<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Ben Dolman on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Ben Dolman on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@btdolman?source=rss-c43cdd35cdac------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 11:37:15 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@btdolman/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[California Shruggin’: ‘Hippie’ as Culture or Mere Fragmentation?]]></title>
            <link>https://btdolman.medium.com/california-shruggin-hippie-as-culture-or-mere-fragmentation-685e049c3fa5?source=rss-c43cdd35cdac------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/685e049c3fa5</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[joan-didion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[new-journalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hippies]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ben Dolman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 10 Oct 2026 04:25:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-10T04:49:50.665Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Reflections on Joan Didion, New Journalism and the Myth of Counterculture</h3><p><em>Turning and turning in the widening gyre</em></p><p><em>The falcon cannot hear the falconer</em></p><p><em>Things fall apart; the centre cannot hold</em></p><p><em>Mere anarchy is loosed upon the world</em></p><p>W.B. Yeats, “The Second Coming”, 1919.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/977/1*0MgCFzZA4jf38pbcBKzV4A.png" /></figure><p>Joan Didion arrives in San Francisco in 1967 to a society pregnant with dreams but hollowing through decadence. The “Summer of Love” was being named even as it unfolded, narrated in advance as the emergence of a coherent counterculture defined by peace, community, and transcendence.</p><p>Didion is immediately sceptical of this coherence. What she encounters instead is a scene with know centre, no unifying sense of value or indeed a sense of value at all, a social space where inherited scripts had lost authority but no new ones had taken their place. The Haight-Ashbury appears not as a unified culture but as a loose gathering of people living among ruins, sustained more by atmosphere than by conviction. Where the contemporary civil rights movement sought to build new institutions, laws and coherence, ‘hippie’ seeks decay and withdrawal. What binds hippie experience together is not a revolution, nor a political project to build a community, but rather the desire to shrug.</p><p>This essay argues that <em>Slouching Towards Bethlehem </em>(1967) demonstrates there was no hippie ‘movement’ or ‘counterculture’ in California set on building something greater, only disparate responses to social breakdown. In the anthropological sense, Kroeber and Kluckholn writing in 1952 suggest, a culture requires a shared system of beliefs, values and institutions and mechanisms of continuity and ongoing innovation. What Didion finds instead is a space where structure has been quietly abandoned. Norms and boundaries are absent as is an aspiration for permanence. Lives drift in isolation or at most within small groups whose collaboration extends as far as sharing bread but not so far as caring about each other’s health and safety.</p><p>Didion’s method is central to this claim. She does not generalise, categorise, or theorise; she watches. The Haight emerges through fragments: overheard conversations, domestic interiors, transient encounters, street theatre and contemporary communiques. In doing so, Didion both dismantles the myth of a singular counterculture and exemplifies a distinctive strand of the New Journalism that mirrors fragmentation rather than conquering it. Her later <em>The White Album</em> (1979) returns to the subject, after a decade of separation, reflection and wisdom, and finds there was really never anything there at all.</p><h3>Slouching Towards Bethlehem, 1967</h3><p><em>Slouching</em> has often been read as a definitive account of a Californian hippie movement, but its force lies precisely in the opposite: it refuses to stabilise the hippie experience into a single, coherent object of analysis. Didion argues that the unity of the Haight was visual rather than cultural. She uses a technique of juxtaposition, placing the vibrant “long hair, beads, [and] music” against the visceral “stale air”, “unmade beds” and rampant drug use of the domestic interiors. By focusing on details, her prose mimics the fragmented quality of the era. The beads and music offer a shimmering projection, but the unmade beds make clear the physical decay and abdication of responsibility she actually found.</p><p>One of Didion’s most unsettling discoveries is the disappearance of adulthood as a meaningful category. Children run away to San Francisco because they have heard it is a place where no one will tell you what to do. Teenage girls take LSD under the supervision of other teenagers, and parental authority survives only as a rumour. A Haight Street inhabitant Otto extends an invitation kindly. “I got something at my place that will blow your mind”. Didion finds a child clad in reefer garb, licking her white-lipstick covered lips. “Five years old. On acid”.</p><p>The condition for adults can hardly be described as any better. The social safety net one might expect a community to extend to its members is entirely absent. Elsewhere on the Street, Didion finds:“The room is overheated and the girl on the floor is sick. Deadeye says she has been sleeping for twenty-four hours now. ‘Lemme ask you something,’ he says. ‘You want some grass?’”</p><p>A communique observes the “politics and ethics of ecstasy”:</p><p>“Rape is as common as bullshit on Haight Street. Kids are starving on the Street. Minds and bodies are being maimed as we watch, a scale model of Vietnam.”</p><p>A central diagnostic tool in <em>Slouching</em> is Didion’s recording of “linguistic drift”. She observes that words like “beautiful,” “together,” and “free” function as gestures of belonging rather than signifiers of stable experiences or shared standards. These words appear as isolated fragments in her prose. By slowing down the chaos she demonstrates that when language floats free of obligation it creates a vacuum.</p><p>This condition though often framed, both by participants and sympathetic observers, as freedom, Didion presents instead as abdication. People drift in and out. An ethic of letting it happen so long as you “don’t bum my trip” functions less as a philosophy than as a refusal to judge, intervene, or care.</p><p>Culture may grow from rebellion, but it requires a shared concept of value, responsibility as much as rejection. If there are shared values in the Haight, they are not liberation but passivity and nihilism — a belief in inaction even when harm is visible and that nothing really matters. One inhabitant notes as a significant piece of data, “God died last year and was obited by the press.” Another remarks “This chick tells me there’s no meaning to life but it doesn’t matter, we’ll just flow right out.” The concept that there is no value cannot sustain a culture; it can only suspend it temporarily. Didion shows repeatedly what happens when responsibility is no longer claimed by anyone. The hippie experience does not so much challenge authority as allow it to evaporate. Any sense of coherence is thin. The consequences of this evaporation are quietly devastating; the costs, Didion shows, are borne by those least able to absorb them.</p><p>For a time, the refusal of authority, judgment, and responsibility is supported by youth, novelty, and the illusion of infinite tolerance. Ultimately, the mirage of the hippie idea as a whole-life philosophy ended swiftly, marked by the killing at Altamont. “Last Drops” for LSD were called not by the ringing of a bell like “Last Drinks” in a bar, but by the tip of a biker’s switchblade. A culture organised around withdrawal had failed to crystallise. By this point, the rigid and stifling society that predated <em>Slouching</em> had been sufficiently ventilated; the old centre had loosened but much of it had held and nothing durable had replaced it. The outside idea of the hippie as a common cause, or even as a mere shared aesthetic, was no longer galvanising new adherents.</p><p>In this sense, <em>Slouching</em> does not portray a Californian society whose centre “cannot hold” so much as a hippie existence with no centre at all. It was incontinent, unable to contain the contradictions it had licensed, nor survive the violence it had refused to acknowledge.</p><h3>The White Album, 1979</h3><p>Didion’s thinking on these issues sharpens in <em>The White Album</em> which chronicles her experiences between 1968 and 1978 and particularly presenting the finality, the closure, of the 1960s. Figures once absorbed into scenes reappear as insulated participants in cultural drift. <em>The White Album</em> draws out the ethical implications of the fragmentation <em>Slouching</em> first records. A central idea is that people rely on stories to impose order on reality, but during this time those stories failed. The usual explanatory frameworks — politics, ideology, morality — collapse in the face of violence against self and others.</p><p>In <em>The White Album</em>, the landscape Didion saw as drift of the Haight in <em>Slouching</em> is instead distinguished by the senselessness of the violence. The hippie no longer appears as even a fragile collective illusion. In <em>Slouching</em> Didion records a mime troupe questioning the children of middle-class families wasting their youth at a concert: “thousands of un-white un-suburban boppers are going to want to know why you’ve given up what they can’t get”. <em>White Album</em> finds Didion willing to answer as she sees it: they don’t know why because there is no reason. Didion presents figures who have absorbed the hippie vocabulary while abandoning any expectation that it might organise action or responsibility. She portrays the campaigns of civil disobedience at San Francisco State as mere mutually agreed distraction, the coherence of the Black Panthers a foil for the atomisation of the hippies.</p><p>‘…only the black militants could be construed as serious: they were at any rate picking their games, dictating the rules and taking what they could from what seemed for everyone else just an amiable evasion of routine … Meanwhile the administrators could talk about programs. Meanwhile the white radicals could see themselves, on virtually no investment, as urban guerillas. It was working out well for everyone.’</p><p><em>Slouching</em> recorded a community dissolving in real time, while<em> White Album</em> takes dissolution as a given. <em>Slouching</em> records a social form already exhausting its own conditions of possibility: “the desperate attempt of a handful of pathetically unequipped children to create a community in a social vacuum.” The implications for a potential Hippie political movement were profound. The activists having seen these children “could no longer overlook the vacuum, no longer pretend that the [hippie] society’s atomisaton could be reversed.” Having abandoned the dream, <em>White Album</em> finds a hippie experience degenerated into sound and fury, signifying nothing, as MacBeth once quipped. <em>Slouching</em> finds an unsustainable hippie existence without a centre; <em>White Album</em> finds it has not been sustained but rather quietly abandoned, its energy redirected. The “stale air” of the 1967 Haight has curdled into the unresolved dread of the late 1960s.</p><p>Didion was not the only traveller on the journey. In <em>One-Dimensional Man</em> (1964), Marcuse presented the philosophical basis for hippie culture by arguing that only a total, lived refusal of consumerism, repressive morality, and instrumental reason — embodied in aesthetic, instinctual, and countercultural forms of life — can resist a society that absorbs and neutralises all conventional dissent. Yet by 1972 Marcuse found the hippie experience had been easily reabsorbed: rebellion turned into fashion; psychedelia into a consumer product; sexual liberation into commodified pornography; “dropping out” into lifestyle niches compatible with capitalism.</p><p>Ultimately, Didion illustrates from different perspectives the loss of narrative coherence in American life. Meaning is no longer reliable, causality breaks down, and the writer can only document fragments rather than tape them together. The essay’s form — disjointed, abrupt, unresolved — is itself the argument. A listing of events as short stories no longer connect logically: The Doors; the Black Panthers; mental illness; religion; and only finally the hippies.</p><h3>Joan Didion: Style and Literary Contribution</h3><p>Didion’s work must be understood within the context of New Journalism, itself a broad church. For the purposes of this essay, New Journalism can be understood as a mode of reportage that rejects strict objectivity in favour of immersion, narrative technique, and the incorporation of subjective experience, while retaining a commitment to factual observation. As Tom Wolfe argued in his 1973 manifesto, New Journalism employed literary devices traditionally associated with fiction — scene-by-scene construction, dialogue, and point of view — in order to render social reality with immediacy and psychological depth.</p><p>In <em>Slouching</em> her role as observer to make sense of the scene remains bound tightly by the factual shards of glass she observes.</p><p>“I am here on some unstated business… I am searching for the spirit of the age, but I keep finding only the things that are gone.”</p><p>This creates a distanced authority, where the lack of a redemption arc forces the reader to confront the messiness that long hair and beads were, perhaps, meant to hide. She reflected on her refusal to synthesise:</p><p>“I was meant to know the plot, but all I knew was what I saw: flash pictures in variable light… images of the incoherence to register without commentary.”</p><p>Yet, her approach contrasts sharply to contemporaries. Though unmistakably personal, Didion’s presence is restrained and analytical marking her divergence from both more flamboyant forms of New Journalism and conventional shallow reportage.</p><p>Hunter S. Thompson’s “maximalist” style relies on a volatile, participatory “I” and seeks to mirror the energy of the era through explosive punctuation and a frantic narrative pace. He sought meaning through immersion and excess, famously insisting on “buy[ing] the ticket” in order to “take the ride”. Once you choose to engage with the madness of life — or drugs, or counterculture, or any high‑risk endeavor — you must accept the consequences and fully experience it. Observer and participant collapse into a single volatile persona.</p><p>In <em>Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas — </em>itself a reflection on the collapse in The American Dream in the 1960s through decadence and drug dependence — Thompson captures this breakdown of the barrier between the journalist and the chaos he documents:</p><p>“We were somewhere around Barstow on the edge of the desert when the drugs began to take hold… And suddenly there was a terrible roar all around us and the sky was full of what looked like huge bats, all swooping and screeching and diving around the car… A drug person can learn to handle such things, but nobody can prepare you for a sight like that”.</p><p>Thompson later observed:</p><p>“I had no choice but to ride the wave of excess… the result was a classic affirmation of everything right and true and decent in the national character.”</p><p>Didion’s contribution to the movement was the inverse of Thompson’s. She uses subjectivity as an analytic tool. In <em>Slouching</em>, the “I” is not a protagonist but a lens that maintains distance. By using controlled, cool, and declarative sentences, she allows the incoherence she sees to register without commentary. Where Thompson’s prose is an affirmation of the chaos, Didion’s prose is a “scalpel” that cuts through it.</p><p>Writers such as Charles Bukowski’s journalism and prose cultivate an abrasive clarity. His contempt for euphemism produces blunt moral judgments. He deploys short, punchy syntax to strip away the floral illusions of the 1960s. In <em>Notes of a Dirty Old Man</em>, Bukowski captures the breakdown he sees without sentimentality:</p><p>“The ‘love’ generation was just another form of madness… a lot of people with nothing to do and nowhere to go, sitting around in the sun waiting for a miracle that was never going to happen.”</p><p>Bukowski employs this style deliberately:</p><p>“An intellectual says a simple thing in a hard way. An artist says a hard thing in a simple way.”</p><p>By contrast, Didion uses restraint to allow incoherence to speak for itself. If Didion wields a scalpel that makes fine incisions, Bukowski wields a “blunt” instrument. His direct denunciation contrasts with Didion’s detached record.</p><p>Didion’s journalism occupies a middle ground. Her authority derives from curiosity and honesty rather than from intoxication or bravado. Where Thompson amplifies chaos through acceleration, Didion slows it down. Where Bukowski tells the reader how to judge, Didion delivers everything they need to judge themselves. Her work neither collapses into nihilism nor retreats into detachment.</p><p>Didion famously noted that her sentences were an attempt to “shatter the telegraphic” and find the “rhythm” of the situation. She discusses this approach in “Why I Write” (1976), where she describes writing as an effort to discover “what I think, what I see, and what it means.” She doesn’t tell the reader that the scene is falling apart; she shows it through the “stale air” and the “unmade beds” of the Haight. Her task is to “document fragments rather than explain them”.</p><p>Didion’s style evolved. In <em>The White Album</em>, her controlled, cool, and declarative sentences remain, allowing incoherence to register the subjects move from “unmade beds” to “senseless violence”. But her confidence in <em>Slouching</em> to place herself in the <em>Corps de Ballet</em> had, by <em>White Album</em>, elevated her to <em>Prima</em>. As exemplified in her reportage on San Francisco State reproduced above, she has become less strictly parsimonious in offering interpretation — fermented through a decade of wisdom — though continues to frugally mind her pennies.</p><p>While these New Journalism styles diverge from each other they share an outright rejection of conventional reportage. They have a new and common purpose. New Journalism focuses on the experience of living as the subject; conventional reportage presents the image a casual passer by might see from the curb. Charles McCabe writing for The San Francisco Chronicle in 1967 offers:</p><p><em>“The hippies who are making the Haight-Ashbury the greatest tourist attraction in America next to maybe the Grand Canyon are another cup of tea altogether… Hippies wear pedantic garb, but they are clean. They go barefoot, but have a concern for their appearance that is theatrical. It is this solemn dedication to essential silliness, which makes the hippie scene the superb show it is.”</em></p><p>Other newspaper stories centred on the violation of health codes, the lack of housing, the potential for disease and riots, the clogged sidewalks and the expense of cleaning them. The lives of Haight residents are mere fodder to sustain the grievances of the municipality’s ruminants. There is little attempt to bridge the gap between the establishment and the hippies’ interior life.</p><p>Long-form journalism of the period instead manufactured coherence. A 1967 <em>Time</em> magazine cover story described hippies as:</p><p>“Whatever their meaning and wherever they may be headed, the hippies have emerged on the U.S. scene in about 18 months as a wholly new subculture, a bizarre permutation of the middle-class American ethos from which it evolved. Hippies preach altruism and mysticism, honesty, joy and nonviolence. They find an almost childish fascination in beads, blossoms and bells, blinding strobe lights and ear-shattering music, exotic clothing and erotic slogans. Their professed aim is nothing less than the subversion of Western society by “flower power” and force of example.”</p><p>Emma Griffin, writing in 2024, distils the <em>Time</em> view: young people “dropping out of a society they find sterile” and “turning on” through drugs and communal living,</p><p>Precisely who preaches to whom is unclear. Precisely who professes an aim of cultural subversion is similarly left dangling. One might read Didion and suggest, uncharitably, that the <em>Time</em> observations are left incomplete because they describe phenomena that never occurred. They falsely present withdrawal itself as a lifestyle, a shared philosophy, a movement, a counterculture because, perhaps, that is what they want it to be, while ignoring the fragile and often bleak reality that Didion documents that was governed by improvised choices.</p><p>Taken together, we see journalism itself became a microcosm of the broader cultural tensions — between imposing order and collapsing into chaos, engagement and withdrawal, conservatism and humanism.</p><h3>Cohering</h3><p>From the outside, the hippie experience seemed to be the beginnings of something. An experiment with a new way of living. A beacon to guide much needed change of a broader, calcified society.</p><p>Didion was one of many writing on the hippie experience at the time but one of the few writing from the inside. Her dry accumulation of facts, snapshots, stories, tragedies and encounters was presented haphazardly and free of expectation, moral opprobrium, coherence into a narrative. Yet the sober reader could not avoid reaching their own conclusion: that the images from the outside, whether theatrical farce or shared counterculture, were disconnected from the experience of life as a hippie. A harbinger of broader social and cultural change perhaps, but certainly not a catalyst to achieving it. What Didion saw lacked any shared system of beliefs, value, or desire for permanence. The falseness of the casual social narrative of a culture soon became evident to hippie activists who descended into violence as distraction and evasion of routine; by the late 1960s it was clear to all.</p><p>Whatever the hippie experience was, if it were anything meaningful at all, Didion’s writing made clear that it was never an emerging, coherent counterculture.</p><h3>The Naturalization of Fragmentation: A Coda</h3><p><em>That twenty centuries of stony sleep</em></p><p><em>Were vexed to nightmare by a rocking cradle</em></p><p><em>And what rough beast, its hour come round at last</em></p><p><em>Slouches towards Bethlehem to be born?</em> — W. B. Yeats, “The Second Coming”, 1919</p><p>Ultimately, Didion’s essays reveal that there was no coherent hippie culture in California, but a fragmentation of society in response to social uncertainty. By resisting caricature and attending to contradiction, she dismantled the myth of unity that was errantly portrayed at the time and, perhaps unfortunately, has come to define popular nostalgia for of the 1960s as innocence, lost. Her work endures not because it explains, but because it records — and refuses to pretend it ever coheres.</p><p>What remains today is fragmentation, naturalised. Freedom to be, freedom to think, freedom to love. Yet Kennedy’s 1963 plea to ask “what you can do for your country” would fall on deaf ears today, out of step, irrelevant. Other hippie tenets have been crushed between the cogs of capitalism as urban streets fill with lycra-clad yogini clinging to anti-bacterial matting as prophylactic against oneness with the universe.</p><p>Similarly, the role of the journalist as a narrator of personal experience — a “living character” within the story — has been naturalized into the fabric of modern media. The “I” that Didion used as a restrained, diagnostic tool has evolved into the ubiquitous subjectivity of the digital age. The flows of advertising revenue to fund conventional newsroom reporting dried up. Paying customers expect personalised opinion writers that make the effort to understand their subject and present issues within their own prism without apology. Nobody needs to be told what the passer-by sees; the curbside view is abundant, merely a Google search away. Even the future of this evolved New Journalism as a profession is under strain as world experts dispatch the same product in the free blogosphere in volume even the most insatiable reader cannot hope to ingest.</p><p>Didion’s work remains instructive as a model of how to observe without pretending that observation resolves uncertainty. In this sense, Didion appears as both a chronicler of a vanished moment and as a precursor to contemporary media conditions. Didion’s insistence on fragmentation and refusing explanatory comfort anticipates a media landscape in which the collapse of shared narrative authority she documents now defines the information environment itself. Today coherence is optional, customised, and algorithmically distributed. Like the Californian society of the 1960s, the centre of professional, modern journalism struggles to hold as the few remaining journalists continue the slouch towards Bethlehem. But perhaps I have erred in pretending too much structure where there are only disparate journalistic experiences?</p><p><strong>Approximate Word Count (excluding bibliography):</strong> 3750 words</p><h3>Works Cited</h3><p>Bukowski, Charles. <em>Notes of a Dirty Old Man</em>. City Lights, 1969.</p><p>Didion, Joan. “Why I Write.” <em>The New York Times Book Review</em>, 5 Dec. 1976, pp. 2, 98–99.</p><p>Didion, Joan. <em>Slouching Towards Bethlehem</em>. Farrar, Straus &amp; Giroux, 1968.</p><p>Didion, Joan. <em>The White Album</em>. Simon &amp; Schuster, 1979.</p><p>Griffin, Emma. <em>The Unraveling: America in the 1960s</em>. Yale University Press, 2024.</p><p>Kennedy, John F. “Inaugural Address.” <em>20 Jan. 1961</em>. <em>John F. Kennedy Presidential Library and Museum</em>,<br> <a href="http://www.jfklibrary.org/archives/other-resources/john-f-kennedy-speeches/inaugural-address-19610120">www.jfklibrary.org/archives/other-resources/john-f-kennedy-speeches/inaugural-address-19610120</a></p><p>Kroeber, A. L., and Clyde Kluckhohn. <em>Culture: A Critical Review of Concepts and Definitions</em>. Vintage Books, 1952.</p><p>McCabe, Charles. “The Love Ghetto.” <em>San Francisco Chronicle</em>, 23 Mar. 1967, p. 39.</p><p>Shakespeare, William. <em>Macbeth</em>. Edited by Nicholas Brooke, Oxford UP, 1990.</p><p>Thompson, Hunter S. <em>Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas: A Savage Journey to the Heart of the American Dream</em>. Random House, 1971.</p><p>Time Magazine. “The Hippies: Philosophy of a Subculture.” <em>Time</em>, vol. 90, no. 1, 7 July 1967, pp. 18–22.</p><p>Time Magazine. “Youth: The Hippies.” <em>Time</em>, 7 July 1967, <a href="https://time.com/archive/6834539/youth-the-hippies/">time.com/archive/6834539/youth-the-hippies/</a>.</p><p>Wolfe, Tom. <em>The New Journalism</em>. Harper &amp; Row, 1973.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=685e049c3fa5" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How does immigration affect the wages of native-born workers?]]></title>
            <link>https://btdolman.medium.com/how-does-immigration-affect-the-wages-of-native-born-workers-3c8aad19a00f?source=rss-c43cdd35cdac------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3c8aad19a00f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[migration]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[labor-economics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ben Dolman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 16 May 2026 05:25:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-05-19T07:08:28.355Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Immigration brings an inflow of skills</strong></p><p>Migrants play a large role in Australia’s economy. Australia has one of the most multicultural advanced economies, with around one-third of residents born overseas. The effect of migrants with new skills on native-born workers depends on how they work together.</p><p>Imagine you are building a house. You need an architect, a project manager, specialist trades like plumbers and electricians, and a range of construction workers, bricklayers and tilers. If you can increase the number of workers, the job can be completed more quickly, allowing more houses to be built. More houses produced by more workers may see wages remain stable.</p><p>Adding workers with different skills and experience is more useful than adding workers with only one skill set. Two project managers may cover contingencies and allow better scheduling. But adding a third project manager is unlikely to help much further. An increase in the number of project managers may lower <em>their </em>productivity and wages while increasing the productivity and wages of <em>other</em> members of the team. The shape of the wage distribution changes, even if average wages remain stable.</p><p>The same forces operate across the national economy.</p><p>Australia has been adding workers through migration at a rapid pace since the mid-2000s. The foreign-born population has increased by about 170,000 people per year. Migrants account for around half of Australia’s total population growth and more than half of employment growth over this period (Figure 1).</p><p><strong>Figure 1: Employment growth has been driven by skilled migrants</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/752/1*3pi5HteqjZllaVZozqKKIg.png" /></figure><p>But the migrant intake has a narrower range of skills and experience than the labour force as a whole. Growth in migrant numbers has been concentrated among holders of postgraduate and undergraduate degrees, particularly those aged 25 to 44 years.</p><p>This has coincided with a decline in the return to education generally — measured by the wage premium earned by workers with university degrees relative to those with no post-school qualifications (Figure 2) — and especially among those ages.</p><p><strong>Figure 2: Returns to education have been falling</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/609/1*IoShBIYeETZ2PLq_wlsucw.png" /></figure><p><strong>What this research does</strong></p><p>So, does competition from migrants place downward pressure on the wages of Australian-born workers?</p><p>The effects of migration on native-born workers are not well understood. International findings, particularly in the United States, remain contentious. Even if these findings were settled, their application to Australia would be limited. Australian migration is predominantly based on skills and employment opportunities. In most advanced economies, migrants have lower levels of education than the native-born population, but Australia is one of the few exceptions: migrants to Australia hold higher qualifications than the broader population.</p><p>Previous Australian studies have taken a non-structural approach and estimated effects on the labour market as a whole (Breunig et al. 2016). They find no robust evidence that immigration has harmed the labour market outcomes of native-born Australians as a whole.</p><p>The current study examines in more detail how native-born and migrant workers combine to produce national output. The approach follows studies of the US labour market by Raphael and Smolensky (2009) and Ottaviano and Peri (2012).</p><p>The labour market is divided into “cells” where every worker has the same education, experience and migrant status:</p><ul><li>nine age categories from 20–24 years through to 60–64 years;</li><li>five highest educational attainment categories: postgraduate degrees, undergraduate degrees, advanced diploma and diploma, trade certificates (level III and IV), and no post-school qualifications</li><li>two nativity categories: native-born and migrant</li><li>four time periods from the 2006, 2011, 2016 and 2021 Australian Census of Population and Housing:</li></ul><p>In total, there are 180 cells representing 38 million full-time equivalent workers.</p><p>The analysis proceeds in two steps.</p><p>The first step is to estimate how different workers combine to produce output, with capital assumed to adjust in step with the expanding workforce within a ‘constant elasticity of substitution’ production function.</p><p>Returning to the analogy of building a house, the question is how well workers with different skills move between roles? Economists refer to this as the “elasticity of substitution” between workers. We estimate an elasticity of substitution between migrants and native-born workers of 10. This means they are close, but not perfect, substitutes. With a rapid inflow of migrants with particular skills, if migrants and native-born workers are close substitutes then competition may drive native-born wages lower. If they were poorer substitutes, wage effects would be concentrated among migrants instead with little effect on native-born wages.</p><p>The second step is to construct a counterfactual. We calculate what the labour market cells would have been like in 2021 without additional migration since 2006.</p><p><strong>What this research finds</strong></p><p>The central question is how wages of native-born Australians changed as a result of migration.</p><p>We do not find evidence that migration has lowered native-born wages overall. However, there is evidence that migration has contributed to a reshaping of the age-earnings profile, resulting in lower native wages in the age and education groups in which migration has been concentrated, particularly among early- and mid-career university-educated workers. By reshaping the skill composition of the workforce, immigration has created winners and losers among native-born workers.</p><p>Nevertheless, the effects are moderate in size.</p><p>For example, the wages of native-born 35 to 39 year olds with postgraduate qualifications have fallen by 30 percentage points relative to workers with no post-school qualifications over the 15 years to 2021 (Figure 3). Around 5 percentage points of this decline — indicated by the gap between wages in 2006 and the simulated wages without additional migration — can be attributed to competition with migrant workers. Effects on those with undergraduate qualifications are smaller.</p><p><strong>Figure 3: Competition with migrants explains a moderate share of the fall in returns to post-graduate education</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/614/1*W2Ugs6qpM3i6k0t4uTpYfA.png" /></figure><p><strong>Summing up</strong></p><p>We do not find substantial effects on native-born wages across the labour market as a whole. Nevertheless, this study presents evidence that migration has altered the age-earnings profile in Australia by reducing relative wages within the education and experience groups in which migrant inflows have been concentrated. These effects appear economically meaningful, particularly among early- and mid-career university-educated workers. This is a novel research finding relevant for policy makers in considering the distributional consequences of migration.</p><p><strong>References</strong></p><p>Breunig, R., Deutscher. N. and To, H. (2016) The relationship between immigration to Australia and the labour market outcomes of Australian workers in Australian Government Productivity Commission (2016). <em>Migrant Intake into Australia</em>. Inquiry Report №77. Canberra.</p><p>Ottaviano, G. I. P., &amp; Peri, G. (2012). Rethinking the effect of immigration on wages. <em>Journal of the European Economic Association</em>, 10(1), 152–197.</p><p>Raphael, Steven, and Eugene Smolensky (2009). Immigration and Poverty in the United States. <em>American Economic Review: Papers &amp; Proceedings</em>, 99(2), 41–44. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1257/aer.99.2.41">https://doi.org/10.1257/aer.99.2.41</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3c8aad19a00f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>