<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Carter Brooks on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Carter Brooks on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@carterbrooks?source=rss-f2afcdd0b0a5------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 10:16:02 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@carterbrooks/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The President’s tweet]]></title>
            <link>https://carterbrooks.medium.com/the-presidents-tweet-4ee137b46fed?source=rss-f2afcdd0b0a5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4ee137b46fed</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[911-truth]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tweet]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[logical-fallacies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trump]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[logical-thinking]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Carter Brooks]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 28 Nov 2020 20:37:16 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-11-29T03:11:13.426Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/610/1*dN1dOalpFcFZNrfVNBxRxQ.png" /></figure><p>Donald Trump’s baseless claims of massive voter fraud have been generally reported accurately as lacking any real evidence whatsoever. But while the mainstream media and social media willingness to call out false claims is a step in the right direction, it would be more effective if they also pointed out the <em>logical</em> fallacies in which these falsehoods are contained.</p><p>The President’s tweet yesterday illustrates one of the logical fallacies that people on all sides of the political spectrum have been falling for the last few decades… the “<a href="https://blog.hubspot.com/marketing/common-logical-fallacies">burden of proof fallacy</a>.”</p><p>In his tweet yesterday, the President asserted that it should be Biden’s responsibility to prove the President’s assertion is false.</p><h3></h3><p>Biden can only enter the White House as President if he can prove that his ridiculous &quot;80,000,000 votes&quot; were not fraudulently or illegally obtained. When you see what happened in Detroit, Atlanta, Philadelphia &amp; Milwaukee, massive voter fraud, he&#39;s got a big unsolvable problem!</p><p>In this circumstance, it is not enough to just say “but there is no real evidence of fraud or illegally cast ballots.” One also has to clearly reject the attempt to transfer the burden of proof, because failing to do so leaves room for the unproven assertion to live on, which is the point, of course, of framing things using this fallacy. As I replied to his tweet…</p><h3></h3><p>That&#39;s not how it works, Mr. President. You have to prove their WAS any fraud, not prove their wasn&#39;t. You have the basic burden of proof backwards. You are presenting a classic logical fail. Disappointing.</p><p>The burden of proof fallacy is particularly pernicious, when allowed to stand, because it is generally hard to prove something <em>didn’t</em> happen. It’s one of the reasons the principle of “innocent until proven guilty” is so important. It is simply invalid to claim something is true until <em>someone else</em> can prove it’s not. To make a claim about truth, it’s their responsibility to provide the evidence.</p><p>It’s truly amazing and alarming that the President of the United States can peddle in such a basic fallacy in pubic communications.</p><p>When responding to the President’s claims here, we should be doing more than just pointing out he has no evidence. We need to at least remind ourselves, if not others, that the premise of the logic is wrong in the first place.</p><p>Another reason to take note of this example is to recognize where else this logical fallacy is infective of our habitual discourse. It’s the core of 911 conspiracy thinking, for example—”prove to me it wasn’t a controlled demolition.” I can’t prove it <em>wasn’t</em> a controlled demolition, but that is simply not evidence that it was. Similarly, controlled demolition theories rely on the assertion that the buildings couldn’t have collapsed under the circumstances, which is an assertion that would be nearly impossible to prove, actually. Given the empirical evidence that the towers <em>did</em> collapse, one has a high burden of proof to claim it wasn’t possible given the extraordinary damage self-evident in the moment. Not understanding exactly how it happened, is not evidence that it must have happened by a theory—controlled demolition—for which there is little evidence, save one’s own lack of imagination or curiosity,.</p><p>It’s also, I believe, how many take for granted ideas like “the DNC rigged the primary” despite any real evidence, or even explanation of how that might have actually worked, or even what it means. Lacking evidence that it <em>didn’t </em>happen is taken as proof that it must have.</p><p>In fact, many of the things folks on the progressives left take for granted are seldom unburdened from rigorous proof by this very logic.</p><p>So, let’s all remember, if a person claims something is true, it is <em>their responsibility </em>to provide evidence to support the assertion, not everyone else’s responsibility to prove the opposite. Or put another way, just because there is not evidence presented against something, doesn’t automatically make that thing true.</p><p>It appears we can all call out the President for violating that standard, surely we can also do it in our casual conversation as well.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4ee137b46fed" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Election Eve 2020]]></title>
            <link>https://carterbrooks.medium.com/election-eve-2020-9d370b43f30?source=rss-f2afcdd0b0a5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9d370b43f30</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[climate-change]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[election-2020]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Carter Brooks]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 03 Nov 2020 08:37:27 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-11-04T05:21:04.586Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>On election eve in <a href="https://carterbrooks.medium.com/election-eve-for-a-climate-artist-6367031f49d7">2016, I wrote…</a></p><blockquote><em>It’s election eve. Like many people I know, I am looking forward to some cathartic relief. Or, at least just a little rest.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>The 2016 election has not only been exhausting. It’s been maddening, crazy making. Even among friends we argue over different realities and even versions of what it means to be thinking critically.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Unfortunately, the cathartic relief will be an illusion. All that the election has been exposing will still be there, and not just the racism and xenophobia, but also the struggle for sanity and critical thinking…</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>…The election may resolve tomorrow, but all the divisions between camps, all the struggles to defend critical thinking, all the infuriating frustration of a post-fact reality remain. The mistrust and cynical rejection of the institutions of government remain. The conditions for the demagogue, or the mob, remain.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Which is why I go to sleep remembering there is no rest after tomorrow.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Less rest than ever.</em></blockquote><p>Election day, of course, was devastating. It was the opposite of cathartic relief. Like many, I suppose, I went to sleep election night with a sense of shocked dread for the decades to come. Within a few days, Timothy Synder, a professor of history at Yale, wrote a Facebook post that went viral, “Twenty Lessons from the Twentieth Century,” which he later expanded into a short book, <em>On Tyranny</em>. He also made rounds in the talk show circuit warning that we maybe had 6 months before it may be too late to save democracy.</p><p>Now, 4 years later, many, if not most of our worst fears are realized. Trump has appointed 3 Supreme Court justices, and more Federal judges. We are in the middle of the global crisis — a pandemic — for which lack of thoughtful leadership has resulted in expected catastrophe. Incessant lying has accelerated the post-truth conditions of our public conversation. What was a nascent return of voter suppression in 2016 is an all out and brazen attack on voting rights, and faith in the results.</p><p>Most disturbingly, perhaps, we are seeing the paramilitaries Timothy Synder told us to be wary of…</p><blockquote><em>When the men with guns who have always claimed to be against the system start wearing uniforms and marching with torches and pictures of a leader, the end is nigh. When the </em><a href="https://www.nytimes.com/video/us/100000007424380/police-black-lives-matter-protests.html?referringSource=articleShare&amp;fbclid=IwAR336yihui55zOv92zJRDpssBKo4Xv6m2rk3KnCM6XUlwFeMH9xw8NJHTTs"><em>pro-leader paramilitary and the official police and military intermingle</em></a><em>, the end has come.</em></blockquote><p>The “Trump Train” parade of flag waiving trucks loaded with armed boys driving around with the intent of intimidating is strikingly similar to the same images of ISIS fighters in the middle east, as many a meme and cartoon have noted.</p><p>Meanwhile, distracted by our domestic situation, we aren’t even noticing how the US’s absence from the world stage has ceded the field for China’s ambitions, whose style of authoritarianism we may all end up under in time.</p><p>In fact, we also aren’t noticing how the effects of climate change are not only accelerating, but also part of what is creating the chaotic conditions that help drive the domestic mob, or the appeal of a demagogue.</p><p>So, again, I go to sleep on election eve remembering the same thing I did in 2016. There is, unfortunately, no rest after tomorrow. Less rest than ever.</p><p><a href="https://www.facebook.com/thisisnotadrill.us">This is not a drill.</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9d370b43f30" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why I’m not voting for Bernie Sanders]]></title>
            <link>https://carterbrooks.medium.com/why-im-not-voting-for-bernie-sanders-d70f08cf563e?source=rss-f2afcdd0b0a5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d70f08cf563e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[bernie-sanders]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[democratic-primary]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Carter Brooks]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 29 Feb 2020 00:08:43 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-03-11T08:31:45.255Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/905/1*cDlpF_iLRsK4U-84QckgNA.png" /></figure><p>I’m not voting for Bernie Sanders for the Democratic nomination. I’m not voting for him now for the same reason I didn’t vote for him in 2016… I wouldn’t want him as my president. It’s that simple. I wouldn’t want him as president, because of how <a href="https://medium.com/@mirthbottle/what-i-dislike-about-bernie-sanders-campaign-e3d95490339e">his rhetoric has destroyed thoughtful political discourse</a>. It’s no secret that stating publicly one is not voting for Bernie Sanders for the Democratic nomination is bound to bring on all sorts of grief from his supporters, most of which is impossible to reason with. That’s a result of how Bernie has framed his politics, and it’s not what I’m looking for in a president, no matter how much I might be sympathetic to his policy objectives. As a dear friend of mine puts it about Bernie, “I’m rejecting you <em>in spite </em>of your politics, dude, not because of them.”</p><p>A vote for president ought to be just that, a vote for who is going to do the best job. The best job steering a lumbering ship of state. For me, and at least a few other friends I can count, it’s a job interview, like <a href="https://www.esquire.com/entertainment/tv/news/a45781/louis-ck-plane-election-analogy/">picking a pilot to fly your plane</a>. It’s not a referendum on policy issues, an opportunity to send a signal to the establishment, a “last chance at system change,” a game theory exercise driven by polling, a position statement on my personal values, or any of the other convoluted rationales people are fond of layering onto their decision. It’s a vote for a fucking position, President. Period.</p><p>This is as true in the primary as it is in the general election. In either case it’s a choice of available options, not ideal ones. As former marine Jake Cusack <a href="https://qz.com/827376/america-is-more-fragile-than-you-think-a-marine-corps-officer-on-why-voters-must-defeat-donald-trump/">wrote</a> in 2016, to warn that “<a href="https://qz.com/827376/america-is-more-fragile-than-you-think-a-marine-corps-officer-on-why-voters-must-defeat-donald-trump/">what we have is more fragile than you think</a>” :</p><blockquote>“For those who say they’d rather not decide between flawed choices, I’d ask them to think about what life is like every day for our troops in Iraq and Afghanistan. <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MFOkBnYGfIM&amp;feature=youtu.be">They don’t have the luxury of abstaining or making a protest vote on the flawed options they see before them every day</a>.</blockquote><blockquote>Our country does not ask for much in the way of national service — indeed, it should ask for more. A thoughtful and considered vote … is the bare minimum.”</blockquote><p>It’s why I didn’t vote for Ralph Nader in 2000, even though I was in a “safe” state of California. I wouldn’t have wanted him as president either, no matter how much I might support many of his values. It’s not thoughtful or considered to use a presidential vote as a scheme to get 3rd party funding for a party that had at best one mayor in elected office (not to mention any state or national legislators.) It’s not thoughtful or considered to protest vote, either. At least, not in a presidential election.</p><p>As my friends can attest, I’ve been a vocal critic of Bernie from the start, despite the discomfort it’s caused for many friendships or my own reputation in certain communities. What I’ve discovered in the process, is that a lot of folks, particularly women, feel shouted down for pointing out any nuance that might be percieved as being critical of Bernie or the theory of the Berner revolution. So there is a reason to be a voice and take the punches, despite the bewilderment of the Berners in my life. Little has changed since 2016. The same things that concerned me then, concern me now, and they’ve played out as expected.</p><p>It was, in fact, the first stump speech I heard Bernie give that illustrates why I don’t want him as my president. In his speech he said, “I’m going to tell you something no one else will… I’m not going to be able to do everything I say I want to do.” My interest was piqued, because that’s true. It’s frank. It’s true for a whole host of reasons. But then he finished the thought by saying, “…because Wall Street won’t let me.” And that’s just not true. It’s only a fraction of truth. It’s a misleading simplification to blame an amorphous and almost undefinable “Wall Street” (or “billionaires” or “establishment”) for something that involves so many other realities, like a stalemated and obstructionist congress, existing institutions, structural factors that are no one’s fault, not to mention the fact that some things simply take time. In this way, Bernie’s rhetoric is almost identical to Nader’s in 2000. “The whole system is corrupt,” and by definition anyone in it.</p><p>2000 was a disaster, of course. It wasn’t just that Nader offered a 3rd party alternative that was problematic. It was how his campaign and the logic behind it undermined reasoned discourse. If you weren’t supporting Nader, people accused you of “being with the ‘corporatists’” or “believing in the status quo.” People were confronted with making their presidential vote about something other than choosing a president. The vote was treated as a referendum on ideals. Nader was in no way qualified to run the government, nor did his party have any experience or infrastructure to do so. I myself was caught up in it until 7pm on the west coast, when my head got clear, and I decided to treat my vote for president like nothing else but a vote for president. What was I even thinking?</p><p>It was only a few days after hearing Bernie’s stump speech that I ran into a friend who worked in state government on the bus. She told me she’d been listening to Bernie and had an awful feeling we were going to have 2000 all over again. I knew exactly what she meant. In fact, almost all my friends who worked in government voiced the same concern—that people don’t really have an appreciation for how slowly most government change happens in practice. Unreasonable expectations leads to conflict when anyone then tries to point out reasonable realities.</p><p>Bernie’s politics celebrates anger and impatience. Anger at what is, and impatience that it should be something different. Encouraging impatience is super unhelpful, however. He’s made it impossible for me to have rational political conversation with many of my friends. And he’s done it in the same way Trump has, by blaming an “other” for all problems. Trump’s primary villains are immigrants and muslims. Bernie’s are “billionaires,” “the corporations” and the “democratic establishment.” Bernie is not Trump, obviously. Not even close. But the general appeal to impatient populism is the same, and as worrisome. It’s no surprise that there is a popularity among the youth—who weren’t around in 2000, so can’t be expected to know how they are being fooled again. Having the same position forever is not something I’m looking for, either. To quote Bret Stephens out of <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2020/02/28/opinion/bernie-sanders-2020.html?action=click&amp;module=Opinion&amp;pgtype=Homepage&amp;fbclid=IwAR2YoyPDXCcofSG8gfOuhctZIMMeKSTl9elhAJjF0eelNcAXW9W3Kzrjsqs">context</a>…</p><blockquote>To have our convictions knocked sideways by stronger arguments, fresh experiences, contrary evidence, maturing judgment, or simply the honesty of a second-guessing mind, is how we become educated.</blockquote><p>I’m as concerned with defeating Trumpism as I am with defeating Trump. Whipping up anger, impatience towards an unanswerable villain naturally ends up at the bullying people to join your bandwagon and the “<a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2020/02/27/opinion/bernie-sanders.html">demand for ideological purity among your friends</a>” that is characteristic of many (but obviously not all) of the Berner evangelists that were already in my life or have crossed my path. I’m not voting for more of that. It is definitely not the sort of leadership I’m looking for in a president.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d70f08cf563e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Asshole Politics]]></title>
            <link>https://carterbrooks.medium.com/asshole-politics-667cf15c791c?source=rss-f2afcdd0b0a5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/667cf15c791c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[donald-trump]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Carter Brooks]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 14 Dec 2018 23:14:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-12-14T23:14:46.001Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Donald Trump is an asshole. Obviously. In fact, only an asshole would argue otherwise. It’s not all he is, of course. He’s also a narcissist, a wannabe authoritarian, a danger, an idiot, and the list goes on. But there is a <em>particular usefulness</em> of remembering he is— categorically—an asshole. Not because it’s funny, but because a good theory of the asshole explains a lot—both how he can be dismissive of our most basic norms, and why our response tends to be so exhausting and impotent.</p><p>The urgency of considering assholes generally goes beyond Donald Trump, as we are also suffering a more general asshole epidemic. Assholes are now installed in leadership and decision making positions within our core democratic institution, including our courts. Assholes are in your parking lot as the driver of the pickup-on-steroids parked across two parking spaces. This is not to mention other assholes on the geopolitical stage. Explosions in asshole populations overwhelm the normal asshole dampening mechanisms cooperative societies take for granted. Eventually we end up with asshole systems—asshole capitalism and asshole politics—at which point a society is vulnerable to decay, or worse. (Like, just fascism.) So, this is not a drill.</p><p>The most insightful and entertaining thinker on the subject of the asshole is undoubtedly Aaron James, author of <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Assholes-Theory-Aaron-James/dp/0804171351/"><em>Assholes: A Theory</em></a>. He noticed that though we have no problem identifying that we find assholes deeply bothersome, we often have a hard time identifying why. And when we don’t notice why, exactly, the asshole bothers us, we aren’t very effective in our asshole management.</p><p>All of which is why it helps to start with the most basic of philosophical questions:</p><blockquote>What is it for someone to be an asshole?</blockquote><p>That is, what is the definition of an asshole? What is the asshole’s consistent characteristic or practice?</p><blockquote>…If nothing else, a good answer—a good theory of the asshole—would be intellectually interesting. It would give us the concepts to finally think or say why some people disturb us so. …Ideally a good theory would be practically useful. Understanding the asshole we are stuck with might help us think constructively about how best to handle him….</blockquote><blockquote>The answer is not obvious, despite the fact that we are often personally struck dealing with people for whom there is no better name…The asshole is not just another annoying person but a deeply bothersome person—bothersome enough to trigger feeling of powerlessness, fear, or rage. To make matters worse, we may be unable to understand why exactly someone should be so disturbing. We may feel certain only that “asshole” is a suitably unsavory name for this particular person.</blockquote><p>This is why when one says “Donald Trump is an asshole,” the first response is usually, “Well, duh!” We know he’s an asshole, but it’s so obvious to us we don’t even notice we couldn’t tell you what defines him as such. Meanwhile, we’re still bewildered our system of norms can’t stop him from getting away with it. We flail about comforting ourselves we’re not assholes, by sharing eye-rolls and agreement among ourselves he’s an asshole. But without understanding the nature of what makes an asshole an asshole, we don’t even notice which buttons we are letting the asshole push, nor how we are manipulated into fighting the asshole on his terms.</p><p>Here’s the key problem of the asshole: when we’re fighting the asshole, we’re fighting for something that is important to us, but the asshole couldn’t care less about. What the asshole exposes and exploits the importance we attach to being heard and being recognized. This is one of James’ great insights…</p><blockquote>The asshole refuses to listen to our legitimate complains, and so he poses a challenge to the idea that we are each to be recognized as moral equals. This explains why the asshole is so bothersome, by revealing the great importance we attach to recognition in unexpected areas of our lives….The key is to understand why we are easily tempted to fight on the asshole’s terms: we are fighting for moral recognition in his eyes.</blockquote><p>We waste a lot of time fighting with the asshole over something that, if we considered a proper definition of asshole, we should have never expected to get anyway. A good theory of what a makes an asshole could save us a lot of trouble, or at least help more effectively managing the situation. It can inoculate us against the crazy making we are otherwise drawn into.</p><p>For an illustration of how this plays out in practice, just think about how easily the press is maneuvered into repeating Trump’s lies and thus reinforcing his frame—”the asshole’s terms.” The linguist George Lakoff, like a modern day Cassandra, has been describing how <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2018/jun/13/how-to-report-trump-media-manipulation-language">the media, in repeating Trump’s words when reporting his lies, is in fact reinforcing Trump’s terms for reality</a>. It’s a bit of a catch-22. Trump lies, because as an asshole, his sense of entitlement allows him say whatever lie he wants. We may be outraged by the lie, but challenging the lie requires repeating the lie, which in the end just reinforces the frame the lie creates. By having to refute all his lies, we just are caught arguing on the asshole’s terms, rather than, say, noticing that the entitlement to lie is a special privilege this asshole takes, and no amount of discussion, proof, or refutation of the lie is going to sway the asshole Donald Trump (nor, for that matter, those who like his style.)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*bIx0mmBKSGNaN-jzV8hulw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Donald Trump’s success also enables and emboldens the day to day asshole. Consider, for example, the experience of a friend mine who comes across a pickup taking up two parking spaces at the local supermarket during its rush hour. (Two spaces reserved for “expectant mothers and families with small children,” no less.) My friend stops to take a picture, thinking about noticing a general increase in people breaking norms at work and in the public sphere, only to turn around to find the white-male middle aged owner of the truck taking a picture of him—“if someone takes a picture of my truck, I take a picture of them.”</p><blockquote>I didn’t say anything and he climbed alone into his truck. The white bumper sticker on his tailgate was “Trump” and “Make America Great Again”. Parking solo one of these slots is a breach of a norm (nothing illegal about it). Taking two was at a minimum passive aggressive, if not openly aggressive.</blockquote><p>Not only is being caught in the breach not a deterrent for the local asshole, drawing others into responding impotently to the asshole’s norm busting is the very game the openly aggressive asshole is playing. (In Trump’s circle, Stephen Miller is the aggressive asshole on steroids with a shot of cruelty thrown in.) The wise manager of assholes is left to do as my friend did, just say nothing and watch him drive away. Saying something only satisfies yourself, but also is only necessary because you got baited into responding in the first place. Again, a catch-22. Nevertheless, one can often manage the effect the asshole on oneself, but to manage assholes collectively is not as easy, which is why a sharable and solid theory of the asshole is even more imperative.</p><p><em>Assholes: A Theory </em>has a very straightforward definition of an asshole…</p><blockquote>Our theory is simply this:</blockquote><blockquote>a person counts as an <em>asshole</em> when, and only when, he systematically allows himself to enjoy special advantages in interpersonal relations out of an entrenched sense of entitlement that immunizes him against the complains of others.</blockquote><p>As a philosophical theory, it’s not a claim about how the word is commonly used, or that everyone would agree. Rather it is a <em>constructive proposal. “</em>It tries to articulate what we ordinarily mean” so that it hopefully “captures the importance assholes have for us—where the ‘us’ is, in the first instance, you and me” The theory helps us have a focused conversation about the asshole, especially what is essential.</p><p>Donald Trump fits the theory’s three main parts …</p><blockquote>In interpersonal or cooperative relations, the asshole:</blockquote><blockquote>(1) allows himself to enjoy special advantages and does so systematically;</blockquote><blockquote>(2) does this out of an entrenched sense of entitlement; and</blockquote><blockquote>(3) is immunized by his sense of entitlement against the complaints of others</blockquote><p>With that theory every instance of Trump’s norm busted buffoonery is totally in character. It’s no longer surprising. It’s only surprising we’ve wasted so much energy expecting or even demanding for him to hear our complaints. Like you can’t expect your spouse to change, we can’t expect Trump to stop being an asshole.</p><p>No doubt this is a disturbing problem, because this asshole is the President of the United States. Our norms not being respected, means our institutions are potentially not capable of being heard or respected, at least by the man himself, if not by others. We can extend our concern to the proliferation of assholes in the general population, because they may not respect institutional authority either—for example, the findings of special counsel Mueller.</p><p>“Donald Trump is an asshole” explains how easily he can maintain a dismissive attitude towards the press. Not only does he not treat the reporters as moral equals, he doesn’t care about how people feel about what they say. If people are disturbed, then just don’t understand how his “winning” gives him a blank check. He wants to be seen as winning, but he doesn’t even know he doesn’t care about whether people think he’s a moral human. Morality doesn’t apply to him.</p><p><em>Assholes: A Theory</em> was mostly written to help us with more realistic asshole management in our everyday lives. The punchline, unfortunately, is that the best we can do usually is manage our own emotions when we run across them. Proper asshole management becomes a practice of picking our battles, and, like a meditation, focusing on our breath and letting go of a fantasy of moral clarity changing the asshole. At best, we find solace every so often silently appreciating the deft and generous management of assholes by others more patient, wise, or with more authority than us.</p><p>But James also wrote a whole chapter on “Asshole Capitalism.” He points out that something like capitalism can take on the asshole characteristics as a system, which can so strain a society as to tend it towards decay. His suggestion is not that capitalism itself produces assholes (though “that may well be true.”) What he addresses is, in his words, “a particular, increasingly prevalent <em>entitlement-oriented style</em>” of capitalism.</p><blockquote>Asshole capitalism has three essential features:</blockquote><blockquote>(1) incentives: it affirms expansive entitlements (e.g., to unbounded personal enrichment, even at social cost) that create powerful incentives for thinking like an asshole.</blockquote><blockquote>(2) undermanagement: it lacks a reliable system for dampening asshole profusion (e.g., the family or the rule of low is overpowered by the entitlement based incentives); and</blockquote><blockquote>(3) destabilization: the resulting profusion of assholes undermines the cooperation needed for a capitalist systems’ healthy functioning, according to its own founding values (of freedom, opportunity, and general prosperity). The system, in that sense, deteriorates or degrades</blockquote><p>When capitalism is working as we fantasize it should, cooperative people are upholding the norms and rules needed for everyone to enjoy freedom, opportunity and general prosperity.</p><blockquote>… But now suppose the society switches to an entitlement system (perhaps as the Entitlement Party rises to power). The system is now sending a powerful entitlement message, for instance, that having ever more is one’s moral right, even when it comes at a cost to others. As asshole thinking and culture spread and take hold, the asshole-dampening systems that used to keep assholery in check become overwhelmed. Parents start preparing their kids for an asshole economy, the law is increasingly compromised, the political system is increasingly captured, and so on. As some switch sides while others mainly withdraw, cooperative people find it more difficult to uphold the practices and institutions needed for capitalism to do right by its own values. Although the society won’t necessarily collapse—even assholes won’t prosper if they take it that far—the practices and institutions that fulfilled capitalism’s promises increasingly break down. The capitalist system, as we are putting it, degrades.</blockquote><p>A reasonable case can be made that we are already managing this situation. With Donald Trump, we are certainly seeing people “switch sides,”—i.e., double down on backing Trump, adopting the immunity to the complaints of others—as well confronting great difficulty upholding our basic institutions and norms. Much has been made of how much our institutions have depended on informal norms, which puts a new urgency on addressing the asshole dynamic, which mostly plays out in and insult to informal daily norms.</p><p>Though James’ sees asshole politics as a subset of asshole capitalism, one can reasonably argue that asshole politics itself is the more urgent systemic crisis in its own right.</p><p>In fact, the political system has already been “increasingly captured” by asshole thinking since Newt Gingrich changed the rules of the game. If there was ever an asshole move, it was Newt’s refusing to cooperate with Democrats to stall any action in Congress, and then effectively whipping up anger at Democrats for not getting anything done, which swept Replublicans into control of the House under Bill Clinton. Donald Trump, Mitch McConnell, and the rest of the contemporary Republican party are playing out the mature entrenched state of this “capturing”. How else do we get Merrick Garland’s seat on the Supreme Court refused? Or Brett Kavanaugh able to act like an asshole in confirmation hearings, and be celebrated rather then disqualified for it?</p><p>Asshole politics is a real problem. We now have an asshole president defining the terms, backed up by asshole thinking at every level. Trying to simply defend our norms and institutions is going to be a challenge, because it exactly the entitlement to ignore these that is the central feature of an asshole system—i.e., “undermanagement”. Hearing our defense of these norms or institutions is exactly what the asshole is immune to. As this takes on geo-political consequences, the prognosis is, well, a bit dire.</p><p>The stakes are high, and as they relate to Donald Trump can be illustrated by <em>Assholes: A Theory</em>. I thought I was being clever noticing Donald Trump fit James’ theory of an asshole, but when I went back to look for quotes for this piece, I found Donald Trump on page 2, offered up as example. Though writing way back in 2012, Donald Trump is bracketed by modern political demagogues and descriptions of fake news in a bit surreal and sobering foreshadowing…</p><blockquote>“… we might think of such contemporary figures as former Italian president Silvio Berlusconi, Venezuelan president Hugo Chavez, or Iranian president Mahmoud Ahmadinejad. We might think of the self-important developer-entertainer Donald Trump, the harsh pop music critic Simon Cowell, or the narcissist actor Mel Gibson. Assholes are found on cable news, where hosts repeatedly interrupt their guests, and also on talk radio, where airtime is given to commentators who thrive on falsehood and invective. Even as this demonstrably degrades the public debate so vial for a healthy democratic society…”</blockquote><p>Now, two years into the Trump presidency, the public debate is already degraded. To start to be more effective addressing that situation, understanding how asshole thinking makes our usual tools ineffective is going to be important in transforming the reality back towards cooperation. While a simple theory of the asshole helps us tremendously, further consideration to the nuances is also needed, because assholes come in many flavors. Understanding <em>sort</em> of asshole we have in Donald Trump gives us insights into the particular tactics he uses or weaknesses he exploits.</p><p>Fortunately for us, Aaron James has already gotten started. See, when I went to lookup a link for <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Assholes-Theory-Aaron-James/dp/0804171351"><em>Assholes: A Theory</em></a><em>,</em> I discovered a more recent book: <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Assholes-Theory-Donald-Aaron-James/dp/0385542038"><em>Assholes: A Theory of Donald Trump</em></a> by—(you guessed it)—Aaron James. A book written “in a rush, in view of the philosophical emergency” and released before the 2016 election, it’s final chapters revisits the foreshadowing above.</p><blockquote>As bad as things are, the can get worse, much worse. Berlusconi ravaged Italy for many years, and the country still languishes. The populist Hugo Chavez left Venezuela in tatters. Our union, of the greatest republics since the Roman Empire, can devolve into authoritarianism in the style of Putin, who, like Trump, is willing to use force and dominance in the name of Russia’s restoration to greatness. We have a strong judiciary, and presidential power is limited (though expanding), but our fragile separation of powers has limits. If we love America, the idea and the country, we cannot test them further.</blockquote><p>Can it happen here? Could the US devolve into authoritarianism in the style of Putin’s Russia? Or worse, Nazi Germany? Or something just as bad but with it’s own American flavor? Whichever version of authoritarianism we may be at risk of, the surest way to let it happen is to not believe it’s possible. If we don’t imagine it is possible, we risk not taking seriously each of the steps in that direction, like the undermining of our norms.</p><p>So it is not encouraging that one of the particular tactics and forms of asshole behavior characterizing both Donal Trump and the culture generally is a selective nihilism. “Who knows, we’ll see,” end almost any statement by the Donald. It is an uncomfortable echo, as the Nazi 30’s, by many accounts, were also characterized by a similar popular nihilism. That’s one reason the battle over “fake news” is so real and important.</p><p>Another disturbing parallel is the genre of asshole we have in Donald Trump, which James labels the “Ass-Clown.” The Ass-Clown is both a showman and an entertainer. The type that we can’t help watching, but also have a hard time taking seriously. Many in the 30’s also had a hard time taking Hitler seriously until it was too late. While comparisons to Hitler are often taken as extreme, asshole theory helps us treat the comparison with a bit of equanimity.</p><p>In theory, the problem of the potential demagogue is exactly what our system of checks and balances of our system was designed for. Though it’s not clear whether the founding fathers realized how much the strength of the institutions would come to rely on individuals upholding informal norms, or people actually stepping up to their duty. Congress’ ethics officer hasn’t, for example, been able to get Donald Trump to actually divest from his businesses, contrary to precedent or expectations. For the checks to work our faith in the system can’t be a passive faith. The institutions still have to do their job.</p><p>I am reminded of the joke about the man during a flood, who is sitting on his porch as the waters rise. When a neighbor comes by and offers him a ride to evacuate, he replies “No thanks, God will save me.” Soon the waters have reached the first floor of his home. When another rescuer comes by with a boat, he waves them off, “God will save me.” Eventually he’s on the roof as a helicopter lowers a rope, “No, thanks, God will save me.” The flood waters keep rising and he drowns. Up in heaven he asks God, “I thought you would save me, why didn’t you do anything?” to which God replies, “Hey, I sent you a car, a boat, a helicopter…”</p><p>With asshole politics, we’ve not been very successful at turning it back while it escalates. What we’ve discovered, if anything, is how much of our system has relied upon unwritten and informal norms. When an asshole comes along who feels entitled to break those norms our institutions fail. At this point, asshole politics is entrenched and mature enough that we increasingly need a miraculous and spectacular type of failure to reset the balance—“Our institutions will save us”—which becomes increasingly a long shot. At this point asshole politics needs to fail and to be seen conspicuously doing so.</p><p>Confronting the nihilism taking hold in the general population may mean we all have to confront it on a daily basis, whether with our Fox News watching parents or in-laws, or the white nationalist marchers chanting “we will not be replaced.” While we may be lucky if our institutions are able to hold Donald Trump accountable, we still need to deal with the groundswell of nihilistic thinking all around us in our every day lives, if the society is going to actually respect the outcome, not to mention the systemic asshole politics in the Senate, House and state legislatures.</p><p>One benefit of seeing these daily encounters through the frame of asshole politics is that it allows us to approach the situation with some level of equanimity. If we know the problem is that the asshole is immune to moral reasoning, we can remove the emotional charge, we can avoid being triggered ourselves, wasting energy on making moral arguments, while still refusing to let the asshole take the special privilege he attempts to.</p><p>A first step might be to take seriously one of Timothy Synder’s lessons from his short book <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Tyranny-Twenty-Lessons-Twentieth-Century/dp/0804190119/"><em>On Tyranny</em></a><em>…</em></p><blockquote>12. Make eye contact and small talk.</blockquote><blockquote>This is not just polite. It is part of being a citizen and a responsible member of society. It is also a way to stay in touch with your surroundings, break down social barriers, and understand whom you should and should not trust. If we enter a culture of denunciation, you will want to know the psychological landscape of your daily life.</blockquote><p>There are many dimensions to this suggestion. The context for Synder is preparing for basic survival when things get truly dystopian. However, as an asshole dampening practice it also has application. Not only does the practice help us be more aware of the level of assholes in the landscape of our daily lives, but it may also help in asshole dampening. Extending even the slightest humanity to the asshole may still generate some resistance to the asshole in training’s subconscious.</p><p>We may not have control over the systemic trends of asshole politics, but we can start a more concerted groundswell of asshole dampening as it touches our daily lives. This might mean breaking the rule of avoiding political discussions in our holiday family settings. At least we might gently push back on creeping nihilism where it has taken hold in our personal relationships.</p><p>Asshole theory is not a magic hammer for dealing with Donald Trump or the rise of right wing nationalism globally. The morality that assholes and asshole politics are immune to is still important to keep alive. That said, understanding assholes, maintaining a functional asshole monitor gives us, at the very least, a more robust diagnosis of the situation, if not blinding clarity and insight.</p><p>By recognizing the immunity to moral reasoning inherent in the asshole dynamic, we can find more equanimity in ourselves, while simultaneously being more effective at asshole dampening as a practical matter. It’s not just our personal sanity that is at stake. It may be the future of the world.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=667cf15c791c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why I’m still arguing with Bernie Bros]]></title>
            <link>https://carterbrooks.medium.com/why-im-still-arguing-with-bernie-bros-e82e83c47234?source=rss-f2afcdd0b0a5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e82e83c47234</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[hillary-clinton]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bernie-sanders]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bernie-bros]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Carter Brooks]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 21 Jan 2017 19:27:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-01-25T16:28:14.381Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*MMeBSKZdaEBxkpURmm9ugw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Women’s March San Francisco, January 21, 2017</figcaption></figure><p>As Donald Trump continues to act like a candidate even after the election, there’s still an argument in post-mortem about Bernie vs. Hillary, which generally centers around the idea that “Bernie would have won if only ‘they’ had let him.” Bernie supporters want to blame Clinton supporters for Trump’s victory. Like 2000, when many Nader voters refused to reflect on their contribution to the outcome, only pointing to the other mistakes as the cause, so too we have Bernie Bros argue it was more important to be angry at ‘neocolonialism’ than it was to accept peas for dinner. The logic is based on a number of assumptions that rarely get challenged in the full light of day, but which continue to be taken for granted, making discussion as frustrating as debating climate science with a climate denier. These include assumptions like there is some invisible “they” that dictated our choices, or that Clinton voters only acted out of fear and caution. If these were true, ok, but they are not, which makes further discussion an exercise of ships talking past each other in the night.</p><p>So, I recently received the following response in a Facebook thread, which I present it here, followed by some thought…</p><blockquote>Sorry guys, you are just flat out wrong and need to accept that. For three decades we have sat back and were told to be moderate, move to the center, don’t be too liberal, etc. Well, fuck that shit. If conservatives can rally their base as a “tea party” and effectively maintain a “purity test” about being conservative, we can do the same with liberal politicians. I do not want any more “new Democrats,””moderates,” or centrists. This has caused the Dem party to become completely dysfunctional where they felt that getting rid of Sanders was a good idea — it wasn’t. Conservatives let their populist candidate win, and we squashed ours out of fear and caution….and, how did that turn out for us? So, spare me your entitled, arrogant, attitudes and get on the train, or get run over. “Progressives” like YOU caused Trump to win — that is a FACT!</blockquote><p>Here’s my response…</p><p>…you literally are the embodiment of what these articles are highlighting. You are “that guy.” That guy who will “<a href="https://medium.com/@sammystyle77/the-nihilistic-purity-of-the-far-left-will-kill-us-all-54169b25e3a8#.byk2qo8pc">throw away their votes on crackpot third-party candidates so they can preen to everyone how “radical” or “revolutionary” they supposedly are and to try and shame people who consistently vote Democrat as ignorant and brainwashed sheep</a>.” You are actually arguing that the “purity test” IS more important than sanity in our vote. That it’s more important to teach the democrats some lesson you think you know the answer to, than it is to make a thoughtful choice between Trump and Clinton when faced with it. Meanwhile, you are going to blame other people for not “giving” you the choice you want, something to excite you enough… rather than take the responsibility to make a thoughtful choice about real outcomes on election day, like whose team is packing the court.</p><p>I’ll be blunt. I find that to be adolescent thinking. It’s all about what everybody else is going to do for you. Every other sentence is about what “we have been told.” What? Is the democratic party your mother? No one’s telling me “don’t be too liberal.” No one is telling me to “move to the center.” What is twisted is that you feel your are being told to be anything. If I’m accepting that change comes slowly, or that opinions or policies often end up in the center, it’s not because I’m letting someone tell me I have to accept it, it’s that I’ve studied the world, and I notice how it works.</p><p>So, no, there is no being wrong that I ‘have to accept’ here. But not just because you are putting exclusive emphasis the wrong question, but more importantly, because I don’t actually accept most of your assertions of fact. Now, you’re clearly not questioning your assertions of fact, so there’s no use wasting energy engaging with you. In the same way there’s not much use engaging climate skeptics on climate science. …Therefore, any response here is really for the benefit of anyone else reading along who in interested in some insights…</p><p>Here’s a few places we disagree.</p><p>1) That that we’re being told to be something like “moderate,” and that’s the source of dysfunction of the democratic party.</p><p>I don’t doubt there’s dysfunction in the democratic party, but I don’t see how being centrist or moderate is any obvious cause, particularly with so many other more variables to contribute to disfunction. So, being “pure” isn’t any sort of solution to the real problems, even if one could identify them.</p><p>2) That we “we squashed our [populist candidate]”.</p><p>Here you imply, basically, that someone, somewhere pulling invisible strings stopped some “people’s choice.” Sorry, the world, or at least this world, just doesn’t work like that. Yes, we were faced with our own populist candidate, pretty much running the same anger feeding rhetoric as the other side’s populist candidate. There is no invisible “they.” No elite squashed Bernie, more people voted for something else. Simple.</p><p>3) That we voted “out of fear and caution.”</p><p>That’s a pretty common assumption among the “should have been Bernie crowd.” But it’s also wrong. I mean it sounds good if your aim is belittle people as arrogant and brainwashed, and I’m sure there are some people, somewhere who were just cautious. But I know I voted for who I preferred in the job. I gave Bernie a fair consideration, including his following. Ultimately, I decided Bernie didn’t make the cut. In choosing who I’d want actually doing the job Clinton won hands down. There’s no fear or caution there. Just a thoughtful evaluation of ALL the variables, not just a set of opinion polls. Now, if you can’t imagine anybody chosing Hillary out of anything other then fear and caution, then I submit you didn’t bother to listen or find out. That’s just willful ignorance. Willful ignorance that really can’t be blamed on anybody else.</p><p>4) That I’m telling you to “get on the train,” and therefore am being entitled, arrogant, etc.</p><p>This I can only say is in your own head. It’s revealing. It’s telling me you’re more concerned with a petty war of attitudes among… I’m not sure who. It’s unfortunate, because what it sets up is a convenient way to reject points of reality and blame others for your own irresponsibility. That is, if I point that in a presidential election one of the two major party candidates is going to win, so the only effective vote is for one or the other, that a ‘protest vote’ is effectively not participating, that’s not telling you to “get on the train.” It’s just pointing out the math. If I say 2+2=4 I’m not telling you you have “get with the crowd,” I’m just pointing out the rules of math are set. Same for incremental change. <a href="http://www.vox.com/2016/2/7/10930018/assessing-political-candidates-clinton-sanders">It’s not that I “believe” in incremental change, it’s that I understand things are complicated and incremental change is often the best you get.</a></p><p>5) That Obama won because he was a “seen as a populist.”</p><p>Wrong. Or at least way too narrow. Obama won because he is an extraordinary human being, brought a tone and nuance to his rhetoric and person that we are unlikely to see for some time to come. He won because he accepted how the system has evolved, and played his best hand. He won for a whole host of things. And he inherited a litany of problems and obstruction at every corner, and still managed to shape up a lot. To suggest his singular dimension was being “seen as a populist that cared about ordinary Americans” just so you can say, “And Bernie was one, too. See, you should have learned from Obama (who by the way I now think is a sellout)” is just downright disgusting and petty. How dare you belittle the legacy of Obama’s character as a pawn in a petty argument like this.</p><p>6) That protest votes do anything effective.</p><p>They don’t. They don’t inspire politicians to be more “courageous.” Especially, when you are protesting things that can’t really be fixed anyway. They only take your vote off the field, and more often than not just give the ball to the other team. More importantly, we disagree here because you have not (nor has anyone really) provided a compelling case for how this actually works. We have an assertion that a protest vote will induce the change, but no real explanation for what the mechanism is, how that works when part of it is giving the ball to the other team, and that’s just not something I take for granted. If a protest vote risks producing an undesirable outcome, there’s some burden of proof to prove it’s worth the risk in the first place. I see none.</p><p>7) That “people can vote for whoever they want and should not be expected to tow any party line.”</p><p>What you are actually asserting, is that people should be able to vote for whoever they want without being confronted about the outcome. I don’t think you have a right to avoid being challenged on your thinking. If you are thinking and acting like a child, and I mean that in the clinical sense I’ve described above not as an insult, you don’t have a right not to hear people say “hey, dude, grow up.” Especially when the effect of your “right” is to wash your hands of responsibility in burning down the house we all have to live in.</p><p>8) That we didn’t listen to you when “we tried to warn you.”</p><p>Here you are trying to pass off responsibility for your protest vote waste on other people. Be an adult, own that yourself. If a vote for Clinton was a vote for Trump, it’s because you made it so by your own refusal to accept the ultimate choice. Or, as it happened in practice, sold that logic to the new voters, so they could refuse to vote responsibly for you. “We tried to warn you that we would abandon you” is what you are saying. Guess what that is? Basically it’s the logic of blackmail. I’ll give you credit, you stood by your blackmail, it seems. But sabotaging the outcome and then trying to turn around and blame others for your own refusal to truly consider the reality of the outcome, that’s just gas-lighting.</p><p>As a <a href="http://qz.com/827376/america-is-more-fragile-than-you-think-a-marine-corps-officer-on-why-voters-must-defeat-donald-trump/">veteran wrote</a> before the election,</p><blockquote>“For those who say they’d rather not decide between flawed choices, I’d ask them to think about what life is like every day for our troops in Iraq and Afghanistan. They don’t have the luxury of abstaining or making a protest vote on the flawed options they see before them every day.</blockquote><blockquote>Our country does not ask for much in the way of national service — indeed, it should ask for more. A thoughtful and considered vote this November 8th is the bare minimum. I hope we can all do our duty. What we have is more fragile than you think.”</blockquote><p>It’s like given the choice to between a trained pilot or an arrogant business man to fly the plane, you can’t choose the pilot, because you’re too angry that anyone’s pointed out the choice is obvious. Such thinking is the petulance of a child, which is why so many pieces addressing this eventually come down to one refrain: Grow the fuck up.</p><p>It’s not arrogance or entitlement to say “grow up,” it’s just time to stop beating around the bush and tolerating adults being children.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e82e83c47234" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Election Eve for a Climate Artist]]></title>
            <link>https://carterbrooks.medium.com/election-eve-for-a-climate-artist-6367031f49d7?source=rss-f2afcdd0b0a5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6367031f49d7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[climate-change]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Carter Brooks]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 08 Nov 2016 09:56:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-11-08T09:56:44.628Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>It’s election eve. Like many people I know, I am looking forward to some cathartic relief. Or, at least just a little rest.</p><p>The 2016 election has not only been exhausting. It’s been maddening, crazy making. Even among friends we argue over different realities and even versions of what it means to be thinking critically.</p><p>Unfortunately, the cathartic relief will be an illusion. All that the election has been exposing will still be there, and not just the racism and xenophobia, but also the struggle for sanity and critical thinking that divides—for lack of a better term—the left.</p><p>Here on the eve of the election, there really is nothing more to do. The perfectly written paragraph is not going to suddenly wake up the protest voter. The Trump persuaded are not going get converted at the last minute. And it is, perhaps, not surprising that I find myself meditating on the long view, where we are in the context of the anthropocene.</p><p>In his piece for <em>The Atlantic, “</em><a href="http://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2016/10/trump-the-first-demagogue-of-the-anthropocene/504134/">Donald Trump Is the First Demagogue of the Anthropocene</a>,” Robinson Meyer writes:</p><blockquote>Spend enough time with some of the worst-case climate scenarios, and you may start to assume, as I did, that a major demagogue would contest the presidency in the next century. I figured that the catastrophic consequences of planetary warming would all but ensure the necessary conditions for such a leader, and I imagined their support coming from a movement motivated by ethnonationalism, economic stagnation, and hatred of immigrants and refugees. I pictured, in other words, something not so far from Trump 2016.</blockquote><blockquote>I just assumed it wouldn’t pop up until 2040.</blockquote><blockquote>This kind of worry is speculative — <em>very</em> speculative — but it is not ungrounded. A large body of scholarship suggests that climate change could exert grave effects on international politics this century. Planet-wide warming will dry out regions of the world already riven with ethnic and political strife, all the while impoverishing and destabilizing the Western powers that backstop global order. A recent study even argues that climate-triggered environmental shocks will exacerbate the very divisions that authoritarians have historically sought to exploit.</blockquote><blockquote>So to now watch a demagogue contest the presidency, running a campaign that appeals to racism and xenophobia, has felt less like the sudden apparition of an unfathomable nightmare and more like the early realization of a seasonal forecast. You can hear the long-predicted gusts, the rain pounding on the roof and the groaning thunder. It’s all just happening four decades earlier than the weather person said.</blockquote><p>In the longer story of climate change, everything is happening faster than was predicted. Around the time of my daughter’s birth in 2000, the ice cap was expected to melt away a summer 70 years off. Now we might get there in the next decade. Meyer’s realization about climate related geopolitical destabilization reminds me how often I feel like WWWIII has already started, but no one’s really noticed yet.</p><p>The sobering thought is that conditions Meyer’s speaks of have arrived. We hit the iceberg a while ago, but we’re reaching that point when the deck is starting to get suddenly steeper as the bow goes under. The election may resolve tomorrow, but all the divisions between camps, all the struggles to defend critical thinking, all the infuriating frustration of a post-fact reality remain. The mistrust and cynical rejection of the institutions of government remain. The conditions for the demagogue, or the mob, remain.</p><p>Which is why I go to sleep remembering there is no rest after tomorrow.</p><p>Less rest than ever.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6367031f49d7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Through the Eyes of a Climate Artist]]></title>
            <link>https://carterbrooks.medium.com/through-the-eyes-of-a-climate-artist-4696d57c0d6a?source=rss-f2afcdd0b0a5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4696d57c0d6a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[climate-change]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[environment]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Carter Brooks]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 16 May 2014 00:00:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-04-26T04:26:45.559Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Nxj1KGysCalWEbq_8E0IYA.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>Artist statement for Mountain Film in Telluride, 2014. by Carter Brooks</em></p><p>During the late 1990s, while my brother, Cameron, was assistant director of Mountainfilm, I was a regular. So I’m excited to return after more than a decade’s hiatus, and it’s fortuitous that the word in the air this year is “wilderness.” Cameron wrote his senior college paper on the Wilderness Act, perhaps inspired by a class we both took with the legendary philosopher-turned-environmental-historian Bill Cronon. Cronon taught us how our mental concept of wilderness and nature affected how we manifest ourselves on the landscape, whether we were conscious of it or not.</p><p>The year was 1988, and climate change wasn’t yet on my radar. In fact, it was just stepping onto the public stage. The IPCC was formed that year, and Jim Hansen gave his now-historical first testimony on climate change before the U.S. Senate. A year later, Bill McKibben published the first book on the subject for the general public, The End of Nature, in which he pointed out the surreal realization that an untouched nature wasn’t possible anymore, now that we’ve changed the air.</p><p>In the intervening years, things have, well, changed. Last year, just a few weeks before my twenty-fifth reunion, CO2 concentrations in our atmosphere passed 400 ppm. We’ve set the atmosphere back 2 million plus years to a different geologic epoch. We talk daily and matter of factly about the ice cap melting and measuring carbon footprints, while bemoaning humanity’s tendency not to take action until the consequences are obvious — when they are dire and already upon us.</p><p>Echos of Cronon’s class are as relevant as ever when it comes to climate change, not just for the profound challenge to our idea of nature it implies, but also because those ideas shape our response. Perhaps this is seen most clearly in the way our concept of nature as a symbol of virtue results in an incredible overemphasis on what individuals can personally, virtuously, do to “save” it. This, unfortunately, comes at the expense of focusing on systematic changes. We can see it play out in the public conversation, the vitriol of the political spat, right down to neighborly tensions over SUVs versus Priuses.</p><p>Conceptual metaphors in language unrelated to nature also shape our actions. Think about the dominant conceptual metaphor: “Change is motion.” We speak of climate change as “speeding up,” having “momentum,” and are even so bold as to suggest the goal is to “stop” climate change. For substantial natural changes a big rolling boulder comes to mind. Our general call for mass behaviour change is, in a way, an organizational principle that is a natural entailment of this metaphor. We can conceive of “stopping” climate change because we can imagine the boulder coming to rest.</p><p>The truth, I daresay, is more complex — a bit more sobering, too. A better metaphor might be a big wave. In fact, truly wrapping our head around it may require taking the advice of the great Donella Meadows to “be unattached in the arena of paradigms.” She was speaking about leverage points in systems. But I think what she was getting at was that in order to see complex systems truly requires a profound act of letting go: “It is in the space of mastery over paradigms that people throw off addictions, live in constant joy, bring down empires, get locked up or burned at the stake or crucified or shot, and have impacts that last for millennia.” And isn’t that the current challenge? To have an impact on the situation on a millennial scale?</p><p>One of the roles of artists is to look at things differently. So, when I, as climate artist, look at the current global event, I don’t see a “problem,” for which there are “solutions.” I think civilization has a “situation,” or, as the kindred souls at the Dark Mountain Project put it recently, a “predicament.” It doesn’t imply solutions; it implies evolution. I don’t see a bunch of individuals not changing behavior. I see a civilizational organism metabolizing the earth’s stored energy. I see hundreds of millions of years of the earth’s stored photosynthesis risen up and animated at once in the form of a sort-of-industrial meta-being. With a big sugar pile that no one can guard. That’s not a problem that can just be solved. It, perhaps, implies a different sort of response.</p><p>For this reason, I like to talk about climate art as an art and a philosophy. The art is to come at the situation from a different angle. The philosophy, well, that’s a longer conversation…</p><p>Considering wilderness at this moment may be about softening our focus on time. The wild being in me is haunted by the images David Breashears showed us years ago in the Sheridan Opera House of the Himalayan glaciers’ dramatic deflation. Living geology passing before our eyes. To find the wild in ourselves is to find the dignity of humanity from that time when the energy efficiency of our body was our advantage on the shelterless plain. With that dignity, be present and bear witness. See the eons of time dissolving into the air and melting before you, and marvel at the responsibility and excitement of being alive on the planet at this moment.</p><p>— Carter Brooks</p><p>Original Post<br><a href="http://www.mountainfilm.org/2014/05/16/climate-change-through-the-eyes-of-a-climate-artist">www.mountainfilm.org/2014/05/16/climate-change-through-the-eyes-of-a-climate-artist</a></p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="http://carterbrooks.com/through-the-eyes-of-a-climate-artist/"><em>carterbrooks.com</em></a><em> on May 16, 2014.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4696d57c0d6a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>