<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by The Charter of the Genome on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by The Charter of the Genome on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@bzring?source=rss-56ce01f25b02------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 00:03:29 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@bzring/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Genetics To End All War (and bring about universal peace)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@bzring/genetics-to-end-all-war-a6ecfa275ad7?source=rss-56ce01f25b02------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a6ecfa275ad7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[peace]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[genetics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[The Charter of the Genome]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 23 Oct 2016 07:31:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-04-10T06:38:16.968Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*v5J22L92outc1LJ21eR0nA.jpeg" /></figure><h4><strong>An understanding of how our genes may be tied to our political choices and social bonds could help lessen our partisan discord- if we let it.</strong></h4><p>Conflict seems to be a part of the human spirit. A good story needs conflict, otherwise we’re apt to find it dull. A story about making a sandwich is not going to be very interesting, even if it looks like it would be a good sandwich. Ingredients will be laid out, and a sandwich will be made. There is no suspense, no tension. Sandwich aficionados will know this to be not <em>completely</em> true, as there is a certain unpredictability, even magic, in the creation of a good sandwich, and the hoped for outcome cannot be completely assured. Nonetheless it’s telling that “making a sandwich” is not a major fictional genre. However if I go to the kitchen to make that sandwich, and I see my son is reaching for the last two pieces of bread, now it’s interesting (to me). Steel cage death match is assured, and a story worthy of a last a direct-to-DVD movie is born.</p><p>Even if a story doesn’t appear to have conflict, we’ll insert it in our reading, just to add interest. For example, one bestselling book which has lots of conflict throughout, starts out with a story that’s ostensibly conflict free. “<em>In the beginning God created the heaven and the earth. And the earth was without form, and void; and darkness was upon the face of the deep</em>.” It’s just a slice of life story- except before there was life- a simple portrayal of everyday events-except there was no day yet, that comes later. Nonetheless, I read conflict into this story. There is a tension between order and chaos, between something and nothing. It’s like a sandwich story, except with higher stakes. Whether or not Moses meant to have that in there, conflict exists.</p><blockquote><strong>Like conflict, depositing people into categories of ‘us vs them’ is not necessary for a good story, but it seems to help.</strong></blockquote><p>Another common story element is a clear delineation of who the good people in the story are, and who are the bad people. Although modern literature, outside of the oeuvre of Tom Clancy and ilk, may not support simplistic definitions of who is good vs bad, at least the depiction of “us” vs “them” is usually made clear. Even with anti-hero’s, like Holden Caulfield in the perennial high school assignment of Catcher in the Rye, or for the moderns among us, Deadpool, or Jayne in Firefly, it’s clear that these characters are “us”, they are on our team. Whoever they are angry at (or in the case of Jayne and Deadpool, about to kill) is “them”.</p><p>This dichotomization of good vs evil, or us vs them, our crowd vs the others, isn’t as essential as conflict for a good story, but without it the author has to spend an extra effort helping us know who to root for. It may not be necessary for a story, but it certainly fits with how most of us see the world, to one degree or another. Kurt Vonnegut felt compelled to write of his eschewing of this story element.</p><blockquote>“I went to the University of Chicago for a while after the Second World War. I was a student in the Department of Anthropology. At that time they were teaching that there was absolutely no difference between anybody.</blockquote><blockquote>They may be teaching that still.</blockquote><blockquote>Another thing they taught was that no one was ridiculous or bad or disgusting. Shortly before my father died, he said to me, ‘You know — you never wrote a story with a villain in it.’</blockquote><blockquote>I told him that was one of the things I learned in college after the war.”</blockquote><p>Though a need for “us vs them” is common, how we define these two groups has a lot of variation. Nationality is a common way to delineate these sets. Clothing choice works too, in a pinch. Religion use to be a reliable method, as was race. There are many other tags we use, of course. Generally our field marks for who is on the good side will connect with power, in some form or other. Fortunately many of these attributes seem to be falling by the wayside. Surveys of how “warm” one feels towards people of other races or religions show a steady decrease over the last fifty years in the difference between our feelings for people in our group vs how we feel towards people outside it.</p><p>Possibly that Coke commercial from the 1970’s, I’d Like to Teach the World to Sing (In Perfect Harmony), had an effect.</p><p>On the other hand, we clearly haven’t achieved world peace yet. We’ve stopped using some tags to classify people as “other”, but we haven’t abandoned a need to keep people out of our group. In fact, resentment towards people of opposite political affiliations <a href="https://www.researchgate.net/publication/255992384_Affect_Not_Ideology_A_Social_Identity_Perspective_on_Polarization">has increased:</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/614/1*O5kKdbF9jhbbdZ1JbYafHg.png" /></figure><p>In a recent study of this phenomenon, people were asked to rate scholarship applications. The vast majority of participants, whether Democrat and Republican, preferentially chose to give students who were members of their own parties a scholarship, even when the candidate from the other party had stronger academic credentials. Race mattered too, but not as much (both whites and blacks preferred African Americans as recipients). This should be astonishing (which is a nice way to say “appalling”). Given a candidate for an academic scholarship with a better academic record, we nonetheless tend to choose candidates that will vote the same as us. Given that most students don’t bother to vote, this decision is wrong on multiple levels.</p><blockquote><strong>We’re beginning to abandon some old favorite methods of declaring some people to be “other”, but our political party preferences are becoming a new way to classify someone as outside the pale.</strong></blockquote><p>The study also examined if our political views could affect our judgement. Using an implicit bias test, they found that American participants were far more biased politically than they were racially (you can try the test <a href="https://implicit.harvard.edu/implicit/user/featuredtasks/polid2012/featuredtask.html">here</a>). The researchers found this surprising. “The common story is most Americans don’t care about politics”, <a href="http://www.vox.com/2015/12/7/9790764/partisan-discrimination">commented one author of the study</a>. “They don’t understand politics, they don’t understand policy. So you wouldn’t expect Americans to have strong preferences. That’s where I started.”</p><p>The participants in this study certainly were not non-political, and several surveys confirm this that this bias is growing and widespread. In 1960, about 5% of Republicans and Democrats would be“somewhat upset” or “very upset” by a “mixed party” marriage by their children. In 2008 that had risen to over 20%, and in 2010 almost 50% of Republicans (and 30% of Democrats) would object to their son or daughter marrying across party lines. British participants, asked a similar question about Conservative vs Labor party affiliation showed a similar, if less pronounced, trend.</p><p>It seems a bit like a seesaw, the importance of one of our discriminatory tags goes down, so another has to go up. Maybe we’re not ready for utopia, it’s as if we have an inborn need for some level of conflict in our society, just like we do in our fiction. As we decrease our use of religion, race, gender or sexual preference in deciding who is for us or against us, we are forced chose another criteria to put people in the “other” group, and the balance is restored, we maintain a constant number of people in the outside group. This may be good for weapons sales, but is less so for world peace. But is our need to put people out of our crowd really fixed? Don’t we have a choice in this?</p><blockquote><strong>Does there really have to be a constant size to the number of people that we put outside our “in crowd”?</strong></blockquote><p>Unless a balance between good and evil is an intrinsic part of the universe, and that hasn’t shown up in the Hubble space telescope photos yet, there shouldn’t be a need to have a set number of people in the wrong vs the right groups. So why does it appear to be a constant? The answer may be biological. One clue of this comes from the prevalence of social behavior; we are finding that our complex behaviors may be as much due to basic biology as they are to our human reason. Social interactions are found in all classes of organisms, from bacteria (who can engage in what is called “quorum sensing” to coordinate a number of behaviors), plants (which can interact with each other in a number of ways, including mycorrhizal networks, also called the “Wood Wide Web”), and of course in animals. Almost every organism is a social organism, and thus the notion that biology is a key factor in determining our social behavior is increasingly undeniable. And thus, determination of who and how many get to be in our in-crowd, may, in fact, be an intrinsic part of our physical makeup.</p><p>Our behaviors, we are discovering, are wired into our genes. Though we may like to think of ourselves as governed by reason, that genetics plays a strong role in our complex social behaviors shouldn’t be too surprising. It’s easy to imagine pressures on our ancestors that would select for genetic variability that affects how we decide our group membership. Under some circumstances, being open to other groups would be beneficial, for example when resources are plentiful, and sharing between communities could provide for more opportunities for hunting or mate selection. In contrast, when resources are limited then a drive to form tighter groups, probably based largely on kinship, could be more evolutionarily favorable. Even though logic usually dictates against it, you’re more likely to loan money to your brother-in-law than to a neighbor.</p><p>In other words, sometimes it’s good to have a loose characterization of “us”, sometimes it’s better to have a tighter rule. Evolutionary selection for both of these two traits could help ensure that the genetic drivers of both behaviors stay present in our gene pool. These genetic determinants could create our definition of what makes up “our” group, and likely help set the size of this group too. Genetic variants that affect our sensitivity to threats, how membership within the “in-group” or “out-group” is determined, or our preference for how tight we want our in-group to be, all could be important players in helping us decide who gets to be in our crowd.</p><blockquote><strong>Our genetic makeup might be determining both our political affiliation, as well as how we decide how to put people in our group.</strong></blockquote><p>The above is a “Just So” story, a plausible sounding explanation without real proof, but there is increasing evidence supporting that our group preferences have a genetic component. A common method to discern the effects of genetics vs environment (nature vs nurture) are twin studies, in which we expect to see a stronger sharing of traits between identical twins rather than fraternal twins. A recent <a href="http://www.midus.wisc.edu/findings/pdfs/1287.pdf">study</a> using this method found that genetics was strongly associated with in-group favoritism, and this seemed to overlap with a genetic contributor towards favoring traditionalism and authoritarianism. <a href="http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1540-5907.2010.00461.x/abstract">Another study</a>, which used family relationships other than just twins, and thus allowed for a larger study population, found a similarly strong link between genetics and many political and social attitudes or preferences.</p><p>How our genes specifically affect our determinants of political preferences and who is in our in-group isn’t yet clear. The family study found a strong link between genetics and our political affiliations, as well as our feelings towards the death penalty, gay rights, and capitalism. Probably these were not factors that were selected for during our evolution- though it’s very possible that field studies of primates are missing out on some important behavioral subtleties (what would a chimp poster saying “OCCUPY THE SAVANNAH” look like?). It’s likely that our genes help define our broad attitudes about social conduct and what cues we use to signal group membership. Some people may be more genetically predisposed to favor maintenance of our cultural norms, and others are more open to change. These factors, in turn, help determine our specific attitudes, like with what political party we identify.</p><p>Obviously these factors can interact in complicated manners. Someone may be genetically more willing to go against society’s norms, and thus be more likely to engage in behavior deemed risky or unusual by society. This is a trait found in many entrepreneurs and people favoring the politics of the left. However a person’s success via these risky endeavors (i.e., they get rich with their business) may lead to them adopting attitudes that favor societal norms, as their wealth is more secure when little is allowed to change. The initially out-group favoring leftist entrepreneur thus becomes rich, old and cranky, and is now an in-group favoring conservative. Unless you live in California, that is, where you are now called a venture capitalist and your new found wealth is channeled back into the out-groups, and you still vote on the left (as long as taxes stay reasonably low and you get invited to the right parties). The argument isn’t that genetics is a totalitarian driver of our political and personal attitude, but a significant contributor in a complex process.</p><p>For example, it’s been seen that variation in the dopamine D4 receptor gene may be important in affecting these kinds of behavior. Dopamine is a neurotransmitter that is involved in many aspects of brain function, including risk-based decision-making. Several studies have shown that this gene may be linked to risk taking or novelty seeking in people, as well as political attitudes. One <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/26246555">study</a> of over 1500 university students found that women with two copies of a particular dopamine D4 receptor variant were significantly more conservative. Another <a href="http://vipbg.vcu.edu/vipbg/nathan/publications/Hatemi2011.pdf">study</a>, which surveyed the entire genome, also implicated the dopamine pathway, and additionally found many genes involved in NMDA and glutamate related receptors to be associated to political attitudes. These receptors are known to play important role in memory and the development of the brain. The total number of genes involved in helping us decide on our group membership is impossible to calculate, no gene will have specific roles just towards shaping our political attitudes. Instead, hosts of genes are being found that may help shape the behaviors that make one more or less comfortable with being in the in-group or exploring the out-group.</p><p>So what does this all mean? It’s become clear that we have a biological drive that helps us define and align with an “us vs them” dichotomy, the in-groups and the out-groups. These inborn drivers to put people in (or out) of our group help ensure that conflict is never far from the story of our lives. Of course we make conscious and reasoned decisions about membership in these groups, but our biology sets a basic preference for us that we cannot change, and these preferences shape our political views. Those more willing to be open to changes to our societal norms tend to side with the Democrat (or Labor) party, while those that value preserving our norms may tend to the Republican or Conservative party. This is not to say that those on the left side of the political spectrum don’t perceive an out-group. Those on the right and left very definitely both have their “us vs them”s, but they have different rules to decide who is in which group. And of course, nobody has just one in-group and one out-group. Everyone is in many groups, some of which can overlap in complicated patterns. Supporters of Bernie Sanders, or anyone ever involved in high school cliques, know that this is true.</p><blockquote><strong>Can genetics lead us to the promised land and end political discord? Maybe not, but it can at least be a road sign in the general direction.</strong></blockquote><p>Is an understanding of genetics a new messiah that can lead us out of this innate conflict? No, but maybe understanding the biological basis for our political feelings can help bridge the divide. Two ways genetics could help: One, understanding that our desire to place people on our side or the other side is partially biology, and not solely a product of our reason, <em>should</em> help. However genetics has also shown us that our desire to eat another potato chip has more to do with a biology geared towards a caveman diet where high fat=nutritious, rather than a rational assessment of our actual caloric needs, and this knowledge does not stop us from eating said potato chip. Therefore this may not be too helpful, at least in the heat of a political argument. It’s hard to fight the biology of basic drives.</p><p>However a second aspect of this new understanding may offer us a better approach. We’ve made great strides in embracing diversity, though obviously much more work remains undone. We understand now that there is no justice, and no merit, in discriminating on the basis of race or gender. Our understanding of the biological and genetic underpinnings of these facets of our being has helped with this. We now know that, basically, we are all alike, despite our outward appearances. We may differ in skin color, but this is governed by just a few genes. Similarly, we may choose our political parties with a little more freedom than we choose our gender, but maybe not more than we choose our sexual preference. To some degree, we are <em>born</em> on the left or right side of the political spectrum.</p><p>It’s here that one can hope that genetics can help us have more understanding and compassion across our political divisions. Politics can be extraordinarily personal. As the studies discussed above show, our choice to be on the left or right is tied to a host of our personal traits and feelings. Being told that our choice is wrong can feel like an attack on our very core. However genetics now tells us that these attitudes of ours are partly outside of our control, are part of our shared evolutionary story. The biology-driven traits that help determine our political parties, whether we are comfortable with change or whether we favor maintenance of society’s norms, both have selective advantage in different circumstances. We are stronger for both sentiments being in our society than if we could purge one or the other from the land. Embracing this diversity among us is not only rational, but will make the world a more pleasant place.</p><p>Conflict is fine for stories, and easy-to-spot tags that set characters apart as the bad guy aren’t a problem either. After all, you only have a minute or two in which to capture your audience before the title sequence starts rolling, followed by the first commercial break. But as Kurt Vonnegut noted, that’s not what he was taught in school, and he did quite fine without villains in his stories. More importantly, life is different than fiction, and we clearly need to be doing a better job of getting past our differences in the real world. Can genetics help us bridge our divides? It should. Recognizing that our desire to put people into groups of us vs them is a reflection of our genetic and evolutionary story, and that those who disagree with us politically are responding to basic genetic drivers, just like we are with our political opinions, might just make our elections a little more peaceable.</p><p>Will we even be able to renounce a need for conflict such that we can embrace tales of sandwich making as an acceptable genre of fiction? Of that I’m less sure.</p><p>Title image “Peace DNA” credit to reddit.com/user/blakesta</p><p>[Originally published at <a href="http://charter-of-the-genome.org/2016/10/23/genetics-to-end-all-war/">The Charter of the Genome</a>]</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a6ecfa275ad7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Gene Editing and the Need for Science Fiction]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@bzring/gene-editing-and-the-need-for-science-fiction-cb9d785e0db3?source=rss-56ce01f25b02------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/cb9d785e0db3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[science-fiction]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[genetics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gene-editing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[health]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[The Charter of the Genome]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 23 Aug 2016 03:44:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-08-25T14:15:45.945Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*psdzKS8MZyFJGNxH83SsQg.jpeg" /></figure><h4>Thinking outside the Punnett square</h4><p>It’s the year 2035, and Crayola is releasing a new set of crayons for children who have been genetically modified to be tetrachromatic, able to see four primary colors instead of the usual three. Though the World Anti Doping Committee initially banned all “gene doping” of athletes, gene editing for the improvement of basic health has become so widespread that the Anti Doping Code is rewritten to allow athletes to engineer any “naturally occurring genetic variation”. China, which has been petitioning for this change for over ten years, is predicted to medal in most events in next year’s summer Olympics. Designed for military use, a “smart dog” is the subject of a series of lawsuits that has finally worked its way this year to the Supreme Court. By accepting a writ of habeus corpus on behalf of the plaintiff, smart dogs were essentially granted the status of personhood. And in another court case, a now standard suite of gene edits that boost cognitive potential is deemed as essential care, and will thus be provided free of cost via the US National Health Service. On the lighter side, the passenger pigeon population in the United States reached over one million birds this year. Extinct since the early 1900’s, the bird was reclaimed via a massive series of gene edits to the related band-tailed pigeon. Similarly, the small herd of genetically reclaimed mammoths in Glacier National Park is doing well (despite the absence of glaciers in the park for the last five years).</p><p>Almost assuredly, none of those events will happen that year (hopefully we’ll have the passenger pigeons much <a href="http://reviverestore.org/passenger-pigeon-de-extinction-roadmap/">sooner</a>, for one). It’s hard to predict what is happening right <em>now</em>, let alone twenty years in the future. For that matter I’m often not even sure what happened yesterday. Nonetheless, there has recently been a lot of talk in the genetics community about the need for guidelines of gene editing. As discussed <a href="http://charter-of-the-genome.org/2016/02/03/a-right-to-stay-human/">earlier</a>, new technology is making it easier to instill specific genetic changes to an embryo and create modified, even “designed” people. Wisely, we’ve already started talking about where this technology will lead us, and some general <a href="http://www8.nationalacademies.org/onpinews/newsitem.aspx?RecordID=12032015a">guidelines</a> on how to proceed are being discussed. The consensus is that before it can be applied to people, this technology needs to be safer, clearly benefit the recipient, and be subject to appropriate regulation.</p><p>The current dialogues on gene editing are mostly concerned with the safety of the recipient, is the technology good enough that there won’t be unanticipated problems for people modified via this technology? There is agreement that we’re not ready yet to generally apply the technology to people, especially not at the germline level, that is, where we modify an embryo so that every cell in the resulting adult will carry the genetic change. Despite these concerns, the hope seems to be that the use of this technology is not too far off, at least for the application of repairing genetic variants linked to life-threatening diseases. However it is an easy series of steps to go from using the technology to fix a variant in the haemoglobin gene so as to prevent a child from being born with sickle cell disease, to using it to fix genetic variants associated with increased risk of heart attack in old age, to “fixing” gene variations <em>not</em> associated with above average intelligence. Once an ethics committee allows the use of gene editing for the first instance, we may arrive at the third case much more quickly than we anticipated. It’s likely that use of the technology will rapidly extend into new territories soon after it begins to be employed for any reason.</p><blockquote><strong><em>It’s hard to create ethical guidelines for a new technology when we don’t know yet what choices we will face</em></strong></blockquote><p>This makes having an ethics discussion about gene editing difficult. The potential negative repercussions to society of ensuring that a child is not born with a particular debilitating disease are small, while the benefit to the child is great. There is little disagreement that this type of application would be a great achievement for the technology. But what about some of the other uses of gene editing? A technology that could make one’s children smarter, better looking, and healthier than the average child is a different kettle of fish than preventing a debilitating disease. This is especially true if, as will surely be the case, gene editing is an expensive procedure only available to the few.</p><p>How to anticipate the ethics of choices that don’t exist yet? Or should we even try? Too much regulation can stifle innovation, yet too little can allow technology to ride roughshod over society. The Locomotive Act of 1865, enacted by Parliament in the UK, stipulated that “road locomotives” (“cars”, in our modern parlance) must adhere to these stipulations:</p><p><em>(1) At least three persons shall be employed to drive or conduct such locomotive….</em></p><p><em>(2) One of such persons, while any locomotive is in motion, shall precede such locomotive on foot by not less than sixty yards, and shall carry a red flag constantly displayed, and shall warn the riders and drivers of horses of the approach of such locomotives, and shall signal the driver thereof when it shall be necessary to stop, and shall assist horses, and carriages drawn by horses, passing the same.</em></p><p>Furthermore, speed limits were set:</p><p><em>…it shall not be lawful to drive any such locomotive along any turnpike road or public highway at a greater speed than four miles an hour, or through any city, town, or village at a greater speed than </em><strong><em>two</em></strong><em> miles an hour;</em></p><p>It must have been great to get out of the city and be able to open that throttle and speed up to a blistering four miles an hour. It wasn’t until this act was amended in 1896, in part from pressure from automobile enthusiasts, that our modern relationship of the car and the road was able to exist (for better or worse).</p><p>It’s easy, at first read, to dismiss the Locomotive Act as reactionary technophobia, or machinations by the railroad industry to stifle new innovation. After all, this was only fifty years after the Luddites were burning mills in England. On the other hand, the vehicles the act had in mind were not exactly like today’s cars. Here is an example of a relatively small road locomotive:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Yy1x6-A7o7hrd_14UU_Zyg.jpeg" /></figure><p>[image credit: David Collidge <a href="http://www.steamscenes.co.uk/">http://www.steamscenes.co.uk/</a>]</p><p>Loosening these anti-automobile regulations ultimately improved the efficiency of the economy, but also ceded control of roads from use by pedestrians to becoming the domain of the car. Cities are now designed more to facilitate the automobile than people. Without reasonable regulation we often find ourselves forced to adapt <em>to</em> technology, rather than being permitted to use it (or not use it) on our own terms (acolytes of the philosophers of technology Jacques Ellul, Ivan Illich or Lewis Mumford should nod vigorously at this point).</p><p>Except for a small number of Ayn Rand acolytes, who tend to be easy to identify and avoid, few doubt that new technologies need some regulation. However, as occurred in the thirty year’s between the Locomotive Act and its amendment, it’s common for technology to advance much faster than the legislation we create to oversee it. How do we set reasonable rules, or ethical guidelines, when we don’t know where the technology will lead?</p><blockquote><strong><em>It’s easy, fun, yet probably pointless to imagine an unending list of dystopian gene editing scenarios</em></strong></blockquote><p>The examples in the first paragraph of how gene editing may be used are largely harmless, possibly even fun. However it’s easy to imagine other used of the technology that are more complex, or are just patently bad ideas. If instead of correcting life threatening diseases, or selecting for clearly favorable traits, like increased intelligence, what do we do if some parents want traits for their children that serve no obvious benefit except to their own personal aesthetic? Having large eyes, like a character in a Japanese manga, or looking like a Klingon, or to be covered in fur and have a tail may seem fantastical, but some people would like this if possible. What if an industry is created that steals genetic containing material (like some strands of hair) from movie stars and then offers a “Be Brad Pitt” service to parents? Terrorists could create novel smallpox variants and then use gene drive techniques to make all mosquitoes to be a vector. A ‘Back to the Pleistocene’ group brings back the Neanderthals and petitions they be given the right to vote. Some jobs are now open only to those who have visual sensors and emitters in their fingertips, a technology first developed for gamers as it allows a level of human-machine interface not available to “un-edits”. On the agricultural front, it’s recognized that traditional methods for breeding new plant varieties is essentially random genetic engineering, and is outlawed; new crops can only be created from a small list of white-listed cultivars as the recipients of the gene edits, new crops must be tested via randomized clinical trials for safely, and all genetic modifications have to be clearly listed.</p><p>It’s easy (and fun) to add to this list. I could do this all day. Nonetheless this list probably doesn’t encompass the scenarios that we will actually have to confront.</p><p>Is there a better way? Hackers are sometimes used to check the security of computer networks and servers. One could imagine a similar “black hat” approach to this problem. The idea is simple: train some psychopaths in the technology of genetic engineering and then monitored to see how far off the reservation can they take gene editing. #ProbablyBadIdea.</p><p>A safer, and more fun, idea is to include science fiction authors in the discussion. A problem with lists of “what ifs”, like above, is that they have no context. We can create endless lists of disturbing or scary uses of gene editing. What is more interesting, and more useful, is understanding <em>why</em> someone would actually want that particular edit, and what happens afterwards. In other words, we want the story of the gene edit.</p><p>An oft-mentioned trope of the perils of genetic engineering is the design of the super-soldier. A nefarious government secretly creates elite enhanced soldiers that can operate outside the bounds of normal humans. In the movies, heartbreak, suffering, and lots of manly handshakes/back slaps are the usual outcomes. So, let’s just add a “no creating super-soldiers” amendment to our guidelines for gene editing? But would a government really make super-soldiers via genetic engineering? If you think about it, it’s probably a pretty bad plan. You have to wait twenty years to see if the project works, and no one is going to offer their children to be modified so they can fight in situations too dangerous for a normal soldier. It’s easier, cheaper, quicker to invest in more body armor and those fancy new phased plasma rifles in the 40 watt range. Even cheaper is to not use soldiers at all, but that idea’s time doesn’t seem to have yet come. So maybe we can just ignore this “super-soldier” possibility for now?</p><blockquote><strong><em>Adding science fiction writers to our genetic advisory panels may increase the liquor bill, but will also allow us to understand this new technology as stories.</em></strong></blockquote><p>A science fiction writer might agree that the genetically engineered soldier is a bad story idea. However, it’s also possible that they might find a reasonable context for this idea. Here is one story pitch about super-soldiers: It’s 2025, and the US is worried that China might be developing a super-soldier project. Or at least, the idea has been in so many movies that nobody on the Joint Chiefs of Staff is clear any more whether they read about this in an actual intelligence briefing, or if it was the plot of one of the latest summer blockbusters. We still outclass China on a technological level in our armed forces (barely), but the Pentagon is worried about the psychological effect of the (supposed) Chinese program. Will our soldiers feel outclassed if put up against soldiers who are demonstrably superior people? And in a somewhat related matter, there is growing social tension in the US as wealthy families are increasingly opting to get expensive gene edits for their offspring, a choice out of the price range for most families. There is concern that a permanent genetic underclass could develop. Even though the current center-left president gained office by denouncing the recent disastrous conflict in the Pacific and has pledged to end militarism in the Pacific region, they are won over to the super-soldier project. In exchange for five years military service when they come of age, as well as committing to lifetime enrollment in the reserves, children produced by embryonic modification with the super-soldier mods (which includes improved reaction time, strength, stamina and nighttime visual acuity, a set of novel enzymes that can metabolize custom drugs that alleviate the need for sleep and decrease pain perception, plus, it’s assumed, a host of secret edits) will also receive an extensive package of edits that remove all known disease-related variants, as well as gene variants linked to improved intelligence. It’s billed as a win-win solution for the military and society at large.</p><p>The outcome twenty years later (choose your story ending), is that A) these super-soldiers take over the US in a military coup because the idea of the citizen-soldier has now been erased, B) the project is a fundamental disaster; as all the soldiers receive the same set of intelligence gene variants, their responses are predictable and easily countered, C) society is not able to repatriate these elite soldiers back to society after their service, and an island reservation is created to house them (I’m pretty sure I saw this movie on an airplane once), or D) everything works out fine and it was a good idea.</p><p>Given this write-up, we can see two things. One, creating super-soldiers is probably a bad idea. Second, a key driver of this particular application may be not the need for better soldiers, but a means to offer gene editing to a wide spectrum of society, and thus avoid the creation of a new genetic caste system in society.</p><blockquote><strong><em>Stories allow us to understand a subject in relationship to our inner selves. Stories about gene editing can thus show us where the real drivers of its ethical quagmires may lie</em></strong>.</blockquote><p>The stratification of society as a result of (or purposely created by) genetic engineering has already been explored in science fiction, of course. From Huxley’s “Brave New World”, David Brin’s “Uplift” series, to the movie GATTACA, it usually doesn’t appear to be a good thing. It’s easy to imagine other questionable applications of gene editing rooted in the stratification of society that might be caused by the technology. For example, those extravagant aesthetic modifications, like big cartoonish eyes or fur, could also be prompted by this driver. A story line: a suite of modifications for increased intelligence is created by the Tyrell Corporation. Because of the GoogleGene vs State of Puerto Rico decision in 2025, gene edits are not patentable, so Tyrell’s gene edit package is a trade secret, and is very expensive. Subtly showing off the broad foreheads characteristic of infants with these mods becomes a form of one-upmanship among new parents. At least, it is among the few that can afford these edits. Much cheaper aesthetic modifications become a way for less well-heeled parents to show that they are part of the gene editing game as well. They’re saying, “My decision to not buy either the “Voltaire” or “Copernicus” package from Tyrell isn’t necessarily because I can’t afford it, but because I’m making a life style decision. Judge me at your peril.”</p><p>The point of outlining these two stories is not to say we need to allow the public availability of free gene editing to ensure we don’t have super-soldier programs and to prevent parents from trying to make their children look like Brad Pitt or have a fine pelt of tawny fur. The broader issue is that we need to start thinking outside the relatively rigid framework that most science discourse operates within to understand where this technology may lead us, and why some of us might want to go there. Despite the inherent difficult in the task, we probably need more of these discussion groups exploring the guidelines for the use of gene editing. Geneticists are needed on these advisory panels, of course. They understand the tools, and their weaknesses and strengths. Bioethicists can help frame the question of how the technology can be developed in ways that are socially responsible. But science fiction writers are needed too. Not just to help think of the crazy uses for the technology, though they’re great for that, but more importantly, to place the technology into stories for us.</p><p>Stories are how we understand our lives, and in turn, our stories also explain us. But our stories aren’t just a search for meaning, our stories help create us as well. Stories allow us to connect our physical, outer world with our inner world. A science fiction writer on the advisory genetic engineering panel (or better yet, two, so as to help ensure that at last one is likely to be sober at any moment), can place this new technology into the context of our life. As the German Romantic poet Novalis said, “The seat of the soul is there where the inner and outer worlds meet.” By placing the technology into relation to our soul, an understanding of where we will want to take these new tools naturally follows. Instead of a simple list of bad scenarios to avoid, most of which won’t happen, the writer can give us an understanding of who we are, and what the technology can mean to us.</p><p>Plus, you might get something out of the discussion that you can sell to Hollywood. Brad Pitt can play the part of his clones.</p><p>[top image credit: “Grandma” by Chase Stone]</p><p>[First published at <a href="http://charter-of-the-genome.org/2016/08/22/gene-editing-and-the-need-for-science-fiction/">The Charter of the Genome</a>]</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=cb9d785e0db3" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Dark Genes]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@bzring/dark-genes-3e8956542c06?source=rss-56ce01f25b02------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3e8956542c06</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[genetics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[The Charter of the Genome]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 23 Jul 2016 19:01:11 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-07-23T19:01:11.521Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*1IS1z68kGhuN5Bl-glnfyA.jpeg" /></figure><h4>The Genetics of Evil</h4><p>A compilation of the 50 most evil villains in literature by the UK’s newspaper, The Telegraph, listed the devil at the number one position on its list. The number two position was given to a fictional rat. Samuel Whiskers, from Beatrix Potter’s story, The Tale Of Samuel Whiskers, is certainly a bad fellow. He steals from the house in which he lives, and tries to make Tom Kitten into a dumpling:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/1*aQ-p6qd9nbMUbaV0mxLJVA.jpeg" /></figure><p>But determining whether Samuel Whiskers is truly evil is difficult. According to most Western traditions, evil is the absence of good, and doesn’t have an independent identity. Other traditions, such as Buddhism, in which evil is an intrinsic element of existence, or Zoroastrianism and Star Wars, in which good and evil are opposing forces, have different definitions. Even if we stick with Western definitions, the question of Samuel Whiskers still is not clear. According to Thomas Aquinas, evil is the absence of goodness which should be found in our nature. A rat, which is an omnivore, may be acting in accord with its nature when it tries to eat a kitten (Tom Kitten survives, by the way, and learns to avoid rats in the future), and thus is not really evil. At best we could say that he seems to be participating in a metaphysical evil, in that nature can seem cruel and evil. As Woody Allen said, “To me, nature is… I dunno, spiders and bugs and big fish eating little fish. And plants eating plants and animals eating…It’s like an enormous restaurant.”</p><blockquote><strong><em>A well fed rat may not be evil </em>per se<em>, but cooking a live kitten in a dumpling probably is.</em></strong></blockquote><p>So let’s suppose that Tom Kitten and Samuel Whiskers are both people, or at least, sentient beings, and judging by their clothing (Tom Kitten had a nice blue jacket before being covered in dough), that is a reasonable assumption. In this case, most would agree that Samuel Whiskers was performing a moral evil by going against our accepted moral order. Sentient beings don’t cook each other for their puddings. Furthermore, Aquinas also suggests that as our world is not in itself bad, evil must exist within our actions, not in the effect. In this case, a well fed rat (the result of eating Tom Kitten) is not an evil thing, <em>per se</em>. Rats deserve to be fed. However, rolling a live kitten into a dumpling is evil.</p><p><em>Why</em> Samuel Whiskers is evil is an even more difficult question than determining if he is evil. All rodents are not bad to Beatrix Potter, as her Tale of Mrs. Tittlemouse clearly attests. Therefore the problem must be something specific to Samuel. Still following Aquinas, the root cause of evil is our free will, we have been given the freedom to make bad choices, and we frequently do so. Aquinas states that maybe sometimes the temptation to transgress can come from that villain at the number one slot on The Telegraph’s list (Satan), but often not, it’s just our choice. Current thinking, which largely discounts a role of Satan in clinical psychology, specifically posits social and economic factors as main factors in prompting our transgressions. Additionally, since the 1960’s a genetic cause for moral evilness has also been a contested but active area of research.</p><p>One of my personal pleasures that I don’t often broadcast is an appreciation for the Taiwanese TV series Meng Xue Yuan. A story about a boarding school for magically adept students, it’s like Harry Potter written with the sensibilities of Gilligan’s Island (or Mr Bean). The heroine of the story, Wuke Nana (烏克娜娜), upon discovering that her father was a dark wizard, flees the school, explaining, “我有暗黑基因!” (I have dark genes!). In her own way, Wuke Nana is raising a valid question, is evil heritable?</p><blockquote><strong><em>XYY males: aggressive super males or not? (answer: not)</em></strong></blockquote><p>A specific genetic cause for evilness, or to be more clinically precise, antisocial behavior, was first proposed in the 1960’s when it was found that some males harbor an extra Y chromosome (so that they were XYY instead of the normal XY). Carriers of this rare genetic condition (occurring in about 1 out of 1000 males) were suggested by early studies to be found in prison populations more than expected by chance. The president of the American Association for the Advancement of Science in 1970 suggested that these dangerous and aggressive “super males” could be eliminated from society if women carrying fetuses with an XYY set of chromosomes would be required to abort them. Subsequent studies have found that though XYY might be associated with slighter lower intelligence, there doesn’t appear to be any direct connection to aggressiveness or law breaking. Nonetheless, the idea that XYY males are dangerous still persists in much literature.</p><p>Despite this setback in identifying genetic determinants of criminality, we know that genetics affects all aspects of our life, including behavior, so few doubt that there can be found a manner in which our genes can contribute to morally unaccepted actions. Our genes are rarely completely determinative, however, and never act alone. Therefore current studies often try to see how our genetic variations may interact with other social factors that can contribute to antisocial behavior. For example, a variant of the serotonin transporter protein gene (SLC6A4) <a href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2916190/">has been found</a> to confer a risk of predatory, psychopathic traits in children raised in disadvantaged environments.</p><blockquote><strong><em>Seratonin: psychopharmacology wonder chemical</em></strong></blockquote><p>That serotonin is important factor in regulating our behavior is well established, and so the finding that genetic variants affecting Seratonin uptake make affect antisocial behavior is not surprising. Seratonin is a chemical messenger in the brain, and the neurons to which it binds are involved in a wide range of processes, including sensitivity to pain, regulation of the heart and respiration, mood, and even learning and basic cognition. It also has been shown to affect a number of psychiatric conditions, such as schizophrenia, depression, addiction, and anxiety. Drugs which target the serotonin system (termed selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors, or SSRIs) work by altering the levels of serotonin in the brain. Common brands of SSRI’s include Prozac and Zoloft.</p><p>Besides the serotonin transporter protein gene SLC6A4, several other genes have been shown to be able to apparently contribute to antisocial behavior. In one <a href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3684360/">recent study</a>, tryptophan hydroxylase 1 (TPH1); the serotonin transporter (SLC6A4); and monoamine oxidase A (MAOA), each of which is involved in the regulation of serotonin, also were associated with early signs of antisocial behavior (physically aggressive behavior, disruptiveness, and relational aggression, etc.). The relationship of these genes to behavior was not simple, however. Among non-mistreated children there were no differences in antisocial behavior associated with the studied genetic variations. In contrast, among maltreated children the variations in the three genes were each significantly related to an increase in reports of antisocial behavior.</p><p>None of these studies are definitive. Measurement of antisocial can be subjective, and much larger studies are needed. However the basic notion that genetic variants can contribute to behavior that violates our moral codes is becoming better established.</p><blockquote><strong><em>A genetics of evil?</em></strong></blockquote><p>Whether this means there is a genetics of evil is still not clear. Recall Samuel Whiskers: was he participating only in a metaphysical evil, that is, he didn’t violate a rat moral code, but his actions were viewed as evil because preying on the week by the strong in nature seems evil? This is evil only by analogy, and if we believe that that nature itself cannot be evil, then a metaphysical evil doesn’t really exist. Or did Samuel perform a moral evil because he violated the moral code of all pants-wearing sentient beings? If the former is true, if our genes determine our nature and we must be judged accordingly, then one might argue that children with SLC6A4 variants are only acting according to their proper nature when they act with heightened aggression. If we believe the latter, then an immoral act is an immoral act, no matter our genetic makeup.</p><p>Though the genetics of metaphysical evil may seem like a question only for the philosophers, it’s an important issue. In 2010 the governor of Ohio commuted the death sentence of Sidney Cornwell, a gang member convicted of killing a young girl in a drive-by shooting. Sidney Cornwell carries an XXY set of chromosomes, instead of having the extra Y of the XYY males mentioned previously, he has an extra X chromosome. This condition, like XYY, has been associated with a lower IQ on average. The judge decided that this genetic condition reduced his responsibility below that required to merit a death penalty. In other words, it was decided that it was in Sidney Cornwell’s nature to act in a manner not completing fitting with society’s standards. It is probable that the harboring of variations in genes in the serotonin pathway will also become issues in court cases in the near future.</p><p>However, it’s unlikely we’ll adopt a completely biological view of the nature of evil. Sidney Cornwell was not released based on his genetic makeup, his sentence was only reduced. Likewise most of us are will not attest that we are completely beholden to our genetic makeup. Origen, a 2nd century theologian, stated that even if the devil were no more, our desire for food, sex and the like will still make us stray. Temptations are always around us, sometimes more, sometimes less, sometimes made more difficult to resist based on our genetic code, sometimes easier to resist. Even if we do have dark genes, like Wuke Nana, we are still responsible for our actions.</p><p>[First published at <a href="http://charter-of-the-genome.org/2016/07/22/dark-genes/">The Charter of the Genome</a>]</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3e8956542c06" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Intersect of Harry Potter and Charles Darwin]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@bzring/the-intersect-of-harry-potter-and-charles-darwin-12a4fc3c504f?source=rss-56ce01f25b02------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/12a4fc3c504f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[evolution]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[harry-potter]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[genetics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[The Charter of the Genome]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 22 Jun 2016 15:36:39 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-06-22T15:36:39.249Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*VCkkOJepf97EfsZaAJpulg.jpeg" /></figure><h4><strong>Genetics, fan fiction, and the meaning of life.</strong></h4><p>An excellent rule for avoiding conflict in social situations is to avoid any discussion of religion and politics. A recent addendum to this advice would be to also shun discussing the potential love interest of fictional characters, or in the lingo of fan-fiction, “’ships”. An example: in the world of Harry Potter, for many, Harry and Ginny Weasley never marry, though this was established in the final book’s epilogue. For these fans, whose mantra is “Epilogue? What epilogue?” the correct pairings are Harry and Hermione, Harry and Draco Malfoy, or Hermione and Snape (incidentally, I will contend that last one is wrong on multiple levels). Online discussions of the obviousness or absurdity, propriety or unseemliness of these relationships can assume levels of violent self-righteousness that makes one very grateful that these arguments are conducted largely within a demographic with low gun ownership.</p><p>Fictional characters engender so much emotion in us because they are incomplete, no matter how good the author is. In fact, good writing is as much as what should be left unsaid as what needs to be written down. The book (or the movie) can only give us a limited set of facts or images. The full character of a character is left unwritten, and it’s our job as readers to fill this in. Therefore it is in the act of reading, when we fill in the blanks with our own visions, that gives the characters real meaning. And when our visions of a character’s personality are denied in book five, or in episode four of the second season, or the epilogue, or even in someone else’s fan fiction, it’s a personal attack. We’ve created the characters in our image, and vested them with our own visions of what they mean to their fictional world, and now that is being annulled. And in the cases of those writing any romances which involve Dumbledore, those fan fiction versions of the character are also just plain wrong.</p><blockquote><strong><em>Except for cereal boxes and magazine covers, most things in our life don’t readily tell us their inner substance</em></strong></blockquote><p>It’s not just the inner life of fictional characters that are left to our own efforts to create. In fact, barring the descriptions on boxes of breakfast cereal, most things in our life don’t have their complete meaning handed to us in large text and colorful pictures. It is by filling in these blanks, by creating meaning in our life where there was no obvious meaning before, that we define ourselves. This is why we are so sensitive to disagreement on some subjects. Our politics describes how we believe we ought to live together as a society, and what our roles and duties to our community entail. Our philosophy and religion tells us how we relate to the whole universe. Encountering others with differing views means either that one of us is wrong, or that we need to build a tent for our world views that is big enough to house all these contrary stories. Choosing the former is usually the easiest choice, with the other person being the one that is wrong, of course.</p><p>We do much of this creation of meaning via storytelling, we create or share narratives that describe our beliefs. Stories about past kings or presidents that exemplify our best attributes, or stories about events, historical or mythical, that describe our place in this world, are all integral to how we understand ourselves. Arthur and his Round Table illustrate bravery and fairness, Moses and the Pharaoh describes steadfastness and justice, and King Charles hiding in the oak tree reminds us that even kings sometimes have to hide in trees (actually I’m not sure of the meaning of this legend, but it’s a good story). Similarly our preferences in fiction, whether it’s political thrillers, science fiction, mysteries, or romance novel, and whether we believe that Harry and Hermione are bound by fate to marry one day, describes, ultimately, our personal desires and hopes.</p><p>Science is supposed to be immune to the emotional stress created by our search for meaning. Opinion, personality, and ego are meant to be left out of the scientific process. Instead, we create objective, testable hypotheses to explore what we’re studying, and then perform an experiment so see if the hypothesis is correct. Narrative is not a part of the process. This doesn’t mean that we’ve taken personality out of our discipline, but at least we’ve put some shackles on how much importance it is supposed to have. ‘Supposed’ is the operative word in that last sentence, as science can often have melodrama at Brontë sisters/reality TV levels. When Jim Watson, one of the leaders of the projects to sequence the human genome, has to release a statement that he hadn’t been trying to call another scientist a monkey, <em>per se</em>, it’s clear that some emotion still creeps into our discipline.</p><blockquote><strong><em>Science has sometimes faltered when we couldn’t easily frame a testable hypothesis; the origin of the universe and the origin of species are two examples.</em></strong></blockquote><p>This banishment of narrative from science falls apart when we don’t know how to frame a testable hypothesis, especially when it looks like there <em>should</em> be a scientific approach to the problem. One example: the origin of the universe. This is a subject that physics gets us frustratingly very close to addressing, but ultimately fall short. The physical forces we can measure are understood to have emerged around 10−12 seconds after creation. That’s one tenth of one tenth of one tenth…(repeat eight more times)… of one tenth of a second. In that amount of time light can travel only about one third the thickness of a dime, so you might think that not much could have happened during that 10−12 seconds. However the early universe was a busy time, and during that fraction of a second the basic physical forces that govern everything since then were getting resolved. This means that we can’t know much about what happened before 10−12 seconds has passed as we can’t test how things worked at that time. We have a variety of conjectures for what happened in that fraction of a second, but not much in the ways to address these theories experimentally.</p><p>This doesn’t mean that we should compare theories that scientists use to describe what may have happened during that 10−12 seconds to the realm of fiction. Kipling’s ‘Just So’ stories, like the one about how the camel got its hump, or the leopard its spots, are different, fundamentally, than string theories or the idea of the multiverse. Nonetheless, their shared reliance on a reasonable sounding narrative is possibly more important than many physicists may want to acknowledge. As for what happened before <em>T</em>=0…, science fiction is as good of a tool as science. And religion too, of course, has several strong opinions about this period as well. However new ideas and new technologies have let us push back on this barrier to understanding the early universe, and it’s not unreasonable to suppose that we may soon have testable ideas that bring us all the way to <em>T</em>=0.</p><p>The origin of species is another topic that looks scientific, but for a long time we couldn’t frame an explanation in a testable manner. In the West, ideas on the origin of species were largely based on the book of Genesis in the bible, and on Aristotle’s metaphysics. Genesis contains two different but complimentary origin stories that describe the beginning of life largely in allegorical terms. Aristotle thought that life on Earth existed for the sake of realizing its potential. This was an idea that the early Church scholars, such as Thomas Aquinas, embraced in the Middle Ages. Like the stories of Genesis, Aristotle’s metaphysics attributes purpose and meaning to the differences we find in life forms. Animals swim or fly or crawl, or are edible or inedible, because they are <em>meant</em> to swim or fly or crawl or be eaten. That is their purpose.</p><blockquote><strong><em>The camel’s hump may not exist because it said “humph”, but it surely has a purpose, right?</em></strong></blockquote><p>This is an attractive explanation. With this philosophy, meaning is attributed to all life, and to all aspects of living things. The camel may not have a hump because, as Kipling claimed, it said, “humph” too frequently, but it surely has some purpose. The spots on a leopard likely exist for the purpose of allowing the leopard to hide from its prey. Similarly, the large portions of my brain devoted to Star Trek trivia, as opposed to knowledge that would actually help me in most facets of my life, is not because I lack direction and ambition, but because my purpose in life is to be able to correct people when they confuse the Cardassian/Klingon alliance from the mirror universe with the Klingon/Federation alliance against Cardassia (a common source of confusion). OK, maybe that last is a bit of wishful thinking, but the ability to attribute purpose to life is definitely alluring.</p><p>Georges Cuvier was an influential scientist of the early 19th century who helped define methods for classifying species based on their anatomy. His encyclopedic knowledge of anatomy often allowed him to identify a specimen from a single bone. The pelvis of a predator is different than the pelvis of a plant eater because all parts of our body are intricately fit together, and differences in one part of the body, such as having powerful jaws and legs, will have consistent effects on all other parts of the body. Like Aristotle, he espoused a view of the origin of species that focused on purpose. It’s told that one of his students, dressed as the devil, surprised him in his sleep, yelling, “I am the Devil. I have come to devour you!” Cuvier studied the apparition and replied, “I doubt whether you can. You have horns and hooves, and thus you eat only plants.” Cuvier believed that the perfect fit, as he saw it, of anatomical form to function meant that species could not change, as any alteration of a species’ anatomy would move that aspect of their body away from its ability to perform its function.</p><p>Charles Darwin began work on an explanation for the origin of species about the time of Cuvier’s death. His theory, evolution through natural selection of existing variation within species, did away with the need to attribute purpose to species, or even to our anatomy. Darwin, in brief, supposed that variation in a species is heritable, and that animals with variations that give them a survival edge over their compatriots will have more offspring. Their children will carry those traits that gave they parents an edge, and if the selection pressure stays the same, their offspring are also more likely, in turn, to have more offspring than other members of their species.</p><p>We now know that the heritable variation on which his theory depends is described by genetics, which was a missing piece at the time that Darwin described his theory. Variation in the sequence of a gene from one organism to another can result in changes to the structure of the protein it produces, or changes in when or how much a protein is produced. Most of the genome projects currently underway now focus on describing this genetic variation between people, and trying to discern what effects these gene variants have on our bodies.</p><blockquote><strong><em>Contrary to Kipling’s “Just So” stories, Darwin’s vision of evolution says that we can describe a benefit of the leopard’s spots, but we can’t talk about their purpose.</em></strong></blockquote><p>And thus, with the addition of genetics, a complete theory of evolution is now available. Genetic variation exists in great abundance in all species, which results in the differences we can see between and within species. Natural selection for animals exhibiting favorable variation will thus allow the selected genetic variants to accumulate over time in a species. The perfect fit of form to function that Cuvier found isn’t, therefore, because the purpose of a wolf’s tooth is to kill, but because wolves with gene variants that allowed for sharper and stronger teeth were better able to have more little wolves, and thus pass on their traits.</p><p>It was this divorce of meaning and purpose from biology that has caused many to so stridently reject Darwin’s idea. Evolution through natural selection removes any sense that there is a prescriptive ‘ought’ to our life, only a descriptive ‘is’. Before Darwin, all aspects of life seemed easily fit into narratives about design, meaning and purpose. For many, this seems to do away with a role for God in the design of life. Even setting aside the religious implications, the implications of Darwin’s theory are still unsettling. With his theory in hand, it appears that the meaning we attribute to life are simply stories that we have made, but that don’t truly explain life. Not, at least, from a scientific perspective. Like having our plans for Harry Potter denied in the epilogue, Darwin through out all the stories we had made explaining life on Earth. This isn’t easy to accept. It seems too random, directionless. Not only are our stories denied, but nobody is writing the story at all.</p><p>Furthermore, in Darwin’s explanation of evolution we can’t evolve towards a function. Instead, genetic variants that give a species a slight edge are selected for, but where this will lead to over time is anybody’s guess. The leopard did not develop spots in order to be able to hide. Instead, we would say that the leopard’s ancestors who had some spots were able to hide better than their compatriots without spots, and thus had more offspring (with spots). So not only does Darwin’s theory mean that we can’t say that the wolf evolved sharp teeth in order to eat sheep, but we can’t say that there is any direction to the tree of life. Wolves, just because they eat sheep, are not more advanced than sheep. Similarly, and more difficult for some to accept, we also can’t say that humans are ‘more evolved’ or more advanced than apes, or any other species for that matter. Not even Trump supporters. All we can say is that our species has differences from our ape-like forbearers that allowed our ancestors a breeding advantage.</p><p>Modern biology has not completely detached itself from a belief in purpose. As discussed <a href="http://charter-of-the-genome.org/2016/03/17/how-many-genes-in-our-genome-or-the-metaphysics-of-genomics">previously</a>, we often name genes as if we can discern their purpose, despite most proteins having multiple possible functions. For example, the enzyme ‘cyclin-dependent kinase 1’ is also known as ‘cell division control 2’. The first name describes a function, while the second name implies a purpose. ‘Cyclin-dependent kinase 1’ is now the official name, but many genes still have names that suggest a clear role or purpose for them in our cells.</p><blockquote><strong><em>This isn’t to say that there is not a meaning to life. Just don’t ask a geneticist to tell you what it is. Fortunately, we’re rarely asked.</em></strong></blockquote><p>Is there an underlying structure to our universe that provides meaning to life? Darwin’s theory doesn’t really address that, it just means that we can’t look at how fit things seem to be, like eagles to flying, dolphin’s to swimming, or Harry to Hermione, and the declare that this then shows that there is purpose to these difference. Darwin’s theory doesn’t say there isn’t a clear meaning of life, just that the matching of form to function doesn’t show evidence of meaning. It just <em>is</em>.</p><p>And of course, even if biology has been able to mostly shed itself of a belief in purpose, this doesn’t spell the end of meaning from all walks of our life. We are free to create our own purpose, of course. As Sartre said, we are condemned to be free. Politics is still the art of getting everyone to agree on a purpose, and then, often much more difficult, plan how to get us to that goal without killing each other (that last clause is frequently not seen as necessary). Religion is body of practices and philosophies that also help us use the notion of purpose to direct our lives. However if we’re confining ourselves to just the realm where biology and genetics can have a say, then we are left with a world without a given purpose or meaning.</p><p>Of course, we always have our fan fiction too allows us to explore meaning. Just leave the Hagrid and Hermione, Luke and Leia, and Mulder and Scully pairings aside, please.</p><p>[First published at <a href="http://charter-of-the-genome.org/2016/06/22/the-intersect-of-harry-potter-and-charles-darwin/">The Charter of The Genome</a>]</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=12a4fc3c504f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Three R’s of Genetics]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@bzring/the-three-rs-of-genetics-e5ddaaf4fd7f?source=rss-56ce01f25b02------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e5ddaaf4fd7f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[genetics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[health]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[The Charter of the Genome]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 30 May 2016 17:34:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-06-02T10:41:23.400Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*fbYEYhgo_WiDh6Y_wvACUQ.jpeg" /></figure><h4>Walk before you can run, read before you can write.</h4><p>The three ‘R’s of genetics are reading, writing, and arithmetic. Of course, only one of those skills starts with an actual letter ‘R’, but as the arithmetic portion of genetics is often met using a statistical program known as ‘R’, it’s only ‘writing’ that is the real outlier. Writing stands out in another way, besides being spelled ‘rong. We read a lot of genetic sequence (almost 1.5 trillion bases of whole genome sequence has been read, to date). We use a lot of arithmetic in figuring out what those 1.5 trillion bases are doing. However we have yet to <em>write </em>out a whole animal genome. We change a word here and there in the genetic code, but writing isn’t a skill we’ve mastered in genetics. That could soon change.</p><blockquote><strong><em>Though reading usually follows writing, in genetics it’s the opposite. We can read well, but writing is hard.</em></strong></blockquote><p>In general, things are written before they are read. Even the world’s sacred texts, which you could imagine might arise via supernatural fiat and spontaneously burst into being, didn’t. They were written. God wrote the ten commandments on stone tablets with his finger (pen doesn’t write well on stone, and crayons just melts in his hands). Moses wrote down the first five books (except probably the last bit, where he dies). The Vedas began as an oral tradition, the Koran was transcribed by Muhammad’s disciples, and the entire Star Wars prequel series was simply adlibbed throughout. The closest inversion of the normal order of write-&gt; read is in the book of John, where he says that, “In the beginning was the Word”. But this doesn’t seem to be a word that is actually available to be read, somewhere. It just <em>Is</em>. Which certainly saves on paper.</p><p>The human genome is an exception, we first read it (that was the Human Genome Project, completed in April of 2003), and we’re now just beginning to talk about writing it.</p><p>To be precise, the human genome has been <em>transcribed</em> many times already. Given that each cell in our body has a copy of our genome (except for the red blood cells), and that we each have about 10 trillion cells (not counting those blood cells), and that it’s estimated that about 100 billion people have ever lived on Earth, altogether we can estimate that the human genome has been copied about a trillion trillion times. But no one has ever written it <em>de novo</em>. No one ever sat down and just wrote out the whole thing, with whatever genes, edits or genetic flights of fancy they imagined. From a genetics perspective, writing isn’t really our strong suite.</p><blockquote><strong><em>The story of the writing of our genome involves a lot of time, a lot of duplications, and a lot of mistakes</em></strong></blockquote><p>Our genome had a beginning, of course, but it wasn’t written by us. If we leave to the side the “God wrote Adam’s genome” hypothesis, as our available biblical texts are unclear on the genomic aspects of the creation story, we’re a little hazy on how it all started. The first life on earth began about 4 billion years ago, so it’s not surprising that our understanding of its first steps are still incomplete. We’re very lucky when we find a complete dinosaur fossil, let alone preserved chemical evidence of what life might have been like three billion years earlier than the Brontosaurus. What is known is that your genome came from a mixing of your parents’ genomes, and their genomes came from their parents, and so on and so on. There is an unbroken path of your genome’s journey which traces back to the beginnings of life. This makes placing the blame for any faults or deficiencies in your genetics difficult to pin down on any one person (or ancestral animal).</p><p>One idea about the origins of genetics (and life) is that a short RNA polymer was created in the early Earth that could copy itself. RNA, which is chemically very similar to the DNA that comprises our genome, has the additional feature that it can fold into complicated forms, some of which have been found to be able to function like enzymes. Some of these catalytic RNA’s can even copy other RNA’s. It’s possible the first life, and the first genome, were one and the same, a relatively short stretch of RNA that could copy itself.</p><p>Admittedly, a short snippet of RNA that happens to be able to copy itself is a long ways from the complexity of us, though it’s a crucial start. But how to get from this ancestral RNA chain, which can’t do anything beyond make copies of itself, to ourselves, all via an unbroken chain of increasingly complex organisms? Through transcription errors, duplications, natural selection, and an intervening several billion years, and we believe you might get us. And every other living thing on Earth, for that matter.</p><p>That’s a lot of power to attribute to some copy errors, but four billion years is a long time to accumulate a lot of changes, and mistakes are hard to avoid when writing. Take the bible again, for example. It is supposed, by many, to be inerrant. It is divinely inspired and every aspect of it is true, it is claimed. In other words, no mistakes. Many religionists will concede that this inerrancy likely just applies to the original inspired texts, and that human error could have crept into our current biblical texts. Obviously, however, copy mistakes should be avoided, as introducing error into copies of the bible is probably a special class of blasphemy, and lord knows what the punishment for that would be. Being forced to transcribe the screams of the damned, in longhand, perhaps. Especially wicked people will find the ‘A’ key of their hell-issued typewriter frequently jams, as well.</p><p>In fact modern Hebrew owes its vowels and a standardization of pronunciation to efforts to reduce biblical copyist errors. A group of Hebrew scholars in the 6–10th centuries known as the Masoretes created an authoritative text of the Hebrew bible that was later used as the source for many of the Christian translations of the Old Testament. Written Hebrew existed for a over a thousand years without vowels, as they can be inferred from the surrounding consonants in a word. However their lack can make some words ambiguous, especially if any of the consonants are smudged. Adding vowels reduces copy error, and so the scribes invention of vowels, as well as other transcription and editing aids, all helped ensure their copies contained as few errors as possible. Despite these precautions, however, the Masoretes still made mistakes.</p><p>An excellent example is a very brief note on a king of Judah, Jehoiachin. In 2 Chronicles 36:9 we read:</p><blockquote>Jehoiachin was eight years old when he began to reign, and he reigned three months and ten days in Jerusalem: and he did that which was evil in the sight of the Lord.</blockquote><p>But 2 Kings 24:8 says:</p><blockquote>Jehoiachin was <em>eighteen</em> years old when he began to reign, and he reigned in Jerusalem three months. And his mother’s name was Nehushta, the daughter of Elnathan of Jerusalem</blockquote><p>In 2 Kings, he’s eighteen:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/463/1*2w3ZvKTOfAer0MfO5n6SBA.jpeg" /></figure><p>While in 2 Chronicles, he’s eight:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/267/1*04EpivDldrdYnRHG6091kA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Either there was a copy mistake, and the “ten” got left out of one version, or Jehoiachin was eight <em>and</em> eighteen when we began his reign, each time he reigned for three months. Also, according to the account in 2 Chronicles, he becomes king when he was eight, and furthermore, he “did that which was evil in the sight of the Lord.” As a father of a male child I can attest that it’s <em>definitely</em> possible for an eight year old to do evil in the sight of the lord (though clever eight year olds will endeavor to not do so in the sight of their mother). However it’s probably more in the realm of an eighteen year old to do the kind of acts that would catch the attention of the God of the Old Testament. Those were extreme times, with extra smiting, so you had to have your game on to rise above the basal level of debauchery and corruption. The most likely explanation is a simple copy error. Several more probable errors are known, where, like here, identical information is given in two verses. In other cases, distances or other accounts don’t match what we know of the actual circumstances, and a simple transcription error seems to explain the discrepancy.</p><p>Similar mistakes happen to DNA. Sunlight is a big culprit, as UV radiation can cause chemical changes to the DNA bases that makes them impossible to copy. These damaged bases get snipped out by cellular machinery, and are usually repaired correctly, but mistakes happen. Other mechanisms can also cause minor substitutions and deletions to the DNA as well. Over billions of years, these rare changes can add up.</p><p>Of course more than just simple substitutions and deletions are needed to add complexity, as these just change the information, but don’t increase it. What’s important, in that regard, are <em>additions </em>to the genome. With our genome’s evolution this probably mostly came about via duplications of stretches of DNA, which can happen relatively easily. Going back to the bible as an analogy, we can see it happened there as well. The first book of Genesis contains two accounts of the creation of man, one in the first chapter, the second in the next chapter. Though thematically similar, they differ in some key details, which causes some trouble for those that insist on a strict grammatical interpretation of the events of the bible. Unlike the multiple ages of wayward Jehoiachin, it’s certain that these two differing accounts of creation weren’t a transcription error. Instead, each story has a different emphasis, the first rendition of the creation story is an account of how the world arose, while the second focuses more on our relation to our world, and to god. The two similar creation stories likely have a shared root in a Mesopotamian story about the creation of the world. However the early priests modified each account to fit the narrative need of the first books of the bible. In other words, a story was duplicated, and then changes to each copy of the story were used to allow the book of Genesis to give a more complex narrative than one copy of the creation story would allow. This method doesn’t just apply to the bible, of course. About half the works of Shakespeare are just variations on the single story-line, ‘Someone’s identity is mistaken, and hilarity ensues’. He just changes the hats around.</p><p>It’s worked in a similar manner in our genome. A single gene can have only so many functions. However if a gene happens to be duplicated, each copy can develop in different manners, with different functions. This creates what are known as gene families, sets of very similar genes with similar but distinct roles. For example, an important gene family in humans (and all animals) are the Hox genes, which control some of the first steps in early development of the embryo. We have about 40 different Hox genes, all with different roles in our development, but all probably arose early in the evolutionary history of animals from a single Hox gene.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Mqzbi2zfYDWST4NCPkkJpg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Evolution is powerful, obviously, but also slow. Most investors in a biotech firm hope for returns within a few years, and telling them to wait for a million years, give or take, would be a tough sell (though possibly a refreshing break from the standard slides of projected revenue growth, which invariably shows profits growing exponentially after three years). Hence there is now an effort to create a phase 2 of the genome project, moving from reading to writing. Instead of relying on mutation and selection, we will simple write the genome we want.</p><blockquote><strong><em>The original Human Genome Project was, in retrospect, “HGP:Read”. Phase II could be “HGP:Write”</em></strong></blockquote><p>That was the basis of discussion at a recent <a href="http://www.nytimes.com/2016/05/14/science/synthetic-human-genome.html?_r=0">meeting</a>, early this month at Harvard Medical School. The original Human Genome Project was about reading the genome. The discussion at this meeting was about a logical extension of this project. Entitled, “HGP-Write: Testing Large Synthetic Genomes in Cells”, the meeting’s goals were to discuss the concept and technology behind rewriting large sections of the genome, or even crafting entire genomes from scratch. The technology to do so doesn’t yet exist. However, our ability to synthesize long stretches of DNA with a specific sequence is rapidly developing, while the cost of doing so decreases. It’s reasonable to speculate that writing a genome will soon be a capability of ours.</p><p>The potential applications of the ability to write genomes are several fold. New genetic tools allow us, with relative ease, to make small changes to our genome, as discussed <a href="http://charter-of-the-genome.org/2016/02/03/a-right-to-stay-human/">previously</a>. What is being discussed now is the ability to write with complete freedom whatever part of the genome one wishes. The likely starting points would include basic science, rewriting whole sections of the genome would be a quicker route to exploration than piecemeal picking apart at the genes. Industrial applications are easy to imagine as well, as entire metabolic pathways could be reengineered to allow production of a slew of different compounds.</p><p>There are, of course, a few ethical considerations involved. For one, this technology would expand our abilities to clone people. Currently cloning a person, which hasn’t yet been done, involves extracting cells from the person to be cloned. With the ability to write a genome, we just need to know the person genetic code, which can be contained in a text file about 1 GB in size (less than DVD), and we can then reconstitute them. If you’re interested in an army of thousands of Jim Watsons, former head of the Human Genome Project, you could do it. Having met Jim I’m confident this is low on the intended uses of HGP:Write, but it’s a formal capability (and if you want to do it, you can find his genome <a href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/Traces/trace.cgi?&amp;cmd=retrieve&amp;val=CENTER_PROJECT%20%3D%20%22Project%20JIM%22&amp;size=0&amp;retrieve=Submit">here</a>). For science fiction fans, it solves a problem of long distance colonization of other stars. There is no need for faster than light travel or “generational” ships. Just pack your colonists into a hard drive and reconstitute them on arrival.</p><blockquote><strong><em>Is rewriting our genome similar to rewriting part of the bible, or is it more akin to adding another Harry Potter fan-fiction to the internets?</em></strong></blockquote><p>Furthermore, we’re still grappling with the ethics in making small changes to our genome, and here we are facing the possibility of being able to rewrite entire chromosomes. Our understanding of cellular metabolism and its regulation means that we don’t know enough to really utilize this level of genetic control, but that will likely come soon. What will it mean if we have the ability to add completely novel biochemical pathways to our children? Is our genome akin to an inerrant sacred text, where no changes are allowed? Is it more like a country’s constitution, and changes need to be agreed upon before being written? Or will we approach HGP:write like human genome fan fiction, and every scientist or parent gets to write whatever they see fit? For example, adding chloroplasts to our skin could save on the grocery bill as well as giving us a healthy green complexion. However, it might also lower property values in cloudy cities. Who decides if this is an acceptable addition to human diversity?</p><p>Hence there were concerns that this meeting was open to only a hundred attendees, and no reporting to the media of the meeting’s discussion was permitted. This is likely not due to great secrecy about the technology under discussion, an army of clone soldiers to be put under UN auspices was not the agenda of this meeting. Instead it appears that the gag order was due to a scientific journal being given the rights to publish about the meeting, and the attendees acquiescing to their demands for exclusivity. This may show a problem in the way that scientific results, which are often generated with public money, can become in effect the property of the scientific publishers, but that’s an issue for a separate discussion. Nonetheless, it’s probably bad form to keep a meeting on this topic private.</p><p>Whether this technology to write our own genomes moves quickly or slowly, it’s clear that we’re quickly learning the basic skills we need to grapple with our genomes. Reading and ‘rithmetic are already well in hand in the field of genetics, and writing will soon be added as well. The only clear fact is that at least we don’t have to worry about arguments over the appropriate fonts to use. In genetics there is no sans-serif or Time New Roman (or Comic Sans). We don’t even have italics or bold. For the conceivable future, at least, we’ll be stuck with just A, C, G, T as we write our genomes.</p><p>[Originally published at <a href="http://charter-of-the-genome.org/2016/05/30/the-three-rs-of-genetics/">Charter of the Genome</a>]</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e5ddaaf4fd7f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[In Defense Of Irreproducible Results]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@bzring/in-defense-of-irreproducible-results-1b002ed634cd?source=rss-56ce01f25b02------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1b002ed634cd</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[health]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[The Charter of the Genome]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 14 May 2016 08:45:09 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-04-10T07:10:33.324Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*P3TujUFIuBMbzd6GBstyTA.jpeg" /></figure><h4>The dangers of p-values and Klingons</h4><p>Science is hard. Well, lots of things are hard. Baking a good baguette is hard. Remembering everyone’s birthday (before their birthday) is hard too, as are granite boulders. But science has a special trick up its sleeve that makes it <em>quantifiably</em> hard: the p-value. P-values are supposed to help us identify results that are statistically significant, but getting a low p-value is difficult. In the medical sciences, achieving statistical significance usually means having a good question, a lot of patient samples, and doing your assays and calculations well. The former requires cleverness, the middle requires resources, and the final entails diligence. Combining all these traits in one researcher, or even one research team, is hard. I, for one, still haven’t figured out what all the bins in my refrigerator are for, let alone be able to manage an entire clinical study workflow.</p><p>And to make it worse, the scientific community is now taking very close looks at everyone’s p-values to make sure that these low p-values mean what they’re supposed to mean. Not only should data be significant, but it should be reproducible. Unfortunately it seems that research results frequently are not reproducible. In fact, we are in the midst of a “reproducibility crisis”, according to some. Various studies have suggested that most published results, in <a href="http://journals.plos.org/plosmedicine/article?id=10.1371/journal.pmed.0020124">medicine</a> and the <a href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/26315443">social sciences</a>, are not repeatable, despite having nice p-values in the original study.</p><blockquote><strong>Does this reproducibility crisis merit pitchforks and torches, or better study design and a philosophical debate? Why not both?!</strong></blockquote><p>Why is this? Is the reproducibility crisis due to a mixture of fraud and lazy science, for which pitchforks, lighted torches, and storming the gates are the best response? Or is it more complicated, requiring more agreement on good study design and an understanding of just how reproducible scientific results really should be? Probably mostly the latter, but we can add in a little of the former too, just to keep in interesting.</p><p>The use of p-values was standardized by Ronald Fisher in the 1920’s to help identify studies whose results that are statistically significant. A p-value of less than 0.05 is often used as a threshold, and sometimes one will see it interpreted as, “the chance that our hypothesis was wrong was less than 5%.” That’s incorrect. What it actually means is, “the chance of getting these results (or even more extreme results) if our hypothesis was completely wrong was less than5%” (there are more exact ways of defining a p-value, but that will suffice). The difference between these interpretations is important.</p><p>As an example, let’s take an everyday situation. Say you’re a science officer on the starship Enterprise, and your ship has a cargo hold of the wheat hybrid quadrotriticale, destined for the planet Sherman’s World, whose colonization is under dispute between the Federation and the Klingon Empire. You find that the grain hold has been infested by tribbles, which are eating the grain, and that half the tribbles are dead. You hypothesize that, given the known life-cycle of tribbles, many more tribbles are dead than one would expect- the grain was likely poisoned by the Klingons. A statistical test is in order! You count 1000 tribbles, and find 454 dead, and 546 are alive. Given their known life span, and that the entire population descended from two tribbles introduced by a crew member just last week (tribbles breed really fast), you expect no more than 10% to be dead (100 tribbles) if they were living normal, happy tribble lives. A standard statistical test would give us a p-value of less than 0.0001 with these numbers, meaning that if our expected death rate of tribbles were correct, the probability of observing such a large number of dead tribbles is very low.</p><blockquote><strong>A low p-value just rules out that tribbles are dying at the expected rate, but not the possibility that it’s all due to not reversing the polarity of the neutron flow*</strong></blockquote><p>Does this mean that the Klingon’s poisoned our grain? Well, it doesn’t look good for them, the p-value is very low. However it doesn’t necessarily follow that the Klingons are at fault. As described above, the p-value tests not that our hypothesis (a lot more tribbles are dead than should occur naturally, probably due to those nefarious Klingons) is correct. Instead, the study just shows that it’s very unlikely that we’d see half of the tribbles are dead if they had an expected life cycle. It could be that we have a special breed of short-lived tribbles, or that tribble’s hate wheat, or that someone reversed the polarity of the neutron plasma flow that runs right past the grain hold and resulted in a temporal fold such that time moved differently in there (this latter hypothesis has a good chance of being correct, as any Star Trek fan will attest). In other words, a low p-value doesn’t mean our hypothesis is correct, just that we don’t have a good reason to discount it (yet).</p><p>Another way our p-value could lead us astray is if we had only a few tribbles to count. Possibly the grain hold had been opened to space to clean it out, and we only had a few tribbles to measure, or the Chief Engineer had transported the whole lot to the Klingon ship. We only found six remaining living tribbles and four dead ones. Given that we expected to find no more than one dead tribble, we still get a significant p-value (p=0.0018). However we can also ask that, given that we only tested a few tribbles, how confident are we that we’re testing the true proportions in all the tribbles (before they were blown into space)? Another test shows us that we can say we have a 95% confidence that the real number of dead tribbles lay between 10% to 70%. That’s a pretty big range, given that we expected to see 10% dead from natural causes. In contrast, when we had 1000 tribbles to measure, our 95% confidence range was between 42% to 48% dead tribbles in the cargo hold.</p><blockquote><strong>“P-hacking” your way towards an implication that Klingons are responsible?</strong></blockquote><p>We have some evidence consistent with the Klingon’s being involved with sabotaging colonization efforts on Sherman’s World (though no definitive proof has been shown yet), but what has this to do with the current reproducibility crisis in science?</p><p>One, reproducibility relies on a large population to study. We have seen that sample size can affect the quality of our results, even if p-values remain small. It’s now becoming a standard demand for publication of a scientific study that more than p-values be given. In our two scenarios, showing the confidence ranges helps us gauge the reliability of the study:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/408/1*iqG0EvspaZMU0jSK9pCZUQ.png" /></figure><p>Presented this way, the results with only ten tribbles doesn’t look very impressive. Before risking war with the Klingon empire, another test with more tribbles is probably in order. This holds for clinical studies too, of course. A good looking result with a phenomenal p-value may simply be due to a small sample size. Though it’s still unlikely that the tribbles are dying at a rate predicted by what we know of their lifecycle, it wouldn’t be at all surprising to find from a larger sampling that only 20% of the tribbles were dead. That’s more than we thought there would be, but not a very exciting number. It’s probably not worth a war with Klingons simply because they made tribbles sickly.</p><p>Secondly, reproducibility relies on a good hypothesis. Our low p-value in our tribble measurement study doesn’t mean our hypothesis was correct. Setting aside the plasma flow induced temporal fold theory, all we’re really confident in is that the grain is <em>probably</em> related to tribbles dying. Tribbles eating the grain died faster than expected, those that didn’t were fine. Given the circumstances, Klingon sabotage is a good guess, but it could be other aspects of the grain were involved. This is a new space-hybrid, just right for the colonization efforts on this new planet, after all. Therefore it’s possible that an effort to show that Klingons are poisoning grain would not be replicated in another study (on another ship colonizing another world, presumably). However we know now to be looking at the grain for problems. It may not be Klingon poison, but quadrotriticale may still be not all that it’s supposed to be.</p><p>These two factors, which may affect our ability to replicate our tribble study, are why we can say that pitchforks may have <em>some</em> utility in confronting the “reproducibility crisis”. Poor study design and analysis can contribute to a study, even one with really low p-values, having a low chance of reproducibility. The scientific community therefore has an obligation to find better ways of encouraging proper techniques in analysis and reporting to ensure that studies with a better chance of reproducibility are published. There have been many recent <a href="http://www.nature.com/news/statisticians-issue-warning-over-misuse-of-p-values-1.19503">recommendations</a> on better reporting practices and study design to help improve the matter. This is a good thing, wasting money (often public money) on studies that don’t mean anything is inefficient and slows the discovery of ‘real’ results. So to those who resort to “p hacking”, using just the right statistical test or study subset to hit that magical “p-value &lt;0.05” number, mind our wrath!</p><blockquote><strong>An inability to reproduce a study can have many meanings. Not all suggest incompetence.</strong></blockquote><p>However, a lack of reproducibility can have a great number of causes, and an equally great number of interpretations. For example, following up our space wheat/tribble study may not result in showing that Klingons are nefarious grain poisoners. It may be that more studies will show that quadrotriticale is unstable in space, and breaks down into lethal tribble poison (which has also been shown to cause an unsightly space rash** in people). Furthermore, tribbles may be more diverse than expected, and some populations get space sick easily, making them more susceptible to space wheat poison. Therefore our study wasn’t reproducible, but it was <em>useful</em>. Initially we had no idea that quadrotricale may have problems. Following a lead based on the dead tribbles, and an idea it may be due to poisoned grain, we eventually were able to create a complicated, but reproducible explanation about how quadrotricale, space travel, and tribbles interact. The initial study was necessary to guide further studies that eventually rooted out just what’s wrong with space wheat.</p><p>A more down-to-earth example, we once did a <a href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24901479">study</a> looking at reproducibility of genetic variants that predict risk of cancer. We weren’t looking at the reproducibility crisis <em>per se</em>, but whether genetic cancer risk studies performed in one country are applicable to another. We found that, by one standard, they often weren’t; most genetic cancer risk studies did <em>not</em> replicate when performed in a different ethnic group. However, we also found that the basic effect of a genetic variant was consistent between ethnic groups; you might not get a p-value &lt;0.05 in another study, but a marker associated with high risk in one group is more likely to predict high risk rather than low risk in another group. Therefore, it seems that these “irreproducible” studies were still useful: the genetic markers they were testing were not ready for clinical use, but they were pointing at consistent biological effects that, if studied more closely, possibly will be useful in the clinic. In particular, it appeared that the genetic variants that had been tested were probably markers for the real risk alleles, which were close but not exactly at the location of the studied alleles.</p><blockquote><strong>Basically we need to ask, “How much reproducibility is correct?” This isn’t just a scientific question, but an ethical one as well.</strong></blockquote><p>This leads us to an interesting, though often unasked, question underlying the supposed reproducibility crisis: how much reproducibility should be expected from our research? Accepting low reproducibility allows difficult studies to be performed, at the cost of generating a lot of studies with unclear results. Aiming for high reproducibility saves money and time, but means many scientific questions may lay unanswered.</p><p>As we have shown, poor sample size is probably key contributing factor towards a lack of reproducibility. Studies done in small groups can give an apparent effect size larger than is likely to be found in the real world, and thus are less likely to replicate. Therefore it has been proposed that only studies with a very good prior likelihood of being shown to be true should be performed. Under these criteria, a study that is measuring only a tiny effect, say for a drug that extends the life span of cancer patients by a few months, or that affects only a small percentage of people, should not be tested. This is an issue that is becoming more and more relevant, especially in cancer, as we are finding many diseases are actually a constellation of related disorders, each which may only affect a small number of people.</p><p>Or consider our difficulty in framing a good hypothesis when confronted with the dead tribbles (or the cancer risk gene variants). An initial study may not be able to offer much to base an expected result upon. We can see a clear benefit, a planet is waiting for our space wheat, but frankly, the chance that our first hypothesis is going to be correct and reproducible is small. Our best hope is that it will guide a better study the next time. If reproducibility is the main criteria, however, this study may not be performed.</p><p>It’s important to recognize that these criteria for deciding whether to perform a study are not primarily scientific, but philosophical. Is the goal of science to efficiently increase the greater good? Or can there be a moral cause to follow a scientific lead, even if it benefits only a small number of people and may be hard to replicate? The former could be defined as a version of pragmatic utilitarianism, the belief that the most moral act is the one that benefits the most people, with “benefit” being something that can be empirically defined. This methodology has the advantage of being quantifiable, almost anything pragmatic (using a philosophical definition of pragmatism) can get numbers wrapped around it. Numbers are easy to communicate, at least, easier than more squishy value statements. However utilitarianism has, it its root, a belief that “useful” and “morally right” are essentially the same. There is not much room for ideas like justice in this mode of thought. It states that any acts of apparent self-sacrifice, altruism, or love, if morally correct, must be oriented towards the good of all. Any acts that benefit only a few are morally wrong, or at least, misdirected. Inefficient research is a form of self-sacrifice. This may seem like a fairly bland form of sacrifice, but given the tightness of research budgets, it’s not the smallest sacrifice one might face.</p><p>Science is hard. Not only do we need to get a good p-value at the end of all our work, which requires first formulating a good hypothesis and getting a large enough population to study it in, but we have to be able to defend our study on philosophical grounds. Are we limiting ourselves to only studies with large effect sizes and for which we can assemble large patient populations, ensuring a high likelihood that a replication of the study would be successful, and thus maximizing the efficiency of research dollars? Or can we justify experiments solely on the basis that we have a promising lead may benefit people, even when the odds of a replication of the study is low? Or when a hypothesis is just at the beginning stages of being formulated (like our space wheat/Klingon poison theory), and we really don’t have enough studies yet to know what, precisely, we need to be testing, can we justify performing the experiment on the basis on laying new ground in an uncharted territory?</p><p>Improving our research efficiency will help reduce the reproducibility problem. It would also mean setting aside notions like equality and justice when deciding what we should study. Obviously this isn’t an “either/or” decision. Efforts to improve reproducibility, or at least highlight problems in achieving it, are for the good. However setting the bar for reproducibility too high is likely not the type of science we want. Most of us probably have notions of of just practice and courageous exploration of new scientific territory as part of our vision of science. It’s likely that some irreproducibility in our research is an unfortunate necessity.</p><p>* In Star Trek, all problems are solved by reversing the polarity of the neutron flow.</p><p>** Putting the word “space” in front of anything occurring in space is, unfortunately, a narrative law in science fiction.</p><p>[Originally published at <a href="http://charter-of-the-genome.org/2016/05/14/in-defense-of-irreproducible-results/">The Charter of the Genome.org</a>]</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1b002ed634cd" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Genomic Theory of Self: The Rise of the Microbiome]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@bzring/the-genomic-theory-of-self-the-rise-of-the-microbiome-10b7f8eb0501?source=rss-56ce01f25b02------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/10b7f8eb0501</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[health]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[The Charter of the Genome]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 29 Apr 2016 09:42:05 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-04-29T09:42:42.093Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*P7k9ZxDKXEvk7Bkg_aezSA.jpeg" /></figure><h4>Who am I? Ask your bacteria.</h4><p>The question “Who am I?” has been a mainstay of philosophy for centuries, at least, if we discount “me” as a complete response. It might even be the mother of philosophy, as “who am I?” was probably asked before the more difficult, “why am I?”. Of course, “what do you want to do now?” was probably asked even earlier, but that only led to the birth of the shopping mall.</p><p>Thomas Aquinas gave us an answer (cribbed from Aristotle, and then filtered through a theological perspective). He said that we are defined by our body plus our intellect, a soul, and together these two describe who each of us is. These two aspects of ourselves are not distinct entities; the soul, he said, was the form, or principal, that allows our bodies to live. Our soul, he further defined, had an intellectual aspect that was unique to humans. It also has a sentient activity, that is, it could sense and perceive our environment. This part of our soul is shared with animals, and arises from the activity of the body and soul acting as one. The intellectual aspect is unique to humans, he thought. Together, all these defined who we were. Separate they have little meaning.</p><blockquote><strong>Attributing our thinking processes to regions of the brain based on a comparison to the brain of more simple animals is in part due to Thomas Aquinas. And the fact that some people really do have a ‘reptile brain’ (they’re called lawyers).</strong></blockquote><p>This description of what a human being is has stayed with us, and is still largely in line with Catholic church doctrine. It is in many ways a largely materialist perspective; the soul is dependent on the body, and if the body goes, so does anything that we would think of as being “ourselves”. Divine intervention, he believe, could preserve our sense of self, but the naturalistic aspects of his description matches our modern notions. Even our description of our brain has been shaped by his depiction of a human being. Certain regions of the brain have, until recently, been described as being largely devoted to sensory management and managing the basic works of keeping a body functioning, while the intellect was largely confined to the neocortex. Part of the brain has even been termed the ‘reptile brain’, which supposedly governs the most basic functions of living. Recent advances in mapping brain function are changing this conceptualization of how the brain works, and we know now that our thinking and other neural functions are distributed in complex manners. However the historical compartmentalizing of brain functions based on how our brain compares to that of more simple animals is in part due to Aquinas’s definition of a human.</p><p>Four hundred years later, Rene Descartes creates his own theory of self. He begins by famously establishing that he existed (“Cogito ergo sum”, I think therefore I am). Aquinas, understandably, took this first step as fairly obvious and had skipped past it. But emboldened by this beginning, Descartes defined himself as a thinking being. He felt, somewhat similar to Aquinas, that we were composed of a body and an intellect. However Descartes saw these as very distinct entities, and as we are defined by our intellect, the aspect of us that can ask the question “Who am I?” (or as Descartes started, simply “Am I?”) consists solely of the intellect. This is now referred to as Cartesian dualism, and though not a strong part of most modern theories of cognition, we’re hearkening back to it if we talk of someone’s mind “wandering”, or posit the possibility of “out of body experiences”.</p><p>Descartes and Aquinas had rationalist approaches to coming up with their theories of self. Basically they found a nice chair and thought rather hard, confident that we are part of universe based on reason and thus we can discover truths through logic. Modern science is empirical, we believe our theories must lie on tested principles. Therefore our modern ideas of self tend to have lots of specifics, but the more grand notions are left out. At least, they’re left out of our published articles. Despite our skepticism, most scientists still have lots of private conceptions of how it all might fit together. Beer is usually needed to draw these out, however.</p><blockquote><strong>We’ve always used genetic language to discuss how our personality arises: your good traits come from your mother, the rest from your father’s side of the family.</strong></blockquote><p>Genomics has much to say about what defines us, especially if you’re satisfied with a lot of details and can handle the big picture aspect on your own. Many gene variants have been implicated in affecting many aspects of our personality, from relatively specific traits like intelligence and risk perception, to very broad ones like a <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22432931">sense of well-being</a>. We’ve been quick to adapt to this new science, as we’re already used to attributing to our hereditary parts of our personality. When Junior jumps off the garage roof holding an umbrella as a parachute we say, “Oh, he gets his wild side from his father.” His good grades, of course, come from his mother’s side of the family.</p><p>However another aspect of genomics is now arising which may be a little harder to incorporate into our traditional notions of self. This is the science and genomics of our <em>microbiome</em>, that is, the study of all the microorganisms that live on our skin and in our gut. There are <em>a lot</em> of these microbes on/in us, both in total cell numbers (we each host trillions of microbes) and in number of different species we harbor (probably in the many hundreds), and all together these microbes weigh a few pounds. These cohabitating bacteria aren’t a sign of poor grooming or not washing the vegetables, they are a vital part of how we live. Microbes on our skin help protect against infection from pathogens, and the microbes in our gut are important for digestion. We can probably live without them, at least, studies on mice have shown it’s possible, but they are nonetheless a very important aspect of keeping us healthy.</p><p>The fact that we have about three pounds of a huge and happy family of microbes living on us may be interesting- or disgusting, depending on one’s view- but why does it mean a rethinking of our notion of self? I could (should) lose three pounds of fat and I wouldn’t even notice it (unfortunately). What does three pounds of microbes mean to us?</p><blockquote><strong>Our microbiome is an ecosystem, actually, several distinct ecosystems, residing on and in us. Whether this is fascinating or appalling is a personal decision.</strong></blockquote><p>The microbiome that resides with us is not passive, like a hat we can take on or off. Instead, it’s an active part of our body; it’s flexible and changes during our lifetime. Come to think of it, hats can do that too, but the microbiome is much more complex than a hat. It’s an ecosystem, actually, several ecosystems, the biomes on different parts of our body are completely distinct from one another. Our body affects our microbiome; our immune system regulates the composition of our microbiome. In turn, our microbiome regulates gene expression in our immune and digestive systems. In short, a complete description of our genomics would not make sense unless it incorporates the genomes of our microbiota as well, and how they all interact. Together we are a complete organism.</p><p>How this interplay of genetic functions actually works is just beginning to be researched. Most of the initial studies have been done on how the microbiome can affect disease, and it’s been implicated in affecting diabetes, obesity, cancer, and inflammatory diseases of the gut. However it seems it may also be a part of how we form our daily emotions as well. This shouldn’t be too surprising, I certainly have learned to not go shopping when I’m hungry as I will invariably come home with bags of very questionable (and fattening) food choices. Our gut is lined with a massive network of neurons that is so extensive that it’s been called our “second brain”. Technically it’s called the enteric nervous system, and it helps control our digestive processes. It takes over some of the work in regulating this important work, but there is a lot of crosstalk between the brain and the enteric nervous system.</p><p>Therefore, that our gut flora can contribute to our emotions isn’t a great leap. The composition of the gut microbiome has been linked to feelings of <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/27090302">anxiety</a>, though it’s not yet clear how this connection works. Does anxiety cause changes in our gut flora, is it the other way around, or does a third part of our body affect both? The microbiome has also been suggested to be able to play a part in the course of <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/27045844">depression, schizophrenia and autism</a>. There is much more work to be done in this area to understand how our microbiome affects how we think, but the research done so far suggests that our microbial partners may play substantial roles in how we think, in what we would call our intellect.</p><blockquote><strong>Are we a biome, a community of organisms, or are we two selves, only one of which is conscious?</strong></blockquote><p>However the science plays out, and whatever roles we find attributable to our gut microbiome, it clearly means that our notion of self needs adjusting. Are we best described as a biome, a community of organisms in which our consciousness is distributed over our whole body? Or are we two selves, only one of which is conscious? Certainly Descartes’ dualism has to be tossed out the window, though there probably aren’t many strict Cartesian dualists left anyhow (astral travelers riding their out of body experiences are the exception, of course). But thinking of our intellect as something we can divorce from our body is not divorced from modern thought (the phrase “mind over matter” comes to mind). Yes this new sciences shows that we can’t even try to set our mind safely in our brain, like an egg in an egg cup, but instead it’s distributed over our whole body, and among several hundred different species of microbes residing with us.</p><p>Aquinas might be able to go along with the new understanding of how our mind works, in that it roughly fits his conceptualization. That is, our body shapes our mind, and our intellectual self is comprised of both a conscious, reasoning aspect, as well as a separate and simpler sensation-responding aspect. Of course Aquinas also attributed other aspects to our intellect, in that it was a soul, an incorruptible creation that can persist after the destruction of our bodies. However he saw this incorruptible nature as dependent on God, for without supernatural aid our intellect would not be “us” without our body as well. Adding in a role for our microbiome into his conceptualization is not that much of a stretch. Using Aquinas’s framework, not only must we say that our body is the form, or font, of our soul, but the panoply of bacteria we carry with us play a part in forming our soul as well. That’s certainly a new role for the lowly microbe.</p><p>Regarding our original question, “Who am I?”, besides armchair reasoning and sequencing our genome, we may need to consult our bacteria as well.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=10b7f8eb0501" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Lord Byron, defender of textile workers and primary care physicians]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@bzring/lord-byron-defender-of-textile-workers-and-primary-care-physicians-8e897199303b?source=rss-56ce01f25b02------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8e897199303b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[genomics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[healthcare]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[medicine]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[The Charter of the Genome]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 18 Apr 2016 16:57:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-05-03T01:58:44.025Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YTcR2xeTJ9tD8ru5KeH1TA.jpeg" /></figure><h4>Or why not to bring your entire genome sequence print-out to a doctor visit</h4><p>Before there was Justin Bieber, or for those of us in Asia, any one the boys of a K-pop band, there was Lord Byron. To many of the women of the early 1800’s, as well as more than a few men, he was the epitome of romance. His noble birth, alluring poetry, spendthrift ways, his many loves, his foreign travels and adventures, all created- abetted by his active promotion- an image of exotic allure that captured the time. Even now if one’s love presents herself in a black dress, many points will be scored by repeating the opening lines to one of his most remembered poems,</p><p><em>She walks in beauty, like the night</em><br><em>Of cloudless climes and starry skies…</em></p><p>His reach extends even into today’s world of genomics, albeit tangentially and if one is willing to stretch a point. I count three connections:</p><p>The first of these links occurred during a rainy visit to the vacation home of the English Romantic poet Percy Shelley in Switzerland, where he and the Shelley’s competed in storytelling. It was on these inclement days, cooped up with Byron and friends, that Mary Shelley began the iconic novel, Frankenstein. We often call upon her novel today when comparing our modern use of genetics for recrafting life to Dr. Frankenstein’s efforts (though his were more needle, thread and lightening based), and in deriving the term ‘Frankenfood’ to describe genetically modified food.</p><p>Secondly, Byron’s only legitimate daughter, Ada Lovelace (<em>née</em> Bryon), wrote the first extant computer program. This program was meant to run on Charles Babbage’s mechanical computer, the “analytical engine”. Unfortunately Charles’ analytical engine was never built, and Ada’s program has yet to be run. Nonetheless she gets the credit for being the first computer programmer, and one of the key differences between genomics and its forerunner, genetics, is the necessity of computational power. Genetics deals with just a few genes at a time, genomics deals with all of them. Though I wouldn’t want to have to do genetic linkage analysis on Babbage’s contraption, our modern computers can trace a direct lineage back to his device, and to Ada Lovelace’s program.</p><p>And finally, Lord Byron defended the Luddites. This was a textile worker’s movement at the rise of the 19th century who claimed to follow in the footsteps of a Ned Ludd, and who smashed the new powered looms and mills that threatened their livelihoods. At that time, as well as now, to say that someone was a “Luddite” was a pejorative, impugning them with an unthinking rejection of technology and progress. However Byron championed them, and his debut speech before the House of Lords was to denounce a new act which would allow the death penalty for those who damaged a machine. His defense of the Luddites was that their frustration at being abandoned in the face of technological advances was worthy more of compassion than of capital punishment. He also wrote “Song For The Luddites “, which included the verse:</p><p><em>When the web that we weave is complete,</em><br><em>And the shuttle exchanged for the sword,</em><br><em>We will fling the winding sheet</em><br><em>O’er the despot at our feet,</em><br><em>And dye it deep in the gore he has poured.</em></p><p>Pretty strong stuff, though he told a friend that, “I have written it principally to shock your neighbor, who is all clergy and loyalty.” People like Byron tend to think of themselves as too clever by half.</p><blockquote><strong>Akin to Byron’s defense of the textile workers, let’s not dismiss an Annals of Internal Medicine editorial as being written by mere Luddites.</strong></blockquote><p>It is this defense for the Luddites that lets us connect Byron with genomics: inspired by Byron, I’m not going to dismiss an <a href="http://annals.org/article.aspx?articleid=2498493">editorial </a>in a recent issue of Annals of Internal Medicine as being written by mere Luddites.</p><p>The editorial accompanies the <a href="http://annals.org/article.aspx?articleid=2498491">research article</a> “Consumer Perceptions of Interactions With Primary Care Providers After Direct-to-Consumer Personal Genomic Testing”. This new study surveyed 1026 people who have used a personal genomic service (like 23andMe), and the results were quite positive. About 80% of participants were very satisfied with their decision to be tested, and less than 15% thought that none of the results could be used to improve their health. Most found their results understandable, and for those who discussed the results with their doctor, few were dissatisfied with the discussion, and most found that their physicians were quite capable and willing to help interpret the results. Among the few (&lt;20%) who reported a dissatisfying meeting with their doctor, 71% said their physician did not understand genetics well enough to discuss the results, and 90% said their physician was only willing to discuss somewhat or not at all the results. In contrast, those who had a good meeting with their physician reported the opposite, 71% said their physician did understand genetics, and all were at least willing to somewhat discuss the results.</p><p>My interpretation of the study is that everything looks surprisingly good, and we should all go out for a beer: most people were satisfied with the testing <em>and</em> their doctor. As only 27% of participants took their results within six months (the time period of this study) to ask their doctor’s opinion, that &lt;20% dissatisfied with the discussion only represents 5% of all participants. We all know you can’t make all of the people happy all of the time, especially if you are only granted 15 minutes for your appointments. Some of these unhappy 5% would probably have been unhappy if their doctors had specialized in medical genetics, devoted all the appointment plus an extra five minutes to this matter, <em>and</em> gave them a lollipop at the end. Some physicians were probably not comfortable discussing a complex topic with no time to review their patient’s testing results. And a few of those physicians possibly are contrary and unlikable souls that would get a poor mark no matter <em>what</em> they are discussing. We can’t tell how many of that 5% fall into each category, but the numbers are low enough I shall not lose much sleep over the matter.</p><p>The accompanying editorial has a different and more dyspeptic interpretation of the study, however. The editorial authors complain that the study’s results demonstrate that genomic tests have “externalized not only the costs of counseling and education but also the dissatisfaction consumers feel when their experience falls short of marketing promises.” This is akin to demanding that anyone who dares makes an advance in medical science also has to pay for educating the physicians as well as their clients, and to hold our hands while we adapt to the new knowledge. I don’t disagree with this sentiment, <em>per se</em>, though I wish the authors’ tone was less fractious and didactic.</p><p>Less easy to defend, the editorial additionally conjectures that the problem is not that the physicians are uneducated about genetics, but rather that the general populace is, and “professional societies should not need to take on this educational task, and physicians should not spend valuable time in the clinical encounter deflating a misguided marketing message.” Essentially the authors are saying, “We are not amused at having to discuss new types of medical information with our patients.” Fair enough, I suppose, however their solution is increased regulation of companies providing genetic testing and the production of educational material promoting the limitations of such testing. In terms of my recent <a href="http://charter-of-the-genome.org/2016/02/29/the-genome-as-a-commons/">discussion </a>on this subject, their response to this encroachment on their domain is an enclosure of our genome into the folds of government regulation and the medical profession, and the hopes that other people just stay out.</p><blockquote><strong>Though the editorial’s choleric style suggests that its conclusion is as much rooted in indigestion as in clear-headed reasoning, it raises a valid question: is a new technology responsible for easing its path into our world?</strong></blockquote><p>However, in the spirit of Lord Byron, who was not put off by the even greater less-than-polite actions of the Luddites, let’s not dismiss this editorial, even though its choleric style suggests that its conclusion is as much rooted in indigestion as in clear-headed reasoning. Though it is unusual to insist that a new technology is responsible for easing its own path into our world, is this an incorrect demand? Economists are fond of declaring that those worried about jobs lost via new technology or the globalization of the marketplace are not viewing the big picture; technology advances or new trade deals that increase productivity will raise the standard of living, on average, and are therefore a good thing. I don’t agree with this sanguine attitude. As I’ve told my children many a time, if someone tries to sell them the idea that it’s OK to hurt others because it’s “for the greater good”, they are to take two cautious steps back, and then start running. It’s that “on average” that’s the problem, as it means some real people are getting shafted. In this case, this is a small set of doctors and their patients. This is not to say that we should reject technology advances, or trade deals for that matter, but simply that we must listen to those that are on the front lines of these changes when they complain.</p><p>The editorial is correct, therefore, in its willingness to call a new technology in question. Instead of asking how we can best work with a new tool, it is better to instead demand it to work for us. Ivan Illich, Catholic priest and philosopher, had proposed the term ‘convivial tools’ to describe such human-centric technologies. These are technologies that let us improve our lives on <em>our</em> terms, and not terms set by others, and certainly not by the tool itself. Unfortunately he saw our world as being filled with an increasing number of non-convivial tools, technology that dehumanizes us, stratifies society and favors those with means versus those without. With our DNA being so central to life, it’s important to ensure that genomic testing is as convivial as possible.</p><p>Fortunately the overall favorable attitude of most participants to the genomic testing results and to their physicians’ responses suggests that further government regulation does not seem to be needed, at least in terms of the issues addressed by this study. However improved presentation of the results of genetic testing likely is in order. Test reports can be bettered in two ways, prioritization and simplification.</p><blockquote><strong>Physicians are overworked, and dropping fifty gene reports on them, each of which presents the data spread out over several web pages, and hoping this can be covered in a 15 minute appointment, … it’s just not going to go well.</strong></blockquote><p>Simplifying a gene report is the easiest. 23andMe, one of the genetic testing companies used in this study, offers a very large amount of information to accompany all of the alleles they test, but from my experience in designing genetic testing reports for physicians, what they desired was a single (one sided) sheet that simply expressed what the assay found, what were the other results possible and how the patient’s result compared to those, and what actions (if any) could be taken. Physicians are overworked, and dropping fifty gene reports on them, each of which presents the data spread out over several web pages, and hoping this can be covered in a 15 minute appointment, … it’s just not going to go well.</p><p>Which leads us to the other means of improving the doctors’ lives, how to triage a testing report? With hundreds of genes currently linked to human health and with many sites of variation in each of these that may be important, the standard way of assessing the reliability and importance of these tests and determining what a physician should do with the results cannot happen. This would entail clinical trials for all the gene variants, and there is neither the money, time, nor patient numbers to assess all these genetic variants in this manner. Furthermore, the number of gene variations linked to human health is expanding, so it’s not just a matter of waiting for the studies to be done, there will <em>never</em> be clinical trials to validate all these findings. Therefore gene testing companies need to determine ways of filtering reports: which of the many heath related tests in a person’s report possibly warrant a look-over by one’s physicians? Given the newness of the science, this number is currently not over burdensome. Which results are health related and of personal interest, but too tenuous for most physicians to feel comfortable offering definitive advice? At this stage, most results will fall into this category.</p><p>Though this triage is, to a degree, subjective, it is doable, and possibly worth doing. I imagine that if the cheerless 5% identified in this study had been able to come prepared with only one or two single sheets describing the genetic tests of greatest import to them, that 5% might have dropped. Admittedly, given the number of froward people in the world, and that <em>any</em> interaction between two people is still going to generate a certain baseline of discontent, I am doubtful of it dropping much. Nonetheless, asking that genomic testing reports not make physician appointments more difficult than they already are is a reasonable request.</p><p>At a poetry recital at my daughter’s school this week, one of the student’s “poems” was a translation of a song by the K-pop boyband, EXO-K. I was unmoved, but the students seemed appreciative. Byron would likely have approved- or been jealous, or set about to woo the lead singer. Probably all three- he was like that. Possibly too he would approve of efforts to ensure that technological changes leave control in our hands, and are not so complicated or disruptive that we, physicians and patients, must have it wrested from us and relegated to the demesne of the few. Though it is unlikely the Lord Byrons of our day will write a song in support of the physicians, I’ll pay attention at the next poetry recital, just in case.</p><p>[Originally published at <a href="http://charter-of-the-genome.org/2016/03/07/lord-byron-defender-of-textile-workers-and-primary-care-physicians/">The Charter of the Genome.org</a>]</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8e897199303b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Demise of the Handkerchief and the Rise of Genomics]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@bzring/the-demise-of-the-handkerchief-and-the-rise-of-genomics-1f0cde30d9f9?source=rss-56ce01f25b02------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1f0cde30d9f9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[medicine]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[genomics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[The Charter of the Genome]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 16 Apr 2016 03:32:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-04-18T14:55:00.590Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*2Kc6fPl1Zf3E-jBFt3euwQ.jpeg" /></figure><h4>…plus disposable rain bonnets and the Chinese river dolphin</h4><p>Three sartorial items from my childhood have largely disappeared, at least in the company I keep: handkerchiefs, plastic head scarves, and galoshes. Some might say this is a good thing. Handkerchiefs are unsanitary, disposable rain bonnets are hardly fashionable, even among the grandmotherly set, and there is little of <em>haute couture</em> in a pair of rubber overshoes (in fact, there is none). So begone with them.</p><p>The merits of their passing into oblivion aside, around the time that these items disappeared from the landscape, the science of genomics arose. Is there a connection?</p><p>No, of course not. One would have to be completely and unhealthily obsessed with handkerchiefs to attempt to make that connection, or simply mentally deficient. Probably both.</p><p>For one, these three items haven’t completely vanished. Once I noticed the absence of handkerchiefs I pined for them, and was quickly (albeit reluctantly) given a new package of twelve by my family. Galoshes and disposable headscarves are still sold too, though I doubt you can find many young people who will dare to sport them. Secondly, the timing isn’t quite right. While the advent of techniques capable of sequencing a small genome (Maxim-Gilbert and the Sanger technologies) were created in the late 1970’s, which corresponds to when these three items disappeared from my life, genomics really arose to prominence in the 90’s and afterwards. Genomics depends primarily on two technological platforms: high-throughput DNA sequencing, and lots of computational power. Physical maps of the genome are important too, but those other two legs are the real technological pillars of the field, and each didn’t have the right stuff for large scale genomics until the late 90’s.</p><blockquote><strong>The demise of handkerchiefs and the emergence of genomics are not causally linked. One might as well say that the recent extinction of the Chinese river dolphin is related to the rise of genomics.</strong></blockquote><p>So, handkerchiefs and genomics, and their fall and rise, are not causally linked. One might as well say that the extinction of the Chinese river dolphin (last specimen seen in 2002) is related to the rise of genomics. The timing for this dolphin vs genomics hypothesis (late 1990’s-early 2000’s) is even better than for my supposed handkerchiefs/genomics link. However not even the most hyperkinetic conspiracy theorists, those who can make detailed and manifold connections between any random news story and the Illuminati, would suggest that the poor river dolphin had anything to do with the rise of genomics, or the other way around. [Though there was a Star Trek episode in which Dr. Crusher “activated the introns”, and the crew “devolved”, with Counselor Troi turning into a fish, but that doesn’t really encompass this situation.]</p><p>Nonetheless, if one is willing to stretch a point, there <em>might</em> be a connection between all these events. At least the passing of plastic headscarves, galoshes, river dolphins, and genomics. Handkerchiefs I’m not sure about, and since I’ve started using them again and genomics hasn’t collapsed, maybe they aren’t in the equation. Plastic headscarves probably faded away when women worried less about protecting elaborate, towering hairdos from the rain; our busier lives and two income families favor more casual and easier to manage hairstyles. More importantly, we simply have to worry less about protecting our heads from rain these days. The same goes for galoshes- we now can avoid rain without having to cover our shoes. Online shopping, indoor malls, giant one-stop shops like Walmart, and two car families mean less trudging through the wet to get all the errands accomplished. Possibly handkerchiefs fit into this this schema too, in terms of being part of a general inclination towards convenience. Economic development may therefore be the driving force behind the disappearance of all these fashions.</p><p>The river dolphins, for that matter, were also done in by economics. Increased river traffic, habitat destruction (and not being as cute as pandas) are the primary factors in their disappearance. Having only a backflip as their sole defensive strategy didn’t help either.</p><blockquote><strong>What connects galoshes, genomics and river dolphins is money</strong></blockquote><p>Money connects all these phenomena; more money spent on our part (buying that second car, or being willing to replace shoes more often), more money spent (and earned) by property developers, more money spent by NIH and biotech on research, and more money spent (and earned) by the factories shipping goods down the Yangtze river. Since 1970 the gross world product has increased over six fold. By and large, and though it may not feel like it on some days, we (the average “we”, not necessarily the personal “we”) are much richer than we were when galoshes ruled the land. This increase in money means more money spent on convenience, shoes, and the shipment of those shoes through the dolphin’s habitat.</p><p>And the rise of genomics? Genomics is a costly science. The Human Genome Project, which oversaw the sequencing of the first human genome, cost about $2.7 billion US dollars. Science, overall, has been moving towards larger, costlier studies. One indication of this is the <a href="https://www.nlm.nih.gov/bsd/authors1.html">rise of scientific publications with many authors</a>, sometimes numbering in the thousands, leading to the coining of the word “hyperauthorship”, though dozens or even hundreds are more common. This is because resources must often be pooled to perform a genomics study. Not only is the equipment expensive, but the science usually depends on putting together a large study population. After the first paper describing the sequencing of a species (which in itself involves a large team), follow-up studies will describe why one individual is different than another, and that often means looking a <em>lot</em> of people. This involves many hospitals and collecting of many records, and also simply means that the reagent costs go up too.</p><p>A study of the genetic variations involved in a reasonably simple disorder, for example, macular degeneration, might entail looking at DNA samples from a thousand people. Trickier studies, those looking at complex diseases like hypertension, or trying to discern small increases in a treatment or test’s efficacy, may need to have patient numbers in the tens of thousands. That costs money. Fortunately, despite spending more money on shoes and that second car, we have more research money too; the budget of the NIH has increased about five-fold (adjusting for inflation) since 1970. For those worried about the sustainability and financial prudence of these expenditures, it’s been <a href="http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2013-06-12/human-genome-project-spurred-966-billion-sciences-boom">estimated</a> that the money spent on the Human Genome Project gave an over fifty-fold return, in terms of the US economy. I’m sure my buying that Star Trek: The Next Generation DVD box set had a similar economic return. Genomics not only uses a lot of money, it seems to be increasing wealth too.</p><p>From this we can conclude two things. One, as plastic headscarves and river dolphins are not causally linked to the development of genomics as a leading science, and are only connected via an association with our underlying economics, we don’t need to worry that a fortuitous finding of a lost population of river dolphins will doom our science. Nor would a resurgence in the popularity of galoshes cause the science to collapse. Therefore I can continue to enjoy my rediscovery of handkerchiefs guilt free.</p><p>Secondly, since increased money may have contributed to the rise of genomics, more money might help it ascend to even greater heights. Despite the advances in the field we’ve seen in the past 20 years, we’ve really only set the stage of what needs to be done. To move past simply knowing what genes there are in the human genome to understanding what these genes means about our health and biology requires studying people. A lot of people. As part of an initiative to better target health care based on our personal genomes, the US government is pursuing a “<a href="http://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-obama-precisionmedicine-idUSKBN0L313R20150130">one million genome</a>” initiative. Private companies and institutes have similar “million genome” plans. Through these large scale efforts, which we’re still building the technology to be able to complete, we hope to be able to truly use the potential of genomic medicine. Galoshes and disposable rain bonnets are accepted attire, but not required (or forbidden).</p><p>[Originally published at <a href="http://charter-of-the-genome.org/2016/04/16/the-demise-of-the-handkerchief-and-the-rise-of-genomics/">The Charter of the Genome.org</a>]</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1f0cde30d9f9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[All the world in an NIH grant application form]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@bzring/all-the-world-in-an-nih-grant-application-form-5e447bb185a3?source=rss-56ce01f25b02------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5e447bb185a3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nih-grants]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[The Charter of the Genome]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 04 Apr 2016 02:57:42 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-04-18T15:34:35.344Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/720/1*pebSlVzzyOtD-N2PZMa57w.png" /></figure><h4>The intersect of applying for grants and St. Augustine</h4><p>William Blake said that we can see the world in a grain of sand. Probably he was speaking metaphorically. If not, considering that sand is very small and the Earth is very large (comparatively), you’d have to be standing pretty far from our planet in order to be able to do this. Just how far from the Earth would we have to stand? We solve this equation:</p><p><em>2*arctan(diameter of earth/(2*distance grain of sand is from earth))= 2*arctan(diameter of grain of sand/(2*distance sand is from eye))</em></p><p>Assuming the grain of sand is a millimeter across and we’re holding it about 10 cm from our eyes, the answer is about 1,275,000 kilometers, or about three times the distance from the earth to the moon. So Blake probably meant this figuratively; the wonder of creation is found just as profoundly in the small as it is in the big…. or possibly he thought interplanetary space travel was possible in the year 1803. Reading some of his later prophetic poems will lead one to conclude that this is a distinct possibility.</p><blockquote><strong>In a clarification of NIH research grant application requirements we can see a reflection of a philosophical question: does progress exist?</strong></blockquote><p>Similar to Blake’s linking of the prosaic and the grand, in a clarification published this week of the National Institute of Health’s research grant application requirements, authored by the director of the NIH, Francis Collins, we can see a reflection of a long-standing philosophical question: does progress exist? For the impatient, just the title of the <a href="http://science.sciencemag.org/content/351/6280/1405.1.full">letter</a>, “Basic science: Bedrock of progress”, makes an affirmative answer to that question. Not only does progress exist, the implicit sentiment is that it is for the good. The letter was penned to affirm the institute’s support for basic research, that is, research which doesn’t have a clear utilitarian objective but whose primary goal is to better understand a phenomenon. Applied research, in contrast, is directed to fixed and practical goals, such as an improved treatment for a specific disease. It’s clear how applied research intends to make our lives better. However a belief in the importance and usefulness of basic research makes a leap, and entails a faith that understanding our world in greater detail will naturally lead to an improved world.</p><p>But does it basic research really do this? Our recent history is filled with examples both pro and con: antibiotics and nuclear weapons, vaccines and global warming, clean drinking water and reality TV. Nonetheless, most of us (myself included) have some degree of faith, often unquestioned, in the power and benevolence (or at least innocuity) of progress. At worst we think it is just something that needs to be closely monitored, like a slightly self-destructive toddler. NIH’s statement is another voice in the choir singing its praises. However this faith in progress is not universal.</p><blockquote><strong><em>“For all funding requests at NASA one should state, if possible, that if the project was not funded that the astronauts would die.”</em></strong></blockquote><p>After I had finished a fellowship at Stanford I tried to become an exobiologist at NASA. Neither I nor NASA used the word “exobiologist”, instead the project I proposed used microarray technology (then very new) to examine simple microbial ecologies in extreme environments on Earth, but “exobiology” is what we were all thinking [though they were enthusiastic about the idea and offered me a position, administration details and funding were problems, and I reluctantly turned it down]. I learned two stratagems towards securing a position at NASA during my interviews. One was to ensure other researchers that I did <em>not</em> want to go into space; most researchers seemed to be hoping for one of the very few mission specialist position on a space shuttle or ISS mission. I assured them that Earth orbit had no relevance for me, and that the salt water ponds in NASA Ames’ backyard were much more relevant to my studies. Secondly, I was told that for all funding requests I should state, if possible, that if my project was not funded that the astronauts would die. This was not meant to be stated as a threat (though I suppose that might work too), but that the purpose of the research was directed towards a practical, in fact vital, goal, and was critical for advancing manned space flight.</p><p>Similarly, NIH grant applications must include a Public Health Relevance Statement so as to “ensure the description of the projects’ potential to improve public health is clearly articulated.” This has led many to express a fear, what with tightened budgets, that research with no immediate impact on public health may go unfunded. The necessity of framing one’s research goals in this constrained manner was, though not definitively worded so, possibly an affront to the idea of progress. Thus the public letter this week from Dr. Collins, and his assurances that NIH is dedicated to the promotion of basic research.</p><p>Certainly the use of the phrase, “Bedrock of Progress” in the title is a strong affirmation in the belief that progress exists. Bedrock is what we prefer to build our foundations upon, where possible. The skyline of Manhattan reflects the underlying geology of the island, the buildings rise highest where the bedrock is closer to the surface. However this sentiment about progress may be a relatively recent addition to human thought. The Greek philosophers didn’t seem to support this view; Plato suggested that while government might advance through stages, it was inherently unstable, and we weren’t inexorably progressing towards a better future. Instead the idea that cycles of rises and falls explains human history was a more accepted understanding. Greek mythology, in fact, suggests that we are <em>descending</em> from a previous golden age, the heroic epics of the time of Troy took place in a bronze age, and the Greeks at the time of Athens’ ascendancy were in an iron age. Instead of progress we are defined by retrogression: worse is yet to come.</p><p>The contrasting idea progress, of time as an arrow pulling humans along in its path towards a better future, may have arisen in the West with Christian philosophy. St. Augustine, writing around the year 400, believed that the events of the bible, specifically the birth, resurrection, and promised return of Jesus, are fixed points in time. With these unique milestones marking the path of our past, there cannot be a cyclical quality to our history. However the modern idea of progress, of human effort being the force that draws us forward, was an idea of the Enlightenment. That was the period around the mid 1700’s when a faith in God’s stewardship, and his overseers on Earth via the Church and the divine right of kings, was replaced by a confidence in our own ability to lead ourselves. Science was the brightest of our guiding lights on our march forwards.</p><blockquote><strong><em>“… no one has ever been so witty as you are in trying to turn us into brutes: to read your book makes one long to go about all fours.”<br> -Voltaire</em></strong></blockquote><p>Of course this movement did not lack its detractors. The <a href="http://charter-of-the-genome.org/2016/03/07/lord-byron-defender-of-textile-workers-and-primary-care-physicians/">Luddites </a>of the early 19th century were not believers in the benevolence of progress. The phrase “noble savage” arose during the Enlightenment, extolling the virtues of those not sullied by the taints of civilization, stating that the rise of more complex societal structures and technology were not necessarily for our betterment. Jean Jacques Rousseau, who is often linked to that phrase though he never actually said it, argued that civilization should be reorganized on a simpler, fairer and more “natural” basis. Rousseau proudly sent a copy of his first book that expounded this view (<em>Discours sur l’origin et les fondements de l’inégalité parmi les hommes</em>) to Voltaire, chief wit of the Enlightenment and promoter of its ideals of progress. Voltaire replied, “… no one has ever been so witty as you are in trying to turn us into brutes: to read your book makes one long to go about all fours. Since, however, it is now some sixty years since I gave up the practice, I feel that it is unfortunately impossible for me to resume it.”, and he closed his letter with an invitation for Rousseau to come join him in Rousseau’s native Switzerland, “…you must come … here in your native place, enjoy its freedom, drink with me the milk of its cows, and browse on its grass. I am yours most philosophically and with sincere esteem.”</p><p>William Blake, who said we could see a world in a grain of sand, was decidedly in Rousseau’s camp. In his poem “London”, he writes disparagingly of its streets:</p><p><em>And mark in every face I meet<br> Marks of weakness, marks of woe.<br> In every cry of every Man,<br> In every Infants cry of fear,<br> In every voice: in every ban,<br> The mind-forg’d manacles I hear</em></p><p>This is not the bleakest of Blake’s poems about civilization’s effects.</p><p>Like Blake, we too can try to see our world, not in a grain of sand, but in the equally commonplace of the application criteria for an NIH grant. Believers in the power of science as a power that intrinsically pulls us forward to a better future balked at the limiting and utilitarian language of the mandated public health relevance statement, and NIH agreed. The instructions for the statement now clarify that one is to “describe how, in the short or long term, the research would contribute to fundamental knowledge about the nature and behavior of living systems and/or the application of that knowledge to enhance health, lengthen life, and reduce illness and disability.” And as stated earlier in this essay, their announcement of this clarification is titled “Basic Science: Bedrock of Progress”, in case we still weren’t sure of where they stood in this debate. NIH adds its voice to ours in the choir of progress.</p><p>Of course this letter from Dr. Collins does not end the dispute of Voltaire vs Rousseau in favor of Voltaire and progress. We arguably have more evidence now of the dangers of civilization and technology than at any time in our past. Despite this, however, most of us continue to believe that more knowledge and more technology will help. Is this illogical and a product of deluded thinking? Or is it rational and correct, or maybe a matter of faith and choice? Possibly, a mixture of all three.</p><p>[Originally published at<a href="http://charter-of-the-genome.org/2016/04/03/all-the-world-in-an-nih-grant-application-form/"> The Charter of the Genome.org</a>]</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5e447bb185a3" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>