<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Chad Makaio Zichterman on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Chad Makaio Zichterman on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@chadmakaiozichterman?source=rss-64716d04594d------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 01:18:37 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@chadmakaiozichterman/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why Whites Should End White Supremacy, Part II: Better Mistakes For Life]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@chadmakaiozichterman/why-whites-should-end-white-supremacy-part-ii-better-mistakes-for-life-8237d25c3466?source=rss-64716d04594d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8237d25c3466</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[anti-racism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[white-supremacy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Chad Makaio Zichterman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 11 Feb 2019 22:00:05 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-02-11T22:00:05.078Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>For white people, committing to defeating white supremacy means a lifelong process of improving our failures. There is no way around this, and so white people must get to work and get used to doing this work badly as the only means of doing it at all, let alone doing it <em>well</em>.<br> <br> We will fail because nothing in our context provides practical and sustained guidance for defeating white supremacy, while we are surrounded with temptations to leave it alone or reinforce it. Acknowledge those temptations. Get used to them. Help each other see them, and keep doing the work.<br> <br> We will fail repeatedly because inaction is the greatest and most complete failure of all, and we are not trained into endurance. Careerism and consumerism teach us to be risk-averse, or to ask or hire someone to do what we aren’t good at. White supremacy teaches us that those things which white people aren’t prepared to do easily must not be that important, and so they are dismissed. This work <em>can’t</em> be farmed out or handed off; it is a challenge embedded in the nature of white supremacy as a system, and a critical part of the work to dismantle it <em>can only be done by white people.</em> <br> <br> We will fail because the work is new to us, and it is irrational to expect that — unlike every other difficult skill or discipline — somehow antiracism will either just come naturally to us or not at all. <br> <br> We will fail because our privilege trains us to see problems in individual — rather than systemic — terms, and <em>there is no individual solution for systemic problems.</em></p><p>We will succeed, ultimately, if and when we demonstrate more concern for actually defeating white supremacy than we do for *being seen* defeating white supremacy. Our participation is vital and necessary, our comfort and recognition are not. If you want recognition? End white supremacy first, and then — as peers rather than as imagined saviors — share in the unknown collaboration and achievements of what we can build in a world without white supremacy.<br> <br> The most basic point of white people engaging in this work — and yesterday — is that antiracism is not magical: it is difficult and complicated, but it is still subject to improvement. Like any skill, if you are normal, you will not be good at it when you start, and it will take tons of practice to become good at it. Like any addiction, you will fight rationalizations and denial every step of the way in order to avoid facing it honestly, and much of the fight will be about having the integrity to keep pushing when no one else is around to hold you accountable. But since the purpose is the actual liberation of most of humanity — and not your own moral vanity or comfort — contribution of actual work is more important than feeling like this work is a good fit.</p><p>White people also must pick up this challenge <em>now</em> because the habit of backing off whenever things become difficult prevents us from achieving any kind of momentum or continuity. This pattern of tiptoeing around or wading gently into confronting white supremacy as a system is itself a defense mechanism of the system: by centering the comfort of white people, this virtually guarantees that the first steps are taken and repeated over and over, and the more difficult and sustained work is rarely even named, let alone done. This is how we end up with millions of people hitting a plateau and leveling off at Antiracism 101, and a tiny, overextended few stumbling their way through any sustained struggle beyond it. When talk shows and short segments on news programs supposedly aimed at addressing racism promptly cut to commercial and say “we’ll have to leave it there,” we have to pick it up and run with it without any cameras in our face and anyone recording our efforts. That’s precisely not where to end or to leave things, but where to begin.<br> <br> The point of white people moving and acting <em>now</em> is to get in the trenches (which are everywhere, and most of the time), and break through the hardest part of the learning curve — and the inevitable backlash — as soon as possible, so that you can build up endurance and a resistance to the temptation of inaction, the temptation towards comfort. We must push on this today and every day, so that if and when the comprehension AND urgency within you click at the same time in the presence of white supremacy, you’re not losing precious and pivotal moments looking over your shoulder or checking the test of the white person next to you for what you imagine to the right answer. They may not know any better than you, and the worst failure is to give no response at all. If you are hesitant or tempted back into false comfort, you will fail to recognize or confront many of the routine instances of white supremacy in action, such as…</p><ul><li>concentration camps for brown children at the U.S.-Mexico border</li><li>government-sanctioned poisoning of the water supply in Flint</li><li>multiple attempts at banning travel and immigration by Muslims</li><li>seeing a chaperoned mob of white supremacist students on a sponsored lobbying trip be treated in person and in mass media as innocent bystanders rather than aggressors</li><li>going along with the pretense that the economy is meritocratic, or that we live under a democracy</li><li>the grand arc of U.S. international policy and interventions as an extension of white supremacy, in which just about every mass atrocity white people claim to oppose has been and often still is visited upon people in other countries, by “our” government(s), with the normal objections quietly defeated by the subtext that the targeted countries are led and populated by people of color (for those who aren’t tracking the math, that’s most of the world)</li></ul><p>These mistakes we make and will continue to make are <em>for life</em> because it took a lifetime — your lifetime — to train you to be this way, and even with consistent and conscientious intervention and rigorous work prying open your own perceptions and habits, it will take the rest of your life to approach the limit of what you can do to remedy it. On an institutional level, a “lifetime” often means well beyond your own life. So get used to the idea of not being done with this work…ever.</p><p>The point of a <em>system</em> is to ensure a priority against the individual intent of participants. Upholding narrow focus on individual-scale cases of racism and ideological endorsement of racism therefore leaves most of white supremacy unchallenged. It is a successful diversionary tactic, a kind of strategic plea bargaining, in which the presentation of individual persons or small groups are acknowledged as bad (racist) as a means of deflecting from the fact that people don’t have to be failed persons in order to participate in and uphold white supremacy. White supremacy has been able to expand and entrench itself precisely because it offers an escape for its participants to falsely counterpose white supremacy with being a “good person.”</p><p>We don’t need more “good white people” to blunt the most obvious and personal instances of white supremacy. We need sustained, institutional, systematic, revolutionary action to dismantle and overturn white supremacy, carried out by flawed, real white people (the only kind available), because we are literally the people keeping white supremacy in place.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8237d25c3466" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Disclaimer: You’ve Been Told All of This Before]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@chadmakaiozichterman/a-disclaimer-youve-been-told-all-of-this-before-857f0b9fc098?source=rss-64716d04594d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/857f0b9fc098</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Chad Makaio Zichterman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 21 Jan 2019 17:55:27 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-01-21T17:55:27.574Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>*This is not so much a piece of its own, but something which bears repeating in front of everything I write here…</p><p>As a matter of basic respect, integrity, and accuracy, I declare the following:<br> <br>With the exception of my direct personal experiences, almost nothing I have or will write about white supremacy, sexism, class oppression, colonialism, etc. is original.</p><p>There is no insight I may have — no grievance I may raise against injustice — which has not already been done more clearly and powerfully by those directly targeted by that injustice.</p><p>I recognize that if white people consistently heard and acted upon what nonwhite people have been saying, writing, and doing to fight white supremacy since its very beginnings? There would be no need for my work. If men actually heard and acted upon what women in their struggle to endure and defeat patriarchy have seen and called out? Again, <em>my</em> analysis would be irrelevant. On these and so many other fronts, there is a role for me to play <em>not</em> because I have some imagined gift for communication or organizing, but because those forms of oppression have successfully muted or distorted the testimony of the oppressed to the point of obscurity and erasure.<br> <br> There will be many times when it seems as if I’m just repeating or re-framing something targeted people already pointed out about their oppression, but have not been recognized for because the same forces which marginalize them also marginalize perception of their reflection upon that experience. It will seem this way, <em>because it is, and that’s exactly what I am doing.</em></p><p>My main <em>project</em> in writing and as a trainer is not to assert myself as some kind of pioneer, but to try to find the right combination of ideas, words, and voice which may reach privileged audiences in such a way that they finally recognize and acknowledge what has been shown to them — to blank stares or to hostility — a thousand times over long before I was even born. The targeted don’t need me to explain their own lives for them — they can do that just fine without me. The privileged, however, are trained to only see or hear certain kinds of people, and to summarily reject certain messages about their privilege. That’s something <em>I</em> can actually work on, since I know what that conditioning has been (I went through it myself).<br> <br> My role is not to find a new explanation, but to poke and prod and experiment to find a new way through a very old set of blinders, some of which I have managed to break through in my own life.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=857f0b9fc098" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why White People Must Defeat White Supremacy, Part I: Burning Your Draft Card is Not Enough]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@chadmakaiozichterman/why-white-people-must-defeat-white-supremacy-part-i-burning-your-draft-card-is-not-enough-61ef1050f57c?source=rss-64716d04594d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/61ef1050f57c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[anti-racism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[white-supremacy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Chad Makaio Zichterman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 28 Dec 2018 20:17:21 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-12-28T20:17:21.793Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I first noticed the lifelong attempts to recruit me into white supremacy when I was in third or fourth grade. A district employee had come to our school for demographic information around standardized tests, and I remember our class filling in a series of bubbles with my pencil to mark my answers. I arrived at the line for recording my “race” and thought of my parents and my extended family, so I marked “white” (due to my father’s side of the family), <em>and</em> I then marked “Asian” (due to my mother’s side). When the employee came to collect my sheet later, she leaned over me, took the pencil out of my hand without comment, and promptly <em>erased</em> my mark next to “Asian,” blew away the eraser dust (along with my family), and gathered up the paper, moving along mechanically, wordless, to the next student. I felt sad and turned quiet for a few days, and then didn’t think much of it afterwards. But I learned that I was both white and…something <em>else</em> which — whatever it was — was clearly less important than white.</p><p>That same year, was bullied from time to time. One time stood out because it completely blindsided me. I had been pushed to the ground by a pair of bullies — one of them crouching behind my knees and the other shoving me from my front (<em>kids actually do that</em>) — and as I went head over heels and tumbling to the blacktop, they chanted “Chink! Chink!” and instantly drew in others to do the same, some of them pulling the corners of their eyes. Kids who moments earlier had been playing tag with me or patiently taking turns with me on the monkey bars or spelling animals and colors with me in the classroom morphed into a tanbark mob and surrounded me. Somehow it had gotten out that I have some Chinese ancestry, and overnight this had become some special weak spot they could exploit. Just as suddenly as this had come up, however, so too it faded. Later that same week I was already playing around those bullies as if nothing had happened. But I still felt what I wasn’t yet able to voice…decades later, looking through my papers from school, I noticed that for a few months I stopped using my (Hawai’ian) middle name, writing “Matthew” instead of “Makaio.” Like checking the tree rings in a stump, I could see the trace of that flinching retreat frozen in time in the ripples of my homework, my name flickering in and out of the byline and with it, a part of me. In time, I brought my name back, and my class seemed to have distracted itself with other reasons for teasing. I was able to dust myself off and for <em>years</em> went back to not thinking about it.</p><p>In my second year of junior high, on literally the first day I ever broke my parents’ rules about where I was allowed to go and walked way beyond the neighborhood limit they had set, I stumbled upon the person who would later be my first girlfriend. She was so much that I was not: independent, a recent immigrant, a dancer, fluent in five languages as a teenager, and a street-smart and chronic truant. She was also a deep, dark brown, with multiracial parents from different corners of Asia, and enduring frequent abuse from her father. Days after moving from a cramped apartment to their first house in the Bay Area, her family’s living room window was shattered with a brick that had “<em>go home, gook!</em>“ written on it. Within months of that move, her father had fallen back into his habit of commanding and dominating the family out of fear, whether of his fists or even of deportation, as he threatened his own family with deliberately neglecting their paperwork whenever they didn’t do exactly as he wanted. Within a year and a half, that shell of a man — who himself came from an interracial marriage and became part of one — picked up and moved the entire family out of state just to break us up. She was trapped in abuse, and I was paralyzed in my ignorance and fear, and her father won that struggle. As horrible as that was, I still walked — or perhaps crawled — away from that loss and back to a world that welcomed me: loving parents, an elite prep school (even if I eventually flunked out on purpose just to be back with friends in the public system), and most of all, the tastes, the acceptance, and the daily rhythms and affirmations of a world which treated me — almost all of the time — as someone who has a place…who belongs.</p><p>Decades later, I am in a demonstration in San Francisco, chanting “ Shame! Shame!” and trying with several friends to put my body between a line of police and several volunteers who are distributing food to the hungry in the city. On pretext of violating some city safety code, the police rush in and are seizing donated food and arresting the volunteers passing it out. Two officers with batons push right past me, force their way through the crowd, and drag away the <em>only</em> black man in our group of demonstrators. The rest of us are furious, but still resigned…we drag and push for a time to try to slow things down, but it is over in seconds, and our shouts of “LET HIM GO” bounce unheard off the back of the police helmets. The man vanishes into the back of the squad car, and a dozen local homeless people are served and protected out of having a meal. And then I go home, and maybe a few sleepless hours later, I finally get to choose to put it aside…in my own bed…while that man lay in a jail cell downtown.</p><p>These are just some of the contours of a lifetime under white supremacy…<em>from the top.</em> By a conservative account, it has cost me friends, love, lost or never-attempted relationships, knowledge of and genuine interactions with thousands of people, years of battling post-traumatic stress…but most of all, it has invited me, over and over, to step back and accept an unspoken lifeline out and rest…<em>because I can.</em> This reprieve, this call to turn away from the shrieking, daily atrocity that is racism because we have the opportunity to do so? That is, by far, the most powerful and seductive recruiter into white supremacy. The greatest temptation into white supremacy is not the absurd and obvious lies and open bigotry of white terrorists chasing after a return to an elevated community which never existed, but instead being invited to ignore the agony and suffering of most of the world. The district admin gathering statistics in my class never told me directly that there was anything wrong with Chinese people, but her erasure of part of my identity certainly did, just as it encouraged me to walk away from it. The bullies at my school and the mob they enlisted taught me that being something other than white was grounds for harassment, for attack, just as surely as their easy shift into the next target or distraction told me that I — as someone treated as white — could walk away from it by going along with pretending that “white” means the same thing as “person.” My first girlfriend’s father — himself a man of color — didn’t need to tell me that there was and remains a twisted web of vulnerabilities wrought by white supremacy which he could use to prop up his own leverage in abusing his family through patriarchy…his actions <em>showed</em> me. What they showed me was that even at its worst, white supremacy continues to command the participation of white people because it allows them to <em>choose</em> if and when they work against it. Faced with that choice, most white people — most of the time — choose to do nothing…yet the white supremacy of being able to retreat and tune out, by the millions and over generations, is far more lethal.</p><p>The freedom of engaging in mass neglect — to ignore or dismiss white supremacy and be able to suffer few, if any, direct consequences as a result — is both an expression of white supremacy and the primary means by which it is maintained. It is also a key to the central, mandatory pretense of white supremacy as a system: that white supremacy was created and is maintained by an always-abstract group of <em>other</em> white people (…not <em>me…</em> not <em>my</em> white friends or family, not <em>now </em>or in any time I’m part of). In fact, white supremacy is maintained by both the action and the neglect of all those white people who don’t regularly fight against it. That’s <em>us.</em> The self-styled “good white people” (relative to fighting white supremacy) who have imagined at some point that they’ve arrived or that they are doing their fair part in ending white supremacy…the ones who pretend that racism is primarily about attitude and integrity of persons instead of patterns of actions and policy in institutions, and therefore that the limit of antiracist work is a personal one: elite whites with wealth or high social status should do more (because that have greater resources), “normal” white people should not be expected to do as much, but in any case their general project as whites looking to work against racism is to believe the right things about racism ( it’s bad, don’t do it), and that’s it. What is left unsaid and unexamined is that <em>the bulk of white supremacy is maintained and expanded by those very same “good” white people, </em>precisely because they — <em>we — </em>stop where we should be beginning…and we are rendered <em>able</em> to stop because we are predominantly living and working with and around fellow white people (who won’t call us out for not doing more, or who will let us withdraw in silence even when we are called out).</p><p>In other words… <em>white people are trained to uphold white supremacy by default.</em> We are told to just see ourselves as “people,” instead of <em>white</em> people, which implies that if something is not a problem for us…it’s not a problem, period. We don’t need to actively do anything to keep our privilege…we need to actively do something to challenge it. We are trained to act in ways which put us — specifically as white people — above others, not just through passively going along with oppression, but literally performing the daily actions and making the daily decisions which keep that oppression in place.</p><p>Stop and think about that… as a white person, <em>challenging</em> white supremacy makes you abnormal…inappropriate…even criminal. Going <em>against</em> a system which undermines the lives of most people on earth…makes you abnormal. White people are, as a population, <em>weaponized</em> against the rest of humanity.</p><p>So if all that weight doesn’t reliably motivate you — or me — to end white supremacy, this raises an ugly question: why should white people end a system which props them up, sets them up with advantages, social status, even wealth? White supremacy is such a great deal (for white people), so why bite the hand that feeds us?</p><p>Here’s why.</p><p>Because it’s a lie. It’s a counterfeit. It doesn’t sustain us or solve our problems, it just deflects and postpones them, only to resurface in other forms. Propping up white people at everyone else’s expense may make us better off — in a very narrow sense, relative to race — but it also carries a heavy price <em>as a white person</em>:</p><p>It deludes us, slowly destroying our judgment about ourselves and others: <em>sure, racism is awful for some people, but that’s got nothing to do with me, or most of the white people I know.</em></p><p>It distorts our sense of our own abilities, telling us we’re capable of doing things which in fact no one can do: <em>I know how good or bad life is for nonwhite people, even though I don’t experience it and I have spent little or no effort listening to their direct accounts.</em></p><p>It treats routine, possible, and desperately needed things as impossible: <em>some things may be unfair, and we should work against it when we see it, but this is the best we can do (where “best we can do” is defined by not going beyond white comfort).</em></p><p>It erodes our very humanity, our ability to act upon the instinct to help and protect one another, trading in a broad horizon of solidarity for an increasingly narrow one: <em>I need to take care of my own family / neighborhood / community first ( most of which will be predominantly white ).</em></p><p>White supremacy tells us as white people that we’re so terrific at well…<em>everything</em>…that when we inevitably fail at something, then something is wrong with <em>us — not the narrative we tell ourselves — </em>and our learned weakness and rigid thinking cuts us off from the best, most genuine, most capable versions of our selves. Worst of all, the combination of willful, learned ignorance and privileged institutional power turns white people into a deadly and unstable weapon against <em>most people on earth.</em> By laundering the origin and operation of white political dominance, white supremacy turns white people into the exact opposite of what it claims them to be: from mythical saviors to actual oppressors…from visionary pioneers into hapless dupes…from companions in righteous struggle into liabilities. We wander in search of the source of a problem, when the source — and the means to correct it — is <em>our own refusal to act.</em></p><p>Because even noticing the big lie of white supremacy under a lifetime of training that tells you it doesn’t exist is already a struggle, and white supremacy also tells us that the individual is the beginning and end of all things ( <em>We’re not white! We’re individuals! )</em>, the first response our training teaches us to reach to is that of a conscientious objector, to renounce the unearned mantle placed upon our shoulders. Even that attempt is still white supremacy working us over. White supremacy didn’t ask our personal permission in its establishment, and it doesn’t magically dry up just from declaring personal intention to get rid of it. We can’t end white supremacy just by <em>saying</em> we don’t want it any more, or that we’ll strive to respond to the worst and most obvious individual manifestations of it. Expecting things to change just because we declare something is a cue we’ve taken from white supremacy ( <em>do nonwhite people generally expect things to just happen because they declare their intentions about them, as if the world is their servant? ). </em>Declaring an intention to reject white supremacy is easy. What actually <em>works</em> against white supremacy, however, is a host of actions which white people are (again, due to their training) especially bad at doing, and there’s no way to improve except to jump in and learn to make better mistakes with practice.<br> <br> (…to be continued in Part II: <em>Better Mistakes for Life</em> )</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=61ef1050f57c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>