<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Brooke McArdle on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Brooke McArdle on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@brookemcardle1?source=rss-426d68a66a58------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 07:41:38 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@brookemcardle1/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Moving Forward Together]]></title>
            <link>https://brookemcardle1.medium.com/moving-forward-together-9820223f1f2d?source=rss-426d68a66a58------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9820223f1f2d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[liberal-arts]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marquette-university]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[higher-education]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Brooke McArdle]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2020 22:33:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-11-20T22:33:32.851Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*UOtuKoybp-3YdytwSFElJg.jpeg" /><figcaption>The sunset from Joan of Arc chapel 11/19/2020.</figcaption></figure><p>If my experiences this semester have taught me anything, I have learned how a mounting burden is often invisible until it is finally taken away. I imagine this is how Atlas would have felt with the world having been removed from his shoulders. My case has been overturned and my record wiped clean.</p><p>As the tears roll down my face, I realize that I, in fact, was not bearing this weight alone. Every step, God was with me. The Blessed Mother was with me. My patron saint, Lucy, was with me.</p><p>Perhaps the more visible forms of solidarity were the students, faculty, staff, and community members who stood by me. I cannot possibly name everyone here but I’ll try:</p><p>My parents, who cried with me and supported me. My friends, who reminded me to eat, to try to sleep, and provided so much emotional support. Faculty and staff, many of whom reached out to me individually to convey solidarity and support. I am forever indebted to those who often called and texted me to check up on me. The community members, particularly alumni, who reached out and worked closely with me. Those even from other universities who took up this fight with me. I’m sure I’m unintentionally missing others.</p><p>I cannot even express my gratitude eloquently enough.</p><p>As I once learned, it is not proper to think we can ever “move on” from situations. Our lives do not exist in a vacuum, but end up being an amalgamation of everything that has happened to us.</p><p><strong>Therefore, I will not move on. I will move forward.</strong></p><p>I will choose to remember <strong>my </strong>Marquette. I will carry with me my friends, professors, and the experiences that have shaped me to be who I am now. I have triumphed and I am charged and gifted with the responsibility to approach every obstacle and problem with the grace and insight I have gained from my three and a half years here.</p><p>I will move forward with renewed hope and faith in my values and in who I am as a person. I will remain committed to these values and I gain reassurance in the core of my being, though I know this should never falter. It is best conveyed in Latin: <em>alis volat propriis. </em>She flies with her own wings.</p><p>In this life, I am called to be a steward and a woman for others. I cannot imagine living out this call any differently than I have the past few weeks and I continue to allow these principles guide my life.</p><p>As I walked on campus last night, the sunset cast a pink glow over the blue Milwaukee sky. Its beauty struck me and I, looking at the picture now, realize that the sun is setting on my time at Marquette.</p><p>It has been a privilege to attend <strong>my </strong>Marquette. My heart is made full from all of the incredible people I have met during my time here. I could not be prouder of everything I have accomplished.</p><p>As I finish my semester, I hope and strive to make my parents, professors, friends, family, and community as proud as I am able. I am excited to open a new chapter in my life. I am excited to move forward.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9820223f1f2d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Be the Difference: A Marquette Myth]]></title>
            <link>https://brookemcardle1.medium.com/be-the-difference-a-marquette-myth-a32096e05b0a?source=rss-426d68a66a58------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a32096e05b0a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[higher-education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marquette-university]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Brooke McArdle]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 12 Nov 2020 21:25:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-11-13T00:17:16.909Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Responsible.</p><p>This is the adjective used to describe my culpability in two student conduct violations: <a href="https://brookemcardle1.medium.com/sanctions-and-suppression-c18ea695b0af">failure to present identification and violation of published policies.</a> For some reason, the choice of this adjective stings more than using “guilty.” Guilty accounts for due process and the concept of innocent until proven guilty. Responsible indicates that the decision was made before the hearing even began.</p><p>Somehow I was deceived by this institution. For two years I soldiered on at this university, believing I was more than a number and thinking I was valued. In my junior year, I received a glimpse of such devaluation and three months into my final semester at Marquette University, I feel as though administrative autocracy, resentment, and apathy have engulfed me at every angle.</p><p>I graduate in four weeks from a university that has recently worked hard to suppress me. Despite outrage from students, faculty, staff, and community members, Marquette has stayed the course.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*nwzdQ5n9SaZxS6mNVujoXQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>The day I committed to Marquette University, standing in front of the Joan of Arc chapel.</figcaption></figure><p>At the hearing, the two administrators reassured me that the conduct process was supposed to be educational.</p><h3>It is clear that for me alone, this process is retributive and punitive.</h3><p>In the decision letter, the administrators wrote that the hearing was “needed to answer… [my] personal responsibility” concerning the violations. However, I was assured that the administrators would take into account several factors:</p><blockquote><strong>Nature and gravity of the incident</strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>The motivation underlying the behavior</strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>My disciplinary history</strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>Precedent in similar cases</strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>Developmental and educational impact of this incident and any hoped for lessons from an assigned outcome.</strong></blockquote><p>Despite the fact that I was assured these would be taken into account, they were not. These violations were for technicalities and formalities — clearly not grave in nature. I have no disciplinary history, my disciplinary and academic records are spotless. Students who have held similar demonstrations have not been charged, therefore these sanctions demonstrate the arbitrary and thus <strong>unprecedented </strong>enforcement of the policy.</p><p>The administrators said it was my responsibility to have the student conduct code memorized, which is partly why I am being charged with the violations. No one on this campus has that thirty point conduct code memorized… I asked administrators where in the conduct handbook this was and they could not even tell me where these stipulations were, essentially enabling and directly causing the subsequent violations.</p><p>Perhaps the most ironic part of this outcome is that clearly the administrators ignored the requirement for them to take into account my motivation. This institution advertises Marquette students to “be the difference,” “be men and women for others,” etc. And yet, when I stand up for the core of Jesuit values — academic excellence, serving others, and <em>cura personalis </em>— I am found to be in violation of the conduct code.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CB8NHpu6JT6hY1Es-gqWhQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>In front of Joan of Arc chapel during my junior year.</figcaption></figure><p>The only thing I have violated is Marquette’s pomposity and callousness.</p><h3>I have actively voiced dissent against administrative evisceration of Jesuit values and pedagogy on this campus. In situations like these, where Marquette administration cannot positively spin a story and gain public praise, they expect students to “be the <strong>indifference.</strong>” They want us to stay silent while they destroy everything this university stands for.</h3><p>My punishments for my “inappropriate behavior” are as follows:</p><blockquote>A copy of the letter will be placed in my file and may be taken into consideration if I engage in further inappropriate behavior.</blockquote><blockquote>I am to write a 7 page essay. The essay must accomplish two things. First I must review existing demonstration/protest policies at similar institutions, considering both schools with Jesuit backgrounds and other private universities that are similar to Marquette in size. After reviewing and researching these policies, I must suggest the adjustments I believe that Marquette could make to improve their own demonstration policy. Second, I must explain how I think violations of the demonstration policy should be applied in the future.</blockquote><blockquote>Failure to fulfill any one of these outcomes… will result in your being placed on <strong>University Probation</strong>.</blockquote><p>These punishments exclude me from further participating in demonstrations against Marquette’s administration in the future. They also ask me to do their work for them. I am four weeks from graduating. I have exams to worry about, a thesis to write, and a job. I should not have to be concerned with fixing Marquette’s demonstration policy by compiling <em>comparanda </em>from other universities.</p><p>On November 10th, I participated in a “Coffee Chat” with Provost Ah Yun. A hundred other faculty, staff, and students were present. When Ah Yun called on me to speak, I began presenting IPEDS data about Marquette’s percentage of total expenses spent on instruction.</p><p>Ah Yun proceeded to interrupt me and tell me I was wrong, shutting me down and continuing on to the next question. When others present in the meeting expressed outrage, he let me speak.</p><p>I asked him to stop infantilizing me and others who were voicing opinions in the meeting. I told him that I pay fifty thousand dollars a year to attend this university and that I wanted transparency and a voice. I embarrassed him in front of his colleagues and members of the Marquette community. Two days later, I received these harsh punishment for two technicalities.</p><h3>There is no doubt in my mind that upper administration advocated for and forced these sanctions and harsh punishments.</h3><p>Amidst this outrageous behavior on behalf of Marquette administration, my education has reminded me that I am not the first to be martyred for their values.</p><p>I think of Antigone and her desire to give her brother a proper burial, a decision which she paid for with her life. Antigone was steadfast in her values and Creon was confident in his unyielding commitment to absolute legality. Antigone’s fidelity is viewed in opposition to the advancement of the state, rather than in conjunction with it.</p><p>My pursuit of and commitment to Jesuit values, and consequently to the future of diversity initiatives and futures of my professors and students at Marquette, are in opposition only to the ill-conceived and despotic plan for this institution.</p><p>Like Antigone, my actions were born from filial piety owed to those who have significantly impacted my academic and personal futures.</p><p>I think of Socrates, whose commitment to virtue and bettering those around him resulted in his death. It is from Socrates that I have learned to question unashamedly and to dissent when administrative plans and decisions are incongruent with the values that anchor the institution.</p><p>Like Antigone and Socrates, I will admit that I am culpable of only seeking truth and virtue and acting out of fidelity and staunch commitment to the values the professors and staff of this university have been tasked with instilling in me.</p><p>I will be punished for misbehavior. But my behavior is only inappropriate to those who wish to suppress freedom of speech and opposition.</p><p>I will leave this university disillusioned but I will not stop fighting. I will continue to fight for those who the administration is trying to steam roll in order to cover its own fiscal mishandling. I will fight for the future of this institution, because those entrusted with this task have refused that responsibility and instead preferred to be silent and act only when it advances their checkbook.</p><p>But I, along with so many others, will engage in the hard and gritty work, the work that keeps me up at night burning the midnight oil. This is the work of a Jesuit-educated student. This is the work of a steward. This is the work of being a woman for others. This is the work of <em>cura personalis.</em></p><p>I need not compare myself to Joan of Arc, the Catholic martyr to whom the chapel located at the center of this campus is dedicated, for her presence speaks loud and clear. A martyr for Catholic and Jesuit values is at the literal and physical center of this campus.</p><p>I stand with her.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*82B0yKCtubjX1FxTWvU35w.jpeg" /><figcaption>Me recently in front of the chapel.</figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a32096e05b0a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[An Open Letter to the Marquette University Faculty and Staff]]></title>
            <link>https://brookemcardle1.medium.com/an-open-letter-to-the-marquette-university-faculty-and-staff-392fca7872a8?source=rss-426d68a66a58------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/392fca7872a8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[higher-education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[humanity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marquette-university]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[higher-ed]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Brooke McArdle]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 10 Nov 2020 03:10:27 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-11-10T03:10:27.320Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I am drowning in apathy so much so that I cannot even force myself to work. My days drag on and are filled with existential dread. My nights are riddled with nightmares and, when I do wake up, I am unable to move or speak for a prolonged period of time. My mind and body are overflowing with anxiety to the point that I literally am frozen.</p><p>From what I have seen and heard, many of you are experiencing similar emotions. I don’t even feel as though “emotions” is even the right word… perhaps something more targeted: perturbation, tumult, or lethargy.</p><p>I cannot say that I sympathize because I am not at risk for losing my job, figuring out how I will feed my children, teaching and researching. But I can empathize. I do know what it feels like to be abandoned by the university you trusted as well as many friends who supported you right up until you colored outside of the lines.</p><p>I am beyond grateful for those who have stood with me this past month. I have nothing but love in my heart for those individuals.</p><p>But nonetheless, it sometimes feels as if I bear this weight alone. My brain switches into Classicist mode and I am reminded of Atlas, forced to hold up the weight of the world… alone.</p><p>When I was a freshman, I was so proud to attend Marquette University. I was excited to be involved in a community that valued one another and dedicated itself to preserving its Jesuit values. Recently, I have said and written much recently concerning Marquette’s abandonment of Jesuit principles and their administrative problems. These issues are very real and palpable on campus every day.</p><p>The weight of these troubles is, unfortunately, the easiest burden. The harder quandaries to grasp are the emotions and realizations that result from acknowledging and confronting these problems.</p><p>I am ashamed to attend Marquette University. Perhaps this is the biggest gut-punch of my collegiate career. My university, which ostensibly touts that it values and engages with student opinion, sanctioned me with arbitrary conduct violations five weeks before I graduate. Five weeks.</p><p>While the university I pay to attend attempts to force me into suppression and silence, I try extraordinarily hard to have the desire to continue my studies. So often, I find myself falling short of any and all academic and personal goals I have set for myself this semester. For too many nights, I have stayed up wishing so badly to just give up. During the day, I work exceptionally hard to push those feelings out of my mind and drown my aching, tired spirit in caffeine.</p><p>This is not how I wanted to finish college. This is not how I am as a student, scholar, or human being.</p><p>My parents, who have loved Marquette forever, are experiencing similar feelings of resentment and aggravation. My mother often calls me crying. My father vituperates and shakes his head.</p><p>I open the deepest of my pains to you, those who may be experiencing similar troubles. Many people have told me to take care of myself, to take a step back, to focus on school. But the reality is that I cannot do any of those things without staying in this fight no matter how exhausting and depressing it is.</p><p>I cannot and will not back down. Marquette’s faculty and staff shaped and changed me to my core. They instilled Jesuit values in and out of the classroom. They fought for me and my future and I fight for them now.</p><h3>It is academic filial piety in the most fervent and ferocious denotation of the phrase.</h3><p>I do not struggle because of the fight. I struggle because the university I paid to attend has come close to breaking me. But it is with the help and support of my family, friends, professors, staff, and community members that I stand.</p><p>It is clear in your faces when you walk into or log onto lecture. You are exhausted… from whatever you are going through at the moment. I understand the anger, disillusionment, apathy, resentment.</p><p>My parents gave me the middle name Faith. They waited what seemed like an eternity before they were able to adopt me and they jumped through so many hoops just to hold me in their arms. When I find myself in the midst of raw and unyielding emotions and anxiety, I remember why I am who I am. I remember what my name means and what I mean to everyone I love.</p><p>You may feel alone, and that’s okay. Because I often do, too. When I am reminded of who you taught me to be, I rise. I carry what seems to be the burden of Atlas himself so that I may continue on. So that I may affect change. Or even so that I can have more coffee. Regardless, I endure.</p><p>As a Classicist, I finish with this: ad astra per aspera.</p><p>To the stars, through the struggles.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=392fca7872a8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[With extraordinary gratitude]]></title>
            <link>https://brookemcardle1.medium.com/with-extraordinary-gratitude-5deb1d56bea3?source=rss-426d68a66a58------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5deb1d56bea3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[higher-education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[liberal-arts]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cura-personalis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[humanities-courses]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marquette-university]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Brooke McArdle]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 03 Nov 2020 22:09:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-11-03T22:09:26.565Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>In the past few days, time has become a more nebulous concept for me than it has been previously. I have been moving systematically from one phone call to the next, from one social media platform to the next. I do not sleep anymore and eat only when my friends remind me that I haven’t recently. My conduct violations, in tandem with the election, pandemic, etc., have coalesced into one catastrophic union.</p><p>When I read the subpoena, I felt entirely alone. I felt that I was being unfairly targeted and punished for doing what my university taught me to do: stand up for those in need (living out <em>cura personalis</em>). I felt silenced. I felt betrayed.</p><p>I knew I could not and should not back down, despite the university’s blatant intimidation efforts. But in those feelings of confidence, I nonetheless felt burdened by injustice.</p><p>The heart break and the anxiety surrounding my subpoena was lessened when I saw that others in the Marquette community were equally as disgusted by Marquette’s intimidation efforts.</p><p>To those who have commented, reposted, tweeted, and shared, I am indebted and forever grateful. I am proud to stand with you and fight for the future of Marquette University. Together we are actively working to ensure that Marquette not only has a future, but a future where <strong>all </strong>students feel welcomed and feel that they can voice their opinions without fear of retribution.</p><p><strong>You </strong>make the difference in my life by standing with me during these times of intense division and suppression. There are not enough words to describe my gratitude.</p><p>I again challenge Marquette University to “Be the Difference.” Seek efficacious and creative solutions <strong>in collaboration with faculty, staff, students, and community members. </strong>Be entirely transparent. Reaffirm your commitment to HSI, REIS, and other diversity efforts. Reaffirm your commitment to your faculty and students.</p><p>I dream of a better future for this university and community than the one Marquette envisions. For those who are dreaming with me: continue to make change, seek justice, and find your voice.</p><p>In the spirit of my favorite musical, <em>Hamilton</em>: “rise up.”</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5deb1d56bea3" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Sanctions and Suppression]]></title>
            <link>https://brookemcardle1.medium.com/sanctions-and-suppression-c18ea695b0af?source=rss-426d68a66a58------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c18ea695b0af</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[higher-ed]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jesuiteducated]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marquette-university]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[higher-education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[first-amendment]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Brooke McArdle]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 31 Oct 2020 18:18:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-10-31T20:49:32.287Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Personal and Confidential.</strong></p><p>These are the bolded words on the subpoena from Marquette University charging me with two separate conduct violations.</p><p>For context, I am a senior at Marquette University majoring in Classical Languages and History. I graduate in a little over a month. Recently, Marquette University has announced a $45 million dollar budget shortfall and proposed that firing 200–450 faculty and staff positions will solve this fiscal catastrophe.</p><p>I have spent today reflecting on the day when undergraduates, graduate students, faculty, staff, and community members joined me at the sit-in at Zilber Hall to oppose proposed budget cuts that would disproportionately affect humanities departments and minority faculty and staff.</p><p>Members of university administration threatened us four times throughout our six hour peaceful sit-in. We honored their requests: do not block doors or business proceedings for the day and please be COVID safe.</p><p>Stephanie Quade, the Dean of Students, approached us and threatened students directly, saying campus police would get involved and we would be forced to hand over university identification. A little while later, her and other administrative representatives came downstairs with clipboards, demanding those present show our identification or risk “repercussions.”</p><p>No one gave their name or IDs because we had all forgotten them that day.</p><p>We finished the sit-in as we had intended, after confirming that we were not in violation of any university policy.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*MZl-TKxQyXa3orPe0CyWwg.jpeg" /><figcaption>At Zilber Hall (administrative building) holding a sign and a packet containing financial data about Marquette University.</figcaption></figure><p>Ten days pass and I wake up on a Saturday morning to a subpoena for two student conduct violations.</p><p>“1. Refusing to show or surrender a university identification upon request by a university employee acting in the performance of his/her duties.</p><p>2. Violating published policies and rules governing residence halls, student organizations or the university.”</p><p>I did not think my heart could break any more than it already had. I did not know I could feel such distrust, shame, and resentment as I do now. I am not ashamed for standing up for my rights.</p><p>As a woman with a disability, I know better than to yield to the current ableist and sexist patriarchal structure that is Marquette University’s administration.</p><p>My emotions stem from the administration’s gross intimidation tactics, most notably their blatant suppression of students’ first amendment rights and also their obvious disavowal of their commitment to appreciating student voices.</p><p>The following quotation was taken directly from Marquette University’s demonstration policy, effective February 13th, 2020: “The spirit of inquiry and challenge that the university seeks to encourage will produce many conflicts of ideas, opinions and proposals for action. The <a href="https://www.marquette.edu/university-policies-procedures/documents/Safety-DemonstrationPolicy-UPP6-11.pdf">university community</a> recognizes its responsibility to provide effective channels for internal communication, free discussion and rational persuasion as the normal and preferred means of airing and reconciling such differences. On occasion, recourse to public demonstration and protest may become a necessary and justified means of supporting a cause or position. In such cases, the university must seek to ensure a fair and reasonable balance and coordination between two values that are brought into conflict with one another. <strong>The first is the right of university community members to freely pursue their academic and vocational objectives without unreasonable obstruction or hindrance. The second is the right of university community members to freely communicate, by lawful demonstration and protest, the positions that they conscientiously espouse on vital issues of the day</strong>.”</p><p>It is abundantly clear that this subpoena and subsequent hearing is yet another intimidation tactic to smother my voice. The administration knows that undergraduate student support is essential to this university. If they cannot enact budget cuts and other changes without student reproach, they will force submission. They have done it to the faculty by threatening to fire individuals and cut departments and now they are doing it to the students.</p><p>Despite the despicable disregard for student voice, these student conduct violations are a demonstration of the systemic institutional racism that is pulsating through the administration’s veins.</p><p>Earlier this academic year, Marquette’s <a href="https://www.wuwm.com/post/marquette-university-agrees-black-student-unions-demands-students-say-fight-continues#stream/0">Black Student Council held a </a>demonstration at Zilber Hall as well, demanding administrative commitment to diversity initiatives. <a href="https://marquettewire.org/4041088/news/native-american-student-association-holds-protest/">Marquette’s Native American Student Association also held </a>a demonstration that ended at Zilber Hall, demanding among other things that Marquette change its seal, which inaccurately portrays Jacques Marquette’s interactions with indigenous communities.</p><p>None of the students involved in these demonstrations received student conduct violations yet.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*QfQWxGJYYiGcW0yizTrAvQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Students at the sit-in, being COVID safe as I discuss financial information about Marquette university.</figcaption></figure><p>It is clear that Marquette administration feared retaliating against similar demonstrations because they do not want to appear to target students of color during a national movement for racial equality. Marquette clearly feared repercussions from sanctioning minority students when handling their demonstrations.</p><p>Many other students were present at the sit-in and did not present their university identification. No one else was sanctioned.</p><p>I am a little over one month from graduation, as they know, and they have targeted me and threatened my student status. Their attempt to silence me has failed utterly and they have thus resorted to engineered and unsound conduct violations.</p><p>The hearing is scheduled for November 5th 2020 at 11am. That is less than a week from now. Notifying me on the weekend, they have given me little time to prepare witnesses and seek legal counsel. Again, they are intentionally gatekeeping me from protecting myself.</p><p>I am entirely disheartened by Marquette University. I am a student with a disability that has significantly altered the way I live my life. Just as all students, I have the right to express my opinion. I, along with so many other students and members of the community, am a victim of Marquette’s attempt to preclude voicing dissent or disapproval.</p><p>I, and other students, will not stand idly by as the university implements measures that will decimate the value of and the livelihoods of those entrusted to uphold our Jesuit education.</p><p>In declaring the subpoena as <strong>personal and confidential, </strong>the administration only furthers their desire to suppress student voices and recognizes their own culpability in such an inhumane and unethical process of self-destruction.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c18ea695b0af" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Reflections on and a Call for Humanity]]></title>
            <link>https://brookemcardle1.medium.com/reflections-on-and-a-call-for-humanity-57fbb42168ca?source=rss-426d68a66a58------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/57fbb42168ca</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[academia]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[covid19]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marquette-university]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[liberal-arts]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Brooke McArdle]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 14 Oct 2020 16:35:02 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-10-14T22:55:59.155Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>As I sit in my apartment appreciating the picturesque view of Marquette’s campus, I wonder how I got here. My brain is dwelling on the reality that I am graduating in less than two months but my heart is yearning for more time. I didn’t believe everyone when they said how fast college goes by, how the years seem to be so long in the moment but when you look back, they seem drastically shorter. I think about the movie nights and study nights in my dorm room when I was a freshman. I look back fondly on waking up to the first snowfall from my eighth floor dorm room sophomore year. I question whether junior year happened at all because it was so busy! And now I’m here, a senior.</p><p>I struggle to face the reality around me. The world is in shambles. Social injustice, systemic racism, bigotry, sexism, a pandemic, and so much more plagues our nation. I thought I could take comfort in my academic work, as I always have. But unfortunately, even that was all too idealistic. Instead, beginning my last semester of college is inseparably linked with institutional failure.</p><p>Thinking back to high school me, I smile to remember the stress of choosing where I’d go to college. I was privileged enough to have several options, most with great scholarship packages. My love for violin and soccer essentially drove my college search. I was eager to play a collegiate sport. It seemed like everything I always wanted.</p><p>My cousin, a MU alumna, invited me to a Joan of Arc 10pm mass on a cold February night. I was reluctant, studying for AP exams and all of my extracurricular activities took up most of my time. But I said yes anyway. I remember walking up to the chapel and feeling my anxiety about my work fade away. We sat on the floor of the chapel, surrounded by Marquette students. Everyone was genuinely happy to be there. They were warm and friendly towards me, a high schooler. I have never had an experience with mass like I had at Joan of Arc that night. Growing up Catholic, many times mass felt like a process, a series of steps. This mass was the most human experience I have ever felt. Intense emotions of joy and passion and love filled my heart. I sat through the homily with tears silently streaming down my face. I will never forget that night and how it made me feel.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xMBuhdu-J7RiQegvWedt1Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>Me in front of Joan of Arc</figcaption></figure><p>I knew instantly I would attend Marquette because of that experience. I had applied to Marquette because of their Jesuit values. <em>Cura personalis </em>(which I will talk more about later), a commitment to serving others, a liberal arts education. My parents raised me to live my life in service to others. It wasn’t about getting a job, it was about finding a vocation, a calling. Marquette seemed to offer me all the opportunities to continue to live out these core tenets of who I was. Soccer and orchestra still could be an integral part of my collegiate experience, but I chose to place my value system and the quality of my education first.</p><p>My freshman year, I spent most of my time working on completing the core requirements. While my AP score got me out of one semester of Latin, I needed one more course. I enrolled in 2002, a class that was taught by the Classics adjunct. There were only three of us in the course, but the small size created a close bond between us. I met my best friend in that class, who is very much like a sister to me. At the beginning of that semester, she encouraged me to also take the upper division class on Virgil’s <em>Aeneid </em>concurrently. I did not need to take the course and my advisor certainly told me to avoid taking 19 credits, but I did it anyway. That decision changed my life, quite literally. I declared my Classics major after only a few classes and fell in love with a discipline that I had enjoyed since I was a little girl building a replica of the Trojan Horse with my grandpa.</p><p>I soon realized that Marquette didn’t have the resources I needed. I outgrew the Classics program almost as soon as I started it. We had one professor, who was brilliant, but pedagogically, it was difficult to feel like I could grow as a scholar. Marquette had already cut down the languages faculty, it was essentially bare bones. What I didn’t understand was why they did this. Sure, save money. But… mission?</p><h3>They advertised incessantly about “be the difference” and how they valued Jesuit pedagogy. Well, Jesuit teaching is founded on the humanities. It was utterly paradoxical.</h3><p>Flash forward several years and the situation is worse. COVID-19 obviously isn’t helping, but Marquette recently proposed cutting around 200 (if not more) faculty because of our financial situation. It’s pretty clear that most of those cuts will come from the humanities. This is a hastened continuation of Marquette’s degradation the humanities in recent years.</p><p>I chose this university because of its mission. I had better scholarships from other schools. I could have played collegiate soccer at other schools. But I chose to prioritize my education and my values.</p><h3>I am asking Marquette to do the same.</h3><p>As a Classics major, I want to take a moment to break down one of the Latin mottos that Marquette constantly harps on. <em>Cura personalis. </em>In translation, Ignatian spirituality says this means “care for the whole person.” I give this translation an A+… but with a catch. Classicists will applaud you for your ability to translate, but perhaps more important is your ability to contextualize. This is where the work begins!</p><p><em>Cura </em>gives us the English cognate care. This term necessitates some nuancing, which can help use better understand the motto. <em>Cura </em>as care has a lot of other Latin words bound up in it. <em>Diligentia, opera, labor, studium, </em>all of which are a part of this. Diligence, work, labor, and zeal. <em>Cura </em>incorporates toil, duty, passion, work. <em>Cura personalis </em>isn’t only care for academic success in college. It is care for the spiritual, physical, emotional wellbeing of students <strong>and </strong>faculty. <em>Cura </em>isn’t easy to accomplish. It takes work and diligence but most importantly, it takes commitment.</p><p><em>Personalis </em>gives us the English cognates person/personality. Quite literally, it means “of the person.” Again, this term is integrally connected to the aspects that make up a person. This is about the soul or the innermost being of every human. Taken as a phrase, <em>cura personalis </em>charges those who use the expression with caring for the individual soul, the personhood of those who they meet. The phrase is pregnant with responsibility to individuals and therefore, attention to their talents, desires, needs, and concerns. For Marquette, this motto is often employed to demonstrate that the university goes beyond caring for the academic success of their students, instead offering a well-rounded education that makes students better people.</p><p>But if Marquette wants to tout that they teach more than academics, the humanities are <strong>indispensable </strong>to that process. The humanities teach students how to critically navigate their world. The humanities are not cut and dry. Liberal arts ask students to engage with problems from different angles. Disciplines like history, philosophy, theology, languages, and many more are essential to creating these kinds of students.</p><h3>You cannot have cura personalis in the most legitimate and real sense of the phrase without humanities being at the center of education.</h3><p>For the value of a liberal arts degree: <a href="https://hbr.org/2019/09/yes-employers-do-value-liberal-arts-degrees">https://hbr.org/2019/09/yes-employers-do-value-liberal-arts-degrees</a></p><p>I want to leave Marquette University better than I found it, for the students and for the faculty. I am asking Marquette to shoulder this desire with me. The goal of <em>cura personalis </em>at its core is humanity. This reflects the emotions that I experienced at my first Joan of Arc mass. By putting “human” back into humanities, Marquette can be at the forefront of maintaining Jesuit ideology.</p><blockquote>Marquette can actually “be the difference.”</blockquote><p>We are stronger together. We can accomplish our goals when we are united. We need to voice our frustrations and our demands. Undergraduates, graduate students, alumni, faculty, and staff. No one gets fired. That is the only way to truly embody <em>cura personalis.</em></p><blockquote>Please sign this petition: <a href="https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSdG4Iu111GfBzAZngaWknjsIfNlOZqFz3tig5y0KBJpnkosGw/viewform">https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSdG4Iu111GfBzAZngaWknjsIfNlOZqFz3tig5y0KBJpnkosGw/viewform</a></blockquote><p>Brooke McArdle is a senior at Marquette University, majoring in Classical Languages and History. She is planning to pursue a doctoral degree in Classical Philology after her graduation.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=57fbb42168ca" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[To Withstand an Earthquake]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/marquette-meets-peru/to-withstand-an-earthquake-2a9cc5ecef56?source=rss-426d68a66a58------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2a9cc5ecef56</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[peru]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[inequality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Brooke McArdle]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 28 Jun 2019 01:59:03 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-06-28T22:45:15.123Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*sgT_S2UJ-nuH6RT-77cd6w.jpeg" /><figcaption>The canvas I painted, entitled “To Withstand an Earthquake,” as an artistic representation of what I learned from my time in Peru.</figcaption></figure><p>It is the age-old saying: a picture is worth a thousand words. It means that whatever is captured within a lens or on a canvas has a deeper meaning, more complex than a short explanation could give. I picture my time in Peru — the experiences, what I learned, and the people I met — like this. That is why I decided to put my thoughts and feelings on a canvas, in an attempt to make sense of and depict what I discovered in Peru, about myself and about education. After all, that is why I embarked on this trip… right? I cannot promise that the short explanation I write will be a thousand words, like the adage suggests, but I hope my attempt to explain my creative process refocuses my painting, beyond a surface-level assessment, to demonstrate its deeper connection to educational philosophy. I decided to title this painting “To Withstand an Earthquake,” which seemed fitting not only practically, the reason for which I’ll talk about soon, but also personally, because of what I experienced in Peru.</p><p>My canvas consists of three different sections: Inca, Spanish, and Pamplona Alta. To each of these sections I have assigned one of the three main questions from the course. The Inca section correlates to the question: what is a just education? The Spanish section correlates to the question: what is a high quality education? Finally, the Pamplona Alta section correlates to the question: what is equity in education? My thoughts and creative processes were different for each of these sections, and I want to underscore the artistic importance of this. When I first learned that the medium for the final project for this trip could be whatever I wanted, I knew that I wanted to paint. Throughout the whole trip, I wanted some way to let out all of the thoughts and feelings I experienced, in way which I could not do with words. Some of the things that stuck out to me the most about Peru on this trip were as follows: art, color, and rocks. The first two may not come as a surprise, but rocks? Where did that come from? These three things were the different inspirations for my canvas. Now let me tell you why.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/471/1*ka2fNDnP-ChmMS8CX_w5BQ.png" /><figcaption>The Inca Section</figcaption></figure><p><strong>The Inca</strong></p><p>For each of the sections, I want to start off by detailing my creative process and the symbolism, and then move into its connection with what I read and experienced. A quick note about the design of the painting in general: my goal was to create my own rendition of Lima’s Wall of Shame, but depicting the wall with the Inca and Spanish foundations that I saw at Ollantaitambo as a testament to Peru’s past. In the background is Pamplona Alta, the present.</p><p>As I mentioned earlier, one of the inspirations for this canvas was rocks. It definitely seems out of place, but as I reflected on my trip, I could not ignore how often I thought of the geologic formations, the architecture, and the prevalence of rocks during my time in Peru. From the various Huaca and Inca ruins I visited, to the brickwork in the Catacombs of the Museo Convento San Francisco y Catacumbas, geology played an important, yet commonly overlooked, role in my experiences. One moment of the trip that, may seem insignificant in the grand scheme of this whole journey but, stuck out to me was when Marisol, Theresa, and I walked around the streets of Ollantaitambo after visiting the ruins there. I followed Theresa and Marisol as they guided us past the bustling streets filled with car horns and tourists to a quieter area, which was actually only a block away from the chaos. One block made a huge difference in the noise level, but also in the architecture. As we walked deeper into the streets, the foundations of the houses began to change. We first walked past foundations made with large rocks, the original feat of the Incas. When I saw how precise and perfect the cuts of the stones were, Theresa explained to me their purpose. She said that the Incas built and cut this way, not only with impeccable accuracy, but also with the knowledge that the powerful earthquakes commonly experienced there would damage the foundation. With this knowledge in mind, as Theresa explained, the Incas left crevices and holes in the foundation, precisely placed, to accommodate any shifting that would occur during an earthquake, so as to preserve the structural integrity of the foundation. For that reason, the original Inca architecture has withstood time, let alone earthquakes. This is the practical reason as to why I decided to entitle my canvas “To Withstand an Earthquake,” because of the mastery of the Inca craftsmen and the physical stability their ingenuity provided for their people. Hearing Theresa’s words and seeing the stones sitting so perfectly, undisturbed, made me feel connected with an integral part of Peruvian history and culture. Here is a picture I took of the foundation, made solely out of rocks that have been cut to fit together perfectly, without any bonding agent and having gaps only when structurally necessary to withstand earthquakes.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/285/1*HV01fsBB0PggkfEcuX5PeQ.png" /><figcaption>Original Inca foundation in Ollantaitambo</figcaption></figure><p>With this knowledge and experience in mind, I wanted my painting to reflect the intricacy and delicate nature of the Inca design. With time, the original rocks have been damaged at certain points and I wanted to depict that to stay true to the original image I captured of the foundation. However, there are only three places where there are significant damages or cracks. Only three. This was one of the things I found truly incredible about the rocks and foundation. In painting the Inca rocks, I wanted to highlight the smoothness in the way the Incas cut the rocks to fit together and I also wanted to emphasize the type of rock chosen, sedimentary rock, by varying the colors I used, still reflective of the original image. This section was the most labor intensive because of the blending of the colors; however, it is my personal favorite for this reason in itself. The work I spent on this section and its tedious nature reminds me of the work put into the original foundation itself, each precise cut and the care put into making it structurally sound.</p><p>I decided to assign the question of a just education to the Inca section because of the Inca history. In the PBS/Nova article <a href="https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/article/inca-empire/">“Rise of the Inca,”</a> anthropologist Terence D’Altroy details the consolidation and growth of the Inca Empire. He notes that the Incas adeptly incorporated peoples into their empire by portraying their management as a larger system of the local governments. He also discusses the advantages of living under Inca rule and the disadvantages, notably the loss of autonomy. The question of autonomy is applicable to the Inca Empire and also to educational contexts. Autonomy is closely aligned with value, flourishing, and communal betterment, three aspects which I think are important when considering what makes an education just.</p><p>I do not intend to answer the question of what a just education is, but I want to offer what I’ve learned about what it means to be just and what that means in an educational setting through the lens of my experiences in Peruvian educational contexts. I want to define ‘just’ with the help of Nancy Fraser and her piece <a href="https://drive.google.com/open?id=18KLTPYk-UAorUEb0qEGBXygT3QlGfO8c">“On Justice: Lessons from Plato, Rawls, and Ishiguro.”</a> Fraser discusses justice and writes that “justice requires that all who are governed by a common set of ground rules be recognized as counting… all of [the people] deserve equal concern” (<a href="https://drive.google.com/open?id=18KLTPYk-UAorUEb0qEGBXygT3QlGfO8c">page 45</a>). Therefore, a just system would recognize and, moreover, value all of its members. To relate this back to my canvas, the Inca Empire, embodied by the Inca foundation, consolidated power and took away its subjects’ autonomy in doing so, disregarding the premise of a just system, which recognizes each individual and their contribution to the system. This analysis is applicable to Francisco Pizarro’s, the conqueror of the Incas, actions as well.</p><p>Educational contexts and schools also replicate systems of recognition and value. In <a href="https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B4YrkLKx4DUzMEJEZHVCaWpmUzA/view">“Engaged Pedagogy,”</a> Bell Hooks discusses this idea. Hooks states that “students want [teachers] to see them as whole human beings with complex lives and experiences rather than simply as seekers after compartmentalized bits of knowledge” (<a href="https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B4YrkLKx4DUzMEJEZHVCaWpmUzA/view">page 15</a>). By recognizing students and acknowledging their value, classrooms become more than places where information is exchanged, but become just spaces for learning. Obtaining information is not learning; instead, learning is actively seeking, engaging in, and connecting material with personal experience. This can only happen when shared value is recognized by both students and teacher. Looking at education and learning as obtaining information relates to another point that Fraser deems as unjust. Fraser discusses personhood and says that a person “deemed to possess only extrinsic value, and thus to be a mere means to others’ ends, can nevertheless be elevated in status… into a being that is valuable and deserving of consideration in its own right” (<a href="https://drive.google.com/open?id=18KLTPYk-UAorUEb0qEGBXygT3QlGfO8c">page 47</a>). Consequently, Fraser is arguing that, when seen as only have extrinsic value, like when student learning is perceived as only passively receiving information, a person, or student, cannot obtain value and recognition.</p><p>This, then, is inherently unjust, as it manipulates students and lessens their abilities, talents, and intrinsic value. Therefore, a just education must appreciate and actualize the value of each student in a classroom in order for that student to engage and thrive. The practice of recognizing each students’ value is closely tied with student flourishing. Harry Brighouse, in <a href="https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B4YrkLKx4DUzZWhTTm1UV2E5Mjg/view">“Moral and Political Aims of Education,”</a> lists flourishing as one of the aims of education. Brighouse discusses the importance of exercising talents and engaging with life’s challenges in cultivating flourishing. When students are able to do these things in an educational setting, their intrinsic value is being recognized. Bell Hooks underscores the importance of “teachers who have had the courage to transgress those boundaries that would confine each pupil to a rote, assembly-line approach to learning” (<a href="https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B4YrkLKx4DUzMEJEZHVCaWpmUzA/view">page 13</a>). Consequently, when teachers move beyond the memorization and passive view of learning, they not only demonstrate that they value their students, but students are able to discover and utilize their talents and engage with challenges, two aspects of Brighouse’s flourishing.</p><p>Recognizing the value of each student was one of the things I saw at the Casitas program I visited in El Agustino. Maria was intent on purposefully allocating time to hear everyone’s opinions and perspectives. After the International Day of Play, each student at my Casitas was asked to write what they enjoyed, what they did not enjoy, and what they want next year. After giving the students time to think and write, we joined in a circle and shared opinions. Maria was careful about acknowledging what the students said and asking them to build upon their answers by posing questions. Again, at the end of each session, she asked each student to say what they enjoyed, what they did not enjoy, and what they congratulated themselves for that day. This was her way of recognizing each student and what they contributed to the program. The Casitas program exists to provide an after-school activity for students, designed to keep them away from violence and drugs. While Maria could easily let the students run wild and do what they wished within the time frame, she instead sets aside time to allow the students to express themselves, openly acknowledging their value and contributions to the Casitas environment and program.</p><p>Another aspect that I believe contributes to a just education is providing students the tools they need to be successful. While the intangible and tangible skills students need to learn from school are practical, their importance cannot be understated. In Harry Brighouse’s chapter, <a href="https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B4YrkLKx4DUzZWhTTm1UV2E5Mjg/view">“Moral and Political Aims of Education,”</a> he lists contributory effectiveness as one of the aims of education. Contributory effectiveness is the idea that students should be self-sufficient but also cooperative in their society, which aids in the betterment of the community, a process which Brighouse ties to the development of self-worth. John Dewey, in <a href="https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B9K8OLyuF8_TLTl2YThUTGZOdk0/view"><em>Experience and Education</em></a><em>, </em>also discusses the role preparation plays in education. While one purpose of schools is to prepare students for their futures and to enable students to productively engage in and better their communities, Dewey suggests that the notion of preparation is flawed. Dewey notes that “when preparation is made a controlling end, then the potentialities of the present are sacrificed to a suppositious future” (<a href="https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B9K8OLyuF8_TLTl2YThUTGZOdk0/view">page 13</a>). He posits that the rigid idea of preparation looks too far in the future and disregards the present circumstances and learning opportunities available. Instead, it essentially pigeonholes students and biasedly controls their experiences. Dewey argues that, since we can only act in the present, the value of each present experience, regardless of what regimented preparation’s intent for the future would decide, should be seized. This, I believe, is one of the most important ways that teachers can help students to be contributing members of society, and is an important intangible skill that will enable students to be successful.</p><p>At Tupac Amaru, a public school in Villa Maria de Triunfo, the idea of giving students the tools necessary to be contributing members of society seemed to be one of the purposes of education. Tupac Amaru emphasizes future technical careers, where students pick from a variety of different trades so that, once they finish school, they can enter into the workforce and help better their community. Since Tupac Amaru is in a working class neighborhood, this purpose of education is very practical and suited to the community’s needs. The article, <a href="http://publicspherejournal.com/2017/11/breaking-the-paradigm-technical-education-in-peru-and-latin-america/">“Breaking the Paradigm: Technical Education in Peru and Latin America,”</a> discusses the aim of contributory effectiveness in relation to the need for more technical certifications and institutions in Peru and Latin America. The author, Hans Frech La Rosa, cites that in Peru in 2016, “70% [of students] chose to study in a university, while 30% chose a technical or vocational institution… given that there is an increasing demand for more technical professionals than university graduates, around 40% of professionals in the country are over-schooled, under-payed or occupying positions that do not correspond to their academic degree.” Clearly there is a disconnect in what the communities and country, as a whole, need; additionally, as the author suggests, the negative association with technical education results in a lack of people properly trained for important, necessary jobs and also people whose qualifications do not match their job. Therefore, the aim of contributory effectiveness, an important aspect of a just education, is diminished or absent for many workers. At Tupac Amaru, it seems like the administration has carefully considered their community’s needs and created a school structure and curriculum accordingly to benefit their students, after their schooling, and their community.</p><p>However, I wonder if their application of the idea of preparation is contradictory to what Dewey posits about preparation. Since we only visited Tupac Amaru for a few hours, I know that I do not have all the information necessary to make a judgment about the type of preparatory education. With the information I do have and with my experiences from visiting, I question if their implementation of preparation with the goal of contributory effectiveness leans more towards Dewey’s definition of preparation, which deemphasizes pigeonholing students, or if it leans more toward the traditional definition of preparation, which focuses students on one path with little room for exploring other options.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-8lgoOd8csSkN-eYb9vWmQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>The Spanish Section</figcaption></figure><p><strong>The Spanish</strong></p><p>In all honesty, painting the Spanish section was my least favorite, I think because of what it represents. Again with the rocks in this section! Give it a little more time, you’re almost to the part where my other inspirations, art and color, have their chance to shine. During my conversation with Theresa, she also mentioned that, after the conflict between the Spanish and Incas, the Spanish settled in and built on the preexisting Inca structures, hence why there are many buildings, especially in Ollantaitambo, that have Inca and Spanish foundations. The Spanish foundation, however, is cruder than the Inca. In traditional conquistador fashion, the Spanish, with disregard for the care and elegance of the Inca foundation, took their seemingly superior mortar and slapped it on top of the Inca structures. They scattered small rocks or pieces of bigger rocks throughout the mortar to provide stability. However, the Inca rocks, in my opinion, have weathered better, not to mention longer. The mortar, while stable and holding, is riddled with cracks.</p><p>When painting this section, I was frustrated. I thought about the time, effort, and care that I had taken when painting the Inca rocks, each with their own unique shape and cut, and felt that the mortar I was painting took much less attention to detail. While I worked to blend the colors and detail the rocks in the Spanish section, it was mostly for artistic effect. The actual process of and work that goes into mixing and laying down mortar is labor-intensive in a very different way. Additionally, when painting this section, I purposefully did not wash or wipe off my brush. Therefore, each rock in the Spanish section, with the exception of the mortar, shared paint. I did this in an attempt to subtly replicate the haphazard nature of the rocks in the Spanish mortar, that they exist for stability but were not hand-picked, not hand-carved like in the Inca section where each rock was unique with its own colors and paint. Painting the cracks in the mortar was also an aspect of the image that I wanted to emphasize. As I mentioned previously, there are a considerable amount of cracks in the Spanish mortar and, to me, this was symbolic again of the care, or lack of, put into the architecture. Pictured here is the photograph of Inca and Spanish rock from Ollantaitambo that I used to create my canvas.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/253/1*2pUGrf8pvCl6Z0kj74uM6Q.png" /><figcaption>The intersection of Inca and Spanish foundations at Ollantaitambo. This picture provided the inspiration for my rendition of Lima’s Wall of Shame.</figcaption></figure><p>It seemed logical to assign the question of what a high quality education is to the Spanish section because of the conquistador attitude and general attitude of Europeans during the colonization. The idea of the civilizing mission applies more so to colonization efforts during the Scramble for Africa but can also be interpreted and found in colonial efforts of the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries. Its basis is rooted in the idea that indigenous peoples were uncivilized and primitive and that it was the responsibility of the Europeans to bring civilization to these peoples, providing a justification for imperialism, colonialism, and expansionism, three processes that took off after technological developments improved sailing and exploring. In later centuries, the same idea became known as the “White Man’s Burden,” after a poem of the same name authored by Rudyard Kipling. When Francisco Pizarro killed the last Inca king, Atahualpa, the Spanish conquered the Incas in the name of their God but with the motivation of greed. They forever altered the development of Inca, and Peruvian, history. The Spanish brought over various goods and implemented practices that they deemed as superior, disregarding the preexisting richness of the Inca Empire. This foreign sense of superiority and disregard for indigenous culture, which has now become an integral part of Peruvian history and is demonstrated by the Spanish use of mortar foundation, is why I related the Spanish section of my painting to the question: what is a high quality education?</p><p>The components of a just education that I have suggested also, for me, help to paint a picture of what a high quality education looks like. Without valuing students, enabling them to flourish, and providing them with tangible and intangible tools to succeed, the very foundation of a high quality education would crumble. In my time in Peru, I was able to see very wealthy schools and poorer schools. The opportunities afforded to students at Roosevelt and at La Inmaculada were incredible. At Roosevelt, students had access to the “FDR Fab Lab” for creating and building, which included a 3D printer. They also had a very large list of extra-curriculars to choose from, some of which offered international travel for competitions, like Model United Nations and various sports teams. At La Inmaculada, the students had a zoo, a fully-equipped gymnasium, and several soccer fields. All of this wealth and privilege is in contrast to Fe y Alegria, where students in the Andes did not have those kinds of opportunities. While I’m sure any student would enjoy being on a travel team for soccer or going to their school zoo for science class, that is not how I am going to define, or attempt to define, a high quality education. Material wealth, at least for me, does not constitute good pedagogy or necessarily better learning. While not all-encompassing, I want to offer that a high quality education consists of the following: emphasizing student and contextual assets, allowing for collaboration, and encouraging involvement.</p><p>John Dewey discusses the importance of a child-centered education in <a href="https://drive.google.com/open?id=0B4YrkLKx4DUzcUhxcC1LTEF1SjA"><em>The School and Society</em></a><em>. </em>He discusses how traditional schooling works, and summarizes its hallmarks: “its passivity of attitude, its mechanical massing of children, its uniformity of curriculum and method… the center of gravity is outside the child” (<a href="https://drive.google.com/open?id=0B4YrkLKx4DUzcUhxcC1LTEF1SjA">page 35</a>). The rote memorization and the passive listening without any room for interjection are things that many students, unfortunately, are familiar with. Instead, Dewey argues that education should be child centered and he makes the analogy that education is actively getting information and experiences <em>from</em> students, instead of handing it <em>to</em> them passively. He uses the example of cooking an egg and notes that, when students cook an egg and are told exactly how to do it, without any cultivation of experimentation and excitement, there is no genuine learning happening there. Conversely, when students act on their own to figure out what they want and when they work to discover and experiment, that is genuine learning. Dewey’s child centered education is contingent on recognizing student assets. When teachers recognize what each student has to offer in their classroom and is able to capitalize on those talents and abilities, they are going to be more able to help their students genuinely learn.</p><p>A high quality education should acknowledge the contextual assets in addition to student assets. One example of this that I saw in Peru was at Fe y Alegria, a bilingual (Quechua and Spanish) school. Quechua, while deemed culturally inferior by many Peruvians, is the language and culture of the Andean people. The Jesuit social project at Fe y Alegria is insistent on maintaining Quechua’s cultural relevance and importance in students’ lives. The teachers speak Quechua and the school encourages the continuation of different cultural practices, like weaving. In her book, <em>A White Teacher Talks About Race</em>, Julie Landsman reflects on her own teaching experience in Minnesota and how she saw perceptions of race, poverty, and culture blending in her school and classroom. One quote from her book is particularly relevant both to the importance of incorporating contextual assets into a classroom as well as to my chosen career as a History teacher. The quote is as follows:</p><p>So many of the… students I teach are absent from our texts. The working white and black men on their hands and knees laying wire for the new concert hall are not shown in our history books… the Native-American men who hang up above the others in the balcony, adjusting the velvet on the box seats, and the white women who climb to install the chandeliers: they are nowhere to be seen when we look at the pictures of the elegant hall. (Landsman 31)</p><p>Landsman is not only talking about many cultures and races being left out of history books. Of course that is important to note, but that is only a consequence of a larger issue: systemic racism and prejudice born from one culture deeming other cultures inferior. At Fe y Alegria, teachers and staff are making a conscious effort to validate and appreciate the Quechua language and culture that is an integral part of the Andean culture. They may not be rewriting the history books, but as a bilingual school, they are putting Quechua and Spanish on the same plain, validating their students’ culture. This is essential in not only perpetuating the existence of Quechua, but also in helping their students discover and appreciate their identities.</p><p>Another aspect that I believe constitutes a high quality education is the presence of and emphasis on collaboration between students and teachers. As I’ve discussed earlier, Dewey talks a lot about what traditional education looks like: listening, passivity, and rote memorization. Instead of this, the classroom should be a collaborative space, where teacher and student work together to learn, because teachers should always be striving to learn something, not just to teach something. In Vivian Chavez and Elisabeth Soep’s article, <a href="https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Y2hU-D-vG_Oi1B8C9YTSpJP3ClZFI8vM/view?usp=sharing">“Youth Radio and the Pedagogy of Collegiality,”</a> the authors talk about a Youth Radio program that is collaborative and student-led but guided by adults. The authors reference Bell Hooks’ idea of ‘engaged pedagogy’ and note that this idea is central to Youth Radio’s pedagogy. They note that “rather than expect only students to learn and change, teachers are also transformed… when teachers offer their own narratives or interpretations, they cease to function as ‘all-knowing silent interrogators’” (<a href="https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Y2hU-D-vG_Oi1B8C9YTSpJP3ClZFI8vM/view?usp=sharing">page 418</a>). The idea of collegiality at Youth Radio insists that learning is a transformative experience for both youth and adult, enabling students and teachers to work together in an interdependent way to accomplish their projects successfully. Paulo Freire, in <a href="https://drive.google.com/open?id=0B9K8OLyuF8_TZWNRZmF1aFhQWEE"><em>Pedagogy of Freedom</em></a><em>, </em>also discusses the importance of changing the traditional student-teacher relationship. Freire talks about transfer knowledge, which is linked with traditional conceptions of education: the idea that, at school, teachers transfer knowledge to students. Freire disagrees with this idea and suggests that teaching should be about creating the space and environment that promotes the discovery of knowledge. He writes that “in the context of true learning, the learners will be engaged in a continuous transformation through which they become authentic subjects of the construction and reconstruction of what is being taught, side by side with the teacher, who is equally subject to the same process” (<a href="https://drive.google.com/open?id=0B9K8OLyuF8_TZWNRZmF1aFhQWEE">page 6</a>). Therefore, Freire not only defines learning as an active process, but emphasizes the importance of the teacher being a collaborative and also moldable figure in that process.</p><p>In Matthew’s classroom at La Inmaculada, I feel like I was able to see some pieces of this process happening. The boys in the class were working on gender inequality and comparing and contrasting gender inequality in Peru with another country. In their groups, the boys were asked to draw a Venn Diagram and then write a paragraph, using their diagram, to practice their English. Matthew seemed to hand over the responsibility of coming up with an argument and the claims to the students, but he was always watching and checking to see if he needed to step in. When he would step in, he would not tell the students they were wrong, instead, he would frame his suggestions differently, in a way that made the students think about their claims and their writing. He did not want a specific answer from them but wanted them to think for themselves. In doing this, he learned what his students were thinking, not what he wanted them to think, allowing him to discover and learn from his students instead of feed them an answer. For me, the class I observed seemed radically different from the passive classroom where the teacher gives the students information. Instead, the classroom was noisy and the students were busy working together and with Matthew guiding them to discover more about gender inequality and English grammar.</p><p>The last piece of a high quality education that I want to offer is cultivating involvement. In school it is not only important for students to learn material, but it is also crucial that students learn to advocate not only for themselves but for others as well. Therefore, it is essential for teachers to help guide students to be involved and actively engaged in their community and the world around them. Wheeler-Bell discusses this in his article, <a href="https://drive.google.com/file/d/1IqDuq-2LJ0KPOMt_L1mVBReLJ2JtgGzV/view?usp=sharing">“Educating the Spirit of Activism: a ‘Critical’ Civic Education.”</a> He talks about fostering a sense of justice in students and encouraging them to engage in social movements, an attitude which he calls the Spirit of Activism. Specifically, Wheeler-Bell states that a high self-esteem is directly linked to developing a spirit of activism. Consequently, a high quality education should have a positive influence on their students’ self-esteem and also aim to cultivate a sense of justice and a desire for communal involvement. In this way, a school can serve as a learning environment and an environment for creating social change to better society. David Pariser, Juan Carlos Castro, and Martin Lalonde discuss the idea of civic engagement in their article, <a href="http://0-search.ebscohost.com.libus.csd.mu.edu/login.aspx?direct=true&amp;db=ehh&amp;AN=115397797&amp;site=eds-live">“Mobilities, Aesthetics, and Civic Engagement: Getting At-Risk Youth to Look at Their Communities.”</a> The authors describe civic engagement as an example of social capital and agree with the following definition: “by civic we mean activity aimed at addressing social and/or community issues that are not political by nature but nevertheless, are conducive to the collective well-being” (<a href="http://0-search.ebscohost.com.libus.csd.mu.edu/login.aspx?direct=true&amp;db=ehh&amp;AN=115397797&amp;site=eds-live">page 214</a>). The findings of Pariser, Castro, and Lalonde, however, suggest another form of civic engagement in addition to active participation in the community. The authors state that their project, meant to engage at-risk students with problems in their community, achieved this goal, not only by having students go into their community, but by having students think critically about their experiences in the community via art. The realizations that the students had, only after a type of reflective exercise, reminded me of the emphasis placed on reflection during our time in Peru and by the Jesuits, like at La Inmaculada.</p><p>In my own experience, I think I learned a lot about social justice and involvement especially in high school. My school placed an emphasis on social justice and participating in social change. We did service but connected our experiences to our class material. In my senior year social justice theology class, our curriculum was based on examining social issues in relation to our service experiences. Having a space for reflection in my classes fostered a passion for working to make a change and being able to critically examine social justice problems. The pastoral program at La Inmaculada, while oriented toward building relationships with students across socioeconomic lines, also seems to share this purpose. Three steps in the <a href="https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B4YrkLKx4DUzczE4azI5czc2RDQ/view">Jesuit Pedagogical Paradigm</a> are: experience, reflection, and action. The experience from their relationships and the reflection from their classes theoretically enables students to act in the future. While not the primary intent of the pastoral program, it seems to me that a positive consequence of the program could be that students who have the ability and capacity to produce dramatic social change would recognize the stark inequality just over the Wall of Shame, if their spirit of activism was cultivated and fostered by their teachers at La Inmaculada.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*2tNihbdnsFokPBgZHB_9EA.jpeg" /><figcaption>The Pamplona Alta Section</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Pamplona Alta</strong></p><p>Perhaps one of my favorite parts of the trip was visiting Pamplona Alta. We were there for a short time and it was rainy (but really misty compared to Wisconsin weather) and muddy. We climbed the stairs, which wove their way up the mountain, and met with a woman who had recently opened up a tienda there. She was incredibly proud of the work she put in to opening her store, and it showed. We traveled from her store to the Casitas program, where the kids greeted us with hugs and handshakes. They worked on their homework and played in a small yet colorful room. While I wanted to stay, the students needed to get their work done, and we were on our way back to the bus, as it was getting late. On our way back, just over a retaining wall, I could see the scape of Pamplona Alta. It was incredibly foggy and gray, so only the first few rows of houses were remotely visible. The lights, however, I could see up the mountain, shining and gleaming despite the heavy fog. Here is the photograph that I took of that scene, and the one I used to paint this section.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*BmyUhWQ4yHZpGnQ80L1PyA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Pamplona Alta</figcaption></figure><p>In painting this section, I wanted to replicate the vibrant colors of the houses that only peaked through the fog at the very bottom and also the grayness of the fog that was moving and consuming all of the mountain. One of the challenges I faced in painting this section was the balance between letting the buildings towards the bottom peak through the fog but also have them be covered by some degree of grayness, like in the photograph. It took me several tries and layers of paint to accomplish this. However, my dissatisfaction with the original fog I painted and the need for re-layering reminded me of the Wall of Shame’s purpose, which Belen Desmaison describes in <a href="http://theconversation.com/limas-wall-of-shame-and-the-gated-communities-that-build-poverty-into-peru-53356">“Lima’s ‘Wall of Shame’ and the Gated Communities that Build Poverty into Peru.”</a> Desmaison notes that “the Wall of Shame was built to exclude poor and disadvantaged citizens from more affluent areas of the city… Pamplona Alta is one of the poorest neighborhoods in Lima.” The purposeful and physical barring of the poor from the rich was something I thought about a lot during my struggle to find balance in my painting of Pamplona Alta. I started off painting buildings rich in color and covered them in gray, dull fog. From my experience in Pamplona Alta, although short, I gathered that the community was hard-working and culturally vibrant, maybe not monetarily rich, but rich in other ways. The fog, like the Wall of Shame, swallowed and hid it from sight.</p><p>My decision to assign the Pamplona Alta section the question about equity in education is based off of the blatantly obvious inequality that exists between Pamplona Alta and Sucro, physically separated only by a wall. Before I attempt to discuss equity in education, I want to distinguish equity from equality, a difference which came up in one of our seminars. When talking about equality, it is the idea that everyone gets the same thing. Equity, however, is not about having the same thing, it is about having what is needed to enjoy the same quality of life as another person. When considering race, socioeconomic status, gender, religion, and a multiplicity of factors, implementing measures to achieve equality may not always accurately achieve the goal of equity.</p><p>Like when discussing a high quality education, I do not believe that increasing access to material gains in education is enough to obtain equity in education. Adding new technology and implementing a better curriculum is only one part in a complicated process. In Gloria Ladson-Billings article, <a href="https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B4YrkLKx4DUzeXRhYmhRTngwZGM/view?usp=sharing">“Landing on the Wrong Note: The Price We Paid for Brown,”</a> the disconnect between equality and equity is something she considers. Ladson-Billings argues that one of the problems with <em>Brown vs. Board of Education </em>(1954) was that it dealt with the surface-level issue of the fact that separate but equal is inherently unequal. <em>Brown</em> ruled in favor of integrating schools, rightfully so, but the ways in which desegregation was implemented had several flaws. Instead of focusing on the education students were receiving, the ruling was focused mainly on fixing the fact that schools were segregated. While trying to be equal, it was not equitable. The <em>Brown</em> ruling had many unintended consequences. Importantly, Ladson-Billings notes that “had the Supreme Court’s remedy focused on the quality of education students received, White working class and poor students could have been folded into the classroom in a way that might benefit them rather than underscore the adversarial relationship between Blacks and Whites” (<a href="https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B4YrkLKx4DUzeXRhYmhRTngwZGM/view?usp=sharing">page 8</a>). In focusing on the quality of education in addition to the issue of segregated schools, <em>Brown</em> would have been more effective in dealing with racism and resistance. Ladson-Billings’ argument reminds me of equity in education because her assessment argues that the Supreme Court ruling, while entirely necessary, would have been more effective if it would have encompassed more than integrating schools. I find this argument applicable to the question of equity in education as well because simply handing poorer schools newer technology and a better curriculum may make it equal, but because these schools may not be pace with other schools in different ways, these additions may not make education truly equitable.</p><p>One way that I think education could be more equitable is by tailoring curriculum and teaching to be context specific. This means that every sixth grade classroom in a district will not look the same, but they should not look the same because the students in each of those classroom will be different. As I mentioned when talking about a high quality education, student assets and contextual assets need to be considered. In the narrative inquiry, <a href="http://0-search.ebscohost.com.libus.csd.mu.edu/login.aspx?direct=true&amp;db=ehh&amp;AN=133263749&amp;site=eds-live">“Gloria Ladson-Billings: Igniting Student Learning Through Teacher Engagement in Culturally Relevant Pedagogy,”</a> the authors discuss Ladson-Billings’ perspective on equity in education in regard to cultural and student context. They note Ladson-Billings’ emphasis on teachers being aware of their students’ lives outside of school and they cite her as follows: “different children have different needs and addressing those different needs is the best way to deal with them equitably… the same is true in the classroom — if teachers pretend not to see students’ racial and ethnic differences, [teachers]… are limited in their ability to meet their educational needs” (<a href="http://0-search.ebscohost.com.libus.csd.mu.edu/login.aspx?direct=true&amp;db=ehh&amp;AN=133263749&amp;site=eds-live">page 25</a>). One of the limitations of <em>Brown </em>that Ladson-Billings mentions in <a href="https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B4YrkLKx4DUzeXRhYmhRTngwZGM/view?usp=sharing">“Landing on the Wrong Note,”</a> is that desegregation resulted in job loss for Black teachers. During the <em>Plessy </em>era, when school segregation was legal, Black teachers were able to integrate and weave their culture into their classrooms for their students. When <em>Brown </em>was enacted, Black students integrated with White students and White teachers, who knew little about incorporating various cultural identities into the classroom. That is not to say that the Supreme Court’s decision in <em>Brown </em>was wrong, but it did not account for these contextual and student assets; consequently, it isolated students while trying to include them. Avoiding this mistake and, instead, accounting for various assets contributes to making education equitable for students because it validates who they are and creates an open and inclusive learning environment.</p><p>One of the arguments for achieving equity in education is to better our public schools. The response I have heard to this answer is: why not just send your child to a private school? However, there are many misconceptions about the difference in the educational effectiveness of public and private schools. As the article, <a href="https://www.usnews.com/news/best-countries/articles/2016-08-09/worldwide-public-education-is-up-for-sale">“Worldwide, Public Education is Up for Sale,”</a> discusses, the flaws in public schooling are being used to advocate for increased privatization. The article notes the rise in privatization and also some important results: the advent of charter schools and voucher programs. However, despite the push for private schooling, student results do not necessarily correlate with its promises. Balarin’s paper, <a href="http://www.periglobal.org/sites/periglobal.org/files/WP65%20Peru.pdf">“The Default Privatization of Peruvian Education and the Rise of Low-Fee Private Schools,”</a> addresses this point. Balarin notes that “Peruvian test results show that private schools located in areas with high concentrations of pupils from poorer families tend to have similarly low, and in some cases worse results than public schools operating in those same areas” (<a href="http://www.periglobal.org/sites/periglobal.org/files/WP65%20Peru.pdf">page 12</a>). That trend is not unique to Peru, it’s applicable to the United States as well. I have spent my entire life in private schooling and, even before knowing the comparative statistics about public and private school performance, I would not have said that, because my high school was private and Catholic, it directly impacted my ACT score. Instead, my academic performance was directly impacted by the dedication and work of my teachers and the administration, in addition to my personal commitment to my education. Consequently, equity in education has little to do about where a school gets funding, but equity is a systemic issue. However, I do think that schools have the ability to counteract the broader problems on their own. One way they can do this is through their mission and commitment to student achievement. I realize that this sounds idealized, but I believe that administrative commitment to actively bettering their students’ school experience is essential. In my opinion, Fe y Alegria seemed to be committed to this. As I already mentioned, the Jesuit social project and mission at Fe y Alegria seemed intent on giving their students a holistic education that, in some ways, seemed more impactful and beneficial than what I saw at more privileged schools in Lima. However, Fe y Alegria is a charter school with the Jesuits playing an important role in the students’ education. I am not suggesting that Jesuit control over education is necessary to produce a kind of equity in education, I am merely advocating for replicating the concept of <em>cura personalis </em>and administrative commitment to student achievement in a secular fashion.</p><p>My time in Peru has changed the way I think about education and my role as an educator. It has introduced me to a new culture, language, and place that I may have never known. I miss Peru immensely, but I know that I will take what I learned with me and use my experiences to better myself, my pedagogy, and add a different depth to my future classroom.</p><p><strong>Print Work Cited</strong></p><p>Landsman, Julie. <em>A White Teacher Talks About Race. </em>Lanham, Rowman &amp; Littlefield Education, 2009.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2a9cc5ecef56" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/marquette-meets-peru/to-withstand-an-earthquake-2a9cc5ecef56">To Withstand an Earthquake</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/marquette-meets-peru">Marquette Meets Peru</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Schools…Are They Failing?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/marquette-meets-peru/schools-are-they-failing-7d13cccdd8e7?source=rss-426d68a66a58------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7d13cccdd8e7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[schools]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[peru]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[privatization]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[inequality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Brooke McArdle]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 19 Jun 2019 00:28:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-06-19T00:28:00.668Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>We spent this past week in Cuzco, moving around a lot to visit our last school and afterschool program, as well as visit various ruins and experience more of the Andean culture. I did not know what to expect from Cuzco and I did not realize how much I missed the sun! During our time in Lima, we had only a few hours of sun on one Saturday; however, in Cuzco, I think it was sunny almost every day. Our bus trips up, down and around mountains as well as our train rides made me feel like I was in another country because it was so different from Lima. The geography, languages, weather, and culture all differed from what I had experienced in Lima with my host family and while visiting our different educational contexts there.</p><p>Cuzco was mountainous, open and sunny, whereas Lima was congested, the air was polluted, sky cloudy, and car horns could be heard at all hours. Spanish, while it was dominant in Lima, seemed to wrestle with Quechua in Cuzco, linguistically and culturally. These differences were only replicated and echoed in the schools and educational contexts in both Lima and Cuzco. One thing that we saw in both contexts was how privatization impacts education. In Lima, we worked at La Inmaculada for a week and in Andahuaylillas we spent time at Fe y Alegria, both schools have some degree of Jesuit influence. Fe y Alegria is a public school, but more so of a charter school, as the Jesuits fund the social programs for the school.</p><p>The mission of La Inmaculada, in the spirit of Jesuit pedagogy, is whole person formation with an emphasis on social justice. One of the ways La Inmaculada cultivates this is through the service learning program, which I’ve mentioned in another blog. The purpose of the service learning program is to build relationships between students from Pamplona Alta and La Inmaculada. One of the key aspects of the <a href="https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B4YrkLKx4DUzczE4azI5czc2RDQ/view">Jesuit Pedagogical Paradigm</a> is experience, a way to tie in what students learn in the classroom to their personal lives. Creating relationships with students in Pamplona Alta provides students at La Inmaculada with not only friendships but insights into what they learn about in school. This was one of the important aspects of Jesuit education at La Inmaculada.</p><p>A central component of the mission of Fe y Alegria was perpetuating and reinforcing the existence of Quechua culture in students’ lives. During our orientation to Fe y Alegria, we watched a video that detailed the importance of integrating Quechua culture into the curriculum. Classes for the younger students begin in Quechua and bilingual education (Quechua and Spanish) begins in older grades. Students learn traditional practices from Andean culture, like dying yarn and weaving. In one of the classes that I observed, the teacher asked the students about their connection to Quechua. She asked how many of the students’ parents spoke Quechua, and majority of the students raised their hands. She then asked how many of the students spoke Quechua, and one student raised their hand. She then proceeded to ask her students why they did not speak Quechua. From the students’ responses and what we have learned about the perception of Quechua and Andean culture, it was clear that parents did not want their children learning Quechua because of the dominance of Spanish and the perception that Spanish is better. The Jesuit mission at Fe y Alegria is to break these perceptions and stereotypes about Quechua and work with families and students to incorporate it into students’ lives. Although both La Inmaculada and Fe y Alegria have Jesuit influence, their missions differ because of their contexts. While La Inmaculada works to provide its students with experiential learning and emphasize the importance of relationships through its service learning program, Fe y Alegria concentrates its attention on the importance and relevance of Quechua, the culture and language prominent, but also preyed upon, in the Andes. The different contexts of Lima and Cuzco play an important role in determining the direction and aims of education for schools in these areas.</p><p>In addition to context, privatization was something we saw with La Inmaculada and Fe y Alegria. The article <a href="https://www.usnews.com/news/best-countries/articles/2016-08-09/worldwide-public-education-is-up-for-sale">“Worldwide, Public Education is Up for Sale,”</a> by US News, discusses the possible ramifications of privatization. The article discusses how public education is under attack and notes how many people argue that public education is failing so as to advocate for increased privatization of education. However, the article discusses how privatization does not necessarily mean better quality education and better outcomes. It offers the example of Chile, where privatization led students “to self-segregate by religion, social class, race, and family income,” which hurt students and outcomes <a href="https://www.usnews.com/news/best-countries/articles/2016-08-09/worldwide-public-education-is-up-for-sale">(page 3)</a>. Cabalin’s article, <a href="http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.1011.4194&amp;rep=rep1&amp;type=pdf">“Neoliberal Education and Student Movements in Chile: Inequalities and Malaise,”</a> also looks at Chile and the impact of neoliberalism and privatization. Cabalin discusses how neoliberalism in education has resulted in the increased privatization of education and thus, disregarded the concept of a just education. In Chile, privatization resulted in more segregation and the further allocation of privileges to the wealthy. The resulting stratification has not bettered the quality of education. In turn, it has generated more inequality. Since the Jesuits play an important role at both La Inmaculada and Fe y Alegria, it is important to consider these schools within the context of privatization. At these schools, the Jesuit mission and its goals for the students are woven throughout the curriculum and schooling experience. Without the Jesuit influence, I doubt the students at La Inmaculada would build relationships with students from Pamplona Alta and I question whether Quechua would hold a privileged place at Fe y Alegria.</p><p>In the United States, I’ve heard privatization discussed in the context of outcomes, namely the idea that children educated in private schools perform better. However, this is a misconception, and one that has consequences for equity in education. In Peru, private influence at La Inmaculada did seem oriented to outcomes but with the shadow of Jesuit pedagogy, embodied in supplemental programs, lurking in the background. Conversely, at Fe y Alegria, Jesuit influence seemed more concerned with the incorporation and survival of culture and language native to the Andes, in addition to student success and outcomes. To me, this was another contextual difference between Lima and Cuzco, and one that is incredibly important. The emphasis on preserving and respecting culture is something I loved seeing at Fe y Alegria and it was not something that was only espoused, I physically was able to see it at work in the classroom. As a teacher, care and recognition of culture is something that I want to always be aware of and working towards because I think it is one of the ways that teachers can connect to students and their families in a genuine way.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7d13cccdd8e7" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/marquette-meets-peru/schools-are-they-failing-7d13cccdd8e7">Schools…Are They Failing?</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/marquette-meets-peru">Marquette Meets Peru</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Adios Lima]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/marquette-meets-peru/adios-lima-f8100854a5b7?source=rss-426d68a66a58------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f8100854a5b7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[peru]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Brooke McArdle]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 09 Jun 2019 03:47:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-06-09T03:47:57.783Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I truly cannot believe how fast our time in Lima has flown by. It seems crazy to me that soon we will be on a plane to Cuzco, having completed three of our four weeks in Peru. My time in Peru has been amazing and also challenging for a variety of reasons. I have enjoyed getting to know the culture and the people, as well as picking up on whatever Spanish I am able. In addition, I have definitely felt linguistically inadequate several times on this trip, which is difficult to deal with, especially in settings were everything is in Spanish. With all of these different experiences and feelings, my third week in Lima is drawing to a close and I have had the opportunity to learn a lot about the different educational contexts here and also have been able to connect them with what I’ve experienced not only as a pre-service teacher, but also as a student.</p><p>We have been able to partake in a variety of educational experiences, each uniquely structured to fit the context and students which they serve. Two of the different experiences we worked with this week were: Tupac Amaru and Lombriz Feliz. As I discussed in my previous blog post, Tupac Amaru is a public school, geared to prepare their students to work in a trade for the betterment of their local community. Contextually, this approach for schooling is practical because the goal is to help the community flourish as a whole. Having students who can participate in and help their community with their trade has a positive effect on the advancement of the community. One of the things that we have talked a lot about in seminar and that has stuck with me is the idea of creativity and curiosity in education. In the article, <a href="https://www.thenewatlantis.com/publications/shop-class-as-soulcraft">“Shop Class as Soulcraft,”</a> Matthew Crawford discusses the importance of manual labor in education and its connection to cultivating creativity. Crawford describes the connection that exists between the self and the product of manual work, specifically how the product of manual labor emulates its maker, a humanizing process. Therefore, Crawford makes the argument that this manifestation then enables the maker to engage creatively with their world. Consequently, he argues that critical thinking stems from manual labor and crafts, both of which we deprive students of in our schools. At Tupac Amaru, the trade is the center of the curriculum and students are encouraged to connect with their trade to explore their creativity and expression. For example, in the metalworking classroom, students welded scorpions, elephants, or bicycles, which were, as Crawford would argue, expressions of themselves. While there is a practical aspect of this type of education, it also enables students to explore their world through their own abilities and interests, making their education even more relevant for the students.</p><p>In addition to this experience, we also visited Lombriz Feliz this week. Lombriz Feliz is a community composting organization just on the outskirts of Lima. They were started in 1991 with the intent of minimizing waste and organizing their waste management. A group of German missionaries worked side by side with the community to begin a composting program. Since then, Lombriz Feliz has thrived, producing organic humus that helps plants better grow in the desert climate of Lima. The organization has also been asked to educate other communities, including wealthier communities, about how to compost successfully. One of the things that I really enjoyed learning about Lombriz Feliz is how the community came together to recognize and solve a problem. With the help of the missionaries, the community worked democratically to better itself. The Chavez and Soep article <a href="https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Y2hU-D-vG_Oi1B8C9YTSpJP3ClZFI8vM/view?usp=sharing">“Youth Radio and the Pedagogy of Collegiality”</a> discusses the implications of educational relationships rooted in interdependence. The authors explain that the Youth Media program is meant to encourage shared interest and investment in a final product, which then creates not only a more robust product but also a relationship and community. The experience at Lombriz Feliz is based on this type of teaching and learning experience. The ideology behind Lombriz Feliz is communal advancement not only through participation, but by working together. Their composting requires the active participation of community members to continue the process. Consequently, the educational structure of Lombriz Feliz is relationally based and emphasizes the importance of both personal and communal contributions.</p><p>The approaches of Tupac Amaru and Lombriz Feliz demonstrate different approaches to learning than the traditional banking system of education that Freire discusses in <a href="https://drive.google.com/open?id=0B9K8OLyuF8_TZWNRZmF1aFhQWEE">“Pedagogy of Freedom.”</a> Personally, I believe that a classroom should incorporate components of both. I think that capitalizing on student creativity and curiosity is essential, which Crawford suggests can be accomplished through manual labor and crafts. Allowing students to actively participate in their education through creative engagement is crucial in helping the students to maximize their full potential. Additionally, redefining the relationship between teachers and students is also important for allowing this creativity and potential to take shape in schools. Education should not be about menial bits and pieces of information but about creating confident and capable learners who are able to engage with others and their world. Consequently, teachers should provide relevance, emphasize personal value, and exist to guide students in their own self-actualization.</p><p>In connection with my own educational experiences, these are two aspects that I wish I would have seen more of in my primary and secondary education and even at university. Personally, I think younger grades tend to emphasize creativity more. I remember these classes being filled with the type of hands on work that Crawford describes, where I was encouraged to explore and create what I thought was relevant to my education in the context of the given assignment. As I got older, however, rote memorization and templated assignments and essays became the new normal. Similarly, throughout my whole educational experience, I have had few teachers who have treated their classroom as a collaborative space where teachers and students work together to learn. Instead, the teacher is the sole authority and the students are expected to observe and respect this hierarchy. With my experiences in mind, I want to take both of these aspects, cultivating an environment ripe for creativity and working side by side with students, and implement them in my future classroom because I feel that these are two key components for helping my students thrive.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f8100854a5b7" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/marquette-meets-peru/adios-lima-f8100854a5b7">Adios Lima</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/marquette-meets-peru">Marquette Meets Peru</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Same Number of Students]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/marquette-meets-peru/the-same-number-of-students-a4aafc8f751c?source=rss-426d68a66a58------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a4aafc8f751c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[educational-inequality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[peru]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Brooke McArdle]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 04 Jun 2019 21:16:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-06-07T16:03:51.050Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>When the question about the importance of education is posed, I feel that the answer for many is often confining. Many times I feel that the social construct and ideas about education are too influenced by stereotypes and stigmas surrounding gender, race, socioeconomic status, et cetera. One thing I’ve taken away from my experiences this week is that the answer, while completely individualized for each person, could be broadly described as “progress.”</p><p>The idea of progress from education looks very different, as we have seen, across different contexts. For instance, we spent last week at La Inmaculada, a Jesuit school, where progress was directly tied to the tenets of Ignatian Pedagogy. For example, the idea of whole person education through service was one of the components of the mission statement that Father Oscar emphasized. He, and Javier later, discussed the service learning experiences that all students participate in at La Inmaculada. He described the relational aspect of this type of service learning, not necessarily the idea of doing physical work or service to benefit those who are less fortunate. Instead, the service learning program relies on and works to build meaningful relationships between the La Inmaculada students and students from surrounding areas. In the article “<a href="https://drive.google.com/file/d/1IqDuq-2LJ0KPOMt_L1mVBReLJ2JtgGzV/view?usp=sharing">Educating the Spirit of Activism: A ‘Critical’ Civic Education</a>” written by Quentin Wheeler-Bell, the author describes the problems with what he calls “isolated activism,” or the passive, private acts of affecting change while distancing oneself from social movements on the larger scale. Isolated activism is exemplified by volunteering and donating in a privatized way. Conversely, Wheeler-Bell outlines the spirit of activism, which is, in a sense, an enlightened view about injustice and social justice. He notes the importance of conscious action and understanding injustice on order to cultivate a spirit of activism. Consequently, to act on an injustice and affect social change, students need to be aware of injustices, their causes, and potential problems in cultivating change. I think this idea of the spirit of activism relates to the Jesuit Pedagogy and the idea at La Inmaculada that service is much more than the volunteering and inconsequential acts of physical labor; instead, it involves a relational component that better enables students from both contexts to understand the injustices that surround them in a more robust way. This is one, among many, of the ways that I see La Inmaculada and the Jesuit mission emulating the idea of progress stemming from education.</p><p>Our visit yesterday to Tupac Amaru, a public school in Villa Maria del Triunfo, I think also demonstrated the purpose of education as progress, but in a different way because of the socioeconomic context, in addition to the other contexts, of the students. What we learned from our tour was that one of the primary reasons for education at Tupac Amaru is to provide students with the life skills needed to contribute to their family and society. The chapter written by Harry Brighouse, entitled “<a href="https://drive.google.com/open?id=0B4YrkLKx4DUzZWhTTm1UV2E5Mjg">Moral and Political Aims of Education</a>,” discusses a variety of aims for education. One aim that I think connects well to the context of Tupac Amaru is contributory effectiveness. Brighouse describes contributory effectiveness as enabling students to use their talents to become contributing members of an economy and society. Therefore, this aim emphasizes not only self-reliance but cooperation and how they are codependent on each other, meaning that communal flourishing is dependent on individual talent but also collective participation. Tupac Amaru was focused on preparing students for the trades. For example, their curriculum was structured similarly to a technical school, with paths in sewing, woodworking, cosmetology, metalworking, and cooking. From early on, the students get to have a variety of experiences in different trades, but as they progress, they begin to specialize. This specialization is meant to prepare them to be contributing members of society, where they can utilize practical skills to support themselves, their families, and their community. This, while different from the education context we saw at La Inmaculada, is also a form of progress, though tailored specifically to the socioeconomic status and needs of the community in which the students live.</p><p>At Tupac Amaru, I noticed that the trades seemed to be implicitly gendered. While boys and girls were present in all of the trade classrooms we visited, I saw that trades deemed traditionally female by society had more girls and vice versa. Although the students get to choose their trade and path, I wonder how much power and influence they personally have in this decision. In the Brighouse article, he describes the constraints of education, namely parental and child-centered. For example, I wonder how much a girl’s decision is influenced by their parents’ preferences and expectations. Additionally, I would add another category of constraints to the ones that Brighouse poses, notably, societal constraints. Undoubtedly, traditional views for what trades girls and boys should pursue infiltrate the minds of students everywhere, not just in Villa Maria del Triunfo and not just in Peru. Therefore, I was curious about where majority of the influence for girls’ and boys’ decisions comes from and how much agency is present for the students versus what is implicitly or explicitly imposed upon them.</p><p>In addition to La Inmaculada and Tupac Amaru, we have also spent time at PEA (Programa Educacion Alternativa) and Casitas in El Agustino. PEA is a secondary alternative education program for those ages 16–40 who have not completed, but want to complete, their secondary education. The students come three times a week from 6:30–10:30 p.m. to learn. The purpose of PEA is to allow students, who may not have fit into a traditional educational context, to have the ability to complete their education. Additionally, once finished with the accelerated program, it opens doors for the students to attend technical schools and obtain a better job. Casitas is an after school program for children with the purpose of keeping the students off the streets and engaged in positive activities that steer them away from violence and drugs. Therefore, both of these contexts also can be seen in the framework of progress. PEA is an alternative program with the hope of providing students with access to progress, not only in their individual learning, but also afterwards. While Casitas may not appear to aim for progress like traditional schooling with a set curriculum, the idea of having a place for children to go after school guides the students to engage with positive activities and practices, thus keeping them from slipping.</p><p>My experiences in Peru so far have shown me that educational contexts may look different but tend to center around universal goals for their students. The contexts we’ve observed have helped me to understand the different purposes of education specific to varying contexts. While I’ve paid particular attention to the idea of student progress, there are many others as well. All of these different experiences have definitely made me question educational equality and the purpose of education. At La Inmaculada, I felt myself quickly assimilating to the overt display and prevalence of wealth, as I did at Roosevelt today. Whereas at Tupac Amaru, I was struck by the government’s inability to fund basic necessities for the students. One example of this difference was that at both Tupac Amaru and Roosevelt, each school has about 1,800 students. The available resources for students at each school differed dramatically. Size of the campus, extracurriculars, curriculum, and opportunities for students each fit the contexts of the community in which the schools served, but disproportionately enabled students of a higher socioeconomic status to have ample opportunity to succeed and pursue autonomy in their own education; conversely, students at Tupac Amaru had limited options to pursue a trade from which the community could universally benefit from. To me, it was frustrating to see how schools with the same number of students are better equipped or not to provide for their students in different ways. Additionally, it made me wonder about how the idea of progress connects and is affected by the lack of resources and educational inequality.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a4aafc8f751c" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/marquette-meets-peru/the-same-number-of-students-a4aafc8f751c">The Same Number of Students</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/marquette-meets-peru">Marquette Meets Peru</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>