revolutions, which is manifestly true and good.</p><p>However, Alyson also says that the Maoist position is that there is no more coherent internationalist bloc of Socialist countries, and since this is wrong, it obscures the utility and validity of her other point. Why is this wrong? Because there is an internationalist bloc of socialists resisting US imperialism, because it is led by China, because those people recognise the leading role of China in the resistance to imperialism.</p><p>I’m not here going to talk about the facts about why the CPC is a revolutionary force inside China, because that would take pages and pages and pages and require me to go back to my source material and make citations. Other people have done a better job writing about it than I could. But the basic argument laid out by Maoists is an academic one that rests on factual observations about China and other countries — those factual observations are wrong, but Maoists rarely address this, instead focusing on an academic critique of a thing that doesn’t exist.</p><p>This poses a problem for Alyson’s analysis because it is the solidarity between the revolutionary states which defeats imperialism, not the unconditional support of the western left. The empire is defeated by the revolution, and wherever there is revolution, there is anti-imperialism.</p><p>I think we should return to when Breht said: “<em>the ML position can pretty much be that as long as the Party in charge declares itself to be a Socialist, Marxist or Communist Party, that means that the socialist transition has begun.”</em></p><p>This is an interesting charge, especially as it relates to Alyson’s point, and here I would like to say, with respect, that this is a very simple projection. The revolution that we see now will of course not look like any other in history because it reflects a different historical and material character to the revolutions we have seen before. Alleging Marxist-Leninists are drawn to Communist Parties because of iconography is a projection from Maoists, when so much Maoist ideology depends on resurrection of lost icons.</p><p>The revolution is about the process of change between two systems and the changing characters of those two systems. Everywhere, across the whole world, socialism is standing up once more, for the first time since 1985. It does not look like 1985, like 1965, like 1945, or like 1925. Of course not. Maoists make this mistake all the time because they focus on comparing the ongoing revolution with some other revolution that they prefer, despite having experienced neither.</p><p>The revolution that we are working towards, the defeat of the empire and the construction of a new society and new world will look different from other revolutions, and its processes will be different in character too. We can’t say what it will be. We can only say what it will not be: the restoration of a lost age of socialism to a new calendar year. This is where the charge of superficiality against Marxist-Leninists fails, and it is also where the critique of our position by Breht and Alyson fails.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7d451071be0d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Sex and Socialism]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@britishworkersjournal/sex-and-socialism-fdf9237d8626?source=rss-7e534bff150a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fdf9237d8626</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[British Workers' Journal]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 23 Oct 2021 18:41:39 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-10-23T18:41:39.330Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I think that there’s a certain machoism to Socialism.</p><p>The symbology of <em>capitalist</em> sex is best presented as the third page of the Britain’s favourite brand of toilet paper. A semi-naked girl lies over a two page cover with a line from the editor in a speech bubble, the inference being that the woman herself could never have come up with a thought on current affairs etc.</p><p>And there is a little metaphor here too, that obviously a picture of a naked woman <em>isn’t </em>sexual activity, which is a nice observation because the most conservative governments in capitalist history often seek to prevent people from having sex as much as they possibly can, by stigmatising it and either making it illegal or dangerous.</p><p>But sex itself is everywhere in capitalist marketing and capitalist ideology, and we don’t need here to have a conversation about the commodification of sex.</p><p>In any case, almost all capitalist sex symbols are female. In contrast, socialist sex symbols are traditionally male, from Che Guevara and Fidel Castro to the Tendency of the Rate of Men Giving Women Orgasms to Rise in East Germany.</p><p>Even in the socialist propaganda, the woman is presented as man; the sniper, the scientist, the soviet cosmonaut. Socialist propaganda presented equality as <em>women being </em><strong><em>just as good as</em></strong><em> men. </em>In some respect this must be a sign of the times and almost certainly a result of the very first wave of socialist feminism, characterised by ‘fuck you, I’m not your property’ — a very vulgar and simplistic representation of the writings of say, Alexandra Kollontai, but also not wrong.</p><p>Quite tellingly, legal sexual slavery ended in Britain only in 1991. The highest court in the land finally ruled that it was a crime for a man to force himself on his wife, and 1991 is therefore a good point for us to observe that a qualitative change had finally occurred, even though the sexual revolution had begun thirty years earlier and feminism as a mainstream ideology around ninety years earlier.</p><p>I think that the macho socialist probably does not think himself as being macho, or if he does it’s the <em>good kind </em>of macho: the walk you home in the dark boyfriend, the thoughtful lover, the occasional washer of dishes, the communist unafraid of cunnilingus, the new Soviet Socialist Man who respects women but doesn’t watch women’s football.</p><p>The macho socialist also hates pornography, prostitution, and all forms of super exploitation. I think that first before we discuss this strain of marxist thought, we should make some facts quite clear.</p><p>The criminalisation of sex work does not mean the criminalisation of sex workers, who are victims of super exploitation and should be treated so. Alongside criminalisation should come the <em>right to exit</em>, including maximal state support for sex workers to return to society in another form of work. This is what the Communist authorities did in China in the 1950s — and this work included bringing in Party cadres to train former prostitutes in socialist thought and to ensure that they didn’t suffer from stigmata when returning to society.</p><p>But we have to be super clear about why we are against sex work and we have to be super clear about that from a marxist perspective.</p><p>Workers sell a commodity, their labour [C], in exchange for money [M]which they need to buy more commodities [C], like food and shelter. This is C-M-C.</p><p>Capitalists use money [M] to buy commodities (labour, goods) [C] in order to sell them to make more money [M]. This is M-C-M.</p><p>This structural difference between workers and capitalists is at the centre of marxist political economy and is outlined in the opening chapters of <em>Das Kapital. </em>M-C-M is the general formula of capital but is impossible without C-M-C otherwise all exchanges would be zero sum.</p><p>So the problem of sex work is not just that it is misogynistic, which we will come to later, but that it is a capitalist transactional engagement. The whole communist objective is that one day we will have enough martial power to deploy overwhelming state terrorism against capitalists, ie the class of people who profit from M-C-M exchange, until — and until is an important word here — there are no more capitalists <em>in the whole world</em> and therefore no more transactional exchange and then we will have a classless society.</p><p>Sex work occupies a special place in the thought of marxist feminists because it is a form of super exploitation. Super exploitation is a capitalist phenomenon in which the exploited class <em>exploits others </em>in order to acquire things necessary for its survival. The first type of super exploitation is racism, in which the worst jobs in society are handed to ethnic minorities. The second type of super exploitation is sexism, in which women work either at lower wages, or completely unpaid, to provide services to (usually white) working class men. Surrounding these two core types of super exploitation, which intersectionally connect (Bangladeshi women are the most super exploited class in Britain) are a whole host of marginal identities who suffer different and usually worse forms of exploitation.</p><p>The hungry factory worker is exploited, but the wife who makes his food and doesn’t receive a wage is <em>even more exploited</em>. In history, men could simply rape their wives if they had a sexual appetite. There were no legal protections for married women. Men who were unmarried could buy the sexual services of women who were essentially prohibited by circumstance from any other kind of work.</p><p>So combine the two capitalist forms — super exploitation, rooted deeply in misogyny, and transactional labour exchange, to make one of the most exploitative industries on the planet, which all communists should strive to abolish.</p><p>I think that since our objective as communists is to deploy terrorism against capitalists, it both logically follows and is morally correct that super exploited people can deploy super terrorism against capitalists. I have no doubt personally that the revolutionary popular forces will violently and fatally sweep away the <em>capitalists </em>who super exploit women in the sex trade.</p><p>I am advocating the shooting of PornHub chief executives. So what? Super exploited people have the right to exercise super retaliation. Super exploitation’s propaganda — pornography — serves a dual purpose, not just the generation of profits for capitalists but the normalisation of super exploitation and the misogynistic behaviours contained within it.</p><p>Only one question remains: how does the Socialist society treat sex? There is only one answer. Not as a transactional profit-generating industry, but as a fundamental part of the human existence and requirement, just as it does food, shelter, and water.</p><p>I think this is something for the macho socialist to think about quite seriously, because macho socialism is a result of macho capitalism, just like socialism is a result of capitalism. The male socialist should not treat their approach to sex as a <em>reformed capitalist, </em>but instead remove entirely the traces of bourgeois sex relations from their perspective.</p><p>Fidel Castro once famously remarked that Cuba has the best-educated prostitutes in the world. Inside this remark there is something deeper than simple flippancy — an acknowledgment that we can’t change the world overnight, but that we can do our best to eliminate bourgeois ideology. This requires serious self reflection and thought, behaviours antagonistic to arrogance, which after all, is most probably the defining feature of machoism.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fdf9237d8626" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A choice for the British Left — Surrender or Revolution]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@britishworkersjournal/a-choice-for-the-british-left-surrender-or-revolution-e854209c58e6?source=rss-7e534bff150a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e854209c58e6</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[British Workers' Journal]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 20 Oct 2021 23:41:24 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-10-20T23:41:24.501Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>A choice for the British Left — Surrender or Revolution</h3><p>The biggest worry my mother seems to have about me being a communist is that at some point I am going to get involved in political violence and go to prison or something. I haven’t told her about the arsenal of Kalashnikovs and Armalites that the Communist Party keeps in an abandoned mine somewhere in South Wales.</p><p>Of course I haven’t told her this because it isn’t true (and even if it was, the Party is not daft enough to entrust its whereabouts to me) which begs really a bigger point — what is the purpose of the Communist Party then? After all, we are really clear about who we are. Our politics are revolutionary, not reformist. This is actually quite a serious distinction for one obvious reason: there has never ever been a revolution in a country at the highest stage of capitalist development (ie imperialist) like Britain.</p><p>These countries have only had successful reformist movements. In our country the Labour Party has managed, although not often, to control the Parliament and institute some social democratic reforms. Not many of them have lasted. The National Healthcare System is still around, but almost every vestige of Labour’s social democratic system is now gone. Britain’s welfare state was never meant to substitute employment for welfare, but since we no longer have full employment that is precisely what it does. This system is obviously untenable, and so attacks on it from the right (including the Labour right) aren’t just reflections of Tory meanness, but materially predictable.</p><p>Gone are the last traces of the British Empire, which allowed us to distribute economic wealth to our people from overseas. The money has run out. The centre-left’s claims of a Tory attack on living standards — summed up by the phrase “austerity is a choice” are actually wrong. Austerity is not a choice. The working class have always got the leftovers of capitalism, that’s why we’re the working class. Now, though, faced with contracting economic power<em>, </em>the right has actually run out of surplus to distribute to the general population.</p><p>For example: they don’t want to privatise the NHS because they’re cruel, bad people. Their material position in society means they <em>must</em> privatise the healthcare system, and as a result they become cruel, bad people. It’s not that scum floats to the top. It’s that scum knows what it has to do to stay at the top.</p><p>So, the economic crisis that we’ve lived with since 2007 is not a one off affair or a mere cyclical problem: it represents the final elimination of Great Britain’s ability to materially or practically offer social democracy to its people. Our new normal wasn’t from 2020, it was from 2007. The beneficiaries of our capitalist economy are now becoming fewer and fewer, as is the same in the United States and Europe, and the response to this rising economic crisis has necessarily been a political response.</p><p>The social democrats burst into prominence, almost overnight. Britain had Corbyn. The United States had Sanders. Where are they now? Defeated, washed away by corrupt party machines, billionaire media smear campaigns, never to return. In Britain the whispers run up and down the country — a new party! Corbyn and McDonnell should make a new party!</p><p>Maybe they do. Maybe they go and form the Peoples Labour Party. Maybe it gets union backing. What will it achieve? Nothing more than 2017. Our entire electoral system is designed and manufactured to prevent that kind of government ever coming to power electorally. Even if they did, they would find themselves in dire straits: <a href="https://www.jacobinmag.com/2011/09/the-rights-favorite-strike/">capital strikes</a>, <a href="https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-41393021">runs on the Pound</a>, <a href="https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/british-army-could-stage-mutiny-under-corbyn-says-senior-serving-general-10509742.html">coup threats</a>.</p><p>I feel like I do disservice to my writing by using metaphor: but there’s no more petrol in the tank for reformism. The Tories know this especially well. Boris Johnson’s tax and spend is actually a wealth transfer to the capitalist class. He will raise our national insurance rates in order to pay for social care, but social care providers are overwhelmingly private. The sensible option would be to take them into public ownership and not have to subsidise private profits, but this isn’t about keynesian economics — it’s about structural power over the economy.</p><p>There is a deep malaise on the British Left for a good reason. Their platform, reformism, was defeated, and decisively. It’s natural — we had a lot of malaise on the far left after the collapse of the Soviet Union. So where now?</p><p>I suppose there’s a choice here. Surrender — or revolution. If you choose the former you can close this article now and go back to watching Squid Games or whatever.</p><p>I am sure there are many of us who would like the revolution to happen soon, maybe tomorrow. Perhaps if there was a broad left victory at the polls, and there were thirty thousand British Communists, we would have to defend our <em>reformist gains </em>with <em>revolutionary means</em>. We make absolutely no attempt to hide this — it’s in Britain’s Road to Socialism.</p><p><em>“The extent to which this process involves physical or military violence will depend upon the revolutionary movement having the best strategy to minimise the capacity for resistance of the capitalist class. As the working class invariably bears the brunt of counter-revolutionary violence, </em><strong><em>it is the duty of all serious revolutionaries to devise such a strategy, rather than propose simplistic notions of violent insurrection and armed struggle</em></strong><em>.”</em></p><p>“<em>In any event, there can be no question: </em><strong><em>the democratically elected left government will use all the official and popular forces at its disposal to crush each and every attempt at military subversion</em></strong><em>, rebellion or invasion.”</em></p><p>At first, Britain’s Road to Socialism looks like a reformist document. It advocates a broad front of the British left achieving political power by reformist means but it advocates the transformation of those reformist means into revolutionary goals, defended by revolutionaries.</p><p><em>“The drive to implement key policies relating to the state, capital controls, media ownership and alignment with the EU or NATO will almost certainly meet the most determined resistance from monopoly capital and its forces within and outside the state apparatus.</em></p><p><em>Enormous confrontations will signify that the revolutionary process has entered its third, most crucial stage, following those in which the left government has taken office and then, with the mass movement, fought to enact left wing policies. These new confrontations will decide whether the monopoly finance capitalists retain state power or have it taken from them by the working class and its allies.”</em></p><p>I think this is basically right, although I’m sure that BRS will have editions made to it soon. We acknowledge the material reality that we do not have thirty thousand revolutionaries with automatic weapons to call to the streets. We acknowledge that the idea of our General Secretary opening arms caches and declaring protracted peoples war against the British state is simplistic and stupid. But we do not agree that this is the only way for us to wage a revolution at this moment in time. We believe that we must gain our power in stages, by increments, until we are sufficiently strong that there is no stopping us.</p><p>A British revolution will be no less than — and let me use a long word, please — the transubstantiation of a body of reformist politics into a body of revolutionary politics, and that will take place over time and space and the stages of its progression will never be immediately obvious, just as we know when a kettle has boiled but not at what temperature it is at a given second.</p><p>If you study the history of revolutions, you should come to one conclusion, which is — to make a revolution, you need only one thing: revolutionaries. I don’t mean this as an illuminating ‘gotcha’ statement. It’s actually obvious. An army needs soldiers, a factory needs workers, a bank needs bankers. If you want a revolution, you must be first be a revolutionary yourself. Then you should help to train and make other revolutionaries. The difference between a revolutionary and a reformist is huge.</p><p>A reformist agrees with his enemies that the political system is fundamentally just and worthy. A revolutionary does not.</p><p>A reformist negotiates or co-operates with his enemies, enters coalitions and campaigns with them, drinks and eats with them. A revolutionary does not.</p><p>A reformist accepts the propaganda of his enemies, believes in the same worldview, uses the same sources of information. A revolutionary does not.</p><p>A reformist undermines his own movement, disregards feelings of solidarity between his friends, places his ego first, act selfishly in politics. A revolutionary does not.</p><p>A reformist surrenders. Revolutionaries never, ever surrender.</p><p>Reformism is dead. The choice now is between surrender or revolution. We are at the opening stages of the contest between the revolutionaries and British monopoly capital, so what we need now are revolutionaries. You want a revolution? Become a revolutionary.</p><p>At the beginning I asked what the purpose of our Party was. It should be obvious now. Its purpose is to recruit, train, and organise revolutionaries. Those revolutionaries work alongside the working class forces in our country to advance our goal: revolution, not reform, not surrender.</p><p>If all the reformists in our country became revolutionaries we could walk on Parliament tomorrow and chase out the elite. Luckily, we don’t need all of them. We just need enough — and one day, we’re going to find out exactly how many ‘enough’ is.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e854209c58e6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Ecofascism]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@britishworkersjournal/ecofascism-65b5fed4315d?source=rss-7e534bff150a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/65b5fed4315d</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[British Workers' Journal]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 25 Sep 2021 22:18:14 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-09-25T22:27:41.183Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>The year is 2071.</em></p><p><em>Champagne flutes clink at the Reform Club. The building, like all of London’s gentleman’s clubs, has always stunk of privilege, and today is no different. The Climate Reform Group is having its annual social, and dignitaries from across the ecological reform movement have gathered to drink, eat, and talk. It’s eight o’ clock, and at the doors of the club, valets have finally finished parking up all the new electric cars.</em></p><p>I will take a leap here, offend my meagre readership, and suggest that the only two progressive social modes are socialism and fascism. By progressive I mean this in the dialectical sense, obviously — that only socialism and fascism contain the power to overcome the current social and economic modes and establish new ones.</p><p>Historically, the tradition of all fascist movements has been essentially reactionary, and all fascist movements have internally squashed their revolutionary parts. But that doesn’t mean they didn’t exist, or couldn’t again in the future. We can start with admitting one simple thing: fascism has the potential to be a powerful social movement, whether we like it or not.</p><p><em>The first speaker is a Chief Executive of a major national landlord, a company investing in green properties for rent. He talks about the new technical advances that have made their properties more and more environmentally friendly.</em></p><p><em>Sensors on rubbish bins can tell whether waste has been recycled properly, he explains, and automatically issue a fine to the tenant. The properties are heated by a central control mechanism that automatically lowers the temperature of the house’s heating system in line with per-capita emission controls. Blockchain technology has been put to use so that wealthier tenants can “purchase” more emissions from poorer tenants across the entire national grid. The system, he says to much applause, works flawlessly. This company provides the most green housing in Great Britain.</em></p><p>If we think about current social and economic mode (or use the word system or style if you want), ie neoliberalism, everyone understands that this mode does not have the tools, politically, socially, or economically to change itself or to make any kind of meaningful change. It can only be changed by being replaced with another system and that system must emerge from social and political pressure — from a movement.</p><p>One of those movements is obviously socialism, rooted in the class warfare tradition and supported at its core by organised workers taking control of the state and eliminating the ruling class. The other is fascism, which seeks usually to corporatise the state, to have all the existing institutions of capitalism represented as investors in the state, and to deploy massive violence to crush resistance to this corporatisation, whether from above or below.</p><p>And of course, fascism and war go hand in hand — war being a dialectical tool to progress a society.</p><p><em>Lieutenant-Colonel Mark Williams has just returned from the Congo with the Black Watch, the old and famous 3rd Battalion of the Scottish Regiment. He describes, to much fanfare, the destruction of the Congolese rare earth mines in a United Nations Climate Control Mission.</em></p><p><em>He describes to the rapt audience the terrible ecological conditions imprinted on the Congolese countryside and the damage to the global ecology caused by mining these rare minerals, and how bravely his troops carried out their operation, and ends with a funny story about a squadron of the Belgian paracommandos and an endangered primate.</em></p><p><em>There are no mention of the civilian casualties.</em></p><p>The defeat of actual fascist forces in 1945 does not signal the end of fascism as a mode, just as the defeat of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union in 1991 does not signal the end of socialism as a mode. Since these are progressive forces, they face only setbacks, not permanent defeats. They must be re-imagined and re-created for new centuries and new material situations.</p><p>If we think about fascism as a progressive force that can actually change society and attempt to address the problems of a society, we can think about fascism outside of the boundaries of “Nazis bad”, which while being true, doesn’t help us analyse existing fascist movements. The essentialist belief that fascism is about barbed wire and Roman salutes makes us ignorant to when fascism is actually developing before our eyes.</p><p>At the centre of fascist ideology is the marshalling of existing forces to create the aesthetic of the new world. Socialism, which excludes hostile elements from the society (like bankers, landlords, etc), wants to form a materially different system, while fascism wants to incorporate all these forces into a new aesthetic and form an aesthetically different system. This is why the British ecofascists have a <a href="https://www.facebook.com/groups/2227948060614385/">department for landlords</a>, <a href="https://www.currentaffairs.org/2019/10/extinction-rebellion-has-a-politics-problem">police officers</a>, etc. Fascism’s objective is to summon all the parts of the state for an aesthetic mission. There is every reason to believe this mission will be climate controls.</p><p>Even on their own website, the British ecofascists— unlike any other group-have separate community groups for different ethnic groups, races, religions, professions and so on. This is relatively normal for a political party, but is completely unheard of from a “non-political” action group like Extinction Rebellion. For example — Hope not Hate does not have a “Hope not Hate Vegans” and the Taxpayers Alliance does not have a “Taxpayers Alliance LGBT Department.”</p><p>Ecofascism will be the collusion between all elements of society and the state to address a social problem that only a progressive force can solve: ecological collapse.</p><p><em>The Climate Reform Group is lucky to have members of the government in its ranks. The Minister for Production stands up and tells the audience how the trade union laws of the past ten years have worked, culminating in the government’s new Trades Union Bill.</em></p><p><em>The governments attempts to finally unite all trades union under one banner, outlawing the Trades Union Congress, and uniting all trades union behind the ecological causes, have finally succeeded. Resistance to the government’s anti-consumption laws from the trade unions have finally failed, and the new All-Britain Green Union has accepted the government’s new Reduced Consumption Act.</em></p><p><em>The act allows the government to use sophisticated surveillance software to track an individuals consumption of ‘emissions-controlled goods’ relative to their income. Banks and big tech have assisted the government in creating a scheme to monitor a persons ‘restricted emissions consumption’ relative to their income. It will prevent, the Minister says, persons who do not contribute to society from damaging the planet that we all live in. Those who continue to burn more of the planet than they deserve to burn will go to prison. As usual — raucous applause.</em></p><p>In this conversation it’s important for us to remember that ecology is naturally at the forefront of Communist politics. Like I said earlier, both socialism and fascism have the social, political and moral tools to attempt to solve social problems. We know how a centrally planned, workers owned economy could solve the ecological crises brought about by capitalism and we don’t need to discuss that here.</p><p>But it is important to think about how a fascist society, with ecology at the centre of its new, symbolic and even spiritualised aesthetic, would attempt to solve these problems — at the expense of all others. Just as the fatherland, Norse mythology and the imprecise science of the Aryan race occupied the centre of all Nazi politics, like the dream of Ancient Rome did to the Italian and the deep, spiritual connection to the Catholic Church did to the Spanish and Portuguese, fascist politics is always chasing.</p><p>The struggle occupies the centre of the fascist political world, just as it does the socialist. For us, socialism offers a vehicle to resolve the contradictions that come out of the human social condition, by winning the class struggle — but for the fascists, it is the struggle itself that makes the man. The militarism, the harsh and Spartan character of all fascist politics is thereby embodied.</p><p><em>You have to be lucky always. We only have to be lucky once.</em></p><p><em>Many of the people at the annual social were killed instantly — others died en-route to the hospital, or afterwards. The bomb attack was decisive, well executed, and bloody. In its aftermath, the ‘terrorists’ of the Resistance Forces took credit for the deaths of more than eighty high ranking members of the establishment. But while these terrorists were hunted down and eventually tortured and murdered…</em></p><p><em>The government held a state funeral for those killed at the ‘terrorist attack.’ Candlelit vigils were held in New York, Paris, and Berlin (not, of course, in Accra, Jakarta, or Pyongyang) and the Prime Minister went on television to affirm that those who died had not died in vain, but had given their lives for the service of a great cause — for mother earth, for the planet, for human progress.</em></p><p>Today the candlelit vigil is a normal public expression of sorrow. But the crazed behaviours of the British ecofascists aren’t that far from the cultish behaviours of the fascists we thought our grandfathers buried. The spiritual struggle that must absorb the energy of the entire society can be found today, in our country, not in the moribund and dying British far right but in the British ecofascists who not so long ago declined the offer to describe themselves as socialists.</p><p>What else can they be, then, all other things considered?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=65b5fed4315d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Attack, attack, attack !]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@britishworkersjournal/attack-attack-attack-4c6a7e513b02?source=rss-7e534bff150a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4c6a7e513b02</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[British Workers' Journal]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 30 Jul 2021 21:58:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-08-04T09:10:20.691Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Attack, attack, attack !</h3><p>I had more comments than I expected from <a href="https://medium.com/@britishworkersjournal/death-to-debaters-de1d290bfdb9">Death to Debaters</a>. I want to address some of them here and clarify (read: intensify) what I said, but also writing this helps me to answer some questions that I have been thinking myself. I won’t here just rehash what is written in<em> Britain’s Road to Socialism </em>but instead put forward my ideas on how that excellent document could be put into practice.</p><p>The main question for Communists is, above all, how to take power. Before we try to answer this I think we should step back a little and ask ourselves why we want to take power. The reason isn’t so we can “do a little socialism”, but because taking state power is a vital part of waging class struggle, which is our aim. Class struggle is not won and lost, because the struggle continues after we have taken power anyway — class struggle is a process with an ebb and a flow.</p><p>We advance, and we retreat. The enemy advances and he also retreats. We want to advance more, and we want him to retreat more.</p><p>So we are interested in the class struggle: the balance of power between the working class and the capitalist class. Our objective is always to shift the balance against the capitalist class. Every little victory won by working class organisations in our country does this, and this is the difference between taking power in a parliamentary sense.</p><p>Some people think we should persuade people we are right and then get them to vote for us. This is the Westminster Delusion.</p><p>Her Majesty’s Government is the mechanism which the capitalist class uses to rule Britain. From the nuclear armed submarine or tank brigade down to the riot squad, the offices of judges and tax collectors and policemen and prisons and so on down to the piece of legislation or the council edict, these mechanisms are the physical barrier between the property of the ruling class and the people.</p><p>The idea that we can peacefully persuade people that the government should disband its forces and allow the people to seize the property of their rulers is nothing more than a joke. Nobody ever gave up their power by request. Nobody ever gave up their power by debate. In his butchering of the Internationale, Billy Bragg writes: <em>respect makes the empires fall.</em> He’s wrong. <em>Avtomat Kalashnikova</em> made the empires fall.</p><p>But we don’t have Kalashnikovs, and what most people think political power means is entering the Parliament and writing laws. But the Parliament itself is an institution of capitalism, and our goal is the destruction of capitalism and we mean to replace it with socialism.</p><p>We are not here to become the government. We are here to attack capitalism. The government is just the thing that stands in the way. If we win we will be able to make our own government, with our own legislature and our own uniformed forces and tax collectors and use them to suppress and destroy our ruling class, and that will be advancing working class political power. But we’re pretty far from that.</p><p>Ok, what then? Simple. I suggest a new slogan for us, which is literal and not just motivational: <em>Organise, mobilise, attack !</em></p><p>We mobilise working class people into political units and together, as one broad front, we attack capitalism relentlessly, non-stop, on every issue. We organise strikes. We organise against landlords. We organise against vacant land. We organise for womens issues and other minority issues. We organise mutual aid. We make it difficult, by any means necessary, for capitalists to create profits.</p><p>Capitalism causes economic crises of its own accord. We know this. We’ve lived in an economic crisis for fourteen years now. But economic crisis doesn’t always lead to political crisis. Ours certainly hasn’t. A great man once said that <em>we’ll hang them with the rope they sell us</em>.</p><p>We need to convert these economic crises into political crises by organising outright civil unrest, leading into outright civil disorder, leading into outright insurrection.</p><p>In other words: we need to buy the rope.</p><p>It is our organising and our mobilising that can bring about a change in the social and economic system — and only that. And those things are the only things we have to attack capitalism. So in that sense, I will reword the earlier proposed slogan:</p><p><strong><em>Attack, attack, attack !</em></strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4c6a7e513b02" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Socialised British Economy (Pt 1)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@britishworkersjournal/were-not-social-democrats-f10af2a49ce7?source=rss-7e534bff150a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f10af2a49ce7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[socialism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[British Workers' Journal]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 25 Jul 2021 19:02:35 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-07-26T11:07:35.217Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>We’re not social democrats.</p><p>Our big idea isn’t to borrow loads of money from capitalists and spend it on investing in capitalist businesses.</p><p>Whatever the path of revolution, we’re absolutely clear: the working class will retrieve what is rightfully ours, and without compensation, nationalise at the very least the commanding heights of the economy — the 8,000 firms that employ more than 250 people, and to bring into public ownership every rental property and second home in Britain.</p><p>We do not pay compensation because these things never belonged to our ruling class. To pay compensation is to admit that we are taking something that belongs to somebody else. That is not true. The British economy belongs to the British people.</p><p>There are often questions of what a socialist economy could afford, how it could afford those things, whether people would have to work a lot, so on and so forth. We have to remember firstly that if there was a British socialist state, it would most likely have to interact with global commodity capitalism, as do the Chinese and Vietnamese workers states.</p><p>It would likely have friends to trade with, unlike Cuba, simply because its economy is so large. I will write more about what I think socialist trade would be like in the future. This article exists to show that our policy should not be one of mere tax redistribution, but to increase the labour output of our economy, direct the surplus of private industry towards social means, and thereby pave the British Road to Socialism.</p><h4>Why not just borrow the money?</h4><p>In the recent elections there was a lot of talk about borrowing to fund public investment, because interest rates are low and this is a historic opportunity, or whatever. The fact is that we shouldn’t and can’t do this.</p><p>We shouldn’t do this because our objective is not to re-create the conditions of social democracy but with more worker power. Our objective is to overturn the system of property relations. It doesn’t advance our cause to raise debts on traditional systems of national accounts and consequently owe sums to capitalist institutions that could later manipulate us. We saw this with Yugoslavia. Yugoslavia’s borrowing of funds from international monetary agencies in the 1980s resulted in the downfall of the socialist system in Yugoslavia. We must be very careful to avoid this.</p><p>We can’t do this because after we seize the commanding heights of the economy and the property of our ruling class, they won’t lend money to us anyway. Our credit rating will fall. We will be cut off from traditional lines of credit unless the world has truly become extremely multipolar. Our currency will be weakened and our reserves and assets in capitalist countries seized. The economic conditions for creating socialism must come from actual labour in our country and not balanced on speculative financial markets.</p><h4>Why not just tax the money?</h4><p>Well naturally we will have to collect some funds in tax, as this is already how the Exchequer funds government services. But simply raising tax evades the Marxist analysis of our economy. The fact is that tax and spend is a Cambridge fantasy and we shouldn’t and can’t do this.</p><p>We shouldn’t do this because, as Marxists, we know that wealth is based on production — production of goods by labour. Our objective isn’t to move wealth around the economy, it’s to return surplus from capitalists to workers and to institute a political system capable of doing that, ie suppressing owners in favour of workers. Our job is to direct surplus into social production, not to negotiate on the terms by which some surplus is kept.</p><p>We can’t do this because in a revolution the capitalists disappear, either willingly or by some incredible act of mass accident. Their surplus disappears and reappears as the collective surplus of working class production. Consequently taxes are not necessary or even really possible when the entire national surplus is collectivised.</p><h4>If we can’t tax and spend, and if we can’t borrow, how can we make enough money to fund Socialist construction?</h4><p>The <a href="https://data.oecd.org/lprdty/gdp-per-hour-worked.htm#indicator-chart">OECD says</a> that the GDP output per hour worked was $58.41 in 2019, and the <a href="https://www.ons.gov.uk/employmentandlabourmarket/peopleinwork/employmentandemployeetypes/timeseries/ybus/lms">ONS says</a> that hours worked in 2019 was 1,052 million. This gives us some interesting options to think about.</p><p>The first is that if we increased average working hours of full time employees from <a href="https://www.ons.gov.uk/employmentandlabourmarket/peopleinwork/earningsandworkinghours/timeseries/ybuy/lms">37 hours</a> to 46.25 (25%), total weekly output of a full time worker would increase from $2,161 to $2,701. There were approximately <a href="https://www.ons.gov.uk/employmentandlabourmarket/peopleinwork/employmentandemployeetypes/bulletins/employmentintheuk/august2019#:~:text=Estimates%20for%20April%20to%20June,year%20to%20reach%2024.11%20million).">24 million</a> full time workers in 2019 — this means just short of $13 billion extra output weekly — or $676 billion annually. If we put the total unemployed (<a href="https://www.ons.gov.uk/employmentandlabourmarket/peopleinwork/employmentandemployeetypes/bulletins/employmentintheuk/september2019#:~:text=For%20May%20to%20July%202019%2C%20an%20estimated%201.29%20million%20people,fewer%20than%20five%20years%20earlier.">approx 1.3 million</a>) into 46.25 hour work weeks, this would add a further $180 billion of yearly output — just about $850 billion extra output.</p><p>This doesn’t include the underemployed, a new important category of people, who are difficult to measure. That’s fine. We are talking aggregates here — some people of course can not work that many hours, some people need to remain part time, etc. This is also only a rough demonstration. Remember our question was — “how can we afford this?” and the answer is not by taxes, not by borrowing, not by playing with accounting ledgers but by putting the whole British workforce to work.</p><p>Of course those numbers can be criticised. Those are averages. It’s possible that the unemployed constitute the lower-skilled side of the workforce anyway. It’s also possible that some industries have already reached the point of diminishing returns in terms of productivity per hour, and those numbers are capitalist commodity-interfacing too — they count investment bankers as being highly productive, for instance.</p><p><strong>But these workers are not working for capitalists. They’re working for their own class, which now owns the commanding heights of the economy.</strong></p><p>The net operating surplus of “public non-financial corporations” (ie corporations that aren’t banks) is about <a href="https://www.ceicdata.com/en/united-kingdom/esa-2010-profitability-statistics-private-non-financial-corporations/private-non-financial-corporations-pnfc-gross-operating-surplus">£370 billion per year</a>. There are around 2,000 publicly traded companies on the London Stock Exchange — about 25% of the 8,000 firms that we want to nationalise. According to the OECD’s reporting of British accounts, total gross operating surplus for the entire economy is about <a href="https://stats.oecd.org/Index.aspx?DataSetCode=SNA_TABLE14A">£800 billion a year.</a> In terms of turnover, businesses under 250 employees only make up half of the turnover of big business and about 80% of those businesses make a profit.</p><h4>We therefore now possess a huge amount of surplus funds, made up by a general increase in labour hours worked and the nationalisation of big business. Those surplus funds are now the property of the British working class. What should we do with them?</h4><p>A perennial problem for socialist economies is the ratio of consumer goods and services output (food and healthcare for eg) balanced against capital goods output (production to make more production). Capitalists call the latter <em>gross fixed capital formation</em>.</p><p>Britain has long lagged behind other countries in gross fixed capital formation — investment into new production makes up o<a href="https://www.ons.gov.uk/economy/grossdomesticproductgdp/articles/aninternationalcomparisonofgrossfixedcapitalformation/2017-11-02">nly about 15%</a> of our economy. In Sterling terms, gross fixed capital formation is about <a href="https://www.ons.gov.uk/economy/grossdomesticproductgdp/bulletins/businessinvestment/octobertodecember2017provisionalresults">£80 billion</a>, which includes both construction of houses (about 30%), investment in businesses, intellectual property acquisition etc.</p><p>I will give you the exercise to do yourself, because in reality this would be done by highly educated economic planners who have a wealth of data about the national economy at their fingertips. We aren’t that, but we can still entertain the exercise. Let’s say that adding the surplus output from fully employing the economy to the amount of profit-making industries that we seize, we have an extra £700 billion.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/687/1*czGgSQbGYKz3OV83LPF1Tg.png" /></figure><p>This is what I came up with in five minutes. Note that the “Increase of” section is additional — it’s what we’d add to the original sum, not a new amount.</p><p>Notice that I didn’t suddenly give everyone more money. I didn’t increase wages at all, but increased child benefit <strong>by ten times.</strong> I doubled disability benefit. I hugely subsidised public transport, paid out generous pensions, invested in parks and so on. At the same time I increased the amount of investment into the economy by three times.</p><p>At this point the exercise feels a little like a video game, which I am conscious of. The list doesn’t include all public spending and the figures are very rough. What it is intended to do is demonstrate that by nationalising the commanding heights and by putting our people to work at their maximal capacity, we can build the British Road to Socialism.</p><p>But building that road will mean hard work, for all of us, so that our posterity can reap the benefits. A final note on whether a socialist economy should pay out benefits or wages.</p><h4>Wages or social benefits?</h4><p>In this essay I have departed from the traditional position of British socialists, who believe that because we have Amazon that nobody needs to work anymore.</p><p>The truth is that to fund Socialist construction, those of us who can work will have to do so very hard, perhaps for a very long time. I haven’t discussed issues of how much it might cost to defend the revolution against the British gusanos who will no doubt flee to New York and Toronto (or perhaps, ironically, Brussels.) Atomic weapons aren’t cheap. I haven’t discussed how much a British workers state would pay in solidarity payments to our former colonies or Socialist states abroad. We haven’t discussed the fact that we will need to produce more children in order to offset the increasing number of old people, and children require a lot of financial support — and we haven’t discussed how investment in mental and physical health might expand the workforce.</p><p>And the numbers I have given are very raw and I gave them only to give you ideas — ideas based around what surplus we can nationalise, how much that surplus could be grown by an increase in labour hours and what we could do with that surplus.</p><p>But I think, and I believe I’m very justified in thinking, that Britishers are capable of working long and hard hours if they can see a change around them. I think if they knew that their children and grandparents were very well taken care of, that the state provided opportunities to everyone and rebuilt their communities, that every hour of work went into making our country more beautiful, more fair, and more prosperous, that they would be able to carry on, at least for a reasonable amount of time.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f10af2a49ce7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Death to Debaters]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@britishworkersjournal/death-to-debaters-de1d290bfdb9?source=rss-7e534bff150a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/de1d290bfdb9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[communism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[socialism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[British Workers' Journal]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 24 Jul 2021 18:59:17 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-07-24T19:02:52.059Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I don’t know when the first people had debates, but the Greeks probably came up with the first principles, and these are ones that some people still use today. They also probably came up with the first definition, and there are many definitions today.</p><p>I am going to use my own — a debate is a discussion between two people with different premises. I think that’s important because that’s basically what debates are now. Someone challenges another person to a debate to “own” them and then they have a “debate”. But if you have a debate against a person because you want to beat them, you have to share different premises and there can be no co-operation.</p><p>Here is a good and prominent example: Jordan Peterson challenged Slavoj Zizek to a debate about Marxism. At the beginning of the debate Jordan Peterson admitted he’d only read the Communist Manifesto, which is a bit like having a debate on the US Constitution if you’ve only read the preamble, and the rest of it was a huge waste of time.</p><p>Another example, perhaps more illuminating, was the debate between Vaush and Hakim. Vaush is a “libertarian socialist” who became notorious for grooming fifteen year olds on his discord server and throwing n-bombs at white supremacists. Hakim is an Iraqi doctor who runs a Marxist-Leninist youtube channel. Hakim knows a lot about Marxism and Vaush doesn’t know anything about Marxism and so, obviously, Hakim wiped the floor with Vaush.</p><p>And these debates happen a lot, all over the political spectrum, and my point is they are all a huge waste of time for Communists, who shouldn’t engage in them ever, for any reason at all.</p><p>There is the argument that debates happen to convince people in the middle that people on one side are right. With all respect to Hakim, I highly doubt this happened. The debate served to remind both sides’ supporters that Hakim is educated and Vaush isn’t. On both sides of the Atlantic, recent elections have featured debates between leading politicians, and these debates serve no other purpose than for these politicians to subtly announce new policy positions: which is not the purpose of a debate.</p><p>The problem is that you can not convince people to change their world premise — what the Germans call <em>weltanschauung — </em>by being more educated, more intelligent, or more adroit than them.</p><p>Politics is about power. Anyone who thinks that politics is about being educated, intelligent, or adroit is wrong, and stupid, and dangerous. Politics is not about being right. Politics is about power.</p><p>Demonstrations of education, intelligence, adroitness, or just being right about something, do not increase our political power. They don’t make us stronger. Internal discussions about how to wage class warfare are useful, and while they can be heated, they’re not debates because we all have the same premise and we all want the same thing.</p><p>After all, we could not be clearer about what we want to do. We want to organise workers into political units like unions, parties, peoples assemblies, direct action units, and so on, and wage class war, eventually advancing on the political, economic and possibly military centre of capitalism and squashing it, hopefully decisively.</p><p>Anyway, you might wonder what this has to do with debates. Let’s be clear that the vast majority of people don’t have an ideological premise that they have come up with themselves through investigation. People are not ideological and when they have ideas, those ideas are — to quote Marx — in every epoch, the ideas of the ruling class, by and large. Separating working class people from the ideas of their ruling class is important work, and we call this creating class consciousness.</p><p>But this does not happen through debate, has never happened through debate, will never happen through debate. That happens through organisation. This is not a post about organising.</p><p>Nobody cares if we are right. Also, we do not care if we are right. We know we are right and if you are a Communist and you are not sure that you are right, all you have to do is get other Communists to give you educational materials and it won’t be long in coming. The enemy doesn’t care if we are right, he cares if we are strong, and so we should be spending our time on becoming strong.</p><p>But every moment we spend debating is a moment that we do not spend on building our strength. And since the enemy, in his high and apparently impregnable castle, builds his strength every day, that means that every moment we spend debating actually makes us weaker. Not just does it make us materially weaker, but it weakens the morale of our movement and weakens the morale of our party cadres by directing their attention towards sub-median intelligence internet intellectuals.</p><p>Therefore —</p><p>Communists: hide debate threads, ignore debate threads, do not reply to debate posters.</p><p>Communists: we are not here to negotiate with our enemies. We are here to squash them, like bugs beneath a rotten floorboard.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=de1d290bfdb9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>