<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Christine Berry on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Christine Berry on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@christinejaneberry?source=rss-be04037682a0------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 02:25:15 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@christinejaneberry/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[An argument for hope — an open letter to the post-Corbyn left]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@christinejaneberry/an-argument-for-hope-an-open-letter-to-the-post-corbyn-left-e1e78cb775b8?source=rss-be04037682a0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e1e78cb775b8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[labour-party]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hope]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[keir-starmer]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jeremy-corbyn]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[uk-politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Christine Berry]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 13 Aug 2020 12:23:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-08-13T12:42:39.013Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>An argument for hope — an open letter to the post-Corbyn left</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*MK7F-ffpmOC9tiEHBaTQEg.jpeg" /><figcaption>My son Rory at TWT 2019 in Brighton. Literally the poster child for hope.</figcaption></figure><p>If you’re on the left — at least, if you’re anything like me — you’re probably feeling a lot of feelings at the moment. These may include the usual ones that have come to define 2020 — anxiety about the virus, financial worries, exhaustion with lockdown, many varieties of bereavement and loss — but perhaps also some that are particular to this political moment.</p><p>If we do not trust the government to manage the pandemic, we may be living with a heightened sense of fear and vulnerability. This is exacerbated at moments when we don’t feel that anyone in public life is voicing these fears (as when Starmer “welcomed” the easing of lockdown). Over the last six months many Labour activists will also have experienced burn-out and grief following the 2019 election result; bitterness and resentment at the revelations in the ‘Labour Leaks’ report; disappointment and despair at the turn taken by the Starmer leadership.</p><p>On top of all this, we may have internalised the narrative that crisis equals opportunity for change, that we must not screw this one up like we did in 2008. Having just been spat out of a gruelling ‘once-in-a-generation’ election campaign, we have been flung straight into a ‘once-in-a-generation’ crisis. Friends working in think tanks and organising roles have told me of intense feelings of pressure, guilt and overwhelm attached to this.</p><p>None of this is to imply that people on the left are somehow uniquely suffering or uniquely to be pitied: the pandemic is taking a huge toll on mental health for almost everyone, most of all for those who face destitution or are engaged in risky frontline work. The point of acknowledging these emotions is to recognise that they colour our reactions to politics — in ways that might be distorting or counter-productive — and to work out how we can process them better.</p><p>One of the cruel twists of lockdown has been to make it almost impossible to collectively process our feelings. It’s been hard to see people we love and trust, to chat about politics or our personal lives with them down the pub. It’s been impossible to gather, reflect and organise in large groups. Instead, we sit at home stewing in a pool of our own anxiety and depression, or getting lost in a Twitter bubble that endlessly reflects it back at us like some gruesome hall of mirrors. People we follow lash out increasingly wildly at the government, the Labour Party, each other and the world in general. Maybe we’ve been doing the same. Stuck in a digital echo chamber of other angry, depressed people, we can start to feel paralysed, increasingly convinced that everything is hopeless.</p><p>I know it’s not just me who’s been through this wringer repeatedly in the last six months. I’ve heard the same stories from friends and colleagues — and I’ve seen the frequent degeneration of left Twitter into cries of rage and recrimination. But we need to find a way past this. It’s not helping us and it’s certainly not helping the world.</p><p>The point is not that we should bury these feelings, or that it’s wrong to feel them. The point is that acting out of unprocessed rage, grief or anxiety is rarely a good idea. As psychologist and Buddhist teacher Tara Brach puts it, we can get stuck in a “<a href="https://www.npr.org/transcripts/802347757?t=1595410081557">limbic hijack</a>” that stops us from seeing and thinking clearly or acting wisely and effectively. We need to listen to our feelings, not be submerged by them — and find space to ask the question that really matters: where do we go from here?</p><p>To answer this question, we need to reflect more deeply both on the lessons of the Corbyn era and on possible routes to change in the post-Corbyn era. We also need to distinguish between the things we can control and the things we can’t — and refocus our energies on the former.</p><p><strong>Losing the rose tinted glasses: an honest assessment of the Corbyn years</strong></p><p>It’s easy to fixate on the actions of saboteurs in Labour HQ, on the few thousand votes that lost Labour the 2017 election. It’s tempting to dwell on the alternate universe where we could have had a radical Labour government, where the pandemic wasn’t being murderously mismanaged by Johnson and Cummings. But here’s the thing: this alternate universe never really existed.</p><p>Yes, you can tell this version of history, and it has some truth to it. But it’s also true that there were deep weaknesses in the Corbynite movement which contributed to its inability to take power, and which meant that had it done so, it would still have faced an uphill struggle to deliver radical change. Joe Guinan and I documented many of these issues in our book <em>People Get Ready!</em></p><p>The Corbyn project was an attempt to build the car whilst driving it. It was trying to back-fill a generational deficit in left thinking and left organising. These efforts focused largely — perhaps too much — on the need to flesh out a policy agenda; there was not time to lay the deep roots in communities that would have been needed for these ideas to flourish. This generational deficit extended to leadership, too: this is why the movement ended up being represented by an unlikely septuagenarian survivor of the Blair years, carrying a lifetime’s political baggage — someone who had never expected or aspired to high office. Last but not least, it extended to basic institutional knowledge of how to run stuff effectively: the internal operation <em>was </em>frequently shambolic. When we take a sober look at the last five years, it’s hardly surprising that Labour didn’t make it into government: what’s surprising, astonishing even, is that it got as close as it did.</p><p>What’s more, even if Labour had taken power, we wouldn’t have been in the sunlit uplands. Resistance from many powerful quarters would have made the ship very difficult to steer. We are deluding ourselves if we think that the advent of a global pandemic would have made this easier rather than harder, or that a Corbyn government could have avoided the mass suffering we are now witnessing. For one thing, many of the reasons covid-19 has hit the UK so hard — austerity, precarious work, a trashed social safety net — stretch back decades. There is no universe in which a radical Labour government could have resolved these problems overnight — especially one so underprepared to govern. But it would sure as hell have been blamed for the fallout — by a hostile media and a Conservative Party that would not have pulled its punches in the name of ‘responsible opposition’. This could easily have been the iceberg which sank progressive hopes for another generation.</p><p>Finally, it’s worth remembering that Corbyn was given a free pass by activists on many of the things that Starmer is now berated for — simply because they trusted the former and do not trust the latter. Starmer’s interview on Black Lives Matter was awful, but Corbyn promised more police on the beat — using anti-austerity politics to appeal to socially conservative attitudes rather than challenging them. Starmer was roundly abused for not committing to the party’s 2030 decarbonisation target, but neither did Corbyn: the policy was pushed and passed by members and did not make it into the 2019 manifesto (reportedly because of union opposition). Yes, of course the left must hold Starmer to account. But we can only do this effectively if we’re honest about what really marks him out from Corbyn — not by holding him up against a mythical and increasingly idealised version of the latter.</p><p>I’ve spent a bit of time on this counterfactual because I think we all need to let go of the fantasy version in our heads, the endless dwelling on ‘what might have been’, the idea that we could have had the best of all possible worlds — and face up to the reality. Only then can we move forward, clear-eyed about the strengths and weaknesses of our movement and the lessons to be learned from the last five years. For me, a key one is that we need to recognise the limits of party politics and do much more to be present on the ground in communities, making our politics relevant to people’s everyday lives and struggles, making it something we build together — and counteracting the messages pushed by a hostile media.</p><p><strong>Labour’s future: grounds for despair and grounds for hope</strong></p><p>Of course, the fact that the movement lost is not the only grounds for despair. What has really hit people hard is how quickly the waters appeared to close over this political moment: how soon Starmer’s promises to unify and to keep Labour’s ‘popular socialist platform’ seemed to go under the bus; how willing he has been to alienate Labour’s base and how plainly galvanising a mass movement is not part of his strategy. Beyond Labour itself, the political establishment has eagerly embraced a new consensus that everything about Corbynism was a dead end and we can go back to politics as usual — even as Rishi Sunak raids the 2019 manifesto and the pandemic turns politics upside down. If Corbynism could now be seen as a transitional phenomenon that had palpably shifted the dial and left a lasting legacy, that might be easier to swallow. Instead, many are left feeling that it was all for nothing.</p><p>Even more emotionally challenging, having had a place in mainstream politics for the first time ever, many feel unceremoniously cast back into the wilderness. As one friend said to me, “There’s a palpable sense of relief that they don’t have to listen to us any more.” It’s now clear that, for Corbyn’s most vociferous opponents, it’s not enough that the left is no longer in charge: they must be hounded out of public life altogether. Socialism must become a dirty word once again. Never very interested in understanding the roots of the Corbyn surge, in their haste to consign him to the dustbin of history the Labour right are treating an entire generation as collateral damage — including some of the most exciting social movements and most intelligent thinkers I’ve ever encountered.</p><p>There are a few ways of responding to all this. One is to lapse back into despair and oppositionism. We can retreat into the comfort of moral superiority combined with political impotence, that — as Rebecca Solnit points out — asks less of us and is less emotionally demanding than hope. This has been the left’s default setting for most of my life. Indeed, for many of us, it was not until after the 2017 election — in retrospect, the high water mark of Corbynism — that we genuinely <a href="https://www.christineberry.net/2017/06/first-thoughts-on-the-election-result/">allowed ourselves to believe that it might be possible to win</a>, and to think seriously about strategy in this light. It’s this taste of hope that makes the crash back down to earth so hard for people to take. But it’s that spirit we must try and hold on to.</p><p>There’s no doubt about it — despair is tempting. But it’s not helpful. Despair risks turning us all into angry armchair Twitter warriors. If there’s no longer anything at stake, why not vent your rage at Starmer and his shadow cabinet, denouncing them as a shower of ‘red Tories’? The problem is that this produces a vicious cycle: in the nature of social media, the main audience for this is actually other people on our own side, who in turn feel increasingly powerless and despairing. The left shrinks down to an embittered and isolated sect that nobody else listens to. It begins to turn inward and eat itself: left splits and in-fighting have escalated since the election, as the <a href="https://www.christineberry.net/2020/01/the-post-election-woes-of-the-labour-left/">uneasy coalitions held together by Corbyn begin to break apart again</a>. Much of the energy that a year ago was being used to chart a new future is now being sunk into angry, backward-looking factional battles with the Labour right. I understand the logic of this: the left is under existential attack and feels it must defend itself. But I worry that it is backing us into a corner.</p><p>As Solnit argues, though, there’s another way to respond: “Hope locates itself in the premises that we don’t know what will happen and that in the spaciousness of uncertainty is room to act.” We can recognise that we’re still in the eye of the storm: we don’t have a vantage point from which to judge the ultimate impact of Corbynism. We can say, as Zhou En-Lai famously did in relation to the French revolution, “too soon to tell”. We can pick ourselves up, dust ourselves off and do our best to identify the opportunities to make change in the here and now. The amazing things happening around the world as a result of Black Lives Matter prove that those opportunities are still there.</p><p>This is not to deny that the turn in Labour’s strategy over recent months has been frustrating and demoralising. I’m not here to try and defend it — in fact, defending a particular take on Starmerism isn’t really the main point of this piece. My real point is that we just don’t know yet. Of course, it’s clear that Starmerism will have serious political limits. But I don’t think those limits have really been tested yet, let alone reached. To dismiss the potential for pressure and engagement to push Labour to the left seems to me a self-fulfilling prophecy. I worry that many on the left — influenced by the gloomy picture we’re absorbing from social media — are prematurely giving up on the new conjuncture as entirely without possibility, and thus giving up on our own power to influence it.</p><p>Some are inclined to characterise the Starmer leadership as a return to unreconstructed Blairism. I don’t think this is particularly helpful. It simply isn’t yet clear what Starmer stands for. Perhaps he doesn’t even know himself. To be sure, the Labour right are doing their level best to step into the vacuum — but their victory is not a foregone conclusion. The internal debate is still raging — there are those pushing from inside for the party to be bolder and to engage more seriously with the left. Even the <a href="https://www.labourtogether.uk/review">Labour Together report</a> concluded that the party must retain its economic radicalism in order to win. But this debate cannot be contested if its left pole becomes fragmented, bitter and demoralised — still less if merely engaging in that debate is enough to get you loudly denounced as a shill who’s probably angling for a job in HQ.</p><p>For me, the big issue with the Starmer leadership is not policy but politics. The problem isn’t that they are right-wing ideologues. It’s that they are committed to trying to game the UK’s increasingly decaying political system, rather than finding ways to change it. They don’t believe it is possible to win by challenging powerful interests, so they try to get them on side: hence their weakness over tenants’ rights during lockdown. They don’t believe it is possible to win by changing the national discourse on race and migration, so they try to avoid it: hence their cowardice over refugees and Black Lives Matter. They don’t believe it is possible to win by neutralising the hostile media that destroyed Corbyn’s reputation, so they try to appease it: hence the reluctance to say anything remotely controversial.</p><p>Starmer does not have a clear political project in the service of which he is willing to expend political capital. Indeed, he appears convinced that Corbyn has destroyed Labour’s political capital and that his key task for the next few years is to rebuild it — not by re-rooting the party in communities and investing in participatory politics, but by making it acceptable to established opinion. What he will do after that is anyone’s guess. Of course, <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2020/jul/14/labour-defeat-super-rich-conservatives-calling-higher-taxes-starmer">as I’ve argued before</a>, there are path-dependencies in this strategy that will close down possibilities later. But the grounds for hope is that, unlike deeply-held ideological commitments, political strategies can change. Labour under Starmer is no longer interested in being the leading edge of change. But that does not mean they will not ultimately follow where others lead. If they sense the balance of power shifting, their strategy may shift too. And this is really where the possibility and the power of the left might lie.</p><p><strong>Beyond Labourism: making the political weather</strong></p><p>Realising this possibility requires us to reorient our political compasses beyond Labour. Again, it’s easy to forget, but many of those from my generation and younger who rallied behind Corbyn had previously never engaged much with party politics at all. The Corbyn years were a necessary corrective to a ‘movementist’ mode of organising that was not serious enough about the need to win institutional power — what Srnicek and Williams called ‘folk politics’. But we now need to recalibrate again. In <em>People Get Ready!</em>, Joe Guinan and I warned that “there is a danger that activists swing from an outright rejection of electoral politics and leadership figures to a wholesale and uncritical investment in them”. Many who never identified with the Labour Party before 2015 now identify with it so closely that, when the party no longer seems like a viable route to radical change, they begin to lose hope that such change is possible at all.</p><p>But here’s the thing: working within the Labour Party never was enough. In fact, having a Labour leadership so closely aligned with social movements tended to mask this fact in ways that ultimately contributed to its defeat. It blurred the distinction between the role of political parties and the role of social movements. It encouraged the illusion that our job was simply to get Corbyn into Downing Street, and the rest would take care of itself. That illusion was, ironically, one of the reasons that Corbyn’s Labour was ultimately unable to get into government in the first place. We had not done enough of the deeper groundwork needed to achieve truly transformative shifts in wealth and power, or to change the ‘common sense’ of a nation’s politics.</p><p>Of course, the leadership did successfully shift the window of political possibility on many issues, from austerity to public ownership of utilities. But it became its own vanguard — and this was part of its downfall. The starkest example of this was the policy of free public broadband — which came out of the blue in the 2019 manifesto, which nobody had been calling for and which did not sit within a clear story about the kind of change the country needed. Manifestos are not the place for flying kites. A thriving left ecosystem requires strong social movements to act as the restless leading edge of change, constantly pushing politics to the left, and creating space that political parties step into — whether enthusiastically or reluctantly. Labour’s drift back towards the centre should focus minds on the need to build these sources of social power — but this would have been our key task anyway. It changes everything, but it also changes nothing.</p><p>The Corbyn project was trying to bring about a fundamental paradigm shift in UK politics. The core argument of <em>People Get Ready! </em>was that history shows these shifts are always deeper than one political party’s platform. Their roots lie in new sources of power that begin to displace old interests; new economic realities that begin to displace old structures; new ideas spreading through academia and the public discourse that begin to displace old assumptions. As Solnit argues, sometimes legal and political changes are really just “ratifying” these deeper shifts going on beneath the surface. We also argued that Corbynism was at its best a project of radical democracy — and by definition, radical democracy cannot simply be bestowed from the top down. It needs to be built and demanded from the bottom up.</p><p>The grounds for hope is that the left <em>has </em>improved its capacity to do these things during the last five years. The ecosystem of left think tanks is much stronger and more radical than it was even a few years ago. Meanwhile, other wings of the Labour Party have invested little time or energy in developing new ideas: they were far too busy waging war on Corbyn. The climate movement, the private renters’ movement, the anti-racist movement — all have helped make the political weather and continue to do so. One of the lessons of 2019’s defeat is that we need to double down on organising and participatory policy — building a politics that is genuinely by and with those it is supposed to be for — whilst also contesting the debate within powerful institutions.</p><p>Much of the most urgent organising that will be done in the coming months has nothing to do with national politics at all, but will be focussed on directly mitigating the impacts of the crisis: eviction resistance, workplace organising, mutual aid. The growth of union membership during the pandemic is a key opportunity to reverse decades of decline in workers’ power. A burgeoning anti-racist movement could create space to change the conversation about national identity. There may also be opportunities to work with progressive local authorities who are willing to step into the leadership vacuum and spearhead imaginative economic recovery strategies. This is where the real action is likely to be over the next five years: building power, building alternatives and shaping the debate. Perhaps, if we nurture the roots of change, national politics will eventually catch up.</p><p><strong>Where do we go from here?</strong></p><p>Seeing this landscape for what it is, we can all make our choices about the role we want to try and play. Some will choose to stay in the Labour party and provide a counterweight to the right. This is a legitimate choice and an important job. Some will choose to leave and focus their energy on social movements or community organising. This is also a legitimate choice and an important job. There is very little point in wasting time arguing about which of these is ‘right’, why one is woefully naïve and the other is brilliantly strategic. It is surely obvious that any serious strategy for social change in the UK requires both. What matters is that we get on with the work.</p><p>This means we need to recognise and process the storm of emotions many of us are feeling about politics right now, so that we can stop acting them out. Before sending that angry tweet, we need to ask ourselves: is it true? Is it necessary? Is it kind? And, most importantly, could I be doing something more useful with this energy?</p><p>We need to spend less time fixating on what the Labour leadership is or isn’t doing, and more time working out what <em>we </em>are going to do. We need to spend less time adding to the pool of toxic emotions our political allies are already drowning in, and more time supporting each other to take care of ourselves and find a way through this grim time. We need to spend less time lashing out and more time building. We need to find projects and spaces, whatever they are, that nourish us rather than depleting us — that give us back our sense of hope and agency so that we can move forward. Things like <a href="https://theworldtransformed.org/">The World Transformed</a> and John McDonnell’s <a href="https://claimthefuture.today/">Claim the Future</a> will hopefully help with this.</p><p>It might be hard to see it right now, but the UK left <em>is </em>still stronger than it was five years ago — and will remain so if we can find it in ourselves to act out of hope rather than rage. In decades to come, perhaps Corbynism <em>will </em>look like a transitional phenomenon on the way to the era-defining change we need. We have to hope so, and act as though it is true. What else is there to do?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e1e78cb775b8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>