<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Colleen Farrell on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Colleen Farrell on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@colleenmfarrell?source=rss-7a64c5a9dcbf------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 06:01:28 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@colleenmfarrell/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Subjectivity & Pain]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@colleenmfarrell/subjectivity-pain-c2c62a4b0f76?source=rss-7a64c5a9dcbf------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c2c62a4b0f76</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[medicine]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pain]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[health]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[poetry]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Colleen Farrell]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 01 Apr 2019 02:07:16 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-04-01T02:25:34.654Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>#MedHumChat №9</h3><p>At the very beginning of medical school, before classes had even begun, I was taught the acronym SOAP. S — Subjective; O — Objective; A — Assessment; P — Plan. This acronym was to guide how I spoke and wrote about patients for years to come.</p><p>Subjective, I was told, was what the patient told me. <em>It hurts here. I can’t breathe.</em></p><p>Objective was what the doctor observed. <em>Patient is in no acute distress. Breathing comfortably. No use of accessory muscles of respiration.</em></p><p>Such was my introduction to doubting my patients’ versions of things. What they said was subjective, but my observations were objective.</p><p>Soon I would hear what doctor’s said about pain behind the closed doors of the work room. <em>He’s just drug seeking. She doesn’t look like she’s in ten-out-of-ten pain. He’s being a baby.</em></p><p>These phrases appalled me. And then, years down the road, I caught myself thinking the same things. <em>I don’t believe you’re in that much pain.</em></p><p>For the person in pain, trying to put that pain into words is nearly impossible. And for the listener, when you have no way of seeing someone else’s pain, or feeling it for yourself, it requires trust and imagination to fully accept its existence. As physicians, listening to our patients’ accounts of their pain is central to our work. Yet by many accounts, we are quite bad at this core task. All too often, we doubt, disbelieve, question, brush off, ignore.</p><p>How can we push ourselves to do better? In this chat, we practiced listening deeply. We read and reflected on two powerful accounts of pain: <em>Pain Has An Element of Blank </em>by Emily Dickinson and <em>The Pain Scale </em>by Eula Biss.</p><h3>#MedHumChat №9 | March 20th, 2019</h3><p>Theme: Subjectivity and Pain</p><p><em>Poem: </em><a href="https://www.poemhunter.com/best-poems/emily-dickinson/pain-has-an-element-of-blank-2/">Pain Has an Element of Blank </a><em>by Emily Dickinson</em></p><p><em>Dickinson details the all-consuming experience of feeling pain.</em></p><p><em>Prose: </em><a href="http://www.snreview.org/biss.pdf">The Pain Scale</a> <em>by Eula Biss</em></p><p><em>Eula Biss wrestles with the complexity of experiencing pain and the fact that tools to “objectively” describe pain cannot communicate the subjective feeling.</em></p><h3>Pain Has an Element of Blank</h3><h4>1. How do interpret the Emily Dickinson poem? Did it change how you think about the experience of being in pain? Does it resonate with your experience?</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*qKfhIpSdeLzU0u-D" /></figure><h3>The Pain Scale</h3><h4>2. Trying to put pain into words so someone else will fully understand, is, in some sense, impossible. Biss gets at this impossibility in many powerful ways. What stood out to you?</h4><blockquote>The sensations of my own body may be the only subject on which I am qualified to claim expertise. Sad and terrible, then, how little I know. “How do you feel?” the doctor asks, and I cannot answer. Not accurately. “Does this hurt?” he asks. Again, I’m not sure. “Do you have more or less pain than the last time I saw you?” Hard to say. I begin to lie to protect my reputation. I try to act certain. — Eula Biss</blockquote><h4>3. Suffering for patients in pain, especially women, is so often compounded by being disbelieved by doctors. Biss expresses this many ways. Did you relate? What did you learn?</h4><blockquote>There is no evidence of pain on my body. No marks. No swelling. No terrible tumor. The X-Rays revealed nothing. Two MRIs of my brain and spine revealed nothing. Nothing was infected and festering, as I had suspected and feared. There was no ghastly huge white cloud on the film. There was nothing to illustrate my pain except a number, which I was told to choose from between zero and ten. My proof.</blockquote><blockquote>“This is a pathology,” the doctor assured me when he informed me that there was no definitive cause of my pain, no effective treatment for it, and very probably no end to it. “This is not in your head.” It would not have occurred to me to think that I was imagining the pain. But the longer the pain persisted, and the harder it became for me to imagine what it was like not to be in pain, the more seriously I considered the disturbing possibility that I was not, in fact, in pain. — Eula Biss</blockquote><h4>4. Pain is paradoxically universal yet isolating. How does Biss help us think about pain in connection with others?</h4><blockquote>Assigning a value to my own pain has never ceased to feel like a political act. I am a citizen of a country that ranks our comfort above any other concern. People suffer, I know, so that I may eat bananas in February. And then there is history . . . I struggle to consider my pain in proportion to the pain of a napalmed Vietnamese girl whose skin is slowly melting off as she walks naked in the sun. This exercise itself is painful.</blockquote><blockquote>“You are not meant to be rating world suffering,” my friend in Honduras advises. “This scale applies only to you and your experience.”</blockquote><blockquote>At first, this thought is tremendously relieving. It unburdens me of factoring the continent of Africa into my calculations. But the reality that my nerves alone feel my pain is terrifying. I hate the knowledge that I am isolated in this skin — alone with my pain and my own fallibility. — Eula Biss</blockquote><h4>5. What can we take from these readings to improve the care of patients in pain?</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*dNi9YHwwUlaUlKHZVCV6Ug.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Responses to Question 1:</h3><blockquote>How do interpret the Emily Dickinson poem? Did it change how you think about the experience of being in pain? Does it resonate with your experience?</blockquote><h3>MeegGMD on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A1 - I see many patients with fibromyalgia and they have used similar language to describe their experience of pain, it&#39;s hard to remember a time when pain was not there, it can be hard to imagine a future state without it. #medhumchat</p><h3>RanaAwdishMD on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A1. I also think the &quot;element of blank&quot; conjures a feeling of erasure. Pain erases so many other elements of the present. #medhumchat</p><h3>Lance Shaver MPH MScAH(c) on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A1. The first stanza resonated with me the most. I reflect on my own experience w/ chronic pain and this stanza captures it fully. I question whether it&#39;s always been this way. I also worry that I wouldn&#39;t recognize my own body if the pain were to disappear one day.</p><h3>Altaf Saadi on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A1. I love that pain is personified in her poem, that it exists outside the person, taking an identity and shape of its own, how pain can sometimes overcome our own identities. #medhumchat</p><h3>Beo_Beathach on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat My burst fracture L1, in &#39;99, was &quot;graduate school&quot; for me re: pain. The acute pain was nearly unbearable: all consuming of my senses and undertreated. Blank is a good term to describe the lack of thought that I had regarding anything else. #medhumchat</p><h3>Responses to Question 2:</h3><blockquote>Trying to put pain into words so someone else will fully understand, is, in some sense, impossible. Biss gets at this impossibility in many powerful ways. What stood out to you?</blockquote><h3>Emily Silverman on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A2: Our bodies speak to us in a strange, secret language. Sometimes, words cannot capture it. We grasp at common metaphors (pain as &quot;burning,&quot; &quot;twisting&quot;) which never sounds right, but all we have is words - language. #medhumchat</p><h3>ZacharySagerMD on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A2. This gets at the crux of what is so central in #HPM--how does one understand and appreciate an experience that is so individualized? How do I select a treatment for something that I might not be able to explain, see, feel? Sometimes I try to let the suffering wash over me.</p><h3>Hui-wen (Alina) Sato on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A2: There&#39;s such a strong sense of obligation to the doctor, of answering somehow the right way, the believable way, the understandable way, the treatable way. It&#39;s so hard to 1) discern and 2) just say what it is. #medhumchat</p><h3>Andy on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat This gives me more of a sense of the Dr-Pt power dynamic and the author knowing her body, her feelings is afraid/hesitant to share because of how she will be perceived/believed so instead &quot;lies&quot;. It&#39;s quite disheartening how common it is for patients to feel this way. #medhumchat</p><h3>Nicole Jochym on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A2. The &quot;begin to lie to protect my own reputation&quot; stands out to me and I interpret it in a second way. Often time, those with pain are fearful of even attempting to articulate their pain to a health care provider for fear of the bias that being in pain comes with.</p><h3>Responses to Question 3:</h3><blockquote>Suffering for patients in pain, especially women, is so often compounded by being disbelieved by doctors. Biss expresses this many ways. Did you relate? What did you learn?</blockquote><h3>Matthew Tyler on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A3 I&#39;ve always assumed it was reassuring to say &quot;this is not in your head&quot;. What I thought was a statement that aligned myself with my patient may actually be interpreted as condescending or patronizing. Biss is absolutely right, why wouldn&#39;t her pain be real? #medhumchat</p><h3>B. Bobby Chiong, MD 🔜 EDCLV on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat When I was in medical school, I was taught, &quot;Pain is whatever the patient says it is.&quot; I&#39;m not sure how I feel about that or if I believe it. But I&#39;ve thought a lot about that statement over the years. #medhumchat</p><h3>Diana Cejas, MD, MPH on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A3: I wonder about how much you have to hurt for doctors to believe that you are hurt. How much blood should you lose? How many wounds have to show?</p><h3>Allison Chrestensen on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat This piece made me think about how we&#39;ve designated physicians (as diagnosticians &amp;amp; prescribers of pain meds) and nurses (as dispensers of meds) as gate keepers. There is a tendency among pts to give the &quot;right&quot; answer to get what they need. #medhumchat</p><h3>Hui-wen (Alina) Sato on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A3: I&#39;ve had a pain experience dismissed as &quot;in my head&quot; and I felt humiliated and ashamed. Took a second opinion to validate a real reason for the pain, but I&#39;ll never quite forget the initial shame I felt bc of an &quot;expert&quot; opinion. Shame begets greater suffering. #medhumchat</p><h3>Responses to Question 4:</h3><blockquote>Pain is paradoxically universal yet isolating. How does Biss help us think about pain in connection with others?</blockquote><h3>MeegGMD on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A4 again drawing on my experience working w/ women with fibromyalgia - because &quot;the MRI is normal&quot; and patients describe the disease as &quot;invisible&quot; they express feeling very isolated. You can&#39;t walk through a medical center and know who feels the way you do #medhumchat</p><h3>Matthew Tyler on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A4 She does an excellent job highlighting the absurdity of a &quot;ceiling&quot; number for pain. How can my &quot;10/10&quot; possibly be the same as yours? &quot;The problem of pain is that I cannot feel my father&#39;s, and he cannot feel mine.&quot; #medhumchat</p><h3>Indu Partha, MD FACP on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A4: When I&#39;m suffering, hurting, it actually helps me to &quot;compare&quot; my suffering to others. It helps to maintain perspective, to allow me to not succumb to the pain/rough times, to help me maintain some degree of remembering all the good that I&#39;ve been given. #MedHumChat</p><h3>Beo_Beathach on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat Experiencing pain ourselves provides leverage to our ability to recognize, understand and sympathize as we interact with patients. My experience with severe acute and then daily chronic pain has made me more sensitive and useful to patients. #medhumchat</p><h3>Vishesh Jain on Twitter</h3><p>@Beo_Beathach @medhumchat I worry and wonder about this. How likely is one&#39;s own pain to improve empathy as you beautifully describe, vs create an arbitrary standard against which one implicitly judges others&#39; pain? Eg &quot;I&#39;ve been through that and never needed so much medicine...&quot; #medhumchat</p><h3>Responses to Question 5:</h3><blockquote>What can we take from these readings to improve the care of patients in pain?</blockquote><h3>Diana Cejas, MD, MPH on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat Q5: To remember that pain is experienced in as many ways as there are people. To think about how much our biases effect our perceptions of our own pain and the pain of others. #MedHumChat</p><h3>Nathan Douthit, MD on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A5. For me--resist the urge to quantify and reflexively treat. Like with unexplained fever, pain needs investigation, not just Tylenol. To do so means to listen, empathize and wait. Understand that the patient feels this won&#39;t end, and may speak that way. #medhumchat</p><h3>B. Bobby Chiong, MD 🔜 EDCLV on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat Take home for me: listen to patients and believe patients. Let the patient tell their story, their way. Easier said than done, I know. #medhumchat</p><h3>Briana Ruíz Christophers on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A5. To never dismiss pain and know that we can never truly understand it. To think of pain broadly as not just something affecting an individual but also having broader effects. Pain has the capacity to transform a person &amp;amp; open up a new &quot;blank&quot; space before them... #medhumchat</p><h3>Allison Chrestensen on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat An acknowledgement of all the ways we systematize &amp;amp; dehumanize pain. An opportunity for individual clinicians to meet patients in pain on a human level. &quot;I can&#39;t know exactly how this feels for you. I will stay with you.&quot; #medhumchat</p><p><em>Thank you to all of our participants for sharing their reflections and making these rich discussions possible. Going forward, </em><a href="https://twitter.com/hashtag/medhumchat?src=hash"><em>#medhumchat</em></a><em> will be approximately every other week. A schedule for chats through June will be released soon.</em></p><p><em>Medical Humanities Chat is hosted by </em><a href="https://www.colleenmfarrell.com/"><em>Dr. Colleen Farrell</em></a><em>. The mission of #medhumchat is to foster reflection, empathy, and connection in healthcare through discussions of poetry and prose. Find information on past and upcoming chats </em><a href="https://www.colleenmfarrell.com/medhumchat"><em>here</em></a><em>. Visit </em><a href="https://twitter.com/medhumchat"><em>@medhumchat</em></a><em> to join our next chat.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c2c62a4b0f76" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Body as Garden—A Metaphor for Medicine?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@colleenmfarrell/the-body-as-garden-a-metaphor-for-medicine-8af97a5a5061?source=rss-7a64c5a9dcbf------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8af97a5a5061</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[narrative-medicine]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gardening]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[medicine]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[health]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nature]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Colleen Farrell]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 24 Mar 2019 22:15:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-03-24T22:19:24.353Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>#MedHumChat №8</h3><p>In medical school, I was taught to think of the body as machine. The body has a pump—the heart. It has hinges—the joints. It has a waste filter—the kidneys. Learning about the body mechanistically is, of course, important. It is how we learn to diagnose and treat disease.</p><p>But at what point does understanding the body as a machine hinder our ability to care for human beings? How else might we think of the body?</p><p>In this #medhumchat, we read works by two physicians—Zachary Sager and Victoria Sweet—who have approached medicine by thinking of the body as a garden. We explored what gardening can teach us as we care for our patients, each other, and ourselves.</p><h3>#MedHumChat №8 | March 6th, 2019</h3><p>Theme: The Body as Garden</p><p>Special Guest: Zachary Sager: a psychiatrist, researcher, and palliative care physician <a href="https://twitter.com/ZacharySagerMD">@ZacharySagerMD</a></p><p><em>Prose: </em><a href="https://t.co/PtMNLANbHS"><em>“Nurturing Medicine”</em></a><em> by Zachary Sager, MD</em></p><p><em>In this essay, Dr. Sager explores the similarities between gardening and doctoring and the way gardening transformed his approach to healing others.</em></p><p><em>Prose: </em><a href="https://twitter.com/medhumchat/status/1100954822843551744">A passage from God’s Hotel<em> </em></a><em>by Victoria Sweet, MD</em></p><p><em>In treating a patient for two years at Laguna Honda Hospital, Dr. Sweet realizes that healing is as Hildegard von Bingen, writing in the twelfth century, described it: a natural, slow, human process, driven by the patient herself.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/333/0*hVHfjDy-XrYT-ucy" /></figure><h3>Nurturing Medicine</h3><h4>1. Before we discuss the texts, I’d like to take a few minutes to reflect on our relationships with gardening and nature. Feel free to share stories, photos, musings.</h4><h4>2. What insights does Dr. Sager learn about death from his gardening? Does this resonate with your own thinking about death?</h4><blockquote>“I saw that in the garden, death was expected and ordinary. But in medicine, death was a dreaded failure. If I had looked harder, diagnosed sooner, found the right treatment, maybe the inevitable could be staved off.”</blockquote><blockquote>— Dr. Sager</blockquote><h4>3. Dr. Sager also gains a new perspective on trauma and resilience through his reflections on nature. Does this perspective resonate with you?</h4><blockquote>“Death Valley, despite its dry and hot climate, is home to more than 1000 species of plants, including wildflowers that bloom after rainfall in the spring. Sometimes, years will pass between large blooms, the ecosystem waiting for the right conditions. Like plants, people can thrive in inhospitable places. Every day I see individuals who have endured overwhelming trauma only to find meaning and growth as life fades, making time for laughter, connecting with distant relatives, and renewing frayed bonds with those closest to them.” — Dr. Sager</blockquote><h3>A Passage from God’s Hotel</h3><h4>4. Modern medicine usually laughs at antiquated medical ideas (bloodletting, leeches, etc), but Dr. Sweet finds wisdom in Hildegard von Bingen’s 12th century approach. What did you take from the God’s Hotel excerpt?</h4><blockquote>“Whether there is such a thing as the healing power of nature is, perhaps, beside the point. What I do know for sure is that it is a useful way of looking at my patients’ bodies; it gives me a way of imagining that the body’s natural state is to be whole, perfect, and without blemish. And it is what differentiates the living body from a machine: because if nothing interferes, the body, unlike a machine, will heal itself.” — Dr. Sweet</blockquote><h3><strong>General Reflection</strong></h3><h4>5. How might you use the garden metaphor to approach caring for your patients, loved ones, or yourself?</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*q9sDgacEuAd4oaCqa45VbQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/photos/ruQHpukrN7c?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">Francesco Gallarotti</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/search/photos/gardening?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><h3>Responses to Question 1:</h3><blockquote>Before we discuss the texts, I’d like to take a few minutes to reflect on our relationships with gardening and nature. Feel free to share stories, photos, musings.</blockquote><h3>B. Bobby Chiong, MD on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat I took this picture last weekend. I hate being inside. Wish I was better about going out and taking walks to clear my head during the day. Being underexposed to nature is a huge problem for most people, I think. #medhumchat</p><h3>Briana Ruíz Christophers on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A1. Nature is a huge source of balance &amp;amp; perspective for me (esp as a hobby nature photographer for a decade, insta @justbriithephotography) but I did not inherit the gardening aptitude my mother &amp;amp; aunt possess 😂 I have a succulent that has miraculously lived 2 years #medhumchat</p><h3>Jennifer Madeline on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A1 I used to have a black thumb, even managing to kill succulents, then I took to evaluating my plants 2-3 times per week for water, repotting, feeding etc and they&#39;re thriving, and I find I think of it as rounding on my plants #medhumchat</p><h3>Laura Michaeli on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat #medhumchat I&#39;ve had so many &#39;impossible&#39; gardens: perennials in college, a plant that jumped into the NYC air shaft, a 2 foot space in front of my parking spot where I tended to unwind at 3 am when I got home from the ED shift.</p><h3>ZacharySagerMD on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat lots of folks saying they aren&#39;t a &#39;good&#39; gardener. What I love is the plants tell you what they need, and there is a learning curve...but they are resilient. I&#39;m reminded when I see stray tomato plants sprout up in sidewalk cracks #medhumchat</p><h3>Responses to Question 2:</h3><blockquote>What insights does Dr. Sager learn about death from his gardening? Does this resonate with your own thinking about death?</blockquote><h3>Kirsta Hoffman on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat @ZacharySagerMD A2. The paradigm shift from working hard to save something at all costs to becoming a guide, someone that tends to something and helps guide it down a path. A nurturer. #medhumchat</p><h3>Alex Azan on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat @ZacharySagerMD I believe in finding beauty in the seemingly uncontrollable rhythms of nature, of life, but also acknowledging the structural influences on said rhythm (racism, financial disinvestment, etc.) so that we can try to prevent deaths that are our, not deaths, doing. #MedHumChat</p><h3>Matthew Tyler on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat @ZacharySagerMD A2 It&#39;s an important lesson that death is as natural as birth. It&#39;s also important to not view death as &quot;failure&quot;. Even so, it&#39;s hard to quiet that voice in your head that asks &quot;did I do everything I could?&quot;, &quot;would someone smarter have saved this person?&quot; #medhumchat</p><h3>ZacharySagerMD on Twitter</h3><p>@alinasato @medhumchat Yes! For me recognizing I had very little(or no) control was liberating, and really allowed me to focus on the person, not the illness. It&#39;s what I love about #HPM and my work. #medhumchat</p><h3>Alessandra Colaianni on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat @ZacharySagerMD #medhumchat A2: I was struck by how gentle the process of death can be when we look at it as a natural part of life. As opposed to the violent, unnatural deaths we sometimes subject patients to in-hospital. Death as failure plays into the idea that &quot;we should do everything.</p><h3>Responses to Question 3:</h3><blockquote>Dr. Sager also gains a new perspective on trauma and resilience through his reflections on nature. Does this perspective resonate with you?</blockquote><h3>ZacharySagerMD on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat For me I saw people who had such difficult and downright terrible experiences in life, but in the process of dying would find strength to flourish, forgive, thrive. It really taught me how resilient individuals are #medhumchat</p><h3>Hui-wen (Alina) Sato on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat @ZacharySagerMD A3: I&#39;ve beheld a couple of pts recently who display inexplicable joy despite all they&#39;ve endured and are still recovering from. They and their families have taught me that deep, substantial hope and life are possible where I&#39;d have only expected despair. #medhumchat</p><h3>Designer turned Doctor: Chris Sebastian on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat @ZacharySagerMD A3: Miracles don&#39;t end at birth. We are witnesses to incredible stories every day, but it&#39;s easy to miss- can you find it if you&#39;re not looking for it? #MedHumChat</p><h3>Briana Ruíz Christophers on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat @ZacharySagerMD A3. I love the part about &quot;waiting for the right conditions.&quot; As a developmental biologist &amp;amp; future doc that is what I think about: how do time, space &amp;amp; interactions come together for one &amp;amp; collective? Can we nurture an environment of &quot;right conditions?&quot; #medhumchat #DoubleDocs</p><h3>Becca Omlor on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat @ZacharySagerMD #medhumchat I am constantly humbled by how people allow me the enter their lives at the pivotal moment, and deeply honored to become a temporary fixture in their life tapestry.</p><h3>Responses to Question 4:</h3><blockquote>Modern medicine usually laughs at antiquated medical ideas (bloodletting, leeches, etc), but Dr. Sweet finds wisdom in Hildegard von Bingen’s 12th century approach. What did you take from the God’s Hotel excerpt?</blockquote><h3>Briana Ruíz Christophers on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A4. One takeaway I had from reading is how we do not heal the body, the body heals itself (with time and maybe a little bit of help). We are helpers in the healing process and maybe &quot;healers&quot; is a misnomer for our profession... #medhumchat</p><h3>Kirsta Hoffman on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A4. I think we have created a culture where we expect things to heal faster by adding modern medicine. It can help (and may be how some things heal, they require intervention), but I think we&#39;ve forgotten about things that heal with time. #medhumchat</p><h3>MeegGMD on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A4 - there are some many things we can&#39;t predict, so many &quot;idiosyncratic&quot; responses, pts outliving their prognoses etc. And #EBM doesn&#39;t address everything, uncertainty exists. There are clearly aspects of healing that do not conform to the norms of Western medicine. #medhumchat</p><h3>Matthew Tyler on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A4 I struggle with this on a few levels. I worry about the different levels of interpretation that can be applied to &quot;without blemish&quot;. I also feel that it takes a very holistic understanding of &quot;healing&quot; to reconcile this sentiment in the face of serious illness #medhumchat</p><h3>Indu Partha, MD FACP on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A4: I don&#39;t think I agree. I don&#39;t think the body&#39;s natural state is unblemished. I think it is a little tarnished, a bit broken, often asymmetric. And that&#39;s okay. I don&#39;t think my natural state is the same as another&#39;s. Too much impact of &quot;nurture&quot; on &quot;nature&quot; #medhumchat</p><h3>Responses to Question 5:</h3><blockquote>How might you use the garden metaphor to approach caring for your patients, loved ones, or yourself?</blockquote><h3>ZacharySagerMD on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat For me it&#39;s also that while we can see ourselves as gardeners, we are the plants too. We need rich soil, we need to be tended too and take care of ourselves in order to grow. Reminding myself that I&#39;m a plant prioritizes my own self care #medhumchat</p><h3>Hui-wen (Alina) Sato on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A5: Pay close and then closer attention to signals of what the person really actually craves. Don&#39;t underestimate the basics of what&#39;s needed for life, but don&#39;t use them to suffocate. Step back and know things will grow - or not - bc of you and/but also despite you.</p><h3>Alex Azan on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A5:To remember life, whether in a flower, a body, or a shared interaction is a gift of love that the world gets to know, celebrate, and learn from. Medicine, in my opinion, is a skill set that helps &quot;us&quot; to remember, fight to prolong, and at times just respect, this.</p><h3>Briana Ruíz Christophers on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A5. This metaphor has really helped me conceptualize how as physicians we are no more &quot;god-like&quot; than a gardener is with their garden. They merely help the garden along but the flowers/plants/nature do their thing and the gardener is just a piece of the cycle #medhumchat</p><h3>Carly Sokach on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A5: to stay focused on the beauty of the moment - each &amp;amp; every bloom is worth celebrating! Gardens faces many &quot;ends of seasons&quot; but we can prepare for them and approach each one with the memory of all the incredible blooms that led us to that point. #MedHumChat</p><p><em>Thank you to all of our participants for sharing their reflections and making these rich discussions possible.</em></p><p><em>Medical Humanities Chat is hosted by </em><a href="https://www.colleenmfarrell.com/"><em>Dr. Colleen Farrell</em></a><em>. The mission of #medhumchat is to foster reflection, empathy, and connection in healthcare through discussions of poetry and prose. Find information on past and upcoming chats </em><a href="https://www.colleenmfarrell.com/medhumchat"><em>here</em></a><em>. Visit </em><a href="https://twitter.com/medhumchat"><em>@medhumchat</em></a><em> to join our next chat.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8af97a5a5061" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[No Crystal Ball: Profound Uncertainty in the Patient Experience]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@colleenmfarrell/no-crystal-ball-profound-uncertainty-in-the-patient-experience-465d55b9cb44?source=rss-7a64c5a9dcbf------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/465d55b9cb44</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[narrative-medicine]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[poetry]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cancer]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[healthcare]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[medicine]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Colleen Farrell]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 13 Mar 2019 02:19:36 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-03-24T22:55:30.819Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>#MedHumChat №7</h3><p>“I’m waiting for him to read / my fortune,” Chana Bloch writes in her poem “In the Land of the Body (#2).” She is waiting for her doctor to interpret some kind of image—an xray, or perhaps at CT. These radiographic images are strikingly modern technologies. But in this poem, Bloch harkens to the age old practice of interpreting stars in the night sky. Woven into this poem is a question we all ask, <em>what does my future old? </em>Can a doctor answer that question?</p><p>In this chat, we explored the profound, existential uncertainty patients face. Even with all the clinical trials and mathematical modeling of modern medicine, the unique course of an individual’s life simply cannot be known. How does one live—and live well—under such circumstances?</p><h3>#MedHumChat №7 | February 27th, 2019</h3><p>Theme: Profound Uncertainty in the Patient Experience</p><p><em>Prose: </em><a href="http://nyti.ms/2uwj7ty"><em>“How Long Have I Got Left?”</em></a><em> by Paul Kalanithi, MD</em></p><p><em>From his perspective as a neurosurgeon with metastatic lung cancer, Dr. Kalanithi reflects on his statistical understanding of morality and the inherent uncertainty of his life.</em></p><p><em>Poem: </em><a href="https://twitter.com/medhumchat/status/1100939193554010112"><em>“In the Land of the Body (#2)”</em></a><em> by Chana Bloch, PhD</em></p><p><em>Dr. Bloch describes the ambiguity of a radiographic image as she waits in uncertainty for her diagnosis.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*QAcT3OMD8ag6ja0Fv5YxiA.jpeg" /></figure><h3>How Long Have I Got Left?</h3><h4>1. Kalanithi wrestles with a desire for prognostic and statistical certainty. How do you interpret his relationship with statistical data? Does it resonate with your own experience?</h4><blockquote>“Poring over studies, I kept trying to find the one that would tell me when my number would be up… Getting too deep into statistics is like trying to quench a thirst with salty water. The angst of facing mortality has no remedy in probability.” — Paul Kalanithi</blockquote><h4>2. Kalanithi writes powerfully of the profound uncertainty that comes with his diagnosis. How does his story deepen your understanding of uncertainty, and what it feels like to live with it?</h4><blockquote>“In a way, though, the certainty of death was easier than this uncertain life. The path forward would seem obvious, if only I knew how many months or years I had left. Tell me three months, I’d just spend time with family. Tell me one year, I’d have a plan (write that book). Give me 10 years, I’d get back to treating diseases. The pedestrian truth that you live one day at a time didn’t help: What was I supposed to do with that day?” — Paul Kalanithi</blockquote><h3>In the Land of the Body (#2)</h3><h4>3. What words or images stand out to you in the poem?</h4><h4>4. How is uncertainty expressed in this poem?</h4><h3>General Reflection:</h3><h4>5. Reflecting on the pieces we read tonight, what can doctors and other caretakers do to support patients as they face profound uncertainty?</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*LDnaiijMgd1Xk2Zuoe3CKg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/photos/fa73YB-Vono?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">Jonas Verstuyft</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/search/photos/night-sky?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><h3>Responses to Question 1:</h3><blockquote>How do you interpret Kalanithi’s relationship with statistical data? Does it resonate with your own experience?</blockquote><h3>Carly Sokach on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A1: we face this struggle in so many ways throughout medical school. We work so hard to understand the nitty gritty of scientific processes and sometimes lose sight of the reason why we&#39;re learning these things - losing sight of the forest through the trees #MedHumChat 1/</p><h3>Priya Kantesaria on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A1: I think this excerpt focuses on the the real melancholy of statistics. Often to deal with a difficult prognosis, people turn to stats to gain hope, or rally against it thinking that they would be the exception. This conundrum I think lends itself to the quote. #medhumchat</p><h3>Robert Rosencrans on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat My struggle with (descriptive) statistics was better summarized by Steven Jay Gould: &quot;the median isn&#39;t the message.&quot; No one has any obligation to be the central tendency of their distribution, though that&#39;s the number that&#39;s most often quoted. #medhumchat</p><h3>Hui-wen (Alina) Sato on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A1: I see him as someone who, like all of us, has life goals that suddenly have to be speed-prioritized. He writes about how he wants to figure out what he can actually do given his guesstimate on his time left. He wants some guide for this prioritizing. #medhumchat</p><h3>brooke kowalke on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A1 we asked for all kinds of statistics when we got our daughter&#39;s diagnoses. In the end, they didn&#39;t mean much. It was interesting to me to see a doctor-who knows better-ask the same things and want answers like this. #medhumchat</p><h3>Responses to Question 2:</h3><blockquote>How does Kalanithi’ story deepen your understanding of uncertainty, and what it feels like to live with it?</blockquote><h3>UroPoet on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat @medhumchat It&#39;s really quit a soul crushing paradox How can I live, while I&#39;m dying? #medhumchat</p><h3>Briana Ruíz Christophers on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A2. The piece left me unsettled - even as a physician Kalanithi feeling the symptoms, knowing how to read the scans and read the literature, he cannot change what might happen. But then again the ending is thus more powerful bc he still chooses to go on #medhumchat</p><h3>Kirsta Hoffman on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A2. It reminds me that I shouldn&#39;t assume that what I&#39;m telling a patient is what they want, or really need, to hear. But also that I may not have all the answers to all of their questions. Maybe we need to be better guides through death? #medhumchat</p><h3>Becca Omlor on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A2. #medhumchat I think one of the hardest lessons in medicine is to be able to sit with the uncertainty. I&#39;m still learning how to do this without falling back to the security of data-vomiting.</p><h3>Responses to Question 3:</h3><blockquote>What words or images stand out to you in the poem?</blockquote><h3>Diana Cejas, MD, MPH on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A3: &quot;the star he&#39;s discovered but hasn&#39;t named&quot; sticks with me. I get the feeling that both people in this poem know that star&#39;s name &amp;amp; exactly what it is. It feels like the speaker is painting a beautiful picture that distances themselves from the situation... #MedHumChat</p><h3>Nathan Douthit, MD on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A3. The word translated--as a patient, to see the body in a different language, which needs a translator, a doctor. Helping patients to understand something about themselves has to be one of the hardest greatest honors of being a physician, especially with bad news. #MedHumChat</p><h3>Priya Kantesaria on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A3: My eyes were always draw to the words &quot;soft blind organs.&quot; To me, the body has always confounded me. It all looks like a a random bundle of...things. This one line reminds me of my own view of the human body, that its soft, and unassuming...with great power.</p><h3>Carly Sokach on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A3: the contrast between dark and light throughout the poem really struck me - &quot;black air...dark pupil...shades of grey&quot; vs. &quot;swirls of light...white eye...burst of rays.&quot; #MedHumChat</p><h3>Matthew Tyler on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A3 I love the allusion to fortune telling. The way we point to imaging studies at the bedside with such certainty... I wonder if it looks like we are reading tea leaves sometimes? #medhumchat</p><h3>Corbin Stinnett on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A2: &quot;a burst of rays around the star he discovered&quot; After reading the book, the little prince, normally such a statement would be full of positivity. This positive connotation is subverted, and that really stood out to me. #medhumchat</p><h3>Responses to Question 4:</h3><blockquote>How is uncertainty expressed in this poem?</blockquote><h3>Amelie on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A4: She describes the xray as a fortune waiting to be read, the tumor as &quot;the star he&#39;s discovered/ but not yet named&quot;. Takes a diagnostic image &amp;amp; connects it to things in the spiritual &amp;amp; natural world to which we ascribe magic/mysticism (fortune telling, astronomy) #medhumchat</p><h3>Irène P. Mathieu on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A4: Sorry I&#39;m late to #medhumchat! I love the imagery in this poem - At times it&#39;s unclear how the images relate to parts of the body, or to which parts of the body. For me that disorientation conveys uncertainty.</p><h3>Becca Omlor on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat #medhumchat I think so much of medicine lives in the &quot;relative shades of gray&quot;, and like Paul Kalanithi notes, there&#39;s no statistic that can really change the gray into black or white.</p><h3>Hui-wen (Alina) Sato on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A4: &quot;values on a scale, relative&quot; We do this all the time. Let me give you the good news, perhaps downplay the bad news. Or do I know what is good news / bad news to you? Is it my scale we are going by or yours?</p><h3>Responses to Question 5:</h3><blockquote>Reflecting on the pieces we read tonight, what can doctors and other caretakers do to support patients as they face profound uncertainty?</blockquote><h3>Nathan Douthit, MD on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A5. Be patient with them. Listen to them. Say I don&#39;t know. Help them talk through what they want to do and how they want to pursue it. Realize their values and help them to be successful in illness-no matter how they define that success. #MedHumChat</p><h3>Matthew Tyler on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A5 If nothing else we can be honest about uncertainty, and acknowledge the struggle in deciding how to move forward.</p><h3>Irène P. Mathieu on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A5: I loved this line from Kalanithi&#39;s essay: &quot;The fact of death is unsettling. Yet there is no other way to live.&quot; There&#39;s a tension between the certainty of death &amp;amp; the pedestrian nature of so much of life (replying to emails, washing dishes)... #medhumchat</p><h3>Irène P. Mathieu on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A5: ...which makes me think about mindfulness - how we might learn to take joy in even the smallest moments - and about how physicians might help our patients (&amp;amp; ourselves) with this practice. #medhumchat</p><h3>Amelie on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A5: Meet them where they&#39;re at. Don&#39;t rush them through processing. Be there to talk, but don&#39;t force conversations. Listen actively &amp;amp; be willing to sit w/ fear, discomfort, anger, etc. Hold space for their feelings, make sure you have your own support network, too. #medhumchat</p><h3>Diana Cejas, MD, MPH on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A5: listening is a good way to start. Sometimes I think that we try to fill silence or make up for our own uncertainty by inundating patients with data. That isn&#39;t always helpful. Sometimes listening, being present in uncomfortable moments with them, goes a long way #MedHumChat</p><p><em>Thank you to all of our participants for sharing their reflections and making these rich discussions possible.</em></p><p><em>Medical Humanities Chat is hosted by </em><a href="https://www.colleenmfarrell.com/"><em>Dr. Colleen Farrell</em></a><em>. The mission of #medhumchat is to foster reflection, empathy, and connection in healthcare through discussions of poetry and prose. Find information on past and upcoming chats </em><a href="https://www.colleenmfarrell.com/medhumchat"><em>here</em></a><em>. Visit </em><a href="https://twitter.com/medhumchat"><em>@medhumchat</em></a><em> to join our next chat.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=465d55b9cb44" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“We know what makes us ill”]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@colleenmfarrell/we-know-what-makes-us-ill-1d802394ff52?source=rss-7a64c5a9dcbf------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1d802394ff52</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[healthcare]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[homelessness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[poetry]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[medical-humanities]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[poverty]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Colleen Farrell]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 05 Mar 2019 01:10:30 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-03-24T22:50:18.416Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Poverty, Homeless, and Health in the Poetry of Bertolt Brecht</h3><h3>#MedHumChat №6</h3><p>In my first year of medical school, a health policy professor showed us a slide with pie chart and pointed to one little sliver. The pie represented patients’ health. That sliver, <a href="https://nam.edu/social-determinants-of-health-101-for-health-care-five-plus-five/">between ten and twenty percent</a>, was the impact that modern medical care is thought to have on our patients’ health. I was shocked. Wasn’t I in medical school to prevent and treat disease? How could our impact be so small? And what was the other eighty to ninety percent?</p><p>The vast majority of the pie is the social determinants of health (SDOH)—factors like structural inequality, poverty, homelessness. I received several data-filled lectures on SDOH in medical school. But it wasn’t until I began caring for patients that I had any visceral understanding of the SDOH.</p><p>I care for a man who immigrated to the US some thirty years ago, leaving his wife and toddler behind. He labored for decades, sending money to his family. In his loneliness and isolation, he drank. After decades apart, he’s been reunited with his family and no longer drinks. But the damage to his liver is irreversible and will cut years off his life. What might his life have been had he not been borne into poverty? How much pain and suffering could have been spared had he been able to be with his family whilst earning enough to live?</p><p>In this chat, we read two poems by Bertolt Brecht, the German poet and playwright, that humanize the social determinants of health and call on those with power and resources — including doctors — to advocate for change. Brecht wrote from a time and place different from our own. His poem <em>A Bed for the Night </em>was written between 1929 and 1933, as Hitler was coming to power in Germany. And yet, the themes of his work are so relevant to our current times. We were joined in this discussion by Dr. Kelly Doran and Dr. David Rosenthal, both of whom care for patients facing poverty and homelessness, research SDOH, and advocate for change</p><h3>#MedHumChat №6 | February 20th, 2019</h3><p>Theme: Poverty, Homeless, &amp; Health in the Poetry of Bertolt Brecht</p><p><a href="http://bit.ly/2N4QOss"><em>A Worker’s Speech to a Doctor</em></a></p><p><em>A worker challenges a doctor to see how a detached biomedical analysis fails to recognize the social and economic factors that drive disease.</em></p><p><a href="http://bit.ly/2SnME4C"><em>A Bed for the Night</em></a></p><p><em>A man on a New York Street corner finds beds for people experiencing homelessness. This goodness counts for something, is it enough?</em></p><p>Special Guests: <a href="https://nyulangone.org/doctors/1043416555/kelly-m-doran">Dr. Kelly Doran</a> &amp; <a href="https://medicine.yale.edu/intmed/people/david_i_rosenthal.profile">Dr. David Rosenthal</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8kM4Q2liWqqcq4IjZ4xtRQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/photos/lWqirKztRno?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">Matt McNulty</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/search/photos/subway?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><h3>A Worker’s Speech to a Doctor</h3><h4>1. The poem draws us into the clinical encounter — naked body, ragged clothes. How does it speak to the root causes of illness?</h4><blockquote>“And you listen all over our naked body.<br> As to the cause of our illness <br>A glance at our rags would be more <br>Revealing”</blockquote><h4>2. The poem is critical of advice from doctors. When have you given, received, or overheard medical advice that was out of touch with social context? How did you feel about it?</h4><blockquote>“Too much work and too little food <br>Make us weak and scrawny. <br>Your prescription says: <br>Put on more weight. <br>You might as well tell a fish <br>Go climb a tree”</blockquote><h4>3. The ending of the poem is especially evocative. Especially for those who practice medicine, how can we avoid defensiveness and learn from these lines?</h4><blockquote>“You’ll no doubt protest <br>Your innocence. <br>The damp patch <br>On the wall of our apartments <br>Tells the same story.”</blockquote><h3>A Bed for the Night</h3><h4>4. The poem has a really interesting structure, with repetition of lines, interrupted by the direct statement: “Don’t put down the book on reading this, man.” What meaning is conveyed with this structure?</h4><h4>5. What role do you think physicians and the broader healthcare system should play in addressing poverty, homelessness and other social determinants of health?</h4><h3>Responses to Question 1:</h3><blockquote>The poem draws us into the clinical encounter — naked body, ragged clothes. How does it speak to the root causes of illness?</blockquote><h3>Kelly Doran on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat We could almost write this poem in #SDOH ICD-10 Z codes: Z59.4 (lack of adequate food), Z59.1 (inadequate housing), Z56.6 (other physical &amp;amp; mental strain related to work), Z59.5 (extreme poverty), Z59.8 (other problems related to housing &amp;amp; economic circumstances). #medhumchat</p><h3>David Rosenthal MD on Twitter</h3><p>A1. Struck by how we often looking for &quot;causes&quot; of illness - when patients may simply want treatment and care, rather than cause #medhumchat</p><h3>Nathan Douthit, MD on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A1. One and the same cause wears out our bodies and our clothes We can&#39;t separate the social determinants of our patients from their illnesses. The examiner looks past the modifiable cause of the disease and looks only to palliation of the symptoms. He&#39;s not healing. #medhumchat</p><h3>Carly Sokach on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A1: We tend to take patients out of the context of their daily life in the hospital. Everyone wears a hospital gown, we treat their acute conditions, and only worry about social barriers when discharge comes. That context is critical to long-term health. #MedHumChat</p><h3>Amar Kelkar MD on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A1. &quot;One and the same cause wears out Our bodies and our clothes.&quot; Illness is a product of environments. Here it&#39;s depicted literally with jarring, traumatic imagery to help us identify with the &quot;worker&quot; and it&#39;s in stark contrast to the ivory tower of Medicine. #medhumchat</p><h3>Maria Coluccio on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat The physician is literally removing the social aspects of the illness (listening all over our naked bodies), to find a biological dx. IMO, its speaking more towards the medical fields&#39; focus on the physical rather than the societal causes of illness. #Medhumchat</p><h3>Megan, but stressed on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A1 Other than homelessness I think of pts with long healthcare issues or disability or chronic conditions.</p><h3>Responses to Question 2:</h3><blockquote>The poem is critical of advice from doctors. When have you given, received, or overheard medical advice that was out of touch with social context? How did you feel about it?</blockquote><h3>Kelly Doran on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A2. Though I&#39;m a big advocate in the #SDOH sphere I don&#39;t blame or harshly judge doctors. Even if we were taught this stuff in med school, it&#39;s still really hard. Most docs I know feel pretty strong emotions related to their patients&#39; social struggles (1/2) #medhumchat</p><h3>Kelly Doran on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A2. Doctors often fear even asking the questions since they can&#39;t &quot;fix&quot; the social context, which of course results in being out of touch. But even if we can&#39;t solve underlying problems, often we can at least make tweaks in tx plans. So it&#39;s worth seeking to learn. #medhumchat</p><h3>David Rosenthal MD on Twitter</h3><p>A2. Homelessness and poverty often take years, takes continuity, trust and months (sometimes forever) to address. We can&#39;t expect to solve all problems in one or two or even 10 encounters. It takes time and TRUST must be earned. #medhumchat</p><h3>Diana Cejas, MD, MPH on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A2. As a student, I listened as a doc suggested that a pt w/ diabetes try joining an expensive gym, then learn that she was rationing her meds because she couldn&#39;t afford to pay for them &amp;amp; her rent too.</p><h3>Indu Partha, MD FACP on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat &quot;Go our and walk in the neighborhood&quot; neglecting the fact that their surroundings are violence-ridden. &quot;Eat more fruits/veg&quot; forgetting they can barely afford boxed max&amp;amp;cheese. &quot;Here&#39;s info about your illness&quot; not realizing pt can&#39;t read or not fluent in English. #MedHumChat</p><h3>Jennifer Madeline on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A2 as a student had many pts who lived where there was no grocery store in their zip code, only fast food and convenience stores. Saw much advice given about eating healthy diet, but no advice on how to do so when it&#39;s completely absent from patient&#39;s environment #medhumchat</p><h3>Responses to Question 3:</h3><blockquote>The ending of the poem is especially evocative. Especially for those who practice medicine, how can we avoid defensiveness and learn from these lines?</blockquote><h3>David Rosenthal MD on Twitter</h3><p>A3. I&#39;ve learned to take out of my medical vernacular &quot;I understand&quot; --instead I&#39;ve switched to &quot;I hear you.&quot; I can hear the words of suffering but I can never truly understand the experience. #medhumchat</p><h3>Kelly Doran on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A3. As physicians one of our most powerful roles can be in lending our voices in advocacy to get at the real root drivers of our patients&#39; health-things like housing policy, SNAP benefit laws, structural racism, etc. We need to think big: outside the clinic (2/2). #medhumchat</p><h3>MeegGMD on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A3 we need to remain humble &amp;amp; let our pts teach us. At VA we have used the &quot;whole health&quot; approach asking pts &quot;what really matters to you&quot; rather than &quot;what&#39;s the matter with you&quot;? Healthcare is a partnership. #medhumchat Sometimes easier said than done.</p><h3>Matthew Tyler on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A3 When faced with such deeply rooted systemic disparities, it is understandable that we may reflexively throw up our hands and ask &quot;what can I possibly do?&quot; In reality, we can all likely do just a little bit more to level the playing field. #medhumchat</p><h3>Hollis on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A3. Humility. Grounding ourselves in the moment, with each patient, and remembering what it is like to be on the other side of the examination table (as the patient or loved one, or in any other capacity). #medhumchat</p><h3>Responses to Question 4:</h3><blockquote>The poem has a really interesting structure, with repetition of lines, interrupted by the direct statement: “Don’t put down the book on reading this, man.” What meaning is conveyed with this structure?</blockquote><h3>David Rosenthal MD on Twitter</h3><p>A4. Little acts of kindness go a long way. A peanut butter bar. A bus pass. A cup of coffee. A foot soak. These acts of kindness can be critical to establishing therapeutic relationships. #medhumchat</p><h3>Jonas Attilus on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat don&#39;t be quiet don&#39;t turn your face away don&#39;t be friendly to injustice or inequity say something. do something make something happen #medhumchat</p><h3>Melanie Fritz on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat the repetitive lines conveyed a feeling of a person&#39;s life cycling in and out of poverty, that it seems might never improve. and this line says, &quot;even if you, as an outsider, perceive this person&#39;s life as hopeless- you don&#39;t get to look away bc you&#39;re uncomfortable&quot; #medhumchat</p><h3>Amar Kelkar MD on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A4: Since we&#39;re talking about structural change and #SDOH, this poem is itself a metaphor. I love the simplicity of this poem. It challenges apathy, prioritizing the potential good without ignoring or erasing the big-picture challenges. #medhumchat</p><h3>Kamna Balhara on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat The barriers of social inequity may seem insurmountable, but that doesn&#39;t mean we stop trying to dismantle them. Don&#39;t devalue the impact of a simple act of kindness. #medhumchat</p><h3>Responses to Question 5:</h3><blockquote>What role do you think physicians and the broader healthcare system should play in addressing poverty, homelessness and other social determinants of health?</blockquote><h3>Kelly Doran on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A5. Concisely, I see 3 role categories: 1) adjust treatment decisions to account for #sdoh when needed (ex: maybe that homeless patient needs to be admitted not discharged); (1/3) #medhumchat</p><h3>Kelly Doran on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A5. 2) help patients with #sdoh needs, ideally via partnerships with community orgs (ex: refer to employment training program); (2/3) #medhumchat</p><h3>Kelly Doran on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A5. 3) advocate for policy change to get at the root drivers of #sdoh (ex: advocate for affordable housing because #housingishealth) (3/3) #medhumchat</p><h3>David Rosenthal MD on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A5. Advocate for policy changes. Support and respect the work of social workers, lawyers, case workers. Integrate them into your teams. Ask what they do, go to case management meetings with them if you can. And advocate for Housing First policies. 1/2</p><h3>Nathan Douthit, MD on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A5. We are witness to the suffering inflicted by #SDoH and must testify We are also the attorneys, crafting a case for change We are the clergy, listening to our patients and understanding them; in a cold world we give absolution and succor. We stand with them #MedHumchat</p><h3>The Urban Resident on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A5: We are of the few remaining respected paradoxes in society: the wounded healer, the powerful servant, the objective comforter, the palliating therapeutic, the intimate stranger. When we speak, people listen because they know the burden of what we bear. #MedHumChat</p><h3>MeegGMD on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A5.2 I know this gets quoted a lot, this is what was on my med school yearbook page: &quot;Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed, citizens can change the world. Indeed, it is the only thing that ever has.&quot; - Margaret Mead #medhumchat #SDOH</p><p><em>We thank all of our participants for sharing their reflections and making these rich discussions possible.</em></p><p><em>Medical Humanities Chat is hosted by </em><a href="https://www.colleenmfarrell.com/"><em>Dr. Colleen Farrell</em></a><em>. The mission of #medhumchat is to foster reflection, empathy, and connection in healthcare through discussions of poetry and prose. Find information on past and upcoming chats </em><a href="https://www.colleenmfarrell.com/medhumchat"><em>here</em></a><em>. Visit </em><a href="https://twitter.com/medhumchat"><em>@medhumchat</em></a><em> to join our next chat.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1d802394ff52" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Music and Laughter on the Oncology Ward]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@colleenmfarrell/music-and-laughter-on-the-oncology-ward-501d817e263b?source=rss-7a64c5a9dcbf------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/501d817e263b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[music-therapy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[poetry]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cancer]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[health]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[medicine]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Colleen Farrell]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 18 Feb 2019 00:35:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-03-24T21:54:55.419Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>#MedHumChat №5</h3><p>“Oncology wards, more than anywhere else I know, are musicless places,” <a href="https://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/05/24/life-interrupted-the-beat-goes-on/">wrote Suleika Jaouad</a> in the <em>New York Times, </em>after she was diagnosed with leukemia at twenty-two. As a teenager she had travelled weekly from Upstate New York to Manhattan, lugging her enormous double bass to study at Julliard. In her early twenties she repeated this journey from Upstate to Manhattan. But instead of arriving at Julliard, she found herself in the uncertain, eery world of a cancer ward.</p><p>I read Suleika’s essay <em>The Beat Goes On </em>in my early twenties, from my desk at the job I had landed after college. It had a particularly visceral impact on me. Suleika and I had grown up in the same town and had played in orchestra together (the violin was my instrument). The Suleika I knew—Susu as she was called then—was vivacious and radiant. The terrifying turn her life had taken was hard to comprehend.</p><p>At twenty-two, I was about to begin medical school. Suleika’s own dreams had been fractured. <em>Life, Interrupted </em>was the apt name of her series of essays chronically her illness and recovery. “Everyone out there is moving forward, I thought to myself, and I’m in here, in an oncology ward, stuck in place,” she wrote.</p><p><em>The Beat Goes On</em> ends with a visit from Suleika’s friends’ band who played for her in her hospital room. “As the sound of Jon’s harmonaboard filled the hallways, nurses and patients filtered out of their rooms… The oncology ward was breathing a sigh of relief, its inhabitants rejoicing in a temporary timeout, losing themselves to the beauty and healing power of the music,” she wrote. This scene is at once joyful and poignant. Music brings into stark relief the vibrancy of life and the proximity of loss.</p><p>Nearly ten years after I read this essay, I cared for an elderly cellist who was dying of cancer. His favorite piece, he told me, was the Brahms Piano Trio in B Major. One day on rounds, I found a recording of the piece on YouTube and played it at his bedside. Cancer had stripped his body of muscle and strength. The hands which had once created so much beauty now struggled to bring food to his lips. But when Brahms’ elegant melody began, his sunken eyes lit up with life. “Oh, it’s Brahms!” he exclaimed. For a moment, cancer faded ever so slightly into the backdrop. Later, when I cried over his death, I pictured this moment, how he had looked off into the distance, his eyes glistening.</p><p>In this Medical Humanities Chat, we read Suleika’s essay <em>The Beat Goes On </em>alongside a poem by Dr. Rafael Campo, <em>The Performance, </em>in which a clown pays a visit to children on a cancer ward. In reading these pieces, we asked how we might foster moments of joy in healthcare, even in the most trying times.</p><h3>#MedHumChat №5 | February 13th, 2019</h3><p>Theme: Finding Joy on the Oncology Ward</p><p>Poetry: <a href="https://bit.ly/2UHNCWd"><em>“The Performance”</em></a> by Rafael Campo</p><p><em>Campo portrays the bittersweet joy of children in a pediatric oncology ward when a clown comes to play.</em></p><p>Prose: <a href="https://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/05/24/life-interrupted-the-beat-goes-on/"><em>“The Beat Goes On”</em></a> by Suleika Jaouad</p><p><em>Jaouad, a Julliard-trained bassist, reflects on the loss of music and her identity when she was diagnosed with acute myeloid leukemia.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/682/1*9l8pGJJf7tkPhYHBfzFOFA.jpeg" /></figure><h3>The Performance</h3><h4>1. What words or images stood out to you in this poem?</h4><h4>2. How does this poem engage with hope?</h4><blockquote>“Wish Bone the cancer clown” <br>“as if a miracle were near” <br>“happy we could savor what we knew, in spite of what we hoped, was cruel joy”</blockquote><h3>The Beat Goes On</h3><h4>3. How does Suleika’s relationship with music help us understand her experience with illness?</h4><blockquote>“Between the hospital walls, hearing my favorite songs filled me with a deep, unbearable ache. Music, and the memories attached to them, reminded me of all that was no longer. Where had that feisty, fresh-faced music student with long auburn hair gone?”</blockquote><h4>4. How have you experienced the sounds of the hospital?</h4><blockquote>“Oncology wards, more than anywhere else I know, are musicless places. Instead of melody, there is constant beeping… Other times, you hear nothing at all… It’s the silent moments, the hollow sounds of quiet suffering, that can be most frightening.”</blockquote><h4>5. How do you feel about the ending of Jaouad’s essay? How does it differ from Campo’s poem?</h4><blockquote>“The oncology ward was breathing a sigh of relief, its inhabitants rejoicing in a temporary timeout, losing themselves to the beauty and healing power of the music. I was beaming beneath my face mask.”</blockquote><h4>6. When have you witnessed or experienced joy in the hospital? How can we foster these experiences for patients, even in small ways?</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*FGkHuXFBy84h1oBFbBTRaw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/photos/qUpzRaylopM?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">Ira Selendripity</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/search/photos/cello?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><h3>Responses to Question 1:</h3><blockquote>What words or images stood out to you in this poem?</blockquote><h3>Grace Oliver, MD-to-be on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A1 &quot;Like a dozen blighted eggs&quot; and the idea of a &quot;cruel joy&quot; stood out to me most... I didn&#39;t see it as cruel to enjoy even an ephemeral moment #medhumchat</p><h3>Carly Sokach on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A1: the clown&#39;s name being Wish Bone really stuck out to me. Made me think about the fragility of life as well as the thousands of wishes we make when we know that time on this earth is going to be cut too short #MedHumChat</p><h3>Jessica Hane on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat &quot;They laughed so hard that one of them, the girl with no platelets, got a nosebleed.&quot; It is so vivid, so easy to picture. It combines the joy and illness in one image. #medhumchat</p><h3>Briana Ruíz Christophers on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A1. The image of the knot in Deb the nurse&#39;s throat hit me hardest. I could almost feel it in my own throat...I think that fact that it was described as an &quot;odd shape I didn&#39;t recognize&quot; was what made me try to picture it #medhumchat</p><h3>Anna Reisman on Twitter</h3><p>Rereading, it&#39;s the title that strikes me as the saddest phrase: &quot;The Performance&quot; - the clown&#39;s, of course, but also the performance of the clinicians and, one wonders, even the kids. They are all trying to protect each other with the perfect performance. #medhumchat</p><h3>Responses to Question 2:</h3><blockquote>How does this poem engage with hope?</blockquote><h3>Nathan Douthit, MD on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A2. I think this speaks to the perspective. The children are having fun. They&#39;re enjoying it. It&#39;s the adults who have a different vantage point and feel the sadness. The kids are full of hope and vitality, even in the midst of suffering. #MedHumChat</p><h3>MeegGMD on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A2 the room is sunny and light - there is laughter ...poem captures the cheerfulness of &quot;childlife&quot; activities/departments - living is celebrated with familiar fun - clown, cookies #MedHumChat</p><h3>Matthew Tyler on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat I felt cynicism permeating throughout the entire piece, especially in the use of &quot;as if&quot; a miracle were near. The author clearly expects no miracles are actually to happen, but is still trying to savor that brief moment of reprieve from the reality. #medhumchat</p><h3>Laura Brereton on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A2: so much of the word choice seems to play on this idea of cruelty, that this bandaid of joy is a sort of façade-hard for the narrator to accept. I wonder if the children see it that way, though. We might venture to accept their joy (and hope) is real.</p><h3>Jennifer K. Chen, MD FAAP on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat #medhumchat A2: To me, Wish Bone is offering a brief escape for those watching. Cancer and other chronic illnesses has a way of reshaping hope into focusing on small victories, like a day with less pain or going outside for a bit</p><h3>Reflections on Question 3:</h3><blockquote>How does Suleika’s relationship with music help us understand her experience with illness?</blockquote><h3>Briana Ruíz Christophers on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A3. She frames music as a choice (&quot;The thought that I could choose my instrument was a revelation.&quot;) and an opportunity for growth (bass was taller than her). It was something that took all of her (talent, physical strength, emotions) and she lost that through illness #medhumchat</p><h3>Grace Oliver, MD-to-be on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A3 At least as I read it, for her, music = agency, normalcy, &amp;amp; joy. The cancer steals all of that from her, and the change of location is a very jarring change in soundscape #MedHumChat</p><h3>Anna Leahy on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A3. The link between music and memory seems important and how memory is recalled through sensory experience. I&#39;m also thinking about how major life experiences like cancer make us feel like a different person. Our sense of self or identity shifts. #medhumchat</p><h3>Indu Partha, MD FACP on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A3: The leukemia has robbed her of her essence: her passion, her vitality, her physical strength, and her identity as a musician. With illness, &quot;the music died.&quot; With illness, hope can die...and music had always represented hope, a future...#MedHumChat</p><h3>MeegGMD on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A3 The bass is a physical instrument you have to almost embrace it to play it. With CA she loses that ability/vitality. Music is gone &amp;amp; she is mourning her lost self until her friend arrives, brings back music &amp;amp; sound/vitality #medhumchat</p><h3>Reflections on Question 4:</h3><blockquote>How have you experienced the sounds of the hospital?</blockquote><h3>Walaa Tout on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat I hardly notice hospital sounds - but sometimes when I leave, I find myself savoring the quiet, releasing a tension I didn&#39;t know I was carrying. #medhumchat</p><h3>Diana Cejas, MD, MPH on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A4: I&#39;ve noticed how different the sounds are in adult vs children&#39;s hospitals. Both can be unnaturally quiet (except for alarms and pagers) but children&#39;s hospitals always seem to be a bit more lively. You hear cartoons or music therapists... #MedHumChat</p><h3>Jennifer K. Chen, MD FAAP on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat #medhumchat A4: I&#39;ve experienced as both MD and family member - the incessant beeping and alarms definitely contribute to #noisefatigue. I always smile seeing music therapists walking around rooms or playing in the hall because it breaks up the monotony with something happier</p><h3>Matthew Tyler on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat @DrJenChen4kids This seems as good a place as any to leave this. I&#39;m very lucky to have had the privilege to sit in during a music thanatology session and it&#39;s a moving experience #medhchat https://t.co/kEI9Msyzjc</p><h3>Briana Ruíz Christophers on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A4. So far the noise feels so disruptive, I haven&#39;t learned how to tune it out yet... The beeps are supposed to alert us to important things but they take up so much mental space in the room preventing sleep, relaxation and having conversations. #medhumchat</p><h3>Responses to Question 5:</h3><blockquote>How do you feel about the ending of Jaouad’s essay? How does it differ from Campo’s poem?</blockquote><h3>Nathan Douthit, MD on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A5. Comparing the two, I feel like Jaouad is expressing what Campo&#39;s children are feeling. Just for the performance, illness has no place in their lives. Her mask is just like the bald heads, still there, but merely covering something beautiful--hope and joy. #medhumchat</p><h3>MeegGMD on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A5: I hope this doesn&#39;t sound trite but I found it way more upbeat- less of a sense that the end was in sight? #MedHumChat</p><h3>Julia Danford on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat another reclamation of humanity in the face of cruelty, much like the clown&#39;s performance. the fact is we have no way of knowing if Jaouad will get better or the children will die. but we must dance anyway. it&#39;s what keeps the spirit alive. #medhumchat</p><h3>Justin Mott on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat All joy is fleeting, but still joy. #medhumchat https://t.co/tU6AnRZgCc</p><h3>Matthew Tyler on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A5 At the end it felt like the entire ward was collectively giving itself the permission to feel hope and joy again. Campo&#39;s poem seems to perseverate on the tension between tragedy and hope, rather than celebrate it #medhumchat</p><h3>Responses to Question 6:</h3><blockquote>When have you witnessed or experienced joy in the hospital? How can we foster these experiences for patients, even in small ways?</blockquote><h3>Grace Oliver, MD-to-be on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A6 My favorite witnessed moments of joy in the hospital are fleeting jokes between staff and patients, even very ill ones. Brief flickers of humor and hearing laughter connect us in such a deeply human way #MedHumChat</p><h3>Jessica Hane on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat I think the best and easiest way to foster joy is to talk about more than their illness. Ask about family, hobbies, or favorite books before you ask about number of stools. I wrote an order for ice cream BID for a kid in the PICU today. That worked too.</p><h3>Matthew Tyler on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A6 I try to give back pieces of humanity wherever I can. Bringing a Gatorade or bag of candy from the cafeteria, &quot;sneak&quot; in a patient&#39;s dog, etc. The pleasant little surprises can make a huge difference #medhumchat</p><h3>Priya Kantesaria on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A6: Our school does trick-o-treating around the hospital with any children there with their family, and for those on the wards who can&#39;t leave. Seeing 30 medical students in costumes certainly brought joy. Especially when we had sugar to share! #medhumchat</p><h3>Melanie, peak Blackness 🕶🤨💓👩🏾‍💻🎵 on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A6 🤣😂🤣 &quot;The baby factory&quot; (nickname for this maternity ward) in StL has unlimited snacks for new mothers and families. It&#39;s such a small thing but if all hospitals/ wards did this, it would relieve so much stress and allow families to stay longer. #MedHumChat</p><h3>Carly Sokach on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat Joy for patients come when we spend time answering questions, when we connect over something NOT related to medical care (a tv show, a song, a photo), when we show that we care about a person - not just their diagnosis. Spending that extra time facilitates joy #MedHumChat</p><h3>Briana Ruíz Christophers on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A6. I remember the look of joy when a cart of food was finally rolled into a patient&#39;s room after a full day of not eating due to testing. The other med student made sure to get it as soon as possible when tests were done.</p><h3>Jeffrey Millstein on Twitter</h3><p>A6. Social worker former opera singer belting out aria in a patient &#39;s room. Will never forget it #medhumchat</p><h3>Justin Mott on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A6. Unrestrained sobbing does not contain joy, but there is a generosity in sharing it. Does that sound wrong? Hearing a family cry reminds me of the deep sinewy link we all share with each other. #medhumchat</p><h3>B. Bobby Chiong, MD on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat I think about how music brings us together. I think about how some of the best times come from just hanging out and playing music with your friends. Such a feeling of almost divine connectedness. Hard to describe but I think it&#39;s captured well here. #medhumchat</p><p><em>Thank you to all of our participants for sharing their reflections and making these rich discussions possible.</em></p><p><em>Medical Humanities Chat is hosted by </em><a href="https://www.colleenmfarrell.com/"><em>Dr. Colleen Farrell</em></a><em>. The mission of #medhumchat is to foster reflection, empathy, and connection in healthcare through discussions of poetry and prose. Find information on past and upcoming chats </em><a href="https://www.colleenmfarrell.com/medhumchat"><em>here</em></a><em>. Visit </em><a href="https://twitter.com/medhumchat"><em>@medhumchat</em></a><em> to join our next chat.</em></p><p><em>Note: Patient details in opening comments were altered to respect patient privacy.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=501d817e263b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Nature, Death, and the Soul in the Poetry of Mary Oliver]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@colleenmfarrell/nature-death-and-the-soul-in-the-poetry-of-mary-oliver-5606963ea9f5?source=rss-7a64c5a9dcbf------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5606963ea9f5</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[nature]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[spirituality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[healthcare]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[poetry]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[death]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Colleen Farrell]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 11 Feb 2019 20:16:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-03-24T21:47:59.325Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>#MedHumChat №4</h3><p>The beloved poet Mary Oliver died January 17th, 2019 at age 83. Oliver lived most of her life in Provincetown, Massachusetts, on Cape Cod. The natural world of Cape Cod—the trees, water, and animals—were the principle subjects of her poetry. Maria Popova <a href="https://www.brainpickings.org/2015/03/27/mary-oliver-happiness/">beautifully describes</a> the artistry of Oliver’s writing: “[Oliver’s] immersive attentiveness to the casual, unremarkable, yet remarkably enlivening moments of life is the raw material of [her] genius, of her singular gift for bridging that vast abyss between the mind and the heart.”</p><p>In this MedHumChat, we discussed two poems by Mary Oliver—<em>The Rabbit </em>and <em>Bone—</em>in which Oliver explores the mysteries of death and the nature of the soul. Neither <em>The Rabbit </em>nor <em>Bone </em>makes explicit reference to medicine. Yet Oliver’s meditations deeply resonate with caring for patients, especially in their final days.</p><h3>#MedHumChat №4 | February 6th, 2019</h3><p>Theme: The Poetry of Mary Oliver</p><p><a href="https://www.poeticous.com/mary-oliver/the-rabbit"><em>The Rabbit</em></a></p><p><em>Oliver portrays the calm cruelty of nature and the cycle of life and death through her poem about a dead rabbit.</em></p><p><a href="https://www.poeticous.com/mary-oliver/bone"><em>Bone</em></a></p><p><em>A whale’s ear bone found on the beach opens reflections on the nature of the soul and its unknowability.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*53xFNq21Jis-305lC227qg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/photos/OgTBKxHltuM?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">Martina Vitáková</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/search/photos/rabbit?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><h3>The Rabbit</h3><h4>1. How do you feel reading the beginning of The Rabbit? How do you understand the relationship between the narrator and nature here?</h4><blockquote>Scatterghost, <br>it can’t float away. <br>And the rain, everybody’s brother, <br>won’t help. And the wind all these days<br> flying like ten crazy sisters everywhere <br>can’t seem to do a thing. No one but me,<br> and my hands like fire, <br>to lift him to a last burrow.</blockquote><h4>2. Turning to the middle of the poem: How do you relate to this portion of the poem? When have you felt like the narrator, in healthcare or otherwise?</h4><blockquote>while the body opens and begins <br>to boil. I remember</blockquote><blockquote>the leaping in the moonlight, and can’t touch it, <br>wanting it miraculously<br> to heal and spring up <br>joyful.</blockquote><h4>3. How do you interpret the final stanza of the poem? Does it bring you closure? A sense of deepened mystery? Hope?</h4><blockquote>the day after I’ve shoveled <br>the earth over, in a field nearby</blockquote><blockquote>I find a small bird’s nest lined pale <br>and silvery and the chicks — <br>are you listening, death? — warm in the rabbit’s fur.</blockquote><h3>Bone</h3><h4>4. To connect this poem to our own experience, when was a time in your life when you really thought about these questions of the soul?</h4><blockquote>Understand, I am always trying to figure out <br>what the soul is, <br>and where hidden, <br>and what shape</blockquote><h4>5. What words in the description of the ear bone and/or the bottom of the sea stood out to you?</h4><h4>6. How can we bring Mary Oliver’s appreciation of not-knowing into medicine?</h4><blockquote>Though I play at the edges of knowing, <br>truly I know <br>our part is not knowing, <br>but looking, and touching, and loving.</blockquote><h3>Responses to Question 1:</h3><blockquote>How do you feel reading the beginning of The Rabbit? How do you understand the relationship between the narrator and nature here?</blockquote><h3>Natasha Dhawan, MD on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A1: I feel like a heavy weight is being pushed upon the narrator. No matter how many times I&#39;ve read it, I feel this weight... I would associate this with the weight of newly being diagnosed with a chronic illness. #medhumchat</p><h3>Allison Chrestensen on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A1. It feels to me like nature is working against her here. An interesting contrast from her other poems, where nature feels more nurturing. #medhumchat</p><h3>Melanie Fritz on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A1. I get the sense that the narrator feels the heaviness of death and that she is alone in carrying it. That she perceives nature as family to her but in the moment she feels isolated even from what would usually be home. #medhumchat</p><h3>Nathan Douthit, MD on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A1. I love the word scatterghost. It sounds light and ethereal, but it&#39;s obvious from the first few lines that it sits heavily on the author&#39;s soul. We describe death to be a release, but for those left mourning it can be such a weight. #MedHumChat</p><h3>Shannon McNamara, MD on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat Dealing with death and mortality feels like that to me sometimes. Powerless in the face of nature, which can feel callous in the face of suffering. Leading a resuscitation in the ED after an hour of EMS coding in the field feels like that. I need to call it.</p><h3>Responses to Question 2:</h3><blockquote>Turning to the middle of the poem: How do you relate to this portion of the poem? When have you felt like the narrator, in healthcare or otherwise?</blockquote><h3>Jessica Hane on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat Life to death to life. I get the sense that the rabbit&#39;s story is not over. Isn&#39;t that how we cope with the death of a loved one? We carry forward the stories and bits of them we need to keep going. #medhumchat</p><h3>Lila Flavin on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat Not sure what the &quot;begins to boil&quot; part is referring to. But overall this section reminds me of the feeling of clinging and hoping for a magical &amp;amp; full recovery when it&#39;s past that point. #medhumchat</p><h3>Shannon McNamara, MD on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat Reminds me of the in between time between life &amp;amp; death when we&#39;re not exactly sure what happens. Maybe the soul leaves. At some point, the dying process ends and nobody is home anymore. She&#39;s watching it happen, hoping it&#39;s not real. That denial is powerful. #MedHumChat</p><h3>Angela C on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat Angela here, pediatrician and podcaster in Boston. What&#39;s interesting is that we interpret this as death, and I think of death as stasis. But a body boiling over, is that life spilling out? So kinetic that it can&#39;t be captured? #medhumchat</p><h3>Dr. Renée Cassidy on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A2 #medhumchat: I loved the imagery here. &quot;Begins to boil&quot; evokes the decay of the physical when we die, but I also had a moment of naughtiness picturing a rabbit in a stew! The longing for the wholeness of life to return is universal when a loved one dies.</p><h3>Responses to Question 3:</h3><blockquote>How do you interpret the final stanza of the poem? Does it bring you closure? A sense of deepened mystery? Hope?</blockquote><h3>Elizabeth Pinborough on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat For those who were well who become sick, the memory of health can be torturous. It is a blissful state impossible to re-enact, just as it is not possible to bring the rabbit back to life to leap in the moonlight. Sick bodies boil, with pain and emotion and memory.</p><h3>Lance Shaver MPH MSc(c) on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A3. I see shovelling as the process of mourning, of bereavement, &amp;amp; of moving on.</p><h3>Dr. Renée Cassidy on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A3 #medhumchat: I found the entire poem, not just the last stanza, powerfully hopeful. Life goes on, despite the inevitability of death; the circle continues, though the souls within each cycle vary. To me it spoke of how rituals and the process of bereavement help us move on.</p><h3>Indu Partha, MD FACP on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A3: As death takes place in the field (shoveling dirt on a grave), so does birth happen simultaneously...warm baby birds. I&#39;m assuming that perhaps the dead rabbit&#39;s fur is the same used to sustain new life. The circle of life. As a Hindu, I believe in reincarnation ... (1/2)</p><h3>karla fc holloway on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A3 Here the cycle is clarified-even insisted upon. Death has no dominion, life literally lies literally within its remains. So not so much hope, as assurance there is practice &amp;amp; pattern enough to sustain. Also the author discovers her necessary interpretive presence #medhumchat</p><h3>Responses to Question 4:</h3><blockquote>To connect this poem to our own experience, when was a time in your life when you really thought about these questions of the soul?</blockquote><h3>Jennifer Madeline on Twitter</h3><p>I was 15 when my dad died. He collected clocks and a beloved one stopped around his time of death which has always made me wonder if you can leave a part of you behind #medhumchat https://t.co/lMqN4SgIvO</p><h3>Nathan Douthit, MD on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A4. To be intensely practical (I&#39;m on an ICU rotation) I find myself thinking that often when there is a patient with severe brain injury. Knowing that they won&#39;t recover cognition, but there body is still alive, I struggle to imagine where the soul lives. #MedHumChat 1/2</p><h3>Jane Liebschutz, MD MPH on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat I have done bystander CPR three times in my life- in one instance, he died while I was doing compressions- no others, no equipment. I could feel the soul leave the body - it was very strange. First responders showed up as I was doing CPR but I knew the soul had fled.</p><h3>Allison Chrestensen on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat That question brings to mind the most painful events in my life. When my anguish was so deep, I felt it as a conduit from my soul. Too painful to talk about in the Twitterverse, but I bet many of you have experienced this. #medhumchat</p><h3>Elizabeth Gundersen on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat All of those moments we see in hospice that seem to be more than coincidence, that transcend the physical. People who die when that last family member arrives, or when they receive absolution for perceived sins, or when it&#39;s the day of their 50th wedding anniversary...#medhumchat</p><h3>Natasha Dhawan, MD on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A4. This is quite dark, but I tend to think of a person&#39;s soul if there&#39;s an impending code. I question what we are doing? What the patient&#39;s spirit must be feeling in this moment? How (if?) as a medical field, we&#39;re actually helping them. #medhumchat</p><h3>Responses to Question 5:</h3><blockquote>What words in the description of the ear bone and/or the bottom of the sea stood out to you?</blockquote><h3>Kat Ogle MD on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A5: my first thought was &quot;how&#39;d she know it was the ear bone?&quot; Then I thought of what that part of the whale meant to its communication with its community, the whale song and vibration, the connection and that we make learning of our communications with one another. #medhumchat</p><h3>MeegGMD on Twitter</h3><p>@allison_tandem @medhumchat maybe what is meant is that the soul (like bone) doesn&#39;t degrade as easily as flesh, endures, is what is left behind? #medhumchat</p><h3>Grace Oliver, MD-to-be on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A5 The back and forth between the grand &quot;the house of hearing&quot; and the small/mundane &quot;tiny pink scoop&quot; were particularly beautiful to me. It instilled a sense of wonder in me for even the least noticeable or plainly unique things #medhumanchat</p><h3>Lance Shaver MPH MSc(c) on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A5. I love how, despite how she &quot;couldn&#39;t see anything,&quot; she still describes the colour of the &quot;golden sand&quot; at the bottom. Like she knows the richness it has, despite not being able to see it. #medhumchat</p><h3>bethgarbitelli on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A5: the concept of a soul being as a bone &quot;so hard, so necessary&quot; - and it&#39;s origin from a whale&#39;s ear conjures the sense of the unknown, a dark abyss. And it makes me imagine how whales listen. How they navigate by sound.</p><h3>Responses to Question 6:</h3><blockquote>How can we bring Mary Oliver’s appreciation of not-knowing into medicine?</blockquote><h3>Lori Ruder #Insulin4All on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A6 I really see this in my #hpm work. I play at the edges of knowing: seeing signs of prognosis but my part is not-knowing and holding space for my patients and families-I look and touch and love them-while they find their way using their own life experiences. #medhumchat</p><h3>Grace Oliver, MD-to-be on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A6 This is easier for me to say as a med student, but I think an important chunk of my role in medicine IS not knowing, and instead just loving. Sometimes it&#39;s all we can do; sometimes it&#39;s all that&#39;s needed.</p><h3>Dr. Emil Lee on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat There&#39;s much we don&#39;t truly &quot;know&quot; in medicine; we have models, some work, some don&#39;t work. We keep striving. Keeping us humble &amp;amp; encouraging us to continue to explore &amp;amp; learn - without the hubris of thinking we will ever truly &quot;know&quot; everything. #medhumchat</p><h3>MeegGMD on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A6 many of above responses embrace this - deaths that occur at times that seem beyond coincidence, clock story. We need to embrace the idea that medicine &amp;amp; science don&#39;t explain everything, the spiritual, the matters of the soul are &quot;not known&quot; in that sense #medhumchat #HPM</p><h3>Hollis on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat Honesty within ourselves when we do not know. Honesty with our patients when we do not know. Honesty within our profession when we reach this boundary. Respect for this boundary and what it can teach us. #medhumchat</p><p><em>We thank all of our participants for sharing their reflections and making these rich discussions possible.</em></p><p><em>Medical Humanities Chat is hosted by </em><a href="https://www.colleenmfarrell.com/"><em>Dr. Colleen Farrell</em></a><em>. The mission of #medhumchat is to foster reflection, empathy, and connection in healthcare through discussions of poetry and prose. Find information on past and upcoming chats </em><a href="https://www.colleenmfarrell.com/medhumchat"><em>here</em></a><em>. Visit </em><a href="https://twitter.com/medhumchat"><em>@medhumchat</em></a><em> to join our next chat.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5606963ea9f5" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Messy Relationship between Food and Medicine]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@colleenmfarrell/the-messy-relationship-between-food-and-medicine-5bfbda23b8e0?source=rss-7a64c5a9dcbf------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5bfbda23b8e0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[narrative-medicine]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[medicine]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[poetry]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[food]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[health]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Colleen Farrell]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 03 Feb 2019 19:35:39 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-03-24T21:45:16.202Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>#MedHumChat №3</h3><p>The sore throat started just as I was beginning my junior year of college. I imagined it as a kind of sleeping dragon. I tried to pass my saliva by as gently as possible so as not to disturb it, but the dragon was awoken by each swallow. It breathed fire.</p><p>I tried to cool it off with ice cream. My doctor tried antibiotics. For months, it would settle down for a few nights, and then wake up again, angry as ever. Around Thanksgiving, I left school for a week and rested on my parents’ couch. Fearing the anger of each swallow, I collected my saliva in a plastic cup. By the time I went to a surgeon to investigate my tonsils, I was so dehydrated that I fainted on his exam table.</p><p>Once my tonsils were excised, I tried to eat again. My mom made spaghetti and tomato sauce and I gobbled it down. But after a few bites, the fire came raging back. I felt like someone was trying to rip my tongue out of me. The acidity of the tomatoes had awoken my surgical scars into flaming anger.</p><p>So I returned to vanilla ice cream. The end of three weeks—the expected window of healing—happened to fall on my twentieth birthday, and the first snowfall of the year. My parents took me to a little crepe place called Ravenous. As snow coated the sidewalks, I bit into a crepe stuffed with goat cheese and grape tomatoes. A tomato burst in my mouth. I swallowed. I felt only pleasure, and relief. The dragon was gone.</p><p>My nasty case of tonsillitis made me profoundly grateful for the simple joy of swallowing tomatoes. Illness had disrupted such a basic facet of life. Ten years later, now a doctor myself, I find it useful to recall this experience. I am often responsible for disrupting my patients’ eating and their relationship with food. It’s so easy for me to forget the toll this can take.</p><p>Hospitalized patients are routinely made NPO, <em>nihil per os, </em>Latin for nothing by mouth. It’s a safe guard in case the patient needs a procedure in the morning (food in the stomach can be aspirated into the lungs). For doctors, NPO is an order in the computer. For patients, it means being deprived of food or drink for hours, sometimes even days.</p><p>In the primary care clinic, I care for many patients whose diabetes is poorly controlled. I know with lower levels of sugar in their blood they are less likely to have heart attacks, strokes, kidney failure, blindness and amputations. And so we talk about what they are eating. It’s so easy for me to say “avoid white rice,” or “cut back on sweets.” But to really care for my patients, I need to remember that food is so much more than a risk factor. Food is woven into culture, family, pleasure, and love.</p><p>This week on #medhumchat we explored these questions of the relationship between food and medicine with two beautiful pieces. Both pieces are written by physicians—Dr. Diana Cejas and Dr. Irène Mathieu—who expand our clinical gaze to explore life and love through food.</p><h3><strong>#MedHumChat №3 | January 30th, 2019</strong></h3><p>Theme: food &amp; medicine</p><p>Special guests: The authors, <a href="https://www.dianacejasmd.com/">Dr. Diana Cejas</a> and <a href="https://irenemathieu.com/">Dr. Irène Mathieu</a></p><p>Prose: <a href="https://bit.ly/2AOcJPD"><em>Meat Slurry and my Particular brand of optimism</em></a><em> </em>by Dr. Diana Cejas</p><p><em>Dr. Cejas tells the story of her recovery from a stroke through her relationship to food—from NPO in the ICU, to saltines in occupational therapy, and finally home with gumbo.</em></p><p>Poetry: <a href="https://bit.ly/2ROQByb"><em>the benediction of Our Lady of Hyperglycemia</em></a> by Dr. Irène Mathieu</p><p><em>Dr. Mathieu explores the spiritual and cultural significance of food in a poem that complicates medical teaching on nutrition.</em></p><p><em>Consider taking a few minutes to read the texts and then return to the questions. You might try writing down your responses, as writing encourages us to slow down and reflect. Below the questions are tweets from #medhumchat contributors clustered by common themes.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*TQaNAAj2_CEAQPzaDgQnLw.jpeg" /></figure><h4>1. The essay tells the story of Dr Cejas’ illness and recovery through her relationship with food. How does the focus on food help us understand her experience?</h4><blockquote>I’d gone from an active, athletic, independent young woman to an emaciated, defeated, discouraged girl in less than 6 months. I wanted my life back. I wanted gumbo back. — Dr. Cejas</blockquote><h4>2. In Dr Cejas’ essay, a basic bodily function — eating — is not only constrained by her new disability, but controlled by her medical team. How is this control expressed in the essay? How does it relate to your experience in healthcare?</h4><h4>3. What words or phrases stood out to you most in Dr. Mathieu’s poem?</h4><h4>4. There is tension in the poem between medicalized descriptions like ‘hyperglycemia’ and ‘capillaries’ and the rich language of food, culture, and pleasure — ”wouldn’t dream of spilling a sweet sauce drop / this is the way it was done in New Orleans.” How does the poem explore this tension? Is it resolved? Do you relate to this tension?</h4><h3>Reflections on the Essay—Gumbo as Metaphor:</h3><h3>Dr. Renée Cassidy on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A1 #medhumchat:I&#39;m late to the party (laundry beckoned) but I thank Dr. Cejas for her story. Her descriptive imagery and using food as a universal, essential human experience brings us right into the heart of her devastation and recovery, though many of us have not had a stroke.</p><h3>Designer turned Doctor: Chris Sebastian on Twitter</h3><p>A1: it seems to me that she has lost so much of her identity over the last 6 months. Gumbo as a metaphor for everything that once brought color to her life. #medhumchat</p><h3>Ken Gordon on Twitter</h3><p>@meggerber @Ndouthit @medhumchat @DianaCejasMD We want to leap into the gumbo pot. Then illness hands us a saltine. #medhumchat</p><h3>Allison Chrestensen on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat Thinking about &amp;amp; eating food is such a sensory experience. Interesting when you think about that juxtaposed with the sensory experience of being in a hospital room: bland, colorless... Great metaphor for before &amp;amp; during illness. #medhumchat</p><h3>Reflections on the Poem—The Beautiful Language of Food:</h3><h3>Alessandra Colaianni on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A5 #medhumchat One of the things that I loved most about this poem is how rich the language of medicine can be, when wedded to the language of smells and tastes that arguably make life worth living.</p><h3>Emily Silverman on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat @gumbo_amando A4: &quot;You will die thick-blooded&quot; - somehow conveys a sense of glamour to atherosclerosis 😂 #medhumchat</p><h3>Ken Gordon on Twitter</h3><p>A4 &quot;when you die, thick-blooded, // you will die full of tastes and walk through / the door to the Holy Trinity simmering in pork fat.&quot; #medhumchat We carry the flavors of our lives with us for a very long time. Love that our biographies are written on these layers.</p><h3>Liana Eskola, DO on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat @gumbo_amando &quot;...isn&#39;t the fork a way to worship, too?&quot; Love it. Just love it. That&#39;s my kind of worship. #medhumchat</p><h3>Food is Personal:</h3><h3>Allison Chrestensen on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A1 There&#39;s nothing like illness to remind us the value of the things we take for granted, the simple things. During my hospitalization I too experienced the wonder &amp;amp; horror of eating foods you never thought you&#39;d see in puree form. #medhumchat</p><h3>Matthew Tyler on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat Being cut off from favorite / usual foods is such a dehumanizing experience and that comes across clearly here. We talk about the &quot;badness&quot; of physical and chemical restraints, perhaps we need to think more about the &quot;gustatory restraints&quot; we use too #medhumchat</p><h3>MeegGMD on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat my mom died right before Thanksgiving which was her favorite holiday. I was a resident &amp;amp; didn&#39;t know how to cook a turkey. I felt lost, unanchored. I could have looked up a recipe, but it was that sad realization that she wouldn&#39;t cook w/me &amp;amp; I couldn&#39;t ask her how.</p><h3>Krys on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat Food is often tied to identity, too, and going through intense medical things that radically alter us can lead to a sort of disconnect/identity crisis with &quot;past me&quot; vs &quot;now me.&quot; Getting back to familiar foods is comforting bc it can symbolize that things will b ok. #medhumchat</p><h3>Medicine, Food, and Control:</h3><h3>Irène P. Mathieu on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat @DianaCejasMD A2: How can we share control of patients&#39; care with them while keeping them safe? It&#39;s easy to forget this balance when we are so used to entering routine orders w/out considering their effect on patients emotionally as well as physically. #medhumchat</p><h3>Amar Kelkar MD on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat &quot;It&#39;s safer that way.&quot; Regardless of logic, everything we do is for that elusive goal of improving safety. But it&#39;s a fever dream (a &quot;flavor dream&quot;?) of medicine to think that everything we control, our &quot;special sauce&quot;, actually improves care, except inconvenience. #medhumchat</p><h3>Alessandra Colaianni on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A2- as an ENT resident am part of surgeries that fundamentally change the way pts eat. Sometimes it&#39;s a choice b/w trying to remove cancer and eating - sometimes ever again. I always fear we haven&#39;t done enough education/preparation pre-op.</p><h3>Nathan Douthit, MD on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat @gumbo_amando A4. For me: &quot;you will die full of tastes and walk through the door to the Holy Trinity simmering in pork fat.&quot; Once I told a family elder that what they were eating wasn&#39;t healthy, and they took one look at my salad and said &quot;I&#39;d rather die young than eat that!&quot;</p><h3>MeegGMD on Twitter</h3><p>@Ndouthit @medhumchat Must share that my mom, who was dying of cancer, didn&#39;t like her diabetic diet, called dad at work got his CC# &amp;amp; somehow managed to order Godiva chocolate delivered fr the hospital gift shop. Act of defiance.</p><h3>Diana Cejas, MD, MPH on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat Q5: I don&#39;t think that the tension is resolved but I don&#39;t know if it can be. These rich, delicious foods are both good for you and horrible for you at once. Can we really give up culturally significant, soul healing food even if we know that it can hurt us?</p><h3>Reflections from the authors</h3><p>Diana Cejas on her essay <a href="https://bit.ly/2AOcJPD"><em>Meat Slurry and my Particular brand of optimism</em></a><em>:</em></p><h3>Diana Cejas, MD, MPH on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat I actually wrote this piece in response to someone asking me how I could be optimistic and even happy despite everything that had happened. I&#39;m pretty sure that I experienced every single emotion at some point during my illness... #MedHumChat</p><h3>Diana Cejas, MD, MPH on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat But the one that surprised me the most was joy. That first saltine may have been dry and tasteless (and I may have bit my tongue bloody trying to eat it) but I celebrated every bite of it. I was overjoyed each time I got a new food back...</p><h3>Diana Cejas, MD, MPH on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat I literally cried when I could swallow rice again. But rice and all of these foods are so closely associated with happy memories, my family, and my culture that gaining them back felt like gaining back everything #MedHumChat</p><h3>Diana Cejas, MD, MPH on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat Illness is very humbling. It can make you appreciate and celebrate things that you never knew you took for granted. Even peaches. Even rice. I wanted to convey those overlapping feelings of gratitude, optimism, and even joy with this piece. #MedHumChat</p><p>Irène Mathieu on her poem <a href="https://bit.ly/2ROQByb"><em>the benediction of Our Lady of Hyperglycemia</em></a><em>:</em></p><h3>Irène P. Mathieu on Twitter</h3><p>Sure! When my grandparents were nearly 90 (&amp;amp; in remarkably good health) I asked them what non-genetic factors they thought had contributed to their longevity/wellness. #medhumchat https://t.co/gggQKwB4NK</p><h3>Irène P. Mathieu on Twitter</h3><p>Their answers related to food were clearly bound up w/ culture, family, good memories, &amp;amp; history, but they weren&#39;t all necessarily &quot;healthy&quot; foods per 21st century medicine. #medhumchat</p><h3>Irène P. Mathieu on Twitter</h3><p>In writing this poem I was exploring how, coming from a NOLA Creole family, food/eating is so bound up in emotion &amp;amp; spirituality. So it&#39;s critical to wellness, even though in medicine we often focus more on the nutritional content of foods. #medhumchat</p><p><em>We thank all of our participants for sharing their reflections and making these rich discussions possible, especially the authors, Dr. Mathieu and Dr. Cejas, who joined us to discuss their works.</em></p><p><em>Medical Humanities Chat is hosted by </em><a href="https://www.colleenmfarrell.com/"><em>Dr. Colleen Farrell</em></a><em>. The mission of #medhumchat is to foster reflection, empathy, and connection in healthcare through discussions of poetry and prose. Find information on past and upcoming chats </em><a href="https://www.colleenmfarrell.com/medhumchat"><em>here</em></a><em>. Visit </em><a href="https://twitter.com/medhumchat"><em>@medhumchat</em></a><em> to join our next chat.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5bfbda23b8e0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Racism & medicine: The stories beneath the statistics]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@colleenmfarrell/racism-medicine-the-stories-beneath-the-statistics-5331e67e26ef?source=rss-7a64c5a9dcbf------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5331e67e26ef</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[maya-angelou]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[blacklivesmatter]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[poetry]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mlk]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[health]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Colleen Farrell]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 19 Jan 2019 18:41:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-03-24T21:41:17.561Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>#MedHumChat №2</h3><p>by Colleen Farrell and Nick Mckenzie</p><p>The statistics on racial health disparities reflect, in numerical form, stories of pain, heartbreak, and loss. Black women in the US are <a href="https://www.cdc.gov/reproductivehealth/maternalinfanthealth/pregnancy-mortality-surveillance-system.htm">more than three times as likely</a> as white women to die from pregnancy-related complications. Black infants are more than <a href="https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nvsr/nvsr64/nvsr64_09.pdf">twice as likely</a> as white infants to die in the first year of life. Even after surviving that first year of life, black male babies can expect their lives to be cut <a href="https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nvsr/nvsr66/nvsr66_04.pdf">four years shorter</a> than their white counterparts.</p><p>My training as a doctor has been, in many ways, an education in what these statistics mean at a human level. The black man paralyzed by bullets through his spinal cord. The black woman unable to care for her most basic needs or even talk—devastating complications of what was once a healthy, joyful pregnancy. It is through my patients’ stories that I have begun to understand the human devastation just beneath the statistics I learned in medical school.</p><p>In this Medical Humanities Chat, we explored the relationship between racism and medicine through a <a href="https://www.poetryfoundation.org/poems/48989/caged-bird">poem</a> by Maya Angelou, a personal <a href="https://www.yesmagazine.org/peace-justice/racism-and-the-off-duty-doctor-20181126">essay</a> by <a href="https://profiles.ucsf.edu/sriram.shamasunder">Dr. Sriram Shamasunder</a>, and a <a href="https://thevalueofsparrows.com/2014/05/04/sermon-a-tough-mind-and-a-tender-heart-by-martin-luther-king-jr/">sermon</a> by Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Together, the pieces generated a moving discussion on the human experience of racial oppression and the role of healthcare providers and the healthcare system in addressing it.</p><p>We were joined by <a href="https://profiles.dom.pitt.edu/dgim/faculty_info.aspx/Essien7016">Dr. Utibe R. Essien</a>, a primary care physician and health disparities researcher, who helped us see the connections between statistics and stories.</p><h3>Utibe R. Essien on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A7. As a primary care doctor I am always looking for the root cause- what is going on beneath the surface that brought this patient in today. As a disparities researcher I think about what we can do to intervene, in many cases, addressing the social determinants. #medhumchat</p><p>He and others also shared their own experiences with racism as physicians of color. For many, these painful experiences have been channelled into a commitment to deeper compassion and justice in healthcare and beyond. This commitment is eloquently expressed in the closing paragraph of Dr. Shamasunder’s essay:</p><blockquote>Before blood flows from every orifice, can we note their existence? The 109 Black bodies killed by the police this year. May we learn their names in life? They exist. As a doctor, I aim to stand with them before the beautiful fire of their lives becomes ash. In this country, the only way I know home is through them. I want to reclaim a space for home for the Black, the Brown, the nameless, my patients, myself. I try to find my home through them.</blockquote><p><strong>#</strong><a href="https://twitter.com/medhumchat"><strong>MedHumChat</strong></a><strong> №2 | January 16th, 2019</strong></p><p>Theme: racism &amp; medicine</p><p>Special Guest: Dr. Utibe R. Essien, <a href="https://twitter.com/UREssien">@<strong>UREssien</strong></a></p><p>Poetry: <a href="https://www.poetryfoundation.org/poems/48989/caged-bird"><em>Caged Bird</em></a><em> </em>by Maya Angelou</p><p><em>An extended metaphor of two birds, one free and one caged, communicates the ways in which oppression shapes human experience.</em></p><p>Prose: <a href="https://www.yesmagazine.org/peace-justice/racism-and-the-off-duty-doctor-20181126"><em>Racism and the Off-Duty Doctor</em></a><em> </em>by Sriram Shamasunder</p><p><em>Dr. Shamasunder shares a painful personal experience as a physician of color. He explores what it means to occupy a place of privilege and a place of oppression, and draws on this experience to find “common cause” with the people of color he cares for.</em></p><p>Prose: <a href="https://thevalueofsparrows.com/2014/05/04/sermon-a-tough-mind-and-a-tender-heart-by-martin-luther-king-jr/"><em>A Tough Mind And A Tender Heart</em></a><em> </em>by Martin Luther King, Jr.</p><p><em>In a sermon, Dr. King talks calls for the seemingly contradictory “creative synthesis of opposites.” He argues that to achieve justice in the world we need both tough, discerning minds and loving, tender hearts.</em></p><p><em>Consider taking a few minutes to read the texts and then return to the questions. You might try writing down your responses, as writing encourages us to slow down and reflect. Below the questions are tweets from #medhumchat contributors clustered by common themes.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*TqkjzOGqNrGXtPgUoZlajA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/photos/siTxjRLSkTA?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">Rod Long</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/search/photos/bird-cage?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><h4><strong>1. What was your initial reaction to the poem? Which words or specific images stood out to you?</strong></h4><h4>2. Angelou invokes the caged bird as a metaphor for slavery and oppression. How does this seemingly simple metaphor expand your understanding?</h4><h4>3. The free bird “dares to claim the sky” and “names the sky his own.” What do these lines communicate about power? How might that relate to medicine?</h4><h4>4. What does the caged bird’s singing represent to you?</h4><blockquote>But a caged bird stands on the grave of dreams<br>his shadow shouts on a nightmare scream<br>his wings are clipped and his feet are tied<br>so he opens his throat to sing<br> — Maya Angelou</blockquote><h4>5. What moved you most about the essay by Dr. Shamasunder?</h4><h4>6. Home is a central theme to the essay. What does it mean to have a home? In what ways are the author and his patients displaced from or denied their homes?</h4><h4>7. Dr. Shamasunder powerfully draws a connection between racism and poverty, and disease and death. Hows does this resonate with your experience of healthcare?</h4><blockquote>If the soul is ignored long enough, the body rebels… Sometime when I fill out death certificates, I wish I could write the cause of death as poverty. Or American racism.<br> — Dr. Sriram Shamasunder</blockquote><h4>8. Dr. Shamasunder seeks to “make common cause” with those who are oppressed. What do you think he means by that? What does it mean for you personally to “make common cause” with others?</h4><blockquote>As a doctor, I am looking to make common cause with Black boys stopped by the police, shot by the police without a doctor’s ID to protect them.<br> — Dr. Sriram Shamasunder</blockquote><h4>9. In what ways do Angelou’s poem and Shamasunder’s essay speak to each other?</h4><h4>10. In his sermon, Dr. King calls for a “creative synthesis of love and injustice.” He writes, “We must combine the toughness of the serpent and the softness of the dove, a tough mind and a tender heart.” How can we apply the wisdom of a tough mind and tender heart as we seek to dismantle racism in medicine and beyond?</h4><h3>Interpretations of Caged Bird:</h3><p><em>Many participants found meaning in the cage, the birds, and the landscape. Each piece of this extended metaphor allowed contributors to reflect on current societal manifestations of oppression, power, liberty, and activism.</em></p><h3>Altaf Saadi on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat I&#39;ve been mulling over &quot;bars of rage.&quot; First I thought this was the rage of the caged bird, but then it struck me it&#39;s coming from those who caged the bird. I thought of immigrants in detention, in cages, anger directed at them &amp;amp; the parallels across minority groups.</p><h3>Briana Ruíz Christophers on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A1. What hit me most was this stanza: &quot;The caged bird sings/with a fearful trill/of things unknown/but longed for still/and his tune is heard/on the distant hill/for the caged bird/sings of freedom.&quot; It speaks to a longing for a future that could exist but doesn&#39;t #medhumchat</p><h3>Morris A. Aguilar on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A2. What sticks out at me is birds typically do not build cages around themselves. Someone/thing/thought/group made it. How did the bird get in the cage? So what are the forces that built the cage/oppression? #medhumchat</p><h3>Utibe R. Essien on Twitter</h3><p>A2. It&#39;s such a powerful metaphor, particularly with the contrast made with the free bird, who &quot;leaps,&quot; &quot;floats,&quot; &quot;dares,&quot; &quot;thinks,&quot; and &quot;names the sky his own.&quot; The idea that the caged bird can&#39;t even think really stands out to me. #medhumchat https://t.co/CUXtUL7QN1</p><h3>Eloho Ufomata on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat The caged bird is still a bird however there have been numerous attempts to stifle its spirit and to make it less than. Despite this, the bird still has dreams and sings of freedom. Illustrates the unbreakable spirit of those who are enslaved. Reminds me of their humanity</p><h3>Mitochondrial Eve on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat Has anyone noticed that the free bird doesn&#39;t sing? Surrounded by the privilege and opportunity afforded by his station, yet he is silent. I wonder why that is. #MedHumChat</p><h3><strong>Personal experiences evoked by the poem:</strong></h3><p><em>Maya Angelou’s metaphor prompted several people to reflect on the role race continues to play their own experiences as physicians and/or as people of color.</em></p><h3>Utibe R. Essien on Twitter</h3><p>A1. The phrase that stood out to me the most was &quot;bars of rage.&quot; Reminds me of how much time I spend frustrated, saddened, &quot;rageful&quot; by the conversations around race today, that though much better than when Angelou first wrote this, still aren&#39;t where they should be. #medhumchat https://t.co/4tUJmiOrTt</p><h3>Qureshi on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A3. This resonates. How wonderful -unimaginably great- would it be to freely express oneself and act with such confidence as if to be judged on substance rather than on background. More so with co-physicians/staff than patients/ families. #medhumchat</p><h3>Utibe R. Essien on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A4. The caged bird sings &quot;of things unknown but longed for still.&quot; I think this is the story of many people of color. The hope for a better tomorrow. A hope that was beautifully summed up in @JAMA_current piece by @oumgbako, &quot;The Unicorn.&quot; (https://t.co/Tm9UIYjSCA) #medhumchat</p><h3>Dr. Chavon Onumah on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat Q4. The caged bird&#39;s singing represents finding strength &amp;amp; joy (sing=make a joyful noise) despite inequities and using one&#39;s VOICE even when bound/one&#39;s power is stripped...Therein lies the caged bird&#39;s hope and power. #medhumchat</p><h3>Reflections on the essay:</h3><p><em>Contributors reflected on the familiarity of Dr. Shamasunder’s essay and the intersectional complexity of occupying places of privilege and oppression.</em></p><h3>Irène P. Mathieu on Twitter</h3><p>@LanceShaver @AMLeahy @medhumchat Right. Only part of his identity was validated - the doctor part - but parts of him were clearly not welcome. #medhumchat</p><h3>Robert Rosencrans on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A8 POC all over the globe didn&#39;t wake up one day and decide to think of themselves as POC. The history of common cause is the history of whiteness and violence *which creates otherness*. But common cause is also refuge, solidarity, and sanity of shared experience. #medhumchat</p><h3>Diana Cejas, MD, MPH on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat @srijeeva A5: The thing that sticks with me is the feeling that what happened to the author happens to so many POC in and out of medicine everyday. Rather than being shocked or moved by the essay I just felt a discomforting sense of familiarity. #MedHumChat</p><h3>Kistein Monkhouse, MPA on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A8: I think it highlights the importance of community. My goal in my work is to bridge the gap between &quot;them &amp;amp; us&quot; mindset i.e doctor/patient. Especially when there needs to be systemic change that recognize all ppl interacting with the medical community as #humans #medhumchat</p><h3>Lance Shaver MPH MSc(c) on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat @srijeeva A5. Moved by the sadness I felt wondering why the person the cop thought they saw without the white coat was somehow incongruent with who they saw with the coat. It&#39;s the same person-yet they are seen differently b/c power &amp;amp; status have more value than personhood. #medhumchat</p><h3>Utibe R. Essien on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat @srijeeva A5. I got to listen to @DamonTweedy discuss his book &quot;Black Man in a White Coat&quot; and I remember saying to my friend &quot;I feel like any of us could have written this book.&quot; That&#39;s what moved me the most. Those experiences sadly weren&#39;t just Sriram&#39;s, they&#39;re all of ours.</p><h3>Briana Ruíz Christophers on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat @srijeeva A5. That putting on a white coat or even an ID puts you in a different position. As a student, I feel like a fraud. As a Latina, I long to be able to relate with my patients without them assuming I won&#39;t understand.</p><h3>Robert Rosencrans on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat @srijeeva He&#39;s forced to become complicit in classism to avoid to violent consequences of racism. As if he weren&#39;t valuable enough as just a human body, regardless of profession. Echoes of our obsession with &quot;the good immigrant&quot; narrative (e.g. Einstein). You are enough. #medhumchat</p><h3>The social determinants of health:</h3><p><em>Dr. Shamasunder’s essay inspired tweets related to race, housing and place, social determinants of health, and stories of patients.</em></p><h3>Altaf Saadi on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A7. It made me think about how things like race and racism, or poverty, or homelessness, etc are often relegated to the social history, when the social history is really the entire story. #medhumchat</p><h3>Kistein Monkhouse, MPA on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat This was such a powerful line! It beings me back to the reality that your zip code determines your life expectancy, which is nothing new but finally it is recognized in #medicine as being a determinant of #health and health outcome between populations #SDOH #medhumchat</p><h3>Irène P. Mathieu on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A7: These are connections I see every day in clinic. It made me think about calls I&#39;ve seen by others to stop calling (the social construct of) &quot;race&quot; a risk factor &amp;amp; instead name exposure to racism as the risk factor. Feels more accurate. #medhumchat</p><h3>Reflections on the MLK quote:</h3><p><em>Statistics speak to our discerning minds. Stories speak to our tender hearts. Dr. King’s sermon provides insight into how we can blend these seemingly opposed parts of ourselves as we work to dismantle racism.</em></p><h3>Nathan Douthit, MD on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat &quot;The hardhearted individual never sees people as people, but rather as mere objects or as impersonal cogs in an ever-turning wheel. In the vast wheel of industry, he sees men as hands.&quot; We will not impact systemic racism without appreciating each individual person&#39;s dignity. 1/x</p><h3>Nathan Douthit, MD on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat Dr. King captures so beautifully that we must stand firm in our convictions, but always begin with love for our neighbor. People are not a means to an end, but must be treasured, appreciated, and served due to their dignity as human persons. 2/x</p><h3>Anandhi Narasimhan on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat We fight hard for the sick and disabled with a tough mind, whether it&#39;s in terms of health policy issues or treatment inequalities, while holding their suffering tenderly in our hearts. We manage our frustrations by being an effective voice for patients.</p><h3>Irène P. Mathieu on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A10: For me, &quot;tough mind&quot; means having the wherewithal to stand up for what&#39;s right, even if it goes against the status quo, even - &amp;amp; especially - if it means unlearning what we&#39;ve been taught. Maybe the hardest work is the decolonization of our own minds. #medhumchat</p><h3>Jane Liebschutz, MD MPH on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat Toughness of a serpent- the scaly covering that doesn&#39;t allow things to penetrate its skin= not getting beaten down by a system that is stacked to be unfair; softness of a dove- finding living things and live anew (e.g. dove in Noah and the Ark); tenderheart- forgiveness</p><h3>Anna Leahy on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A10. The word &quot;compassion&quot; comes from the Latin meaning to suffer together. We cannot really know each other&#39;s suffering, so maybe the goal of medicine might be to treat a person with both intellectual and emotional understanding. #medhumchat</p><p><em>We thank all of our participants for sharing their reflections and making these rich discussions possible.</em></p><p><em>Medical Humanities Chat is hosted by </em><a href="https://twitter.com/colleenmfarrell"><em>Dr. Colleen Farrell</em></a><em>. The mission of #medhumchat is to foster reflection, empathy, and connection in healthcare through discussions of poetry and prose. Visit </em><a href="https://twitter.com/medhumchat"><em>@medhumchat</em></a><em> to find out how you can join our next chat.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5331e67e26ef" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Can fairy tales and poetry help us heal? #MedHumChat №1]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@colleenmfarrell/can-fairy-tales-and-poetry-help-us-heal-medhumchat-1-10a122c4bc48?source=rss-7a64c5a9dcbf------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/10a122c4bc48</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[poetry]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[medicine]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[healthcare]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[empathy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[storytelling]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Colleen Farrell]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 13 Jan 2019 22:32:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-03-24T21:48:31.022Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Can fairy tales and poetry help us heal?</h3><h3>#MedHumChat №1</h3><p>Every fourth day in the ICU, I stayed on through night, caring for patients until the sun came up again. Perhaps by some effect of darkness, or the cognitive distortion wrought by exhaustion, it seemed the greatest tragedies struck during those long nights. Three deaths that month left me grief stricken. I hadn’t known these patients well—each was teetering on unconsciousness when we met. But in each case, I had had to tell their family members that we couldn’t fix their broken bodies.</p><p>Sleep-deprived to the point of delirium, I would stumble home, get into bed, and sob in my husbands arms. My recollection of this grief is that it lacked particulars. It was grief at the human condition, at death itself.</p><p>Weeks after that ICU rotation ended, those nights in the ICU still rested heavily on my heart. I turned to a collection of poetry by Mary Oliver, and stumbled upon a poem called “The Rabbit.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/461/1*0Sqn0xwTGVMbXf8NTZxGzQ.png" /></figure><p>This haunting poem is about a dead rabbit, decaying in the elements. The narrator longs for the rabbit to heal, to see him “leaping in the moonlight.” In beholding him, her own woundedness is apparent. Nature is cruelly unconcerned: “the rain… won’t help / the wind… can’t seem to do a thing.” Though her hands are “like fire,” she brings herself to bury his open, boiling body. The next day, she finds a bird’s nest made of his fur.</p><p>Sitting up in bed, alarm set for clinic early the next morning, I read this poem some dozen times. It was the interruption in the final two stanzas—“Are you listening, death?”—that I most needed. The fur of the rabbit woven into the chicks’ nest is defiance against death.</p><p>Reading stories and poetry helps me make sense of the seemingly senseless suffering and heartbreak I witness daily as a doctor. In sharing poetry with fellow resident physicians I’ve found I’m not alone in this. Stories and poetry foster personal reflection, deepened empathy, and when shared with others, a sense of community. Words have healing powers.</p><p>This year, I’m trying something new: bringing my love for stories and poetry in medicine to a Twitter chat that I’m calling Medical Humanities Chat, or #medhumchat. Each chat is guided reflection around a few short texts. After the chat, I’ll share the readings, questions, and a few comments from participants here. These blog posts will function as discussion guides that anyone, anywhere can use to foster reflection, empathy and connection in healthcare. It’s #FOAMed (free open access medical education) for the medical humanities.</p><p><strong>#MedHumChat №1 | January 2nd, 2019</strong></p><p>Theme: medical humanities, an introduction</p><p>Poetry:<em> </em><a href="https://www.poetryfoundation.org/poetrymagazine/browse?contentId=38483"><em>Intensive Care</em></a> by Jane O Wayne</p><p><em>A loved one is critically ill and sedated in the ICU. The narrator communicates her the uncertainty and endless waiting through the metaphor of a ship out at sea.</em></p><p>Prose: <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2011/07/01/opinion/01gribben.html?smid=nytcore-ios-share"><em>Practicing Medicine Can be Grimm Work</em></a> by Valerie Gribben</p><p><em>A young woman loves fairy tales, but when she goes to medical school, she leaves these stories behind, focusing instead on biochemistry and anatomy. When she enters the hospital, she realizes fairy tales had taught her far more about medicine than she had realized.</em></p><p>Take a few minutes to read the texts and then return to the questions. You might try writing down your responses, as writing forces us to slow down and reflect.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_cGY3edo1qrsH6D9qDdYog.jpeg" /></figure><h3><strong>Question 1: How did you react to Wayne’s poem? What did it stir up in you?</strong></h3><h3>Melodie Kolmetz, PA-C on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A1: As a caregiver, it made me reflect on how fixated on specific vital signs family members of critically ill patients can become. So important to stress that patient care is about the whole picture, not just one piece. #medhumchat</p><h3>Carolyn Chan on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A1: It stirred a profound sense of empathy for my patient&#39;s families sleeping in ICU lobbies. The line, reminder that &quot;your open eyes taunting us&quot;, and &quot;waiting.. for the wind to give a different verdict&quot;. Goosebumps. #medhumchat</p><h3>Emily Silverman on Twitter</h3><p>A1: &quot;your open eyes taunting us&quot; - this line resonated with me. The strangeness of seeing a body whose mind is not functioning - and worse, the body of a loved one. Inner life feels so boundless. Seems odd that it should be confined to the body. #medhumchat</p><h3><strong>Question 2: Wayne uses a metaphor of a ship lost at sea. What does the metaphor capture that an objective, medical description of the ICU would miss?</strong></h3><h3>Nick McKenzie on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A2 #medhumchat. For me, the strength of these metaphors lie largely in the fact that they are NOT objective. They are able to live in my mind. I find more comfort in words that communicate complexity and ambiguity than in more objective, diluted words.</p><h3>Ian Kwok on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat For me it&#39;s the vastness and incomprehensible sense of scale expressed by the sea. It allows for acceptance that the forces of nature are bigger than us. #medhumchat</p><h3>Diana Cejas, MD, MPH on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat It also makes me think of how caring for a critically ill person separates the caregiver / loved ones from the rest of the world. Sometimes simple description isn&#39;t enough to convey the kind of profound loneliness that comes with that. #MedHumChat</p><h3><strong>Question 3: How do you interpret the title of the poem, Intensive Care<em>?</em></strong></h3><h3>Briana Ruíz Christophers on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat Q3. I interpreted the title as presenting a paradox: the poem paints a picture of loneliness &amp;amp; desolation which is the opposite of &quot;intensive care.&quot; One is surrounded by machines and wires that are needed for &quot;care&quot; yet neither the patient nor family feels in control #medhumchat</p><h3>Matthew Tyler on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A3 I love the double meaning. This patient is in the ICU, yes, but the poem reflects the intensity with which the family and medical team care for this patient. Intensive hope. #medhumchat</p><h3><strong>Question 4: How did you react to the essay by Dr. Gribben? Did it resonate with your experience?</strong></h3><h3>Vishesh Jain on Twitter</h3><p>medhumchat A4: For me the essay demonstrates the resonance of narrative medicine. As a species we use stories to make sense of the world, and we *need* that meaning in order to process, heal, and move onward. Fairy tales are archetypes of stories that we all live through. https://t.co/K47v08lkAW</p><h3>Emily Silverman on Twitter</h3><p>A4: &quot;What happens when...the bloody secrets spill onto your aseptic field of study?&quot; - damn, what a line. In med school we learn much about the human body, but not much about human nature. Why? #medhumchat</p><h3><strong>Question 5: Dr. Gribben left her fairy tales behind when she went to medical school. What parts of yourself have you left behind when entering the hospital or clinic? As a patient? As a family member? As a clinician?</strong></h3><blockquote>“But when I started medical school… I reordered my bookshelf, moving my well-thumbed but now irrelevant Brothers Grimm stories behind a biochemistry textbook.” —Dr. Valerie Gribben</blockquote><h3>RanaAwdishMD on Twitter</h3><p>I have found that the things I had initially believed irrelevant (art, poetry, painting) are truly the things I need to flourish. #medhumchat https://t.co/EUTrg8NuB3</p><h3>Jennifer Madeline on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A5: I let all the parts of myself that weren&#39;t medicine fall away through my training and when I finished I realized I felt empty. In the last couple years I&#39;ve rekindled my hobbies and find it&#39;s those interests that make me whole and help me connect #medhumchat</p><h3>Carolyn Chan on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A5. I perform improv comedy, write/perform creative non-fiction. I often feel like I have to leave these parts of myself outside of the hospital, as some misinterpret the spontaneity, playfulness, and vulnerability as unprofessional, especially as a WIM. #medhumchat</p><h3><strong>Question 6: The gritty details in this essay are what make it so haunting, so powerful. Which specific descriptions captivated you?</strong></h3><blockquote>“Fairy tales are, at their core, heightened portrayals of human nature, revealing, as the glare of injury and illness does, the underbelly of mankind. Both fairy tales and medical charts chronicle the bizarre, the unfair, the tragic.” — Dr. Valerie Gribben</blockquote><h3>Adam B. Hill, M.D. on Twitter</h3><p>medhumchat A6 The imagery of abuse flooded back memories of child abuse cases I saw in medical school/residency that still are fresh wounds in my memory. Time I just wanted to scream, punch a wall, run into a room and cry. I didn&#39;t know how to process those events back then.</p><h3>Healers who Listen on Twitter</h3><p>medhumchat A6: &quot;The terrifying things that go bump in the night are what doctors treat at 3 a.m. in emergency rooms.&quot; This is the literary version of what motivated #ThisIsOurLane - it&#39;s not just an argument for us, it&#39;s under our nails and in our nostrils.</p><h3><strong>Question 7: Dr. Gribben returns to stories as a way of coping and making sense out of suffering and tragedy. Have stories helped you make sense of your experiences with illness and healthcare? How so?</strong></h3><blockquote>“But what happens when the door to Bluebeard’s horror chamber opens, and the bloody secrets spill onto your aseptic field of study? How do you process the pain of your patients?</blockquote><blockquote>I found my way back to stories.” -Dr. Valerie Gribben</blockquote><h3>Allison Chrestensen on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A7, there is a tendency among clinicians to keep pts&#39; stories separate from our own. When I realized that I was part of pts&#39; stories &amp;amp; they were part of mine I allowed myself to fully experience the emotions arising my experiences. #medhumchat</p><h3>bethgarbitelli on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A7: it&#39;s such a powerful form of solidarity. Reading a story that resonates sometimes feels like a greeting from a friend. It can be a wave or an embrace. You&#39;re not alone in whatever you&#39;re experiencing #medhumchat</p><h3>Grace Oliver, MD-to-be on Twitter</h3><p>A7 The biggest way stories have helped me is to validate my vulnerable feelings that I may not have the chance to discuss with peers, or even if I did that we might not feel safe to say. The most raw feelings can be safely enclosed in a poem.</p><h3>Jeremy Topin MD on Twitter</h3><p>Q7. Writing,for me,the stories of my patients / my experiences has been crucial..forcing me to slow down and creating space to process, understand and feel #medhumchat</p><h3>Anna Leahy on Twitter</h3><p>@medhumchat A7. Yes! But I am a writer, not a clinician, so writing, language, narrative are the way I make sense of everything in a way. Language and storytelling are perhaps the most human means of sense-making, though we also make sense in less conscious or organized ways. #medhumchat</p><h3>Kate Nicholson on Twitter</h3><p>A.7. I&#39;m currently writing about my own experience with severe pain and disability - largely in order to advocate for people suffering from something that very few lacking direct experience of it understand. #medhumchat</p><p><em>Huge thanks to </em><a href="https://twitter.com/nick_mcken"><em>Nick McKenzie</em></a><em> for helping to get the #medhumchat blog started, and to all the participants.</em></p><p><em>I hope you’ll join me for the next </em><a href="https://twitter.com/medhumchat"><em>@medhumchat</em></a><em>!</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=10a122c4bc48" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>