<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Roger Wilson on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Roger Wilson on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@civicdec?source=rss-ed2e7921460e------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 14:00:18 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@civicdec/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[United Breaks Heads…And Guitars; Three Lessons about News Judgment]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@civicdec/united-breaks-heads-and-guitars-three-lessons-about-news-judgment-72b5876a4846?source=rss-ed2e7921460e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/72b5876a4846</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[journalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[medium]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Roger Wilson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 28 Apr 2017 18:57:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-04-28T18:57:04.751Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>United Breaks Heads…And Guitars; Three Lessons about News Judgment</p><p>(Originally published on the “<a href="http://bit.ly/PracticallySpeaking">Practically Speaking</a>” blog</p><p>Anybody who has been close to a news story knows that <strong>“news judgments” are often wrong</strong>. Making news <strong>judgments more explicit</strong> might be a step toward making them better. The April 9th incident Dr. David Dao being dragged off a full United flight holds <strong>key lesson</strong>s about news judgment.</p><h4>Conclusion First: Bottom Line Up-Front</h4><p>Current norms of journalism<strong> leave news consumers guessing </strong>whether outright <strong>omissions</strong> and varying <strong>weightings of facts</strong> are deliberate and motivated by <strong>reason</strong>, deliberate and motivated by an interest in <strong>spin</strong>, or not deliberate and simply reflecting <strong>ignorance</strong>. This problem is especially evident when big stories like “<strong>United Breaks Heads</strong>” are breaking. Consumers could be<strong> better served</strong> by journalism that tells them the <strong>reporter’s conclusion up-front</strong> followed by supporting details and links to the depth of the journalist’s background work.</p><h4>Lesson One: Judgment Ain’t Fact — Even When It is Good Judgment</h4><p>One sentence in a <a href="http://bit.ly/Uberti-United"><strong>thought-provoking post</strong></a> on the United story by David Uberti, staff writer for the <strong><em>Columbia Journalism Review</em></strong>, stopped me cold, “The breadth of the <em>Courier-Journal</em>’s coverage doesn’t absolve it from the fact that Dao’s criminal history is irrelevant to this bizarre episode.” Uberti’s piece otherwise highlights <em>The Louisville Courier-Journal </em>Executive Editor Joel Christopher‘s points in defense of <em>The Courier-Journal’s </em>widely criticized “breaking” coverage of Dao’s “troubled past.”</p><p>Uberti’s “fact” is a figure of speech. But those who chose not to report Dao’s past left too much room for “alternative facts” in modern parlance. Paranoid competing stories based on “alternative facts” quickly sprung up. It is Uberti’s reasoned <strong><em>judgment</em></strong>, which he further defended in correspondence with me, that there was no evidence that Dao somehow contributed to the escalation or had any inclination toward violence. Additionally Uberti expressed the concern that a news subject’s past could have unfair consequences for the subject and <strong>“shade the current moment.”</strong></p><p>“There must be <strong>something more to this story</strong>,” was a natural news consumer reaction to United Breaks Heads. Dao’s prior experience with authorities is a reasonable line of inquiry. What Uberti is really saying is that <strong><em>in his judgment</em></strong>, United’s, and more generally the airline industry’s rules and norms are what <strong>deserve the attention of the news consumer</strong> (Oddly, the conduct of the security officers in this incident has been judged to be of secondary importance).</p><h4>Lesson Two: Journalists are in the Belief Business</h4><p><strong>News judgment renders facts useful</strong> to news consumers. News consumers need to <strong>know what to think</strong> about events of the day. Collecting facts is a small part of the value that journalism provides.</p><p>News judgment <strong>weights facts to assemble a coherent story</strong>. News stories <strong>influence beliefs</strong> about matters of fact and values. Beliefs are a key <strong>element of political economics</strong>. Beliefs are useful to all believers and to those who seek to influence the beliefs of others (grammatically dubious, but I might call the later <strong>“believees”</strong>).</p><p><strong>Beliefs are not neutral</strong>. The power of the fourth estate is derived from <strong>people’s thirst for information</strong> independent of the coercive powers of government and the productive powers of economic entities (in this case <strong><em>combining forces</em> </strong>to batter a hapless passenger).</p><p>The <strong>passenger lives matter</strong> moment (see my blog about <a href="http://bit.ly/BlankLivesMatter"><strong>blank lives matter</strong></a>) was a <strong>teachable moment.</strong> People <strong>saw themselves</strong> in the images of Dr. Dao being dragged down the aircraft aisle, It was an <strong>opportunity for the fourth estate to assert its power</strong>. Personally, I didn’t feel Dao’s past “shaded the current moment” as the story unfolded. Others experienced the story differently. I did wonder why so many reports failed to observe what I thought were the most egregious facts, available from some of the earliest reports.</p><h4>Lesson Three: A Hot Story Requires More Explicit Judgments Not Less</h4><p>The trope of how <strong>David can slay Goliath with social media</strong> was probably one of the reasons the <strong>Journalist-Twitterati </strong>jumped on<strong> United Breaks Heads. </strong>The interest generated by social media postings of witnesses evoked the oft-repeated story of “<a href="http://bit.ly/United_Breaks_History"><strong>United Breaks Guitars</strong>,</a>” a great publicity stunt that musician Dave Carroll and his band, Sons of Maxwell, turned into a <strong>viral cyclone</strong> in 2009. People seem to dearly love the notion that social media in the hands of the masses empowers the little guy. What “United Breaks Guitars” actually proves is that <strong>the secret to going viral is to get picked up by big media</strong>.</p><p>United Breaks Heads is a <strong>case study</strong> in what makes a story <strong>hot</strong>, why <strong>big stories just get bigger,</strong> and how the <strong>peculiar political-economics</strong> of information deliver almost <strong>unlimited returns to scale</strong>. When a story gets big and hot in today’s competitive, low-margin media environment, <strong>genteel news judgment cripples the news product.</strong></p><p>“United Breaks Heads” has been <strong>great fodder</strong> for call-in shows, expert panels, interviews, talking heads, posts and front page stories, not to mention twitter and comment section skirmishes. It is <strong>heartening</strong> how many different legitimate stories, considering aspects of finance, regulatory issues, corporate culture, algorithmic decision-making, executive PR crisis management, etc. grew out of this one sorry incident. And it is heartening to see that United and other carriers claim to have <strong>responded by reform.</strong></p><p>However it was also <strong>disheartening</strong> to see how long reports persisted as if the incident arose from a typical overbooking situation, omitting the apparent facts that it was a desire to transport late arriving airline crew members needed in Louisville and the ensuing low-ball offers of compensation for volunteers that led to the demand that <strong>“computer-selected” seated passengers give up their seats.</strong> And it was disheartening to see alternative stories take-off, blaming Dao or conversely claiming that he was the victim of mistaken identity by the media.</p><h4>Conclusion: Make the Case for Your News Judgment</h4><p>Again the bottom line for <strong>modern journalism</strong> is for reporters to <strong>lay out the conclusions</strong> they <strong>wants news consumers to reach</strong> and back up their propositions with the details according to the reporters’ judgments of weight. Over time the individuals and outlets that explain their conclusions well will earn <strong>trust they can take to the bank</strong> in reputation and revenue. More importantly the <strong>fourth estate will continue to be a check</strong> on the powers of governments and economic interests, seeking to shape belief to their own ends.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=72b5876a4846" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Blank Lives Matter! D’you Got a Problem with That?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@civicdec/blank-lives-matter-dyou-got-a-problem-with-that-eee1efc289f9?source=rss-ed2e7921460e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/eee1efc289f9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[blacklivesmatter]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Roger Wilson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 29 Aug 2016 15:32:51 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-08-29T15:32:51.672Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>(originally posted on the <a href="http://bit.ly/PracticallySpeaking"><em>Practically Speaking</em></a> Blog)</p><p>Are you willing to <strong>test yourself</strong>? Before you read any further, perform the following <strong>thought experiment</strong>: Relax. Take a deep breath. Now gently and slowly, in your mind, <strong>substitute a series of ethnic groups for the “blank” in “Blank Lives Matter.”</strong> For example, “Irish Lives Matter, Italian Lives Matter, Puerto Rican Lives Matter, Mexican Lives Matter, African-American Lives Matter,” etc.</p><p>Feel your <strong>emotional response to your words</strong> representing each ethnic group as you do this. If you are like me, you experience at least a slight variation with each substitution. Don’t judge or explain — just observe.</p><p>Now try <strong>religions and denominations</strong>, “Christian Lives Matter, Catholic Lives Matter, Jewish Lives Matter, Hindu Lives Matter, Muslim Lives Matter,” etc.” Try <strong>sexual orientation</strong>, “Gay Lives Matter, Straight Lives Matter, Lesbian Lives Matter,” etc. <strong>Try colors and shades</strong>, “White Lives Matter, Red Lives Matter, Yellow Lives Matter, Light Lives Matter, Dark Lives Matter,” etc. You can try it with <strong>any categorical series</strong> that might relate to having a life.</p><p>Sitting on my exercise mat on earlier this month, in my little nest of newsprint, I read about <a href="http://bit.ly/BLM-Protest">Police and EMT personnel protesting a “Black Lives Matter”</a> banner on the Somerville, MA, City Hall. Somerville is described by the New York Times as “a white working class suburb of Boston.” Somerville is actually a rapidly gentrifying urban part of greater Boston, governed by a highly regarded mayor, Joseph Curtatone, the son of Italian immigrants. He had refused to have the banner removed. The <a href="http://bit.ly/BLM-Protest-BG">Boston Globe had a more nuanced account</a> more sympathetic to the protesting Police.</p><p>I ran the “Blank Lives Matter” thought experiment to <strong>test my own feelings</strong> about a “Black Lives Matter” banner on a public building. I was prompted, in part, by seeing a Democratic convention interview on CSPAN in which a delegate said, “If you have a problem with “Black Lives Matter,” that’s your problem not mine.”</p><p>Performing the experiment in a non-filtering mood, as I stretched and exercised, <strong>I was surprised to find that my feelings varied with almost every substitution</strong>, mildly in most cases but noticeably. It is a testable proposition, but I am sure such emotional variation is detectable physiologically, in psychological tests and behavioral observation. Additionally my sample of one is very easy to enlarge.</p><p>I had <strong>emotions associated with each word I tested</strong>. What surprised me is that I had negative emotions associated with many common <strong>negative cultural stereotypes</strong>. I <strong>felt a conflict between the negative emotion and the positive statement</strong> that “Blank Lives Matter.” In my particular ethnic culture, negative stereotypes applying to every ethnic group and religious practice (including our own), are readily available, so I have many stereotypes to draw on. I doubt that my ethnic culture is unique concerning stereotypes, positive or negative.</p><p>Both logically and intuitively, I believe that <strong>all people are born equal and endowed with inalienable, equal rights</strong>. However, at the same time I find that I value the lives of some people more than others. At a personal level this is natural and not a problem. It is natural to consider one’s own family most dear. One’s close friends and neighbors are more important than distant relationships. What is more problematic, although also perfectly natural, is that <strong>I evaluate whole classes of people stereotypically</strong> according to oversimplified, standardized and in some cases negative ideas.</p><p><strong>All perception, across all senses, employs stereotypes</strong>. Reality provides too much information for our brains to process quickly without simplification. However, the use of stereotypes makes us susceptible to misleading illusions. Like a magician creating optical illusions, others can use our stereotypes to trick us into false perceptions. We can also trick ourselves by failing to notice patterns that we don’t expect.</p><p>I tried <strong>another thought experiment</strong>, as I showered that morning. I recalled a “Blank Lives Matter” that I had felt conflicted about and repeated it in my mind just as I repeat positive statements or affirmations to keep myself motivated in sports training and competition. I found that the <strong>repetition melted away negative emotions</strong> and encouraged a good feeling that “Blank Lives Really Do Matter.”</p><p>These two thought experiments demonstrated that <strong>negative reactions to the positive statement that any given “Fill-in the-Blank Lives Matter” and especially with “Black Lives Matter” are well worth examining</strong>, both personally and in public discourse. I would need strong evidence to convince me that my stereotypical negative reactions are unusual.</p><p><strong>Common negative stereotypes reduce the strength of our positive valuation</strong> of fill-in-the-blank peoples’ lives. Values influence action. However, my experiments also demonstrate that we can examine and alter our stereotypes. <strong>The closer our stereotypes come to our belief that all people are born equal and endowed with inalienable, equal rights, the better we will feel and better we will become.</strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=eee1efc289f9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why We Need “NOVpartisan” Instead of “Nonpartisan” Civic Media]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@civicdec/why-we-need-novpartisan-instead-of-nonpartisan-civic-media-4174e573d2f1?source=rss-ed2e7921460e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4174e573d2f1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[civic-media]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[civictech]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[journalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[civic-engagement]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Roger Wilson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 21 Jul 2016 19:02:08 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-07-21T19:18:18.225Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>The truth is not getting play</strong> in our media according to New York Times media columnist Jim Rutenberg. An increasingly partisan press is the culprit, he charges in an <a href="http://nyti.ms/2ajNpGs">Independence Day column</a>. Dangerous political outcomes are afoot. But do we really think conventional “nonpartisan” journalism can shift the balance toward truth?</p><p><strong>If truth is losing out to falsehood we need stronger stuff on the side of truth</strong>. That is why I assert<strong> we need “novpartisan” journalism produced on a new kind of media platform</strong>. The need is urgent. Some of the same technologies that make a new platform possible can be deployed to promote falsehood.</p><p>I coin the term novpartisan to signify<strong> a novel, alternative way of producing civic content</strong> but also novel way of being part of a party. Novpartisan is “partisan” not by blindly adhering to an external party, faction, cause, or person. Novpartisan is partisan in the sense that<strong> it develops and cultivates common interests in civic action</strong> among its participating audience members. The audience itself becomes a party or a better informed faction of a larger party.</p><p><strong>The full scale, first mover opportunity is still wide open</strong>. Our time is ripe for new enterprises that use modern technology to supply active citizens with useful information and create better ways to experience citizenship. Social, business, technical and political trends favor new forms of media and new means of political influence and participation.</p><p><strong>New civic media must focus on what citizens want — not what you or I think citizens need</strong>. Obviously, novpartisan civic media can’t magically satisfy citizens’ desires. At best the new platform can systematically approach them by degree.</p><p><strong>Citizens want citizenship to become a challenge they can master</strong>. Citizens want good answers to hard questions; understandable solutions to complex problems; trustworthy prescriptive and explicatory information that can be easily absorbed; autonomy and control; and they want citizenship to be pleasant and satisfying. Our current media is not much help.</p><p>Conventional nonpartisan and partisan media models produce similar information. Conventional media misses what citizens want because <strong>the business models of both partisan and nonpartisan models are advertising based</strong>. Advertising revenue is the primary method to make a media model viable. Advertising models turn editorial content into a cost center that must attract and hold audiences in service to the advertisers. That function shapes the information more than any editorial intent to be nonpartisan or partisan.</p><p><strong>True power is the key missing link</strong> between true satisfaction and the many laudable efforts to address civic interest with new civic tech or civic media. The goal of civic media should be to provide information d and media experiences that result in true satisfaction. The new platform has to be perceived as much better than ad-supported platforms to induce audience members to pay more and engage more with the form.</p><p>People with the means to create a medium that generates true power for citizens have been reluctant create such a medium. Their <strong>reasons are both political and economic</strong>. If they have the means, they usually want the power for themselves. The economic case is simple — <strong>people want to be compensated</strong>. Real satisfaction is secondary and even potentially threatening to the advertising model.</p><p>The political reluctance to generate power for citizens is more complex than the economic. In part, that political reluctance reflects interests in deluding citizens for private benefit, usually economic. <strong>Satisfying citizens with the power of truth is not in the interests of those who benefit from falsehoods</strong>.</p><p>Another part of the political reluctance stems from a <strong>nonpartisan ideal</strong> dating back at least to the creation of our republic. The complex web of calculation and compromise that allows groups to aggregate individual interests into a common interest is a mechanism with many random, unconscious, and irrational factors. The <strong>founding fathers wished for a better human nature</strong> even as they created our republic to deal with the reality. Their wishful thinking persists.</p><p>Deep <strong>distrust of democratic process and republican structures</strong> is, however, the most formidable barrier to facilitating citizen power. People don’t like to share power with people they disagree with. People with any sense of personal power can be reluctant to equate themselves with their fellow citizens. <strong>The humility of equal citizenship is not a natural impulse</strong>.</p><p>Democratic (little “d”) and republican (little “r”) values coexist with tribal moral codes, passed down over millennia, which deny that all people are born equal. Ancient and modern values of charity and benevolence appear to conflict with the cold republican formulation of individual rights. Modern usage conflates individual rights with a long list of “nice to haves” which many are reluctant to forego. Elaborate social structures mask the role of force in developed societies, freeing many from any realistic reckoning of basic political economics.</p><p>A <strong>commitment to reason and science is the one attribute of the novpartisan media opportunity that seems to unlock and overpower political reluctance</strong>. Savvy journalists, political operatives and academic observers may scoff at this role for reason and science. They know all too well the rough and tumble reality of politics.</p><p><strong>What experts immersed in the current order underestimate is the rough and tumble reality of reason and science</strong>. It is no accident that modern disciplines of reason and science emerged, in part, from an effort to develop an alternative to trial by ordeal as a source of justice. The alternative to rudimentary reason and science was to throw the suspected witch in the pond and see if she sank!</p><p><strong>Science is a social system</strong>, not simply a discipline for individual minds. Like any other human social system it is complex and highly variable but it has produced results more dramatic any other social development. The fruits of science have been a major factor in human increase and prosperity. On balance, people have good reason to trust the systems of reason and science rather than mystical revealed truth or truth declared by authorities.</p><p>What I have found, in countless conversations, is that a<strong> commitment to reason and science, alongside democratic process and republican structure, is the essential and distinctive element of the novpartisan media model</strong>. There are enumerable possible configurations of the general model but without the three legged support including a commitment to reason and science the model doesn’t seem attractive enough to become a significant civic media alternative.</p><p>The novpartisan model also <strong>requires robust use of modern technology</strong> to be practical. Imagine a form of <strong>civic media as a specialized type of social media</strong> wherein:</p><ul><li>The enterprise has some of the character of a public radio station but with <strong>paying members who actually have a direct role in the governance</strong> of the outlet</li><li>The enterprise structure includes internal r<strong>epresentative</strong> and <strong>deliberative</strong> functions; <strong>executive</strong> functions and <strong>adjudicating</strong> functions, operating transparently according to a <strong>clear charter</strong></li><li>The enterprise is <strong>location based down to the precinct and even neighborhood level</strong> for information development and distribution as well as internal governance</li><li>Audience or member participation includes processes by which <strong>contributors are tested or vetted</strong> e.g. classed by earning certain internal certifications</li><li>The enterprise issues <strong>specific calls to civic action</strong> governed ultimately by members</li><li>Participation includes options for <strong>civic games and certifications</strong> yielding status and recognition within the civic network</li><li><strong>Scientific norms</strong> of data transparency, attribution, replicability, professional and earned authority are applied to civic information.</li></ul><p>None of these characteristics would be practical without technology.</p><p><strong>Testing this novpartisan media concept</strong> is admittedly a daunting prospect. We can have no doubt that significant subsets of active citizens are ready for new solutions. We know that redirecting a small percentage of time and money which active citizen’s invest in their civic interests could amount to huge sums. We know that systematically mobilizing active citizens could be highly influential in voting and other civic affairs. We also know that civic affairs are often extremely difficult to understand and properly report and that useful coverage developed exclusively by paid personnel is beyond the means of most conventional nonpartisan and partisan outlets. And we know that particular civic matters are often interesting in any detail only to small subsets of activists , compounding the challenges of developing conclusive civic information.</p><p>Do we not also know, however, that <strong>digging deeper in the conventional nonpartisan and partisan veins is unlikely alter political outcomes</strong>? Conventional advertising based models have been tinkered with for over 200 years and layered with waves of new technology including high speed presses, telegraph transmission, linotype machines, film, radio, TV, cable, fax and now of course the internet. Isn’t it time to test a <strong>new way of getting at the truth that takes full advantage of modern information technology</strong>?</p><p>If truth is losing out to falsehood <strong>we need a more potent participatory media on the side of truth — we need “novpartisan” journalism</strong>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4174e573d2f1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[You Do Believe In Democracy, Don’t You?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@civicdec/you-do-believe-in-democracy-don-t-you-132e757fe6f9?source=rss-ed2e7921460e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/132e757fe6f9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[democracy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Roger Wilson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 15 Mar 2016 16:22:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-03-15T16:22:58.703Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Acquiescence to the candidacy of Donald Trump in the name of “democracy” is <strong>sloppy thinking</strong>.</p><p><strong>Simplistic and unrealistic beliefs in democracy can get people killed</strong>. Bad things can happen when well-meaning people misapply good ideas. Ross Douthat says, in a recent <a href="http://bit.ly/Partydecision"><strong>op-ed in the <em>New York Times</em></strong></a> that Americans, including our “officially neutral press…<strong>speak and think in the language of Democracy without appreciating the deeper wisdom of the American system</strong>.”</p><p><strong>“You do believe in democracy, don’t you?”</strong> was a question <strong>Paul Wolfowitz</strong>, then US Deputy Secretary of Defense, posed to <strong>Paul Bremer</strong>, before Bremer became head of the Coalition Provisional Authority in Iraq according to Neil Swidey’s<a href="http://bit.ly/Swideyreckoning"> <strong>recent <em>Boston Globe </em>profile</strong></a> of Bremer. Bremer later concluded that Wolfowitz wanted to be sure Bremer was not “infected” by the State Department’s “defeatist” thinking that democracy is not possible in the Middle East. Wolfowitz’s slack triumphalism turned out to be more dangerous.</p><p><strong>Sloppy thinking has consequences.</strong> It <em>is</em> defeatist to believe that liberty and justice are not possible someday, for all people, everywhere. However, the <strong>shallow understanding of democracy and of political-economics more generally </strong>cost <strong>4,500 American lives</strong> in Iraq and many <strong>more Iraqi lives</strong> and cost American taxpayers nearly <strong>$1 trillion</strong>. Our inept conduct in Iraq <strong>helped spawn a new adversary</strong>, ISIS, now wreaking havoc on three continents.</p><p><strong>The American system embodies a deep wisdom</strong> in its intricate government structures and its partisan, non-governmental institutions. Our founding fathers designed our democratic republic to reduce the risk of abuses of power. Our party institutions, which the founders did not anticipate precisely, have evolved with similar rules, checks on power, and balances of powers. Political conduct is further regulated by complex state and federal systems, including government-run party elections, which have grown from attempts to adapt and improve the way our democracy functions.</p><p><strong>Democracy provides legitimacy to government.</strong> Our system creates incentives for <strong>elites to compete for power</strong> through popular support, providing some degree of <strong>consent of the governed</strong>. Republican (little “r”) structures improve the likelihood that liberty and justice will result.</p><p>The wisely crafted structures of our democratic republic <strong>separate and disperse power</strong> across layers of representation and deliberation according to <strong>written rules and procedures.</strong> These republican structures allow us to know when <strong>democratic decisions</strong> are actually final (for instance with requirements of plurality, majority, or super-majority votes), <strong>protect minorities</strong> who might otherwise become rebels, and allow democratic governance to <strong>function at scale</strong>, through representation.</p><p>Democracy has a <strong>moral underpinning</strong> –the self-evident truth that <strong>all men are created equal</strong>; that individuals of our human species have morally equivalent claims upon each other. Thus, people have an equal right to a say in their government. But <strong>limits to democracy have an equally strong foundation</strong>, in that people are endowed by their Creator with certain <strong>unalienable Rights</strong>, and that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.</p><p><strong>You can’t just <em>believe</em> in democracy. You have to work at it</strong>, using <strong>all the levers</strong> of our deeply wise system, including party rules that limit and moderate power. Democracy does not <strong>robotically produce</strong> good results (although there is a certain type of wisdom in crowds, if individuals have diverse sources of information). Nor does it function in an vacuum outside of the real political-economics of belief and information, coercion, and production. Neither our party institutions nor our governments run on <strong>autopilot</strong>. As I write this, on an election day, it should be obvious that our American system has some<strong> serious defects</strong>, but our problems are compounded by a <strong>shallow understanding of how and why our system has worked in the past</strong>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=132e757fe6f9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>