<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Christian Hartvig on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Christian Hartvig on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@christian.hartvig?source=rss-940ef270fe1f------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 00:48:17 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@christian.hartvig/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[You Can’t Change the Corporate Mentality (Trust Me, I Tried)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@christian.hartvig/you-cant-change-the-corporate-mentality-trust-me-i-tried-303bee52b703?source=rss-940ef270fe1f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/303bee52b703</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[corporate-culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[startup]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[leadership]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[workplace]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[innovation]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Christian Hartvig]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 07 Apr 2026 11:12:35 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-04-08T13:55:41.290Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>What happens when someone raised on speed, instinct, and unreasonable ambition tries to inject life into a system built to neutralize it?</h4><figure><img alt="Person running out of a cave, towards the light." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*PiZWRoA4PsQAArsEXerefQ.png" /><figcaption>Image created with the use of AI.</figcaption></figure><p>Everyone thinks <em>this</em> company will be different. That <em>this</em> culture really cares. That <em>this</em> time, your energy, vision, and startup scars won’t be politely absorbed, digested, and quietly buried beneath layers of “alignment.” You walk in thinking you’ll shake things up. But instead, you’re offered a seat at the table — along with a branded water bottle, a 42-slide onboarding deck, and just enough optimism to keep you docile. You don’t notice the cave at first. The lighting’s too good. The smiles too sincere. But give it time — the shadows always return.</p><p>And just like that, the shadows on the wall start to feel… familiar.</p><h3>From Startup Freedom to Plato’s Basement Dungeon</h3><p>Once upon a time — in the golden age of naïveté and flat hierarchies — I believed you could change the system from within.</p><p>The system, of course, being that fluorescent-lit behemoth we call corporate life. A place where dreams go to die wearing lanyards, and creativity is scheduled between compliance trainings and lunch-and-learns that no one asked for.</p><p>I came from the world of startups. Speed. Chaos. Freedom. We built things before the market even knew it wanted them. We ran on instinct, Red Bull, and a whiteboard full of half-baked brilliance. It was dirty, unpredictable, and deeply human.</p><p>And then I joined Big Corp.</p><p>Not a bad one, mind you. In fact, it was full of nice people. A progressive mission. Thoughtful onboarding. Slideshows about psychological safety.</p><p>But like a frog in slowly boiling water, you don’t notice what you’re losing until you’re halfway poached. And by then, it’s too late. Your rebellious spirit is still in there somewhere, but HR has firewalled your access to it.</p><p>And so begins the descent into Plato’s Cave.</p><h3>Welcome to the Cave. We Have KPIs.</h3><p>Let’s rewind 2,400 years.</p><p>Plato, the original philosophical troublemaker with a flair for drama, gave us a parable that still cuts like a knife — <em>The Allegory of the Cave</em>. It goes like this:</p><p>A group of prisoners has been chained inside a dark cave since birth. They can’t move. Can’t turn their heads. Their entire world is a stone wall in front of them. Behind them, a fire blazes — and between that fire and the prisoners, other people walk by, carrying objects. These objects cast shadows on the wall.</p><p>That’s all the prisoners can see. Shadows.</p><p>They don’t know they’re shadows. To them, these flickering shapes <em>are</em> reality. The fire is their sun. The echoes bouncing off the walls are the only voices they trust.</p><p>Then, one day, one prisoner breaks free. It’s clumsy. He’s weak. The light hurts. The real world is terrifying in its complexity. But slowly, his eyes adjust. He sees trees. Mountains. The sky. Not shadows — <em>real things</em>. He realizes everything he thought was real was just a projection. A game. A lie.</p><p>Overwhelmed with truth and purpose, he returns to the cave, desperate to share what he’s seen.</p><p>And what do the others do?</p><p>They mock him. Laugh at him. Call him blind. They’ve spent their whole lives staring at a wall, and now he’s back saying <em>none of it was real</em>? Of course they resist. In Plato’s version, they don’t just dismiss him — they threaten to kill him if he tries to drag them into the light.</p><p>Now fast forward to your average Fortune 500 company.</p><p>The cave is the office. The chains? Org charts, Outlook calendars, compliance policies, and the hypnotic glow of KPI dashboards. The shadows on the wall? PowerPoint decks. QBRs. Market research readouts. Agile rituals where nothing changes. “Customer-centricity” diagrams with no customers in sight.</p><p>And that startup soul — the escaped prisoner — walks in with fire in their chest and stars in their eyes, believing they’ve come to liberate.</p><p>They talk about truth. Vision. Urgency. Momentum.</p><p>But to the people inside, you’re just making the wall flicker funny. Disturbing the shadowplay.</p><p>Because here’s the cruel twist: the longer someone sits in the cave, the more invested they become in the shadows. They’ve built careers decoding them. Written OKRs about them. Hired consultants to optimize their clarity and consistency. The shadows might be fake — but they’re familiar. Safe. Measurable.</p><p>You can A/B test shadows. You can build a 12-month roadmap around them. You can link them to incentive programs and ISO certifications.</p><p>But sunlight? That’s chaos. Unquantifiable. You can’t align a quarterly board deck to “trees and truth.” There’s no Jira ticket for “escape the cave.” So they stay. And rationalize. And polish the shadows until they sparkle.</p><p>Meanwhile, the startup misfit — you — keeps pointing to the cave entrance like a madman with a Wi-Fi signal.</p><p>You think you’re freeing people. But in their eyes, you’re just some barefoot heretic trying to torch their pension plan.</p><p>Because truth in the sunlight is terrifying when you’ve spent your whole life optimizing for shadows.</p><h3>The Corporate Immune System: Built to Reject Real Change</h3><p>Clayton Christensen, in his book <em>The Innovator’s Dilemma</em>, pointed out how companies get disrupted not because they’re incompetent, but because they’re too competent at defending the status quo. And let me tell you: corporate immune systems are ruthlessly competent.</p><p>They have antibodies for everything:</p><ul><li><strong>New ideas?</strong> <em>Let’s run a feasibility study.</em></li><li><strong>Bold direction?</strong> <em>Circle back after alignment.</em></li><li><strong>Clear vision?</strong> <em>Needs a few more stakeholder buy-ins.</em></li><li><strong>Momentum?</strong> <em>Let’s put that on the Q3 roadmap.</em></li></ul><p>They don’t fight change head-on. That would be too obvious. Instead, they drown it in Excel sheets and meeting invites. Death by a thousand syncs.</p><p>It’s not even malicious. It’s bureaucratic homeostasis. A system optimized for risk aversion. A culture evolved not to grow, but to survive itself.</p><p>You may walk in with fire. But sooner or later, they’ll give you a fire extinguisher and make you the Head of Fire Prevention.</p><h3>Corporate Vision: Like a GPS with No Destination</h3><p>Startups begin with a vision. A gut feeling that the world could — and should — be different. It’s messy and unproven, but it’s alive. You build the product <em>as you build the world around it</em>.</p><p>In contrast, most corporate “vision” documents are indistinguishable from an AI-generated TED Talk title. Vague, sanitized, and universally ignorable. (“Empowering innovation through scalable ecosystems that unlock next-gen synergy” — like, what does that even mean? And are we talking about MedTech, FinTech, or the oil industry?)</p><p>Corporate vision isn’t about direction. It’s about <em>alignment theatre</em> — a way to make sure no one can be blamed when nothing changes.</p><p>And don’t even get me started on “agile.” There’s nothing agile about a 28-person sprint planning call with three project managers and a Gantt chart in disguise.</p><h3>Meetings: The New Cave Shadows</h3><p>If Plato’s prisoners stared at shadows, today’s workers stare at slides. Meetings are the modern shadow puppetry — an illusion of progress, a ritual of relevance.</p><p>The average knowledge worker spends over 30 hours a week in meetings <a href="https://hbr.org/2022/05/stop-the-meeting-madness">source</a>. That’s not collaboration. That’s spiritual euthanasia.</p><p>And if you dare question the need for all these meetings?</p><p>“Oh, we need to ensure cross-functional alignment and transparency.”</p><p>Translation: “We don’t trust each other enough to let work speak for itself.”</p><p>The deeper truth? Meetings aren’t about outcomes. They’re about <em>optics</em>. A way to signal involvement without actually risking anything. You can’t fail in a meeting. But you also can’t build anything in one.</p><h3>The Cult of Process: Because Outcomes Are Scary</h3><p>In startups, the only metric that matters is: <em>does it work?</em></p><p>In corporations, the most sacred relic is <em>the process</em>.</p><p>Not because it leads anywhere. But because it protects everyone from the terror of accountability. If you followed the process, then whatever happened couldn’t possibly be your fault. You “did your due diligence.” You “looped in stakeholders.” You “leveraged the framework.”</p><p>Meanwhile, the product is a Frankensteined mess. The customer is confused. The team is demoralized. But the unambitious quarterly goals were (almost) met, so… champagne?</p><p>Here’s the thing no one says out loud: corporate process isn’t about quality. It’s about <em>plausible deniability</em>. Bureaucracy is just fear wearing a lanyard.</p><p>And once you’ve tasted that fear, it’s hard to go back to building. Because building means risk. And risk means exposure. And exposure means you might get blamed. Or worse — promoted into middle management.</p><h3>The Echo Chamber of “Customer-Centricity”</h3><p>Another corporate hallucination is the fetishization of customer interviews.</p><p>Don’t get me wrong — talking to customers is crucial. But in big companies, it’s become a religion. An excuse to stall. A way to avoid bold decisions.</p><ul><li>“We can’t move forward until we validate this with more users.”</li><li>“Let’s A/B test the strategy itself.”</li><li>“We should run another round of discovery.”</li></ul><p>But you don’t build greatness by asking people what they want. If Steve Jobs had relied on customer interviews, we’d still be tapping away on Nokias.</p><p>In the startup world, you <em>listen</em> to customers. But you <em>lead</em> with vision. You see around corners. You take leaps. You put something real into the world, then refine it.</p><p>In corporate land, “customer obsession” is often just <em>decision paralysis</em> in disguise.</p><p>Because if you always follow the customer, you’ll never lead the market. You’ll just keep optimizing the cave walls.</p><h3>The Final Phase: Assimilation or Exile</h3><p>Eventually, you face a choice.</p><p><strong>Option A: Assimilate.</strong> Learn the language. Master the dance. Become a high-functioning shadow manager who knows when to nod, when to object softly, and when to book the follow-up. You’ll be rewarded with title inflation, a bigger monitor, and a yearly bonus just generous enough to dull your pain.</p><p><strong>Option B: Exile.</strong> Walk away. Back into uncertainty. Back into hunger, and chaos, and magic. Back to building, not babysitting.</p><p>Most choose Option A. Not because they’re weak. But because <em>leaving</em> means admitting you were never going to change the system. And that stings.</p><p>But if you’ve made it this far, you already know the truth:</p><p><strong>You can’t bring sunlight to a place designed to block it.</strong></p><p>You can’t liberate minds that have paperclips for shackles and Outlook invites for bars.</p><p>You can only leave the cave — and build a world where the light is <em>normal</em>, not dangerous.</p><h3>Epilogue: A Message from the Cave</h3><p>If you’re still working in corporate, I salute you.</p><p>Truly.</p><p>You’re doing the best you can in a system that was never designed for imagination. You might even be doing good work. Sometimes, great work. But you know — deep down — how much you’re leaving on the table. How much brighter the world could be if we stopped mistaking the safety of sameness for progress.</p><p>This post isn’t a resignation letter.</p><p>It’s a survival guide. A lighthouse for the weirdos, the rebels, the builders who tried to bring fire to the cave and got handed a fire safety policy instead.</p><p>Here’s your reminder:</p><ul><li>Your instincts are not too much.</li><li>Your urgency is not misplaced.</li><li>Your frustration is not unprofessional.</li><li>Your boldness is not dangerous — it’s <em>needed</em>.</li></ul><p>Just maybe… not here.</p><p><strong>P.S.</strong> If you ever escape again, don’t waste time throwing shadows at the wall. Go build something that burns.</p><p>And invite others to join you — in the sun.</p><h3>A note on AI use</h3><p>This piece was written by me — with a little help. Like many non-native English speakers, I use AI as a creative assistant to sharpen phrasing, stress-test arguments, and catch idioms I might otherwise miss. It doesn’t write for me — it helps me write <em>more like me</em>.</p><p>I’ve shared more thoughts on this here: <a href="https://medium.com/@christian.hartvig/ai-isnt-ruining-writing-it-s-finally-giving-non-native-speakers-a-voice-2fdbde4fa870">“AI isn’t ruining writing — it’s finally giving non-native speakers a voice”</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=303bee52b703" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The $189 Billion Lobotomy: Why Data Obsession Just Wiped Out 65% of Nike’s Market Value]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@christian.hartvig/the-189-billion-lobotomy-why-data-obsession-just-wiped-out-65-of-nikes-market-value-2ecabe56cb06?source=rss-940ef270fe1f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2ecabe56cb06</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[innovation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[critical-thinking]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[business-strategy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[product-management]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[data-science]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Christian Hartvig]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 25 Nov 2025 21:22:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-06-23T12:01:01.242Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Why your addiction to metrics is guaranteed to kill your vision (and why your dashboard is just numbers porn)</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3hZDQC75VZjTDo8Ge94fEw.png" /><figcaption><strong>Source:</strong> Generated by Nano Banana 2</figcaption></figure><p>There is a distinct, sterile smell in the boardrooms of modern software companies. It smells of dry-erase markers, lukewarm cold brew, and the pervasive, sweating fear of being wrong.</p><p>To alleviate this fear, we have invited a new priesthood into the temple: The Data People.</p><p>They arrive with their sermons written in SQL and their prophecies visualized in Tableau. They promise salvation through optimization. They promise that if we simply measure enough variables, if we A/B test enough button colors, if we stare long enough into the abyss of the retention cohort analysis, the “truth” will reveal itself.</p><p>But let’s call this what it really is: <strong>Numbers Porn.</strong></p><p>It’s a voyeuristic obsession. You are watching the shadows of human behavior on a cave wall, pleasuring yourself to the illusion of control. And just like an addiction to the real thing, this obsession with data desensitizes you to the nuance, the romance, and the messy, beautiful complexity of real life. It renders you impotent in the face of the blank page.</p><h3>The Man with the Hammer (and the tiny, tiny vision)</h3><p>Abraham Maslow, the psychologist famous for his hierarchy of needs, gave us a concept that explains the current rot in software development: <strong>The Law of the Instrument</strong>.</p><blockquote>“I suppose it is tempting, if the only tool you have is a hammer, to treat everything as if it were a nail.”</blockquote><p>For the modern data-driven Product Manager, the world is nothing but a bag of nails.</p><p>When your only tool is quantitative analysis, you stop seeing human beings. You stop seeing “delight,” “surprise,” “status,” or “joy.” Those things don’t fit in a CSV file. Instead, you see metrics to be moved.</p><ul><li>A user isn’t a stressed mother trying to buy groceries; she is a <em>“conversion funnel drop-off point.”</em></li><li>A reader isn’t a curious mind seeking inspiration; they are <em>“Time on Page: 43 seconds.”</em></li></ul><p>This is the cognitive trap of the <strong>reductionist mindset</strong>. By reducing the world to what can be measured, you implicitly decide that what cannot be measured does not exist. And perhaps more importantly, it does not count. Once something falls outside the spreadsheet, it quietly slips outside the conversation.</p><p>That blind spot isn’t new. Even those working at the sharp edge of measurement have warned against it. The theoretical physicist Albert Einstein, keenly aware of the limits of his own discipline, supposedly kept a sign in his office at Princeton as a reminder:</p><blockquote><strong><em>“Not everything that can be counted counts, and not everything that counts can be counted.”</em></strong></blockquote><p>Your data team is counting the clicks. But they cannot count the <em>feeling</em> of a user falling in love with a brand. They can measure the efficiency of a checkout flow, but they cannot measure the <em>fantasy</em> that the product promises. And because they can’t measure it, they de-prioritize it. They optimize the soul right out of the software until it is as aerodynamic and lifeless as a grey Toyota Corolla.</p><h3>The Castration of Fantasy</h3><p>The greatest superpower of the species <em>Homo Sapiens</em> is not calculation. A pocket calculator from 1985 can calculate faster than you.</p><p>Our superpower is <strong>Fantasy</strong>.</p><p>It is the ability to imagine a reality that <em>does not yet exist</em>. It is the cognitive leap that allows us to look at a cave and see a cathedral, or look at a horse and imagine a Ferrari.</p><p>Data is the enemy of fantasy. Why? Because <strong>Data is a historian.</strong></p><p>Data is, by definition, an artifact of the past. It is a record of what people <em>did</em> do, not what they <em>could</em> do if you inspired them. When you build strictly based on data, you are locking your future into the cage of your past. You are doomed to iterate on what already exists, refining the status quo into oblivion.</p><p><strong>Clayton Christensen</strong>, the Harvard Business School professor who literally wrote the book on innovation (The Innovator’s Dilemma), put it savagely well:</p><blockquote><strong><em>“Data only tells you about the past — not what you should create next.”</em></strong></blockquote><p>If Henry Ford had looked at the data, he would have bred faster horses. If Steve Jobs had looked at the data, the iPhone would have been a BlackBerry with a slightly better keyboard. The data did not say, “People want a glass slab in their pocket that contains the sum of human knowledge.” The data said, “People buy phones with buttons.”</p><p>Data cannot dream. And when you let data people drive the car, you are essentially driving with a blindfold on, guided only by the vibrations of the road behind you.</p><h3>The Cargo Cult of the KPI</h3><p>The most insidious failure mode of the data mindset is the <strong>Cargo Cult</strong>.</p><p>This concept, made famous by Nobel Prize-winning physicist <strong>Richard Feynman</strong> in his 1974 Caltech commencement address, describes people who mimic the <em>form</em> of success without grasping the underlying <em>substance</em>.</p><p>During WWII, indigenous people in the South Pacific observed Allied forces building airstrips and control towers. When the military left, the locals built their own runways out of wood, erected bamboo control towers, and sat there wearing coconut-shell headphones, waiting for the planes (the “cargo”) to land.</p><p>They copied the <em>observable metrics</em> (runway length, tower height) but missed the <em>unobservable mechanics</em> (radios, supply lines, military necessity, advanced engineering).</p><p>This is your average “Data-Driven” tech company today.</p><p>They look at Netflix and see a retention metric, so they copy the metric. They look at Spotify and see the use of collaborative filtering, so they copy the feature. They copy the bamboo tower and the coconut headphones of the successful competitor’s dashboard, but they fail to copy the deep cultural commitment to taste, risk, and visionary design that actually brings the cargo (the success) in.</p><p>In short, they’re not doing strategy; they’re engaging in statistical cosplay.</p><p>This tendency is rooted in what is academically known as the <strong>McNamara Fallacy</strong>, named after former US Secretary of Defense Robert McNamara.</p><blockquote>McNamara, during the Vietnam War, famously tried to quantify success through objective metrics like enemy body counts and bomb tonnage, ignoring all qualitative, unquantifiable factors like political will, troop morale, and cultural identity. He had all the data, and he lost the war. The obsession with what is measurable blinded him to what was essential.</blockquote><p>Your product roadmap is filled with McNamara Fallacies: velocity points, engagement minutes, and churn rates — all perfectly quantified ways to describe a sinking ship.</p><h3>The Law That Explains the Rot</h3><p>There is a deeper law at work here, one that explains why intelligent organizations repeatedly optimize themselves into mediocrity.</p><p>In 1975, the British economist Charles Goodhart observed something that, at first glance, sounds almost trivial:</p><blockquote>“When a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure.”</blockquote><p>But this is not a clever aphorism. It is a structural law of institutional behavior.</p><p>A metric is useful precisely because it is a proxy. It stands in for something more complex — customer trust, product-market fit, cultural relevance, loyalty, desire. It works only as long as it remains an indirect signal.</p><p>The moment you elevate it from signal to objective — the moment compensation, promotions, quarterly OKRs, and investor expectations hinge on it — the relationship inverts. People stop improving the underlying reality and begin improving the metric itself.</p><p><strong>Customer Satisfaction</strong> <em>becomes </em><strong>survey manipulation</strong>.</p><p><strong>Engagement</strong> <em>becomes</em> <strong>addiction engineering</strong>.</p><p><strong>Velocity</strong> <em>becomes</em> <strong>story-point inflation</strong>.</p><p><strong>Revenue growth</strong> <em>becomes</em> <strong>channel stuffing</strong>.</p><p>The number was originally correlated with health. But once targeted directly, it detaches from the organism it was supposed to represent. It becomes a surface performance of health.</p><p>This is why optimization so often feels productive while quietly hollowing out the core. The dashboard still glows green. The charts still slope upward. But what they are now measuring is adaptation to the metric, not improvement of the product.</p><p>The tragedy is not that people game the system maliciously. It is that they respond rationally to incentives. When you reward a number, you will get behavior designed to serve that number. And because numbers are clean while human experience is not, the organization slowly migrates toward what is legible and away from what is meaningful.</p><p>Goodhart’s Law does not attack data. It exposes the corruption that occurs when measurement replaces judgment.</p><p>And once you see it, you cannot unsee it.</p><p>The very act of declaring something measurable and important begins to distort it.</p><h3>The $189 Billion Lesson: Nike’s Spreadsheet Suicide</h3><p>You might be sitting there, nodding, but thinking: <em>“This is just about small, incremental failures. The solution isn’t to ditch data; it’s to simply get more data — deeper, cleaner, more comprehensive data! If only we had enough data, the truth would be perfectly clear!”</em></p><p>This is the final, most seductive lie the data priest will whisper: the promise of perfect information. It is the delusional pursuit of a finish line that doesn’t exist.</p><p>The truth is that <strong>the problem is not about the quantity of data; it’s about the quality of the question.</strong> You can have every single data point in the universe, but if your leadership lacks vision, conviction, and a capacity for fantasy, all that data only serves to build a beautiful, high-resolution map of the disaster you are driving straight into.</p><p>If you don’t believe the theoretical risk, let’s look at the actual wreckage. Let’s look at Nike — a company that didn’t lack data; it practically drowned in it.</p><p>For decades, Nike wasn’t a shoe company. It was a fantasy factory. They sold the dream of athleticism, the grit of the underdog, the “Just Do It” spirit. They understood that coolness is an intangible asset — it relies on scarcity, vibe, and cultural cachet.</p><p>Then, they got the “Hammer.”</p><p>Nike hired John Donahoe, a tech CEO and ex-Consultant (Bain &amp; Company, eBay and ServiceNow) and brought in the expensive consultants from <strong>McKinsey</strong>. The data people looked at the spreadsheets and said: <em>“This is inefficient. Why are we letting Foot Locker and local skate shops sell our shoes? We lose margin! The data says if we sell Direct-to-Consumer (DTC), we keep all the money!”</em></p><p>It was logically perfect. It was mathematically sound. It was the ultimate “Data-Driven” decision.</p><p>They cut off their wholesale partners. They pulled their product into their own ecosystem. They used their vast data troves to identify the best-selling models (Air Force 1s, Dunks, AJ1s) and they flooded the market with them because the algorithm said <em>demand is high</em>.</p><p><strong>They optimized for the transaction and killed the romance.</strong></p><p>By making the shoes easy to get, they killed the scarcity. By cutting out the local skate shops, they killed the cultural roots. They stopped innovating in performance running because the <em>sales data</em> said retro styles were the cash cow.</p><p>The result? In June 2024, the market woke up. The stock crashed, wiping out <strong>$25 billion in market value in a single day</strong>. But the true, unforgivable cost of the McKinsey data fetishism is the long-term strategic obliteration: as of today, Nike has hemorrhaged <strong>approximately $189 billion in value</strong> since its peak in November 2021 —<strong> </strong>a staggering loss of almost 65% of its market value.</p><p>As critics noted in the aftermath, Nike hadn’t just turned into a company run by spreadsheet managers — they had weaponized perfect data to destroy their own magic. They were drowning in numbers but starving for vision. In the process, they severed the one bond no algorithm can measure: their connection to the cultural tribes that made them matter. The sneakerheads, the local runners, the core community that validated the brand. And the moment you lose your cultural gatekeepers, the slaughter is inevitable.</p><h3>The Optimization of the “Local Maximum”</h3><p>Here is the technical term for what data people do to your software: <strong>Hill Climbing to a Local Maximum</strong>.</p><p>Imagine you are in a mountain range, blindfolded. You want to reach the highest peak (The Global Maximum). You decide that your strategy is to always take a step in the direction that goes <em>up</em>.</p><p>This works for a while. You climb. The numbers go up! The conversion rate increases by 5.2%! You feel great.</p><p>Eventually, you reach the top of a hill. Every step you take now leads down. You declare victory. “We have optimized the product!”</p><p>But if you took off the blindfold — if you used your <em>eyes</em> and your <em>imagination</em> — you would see that you are standing on a tiny mound of dirt, and right next to you is Mount Everest.</p><p>Data keeps you on the little mound. It terrifies you into staying there, because to get to Everest, you have to go <em>down</em> first. You have to traverse the valley of uncertainty. You have to try something that the metrics say is a “bad idea” in the short term to achieve a breakthrough in the long term.</p><p>Data people hate the valley. The valley ruins their quarterly OKRs. So they keep you on the molehill, polishing the dirt, insisting that this is as good as it gets.</p><h3>The Burnt Pizza Experiment</h3><p>There is another subtle trap in the modern obsession with experimentation, and it hides behind the seemingly noble phrase <em>“Let the data decide.”</em></p><p>In theory, this sounds wonderfully scientific. Form a hypothesis, build the smallest possible version of the idea, release it into the world, and observe what happens. The market will tell you the truth.</p><p>But there is a quiet assumption buried in this logic: that the thing you put into the world is at least <em>competent</em>.</p><p>Very often, it isn’t.</p><figure><img alt="Famous burnt pizza meme, showing a burnt pizza and then declaring there’s no demand for pizza." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/418/0*sZxEsIfXu-AJuVcB.jpg" /></figure><p>You may have seen the now-famous “Minimum Viable Pizza” meme. A team wants to test a simple hypothesis: <em>Can we sell pizza for profit?</em> In the spirit of lean experimentation, they move quickly. Four minutes later, they produce a blackened, charcoal-looking disk that vaguely resembles something that once aspired to be food.</p><p>They show it to customers.</p><p>The result, unsurprisingly, is devastating: nobody wants it.</p><p>The data is clear. The hypothesis is rejected. The team writes the learning on the whiteboard: <em>“There is no demand for pizza.”</em></p><p>On paper, the process looks rational. The experiment was run. The metrics were collected. The conclusion is backed by evidence.</p><p>But the evidence did not measure the demand for pizza.</p><p><strong>It measured the demand for burnt pizza.</strong></p><p>This distinction sounds trivial, but it quietly destroys a shocking amount of “data-driven learning.” When an experiment fails, teams almost never question the quality of the thing they shipped. Instead, they assume the market has spoken.</p><p>The market, however, is not answering the question you think you asked. It is simply reacting to what you put in front of it.</p><p>If the prototype is clumsy, the experience awkward, the design uninspired, or the execution rushed, the resulting data says very little about the idea itself. It says almost everything about your implementation of it.</p><p>And here lies the psychological trick: the numbers give the outcome a veneer of objectivity. Killing the idea feels intellectually honest. You are not rejecting the vision; you are <em>respecting the data</em>.</p><p>But sometimes the data is not telling you the idea was wrong.</p><p>It is telling you the pizza was terrible.</p><h3>The Defense (Because I have to)</h3><p>Now, before the Data Scientists start dossing me: <strong>Sit down.</strong></p><p>I am not saying we should return to the stone age. And I am not saying you should run a business on vibes alone.</p><p><strong>Not all data is bad.</strong> That would be a stupid thing to say.</p><ul><li><strong>Sales numbers</strong> are a scoreboard. You need to know if you are winning or losing.</li><li><strong>Performance metrics</strong> are a mechanic. You need to know if the engine is overheating.</li><li><strong>Retention data</strong> is a health check.</li></ul><p>Data is fantastic at <strong>diagnostics</strong>. It tells you <em>what</em> is happening. <strong>But it is completely worthless if you cannot ask the imaginative question first.</strong></p><p>The case of <strong>Survivorship Bias</strong> from World War II proves this perfectly. When Allied bombers returned from Europe, they were riddled with bullet holes. Analysts proposed reinforcing the most damaged areas — the wings and tail — believing these were the most vulnerable.</p><p>But the mathematician <strong>Abraham Wald</strong> had the strategic vision to ask: <em>Why are we only looking at the returning planes?</em></p><p>Wald realized the data was incomplete: the planes that crashed and never returned were hit in the <strong>unmarked areas</strong> (the cockpit and engines). The data they had only showed where the plane <strong>could afford to be hit and survive</strong>. His solution was counter-intuitive, but correct: <strong>Reinforce the parts that showed no damage</strong> on the survivors.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*aZmA_3f18TzHQ7aHKi14ow.png" /><figcaption>Source: <a href="https://wordzz.com/finding-the-missing-bullet-holes/">Wordzz.com</a></figcaption></figure><p>This is the central lesson: When you build a predictive model, the active, measurable data you feed it is primarily the map of the things that worked or survived your current environment (your successful customers, your retained users, your thriving products). To innovate, you need the vision to identify the failure cases that never entered your model, and the strategic logic to invest in the unquantified solution.</p><p>Because of this fundamental, survival-driven bias in the data we actively measure, data is terrible at strategy; it can analyze the tracks left behind, but it can never chart the course ahead.</p><h3>The Verdict: Put Down the Hammer</h3><p>We need to stop treating data analysis as the highest form of intelligence. It isn’t. It is the easiest form of intelligence. It is rote, mechanical, and safe.</p><p>The highest form of intelligence is synthesis. It is the ability to take the data — the diagnostic information — and mix it with intuition, cultural awareness, psychology, and a healthy dose of reckless fantasy, to create something that sparks a vision, ignites genuine joy, and makes a user stop and say, “Wow.”</p><p>Tony Fadell — the guy who helped build the iPod and iPhone, so not exactly shouting from the cheap seats — puts it bluntly:</p><blockquote>“No amount of data will tell you if a feature should be in the product, because it doesn’t exist. You need a clear leader with a clear point of view… otherwise, you get a mishmash of features and stuff that doesn’t make a lot of sense.”</blockquote><p>Because that’s what happens when synthesis is replaced by spreadsheets. You don’t get vision. You get accumulation.</p><p>Ultimately, we need fewer people who can build dashboards, and more people who can build worlds — so the data people actually have something worthwhile to measure.</p><p>So, take a look at your roadmap. Is it a list of bold, terrifying ideas that might fail but could change the world? Or is it a list of 45 minor optimizations designed to move a metric by 1% so you can tell your boss you did a “good job”?</p><p>If it’s the latter, congratulations. You’re good at math. But you’re bad at business.</p><p>End the end, data is a nothing but a mirror showing you what you were. So stop admiring the reflection, and look through the window. Because in a world of optimization, the greatest competitive advantage is simply having an imagination.</p><h3>A note on AI use</h3><p>This piece was written by me — with a little help. Like many non-native English speakers, I use AI as a creative assistant to sharpen phrasing, stress-test arguments, and catch idioms I might otherwise miss. It doesn’t write for me — it helps me write <em>more like me</em>.</p><p>I’ve shared more thoughts on this here: <a href="https://medium.com/@christian.hartvig/ai-isnt-ruining-writing-it-s-finally-giving-non-native-speakers-a-voice-2fdbde4fa870">“AI isn’t ruining writing — it’s finally giving non-native speakers a voice”</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2ecabe56cb06" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Your Idea Isn’t Worth Anything — Until You Do This]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@christian.hartvig/your-idea-isnt-worth-anything-until-you-do-this-5e2bc2ec633b?source=rss-940ef270fe1f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5e2bc2ec633b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[productivity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[entrepreneurship]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[personal-development]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[creativity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[startup]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Christian Hartvig]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 21 Sep 2025 12:25:34 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-09-21T14:18:06.156Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Your Idea Isn’t Worth Anything — Until You Do This</h3><h4>Your genius idea won’t save you. In fact, it’s worthless — unless you’re willing to do the one thing most avoid.</h4><figure><img alt="A glowing neon sign reading “IDEAS” being sliced apart by a chainsaw held by strong hands, sparks and bright colors illuminating the red background." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*JadtBS347aPDXzuIYTuWqg.png" /><figcaption>Image created with a little help from AI.</figcaption></figure><p><strong>I’m sorry.</strong></p><p>I have a confession. This piece is really based on a personal love story — hang on, it’s not what you expect. It starts with my girlfriend — and the uncomfortable truth she accidentally taught me about ideas.</p><p>You see, I live with a saint. A woman so loving, selfless, and generous she could probably qualify for canonization if sainthood were based on emotional labor. She’s brilliant, funny, supportive — and like so many people, she’s also a dreamer. She dreams of being her own boss, of making more money, of finally living a life where almond butter doesn’t have to be a budget line item.</p><p>But there’s one problem: she dreams more than she does.</p><p>Not when it comes to her training — she’s a machine there, relentless, disciplined. But with her ideas? That’s where hesitation sets in. She spins visions with dazzling detail, sometimes down to the color of the office walls, only for the whole thing to evaporate when the next shiny idea arrives.</p><p>But this isn’t about her. It’s about all of us. Because she’s caught in the same trap millions are: worshipping the idea, fearing the execution.</p><h3>The Cult of the Big Idea</h3><p>We live in a culture that fetishizes the “big idea” like it’s some kind of divine lightning strike. Every TED talk, startup pitch, and business-school case study feeds the myth that what separates the winners from the losers is a singular moment of genius.</p><p>It’s a lie.</p><p>The world isn’t short on ideas. It’s drowning in them. Every failed startup graveyard, every dusty patent archive, every half-finished business plan sitting in a drawer is proof.</p><p>Take the Segway. Remember the hype? Launched in 2001, it was hailed as the invention that would “revolutionize personal transport.” Steve Jobs himself allegedly said it would be “bigger than the PC.” Investors poured in $90 million before launch. The idea was shiny. The reality? The Segway was expensive, impractical, and made you look like a mall cop on probation. By 2020, it was dead.</p><p>Compare that to Facebook. Social networking wasn’t Zuckerberg’s idea. Friendster and MySpace got there first. What Zuckerberg did was execute faster, better, and more ruthlessly than anyone else. The difference between Segway and Facebook isn’t brilliance. It’s execution.</p><p>Ideas are seductive because they’re flawless in your head. They’re dopamine with no hangover. You can imagine ten unicorns before breakfast and feel like a genius without doing a single thing. But once you drag them into the light, they collapse under the weight of reality.</p><p>Which is why most people keep them in their heads. Safer that way.</p><h3>The Perfectionism Trap</h3><p>Dreamers cling to one seductive lie — perfectionism: that an idea must be perfect before it’s worth starting. Perfect plan, perfect timing, perfect pitch.</p><p>But nothing enters the world perfect. The first iPhone couldn’t even copy and paste. Windows ’95 crashed like a toddler learning to walk. SpaceX rockets exploded so spectacularly they looked like expensive fireworks displays. And even Netflix began as a fragile DVD rental service that nearly went bankrupt.</p><p>Perfection isn’t the starting line. It’s the mirage on the horizon. Wait for it, and you’ll die of thirst. Start anyway, and you might stumble into water.</p><p>Because here’s the truth: plans are comforting lies. They make you feel in control — but reality doesn’t care. Mike Tyson said it best: <em>“Everyone has a plan — until they get punched in the mouth.”</em> And execution is just that — getting punched in the mouth, again and again, while you keep moving forward.</p><p>Reid Hoffman, co-founder of LinkedIn, took it further: <em>“Starting a company is like jumping off a cliff and assembling an airplane on the way down.”</em> You don’t get the luxury of sketching the perfect jet in a safe little conference room. You start falling, you build with whatever’s in reach, and you pray the wings hold before you hit the ground.</p><p>That’s why flexibility is everything. On the surface, it looks like the opposite of perfection — messy, inconsistent, even chaotic. But it’s the only thing that lets you survive contact with reality. Flexibility means admitting you were wrong quickly, pivoting without ego, and seeing every mistake as new data instead of a personal failure.</p><p>And this is where the <em>“if you really want something”</em> moment comes in. If you truly want something, you will find a way — even if that way looks nothing like what you first imagined. If you don’t really want it, you’ll find an excuse. And <strong>perfectionism is the most elegant excuse ever invented</strong> — because it sounds noble. It sounds like “high standards.” But really, it’s just fear in a tuxedo.</p><p>Flexibility, on the other hand, is raw and uncomfortable. It requires you to kill your darlings, scrap weeks of work, admit you were wrong yesterday and start again today. It looks messy, but it’s the only way anything actually improves. Perfection seeks control; flexibility seeks progress.</p><h3>School: The Factory of Fear</h3><p>Where does this obsession with perfection come from? School.</p><p>We’re raised in systems where mistakes are the worst thing you can make. Red ink on the page, grades that haunt you, teachers who measure compliance more than curiosity. Every error is treated as failure, not as raw material for learning.</p><p>By adulthood, the wiring is set. The thought of making a mistake — of launching something half-baked, of failing in public — triggers the same humiliation as a giant red X scrawled across a test. So we wait. We delay. We fantasize about success rather than risk visible failure.</p><p>But here’s the irony: the fields that actually produce greatness are built on failure. Science runs on disproven hypotheses. Art evolves through experimentation. Business is trial and error with a balance sheet.</p><p>Edison didn’t stumble on the lightbulb by brilliance alone. He failed a thousand times, then shrugged and called it “data.” The Wright brothers didn’t fly on the first try — they crashed so often they could have opened a scrapyard. But they kept iterating.</p><p>School teaches compliance. Reality demands iteration. And iteration requires mistakes. Which means perfection isn’t just unattainable — it’s a dangerous illusion.</p><h3>The Cult of Excuses</h3><p>If perfectionism is fear in a tuxedo, excuses are fear in sweatpants — lazy, comfortable, and perfectly at home on the couch.</p><p>Excuses are seductive because they sound reasonable. <em>I can’t start until I get a better laptop.</em> Fair enough. You get the laptop — and now it’s the wrong color and doesn’t inspire you. <em>I can’t work from home, the space is too small.</em> So you move to a bigger place — and now there’s too much to clean and that becomes the excuse.</p><p>This is how excuses work: they’re not roadblocks, they’re detours. They let you keep moving, but only in circles. You feel busy, but you never actually get anywhere.</p><p>And circles are comforting. They give you the illusion of progress without the risk of forward motion. That’s why excuses almost always come paired with procrastination — the quiet little contract you sign with yourself that says: <em>I’ll start tomorrow. Next week. After the holidays. When things calm down.</em></p><p>But things never calm down. There will always be one more thing — the perfect desk, the perfect software, the perfect timing. And in the meantime, you’ll keep filling the space with distractions that feel harmless: one more episode, one more scroll, one more “just checking my phone.”</p><p>But here’s the truth that stings: if you have time to binge-watch an entire series, to scroll Instagram until your thumb cramps, to watch strangers on TikTok live lives you wish you had — you have time for your dreams. Every hour you give away to someone else’s content is an hour stolen from the life you could be building.</p><p>And that theft is subtle — until it isn’t. Procrastination feels cheap in the moment, but it compounds. Every day you delay, the gap between the life you want and the life you have grows just a little wider.</p><p>Excuses feel comfortable. Procrastination feels safe. But together, they’re the most expensive habit you’ll ever have — because the price of procrastination is the life you could’ve lived.</p><h3>Imperfection as the Entry Fee</h3><p>The tragedy is that imperfection isn’t a bug in the system. It’s the price of admission.</p><p>No product, company, or movement ever enters the world fully formed. They start ugly, incomplete, often embarrassing. The first versions are never the ones you’d brag about. But without those awkward first steps, there’s no growth, no maturity, no mastery.</p><p>Pixar, of all places, knows this better than anyone. Ed Catmull, the studio’s co-founder, calls new ideas “ugly babies.” At birth, a story or character is fragile, awkward, unconvincing — not something you’d show to the world. But like real babies, these ugly beginnings need protection, not ridicule. If you expect perfection too early, you strangle them before they can grow. Every Pixar masterpiece you know — <em>Toy Story</em>, <em>Finding Nemo</em>, <em>Inside Out</em> — began life as an ugly baby. What made the difference wasn’t genius, but relentless iteration.</p><p>Doers understand this. They accept the humiliation, the mess, the clumsiness of beginning. They know that failure is simply tuition paid to the school of execution. Dreamers, on the other hand, keep waiting for a shortcut — a way to bypass the mess and arrive at perfection instantly.</p><p>That shortcut doesn’t exist. The only way out is through.</p><h3>Execution: The Cruel Gatekeeper</h3><p>If ideas are free and perfection is a mirage, execution is the cruel bouncer at the door of reality. It doesn’t care about your dreams, your passion, your “manifestation journal,” or the fact that your friends think your idea is genius. Execution only asks one question: Did you do the work?</p><p>Execution is boring. It’s repetitive. It’s the grind of spreadsheets, the humiliation of rejection, the endless debugging, the awkward sales calls, the supplier who screws you, the customer who ghosts you.</p><p>Execution is ugly. It exposes you. It shows you that your idea isn’t special, that your product isn’t loved, that you aren’t ready. It drags your shiny fantasy into a street fight with reality.</p><p>And yet — execution is the only way anything ever gets built. The cathedral wasn’t a sketch, it was stone laid in freezing rain for decades. Nike’s “Just Do It” isn’t a slogan; it’s the entire philosophy of execution distilled to three words.</p><p>Execution is unfair, unglamorous, and cruel. But it’s also the great equalizer. You don’t need to be the smartest, richest, or most visionary. You just need to show up and outlast. That’s it.</p><h3>Dreamers vs. Builders</h3><p>Let’s be clear: there is no builder without a dream. Every skyscraper started as a sketch. Every company as a fantasy. Every movement as a wild idea in someone’s head. Dreaming isn’t the problem. Dreaming is the spark.</p><p>The problem is stopping there.</p><p>The people who actually move the world aren’t the ones with the wildest dreams, but the ones who refuse to let those dreams stay fantasies. They take the same fragile, imperfect sparks everyone else discards and drag them — screaming, stumbling, embarrassing — through the fire of execution.</p><p>Jobs dreamed of personal computers, sure. So did dozens of others. He’s remembered because he built them. Zuckerberg wasn’t the first nerd with a social network idea — he’s remembered because he executed faster and meaner. Musk wasn’t the first kid to stare at the night sky and dream of rockets. He’s remembered because he lit the fuse.</p><p>Builders aren’t a different species. They’re dreamers who stayed in the fight after it stopped being fun.</p><p>Dreaming without doing is fantasy. Doing without dreaming is labor. But dreaming <em>and</em> doing — that’s creation.</p><h3>The Savage Bottom Line</h3><p>Dreaming is free. Execution charges interest.</p><p>You pay with late nights, with ego bruises, with broken plans, with the humiliation of being wrong in public. You pay with boredom, with fear, with the pain of starting over when you’d rather quit.</p><p>But that’s the price of building anything that matters. And the price is non-negotiable.</p><p>There’s no hack, no shortcut, no version where you get to keep your dream spotless and untested. The world doesn’t reward what’s in your head — only what survives the fight to exist.</p><p>So stop waiting. Stop polishing the fantasy. Get punched in the mouth, pivot, keep swinging.</p><p>Because in the end, your dreams don’t work unless you do.</p><h3>A note on AI use</h3><p>This piece was written by me — with a little help. Like many non-native English speakers, I use AI as a creative assistant to sharpen phrasing, stress-test arguments, and catch idioms I might otherwise miss. It doesn’t write for me — it helps me write <em>more like me</em>.</p><p>I’ve shared more thoughts on this here: <a href="https://medium.com/@christian.hartvig/ai-isnt-ruining-writing-it-s-finally-giving-non-native-speakers-a-voice-2fdbde4fa870">“AI isn’t ruining writing — it’s finally giving non-native speakers a voice”</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5e2bc2ec633b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why I’m Not a Feminist (and You Probably Aren’t Either)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@christian.hartvig/why-im-not-a-feminist-and-you-probably-aren-t-either-bb66467e6dd5?source=rss-940ef270fe1f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/bb66467e6dd5</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[feminism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-justice]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[language]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[humanity]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Christian Hartvig]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 20 Sep 2025 10:03:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-02-03T05:55:10.191Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Feminism won. Now it’s policing language, inventing battles, and shrinking debate. Here’s why humanism — not hashtags — might be the real way forward.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/768/1*XicFziorV6m66atPKISOHQ@2x.jpeg" /><figcaption>Image created with a little help from AI.</figcaption></figure><p>Let’s start with the part no reasonable person can argue with:</p><p>There was a time when feminism wasn’t just noble — it was necessary. When it meant fighting for rights so basic it’s almost embarrassing to list them: the right to vote, to own property, to have a bank account without a husband’s signature. To get a job based on ability, not anatomy.</p><p>These weren’t luxuries. They were the bare minimum of being treated as fully human. The women (and men) who fought for them were warriors of the highest order. If the word <em>brave</em> belongs anywhere, it’s there — not under a filtered selfie with #BossBabe.</p><h3>The Awkward Truth</h3><p>In most of the developed world, the major battles were won decades ago. The laws changed. The barriers fell. The peace treaty, for the most part, was signed.</p><p>And yet the banners still wave. The chants still echo — not because the enemy is at the gate, but because outrage has become an identity.</p><p>Movements that forget they’ve won don’t just lose relevance. They start inventing new battles to justify their existence.</p><h3>From Rights to Ritual</h3><p>The original purpose of feminism was laser-focused: correct systemic injustices, create equal legal standing, dismantle obvious barriers. It had clarity, urgency, and moral weight.</p><p>But modern feminism has drifted from cause to culture. It’s less about human rights and more about maintaining the brand of “feminist” as a cultural badge. Each generation seems determined to be louder, more radical, more uncompromising — even if the ground they’re standing on was secured long ago.</p><p>It’s the political version of an aging rock band that keeps touring, not because there’s new music, but because they can’t bear to step off the stage.</p><p>What began as a fight for equal pay morphs into campaigns for preferential hiring. What started as a push for safety morphs into policing language, tone, even facial expressions. The war cry turns inward, and suddenly the enemy isn’t injustice — it’s anyone insufficiently pure in their feminism.</p><p>When the rallying point is no longer justice but identity, the struggle stops being a means to an end — and becomes the end itself.</p><h3>Equality Isn’t a Gender — It’s a Species</h3><p>Here’s a radical proposal: stop thinking like a feminist. Start thinking like a humanist.</p><p>Humanism has one quiet, underrated strength: it recognises that while we are all human, we are also all individuals. We are alike enough to connect — but different enough that it matters. That’s the beauty of being human.</p><p>Biology makes sure of it. Men and women are built differently from the start — hormonally, neurologically, physically — and that’s not a measure of worth. Pretending those differences don’t exist isn’t progressive; it’s dishonest. Muscle distribution, hormonal cycles, brain structure, and reproductive roles all differ in ways that shape our abilities, behaviours, and preferences.</p><p>Yes, some of those differences may feel “unfair.” But that unfairness isn’t a conspiracy built into the legal system — it’s built into life itself. You can no more legislate away sexual dimorphism than you can outlaw gravity.</p><p>Humanism doesn’t erase differences. It builds equality that can survive them. And nowhere is that need clearer than in the way we’ve started policing ordinary human behaviour.</p><h3>Words Mean Things</h3><p>Let’s clear up another modern linguistic fantasy: the idea that feminism “isn’t just about women.”</p><p>If you believe that, you don’t just misunderstand the movement — you misunderstand the word itself.</p><p>Femi- comes from the Latin <em>femina</em>, meaning “woman.”</p><p>-ism comes from the Greek <em>-ismos</em>, meaning “belief system” or “ideology.”</p><p>Put them together, and you don’t get “a movement for everyone.” You get “an ideology centered on women.” Claiming otherwise is like insisting monotheism is about many gods or that veganism includes bacon.</p><p>And yes — sorry for mansplaining the dictionary here. But words matter. If we start twisting them to mean the opposite of what they say, we’re not expanding the definition. We’re erasing it.</p><p>If we can’t even agree on what the word <em>means</em>, what exactly are we debating?</p><h3>The Mansplaining Farce</h3><p>Few words have done more to police behaviour — or to shrink the conversation — than <em>mansplaining</em>.</p><p>Explaining things, wanted or not, is one of humanity’s oldest social habits. People do it across every gender, age group, and culture. Sometimes it’s arrogance. Sometimes it’s overconfidence. Often, it’s just enthusiasm. We share what we know. We clarify when we think someone’s confused. And yes, we sometimes overdo it and look like idiots. That’s not a gender flaw. That’s just being human.</p><p>Somewhere along the way, this universal habit got rebranded as a male-only crime and given a hashtag. The story goes that men have a unique urge to explain things to women who already know them — a neat narrative, if you ignore that women do it to women, women do it to men, and men do it to men.</p><p>Strip away the outrage, and another truth emerges: for many men, explaining something isn’t about dominance at all — it’s about giving. Not a power move, but an ancient reflex older than language itself.</p><p>Across the animal kingdom, males court and connect by offering value. The male penguin searches for the smoothest pebble and lays it at his mate’s feet. The bowerbird spends days arranging scraps of colour to impress. The male chimp offers food to build bonds.</p><p>Human males are no different. We give flowers (rarely met with complaints), we give jewellery (also generally well received), and we give knowledge. The first two are called romantic; the third is hashtagged as an insult. Yet the root impulse is the same: a hardwired instinct to signal care, impress, and offer something useful.</p><p>Yes, it can be clumsy. Yes, it can miss the mark. But so can giving someone roses when they’re allergic to pollen.</p><p>And when a woman does something presumptuous or overbearing, we don’t rush to make it a gender issue. We don’t have <em>womanterrupting</em> or <em>womanconcluding</em> as hashtags. We don’t turn female behaviour into a cultural punchline. And we shouldn’t — because most of the time, people are just being people.</p><p>The double standard is obvious: when men do it, it’s a gender problem. When women do it, it’s just Tuesday.</p><p>And that’s the real danger of the term <em>mansplaining</em>: it takes a universal human habit and paints it as male-only. Which is, ironically, sexism wrapped in feminist paper — or, just as often, in personal convenience. The real trick? It hands out moral high ground on demand: claim the victim’s chair, and every counterpoint becomes an attack, every disagreement proof of guilt.</p><p>Let’s not pretend that makes the world fairer. It just makes the conversation smaller.</p><h3>When Equality Becomes a Sport</h3><p>The tragedy of post-victory feminism is that it treats equality like an Olympic sport where every generation must beat the last record. But once you’ve crossed the finish line, the only way to “win” again is to move the goalposts — or start taking from the other team.</p><p>This is how we end up with corporate diversity schemes that openly prioritise gender over merit — something that would be condemned as discrimination if the roles were reversed. It’s how symbolic victories — changing job titles, banning words, adding hashtags — get mistaken for structural progress.</p><p>Once the central injustice is solved, the machinery built to fight it has to find new targets to justify its existence. Without real oppression, every slight becomes a crisis, every disagreement becomes violence, every unflattering statistic becomes conspiracy.</p><h3>The Scoreboard of Victories</h3><p>When the scoreboard becomes more important than the game, you’re no longer playing for equality. You’re playing to win, at any cost.</p><p>And part of that full picture is this: women have been winning — spectacularly — in many areas of modern life. These victories deserve celebration, not denial, because they’re the reason we get to have a conversation about what comes next instead of still fighting the battles of the past.</p><p>Women aren’t just catching up. In many places, they’ve surged ahead — rewriting what “normal” looks like in education, work, and leadership:</p><ul><li><strong>Education:</strong> University campuses are now majority female. In the U.S., nearly 60% of bachelor’s degrees go to women, along with most master’s and PhDs (<a href="https://nces.ed.gov/fastfacts/display.asp?id=72">NCES</a>).</li><li><strong>Health and Longevity:</strong> Women live five to seven years longer than men in most developed nations (<a href="https://www.who.int/data/gho/data/themes/mortality-and-global-health-estimates">WHO</a>). They also smoke less, drink less, and die less often from preventable causes — which is another way of saying they’ve cracked the code on staying alive.</li><li><strong>Professional Fields:</strong> In medicine, law, and education, women are now the majority of new entrants. In some countries, becoming a male doctor is statistically more unusual than becoming a female one (<a href="https://www.mckinsey.com/featured-insights/diversity-and-inclusion">McKinsey</a>).</li><li><strong>Wealth:</strong> Women control about a third of the world’s wealth, and this share is projected to approach parity in the next two decades (<a href="https://www.bcg.com/publications/2020/managing-next-decade-women-wealth">BCG</a>).</li><li><strong>Leadership:</strong> Representation is climbing steadily — from boardrooms to parliaments — with countries like Iceland, New Zealand, and Finland setting global records (<a href="https://www.weforum.org/reports/global-gender-gap-report-2023">WEF</a>).</li><li><strong>Entrepreneurship:</strong> Women-owned businesses are growing at twice the national average in the U.S. (<a href="https://about.americanexpress.com/files/doc_library/file/2019-state-of-women-owned-businesses-report.pdf">AmEx Report</a>).</li></ul><p>None of this means sexism is gone. There are still glass ceilings, sticky floors, and industries where women remain underrepresented. But it does mean the narrative that nothing has changed is no longer the whole story.</p><p>And while women have been smashing ceilings, men have quietly started falling through the floorboards. Boys are now trailing in school performance, fewer men are earning degrees, and men make up the majority of workplace deaths, suicides, and homelessness cases (<a href="https://www.oecd.org/education/education-at-a-glance/">OECD</a>, <a href="https://www.cdc.gov/suicide/facts/index.html">CDC</a>).</p><p>If equality is really the goal, then we have to celebrate these wins — and take seriously the new gaps opening up. Because the point isn’t to keep playing until one side wins forever. It’s to call the game when the score is even and start building something better together.</p><h3>The Humanist Endgame</h3><p>If you actually care about equality, there’s only one position that survives the stress test of logic: <strong>humanism</strong>. Not feminism. Not men’s rights. Not any ideology that starts by dividing the room into teams and then wonders why the fight never ends.</p><p>Humanism begins with a simple premise: your rights are not a favour, not a quota, not a concession handed to you because you fit a category. They are your birthright, stamped into you the moment you drew breath. It refuses the lazy fiction that people are interchangeable units in some grand social spreadsheet. It knows that fairness does not always mean symmetry, and that recognising difference is not the same as creating hierarchy.</p><p>It is harder work than identity politics because it demands that we meet each other as individuals, not avatars of a tribe. It requires curiosity instead of assumptions, responsibility instead of entitlement, and the courage to judge a person by their actions, not their labels.</p><p>The irony — and the tragedy — is that true equality isn’t exciting. It doesn’t trend. It doesn’t need slogans, hashtags, or daily outrage to keep it alive. It’s a quiet, steady state of mutual respect. And for those addicted to the adrenaline of conflict, that’s unbearable. Without an enemy, they wouldn’t know who they were.</p><h3>Retire the Labels</h3><p>Here’s the part everyone pretends not to hear: movements end. Not because the ideals were wrong, but because the mission was achieved. The honest thing to do after victory isn’t to keep marching — it’s to lay down the banners and build the peace. That requires maturity, not marketing.</p><p>So retire the labels. Keep the wins; lose the uniforms. If equality is the goal, stop issuing team jerseys. Your rights are not a loyalty program. They don’t accrue faster because you shout the right slogans or wear the right badge. They belong to you because you’re human — full stop.</p><p>This doesn’t mean silence in the face of real injustice. It means precision. Fight specific harms with specific remedies. Not quotas dressed up as justice. Not language games that fix nothing in the real world. If a company cheats on merit, call it what it is: corruption. If a law discriminates, change the law. That’s adulthood — action without theatrics.</p><p>Humanism is the upgrade path. It asks us to meet each other without costumes: no saints, no villains, just citizens bound by the same rights and duties. It’s harder than chanting, because it forces us to judge people by their choices, not their categories. It’s also fairer, cleaner, and far more resilient.</p><p>Because the moment you divide the room by gender, you’ve already lost the war you claim to be fighting.</p><p>The future isn’t pink or blue.</p><p>It’s human.</p><h3>A note on AI use</h3><p>This piece was written by me — with a little help. Like many non-native English speakers, I use AI as a creative assistant to sharpen phrasing, stress-test arguments, and catch idioms I might otherwise miss. It doesn’t write for me — it helps me write <em>more like me</em>.</p><p>I’ve shared more thoughts on this here: <a href="https://medium.com/@christian.hartvig/ai-isnt-ruining-writing-it-s-finally-giving-non-native-speakers-a-voice-2fdbde4fa870">“AI isn’t ruining writing — it’s finally giving non-native speakers a voice”</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=bb66467e6dd5" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[ADHD Didn’t Rise. Parenting Collapsed.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@christian.hartvig/adhd-didnt-rise-parenting-collapsed-793988ecc9c7?source=rss-940ef270fe1f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/793988ecc9c7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[adhd]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[life]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[society]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[parenting]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[children]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Christian Hartvig]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 31 Aug 2025 16:46:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-11-09T07:11:24.285Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Why the ADHD boom isn’t about children who can’t sit still. It’s about adults who can’t stand up.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Qgm1xrOzD4JMZZXngxlEpQ.png" /><figcaption>Image created with a little help from AI.</figcaption></figure><p>ADHD is the new gluten intolerance. Everybody seems to have it, nobody can define it, and the cure is conveniently available on prescription with free refills.</p><p>If you looked only at the stats, you’d think the human brain had experienced a sudden mass extinction event sometime around 1995. ADHD diagnoses in the U.S. nearly doubled between 1997 and 2016 (<a href="https://www.cdc.gov/ncbddd/adhd/data.html">CDC</a>). Evolution, however, does not work like a Silicon Valley app update. Our species didn’t suddenly glitch. So, what did? Parenting.</p><p>The so-called “rise” in ADHD is not a neurological epidemic. It’s the fallout of parents who can’t parent, schools that can’t teach, and an industry that figured out there’s more money in medicating restless kids than in telling adults to put their damn phones down and raise them.</p><p>But to see how this delusion took root, we have to start with the most basic transformation: how ordinary childhood behavior was rebranded as disease.</p><h3>From Tantrum to Diagnosis: How Childhood Became a Disorder</h3><p>There was a time when children misbehaved and the explanation was brutally simple: kids are chaotic little humans who need to be taught how to behave. Johnny flicked pencils in math class? The teacher glared, maybe barked his name, and Johnny sat down — chastened, if only for five minutes. Emily drifted into a daydream during geography? She got called back with a sharp question about mountain ranges or rivers. Children were restless, forgetful, impulsive, stubborn. In other words: they were children.</p><p>Fast forward to today, and every ordinary act of childhood has been rebranded as a symptom. Johnny isn’t mischievous, he’s “presenting signs of hyperactivity.” Emily isn’t bored, she’s “showing inattentive tendencies.” The restless, the dreamy, the stubborn — all neatly folded into a diagnostic checklist. Parents leave the pediatrician’s office with a prescription slip in hand, a tidy medical explanation, and, most importantly, the absolution that none of this is their fault.</p><p>This is the quiet seduction of diagnosis: it shifts the blame. A label relieves the parent of guilt, the teacher of responsibility, and the child of learning self-control. A bad report card isn’t a problem to solve; it’s a condition to manage. What was once the domain of discipline and patience has become the jurisdiction of psychiatry.</p><p>The cruel joke is that ADHD has become the 21st-century version of “the dog ate my homework” — an all-purpose alibi for why expectations can’t be met. But unlike the old excuse, this one comes wrapped in medical authority and garnished with pills. And when everyone nods along in sympathy, no one is forced to ask the uncomfortable questions: Why can’t my child focus? What environment am I building around them? How much of this problem is actually me?</p><p>And once childhood was pathologized, the next step was inevitable: pathologies became markets. Which brings us to the real winners of this epidemic.</p><h3>The Billion-Dollar Babysitter: Pharma’s Quietest Success Story</h3><p>Follow the money, and the story writes itself. ADHD isn’t just a diagnosis anymore; it’s an industry — a finely tuned machine where children’s restlessness is alchemized into shareholder value.</p><p>By 2022, the U.S. market for ADHD medication was worth more than $10.5 billion annually (<a href="https://www.iqvia.com/">IQVIA</a>). That’s not just a pile of pill bottles — that’s a Wall Street revenue stream, a dependable growth engine with children as the renewable resource. When demand wavers, awareness campaigns nudge it back up. When parents hesitate, sympathetic language softens them. When schools complain about disruptive classrooms, doctors prescribe. The cycle is beautifully self-reinforcing.</p><p>And it works because everyone wins — except the children. Teachers enjoy quieter classrooms, relieved from the burden of actually disciplining. Parents reclaim their evenings, spared the grind of holding their kids accountable. Doctors secure steady patients. Pharma companies toast quarterly earnings. The only ones not celebrating are the kids themselves, who are chemically tranquilized long before they’ve even learned the muscle of self-control.</p><p>But here’s the catch: medication isn’t a cure. It’s a quick hack — like taking painkillers for a broken leg. It dulls the discomfort just enough to keep everyone functioning, but the fracture remains. The real causes — fractured parenting, overstimulation, lack of discipline, broken schools — go unaddressed. Pills offer a temporary quiet, but at the cost of long-term growth. They mask symptoms while the disease — our cultural collapse of boundaries and responsibility — spreads unchecked.</p><p>This is not medicine in the noble sense of healing the sick. It’s narcotic babysitting, an outsourcing of responsibility dressed in clinical respectability. What we once expected from parenting and teaching has been converted into a subscription service. Pills have become the new pacifiers — not to ease teething pain, but to soothe the adults who don’t want to deal with the messy, inconvenient reality of raising children.</p><p>And if the pill is the pacifier, the screen is the babysitter. One chemical, one digital — both designed to keep children quiet while adults look away.</p><h3>Pixels and Pacifiers: Parenting in the Age of Screen Time</h3><p>If the 20th century was the age of the pacifier, the 21st century belongs to the iPad. The glowing rectangle has replaced bedtime stories, playgrounds, and even parental authority itself.</p><p>Hand a toddler a tablet before they can walk, and you’ve rewired their brain for instant dopamine rewards before they’ve mastered crayons. Every swipe is a tiny slot machine: unpredictable, stimulating, addictive. The brain’s reward system — once tuned by human interaction, play, and gradual learning — is hijacked by flashing lights, jump cuts, and algorithmic content designed to keep even adults hooked.</p><p>Pair that with a diet of processed sugar and a schedule stripped of unstructured play, and you’ve created a child who looks suspiciously like they “have ADHD.” The symptoms aren’t mysterious. They’re manufactured. Short attention spans? Try bingeing YouTube Kids, where scenes change faster than the human nervous system evolved to process. Hyperactivity? What do you expect when a seven-year-old is locked indoors like factory-farmed poultry and fueled by corn syrup? Forgetfulness? Hardly surprising when Alexa sets the reminders and Google provides every answer before the child has finished typing the question.</p><p>And parents defend this as “keeping them occupied.” But let’s call it what it is: outsourcing. Digital pacifiers are handed over not because they nurture, but because they’re convenient. The result is a generation raised by algorithms — children who learn more from autoplay than from their own parents.</p><p>Here’s the bitter irony: the same parents who fret that their children “can’t focus” are the ones who trained them to chase novelty every thirty seconds. And when the inevitable crash comes, they run to the doctor, who obligingly writes the prescription. A pill for every pixel. A diagnosis for every dopamine crash.</p><p>What we call ADHD in this context isn’t a disorder. It’s the logical outcome of parenting redesigned for convenience rather than growth. The screen may buy peace in the short term, but like feeding a child candy for dinner, it leaves them undernourished in ways you can’t see — until the bill comes due.</p><p>And yet, the story runs deeper than devices and sugar. Screens fell into a world already softened by ideology — a culture that had quietly dismantled boundaries and rebranded consequences as cruelty. To understand why the epidemic could take root so quickly, we have to rewind half a century.</p><h3>When “Free Spirit” Parenting Killed Consequences</h3><p>Part of this epidemic isn’t just iPads and sugar. It’s ideology. Specifically, the boomer inheritance: the “free spirit” parenting style that trickled down from the 1960s and 70s.</p><p>Once upon a time, consequences were as real as gravity. You forgot your homework? You failed. You mouthed off at the teacher? You got detention, if not a chalkboard eraser flung at your head with Olympic precision. You misbehaved at home? Let’s just say you learned very quickly that actions have reactions.</p><p>Then came the hippie revolution, which replaced rules with vibes. Discipline became “oppressive.” Boundaries were “conformist.” Children weren’t raised — they were “allowed to flourish.” Translation: little emperors grew up without a single law of consequence to shape them.</p><p>Fast forward fifty years, and those free-spirited flower children became parents. They raised kids not with structure, but with slogans: <em>follow your bliss, express yourself, you’re perfect just as you are.</em> Lovely words — until their toddler took “express yourself” to mean throwing spaghetti at the wall during dinner.</p><p>What happens when an entire generation is raised without consequences? You get children who believe rules are optional, effort is oppressive, and failure is negotiable. In other words: you get kids who look suspiciously like the diagnostic checklist for ADHD.</p><p>And this is why boundaries matter — not as cages, but as the very scaffolding of freedom itself.</p><h3>Guardrails, Not Prison Walls: Why Boundaries Are Love</h3><p>Here’s the paradox nobody likes to admit: children scream against boundaries, but they drown without them.</p><p>Think of boundaries as the shoreline to an ocean. Without land, water becomes a flood — shapeless, destructive, impossible to navigate. With land, it’s a beach: a place where kids can run, play, and even test the waves without being swallowed whole.</p><p>We’ve mistaken discipline for cruelty, as if saying “no” to a child will crush their spirit. In truth, boundaries are what make freedom possible. A child who has never been told “enough” is not free — they’re lost.</p><p>And society isn’t helping. Everything around kids today whispers the same poisonous lie: nothing is fixed, everything is negotiable. Teachers aren’t allowed to enforce rules, parents outsource discipline to screens, and entire institutions bend over backwards to ensure no child ever feels the sting of failure.</p><p>The result? Children grow up in a consequence-free theme park where rules are suggestions, grades can be argued, and even gravity feels optional. Until, of course, the real world shows up — and the real world is merciless. Banks don’t care about “free spirit.” Employers don’t hand out medals for “trying your best.” Reality is a wall, and if you’ve never been taught how to bump against smaller ones, you’ll shatter on the big one.</p><p>Children don’t just need boundaries for their own sake — they need them because society is built on them. Roads only work if people obey traffic lights. Games only work if players follow rules. Civilization itself is just one big network of boundaries we all agree to respect. To raise a child without them is not progressive. It’s negligent.</p><p>But instead of facing that truth, we hide behind excuses.</p><h3>The Psychology of Excuses</h3><p>Psychologists call it externalization: the neat trick of blaming everything outside yourself for the problems you don’t want to face inside. It’s the mental equivalent of sweeping dirt under someone else’s rug and pretending your floor is clean.</p><p>Parents who can’t say “no” to their kids find it far easier to say “yes” to a diagnosis. Schools that are too bureaucratic, too standardized, too exhausted to adapt prefer to ship off behavioral problems with a doctor’s note. And our wider culture, allergic to accountability, clings to the language of disorders because it feels more compassionate to say “it’s your neurology” than to admit “we’ve built an environment that’s a dopamine casino.”</p><p>This is the comforting story: if it’s biology, no one is at fault. If it’s “brain chemistry,” then neither parent nor school nor society must change. Responsibility is dissolved into the bloodstream, swallowed with a capsule. It’s the perfect arrangement: guilt anesthetized, children sedated, adults absolved.</p><p>But externalization has a hidden cost. Each time we blame biology for what culture created, we lose the will to fix the culture. If the child’s inability to focus is “neurological,” then there’s no reason to redesign classrooms, no reason to limit screens, no reason to enforce discipline. Excuses, once medicalized, become permanent. And a society that thrives on permanent excuses is one that slowly unlearns how to raise resilient human beings.</p><p>And when the excuses run out, only one truth remains — a truth as cruel as it is unavoidable.</p><h3>Parenting on Life Support: A Field Guide to Excuse-Making Adults</h3><p>The epidemic isn’t restless children. It’s pathetic parents. Adults who’ve outsourced every ounce of discipline to glowing rectangles and pill bottles, then clutch their pearls when little Timmy acts like a feral raccoon. A sampler platter of modern parenting “logic”:</p><blockquote><strong><em>“My kid just can’t sit still in class.”</em></strong></blockquote><p>Of course not. You raised him on YouTube jump cuts and Capri Suns. He’s basically a lab rat trained to hit the dopamine lever every three seconds. But sure — let’s call Pfizer, not a parenting coach.</p><blockquote><strong>“She gets really emotional when she doesn’t get her way.”</strong></blockquote><p>That’s not ADHD. That’s you being too spineless to survive a toddler tantrum without waving the white flag. Napoleon lost Waterloo with more dignity than you lose bedtime.</p><blockquote><strong>“He can’t focus on reading.”</strong></blockquote><p>Right. Because why read a book when you’ve spent his entire childhood proving that TikTok is more important than your voice? That’s not a diagnosis. That’s a mirror.</p><blockquote><strong>“She’s impossible in the mornings.”</strong></blockquote><p>Maybe because you let her scroll until 1 a.m. while you binge Netflix with noise-cancelling headphones on. That’s not neurology. That’s you parenting from the fetal position.</p><blockquote><strong>“He melts down when we take away the iPad.”</strong></blockquote><p>Yes, junkies tend to melt down when you take away their fix. You didn’t raise a child. You manufactured a tiny addict.</p><blockquote><strong>“She talks back constantly.”</strong></blockquote><p>Which is the natural result of being raised by adults who debate with their children like they’re members of parliament instead of just saying “go brush your damn teeth.”</p><p>And the pièce de résistance: parents who, after years of feeding their kids sugar, screens, and zero boundaries, finally declare: <strong><em>“There must be something wrong with his brain.”</em></strong> No. There’s something wrong with yours.</p><p>We don’t have an ADHD crisis. We have a crisis of adults who want all the perks of parenting — Instagram photos, Mother’s Day cards, genetic legacy — without doing the actual job. The children aren’t disordered. The parents are defective.</p><h3>The Cruel Truth Behind the ADHD Epidemic</h3><p>Of course, real ADHD exists. In rare and severe cases, it’s undeniable, and those children need genuine support. But the explosion of diagnoses we see today? That’s not medicine. That’s cultural theater — the performance of compassion, scripted by convenience.</p><p>Most kids don’t have ADHD. They have parents who treat them like Tamagotchis: keep them alive, push the button when they beep, and when the noise becomes too much, reach for the off-switch. Only this time the off-switch isn’t digital. It’s pharmaceutical.</p><p>And here’s where the cruelty cuts deep. Because what pills really deliver isn’t calm. It’s a story. A restless boy doesn’t hear, <em>you’ll learn patience, you’ll grow into discipline.</em> He hears, <em>you are defective — only chemicals can make you whole.</em> A distracted girl doesn’t learn resilience. She learns dependency.</p><p>If that sounds cruel, good. Because reality is crueller still. The reality is that we are sedating children not because they’re hopeless, but because the adults in charge have quietly given up. We are medicating childhood itself to cover for our own failures — our refusal to say no, to hold firm, to fight boredom with imagination instead of pixels. The real epidemic isn’t attention deficit. It’s responsibility deficit.</p><p>And this brings us to the final, uncomfortable truth: the problem was never the children. It was always us.</p><h3>The Theft of Diagnosis: Robbing the Most Defenseless</h3><p>The worst though? Well, let’s just say every time you borrow a diagnosis to excuse ordinary problems, you’re not just bending the truth. You’re robbing the people who can least afford to lose anything.</p><p>For a child with real ADHD, that label isn’t a fashionable hashtag or a convenient alibi. It’s the thin thread that keeps teachers from giving up on them entirely. For someone with real anxiety, it isn’t “I felt nervous before my presentation.” It’s nights of choking panic, days spent fighting an invisible enemy that never lets go. For a veteran with real PTSD, it isn’t “my breakup was traumatic.” It’s the battlefield following them home, exploding into their lives every time a door slams or a car backfires.</p><p>When you dilute those words, you’re not just softening them. You’re taking from the people who already have the least: credibility, patience from others, and the strength to explain themselves one more exhausting time. You make their battles even harder, their voices easier to dismiss. It’s like stealing bread from the starving — except the currency here is language, dignity, and belief.</p><p>That’s what casual diagnosis really is: not empathy, but exploitation. Not compassion, but cruelty wearing compassion’s mask. You get a comfortable excuse. They get another reason not to be believed. You get to avoid the hard work of parenting, of discipline, of self-reflection. They get stripped of the little protection a diagnosis was supposed to give them.</p><p>And if that doesn’t sting, it should. Because what you’re doing isn’t harmless. It’s theft — from the poor, the fragile, the defenseless. The ones who already carry more pain than they can bear — and should bear.</p><h3>Closing Note: Boredom, Boundaries, and the Forgotten Art of Parenting</h3><p>This was never about children. Children have not changed. They are still noisy, restless, impulsive, curious — maddening and magnificent in equal measure. What has changed is us: parents too timid to say no, schools too bureaucratic to adapt, and a society too distracted to hold its own reflection. We have confused indulgence for love and sedation for care. We do not raise children anymore. We manage them.</p><p>But children raised without boredom, boundaries, or consequence do not grow stronger. They grow fragile. And fragile children don’t remain children. They become fragile adults — brittle in the face of reality, prone to breaking at the first collision with a world that does not negotiate.</p><p>And history is merciless with fragility. It gives us only two paths forward.</p><p>One is drift: each generation softer, weaker, more medicated than the last, until collapse becomes the only teacher left standing.</p><p>The other is swing: the violent correction of the pendulum. We’ve seen it before. The authoritarian rigidity of the 1930s and 40s gave way to the utopian permissiveness of the 60s and 70s. In architecture, the stripped severity of modernism provoked the ornamental rebellion of postmodernism. In literature, Hemingway’s spareness made room for the excess of David Foster Wallace. More recently, the moral absolutism of the woke era invited its own backlash in the populist rage of Trumpism. The pendulum always swings — and rarely with grace.</p><p>So let us not deceive ourselves: the erosion of parenting will not plateau gently. It will either spiral downward into generations too fragile to function, or it will recoil into something darker — rigidity, authoritarianism, cruelty disguised as order. Neither future is worth gambling on.</p><p>ADHD didn’t rise. Parenting collapsed. And unless we recover the courage to raise children with the things they actually need — love tied to discipline, freedom framed by boundaries, boredom as the soil of imagination — we will not prepare them for life. We will abandon them to history’s pendulum, and history does not swing kindly.</p><h3>A note on AI use</h3><p>This piece was written by me — with a little help. Like many non-native English speakers, I use AI as a creative assistant to sharpen phrasing, stress-test arguments, and catch idioms I might otherwise miss. It doesn’t write for me — it helps me write <em>more like me</em>.</p><p>I’ve shared more thoughts on this here: <a href="https://medium.com/@christian.hartvig/ai-isnt-ruining-writing-it-s-finally-giving-non-native-speakers-a-voice-2fdbde4fa870">“AI isn’t ruining writing — it’s finally giving non-native speakers a voice”</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=793988ecc9c7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Shut The F*ck Up: Why The Loudest People Are Always the Dumbest]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@christian.hartvig/shut-the-f-ck-up-why-the-loudest-people-are-always-the-dumbest-30224df04c01?source=rss-940ef270fe1f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/30224df04c01</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[humor]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[life]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[society]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[satire]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Christian Hartvig]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 06 Aug 2025 10:01:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-08-22T14:14:03.479Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4><strong><em>Warning: This story contains more words than the average TikTok user reads in a year. Proceed at your own intellectual risk.</em></strong></h4><figure><img alt="A furious man surrounded by loud, oblivious people blasting phones and tablets — chaotic satire of modern noise culture." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*et36uGaf_7SVxog6QELLlg.png" /></figure><p>There are many subtle signs a civilization is rotting from the inside.</p><p>Currency debasement. Bread shortages. The rise of baroque job titles like “Head of Emotional Strategy.” But perhaps the most viscerally accurate predictor of societal decay isn’t tucked away in dusty history books or economic charts.</p><p>It’s right in front of you.</p><p>On the train. At the café. In line at the pharmacy.</p><p>It’s the person playing music from their phone at full volume like they’re headlining Coachella.</p><p>The human subwoofer. The FaceTime yeller. The TikTok echo chamber with zero headphones and even less shame. The parents who think it’s fine their kid is watching YouTube at full blast over dinner, like the restaurant is a daycare with a wine list.</p><p>Let’s not pretend this is harmless: these people are the foot soldiers of a new idiocracy — proud, loud, and unbothered by the basic idea that other people might exist.</p><p>And somehow, they’re multiplying.</p><h3>When Did Volume Become Virtue?</h3><p>There’s a special place in hell for people who use speakerphone in public. And judging by the noise levels on public transport, it’s going to be standing room only.</p><p>These aren’t citizens. They’re audio terrorists — weaponizing sound like it’s a basic human right. Every call becomes a live podcast nobody subscribed to. Every message a voice note launched like a grenade into the collective sanity of the room.</p><p>And just when you think it can’t get worse, enter the Phone DJs: No headphones. No shame. Just pure, undistilled auditory sewage: cartoon screams, Instagram reels, drill beats, motivational speeches from men named Brad who sell crypto and do push-ups for likes, and TikToks that make you wish for deafness — all sprayed into public space like acoustic graffiti.</p><p>These creatures confuse volume with personality. They think manners are oppression. That silence is violence. That every blank moment is a threat to their carefully curated, painfully mediocre brand.</p><p>They don’t need attention. They need a mute button. And a one-way ticket to a soundproof gulag with no exit sign.</p><h3>When Did Volume Become Virtue?</h3><p>How did we get here?</p><p>Public space used to be a social contract. A fragile truce. You didn’t video chat loudly on the train, not because it was illegal — but because you weren’t a psychopath. And you didn’t play music without headphones because you weren’t raised by monkeys.</p><p>But something shifted. Somewhere between narcissism-as-identity and the death of shame, a new creed emerged:</p><p><strong><em>“I’m the main character, so I can do whatever I want.”</em></strong></p><p>And no — it’s not just “the youth.”</p><p>It’s parents yelling into speakerphone in pediatric waiting rooms. It’s businessmen barking into AirPods like Gordon Gekko never died. It’s middle-aged gym bros blasting techno in public parks.</p><p>Idiocy, it turns out, is age-agnostic and evenly distributed across demographics like a particularly stupid form of universal basic income.</p><h3>The Rot Behind the Noise</h3><p>And it’s not just sound.</p><p>It’s the spirit behind it — the metastasizing selfishness leaking into every crack of public life like black mold.</p><p>You see it in traffic, where turn signals are considered optional and honking is now just the local dialect. In how people park sideways across two spaces like warlords claiming land. In the way they treat service workers like broken robots — snapping fingers, mumbling orders, never making eye contact unless it’s to launch a complaint.</p><p>You see it when someone hoists their filthy shoes onto public benches or train seats like they’re at home on their couch, soles marinated in dog piss, chewing gum, and the collective fluids of the city — planted exactly where someone else’s coat, bag, or tired body is supposed to go next. Not because they don’t know better. But because the idea that another human might use that seat after them simply never enters the equation.</p><p>You see it in how the rich build taller walls while the rest of us can’t even find a quiet bench that doesn’t double as a Bluetooth speaker test site. Even billionaires used to fake empathy. Now they livestream rocket launches while their warehouse workers piss in bottles and sprain their spines shipping same-day yoga mats to people too important to wait until Tuesday.</p><p>It’s all the same rot: I matter, you don’t. My phone, my noise, my moment. Your sanity? <em>Not</em> my problem.</p><p>And before someone squeaks out the inevitable deflection — <strong>no, this doesn’t make you a Karen.</strong></p><p>That’s the favorite get-out-of-jail-free card for the loud and the clueless: frame any request for decency as the ravings of a menopausal suburban a middle-aged woman demanding to speak to the manager because her latte had too much milk and not enough emotional support.</p><p>Karens want special treatment.</p><p>We’re just asking for the bare minimum: that the guy blasting fart-prank compilations next to a chemo patient be tasered — gently, civilly — in the crotch.</p><p>That’s not entitlement.</p><p>That’s basic public hygiene.</p><h3>The Psychology of Public Loudness: A Diagnosis</h3><p>So what’s really going on?</p><p>There’s a name for people who don’t recognize boundaries. It’s not “free-spirited.” It’s narcissistic. But that word is now so mainstream it’s practically a compliment.</p><p>Underneath it all is a deeper psychological quirk known as <em>egocentric bias</em><strong> </strong>— the belief that others are just as interested in your thoughts, feelings, and existence as you are. It’s a normal phase in childhood. Most of us grow out of it around age five, right around the time we stop smearing our own feces on the wall and calling it art.</p><p>The tragedy? Some never did. They just upgraded the wall to Instagram stories and brought the exhibition to the subway.</p><p>And it gets worse. There’s another psychological phenomenon lurking beneath the noise: the <em>Dunning-Kruger effect</em> — the phenomenon where those with the least competence tend to be the most confident. Now give that person a smartphone, a social media feedback loop, and a complete lack of shame, and you get what can only be described as the <strong>Dunning-Kruger Megaphone Effect</strong>: the less self-aware you are, the more noise you make.</p><p>None of this is brand new. Ancient Rome had its own version. The Stoic philosopher Seneca once ranted about how public bathhouses were becoming unbearable — filled with shouting, grunting, and, as he put it, <em>“those who think they are singing.”</em> Even back then, volume was a reliable proxy for oblivion.</p><p>The difference? Rome collapsed. We just bought noise-canceling headphones.</p><h3>The Real Cost of the Noise</h3><p>It’s tempting to laugh. To shrug it off as a harmless byproduct of modern life.</p><p>But constant unsolicited noise corrodes more than peace and quiet — it erodes mutual respect. It chips away at boundaries, patience, and dignity.</p><p>Noise pollution, according to the World Health Organization, isn’t just annoying — it’s deadly. Long-term exposure increases stress hormones, blood pressure, and risk of heart disease. It diminishes learning. It derails focus. It makes you more aggressive, less generous, and generally less human.</p><p>In short: <strong>being exposed to loud phone people might literally be killing you</strong>.</p><p>But even if it weren’t, the cultural damage is worse.</p><p>Because once you stop expecting basic decency in shared spaces, you stop expecting it anywhere. You lower your standards. You adapt. You tolerate. Until one day you’re thanking a stranger for not playing porn at full volume in the waiting room (and yes, that has actually happened. In several countries).</p><h3>The iPad Orphans: Children of the Loud</h3><p>But if you want to see where this ends, look no further than the kids.</p><p>Few things are as bleak as the pixelated screech of a poorly animated children’s movie echoing through a restaurant. You know the sound. Somewhere between helium and hell. A nasal side character voiced by a C-list YouTuber, screaming something like “Let’s go, Mr. Picklebutt!” at 180 decibels while the adults at the table stare numbly into their wine glasses.</p><p>The only thing louder would be the sound of Mount Vesuvius erupting — which, frankly, would be a welcome reset. At least it had the decency to bury people quickly.</p><p>These are the <strong>iPad Orphans</strong> — children no longer parented by humans, but by algorithm. And their careless creators? Exhausted adults who have made a simple trade: peace and quiet, outsourced to YouTube.</p><p>Let’s be clear: this isn’t about the kids. No child dreams of watching Russian Peppa Pig knockoffs dubbed in Vietnamese while inhaling nuggets in a strip mall. This is about the grown-ups. The ones who gave up parenting the moment they realized an iPad was cheaper than a babysitter and less judgmental than a fellow adult.</p><h3>The Next Generation Is Listening — and We’re F*cked</h3><p>This needs to stop — right now. Because, if there’s one thing as certain as an <em>amen</em> in church, it’s this: iPad Orphans don’t grow up.</p><p>They mutate into louder, dumber, ruder versions of their already unbearable parents — weaponized by algorithm, desensitized by overstimulation, and raised to believe silence is oppression.</p><p>They’ve been trained from birth that boredom is violence. That headphones are optional. That every blank moment must be filled with screeching cartoon pigs, voice notes, and half-digested TikTok wisdom delivered at rock concert volume by someone who failed kindergarten school but nailed going viral</p><p>They don’t need conversation. They need feedback loops. They don’t ask questions. They broadcast. Nonstop. With volume. In public.</p><p>So don’t be shocked when they FaceTime during a funeral. When they scroll TikTok in the front row of a wedding. When they take a speaker call while the dentist is mid-drill — and call <em>you</em> rude for raising an eyebrow.</p><p>And if you think it’s bad now, then I have some bad news for you: this is just the tutorial.</p><p>These creatures tend to reproduce in litters — multiplying the pattern like rabbits on fertility medication in spring. What was once an isolated case of parental laziness is now an epidemic with a growth curve steeper than the crypto hype in 2021.</p><p>So, don’t call it decline.</p><p>Call it inheritance.</p><h3>The saddest part? The real tragedy isn’t the noise.</h3><p>It’s the silence.</p><p>The silence of people who know how to behave. Who understand that not every impulse deserves an audience. Who grew up believing public space was something you <em>shared</em> — not something you hijacked like a toddler with a megaphone and brain damage.</p><p>But they’ve gone quiet.</p><p>Not because they stopped caring. But because the world flipped the rules. Now, <em>they’re</em> the freaks. The troublemakers. The ones who are “making it awkward” by asking for the bare minimum: a little goddamn peace.</p><p>We live in a culture so backwards, so proudly idiotic, that some people have become too polite to defend politeness. They feel it would be <em>rude</em> to ask someone to stop shouting into a phone while others try to exist.</p><p>And if you dare to say something?</p><p>You’re not correcting someone. You’re stepping into a hostage negotiation with a walking Red Bull who thinks eye contact is aggression and that volume = confidence. Ultimately, you risk being mocked, filmed, or stabbed — in that order.</p><p>So the decent people stay silent. Not out of weakness. But out of exhaustion. Because when you’re the only one upholding the standard, it doesn’t make you noble — it makes you <em>exposed</em>.</p><p>And that’s how the loud ones win.</p><p>Not because they’re right. But because the people who are… are too tired to fight anymore.</p><p>Which brings us, neatly, to a quote that still applies — although probably not known by the verbal diarrheists with 5G who refuse to read books and who call Netflix documentaries education and YouTube subtitles literature:</p><p><em>The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing.</em></p><h3>Three Brutal — and Completely Realistic — Ways to Break the Circle</h3><p>So how do we fix this?</p><p>Well, you don’t fix rot by reasoning with the maggots.</p><p>You see, this isn’t a debate. This isn’t even a “dialogue about norms.” It’s trench warfare in the shattered ruins of shared space. And if we’re serious about reclaiming public life from the speakerphone sociopaths, we need more than virtue-signaling blog posts.</p><p>So here’s the fix: stop trying to educate the offenders – and just start making their lives miserable. Not with violence. With rules, tech defaults, and consent. Here’s how:</p><h4>1. Ban public speaker audio by law — and enforce it like smoking</h4><p>No unmuted music, video, or calls in transport, waiting rooms, cafés, or indoor public spaces.</p><p>First offence: €250 fine. Second: double it. Third: community service cleaning train carriages while listening to the full works of Enya — with headphones, of course.</p><p>Treat it like lighting a cigarette indoors. Everyone knows the line. Everyone respects it. Not because it’s polite — but because there’s a price.</p><h4>2. Headphones by default. Consent for everything else</h4><p>Here’s a rule that shouldn’t need saying: you don’t get to touch someone, track someone, or push something into someone without asking first. A hand on a thigh. A cookie in a browser. Whatever’s rattling around in your pants. And yet sound – the thing that travels furthest and forces its way into the most people – gets a free pass every single time. No ask. No hello. Just impact.</p><p>So fix the default. Every phone, speaker, and app ships mute in public – silence is the baseline, not a favor you’re owed an apology for. Want to broadcast without headphones? Ask first. Every device within 10 meters gets a ping: Allow / Deny. Brought an actual speaker instead of your phone’s tinny little death rattle? The radius scales with the wattage – the louder your ego, the wider the crime scene. No response, no consent. Default to silence. One denial, and the thing chokes itself out mid-beat.</p><p>And nobody’s better built for this than the tech giants and the EU. One already fingerprints your every click and makes you beg to read a recipe. The other legislated the acceptable bend of a cucumber. Between them, a mute-by-default patch for Kevin’s speakerphone is a Tuesday afternoon, not a moonshot.</p><p>We’ve engineered products to babysit our sleep, our screen time, our doomscrolling. We can engineer one to babysit our manners. Tech built this dumpster fire. Tech – or Brussels – can finally put it out.</p><h4>3. Go Full China</h4><p>If kindness doesn’t work, confrontation gets you stabbed, and rules and regulations aren’t biting hard enough – there’s always surveillance.</p><p>Let people record the offenders. Not for clout. For enforcement. Add facial recognition. Plug it into the state database. Every time someone blasts TikTok in a café, a little red light blinks somewhere in a municipal server farm — and a week later, they get a letter in the mail.</p><p>Not an angry letter. A quiet one. With a €500 fine.</p><p>You want to treat public space like your personal living room? Fine. We’ll treat you like a license plate.</p><p>It’s fast. It’s scalable. And it only hurts the ones ruining it for everyone else.</p><p>Of course, there’s one tiny problem: <strong>this is how authoritarianism starts</strong>.</p><p>So yes, it would work. But the moment you let the State use automatic facial recognition to fine speakerphone abuse, you’ve built the infrastructure for something far worse. And no matter how loud these people are, they’re not worth that.</p><p>But the fact we’re even <em>considering</em> it? Tells you just how desperate it’s gotten.</p><h3>Silence Is Not Empty. It’s a Right.</h3><p>Silence isn’t emptiness. It’s presence. It’s where thoughts form, strangers coexist, and a city remembers how to breathe. It’s not a luxury — it’s the last refuge of sanity in a culture that won’t shut up.</p><p>But we’ve built a world where peace is the exception. Everyone’s a DJ, a vlogger, a motivational speaker mid-meltdown — and you’re the unwilling audience. No ticket, no escape.</p><p>So what now? You could surrender. Or draw the line.</p><p>Not by shouting — that’s just more noise — but by defending the idea that public space belongs to everyone.</p><p>Imagine the teenager blasting music on a train tells you:</p><p><em>“Then go sit in the quiet carriage.”</em></p><p>Most people would launch into a speech about manners.</p><p>Chris Voss, former FBI hostage negotiator, would likely do something far simpler. He uses a technique called the mirror method: repeat the last few words someone says, and then let silence do the work.</p><p>He would probably just lean back and repeat:</p><p><em>“Sit in the quiet carriage?”</em></p><p>And then wait.</p><p>Silence has a strange effect on bad ideas. It gives them room to echo.</p><p>People hate empty space in conversations. They rush to fill it. They elaborate. They explain.</p><p><em>“Yeah. If you don’t like it, go somewhere else.”</em></p><p>Now you have something to work with.</p><p><em>“It sounds like you think everyone else should move so you can listen to music without headphones.”</em></p><p>Not angry. Not sarcastic. Just an observation.</p><p>And if the answer is yes?</p><p><em>“How did you arrive at that as the most considerate solution for everyone else on the train?”</em></p><p>At that point, you’re no longer arguing. You’re auditing the logic.</p><p>And that’s often where the performance collapses.</p><p>Not because you’ve won.</p><p>Because for the first time, they’ve had to listen to themselves.</p><p>Silence does that. Not through force, but through exposure.</p><p>And that’s the real trick: not defeating noise with more noise, but letting it reveal itself when it has nowhere left to hide.</p><p>So if you still know how to whisper, how to listen, how to share space without turning it into your mixtape…</p><p>Welcome to the resistance.</p><p>And to everyone else?</p><p><strong>Please, shut the f*ck up.</strong></p><h3>A note on AI use</h3><p>This piece was written by me — with a little help. Like many non-native English speakers, I use AI as a creative assistant to sharpen phrasing, stress-test arguments, and catch idioms I might otherwise miss. It doesn’t write for me — it helps me write <em>more like me</em>.</p><p>I’ve shared more thoughts on this here: <a href="https://medium.com/@christian.hartvig/ai-isnt-ruining-writing-it-s-finally-giving-non-native-speakers-a-voice-2fdbde4fa870">“AI isn’t ruining writing — it’s finally giving non-native speakers a voice”</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=30224df04c01" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How User Research Slowly Sucked the Soul Out of Design]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@christian.hartvig/how-user-research-slowly-sucked-the-soul-out-of-design-2189bcf9087e?source=rss-940ef270fe1f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2189bcf9087e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ux-research]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[user-research]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[creative-process]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[product-design]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Christian Hartvig]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 23 Jul 2025 09:04:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-23T08:56:32.429Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4><strong>We’ve confused user research with creativity — and ended up with process over progress. This is what happens when imagination is managed to death.</strong></h4><figure><img alt="A group of intense scientists in lab coats obsessively test whether a red wheel fits into a round hole, while outside the window, the cheerful world rolls on, utterly uninterested." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*x5G3fRqrFO283gWqFqKk4A.png" /></figure><p>Let’s start with a confession: I find most user research about as useful as a screen door on a submarine.</p><p>There, I said it.</p><p>David Ogilvy said it too — decades before “user research” had its own job title and its own Slack channel. The man who more or less invented modern advertising, and did it on instinct as much as anything else, put it better than I ever could:</p><blockquote>“The trouble with market research is that people don’t think what they feel, they don’t say what they think and they don’t do what they say.”</blockquote><p>Not because users don’t matter — they do. Profoundly. But the process we worship in most European corporations today isn’t about empathy at all. It’s about eliminating risk, shifting blame, and calling it insight.</p><p>And to be fair, I get why most product people — and their colleagues in sales, marketing, and management — cling to user input. On the surface, it seems noble. The most logical thing in the world. Who wouldn’t want to listen to the very people you’re building for? In fact, not doing it feels almost like heresy — arrogant, reckless, even irresponsible.</p><p>However, that’s exactly where the trap begins. What sounds like humility can quietly turn into abdication. The instinct to “let the users decide” feels safe, but safety has a way of smothering imagination.</p><h3>From Visionaries to Bureaucrats</h3><p>Once upon a time, we hired designers to dream. Now we ask them to validate. To observe. To nod solemnly while users fumble through half-baked wireframes, and then return to the tribe with sacred Post-its scrawled in corporate glossolalia.</p><p>How did we get here? Easy. Somewhere between Agile and the age of accountability, someone swapped imagination for indemnity. You see, vision is risky. And risk, in big orgs, is career kryptonite. So we built a fortress around ourselves — lined with user quotes, metrics, workshops, and process porn — and called it safety.</p><p>But let’s not kid ourselves. Most research in big corporations today isn’t about learning — it’s about laundering responsibility.</p><h3>What Dies in the Process</h3><p>The casualties of this corporate theater? Vision. Momentum. Courage. That electric spark that says, “Let’s make something extraordinary.”</p><p>Instead, we get consensus-driven Frankenstein features, stitched together from the dismembered limbs of user feedback. No pulse. No soul. Just a bloated thing that nobody hates — and therefore, nobody loves.</p><p>I’ve seen it too many times: teams drowning in research, operating inside big, well-funded corporations, produce the most excruciatingly bland products imaginable. Dead on arrival. Meanwhile, a tiny, scrappy startup led by a clear product vision outperforms them by a factor of 1000 — in impact, in elegance, in relevance. They do it faster, with exponentially fewer people, and zero stakeholder-alignment meetings. And the kicker? They actually make something people want.</p><p>If the output and outcome are bad — and they usually are — there’s something wrong with the input. Garbage in, garbage out, as they say in programming. Except in this case, the garbage isn’t the data — it’s the system. The processes. The endless loops of pseudo-rigorous rituals that mistake movement for progress.</p><p>And what’s the corporate response to poor outcomes? Almost always more of the same. More research. More frameworks. More consultants. As if flogging the horse harder will suddenly teach it to code.</p><p>Why? Because most modern corporations are run by academics. People fluent in research but allergic to intuition. Trained to deconstruct rather than construct. Their default mode is analysis, not synthesis. And when all you have is a hammer made of frameworks, every problem starts to look like a process waiting to happen.</p><p>These are the folks who treat <em>“Let’s just try it!”</em> like a dirty phrase. Who think “gut feeling” is a symptom to be treated, not a muscle to be trained. Who’d rather spend six weeks mapping out customer journeys than six hours building something testable. Because God forbid we build something based on… judgment. Experience. Taste. (Shudder.)</p><h3>Feedback Won’t Save a Sinking Ship</h3><p>There’s a certain irony in how the companies with the dullest, most soulless products are often the ones most obsessed with collecting user feedback. Big corporations, in particular, seem to cling to surveys and focus groups as if more data will somehow breathe life into something already dead on arrival. It’s like asking passengers on a sinking ship whether they’d prefer red or blue life vests — when the real problem is that the ship never should’ve left the harbor in the first place.</p><p>The hard truth is this: feedback can point out leaks and splinters, but it can’t chart a course. When a product drifts without a strong vision, every new suggestion just spins it in tighter, more random circles. Users are great at spotting rough edges, but they can’t redesign the vessel. That’s our responsibility. That’s what product and design are supposed to do.</p><p>And yet too often we confuse patchwork with progress. We slap on fixes, stitch over holes, and convince ourselves we’re moving forward. But the more patches we add, the heavier and clumsier the ship becomes — weighed down by compromises instead of propelled by purpose.</p><p>That’s why the best products don’t come from focus groups. They’re born from bold ideas, shaped by people who can see horizons users don’t even know exist. <strong>Feedback has its place, but it’s a tool, not a steering wheel.</strong> Too many companies forget that — and end up navigating by committee, only to wonder why they keep drifting in circles.</p><h3>Why Lab Testing Is Just Another Form of Denial</h3><p>You know what else we’ve tamed, sanitized, and over-theorized into oblivion? Testing.</p><p>Somewhere along the way, “test and learn” became “simulate and stall.” We put people in pastel-colored rooms with mirrored walls, offer them lukewarm coffee, and ask them to imagine they’re shopping for shoes while a UX researcher hovers politely behind them like a digital ghost. Meanwhile, the real world — with its noise, distractions, dropped phones, crying babies, and battery anxiety — rolls on, completely uninterested in your prototype’s intentions.</p><p><strong>Lab tests are the new delay tactic.</strong> A softer, more researchy way of saying, <em>we’re afraid to ship.</em></p><p>The irony? We pretend this is about safety. But real safety doesn’t come from controlling variables — it comes from knowing how your product performs <em>when you can’t.</em> That’s why testing in the wild isn’t just more honest — it’s more <em>useful.</em></p><p>Because out there, nobody’s trying to “give feedback.” They’re just trying to get through their day. They rage-click, bail mid-flow, ignore your onboarding, and then tell their friends your app sucks — <em>if</em> they remember it existed. Painful? Yes. Invaluable? Also yes. Because as any founder who’s actually shipped something will tell you: that’s where real learning lives.</p><p>And it’s not a new idea. Herbert Simon’s concept of <strong>bounded rationality</strong> reminds us that people don’t make decisions in ideal conditions. They make them with half their attention and most of their cognitive energy already spent. Your product needs to survive <em>that</em>. Not a sandbox with sticky notes and snacks.</p><p>But here’s the real kicker: simulated tests don’t just miss reality — they often hide <em>truth</em>. Users behave differently when they know they’re being watched — it’s called the <strong>Hawthorne Effect</strong>. Which means most of your lab “insights” are about as useful as testing a parachute indoors.</p><p>Meanwhile, companies like SpaceX? They launch. They learn. Sometimes they explode. Then they launch again. Because the cost of waiting to be “sure” is much higher than the cost of being wrong and recovering fast.</p><p><strong>Great products aren’t built in labs. They’re built in contact with the world.</strong></p><p>They’re built when someone trusts their judgment more than the testing script. When they notice what <em>people do</em>, not just what they <em>say</em>. When they ship early, learn loud, and course-correct in public — because that’s where the signal is.</p><p>So if your team is spending more time preparing usability test scripts than shipping product… maybe it’s not about rigor. Maybe it’s about <em>fear.</em></p><p>And maybe — just maybe — that fear is what’s sucking the soul out of your design.</p><h3>The Wheel Has Been Tested. It’s Still Round.</h3><p>You’d think, with all the funding, frameworks, and PhDs floating around, we’d be shaping the future. Bold new paradigms. Uncharted interaction models. Interfaces that surprise and delight.</p><p>But no. We’re mostly just confirming that water is, in fact, still wet.</p><p>We run studies to confirm that clean interfaces work better than cluttered ones. That readable text outperforms unreadable text. That cookie banners are annoying. And when we’re feeling really bold, we might validate that users like things that are… easy to use.</p><p>However, research <em>can</em> be powerful — when it challenges assumptions, provokes direction, or reveals the unexpected. But that’s not what happens in most big companies. In corporate culture, design research has been tamed. It’s become a compliance ritual — a shield against accountability. A way to say, “We followed the process,” while building the same safe thing as last quarter.</p><p>Even worse, research is often weaponized to <em>block</em> ideas: “We can’t move forward until this is validated.” Validated against what? That red error messages feel aggressive? That people enjoy speed?</p><p>At some point, we stopped researching to explore and started researching to defend. It’s no longer about insight. It’s about indemnity.</p><p>Companies will spend months testing whether a known UX pattern… still works. Entire teams will fret over whether people understand what a tab does. We treat established patterns like unstable chemicals. As if tab navigation might spontaneously combust if left unchecked.</p><p>Imagine if architecture worked this way. “We’re just going to test whether people can find the front door. And then we’ll A/B test how they feel about walking through it. Phase three is a usability study on doorknobs.”</p><p>It’s research theatre. A way to signal rigor without actually committing to risk. Because true research — the kind that challenges, reframes, or inspires a leap — is inconvenient. It slows down roadmaps. It doesn’t always end in consensus. And worst of all, it requires people in the room to <em>have opinions</em>.</p><p>But opinions are dangerous in corporate culture. You might be wrong. You might be blamed. So instead, we build fig leaves out of findings. And we nod sagely at quotes like “I just want it to be simple” as if we’ve discovered gravity.</p><p>Meanwhile, companies actually building great products? They talk to users too — but then <em>they</em> decide. <em>They</em> build. <em>They</em> move. They trust <em>their people</em> to have judgment. And when they make bold moves, they don’t run twelve rounds of testing to check if people like circles.</p><p>They know the wheel works. They’re just more interested in where it can take them.</p><h3>Blame Academia: The Process-First Mindset Was Born There</h3><p>This mess didn’t start in tech. It started in academia — and not the kind with chalk-dusted geniuses scribbling wild equations on blackboards. No, this is the <em>modern</em> breed. The PowerPoint academics. The ones who publish papers with titles like <em>“Toward a Transdisciplinary Epistemology of Postmodern Frictionality: A Heuristic Model for Emergent Dynamics in UX Ecosystem Ontologies”</em> — and never ship a damn thing. The kind that rewards publishability over discovery. The kind where entire careers are built on deconstructing things other people built.</p><p>Especially in the humanities, where — let’s be honest — there’s been a decades-long identity crisis. Desperate to prove it belongs at the grown-up table with the natural sciences, the field traded curiosity for citation, and imagination for methodology. Not because it wanted to explore new ideas — but because it wanted to look serious while doing it.</p><p>So it wrapped everything in process. Frameworks. Jargon. Performative rigor. You can almost hear the collective whisper: <em>“We don’t know what this is yet, but we’ve organized it into quadrants.”</em></p><p>And now that mindset has trickled into the world of design. Not the wonder. Not the exploration. Just the paperwork. Just the pressure to look rigorous without ever risking anything real.</p><p>And this is the dirty secret: most “research” isn’t about exploring the unknown. It’s about validating well-trodden patterns in controlled environments — often for the fifth time. It’s testing, not inventing. Tinkering, not trailblazing. We’re not designing the future — we’re dragging the past into another spreadsheet.</p><p>Why? Because genuine invention is risky. It’s messy. It can’t always be benchmarked, and it often fails before it succeeds. That makes it deeply uncomfortable for institutions that run on academic publishing cycles and corporate KPIs. So instead of original ideas, we get safe ones. Recycled. Peer-reviewed. Sanitized.</p><p>This is how we end up with designers who can quote Foucault but are terrified to pick a font without a test group.</p><p>Think of it as design taxidermy: it looks real enough, but it sure as hell ain’t alive.</p><h3>The Cult of Certainty</h3><p>It all comes down to one thing: fear. The modern enterprise is terrified of being wrong. So terrified, in fact, that it will build an entire bureaucratic ecosystem just to avoid having to make a single bold decision. Better to drown in validated mediocrity than risk unvalidated brilliance.</p><p>And therein lies the great irony: the more we try to eliminate uncertainty, the more we kill the very spark that makes products great. Every visionary product you love — the ones that made your jaw drop, that felt like they read your mind — wasn’t born from a focus group. It came from someone with the guts to say, “I think this will work. Let’s go.”</p><p>Apple didn’t invent the iPhone because people asked for it. LEGO didn’t create its AFOL (Adult Fans of LEGO) community because a user journey map told them to. And Slack? It was literally built <em>because</em> their video game failed. You think that pivot came from a meticulously filled-out UX research template?</p><h3>Reclaiming the Craft</h3><p>So here’s my modest proposal: bring back the weirdos. The rebels. The misfits who trust their gut and their craft more than a post-it wall. Let’s hire people with strong taste and give them enough room to be wrong sometimes. Let’s replace some of those “alignment meetings” with good old-fashioned making.</p><p>And let’s remember: the job of a designer isn’t to serve the data. It’s to serve the people the data represents. That takes imagination. Empathy. Courage. And yes — a little rebellion.</p><p>Because the next big thing won’t come from a research repository. It’ll come from someone who sees the world not as it is, but as it could be — and, despite all the obstacles, has just enough delusion to build it anyway.</p><p>Long live the dreamers. Death to design by committee.</p><h3>A note on AI use</h3><p>This piece was written by me — with a little help. Like many non-native English speakers, I use AI as a creative assistant to sharpen phrasing, stress-test arguments, and catch idioms I might otherwise miss. It doesn’t write for me — it helps me write <em>more like me</em>.</p><p>I’ve shared more thoughts on this here: <a href="https://medium.com/@christian.hartvig/ai-isnt-ruining-writing-it-s-finally-giving-non-native-speakers-a-voice-2fdbde4fa870">“AI isn’t ruining writing — it’s finally giving non-native speakers a voice”</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2189bcf9087e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[You Can’t Find Palestine on a Map — But Sure, Go Ahead and March]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@christian.hartvig/you-cant-find-palestine-on-a-map-but-sure-go-ahead-and-march-5476e9777fd7?source=rss-940ef270fe1f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5476e9777fd7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[current-events]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[activism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[society]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Christian Hartvig]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 06 Jul 2025 11:10:54 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-23T08:42:04.517Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>You Can’t Find Palestine on a Map — But Sure, Go Ahead and March</h3><h4><strong>A brutal takedown of aesthetic activism, shallow outrage, and why turning geopolitics into a fashion statement does more harm than good.</strong></h4><figure><img alt="A group of young activists passionately protest with signs reading “Palestine,” “Tax the Rich,” and “Climate Action Now,” while one confused protester proudly points to the wrong location on a blank map, highlighting the irony of performative activism." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*1EJRJu24EQWoD8DO_RcCVA.png" /></figure><p>Let’s get something straight.</p><p>Writing this is asking for trouble — not from the right, but from the very people who claim to fight for compassion, solidarity, and freedom of speech. Because here’s the uncomfortable truth: those values only seem to matter when they confirm their worldview. The modern Western left loves “love” — but only if it’s directed inward. Their empathy stops at the border of disagreement.</p><p>They’ll preach “no one is free until we’re all free,” then publicly shame anyone who asks a follow-up question. They’ll say “educate yourself,” but what they really mean is “agree with me — or else.”</p><p>That’s the bitter irony: the same people who once stood for complexity, depth, and actual dialogue now lead a movement fueled by aesthetic outrage and algorithm-approved slogans. It’s no longer about justice — it’s about vibes. No longer about change — but being seen trying.</p><p>So no, this isn’t a gentle reflection on geopolitics. This is a mirror held up to a generation that confuses moral performance with moral clarity. That picks causes like festival outfits. That can’t find Palestine on a map — but will scream about it for likes.</p><p>Let’s talk about what activism has become. And why pretending to care might be doing more harm than good.</p><h3>The Performance Formerly Known as Politics</h3><p>Once upon a time, being a leftist meant something dangerous. Union leaders with bloodied knuckles. Factory strikes that crippled industries. Writers exiled for their ideas. There was risk. There was pain. There was depth.</p><p>Now? It’s mostly merch.</p><p>The left has become a lifestyle brand. A vibe. A curated aesthetic that looks fantastic on a sticker-plastered MacBook, ideally next to an “ACAB” decal and a Fair Trade coffee logo. What matters is not the conviction — but the costume.</p><p>You don’t need to read Chomsky. You just need to quote him. You don’t need to understand Palestinian history. You just need to wear the keffiyeh. You don’t even need to know where Gaza is. You just need to spell it in spray paint on an urban wall.</p><p>This shift from substance to style is more than embarrassing — it’s corrosive. It allows an entire generation to outsource its moral compass to memes and influencers. It creates a false sense of righteousness that doesn’t require engagement, just aesthetics. The result? A movement that looks like rebellion, sounds like resistance, but functions more like a pop-up shop for political identity.</p><h3>The Geography of Good Intentions</h3><p>Try this next time you find yourself near a protest: walk up to one of the louder voices, hand them a blank map of the Middle East, and ask them to point out Palestine.</p><p>Cue the awkward silence.</p><p>Some will point at Egypt. Others will hover around Syria. A few might pause, squint, and gesture somewhere between Jordan and… Afghanistan? Confidence crumbles fast when ideology meets geography.</p><p>And yet, minutes later, these same people will be chanting <em>“From the river to the sea, Palestine will be free”</em> — with all the gusto of someone shouting along to a Taylor Swift song they don’t actually know the lyrics to. It’s tribal karaoke: loud, rhythmic, and emotionally satisfying — just don’t ask what it means.</p><p>So let’s break it down. That slogan? It refers to the land between the <strong>Jordan River</strong> and the <strong>Mediterranean Sea</strong> — which includes all of Israel. Historically, it’s been a call for the dissolution of the Israeli state. Not coexistence. Not a two-state solution. A clean sweep.</p><p>Now, I get it — some of you might say, <em>“That’s not how I mean it.”</em> Fair. But meaning isn’t just what you intend; it’s how it lands. And when you’re repeating a phrase with that much historical baggage, parroting it without understanding makes you less an activist and more an amplifier.</p><p>This isn’t about silencing solidarity. It’s about putting in the work. If your convictions are real, so should your knowledge be. You wouldn’t sign a contract without reading it — so why chant a battle cry you haven’t even Googled?</p><p>Because if you’re going to march for a cause, the very least you can do is <strong>know what you’re marching for.</strong></p><p>Otherwise, next time you might find yourself at a Ku Klux Klan rally because you thought <em>KKK</em> stood for <em>“Kittens, Kindness, and Kombucha.”</em></p><p><strong>(And just to be safe — for those of you whose education comes primarily from friends and TikTok: the Ku Klux Klan is… not that).</strong></p><p>But let’s be honest with each other, this isn’t really about Palestine. It never was. It’s about identity — ours, not theirs.</p><p>It’s about how righteous anger has become a shortcut to meaning in a world that’s increasingly hollow. When institutions crumble, community fractures, and religion fades, causes become the new church. Activism fills the void left by spiritual and civic disengagement. It’s no wonder the chants sound like hymns and the marches like processions.</p><p>And for many, Palestine is just the latest proxy. A symbol through which they can signal empathy without understanding, outrage without effort. It’s not about solidarity — it’s about self-definition. About being able to say: <em>“I’m one of the good ones.”</em></p><h3>Activism as Image Management</h3><p>Marching feels good. It gives you that rush — that tribal thrill of being “on the right side of history.” But let’s be honest: most people aren’t there for the cause. They’re there for the aesthetic. For the selfies. For the sense of moral superiority you can’t buy in stores (but you can post on Instagram).</p><p>In psychology, this is called virtue signaling — performing your values publicly to boost your social standing. It’s the political equivalent of flexing a Rolex, only now it’s “Free Palestine” instead of Swiss timekeeping.</p><p>Even better? It’s low cost.</p><p>Because unlike risking your job, your safety, or your reputation (you know, real stakes), joining a protest in a liberal Western city is about as risky as attending a food truck festival. It’s loud, colorful, and the only thing you might lose is your voice from chanting.</p><p>But your moral credit score? Sky high.</p><p>This isn’t activism. It’s optics. It’s moral exhibitionism tailored for social media algorithms. It’s the transformation of justice into content marketing. The camera always finds the handmade sign with the perfect message. The photo carousel always ends with a group shot, grinning behind slogans no one bothered to research.</p><p>And when the protest ends? So does the interest. Until the next trend.</p><h3>Herd Thinking with a Hammer and Sickle</h3><p>Back in the 1970s, a Polish-born psychologist named Henri Tajfel — a man who had seen firsthand what tribalism could do to the world — came up with something called <strong>Social Identity Theory</strong>. It explains how we humans instinctively sort ourselves into groups (“us”) and define ourselves against “them,” often for absurdly flimsy reasons. In one of his most famous experiments, people started favoring strangers who just happened to be assigned to the same random group — literally based on a coin toss.</p><p>Now apply that to politics.</p><p>Today’s left doesn’t always want to understand. It wants to belong. Which means it’s far more interested in signals than in substance.</p><p>Palestine becomes a symbol. Not a place with real people, real histories, real tragedies — but a canvas onto which Western progressives can project their guilt, their rage, their yearning for purpose.</p><p>It’s cosplay with casualties.</p><p>And here’s the kicker: once the groupthink takes hold, dissent becomes betrayal. Questioning becomes heresy. If you point out a contradiction, you’re not “nuanced” — you’re a traitor. The modern left demands conformity, not curiosity. Allegiance, not inquiry. And if you step out of line? You’re excommunicated with the digital equivalent of torches and pitchforks: callout posts, cancellations, and TikTok takedowns.</p><p>This isn’t community. It’s cult behavior with hashtags.</p><h3>The Infantilization of Complexity</h3><p>Ever try having a real conversation about the Israeli–Palestinian conflict with someone who just came back from a protest?</p><p>It’s like discussing quantum mechanics with someone who skimmed a horoscope.</p><p>And let’s be honest: this conflict is <em>deeply</em> complicated. We’re talking about thousands of years of tangled history, religion, trauma, conquest, colonization, identity, and survival. Both sides have done good. Both sides have done horrific things. It’s not a comic book. There are no capes.</p><p>And I’m not claiming to be an expert either. I don’t know nearly enough about all the different aspects. Most of us don’t — including you (sorry, I know, very generalising of me). Which is exactly why we should approach it with caution, humility, and at least a shred of neutrality before we start chanting slogans or picking sides like it’s a football match.</p><p>But nuance doesn’t trend. Outrage does. So we flatten everything.</p><p>The left used to pride itself on complexity — Marxist dialectics, Gramscian hegemony, Frankfurt School critique.</p><p>Now? If your talking point doesn’t fit on a tote bag, it’s probably too much.</p><p>But infantilizing complexity doesn’t just insult intelligence — it erodes critical thought. It teaches people that feeling is more important than thinking. That emotional certainty trumps intellectual humility. That shouting louder means you’re more right.</p><p>The result? A generation that speaks in absolutes about issues they barely understand. A movement allergic to ambiguity, and addicted to applause.</p><h3>What We Choose Not to See</h3><p>While you’re marching, here’s what you’re not doing:</p><ul><li>Reading about Egypt’s role in the blockade of Gaza.</li><li>Studying the internal politics of Hamas and Fatah.</li><li>Questioning why your university boycott includes Israeli hummus but not Chinese surveillance tech.</li></ul><p>Selective outrage is convenient. It lets you stay morally “pure” without doing the dirty work of knowing what the hell you’re talking about.</p><p>Let me be crystal clear: this isn’t a defense of Israel. It’s a critique of shallow tribalism. Because when your political compass is calibrated by vibes, not values, you become easy to manipulate — by algorithms, by echo chambers, by peers.</p><p>And worse: you lose the ability to think.</p><p>It also raises a scarier question: what else are you not seeing? What other injustices are going unnoticed because they don’t align with your brand? What crises go ignored because no influencer told you to care?</p><h3>“But It Raises Awareness!”</h3><p>Ah yes, the old defense. The sacred phrase of every slacktivist since 2008.</p><p>Raising awareness is the participation trophy of activism. It demands nothing, changes nothing, and often leads nowhere. But it feels great. And more importantly: it looks great.</p><p>But awareness without understanding is just noise. And noise can be dangerous. It drowns out people who actually know what they’re talking about. It silences those living the conflict. It replaces informed discussion with TikTok explainers and slogans you can chant on beat.</p><p>You are not amplifying the voiceless. You are speaking over them — with a megaphone you don’t know how to use.</p><p>In the worst cases, raising awareness becomes a smokescreen for ego. A performance designed not to educate others, but to elevate yourself. It’s clout chasing wrapped in compassion.</p><p>And in a world flooded with content, sometimes the most helpful thing you can do is say nothing at all.</p><h3>The True Cost of Pretending</h3><p>There’s a line from philosopher Harry Frankfurt’s book <em>On Bullshit</em> (which, yes, is an actual academic book):</p><blockquote>“The essence of bullshit is not that it’s false, but that it’s phony.”</blockquote><p>That’s the core of today’s image-based leftism. It’s not that everyone is wrong — it’s that so many are fake.</p><p>Phony knowledge. Phony courage. Phony sacrifice. A theater of empathy performed for clout.</p><p>But here’s the thing about pretending: it has consequences.</p><p>When everyone is yelling, the people who actually suffer — the real Palestinians, the real Israelis, the ones who don’t have the luxury of treating this like content — get drowned out. And when we treat politics as performance, we lose the ability to act when it actually matters.</p><p>Pretending also breeds cynicism. People stop believing in movements. They stop trusting causes. Because once something becomes a trend, it dies like one.</p><p>And that’s how real change loses its chance.</p><h3>The Climate Will Kill Us All — But Only After Brunch</h3><p>And if you think this performative theatre is limited to foreign policy — think again. Let’s talk about Copenhagen’s — my own city’s — climate activists.</p><p>You’d think that living in a Nordic swamp with wind that slaps harder than your ex and rain that falls sideways, people would be used to discomfort. And yet, strangely, Copenhagen’s most climate-conscious citizens only seem to discover their activist spirit when the sun’s out and it’s a solid 19°C with just the right amount of cloud cover for good photos.</p><p>Because here’s what I’ve noticed: climate protests in this city are meteorologically selective. They erupt in spring. They bloom in summer. And by the time October rolls around? Extinct. Like polar bears, but with tote bags.</p><p>If you’ve ever been caught behind one of these road-blocking, slogan-chanting flash mobs, you’ll notice something odd. It’s never raining. Not once. Never during the long Danish winter when it’s 3 degrees and your bones feel wet. Never when it’s snowing. Never during actual climate-type weather.</p><p>Apparently, the climate crisis is a seasonal emergency — urgent, but only after everyone’s had breakfast and checked the UV index.</p><p>The irony here isn’t subtle. These people claim to be battling extreme weather, but refuse to go outside when it’s mildly unpleasant. They want to fight global disaster, but not if it requires gloves.</p><p>They’ll chant “System change, not climate change,” but the only system they’re willing to disrupt is light urban traffic on a sunny Tuesday between 11:00 and 13:00. After that, they’re off to a sourdough café to recharge their iPhones — which, incidentally, contain cobalt mined by children in Congo, lithium drained from collapsing ecosystems in Chile, and rare earth metals smelted in coal-fired Chinese factories. The phones are then assembled by underpaid workers in Shenzhen who sleep in dorms, jump from rooftops, and live under constant surveillance. They’re packed in plastic, flown or shipped across oceans in cargo vessels powered by bunker fuel — a liquid so filthy it makes diesel look like kombucha — then driven inland on large diesel-burning trucks with tires made from rubber harvested from deforested plantations —only to be sold back to them by a trillion-dollar American corporation for a hefty profit . All so they can post a TikTok about why capitalism is evil.</p><p>But that’s fine — because the iPhone charges fast, takes good selfies, looks great, and fits neatly into a hand holding a cardboard protest sign made from bleached rainforest pulp, glued together with a petroleum-based adhesive, and stapled to a stick made from God-knows-what.</p><p>No, we don’t talk about that, because it ruins the vibe.</p><p>And yes, I hear you: “But protesting is emotionally exhausting!” Sure, but so is drowning in a flash flood, Greta.</p><p>If your rebellion fits neatly between oat lattes and your afternoon pottery class, it’s not a revolution — it’s a vibe. And vibes don’t stop climate change.</p><p>Let’s be honest: this isn’t about saving the planet. It’s about being seen trying to save the planet. Preferably in ethically sourced vintage, with a good filter.</p><h3>A Call to Discomfort</h3><p>So what now?</p><p>Here’s a wild idea: next time a cause catches fire, do this before you hit “share”:</p><ul><li>Read a full-length book on the subject.</li><li>Talk to someone from the region who disagrees with you.</li><li>Find the best argument on the other side — and then try something truly radical: shut up, sit with it, and actually try to understand it without flinching, interrupting, or posting about it halfway through.</li><li>Ask yourself: “Am I willing to be wrong in public?”</li></ul><p>Because real conviction isn’t loud. It’s informed.</p><p>And real solidarity doesn’t always feel good. It’s not always aesthetic. Sometimes, it means shutting up. Sometimes, it means listening. Sometimes, it means marching — but not for the reasons your friends are.</p><p>We need to stop outsourcing our ethics to influencers and start doing the hard work ourselves.</p><p>Because if you’re only an activist when it’s easy, you’re not standing up for anything — you’re just standing in.</p><h3>Yes, You Can March. But at Least Know Why You’re Marching.</h3><p>To be clear: this isn’t a takedown of caring.</p><p>Caring is good. Passion is good. Rage, even, has its place. But performative caring? That’s poison. It hollows out movements. It replaces substance with slogans. And it breeds a generation of people who confuse shouting for doing — and being seen for being right.</p><p>So if you’re going to wear the keffiyeh, at least know what it means. If you’re going to chant “From the river to the sea,” know where that river is. And if you’re going to scream for liberation, ask yourself: whose liberation, exactly?</p><p>Or — put more simply:</p><p><strong>If you can’t find Palestine on a map, maybe don’t make it your personal brand.</strong></p><h3>A note on AI use</h3><p>This piece was written by me — with a little help. Like many non-native English speakers, I use AI as a creative assistant to sharpen phrasing, stress-test arguments, and catch idioms I might otherwise miss. It doesn’t write for me — it helps me write <em>more like me</em>.</p><p>I’ve shared more thoughts on this here: <a href="https://medium.com/@christian.hartvig/ai-isnt-ruining-writing-it-s-finally-giving-non-native-speakers-a-voice-2fdbde4fa870">“AI isn’t ruining writing — it’s finally giving non-native speakers a voice”</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5476e9777fd7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How Scrum Quietly Became The Most Profitable Circus in Corporate History]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@christian.hartvig/how-scrum-quietly-became-the-most-profitable-circus-in-corporate-history-59c4b0815ae2?source=rss-940ef270fe1f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/59c4b0815ae2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[software-development]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[product-management]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[scrum]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[innovation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[agile]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Christian Hartvig]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 08 Jun 2025 07:18:27 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-06-10T08:07:00.670Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4><strong>Why management loves it, B-players hide behind it, and C-players religiously follow it — while real product builders slowly leave or suffocate in alignment meetings.</strong></h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*7cmnVEbrCuWV0u2XlK2z0Q.png" /></figure><p>Let’s be honest upfront: this is a long read. About 22 minutes.</p><p>Roughly the same amount of time your team likely spent passionately debating whether that ticket 82 items deep in your backlog — you know, the one you’ll never build — should be assigned 3 or 5 story points. An argument so gloriously pointless that by the time you ever get near that feature, the customer, the business, the market, and quite possibly society as a whole will have changed completely.</p><p>But — unlike that masterclass in collective self-deception — this might actually be worth your time.</p><p>Because this isn’t just another critique of agile theater. This is the full autopsy. The unsanitized post-mortem of how Scrum — once sold as liberation for builders — has metastasized into one of the most profitable compliance cults modern corporate life has ever produced. A safe space for careerists who want the appearance of progress without the risk of actual accountability.</p><p>If you’ve ever found yourself in yet another standup, listening to blockers that haven’t moved since Q3, pretending to care while secretly wondering whether Kafka or Orwell would’ve done a better job chronicling this disaster — congratulations: this one’s for you.</p><h3><strong>The Monster Scrum Was Meant to Kill</strong></h3><p>There’s a particular kind of irony that deserves its own category in the museum of human stupidity: when something becomes the very monster it was created to slay. The revolutionary who seizes power only to become a dictator. The privacy advocate who winds up selling your data. The doctor who dies from malpractice.</p><p>And then there’s Scrum.</p><p>Scrum, which began life as an <em>agile</em> methodology — a lightweight framework designed to liberate teams from heavyweight bureaucracy — has quietly mutated into one of the most profitable bureaucratic machines in corporate history. Kafka would’ve poured himself a stiff drink just looking at your company’s Jira board.</p><p>What started as a rebellion against Gantt charts and endless sign-offs has become its own elaborate theater of process, complete with sacred ceremonies, certified priests, and armies of true believers performing daily rituals in the name of “agility.” Meanwhile, the people actually building products? They either leave, suffocate, or retreat into Slack DMs to do the real work after-hours.</p><p>The tragedy isn’t just that Scrum has lost its way. The tragedy is how thoroughly we’ve convinced ourselves that this is agility.</p><h3>The Revolution That Forgot Its Purpose</h3><p>Remember the <a href="https://agilemanifesto.org/">Agile Manifesto</a>? That beautiful, concise document that valued:</p><ul><li><strong>Individuals and interactions</strong> over processes and tools</li><li><strong>Working software</strong> over comprehensive documentation</li><li><strong>Customer collaboration</strong> over contract negotiation</li><li><strong>Responding to change</strong> over following a plan</li></ul><p>If you’re reading this while working in a modern Scrum environment — developer, designer, product manager, QA, you name it — there’s a decent chance you just snorted coffee through your nose. My apologies for the keyboard damage.</p><p>Because whatever you’re doing in the name of “Agile” right now likely has about as much to do with those original principles as a military parade has with interpretive dance.</p><p>Somewhere along the way, we took a lightweight framework designed to liberate teams — and turned it into a religion. Complete with high priests (Scrum Masters), sacred texts (Scrum Guides), and elaborate ceremonial rites (standups, sprint planning, retrospectives) that must be performed with increasing orthodoxy lest we anger the productivity gods.</p><p>The result? A framework that once promised freedom now delivers suffocation. A system built for autonomy has grown obsessed with control. A process designed for adaptability has become allergic to improvisation.</p><p>Yet the deeper the dysfunction, the stronger the faith. Like any good religion, its followers insist the problem isn’t the system — it’s you.<em> You’re simply not doing it right.</em></p><p>And in a way, that’s exactly why it succeeded. Not because it delivered better products, but because it delivered something far more valuable in corporate life: the comforting illusion of control.</p><h3>The Sacred Ceremonies of Progress Theater</h3><p>Once the rituals took hold, the theater began.</p><p>The most talented actors I know don’t work in Hollywood — they work in IT departments, performing in the daily production known as the <em>standup meeting</em>.</p><p><em>“What did I do yesterday? What am I doing today? Are there any blockers?”</em></p><p>This script is recited with all the passion of someone reading nutritional information off a cereal box, while the SCRUM Master nods sagely, perhaps making a note in the sacred JIRA board. The actual content barely matters — what matters is that we performed the ceremony correctly.</p><p>Does anyone care that half the “blockers” mentioned have been blockers for weeks? Or that the “what I’m doing today” is often a carbon copy of yesterday’s statement? Of course not. We’ve checked the box. We’ve done the standup. Agile has been achieved!</p><p>Meanwhile, actual problems get discussed in Slack messages, hallway conversations, or that most agile of all solutions: after-hours panic sessions when deadlines loom.</p><p>What makes this particularly painful is that these ceremonies pile onto an already meeting-saturated work culture. In corporate environments especially, the average knowledge worker already spends 85% of their week in meetings, according to research from Harvard Business School. Add daily standups, sprint planning, backlog refinement, sprint review, and retrospectives to an already packed calendar, and when exactly is the actual work supposed to happen? Work gets pushed to evenings and weekends, while daylight hours are consumed by talking about the work rather than doing it.</p><p>And here’s the final twist of irony: SCRUM’s ceremonies were never supposed to be additive. They were originally designed to <strong>replace</strong> unnecessary meetings — to streamline communication and eliminate waste. Yet in most organizations, they’ve simply become <em>additional</em> meetings layered on top of everything else, further squeezing the already limited time that makers and creators have to enter a state of flow and produce meaningful work.</p><p>Instead of liberating teams, the rituals have chained them to an endless calendar of performative coordination — where appearing aligned has become more important than actually building anything valuable.</p><h3>The SCRUM Master: From Servant-Leader to Process Police</h3><p>Of course, every theater needs a director. Enter the SCRUM Master.</p><p>Originally, the role was conceived as a servant-leader — someone who would remove obstacles and help the cross-functional team self-organize. The SCRUM Master was there to support developers, designers, testers, business analysts, and product owners, ensuring collaboration could thrive. A noble concept, truly.</p><p>But somewhere along the way, the director forgot the play.</p><p>In many organizations, the SCRUM Master has quietly mutated into something between a micromanager, a timekeeper, and a process enforcer. Instead of protecting teams from bureaucracy, they’ve become its front-line officers — personally offended whenever a team dares to adapt the framework to its actual needs.</p><p><em>“I see you’ve modified the retrospective format to better suit your team’s communication style. Unfortunately, that’s not compliant with our Agile Transformation Initiative’s standardized approach to retrospectives. Let’s revert to the approved template.”</em></p><p>The certification industry hasn’t exactly helped. In fact, it’s built a factory for producing armies of freshly minted process police after two-day workshops. Thousands of SCRUM Masters emerge, armed with certificates and buzzwords but often lacking any real understanding of the philosophy they are meant to uphold.</p><p>Give someone a hammer, and suddenly everything looks like a nail. Give someone a SCRUM certification, and suddenly everything looks like it needs more ceremonies.</p><p>What was intended to be a role that facilitated collaboration across disciplines has too often become a bureaucratic gatekeeper, enforcing uniformity at the expense of the diverse needs of different team members — from UX researchers who need time for user testing, to QA specialists who need flexibility in their testing approaches, to product managers balancing stakeholder needs with technical constraints.</p><p>And so, in the name of “agility,” we’ve built a system where flexibility is punished, nuance is forbidden, and anyone attempting to tailor the framework to reality is gently but firmly reminded to follow procedure. The servant-leader has become the process warden.</p><h3>The Sprint: A Marathon in Disguise</h3><p>Once the process police are firmly in place, the sprints begin — artificial time boxes that were meant to create focus but often serve as little more than bureaucratic containers for work that doesn’t fit real life.</p><p>In theory, sprints help teams limit work in progress and deliver value in small, manageable increments. But in practice? They rarely align with the natural rhythm of cross-functional work. Complex problems don’t politely fit into two-week windows. Creative solutions — whether in code, design, user experience, or business logic — don’t emerge on schedule. Research insights don’t arrive conveniently before sprint planning. User feedback doesn’t wait for the end of your sprint to invalidate assumptions.</p><p>But rather than adapt the framework to fit the work, we adapt the work to fit the framework. We slice logical units of work into arbitrary chunks, creating artificial fragments that satisfy the sprint board but fracture the actual flow of progress. Or, even better, we lean on the time-honored tradition of <strong>sprint spillover</strong> — where the same tasks migrate from sprint to sprint like digital nomads, never quite finding a home.</p><p>And if someone dares finish early? That’s not a sign of efficiency — it’s a planning failure. Quick, pull in more stories before anyone notices we have breathing room to think, experiment, or address technical and design debt.</p><p>The sprint structure creates particular challenges for non-development roles. Designers find their discovery work compressed to fit arbitrary deadlines, compromising the depth of their research. QA specialists are perpetually squeezed at the end of sprints as development inevitably runs long. Product managers spend so much time preparing for the next sprint that they barely have time to evaluate what just happened.</p><p>The end result? Instead of achieving “agile” flow, teams are trapped in a manic loop of perpetual planning, constant reshuffling, and mechanical delivery — always performing, rarely reflecting.</p><p>And still, the ceremonies continue. The standups are held. The retrospectives are scheduled. The sprint boards are updated. On the surface, everything looks organized. But underneath, real agility is quietly suffocating under the weight of artificial deadlines and empty rituals.</p><h3><strong>The Great Estimation Delusion</strong></h3><p>If the artificial constraints of sprints weren’t already absurd enough, SCRUM offers an even more elaborate ritual: estimation.</p><p>Perhaps nothing better exemplifies SCRUM’s growing divorce from reality than its obsession with trying to predict the unpredictable. Story points. Planning poker. Velocity tracking. An entire ecosystem of tools and techniques dedicated to giving the comforting illusion that we can accurately forecast creative work.</p><p>The problem, of course, is that estimation in software development is notoriously unreliable — because we’re constantly solving new problems, working with evolving technologies, and discovering requirements as we go. The honest answer to “how long will this take?” is almost always: <strong>“I don’t know yet.”</strong></p><p>But that’s not good enough for SCRUM. Instead, we gather in rooms — physical or virtual — and invent elaborate ceremonies where developers guess at complexity using Fibonacci numbers or t-shirt sizes, as if wearing an “XL” label somehow brings us closer to certainty. We act surprised when these guesses prove wildly inaccurate. The most experienced developers I know have quietly adopted their own conversion system: whatever number feels right, double it. Then double it again. Then add some buffer.</p><p>The truly insidious part? Despite years of evidence showing how inaccurate these estimates are, companies continue to use them as hard commitments — for deadlines, performance evaluations, and project forecasting. It’s like using astrology to set your investment strategy, then firing your financial advisor when Jupiter doesn’t align with Mars.</p><p>But the appeal remains irresistible — especially to managers desperate to impose order on the chaos. Estimations turn complex work into colorful charts, spreadsheets, and projections that can be presented to leadership. Suddenly, software development looks rational. Measurable. Governable.</p><p>Of course, none of this actually maps to reality. But that becomes an inconvenient detail. When estimates fail (as they inevitably do), the problem is never the estimation process itself — it’s that <strong>“the teams aren’t doing SCRUM correctly.”</strong> And so the response is always the same: more process, more training, more ceremonies.</p><p>And slowly, the work of building great products becomes secondary to the work of feeding the framework’s insatiable hunger for predictability.</p><h3><strong>The Illusion of Control: Putting Chaos in Neat Corporate Boxes</strong></h3><p>At the core of it all lies SCRUM’s most seductive promise — and its greatest deception: the illusion of control.</p><p>Software development is, by nature, unpredictable. It’s messy, creative, nonlinear. We solve novel problems. We navigate shifting requirements. Unknown unknowns emerge in every corner of the work. That’s simply the price of building something new.</p><p>But for many corporate managers — especially those armed with MBAs and zero lines of code to their names — this uncertainty feels deeply unsettling. Their professional world revolves around quarterly forecasts, predictable returns, and clean metrics. The messy reality of software development doesn’t fit neatly into spreadsheets or board presentations.</p><p>Enter SCRUM — a corporate savior whispering sweet assurances:</p><p><em>“Don’t worry. We’ll turn the uncontrollable into the controllable. We’ll put everything into neat boxes: teams with defined velocities, work broken into two-week increments, budgets projected from story points. We’ll make software development look just like manufacturing.”</em></p><p>And the appeal? Irresistible. Finally, executives can translate software work into language the board understands. Colorful charts. Velocity trends. Sprint counts. Estimated completion dates. Suddenly, product development can be scheduled like factory output.</p><p>The small problem, of course, is that none of it’s real.</p><p>When estimates prove wildly inaccurate (as they always do), the problem is never attributed to the framework itself. Instead, blame falls on the teams: <em>“You’re not doing SCRUM correctly.”</em> When arbitrary deadlines force shortcuts and quality suffers, the solution is always more process. More ceremonies. More control.</p><p>And the tragedy? Many of these managers genuinely believe they’re helping. They aren’t cartoon villains twirling mustaches while laughing maniacally. They’re simply applying familiar management techniques to a domain they fundamentally don’t understand. Their intent isn’t malicious — it’s catastrophically misaligned.</p><p>And so we arrive at the absurdity: creative professionals managed like assembly line workers, their output measured in artificial units, their work chopped into arbitrary time segments, their success judged by conformance to process rather than the quality of what they build.</p><p>Because SCRUM promised to tame the chaos. To make the complex simple. To turn unpredictability into something forecastable.</p><p>And in return, we built a system that rewards obedience over judgment, metrics over outcomes, and busywork over craftsmanship.</p><h3>Certified Agile™: When Process Becomes Product</h3><p>None of this happened by accident. SCRUM didn’t just evolve into this system — it was commercialized into it.</p><p>Somewhere along the way, SCRUM stopped being a framework and quietly became a product.</p><p>A very lucrative one.</p><p>Books. Certifications. Training courses. Consultants. Software tools. An entire industry arose around the packaging and selling of agility — with predictably un-agile results.</p><p>As Martin Fowler aptly named it, the <strong>Agile Industrial Complex</strong> was born — and it has a deeply vested interest in keeping things complicated. Simple, truly adaptive approaches don’t generate recurring revenue. But complex frameworks? With specialized roles, mandatory tools, certification ladders, and endless transformation programs? That’s a business model.</p><p>And so companies are sold “Agile Transformations” — massive, top-down initiatives that implement SCRUM with all the flexibility and contextual awareness of a steamroller. Teams are reorganized. New roles are created. Old processes are destroyed — all in service of a standardized approach to being… adaptive.</p><p>The irony would be hilarious if it weren’t crushing real people trying to do real creative work.</p><p>If you want to see how far SCRUM has drifted from its roots, don’t look at the teams — look at the ecosystem orbiting around them.</p><p>Behold: Certified SCRUM Masters, Certified Product Owners, Advanced Certified Agile Coaches, Professional SCRUM Practitioners — and whatever shiny badge the certification mills invent next quarter. Some courses last two days. Some are half-day webinars. All promise instant expertise. No actual experience required. Just pay the fee, pass the quiz, print the certificate. Congratulations — you’re now officially qualified to enforce ceremonies you may or may not fully understand.</p><p>It’s the perfect racket. The vendors get recurring revenue. HR departments get easy filters for job postings. The newly certified get LinkedIn-ready credentials. Everybody wins — except, of course, the product itself.</p><p>Because while the certification industry thrives and careers advance on the back of laminated credentials, the actual work of building great products quietly suffers under the weight of over-processed rituals. Process compliance gets rewarded. Product outcomes quietly degrade.</p><p>And this isn’t some uniquely American pathology. The same certification theater plays out in boardrooms and HR departments across industries and continents — anywhere process is mistaken for progress.</p><p>Ironically, the people selling agility have built one of the most rigid, scalable, and predictable businesses imaginable:</p><p><strong>selling permission slips for a framework that was supposed to promote adaptability.</strong></p><p>SCRUM was never meant to become a product. But somewhere along the way, agility became something you could buy — and nothing sells better in corporate life than the illusion of competence.</p><h3><strong>The Academics Who Built This Disaster</strong></h3><p>The Agile Industrial Complex didn’t conquer product teams by persuasion.</p><p>It conquered them because the teams were already trained to surrender.</p><p>For decades, universities have been producing graduates who are experts at everything — except thinking for themselves. Graded on rule-following. Praised for compliance. Rewarded for citing the right theories. It doesn’t matter whether your solution works — only that your methodology was properly documented. The result? A professional class fluent in applying models but allergic to judgment.</p><p>By the time they enter the workplace, one habit is fully installed:</p><ul><li>Trust the framework, not your own thinking.</li><li>Don’t question — apply.</li><li>Don’t improvise — document.</li><li>Don’t experiment — reference best practice.</li><li>Don’t decide — align.</li></ul><p>When these people encounter SCRUM, it feels familiar.</p><p>Another syllabus. Another checklist. Another safe system where nobody ever has to sit alone and own a risky decision.</p><p>But the truly dangerous part isn’t that these people exist — it’s how efficiently they replicate. They hire people just like themselves: highly certified, perfectly credentialed, fluent in governance, alignment, and stakeholder theater — but paralyzed the moment you take away the playbook. People who know a lot but understand very little.</p><p>And so we end up with a professional caste designed not to solve complexity but to administer it. A system where every promotion reinforces the same dynamic: more process managers hiring more process managers, each one slightly further removed from actual customers.</p><p>The irony is obvious — because innovation has never come from this class. It comes from people who learned by doing. People who failed early. People who took bets without perfect information — exactly the kind of messy, uncomfortable environment this system was built to eliminate.</p><p>And yet the system continues to grow. Because in a world trained to fear ambiguity, process feels safer than judgment.</p><p>The result isn’t a talent shortage — it’s a judgment shortage.</p><p>An entire generation of professionals trained to execute playbooks, but terrified of throwing them away when reality demands it.</p><h3><strong>The Cargo Cult of Process (feat. Marty Cagan &amp; Friends)</strong></h3><p>When you train an entire professional class to fear ambiguity and worship frameworks, you don’t just get bad decision-making — you get an entire organizational operating system built around <em>process as protection</em>.</p><p>At some point, large companies quietly figured out a simple truth:</p><p><strong>You can’t really fire someone for following the process.</strong></p><p>And that’s where modern product development finds itself today.</p><p>You don’t need teams who think — you need teams who execute.</p><p>Not people who challenge assumptions — but people who move tickets.</p><p>Not leaders who take responsibility — but managers who approve roadmaps and track burndown charts.</p><p>And when it all goes wrong (which it often does), you simply point to the framework:</p><p><strong>“We followed the process.”</strong></p><p>That’s the secret.</p><p>Process doesn’t just organize the work — it absorbs the blame.</p><p>Marty Cagan has been calling out this farce for years. Companies congratulate themselves for running agile at scale, while slowly converting every product team into a glorified feature assembly line.</p><p>Product managers stop solving problems and start administrating backlogs.</p><p>Designers stop exploring and start decorating wireframes.</p><p>Engineers stop thinking about customers and start measuring story points.</p><p>Everyone stays busy.</p><p>Everyone looks productive.</p><p>Nobody owns the outcome.</p><p>And then — the punchline — leadership gathers every quarter to wonder, with a straight face:</p><p><strong>“Why aren’t we seeing more innovation?”</strong></p><p>As if creativity can magically appear inside a system carefully engineered to punish risk.</p><p>As if people trained for years to clear their sprint boards and follow the playbook will suddenly wake up one morning and start making bold bets.</p><p>You can’t bureaucratize your way into original thinking.</p><p>You can’t optimize your way into great products.</p><p>You can’t train risk-aversion for years and then act surprised when nobody sticks their neck out.</p><p>The truth is painfully simple:</p><p><strong>You built exactly what you optimized for.</strong></p><p>And the people who still know how to build great products?</p><p>They’ve been warning about this for years — often loud enough to make certified Agile Coaches extremely uncomfortable:</p><p><strong>Elon Musk:</strong></p><p><em>“The problem is that at a lot of big companies, process becomes a substitute for thinking. You’re encouraged to behave like a little gear in a complex machine.”</em></p><p><strong>Steve Jobs:</strong></p><p><em>“That’s what makes great products. It’s not process; it’s content…The system is that there is no system. That doesn’t mean we don’t have process… But that’s not what it’s about.”</em></p><p><strong>Jeff Bezos:</strong></p><p><em>“As companies get larger and more complex, there’s a tendency to manage to proxies… A common example is process as proxy. Good process serves you so you can serve customers. But if you’re not watchful, the process can become the thing.”</em></p><p><strong>Reed Hastings:</strong></p><p><em>“Netflix has been successful because it values people over process, innovation over efficiency, and leads with context, not control.”</em></p><p>The pattern is obvious:</p><p><strong>World-class companies trust capable people to make judgment calls.</strong></p><p>They obsess over customers, not ceremonies.</p><p>They adapt constantly, rather than manage to velocity charts.</p><p>The bloated corporate version of SCRUM has simply become the perfect operating system for teams pretending to be agile — while obediently delivering features no one needs — all while the real work of product discovery, innovation, and customer value sits quietly rotting in the backlog.</p><h3><strong>The Choice Is Yours: Learning from the Successful Rebels</strong></h3><p>By this point, the picture should be clear:</p><p>The ceremonies, the certifications, the alignment theater — they’re not accidents. They’re features of a system carefully engineered to feel safe, while quietly starving real product work of oxygen.</p><p>And yet — not everyone is playing along.</p><p>Because despite the dominance of process theater in much of corporate life, some teams have managed to quietly escape its gravitational pull. Not by rejecting agility — but by reclaiming it.</p><p>As IT professionals — not just developers, but designers, product managers, QA specialists, user researchers, and everyone involved in building digital products — we face a simple choice:</p><p>We can continue the charade, performing the ceremonies while the spirit of agility gasps for breath beneath the weight of JIRA tickets and velocity metrics. We can keep playing progress theater while actual progress happens despite our processes, not because of them.</p><p>Or we can learn from the companies that have successfully broken free from rigid SCRUM practices while still embracing true agility.</p><p>Take <strong>Spotify</strong>, for example, which famously developed its own approach with squads, tribes, chapters, and guilds. While they borrowed some concepts from SCRUM, they explicitly rejected its rigid ceremonies and timeboxes in favor of autonomous teams united by purpose rather than process. Their engineering culture prioritizes autonomy, mastery, and purpose over conformity to frameworks.</p><p>Or consider <strong>Basecamp</strong> (formerly 37signals), whose founders have been vocal critics of traditional agile methodologies. Instead of sprints, they work in six-week “cycles” with almost no formal process beyond that. Their focus is on calm, thoughtful work rather than artificial urgency, and they’ve built a successful, profitable business without a SCRUM Master in sight.</p><p><strong>GitHub</strong> is another example, having embraced asynchronous communication and a results-oriented approach rather than ceremony-driven development. They’ve proven that high-quality software can emerge from teams that focus on outcomes rather than adherence to methodologies.</p><p>Even larger enterprises like <strong>Microsoft</strong> have moved toward more flexible approaches in many divisions. Their Developer Division shifted from rigid SCRUM to a more fluid approach that emphasizes flow and customer value, contributing to the remarkable turnaround in products like Visual Studio Code and Azure.</p><p>These teams haven’t abandoned structure entirely. But they’ve returned to first principles — treating frameworks as starting points, not destinations. Questioning ceremonies that don’t add value. Adapting timeboxes to fit the work, not the other way around. Prioritizing outcomes over process compliance.</p><p>They’ve remembered something the rest of the industry seems determined to forget:</p><p>People build software — not processes.</p><p>Trust enables agility more than any framework ever could.</p><p>The goal isn’t to do SCRUM. The goal is to deliver value, learn continuously, and create environments where people can do their best work.</p><h3><strong>The Ironic Betrayal of SCRUM’s Own Origins</strong></h3><p>The most tragic part of this entire story isn’t just how badly SCRUM is implemented today — it’s how far it has drifted from the intentions of its own creators.</p><p>Jeff Sutherland, who co-created SCRUM in the early 1990s, was trying to escape precisely the kind of heavyweight project management bureaucracy that now bears his framework’s name. As a fighter pilot turned medical database engineer, Sutherland had seen firsthand how rigid processes collapsed under real-world complexity. He wasn’t chasing control — he was chasing adaptability.</p><p>And yes — the irony isn’t lost:</p><p>When a military guy starts looking at your project plan and says, <em>“Wow, this feels a bit bureaucratic,”</em> you’ve officially broken new records in red tape.</p><p>Sure, fighter pilots follow checklists too — but theirs are designed to handle reality, not avoid it. In the air, rigid process doesn’t save you when conditions change — adaptability does. You either react, improvise, and adjust — or you crash.</p><p>In his search for something better, Sutherland stumbled across an article that would give his instincts a formal structure. In 1986, two Japanese researchers published <em>The New New Product Development Game</em> in the Harvard Business Review. They studied how companies like Honda and Canon were using small, autonomous, cross-functional teams to innovate rapidly. The metaphor they borrowed from rugby — the “scrum” — captured the kind of collaborative, adaptive teamwork Sutherland wanted to replicate in software.</p><p>What Sutherland envisioned was light, flexible, and above all — human-centered.</p><ul><li><strong>Empirical process control.</strong></li><li><strong>Self-organization.</strong></li><li><strong>Continuous improvement.</strong></li></ul><p>SCRUM was never meant to become a rigid doctrine. It was designed as a lightweight starting point that teams would adapt to their specific contexts — not follow like scripture. In his book <em>Scrum: The Art of Doing Twice the Work in Half the Time</em>, Sutherland emphasized adaptability and even happiness as key metrics — a far cry from the velocity-obsessed, burn-down-chart-worshipping rituals dominating most organizations today.</p><p>Yet somewhere along the way, that vision was quietly betrayed.</p><p>Instead of freeing teams from heavyweight process, SCRUM metastasized into exactly the kind of bureaucratic, process-heavy machinery it was created to replace. The ceremonies became obligations. The roles became hierarchies. The artifacts became compliance documents.</p><p>Today, many corporate implementations of SCRUM would be almost unrecognizable to its creators. What began as a rebellion against control has become its servant.</p><p>And the bitter irony?</p><p>The very framework designed to empower teams has become the latest weapon used to control them.</p><h3><strong>Why Good Ideas Break Bad in Big Corporations</strong></h3><p>After all this, it’s important to remember one thing:</p><p><strong>SCRUM didn’t start broken.</strong></p><p>The original idea was noble — a simple, flexible framework to help small, cross-functional teams collaborate, adapt, and get real work done without drowning in Gantt charts and committee meetings.</p><p>And in smaller companies, startups, and early-stage teams, SCRUM actually works. Light structure. Fast feedback loops. Autonomy. Exactly what you’d want when building something new under conditions of uncertainty.</p><p>But large corporations? They play by entirely different rules. Big organizations aren’t built for uncertainty. They’re built for risk management, standardization, and accountability.</p><p>The bigger the ship, the more it fears waves.</p><p>Entire org charts exist to manufacture predictability — often by slicing complex work into processes that can be controlled, audited, and explained at the next board meeting. And when you hand them something like SCRUM — originally intended as a lightweight framework — they do exactly what they’ve been trained to do: turn it into a full-blown process.</p><p>Psychologists have a name for this reflex: <strong>ambiguity aversion</strong> (Ellsberg paradox). Humans naturally prefer known risks over unknown ones — even when the unknown may objectively offer better outcomes. Process offers the illusion of safety. It replaces the messy reality of creative work with tidy checklists, Gantt charts, and standardized templates.</p><p>Deviating from the process feels dangerous. Because if something goes wrong, there’s no clear scapegoat. But if you followed the prescribed method and still failed? Well — at least you followed protocol.</p><p>It’s the same reason inexperienced cooks obsessively follow recipes to the gram. They don’t yet trust their instincts, so the exact measurements feel like protection:</p><p>225 grams of flour. 16 minutes at 185 degrees.</p><p>Safe. Predictable. Blameless.</p><p>Compare that to the seasoned chef who throws in <em>“a pinch of this”</em> or <em>“a splash of that”</em>, constantly adjusting on the fly based on taste, smell, and experience.</p><p>In corporate environments, many teams are filled with people clinging to the recipe book — sometimes because they’re inexperienced, sometimes because they’re simply not very good, and sometimes because they’ve grown far too comfortable trusting the process to think for them.</p><p>After all, following the procedure is safe: If the project fails, it wasn’t your fault — you followed protocol.</p><p>As Harvard professor Amy Edmondson’s research on psychological safety shows, when people fear making mistakes, they retreat into process rather than exercise judgment.</p><p>But fear isn’t the only factor. Sometimes it’s just professional inertia.</p><p>As NPR journalist Scott Simon once dryly observed:</p><p><strong><em>“Rules and procedures may be dumb, but they spare you from thinking.”</em></strong></p><p>And for many, that’s a trade-off they’re perfectly happy to make.</p><h3><strong>Time to Stop Playing Agile Dress-Up</strong></h3><p>The Agile Manifesto never mentioned two-week sprints, story points, velocity charts, or daily standups. It talked about people. About working software. About customer collaboration. About responding to change.</p><p>Somewhere along the way, we turned these principles into theater. We wrapped creativity in ceremonies, duct-taped complexity to velocity charts, and convinced ourselves that compliance was agility.</p><p>But agility was never about process. It was about trust. About letting skilled people do good work, adjust as they learn, and collaborate like grown-ups.</p><p>So the choice is simple: keep performing your perfectly scheduled standups while progress quietly happens in Slack after-hours — or stop pretending and actually reclaim agility. Not the trademarked, certified, process-mandated version, but the messy, adaptive, human one the Manifesto originally called for.</p><p>Because at some point, every team has to decide: do we want to <em>look</em> agile, or do we want to <em>be</em> agile?</p><h3><strong>The Death of SCRUM-as-We-Know-It</strong></h3><p>At this point, we’re long past debating frameworks. What we’re looking at is a fully operational system built to protect itself — and to protect the people who depend on it.</p><p>The modern SCRUM machine doesn’t just tolerate mediocrity — it rewards it.</p><ul><li>You don’t need product vision — you need certification.</li><li>You don’t need courage — you need compliance.</li><li>You don’t need to solve problems — you need to move tickets.</li></ul><p>It has become the perfect ecosystem for the risk-averse: the certified Scrum Masters, the backlog administrators, the Agile Transformation Officers — all comfortably insulated from actual outcomes. It’s an entire caste of process specialists whose real job is to enforce rituals that ensure nobody has to sit with the terrifying responsibility of making real bets.</p><p>And that’s why SCRUM, as it exists today in most companies, cannot be fixed. You can’t reform a system that was re-engineered to eliminate accountability. You can’t “train” people into courage. You can’t run a workshop on judgment. No amount of coaching will turn ceremony-followers into product leaders.</p><p>The companies building great products have already left this behind. They’re not “adapting the framework.” They’re operating in a completely different universe — one where ownership, risk, and real product thinking still exist.</p><p>For everyone else, there’s SCRUM: endlessly refined, endlessly scaled, endlessly certified — and endlessly irrelevant to the work of building something great.</p><p>This isn’t a framework anymore. It’s a bureaucracy with better marketing.</p><p><strong>Stop calling it agile. Call it what it is: process theater.</strong></p><p>And what it needs now isn’t another transformation plan.</p><p><strong>It needs a burial.</strong></p><p>Because the real tragedy isn’t that SCRUM betrayed agility.</p><p>The real tragedy is how many brilliant people are still trapped inside its theater, performing rituals they secretly know are useless — while the work that could actually change things is left starving for oxygen.</p><h3><strong>A note on AI use</strong></h3><p>This piece was written by me — with a little help. Like many non-native English speakers, I use AI as a creative assistant to sharpen phrasing, stress-test arguments, and catch idioms I might otherwise miss. It doesn’t write for me — it helps me write <em>more like me</em>.</p><p>I’ve shared more thoughts on this here: <a href="https://medium.com/@christian.hartvig/ai-isnt-ruining-writing-it-s-finally-giving-non-native-speakers-a-voice-2fdbde4fa870">“AI isn’t ruining writing — it’s finally giving non-native speakers a voice”</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=59c4b0815ae2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why Customer Satisfaction Scores Are Just Gold-Plated Bullsh*t]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@christian.hartvig/why-customer-satisfaction-scores-are-just-gold-plated-bullsh-t-730c0f6d056f?source=rss-940ef270fe1f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/730c0f6d056f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[product-management]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[customer-experience]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[product-development]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[innovation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[business]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Christian Hartvig]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 05 Jun 2025 10:35:35 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-07-06T11:45:38.597Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4><strong>How companies use NPS and CSAT to polish the golden turd — before pulling the chain and sending their business straight down the drain.</strong></h4><figure><img alt="A hyper-polished golden turd displayed on a red velvet pillow, surrounded by exaggerated business symbols like gold stars, coins, trophies, and a customer satisfaction chart, creating a surreal, satirical take on corporate vanity metrics." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*UDWgDl4T5JfVIXIghwwryw.png" /></figure><p>Imagine asking a Blockbuster customer in 2004 if they were happy.</p><p>Of course they were.</p><p>It was Friday night – the ritual that pulled everyone in. Families loaded kids into minivans, couples wandered in for movie night, singles browsed quietly, pretending they weren’t just killing another lonely evening. Nervous first dates played out in awkward debates over which movie to rent, each person trying to read the other’s taste like some fragile early test of compatibility.</p><p>Inside, the humming fluorescent lights cast everything in that strange Blockbuster glow. Kids ran wild between towering shelves. Parents negotiated movie choices like hostage swaps. The jackpot was finding the last copy of a new release. If not, they settled for something close enough.</p><p>The carpets were sticky. The candy was overpriced. The late fees always lurking. But nobody questioned any of it.</p><p>This was normal. This was “happy.”</p><p>Because nobody had ever shown them what <em>better</em> could feel like.</p><p>Then Netflix kicked down the door like a SWAT team on meth, firebombed the business model, and did a TikTok dance on the ashes — while Blockbuster executives clutched their customer satisfaction scores like toddlers gripping the fake steering wheel on a carnival ride, blissfully convinced they were still in control as the tracks collapsed beneath them.</p><p>And that’s the great tragedy of customer satisfaction: people swear they’re happy — right up until someone shows them just how embarrassingly low they’ve set the bar. Satisfaction isn’t greatness. It’s simply proof of how thoroughly your customers have been trained to tolerate mediocrity and call it normal.</p><h3><strong>NPS &amp; CSAT: Corporate Comfort Food for the Delusional</strong></h3><p>Enter NPS (Net Promoter Score) and CSAT (Customer Satisfaction Score): the comfort blankets for risk-averse executives. These aren’t metrics — they’re anesthesia. High-grade corporate opioids, perfectly dosed to let upper management sleep like babies while their companies decompose beneath them.</p><p><em>“Hey look, 87% of customers say they’re satisfied!”</em></p><p>Yes. And 100% of medieval peasants were satisfied with not being disemboweled. Until someone invented soap, democracy, and antibiotics — and ruined that little dream.</p><p>Executives love customer satisfaction scores because they’re easy. One number. One chart. One fantasy where reality politely stays outside the quarterly business review. They don’t want truth. They want plausible deniability in PowerPoint form.</p><p>And this is where satisfaction scores shine: they’re the perfect golden turd — polished just enough to look impressive in the boardroom, but still, unmistakably, a turd. You can buff it, frame it, model charts around it — but the stench always leaks through the corporate perfume.</p><p>Because here’s the thing: BlackBerry’s NPS was fantastic. Nokia’s CSAT was stellar. Yahoo looked great — right up until Google stuffed them into an unmarked grave. Even Enron’s employee satisfaction was glowing — until the FBI arrived with handcuffs.</p><p>Turns out, polishing shit is a terrible growth strategy. But hey — at least the chart looked great in the quarterly business review!</p><h3>The BlackBerry Case Study: Satisfaction vs. Reality</h3><p>The entire customer satisfaction industry rests on one charming little lie: that customers know what they want.</p><p>They don’t.</p><p>They only know what they’ve grown to tolerate. Like hostages developing fondness for their kidnappers.</p><p>Look no further than BlackBerry.</p><p>In 2009, BlackBerry users grinned like lobotomized office hamsters while furiously tapping away at their tiny plastic keyboards. Their executives were swimming in record satisfaction scores. NPS through the roof. Global market share at 20%. In the U.S.? A staggering 50%. BlackBerry wasn’t just winning marketshare — they <em>were</em> the market.</p><p>Then Steve Jobs walked on stage, casually pulled a piece of glass from his pocket, and quietly rewrote reality.</p><p>Overnight, BlackBerry fans suddenly looked like people bragging about how fast their carrier pigeons could deliver messages.</p><p>But instead of reading the writing on the wall, BlackBerry’s leadership did what most corporate executives do best: they doubled down on delusion. Arrogantly waving their glowing satisfaction scores, they declared that business users <em>demanded</em> physical keyboards.</p><p>The result? A complete, textbook collapse.</p><p>In just four years, BlackBerry’s global market share collapsed below 1%. Their stock price imploded, shedding over 90% of its value. They went from untouchable dominance to historical punchline in less time than it takes most big corporations to schedule the first committee meeting about redesigning their logo.</p><p>And through it all, customer satisfaction surveys kept faithfully recording how pleased users had been with their tiny keyboards — oblivious to the fact that the future had already run them over, backed up, and run them over again.</p><p>Naturally, the executives who drove the company straight into a wall were handsomely rewarded for their heroic efforts. Multi-million dollar salaries, stock options, golden parachutes — every button on the self-destruct panel came with a bonus. Because in corporate boardrooms, failure isn’t a career-ending disaster — it’s a retirement plan.</p><h3>Corporate Stockholm Syndrome: How Companies Mistake Hostages for Fans</h3><p>We’ve seen this sad little hostage drama play out on repeat:</p><ul><li>Taxi users swore they were fine — until Uber made standing in the rain feel like a humiliation ritual.</li><li>Hotel guests said they were content — until Airbnb turned spare bedrooms into global mini-empires.</li><li>Record store customers claimed they were happy — until Spotify made physical media feel like hauling furniture.</li><li>Retail shoppers insisted they enjoyed the mall — until Amazon made pants-optional shopping the new default.</li><li>Recruiters lived happily in Excel sheets — until LinkedIn turned headhunting into online window shopping.</li></ul><p>In every case, satisfaction scores told the same comforting lie:</p><p><em>“They love us.”</em></p><p>No, they didn’t.</p><p>They just had nowhere better to go — yet.</p><p>That’s the great corporate fantasy: mistaking lack of alternatives for devotion. Confusing tolerance for enthusiasm. Reading hostage compliance as customer loyalty.</p><p>Meanwhile, the spreadsheets keep lighting up with glowing satisfaction metrics while customers quietly endure the friction, the fees, the annoyances — all while secretly praying for someone to come break the lock.</p><p>Because that’s what Corporate Stockholm Syndrome really is: people learning to praise their captors just to survive another quarter.</p><p>And the executives? They walk into boardrooms waving NPS charts like ransom notes written in glitter:</p><p><em>“See? They’re happy. They love us. Everything’s fine.”</em></p><p>Until, of course, it isn’t.</p><h3><strong>Boardrooms: The Last Safe Spaces for Delusion</strong></h3><p>And this is exactly where these metrics find their true home: the boardroom.</p><p>Why do corporations cling to these metrics like drunks hugging fire hydrants? Because they give permission to remain stupid.</p><p>NPS purrs: “You’re doing great, boss.”</p><p>CSAT whispers: “Steady as she goes.”</p><p>Meanwhile, reality has packed its bags and fled your product roadmap like a hostage escaping through a basement window.</p><p>It’s corporate group therapy. Nobody wants to say: <em>our product sucks.</em> Instead, they polish pie charts while competitors quietly eat their lunch and start on dessert.</p><p>Kodak invented the digital camera. Then Kodak buried it to protect their film sales — while their NPS scores remained perfectly respectable right up to bankruptcy court.</p><p>NPS and CSAT thrive because they’re easy. Safe. Politically harmless. Designed to make insecure executives feel busy while avoiding anything that might threaten next quarter’s bonus.</p><p>It’s innovation cosplay.</p><p>Metrics porn for corporate cowards.</p><p>Dopamine hits for PowerPoint warriors terrified of real risk.</p><h3>When Does Customer Satisfaction Actually Matter?</h3><p>Alright, let’s not get completely drunk on cynicism. There <em>are</em> places where satisfaction scores serve a purpose. They just need to know their place — like karaoke machines and middle managers.</p><p>If you’re running:</p><ul><li>A hotel chain</li><li>An airline</li><li>A delivery service</li><li>A coffee shop</li><li>Basically, anything where <em>consistency</em> is the product</li></ul><p>…then yes, CSAT can actually tell you something. These are businesses where the goal is to not screw up the basics. Hot coffee. Clean rooms. Flights that take off. Bags that arrive where you do. If your CSAT tanks because your pilots keep confusing Auckland, New Zealand with Oakland, California — or your restaurant is serving salmonella with a smile — that’s not customer insight. That’s operational malpractice. And you don’t need customer insight. You need a good cleaning, a great lawyer, and a wildly creative PR team.</p><p>In these high-volume, low-imagination industries, CSAT isn’t strategy — it’s basic sanitation. Keep the essentials working, and nobody notices. Like plumbing: as long as it flushes, life moves on. But the moment it doesn’t, everything backs up, overflows, and suddenly you realize that the whole time, you’ve been full of… well, shit.</p><p>But here’s where companies truly earn their corporate Darwin Awards: they mistake operational hygiene for strategic insight. They take tools built to measure basic competence and try to use them to steer innovation, product vision, and long-term relevance — which is roughly as effective as navigating the open ocean using your fridge light as a lighthouse.</p><p>The more your business relies on creativity, invention, and seeing what others can’t, the more dangerous these metrics become. Because customers can’t crave what hasn’t been invented yet. They’ll happily rate their fax machine five stars — right up until someone hands them an iPhone.</p><p>In short: <strong>Customer satisfaction measures how well you’re meeting expectations. Innovation is about detonating those expectations entirely.</strong></p><h3>Status Quo Bias: The Coward’s Comfort Zone</h3><p>And why do companies keep falling for it? Because <em>inaction feels safe.</em></p><p>In psychology, it’s called <em>status quo bias</em>: the brain’s natural craving for the familiar, even when it’s actively killing you. Daniel Kahneman, Nobel Prize winner and professional demolisher of executive fantasies, showed we fear loss twice as much as we desire gain.</p><p>Translated to corporate English:</p><p><em>We’d rather spiral downward on a 75 NPS than risk upsetting anyone with real change.</em></p><p>This is why companies fund “innovation labs” — glass boxes where nothing dangerous happens — instead of fixing their actual products.</p><p>They hire “transformation consultants” to deliver 300-slide decks that say: <em>Be bold. But carefully.</em></p><p>Clayton Christensen (the author behind the now iconic ‘The Innovator’s Dilemma’) put it simply:</p><p><em>“Most companies fail not because they make the wrong decisions, but because they make no decisions.”</em></p><p>Satisfaction scores are perfect companions to indecision — infinite reassurance that standing still is progress.</p><p>And as Kahneman said:</p><p><em>“We are blind to our own blindness.”</em></p><p>In the end, every “happy” customer is simply one Steve Jobs away from realizing how much they’ve been settling for your mediocrity.</p><h3>Fixed Scores: The Corporate Circle Jerk</h3><p>Let’s be surgical: fixed satisfaction scores are not management tools. They’re masturbatory rituals for middle managers clinging to relevance.</p><p>NPS is not insight. It’s a bloodletting ceremony while the patient slowly dies, smiling for the quarterly report.</p><p>CSAT is not predictive. It’s emotional support for fragile executives desperately avoiding adult conversations.</p><p>The brutal truth? These scores measure nothing but the speed of your funeral procession.</p><p>When Blackberry collapsed, their last quarterly report bragged about record customer satisfaction. When Nokia imploded, their NPS was perfectly healthy. In other words, these metrics are nothing but thermometers jammed into a cooling corpse, reading “normal” while rigor mortis sets in.</p><h3>Goodhart’s Law: When Metrics Mutate Into Monsters</h3><p>There’s an old economic principle that should be engraved above every corporate dashboard — by Charles Goodhart, economist and unintentional destroyer of PowerPoint fantasies:</p><blockquote><strong><em>“When a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure.”</em></strong></blockquote><p>Let’s translate that into something even the KPI cultists in marketing can understand:</p><p>The moment you start chasing the number, you stop chasing the truth.</p><p>Satisfaction scores are especially vulnerable. Because unlike revenue or uptime, NPS and CSAT aren’t grounded in observable reality — they’re subjective, squishy, and dangerously easy to manipulate. A tweak here, a wording change there, a well-timed survey when customers are still drunk on discounts — voilà, you’ve gamed your way to fake success.</p><p>But here’s the real kicker: once the score becomes the goal, everything else bends around it. Products are dumbed down to avoid complaints. Features that cause “confusion” (read: innovation) get delayed or killed. Support agents are told to prioritize a happy emoji over an honest solution. Entire roadmaps are held hostage by a number that exists mostly to preserve internal egos and quarterly bonus math.</p><p>Why? Because change — real, meaningful, potentially disruptive change — often tanks customer satisfaction in the short term.</p><p>And most executives? They’d rather defend a good number than pursue a better future.</p><p>So you don’t ship the bold redesign.</p><p>Because once you start treating the metric as the mission, you’re not serving customers anymore.</p><p>You’re serving the scoreboard.</p><h3>You’re Asking the Wrong F#@&amp;ing Questions</h3><p>After millions spent on strategy decks and transformation consultants, it always comes down to this masterpiece of corporate stupidity:</p><blockquote>“How would you rate us on a scale of 1–5?”</blockquote><p>An act of corporate self-delusion, wrapped in pseudo-science — so mindless it qualifies as avant-garde performance art for executives cosplaying as data scientists, still high on PowerPoint fumes and their own quarterly bonus projections.</p><p>Rate what? Against what exactly? And on whose broken scale? My 1 might be your unambitious, deeply unimaginative 4 — and neither of us has seen what a real 5 even looks like yet.</p><p>It’s like asking a plague-ridden peasant in 1665 to rate their leech doctor while coughing up blood and burying their third cousin: <em>“Fantastic treatment! Only three relatives dead this week — much better than the Johnsons next door!”</em></p><p>The real questions are far uglier — and far more useful:</p><ul><li>If someone you trusted asked, <em>“What should I watch out for with these guys?”</em> — what would you say?</li><li>What part of our experience feels like it hasn’t evolved in years?</li><li>What are you currently solving with spreadsheets, workarounds, or side tools — because we don’t handle it?</li><li>What have you seen elsewhere that quietly makes you think: <em>“Why the hell aren’t we getting that here?”</em></li><li>If you could completely forget tools, features, or vendors — what outcome are you really chasing?</li><li>What part of our product or service feels like it was designed by someone who’s never actually used it?</li><li>If you were forced to rebuild our product from scratch, what would you throw out immediately?</li><li>If we disappeared tomorrow, who would you replace us with — and why?</li><li>Why haven’t you left us already?</li></ul><p>Because the gold? It’s buried exactly where your surveys are often too terrified to go.</p><h3>The Bottom Line</h3><p>If your company still worships at the altar of NPS and CSAT, congratulations: you’ve mastered the art of measuring how blissfully your customers have resigned themselves to your mediocrity — right before they abandon you.</p><p>Stop asking if they’re happy.</p><p>Start asking: What will finally push them to leave.</p><p>And fix it —before your competitors pull the chain and send your golden turd swirling down the drain.</p><h3><strong>A note on AI use</strong></h3><p>This piece was written by me — with a little help. Like many non-native English speakers, I use AI as a creative assistant to sharpen phrasing, stress-test arguments, and catch idioms I might otherwise miss. It doesn’t write for me — it helps me write <em>more like me</em>.</p><p>I’ve shared more thoughts on this here: <a href="https://medium.com/@christian.hartvig/ai-isnt-ruining-writing-it-s-finally-giving-non-native-speakers-a-voice-2fdbde4fa870">“AI isn’t ruining writing — it’s finally giving non-native speakers a voice”</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=730c0f6d056f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>