<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Caleb Smith on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Caleb Smith on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@calebrsmith95?source=rss-9c9c24667ada------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 12:38:06 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@calebrsmith95/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Most Memorable Michigan Games of the Jim Harbaugh era]]></title>
            <link>https://calebrsmith95.medium.com/most-memorable-michigan-games-of-the-harbaugh-era-de148c4f202d?source=rss-9c9c24667ada------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/de148c4f202d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[michigan-wolverines]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jim-harbaugh]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[michigan-football]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ncaa-football]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[college-football]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Caleb Smith]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 19 Jan 2025 00:47:29 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-05-26T14:31:19.187Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Every game ranked from 114 to 1. You’re welcome.</h4><p>Many Michigan fans look back fondly on Jim Harbaugh’s 9-year coaching tenure as a Golden Age in the program’s storied history. And in many ways it was. But to fully appreciate these 9 seasons of Michigan football, the good needs to be remembered with the bad. What better way to do this than to rank all 114 games of his career from least to most memorable? Let me be clear: many of his most “memorable” games did not turn out the way we wanted. But a double-OT loss to Ohio State is certainly more memorable than a blowout win over SMU in the third week of the season. To be sure, there’s a lot more good than bad on this list (Harbaugh won 86 games at Michigan and lost only 25. And yes, that doesn’t add up to 114 because he was suspended for a few of those. I still included those games in my list). I hope you enjoy reading this as much as I enjoyed writing it!</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*vYL_5jtmrFbnsshP.jpg" /><figcaption>Stacy Revere/Getty Images</figcaption></figure><h3>Did Any of These Games Actually Happen?</h3><p><strong>114. Michigan 45 — SMU 20 (September 15, 2018)</strong><br>I’m pretty sure this game was never actually played.</p><p><strong>113. Michigan 36 — Cincinnati 14 (September 7, 2017)</strong><br>Same with this one.</p><p><strong>112. Michigan 35 — UNLV 7 (September 9, 2023)<br></strong>The most forgettable game of an unforgettable season.</p><p><strong>111. Michigan 28 — UNLV 7 (September 19, 2015)</strong><br>Apparently Jim Harbaugh played UNLV twice??? Who knew?</p><p><strong>110. Michigan 63 — Northern Illinois 10 (September 18, 2021)<br></strong>I’m pretty sure we’re just making games up at this point</p><p><strong>109. Michigan 38 — Maryland 7 (November 2, 2019)</strong><br>It’s appropriate that Maryland is the first Big 10 game on this list. They played Michigan literally every year of the Jim Harbaugh era and maybe gave us like 2 semi-memorable games?</p><p><strong>108. Michigan 35 — Maryland 10 (November 11, 2017)</strong><br>If it wasn’t for them randomly beating Texas two seasons in a row, I’m pretty sure most people would’ve forgotten that Maryland was even in the Big 10.</p><p><strong>107. Michigan 59 — Maryland 3 (November 5th, 2016)</strong><br>Anyone who claims to remember this game is lying.</p><p><strong>106. Michigan 59 — Maryland 18 (November 20th, 2021)<br></strong>Yawn</p><p><strong>105. Michigan 41 — Illinois 8 (October 22, 2016)</strong><br>Does anyone remember Michigan playing Illinois in 2016? I sure don’t.</p><p><strong>104. Michigan 34 — Nebraska 3 (November 12, 2022)</strong><br>Do I have a good reason for ranking this game as “more memorable” than any of the ones before it? Not really.</p><p><strong>103. Michigan 49, Rutgers 16 (November 7, 2015)</strong><br>Rutgers might have been horrible during Jim Harbaugh’s entire tenure, but there were actually a handful of memorable games they played against Michigan over those 9 years. This was not one of them.</p><p><strong>102. Michigan 29 — Indiana 7 (November 6, 2021)</strong><br>Michigan had a lot of surprisingly memorable games against the Hoosiers during the Harbaugh era. This was not one of them.</p><p><strong>101. Michigan 41 — Purdue 13 (November 3, 2023)<br></strong>This game was played barely over a year ago, which I guess makes it slightly more memorable than the ones above it?</p><h3>There’s at Least 1 Semi-Memorable Thing from Each of These Games</h3><p><strong>100. Michigan 51 — UCF 14 (September 10, 2016)</strong><br>Scott Frost was coaching UCF in this game. I guess that’s kinda memorable?</p><p><strong>99. Michigan 56 — Nebraska 10 (September 22, 2018)</strong><br>Scott Frost again! And he lost by even more this time!</p><p><strong>98. Michigan 33 — Northwestern 7 (October 23, 2021)</strong><br>This game was kinda close at halftime.</p><p><strong>97. Michigan 52 — Rutgers 0 (September 28, 2019)</strong><br>The game itself wasn’t really memorable, but it was kinda nice to win big after getting our asses handed to us by Wisconsin the week before.</p><p><strong>96. Michigan 42 — Rutgers 7 (November 10th, 2018)</strong><br>Isiah Pacheco had an 80-yard run in the 1st quarter to make it 7–7.</p><p><strong>95. Michigan 35 — Rutgers 14 (October 28, 2017)</strong><br>Rutgers always seems to have one big play every time they play Michigan. This time, it was another long run in the 1st quarter to again make it 7–7. This game was virtually the same as the 2018 version, but I’m ranking it a tad higher because it was basically a moral victory for Rutgers after their MUCH more memorable debacle from the year before.</p><p><strong>94. Michigan 31 — Rutgers 7 (September 23, 2023)</strong><br>Rutgers threw a 69-yard TD pass to take a 7–0 lead on the eventual National Champions.</p><p><strong>93. Michigan 42 — Maryland 21 (October 6, 2018)</strong><br>Maryland had a 98-yard kickoff return in the 1st quarter to take a 7–3 lead. But this game wasn’t as close as the final score makes it appear.</p><p><strong>92. Michigan 49 — Western Michigan 3 (September 8, 2018)</strong><br>I’ve always enjoyed these in-state games. This particular one wasn’t super memorable, but it was the first home game of the 2018 season (Michigan lost in South Bend the week before).</p><p><strong>91. Michigan 47 — Western Michigan 14 (September 4, 2021)</strong><br>This game was a season opener, which is the only memorable thing about it. In hindsight, 2021 was a breakthrough season for Harbaugh, but at the moment this just seemed like a mediocre opening to another mediocre season.</p><p><strong>90. Michigan 40 — Middle Tennessee State 21 (August 31, 2019)</strong><br>MTSU actually took a 7–0 lead in the 2019 season opener. But I’d be lying if I said I remember anything else about this game.</p><p><strong>89. Michigan 30 — East Carolina 3 (September 2, 2023)</strong><br>Another complete yawner of a season opener. Expectations for this team were higher than any other in the Harbaugh era, and this game told us basically nothing about whether these expectations would actually be met. The only really memorable thing about it was the suspension of Harbaugh to begin the season, but no one actually thought this would cause them to lose to East Carolina.</p><p><strong>88. Michigan 51 — Colorado State 7 (September 3, 2022)</strong><br>The last in a string of mostly forgettable season openers, I’ll put this one ahead of the others because of the intrigue surrounding the QB competition between Cade McNamara and JJ McCarthy. McNamara started this game and was the same low-risk, low-reward guy he had been the season before. The next game (in which JJ would get his chance to shine) was a bit more memorable.</p><p><strong>87. Wisconsin 24 — Michigan 10 (November 18, 2017)</strong><br>2017 was mostly a season to forget. This game was no exception. Arguably the most forgettable loss of Harbaugh’s Michigan career.</p><p><strong>86. South Carolina 26 — Michigan 19 (January 1, 2018 — Outback Bowl)</strong><br>I’m not going to lie, I initially had this game ranked much higher because I thought it was the Jadaveon Clowney game. Turns out Michigan played South Carolina in the Outback Bowl twice in 5 years. Who knew??? This has to be the most forgettable Bowl Game in Michigan football history.</p><p><strong>85. Michigan 59 — Connecticut 0 (September 17, 2022)</strong><br>JJ McCarthy’s first game after winning the starting QB job.</p><p><strong>84. Michigan 28 — Purdue 10 (September 23, 2017)</strong><br>Purdue actually took a 10–7 lead into the locker room at halftime.</p><p><strong>83. Michigan 52 — Rutgers 17 (November 5, 2022)</strong><br>Rutgers actually took a 17–14 lead into the locker room at halftime.</p><p><strong>82. Michigan 31 — Indiana 10 (October 8, 2022)</strong><br>Michigan always seems to have surprisingly competitive games against the Hoosiers. This one was tied 10–10 at halftime.</p><p><strong>81. Michigan 39 — Indiana 14 (November 23, 2019)</strong><br>Indiana led 14–7 early in the 2nd quarter of this “trap” game.</p><p><strong>80. Michigan 42 — Illinois 25 (October 12, 2019)</strong><br>This was supposed to be the Brandon Peters revenge game, but he got injured beforehand and didn’t play. Illinois actually came back from a 28–0 deficit to make it 28–25 early in the 4th quarter, but Michigan put the game away late.</p><p><strong>79. Alabama 35 — Michigan 16 (January 1, 2020 — Citrus Bowl)</strong><br>Literally no one expected Michigan to win this one. The Wolverines actually led 16–14 at halftime before the Tide rolled in the 2nd half. An expected and predictable end to another disappointing season.</p><h3>These Ones are Actually Kind of Memorable</h3><p><strong>78. Michigan 52 — Indiana 7 (October 14, 2023)</strong><br>JJ McCarthy absolutely balled out in this one. <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zaK4QdfvrpE">His 54-yard TD pass to Colston Loveland early in the 2nd quarter</a> was one of the best of his college career.</p><p><strong>77. Michigan 31 — Bowling Green 6 (September 16, 2023)</strong><br>JJ threw 3 interceptions in this game. Although the outcome was never really in doubt, it raised questions about whether this team was really the National Title contender so many had expected them to be.</p><p><strong>76. Michigan 52 — Minnesota 10 (October 7, 2023)</strong><br>And this game answered those questions in one of the most dominant performances of the entire Harbaugh era. Will Johnson had a pick-6 on the first play of the game and the Wolverines never took their foot off the gas. Minnesota wasn’t a terrible team, but that night they didn’t belong on the same field as the Wolverines.</p><p><strong>75. Michigan 28 — Penn State 16 (November 21, 2015)</strong><br>Pretty much the least consequential Michigan/Penn State game of the Jim Harbaugh/James Franklin rivalry. Both teams were mediocre. The game itself was mediocre. But every Michigan/Penn State matchup is at least somewhat memorable, so I’ll give this one the benefit of the doubt.</p><p><strong>74. Michigan 29 — Air Force 13 (September 16, 2017)</strong><br>Air Force kept this game competitive into the 2nd half. Harbaugh’s first 2 teams had dominated inferior competition: this was the first sign that the 2017 season might not go as smoothly.</p><p><strong>73. Michigan 20 — Indiana 10 (November 19, 2016)</strong><br>Classic trap game against Indiana. The Hoosiers led 10–6 in the 3rd quarter before Michigan put the game away late with two long De’Veon Smith runs.</p><p><strong>72. Michigan 28 — Maryland 0 (October 3, 2015)</strong><br>This one is mostly memorable as the 1st Big 10 game of Harbaugh’s coaching career. It was also the 2nd of 3 consecutive shutouts.</p><p><strong>71. Michigan 63 — Hawaii 3 (September 3, 2016)</strong><br>Michigan had high expectations coming into Harbaugh’s 2nd season as Head Coach. This season opener proved those expectations were justified.</p><p><strong>70. Michigan 35 — Oregon State 7 (September 12, 2015)</strong><br>I had a hard time ranking this game. It was the first home game for Harbaugh as the head coach of his alma mater. But the game itself was a snooze. I guess #70 seems about right.</p><p><strong>69. Michigan 27 — Iowa 14 (October 1, 2022)</strong><br>Nice!</p><p><strong>68. Florida 41 — Michigan 15 (December 29, 2018 — Peach Bowl)</strong><br>Not nice! A disastrous end to a once-promising season.</p><p><strong>67. Michigan 20 — Rutgers 13 (September 25, 2021)</strong><br>A surprisingly competitive game. Michigan took a 20–3 lead into halftime, then held on in the second half. I doubt most fans leaving the game expected this to be Harbaugh’s first Big 10 championship team, especially after the disastrous 2020 season.</p><p><strong>66. Michigan 10 — Iowa 3 (October 5, 2019)</strong><br>2019 was a weird season, and this was probably the most underwhelming ranked win of Harbaugh’s Michigan career. Oh, you scored 10 points and beat Iowa? Big whoop.</p><p><strong>65. Michigan 45 — Nebraska 7 (September 30, 2023)</strong><br>The only thing memorable about this game <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=32Vk-3uy8yw">was the Roman Wilson Catch</a>. But damn was it memorable.</p><p><strong>64. Penn State 27— Michigan 17 (November 28, 2020)</strong><br>An embarrassing end to an embarrassing season. Penn State was winless coming into this game. A COVID outbreak afterward canceled the rest of Michigan’s season and might have saved Jim Harbaugh’s job.</p><p><strong>63. Michigan 31 — Indiana 20 (November 17, 2018)</strong><br>Indiana always seems to play Michigan tough, especially the week before Ohio State. This was no exception, as Indiana took a 17–15 lead into halftime. Michigan dominated the 2nd half, but not before Indiana showed that you could expose Don Brown’s defense with crossing routes…</p><p><strong>62. Michigan 33 — Minnesota 10 (November 4, 2017)</strong><br>Probably the most impressive win of the 2017 season (which admittedly isn’t saying much). Khaleke Hudson had an out-of-nowhere incredible performance that had people comparing him to Jabrill Peppers.</p><p><strong>61. Michigan 56 — Hawaii 10 (September 10, 2022)</strong><br>The game that won JJ McCarthy the starting job. He played an almost perfect game (albeit against inferior competition), and showed why his ceiling as a player would be needed if Michigan was going to seriously compete for a National Championship.</p><p><strong>60. Michigan 44 — Michigan State 10 (November 16, 2019)</strong><br>Always nice to blow out Little Brother.</p><p><strong>59. Michigan 29 — Michigan State 7 (October 29, 2022)</strong><br>Little Brother took a 7–3 lead late in the 1st quarter. It was all Big Brother from there.</p><p><strong>58. Ohio State 42 — Michigan 13 (November 28, 2015)</strong><br>No one expected Harbaugh to be competitive vs. Ohio State in his first season, and he wasn’t. But it’s still The Game, so I couldn’t justify putting it lower than this.</p><p><strong>57. Wisconsin 49 — Michigan 11 (November 14, 2020)</strong><br>Arguably the most embarrassing loss of Jim Harbaugh’s Michigan career. Even his biggest defenders (like me) started questioning if it was time to part ways.</p><p><strong>56. Michigan 26 — Iowa 0 (December 2, 2023 — Big 10 Championship)</strong><br>About as forgettable as a Big 10 Championship game could possibly be. Michigan had already won 2 Big Ten Titles in a row, and by this point it was business as usual. Everyone pretty much knew Iowa’s offense wasn’t going to score. Although Michigan started sluggish, once they went up 10–0 at the end of the 1st quarter the game was essentially over.</p><p><strong>55. Utah 24 — Michigan 17 (September 3, 2015)</strong><br>Considering this was the first game of the Jim Harbaugh era, it was pretty forgettable. The game wasn’t a blowout, but was never really in doubt either: Michigan scored a garbage-time Touchdown with 54 seconds left to make it appear closer than it actually was. As far as debuts go, it could’ve been better could’ve been worse. But it was a debut nonetheless, and that makes it memorable if nothing else.</p><p><strong>54. Michigan 49 — Penn State 10 (September 24, 2016)</strong><br>This game is more memorable in hindsight. Penn State was coming off a loss to Pitt: no one thought they’d go on to beat Ohio State and win the Big 10, especially after this one.</p><p><strong>53. Michigan 38 — Northwestern 0 (October 10, 2015)<br></strong>Third shutout in a row: a first in Michigan Football history.</p><p><strong>52. Michigan 31 — BYU 0 (September 26, 2015)</strong><br>The first truly impressive win of the Harbaugh era. BYU was ranked #22 coming into this one: Michigan not only won, but dominated. The first in a streak of three consecutive shutouts. Also, <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7KNfWrIN1yY">this De’Veon Smith mini-Beat Quake</a> is still one of the most badass plays I’ve ever seen.</p><p><strong>51. Michigan 49 — Michigan State 0 (October 21, 2023)</strong><br>Maybe the most enjoyable game of the entire 2023 National Championship season, and the most thorough demolition of Little Brother in the Harbaugh era.</p><p><strong>50. Michigan 31 — Washington 10 (September 11, 2021)</strong><br>Michigan was coming off the infamous 2–4 COVID season that forced Harbaugh to take a pay cut. The fanbase’s morale was arguably at an all-time low going into this game. Although Washington ended up being pretty bad, it sure felt good to easily beat another Power Conference team. This was also the breakout game for Michigan Legend Blake Corum.</p><p><strong>49. Michigan 49 — Minnesota 24 (October 24, 2020)</strong><br>The highlight of an otherwise disastrous COVID season. For one game, we all thought Joe Milton’s “Speed in Space” offense could be lethal.</p><p><strong>48. Ohio State 31 — Michigan 20 (November 25, 2017)</strong><br>A surprisingly competitive game, considering Michigan’s QB was John O’Korn. Michigan might genuinely have won had JT Barrett not been injured. But when the greatest screen-pass thrower in college football history was replaced by future Heisman Finalist and 1st-Round Pick Dwayne Haskins, the game was essentially over.</p><p><strong>47. Indiana 38 — Michigan 21 (November 7, 2020)</strong><br>Michael Penix’s Hoosiers rolled Michigan for Indiana’s first win over Michigan in like 50 years or something (I can’t remember the actual number and was too lazy to look it up). Indiana was a genuinely good team in 2020, and Michigan was terrible. Honestly, it’s kind of shocking Indiana only beat Harbaugh once given how tough they always played him. They deserved this one.</p><p><strong>46. Michigan 27 — Indiana 20 (October 14, 2017)</strong><br>Speaking of which…Indiana took Michigan into overtime in this one. It won’t be the last Michigan/Indiana OT game on this list.</p><p><strong>45. Michigan 34 — Maryland 27 (September 24, 2022)</strong><br>An underrated and entertaining game (especially for Michigan/Maryland). Maryland came out with a fantastic game plan on offense and put the Wolverines on their heels early. Michigan was able to pull away in 4th quarter, but this is one I remember watching with wayyy more nerves than I was expecting.</p><p><strong>44. Michigan 31 — Maryland 24 (November 18, 2023)</strong><br>Speaking of which…the most memorable Michigan/Maryland game of the Harbaugh era was this “trap” game, nestled between Penn State and Ohio State during Michigan’s 2023 National Championship run. Harbaugh was in the middle of serving his 3-game suspension, and Michigan let Maryland hang around despite taking an early lead. Maryland had the ball down 29–24 late in the 4th quarter with the chance to take the lead before a safety put the Terps away for good.</p><h3>Legitamately Memorable Games</h3><p><strong>43. Michigan 48 — Rutgers 42 (November 21, 2020)</strong><br>I don’t think I’ve ever felt more mixed emotions after watching a Michigan game. Sure, we beat Rutgers in Triple OT. On the flip side, it took us 3 OT’s to beat Rutgers. The most memorable thing about this game was Cade McNamara replacing Joe Milton as Michigan’s starting QB at halftime (what took them so long?). It would have been hard to believe at the time, but only a year later McNamera would help lead Michigan to their first Big 10 championship in 17 years.</p><p><strong>42. Michigan 24 — Army 21 (September 7, 2019)</strong><br>Ok scratch that, this one mixed my emotions even more. Michigan needed double OT to beat Army. Absolutely incredible. 2019 might have been the weirdest season of Harbaugh’s Michigan career, and this was probably the weirdest game of that season.</p><p><strong>41. Ohio State 56 — Michigan 27 (November 30, 2019)</strong><br>Michigan was in the middle of an up-and-down season and came in as underdogs. However, they were riding an impressive 4-game winning streak that included an absolute demolition of a Top-10 Notre Dame team. More importantly, I was there and Michigan had never lost a game with me in attendance. Hope was in the air. That hope quickly vanished with a couple of disgustingly beautiful Justin Fields deep balls (and a Quinn Nordin missed extra point). This is also where I’ll butt in and say that if Ryan Day had used Fields correctly, they would’ve won a Natty. But thankfully he didn’t and they didn’t.</p><p><strong>40. Michigan 45 — Colorado 28 (September 17, 2016)</strong><br>In my opinion, this was the most underrated game of the Harbaugh era. I remembered this being a widely entertaining and nerve-racking game, but I had forgotten just how close Colorado had come to upsetting us. The 2016 Buffs were actually a pretty good team, and quieted the Big House by taking a 21–7 lead in the first quarter. Unfortunately for Colorado, their QB sustained an injury early in the 2nd half and was never the same after that. Michigan cruised to a margin of victory that was not indicative of how much the #4 Wolverines were tested in this game.</p><p><strong>39. Michigan 41 — Florida 7 (January 1, 2016 — Citrus Bowl)</strong><br>The most dominant bowl performance from Michigan I can remember. This game was the perfect finish to a promising first season of the Harbaugh era, and one that planted hope for even better things in 2016. It seemed inconceivable that Harbaugh would fail to win a single Big 10 title or beat Ohio State once over the next 5 seasons.</p><p><strong>38. Iowa 14 — Michigan 13 (November 12, 2016)</strong><br>The first loss for Michigan in 2016 came on a last-second field goal in Kinnick Stadium. This game would probably rank higher, but it essentially didn’t matter for Michigan: as long as they could beat Ohio State two weeks later, they’d still win the Big 10 and probably go to the College Football Playoff. As weird as it sounds, this game ended up hurting Ohio State more: had Michigan won this game, the Buckeyes would have gone to the Big 10 Championship game instead of Penn State (the reasons for this are convoluted but this is true, feel free to fact check me). So I guess in a weird way this was the best loss of Jim Harbaugh’s career?</p><p><strong>37. Michigan 19 — Illinois 17 (November 19, 2022)</strong><br>Michigan needed a last-second field goal to win this game. Possibly even more important: Blake Corum went down with an injury that essentially sidelined him for the rest of the season. Much like the game above, it wouldn’t have mattered much if the outcome of this game had been different (Michigan would still have won the Big 10, gone to the College Football Playoff, and probably still played TCU). But this was the quintessential trap game, and was a nail-biter throughout.</p><p><strong>36. Wisconsin 35 — Michigan 14 (September 21, 2019)</strong><br>The Wisconsin game was an early-season measuring stick for Michigan during much of the Harbaugh era, and this game was no different. Michigan was coming off an extremely unimpressive win over Army, and this was their chance to steer the ship back on course. Instead, Wisconsin exposed Michigan on both offense and defense. Jonathan Taylor ran wild all day, finishing with over 200 yards. Michigan came into 2019 with fairly high expectations: they left this game completely shattered.</p><p><strong>35. Michigan 38 — Wisconsin 13 (October 13, 2018)</strong><br>As mentioned above, the Wisconsin game was often a measuring stick for Michigan, and this game reasserted the Wolverines as a true Big 10 Title contender after a down year in 2017. It was also the beginning of Chase Winnovich’s “Revenge Tour”: a 3-game stretch in which Michigan avenged 3 of their losses from the previous season.</p><p><strong>34. Michigan 42 — Penn State 7 (November 3, 2018)</strong><br>In the 3rd and final game of Michigan’s revenge tour, Michigan outclassed #14 Penn State in every way. The Nittany Lions scored a garbage-time touchdown with less than 2 minutes to go to avoid the shutout.</p><p><strong>33. Michigan 33 — Florida 17 (September 2, 2017)<br></strong>After a mostly successful but ultimately disappointing 2016 season, Michigan came into 2017 with a young but talented team and fairly low expectations. Although this game ended up being a mirage, it was a massive opening-game statement against a Florida team that ended up not being very good. I also thought Tarik Black was destined to become the next Braylon Edwards. Oh well.</p><p><strong>32. Penn State 42 — Michigan 13 (October 21, 2017)</strong><br>Penn State should’ve won the National Championship in 2017: that they didn’t might legitimately be the biggest stain on James Franklin’s legacy. This is probably the most watchable blowout loss I ever witnessed as a Michigan fan: everyone knew we were getting crushed, and honestly I was too in awe of Saquon Barkley for 60 minutes to actually feel upset about the pounding we were taking.</p><p><strong>31. Michigan 20 — Northwestern 17 (September 29, 2018)</strong><br>2018 Northwestern was a decent team that would go on to play in the Big 10 Championship game. In the first real test of the Shea Patterson era, the Wildcats went up 17–0 early in the 2nd quarter before Michigan’s defense clamped down. Karan Higdon basically put the offense on his back to give Michigan its first lead with just over 4 minutes left to play. A gutsy win against a gutsy Northwestern team.</p><p><strong>30. Georgia 34 — Michigan 11 (December 31, 2021 — CFB Playoff)</strong><br>After shocking the world by beating Ohio State and winning the Big 10 in the same season for the first time in 18 years, Michigan was just happy to be here. They were outclassed by a Bulldogs team that ended up winning the National Championship. Although the game itself was a complete disaster (and not even as close as the final score would indicate), it is memorable for being the first playoff game in the Jim Harbaugh era.</p><p><strong>29. Michigan State 27 — Michigan 24 (October 31, 2020)</strong><br>Michigan was riding high off their “Speed in Space” showcase win over Minnesota the week before. But when Big Brother gets cocky, it’s Little Brother’s chance to pounce. This game showed us that Speed in Space was a fraud, Joe Milton might not be the answer, and 2020 would be the longest 6-game season in Michigan football history.</p><p><strong>28. Michigan State 14 — Michigan 10 (October 7, 2017)</strong><br>I’m not sure if this should be titled “The Weather Game” or “The John O’Korn Game”. A downpour contributed to a sloppy game in which O’Korn threw 3 interceptions. In hindsight, the biggest loss of the season had been 2 weeks prior, when starting QB Wilton Speight went down with an injury. Although Speight wasn’t spectacular, O’Korn was probably the worst starting QB of the entire Harbaugh era. This was the ugliest game of Harbaugh’s 2nd ugliest season.</p><p><strong>27. Michigan 29 — Minnesota 26 (October 31, 2015)</strong><br>A back-and-forth game that ended with an <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N3Rxthn1PK0">epic goal-line stand on the 1-yard-line as time expired</a>.</p><p><strong>26. Michigan 43 — Purdue 22 (December 3rd, 2022 — Big 10 Championship)</strong><br>This ended up being the most entertaining Championship Game of Michigan’s 3-peat Big Ten title run. Granted, Michigan was clearly the better team and pulled away at the end. But Aiden O’Connell and Chuck Sizzle made enough splash plays to keep the Boilermakers competitive.</p><p><strong>25. Michigan 48 — Indiana 41 (November 14, 2015)</strong><br>Speaking of entertaining, back-and-forth games, this double OT thriller was the best of some wild Michigan/Indiana matchups during the Harbaugh era. Future NFL running back Jordan Howard racked up 236 yards on the ground as Indiana’s offense rolled. Unfortunately for them, Jake Rudock and Jehu Chesson connected for 207 yards of their own, including 4 TDs. The Harbaugh era at Michigan certainly wasn’t known for shootouts like this one, but the rules never seem to apply when facing the Hoosiers.</p><p><strong>24. Michigan 32 — Nebraska 29 (October 9, 2021)</strong><br>The quintessential Scott Frost game: Nebraska played up to a superior opponent <a href="https://www.espn.com/video/clip/_/id/32370227">only to lose at the end on some dumb mistake</a>. Michigan was coming off a big win against Wisconsin and seemed primed for a letdown. But unlike so many Harbaugh teams in the past, they weren’t going to let that happen. Also, <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xENenyFtevs">Hassan Haskins was a badddd man.</a></p><p><strong>23. Michigan 32 — Michigan State 23 (October 29, 2016)</strong><br>Although the undefeated Wolverines were heavily favored against the 2–6 Spartans, the records can be thrown out in this rivalry. Little Brother had won 3 in a row against Michigan, including a stunning last-second win the year before. Michigan was able to hold on to this one and finally got Little Brother off their back. <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vllcQZgJPXE">Jabril Peppers’ 2-point return with 1-second left</a> was both an exclamation point and a sigh of relief.</p><p><strong>22. Notre Dame 24 — Michigan 17 (September 1, 2018)<br></strong>Michigan/Notre Dame is a fake rivalry and I will die on this hill. Real rivals play more than twice in 9 years. That said, when these teams do face each other the resulting game is usually pretty memorable. The 2018 season opener was no exception. Notre Dame spoiled Shea Patterson’s Michigan debut, and we all began wondering if maybe the former 5-star wasn’t the savior after all.</p><p><strong>21. Michigan 45 — Notre Dame 14 (October 26, 2019)</strong><br>This might be the second-most surprising win of the Harbaugh era. And much like the first, Hassan Haskins led the way. Michigan was a really weird team in 2019 and had pretty much failed every big test they had been given. For whatever reason, this one turned out completely different. The Wolverines dominated the Irish in a torrential downpour en route to one of the most shockingly lopsided games I have ever seen.</p><p><strong>20. Michigan 14 — Wisconsin 7 (October 1, 2016)</strong><br>This game is memorable for two reasons. First, it was Jim Harbaugh’s first top-10 win as Head Coach of Michigan. Second, <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kwZwFfsr8YA">Jourdan Lewis’s spectacular interception</a> is arguably the most memorable play of Harbaugh’s entire Michigan tenure. The rest of this game was pretty boring (trust me, I was there), otherwise it would rank even higher.</p><p><strong>19. Michigan 41 — Penn State 17 (October 15, 2022)</strong><br>A Top-10 matchup that ended up not being very competitive. Michigan ran away with this one (literally) as both Blake Corum and Donovan Edwards ran for over 160 yards. This game proved beyond the shadow of a doubt that Michigan’s 2021 Big 10 Championship was no fluke.</p><p><strong>18. Penn State 28 — Michigan 21 (October 19, 2019)<br></strong>I remember watching this game in a bar in Philadelphia. Everyone else in the bar (including the bartenders) were against me. I almost thought of leaving early after Penn State took a 21–0 lead midway through the second quarter. It would’ve been less heartbreaking had Michigan just given up there. But instead, Shea Patterson and Michigan came storming back. The Wolverines had a chance to tie it at the end before Ronnie Bell let the game slip through his fingers (literally).</p><p><strong>17. Florida State 33 — Michigan 32 (December 30, 2016 — Orange Bowl)<br></strong>Speaking of heartbreak…this one played out eerily similar to the one above. FSU jumped out to a big lead early, but Michigan came storming back, actually taking a 30–27 lead with 2 minutes left. But the Wolverines allowed a big return on the ensuing kickoff, and the always-reliable Jourdan Lewis allowed the game-winning TD over his outstretched arms with only seconds left to play. I still can’t believe this happened! This game was a fitting ending to what was a promising but ultimately unfulfilling 2016 season.</p><p><strong>16. Michigan 38 — Wisconsin 17 (October 2, 2021)<br></strong>As mentioned above, early season Michigan/Wisconsin games were often a test of the Wolverines mettle throughout Jim Harbaugh’s tenure. This game was no different. Michigan not only passed their first test of the 2021 season, they blew out a good Wisconsin team in Camp Randall Stadium. Maybe this was finally the year…</p><p><strong>15. Michigan State 37 — Michigan 33 (October 30, 2021)</strong><br>…or not. A few weeks later, the Wolverines seemed to confirm everyone’s suspicions: sure, Michigan may have improved from their disastrous COVID-shortened season, but they were still pretenders in the rugged Big 10 East. The Wolverines blew a 30–14 lead as Kenneth Walker ran wild in the second half. Michigan was certainly destined for another 10-win season in which they wouldn’t find a way to beat their two biggest rivals…</p><p><strong>14. Michigan 21 — Penn State 17 (November 13, 2021)<br></strong>Michigan had found a way to lose 2 weeks earlier in East Lansing. This time they’d find a way to win. Down 17–14 with under 4 minutes to go, <a href="https://www.espn.com/video/clip/_/id/32621789">Cade McNamara found Erick All for a 47-yard touchdown</a> in what might have been the most crucial play in Jim Harbaugh’s entire Michigan career. Lose this one, and even a victory against Ohio State wouldn’t have led to a Big 10 Championship or a birth in the College Football Playoff. But the Wolverines lived to fight another day.</p><p><strong>13. Michigan 21 — Michigan State 7 (October 20, 2018)</strong><br>Jim Harbaugh’s first win on the road over a ranked team and the second game in the 2018 “Revenge Tour”. Devin Bush famously stomped on the Spartans logo which caused a brawl during pregame. This game also featured <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1DdpqPZuZ1c">Donovan Peoples-Jones’s iconic “Paul Bunyan” celebration after scoring a 79-yard touchdown</a> late in the 3rd quarter to break open what was up to that point a sloppy 7–7 contest.</p><p><strong>12. Ohio State 62 — Michigan 39 (November 24, 2018)<br></strong>For the first time in the Jim Harbaugh Era, Michigan was favored going into The Game against their archrival. This was finally the year! Instead, Ohio State exploited a weakness in Don Brown’s defense discovered the previous week by Indiana. Oh you’re going to blitz and play man coverage on every single play? We’ll just run crossing routes all day and put up 62 points. This game made it abundantly clear that Michigan needed to make some significant changes if they were ever going to beat their biggest rival. Either Harbaugh had to figure this thing out, or someone else would soon be coaching this team.</p><p><strong>11. Michigan 42 — Iowa 3 (December 4, 2021 — Big 10 Championship)</strong><br>The game itself was a complete snoozer. Everyone I was watching with was rooting against Michigan, but none of us could help making fun of Kirk Ferentz’s obsession with punting on 4th and short deep in Michigan territory. He played not to get blown out and got blown out. But no matter how lopsided the game was, we were going to enjoy it. This one was a long time coming. Also, <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K_xK-PCBVo8">Donovan Edwards&#39; TD pass</a> was incredible.</p><p><strong>10. Michigan 78 — Rutgers 0 (October 8, 2016)<br></strong>We all love Rutgers don’t we folks</p><h3>Instant Classics and Legendary Games</h3><p><strong>9. TCU 51 — Michigan 45 (December 31, 2022 — College Football Playoff)<br></strong>I don’t feel as bad about this game in hindsight as I did in the moment. Yes, Michigan was the better team and should’ve won. But let’s be real: the 2022 Wolverines were not equipped to beat Georgia. I really believe this game was crucial to JJ McCarthy’s development as a Quarterback: we knew he could throw for a lot of yards, but he needed to drastically reduce the turnovers if we were ever going to compete with the big boys in the SEC. And as many mistakes as Michigan made in this game, TCU played their hearts out and deserved to win. So hats off to them.</p><p><strong>8. Michigan 24 — Penn State 15 (November 11, 2023)<br></strong>I toyed with ranking this game even higher. Harbaugh finding out 30 minutes before the game that he was suspended? 30 straight running plays? The interim coach dropping the f-bomb multiple times on live TV? Like are you kidding me??? This game was awesome!</p><p><strong>7. Michigan 30 — Ohio State 24 (November 25, 2023)</strong><br>You might think this is too low, but honestly I never really expected OSU to win this game: Michigan was clearly the superior team this time around. Ohio State’s drive at the end would’ve been much scarier to me if CJ Stroud was still their QB and not Kyle McCord. I seriously considered ranking the Penn State game ahead of this one, but I thought I would never hear the end of it. So #7 seems about right. Also, <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1d5eBlNFhRE">the Zac Zinter moment was tragic but really cool at the same time</a>.</p><p><strong>6. Michigan 45 — Ohio State 23 (November 26, 2022)<br></strong>Michigan beating Ohio State the year before was clearly just a fluke. Now The Game was back in the Horseshoe, and Ohio State would get their revenge. At least, that was the narrative going in. The reality was much different. Ohio State made it clear they wouldn’t allow Michigan to bludgeon them at the line of scrimmage like they had the year before. And in previous years, crowding the line would’ve worked against the likes of John O’Korn or Joe Milton. But JJ McCarthy was different. Harbaugh chose him as the starter over Cade McNamara for games like this, and McCarthy delivered. And despite an otherwise mostly underwhelming career, <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JImnLGnlZGs">this game made “The Don” a Michigan legend</a>.</p><p><strong>5. Michigan 34 — Washington 13 (January 8, 2024 — National Championship)<br></strong>How could this not be #1??? A few reasons. First, the real National Championship was the week before in Pasadena. This game always felt like a coronation, and Washington didn’t do much to change that. Second, this was a pretty sloppy game by both teams. Michigan was clearly better, but they handed Washington several opportunities that the Huskies just never capitalized on. I’m a big Michael Penix fan, but he played probably the worst game of his college career. Of course, he was also being harassed by Michigan’s legendary D-Line all night. The game itself might have been anti-climatic, but since it was the Natty I couldn’t justify putting it any lower than this. Although I’ll probably remember <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=08KhD0joV-Q">Jack Harbaugh screaming into the microphone</a> more than anything from the actual game itself.</p><p><strong>4. Michigan State 27 — Michigan 23 (October 17, 2015)<br></strong>“Wow he has trouble with the snap…scooped up by Jalen Watts Jackson…and he SCOAOAORES (massive voice crack) on the LAST play of the game. UNBELIEVABLE!” I don’t really need to say much more, except that this list is not a list of my FAVORITE games, but the most memorable. And despite how hard we’ve all tried to forget this one, you know exactly where you were when this happened. This is my second-least favorite game of the Harbaugh era, but I believe to truly appreciate the good we must also remember the bad. So buckle up for this next one…</p><p><strong>3. Ohio State 30, Michigan 27 (November 26, 2016)<br></strong>Yea this one was the worst. JT was short. We all know JT was short. But the refs wanted to make it out of the stadium alive. Michigan was the better team, and we can (justifiably) blame the refs all we want. But at the end of the day, Michigan made too many mistakes to deserve to win this one. The pick-6? The fumbled snap at the goal line? And the play right before the infamous Spot, where we had Curtis Samuel 10 yards behind the line of scrimmage and allowed him to juke our entire defense to within inches of a first down? This was certainly the most painful game of the entire Harbaugh era, and arguably in Michigan football history. And it left a scar that could only be healed by finally giving the Buckeyes a taste of their own medicine. Little did we know this would take 5 long years…</p><p><strong>2. Michigan 27 — Alabama 20 (January 1, 2024)<br></strong>Maybe the most exciting college football game I’ve ever watched. JJ McCarthy and Blake Corum converted a 4th and 2 that I thought would certainly be the final play of their brilliant careers. But even when Roman Wilson skipped into the endzone to tie the game at 20–20, I still thought we’d find a way to blow it. That’s just what Michigan does after all! And blow it we almost did: I still have a hard time rewatching the muffed punt at the goal line that miraculously bounced inches outside the endzone. From there, <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0NBDegpbe90">it was Blake Corum time</a>, as he put the offense on his back in OT for an unforgettable 2-play TD drive. And the defense (and Alabama’s Center) <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nNKb4phfTXg">did what they had done all night to send Michigan to the National Championship</a>. As I mentioned previously, this felt like the real Natty. In previous years Michigan would have found a way to lose. But this group was different. This team was special.</p><p><strong>1. Michigan 42 — Ohio State 27 (November 27, 2021)</strong><br>“I can’t believe that just happened” was the text I got about 47 times in the aftermath of this game. And to be honest, I couldn’t either. Going into this one, there was nothing to suggest it would be any different than 2016 or 2018. In both those seasons, Michigan was a really good team with a disappointing loss before The Game. And each of those teams had found a way to lose to their archrival. It would be crazy to think this one would be any different. Yet for some reason it was. Perhaps it was the unrelenting motor of Aiden Hutchinson or Hassan Haskins’ nose for the goal line. Or maybe it was just Ryan Day. Whatever the reason, this game might genuinely be the most important win in the entire history of the Michigan Football program. Lose this one, and Harbaugh might not have stuck around. Lose this one, and you probably don’t win a National Championship 2 years later. But although Cade McNamara, Aiden Hutchinson, Hassan Haskins, and the other leaders of this team may never have won a National Championship, they might have done something even more important. They broke a mindset and culture of losing big games that had plagued this program for decades. And that’s just as impressive as anything the 2023 team accomplished. <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9ak9Uxtntfk">Cue Mr. Brightside</a>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=de148c4f202d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Top 10 Basketball Players of All Time]]></title>
            <link>https://calebrsmith95.medium.com/top-10-basketball-players-of-all-time-11269fe3c76f?source=rss-9c9c24667ada------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/11269fe3c76f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[basketball]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sports]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nba]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[goats]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Caleb Smith]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 16 Sep 2024 20:01:47 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-02-23T16:20:52.527Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>#1 Will SHOCK You!</h4><p>Ok yea so I couldn’t help but put a clickbait title on this one. But I do think my GOAT is going to be a bit controversial to say the least (SPOILERS: it’s neither Jordan <em>nor</em> LeBron). And I’m not simply writing this to be controversial: I genuinely believe there’s a really obvious player that we’ve left out of the GOAT conversation for far too long, and we need to give him his due. But before revealing who I’m talking about, I thought it would be fun to do a Top 10 list. So without further ado, the 10 greatest basketball players of all time:</p><h4>Honorable Mentions</h4><p>There are 5 players I wanted to make sure to mention before diving into my top 10. One active player <em>just</em> missed the cut for me:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/0*v21z2Qf1XtmylfDo" /><figcaption>AP photo by David Zalubowski via <a href="https://www.timesfreepress.com/news/2024/may/08/nikola-jokic-is-nba-mvp-again-hamilton-heights/">Chatanooga Times Free Press</a></figcaption></figure><p>11. <strong>Nikola Jokic (2015- ):</strong> I really should have called this the “Top 11 Basketball Players of All Time”, but no one reads “Top 11” lists. So instead, the Joker is my first honorable mention. I firmly believe he’ll be in the Top 10 by the end of his career, but I had a tough time putting someone there who’s spent less than a decade in the Association. Still, he’s been on a historic offensive stretch over the last 4 years, winning MVP in 3 of those seasons and an NBA Championship in the other. At this point he’s the undisputed “Best Player in the World” (although Luka Doncic and potentially Victor Wembanyama are quickly coming for that title). He’s the 2nd best offensive center in NBA history (more on #1 later), the best passing big man of all time (and arguably a Top 10 passer <em>regardless</em> of position), and one of the best rebounders in the league. And although he is far from the league’s highest volume scorer, he’s easily its most efficient, with an eFG% of over 60% in each of the last 4 seasons.¹ Unless he retires in the next couple of seasons to focus on ponies, he’s pretty much a lock to finish his career in my Top 10. He’s already the greatest European basketball player ever.</p><ul><li><strong>Moses Malone (1974–1995):</strong> In my opinion, Moses is one of the most underrated players in NBA history. Although he’s not in my Top 10, he’s close. And I rarely hear his name discussed among the other greats on this list. He is, by a wide margin, the greatest offensive rebounder ever. He is the only player in NBA history to average over 7 ORBs in a season, and he did it twice. He averaged over 6 ORBs in 2 other seasons, <a href="https://www.statmuse.com/nba/ask/who-has-the-most-offensive-rebounds-per-game-in-a-season">giving him 4 of the top 5 offensive rebounding seasons of all time</a>. <a href="https://www.basketball-reference.com/leaders/orb_career.html">His 7,382 career ORBs are by far the most ever, with 2nd place Artis Gilmore a full 2,500 behind him at 4,812</a>. Although Moses was never an elite post player, it didn’t matter: <a href="https://www.basketball-reference.com/players/m/malonmo01.html">he finished his career averaging over 20 points per game</a>, in large part due to the sheer number of rebounds he was getting on the offensive end. And he wasn’t a bad defensive rebounder either: he led the league in total rebounds 6 times. He also won 3 regular season MVPs, and in 1983 won both regular season and Finals MVP. Each of the 9 players with at least 3 MVPs are at least an honorable mention, but of these 9, Moses is the one I see the least on other people’s lists. That disrespect needs to end.</li><li><strong>Karl Malone (1985–2004):</strong> NBA GOAT debates typically revolve around 3 things: peak, longevity, and championships. For instance, Nikola Jokic certainly has a Top 10 peak in NBA history, but his lack of longevity keeps him just outside that discussion for me. Karl (somehow no relation to Moses) Malone is the polar opposite. Much has been made of his failure to win a championship, and there was no point in his career where he was even in consideration as the Best Player in the World. But as far as longevity goes, he’s one of the Top 5 players ever. He’s still the 3rd leading scorer in NBA history (up until recently he was #2, before an obvious member of my Top 10 passed him). He’s also the 7th leading rebounder in NBA history, won 2 MVP’s, and was first-team all-NBA an astounding 11 times in a row. He’s not a Top 10 player of all time, but he’s damn close.²</li></ul><h4>Notable Omissions</h4><p>There are 2 more guys I did not consider for my Top 10, but who I need to mention. These are 2 guys I routinely see on other people’s Top 10 lists, but who simply do not belong in this discussion. I want to make it clear that I am not trying to disrespect these 2 players (both of whom are all-time greats in their own rights), but rather the sports media apparatus that consistently overate them. These 2 guys are:</p><ul><li><strong>Tim Duncan (1997–2016):</strong> Duncan is solidly a Top 20 player ever, and is in the discussion for the greatest defensive player in NBA history. He also won 5 NBA Championships. So how could he not make my Top 10? A few reasons. First of all, as I’ll continue reiterating throughout this list, not all Championships are created equal. Robert Horry won 7, but was never close to being the best player on any of those teams. Duncan won 5, and was the best player on 4 of those teams, clearly making him a better all-time player than Horry. But he was NEVER the best player in the world at any point in his career, which is something that can’t be said about most of the guys in my Top 10. He also didn’t make a single All-NBA first-team (or even score 20 PPG in a season!) during the entire second half of his career. And while he was a good offensive player, he was never a dominant one. As anyone willing to be honest about the NBA knows, being an elite offensive player trumps being an elite defender every day of the week (which is why I already consider Jokic to be a better player than Duncan). None of this is said to disrespect Duncan, or to take away from his incredible list of accomplishments. Again, he’s easily a Top 20 player in my opinion. But I personally can’t justify putting someone who was never the best player in the world, and who averaged less than 20 PPG for his career, in my Top 10.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*yqPBv2wkasG78TMr.JPG" /><figcaption>Image from <a href="https://www.google.com/url?sa=i&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.usatoday.com%2Fstory%2Fsports%2Fnba%2Fspurs%2F2021%2F05%2F11%2Ftim-duncan-best-forwards-he-wont-tell-you%2F5035526001%2F&amp;psig=AOvVaw2Xg_n__1UQf7kobqiz7GqR&amp;ust=1726602720717000&amp;source=images&amp;cd=vfe&amp;opi=89978449&amp;ved=0CBQQjRxqFwoTCNDzjsGeyIgDFQAAAAAdAAAAABAJ">USA Today</a></figcaption></figure><ul><li><strong>Bill Russell (1956–1969):</strong> Russell’s career is a more extreme version of Duncan’s, which in my mind makes him the most overrated player in NBA history. Much like Duncan, he is arguably the greatest defensive player of all time. He is also the 2nd leading rebounder in NBA history, and he won a staggering 11 Championships! How could he not be in my Top 10? Here’s why: because, unlike even Duncan, Russell wasn’t a good offensive player, or even a mediocre one: he was a genuine liability on the offensive end of the court. Russell was never the leading scorer on any team he played for. In fact, he routinely finished 3rd or 4th on his own team in PPG. And this is despite playing over 42 minutes a game for his career, far more than any of his teammates. He also never shot better than 46% from the floor. People will defend him by saying it was more difficult to score in the era he played in, but then proceed to downplay the gargantuan and efficient scoring numbers of another player from his era (more on him later). Here’s the facts about Russell: he is one of the greatest rebounders and defenders in NBA history. He was also a crucial member of a dynasty that won an astounding 11 NBA championships in his 13-year career. But he also played on what was, <em>by far</em>, the most stacked dynasty in NBA history. The Steph/KD Warriors had the 2nd and 3rd best players in the league, as well as a couple other guys who were borderline top-20. We all acknowledge how unfair that team was in comparison to the rest of the league. But if Bill Russell was indeed the 2nd best player of his era (in my opinion guys like Oscar Robertson and Jerry West push him to 4th or 5th), he was teammates with 5 or 6 guys who were also in the Top 10-to-15. And despite winning 5 MVP’s, there is no legitimate argument that he was ever the best player in the world at any point in his career (MUCH more on that later). Would the Celtics of the 60’s have won 11 titles without Russell? Probably not. But they still might win 5 or 6. Russell’s rebounding and defense alone make him a Top 50 player ever, which shows just how dominant he was in those 2 categories. Again, none of this is meant as disrespect to a guy who was genuinely one of the greatest basketball players to ever live. But people who try to put him anywhere near the Top 10 because “hE’s GoT eLeVeN rInGs” simply don’t know anything about basketball.</li></ul><p>And now, the moment you’ve all been waiting for: the objective Top 10 basketball players of all time. I’m sure no one will have any disagreements with this list:</p><p>10. <strong>Hakeem Olajuwon (1984–2002):</strong> Olajuwon is the third guy whose name gets thrown around as the greatest defender in NBA history, along with Duncan and Russell (there’s a 4th guy who should be given consideration here, but we’ll get to him later). And this is well earned: he won 2 Defensive Player of the Year awards, finished top-5 in voting 6 other times, and is the only player in NBA history to win Defensive Player of the Year, league MVP, and Finals MVP in the same season. He was also a better offensive player than Duncan (and MILES ahead of Russell). He finished his career averaging nearly 22 points per game, and was still averaging 20 into his mid 30’s. He led the Association in blocks 3 times, and finished his career with more than 3 per game. He’s the only player in NBA history with at least 200 blocks and 200 steals in the same season. So why is he only 10th on this list? Several reasons. First, he was only the undisputed “best player in the world” for 2 years of his career (and that was because an even greater player “retired” to play minor league baseball). Second, despite being an excellent scorer, he was not an all-time great offensive weapon, certainly not compared to the 9 guys ahead of him on this list.³ But this is only nitpicking a guy who is still one of the Top 10 basketball players ever, and someone who will always be rightfully considered an all-time great.</p><p>9. <strong>Kobe Bryant (1996–2016):</strong> First, let’s get this out of the way: Kobe has one of the most toxic fanbases of any player in basketball history. Despite putting him in my Top 10, many people will see it as disrespectful that I have Kobe this <em>low</em> on my list. Because of his insane fan base (and not because I want to disrespect Kobe), I have to clarify why he’s not in the same stratosphere as guys like Jordan or LeBron. First, we’ll look at ring count. Jordan has 6, Kobe has 5, LeBron (as of the time of this writing) has 4. So obviously Kobe is better than LeBron! Case closed, right? This type of dishonesty is why I can’t stand Kobe fans. When you look at how many rings each of these guys won as the best player on their teams, Kobe’s count drops to 2 (whereas LeBron’s and Jordan’s remain unchanged). Furthermore, when you look at rings won as the best player in the world, Kobe drops to 0 (again, LeBron’s and Jordan’s remain unchanged). Not all championships are created equal. I don’t understand why this is so difficult for people to grasp. The other major knock on Kobe is his efficiency stats. Kobe finished his career with an eFG of 48.2%, which is a mediocre number even for his era. Kobe missed <em>a lot</em> of shots. In some seasons, his teams were good enough to overcome this. In many others, they weren’t.</p><p>Despite these flaws, Kobe is still an all-time great. First, regardless of efficiency numbers, scoring 30 PPG in 3 separate seasons is incredibly impressive. Kobe won MVP in 2007; he should have won another in 2005 (when he averaged 35 PPG) but finished 4th behind Steve Nash, who is notoriously the worst player to ever win the award. So despite being a “Kobe hater”, I’m the first to acknowledge this as one of the biggest snubs in NBA history. Kobe was the greatest sidekick in basketball history, 3-peating with Shaq in the early 2000’s. While Shaq was this dynasty’s best player, he doesn’t 3-peat without Kobe. When Shaq left, Kobe became arguably the best player in the world for a few years, but couldn’t win a championship without his big man. By the end of the decade, Kobe was no longer the best player in the world (this was now LeBron), but he was the clear #2 and won back-to-back titles to close the decade. While his stretch of being the best player in the world during the mid-2000’s was short-lived (being sandwiched between the Shaq and LeBron eras), he’s still probably the player of the decade when looking at his overall body of work. He was an elite defender, one of the greatest volume scorers in basketball history, a 5-time champion, and one of the fiercest competitors of all time. Overall, this was more than enough for me to include him in my Top 10.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/896/0*FmQi8gkUG_DLXv36" /><figcaption>RIP Kobe and Gianna (image from FREDERIC J. BROWN/AFP via <a href="https://www.foxnews.com/sports/kobe-bryant-mural-near-lakers-arena-kept-landlord-ordered-removal">Fox News</a>)</figcaption></figure><p>8. <strong>Steph Curry (2009- ):</strong> This one is really going to piss Kobe fans off. Steph is the greatest shooter in baskeball history, and arguably the most lethal offensive weapon the game has ever seen. He was the best player on 4 championship teams. This might be a controversial statement since he only has 1 Finals MVP, but I believe this is misleading. First, I think everyone acknowledges he should have won the award in 2015 over Iguodala (the only other guy with an argument at this award was LeBron, but if we accept the tradition that Finals MVP should go to the best player on the winning team, there’s no argument for anyone but Steph). Second, while it&#39;s true that Durant won back-to-back Finals MVPs, I always considered Curry the more valuable player on those teams. Yes, KD might have scored more points during those title runs, but this was due to the constant attention teams had to pay to Steph. To back up my argument with numbers, Steph’s efficiency numbers (specifically eFG%) have been similar throughout his career, whether or not he was playing alongside KD. Meanwhile, KD’s efficiency numbers increased while playing with Steph. This signals to me that teams were picking their poison and choosing to continue guarding Steph, while allowing KD (a Top 20 all-time player in his own right) to shoot open shots and score more points than his teammate. If you want to disagree with this analysis, fine. But this is my list not yours.</p><p>The only 2 knocks on Steph are his defense, and the fact that (much like Kobe) he was overshadowed for most of his career by another all-time great player. Even in 2015/2016, the season when many people thought he might have passed LeBron as Best Player in the World, his team stumbled in the finals to a far inferior Cavs team. That season pretty much shut the door on the notion of Steph as the Best Player in the World, a title that everyone above him on this list held for multiple seasons. As far as defense goes, he was an underrated player for the majority of his career. While the present-day 36-year-old Steph is a genuinely bad defender, Prime Steph was more-than-adequate, and even led the Association in steals in 2015. While it’s certainly true that he was never elite, he was a better defensive player than he gets credit for during his first 3 championship runs. He also has a career eFG of 58.2%, an astonishing number for a high-volume guard and a full 10 percentage points ahead of Kobe. He has changed the game in a way few (if any) players before him have. It&#39;s crazy to think Steph was the first scoring champion in NBA history to shoot more 3s than 2s in a season, something that is now commonplace in today’s NBA. Because of a culmination of all these factors, Steph lands at 8 on my list.</p><p>7. <strong>Shaquille O’Neal (1992–2011):</strong> Shaq is the first player on this list who was the undisputed Best Player in the World for several years of his career, which is why he lands here. From the minute Michael Jordan retired for a 2nd time in 1998, Shaq took this title, and held on to it until at least 2002 (and arguably up until 2004/05, when he finished 2nd in MVP voting to, you guessed it, Steve Nash⁴). He has 3 rings both as the best player on his team and in the world, and won a 4th as the sidekick to Dwyane Wade’s epic 2006 playoff run. He won a scoring title, finished his career averaging a double-double, and as of the writing of this article, has the same career eFG as Steph Curry (58.2%, which is kind of funny considering they got to these numbers in polar opposite ways). Because of this, many people consider Shaq “the most dominant Big Man of all time.” In my opinion, this isn’t quite correct. Much has been made of how incredible it is that Shaq is a Top 10 player ever, and was the Best Player in the World for half a decade, despite being notorious for not training in the offseason. He would routinely show up to training camp and preseason out of shape, <a href="https://sports.yahoo.com/shaquille-o-neal-claims-weighed-120042680.html">and even he admits he was over 400 pounds at different points in his career</a>. He was also a notoriously bad free-throw shooter, something that came back to bite his teams in the ass on numerous occasions. Because of this, I think a better moniker for Shaq would be “Most Talented Player Ever” (although Victor Wembanyama is already giving him a run for his money). I think the reason people don’t use this description for Shaq more often is they don’t consider size as being part of a player’s “talent”, which is ridiculous.⁵ There’s a legitimate argument to be made that Shaq would have been the GOAT had he taken his training more seriously. But this list doesn’t grade players on potential, it grades them on accomplishments and success. And despite not working very hard, Shaq’s accomplishments and success still make him the 7th Greatest Basketball Player ever.</p><p><strong>5 Magic Johnson (1979–1991, 1995–1996) and Larry Bird (1979–1992):</strong> These 2 players’ careers are inseparable. Is it cheating to rank them both as the 5th best players ever? Perhaps. But it’s my list so you’ll have to deal with it. The 1980’s were one of the most unique decades in NBA history: instead of having 1 player who transcended the sport, it had 2. I don’t consider it a knock that neither was ever the undisputed Best Player in the World, since without the existence of the other guy either of them would have easily held this title for a decade. The 2 of them combined to win 8 of the 10 Finals in the 1980’s (only a historic season by Moses Malone in 1983 and the first of back-to-back titles by the Bad Boy Pistons in 1989 kept this from being a clean sweep). In many ways, Bird and Magic were polar opposites; in other ways they were exactly the same. Magic might have been black while Bird was white, but both grew up in poor working-class families in the Midwest. Both took their local State Universities to the NCAA championship game in 1979 (with Magic’s Michigan State Spartans beating Bird’s Indiana State Sycamores 75–64). Both went to storied and iconic NBA franchises, with Bird being drafted by the East Coast Celtics and Johnson by the West Coast Los Angeles Lakers. Each embodied their respective cities: Bird fit in perfectly with gritty, hard-nosed, rough around-the-edges, blue-collar Bostonians; while Johnson (whose real first name is “Ervin”) became “Magic” in the showbiz capital of the world. Magic was arguably the greatest passer of all time, while Bird was the world’s greatest shooter (at least until Steph Curry came around). This was despite both players standing at 6&#39;9&quot;, far taller than any “passers” or “shooters” that came before them. Both left a lasting impact on the game, and are credited as being the duo that “saved” basketball after a decline in popularity during the 70’s. For a long time I went back and forth on who to place at 5 and who to bump to 6, but I ultimately decided I couldn’t separate these 2 all-time legends.⁶</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*SDdj3R-FpA_-2TxJ.jpg" /><figcaption>Magic and Bird</figcaption></figure><p>4. <strong>Kareem Abdul-Jabbar (1969–1989):</strong> This is probably going to be the first true eyebrow-raiser on this list. For many people who aren’t Kobe fanboys, Kareem is the consensus #3 basketball player in history. Let me again be clear: ranking Kareem 1 spot below the consensus is not meant to be disrespectful toward Kareem. Until very recently, he was the all-time leading scorer in NBA history. He won 6 MVP’s, which is still the most ever. He averaged almost 25 PPG over his 20 seasons, and shot a remarkably efficient 55.9% for his career. He is the 3rd leading rebounder in NBA history, behind only Bill Russell and He That Has Yet to be Named. Although he’s not quite in the same league defensively as Russell, Duncan, or Hakeem, he still led the league in blocks 4 times. His skyhook was the most feared shot in basketball history, and is still probably the most iconic of all time. He won 6 NBA Titles, including 2 Finals MVPs. He was the undisputed Best Player in the World for practically the entire decade of the 70s. So why isn’t he higher? There’s a few things that keep me from moving Kareem into the Top 3. For one, as hinted above, he wasn’t the best player on several of his Finals runs (he teamed up with Magic Johnson in the 80’s, and for most of that time Magic was the better player). He also only managed to win 1 Finals in the 70s despite being head and shoulders above his competition. For a long time, he had a case as the GOAT simply based on longevity. But he has since lost that argument to another player, and he’s never been in the discussion for greatest peak. Kareem is solidly the 4th best basketball player ever, but despite his greatness, there’s 3 guys I consider to be unquestionably better.</p><h4>GOATS</h4><p>The 3 remaining players all have legitimate GOAT cases. We all have opinions on who the real GOAT is, but before I get to mine, let me just say that the only crazy people in this debate are the people who think any of these guys are WAY better than the others. Anyone who thinks the debate between LeBron and Jordan (or the 3rd player I have extensively hinted at) is over and that one is <em>clearly</em> better than the other is wrong. All 3 guys have legitimate arguments for being #1. I will do my best to clearly state each of these arguments, and which ones I tend to put more weight into. Without further ado, the 3 Greatest Basketball Players of all Time:</p><p>3. <strong>LeBron James (2003- ):</strong> As I stated in my write-up on Karl Malone, the 3 main criteria in the GOAT debate are typically longevity, peak, and championships. And as far as longevity is concerned, LeBron is the undisputed GOAT. He’s the Association’s all-time leading scorer, with over 40,000 points during his career. He’s also the only player with more than 10,000 assists <em>and</em> 10,000 rebounds. He’s a player with no real weakness: he’s an elite scorer and passer, excellent defender, good rebounder and shot blocker, and even has the 8th most steals in NBA history! He’s also an efficient scorer, with a career eFG of 54.7%. He’s even become one of the game’s best 3-point shooters in the twilight of his career. And maybe most importantly, he held the unofficial title of World’s Best Player for well over a decade. If you want to argue that he’s the GOAT for these reasons, I won’t push back.</p><p>However, LeBron is “only” #3 on my list, so I need to list the arguments against him. The most obvious is his peak. And while it was an incredible peak, there’s no question the peaks of the 2 guys ahead of him were even better. The tiebreaker for me comes down to his 4 championships, and specifically his failure to win more with the Miami Heat. As I have previously stated, not all championships are created equal. HOWEVER, it is what breaks the tie between Jordan and LeBron. And it&#39;s not simply because 6 &gt; 4, but rather the context of these championships. I hold nothing against LeBron for not winning one during his first stint in Cleveland. In many ways, this portion of his career was nearly identical to the beginning of Jordan’s: both became the Best Player in the World almost immediately, but failed to win any championships due to the failure of their front offices in giving them any help. I also don’t fault LeBron for only winning 1 in his 2nd stint with the Cavs since he ran into a Warriors dynasty that was <em>far</em> better than any team Jordan ever played (and yes Jordan fans, this is objectively true. Jordan would not have single-handedly beaten the Steph and KD Warriors). In fact, in my opinion, LeBron’s playoff run that led the Cavs to the 2016 Title was more impressive than any of the individual playoff runs Michael made in the 90’s. But the one stain on LeBron’s legacy that I cannot overlook is his 4-year stint with the Heat. Let me reiterate: not all championships are created equal. This is why, to me, LeBron’s 2016 Title with the Cavs (and even his “Mickey Mouse” ring with the Lakers in 2020)⁷ was more impressive than both of his championships in Miami combined. Michael was not a perfect playoff performer as many of his fans claim, but he certainly never had a performance as embarrassing as LeBron’s during Miami’s 2011 loss to Dallas. LeBron was supposed to be the best player in the world, but in that series he wasn’t even the best player on his own team. Because of how poorly LeBron played, the Heat lost to an inferior Mavericks team, and Dirk Nowitzki (who is another legend but nowhere near my Top 10) made LeBron his bitch. To me, this is the tiebreaker that pushed Jordan over LeBron. Despite several disagreements I have with Jordan fans, he doesn’t have any blemishes on his career as large as this. In a debate this close, I can’t overlook that.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/749/0*CkCJSku3c-eVwiUq.jpg" /><figcaption>The Block (image from <a href="https://www.wsj.com/articles/lebrons-block-for-the-ages-didnt-come-from-nowhere-1466451986">Wall Street Journal</a>)</figcaption></figure><p>2. <strong>Michael Jordan (1984–1993, 1994–1998, 2001–2003):</strong> Now that I’ve pissed off LeBron’s entire fanbase, it’s time to piss off Jordan’s. I agree with you all that Jordan is better than LeBron, but your fanbase <em>still</em> pisses me off more than his. The “6–0 vs. 4–6 in the Finals” argument is stupid: as LeBron fans correctly like to point out, making the Finals only to lose is obviously better than not making the Finals at all; anyone arguing otherwise is delusional. There’s also this aura of invincibility around Michael Jordan that makes you all feel as if there’s <em>nothing</em> any player could ever do to pass Jordan in the GOAT discussion (even if they were to do something absurd like average 50 PPG in a season <em>HINT HINT</em>). And finally (and this is not brought up nearly enough), his decision to retire in the prime of his career to play Minor League Baseball is one of the stupidest decisions any athlete has <em>ever</em> made. We don’t make fun of him nearly enough for this. This guy’s a fucking idiot. People like to pretend he won 8 Championships in a row because of this. Would he have? Honestly, I think so. But he didn’t. Much like Shaq and Bird, hypotheticals don’t count. Michael would probably be #1 on my list had he won 8 in a row. But he didn’t. So let’s be clear: Michael was neither perfect nor invincible. He was a human being after all. But at times he seemed as close as was humanly possible.</p><p>Michael’s GOAT case is pretty straightforward. Much like LeBron and Kareem, Michael was the undisputed Best Player in the World for over a decade. Unlike Kareem or LeBron, however, he won 6 championships during his prime (as a reminder, Kareem wasn’t the Best Player in the World for the majority of his). Michael is (by a hair) Professional Basketball’s all-time leading per-game scorer, with 30.1 PPG for his career. He won 10 scoring titles in 12 years, and that’s only because, again, he made the worst decision in professional sports history by choosing to play baseball during the other 2 seasons. He has 5 MVP’s, 6 Final’s MVP’s, 10 All-NBA First Team selections, 8 Defensive First Team selections (as well as a DPOY in 1987), and has the 4th most Steals Per Game ever. Only one player has averaged more points in a season than Jordan’s 37.1 in 1986 (and trust me, we’ll get to him). When compared to LeBron, there’s no question Jordan had a higher peak (just as there’s no question LeBron has had more longevity). Again, the tiebreaker for me is Jordan taking full advantage of every Finals opportunity he had, whereas LeBron (despite me not counting his Cavs losses against him) did not. For me, that’s enough to make Jordan my #2.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*8cckGtQxRMyb3-Ot" /><figcaption>Arguably the most legendary shot in NBA history (image from <a href="https://www.hoopsbasket.com/blogs/hoops-basketball/michael-jordans-final-shot">hoopbasket.com</a>)</figcaption></figure><p><strong>1.Wilt Chamberlain (1959–1973):</strong> And finally, my biggest basketball (and potentially sports) hot take: neither LeBron <em>nor</em> Jordan is the Greatest Of All Time. In my opinion, the real GOAT (and <em>by far</em> the game’s most underrated player) is Wilton Norman Chamberlain. The amount of mental gymnastics people do around this man’s career is exhausting. As I mentioned earlier, only one player has ever averaged more points than Michael Jordan in 1986. The catch: Wilt did it <em>4 times</em>. In 1959, Wilt’s <em>rookie season</em>, he averaged 37.6 PPG. Had he retired after one year, that would still be the record. Thankfully, Minor League Baseball was not in his plans. He followed up this historic season by averaging 38.4 the next. Then in 1961, he did what no player had ever done before (and possibly will never do again): <em>he averaged over 50 points per game over an entire season</em>. Teams decided during his 4th season to finally put the clamps down on him defensively, and for the first time in his career, Wilt didn’t set the single-season scoring record, averaging a mere 44.8 PPG. By his 5th season he failed to even eclipse Jordan’s 1986 number, finishing with only 36.9 PPG. In short, below is the list of most PPG in a single season in NBA history:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/611/1*WscdelAyNLpQwW6GQIyPAw.jpeg" /><figcaption><a href="https://www.statmuse.com/nba/ask/who-has-the-highest-ppg-in-a-season">https://www.statmuse.com/nba/ask/who-has-the-highest-ppg-in-a-season</a></figcaption></figure><p>In the first 5 seasons of Wilt Chamberlain’s professional basketball career, he had (at that time) the 5 highest scoring seasons in NBA history. That’s a peak that not only tops Jordan’s, but blows him out of the water. And no, those rebounding numbers aren’t a misprint: Wilt is the NBA’s all-time leader in rebounding, finishing with a career average of just under 23 a game. While we’re at it, let’s take a look at the top 18 rebounding seasons in NBA history:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/518/1*h_9p-kkfc0xwnidKQopE4Q.jpeg" /><figcaption><a href="https://www.statmuse.com/nba/ask/highest-rebound-average-in-a-season">https://www.statmuse.com/nba/ask/highest-rebound-average-in-a-season</a></figcaption></figure><p>This of course finally brings us to the elephant in the room: Bill Russell. Of all the NBA GOAT lists I’ve seen, Michael is probably #1 about 60% of the time, and LeBron about 30%. Of the remaining 10%, the guy I most often see at #1 is Russell. This is because of the completely out-of-context “11 Championships” argument. Wilt only had 2. Case closed, right? Only if you’re willing to call Robert Horry a better player than Michael Jordan. <a href="https://stathead.com/basketball/vs/wilt-vs-bill-russell">Wilt is miles ahead of Russell in almost every statistical category</a>. Russell only tops Wilt in head-to-head wins (which is a team stat, not an individual one), free throw %, and MVP’s (which goes to show how biased people were against Wilt even back then, possibly stemming from the fact that <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3eVH5mFVbB4">he probably slept with at least half of their wives</a>). When playing against each other, <a href="https://www.news-herald.com/2022/07/31/rivals-dont-get-better-than-bill-russell-wilt-chamberlain-opinion/">Wilt averaged 30 points and 28 rebounds a game, Russell averaged 14 and 23</a>. If Russell hadn’t had far better teammates than Wilt throughout his career, this wouldn’t be a debate. Quite frankly, given this context, it still isn’t.</p><p>I could go on and on about Wilt. About whether the number “100” or “20,000” is more impressive. About how he was arguably the most dominant offensive AND defensive player of all time (DPOY wasn’t an award back then, and All-Defensive teams were just beginning to be selected, but Wilt had more selections than Russell). But I decided to leave you with this: in my opinion, the best season of Wilt’s career (and by extension, the best season in NBA history) wasn’t in 1961 when he averaged over 50 PPG, or even the year before when he set the single-season rebounding record while still averaging more PPG than any other player in history. In my estimation, Wilt’s best season came in 1966, when he averaged a “mere” 24.1 PPG. That season, Wilt won his 3rd MVP (somehow Russell won the award when Wilt averaged 50, because that year he scored an incredible 18.9 PPG, the highest of his career), and finally captured his first NBA title. In a season where Wilt finally had teammates that could match up with Russell’s, he showed the type of player he could have been his entire career if he and Russell had switched places. No longer having to carry the heaviest offensive load in NBA history, he was able to shoot an absurdly efficient 68.3% from the floor, still <em>by far</em> the best FG% by a player with more than 20 PPG in NBA history (even when using eFG, his 68.3% is still higher than the most efficient modern-day 20-point shooting performance: Nikola Jokic’s 66% in 2022). He also averaged 24 RPG, and finished 3rd in the league with 7.8 assists per game (he would go on to lead the league in total assists the next season, making him arguably the 2nd greatest passing big man in history behind Jokic). This means that as his career evolved, Wilt went from being the greatest volume scorer in NBA history to the Association&#39;s most efficient scorer ever, and one of its best passers. He would finish his career with the Lakers, winning another championship during a season where he shot nearly 73% from the floor (albeit while averaging 13 PPG), and becoming unquestionably the game’s most feared defender. If you want to argue that he’s not the GOAT because he played in a different era, fine. But literally every player on this list (except Magic/Bird and Jordan/Hakeem) played in different eras from each other player (although several other careers overlapped). If you want to argue this, the logical conclusion is that it&#39;s futile to compare any of these guys to each other in the first place. This may be true, but it&#39;s no fun. If we want to take part in GOAT conversations at all, Wilt needs to be near the top, and probably #1. Please let me know in the comments why I’m correct about this.</p><h4>Footnotes</h4><p>1: I am planning a future article about why eFG% is my favorite measure of offensive efficiency. For now, it’ll suffice to say that eFG% acknowledges that 3-point shots are worth more than 2-pointers, something traditional FG% fails to account for.</p><p>2: Much has also been made about how Karl Malone is a massive piece of shit. It’s basically obligatory to mention this any time his basketball career is discussed</p><p>3: It&#39;s for this reason that I fully expect Jokic to pass him on this list soon.</p><p>4: The fact that Steve Nash was not only the worst player to ever win MVP, but arguably had the 2 worst MVP seasons of all time is an absolute travesty. Kobe and Shaq should each have 2 MVP seasons, but instead Nash is the one with 2. Every single person who gave Nash a first-place vote in either of those seasons knows absolutely nothing about basketball and deserves to be fired.</p><p>5: Consequently, it irks me when people tell me Steph Curry is not a “talented” player, and simply got ahead through working harder than everyone else. While I don’t want to downplay Steph’s work ethic, it’s hard to take people seriously when they claim the son of an NBA player doesn’t have “talent”. I wrote much more about this <a href="https://medium.com/@calebsmith_87504/the-myth-of-getting-ahead-through-hard-work-df205b02881c">here</a>.</p><p>6: The only thing I’ll add here: I think Larry Bird might have become the GOAT had he played in today’s era where he was actually allowed to shoot 3s. BUT, hypotheticals are disqualified from these rankings (see also: if only Shaq had worked harder!!)</p><p>7: I tease, but let me be clear about something: it is ridiculous to claim that the Lakers title in the bubble was the “easiest” championship of all time. If this championship was so “easy”, why was only one team able to win it? I hope this question illustrates the absurdity of this claim.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=11269fe3c76f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Steelers All-Time 53 Man Roster]]></title>
            <link>https://calebrsmith95.medium.com/steelers-all-time-53-man-roster-f0ab7ae9e16d?source=rss-9c9c24667ada------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f0ab7ae9e16d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[nfl]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[football]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[steelers]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nfl-history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hall-of-fame]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Caleb Smith]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 08 Mar 2024 15:18:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-03-08T23:30:37.908Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The history of the NFL has always fascinated me, so what better way to spend Mount Rushmore Season™ than with a series of articles documenting (my take on) each NFL team’s all-time 53 man roster. Since the Steelers are my favorite, I’m starting with them. We’ll see how far I take this series, as it’s going to be a lot of work to do the research on the history of all 32 teams. Ideally, I would like to put all 32 teams into a single-elimination tournament to give my take on which franchise has the greatest all-time team. We’ll see if I ever get close to that.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/318/1*reYnIhTWAmPiztar6OuQGg.png" /></figure><p>I don’t have any strict criteria, other than my own superior intellect of course. At the end of the day, there is no objective way of comparing players from completely different eras. If you just look at the stats out of context, <a href="https://www.pro-football-reference.com/players/W/WilsZa00.htm">Zach Wilson</a> is a better QB than <a href="https://www.pro-football-reference.com/players/N/NamaJo00.htm">Joe Namath</a>. This of course doesn’t take into account the difference in rules, schematics, and even <a href="https://sports.yahoo.com/why-chiefs-len-dawson-was-smoking-at-halftime-of-super-bowl-i-and-how-it-became-immortalized-010008031.html?guccounter=1&amp;guce_referrer=aHR0cHM6Ly93d3cuZ29vZ2xlLmNvbS8&amp;guce_referrer_sig=AQAAALyY8WA6fgfR_zUJQ7sJ1GmH7_i881g3k_sG9VmAcCJ2doONAtBK7qJhhs2Z-AgzzuCcPJhXuOGufPfKKlCVxzFFiFxg3WUFgvDQqHbvZwvnfddU7Qsx0KTz2TWoQ24lNur4-F4VpoOAkDkmOV5HNVMeCOhe7C13AXDzLXiD4uO6">just how much the players actually cared</a>. Obviously at the same time, stats can’t just be completely discounted. In my opinion, the best way to compile a team like this is to make subjective comparisons of each player against guys from their era, then put their dominance (or lack thereof) into the perspective of the entire history of the league. Here’s an example to illustrate what I mean: many experts consider <a href="https://www.pro-football-reference.com/years/1984/passing.htm">Dan Marino’s 1984 season</a> the greatest season by a QB in NFL history. The difference between him and his peers that season was greater than the distance between any other QB and their peers in NFL history. So while <a href="https://www.pro-football-reference.com/years/2013/passing.htm">Peyton Manning’s 2013 season</a> is statistically better than Marino’s in just about every way, there were other QB’s that season closer to his level of production than anyone else was to Marino’s in 1984. Careers can be compared the same way: <a href="https://www.pro-football-reference.com/players/R/RomoTo00.htm">Tony Romo</a> had way better numbers than both <a href="https://www.pro-football-reference.com/players/S/StauRo00.htm">Roger Staubach</a> and <a href="https://www.pro-football-reference.com/players/A/AikmTr00.htm">Troy Aikman</a>, but few serious fans would therefore call Romo the greatest QB in Cowboys history.</p><p>The page I found most helpful in coming up with this team was <a href="https://www.pro-football-reference.com/teams/pit/all-pros.htm">this list of every Pro Bowler and 1st Team All Pro in Steeler’s history</a>. This is as good a list as any to rank the impact of the players throughout Steelers history! I came in with a pretty good understanding of who would be on this list, but there were still a few surprises along the way. Finally, I only counted what each player did as a member of the Steelers. So, while Michael Vick would’ve been a fun addition to this team, he clearly doesn’t deserve a spot based solely on his time in Pittsburgh.</p><h4>Quarterback (3)</h4><p><strong>Starter:</strong> Terry Bradshaw (1970–1983)<br><strong>Backups:</strong> Ben Roethlisberger (2004–2021), Bobby Layne (1958–1962)</p><p>This is the toughest choice on the entire list, and I went back and between Ben and Bradshaw. Ben has the better stats, but he played in a more passer-friendly era. Bradshaw has more championships, but “Rings” are not exclusively a QB stat. What put Bradshaw over the top for me was his league MVP in 1978, an award Ben never came close to winning. Bradshaw had a stretch in the late 70’s where he was arguably the League’s best QB. And while Big Ben was better for longer, there was never really a point during his career where he felt like the best passer in the NFL. Ultimately, I don’t think either choice is incorrect, and picking which first-ballot Hall-of-Famer to start is a good problem to have. While the gap between Ben and Bradshaw is razor thin, the gap between the 2nd and 3rd QB is massive. There were a bunch of guys I considered for this spot, including Kordell Stewart, Neil O’Donnell, and nobody (do you really <em>need</em> a 3rd string QB?). Ultimately, I settled on Layne, a Hall-of-Fame QB for the Detroit Lions in the 1950’s who spent the twilight of his career in Pittsburgh. Layne finished 3rd in MVP voting his first two years with the team, leading them to back-to-back winning seasons for the first time ever (a subtle reminder of how terrible the Steelers were before the 70s). Even though his career with the Lions was not considered here, he did enough during his Steelers tenure to deserve recognition.</p><h4>Running Backs (5)</h4><p><strong>Starters:</strong> Franco Harris (1972–1983), Jerome Bettis (1996–2005)<br><strong>Backups:</strong> John Henry Johnson (1960–1965), Barry Foster (1990–1994), Le’Veon Bell (2013–2017)</p><p>I thought it appropriate to start two RBs on a team known for smash-mouth football. Both Bettis and Harris are Hall of Famers, and guys who were faces of the franchise. Although Bettis has more career rushing yards than Harris, Harris is actually the Steelers all-time leading rusher, as Bettis spent the first few years of his career with the Rams. But both of these players are Steelers legends, and sitting either felt wrong. Once again, the gap between the top 2 and the rest is pretty large. Johnson deserves recognition as the only other Hall of Famer on this list, though only about half of his career was with Pittsburgh. Foster also deserves recognition as the man who still holds the Steelers single-season rushing record, with 1690 yards in 1992. Injuries cut an otherwise promising career short. Bell (the #4 leading rusher in franchise history) edges out Willie Parker (#3) for the last spot in this group. A case can be made for either player, but Bell’s peak was higher than Parker’s, with First-Team all-pro selections in 2014 and 2017, something Parker never achieved. Bell is also the best pass-catching RB in team history, and would be a valuable 3rd-down back for this squad.</p><h4>Wide Receivers (6)</h4><p><strong>Starters:</strong> Antonio Brown (2010–2018), Hines Ward (1998–2011)<br><strong>Backups:</strong> John Stallworth (1974–1987), Lynn Swann (1974–1982), Louis Lipps (1984–1991), Santonio Holmes (2006–2009)</p><p>This was the easiest group to pick. The first 5 guys on here are pretty clearly the 5 greatest receivers in Steelers history, and any of the the top 4 have arguments for starting. Swann was the easiest of the 4 to bench: despite being a Hall of Famer, his stats don’t stack up with the other 3. I went back and forth between Ward and Stallworth, but Ward is the Steelers all-time leader in every receiving category and has a trump-card that Stallworth doesn’t: his Super Bowl 40 MVP. But (<strong>TRIGGER WARNING</strong>) the best of this group is Brown, and by a pretty sizable margin. Before catching radioactive CTE, the man was on pace to be in the same conversation as Jerry Rice. He made 4 All-Pros, more than every other receiver in team history combined. You certainly don’t have to like him as a person, but no one on this squad played the position better than him.</p><p>Lipps is sometimes forgotten about in the team’s lost era of the 1980s, but he actually has more catches and receiving yards than Swann. He’s the 5th best WR in team history. I added Holmes for his return ability, plus his legendary playoff performance in 2008. This was capped off by his Super Bowl 43 MVP, which included <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oEoTvQJKhpE">one of the most memorable catches in the history of football</a>.</p><h4>Tight End (3)</h4><p><strong>Starter:</strong> Heath Miller (2005–2015)<br><strong>Backups:</strong> Elbie Nickel (1947–1957), Bennie Cunningham (1976–1985)</p><p>This is one of this squad’s weaker position groups, and I actually considered starting a 3rd WR (Stallworth) over any of these TE’s. But again, this is a team with a smashmouth identity, which made Miller a fan-favorite during his time in Pittsburgh. He’s the 4th leading receiver in team history and (arguably more importantly) was a tremendous blocker. So, while he’s not going to be a Hall-of-Famer like Stallworth or Swann, he’d be far better than either at opening lanes for The Bus and Franco. Nickel is the Steelers 7th All-Time leading receiver (behind Miller and the top 5 WRs), which is super impressive for a guy who played in the 40s and 50s. He’s actually closer to Miller than you might think, and gives this team flexibility to run plenty of 2 TE sets. Cunningham was the Steelers TE during the tail end of their dynasty in the 70s, and is the franchise’s 3rd leading TE in catches and receiving yards.</p><h4>Offensive Line (9)</h4><p><strong>Starters:</strong> Mike Webster (C, 1974–1988), Dermontti Dawson (C/G, 1988–2000), Alan Faneca (G, 1998–2007), Frank Varrichione (T, 1955–1960), Tunch Ilkin (T, 1980–1992)<br><strong>Backups:</strong> Maurkice Pouncey (C, 2010–2020), David DeCastro (G, 2012–2020), Jon Kolb (T, 1969–1981), Jeff Hartings (C, 2001–2006)</p><p>I cheated just a tad here. Technically, Dawson was a Center during his entire NFL career, but I wasn’t going to make the 2nd greatest lineman in team history a backup. I’m sure he’d be able to transition to guard without any issues. Mike Webster deserves that starting spot, as he is arguably the greatest Center in NFL history. Faneca is yet another Hall-of-Famer along the interior of the offensive line.</p><p>Things get interesting after this, since Pittsburgh has never really had an elite offensive tackle during their entire history as a franchise. Pouncey is probably the 4th greatest lineman in Steelers history, but it was too much of a stretch for me to move a center all the way over to tackle. Varrichione is probably not a household name among Steelers fans today, but he went to 4 Pro Bowls during his 6 years with the team. He’s the best offensive tackle in team history. The late Tunch Ilkin is more fondly remembered in Pittsburgh as a legendary radio announcer, but he wasn’t a bad player either, making back-to-back Pro Bowls in 1988–89. That’s enough to give him the starting nod at a lack-luster position group. As for the other reserves, I went with Decastro (who was a 2-time All Pro in the mid 2010&#39;s), Kolb (the starting left tackle on 4 Super Bowl winning teams), and Hartings (another center who, despite only spending 6 years with the team, went to 2 Pro Bowls and was an All-Pro in 2004).</p><h4>Defensive Line (8)</h4><p><strong>Starters:</strong> Joe Greene (T, 1969–1981), Ernie Stautner (T, 1950–1963), LC Greenwood (E, 1969–1981), Cam Heyward (E, 2011-present)<br><strong>Backups:</strong> Ernie Holmes (T, 1972–1977), Dwight White (E, 1971–1980), Casey Hampton (NT, 2001–2012), Kevin Greene (DE/OLB, 1993–1995)</p><p>We finally come to the defense, and no franchise can boast more star power on this side of the ball. All 3 levels of this squad are elite and stacked with Hall of Famers. This team could easily run either a 4–3 or 3–4 base defense. I like to think they could switch off between both. Joe Greene is arguably the greatest defensive tackle ever (he was considered the consensus #1 until Aaron Donald came along). His first overall selection in 1969 is considered the first step in building the Steelers 1970’s Dynasty. Stautner is the greatest pre-Super Bowl Era player in team history, and the first Hall-of-Famer to spend his entire career with the Steelers. Both his and Greene’s number are retired by the franchise. Greenwood is currently one of the Hall’s biggest snubs. The 6-time Pro Bowler and 2-time All Pro was the 2nd greatest member of the Steelers legendary “Steel Curtain”.¹ I added the remaining two members, Ernie Holmes and Dwight White, as reserves. The final starter is Heyward, the reigning Walter Payton Man of the Year and a 3-time All Pro. He may also be destined for the Hall of Fame someday. My other reserves are Hampton (arguably the best run-stuffing nose tackle of his era), and Hall-of-Famer Kevin Greene (who was technically a 3–4 outside linebacker during his 3-year Steelers tenure, but was a 4–3 end at other times during his career). He could play either position on this squad.</p><h4>Linebackers (8)</h4><p><strong>Starters:</strong> Jack Lambert (MLB, 1974–1984), Jack Ham (OLB, 1971–1982), TJ Watt (OLB, 2017-Present)<br><strong>Backups:</strong> James Harrison (OLB, 2002–2012, 2014–2017), Greg Lloyd (OLB, 1988–1997), Andy Russell (LB, 1963–1976), Dale Dodrill (LB, 1951–1959), Levon Kirkland (MLB, 1992–2000)</p><p>This might be my hottest take on the whole list: if TJ Watt stays healthy, he’ll be the greatest linebacker in Steelers history. Yes, the Jacks are both Hall of Famers and two of the greatest to ever do it, but TJ is on another level. In fact, he’s on track to be in the argument with Joe Greene as the greatest Steelers defensive player ever, period. He’s already won one DPOY, and probably should have had 2 more under his belt. Lambert also won DPOY in 1976, and Ham was an All-Pro 6 years in a row from 1974–1979. This is as good of a starting 3 as it gets. Harrison was my 3rd starter until Watt recently overtook him. His peak was short, but it included DPOY in 2008 and <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nUTXpxNA9BI">one of the greatest plays in Super Bowl history</a>. He might not be destined for the Hall like the 3, but he is a Steelers legend nonetheless.</p><p>Lloyd and Kirkland were two of the best linebackers in the league during the 1990’s and were the leaders of some great defenses. Had they played with a Hall of Fame QB, they might have won a Super Bowl and been remembered in the same way as the guys above them. Andy Russell was perhaps the greatest Steeler of the 1960s, and started on the franchise’s first two Super Bowl teams. Dodrill was one of the few players I didn’t know before compiling this list, but he made 4 Pro Bowls in the 50s and was an All-Pro in 1954. This is an absolutely stacked position group, and guys like Jason Gildon, Joey Porter, and James Farrior (who would start for some other franchises’ All-Time teams) didn’t even make the cut.</p><h4>Secondary (8)</h4><p><strong>Starters:</strong> Mel Blount (CB, 1970–1983), Rod Woodson (CB, 1987–1996), Troy Polamalu (S, 2003–2014), Jack Butler (S/CB, 1951–1959)<br><strong>Backups:</strong> Donnie Shell (S, 1974–1987), Minkah Fitzpatrick (S, 2019-present), Carnell Lake (CB/S, 1989–1998), Mike Wagner (S, 1971–1980)</p><p>Despite the embarrassment of riches at LB, secondary might actually be the best position group on this team. Five of these guys were Hall-of-Famers, so needs to come off the bench! Blount was so dominant <a href="https://steelersdepot.com/2022/09/implementation-of-mel-blount-rule-in-1978-was-a-bit-insulting-for-steelers-star-defensive-back/">they named a rule after him</a>. He’s the Steelers all-time leader in INTs and was DPOY in 1975. Woodson was the greatest Steeler of the 90s and has an argument to be considered the greatest CB of all time. Although he didn’t spend his entire career in Pittsburgh, this is where he played the bulk of his prime, including his 1993 DPOY. Polamalu is the third DPOY in this group, winning the honor in 2010. He was arguably the greatest Strong Safety in the history of the league, and might have <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UL8diqVaEY0">the most impressive highlight reel of any defensive player ever</a>. The last starting spot was a toss-up. I initially had Hall-of-Famer Donnie Shell starting alongside Polamalu, and he’s certainly deserving, winning 4 Super Bowls and being named a First-Team All-Pro 3 times. But when I looked at fellow Hall-of-Famer Jack Butler’s stats, I was blown away. Butler and Shell have similar career INT numbers (52 and 51, respectively), but Butler accomplished this in nearly 100 fewer games! And he might have won a DPOY himself in 1957 had the award existed (it wasn’t given out until 1971). That season, he led the league with 10 INTs. A horrific injury cut his career short in 1959 or he would easily be the team’s all-time leader too. Butler played both corner and safety during his 9 year career, allowing this squad to put 5 HOF’s on the field in their nickel package.</p><p>As for the other 3: Fitzpatrick is still just 27, but it’s not difficult to envision him joining the first 5 in the Hall of Fame someday. He already has 3 First-Team All-Pro selections in his first 5 years with the team. Lake was Woodson’s teammate in the 90’s and made 4 Pro Bowls in a row with the team from 1994–1997. Mike Wagner rounds out an unbelievably stacked defense as the safety who started next to Shell in the 70s. He made back-to-back Pro Bowls in 1975–76.</p><h4>Special Teams (3)</h4><p>Kicker: Gary Anderson (1982–1994)<br>Punter: Bobby Walden (1968–1977) <br>Utility: Jerry Shipkey (1948–1952)<br>Kick Returner: Rod Woodson<br>Punt Returner: Santonio Holmes</p><p>Anderson is the Steelers all-time leading scorer and the 3rd leading scorer in NFL history. Though he only spent about half of his career with Pittsburgh, he’s the best kicker in team history. Walden spent 10 years with the Steelers and won 2 Super Bowls (yes, Super Bowls are primarily a Punter stat). He’s widely considered <a href="https://www.nfl.com/photos/all-time-team-pittsburgh-steelers-0ap2000000334977#fc5a44b4-c3b2-428a-8c64-3a52b8d9102d">the best punter in team history by people who care about such things</a>. Finally, I had to include Shipkey somewhere on this team. He’s another guy I didn’t know about before researching for this article, but he was too fun to leave off. Shipkey did a little bit of everything for the Steelers in the late 40s and early 50s, playing fullback, defensive back, and linebacker. He was an All-Pro 2 seasons in a row in 1951–52. I thought his versatility would make him the perfect Special Teams ace for this team. As for the returners, Woodson is the team’s all-time leader in kick return yards, while <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8Vt4letHiJc">Holmes had a punt return TD as part of his legendary 2008 playoff run</a>.</p><h4>Coach: Chuck Noll (1969–1991)</h4><p>Noll is the winningest coach in Steelers history and set the standard for all that came after him. He was hired by a perennial loser and turned them into one of the greatest dynasties in NFL history, winning 4 Super Bowls in 6 seasons from 1974–1979. Tomlin will pass Noll in wins within the next couple seasons, but has a long way to go before passing him as the greatest coach in team history. The standard may be the standard, but for now that standard is Chuck Noll.</p><h4>Footnotes</h4><p>1: Contrary to popular belief, the “Steel Curtain” didn’t initially refer to the entire Steelers defense, but to their devastating front 4 of Greene, Greenwood, Ernie Holmes, and Dwight White.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f0ab7ae9e16d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Do Away with Conferences in Every Sport]]></title>
            <link>https://calebrsmith95.medium.com/do-away-with-conferences-in-every-sport-d76a23fb0db8?source=rss-9c9c24667ada------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d76a23fb0db8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[nba]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nfl]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nhl]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mlb]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sports]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Caleb Smith]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 26 Apr 2023 21:17:21 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-02-06T20:23:57.921Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><a href="https://vault.si.com/vault/1995/11/13/downand-out-citing-his-crushing-debts-art-modell-is-taking-his-browns-to-baltimore">In 1995, Cleveland Browns owner Art Model announced his team was moving to Baltimore</a>. The news came as a shock to the entire NFL world, as the Browns were one of the most storied and popular franchises in the league (as the article linked above describes, even through recent struggles the team still had the 4th highest attendance in the league). Win or lose, Cleveland fans were loyal to their Browns. As a demonstration of this loyalty, fans <a href="https://www.si.com/nfl/2015/11/06/cleveland-browns-fans-react-move-baltimore#gid=ci0255844320052580&amp;pid=1995-1105-cleveland-browns-fan-signs-gettyimages-294814_masterjpg">protested</a> and even <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20121104145105/http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1P2-863689.html">sued</a> to keep their team. One of the most interesting of these protests was <a href="https://www.baltimoresun.com/news/bs-xpm-1995-11-14-1995318109-story.html">held in Pittsburgh</a>, where their bitter rival Steelers played. In a rare show of solidarity, Steelers and Browns fans protested side by side to keep the team in Cleveland. Steelers’ owner Dan Rooney (<a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/sports/1996/02/10/owners-approve-move-of-nfl-team-to-baltimore/62005513-0215-46f0-9236-2eefbaae9583/">one of only 2 owners who voted to block the Brown’s relocation</a>), <a href="https://www.baltimoresun.com/news/bs-xpm-1995-11-14-1995318109-story.html">put into words what many Pittsburgh fans were feeling that day</a>: “I’m just sick about it. That killed [the rivalry]. Pittsburgh-Baltimore won’t be anywhere near the same. Even if [Cleveland] gets a new team, it won’t be the same as this one.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*qObhO_vqPdxUXYsfXdKAMw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Cleveland fans protest owner Art Modell’s announcement that the Browns would be leaving Cleveland (image from Brian Bahr/Getty Images via <a href="https://www.si.com/nfl/2015/11/06/cleveland-browns-fans-react-move-baltimore#gid=ci0255844320052580&amp;pid=1995-1119-cleveland-browns-fan-signs-gettyimages-72317875_masterjpg">Sports Illustrated</a>)</figcaption></figure><p>Rooney‘s second prediction ended up being absolutely correct. When Cleveland got an expansion team in 1999 (also called the “Browns”), they quickly became the laughingstock of the NFL, and their rivalry with Pittsburgh has been extremely one-sided since. So one-sided that, <a href="https://www.wkyc.com/article/sports/nfl/browns/baker-mayfield-browns-firstenergy-stadium-record/95-e7be5b14-06ec-45cf-b8cb-0fd179d6316e">until 2020, Ben Roethlisberger of the Steelers had more wins than any other QB in Cleveland’s new stadium</a> (more than every Browns QB until Baker Mayfield). Since ‘99, <a href="https://www.statmuse.com/nfl/ask/browns-vs-steelers-record-since-1999">the Steelers boast a 40–11–1 record against the Browns</a>.</p><p>However, Rooney couldn’t have been more wrong about his first conjecture. Since 1996, the Baltimore Ravens took the place of the old Browns as the Steelers’ biggest rival. Unlike Browns/Steelers, the Ravens/Steelers rivalry has been remarkably even. Since the move to Baltimore, the Steelers hold a slight 30–24 advantage over the Ravens. During that time span, both teams have won two Super Bowls. The rivalry <a href="https://bleacherreport.com/articles/2486606-the-best-rivalries-in-the-nfl-today#slide9">(considered by some as the best in the NFL</a>) features two teams <a href="https://www.espn.com/nfl/playoffs2008/columns/story?columnist=garber_greg&amp;page=HotRead18/Ravens-Steelers">known for their physical, defense-first mentality</a>. They are also division rivals. Since the 2002 division realignment, <a href="http://www.nationalchamps.net/Helmet_Project/ch_afcc.htm">the two teams have combined to win 17 of 23 AFC North titles</a> (the Browns have 0).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*0Tzd4gUk3HjvtYwg.jpg" /><figcaption>Troy Polamalu score the game-clinching touchdown against the Ravens in the 2009 AFC Championship game (image from the <a href="https://www.post-gazette.com/sports/joe-starkey/2021/08/04/pittsburgh-steelers-troy-polamalu-greatest-play-Heinz-Field-history-joe-starkey/stories/202108040084">Pittsburgh Post-Gazette</a>)</figcaption></figure><p>The climax of this rivalry occurred on January 18th, 2009. For the first time in the rivalry’s history, the teams squared off in the AFC Championship game. Like any good Ravens/Steelers matchup, the game was a snowy, defensive slug-fest. With just over 4 minutes to play, Pittsburgh clung to a 16–14 lead, but Baltimore had the ball. <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xy-4TPin4qk">On 3rd down, Ravens’ rookie QB Joe Flacco dropped back and fired a pass that was intercepted by Hall of Fame safety Troy Polamalu</a>. Polamalu weaved through defenders for what felt like an eternity before finally crossing the goal line, giving the Steelers the decisive score in a 23–14 classic. It was fitting that in a game filled with defensive Hall of Famers on both sides, the final touchdown was scored on defense.</p><p>As a 13-year-old Steelers fan watching this game in 2009, I was thrilled with the outcome. But looking back, I can’t help but be somewhat disappointed at its implication. The Steelers would go on to win an all-time classic Super Bowl against the Arizona Cardinals, but that game couldn’t top the satisfaction of beating Baltimore 2 weeks earlier. While the rivals may someday play a game that matches the 2009 one in intensity and significance, under the current system they will never play one that tops it. This is because the NFL is currently split into conferences: the AFC and NFC. These conferences are a hold-over from when professional football was 2 separate leagues: the National Football League (NFL) and the American Football League (AFL). The NFL has been the dominant league since the early 1920’s, but in 1960 the upstart AFL started siphoning off their fans, players, and money. The two leagues agreed to have their 1966 champions play in a “Super Bowl” to determine the best team in professional football. Just a few years later, the two leagues combined, with most of the NFL’s teams forming the new National Football Conference (NFC), and the AFL teams moving to the American Football Conference (AFC). Ever since, each conference has sent one team to the Super Bowl to determine the NFL Champion.</p><p>But why should we keep this system? Football is a brutal sport in which teams cannot play enough games to face off against every other team, so DIVISIONS are needed to organize schedules and provide coherent criteria for making the playoffs. But CONFERENCES serve no actual purpose. On the contrary, they restrict certain matchups from being played on the sport’s biggest stage. Under the current system, the Steelers and Ravens will never face off in the Super Bowl. Neither will the Bears and Packers, the NFL’s oldest rivalry. The four TV-ratings machines in the NFC East (Dallas, Washington, Philadelphia, and the New York Giants) will have to settle for only ever getting 1 team into the country’s biggest sporting event. And the list goes on.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/660/0*lXBOHi5ZC_J5h_B_" /><figcaption>The Yankees and Red Sox are a perfect example of two historic, bitter rivals that cannot play each other for a championship due to arbitrary conference distinctions (image from Barry Chin, AP, via <a href="https://www.northjersey.com/story/sports/mlb/yankees/2019/07/25/new-york-yankees-boston-red-sox-al-east/1824318001/">USA Today</a>)</figcaption></figure><p>And this doesn’t just apply to the NFL! The NHL and NBA face the same problem, where Toronto and Montreal can never face off in the Stanley Cup, and Brooklyn and New York can never play in a “Subway Series” NBA Finals. Major League Baseball was a bit different until recently, because the American and National League had slightly different rules (such as the use of a designated hitter) and a bit more autonomy than conferences in other American sports. <a href="https://www.sportingnews.com/us/mlb/news/mlb-universal-dh-national-league-pitchers-hitting-2022/r1kbh2jzlpsxrydqqmkqonwq">That all changed in 2022, when the NL officially adopted the DH</a>. There is no reason we can’t see a Yankees-Red Sox World Series except for a blind adherence to tradition. It’s time for every league to abolish conferences once and for all, and open up the possibility of new matchups that players and fans would love.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d76a23fb0db8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Using Game Theory to Solve NHL Overtime]]></title>
            <link>https://calebrsmith95.medium.com/using-game-theory-to-solve-nhl-overtime-9ff1ce4b13ec?source=rss-9c9c24667ada------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9ff1ce4b13ec</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[statistics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sports-statistics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[game-theory]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nhl]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hockey]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Caleb Smith]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 07 Mar 2023 02:01:14 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-04-27T18:27:30.452Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I’ll be the first one to admit I’m not a hockey fan. I’ve seen my hometown Pittsburgh Penguins win 3 Stanley Cups in my lifetime, but have probably only watched 10 to 15 full hockey games over that entire stretch. By contrast, my college roommate (we’ll call him “Brad”) was the biggest Pens fan I’ve ever met. We occasionally liked to argue about whether basketball or hockey was better (this seems to be a common debate as the two seasons coincide with each other, but the two sports are about as diametrically opposed as is possible¹). Both the NBA and NHL had 30 teams at the time (the NHL has since added 2 expansion teams), and both leagues played 82 game seasons in which the top 8 teams from each conference (16 teams overall, or just over half of the teams in each league) made the playoffs. This system typically lends itself to a few teams with losing records making the playoffs. One day, we had a discussion that went something like this:</p><blockquote>Brad: “I don’t like how the NBA seems to have teams with losing records in the playoffs each year.”</blockquote><blockquote>Me: “I kind of agree, but the NHL usually does as well.”</blockquote><blockquote>Brad: “The NHL almost never has teams with losing records make the playoffs! What are you talking about?”</blockquote><blockquote>Me: “The overtime loss is a loss Brad. A team that’s 37–35–10 has a losing record. When you count the final column as a loss, there’s often losing teams in the NHL playoffs.”</blockquote><p>If you’re not familiar with hockey, let me briefly explain what I’m talking about. Similar to soccer (or “football” if you live across the pond), the NHL has a point system² to determine the final regular season standings. On its face, I have no issue with this system. Both soccer and hockey are relatively low-scoring sports with lots of tie games at the end of regulation. In most soccer leagues, if a game ends in a tie (or “draw” if you continue to insist on being a snob), both teams get one point added to their season standings. If it doesn’t, the winning team gets 3 points and the loser gets nothing. At the end of the season, the team with the most points is crowned champion. I think this is a good system. Normally, a game is worth a total of 3 points, but a tie game only counts as 2.³ This means a tie is considered closer to a loss than a win, which incentivizes teams to take some risks at the end of games. If two evenly matched teams play each other twice, it’s better for them each to win and lose once (and each get 3 points) than to tie twice (and each only get 2).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*mXG7NrqiFxTrhxGdRv0fxw.jpeg" /><figcaption>In 2005, the NHL added the shootout as the final way to determine the outcome of a game. Before this, games not decided after 1 OT period would simply end in ties (photo is thumbnail of video from <a href="https://www.nhl.com/video/oshies-shootout-goal/t-277350912/c-40923003">NHL.com</a>)</figcaption></figure><p>Ties used to exist in hockey as well, but in 2005 the NHL decided to get rid of them. I also don’t have an issue with this. In most American sports, ties don’t exist (or very rarely occur, like in football⁴). If the NHL had decided to do away with the point system and simply keep track of wins and losses, I wouldn’t be writing this article. But for some reason, the league insisted on keeping the point system in tact, and kept a relic no hockey fan has been able to explain to me since: the “overtime loss.” In this system, a team receives 2 points if they win a game and 0 if they lose. At the end of regulation, instead of ending the game if the teams are tied, the game goes into overtime. So far so good. Now comes the inexplicable part: in the OT period, the team that wins still receives 2 points, but the loser gets 1 point instead of nothing. On the surface, this may not seem ridiculous. After all, losing a close game in overtime is certainly not as bad as getting blown out in regulation. Why not reward teams for playing close? Here’s the problem: it incentivizes teams to take games into overtime. If 2 evenly matched teams split two games in regulation, each team gets 2 points. But, if they make a pact to go into OT in both games, both teams GET 2 POINTS NO MATTER WHAT. Even if one team loses both games, they still end up with 2 points. And if the teams split in overtime instead of regulation, each team will now have 3 points to add to their season total. This is because regulation games are worth a total of 2 points, but overtime games are worth 3. A point is created for OT games out of thin air, making them more valuable than games that end in regulation.</p><p>As a statistician interested in game theory, I found this to be an interesting opportunity to determine if (and when) teams should intentionally go into overtime. According to game theory, each participant⁵ in a game acts “rationally” to maximize the value of their utility.⁶ In hockey, utility is measured in “points.” I need to mention this because the arguments I’ve heard against this type of agreement are not “rational” in an economic sense. For instance, the idea that hockey players are competitive and have too much respect for the game to not try during regulation might be true, but it’s not “rational.” What is rational from the perspective of game theory is maximizing the number of points earned by the team at the end of the season, as this is how you advance to the playoffs and get the chance to compete for a championship.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Bze_FYrM08eNQDyF2A7-Hg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Florida and Colorado play in different conferences; therefore, they don’t compete with each other for a playoff spot at the end of the season (photo from <a href="https://www.nhl.com/avalanche/news/colorado-falls-in-florida/c-327088612">NHL.com</a>)</figcaption></figure><p>There is, however, one rational argument against intentionally taking games into OT: it gives the other team a point you may not want them to have. After all, the value of points are relative, not absolute. There is no number of points that guarantees a spot in the playoffs (unless you literally win every game). In the 2016/17 season, <a href="https://www.hockey-reference.com/leagues/NHL_2017_standings.html">94 points was enough to make the playoffs in the Western Conference</a>, but <a href="https://www.hockey-reference.com/leagues/NHL_2018_standings.html">it wasn’t enough to make it the next year</a>. This means giving away a free OT point to a rival might not be such a good idea, as this could allow them to pass your team in the standings at the end of the year.</p><p>And this brings us to the cherry on top: the organization of teams into “conferences.” All major American sports do this, and <a href="https://medium.com/@calebsmith_87504/do-away-with-conferences-in-every-sport-d76a23fb0db8">I have written an entire article about why this system should be abolished</a>, but my main gripe is that teams only compete with half the league for playoff spots. In the NHL, these conferences are divided by East and West. Since exactly 8 teams make it from each conference, this means Eastern teams (such as Boston and Montreal) aren’t competing with Western teams (like Vancouver and Los Angeles) for playoff spots. In <a href="https://www.hockey-reference.com/leagues/NHL_2018_standings.html">2017/18</a>, the Florida Panthers missed the playoffs with 96 points, while the Colorado Avalanche made it with 95. This is because Florida is in the Eastern Conference, while Colorado plays in the West. Had Florida given Colorado an additional point by allowing them to go into overtime, it wouldn’t have mattered. Even though both teams would now have 96 points, it would have no bearing on Florida’s playoff chances, since the teams play in opposite conferences. Therefore, when playing a team from the other conference, YOU DON’T CARE ABOUT GIVING AWAY FREE POINTS, because it can’t come back to bite you at the end of the season.</p><p>With all that context out of the way, it’s time to use statistical analysis to determine how often teams should agree to intentionally take games into overtime.⁷ I won’t go into too much technical detail in this article, but if you are interested in a full explanation of my work you can find it <a href="https://github.com/caleb-smith-95/NHL-OT/blob/main/Analysis.ipynb">here</a>. Basically, I simulated thousands of hockey games to calculate the number of points “Team A” is expected to earn after playing “Team B”.⁸ I ran enough simulations that every NHL team from 2006–2022 (except from the COVID-shortened 2021 season) can be plugged in for either Team A or B. The heatmap below shows how many points Team A is projected to earn in a game against Team B, based on the expected final score of that game:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/972/1*wArWaJj9_PTQxSCNSxw6PA.png" /><figcaption>As should be expected, a game in the bottom right corner (where Team A is expected to win 5–1) results in about 2 expected points for Team A, while a game in the top left (where Team A is expected to lose 5–1) predicts Team A to get about 0. Every simulated score falls between 0 points (Team A is projected to lose every game) and 2 points (Team A is projected to win every game). For instance, if Team A is expected to tie Team B 3–3 in regulation, they are projected to earn about 1.1 points per game. This accounts for the 2 teams splitting the games that end in regulation (receiving an expected 1 point), plus an additional 0.1 points picked up when these teams go into overtime. Note that this heatmap assumes when teams do go into OT, it is not intentional.</figcaption></figure><p>Because NHL overtime is so much different and less predictable than regulation,⁹ I assumed once OT is reached each team has a 50/50 shot at winning the game. This means when a game goes into OT, each team is expected to earn 1.5 points.¹⁰ Therefore, Team A should agree to take a game into OT if and only if they would normally be expected to earn fewer than 1.5 points in a game against Team B (assuming the teams play in different conferences). This roughly corresponds to the bright orange and yellow areas of the above heatmap. One flaw of this visualization, however, is it does not account for number of games expected to fall within each score. Although about 25% of the heatmap is yellow (signifying a game in which Team A is expected to pick up at least 1.5 points), far fewer than 25% of actual games fall within that section, since these yellow spots constitute very high scores (the heatmap doesn’t realize that no teams are expected to score 5 goals, whereas several are expected to score 3). A histogram is needed to visualize the actual distribution of goals each team is expected to score per game:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/972/1*GxYTL4MRebTm8fsy8-UaVg.png" /></figure><p>Practically every team since 2006 has scored between 2 and 4 goals per game. Therefore, the vast majority of actual games fall somewhere in the middle of the heatmap. Since this section of the map is mostly purple and dark orange, very few teams are expected to pick up more than 1.5 points in a game. But how few? This is the final question that needs to be answered. I combined my simulations with real-life data to determine which historical teams should actually try to win a non-conference game in regulation. To do this, I sorted each team by conference and year, and found which teams were expected to gain at least 1.5 points against a specific opponent. Below is the full list of these matchups:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/787/1*UuCHQ7cjZqw6PPWakirQZA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Since 2006, only 8 matchups were so lopsided that one team was expected to pick up at least 1.5 points. By contrast, 3,664 non-conference matchups were NOT this lopsided. This means that, in the rational world predicted by game theory, 99.8% (!!!) of non-conference games should be taken into overtime for teams to maximize their chances of making the playoffs.¹¹</p><p>The concept of the overtime loss is something I’ve found troubling for awhile now. The perverse incentives it creates become apparent when digging just below the surface. The question of which teams should tank in regulation to secure a spot in OT has intrigued me for close to a decade, but I’ve finally gotten around to analyzing this question from a statistical perspective, and the results are even more drastic than I thought. If over 99% of non-conference games should result in the teams agreeing to not try in regulation, there’s a flaw in the system. Clearly, players and coaches have not caught on to this, as not nearly this many matchups actually go to OT. The reasons for this are probably varied, but I think it ultimately comes down to a flaw in Game Theory itself: we don’t live in a “rational” world in which players and coaches have no egos. It is also almost certain that the NHL would crack down if they caught wind of teams fixing games. So despite my analysis, I’m not naive enough to conclude the number of non-conference games going into OT will ever approach 99%.¹² What I will conclude, however, are two things:</p><ol><li>Stats and Game Theory are fun, and can be used to solve a variety of interesting problems</li><li>I have mathematically proven that receiving points for overtime losses is dumb</li></ol><h4>Footnotes</h4><p>1: Watch <a href="https://www.vox.com/videos/2017/6/5/15740632/luck-skill-sports">this video</a> for an explanation of why hockey and basketball are considered polar opposites</p><p>2: In many American sports, “points” are used to describe the scores of individual games (for instance, the Chiefs scored 38 points in the Super Bowl). By contrast, hockey uses the word “points” to tally wins, losses, and OT losses over the course of the season. To avoid confusion, I will only use the word “points” to describe this season-long tally and “goals” to describe scores in an individual game</p><p>3: Each team gets 1 point for the tie, 1 + 1 = 2. Otherwise, one team gets 3 points and the other gets zero, 3 + 0 = 3</p><p>4: Even in American Football, fans absolutely despise ties despite usually occurring only once or twice across the entire league in any given year</p><p>5: In this case, the participant is the “team” rather than the “player”, since hockey is a team sport</p><p>6: The way “rationality” is understood in classical economics is (in my opinion) suspect to say the least. This, however, is a topic for another article (or more likely, series of articles). For now, we will understand rationality as classical economists do: utility maximization</p><p>7: The mechanics of this agreement can be left up to the imagination. I’d imagine the easiest way would be to have every player on both teams just sit on the ice for 60 minutes waiting for the game to end in a scoreless tie, but of course there are many (potentially funnier and more entertaining) other ways to do this as well</p><p>8: The range of expected points is between 0 (meaning Team A is never expected to win) to 2 (meaning team A is expected to win every time)</p><p>9: NHL overtime consists of a 5-minute period of 3-on-3 hockey, followed by (if necessary) a shootout. This is opposed to regulation, in which most of the game is spent playing 5–on-5</p><p>10: The calculations for both teams are the same. There is a 50% chance of winning and receiving 2 points, and there is a 50% chance of losing and receiving 1. (0.5 x 1) + (0.5 x 2) = 1.5</p><p>11: Since 2006, there have been 3,672 potential matchups between Eastern and Western Conference teams. The full work for determining this can be found in Git, but I’ll run through the basic logic here. For most of the seasons between 2006 and 2022, there have been 15 teams in each conference. This means there are 225 potential matchups between non-conference teams per year (15x15 = 225). Multiply by the total number of seasons in that span (16), and you are left with 3600. The remaining 72 matchups come from conference realignment and the addition of expansion teams that have happened in that time-frame. Since only 8 of these matchups end with one team expected to earn at least 1.5 points, 8/3672 (or 0.2%) of teams should try to win in regulation</p><p>12: Ironically, I’m not “rational” enough to conclude this either. In the mind of a classical economist, human beings are rational, therefore 99% of NHL non-conference games should be going into OT. As someone who subscribes to the behavioral theory of economics, I have no problem calling something both “rational” and “stupid” at the same time</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9ff1ce4b13ec" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Impact of Age on NFL Player Performance: Inflation (Part 6)]]></title>
            <link>https://calebrsmith95.medium.com/impact-of-age-on-nfl-player-performance-inflation-part-6-140cb53edf0f?source=rss-9c9c24667ada------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/140cb53edf0f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[nfl]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[statistics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[football]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sports-analytics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[data-science]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Caleb Smith]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 03 May 2022 19:13:51 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-05-05T21:57:47.070Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Jameis Winston was not the first Quarterback to lead the NFL in both passing yards and interceptions. In fact, Fran Tarkenton’s 1978 season was arguably crazier than Winston’s 2019. Like Winston, Tarkenton threw more passes (572) and yards (3468) than any other Quarterback, while simultaneously throwing over 30 interceptions (32 to be precise). In the first season after the Mel Blount Rule, the 38-year-old Tarkenton threw over 3000 yards for only the second time in his 18-year career. These numbers are underwhelming by today’s standards, but Tarkenton’s Hall of Fame career was anything but. In fact, he retired after the 1978 season with <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_National_Football_League_career_passing_yards_leaders">more passing yards than any player in NFL history</a>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/400/1*bfmgnzj_SaTwo-6G2GcNyw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Fran Tarkenton retired with 47,003 passing yards, a record the wasn’t broken until 19 years later (Photo by Focus on Sport/Getty Images)</figcaption></figure><p>Tarkenton’s 3468 passing yards in his final season were the most of his Hall of Fame career. This past season, 18 players surpassed this mark. Guys like Jimmy Garoppolo and Ryan Tannehill were among those who bested the highest total of one of the greatest Quarterbacks ever. This demonstrates just how much the NFL has changed over time. Changes in rules, strategy, and number of games are among the factors that led to the explosion in passing yards that we see today. In an attempt to put the careers of players like Tarkenton into perspective, I’ve borrowed a concept from economics: inflation.</p><p>One of the most famous applications of inflation adjustment is movie revenue. <a href="https://editorial.rottentomatoes.com/article/highest-grossing-movies-all-time/">Every single one of the 50 highest grossing films of all time has been released since 1993</a>. Included in this list are all-time classics like “Minions” and “Transformers: Age of Extinction.” Meanwhile, “Gone with the Wind” and “Star Wars” are nowhere to be found. This is because of inflation. $1 in 1939, when “Gone with the Wind” was released, <a href="https://www.bls.gov/data/inflation_calculator.htm">was the equivalent of almost $20 in 2021</a>. For it to have grossed the $773 million revenue achieved by the 2021 movie “Spiderman: No Way Home”, it would have needed to be 20 times more popular! To make an apples to apples comparison of these films, economists adjust these numbers by inflation. After doing so, <a href="https://www.imdb.com/list/ls026442468/">“Gone with the Wind” and “Star Wars” retake their spots as top 10 box office hits of all time</a>, while “Minions” is no longer anywhere to be found.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/278/1*BkbCe1bOWodtHH3NSO56VA.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/259/1*K8Q6wqm6QNEn_ZNEkDtI-g.png" /><figcaption>Although “Minions” almost tripled “Gone With the Wind’s” earnings at the box office, the latter is the highest grossing movie ever when adjusted for inflation.</figcaption></figure><p>I believe this same adjustment can be used to compare NFL players from different eras. Although “inflation” in the NFL isn’t quite as linear as its economic counterpart, there are definite trends in the data. As discussed in <a href="https://medium.com/@calebsmith_87504/impact-of-age-on-nfl-player-performance-efficiency-stats-part-5-e6d39d4a2109">Part 5</a>, efficiency stats tend to be a better indicator of performance than counting stats. To that end, I will be analyzing the effect of inflation on each of the efficiency stats previously discussed. The full analysis can be found <a href="https://github.com/caleb-smith-95/dmp2022/blob/main/EDA/EDA%204%20-%20Inflation.ipynb">here</a>, but for now I will highlight just a few interesting findings:</p><h4>Yards per Carry</h4><p>A lot has already been made about the explosion of NFL passing stats, both in my articles and the larger NFL community. I was therefore unsurprised to discover that passing efficiency stats improved across the board from 1978 to 2021. What I was less certain about was rushing: <a href="https://github.com/caleb-smith-95/dmp2022/blob/main/Blog%20Posts/Graphs/BP6.ipynb">teams run the ball much less today than they did in 1978</a>. I wasn’t sure how this would affect efficiency, so I was a bit surprised that yards per carry has improved over the past 40 years (especially since 1994):</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/954/1*j1Fa5oWSSMqxlfau8c9C7Q.png" /></figure><h4>Turnovers</h4><p>Turnovers have drastically decreased from 1978. Quarterbacks now throw fewer interceptions, and running backs lose fewer fumbles, than ever before:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/954/1*f5_c8TjaG8VrIyroY7DPYw.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/954/1*pAyX-p7KsVqnMa6mfi--cA.png" /></figure><h4>Field Goal vs Extra Point Percentage</h4><p>One of the most interesting inflation findings occurs with kickers. Kickers are significantly better today at every kicking efficiency metric except one: extra point percentage. This is because in 2015, the league moved extra points back from the 2 yard line (essentially a 19 yard field goal) to the 15 (equivalent to a 32 yarder). The effect of this rule change can easily be seen in the extra point inflation graph below:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/954/1*3axmtXrcTlalF0lcKYZhoQ.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/954/1*G8_HhqdTAtQa-YuglejCfw.png" /></figure><p>Fran Tarkenton threw for the equivalent of 3912 yards, 30 Touchdowns, and 15 Interceptions in 1978 after accounting for inflation.¹ While still not elite numbers by today’s standards, they paint a more accurate picture of the type of season he had. These numbers would’ve been good for the 12th most yards and 8th most Touchdowns by any Quarterback in 2021. More interestingly, his new efficiency stats give us a decent feel for the type of player he was. Even adjusted for inflation, his 6.4 yards per attempt wasn’t very good. Yet, his completion percentage shot up to 73.6%, which would have led the league! These numbers are somewhat similar to an Alex Smith, Sam Bradford, or end of career Drew Brees. Tarkenton was dinking and dunking his way to the NFL passing crown. Keep in mind that he was 38 in 1978, which would have made him the 3rd oldest Quarterback in 2021 (after Tom Brady and Ben Roethlisberger). Thus, this isn’t necessarily the type of player he was in the prime of his career.</p><p>Inflation is the final adjustment needed in what is known as the “data cleaning” process. To make accurate predictions, you not only need good data, but you need it in an accessible or “clean” format. I have now <a href="https://medium.com/@calebsmith_87504/impact-of-age-on-nfl-player-performance-data-selection-4a83746c4c09">identified good data</a>, <a href="https://medium.com/@calebsmith_87504/impact-of-age-on-nfl-player-performance-does-position-matter-part-3-6c404f68f6d7">sorted it by position</a>, <a href="https://medium.com/@calebsmith_87504/impact-of-age-on-nfl-player-performance-survivor-bias-part-4-43fbb204f14c">analyzed it for biases and irregularities</a>, and <a href="https://medium.com/@calebsmith_87504/impact-of-age-on-nfl-player-performance-efficiency-stats-part-5-e6d39d4a2109">calculated efficiency stats</a>. Quantifying the effect of inflation was the final part of this process. Now on to the exciting part: building models and making predictions.</p><h4>Footnotes</h4><p>1: In 2021, the NFL played a 17 game schedule for the first time (up from the 16 games played from 1978 to 2020). These numbers are also adjusted to account for this extra game.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=140cb53edf0f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Impact of Age on NFL Player Performance: Why I Hate Passer Rating (Part 5b)]]></title>
            <link>https://calebrsmith95.medium.com/impact-of-age-on-nfl-player-performance-why-i-dont-like-passer-rating-part-5b-6e1923f8415c?source=rss-9c9c24667ada------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6e1923f8415c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[sports-analytics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[statistics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[data-science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[football]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nfl]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Caleb Smith]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 12 Apr 2022 17:35:12 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-05-05T21:44:11.108Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>When discussing Quarterback efficiency stats, it’s impossible to avoid the topic of passer rating. In 1973, the NFL adopted this controversial system to evaluate Quarterback performance. The four inputs into traditional passer rating are Yards/Attempt, Completion %, Touchdowns/Attempt, and Interceptions/Attempt. I agree that these are the four best stats for evaluating Quarterback performance (assuming a certain amount of volume). But using four different stats to evaluate performance makes it much harder to definitively say “Player 1 is better than Player 2.” What if Player 1 has more Yards/Attempt, Completion %, and TDs/Attempt, but also more Ints/Attempt? Is he better than Player 2? It’s impossible to say for sure without somehow combining these four metrics. In an attempt to do this, the NFL came up with this formula:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/597/1*xwwIWPplL4khk-Z36kVn7g.png" /><figcaption>Credit for this visualization comes from <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Passer_rating">Wikipedia</a>. Confirmation of these definitions can be found at <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20110814052052/http://www.nfl.com/help/quarterbackratingformula">NFL.com</a></figcaption></figure><p>As if this formula wasn’t confusing enough, the league defines arbitrary cutoffs at 0 and 2.375 for a, b, c, and d. This means the lowest possible passer rating is 0 (makes sense), while the highest is 158.3. (???) Incredibly, there is no explanation given for why these exact cutoffs were chosen. Because of this, we are left to believe that these numbers were simply made up. This is neither a mathematically rigorous nor logically satisfying way to create a formula. Because of this, simpler metrics have been proposed. For instance, college football calculates passer rating this way:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/633/1*TCfokL8M9T_HqLvudzvH3Q.png" /><figcaption>Taken from the same Wikipedia article. Source for this article can be found <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20111110083943/http://football.stassen.com/pass-eff/">here</a></figcaption></figure><p>This formula is much easier to justify. There are no artificial cutoffs, and the final calculation doesn’t arbitrarily multiply by 100/6 like its NFL counterpart. The highest possible rating of 1261.6 can only be achieved by throwing 99 yard touchdowns on every pass (as opposed to the NFL formula, where there are so many ways to get a “perfect” rating that it has happened <a href="https://www.pro-football-reference.com/leaders/pass_rating_single_game.htm">78 times</a>). Even so, there’s still a major problem: the “weights” given to each stat¹ are subjective. Someone had to decide that a touchdown is 3.3 times more valuable than a regular completion, while an interception equivalent to -23.8 passing yards.²</p><p>This is the inherent flaw in any metric designed to incorporate multiple different statistics: the weights given to each part will always be subjective. Even a formula that gave equal weights to each stat would be subjective. Is one Touchdown pass really equivalent to one passing yard? Because of these inherent biases, I’ve decided to analyze the effect of aging on Yards, Completions, Touchdowns, and Interceptions (all by Attempt) separately. This eliminates the subjectivity inherent to every passer rating metric.</p><p>I find it interesting that you rarely see a “rating” for positions other than QB. For instance, Receivers have catches, yards, touchdowns, and fumbles, but these are almost never combined into a single metric. If it seems a bit silly to do this for Receivers (or Running Backs or Kickers), why does it make sense for Quarterbacks?</p><p>Footnotes</p><p>1: 8.4 is the weight given to each passing yard, 330 is the weight of each Touchdown, 100 is the weight of each completion, and -200 is the weight of each Interception.</p><p>2: 330/100 = 3.3, while (-200)/8.4 = -23.8</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6e1923f8415c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Impact of Age on NFL Player Performance: Efficiency Stats (Part 5)]]></title>
            <link>https://calebrsmith95.medium.com/impact-of-age-on-nfl-player-performance-efficiency-stats-part-5-e6d39d4a2109?source=rss-9c9c24667ada------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e6d39d4a2109</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[data-science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[football]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nfl]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sports-analytics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[statistics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Caleb Smith]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 12 Apr 2022 17:34:19 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-07-27T15:58:50.828Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Here’s a riddle: Player 1 leads the NFL in passing one season with over 5000 yards. Yet the very next year, his team gets rid of him and replaces him with Player 2. Player 2 goes on to throw for almost 500 fewer yards, yet no one would deny he was an upgrade. Why is this? Bonus points if you know the situation I’m referring to.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*AbruKyZpQF5DzEqXz_RvSA.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/400/1*bzuMvKZtVwVeQ9R4LaYTYA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Left photo (Winston) by Julio Aguilar/Getty Images, right photo (Brady) by Nathan Ray Seebeck-USA TODAY Sports</figcaption></figure><p>Here’s the answer: the 2020 Tampa Bay Buccaneers replaced Jameis Winston with Tom Brady. Winston lead the NFL in passing yards in 2019 with 5109. So why’d the Bucs move on? There were probably two reasons:</p><ul><li>Almost any team would replace their starting Quarterback with Brady, a future Hall of Famer who many regard as the greatest football player of all time.</li><li>Winston’s 2019 season wasn’t actually as good as his passing yards would indicate.</li></ul><p>That season, Winston became the first player since 1988 to throw 30 interceptions. The significance of this cannot be understated. The 2019 Bucs were 6th out of 32 teams in yards per play allowed, and 1st in the league in rushing defense. Yet, they gave up the 4th most points in the league, mostly as a result of the interceptions Winston was throwing. Because the Bucs were allowing so many points, they were throwing the ball a ton: Winston lead the NFL in passing attempts with 626. In a strange way, Winston’s interceptions were allowing him to throw for more yards (and even more interceptions). The Bucs had a talented team (despite Winston’s play, they finished a somewhat respectable 7–9), but were trapped in this endless cycle. If they could simply find a Quarterback who wasn’t throwing an historic number of interceptions, they’d be pretty good. In Brady, they got this and more. Not only did the 2020 Bucs improve by 4 games to finish 11–5, they went on to win the Super Bowl.</p><p>The Winston/Brady Bucs are an extreme example of why counting stats (such as yards) can be misleading. A player can throw (or run or catch) for a lot of yards simply because they have lots of attempts. This creates an issue for evaluating player performance (and ultimately aging). That’s why efficiency statistics are preferred by the sports analytics community. Efficiency stats simply take a counting stat (like yards) and divide by attempts. This looks different for each position:¹</p><h4>Quarterbacks</h4><p>There are four basic counting stats for Quarterbacks: Yards, Completions, Touchdowns, and Interceptions. All of these can be converted into efficiency metrics when divided by passing attempts.²</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/954/1*SlJAu1c43mgXZafjwu7isg.png" /><figcaption>TD% by age for Hall of Fame QB Peyton Manning. Manning’s efficiency was fairly consistent besides a sharp spike at age 28 (when he broke the single season pass TD record with 48), and a steep drop-off at age 39.</figcaption></figure><h4>Running Backs</h4><p>The three basic counting stats for Running Backs are Yards, Touchdowns, and Fumbles. Again, each can be converted into efficiency stats when divided by carries.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/954/1*3N5At9C_L0NUe6SxozcVrw.png" /><figcaption>Yards per carry for Emmitt Smith, the leading rusher in NFL history. Smith’s most efficient season came at age 24, after which his performance declined.</figcaption></figure><h4>Receivers</h4><p>The three basic counting stats for Receivers are catches, yards, and touchdowns. To properly determine how efficient a Receiver is, we need to divide each of these numbers by targets.³ One thing to note: targets were not officially counted until 1992, so seasons before this will not be analyzed.⁴</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/954/1*ucYesPMVhZFkhQkWiCzKoQ.png" /><figcaption>Catch% numbers for Terrell Owens, the third leading receiver in NFL history. As he got older, Owens caught fewer of the passes thrown his way.</figcaption></figure><h4>Kickers</h4><p>Kickers only have two basic counting stats: makes and misses. However, there are many ways to categorize these two basic numbers. First, there is the difference between field goals and extra points. Second, there are many different lengths of field goals. Typically the longer the attempt, the more difficult a field goal is to make. Because of this, I split field goals into five categories: less than 20 yards, 20–29 yards, 30–39 yards, 40–49 yards, and 50+ yards. I also kept each Kicker’s combined Field Goal %. I thought it would be interesting to analyze the effect of age on each of these stats. For instance, it’s possible that as Kickers grow older, their leg strength decreases and it becomes harder for them to kick 50 yard field goals. But perhaps this doesn’t affect their ability to kick extra points. This is one of the hypotheses I will be testing in the coming weeks.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/954/1*7Bo4ECOEslbKv6L1KrBwNw.png" /><figcaption>Adam Vinatieri is the leading scorer in NFL history. He remained fairly consistent from age 24 until age 46, before experiencing a steep decline at age 47.</figcaption></figure><p>One more quirk in the data must be discussed before predictions are able to be made. In <a href="https://medium.com/@calebsmith_87504/impact-of-age-on-nfl-player-performance-inflation-part-6-140cb53edf0f">Part 6</a>, I will discuss inflation: the overall trends in NFL statistics from 1978 to today.</p><h4>Footnotes</h4><p>1: Code for the graphs in this article can be found <a href="https://github.com/caleb-smith-95/dmp2022/blob/main/Blog%20Posts/Graphs/BP5.ipynb">here</a>.</p><p>2: Some people like to combine these metrics into one number: Passer Rating. My footnote explaining why I didn’t use it was too long, so I wrote a <a href="https://medium.com/@calebsmith_87504/impact-of-age-on-nfl-player-performance-why-i-dont-like-passer-rating-part-5b-6e1923f8415c">short article</a> instead.</p><p>3: Targets are the number of times a pass was thrown to a certain receiver.</p><p>4: This change will cause a smaller sample size, making my Receiver predictions less reliable. For this reason, I thought of dropping Receivers from my analysis altogether, but decided they would still be interesting to analyze.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e6d39d4a2109" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Impact of Age on NFL Player Performance: Survivor Bias (Part 4)]]></title>
            <link>https://calebrsmith95.medium.com/impact-of-age-on-nfl-player-performance-survivor-bias-part-4-43fbb204f14c?source=rss-9c9c24667ada------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/43fbb204f14c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[nfl]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sports-analytics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[statistics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[football]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[data-science]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Caleb Smith]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 12 Apr 2022 17:33:45 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-07-27T15:54:28.911Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Imagine you are a strategist for your country’s military. You have been tasked with analyzing fighter jets returning from war, and deciding where to add additional armor. The red dots on the diagram below represent all the spots where these planes have been shot. Based on this data, which parts of the plane would you choose to reinforce?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/403/1*OtXTCShOIOVUCtu7p0f8SA.png" /><figcaption>Credit for this diagram comes from an article by Jonathan Jarry of McGill University. To read a more in-depth description of Survivorship Bias, <a href="https://www.mcgill.ca/oss/article/general-science/tips-better-thinking-surviving-only-half-story">click here</a></figcaption></figure><p>This exact problem was posed to American military strategists during World War 2. If you answered “I’d reinforce the spots with red dots!”, you’d be in agreement with these strategists. Unfortunately, you’d both be wrong. The US Air Force was baffled that their new armor wasn’t decreasing the number of planes being shot down. Fed up with their strategists, they turned to a statistician: Abraham Wald. Wald correctly pointed out that their sample of planes was incomplete: it did not contain the planes that had been shot down in battle. Because the only planes being studied were the ones that had survived, the red dots actually represented non-lethal bullet holes. Wald hypothesized that planes hit in spots without red dots were the ones that hadn’t made it back. Therefore, the armor should’ve be placed in these spots all along. Without Wald, the Allies had fallen for a common statistical fallacy: Survivorship Bias.</p><p>Survivorship Bias showed up pretty quickly in my analysis of passing data. Using the Quarterbacks that <a href="https://medium.com/@calebsmith_87504/impact-of-age-on-nfl-player-performance-does-position-matter-part-3-6c404f68f6d7">previously qualified for my analysis</a>, I calculated average passing yards by age. The results are shown below:¹</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/954/1*hdFhUGmY1WjYc5-oEBDFtA.png" /><figcaption>Figure 1</figcaption></figure><p>Figure 1 could easily be featured in the classic 1954 book “How to Lie with Statistics.” If someone was trying to convince you that Quarterbacks get dramatically better with age (especially after 43!), this is the picture they’d use. The problem is, while good visualizations make real patterns in data easier to understand, bad visualizations can just as easily be used to mislead. The graph above is missing context. Let’s take a different look at the data:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/954/1*0ajKtbQOpbrpbaRvFz_13Q.png" /><figcaption>Figure 2</figcaption></figure><p>Since 1978, of the 1,593 times someone has thrown for over 1000 yards in a season, 955 were under 30 years old. Another 621 were between ages 30 and 40. Only one player has “survived” to ages 43 and 44: Tom Brady. And Brady didn’t just throw for over 1000 yards in those two seasons: he threw for 4,633 at age 43 and 5,316 at age 44! This is the “Brady Bump” we see at the tail end of Figure 1.</p><p>It is no accident that Brady is the final “surviving” Quarterback. In Figure 2, there is a steady drop-off of qualifying players after the age of 26. To understand why this is, let’s observe the careers of two Quarterbacks: Brett Favre and Joey Harrington:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/954/1*PUrAhH27JPEk2PYJ3mIKTA.png" /><figcaption>Figure 3</figcaption></figure><p>Figure 3 does a decent jobs of providing a snapshot of these two players’ careers. I have three main takeaways from this graph:</p><ul><li>Brett Favre was a better player than Joey Harrington.</li><li>Neither player improved with age. In fact, the trend lines for both provide evidence that both got worse as they got older.</li><li>Under my definition, Joey Harrington no longer qualified as a Quarterback after turning 30.</li></ul><p>If you are familiar with these two players, none of this should surprise you. Favre is in the Hall of Fame, while Harrington never had a winning record as a starter. Now let’s look at a bad visualization that uses the exact same numbers, but in a different way:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/954/1*959RjNGMvQ1QkWFQQooa6g.png" /><figcaption>Figure 4</figcaption></figure><p>Figure 4 is identical to Figure 1, but with two players instead of hundreds, and it shows the same effect. It appears as if performance is improving with age (until the dramatic drop-off at age 41). But we know from Figure 3 that this isn’t true. Performance only appears to be increasing in Figure 4 because the better player “survived” longer than his counterpart. Bad players don’t tend to last long: the NFL will always find someone to replace you. Meanwhile, Hall of Fame caliber players like Favre and Brady can essentially play as long as they want. Of course, there is a spectrum of careers in between. This is why Figure 1 seems to show a steady improvement with age even before the “Brady Bump”: more players fall off every year, leaving only the best of the best behind.</p><p>There is another issue with all the graphs above: counting stats like “Yards” are not a great indicator of how good a player is. <a href="https://medium.com/@calebsmith_87504/impact-of-age-on-nfl-player-performance-efficiency-stats-part-5-e6d39d4a2109">In Part 5</a>, I will talk about one of the strangest seasons by a player in NFL history, and use it to illustrate why efficiency metrics are superior to counting stats.</p><h4>Footnotes</h4><p>1: The coding for this article (including all the graphs) can be found <a href="https://github.com/caleb-smith-95/dmp2022/blob/main/EDA/EDA13%20-%20Selection%20Bias.ipynb">here</a>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=43fbb204f14c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Impact of Age on NFL Player Performance: Does Position Matter? (Part 3)]]></title>
            <link>https://calebrsmith95.medium.com/impact-of-age-on-nfl-player-performance-does-position-matter-part-3-6c404f68f6d7?source=rss-9c9c24667ada------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6c404f68f6d7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[football]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[statistics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[data-science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nfl]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sports-analytics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Caleb Smith]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 29 Mar 2022 21:47:29 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-07-27T19:49:13.445Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I grew up less than an hour from the City of Jeannette. Like many small manufacturing towns in Western Pennsylvania, High School football is king. In fact, <a href="https://tribhssn.triblive.com/jeannette-football-program-soldiers-on-as-transfers-defections-decimate-roster/">no program in Western PA football history has won as many games as the Jayhawks.</a> But throughout the storied history of their program, one name stands out: Terrelle Pryor. After leading Jeannette to the <a href="http://www.piaa.org/assets/web/documents/2007_AA_FB.pdf">state championship in 2008</a>, Pryor was listed by Rivals as <a href="https://n.rivals.com/prospect_rankings/rivals100/2008">the number 1 recruit in the country</a>, ahead of future NFL Hall of Famers Julio Jones and Patrick Peterson. Yet after an up and down 7-year professional career, no one would still compare him to these all-time greats. So what happened?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*K3VmAl_2vsg1sD7TClMY5A.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/612/1*QjXtTtOX8a9pfi7PAt22QQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Terrelle Pryor is one of a handful of NFL players to play multiple positions (left image from AP Photo/Joe Mahoney, right image from Getty Images)</figcaption></figure><p>From the beginning, Pryor was destined to have a strange career. <a href="https://www.espn.com/college-football/news/story?id=5950873">Due to receiving improper benefits from a tattoo parlor while attending Ohio State</a>, he was forced into the obscure Supplemental Draft, where he was taken by the Oakland Raiders in 2011. Drafted as a Quarterback, he only started 10 games at the position. Nine of these came in 2013, when he threw for nearly 1800 yards. After being released and not playing a single down in 2014, <a href="https://www.nfl.com/news/terrelle-pryor-switching-to-wr-after-bengals-release-0ap3000000497963">Pryor made the shift to Wide Receiver</a>. He bounced around the league before breaking out with the Cleveland Browns in 2016, catching 77 passes for 1007 yards. In doing so, <a href="https://www.nfl.com/photos/notable-nfl-supplemental-draft-picks-0ap3000000819256#3f1e05e5-76f5-401c-b3d2-c7ffd23b3f03">he became only the second player in league history with both a 1000 yard passing and receiving season</a>. He would never hit either of those numbers again.</p><p>One of the most famous concepts in statistics is the “null hypothesis.” This is the assumption that any anomalies in the data can be accounted for by random chance. In the context of our question, the null hypothesis is that position has no impact on aging. This assumption should make even the most casual football fan uneasy. The conventional wisdom is that Running Backs (who take a constant physical beating) don’t last as long as Kickers (who don’t). Let me be clear: the null hypothesis is not always correct, but the logic behind it is sound. We can’t just take the conventional wisdom at face value. It is the data scientist’s job to provide evidence that position impacts aging. Otherwise, we need to treat every position’s aging process the same.¹</p><p>To test this assumption, we need to group players into positions. The problem is that a player’s position is not always clear. The obvious cases are guys who have played multiple, like Terrelle Pryor. Was he a Quarterback or a Receiver? Next, you have guys who played one position, but have traits of another. LaDainian Tomlinson was a Running Back who caught 100 passes in 2003, and Michael Vick was a Quarterback who ran for 1000 yards in 2006. This is an issue because accurate position data is hard to come by. Below is a snippet from the <a href="https://www.pro-football-reference.com/years/2021/passing.htm">complete 2021 passing records</a> compiled by Pro Football Reference (PFR):</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/615/1*Kn4wObe2OAmyRZMQFbFjnQ.png" /></figure><p>Two players above are listed without positions: Kyle Allen and Chad Henne. Diehard fans will recognize them as backup quarterbacks, and may be tempted to fill their position by hand. But missing position data is an issue throughout PFR, and manually filling in thousands of records dating back to 1978 would be nearly impossible. Another quirk in the data: Cedrick Wilson Jr. is a Receiver who threw for more yards than Henne (and several other QBs listed further down). This brings into question the usefulness of comparing backups like Henne to full-time starters, even those who technically play the same position. Starters and backups are fundamentally different types of players, so their aging processes may be different.</p><p>In order to explore the effect that position has on aging, I sorted every player since 1978 using the decision tree below:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*EpP7VI3ve2qaQGttJt6_Bg.jpeg" /><figcaption>The precise cutoffs above are somewhat arbitrary. However, a significant amount of playing time is necessary for a player to hit these numbers in a given season, even if they are not a full-time starter.</figcaption></figure><p><a href="https://medium.com/@calebsmith_87504/impact-of-age-on-nfl-player-performance-data-selection-4a83746c4c09">In Part 2</a>, I stated my positions of interest going forward would be Quarterbacks, Running Backs, Receivers,² and Kickers. Since 1978, 22 Quarterbacks have run for at least 500 yards in a season, 107 Running Backs have gone over 500 yards receiving, and one player (Pryor) hit all three thresholds.³ Each season, these players were assigned a position by the tree. Some players are considered to have played different positions in different years. For instance, Pryor is classified as a Quarterback in 2013, a Receiver in 2016, and a Backup for the other 5 years of his career. Using these classifications, some interesting patterns begin to emerge:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/954/1*oS3-PU7cHSQQIto4o2lYPA.png" /></figure><p>The peak (or mode) of each distribution is around 25 (24 for Running Backs, 25 for Receivers and Kickers, and 26 for Quarterbacks).⁴ However, the distributions for Quarterbacks and Kickers are far more skewed than the distributions for Running Backs and Receivers. This means Quarterbacks and Kickers are more likely to play into their late 30s and 40s.</p><p>The biggest flaw of comparing the histograms above is the difference in the number of total qualifiers at each position. For example, there have been 3,121 instances of a Receiver with 500 yards in a season since 1978, but only 1,617 instances of a Running Back with 500 yards. Therefore, to make a useful comparison of the two positions, we need change these numbers to percentages. More 24-year-old Receivers had 500 yards than 24-year-old Running Backs (346 vs 240, respectively). But 15% of 500 yard Running Backs were 24, as opposed to only 11% of 500 Yard Receivers.⁵ This can be visualized below:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/954/1*WfUg-yopl9n3M-gbdkUVfQ.png" /></figure><p>This graph shows that Kickers tend to last longer than Quarterbacks, who in turn last longer than Receivers and Running Backs. While Running Backs have the highest peak at 24 years old, no 500 yard rushers were older than 37. Meanwhile, Kickers have the lowest peak, but the longest tail (going all the way out to age 47). In fact, almost 4% of qualifying Kickers were in their 40s!⁶</p><p>The data clearly show that position has an effect on aging. Thus, we can safely reject the null hypothesis: the assumption that position doesn’t matter was shown to be false.⁷ However, the extent of this effect has not yet been demonstrated. We have not shown that 25-year-old Receivers are better than 35-year-olds, only that there are more of them. In fact, there are some surprising results that seem to contradict the idea that aging negatively affects NFL players. <a href="https://medium.com/@calebsmith_87504/impact-of-age-on-nfl-player-performance-survivor-bias-part-4-43fbb204f14c">In Part 4</a>, we will examine some strange findings, and discuss an important statistical concept: survivor bias.</p><h4>Footnotes</h4><p>1: My goal here is to introduce the concept of the null hypothesis, not the math behind it. My calculations for hypothesis testing (and all other Python code for this article) can be found <a href="https://github.com/caleb-smith-95/dmp2022/blob/main/EDA/EDA10%20-%20Frequencies.ipynb">here</a>.</p><p>2: “Receivers” includes both Wide Receivers and Tight Ends. Because of the missing position data, it was too difficult to separate these two groups. Although this isn’t ideal, the two positions are similar enough for the purposes of exploratory analysis.</p><p>3: No Kickers qualified as any other position.</p><p>4: Mode is the value of the distribution that appears the most, and is represented in each histogram by the highest bar. For example, there are 150 26-year-old QBs with 1000 yard passing seasons, which is more than any other age.</p><p>5: The math here is simple: 240/1617 = 14.8%, while 346/3121 = 11.1%.</p><p>6: As opposed to about 1% of Quarterbacks, 0.1% of Receivers, and no Running Backs.</p><p>7: For the stats nerds: the p-value of the ANOVA test was effectively 0. The most similar positions in terms of aging were QBs and Kickers, but the difference between them was still significant at the 5% level (p = 0.0118).</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6c404f68f6d7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>