<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by C. Narby on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by C. Narby on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@caroline.narby?source=rss-3709287da95------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 23:44:20 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@caroline.narby/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[There is no “them”]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@caroline.narby/there-is-no-them-14f8a6de3c6a?source=rss-3709287da95------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/14f8a6de3c6a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[transgender]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[progressive]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[liberalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lgbtq]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[C. Narby]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 21 Mar 2017 17:56:08 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-03-21T17:56:08.128Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I don’t happen to have cable. So when I visit my parents, I sometimes like to park myself in front of their television and just flip through the channels. It’s a nostalgic escape. It reminds me of a time in my life when the world felt small and safe, and yet also huge and full of hope, all at once. Nowadays, I can never just feel comfortably bored, the way that I did when I was a child and I would space out in front of the TV. In my quiet moments now, I just feel constant dread and fear. I worry about what’s going to happen, to the people I love and to the world in general.</p><p>One of the channels that my parents receive is called One America News Network. It has a very conservative bent, so I would usually flip right past it. I can’t bear to see people trying to argue that my friends deserve to be hurt. On a recent visit, however, something on the network caught my eye. I watched it with curiosity and astonishment.</p><p>It was a news segment about a little girl who was starting kindergarten. Because the girl was transgender, her mother was ready to fight the school district to protect her daughter’s safety and dignity. This was not on one of the coasts or in some city regarded as a major cultural center. This was a family living in the so-called “Bible belt,” who were apparently devout Christians themselves. The mother talked about her faith, she talked about how she did not fully understand her daughter. But she was resolved, nonetheless, to give her daughter every opportunity to be herself and to be happy. She would protect her child. Because that’s what mothers do.</p><p>The program did not frame the story in a way that condemned the mother or her daughter. In fact it was strongly supportive. That brief bit of news coverage on a deeply conservative channel got something right about difference and diversity that “the left” often fails to grasp. We do not accommodate and celebrate difference just for difference’s sake. We strive to make the world around us safe for the people we care about. And the people we love have different needs and experiences than we do, because everyone is different. But we also share basic needs that are common to all people: to be safe, to be supported by our family and peers, to get up every morning with a sense of dignity and purpose.</p><p>I mention trans people in particular because they are so often held up as an example of the “excesses” of progressivism, even by self-styled progressives themselves. For example, in<a href="http://t.umblr.com/redirect?z=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.nytimes.com%2F2016%2F11%2F20%2Fopinion%2Fsunday%2Fthe-end-of-identity-liberalism.html&amp;t=OTFjMjUzNTk1NDg5NWQ2NzQ3MjNhNjBhNzU4Y2NlZjljYmM0NWYwZSx1TzN5NDZ0Sg%3D%3D&amp;b=t%3AJZaT_OnRaJCxC82pd9TLTQ&amp;p=http%3A%2F%2Fcarrows-blog.tumblr.com%2Fpost%2F153602170249%2Fthere-is-no-them&amp;m=1"> a recent but now infamous op-ed</a> for the New York Times, political historian Mark Lilla declares that “America is sick and tired of hearing about liberals’ damn bathrooms.” What he seems to mean is that the majority of Americans–or, implicitly, the rural and rust belt working class Americans whom we keep blaming for Trump’s electoral victory–think that the very concept of transgender people is foreign and frivolous. This accusation does not account for reality: for that mother in the Bible belt standing up for her daughter, for the fact that there are hardworking people in the heartland and the rust belt who not only have transgender loved ones but who <em>are trans themselves</em>. “Americans” and “transgender people” are not separate and opposing categories.</p><p>I actually <em>do</em> think that “identity politics” have weakened the resolve and efficacy of progressive movements. But not in the way that commentators like Lilla claim. Trans people expressing the basic human need for safety and dignity are not to blame for dividing the left, or for alienating broad swaths of Americans in general. Rather, the very impulse to label that need as “identity politics” in the first place, to declare it as something peculiar to those <em>other</em> people, is what has weakened our cause as would-be progressives. One<a href="https://twitter.com/meakoopa/status/800457648483303429"> tweet</a> that recently came across my Twitter feed put it very succinctly: “why are they ‘identity politics’ when they are mine but just ‘politics’ when they are yours?” The mainstream of the American left has lost sight of our real mission: to ensure that everyone’s basic, universal human needs are met. We believe in the inherent worth and dignity of all people. That everyone has the right to safety, healthcare, education, food and water, a home. Certain subpopulations among us need specific attention not because they are special, but because they are being left out and left behind.</p><p>Yet, progressives have started to see <em>ourselves</em> as charitably accommodating difference for difference’s sake. So when we fail to capture the hearts of our fellow Americans we think that difference itself must be the problem. We start to imagine that we were too busy catering to <em>them</em>, to those strange <em>other </em>people, and that now we need to focus on ourselves, on the needs of us <em>normal</em> people.</p><p>That simple, prevalent notion, that the world is divided into “us” and “them,” is the most dangerous idea that humans have ever conceived. When other people become “them,” we start to see them as alien. They are not quite real, not fully human. We imagine that they do not think and feel like we do. Their difference from us is so great that they are dangerous to us. So we can justify hurting them.</p><p>And, if we are perfectly honest with ourselves, it can feel good to hurt people. When you are afraid for yourself and your family, when you feel anxious or threatened by your environment, when you feel powerless, it feels good to lash out. Hurting or dominating someone who is more vulnerable than you are can make you feel powerful by comparison. It makes you feel like there’s something that you can control. This is an ugly thing about humans, but it is a very real part of our nature.</p><p>Certain leaders are very, very good at exploiting those feelings. They will tell you a potent lie: That the person who is less powerful than you are is actually <em>stronger</em>, that they are truly dangerous. And that will make you feel all the more powerful, all the more justified, if you hurt that person. This kind of rhetoric turns the trans girl in your child’s class into a strange monster. It turns innocent young men into thugs. It turns immigrants into a faceless menace. And so you can feel like a hero for hurting children, for supporting an assault on people who–like you–are just trying to live their lives.</p><p>It is men like that, bullies who want to turn you into a bully too, who have <a href="http://t.umblr.com/redirect?z=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.salon.com%2F2016%2F11%2F15%2Fthe-racist-fascist-extreme-right-is-represented-footsteps-from-the-oval-office-republicans-warn-of-trump-presidency%2F&amp;t=ZDg4N2RkOWI2ODA2ZjhkODkxNTgyNjZiZmJiMTBkODc5Mjk5NzQ4MCx1TzN5NDZ0Sg%3D%3D&amp;b=t%3AJZaT_OnRaJCxC82pd9TLTQ&amp;p=http%3A%2F%2Fcarrows-blog.tumblr.com%2Fpost%2F153602170249%2Fthere-is-no-them&amp;m=1">risen to power</a> in the United States. The media is already treating the <a href="http://t.umblr.com/redirect?z=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.latimes.com%2Fnation%2Fla-na-pol-white-nationalists-thinktank-20161119-story.html&amp;t=NmFjZDY5MjU0ZjYxYjczYmRiYjg5MDYzMzM2NjY2Yjk3Mjc0Y2E4Nyx1TzN5NDZ0Sg%3D%3D&amp;b=t%3AJZaT_OnRaJCxC82pd9TLTQ&amp;p=http%3A%2F%2Fcarrows-blog.tumblr.com%2Fpost%2F153602170249%2Fthere-is-no-them&amp;m=1">new extreme right</a>–the reactionaries, and fascists, the <a href="http://t.umblr.com/redirect?z=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.theatlantic.com%2Fpolitics%2Farchive%2F2016%2F11%2Frichard-spencer-speech-npi%2F508379%2F%3Futm_source%3Datlfbcomment&amp;t=NjYzNTY5MDYxMDRiOGQ1ZmY5YTM0NDFkYzU2ZGYzOTE0MjdlNDM3ZCx1TzN5NDZ0Sg%3D%3D&amp;b=t%3AJZaT_OnRaJCxC82pd9TLTQ&amp;p=http%3A%2F%2Fcarrows-blog.tumblr.com%2Fpost%2F153602170249%2Fthere-is-no-them&amp;m=1">outright Nazis</a> and <a href="http://t.umblr.com/redirect?z=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.theguardian.com%2Ftechnology%2F2016%2Fjul%2F21%2Fpeter-thiel-republican-convention-speech&amp;t=MWNiMmIwMWRmMmRhMTFmMWY2MDM3Y2E0OTc2ZmJiMWFiOTczZWQ5MCx1TzN5NDZ0Sg%3D%3D&amp;b=t%3AJZaT_OnRaJCxC82pd9TLTQ&amp;p=http%3A%2F%2Fcarrows-blog.tumblr.com%2Fpost%2F153602170249%2Fthere-is-no-them&amp;m=1">enemies of democracy</a> who have edged their way into the government–as if they are truly novel, as if there is some kind of mystique to them. But they couldn’t be less mysterious. Old and new, the far right is fundamentally the same: they are simply tyrants. They want to hurt other people to make themselves feel powerful. And yet even these people are not “them.” They are also us. They represent our collective ugliness and cruelty, the things that we think, and say, and do when we are at our worst.</p><p>The rhetoric of “us versus them” is a cornerstone of fascist thought but it also transcends political identity. “The left” often falls into the very same trap. If “identity liberalism” does end, it must not turn into a reactionary movement by another name. We cannot leave people behind. We cannot turn our backs on suffering under the guise of unity. We must recognize our common needs as human beings, and we must understand that different people experience those universal needs in different ways. In these bleak and desperate times we must be truly indivisible.</p><p>I am speaking to other would-be leftists, to remind them of what we stand for. But I also have a plea for centrists, for moderates, for conservatives. Everyone who believes in democracy and decency needs to stand together now. Don’t call it “progressivism” or “leftism,” if the words bother you. They are not properly descriptive anyway. Americans, in all our endless diversity, need to come together to proclaim who we are. We will not be made into tools for dominating the weak and vulnerable. We will not let fear turn us against our neighbors, our loved ones, our fellow human beings. We will not submit to tyrants.</p><p>There is no “them.” There is just us. And we are so much better than our own worst impulses. If we choose to stand together, if we refuse to be complicit in domination and cruelty, then justice and compassion will prevail.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="http://carrows-blog.tumblr.com/post/153602170249/there-is-no-them"><em>carrows-blog.tumblr.com</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=14f8a6de3c6a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Musings of a Frustrated Cyborg]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@caroline.narby/musings-of-a-frustrated-cyborg-e4f88cf92316?source=rss-3709287da95------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e4f88cf92316</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[asperger-syndrome]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mental-health]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-justice]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[autism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[C. Narby]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 21 Mar 2017 17:50:51 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-04-21T18:12:32.495Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Despite the title of this essay, I am a person. I am <em>just</em> a person.</p><p>I have struggled to put this piece together, in so many ways. One of those struggles was figuring out how to start.</p><p>Like every other human being I am, as a creature, as an animal, a product of evolution. As a subject, a roving knot of consciousness, I am a product of my culture. As a person in the world I am a product of my lived experience and my relationships.</p><p>I am not a changeling. I am not an alien. I am also not a mysterious relic from the past or a robot or some kind of eccentric genius. I do not exist for you to project meaning onto me. I am not here to be an object of anxiety, or wonder, or inspiration. Let’s start there.</p><p>I am autistic. I was diagnosed with Asperger syndrome when I was 20. In 2013, in the DSM-5, Asperger syndrome was merged with autism, subsumed under the diagnostic category “autism spectrum disorder.” Like many other people diagnosed with Asperger syndrome, however, I identified simply as autistic long before the labels were officially consolidated.</p><p>The general shape of my story, leading up to the diagnosis, is the same as it is for many people who were diagnosed “late.” I was a strange and lonely child. I was a “little professor,” intense and articulate, and those very qualities staved off any suspicion that I might have a developmental disability. In college, however, the differences that mark me as autistic got in the way of my life too much to be written off as “quirks” or “eccentricities.” I wondered if there might be a name for these differences, and I found one.</p><p>The dominant understanding of autism, at least until very recently, has been that it is a serious neurobehavioral disorder. Despite the “neuro-” prefix, which implies some relationship to the brain as a physical organ, there are no physiological features that are uniquely and consistently associated with autism. Although there is a large and growing body of medical research on autistic neurology, autism cannot be and is not diagnosed through a brain scan or any other kind of physical test. Autism is diagnosed by observing behavior. Over the years it has, in popular discourse, become a kind of catch-all category for almost any kind of atypical behavior. Anyone who deviates from the bounds of “normal” behavior might be suspected of being “on the spectrum.”</p><p>In the popular imagination, autism is and has been a source of both horror and wonder. Popular portrayals of autism incorporate but also freely embellish upon clinical understandings of the condition. Autism is often portrayed as a child-snatching plague. At its most frightening, it will steal your children and seal them away in “their own world.” It will warp them such that you’ll look into their eyes and see nothing there. Autistic people may outwardly appear human but our minds are so alien and inscrutable that they might as well be blank.</p><p>And yet, at the same time, we are imbued with strange and wonderful gifts. The narrative of autism as a “gift” or advantage is not novel, and it is not at odds with the construction of autism as disease, deviance, or deficit. In one of the chapters of <em>Representing Autism</em> (2008), Stuart Murray provides an in-depth analysis of the figure that has long embodied this concept of autism-as-advantage: the autistic savant. Autism and savantism are so closely linked in the popular imagination that Murray muses upfront “whether it is possible to be a savant without also having autism, or equally whether it might be supposed that all those who are autistic possess savant abilities.” Despite her gifts, the savant is still so alien that she may as well possess no interiority at all. Her abilities have meaning and purpose only so far as they benefit non-autistic people. The “advantage” that comes with autism is not the autist’s own, but that of (non-autistic) humanity on the whole.</p><p>I know that we would all like to think that we have moved beyond these archetypes. Particularly in light of neurodiversity’s rise to mainstream influence, we hope that this shift in popular discourse heralds a more humane and welcoming society. But as long as the default subject in society is assumed to be non-autistic, and as long as autism persists as a category of deviation from that norm, these dehumanizing narratives will also endure.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/0*BEzNXy1-xjw07Yjj.jpg" /></figure><p>Before I go on, I want to make something absolutely clear: I do believe that non-autistic people writing and speaking about autism usually have genuinely good intentions. Steve Silberman in particular seems like an earnest and thoughtful person. I trust that he really does want to support autistic people and to see the world do right by us. I know that non-autistic clinicians, professionals, and especially parents and guardians care deeply about their autistic clients, students, and children. I am not interested in assuming or promoting an adversarial relationship between autists and non-autistic caregivers and supporters. That would be in bad faith, and I fear that fostering such conflict would be especially harmful to the most vulnerable members of the autistic population.</p><p>I also do not want any fellow autistic people to feel guilty about finding value in Silberman’s work or in any similar works on neurodiversity by non-autistic authors. I am here to tease out, describe, and engage with a very stubborn and deep-seated narrative about autistic people–one that finds its way into even the most thorough and sensitive works. My gripes and quibbles do not mean that these works are bad or worthless. And my issue is ultimately not with Silberman or his book in particular, but with overarching trends or tropes in the discourse around autism.</p><p>I wanted to clarify all of that because, truthfully, I do not like <em>NeuroTribes</em>. It didn’t make me feel comforted or understood. I still feel dehumanized and exploited, and all the more frustrated because the author explicitly and so very, very earnestly intended otherwise.</p><p>Silberman’s book has been met with universal praise. It traces the history of autism from the work of Hans Asperger and Leo Kanner to the present day, exhaustively covering discursive trends from refrigerator mothers to the vaccine controversy to the neurodiversity movement. Silberman has been well-known for writing on autism since the publication of his now seminal 2001 <em>Wired</em> article “The Geek Syndrome.” <em>NeuroTribes</em> is the long-awaited culmination of his fascination with autism and autistic people. And I think, with that last sentence, that I have uncovered the root of my own discomfort and feelings of alienation. I can never quite be a person as long as I am an object of fascination.</p><p>I gather from his writing in general that Silberman is aware of how the alien and savant archetypes are deployed to the detriment of autistic people. As quoted in <a href="http://t.umblr.com/redirect?z=http%3A%2F%2Fio9.gizmodo.com%2F5879242%2Fwhy-do-we-want-autistic-kids-to-have-superpowers&amp;t=YjBjNzUyYTUyMjY2NDVhZjE2ZjI4NGY1MDVlZmFiOGZhNWZjM2EzMCxCc09BNEdFZg%3D%3D&amp;b=t%3AJZaT_OnRaJCxC82pd9TLTQ&amp;p=http%3A%2F%2Fcarrows-blog.tumblr.com%2Fpost%2F139400083299%2Fmusings-of-a-frustrated-cyborg&amp;m=1">a 2012 io9 article</a>, for example, he acknowledges how autistic characters in popular media are reduced to narrative devices. I do not think, however, that Silberman avoids perpetuating such othering narratives in <em>NeuroTribes</em>. No matter how many autistic people he has interviewed, Silberman cannot decenter the non-autistic gaze and perspective.</p><p>There is a whole chapter of the book devoted to <em>Rain Man</em>, the ur-text of autism in popular media. In the film, the (in)famous autistic savant character is a fascinatingly strange spectacle. He is less a person than simply a narrative device that drives the non-autistic protagonist’s arc. Silberman is strangely uncritical of the film. He credits it with jettisoning autism into the public (i.e. non-autistic) consciousness. Certainly, at the most basic level, that is an accurate assessment. But visibility is not the same thing as representation. Hypervisibility is a damaging phenomenon. <em>Rain Man</em> made autistic people hypervisible to the public eye, and its legacy is that we are still interpreted and interpellated through stereotypes and spectacle. Becoming an object of popular fascination is the opposite of humanizing.</p><p>Silberman also seems generally fond of that tired, inescapable analogy of autistic people in “a neurotypical world” as aliens navigating a strange planet. In a <a href="http://t.umblr.com/redirect?z=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.wired.com%2F2012%2F04%2Fthinking-smarter-about-people-who-think-differently%2F&amp;t=ZmVmZGE3ZDZjZWMyYjM2YzJiYTdhODEzZjYwYmEyY2U2M2NiNmNmNyxCc09BNEdFZg%3D%3D&amp;b=t%3AJZaT_OnRaJCxC82pd9TLTQ&amp;p=http%3A%2F%2Fcarrows-blog.tumblr.com%2Fpost%2F139400083299%2Fmusings-of-a-frustrated-cyborg&amp;m=1">2012 interview for <em>Wired</em></a>, he prompts the reader to, “Imagine Mr. Spock on Star Trek arching a Vulcan eyebrow in the face of McCoy’s ‘highly illogical’ behavior,” and claims that this analogy is “a perfect visual representation of how the follies of neurotypical society look to many autistic adults.” The alien comparison comes up in <em>NeuroTribes</em> as well, albeit sometimes in the mouths of autistic people themselves. Silberman does specifically liken us to Spock again, a couple of times.</p><p>On a certain level, I get it. Autistic people have sometimes analogized their own experience of, well, <em>alienation</em> as feeling like a lonely extraterrestrial. And non-autistic people love that, they eat it up. But here’s the thing: If someone tells you that their experience around you makes them feel like an alien or a monster or otherwise less than human, your impulse should be to reflect on and change your attitude and behavior. Instead of uncritically parroting the sentiment that autistic people are basically like aliens, you need to regard and treat us like fellow human beings.</p><p><em>NeuroTribes</em> doesn’t <em>quite</em> succeed in conveying that need for deep attitudinal change based on the understanding that autistic people are human. The book’s ultimate argument or thesis relies on the narrative of autism as a wondrous, mysterious gift and on the construction of autistic people as a fascinating other. Autism “is a strange gift from our deep past, passed down through millions of years of evolution,” Silberman writes in the concluding chapter. Autism is still an “atypical” mode of being, albeit one that should be accommodated because of its potential to benefit the general population (that is, to benefit non-autistic people).</p><p>Again, I am not saying that <em>NeuroTribes</em> is a completely bad or worthless text. For readers who may be new to the history and concepts presented in it, and for autistic readers looking for affirmation of their experiences, I am sure that the book has value. It does represent an attitudinal shift away from exterminatory panic. Silberman does argue that autism is not a problem in itself, but that a lack of access to resources and support leaves many autistic people and their families in crisis. He lists potential accommodations that might be introduced to public and communal spaces to make those spaces more welcoming to autistic people.</p><p>Then again, what Silberman really does is recount a history of the autism rights movement, and then he relays autistic advocates’ own arguments and propositions. And he — a non-autistic commentator — is rewarded with profit and acclaim for rehashing autists’ work.</p><p>I believe that part of what is harmful or troubling about even this book is also an inescapable feature of any and every text written about autistic people by a non-autistic person. Such works are emblematic of a longstanding, infuriating paradigm in which non-autistic authors and advocates are applauded for capitalizing on the work and experiences of autistic people. It is telling that in the language of the autism rights movement–and of disability rights more broadly–we have to use the term “self-advocate.” LGB people, for example, do not need to call ourselves “self-advocates” when we identify ourselves as gay rights activists. It would be recognized as redundant. Straight people need clarify that they are “allies” when they align themselves with our cause. Autistic people don’t get to have allies. Non-autistic people are centered as the advocates and we’re the ones who need to clarify who we are and justify our presence.</p><p>The mantra of “nothing about us without us” has set the bar far too low. It is not enough to be merely present. Despite the lip-service suddenly being paid to neurodiversity, autistic people are still, overwhelmingly, excluded from the mainstream of our own movement. We might be physically present, granted a “seat at the table” in the most literal sense, but we are not in charge. All mainstream discourse and activity around autism–clinical, academic, and political–is dominated by people who are not autistic. We might be consulted with but we are never deferred to. We are invited along as guests. Being guests, we must behave ourselves. Autistic advocates have worked tirelessly for decades to connect with each other, to carve out spaces for ourselves, and to make ourselves heard. Non-autistic people are still the gatekeepers. They control the institutions that govern our lives. If they don’t like what we have to say, we are still easily dismissed and ignored.</p><p>That is what autism is: A subordinate social position.</p><p>That one narrative, that deep-seated, inescapable narrative that is my ultimate bane and that I am desperate to describe and deconstruct is simply this: that autism is a fixed and natural state. That it is wired into my brain and coded into my DNA. That I would be inescapably deviant, or disabled, or otherwise different from “the norm” regardless of my culture or social context.</p><p>We–humans–make meaning through narrative. The whole world, as we apprehend it, is made of stories. Autism itself is one of those stories. Or perhaps it is better described as a genre of stories.</p><p>Cognitive and behavioral differences are very real. But what those differences <em>mean</em> depends on their cultural and historical context. Autism does not reside a priori within the human body. It is not immutably, transhistorically and transculturally, inscribed by nature or by God onto particular behaviors or modes of thought. Autism is the meaning that we read onto certain patterns of behavior. It is a “nominal category,” as Majia Holmer Nadesan puts it in <em>Constructing Autism</em> (2005). It has no fixed essence or substance except as a name for behavioral deviance.</p><p>We are different, but only insofar as every human is different from every other human. The behavioral attributes that have been named “autism” are just that: a set of traits picked out of a sea–not a tidy spectrum but a teeming sea–of difference and variation. Autism <em>is</em> a post-modern phenomenon, but not in the sense of being some kind of punishment for medical advancements or pollution or TV or junk food or feminism. It is a projection of our collective anxieties, a product of ever more restrictive systems of surveillance and taxonomy.</p><p>As long as non-autistic people believe that autists are a coherent category of people who are inherently and irreconcilably different from them–a different “tribe”–we will always be subordinate. The idea of normal, typical, default humanity assumes a non-autistic subject. The autist is the inscrutable other, the object of simultaneous revulsion and wonder. This state of abject otherness is why autism is constructed as both a curse and a gift.</p><p>Again, the concurrent narratives of deficit and advantage are not at odds but are complementary. And they have material consequences. If a population is constructed as aberrant and burdensome, then they must assert their worth in spite of that. If a population is constructed as wondrous and gifted, then they must meet that expectation or be deemed aberrant and burdensome. The deficit/advantage paradigm is not a dipole but an ouroboros.</p><p>On both sides of the coin, by alarmists pushing exterminatory rhetoric and by well-intentioned would-be proponents of neurodiversity, autists are constructed as cyborgs. We are understood as either less than fully human or as more than merely human. Not quite people, in any case. We are always part animal, part alien, part void, or part machine–always at least a little bit monstrous.</p><p>Monsters, incidentally, are what some would term my “special interest.” For my whole life I have had a passionate affinity for the monstrous. This affinity is what first drew me to cultural analysis and the social sciences. It led me to <a href="http://t.umblr.com/redirect?z=http%3A%2F%2Ffaculty.georgetown.edu%2Firvinem%2Ftheory%2FHaraway-CyborgManifesto-1.pdf&amp;t=OGY2ZWI2YjE2YmRkZGJiZjIzMGQ3ZDY5OWM4OTI3YWU0YmIwYzQwNixCc09BNEdFZg%3D%3D&amp;b=t%3AJZaT_OnRaJCxC82pd9TLTQ&amp;p=http%3A%2F%2Fcarrows-blog.tumblr.com%2Fpost%2F139400083299%2Fmusings-of-a-frustrated-cyborg&amp;m=1">Donna Haraway’s famous argument</a> that a discursive landscape comprised of oppositional dualisms has made cyborgs of us all.</p><p>I am 27 now. Seven years doesn’t seem like such a long time but I feel like a completely different person from who I was when I was 20, or when I was 23, or who I was last year. Having a diagnosis, being able to say that I fall into a particular category of deviance, has been a key to accessing the supports that I needed to grow and thrive. At this point in my life I’ve finally thought to ask: Why? Why don’t we support and care for every person as a matter of course?</p><p>And why should helping someone survive and thrive need to be justified by their utility or productive potential? In all the mainstream rhetoric about the potential benefits of embracing autism as “difference,” the inconvenient extremes of autistic difference are glossed over or brushed aside. Silberman’s book doesn’t totally shrug off the existence of nonverbal and “low-functioning” autistic people, but it does force them into a narrative of “potential.” On the findings of Leo Kanner’s work, Silberman writes, “Even ‘low-functioning’ children could grow up to become ‘high-functioning’ adults, but only if they managed to stay out of an institution and were given a chance to develop their innate gifts.”</p><p>It is absolutely true that a person’s behavior and level of functioning <em>can</em> change, even dramatically, and that some people need long-term, intensive intervention to experience that change. But what about those people who will never grow out of the traits for which they have been labeled “low-functioning?” Why accept any paradigm in which they are constructed as unfortunates, as failures of some kind if they never realize their “gifts?”</p><p>What happens when accommodating someone doesn’t provide a means to extract labor from them? Doesn’t a person deserve all the support and care that they need just on the basis of being alive in the world?</p><p>For me, neurodiversity has been a gateway to adopting more radical politics overall. I came to anti-capitalism through neurodiversity. I have acquired a broader political imagination and a greater sense of urgency through neurodiversity. If there is any possibility of living in a just world, it relies on our resolve to unmake the world as it currently is.</p><p>The fundamental premise of neurodiversity–as I understand it–is that difference is absolutely mundane. I believe that neurodiversity does have liberatory promise insofar as the idea of “diversity” is properly understood. Human cognition and behavior are so diverse that they defy taxonomy completely. There is no normal humanity from which to deviate or to use as a point of reference; difference is the rule. I do think that Silberman would agree, I just also think that he doesn’t quite get there in the text of his book. In the end he still imagines a world built by and for non-autistic people, in which autistic people don’t quite fit and need to be accommodated. Even in the rosiest future, we’re still outsiders.</p><p>The paradoxical promise of Haraway’s cyborg is that its liberation lies in its own dissolution. The cyborg carries in itself the possibility of rupturing the binary systems and taxonomies that created it, but in doing so it must cease to be a cyborg. Similarly, the liberation of autists and other neurodivergent people calls for the abolition of the very categories “autistic,” “neurodivergent,” and “neurotypical.” Not for those categories to be reimagined, or renamed, or subdivided, but for the entire taxonomic system to be dissolved.</p><p>In a world where autism exists, because we do taxonomize human difference and build systems of power around it, I am autistic. I am also nothing more or less than just another person. I am not magic. I am not an object for you to project meaning onto. I don’t exist to teach you anything. I have nothing profound to tell you about yourself or about human nature or about humanity’s collective past or about our future. I still deserve to live and thrive in the world.</p><p>I am not here for your benefit but listen: I am here. And we are in this together.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="http://carrows-blog.tumblr.com/post/139400083299/musings-of-a-frustrated-cyborg"><em>carrows-blog.tumblr.com</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e4f88cf92316" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Shadow in the Doorway: Revisiting Matilda as someone who grew up to be the Trunchbull]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@caroline.narby/the-shadow-in-the-doorway-revisiting-matilda-as-someone-who-grew-up-to-be-the-trunchbull-55cd2f6dbced?source=rss-3709287da95------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/55cd2f6dbced</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[movies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[books]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lgbtq]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lesbian]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[C. Narby]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 12 Jan 2017 03:02:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-03-21T17:54:59.260Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>The Shadow in the Doorway: Revisiting <em>Matilda</em> as someone who grew up to be the Trunchbull</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/0*4pSjxrNWC6c94Cz7.jpg" /></figure><p>At the climax of <em>Matilda</em> (1996), when the students of Crunchem Hall finally revolt against Pam Ferris’s iconic villainess, the narrator declares that “the Trunchbull was gone: never to be seen or heard from, never to darken a doorway again.” And she does simply drive out of the film, defeated and crammed into an old clunker. It’s a strangely anticlimactic exit for such a bombastic villain.</p><p>The film is, of course, based on a children’s book by Roald Dahl. Like every white man enshrined in the western consciousness as a kind of beloved uncle, Roald Dahl was a bigoted creep. His Oompa-Loompas were originally “<a href="http://t.umblr.com/redirect?z=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.roalddahlfans.com%2Fdahls-work%2Fbooks%2Fcharlie-and-the-chocolate-factory%2Fpolitically-correct-oompa-loompa-evolution%2F&amp;t=NTMxMTk2MThmMjhkZDZmZGQzZDM3N2JkZTgzYmNlNWVhYWU5NDZkZCxId2kxeFc1TQ%3D%3D&amp;b=t%3AJZaT_OnRaJCxC82pd9TLTQ&amp;p=http%3A%2F%2Fcarrows-blog.tumblr.com%2Fpost%2F148754981169%2Fthe-shadow-in-the-doorway&amp;m=1">black pygmies</a>.” He was infamously antisemitic. And so forth.That isn’t what this post is about. Dahl’s creepery is old news. Everyone knows about it. We tend to do the same thing with him that we do for the likes of Rudyard Kipling and H.P. Lovecraft and C.S. Lewis: We dutifully list his sins and then we cheerfully brush them aside so that we can keep on adulating him, or at least so that we can enjoy his work without feeling conflicted and without thinking too hard about it.</p><p>This post is about something that’s been kicking around in my brain for years. The 20th anniversary of <em>Matilda</em>’s release seems like an apt time to finally write about it.</p><p>I was 7 when <em>Matilda</em> came out and my family went to see it in the theater. I loved it immediately. On one level I readily identified with the protagonist: I was a bookish and lonely little girl. I read voraciously and schoolwork came so easily that I was constantly restless, but my social development lagged. I felt alienated both from my peers and from adults, unsure of my place in the world. Naturally I felt validated by Matilda’s triumph, as so many girls of my generation have felt.</p><p>There is a superficially “feminist” reading that one can ascribe to the film. When I was growing up, fantastical stories about child-heroes were usually about boys. The first book in the <em>Harry Potter</em> series would be published a year after <em>Matilda</em> was released, and it would re-solidify the archetype of the magical child-hero as quintessentially male. Boys were, and are, allowed to have grand, awe-inspiring adventures. They were allowed to slay monsters and to uncover terrible mysteries. Popular fiction about girls tended to be more grounded in reality, and was often smaller in scope and with lower stakes. As a child I was so utterly bored by most of the available media that featured girl protagonists.</p><p>The most notable exceptions to the trend of the boy-hero in children’s fantasy were Dorothy Gale of L. Frank Baum’s Oz series and Lewis Carroll’s Alice. Matilda herself, as portrayed both in Dahl’s original text and in the film (which is almost a moment-for-moment retelling of the book), is reminiscent of both Dorothy and Alice. She is thrust (by virtue of being born and by existing as a child) into a nightmarish world where she must prevail against a child-killing–or at least child-hating–villainess. In Entertainment Weekly’s <a href="http://t.umblr.com/redirect?z=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.ew.com%2Farticle%2F1996%2F08%2F09%2Fmatilda&amp;t=MDk2ZThmMmZjMjdmOTlhOTg0MTBjMTE0NWJiYjZjOTNkNTgzMGY5MixId2kxeFc1TQ%3D%3D&amp;b=t%3AJZaT_OnRaJCxC82pd9TLTQ&amp;p=http%3A%2F%2Fcarrows-blog.tumblr.com%2Fpost%2F148754981169%2Fthe-shadow-in-the-doorway&amp;m=1">review of the film</a>, Ty Burr even declared that the Trunchbull is “maybe the most frightening movie villainess since Margaret Hamilton slathered on the green paint for <em>The Wizard of Oz</em>.“ Certainly the Trunchbull is also reminiscent of the Queen of Hearts: she is oversized, “mannish,” and loud, and ironically childlike in her emotional volatility.</p><p>In <em>Matilda</em>, the real world of home and school becomes a dreamlike otherworld through the eyes of its child protagonist and the eyes of child viewers. Upon discovering her fantastic powers, the protagonist is called to a kind of quest. She liberates herself and her comrades from the tyranny of the monstrous headmistress, and she lives happily ever after. On the surface, she seems to defy stereotypes about what girls should be like and care about.</p><p>But, in addition to whatever other prejudices the man harbored, a deep, ugly misogyny also permeates Roald Dahl’s work, including his books for children. <em>Matilda</em> is, on another level, precisely a story about what girls and women ought–and ought not–to be.</p><p>In the novel, size is a prominent marker of appropriate femininity. Matilda’s smallness is emphasized in contrast with her fat mother and with the massive Trunchbull. Miss Honey, the other “good woman” in the text, is similarly small and quiet, again in contrast with the loud, active Trunchbull. Matilda’s powers manifest as telekinesis: she acts literally through her mind and with invisible influence, yet again in contrast with the distinctly physical Trunchbull. Miss Honey lives in a kind of arrested state of development, a sort of perpetual girlhood, and at the end of the story Matilda joins her there, ending up as neither a vapid housewife nor a grotesque spinster. The message seems to be that the only good way to be a woman is to avoid becoming a woman at all. Instead, the ideal performance of femininity is to remain an eternal girl: small, and sweet, and still. Nurturing without being a mother, pure without being a prude. Most of this was carried over into the film. The Trunchbull definitely embodies everything that women are not supposed to be. The spinster is a well-worn villainess archetype and Agatha Trunchbull is basically a spinster on steroids. Literally, almost: she has all the drabness and severity of any bitter schoolmistress, combined with the bulk and power of an Olympic shot put thrower. In the popular consciousness all spinsters are implicit man-haters (recall the line “Why are all these women married?!”) and suspected lesbians. I don’t think it’s an exaggeration to declare that the Trunchbull is one of the most prominent and influential representations of a butch lesbian in popular media.</p><p>My own 7 year old self was a lonely bookworm, as I’ve already described. But I was also a “tomboy.” I was (and am) loud and aggressive. I was rough-and-tumble, I was awkward and large. I had less than zero interest in boys, I was losing interest in other things that girls are “supposed” to care about, and I often had a difficult time relating to other girls.</p><p>Watching <em>Matilda</em> as a child, I saw myself in Matilda but I also saw myself in the Trunchbull. The narrative drew a firm line between the girl and the monster, but I was both.</p><p>Twenty years after the film’s release, the Trunchbull still casts a long shadow across children’s fiction. I don’t think that children’s media has budged from consistently representing big, gruff, aggressive, “mannish” women as the natural enemies of children.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/400/0*Y4kOo08I0YVL1uLv.jpg" /><figcaption>This “<a href="http://crystalgem-confessions.tumblr.com/post/131158506490/i-kinda-see-jasper-as-being-like-miss-trunchbull">Crystal Gem confession</a>” is presented without further comment.</figcaption></figure><p>The Trunchbull has also cast a shadow over my own self-image. I never grew out of my tomboyishness into some acceptable expression of femininity. Despite the film’s warning, I did become the Trunchbull, and I’m still trying to understand what that means.</p><p>Over-identification with monsters and villains is a common experience of LGBT people. Sometimes I feel like that’s the only thing my close friends and I ever really talk about: being, or feeling like, or otherwise relating to monsters. I recall one conversation with a friend in which we discussed the portrayal of butch or “mannish” women in fiction. As much as figures like the Trunchbull are meant to be repulsive, I confessed, I often wish that I really were huge and scary and physically powerful. “We want to become the monsters that they say we are,” my friend replied. I think that’s a great way to put it. If people are going to hear “butch” and envision the Trunchbull, couldn’t I at least <em>actually</em> be that? If I could pick up a car maybe that would feel like some kind of consolation.</p><p>Queer and queer-coded villains have become aspirational figures in this defiant sort of way, or at least a source of something like pride or identity. Like mascots. I mean, despite everything I’ve described, I still <em>like</em> the Trunchbull. I still enjoy <em>Matilda</em> as a film. But, recently, I’ve started to wonder just how much I might have internalized the story’s message about gender. Maybe that’s why I’m so deeply uncertain of my own womanhood. I didn’t turn out like Miss Honey. I became the very thing that I was told not to become. I did girlhood wrong, so do I even get to be a woman?</p><p>I’m left with all of that uncertainty and ambivalence. Even as, again, I can rewatch <em>Matilda</em> and enjoy it.</p><p>It’s easy to see why the film has endured. It is ugly and frightening in just the right ways. It strikes a certain darkly fantastic tone that is a hallmark of the early to mid-90′s, and yet it also seems timeless. It is impossible to say what decade the film is supposed to be set in. There are plenty of trappings and tropes that evoke the 90′s, but the Wormwoods and their house look like caricatures out of the 60′s. Despite all the Americanization, the Trunchbull is still a British schoolmarm who looks like she stepped out of the 1930′s, as the same friend who made the observation about monsterhood once put it.</p><p>As long as children feel like strangers and underdogs in a world created by adults, the story’s central conflict will also remain timeless. So we’ll find ourselves revisiting <em>Matilda</em> forever.</p><p>Maybe the film’s ending isn’t so much of a let-down. Maybe it’s satisfyingly unsatisfying. Like all the best monsters, the Trunchbull is still out there somewhere. She’s left to lurk, to cast her shadow. Thinking about that long, cold shadow, I just hope that we can start telling some new stories too.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="http://carrows-blog.tumblr.com/post/148754981169/the-shadow-in-the-doorway"><em>carrows-blog.tumblr.com</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=55cd2f6dbced" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[It’s Time To Stop Portraying Autistic People As ‘Aliens’]]></title>
            <description><![CDATA[<div class="medium-feed-item"><p class="medium-feed-image"><a href="https://medium.com/the-establishment/its-time-to-stop-portraying-autistic-people-as-aliens-1898bf4a23b?source=rss-3709287da95------2"><img src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1920/0*nfGgF2W6F5ZN-6HZ.jpg" width="1920"></a></p><p class="medium-feed-link"><a href="https://medium.com/the-establishment/its-time-to-stop-portraying-autistic-people-as-aliens-1898bf4a23b?source=rss-3709287da95------2">Continue reading on The Establishment »</a></p></div>]]></description>
            <link>https://medium.com/the-establishment/its-time-to-stop-portraying-autistic-people-as-aliens-1898bf4a23b?source=rss-3709287da95------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1898bf4a23b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[autism-spectrum]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[brain-body]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[representation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[essay]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[autism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[C. Narby]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 08 Sep 2016 09:00:21 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-03-30T15:09:57.770Z</atom:updated>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>