<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Andrii Brodetskyi on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Andrii Brodetskyi on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@brodetskyi?source=rss-f421a4757f26------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Mon, 16 Nov 2026 00:35:58 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@brodetskyi/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Next Trillion-Dollar Opportunity: Why Vertical AI is the Future of SaaS]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/included-vc/the-next-trillion-dollar-opportunity-why-vertical-ai-is-the-future-of-saas-b7119614cee5?source=rss-f421a4757f26------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b7119614cee5</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[venture-capital]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Andrii Brodetskyi]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 16 Apr 2025 13:34:29 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-04-16T13:34:29.119Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Introduction: The Rise of Vertical AI</h3><p>The software industry stands at the threshold of a transformative era. After decades dominated by horizontal platforms and cloud-based applications, we’re witnessing the emergence of a new paradigm that promises to reshape enterprise software as we know it: Vertical AI.</p><p>For over a decade, horizontal SaaS products like Salesforce, Workday, and HubSpot have captured the imagination of investors and entrepreneurs alike. These platforms, designed to serve universal business functions across industries, have created enormous value and defined the cloud revolution. But now, the confluence of AI and vertical-specific expertise is creating unprecedented opportunities for specialized applications that can penetrate markets previously resistant to technology adoption.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0_TTKrz-WbxvKnspefL94g.jpeg" /></figure><p>Vertical AI represents a fundamental shift from general-purpose AI to industry-specific applications that combine the power of large language models with deep domain knowledge. Unlike conversational AI tools like ChatGPT, which aim to be versatile generalists, Vertical AI solutions are designed to excel at specific tasks within particular industries, from contract analysis for lawyers to automated medical documentation for healthcare providers.</p><p>“The next titans of software will be vertical AI companies in specialized industries,” NEA declared in their 2025 analysis. This isn’t mere speculation — we’re already seeing the early indicators of this shift as capital flows into vertical-specific AI applications and early adopters report unprecedented productivity gains.</p><p>What makes this moment so pivotal is the convergence of several critical factors: the maturation of LLM technology, the growing recognition of industry-specific data as a competitive moat, and the economic reality that AI can now automate high-value knowledge work previously thought to be the exclusive domain of human experts.</p><p>This isn’t simply an incremental improvement on the vertical SaaS model. It represents a fundamental expansion of what software can do and which markets it can serve. While traditional SaaS primarily focused on digitizing workflows and improving efficiency, Vertical AI can actually perform complex tasks and make decisions previously reserved for trained professionals.</p><h3>Market Opportunity: Expanding the Addressable Market</h3><p>The market opportunity for Vertical AI extends far beyond traditional enterprise software boundaries. While SaaS targeted efficiency improvements valued at around 1% of U.S. GDP, Vertical AI has the potential to address a significantly larger slice of the economic pie — the labor market itself.</p><p>According to NEA’s 2025 analysis, Vertical AI will target the $11 trillion U.S. labor spend, dwarfing the $450 billion enterprise software market. This expansion is possible because AI fundamentally changes what software can do and how it’s valued by customers.</p><p>Consider the economics: Traditional SaaS typically captures 1–5% of an employee’s value through efficiency gains. A CRM might make a sales representative more productive, but the salesperson still does the core work. Scale Venture Partners notes that AI enables vertical software to capture 25–50% of an employee’s value by automating substantial portions of their role. When software can draft a legal document, process an insurance claim, or generate clinical notes — not just streamline how humans do these tasks — the potential economic value skyrockets.</p><p>This shift allows Vertical AI companies to transcend the limitations that constrained previous generations of vertical software. Historically, many industries were considered too niche to support large software outcomes. The conventional wisdom was that these markets were either too small, too conservative, or too fragmented to build billion-dollar companies.</p><p>Sapphire Ventures challenges this notion: “While certain verticals may be earlier in the technology adoption curve, we are at a Goldilocks moment in terms of established playbooks and talent diffusion.” The firm points out that several early success stories in vertical software like Veeva, Procore, and ServiceTitan have proven that TAMs often end up being larger than initially anticipated. With AI expanding the value proposition further, even specialized niches can support substantial businesses.</p><p>Bessemer Venture Partners goes even further, predicting that “Vertical AI’s market capitalization will be at least 10x the size of legacy Vertical SaaS” as these applications take on the services economy. Their analysis of early Vertical AI companies shows them growing at approximately 400% year-over-year while maintaining healthy 65% gross margins — growth rates that exceed even the most successful early SaaS companies.</p><p>Industries previously resistant to software adoption are now embracing AI-powered solutions. Healthcare providers, law firms, and insurance companies — all historically slow to adopt new technology — are actively seeking AI tools that can address critical pain points. The reason is simple: the ROI is compelling enough to overcome organizational inertia.</p><p>Take healthcare, for instance. Doctors spend more than two hours on paperwork for every hour with patients. An AI solution that can automate clinical documentation offers such obvious value that adoption becomes a competitive necessity rather than a nice-to-have. Similarly, legal professionals spending hours on document review can immediately recognize the value of an AI that performs this task in minutes.</p><p>The markets Vertical AI can address aren’t just larger — they’re also more diverse. Christine Kim of Greylock Partners notes that “in earlier tech eras, Vertical SaaS could only be applied to companies with modern tech stacks.” This left out foundational industries primarily dependent on unstructured data like contracts, records, and multimedia files. “Now, large language models are equipped to handle workflows with unstructured data, meaning AI can be the missing piece that finally brings technologically-underserved industries into the modern era.”</p><h3>The New Control Point: From Systems of Record to Systems of Action</h3><p>For decades, the most valuable enterprise software companies have been systems of record — the databases and platforms that store, organize, and process critical business information. Salesforce for customer relationships, Workday for human resources, and SAP for enterprise resources have built empires by becoming the central repositories of business data.</p><p>These systems derived their power from three main sources, as NEA outlines: “High switching costs due to their role in storing and structuring critical data; ownership of workflows because users operate within their platforms; and a robust ecosystem of applications and integrations that creates lock-in.”</p><p>However, the emergence of AI agents capable of processing unstructured inputs and taking autonomous actions threatens to disrupt this established order. “The nature of software is changing from a system of record to a system of actions,” NEA observes. In this new paradigm, the most valuable software isn’t necessarily the one that stores the data, but the one that can act on it.</p><p>Consider what happens when an AI agent can directly process emails, transcribe phone calls, analyze documents, and execute actions based on this information before it ever reaches a traditional system of record. The agent not only captures data that might never have made it into these systems in the first place but also generates new, structured data as a byproduct of its operations.</p><p>This shift creates an opening for Vertical AI companies to establish a new control point within customer organizations. By positioning themselves at the beginning of the workflow chain rather than the end, they can intercept and process information before it reaches legacy systems.</p><p>Axon provides a compelling example of this strategy in action. The company started with body cameras for law enforcement, then built AI agents that analyze footage to automatically generate police reports — a task that traditionally consumes 50% of officers’ time. The reports are logged in existing record management systems, but the real value is created before the data ever touches those systems. Axon has subsequently launched its own records management offering, building backwards into the system of record after establishing itself as the system of action.</p><p>Similarly, in healthcare, companies like Abridge transcribe patient-doctor conversations, extract key information, and automatically generate clinical notes. While these notes eventually find their way into electronic health record systems, the critical value-add happens upstream of the traditional system of record.</p><p>This repositioning of the “control point” has profound implications for incumbents. Systems of record that fail to develop their own AI capabilities risk becoming commoditized backends, while the AI-powered front-end captures an increasing share of customer value and mindshare.</p><p>For startups, this creates an opportunity to establish beachheads in markets previously dominated by entrenched incumbents. Rather than attempting to replace entire systems of record — a formidable challenge given switching costs — they can focus on specific high-value workflows where AI can deliver immediate ROI. As these startups capture more data and expand their capabilities, they can gradually work backwards to challenge the incumbents’ core offerings.</p><h3>The Vertical AI Playbook: Business Models That Work</h3><p>The rise of Vertical AI is giving birth to new business models that differ fundamentally from traditional SaaS. Understanding these models is essential for founders seeking to build enduring companies in this space and for investors evaluating opportunities.</p><p>Bessemer Venture Partners identifies three primary emerging models:</p><p><strong>Copilots</strong> augment human workers in completing tasks, sitting side-by-side with users as they navigate workflows. GitHub Copilot exemplifies this model, helping developers write code more efficiently and reportedly increasing productivity by as much as 55%. Similarly, Harvey AI assists lawyers in summarizing contracts and answering specific questions about content, while Sixfold AI helps insurance underwriters collate information to assess risk profiles.</p><p>Copilots are typically priced on a per-seat basis like traditional SaaS, but they command significant premiums. Microsoft’s Copilot for Office 365, for instance, costs an additional $30 per user on top of base subscription fees, effectively doubling or tripling the price per seat. This pricing power reflects the substantial productivity enhancements these tools provide.</p><p><strong>Agents</strong> take automation a step further by fully automating workflows with minimal human intervention. Unlike copilots, which assist humans, agents can independently complete tasks from start to finish. LinkedIn’s Hiring Assistant automates candidate sourcing and job description drafting, while Slang’s voice AI handles restaurant phone calls, answering questions and making reservations without human involvement.</p><p>Pricing for agents often aligns with the value of labor automated rather than traditional software metrics. As they can substitute for future headcount growth and allow existing employees to focus on higher-value tasks, agents can capture a significant portion of the labor costs they offset. This allows for substantially higher revenue per customer than traditional software.</p><p><strong>AI-enabled Services</strong> represent perhaps the most disruptive model, directly competing with traditional service providers by offering similar services at lower costs through automation. EvenUp automatically builds demand packages for injury lawyers, while SmarterDx automates clinical documentation integrity work in hospitals.</p><p>These services are generally priced relative to existing service providers but maintain higher margins due to automation. By benchmarking against established service fees rather than software subscriptions, they can capture a larger share of customer budgets while still offering compelling cost savings.</p><p>Across these models, innovative pricing approaches are emerging. NEA describes the evolution: “While the cloud vertical SaaS pioneers faced minimal competition, tackling pen-and-paper workflows or outdated on-prem solutions in companies with limited engineering resources, today’s AI startups face a tougher landscape.” To succeed, many are embracing usage and output-based pricing to align value capture with value creation.</p><p>This approach ties pricing to specific outcomes delivered — per demand letter generated, per ticket resolved, per document analyzed — making ROI easily quantifiable for customers. Many companies combine this with subscription fees or tiered pricing to ensure predictable baseline revenue while capturing upside from expanded use.</p><p>The go-to-market strategy for Vertical AI also differs from traditional SaaS. NEA advises: “Use AI-powered wedges to land the customer” and “Integrate with existing systems of record, at first.” This approach recognizes that customers are unlikely to rip and replace core systems immediately, but will adopt point solutions that deliver clear, immediate value.</p><p>Voice agents, semantic document search, and content generation have emerged as effective wedges for entering customer organizations. Once established, Vertical AI companies can expand their footprint by collecting new data through their systems of action and gradually building their own systems of record.</p><p>Success in this environment requires what NEA calls “industry-specific GTM” — deep knowledge of customer pain points, buying processes, and value metrics. “Customers buy solutions, not AI,” they emphasize, highlighting the importance of framing offerings in terms of business outcomes rather than technological capabilities.</p><h3>Building Defensibility: Moats in the AI Era</h3><p>In an era where foundation models are increasingly commoditized and available through open-source channels, the question of defensibility becomes paramount for Vertical AI companies. Critics often dismiss AI applications as mere “wrappers” around third-party models without sustainable competitive advantages. However, vertical specialization offers several robust paths to building deep moats that can withstand competitive pressures.</p><p>“Data is arguably the most important currency in building a differentiated position,” Greylock Partners emphasizes. This observation is particularly relevant for vertical applications where relevant training data often doesn’t exist in sufficient volumes in the public domain. Industries like healthcare, legal services, insurance, and manufacturing operate with vast volumes of domain-specific data that remains inaccessible to general models like GPT-4.</p><p>According to Christine Kim of Greylock, the first step startups must take is to “identify whether the vertical or workflow requires a very large corpus of data, or if there is an opportunity to build a proprietary data asset.” Companies that can aggregate industry-specific datasets — whether from public sources, private partnerships, or their own customer base — gain a significant advantage that general-purpose models can’t easily replicate.</p><p>This advantage becomes even stronger when the product itself generates valuable data. As Kim notes, “initial access to data is important as the preliminary moat, but ultimately, the data created by customers using your product provides the long-term moat.” When customers use a vertical AI solution, they create feedback loops and generate new data points that further enhance the model’s effectiveness, creating a virtuous cycle that’s difficult for competitors to interrupt.</p><p>Scale Venture Partners identifies three “unfair advantages” that vertical applications have over horizontal solutions:</p><ol><li><strong>Unstructured data handling</strong>: Many vertical industries operate primarily with unstructured data (documents, images, audio recordings) that general models struggle to parse effectively within the specific context.</li><li><strong>Domain-specificity</strong>: Building AI applications for vertical environments requires highly specialized knowledge. As Scale notes, “Using OpenAI to make a loan decision is not possible today, since it cannot provide an audit on bias for regulators, even if you can solve the data regulations that come with handling personally identifiable information.”</li><li><strong>Regulatory compliance</strong>: Vertical markets often operate under complex regulatory frameworks that generic AI solutions can’t navigate effectively. HIPAA in healthcare, compliance in trucking, OSHA in construction — these regulatory environments create natural barriers to entry that favor specialized solutions.</li></ol><p>The ideal moat combines proprietary data with specialized workflows and deep domain expertise. Take Abridge in healthcare, which uses speech recognition technology that automatically detects a doctor’s specialty and the language spoken by the patient across 28 languages. This specialized capability stems from extensive training on medical conversations and terms that general-purpose models haven’t seen in sufficient volume.</p><p>Vertical AI companies can also enhance defensibility through multimodal approaches. As Euclid Ventures explains, “Multimodal AIs federate multiple models to handle various forms of input/output and/or perform discrete functions which warrant a dedicated architecture.” A tutoring app for college students might supplement a base LLM with more symbolic models that can parse mathematical expressions — creating a capability that no single model could achieve.</p><p>Regulatory requirements can be transformed from constraints into competitive advantages. In heavily regulated industries like healthcare, financial services, and insurance, AI solutions must provide audit trails, explain their reasoning, and meet stringent compliance standards. Companies that build these capabilities into their core architecture create barriers to entry that generic models struggle to overcome.</p><p>Ultimately, as Euclid Ventures concludes, “We don’t think the determinants of success for Vertical AI are so different from those in traditional software — winners will leverage deep domain expertise to apply LLMs, access the right partners and datasets, and address a pain point with large dollars at stake.”</p><h3>Why Vertical AI Will Win: The Economic Advantage</h3><p>Beyond the technical moats discussed above, Vertical AI companies demonstrate compelling economic advantages that position them for outsized success. These advantages manifest in better unit economics, more efficient growth, and ultimately higher valuations.</p><p>Euclid Ventures’ analysis reveals that public Vertical SaaS companies already trade at nearly double the EV/Gross Profit multiples of their horizontal peers — 11x versus 5x on the median. This “vertical profit premium” reflects investors’ recognition that these companies often achieve market dominance in their niches, build stickier products, and operate with more efficient go-to-market strategies.</p><p>What drives this premium? Euclid Ventures identifies three key factors:</p><ol><li><strong>Market Dominance</strong>: Vertical software companies often achieve higher market penetration within their target segments, leading to stronger competitive positions and pricing power.</li><li><strong>Product Stickiness</strong>: Domain-specific solutions tend to become deeply embedded in customer workflows, resulting in lower churn and higher net dollar retention over time.</li><li><strong>Go-to-Market Efficiency</strong>: Vertical companies typically spend far less on sales and marketing per dollar of revenue. Public vertical software companies spend half as much on go-to-market activities compared to horizontal peers, while private companies show 30–50% higher Net Magic Numbers.</li></ol><p>Early data on Vertical AI companies suggests these advantages may be even more pronounced. According to Bessemer Venture Partners, LLM-native vertical companies are growing approximately 400% year-over-year while maintaining healthy 65% gross margins. They also note that these companies have quickly reached 80% of the average contract value of traditional vertical SaaS systems, despite their relative youth.</p><p>The economic advantage extends to customer acquisition as well. As Sapphire Ventures observes, “Given the relative lack of competition and a capital environment that didn’t invest hand over fist in these spaces, vertical SaaS companies tend to experience consistent growth coupled with solid efficiency.” Word-of-mouth referrals tend to be stronger in vertical markets due to tighter professional networks, further reducing customer acquisition costs.</p><p>Scale Venture Partners points to another economic advantage: the expanded value capture enabled by AI. “With AI, companies can automate tasks traditionally performed by human experts, capturing a greater share of their customers’ value chains,” they explain. “For example, instead of merely offering software to manage claims, an insurance-focused platform could automate claim approvals or fraud detection.”</p><p>This shift allows Vertical AI companies to price based on value rather than relative to employee salary, potentially increasing their share of customer spend by 5–10x compared to traditional SaaS. “This TAM expansion means that subfractions of markets are now in play,” Scale notes. “Legal software, for example, used to be one category. Now we’re seeing software just for accident lawyers.”</p><p>The combination of rapid growth, strong margins, efficient customer acquisition, and expanded value capture creates a powerful economic engine. This explains why Bessemer predicts we’ll see at least five Vertical AI companies with $100M+ ARR within the next two to three years and the first Vertical AI IPO in the next three years.</p><h3>Case Studies: Vertical AI Success Stories</h3><p>While Vertical AI is still in its early stages, several companies are already demonstrating its transformative potential across various industries. These early successes provide a window into the patterns and approaches that lead to breakthrough products in this category.</p><p><strong>Legal Technology</strong></p><p>The legal industry, with its heavy reliance on language, document review, and pattern recognition, has emerged as a natural fit for Vertical AI applications. Harvey AI exemplifies the copilot model, helping lawyers quickly summarize contracts and answer specific questions about their content. The company provides AI assistants that leverage domain-specific knowledge to accelerate tasks like contract analysis, legal research, and document drafting.</p><p>Casetext, acquired by Thomson Reuters for $650 million in 2023, built an AI research assistant that helps lawyers find relevant precedents and prepare documents. The substantial acquisition price — especially notable for a company founded just a decade earlier — signals the strategic value incumbents place on AI capabilities.</p><p>EvenUp represents the AI-enabled services model, automating demand letter generation for personal injury attorneys. By handling this time-intensive process, EvenUp allows firms to serve more clients with fewer resources, capturing a significant portion of the value created. The company prices per demand package generated rather than using a traditional subscription model, aligning their revenue with the value delivered.</p><p><strong>Healthcare</strong></p><p>Healthcare has emerged as a particularly fertile ground for Vertical AI, with applications addressing everything from clinical documentation to diagnostic support.</p><p>Abridge exemplifies voice AI in healthcare, transcribing and structuring doctor-patient conversations in real-time to generate clinical notes. By addressing one of healthcare’s most pressing problems — documentation burden — Abridge delivers immediate ROI to healthcare providers while improving the patient experience. The company’s speech recognition technology can automatically detect medical specialties and handle multiple languages, showcasing the power of domain-specific training.</p><p>SmarterDx analyzes patient charts to improve clinical documentation and capture revenue that might otherwise be lost due to incomplete or inaccurate coding. By reviewing 100% of patient data rather than the small sample human specialists might manage, the solution improves both compliance and financial outcomes.</p><p>Sixfold AI helps with insurance approvals, addressing the broken provider-payer relationship by focusing on prior authorization flows. This solution demonstrates how AI can bridge gaps between stakeholders in complex ecosystems, creating value throughout the healthcare value chain.</p><p><strong>Public Safety</strong></p><p>The public safety sector, facing critical labor shortages and overwhelming data volumes, has become an early adopter of Vertical AI solutions.</p><p>Axon has built AI agents that analyze body camera footage and generate police reports, automating a task that traditionally consumes 50% of officers’ time. The company’s expansion from hardware (body cameras) to AI-powered software illustrates how domain-specific data can create a foundation for increasingly valuable solutions. Axon has now built its own CAD and records management offerings, working backwards from a system of action to become a comprehensive system of record.</p><p>Prepared uses voice agents to handle inbound emergency calls, transcribing, summarizing, and logging information into dispatch systems. By addressing the 25% vacancy rate in 911 centers, Prepared delivers value in a critical area where human resources are increasingly constrained.</p><p><strong>Construction and AEC</strong></p><p>The construction industry, historically underserved by software despite representing 4.5% of the U.S. economy, is now seeing AI applications tackle its unstructured data challenges.</p><p>Trunk Tools uses semantic document search to help construction teams navigate complex project documentation and find critical information buried in thousands of pages. By reducing the time spent searching for information, the solution helps prevent costly mistakes and delays.</p><p>Workpack AI and Togal AI serve as visual copilots for estimators in the preconstruction process, automatically measuring and labeling project specifications from visual inputs. These solutions demonstrate how multimodal AI can address industry-specific workflows that combine visual, textual, and numerical data.</p><p><strong>Insurance</strong></p><p>The insurance industry, with its complex risk assessment processes and document-intensive workflows, has seen notable innovation in Vertical AI.</p><p>Sixfold helps underwriters process documents and compare them against underwriting policies, making recommendations that automate hours of human labor. By integrating with incumbent systems like Guidewire, Sixfold demonstrates the wedge strategy of building alongside existing systems of record before potentially displacing them.</p><p>Reserv automates the entire insurance claim process, delivering better data and insights to carriers, MGAs, and other partners. The company competes with legacy third-party administrators by combining AI automation with human expertise, delivering superior service at competitive prices.</p><p>These success stories share common elements despite spanning different industries: they target high-value, repetitive tasks that consume significant portions of professionals’ time; they leverage advanced AI to process unstructured data in ways previously impossible; and they deliver clear, measurable ROI that makes adoption a straightforward decision despite organizational inertia.</p><h3>Conclusion: The Future Belongs to Vertical AI</h3><p>The next decade of software will be defined by vertical applications powered by artificial intelligence. As these applications evolve from enhancing human productivity to automating entire workflows, they will reshape industries and create immense value for customers, founders, and investors alike.</p><p>The potential of Vertical AI stems from fundamental shifts in what software can do and how it’s valued. By processing unstructured data, automating complex tasks, and delivering industry-specific intelligence, these applications can penetrate markets previously resistant to technology adoption and capture a significantly larger share of economic value than traditional software.</p><p>For entrepreneurs, this represents perhaps the most exciting opportunity in enterprise software since the rise of cloud computing. The playbook for success combines technical excellence with deep domain expertise — understanding not just how to build AI systems but how to apply them to the specific challenges and workflows of target industries.</p><p>For incumbent software companies, the message is clear: adapt or risk disintermediation. As AI-powered systems of action establish new control points in customer organizations, traditional systems of record must evolve to maintain their relevance and value. This doesn’t necessarily mean building everything in-house — strategic acquisitions like Thomson Reuters’ purchase of Casetext for $650 million demonstrate how established players can incorporate AI capabilities.</p><p>For investors, the parallels to the early days of cloud computing are striking. Those who recognized the transformative potential of SaaS a decade ago and invested accordingly were rewarded with outsized returns. Vertical AI represents a similar inflection point — a fundamental shift in how software is built, delivered, and monetized.</p><p>Bessemer predicts we’ll see at least five Vertical AI companies with $100M+ ARR within 2–3 years and the first Vertical AI IPO in the next three years. This rapid scaling reflects the inherent advantages of the Vertical AI model: larger addressable markets, novel business models that capture more value, and the ability to build defensible moats through specialized data and domain knowledge.</p><p>As Euclid Ventures succinctly puts it, “The future of AI is specialized.” General-purpose models will continue to advance and grab headlines, but the real value creation will happen where AI meets industry-specific challenges and workflows. The companies that successfully navigate this intersection will become the next generation of software giants.</p><p>Just as cloud computing produced vertical winners like Veeva (life sciences), Toast (restaurants), and Procore (construction), the AI era will produce its own vertical champions across industries. But unlike their SaaS predecessors, these companies won’t be constrained by the limitations of traditional software. They’ll automate not just workflows but decision-making itself, expanding their impact and value exponentially.</p><p>The vertical AI revolution is not coming — it’s already here. And its impact will be measured not in billions, but in trillions.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b7119614cee5" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/included-vc/the-next-trillion-dollar-opportunity-why-vertical-ai-is-the-future-of-saas-b7119614cee5">The Next Trillion-Dollar Opportunity: Why Vertical AI is the Future of SaaS</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/included-vc">Included VC</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Engineering under Fire: Investment Opportunities in Ukraine’s Defense Tech Sector]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/included-vc/engineering-under-fire-investment-opportunities-in-ukraines-defense-tech-sector-8fe7275c123a?source=rss-f421a4757f26------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8fe7275c123a</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Andrii Brodetskyi]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 14 Dec 2024 20:58:37 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-12-14T20:58:37.272Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>In the shadow of Europe’s largest conflict since World War II, an unlikely innovation ecosystem has emerged. Ukraine, long known as an IT outsourcing powerhouse with over 300,000 technology professionals and a deep tradition of STEM education, has transformed its engineering expertise into a potent weapon against a numerically superior adversary.</p><p>This is a story of necessity breeding invention. Faced with Russia’s overwhelming advantages in conventional military power, Ukraine has turned to technological innovation as an asymmetric response. “Now I understand why, before the full-scale Russian invasion, no one in a ‘sober state’ entered the defense industry,” reflects Dmytro Shymkiv, an experienced tech executive turned defense entrepreneur. Yet the pressing demands of the battlefield leave no time for perfect conditions — Ukrainian innovators are creating solutions today that will shape tomorrow’s warfare.</p><p>The results have been remarkable. Ukrainian defense technology companies have compressed decades of military innovation into months, driven by what may be the fastest feedback loop in military history. As Nataliia Kushnerska, Project Lead at Brave1 defense cluster explains, “Technologies that cost a huge amount of money, made in [overseas] labs, are coming to the front line, and they’re not working.” In contrast, Ukrainian solutions are battle-tested daily, refined hourly, and improved continuously through direct interaction with frontline users.</p><p>Yet transforming battlefield innovation into sustainable business success remains dauntingly complex. Export controls limit access to international markets. The ever-present threat of Russian missiles complicates manufacturing. Traditional venture metrics struggle to capture the value of companies operating in an active war zone.</p><p>Despite these challenges, a vibrant ecosystem has emerged. Over 2,800 defense tech projects are registered with Brave1, Ukraine’s government innovation cluster. Dozens of venture funds, from Silicon Valley veterans to European defense specialists, are actively investing. Most importantly, hundreds of thousands of Ukrainian soldiers validate new technologies daily.</p><p>This deep dive examines the opportunities and challenges this unprecedented situation presents for VC investors. We’ll explore how Ukraine’s defense tech sector is revolutionizing modern warfare while attempting to build sustainable businesses. We’ll analyze the unique dynamics of investing in a wartime innovation ecosystem, from navigating export controls to structuring international operations. And we’ll look at how some of the world’s most battle-tested startups are working to transform tactical necessity into strategic advantage.</p><p>For venture investors, Ukraine’s defense tech sector represents both extraordinary opportunity and unusual complexity. Understanding how to navigate this landscape may prove crucial not just for portfolio returns, but for the future of military technology itself.</p><p><em>Note: this deep dive is focused on light-asset defense tech, excluding weapon systems, heavy machinery, missile systems, etc. Also, some information was gathered during informal conversations with market participants and can’t be attributed.</em></p><p><strong>Market overview: size, structure, and evolution</strong></p><p>Over 300 companies actively develop defense solutions across Ukraine, from AI-enabled drones to electronic warfare systems, marking the emergence of a vibrant military technology sector. Yet perhaps the most telling metric is not the current market size, but the gap between production capacity and utilization. Ukrainian defense manufacturers have demonstrated the capability to produce approximately $20bn worth of equipment annually, while current procurement levels hover around $6–10bn. This $10bn gap represents both a challenge and an opportunity for the sector.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*RlgFZxinwxhklnyvg9ctfA.png" /><figcaption>Structure of Ukrainian defense tech market (via Data Driven)</figcaption></figure><p>The market’s structure reflects the diverse needs of modern warfare. Unmanned systems, predominantly drones, command the largest share at 19% of defense tech projects. This is followed by robotics and AI solutions at 13% each, with electronic warfare systems comprising 6%. The remaining 49% spans a range of specialized technologies, from advanced materials to secure communications systems. This distribution reflects emerging battlefield trends, where autonomous systems and electronic warfare capabilities increasingly determine tactical advantages.</p><p>The geographical dispersion of production facilities across Ukraine represents a deliberate strategy to ensure resilience. Rather than concentrating manufacturing in traditional industrial centers, companies have adopted a distributed model that minimizes vulnerability to disruption. This approach has proven prescient, enabling continued production despite operational challenges.</p><p>The evolution of Ukraine’s defense technology sector can be traced through three distinct phases, each marking a significant leap in sophistication.</p><ul><li>In 2022, the industry emerged from necessity, characterized by small teams of 3–10 people focused on immediate tactical needs rather than sustainable business models. These volunteer-driven initiatives, while crucial for immediate defense needs, laid the groundwork for more structured development.</li><li>By 2023, the sector entered its formalization phase. Companies began establishing proper business processes, securing initial investment rounds, and developing systematic approaches to product development. This period saw the emergence of notable success stories like Buntar Aerospace and Himera, which demonstrated the potential for Ukrainian defense technology companies to attract significant investment and scale operations.</li><li>The current phase, marking 2024, represents a crucial transition toward industry maturation. With over 500 manufacturers in the drone sector alone, the market has reached a point where consolidation becomes inevitable. This consolidation is not merely about survival; it represents a natural evolution toward more capable, better-resourced organizations that can compete on a global scale.</li></ul><p><strong>Market overview: supply and demand dynamics</strong></p><p>The supply side of Ukraine’s defense technology market presents a study in rapid industrial transformation. The manufacturing base has demonstrated remarkable adaptability, with domestic content in defense products ranging from 40% to 70% depending on the category. This level of localization, achieved in less than two years, represents a significant shift from earlier reliance on imported components.</p><p>Production capabilities have scaled dramatically, particularly in the drone sector.</p><blockquote>“If a unit had a dozen FPV drones and burned an enemy tank with them in early 2023, they were perceived as space marines and legends were made about them,” recalls the co-founder of <strong>Wild Hornets</strong>, one of Ukraine’s first mass producers of strike drones.</blockquote><p>Today, Ukraine hosts over 500 drone manufacturers alone, with production capacity projected to reach 4 million units in 2024 — a stark contrast to the mere 3,000–5,000 units produced in 2022. For example, <strong>TAF Drones</strong>, one of the largest drone producers, reached $150m in sales in H1 2024, with another $500m coming from selling components.</p><p>This exponential growth reflects both improved manufacturing processes and significant technology learning curves. <strong>Technology development cycles have compressed dramatically</strong> under wartime pressure. Electronic warfare systems, for instance, require updates every three months to remain effective, driving a pace of innovation rarely seen in traditional defense industries. This rapid iteration cycle has become a defining characteristic of Ukrainian defense technology development.</p><p>Pricing dynamics reveal a significant competitive advantage for Ukrainian manufacturers. <strong>Their products typically cost 30–70% less than Western alternatives</strong> while offering battle-tested capabilities. This cost advantage, combined with proven effectiveness, positions Ukrainian companies favorably for international expansion once export restrictions ease.</p><blockquote>As Dmytro Shymkiv, co-owner of <strong>AeroDrone</strong>, says, “When we show our product, in Ukraine they ask us why it is so expensive, and in the West they ask why it is so cheap.”</blockquote><p>The procurement pattern has evolved from the early days of emergency purchases to more structured acquisition processes. The establishment of the Brave1 defense cluster has introduced greater systematization to military procurement, with 344 grants totaling $8 million awarded to date. This institutionalization of the procurement process has created more predictable demand signals for manufacturers.</p><p>However, domestic procurement still faces budgetary constraints that limit the market’s immediate growth potential. The state budget can currently support only about half of the industry’s production capacity, creating pressure for market expansion beyond national borders.</p><p><strong>Market overview: competitive landscape</strong></p><p>The competitive landscape has undergone a fundamental transformation since 2022. While state-owned enterprises dominated the sector before the war, private companies now account for 80% of defense equipment suppliers, up from 20% in 2022. This shift reflects not just a change in ownership structure but a broader transformation in how military technology is developed and deployed.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*bVLUk3AmFHStoXv-.jpg" /><figcaption>Raybird-3 UAV by Skyethon (Photo: Come Back Alive foundation)</figcaption></figure><p>Within this transformed landscape, distinct strategic groups have emerged.</p><ul><li>At the top end, companies like <strong>AeroDrone </strong>compete in the high-value reconnaissance drone segment, with products like the D-80 Discovery platform priced at $450,000 per system. Even more sophisticated <strong>Skyeton </strong>reconnaissance systems cost up to $1.2m and the company expects up to $80m in annual sales in 2024.</li><li>The middle market is populated by innovative integrators like <strong>Buntar Aerospace</strong>, which has deployed over 1,000 units of its AI-enhanced surveillance systems.</li><li>At the tactical level, numerous manufacturers compete in the FPV drone segment, where success depends on rapid iteration and close customer relationships.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*vkN3GQ1wGzZfruVo" /><figcaption>Ukrainian defense tech market map (created by author using Data Driven data)</figcaption></figure><p>Entry barriers vary significantly by segment. While basic drone manufacturing has relatively low entry barriers, segments like electronic warfare require significant technological expertise and data accumulation. Companies like <strong>Kara Dag</strong> have built competitive advantages through the development of comprehensive UAV signature databases, creating moats that deepen with each operational deployment.</p><p>Looking ahead, three key trends are reshaping the competitive landscape.</p><ul><li><strong>First, technology integration is accelerating, with successful companies increasingly combining multiple capabilities</strong> — autonomous systems, artificial intelligence, and electronic warfare — into integrated solutions. This trend toward system integration favors companies with broader technological capabilities and strong partnership networks.</li><li><strong>Second, international expansion strategies are evolving beyond simple export models</strong>. Companies like <strong>Skyeton</strong>, which invested €3.5m in Slovak production facilities, and <strong>DeViRo</strong>, which established operations in the Czech Republic, are pursuing sophisticated internationalization strategies that combine market access with technology development.</li><li><strong>Finally, the sector appears poised for significant consolidation</strong>. With 85% of surveyed companies considering partial relocation abroad and 30% interested in M&amp;A, the current landscape of numerous small competitors may soon give way to fewer, but more capable, players. This consolidation, rather than dampening innovation, could create organizations better equipped to compete globally.</li></ul><p>The future trajectory of Ukraine’s defense technology sector will likely be determined by how successfully companies navigate these trends while maintaining their core advantage in rapid innovation and battlefield validation. Those who succeed will have written a new chapter in the history of defense industry development, demonstrating how national necessity can drive global innovation in military technology.</p><p><strong>Investment landscape: selected deals and investors</strong></p><p>The transformation of Ukraine’s defense tech investment landscape tells a story of rapid institutionalization. In 2022, funding largely came through informal channels — angel investors, military units, and volunteer organizations. By 2023, the sector had attracted more than $9 million in private investments, with 2024 showing signs of accelerating institutional involvement.</p><p>This evolution reflects a maturing ecosystem. Where early investments were often driven by immediate tactical needs and patriotic sentiment, today’s funding rounds increasingly reflect sophisticated VC dynamics. Companies are now raising larger rounds — up to $3 million, up significantly from the previous average of $500,000 — and facing more rigorous due diligence processes.</p><iframe src="" width="0" height="0" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/65e65de02b467e8ce8d314fff4dca661/href">https://medium.com/media/65e65de02b467e8ce8d314fff4dca661/href</a></iframe><p>Several landmark deals in 2023–2024 highlight the sector’s growing attraction to institutional investors.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*QHqJ6Xr23OZaJv_IVCVaJg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Serhii Kuprienko, Swarmer CEO and Founder, in the startup’s secret office (Photo: The Times)</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Swarmer</strong>, developing AI-powered drone swarm technology, secured a $2.7m seed round led by U.S. defense technology company <strong>R-G.AI</strong>, with participation from American funds <strong>Radius Capital</strong>, <strong>Green Flag Ventures</strong>, and <strong>D3</strong>. This deal is particularly noteworthy for bringing together strategic and financial investors, a combination that has become increasingly common in successful raises.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*aDUpjJIien4wckWmiX_ruw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Buntar One UAV (Photo: Buntar One)</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Buntar Aerospace </strong>has emerged as a prominent developer of UAVs and drone software for military applications, having deployed over 1,000 units of its flagship Buntar One reconnaissance drone equipped with advanced AI-driven surveillance capabilities. Founded in 2023 by tech entrepreneurs Ivan Kaunov and Bohdan Sas, the company has raised $1.2m from investors including <strong>Nezlamni</strong>, and its innovative Buntar copilot system can autonomously conduct 90% of reconnaissance flight operations.</p><p><strong>Himera</strong>, a manufacturer of military communications systems, raised $550,000 from several angel investors, including members of the United Angels Network. The company’s ability to secure funding while maintaining a valuation multiple in line with Western defense tech companies suggests growing investor confidence in Ukrainian firms’ ability to generate commercial returns alongside strategic value.</p><p>The investment landscape has also been marked by the emergence of specialized funds focused on defense technology.</p><p>The <strong>Brave1 </strong>state defense cluster has awarded 344 grants totaling $8 million, while new venture funds like <strong>Resist.ua (</strong>led by former banker Roman Sulzhyk), and <strong>Freedom Fund VC</strong> (led by a prominent Ukrainian tech entrepreneur) have emerged specifically to target defense tech opportunities. This institutional development has been complemented by increased activity from international investors, with firms like <strong>Green Flag Ventures</strong> making multiple investments in Ukrainian startups over short periods.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/777/0*nMGgBELfi1dKaw9R" /><figcaption>Investors in Ukrainian defense tech (created by author using Data Driven data)</figcaption></figure><p>The ecosystem is further strengthened by specialized accelerators bridging the gap between battlefield innovation and sustainable business.</p><p><strong>Defense Builder</strong>, launched by veteran founder <strong>Kateryna Bezsudna</strong>, has pioneered a practical approach to startup development. “Almost all startups have a problem with the front-line check,” notes Bezsudna. “Without that first prototype demonstration in combat, they can’t secure funding.” The Defense Builder Accelerator program, developed in collaboration with tech companies <strong>Genesis</strong> and <strong>Sigma Software</strong>, brings together military personnel, engineers, and entrepreneurs to rapidly validate and scale promising technologies.</p><p><strong>MITS Capital</strong>, founded by a former executive at Point72 hedge fund <strong>Perry Boyle</strong>, brings sophisticated financial expertise to the sector.</p><blockquote>“Ukraine is the low cost producer of drones on the free world. I estimate that $800m on Ukrainian made drones is the equivalent of at least $2.5bn on US drones — it could be closer to $5bn,” says <strong>Boyle</strong>, highlighting the cost-effectiveness of the Ukrainian tech.</blockquote><p>Meanwhile, <strong>Dare to Defend Democracy (D3)</strong>, a $19m fund launched with backing from former Google CEO Eric Schmidt, has already built a portfolio of 14 companies.</p><p><strong>Investment landscape: deal trends and future outlook</strong></p><p>Investment activity reveals clear patterns in target segments and deal structures. <strong>Drone technology has attracted the largest share of venture funding</strong>, reflecting the sector’s rapid growth and its clear path to commercialization. Within this space, investors have shown particular interest in companies developing proprietary technology in areas such as autonomous navigation, swarm control, and electronic warfare resistance.</p><p>Deal structures have evolved to address the challenges of investing in a wartime economy. Many successful raises have involved parallel corporate structures, with intellectual property held in Western jurisdictions while development and operations remain in Ukraine. This approach has helped address investor concerns about asset protection while maintaining the operational advantages of Ukraine’s engineering talent and testing capabilities.</p><p>The emergence of <strong>consolidation opportunities</strong> is particularly noteworthy. According to industry surveys, approximately 30% of companies are interested in either buying or selling operations, suggesting significant M&amp;A activity ahead. This consolidation trend could create more substantial platforms capable of attracting larger investment rounds and strategic buyers.</p><p><strong>Valuation </strong>dynamics in Ukrainian defense tech reflect a unique combination of factors. Companies typically trade at significant discounts to Western peers — often 30–70% lower — despite demonstrating similar or superior technological capabilities. This valuation gap reflects both the perceived risks of operating in a conflict zone and the current limitations on export activities.</p><p>Looking ahead, <strong>several factors suggest accelerating investment activity in Ukraine’s defense tech sector</strong>. The combination of proven technology advantages, cost competitiveness, and growing international interest creates a compelling investment thesis. The sector’s demonstrated ability to develop and deploy sophisticated technologies at a fraction of Western costs positions it well for the increasing focus on defense modernization among NATO countries.</p><p>The emergence of more sophisticated investment structures and growing involvement of Western strategic investors suggests <strong>the sector is entering a new phase of development</strong>. While early investments were often opportunistic, <strong>future rounds are likely to be larger and more strategic</strong>, potentially including:</p><ul><li>Series A and B rounds led by international venture firms</li><li>Strategic investments from Western defense contractors</li><li>Growth equity investments in consolidated platforms (the author knows about at least one case of potential merger deal in the cybersecurity space)</li><li>Joint venture structures with NATO-country partners</li></ul><p>This evolution reflects the maturing of the sector and growing recognition of its strategic importance in the global defense technology landscape. For investors, the opportunity lies in identifying companies that can successfully navigate the transition from local innovation to global scale, leveraging Ukraine’s unique combination of technical talent, operational experience, and cost advantages.</p><p><strong>Challenges and risks: investor’s view</strong></p><p>For VCs eyeing Ukraine’s defense technology sector, the opportunity comes wrapped in layers of complexity. While the sector’s rapid technological advancement and cost advantages are compelling, a sobering array of structural, regulatory, and competitive challenges demands careful consideration. Understanding these risks — and available mitigation strategies — is crucial for developing successful investment theses in this emerging market.</p><p><strong>Risk 1: The exit conundrum</strong></p><p>Perhaps the most fundamental challenge facing investors is the limited exit landscape. Traditional VC math becomes particularly thorny in Ukraine’s defense tech sector. While typical venture investments target 5x-20x returns through exits, defense tech acquisitions historically command much lower multiples — typically 1x-2x revenue. This valuation ceiling stems from the nature of potential acquirers: major defense prime contractors themselves trade at similar modest multiples due to the cost-plus nature of defense contracting.</p><p>This dynamic creates a mathematical challenge for venture returns. As demonstrated in the hypothetical case cited by Marque Ventures, a defense tech startup generating $50m in revenue might be valued at $1bn by private investors (20x revenue) but would only command $100m (2x revenue) from a major defense contractor. The acquiring company’s own public market valuation makes paying higher multiples financially unsustainable, effectively capping exit values regardless of technology superiority.</p><p><strong>Risk 2: The export control trap</strong></p><p>Current export restrictions create a particularly vexing challenge for scaling Ukrainian defense companies. While domestic manufacturers have demonstrated capacity to produce approximately $20bn worth of equipment annually, state procurement can only absorb about $6–10 bn. This gap between capacity and addressable market fundamentally constrains growth potential.</p><p>The impact of export controls extends beyond simple market access. Without the ability to sell internationally, companies struggle to :</p><ul><li>Achieve economies of scale in production</li><li>Attract international strategic investors</li><li>Develop diverse revenue streams</li><li>Build credibility with Western defense ministries</li></ul><p>Some companies have found creative solutions. <strong>Skyeton</strong> invested €3.5m in Slovak production facilities, while <strong>DeViRo</strong> established operations in the Czech Republic. However, as one drone manufacturer notes, “This approach requires significant capital and creates operational complexity that many startups cannot manage.”</p><p><strong>Risk 3: The NATO procurement labyrinth</strong></p><p>Even if export restrictions ease, selling to NATO governments presents its own formidable challenges. Defense procurement processes in Western countries are notoriously complex, lengthy, and often politically influenced. The average timeframe from initial engagement to contract can stretch 18–24 months — an eternity for venture-backed companies managing cash burn.</p><p>Moreover, NATO procurement often requires:</p><ul><li>Extensive prior performance history</li><li>Significant balance sheet strength</li><li>Complex security clearances</li><li>Local industrial participation</li><li>Political relationships</li></ul><p>These requirements create a chicken-and-egg problem for Ukrainian startups: they need scale to win NATO contracts but need contracts to achieve scale. The result is that many promising technologies struggle to break into Western markets despite compelling cost and capability advantages.</p><p><strong>Risk 4: The competitive counterattack</strong></p><p>A growing threat comes from Western defense contractors establishing research and development operations in Ukraine. Major players like Anduril, Palantir, and Quantum Systems have already set up local service, support, training, and logistics centers. These moves threaten to erode one of the Ukrainian startups’ key advantages: rapid battlefield feedback and iteration.</p><blockquote>“You can’t even imagine how many foreign companies are already using Ukraine as a testing ground for their products,” says Alex Bornyakov, Ukraine’s deputy minister for digital transformation. “This experience we’re in right now — how to manage troops, how to manage them smarter and automatically — nobody has that.”</blockquote><p>When Western defense giants combine their substantial resources and established customer relationships with local operational presence, they can potentially outmaneuver domestic startups. Their ability to invest more heavily in product development, leverage existing sales channels, navigate complex regulations, and provide sophisticated after-sales support could leave Ukrainian companies competing solely on cost — a difficult position for long-term value creation.</p><p><strong>Risk 5: Capital market constraints</strong></p><p>The Ukrainian financial market poses its own set of challenges. The National Bank’s capital controls, while necessary for macroeconomic stability, create complications for international investors. Restrictions on equity inside Ukraine and limitations on moving capital out of the country can make standard VC investment structures difficult to implement.</p><p>These restrictions have led many companies to establish complex international corporate structures, often domiciling intellectual property and holding companies in jurisdictions like Delaware or Estonia. While functional, these arrangements create additional legal complexity and cost.</p><p><strong>Risk 6: Operational vulnerabilities</strong></p><p>Physical security remains a critical concern. Manufacturing facilities, despite distributed locations and underground placement, remain vulnerable to missile strikes. More subtle but equally concerning are threats to intellectual property and technical talent. The discovery of GPS trackers on trucks at defense enterprises highlights the ongoing risk of industrial espionage.</p><p>The human capital challenge is particularly acute. Key technical personnel may be subject to military mobilization, creating continuity risks for development programs. According to industry surveys, this concern ranks among the top three reasons companies consider relocating operations abroad.</p><p><strong>Future outlook and opportunities</strong></p><p>For venture investors surveying Ukraine’s defense technology landscape, distinguishing genuine opportunity from circumstantial enthusiasm requires both careful analysis and strategic foresight. While the sector’s rapid technological advancement and cost advantages present compelling investment possibilities, success will demand sophisticated approaches that can navigate the industry’s unique challenges while capitalizing on its structural advantages.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5AEXLbGUe1OJk4zILaXEnw.jpeg" /><figcaption>The author with Kseniia Semenova, the acting rector of Kyiv Aviation Institute, at the Defense Tech Investment Summit</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Opportunity 1: Beyond the battlefield</strong></p><p>The most promising path forward may lie not in pure military technology but in the broader dual-use space where defense innovation meets civilian applications.</p><blockquote>“The world doesn’t need as many drone companies as Ukraine has,” observes <strong>Justin Zief</strong>, founder of Green Flag Ventures. “What we need are companies that can translate battlefield innovation into broader commercial applications.”</blockquote><p>This dual-use imperative is already reshaping investment strategies. Consider <strong>Astra Nav</strong>, which recently secured venture funding for its precision positioning technology. While the company’s systems serve critical military functions, their applications span autonomous vehicles, robotics, and industrial automation. This market breadth not only provides multiple paths to value creation but also helps insulate investors from the vagaries of defense procurement cycles and export restrictions.</p><p><strong>Opportunity 2: Going global</strong></p><p>Successful investors in Ukrainian defense tech are increasingly adopting an international-first mindset. Rather than trying to retrofit domestic companies for global markets, they’re building international structures from inception. This approach, while more complex initially, creates optionality for both growth and exits. <strong>DeViRo</strong>’s establishment of operations in the Czech Republic exemplifies this strategy, demonstrating how companies can maintain their technological edge while gaining access to international markets.</p><p>The component play presents another intriguing opportunity. Rather than backing companies developing complete weapons systems — a path fraught with regulatory complexity — investors are finding success supporting developers of critical subsystems. <strong>Kara Dag</strong>’s focus on UAV signature detection rather than complete counter-drone systems shows how specialized capabilities can create significant value while facing fewer regulatory hurdles.</p><p><strong>Opportunity 3: The software advantage</strong></p><p>While hardware manufacturing in Ukraine faces significant scaling challenges, software and AI solutions offer more flexible growth paths. Battlefield management systems, autonomous control platforms, and intelligence analysis tools typically face fewer regulatory restrictions while offering higher margins and more straightforward paths to international markets. This software-first approach also aligns with global defense modernization trends, where computational advantages increasingly determine battlefield success.</p><p><strong>Opportunity 4: Smart money gets smarter</strong></p><p>The complexity of Ukraine’s defense tech sector is driving evolution in investment approaches. Traditional VC models are being adapted to the sector’s unique characteristics. Milestone-based funding, once relatively rare in VC, has become increasingly common as investors seek to manage risk while ensuring companies maintain focus on key value-creation metrics.</p><p>Consortium approaches are also gaining traction. <strong>Swarmer</strong>’s recent $2.7m raise brings together American defense technology company R-G.AI with several venture funds, creating a powerful combination of strategic and financial investors. This model helps companies navigate both technical and market development challenges while providing investors with better risk management.</p><p><strong>Opportunity 5: The consolidation play</strong></p><p>The current fragmentation of Ukraine’s defense tech sector — with over 500 drone manufacturers alone — suggests significant opportunity for consolidation. Industry surveys indicate that 30% of companies are interested in M&amp;A activities, creating possibilities for building more substantial platforms through strategic combinations. However, successful consolidation will require more than simple financial engineering. Deep technical understanding, regulatory navigation capabilities, and clear paths to international market access will determine winners in this space.</p><p><strong>Opportunity 6: Strategic partnership / cooperation over competition</strong></p><p>As Western defense contractors increase their presence in Ukraine, the competitive landscape is evolving. Rather than viewing this as a threat to domestic companies, sophisticated investors are identifying opportunities for structured partnerships. Early-stage companies can become specialized technology providers to larger platforms, participate in joint R&amp;D programs, or build complementary capabilities. This approach turns potential competition into a path for accelerated market access and technology validation.</p><p><strong>A framework for success</strong></p><p>For investors evaluating opportunities in Ukraine’s defense tech sector, certain fundamental criteria emerge.</p><ul><li><strong>Technology differentiation</strong> must be genuine and demonstrable, not merely incremental improvements on existing solutions.</li><li><strong>Market access strategies</strong> need to be realistic and well-planned, with clear paths to international customers.</li><li><strong>Teams </strong>require a rare combination of technical excellence, operational experience, and international business development capabilities.</li><li><strong>Financial profiles </strong>matter more than ever. In a sector where traditional venture exit paths face significant constraints, companies must demonstrate clear paths to sustainable unit economics and multiple potential revenue streams.</li><li><strong>Capital efficiency </strong>becomes crucial given the longer timelines often required for defense tech development and market access.</li></ul><p><strong>The long view</strong></p><p>Success in Ukrainian defense tech investment will require patience, sophistication, and active involvement. Development cycles typically stretch 12–18 months, regulatory approvals can consume another year, and international market access development often requires two years or more. Exit processes may demand several years of careful preparation.</p><p>Yet for investors who can execute thoughtful strategies while maintaining realistic expectations about timelines and exit possibilities, the sector offers genuine opportunities for value creation. The key lies in remaining selective, maintaining discipline in diligence and structuring, and focusing on opportunities with multiple paths to value creation rather than being swayed by short-term enthusiasm.</p><p>Ukraine’s defense technology sector stands at a crucial inflection point. Those who can navigate its complexities while leveraging its unique advantages — battle-tested innovation, cost-effective development, and deep technical talent — may find significant opportunities amid the challenges. The winners will likely be those who combine strategic patience with tactical agility, building companies that can succeed not just in today’s conflict environment but in tomorrow’s global defense technology marketplace.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8fe7275c123a" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/included-vc/engineering-under-fire-investment-opportunities-in-ukraines-defense-tech-sector-8fe7275c123a">Engineering under Fire: Investment Opportunities in Ukraine’s Defense Tech Sector</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/included-vc">Included VC</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Как в Киеве будет работать система видеонаблюдения с распознаванием лиц]]></title>
            <link>https://brodetskyi.medium.com/kyiv-surveillance-system-74f83ceb8737?source=rss-f421a4757f26------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/74f83ceb8737</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[surveillance]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[kiev]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[security]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Andrii Brodetskyi]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 24 Oct 2017 07:38:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-10-24T11:20:48.194Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Недавно я узнал, что городские власти установили в Киеве 5000 камер наблюдения, в том числе с опцией распознавания лиц. Я поговорил о проекте с директором IT-департамента КГГА Юрием Назаровым и узнал некоторые интересные подробности.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FCEVjJT9h6rQ%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DCEVjJT9h6rQ&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FCEVjJT9h6rQ%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/9097e99227811e34ffdb42b2818c087d/href">https://medium.com/media/9097e99227811e34ffdb42b2818c087d/href</a></iframe><p>Как рассказал Назаров, сейчас в Киеве установлены 5000 камер наблюдения, в планах — подключить ещё 3000. На двух станциях метро (Золотые ворота и Вокзальная) работают камеры с детекцией лиц. До конца года таких камер будет 300. Ими планируют оборудовать все станции метро и Центральный железнодорожный вокзал.</p><p>Одна камера может фиксировать до 32 лиц в секунду. Она находит в кадре лицо и отправляет данные о нём в облако, где система видеоаналитики сравнивает метаданные лиц с теми, что есть в базе.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*c8GDtFZqy2K242uMDra00g.jpeg" /></figure><p>Сейчас в базе более 100 тысяч преступников из розыска Национальной полиции. Ожидается, что позже база будет содержать также фотографии пропавших без вести людей.</p><p>Тестирование системы показало точность распознавания лиц в 95–98%. Камеры тестировали три месяца. За это время были успешные кейсы: к примеру, с помощью камеры с метро Вокзальной полиция нашла преступника, который был в розыске 15 лет. Данные с камер были использованы в качестве доказательств в 30 уголовных делах. Благодаря камерам наблюдения полиция раскрыла резонансное <a href="https://strana.ua/news/100042-vse-chto-izvestno-o-pokhishchenii-devochki-u-detsada-na-oboloni-v-kieve.html">похищение</a> ребенка из детсада менее чем за сутки.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*HZnmmfUe7eMPqNpUl_1wdQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Видео с камер пишется в Full HD. Сейчас записи хранятся на сервере три месяца. Записи с мест массового скопления людей будут храниться до года, с менее приоритетных мест — неделю. Метаданные обнаруженных лиц и номеров хранятся год.</p><p>Доступ к системе имеют правоохранительные органы и спецслужбы: МВД, СБУ, Нацгвардия. Кроме того, доступ к камерам в местах массового скопления людей имеют районные администрации, Киевавтодор и Киевдорсервис.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*FoOpvpx-TGEaHeEbMaE0Ng.png" /><figcaption>Из презентации проекта</figcaption></figure><p>Производитель системы — китайская компания <a href="http://www.hikvision.com/en/">Hikvision</a>. Составляющие системы — cloud-платформа, обрабатывающая стримы (максимальная загрузка — 11 000 камер), система видеоаналитики, хранилище данных на 3,36 петабайта, 4000 камер наблюдения Hikvision и 1000 — Huawei.</p><p>Затраты на реализацию проекта на данный момент составили около 120 миллионов гривен (~$4,5 млн).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*rW8DWWBC3CfrsqOEDNuozQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Кроме того, в Киеве с января работают камеры наблюдения за транспортной системой города. За это время они зафиксировали более 300 ДТП. Камеры распознают номерные знаки (что позволяет полиции находить угнанные машины) и собственно автомобили (что позволяет городским службам моделировать транспортные потоки). В основном такие камеры расположены на мостах и в центре, а до конца года появятся на 46 въездах-выездах из города. Это позволит контролировать транзит автомобилей через Киев. Камеры могут распознавать габариты машин, замерять скорость движения, фиксировать нарушение правил парковки. Ещё одно направление видеонаблюдения — охрана памятников (фиксация действий вандалов).</p><p>Наблюдение с распознаванием лиц — обычное дело в мировых мегаполисах. В сентябре московские власти <a href="https://www.mos.ru/news/item/30105073/">подключили</a> к системе наблюдения 160 000 камер. В 3000 из них используется технология распознавания лиц российской компании Ntech.lab, известной своим нашумевшим приложением FindFace. В Китае система распознавания лиц помогла полиции <a href="http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-4851564/Facial-recognition-detects-criminals-beer-festival.html">задержать</a> 25 разыскиваемых преступников на ежегодном фестивале пива в Циндао. Одним из самых просматриваемых городов мира считается Лондон — там <a href="https://www.cctv.co.uk/how-many-cctv-cameras-are-there-in-london/">установлены</a> 500 000 камер наблюдения.</p><p>Об этих и других технологиях я пишу <a href="https://t.me/brodetsky">в своём блоге в Telegram</a>. Подписывайтесь, и вы узнаете:</p><ul><li><a href="https://t.me/brodetsky/634">как в Балтиморе для безопасности записывают всё происходящее на улицах с помощью аэросъемки</a></li><li><a href="https://t.me/brodetsky/954">как работает внушающая система распознавания людей в Китае</a></li><li><a href="https://t.me/brodetsky/956">зачем в Китае установили камеры с распознаванием лиц в туалетах</a></li><li><a href="https://t.me/brodetsky/934">почему кепка и очки не помогут вам скрыться от умной системы наблюдения</a></li><li><a href="https://t.me/brodetsky/802">как распознавание лиц используют для таргетирования рекламы</a></li></ul><p>А также много интересного про искусственный интеллект, нейросети, роботов, криптовалюты и приватность. И подписывайтесь на меня <a href="https://www.facebook.com/andriy.brodetsky">в Facebook</a> — там тоже интересно.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=74f83ceb8737" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Каталог украинских каналов в Telegram]]></title>
            <link>https://brodetskyi.medium.com/ukrainian-telegram-channels-rating-cfd9f1ceb49?source=rss-f421a4757f26------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/cfd9f1ceb49</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[telegram]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Andrii Brodetskyi]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 18 Oct 2017 17:19:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-10-18T17:19:58.729Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Привет, меня зовут Андрей Бродецкий, я журналист и автор самого популярного украинского блога в Telegram. Для популяризации Telegram в Украине я составил этот рейтинг. Если я что-то пропустил, пишите <a href="http://t.me/politehnik">мне</a>. И <a href="https://www.facebook.com/andriy.brodetsky">добавляйтесь в Facebook</a>.</p><p><a href="http://medialab.online/news/ya-zareyestruvavsya-u-telegram-shho-dali/">Конспект моего выступления на Львовском медиафоруме: “Зачем вам Telegram-канал и как его вести”</a> (+<a href="https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1HfuxU3hEHcWNBA7IMyg4OD7ThTIIOD6TNGnnh6tJCqY/edit#slide=id.p">презентация</a>)</p><p><strong>Авторские и профессиональные каналы</strong></p><p>Андрей Бродецкий, <a href="https://t.me/joinchat/AAAAAD0Ss9qV77WGml_baA">Технологии, медиа и общество</a> (28100 подписчиков)</p><p>Блог о технологиях и их влиянии на общество. Самый популярный канал в украинском Telegram. Я веду ещё один, <a href="https://t.me/brodetsky_2">личный канал</a> с интересными ссылками.</p><p>Виталий Волочай, <a href="https://t.me/v1latfans">На хате у Вилата</a> (14400 подписчиков)</p><p>Блог популярного комментатора киберигр</p><p>Наташа Шелягина, <a href="https://t.me/muzkultura">Музкультура</a> (12700 подписчиков)</p><p>Популярный видеоблогер и обозреватель гаджетов делится понравившейся музыкой</p><p>Михаил Сапитон, <a href="https://t.me/sapiton">Booker</a> (8900 подписчиков)</p><p>Блог о книгах</p><p>Кира Еремина, <a href="https://t.me/kiraeremina">Кираджан</a> (8100 подписчиков)</p><p>Личный блог популярного твиттер-блогера про жизнь и отношения</p><p>Денис Довгополый, <a href="https://t.me/DDlinks">DDlinks</a> (3000 подписчиков)</p><p>Ссылки о стартапах и бизнесе</p><p>Сергей Сурепин, <a href="https://t.me/gamer">Геймер</a> (2400 подписчиков)</p><p>“Твой гид по миру видеоигр”</p><p>Олег Цегельник, <a href="https://t.me/apps4life">Apps4Life</a> (2300 подписчиков)</p><p>Полезные приложения для iPhone и iPad</p><p>Денис Судилковский, <a href="https://t.me/product_design">Лавка Продуктового Дизайна</a> (2300 подписчиков)</p><p>Блог о продуктовом дизайне</p><p>Владислав Рашкован и ко., <a href="https://t.me/SixArticlesToRead">#SixArticlesToRead</a> (2100 подписчиков)</p><p>Статьи про финтех, менеджмент, экономику, международную политику</p><p>Артур Оруджалиев, <a href="https://t.me/arturclancy">Канал без названия</a> (2000 подписчиков)</p><p>Личная продуктивность, бизнес, полезные сервисы, статьи и книги</p><p>Александра Рынк, <a href="https://t.me/comixology">Основы комиксологии</a>, (1900 подписчиков)</p><p>Алексей Осипенко, <a href="https://t.me/itextrapolation">Экстраполяция IT</a> (1800 подписчиков)</p><p>Блог об IT и программировании</p><p>Дарья Т, <a href="https://t.me/nenormalnie">Сами вы ненормальные</a> (1500 подписчиков)</p><p>Необычные факты об убийцах, психопатах, преступниках</p><p>Вика Прудник, <a href="https://t.me/lectur">Лекции в коллекцию</a> (1400 подписчиков)</p><p>Лекции, интервью с учёными и прочие умняки</p><p>Ольга Кудиненко, <a href="https://t.me/olyabooks">Оля и её библиотека</a> (1200 подписчиков)</p><p>Основатель фонда Таблеточки пишет о прочитанных книгах</p><p>Павел Грозян, <a href="https://t.me/californian_designer">Грозян</a> (1200 подписчиков)</p><p>Жизнь украинского дизайнера в Сан-Франциско</p><p>Ігор Стефурак, <a href="https://t.me/startupcontent">Startup Level</a>, (1200 подписчиков)</p><p>Ссылки о стартапах</p><p>Оксана Павленко, <a href="https://t.me/lovetoeat">Еда и сериалы</a> (1200 подписчиков)</p><p>Блог главного редактора The Devochki</p><p>Влад Гаращенко, <a href="https://t.me/traveltown">Города мира</a> (1080 подписчиков)</p><p>Блог о путешествиях по разным странам и городам мира</p><p><a href="https://t.me/telegrafdesign">Telegraf.design</a> (1000 подписчиков)</p><p>Журнал об украинском и мировом дизайне</p><p>Сергей Мартыненко, Саша Белова, <a href="https://t.me/beard_corn">Beard&amp;Corn 🌽- 🌏travel</a> (1000 подписчиков)</p><p>Канал о путешествиях одной пары</p><p>Александр Дубинский, <a href="https://t.me/dubinskypro">Dubinsky.pro</a> (970 подписчиков)</p><p>Политота от ведущего программы “Гроші”</p><p>Евгений Белошицкий, <a href="https://t.me/indielance">Indielance | Фриланс-обозрение</a> (960 подписчиков)</p><p>Новости из мира фриланса</p><p>Алексей Бондаренко, <a href="https://t.me/musicgeek">Музыкальный гик</a> (900 подписчиков)</p><p>Блог главного редактора LiRoom</p><p>Сергей Лямец, <a href="https://t.me/politicusvulgaris">Politicus Vulgaris</a> (900 подписчиков)</p><p>Главный редактор издания Realist шутит об украинской политике</p><p>Сергей Кейн, <a href="https://t.me/sergeycanemusic">Лента Кейна</a> (850 подписчиков)</p><p>Блог главного редактора Comma о музыке</p><p>Владислав Волочай, <a href="https://t.me/krutoznavstvo">Крутознавство</a> (720 подписчиков)</p><p>Рассылка про крутые и красивые штуки (в основном про дизайн)</p><p>Юрий Береза, <a href="https://t.me/bbttjj">Березовый сок</a> (720 подписчиков)</p><p>Блог о музыке редактора Karabas.live</p><p>Роман Шрайк, <a href="https://t.me/ShrikeReview">Рецензии от Шрайка</a> (650 подписчиков)</p><p>Коротко о посмотренных фильмах и сериалах</p><p>Никита и Даша Южаковы, <a href="https://t.me/mygdetozdes">Мы где-то здесь</a> (570 подписчиков)</p><p>“Никита и Даша едут в кругосветку и хотят рассказать, как людям живётся на нашей планете”</p><p>Сергей Петренко, <a href="https://t.me/blognot">БлоGnot</a> (510 подписчиков)</p><p>Блог бывшего директора Яндекс.Украина</p><p>Радмила Сегол, <a href="https://t.me/tvdoc">TV Doc</a> (500 подписчиков)</p><p>Преподаватель КПИ пишет о сериалах</p><p>Андрей Федив, <a href="https://t.me/ikpyto">Крутой Канал Kpyto</a> (480 подписчиков)</p><p>Футуризм, IT, гаджеты, популярная наука</p><p>Максим Загоруйко, <a href="https://t.me/laowhy">Дневник лаовая</a> (440 подписчиков)</p><p>Блог о жизни и учебе в Китае</p><p>Ксения Ляшко, <a href="https://t.me/ksuserial">Ксюша и её сериалы🍷</a>(440 подписчиков)</p><p>Блог о сериалах</p><p>Дмитрий Столяренко, <a href="https://t.me/phaeton_gls">Мысли и панчи</a> (380 подписчиков)</p><p>Блог о философии, педагогике и литературе</p><p>Евгений Короткий, <a href="https://t.me/edutek">Education &amp; Technology</a> (380 подписчиков)</p><p>Преподаватель КПИ пишет о науке, технологиях и образовании</p><p>Юрий Поворозник, <a href="https://t.me/pop_culture">Метафизика поп-культуры</a> (380 подписчиков)</p><p>Блог о поп-культуре</p><p>Юрий Рочняк, <a href="https://t.me/catops">CatOps</a> (300 подписчиков)</p><p>Блог про DevOps</p><p>Александр Беленко, <a href="https://t.me/kyivbeer">Киевский пивной балдёж</a> (300 подписчиков)</p><p>Про пиво и пабы Киева</p><p>Богдан Мифтахов, <a href="https://t.me/bogdandevisu">Глазами Богдана</a> (300 подписчиков)</p><p>Молодой украинский журналист пишет о жизни в Берлине и политике</p><p>Марина Мойнихан, <a href="https://t.me/cemetery_partisan">Cemetery partisan</a> (300 подписчиков)</p><p>“Фолк-хоррор, бульварная крипота, странные обскурные фильмы, литература беспокойного присутствия, книжки за $0.99 и шутки за 300”</p><p>Геннадий Новиков, <a href="https://t.me/pioupiou">Пиу-пиу</a> (280 подписчиков)</p><p>Блог основателя КПИ live. Жизнь университета, низовые инициативы, интересные ссылки</p><p>Елизавета Илюсенко, <a href="https://t.me/aboutvideo">About video</a> (280 подписчиков)</p><p>Канал о видео и видеопродакшне</p><p>Наташа Гречушкина, <a href="https://t.me/unicorn_daughters">Unicorn daughters</a> (270 подписчиков)</p><p>Блог о феминизме</p><p>Артем Рисухин, <a href="https://t.me/mr_connolly">Почему я люблю Фрэнка Заппу?</a> (250 подписчиков)</p><p>Музыка и интересные статьи о музыке</p><p>Назар Шешуряк, <a href="https://t.me/hyperthelia">Гіпертелія</a> (230 подписчиков)</p><p>“Українські хтонічні ініціативи. Підпільне мистецтво, аутсайдерські розваги, діу-культура, таємні архіви і запах часу.”</p><p>Юрий Шевченко, <a href="https://t.me/GianlucaLapadula">ДжанлукаЛападула</a> (200 подписчиков)</p><p>Только итальянский футбол</p><p>Ярослав Зорка, <a href="https://t.me/austriakanal">Der Kanal</a> (200 подписчиков)</p><p>Блог украинца о жизни в Австрии</p><p>Максим Комлев, <a href="https://t.me/lvhtg">Без лишних слов</a> (200 подписчиков)</p><p>Новая музыка и новости музыки</p><p>Александр Ткач, <a href="https://t.me/oiteag">Ткач</a> (160 подписчиков)</p><p>Интересные статьи</p><p>Богдан Будзинский, <a href="https://t.me/budz1k">Канал без названия</a> (150 подписчиков)</p><p>Блог про историю войн и флота</p><p>Михаил Кашкин, <a href="https://t.me/cpfeed">Cyberpunk news</a> (140 подписчиков)</p><p>Киберпанк вокруг нас</p><p>Лев Шевченко, <a href="https://t.me/iroboship">Я, робот и электроовцы</a> (120 подписчиков)</p><p>Новости фантастической литературы, игр, кино. Обзоры, авторские статьи, арты и видеоролики.</p><p>Антон Сененко, <a href="https://t.me/mouselab">Лабораторна миша</a> (100 подписчиков)</p><p>Канал про науку, науково-популярні заходи, реформування наукової сфери України, цікаві розумні статті про розумних людей та їх роботу</p><p><strong>Компании и сервисы</strong></p><p><a href="https://t.me/correctarium_channel">📢 Correctarium</a> (4500 подписчиков)</p><p>Ежедневные советы о правописании русского и английского</p><p><a href="https://t.me/tripmydream">TripMyDream</a> (1600 подписчиков)</p><p>Поиск дешевых билетов, новости и статьи для путешественников</p><p><a href="https://t.me/prometheusmooc">Prometheus</a> (1100 подписчиков)</p><p>Безкоштовний онлайн-доступ до найкращих навчальних курсів університетського рівня всім охочим в Україні</p><p><a href="https://t.me/correctariumukr">Корректаріум</a> (1000 подписчиков)</p><p>Щоденні поради з української мови</p><p><a href="http://t.me/fast_fast_fast">Act Fast</a> (900 подписчиков)</p><p>Блог о том, как правильно предоставлять первую помощь</p><p><a href="https://t.me/datarootlabs">Dataroot Labs</a> (440 подписчиков)</p><p>Статьи и курсы по data science</p><p><strong>Вакансии, стажировки, скидки</strong></p><p><a href="http://t.me/veter_doit">Ветер дует</a> (15500 подписчиков)</p><p>Дешевые туры и перелеты. Ведёт Алена Деньга.</p><p><a href="https://t.me/TimeToTravel">Time To Travel</a> (4500 подписчиков)</p><p>Дешевые туры и перелеты. Ведёт Александр Радченко.</p><p><a href="https://t.me/tripmix">Путешествуй дешево</a> (2200 подписчиков)</p><p>Дешевые туры и перелеты</p><p><a href="https://t.me/lowcostua">Lowcost UA</a> (1500 подписчиков)</p><p>Акції авіакомпаній, знижки на автобуси, гарячі тури</p><p><a href="https://t.me/junior_dou_ua">Junior дайджест dou.ua</a> (8100 подписчиков)</p><p>Вакансии и стажировки для начинающих разработчиков</p><p><a href="https://t.me/djinni_relocate">Трактор на Джинне</a> (3600 подписчиков)</p><p>Вакансии для программистов с релокейтом в Европу и США</p><p><a href="https://t.me/dou_relocate">Трактор на DOU</a> (3500 подписчиков)</p><p>Все по теме релокации для программистов</p><p><a href="https://t.me/prjctr">Projector</a> (2900 подписчиков)</p><p>Вакансии, статьи и новости для дизайнеров</p><p><a href="https://t.me/dna325">NON-tech Jobs in IT</a> (2000 подписчиков)</p><p>Нетехнические IT-вакансии в Украине и relocate: management, marketing, PR, PM, product, sales etc</p><p><a href="https://t.me/zaichenkoteam">Zaichenko Team</a> (1700 подписчиков)</p><p>Вакансии и предложения по работе для дизайнеров, маркетологов, программистов</p><p><a href="https://t.me/afishakieva">Афиша Киева</a> (1500 подписчиков)</p><p>Новости Киева, анонсы интересных событий</p><p><a href="https://t.me/studwaydiem">Studway DIEM</a> (1400 подписчиков)</p><p>Возможности для молодежи: вакансии, стажировки, гранты, стипендии, программы</p><p><a href="https://t.me/UAITEvents">UA IT Events</a> (1000 подписчиков)</p><p>Анонсы, скидки, билеты на IT-мероприятия в Украине. Ведёт Денис Довгополый.</p><p><a href="https://t.me/kitdigest">KIT Digest</a> (300 подписчиков)</p><p>Вакансии и ивенты для начинающих ITшников (Одесса)</p><p><a href="https://t.me/ikrus">Krus</a> (400 подписчиков)</p><p>Новости, анонсы событий, бесплатные билеты на вечеринки</p><p><strong>Сообщества и организации</strong></p><p><a href="https://t.me/kpilive">КПИ live</a> (7500 подписчиков)</p><p>Самое большое университетское сообщество в русскоязычном Telegram</p><p><a href="https://t.me/KyivOperativ">Киев Оперативный</a> (5400 подписчиков)</p><p>ДТП, ЧП, преступления в Киеве</p><p><a href="https://t.me/typical_kiev">Типичный Киев</a> (4500 подписчиков)</p><p>Telegram-представительство самого популярного киевского паблика</p><p><a href="https://t.me/chankpi">КПИ чан</a> (4200 подписчиков)</p><p>Мемы про КПИ</p><p><a href="https://t.me/autokiev">Киев Автомобильный</a> (2300 подписчиков)</p><p>Новости и происшествия на дорогах Киева</p><p><a href="https://t.me/ukrnastup">Український наступ</a> (1700 подписчиков)</p><p>Патриотические новости и мемы</p><p><a href="https://t.me/dtpkievua">DTP.kiev.ua</a> (1660 подписчиков)</p><p>ДТП и происшествия в Киеве</p><p><a href="https://t.me/itkpi">IT KPI</a> (1500 подписчиков)</p><p>Сообщество IT-шников КПИ</p><p><a href="https://t.me/nationalcorps">Національний корпус</a> (1300 подписчиков)</p><p>Новости Национального корпуса (“Азов”)</p><p><a href="https://t.me/kpitv">KPI TV</a> (760 подписчиков)</p><p>Студенческое телевидение КПИ</p><p><a href="https://t.me/Your_TURN">True UA Resistance News</a> (700 подписчиков)</p><p>Сообщество украинских игроков в Ingress</p><p><a href="https://t.me/leport">Leport</a> (470 подписчиков)</p><p>Литературная платформа</p><p><a href="https://t.me/dncuug">.NET Core Ukrainian User Group</a> (350 подписчиков)</p><p>Сообщество украинских разработчиков .NET Core</p><p><strong>Интересные медиапроекты</strong></p><p><a href="https://t.me/alphacentaurichannel">Alpha Centauri</a> (1890 подписчиков)</p><p>Проект о космосе</p><p><a href="https://t.me/wasmedia">WAS</a> (1300 подписчиков)</p><p>Журнал потрясающих историй</p><p><a href="https://t.me/BifMagRu">BirdInFlight</a> (470 подписчиков)</p><p>Интернет-журнал о фотографии и визуальной культуре</p><p><strong>Маркетинг, веб-аналитика, контекстная реклама</strong></p><p>Алена Деньга, Евгений Зингер: <a href="https://t.me/digital_masons">Тайное общество digital-масонов</a> (6800 подписчиков)</p><p>Блог для сотрудников digital-отрасли</p><p>Сергей Аликсюк, <a href="https://t.me/imarketingua">I-Marketing.ua</a> (3700 подписчиков)</p><p><a href="https://t.me/schoolWA">Школа веб-аналитики Осипова</a> (3700 подписчиков)</p><p>Новинки, кейсы, решения в веб-аналитике</p><p>Татьяна Михальченко, <a href="https://t.me/ppc_analytics">Контекстная реклама. PPC. Analytics. AdWords</a> (3000 подписчиков)</p><p>Евгения Аликсюк, <a href="https://t.me/webmagic">Webmagic</a> (2500 подписчиков)</p><p>Ссылки и статьи по контекстной рекламе</p><p>MMR 📖 (1700 подписчиков)</p><p>Колонки, аналитика, статьи о маркетинге и PR</p><p>Алексей Канслер, <a href="https://t.me/instagramGO">Instagram. Полезные ссылки, приложения, интересные аккаунты</a> (1200 подписчиков)</p><p>Евгений Шевченко, <a href="https://t.me/DMMlinks">Digital Marketing Management</a>, (1100 подписчиков)</p><p>Роман Рыбальченко, <a href="https://t.me/marketing_roman">Продуктивный Роман</a> (1000 подписчиков)</p><p>Веб-аналитика, email-маркетинг, PPC реклама, продуктивность</p><p>Елена Федоровская, <a href="https://t.me/DigitalPuzzle">Digital Puzzle</a> (400 подписчиков)</p><p>Инструменты интернет-рекламы: таргетированная реклама, социальные сети, email маркетинг. Кейсы, обзоры.</p><p>Дмитрий Осиюк, <a href="https://t.me/webanalyst">WebAnalytics</a> (360 подписчиков)</p><p>Интересное из мира веб-аналитики. Автор — веб-аналитик в digital-агентстве UAMASTER.</p><p>Евгений Стругацкий, <a href="https://t.me/marketingforbiggest">B2B-маркетинг</a> (260 подписчиков)</p><p>Бортовой журнал B2B-маркетолога</p><p><a href="http://telegra.ph/ukrainian-media-telegram-rating-05-25"><strong>Каналы СМИ — в отдельном рейтинге</strong></a><strong> (он давно не обновлялся)</strong>.</p><p>Если я пропустил какой-то канал — пишите <a href="http://t.me/politehnik">мне</a>. Каналы с несколькими десятками подписчиков и каналы, которые не обновляются месяцами, сюда не попадают.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*EXqQHBxtsKkLn-7b.jpg" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=cfd9f1ceb49" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>