<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Charles Adams Cogan on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Charles Adams Cogan on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@charlesadamscogan?source=rss-50a1ab437ef5------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 10:56:14 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@charlesadamscogan/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The United Nations Should Be Invited to Help Broker Peace in the Broader West Asia and Northeast…
]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@charlesadamscogan/the-united-nations-should-be-invited-to-help-broker-peace-in-the-broader-west-asia-and-northeast-f3ddfc166b7a?source=rss-50a1ab437ef5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f3ddfc166b7a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[united-nations]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[iran]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[united-states]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[unicef]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[world-health-organization]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Charles Adams Cogan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 26 Sep 2026 03:16:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-26T03:16:13.980Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*GxFZW0n2VsjhKRXk" /><figcaption>West Asia, Northeast Africa, and Their Neighbors</figcaption></figure><p><strong>The United Nations Should Be Invited to Help Broker Peace in the Broader West Asia and Northeast Africa Sub-Region</strong></p><p>In January, American leaders expressed concerns about the safety of the Iranian people as internal protests led to massive repression. In February, the US and Israel began to bomb strategic targets in Iran. They quickly killed several top Iranian leaders and expected the regime to fall. It didn’t. They also accidentally killed little girls at a school near an airbase and plenty of innocent civilians. Then, on April 7, the US president said, “a whole civilization will die tonight, never to be brought back again” on Truth Social.</p><p>Tensions are high in the Gulf of Hormuz, and ceasefire negotiations have so far failed, despite occasional claims that an agreement is near. Gradually, the needs of the Iranian people have become secondary to the need to project military strength. If the desire of the United States government is truly to help the Iranian people and prevent Iran from developing nuclear weapons, bombing is not the only path.</p><p>To be clear, the Iranian regime recently murdered hundreds, if not thousands, of its own citizens and has long supported violent proxies in Lebanon, Syria, Yemen, Syria, and Iraq. Iranian drones supplied to Russia are killing Ukrainians. Iran has the materials and expertise to develop nuclear weapons eventually. However, the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA) was developed through direct negotiations with Iran in 2015 to address this concern. Iran, the United States, and a broad coalition of nations signed the treaty. Regular monitoring showed that Iran was complying until the current president withdrew from the JCPOA in May 2018.</p><p>One of the declared weaknesses of the original JCPOA negotiations is that Iran was allowed access to funds that had been seized during sanctions. The argument is that releasing these funds would allow Iran to invest in its nuclear program. The reality, as is often the case, is more complicated. While the sanctions have increased pressure on the Iranian regime and were one of the causes behind the uprisings that were recently suppressed, the lack of funding has also weakened Iran’s healthcare system, once one of the strongest in the region, leading to unnecessary suffering and deaths among the very populations we claim to want to support. If the monitoring of the nuclear program is allowed by Iran at the same level as in the original JCPOA, this helps to orient the funds toward more basic needs of the Iranian people.</p><p>In a complicated situation like this, an organization that is trusted by both parties is needed. The United Nations, where both President Trump and President Pezeshkian both delivered addresses in late September, is one such organization. If the funds were to be delivered to healthcare, the World Health Organization (WHO) could help. If the funds were to be directed to feeding, housing, and educating Internally Displaced People (IDPs) from Iran to Sudan, the UN High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) and UNICEF could help. If the need were to separate combatants in conflict zones like Gaza, Lebanon, Sudan, and Yemen, then UN Peacekeepers could play a vital role. This list goes on to include the World Food Program (WFP), the Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) and many other UN agencies that can help to support a reset in West Asia and Northeast Africa.</p><p>Diplomats are trained in difficult negotiations. Many years ago, after three years in the Peace Corps, I was a Foreign Language and Area Studies (FLAS) Fellow at Northwestern University, a program developed to ensure that the United States government would always have people with relevant expertise when crises like this emerge. Many former FLAS fellows have gone into the foreign service, and Farsi is a strategic language. The problem is that those diplomats have often been sidelined in favor of high-profile businesspeople with political connections who do not have the training for a complex job with so many human lives at risk. Over the past thirty years, I have followed the careers of many old friends and one of them served for several years as a Conflict Resolution Officer with the UN in Sudan, South Sudan, Ivory Coast, and other hot spots. He read an earlier draft of this essay and returned it with lots of suggestions, corrections, and even some encouragement.</p><p>The time has come for a reset. The United States needs to remember that it is working for the people of Iran and for peace across the region. If we can reengage with the JCPOA and reinforce its operations, that would be a good first step. If that is no longer an option, we should build another strong coalition to negotiate a new treaty. In addition to strict monitoring of the nuclear program, the United States should have open discussions about internal human rights reforms in Iran. Some of the internal conflict was exacerbated by sanctions and while hardliners in the US, Israel, and the Gulf States do not want to ease the sanctions, there are ways of directing these funds to healthcare and other sectors in need of funding. This recalibration will involve reaching out to partners who have worked with the United States in the past. Putting the wellbeing and future of the Iranian people front and center in such talks, the nature of the discussions will change. If the people of Iran sense that the United States government and its partners are working to make their lives better, it may weaken hardliners in the regime who are undermining negotiations. The recent sabotage of peace negotiations by these very hardliners was well-documented in a September 13 opinion piece by Farnaz Fasihi (https://www.nytimes.com/2026/09/13/world/middleeast/iran-hard-liners-sabotaged-peace-deal.html).</p><p>The Iranians are not the only regional power with proxies in conflict zones, as observers to Yemen, Somalia, and Sudan can attest. An Israeli colleague read a draft of this paper and argued that no one can negotiate with the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC), citing Neville Chamberlain in 1938, who gave in to Hitler and allowed the partition of Czechoslovakia. The difficulty is clear, but negotiation is always preferable to violence.</p><p>The negotiations with Iran cannot be held in a vacuum since the activities of other regional powers (Israel, Hezbollah, Hamas, the Gulf States, and other neighbors) need to be considered as a part of any lasting solution. The entire region has become a war zone, and no one wants to be the first to lay down their weapons. There are hardliners throughout the region and in the United States and Israel, who do not wish for lasting peace. The job is to empower those who do want peace and help them to make the case for their own people.</p><p><strong>Now is the Time for a Regional Accord, not Just a One-Off Negotiation with Iran</strong></p><p>I have focused on the Iranian people in this essay because they are often forgotten. While Iranians were dying during the bombing attacks, Israelis and American military and civilians across the region were dying due to Iranian missiles. Over recent months, Lebanese and Palestinians have been dying from Israeli bombs and ground incursions. In Sudan, the Rapid Support Forces (RSF) have been massacring civilians in the Darfur region, with evidence pointing to funding and weaponry from the Gulf States. There is no hierarchy here. Every life is precious, and I do not say this naively.</p><p>Right now, the entire region is in a phase of what psychologists call Amygdala Hijack, when the fight or flight instinct overrules rational thought. I have family in Israel (my father’s side), and since October 7, 2023, they have felt threatened and felt the need to project strength for their own safety. A friend who teaches at my school in Shanghai is Lebanese, and she argues that without Hezbollah, the entire nation of Lebanon would be helpless in the face of Israeli assaults.</p><p>In terms of leadership, Israel’s current governing coalition includes extremist leaders who have no interest in peace. The hardest militants in Iran are equally focused on violent resistance. There are elements in the US government who are comfortable with destroying boats and people in South American waters on the suspicion that they might be drug traffickers. The bombing of Iran was initially conceived as a case of “Epic Fury,” where a surgical bombing campaign would dispose of the regime and allow Israel and the United States government to put a more ‘friendly’ regime in place. At times like this, the work of Yitzhak Rabin and Yasir Arafat in the Oslo Accords (Oslo I 1993, Oslo II 1995) seems like it took place in another world. Their work for peace and a two-state solution for Israeli and Palestinian coexistence has been undermined by extremists on both sides, but the principles are still in place; there are people in each nation who want peace, and there are nations around the world who would be willing to help to make peace a reality.</p><p>It is difficult for the United States government to ask for money or ships and planes to open the Straits of Hormuz because it started the war on its own initiative in partnership with the current Israeli regime. If it were a question of deepening the current negotiations to push for a lasting peace that could allow for gradual disarmament and nuclear guarantees from both Iran and Israel, there would be plenty of interest from allies. A focused program with international support to help the civilian populations throughout the region to rebuild their lives and their communities would be expensive but would cost far less than endless conflict.</p><p>It is not just time for a reset in current negotiations with Iran, it is time for a regional reset to allow the peoples of Iran, Israel, Lebanon, Iraq, Syria, Sudan, the Gulf States, Jordan, and the Palestinian territories to breathe again. Real discussions, real demands, pragmatic concessions, and guarantees. My cousins in Israel would be safer, my friend’s family in Lebanon would be safer, and the world would breathe a sigh of relief. Not everyone would be happy with peace, at least in the short run. Building trust takes time and perseverance. Still, it can be done, and the moment to begin is now.</p><p>At this point in the past, the United Nations would have stepped in to work to help broker a peace agreement. The United States was one of the founders of the United Nations after World War II and has a permanent seat on the Security Council. At the same time, even though the UN General Headquarters is in New York City, the people of the world trust the UN to represent the best interests of the people of the world, not just its elites. At a time when peace talks are in jeopardy, now would be the perfect time for the US and Iran to bring their problems to the United Nations and request assistance in mapping out a path to peace. It would involve serious investment in the UN and yet it is hard to argue that continued conflict does not cost billions of dollars. The choice is now before us. The mark of strong leadership is the ability and confidence to change course when changing circumstances require new approaches.*</p><p>*This essay has been revised since its initial drafting in June 2026 to include the direct role that the United Nations could and should play in bringing peace to a region that has been in turmoil for much too long.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f3ddfc166b7a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[It is Time for a Reset with Iran and Across the Middle East (West Asia)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@charlesadamscogan/it-is-time-for-a-reset-with-iran-and-across-the-middle-east-west-asia-17bd0f4add73?source=rss-50a1ab437ef5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/17bd0f4add73</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Charles Adams Cogan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 12 Jun 2026 01:24:12 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-07-07T22:59:18.238Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*b6DpuoN7mfOHPwTJ.jpg" /><figcaption>A Map of the Middle East (West Asia) and NE Africa for Reference as you read this Essay (and yes, this map is from before South Sudan was born in July 2011)</figcaption></figure><p><strong>It is Time for a Reset with Iran and Across the Middle East (West Asia) and Northeast Africa</strong></p><p>In January, American leaders expressed concerns about the safety of the Iranian people as internal protests led to massive repression. In February, the US and Israel began to bomb strategic targets in Iran. They quickly killed several top Iranian leaders and expected the regime to fall. It didn’t. They also accidentally killed little girls at a school near an airbase and plenty of innocent civilians. Then, on April 7, the US president said, “a whole civilization will die tonight, never to be brought back again” on Truth Social.</p><p>Tensions are high in the Gulf of Hormuz, and ceasefire negotiations have so far failed, despite occasional claims that an agreement is near. Gradually, the needs of the Iranian people have become secondary to the need to project military strength. If the desire of the United States government is truly to help the Iranian people and prevent Iran from developing nuclear weapons, bombing is not the only path.</p><p>To be clear, the Iranian regime recently murdered hundreds, if not thousands, of its own citizens and has long supported violent proxies in Lebanon, Syria, Yemen, and Iraq. Iranian drones supplied to Russia are killing Ukrainians. Iran has the materials and expertise to develop nuclear weapons eventually. However, the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA) was developed through direct negotiations with Iran in 2015 to address this concern. Iran, the United States, and a broad coalition of nations signed the treaty. Regular monitoring showed that Iran was complying until the current US president withdrew from the JCPOA in May 2018.</p><p>One of the declared weaknesses of the original JCPOA negotiations is that Iran was allowed access to funds that had been seized during sanctions. The argument is that releasing these funds would allow Iran to invest in its nuclear program. The reality, as is often the case, is more complicated. While the sanctions have increased pressure on the Iranian regime and were one of the causes behind the uprisings that were recently suppressed, the lack of funding has also weakened Iran’s healthcare system, once one of the strongest in the region, leading to unnecessary suffering and deaths among the very populations we claim to want to support. If the monitoring of the nuclear program is allowed by Iran at the same level as in the original JCPOA, this helps to orient the funds toward the more basic needs of the Iranian people.</p><p>Diplomats are trained in difficult negotiations. Many years ago, after three years in the Peace Corps, I was a Foreign Language and Area Studies (FLAS) Fellow at Northwestern University, a program developed to ensure that the United States government would always have people with relevant expertise when crises like this emerge. Many former FLAS fellows have gone into the foreign service, and Farsi is a strategic language. The problem is that those diplomats have often been sidelined in favor of high-profile businesspeople with political connections who do not have the training for a complex job with so many human lives at risk.</p><p>The time has come for a reset. The United States needs to remember that it is working for the people of Iran and for peace across the region. If we can re-engage with the JCPOA and reinforce its operations, that would be a good first step. If that is no longer an option, we should build another strong coalition to negotiate a new treaty. In addition to strict monitoring of the nuclear program, the United States should have open discussions about internal human rights reforms in Iran. Some of the internal conflict was exacerbated by sanctions, and while hardliners in the US, Israel, and the Gulf States do not want to ease the sanctions, there are ways of directing these funds to healthcare and other sectors in need of funding. This recalibration will involve reaching out to partners who have worked with the United States in the past. Putting the well-being and future of the Iranian people front and center in such talks, the nature of the discussions will change. If the people of Iran sense that the United States government and its partners are working to make their lives better, it may weaken hardliners in the regime who are undermining negotiations.</p><p>The Iranians are not the only regional power with proxies in conflict zones, as observers to Yemen, Somalia, and Sudan can attest. An Israeli colleague read a draft of this paper and argued that no one can negotiate with the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC), citing Neville Chamberlain in 1938, who gave in to Hitler and allowed the partition of Czechoslovakia. The difficulty is clear, but negotiation is always preferable to violence.</p><p>The negotiations with Iran cannot be held in a vacuum since the activities of other regional powers (Israel, Hezbollah, Hamas, the Gulf States, and other neighbors) need to be considered as a part of any lasting solution. The entire region has become a war zone, and no one wants to be the first to lay down their weapons. There are hardliners throughout the region and in the United States and Israel who do not wish for lasting peace. The job is to empower those who do want peace and help them to make the case to their own people.</p><p><strong>Now is the Time for a Regional Accord, not Just a One-Off Negotiation with Iran</strong></p><p>I have focused on the Iranian people in this essay because they are often forgotten. While Iranians were dying during the bombing attacks, Israelis and American military and civilians across the region were dying due to Iranian missiles. Over recent months, Lebanese and Palestinians have been dying from Israeli bombs and ground incursions. In Sudan, the Rapid Support Forces (RSF) have been massacring civilians in the Darfur region, with evidence pointing directly to funding and weaponry from the Gulf States. There is no hierarchy here. Every life is precious, and I do not say this naively.</p><p>Right now, the entire region is in a phase of what psychologists call Amygdala Hijack, when the fight or flight instinct overrules rational thought. I have family in Israel (my father’s side), and since October 7, 2023, they have felt threatened and felt the need to project strength for their own safety. A friend who teaches at my school in Shanghai is Lebanese, and she argues that without Hezbollah, the entire nation of Lebanon would be helpless in the face of Israeli assaults.</p><p>In terms of leadership, Israel’s current governing coalition includes extremist leaders who have no interest in peace. The hardest militants in Iran are equally focused on violent resistance. There are elements in the US government who are comfortable with destroying boats in South American waters on the suspicion that they might be drug traffickers. The bombing of Iran was initially conceived as a case of “Epic Fury,” where a surgical bombing campaign would dispose of the regime and allow Israel and the United States government to put a more ‘friendly’ regime in place. At times like this, the work of Yitzhak Rabin and Yasir Arafat in the Oslo Accords (Oslo I 1993, Oslo II 1995) seems like it took place in another world. Their work for peace and a two-state solution for Israeli and Palestinian coexistence has been undermined by extremists on both sides, but the principles are still in place; there are people in each nation who want peace, and there are nations around the world who would be willing to help to make peace a reality.</p><p><strong>Alliances are the Key</strong></p><p>It is difficult for the United States government to ask for money or ships and planes to open the Straits of Hormuz because it started the war on its own initiative in partnership with the current Israeli regime. If it were a question of deepening the current negotiations to push for a lasting peace that could allow for gradual disarmament and nuclear guarantees from both Iran and Israel, there would be plenty of interest from allies. A focused program with international support to help the civilian populations throughout the region to rebuild their lives and their communities would be expensive, but it would cost far less than endless conflict.</p><p>It is not just time for a reset in current negotiations with Iran, it is time for a regional reset to allow the peoples of Iran, Israel, Lebanon, Iraq, Syria, Sudan, the Gulf States, Jordan, and the Palestinian territories to breathe again. Real discussions, real demands, pragmatic concessions, and guarantees. My cousins in Israel would be safer, my friend’s family in Lebanon would be safer, and the world would breathe a sigh of relief. Not everyone would be happy with peace, at least in the short run. Building trust takes time and perseverance. Still, it can be done, and the moment to begin is now.</p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p>Charles Adams Cogan is a former Peace Corps Volunteer, Foreign Language and Area Studies (FLAS) Fellow, and Fulbright Scholar. He studied and taught African, Middle Eastern, World, and US Immigration History while a graduate student at Northwestern before moving into a career in international undergraduate admissions. He is an active Rotarian, a member of the board of directors of the United Nations Association of Minnesota, served for many years as a part of the West Africa Country Specialist Team of Amnesty International USA, and is in Shanghai for the academic year.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=17bd0f4add73" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Should the US Really Want to Bomb Iran into the Stone Age?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@charlesadamscogan/should-the-us-really-want-to-bomb-iran-into-the-stone-age-de7a8774645e?source=rss-50a1ab437ef5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/de7a8774645e</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Charles Adams Cogan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 21 Apr 2026 04:26:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-05-04T01:19:08.433Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>First, a bit of background . . . feel free to come back to it if you’d like to continue straight to my essay.</p><p><strong>The Cyrus Cylinder and Ancient Persia: A New Beginning</strong></p><p><strong>On loan from the British Museum, <em>The Cyrus Cylinder and Ancient Persia: A New Beginning</em> concludes its U.S. tour with a nine-week presentation at the Getty Villa. Found at Babylon in 1879, the Cyrus Cylinder is among the most celebrated discoveries from the ancient world, with a legacy that resounds to this day.</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/0*a8AmR69r-ELpDATG.jpg" /></figure><p>The Cyrus Cylinder, Achaemenid, after 539 B.C. Terracotta, 22.9 x 10 cm. Image courtesy of and © The Trustees of the British Museum (2013). All rights reserved</p><p><a href="https://www.getty.edu/art/exhibitions/cyrus_cylinder/">The Cyrus Cylinder and Ancient Persia: A New Beginning (Getty Villa Exhibitions)</a></p><h3><strong>Should the United States Really Want to Bomb Iran into the Stone Age?</strong></h3><p>Two weeks ago, I was walking to a Rotary Club of Shanghai meeting when a security guard waved us to the other side of the road. We were approaching the US Consulate in Shanghai. One hundred meters down the road, we were able to cross back. It dawned on me that the security might be due to the war against Iran and the general conflagration across West Asia, including continued violence in Gaza and Lebanon. As we continued, I looked up, and the next consulate was the Islamic Republic of Iran. Seeing the two diplomatic outposts so close together made me sad. Let me explain.</p><p>Our president’s declaration that Iran needed to meet all our demands immediately or the world would see the destruction of a civilization made me wonder how much he knows about Iran. Which civilization? The one that brought the Zoroastrian focus of good and evil, light and darkness, and even the final judgement into Achaemenian Persia, to be embedded in Judaism, Christianity, Islam, Buddhism, and in our daily lives? Think about a one true God (Ahura Mazda) and his heavenly host of Angels, locked in an eternal battle with the forces of evil, led by Satan (Ahriman) and his army of Demons. Sound familiar? The Persians freed the Jews from their Babylonian captivity and then ruled the region for more than two centuries, respecting the religious traditions of their subject peoples. Then they preserved the holy message of Zarathustra during long years of Hellenistic (Greek) occupation (side-by-side with Jews who were doing the same) after the conquests of Alexander the Great. Are we talking about the civilization that fought Rome to a standstill for over seven hundred years during both Parthian and Sasanian regimes? Or perhaps the civilization that flourished during the Abbasid Caliphate, when the learning of Greece and Rome was preserved, and the writings of Ferdowsi and Rumi were shared with humanity?</p><p>In the nineteenth century, it was an Iranian, Baha’u’llah, who drew on older faiths in the region and ancient prophesies to elaborate the inclusive and tolerant Baha’i faith. Iran sponsored more students to the US than any other nation in the 1970s, some of whom stayed here after the revolution. Others returned to Iran, often nurturing a love for this country despite the Islamic Republic’s anti-US rhetoric. Are they the people we want to bomb?</p><p>Living in Shanghai for the year has given me time to re-read the books that I loved as a graduate student thirty years ago. One is <strong>The Mantle of the Prophet</strong> by Roy Mottahedeh, which navigates more than two thousand years of Iranian history and then focuses on the unrest and alienation that led to the fall of the last Shah and the rise of the Islamic Republic. The past forty-seven years have been difficult for Iran and its people, from the war with Iraq to the upheaval of the entire region during the US wars with Iraq and Afghanistan, to the current bombing of the nation, civilian casualties, and the violent counterattack unleashed by Iranian forces.</p><p>The current Iranian regime is not the first theocracy in its history. The Lebanese author Amin Malouf wrote a beautiful book entitled <strong>Gardens of Light</strong> about the life of Mani (of the Manichaeans). Many of the themes would be familiar to modern residents of Iran and the USA. The Sasanian regime included hardline Zoroastrian priests who pushed for religious purity and their own power. Shapur was wise enough to channel this hardline energy to military success, but powerful enough to accept and embrace Mani, who had traveled to what is now Pakistan, India, and Afghanistan and learned much along the way. When Shapur died, so did Mani, as the priesthood exerted supremacy, much in the same way that secular allies of the mullahs were marginalized and often killed soon after the revolution forty-seven years ago. Is there a universal lesson about the need to keep religion out of politics here? The fact that Lebanon itself is now under attack and that hardline Israelis, hardline Iranians, hardline Americans, and their hardline Gulf allies are all eager for war makes it hard to see hope for the people of Iran, the people of Lebanon, the people of Gaza, and the people of Israel itself.</p><p>Still, the juxtaposition of the American and Iranian consulates reminded me that diplomacy remains an option, and both nations have people trained in difficult negotiations. The announcement of a two-week ceasefire is a start. Now, it’s time to let the diplomats do their job.</p><p><strong>Addendum:</strong> The day after I wrote this, I learned that Israel had refused to join the ceasefire and would continue to attack Lebanon. My father’s side of the family is Jewish. I have Israeli cousins. I even read Exodus (Leon Uris) as a teenager and fell in love with the history. Still, when the head of our English department in Shanghai let us know yesterday that her neighborhood in Lebanon had been bombed, with hundreds dead and others still buried under the rubble, I could not see the good in that attack. She and her family are Maronite Christians, and this just shows the price we pay when we substitute violence for diplomacy. Is her neighborhood ‘collateral damage’? Muslims, Christians, and Jews, and many other minority religions, have lived side-by-side in Lebanon for centuries. Has it always been easy? Not at all, and Lebanon has its own homegrown extremists. Can we bomb them all into oblivion without creating a new generation of people who hate Israel because they lost family members to bombings? I do not think so. We should know better after almost 250 years of experience, but Iranians can look back at 2,500 years of rich history, and their current government is a terrible role model. That does not mean that we cannot find a way back from the abyss and negotiate effectively. Diplomats have the training; most real estate developers do not.</p><ul><li>Charles Adams Cogan is a former Peace Corps Volunteer (Togo), Foreign Language and Area Studies (FLAS) Fellow, Fulbright Scholar, and Member of the Board of Directors of the United Nations Association of Minnesota. After the Peace Corps, he studied African and Middle Eastern History at Northwestern University. He taught African, Asian, World, and US Immigration History at colleges and universities in the Chicago area for eight years before beginning a career in admissions. He is an active Rotarian and served for seventeen years as the director of international admissions at Carleton College in Northfield, Minnesota. He is currently in Shanghai for the academic year.</li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=de7a8774645e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Tale of Two Sectors]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@charlesadamscogan/a-tale-of-two-sectors-c8757f41993c?source=rss-50a1ab437ef5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c8757f41993c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[history-of-immigration]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[manufacturing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[respect]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[immigration]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Charles Adams Cogan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 23 Oct 2025 06:55:16 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-10-23T06:55:16.432Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>A Tale of Two Sectors</strong></p><p>Last year, due to declining demographics, my hometown’s public schools cut down their global language offerings at the Middle School, leaving the high school French position so truncated that the teacher of 29 years had no choice but to leave for a new job. French was about to be dropped from the curriculum when I stepped in to teach for the year on a part-time contract with no insurance or benefits. Teaching is tough work, but it is also very rewarding. Fortunately, the high school was able to hire a licensed teacher with both French and English certifications for this year, and they developed a hybrid position for her that allowed for a full-time contract. These are challenging times for many school districts as the Baby Boomers retire, their children grow up and have fewer children, and schools adjust to smaller enrollments. This is also leading to a labor shortage as fewer students graduate to move into manufacturing. However, unlike the education sector, the manufacturing sector is booming, at least for now. In search of a full-time job that pays a living wage and includes full benefits, I decided to follow in the footsteps of my immigrant grandfather and enter the thriving world of manufacturing.</p><p>When my paternal grandfather arrived in the United States from Belarus in 1910, he immediately took a factory job to support his family. He and his siblings shared housing and worked grueling hours. Despite these hardships, my grandfather pursued night courses in dentistry at Brooklyn College, ultimately earning his degree in 1918. Shortly thereafter, he married my grandmother, whose family hailed from Poland. They had two children: my Aunt Louise and my father, Max Cogan.</p><p>My great-grandmother (grandmother’s mother) was a midwife. She never became fluent in English, living as she did in a neighborhood where Russian and Yiddish were the dominant languages. My father, on the other hand, learned very little of either language. His parents, determined that he and Louise should excel in American schools, prioritized English fluency. Their efforts paid off.</p><p>It is often said that America is a nation of immigrants. Thomas Sowell’s <em>Ethnic America</em>, published during the Reagan years, chronicles the waves of migration that have shaped this country over the past four centuries. Sowell observed recurring patterns as newcomers moved into established neighborhoods, displacing earlier residents who often relocated to the suburbs. He also noted the hostility faced by each new group — hostility often compounded by differences in religion, language, and customs. I never met my father’s parents, as they both died in the 1940s, but I remember family members of their generation recounting tales of struggle and perseverance.</p><p>At a recent teaching workshop hosted by Professor Anton Treuer of Bemidji State University, I learned that many Native American nations can document at least twenty thousand years of residency on this continent, so calling them immigrants would be a stretch. However, the story of migration is not unique to those arriving from abroad. Isabel Wilkerson’s <em>The Warmth of Other Suns</em> captures the internal Great Migration of Black Americans from the Jim Crow South to northern cities, also in response to a need for workers. Overt racism often (not always) gave way to subtler forms of exclusion, such as redlining that limited housing opportunities in many neighborhoods. Similarly, David Treuer’s <em>The Heartbeat of Wounded Knee</em> documents the forced relocations imposed on Native American nations, displacements that began in the seventeenth century and continued well into the nineteenth. Even today, leaving what is familiar for a new and often inhospitable setting remains a central theme in the American experience.</p><p>I have reflected on these patterns while working in a factory in southeastern Minnesota. The factory floor, where many of my coworkers are first-generation immigrants, has been a surprising classroom. Here, I have learned Somali and Swahili phrases, improved my Spanish, and developed a taste for tamales and East African sambusas, shared generously during break time. Working side by side with Muslim colleagues through the entire Ramadan season this year taught me lessons in self-discipline and endurance. My colleagues, speaking English as a second or even third language, have mentored me patiently. Some are much younger than I am, often working their way through college; others have children the same age as mine. During breaks, we swap stories — of children excelling in school, of jobs in the same factory taken up by the next generation. The adage that the first generation does the backbreaking work so the next can thrive feels alive and tangible here.</p><p>Not everyone on the factory floor is a recent immigrant. Some of my coworkers trace their roots in the U.S. back generations, while others are the children or grandchildren of immigrants. The pay and benefits are competitive, and several of my coworkers, having joined right out of high school, have risen through the ranks to hold management positions. The diversity and camaraderie I see every day are a testament to what America has always been: a tapestry of hard work, aspiration, and resilience.</p><p>As a former Peace Corps volunteer in Togo, I know what it feels like to be the one person in the room who cannot follow the conversation. My wife, an immigrant herself, worked her way through a GED, community college, and eventually nursing school at the University of Saint Catherine to become a registered nurse. But beyond individual empathy, I have come to see that working together fosters understanding. When you learn someone’s language, hear about their children, and share the rhythms of daily labor, stereotypes fade.</p><p>The immigrant experience has always been central to the story of America, with each generation writing a new chapter. Today’s factory floors and classrooms are no different. The hard work, determination, and sacrifices of immigrant families are a cornerstone of our national narrative, and their contributions — past and present — deserve both recognition and respect. When we listen to the voices of immigrants and those who work alongside them, we hear not just their stories but the echoes of America’s enduring promise.</p><p>Having worked in the Education sector, I saw the challenges of declining enrollment numbers up close. For now, the manufacturing sector is very strong and in need of more workers. Hopefully, this can be maintained. Instead of speaking harshly of immigrants like the untrue stories that were circulated about the Haitian workers in Springfield, Ohio, during the last election, we should look at our own history and be grateful that America still attracts immigrants from across the globe. Can we do a better job of regulating immigration? Of course, we can. The elections are over, and the need for divisive scapegoating is past. We should approach this as a bipartisan and constructive process that is essential to this nation’s future.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c8757f41993c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Finding the Indo-Iranian Yazata Mithra in Duino, Italy]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@charlesadamscogan/finding-mithra-in-duino-italy-96dc5f966d40?source=rss-50a1ab437ef5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/96dc5f966d40</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[iran]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[italy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[world-religion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ancient-rome]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ancient-history]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Charles Adams Cogan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 20 Feb 2024 00:20:59 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-10-23T07:12:51.603Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Points of Overlap: Finding the Ancient Iranian Yazata Mithra in Duino, Italy</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*nr0iDJKg6WsFnye_zwKjbQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Photo attributed to Daniele Iurissevich</p><p>For several years, while studying the links between the Roman Mithraic Mysteries and their distant Iranian origins, I had heard of the Mithraem in Duino, Italy. During World War I, aviators flying over the region spotted a large mound on a hill above the town. Duino, about twenty miles from Trieste, was in the borderland region between Italy and Austria-Hungary. If you read Hemingway’s <strong>Farewell to Arms</strong>, you hear of neighboring cities like Monfalcone, just a few miles away. The museum in Monfalcone now houses the Mithraic relics discovered when that large mound near Duino was excavated shortly after the war.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/300/0*OWFJt3fk-0-N9fTQ.jpg" /><figcaption>Castello di Duino</figcaption></figure><p>Life sometimes brings us to places of overlap. What brought me to Duino during the years 2003 to 2017 was the United World College (UWC) of the Adriatic in Duino, located in a part of a castle that once hosted famous classical musicians and even Mark Twain during his European travels. As an admissions officer, I made regular visits to interview students from across the globe who had come to Duino to follow a two-year International Baccalaureate program. Although there were always students from Africa and Latin America, the location of this particular UWC was significant because it was in a contested territory that was neither Austrian nor Italian after WW II. Many of the residents are of Slovenian origin, though everyone speaks Italian. A good number of the students at the UWC of the Adriatic came and still come from Eastern and Central Europe and the Central Asian nations of the former USSR. The goal is to bring students from nations that are sometimes in conflict together for two years to learn about each others’ countries, cultures, and histories to educate future leaders who can find common ground.</p><p>Maria Rainier Rilke also wrote a collection of mystical poetry about Duino, <strong>The Duino Elegies. At that time, he was </strong>a guest of the family that owned the castle in the early twentieth century. There is a wooded area near the castle dedicated to Rilke and named “The Rilke Walk”. During WWI, there were dugout caves along the hills where batteries of cannons were hidden to protect the coast. There are beautiful paths with views of the castle.</p><p>Faculty at the UWC told me that the Mithraeum of Duino was within walking distance and they encouraged me to reach out to an Egyptian math teacher who could guide me to the temple. One year followed the next and my visits never seemed to align with the teacher’s availability. One day, I asked someone to draw me a map so that I could make the effort on my own. I had interviews scheduled to begin at 10 a.m. that day, so I rose before dawn for an early start. The early part of the walk was quite scenic, traveling through the Rilke walk paths. Then, I crossed the highway and began to climb up the nearest hill. It was still dark and rather foggy and more than a bit spooky. I had heard stories of Satanic cults who had used the Mithraeum for their rituals, ironic since Mithra was the god (Yazata = Archangel) of goodness, light, and integrity in the Iranian world. Still, he would have been viewed as a pagan god by Christians.</p><p>My map led me to the railroad tracks at the top of the hill and I followed an arrow to the left, and followed the tracks for about a kilometer, looking to my left for signs of the Mithraeum. I began to have some doubts about who and what I would find there. It was still only half-light and gloomy and foggy and I wondered if I would have the courage to enter the temple and go underground. Many of the original artifacts are now housed at the museum in Monfalcone, but replicas were made and left in their place, so the carved stones with their Latin inscriptions are still to be seen. When I finally found the temple, I climbed down from the railroad tracks and approached the opening of the underground cave. Everything seemed very quiet and calm. I stood by the entrance for a bit to think about whether now would be a good time to check the box and declare victory, since entering an isolated temple in semi-darkness was not comfortable. In the distance, I heard voices approaching. Within a couple of minutes, a large group of Italian-speaking tourists from Argentina arrived with their tour guide. They had just visited the old church, San Giovanni de Duino, and were now coming to tour the Mithraeum. I asked the tour guide if I could come inside with the group, and he was very gracious. It was a wonderful tour and since my French is good and I had visited Italy many times, I could follow part of his commentary.</p><p>The Roman Cult of Mithras became an imperial cult of the Invincible Sun (Sol Invictus) at about the same time that Christianity began to gain converts in Rome. The story of its origins in the Persian-Armenian world and its arrival in Rome when the empire grew and faced that of the Parthians in what is now Turkey, Syria, Iraq, and parts of Iran has been hotly debated. The cult was limited only to men and was popular among the Roman armies. There is a beautiful poem in Rudyard Kipling’s <strong>Puck of Pook Hill </strong>entitled “A Song to Mithras” that captures some of the spirits of the time.</p><pre>Mithras, God of the Morning, our trumpets waken the Wall! <br>&#39; Rome is above the Nations, but Thou art over all!&#39; <br>Now as the names are answered, and the guards are marched away,<br>Mithras, also a soldier, give us strength for the day!<br><br>Mithras, God of the Noontide, the heather swims in the heat,<br>Our helmets scorch our foreheads ; our sandals burn our feet.<br>Now in the ungirt hour; now ere we blink and drowse,<br>Mithras, also a soldier, keep us true to our vows !<br><br>Mithras, God of the Sunset, low on the Western main,<br>Thou descending immortal, immortal to rise again ! <br>Now when the watch is ended, now when the wine is drawn,<br>Mithras, also a soldier, keep us pure till the dawn!<br><br>Mithras, God of the Midnight, here where the great bull dies,<br>Look on Thy children in darkness. Oh take our sacrifice !<br>Many roads Thou hast fashioned: all of them lead to the Light,<br>Mithras, also a soldier, teach us to die aright! * (please see citation below)</pre><p>The song itself is a creation of Kipling’s mind and pen, since the mysteries of Mithras were carefully guarded, and only glimpses can be pieced together now from secondary sources. One of the central themes of the cult is the “Tauroctony,” where Mithras slays the Bull to release the bounty of the earth. The scene appears in many Mithraea, and the quality of the artwork ranges from quite rudimentary to some very elaborate and beautiful depictions in Mithraea in larger cities where better artists were available.</p><p>As the tour guide led us through the temple in semi-darkness, it was possible to imagine an assembly of followers in this space two thousand years earlier. In listening to the tour guide&#39;s narrative, I felt that I recognized the broad outlines of the story. Mithras wanted to provide for humanity. To do so, he needed to make an ultimate sacrifice. Mithras was a very powerful god, and his best friend was the Bull in the depictions. They had been through many adventures together. Mithras had no choice. To provide humanity with the bounty to thrive, he had to sacrifice his oldest and dearest friend, the Bull. Whether this mirrored the mythical battle between the Sun and the Moon is the object of many debates, even today. What came through very clearly in the tour guide’s talk was that Mithras could only assure a better future for mankind by sacrificing what was dearest to him.**</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*sWXoep8zK26MeLiC.jpg" /><figcaption><em>CIMRM</em> 641: Tauroctony scene on side A of a two-sided Roman bas-relief. 2nd or 3rd century, found at <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fiano_Romano">Fiano Romano</a>, near <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rome">Rome</a>, now on display in the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Louvre">Louvre</a>. In the upper corners are <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helios">Helios</a> with the raven, and <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Selene">Luna</a>.</figcaption></figure><p>Walking back after the tour, I wondered if the tour guide was inspired by the story of Abraham and Isaac. Or was the broader interpretation even more Christian, that God sacrificed what was dearest to him for the good of humanity? How much of this interpretation was inspired by the fact that the tour guide was a Christian, coming directly from the Church of San Giovanni de Duino? Did he intentionally use this metaphor because it would resonate with his tour group, who were all Italian-speaking Christians? For that matter, do our attempts to understand the Roman Cult of Mithras reflect a similar quest to find something familiar in a set of mysteries that may be very unfamiliar? While the Roman Cult of Mithras was cloaked in secrecy, the Iranian Yazata Mithra had been well-known in the region since the time of the Achaemenian Persians, led by Cyrus the Great in the sixth century BCE (see “The Strange Tale of How We Came to See The World as an Eternal Battle Between Good and Evil”, also on Medium).</p><p>Having studied the Mithraic Mysteries for many years as a part of a broader study of Zoroastrianism and its influence on Judaism, Buddhism, Christianity, Manichaeism, Yazidism, and Islam, I still wrestle with these questions. At the same time, I’m grateful that the tour guide arrived in time to prevent me from giving up and heading home without ever exploring the interior of the Mithraeum of Duino. When I attend the annual Diwali celebration at Carleton College in Northfield, Minnesota, the story is of the eternal conquest of light over darkness. The Gods of the Rig Veda are often called Indo-Iranian Gods, and the name Mithra (Mitra-Varuna) figures prominently in the Rig Veda. As we navigate life, we are usually tempted to focus on what differentiates us from others. If we look deep within ourselves, perhaps there’s room to reflect on the deep connections we share, the points of overlap.</p><p><strong>A Reflection:</strong></p><p>As I hurried back to the United World College, I looked at the roster and realized that my first student was from Iran, having traveled to Duino to spend two years at the United World College. One of her favorite activities at the UWC was working with students from across the Middle East and Central Asia to put on a big Nowruz party in the spring for the whole student body, faculty, and staff. Nowruz is a tradition that long predates Islam and is still a deep part of the regional culture of nations with historical ties to Persia. Almost seventeen hundred years after the Mithraeum of Duino was abandoned, the town is still a point of overlap.</p><ul><li>A Song to Mithras</li><li><a href="https://www.kiplingsociety.co.uk/poem/poems_mithras.htm">https://www.kiplingsociety.co.uk/poem/poems_mithras.htm</a></li></ul><p>Hymn of the XXX Legion: circa A.D. 350</p><p>“On the Great Wall” <em>Puck of Pook’s Hill</em></p><p>Rudyard Kipling</p><p>**Having lived in Minnesota for almost a quarter of a century, I thought of Paul Bunyan, the legendary lumberjack. I imagined his agony if he were told he needed to sacrifice Babe the Blue Ox for the greater good.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=96dc5f966d40" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Where Have All the Experts Gone?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@charlesadamscogan/part-three-of-three-of-an-extended-reflection-on-why-human-beings-can-be-motivated-to-kill-each-961a3960711f?source=rss-50a1ab437ef5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/961a3960711f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[doc-savage]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[afghanistan]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[iraq]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[war]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ukraine]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Charles Adams Cogan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 02 Aug 2023 14:42:27 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-08-30T07:49:39.493Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/681/0*WzAdRSMc_I3mx4eA" /></figure><p>Part Three: Where have all the Experts Gone? Or, Where <strong>is Doc Savage When You Need Him?</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/243/1*-37WYerPF5BOGjsltBRG2g.jpeg" /><figcaption>Doc Savage and his brilliant associates are here to save the day!</figcaption></figure><p>In the 1930s, another time when Americans were feeling uncertain and over-extended, a pulp superhero was hand-crafted to lift our spirits and give young Americans a sense of purpose. Clark Savage, Jr., and his five assistants were all mental marvels and spent their lives fighting evil wherever it appeared. All through the Great Depression and World War II, they saved the world countless times. As a child, I was always amazed that wherever they landed, Doc Savage, fortunately, had perfect fluency in the local language and understood the local culture. When I left for the Peace Corps in 1983 (in the middle of another tough economic time) I was pretty sure I was up to the job and would be fluent in all of the necessary languages in a few months. Three years later, I emerged with a working knowledge of a few African languages, but it wasn’t easy and it wasn’t smooth sailing. This made me particularly appreciative when I read <strong>Three Cups of Tea</strong> by Greg Mortenson and David Oliver Relin. I could empathize as Greg Mortenson struggled in his early months and even years of work in the mountainous regions of Pakistan and later Afghanistan, facing new challenges each time he went to a new village or crossed a linguistic boundary. Though it took him quite some time, it was exciting to see the momentum and team of co-workers that Mortenson gradually was able to build, with the core message being that you cannot move into a community and take over, you have to get to know people and work with them. I am not his publicist so I won’t go into the whole meaning of the book’s title, but it did raise a question in my mind: what kind of training our troops are getting as they move into a new phase of operations in Afghanistan? (And yes, this paragraph was written before Mortenson’s legacy was criticized in the press. I believe that the learning journey that is described in <em>Three Cups of Tea</em> has universal value and I still value what Mortenson worked to do. If he had been lucky enough to have strong organizational partners back home, like Dr. Paul Farmer from<em> Mountains Beyond Mountains</em>, he might not have faced those challenges).</p><p><strong>What kind of training is needed when we work far beyond our comfort zones?</strong></p><p>Since two heads are usually better than one, especially when one of them is wiser than your own, I showed this “final” draft to a Northfield neighbor, Robert Flaten, who served as a diplomat in the region for many years before becoming the US Ambassador to Rwanda in the early 1990s. He had a few comments to share, but one, in particular, caught my attention. In discussing recent developments and our new mission, with a larger number of troops and specialists and a renewed and revised mandate, he said that “We don’t even have a few dozen diplomats trained to do what 100,000 soldiers are supposed to do in Afghanistan. Some of these guys and gals are really good, but they have little training in the language and culture. Nevertheless, the Afghans mostly like them. With the US there for eight years, there are no refugees leaving the country; after a couple of years of Soviet occupation, over five million Afghans fled. They know the difference between our presence and the Soviet occupation”.</p><p><strong>The Foreign Language and Area Studies (FLAS) Program: Where have all the experts gone?</strong></p><p>In this light, it seems like the challenge of staffing is closely linked to that of training. We will now have more feet on the ground, but we need to provide language and cultural training to make our forces as effective as possible. Over a month ago, Bob Herbert wrote a column in the New York Times that was very critical of our decision to increase staffing in Afghanistan (Dec. 7, 2009). In it, he mentioned a conversation with a Columbia University student who was enthusiastic about our expanded plans in Afghanistan but had no plans to go himself. When I was leaving the Peace Corps in 1986, I was able to enroll at Northwestern University in a Ph.D. program in African and Middle Eastern History thanks to a grant from the Department of Education’s Foreign Language and Area Studies (FLAS) Fellowship program. The idea was that the United States needed to build a cadre of people with knowledge of “strategic” languages, cultures, and histories. My studies focused on the Hausa language of Nigeria, Niger, and neighboring countries and African History, with a secondary focus on Middle Eastern history. This knowledge might or might not be of use right now (I recently published an opinion piece relating to the recent coup in Niger and uploaded it to Medium afterwards), but many American educators have very relevant language and cultural expertise for work in West and Central Asia, including Afghanistan. There are plenty of former FLAS fellows across the academic world and in a variety of other fields with a deep knowledge of the region. The problem is that there is not really any reliable way for former FLAS fellows to be located and their expertise tapped into, even for an important and worthy cause like helping Afghanistan to find peace and prosperity again. The same can be said for other regions of the world, where we have trained experts and rarely use them.</p><p>There are reasons for this disconnect, including the fact that many academics are not completely comfortable with the kind of military mission that is underway, but if we want to mobilize all of our national resources to increase our chances of success, we’ll need to find more experts and ask them to help. For that matter, generations of Fulbright Scholars and others who have benefitted from government funding for their education might also be willing and even eager to lend a hand, if they truly believed that this is a new kind of effort, a real commitment to building a better future for a country that has suffered far too much, partly due to our own inconsistent interventions during recent history. In the process, the outcome of the effort might be positively impacted by drawing on this pool of experienced and educated people, who have rarely been asked to do anything in return for all of the support that was provided for their own studies.</p><p>Last but not least, there is another source of expertise that we’re already consulting, Afghans themselves. As Ambassador Flaten said at the end of our conversation, “Americans like to be in control, and Afghan methods of negotiation will be bewildering to many of us. But we must let them take the lead. Can we accept being just referees?”</p><p>I think we can and I think we should, but please don’t underestimate the need for plenty of training if you want the job done right. We cannot be naïve and there’s no use pretending that the mission of the military can be as simple as that of Peace Corps volunteers and Fulbright Scholars. An Iraq War veteran, Gunnar Swanson, has recently completed a 1,000 Mile “Soldier’s Walk for Peace”, beginning in Texas and ending his walk in Northfield, Minnesota. In explaining why he wants to commit himself to making a positive difference in the lives of children in Iraq and Afghanistan, he explained that during the most violent period of the war in Iraq, a terrible thing happened. The children in the communities where they were stationed, who had often been their only friends and were willing to bring them cold water and help them to feel wanted in a faraway land, were suddenly being used by extremists as weapons, forced or convinced to carry bombs in their clothing since the extremists knew that they could get closer to the soldiers because of the relationship of trust. He remembers vividly the time when they received orders that no children could be allowed to approach too closely and he remembers how it felt to have to point their guns at the same children who had made them feel good about their mission to begin with. These are difficult decisions and in periods of extreme conflict, it’s hard to imagine not having to create a periphery that keeps out friends and foes alike, since it’s impossible to be sure who is who.</p><p>Our goal at present is clearly to move the situation in Afghanistan to a new point, where we can begin to reach out to communities and become actively involved in rebuilding the country, through a combination of military force, diplomacy, and community development. This is a complex mission, one which will have to be carried out in close cooperation with Afghans across the country, using different approaches that can be effective from one community to the next depending on the local conditions. With the proper staffing and training and attitude, I join many other Americans in hoping that this effort can be successful and that Americans will eventually be able to leave Afghanistan and leave on good terms while maintaining the kind of ongoing relationship that should exist between all the members of the United Nations. Unlike the British and other would-be conquerors of the past 2,500 years, I do truly believe that our long-term goal is not to set up shop as the latest imperial overlord. Instead, we truly do want to help Afghanistan get back on its feet and then withdraw, perhaps approaching the beauty and simplicity of the proclamation of Cyrus the Great so many long centuries ago. This is probably too idealistic, but idealism combined with pragmatism can be a powerful combination.</p><p><strong>Epilogue:</strong></p><p>This paper was written over a period of fifteen years and reads like a series of shorter essays. The conditions on the ground shifted significantly when the Islamic State rose in parts of Iraq and Syria and the world’s attention shifted away from Afghanistan to Southwest Asia. In 2021, in keeping with the terms negotiated under the previous administration (with the Afghan government not represented at the negotiating table) the United States withdrew from Afghanistan and the scenes of disorder and despair at the airport in Kabul were difficult to watch. In the past eighteen months, the focus has shifted again, now to Ukraine and the Russian attempts to overrun the country and the surprising success of the Ukrainians in holding their own on the battlefield. Meanwhile, conditions in Afghanistan have deteriorated and the Taliban have struggled to provide basic services to the Afghan people. Much of this was far in the future when this paper was begun. However, the themes of Good vs. Evil and Empire vs. Democracy and Military Power vs. Spiritual Power are still playing themselves out in real time with a devastating impact on people’s lives.</p><p>There is a powerful song by the French/Celtic/Hip Hop band, Manau. The title, “L’avenir est-il un long passe?” is telling. The song begins in the trenches in 1917 with a French soldier who is preparing to run to certain death as they attack an enemy position. He fixes a bayonet onto his gun, though he knows they will have no chance of reaching the Germans for hand-to-hand combat since the German position is armed with machine guns that will cut them down before they can cross the field. The next sequence is about a French Resistance fighter in 1944 who knows he will die when he blows up a bridge to stop a German train. The next scene asks the question, why do men give their lives for a cause that is beyond their reach? And is the future fated to be a continuous replay of the same deadly conflicts? (<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XojzxJSznEU">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XojzxJSznEU</a>)</p><p>No sooner had the United States and NATO pulled out of Afghanistan than the conflict between Russia and Ukraine intensified. Are we really fighting an eternal battle against the forces of evil, or have we just been conditioned to think in this way when religious and spiritual traditions became militarized? After all, Constantine did not become a Christian because his mother had convinced him of the goodness and mercy that the faith embodied. He became a Christian when he saw the Chi-Rho in a dream and heard a voice say, “In this sign, you will conquer.” That marriage of faith and militarism was not invented by Constantine. It has been a part of military history for several thousand years. Perhaps people need to believe that they are dying for a higher cause or they would not give up their lives so willingly. How do we change this perspective? If we can get the answer to this question, we might finally be on the verge of a world without war. The starting point is to recognize these beliefs for what they are and the history that brought them into our world.</p><p>In his powerful novel, “All Quiet on the Western Front”, Erich Maria Remarque wrote of a scene where the narrator, a German infantryman in World War One, unexpectedly encounters a French soldier in a bomb crater. After initially gaping at each other in surprise, they grapple and he kills the Frenchman. Immediately, he is seized with remorse and goes through the man’s pockets and finds his ID card, and learns that he was Gerard Duval, a printer with a wife and child. He decides that he will need to write to the man’s family and explain how he died, but then realizes he will never write the letter. He reflects on the fact that neither he nor the Frenchman really had any reason to be killing each other beyond the fact that their leaders had ordered them into battle. This novel was much-hated by Hitler and his National Socialist friends since Remarque makes the war human and shows the reader how pointless the killing was. At one point, the German soldiers are reflecting on the fact that they are killing Frenchmen and the French are killing Germans and one of them speculates that if the leaders were required to live like them for a week, the war would be over in no time.</p><p>This paper began with a soccer referee and ends on the battlefield. Are some of the themes transferable? For one thing, a referee begins each game with a set of rules that have been agreed upon by the two teams. As the game progresses, anger and frustration, and even vengeance can enter the game and the game can become dangerous and the competence of the referee can be questioned and even rejected.</p><p>Today, there are universal principles for warfare, due in part to the brutality of the two world wars. Are these rules always followed? In Syria, Assad’s troops used chemical weapons, just as Saddam Hussein clearly used poison gas against the Kurds in Halabja in 1988. In Ukraine, the withdrawal of Russian troops from the suburbs of Kyiv left evidence of war crimes on a large scale. In Ethiopia, Rwanda, Ukraine, and Myanmar, in battle zones across the earth, the clear rules of engagement have been often ignored. Do we lose hope at this point? No, but we need to understand that war consistently brings out the worst in people and in their leaders.</p><p>It would be naïve to say that war should always be avoided. In the early years of World War II, there was a powerful anti-war movement in the United States led by Charles Lindberg, and FDR had to be very careful in finding ways to support the Allies against the Axis. With the benefit of hindsight, we now know that if Chamberlain had stood up to Hitler over Czechoslovakia it might have been possible to save millions of lives before the war had ever begun. When we study history, we benefit from hindsight. Do we also develop foresight, the ability to draw on lessons learned in the past to chart a better course for the future? We certainly can and should learn from our mistakes, just like a referee who can improve over time and achieve greater competence. The stakes are much higher when it comes to War and Peace. The future does not have to be a constantly repeated cycle of past sorrows and defeats, but it could be.</p><p><strong>The Value of Humility</strong></p><p>Humility is important. A humble person can listen and learn since there is no assumption that everything is already in one person’s brain. While Doc Savage was ready for anything and confident in his righteousness, he was also a fictional hero. People need to be ready to argue and do more research and come back and argue again. For example, about ten years ago one of my favorite professors from college read an earlier draft of this paper. Never one to mince words, he began by saying that the maundering introduction should be dropped. He said no one has time for dithering. If I had something to say I should just say it. Then, he announced that the age of empires had ended years ago and was a non-issue. At the time, I listened to him but more recently I took another look at the world around us and I cannot agree with him.</p><p><strong>Has the Age of Empires Ended Once and For All?</strong></p><p>As we look around the world, we see a series of empires struggling to hold together in the face of rebellions. Beginning with PR China and Xinjiang Province, how can the situation be seen as anything but an old empire cracking down on a rebellious province and forcing cultural and political assimilation on the Muslim Uyghurs? Next, when Russia attacked Ukraine, how can this be viewed as anything but an attempt by the old Russian empire to reimpose control on a rebellious former province? When Iran and Turkey both seek to extend their influence over neighboring countries, how is this not an attempt to reassert imperial control over regions that were long part of their empires? And the quest to spread democracy is not simple. We often forget that the United States was a democracy leading up to the Civil War when the South claimed its constitutional right to secede.</p><p>Generic solutions will not work, but there are models within the democratic tool kit that may be viable. In Iraq, the Kurdish regions have been given more autonomy under a federal model. In the United States, each state was given two senators even though the population of states like California and New York dwarfs that of Wyoming and Montana, and Alaska. Before people can work on solutions they have to be willing to talk to each other. Organizations like <strong>Braver Angels</strong> have begun to work with American voters from different parts of the political spectrum to encourage them to sit down and talk, listen, and even argue politely. When I began this essay (or series of essays) I believed that human beings can break the cycle of war and violence if we work together. I still believe this, but wish we had Doc Savage to lead the way. Since we do not, the rest of us will need to step up and do our part.</p><p>And it goes without saying that we are stewards of this planet as well and it will not help for the peoples of the world to be singing and dancing happily together as the world becomes uninhabitable. But that is for another essay!</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=961a3960711f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Part Two of Three: Democracy vs. Empire: What Can History Teach Us?]]></title>
            <description><![CDATA[<div class="medium-feed-item"><p class="medium-feed-image"><a href="https://medium.com/@charlesadamscogan/part-two-of-three-e0b63e48d3?source=rss-50a1ab437ef5------2"><img src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/0*orcwjowpwrNEIcjO.jpg" width="600"></a></p><p class="medium-feed-link"><a href="https://medium.com/@charlesadamscogan/part-two-of-three-e0b63e48d3?source=rss-50a1ab437ef5------2">Continue reading on Medium »</a></p></div>]]></description>
            <link>https://medium.com/@charlesadamscogan/part-two-of-three-e0b63e48d3?source=rss-50a1ab437ef5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e0b63e48d3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ancient-history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[afghanistan]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[empire]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[democracy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[world-religion]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Charles Adams Cogan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 29 Jul 2023 21:18:18 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-08-02T23:51:48.280Z</atom:updated>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[An Extended Reflection on How Rational Human Beings Can Be Motivated to Kill Each Other Again and…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@charlesadamscogan/an-extended-reflection-on-how-rational-human-beings-can-be-motivated-to-kill-each-other-again-and-a8373cb69595?source=rss-50a1ab437ef5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a8373cb69595</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Charles Adams Cogan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 28 Jul 2023 17:34:10 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-11-08T06:24:19.253Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/283/1*bwJn6O2a3m5HuhpyKflFkQ.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/0*006WRV9JhAGu_0wy.jpg" /><figcaption>A visual to support the first installment of this essay.</figcaption></figure><p><strong>An Extended Reflection on How Rational Human Beings Can Be Motivated to Kill Each Other Again and Again</strong></p><p>Part One of Three</p><p><strong>Begun in September 2007</strong></p><p>This morning, I’ve been trying to untangle the conflict in my mind. For the past five years, I’ve been trying to put together an opinion piece about the state of the world that would express some of the turmoil that I feel within and think I see in the world around me. This piece was supposed to bring clarity, based on my knowledge of the world’s history, religions, cultures, etc. It has gone through about five titles and is now fifteen pages long and has been read by friends, scholars, and total strangers. The first draft, written during the period leading up to the War in Iraq was entitled, “George W. Bush: A Mithras for Our Times?” and focused on my sense that the past administration had fallen into the time-honored trap of believing that our people could and should bring a higher form of civilization to others and teach them the difference between Good and Evil. After several gradual alterations, it is now entitled, “Righteous or Self Righteous?” (in deference to a respected Mithraist who had written to say that he was disturbed to see the name of the great Persian/Armenian/Roman Sun God and Zoroastrian arbiter of the final judgment tied to a piece of mundane, morally-bankrupt, NPR-style blather). Subsequent drafts have grown longer, but as the years have flown by, the situation in Iraq and Afghanistan has not remained constant, and new conflicts have flared up in Ethiopia, Ukraine, the Sahel Region of Africa, and now in Israel and the Gaza Strip.</p><p>At moments like these, I have often found it useful to get out and do something physical, some form of bracing outdoor activity. An opportunity came up recently when our local school district made a plea to my soccer club (the Old Gringos) for referees. As a soccer player with over twenty-five years of competitive experience (40 years, now) and enough gray hairs left to look like an authority figure, I decided I would be a natural for the job and could use this opportunity to get some exercise and rebuild my flagging self-esteem. I know soccer. I would be refereeing ninth-grade boys, junior varsity girls, and the high school B-squad. I bought a referee shirt, and a whistle and got one of those little booklets for my front pocket, complete with a red and yellow card, just in case. I would bring order to chaos, establish some clarity in a world in danger of disorder, and help my town’s youth when they were in need. In the process, I also learned humility.</p><p><strong>Lessons Learned the Hard Way by a Sub-Par Referee</strong></p><p>First of all, there’s a big difference between playing soccer and refereeing a soccer game! In the past, as a player, I only got mad at referees when they caught me or my children committing a foul or didn’t protect them when they were being fouled. Once in a while, I’d also get mad when they didn’t call an “off-side” attacker or obstruction, but to be honest, those rules were never completely clear to me anyway, so I usually assumed they must know why they made the calls. After all, there are rules and all the refs have to do is enforce them.</p><p>Second, I always assumed that kids playing soccer wanted to follow the rules and would be happy if I were on hand to make the calls.</p><p>Third, I always assumed that the referees were seeing all of the action and just deciding what to call and what not to call.</p><p>Fourth, I think I always assumed that the referees knew the rules and were aware of what they could and should be calling.</p><p>Fifth, I’m not sure I ever thought of the referees at all, except when I was mad at them. What on earth possessed me to think that anyone would appreciate the referee (me) or be any nicer than I had been for the past twenty-five years?</p><p>Having tried to keep order in six separate games, I have learned that even a coach who is your friend will say nasty things about you loudly when she/he thinks you’re doing a bad job. This is nothing compared to the coaches from opposing teams, who all assume that you are ignoring the fouls that the home team commits because you are trying to let them win.</p><p>Yesterday, a junior varsity girls’ game got out of control. One player slide-tackled another from behind. When that player fouled her a minute later, she got caught and was angry because the referee (me/I) had missed the earlier foul. Before long, there was another slide tackle and the coaches were both complaining about the game getting out of hand. When the referee (me/I) whistled some plays dead to separate the combatants, both teams were mad that they were being penalized for playing rough when “the other team” had started it. Pretty soon, I was just eying my watch, hoping the game would be over soon. Voices in the back of my mind kept on whispering things like, “Beware of The Lord of the Flies”, where weak or absent adults let children slide out of control, causing mayhem and the complete reversion to primitive violence. How and why did I ever get myself into this? Could I make it to the end and would anyone be permanently injured before then?</p><p>It seemed so easy from the sidelines.</p><p>Reality is complex and messy at every possible level. It’s so tempting to think we can step in and clean things up, restore order, and provide security. I still think we should, but I’m a lot less confident that I know how it should and can be done, and am not even completely sure that I’m capable of doing it for others, even in a very limited and controlled context, like a high school soccer game. Do our leaders ever have doubts of their own when we try to carry out much bigger and more daunting interventions, keep the peace between warring factions, separate the good from the evil, and set up new forms of government under conditions much different than our own? If not, then I challenge them to try to referee tomorrow’s soccer game in Northfield, Minnesota, and see how easy it is. It’s only ninety minutes long, there’s your exit strategy. Even better, the opposing teams wear uniforms, so you can tell who is who.</p><p><strong>Camera Fades. The Clock ticks on and the pages of the calendar fly by for twenty-seven months and many things change…</strong></p><p><strong>December 2009</strong></p><p><strong>Debriefing:</strong> This piece was written two years ago, during the reign of a previous administration, and is a clever critique of the big mess we had made for ourselves in Iraq and Afghanistan. In the interest of total disclosure, I showed it to some friends, colleagues, students, and even my spouse. To start with the harshest criticism first, my wife’s basic feedback was that as far as she could tell, I had only identified one real problem, that I’m a lousy referee with no training and that I should suck it up and do my job. She also suggested I should take a referee certification course or just quit since having a bad referee is worse than not having one at all. The students were the kindest, but even they were honest. One said that he could see two problems: training and staffing. First, since I had never had proper referee training, he didn’t think it was really convincing for me to talk about how difficult it is to maintain order in a soccer game. Perhaps, the proper training might have eliminated that challenge and he assumed that our armed forces receive very extensive training before entering conflict zones, thus invalidating my attempt to compare the two. Second, he said that it wasn’t fair to expect one referee to do a good job in a soccer game, since the same person cannot keep track of action both in front of and behind him at the same time. In an official game of any kind, there are usually three referees, with two of them on the opposing sidelines to call offsides, possession changes, etc. In summary, he said that while conditions might require a referee to call a game solo, in that case, you’d need a very experienced referee, not a beginner. In both cases, the final verdict was the same, my attempts to generalize from one limited experience were not really valid or very useful.</p><p><strong>Response:</strong> I’ve thought this over. A new administration is now in power and some of the same challenges are still present, along with some new ones. Locally, this means that several friends who were in Iraq at the time the first draft was written have finished their tours of duty, while one member of our Old Gringos soccer team is back in Iraq for a second time. On the international side, things in Iran seem much worse than before. President Ahmadinejad seems intent on playing the part of an evil vizier from the pages of Ferdowsi, isolating his country diplomatically and attempting to maintain his political power through manipulation and the violent suppression of a growing opposition movement. The situation in Iraq seems more stable than it was two years ago, with US troops in the slow process of moving from direct engagement to training and advising. Even there, recent controversies about the exclusion of numerous prominent Sunni politicians as “Baathists” are threatening to pull the country back into sectarian strife. There seems to be some hope for a better future, but things are still fragile.</p><p>(Spoiler: Here is a time when events changed very quickly in Iraq at about this time, but for now I was focused on Afghanistan)</p><p>Events in one part of this vast region have an impact elsewhere, but the focus these days (2009) is on Afghanistan. Do we need to change our mission in Afghanistan? Do we need to train people with new skills to build confidence in our presence and show that we truly mean to make a positive difference? Do we need more soldiers in the field to maintain order? Again, it seems to all come back to training and staffing. I’ve read some convincing editorials that urge us to keep our staffing at current levels or even begin to draw down our forces while focusing on building up the Afghans’ capacities for self-policing and administration. At the same time, there are counterarguments that we need more people on the ground in order to establish an environment conducive to civil society and socio-economic development. This time, the administration in power is one that I voted for, so I have had to think a bit more deeply.</p><p>Here is the first part of this essay. The following part, which will be posted soon, looks at two historical models that we could study to inform our present efforts to promote peace and stability in the world.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/283/1*bwJn6O2a3m5HuhpyKflFkQ.jpeg" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a8373cb69595" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Strange Tale of How We Came to See the World as an Eternal Battle Between Good and Evil]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@charlesadamscogan/the-strange-tale-of-how-we-came-to-see-the-world-as-an-eternal-battle-between-good-and-evil-8a5358532eb1?source=rss-50a1ab437ef5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8a5358532eb1</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Charles Adams Cogan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 31 Oct 2022 21:29:12 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-08-20T07:12:27.763Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*WvdnFDl8rmFE27zQ0Y8NFg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Something to visualize while you read this essay- CAC</figcaption></figure><p>On September 30, Vladimir Putin gave a fiery speech about the Satanic West and Russia’s fight to overcome Evil (New York Times, September 30, 2022, “With Bluster and Threats, Putin Casts the West as the Enemy”). He also announced that the four regions of Ukraine that Russia had occupied were now formally a part of Russia. What does this rhetoric of Good vs. Evil mean and how did we come to the place where everything needs to be characterized in extremes?</p><p>When the United States moved into Afghanistan over twenty-one years ago the same language was used. After twenty years, the United States has withdrawn from Afghanistan and the new Taliban regime is struggling to build an inclusive government and meet its people&#39;s needs. Russia has invaded Ukraine and images of death and destruction along with increasing allegations of war crimes have become the new normal. At the same time, there is polarization taking place across the planet with incredibly diverse countries divided along tectonic plates of identity, history, nationality, language, culture, and ideologies.</p><p>This trend has been active for many years and the divergence became pronounced following September 11, 2001, when the US responded to unexpected attacks by intervening militarily in Afghanistan and Iraq. As the borders in West and Central Asia are fluid and do not represent any true realities on the ground beyond those considered during the partition of the region after World War I, the fall of the Ottoman Empire, and Russian expansion to the borders of Afghanistan in the nineteenth century; the complexity can be overwhelming to the average person. Instead, the governments began to focus on terms with a long history in the region, the duality of good versus evil. This worldview dates back more than two thousand years and a glance at even the language of the past fifty years can show the influence of older ideas and worldviews. The simplistic language of Good vs. Evil doesn’t seem sufficient to describe what is going on or to help us find solutions. Some have likened George W. Bush’s rhetoric after 9/11 to Manichaeism, whose focus on Light vs. Darkness, Good vs. Evil, a never-ending struggle between the forces of light and darkness, etc., all evoke images very familiar to the average Christian American. The same desire to demonize the enemy is in play right now as Vladimir Putin describes all Ukrainians as Nazis. Why is it so important for current leaders to demonize their enemies?</p><p><strong>Good vs. Evil as a way of seeing the world</strong></p><p>Any student of Middle Eastern History knows that the many religious traditions influenced one another over the past five thousand years. While most Americans are very familiar with Judaism, Christianity, and Islam, which all trace their roots back to Abraham; much less is known about ancient religious traditions that exerted a powerful influence on the history and imagery, and even theological conceptions of their Abrahamic neighbors. Examples would be Heaven and Hell, the Final Judgement, and the Resurrection of the Dead, which only enter the Jewish Tradition during the years when Persia ruled over the region. When we begin to peel away the layers to reconstruct the process, never inevitable or pre-ordained, through which modern Americans and other global citizens received their holy books and their world views, the results can surprise us.</p><p>The direct impact of these deeply-held images can be seen in our political rhetoric. From Ronald Reagan’s characterization of the Soviet Union as “The Evil Empire” to George W. Bush’s identification of “The Axis of Evil”, neo-conservative politicians use the imagery of dualism on a regular basis. The fact that some of these forces of evil happen to be former allies (the USSR in WW II and Saddam Hussein’s Iraq in the years after the Iranian Revolution, especially during his war with Iran in the 1980s) doesn’t faze us, since we know that some questionable alliances need to be made in the face of even greater evils.</p><p>This dualism is not limited to Christian Americans. When the Shah of Iran was overthrown in 1979 and Ayatollah Khomeini eventually emerged as the spiritual and political leader of Revolutionary Iran, he described the United States as “The Great Satan”. In the past fifty years, the language of discourse has become so polarized that it’s not uncommon for politicians throughout the Middle East and some parts of Europe to invoke their own religious metaphors to paint their opponents in the darkest possible terms. When such language can be used at the level of nation-states, it’s not surprising that the terms bandied about on the streets of Gaza, Baghdad, and Tehran, not to mention Washington, D.C., and throughout Europe, have taken on very ominous tones. Political allies are the forces of light and progress (and Democracy), and political enemies are seen as ‘demons’ and the ‘forces of darkness’ and evil terrorists. The identities of these evildoers often shift. Former allies become evil (Saddam Hussein), and former enemies become good (Yasir Arafat). It’s hard to keep up in the best of times, but at present, the mood seems disturbingly similar to that described by W.B. Yeats in his timeless poem, “The Second Coming”:</p><p>“Things fall apart; the centre cannot hold;</p><p>Mere anarchy is loosed upon the world,</p><p>The blood-dimmed tide is loosed, and everywhere</p><p>The ceremony of innocence is drowned;</p><p>The best lack all conviction, while the worst</p><p>Are full of passionate intensity.”</p><p>These words, penned during the years between the World Wars, reflect a time when the Bolsheviks had seized power in Russia, even before the Fascist governments of Europe began to leverage fears of Communist revolution in order to make the case for their own brand of strong government. The mention of a second coming, for Yeats, was a very Biblical thing, coming straight from the Old Testament. The sentiments he describes would not be out of place in many parts of the world today and fit with current reports emerging from Ukraine, Syria, and Afghanistan as if they were written yesterday.</p><p>These images are deeply-ingrained in the American psyche, though often conceived of in Christian terms. One needs to go no further than <em>The Lord of the Rings</em> and <em>Star Wars</em> to see Good vs. Evil writ large. Several years ago, in a movie review in the <em>New York Times</em>, CARYN JAMES wrote that “With an emphasis on an eternal struggle between equally matched forces of darkness and light, “Star Wars” and “Batman Begins” suggest a kind of pop-culture Manichaeism” (NYT: June 17, 2005, Movies section). Where do we get these images of Darkness vs. Light, Good vs. Evil, an ultimate struggle in which the forces of goodness and light will eventually overcome the forces of evil and darkness?</p><p>The answer may strike some as strange since many Americans consider Christianity to be the ultimate source of morality and Christian values to be the cornerstone of American society. As we moved into Afghanistan and Iraq, twenty-one years ago, the Evangelical Christian West saw us pitted against the “forces of darkness” personified by militant Islam. In her movie review, James refers to Manichaeism, which was characterized by a strong focus on good vs. evil. However, Manichaeism itself was considered to be heretical development from an older tradition, one that has had a powerful influence on almost all of the major religions of a vast region, ranging from ancient Iran and Iraq to what is now Northern India, Pakistan, Afghanistan, and parts of the former U.S.S.R., and moving westward throughout the entire Roman Empire, to what is now Great Britain, France, the Balkans, Germany, etc. This religious tradition is Zoroastrianism, and without taking the time to know more about the Zoroastrian tradition, we cannot really claim to understand the roots of our own Christian, Muslim, and Jewish beliefs. A historical discussion of any of the three above traditions without acknowledging the importance of the teachings of the prophet Zarathustra would be like believing that all of our beliefs have sprung fully formed from the head of Zeus, like Athena.</p><p><strong>How far back does all of this go?</strong></p><p>Over 2,500 years ago, a prophet traveled across West-Central Asia, teaching a radical new message, that there were not many gods, but one true God. The exact time of his life is still not certain. By some accounts, he was an advisor to the father or grandfather of Cyrus the Great of Persia, at some point in the 7th century B.C. According to other accounts, based on the language of the Avesta, he might have lived hundreds of years earlier.</p><p>Zarathustra (Zoroaster) was his name, and he taught a very powerful vision of the world, in which the forces of Goodness and Light, led by Ahura Mazda, were locked in battle with the forces of Evil and Darkness, led by Ahriman. This ultimate struggle would take many forms, would span the lives of many generations, and would claim many lives, but the ultimate victory would lie with the forces of Goodness and Light. Those who had died in the name of the struggle for the victory of Light would be raised from the dead on a final judgment day, to reclaim their rightful places in the world, while the forces of darkness and evil would be condemned to eternal damnation. This philosophy was a very powerful one and was characterized by an emphasis on personal choice. By making virtuous decisions and performing proper ceremonies, each person could strengthen the cause of goodness. By succumbing to the temptations of evil, the cause of goodness could be undermined. The Avesta even contains scenes in which the prophet Zoroaster is tempted by the evil Ahriman, in a series of scenes that would be familiar to those who have studied the Bible (or the life of the Buddha, where Joseph Campbell has pointed out similarities to the temptations of Jesus in his series of interviews with Bill Moyers, <em>The Power of Myth</em>). Although there was only one God, he had many superhuman helpers, Yazatas, who were very similar to the angels of the Abrahamic traditions.</p><p>It is difficult to reconstruct the original teachings of Zoroaster, especially the Avesta. The sacred teachings were handed down through oral tradition, from generation to generation of mobeds (Zoroastrian priests), and the first known written copies of the Avesta were produced during the Sasanian period (though work was first begun during the late Parthian period), over 700 years after Zoroastrianism appeared as the imperial religion of the Achaemenid rulers of ancient Persia, who play such a prominent role in the Old Testament, especially in the Book of Daniel.</p><p>Mary Boyce posited that the teachings of Zarathustra were especially powerful because they came at a time when there was excessive violence and lawlessness in the Central Asian Steppes. In the older Indo-Iranian pantheon of gods were several who were clearly war gods, like Indra, who plays such a prominent role in the Rig Veda, one of the holiest books of the Indian tradition. By injecting morality and a struggle of good vs. evil, Boyce argues that Zarathustra’s teachings were transformational. At the same time, some older gods were reclassified as demons, those who sought senseless war and destruction, while others were classified as yazatas, allies of the one supreme God, Ahura Mazda, in the struggle for control of the world. In a very real sense, these teachings were designed for situations where anarchy ruled, to inject a higher calling to leaders, and to encourage ethical and moral thinking.</p><p>Boyce and others have devoted entire books (amazingly readable ones) to the study of Zoroastrian history and traditions over a period of 3,000 years. Her major work on the subject is a three-part series of books, published over the course of many years, in which she examines pre-Zoroastrian (Pagan) Iranian, Achaemenian, and then Parthian/Sasanian Iran. She notes many transformations of the Zoroastrian tradition over those 3,000 years, including the gradual eclipsing of some major gods, the growth of fire temple worship, the cult of Anahita who eventually joined the trinity of the Ahuras, with Ahura Mazda as the principal, followed by the male Mithra and the female Anahita as his lieutenants. This tradition is incredibly rich, and chapters on the Persian Zoroastrian influence on some of the writings of major Jewish prophets, from Second Isiah to Nehemiah (including the hypothesis that Persian support helped lead to the eventual victory of the “Yahweh-alone-ists” -monotheists, led by Nehemiah, at a point in time when the Jewish tradition was under considerable influence tending towards henotheism- one god above the others) and the teachings of Ezra and others in the period 465–424 BCE. At the same time, this influence was not limited to the Jewish tradition, as Boyce also explores the Zoroastrian influence on many of the leading Ionian Greek thinkers of the time (Thales, Anaximander, Anaximenes, Heraclitus of Ephesus, for example). This influence may have been mutual, and elements could be chosen while others were rejected. Religious traditions are alive and incredibly diverse, but it would be naïve to assume that the appearance of so many Zoroastrian concepts in Judaism during the period of Achaemenian over-rule and patronage was a mere coincidence.</p><p>During periods when the light of the Zoroastrian empires was dimmed (after Alexander the Great’s conquest in 330 BCE and in the years following the eclipse of the Sasanian Empire in the mid-seventh century CE), many historical documents were destroyed and lost forever. Nevertheless, Zoroastrian Empires ruled most of what is now the Middle East and parts of Central Asia for much of a period of twelve hundred years, from the sixth century BCE until the middle of the seventh century CE. Scholars attribute a very powerful influence to the teachings of Zoroaster and many succeeding generations of Persian mages and scholars. As in the case of Rome’s eventual patronage of Christianity as a Roman Catholic religious tradition by Emperor Constantine, and its spread through conquest, the teachings of Zoroaster were spread and made credible by their adoption by Cyrus the Great and several centuries of Persian rulers, from Cambyses to Darius I to Xerxes and others. The Achaemenians ruled a vast empire, ranging from Egypt to the Middle East, covering most of what is now Turkey, Israel, Palestine, Syria, Iraq, and Iran and moving off in directions later followed by Alexander, in the wake of his conquest of Persia under Darius III, to a region of what is now Pakistan and Afghanistan.</p><p>It is no coincidence that the “Babylonian” captivity of the Hebrews was ended by the Persian Conquest of the region, though the Neo-Babylonian regime was actually vanquished some years earlier by the Medes. There are many Old Testament stories of the influence of the Hebrews on their Persian overlords, such as the story of Daniel in the Lion’s Den. The Old Testament is full of stories of the power and protection of the One True God, who impressed the Persians (and earlier rulers) with his power to protect His prophets and the willingness of martyrs to die for their faith. In fact, at one point in the Bible, when Daniel had caused the destruction of the idol, Bel, and the great dragon of the Babylonians, they rose up against Cyrus, saying, “The king has become a Jew”. (Daniel, Chapter 14, pp. 934–935, The New American Bible) They forced Daniel to be placed in a den with seven lions, but he miraculously survived again (his second encounter with lions), with the result that the priests themselves were consequently cast to the lions and devoured. In fact, the monotheistic beliefs of the Hebrews fit nicely into the monotheism of orthodox Zoroastrian teachings, which could account for the favored position given to the Jewish community for many years under Zoroastrian Persian rulers.</p><p>What is less popularly known, but equally clear, is that the Persian religious tradition had a powerful impact on the evolution of the Judaic tradition, and thus influenced the Christian and Muslim traditions as well, both indirectly and directly. The Manicheans and Maitreya Buddhists were also deeply influenced by Zoroastrian beliefs, as can be seen in Mani’s imagery of light and darkness as well as the eschatology of the Maitreyan tradition, with its expectation of an eventual final judgment and second coming, etc. Some of this influence is easy to trace since the Persian Zoroastrian empires ruled large regions of what is now Pakistan, Afghanistan, and India all the way up to the seventh century CE. During the course of over a thousand years, the Zoroastrian tradition was the official religion of a succession of powerful Persian dynasties, beginning with the Achaemenians (Cyrus, Darius, Xerxes, etc.), followed by the Parthians and later the Sasanians. The division of the world into good and evil was a very effective theology for a growing empire. Zoroastrianism was the state religion of the Persia of Darius and Xerxes, which failed to conquer Athens and its various (polytheistic) allies in successive battles from 492–480 B.C.E. However, the empire enjoyed another 150 years of undisputed hegemony, until finally meeting disaster at the hands of Alexander the Great.</p><p><strong>Zoroastrianism meets Hellenism</strong></p><p>While Alexander is given credit for conquering much of the known world, most of what he conquered had been under the control of the Persian Empire for over 200 years (including Egypt, where Alexander supposedly received a prophecy of his future glory, which he never revealed to anyone). Alexander’s conquest of the region was a terrible setback for the Persian Empire and the Zoroastrian faith, but Hellenistic domination of the region outlived his death by less than a century, though smaller Hellenistic kingdoms competed with other regional powers for a longer period. True believers kept the Zoroastrian traditions alive under the Hellenistic kingdoms, and when the power of Alexander’s successors (especially the Seleucid kingdom) became fragmented.</p><p>In the spirit of cohabitation, the Parthians seem to have continued to consider themselves Zoroastrian, but were also willing to place themselves within the Hellenic tradition and were not averse to using Greek equivalents to their own gods when appropriate. Thus, many devotions to Zeus can be seen as devotions to Ahura Mazda, while Mithra was often equated to Apollo (a Sun God, later Helios or Sol in Roman times) and Anahita was equated to Artemis.</p><p>As they reasserted themselves in the region they tapped into the wealth and power provided by their location, in the heart of the old Silk Road. From this central location, the Parthians controlled trade between the commercial capitals of North Africa, West Asia, Central Asia, India, and China. It is clear that religious ideas also traveled the same routes, which helps to explain the influence of Zoroastrian beliefs on some Buddhist traditions.</p><p><strong>The Parthian Religious Mix</strong></p><p>Like Christianity, Islam, Judaism, and Buddhism, the Zoroastrian tradition was influenced over the years by the faiths of the regions they ruled and those with which they had regular contact. There is an ongoing and yet unresolved debate amongst scholars as to whether the traditions practiced by the Parthians can really be considered “Orthodox” Zoroastrianism. Some argue that their contact with Alexander and the Hellenistic world encouraged the Parthians to elevate some of the older “pre-Zoroastrian” Iranian gods to a status similar to that of Ahura Mazda, a fashion similar to the Greco-Roman model, in which a supreme God like Zeus or Jupiter could be given primacy, but other gods were adopted by certain regions and cities as patron gods. In the Parthian case, the rise of Mithra (a Yazata, or immortal being who was an ally of Ahura Mazda in his fight against evil) became an important figure in the Parthian armies, where he was exalted as their leader in the battle against evil. Within the Hellenistic world, it was easy for neighboring peoples to adopt Mithra (or Mithras in its Greek and Roman form), since a pluralistic society had room for more than one god and often found it easy to adopt gods of other cultures, endowing them with a rough equivalency to gods of their owns. Thus, one famous monument to Antiochus I at Commagene shows him paying tribute to a variety of gods, with a primary place given to Mithra (Clauss: 6), who is depicted as a Sun God, comparable to Apollo or Helios. One fascinating study has traced the influence of the cult of Mithras in the Hellenistic world and eventually in ancient Rome back to Armenia, an integral part of the Parthian Empire, a Zoroastrian power at the time, whose ruler, on meeting with the Roman Emperor Nero, pledged his allegiance to Nero just as he would pledge his allegiance to his God, Mithras (Clauss: 5).</p><p>Only a few years before the birth of Jesus Christ, the Parthians defeated the Roman legions at Carrhae. At this battle, one member of the triumvirate, Crassus, literally lost his head (53 BCE) and the Roman forces were completely routed and their standards captured and paraded by the Parthians in celebration of a great victory. At this point, the imperial Parthian theology (or at least its military) seems to have focused on Mithra, the ally of Ahura Mazda and the champion of light and goodness in the battle against darkness and evil. In the Avesta, there are references and praise hymns dedicated to Mithra. Because of the seeming invincibility of the Parthian armies in battle, the cult of Mithras became very popular in the Roman army as well. The rise of Mithras is an interesting phenomenon. As the lieutenant and/or son of Ahura Mazda (the Romans thought of Mithras as a sun god, “Sol Invictus Mithras”, while in the Avesta, “fire” is praised as the Son of Ahura Mazda, not necessarily Mithra by name), he was mentioned in the original teachings of Zarathustra, so he was not an “invention”. However, Mithras (Mitra or Mehr or Mihr in Persian, Mithras in Roman usage) was also a god in the non-Zoroastrian pantheon of Persian deities and other regional traditions, which raises the question of whether his rise could be compatible with a “monotheistic” tradition. In a much-quoted praise hymn devoted to Mithra in the Avesta, Mithra is given important qualities: truthfulness, a thousand eyes and ears to understand the plans of the enemies of goodness, a powerful support to those who honor their oaths to goodness, “a Heavenly Yazata bestowing rule, he increases the victory of those who offer to him piously, knowingly, purely with alms. For his brightness, etc.” (Avesta, (10) Mihr-Yast: 58–59).</p><p><strong>Mithra goes to Rome</strong></p><p>There has been much debate over whether the appearance of the Roman Cult of Mithras was ever directly tied to the Persian Yazata Mithra. Books have been written about the subject, including some that have argued for a veritable DaVinci Code of hidden meanings in the principal Roman representation of Mithras slaying the sacred Bull (Ulansey). It’s a fascinating question, but given the diversity of beliefs that exist under the general rubrics of Judaism, Christianity, and Islam, including the well-documented influence of Hellenistic mystery cults on the development of Roman Christianity, the search for a ‘pure and unadulterated’ faith tradition is difficult. During the years when Christianity was emerging as a powerful force in the Roman Empire, the Sasanian Empire was attempting to establish itself as the guardian of Zoroastrian orthodoxy. Nonetheless, the diversity of beliefs that Sasanian Persia inherited from the Parthians and the influence of Jewish and Christian doctrines led to the teachings of Mani, which drew on faith traditions very similar to those of the Baha’i in the present world, from Judaism to Christianity to Buddhism and Zoroastrian teachings (with the prophecy of Mohammed only bringing the Islamic tradition into the mix in the seventh century, several hundred years after Mani’s death). The richness and complexity of the religious world at that time is fascinating and has been explored in depth by scholars like Boyce and Zaehner. A very readable book on the history of dualism (Good vs. Evil) is Yuri Stoyanov’s, <em>The Other God</em>, but that is material for another day.</p><p>What is very clear is that Mithra and Mithras are both deeply connected to oaths of loyalty, and military success in the battle for a just cause, with the expectation of eventual success in the battle against “forces of darkness and evil”. In Zoroastrian beliefs, fire is the sacred weapon and purifier. In the Lord of the Rings, Gandolf (Mithrandrir) is the guardian of the sacred flame, who vanquishes the darkness of Mordor. Christian readers can very easily relate to this struggle, as can Jewish and Muslim readers. The imagery of light vs. darkness is a part of our shared heritage.</p><p>The dualism of the Zoroastrian tradition is a wonderful mobilizing force for the building of an empire. It is also a wonderful rallying cry for those seeking to unite in the face of an overwhelming outside threat. However, the language of duality: with us or against us, good vs. evil, light vs. darkness, is not as effective for building community and finding common ground between peoples of diverse faiths, traditions, histories, and interests.</p><p><strong>Can Dualism be a Positive Force?</strong></p><p>My goal here is not to advocate for a renewal of militant Zoroastrianism or to claim that any religious tradition is superior to others. The Zoroastrians who claimed Mithra as their champion against their Hellenistic enemies, the Romans, the Byzantine Empire, and other regional enemies were focusing on the physical military battle, not the spiritual quest. Their focus on Mithra had evolved to justify the conquest and incorporation of enemy lands and the maintenance of an elite of priests and aristocrats, far removed from the earlier teachings of Zoroaster and the practices of Cyrus the Great and his immediate successors. The fact that the Romans, including several emperors, felt comfortable using Mithras as a Roman symbol (comparable to Apollo and Helios, all Sun Gods) shows that the cult of Mithras in Rome was not considered in any way to be equivalent to Persian Zoroastrianism. While Mithras is supposed to lead the forces of goodness and light in battle against the forces of darkness and evil, there were even occasions when Roman forces went into battle against Persian Zoroastrian armies, with both sides counting on the support of their own Mithras/Mithra/Mehr/Mihr/Mir in their quest for victory. In a way, this ancient history sheds a direct light on our current crisis, where followers of the three surviving imperial monotheistic traditions are squared off in the Middle East and Central Asia, all calling on the same sources of inspiration and guidance as they seek to defeat one another and combat the evil that they see in their enemies. The spiral of violence is not a new one. The message and spirit of imperial Mithras, for all of its power and martial splendor, is not the one that is needed to solve current crises.</p><p><strong>When the Military Power is Subtracted from the Spiritual Quest</strong></p><p>Today’s Zoroastrian communities have found a way to move beyond the militancy of Imperial Zoroastrianism to a more spiritual tradition, which seems closer to the original teachings of Zoroaster himself. There are still small Zoroastrian communities in Iran and India. In Iran, they are generally very poor and limited to only a few ancient cities, including Yazd. In India, the Parsees tend to be rather affluent, highly educated, known in general for strong ethical practices, and devoted to a much quieter and pacific search for goodness and light. Despite some periods of persecution, followers of “the good religion” have usually been accorded a protected and respected status within the Islamic world, especially once their threat as the rulers of an earthly empire came to an end. Many Zoroastrians converted to Islam after the fall of the Sasanian Empire, though it has become clear that the waning of the Zoroastrian faith has been a protracted one, not the instant fall that early Islamic accounts liked to portray (see Boyce and others on this). Be that as it may, the culture and beliefs of ancient Persia were powerful, and Islam, like Christianity and Judaism, has been heavily influenced by Zoroastrian teachings and imagery.</p><p><strong>What can we take away from this exploration of the ancient past?</strong></p><p>Current conflicts in the Middle East and Central and South Asia are not new. Their roots go back for thousands of years, but there have also been long periods of peaceful coexistence and even very productive collaboration between the many cultural, religious, and socio-economic groups of the region. The Prophet Mohammed’s quest for unity and his tolerance of rival traditions shaped Islam through much of its history, though the Islamic world is also incredibly diverse in its traditions, from region to region and through different periods of history.</p><p>Up through the end of World War II, there were Jewish minorities, often thriving minorities, in every single Arab and Middle Eastern state. As much as a third of the population of Baghdad was Jewish, and many of those who fled Baghdad preserved a sense of nostalgia for their long and prosperous centuries in the heartland of successive Islamic empires. In most, there were also Christian minorities, including a very large Coptic Christian minority in Egypt up to the present day. In Iran, there was an important Baha’i minority for many long years. Peace has not been uninterrupted, even between fellow Muslim states, but the Islamic world has had long periods of stability and cultural pluralism.</p><p>Mary Boyce, in describing the relations between the Zoroastrian communities of Iran and their Muslim neighbors, pointed out that the term, “Najib” (noble) is used by the Zoroastrians of Iran to describe tolerant Muslims, while “na-Najib” (ignoble) is the term to describe those who are intolerant and oppressive. This kind of broad distinction is a very useful one and can be used equally well in other parts of the world. The same dichotomy would be familiar to those trying to describe Jewish-Palestinian relations, as well as those between Sunnis and Shiites in Iraq, Catholics and Protestants throughout the world, Christians and Muslims in the USA, etc.</p><p>Recently, some elements claiming to represent Islam have become just one more player in the competition for hegemony in the Islamic world. The language of Islamic militants in Iraq mirrors very closely the stark dualism of the Zoroastrian past. A fight for the cause of Islam, with death guaranteeing Paradise, the light of a superior religion conquering lesser religions, and a struggle for an eventual victory of Light over Darkness. All of these images come directly from the ancient Zoroastrian texts that were born in this very region so many years ago. Unfortunately, there are equally strident and equally Zoroastrian messages in Judaism (see the prophecies of Daniel) and Christianity (from the imperial ambitions of Constantine’s Roman Christianity to the Crusades to some of the fiercer present-day televangelists). The bottom line is that the Abrahamic religious traditions in the region have plenty of battle cries to keep them fighting forever. What can be done?</p><p><strong>The Framework for a Better Future</strong></p><p>First, we could begin by dropping the language of our Zoroastrian ancestors and realize that we are all drawing from the same well of traditions as we speak and are just speaking over each other. The fight in Iraq is not between ultimate good and ultimate evil. This is equally true of current conflicts in Israel/Palestine, India/Pakistan, and even in Darfur, where Muslims have been oppressing fellow Muslims. There is a struggle in each person between tendencies to good and evil, and if we assume that all people of all faiths are involved in similar struggles, then the need is to lower the volume, back away from the Mithraic image of death and destruction and toward a discourse of trying to find ways of encouraging the good and containing the evil within each person. The language Good vs. Evil, Light vs. Darkness, and Cosmic Dualism conjure up powerful antagonisms and fans the flames of conflict at a time when each of the world’s great monotheistic traditions is struggling for a language of discourse that can allow for reconciliation, reconstruction, and peaceful coexistence. This does not mean anything so idealistic as a call for everyone to lay down their arms and become friends, but we badly need to avoid the language of polarization and demonization, especially when referring to people of other religious traditions. We have more in common than we believe and realize, both for the better and for the worse.</p><p>The image of the Roman Mithras is that of a messianic figure, ordained by the One True God (or even The God himself, since Ahura Mazda never became a Roman God), supremely self-confident, self-righteous and militant, spoiling for a fight and sure of victory against inferior peoples and their inferior gods. The problem comes from the marriage of a spiritual-religious tradition of great appeal to an earthly empire, which faced all of the pressures and real-life challenges of the physical world.</p><p><strong>The Cyrus Cylinder and What it can Teach Us</strong></p><p>To give proper credit to the first great Zoroastrian dynasty, the Achaemenian rulers of ancient Persia, Cyrus the Great managed to balance his own strong faith with a Human Rights Charter, proclaimed in 539 BCE, that has been favorably compared with the present-day “Universal Declaration”. After conquering Babylon, he was careful to show respect for the Babylonian Gods, even though orthodox Zoroastrian doctrine proclaimed that there was only one true God. At the same time, he proclaimed that his forces would guarantee peace, “I would not allow anyone to terrorize any place of the country of Sumer and Akkad”, while he also “abolished the yoke which was against their standing. I brought relief to their dilapidated housing, putting an end to their main complaints. Marduk, the great lord, was well pleased with my deeds and sent blessings…” (both quotes from p. 35, Upshur et al.). Much of what we know of the reign of Cyrus, Darius I, and others came for many years from stories in the Old Testament, which echoed the fact that the Persian rulers were more just than their predecessors and strongly supported the rights of their Jewish subjects, with much praise for the God of the Hebrews.</p><p>In the ancient stone “Cyrus Cylinder” (which was discovered in 1878 during the excavation of the site of Babylon) he even went to the point of proclaiming that, with the help of Ahura Mazda, he would only rule those who willingly accepted his rule, would respect the “traditions, customs and religions of the nations of my empire” and would not resort to war to impose his rule (for an easily accessible source, please see English translation at <a href="http://iranchamber.com/history/cyrus_charter.php).">http://iranchamber.com/history/cyrus_charter.php).</a> Given the policies and practices of his predecessors, the Assyrians and Chaldeans, and Medes, this Human Rights policy is even more striking. It reflects, perhaps, one of the most important principles contained in the teachings of Zoroaster, “that men and women possessed free will and were expected to avoid sin and abide by divine laws. Each person’s choices mattered in the struggle. The king of kings himself was a devotee and example to his people” (Upshur et al, p. 38). By internalizing the teachings of Zoroaster, early rulers like Cyrus and Darius I had to make difficult choices. That both chose to hold themselves to high ideals can be seen as a very positive outcome of their belief in the teachings of Zoroaster, though the realities of maintaining and reinforcing an empire required many compromises.</p><p>The importance of Cyrus the Great’s Human Rights policy was underlined fifteen years ago in a Nobel Peace Prize Forum at St. Olaf College, Northfield, Minnesota, as having, “promoted a Human Rights policy that rivals the Universal Declaration in its breadth”. The person who originally shared this with me is a retired ambassador, Bob Flaten, who agreed to read an early draft of this paper. Pursuing this theme, he asked, “How could Cyrus the Great do this in the context of good vs. evil? If he could do it, why can’t we?”</p><p>The challenge, then, is to find a way to combine high ideals and strong beliefs with a tolerance of differing opinions and traditions. If we need to look for a Mithras in today’s world, we might find him among the most radical and intolerant, and violent elements of each religious community. Mithras is the Judge, the one who chooses who is good and who is evil and then helps the good ones to defeat the evil ones. In a fascinating essay, written shortly after George Bush’s original “Axis of Evil” speech, Dan Skinner pointed out one of the critical problems of Bush’s dualism: “Did Bush get the categories right? Is he sure who is Good and who is Evil? If not, he is energizing a high stake dualistic game based on false distinctions” (Skinner, “Calling Bush’s Views Manichean Is an Insult to the Manicheans”: 2–3, from History News Network, 9/24/04, <a href="http://hnn.us/articles/printfriendly/7202.html).">http://hnn.us/articles/printfriendly/7202.html).</a></p><p>The key to finding a way to a better future will be to avoid this path and find better solutions, better voices, and better paradigms from the past and the present for the years to come. Deep religious faith can be a wondrous thing if it gives people a sense of justice, tolerance, and appreciation for the human dignity of others. All of these virtues can be found aplenty in the diverse Zoroastrian, Manichean, Jewish, Christian, Islamic, Baha’i, and Buddhist traditions of the past three thousand years. We all have to seek a little harder and then look within ourselves to make conscious choices on behalf of “good thoughts, good words, good deeds” (NYT, Sept. 6, 2006, Laurie Goldstein, “Zoroastrians Keep the Faith, and Keep Dwindling”, <a href="http://www.nytimes.com/2006/09/06faith.html).">http://www.nytimes.com/2006/09/06faith.html).</a></p><p>In some future time, in some distant place, humble and modest Christians, Jews and Muslims may all live again in harmony, looking back at their imperial days and wondering how the teachings of their prophets led to the hubris and bloodshed, and irreconcilable differences of the today’s world. Like today’s Zoroastrian communities, they may reflect back on the glory years of their faiths, when their religions were spread around the world by mighty empires and their principles were admired and followed by peoples of widely diverse languages and histories, and traditions. Unfortunately, this humility and introspection seem to be much easier to achieve after the empire has failed and worldly power is a thing of the past. If we’re looking for a way out of today’s spiral of violence, it will take tremendous commitment and courage for world leaders to set aside the imperial militancy of their spiritual traditions and seek commonality and compromise, and cohabitation. Mithra/Mithras became a war god and a ‘self-righteous’ judge during the years of Persian and Roman imperial might. In earlier times, Zarathustra seemed to want his Mithra to be a judge who could truly provide fair judgments to all of humanity, not just his own team, and the spiritual journey outlined by Zarathustra seemed to be very universal in its abhorrence of senseless violence and bloodshed. Identifying and encouraging good thoughts, good words and good deeds may be just the recipe we need right now.</p><p><strong>A Basic Bibliography for Sources Reviewed for this piece</strong></p><p>Boyce, Mary (1977) A Persian Stronghold of Zoroastrianism, Clarendon Press, Oxford (UK).</p><p>Boyce, Mary (1996) A History of Zoroastrianism Volume I: The Early Period, EJ Brill, Leiden/New York/Koln.</p><p>Boyce, Mary (1982) A History of Zoroastrianism Volume II: Under the Achaemenians, EJ Brill, Leiden/Koln.</p><p>Boyce, Mary (1975) A History of Zoroastrianism Vol. III: Under Macedonian and Roman Rule, EJ Brill, Leiden/Koln.</p><p>Clauss, Manfred (2001) The Mysteries of Mithras: The God and His Mysteries, Translated by Richard Gordon, Routledge, New York.</p><p>Stoyanov, Yuri (2000) The Other God: Dualist Religions from Antiquity to the Cathar Heresy, Yale University Press, New Haven and London.</p><p>Kriwaczek, Paul (2004) In Search of Zarathustra: Across Iran and Central Asia to Find the World’s First Prophet, Knopf Doubleday Publishing Group, New York City.</p><p>Mottahedeh, Roy (1986) The Mantle of the Prophet: Religion and Politics in Iran, Knopf Doubleday Publishing Group, New York City.</p><p>Russell, James R (1987) Zoroastrianism in Armenia, Harvard Iranian Series, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA (USA).</p><p>Ulansey, David (1989) The Origins of the Mithraic Mysteries: Cosmology and Salvation in the Ancient World, Oxford University Press, London.</p><p>Upshur, Jiu-Hwa, Terry, Janice, Holoka, James, Goff, Richard, Cassar, George (2002) Volume I: World History Before 1600: The Development of Civilization, Fourth Edition, Wadsworth, Thomson Learning, Australia-Canada-Mexico-Singapore-Spain-UK-United States.</p><p>Zaehner, R.C. (1961) The Dawn and Twilight of Zoroastrianism, Weidenfeld and Nicolson, London.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8a5358532eb1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>