<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Brendan Carty on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Brendan Carty on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@carty.brendan?source=rss-4dbc64ba0474------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 09:08:27 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@carty.brendan/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Bailout Nation]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@carty.brendan/bailout-nation-e2b5e964a5fb?source=rss-4dbc64ba0474------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e2b5e964a5fb</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[barry-ritholtz]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dodd-frank]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bitcoin]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[donald-trump]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Brendan Carty]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 15 Mar 2018 19:50:55 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-03-15T19:50:55.655Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Today could be looked at in the near future as a pivotal day. While everyone is talking about Stormy Daniels, the Senate passed the rollback of banking rules enacted after the financial crisis one decade ago. Dodd-Frank was the legislation passed in 2010 as a response to financial crisis of 2007–2008 that brought significant regulation to the financial services industry. The new bill would let hundreds of smaller banks avoid some federal oversight intended to prevent another banking crisis. Banks with $50 Billion in assets are considered a higher systemic risk and are governed under more stringent regulations. The bill passed by the Senate today increases that asset threshold from $50 Billion to $250 Billion leaving small and medium sized banks with less government oversight. Mortgage rules for smaller lenders would also be eased and relieved of strict regulation. Proponents of the bill suggest it will help banks better serve customers and communities. Some critics suggest the loosening of regulations will lead to predatory lending practices that catalyzed the global banking crisis ten years ago. I think now is a good time to revisit a class book that tells the story of the Global Financial Crisis of 2007–2008 and explore what actions led to the melt down. This is also a reminder of why Bitcoin exists and why cryptocurrency is so important.</p><p>Between the volatility of Bitcoin’s price and the recent onslaught of negative opinions about the cryptocurrency, some doubt may creep into your own mind about whether Bitcoin is viable or not. Well, the reminder you need to quell that fear and doubt is the book Bailout Nation: How Greed and Easy Money Corrupted Wall Street and Shook the World Economy by Barry Ritholtz. Published in 2009, this book revisits the global financial crisis caused by bad debt created by America’s largest and most powerful banks. Barry delves into how this crisis was created and how it became acceptable for corporations to ask the government for relief when their bets went bad.</p><p>As a Bitcoin holder and supporter, this book helped me to understand the history of banking and investment in America, as well as understand what the creators of Bitcoin were thinking when they were researching and creating the cryptocurrency. There are many reasons to buy Bitcoin, whether you want a decentralized global currency, instant transactions that can be made 24/7, an immutable payment method, or some other feature that fiat does not provide. I know the reason I buy Bitcoin is to protect myself from inflation and the slow and steady looting of my savings by the US government. It is evident Satoshi had that in mind too by the message he encrypted in the Bitcoin Genesis Block: “The Times 03/Jan/2009 Chancellor on brink of second bailout for banks”. At the time Bitcoin was launched by Satoshi, a global banking crisis was in full swing and national governments were handing out unfathomable amounts of cash to the World’s largest investment banks in order to maintain confidence in the banking system and prevent all-out global chaos. No doubt, Satoshi had seen many corporate bailouts over the decades and could not stand to see the government take taxpayer money and give it to reckless and incompetent corporate executives. Thankfully for us, he didn’t grab a picket sign and march around his local city hall screaming about fairness. Satoshi was prepared for this moment, when corporate excess and greed bubbled over, so he could launch his new and improved form of money on the World.</p><p>Barry Ritholtz pulls no punches in this book as he describes how America became a bailout nation corrupted by the greed of Wall Street. A former Wall Streeter himself, Barry gives us a financial history lesson on how the United States evolved from a rugged, independent nation to a soft Bailout Nation. Barry explains how the US was once a nation of independent risk-takers who rejected the idea of a central bank. Ritholtz quotes one of America’s founding fathers, Thomas Jefferson, as saying: “If the American People allow private banks to control the issuance of their currency, first by inflation and then by deflation, the banks and corporations that will grow up around them will deprive The People of all their Property until their Children will wake up homeless on the continent their Fathers conquered.” Throughout the book, Barry shows how those ideas that America was founded on are long gone. Bailout Nation tells the story of a government that is petrified of the world losing faith in the US banking system, a Federal Reserve who slowly seized power over the American banking system, and the world’s wealthiest investment bankers who threatened global collapse to pick America’s pocket.</p><p>What I like most about this book is that Barry does not have a political agenda. He is not an anarchist or a libertarian. He didn’t even know what Bitcoin was at the time the book was published. He is just a smart guy who watched the shenanigans of The Fed and Wall Street for years, then predicted the mortgage crisis and subsequent credit collapse. He casually mentions in the book that his investment firm did short Lehman and AIG before they both went under. So he was able to cash in on this historical orgy of incompetence and greed. Ritholtz has a lot in common with Satoshi in that they took action when they discovered that there were corruption and fraud going on around them. That is what I think about each time I convert my US dollars into Bitcoin. After each chapter of Bailout Nation that I read, my confidence in Bitcoin was reinforced. The book helped me reaffirm what I already believed and it inspired me to take action. The purchase of Bitcoin is a short of the US dollar.</p><p>This story also has plenty of characters that we still hear from today and think their opinions are valid. Jamie Dimon, Chairman, and CEO of JP Morgan Chase Bank makes an appearance in Bailout Nation. Everybody wants to know his opinion on Bitcoin. He did NOT approve of Bitcoin six months ago, but since then he has changed his mind and will be opening a crypto trading desk at JP Morgan. It didn’t take long for him to succumb to the profitability that attracts almost everyone to Bitcoin. Warren Buffet is another major name who makes a cameo in Bailout Nation. Warren is a current Bitcoin hater, but he did have interest in a particular investment bank that failed miserably in 2008. He is a value investor though, and growth and new technology are investments that he explicitly stays away from. Stick to your guns Warren! We also hear from various Fed Chairmen and Treasury Secretaries with idealistic views on markets and the economy. None of their philosophies worked as we will see in Bailout Nation.</p><p>First and foremost, I am not going to explain what Collateralized Debt Obligations (CDOs) or Credit Default Swaps (CDSs) are. I am not sophisticated enough to fully understand what they are myself so there is no way in hell I will be able to properly explain them to anyone else. Go watch the movie The Big Short, they attempt to explain it but I think it was just an excuse to put Margot Robbie in a bathtub. I do know that the CDOs these big banks were passing around like a hot potato were made up of bundled mortgages that were not going to be paid back due to the fact that the people who took out these mortgages were not qualified to buy a house in the first place. The CDOs and CDSs are also known as derivatives which are the investment vehicle so many of these major financial institutions held during the financial collapse. It is important to have a grasp on what derivatives are for the understanding of Bailout Nation.</p><p>Barry begins his introduction to Bailout Nation by describing America as a place that used to be viewed as a rugged country full of determined and self-reliant individuals. He is disgusted to see America for what it is now. He describes the big banks on Wall Street as “market players who fail to live or die by their own swords” and as people who “Privatize gains and socialize losses.” Barry is a Wall Street alum who express concern over the way executives are compensated. Through Barry’s podcast Masters in Business, I learned that during his Wall Street days he saw the majority of his peers as hard-working people who were rewarded by their skill, smarts, and ability to identify opportunity while managing risk. What he observes in this new era of business are CEOs who are compensated for short-term profits from quarter to quarter with no vision for the long run. If they have a few bad quarters these executives are outed, but not without a huge bonus. We will see how this management style catalyzed the largest economic disaster since the Great Depression.</p><p>First, Barry gives us a history lesson. The history of the Federal Reserve, which was created in 1913, is crucial in understanding what led to a free-for-all money grab that occurred nearly 100 years later. Originally, the Federal Reserve, a.k.a. “the Fed”, only had modest fiscal and monetary powers. The Central Bank was brought into existence to establish financial order in a country that had over 50 different currencies in circulation. Throughout the book, Barry masterfully shows us how the Fed used each economic crisis over the next 100 years to ratchet up their power and seize control over the decision making regarding government funds. Barry describes the new era of the Federal Reserve System as an organization that has behaved as though it were in charge of anything economic. The Fed now has responsibilities in moderating swings in the business cycle, maintaining interest rates, and most shockingly, supporting the value of depreciating assets even if that means intervening with the stock market.</p><p>During the Great Depression era and World War II, widespread economic turmoil and political discontent forced the government to engage in a series of economic stimuli designed to create jobs, income, and economic activity. Roosevelt’s New Deal pumped money into emerging industries and let companies compete for dominance. A winner would emerge and the losers would move on. Boom and Bust were common and widely accepted as part of the innovation process. Bubbles that popped would leave behind valuable infrastructure for companies to build upon. Recent examples of this are the Tech boom and bust of the 90s that left Amazon and Google in its wake. Bitcoin and crypto are in its boom phase and years from now there will be winners and losers declared.</p><p>Post World War II the first government intervention in corporate America was for a company whose failure could put the US defense system at risk. This event was the rescue of Lockheed Martin, the country’s biggest defense firm, in 1971. This was a pivotal moment in bailout history because Lockheed was the first bailout of a public corporation and its rescue became the blueprint for future bailouts. This bailout opened the floodgates as Penn Central was given $646M in loan guarantees in 1974 and Chrysler was given $1.5B in 1980 and Continental Illinois Bank was given $1.8B in 1984. The threat posed for the Chrysler bailout was the job security of about 200,000 people.</p><p>One of my favorite segments in this book is how Barry, who is a car aficionado, slams Chrysler and the American auto industry for spending millions of dollars and years of time lobbying the government to ease up on emissions regulations instead of simply improving the design of their automobiles. All the while, Toyota worked on creating a more cost-effective and fuel-efficient car that led them to become the number one car manufacturer in the world. He sees this era as a perfect opportunity to reboot the entire US auto sector had the government just allowed Chrysler to fail.</p><p>In addition to the government bailouts, another enemy emerged for the US taxpayer. That enemy is inflation. Barry informs us something that should be common knowledge but isn’t: Nixon took the US off the gold standard in 1971. From this point on the US dollar was no longer backed by gold or anything else but the US military. Ritholtz suggests that this was another catalyst for the US becoming a bailout nation. What resulted was an explosion of Federal Debt and money supply. Barry believes that as long as foreigners were willing to buy US Treasury securities, it became easier as the years went by for politicians and policymakers to approve bailouts that were largely financed by debt. That debt ceiling raises every year and we have just become numb to it. Below is a chart displaying the purchasing power of the dollar since the creation of the Federal Reserve. This chart isn’t included in the book, but it gives you a visual understanding of what Barry is talking about.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*pyj5gbIJpo063Vzp.jpg" /></figure><p>After the corporate bailout era that threatened job security and national security in the 70s and 80s, we had the stock market bailout era that threatened global financial stability in the 80s, 90s, and 2000s. This era was defined by keeping up the appearance of being solvent as opposed to actually being solvent. Alan Greenspan took the reigns as Fed Chairman in 1987 and as luck would have it a crisis fell into his lap with the Black Monday stock market crash. Ritholtz proves again that the Fed never lets a crisis go to waste as Greenspan used the 1987 crash to advance their role in market interventions. It is during this period of time that the Fed goes from what Barry called “lender of last resort to guarantor of asset price.”</p><p>It is important to note that the major bailout in 1987 was for the hedge fund Long Term Capital Management (LTCM) who lost a heavily leveraged bet (100:1) in emerging markets. The Fed used its authority to help work out the demise of what was a private partnership that should have died on its own. Greenspan bailed out LTCM to help maintain the psychology of the market. Ritholtz, being a man with common sense and integrity, once again questioned this decision and wondered why this investment bank wasn’t just left to go belly-up. Yes, the investors who were dumb enough to lend LTCM all that money would take a huge loss, but that is what is supposed to happen when you make a risky bet and lose. In this case, the threat LTCM used to receive a government bailout was investor confidence. You can definitely say that investment banks became more confident when they witnessed an overleveraged hedge fund receive government money for a failed private investment.</p><p>A major theme of bailout nation is moral hazard which is defined as a lack of incentive to guard against risk where one is protected from its consequences. Barry uses an example of moral hazard as someone who has extensive liability insurance on their car so they drive recklessly because they know they are covered. Barry argues that moral hazard was created in 1987 when Greenspan neglected to target inflation but instead focused on propping up asset prices. Greenspan’s tenure as Fed Chairman was characterized by his frequent reduction in interest rates with zero regards for the health of the economy. “The Maestro”, as Greenspan was called for the way he conducted the markets, was using low interest rates to promote and protect asset prices. These actions set the stage for future crises and subsequent bailouts.</p><p>Chapter 7: The Tech Wreck brings us to the 1990s tech boom where new technologies were in their “hockey stick” phase of growth and IPO’s exploded in popularity. The economy continued to expand and the Federal Reserve continued to cut interest rates. The chapter on this era is what Barry calls the “Irrational Exuberance Era.” During a speech in 1996, Alan Greenspan floated the phrase “Irrational Exuberance” hinting that the market may be overvalued but said central bankers need not be concerned about a bubble collapse. Once traders figured out Greenspan had their backs, they lost much of their restraint and the bubble eventually did in-fact collapse. Interest rates remained low and incredibly inflationary…economists warned there would be consequences…Barry says there is no free lunch.</p><p>After the 2000 stock market crash then came a recession. That brings us to the historically unique housing cycle of 2002–2007. The combination of ultra-low rates, new types of exotic mortgages, changes in lending standards, and massive securitization created the perfect storm for a housing boom. Had the country recovered from the recession in a natural way with robust job creation and healthy wage gains, which it did not, Ritholtz suggests that high-risk subprime loans and unorthodox lending methods would not have been necessary to jumpstart the housing market. Greenspan and the Fed stuck to their agenda of propping up the stock market and “combating” deflation. In November 2002, then Fed Governor and not yet Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke, made a speech referencing the government’s not-so-secret anti-deflation weapon: the printing press. Bernanke said, “Under a paper-money system, a determined government can always generate higher spending and hence positive inflation.” Ben eventually got his chance to put that printing press to good use. But what is important here is the Federal Reserve’s strategy for higher asset prices is low interest rates and more money supply.</p><p>“Ultra cheap money” was borrowed by banks and consumers alike. Residential real-estate soared and automobile sales spike. Corporate profitability was at an all-time high and commodity prices exploded. Ritholtz described all this as “imagined wealth.” Housing prices soared and people took out home equity loans to buy things. Inflation and low interest rates fueled Americans’ worst consumption habits and added to a shit ton of total consumer debt. This ended with consumers not being able to pay back this debt to the banks and defaulting on their loans. Major banks all over the world held these securities bundled with bad debt that were not going to be paid back. The housing market collapsed and economic chaos ensued. Ritholtz points out that the Fed could have prevented all this if they actually did their duty of supervising credit and lending standards instead of making sure asset prices didn’t fall. For a short period of time (2002–2007) the basis of lending money shifted from the borrower’s ability to pay back the loan to the lender’s ability to sell the debt for securitization purposes. I can’t stress enough of how good Barry Ritholtz is at describing the securitization process of derivatives and how it created a catastrophe. This is probably the best summary of the securitization process I could find in the book (page 109):</p><p><em>Wall Street could take all manner of debt — credit cards, auto loans, mortgages, student loans — and repackage them into new bundles of paper. Collateralized Debt Obligations (CDOs) paid out significantly higher interest rates than either U.S. Treasuries or blue-chip corporate bonds. And thanks to some Wall Street razzle-dazzle, they were all triple-A rated.</em></p><p>The bond rating process is just another part of the system that is rigged to favor the banks and it’s all detailed in Bailout Nation.</p><p>Chapter 10 details the subprime lending scheme and its complete lack of ethics. Exotic mortgage structures were created to target potential home buyers who wouldn’t be able to afford a home under the normal mortgage agreement. For example, the NINJA loan was aimed towards people with No Income and No Job or Assets. There were also Liar loans where no income verification was needed for loan approval. The goal was to get the buyer to be able to make payments for 90 days, just enough time to securitize the debt and sell it to someone else. The loans would have low initial “teaser” rates, but a higher rate would eventually kick in. This higher rate would come into effect after the securitization process was complete and the debt was purchased by someone else. Once the debtor could no longer make payments on the higher interest rate, the mortgage would go into default and the house would be foreclosed on. But the housing market was booming and money was being made so everyone just buried their head in the sand.</p><p>Low interest rates and unethical lending practices weren’t the only culprits for the housing market collapse and the bailouts that followed. Major regulatory changes in 1999 came about that changed the landscape of the banking world. The Gram-Leach-Bliley Act of 1999 reversed the Glass-Steagall Act of that prohibited bank holding companies from owning other financial firms. This allowed insurers, banks, and brokerage firms to merge into giant financial centers such as Citibank. These newly deregulated behemoths were now able to take on more leverage and more risk which made them unmanageable. The Commodity Futures Modernization Act of 2000 removed derivatives and credit default swaps from any and all state and regulatory oversight. Ritholtz is able to trace the roots of the CFMA back to ENRON and the thought process behind the CFMA was that self-interested, rational market participants would not endanger their firms. Greenspan shared this sentiment as well. Unfortunately, it seems this type of thinking can only be proven to work in textbooks.</p><p>Upon financial collapse, Morgan Stanley and Goldman Sachs received capital injections from the Feds, and had to change their status to commercial banks — to make it easier to obtain even more government money. The bailout money was ultimately used to enrich senior management from nine different banks at the expense of shareholders, taxpayers, and employees. Ritholtz revisits the perils of Moral Hazard in Chapter 13. He is concerned that the bailouts of 2008 and 2009 are creating moral hazard encouraging more reckless behavior in the future. When these banks were about to go under they didn’t hesitate to contact the Treasury Secretary and threaten global financial collapse. Oh, and the Treasury Secretary at the time was none other than former Goldman Sachs CEO Hank Paulson. They had a guy on the inside and received their money quickly. These bankers weren’t attempting to save the world, they were trying to protect their own wealth. In a New York Times article from 2009, it was found that the bonus pools from the nine banks that received bailout money was $32.6B while those banks lost $81B. Ritholtz sees the compensation packages for miserable performance as a wealth transfer from shareholders to C-level executives. An elaborate heist.</p><p>Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act was signed into US federal law in 2010 by Barack Obama. It brought significant changes to the financial regulatory environment that affected almost every part of the nations financial services industry. This bill brought transparency to derivatives trading and laws to prevent predatory lending practices.</p><p>This book is truly a gem filled with important information about recent US history. Ritholtz is warning us that the game is rigged and that another financial catastrophe is on the horizon, though he doesn’t specifically say that. He begins each chapter with a quote and the quote at the beginning of Chapter 14 is from one of America’s founding fathers John Adam. It reads:</p><p><em>Remember, democracy never lasts long. it soon wastes, exhausts, and murders itself. There was never a democracy yet that did not commit suicide.</em></p><p>Even the guy who is responsible for America becoming a democracy knew it wouldn’t last. Our current leader Donald Trump has taken six business bankruptcies as a businessman and now he is the head of a regime that is $20 Trillion in debt. Moral hazard isn’t a strong enough term for the situation we have going on in the White House. Trump has been very vocal about repealing Dodd-Frank and today was his first victory. No doubt moral hazard is created by relaxing banking regulations, and this just might be the beginning of deregulation. The stock markets are at an all-time high and the President is taking credit. My inclination is that Trump wants to maintain these all time highs and will promote the same tactics that Greenspan used…low rates, inflation, and deregulation.</p><p>Lucky for us, we have Bitcoin. And Bitcoin has a finite amount and is controlled by no one entity. Bitcoin doesn’t have an agenda and it isn’t friends with greedy Wall Street executives who have no moral compass. Despite the price volatility, it is doing a pretty good job at maintaining its deflationary characteristics. Who knows, maybe the next banking crisis will bring the realization that the dollar is an inferior form of money and there are better options such as Bitcoin.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e2b5e964a5fb" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>