<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Coinscrum on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Coinscrum on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@coinscrum?source=rss-4e43d504e8f8------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 08:41:29 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@coinscrum/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[First anniversary review of “The fractal relationship between bitcoin’s first two bubbles and what…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@coinscrum/first-anniversary-review-of-the-fractal-relationship-between-bitcoins-first-two-bubbles-and-what-c548eb2647b9?source=rss-4e43d504e8f8------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c548eb2647b9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[bitcoin]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[elliottwave]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ethereum]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[blockchain]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[crypto]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Coinscrum]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 14 Feb 2018 00:04:22 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-03-21T18:35:48.476Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>First anniversary review of “The fractal relationship between bitcoin’s first two bubbles and what they might tell us about a third”</strong></p><p>Just over a year ago I posted an analysis entitled “<em>The fractal relationship between bitcoin’s first two bubbles and what they might tell us about a third</em>”.</p><p>If you didn’t happen upon it, I’d recommend that you <strong>click </strong><a href="https://medium.com/@coinscrum/the-fractal-relationship-between-bitcoins-first-two-bubbles-and-what-they-might-tell-us-about-a-7c8df5fb9613"><strong>here</strong></a><strong> and read it</strong> <strong>first</strong> if this post is going to make much sense.</p><p>It included my 3 year forecast and reasoning behind how that previous price-action <em>might</em> give us some indications as to where we were about to head.</p><p>A few people asked for an update along the way so here it is. I’ll write up another update a year from now — if you’re going to be stupid enough to publicly make long term predictions on the price of bitcoin, I don’t think there’s much point in tying yourself up in knots by reflecting on every twist and turn along the way.</p><p>So, let’s start by recapping on what, as I agreed myself at the time, seemed like a ridiculous forecast.</p><p>It went like this:</p><p><strong>a) </strong>We were about to break the previous all time high (in USD terms after an initial failed attempt) and that, previously, when the bitcoin price had done so, it had never, so far, fallen back below it.</p><p><strong>b)</strong> We would then begin a strong push higher, forming a proposed <strong>Primary Wave 3</strong> that would temporarily peak at ~$9304 in ~October 2018 (having briefly paused at ~$3000 in ~November 2017).</p><p><strong>c )</strong> Then pull back to ~$5500 whilst consolidating in a <a href="https://www.investopedia.com/terms/t/triangle.asp"><em>5 wave triangle pattern</em></a> over the course of around a year whilst forming <strong>Primary Wave 4.</strong></p><p><strong>d)</strong> Before finally jumping back onto its pogo stick and springing higher to complete its <strong>Primary Wave 5 </strong>of the current bubble cycle — topping out at ~$33,717 in May ‘20 (therefore completing <strong>Cycle Wave I</strong> at the same time).</p><p><strong>e)</strong> Before crashing again by around 80–90% as <strong>Cycle Wave II</strong> takes hold.</p><p>— — — — — —</p><p>First things first, and hands up. I was right-ish, wrong and wrong.</p><p>Never being one that likes to reward failure, I’ll do the right thing and agree to block my access to coinmarketcap.com for 3 straight hours, starting…… now.</p><p>In the mean time, let’s go back to where I left off last year and see if there’s something to salvage nonetheless.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/924/1*u6bmXGI1ZzboJn-EWG4bkw.png" /><figcaption><em>The final chart indicating my 3 year prediction from my Jan ’17 post</em></figcaption></figure><p><strong>What happened?</strong></p><p>So, a few weeks after the original post we finally made a new USD denominated high at $1350 on the day the Winklevii Bitcoin ETF application was rejected. The market reacted negatively to this for a while before deciding, as is its wont, “what the hell, let’s just go up anyway”.</p><p><strong>[A brief aside. </strong>This was a classic case of the market interpreting news that it had assumed would have a negative impact prior to the event, reacting very differently after it. I was asked a few times after posting the original article about Fundamental Analysis vs Technical Analysis. Each camp tends to like to sneer at the other but you can read my thoughts on the subject in a comment <a href="https://medium.com/@coinscrum/hi-graham-3459404828df">here</a>.<strong>]</strong></p><p>And so it carried on.</p><p>By mid June we’d already hit my projected <em>pausing point</em> within <strong>Primary Wave 3 </strong>that I’d guestimated might be reached at ~$3000 by ~Nov ’17.</p><p>So roughly twice as fast as expected.</p><p>The market did take a breather from there for a month or so then, again, simply went marching on its merry way, briefly taking some very short term breathers as it did so.</p><p>On <em>November 29th ’17</em> we then broke clean through the $9304 high that I’d forecast as being a potential crest for <strong>Primary Wave 3</strong> by <em>~ Oct ’18</em>.</p><p><em>And still it just went marching on.</em></p><p>I’d explained my reasoning in the original post for why I thought $9304 might end up marking a high for <strong>Primary Wave 3</strong>— speculating that this current cycle should be analogous to the first 2 bubble cycles (in 2011 and 2013) whereby each of their respective <em>3rd waves</em> had peaked at ~8x their preceding<em> 1st waves</em>.</p><p>So<em> nil point</em> on that prediction.</p><p>But if not there, then how high was this little rocket ship about to fly?</p><p>There was one <em>possible</em> pointer, something I’d previously noted when looking back at <strong>Wave iii</strong> and <strong>Wave v </strong>within the complete 2012/13<strong> Primary Wave 1 </strong>bubble cycle. It wasn’t something I could have calculated in advance for this cycle but, back in 2013, both the $259.34 (<strong>wave iii</strong>) and and $1163 (<strong>wave v</strong>) highs had topped out at <strong>~18x </strong>their respective <em>200 week simple moving average prices </em>at the time.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*vQ6Jjceu58cRff-oaK_ZFw.png" /><figcaption>Deviations from 200 Week SMA’s in 2013 (chart courtesy of BitcoinWisdom.com)</figcaption></figure><p>I started pointing this out last year when people began screaming “bubble” when bitcoin was trading at ~$4300.</p><h3>Coinscrum on Twitter</h3><p>1/2 Both extended peaks within the #bitcoin bubble of 2013 topped at 18x the 200 week MA. We&#39;re currently only at 6.3x (200WMA = $710)</p><p>Not even close to being a bubble in relative, 2013 terms.</p><p>By early Dec ’17, however, things had started to look decidedly frothier until bitcoin <em>finally</em> seems to have put in a significant top on 17th Dec ’17.</p><p>On that day the <em>200 week simple moving average </em>clocked in at $1229.2 with the high-print coming in at £19,666 — or <strong>15.99x</strong> the <em>200 week simple moving average</em>.</p><p><strong>[Another brief aside</strong>. If you’re of the thinking, like am, that their might be a decent argument for charting the <em>aggregate</em> price of coins that have forked from a single chain (given that they <em>must</em> have some influence on the price of one another), the combined price of bitcoin plus its recent 2017-born siblings, Bitcoin Cash &amp; Bitcoin Gold, hit $21,855 on 17th Dec ’17 — or <strong>17.77x</strong> the <em>200 week simple moving average</em>.<strong>]</strong></p><p>My forecast from last year might well have been quite wrong in terms of time and price, but all was not lost. In Elliott Wave terms I was satisfied that the initial analysis was still in tact — the only difference being that we were heading much higher, much faster.</p><p><strong>[And another</strong>. You’ll recall from my original post that I’m of the firm belief that the quasi-science called Technical Analysis will never be able to predict definitive outcomes (you’d be very disappointed if you think it can) but should, instead, be used as a tool to help skew the odds of the bet you’re about to make in your favour. It should only be used to help you define your entry and exit points for any given trade, both in terms of where to take projected profits as well as possible losses<em>.</em><strong>]</strong></p><p>With these few clues at our disposal, what could one start to deduce?</p><p>Firstly, the sharp rally of 2017 began on cue and still looked to be a fine candidate for being the <strong>Primary Wave 3 </strong>that I was looking out for. Along the way we’d seen these brief corrections (that also had me <em>incorrectly</em> calling a top on a few occasions) but none had ever lasted long enough to realistically be considered as a potential <strong>Primary Wave 4.</strong></p><p>The previous <em>Wave 4’s</em> had lasted for about half the time their preceding <em>Wave 2’s</em> had, so we should reasonably be expecting something that lasts for ~12–15 months on that basis.</p><h3>Quantave on Twitter</h3><p>1/2 Could be good risk/reward trade to sell #BTC here (~$4800) w/ stops above ATH if forming the multi-month correction previously predicted</p><h3>Quantave on Twitter</h3><p>2/2 Targeting ~$4000 or below as we complete a 5 wave triangle before next significant break higher.</p><h3>Coinscrum on Twitter</h3><p>@maartenverheyen See attached. Was gonna wait til Jan to review but potentially relevant now given upcoming events Original post here https://t.co/F33dywLmto</p><p>Secondly, the price was starting to get mighty close to the <em>18x</em> <em>200 week simple moving average </em>mark.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*mgMR-jlgmHrEm4g8n20osg.png" /><figcaption>Deviation from 200 Week SMA in Dec 2017 (chart courtesy of BitcoinWisdom.com)</figcaption></figure><p>With those two things in mind, the odds were leaning heavily towards the <em>actual</em> start of <strong>Primary Wave 4</strong> being pretty imminent. If so, history was hinting that it might resemble the prior <em>4th wave</em> instances , with 2011’s <strong>Wave (iv) </strong>giving back ~40% of its <strong>Wave (iii) </strong>gains and<strong> </strong>2013’s <strong>Wave iv</strong> retracing a full 80% of its <strong>Wave iii</strong> gains during its first leg down.</p><h3>Quantave on Twitter</h3><p>In 2013, both the April (wave 3) and Nov (wave 5) highs topped out at ~18 x #BTC 200week MA. Currently at 8.2x Remember there were no real shorting options then tho #bitcoin</p><h3>Coinscrum on Twitter</h3><p>We tweeted in Q1 this year &amp;amp; since that the sign of an extended top for #bitcoin would be if it hit ~18x its 200 week MA. That&#39;s where we got to. Expect a 60-80% retracement for buying opp</p><p>So, to complete the <em>recap</em> section of this article, we’re left with this current situation versus my analysis from Jan ‘17.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/924/1*QDifKr4RHTxH0M6aEMo_zQ.png" /><figcaption>State of play since my Jan ’17 analysis</figcaption></figure><p><strong>What next?</strong></p><p>The market topped on 17th Dec ’17 before, as I’m sure you’re all well aware, turning sharply lower.</p><p>An initial collapse down to a low of $11,160 on 22nd Dec ’17 was followed by a sharp bounce back up to $17,200 by 5th Jan ’18.</p><p>Whilst bitcoin was failing to make yet another new all time high in late December, the “smallcap” insanity that is the <em>alt coin</em> market made its last hurrah, reaching new highs across the board — being responsible for the entirety of the final wave higher for the <em>Total Market Cap </em>of the crypto sector.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*lvdbicxj19xD9VwmildDMw.png" /><figcaption>Chart courtesy of coinmarketcap.com</figcaption></figure><p>In other markets this <em>divergence</em> in valuation between the <em>benchmark</em> index versus the <em>lower quality</em> equivalents would be considered a <em>non-confirmation</em> and would be construed as a possible indicator that the <em>internal strength</em> of the overall market might not match what its individual constituents were implying — i.e. a reverse indicator.</p><h3>Coinscrum on Twitter</h3><p>@tombulllikes 1st thoughts r &quot;the world&#39;s gone mad&quot;. 2nd r that the new total cap high has been led by the alts &amp;amp; not yet been confirmed by the benchmark (BTC) - a little like Dow Theory. Primary view is BTC won&#39;t make new highs for now &amp;amp; a pop in the alts will keep it in check i.e.</p><p>As expected, and if you look back on the structure of bitcoin’s previous significant <em>2nd and 4th Wave</em> corrections which have generally followed a <em>collapse&gt;bounce&gt;collapse-harder</em> pattern, the market did indeed reverse again, heading quite sharply lower until we bounced off $5920 on the 6th Feb ’18 (a tad above the ~$5500 target in the original forecast — perhaps relevant in notional terms but quite different in percentage terms. Maybe just a coincidence).</p><p>Unlike the brief pull-backs in 2017, this correction is already over 8 weeks old giving us a much more acceptable indication that our <strong>Primary Wave 4 </strong>has now taken the first steps along its path— again, possibly looking to map out a <em>5 Wave Triangle</em> pattern as alluded to in the final chart of the original analysis, something that I’d expected, and got, during 2013’s <strong>Wave iv</strong>.</p><p>These corrective patterns, messy and overlapping when compared to the 5 clean advancing waves within<em> Impulse Waves, </em>are typically labelled A, B, C, (D &amp; E) and are usually formed in clusters of 3 or 5 waves — able to, according to Elliott, extend and append to each other in all sorts of mishy-mashy ways.</p><p>Unlike <em>Impulse Waves</em>, they clearly indicate indecision in the market where <em>distribution</em> takes place. Bulls and bears battle it out as they try to identify the next trend as weak (or smart) hands turn their booty over to stronger (or deluded) ones.</p><p>So far, the <em>candidate</em> for <strong>Primary Wave 4</strong>’s first (<em>Wave A</em>) leg down, with a current low at $5920, equates to a 69.9% correction from the all time high — bang in the middle of the 60–80% correction forecast in my 22nd Dec tweet (above) .</p><p>It’s certainly <em>possible</em> that this is as low as we go but it’s also too soon to rule out the possibility of a lower-low still to come. A full 80% retracement a-la-2013’s <strong>Wave iv</strong> would take the price down to ~$4000. Since the market is much more liquid than it was back then, a shallower correction is perhaps warranted but only time will tell.</p><blockquote>When the facts change, I change my mind. What do you do, Sir? — John Maynard Keynes</blockquote><p>Now, to finally get to the point that I imagine is the only thing you care about if you’ve bothered to read this far.</p><p><em>Where next?”</em></p><p>As I’ve said, there’s no guarantees that any of this will continue to pan out as I’m suggesting and we should only be using such analysis to try to skew odds in our favour before placing trades anyway.</p><p>Given that, I believe that one always need to keep their options open by having a <em>preferred projection</em> as well as <em>secondary</em> and <em>tertiary</em> ones too. If some facts change along the way, whilst your overall view stays in tact, then just be ready to either adapt your opinion or else cut you position accordingly.</p><p>In Elliott Wave terms, a valid pattern is <strong>paramount</strong> to the analysis. If the pattern remains valid then price targets and timeframes may just have to be adjusted should reality decide to wander off-course along the way.</p><p><strong>Preferred projection</strong></p><p>So, I’ll start with what remains as my <em>preferred</em>, less deviating, projection based upon the original dates that I’d extrapolated as potential key turning points in my original analysis.</p><p>Namely ~Oct ’18 and ~May ‘20.</p><p>I’ll start by accepting that I was most likely plain wrong in my original forecast which proposed that the high point of <strong>Primary Wave 3</strong> would be reached in ~Oct ’18 rather what now looks like Dec ’17 (there is still an argument for this still becoming the case if we go on and make a further all time high by then but I’ll wait to see how things look nearer the time before confusing matters now with what would be my <em>tertiary projection</em>).</p><p>However, I’ll retain the opinion that May ’20 might <em>still</em> turn out to be a date where any forthcoming <strong>Primary Wave 5</strong> marks a high.</p><p>With the facts having possibly changed regarding timings, I also have to account for the fact that the price target for <strong>Primary Wave 3 </strong>was definitely wrong too.</p><p>You’ll recall my target for the <strong>Primary Wave 5</strong> high last year was $33,717 (+/- 20%).</p><p>Our current <strong>Primary Wave 3 </strong>candidate travelled a smidge over twice as far as expected so I’m now going to surmise that <strong>Primary Wave 5 </strong>will now <em>also</em> go twice as far, targeting <em>$67,434 (+/- 20%)</em>.</p><p>Simple.</p><p>An 8<em>x</em> move higher from current levels probably seems slightly less ridiculous from this vantage point than a <em>greater than 30x</em> forecast did this time last year.</p><p>On that basis, my new <em>preferred projection</em> looks like this:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/924/1*nDITmcD6wsHW50kVz_yfTw.png" /><figcaption>New Preferred Projection as of Feb ‘18</figcaption></figure><p><strong>[Brief aside</strong>. I mentioned above that I don’t think that <em>technical</em> and <em>fundamental</em> analysis mix that well but I did, nevertheless, have a think about possible “why’s” for these two dates last year. I’ll come onto the Oct ’18 date later, but I subsequently noticed that May ’20 also happens to be the month right before the date <a href="http://www.bitcoinblockhalf.com/">forecast</a> for the next ~4-yearly <em>bitcoin halving</em> event (when the <em>block reward</em> will drop to 6.25 BTC from its current 12.5 BTC).</p><p>Previously, the 2012 and 2016 halvings woke the market up from long term slumbers and triggered major rallies rather than coinciding with significant highs as suggested in the chart above.</p><p>We’ll just have to see how the market reacts next time around.<strong>]</strong></p><p>As the chart shows, the <em>5 wave triangle</em> pattern is still their but I’ve simply (maybe lazily) spread it out over a longer timeframe than originally proposed. <strong>Primary Wave 5 </strong>might then still kick in and continue to target a revised high point in ~May ‘20.</p><p><strong>N.B</strong>. 2013’s <strong>Wave iv</strong> triangle correction lasted 5.75 month between the 9th April $259.80 <strong>Wave iii </strong>high and the final <strong>Wave E </strong>low in late Sep ’13. This was just about half the duration of its preceding <strong>Wave ii</strong> which ran from June ’11 to June ’12. Likewise, the previous <strong>Wave (iv)</strong> in 2011 was just about half the duration of its preceding<strong> Wave (ii).</strong></p><p><strong>Primary Wave 2</strong> ran from Dec ’13 through to June ’16 (or 30 months) — hence (on the chart) an estimated ~15 month duration for this possible forthcoming <strong>Primary Wave 4</strong></p><p>This would take us from the Dec ’17<strong> Primary Wave 3</strong> high though to a completion date of ~March ‘19.</p><p>As mentioned, we can’t be certain that <em>Wave A</em> of this <strong>Primary Wave 4 </strong>candidate has yet reached its low. If we do make a new low, a range between the previously identified 80% retracement level at ~$4000 and the<em> 50 week simple moving average</em> (currently at ~$5420) should offer decent support.</p><p>Any expected triangle pattern would pretty much remain the same, simply evolving from a lower floor that suggested above.</p><p><strong>Secondary Projection</strong></p><p>Alternatively, one could speculate that <em>both </em>the ~Oct ’18 and ~May’20 dates might still remain relevant but in an alternative manner.</p><p>If so, how?</p><p>I never touched upon <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fibonacci_number">Fibonacci numbers and ratios</a> last year. Although widely used by technical analysts to try to predict the depth of corrections, targets for new highs and also timeframes, their significance has been heavily debated and questioned over time.</p><p>Elliott himself started to look at the possible relevance of these so-called <em>natural numbers</em> during his original work. He hypothesised that, if these waves that he’d <em>thought</em> he’d identified really were simply a reflection of human/crowd behaviour, and by extension <em>natural </em>themselves, perhaps this sequence of numbers (and the ratios between them), that had first been purported to reveal themselves in nature some <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fibonacci_number#Origins%5C">1700+ years before</a> before Fibonacci got to work on them, would reveal themselves within market chart patterns too.</p><p>After writing my post last year, and thinking about these two dates, I did start to consider other reasons as to why they <em>might</em> be significant.</p><p>With very little previous information to go on, I will <strong>caveat this by emphasising</strong> that this is purely speculative on my part. Without having anywhere near enough data to go on, it’s quite likely that the cognitive biases that we’re all susceptible to are kicking in and I’m simply trying to make something fit with little real evidence.</p><p>Let’s give it a go anyway and we can simply keep it in mind as and when things start mapping out over the next few years.</p><p>The first few numbers in the Fibonacci sequence are 1, 1, 2, 3, 5, 8, 13…..</p><p>Now I mentioned above that this candidate for <strong>Primary Wave 3 </strong>travelled twice as far and twice as fast as expected — reaching its peak in ~12 rather than ~22 months from the time of the original post.</p><p>As I said, purely speculative but the number “2” features there as two lonely data points as a multiplier (in terms of the 2x original price target) and divisor (in terms being achieved in half the time).</p><p>As you can see from the chart below, there happens to be a level of equality between the time it took bitcoin to reach its first <strong>Wave i </strong>high in June ’11 and the time it subsequently took to then reach its second <strong>Primary Wave 1</strong> high in late November ’13 (if we can assume that bitcoins did actually have some infinitesimally small <em>value</em> the day the network was launched in Jan ‘09)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/924/1*MWXFVjexCZir16Ch-GhkPw.png" /><figcaption>Proposed Fibonacci Timeframes</figcaption></figure><p>It basically took 30 months to go from<strong> zero</strong> in Jan ’09 to the <strong>Wave i</strong> high in June ’11 and just shy of another 30 months to go from the <strong>Wave i</strong> high in June ’11 to the <strong>Wave 1</strong> high in late Nov ‘13.</p><p>Or a ratio of 1:1 in terms of <em>time</em> for each full cycle to complete as per the first two numbers in the Fibonacci sequence.</p><p>Irrespective of any relevance to these two timeframes, it’s obvious in hindsight that both June ’11 and Dec ’13 marked the completion of significant cycle highs for bitcoin.</p><p>Now, if we <em>purely</em> speculate that this sequence <em>might </em>play some role in bitcoin’s future price action, perhaps the next complete cycle will be due to take (a Fibonacci) <strong>2x</strong> as long as the preceding two (along with the price ascending <strong>2x</strong> as high as previous cycles might have suggested it would).</p><p>If so, this current full cycle<em> </em>might now take <em>60 months (2x 30 months) </em>to complete instead — or Dec ’13 plus 60 months which equates to Nov ’18.</p><p>Not an exact match with the ~Oct ’18 turning point identified in my original projections but close enough to take note of given the overall 3 year timeframe of the analysis.</p><p>Now, if we put my <em>preferred projection</em> to one side for now, I discussed earlier how <strong>Primary Wave 3</strong> seems like it might have travelled twice as far, twice as fast as originally predicted.</p><p>If we also carry this idea forward to this current candidate for <strong>Primary Wave 4, </strong>it might well also travel “<em>twice as fast”</em> as predicted too.</p><p>I explained above how the duration of the 4th waves during bubbles #1 and #2 were roughly half that of their preceding 2nd Wave’s which meant that any forthcoming <strong>Primary Wave 4</strong> should take ~15 months based on the 30 months it took <strong>Primary Wave 2 </strong>to complete.</p><p>We only have last year’s rally to go on but, if this current wavelength also proves to be half as wide as preciously expected, then this candidate for <strong>Primary Wave 4</strong> <em>might</em> now choose to only take ~7.5 months (rather than 15) to reach its journey’s end from the Dec ’17 high — taking us to around late July or early Aug ’18.</p><p>Should that transpire, the market <em>could</em> feasibly still then have time to form an earlier than expected <strong>Primary Wave 5</strong>, possibly targeting<strong> </strong>the same <em>$67,434</em> level by ~Oct/Nov ’18 rather than May ’20 — not entirely outlandish given the speed at which the final stages of previous 3rd and 5th wave manias have travelled.</p><p><strong>N.B. </strong>Although I’m making some pretty grand projections for possible targets for any forthcoming <strong>Primary Wave 5</strong>, in Elliott Wave terms, any <em>5th wave</em> only needs to reach beyond the high-print made by its preceding <em>3rd wave</em> i.e. beyond $19,666 to qualify.</p><p>We do know that all prior 5th waves thus far have been by far the longest of the 3 advancing waves but we just need to keep this in mind and, if long, have a sensible “scaled up” approach to selling.</p><p>Irrespective of how ambitious that might seem, what then about the May ’20 turning point?</p><p>Well, should <strong>Primary Wave 5</strong> actually end up surprising us all in Oct or Nov ’18, we’d have to then seriously consider that, in doing so, it’s also completing <strong>Cycle Wave I </strong>at the same time (itself made up of <strong>Primary Waves 1, 2 , 3, 4 &amp; 5</strong>).</p><p>Then, as you’re aware by now, we’ll possibly enter <strong>Cycle Wave II</strong> (perhaps crashing up to 80 or 90% as was the case in <strong>Wave ii </strong>(in 2011) and <strong>Wave 2 </strong>(between Dec ’13 and May ’16).</p><p>As a reminder, this is the table from the original article showing the time it took <strong>Wave ii </strong>and <strong>Wave 2</strong> to each find their troughs (although I speculated that each full 2nd wave corrective pattern took some time longer to actually complete <em>after</em> reaching their lows).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*S_x80kORkvVQmTmym-5M9A.png" /></figure><p>What does that mean in terms of projecting how any future <strong>Cycle Wave II</strong> might pan out?</p><p>Intuitively, I guess we should expect it to be a<em> longer</em> affair than its prior <strong>Wave 2</strong>, especially if the timeframe for our next cycle does indeed end up following the proposed Fibonacci sequence.</p><p>Then again, we’re also on the lookout for the possibility that wavelengths are speeding up too.</p><p>Finally, we also have to consider the reference points of the two previous bitcoin <em>block reward halving</em> events whereby they each occurred at or near the end of a 2nd wave or early in a 3rd.</p><p>In short, we’ll just have to wait and see and consider options based on the course of events between now and then.</p><p>Under this purely speculative scenario, given that <strong>Primary Wave 2 </strong>lasted 30 months, and under the assumption that wavelengths <em>might </em>continue to occur over half the timeframe of their predecessors, then that would equate to <strong>Cycle Wave II</strong> taking <em>only</em> 15 months to complete from an Oct/Nov ’18 <strong>Cycle Wave I</strong> high — or in other words, by March ’20.</p><p>That may not be too far from the May ’20 date, by coincidence, but it seems somewhat short to me to be honest.</p><p>Taking all of the above into account, that would then produce something along the lines of this:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/924/1*rOPQdsTiuIxt0uC5TvWLiQ.png" /><figcaption>New Secondary Projection as of Feb ‘18</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Summary</strong></p><p>My <em>preferred projection</em> has to be, well, my <em>preferred projection.</em></p><p>But with this crazy market being what it is, I’m going to obviously keep a very close eye on the <em>secondary projection</em> too.</p><p>If it looks like we have a clear candidate for a <em>5 Wave</em> triangle pattern (or even something that does a good job of fitting the bill) completing by around July/August this year, perhaps my <em>secondary projection</em> will take over the driver’s seat for a few months whilst I keep a beady eye on what the market‘s doing.</p><p>I can always switch back if it fails to deliver whilst, at the same time, the overall <em>valid Elliott Wave</em> <em>pattern</em> remains in good health.</p><p>Of course, as is still entirely possible, if the market simply crashes from here and dips back below the proposed Dec ‘13 <strong>Primary Wave 1</strong> high at $1163, then the entire wave-count I’ve been proposing across these two articles will become null &amp; void.</p><p><strong>[Remember</strong>, if potential 4th waves dip back below the high point of potential 1st waves, then all bets are off. Elliott’s golden rule for <em>Impulse Waves</em> will have been contravened, your stop losses will have been triggered (you did identify your exits before placing the trade didn’t you?) and it’s back to the drawing board and job centre for you and me.</p><p><em>4th waves</em>, if they ultimately prove themselves to be just that, can offer an excellent opportunity to skew any risk/reward ratio in your favour. You know your stop-loss <em>has</em> to be just below (or above, in a down trend) any suspected prior <em>1st wave</em> high (or else the Elliot Wave pattern invalidates itself) whilst having good reason to expect that any subsequent <em>5th wave</em> will make a new all time high at the very least.</p><p>If you’d been lucky enough to buy-in at, or close to the $50 <strong>Wave iv</strong> low in 2013, your stop-loss order <em>had</em> to be placed just below the prior $31.90 <strong>Wave i</strong> high, with an expectation, that was ultimately realised, of a 10-20x <em>reward</em> vs a<em> risk</em> of less than 50% of your initial capital.<strong>]</strong></p><p><strong>Final thoughts</strong></p><p>So that’s about it for another year. I’ll return in early 2019, either with egg dripping down my face or a big bag of I-told-you-so’s.</p><p>At the start of the first article, I stated that, whilst a fan of Elliott Wave Theory, I wasn’t at all certain (based on my own long term, and sometimes painful experience) that it could offer truly consistent returns in mature markets where cycles were <em>so</em> advanced that patterns, although still possible to identify in the rear view mirror, can take so long to form that they may exceed the years you’ve been allocated here by your maker.</p><p>The reason why I was most interested in looking closely at this from a bitcoin perspective was that we‘ve, rather uniquely, been given a rare opportunity to plot Elliott’s theory from the very birth of a brand new asset class.</p><p>Should my spurious-for-now thesis (that some correlation might prove to exist between; the time it’s taking cycles to complete; and the <em>Fibonacci sequence) </em>end up having any merit, in distant hindsight of course, then the next <em>cycle</em> may well last for <em>3x 30 months</em> — or 7.5 years — and the one after that<em> 5x 30 months</em>— or 12.5 years.</p><p>I’m hoping that’s not a major deal-breaker for some of you reading this but I’m getting on a bit and and such timeframes will start to become somewhat less inspiring to me.</p><p>Many people will, and do, poo-poo technical analysis and, in the most part, I can’t blame them. Maybe it is just voodoo and all that I’ve written here along with the patterns I’ve tried to identify are either <strong>a)</strong> pure coincidence or <strong>b)</strong> me simply doing what humans are predisposed to do and look for patterns in <em>everything</em> in order to attempt to give ourselves some knowledge of, or comfort with, the dirty unknown future.</p><p>However, to finish up, and it may again just be pure coincidence, I thought I’d throw in a chart of what’s currently still the second most dominant crypto asset out there, <strong>Ether</strong>.</p><p>Obviously somewhat younger than bitcoin, we were able to start charting Ether’s price-action when the network launched on 30th July 2015.</p><p>It looks to me that Ether’s own formative <em>cycle</em> may have now completed at the same time that bitcoin reached a turning point somewhere within its third — taking a bitcoin-like 29 months to do so.</p><p>I’ve probably given enough examples by now for what one ought to be looking out for, so here’s a chart depicting <em>Ether’s price-action</em> (so far) overlaid with that first Elliott Wave-based forecast for bitcoin that I scribbled down, then threw away, way back in late 2011.</p><p>Am I deluding myself, and you, by trying to suggest that fractals exist within historical chart patterns? Most probably.</p><p>Or else, might we really just be bunch of idiot lemmings, destined to repeat our actions, both wise and stupid, in perpetuity?</p><p>I’ll let you draw your own conclusions.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/924/1*VPmMzxC6dE1hwPVUuJcO9A.png" /><figcaption>Ether’s first full 5 wave bubble cycle overlaid with my original scribbled prediction for bitcoin in 2011. Thanks to CryptoCompare.com for the data</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Really final thoughts</strong></p><p>If I could distill into a single line the most meaningful thing I’ve learned in the 6+ years that I’ve spent too much time thinking about this curious little technology, it would be this (thanks to Louis Smyth).</p><p>“Money is Technology”</p><p>If I were to expand on that at all, it would be to say that “Money is the best technology <em>currently </em>available to the community in which it’s employed to serve its desired purpose.”</p><p>Thinking of it as such has caused my mind to travel back and forth through time; to the first single-celled organisms on earth; through the ages of man and into the present day and beyond as I’ve tried, like many, to put my finger on what <em>money</em> actually is.</p><p>Perhaps I’ll write more about that another day but if I’ve learned anything useful in my 47 years here, it’s that <em>perspective</em> is your best friend.</p><p>Unless you take the 10 mile high view, you’ll always be blinded by what’s directly in front of and behind you.</p><p>Yes, looking at charts, making predictions and, perhaps, scalping a few winners along the way is certainly fun.</p><p>However, if you’re coming into this afresh, I can assure you that you’ll get a lot more satisfaction from this topic if you both; look back far enough to comprehend all that has come before (and more importantly, how and why it evolved the way it did) and also; use your imagination to wonder just what <em>might</em> be possible given enough time, ingenuity and, of course, perspective.</p><p><strong>The small print</strong></p><p>Whatever happens, have fun trading and investing. Still only invest what you can afford to lose. Please, please, please research and understand what it is you’re investing in before you pull the trigger and do all you can to avoid being scammed.</p><p>Past performance is <em>still</em> not an indicator of future outcomes.</p><p>These are <em>still</em> only the opinions of the author and do not constitute investment advice.</p><p>Your investments can <em>still</em> go down as well as up (or more often than not, <em>down</em> as well as <em>down</em>).</p><p>Until this time next year — may the forth (wave) be with you.</p><p><em>— — — — — — —</em></p><p><strong>About Me</strong></p><p><em>Paul Gordon</em></p><p>Formerly a derivatives trader for 20 years, I’ve been organising the UK’s largest bitcoin/blockchain meetup group, <a href="http://www.meetup.com/London-bitcoin-meetup/">Coinscrum</a>, since 2012.</p><p>Currently CEO at Quantave.</p><p>[edits — corrected error in the Fibonacci number sequence 21.03.18]</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c548eb2647b9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What the fractal relationship between bitcoin’s first two bubbles might tell us about a third]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@coinscrum/the-fractal-relationship-between-bitcoins-first-two-bubbles-and-what-they-might-tell-us-about-a-7c8df5fb9613?source=rss-4e43d504e8f8------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7c8df5fb9613</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[economics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[finance]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[blockchain]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bitcoin]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trading]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Coinscrum]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 07 Jan 2017 01:37:06 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-01-09T22:47:18.394Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>The fractal relationship between bitcoin’s first two bubbles and what they might tell us about a third</h4><p>I started staring at bitcoin charts just over 5 years ago.</p><p>I’d already spent years staring at all sorts of charts as a derivatives trader so I thought I’d recount to you just why I thought that first bitcoin chart I saw in September 2011 looked so interesting to me.</p><p>I liked to use Elliott Wave Theory when doing my own technical analysis — the idea that financial charts depict, as fractals, the repetition of humanity’s collective behaviour at any given scale, over any given timeframe.</p><p>The wisdom and madness of the crowd repeating over and over again.</p><p><em>— — — — — —</em></p><p><em>Before I carry on, if you’re not familiar with the basic rules of Elliott Waves, </em><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elliott_wave_principle#Elliott_Wave_personality_and_characteristics"><em>click here</em></a><em> for a brief heads up.</em></p><p><em>To help your reading of this post, note that I will label my “waves” as follows:</em></p><p><strong><em>Minor</em></strong><em> waves will be labelled </em><strong><em>(i)</em></strong><em>,</em><strong><em> (ii)</em></strong><em>, </em><strong><em>(iii)</em></strong><em>, </em><strong><em>(iv)</em></strong><em> &amp; </em><strong><em>(v)</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Intermediate</em></strong><em> waves will be labelled </em><strong><em>i</em></strong><em>,</em><strong><em> ii</em></strong><em>, </em><strong><em>iii</em></strong><em>, </em><strong><em>iv</em></strong><em> &amp; </em><strong><em>v</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Primary </em></strong><em>waves will be labelled </em><strong><em>1</em></strong><em>,</em><strong><em> 2</em></strong><em>, </em><strong><em>3</em></strong><em>,</em><strong><em> 4</em></strong><em> &amp; </em><strong><em>5</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Cycle </em></strong><em>waves will be labelled </em><strong><em>I</em></strong><em>,</em><strong><em> II</em></strong><em>, </em><strong><em>III</em></strong><em>,</em><strong><em> IV</em></strong><em> &amp; </em><strong><em>V</em></strong></p><p><em>Also note the final section in that article entitled “Criticism” — with which I absolutely agree. Predicting where the value of an asset sits within an Elliott Wave cycle in mature markets (such as equities, bonds and traditional commodities) can be very difficult indeed, especially where patterns may be taking years or even decades to form.</em></p><p><em>Elliott Waves, more often than not, only become apparent in hindsight but, used correctly, they can be a useful tool to help a trader define their entry and exit points so as to skew risk vs reward in their favour.</em></p><p><em>Hitting the “sweet spot” of certain sub-waves can yield uncannily accurate results but repeated and consistent success in those mature markets is far from guaranteed, if possible at all.</em></p><p><em>However, this post is looking at bitcoin which has provided a much rarer opportunity for us to plot its market-driven value (virtually) since inception. Even most publicly traded companies have a hidden pre-IPO track record.</em></p><p><em>As such, we know exactly where we sit within any possible Elliott Wave cycle(s) as we’re still within touching distance of its very beginning.</em></p><p><em>— — — — — —</em></p><p>Since Elliott documented his ideas in the 1930’s, many others have identified similar patterns of repetitive crowd behaviour — whether it be <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jean-Paul_Rodrigue">Jean-Paul Rodrigue’s Stages of a Bubble</a> in markets….</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/720/0*uslx0lGlKXc6TwMx." /></figure><p>…or, technology hype cycles as identified by <a href="http://www.gartner.com/technology/research/methodologies/hype-cycle.jsp">Gartner</a>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*QTjGkFnXOG9TsDvB." /></figure><p>Given that bitcoin is a curious mix of both technology and tradable asset, it’s surely worth taking a look to see if these patterns apply to bitcoin from an Elliott Wave perspective.</p><p>So when I first looked at that bitcoin chart in 2011, I found the textbook “Impulse Wave” that the world’s first digital commodity had plotted during its inaugural bubble routine (between June ’10 and June ’11) somewhat intriguing.</p><p>This was my thinking back then:</p><ol><li>I know the market-driven value of this asset since its inception (virtually)</li><li>I know exactly where we sit within any forthcoming cycle (that <em>may</em> be predictable) within a timeframe that is actually useful to me (i.e. it won’t take my entire life to map out)</li><li>This market has not yet become co-opted by insiders or central planners so the patterns it forms might truly reflect the mood of “the crowd” — for now at least</li><li>This could, without doubt, crash and burn at any time</li><li>Equally possible is the notion that the pattern plotted during that initial bubble could well (as Elliott Wave Theory proposes) repeat itself proportionately at a far greater scale(s)</li><li>If so, clues as to where that larger fractal might take us could potentially be deduced from the price action so far</li></ol><p><strong>Bitcoin Bubble #1</strong></p><p>The chart below shows the <strong>Minor</strong> <strong>Waves (i), (ii), (iii), (iv) </strong>and<strong> (v)</strong> pattern that, in hindsight, formed a complete and valid<strong> Wave i</strong> bubble<em>.</em></p><p><em>Note </em>that <strong>Wave (v) </strong>was by far the longest of the 3 advancing waves — something that has previously been identified as common during <em>physical</em> commodity hype cycles.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/813/0*4vBnyLisx2zvWfPy." /></figure><p>As I said, 5 very typical Elliott Waves with the table below showing the key peaks and troughs that made up what clearly looked like a bubble given that this market had started trading on Mt Gox at just $0.10 a year earlier.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/828/0*hH6cJ-vunDN4hbjM." /></figure><p>The notion here was that <strong>Wave i </strong>would itself potentially become the first wave of a subsequent larger (and valid) 5 wave pattern over time<strong>.</strong></p><p><em>But then, as the chart below shows, the market crashed violently — ultimately giving back some 95% of its gains (with 80–90% being identified by others such as Rodrigue as typical of bubbles) when it eventually made a low some 5 months later when it touched $1.90.</em></p><p>This crash, however, was (again in hindsight) simply the start of a <strong>Wave ii</strong> correction (with <strong>Waves iii</strong>, <strong>iv</strong> and <strong>v</strong> possibly still to come if Elliott’s theory was to prove correct).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/801/0*YaVHpy4q4g0sIlKI." /></figure><p>So, having stared at that chart for some considerable time it made sense to me to look at the relationships in scale between <strong>Waves (i)</strong> and <strong>(iii)</strong> and <strong>Waves (i)</strong> and <strong>(iv)</strong> during <strong>Wave i</strong> in order to see what a well formed larger analogue of this initial fractal might look like in terms of future peaks &amp; troughs.</p><p><em>Just for laughs</em>.</p><p>So, as highlighted in the table above, <strong>Wave (iii)</strong> ($8.90) had peaked at 8x <strong>Wave (i) </strong>($1.10).</p><p>Therefore if <strong>Wave i</strong> had itself peaked at $31.90, a forthcoming <strong>Wave iii </strong>might well also peak at 8x <strong>Wave i</strong> :</p><p><em>8x $31.90 = $255.20</em></p><p>And <strong>Wave (v)</strong> ($31.90) had peaked at 29x <strong>Wave (i) </strong>($1.10).</p><p>So a forthcoming <strong>Wave v</strong> might well also peak at 29x <strong>Wave i</strong>:</p><p><em>29x $31.90 = $925.10</em></p><p>In between those two forthcoming advancing waves one would then expect to see a <strong>Wave iv</strong> correction that would, as in the case of <strong>Wave (iv)</strong>:</p><ol><li>abide by “the rules” and not sink below the <strong>Wave i</strong> peak (i.e $31.90)</li><li>perhaps also form a <a href="http://www.investopedia.com/university/charts/charts5.asp"><em>5 wave triangle</em></a> that Elliott theorised as the pattern that most commonly formed during fourth wave corrections.</li></ol><p>Taking all of that into account, the chart below shows roughly what I scribbled down some time in late 2011 as my “prediction” for what, in a perfect world, might be about to pan out in this market over the next couple of years.</p><p><em>I was guessing “a couple of years” based on the time it had already taken </em><strong><em>Wave i</em></strong><em> and (an as yet unconfirmed and possibly incomplete) </em><strong><em>Wave ii</em></strong><em> to play out. There weren’t really enough previous reference points to estimate forthcoming timeframes even though those relationships do often exist — I therefore just assumed </em>there might be some symmetry in terms of duration between <strong>Waves ii</strong> and <strong>iv</strong>:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/844/0*VcFdDK-6lJewmwSD." /></figure><p><em>And then, like any sane person would, I chuckled to myself, screwed it up and threw in in the bin. A 200x return from the current price in 2 years? Yeah, right….</em></p><p>Not that I wasn’t still confident that this initial Elliott Wave pattern <em>could</em> repeat itself at a greater scale.</p><p>Just surely not <em>that</em> scale!</p><p>So, after downing a dose of reality, I re-drew the same 5 wave chart but, this time, with a predicted <strong>Wave v </strong>peaking at a more realistic $100 over the same 2 year timeframe.</p><p>Still a very high risk long shot but ya never know.</p><p>— — — — — — -</p><p><strong>Bitcoin Bubble #2</strong></p><p>The rest, as they say, is history and, as is now clear for all to see, this is what did happen over those next 2 years.</p><p><strong>Waves i</strong>, <strong>ii</strong>,<strong> iii</strong>, <strong>iv</strong> and <strong>v</strong> themselves forming what I’ve now labelled as the next (larger) <strong>Primary Degree Wave 1</strong>. Sound familiar?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/836/0*-UUX1ePy3mOpspzw." /></figure><p>And (with much self-kicking) this is the same chart with the rough copy of my original scribbled chart overlaid on top:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/807/0*8cXVXnaLc0GHGXqK." /></figure><p>OK, so my timings were a little off. The duration of <strong>Waves ii</strong> &amp; <strong>iii</strong> ended up being longer than predicted; <strong>Wave’s iv &amp; v </strong>shorter than predicted; and the <strong>Wave iv</strong> correction deeper than my expected (typical) 50% retracement of <strong>Wave iii.</strong></p><p>Even so, the form and price targets had proven to be pretty damn accurate all the same.</p><p>Elliott’s theory (and not I) had predicted that:</p><ul><li><strong>Wave iii </strong>might peak at $255.20 vs an actual $259.34 (almost exactly the predicted 8x <strong>Wave i</strong>);</li><li><strong>Wave v</strong> might top at $925.10 vs an actual $1,163 (an overshoot at 36x <strong>Wave i</strong> instead of the predicted 29x — I’ll let you decide if you think a 20% margin of error is acceptable at the peak of a bubble mania phase)</li><li>the low point of <strong>Wave iv</strong> ($50) wouldn’t encroach on the peak point of <strong>Wave i </strong>($31.90) whilst, at the same time, forming a 5 wave triangle pattern</li></ul><p>So, what next?</p><p>As noted above, after the June ’11 $31.90 <strong>Wave i </strong>peak, the market gave back 95% of its gains to make an eventual low at $1.90 in Nov ‘11.</p><p>Now that you’re probably getting the hang of this, you’ll know that one possible assumption after the Nov ’13 <strong>Wave 1 </strong>bubble<strong> </strong>peaked<strong> </strong>at $1,163 might be, according to Elliott’s theory, that the market would again give back 95% of those gains.</p><p>Well, almost.</p><p>As it turns out the <strong>Wave 2</strong> correction ultimately gave back a mere 87% when it made a low at $152.40 in January ’15 as shown on the chart below.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/811/0*Y1FAweKFz2j8iCPD." /></figure><p>It was impossible to know for sure that that would mark a significant turning point at the time but, in hindsight, I guess we can say that it was an improvement on 2011!</p><p>Still, it’s always quite subjective in terms of where one decides to label the endpoint of a correction but by now we did have some clues as to where <strong>Wave 2</strong> might have been due to end — around June ’16 as labelled on the chart above (we’ll only ever be sure if this is true in distant hindsight, however).</p><p>— — — — —</p><p><strong>Wavelengths</strong></p><p>So far I’ve only looked at the <em>amplitudes</em> of the waves so as to identify peaks and troughs.</p><p>I mentioned earlier that, in terms of trying to predict the durations (or wavelengths) of forthcoming waves, there weren’t really enough previous reference points back in 2011.</p><p>By now, however, we had a few and so I’ll quickly explain.</p><p>It took 5 months (after the June ’11 <strong>Wave i </strong>bubble popped) for the market to hit a low at $1.90.</p><p>After an initial bounce to ~$7.20 the market settled down and hung around at just under $5.00 until May ’12. It was the break up through that resistance (<strong>11 months</strong> after the June ’11 peak) that felt significant to me at the time which is why I labelled that as the end of <strong>Wave ii.</strong></p><p><strong>Wave iii</strong> then peaked at $259.34 in early April ‘13.</p><p>So the time between the <strong>Wave ii </strong>low and the <strong>Wave iii </strong>peak was ~<strong>17 months</strong><em>.</em></p><p>Fast forward to the popping of the Nov ’13 bubble peak ($1,163).</p><p>This time it took <strong>13.5 months</strong> to reach what I’ve labelled as the <strong>Wave 2</strong> low in Jan ’15 at $152.40 (or <strong>2.7x</strong> the <strong>5 months</strong> it took for <strong>Wave ii </strong>to make its low).</p><p>So let’s use the factor of <strong>2.7</strong> to look at future wavelengths (durations).</p><p>If <strong>Wave ii </strong>lasted<strong> </strong>11 months, perhaps <strong>Wave 2</strong> would last <strong>30 months</strong> (11 x 2.7).</p><p>That would take us from the late Nov ’13 peak through to June ’16.</p><p>As it turned out, the period between Nov ’13 to the <strong>Wave 2</strong> low in Jan ’15 and then through to June ’16 displayed similar price action to that which occurred during <strong>Wave ii </strong>between June ’11 and May ’12 — i.e an initial strong bounce from the low point (this time to ~$500 then consolidating at ~$400) before breaking out to the upside just before the 2016 block reward halving in July ‘16.</p><p>It’s certainly slightly arbitrary but it’s the only clue we have so the table below shows what that 2.7 factor might tell us about any forthcoming wavelengths and the timings of future peaks for this current <strong>Primary Degree Cycle</strong>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/828/0*Di6KK6u-f-djK7-V." /></figure><p>We’ll come back to this later….</p><p>— — — — — — —</p><p>However, as we now start to flirt with the <strong>Wave 1</strong> high (in USD terms at least — most other currencies have already exceeded it) we can begin to postulate that <strong>Wave 3</strong> <em>might </em>have started in June ’16 on its merry march upwards (although we’d want to see that old high surpassed as an initial confirmation).</p><p><em>Note for reference that, when each of the </em><strong><em>Wave (i)</em></strong><em> and </em><strong><em>Wave i</em></strong><em> peaks were subsequently breached, those prices were never touched again.</em></p><p>Only time will tell if a breach of the <strong>Wave 1</strong> peak delivers a similar result.</p><p><em>Just for comparison’s sake at this point:</em></p><p><em>Bitcoin chart on 4th Jan ’17 as we head back towards the </em><strong><em>Wave 1</em></strong><em> peak</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*AFtf6XOvwpom6LRp." /></figure><p><em>And here’s what a bitcoin chart looked like just before we breached the </em><strong><em>Wave i</em></strong><em> peak in late Feb ‘13.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*W4myeeCVo-9aZSAW." /></figure><p><em>Edit: Writing this post whilst the bitcoin price has been so volatile this week ain’t easy! As of this morning (6th Jan) we’ve had a very strong two day sell off when the market failed to take out the previous $1163 high. We saw very similar price action in Feb ’13 as the market got back to within a whisker of its 2011 all time high at $31.90 before correcting sharply but then taking it out at a second attempt.</em></p><p><strong>Bitcoin Bubble #3?</strong></p><p>Now, finally, let’s get to the crux of what this (hopefully not too) rambling post might tell us about bitcoin’s next bubble — <strong>IF</strong> that bubble materialises at all.</p><p>Of course, the correlations I’ve highlighted may have just been pure coincidence.</p><p><em>Furthermore, without that original scribbled chart to validate my 2011 thoughts it’s tough for me to prove to you that I’m not simply surmising this analysis in retrospect. No matter really as the resulting numbers are there in black and white and you can </em><a href="http://imgur.com/Les9scO"><em>click here</em></a><em> to get a hint at my previous thinking in my last post on the subject in May ‘13.</em></p><p>Bitcoin may well survive and grow and, indeed, continue plotting valid Elliott Wave forms that bear little resemblance to the two I’ve identified here.</p><p>There is, of course, no <em>guarantee</em> that those patterns will repeat again at a grander scale — remember that during bubbles #1 and #2, and unlike today, there was virtually no capacity to short the market at any of the exchanges to exert any counter pressure as the bulls ran wild.</p><p>Also, bitcoin’s ongoing and unresolved scaling issues have so far been left at the door in this recent run up and the outcome of that remains to be seen.</p><p>And, without doubt, bitcoin could still just as easily crash and burn as has been <a href="https://99bitcoins.com/bitcoinobituaries/">predicted 119 times</a> already — consigned to history along with this post.</p><p>But,<em> just for laughs</em>, and so you can get back to doing something useful, let’s stick with it and see what those previous peaks and troughs might just predict today.</p><p>As I’m sure you’ve now guessed, the maths are quite simple.</p><p>In short, we’re simply looking for another larger fractal of our original <strong>Waves (i</strong>), <strong>(ii)</strong>, <strong>(iii)</strong>, <strong>(iv)</strong> and <strong>(v)</strong> that formed the original 2010–11 bubble.</p><p>Our original <strong>Wave (i)</strong> peaked at $1.10</p><p>Our eventual <strong>Wave 1</strong> peaked at (an almost exact 3 orders of magnitude greater) $1,163.</p><p>So will our forthcoming (?) <strong>Waves 3</strong>, <strong>4</strong>, and <strong>5</strong> simply also be 3 orders of magnitude greater in scale than <strong>Waves (i</strong>), <strong>(ii)</strong>, <strong>(iii)</strong>, <strong>(iv)</strong> and <strong>(v)</strong> and will the <em>wavelengths</em> I projected earlier be relevant too?</p><p>The previous peaks gave us an almost exact prediction of <strong>Wave iii</strong> reaching ~$255<strong> </strong>whilst giving us a 20% overshoot on on the predicted $925 target when <strong>Wave v peaked </strong>at $1,163.</p><p>That gives us the simple outcome that:</p><p>As before, a target for <strong>Wave 3</strong> <em>could</em> be 8x <strong>Wave 1</strong>.</p><p>Or £1163 x8 = $9,304</p><p>And <strong>Wave 5 </strong>might again, look to reach a price at 29x <strong>Wave 1</strong>.</p><p>Or £1163 x29 = $33,727 (+/- 20%)</p><p>And, finally, in between those two advancing waves we might again see a <strong>Wave 4</strong> correction, that, if analogous to <strong>Wave i</strong> in 2011, corrects back down to around $5,500, possibly by forming yet another <em>5 wave triangle pattern</em>, before a subsequent <strong>Wave 5</strong> mania begins.</p><p><em>My scribbled chart this time looks like this:</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/892/1*qSPcnHyJ5UMM-uWDdtnWAQ.png" /></figure><p>And that, intrepid reader, would complete our new <strong>Cycle Degree</strong> <strong>Wave I </strong>before — you guessed it — crashing again, giving back 80–90% of its gains as we progress through <strong>Cycle Degree</strong> <strong>Waves II, III, IV </strong>and<strong> V </strong>over the course of many, many years as wavelengths broaden whilst amplitudes increase in size.</p><p><strong><em>Do I think that sounds ridiculous?</em></strong></p><p>Of course. Bubbles and hype-cycles always are (in hindsight).</p><p><em>If</em> it ever gets to that stage the market will no doubt begin to behave much like any other <em>maturing</em> market with far more outside (and inside) influences to truly reflect “the crowd” with predictions becoming harder and harder.</p><p>I’m simply drawing past patterns to your attention and, as any good disclaimer should say:</p><p>Past performance is not an indicator of future outcomes.</p><p>These are only the opinions of the author and do not constitute investment advice.</p><p>Only invest what you can afford to lose as your investments can go <em>down</em> as well as up (or more often than not, <em>down</em> as well as <em>down</em>).</p><p><em>It’s just for laughs…</em></p><p><em>— — — — — — —</em></p><p><strong>About Me</strong></p><p><em>Paul Gordon</em></p><p>Formerly a derivatives trader for 20 years, I’ve been organising the UK’s largest bitcoin/blockchain meetup group, <a href="http://www.meetup.com/London-bitcoin-meetup/">Coinscrum</a>, since 2012.</p><p>Currently CEO at Quantave.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7c8df5fb9613" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>