<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Leslie Butler on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Leslie Butler on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@butler0910?source=rss-6f8c564a429a------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Mon, 16 Nov 2026 20:38:41 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@butler0910/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Bi-partisan Ghost Dancing]]></title>
            <link>https://butler0910.medium.com/bi-partisan-ghost-dancing-70427df31848?source=rss-6f8c564a429a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/70427df31848</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[joe-biden]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[donald-trump]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[november-elections]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nostalgia]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Leslie Butler]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 21 Jun 2024 16:50:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-06-21T16:50:48.041Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/224/1*gNQx14sUyCZHqqfAyQtBIQ.png" /></figure><p>by Alan Wain</p><p>Isn’t the US presidential election exciting? Can you feel the tension mounting? Who will win this cliffhanger they are calling the most consequential election ever? Team Red or Team Blue? Tweedledum or Tweedledee? Kang or Kodos? Dotard 1 or Dotard 2?</p><p>I know, don’t be cynical. “Elections have consequences”. There is bi-partisan agreement on that. The gamut of agreement stretches across the political spectrum all the way from A to B. And they <strong>don’t </strong>mean anything thing so vapid as America won’t be identical regardless of who wins. They mean America could be irrevocably altered and damaged and become unrecognizable should the wrong side win.</p><p>But both sides agree on this: apparently, it’s morning in America once again.</p><p>Team Red says it’s morning in America because the Donald stands poised to turn back time and bring back the good old days when men were men, America kicked ass and the rust belt hadn’t rusted yet. The MAGA (Make America Great Again) crowd are ghost dancers with a fierce case of nostalgia.</p><p>To Team Blue it’s morning in America because doddering old Genocide Joe, the self-proclaimed restorer of America’s soul, is on a parallel MABA (Make America Believe Again) mission. He is shuffling through his own ghost dance, inspired by his own nostalgia. He’s apparently going to turn back time and bring back what he remembers — bi-partisan civility, American capitalism kicking ass and full union halls sprinkled all throughout the rust belt.</p><h4>Longing for the 40s</h4><p>Joe wants to Make America Believe Again in what it believed in the1940s. He wants to restore the simple faith America once had in its government agencies before they spied on the civil rights movement, created a surveillance state and started hiding their own activities by classifying them “top secret”. He’s as pro FBI, pro CIA and as “cops are tops” as he ever was. After George Floyd’s murder, he opposed decreasing police budgets and recommended giving cops even <strong><em>more</em></strong> money. If Merrick Garland wants to put journalists like Julian Assange in prison for being enemies of the people, Joe is fine with that. They prosecuted traitors in the old days, right? Daniel Elsberg — Daniel <em>Schmellsberg</em>. And Guantanamo prison is staying open.</p><p>Nobody needs to chant “lock ’em up” at a Biden rally. Merrick Garland’s already nailing Trump’s crew and old Joe personally brought mass incarceration to America decades ago.</p><p>Despite what damn hippies like Dwight Eisenhower warned, old Joe still believes in the military industrial complex. He remains all for the foreign entanglements that led America into foreign wars. Business in the worldwide armaments industry has been booming since Genocide Joe assumed leadership of the free world. Where others see “merchants of death” Joe sees “job providers” and a World War 2 style “arsenal for democracy”. He assumes that if a little NATO was good enough for President Truman, a grossly expanded NATO must be even better now. If Truman was willing to go to war over Taiwan, how can we not still be up for that?</p><p>Seen through a 1940s lens, all villains are Hitler. All allies are Churchill. And anyone for peace is Neville Chamberlain. Nobody was <strong><em>for</em></strong> the Palestinians in 1948. So what’s all this fuss about 40,000 dead Palestinians now? Americans would have been chanting “Bomb, Bibi, bomb!” in the 1940s, which makes Biden relate better to those simpler times.</p><h4><strong>Joe’s best wishes</strong></h4><p>Biden also wants to Make America Believe Again in old school politics when voters could still be impressed by unkept promises, empty rhetoric and unrealized aspirations. Joe is running as the consoler-in-chief, not for chief fixer. He’s offering to feel your pain and make you feel seen and heard before he moves on from your unsolved problem. He <strong><em>says</em></strong> he wishes the mass shootings would end, that your student debt didn’t exist, that Roe v. Wade was still in force, that your loved one hadn’t died in the last foreign war, that food and gas were cheaper and houses were still affordable. He wishes<em> </em>the homeless had homes, that minimum wages could rise, that the planet wasn’t frying, that unions could make a comeback and that fewer Palestinians were dying. Isn’t that nice? Can’t wishes be enough? It used to be enough.</p><p>Washington never became a swamp to Joe. He still sees it as the place the elite should meet to call each other “statesmen” while trying to out-do each other in praising America, capitalism and common sense. Gridlock or no, he’s for maintaining the arcane rules and traditions. Yes, money corrupts politics but he’s keeping his corporate donors. And though mass shootings sadden him, he is still no foe of guns or the Second Amendment. He’s not a foe of much in the status quo.</p><p>Everybody knows Joe and the Donald are both better talkers than doers. They are both selling aspirations knowing neither of them can actually turn back time or make the misremembered good old days return. It’s not morning in America. It’s not 1945. The rust is staying on the rust belt and the union halls aren’t reopening. The cure for disillusion can’t really be more delusion.</p><p>Every ghost dancer keeps chanting: “MAGA or MABA, Pick a side, you gotta!”, because if you don’t choose Kang or Kodos you really can’t complain about the outcome. Still, “The parties, united, are keeping us divided!” is a bit of a toe tapper too. And who is Cornel West?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=70427df31848" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Dim Donnie Didn’t Get It]]></title>
            <link>https://butler0910.medium.com/dim-donnie-didnt-get-it-2010d80dad0f?source=rss-6f8c564a429a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2010d80dad0f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[trump]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[election-fraud]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[murdoch]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Leslie Butler]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 30 Dec 2020 18:34:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-12-30T18:48:45.336Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*tpKOafCPlb_en3IoaGXsQg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Image Attribution-ShareAlike 2.0 Generic (CC BY-SA 2.0)</figcaption></figure><p>So Rupert Murdoch is pretty pissed at DJT. His New York Post screams the headline, “STOP THE INSANITY”. Meanwhile, Rupert and Trump are heading for an acrimonious divorce. Considering the bloviated egos involved, it’s shaping up to be a dandy. But why the falling out?</p><p>America’s chump-in-chief apparently didn’t get the memo, the one about how two parties are really <em>one </em>party, about how elections are theatre and the script must always be followed. But Dim Donnie didn’t get it, that you’re supposed to have a peaceful transfer of power to the –nudge, nudge, wink, wink, — “other” party. Not blow the whole election fiction to smithereens.</p><p>It was all fine and good when the Nutcase from New York was careening along in his clown car giving billionaires tax breaks, protecting corporations from COVID liability, attacking union elections, health care, social security, environmental protection, immigrants, workplace safety — you know, everything decent.</p><p>Things got a little iffy when the Cretin from Queens blew the COVID response and the economy tanked. But that’s okay, the billionaires got a grotesque share of relief and profited nicely from the misery of their fellow citizens being warehoused in mobile morgues. Besides, the shit gibbon’s steady stream of demented Tweets that the corporate media slopped up like dripping red meat was always a good distraction from the steady upward transfer of wealth.</p><p>But the election was the thing. More specifically, the Moron from Mar-a-Lago’s loss and his maniacal fixation with overturning the result was the thing. It was dangerously off script. The billionaire’s Frankenstein was on the loose. Out of control. Blathering the quiet part out loud in all directions at once.</p><p>Trump and the clods that follow him are the court jesters, the fools who unwittingly speak the truth. Elections <em>are theatre</em>. America <em>is an oligarchy</em>. The rule of law <em>is a sick joke for losers</em>. America <em>is exceptionally stupid and racist.</em> The shining city on the hill <em>is an insane asylum for diseased old white men to spread destruction to every corner of the planet.</em></p><p>The oligarchs need the rosy fiction about the great American experiment. They need it badly. And Trumplandia has blown their cover. So Murdoch is freaking out.</p><p>Since the American ship of state has been veering toward the shoals for a long time, the last line that tethers people to the hold is the idea that American elections are a pitched battle between two parties with opposing political ideologies and economic policies. That <em>people</em> have the power to choose.</p><p>Americans will not give this idea up easily because an abyss opens up so deep and dark that they recoil in horror. Now, they’re in grave danger of realizing they’ve been living in this horror flick since the beginning.</p><p>As Faulkner said, we cling to that which robs us. And Donald Trump is making it mighty hard to keep clinging.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2010d80dad0f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Is the Scranton Scrapper in Fighting Shape?]]></title>
            <link>https://butler0910.medium.com/is-the-scranton-scrapper-in-fighting-shape-a1c7665846a6?source=rss-6f8c564a429a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a1c7665846a6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[trump]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[biden]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[election-preview]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Leslie Butler]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 23 Sep 2020 16:18:10 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-09-23T16:37:41.791Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Is the Scranton Scrapper in Fighting Shape? Will President Pinocchio squeeze out a W? A Nov. 3 preview.</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*lViyGOAk-rPy3PqnQlQ1aQ.png" /></figure><p>by Alan Wain and Leslie Butler</p><p>Slow Joe Biden is really up against it now folks. He’s out of his element. Nothing in his recent political experience will have prepared the Delaware Dotard for the upcoming fight of his life. If he’s to win this thing, he will have to stop thinking of it as an election. It’s more like a fight film — the sequel to the 2016 hit “<em>The Big Fight:</em> <em>Dirty Donnie versus Shrill Hil”, teaser-line</em> “This time it’s personal!” Let’s call the new one: “<em>The Big Fight 2: Hil’s nicer buddy tags in</em>”: “This time, also personal”.</p><p>Joe had better keep a close eye on his opponent. Dirty Donnie is not above kicking a foe in the nards and biting his ear before the ref has even finished explaining the rules. Nor will he hesitate to throw his money and power around to fix fights because fair fighting is for suckers and losers. And don’t expect the judges to ensure fairness because this bout’s top judge is none other than Donnie’s bestie, Big Bill “I’ll allow it” Barr.</p><p>Overconfidence on Biden’s part would be an ill-advised repeat of the hubris what led to hapless Hil’s horrible hammering in aught 16. The Dems in Joe’s corner will surely not, this second time around, underestimate the appeal of nostalgia and faux populism delivered in a two-stooges, dumb and dumber act by Trump and Pence. The Dems must accept from the opening bell that the American people love low brow corn, hope (even when its false) and lies so long as they are tarted up to look pretty.</p><h4>Trash talk and eye candy make the fight</h4><p>In fight theatrics, production values matter. The pre-fight stare-down, posturing and trash talking are integral and crucial to the spectacle. Who can forget Dirty Donnie’s debate-debasing hovering behind bewildered little Hil during the 2016 debates? Having a hot chick circle the ring carrying the round-number sign between bells while showing a lot of skin is always a great visual too. So, First Lady Melania should be a great asset to the Trump campaign. She’s worth every penny Dirty Donnie paid for her. Hubba hubba, right fellas? (and lesbians?). And, of course, in an election, the stare-down, posturing, trash talking, flexing and eye candy <em>are </em>the fight. There’s really not a whole lot more for the voters beyond that.</p><p>Make no mistake though, Dirty Donnie is the defending champ for a reason. If there is one thing this potty-mouthed prez knows how to do, its dish trash on an opponent.</p><p>A lot of people say he’s the Prince of Putdowns, the Sultan of Smears, the Duke of Dissing, a Bellowing Bronx Bully, a real New York Nasty and Rude Roarer. Unfettered by truthfulness, conscience or decency he’ll bob and weave freely, constantly inflating his own importance while flicking out a steady stream of mean, petty, cutting little jabs belittling the legitimate accomplishments of others. The book on him is: bloats like a butterball, stings like a flea. Give him his due though — President Pinocchio is a veritable Lord of the Lies, a Baron of Bragging, Shaman of Sham, Khan of Cons, Mouth of Myths, Fount of Fables, and a Washington Windbag.</p><p>For voters yearning for sunshine and happy tales, Dirty Donnie delivers that too. He’s Mr. Make-Believe, the Great Gaslighter. “Crisis? What crisis? Nobody’s still talking about COVID anymore. That’s sooo last season!! And was it ever even here, I mean really here, much? Ventilators, baby. I got us the ventilators. So strap in for your super V recovery. It’s going to be so treeeemendous like you should not, I mean would not, even believe!!!”</p><h4>The game is checkers, stupid</h4><p>And that works. So Biden needs to figure out how to duck and counter punch against a guy who when he goes low, goes ankle-sweep low.</p><p>Dirty Donnie’s highly effective debating tactics are worth studying. They are unorthodox. He has borrowed nothing from the genteel and toney cleverness of groups like the Harvard Debate Team. He keeps it simple knowing he does not need three dimensional chess skills when the game is checkers. Trump is old school — very basic, primitive even. Old school like from the 1950s and basic like a grade school. He’s primitive in that his debating tactics are those of a skilled but bratty, Grade 5, maybe 6, schoolyard taunting bully.</p><p>Dirty Donnie still lives in that simpler, more innocent time, circa 1956, when he was much more innocent too. Back then he’d only grabbed ’em by the pig-tails (we must all hope). Nor had he yet acquired his impressive, almost magical phoenix-like ability to rise up unscathed from the ashes of bankruptcy after bankruptcy after bankruptcy (assuming the lad had dodged the financially perilous world of paper routes).</p><p>But if the child is indeed father to the man we can safely assume the future prez cut his debating teeth in the cruel world of schoolyard pecking orders. His daddy’s money had purchased him a top spot among the cool boys and mean girls who terrorized the playground teasing, putting down and belittling the other little people. And little Donnie must have really enjoyed doing that because he has never out grown it.</p><p>Biden must beware of at least three well-known and effective debating techniques that every grade six bully worth his salt learns to master. Let’s call them: the trope a dope, the I-am-rubber and blow-harding in the wind. The first taught Dirty Donnie how to jab and force an opponent to play defense. The second taught him counter punching. And the third was perhaps the most important of all — it taught him how to pose and posture and brag in the pre-fight.</p><h4>Trope-a-Dope</h4><p>The trope-a-dope is a devastating tease. It is performed by telling insulting, often untrue stories about someone just to make him or squirm and deny the accusations. In childhood this might mean saying, for example: “Joey wets his bed! Joey has cooties! Joey’s mom is a slut! Joey is dumb! Joey is a sissy! Joey stu-stu-stu-stutters! Joey’s family is poor! Joey likes the fat loser and has a crush on the homely girl! The taunts can be so unpleasant that a targeted victim can have a knee jerk overreaction to try to get out from under the tropes. Little Joey may even do things he will regret like defriending his fat friend, calling the very nice homely girl “ugly” or beating up some other kid who doesn’t deserve it just to prove Joey is not a sissy.</p><p>In adulthood the trope-a-dope may take the form of rapid fire taunts like: “Joe is senile. Joe is a puppet. Joe loves China. Joe’s got socialism. Joe loves criminals. Joe loves anarchists. Joe hates guns. Joe hates cops. Joe hates the burbs. Joe hates fracking. Joe hates America.” Biden will need to be constantly checking his back and removing the steady stream of “kick me” signs that Donnie keeps putting there during clinches.</p><p>He should expect to have to peel a lot signs off his back saying things like “loser”, “old man”, “deep state traitor”, “swamp thing” and “demented”. And he must avoid the temptation to overreact. He must be careful not to suck in for becoming too effusive while publicly distancing himself from “radical” protestors, environmentalists, gun control activists, peaceniks and progressives or in embracing cops, guns, law and order, war, fracking and the status quo. Otherwise, those struggling hard to abide Biden will walk away in disgust.</p><h4>I am rubber</h4><p>The I-am-rubber tactic is short for “I am rubber, you are glue. What you say bounces off me and sticks to you.” Or you may know it by the pithier: “I know you are but what am I?” It is just throwing any accusations against yourself back at your accuser. In childhood this might mean counterpunching with: “No, <em>you’re </em>dumb.” “<em>You </em>have the cooties.” Or the devastating: “He who smelt it, dealt it”.</p><p>In adulthood, the I-am-rubber counterpunch becomes: “I was out of line in Ukraine? You were out of line in Ukraine.” “I’m a Russia puppet? China plays you like a fiddle.” “I don’t respect science? You don’t respect science.” “I messed up on Covid? You messed up on Covid.“ “I hate Black people? You take them for granted and give them nothing.” And on and on, leaving those not paying close attention with the illusion that the fight must be a draw.</p><p>Finally, there is the blowhard ploy. In Grade 6, when a guy has few real life accomplishments of which to boast, the answer my friend is blowharding in the wind. The answer? Blowharding in the wind. For this ploy to work, it is crucial to round up the most gullible minded in the herd and brag only to them.</p><p>Luckily, the gullible minded were numerous on a Grade 6 playground circa 1956. You can tell them you are practically a genius, already getting hit on by high school girls and friends with Elvis. The genius thing may be only your mom’s opinion, and the high school girlfriends and Elvis friendship are more aspirational goals than real things. But you don’t have to tell the mouth breathers that. They will believe you because, well, it’s Grade 6.</p><p>In adulthood, blowharding in the wind may also include claiming to being a very stable genius because “person, man, woman, camera, television”. Right? One’s famous friends may include Vlad The Poisoner, Lil Kim (the dictator not the singer) and the mysterious shadowy patriot QAnon. To pad your resume’s list of milestones passed on the road to making America Great Again, one can always add a few boasts requiring an asterisk, like:</p><p>-built a wall across the southern border*</p><p>- stuck Mexico with the bill for it*</p><p>- ended ISIS*</p><p>- ended America’s foreign wars*</p><p>- ended Obamacare and replaced it with Trump Doesn’t Care*</p><p>-shrank the national debt*</p><p>-saved the nation’s racist monuments and symbols*</p><p>-forced Iran back to the renegotiation table*</p><p>-brought regime change to Venezuela*</p><p>-banished nuclear weapons from the Korean peninsula*</p><p>-drained the Washington Swamp*</p><p>-made coal and oil cool again*</p><p>-restored America’s reputation in the world*</p><p>*indicates “aspirational only at present”</p><h4>Uh oh. Did the DNC pick another stiff?</h4><p>The smart money is betting on no knockout on November 3rd. But there are enough riveting storylines to still make watching the returns must-see-tv. Which way will the swing states swing? Will the pollsters have egg all over their faces again? Did the DNC pick another stiff?</p><p>Are the progressives doomed to a night of regret regardless of who wins, regardless of whether they sat out the election or held their noses and tried to help put their un-beloved Uncle Joe into the White House? Will Sleepy Joe’s handlers let him stay up past his bed time to see the late returns come in? Will he understand why they won’t let him go to sleep, or get cranky? And what kind of conspiracy story will Dirty Donnie go with to pretend he was robbed of victory when things don’t go his way?</p><p>If it goes to the score cards, The Big Fight 3 will be a courtroom drama. It’s working title: “<em>A Plague of Lawyers” </em>with the teaser tag-line “<em>This time, it’s nerdy”. </em>It will feature a great flock of briefcase clutching nattering nerds descending upon the Supreme Court to begin screeching and pecking away at one another in front of nine judges. It won’t be riveting but it will produce a verdict that the losing side can brand “fake justice”, premise for “<em>The Big Fight 4: The Final Showdown — Libtards versus Deplorables — “This time, it’s for keeps!”</em></p><p><em>The Big Fight 4 </em>might be action-packed and also scary. None of us is likely to enjoy it. So, let’s hope it never gets produced. Let’s hope Joe Biden, the Scranto Scrapper surprises us with a knockout November</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a1c7665846a6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Plandemic! Where truth, quasi-truth and truthiness intersect]]></title>
            <link>https://butler0910.medium.com/plandemic-where-truth-quasi-truth-and-truthiness-intersect-bc00274b5531?source=rss-6f8c564a429a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/bc00274b5531</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[mikki-willis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[plandemic]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Leslie Butler]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 25 Jul 2020 17:15:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-07-25T17:22:27.878Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/416/1*QElFpHus4nma0XKVdbZjTw.png" /></figure><p>by Leslie Butler and Alan Wain</p><p>One big problem with edgy docs that live in the gray territory between serious inquiry and disingenuous fakery is that the controversy erupting around them can bury some important kernels of truth.</p><p>Take the controversial doc, <em>Plandemic!</em> that Netflix refused to air but Sinclair is purportedly planning to. It’s Mikki Willis’s foray into the rich swamp of uncertainty around the COVID-19 pandemic. The 24-minute teaser for the doc — almost exclusively — features Judy Mikovits, an American research scientist who makes a number of eyebrow-raising claims including:</p><p>· COVID-19 was probably a by-product of lab research because natural selection would have taken 800 years to produce this virus</p><p>· it’s being allowed to spread so that Big Pharma and other vested interests can profit from vaccines and treatments</p><p>· Dr. Tony Fauci had ties to the Wuhan lab and ominously predicted the current pandemic in 2017</p><p>· social distancing, wearing masks and staying inside will weaken our immune systems</p><p>· powerful state forces have muzzled her research findings</p><p>The film has been roundly condemned as misinformation by <a href="https://www.politifact.com/article/2020/may/08/fact-checking-plandemic-documentary-full-false-con/">Politifact</a>, <a href="https://www.forbes.com/sites/tarahaelle/2020/05/08/why-its-important-to-push-back-on-plandemic-and-how-to-do-it/?fbclid=IwAR03WecRtFpIs7wNudy3BpPbwT_YcDQT0K8m5NtZ95LpmE-k2REdDM_pvaY#5677caf45fa3">Forbes</a>, <a href="https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/scientist-vaccine-jailed/">Snopes</a> and a host of scientific sources. Mikovits herself has been discredited <a href="https://respectfulinsolence.com/2020/05/06/judy-mikovits-pandemic/">here</a>, <a href="https://www.nature.com/news/2011/111005/full/news.2011.574.html">here</a> and <a href="https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2011/12/updated-rare-move-science-without-authors-consent-retracts-paper-tied-mouse-virus">here.</a> So we don’t intend to go over this already well-worn territory.</p><p>What’s interesting is that in the furious backlash, big important truths sometimes get lost or distorted. Like rumours, a lot of quasi-truths begin with truth. This is what makes them so beguiling.</p><p>The specific assertions made in <em>Plandemic! </em>may well be false. The film’s many debunkers say the bullshit is in the details. They say the film’s specific facts do not check out. But criticism of the details does not debunk the more general and very realistic concern that science <em>could </em>become corrupt and is unquestionably open to corruption.</p><p>In fact, the only reason the film gains any rhetorical traction at all with ordinary viewers is because it plays upon some <em>legitimate </em>fears about potential threats to the independence and integrity of science.</p><p>One does not have to be a crank or anti-science to worry about these threats. One just has to be open to the idea that science is susceptible to the same kinds of threats to its independence and integrity as other fields are. These threats include:</p><h4><strong>Money negatively influences the conduct of science.</strong></h4><p>As science has become increasingly dependent on private funding, it has lost some of its independence and some of the luxury it once enjoyed to pursue pure research for the sake of intellectual curiosity alone. Privatizing medical research has been a 40-year project in which Big Pharma has increasingly called the tune by paying the piper.</p><p>Big Pharma has, at the very least, set research agendas. At the very worst it has engineered blatantly bogus results and commissioned studies to reach misleading conclusions. Publicly funded universities, squeezed by austerity, became supplicants to rich vested interests for private research grants with big strings attached.</p><p>We accept that truth is the first casualty of war. So why should we doubt that truth seeking empirical science could be a casualty of funding-for-profit research? We accept that funding can affect the actions politician will take. So why would we doubt that principle applies to scientists too?</p><p>Mikovits plays on our fear of funders corrupting science. And even if she is wrong about the specifics of this pandemic, it does not invalidate the fear in general. And it’s why the film resonates at all.</p><h4><strong>Property rights negatively influence the conduct of science: The Bayh-Dole Act</strong>.</h4><p>This intellectual property legislation in 1980 allowed private contractors to retain ownership over inventions made with government-funded R &amp; D. It effectively means taxpayers’ millions are being used to fund research for which private companies then obtain a patent and make big profits.</p><p>Giving scientific researchers a financial stake in the outcome of their research incentivizes them to exaggerate the benefits, and to minimize the harm, of discoveries they have made that could lead to profit-making products. Willis and Mikovits rightly identify this as a having a potential for serious conflicts of interest.</p><p>But it doesn’t at all <em>automatically </em>follow that Dr. Tony Fauci and others did block effective treatments for HIV/AIDS while pushing their own patented ineffective treatments for profit. It doesn’t mean Fauci is personally responsible for millions of deaths in Africa. Willis and Mikovits would have to show us a lot more evidence to prove this, evidence that the film’s debunkers say does not exist.</p><p>But that does not invalidate the question of whether repealing the Bayh-Dole Act might be a good idea. A lot of us could get behind that.</p><h4><strong>Personal ambition and egos negatively influence the conduct of science.</strong></h4><p>Despite its central claim of objectivity, science is still a human activity. That means it is an activity done by people prone to making biased assumptions, faulty research methods, unsubstantiated claims, unwarranted leaps of logic, honest mistakes and sometimes even deliberate hoaxes.</p><p>The scientific method is only as impartial as the men and women who use it. It cannot protect individuals from being seduced by their own dreams of fame, acclaim and personal glory or from falling into hero worship or excessive deference to authority.</p><p>So, it is not necessarily anti-science or crankish to be rigorously skeptical of scientific experts.</p><p><em>Plandemic!’s</em> skepticism about the science of masks, or the weakening of our immune systems due to social distancing and excessive hygiene play on our knowledge that science is not infallible. Willis and Mikivitcz tug at the strand that too much deference to questionable authorities can be a very bad thing.</p><h4><strong>Power corrupts, negatively influencing the conduct of science</strong></h4><p>Most of us are quite willing to believe that powerful people are capable of using their power to unfairly silence dissenters who displease them. We have heard about this happening in government or law enforcement or big business.</p><p>We’ve seen Karen Silkwood, Erin Brockovich and Gary Webb. So when Willis artfully paints a picture of Mikovits as a victim of false charges whose research was buried and whose due process rights have been trampled, the possibility of that having happened resonates.</p><p>We are open to the idea that Mikovits could have been like the above-mentioned heroes even though fact-checkers insist, in her case, she was treated lawfully. But lawfully might not be the issue. It is lawful for the funder of scientific research, as owners of the research, to suppress public knowledge of the results.</p><p>Likewise, it is lawful for media conglomerates who pay for the exclusive right to publish a story to instead kill the story. It’s called “catch and kill”. Likewise, it is lawful for powerful people to do bad things to people and then buy their victims’ silence under “non-disclosure agreements”.</p><p>But catch and kill journalism and NDAs can still be viewed as problems even though they are legal. We might be willing to believe Judy Mikovitz was the victim of catch-and-kill science whose research was buried by her powerful male bosses.</p><h4><strong>Long serving Czars negatively influence the conduct of science</strong></h4><p>One of the points <em>Plandemic! </em>makes about Dr. Faucci is that his is very powerful by virtue of having his job for so many decades. Even if he hasn’t abused his power, it is still legitimate to ask about the wisdom of creating such long serving public health czars. One of the problems with the late J. Edgar Hoover of the F.B.I. is that he grew too powerful simply by being in charge too long. Maybe that lesson applies to the conduct of science too.</p><p><em>Plandemic! </em>may be more about truthiness than truth. It may be, as Frances Fitzgerald observed with such breathtaking clarity: “…truer than truth. That which never happened but ought to have.” Willis and Mikovitz may be engineering the details to tell an overarching narrative that is true. But it still raises some issues worth pondering.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=bc00274b5531" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The con is on: good cops tag in for bad on police reform]]></title>
            <link>https://butler0910.medium.com/the-con-is-on-good-cops-tag-in-for-bad-on-police-reform-9618acf4251a?source=rss-6f8c564a429a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9618acf4251a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[police-reform]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[arab-spring]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[joe-biden]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Leslie Butler]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 15 Jun 2020 00:19:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-06-15T00:23:51.779Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>The Con is On: good cops tag in for bad cops on police reform</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*e230PCsWSC-rE13wc3VUGQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>by Alan Wain and Leslie Butler</p><p>Now that the systemic problems of policing in America have finally been exposed for all to see, Americans are about to witness the awesome power of a self-correcting system. Cue the chorus: “The system sucks; long live the system!”</p><p>We are about to see illustrated what former president Bill Clinton never used to admit — how there is nothing right with America that can’t be made wrong by what’s wrong with America. Nothing escapes from the Washington swamp that can’t be dragged back into that swamp and drowned. Police reform is about to be made wrong again.</p><p>The con is on. Spin doctors of the chattering and political classes have begun revealing the fine print on what they mean by “the system” or by “the problem is systemic”, or “the system is broken” and by promising “meaningful, fundamental change”. More importantly, we are starting to learn what changes the chattering classes and politicians deem too radical.</p><p>The bad cops, the brutes who allegedly embarrassed the system, have been asked to temporarily take a seat. It is time for the good cops with their softer, politer voices now. The bad cops haven’t gone anywhere. They are just tagging out to let their partners tag in. It’s how the partnership works.</p><p>But the really artful part of this tag team con is how, by suggesting that cops can embarrass a policing system, it implies cops are somehow outside<em> </em>the system. It suggests the broken “system” refers only to words on paper — to the set of rules, instructions and policies that tell people within a policing system what to do. The cops themselves can still be tops, still the city’s finest. Just change the policies and we can let almost all the cops stick around to enforce some new policies.</p><h4><strong>What we have here is a failure to communicate</strong></h4><p>Police officer layoffs can be avoided by pretending we aren’t over policed, just <em>wrongly</em> policed due to a failure to communicate clearly to the boys in blue. The problem is miscommunication, not malice. And, by extension, if there are almost no bad cops, there are probably almost no bad police chiefs, bad mayors, bad legislators, or bad watchdogs either. We mustn’t think that any of the overwhelming majority of good people in the system aided and abetted, tolerated and protected the brutality of the bad apples because…well…just because.</p><p>We are urged to pretend we have had an awareness problem, that the proper authorities didn’t know about the prevalence of police brutality until just now. Perhaps the cops didn’t realize that killing unarmed citizens was so frowned upon. Maybe, when someone’s diction or hearing is a slightly off, “serve and protect” can sound like “intimidate and terrorize”.</p><p>We’ve seen this movie before, in the Arab Spring. The Egyptian people rose up and got military dictator Hosni Mubarak arrested. The other generals thanked the mob for alerting them to their dissatisfaction with a bad apple. We get it, they said. Message received. So, clear the streets and leave it to us to safeguard your revolution for you. Trust us, they said: “There’s nothing wrong with a military dictatorship that can’t be put right but what’s right with a military dictatorship.”</p><p>So, the Egyptian people left the streets. They trusted the generals. Then the Arab Spring reverted back to winter. The generals went back to kneeling on the people’s throats and eventually even to letting Mubarak out of jail.</p><p>It’s why Maya Angelou advised the exact opposite of: “when someone shows you who they are, don’t believe it. Be a chump. Give them another chance”.</p><h4><strong>The Evolution of Joe Biden</strong></h4><p>If anyone does insist on holding someone accountable for decades of police brutality and racism there’s always Donald Trump. Some think replacing that jerk with the fresh faced Joe Biden will bring happy days to policing.</p><p>Okay, fine, Biden’s face maybe isn’t so fresh. He’s even older than Trump and has sloshed around in the Washington swamp for forty years. Plus, he carries some embarrassing baggage as the guy who sponsored the 1994 crime bill that brought in over policing, mass incarceration and a war-on-crime ethos that encouraged cops to adopt a warrior mentality against their fellow citizens.</p><p>But Biden’s thinking has supposedly evolved. The 1994 Biden supported a massive expansion of police numbers and incarceration based on an assumption that power would not corrupt. It is unclear whether he was naïve then or just pandering to swing voters — the white suburban soccer moms and white folk of middle America. If those fine folks believed stories of police brutality and systemic racism were urban myths, that was good enough for 1994 Biden.</p><p>But 2020 Biden is prepared to assume the same people who abused their power the first time around won’t do it again. It is unclear whether he is naïve now or just pandering to swing voters — the white suburban soccer moms and white folk of middle America. If those fine folks believe the black community’s fears that police brutality and systemic racism will continue if everybody keeps their cop jobs is paranoid and over blown, that is good enough for 2020 Biden.</p><p>This is evolved? This is learning from the past? This is recognizing that the Black Lives Matter movement actually know what they are talking about?</p><h4><strong>Ass-covering, gaslighting and bullshitting</strong></h4><p>It is depressing watching the parade of shameless self-congratulating politicians covering their asses by scrambling to get out in front of the mob’s uprising to pretend they are, and have long been, against the very police practices they have been promoting, tolerating and ignoring for so long.</p><p>It is also depressing to hear the chattering classes gaslight and bullshit us about what we have witnessed these past few days. Most of them parrot a mantra they know is false. They say violence never solves anything and the authorities will ignore any calls for change that come with property damage.</p><p>They spout this nonsense knowing we just saw the unprecedented swiftness with which the Minneapolis officers got charged after the mob police burned a police station. They say it knowing we just saw mobs get rid of offensive statues by foregoing petitions and tearing them down. And as students of history they likely know race riots preceded the passing of the 1965 Civil Rights Act. They’ve likely heard that Lincoln condoned a bit of violence, a little property damage and a little taking away of private property (slaves) in his war for a good cause.</p><p>The talking heads urge a return to proper channels now — back to peaceful protests, back to voting, to re-attending debates and public consultations, to patiently awaiting the results of inquiries and of studies. In lieu of action, we’re offered theatre. Colin Kaepernick got his apology, not rehired. Mass incarceration got officially regretted but the inmates remain locked up. A street is named after Black Lives Matter now and many police chiefs took a knee for the cameras.</p><p>Past victims of institutional racism and police brutality are being told they will be able to relax the next time they run into the very same cops who have brutalized them before. In the future, they will be protected by the department’s re-written brochures. Sure, right? What could go wrong?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9618acf4251a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Throw the fatuous argument for preserving Confederate symbols in the dust bin of history]]></title>
            <link>https://butler0910.medium.com/throw-the-fatuous-argument-for-preserving-confederate-symbols-in-the-dust-bin-of-history-862c954ae252?source=rss-6f8c564a429a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/862c954ae252</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[racism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[george-floyd]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[confederate-monuments]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Leslie Butler]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 14 Jun 2020 21:48:42 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-06-14T21:48:42.822Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*uxOjhqXbo3eJ4bctI1UneQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>by Leslie Butler and Alan Wain</p><p>From the tiny fingers of the most profoundly stupid public figure in recent memory came this, “THOSE THAT DENY THEIR HISTORY ARE DOOMED TO REPEAT IT!”</p><p>Trump apparently offered this as a stroke of rhetorical genius in the debate about keeping Confederate officers’ names on several American domestic army bases. As with keeping monuments to such people in public spaces, the argument seems to be that we erase history at our peril, that depriving us of daily exposure to these names and images would be a kind of Orwellian negation of history.</p><p>The debates have been sparked by America’s latest forced confrontation with its entrenched racism brought on by the murders of George Floyd, Breonna Taylor, Rayshard Brooks and other blacks.</p><p>Many more than Trump are lazily on board with <em>don’t erase history</em>. It sounds good. But the “argument” is at best fatuous, and at worst specious. In other words, it’s either silly or intentionally misleading, or both.</p><p>A name on a building or a statue in the square is not history. At the risk of being obvious, history is a grand narrative informed by the accumulated knowledge of human affairs, a deep analysis of the human condition as it relates to people, events and past civilizations. It’s understanding and insight and judgement and revelation.</p><p>A name on a building or monument in the square is something else entirely. It’s a tribute to someone we literally look up to. It denotes heroism. It raises up qualities for us to admire. It glorifies. It’s asking for our respect and reverence.</p><p>It <em>signifies</em>.</p><p>So what does the Confederacy signify in America? As concrete symbols of the Southern slave economy and the bloody war to preserve it, monuments to the Confederacy cannot be reasonably understood in any other way than to signify racism, brutality, and inhumanity. Cultural shorthand for heartless cruelty, exploitation and oppression that went on for centuries.</p><p>And we are keeping these monuments because…? (Some will offer a more palatable reason for keeping them, which we will get to shortly.)</p><h4>Racist brutality</h4><p>Imagine for a moment — and it doesn’t take a terribly high EQ — what it must feel like for black people to be subjected to daily reminders that the culture celebrates those murderous racists who enslaved their grandparents and great grandparents. Who worked them to death generation after generation after generation. Whipped them. Lynched them. Raped their mothers and sisters and daughters. Tore up their families, sold their children. Infantalized them. Crushed their spirit, stole their heritage. Denied their very humanity.</p><p>These monuments are in state capitols, cities and towns across the South. And the memories of these guys are worth preserving?</p><p>Should South Africa keep monuments to the apartheid-era leaders up as a symbol of how that country’s black population got crushed under the iron heel of British and Dutch colonialism? Ditto for Zimbabwe. Should it have retained its colonial name of Rhodesia out of deference to Cecil Rhodes and the other upper class British twits who so selflessly and generously spread their superior civilization to the uneducated Africans while raping and pillaging their country?</p><p>Is it conceivable that statues of arguably the biggest mass murderer in history, King Leopold II of Belgium, which came down just last week, ought to stay up forever? What the actual fuck?</p><p>Keeping the monuments to colonial brutality because they are “history” is not only specious, it conveniently ignores the fact that the victims of colonialism everywhere, just like African Americans, had a long and vibrant history long before Europeans snuffed that out. Maybe monuments to that history could go up in city squares. It matters <strong><em>whose</em></strong> history you’re wanting to preserve. Yet Trump and the don’t-erase-history crowd never speak to that question.</p><p>Should we keep the names of Catholic priests who raped little boys and girls on churches and schools because that’s “history” and they were once part of a perfectly legal and very powerful religious institution run by generations of corrupt Popes and Bishops? Would you be on board with that?</p><h4><strong>A Harvey Weinstein School for Aspiring Female Actors</strong></h4><p>But here’s the thing. The hard core don’t-erase-history bunch would never openly admit they want to keep glorifying racists and murderers. So they cynically twist it, pretending that if we keep the monuments, people will start seeing them as a <em>condemnation </em>of racism, a necessary reminder of past evil. Thus, it follows that the monuments are kind of, sort of, a <em>gift </em>to black people, and the misguided BLM supporters should get on board with preserving those larger-than-life monsters on horseback in the square.</p><p>If that’s true, how about a Harvey Weinstein School for Aspiring Female Actors, a Jeffrey Epstein Charity for Victims of Human Trafficking or an Omar Mateen Memorial Shooting Range to help us remember to condemn sexual assault and the murder of gays?</p><p>If monuments have educational value about past evil, why doesn’t the Holocaust Memorial have statutes of Hitler tastefully positioned throughout? Why wouldn’t Israel welcome shipments of Hitler statues to put up in their public squares? To educate.</p><p>If the Southern states truly want to teach people about the evils of slavery they could put up real memorials at the sites of these toppled monuments — photographs, testimonials, historical artifacts, museums — that reveal the true depth of black oppression, the damage done by white supremacy. Show how it is alive and well today in the form of institutionalized police brutality, systemic discrimination and racialized social injustice.</p><p>That would be the honest way to keep history alive.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=862c954ae252" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Finally the Tables are Starting to Turn….Talkin’ About a Revolution?]]></title>
            <link>https://butler0910.medium.com/finally-the-tables-are-starting-to-turn-talkin-about-a-revolution-31351d944e05?source=rss-6f8c564a429a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/31351d944e05</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[riots]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[civil-rights]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[george-floyd]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Leslie Butler]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 06 Jun 2020 21:21:27 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-06-06T21:22:12.881Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/159/1*NUWYTJjq9jwrPNHmW1vwGw.png" /></figure><p><strong>By Alan Wain and Leslie Butler</strong></p><p>So, Black Lives Matter was telling the truth all along. Police brutality and institutional racism are real, monstrous and must be ended as soon as possible. We finally get it and are asking: so what is next?</p><p>Some want to bask a while longer in the newly found self righteousness of the present feel-good moment. The people united in demanding good is a beautiful thing. Others are impatient to get on with implementing solutions.</p><p>Either of those impulses can, on its own, be dangerous. But combining self-congratulation with conning ourselves with easy solutions can be disastrous. If we get this wrong, it will lead to even greater outrage and violence.</p><p>It is easy to get seduced by beautiful things like peace, harmony, unity and the prospect of quick and simple solutions to very bad, long standing problems. It would be fantastic if the murder of George Floyd really does become a catalyst for making policing more fair and less brutal. We would all love it if carrying signs and marching for a few days were enough to end decades of injustice. And the idea that the very same legislators, mayors, police chiefs, prosecutors and cops who created and/or tolerated an unjust justice system might now turn on a dime and fix things — how cool would that be?</p><h4>Pretty nonsense</h4><p>But we all also know what they say about things that seem too good to be true. Believing in pretty nonsense got us into this mess in the first place. Pretty nonsense like pretending an officer’s oath would make him behave properly or having a policy is enough to ensure compliance.</p><p>Yet our instinct to embrace more pretty nonsense remains intact. Pretty nonsense like the protestors being united in their analysis of the problem. Or the fiction that says the people who spray “Fuck the police” and set police cars on fire must be out-of-towners because no locals could feel that angry or do those things. Or the ludicrous suggestion that white America was unaware of racism and police brutality up until the George Floyd video went viral.</p><p>Let’s be honest. White Americans didn’t look at the pictures of Mr. Floyd’s murder and think: “There’s police brutality against blacks!? Really? Why is this the first I’m hearing of it? Why is this the first I’m seeing of it?”</p><p>Images similar to the Floyd murder have been shown to white America over and over again in recent years. This wasn’t a case of 43rd time being the charm in getting our attention. We’ve seen this horror too many times before. Yet we stayed as passive as Derek Chauvin’s fellow cops.</p><p>We weren’t going to call what was blatantly immoral, disgusting and inexcusable by its proper name unless and until the majority of our neighbours were ready to do so too. Not in public, anyway. There is safety in numbers and danger in being an isolated truth teller. The brave members of Black Lives Matter got hated and ridiculed for telling the truth.</p><h4>Make-believe is easier</h4><p>White America just <em>pretended</em> not to know the evil that was happening and that it was widespread. It was easier to pretend that each incident was an isolated event involving a rare bad apple for the same reason police chiefs and mayors pretend the protestors who hate them must be out of towners. Make believe is more pleasant. It lets those with power off the hook. It pre-empts the need for engaging in conflict, which is sure to be difficult and unpleasant.</p><p>Our dislike of conflict remains so strong that to avoid it we may be prepared to squander the opportunity of turning Mr. Floyd’s murder into a catalyst for real and meaningful changes to society. No one doubts how widespread and sincere the desire for meaningful change is now. But there is plenty of reason to doubt good people’s stomach for the brutal honesty, conflict, difficult choices and trade-offs that may be necessary to achieve those changes. So many of the things that need changing are deeply rooted and some people will lose things dear to them.</p><p>Look at the reluctance so many feel to ask what went wrong, who did wrong or who has been part of the problem. Those are awkward questions which will surely start arguments. So we let people tell us to just look forward, not back, to eschew “the blame game”, and — going forward — to welcome everybody’s participation and all suggestions for improvement, even the dumb ideas which would make meaningful change unlikely.</p><p>Protestors marching on governor’s mansions, city halls and police headquarters have been finding nobody home. The gov, the mayor and the police chief often can’t come out to receive the mob because they are hiding among the mob and claiming to be just as disappointed in their own administrations as everyone else.</p><p>Apparently, they were always against the bad things their own administrations have been doing and tolerating. Hell, they were the first ones to be against themselves! To hear them tell it now, they have always been their own harshest critics. Who knew?</p><p>You want to call bullshit as the mayor and police take a knee for their photo op. But one must not be rude.</p><p>And then there is that even more awkward conversation no one wants to have with the beloved grey haired leaders who have championed the civil rights movement for fifty or sixty years. The old-timers are proud of their achievements and act as though, since they have proven themselves to be part of the solution for so long, people should trust them to get things done going forward. They are such admirable people for having fought the good fight for so long that no one wants to contradict them or appear disrespectful or ungrateful towards them.</p><p>So, no one wants to say out loud there is a difference between having been part of an effort and having been part of a solution. Nobody can truly claim yet to have been part of the solution to racism and police brutality until those problems get solved. As the almost casual murder of George Floyd reminds us, that hasn’t happened yet.</p><h4>White-splaining power politics</h4><p>This is not the time for complacency and self congratulation. This is a time for capitalizing on momentum. The Black Lives Matter movement is likely about to start testing people’s patience again by seeming hard to please.</p><p>Having come this far, they are unlikely to just go along to get along now, to settle for symbolic gestures, tokenism, promises, feel-good photo ops and pretty words. More likely they will insist on “more, more and more”, and on hard proof that things have indeed changed. White America may feel tempted once again to white-splain power politics and how to be “reasonable” to them.</p><p>But let’s hope that urge gets stifled this time. If recent history has taught us anything, it is that White America needs to listen better and more honestly to its truth tellers.</p><p>Tracy Chapman wrote Talkin’ About a Revolution more than 25 years ago. Will it be another 25 years until real change happens?</p><p>Now that we have finally acknowledged the abominations of police brutality and racism, perhaps we will find the collective will to acknowledge and solve some other problems that are obvious to people with their eyes open. Like the scourge of a rich society not housing its homeless and the abomination of the “land of the free” keeping millions of its own citizens locked in cages.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=31351d944e05" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Note to the Chattering Classes: Riots are not Street Theatre]]></title>
            <link>https://butler0910.medium.com/note-to-the-chattering-classes-riots-are-not-street-theatre-6ad2948a5e6e?source=rss-6f8c564a429a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6ad2948a5e6e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[police-brutality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[george-floyd]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[riots]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Leslie Butler]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 01 Jun 2020 21:46:51 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-06-01T21:46:51.643Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/910/1*F-cXp-EmC9brvrOegvaZYA.jpeg" /></figure><p>By Alan Wain and Leslie Butler</p><p>Something embarrassing has happened to America’s self-proclaimed leaders now that the mob has burned down a police station and several police cars. The usual suspects — professional experts and elected officials — have dutifully lined up again to give us their expert commentary on how we ought to feel about the “performance” of violence in the streets. Yet it is the strangest thing. They all, whether white or black, young or old, sound so alike now. Whatever these commentaries start out to say, it somehow all comes out as “blah, blah, blah”.</p><p>Their commentary feels like a theatre critic’s or actor’s critique of some play. But their reviews are not interesting, helpful, innovative, insightful or relevant. They keep trying to interpret <em>for </em>us what message the performers of the violence are trying to convey to the audience, and especially to the proper authorities. But their reactions to what they are seeing are filled with stale ideas, empty clichés, implausible, discredited propositions, phoney sounding sentiment and obligatory affirmations of political correctness for the edification of those tuned in.</p><p>Because these experts have devoted their own lives to performing and critiquing political theatre, they seem unable to view street riots through any other lens. So, for example, they assume the mob could benefit from feedback on what they, the members of the privileged class of opinion molders and policy deciders will and won’t condone. We will never condone property damage, the chattering classes warn. So if you expect our sympathy and help, control your temper and stop burning and breaking things.</p><h4>Reform at the ballot box…?</h4><p>Often there is a scolding tone from the experts, and a snippy defensiveness from those now running society. The black mayor of Atlanta, for example, angrily chastised the mob in her city for damaging property when, she explained, voting is the proper way to effect change. Ditto for former <a href="https://medium.com/@BarackObama/how-to-make-this-moment-the-turning-point-for-real-change-9fa209806067">President Barack Obama</a> who just today wrote, “we have to organize and cast our ballots to make sure that we elect candidates who will act on reform.” Really? Voting? Why hadn’t the silly mob considered that? Imagine how quickly and easily they could end police brutality against blacks if they would just, say, elect a black mayor or president..er…or something.</p><p>Others in the chattering classes have suggested that peaceful protest is the proven way to get the ears and hold the sympathy of those running society. Just look what 60 years of peaceful, orderly, polite protest has achieved. Okay, it didn’t stop the murder of George Floyd. But it has won the murdered man the sympathy of we liberal, right-thinking elites. Isn’t that nice, feeling so affirmed and morally supported while your people are being murdered by cops?</p><p>Those in charge, like the governor of Minnesota, often claim an ability to identify who the “real” protesters and “real” issues are. They apparently know who is an illegitimate or fake protestor and really just a troublemaker, or that perennial villain of dissent — “the outside agitator”.</p><p>There is a lot of: “let’s start a conversation”, “begin a dialogue”, rap. There are offers to study the situation, review policies maybe even pass new legislation. Who wouldn’t like that? A little more of same because to do the same thing over and over again while expecting a different result is the definition of…don’t say insanity…say, giving the system yet another chance to work.</p><h4>The arc of history is not infinitely long</h4><p>Martin Luther King Jr. gets quoted to the mob a lot now. He had his famous dream of racial equality that he acknowledged might not get realized in his own lifetime. He offered hope by claiming that though the arc of history is long it bends towards justice. But he only said the arc was long, not <em>infinitely</em> long. Patience can’t be infinite either. He was assassinated more than fifty years ago and it seems like a distortion of his hope to suggest the mob should settle for a perpetual postponement of the realization of his dream.</p><p>Many among the chattering classes mean well. They sincerely want to help the mob. But they are not humble enough to see their own limitations as clearly as the mob does. If those reforming the system from within were able to solve anything, they would surely have already done so by now. So the mob has stopped waiting for the chattering classes to rescue them. They are not trying to impress the chattering classes with street theatre. They are desperate for justice. A few of them are just trying to help themselves by becoming vigilantes.</p><p>It is not theatre when a mob burns and breaks police property. It is a form of self defence, a warning expressed by the victims of police brutality directly to the front line cops. It is a community that has suffered from state sponsored violence telling their bullies and murderers that they, the victims of violence, are capable of violence too. It is a clear warning to the police that continued police brutality may come back and bite the police because victims can retaliate.</p><p>Issuing direct challenges to the police is a dangerous and desperate thing to do. It is undertaken as an act of nearly last resort by a group feeing it has run out of viable options. But it is not the final act of desperation. Things could still get worse.</p><h4>Stay focussed on police racism and brutality</h4><p>Few in the chattering classes are likely to ever fully admit they too have let the mob down, that they too have no solutions to offer so that the mob, therefore, has a good reason for having given up on them. Feeling criticized and unappreciated, many liberal intellectuals, including black intellectuals, will change the focus of the story. More and more of them will join in shifting the topic to condemning violence, vandalism and anarchy. And even though they are the ones doing the talking, the chattering classes will blame the mob for changing the focus on events.</p><p>But the truly dangerous moment will come when the chattering classes, from the left as well as from the right and including blacks as well as whites, give the state their approval for unleashing renewed violence against the mob in the name of restoring order. If protesters or looters then get killed by the police or national guard, the mob will face a horrible choice — accept more deaths or return fire and try to kill some of those who have killed their friends and family.</p><p>This is not the time to roll the dice on hoping to intimidate an angry mob with renewed violence against them. It is not the time to take the focus off the mob’s grievances. The elites don’t have to make this current crisis be, yet again, about them and their authority. Police brutality is wrong and out of control. There is plenty to do if we stay focussed on that one problem.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6ad2948a5e6e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Corporate environmentalists to Michael Moore and Jeff Gibbs: “You’re are either with us or with…]]></title>
            <link>https://butler0910.medium.com/corporate-environmentalists-to-michael-moore-and-jeff-gibbs-youre-are-either-with-us-or-with-517d047559ed?source=rss-6f8c564a429a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/517d047559ed</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[planet-of-the-humans]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[binary]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[michael-moore]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Leslie Butler]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 12 May 2020 18:09:16 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-05-12T18:14:24.516Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/910/1*Ji172BkWTrfh_MifW2wV6w.jpeg" /></figure><h3><strong>Corporate environmentalists to Michael Moore and Jeff Gibbs: “You’re either with us or with big oil”</strong></h3><p>by Leslie Butler and Alan Wain</p><p>Over-the-top attacks on Jeff Gibbs’ fascinating and provocative new film, <em>Planet of the Humans, </em>have a depressing sameness to them. The film’s thesis is that green alternatives to burning the fast-dwindling supplies of fossil fuels that are heating and damaging our planet don’t appear able to save us.</p><p>That’s it. For expressing that one heresy, Gibbs and producer Michael Moore have been absolutely excoriated by many of their fellow environmentalists and fellow leftists. How dare they. What traitors. They’ve clearly gone over to the dark side! They’ve joined <a href="https://www.thenation.com/article/environment/planet-humans-film-moore/">Breitbart</a> and the fossil fuel lobby.</p><p>But how do we know Gibbs’ being unimpressed with Plan A for saving the planet proves he has thrown in his lot with or become a <a href="https://www.vox.com/2020/4/28/21238597/michael-moore-planet-of-the-humans-climate-change">gift to big oil</a> ? Well, isn’t it obvious? There’s only two options. You must either be for renewables or for fossil fuels, right?</p><h4><strong>Binary choices: Green New Deal or fracked Kool-Aid</strong></h4><p>Wrong. There is no evidence anywhere that Gibbs’ subscribes to the faulty assumption that this is a binary issue. Nothing in the film indicates that Gibbs shares his detractors’ simplistic view that you are either all for renewables or all for fossil fuels.</p><p>Writing for <em>The Nation</em>, filmmaker <a href="https://www.thenation.com/article/environment/planet-humans-film-moore/">Josh Fox</a> is particularly vitriolic on the binary: if you’re not with the Green New Deal, you’re with a doomsday death cult drinking “fracked Kool-Aid of the fossil fuel industry.”</p><p>Proponents of green energy seem particularly stung that Gibbs is questioning fellow leftists. But actual leftists should have learned by now to be wary of people offering false binary choices. The right has used them way too many times to push through bad decisions. In rhetoric this is called the either/or fallacy.</p><p>The NRA says: “it’s either bad guys with guns, or bad guys and good guys with guns”. George Bush, planning to invade Iraq because of its non-existent weapons of mass destruction told us: “you are either with us or with the terrorists”. And every quack with an alleged cure for the coronavirus pretends the choice is: snake oil or death by virus.</p><p>Gibbs’ film implies a need for a “door number three” option. He is warning us that if we are hoping Plan A — wind, solar and biofuel — will save us, we appear to be headed for disappointment. And why would anyone voice disappointment or issue warnings?</p><p>His detractors claim to know. They call him a <a href="https://www.vox.com/2020/4/28/21238597/michael-moore-planet-of-the-humans-climate-change">nihilist</a>, apparently because, again, they can see only two options: optimism or nihilism. It apparently does not occur to them that Gibbs could be genuinely worried and pointing out the flaws in Plan A because unwarranted faith in Plan A will prevent anyone from even thinking about a Plan B or C.</p><h4><strong>Greenwashing: bullshit baffling brains</strong></h4><p>Likewise, Gibbs’ detractors seem annoyed that the filmmaker did not recognize the binary choices regarding the politics of environmentalism. Every environmentalist is familiar with the concept of greenwashing. It refers to a public relations con job whereby companies that are doing net harm to the environment will try to rehabilitate their public image by making some token pro-environment gesture that appears to put them on the side of the angels.</p><p>Given that greenwashing is the overarching frame of <em>Planet of the Humans,</em> indeed proof that Plan A may be a sham, it is telling that his detractors remain mostly silent on this issue. Greenwashing is a sub-category of bullshit baffling brains. It can be disorienting to the casual observer to see ex-enemies shaking hands, sharing a stage or announcing a partnership. (See the film’s images of fossil fuel billionaire Richard Branson joining forces with the green movement). It suggests the very powerful bad guy is a good guy now, somehow having been won over by his much less powerful critic.</p><p>This is a very old con. It has worked in industry after industry for centuries. Think of the Mafia don terrorizing the neighbourhood all year but giving back by handing out free turkeys at Christmas. Think of the tobacco company making a very generous donation to lung cancer research. But in order for the con to work, someone has to play the role of gratefully accepting the reformed bad guy’s check at the press conference.</p><p>You want to say hey, wait. Isn’t that “good guy” the same bad guy who…? But then you will be shouted down by people who like free turkeys and lung cancer research. They think it is a binary choice: you are either for turkeys or for hunger, for research or for cancer, either for big checks from fossil fuel billionaires or for weak environmental movements. But it is not that simple.</p><p>Greenwashing and the co-opting of well intended-environmentalists are so well known that they are taught in university environmental programs. But unfortunately they are taught as a theoretical danger that <em>could</em> happen to some other weak-minded environmentalist (but not I who am aware of it). In that sense it is taught the way truth being the first casualty of war is taught (though not in my war where my enemy <em>really is</em> a total shit) or that irrational exuberance causes stock market bubbles (though not this bubble where I’m going to score so big).</p><p>But Gibbs’ film apparently broke a taboo by treating greenwashing and co-opting as something that actually happens in the real world to identifiable people such as Al Gore and Bill McKibben. Naming names has upset many critics because those may be good men with good intentions. Writing for <em>Vox</em>, Leah Stokes laments “The most egregious attack is made against Bill McKibben, a dedicated and kind environmental leader.” <a href="https://ketanjoshi.co/2020/04/24/planet-of-the-humans-a-reheated-mess-of-lazy-old-myths/">Ketan Joshi</a> complains that Gibbs attacks “the nicest guy in the whole of climate activism, Bill McKibben.”</p><p>But good men with good intentions can still make honest errors in judgment. And if Gibbs had named no environmentalists who had strange bedfellows, it seems likely he would have been accused of failing to document that the greenwashing/co-opting phenomenon is real.</p><p>Gibbs’ critics would, again, have us think it’s a binary choice — endorse Gore and McKibben or you’re in bed with Breitbart and the Albert oil patch. Love them or leave them because merely questioning their effectiveness or having misgivings about their leadership is not an option.</p><h4><strong>Dissent is divisive: hold your nose fall in line</strong></h4><p>This intolerance of dissent within the environmental movement is reminiscent of intolerance of dissent within the Democratic Party in the U.S. Gibbs is being told that environmentalists have to stick together because dissent is divisive and a divided movement is a weakened movement. Therefore, support your leaders whether you think they are right or wrong because anything else would aid the other side. It is exactly what the Democratic party establishment is telling Bernie Sanders people now. Hold your noses, its time to shut up and rally round Biden. It is time to be politic, and politics we are told — at least in America — is a binary choice. You are either for Biden or you are for Trump.</p><p>Whether quashing dissent is wise even within political parties is a debatable question we can leave to discuss some other time. But the calls for political unity in reviews of a movie about technology seem off point, ill-advised and even dangerous.</p><p>Gibbs’ made a movie about whether green technology is likely to be up to the task of solving the twin crises caused by fossil fuel depletion and the environmental degradation fossil fuel use brings.</p><p>Answering that question requires answering a bunch of other scientific questions like: how much time are we likely to have? How bad is the environment likely to get and how quickly will it worsen? How much better can the green technology reasonably be expected to become and how quickly can it be improved? How much energy will we probably need in the future, and is that a feasible amount of energy for the green technology to be expected to generate in the time we are likely to have?</p><p>Since there are many unknowns in those questions, venturing an answer to them requires relying on assumptions for making predictions that may turn out to be wrong. The truth is, no one knows how this story ends. And the only way to judge the educated guesses today is to examine the soundness of the assumptions they are based upon. When Gibbs’ critics have stuck to assessing his assumptions, their points are usually fair. They say things like <a href="https://www.ecoequity.org/2020/04/why-the-planet-of-the-humans-is-crap/">“his central point…is pretty legit”</a>. But they don’t do a lot of that. Most of their criticisms have instead been off the mark because they have been <em>ad hominem</em> smears of Gibbs or of who they imagine he might be.</p><h4><strong>Traitors and “deplorables”</strong></h4><p>It is as if Gibbs’ critics believe if they can’t refute his assumptions they can at least tar Gibbs’ reputation as a lefty, to taint his message and what it says about them. So corporate environmentalists — let’s call them that — are taking a page out of the corporate Democrats’ playbook: paint Gibbs’ as traitor who is aiding the “deplorables” in big oil and Breitbart just as Bernie Sanders was painted as a double-crosser who would help “the deplorables” elect Donald Trump.</p><p>As if any of that is even remotely relevant to whether his thesis is right or wrong or worth considering.</p><p>We don’t know Gibbs so we cannot vouch for what is in his heart. We also don’t know Michael Moore although we have been fans of his movies for years. We imagine that if we were ever to meet Moore we would most probably like him since we share his political bent and are cracked up by his sense of humour. Moore supporting Gibbs was a good enough reason for us to want to give Gibbs’ thesis a hearing. And we are glad we did.</p><p>This much is clear. It took guts to make a controversial film like<em> Planet of the Humans</em>.<em> </em>Gibbs had to know he would piss off and alienate many of his friends on the left. And its thesis, if true, is pretty scary. But if Plan A — renewable energy — for saving the planet is fundamentally flawed, it is better to know that. All is not necessarily lost. Let’s hear the Plan Bs. And no, Plan B doesn’t mean riding out the end of fossil fuels. Choices don’t have to be binary.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=517d047559ed" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Planet of the Humans exposes dirty secrets and the green movement needs to own up]]></title>
            <link>https://butler0910.medium.com/planet-of-the-humans-exposes-dirty-secrets-and-the-green-movement-needs-to-own-up-8ece2bc64084?source=rss-6f8c564a429a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8ece2bc64084</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[planet-of-the-humans]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bill-mckibben]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[michael-moore]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Leslie Butler]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 08 May 2020 13:23:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-05-08T13:49:22.954Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*R8dFbD951Fmg6Wey8kl2jw.jpeg" /></figure><p>By Leslie Butler and Alan Wain</p><p>It’s hard not to empathize with environmental activist Bill McKibben lamenting how he comes off in <em>Planet of the Humans</em>, Michael Moore and Jeff Gibbs’ hit documentary about greenwashing in the renewable energy sector. And empathize we should, on a human level.</p><p>McKibben has penned a very <a href="https://www.rollingstone.com/politics/political-commentary/bill-mckibben-climate-movement-michael-moore-993073/">personal piece</a> for <em>Rolling Stone</em> in which he describes himself as the “foil” in a film that warns renewable energy cannot and will not save us from planetary destruction wrought by the burning of fossil fuels. A foil is a hero’s nemesis, the bad guy opposing the good guy. The foil’s purpose in a story is to provide a contrast to a protagonist or hero to help show us what’s heroic about the hero.</p><p>But if that’s the case, maybe McKibben is not actually the foil to the hero of <em>Planet of the Humans </em>because the film has no hero who appears as McKibben’s opposite. It only has a very worried narrator who is disappointed and unimpressed with the record of green energy, and who, accordingly, has some alarming revelations to share with viewers.</p><p>McKibben says the release of Gibbs’ film feels like someone detonated a bomb within the environmental movement. He implies Gibbs is being destructive and cruel towards the good, hard working people of the movement, undermining their laudable attempts to do good deeds on our behalf.</p><h4>Shooting the messenger</h4><p>It is an interesting twist on the “bombshell” revelations of Gibbs’ documentary. Because, make no mistake, the film, like every good expose, does indeed drop some bombshells that shatter our previously held notions. It is a recurring dramatic technique Gibbs uses effectively, over and over again to tell his story. It is what makes the film so interesting.</p><p>Gibbs shows us apparently solar powered festivals…that actually rely on generators to keep their lights on. He shows us electric cars…and then reminds us the electricity that will power them comes from fossil fuels. He shows us solar panels … and then tells us that they are connected to natural gas powered generators. In each case, he shows us the publicly visible face of something and then the surprising thing to which it is connected.</p><p>In each case he is asking: did you know about or think about this connection? And in each case the reveal works because we are surprised to have to admit that either we never knew or hadn’t considered the connection. To average folk like us, viewing the green movement only from a distance, these connections are news, thought-provoking news.</p><p>The fact that Gibbs’ film is an expose says something about the green moment that its activists don’t like. It says the activists must have been less than straightforward with the public about what green technology is because it is impossible to do an expose on something that is already common knowledge.</p><p>Somehow, many of us got the impression that a 100 per cent renewable power source would be, well, 100 per cent powered by renewable sources of energy. We somehow came to assume that “solar powered” meant <em>just </em>solar powered. We got the mistaken idea that green energy was displacing, not augmenting, traditional, dirty, non-renewable energy.</p><h4>Excessive positivity</h4><p>You can say those wrong impressions are on us. We should have read the fine print, the little asterisk that says “solar generation may contain some coal burning, maybe lots of coal burning”. We didn’t do that. We let ourselves get buoyed up and excited by the happy headlines displayed each time a wind or solar or biomass plant opens. So it’s no wonder we are finding ourselves uncomfortably dismayed by the fine print to which Gibbs is now directing our attention.</p><p>But we, as fans of the green movement who wish people like McKibben well and who are rooting ardently for the environmentalists to succeed at saving our planet, don’t share their anger at Gibbs and Michael Moore. The filmmakers are only doing what Ralph Nader has made an admirable career of doing — going behind the scenes and showing consumers surprising things. If there is something disturbing and alarming in the fine print or happening behind the scenes, that’s what we get upset about. We don’t want to shoot the messenger.</p><p>With all due respect to the well-intended and decent leaders of the environmental movement, they bear some responsibility for leaving themselves open to an expose. There would have been nothing to reveal if the leaders of the green movement had been up front and perfectly candid all along. Instead they chose to accentuate the positive so much that some of us got incorrect impressions. Excessive positivity doesn’t help the green cause because fans of environmental activists, just like defence attorneys, need all the facts to effectively defend their people.</p><p>Being less than honest can seriously damage a movement. People hate finding out, for example, that all of their dutiful recycling ends up in the same landfill, or that it takes more energy and resources to recycle than the recycling industry is admitting. No one who really cares wants to be part of an exercise in virtue signalling.</p><h4>Getting it done in the short time physics allows</h4><p>It’s not hard to see why McKibben is stung by the film. As a giant of the environmental movement with a long list of achievements, it must be hard for McKibben to see himself portrayed as someone who spent his life working for a losing cause, and it must be particularly galling when the messengers are his fellow lefties.</p><p>As he talks about passing the torch to young activists, McKibben strikes a wistful tone. He believes the young people are “headed in the right direction” and that they “have the basic message right”. But he also expresses doubt about whether they can get it done in the “short time physics allots us.” And this is, in a nutshell, the exact fear Gibbs raised that sparked an avalanche of vitriol against <em>Planet of the Humans.</em> It obviously matters whether the green movement “gets it done” because a good try won’t save us. But how dare Gibbs raise this topic in public in front of ordinary people.</p><p>In response, angry and incredulous critics of Gibbs’ film dismiss his evidence, discredit his experts, impugn his motives, but few present compelling evidence to dispute his contention that green energy is at best long shot and at worst an enabler for continued consumption. They link readers to hopeful short term studies from a handful developed countries and <em>infer </em>a planet wide trend, they cite evidence that green has made vast improvements in efficiency and longevity, but they cannot and do not provide a meaningful calculus that this will be in time and enough. And if that can’t be done, it would be irresponsible in the extreme <em>not</em> to look at solutions other than incremental gains in renewable energy.</p><p>But the defenders of green currently attacking Gibbs not only ignore solutions such as population control, a rejection of consumer capitalism, massive institutional and fundamental economic change, they vilify them with accusations of racism and naivety. They fall back on incrementalism, movement building and small victories.</p><p>Rather than tackle the heart of matter head on by admitting that the danger Gibbs raises is real, too many environmentalists have doubled down on obfuscation. They say Gibbs thesis has been “debunked” because more recent green technology is now better than the technology shown in the film. Therefore the film needs to be updated. Only if the update would convincingly show that green has the capacity to buy us enough time, the tech-has-improved argument is not convincing.</p><h4>Politics and the “circular firing squads”</h4><p>So being short on relevant, reliable hard science that focusses on the question the film raises, Gibbs’ critics focus on the alleged <em>political</em> problems the film has created for the left. The headline of McKibben’s piece is, “A bomb in the centre of the climate movement”.</p><p>McKibben spends a lot of time talking about the danger of divisiveness in the environmental movement, about Obama’s reference to “circular firing squads”, about progressives “eating their own”, and even about the effect of the film on voter turnout. The themes of disloyalty, betrayal, ingratitude and terrorism are all front and center. It is all a bit much given that the film that stirred up all this controversy is ostensibly about a scientific issue: how good is green technology at saving us?</p><p>The reaction to Gibbs’ film has also been nakedly political and weirdly vicious given that it has become an in-house debate among lefties who have been friends for many years. Michael Moore, who produced the film, has an impressive record of championing left wing causes. One might think that would have bought him some trust from his fellow lefties. But once the film implied that McKibben allowed himself to be seduced by corporate green washers, the gloves came off. McKibben has countered by calling Moore “a millionaire carnival barker”, a bully who now mostly “punches down”, and a person more concerned with brand management than the issues. He has called the film a <a href="https://www.insidehook.com/daily_brief/movies/bill-mckibben-michael-moore-movie">“sewer”</a> and “bad journalism”.</p><p>By arguing politics, rather than demonstrating the technology is up to the task, the environmental movement has conceded Gibbs’ basic point — that so far, as of today, the technology is not ready to displace fossil fuels. So the environmentalists have no choice but to talk about their hopes for the future rather than their capabilities today. They just want to keep hope alive in the meantime. They seem very worried that Gibbs’ film will kill hope.</p><p>But we, who found <em>Planet of the Humans </em>so interesting and enlightening, are only interested in keeping realistic and appropriate hope alive. We don’t want to fight the good fight only to signal our virtue and then experience failure. We want to actually win. We have to win. And the victory has to be the right kind.</p><h4><strong><em>Dismembering the earth</em></strong></h4><p>Gibbs’ film put more than one fear into us. There’s the fear that renewables might not be all they have been cracked up to be. And then there is an even deeper one that Dr. William Rees of the University of British Columbia has noticed. He puts it this way:</p><p>“Even if renewables were ‘the answer’ — i.e. even if techno-industrial capitalist society succeeds in contriving any cheap plentiful substitute for fossil fuels — it would be catastrophic. Without a sea-change in expansionist values and our anthropocentric/instrumentalist approach to the natural world, humans would simply use the energy bounty to complete their dismemberment of Earth. (The film’s horrific sequences of stranded Orangutans — habitats destroyed for palm-oil plantations to provide ‘green’ energy to motor vehicles — is perhaps illustrative.)” Read an interview with Dr. Rees about the film <a href="http://www.thechantecler.org/?fbclid=IwAR0J3LRPTlpIzm9nsKmwTmOcPvmrSF1KTP3GGhOM8mpQNVLsnHauqoBIJfM">here</a>.</p><p>We’ve all clearly got a lot more to talk about thanks to Gibbs’ provocative film. Let’s hope we can all do it more civilly, like friends stuck on the same planet.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8ece2bc64084" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>