<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Christie Nordhielm PhD on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Christie Nordhielm PhD on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@christienordhielm?source=rss-ba31e9c694d------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 04:45:55 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Marketing Management: A Systems Framework (15)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/marketing-management-a-systems-framework/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-15-e660600b8dd1?source=rss-ba31e9c694d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e660600b8dd1</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Christie Nordhielm PhD]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 23 Feb 2022 00:47:18 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-02-23T00:48:34.675Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Chapter 15: Metrics</h3><p>Christie L. Nordhielm</p><p>Georgetown University</p><p>© 2021 Christie L. Nordhielm all rights reserved</p><p><em>This is part 15 in a 15-chapter collection that makes up this book. Enjoy!</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-D5b9zLwG__0Z8SmQm17UA.jpeg" /></figure><p>At every step of the framework, we should be collecting information on our performance. Performance metrics, (also referred to as KPI’s or key performance indicators) properly used, help us to monitor and adjust our marketing execution and strategy on an ongoing basis. On the other hand, if metrics are used improperly, they can distort our strategy and have a deleterious impact on execution. It is therefore crucial to our success that we have understanding and facility with metrics.</p><h4>Measuring Results: The Model</h4><p>Throughout this book we have considered different models of the relationships between marketing variables. These models articulate assumptions about cause-and-effect relationships. For example, a core assumption of marketing is that beliefs drive behaviors. To test the strength of this assumption in the marketplace we can measure the two elements and consider how they change in relationship to one another. These measurements give us information on correlation; that is, whether the movement of the two elements are related to each other in some way. It is not generally possible to prove causation in the marketplace; to accomplish this we would need a more controlled environment. Nonetheless, if we collect metrics frequently and consistently, we can glean useful and actionable information about our marketing strategy and execution.</p><p>If our model is incorrect, our metrics can lead to erroneous conclusions. Consider the case of the Nissan “Toys” advertising campaign that aired in the mid-1980s in the United States. The TV commercial developed for this campaign was considered wildly successful; it generated significant awareness and a positive attitude toward the company. After about a month, however, dealers began to complain that the campaign was a failure: sales had not increased at all because of the ad campaign.</p><p>Even though the ad was popular among consumers and had won numerous awards, it was eventually deemed ineffective and was pulled off the air. Obviously, there was a failure somewhere — the company did not achieve their sales targets. However, identifying the ad as the cause of the failure in increasing sales is a misdiagnosis based on an overly simplistic model. The decision to pull this ad in response to poor sales suggests a belief in a one-dimensional model:</p><blockquote>Advertising ▻ Increased sales</blockquote><p>According to this model, if car sales do not increase, the advertising has failed. While this may seem naïve, this type of model, conclusion, and behavior is not uncommon in the marketplace.</p><p>As managers operating in an uncertain and dynamic environment, we must anticipate a certain number of failures. If we rely on simplistic hypotheses, however, any failure will be compounded by the fact that we don’t learn from our mistakes and correct them as appropriate. By spending time to develop a more accurate model, we increase our chances of identifying the true source of our failure and of mitigating this failure with the increased knowledge we obtain from the experience. In the case of Nissan, a better model might look something like this:</p><blockquote>Advertising ▻ Awareness &amp; Attitude Change ▻ Increased Dealer Visits ▻ Increased Sales</blockquote><p>This model is a much better representation of the steps in the process linking advertising exposure and the actual purchase behavior we are seeking. Evaluating the situation through the lens of this model, we draw a very different conclusion as to the source of the failure. The objective of the advertising campaign is to change attitudes toward the car, not to directly increase sales. The sales increase is presumed to be the result of increased dealer visits because of the attitude change. In the case of the “Toys” campaign, advertising <em>did</em> succeed in generating awareness and an attitude change and should therefore be considered “successful” in achieving this change. Furthermore, the change in attitudes led initially to an increase in dealer visits, suggesting that our hypothesis about the relationship between attitude change and dealer visits was correct. Unfortunately, these increased visits didn’t lead to more sales. Why not? Because the product at the dealerships did not meet the expectations created by the advertising. Viewers of the ad campaign were interested in the brand because it seemed hip and cool, featuring a popular rock song, great visuals, and a very entertaining storyline. Those potential customers went to the dealership with these expectations but were met at the dealership by the same salespeople who had always been there, and the product line, apart from the Z series, was composed of mini-vans and family coupes, decidedly un-hip and un-cool. In essence, the same attitudes that drove people into the dealership drove them right back out.</p><p>This more sophisticated model allows us to identify the “failure” in the execution of our strategy more specifically, in such a way that we can make adjustments to improve our performance in the future. The executional failure in the Nissan case occurred in the relationship between the attitude change and the experience at the dealer. To fix this problem, we either need to modify the in-store experience to match the expectations created by the advertising or modify the expectations created by the advertising so we can meet them at the dealership and with the product. This case, and many others just like it, demonstrates the importance of good models. No problem can be diagnosed effectively without one.</p><p>Good models are even more important when we succeed. This is because success breeds an expectation of continued success. Unfortunately, companies (and managers) often celebrate success without taking the time to confirm the true reasons for the success. Sustainable competitive advantage, however, is derived from the ability to replicate success, and this is accomplished by precisely articulating our model, and collecting data that are adequate to test this. It is not enough simply to collect sales data.; it is equally erroneous to collect massive quantities of data without first developing a model.</p><p>In the Nissan case, our model suggests that increased advertising will lead to an attitude change (Nissans are “cool”), and this attitude change will lead to a dealer visit. To test this part of the model, we would collect pre and post-ad exposure attitudes toward the brand, and count dealer visits. Ideally, we would poll a certain number of customers entering dealerships to determine the reason for their visit and their attitudes toward the cars. We would then also briefly question them as they exit, to understand whether their attitude had changed after being at the dealership. These data would help us evaluate the strength of our hypothesis that advertising drives dealer visits and help to rule out other possible explanations for the increase in dealer visits unrelated to the advertising. For example, it is possible that lower interest rates, as opposed to the ad campaign, drove the increase in visits. If this is the case, we would have experienced “success,” but we won’t be able to replicate this success by continuing with our ad campaign.</p><h4>Type of Models</h4><p>Marketers use different types of models to analyze the relationships between variables, and to predict outcomes from marketing actions based on those relationships. The framework is an example of a <em>strategic</em> model; it is based on assumptions about the relationship of customer focus and competitive focus, and between the left side of the framework and the tactical elements on the right side of the framework. When making specific choices within this model structure (e.g., retention spending will drive our ability to stimulate primary demand), we can test the assumptions underlying these choices. An example of a <em>process</em> model is the customer journey from potential customer to retained customer. This type of model attempts to predict consumer behavior based on the relationships amongst some key variables. It assumes, for example, that attitudes drive behaviors. Although we may think that it is obvious that attitudes drive behavior, this link is not always strong. People may report a very positive attitude toward charitable giving or health club attendance, but they do not always behave in a manner congruent with these reported attitudes. Another class of models of interest to marketers is that of <em>psychological</em> models; these are models of how people process information and form attitudes. For example, research in information processing has yielded a variety of models about how people learn and remember things. As a marketer seeking to persuade, it is important to understand these types of models as well. In any case, prior to identifying what metrics we wish to collect, we need to develop a model that represents our beliefs about cause-and-effect relationships.</p><h4>Strategy Integrated Metrics</h4><p>Here we present Strategy-Integrated Metrics (SIMs). SIMs are those metrics that reflect our strategy and execution as expressed in our model(s). SIMs meet five important criteria:</p><p>Strategic. SIMs reflect the strategy of the firm, not just industry convention. Many companies collect metrics using standards established, for example, by equity research analysts, or other industry “experts.” However, equity analysts frequently change the way they look at industries, and when they do, companies who use analyst-generated metrics can be exposed to the considerable expense associated with altering reporting systems; and, more importantly, employee incentives. Also, and more importantly, adopting industry-standard metrics can have a negative impact on firm performance by limiting the company’s creative and market-shaping opportunities. In the 1980s and early 1990s, US airlines increased their reliance on capacity metrics extensively and spent a substantial number of resources on revenue management systems and processes. Moreover, airlines benchmarked their yields against those of other airlines. This narrow focus on revenue management left the industry open to the entrance of low-cost competition. In contrast to this focus on capacity utilization and revenue, low-cost entrants, like Southwest Airlines, measured the execution of their cost-focused strategy using aircraft and employee productivity metrics. They benchmarked their yields against those of alternative forms of transportation, such as buses and trains. The differentiated approach Southwest took to its strategy, clearly mirrored in its metrics, enabled it to become and remain competitive in a much broader transportation category.</p><p>More recently (and perhaps even more dangerously) metrics have been established by the firms selling advertising, e.g., Facebook or YouTube. Adopting generic or externally provided metrics is equivalent to blindly following someone else’s strategies, good and bad. It is crucial that our metrics collection is independent from the firms who might benefit by increases in these metrics. By strategically controlling the metrics we collect and respond to, we control our strategy and increase our impact on outcomes. SIMs represent this strategic approach to metrics setting. SIMs meet the following criteria:</p><blockquote><em>Prioritized.</em> SIMs are hierarchical: they follow a top-down approach. They begin with an overall business objective, financial in nature, which is followed by the lower complementary goals necessary to make the overall business objective a reality. Many businesses implementing performance measurement dashboards set many parallel objectives. This can be both confusing and wasteful as it results in resources being split amongst many initiatives with potentially conflicting, yet equally important priorities. Consider the case of a major leasing company where each of its major functions holds separate metric-setting sessions. The sales teams naturally adopt revenue targets; the customer service department uses cost metrics; and finally, the asset management department, a profit center, measures profitability. Under the incentive system that these broad metrics create, the asset management department institutes a policy by which customers returning equipment, at the end of their leases, face high fees for lightly damaged equipment or missing manuals. The customer service department, to reduce call times, outsources sensitive customer complaint resolution calls (many of them regarding the missing and damaged charges) to a third party. However, they and the third party lack a detailed understanding of the delicate customer issues facing the organization. Finally, the sales team misses its targets as word-of-mouth impacts customers’ willingness to do business with the company. The company would have saved precious resources and increased its chances of meeting its sales targets if it had first prioritized its goals, and then carefully established metrics designed to achieve them.</blockquote><blockquote><em>Integrated.</em> SIMs integrate internal and external perspectives of firm performance. They link the firm’s success criteria — its overall business objective and overall firm positioning — to the customer and employee behaviors; and operational processes necessary to achieve them. The metrics-setting process should reflect this interrelatedness and should therefore be iterative: the management team will select overall business goals and the overall company positioning, and will then model prerequisite employee and customer behaviors, and internal processes. This iterative process should continue until a realistic and congruent combination of goals, behaviors, and processes is found. The process for establishing SIMs is discussed in more detail later in the chapter.</blockquote><blockquote><em>Causal.</em> SIMs address root causes rather than merely identifying symptoms. Building metrics based on causal models allows managers to learn from their mistakes and to replicate successes. SIMs require that our models are continually tested, rather than simply assumed. For example, managers may believe that 100% customer satisfaction is required to increase customer retention and in turn achieve their revenue goals. Yet achieving 100% customer satisfaction may be difficult and extremely expensive. Prior to setting this type of overall objective, managers ought to test the relationship between satisfaction, retention, and revenue. Otherwise, they will risk wasting precious resources by establishing metrics that may or may not contribute to their strategic goals. While testing several models may seem overwhelming, wasting resources implementing the wrong metrics is infinitely more expensive.</blockquote><blockquote><em>Competency-Based.</em> SIMs reflect and foster the core competence of the firm. The firm’s chosen positioning is directly tied to the benefits it offers its customers, and in turn, those benefits are directly linked to the core competence of the company. Therefore, the company’s business metrics should help us measure and continually enhance the core competence of the company. Consider the case of a large supermarket chain that, upon implementation of the framework, chose to reposition itself on the main benefit of Freshness. The company selected a financial goal consistent with that positioning through an iterative process which carefully mapped salient customer experiences at the supermarket. They then articulated the prerequisite operational processes that would engender these experiences, identify congruent purchasing behaviors, and estimate their financial impact. The company’s freshness positioning is directly linked to the company’s core competence in process and agro-industrial operations. Progress towards implementation of the new positioning is measured through a handful of metrics that require best-in-class agro-sourcing, cold distribution chain management, and in-store display and merchandising. Successfully meeting the company’s operational metrics simultaneously enhances the company’s core competence, its competitive position, and most importantly bottom line.</blockquote><h4>The Process of Metric Setting</h4><p>The process of establishing SIMs goes hand in hand with the process of executing the company’s strategy. In establishing SIMS, we need to think back to each step in the framework and follow an iterative process by which we formulate a model, we gather data and adjust the model and then prioritize projects across the organization based on the result. Metrics setting will naturally take place as part of the company’s strategic process. As such, although we address metrics as the capstone chapter of the framework, many of the activities included in this discussion have already been undertaken in other chapters of the framework. To set metrics we can follow these steps:</p><blockquote><em>Measure the core competence:</em> The company’s ability to establish SIMs is tied to its understanding of its core competence. This understanding should be reality-based rather than merely intuitive. So, for example, an executive team who claims their company has a core competence in logistics must be able to demonstrate that the company’s logistic capabilities are best in class. One way to measure the core competence is through benchmarking: assessing skills of other firms and comparing them to our own. While we may benchmark basic <em>competences</em> against industry competitors, we benchmark <em>core competences</em> against best-in-class firms outside our industry. For example, a consulting company looking for benchmarking data on logistics should probably look to logistics-intensive industries such as fleet management or inventory management industries.</blockquote><blockquote>Measure and connect the core benefit:<em> Once we have a good understanding of our core competence, we need to connect it to our customers perception and importance of our core benefit tied to this competence. We must have metrics in place to consistently measure this information; in combination with executional metrics, we will be able to assess our ongoing performance and make appropriate adjustments. If we are implementing an earn share strategy, we will likely track importance and perception ratings for our key competitors as well.</em></blockquote><blockquote>Connect the business objective:<em> The link between the business objective and the strategy of the organization is established through SIMs. In the end, all other metrics will ladder up to this objective, and each one is therefore connected, either directly or indirectly to the business objective. Incoherent metrics result in unrealistic goals; that is, goals that do not reflect the reality of the organization and its customers. The role of metrics vis-à-vis the business objective of the firm is two-fold: they provide the information the company needs to establish realistic goals, and they play a diagnostic role in the evaluation firm performance. Firms who lack diagnostic metrics are unable to turn success and failure into continuous learning.</em></blockquote><blockquote>Tie financial objectives to customer value and behaviors:<em> To build the financial model needed to articulate our business objective, we need to turn to the work already done in customer and competitive focus assessment. Several important definitions and key measures are estimated in these steps of the framework. In the customer focus chapter, we discussed alternative customer definitions, using either spend, frequency of purchase, share of wallet, or another loyalty measure. While behavioral customer definitions are appropriate for products with frequent purchase cycles, for products with longer purchase cycles loyalty measures or purchase intention are generally more adequate. For customer focus we should also estimate the 1) percentage of resources we are allocating to acquisition and retention and 2) the acquisition and retention rates for the firm. With these data and contribution information we can calculate CLV. CLV is a core metric for most firms; however, it is our understanding of the drivers of CLV that will make our metrics strategic.</em></blockquote><blockquote>Model customer experience and operational metrics:<em> Once we have identified financial goals, core competence, and core benefit metrics, we can drill down to experience and operational metrics that are aligned with our higher-level goals. This is a far more detailed process as it involves identifying metrics throughout all levels of the organization in all functional areas. We present this process below.</em></blockquote><h4>Identifying Input and Output Metrics</h4><p>Before proceeding to detailing operational metrics, we must clearly discern <em>input</em> and <em>output</em> metrics. Essentially, the names here tell the story: input metrics measure resources and or/activities that we commit to to achieve a result that we measure with output metrics. For example, we might invest $30M in a TV campaign designed to increase awareness by 20%. These input/output relationships can be more detailed or general, depending on our functional perspective. For example, we may “zoom in” to set metrics for a specific activity (e.g., field 5 in-store sampling teams over 2 weeks) and a more specific output (achieve product trial among 500 unique customers.) Or we might “zoom out” and set an input metric as our total marketing budget of $250M and an output metric of changing brand perception of our brand as tasty from a 7 to a 9 on a 10-point scale. Our advertising and sampling activities should link up to this higher-level perception goal. This means that a lower-level output (e.g., perception) might become an input for a higher-level output (e.g., acquisition rate).</p><p>Because our metrics are built on our company strategy, they will necessarily be distinct from those of our competitors. Consider the example in Figures 1 and 2 below. In this first example we present potential input and output metrics for a Southwest Airline whose core benefit we will identify as <em>efficiency</em>. In Figure 1 we outline the customer journey from their recognition of a need to travel, their search and comparison of alternatives, on to purchase, use and finally post-purchase experience. We then identify our target consumer’s current experience (prior to using our product). In the final column we identify the desired experience, which should be aligned with the Southwest positioning.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*iDvlxqYH6kedTNXUDakmMA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Figure 1: Southwest Airlines current and desired experience</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*uTqqcjN5pQ4aBvPuQChphg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Figure 2: Southwest Airlines evaluation and experience metrics</figcaption></figure><p>The desired customer experience gives us a road map for identifying input and output metrics as presented in Figure 2. By linking these metrics to the desired customer experience, we ensure that our activities are coherent with our strategy, and by extension differentiated from our competitors. Consider a similar exercise for Delta airlines, with a presumed core benefit of <em>service.</em> Let’s assume, for purposes of simplicity, they are targeting the same customer as Southwest, and the current experience is therefore the same. However, the desired experience, and therefore input and output metrics, are quite different.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*F0jbNDT7BpnW_i3-xXspQg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Figure 3: Delta Airlines current and desired experience</figcaption></figure><p>Because Delta is seeking to support the core benefit of service, they tend to focus on elements of the experience that help the customer to perceive the unique service elements that are available to the Delta Airlines customer. This positioning leads them to pursue a different desired experience, and therefore different metrics as presented in Figures 3 and 4.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*G3aEs9PbVNwj0JXUYk4owQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Figure 4: Delta Airlines input and output metrics</figcaption></figure><h4>Systems Thinking and Metrics</h4><p>Strategic thinking leads to strategic action; the metrics we create and pay attention to have a dramatic impact on the actions we take. This is why it is so important to clearly and specifically outline our metrics and be sure they adhere to the criteria described in this chapter. The crucial relationship in the model below is between our focus on strategic vs. generic metrics. If we lose discipline and simply choose metrics based on external factors, we will end up de-emphasizing strategic metrics. In contrast, as we increase our use of strategic metrics, unnecessary, generic metrics will tend to recede.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/936/1*VTwvZDvOj3WnjognIm3UyA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Figure 5: Systems model of strategic metrics</figcaption></figure><h4>Metrics and the Framework</h4><p>Any model or framework offers us a jumping-off place for developing coherent metrics. For example, as we use the systems framework to develop our strategic plan, we inevitably will encounter areas where we are more uncertain as to what our model looks like, or where we feel we must make several assumptions in our analysis. These are areas where we might consider further research, or at minimum where we will focus our attention as we monitor the effects of our plan. Furthermore, the strategic models we develop and rely upon are most crucial; no amount of great execution can make up for bad strategy. Unfortunately, the proliferation of marketing tactics and tools available to us has moved our focus from strategy to execution. While this shift might yield short-term positive results, sustainable competitive advantage results from strategic and executional coherence. A clear articulation of our metrics at all levels of the organization is a first step toward achieving this coherence.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0TUrOdY328ghE2HDjAIylQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Figure 6: Metrics and strategy</figcaption></figure><p>Figure 6 outlines some potential key metrics that could be considered at different stages of the framework. The metrics identified on the left side of the framework will drive our decisions as we move through to execution and are therefore most important. It is crucial, for example, that we measure our core competence, acquisition and retention rates and spend, and CLV. After we have identified our core benefit and strategic focus, we will know what type of perception/importance data we will track. While the type of metrics we collect will be quite specific and distinct when we get to execution, there are general categories we will evaluate in each of the four Ps. For product, we are interested in tracking how well our product supports our positioning. We will likely also track our relative price premium if we are implementing an earn share strategy and will want to monitor price implementation in any case. We will also seek to monitor channel implementation and communications implementation.</p><p>These top-line metrics are the start of the development of a coherent metrics plan. Metrics, properly implemented, keep us honest, focused, and coherent. As such, they are arguably the most important element of the framework.</p><h3>Marketing Management: A Systems Framework</h3><h3>Conclusion</h3><p><em>“They have succeeded in accumulating a greater mass of objects, but the joy in the world has grown less.”</em></p><p>- Fyodor Dostoevsky, The Brothers Karamazov</p><p>As marketers, we often tend to focus on the short-term impact of our efforts on awareness, behavior, and of course sales. But the impact of marketing is far greater than that. Marketers construct our cultural landscape, establish norms of behavior amongst consumers. This is why systems thinking is so important in marketing. We must establish a habit of stepping back and considering the bigger picture: the long-term impact of our actions on our community and on society. As issues such as climate change, income inequality and societal fragmentation loom larger and larger, it is incumbent upon us as marketing professionals and citizens of the world to carefully consider where and how we might have a positive impact, not just on sales, but on the general well-being of our fellow humans. Anyone reading this book is likely already enjoying substantial financial wealth; this is the easy part. The difficult part is <em>to do important work</em> that has a positive impact on our worlds, the small, close ones like our world of family and friends, and the large ones that extend across many borders. This is true prosperity.</p><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/marketing-management-a-systems-framework/marketing-management-9dcd7af7af82">Chapter 1</a>: Introduction and Ethics</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/marketing-management-a-systems-framework/chapter-2-fb1b1c97ed2">Chapter 2:</a> Systems Thinking</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-46ee0f9e8fed">Chapter 3:</a> Business Objective</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-acca9198d5c4">Chapter 4</a>: Customer Focus</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-5606fe5549cd">Chapter 5</a>: Competitive Focus</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-caef5a55ce5">Chapter 6</a>: Estimating Market Potential/The 4 B’s</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-7-6d70d7d82fe">Chapter 7</a>: Segmentation</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-8-cd67a3a30366">Chapter 8</a>: Targeting</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-9-dda03c5b30b">Chapter 9</a>: Positioning</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-10-6ed681a90fc3">Chapter 10</a>: Product</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-11-2b15ae515308">Chapter 11:</a> Service as Product</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-12-226d545c4557">Chapter 12:</a> Communications</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-13-7deb8a757a1a">Chapter 13</a>: Channels</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-14-75ec5ec787c1">Chapter 14:</a> Pricing</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-15-e660600b8dd1">Chapter 15:</a> Metrics</blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e660600b8dd1" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/marketing-management-a-systems-framework/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-15-e660600b8dd1">Marketing Management: A Systems Framework (15)</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/marketing-management-a-systems-framework">Marketing Management: A Systems Framework</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Marketing Management: A Systems Framework (14)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/marketing-management-a-systems-framework/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-14-75ec5ec787c1?source=rss-ba31e9c694d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/75ec5ec787c1</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Christie Nordhielm PhD]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 02 Feb 2022 00:21:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-02-23T00:49:14.225Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Chapter 14: Pricing</h3><p>Christie L. Nordhielm</p><p>Georgetown University</p><p>© 2021 Christie L. Nordhielm all rights reserved</p><p><em>This is part 14 in a 15-chapter collection that makes up this book. Enjoy!</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*FRlGZfKS6igDX71q6tjf_w.jpeg" /></figure><p>Pricing strategy and implementation requires the use of both sides of the brain. It should come as no surprise that sound pricing strategy depends on our ability to “run the numbers:” use quantitative analysis to estimate such elements as contribution margin, price sensitivity, impact of a price change on revenue, etc. The fact that a price is a number naturally leads us in the direction of quantitative analysis. Pricing is also inherently tied to more qualitative issues such as competitive strategy, and the importance of competitive analysis in developing pricing strategy cannot be underestimated. Finally, consumer psychology is a crucial consideration for pricing strategy and tactics. Thus, both qualitative and quantitative analysis are necessary for development of sound pricing strategy and tactics.</p><h4>Characteristics of Pricing</h4><p>There are distinct characteristics of pricing compared to the other executional elements of the framework at our disposal that merit consideration.</p><blockquote>First, price is the element that is easiest to change;<em> in the digital space prices can be changed nearly instantaneously. pricing is one of the easiest to change. While this may seem to be a good thing at first glance, the fact that we can and do change price so quickly can prevent us from learning about any longer-term or strategic implications of our strategy. This will drive us into a purely tactical approach to pricing which may not be optimal.</em></blockquote><blockquote>Second, price is tied directly to profits in a way that differs from the other marketing elements<em>. There is an allure to taking a price increase to ostensibly make a quick change to our bottom line, or to take a price cut ostensibly to quickly improve our competitive position. While we may want to make these moves, again we need to make them in the context of our longer-term strategy.</em></blockquote><blockquote>Third, price is pervasive throughout the organization<em>. A price change has an obvious impact on short-term profitability but will also impact consumer perceptions and competitive position. For this reason, it is important that the marketing team is involved in pricing decisions.</em></blockquote><p>The best way to keep these characteristics in mind is to clearly distinguish pricing tactics, short-term moves we make to elicit specific, short-term responses, from pricing strategy, our longer-term approach to managing our brand and our pricing. We will discuss this distinction further in this chapter.</p><h4>Steps in the Pricing Process</h4><p>The pricing process can be broken down into two basic stages: price-making and price implementation. Price-making is influenced most significantly by decisions made in the business objective and strategic focus steps of the framework. For example, if our business objective is to increase profits ten percent, it is likely that a change in pricing or variable costs will figure prominently into our strategy. Our customer focus on retention or acquisition will also influence price setting: existing customers commonly have different price expectations than do potential customers. Finally, our competitive focus will affect our overall price-making process. If, for example, we are implementing a earn-share strategy, prices likely will be benchmarked against our key competitor.</p><p>Price implementation, how we execute our pricing strategy, is integrally linked not just to the other Ps of product, place, and promotion, but also with our STP decisions. Pricing will be implicated directly if we have chosen price as our main or dynamic benefit; for example, if we are seeking to earn share based on a superior price (better value) then we will obviously benchmark our prices vs. our target competitor. We will only use price as a main or dynamic benefit if we have a core competence that enables us to consistently deliver a better price or value.</p><p>Even if we are not positioning our product based on a price benefit, price will be part of our communications and positioning process. If we are trying to establish a luxury positioning, for example, we will seek to maintain a price premium vs. competitors and will avoid price promotion tactics. If we are promoting the benefit of convenience or ease of use, we may seek to simplify our pricing strategy to make it simple and easy to understand. If we are trying to maintain a hand-loyal customer base, we may minimize our price communications, keep our price high, and rely on the fact that our low-involved customer base is not particularly sensitive to price if the product keeps working.</p><p>Price implementation is also related to the customer experience of price. How consumers perceive our prices is influenced by a variety of factors, some within our control and some outside our control. Our price is not absolute, but relative, evaluated by consumers in the context of other competitive prices, past prices paid, the prices of substitute products (products that may satisfy some of the same needs for customers as our product), advertising, promotion, and other channel factors such as availability. Different consumers also vary in their individual decision-making and information processing approaches; this too has a significant influence on their perceptions of price. While we may have a hypothesis about how our price will be perceived by consumers, it is crucial to test this hypothesis on an ongoing basis in the marketplace. Thus, while “price” appears in one small box in the framework, it should not be considered in isolation, but rather as a factor that influences and is influenced by other variables both inside and outside the framework.</p><h4>Price-Making: The Economics of Price</h4><p>To understand pricing, we must first understand the economic concept of surplus. Consider the purchase of a cup of Starbucks coffee: a Grande Pike Place Roast at the San Jose drive-through is priced at $2.75. Because I find the drive through so convenient, I would have been willing to pay $3.00 — this is my <em>perceived value </em>for this cup of coffee. The difference between a customer’s perceived value and the actual price of the product is that individual’s <em>consumer surplus</em>, and the aggregate of everyone’s willingness to pay minus the actual price is the total consumer surplus, represented by the pink triangle in Figure 1. The folks at Starbucks would love to be able to capture all that surplus and add it to their producer surplus, the difference between the revenues they collect and the costs they incur (Figure 2). Unfortunately, it will be difficult or impossible to know what each customer’s exact perceived value is. In addition, they will likely be unable to price each cup of coffee differently for each customer.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*johT8BhZDdo6wcXr9siiIQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Figure 1: Downward Sloping Demand Curve</figcaption></figure><p>In Figure 2 we represent consumer and producer surplus and include another type of surplus we will refer to as <em>unrealized surplus.</em>This is the difference between perceived value and another, more theoretical that we characterize as the “true” value of the cup of coffee. This theoretical number represents the value a consumer might assign to this product if she fully understood and appreciated all the benefits the product might represent. For example, by drinking this cup of coffee she may avoid falling asleep at the wheel while driving home and getting into an accident. How much would it be worth to avoid a car accident? Far more than $2.75.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4PCawC5r_RSZaLI0CPOk6A.jpeg" /><figcaption>Figure 2: Sources of Surplus</figcaption></figure><p>Cost, price, perceived value, and true value are the variables we have available to play with to increase our profits, or producer surplus. The simplest way to increase profits is to <em>reduce costs</em>. Cost reduction is a constant goal for most firms: they seek to increase production efficiencies, reduce labor and materials costs, and improve technology help to reduce costs. However, there is a lower limit to this approach; we can at most reduce costs to 0, and as we reduce costs, we run the risk of negatively impacting our product quality. These cost reduction activities can have an impact on our marketing strategy but tend to be the responsibility of other functional areas in the firm; it is important for marketing to provide guidance or at least input on these decisions.</p><p>From a marketing perspective, we must look beyond cost reductions to increase producer surplus. To accomplish this, we can either try to <em>capture more existing consumer surplus</em> via the price discrimination tools presented below or try to <em>raise perceived value</em> and thus increase willingness to pay.</p><h4>Capturing Consumer Surplus</h4><p>The practice of attempting to identify groups of consumers with higher or lower willingness to pay and then provide a different price to these groups is known as price discrimination. This tactic of differentiating between consumers with high and low-price sensitivity is a potential means of increasing surplus without having an overall negative impact on demand for our product. There are several ways to accomplish this:</p><p><em>Second Market Discounting</em> is an option for a firm with excess capacity seeking to move inventory in a second market that is distinct from the primary market. Quite often this distinction is geographic; for example, we may attempt to sell excess inventory in a different country or region at a lower price. The second market also may be distinguished by other variables such as type of outlet. A warehouse store that sells excess Lands’ End inventory is an example of second market discounting.</p><p><em>“Pricing to Market”</em> (pricing differently based on the different willingness to pay in different markets) and differential pricing by channels are powerful strategy if arbitrage can be prevented. Arbitrage, simply stated, is buying low and selling high. If the same product is sold at two different prices in two different locations, then it may be possible to buy low and sell high. Preventing this arbitrage requires that we choose to differentially price in markets that are clearly separated from one another (ideally both physically and conceptually). Additionally, there must be some cost to move goods from one market to another; this might be as simple as the cost of transportation or, in the case of a cross-border differential price, there may be taxes (tariffs) or non-tariff barriers (perhaps there are laws restricting imports, such as those that prevent Canadian pharmacies from selling drugs in the United States). In some cases, the transaction cost is just too high; (I may be able to find a book for a lower price on Amazon.com than my corner bookstore, but if I need it today, the cost of waiting for delivery may outweigh the lower price). Effective second market discounting will occur only if the price differential between the two markets is less than or equal to the costs of buying low in one market and selling high in the other.</p><p>Periodic Discounting is reduction of price at a fixed, pre-determined point in time. The traditional January White Sale held by many department stores is an example of this practice. Price-sensitive consumers with low search costs, who would not otherwise enter the marketplace, and who don’t mind delaying their purchases a little bit, anticipate these sales and take advantage of the lower prices. Consumers with higher search costs will not have the motivation or ability to identify and limit their purchases to these sale periods; alternatively, they simply may not be able to wait (if a present needs to be under the tree on December 25, the buyer may not be able to wait until the January sale, even if she would like to). Periodic discounting allows the marketer to extract a higher price from the consumers with the higher willingness to pay, while still generating sales revenues from the more price-sensitive segment who doesn’t mind searching out and waiting for the “Big Sales.”</p><p><em>Random Discounting</em> is discounting that occurs not at a (predictable) fixed time of year, but rather at random periods throughout the year. The advantage of random discounting, versus periodic discounting, is that the predictability of periodic discounting results in some customers with a high willingness to pay (perhaps because they have high disposable incomes, etc.) waiting for the sales that are designed to appeal to customers with a low willingness to pay. By removing the predictability of the sales, theoretically, the consumers with high search costs and lower price sensitivity will not worry about trying to uncover discounts or predict sales, but rather will purchase the product immediately and at a high price. In contrast, consumers with lower search costs and higher price sensitivity still benefit from sales that put the products in their price range, but just must be patient and then act quickly when a sale does occur (note: this requires that they spend additional resources to monitor prices and identify sale periods). Hence, just like periodic discounting, the producer can charge higher prices to the less price sensitive segment while still selling to the highly price sensitive consumers on a regular basis. The advantage of this technique is that it reduces the number of sales to the “wrong” buying segment.</p><p><em>Product Line Pricing</em> represents another class of tactics designed to extract surplus value from consumers. These tactics are designed to capitalize on consumers’ heterogeneous demand for certain products. The central element of product line pricing is that all products within the product line are priced relative to one another. Products that deliver less value (for example, products that have fewer features) are priced lower than products that deliver more value. A straightforward example of product line pricing is BMW’s pricing strategy illustrated in Figure 3. The prices for the 3 series are lower than the 5 series, which are lower than the 7 series, etc. With each “series” increase, BMW adds features and value. The product line has some common characteristics (quality standards, reputation, image — the cars may even have many technologies in common, for example the same braking system or headlight bulbs), but between each product in the line there are distinct differences that justify, in the eyes of the consumer, different prices. Product line pricing takes advantage of the fact that different customer segments may be willing to pay more to receive more value.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ZhhoEVFZ5jUIoz3cWpunMQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Figure 3: BMW Product Line Pricing</figcaption></figure><p><em>Menu Pricing</em> can be thought of as a type of product line pricing. A hamburger on its own is $0.69, but add cheese and it rises to $0.89, add a second patty and lettuce, onions and special sauce and it rises to $1.09. Product line pricing can be used strategically; a customer may be lured in by the promise of a $0.49 hamburger, but then realizes that the burger would really be better with cheese, lettuce, sauce, etc., and decides to up the purchase to $1.09 (a 122 percent increase). This is not the same as an (illegal) bait-and-switch tactic,13 since the $0.49 hamburger is fully available for sale, it is simply revealing to the customer other alternatives available for purchase and allowing the customer to weigh whether she would get more than $0.60 of surplus (in the example cited above) by “trading up” to the more feature-laden burger.</p><p><em>Price Bundling</em> involves offering several products for sale in a group to consumers who may value the individual products differently. For example, a movie distributor may bundle several movies of varying popularity together and offer them at a particular price. If these movies were sold individually, theatres might only purchase certain titles, thus reducing overall sales volume and revenue. The distributor who bundles these titles and offers them at a slight discount will achieve higher overall sales volume and revenue.</p><p>There are two types of bundling: pure bundling and mixed bundling.14 In the case of pure bundling, the products are only offered as a package. To stick with the movie theme, in pure bundling, the videotapes of two movies like Ace Ventura: Pet Detective and Ace Ventura: When Nature Calls would only be offered for sale together (perhaps in a shrink-wrapped two-tape set). Pure bundling of this sort is valuable when one of the products is unlikely to sell well on its own; as a bundle, however, its “piggybacks” on the success of the product or products with which it is bundled.</p><p>In mixed bundling, the products (movies) are offered not only together as a set, but also separately; the bundle is then offered at less than the sum of the two videos when offered separately. The key to the success of this strategy is that there must be at least three distinct segments of people in the world — those who liked “Pet Detective” enough to pay a high price for it, but didn’t really like “When Nature Calls” enough to buy it; those who had the opposite preference (loved “Nature,” but disliked “Pet Detective”), and those who liked both movies, but not enough to purchase either on a “stand-alone” basis (at a high price). By bundling the two movies together and offering a slight discount, this last group purchases them, whereas those with strongly polarized preferences purchase one movie or the other (but at a high price).</p><p><em>Premium Pricing</em> is simply the practice of offering additional features and benefits to a sub-segment of buyers interested in paying more for these add-ons.15 Business class airline travel is a classic example of this pricing tactic; instead of offering the same grade of service to every passenger at a certain price, the airlines can realize higher revenues by identifying a target segment that is willing to pay more to get more. Premium pricing is like product line pricing but does not necessarily require a full product line to be carried out. For example, a certain limousine service could be “premium priced” relative to other car services if it offers special types of cars (stretch Humvee limos, limos with Jacuzzis, etc.). In comparison to competitors that just offer “Town cars,” the specialty limo service might command a “premium” in its price. This premium pricing could occur even if the specialty service offers no “normal” cars; the premium is relative to other alternatives.</p><p><em>Image Pricing</em> is increasing the price of a product to attract a certain price-insensitive segment of the population that believes that a higher-priced product signals a better product. This tactic is distinct from the premium pricing tactic because, in this case, while the price is higher, the actual features of the product are not substantively changed. Consumers’ willingness to pay significantly more for Chanel perfume vs. a private label perfume with the same formulation is a classic example of image pricing. In a similar vein, Hervé Chapelier handbags are made of inexpensive nylon, yet sell for much more than many leather bags at our local luggage stores. These handbags command a high price not because of the value of the materials in which they are made, but because of the image they convey. The very fact that they are distinctive looking and expensive signals something about the owners to others; the owners are, effectively, buying this image when they’re buying the handbag.</p><p><em>Complementary Pricing</em> is a tactic that involves low-balling the price of one item that is used in tandem with another item. The classic example of this is the practice of selling razors at a very low price, then making up profits on the sale of the replacement razor blades. For marketers attempting to leverage this strategy, it is crucial that the product is proprietary; that is, competitors will not be able to step in and sell razor blades to fit the razor at a lower price.</p><p>The other time that this type of pricing happens is in a retail context, when the retailer offers one product at a very low price to encourage the sales of other products (this is the low-price leader strategy noted in the opening section of this module). A grocery store knows that consumers often use the price of milk as a benchmark for how well a store’s products are priced (this has been shown empirically). As a result, the grocer prices milk at cost (or below cost, which is legal in the United States, but illegal in some other countries), to attract shoppers and then sells other items (for example, cereal) at very high margins.</p><h4>Competitive Pricing Tactics</h4><p>We have addressed pricing tactics that reflect attempts to capture additional surplus by looking internally within the firm and lowering the company’s cost base, thus increasing producer surplus, or outside the firm, and discriminating between consumers, obtaining additional consumer surplus. Another class of pricing tactics results from consideration of our competition’s prices. In general, these tactics involve attempting to use price to capture additional market share, presumably to obtain a competitive advantage. The focus of these tactics is to price relative to our competitors. It is thus important to be aware that in implementing such tactics we are: 1) moving our attention away from our end consumer, and 2) potentially allowing our competition to drive our pricing strategy. As such, there is significant risk associated with these tactics, and they should be considered only for short-term purposes. Before engaging we should predetermine exactly what we’re aiming to accomplish with the tactic, the length of time it will take to do it, what we will do after the goal is reached.</p><p>Additionally, whenever we use these tactics, we must monitor our competitors’ reactions closely. A key risk to competitive pricing is that it may tip off a price war. If this happens, we most likely will need to immediately take a step back and move to a more strategic approach. The more widespread our use of competitive pricing, the greater the likelihood that a price war will result; as such, we should use these tactics sparingly and with our “eyes wide open.” In the early 1990s a price war was waged in the cigarette market. In the early 1990’s discount cigarette brands successfully sought to earn share from name brands such as Marlboro, whose share eroded from 30 to 22 percent by 1993. On April 2, 1993 (the infamous “Marlboro Friday”) Philip Morris responded by cutting the price on its brands by around 20 percent on April 2, 1993. Philip Morris market capitalization initial dropped by around 20 percent as well. The move effectively ended the price war, however, and over time, however, the brand share and prices eventually recovered.</p><p>We will discuss four types of competitive pricing tactics. While widely used, pricing tactics motivated by competitive concerns are unlikely to yield sustainable market share gains if they are at odds with our already established strategic decisions.</p><blockquote><em>Penetration Pricing</em> is the tactic of pricing a product low, sometimes below variable cost, to secure share and therefore achieve some level of volume necessary to develop economies of scale. For this tactic to be successful, the producer 1) must have an accurate forecast of future sales, and 2) be able to leverage economies of scale to lower variable costs in the long run. Latecomers to a market who are striving to catch up to the first mover in a market often employ this tactic. It is performed best by followers who have a cost advantage relative to the incumbent; a large company with deep pockets tries to overcome a startup that has been first to market in a nascent category.</blockquote><blockquote><em>Experience Curve Pricing</em> involves introducing a new product with a low price based on the expectation that continued learning about how to produce and market the product eventually will lower variable costs to the point of long-term profitability. Again, accurate forecasts of both volume and anticipated cost reductions are crucial for this strategy to work.</blockquote><blockquote><em>Price Signaling</em> involves using price as a communication tool, usually to sustain price levels and profitability in a category. For example, a market leader may announce an across-the-board ten percent price hike in the hopes that competitors will follow suit and overall category profitability will increase. This tactic is particularly dangerous because it easily can be interpreted as anti-competitive/collusive. Nevertheless, it is quite common in some industries (for example, the airlines).</blockquote><blockquote><em>Geographic Pricing</em> is the tactic of taking transportation costs into account when pricing a product to achieve a competitive advantage in certain markets. For example, a producer on the East Coast of the United States may choose to offer products in the eastern region at a lower price than their West Coast rivals because its shipping costs are lower.</blockquote><p>In addition to these tactics, we will also consider competitive pricing from a strategic perspective as described below.</p><h4>Strategy vs. Execution</h4><p>Short-term tools can be effective for capturing consumer surplus and market share; however, it is important to remember that these tactics are just that: tactical. They have a short-term impact and are not necessarily tied to our overall strategy. It is very important that we distinguish between tactics and strategies both internally, and in our communications to the customer. If we do not, short-term price reductions can quickly become permanent as our customer adapt and begin to expect lower prices. Therefore, it is crucial to communicate a clear timeframe for tactical price reductions, and/or clearly identify why we are making the specific price change. We must always overlay our tactical activities on a solid strategic foundation.</p><p>The final area of opportunity outlined in Figure 2 takes this strategic approach. Here we are essentially interested in capturing additional unrealized surplus by increasing perceived value. This method increases producer surplus but does not decrease consumer surplus. For example, Starbuck’s might promote their late-night drive-through, emphasizing the convenience and the safety of being awake while driving. This might push the average perceived value the cup of coffee to $5.00. In essence, Starbucks would be seeking to capture some of the unrealized value by pushing perceived value closer to “true” value. We will refer to this approach as a value pricing strategy. Generally, this approach is best utilized by category leaders who have the resources to explore different value options.</p><h4>The Value Pricing Approach</h4><p>Value pricing is a natural extension of segmentation, targeting and positioning, the process by which we identified a group of consumers most likely to be interested in our product. This process involves identifying key segmentation benefits that are likely to be appealing to our target. By selecting and emphasizing the appropriate benefits for our target audience, we can increase perceived value.</p><p>Consider the following example: our R&amp;D department has developed a computer keyboard that allows people to type 10 percent faster. Current keyboards that are comparable on all other features besides speed are priced at $100. How should we price this product? A common answer to this question is $110, based on the idea that a 10 percent increase in speed should somehow translate to a 10 percent increase in price. A deeper analysis, however, is necessary. Speed is a <em>feature</em> of the product; to assess value, we must consider the benefit that this feature provides. To do so we must consider how our product is used. For example, if the keyboard is used in the home, perhaps the 10 percent increase in speed will allow the user who usually works two hours a day on the computer to reduce her computer time to one hour and 40 minutes, giving her an additional 20 minute per day to spend with her family. When the benefit is expressed in this way, the incremental value she experiences from this feature improvement may be much higher than $10. This process of identifying a benefit associated with a feature of our product, and then assessing the potential value that might be derived from this benefit, is the process of value pricing. This is a natural extension of the laddering exercise described in the product chapter.</p><p>This process is quite useful in business-to-business contexts as well. Perhaps the keyboard will be used by a research associate in a consulting firm. Last year he produced research reports that generated $100,000 in income for the firm. Based on his increased productivity, we could argue that he will create $110,000 in income with his new keyboard. This $10,000 amount arguably represents the “true” value of the keyboard. Can we charge $10,000 for this item? No. By emphasizing the benefit of increased productivity, however, we can increase the perceived value of this item, thus increasing the consumer surplus. We can then elect to capture some of that increase by raising the price, or to maintain the price and leverage this surplus to achieve additional market share and/or increased customer loyalty.</p><p>When seeking to set price based on value, we must be sure that both our company and our customers know all the ways in which we are delivering value. Value pricing is thus the process of identifying the “true” benefit of a particular product, ensuring that this benefit is communicated effectively to consumers, then pricing strategically either to capture additional consumer surplus or additional market share. Because value pricing is based on assessment of benefits, it is integrally related to other steps in the framework, particularly strategic focus, STP, and product steps. By approaching pricing from this perspective, we are thus able to ensure that the price-making process is driven by sound strategy, as opposed to opportunistic tactics.</p><p>As discussed above, value pricing strategy is generally pursued by the category leader. In an efficiently functioning category, the category leader sets price for the category. Other competitors will execute a competitive pricing strategy. For a competitive pricing strategy, we will note the price set by the category leader and then benchmark our price against that. We may choose to set our price higher or lower, depending on our positioning. For example, in the discount retail category Walmart is the category leader. Target, who offers the benefit of design at low prices, will be priced slightly higher than Walmart, but will track Walmart prices and move their own pricing up or down based on Walmart’s moves. In contrast, Taco Bell will watch McDonald’s pricing and ensure that they are consistently a bit lower than McDonalds for a comparable meal. The key her is to consistently monitor competitive pricing, react consistently, and react publicly. By publicizing our prices, we are signaling to all competitors what our reaction will be. Price signaling can help keep us from getting into a price war.</p><h4>Promotional Pricing: Strategic Tactics</h4><p>In addition to the pricing tactics discussed above, there are two basic classes of promotional pricing that can be implemented in a more strategic fashion: trial and continuity pricing. Trial pricing is targeted toward potential new users of a product, whereas continuity pricing is designed to encourage existing customers to purchase more of our product.</p><p>Trial Pricing involves offering a deep discount, usually on a single unit purchase of the product, with the expectation that after trying the product the consumer will buy additional units at the regular price. One of the key challenges associated with this tactic is the question of exactly <em>how</em> we deliver the discount. Because we wish to offer the reduced price only to first-time buyers, we must somehow distinguish them from our current customers. If we cannot, and simply offer a lower price to all consumers, we run the risk of giving a substantial amount of surplus away. If our product is new to the world, this is clearly less of a concern, but as soon as the first group of buyers accepts the discount and experiences the benefits, the concern will arise.</p><p>In implementing a trial pricing strategy, it is important to understand the behavior that we are seeking to engender among our customers. Of course, we assume that a substantial price reduction will provide a sufficient incentive for potential customers to purchase a product that they likely would not have purchased at the regular price. The real test of a successful trial pricing strategy, however, comes with the consumers’ experience of the product. Based on this experience, their perceived value of (and, therefore, willingness to pay for) the product should increase. Thus, for trial pricing to be a good investment (and we should consider ourselves to be “investing” in customers by offering a trial price) we must ensure that the experience our customers have is positive enough that they will be willing to spend more on subsequent purchases. Therefore, when implementing a trial pricing strategy, we must emphasize an experience attribute of the product. Our ability to retain trial users and convert them into long-term customers is crucially dependent on this fact.</p><p>Continuity Pricing involves offering a lower price to our existing customers, generally across multiple purchases, to keep them in the franchise. If a customer buys eight rolls of toilet paper at a discount instead of four at the regular price, we have essentially “locked down” that customer, at least for the near term. Continuity pricing strategies tend to be most effective for products that are perishable, used on a regular basis, or that are difficult to store. For these types of products, a lower price will lead to increased purchase and consumption. If, on the other hand, a consumer “loads up” on our product due to a price promotion, but does not increase her overall consumption, our promotion has failed. A common way that marketers try to elicit consistent buying while avoiding “loading” is with in-box (or in-package) coupons. Only after the customer has bought the product, taken it home and opened it, is she able to access the coupon that lowers the price on the subsequent purchase.</p><p>In essence this practice is a form of price discrimination where we reward our loyal customers with a discount.</p><p>Another danger of continuity pricing stems from the fact that this tactic naturally results in an increase in the length of time between purchases. If, for example, our customer has developed a habit of purchasing our product every two weeks, then a continuity promotion that breaks this habit may lead to unforeseen consequences. When the consumer finally runs out of our product and returns to the store to replenish, she may take more time to evaluate the competitive offerings than she might have otherwise. Finally, if our continuity pricing strategy results in regular discounts of the product, our customer will likely come to expect this price on an ongoing basis. Therefore, when implementing a continuity pricing strategy, the firm should seek to emphasize <em>non-price rewards</em>, ideally proffered in a random, as opposed to regular fashion.</p><p>Both continuity and trial tactics can be effective under the appropriate circumstances. It is important, however, to be realistic in considering the potential costs and benefits of the tactics, and to apply them appropriately as necessitated by the specific situation.</p><h4>Systems Thinking and Pricing</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/646/1*ILeRJWyS4WQoKyUpBGxCKg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Figure 4: Systems Impact of Price Change</figcaption></figure><p>There are myriad examples of systems effects of pricing activities. We covered several simple models in chapter 2. In Figure 3 we consider the impact of a price cut on consumer perceptions and, ultimately, revenues. The relationship between price and unit sales is presumed to be negative; that is, when price goes down, unit sales will go up. There is also an impact of unit sales on price: if sales go down, we may elect to cut price further to increase sales. Such a cut has an uncertain impact on revenues, as we do not know whether the increase in unit sales will be enough to offset the lost revenues from the lowered price. What we can be surer of, however, is the impact of a price cut on perceived value. Price and perceived value will generally move in the same direction; if price goes down, perceived value goes down; as perceived value goes down, price will likely be lowered further. In addition, as perceived value goes down, unit sales will likely go down. Even without the impact of competitive response and potential price wars, a price cut can get us into a negative feedback loop that can be extremely damaging.</p><h4>Pricing and the Framework</h4><p>The specific relationship between strategic focus and pricing is outlined in Figure 5. In general, value pricing strategies are applied more commonly when seeking to stimulate demand, whereas when we are seeking to earn share, we will likely benchmark our pricing against our key competitor. If either our main or dynamic benefits are price-related, we must first ensure that we have a core competence that gives us the ability to consistently deliver at the price we are setting. In all other cases we simply will seek to keep the price differential between ourselves and our competition constant while emphasizing whatever dynamic variable we have chosen.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/894/1*HdAKk_TQ2as0yHG47a0_cA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Figure 5: Strategic Focus and Price</figcaption></figure><p>For obvious reasons, trial pricing tactics are recommended when we are attempting to acquire new customers, but <em>only</em> if we will be able to leverage an experience attribute of the product to convert these trial-users into loyal customers. Continuity tactics generally will be considered for the retention of existing customers but should not be implemented without considering the potential pitfalls mentioned above.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*P9hmjbZ_a0nQQIHo1ZCQfg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Figure 6: Pricing and the Framework</figcaption></figure><p>While pricing is often considered a tactical tool, from the point of view of the framework it is integral to the success of our overall strategy and is significantly influenced by each of the other steps. Key aspects of these relationships are illustrated in Figure 5. This figure serves as an important reminder of the pervasive nature of this tool. No pricing decision should be implemented without considering the impact of this decision throughout the framework.</p><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/marketing-management-a-systems-framework/marketing-management-9dcd7af7af82">Chapter 1</a>: Introduction and Ethics</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/marketing-management-a-systems-framework/chapter-2-fb1b1c97ed2">Chapter 2:</a> Systems Thinking</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-46ee0f9e8fed">Chapter 3:</a> Business Objective</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-acca9198d5c4">Chapter 4</a>: Customer Focus</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-5606fe5549cd">Chapter 5</a>: Competitive Focus</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-caef5a55ce5">Chapter 6</a>: Estimating Market Potential/The 4 B’s</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-7-6d70d7d82fe">Chapter 7</a>: Segmentation</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-8-cd67a3a30366">Chapter 8</a>: Targeting</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-9-dda03c5b30b">Chapter 9</a>: Positioning</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-10-6ed681a90fc3">Chapter 10</a>: Product</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-11-2b15ae515308">Chapter 11:</a> Service as Product</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-12-226d545c4557">Chapter 12:</a> Communications</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-13-7deb8a757a1a">Chapter 13</a>: Channels</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-14-75ec5ec787c1">Chapter 14:</a> Pricing</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-15-e660600b8dd1">Chapter 15:</a> Metrics</blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=75ec5ec787c1" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/marketing-management-a-systems-framework/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-14-75ec5ec787c1">Marketing Management: A Systems Framework (14)</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/marketing-management-a-systems-framework">Marketing Management: A Systems Framework</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Marketing Management: A Systems Framework (13)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/marketing-management-a-systems-framework/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-13-7deb8a757a1a?source=rss-ba31e9c694d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7deb8a757a1a</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Christie Nordhielm PhD]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 18 Jan 2022 18:01:28 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-02-23T00:51:03.896Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Chapter 13: Channels</h4><p>Christie L. Nordhielm</p><p>Georgetown University</p><p>© 2021 Christie L. Nordhielm all rights reserved</p><p><em>This is part 13 in a 15-chapter collection that makes up this book. Enjoy!</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5AiVW771r1YrIHyyHW6lEw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Channel strategy and execution concerns the flows of product, money, services, information, and risk up and down the supply chain. In the past two decades much of the value created in the marketplace has come from channel innovations; changes in how these flows transpire. Amazon and Vroom disrupted the flow of product, PayPal and Affirm have altered the flow of payments, firms like Uber Eats and Task Rabbit offer alternatives in the services sector, Google and Wikipedia have transformed information access and dissemination and the burgeoning DeFi (decentralized finance) industry is in the midst of overturning the traditional risk/reward relationship in financial markets. Whether we are seeking to disrupt an industry or simply get our products to our consumers, no coherent marketing plan is complete without a robust channel strategy.</p><p>Because this area is so dynamic, it is crucial to return to first principles as we think about how to build this strategy. As has been eloquently articulated by Louis Stern, the goal of any channel is <em>to deliver a benefit to the end consumer.</em> We must always bear this goal in mind, regardless of our position in the supply chain or how distant this consumer may appear. If all channel members clearly understand this fact, they have a far better prospect of achieving profitability.</p><p>Of all the executional modules in the Framework, channel strategy presents the greatest number of challenges. First and foremost, channels can be exceptionally <em>difficult to change</em>; hence, channel strategy development requires both advanced planning and skill at forecasting future market conditions. Unfortunately, as markets have become increasingly dynamic and volatile, our ability to forecast future conditions has become more limited. This limitation means that often we must rely on our executional abilities — our ability to change our channel strategy and implementation as conditions change. But channels are not prices, and changing a channel is not simply a matter of leveraging a pricing algorithm and then pushing a price revision out to our web page.</p><p>In contrast to other executional elements in the framework, a channel is a <em>system</em>. Instead of one organization, a channel is often made up of many interrelated organizations, some which we may control directly, others which we may not control at all; some which share our goals, and some which have goals of their own. <em>Channel control</em> is thus another key challenge that we address in this chapter. The systemic character of channels also means that it is often difficult to observe and measure the impact of our actions on the end consumer. As a manufacturer we may elect to launch a new product with a benefit that we hope will increase consumer interest and demand. If we are marketing and delivering our product directly to the end consumer, we will be in a good position to observe and interpret the results of our actions. In many cases, however, there will be other members in the supply chain between us and the end user, perhaps a distributor and a retailer, for example. These members often have a significant ability: 1) to influence customer behavior, potentially in ways that conflict with our marketing strategy; and 2) to restrict or distort customer feedback, reducing our ability to clearly gauge the impact of our strategy.</p><p>Finally, we must consider the human element of channel execution. A price is a price; an ad is an ad; a package is a package. These elements of the marketing mix are observable, stable, and for the most part within our control. In contrast, a channel inevitably relies on the actions of humans, and as we all know humans don’t always do exactly what we want them to do. For example, a retailer may be most interested in attracting customers to the store and may use our product as a loss leader, pricing it near or below cost even though we may be seeking to implement a premium pricing and positioning strategy. Further, even if we manage to fully align the objectives of all channel partners, humans differ in their emotional, physical, social, and intellectual capacity to execute these objectives. Humans make mistakes, they get tired, they get confused, they get frustrated, they get angry. Of course, they also can adapt, navigate complex and dynamic situations, recognize emotional cues, and customize their responses on an individual basis. Humans play an important part in even the most technological or standardized supply chain, so to manage a channel effectively is to manage humans effectively.</p><p>Thus, in our study of channels we face several substantial challenges, both strategic and executional. It is hence crucial for us to leverage the framework to develop and apply a disciplined strategy that will increase the efficiency of our decision making and our chances for success.</p><h4>Channel Purpose and Definition</h4><p>A channel is defined as a set of interdependent organizations involved in the process of making a product or service available for consumption or use to the final consumer. There are several important aspects of this definition. First and foremost, it is crucial to remember that the ultimate purpose of a channel is to deliver a benefit to the end consumer. No matter how far away in space and time a particular channel member is from this end consumer, their long-term survival depends not on how well they satisfy their customers, but how well the channel satisfies the end consumer. Of course, the farther away a channel member is from this end consumer, the less tenable this position may seem. The immediate pressures and demands of our nearest neighbors in the supply chain often loom larger than the remote needs of the end consumers. However, if channel members lose sight of their primary objective of delivering value to the end consumer, the consumer will inevitably abandon that channel in favor of another more responsive one. Without end customers, there is no channel. Thus, regardless of how distant the end consumer may seem, the first purpose of all channel members is clear: maximize profits for the channel as a whole by profitably meeting the needs of this end consumer. After profit maximization has been achieved, the channel members can allocate profits among the members. Again, this may seem like an onerous task as most channel members will inevitably consider themselves deserving of the lion’s share of profits. If, however, a channel leader can emerge and rise to the challenge of supply chain profit maximization and equitable profit allocation, this firm will ensure the long-term survival of the channel and all its members.</p><p>With the primary objective of the channel understood, the task becomes to conceive and implement a channel strategy where each channel member <em>adds value</em> within the supply chain. In general, channels can be thought of as providing three basic utilities, or benefits:</p><blockquote>Product Utility: <em>All channels are concerned with delivering products or services of some kind. It is important to understand the specific benefit each channel member provides vis-à-vis this product. Some members may add value by providing assortment, depth of inventory, or selection. For example, most distributors provide a wide assortment of products, enabling retailers to select those products most suitable for their customers. In contrast, some retailers may focus on a much more limited inventory, selected according to some clear criteria, that allows the customer to make purchase decisions more efficiently and effectively. Crate &amp; Barrel, for example, provides only a limited number of products in each product category, and core customers rely on the belief that all these products will be of a particular quality and reflect a particular style.</em></blockquote><blockquote>Time Utility: <em>Many channel members add value by providing time utility. Any activities that reduce search time, increase speed of delivery, or assure sufficient inventory at times of peak demand are essentially time-utility activities. It is important to recognize that different types of time utility are quite distinct and of varying importance to different consumer groups. For example, a consumer shopping at Amazon.com may value the time utility that the website offers in terms of instant search capability and ease of payment. However, the online customer does not enjoy instantaneous delivery as they would in a brick-and-mortar bookstore. Hence both Amazon and Powell’s books in downtown Portland deliver a measure of time utility.</em></blockquote><blockquote>Place Utility: <em>The final value added by channel members is that of place utility. The shorter the distance the consumer must travel to inspect/pay for/receive their product, the greater the place utility. Perhaps the most famous example of place utility is Starbucks; in many cities in the world, it is possible to stand in one place and see two different Starbucks coffee outlets within a short walking distance. Starbucks ubiquity makes it that much easier for a consumer to decide to stop in for a cup of coffee. It is doubtful that the chain would have experienced the tremendous growth observed throughout the 90s had they not pursued an aggressive store expansion strategy to deliver this utility.</em></blockquote><p>It should be noted that these three utilities represent broad categories of possible benefits that a channel can provide. To understand clearly the potential value added by a channel member, we must dig deeper and characterize the specific nature of the benefit being provided. Even a seemingly simple concept like “assortment,” a further specification of product utility, can mean very different things to different people. For example, a retailer can offer brand assortment — a broad selection of different brands, or product assortment — a broad choice of products from a narrower set of brands. It is thus vital to develop a clear and specific understanding of the various utilities provided by channel members. This understanding will help up link our channel strategy to the other strategic decisions in the Framework, most notably segmentation, targeting and positioning.</p><h4>Channel Flows and Functions</h4><p>One of the most notable characteristics of channels vs. other executional elements of marketing is the fact that they involve <em>flows</em>. The most obvious flow is that of product and ownership. In many cases the actual physical possession of the product and the legal ownership of the product are held by different channel members; an agent may purchase inventory and resell it without ever holding the inventory (e.g., a stockbroker) or may alternatively hold the inventory and offer it for sale without ever taking title (e.g., real estate brokers). The competencies associated with holding and transferring physical product are quite distinct from those associated with holding and transferring ownership; it is thus quite sensible to break up these two channel functions when it appears more appropriate.</p><p>While we tend to think of channels as dedicated to moving product, they enable flows of many other assets as well. One key commodity that flows backward and forward through a channel is information. Information, primarily regarding the product or service, flows forward through the channel to the end consumer. The various channel members may add value to this information by amassing and presenting (e.g., a technical salesperson), transforming (e.g., unit price information in the grocery store), or interpreting/reinforcing (e.g., an art dealer, an ad agency) the information. Perhaps more importantly, information flows from the customer back up the supply chain as well. Ideally, value also is added to information as it flows in this direction; for example, our in-house sales force returns from the field with crucial information about customer preferences. In some cases, however, consumer information that would prove quite valuable to upstream or downstream channel members does not reach them or is distorted on the way. In some cases, this issue is addressed by setting up a distinct information channel whereby consumer data is sold to third party research firms who then collate and sell the information to other channel members. Direct or digital marketers or those using fewer intermediaries generally have an advantage regarding the flow of information, and many can capitalize on this situation. Dell’s decision to sell personal computers direct not only enabled them to cut costs, but more importantly gave them access to specific consumer preferences. Netflix and Spotify have established strong customer and brand value by making use of the voluminous behavioral data available to them.</p><p>Product and information are arguably the two most important assets that flow through channels, but channels also enable several other key flows, such as flows associated with money. Once again, those channel members dedicated to this function must add value in a specific fashion. The most obvious task in this area is that of providing financing or handling payments for/between other channel members and/or the end customer. A specific channel member also may assume the task of negotiation, as is the case with car dealers or real estate agents since they are presumably most cognizant of the needs and interests of each customer and are best able to execute this task. Finally, channel members may assume all or part of the risk associated with a particular channel such as a franchise system whereby many people each invest in one franchise, thus assuming some of the risk for the overall venture.</p><p>As we assess or design a channel it is crucial to recognize the various functions in which channel members may engage and the associated value to the end customer of each of these functions. In doing so we can identify the optimal means of efficient delivery value to our end customer.</p><h4>Channel Design/Management and the Framework</h4><p>Because of the challenges involved in channel design and management, it is important to establish a strategic link between our overall marketing strategy and channel decisions. As with most executional elements of the Framework, our channel decisions should tie directly back to our business and strategic focus, and most importantly to the core benefit. We structure our channel with these in mind. In aligning our channel structure with our marketing strategy, we will consider three key executional channel decisions we must make: channel length, channel breadth, and channel depth.</p><p><em>Channel length</em> refers to the number of channel members involved in delivering the product to the end customer. At one end of the spectrum is direct distribution, where few or no intermediaries are involved. Examples of direct channels include Dell and Amazon.com, two firms that sell directly to the consumer without using a brick-and-mortar retail store. There are several benefits to direct distribution, most notably the increase in control over product, money, and information flows. At the other end of the spectrum is indirect distribution. The computer chip manufacturer Intel faces an indirect distribution model; the chip must go through a variety of intermediaries, including wholesalers, distributors, OEMs (Original Equipment Manufacturers) such as Dell and Apple, and finally retailers before reaching the end consumer. Firms that are referred to as B2B (business to business) generally participate in a more indirect distribution channel. There are many good reasons to add intermediaries and structure a more indirect channel. Intermediaries add value to the channel by performing the various functions mentioned above. In addition, the use of intermediaries improves exchange effectiveness and efficiency by reducing the number of transactions. Consider an extreme case where each manufacturer of packaged goods might elect to sell directly to the end consumer through company-owned stores, bypassing the grocer. By removing the grocer, the manufacturer can save money and enhance control while lowering costs. However, the consumer would have to visit multiple stores to do their grocery shopping, something they would likely be unwilling to do. Hence, the presence of a brick-and-mortar retail store in the grocery channel makes good sense.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*FOfQ_jbnFIO9r9rQUJsgKw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Figure 1: Channel Length — direct vs. indirect</figcaption></figure><p>The decision as to whether to add or remove channel members is a cost benefit analysis. Costs are easy to assess, but quantifying benefits, which is equally important, can be far more difficult. For example, the benefit of “going direct” and thereby removing costly intermediaries is strong, but this step should not be taken until the added value of each channel member is realistically assessed. For example, a dedicated customer service center to handle repair may seem expensive until it is eliminated, service levels decline, and long-term customers are lost. It is thus crucial to understand in detail the specific functions provided by each channel member and the benefits associated with these functions. The channel should be long enough to ensure that key benefits and functions are performed, and short enough to ensure sufficient control of product, money, and information in the channel.</p><p><em>Channel breadth</em> refers to the number of different types of outlets involved in distributing the product to the consumer at each stage in the value chain. Most often channel breadth is considered at the end consumer level. Here the two ends of the spectrum are described as exclusive distribution where the number of outlets is limited and carefully controlled, to mass or intensive distribution where the number of outlets is very high, thus minimizing the travel and search costs for the end consumer. Very often the breadth of a channel is determined based on which type of product attribute the firm is seeking to leverage and promote. Consider a case of exclusive distribution: Cartier watches, distributed only in limited, upscale locations by authorized retailers. These high-end watches are awash in credence attributes, and the channel itself helps establish these attributes for consumers. The Cartier retailer is an important part of the packaging and promotion for the product.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YBexUlMxR4CkqvBArk8Sxg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Figure 2: Channel Breadth — selective or exclusive distribution vs. intensive or mass distribution</figcaption></figure><p>When the firm seeks to emphasize search attributes, particularly for a more complex product such as an automobile, the number of outlets may increase somewhat, creating a selective distribution strategy. For this type of strategy, the number of outlets higher than it might be for an exclusive strategy, but is still limited to control brand image, and to enhance the firm’s ability to properly educate the sales force as they market the product. The added value of the Volvo dealer is the knowledgeable salesperson who can identify the needs of the customer and meet those needs by pointing out certain search attributes of the product. Finally, a product may be distributed on a mass or intensive scale. Most items of lower cost and complexity and high in experience attributes (such as packaged goods) tend to fall into this category: HUGGIES® Diapers are available in grocery stores, drug stores, Wal-Mart, Target, etc. The key benefit added by the channel for mass distribution is that of time utility — ease of access. This ease of access encourages consumers to try and experience these low-involvement products without expending substantial effort.</p><p><em>Channel depth</em> refers to the extent to which the channel is controlled, via forward and/or backward integration, by one or a few key channel members. Integration can be accomplished through simple ownership of the channel member, or in the absence of outright ownership, substantial legal control. In a deep, highly integrated channel the same company may own the raw materials providers, manufacturing facilities, transportation companies, distributors, and/or retail outlets. In a shallow, less integrated channel each of these functions will be performed by distinct and separately controlled companies. Of course, the key advantage to integration is the increase in power and control that it confers on the firm. Gallo Winery owns vineyards, cork and bottle manufacturers, trucks, and distributors, enabling them to control virtually all aspects of the wine production and distribution process. However, to the extent that performing each of these functions effectively requires different competencies, a single company might find it quite difficult to administer a substantial portion of the channel. Ideally, a company will outsource any functions for which they do not possess a core competence, thus enabling them to focus on areas where they can establish a competitive advantage.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*IYkv_xBZjLXRaimCS4HyHA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Figure 3: No integration, forward integration from manufacturer, backward integration from wholesaler</figcaption></figure><p>Channel integration decisions are commonly known as “make-buy” decisions. The firm must decide whether to outsource or purchase a particular function, or to in-source and perform the function themselves. Amazon, for example, has chosen to outsource package delivery to firms such as FedEx and UPS. More recently, however, they have begun integrating forward, taking more control of the delivery function. This integration make sense given Amazon’s core benefit of convenience. Delivery is a key component of this benefit, and as such Amazon would ideally like to develop a competence tied to this benefit. Hence when we make the decision whether to integrate or not, we should consider both the insource/outsource decision, and whether we would like to develop a competence tied to that function. This decision matrix is presented in Figure 4. In a situation where the degree of value-added by the function is high, and our core competence is high, then competence and value add are aligned. An example of this would be Amazon’s core competence at logistics tied to the benefit of convenience. In the lower right-hand corner, we see the opposite situation: the function is low value add and the firm does not have a core competence. Presumably this was the situation for Amazon through the early 2000’s, where they believed that delivery was not a crucial component of the convenience benefit, and they therefore outsourced this function. The two areas of danger for the firm are if the degree of value-add of the function is high but the firm does not have a competence tied to this function. This describes a situation where the firm benefit is not tied to their core competence. In this case it the firm will need to develop a competence in this function. In the upper right quadrant, we have a situation where the firm has a core competence at performing a function that does not add value. In this case the firm needs to leverage communications to change the importance of this benefit, or else outsource the function.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/818/1*28qECMZuyI32VSNInwjHKQ.png" /><figcaption>Figure 4: The “make/buy” decision should consider both competence and value add</figcaption></figure><h4>Systems Thinking and Channels</h4><p>Since channels are systems, systems thinking is an effective tool for considering channel decisions. In Figure 5 we look at the tradeoff between investment in core competence vs. outsourcing and the subsequent impact on differentiation and firm revenue. If the firm increases investment in core competence, the amount of outsourcing should go down and vice-versa. As the firm increases outsourcing there is a direct negative impact on firm competence, and on differentiation. These investments can disrupt the positive feedback loop that firms can develop between core competence and differentiation.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/938/1*Eu_UbLnImfUDrgS8A4IYOQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Figure 5: Systems model of core competence vs. outsourcing investment</figcaption></figure><h4>Channels and the Framework</h4><p>As discussed above, it is important to consider the relationship of our core competencies to our distribution strategy. Our choice of goal and time frame will strongly influence our channel strategy. A short-term time frame may dictate the use of pre-existing indirect channels to quickly build distribution. On the other hand, a profit goal suggests that we might want to remove channel members to lower our cost basis While channel strategy decisions tend to vary widely from industry to industry, our choice of customer focus and competitive focus can still help to direct channel strategy with respect to what channel value we seek to emphasize and leverage. In Figure 6 below present these relationships.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/902/1*fnylEVCXOxPjd7GIVSkqlQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Figure 6: Strategic Focus and Channels</figcaption></figure><p>If our primary strategic focus is acquisition/stimulate demand, we are inviting consumers to try our category and brand. In this case we need to leverage the channel to provide product expertise. In the case of acquisition/earn share product expertise will also be important, particularly the ability to help consumers compare our product to the competitor. In addition, the added value of place (location utility) such that our product is available to consumers, particularly when they are considering purchasing the competitor. As we move to retention/stimulate demand, we may still need to provide product expertise, particularly in the case of complex products where this expertise might be leveraged to enhance brand loyalty. In addition, time utility is important: we need to support our customers with parts and consumables quickly and easily to keep them in the franchise. This is important if we are trying to encourage hand loyalty. Finally, for retention/earn share place and time utility are most important. Recall that in this quadrant we are targeting multi-brand users. Our products and services need to be accessible in space and time to maximize the chance that consumers will select our product instead of the competition. Because we wish to encourage comparisons between our brand and our competitor we will likely leverage an indirect and more intensive distribution strategy to ensure we are where our competitor is. At this stage we may also consider integrating forward or backward in to enhance our control of more possible benefits in the value chain.</p><p>Proper channel strategy and implementation are crucial for the success of our marketing efforts. Because channels are pervasive and difficult to change, we must leverage the framework in a disciplined fashion to ensure that our channel strategy is fully integrated with our overall marketing strategy.</p><p><strong>Thanks for reading!</strong></p><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/marketing-management-a-systems-framework/marketing-management-9dcd7af7af82">Chapter 1</a>: Introduction and Ethics</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/marketing-management-a-systems-framework/chapter-2-fb1b1c97ed2">Chapter 2:</a> Systems Thinking</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-46ee0f9e8fed">Chapter 3:</a> Business Objective</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-acca9198d5c4">Chapter 4</a>: Customer Focus</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-5606fe5549cd">Chapter 5</a>: Competitive Focus</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-caef5a55ce5">Chapter 6</a>: Estimating Market Potential/The 4 B’s</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-7-6d70d7d82fe">Chapter 7</a>: Segmentation</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-8-cd67a3a30366">Chapter 8</a>: Targeting</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-9-dda03c5b30b">Chapter 9</a>: Positioning</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-10-6ed681a90fc3">Chapter 10</a>: Product</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-11-2b15ae515308">Chapter 11:</a> Service as Product</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-12-226d545c4557">Chapter 12:</a> Communications</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-13-7deb8a757a1a">Chapter 13</a>: Channels</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-14-75ec5ec787c1">Chapter 14:</a> Pricing</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-15-e660600b8dd1">Chapter 15:</a> Metrics</blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7deb8a757a1a" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/marketing-management-a-systems-framework/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-13-7deb8a757a1a">Marketing Management: A Systems Framework (13)</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/marketing-management-a-systems-framework">Marketing Management: A Systems Framework</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Marketing Management: A Systems Framework (12)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/marketing-management-a-systems-framework/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-12-226d545c4557?source=rss-ba31e9c694d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/226d545c4557</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Christie Nordhielm PhD]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 12 Jan 2022 19:12:05 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-02-23T00:51:37.795Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Chapter 12: Communications</h3><p>Christie L. Nordhielm</p><p>Georgetown University</p><p>© 2021 Christie L. Nordhielm all rights reserved</p><p><em>This is part 12 in a 15-chapter collection that makes up this book. Enjoy!</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hUZku4la7M3wFaKM4FQsNg.jpeg" /></figure><p>In 2017 Andrew Essex, journalist, and founder of the advertising agency Droga5 published a book entitled “The End of Advertising.” Other commentators, including Phillip Kotler, piled on, echoing some form that sentiment. By July 2021 Facebook and Alphabet Inc. (Google), two companies who primary source of revenue is advertising, had a combined market capitalization of $2.23 trillion,[1] Digital advertising spend in 2021 is projected to by $455.3 billion,[2] and the average cost of a “traditional” 30-second spot of Super Bowl LV was $5.6 million.[3] “Advertising,” in all its forms, is alive and well.</p><p>In this chapter we address the topic of marketing communications. The scope of marketing communications extends beyond advertising to include all brand contacts. Any time the consumer or any member of the value chain encounters the brand we are engaging in marketing communications. These activities include corporate/public relations communications, customer service, packaging elements, pricing communications, event promotions, sponsorships, trade promotions, sales materials, sales presentations, consumer promotions, communications and, of course, advertising. The pervasiveness of marketing communications throughout most executional elements of our marketing plan highlights the importance of developing a systematic approach to communications planning to: 1) ensure a consistent message across all marketing elements, and 2) enhance the efficiency of these communications by leveraging potential synergies across all activities.</p><p>The purpose of marketing communications is attitude change; we are working the “beliefs” portion of the 4’s Bs. We accomplish this change with some combination of rational argument, emotional appeal, and dramatic presentation. Our decisions in this area can start to feel more uncertain and subjective as we move more into the creative execution of our strategy. A common response to this uncertainty is to do more research; however, research on creative work is notoriously difficult and dangerous. A better way to reduce uncertainty is to take a systematic approach, by 1) setting communications objectives that align with our strategic decisions so far, 2) executing against those objectives in a disciplined and single-minded way, and 3) setting constantly monitoring and assessing the impact of our actions with respect to these objectives.</p><p>Marketing is decision-making under uncertainty in a complex and dynamic environment. This is particularly true as we start working with creatives. It is a mistake to become rigidly committed to quantitative analysis, and it is equally misguided to blindly place our trust in people who we believe are more creative than we are. Instead, we need to understand that our executional decisions will not always be correct. Therefore monitoring, assessment, and adjustment are key to effective communications execution.</p><p>One final note of caution: marketing communications are among easier elements of the marketing mix to change; a new brochure, digital ad or outdoor campaign can be developed in a matter of weeks or even days. This fact, coupled with the fact that judging marketing communications materials is an inherently subjective process, means that decisions in this area are likely to be subject to emotional, as opposed to logical analysis. In general, firms change marketing campaigns (and the agencies who create them) much more often than they probably should. But just because we can change the advertising doesn’t mean we should change the advertising. In fact, just the opposite is true: virtually all the most successful marketing communications campaigns are also the ones that have remained the most consistent, leveraging brand equity to efficiently build or maintain awareness and attitudes, and vice-versa. Therefore, the fact that we <em>can</em> change executions so easily means we need to be extremely cautious when considering whether we <em>should</em>.</p><h4>Communications Objective</h4><p>With the above in mind, the first step in the communication process is to clearly identify our communications objective. The communications objective helps us to distinguish the goals of communications from the goals of marketing in general. One of the common mistakes made in marketing is to presume that the objective of every marketing communications campaign is to <em>sell something</em>. This is as misguided as saying that the objective of pricing is to sell something. Our overall business objective is, of course, to achieve some level of sales and we accomplish this objective by setting and meeting sub-objectives for each of the four P’s. Hence, while the overall objective of marketing is usually to change behaviors, the objective of marketing <em>communications</em> is generally to accomplish an intermediate step in that process such as an increase in awareness or a change in attitude. These changes, coupled with our effective work in product, place, and price, will result in a change in behavior.</p><p>In developing a communications plan, we will choose between five different types of objectives. While a particular communication may appear to serve more than one objective, as in other areas of the framework we will seek to identify a <em>primary</em> objective — the most important goal for our marketing communications to accomplish. Our communications objective will direct our creative development, media, and promotion planning. It also should be noted that while these objectives are sometimes referred to as advertising objectives, they should be more properly considered marketing communications objectives. While traditional advertising is one channel to accomplish our marketing communications objectives; in executing a campaign, we will leverage a variety of alternative channels including public relations, sales support materials, point of purchase materials, word-of-mouth, product placement, etc. The specific objectives are as follows:</p><blockquote>Basic Awareness.<em> A brand that is new to the market and is seeking to acquire new customers may elect to pursue a basic awareness objective. The objective of a basic awareness campaign is simply to increase brand recognition. A marketing communications campaign with basic awareness as its primary objective will emphasize the brand name either by featuring the brand as “hero” in a dramatic story or by simply by repeating the brand name as many times as possible. To accomplish this without irritating consumers is a creative challenge, and communications of this type typically employ humorous or dramatic appeals or multiple executions that entertain consumers and allow them to “tolerate” such repetition. The classic Aflac campaign that features a duck repeating the brand name is a terrific example of such a strategy.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>While a basic awareness objective may be an obvious first step for any new product or company, it generally represents a short-term goal. The product or brand will very quickly need to move beyond basic awareness and establish specific brand attitudes or information. We therefore need to track awareness carefully by simply measuring brand recognition and have a plan ready for the next step in our campaign.</em></blockquote><blockquote>Top-of-mind Awareness.<em> This type of awareness goal is distinct in all ways from basic awareness. Whereas basic awareness seeks to establish recognition, the goal for top-of-mind awareness is unaided recall. Many companies, notably beer and soft drink marketers, appear to be advertising nothing more than their brand name even though they have already achieved nearly 100 percent brand recognition. These firms are pursuing a top-of-mind awareness objective. Here the company does not just want to be recognized, it wants to be foremost in consumers’ minds when they are making a brand choice.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>From a creative perspective this type of awareness objective presents a challenge that is also quite different from that of basic awareness: if consumers are already aware of our brand name they might “tune out” when presented with our ads. Our communications, therefore, need to be highly engaging to capture and hold consumers’ attention. We do not, however, need to repeat the brand name in this case. Instead, we just need to tie the communication to the brand in some way. For instance, in these types of campaigns include (in)famous slogans that have little or nothing to do with the brand name or an explicit brand message: the Budweiser “Wazzup” campaign is an excellent example. This slogan worked its way into popular culture, and consumers began repeating the tagline from these humorous and captivating spots, increasing top-of-mind awareness for the brand.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>As stated above with top-of-mind we are not interested in whether consumers can recognize our brand, but rather, whether they can recall it. We capture this information by collecting first-mentions: we survey consumers and ask them to tell us, for example, the first three brands of beer that come to mind. If our campaign is successful, we will see an increase in the percentage of first mentions among our target; if our strategy is successful this increase will also result in an increase in sales.</em></blockquote><blockquote>Information.<em> For this objective we seek to disseminate specific information about the product. Southwest Airlines has the lowest prices; Kinko’s is open 24 hours; Subaru has 4-wheel drive. Ideally there is only one piece of information; this is how a single-minded campaign is developed. If we have done the difficult strategic work leading up to this module, we can presume that the information in this single thought is linked to the core benefit. The inherent appeal of this information will help to drive the effectiveness of our communications. The challenge for the creative team in this case is to tightly tie our brand to the information and to communicate it in the most compelling and engaging way possible.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Measuring an information objective simply involves gauging how well consumers associate the specific information with our brand. It is quite common in communications research to ask consumers about their evaluation of the brand on a variety of performance metrics, such as price, convenience, quality, efficiency, etc. If a brand scores reasonably well on recall for several metrics the results are referred to as “rich” brand associations. However, if we are pursuing a single-minded campaign, we should measure, and concern ourselves with two things: perception of how our brand performs on our key benefit, and the importance of this benefit. Other associations are extraneous and distracting.</em></blockquote><blockquote>Image/Attitude.<em> For many communications campaigns, the primary objective is to change an attitude toward or image of the brand. If awareness and information campaigns are seeking to capture share of mind, image campaigns seek to capture share of heart, evoking an emotional response in consumers. Most advertising for credence products has image objectives. Also, many mature brands, in attempting to solidify their position in the marketplace and protect against competitive entry, will try to move their communications from an information or awareness objective to an image/attitude objective. The focus of an image objective is the person in the target audience, as opposed to the brand. For example, Volvo initially focused on communicating information about their brand by emphasizing product features such as daytime running lights and driver’s side airbags: Volvo cars are safe cars. More recently, Volvo campaigns have emphasized the Volvo driver: Volvo drivers care about the safety of their family. These two examples both focus on a target audience with a high need for safety, and likely represent highly similar positioning strategies. However, they have distinct communications objectives, the former being information and the latter being attitude/image.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>It is most difficult to establish clear measurement criteria for an image campaign; this is because it is quite difficult to measure directly how “cool” or “smart” or “safe” a particular brand is. A common approach to gauging our success with an image campaign is using projective techniques. Instead of asking consumers for a direct response, we ask them, for example, to describe a person who might use the brand. Another tactic for measuring image changes is to use surrogates, other brands or objects that represent the same image we are trying to achieve with our brand, and then ask consumers to assess similarity between our brand and the surrogates.</em></blockquote><blockquote>Behavioral Objective.<em> The final possible communications objective is not about beliefs, but about behavior. As discussed above, most communications are concerned with changing attitudes or emotions. However, there are some instances where a communications campaign has a specific behavioral objective that can be achieved without any other marketing activities. An “infomercial,” a long-form web or tv video that presents a full sales pitch for a product, is an excellent illustration of this point. The objective of an infomercial is to get the consumer to pick up the phone and call to purchase the product. It contains a call to action specifically providing a phone number and asking the consumer to place the call. Other calls to action might be “visit the website” or “ask your doctor.”</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>It is quite straightforward to measure our success in accomplishing a behavioral objective: we simply assess the extent to which the behavior occurs because of exposure to our marketing communications. The key challenge with a behavioral objective is to ensure that it is truly appropriate; to the extent that we also rely on other marketing tools such as distribution to elicit a specific customer behavior, a more appropriate advertising objective may be information, attitude, or awareness. Once we have established our communication objective, we must develop our communications materials and determine how and how much we will spend on media. If we have clearly identified our objective, and it is linked to our overall strategy, these tasks will be significantly easier.</em></blockquote><h4>Developing Communications Materials: Copy Development</h4><p>One of the most difficult tasks a marketing manager faces in the communications arena is assessing the quality and appropriateness of copy execution. Generally, copy development is not created directly by the brand manager or account executive; the actual commercials, print ads, point-of-purchase displays, etc., are usually developed by a communications firm such as an advertising or PR agency. The people who do the work are often referred to as “creatives.” Creatives are responsible for bringing a copy strategy to life; transforming it from a simple set of words on paper to a dramatic execution which captures consumers’ attention and holds their interest. In the case of trade or consumer advertising, identity work, logos, or packaging; advertising, the first stage of this process is generally the development of a rough concept, a sketch, layout, storyboards, or some other representation of the envisioned final communication. It is the job of the marketing manager to assess creative development from this stage all the way through to the final product. This task is daunting because in most cases we as marketers have no formal training in design, copywriting, photography, screenwriting, graphics, or basically any of the skills necessary to create copy. And yet, we must pick and choose from amongst alternatives, approve the outlay of many thousands and sometimes hundreds of thousands of production dollars, make decisions regarding editing, photography, casting, fonts, headlines, basically all creative elements during the process.</p><p>While there is no magic formula for commenting on creative work there are a few basic rules that make the task easier. First, it is crucial to remember that the marketing manager is the keeper of the strategy. Her primary responsibility is determining whether the copy piece accurately communicates the agreed upon strategy as developed in the 5-box positioning statement. There are occasions when we review a piece of copy and find it to be extremely appealing, but not connected to our strategy. For example, we might have developed a convenience positioning and the copy communicates safety. We should not reject such an execution out of hand; instead, we should first evaluate the strategy that the copy appears to communicate. Is this strategy better than the one we originally developed? If so, we may want to consider backing up, codifying this strategy, and starting the copy development process again. In most cases, however, this is not the case. It is more likely in our example that another competitor owns the competence tied to a safety benefit, and we would be misadvised to pursue it ourselves. If this is the case, we need to review the agreed upon strategy with the creative team and ask them to stay on this strategy.</p><p>If the work is on strategy, we then move to the task of assessing execution. The ability to judge and comment on copy is one that depends on experience, but we can at least apply criteria in a systematic fashion. One way of evaluating execution is to do a BUMP analysis:</p><blockquote>Believable<em>: Is the execution believable? Does the dramatization sufficiently suspend the disbelief of viewers, or do we expect that the target will be watching the ad and saying, “that is silly, that would never happen.”</em></blockquote><blockquote>Unique<em>: Is the execution unique, or have we seen the same storyline in other product categories? Do we think the target audience will see it as boring or interesting?</em></blockquote><blockquote>Memorable<em>: Memorability goes hand-in-hand with uniqueness; the more unique a spot is, the more memorable. Creative tactics such as repetition enhance memory, but these tactics must be artfully executed to avoid irritating viewers.</em></blockquote><blockquote>Pertinent<em>: Is the execution relevant to the target audience? Is the dramatization something that will resonate with this group? Can we imagine the target identifying with the characters in the commercial, or find them entertaining in some way? Does the execution reflect the culture of the target audience It is important to note that this is an analysis of the execution, not the strategy. We already should have done a similar analysis on the copy strategy during the development of our positioning statement prior to moving to the copy development stage.</em></blockquote><p>Because copy development is inherently subjective, we often fall back on using copy research to support the decision-making process. This can range from concept testing, where we simply show the concepts to consumers and collect feedback, to more sophisticated techniques such as audience testing where ads are embedded in content that “screened” by an audience. We can also engage in A/B testing, where we leverage digital or other tools to split our audience and test two or more versions of a particular ad to see which generates more interest. In all these cases we assess some form of consumer response such as awareness, recall of specific information, interest, or belief or behavior change. If we choose to copy test, it is <em>crucial</em> that we evaluate the copy vis-à-vis our stated communications objective, <em>and only that objective. </em>For example, if our objective is basic <em>awareness</em>, we are not interested in whether the communication changes consumers’ <em>image</em> of the brand.</p><p>One final note: when commenting on copy it is advisable to focus not on the execution per se, but rather the takeaway from that execution. In other words, instead of suggesting that a particular headline should be larger or smaller, we should note how quickly we see, recognize, or recall that headline. We can then leave it up to the creative team to make specific adjustments.</p><h4>Media Planning and Buying</h4><p>In traditional marketing practice, media planning and buying is carried out as a distinct task with little consideration for the specifics of the copy being developed. In the current marketing environment, however, it is unrealistic to consider creative execution and media planning/buying as separate undertakings. The choice of media drives the creative work and vice versa; therefore, a media strategy must be developed side-by-side with a creative strategy and our communications objective.</p><p>Media choices continue to proliferate. Traditional media choices such as television, radio, print and outdoor now appear next to myriad options such as web video, product placement, platform-specific advertising on social media, virtual reality integration, the use of influencers…the list goes on. As these options multiply, it is increasingly important that we maintain discipline and continue to make strategic choices instead of simply choosing media because it is the latest thing. When we are making these choices, the following characteristics should be considered:</p><blockquote>Exposure control.<em> To what extent does the consumer control the time of exposure to the communication? In the case of a 30-second TV ad, the maximum exposure, is, of course, 30 seconds. The viewer may choose to ignore the ad entirely, but if they are interested, at most they can watch for 30 seconds. In contrast, a webpage or print ad can be viewed for an unlimited amount of time, depending only on consumer interest. If we need to disseminate more or more complex information, we need to select media where consumers have more control.</em></blockquote><blockquote>Communications modality:<em> Communications take many forms. They can be pictures or words; they can be static as in a print ad or dynamic as in a web video. The use of music and other sounds is an option in some modalities. In some cases, such as in-store displays, we may be able to make use of smells. These different modalities have different effects on emotions, learning, and memory. Verbal modalities tend to be more consonant with information objectives, whereas audio and dynamic modalities are more effective for image objectives.</em></blockquote><blockquote>Intrusiveness.<em> Different media types have different levels of intrusiveness. If we can’t capture attention, we can’t deliver our message. On the other hand, more intrusive communications can irritate consumers. A commercial interruption during a crucial sports match can create negative emotions that spill over to our communications and brand. We therefore must balance our goal of attention capture with the danger of consumer annoyance.</em></blockquote><h4>Budget-Setting</h4><p>John Wanamaker, a famous merchant from the late 1800’s famously said “I know that half my advertising dollars are wasted. The trouble is, I don’t know which half.” Though digital platforms claim that all or most of the uncertainty has been removed from media decision making due to click-through or other tracking data, the reality is that this statement rings as true today as it did over a century ago. Much of the reason for this is mis-specified models of how communications work. Many firms, when setting media spending budgets still fall back on a “black box” approach that relates comms spending to overall sales in the most general terms. For example, common approaches to marketing communications budgeting include metrics such as spending as a percent of sales, relative to competition, or to simply spend in line with past spending. These approaches ignore strategy in favor of history and/or creates a reactive budget-setting strategy where competitive spending drives our spending; what we spent last year, regardless of firm and competitive context, determines what we will spend this year. An alarming number of firms use the “what’s left over” method of ad budgeting, simply allocating resources to “hard” expenses such as labor, plant, and equipment, etc. and then putting any excess funds into advertising. This is perhaps the most dangerous strategy for ad budgeting, primarily because failure to properly support our brand consistently may result in declines in demand that can quickly threaten the viability of the firm.</p><p>The appropriate way to set media spending levels is through a zero-based, objective-driven budgeting process. A simple version of such an approach is illustrated in Figure 1. Based on our strategic decision making in the framework thus far we can construct a model that will help us estimate our ad budget more realistically. The key elements in this model include our target population size and characteristics, our advertising objective, the type of creative we have developed, and our specific media chose. Based on these decisions we can make an educated guess as to how many average exposures we are seeking. With this information and cost per exposure information provided by the platforms/media we will use, we can develop a true zero-based budget. We will then continually update this budget as we monitor our progress toward our communications objective.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*pcVHepCGjUP6m2Twk56H0A.jpeg" /><figcaption>Figure 1: Zero-Based Budgeting</figcaption></figure><p>There are myriad tools available to us for measuring the cost of reaching our consumer through various media and it is wise to take advantage of these tools. However, we are better off constructing our spending plan independently from the firms who are trying to sell us media and basing this plan on our specific strategy.</p><h4>Systems Thinking and Communications</h4><p>There are many systems relationships in communications, ranging from network effects and viral marketing to the impact of demand on media pricing. Here we will look at a systems model for messaging execution. In this model we consider the challenge of creating a message that captures attention and has positive impact on attitudes as well. Attention capture is crucial for a successful communications strategy; if we do not have the attention of our target audience, we cannot hope to deliver a message. In general, more intrusive messages generate more attention. However, an intrusive message can also be an irritating message, causing the audience to tune out. In this model we add the concept of <em>message value</em>; this is essentially the utility the consumer gets from paying attention to the message. This utility generally takes two forms: entertainment value, and information value. Entertainment value is simply the general pleasure the consumer gets from watching the communication; they may enjoy it because it is funny, touching, dramatic, etc. Ideally this entertainment is somehow linked to the brand we are promoting; if it isn’t, there is a chance the consumer will remember the execution but not the brand message. Information value is the utility the consumer gets from the information conveyed in the communication. The fact that you can buy a car without leaving your home with Vroom, or that the new Google Phone has an adaptive learning chip are examples of information value in a communication.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zMh36VtZHi9h3VnbFL3jXQ.png" /><figcaption>Figure 2: Impact of Intrusiveness and Attention on Messaging</figcaption></figure><p>In the systems model presented in Figure 2, we see that intrusiveness has a positive impact on attention, and that when attention goes up, consumer expectations go up as well. These expectations may or may not be met by the value of the message they are now attending to. If the message value meets or exceeds these expectations, the impact of the message will likely be positive. If, on the other hand, we capture consumers’ attention with an intrusive ad that has little or no message value, we will see message impact decline and possibly go negative. Finally, we have included a positive feedback loop between message impact and attention. If message impact goes up, we can expect attention to go up, and increases in attention will lead to increases in message impact. The opposite will also hold true: if message impact declines, then attention will decline.</p><h4>Marketing Communications and the Framework</h4><p>As with other executional elements, our decisions regarding marketing communications can be guided by decisions made previously in the framework as described in Figure 3.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Nm74IBJqmgyN6ZSMyrOwDA.png" /><figcaption>Figure 3: Strategic Focus and Communications</figcaption></figure><p>For acquisition/stimulate demand we are seeking to bring new users to the category. In this case we generally will pursue an awareness or informational objective. For acquisition/earn share we are seeking to compare ourselves to a key competitor or segment. We will therefore tend to pursue an informational objective, seeking to communicate our benefits vs. the competition, or a behavioral objective, seeking to encourage consumers to try our product to compare it with their current brand. In the case of a retention/stimulate demand strategy, our communication objective generally will be to enhance our image, or in the case of attempting to increase volume of usage, we may pursue a behavioral objective. Finally, for a retention/earn share strategy, we will likely pursue a communication objective of top-of-mind awareness, information, or simply behavior.</p><p>The area of marketing communications is where our marketing strategy finds its expression. Whether that expression takes the form of trade brochures, podcast sponsorship, or an ad on the Super Bowl the same philosophy should apply: establish clear, focused strategic objectives and work to ensure that our executions align with those objectives. This approach will ensure that our marketing communications serve their purpose in the overall marketing plan.</p><p>[1] <a href="https://big4stats.com/biggest-companies-in-the-world-by-market-cap/">https://big4stats.com/biggest-companies-in-the-world-by-market-cap/</a></p><p>[2] <a href="https://www.statista.com/statistics/237974/online-advertising-spending-worldwide/">https://www.statista.com/statistics/237974/online-advertising-spending-worldwide/</a></p><p>[3] <a href="https://www.statista.com/statistics/217134/total-advertisement-revenue-of-super-bowls/">https://www.statista.com/statistics/217134/total-advertisement-revenue-of-super-bowls/</a></p><p><strong>Thanks for reading!</strong></p><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/marketing-management-a-systems-framework/marketing-management-9dcd7af7af82">Chapter 1</a>: Introduction and Ethics</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/marketing-management-a-systems-framework/chapter-2-fb1b1c97ed2">Chapter 2:</a> Systems Thinking</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-46ee0f9e8fed">Chapter 3:</a> Business Objective</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-acca9198d5c4">Chapter 4</a>: Customer Focus</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-5606fe5549cd">Chapter 5</a>: Competitive Focus</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-caef5a55ce5">Chapter 6</a>: Estimating Market Potential/The 4 B’s</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-7-6d70d7d82fe">Chapter 7</a>: Segmentation</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-8-cd67a3a30366">Chapter 8</a>: Targeting</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-9-dda03c5b30b">Chapter 9</a>: Positioning</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-10-6ed681a90fc3">Chapter 10</a>: Product</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-11-2b15ae515308">Chapter 11:</a> Service as Product</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-12-226d545c4557">Chapter 12:</a> Communications</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-13-7deb8a757a1a">Chapter 13</a>: Channels</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-14-75ec5ec787c1">Chapter 14:</a> Pricing</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-15-e660600b8dd1">Chapter 15:</a> Metrics</blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=226d545c4557" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/marketing-management-a-systems-framework/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-12-226d545c4557">Marketing Management: A Systems Framework (12)</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/marketing-management-a-systems-framework">Marketing Management: A Systems Framework</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Marketing Management: A Systems Framework (11)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/marketing-management-a-systems-framework/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-11-2b15ae515308?source=rss-ba31e9c694d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2b15ae515308</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Christie Nordhielm PhD]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 27 Dec 2021 23:25:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-02-23T00:53:37.911Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Chapter 11: Service as Product</h3><p>Christie L. Nordhielm</p><p>Georgetown University</p><p>© 2021 Christie L. Nordhielm all rights reserved</p><p><em>This is part 11 in a 15-chapter collection that makes up this book. Enjoy!</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*rZqOC5gtAItaAA0djYOs1A.jpeg" /></figure><p>The focus of this chapter is services — how to manage service offerings and how to augment products with services. Today, there are very few companies that only sell products; even consumer packaged goods and food giants like Procter &amp; Gamble and Kraft augment their product offerings with services like category management (offered to large retailers like Wal-Mart). A vast number of newly minted MBAs begin their careers each year in service industries. And even MBAs who chose to work in “product” industries, are likely to deal with aspects of bundled product–service offerings. Traditional hard goods manufacturers in mature markets are adding service components to sustain their competitive advantage. Furthermore, services are becoming a key component of retention activities — crucial contributors to the sustainable competitive advantage of the firm. These facts demonstrate the crucial importance of services marketing.</p><p>While the marketing of services and hard goods diverges enough to compel separate consideration, we can begin by applying the general framework, treating a service as we would any other product/ branding marketing challenge. However, there are certain differences between services and hard goods that must be considered as we engage in marketing planning and execution. The involvement/functionality paradigm presented in the previous chapter provides an excellent means for considering issues in services marketing. Many types of services are high in credence attributes; that is, they are quite difficult to evaluate even after they have been consumed. Consider a visit to the doctor for a simple check-up. While we may have been extremely careful in selecting a doctor, considering references, education, and other qualifications, it really is impossible to know whether this specific doctor will provide us better health care than another doctor down the hall. The same situation holds for a variety of other services ranging from haircuts to legal consultations. When consumers are unable to depend on objective measures of quality or performance, a multiplicity of other factors may influence their judgments, some within our control and some outside of our control. Hence, from a marketer’s perspective, it is not enough to simply attempt to control the quality of the specific service being provided. All aspects of the experience before, during, and after service delivery must be controlled as much as possible.</p><h4>Defining Characteristics of Services</h4><p>Why should we consider services distinct from hard goods? In fact, there has been an ongoing trend in marketing toward “productization” of services, particularly in the financial services and consulting industries. This move has been, for the most part, quite beneficial, as it has helped to emphasize the importance of traditional marketing principles and strategic discipline in industries where it often has been in short supply. “Productizing” services also increases the profitability of service organizations. Productization of services leads to standardization. By standardizing services, a company avoids “reinventing the wheel” every time a service is performed and reduces operating costs. The other key benefit of standardizing services into modularized “products” is that it increases the ability of the service organization to maintain consistent performance quality across customers and projects. Consistency is critical to the successful sale of services.</p><p>While productization of services is a growing and important trend, there are still several ways in which services are distinct from hard goods, and there are implications that arise from these differences. Hence, as we consider services within the Framework, we also should be cognizant of areas where the two product types diverge.</p><blockquote>First, services are <em>intangible</em>: they cannot be viewed or handled. This makes brand-building much more challenging. A consumer wearing a new pair of blue jeans not only will be able to touch them and look at them herself, she also will be able to receive comments from friends and associates about the jeans and how good she looks in them. The brand and product are physically present to capture those good feelings. In contrast, a consumer who receives excellent brokerage advice may feel quite satisfied, but those feelings may not be associated with any particular object. Furthermore, while she may share her positive feelings with others, these conversations must be initiated by her as opposed to being sparked by an object. The physical presence of hard goods is therefore an important marketing advantage that services lack.</blockquote><blockquote>Second, <em>services cannot be inventoried</em>. This has crucial implications for both quality control and operations. A product that cannot be inventoried cannot be inspected prior to use; if a service fails, it fails in the field. This, of course, is the absolute worst place for a product to fail because it offers the least opportunity for recovery. Furthermore, if we cannot hold inventory, we cannot respond effectively to demand fluctuations. There are no warehouses filled with accountants in storage who come out at tax time, nor are there extra professor-parts sitting in the basement for quick assembly during the winter quarter.</blockquote><blockquote>Third, <em>services are generally produced and consumed at the same time</em>. This means that there is a performance element to services that is not present for hard goods. Very often services are co-produced; their quality is dependent on both the producer and the consumer. A communicative patient helps to produce a better medical examination; a well-prepared client can help a lawyer achieve a favorable decision.</blockquote><blockquote>Finally, <em>services are typically performed by humans</em>. This makes standardization, and therefore consistency, extremely difficult to achieve. As discussed above, consistency is crucial for competitive success, making this issue paramount for service marketers.</blockquote><h4>Implications for Service Marketers</h4><p>Unfortunately, all the differences listed above have the potential to reduce the effectiveness and efficiency of our marketing efforts in the service sector. It is therefore important to consider exactly how we can effectively adjust to these differences as we construct our marketing plan. For the most part, we can do this by leveraging the marketing tools at our disposal.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/308/1*MN74vGc1bpDjDwFMOt-YSw.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>Intangibility:</em> To address the intangibility issue we must develop and use marketing elements to capture brand equity. We accomplish this with the use of symbols, logos, taglines, jingles, and other memory aids. These tools are even more critical for services than for hardgoods because they help make the intangible tangible. For example, Prudential Life Insurance uses a rock as its symbol, connecting an ethereal product with no packaging or physical attributes to a dense substantial concept that communicates permanence and stability. Other examples of powerful logos in the service sector include NASA, FedEx, and UPS, to name a few. The use of consistent dress, or uniforms, is another way to capture the value of the services we deliver. Ecolab salespersons conduct on-sight client visits wearing white lab coats. The Best Buy “blue shirt” refers not just to the shirt, but also the service provider who wears this shirt both in-store and on calls. For many years companies such as McKinsey and IBM, while not requiring specific uniforms, maintained a corporate culture where employees essentially dressed the same. One result of keeping service employees in similar dress it they seem more interchangeable, and the more of value they create will be captured by the corporation, instead of to the individual. While visual logos are one way to increase the tangibility of a service, other methods are also viable. Taglines, works, and even sounds, supported with a strong communications campaign, can occupy significant real estate in consumers’ brains. Lines such as <em>You’re in good hands with Allstate</em>, <em>It’s everywhere you want to be</em> (MasterCard), <em>We Try Harder (</em>Avis) help to establish service sector brands without depending on a visual representation. Many American consumers, whether they like it or not, are able to recite the phone number for Empire Carpet; Bostonians know the jingle for Giant Glass equally well. In recent years “earcons” have become more popular. The Intel sound, and the ubiquitous Microsoft “startup sound,” (crafted in part by Brian Eno) are firmly embedded in virtually every PC user’s memory. Again, these marketing tactics are certainly important for hard goods as well, but they are crucial for service products. Other promotional tactics also serve this purpose on a smaller scale. The tiny chocolate mints left on our pillow by the turndown service at the Hyatt are an example of an effort to increase the tangibility of a service (the mint reminds us that we have been given service), as are the little plastic wings pinned on your child’s t-shirt by the United Airlines flight attendant. These seemingly minor tactical moves can significantly increase a company’s ability to capture value created by good service.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/384/1*DaQpQoNddTK-kU3chc2xBw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Another area to which marketers in the service sector must pay particular attention is word-of-mouth. In the absence of a physical product and associated cues such as packaging and logo, word-of-mouth becomes a crucially important factor. The general rule of thumb is that every customer who has an extreme service encounter, positive or negative, tells ten other people. Hence, it is crucial to ensure satisfaction on a continuous basis, and to work to leverage positive experiences.</p><p><em>Inventory issues:</em> The ability to inventory and inspect products prior to distribution is a luxury that service marketers do not enjoy. In many cases, dealing effectively with the fact that services cannot be inventoried requires organizational change and substantial resource commitment. We must engage in consistent pre-planning, to anticipate and correct possible service issues before they happen. We must also be certain that our real-time service resources are sufficient to meet peak demand. Unfortunately, our tendency toward the manufacturing-based produce-then-inspect model is strong, as is our propensity to fail to allocate sufficient resources to the pre-planning that is necessary to provide service consistency. When service failures do result from under-resourcing, a “death spiral” may occur. Failure to allocate sufficient capital to pre-production planning and service resources results in an ongoing cycle of decline of service effectiveness. Simple budget tracking, with customer service expenditures properly allocated, will help to signal to a corporation when such a situation has arisen.</p><p>Operations excellence is a necessary competence for any company wishing to create a sustainable competitive advantage on a service benefit. In the absence of operations excellence, aggressive marketing and sales teams will help to drive a service organization <em>out</em> of business more quickly. Operations excellence and pre-planning will enhance service quality, and should, to a certain degree, help us meet fluctuating demand without the benefit of inventory. Additionally, certain demand-smoothing activities can help to address this issue. Our objective should be either 1) to offload demand during peak periods, or 2) to boost low-period demand sufficiently to support the fixed and labor costs necessary to meet peak demand. A restaurant bar is a classic example of offloading: customers are more willing to wait to sit down to dinner at 9:30 p.m. instead of 8 p.m. if they are provided a comfortable bar and lounge area to socialize in while waiting. The same restaurant may also offer a 5 p.m. dinner special or happy hour to generate increased revenues during a commonly slow period. These same basic principles can be applied in virtually every service industry — smooth peak loads by creating strategies to shift demand to other periods or increase the acceptable waiting time.</p><p><em>The performance element:</em> This challenge is another must be met with the involvement of operations. The key to truly exceptional service delivery is tight integration of operations and marketing. Without this integration, marketing and sales will continue to over-promise on elements such as delivery time and product performance, and operations will continue to under-deliver. Both functions need to be in sync so that marketing will create expectations that match the company’s delivery capabilities. In this way, expectations are always appropriately set and met.</p><p><em>The human element:</em> Finally, the challenge of attempting to achieve consistent performance using humans looms large. Historically, we have attempted to answer this by take humans out of the process by leveraging technology to either mechanize or standardize aspects of service delivery. The now ubiquitous ATM is a classic example of this approach, and other examples of humans being replaced by machines abound. Initial resistance to this approach is often high; a substantial percentage of the population were initially uncomfortable using ATMs, particularly for larger deposits. Consumers are increasingly adaptive to and receptive to technology, and rapid improvement in technology has also contributed to speed of acceptance.</p><p>This trend leads us naturally to the question of whether we simply might eventually replace all the humans with technology and be finished with the problems humans present for services marketers. Given sufficient resources, it really is impossible to say where and when the trend towards replacement of humans with machines might end. Machines and technology are not just satisfying functional needs, but emotional needs as well. Voice assistants such as Alexa are increasingly personified and accepted by consumers.[1] The question of whether it is possible for a human to have a relationship with a machine has been asked and answered.</p><p>Of course, even if it were theoretically possible to meet all service requirements, including emotional requirements, with machines, it might not be financially feasible. In many cases, the return on investment to training humans is still higher than the return on investment in technology. Thus, in our effort to provide superior service, we must move beyond simply driving to replace humans with machines and instead consider the nature of the service we are providing compared with our ability to deliver it. In Figure 1 we present a framework that details this approach. In this figure we consider whether a service is performed <em>front office </em>or <em>backstage. </em>A service performed in the front office is one the consumer observes as it is performed, such as processing a credit card payment for merchandise in-store. In contrast, a backstage service is one that is not observed by the consumer, such as a doctor reading an x-ray or lab tests being analyzed. The second axis of this framework describes whether the service being performed is <em>customized</em> for each customer, such as giving a haircut, or <em>standardized</em>, such as preparing a hamburger.</p><p>The key trouble spots in this framework are in the lower left and upper right cells. When a custom service is performed backstage, the customer does not have an opportunity to observe the specialized work being performed; thus, any perceived value that might be generated by that activity is lost. To avoid this, we need to either find a way to perform this service in front of the consumer so they can experience the value being created, or, alternatively, find a way to standardize the service so we can reduce our costs. In the upper right quadrant, the opposite is happening: we are performing a low-value, undifferentiating, standard service in front of the consumer. In this situation the customer sees how little value is added and may begin to feel that they are simply a part of an assembly line. Perhaps more importantly, the people providing these repetitive services may become bored and commit more errors. These errors will occur right in front of the customer, and these failures may also be observed by other customers, increasing the negative impact of such a failure. To avoid this, we need to either mechanize or automate and move these activities backstage or find ways to customize these activities and thus add value.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*zZR92xTt3THMQARRue8Clg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Figure 1: Backstage/Front Office Matrix</figcaption></figure><p>We can use this framework to align and improve all aspects of our service delivery. We can do this as follows:</p><blockquote>1. Map the customer journey. Identify all the touchpoints where we encounter our customer. An example of a customer journey with key goals for each experience, is presented in Figure 2. It is important that we are exhaustive in this approach, starting with the first time our customer encounters our firm.</blockquote><blockquote>2. Identify all internal activities associated with delivering on these touchpoints.</blockquote><blockquote>3. Determine where these touchpoints and activities currently fall in the 2 by 2 presented in Figure 1.</blockquote><blockquote>4. Work to clear the upper right and lower left quadrants of Figure 1.</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*a4np5yVhppuXvlofXvxq_g.jpeg" /></figure><p>As we consider exactly how we clear these quadrants, we should again refer to our core competence. If our core competence is in technology, we will likely clear these boxes with technology or mechanization. If our competence is in human resource management, we will more likely dramatize or customize our service</p><h4>The Zone of Tolerance</h4><p>Controlling all aspects of service delivery may seem like a daunting task; the good news is that our consumer, within certain bounds, can be quite forgiving. This phenomenon is captured in the concept of <em>zone of tolerance</em>.[2] This concept, illustrated in Figure 3, describes consumer expectations as having a range around a certain point. The existence of this range has two primary implications: first, if product performance falls below the expectation point but within the zone of tolerance, customers are likely to adjust their memory of their experience upward toward the original expectation point. This is good because it means that consumers “give us credit” for a quality-of-service level that we did not quite achieve. The same effect occurs when expectations are exceeded but performance is still within the zone of tolerance — memories of performance tend to fall to expected levels. Hence, if service levels fall within the zone of expectations, we generally have satisfied customers that remember our performance as meeting their expectations.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*uXcfkP9gAn2ToLlxdUxwUQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Figure 3: Zone of Tolerance</figcaption></figure><p>On the other hand, a different dynamic is observed when our service delivery falls outside the zone of tolerance. If, for example, we fall below the zone (low performance), customers’ perception and level of dissatisfaction often will be much worse than their actual experience. Hence, there is not a one-to-one correspondence between actual performance and perceived performance. Within the zone of tolerance, perceptions and memories of performance tend to regress toward expectations; below the zone of tolerance, perceptions tend to fall precipitously.</p><p>What happens when we exceed expectations beyond the zone of tolerance? At first blush, the goal of radically exceeding expectations seems to be a noble one. However, there can be negative consequences associated with this outcome — this is because consumers are adaptive. When consumers have a positive service or product experience, they are certainly delighted, and may share information about their experience with others. However, they will also, almost certainly adjust their expectations for future performance upward. If the company cannot consistently (and profitably) meet these expectations, the customer will be lost in the long run.</p><p>The key point here is that <em>consistency should come before brilliance</em>. The often-heard call to “under-promise and over-deliver” is a long-term recipe for disaster. This is because each time that we over-perform, we raise the standard for our next performance. It is crucial to identify our company’s capabilities and then to seek to segment the market in such a way that we can target a group for whom we can perform consistently and profitably. These issues are particularly salient for the marketing of services, because of the significant variability that is often observed in both service performance and perception.</p><h4>Customer Satisfaction and Customer Service A Systems Model</h4><p>A basic assumption when considering investments in service is that when customer service improves, customer satisfaction also increases, thereby resulting in a competitive advantage for the firm. The relationship between service and satisfaction, however, is complex; a simple act of increasing investment in service does not in any way guarantee enhanced satisfaction. Furthermore, evidence is mixed as to whether increased satisfaction leads directly to increased loyalty. Finally, the presumption that increased satisfaction will lead to automatic increases in profitability has not always proven to be true.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ofiu27OfafSMLXuXAwWOKw.png" /><figcaption>Figure 4: Relationship of Expectations to Profitabilty</figcaption></figure><p>In fact, the strength of the links between improved service, improved satisfaction and loyalty, and improved profitability rely on more than simple investment. Furthermore, it is quite possible that blind investment in customer service (without sufficient regard as to how customers are responding to this service) can lead to a decline in satisfaction and profitability over time. This is because customers’ expectations are dynamic, changing over time in response to several factors. If we commit resources with the goal of exceeding customer expectations, we will eventually find that consumers have adapted to this new level of service, and therefore come to expect it from your organization. This dangerous cycle is presented below as a systems model in Figure 4. In this model we invest to exceed customer expectations. Our consumers then adapt, and their expectations increase. At this point we have two choices: the first is to increase our resources committed to customer service. This increases our costs and lowers our profits and available resources to devote to customer service. Sooner or later this lack of resources will lead to a failure to meet customer expectations, a subsequent loss of customers, revenues, and profits, leading to a negative feedback loop.</p><p>To avoid such an outcome, we must evaluate and execute our customer service strategy as an integral part of the Framework. First and foremost, we must link our service strategy to our core competence in determining whether and how to improve our service delivery. Southwest Airlines’ success in the 1990s can be traced to the company’s core competence in human resources, which in turned allowed it to deliver consistent, albeit basic, service at a low price. This competence was clearly understood by Southwest management and, perhaps more importantly, by Southwest employees. With this knowledge, employees were able to manage customer expectations and consistently (and profitably) deliver on these expectations. The lessons of Southwest and several other companies who have made the connection between investment in customer service and profitability may be summarized as follows:</p><blockquote><em>Manage expectations.</em> Instead of promising the world, we should ensure that our organization works hard to define and limit its expertise. The objective here should be to never make a promise that we cannot keep. A marketing department might balk at this objective because it limits its ability to compete against escalating competitive claims regarding product performance. In the long run, however, it is not the companies who make the biggest promises that succeed, but those who consistently deliver on the promises they make. It is also important to note that by realistically assessing our abilities at this stage, we will avoid near-certain failures at the next stage.</blockquote><blockquote><em>Manage production.</em> The watchword here is consistency before brilliance. While many companies reward outstanding service providers (for example, with “employee of the month” awards), these employees may be doing the organization a disservice by raising consumer expectations beyond the point at which the company can consistently meet them. Of course, in the long run we do want to provide exceptional service, but only when we can do it all the time. If we have exceptional performers, we should take them off the front line as quickly as possible. Instead, make them trainers and managers of the front line. This will allow them to increase the overall brilliance of the organization, not just their own personal glow.</blockquote><blockquote><em>Manage the memory.</em> Because services are high in credence attributes, the consumers’ opinion of their service encounter can be influenced even after the encounter. We should seek to emphasize successes and reinterpret failures. Soon after we graduate from college, the school’s alumni relations department begins sending us mailings recasting the college experience in the most positive light possible; those mailings generally also include a request for a financial donation to the school.</blockquote><blockquote><em>Quantify the value of our services.</em> All too often, organizations “throw in” services as icing on the product cake. If asked directly, salespeople understand that there is a cost to delivering those ancillary services, but they are still tempted to use services as a sweetener to get deals closed. Some organizations provide services as part of a sales generation program, such as General Electric’s “At the Customer, For the Customer” (ACFC) program. Regardless of the way our organization provides services, we need to be sure we know how much these services are costing us, and how much our customers value them. In some cases, we may find that some customer segments don’t value our “add-on” services very much, while in others, customers see these services as mission critical. We can use this information as a simple segmentation scheme and offer the different service segments differential customer offerings.13 For example, we might choose to target a market segment who does not require and value a high level of service, and we can offer them a “bare bones” solution that is priced accordingly. Alternatively, we may choose to target segments with higher service needs that we might meet based on our core competence. If we clearly identify specific services that customers value, we can determine whether we can profitably meet those needs. The key is not to attempt to be all things to all people, but rather to segment the market by systematically identifying customer groups with unique service needs and then determining which ones we can profitably serve.</blockquote><h3>Services and the Framework</h3><p>Managers love to talk about superior service, marketers love to promise it, and operations people wish they could deliver it. As consumers, we all have our own sad story (or two, or sixty) of a bad service encounter; we all dream of having those wrongs righted and of being treated with respect, competence, and empathy each time we receive service. The inherently emotional aspects of services make it particularly difficult for marketers to think rationally about their strategic use. For this reason, it is crucial to leverage the Framework to do a systematic analysis of service issues.</p><p>At the <em>Business Objective</em> stage, we may choose to redefine what business we are in to account for service issues. For example, instead of being in the home-alarm business we may be in the home safety business — there are many more services that must be leveraged to deliver home safety than are needed to deliver a home alarm. While it sounds much more appealing to be in the home safety business, the additional costs of providing the services necessary to compete in this category must also be carefully considered.</p><p>In addition, a clear understanding of our <em>core competence</em> is particularly important for services marketing. We must be brutally realistic about what we are able to deliver on a consistent basis and be careful not to promise more than this to our customers.</p><p>It is also important that we value our core competence internally and can communicate this value to our employees, and then our customers. Very often, a complaining customer is asking us to deliver something that is outside our area of competence. Companies often reward employees as heroes for delivering services that fall outside the defined scope of competence for the corporation. In the short run, these employees increase customer satisfaction. However, if the company is not able to deliver these services consistently, the customer will be disappointed in the long run. Hence, it is vital that the firm clearly defines and communicates both the value and the limit of its competencies.</p><p>When we determine our<em> customer focus</em>, we should clearly understand the differential nature of the services needed for retention versus acquisition. A company with a large installed base of existing customers likely will have callers to its customer service call center who have a high level of experience and expertise with the product and category. The call center’s customer service representatives must be able to match that high level of expertise to meet the callers’ needs efficiently and without talking down. On the other hand, a company emphasizing acquisition may need service providers who can teach and reassure potential customers. It should be noted, however, that services play the greatest role in customer retention, and it is here that we should see the greatest concentration of expenditures on retention.</p><p>Of course, at the stage of <em>competitive focus</em>, we may elect to leverage a service attribute to earn share from our competitors or stimulate primary demand in a new category. To do this, we must be able to profitably dominate on that variable. It is important to avoid wishful marketing at this stage of the process; in the absence of any substantive product points-of-difference, we may be tempted simply to convince ourselves that we can dominate on some service attribute when, in reality, we cannot. It is easier to make this mistake here because the intangibility of services makes it difficult to disprove our own perception of having an advantage in this area. We will have a competitive advantage in providing a service only if we have a core competence in providing that service.</p><p>This thinking must follow through to the <em>STP </em>stage. If we elect to segment on service benefits, we must be sure that the need for (and interest in paying for) these services exists among enough people to justify such a strategy. Furthermore, it is important to recognize the challenge of effectively positioning ourselves on a service (i.e., credence) attribute.</p><p>In summary, even a packaged goods manufacturer must provide some services to his or her customer, and much of the product differentiation occurring in mature industries is essentially the addition of service attributes. The importance of services marketing is increasing, and therefore, the differences between goods and services must be clearly understood to ensure proper strategy and execution.</p><p>[1] Purington, et. al, “Alexa is my new BFF:” Social Roles, User Satisfaction, and Personification of the Amazon Echo. Proceedings of the 2017 CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems, May 2017.</p><p>[2] Johnston, Robert, The zone of tolerance: Exploring the relationship between service transactions and satisfaction with the overall service. International Journal of Service Industry Management, May, 1995.</p><p><strong>Thanks for reading!</strong></p><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/marketing-management-a-systems-framework/marketing-management-9dcd7af7af82">Chapter 1</a>: Introduction and Ethics</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/marketing-management-a-systems-framework/chapter-2-fb1b1c97ed2">Chapter 2:</a> Systems Thinking</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-46ee0f9e8fed">Chapter 3:</a> Business Objective</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-acca9198d5c4">Chapter 4</a>: Customer Focus</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-5606fe5549cd">Chapter 5</a>: Competitive Focus</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-caef5a55ce5">Chapter 6</a>: Estimating Market Potential/The 4 B’s</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-7-6d70d7d82fe">Chapter 7</a>: Segmentation</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-8-cd67a3a30366">Chapter 8</a>: Targeting</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-9-dda03c5b30b">Chapter 9</a>: Positioning</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-10-6ed681a90fc3">Chapter 10</a>: Product</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-11-2b15ae515308">Chapter 11:</a> Service as Product</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-12-226d545c4557">Chapter 12:</a> Communications</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-13-7deb8a757a1a">Chapter 13</a>: Channels</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-14-75ec5ec787c1">Chapter 14:</a> Pricing</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-15-e660600b8dd1">Chapter 15:</a> Metrics</blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2b15ae515308" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/marketing-management-a-systems-framework/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-11-2b15ae515308">Marketing Management: A Systems Framework (11)</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/marketing-management-a-systems-framework">Marketing Management: A Systems Framework</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Marketing Management: A Systems Framework (10)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/marketing-management-a-systems-framework/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-10-6ed681a90fc3?source=rss-ba31e9c694d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6ed681a90fc3</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Christie Nordhielm PhD]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 27 Dec 2021 21:01:18 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-02-23T00:54:17.922Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Chapter 10: Product</h4><h4>CHRISTIE L. NORDHIELM</h4><p>Georgetown University</p><p>© 2021 Christie L. Nordhielm all rights reserved</p><p><em>This is part 10 in a 15-chapter collection that makes up this book. Enjoy!</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*rZqOC5gtAItaAA0djYOs1A.jpeg" /></figure><p>We now enter the executional phase of the Framework. We will leverage all four of these executional elements — product, pricing, distribution, and communications — to communicate our strategy. As we move into this phase, we will constantly be referring to our strategic decisions to ensure coherence with the strategy. The fact that we have already done the difficult strategic work will make these myriad executional decisions much easier. If, on the other hand, we have not taken the time to fully develop our strategy, or we do not really have confidence in our strategic plan, we will quickly become mired in executional details going forward. Too many companies and business managers fall prey to tactical tunnel vision — they get sucked into devoting all their focus on the day-to-day planning of tactical programs and policies without stepping back to ensure that these tactics align with a consistent strategy. This can be a fatal error and may be the biggest cause of marketing underperformance faced by companies.</p><p>The first, and most important way we communicate our positioning is with our product. The product is our key point of contact with our customer; in many cases they will interact with it every day. Most importantly, whereas we make promises with communications, we deliver on these promises with our product. This is where we retain our customer, create sustainable growth, and build brand value. Simply put: if we get this step wrong no other execution element will save us.</p><h4>Definition of Product</h4><p>What is a product? The common answer is an example: a can of Coke, a Viagra® tablet or Chevy Camaro. These answers convolute the notion of <em>brand</em> and <em>product</em>. Our brand is where we capture and hold value; our products are how we create and deliver this value. We deliver value with the bundle of benefits that our product embodies, and we communicate this value with our product as well. Therefore, we should think of products not as things we sell to generate profit, but rather as tools for creating brand and customer value.</p><h4>Products as Benefits</h4><p>Most products offer a variety of benefits. A smart phone may offer the benefit of communication, entertainment, socialization, status, creativity, value, and safety. Our first job as a marketer is to determine which of these benefits we will actively promote. We started exploring this issue in the Business Objective chapter when we identified the core competence — strategic asset — benefit linkage. We deepened this analysis in the STP steps of the framework. Our challenge here is to maintain this discipline, and not fall prey to the lure of talking up all the benefits of our product based on the false assumption that the more benefits we emphasize the more products we will sell. The opposite is more probable: if we choose to talk about several of our product benefits, we are more likely to confuse our current and potential customers. We also run the risk of promoting a benefit that is tied to a core competence of a competitor. Therefore, we chose one benefit in STP, and therefore we need to stick with one benefit here.</p><p>Consider the MiniCooper, a subcompact car that consumers often compare with the Volkswagen Golf. The “one word” for Mini is <em>Fun, </em>and their product development and promotion efforts are aligned behind this one word. However, on a test drive, a potential customer may ask the salesperson about what kind of gas mileage the Mini gets. It seems appropriate for the salesperson to say that Mini gets great mileage. However, the Volkswagen outperforms Mini on fuel economy (as do many other subcompacts). The salesperson’s response may increase the importance of fuel economy for the potential customer, who would then go on to choose a car with better MPG. Instead of promoting fuel economy, the appropriate response would be to commoditize it and then move back to the differentiating positioning, e.g., “all subcompact cars get great mileage, but Mini is the most fun.” This subtle but important difference in approach, applied across all our communications, is how we achieve a sustainable competitive advantage.</p><h4>Product to Brand: Brand Equity</h4><p>Any discussion of product is not complete without an examination of branding and brand equity. A product is an essential brand building tool, and brand equity is a strategic asset produced by skilled marketers. As such, brand equity possesses many of the same characteristics as other, more tangible assets such as plant and equipment. Investments are made into this asset in the form of advertising, promotion, customer service, and product development. While a brand cannot be depreciated on a balance sheet according to current U.S. accounting standards, it is certainly an asset that can depreciate. Like a piece of equipment, brand equity must be maintained, or it will cease to yield profits.</p><p>The standard definition of a brand is <em>a name, sign, symbol or design intended to identify the products or services of one seller and to differentiate them from those of competitors</em>. More important, of course, is our understanding of how a brand functions. A brand serves different functions for different consumers and product categories:</p><blockquote>At the most basic level, a brand serves as a <em>memory aid</em>, enabling consumers to identify a product that they may have used successfully in the past. In the case of table salt, Morton® Salt in the distinctive blue box is recognized easily by consumers even when they are not committing a significant amount of cognitive resource to the search task.</blockquote><blockquote>In many cases, a brand name also may serve as a <em>surrogate for quality information</em>. In the absence of other information, many consumers rely on the simple assumption that a recognizable brand is generally produced by a reputable company with the expertise, resources, and an incentive to provide consistent quality to customers. This reliance on brand name is generally more important to consumers whose expertise or experience in the category is low. A novice consumer is, therefore, much more likely to buy Tylenol or Advil vs a generic pain reliever. It is important to note that this reliance on brand name can tend to diminish as customer expertise increases and customers begin to use other information (e.g., research, recommendations from friends, personal experience) to inform their decisions.</blockquote><blockquote>Most importantly, a brand should serve as an actual <em>basis for differentiation</em>. In this function, the brand is, in essence, another attribute that drives consumer preference. A consumer may purchase a pair of Nike shoes even though a Reebok pair offers the same functionality, because the Nike brand, in and of itself, represents the benefit of performance.</blockquote><blockquote>Finally, a brand can serve as a <em>locus of emotion</em>. When a customer has positive or negative feelings during a product consumption experience, the brand acts as a repository for these emotional memories. If the product did not have a brand name, these experiences would essentially be lost. The MasterCard “priceless” campaign is aimed at bonding emotional experiences to the credit card brand. As Ruth Ann Marshall, president of MasterCard International’s North America division, said in a 2003 interview, the goal of the “Priceless” campaign is to get people “to put our cards at the top of the wallet by talking to the heart and giving examples in life of where you might use a card to make a priceless experience for yourself.”</blockquote><p>A brand cannot add value to the firm if the product does not perform in a consistent fashion. This is because a brand name provides a simple means for consumers to remember their experiences, good or bad. Branding a product can serve to accelerate its demise in the case of unreliable or poor performance. For this reason, a product should not be branded until we are sure we can provide consistent performance. Chiquita brand bananas, for example, were not marketed actively until 1963. While the brand and certain advertising was introduced in the U.S. in the 1940s, it was not until 1963 that the corporation had perfected a method for controlling ripening of the bananas and shipping them with minimal bruising. With an assurance of quality, Chiquita was able to leverage a simple sticker, a memorable jingle, and a strong advertising campaign to build share for a branded banana.</p><p>Examples of the opposite effect also abound. Customers will use a brand name to help them remember which products performed poorly to avoid purchasing them in the future. The Firestone brand name arguably became a negative asset for the Bridgestone Firestone Corporation in the early 2000’s following a series of product failures of its tires that allegedly resulted in a number of deaths. When product failures of this sort occur, it is a powerful reminder that the communicative benefits of a brand name can operate in either direction. When product failures do occur (such as the poisoning that occurred with Tylenol or the presence of syringes in some Pepsi cans), rapid and dramatic action must be taken to protect the brand as well as the consumers. Customers historically have rewarded firms that have taken fast action to correct known problems with their brands. This fast action is a signal to customers that quality remains important to the company, and that failure is a temporary, rare event.</p><h4>Assessing Brand Value</h4><p>How much is our brand worth? There are a variety of approaches to answering this question. For publicly held corporations, brand value is often assessed by simply adding up the value of all the other assets of the company and then comparing this number to the actual market value of the firm. In essence, the question they are being asked is what would the company be worth if it lost its brand name and kept everything else? This method is less accurate in today’s marketplace as value investing has been increasingly superseded by more speculative trading. Another common tactic is to evaluate the asset value of a corporation before and after a new brand introduction. Unfortunately, these methods essentially leave the task of assessing brand value up to market analysts who may or may not have a clear understanding of the long-term value of a brand.</p><p>We can generally develop more accurate estimates of brand value by taking a consumer perspective. For example, we can consider the price premium that the brand commands in the marketplace or use research to explore the impact of the presence or absence of a brand name on consumer preference for a product. We can also try to estimate how much it would cost to develop a new brand from scratch with an equal market share. Each of these estimate methods likely will yield different results, but by triangulating it may be possible to arrive at a best guess of brand value.</p><p>Assessing brand value is difficult because it is dependent on consumer preferences, which are dynamic. These preferences are influenced by our own marketing efforts, and a change in these efforts can substantially change the value of a brand. Perhaps the most famous domestic example of this is the saga of Snapple brand beverage, a “new-age” non-carbonated beverage that the Quaker Oats Company acquired from the Snapple Beverage Corporation in 1994 for $1.7 billion. At that price, Quaker’s discounted cash flow analysis indicated that the value of the brand was $5.50 more per share than it was paying. Furthermore, this first Snapple purchase price was calculated based on the assumption that Snapple brand sales would benefit from Quakers’ core competence in distribution. However, by 1997, the Snapple brand was sold by Quaker to Triarc Beverage Group for a mere $300 million. Three years later Triarc sold Snapple to Cadbury Schweppes at a valuation of $1.45 billion. While several things changed for the brand over this six-year period, perhaps the most obvious was Quaker’s firing of Snapple’s famous employee/spokesperson, Wendy. The quirky marketing campaign that the Snapple Beverage Corporation had put together behind this spokesperson had built a loyal following for the brand, and this group quickly jumped ship when Wendy got her pink slip. She was later re-hired by Triarc and the brand value was restored. This painfully obvious example of the dynamic nature of brand valuation underlines the importance of including the customer in our calculations of brand value, something the Quaker Oats Company apparently failed to do in this case. In essence, they counted bottles instead of customers in developing their estimates.</p><h4>Product to Brand: Product Portfolio</h4><p>Most companies sell more than one product under the same brand name. If we are working through the framework, we have already determined our Fundamental Entity and know the extent to which we are pursuing and umbrella vs. distinct brand strategy. Even with the narrowest of distinct brands, however, we may have several products that vary by size, price, and other features. The key to a proper portfolio strategy is to assess what role each product in the portfolio plays in building overall brand value. One way to assess the products in our portfolio is by their degree of <em>positionality</em>; that is, to what extent does a particular product embody and or communicate our core benefit? Consider the BMW brand in the United States (BMW positioning varies slightly outside the US). Their slogan is “The Ultimate Driving Machine,” suggesting a core benefit of performance. All the products in the BMW line are named with numbers and or letters, suggesting a strong umbrella strategy. Figure 1 shows the entire BMW line as of 2021. They offer SAV’s (sports activity vehicles), sedans, coupes, convertibles, roadsters, and a small but growing line of electric versions cars in each of these categories. Within each of these lines they offer further options and variations. Each of these models is intended to communicate and deliver on the promise of performance vs. competitors within the specific segment. From a big picture perspective, there are certain BMW models that support and communicate the performance benefit better than others. These products are sometimes referred to as flagship products. They may receive more advertising support than seems justified by their sales volume. This is because they are positional products, and their existence has a positive impact on the BMW brand.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/626/1*Fh__C4o3RIHUG21CID9lwA.png" /><figcaption>Figure 1: BMW models, 2021</figcaption></figure><p>In many industries firms may find it necessary to add products to the line that seem to contribute little or nothing to the brand’s positioning. These types of products are generally included in the portfolio to make it more convenient for customers, and/or to discourage our customers from going to a competitor for certain items. Decisions about whether to add non-positional products to the brand line are extremely difficult; the addition of such products can dilute the brand message and confuse consumers; however, there are times when a “full menu” of products is necessary to satisfy our customers’ basic needs. McDonald’s decision to add salads to the menu is an example of such a decision. Salads are clearly non-positional for McDonald’s; they don’t deliver or promote the benefit of convenience, and may, in fact increase the importance of health amongst their customers, which might drive them to a competitor. However, McDonald’s found that, particularly for families making an out-of-home dining decision, one or more members were objecting to McDonald’s because they didn’t have any healthy options. Salad sales account for an extremely small portion of McDonald’s sales; however, they help to eliminate objections that might cause them to lose other business.</p><p>The key to including non-positional products in the portfolio is to remember that they do not align with our core benefit and should therefore not be promoted in any meaningful way. They should just be made available, and basic awareness of this availability must be achieved. Any support beyond this could be damaging to the brand.</p><p>The above discussion illustrates how products are tools for communication of our core benefit. We will pick and choose among them for the best options to promote and feature and try to discipline ourselves not to over-promote non-positional products. Many companies with a bloated product portfolio have fallen victim to the lure of short-term opportunity at the expense of strategic product management and sustainable competitive advantage.</p><h4>Features to Benefits: Laddering</h4><p>Our products should be optimized to deliver and communicate our core benefit; the same approach holds true for features of these products. The trick here, again, is to distinguish features that may be generally important from those that are linked to our core benefit. Consider MiniCooper again: features such as funky interior lighting, exterior details such as stripes, and even weight distribution for a “go-cart feel” support the core positioning of <em>fun.</em> Other features that might be included on the car, such as a fuel-efficient engine, support a different benefit of fuel economy or lower long-term cost of ownership (value). Side airbags support the benefit of safety. These features are included to keep Mini in the running with other competitors in the subcompact category; they are essentially a <em>cost of entry</em> for competing. But just as McDonald’s shouldn’t promote salads, Mini shouldn’t promote fuel economy or safety unless they plan on reorienting their core competence and strategic assets to make one of these their core benefit. Otherwise, we should assume there is another competitor in the category who dominates on fuel efficiency, and another who dominates on safety.</p><p>The laddering exercise is an excellent way to visualize the relationship between product features, benefits, and ultimate customer values. It is a great tool for brainstorming possible segmentation benefits and helps us to understand and prioritize our product/feature development and promotion. Figure 2 is an example of this exercise for MiniCooper. Here we identify several features of the car, such as side airbags and equalized weight distribution. There are of course many more features that could and should be included. We then consider the benefits that these features support or help deliver. For example, equalized weight distribution supports the benefit of enhanced performance, and therefore fun in the driving experience. Note here there can be lower and higher-level benefits: in general, benefits that can be easily quantified or objectively demonstrated, such as fuel efficiency, are lower-level benefits. A benefit that is more qualitative or subjective, such as fun or convenience, would be considered a higher-level benefit. Finally, we consider the values these benefits support. Values are expressed from the point of view of the customer, usually using first person. This reflects the fact that our brand can have an impact on customer self-perception and social identity. In general, features are about the product, benefits are about the performance of the product, and values are about the person using the product.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/468/1*JHlJ683P_R4Gqq2Ugco56w.png" /><figcaption>Figure 2: Laddering for MiniCooper</figcaption></figure><p>We can see from Figure 2 that one feature can ladder up to more than one benefit and/or value. In the first stage of the laddering process, we want to make as many connections as possible to explore all the strategic and tactical options available to us. In the end, however, we are looking for a coherent connection between features, benefits, and values. In the case of MiniCooper, if our core benefit is fun, we will delete all the elements that don’t link to this benefit, giving us a more focused set of connections as shown in Figure 3. At this point we might add other features that tie out to the benefit of fun. The elements in this figure are the ones we will emphasize in our marketing execution, including packaging, promotional materials, digital/social presence, sales training, and product development, and everything else we do to support our brand. Any elements that are <em>not </em>in this figure will not be promoted unless we can find a way to tie them logically to our core benefit.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/468/1*L9NhqjepftG1BVwBwO2sIQ.png" /><figcaption>Figure 3: Edited Laddering Exercise</figcaption></figure><h4>Types of Product Attributes</h4><p>In the laddering exercise above we connected product features, to benefits, to consumer values. As we move to execute our product strategy another way to deepen our understanding is to consider the different types of attributes products possess. All products have three types of attributes: search, experience, and credence. These attributes may be characterized as follows:</p><blockquote>A <em>search attribute</em> is one that can be evaluated prior to product purchase and consumption. These are attributes that can be easily observed, such as price, brand name, color, size, nutritional information, performance attributes such as EPA ratings or miles per gallon, guarantees or warranties, etc.</blockquote><blockquote>An <em>experience attribute</em> is one that only can be evaluated after consumption. The taste of canned tuna is a classic example of such an attribute; you must open the can and put the tuna in your mouth before you can evaluate it. Other examples of experience attributes include actual (as opposed to predicted) fuel efficiency, cleaning ability (detergents), actual battery life, etc. To evaluate an experience attribute a consumer must either purchase or sample our product.</blockquote><blockquote>A <em>credence attribute</em> is one that cannot be evaluated, even after the product is consumed. Vitamins and other health-related products tend to be high in credence attributes; it is impossible for a consumer to tell whether she is smarter because she ingested large quantities of Gingko Biloba or if she is generally healthier because she takes a multivitamin every morning. Beauty products make claims of delivering shinier hair or longer lashes.</blockquote><p>All products possess search, experience, and credence attributes. Our task is to choose which attributes to emphasize. These types of attributes map onto the features/benefits/values laddering tool, and this tool will direct us as we make these determinations. A key difference with product attributes is we can convert one to the other. Consider the screen grab Purina Dog Chow in Figure 4. The credence claim here is a <em>longer, healthier life,</em> a claim that Purina made for many years. There was, of course, no way for consumers to know that their dog was living longer because they were feeding Purina instead of an alternative product. In Figure 5 we see example of a Purina ad that emphasizes this credence attribute and seeks to support it with the search attribute of ingredients (which are also emphasized on the packaging). But the company went even further, conducting a 14-year study of longevity in dogs that used Purina Dog Chow. They then publicized the results of this study to further support their credence claim.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*HQp9rsSOyLhCUpCgRCcCHA.png" /><figcaption>Figure 4: Purina Dog Chow Screen Grab</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*IKEfoQChnG-e3TJrMuL0dA.png" /><figcaption>Figure 5: Purina Dog Chow Print Ad</figcaption></figure><p>We may also seek to move our attributes in the other direction. For example, the Volvo brand had maintained a safety positioning since the 1970’s. In their early advertising they emphasized search attributes such as 3-point seat belts and multiple braking circuits as illustrated in Figure 6. Over time, however, other competitors matched Volvo on many of these safety features. While Volvo will still strive to develop more and better safety features for their cars, they slowly moved to emphasizing safety as a credence attribute at evidenced in the 2020 ads in Figure 7. This approach leverages and promotes Volvo’s safety promise while reducing the probability that consumers will make specific features comparisons that might not be as compelling in support of this positioning.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*w-VwtjMPL1kIrg1VewM9yQ.png" /><figcaption>Figure 6: Volvo Print Ad 1975</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*I_1B_2IUUKxAE3XfPIJDeA.png" /><figcaption>Figure 7: Volvo Outdoor Ads 2020</figcaption></figure><p>How to decide whether and when to promote search, experience, or credence attributes? This decision should be driven by our strategy and the nature of our product. To ensure efficiency and strategy coherence we can step through this process in a systematic fashion as follows:</p><blockquote><strong><em>1. Brainstorm search/experience/credence attributes.</em></strong><em> Like the laddering exercise above, our first step is to identify as many attributes as possible for each attribute type.</em></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>2. Identify positional attributes:</em></strong><em> Positional attributes are like positional products: they are consistent with or support the brand positioning</em></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>3. Identify power attributes: </em></strong><em>Power attributes cause a substantial increase in perceived value. One way to evaluate this is to consider how a customer might value a product with or without that attribute. For example, we can compare willingness to pay for a car with and without a heads-up display.</em></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>4. Align with customer focus:</em></strong><em> Finally, we choose which types of attributes to promote based on our customer focus. For acquisition we will focus more on search attributes, and, if we can sample the product, experience attributes. For retention we move to emphasizing experience and credence attributes. Experience attributes are generally emphasized if we wish to support hand loyalty, and credence attributes are emphasized for heart loyalty.</em></blockquote><p>By taking a disciplined approach to managing product attributes we can fully leverage our products to increase brand and consumer value.</p><h4>Consumer Involvement and Product Attributes</h4><p>The product is the primary point of contact between the firm and the customer. To engage with customers in a way that is most effective, we need to consider our consumers level of involvement with our brand, product, and product category. We will consider two types of involvement here, functional involvement, which is more concerned with objective product performance, and ego involvement, which is tied to how well the product contributes to or supports the identity of the consumer. These two types of involvement are described in Figure 8.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*kzROS06RqDkd1HgI6n6rRQ.png" /><figcaption>Figure 8: Product Involvement and Product Attributes</figcaption></figure><p>We can think of the level of involvement as tied to <em>risk of loss, </em>a concept that was introduced in the positioning chapter. Risk of loss is the loss (whether utilitarian or ego) that a consumer faces if they make the wrong product choice. A classic example of a product with high functional risk of loss is a parachute: if it fails to perform, the consumer risks death. In contrast, ego-involved loss would be a blow to the consumers self-perception; for example, a couple deciding on a wedding location faces the risk of embarrassment if the venue they choose doesn’t support their vision of the event.</p><p>These types of distinctions can occur at lower levels of involvement as well. We consume many products that contribute to our self-identity, ranging from what beer we order to whether we use a Samsung or an Apple phone. These types of products are often referred to as badge products; they are generally consumed in public and are intended to reflect our sense of self. In contrast, other products tend to be evaluated from a more objective perspective, such as car tires or insurance. It is important to note, however, that there is some ego-involvement in functional products and some functional involvement in ego-involved products. In fact, a competitor seeking to differentiate may choose to emphasize functional attributes in a more ego-involved category or vice-versa.</p><p>In Figure 8 we have overlaid product attributes. In general, we will emphasize credence attributes for ego-involved products, search attributes for functionally involved products, and experience attributes for lower-involved products. If we are seeking to move our positioning from one area of this space to another, one way to accomplish this is by changing our product attribute emphasis. In the case of Volvo mentioned above, the brand sought to move consumers from functional involvement to ego-involvement by moving from search attributes to credence attributes. This movement is also a shift from head to heart brand loyalty.</p><h4>Product Involvement and the Purchase Process</h4><p>To understand product involvement more fully, it is important to examine the purchase process. A common model of the purchase process involves key assumptions about the relationship between attitudes, knowledge, and behavior. It is generally assumed that as people obtain information about a product, this information changes their feelings, and this attitude change leads to a behavior (purchase). This progression, however, may not be as common as we assume, as illustrated in Figure 9. Consider a low-involvement product such as table salt. Consumers purchasing salt are not likely to collect or even attend to any information about the product, and their feelings similarly are not likely to change. In fact, the purchase process for this low involvement item starts not with learning or attitude change, but with a behavior, the actual purchase of the product. Following purchase, the consumer will use the product, and may in this process learn something, particularly if there is a product failure. Assuming no product failure, what they will learn is that this product works, and their feelings are not likely to extend beyond “this product is fine.” This do-learn (feel) process is quite common for low-involvement items.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*UaSTVV7PbSGoL_NirjOBPw.png" /><figcaption>Figure 9: Purchase Process and Involvement</figcaption></figure><p>In contrast, a product positioned against the high ego-involvement segment likely will generate a far different purchase process. Consumers viewing the Volvo ad in Figure 7 learn relatively little from the ad itself, but the ad is intended to change consumers’ feelings about the car. Based on these feelings, potential customers may act by including Volvo in their consideration set, visiting a dealer to learn more about the product. Hence these consumers follow a feel-do-learn process.</p><p>Finally, in the high functional risk of loss category, we can expect customers to follow a more traditional purchase process. They likely will begin by collecting information about the product, and based on this information, they will make a purchase decision. This process aligns with the Volvo print ad in Figure 6, an ad that emphasizes a functional attribute of the product (safety features). This Based on this information, potential consumers will visit the dealer, and will likely continue with their rational evaluation prior to purchase. After this experience they may develop additional feelings beyond the rational evaluation of the product’s performance. These consumers are following a learn-do-feel process. Thus, there are three models of the consumer purchase process, and they stem directly from how customers relate to the product and the product category.</p><h4>Product “Life Cycle”</h4><p>Many traditional approaches to product management rest on the assumption that all products have a lifecycle as described in Figure 10. In this model product sales grow slowly at first as the product is introduced, and then the rate of growth increases during the aptly named “growth” phase. At some point the product matures and sales flattened, and this is followed by a decline in sales and the presumed eventual “death” of the product. Some products have indeed followed this pattern; however, this outcome is not inevitable. Furthermore, the product lifecycle concept sometimes can become a self-fulfilling prophecy. If, for example, we see our product sales begin to flatten we may assume the product has entered the maturity phase, and we may therefore reduce our allocation of marketing resources, causing sales to decline. This cycle can lead to the premature decline of products when, with proper support they might otherwise have been robust contributors to revenues and brand value.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*BvULjfPfmKSeCRWEV92CoQ.png" /><figcaption>Figure 10: Traditional Product Lifecycle</figcaption></figure><p>Further, marketers sometimes conflate products, iterations of products, and brands. For example, this book is being written using Microsoft Word, a product that was launched in 1983 and has had nearly 20 major updates or iterations. One could argue that each iteration of this product had a lifecycle, but that perspective is of interest only to the software development team. From a consumer perspective, Microsoft Word is a brand supported by constantly evolving set of products and iterations. The brand has been continuously promoted and supported by Microsoft and show no signs of decline. The version available today is quite different from the version released in 1983, but both versions deliver essentially the same benefit: effective and efficient word processing.</p><p>It is perhaps more informative to look at products as represented by the “bull’s eye” in Figure11. In this representation we have a core benefit and product, basic word processing. This is the core product provided by all competitors in the category. Each competitor will then make a succession of improvements and augmentations to that product. For Microsoft, the expected product today might be a word processor with an excellent grammar and spell-checker, thesaurus, and tools for adding graphics to documents. The augmented product might have highly accurate dictation component, and the potential product might be one where voice commands could be used to edit the document. In contract, a competitive product such as Apple’s Pages word processer might make improvements in a different direction based on their positioning: the augmented product might provide integrated graphical tools for doing illustrations directly in the document, and the potential product might provide advanced design options and recommendations. The fact that these two brands would augment their products in different ways will maintain their differentiation in the category, and ultimately their profitability.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*huu3gik3d5fIiGnmFtkhnA.png" /><figcaption>Figure 11: Product Lifecycle “Bull’s Eye”</figcaption></figure><p>If we continue to improve our product in strategic ways to deliver and support the core benefit, there is no particular reason why our product cannot evolve for a very long time. Consider the automotive example. The core benefit that any product provides is generally the first benefit developed when the product category comes into being. The first automobiles were developed to provide consumer-controlled transportation from point A to point B, and any manufacturer who was able to develop a product that could deliver that core benefit could consider entering the motorized personal transportation category producing a generic product. The company who delivered this product best sold the most cars. The expected product, after a time, was likely a car that didn’t break down (reliability benefit). With competition and the passage of time, however, the bundle of benefits delivered by automobiles began to change. The first competitors to challenge Henry Ford did so by offering design variations on their automobiles (an augmented product); instead of a black car, for example, customers could choose a different color. This augmented product, a car in your choice of colors, soon became the expected product for the category, and a car that didn’t break down became the generic product. Note that the product feature here is choice of colors, but the product benefit is individual styling and self-expression.</p><p>The dynamic nature of the bull’s eye model is related directly to the market dynamics we observed during the segmentation process. As a result, we can map these stages in product category development directly back to the main and dynamic benefit discussed in STP. The main or category benefit is represented by the expected product, and the dynamic benefit is represented by the augmented product. In determining which augmented product (and therefore dynamic benefit) to promote, marketers evaluate potential products. In the automobile example, even as new color/design options were introduced, car manufacturers were exploring other potential products that might be introduced successfully, considering a wide variety of possible product features that might yield important consumer benefits like performance, safety, etc. This process continues today. The question automobile manufacturers now face is the same question Henry Ford faced: What benefits can I profitably deliver to customers? The answer changes over time, and companies face the constant challenge of adapting to and managing these changes.</p><p>Of course, not all consumers seek the same benefits in a product. Market segmentation arises from the differences in benefits sought by different consumer segments. An auto buyer today may be seeking to signal that she has reached a certain level of professional success and will look for the benefit of status in the luxury car segment. Another auto customer, however, simply may be seeking reliable, low-cost transportation and would therefore look in the economy segment. Customers in each of these categories will evaluate potential products based on the specific benefits offered by alternative products within each of these narrower competitive categories.</p><p>As discussed in STP, a dynamic benefit can eventually become a main benefit. Hence, a competitor seeking to earn share in a category will augment its product in some way with the hope that this product improvement eventually will become a customer expectation. This same process can be undertaken by category leaders; the category leader may identify an augmentation that will help them earn share from another, larger category, or to stimulate demand and stay ahead of competition by continuing to innovate in the current category. In either case, the dynamic benefit is represented in the augmented product.</p><p>Over time, as the augmented product becomes the expected product, the dynamic benefit evolves into the main benefit. McDonald’s sought to stimulate primary demand by emphasizing a brand-new benefit in fast food: family fun. Over time, this benefit may have become the main benefit; that is, consumers may come to expect fun from their fast-food restaurants. If this occurs, then any competitor considering entering this category will need to provide family fun in addition to fast food. Of course, if McDonald’s is successful with this strategy, they drastically increase the cost of entry to this category. This evolution of dynamic benefits to main benefits (augmented products to expected products) should be driven by the category leader but is often driven by competitors seeking to earn share in a category. Augmentations become expectations when they resonate strongly with a group of customers, benefit the innovator, and then are eventually copied by other competitors. By focusing on consistent benefit augmentation instead of simply adding features, we develop a long-term positioning for our brand such that consumers come to associate our brand with a particular benefit positioning even when similar features associated with this positioning are available from other brands. For example, Volvo has consistently positioned and augmented its products on the safety benefit so that consumers associate the brand with this benefit. Today, many competitors deliver nearly identical features such as side air bags, daytime running lights, and superior crash test ratings. However, if they promote these features too aggressively, they may simply be promoting a safety positioning associated with Volvo.</p><h4>Systems Thinking and Product</h4><p>We can leverage product attributes to drive our user base in a particular direction. Figure 12 outlines the move from acquisition to retention with this process. We first emphasize search attributes to encourage functional involvement, head loyalty, and customer acquisition. We must then decide as to whether to emphasize experience attributes to build our hand loyal customer base, or to emphasize credence to stimulate ego-involvement and heart loyalty. We cannot realistically implement both strategies since hand loyalty is low involvement and hearty loyalty is high involvement.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/936/1*6bxPbAy-qyUH0AAiciuAJw.png" /><figcaption>Figure 12: Involvement and Product Attributes</figcaption></figure><h3>Product, Brand, and the Framework</h3><p>The factors involved in product decisions are myriad. If we have clearly specified our strategy up to this point, however, these decisions can be made more efficiently. Strategic choices regarding the core benefit, the type of brand loyalty we seek to engender, and our strategic focus will guide our decision making in all tactical areas of the framework. Figure 13 outlines the relationship between strategic focus and product attributes.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Y3_mWgZOLsVpubQYytW_Og.png" /><figcaption>Figure 13: Strategic Focus and Product</figcaption></figure><blockquote>If we wish to implement an <em>acquisition/stimulate demand</em> strategy where we are attempting to attract new users to the category, we likely will emphasize search attributes, as these types of attributes most clearly reduce the uncertainty consumers may be feeling upon considering entering a new category. Ideally, we could leverage an experience attribute to convince consumers to enter the category — this, however, is generally only an option for low-cost products where sampling is possible and repeated purchases can be confidently predicted once someone has sampled the product.</blockquote><blockquote>For an <em>acquisition/earn share</em> strategy, we generally will emphasize a search attribute that highlights our product point-of-difference vs. the competitor or the segment from whom we are attempting to earn share.</blockquote><blockquote>For a <em>retention/stimulate demand</em> strategy, we will try to promote and solidify our brand position by emphasizing a credence attribute. By moving our product into the credence space, we reduce the possibility that competitors can earn share through imitation.</blockquote><blockquote>Finally, for a <em>retention/earn share</em> strategy, we will try to emphasize an experience attribute on which we can dominate our key competitor if possible. If we do not dominate on an experience attribute, we likely will need to emphasize a credence attribute and invest appropriately in advertising to support it.</blockquote><p>Just as in other areas of the framework, our choice to emphasize one type of product attribute does not mean we will not be concerned with the others. It does mean, however, that our primary focus will be on this attribute. By maintaining this focus, we can ensure that our product-related efforts, as well as other executional efforts, are as efficient as possible.</p><p>In summary, we can improve our ability to develop and market our product by considering, in detail, how consumer involvement and expectations drive product perceptions. Our approach to marketing a specific product should be based on a full understanding of not just the consumer or the product, but also the interaction of the consumer and the product. By understanding this relationship, we can begin to not only market a product, but also to build a brand.</p><p><strong>Thanks for reading!</strong></p><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/marketing-management-a-systems-framework/marketing-management-9dcd7af7af82">Chapter 1</a>: Introduction and Ethics</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/marketing-management-a-systems-framework/chapter-2-fb1b1c97ed2">Chapter 2:</a> Systems Thinking</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-46ee0f9e8fed">Chapter 3:</a> Business Objective</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-acca9198d5c4">Chapter 4</a>: Customer Focus</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-5606fe5549cd">Chapter 5</a>: Competitive Focus</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-caef5a55ce5">Chapter 6</a>: Estimating Market Potential/The 4 B’s</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-7-6d70d7d82fe">Chapter 7</a>: Segmentation</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-8-cd67a3a30366">Chapter 8</a>: Targeting</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-9-dda03c5b30b">Chapter 9</a>: Positioning</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-10-6ed681a90fc3">Chapter 10</a>: Product</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-11-2b15ae515308">Chapter 11:</a> Service as Product</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-12-226d545c4557">Chapter 12:</a> Communications</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-13-7deb8a757a1a">Chapter 13</a>: Channels</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-14-75ec5ec787c1">Chapter 14:</a> Pricing</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-15-e660600b8dd1">Chapter 15:</a> Metrics</blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6ed681a90fc3" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/marketing-management-a-systems-framework/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-10-6ed681a90fc3">Marketing Management: A Systems Framework (10)</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/marketing-management-a-systems-framework">Marketing Management: A Systems Framework</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Marketing Management: A Systems Framework (9)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/marketing-management-a-systems-framework/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-9-dda03c5b30b?source=rss-ba31e9c694d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/dda03c5b30b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[marketing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[positioning]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marketing-strategies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[systems-thinking]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Christie Nordhielm PhD]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 29 Nov 2021 15:25:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-02-23T00:54:55.111Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Chapter 9: Positioning</h4><h4>CHRISTIE L. NORDHIELM</h4><p>Georgetown University</p><p>© 2021 Christie L. Nordhielm all rights reserved</p><p><em>This is part 9 in a 15-chapter collection that makes up this book. Enjoy!</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zUGMO470nBW_FkXA1SY8Ow.jpeg" /><figcaption>Figure</figcaption></figure><p>The final step in the STP process is positioning. This is where we transmit our communications strategy to the firm. Traditionally, the positioning statement has been used to deliver this strategy to the advertising agency; however, in the Framework we will disseminate this positioning statement amongst internal and external stakeholders. Everyone in the firm should understand how we plan to position our product, including but not limited to our communications/PR firms, our digital strategy team, product development team, customer service teams, sales team…the list goes on. Everyone connected to delivering on our brand’s promise needs to know what that promise is.</p><p>There are many different approaches to the format of the positioning statement. For many firms this statement is part of a <em>creative brief</em>. This brief commonly includes communications objective, target audience description, brand information including competitive information, brand messaging, and executional considerations. These elements appear throughout the framework; we just finished addressing target audience description; strategic focus and segmentation covers competitive information, and communications objectives and execution will be covered in here and in the communications chapter. We address these elements in distinct steps of the framework to ensure they get proper attention, and to allow ourselves to step back and see how these elements are connected.</p><h4>Positioning: The One Word</h4><p>If we cannot express our positioning in one key word or phrase, we don’t have a focused positioning. When evaluating advertising we look for that one word in the <em>tagline; </em>the line that appears at the end of a commercial or web video, or is featured on a billboard or print ad. The tagline is the creative execution of our strategic positioning. It is also a promise. It is not our job to write the tagline; it is our job to provide the strategic focus necessary to generate and support this promise. We can explore the relationship between tagline and strategy by reviewing the ads presented here. In Figure 1 the tagline for Grain Belt beer is presented directly on the glass: <em>The Friendly Beer. </em>The strategic one word for this ad is <em>sociability.</em> This positioning is clear and unambiguous, not just in the tagline but in the entire visual.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/666/1*8MZqZzFDe1wB7cKfqd1ugQ.png" /><figcaption>Figure 1: Grain Belt Beer</figcaption></figure><p>Not all ads have taglines, but all good ads clearly communicate the one word. Consider the Band-Aid ad in Figure 2. With only the visual, the ad clearly communicates the benefit of <em>strength.</em> With or without words, the power of the visual in our communications cannot be underestimated. In Figure 3 WMD knives delivers the clear benefit communication of <em>sharp</em>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/647/1*x244TGxp0GNlSvotXMf4Kw.png" /><figcaption>Figure 2: Band-Aid</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*AOz3S5ZlIgyLxj8QRJmyaw.png" /><figcaption>Figure 3: WMF Knives</figcaption></figure><p>These types of clear, impactful communications happen when we provide our creative team with a clear, focused positioning strategy. Our positioning strategy is the input, great creative is the output.</p><h4>Constructing the Positioning Statement</h4><p>Knowing the <em>one word </em>is the foundation for our positioning statement. The format of this statement within the framework and specifically designed, referred to as the five-box positioning statement. In the late 1980s, a team at Leo Burnett Advertising led by Robert Shen developed this five-box format for positioning statements (Figure 4). While any positioning statement that contains a good target audience description and communication objective will generally suffice for copy development, the five-box format is a particularly useful technique within the Framework. The five-box tool articulates the exact change in consumers’ beliefs and behaviors we hope to bring about through our marketing efforts, and is made up of the following elements:</p><blockquote><em>Current do:</em> What is our target consumer doing prior to our marketing intervention? Here we express, from our customer’s perspective, what our customer is currently doing with respect to our brand. For example, if we have an acquisition/earn share strategy, the target customer is currently using another brand. In contrast, if we are implementing a retention/stimulate demand strategy, the target customer is currently using our brand.</blockquote><blockquote><em>Current belief:</em> What is the key consumer belief that drives this behavior?</blockquote><blockquote><em>Desired do:</em> What do we want our target customer to do? If, for example, they are not purchasing our brand, we of course want them to purchase. It is important that we set this behavioral goal in a realistic fashion; we cannot expect a consumer to move from non-purchase to complete loyalty after one campaign. For promotional campaigns, we may simply be trying to get them to try our brand, or even make an inquiry.</blockquote><blockquote><em>Desired belief:</em> How will the current belief change in order bring about the desired behavior? The desired belief should represent a realistic movement from the current belief.</blockquote><blockquote><em>Communication Objective:</em> The communication objective is our proposition to the consumer that we believe will move them from their current to desired belief. In contrast to the belief and behavior statements, which are written from the perspective of the consumer, the communication objective is written as a proposition from our brand to the consumer.</blockquote><blockquote><em>Support:</em> We include support points that may be used to enhance the credibility of our consumer proposition. These may include brand features, consumer or expert testimonial, market data, brand, or simply drama. These support points may or may not be used in every execution, but they should be available.</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*wmzGRxsBNZfIEy7E7XI0_Q.png" /><figcaption>Figure 4: 5-Box Positioning Statement</figcaption></figure><p>Finally, we may choose to recommend message focus, either promotion or prevention. We will present these concepts in the communications chapter.</p><p>This format seems simple, but achieving coherence is never as easy as it seems. The good news is we can use it to evaluate and discuss a variety of different options before moving to execution.</p><p>Inherent in the five-box format is the assumption identified above: to change behaviors, we must change beliefs. The behaviors currently held by our target audience, and those that we hope to prompt are (or will be) driven by fundamental beliefs about our product and the other products in our category. Consider the advertisement in Figure 5.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/732/1*UcHiiV-sJ1WwwEXoU_ZkYA.png" /><figcaption>Figure 5: Nivea Men Ad</figcaption></figure><p>A possible 5-box for this communication is presented in Figure 6. We can can see from the brand and the visual that this ad is targeting men. There is no competition mentioned or invoked in this ad, so the competitive focus is to stimulate demand. The customer focus could be retention, depending on our definition of FE; however, if we define the FE as this product Nivea Men Face Cream, then it is an acquisition strategy. We can further deduce, based on the visual and the tagline, that our target audience may have noticed wrinkles, but, until now, has chosen to ignore them. The communication is designed to help them justify the decision to both admit to themselves that they have wrinkles, but also that they can do something about it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Lew4HhkmYPAkeKE8BPczYw.png" /></figure><p>In Figure 7 we see an example of an acquisition/earn share strategic focus from the segment of <em>non-premium vacuum cleaners.</em> This is made clear by the tagline: <em>Vacuums don’t work effectively. Dyson does.</em> This is a clear and straightforward articulation of the strategic focus and the benefit, cleaning effectiveness. The 5-box for this communication is presented in Figure 8. In this 5-box the current belief is that all vacuum cleaners are basically the same, and a potential customer would shop all of them, perhaps choosing based on price or other features. The goal of this positioning strategy is to differentiate Dyson based on superior technology, such that</p><p>consumers will believe that Dyson is better than a regular vacuum cleaner.</p><p>If we are careful to quantify the current and desired beliefs, the five-box format can serve as an additional reality check for our customer and competitive focus. We began this process with our 4 B’s analysis. If we have done our job in segmentation, we have direction for our consumer proposition as well. By looking at the current and desired beliefs and behaviors on the same page we can also evaluate the “distance” between current and desired. Are we trying to accomplish a major belief change or simply a minor change in perception. This distance suggests how much a particular campaign might cost. We must critically evaluate the reasonableness of this distance, thinking about it in terms of cost. It will cost more to convince people to eat at Subway® every single day than it will to convince them to slightly increase the frequency of their visits. Likewise, it will cost more for McDonald’s to convince people that they are the best choice for healthy fast food than it will to reinforce an existing belief that McDonald’s offers convenient, consistent meals at a decent price. Theoretically, almost any positioning strategy could be implemented if enough resources were committed to the task. Our job is to identify the optimal positioning strategy — one that will give us the best return on our marketing dollar over our stated time frame.</p><p>Articulating our Positioning</p><p>The above positioning method is designed to express the marketing strategy into a single, crisp consumer proposition. This message is sometimes called a “brand promise” or “unique selling proposition.” Whatever the term, it is the core concept that will drive all the tactical marketing decisions that we will make.</p><p>The approach described above is to be distinguished from the “formulaic positioning statement” commonly developed by consumer-packaged goods companies for their brands. This approach to positioning calls on the marketer to complete the following statement for their brand: To target audience, brand name delivers key benefit because reason to believe. This formula can be a helpful tool to summarize the decisions we have made thus far in the Framework. The five-box method and its resultant consumer proposition, however, are more valuable as decision-making tools because they consider the current state of the customer as well as the potential future state, and then illustrate what must be done to build a bridge between these two states. The traditional positioning statement, by contrast, is not customer-driven by necessity. The formula can be filled in just as easily by a marketer who has done no customer research as by one who has a deep understanding of the customer. The risk in using this method is that we will lapse into thinking company-out rather than customer-in. We are more likely to engage in <em>wishful marketing</em> if we don’t force ourselves to consider the current beliefs of our target audience. Even if we are in touch with our customers and our formulaic positioning statement is reasonable, the five-box approach still provides additional information on how significant a change in consumer perception we need to achieve (in terms of intensity and number of consumers) to attain our goal.</p><p>The Influence of Positioning on Subsequent Decisions</p><p>Once the consumer proposition is in place, we need to execute the plan. An effective marketing campaign is one in which <em>all</em>elements of the execution, not just the advertising element, align with the positioning statement. For example, if we have chosen to position Range Rover as a high-status vehicle, we will not participate in price promotions that might work against this positioning. We will exercise strict control over our distribution and product development to ensure that all elements of the execution firmly support our chosen strategy. In the chapters that follow, we will address the specifics of product, price, place, and promotion in greater detail. While these elements are discussed in separate chapters, it is important to remember that they are four elements of what must be a unified strategic plan, outlined in the first six boxes of the Framework. We should keep our consumer proposition in mind when making decisions in each of the following chapters: the subsequent decisions we make should not be consistent only with our consumer proposition, but also should help to enhance it — making it almost axiomatic in consumers’ minds.</p><p>Systems Thinking and Positioning</p><p>The benefits of single-minded positioning are myriad. In the short run, message focus helps us to break through clutter to communicate effectively. There are other benefits of message focus that extend to the category as well. In Figure 8 we illustrate these relationships, which are all positive. Single-minded messaging leads to clear customer perceptions, improved satisfaction, increased market share and revenues. These perceptions also improve category satisfaction, willingness to pay, and, ultimately, category size. It is also possible that our focus will drive our competitors to focus their messaging as well, resulting in a clearly differentiated category, where each value proposition of each competitor is easy to understand. Simply put, a well-differentiated category is a profitable, healthy category for all competitors.</p><p>Positioning and the Framework</p><p>The process of segmentation, targeting and positioning is the final strategic stage the Framework. As we advance from here, we add definition to our strategy, first by quantifying our goals, then by more clearly identifying who we will address in our marketing efforts, and what we will communicate to them. Also, with each strategic decision we make, we simplify our executional decision-making. Knowing that we are implementing an acquisition or retention campaign, and are attempting to earn share or stimulate demand, saves us from making these decisions again and again at the execution stage. Instead, we will be able to quickly eliminate options and focus our executional efforts against a single, consistent conception of what we believe to be the strongest possible strategic approach.</p><p>To capture the value of our efforts up to this point, we must adhere to our strategic decisions when making tactical decisions in the subsequent steps of the Framework. If, for example, in the process of executing a strategy, we find ourselves enamored of an earn-share advertising campaign when we previously had committed to a stimulate demand strategy, we should take a step back and revisit our strategic decision-making process to be sure it is sound.</p><p>A key goal of this and any framework is decisional efficiency. This requires strategic and executional discipline with the overarching objective of strategic coherence. Our challenge going forward is to ensure that, as we move into execution, we align our tactics with our positioning and strategy.</p><p><strong>Thanks for reading!</strong></p><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/marketing-management-a-systems-framework/marketing-management-9dcd7af7af82">Chapter 1</a>: Introduction and Ethics</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/marketing-management-a-systems-framework/chapter-2-fb1b1c97ed2">Chapter 2:</a> Systems Thinking</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-46ee0f9e8fed">Chapter 3:</a> Business Objective</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-acca9198d5c4">Chapter 4</a>: Customer Focus</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-5606fe5549cd">Chapter 5</a>: Competitive Focus</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-caef5a55ce5">Chapter 6</a>: Estimating Market Potential/The 4 B’s</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-7-6d70d7d82fe">Chapter 7</a>: Segmentation</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-8-cd67a3a30366">Chapter 8</a>: Targeting</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-9-dda03c5b30b">Chapter 9</a>: Positioning</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-10-6ed681a90fc3">Chapter 10</a>: Product</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-11-2b15ae515308">Chapter 11:</a> Service as Product</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-12-226d545c4557">Chapter 12:</a> Communications</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-13-7deb8a757a1a">Chapter 13</a>: Channels</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-14-75ec5ec787c1">Chapter 14:</a> Pricing</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-15-e660600b8dd1">Chapter 15:</a> Metrics</blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=dda03c5b30b" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/marketing-management-a-systems-framework/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-9-dda03c5b30b">Marketing Management: A Systems Framework (9)</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/marketing-management-a-systems-framework">Marketing Management: A Systems Framework</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Marketing Management: A Systems Framework (8)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/marketing-management-a-systems-framework/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-8-cd67a3a30366?source=rss-ba31e9c694d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/cd67a3a30366</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Christie Nordhielm PhD]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 22 Nov 2021 22:12:39 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-02-23T00:58:01.427Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Chapter 8: Targeting</h4><h4>CHRISTIE L. NORDHIELM</h4><p>Georgetown University</p><p>© 2021 Christie L. Nordhielm all rights reserved</p><p><em>This is part 8 in a 15-chapter collection that makes up this book. Enjoy!</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*6ezAwoO-iw1eEZHTsdgV8w.jpeg" /></figure><p>Targeting is a distinct step from segmentation, a further refinement in the segmentation, targeting and positioning (STP) process. In the segmenting step we identified the two key benefits that will drive our positioning strategy, giving shape to the competitive space in which we plan to operate. In the targeting step we will identify exactly where in that space we will be. In segmentation we were concerned with general perceptions of our brand and competitors; in targeting we will home in on the specifics of the customer we will be seeking to convert. This process will culminate in a detailed description of a specific target audience member in terms of their attitudes and behaviors. It will also set the stage for subsequent decisions as to how to communicate the value that we provide using all four P’s</p><h4>Specifying the Target Audience</h4><p>At this point in the process, we have identified our main and dynamic benefit, collected and assessed market data, and plotted the market. We also know whether our target audience is current customers or competitive brand users and should have an idea about their consumption rates and their perceptions regarding performance and importance of key benefits. This information is the foundation for our target audience description. We already have a basic sketch of our target consumer: for example, if we are pursuing an acquisition/earn share strategy based on service, we know our target audience is competitive brand users who do or could have an interest in convenience. This simple sketch enables us to estimate market potential and give us our core direction. Arguably, this is all we need; if we add more details to our target audience description, we will only make it smaller and limit our potential. So why go further? Because, in this step, we will bring our target audience to life. Our creative team, customer service team, product development team, basically everyone working in the firm, needs to be working to deliver value to a live person.</p><p>Our challenge then, is to bring the target audience to life without letting this description further limit our market potential. To accomplish this, we will think of each description as an <em>exemplar</em>, a description one person we have plucked out of our pool of potential customers with characteristics that suggest a need for our benefit. We are deliberately avoiding the use of the word <em>persona </em>here, as often personas can tend to be stereotypical and unstrategic. Figure 1 illustrates the danger of personas. First off, this description doesn’t use a really name, but instead opts for a nickname that is stereotypical. Second, while the description is detailed in listing attitudes, behaviors, and demographics, this information does not provide us any strategic direction in terms of segmentation benefits. We cannot leverage this description to differentiate our brand. Put another way, this description could be used by any competitor in the market. Finally, this persona would be one in a collection of personas produced, each one describing a distinct group of consumers. To the extent that these different consumers have different needs this will create a fragmented approach in our execution.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_1lSghEGiD_A74K4owENTQ.png" /></figure><p>While many of the elements of our target audience description will be like a persona, we will take a more strategic approach to building this description. Let’s consider Nerdy Nina from the perspective of the Framework. We can presume that this persona has been developed for the book industry; let’s assume we are trying to promote a retail bookstore, and our strategic focus is retention/earn share from Amazon based on the benefit of personalization. Amazon’s primary benefit is convenience. Based on this strategic focus, we know our target customer is a multi-brand user who buys some books from Amazon and others from our store. A well-constructed target audience description will not only give us insight into the target customer, but also into our current or potential relationship with this customer.</p><h4><strong>Bob’s Books Target Audience Description</strong></h4><blockquote>Nina is a 25-year-old software engineer. Because she spends her workday in front of a screen, she relishes anything that is in three dimensions. She tries to hand-write holiday and birthday cards, prefers theatre to the movies, and she and her boyfriend have a modest collection of photography. She likes to use her free time to escape into a great book, especially a real one. Because she is very busy, she sometimes buys e-books from Amazon, and has begun to rely on Amazon’s recommendations to find her next great read. She still relishes going to Bob’s Books, talking with the staff, actually touching the books before she buys them. Bob’s also keeps a record of her past purchases that she can review in the store or online. She and her boyfriend have limited space in their apartment, and she needs to be thoughtful about her book purchases; a physical book is a big commitment to her. She particularly likes the recommendations for books that are posted in-store at Bob’s; she almost always ends up with a great new read when she goes there.</blockquote><p>Note how the description above, while very similar to the persona, has some important differences. In particular, it clearly describes Nina’s relationship with Bob’s books. In fact, by reading this description we can discern the strategic focus and main and dynamic benefits. Perhaps more importantly, when we write additional TA descriptions, we can keep our strategic focus while opening up our demographic horizons. Consider the following description with the same strategy but a different exemplar.</p><p><strong>Bob’s Books Target Audience Description</strong></p><blockquote>Nick is a 58-year-old COO for a medium-sized international packaging firm. He travels frequently and spends long hours on airplanes. This makes him feel disconnected, and he takes steps to make himself feel more grounded. When at home he mows his lawn himself. He uses his flying time to escape the pressures of work, usually by reading. Even though he likes to travel light, he almost always brings a book along for long flights, one he purchased at Bob’s. He loves the personal service at Bob’s, and sometimes orders books online so they will be waiting for him when he returns home. When he is on an extended trip, however, he uses his Kindle. He has tried purchasing books while traveling but he doesn’t always end up with a good choice. To him, there is nothing worse than wasting time on a mediocre book. He has relied on Amazon and e-books increasingly, even though he feels a bit guilty of taking the most convenient route to his next great read.</blockquote><p>The point of these two TA descriptions is that they are for two people who are essentially different, except for their shared love for reading. This is the core commonality that joins them. While we may use different media to reach Nick and Nina, we can leverage the same positioning, product, pricing, and distribution strategies. This enables us to maintain a coherent strategy, one with the greatest chance of resulting in a sustainable competitive advantage.</p><h4>Elements of the Target Audience Description</h4><p>While the specifics of each target audience description may vary widely, most good descriptions have several features in common, including the following:</p><blockquote><em>A name:</em> The TA name should be a real name, not a nickname. The use of nicknames will lead to stereotyping. It is a bad sign when the communications team begins joking or poking fun at the target audience, even in internal meetings. In contrast, when a real name is used, it can become a personal point of reference for people throughout the organization when they are making key executional decisions. We know we have successfully brought the TA to life if we hear someone saying, for example, “what would Jamie Thurstone think of this packaging?”</blockquote><blockquote><em>A habitat:</em> It is important to construct a clear picture of where our target lives and works. The more revealing details the better. For example, a description of a Mini-Cooper customer might reveal that his refrigerator is covered with pieces from a magnetic poetry kit, whereas the Ford Explorer customer has a refrigerator covered with artwork created by each of his three children.</blockquote><blockquote><em>Revealing behaviors:</em> Does she walk the dog or simply let it out in the backyard? Does he keep and file his utility bills or throw them out after they are paid? These types of specific behaviors speak a great deal about the type of customer we are targeting. It is important, however to be sure these behaviors relate in some way to our key benefits.</blockquote><blockquote><em>Consumption:</em> The products and services that our target customer already consumes provide another set of insights into her character. Does she own a hybrid or a Hummer? Does he have a Mac or a Dell?</blockquote><p>It is important to note that a target audience description that is detailed doesn’t necessarily have to be long. In fact, by carefully choosing a few key elements from each of the categories above, the firm can develop an incredibly efficient instrument that enables deep understanding of the target audience.</p><h4>Understanding the Target Customer</h4><p>How do we gain insights about our target customer? The standard issue response to this question is market research. We will delve into this topic in a subsequent chapter; there are myriad tools available to us that we can leverage to establish foundational knowledge about our current and potential customers. To truly develop customer insight, however, we need to build upon this foundation with more personal work. We first need to assess the difference between ourselves and our customers. In many cases the firms we work for sell products that we know and love, and we share that love with our customers. This helps us to generate valuable insights. An expert marketer, however, is one who can generate insights in categories they are not familiar with, and about customers who are dissimilar from themselves.</p><p>How do we generate insights in these cases? We need to explore the culture of the consumers we will be serving. If, for example, we are engaged in marketing across borders in a new an unfamiliar country, we should immerse ourselves in that culture, consume their literature, music, food, and art. The same is true for any consumer group we are seeking to understand. It is one thing to read about a population, it is another thing to experience them first-hand. There is simply no substitute for this immersion. The primary characteristic of a successful marketing professional is <em>curiosity about the consumer.</em> Great marketers share a passion for understanding consumers and the problems they are seeking to solve.</p><p>Finally, we need to remember that we are engaged in the process of moving our customers from one place to another, behaviorally and attitudinally. For existing customers, we want to change our relationship with them from transactional to transformational. For competitive customers, we want to change either their perception of our brand vs. the competition, or their criteria for choose and using products. For customers outside the category, we need to find ways to make them feel comfortable using our product or service. The target audience description is a description of our “before” customer; that is the attitudes and behaviors they hold prior to our marketing campaign. Our goal, always, is to accomplish change.</p><h4>Systems Thinking and Targeting</h4><p><em>Segmentation is finding similarities; fragmentation is finding differences. </em>Figure 2 describes a model where we can see the negative impact of the number of distinct segments we knowingly (or unknowingly) create with our target audience descriptions. Starting at the upper left corner, we see that the as the number of distinct segments identified goes up, the number of distinct benefits we need to promote and deliver on goes up as well. This increases our message fragmentation, which has a negative impact on our differentiation and as differentiation diminishes so does market share. The interesting final segment of this loop is that, if we see our market share decline, we may cast about looking for new customers to serve, creating even more distinct segments and exacerbating the problem.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*rEj7y-ewSk0TlbGoxUDM2Q.png" /></figure><p>There is a simultaneous problematic loop with respect to core competence investment. The more benefits we are promoting, the greater our investment in resources that are not part of our core competence. This will have a negative impact on differentiation and on core competence investment, causing customer satisfaction and market share to decline even further. We can see from this model that if we reduce the number of distinct segments the drivers lead to increased investment in the core, decreased fragmentation, increased differentiation, satisfaction</p><p>It is important to note that this model could also describe a sales-driven organization where each salesperson is customizing their sales message based on customer needs. To the extent these needs are different, we will find ourselves in the same negative feedback loop that is described above.</p><h4>Targeting and the Framework</h4><p>As with all chapters in the framework, Targeting must be considered considering the overall strategy. Our target audience will change depending on our customer focus and competitive focus (see Figure 3). If we are seeking to acquire customers, our target audience will be potential users of either the category (in the case of stimulate demand) or of our brand (in the case of earn share). In contrast, if we are seeking to retain customers, we will be targeting our current users, either loyal users for whom we are attempting to increase value or volume consumption, or multi-brand users for whom we are attempting to increase our share of total category usage. The strategic decisions we make regarding customer focus and competitive should be reflected clearly in our target audience description.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*d_JbcBfvA76TYSa6SehHwg.png" /></figure><p>With the target audience description in hand, we now have a deep understanding of how we will segment that market and who we will talk to. We can now move on to the final stage of STP where we will determine what we say to them.</p><p><strong>Thanks for reading!</strong></p><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/marketing-management-a-systems-framework/marketing-management-9dcd7af7af82">Chapter 1</a>: Introduction and Ethics</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/marketing-management-a-systems-framework/chapter-2-fb1b1c97ed2">Chapter 2:</a> Systems Thinking</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-46ee0f9e8fed">Chapter 3:</a> Business Objective</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-acca9198d5c4">Chapter 4</a>: Customer Focus</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-5606fe5549cd">Chapter 5</a>: Competitive Focus</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-caef5a55ce5">Chapter 6</a>: Estimating Market Potential/The 4 B’s</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-7-6d70d7d82fe">Chapter 7</a>: Segmentation</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-8-cd67a3a30366">Chapter 8</a>: Targeting</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-9-dda03c5b30b">Chapter 9</a>: Positioning</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-10-6ed681a90fc3">Chapter 10</a>: Product</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-11-2b15ae515308">Chapter 11:</a> Service as Product</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-12-226d545c4557">Chapter 12:</a> Communications</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-13-7deb8a757a1a">Chapter 13</a>: Channels</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-14-75ec5ec787c1">Chapter 14:</a> Pricing</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-15-e660600b8dd1">Chapter 15:</a> Metrics</blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=cd67a3a30366" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/marketing-management-a-systems-framework/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-8-cd67a3a30366">Marketing Management: A Systems Framework (8)</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/marketing-management-a-systems-framework">Marketing Management: A Systems Framework</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Marketing Management: A Systems Framework (7)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/marketing-management-a-systems-framework/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-7-6d70d7d82fe?source=rss-ba31e9c694d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6d70d7d82fe</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Christie Nordhielm PhD]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 07 Nov 2021 16:41:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-02-23T01:01:21.081Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Chapter 7: Segmentation</p><h4>CHRISTIE L. NORDHIELM</h4><p>Georgetown University</p><p>© 2021 Christie L. Nordhielm all rights reserved</p><p><em>This is part 7 in a 15-chapter collection that makes up this book. Enjoy!</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*syvzFFe1yyTAaXTO8E971w.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Chapter 7</h3><h4>Segmentation</h4><p>At this stage in the Framework, the process of segmentation, targeting and positioning formally begins. As we have been makingdecisions throughout the initial chapters, we have been laying important groundwork for this process. In fact, the process ofsegmentation begins with the selection of business objective, primary customer focus, and competitive focus. Based on these choices, the potential target audience already has been narrowed substantially. For example, if we have chosen to implement an acquisition/steal share strategy and we have identified our category as business travel, we already know that our target audience is users of a competitive brand (behavioral) who are employed full time (demographic) and who travel for business (behavioral). This narrowing is segmentation. Demographic and behavioral segmentation are just the beginning, however; in this module we will continue the process by developing attitudinal and aspirational segmentation as well. This deeper understanding will allow us to add value to our strategic choices, and to come to a specific description of our target customer in the next module.</p><p>Segmentation, targeting and positioning is commonly referred to as STP, an acronym that reflects the tight interrelationship betweenthe steps in this process. While these interrelationships are important, it is also important to avoid blurring the steps. Segmentation, targeting and positioning are distinct, sequential activities; each is dependent on the previous, and each adds incremental value tothe process. As is true throughout the framework, a bad choice in an initial stage such as segmentation will naturally lead to inappropriate choices in subsequent stages of targeting and positioning. From another perspective, if we believe we are operating with a poor targeting or positioning strategy, this may be a symptom of an incorrect choice at the segmentation step. Thus, we must be cognizant of how our segmentation decision will be manifested in the targeting and the positioning of our offering. Likewise, as we progress into the targeting and positioning phases of the framework, we may wish to revisit our segmentation choices, and update or revise as appropriate.</p><h4>Why Segment a Market?</h4><p>The decision to segment a market should not be made automatically. The best market is usually the biggest market since it has the most potential customers. As we further segment the size of our target population naturally shrinks, and all things being equal, this is a bad thing. Of course, if we segment effectively, all things will not be equal; as the size of our target population shrinks, our probability of converting the members of this population should increase; this is the essence of why we segment a market. An effective segmentation will enable us to strike the optimal balance between market size and market specificity. By optimal balance we mean that combination of size of target population and the probability of converting a member of that population gives us the greatest return on our marketing investment.</p><h4>Segmentation vs Fragmentation</h4><p>The definition of segmentation coined by Philip Kotler is identifying a group of consumers who share at least one characteristic that will make them more responsive to our marketing message. Our objective is to identify the right combination of characteristics. In the age of big data, we have access to overwhelming amounts of information that might be used for segmentation; our challenge is not to find information, but rather to sort through and select the pertinent information. In the digital world it is possible to leverage algorithms to identify behavioral patterns and adjust product offerings and communications at a granular level. This practice is sometimes referred to as mass customization or mass personalization. Some argue these tools should eliminate the need for traditional segmentation. This argument is incorrect for three reasons: first if all competitors in a particular industry implement these types of tools, there will be no differentiation between the different players, and the use of algorithm personalization will simply become a cost of entry for the category. Second, as we customize our product offerings, we increase our cost of doing business and necessarily stray further and further from our core benefit. The market will become commoditized and lose value. Finally, as we increasingly rely on algorithms for finding customers, we lose contact with those customers and reduce our chance of developing insights about them that could inform future product and service innovations that are linked to our core competence.</p><p>Hyper-personalization or customization leads to market fragmentation. Fragmentation is finding differences; segmentation is about finding similarities. By finding differences we increase complexity and confusion; by finding similarities we increase the size of our potential target audience, increase differentiation, and increase market potential for ourselves and for the industry. This is market segmentation, and this is what we will do in this chapter.</p><p>As we go through the process of segmentation (and then targeting), we will naturally enhance our understanding of customer needs and the links between these needs and the core competencies of the firm. In many ways, this is an exploration and a process of uncovering potential connections. As hypotheses regarding likely segmentation and targeting strategies arise, we should consider these as opportunities to conduct valuable research to test these hypotheses. As we move through this exploration it is a good idea to create a market research “wish list,” a prioritized set of research goals that will allow us to develop useful, specific, and actionable knowledge about our customer. A common habit is to conduct broadscale research that generates mountains of generic data with little useful information. This represents an inefficient use of resources when compared to a goal-based research plan that is developed based on sound strategic analysis and hypotheses. By leveraging the model and our own good sense we can generate such a goal-based plan that can substantially improve our understanding and confidence regarding STP choices. An in-depth discussion of this goal-based approach is presented in the Integrate chapter.</p><h4>Segmentation vs Stereotyping</h4><p>Unfortunately, many people, marketing professionals included, do not adequately distinguish between segmentation, a legitimate and important marketing activity, and stereotyping, an unethical and destructive social practice. These two activities are quite different. Within the framework, proper segmentation will reduce<em> </em>our risk of stereotyping. The two key distinctions betweenstereotyping and segmentation are the following:</p><blockquote>Stereotyping is based primarily on physical characteristics; proper segmentation will focus first on attitudes<em>. Commonexamples of stereotypes tend to be based on race, gender, age, and other physical attributes. These attributes are used to draw other conclusions about our potential consumers. To properly segment a market, we should emphasize attitudinal attributes — interest in benefits such as “need for convenience” or “risk aversion.” When we categorize or sort populationsbased on benefits, we may generate groups of people who have a common attitude but are actually quite diverse from a physical standpoint. In most cases, physical characteristics tend to correlate poorly with the intent to buy particular goods or services. Attitudes toward a brand or category benefit, by contrast, tend to have much stronger impact on purchasing behavior</em>.</blockquote><blockquote>Stereotyping presumes we know everything about our target audience; segmentation strategies focus on one or two key attitudes and remain agnostic regarding other attitudes. <em>An essential assumption made by those who think in stereotypical and prejudicial ways is that they believe they can draw complete conclusions regarding an individual’s personality based on one or two physical attributes. The approach to segmentation proposed here involves gaining a deep understanding of one or two key attitudes or benefits sought. All resources devoted to segmentation will focus on these attitudes and our ability to respond to them from a marketing perspective. For creative development purposes, we will at a later point attempt to “paint a picture” of a particular member of our target population; however, this picture is expressly intended to represent one member of this population as opposed to all members. The only important thing about this member is that she strongly expresses the one or two key attitudes on which we have chosen to segment. Beyond that, she can be completely dissimilar to the other members of our intended segment.</em></blockquote><p>From an ethical standpoint, the practice of stereotyping is unacceptable. From a professional standpoint, it is an inefficient and inevitably incorrect practice that will, in the long run, have damaging effects on our brand and corporation.</p><h4>Approaches to Segmentation</h4><p>In undertaking the process of segmentation, marketers generally consider four basic types of segmentation types: demographic, behavioral, attitudinal, and aspirational. In selecting benefits on which to segment, there is an essential trade-off between the ease with which we can collect information on a type of attribute and the competitive advantage that attribute type affords. This relationship is represented in Figure 1. For example, demographic information, such as age, is relatively easy to obtain and reliable; however, it is difficult to establish a competitive advantage simply based on demographics. On the other hand, attitudinal and aspirational data collection is extremely difficult. Our efforts in this area, if strategic, will likely result in a sustainable competitive advantage. We address the specific costs and benefits of these different segmentation types below.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*iFDtJUADtKgD4Lv1Pi2-uA.png" /></figure><h4>Demographic</h4><p>Demographic benefits are those we physically can observe and measure. They include age, gender, educational status, householdsize, income, marital status, etc. Also included here is geographic information, country of origin, population density of hometown, etc. In the B2B (business-to-business) space attributes such as company size and industry are considered. It is an unfortunate habit of marketers to lead their target audience description with demographic benefits. This habit is founded in marketing history and context: demographic information has always been accessible, valid, and reliable. Information on an attribute such as age and address could be obtained through public sources such as the US census or academic research. Demographic data is valid, observable, and, perhaps most importantly, reliable. If we identify a demographic group based on age, for example, we can make specific and accurate predictions about how the age of this group will change over time. For example, marketers have tracked and profited from baby boomers, a very large demographic segment, literally since their birth.</p><p>All these factors make demographic benefits quite appealing. In fact, most first attempts at market segmentation are based on demographics. In most cases, this does not take segmentation far enough — there is usually too much variability within a particular demographic group to build an effective marketing program on this benefit alone. Furthermore, as discussed above, segmenting by demographics can lead to stereotyping, a practice that will be damaging to the brand franchise in the long run. Finally, segmentation strategies based solely on demographics are easy for competitors to duplicate. For example, observing that Reebok has experienced success marketing to women in the early 80s, Nike was able to direct a similar campaign against this demographic target audience and reclaim its lost share.</p><h4>Behavioral</h4><p>Demographics describe physical characteristics; behaviors describe actions. It is quite common, for example, for a firm to segment their customers and potential customers by usage, identifying heavy, medium, light, and non-users. Their goal might be to convert light users to medium users. In order to execute this strategy, however, they would need to ask <em>why</em> people are light users. A person might eat beef only occasionally because their doctor has told them they have heart issues that might be exacerbated by red meat consumption. From a marketing perspective it would be inefficient and ineffective to target these users. If, on the other hand, light users think beef takes too long to prepare, there are several marketing tactics we could engage in to increase usage. The bottom line is that we should never look at behaviors in a vacuum, but rather try to link them to beliefs. This is where marketing insights are generated.</p><p>We may also wish to segment a market based on complementary or associated behaviors. For example, if we are selling car insurance, we might target purchasers of cars, and particularly those that have a safety positioning, such as Volvo and Volkswagen. If we are selling skateboards, we may target people who listen to a certain type of music. If we are promoting a new-to-the-world product such as electric vehicles we may target people who recycle, or alternatively people who always purchase the latest smartphone. These behaviors give us information about the attitudes of our potential target audience, and in some cases, it is a better approach to observe people’s actions than it is to ask them how they feel. The classic example of this is the original segmentation research that was done for the Campbell’s Soup company when they first introduced soup in cans. They found they were selling lots of soup; however, nobody would admit to buying it because they didn’t want to be thought of (or think of themselves as) lazy because they weren’t making soup from scratch. Researchers identified soup consumers by going through garbage in different neighborhoods and counting the discarded cans.</p><p>The pros and cons of using behavioral segmentation benefits may be evaluated relative to their demographic counterparts. Behavioral information is a bit more difficult to collect than demographic information, but technological advances have significantly decreased the cost and increased the reliability of behavioral information. In the digital space third-party aggregators such as Google have caused the accessibility of behavioral data to go up and the cost to go down; however, companies whose core competence is tied to behavioral information, such as Facebook, Spotify, and Amazon, will opt to collect and analyze proprietary information at substantial expense.</p><h4>Attitudinal</h4><p>The use of attitudinal benefits for segmentation purposes is based on a crucial assumption that attitudes drive behaviors. This may seem obvious: a person who reports that they dislike the taste of beer is not likely to purchase beer. In some cases, however, reported attitudes are really more like wishes. For example, in the 1980s a growing percentage of Americans agreed with the statement, “I believe it is important to eat right and exercise.” At the same time, per-capita consumption of salty snacks and dessert items in the United States grew dramatically, even among those groups claiming an interest in healthy lifestyles. This disconnect reflects how difficult it is to measure attitudes, particularly for products that are referred to as virtue or vice products. Consumers will commonly over-express their interest in virtue products such as health clubs, recycling programs, or charitable giving; in contrast, they will under-express their interest in smoking, drinking, and wanting to spend time away from their children.</p><p>The dynamic nature of attitudes is also a challenge for the marketer. Attitudes can change over a period of years, months, weeks, days, or even moments. Observers of focus groups regularly watch one person influence or even reverse the opinion of other group members, regardless of how strongly held that opinion was at the outset.</p><p>All of this seems to make the prospect of segmenting on attitudes quite dim. But the bad news here can also be the good news: what is difficult for will also be difficult for our competitor. Therefore, to the extent that we can develop skills or insights in attitudinal segmentation we will likely realize a sustainable competitive advantage. Brands such as Apple, Coca-Cola, and Harley Davidson (among many others) have realized significant profits by developing and leveraging their skills at segmenting based on attitudes. Nike’s long-time “Just do it” campaign reflected the company’s understanding of its target customers’ attitudes towards not only sports, but also life in general. By segmenting on this attitude towards life, Nike was able to create a differentiated image in consumers’ minds. The simple fact of the matter is that, regardless of the amount of behavioral information available, we will likely always need to evaluate attitudes and aspirations to generate insights.</p><h4>Aspirational</h4><p>Aspirations are attitudes about the future. They include the wishes, hopes, and dreams of our potential and current consumers. We consider these benefits separately here because a significant portion of positioning work is done against segments identified in this way. The way to determine whether a benefit is attitudinal or aspirational is to consider whether the benefits refer to attitudes about right now, or to attitudes about the future. This future can be realistic: a young student may aspire to graduate and become more mature and sophisticated. As a result of this attitude, he may consider switching from the beer he drank in college to sipping scotch from a heavy glass. He would likely consider this a realistic aspiration — since this attitude can be acted upon in the immediate future, this would be considered an aspirational benefit. In contrast, the same student may wish he could spend his days and nights living on the beach, surrounded by beautiful women, and drinking beer. This is a fantasy aspiration that he may satisfy in part by drinking a certain type of beer that evokes this image in his mind. He doesn’t really believe that the beer will land him in this situation, but the fantasy is nonetheless appealing.</p><h4>Note on Mass Personalization and Segmentation</h4><p>The age of Big Data is upon us. We have access to massive quantities of information on the behaviors of <em>specific</em> people; not just what they buy but how fast they drive, when they stop to eat, what temperature they set on their thermostat, and even if they hover their mouse over a particular area of a screen. We have access to algorithms that will find relationships between these data, even when we cannot. This information can theoretically enable us to practice <em>mass personalization:</em> we can identify and fill needs on an individual level. In certain industries, such as digital streaming, this theory has become a reality. In others, the lure of mass personalization has lead firms down a path of increased costs, loss of customer insight and reduced strategic coherence. As with any new and appealing technology, we must endeavor to maintain a rational, evaluative approach to the tools available to us in this space.</p><p>To decide whether we will use behavioral data for mass personalization we should ask ourselves 3 questions:</p><blockquote>1. Is it possible for our firm to produce a distinct, personalized product for our customers in a timely fashion?<br>2. If we do personalize our products, what impact will that have on our margins?<br>3. If we do personalize our products, do we have or will we develop a core competence that helps us to deliver this personalization?</blockquote><p>If the answer to all three of these questions is yes, then we can leverage behavioral data to develop a sustainable competitive advantage. For example, Spotify has a core competence in algorithmic development (question 3) that enables them to customize their product — personalized music recommendations — (question 1) without increasing their cost of delivering the product (question 2). They would then proceed with this mass personalization strategy by segmenting the market to find consumers who do or might value personalized music recommendations. Hence the decision to use big data to do mass personalization is distinct from our segmentation decision. The firm first decides whether to do mass personalization, then chooses how to position the product that results from the personalization. They will still leverage all types of segmentation benefits to complete this process.</p><h4>Relationship of Segmentation Benefits to the Framework</h4><p>As discussed above the different types of benefits should be considered as having varying levels of value for segmentation. While many traditional marketing segmentation studies tend to rely heavily on demographic and behavioral segmentation, the true added value of a good analysis stems from our understanding of attitudinal and aspirational benefits. Within the framework, the recommended approach is to leverage demographic and behavioral information earlier in the framework as a means for assessing the viability of market opportunities (see Figure 2). For example, in our business objective we identify what business we are in; in this process we identify obvious demographic benefits (e.g., we segment by gender to enter the feminine protection market). Moving through the framework, if we have decided to implement an acquisition/earn share strategy we are segmenting based on behaviors (competitive product usage) and may also consider certain demographic characteristics that define these competitive users such as age or income. Finally, at the STP stage, we must build on this information by laying on an understanding of attitudes and aspirations. It is at this point in the process that we are truly engaged in segmentation.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*MT0eqOcfYD1KSFHfYFv1pg.png" /></figure><h4>Main and Dynamic Segmentation Benefits</h4><p>A common approach to market segmentation is to define a segment based on many characteristics. This definition is often developed with the use of analytical tools such as conjoint or cluster analysis, or elaborate algorithms. These tools presumably allow marketers to define their target audience based on a variety of descriptors. Unfortunately, this multi-benefit approach can tend to muddy the waters as opposed to clearing them, landing us up with a fragmented customer based. The wisdom to rely on here is this: fragmentation is finding differences; segmentation is finding similarities. Our job as marketers is to find the largest addressable audience. Each time we add more benefits to our description we do the opposite, shrinking the size of our target audience. In order to avoid this, we need to take a disciplined, strategic approach to segmentation, carefully avoiding the urge to over-describe our target audience.</p><p>To avoid this problem, we will do our initial market plot by prioritizing the benefits sought in our market, identifying the <em>main and dynamic benefit.</em></p><blockquote><em>The </em>main benefit<em> is the most important benefit to consumers in the category that is still a differentiator. This benefit is “owned” by the category leader; that is, the category leader has a core competence that allows them to deliver this benefit better than the other competitors. For example, in the fast-food category the main benefit is convenience. McDonalds, the category leader, has a core competence at training, logistics and site location that enables them to differentiate themselves from the competition on this benefit. If, over time, other competitors are able to “catch up” with McDonalds on delivering convenience, the benefit would still be important, but it would no longer be the main benefit as it would not be differentiating. Hence, the category leader works hard to maintain their point-of-difference on this benefit (perception) and also the importance of this benefit to consumers. For all other competitors this benefit is the </em>cost of entry<em> for the category; that is, they must be able to deliver some measure of convenience in order to compete.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>The </em>dynamic benefit<em> is chosen by the other competitors in the category as their means of convincing consumers to switch to their brand. Just as the main benefit must be tied to the core competence of the category leader, the dynamic benefit must link out to a core competence for each competitor. Staying with the fast-food analogy, Wendy’s may seek to promote the dynamic benefit of freshness, leveraging a skill at sourcing and managing fresh ingredients. They are not as convenient as McDonalds; however, there are a number of customers who are willing to trade a certain amount of convenience for this dynamic benefit. While Wendy’s is promoting freshness, another competitor such as Subway may be promoting health. This benefit must also be tied to a core competence; for example, skill at low fat/nutritional menu development.</em></blockquote><p>In a well differentiated category, each competitor is promoting a unique benefit. The category leader is promoting the main benefit, and each competitor is promoting a unique dynamic benefit.</p><p>The decision as to whether we will emphasize the main or a dynamic benefit was made when we selected our competitive focus. If we chose an <em>earn share</em> competitive focus, we define the category such that we are <em>not</em> the category leader, and then emphasize a dynamic benefit on which we can dominate the category leader, convincing some customers to switch to our brand. Our choice of which dynamic benefit to emphasize will be based on 1) our assessment of customer needs, and 2) our core competencies in delivering on those needs. The main benefit will have been selected by the category leader; in comparing our brand to this leader we automatically will reassure consumers that we can deliver on this main benefit. If we are successful in our development and execution of this strategy, over time, this dynamic benefit may become the main benefit for this category or a new, smaller segment.</p><p>If we chose a <em>stimulate demand</em> competitive focus, we will define the category such that we are the category leader, and then emphasize the main benefit for that category. We focus on keeping this benefit salient for consumers. At the same time, it is up to thecategory leader to continue to explore possible new category benefit — these benefits will be the dynamic benefits that we emphasize/experiment with, not to earn share, but to continue to build and grow the category.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gzRuKpLv4SL0JFXHwdtC-g.png" /></figure><h4>Segmentation Criteria</h4><p>In choosing our segmentation benefits, we will need to consider several factors that reflect the characteristics of the benefit,consumer needs, and company capabilities:</p><h4>Criteria for Selection Benefits</h4><p>Several characteristics of the benefit itself are important during the selection process:</p><blockquote><em>First, it is important that we can </em>measure<em> consumer attitudes toward the benefit easily. Increasingly sophisticated market research tools allow us to access consumer attitudes more and more easily; nonetheless, certain attitudes are still more difficult to measure than others. For example, it would be easier to measure the extent of a consumers’ need for convenience than it would be to measure consumers’ need for self-esteem.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Second, the benefits should generate a target audience that we reasonably believe can be </em>accessed<em>. Again, it likely would be easy to locate and communicate with people with a high need for convenience; however, it might be considerably more difficult to locate people who have a high need for privacy, even though for certain products this might be an excellent segmentation benefit.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Third, the benefit should generate a reasonably </em>substantial<em> target audience. There are likely a few consumers out there who have a strong desire to learn how to play the Kalimba online, but this target might not be sufficiently large to merit a marketing effort toward them.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Of course, we also must consider the </em>expectations<em> of the consumer as we select our potential segmentation benefits. It is important to remember that consumer expectations do not remain fixed; it is therefore necessary to monitor these expectations on an ongoing basis to maintain the relevance of our message. Consumers tend to be highly adaptive, and this is reflected by the fact that consumer desires quickly change to expectations as product categories mature. When laptop computers were first introduced, the dynamic benefit of need for portability reflected the desires of consumers at that time. However, portability quickly became an expected feature of the product, and need for portability became a less compelling segmentation benefit. This distinction between expectations and desires is crucial and will be discussed again in detail in the product chapter.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Finally, and most importantly, </em>company capabilities<em> must be considered when selecting segmentation benefits. There must be a fit between the benefits sought by the target and the core competence of the company. Based on the criteria above, we may have identified need for innovation as a potential segmentation benefit. However, if our company does not possess the skills necessary to establish a competitive advantage vis-à-vis this benefit, then selecting it would be misguided. Wal-Mart selected need for low prices as a segmentation benefit because they possess a core competence in logistics and sourcing that enabled them consistently to deliver lower prices. Without this core competence they would not have been able to succeed with this positioning. For an earn share strategy, selecting a benefit based on our company’s core competence is crucial, because it means our positioning will be defensible. If we choose a dynamic benefit that our company is not unique in its ability to deliver, we will simply demonstrate demand for the benefit, opening the door for another competitor who has or could develop a core competence in delivering this benefit. This is why it is crucial that our segmentation benefits relate to a clearly identified core competence in our firm.</em></blockquote><p>Thus, in looking for our ideal benefit we simultaneously must satisfy a number of conditions — our company should have a competitive advantage in providing this benefit; the benefit should be measurable; there must be a group of customers that care enough about this benefit to purchase our offering because of the benefit; this group must be large enough to reach our business objective; and we must have some way to reach and inform these customers of the benefit we provide.</p><h4>Segmentation: Steps in the Process</h4><p>Segmentation is the first in a three-step process aimed at developing a detailed target audience description and positioning statement. Our goal in the segmentation step is to identify the main and dynamic benefits upon which we will base our marketing strategy. To begin exploring our possible benefits, we need to assess consumer <em>perception</em> of brand performance on each benefit, and the importance of each of these benefits as they make brand <em>evaluations</em>. For illustration purposes in Figure 4 we present consumer perceptions in the hard cider category of each competitor for taste, authenticity, trendiness, number of flavors, healthiness, and price. In this example they are presented on a ten-point scale. These estimates can be developed via basic market research; however, in many mature categories, and in B2B categories, it is quite possible that the firm can produce initial estimates, or at minimum brainstorm which benefits should be considered. In the long run, however, we want to be tracking perception on the top 5 or so benefits in a category.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*VpgBaQDkEZw8aa0fYblJSg.png" /></figure><p>In this example White Claw, the category leader, dominates all competitors on the benefit of authenticity. This suggests that authenticity is the main benefit for this category. In Figure 5 we present importance ratings for these benefits among exclusive users of each brand. On average, authenticity is quite important in the category, and most important for White Claw users. Perception and importance both influence market share, and as marketers we may choose to attempt to influence one or the other of these attitudes. In this example Bud Light Selzer performs well on perceived healthiness; the brand might therefore choose to emphasize the importance of health in order to capture more share. In contrast, Truly performs relatively poorly in terms of perceived taste. They may seek to improve this perception by reformulating and promoting their taste appeal.</p><p>Another way to use these data is to look at how we perform on each benefit versus the importance of this benefit. In Figure 6 we can see that White Claw is perceived to perform poorly on perceived price (that is, they are thought of as “expensive”). However, since the importance of price is low, this is likely not a concern. It is also interesting that White Claw appears to over perform on Flavors — perception exceed importance. This may suggest that they could reduce resources committed to this benefit, and instead heighten focus on maintaining perception and importance of authenticity and taste. The spider chart is a quick an easy way to visualize the importance/perception relationship and form hypotheses; this gives us a hypothesis to test with further research.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*qswewkZ_MK8-qwpvmPCbuA.png" /></figure><p>We can also use a spider chart to visualize competitive importance and identify potential opportunity. In Figure 6, for example, we see that Mikes users highly value flavors; a competitor such as Twisted or Truly might decide to introduce new flavors more aggressively to encourage switching from Mikes.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*d-_CSUfZ5b5SZRpqmV_DZw.png" /></figure><p>By keeping the data we evaluate simple and clear, we can evaluate different possible approaches to segmentation, develop hypotheses, and test these hypotheses with further research. As we move into execution, we can monitor and evaluate our success in a specific manner, as opposed to just tracking marketing investment and sales.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*HH7RF85BpmeqcivJlLG8cQ.png" /></figure><p>Neither the main nor the dynamic benefits are static. They both will change as consumer expectations and competitive activity changes. The longer we can stay with the same benefit positioning, the more profitable we will be. Therefore, we need to remain focused on the key benefits in our category and our ability to deliver.</p><h4>Collecting Customer Data</h4><p>To support the above analysis, we need to collect consumer data on a consistent basis. Historically market research has been project-based: a large quantity of information was collected every one or two years. This made sense when we were collecting demographic information. However, consumer attitudes are dynamic and can change frequently. To adequately assess the market, we need to focus on trends in consumer attitudes. In the digital space this can be done quite easily, particularly for behavioral data. However, all marketers, regardless of industry, should regularly collect attitudinal information; in particular, consumer perceptions of performance of competitors on key benefits, and the importance of these benefits. We can then relate this information to other data, such as sales data and purchase frequency. We can also look at the connections between our marketing activities and changes in perception and importance. By linking this information, we can form a coherent picture of the marketplace, and use this picture to make our marketing strategy and tactics coherent as well. This decision is informed by our strategic focus as described in Figure 8.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*JS1XO_A2uW8H7A-FHXeLTw.png" /></figure><blockquote><em>For an </em>acquisition/earn share strategy<em>, we will talk to competitive brand users, exploring their perceptions of performance on the two segmentation benefits for all competitors. We are also interested in awareness of our brand and competitors.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>For a </em>retention/earn share strategy<em>, we talk to multi-brand users: those consumers who use our brand as well as the brand from which we are seeking to steal share. Here we are most interested collecting perceptions from this consumer regarding the key segmentation benefits for these two products. This information will provide insight into the areas of opportunity toincrease our product’s consumption at the expense of our competitor.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>For a </em>retention/stimulate demand strategy<em>, we will talk to current users of our brand for whom we are seeking to either increase volume of use or average price paid. We are interested in learning why these customers have selected our brand, and what benefits they value, what benefits remain unmet, and where we might be disappointing them. These insights will help us identify ways to enhance the perceived value for our product among these customers.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Finally, for an </em>acquisition/stimulate demand strategy<em>, we talk to potential category users; those customers who might be interested but are not currently participating in this category. In this case it will be important to uncover very fundamental needs that this group has that we can address and understand how they are fulfilling these needs right now.</em></blockquote><p>In all four cases, our primary concern will be to identify customer perceptions and importance on the key potential segmentation benefits we already have selected. We must resist the urge to collect data on many benefits or doing a data mining exercise. Instead, we want to focus on a limited number of potential benefits and collect this data on a consistent basis.</p><h4>Plotting the Market: Mapping the Competitive Space</h4><p>The market plot enables us to look at different strategic scenarios based on different main and dynamic benefits. In the plots below we represent market share by bubble size. In a mature, differentiated market the market leader will appear down and to the right in this plot, representing its dominance on the main benefit. In Figure 9 we have chosen authenticity as the main benefit, since it is “owned” by White Claw. All plots that include this competitive set will show authenticity as the main benefit. The dynamic benefit in this figure represents the most likely benefit for Mikes. In this plot, both Truly and Twisted are dominated by Mikes and White Claw. This suggests that if these remain the two most important benefits and perceptions remain stable, Truly and Twisted will likely continue to lose share or need to rely on heavy promotions. From Mikes perspective, the strategic proposition is <em>Mikes is better than White Claw because it has more/better flavors</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*b8E09BpID5oa1idJrAXLwQ.png" /></figure><p>Figure 10 is a potential plot for Twisted. In this plot we have the same main benefit, because White Claw is still the category leader. Twisted, however, would promote the benefit of trendiness, since their perception is higher on this benefit. Strategically, the proposition for Twisted could be <em>Twisted is better than White Claw because it is hipper</em>, or perhaps <em>Twisted is better than the leading hard ciders because it is hipper. </em>In this second example we have created a segment from the two leading seltzer brands. We will further refine these strategic statements as we move to positioning.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*RpaOmA2FWkDwekbeTPrrgQ.png" /></figure><p>In the plots above we have been considering the hard seltzer category. However, Mikes also has the option of expanding the category to malt beverages, which would bring beer into the competitive set. In this example (Figure 11) the main benefit is price in our dataset, because beer is the category leader in malt beverages, and it is perceived as performing better on price. In this example, White Claw’s proposition would be <em>White Claw is better than beer because it is more authentic. </em>Note that in this example White claw is not targeting one specific brand of beer, but the beer segment. If we are White Claw, and considering going after beer, we would likely want to do more research on the benefits sought in this category.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0fd6TB_kvYjFJJ5Q-WRxzg.png" /></figure><p>The benefit of this plotting exercise is that it allows us to “try on” different strategic options and consider the pros and cons of each. We can then consider whether to do further research to confirm our hypotheses. This simple, visual representation of the market is easy to understand. Perhaps more importantly, it gives us a foundation for a simple, elegant execution of our targeting and positioning. It is often quite difficult to maintain this focused approach during the process of STP; we feel the need to add more information or do a more complex analysis. It is important to remember that, in the end, we will need to execute a communications campaign. The more complicated this campaign is, the more likely it will simply confuse consumers. Simplicity in analysis can lead to simplicity in execution.</p><p>Systems Thinking and Segmentation</p><p>As is true in other areas of life, the link between reality and perception in marketing is not always strong. Very often, a firm that exhibits early success in performing on and promoting a particular benefit will reap more than their fair share of the rewards. This is because our perception may have a negative impact on our competitor’s perception on a particular benefit, regardless of their performance. Consider the case of Volvo, a brand that has positioned itself on safety for many years. In essence, they have come to “own” this benefit, and efforts by other brands to overtake them are hampered. For example, Volkswagen began to beat Volvo in crash test ratings and other objective safety measures in the early 2000’s. They began to promote a safety positioning, since their performance was superior on this benefit. However, Volvo’s long history of promoting safety and their strong perceptions on this benefit had a dampening effect on the relationship between actual safety performance and safety perception for the VW brand. This one negative link, between our brand perception and competitors brand perception on a benefit can have significant and long-term implications.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hjnS8rUXJXzdieIpA4BAOw.png" /></figure><h4>Segmentation and the Systems Framework</h4><p>Segmentation is the first step in the STP process. STP is the crucial link between execution and strategy. If we do this part right our 4 p’s execution will be coherent. This coherence will lead to sustainable competitive advantage.</p><p><strong>Thanks for reading!</strong></p><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/marketing-management-a-systems-framework/marketing-management-9dcd7af7af82">Chapter 1</a>: Introduction and Ethics</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/marketing-management-a-systems-framework/chapter-2-fb1b1c97ed2">Chapter 2:</a> Systems Thinking</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-46ee0f9e8fed">Chapter 3:</a> Business Objective</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-acca9198d5c4">Chapter 4</a>: Customer Focus</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-5606fe5549cd">Chapter 5</a>: Competitive Focus</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-caef5a55ce5">Chapter 6</a>: Estimating Market Potential/The 4 B’s</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-7-6d70d7d82fe">Chapter 7</a>: Segmentation</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-8-cd67a3a30366">Chapter 8</a>: Targeting</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-9-dda03c5b30b">Chapter 9</a>: Positioning</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-10-6ed681a90fc3">Chapter 10</a>: Product</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-11-2b15ae515308">Chapter 11:</a> Service as Product</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-12-226d545c4557">Chapter 12:</a> Communications</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-13-7deb8a757a1a">Chapter 13</a>: Channels</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-14-75ec5ec787c1">Chapter 14:</a> Pricing</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-15-e660600b8dd1">Chapter 15:</a> Metrics</blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6d70d7d82fe" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/marketing-management-a-systems-framework/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-7-6d70d7d82fe">Marketing Management: A Systems Framework (7)</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/marketing-management-a-systems-framework">Marketing Management: A Systems Framework</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Marketing Management: A Systems Framework (6)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/marketing-management-a-systems-framework/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-caef5a55ce5?source=rss-ba31e9c694d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/caef5a55ce5</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Christie Nordhielm PhD]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 01 Nov 2021 18:54:22 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-02-23T01:58:59.690Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Chapter 6: Estimating Market Potential/The 4 B’s</h4><h4>CHRISTIE L. NORDHIELM</h4><p>Georgetown University</p><p>© 2021 Christie L. Nordhielm all rights reserved</p><p><em>This is part 6 in a 15-chapter collection that makes up this book. Enjoy!</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_2_SF_s9YOSyHc2s6ScB0g.png" /></figure><p>One of the most powerful concepts in marketing is Customer Lifetime Value. It is only when we embrace this concept that we fully understand that, as strategic marketers, we are <em>not </em>in the business of selling products, but rather of building customer and brand value. Products are a tool for building that value.</p><h4>CLV</h4><p>By measuring CLV, we begin to achieve strategic coherence, by connecting metrics to actions. CLV is the core metric for customer acquisition and retention decisions. CLV is simply a calculation of the present value of our stream of profit from our customers over some time period. To make this calculation we need to know 1) how much it costs to acquire a customer 2) how long this customer will stay with us, 3) the gross margin they generate in a period, and 4) our cost of capital. The simple formula for CLV is as follows:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/504/1*EXYxq2d_rnBGz65eK9G4xg.png" /></figure><p>Where <em>gm </em>is average gross margin per customer;</p><p><em>r </em>is retention rate (the probability the customer will stay with us into the next period;</p><p><em>i </em>is the annual interest rate or cost of capital;</p><p>AC is the cost to acquire the customer.</p><p>A far simpler model simply multiplies the estimated number of years the customer will stay with us by contribution margin:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/504/1*iKMwP2Oga2UV_5S3xbet0Q.png" /></figure><p>where Y is number of years we estimate the customer will remain with us.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*sN1JOtife_e8XsO5LETgwg.png" /></figure><p>If we hold cost of capital constant, then the key drivers of CLV are cost, price, and retention rate. These three elements are not independent variables, however. The relationship between them is illustrated in Figure 1 as a systems model. Included in this model are the components of contribution per customer: variable cost, price, and number of purchases per period. Contribution and retention rate have a positive impact on CLV, so we will obviously want to use marketing tools to increase these two variables. However, we should first consider the potential systems effects of price changes. Increasing price may have a negative impact on our retention rate, and this impact is often large enough to offset any profit gains. Decreasing costs can also have a negative impact on retention rate if we cut too deeply. For example, if we re-formulate our product with cheaper ingredients, we may negatively impact product quality, or if we cut customer service or sales force, we may cause customer satisfaction levels to drop. In most cases the most sustainable and safest way to increase CLV is by increasing customer retention. As we leverage CLV as a metric, we should carefully consider and monitor the relationships between these variables. Therefore, we must carefully consider (and begin to collect information on) the specific impact of price on these variables.</p><h4>Estimating Demand: The 4 B’s</h4><p>CLV is a measure of individual or average customer value. It is extremely valuable for allocating investments between acquisition and retention and will be used later as an input to segmentation and other executional decisions. At this step in the process, we can begin to look at demand estimation in a more strategic fashion. All too often marketing sales goals are set in a top-down manner based on corporate revenue goals or historical performance. The classic “last year plus 10%” sales goal is often based on everything <em>except </em>marketing strategy. Of course, a strategic approach is the best approach to estimating demand, this is how we will proceed in the framework.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*NMV15Bcp8gEw3C0cBtiHeQ.png" /></figure><p>Naïve marketing models look only at marketing spend and marketing revenue; we will take an increasingly more detailed and informative view. The 4 B’s (Figure 2) is a simple yet powerful approach that first identifies <em>bodies</em> (our target audience), then considers their <em>beliefs</em>; in particular, the core belief that drives <em>behavior</em> relative to our brand. We can then calculate <em>bucks </em>(revenues) based on this behavior. The key is the evaluating the transitions that occur within this model; these are represented in Figure 3, a 4 B’s analysis for White Claw Seltzer used for illustrative purposes. In this Figure we are evaluating an acquisition/stimulate demand strategy, where we are inviting new users to enter the hard seltzer category. Our target bodies are therefore nonusers; that is, people who do not currently drink hard seltzer; we wish to convert some of them to users. To change behaviors, we must first change beliefs. We must hypothesize what current beliefs they might hold that might drive their current behavior (staying out of the category.) leveraging research and market data to identify a key current belief. The types of beliefs we are interested in differ based on strategic focus as illustrated in Figure 4.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Z2DAmsqIf-WWWYN80nyAOA.png" /></figure><p>Once we have identified a key current belief, we consider how we would like this belief to change (to the desired belief). We then estimate the <em>probability of conversion:</em> given the current and desired belief and our marketing resources, how likely is it that we can change this belief? How do we make this estimate? We leverage market research and common sense. As we move through the framework, and finally as we begin to implement our plan, we will update this estimate based on incoming information</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*1yHo48XSuKEgzbt7c9FU2w.png" /></figure><p>For the demand estimation exercise, we repeat this process for the other three strategic quadrants, considering the differences in the bodies, beliefs, and behaviors for each. Each group will have a different set of beliefs and represent a different strategic opportunity requiring different marketing tactics.</p><p><em>Acquisition/Stimulate Demand:</em> As indicated above, companies implementing this strategy face the task of bringing new users to the brand from outside the category. Such companies may be attempting to develop a new category, as was the case with Uber when they first introduced their ride share services. Existing companies also may seek to attract new users to a category; Toyota introduced the Prius brand to bring customers not only to Prius, but also to the hybrid category. Most potential customers weren’t cautious about purchasing a Toyota, but they needed reassurance and support to enter a new segment.</p><p><em>Acquisition/Earn Share:</em> This strategy involves attracting users who are already in the category to switch to our brand from another brand or segment. The good news for this strategy is that these target users are already familiar with the category, so there is no need to build awareness for the category. For example, when Subway entered the fast-food category, they didn’t need to teach potential consumers about the core benefit of fast (convenience.) Instead, they simply made a direct comparison to the category leader, McDonald’s. By making this comparison, they leverage existing awareness. To convince consumers to switch to their brand, they emphasized a key point-of-difference (lower fat) that might be appealing to some McDonald’s customers. Therefore, to estimate potential acquisition/earn share revenue we first identify this single key competitor or segment, then estimate the number of users for that brand or segment. From there it is simply a matter of estimating our likelihood of converting one of these users to our brand.</p><p>Because our target audience for this strategy is made up of competitors’ users, it is important to do a reality check regarding the possibility of competitive response. If we anticipate earning a substantial percentage of competitive users, we should also anticipate a strong competitive reaction. Therefore, it is crucial that our dynamic benefit, the attribute on which we will be earning share, is linked clearly to a core competence for our firm.</p><p><em>Retention/Stimulate Demand:</em> This strategy is implemented when a market leader seeks to stimulate demand through increased volume or increased value. A simple promotional tactic such as increasing the number of cans in a “promotional” case of beer or suggesting a customer “supersize” their order has the objective of increasing average consumption per period. Hence, for this strategy we are not seeking to convert new customers, but rather convert the behavior of current customers. To estimate revenues for this option we simply estimate how many units per period our customer currently consumes and the amount by which we believe we can increase this consumption through our marketing efforts.</p><p>Instead of increasing purchase volume, we may seek to increase average price paid. In most cases this is accomplished by increasing the perceived value of our product and then capturing that value via a product coupled with a price increase. Our crucial estimate in this case is the amount by which we believe we can increase our price. This approach is quite often the hallmark of a true market leader.</p><p><em>Retention/Earn Share:</em> This final strategic option is generally pursued by number two brands in categories where consumers choose from what is commonly referred to as a “brand set.” For example, a consumer may eat Kellogg’s Corn Flakes four times a week and Post Grape-Nuts once per week. Post may elect to emphasize the superior healthfulness of Grape-Nuts vs. Corn Flakes to increase the number of servings per week to two or three. The key factor distinguishing this strategy from an acquisition/stimulate demand strategy is that: 1) our target customers already consume our brand, and 2) we are seeking to convince them to increase consumption specifically at the expense of another brand they currently use. Just as with acquisition/earn share, we will invoke a direct comparison, emphasizing the benefit of increasing consumption of our brand or perhaps becoming an exclusive user of our brand. This strategy is quite common in business-to-business (B2B) marketing, where purchasers may use several suppliers to control pricing.</p><h4>Competitive Focus and the Framework</h4><p>One of the great benefits of disciplined strategic thinking is that it affords us greater opportunities for learning. In the case of competitive focus, it is important to evaluate our results relative to our strategic goals, not just our sales goals. To keep the strategy coherent, we should check our results after we have run our marketing plan. If we have implemented an earn share strategy, we should see the bulk of our volume coming from our key competitor, and we should obtain feedback from consumers indicating that they selected our brand because it dominated our competitor on the identified, dynamic benefit. If we find, instead, that the reason consumers selected our brand was because our competitor was out-of-stock, we cannot attribute that sale to our strategy. The good luck we experienced by achieving our sales goals is sometime just that: good luck; it is fortunate but not strategic, and therefore cannot be replicated. This is where the iterative structure of the framework becomes so valuable. If we find that our current strategy is not the driving force behind our new customers, we can further investigate the true value that those customers see in our product. Then, we can use this information to refine and improve our analysis, potentially choosing a different go-to-market approach. By carefully analyzing our options and selecting the appropriate strategy, using research where necessary to confirm our hypotheses, we can develop a clear, single-minded strategy. Such a strategy will enable us to proceed through subsequent chapters in an efficient and effective manner.</p><p><strong>Thanks for reading!</strong></p><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/marketing-management-a-systems-framework/marketing-management-9dcd7af7af82">Chapter 1</a>: Introduction and Ethics</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/marketing-management-a-systems-framework/chapter-2-fb1b1c97ed2">Chapter 2:</a> Systems Thinking</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-46ee0f9e8fed">Chapter 3:</a> Business Objective</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-acca9198d5c4">Chapter 4</a>: Customer Focus</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-5606fe5549cd">Chapter 5</a>: Competitive Focus</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-caef5a55ce5">Chapter 6</a>: Estimating Market Potential/The 4 B’s</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-7-6d70d7d82fe">Chapter 7</a>: Segmentation</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-8-cd67a3a30366">Chapter 8</a>: Targeting</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-9-dda03c5b30b">Chapter 9</a>: Positioning</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-10-6ed681a90fc3">Chapter 10</a>: Product</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-11-2b15ae515308">Chapter 11:</a> Service as Product</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-12-226d545c4557">Chapter 12:</a> Communications</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-13-7deb8a757a1a">Chapter 13</a>: Channels</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-14-75ec5ec787c1">Chapter 14:</a> Pricing</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@christienordhielm/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-15-e660600b8dd1">Chapter 15:</a> Metrics</blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=caef5a55ce5" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/marketing-management-a-systems-framework/marketing-management-a-systems-framework-caef5a55ce5">Marketing Management: A Systems Framework (6)</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/marketing-management-a-systems-framework">Marketing Management: A Systems Framework</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>