<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Cathy Dalton on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Cathy Dalton on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@cathydalton?source=rss-3feba8a06929------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 16:23:17 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@cathydalton/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Towards new models of elderly care architecture in Ireland]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@cathydalton/towards-new-models-of-elderly-care-architecture-in-ireland-2a118c4231e0?source=rss-3feba8a06929------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2a118c4231e0</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Cathy Dalton]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 17 Apr 2020 15:35:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-04-17T18:15:26.189Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Towards new models of elderly care architecture in Ireland</strong></p><p>This article is based an unpublished chapter of my 2014 PhD thesis, largely unedited since it was first written in 2013. Reading it now, in the wake of multiple deaths in elderly care homes from coronavirus, it seems at times disturbingly prescient. Little has changed. I would only add that in the interim, I have leaned even more strongly towards sheltered housing models, with house-sized units, and co-ordinated community models based on adapted housing stock. And of course, towards State provision and management of elderly care. The current situation is in part the result of policy-makers and State agencies ignoring oft-delivered warnings, such as are articulated here, together with persisting in over-reliance on wholly medical models of care, with a lack of policy, and by extension realistic funding support for viable alternatives. The article also needs to be considered in the light of the continued, and by now truly alarming lack of investment in public sector healthcare in Ireland, and our close neighbours in the UK, and fairly obvious attempts to push healthcare in both jurisdictions in the direction of private healthcare provision in line with US practice. I will leave commentary on the comparative outcomes in relation to the Coronavirus crisis to others. We reap what we sow.</p><p><strong>Introduction</strong></p><p>The architectural environment of care, and the total culture of residential care are inextricably interlinked: the physical reality of a building, from the general (siting, overall layout) to the specific (internal space planning, and down to the level of intimate detail) impacts continuously and relentlessly on how that building is used, and directs the possibilities and constraints for use. With this in mind, I’ve set out to summarise and contextualise the current situation, in particular in Ireland, in relation to the provision of residential care for the elderly, with people with dementia viewed as a significant and potentially majority subset of the elderly residential care population of the near future. From a critical analysis, it attempts to find ways forward in relation to future provision, in relation to design of residential care for elderly people, grounded in a psychosocial view of environment, and its potential capacity to promote user wellbeing, as a prelude to the further proposal for the integration of environmental responsivity, enabled by wireless sensor networks, into the architectural model.</p><p><strong>DEMOGRAPHIC CONTEXT</strong></p><p>Any description of the context of residential care for elderly people would beincomplete without reference to demographic context. Due to a combination of factors, Ireland’s population is ageing, in line with European and global trends. The 2009 ESRI report entitled “Projecting The Impact Of Demographic Change On The Demand For And Delivery Of Health Care In Ireland”, addressed issues of healthcare provision, arising out of projected demographic change from 2006 -2021 (Layte, R. et al., 2009). Much of the information to follow is gleaned from the report. Ireland’s declining fertility rate, decreased mortality rates and increasing life expectancies all contribute to the prediction that the “elderly” that is, people aged 65 and over, will continue to form a greater and increasing proportion of the population over the coming decades. This is in keeping with increased global life expectancies over the course of the 20th century, when the average US lifespan has increased by 30 years, from an average of 48 and 51 years for men and women respectively, in 1900 (CDC,1999). In a lifespan of around 80 years, this is an enormous percentage increase. There are signs that the rate of increase in life expectancy in the US has slowed in recent years (OECD, 2013).</p><p>In Ireland, average life expectancy for men has risen from 71, in 1986, to 76.8, in 2006, and for women, from 76.8 years to 81.6 years in the same period. Net immigration between 1996 and 2006, predominantly in the 20 to 34 year age group, had the effect of temporarily “putting the brakes” on population aging in Ireland. This trend has reversed during recent years, with net emigration and unemployment in younger age groups, increasing the dependency ratio, but this has not yet been documented or analysed. Based even on the now outdated ESRI 2009 report, the proportion of population made up of people aged 65+ is predicted to increase from 11 per cent to 15.4 per cent, by 2021, with those aged 85 years and over increasing from 1.1 per cent to 2.1 per cent. The absolute number of older people is projected to rise, from 2009 to 2021, with the numbers of “very old old”, i.e. people aged 85 or over, more than doubling from 48,000 to 106,000, and those aged 74–84 years increasing from 157,000 to 248,000. The proportion of older people, now one of the lowest in the OECD, will rise to above the OECD average. While the total population is expected to rise by 21% to 2021, the proportion of population aged 65+ is expected to rise from 11 per cent to 15.4 per cent. The fall in the proportion of younger age groups is predicted to be most pronounced in Western and Southern counties; this in itself may present particular issues, where housing and care provision is required for scattered populations in rural areas. Household sizes are predicted to fall, and while women continue to live longer, the proportion (but not the number) of elderly women living alone is predicted to fall. The actual and projected increases in life expectancy in Ireland, and their impact on overall demographic trends are reflective of the situation in all developed societies, including Japan. Ireland’s population is, in fact, ageing more slowly than many other countries: while the proportion of people aged 65+ is expected to rise to 15.4 per cent by 2021, the UK the proportion of over 65s has exceeded this level since 1985.In Germany this proportion was first exceeded in 1992. The 2009 ESRI report also concludes that the manner in which care, including long-term care, is delivered is <strong>unsustainable</strong>, even if the economic situation is excluded, given the nature of demographic change, and that healthcare needs to be both restructured and made more efficient to moderate the amount of investment required. There are profound implications for society in general, most particularly in terms of housing and healthcare provision, as an older population requires more healthcare provision than a younger one, and will have specific requirements in relation to housing, arising for age-related impairment and disability. If a change in attitude and policy was required on foot of the 2009 report, that need is even more urgent in the light of more recent demographic change.</p><p>Also significant, though largely overlooked in terms of its implications, including for design of care settings and products and environments generally, is that men continue to have lower life expectancies and greater morbidity than women (Kalben, 2003). As global and Irish populations age, we can expect women to predominate in older age groups, and for that trend to become more marked, at least temporarily. Apocryphal evidence from care homes in the UK suggests that this disparity may be beginning to level out. However, in the US, where the demographic trend has progressed further, for a population of 85 years and over there are currently 100 women for every 49 men (United States Census, 2010). Designing for the elderly person of the near future implies that this increasing gender imbalance must be taken into account in the design of care environments. This may require revision of ergonomic standards at least. A further implication for research is a requirement to acknowledge the gender imbalance when involving users in the research process for designed care environments, and to take account of it in design recommendations which are based on ergonomics.</p><p><strong>Ageing and disability</strong></p><p><strong>Disability, arising from both physical and cognitive impairment, including age-related disability, is the most significant marker for a need for residential care for elderly people</strong>. (Layte, R et al., 2009). This is a useful perspective for the designer in terms of designing for an older population. Another notable feature of the ageing demographic is a consequent increase in the projected numbers of people with dementia, as the incidence of dementia increases with age. A recent report suggests that one-third of people aged 65 and over in the US die of, or with dementia (Alzheimer’s Association, 2012). Mortality from dementia increases dramatically with age. When dementia progresses to midstage, it becomes of itself a cause of disability. The use of the term “mid-stage” in somewhat misleading for the layperson, as it appears to understate thedeterioration in the person’s condition at that stage of the disease. Though disability rates for people at older ages are reducing, leading to a real increase in health status, the overall forecast is for an 18.6 per cent disability rate among Irish people aged 65 years and over in 2021, generating a forecast population withsevere disability of 147,677, of whom, based on the 2009 report and on current provision, 35,200, or approximately one-third will require long-term residential care (Layte, R et al., 2009). The number of older people with severe disability is considered to be the direct equivalent, or proxy, of those requiring long-term care. Though rates of disability in older people are decreasing, rates of illness, such as cancer, diabetes, and cardiovascular disease are increasing, in common with trends across the developed world. This is likely to result in an increase in requirements for acute bed capacity, in addition to housing and residential care. There is already a known lack of availability of “step-down care”, (i.e. of Community Hospitals), in the specific context of elderly care, so that acute hospitals are used when they are not appropriate, for example for convalescence. The HSE refers to such patients as ‘bed-lockers’, disparaging terminology which is indicative of attitudes towards elderly patients. The needs of people with dementia in either such context must be carefully considered, especially given that acute hospital environments are very stressful for many people, and that such stress is likely to have an adverse effect on cognitive status of a person with dementia. Current government policy aims to reduce acute in-patient bed places to the lowest in the OECD, replacing acute care with “community care”, the preferred model for healthcare in Ireland. While it is suggested in the ESRI report that a “continuous care” model would provide appropriate support for patients as they move from acute hospital care to convalescent or assessment bed before transition either into long term care or back home, perhaps with community support, it may considerably more practical for step-down/respite care to be co-located with residential care, in larger settlements, minimising the disruption and stress to the individual involved. This approach is exemplified in the UK Close Care model (Habell, 2001), which allows a person to remain “on-site” with intensified care, including palliative care, when the need arises. This latter approach is more person-centred than that of continuous care, where step-down care is not co-located with supported housing or residential care.</p><p>The 2009 ESRI projections indicate trends similar to those in other developedcountries. The oldest populations, and, by extension, the highest level of need, is found in Sweden and Japan. In an Irish context, net emigration in younger age-groups will inevitably reduce the number of younger persons available to act as carers, formal or informal. The full implications of this more recent trend for future care provision have yet to be examined at the time of writing. We also need look further than our current demographic projections to anticipate “possible futures”. Demographic analysis of the type undertaken in the 2010 ESRI report should be extended to 2050, in order to make more useful projections. The proportion of “older old” people predicted to develop dementia also raises significant concerns about the pervasive nature of the disease, and must beg the question as to whetherdementia should properly be considered a natural consequence of extending the human lifespan. The implications of such rapid change for society in general, as well as for people with dementia and their carers, are huge. In Ireland, and in the UK, policy-making has tended to avoid dealing comprehensively with the issue, very possibly because of the scale of those challenges, all the more so in the context of recent economic exigencies. A 2013 report from a UK House of Lords Committee bluntly concludes that the UK is “woefully underprepared” to deal with an ageing population, and that “social care and its funding are already in crisis”, both being required to successfully underpin ageing-in-place initiatives (Select Committee on Public Service and Demographic Change, 2013). It further concludes and that provision of adequate housing suitable for elderly people, and often with“linked support”, will be essential to maintaining independent living, and also draws attention to the inevitable need for increased healthcare for elderly people. A similar report is now required as a matter of urgency in Ireland. A National Dementia Strategy for Ireland was in prepartino at the time of writing in 2013. It is imperative in this context that that dementia should not be considered in isolation from the overall demographic and social context of ageing.</p><p><strong>Ageing-in-place</strong></p><p>“Ageing-in-place” is currently an assumed component of the Irish model ofcommunity care, and is also held as an aspiration in other countries, including the UK and the US. It is based on the belief that a majority of people will wish to continue to live in their own homes they grow older. However, it must be recognised, based on the demographic projections, including projected rates of disability, that it will not be possible to meet the needs of all elderly persons in the home, and also, that without adequate funding of proper supports, continuing to live at home is not a guarantee of quality-of-life. For example, without significant support, it is almost impossible for someone with mid-stage dementia to live alone. From mid-stage on, continuous care is required, while people with more advanced dementia require significant amounts of one-to-one care. Similar concerns on the lack of suitable purpose-designed accommodation has been voiced by UK architect-researcher, Martin Habell, who maintains that care in the community cannot be assumed to have the same success for people with dementia as for elderly people in general and that current care home building stock in the UK is unfit for purpose (Habell, 2010).</p><p>Trends in household composition also influence projected needs for care: if anincreasing number of elderly people live alone, there is, by extension no available source of informal care in the home setting. Non-availability of care in the home makes an earlier move to a care setting more likely, but also contributes to increasing social isolation. People living alone with dementia are at higher risk of self-neglect, injury and institutionalisation (Alzheimer’s Association, 2012). It may be naïve, and even wilfully so, to assume that a majority of older people will in future live close to family supports, in suitable or readily-adaptable accommodation, and in locations where mobility and access to transport is facilitated. Community care and ageing-in-place models rely very heavily onpresumptions that family members will be available as informal carers, despite the increasing participation of women (the traditional carers) in the workforce, rural decline, emigration from younger age-groups, and so on (Barry, Ursula, Conlon, Ciara, 2010). Death of a family carer seriously hinders the possibility of an elderlyperson continuing to age in place. Taking into account the fact that many carers of the elderly are now themselves classed as “elderly”, i.e. aged over 65 years, most often spouse or partner, it is timely to reflect on the consequences of embarking on such a policy naively, without taking account of its full implications. It is also implicit in ageing-in-place models that, to provide adequate support, in particular for a person with dementia, a variety of care workers need to travel to the person, requiring significant financial investment and coordination. If not, assumptions are again made that the person can travel, that transport is available, that someone is available to accompany them. If the real costs of ageing-in-place were considered, including appropriate training for professional carers, loss of working time for family carers, the burden of stress (and often illness) on family carers, it might not be deemed appropriate in many cases, for the welfare of either the carer or the cared-for.</p><p>Disturbingly, the 2012 “Care in Crisis” report from Age UK finds hundreds of thousands of people with dementia in the UK receive no state assistance, or inadequate care and support to facilitate ageing-in-place (Age UK, 2012). The situation is unlikely to differ greatly in Ireland. The actual and proportional increase in numbers of people who will develop dementia is perhaps the single greatest challenge to the community-based, ageing-in-place model. Given the role of stress in development and prognosis of dementia and other illnesses, it seems foolhardy to place such elderly carers in a situation which is likely to cause them ongoing stress and increase their own likelihood of chronic illness. Disability resulting from dementia, combined with living alone will inevitably result in situations where an elderly person rapidly arrives at the point where no level of non-residential care can provide adequate security. This view is borne out by the UK experience.</p><p>Notwithstanding the current emphasis on aging-in-place on policy-making, and to some extent, by extension, on availability of research funding, it seems inevitable that, given current demographic trends, there will be an increased demand for residential care, including supported housing, for elderly people, though it has become unfashionable or even politically incorrect to suggest this. Later. research by Cluid Housing Assiciaiotn extablished a need for age-specifc housing among their existing, and ageing client base. The same research has obvious application in other public and social housing, but continues to be ignored by Local Authorities in housing provision, as it does by the Department of The question then arises of the form such accommodation should ideally take, and how the current situation in Ireland compares with models currently considered best practice internationally. In many societies, there is some availability of supported residential accommodation for elderly people, in addition to similar accommodation intended specifically for people with dementia, though there is a paucity of such accommodation in Ireland. It has also lately been acknowledged that an elderly person may wish to move into purpose-built accommodation for a variety of reasons, including a person’s concerns for her own health, problems with property maintenance, and in particular, garden maintenance, fear of crime, and the desire for the security offered by supported living. (Appleton, N.J.W., 2002)</p><p>It is worthy of comment that a marked preference on the part of elderly people for ageing at home may be related in part to the huge inadequacy of traditional models of elderly care, including in Ireland, in meeting the needs of users. Notwithstanding this preference, while most people with dementia start by living with it at home, a majority will end by living, and dying, often with dementia, in a residential care setting. A considerable amount of the argument of the UK and Irish ageing-in-place models seems to revolve around the cost to the state of providing residential care places for a rapidly-expanding population of older people with dementia, and the deferral of a move to care for as long as possible on that basis. The prime consideration should, of course, be the question of what constitutes an optimal standard of care for people with dementia, and in giving elderly people a real choice as to how they live out their years. The UK and Irish models both rely on swingeing assumptions of the amount of care provided at no cost to the state by a spouse/partner or family living near an elderly person. It also pays scant attention to the cost, both financial and human, to those carers. “Caregiver burden” is a reality. The relationship between carer mortality and hospitalisation of a spouse is an acknowledged fact. US research demonstrated that 8.6% of men whose spouses were hospitalised for dementia died within the following year (Christakis, Nicholas A, Allison, Paul D, 2006). I have witnessed this particular event in my own family.</p><p><strong>Technology and ageing-in-place</strong></p><p>The assumption that new monitoring technologies will somehow obviate the necessity for residential care seems implicit in many policy models of ageing-in-place. The implicit presumption is that telecare, based on monitoring, will provide an omnipresent “magic wand” that will somehow remove the necessity for human carers. This assumption stands to undermine quality-of-life for elderly people, as much as to promote independence. Wellbeing involves far more than basic physical safety: monitoring systems offer very little more than this. A monitoring system can never replace human contact. If this is an implicit assumption in the ageing-in-place model, it is very far removed from placing the person at the centre. The best that might be hoped for is deferral of a move to a care setting, by provision of some level of enhanced physical safety through use of remote monitoring and alarm systems. Significant amounts of research and development are still required inorder to develop intelligent predictive systems even for monitoring purposes. The question also arises as to their suitability for use with a cognitively–impaired population. It seems unlikely that if all associated costs were properly considered, including the necessity for paid carer support, that aging-in-place as currently conceived in Ireland, will by any means provide a panacea. There is a suggestion that use of monitoring technology may provide little by way of safeguards for elderly people: recent research found that older users of such technologies, with multiple health issues, were equally likely to be admitted to an emergency room as those who did not use a monitoring system (Takahashi, P.Y., et al, 2012). This group also experienced an unexplained higher rate of mortality than a similar user group with conventional health care. Where such remote monitoring solutions are most likely to be proffered, rightly or wrongly, is in related to elderly people in isolated areas. The 2011 Census of Ireland shows that more than two out of every five people aged 65 and over lives in a rural community. This raises questions about the quality of life and physical and social isolation. According to the ESRI report, little is currently known about this population. The report, however, does conclude that “The availability of remote monitoring and alarms should not be allowed to overshadow the very real need for provision of a higher level of care in other settings, including sheltered housing, nursing homes and long-stay hospitals.”</p><p><strong>ARCHITECTURAL CONTEXT</strong></p><p>A brief examination of the historical context of care architecture for the elderly in Ireland is useful in this discussion, as it informs, and often continues to inform, the architectural typologies where elderly care takes place, and the evolution both of newer models of care, and their associated, and still largely prototypical, typologies. Ireland’s existing housing and residential care infrastructure is very obviously inadequate to support the projected level of growth in the elderly population, including in terms of how design of current building stock fails to meet user requirements. This is most particularly the case in relation to designing for the person with dementia, where specific needs arise in relation to provision of appropriate, psychosocially supportive care settings, to maximise independence and quality-of-life. While there is some recognition that future models of care must address psychosocial issues, the significance of design of the built environment in the achievement of such an aspiration cannot be over-emphasised. Design can facilitate or restrict; deficiencies in the built environment can further disable a person with cognitive and/or physical impairment. The most serious issue arising is that of many elderly people with dementia in Ireland and the world over, continuing to live in environments which are likely to actually exacerbate their condition, so disabling is the environment. The effect of environment on the person has been discussed in terms of theory and evidence in terms in Chapter 1. That concern is revisited in this chapter, in relation to existing and new architectural typologies of care.</p><p><strong>Cruel Habitation?</strong></p><p>Many Irish workhouses are still in use by the state, or have been used until very recently, to provide residential accommodation for elderly people, though this does not appear to be widely known, and certainly not publicly discussed. The construction of the first workhouses in Ireland followed the 1834 Poor Law Act in the UK, though workhouses had been constructed on a much wider scale in England and Wales prior to that date. In both the UK and Ireland workhouses were original intended for use by those unable to work because of infirmity or illness. After the 1834 Act, workhouses were intended to deter their use by all but the most needy. One observer described the 1830s workhouse designs of architect Samuel Kempthorne as intending to be a “terror to the able-bodied population”. An architectural contemporary of Kempthorne’s described them as “a set of readymade designs of the meanest possible character”. Kempthorne’s designs were succeeded by a model of linked separate blocks more familiar in the Irish context, mostly designed by George Wilkinson.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/858/1*HqDB5FjC6A1_7ntsnQGtlw.png" /><figcaption><strong>Typical Kempthorne workhouse</strong></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/1*DAPTe7_0QWxv-jP97DhpEQ.png" /><figcaption><strong>Typical Wilkinson workhouse of linked blocks</strong></figcaption></figure><p>In purely functional terms, even the physical layout of the typical Wilkinson workhouse renders it difficult to successfully adapt for use as a suitable contemporary setting for elderly care, once it is assumed that the multi-beddedward model is an anachronism. Other than the principal block, the depth of the typical Wilkinson block is generally such that it is possible only to accommodate an inherently inefficient single-loaded corridor. Any adaptation designed to comply with contemporary standards, so including for single bedrooms, will result in a huge loss of bed-spaces, with a resultant requirement for additional new accommodation. It would seem logical given the lack of fitness-for-purpose, to replace workhouse accommodation wholesale with new, purpose-designed accommodation. The same comments apply to former asylum buildings. This has been attempted on a phased basis in many locations. However, as funding has seldom or ever been available to construct replacement accommodation as one project, construction of these facilities tends to be phased, and so, new facilities almost invariably sit alongside former workhouse buildings on the same site. While HSE is conscious of the drawbacks to such an approach, and most often aspires to turn over workhouse buildings to administrative use, simple economic reality even in the Celtic Tiger years precluded taking the ostensibly more rational approach of replacing facilities in their entirety, other than at a small number of locations. While research has established a preference for ageing at home versus moving to care, it may well be the case that research outcomes areinfluenced by the lack of choice available, where almost the only alternative is institutional, nursing-home care. Dr Margaret Calkins, an expert in the creation and evaluaiton of long-term care settings, has written that “there is growing evidence that the design of the built environment, by itself and in combination with organizational policies and procedures has a direct and measurable impact on the physical and psycho-social functioning of residents with dementia” (Calkins, 2009). If it is the case that built environment inevitably affects how users behave and how they feel, how can it be in any way appropriate to continue to house elderly people in settings with the inescapable hangover of their original design intention to deter, demean and control? This is without any reference to the attitudes and folk memory of workhouses and their association with the Great Famine that prevail among a majority of Irish people. Research is required to clarify issues such as the possibility that a person might have preference to relocate to a supported community, given a choice, and also of the negative influence on personal preferences of the cultural values that Irish people in general are likely to attach to public sector elderly care provision, much of which is still located in Famine workhouses, or co-located with such buildings.</p><p>The term “Cruel Habitation” was coined by Martin Habell (Habell, 2009), a UK architect and researcher, to describe the state of much current accommodation for elderly people in the UK, in particularly for people with dementia. Often located in converted large houses, as is the case for many privately-run Irish nursing homes, it suffers from very similar deficiencies as the converted workhouse: lack of light, lack of outside access, no views out because of high windowsills, poor way-finding, and insufficient personal space. The accommodation, as is the case in Ireland, is essentially so unfit for purpose as to merit the appellation “cruel habitation”. The continuing use of such outdated buildings for elderly care in Ireland appears also to influence contemporary constructs of what might constitute an appropriate contemporary setting. For example, the HSE ‘Teaghlach’ model seems to owe as much to what are regarded, in most Western countries, as outdated nursing-home models, as it does to the newer “household’ models, currently perceived as the preferred form of future residential care. In brief, the recommendation for a “household” varies from 8–12 people in UK and US models, but is 20 in the HSE model, in a 50-bed unit. No domestic household with which any resident is likely to be familiar houses 20 persons. Over-scaling of individual house units in this fashion is likely to cause problems with comprehensibility of the building plan. The Teaghlach allocation for a sitting-room is 30 m2, insufficient to accommodate even half that number without creating an unavoidably institutional character. The overall allocation of 30 m2 for the sitting-room does not facilitate any subdivision into smaller spaces, given the increasing size of appliances such as wheelchairs. The model is therefore too compromised to be held up as an exemplar. Aspirations alone are insufficient for a designer to overcome the restrictions imposed by such spatial briefs. While HSE is no longer involved in procurement of buildings for elderly care, the “Teaghlach” model is now being used as a model for special needs care. Its ultimate rationale appears to lie entirely in the exigencies of economics, and available sites and buildings, rather than user needs. There is no identified preferred model for the private sector, though at least some private sector careproviders appear to be voluntarily constructing new facilities to exceed current HIQA standards, in order to “future-proof”.</p><p>There are similarities in the evolution from workhouses to current typologies in the US, Ireland and Britain, which in part result from a common heritage of UK administration. Provision in all cases has progressed from “warehousing”, in open wards, often in former poorhouses (this has been the case in the UK an US also) to hospital or nursing models, and latterly to newer and still largely prototypical “household” models such as the GreenHouse® model (US), and the model recommended by Better Care Homes. Research in the UK, where the cultural context of care is not dissimilar to Ireland (having evolved from Poor Law to Welfare State) also strongly favours clustered household models. The need for such models to be located in, as opposed to isolated from, existing communities is also stressed.</p><p><strong>Designing for Functional and Psychosocial fit: a place to live</strong></p><p>A psychosocial approach to design indicates a preference for smaller residential units, for a variety of now well-researched reasons (Day, K., Carreon, D., Stump, C., 2000). Such settings permit greater resulting opportunities for personalisation and self-actualisation, as well as facilitating legibility and easier way-finding. Research has established that measures of patient well-being for elderly residents in smaller scale settings were consistently better than in larger institutional settings (Calkins, 2009), with residents in smaller units having higher motor functioning and mobility, more friendship formation, less anxiety and depression, while those in larger units had greater use of psychotropic drugs and antibiotics, and also exhibited moreaggression. Research in Green House units, of 10 residents, showed a drop in participation in organised activities (Kane, R et al, 2007). It is curious perhaps that such participation is seen here as a definitive measure of wellbeing. Perhaps the result is simply a consequence of the freedom of a physical setting that afforded subjects the space to choose privacy, and have time to themselves. Another review of research has found that residents considered it important not to be forced to take part in social activities (Croucher, K., Hicks, L., Jackson, K., 2006). Personally, the prospect of being obliged to participate in activities which have never formed a part of my life, or in cherished activities, such as music and art, but at a time and in a fashion dictated by someone else, is a particularly potent vision of hell. It should be by now obvious that residential settings for elderly people should be designed to maximise physical independence and usability by residents, but equally so that to date, they have largely been conceived of as places where old people are sent to die, rather than places where they go to live, and where poor standards are to be accepted without complaint on the same basis. It is also evident that the provision of a physically secure environment should not be prioritised at the expense of considerations of psychosocial support. Range and availability of spaces can impact very significantly on the latter (Archea, 1977). For example, if a care setting does not provide appropriate spaces to support a range of socialinteractions, residents are effectively restricted in the types of social interactions available to them. Most commonly, there is no available, and appropriate, space for intimate, one-to-one social interaction. Visitor’s rooms belong no more to an individual than to a group. There is a qualitative difference between a sitting-roomin one’s own house, and a shared sitting room in a care setting, and a yet greater difference, a quantum gap, between the private domestic social space of a sitting-room, and the types of large-scale spaces common in Irish and international care settings. The entire culture of care appears to be still coloured by a view of elderlycare homes as a place people go to die, not where they go to live out their days in a supportive environment that caters to their total needs, psychosocial and functional. There are of course, exceptions, such as the Cheshire Homes sheltered housing schemes, but these do not currently accept people with a diagnosis dementia. The need for psychosocially supportive environments is absolutely critical in the case of people with cognitive impairment from dementia, often overlaid on other age-related physical impairment. Design guidelines and exemplar models therefore must take into account the detailed interaction between person and care environment at all levels, from siting, to layout and way-finding, through to the detailed design of spaces and objects, most particularly design of the resident’s own personal life-space. Provision of single-room accommodation for all residents should be regarded an absolute necessity. Consideration of provision for couples to continue to live together in care must also be broached, including where one chooses to accompany the other to continue his/her role of carer, which is not currently possible. While it is recognized that a supportive architectural environment must be complemented by a non-institutional model of care-giving, it is also likely that, if we continue to build institutional-style accommodation, the physical environment of its nature will serve only to impede delivery of psychosocial models of care. To quote Margaret Calkins: “It is time we stoppedallowing buildings of this (institutional) style to be built”. (Calkins, 2009)</p><p><strong>“My wallpaper and I are fighting a duel to the death”: Conflicts between aspiration and reality in residential care design for elderly people</strong></p><p>If the built environment is inextricably linked to the culture of care, then it isdifficult, if not impossible, to provide truly person-centred or “psychosocial” care in an institutional environment, which already places additional burdens on carers and residents alike by virtue of its lack of fitness-for-purpose. By the same token, the care-provider’s view of the individual (patient vs. person) colours the entire culture of care, including how design briefs are formulated, and in particular in relation to allocation of space. Despite the best intentions of the designer, (s)he may find herself obstructed by lack of spatial allocation, such as is necessary to properly cater for a range of situations and activities needed to fulfil psychosocial needs. An overweening emphasis on infection control frequently leads to situations where it isvirtually impossible to recreate a domestic atmosphere, for example, precluding, in Ireland, the use of personal furniture. In public sector settings, it is usual for the designer to be restricted to a choice of hard, and frequently synthetic, surfaces only, in the interests of cleanability. This in turn restricts the palette of colours and materials available for specification, which are deemed acceptable by the service provider. Aspirations to “avoid glare” remain aspirational as a result of the perceived necessity for specifying almost exclusively hard, wipe-clean surfaces, which will tend to reflect rather than absorb light (Torrington, J. M., Tregenza, P. R.,2007). The available choice is often one between “shiny” and “less shiny”, by the very nature or materials such as laminate finishes, and sheet flooring. It can be made impossible, in practical terms, to specify natural materials. Hard surfaces also reflect sound; this makes for noisy spaces, where it is often difficult to distinguish speech clearly. It has been said that noise is to people with dementia what steps are to wheelchair-users. Hearing loss and cognitive impairment lead to confusion, discomfort and even alarm arising from ambient noise conditions, including normal “household” noises (van Hoof, J., et al, 2008). An effective restriction on practicing designers to use of hard finishes in residential care for elderly people appears to be courting disaster from the perspective of environmental fit. An embargo on soft and tactile materials pushes such environments towards complete exclusion of a multisensory approach, regardless of any written policy, and with it, any pretensions towards being genuinely psychosocially supportive. An holistic design approach, which might also be described as architectural, suggests that every resident’s room should incorporate multisensory aspects, and that use of all the senses in interpreting an environment should be an everyday possibility, not justsomething restricted to visits to a special room, as is common in special needs care, and currently being introduced into care settings for dementia patients. Whatever about the known benefits of using a multisensory room, (there is in fact almost know reliable research to show that Sonezelen, for example are of proven benefit) how can it possibly be argued that the user’s living space should be hard, unfamiliar, and unwelcoming, and a special room the only respite? Oscar Wilde’s last words are said to have been,“My wallpaper and I are fighting a duel to the death. One or the other of us has to go”, referring to his room at the Hotel d’Alsace. They may hold rather more than a grain of truth.</p><p>Client interpretations of design guides for dementia care and universal design can also be over-rigid, and may stifle innovative design solutions. Previously-used design solutions based on limited research should be viewed as one of many possible answers, not the solution in every situation. Even then, the existing evidence-base is still small. In the absence of considered design input, over-literalinterpretation of narrow research outcomes, for example, those which recommend use of bright colours to aid in identification of important objects, can lead, if not used in a considered fashion, to an over-coloured, and over-stimulating environment, a sort of “McDonald’s syndrome”, which may actually exacerbate dementia symptoms through creating visual confusion. Even McDonald’s has move on from a “fast-food” interior design approach, which aimed at rapid turnover, to one which aspires to entice customers to stay on the premises for longer, though use of softer lighting and colour, and more natural finishes.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*ssrQ2diDZY9fvc4e8rDUOA.png" /><figcaption><strong>There’s a difference at McDonald’s…</strong></figcaption></figure><p>Design guidelines are rarely as restrictive as they might seem at first glance, and usually avoid being over-prescriptive, though it is not unusual for care-providers, such as HSE to themselves impose narrower interpretations of guidelines. Much research on colour, for example, is not carried out in the built environment. Built environment recommendations derived from such research are often naïve when applied in the real world, or unnecessarily restrictive. The most effective way of gauging the success of a design intervention is through post-occupancy evaluation. At the moment, in Ireland, there is little more than anecdotal evidence of success. I can state, as an experienced design professional, that on occasions where I have applied a more intuitive approach to design of care environments, based on a limited research review, there has been little other than positive feedback, despite some apprehensions on my own part, for example, about use of particular colours. Sometimes when it looks right, it is right. The role of a thoughtful and informed designer should not be underestimated. Of late this has been usurped at times by clinical and nursing staff. This is as inappropriate as an architect wandering unannounced into a hospital ward, to seize a hypodermic needle form a nurse and inject a patient, untutored. On the research side of the fence, demonstrating in a convincing manner whether or how design has any beneficial effect, is extremely difficult, given that research methodologies tend to the reductive, while design, in particular architecture, synergises many factors to create a successful environment. It is nigh impossible to separate out the different factors, and perhaps not very useful in the long run. Answers may ultimately be found in research on, and in live environments. John Ziesel, among others cautions, advocates a holistic approach to the design of environments for people with dementia, so that the entire environment becomes comprehensible, andacknowledges that satisfying all the requirements on a list of recommendations is not any guarantee of success (Ziesel, 2005) (van Hoof, J., et al, 2008). Given the available research, and theory in environmental psychology, it seems a contradiction in terms to suggest that a “psychosocial model of care” can thrive in an environment which tends towards sensory deprivation and de-personalisation. Yet it is this, and little more, that current regulatory environment appears to permit. Facilitating environmental congruence demands considerably more than lip-service. These same restrictions on design and specification routinely apply tostep-down and acute hospital care, where at least they may have less potential for damage as the average length of stay is far shorter than in residential care. How much of the extra burden of care created by the lack of congruence, both psychosocial and functional, then falls on the carer?</p><p>The situation in Ireland in relation to both current and future provision of suitable accommodation for elderly people could be described as alarming at best. There is little evidence of ongoing procurement of residential care buildings on the scale likely to be required, or of any coherent move towards developing new models of care, with support in policy. HSE is no longer commissioning elderly care homes, except where substandard accommodation is to be replaced. If the entire provision of care accommodation is to be devolved to the private sector, stronger direction and control is required than is currently available. On the basis of research and comparison with other models, existing HIQA space standards for new facilities are too low, most particularly for bedrooms, and insufficient for any degree of futureproofing.</p><p>There are known, and frequently insurmountable, conflicts, for the architect, between existing statutory requirements, and the desire for a household type care setting. Some of the worst are in dealing with Fire Regulations, when residential care is treated largely as if it were a hospital setting. For example, the insistence on door closers on all doors to a corridor can necessitate closers on toilet doors, for reasons of fire safety, which a resident simply cannot open, and which cannot, for reasons of privacy, be left held open. There are no door-closer products that will meet this need, and simple laws of mechanics dictate that there are unlikely to be. The solution, if a genuinely psychosocially supportive model of care is to be adopted successfully, is to draw up specific regulation for such building types, which better balance considerations of security, congruence, and user characteristics, based on full and rigorous analysis of benefit and risk. Similar comments apply in relation to infection control, when over-zealously applied. In the face of such constraints, a designer can be completely disempowered in relation to creating a user-centred solution that also meets regulatory requirements. The regulatory environment should not be permitted to eclipse the view of the end user. “People, not patients” must be the watchword.</p><p><strong>“I’M STILL HERE”</strong></p><p>Having practised as an architect in healthcare design for many years, I was struck very emphatically by the differences in perceptions of the needs of elderly people in care, in contrast to perceptions of users with “special needs”. In the latter case, emphasis was inevitably on “quality-of-life”, and personal development. By contrast, the focus for elderly people seemed to fall largely on functional provision. Even where more than basic provision was sought by hospital management and nursing staff, those aspirations were effectively obstructed by design briefs, which were inevitably overly restrictive, particularly in terms of space allocation. In turn, the culture and quality of possible care are unavoidably coloured by the physical environment of care. Promotion of personal independence cannot successfully takeplace in a built environment that, by its very nature, mitigates against functional and psychosocial congruence. The consequences are seen in “disturbed behaviours” among persons placed in care, which are often, and lamentably, countered by the administration of psychotropic drugs. Therefore any model of care which purports to be “psychosocial” must, of necessity, simultaneously address the issue of the physical environment, not only because of the known influence of environment on wellbeing, specifically as a source of stress, but alsobecause of the influence of physical environment on delivery of appropriate care.</p><p>Even where intentions are ostensibly the best, design outcomes are often strongly coloured by continued commissioning and use of what are essentially institutional models of care, where scant real regard is paid to the person who should be at the centre of the model. Decisions about care, regarding what is right, wrong, or better, often appear to be persistently informed by an institutional view of the person, which renders them as something slightly less than a whole person, with individual characteristics and needs. What must be remembered that even in the case of significant physical and more particularly, cognitive impairment, is that that the “patient” is one aspect of the complete person, with all their memories and experiences. While behaviour may regress to that of a child, or an infant, this person is still not a child. They must be regarded as not just the outward aspect or set of challenges to care and design that they now present, but also, and critically, as the sum total of everything they were before over the course of their lives. To borrow John Ziesel’s phrase, the plea of the person with (Ziesel, 2010) is “I’m still here”. The essence of the person remains, and must be actively sought, and valued in the culture of care-giving. Care of elderly people invariable and unavoidably implies care of people with dementia, or people who will develop dementia while in care. It is not an issue that can be put to one side either in the proposals for new care models, or their embodiment in the built environment. Given the existing situation, and predicted demographic trends, true consideration of the user must be an absolutely central concern in how we design environments for elderly people, at home or in care. Elderly people and elderly people with dementia are not “two tribes”. This is not to say that every elderly person will develop dementia, but that the incidence of dementia rises with age, and is significantly higher in the “very old old”. The onset of dementia is very often a marker for the move from living at home, to living in a supported environment. There is huge support for “ageing-in-place” in terms of interest and funding; yet how much does this ignore the reality and stress of living in an environment outgrown in terms of congruence, or care to examine the real reasons as to why a majority of elderly people are resistant, if not downright fearful of a move to residential care. Why do we continue to design and build care setting that frighten people? How should we design new residential accommodation that caters for the needs of elderly people, especially those with dementia? What contribution can emerging technologies make?</p><p><strong>Suggested Approaches: community-based care</strong></p><p>Notwithstanding the current emphasis on aging-in-place on policy-making, and to some extent, by extension, on research funding, it is still a certainty that, given current demographic trends, there will be an increased demand for residential provision, in various forms, for elderly people. The question then arises of the forms it should ideally take, and also of how the current situation in Ireland compares with models currently considered to represent best practice internationally. On the basis of demographic predictions referred to earlier, it is reasonable to suggest that all new residential care facilities for older people should be designed so that people with dementia can successfully live in them, rather than, or in addition to constructing specific dementia care units. A person-centred approach suggests that a resident might be required to relocate, but ideally only within the confines of a site, or alternatively, be facilitated in always remaining in the same accommodation, depending on the chosen architectural model. Elderly people who do not have dementia may not benefit from being be co-housed with people with dementia; this needs to be considered in any proposed design solution (Wiltzius, S F, Gambert, S R, Duthie, E H, 1981). A solution that includes for flatlet-style accommodation, such as that proposed by Jenny Willatt in “Design as Therapy” (Willatt, 2011) might largely circumvent this issue. An inclusive approach, coupled with a community-based clustered household or flatlet model, perhaps with onsite respite and palliative care, (as in the UK Close Care model) (Habell, 2001) facilitates ageing in supported accommodation, without further need for a person to be moved offsite, and away from their community, as their condition deteriorates. The level of support provided onsite can be increased as and when required. If clinic facilities are provided onsite, they might also be made available to elderly people in the surrounding community, establishing and fostering relationships within the community, including with potential future residents. The Onni Centre, in Finland, adopts this approach, which aims to comprehensively address both the existing and anticipated care needs of the elderly resident. It should be noted that the stress associated with moving location is almost certain to exacerbate dementia symptoms. Research from Northern Ireland indicates that prescription of psychotropic drugs for elderly people more than doubled (from 8.2% to 18.6%) after they were moved to a care setting, and that rates of prescription of such drugs for elderly people in care settings overall was twenty times that for people living in the community. (Maguire, Aideen et al, 2013) Given the demonstrable unsuitability, and institutional nature, of a majority of care settings as currently constituted, it is almost inevitable that some of this apparent increase in need for medication may arise from stressors of environmental origin. The extent to which this perceived need for over-prescription is due to environmental stressors, or to pathologising of behaviours, which might not be regarded as “challenging” in another physicalcontext, is unknown. There is a real paucity of other research the consequences to the person of a move from home to residential care, though there is research on the effects on carers.</p><p>The 2009 ESRI report refers not only to the changing demographic as a predictor of care need, but also of increased service expectations from an increasingly vocal demographic, and an increased need for services for previously unmet needs. As a lobby group, older people in the US have become both vocal and influential in expressing their needs and preference for a variety of services. It would seem likely that Grey Power will also arrive, albeit belatedly, on these shores, as older people come to represent an increasingly significant market force, including for residential care. At the same time, we appear to be at a critical point, where if heed is not paid in very short order to impending demographic change, existing care provision will be completely swamped by what has been referred to as the Grey Tsunami.</p><p><strong>CONTEMPORARY ARCHITECTURAL MODELS FOR ELDERLY LIVING</strong></p><p>The MyRoom model is conceived as part of a model for communal living based on recent architectural and care-giving trends in the United States and Europe. In the US, there has been a gradual progression from de-institutionalisation (as in the Eden Initiative), through quasi-domestic residential models such as the Evergreen Community and Meadowlark, from facilities with identifiable internal neighbourhoods, to third-generation facilities consisting of grouped stand-alone households of around ten residents, epitomised by the Green House (Fig. 4.5) . Thecurrent most-favoured architectural model for elderly care in the US is the “clustered household” model, where 8–12 residents share a domestic-scale dwelling, with a number of dwellings clustered together, ideally set in an existing community. The Green House model represents the latest evolution of this typology. Residents living in smaller-scale units show a much lower incidence of disturbed behaviours, perhaps unsurprisingly, given the significance of the influence of environment on well-being which both theory and observation would suggest. It is worthy of comment that such any such model should more correctly be regarded as “quasi-domestic”: it is, after all, not generally taken as the norm to share one’s home with complete strangers. Even in student housing, there is usually some degree of choice regarding housemates, as well as far greater choice of being away from the house by personal choice. The newer models of care focus on the needs of the resident, rather than carers, or traditional nursing models. The Green House concept furthermore embraces smart-home technologies; for example, in order to minimize intrusion resulting from monitoring. Significantly, architecture is recognised as a driving force in culture replacement in care of the elderly (Baker, 2007).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/530/1*4Z5skoIwFp8cLQVXs1kN5A.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Interior of Die Rokade (Arons en Gelauf Architecten)</strong></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/668/1*EuBu3FbY6VmjGiaO_M0xvA.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>“Onni” Welfare Centre, Finland: Plan</strong></figcaption></figure><p>European models included here, for comparison, include Finnish, Dutch and UK models of communal residential architecture, as examples of good practice. Finnish models include apartments and group homes, such as “Willa Viola”, the Willa Home, Tampere, and the “Onni” Care Centre at Pukkiila (Fig. 4.6). Here, communal living is in apartments of 40–60 m2 with living room, bedroom, kitchen and bathroom, but also with access to a communal sitting-room, dining-room, kitchen, service facilities and staff rooms. Residents have personal living-space, with the option of communal facilities as and when need arises. The Onni project iscommunity-based, and also incorporates day-care facilities and community healthcare facilities, in what might be described as a “one stop shop” approach. De Rokade, in the Netherlands, designed by Arons en Gelauff Architecten, is a multistorey residential care apartment building, where the internal layout and individual space allocation within the cruciform floor plan is varied from floor to floor, depending on the specific needs of the user: for example, to cater for a single person, or alternatively, for a person who needs care, but lives in a family situation.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/548/1*b4JUTLqkQWmqLz7fxR7mJA.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>The Green House (US)</strong></figcaption></figure><p>In the UK, as in Ireland, a majority of residential care for elderly people is provided by the private sector: 61% of elderly people in long-term care in 2008 were in private sector accommodation (Barry, Ursula, Conlon, Ciara, 2010), most of it in buildings which are not purpose-built. This is a particular issue where they areexpected to cater for residents with dementia. There is a slow move in the UK towards smaller-scale domestic-type and clustered residential settings, such as the “Close Care” model. Close Care and similar models begin to recognise elderly people as a market force, and are geared towards their specific needs. The Close Care model was developed specifically as an assisted living model for elderlypeople, with Martin Habell architect and researcher. It consists of either a singleblock, or individual dwellings arranged “campus-style” with a shared resourceblock. The first built examples broke the rigid distinction that had previously existed between nursing-homes and private retirement housing schemes, a distinction which still persists in Ireland. The private sector is at liberty to break such conventions; the public sector still perpetuates an unhelpful distinction between supported housing and other residential care, which are within the remit of different government departments. In the public sector, residential care falls generally under the aegis of the Department of Health, while sheltered housing is dealt with by Housing Associations in the main, though also through Local Authority housing departments, and through the DHSS in the UK. This is more of an issue than might at first appear to be the case, as the distinction between the two does not facilitate meeting the changing needs of many elderly people. “Close Care” has become a generic term for assisted living schemes with a co-located nursing-home. The model evolved from Martin Habell’s earlier designs for elderly care, which consisted of 10–14 bed units clustered around a shared central courtyard, dating from the 1980s, but also from strong convictions about the unsuitability of previous design and care approaches.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/746/1*qlQy_sNGCh7NQQ51SmgWvw.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Willicombe Park, Tunbridge Wells (Martin Habell/Maybourne Projects)</strong></figcaption></figure><p>While the Close Care model offers better quality of life for elderly people, thedifficulty in finding sufficient suitable sites in time to meet an already urgent need may necessitate focusing instead on provision of urgently necessary bed-spaces in a purpose-built model, which is effectively an ESMI (Elderly Severe Mentally Ill) unit. This approach offers advantages in terms of construction costs, more rapidprocurement, and numbers accommodated on a site. On that basis, Habell has also developed specialised dementia care units, which incorporate design features specifically intended to improve ease-of-use and quality of life for residents (Habell, 2013). These include a comprehensible plan, multiple cuing, an enclosed garden or “pairidaez”, a “Memory Trail”, which moves from inside to outside, and emphasis on light, including a daylight room with therapeutic lighting. The ideal model remains nonetheless that of small-scale units, which incorporate those same characteristics, achievable through multiple design approaches.</p><p>The European models, on the whole, show a greater concern with provision ofpersonal space than the Green House concept, as a consequence of their being based on of self-contained living-units in a supported setting. The issue of flexibility of living-arrangements, for individual needs, or over time is also addressed. The comparison of exemplar models also serves to illustrate that design does not provide any single definitive solution, and that residential models are inevitably influenced by cultural context.</p><p><strong>Residential models derived from research</strong></p><p>Recent hypothetical care models, derived from research, also display sharedconcerns about the availability of personal social space, and environmental fit in general. The UK “Better Care Homes” (NHS/RCA) model (Helen Hamyln Centre, 2011) is described as a “cluster” model, though this is not evident from the actual physical disposition of spaces, which does not clearly articulate discrete house-scale units, though the model extensively describes detailed design. This may be a consequence of an apparent lack of architectural input into the design model, or a conscious avoidance of a prescriptive design approach. Though aspiration towards domesticity is considered, the model, as for the Green House, is essentially quasi-domestic, in part due to its scale, and also the expectation that communal living for elderly people continues to imply sharing of personal living-space with people who are not family members, and are not personally chosen. However, this is compensated for by the provision of additional space in the user’s own room. Space standards and room layout closely resemble those of the thesis room model, though arrived at through different methodologies. The Better Cares Homes model was arrived by group research, on the basis of a broad methodology; MyRoom adopts a design-based approach based largely on ergonomics, and existing design experience from practice. Though it is influenced by research findings on environmental fit, and factors promoting wellbeing, as a design exercise it is relatively simple.</p><p>Jenny Willatt’s model for dementia care, in “Design as Therapy” (Willatt, 2011) comprises small apartments/flatlets ranged around secure shared landscaped spaces, with linked shared facilities. This approach is both more architectural, and more legible to the user as a familiar domestic urban/residential typology, which operates at a variety of scales. It has significant elements in common with the author’s own 1997 residential care scheme for residents with moderate to severe mental learning disabilities (Caomhnú), which is made up of linked house units separated by courtyards, albeit smaller in scale. Willatt’s model makes a concerted attempt to address many of the issues highlighted in the literature review for this thesis, arising from similar concerns for use of “design as therapy” or, in other words salutogenic design. This is addressed at different scales, from overall planning, through to the internal layout of individual rooms, and their relationship with external spaces. While her research sources may differ, there is a very close correlation with this thesis proposal, in identified environmental preferences, for example, for connections with nature, multisensory aspects, and seasonality, and in the sizing and internal arrangement of individual flatlets.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/1*9Bh-JUGOUxNrK4NkaxgSZA.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>“Better Care Homes” Model, 2011</strong></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/768/1*pTaRvti-iz-FJ4zHc6Sbeg.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Caomhnu Residential Care Units, Kilkenny, Ireland (Dalton + O’Donnell Architects, 1997)</strong></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/902/1*7nCt-BYQO4ZbnDdgNqGBVQ.png" /><figcaption><strong>“Design as therapy” model (Jenny Willatt) 2011</strong></figcaption></figure><p><strong>Architecture versus technology?</strong></p><p>Architecture for care settings, and consequently, the design of a template forarchitecturally-embedded interaction in care settings, raises particular issues use of technologies. Fitch (1975) has argued that architecture may be seen to have contradicting requirements of functional versus formal criteria: “The more complex or vital a process to be housed, the more critical the contradiction becomes. Hence the architect’s freedom to create necessarily diminishes in inverse proportion to the criticalness of his task” (Fitch 1975, p.25) Fitch cites the example of an operating theatre as an extreme case, where functionality prevails to the exclusion of other design considerations. More recent healthcare design models have recognised that there are negative aspects to patient outcomes in healthcare environments which are designed with only the functional/technological in mind, and that regardless of the functional necessities of high-tech healthcare buildings, it is no longer acceptable to ignore the significance of user experience, and the negative impacts of the late-20th-century approach to healthcare design. The change in attitude arises out of an ongoing move from institutional and purely functional models, to more patient-centred ideas of care, cognisant of the significance of environmental design in promoting wellbeing. Contained in this aspiration is a return to concerns which were highlighted around the time when modern nursing practices emerged but which have since become lost in a welter of medical technologies, where care architecture, in many respects, has too often been reduced to little more than a container for expensive and sophisticated equipment. Far older architectural models for healthcare buildings overtly concern themselves with basic aspects of the built environment which are considered to be beneficial, such as sunlight and fresh air, both referred to by Florence Nightingale (Nightingale, 1860). More recently, the TB sanitoria of the early 20th century offered patients single rooms, with direct access to outdoors, facilitating enjoyment of fresh air and sunlight, for therapeutic purposes. Somewhere in between, the patient has become commodified, or reduced to a set of symptoms. This becomes highly problematic where the domination of overt medical technology in itself becomes a source of stress for the patient which is highly undesirable, given the role of stress in illness. The existence of post-ICU syndrome, and psychosis, has now been identified. Though in part resulting from illness, and the trauma of medical intervention, environmental factors, such as sensory deprivation, constant light levels, disorientation, stress and intrusive monitoring are all acknowledged as contributing causes. For that reason, many of the proposals made in the MyRoom model also have application in an acute hospital scenario. Though the influence of architecture and environmental design in acute healthcare environments is now well-recognised (Devlin, Ann Sloan, Arneill, Allison B, 2003), change is slow to happen, and often impeded by organizational inertia, as well as continued use of older, and therefore often inappropriately-designed building stock. The issue of environmental influence on residents in long-term care settings has been given far less attention to date. In both acute and residential care, the ability of the user to adjust to the physical environment, in order to achieve a high degree of “congruence” has decreased, temporarily or permanently. While residential environments might not always present themselves as so immediately as quite as alien, or stressful, as acute hospital environments, (though many differ very little from hospitals), the fact that residents are exposed to potentially detrimental environments for months or years could signal even greater and cumulative impact on wellbeing. The analysis of thefunctional and psychosocial needs of an elderly person with dementia, and of the physical reality of a majority current residential care settings, leads to the inevitable conclusion that a majority are unfit for use, so strongly do they mitigate against the possibility of environmental congruence (fit). The review of elderly user needs, and consideration of concepts of congruence, strongly bears out that viewpoint, as does the particular significance of environmental stress for the person with dementia or indeed a person with an intellectual or developentla disability, or both. Good design enables, bad design disables.</p><p>As an architect-researcher, my position is that ICT, specifically in the form of embedded sensor systems and applications, should be used for environmental enhancement, rather than solely for functional or clinical purposes. In this manner it may offer compensation, both for negative effects arising out of functional constraints in built form, and more specifically, for loss of ability, whether temporary or permanent, on the part of the end-users of care architecture, whether that is user is patient or resident. While it would seem self-evident that end-users in healthcare scenarios are more vulnerable to stress of environmental origin than “average” users, as a result of illness or impairment, this seems to be blindly overlooked in many instances, not always by designers, but also by medical institutions as commissioning bodies. To put it very plainly, hospitals and nursing-homes can, and do contribute to making people feel ill, by firstly not affording environmental conditions conducive to wellbeing and recovery, and in the case of long-term care, by failing to provide environments consistent with the particular needs of vulnerable user-groups, and similarly failing to adequately support wellbeing. Thedesign of an acute care environment must address the specific needs of the user who is unwell, and likely, as a result, to be temporarily incapacitated or immobilised, as well as being stressed by the illness itself, all in addition to removal from a familiar, to an unfamiliar, and highly-technologized environment.</p><p>While good design can facilitate functional and psycho-social congruence, assistive and prosthetic environments enabled by ambient technologies and pervasive computing have potential to further enhance the effects of good design by addressing the changing deficit in fit brought about by a user’s changing needs, or by varying environmental circumstances. Embedded technologies also have the potential to enhance congruence where physical limitations of an existing setting act as a constraint. The approach in this model is two-pronged; that is, it consciously deals with both functional and psychosocial considerations in interaction design integrated into architectural design. This is achieved through an exploration of a design template for responsive healthcare setting, seen as a specific localised model of responsive architecture. The model explores the potential of wireless technologies to facilitate, in a new way, the particular relationship between the person and her “personal life space”. Such an approach seeks a closer understanding of how people function in the built environment. It does not consciously seek to invent new physical typologies, but rather to increase their potential functionality, defined to include “user-friendliness” as a measure of true functionality. This invariably leads to the proposal for inclusion of affectivecomputing, as a necessity in any model for architecturally-embedded responsivity in such a context. Without it, the model would fall short of much potential to recognise or address issues of psychosocial fit. In this, it mirrors the evolution of ICT itself, which is moving beyond notions of acquisition and modelling of data, and becoming more concerned with usability, and useful interpretation of “big data”. This change of attitude is evident is the ease-of-use of “Web 2” technologies, where information and social networks, informed by personal information, are readily accessed by web-enabled, user-friendly handheld devices, such as the iPhone and iPad. One might ask what is the relevance to architecture: it is that interface design does not only concern itself with technologies, but equally with the user, and the minutiae of the possible interactions between that user and the system on the other side of the interface. As such, architecture reframed as interaction design, with the built environment as the interface, has potential to influence behavioural outcomes, described by Lawton as a function of the unique interaction between the individual and her environment (Lawton, 1975). In the context of this exploration, the protocols for design of web-enabled systems and applications, as well as being successful standalone technologies, are a significant point on the route to environmental embedment, and to some extent may serve as models. On a practical level, Web computing protocols can be used as a basis for embedded local networks, but may prove to be less appropriate as design of embedded systems progresses.</p><p><strong>Ubiquitous computing and access to information: issues of security, safety, and communication</strong></p><p>Issues of ethics are often raised about gathering personal data from vulnerable subjects, such as elderly people with dementia, in particular with regard to applications which require continuous sensing, and use of personal data, which raise issues of privacy and intrusiveness. Many of those objections to ring hollow in the context of the reality of the restrictive nature of much existing residential care, where ensuring resident “safety”, in a very narrow sense, has hugely negative impacts on psychosocial congruence. Research on resident safety is generally couched in terms of reduction in falls, and of unaccompanied egress. Where fears are expressed about privacy and social control for a vulnerable elderly user, they must be considered in the light of the manner in which conventional care environments are already often very highly-controlled. This is often in order to minimise risk of harm or injury, but at the same time renders such environments fundamentally unsupportive of psychosocial congruence. Common examples of such restrictions, though they have not been perceived as such until very recently, if at all, are the enforced socialisation of the common sitting-room, in the absence of private social space, and restrictions on free access to external space. Restriction by actual physical restraint is still in use, though now considered unacceptable, and still surfaces as a result of inspections, as is overuse of chemical restraint (sedation) highlighted repeatedly in HIQA report on residential care of very vulnerable older persons with intellectual disabilities. Where sensing applications, such as RFID, are used to control access and egress, they are invariably selectively filtered so that residents are restricted from independent egress to outdoors, while staff and visitors come and go freely. Despite the common imposition of such physical restrictions on the resident, it is not unusual, the world over, for persons in care to contive to leave a care setting unobserved, only to be found days after, sometimes dead. A quick internet search throws up many such news stories. Recent cases in Ireland include the death of an elderly person who left a nursing home, and, despite a frantic search by family and police, was killed in a fall a couple of days after, having wandered some distance. GPS tagging might have avoided all this; not only that, but a system can be designed to identify location through GPS only when a user is a certain distance from “base”, or when triggered at an egress point by an RFID tag, or when it proves impossible to locate someone after a reasonable length of time. The “safe” boundary for the resident might then shift from the external door, to the gateway to the property, and thus the domain to which the person has independent and secure access can be allowed to expand considerably, giving free access to a safe outdoor area, which is considered highly desirable in terms of promoting wellbeing (Calkins, M, Szmerekovsky, J, Biddle, I, 2007). So while a building might still incorporate a “memory trail” such as described by Martin Habell, or a garden might still contain secure “wandering paths”, sensing technology can enable these routes to be securely extended, without intrusion on normal lifestyle and privacy. This might also enable the design of such elements moves closer to the “norm”, so that a garden is a source of enjoyment for visitors and residents alike, rather than the immediately-identifiable, if well-intentioned “institutional garden”. Such measures are still restrictive and most be weighed in the balance of personal views, which is where “living wills” may have a role.</p><p>Good design allows for more than one solution to any given problem; sensing technologies can be used to free up design potential in this scenario, and in others where creative input has often been stifled by concerns about safety of use. A person who lives in a supported setting often lives there because of some incapacity resulting from impairment, age-related or other. If it has been acknowledged in the first instance that the person requires full-time care and monitoring, sensing can enable that monitoring to be more secure, and at the same time less personally intrusive. Thus it is not appropriate to monitor physical location within the confines of a residential setting, unless a person cannot be otherwise located. It may, however, be appropriate to monitor movement patterns or other bio-signals, and alert if they indicate, or preferably when they predict advers events, for example, an unacceptable level of stress, or an impending fall, which is usually preceded by identifiable changes in gait (Scanaill, 2011). The answer, as with many other similar issues, “some of the data, not all of the data”. Decisions regarding what data is made available to a third party, or what events should trigger an alert, can, and should, be managed by context. While sensing is continuous, data is relayed from an individual sensor to the system only when a significant event occurs, e.g. in relation to identified threshold values being exceeded, or when patterns of activity are detected, rather than constantly bombarding the system with largely irrelevant data. Intelligence will need be distributed throughout such a responsive system, for example, sensors will require some level of local processing/ decision-making in order to filter useful information,and reduce the amount of information which needs to be processed in order to generate a response by way of actuation (Baumgarten, M, Mulvenna, M, 2011). Critically, in a responsive environment model, locally-sensed data need not necessarily be transmitted to the web, which seems to be regarded as the sine qua non of every new sensing application, including bio-sensing applications in healthcare. Commercial sensing applications aimed at elderly people place much emphasis on remote monitoring systems, where physically remote carers use mobile technologies to access information and receive alerts. While web-enabled monitoring applications may be appropriate for many situations, there is an equally strong case for embedment and localised responsivity, which supplements, rather that aspires to substitute the existing relationship between the carer and the resident/patient, and assists in maintaining independent functioning. Moreover, there is a case to be made in this particular physical context, (that of the personal life-space), that all data should not automatically be transmitted to a remote monitoring station. It might be sent to a local monitoring station, but only selectively, on an as-needed basis. The closing of the feedback loop between user and environment might also serve to allay fears about protection of personal data. Invariably, there will be requirement to make value judgments about issues of privacy, versus those of resident wellbeing, even where that is interpreted as far more than basic physical safety. In any such situation, as Malcolm McCullough puts it “activity must be managed by context because of volume of possibilities” (McCullough, 2004): The design of the constituent system parts, (software, hardware, interfaces, sensors), for any responsive space, where architecture becomes the interface, will be dictated by the nature of the expected (and sometimes unexpected) interactions between user and environment, which are to be mediated through the system as a whole. This becomes rapidly evident even in scenarios for a single-user responsive space, for once the room has been equipped with sufficient sensors and a system capable of usefully interpreting continuous sensor data, multiple other possibilities for use immediately present themselves, and may ultimately prove to be limited only by the imagination of the designers involved. The same necessity for management bycontext is seen to apply at other scales, for example, at the scale of the entire site, as described in the earlier scenario involving GPS sensing, and in the same manner, at the scale of detailed design.</p><p>There are very many situations where the capacity of an individual to communicate information about her own status is impaired; that very impairment is often contributes to the person’s requirement for care. As well as the possibility of anticipating such events through interpreted bio-sensing, an affective responsive system might also be used to communicate information on changes in user affect or other status environmentally, for example by using sensed data to actuate changes in the visual environment, rather than by simply raising an alarm. A further potential consequence of the externalisation of affective status might be to raise an individual’s own awareness of such changes. Some research has been proposed for children with ASD on that basis. (Picard, 2009) For these subjects, outbursts of anger are preceded by a significant increase in heart-rate, though there is noapparent change in facial expression. Altering the person to their own incipient emotional state might be used in that scenario to learn to manage such outbursts. For a person with dementia, it is suggested that some management of stress might be through intervention in the room environment, in addition to alerting a carer in anticipation of a “catastrophic event”. Environmental responsivity thus raises further possibilities of therapeutic intervention at the level of the built environment. While multisensory rooms are a commonplace in day and residential care, the possibility begins to exist of a personal room, or any space, becoming capable of adaptation as required, for therapeutic purposes. In a world of rapidly evolving digital technologies, where personal touch-screen appliances are already permeating the mainstream at primary-school level, the introduction of larger-scale displays for use by instructors is contingent only on the cost of such technologies, which is still bordering on prohibitive for widespread use. With advent of largescale digital screens in day-care contexts comes the possibility of multiple uses, including for visual or multimedia therapy.</p><p>Taking the likely increase, or even predominance of people with dementia inresidential care into consideration suggests a more efficient and user-centred approach to providing and designing for residential care provision. If a more progressive model is adopted, the careful use of monitoring technologies has the potential to provide security with less actual physical restriction. The use of wireless sensor technologies in internal environments offers further potential for unobtrusive monitoring which maximises privacy and independence, as well as the possibility of elimination of standard environmental controls (switches, etc.) allowing elderly people in general, and people with dementia as a subset, greater use of their environment, and lowered stress from the frustration due to lost abilityto interpret and use controls, or to successfully communicate even basic needs. One of the hypotheses presented in “Everyware: The Dawning Age of UbiquitousComputing” (Greenfield, 2006) is that “Everyware is strongly implied by the needs of an aging population in the developed world”, at least partly on the basis that continued autonomous living as we age is very appealing, even where it is “underwritten by an unprecedented deployment of informatics in the home”, to the extent that the adoption of pervasive computing may be an absolute necessity if we are to deal effectively and appropriately with impending demographic change. The case for full automation of environmental management is gretaly strengthened by the imperative for contactless controls dictated by the Coronaviras crisis. Greenfield also acknowledges that solutions developed specifically for elderly users may often have application for other user groups. New residential models should therefore take into account making provision for future technology; at the same time, as technologies tend towards miniaturisation and wireless networking, this becomes less and less disruptive of existing building fabric, and therefore maximises the potential for retrofit. Research in the interim has indicated that there are are very significant energy savings (or the order of 30%) can be achieved through designing the environental controls for individual rooms to be trained to personal pereferemce. Innovative design can hit several birds with the same stone, it seems.</p><p>Because of the nature of the dementia and its inexorable demographic progress, a considerable amount of current argument for ageing-in-place seem to revolve around the cost to the state of providing residential care places for a rapidly expanding population of older people with dementia, and the deferral of a move to care for as long as possible on that basis. The prime consideration should, of course, be the question of what constitutes an optimal standard of care and quality-of-life for the person, and in giving elderly people a real choice as to how they live out their years. A change towards psychosocially-supportive care models is insufficient without a matching change in the architecture of care settings. Responsive architecture, underpinned by sensor-based pervasive computing on sensing, can afford less intrusion, more privacy and self-sufficiency, more personal choice, freedom of movement, and enhanced opportunities for “design as therapy” (Willatt, 2011).</p><p><strong>References</strong></p><p>Age UK, 2012. Care in Crisis, London: Age UK.</p><p>Alzheimer’s Association, 2012. 2012 Alzheimer’s Disease facts and figures. Alzheimer’s &amp; Dementia, June.8(2).</p><p>Appleton, Nigel J. W. 2002. Planning for the majority. The needs and aspirations of older people in general housing. York: Joseph Rowntree Foundation.</p><p>Archea, J., 1977. The place of architectural factors in behavioral theories of privacy. Journal of Social Issues.</p><p>Baker, Beth. 2007. Old age in a new age: The promise of Transformative Nursing Homes. Nashville Tennessee. Vanderbilt University Press.</p><p>Barry, Ursula, Conlon, Ciara, 2010. Elderly care in Ireland — provisions and providers. [Online] Available at: <a href="http://researchrepository.ucd.ie/handle/10197/2083">http://researchrepository.ucd.ie/handle/10197/2083</a> [Accessed 03 December 2013].</p><p>Baumgarten, M., Mulvenna, M., 2011. Cognitive Sensor Networks. Dublin, IEEE Transactions.</p><p>Calkins, M., Szmerekovsky, J., Biddle, I., 2007. Effect of increased time spent outdoors on individuals with dementia residing in nursing homes. In: S. S. B. Rodiek, ed. Outdoor Environments for People with Dementia. New York: Hawthorn Press, pp. 211–228.</p><p>Calkins, M., 2009. Evidence-based long term care design. NeuroRehabilitation, Volume 25, pp. 145- 154.</p><p>CDC, 1999. Ten great public health achievements-United States 1900–1999. Morb Mortal Weekly Rep, 48(12), pp. 241–3.</p><p>Charness, N., Holley, P., 2001. Human factors and environmental support in Alzheimer’s Disease. Aging &amp; Mental Health, 5(Supplement 2), pp. S65-S73.</p><p>Christakis, N. A., Allison, P. D., 2006. Mortality after the Hospitalisation of a Spouse. New England Journal of Medicine, 354(7), pp. 719–730.</p><p>Croucher, K., Hicks, L., Jackson, K., 2006. Housing with care for later life. York: Joseph Rowntree Foundation.</p><p>Day, K., Carreon, D., Stump, C., 2000. The Therapeutic Design of Environments for People with Dementia: A Review of the Empirical Research. The Gerontologist, 40(4), pp. 397–416.</p><p>Devlin, Ann Sloan, Arneill, Allison B., 2003. Healthcare environments and patient outcomes:A review of the literature. Environment and Behavior, Volume 33, pp. 665–694.</p><p>Greenfield, A., 2006. Everyware: The Dawning Age of Ubiquitous Computing. Berkeley, Ca: New Riders.</p><p>Habell, M., 2001. The evolution of ‘Close Care’ as user-led care of the elderly in UK. The Journal of the Royal Society for the Promotion of Healt, 121(3), pp. 165–173.</p><p>Habell, M., 2009. Cruel Habitation: The care crisis for the UK. Royal Society for Public Health.</p><p>Habell, M., 2010. The Dementia Care Building Crisis. Perspectives in Public Health, 130(3), p. 110.</p><p>Habell, M., 2013. Specialized design for dementia. Perspectives in Public Health, 133(3), pp. 151–157.</p><p>Helen Hamyln Centre, 2011. <a href="http://www.bettercarehomes.org./">www.bettercarehomes.org.</a> [Online]Available at: <a href="http://www.bettercarehomes.org/">http://www.bettercarehomes.org/</a> [Accessed 24 February 2012].</p><p>Kalben, B. B., 2003. Why Men Die Younger: Causes of Mortality Differences by Sex. [Online] Available at: <a href="http://www.soa.org/news-and-publications/publications/otherpublications/">http://www.soa.org/news-and-publications/publications/otherpublications/</a> monographs/m-li01–1-toc.aspx [Accessed 02 December 2013].</p><p>Kane, R. et al, 2007. Resident outcomes in Small-House Nursing Homes. JAGS, Volume 55, pp. 832-839.</p><p>Lawton, M. P., 1975. Competence, environmental press and the adaptation of older people. In: Windley, P., Ernst, G. eds. Theory Development in Environment and Aging. Washington, D.C.: Gerontological Society of America, pp. 33–59.</p><p>Layte, R. et al., 2009. Projecting the impact of demographic change on the demand for and delivery of healthcare in Ireland, Dublin: ESRI.</p><p>Maguire, Aideen et al, 2013. Psychotropic Medications and the Transition Into Care: A National Data Linkage Study. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society, 61(2), pp. 215–221.</p><p>Nightingale, Florence. 1860. Notes on Nursing. What it is and what it is not. New York, NY: D. Appleyon &amp; Co.</p><p>McCullough, M., 2004. Digital Ground: Architecture, Pervasive Computing and Environmental Knowing. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.</p><p>OECD, 2013. Health at a Glance 2013: OECD Indicators. [Online] Available at: <a href="http://www.oecd.org/unitedstates/Health-at-a-Glance-2013-Press-Release-USA.pdf">http://www.oecd.org/unitedstates/Health-at-a-Glance-2013-Press-Release-USA.pdf</a> [Accessed 02 December 2013].</p><p>Picard, R., 2009. Future affective technology for autism and emotion communication. Phil. Trans. R. Soc. B., Issue 1535, pp. 3575–3584.</p><p>Scanaill, C., et al. 2011 Clinical Gait assessment of older adults using open platform tools. Proceedings of IEEE EMBC’11. Boston, MA.</p><p>Select Committee on Public Service and Demographic Change, 2013. Ready for Ageing?, London: House of Lords.</p><p>Takahashi, P.Y., et al, 2012. A Randomized Controlled Trial of Telemonitoring in Older Adults With Multiple Health Issues to Prevent Hospitalizations and Emergency Department Visits. Arch Intern Med.172(10):773–779, 172(10), pp. 773–779.</p><p>Teresi, J. A. et al, 2000. Commentary The Therapeutic Design of Environments for People With Dementia: Further Reflections and Recent Findings From the National Institute on Aging</p><p>Collaborative Studies of Dementia Special Care Units. The Gerontologist, 40(4), pp. 417–421. United States Census, 2010.</p><p>Torrington, J.M., Tregenza, P. M., 2007. Lighting for people with dementia. Lighting. Res. Technol.39(1)</p><p>van Hoof, J., et al, 2008. The indoor environment in relation to people with dementia. Copenhagen, 11th International Conference on Indoor Air Quality and Climate.</p><p>Willatt, J., 2011. Design as Therapy. Revista AUS, Volume 9, pp. 4–9.</p><p>Wiltzius, S. F., Gambert, S. R., Duthie, E. H., 1981. Importance of resident placement within a skilled nursing facility. Journal of the Americam Geriatrics Society, Volume 29, pp. 418–421.</p><p>Ziesel, J., 2005. Environment, neuroscience, and Alzheimer’s disease. Alz Care Quart, Volume 6, pp. 273–278.</p><p>Ziesel, J., 2010. I’m Still Here. London: Piatkus.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2a118c4231e0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>