<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Chad Renando on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Chad Renando on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@chadrenando?source=rss-ed20c6660319------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 07:50:46 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@chadrenando/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A map of Australian annual innovation and impact events]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/ready-communities/a-map-of-australian-annual-innovation-and-impact-events-93a7cfac3bfe?source=rss-ed20c6660319------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/93a7cfac3bfe</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Chad Renando]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 05 Apr 2024 18:08:11 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-04-05T18:08:11.822Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>A few weeks back, <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/ready-communities-social-impact-regions-2024-macleay-kempsey-renando-v9uec/">I shared about the new Ready Communities program</a> that co-founder <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/graceevolve/">Kerry Grace</a> and I are delivering with <a href="https://socialimpactintheregions.com.au/ready-communities/ready-macleay/">Ready Macleay</a> as the first region in Kempsey, NSW.</p><p>The post was followed by <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/map-place-based-ecosystem-building-frameworks-chad-renando-peebc/">another that mapped place-based programs in Australia</a> to consider Ready Communities in the mix of other place-based initiatives.</p><p>With the <a href="https://socialimpactintheregions.com.au/">Social Impact in the Regions conference</a> as a key part of the Ready Communities program, we now map annual Australian innovation and impact events to understand the landscape.</p><h3>The value and evolution of events</h3><p>Events are essential features of entrepreneur ecosystems and regional communities. Events provide boundary-spanning connections, bring diverse communities together around shared interests, build individual capability through sharing knowledge and ideas, and advance shared projects for collective impact.</p><p>Events related to innovation and impact have matured in Australia over the past decade. In addition to events for most industry sectors, sub-sectors, technologies, and functions, each state and territory hosts annual events focused on startups and entrepreneurs. Growth in event quality and quantity across Australia also highlights the opportunity to consider ways to support event alignment, differentiation, and sustainability.</p><h3>A personal reflection</h3><p>I can trace my career development to specific event experiences. In 2017, I attended <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/lessons-from-kauffman-foundation-2017-eship-summit-call-chad-renando/">the Kauffman Foundation’s inaugural EShip Summit in Kansas City</a> which I credit with directing me on my current course through mind-expanding new ideas and life-impacting relationships. When I managed <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/fire-station-101-first-18-months-innovation-hub-chad-renando/">the Fire Station 101 innovation hub from 2016 to 2018</a>, we ran two to three events a week plus two to three hackathons a year to intentionally develop communities of practice and create a cadence of activation in the community. For three years from 2015, <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/why-we-rhok-announcing-ipswich-random-hacks-kindness-chad-renando/">I was involved in Random Hacks of Kindness hackathons</a> at a time when leveraging emerging technology for social impact in rapid iteration was a novel experience. From 2018 I continued to learn and share in events specific to the emerging field of innovation ecosystems, including <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/qode-brisbane-state-australian-queensland-innovation-chad-renando/">the Queensland Qode conference</a>, the <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/connecting-practitioners-entrepreneur-research-2019-chad-renando/">Australian Centre for Entrepreneurship Research Exchange</a>, the <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/8point8-conference-entrepreneurship-88-million-regions-chad-renando/">regional 8point8 conference</a>, South Australia’s <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/australian-innovation-ecosystem-leadership-summit-2021-chad-renando/">_SouthStart conference</a>, and the <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/australian-entrepreneur-ecosystem-presentation-2020-g20-chad-renando/">G20 Roundtable on Entrepreneurship</a>.</p><p>In 2019, I <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/global-entrepreneurship-congress-2019-ecosystems-unique-chad-renando/">attended the Global Entrepreneurship Congress (GEC) in Bahrain</a> where I picked up the role of Managing Director for the <a href="https://www.genglobal.org/australia">Global Entrepreneurship Network Australia</a>. I returned to the GEC three years later in Bahrain <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/preparing-2023-global-entrepreneurship-congress-chad-renando/">leading the Australian delegation in 2022</a>. From 2020 to 2023, I was then involved in the project to <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/impact-evaluation-melbourne-2023-global-congress-chad-renando-jw3uc/">bring the Global Entrepreneurship Congress 2023 to Melbourne</a>.</p><p>As my participation in events increased, so did growing questions about impact. The inherent value in events was clear. If nothing else, the evidence was seen in anecdotal observations of my own life. But how could impact be measured more broadly and consistently?</p><p>Can the benefit of events be more than a dopamine hit from thousands of networks and interactions, or is that enough? How do we connect the impact of hundreds of events, or at least draw a connective line through events in the same field over the year and across years? And how can an event have a greater impact on the place in which it is held, or at least avoid being extractive?</p><h3>Insights from GEC 23</h3><p>These questions were top of mind as I worked on the three-year GEC 23 project. The personal impact of the project was significant, including my reinforced respect for leaders in the Australian ecosystem who deliver events year after year. The collective muscle memory and capability in the cohort of leaders involved in innovation and impact event delivery is an undervalued asset in the Australian ecosystem.</p><p>The GEC event provided opportunities to trial approaches for increasing event impact, including a long lead-in engagement before the event to define opportunities to build innovation infrastructure and develop opportunities for collective impact through the event. Some ideas worked and others did not, but the lessons were invaluable.</p><p>Reflections that stayed with me from the GEC include a need to:</p><ul><li>Ensure structural alignment and shared KPIs between event functions of impact, funding, and brand;</li><li>Embed impact evaluation from the project’s outset;</li><li>Embed inclusive and diverse perspectives across event sponsorship and program;</li><li>Engage the local host community in event planning and impact; and</li><li>Define the longitudinal impact across annual events.</li></ul><h3>Application to Social Impact in the Regions</h3><p>Following the GEC I was introduced to <a href="https://kerrygrace.com.au/">Kerry Grace</a> who had also just delivered the 2023 Social Impact in the Regions conference, an event that integrated economic development and community development for broad social impact. Kerry’s views aligned with my previous work in <a href="https://research.usq.edu.au/item/q715x/the-role-of-innovative-hubs-in-building-community-resilience">connecting innovation and entrepreneurship to holistic community resilience in regional communities</a>. We combined our work in <a href="https://socialimpactintheregions.com.au/ready-communities/">Ready Communities</a>, a two-year program with a 10-month engagement, a 3-day conference, and a 12-month follow-on support program.</p><p>The 2024 Social Impact in the Regions conference will be from 4 to 6 September in Kempsey, NSW. The event is designed for anyone who participates in, contributes to, or is interested in social impact in regional, rural, and remote communities. Designed using a principle of “content in context”, the experience is relevant to all regional communities and is informed by the engagement with the local community leading up to the event. The event provides delegates with a unique opportunity to make a lasting impact from their participation.</p><p>As a new event, we are conscious that we are entering a full calendar of events in Australia. The broad coverage of economic and community impact by the Social Impact in the Regions conference expands the types of related events in the minds of delegates and partners.</p><p>In keeping with our practice, we publically share a map of potentially related events and invite conversation and engagement to build clarity, connection, capability, and capacity in the wider Australian innovation and impact ecosystem.</p><h3>A map of innovation and impact events in Australia</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*SPHjMK7rJkozaAXz" /></figure><p>Any static map of ecosystem roles such as the one above will change as soon as it is published.</p><p>You can <a href="https://your.startupstatus.co/map/#All#16#All#All#All#All#All#All#role">view the dynamic live map of events here</a>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/995/0*soxTaRq_fmxdzBZg" /></figure><h3>Caveats and considerations</h3><p>Mapping is always performed with respect and some trepidation as we interpret what can be observed and represent it at a point in time.</p><p>As is the way with any mapping exercise, we start with some caveats:</p><ul><li>The list is not comprehensive: We document events through local knowledge, data mining, and web searches. There are some missing, including some likely embarrassing omissions. If you see something missing, please let us know.</li><li>Zombie events: Events can maintain an online presence years after their last iteration. There will be a few legacy links until confirmation that the event is no longer running.</li><li>‘Innovation’ and ‘impact’ are broad with many intersections: Ecosystem boundaries are blurry, socially defined, and intersecting. Our main focus is on fields related to innovation and impact, with a place-based and sectoral focus. There will always be discussion on what is in and outside this definition.</li><li>Additional categorisation is required: Some events are tagged based on sector and impact. The tagging is not comprehensive or complete. Selecting a sector, impact, or technology filter may not show some relevant events.</li><li>Limited to annual events and awards with events: Our focus is on Australian annual full-day or multi-day events and/or award programs that culminate in an annual event. This excludes international events periodically held in Australia, one-off events that are not recurring, and regular community events. There may also be annual events that emerge or have happened that are not shown based on the time of this writing due to not being in market, including Northern Territory’s October Business Month and the Canberra Innovation Network’s Innovation Showcase.</li><li>This is not a full calendar of events: A logical evolution of the map would be a directory and schedule of events. In the past, we have played with creating a national directory of events including building APIs into Meetup and Eventbrite and using a shared Google calendar. Challenges we experienced include limitations with the increasingly popular Humanitix not having a comparable API, and limited funding models to maintain a national events register. Current approaches are managed by state-based platforms through central bodies such as LaunchVic or Advance Queensland and industry bodies such as Climate Salad for climate-related events.</li><li>Event month may change: The month the event is listed is based on the 2023 to 2025 calendar and may vary based on the year.</li><li>Defer to event peak bodies and experts: I write this as a practitioner, researcher, observer, and leader in organisations not specific to events. My focus is on mapping, which may see me map areas I observe but in which I am not necessarily an expert. Others can provide greater insights including the many professional event practitioners and their peak bodies such as the <a href="https://abea.org.au/">Australian Business Events Association</a>, <a href="https://www.meetingsevents.com.au/">Meetings and Events Australia</a>, and <a href="https://www.eeaa.com.au/">Exhibition &amp; Event Association of Australia</a>.</li></ul><h3>Observations</h3><p>Seeing the map in a single visual provides an opportunity for some initial observations. These are based on a sample and not the total population of events, but observations can still be indicative.</p><ul><li>May and October are busy months: Very little happens in January due to school holidays, coming off New Year’s, and holidays at the end of the month. The heat of the middle of Summer may also not help matters. Of the sample of 103 events, 14 and 15 events are scheduled in October and May, respectively.</li><li>Media driving events: InnovationAus represents with their annual awards and regular capability papers sessions (not listed as they are not single annual conferences). The Australian Financial Review is a prominent contributor to the event schedule, with their AFR Live representing 14 events across the annual calendar. The AFR Live can be seen to bring together thought leaders to drive a narrative captured in the paper while ideally also supporting and not displacing others in each topic verticle.</li><li>Sydney-centric: Sydney has a greater proportion of events likely due to its geographic centrality for travel. Other events have a place-focus such as state conferences like South Australia’s _SouthStart, the Tropical Innovation Festival in Cairns, and the Maranoa Ag Innovation Expo.</li><li>Industry body events: Industry bodies drive events for their members, such as the National Farmers Federation National Conference, GrainGrowers Innovation Generation, Agrifutures evokeAg, Philanthropy Australia’s National Conference, and Cooperative Research Australia’s National Policy Summit and Collaborate Innovation Conference.</li><li>Verticles and sub-sectors: There is an event for most everybody and a niche within sectors, like the Technology in Government conference, HR and L&amp;D Innovation &amp; Tech Fest, EduTech conference, TechDiversity, Legal Innovation &amp; Tech Fest sports tech focused SportsNxt. Technology streams will also have events such as Blockchain Week, Crypto Conventions, and Surgical Robotics Innovation Summit.</li><li>Startup and Entrepreneur events: The national schedule of startup events includes South Australia’s _SouthStart, Queensland’s Tropical Innovation Festival and SomethingFest, Western Australia’s WestTechFest, New South Wales’ Spark Festival and recent addition SXSW Sydney, Northern Territory’s CrocPitch and October Business Month, Canberra’s CBRIN Innovation Showcase, and Now or Never and Thrive in Victoria. There are also events for dedicated functions in the startup community including InnovationBay’s Inspire conference, Blackbird’s Sunrise Festival, and the National Health &amp; Innovation Precincts Summit.</li><li>Months and weeks: Dedicated month-long and week-long campaigns are scheduled throughout the year, including Indigenous Business Month, NT Business Month, Global Entrepreneurship Week, National Science Week, and Blockchain Week. There are more and we can add them in to align campaigns.</li><li>Impact, place, and rural: Looking at the calendar through the lens of the Social Impact in the Regions conference, other events that relate to social impact capability, place, and regional economies include ChangeFest, Social Impact Summit, Regional Australia Institute’s National Summit, National Economic Development Conference, Segra National Regional and Economic Development Conference, Mainstreet Australia conference, and Purpose Conference.</li></ul><h3>Reflections and next steps</h3><p>This review of events has helped confirm the position of the <a href="https://socialimpactintheregions.com.au/">Social Impact in the Regions conference</a>, in that it has a deep connection to place, focused support for practitioners in social impact, integration with a two-year place-based program, and invitation for delegates to join in a ten-year vision of impact. The Conference is also part of a wider ecosystem of related events we can work with to facilitate greater impact and systems change beyond what we can achieve on our own.</p><p>Some reflections on the wider events ecosystem include:</p><ul><li>Clarity and alignment for sponsors and speakers: Many sponsors and speakers are shared among events. It would be good to align efforts to make it as easy as possible for speakers and sponsors, acknowledging competitive tensions from geographic and sector boundaries.</li><li>Work together for systemic change: The annual event schedule creates a cadence of interaction. It would be good to integrate shared challenges and narratives where possible to build on outcomes from other events and effect wider systems change through event connections and collaborations.</li><li>Sustainability: Australian events can be a challenging business model. Australia has a large geographic distribution, a relatively small pool of sponsors particularly for niche topics, and increasing event delivery costs. These challenges are increased for regional communities. While not directly related to innovation and impact events, insights can be gained from the recently cancelled 2024 Splendor in the Grass music festival. Events need to be treated as an asset and supported, particularly for those who would benefit the most from or may not have easy access to the connections.</li><li>Align schedules: One of the motivations for mapping events was to see where there might be conflict in delegate and speaker schedules and travel budgets. A national calendar will help to minimise duplication and create space between similar events where possible.</li><li>Align event impact: We are building the evaluation and impact framework into the Ready Communities program. It would be good to share metrics where possible to build the overall capacity and capability across events, acknowledging <a href="https://www.tra.gov.au/en/economic-analysis/business-events-data">the work already being done to align event data</a>.</li></ul><p>I am grateful for those who have brought people together in events I have attended that have brought me to where I am now. I also appreciate the work of hundreds of leaders who connect Australians and Australia as a country through the national portfolio of innovation, entrepreneurship, and impact-related events every year.</p><p>As always, feedback and critique are most welcome. I am keen to hear your reflections on Australian innovation and impact events and to work with you as part of a national, long-term vision of impact from greater connection and connectivity.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=93a7cfac3bfe" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/ready-communities/a-map-of-australian-annual-innovation-and-impact-events-93a7cfac3bfe">A map of Australian annual innovation and impact events</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/ready-communities">Ready Communities</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Mapping community initiatives in a place-base program: A Ready Macleay update]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/ready-communities/mapping-community-initiatives-in-a-place-base-program-a-ready-macleay-update-4dd29301e48e?source=rss-ed20c6660319------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4dd29301e48e</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Chad Renando]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 20 Mar 2024 04:31:16 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-03-20T04:31:16.463Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>We are three months into <a href="https://medium.com/ready-communities/ready-communities-and-social-impact-in-the-regions-2024-ready-macleay-in-kempsey-nsw-2aa457701f98">the Ready Macleay program</a>, the first implementation of the place-based <a href="https://socialimpactintheregions.com.au/ready-communities/">Ready Communities initiative</a>. The approach is designed to support an established or emerging backbone structure, align with existing and new community-led initiatives, and support impact across community development and economic development before the <a href="https://socialimpactintheregions.com.au/">Social Impact in the Regions conference</a> in September.</p><p>The support and engagement have been encouraging as we build in and with community, along with feedback from the wider national and global ecosystem of place-based practitioners. We are keen to continue to share our progress for collective learning and feedback.</p><p>Ready Communities co-founder <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/graceevolve/">Kerry Grace</a> has been sharing about the journey, reflecting on the <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/reimagining-role-our-regional-main-streets-commerce-connection-grace-qblxc/">role of regional main streets</a>, <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/role-local-procurement-building-regional-capability-kerry-grace-bgiyc/">local procurement</a>, <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/encouraging-community-led-change-while-government-catches-kerry-grace-xytec/">local government and missions</a>, <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/four-principles-consider-delivering-effective-regional-kerry-grace-yup7c/">principles of community conversations</a>, and <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/how-bridging-economic-community-development-silos-generate-grace-lhyic/">bridging economic and community development silos</a>. Last week I reflected on the growth of place-based initiatives including <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/map-place-based-ecosystem-building-frameworks-chad-renando-peebc/">a map of approaches in Australia</a>.</p><p>This post continues the conversation and highlights the engagement with emerging community-defined initiatives and how these are considered in light of existing initiatives and emerging opportunities.</p><h3>Initial engagement: Establishing the focus areas</h3><p>The Initial Engagement stage in January highlighted <a href="https://socialimpactintheregions.com.au/ready-communities/ready-macleay/">five focus areas</a>: Housing, Agriculture Communities, Youth Futures, CBD Activation, and Creative Industries. The initial engagement involved 30 engagements over 45 hours with 28 leaders, a review of current strategy and policy, and a review of current programs and initiatives. The five focus areas were broad enough to be inclusive of other topics while focusing attention. The themes would be validated and refined over the following weeks.</p><p>The focus areas provided a foundation to further develop and build on existing clusters and networks around each topic. While place-based work has a geographic focus, it is the topics of interest and passion areas that bring people around the table. We also acknowledge the cross-over of initiatives between focus areas and topics that intersect across all focus areas.</p><h3>Community conversations: Emerging initiatives</h3><p>The Engagement stage started with a series of group community and one-on-one conversations. Over the past month, we have had 198 engagements over 465 engagement hours with 111 leaders. We are also mapping a growing list of 25 policies, strategies, and funds applicable in the region. The engagements have identified a growing list of 70 initiatives across the five focus areas.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*vekBqFGzV567Qg98" /></figure><p>Over the next month, we will continue the engagement with an iterative approach to add, refine, curate, and start progress on initiatives. Key to this is the connection with <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/jo-anne-kelly-a8098b152/">Jo-Anne Kelly</a> and her team in the local backbone <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/learning-the-macleay-115188298/">Learning the Macleay</a> as they engage across the region to hear challenges and opportunities from the region.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*4t9Zv3pHMk2Wej1Q" /></figure><p>A few principles and considerations become apparent as we review the initiatives.</p><ul><li>Initiatives are integrated and interrelated, connected to each other and with application across focus areas. A need for transport relates to youth futures and housing. A strong creative industry supports CBD activation, and both have shared value with agriculture communities.</li><li>Initiatives have systemic contributing factors. The decline in rural main streets and housing availability and affordability are globally recognised challenges. A review of agriculture supply chains involves many stakeholders and market drivers. We look for achievable outcomes while acknowledging the complexity of underlying factors.</li><li>Initiatives are usually pre-existing and aligned with existing strategies or plans of the local council, state government, economic body, community group, or industry network. Initiatives raised in community may already be underway, but there can also be a lack of visibility or awareness.</li><li>Initiatives are not the only focus. Engagement is an equal measure of relationship and action. While good ideas came through structured workshops, there is just as much value in sitting in Main Street and having a yarn as people walk by. Ideas come at the cross-section of diverse perspectives and often need space in both place and time to develop.</li></ul><p>With all this in mind, there is value in taking a structured approach to reviewing ideas, opportunities, and initiatives that emerge in the lead up to the Social Impact in the Regions conference. To help with this, initiatives are reviewed using a framework to consider how they might relate to each other and other plans, policies, strategies, and initiatives in the region.</p><p>The analysis highlights the interconnected nature of the initiatives in the network graph below. The graph shows the clusters of initiatives around the outside of the diagram connected through themes and attributes in the middle. We are working on a public interface that will allow community interaction with the graph. The picture highlights the potential for additional sets of initiatives from other plans, programs, and strategies to interact and align with the outcomes of the community action.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*wERquGUVFfQKUtxJ" /></figure><h3>Reviewing and aligning community initiatives</h3><p>The initial review of the initiatives is highlighted below. This is far from a definitive statement or exact science, as much as it is a first pass to provide an invitation for engagement and adjustment as we continue the community conversations.</p><p>One of the category sets is a series of assessments about each initiative using what information is available. These include:</p><ul><li>Accountability: This is an assessment of the extent to which the individual, group, or organisation that defines the initiative are accountable or ultimately responsible for the outcomes. In general items with greater internal accountability are more likely to be realised, mixed accountability requires greater collaboration, and there may be limited control over initiatives with fully external accountability.</li><li>Complexity: This is the degree of complexity involved in realising the outcomes, described by the level of uncertainty, the significance of the potential impact, the number of stakeholders involved, and the dependency on other stakeholders.</li><li>Effort required: This is the perceived or actual effort or resource investment involved with the initiative, relative to other items in a similar domain.</li><li>Impact: This is the perceived or actual expected impact of the initiative, relative to other items in a similar domain.</li><li>Specificity: This relates to how specific and detailed or general the initiative is.</li><li>Action: This defines the type or nature of the activity being performed, and describes how the recipient of the initiative will be interacted with.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/952/0*9MYS9Y2_dHZKdMym" /></figure><p>Another consideration is the direct beneficiary of the initiative. This can help identify where there might be gaps as well as alignment with other initiatives in the region.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*TiXCqWLWF66rnd0Q" /></figure><p>The initiatives are also considered against the UN’s Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). While there is an element of subjectivity to many of the ratings, the SDGs provide a globally recognised framework against which initiatives can be compared for other local, state, and national examples.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*qb2k57QtQCvqUoM1" /></figure><p>Another question that can be considered is the initiative status, or the extent that it might be considered new or a continuation to maintain, modify, or expand on what is already in place.</p><p>The recipient level considers whether the beneficiary of the outcome is an individual, a firm, a role, a segment of the community, or the overall geographic region.</p><p>Education considers the type of education provided if relevant, while education stage considers at what level the education is provided.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*zAQbwuFJ-ll6TWxu" /></figure><p>We also consider where the initiative might result in outcomes aligned with the Ready Communities program. These outcomes include greater clarity and understanding, increased connections and connectivity, building capability and capacity, enhanced collaboration for purpose, and greater advocacy and promotion.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/562/0*XknsFxqJBklbIFIv" /></figure><p>The assessment is flexible in that new categories are created for different domains, such as infrastructure, inclusion, climate, agriculture, and health. Given the platform is used to analyse initiatives, strategies, and policies in other geographic regions and sectors, initiatives and strategies that emerge in Ready Macleay can more easily be aligned with other areas to identify connections.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*EwTpXYF6dfLacajj" /></figure><h3>What’s next</h3><h3>Build capacity by doing together</h3><p>The focus for initiatives in the Ready Communities approach is not as much the realisation of the initiative itself as it is the shared experience by the community in realising the initiative. As we work with leaders in the focus areas, we expect to see a shared understanding of opportunities for collective impact.</p><h3>Continued integration, alignment, and adjustment</h3><p>We continue to apply the same coding techniques to various policy, strategy, and program initiatives applicable to the region. This will help connect the community-defined initiatives with other plans and funding opportunities. By building in public, we also receive feedback that continuously updates existing initiatives and identifies new opportunities.</p><h3>A digital map</h3><p>The mapping is performed on a digital platform that provides visibility and transparency. The platform will be made public over the next couple of months. As it is populated, the platform will be provided to the community as part of the continued engagement and support process. This will also help maintain connectivity with other relevant initiatives, strategies, and policies from other programs including other Ready Communities locations.</p><h3>May community conversations</h3><p>The engagement will continue through March and April leading up to the next structured community conversations in May. The plan is to work in community to progress ideas to a stage that can be further developed, validated, and trialed in May. This will inform further development before the third community conversations in July and prior to the conference in September.</p><h3>Integration with Social Impact in the Regions conference</h3><p>Over the coming months, we will continue to refine the initiatives, identifying what is already in place and what might be achieved in the lead-up to the <a href="https://socialimpactintheregions.com.au/">Social Impact in the Regions conference</a>.</p><p>Everyone who has a vested interest in regional impact will benefit from September’s Social Impact in the Regions conference. The program focuses on diverse aspects of economic and community development with an emphasis on practical application. The conference will host broad conversations relevant to practitioners in all regions. It is also unique in that it is informed by the Ready Macleay process over the preceding ten months and designed with a local impact in mind.</p><p>Initiatives from the five focus areas will provide nationally relevant and locally applicable case studies for delegates to learn from, contribute to, and experience first-hand. There will also be opportunities to contribute to the success of the local community over the 12 months following the conference.</p><h3>Join us on the journey and in September</h3><p>If you are involved or interested in social impact in regional communities, it would be amazing to share the journey with you in September. A limited number of <a href="https://socialimpactintheregions.com.au/bursaries/">bursaries are available at this link here</a> or <a href="https://events.humanitix.com/social-impact-in-the-regions-2024">conference tickets are available here</a>. You can also apply to speak <a href="https://socialimpactintheregions.com.au/apply-to-speak-at-social-impact-in-the-regions-2024/">at this link here</a>.</p><p>We are grateful to those supporting the work, including the <a href="https://evolvenetwork.com.au/">Evolve Network</a> and the <a href="https://www.ruraleconomies.org.au/">Rural Economies Centre of Excellence</a> at the <a href="https://www.unisq.edu.au/">University of Southern Queensland</a>. Please <a href="https://socialimpactintheregions.com.au/contact/">get in touch</a> if you would like to join a growing cohort of organisations supporting the work and sharing in the impact.</p><p>Your feedback, insights, and experience are welcome as we co-create the approach with the Kempsey and wider Macleay community and the national and global community of practitioners in the field.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4dd29301e48e" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/ready-communities/mapping-community-initiatives-in-a-place-base-program-a-ready-macleay-update-4dd29301e48e">Mapping community initiatives in a place-base program: A Ready Macleay update</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/ready-communities">Ready Communities</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Ready Communities and Social Impact in the Regions 2024: Ready Macleay in Kempsey, NSW]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/ready-communities/ready-communities-and-social-impact-in-the-regions-2024-ready-macleay-in-kempsey-nsw-2aa457701f98?source=rss-ed20c6660319------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2aa457701f98</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[placemaking]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[entrepreneur-ecosystem]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[regional-development]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Chad Renando]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 22 Feb 2024 10:54:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-02-22T18:38:48.395Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Introducing Ready Communities, a new place-making program developed with cofounder and Evolve Network CEO <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/graceevolve/">Kerry Grace</a> and supported by the <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/company/rural-economies-centre-of-excellence/">Rural Economies Centre of Excellence</a> at the <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/company/university-of-southern-queensland/">University of Southern Queensland</a>. The post below shares some of the why, how, and what’s next.</h4><p>Ready Communities is <a href="https://socialimpactintheregions.com.au/ready-communities/">a new program</a> supporting place-based transformation and transition with a vision to engage 15 to 18 regions over ten years. The first Ready Communities program, <a href="https://socialimpactintheregions.com.au/ready-communities/ready-macleay/">Ready Macleay</a>, launched in January 2024 in New South Wales, Australia. The program includes the <a href="https://socialimpactintheregions.com.au/">Social Impact in the Regions conference</a>, which for 2024 is from 4 to 6 September in Kempsey, NSW. The Social Impact in the Regions conference is designed in, by, and for regions to bring together conversations for impact in the local community and build national capacity in regional social impact leaders and practitioners across Australia.</p><h3>Why Ready Communities?</h3><p>Ready Communities has come about to support regional communities to thrive, accelerate and address challenges in place-based approaches, and align economic and social outcomes in rural communities. The initiative is also the culmination of decades of experience and research into place-based approaches to support regional transition.</p><p>First, there is a need to <a href="https://rebalancethenation.com.au/">address the balance</a> between regional communities and high-population capital cities with factors including distance, population, infrastructure, services, and financial and information capital access. This tension increases with trends in climate impacts, industrial transformation, and technological disruption. Communities are not defined by this tension, providing unique strengths in lifestyle, culture, diversity, and essential contributions to the national economy and identity. Ready Communities explores opportunities to capitalise on strengths and identify areas for collective community action.</p><p>Second, there is a need to support and supplement other place-based interventions. There is <a href="https://www.paulramsayfoundation.org.au/news-resources/where-are-we-place-based-approaches-to-tackling-community-challenges-in-australia">a growing body of work</a> focused on place-based efforts and <a href="https://www.dss.gov.au/families-and-children-programs-services/stronger-places-stronger-people">long-term programs</a> are designed to address <a href="https://jss.org.au/programs/place-based-hub/map-of-place-based-initiatives/">areas of disadvantage</a>. By nature of the challenges of remote delivery, programs can feel as though support is ‘fly-in/fly-out’, lack connection to established support roles, overlook or even reinforce systemic issues, be ‘delivered at’ rather than ‘designed with’ community, and be siloed in specific issues or community segments. As a two-year program working with established roles on shared challenges, Ready Communities aims to augment and enhance existing work while building momentum for new initiatives.</p><p>Third, there is a need to take a holistic view and integrate economic development and community development perspectives. There is a body of work related to innovation and entrepreneur ecosystems, commercialising new technologies and creating businesses to build, grow, and scale. And yet without intentional intervention, there is an unspoken inevitable reality of inequality as opportunities are provided for those who already have access to capital. Programs focused on social challenges or marginalised communities can seem to run in parallel to and disconnected from entrepreneur-focused interventions. Ready Communities considers both social impact and economic opportunities through principles of social enterprise.</p><p>Ready Communities is an initiative developed by <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/graceevolve/">Kerry Grace</a> and <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/chadrenando/">Chad Renando</a> out of decades of experience and research and significant projects in place-based development. Insights from these projects inform the Ready Communities’ vision for thriving regional communities. Early support for the Ready Communities initiative is supported by the <a href="https://evolvenetwork.com.au/">Evolve Network</a>, the <a href="https://www.ruraleconomies.org.au/">Rural Economies Centre of Excellence</a> at the <a href="https://www.unisq.edu.au/">University of Southern Queensland</a>, and the <a href="https://www.genglobal.org/australia">Global Entrepreneurship Network Australia</a>.</p><h3>The Ready Communities program</h3><p>The two-year Ready Communities program includes a 10-month engagement and capability-building program, a three-day Social Impact in the Regions conference, and a 12-month alumni support program. The program design is informed by the <a href="https://ssir.org/articles/entry/collective_impact">collective impact framework</a>, which includes establishing a <a href="https://collectiveimpactforum.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/12/Backbone-Starter-Guide.pdf">collaborative backbone structure</a>. Essential to the program is working with and supporting the development of capacity and capability in one or more community organisations that can provide backbone support during and following the program.</p><p>The 10-month engagement includes an initial engagement to identify focus areas, conduct a desktop and in-community mapping of policies and assets, identify and develop three to five focus areas or clusters, facilitate a series of activation events for each cluster, and provide a capacity and capability building stream for practitioners and leaders.</p><p>The three-day Social Impact in the Regions conference culminates conversations and activates outcomes from the 10-month engagement, and builds capability in practitioners and leaders. Delegates include those who support and apply social impact in regions including government, community leaders, researchers, social entrepreneurs, and economic and community development organisations. The format blends skills development and local practical solutions through interactive sessions and hands-on workshops as delegates learn through doing and connecting. Foll</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*ZYj-oteQUdkRx2wS" /></figure><p>Following the conference, leaders, facilitators, and practitioners from outside the region are invited to return to the region to create a 12-month program of engagement and follow up on the program and projects identified through the conference. Delegates are connected to a national network of leaders and alumni from other Ready Communities programs to align and build on work across shared interests and themes.</p><h3>Ready Macleay</h3><p>Ready Macleay is Year One of the Ready Communities program. Kicked off in January 2024, the Ready Macleay initial engagement identified connections and five focus areas to be explored with the community. The Ready Macleay program supports and is delivered alongside and with the established backbone organisation <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/learning-the-macleay-115188298/">Learning the Macleay,</a> which is part of the federal <a href="https://www.dss.gov.au/families-and-children-programs-services/stronger-places-stronger-people">Stronger Places Stronger People program</a>.</p><p>The five focus areas identified include Agriculture Communities, Youth Futures, Central Business District Activation, Creative Industries, and Housing. The focus areas support clusters to focus attention while allowing integration between the five topics and the inclusion of related topics.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*2B-wVGbI1aLDvZmp" /></figure><h3>Agriculture Communities</h3><p>The Agriculture sector represents <a href="https://economy.id.com.au/kempsey/number-of-businesses-by-industry">over a quarter of businesses in the region.</a> Conversations related to agriculture communities include flow-on impacts across retail, tourism, hospitality, shared community assets, employment, and responses to climate impacts and targets. Building on established work in <a href="https://www.kempsey.nsw.gov.au/files/sharedassets/public/docs/departments/commercial-business/ec-dev/agribusiness-industry-plan-2021-2026.pdf">local agribusiness strategies</a> and <a href="https://macleayvalleyfoodbowl.com.au/">local agriculture initiatives</a> and <a href="https://www.nswfarmers.org.au/">networks</a>, topics raised include paddock to plate and getting more local food on local tables, support for farming commercial opportunities including regenerative agriculture, drought readiness, and diversification through tourism, intergenerational farming, youth pathways in agriculture, and support for women in agriculture.</p><h3>Youth Futures</h3><p>The Youth Futures conversations focus on opportunities to support youth across the region and include topics of education, entrepreneurship, workforce and employability, life skills development, and wellbeing. Working with education providers, established youth networks, and local service providers, topics raised include creating effective pathways for young people, increasing employability and connecting the youth workforce to local business, engaging young people in entrepreneurship and social impact, supporting teacher development and school capability and capacity, and strengthening linkages to early-age support and wellbeing services.</p><h3>Central Business District (CBD) Activation</h3><p>The CBD activation stream has developed through walking through the main street to hear perspectives from store owners, retailers, and customers on the health of the town’s main street. Challenges and opportunities are both unique to the region as well as shared by rural communities across Australia. The focus area will include conversations relating to beautifying main street, leveraging and activating multi-use shared spaces, renewal strategies for vacant stores, and investment attraction opportunities.</p><h3>Creative Industries</h3><p>Creative industries play an essential role in the vibrancy, livability, and transformative capacity of a region. Aligned with momentum from <a href="https://yoursay.macleay.nsw.gov.au/our-creative-macleay">local arts and culture plans</a>, conversations related to creative industries include cultural heritage, visual and performing arts, shared spaces, events and festivals, development and application of emerging technologies, and tourism.</p><h3>Housing</h3><p>Housing is a national challenge with <a href="https://www.regionalaustralia.org.au/libraryviewer?ResourceID=111">particular impacts on regional communities</a>. We acknowledge the complexity of the issue with <a href="https://yoursay.macleay.nsw.gov.au/local-housing-strategy">local considerations in Kempsey</a> including housing densities, diversity, choice, location, dwelling types, and affordability. Our conversation focuses on different ways to use living space to alleviate the housing crisis and other alternative approaches.</p><h3>Ready Macleay Community Conversations</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*OptBF-sZoErbTqVk" /></figure><p>The five themes will be explored through a series of community conversations or activations. The first activations are <a href="https://events.humanitix.com/ready-macleay-community-conversations">from 26 February to 1 March</a> and will consider areas of focus in each theme, integration between themes, and general opportunities that might be identified outside of the themes. The conversations will also identify key roles related to the opportunities and what might be realistically able to be developed leading up to the conference in September.</p><p>The support over the ten months will vary based on the initiatives. Common across all initiatives will be regular virtual check-ins and two additional in-community conversations in May and July to bring the community together to share learning and build momentum. The conversations will be supported with capacity-building sessions for local practitioners focusing on core competencies including community facilitation and consultation, event management, and community engagement.</p><h3>Social Impact in the Regions Conference</h3><p>The Ready Macleay <a href="https://socialimpactintheregions.com.au/">Social Impact in the Regions conference</a> will be in Kempsey, NSW from 4 to 6 September. The conference will act as a key event to present outcomes and workshop ideas related to the five cluster areas as well as provide capability-building skills across the field of social impact, social enterprise, and cross-section of economic and community development.</p><p>The conference will provide a novel and unique experience for delegates who will learn skills through interactive panels, presentations, action-based workshops and learning circles, and in-community engagements. The venue will include a circus tent for main events and sessions throughout the town related to each theme. Delegates, presenters, facilitators, sponsors, partners, and the community will interact over the three days to learn and apply knowledge and experience.</p><p>The conference is designed to engage and activate all aspects of the social impact ecosystem, including government, philanthropy, investment, industry, research, retail, service providers, and the general public. The conference is neither the start nor end of the conversations, but a high point between the work leading up to the event and the 12 months of support after the event. Presenters and facilitators will be provided opportunities to return to the region for the 12 months following the conference to continue the engagement and realise further impact.</p><h3>Understanding Ready Communities’ outcomes and impact</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*jopKzE69TrPXK1BE" /></figure><p>The Ready Communities impact model is based on the premise that challenges in rural communities are systemic in nature. These challenges require collective action through connection and collaboration across the system. Communities improve readiness through a regular pattern of identifying and realising opportunities to address these shared challenges. The impact is realised through the connections, capability, and capacity developed through the community identifying opportunities and delivering outcomes of the focus areas, as much as the results of individual initiatives.</p><h3>Outputs</h3><p>The Ready Communities outputs include the individual activities that can be observed, such as visual maps and information, the number of participants, identified priorities and projects, connections, and activated roles and institutions. These outputs are simple to measure and can be observed through the program.</p><h3>Outcomes</h3><p>The expected Ready Communities outcomes are based on five features of place-making identified in the lead-up to the 2024 Global Entrepreneurship Congress (GEC). The GEC engagement process included consultation with over 500 leaders across 30 working groups defined by industry sector (agriculture, mining, health, creative industries, etc.), area of impact (women, youth, First Nations, climate, etc.), and function (government, research, investment, etc.). The insights from the collective conversations identified five outcomes from place-making work.</p><p>The outcomes would be expected to be realised in the first one to two years of the program.</p><p>First, we can expect increased clarity and understanding. Questions that will be answered include: Does the community have a shared understanding and map of roles and actors in each focus area and their accountabilities? Is there an understanding of policies, including alignment and gaps, and the amount and nature of funding opportunities? Is there an appropriate custodian of data and information and is the information accurate, accessible, and relevant? Are there research partners, opportunities for continuous information management, and evaluation frameworks in place?</p><p>Second, we can expect improved connection and connectivity. Questions that will be answered include: What is the nature (quality and frequency) of connections within community across roles, functions, sectors, and community groups? Are there boundary-spanning activities to access networks and capital across and outside the region? Are there regular formal or informal meetups or events for individual focus areas? Is there connection for people with ideas to start and scale their ideas, initiatives, or businesses? Is there connection for research to be put into practice? Is there adequate digital connectivity or a means to access digital connectivity?</p><p>Third, we can expect to build capability and capacity. Questions that will be answered include: Are there programs for building capability in individual leaders? What is the capability of roles and institutions in the region, including government policy-makers, angel investors, industry support, peak bodies, business associations, education institutions such as schools, TAFE, and universities, collaborative bodies and community groups, and service providers? Do these individuals and organisations have capacity, including financially sustainable business models?</p><p>Fourth, we can expect to see evidence of collaboration for purpose. Questions that will be answered include: Is there a shared understanding of the challenges and opportunities in the community? Are people coming together to make progress on shared challenges or opportunities? Is this progress being measured and shared? Are new groups self-forming to address new challenges and opportunities? Are the individuals in these groups representative of the diversity of the community and inclusive of those impacted?</p><p>Fifth, we can expect to see advocacy and promotion. Questions that will be answered include: Is there a voice to advocate for the various groups and communities in the region and for the region overall? Is there a shared narrative of the challenges and opportunities? Are successes being promoted to those impacted and who can influence greater outcomes? Are there constructive and beneficial relationships with media to support telling the stories of outcomes and impact?</p><h3>Impact</h3><p>Impact is assessed against six dimensions of resilience. These dimensions are intentionally broad and not intended to provide a promise that all will be addressed in each community. Rather, they provide a reference point where several areas can be expected to be realised over time based on both outcomes of individual focus areas as well as the implementation of the overall Ready Communities initiative. Assessing against the full list also helps identify areas of unintended consequences where improvements in one area may have an unexpected or detrimental outcome in another area.</p><p>A quick note is needed on resilience, as the term can be misused and even weaponised in a regional context. Resilience is not used to refer to a return to what was or to settle into a new state of equilibrium. For many communities, there is no returning to what used to be and it can seem as though there is constant change or major disruption following disruption. The sentiment can also be used to defer support in light of considering a community ‘resilient’ as highlighted in <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/tv-and-radio/2022/aug/22/katrina-babies-documentary-edward-buckles-new-orleans">stories from those impacted by natural disasters</a>.</p><p>Resilience in the context of the Ready Communities impact framework refers to a state of readiness and adaptability for change:</p><blockquote><em>“The existence, development, and engagement of community resources by community members to thrive in an environment characterized by change, uncertainty, unpredictability, and surprise” (Hightree et al. 2018).</em></blockquote><p>A holistic view of resilience considers impact across six dimensions of resilience. The first dimension is individual resilience. This considers the impact on the individual, including psychological health, wellbeing, and skills.</p><p>The second dimension is social resilience. This considers the structure such as population composition, skills diversity, home ownership, mobility, liveability and the community including community group connectedness, volunteering and civic engagement, trust and norms or reciprocity, place attachment and pride, conflict resolution, and vulnerable group connectedness.</p><p>The third dimension is economic resilience. This includes economic structure such as employment, income equality, age of working population, skills, and job density; economic security such as savings, collective ownership, business mitigation, financial and investment instruments; and economic dynamism such as inward and external investment, business cooperation, entrepreneurial activity and openness, locally owned businesses, public-private partnerships, supply chain effectiveness and efficiency.</p><p>The fourth dimension is institutional resilience relating to the leadership and structures in the community. Considerations in the institutional dimension include leadership and participation such as stability, shared planning and vision, transparency and accountability, and decentralised responsibility and resources; resource management such as skilled personnel, efficient management, and redundant capacity; contingency such as risk reduction and resilience integration, climate impact planning, risk pattern and trend understanding, emergency and mitigation planning, and inclusive risk planning; collaboration such as cross-sector partnerships, inter-agency MOUs, and knowledge transfer; R&amp;D such as innovation and technology updates and research and translation channels; regulation and policy such as policy relevance, quality, and application; and education and training such as education availability and quality across stages, information availability and application, and migration and adaptation incentives.</p><p>The fifth dimension considers environmental resilience, with considerations including improved agriculture productivity and resource management and reduction in negative environmental impacts.</p><p>The sixth dimension relates to infrastructure resilience. While large-scale infrastructure requirements may be outside the scope of many of the initiatives, there may be outcomes related to robustness and redundancy such as provider collaboration, space multi-functionality, and distribution and redundancy; ICT reliability and availability; and land use accessible needs and services.</p><h3>Future plans</h3><p>One of the main questions we get asked is how we select our regions and where we are planning to go next. Year One is in Kempsey, NSW where we are building capacity in the program and the community. We have a short list for Year Two in 2025. We expect to scale to additional regions by years three and four with a ten-year vision for 15 to 18 locations.</p><h3>Join us on the journey</h3><p>Ready Communities is the culmination of decades of experience, trials, and lessons, contributions from amazing leaders, mentors, and colleagues, a passion project and long-term commitment of both co-founders, and the realisation of impact goals for partners and supporters. We are grateful for the support and amazing people and organisations who are on the journey with us and excited about those who will join along the way. We look forward to realising the impact of efficient and effective approaches to place-based transition and transformation across Australia.</p><p>If you are involved in social impact in the regions, then you will want to <a href="https://socialimpactintheregions.com.au/">attend the conference 4 to 6 September</a>. We are in the process of updating our socials so you can follow along on our journey. If you are in the Macleay Valley region, look out for flyers, emails, invitations, and taps on the shoulder to share in the journey. If you are from an organisation that would see value in partnering for impact in any of the five themes, in the Macleay Region, or the overall approach, connect with us for a partnership prospectus.</p><p>Thank you for being a part of the journey. Your feedback and support are always welcome as we work together to build a community of practice for regional impact in Australia.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2aa457701f98" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/ready-communities/ready-communities-and-social-impact-in-the-regions-2024-ready-macleay-in-kempsey-nsw-2aa457701f98">Ready Communities and Social Impact in the Regions 2024: Ready Macleay in Kempsey, NSW</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/ready-communities">Ready Communities</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The next page of the PhD — the examiner feedback is in…]]></title>
            <link>https://chadrenando.medium.com/the-next-page-of-the-phd-the-examiner-feedback-is-in-40b0eb00c440?source=rss-ed20c6660319------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/40b0eb00c440</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Chad Renando]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 28 Apr 2021 21:50:45 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-04-28T21:50:51.693Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*q_5uITzueiwEHhSo.jpg" /></figure><p>The examiner’s feedback is in for my PhD thesis. I figure this is as good of an opportunity as any for an update as my two… I mean three… um, four… OK, five-year journey nears its conclusion.</p><h4>The examination process</h4><p>For those not familiar with the process, PhDs are not so much ‘graded’ as they are reviewed by a number of external examiners who then provide feedback and recommendations for the student to pass or amend their thesis. The review is ‘blind’ in that the PhD candidate does not know the reviewers and the reviewers do not know the candidate. Some schools have an additional session to ‘defend’ the thesis in front of a panel of experts, but this was not the case in my situation.</p><p>By the time the thesis gets to the examiner, it has gone through multiple reviews with your supervisors and you have spent countless hours writing and rewriting between 80,000 to 150,000 words. Core chapters become the appendix, later relegated to a past revision as you ‘<a href="https://www.publicationcoach.com/why-you-must-murder-your-darlings/">murder your darlings</a>’ — remove sections that you love but do not support the main premise of your research. Some candidates publish in journals as part of the process to get additional feedback along the way. I recommend this approach based on my experience of having not published. That said, I was not clear on my position until close to the very end and am only now feel I am in a position to publish.</p><p>This explanation is to set the stage for my growing anticipation from the time I last posted about my PhD in October 2020, submitted my thesis for review in December, and then receiving the examiners’ feedback last week. I had all intentions of maintaining a more public diary of the process. For most of the past several months, however, there would have been little in the way of a practical update.</p><p>To recap those just tuning in, the journey has included:</p><ul><li><a href="https://sidewaysthoughts.com/blog/2016/07/the-path-to-a-phd-topic-community-resiliency-and-regional-innovation-hubs/">the development of the question</a>,</li><li><a href="https://sidewaysthoughts.com/blog/2018/09/australian-tour-of-innovation-ecosystems-2018-2019/">the launch of the research tour</a>,</li><li><a href="https://sidewaysthoughts.com/blog/2018/11/innovation-tour-reflections-four-weeks-in-with-video/">an update four weeks into the tour</a>,</li><li><a href="https://sidewaysthoughts.com/blog/2018/12/reflections-from-a-tour-of-regional-queensland-innovation-ecosystems/">reflections after the tour</a>,</li><li><a href="https://sidewaysthoughts.com/blog/2019/09/network-analysis-of-an-entrepreneur-ecosystem-phd-in-progress/">thoughts as I analysed the research data</a>, and</li><li><a href="https://sidewaysthoughts.com/blog/2020/10/phd-reflections-what-worked-what-i-would-do-differently/">reflections as I wrapped up the main thesis</a>.</li></ul><p>There is likely one more post after this in the series once I graduate. I share my results here for transparency, to update any who might still be following along, and for others who might learn for their own candidacy journey.</p><h3>The feedback</h3><h4>A ‘hefty’ thesis</h4><p>I first pitched my PhD idea as a driving tour around Australia visiting every innovation ecosystem. This was overly ambitious to the point of unrealistic and I was thankfully encouraged to limit the scope to Queensland. That said, I am grateful to have visited a large number of regions in each state and territory over the past five years.</p><p>Both examiners commented on the scope and scale of the theses, which reflects my own initial thoughts that a PhD was reflective of a life’s work. And yet as I neared the end of my journey, my supervisors drummed it into me that a PhD is only the beginning of a longer trek into continuous personal, professional, and academic discovery.</p><p>My thesis is an interrogation into each aspect of three constructs — uncovering everything I could know on the nature of the <strong>innovation ecosystem</strong>, what we know about <strong>innovation hubs</strong>, and what is meant by <strong>community resilience</strong>. The more I learned, the more nuance I discovered. Each line of questioning would uncover entire new lines of reasoning or bodies of research, like pulling a thread on a never-ending tapestry of collected knowledge. Even in my examiner’s feedback, they identified entire lines of reasoning and foundational authors I had not come across.</p><p>The thesis was a constant tension between putting in too much and needing each link in what I believe to be an important causal chain between innovation activity and community impact. I wavered between the two perspectives, but appreciate the examiners’ feedback as validation that I landed at an acceptable point somewhere in the middle.</p><p><strong>Examiner 1: </strong><em>This is an impressively ambitious thesis that seeks to answer questions on the relationships between innovation hubs, innovation ecosystems and community resilience. These are timely questions given the recent theoretical turns towards the notion of ecosystems in the entrepreneurship and innovation literature and enthusiasm to fund interventions in these ecosystems by policy makers. In exploring these themes, the thesis marshals an impressive amount of data, comprised of 147 interviews across 16 regions of QLD.</em></p><p><strong>Examiner 2: </strong><em>This thesis is unusual, unusually good, in its ambition, the amount of effort and attention-to-detail in data collection and analysis, and its sheer ‘size’…not in pages, but in scholarly heft. There are a huge amount of ‘chunks’ of knowledge, either organized in new ways (the work on typologies here is ‘dull’ work but extremely helpful), presented in new ways, or genuinely new in and of themselves, far in advance of most modern PhD theses. So it’s clear even from a cursory reading that this thesis is absolutely worthy of a doctoral award.</em></p><p><em>Overall, superb work here, and indicative of a researcher who was prepared to go the extra (many) miles. The innovation mapping process is of sufficient detail and rigour to be a worthwhile academic output in its own right, and it is worth saying that this thesis, in terms of ‘heft’ is more than the usual ‘size’ of thesis, particularly in the 21st century. This thesis represents an example that could have been drawn from the 1980s when theses were expected to offer a substantial advance on knowledge. The thesis also offers something of a ‘manual’ for future researchers in the field, and I hope the thesis is rapidly published in forms that make it highly accessible to scholars.</em></p><h4>The theoretical position</h4><p>I have come to refer to my theoretical position as my theory ‘stack’. This is inspired by my software agency background where software is build on a ‘technology stack’ of various database, presentation, and processing platforms. For my thesis, my ‘stack’ integrated theory and method, using systems theory, actor network theory, critical realism, appreciative inquiry, and social network analysis.</p><p>Each of these lines of reasoning and methods is appropriate for situations of uncertainty and disruption, but there was limited documentation I came across on the integration of all of these for research. I struggled early with structured models of ecosystem maps that did not seem to match reality. I am grateful to a mentor early on who shared actor network theory with me that legitimised an approach that treated everyone and everything as a unique actor, while critical realism aligned with my postmodern leanings and allowed for multiple, equal realities of what the data indicated, what could be observed, and people’s lived experiences.</p><p>As noted by the examiners, this will take further refinement and needs to be tested against current approaches by leaders in the field.</p><p><strong>Examiner 2: </strong><em>The conceptual model doesn’t make the mistake of packing too much in, or piling on the complexity that is (genuinely) present in the contexts it describes. It takes the key elements and puts them together in a logical way that will be quite testable and usable by scholars in future.</em></p><p><strong>Examiner 1:</strong> <em>First, the work is theoretically very ambitious in its attempt to integrate a number of theoretical lineages within a broader systems framework. To some extent this is welcome (if brave) because the notion of an ecosystem when applied to social phenomena does invite some theoretical complexity in engaging with it. So while I enjoyed some of the conceptual work displayed in trying to integrate systems theory, critical realism, actor network theory, appreciative inquiry (and even briefly role theory), this approach may well raise some eyebrows (ie cause problems) among reviewers of top journals.</em></p><p><em>Introducing a novel theoretical framework while also trying to present original empirical work, sustain an argument that warrants a significant conceptual contribution to a targeted area of theory is challenging indeed. In the context of the thesis, it meant significant space was devoted to explaining how these frameworks fit together. With hindsight, a straighter line could have been drawn between your conceptual framework, your empirical material and the novel insights of your findings. After reading the thesis closely, it was not clear why adopting the approaches outlined by leading ecosystems researchers such as Ben Spigel and Erik Stam would have led to inferior or less significant insights.</em></p><h4>Are we explaining what or why? And can we establish cause?</h4><p>The core of my thesis is in identifying what, if any, contribution the innovation ecosystem, and specifically the innovation hub, has on indicators of community resilience. I take on board the feedback about the challenges with inferring cause from the interviews as well as not identifying underlying causes. In my defence, I reflect on the personal and national context in which I started my research.</p><p>I began my PhD when I was managing what was possibly the first dedicated innovation hub in Australia that was fully owned and operated by a local government council. Over 70 additional innovation hubs would be created in Australia over the course of my research. This is more than double the number that started in the five years prior to my research. The ecosystem was emerging and there were many unanswered questions both for me personally as well as for the broader community.</p><p>My main question was whether an innovation hub had a contribution towards community resilience, whether that contribution was enabling or inhibiting, and what was the nature of that contribution. I ended up identifying over 60 roles in the ecosystem that contributed to over 80 community resilience indicators through over 120 enabling and inhibiting contributing factors. Further, the emphasis on the innovation hub resulted in correlating 21 functions of the innovation hub to contributing factors.</p><p>As soon as you see the information presented, the next logical question is “but why?” In what situations does the innovation hub have an influence? Does the hub business model matter? What about other roles in the ecosystem? And what is the influence of culture and funding?</p><p>These are all important questions for follow-up research now that a baseline foundation has been established. The interview data also needs correlation with additional data sources and interviews in additional regions. I take the examiners’ feedback on board and look forward to expanding the model. As one examiner aptly noted: “<em>I think the next steps here is to work out a more targeted contribution for the insights contained in this literature — how do the insights developed through your empirical work either challenge or add something new to the core ideas outlined across this work?</em>”</p><p><strong>Examiner 2:</strong> <em>I would say, however, that there is one important limitation missing here. Apart from the ‘natural’ limitations (and strengths) of a qualitative approach, there is no mention here of the cross-sectional nature of the study. Any attempt by the candidate (and there are a number of them) to infer causality are made on poor foundations. The approach relies on participant recollection and perception, with all the sense-making flaws of complex reality, and the systematic biases (e.g. in recall) that that approach ‘naturally’ has. There are times when the candidate brushes over this aspect of his approach and uses language that suggests causation has been more or less established.</em></p><p><strong>Examiner 1: </strong><em>At times, such presentations run the risk of seeming to argue that ‘everything is related to everything else’, and that each actor/role can either be enabling or inhibiting depending on context and other factors. This is, to be fair, one of the more vexing challenges of examining complex social phenomena (I believe there’s an old joke about the so called ‘first law of sociology: sometimes they do, sometimes they don’t). However, I am inclined to agree with Stam’s (2015) ‘sympathetic critique’ of ecosystem approaches: (and note that you cite this paper in your thesis): “the approach as yet only provides a long laundry lists of relevant factors without a clear reasoning of cause and effect. These factors do provide some focus, but they offer no consistent explanation of their coherence or their interdependent effects on entrepreneurship” (Stam, 2015: 1764).</em></p><p><em>In other words, we already know that the various ‘factors and actors’ that comprise ecosystems can be related to each other in all sorts of different configurations and nonlinear ways, but I believe to really make an important contribution in this field requires presenting plausible accounts of relations of strength or significance between some factors/actors over others, or a richer account of a particular context that can help illuminate why this specific innovation hub or ecosystem has this particular relationship with community resilience (eg as a case study or ethnography that adequately paints the historical/cultural/social/economic factors of a particular place). For all its theoretical breadth and empirical scope, the thesis often presents as somewhere in between these two poles– too abstracted to offer a rich sense of a particular hub or place (eg a multi-year case study), and yet too cognisant of local contingencies to advance generalisable claims about the relations between key variables that might hold across contexts.</em></p><h4>Next steps — publications, policy, and practical</h4><p>I am soon to be in that state of purgatory that some PhD candidates find themselves between thesis completion and journal publication. I know I am sitting on a large body of work with several publications that will naturally emerge. Both examiners commented on the need to publish, which add a prompt for me to action.</p><p>The publication process will also come with refinement of the application for policy makers and practitioners. Turning the body of work into actionable chunks will be part of the next process. It will also emerge naturally as I test the results on industry peers who work in the field.</p><p><strong>Examiner 1:</strong> <em>If you haven’t already begun this process, I would encourage you to work some of the key insights into publications for some of the leading scholarly journals that discuss these questions, such as Small Business Economics, Technovation, Research Policy, Strategic Entrepreneurship. Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice. Journal of Business Venturing. Technological Forecasting and Social Change. Journal of Business Research.</em></p><p><strong>Examiner 2: </strong><em>Indeed it is a surprise and something of a disappointment to note that during the production of the thesis, there is no evidence that the candidate published from his thesis. It’s not a major issue, but hopefully this is addressed shortly.</em></p><p>The journal writing process is new to me and has challenged my previous habits of regularly sharing through blog posts and social media. I struggle with the balance of crafting knowledge into a format for a peer-reviewed journal and releasing information for immediate feedback and value. I also feel the tension between writing up the results and being in the field applying the knowledge. This will be my next journey over the course of the next 12 months, to develop the pipeline of papers, get the thesis into a publishable book format, and apply the lessons in community.</p><p>I have had several people who are keen to read the results, and I appreciate their interest. I look forward to sharing more broadly as the results are published.</p><h3>Thank you and give back</h3><p>The examiners’ feedback applies to a large extent to my supervisors and the community who contributed to the work through their interviews, passion, honesty, and hospitality. I am grateful for their patience as I get to this stage and look forward to sharing more throughout the year.</p><p>That gratitude translates to giving back and collaboration with others on the journey. A PhD is a challenging endeavour. I would not be here if not for the help of those who have gone before me. If you are somewhere on the journey and are studying in a related field, I am always happy to share whatever might add value to your path.</p><p>Thank you for reading this far and being a part of the journey. I look forward to learning, sharing, and contributing with you where we might work together on impact.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=40b0eb00c440" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A map of the Australian Indigenous entrepreneur support ecosystem]]></title>
            <link>https://chadrenando.medium.com/a-map-of-the-australian-indigenous-entrepreneur-support-ecosystem-6353e416ffaa?source=rss-ed20c6660319------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6353e416ffaa</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ecosystem-mapping]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[indigenous-entrepreneurs]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[innovation-ecosystem]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Chad Renando]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 28 Jan 2021 03:41:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-01-28T03:48:31.058Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*BDs9iYU0e4sG1zBo.png" /></figure><blockquote>“For years we have walked on a one-way street to learn the white people’s way. We ask you to bring your knowledge and wisdom, but also to learn and understand how we live and listen to what the needs are.”</blockquote><blockquote>- Dr Miriam-Rose Ungunmerr Baumann AM <a href="https://twitter.com/sammostyn/status/1353636584718020608">on receipt of the 2021 Senior Australian of The Year</a></blockquote><p>The Australian entrepreneur ecosystem that focuses on Indigenous entrepreneurs provides an exciting opportunity to practically apply Dr Miriam-Rose Ungunmerr Baumann’s request to develop a shared knowledge transfer and understanding of needs and desires.</p><p>Entrepreneurship has the potential to be a great equaliser, but only if it is intentionally directed to all aspects of the community. This map is one small step in developing a shared understanding of the growing ecosystem in Australia that supports Indigenous entrepreneurs. The map is not intended to be definitive but acts as the start of a conversation, an opportunity to raise awareness of those doing amazing work, inspire others to take up the call, and establish new connections and networks.</p><p>I would also like to acknowledge the Yagara people on whose land I write this post.</p><h4>Caveats</h4><h4>1. History and my role</h4><p>I have been mapping the Australian innovation ecosystem at <a href="https://your.startupstatus.co/">Startup Status</a> since around 2016. Maps have been produced for focus areas such as <a href="https://sidewaysthoughts.com/blog/2019/02/the-australian-creative-industry-innovation-ecosystem-a-sample-and-snapshot/">creative industries</a>, <a href="https://sidewaysthoughts.com/blog/2020/03/the-ecosystem-of-support-for-female-entrepreneurs-in-australia-2020-edition/">female entrepreneurship</a>, <a href="https://sidewaysthoughts.com/blog/2020/01/the-australian-innovation-ecosystem-focused-on-climate-renewable-energy-and-circular-economy/">environmental sustainability and climate change</a>, roles such as <a href="https://sidewaysthoughts.com/blog/2020/06/australian-university-incubators-reflections-on-the-closure-of-qut-creative-enterprise-australia/">university accelerators</a>, and <a href="https://sidewaysthoughts.com/blog/2018/07/a-map-of-the-queensland-innovation-ecosystem/">region-specific analysis such as Queensland</a>. The purpose of publishing is to share what might be known, test assumptions, and ask for input into what is not known.</p><p>My role is as a researcher and cartographer, observing what is in place and sharing in order to discover and co-create through dialogue. I have had many conversations over the years with those actively participating in this map, enough to know I am by no means an expert. The map is based on my reflection and observation but has not been validated by those in the ecosystem. That is in part the purpose of this post.</p><p>I am not telling what it looks like as much as providing one interpretation to inspire dialogue. Similar to other maps I have done for female entrepreneurs, creative industries, or climate change proponents, I seek to understand and learn so we can collectively develop shared wisdom together.</p><p>I also pay respect to others who may be performing similar work including <a href="https://sailist.co/">sailist</a>, <a href="https://www.decodesystem.com/">decodesystems</a>, <a href="https://www.ramenlife.co/">ramenlife </a>/ <a href="https://qihub.com.au/">qihub</a> / <a href="https://www.techsydney.com.au/">techsydney</a>, <a href="https://startupgalaxy.com.au/">startup galaxy</a>, and <a href="https://findingstartups.launchvic.org/">LaunchVic</a> / Dealroom. Additional perspectives help our collective understanding. My focus is specifically on the system by which entrepreneurs are supported, how different roles interact, and the nature of the ecosystem over time. The federal government also recently published the results of their two-year report <a href="https://www.industry.gov.au/publications/supporting-indigenous-business-project">Supporting Indigenous Business Project</a> which provides good insights.</p><h4><strong>2. Scope and boundaries — what’s in and what’s out</strong></h4><p>The Indigenous entrepreneur ecosystem is a subset of the overall innovation ecosystem. For the purpose of this project, the scope or boundary of the Indigenous entrepreneur ecosystem is defined as:</p><blockquote><em>Organisations that have programs and services that explicitly and exclusively support innovation entrepreneurship and startup activity for Indigenous people in Australian</em>.</blockquote><p>The edges of this boundary are admittedly blurry. <strong>Indigenous entrepreneurs are supported by many other programs not in the map</strong>, such as the youth-based programs Young Change Agents or the Australian Centre for Entrepreneurship. Other programs in the wider Australian innovation ecosystem may have a social impact focus like the Impact Boom or Impact Academy accelerators that are aligned with outcomes from Indigenous entrepreneurs.</p><p><strong>Indigenous ownership of the space or program is also not a factor </strong>— only evidence of programs. Programs and spaces may be run by an Indigenous manager but may not have specific Indigenous programming. This is similar to the female ecosystem map, where a coworking space managed by a female will not be included but a female-focused school program for girls that is run by a male will be.</p><p><strong>There will be many feeder programs supporting Indigenous communities that are not listed on the map</strong>. The ecosystem of Indigenous support is extensive, with a number of government and community groups support health and community needs. The map aims to pick up at the boundary of specific entrepreneur programs and spaces.</p><p><strong>Entrepreneurship is broad and includes any engagement with starting a business.</strong> This includes street cafes, tourism businesses, and tech startups. It generally excludes support for established businesses or corporates, but this line is also not clear as many new ideas come from existing businesses. This is also why the map extends to traditional business support such as chambers of commerce.</p><p>The reason for the exclusive focus is similar to the reasons for exclusivity in programs for youth, females, or older entrepreneurs. Programs designed for everyone can have an inherent bias to the dominant population through language, program design, and culture. Targeted programs and agencies engage entrepreneurs who may otherwise feel the innovation ecosystem is not for them.</p><h4>3. Geographic representation</h4><p>Programs and spaces are associated with the region that is serviced. The COVID-19 pandemic has taken many programs virtual, so they are attributed to Australia. Others apply across the state. There are likely many local programs that have been missed as a result of time to drill into specific regions.</p><h4>4. Not comprehensive — feedback is welcome</h4><p>The map is indicative and based on personal knowledge and following online data trails. There are most certainly missing actors on the map. There may also be roles that may be positioned in different categories. This is a start and intended as a conversation starter. Feedback and conversation are welcome.</p><h4>5. A note on design</h4><p>I am not a designer and am usually slightly embarrassed by maps I put out, but I have made <a href="https://sidewaysthoughts.com/blog/2017/08/mapping-innovation-ecosystems/">a study of different ways that people represent ecosystem maps</a> to somewhat align with and learn from others. Graphical maps are engaging, albeit challenging to maintain as new actors are added and removed. Usually, they are just logos on a white background. I felt something more topical might work for this map.</p><p>There are many parallels to the natural network of ecosystems and the inherent design of Indigenous art. The nodes and networks of an entrepreneur ecosystem fit naturally over the backdrop of Indigenous networked design. For the design of this map, I used a background of traditional Indigenous art from Shutterstock for copyright reason, but it will be good to work with an Indigenous artist for a future version. I did not find any opportunities for shared digital rights purchases outside of stock photo sites. As a point of gratitude, <a href="https://www.aboriginal-art-australia.com/artworks/gracie-morton-pwerle-mountain-devil-lizard-dreaming-gm45/">I purchased a piece by Gracie Morton Pwerle from Aboriginal Art Australia</a> that would have also made a great backdrop.</p><h4>The map</h4><p>The map below is at a point in time of this post. Reflecting on the experience from past posts, there may be a series of updates a week or two after publishing. Apart from that, it is likely we will audit and review on an annual basis similar to other segments of the ecosystem.</p><p>You can find an up to date version filtered for Indigenous support at <a href="https://your.startupstatus.co/map/start-ups-in-australia-#ALL#ALL#0#326,421#0#Yes">your.startupstatus.co</a>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*fD6wgXgblasSO_j2.png" /></figure><p>The discussion below provides a brief overview of each category. View <a href="https://your.startupstatus.co/map/start-ups-in-australia-#ALL#ALL#0#326,421#0#Yes">the live map</a> for direct links to each program.</p><h4>Accelerators / incubator programs</h4><p>Accelerator and incubator programs provide support within a set time for a cohort and may include funding or other financial benefits. Accelerators specific to Indigenous entrepreneurs include Accelerate with IBA, Circulanation’s female-focused Ignite program, Barayamal, the Melbourne Global Innovation Program, and the Trade Routes Indigenous Global Growth Program delivered in collaboration with the RMIT Activator program.</p><h4>Connection and virtual hubs</h4><p>Connection and virtual hubs often act as a backbone structure to the ecosystem. An example in Australia focused on Indigenous entrepreneurs is Generation One based out of the Minderoo Foundation.</p><h4>Innovation hub</h4><p>Innovation hubs usually provide some form of coworking as well as dedicated programming for entrepreneur support. Many innovation hubs would support Indigenous entrepreneurs. Hubs in this list have a dominance of programs and support for Indigenous entrepreneurs integrated across their portfolio. Two examples in Australia include Desert Knowledge Australia in Northern Territories and the Aboriginal Entrepreneur Hub (AEH) located in the Lot-Fourteen precinct in Adelaide, South Australia.</p><p><strong>Coworking space</strong></p><p>Coworking spaces provide short-term office space. Coworking that is targeted to specific groups provides access for people who otherwise may not initially engage with share working conditions. Once coworking space has been identified in Sydney in the NCIE Enterprise Hub.</p><h4>School entrepreneur / STEM program</h4><p>School programs include those focused on entrepreneurship and those focused on STEM, with some programs combining each to use technology to provide entrepreneurial opportunities. Four programs in Australia focused specifically on Indigenous students include CodorDojo First nations, CSIRO’s Indigenous STEM Education Project and Young Indigenous Women’s STEM Academy, and Indigital Schools supported by Microsoft and Telstra Purple.</p><h4>Education and Support</h4><p>Education and support programs provide information, mentorship, and advise. These are often not cohort-based, do not always require a business idea. The differentiation from accelerators or incubators is not always clean and some program-based approaches can consider themselves as accelerators. Examples in Australia include Circularnation, Indigenous Business Australia, specific divisions within PwC and KPMG, the Northern Territory government’s Aboriginal Business Development Program, Advance Queensland’s One Business program delivered through TAFE, LaucnhVic supported Ngarrimili, and Dream Spark now delivered out of Minderoo in Western Australia.</p><h4>Hackathon programs</h4><p>Hackathon programs on the list are recurring over the years. Baramoral developed the Give Backathon in 2017 and has a focus on Indigenous businesses.</p><h4>Investment</h4><p>Investment in the list includes programs such as angel investment groups, venture capital, or other funds with Indigenous entrepreneurs as part of their mandate. Indigenous Business Australia provides investment support and First Australians Capital is dedicated to Indigenous projects.</p><h4>Media, tools, and advocacy</h4><p>Media, tools, and advocacy is a broad category of platforms and systems to support awareness and promotion. For indigenous businesses in Australia, these are all directories with an emphasis on a region or type of media. Examples include Buying Black, Indigenousx, and Supply Nation at the national level, Queensland’s Black Business Finder, the Victorian Aboriginal business directory, and The Aboriginal Business Directory WA.</p><h4>Research</h4><p>There are many research groups focused on Indigenous studies and outcomes and slightly relaxes the focus on the entrepreneurial pathway to accommodate a broader innovation perspective. Examples in ACT include the National Centre for Indigenous Genomics (NCIG) and ANU’s Australian Centre for Indigenous History, Centre for Aboriginal Economic Policy Research, National Centre for Indigenous Studies, and School of Culture, History and Language. Two Collaborative Research Centres (CRCs) to note include the CRC — Developing Northern Australia in Darwin, Broome, and Townsville, and the CRC — The Lowitja Institute in Melbourne. Queensland examples include CQU’s Centre for Indigenous Health Equity Research (CIHER) and Centre for Tourism and Regional Opportunities (CTRO) and USQ’s Centre for Heritage and Culture.</p><h4>Events / Pitch / Award programs</h4><p>Major events, pitch, and award programs enhance networks and profile exemplars of entrepreneurship. There are other annual forums and events that need to be added to this list. Examples include the Dream Summit managed out of WA by the Minderoo Foundation, and Indiginous Business Month and the National IDX Awards.</p><h4>Chamber of Commerce</h4><p>Chambers of Commerce provide a central voice for advocacy and coordination. The Australian Indigenous Chamber of Commerce operates at the national level with other state-based chambers in Tasmania, South-east Queensland, New South Wales, and Kinaway in Victoria.</p><h4>Industry groups</h4><p>Industry groups are typically member-based associations for advocacy. However, the Queensland government-established Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Business and Innovation Reference Group is included in this list.</p><h4>Federal government</h4><p>There are a number of government programs supporting Indigenous entrepreneurs across local, state, and federal levels. The Office of the Registrar of Indigenous Corporations and the Indiginous Land and Sea Corporation are listed in the map as a starting point.</p><h4>Other networking and support groups</h4><p>Other networking and support groups include all other communities often found in Meetup groups or other non-Chamber business communities. Examples include Baramoral-backed First Nations Business Yarns, the Cairns Regional Indigenous Business Network, Black Coffee, and the Townsville FRegional Indigenous Business network.</p><h4>Your feedback</h4><p>As stated throughout this post, feedback and comments are welcome:</p><ul><li>If you are running programs or spaces on this list, I am keen to hear your thoughts.</li><li>If you feel you should be on the list or know someone who is missing, please reach out.</li><li>If you would like to have further conversations about what all this means for the overall entrepreneur ecosystem in Australia, let’s chat.</li><li>If you are in another country and have insights about entrepreneur support for indigenous in your region, please share.</li></ul><p>You can connect with me on LinkedIn, as well as through my roles as:</p><ul><li>Research Fellow (Innovation Ecosystems) with the <a href="https://www.ruraleconomies.org.au/">Rural Economies Centre of Excellence</a>,</li><li>Research Fellow with QUT’s <a href="https://research.qut.edu.au/ace/">Australian Centre of Entrepreneurship Research</a>,</li><li>Director of the not for profit <a href="https://startupstatus.co/">Startup Status</a>, and</li><li>Managing Director — <a href="https://www.genglobal.org/australia">Australia for the Global Entrepreneurship Network</a>.</li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6353e416ffaa" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[New Year’s silence: 6 days and 60 hours of meditation using Muse]]></title>
            <link>https://chadrenando.medium.com/new-years-silence-6-days-and-60-hours-of-meditation-using-muse-f65f03964688?source=rss-ed20c6660319------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f65f03964688</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Chad Renando]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 08 Jan 2021 04:27:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-01-19T04:30:21.281Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/512/0*fLJYP3ic0mC9lTLg.jpg" /></figure><p>First, a confession: this post started as “<em>Insights from a self-managed 10-day Vipassana silent meditation retreat</em>”. Below I share the background, capture my reflections, identify shifts in perspective, and consider insights for the year forward.</p><p>I share so others who may be in a similar situation may take value. I also share so that those who have been on a similar journey might compare and share their insights.</p><h3>A self-managed retreat</h3><p>I had heard about 10-day Vipassana retreats in passing from friends and colleagues.</p><blockquote>Before 2020, the idea of spending 10 days in silent focus sounded interesting. Towards the end of 2020, it seemed a necessity.</blockquote><p>Around October, I started looking into the course with greater intention. There are a few locations that provide the full 10-day program, with the closest being a couple of hours away from me on <a href="http://www.rasmi.dhamma.org/">Queensland’s Sunshine Coast</a>. The schedule showed a course starting on 26 December. I figured that the end of year period would be a good time for a pause. Apparently, so did several other people.</p><p>The day the applications opened in November found me hitting refresh on the website every 30-seconds like I was buying tickets to Coachella. At 1:03, the “Apply” button became available and I completed the online form. By 1:15, all spaces were filled and applications were closed. I received an email a couple weeks later that I was on the waiting list.</p><p>So with no other options for a structured 10-day program and no other apparent 10-day windows in my 2021 schedule, I explored how I might be able to do a 10-day meditation course on my own. The ten days are completely silent with no interaction. The daily instructions are pre-recorded and interaction with the instructors is optional if you have questions. In hearing from others who had completed the course, the instructors usually point you back to continuing the practice rather than offering a solution. I figured if it is pre-recorded and no contact, why not try it on my own?</p><p>I searched Airbnb for a suitable location. I googled “Vipassana coaches” to find people I could speak with to<a href="https://mindfulnessworksaustralia.com.au/meet-the-trainers/"> better understand the process</a>. I read a multitude of blog posts by others who had been on a course. I spoke with friends who had completed the course.</p><p>As I planned out my experience, I noted that a self-managed course might have unique outcomes while also missing out on benefits. In my conversations with coaches and past participants, I asked what I might do to compensate for what I might miss from the regular course. It was recommended I be mindful while preparing food and keep the preparation simple, as I would not have the benefit of someone preparing it for me. Another person mentioned having an instructor on call through the course. For accountability, I planned to use the Muse headband to track my progress. I would, however, miss out on the communal experience of sharing with others at the end of the program, not experience the temptation of interacting with others, and not have the watchful eye of the instructors keeping me on track.</p><blockquote>At the end of my review, I did not find anything that pointed to it being unhelpful, much less a negative experience or waste of time.</blockquote><p>With support and insights from friends, colleagues, and coaches, I put the plan in motion.</p><h3>The path to a 10-day</h3><p>Subjecting yourself to 10-days of self-isolation in the midst of a pandemic may sound redundant. I did not head into the decision lightly, although I admit to questioning my choice a few days before I left. Ten days is a long time when considering what else can be done, such as spending time with family and friends, completing reports, working on research papers, developing new products and programs, or binging any number of video streaming services. I also felt somewhat selfish and entitled taking ten days out for myself especially at the end of the year.</p><p>I reminded myself that my attachment to the size and magnitude of the to-do list was one of the reasons I felt the need for the ten days. Gaining focus would help everyone in the long run.</p><p>The end of 2020 came as a transition for me. I submitted my PhD thesis even as work in other areas of my life increased. Along with the thesis, I had developed an online community of over 1,000 leaders in Australian innovation and entrepreneurship, contributed to a number of mapping and measurement projects, taken Research Fellow positions with two universities, facilitated and spoke at a number of events including the G20 Roundtable on Entrepreneurship, coached community leaders as we developed new collaborative approaches for economic and community development, and travelled in regions continuing and applying my research.</p><p>And yet as more opportunities emerged, my productivity declined. I became distracted and unfocused.</p><blockquote>Everything felt like walking, talking, and typing through molasses.</blockquote><p>This is particularly confronting in the field of innovation and entrepreneurship where the twitter-elite manage to “crush their goals” at “100 per cent” to solve the world’s greatest challenges while maintaining work-life balance. The sector is built on a premise of learning from failure, although lessons are usually provided as poignant anecdotes by those on the other side of success.</p><p>I became increasingly concerned watching my attention span shrink as my task list grew. At 48, I reminded myself that I had over the years grown companies and communities. Pull my string and I utter Buzz Lightyear Entrepreneur phrases like “<em>Extra-ordinary outcomes require extra-ordinary effort</em>”, “<em>When you do what you love it is never work</em>”, and “<em>Past success predicts future outcomes</em>”. Perhaps it was the wear and tear of 2020, the culmination of personal and professional changes, or some shift in a mental model. My mojo was missing-in-action.</p><p>There are certainly a number of prescriptions available for this malaise. I knew enough to have “physician, heal thyself” included in my personal narrative. Indeed, I had consumed, prescribed, and delivered many options, including programs, productivity hacks, books, seminars, fitness regimes, professional support services, and spending days on the beach scrolling Instagram motivational memes. Each works to varying degrees.</p><blockquote>As a centuries-old approach with proven psychological underpinnings, meditation is a top option for long-term mental performance.</blockquote><p>My exposure to mindfulness and meditation goes back a few years. Some examples include: a Master of Applied Psychology which includes coaching, mindfulness, meditation, and psychology; formal training frameworks as a leadership and development consultant; a six-month internship with the Enneagram personality framework with half-hour daily meditation and 4-hour stints on weekend retreats; facilitating guided meditations in one-on-one individual coaching sessions and group facilitation workshops, and integrating frameworks of Cognitive Behaviour Therapy (CBT) and Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT) into my personal and coaching practices.</p><p>All that to say while I have enough exposure to be familiar with the practice of meditation, I do not consider myself an expert by any means. I went into this new process as a learner.</p><h3>Views on Meditation and the Vipassana program</h3><p>I approach meditation largely from a psychological perspective. I acknowledge that many people integrate a spiritual element as well. The Vipassana program is not contrary to any religion or spiritual belief system but asks that the practice not be mixed with any other system for the ten days. This is to avoid giving the mind an “easy out” by focusing on an external concept of a deity or scripture, creating a replacement with a new object of craving.</p><p>From a psychological perspective, the mind behaves in predictable ways according to evolutionary fight-or-flight responses. On autopilot, the mind clings to pleasure and avoids pain under the guise of our self-interest.</p><blockquote>Meditation trains the mind to focus on a point in time, countering an automatic reaction.</blockquote><p>A neutral point of focus is the breath. The breath is without judgement, always with us, common to everyone, and less likely to be open to interpretation and ego. By training the mind to focus on the breath consistently during meditation, you are less likely to unconsciously react when something unexpected happens when you are not meditating.</p><p>The 10-day Vipassana program walks participants through the process of first focusing on the breath over the first few days, then expanding the focus to different parts of the body from head to toe. The program is deceptive in its simplicity.</p><p>Our lives can be filled with constantly learning new things. Multitasking is celebrated. Audiobooks and YouTube videos are played at double speed. Micro-credentials allow us to learn five things at once. The world is moving to a Matrix-like input jack in the back of our head where we plug in and learn Kung-Fu in a matter of seconds.</p><blockquote>Focusing on one thing, particularly something as simple as the breath, has become counter-cultural.</blockquote><p>An underlying premise of the Vipassana program is that the only way we can really learn is through experience. We do not learn the benefits of meditation by reading a book or blog or by listening to a speaker. We learn by meditating. And meditating. And meditating some more. We cannot experience overcoming the suffering of tedium, a racing mind, and physical discomfort if we do not suffer these things and work through them. The Vipassana program is learning for ten hours a day across ten days.</p><p>The learning process involves experiencing the sensation, observing our reaction, adjusting, continuing, and repeating. It is a marathon of one step, repeated over an over to an indeterminant end point. The future and the past become irrelevant in a focus on the present state of the current breath. We learn through the culmination of observing our response to countless breaths.</p><h3>The Muse mind-sensing headband</h3><figure><img alt="Muse headband" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*gk2sM7mAxgPaDR9_.jpg" /></figure><p>One of the aspects of doing a self-managed program is that I would be able to use the Muse meditation headband. This would understandably not be allowed in a regular course. My aim in using the headband was to provide some level of accountability, as well as a point of curiosity.</p><p>The <a href="https://choosemuse.com/">Muse headband</a> senses brain patterns. When meditating, it records whether you are in an active, neutral, or calm mental state, along with other aspects of your physiology. It also has features like increasing or decreasing background noise depending on your state, introducing the sounds of birds as a feedback mechanism during a calm state, and pre-recorded guided meditations. I had the sounds turned off for this experiment but have used them in the past.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/512/0*WMbTz_iJug5nrT6f.jpg" /></figure><p>I have been using the Muse headband on and off since around 2016. I used it more when I first got the device, prompted in part by the achievements and reward system that gave you levels based on certain meditation behaviour. Therein lies one of the challenges with Muse, or at least my challenge. It is a form of extrinsic validation that places judgement on the reward and results with the potential to encourage ego and attachment to performance. That said, it can be a great tool to get someone into the practice of meditation. It also provides tracking for more experienced practitioners and has an extensive library for those who appreciate guided meditations.</p><p>I respect that some might share concerns that the headband could break the precept of noble silence or otherwise distract from the meditation process. From my perspective, I viewed the headband the same as the mat I sat on or clothes I wore. It was just part of the meditation environment. After the first few days, the results blurred together. Percentages of active or calm lost relevance to the process apart from casual observation.</p><p>The measures of calm and active also do not reflect what is happening within the mind. For example, nodding off to sleep during meditation registers as an active state. You can be in a calm state and gently thinking about the past or future rather than focusing on the breath. You can be diligently performing a Vipassana scan from head to toe and it may register as neutral state.</p><p>The levels are also relative to the initial calibration performed each time you start a meditation session. If you are active at the time of calibration, the levels during meditation tend to be recorded as calmer. It is important to start the meditation session when the calibration starts so the session reflects your current state.</p><p>For these reasons, it may not be appropriate to say from the results “I am active” or “I am calm”. More accurate would be to say, “Muse indicates a calm or active state”. You can then determine what meaning if any those results have for you.</p><blockquote>Like most feedback, Muse results should be observed without placing judgement.</blockquote><p>Another aspect of using the Muse was that it needs the phone app. This proved problematic as it meant I would have my phone with me the entire time. While I could stay away from the apps, I admit to clicking on a few notifications that came up early on. I was also not confident that I had left everything in order back home before I left. I initially checked emails to see if anything had come up. This turned out to be unnecessary.</p><p>I turned off all notifications a day or so into the process. Since leaving the course, I do not expect that I will turn notifications back on. I opt instead for scheduled check-ins through the day for relevant social sites and emails.</p><h3>The lead-up and preparation</h3><p>There were things I had to consider that would not have been required had I attended a formal course.</p><h4>Coaches and conversations</h4><p>I reached out to a couple of mindfulness coaches as I planned the retreat. I also had a chat with a couple of friends who had been on the 10-day course. I could only get so much from blogs and books, and I acknowledged that I did not know what I did not know.</p><p>I had heard of people experiencing unexpected and confronting emotions through the process. One of the coaches mentioned that he was interested to hear what “came up” for me. I had been streaming the Alien movie series with my kid through December in our weekly Zoom catch-ups and immediately thought of an alien bursting out of my chest during a morning meditation session. Another of my friends who had done the course mentioned I was “brave” for attempting to do it on my own. Brave seemed a strong word for sitting in a room by myself for a few days. I questioned what I was getting myself into.</p><p>Reflecting from the other side of the process, I now understand what they meant. There is a smorgasbord of distractions available in daily life. These occupy the mind away from otherwise unwanted thoughts. Remove the distractions and the mind has nowhere else to go but into itself. I am grateful for the conversations in that they helped me to acknowledge that what I was experiencing was normal, even though it did not diminish the intensity of the experience.</p><p>This is likely also why the formal course advises against participating if there are underlying mental health issues or chemical addictions. Meditation can be a powerful tool as part of other support including professional help and accountability communities and programs. I would not propose someone with significant pre-existing conditions attempt a 10-day silent retreat on their own without on-site support as their first option.</p><h4>Books</h4><p>Many people share the benefit of heading into a 10-day program not knowing what to expect. There is an element of trusting the process and experiencing it as it comes up. As I was preparing my own program, I was recommended William Hart’s <a href="https://www.audible.com.au/pd/The-Art-of-Living-Audiobook/B00FQB8BI6?source_code=M2MORSH051016002X"><em>The Art of Living</em></a> which I listened to as an audiobook. I also listened to the personal account of <a href="https://www.audible.com.au/pd/Vipassana-Meditation-Audiobook/B00Y11VY3G">Robert Crayola’s <em>Vipassana Meditation</em></a> audiobook. These helped me understand and plan the process without taking away from the experience. Other books that have informed my perspective include <a href="https://www.amazon.com.au/How-Practise-Way-Meaningful-Life-ebook/dp/B007D15WW0/">How to Practice by the Dalai Lama</a> and <a href="https://www.amazon.com.au/Peace-Every-Step-Mindfulness-Everyday-ebook/dp/B0038AUYSW/">Peace is Every Step by Thic Nhatr Hanh</a>.</p><h4>Food</h4><figure><img alt="Food for a 10-day meditation retreat" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*K-Kg6EWbMd9vbhDR.jpg" /></figure><p>For my height and weight, meditation consumes around 900 calories a day. My diet over the 10 days equalled roughly that amount. Breakfast consisted of three tablespoons of oats and a couple of slices of canned fruit. For lunch, I had a sealed packet of vegetarian curry. Evening tea was an apple, a carrot, and some watermelon while it lasted for the first few days. I also had a handful of plain almonds with the evening lesson. I included coffee in the morning and at lunch, and a tea in the evening.</p><p>I was surprisingly not hungry through the process. I looked forward to each meal for the experience of eating rather than a desire to fill my stomach. I often find I am “mind hungry” more than “stomach hungry”. I eat to consume attention rather than calories.</p><p>I was also keen for the opportunity of a physical detox. I gained three kilos eating and drinking my way through December, for which I have zero regrets. I left to start the process on Boxing Day Saturday. I expect I was still digesting Christmas lunch well into Tuesday. I do acknowledge though that physical and mental clarity go hand in hand. The ten days is a good head start on diet changes for the New Year.</p><p>As a side note, I also lost more than the three kilos through the process.</p><h4>The location</h4><figure><img alt="Farmstay" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/921/0*_PSKwJg78ur0CVkh.jpg" /></figure><p>I looked on Airbnb for a location that was far enough from home and the city, and where I would not know anyone. I also wanted to support a regional provider given the recent impacts on tourism from the pandemic. Finally, I was after space to avoid any possible distractions.</p><p>I searched in Queensland from Goondiwindi to North Burnett. I decided on <a href="https://www.jerakala.com.au/">a perfect farm stay in North Burnett</a> about four and a half hours drive from home. The drive also allowed me to prepare heading into the process and returning home.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*E0kZRctUrFyKI8SP.jpg" /></figure><p>The farm stay was on top of a hill and provided 360-degree views of trees, hills, and grassland. Cows roamed outside the front gate. Crows, galahs, magpies, and black and white cockatoos flew by the windows and provided a soundscape to accompany the wind gently rattling the panes. I regularly escorted green frogs out of the bathroom and learned to keep the toilet lid closed to avoid breaking the no killing rule with a flush in the middle of the night. The only reminder of a functioning society was the occasional car passing along the single stretch of road 300 meters away.</p><h4>Family</h4><p>Even though I travel frequently for work, there is no convenient time to be away for ten days. My time fell over New Years and my stepson’s 16th birthday. I prepared flowers for New Years and a pre-recorded video message for the birthday, but I still missed family over the holidays. I am grateful for their support through the process.</p><h4>Precepts</h4><p>There are certain precepts to be held during a 10-day Vipassana course. These include:</p><ul><li>to abstain from killing any being;</li><li>to abstain from stealing;</li><li>to abstain from all sexual activity;</li><li>to abstain from telling lies;</li><li>to abstain from all intoxicants.</li></ul><p>The requirements also include following a noble silence, which includes no talking, or digital or written forms. These were all straight-forward. There was a tense moment involving a two-inch wasp that found its way into the meditation room and was hanging out on the window screen. I admit to contemplating options of bug spray or a rolled-up magazine before opting for a glass jar catch-and-release method.</p><h4>Schedule</h4><p>The daily schedule went as follows:</p><ul><li>4:00am: Wake up</li><li>4:30am — 6:30am: Meditate</li><li>6:30am — 8:00am: Breakfast</li><li>8:00am — 11:00am: Meditate</li><li>11:00am — 1:00pm: Lunch and rest</li><li>1:00pm — 5:00pm: Meditate</li><li>5:00pm — 6:00pm: Tea break</li><li>6:00pm — 7:00pm: Meditate</li><li>7:00pm — 8:15pm: Discourse</li><li>8:15pm — 9:00pm: Meditate</li></ul><p>I have been an early riser since the US Navy, so the 4:00am wake up was familiar territory. Each day was the same, and different. Some sessions seemed unusually long, other days passed quickly. Far from ‘relaxing’, the meditation sections required focus. I took advantage of the break times to catch quick naps. Even still, I caught myself nodding off in the evening sessions and would occasionally need to replay the evening instruction over meals the next day.</p><p>A challenge and benefit of the process is that you are the facilitator, the participant, and the assessor of your journey. You are your own reference point, apart from the anchor of the evening discourse. Thankfully, the evening discourse is appropriate for each day. It is as though the instructor knows what you have been going through, explaining how to interpret your experience and adding mental models to help with the following day.</p><h3>Meditation reflections</h3><p>What follows are reflections from each day of the process.</p><h4>Day 1 — Be aware of the breath and know thyself</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*-j8Pb8g0-V3bFzur.jpg" /></figure><p>There was no guidance heading into Day 1. Just a schedule of meditation times and a need to focus on the breath. While I had done 4-hour stints in the past, this would be the longest I had meditated in a day. I was nervous but encouraged by the novelty, curious as to whether I could do it, and bound by the fact I had made the commitment.</p><p>As the tedium set in, I started to develop mind tricks to focus my attention. While I had read that visualising on a word or religious construct was discouraged, I began to keep focus by saying “This breath”. Breath in — “<strong><em>This</em></strong>”. Breath out — “<strong><em>Breath</em></strong>”. In — ‘<strong><em>This</em></strong>”. Out — “<strong><em>Breath</em></strong>”. There was a chair in front of me and I also began to play in my mind about the form of the chair — the structure and shape -, the function of the chair — for sitting or standing -, and its aesthetics — the grain of the wood and shape of the bolts.</p><p>I Initially thought how clever I was to easily calm the mind. That evening’s recorded instruction admonished my inventiveness as though it knew what I had been up to. The speaker noted that using visualisation of shape, word, or form does indeed help calm and focus the mind. It is a common practice with spirituality, focusing on a deity, scripture, or a single word or value.</p><p>But the aim of the exercise is not to calm the mind but to change the behaviour pattern of the mind. Visualisation takes the focus off the breath and does not build up the necessary skills. It is like listening to music while working out or attaching confidence to what you are wearing. It can help in the moment but leaves you at risk if those conditions are not present.</p><p>I am also physically inflexible. Me doing yoga reminds me of cheap toy action figures I had as a kid that only bent at one point at the hip, and even at that it was only 45 degrees. Sitting cross-legged for more than five minutes felt like torture. Thankfully the evening instructor acknowledged this and said fidgeting in the first few days was understandable. I took him up on the offer, even as I worked to view the pain as a process. Rather than an attachment to self that “<strong><em>my</em></strong> knee hurts”, the pain in the knee is to be observed as a process happening in the body.</p><p>The aim, we are told, is to ‘<strong><em>know thyself</em></strong>’ through observing the breath. When the mind experiences a good sensation, it wants to repeat the experience producing craving and clinging. We then have the likelihood of attaching our identity to that sensation. When the mind experiences a bad sensation, it wants to avert from the experience and turns to agitation. In this way the mind is ignorant, moving from sensation to sensation without awareness, from aversion to craving. Our thoughts, emotions, and actions follow in ‘mindless’ automation.</p><blockquote>Focusing on the breath helps to observe and therefore inform the mind, reducing ignorance and increasing knowledge.</blockquote><h4>Day 2 –Train the mind, do the work</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*hidt1HNMBeBi0Rvs.jpg" /></figure><p>Day 2 maintained a sense of novelty. I was sore, but also a bit more flexible, able to maintain a cross-legged position for up to 20 minutes. I also had what I can best describe as a ‘sense’, clear memories of my childhood I had not thought about for decades. What followed was a period of interactive and lucid scenes, borrowing from the past and applying to the present.</p><p>The experience seemed to happen in an instant, but around 2 hours had passed. I thought perhaps I nodded off, but Muse did not show the type of pattern I usually see when I fall asleep during meditation. I am not prone to fascinations or visions and hesitate to document this here at risk of it being misinterpreted as something it is not, either as promoting a spiritual vision or a poor reflection on my mental state.</p><p>In reading the accounts of others however, such experiences are not uncommon. I chalk the experience up to a change in diet, new sleep patterns, a novel environment, and quietening external noise through meditation. Perhaps it was a lucid dream state, perhaps a hiccup of the subconscious, perhaps something else. I capture it simply as one of many outputs from the experiment in case others have a similar experience, or if others do not share the experience as a point of comparison.</p><p>The discussion that evening describes the mind as wild and agitated, like a monkey grasping one branch after the other or a rampaging elephant going wildly in one direction or another. The purpose of meditation is to turn the wild mind into a service to society.</p><blockquote>No one can harm us more than our own wild mind and no one can help us more than our trained mind.</blockquote><p>Like training an elephant, it takes patience, persistence, and experience. Also like an elephant, we do not judge it when it rampages. That is just what elephants do. We continue to gently guide it on the path.</p><p>While spiritual doctrines are not emphasised in the practice, there is a notion of good and evil. Any action that harms another being is a sinful action. Any action that helps another being is a wholesome action. Sinful and wholesome actions start in the mind. You are the first victim of your anger.</p><p>The next day we are told to be more subtle in the practice, and focus specifically on areas of the breath, to feel one thing, to focus on one reality.</p><h4>Day 3 — Learning through experience</h4><figure><img alt="Muse results" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*KmBhRiL93CNPbsVw.png" /></figure><p>Only two days in and I wake on Day 3 thinking I could just stop now. But heading into the mediation I am struck with gratitude at the opportunity and I continue. Still, as the day passes without note, the impatience comes in waves. Even as I observe the breath, I observe the impatience and let it go. I find this prepares me for what is to come in Day 4.</p><p>The talk that evening discusses three ways in which we learn about reality: through hearing, through understanding, and through experiencing. We learn in part through hearing, and some might go off and feel they have the picture. You might read this post and feel you can discuss meditation. We learn more through understanding. You might research further, read other blogs on Vipassana, and feel you can teach others about meditation. But reality is always distorted until we learn through experience and speak from the reality of our experience.</p><blockquote>It is only through experience that we truly learn.</blockquote><p>The past three days have been a foundation. The process of Vipassana begins tomorrow, expanding the focus from the breath to the body.</p><h4>Day 4 — a wild ride</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*JotJj7baf9yNuFUk.jpg" /></figure><p>Day 4 was a wild ride. Shortly after starting the mid-morning session, a gamut of frustration, anger, desire, and challenges came to mind. More than just fleeting thoughts, my mind was consumed with mental narratives, arguments, visuals, fights, and debates. I worked to focus on the breath, but the thoughts were all consuming. The more I fought, the stronger and more entrenched the thoughts came. I caught myself holding my breath, having shallow breath, tense, and with a tight chest. It was tempting to get up, walk around, process, and otherwise find distractions. But I sat in silence.</p><p>Growing up in American Pentecostal churches, I recall speakers sharing similar tales of wrestling through prayer and fasting experiences. Except in their case, they attributed the thoughts as an attack from demons and devils and looked to scripture, prayer, angels, and God to take the thoughts away. Similar experiences are shared across spiritual faiths and secular practices. The instruction that evening also referenced the potential for this condition.</p><p>My personal take from the experience is that the process over the four days removed noise and a sense of self that acted as a filter to cover over thoughts under the surface. Without distraction or counter-argument, the otherwise unwanted thoughts had free reign. This continued on-and-off for the better part of seven hours.</p><p>Over time, the thoughts did not go away, but the thoughts lost their connection with emotional and physical response or reaction. I would not refer to the thoughts as negative or undesirable. They became just thoughts without value or judgement. At some point, I was left with the breath. Except where previously there was discomfort, tedium, impatience, and boredom, there was now relief. Having just the breath without the clatter of emotionally-charged thoughts was like a literal breath of fresh air.</p><p>The evening discussion reviewed the process of Vipassana, moving from head to toe to focus the mind through identifying sensations in the body. The instructor explained four major segments of the mind: <strong>Consciousness</strong> — to recognise through the six senses; <strong>Perception</strong> — to recognise based on with experience, conditioning, and memories of the past and to give evaluation; <strong>Sensations</strong> — based on the perception to flow through the body; and <strong>Reaction</strong> — motivation and reaction of the mind and body.</p><p>Reaction gives fruit through repetition. Few repetitions are like a line in water, stronger repetition is like a line in the sand, and continuous repetition is like a line in rock.</p><h4>Day 5: Dropping in</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*k0Yi6xSK2CNnDZqj.jpg" /></figure><p>In the afternoon I had a new experience. First, I recalled that I could not point to a specific time from my previous meditation sessions where there was discomfort. And yet I knew that I had at some point experienced discomfort. The discomfort was temporary and lost its meaning. This helped put the current discomfort in perspective.</p><p>In the afternoon I found I could ‘drop in’ and ‘drop out’ of meditation with ease. When I ‘dropped in’, it felt like I was in the zone and that time both stood still and sped up. When I ‘dropped out’, it was as if I was observing myself meditating in the third person. This kept up through the four-hour afternoon session. There were other times in the session where the meditation was not so easy and I did not attempt to hang on to the sensation, but I appreciated the experience.</p><p>The evening session spoke of moving to the deeper areas of the mind to understand the clinging and aversion, exposing the blind habit patterns. The aim is to ‘know’ beyond the intellectual level and learn at the experiential level to break the barrier. This is to avoid the sleeping impurities and volcanoes that may lay dormant, training the deeper level of mind to not react.</p><p>Through meditation, we can accept the reality of the misery, not react, and just observe. This stops the process by which we multiply any physical pain we experience with mental pain which comes from craving and aversion.</p><h4>Day 6 — Practical application</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*YqUo5s0ad1qhl0Ff.jpg" /></figure><p>Day 6 was a continued narrative of the previous day. My mind continued to gravitate towards various scenarios, personal relationships, and work challenges. In some cases, I observe the relationship similar to how I might observe my breath; objectively, pragmatically, and without judgement. In doing so, I understand my emotions and my role in the context which helps consider a course of action. I acknowledge that these scenarios and even the work itself can be a form of addiction.</p><p>The discussion in the evening highlighted the mind’s addiction to craving. The craving is not for the object, but for the sensation brought about by the object. The instructor notes for example that the addiction is not necessarily for the alcohol or drugs, but to the sensation they bring (acknowledging the physiological realities of chemicals on the brain). Once the sensation is obtained, the craving can become stale, and a new craving emerges or the craving escalates. The form of sensation can be defined by your personality, following a habit pattern of the mind. Meditation is one approach to support overcoming aversion through the repetition of not reacting.</p><p>Five barriers to this process include the two main ones identified of craving and aversion, as well as laziness which leads to drowsiness to avoid the practice, agitation resulting in distraction from the practice, and doubt.</p><h4>Pressing pause</h4><p>I pressed pause on the 10-day practice after Day 6. This was not without some internal debate. I remained curious as to what further changes or insights I might experience from an additional 40 hours of work. The instruction also gave warning of a potentially negative impact from leaving the process early.</p><p>I had gained much from the process and have no doubt there is more to learn. But the temptation to take advantage of the silence and the idyllic setting was strong. I wanted to capture my thoughts, step back, reflect, relax, and prepare. I spent the next few days continuing morning meditations, writing, and reflecting while staying in the silence. I was also able to prepare for the year ahead, as I knew I would be hitting the ground running when I returned and was also keen to spend time with family without rushing.</p><p>I considered whether this was simply a craving of the mind. Perhaps I missed out on a great epiphany from not continuing the practice over the final days. If I had been in a structured course, I would have likely continued due to lack of any other option. But I am grateful for the clarity and time I had.</p><h3>Reflection, practice, and where to from here</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*iyMmPayQ8dSqCTNa.jpg" /></figure><p>The day I came out of the retreat was the day the US capital was being stormed and the media cycle was in an understandable frenzy. Rather than either retreating back into silence or embracing seeming chaos, the meditation practice encourages leaning into reality to fully understand what is happening and our position. The situation in the US is saddening. It is also motivating for the the work I am involved with helping communities understand differences to better facilitate sustainable regional change and transition.</p><p>I took away two main reflections from the meditation experience. The first is compassion. A lesson from the past year is that everyone is on their own journey. I believe the main challenge facing society is the notion of ‘us versus them’. We can have an aversion to ‘the other’ that is not like us or represents a part of us we do not wish to acknowledge. We can also have an attraction to those who are like us, who reinforce the view we want the world to see. Compassion and understanding breaks down these differences. But before we have compassion for others, it usually starts with understanding ourselves. Meditation assist with this practice.</p><p>The second reflection is gratitude. First, I am grateful for the lessons from the experience I had over the ten days. I am grateful for those who have gone before me to build up the collective wisdom from which I can learn. I am grateful for those who have supported and contributed to my learning over the past year and those close to me who journey with me in life. And I am grateful for the opportunity to live out my vocation in my current field of practice. That gratitude is a strong motivator to give back for what I have been given.</p><p>As to the practice of meditation, I come away with a tool for clarity and focus. Meditation is not a cure-all. It should be used in combination with other approaches to overall wellness. Meditation is also not just doing time. It takes work and focus. If you go to a gym for a five-minute stroll on the treadmill before pounding the big bacon breakfast at the local diner, you will not expect to be physically fit. Similarly, if you only go through the motions of meditating and do not put the effort in to control the mind, you should not expect to see results.</p><p>There is value in a regular practice of silent meditation. Like a gym, meditation is training for the muscle of the mind. Meditation is not just relegated to the yoga mat and secluded house on a hill, however. We have access to the breath wherever we are. Returning the breath ‘in the moment’ provides a grounding, an ability to distinguish between thought and response, and to make decisions accordingly.</p><p>The experience also provided a level of discipline. Doing nothing can be one of the hardest things we do. My intermittent daily meditation practice previously ranged from 10 to 30 minutes. I now know I can sit for ten hours a day over several days. This has greatly diminished the fear from the boredom.</p><p>So where to from here? Over the next month I am engaging a mindfulness and performance coach to embed the practice. I will also be continuing the morning practice of meditation to coincide with a fitness routine that fell by the wayside towards the end of the year. I am also tweaking my productivity stack of OneNote, Trello, and time tracking (aTimeLogger for the iPhone) which has served me well in the past.</p><p>If you have read this far, thank you for going on the journey with me. I welcome any insights from your own experience, and happy to share anything further for those planning a similar process.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f65f03964688" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Today is the best day of my life!]]></title>
            <link>https://chadrenando.medium.com/today-is-the-best-day-of-my-life-1bed6620573a?source=rss-ed20c6660319------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1bed6620573a</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Chad Renando]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 11 Dec 2020 04:30:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-01-19T04:32:47.949Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/0*fKXuSv4fFwc_YyFr.jpg" /></figure><blockquote>“Today is the best day of my life!”</blockquote><p>So might say an Olympian winning a gold medal, parents on the day their child is born, a student when they get their university scholarship, a drought-stricken farmer after the first rain, a startup founder receiving their first round of investment, or a lucky punter winning the lottery.</p><p>While all those are understandable, I heard of this insight mentioned by a young man after he spent a day hanging out with his mum at work over the summer holidays.</p><p>The young man and I shared similar experiences over two days in regional Australia. We both sat in the cafe sharing our favourite drink — mine a large skinny cappuccino, his a chocolate milkshake. While his mother and I had conversations about mapping and developing the entrepreneur and creative sectors of the region, he took pictures of the street with his iPad.</p><p>Later in the library, I worked with the team discussing strategies for building local economic development capability. The young man sat with us, working with scissors and tape to create a paper man he would later buckle up in the car and take home.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/768/0*yaxoAP-rQxhTNXTu.jpg" /></figure><blockquote>“Today is the best day of my life!”</blockquote><p>Hearing this statement automatically infers a position relative in time. If today is the best day, then we must assume it to be better than all the days that came before. The older we get, the more weight the statement holds.</p><p>There was also no regard for comparing his best day to someone else’s best day. Pictures with iPads and cutting paper men was his best day. Other young people may be at water parks, while still others may be at home doing work. His best day was for him and him alone.</p><p>There was also no aspect of seeing his best day through the eyes of others. What I judge as my best day will likely be different from what you would say is my best day. The declaration of their best day by a CEO of a Fortune 500 company may be influenced by the views of company shareholders, that of school teacher by parents, colleagues, and students. We may feel the need to defend such a statement by those whose opinion we respect.</p><p>It is unlikely the young man’s frame of reference was based on an assessment of previous best days. His recollection, if there was any, would have been based on his collected wisdom as he moves from kindergarten to big-person school. I also doubt that relative subjectivity went into his statement. He was unlikely to consider whether his parents or playgroup friends agreed with his declaration.</p><blockquote>“Today is the best day of my life!”</blockquote><p>The young man’s statement and my own epiphany is a timely reminder. Much of life can be spent comparing to a past standard, assessing gaps in the current situation, or in anticipation of a future potential that might be better than today. The result is that it becomes increasingly unlikely you will ever say “this is the best day of my life”.</p><p>The truth from innocence that came from the young man is that every day is the best day of my life. Every day contains varying degrees of success and suffering, elation and depression, learning and validation.</p><p>Saying today is the best day of my life is not a subjective assessment. It is a declaration of fact. It is finding joy in wherever the hand is applied, be it crafting strategies, creating meals, curating policy, or cutting out paper people.</p><p>I am fortunate to be able to work with amazing leaders in regions. The people I meet are passionate, insightful, creative, dedicated, compassionate, humble, and resilient. The challenges faced in regions are complex, no single individual or organisation can address the challenges, and we collectively are making progress. I am able to work with incredible people and the work is rewarding.</p><p>Some days are spent preparing for the work, other days do not go as planned, and challenges in regions need to be shared to be understood. But it is all building to make a real and lasting impact with a cohort of amazing people. It creates a context where every day is the best day of my life.</p><p>It has been an intense year of pandemic and PhD. I have big plans for 2021. I am grateful for the gift of innocent wisdom that provides a valuable perspective as we collectively prepare for the New Year.</p><p>And may today be the best day of your life. :)</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1bed6620573a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Remembering where I was when I heard the news]]></title>
            <link>https://chadrenando.medium.com/remembering-where-i-was-when-i-heard-the-news-d2cf203fccab?source=rss-ed20c6660319------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d2cf203fccab</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Chad Renando]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 07 Nov 2020 04:32:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-01-19T04:33:57.318Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*-aptEgcBD9rCbHqB.png" /></figure><p>It’s 2:40 in the morning in Ipswich, Queensland. The low hum of the refrigerator is drowned out by the kettle as I make my first batch of coffee. The stove-top light has attracted a couple of moths that make light thuds as they strike against the light. My dogs pace the kitchen, anxious to interrogate the cats we hear fighting on my front lawn.</p><p>I scroll through the live blogs on my phone to catch up on US election results that came through as I slept. The ABC bloggers are doing a good job of making conversation in between incremental changes to ballot counts in key states of Nevada, Georgia, Pennsylvania. Some say Arizona could still be in question.</p><p>There are stories about Donald Trump golfing. Trump’s legal team is planning a press conference at <a href="https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1325088995773132803.html">a Four Seasons Landscaping business</a>. The <a href="https://www.yelp.com/biz/four-seasons-total-landscaping-philadelphia">Yelp reviews</a> for the landscaping business have exploded.</p><p>I reflect how any surprise I might have once had from a media scroll is now replaced with dull expectation. The news cycle is like waiting for the next skit in a Saturday Night Live show when they are having an off night.</p><p>Then the notification pops up on my phone from the Australian Financial Review app. “Joe Biden will be America’s 46th president…”. The AP called Pennsylvania.</p><p>And the emotions roll in.</p><blockquote>“Kamala Harris will be the first woman, and woman of colour, to become the vice president of the United States.”</blockquote><p>I am unable to stop the tears each time I hear that statement from the news desks. It is an incredible moment, a major significance on the journey towards acceptance and commonplace. Where one day a “female person of colour in a position of leadership” is noted as “a person in leadership”. As Kamala <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/i-am-who-i-am-kamala-harris-daughter-of-indian-and-jamaican-immigrants-defines-herself-simply-as-american/2019/02/02/0b278536-24b7-11e9-ad53-824486280311_story.html">noted </a>“<em>I am who I am. I’m good with it. You might need to figure it out, but I’m fine with it.</em>”</p><p>The end of the Trump presidency, the first one-term president since 1993, is a statement that being in a position is not validation of behaviour. Trump appeared to <a href="https://www.fastcompany.com/90573062/donald-trump-is-a-loser">negate every lesson</a> taught from Sunday School through to an MBA. Covey’s seven habits, Lencioni’s rules for teams, Schein’s culture, Gandhi’s experiments, Jesus’ beatitudes — all dismissed as unnecessary norms that get in the way of success of self.</p><p>Using a corporate lens, the administration experienced high staff turnover, continuous litigation and corruption, multiple allegations and prior admission of sexual assault, and a lack of singular accountability and personal awareness. Acceptance of Trump was a lesson for corporates that personal character came second to economic performance. Trump staying in office tells future generations that denigrating others based on appearance, age, or background is appropriate. Trump being voted out of office sends a strong message that words and character matter.</p><p>I am looking forward to a US presidency that is not entirely focused on the person of the US president. As an American and Australian in Australia, I often reflect how I do not think about the person of the Prime Minister on a regular basis. Days can go by when the name or face of the sitting prime minister does not come to mind, apart from when it is raised by either side of the moderately politicised media. The Trump administration by comparison was defined by vanity metrics where success is described in terms of ratings, likes, and crowd sizes.</p><p>Some would say that Trump simply highlighted deep divisions that already exist. There is no doubt that there are systemic and embedded inequalities in terms of race, geography, and position. But hate is not overcome by hate.</p><p>We know what distrust, fear, anger, and pride look like. We have seen it particularly over the past four years in social media feeds.</p><p>What we are not as familiar with as a society is love, trust, compassion, and humility. We continue to aspire to examples of what could be, rather than wallow in the depths of what is. We have a daily opportunity to be better versions of ourselves, without having to focus on beating everyone else.</p><p>I remember where I was when I heard the news. And I am grateful.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d2cf203fccab" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Australian entrepreneur ecosystem: Presentation at the 2020 G20 Roundtable on Entrepreneurship]]></title>
            <link>https://chadrenando.medium.com/the-australian-entrepreneur-ecosystem-presentation-at-the-2020-g20-roundtable-on-entrepreneurship-55d4be7abf34?source=rss-ed20c6660319------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/55d4be7abf34</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Chad Renando]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 07 Nov 2020 02:05:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-01-16T10:10:32.119Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/868/0*ihZ3AxJEL1WBta8U.png" /></figure><p>I recently had the honour of sharing virtually at the 2020 G20 Roundtable on Entrepreneurship. The theme of the session was “<em>Policies and actions to promote entrepreneurship in the post-pandemic era</em>”, and my presentation was in a session to “<em>Boost entrepreneurship to promote employment”</em>. The presentations from countries around the world highlighted that each country experienced the pandemic differently while many of the challenges and responses were similar.</p><p>An overview of the presentation is outlined below. I also caught up with my colleague and friend <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/vibhor-pandey/">Vibhour Pandey</a> to hear his perspective on the presentation to reflect on:</p><ul><li><em>What is the state of entrepreneurship in Australia?</em></li><li><em>How has support for entrepreneurship grown over time, and across what sectors and where across the nation?</em></li><li><em>What are some of the impacts and policy changes from COVID-19 on the Australian economy?</em></li><li><em>What does the future hold for Australian entrepreneurship?</em></li></ul><p>Our recorded chat is posted below as well as an overview of each slide. This is just one perspective, and I welcome the views, feedback, and perspectives of others.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FMfVywOOwyQM%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DMfVywOOwyQM&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FMfVywOOwyQM%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/dba8428c3bc29bcc258e7eb03b9d786a/href">https://medium.com/media/dba8428c3bc29bcc258e7eb03b9d786a/href</a></iframe><h4><strong>The G20 Roundtable on Entrepreneurship</strong></h4><p>The G20 Roundtable on Entrepreneurship came out of the 2016 the G20 Labour Employment Ministers’ Meeting in Beijing, which resulted in the establishment of the <a href="http://www.g20e.tsinghua.edu.cn/EN/index.html">Entrepreneurship Research Centre on G20 Economies</a> and the acceptance of several documents including the <a href="http://www.g20.utoronto.ca/2016/160713-labour.html#annex1">G20 Entrepreneurship Action Plan</a>. The G20 Roundtable on Entrepreneurship has been held for each year since with member countries reporting on the progress of entrepreneur support in their respective regions.</p><h4><strong>Entrepreneurship in a post-pandemic Era</strong></h4><p>The topic for 2020 was “<em>Policies and Actions to Promote Entrepreneurship in the Post-pandemic Era</em>”. Member countries shared about their respective policy measures framed broadly using various terms in three approaches: Sustain / Response, Transform / Recovery, and Transition. Approaches are often specific to each stage, such as job saving initiatives and increased support for unemployment in the initial <strong>Sustain and Response, </strong>retraining and investment in digital skilling for established businesses in <strong>Transform</strong> <strong>and Recovery,</strong> and investing in new industries and innovation tax incentives in <strong>Transition</strong>. The IMF has <a href="https://www.imf.org/en/Topics/imf-and-covid19/Policy-Responses-to-COVID-19">a good overview of policy measures by country</a>.</p><p>Listening to responses by other countries, I was struck by both similarities and differences. Each country experienced COVID-19 differently based on factors such as population density, previous economic condition, socio-political landscape, and when the pandemic hit relative to the global spread. The mechanisms to address the pandemic were similar, including tax incentives and deferrals, job stimulus packages, sector-specific recovery plans, specialised grants, and rate cuts. The combination and intensity of these mechanisms varied, with some countries placing a greater explicit emphasis on innovation and entrepreneurship.</p><h4><strong>Representing Australia: Boost entrepreneurship to promote employment</strong></h4><p>So what would you say to best share about and represent Australia in an 8-minute presentation on the topic “<em>Boost entrepreneurship to promote employment</em>”?</p><p>I was conscious that delegates may have limited insights into Australia’s entrepreneur support system. I wanted to share some insights into the COVID-19 response without getting into too much detail. I was also keen to present Australia in a positive light, acknowledging there will be debates in most countries on appropriate measures and whether enough is being done to support new businesses.</p><p>The story I aimed to share is outlined below:</p><h4><strong>1. Set the scene</strong></h4><blockquote>Australia is strong in corporate entrepreneurship and over one in ten Australians are involved in early-stage entrepreneurial activity of some form</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*PHR4U2M2Jqau1tzD.jpg" /></figure><p>Based on a random, representative sample of 10,000 Australians, the <a href="https://research.qut.edu.au/ace/projects/global-entrepreneurship-monitor-gem/">2019 Global Entrepreneurship Monitor</a> identified that between 10.5% to 11.8% of Australians are involved in early-stage entrepreneurial activity. This includes intrapreneurship (entrepreneurs working in a business for an employer), new business ownership, and early or nascent activity. Australia ranks first out of the 50 participating countries for intrapreneurship. Over half of Australians feel they have the capability to start a business, while just under half see good opportunities to start a business where they live.</p><p>Australia’s entrepreneur potential is strong, but it is often held inside established institutions focused on local challenges. There are opportunities to further focus on external and global opportunities.</p><h4><strong>2. Australia’s ‘entrepreneur ecosystem’ has grown rapidly</strong></h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*klwwLe7MOB3z1dFS.jpg" /></figure><p>The federal $1.1 billion National Innovation and Science Agenda was released in 2015. Many states followed suit with their own innovation programs including Victoria’s LaunchVic, Queensland’s AdvanceQld, and New South Wales’ Jobs for NSW. There was also a rapid increase in incubators, investment groups, and innovation and entrepreneur-focused programs such as accelerators and hackathons. While there was already momentum from general trends in technology and global influence, the national and local policies had a significant contribution. This growth was levelling out by 2019 due to market rationalisation and geographic saturation. The diagram below shows the growth in Queensland as an example, and other states and territories have a similar trajectory.</p><h4><strong>3. There is a strong support network for Australian entrepreneurs and Australia’s innovation capability is diverse and integrated</strong></h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*786DsJ7GxWehy5-J.jpg" /></figure><p>A number of investment groups, programs, and spaces <a href="https://your.startupstatus.co/map/">have been established across Australia</a>. Each state and territory has a dedicated program or space that is representative of the entrepreneurial community. We are also seeing focus areas in innovation and entrepreneurship emerge including aerospace and defence in Northern Territories and South Australia, resources in Western Australia, Agriculture in Queensland, and health in Victoria. Regions are specialising in specific sectors and technologies, while also building on existing strengths and diversifying.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*JXjfF8A7uG9dGMdR.jpg" /></figure><p>Innovation happens at the cross-section of different ideas: Agriculture, artificial intelligence, and aerospace; Defence, mining, and advanced manufacturing; Fintech and cybersecurity. This involves all aspects of the ecosystems — government, universities, risk capital, industry, and community — all focused on the entrepreneur’s success.</p><h4><strong>4. Risk capital investment is growing in Australia even through the pandemic</strong></h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*WnNpCFmWvpKD2Uxc.jpg" /></figure><p>Activity of new support organisations and programs is only one indicator. We are also seeing sustained and resilient investment of risk capital. Based on <a href="https://techboard.com.au/funding-reports/">funding reports from Techboard</a>, we are seeing increases in the total number of investments, the amount of investment, and the diversity of investment sources event through the pandemic.</p><h4><strong>5. COVID-19 has had an impact</strong></h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*YyIh8YJ3d1e6RmCp.jpg" /></figure><p>Australia lost 800,000 jobs between February and June 2020, with some industries down by over a third. We have also seen the closure of some incubators and entrepreneur support services. You can read more from our submission to the <a href="https://www.gemconsortium.org/reports/covid-impact-report">Global Entrepreneurship Monitor COVID-19 impact report</a> along with other countries.</p><p>However, startups in many cases have been resilient, Asurvey of 15 VC funds reflecting only 4 to 7 per cent of respondents indicating job losses and the ICT industry overall down only 10 per cent. Other sectors such as agriculture and financial services increased through the pandemic and there were cases of manufacturing pivoting rapidly to support the pandemic efforts.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*Fvtpl4f6Uv2D6_AT.jpg" /></figure><p>Australia invested $239 billion into the initial response efforts through a range of programs, over 13% of the GDP. The recent budget has specific initiatives suited to innovation and entrepreneurship, including continued support for the R&amp;D tax incentive, investment to support businesses engaging in digital technologies, and investment into manufacturing strategies.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*aKUt-_fSchvKKMyQ.jpg" /></figure><h4><strong>6. We have our work cut out for us</strong></h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*8x3Ucnwzgg--k1MZ.jpg" /></figure><p>The rate of new business entries has increased steadily, but has been impacted by the pandemic. There is a good tracking in the report from the <a href="https://research.qut.edu.au/ace/projects/labii/">Longitudinal Australian Business Integrated Intelligence (LABii) report</a>. The stimulus is decreasing the normal trend in business exits, and we can expect a spike once stimulus stops. But we have experienced challenges in the past and we can get through this.</p><h4><strong>7. The way out is through — new business activity is critical for our future</strong></h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*ZRR-GCltgJMw2FSm.jpg" /></figure><p>Any success story we read about today was in a garage, incubator, or hackathon yesterday. These companies are not just creating the jobs for today. The people who work at these companies are gaining valuable skills and experience. Research proves that these people will go on to form their own companies and startups, building on and advancing what they learned from their previous employers. Many of the startup founders of tomorrow are working in the Atlassians, Safety Cultures and Canvas of today.</p><h4><strong>8. Our opportunity is to learning from the pandemic and leverage the disruption for new growth</strong></h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*yHLGD5VHENUyWmJt.jpg" /></figure><p>There are four broad observations we can make from the pandemic.</p><p><strong>First</strong>, we can use the disruption to continue our focus transitioning economies. Australia is familiar with transition from dominant industries such as the resource sector and agriculture. Build on the narrative to transition to new technologies and innovation prompted by the pandemic.</p><p><strong>Second</strong>, use the disruption as motivation. The previously mentioned GEM report also identified Australian’s have a relatively high fear of failure. The pandemic can shake us out of our comfort zone and prompt action in new directions.</p><p><strong>Third</strong>, the pandemic has prompted new collaborations between industry sectors and roles in the ecosystem. Leverage these to enhance collaboration across industry sectors and roles such as governments, universities, and risk capital.</p><p><strong>Finally</strong>, the pandemic is not an either/or situation with other major challenges. The pandemic exposes inequalities for those who may not have access to opportunities based on gender, geography, or nationality. Build on the momentum for change to address other challenges of climate impacts, regional locations, or demographics.</p><h4>What’s next</h4><p>Support for entrepreneurs in Australia has grown over the years. The ‘ecosystem’ has expanded regionally, is more focused by sector, and is increasingly dedicated towards diverse communities. In what is referred to as a complex adaptive system, the ecosystem is continuously evolving to meet the needs of the country.</p><p>Critical to success is increased collaboration between regions, across industry sectors, and through all levels of government, research, education, finance, and industry. The formula for entrepreneur ecosystem collaboration is simple in principle but difficult in execution: mobilise around a common challenge and focused on the success of the entrepreneur.</p><p>The ecosystem will continue to adapt to address the unique challenges introduced by 2020 to support growth of new forms of business into 2021. Having been a participant and contributor in the Australian ecosystem for the the past two decades, I am encouraged by where we are going and the strong foundation on which we can build.</p><p>Mine is just one perspective, informed by my roles as a Research Fellow with the Queensland University of Technology, Research Fellow (Innovation Ecosystems) with the University of Southern Queensland, CEO and founder of the not-for-profit Startup Status, and Managing Director — Australia for the Global Entrepreneurship Network. Your views and stories are welcome and appreciated as we work together to make a difference for those giving it a go.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=55d4be7abf34" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[PhD reflections — What worked, what I would do differently]]></title>
            <link>https://chadrenando.medium.com/phd-reflections-what-worked-what-i-would-do-differently-a47d2f489c8c?source=rss-ed20c6660319------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a47d2f489c8c</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Chad Renando]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 03 Oct 2020 04:34:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-01-19T04:43:20.950Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*eiOgYuvqYLRzej7u.jpg" /></figure><p>I hunkered down to complete my PhD around the time that COVID-19 hit in Australia. My initial thought was that lockdown would be a perfect opportunity to finish the thesis. I was mistaken.</p><p>The pandemic proved an ‘all hands on deck’ moment for anyone involved in economic and community development work. I found myself busier than ever even as I read stories about people learning to bake bread and being bored in lockdown</p><p>COVID-19 also became the dominant distraction. A PhD is already an exercise in disciplined procrastination avoidance. The pandemic combined with a pervasive media cycle has proven virulent in consuming any available attention.</p><p>So my 2020 PhD completion plan of two weeks became four, then a two month plan extended to six. We are now in October, the chapters have gone through multiple supervisor reviews, and I am in the final revision and submission process. Between external reviewers and admin, I am looking at a March 2021 completion date.</p><p>Now that I am coming up for air, I wanted to take a moment to reflect and learn before my own revisionist history gets the better of me. Writing provides benchmarks in our lives. Reading <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/path-phd-topic-community-resiliency-regional-hubs-chad-renando/">my original PhD post from 2016</a>, I smile at who I was, my optimistic two-year prediction, and who I thought I might be when I finished.</p><p>I share so that perhaps others may learn for their future journey, that those who have been down the path might reflect and compare, and those who are considering the PhD path may learn as careers and professions continue to be disrupted. Like any personal narrative, take and apply what adds value, leave the rest. Below are some brief reflections on what I found helpful and what I would do different.</p><h4>The PhD process</h4><p>Some people do a PhD through coursework, others through submitting multiple journal submissions, still others with one main thesis. I did one thesis, but I recommend submitting articles as you go. PhDs will also be different based on the domain — medicine, business, sociology, psychology, manufacturing, etc. The steps below are based on my own experience at the cross-section of business and community.</p><h4><strong>STEP 1: Apply</strong></h4><p>The first step is to <strong>apply</strong>. I have heard of people having a few attempts as they find the right fit with their question, one or more supervisors with interest and capacity to support the topic, and a primary university in which they will be based. Universities are also often looking for people to research a particular field and scholarships are available if your interests align with desired outcomes.</p><p>I was was working as <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/fire-station-101-first-18-months-innovation-hub-chad-renando/">a community manager in an innovation hub</a> in 2016 when I started asking questions about the impact the hub was having on the wider community. This aligned with a focus area for the local university (University of Southern Queensland) and availability of supervisors including one who with a focus on social enterprise and another who was developing an innovation program for women in regional and rural communities. I later added another supervisor from the Queensland University of Technology who specialised in regional innovation-related entrepreneurship and data.</p><h4>STEP 2: Proposal</h4><p>The second stage of a PhD is to <strong>refine the question and develop the research proposal</strong>. This involves a review of research that has gone before and conversations with your supervisor to focus your question.</p><p>I was too broad in so many areas, asking about the role of the innovation hub, ways to measure the impact, innovation hub sustainability, regional comparisons and statistical data, and all this across all of Australia with global comparisons. I developed a software platform to measure innovation hub impact, mapped the ecosystem across Australia, and planned to physically interview every innovation ecosystem in Australia. I was grossly over-ambitious.</p><p>I am grateful for the feedback of those who helped me focus my attention. This process of refinement is natural and not unexpected. In startup terms, this is similar to the process of customer validation. Like many startups, there is a risk of trying to solve to many problems, addressing issues that aren’t really an issue, and not identifying the gap where others have not already addressed the issue or opportunity.</p><h4>STEP 3: Confirmation</h4><p>The third stage is <strong>presenting the research proposal and being confirmed</strong>. This is like pitching your idea.</p><p>I was humbled to present my proposal for confirmation to a panel that included leaders whose work inspired me to pursue my topic. I remember the chuckles as I shared my plan for a national driving tour over 10 months. I am glad I took their feedback on board to limit the scope to Queensland. Otherwise I might still be on the road.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*EbVRIhzV6r4ZTvMu.png" /><figcaption>What was planned…</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/870/0*Q1lgoEBXoeoNC0tO.png" /><figcaption>…and what actually happened</figcaption></figure><p>Through the proposal and confirmation process, I also met the tribe of like-minded researchers, policy-makers, and practitioners who were interested in similar outcomes. This process was valuable to connect with many who I now call colleagues, mentors, advisors, and friends.</p><h4>STEP 4: Research</h4><p>The fourth stage is <strong>conducting the research</strong>. This may be collecting new data from surveys, interviews, or workshops, or collating existing data sets in new ways. My research involved <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/reflections-from-tour-regional-queensland-innovation-chad-renando/">driving across Queensland for almost three months </a>conducting over 180 interviews, as well as fly-in visits to centres in each state and territory.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*i8nMIKcWYypwtU_b.png" /><figcaption>I have an entire hard drive of drone shots</figcaption></figure><p>A key take away was to do one thing and do it well. My intent was to focus on research outcomes while at the same time promoting regional innovation and supporting local leaders through sharing stories. After over 60 days of AirBNBs, going through two drones, five hard drives of data, two laptops, and navigating a summer of record heat and fires, my priority focused exclusively on capturing the stories and data. I still have the content for a potential documentary, but the research became a priority.</p><h4>STEP 5: Analysis and writing</h4><p>Once you have the data, it is time to analyse and write up the results. I found this a process of learning <em>how </em>to write as much as writing itself. My document ballooned to over 250,000 words before settling on the current 120,000 words over nine chapters.</p><p>Written and read is better than perfect. I held on to my work for too long before getting it reviewed and in front of my supervisors early and often. I ended up with significant rewrites having followed a few literature rabbit trails and mixing method with theory. Earlier reviews would have minimised the rework.</p><p>The writing also did not flow like I thought it would. I would stare at the screen for days with only one or two pages to show for it. Then re-reading a week later, I would move entire lines of thought to the appendix as they were not contributing to the original question.</p><p>I ended up taking breaks and engaging regions to break the blocks. It was necessary to reconnect with the original passion that inspired my journey in the first place.</p><h4>STEP 6: Review, submission, and defence</h4><p>I am now in the final stage of review and submission and expect to defend my position with external reviewers by early 2021. Given the past reviews and refinement, I am fairly confident in the next steps. I will keep you updated as I go.</p><h4>Four reflections</h4><p>The PhD process is one of ups and downs. There are Twitter communities dedicated to the journey at <a href="https://renando.com/2020/10/03/phd-reflections-what-worked-what-i-would-do-different/#phdlife">#phdlife</a> and <a href="https://renando.com/2020/10/03/phd-reflections-what-worked-what-i-would-do-different/#phdchat">#phdchat</a>. Anyone doing a PhD will quickly stumble across the disturbingly accurate <a href="http://phdcomics.com/comics/">Piled higher and Deeper comic strip</a>. These streams of thought have been very helpful to normalise my experience versus to my own preconceived view of my PhD journey.</p><p>The tweets below remind me I am not alone in my thinking…</p><p><strong><em>What I thought:</em></strong></p><blockquote>I’m done writing, my thesis is awesome, after a brief review I should be done in two weeks!</blockquote><p><strong><em>The reality:</em></strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/582/0*QBriw4YwkTlEmZ8X.png" /></figure><p><strong><em>What I thought:</em></strong></p><blockquote>I can write, I’ve done a Masters, and have you seen my blog posts?</blockquote><p><strong><em>The reality:</em></strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/590/0*PrsyBOGefVJzUL5u.png" /></figure><p><strong><em>What I thought:</em></strong></p><blockquote>I’ll drive around and collect data across Australia, film and edit a documentary, make a significant contribution to literature, and build a software business in on the side.</blockquote><p><strong><em>The reality:</em></strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/578/0*EfhlLSD89573KZxQ.png" /></figure><p>I could go on, but you get the idea. Part of my desire to write this post is to now contribute for those in the midst of the PhD to know that what they are experiencing is OK. With that in mind, here are some top of mind reflections.</p><h4>Reflection 1: A lot of life happens in a PhD</h4><p>My first reflection is an acknowledgment that life happens around a PhD. A full-time PhD is scheduled at three years. My own journey will clock in at five years and includes a leave of absence and three extensions. A lot of life happens in five years.</p><p>From when I started my PhD to now, I:</p><ul><li>created three businesses,</li><li>was contracted or employed in seven positions,</li><li>completed regional consultancy engagements across Australia,</li><li>toured North America,</li><li>visited every state and territory in Australia,</li><li>divorced, and</li><li>re-married.</li></ul><p>Not to mention the pandemic.</p><p>Who I am now is different than who I was. I have had successes, made mistakes, and learned lessons along the way.</p><p>Through it all the PhD has been a constant. My starting question has not changed, but the personal and global context in which the question is asked has. The PhD has been a constant interaction between self and the environment.</p><p>Rather than detract, these changes and challenges have made the process all the richer. It has allowed me to explore personal, organisation, and community resilience in the midst of disruption.</p><p>A PhD is a marathon. Marathons are about the journey, not the finish line.</p><h4>Reflection 2: The guilt</h4><p>My second reflection is about something I read a lot about in PhD conversations — the guilt. At some point, my life became a constant state of either working on the thesis or not working on the thesis. Everything else — sleep, family, eating, work — was framed as a decision to not work on the thesis. You would think this would be motivating to finish the thesis, but the self-imposed pressure inhibited creativity and the words stopped flowing.</p><p>I also found it difficult to justify writing the thesis with so many immediate needs to be addressed, particularly in the middle of a pandemic. Social media feeds became a vicious cycle of procrastination and guilt. The inner monologue was that others were making a difference while I stared at the screen willing my paragraphs to rewrite themselves.</p><p>A few perspectives helped with this process. First, everyone is in different stages and seasons in life. I have had times of building companies and communities, working in agencies, and studying. This was a season of study. It was just taking a bit longer than I expected.</p><p>Second, I kept reminding myself of the reason I started the journey in the first place. I believe the challenges we face are complex and systemic. These challenges require solutions that have rigour and address systemic and embedded barriers. I believe my research is contributing to this solution.</p><p>Finally, the guilt is a feeling that passes. The way out is the way through, appreciating what the guilt was saying, applying what is mine to own, leaving what is not, and continuing with the work regardless. Once I was able to observe the guilt for what it was, I was able to lean into it and continue writing.</p><h4>Reflection 3: This is not your life’s work</h4><p>The third reflection is that the PhD is only the beginning. When I started the PhD process, I felt it would be the pinnacle of academic achievement and the consolidation of my experiences. One of my supervisors gave me great advice — the PhD is not my life’s work, but a starting point. This was confronting and humbling to realise that what I thought was the finish line is actually the starting block.</p><p>Every day of research is an awareness of how little I know and how much there is to learn. The PhD will not be a culmination of knowledge but joining a group of those on a life journey of sharing knowledge with others.</p><h4>Reflection 4: The support of others</h4><p>My last reflection (for now) is the value of support from others. I started the PhD as a solo effort. It was not until much later that I leaned more on my supervisors and colleagues for input, feedback, and support. Having been a mentor and coach for others, I found it difficult to raise my hand and ask for help or even be aware that help was needed.</p><p>I would not be where I am if not for the last six months of weekly submissions and daily catch ups with a few people who have provided advice or simply a sanity check. I am very grateful and look forward to returning the favour for others. If I were to do it again, I would get this routine in earlier.</p><h4>Next steps</h4><p>Which brings me to where to from here. I am working through the backlog of projects and reports queued up as I worked on the thesis. I am fortunate to have two Research Fellow roles that allow me to apply my research, and there are about six papers to be delivered off the back of my thesis. There is also ongoing regional work and mapping to be done across Australia through the Universities as well as my not-for-profit <a href="https://startupstatus.co/">Startup Status</a>.</p><p>One of the things I am most looking forward to is the ability to be a supervisor for others on the PhD journey. I am keen to pass on lessons and walk with others so they can go even further and faster.</p><p>I am also excited about making my research operational. I expect I will turn my thesis into a book and integrate the models into platforms so leaders in the field can benefit more broadly. Finally, I look forward to reconnecting with everyone I interviewed and repay them for the time they so graciously provided.</p><p>Thanks to those who have been on the journey with me. I look forward to continuing the conversation.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a47d2f489c8c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>