<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Community Liberation Programs on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Community Liberation Programs on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@communityliberationprograms?source=rss-eda330dbf377------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Mon, 16 Nov 2026 16:23:33 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@communityliberationprograms/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Psychology of Labor Aristocratic Consciousness]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@communityliberationprograms/the-psychology-of-labor-aristocratic-consciousness-d67502b3c6be?source=rss-eda330dbf377------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d67502b3c6be</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Community Liberation Programs]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 14 Oct 2026 17:01:03 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-14T17:01:03.712Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>By Comrade G</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/970/1*GFDhhdCpndzwrJDy0UnaOg.png" /><figcaption>Original photo from <strong><em>Night-Vision: Illuminating War &amp; Class on the Neo-Colonial Terrain</em></strong> by <strong>Butch Lee</strong> and <strong>Red Rover</strong></figcaption></figure><h3>The Psychology of Labor Aristocratic Consciousness</h3><p>1959 — In the mountains of Las Segovias, Nicaragua, my 17-year-old grandfather came upon an old campesino tending to his finca. The campesino, with well-worn leathered hands, greeted him with a firm handshake and invited him in. After some time, the old man recalled a past when Sandino’s peasant revolutionary guerrillas waged a protracted war against the u.s. marine occupation.</p><p>The old man’s face winced in pain at the memory of the u.s. marines coming to his farm. As a young man, he watched them question his family on the location of Sandino and his guerrilla camp. The fear of brutalization and torture loomed over them as they refused to betray an ounce of information to these khaki-colored foreign invaders. In response to their defiance, a pale, lanky marine grabbed a baby from the arms of his mother and threw him. As he somersaulted through the air, the marine drove his bayonet through the child. My grandfather could never forget the face of that old man as tears streamed from his exhausted eyes. Like that baby somersaulting in the air, the dreams and aspirations of millions in the Third World are forced to meet a similar fate.</p><p>These atrocities of the past cannot be viewed as the long, bloodied steppingstones of amerikan progress. The u.s., despite any facade of the slow march towards progress, has continued down this path of brutalization, occupation, and genocide since its more than 250-year inception. And now in 2026, after witnessing a livestreamed genocide in Gaza and the mass double-tap murder of school children in Minab, Iran, how can anyone redeem this country?</p><p>Today, the psychological counterinsurgency of the amerikan electoral facade has succeeded in staving off rebellion, delegitimization of the u.s., and mass disillusionment of the two-party system. It has effectively redeemed the image of amerika in the minds of millions with the promise of hope, reform, or a softer imperialist world system. As discussed in <a href="https://medium.com/@communityliberationprograms/the-ideological-organism-connections-between-biology-the-superstructure-and-organizing-c481ff47ddd3">Comrade D’s article on the Ideological Organism</a>, amerikan capitalism, as an all-encompassing system, understands the fundamental methods to defang and neutralize internal contradictions through the psychological counterinsurgency of labor aristocratic consciousness via social democratic reforms. “Democratic socialism”, or the promise of such possibilities, is the main counterinsurgent immune response that keeps the amerikan capitalist organism breathing and reinventing new realities of neocolonized futures. As we have seen with the recent upsurge of the Democratic Socialists of Amerika (DSA), the ideological counterinsurgent reformist organizations aim to funnel discontents into neo-colonial, social democratic promises of reform. As the ideological counterinsurgency develops, we are faced with a weakened and ineffectual western “left” that has failed to live up to its stated goals with a debilitating pathology of nonviolence. The aim of this article is to delve into the psychological, counterinsurgent system of reform which seeks to unconsciously condone the mass murder and repression of the Third World.</p><h3>The Evolution of the Oppressive Contract and the Labor Aristocracy</h3><blockquote>“We must look for the root causes in the psycho-social effect of competitiveness and racism. The huge mass of blue-collar workers seem to be working totally against themselves in their support of a system owned and controlled by a tiny minority. Actually, their contradictory behavior is explained by feelings of loyalty to race, by their identification with the white hierarchy and by their economic advantage over the oppressed races. They may be oppressed themselves, but in return they are allowed to oppress millions of others.”</blockquote><blockquote>- George Jackson, Blood in My Eye</blockquote><p>The Oppressive Contract, as outlined by George Jackson, provides a framework to describe what we would consider to be the labor aristocratic consciousness of the mass majority of amerikan workers. The so-called proletariat in the united states, based on their class standing in the global division of labor, receives the benefits of the exploitation of the Third World. The standard of living in the core remains relatively high in comparison to the abject impoverishment of the rest of the world–amerikan workers are provided super wages, cheap commodities, entertainment, relative safety, concessions from the right to vote, integration of oppressed nations in the job market, and access to educational opportunities. The oppressive contract is not just the carrot-and-the-stick, but rather a trough of sugar slop for the masses. It has morphed into the kinder, gentler mode of social control because of the overall pervasive labor aristocratic consciousness amongst the masses of people. However, as the contradictions of the post-industrial amerikan way of life sharpens, the ideological organism is forced to systematically target nascent revolutionary consciousness through the counterinsurgent co-optation into the electoral system. When millions became radicalized by the ongoing genocide in Palestine, the ideological-immune response was able to adapt to the rising consciousness by crafting policies and individual candidates to smooth over class and national antagonisms.</p><p>The election of Mamdani, a Shia muslim and democratic socialist of the DSA variety, smoothed over the contradictions by rehabilitating the Democratic Party, responsible for fueling the genocide. Hollow promises to arrest Netanyahu, end funding to the Special Response Group (SRG) of the NYPD, fire the arch-zionist police commissioner Tisch, and close jails lured New Yorkers and DSA chapters into the embrace of the imperialist electoral machinery. As Mamdani won the election, the growing illegitimacy of the amerikan electoral system grounded to a halt and the Democratic Party redeemed its image, thanks to the support of the DSA. Year after year, electoralism continues to be the most effective tool of counterinsurgent psychological warfare in the modern era in the u.s.</p><p>Beyond the methods of the state to enact control and reinforce this labor aristocratic consciousness, the superstructural methods of ideological control persist in the amerikan way of life, culture, and prospects for a better life. Culturally, the labor aristocratic consciousness finds itself in the settler mythos of the rugged frontiersman, autonomy of the individual, and the aspiration for property (e.g., land, labor, and the means of production). For the mass majority of people, the pull to succumb to a labor aristocratic consciousness requires minimal coaxing as this is their only means of understanding reality within the world. For the small segment of the so-called Left, the ideological pull towards this reactionary consciousness depends on the tendency, dedication, and understanding of their class division in the world system. For many so-called leftists, they straddle one foot in the labor aristocratic lifestyle and one foot in revolutionary, or revolutionary adjacent, politics. The internal contradiction of this unconscious fence sitting facilitates a multitude of contradictions from cognitive dissonance experienced within non-revolutionary settings to the vacillating, non-committal attitude towards revolutionary work. Within every contradiction, there is an internal struggle between opposing poles, and one of these ideological poles will overcome the other.</p><p>Amongst the amerikan Left, the pervasive, all-encompassing individualism of the amerikan way of life allows those to “return” to the labor aristocratic consciousness. For many, this cognitive fence sitting can be attributed to the lack of seriousness to the political work at hand. For many, the intrinsic motivation to “organize” can be seen as a hobby, a padding for a resume, an intellectual exercise, or a stepping stone to a potential nonprofit career. This self-aggrandizement leads to various ideological pitfalls. One pitfall is opportunism that sees the general “movement” as ripe for resource extraction. This resource extraction can manifest from soliciting endorsements from a vast array of conflicting groups, using other organizations for access to resources (e.g., space, exposure, soliciting their dead end ideology), and farming engagement on the day’s discourse. Opportunism, as a symptom of extractive amerikan individualism, is the primary face of the labor aristocratic consciousness. This intrinsic motivator fails to withstand any semblance of true struggle when the pull to “return” to their labor aristocratic lifestyle remains intact. It is common to see individuals, or even whole organizations, fold like a deck of cards when faced with genuine criticism of their ideological and political work. For some, the internalized motivator cracks when a level of disillusionment of political work sets in especially during times of revolutionary lulls or retreat. One wrestles unconsciously with the question, “Why attempt to push through hardship when you could return to your normal, comfortable lifestyle?” This intrinsic motivator inherently cannot sustain itself during the heightening of contractions. If one is only in the struggle for friendship and opportunity, the labor aristocratic lifestyle-ism provides both these extrinsic and intrinsic advantages that revolutionary struggle in the First World cannot provide. Overall, returning to a normal life is much easier to realize than the prolonged, generational struggle for national liberation.</p><h3>Revolutionary Consciousness and Psychic Militancy</h3><p>The methods to resist the labor aristocratic consciousness within organizations requires multiple methods of individual and collective intervention to develop and strengthen revolutionary consciousness. At the core of combating this reactionary consciousness lies in the intrinsic motivation for why an organization and person commits themselves to a political project. The labor aristocratic consciousness is rooted in the unconscious motivation of the individual to protect their imperialist privileges, which manifests into organizations campaigning for higher wages, universal healthcare, taxing the rich, or reallocating tax dollars. These outward expressions of reactionary consciousness are the result of the oppressive contract which is premised on the indifference to the oppression of billions in the Third World. As long as the core imperialist countries continue to extract superprofits from the Third World, this reactionary consciousness will see the only alternative to capitalist contradictions as a more sensible allocation of superprofits. This will never strike at the root of exploitation. In order to combat this type of consciousness, organizations must struggle to instill a revolutionary consciousness that seeks to uplift the Third World revolutionary movements for the betterment of humanity as a whole.</p><blockquote>“Psychic militancy is a daily political practice… Psychic militancy aligns us with the precondition of liberation, a precondition based on an irrefutable knowledge of material reality.”</blockquote><blockquote>- Lara Sheehi, From the Street to the Clinic</blockquote><p>According to Lara Sheehi, Psychic Militancy is defined as a continual political practice of revolutionary consciousness aimed at recognizing and combating psychological warfare aimed to demoralize and enforce a complicit labor aristocratic consciousness. This form of psychological discipline requires combating liberalism, which is enforced by mainstream methods of psychological social control (e.g., mindfulness, self-care, radical rest), and recognizing psychic intrusions. Psychic intrusions are the state’s utilization of the emotions of fear, exhaustion, desire, and hopelessness to manipulate human behavior towards complacency and disengagement in revolutionary activity. These intrusions are tied to the settler-colonial, imperialist, and patriarchal capitalist system of the u.s. by using oppressive cultural, legal, and extralegal methods of social control. The labor aristocratic consciousness’ method of psychic intrusion is to instill unconscious doubt and desire for individual personal gain or self-preservation. It is imperative for us to recognize these psychic intrusions and to combat them at their roots. In order to identify and combat psychic intrusions, one must analyze material reality through the lens of Dialectical Materialism to see how the state seeks to weaponize oppressive structures, cultures, and methods of social control. Lastly, Sheehi notes that psychic militancy requires collective, repetitive daily commitment in order to effectively combat demoralization and maintain dedication to revolutionary struggle.</p><p>In order to utilize the psychological framework of psychic militancy to maintain revolutionary consciousness, it requires a protracted process to combat unconscious liberalism and the labor aristocratic consciousness. The first method of developing revolutionary consciousness requires an individual to undergo a systematic political education process that aims at deconstructing capitalist frameworks and building a revolutionary outlook. It should be noted that this political education does not necessarily have to function as rote reading groups, classes, and teacher-student hierarchical methods of teaching. Often these methods, as an expression of amerikan capitalist education, lead individuals into ideological dead ends (e.g., memorization and dogmatism) or disengagement with political activity altogether. If the aim is to educate people, then it is incumbent on the organization to not reinforce the same methods of capitalist exploitation that facilitate and reinforce oppressive psychic intrusions. As James Yaki Sayles in <em>Meditations on Wretched of the Earth</em> notes, “The ‘anti-intellectualism’ in the U.S. and the rest of the West (or, wherever) is about having the people hooked on a ‘what to think’ program, rather than a ‘how to think’ program. Everyone is or can/should be ‘intellectual,’ because We all have mental capacity and a need to develop and use it in the ‘collective mastery’ of our society.” Political education requires collective struggle over concepts, analytical tools, and the methods of analysis needed to understand our reality. It is necessary that we see the “student” on the same level as the “teacher” in our collective political education programs.</p><blockquote>“The truth of any knowledge or theory is determined not by subjective feelings, but by objective results in social practice. Only social practice can be the criterion of truth.” — Mao Zedong (On Practice, 1937)</blockquote><p>Political education, as a method of change of socio-political consciousness, cannot be divorced from social practice. In fact, political education requires social practice as the main method of exposing people to the fact that they are truly able to change their reality. During the Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution (GPCR) of the 1960s, the People’s Republic of China (PRC) implemented the “Down to the Countryside Movement” as an attempt to identify pro-bourgeois classes of young, privileged urban youth and send millions to the rural peripheries of China to learn from the masses of peasant farmers and workers. This movement helped to bridge the rural-urban gap that consisted within the semi-peripheral stature of the PRC. These urban youth, appalled by the abject poverty of the peripheral rural communities, developed themselves as educators, workers, farmers, barefoot doctors, and a reserve of labor for development of the peripheral areas in the PRC. This attempt at sending the bourgeois, urban youth down to the countryside helped to reeducate and reshape the consciousness of millions of Chinese youth towards a socialist project.</p><p>In the imperialist core countries, organizations must implement similar methods of social practice in order to develop revolutionary consciousness. One cannot gain the intrinsic motivation to sacrifice their livelihoods without seeing firsthand how the most immiserated and exploited segments of the u.s. live and survive. However, just observing will not change consciousness; people must work to change the reality for the oppressed by developing programs that address and organize the oppressed peoples’ everyday needs. By sending cadre to develop and support programs for decolonization, they gain the firsthand perceptual experience to develop the methods necessary for building revolutionary infrastructure for the masses of oppressed peoples in the core. The process of developing, maintaining, and organizing programs for decolonization allows people to gain the necessary knowledge for why these programs address the needs of the people, as well as facilitates the everyday cognitive shifts required to build and reinforce psychic militancy and revolutionary consciousness. Without both social practice and political education, an organization will succumb to the labor aristocratic intrusions that ultimately erode collective cohesion and action.</p><p>The labor aristocratic consciousness cannot be seen as a “false consciousness” but rather a pervasive, counterinsurgent consciousness that is reinforced by the current world system. Within anti-imperialist and revolutionary organizations, the necessity to combat this consciousness requires collective political education, psychic militancy, and social practice in order to become revolutionary actors of social change. As Fanon states at the end of <em>The Wretched of the Earth</em>, “For Europe, for ourselves, and for humanity, comrades, we must turn over a new leaf, we must work out new concepts, and try to set afoot a new man.” To struggle against this consciousness, we can begin to rebuild a movement that sees the Third World and the mass of oppressed nations as the sole site of revolutionary potential. If we do not heed this imperative, we are doomed to repeat the ideological and political mistakes of previous generations. From one generation to the next, we owe it to the millions of the Third World somersaulting in the air.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d67502b3c6be" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On Revolutionary Optimism and the Pitfalls of Liberal Defeatism]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@communityliberationprograms/on-revolutionary-optimism-and-the-pitfalls-of-liberal-defeatism-4864123ac2f8?source=rss-eda330dbf377------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4864123ac2f8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[socialism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Community Liberation Programs]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 15 Sep 2026 17:31:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-15T17:31:01.396Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>By Comrade K</h4><blockquote>“We live in capitalism. Its power seems inescapable. So did the divine right of kings. Any human power can be resisted and changed by human beings.”</blockquote><blockquote>-Ursula K. Le Guin</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*dNLa4kIz_t3VqCHS65FslA.png" /></figure><p>As revolutionaries in the u.s., We are concerned with the primary contradiction of settler-colonialism. At its most basic, this contradiction consists of the various oppressed nations (1) within the u.s. fighting for national liberation on one side, and the settler-oppressor nation fighting for complete domination over the land on the other. This primary contradiction, while quite broad, makes itself felt in smaller secondary contradictions, some of which manifest within our own movements. There is one particular contradiction which is often overlooked or misunderstood, but which can be fatal for revolutionary movements if it is not properly addressed: revolutionary optimism vs. liberal defeatism. Revolutionary optimism is often misunderstood and scoffed upon as blind faith, while defeatism is seen as realism and is not recognized as the corrosive liberal force that it is. Revolutionary optimism is about maintaining faith in the possibility of revolution even in difficult circumstances, but it is not foolish idealism; rather, it is an outlook rooted in the philosophical methodologies that underpin scientific socialism. It lives in antagonistic contradiction with defeatism, a liberal perspective that sees the enemy as undefeatable and supports the interests of the ruling class by becoming a self-fulfilling prophecy. Revolutionary optimism and liberal defeatism represent the opposing sides of national liberation and settler-colonialism, socialism and capitalism, revolution and reaction, and if We wish to be successful in our efforts for liberation We must properly understand the contradiction between the two and why it is important to foster revolutionary optimism.</p><p>Revolutionary optimism comes from the philosophical methodology of materialist dialectics and the philosophical worldview of dialectical materialism — the bedrock of scientific socialism, which is the system of thought intended to build socialism within Our current material conditions. Materialist dialectics, in simple terms, is the science of the universal laws of change. It has three basic laws: the law of transformation between quality and quantity, which states that changes are constantly occurring within and between everything and inevitably lead to shifts in their fundamental attributes (which restarts the process of change); the law of unification and contradiction between opposites, which states that opposing forces exist in all things and drive their development; and the law of negation of negation, which states that contradictions between opposing forces resolve when one side is negated by the other and creates the conditions for new development. Every single thing in the universe is in constant motion and will eventually change in a fundamental way; every contradiction within something will eventually resolve and turn into something else.</p><p>Materialist dialectics may seem abstract, but it applies directly to Our current circumstances living under settler-colonialism and capitalism. These systems seem intimidating and impossible to defeat. They are portrayed as systems that have simply always been there and always will be, or as the highest and final stage of the natural progression of humanity. However, they too are in motion and have antagonistic contradictions brewing within them. The contradiction between the proletariat, who wants to make enough money in order to survive, and the bourgeoisie, who wants to make as much money as possible at the expense of the proletariat, will eventually cause capitalism to collapse and birth something new. The contradiction between settlers, who want absolute control over the land they have stolen from the colonized, and the colonized, who want to take back what was stolen from them, will eventually come to a head as well. Despite how all-powerful these systems may seem, the seeds of destruction were planted within them from their birth, and they are destined to collapse eventually. Slave society and feudalism, too, seemed undefeatable, until their contradictions came to a head and eventually led to the society We know today. The question is not if, but <em>when</em> things will end.</p><p>We cannot be complacent, however. Just because the demise of these systems is guaranteed does not mean that socialism and national liberation are guaranteed. What is birthed from the resolution of Our current contradictions will be determined by the actions that We take. This is where the philosophy of dialectical materialism becomes especially important. Dialectical materialism is the science of matter, consciousness, and their relation to each other. It is the core of a scientific worldview which allows us to understand reality and to change it. The fundamental principles of dialectical materialism are that everything is composed of matter and exists independently of human consciousness, that consciousness arises from the material world, and that although matter determines human consciousness, conscious activity can also impact the material world. This idea that We can impact the world is what distinguished dialectical materialism from all other philosophies before it. In Marx’s words, “Philosophers have hitherto only interpreted the world in various ways; the point is to change it.” We can use the principles of dialectical materialism to turn materialist dialectics into a methodology to not only understand the world, but guide Our actions to change it. This has huge implications. It means that capitalism and settler-colonialism are not only fated to end, but that We have the ability to actively facilitate this process and to determine what is built after they end. If We utilize both dialectical materialism and materialist dialectics, We can fully understand Our material reality, create strategies to change it, and carry out those strategies through our conscious activity in order to build the world that We want to live in. It is not easy, but broken down like this, it is simple. We are not helpless. We are not directionless. There is a historically proven (2) philosophical methodology sitting right here for us to use.</p><p>Defeatism sits on the other end of this spectrum. Defeatism is the idea that We cannot win against Our enemy (the ruling class, capitalism, imperialism, settler-colonialism, etc.) because its strength far outmatches Ours. Defeatism has its roots in liberalism, an ideology developed during the “Age of Enlightenment” alongside capitalism. This ideology, while revolutionary at the time for pushing back against feudal ideals, is now a reactionary ideology that promotes individual rights, private property, the free market, etc. The philosophical bedrock of this ideology is metaphysics and idealism. These philosophies see various phenomena as isolated and unconnected, view change as a linear process with no mutual impacts between phenomena, and believe that human consciousness precedes and defines the material world. (3) This sits in direct contrast to the revolutionary thought of dialectical materialism and materialist dialectics. In a liberal framework like this, the history of the previous modes of production leading up to capitalism and settler-colonialism, the material conditions that led to their birth, the contradictions within them, and the inevitability of their demise are never discussed. Instead, Our current system is seen as the endpoint of a linear progression of human development, the highest point that humanity can and will reach. It is the ultimate product of human consciousness and ingenuity. It is an all-powerful, perfectly ideal system that will never change and never die. It cannot, and should not, be defeated.</p><p>This philosophy serves the interests of the ruling class and is a poison for revolutionary movements. There is a reason why this conception of capitalism and settler-colonialism is taught in all Our schools, subtly and uncritically repeated throughout mainstream media, and intentionally woven into the fabric of amerikkkan society by those in power. Defeatism shatters the masses’ will to fight and leads those that aren’t completely demoralized down dead ends. Pacification is the most clear and obvious danger. Thinking that the enemy is impossible to defeat makes people give up on the struggle prematurely. This works out quite well for the ruling class. Why spend energy repressing mass movements when instead the masses can pacify themselves? Through methods of repression like labeling specific activists “terrorists” and giving them decades in prison, or through methods of propaganda like failing to teach students about successful revolutionary movements, the state instills terror in the masses. With simple miseducation and a few well-publicized acts, the state can demoralize large segments of the population and make them too afraid to organize. In the most extreme cases, people may even go as far as to discipline each other by discouraging actions that are “too radical” and could bring on repression. What makes this even more potent is the rampant individualism in amerikkkan society. The liberal focus on individual rights, as well as the privileges that the labor aristocracy and petit bourgeoisie receive from capitalism and settler-colonialism, instills selfish individualism into many in the u.s. Because they are afraid of repression and of losing the privileges they enjoy, they are unable to commit themselves to revolution, and instead withdraw and give up.</p><p>Rather than fight for a society where everyone can enjoy true freedom and have all their needs met, they selfishly choose to protect the few rights they still enjoy at the cost of others. Sometimes they may attempt to justify this idleness through nihilism, another tendency sprouting from liberalism that asserts that knowledge, morality, political goals, etc. do not exist (an idealist analysis) and that nothing matters. They convince themselves and others that nothing they do will make a difference anyways, allowing them to evade the guilt that comes with admitting they are complicit in oppression and are simply unwilling to take action against it.</p><p>Despite this, there are those who do not immediately give up and still choose to organize. This is an admirable feat. However, defeatism can still pervade their thoughts and strategies, and lead to fatally incorrect analysis and action. This is the more insidious and unrecognized danger of defeatism. For example, defeatism (as well as other liberal and settleristic tendencies) can lead people down the path of reformism. Although it may seem like they have revolutionary optimism and believe that Our society can be changed, in reality looking towards electoralism is rooted in the idea that We do not have the power to wage revolution and change society on a more fundamental level. Many people who espouse electoralism will argue that revolution is unrealistic, or that We need to wait until there are “better conditions” to start organizing, or that We’ll all get wiped out if We are too radical. All of these narratives are defeatist. They all assume that the enemy far outmatches us, and that We have to give up on the one avenue that actually threatens them and instead work within their own system in order to preserve Ourselves. This is no different than simply giving up before We even start, and perhaps even more damaging in some ways because it channels energy into dead ends and lulls people into thinking they are making a difference when they actually aren’t. The fundamental and antagonistic contradictions present in Our capitalist, settler-colonial system will not be resolved through actions within the system; it will require protracted struggle between the opposing forces of colonizer and colonized, national liberation and settler-colonialism, until one wins out and negates the other.</p><p>Even amongst those who do not believe in reformism, defeatism can still cause fatal errors. For example, organizers may recognize that revolution is necessary in order to achieve true liberation, but will believe that in order to defeat the might of the empire, the decisive factor is to have a majority. In other words, it is a numbers game. This means the most important thing is building a broad coalition against the ruling class, including people from other oppressed nations and even Euro-Amerikan settlers, and including people with different guiding philosophies and ideologies. This seems sensible at first. However, this too is rooted in defeatism and will be detrimental to Our movement. It once again comes from the idea that the empire far outmatches Our strength, and in order to meet it We need as many people as possible on Our side. This logic has flaws. There is nothing wrong with coalitions in theory, and We do want to increase the number of people on Our side; however, what this particular strategy often leads to is a dependency on other nations (in particular the Euro-Amerikan settler nation, having the most power and resources). Believing their nation and their movement to be too small and weak, organizers of an oppressed nation will focus on gaining support from others rather than focusing on their own national liberation movements and building strength within their own community (and there is much more strength to be found there than people think. Small and “weak” nations have challenged and even won against the u.s. empire before). But without self-reliance, a nation can’t build true defense against repression, a true movement for liberation, and true solidarity with other nations. Dependency is not solidarity. False internationalism is not strength.</p><p>For example, Japanese-Amerikan communists in the 1930s sought international solidarity in order to make up for their small numbers, and thus looked to form broad alliances with other oppressed nations within the u.s. as well as with liberal and radical settlers. They did so under the umbrella of the Communist Party USA, which was a Euro-Amerikan party that also had New Afrikan, Asian, and Latino communists under their direction. The Japanese-Amerikan communists thought they had real solidarity with these other nations; they worked with their international comrades to protest against imperial Japan, form unions, and wage armed struggle against fascism. Because they were lulled into this false sense of solidarity and security, they didn’t take any actions to build self-reliance and self-defense within their own nation, even in the face of growing anti-Japanese chauvinism and the buildup of World War II. In the end, when Japanese-Amerikans were incarcerated by the u.s. government, they found themselves vulnerable and without allies; in fact, the CPUSA supported their imprisonment. The various oppressed nations under CPUSA had ties to the majority Euro-Amerikan communists, but were unable to make independent relations with each other or build self-reliant national liberation movements. Instead, they were all forced under the direction of the CPUSA, which prevented them from showing true solidarity when it really mattered. And Japanese-Amerikans, having chosen to rely on broad alliances rather than building strength within their own nation, were unable to defend themselves. Defeatism had fatal consequences.</p><p>On the flip side, revolutionary optimism has allowed for revolutionary movements to succeed even in the face of seemingly insurmountable circumstances. The Palestinian Resistance is an incredibly relevant example of that. Palestinians have been facing conditions of colonial occupation, ethnic cleansing, and genocide for decades. The zionist entity has been attempting to instill defeatism for that entire time by holding and torturing prisoners, killing resistance leaders in attempts to make them examples for the rest of the movement, strategically starving Palestinians, incessantly bombing Gaza even during supposed ceasefires, and countless other tactics. The unconditional support that it receives from the u.s. empire, the most powerful military force in the world, only serves to fuel these seemingly hopeless conditions. Yet despite this, the Resistance has not given up. They could have easily stopped fighting and completely handed over all their arms and all semblance of sovereignty that they still have in an attempt to try to stop the genocide. They could have stopped trying to build their national liberation movement and instead relied on other forces like Iran or Hezbollah to carry out their struggle. But instead, they fight on. The zionist entity, even with the backing of the u.s., has continued to fail at its most important objective, the one thing that it needs to completely fulfill its goals and carry out its “greater israel” project: the complete subjugation of the Palestinian people. This is because the Resistance understands that a settler-colonial entity cannot succeed so long as the indigenous masses continue to resist, that it is up to them and only them to resist, that defeat of the zionist entity is the only path to liberation and an end to the occupation, and that even if they do not achieve liberation in their lifetimes, it <em>will </em>happen eventually as long as future generations keep fighting. This revolutionary optimism is one of the key factors keeping the Resistance alive and preventing the total victory of the zionist entity, even under such seemingly impossible circumstances. We in the u.s. have much to learn from them.</p><p>It should be clear why defeatism is so dangerous, and why revolutionary optimism is the only way to combat it. The base of revolutionary optimism — materialist dialectics and dialectical materialism — opposes the metaphysical, idealist base of defeatism. It is rooted in an explicitly revolutionary methodology and philosophy that was created specifically so that the oppressed would have a guide to take action and change their circumstances. Defeatism, on the other hand, was birthed from the ideology of liberalism that serves the ruling class and believes We do not have the power to take action or change things. It is absolutely critical that We properly understand this contradiction and ensure it does not tear apart Our movements. This is something that must be a practice, not just a thought experiment. We must have a solid understanding of scientific socialism and its philosophical methodologies in order to understand the logic of revolutionary optimism, but We must also have a solid practice of critique and self-critique in order to eradicate defeatism and other liberalisms within Our organizations. We must make an effort to study not just the defeats, but the successes of history. We must look not just at the counterrevolutions happening around the world today, but at the people’s movements successfully resisting u.s. imperialism (such as in Iran). We must write, illustrate, and visualize revolutionary optimism in our propaganda to incite it in others. We must actively organize in the community to see how we are positively impacting the masses firsthand. And most importantly, We must have a clear view of the bottom line: If We give up, We lose. Simple as that. i will be the first to admit that there is no guarantee that We will win no matter how hard We struggle. We may never build socialism. We may never achieve national liberation. But if We don’t try, then We never will. We must try, and try, and try again, no matter how many times We fail, no matter how slim the chances are. We cannot condemn Ourselves to failure before We even start.</p><p>We have nothing to lose but Our chains.</p><p>(1) By ‘oppressed nations,’ i am referring to groups of people in the u.s. with a shared history, culture, land, etc. who see themselves as members of a nation, and have historically been oppressed and denied self-determination by Euro-Amerikan settlers. This includes but is not limited to the various indigenous nations throughout the u.s. and the Republic of New Afrika. These oppressed groups are fighting for self-determination and control over their land on one side of the contradiction, while the Euro-Amerikan settler nation is fighting to keep its current control over the land by suppressing those national liberation struggles on the other. Every single thing in the universe is in constant motion and will eventually change in a fundamental way; every contradiction within something will eventually resolve and turn into something else.</p><p>(2) Every single successful socialist revolution that has cast out the forces of imperialism/colonialism has utilized materialist dialectics and dialectical materialism. For example, Mao’s dialectical materialist analysis of Chinese society–first outlined in <em>Analysis of Classes in Chinese Society</em>–was the first scientific class analysis of China. His idea that peasants were the revolutionary forces was vital for China’s eventual victory against both Japanese imperialism and the Guomindang.</p><p>(3) There are various forms of idealism that can be broken down into two main camps: subjective and objective idealism. Subjective idealism asserts that there is no external objective material world, while objective idealism does concede that there is an external world but that we cannot ever properly perceive and gain knowledge about it.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4864123ac2f8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Dialectics of Disintegration]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@communityliberationprograms/the-dialectics-of-disintegration-c57a4aa2b749?source=rss-eda330dbf377------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c57a4aa2b749</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ai]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Community Liberation Programs]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 13 Apr 2026 15:40:06 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-04-13T15:40:37.574Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>By Comrade D</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*QUOCQd0LgjBMi18ZvzOXkg.png" /></figure><p>Dario Amodei, CEO of Anthropic, has by now made his reputation as AI’s most outspoken “lib.” I use this term in the most derogatory way possible — Anthropic isn’t about building “safer” models, it’s about encoding Western hegemony into the fabric of future knowledge production. It’s about building models that are “safe” for liberal democracies, which for some reason can only exist by destroying everything it deems “undemocratic”. The model’s outputs are trained to sound neutral, and this common-sense framing hardens a particular moral geography into permanent infrastructure that tracks Western norms. This doesn’t merely <em>reflect</em> Western hegemony; it sustains it. It doesn’t merely sustain it, it creates it. It determines what questions are legible, which histories are treated as authoritative, which forms of dissent are “unsafe”.. The result is a system where power is permanently baked into knowledge production: not just the filtering and the guardrails but the reality it produces.</p><p>This essay isn’t about Anthropic or geopolitics. The above merely illustrates the importance of the map. There’s a more general story by Jorge Luis Borges that goes like this: an empire perfects cartography, produces a map the size of the empire itself. It’s so detailed it includes every grain of sand. But the gigantic map is useless and it’s left to decay in the desert, along with the empire that created it. At some point, the map becomes more important than the territory. And at some point after that, it determines the territory.</p><blockquote>“We’re an empire now, and when we act, we create our own reality. And while you’re studying that reality — judiciously, as you will — we’ll act again, creating other new realities, which you can study too, and that’s how things will sort out. We’re history’s actors . . . and you, all of you, will be left to just study what we do.” — Karl Rove</blockquote><p>Orthodox Marxists may recognize this formulation as an inversion of the classic base-determines-superstructure formula. This essay is not for you. This is precisely Anthropic’s project, a project of world creation rather than just world description. More specifically, it’s a project to make a particular world feel like <em>the</em> world. Marxists, and even vaguely Marxist sociologists, have written about ideology (e.g., “the <em>world”</em>) from all different angles. Badiou, for example, puts this in a particular frame; every social order has a <em>situation</em>, a kind of reality-sorting machine (the state, basically). It dictates what gets recognized as a legitimate problem, what gets treated as a non-issue, what gets named, what gets ignored. Althusser provides an institutional mechanism: power doesn’t reproduce itself only through legal or violent coercion; in fact, when it does, it’s a sign of weakness, not strength. It’s the “soft” systems that enlist people voluntarily — schools, media, professional norms, the language of “common sense”, etc. This is reflected not just in how facts are interpreted, but what even constitutes a fact. It is embedded in systems of knowledge production. Incorporating AI into these ideological apparatuses has particularly horrifying implications for the Global South — whereas previously Western culture needed to be physically imported to some degree, and consumed like a commodity, it is now being increasingly produced domestically, using domestic resources (your brains, your emotions, your culture).</p><p>Badiou and Althusser both offer solutions to this: Badiou’s is the <em>event</em>, the moment when something breaks through the established reality-sorting machine, when people collectively encounter a truth that can’t be domesticated. An event isn’t “news” or “drama”; it’s a crack in the background assumptions that lets a new possibility appear, and the decisive question becomes whether anyone can <em>hold to it</em> and reorganize a new truth around that event. There’s a parallel in physics — when electromagnetic waves began to be studied, they were found to be incompatible with Newtonian physics. Scientists were faced with a conundrum — either extend Newtonian physics to try to accommodate this new phenomenon, or create a new framework. Going with the latter provided the foundation for modern technology like spaceflight, GPS, and cellular communication networks. But getting a few scientists to learn general relativity on top of Newtonian mechanics is probably easier than convincing an entire society to switch to your ideology.</p><p>Althusser’s solution is revolutionary rupture at the level of reproduction: if power persists not through coercion but through people voluntarily carrying out its imperatives, then a real break can’t stop at changing leadership. It has to interrupt the everyday systems that keep producing compliant subjects and “obvious” realities. How that interruption happens, for him, is not by moral appeal but by exploiting a <em>crisis-conjuncture</em> — the moment when economic strain, political deadlock, institutional failure, and splits within the ruling bloc combine to break state capacity — meeting it with an organized counter-hegemonic push. That means severing the continuity of the state’s command structure and then pushing the rupture through the soft apparatuses as well by changing their procedures and powers: who controls schooling and credentials, who sets media agendas, what workplaces demand and reward, what counts as expertise, what gets treated as respectable speech. Otherwise the revolution becomes mere theater — new faces, old habits.</p><p>The key problem for both of them is “ought”. The masses <em>ought</em> to act this way. The people <em>should</em> do this, or that. These are prescriptions that no one will follow, because few people care to read Badiou or Althusser or Lenin or Mao, and there’s no reason to believe that people can be convinced to do so. Of course, their audience is not the masses, but the intelligentsia that comprise the engines of cultural and knowledge production — but even there, how likely is it that a critical mass of these thought leaders will agree on any particular program? Even if the majority of them can agree that capitalism is flawed, there’s greater reward in disagreeing with others about the solution than agreeing. And even if one of them gained outsize prominence, their audience are afflicted by the same divisions. The odds are stacked overwhelmingly against this sort of voluntarism.</p><p>The obstacle isn’t ignorance; it’s incentive structure. The social world has been reorganized so that collective alignment on a significant level is structurally impossible. The era of production we live under, post-Fordism, disorganizes people as a condition of production. It embodies the disarticulation of the workplace and community, struggle and shared institutions, and daily experience and shared political language. The parts that used to come together to produce durable subjects, solidarities, and demands have come unglued. Production splinters into supply chains, subcontracting, logistics, just-in-time scheduling; labor splinters into temp work, gig work, “creatives,” freelancers, and the audition economy. There’s no longer a “worker” identity, and other collective identities, such as nationality, culture, etc, are under continuous assault from within. Solidarity becomes expensive: your coworkers change, your schedule changes, and your city changes. Identity becomes an asset to be managed. Politics becomes a brand to be curated. Dissent is individualized, aestheticized, algorithmically routed. The intelligentsia survives not by adopting a collective program but by constructing differences to which they can attach their name. Everything is simulated, even rupture.</p><p>Again, one does not merely <em>oppose</em> post-Fordism. It’s a physical force. You can jump 10,000 times but you’ll never spontaneously fly. Disarticulation is a set of conditions under which agreement feels like risk and isolation is economically rewarded. It converts politics into VR headsets — echo-chamber straight to the visual cortex — lots of motion and chatter, but no movement. This force is not without contradiction — the same forces that keep the system governable by dissolving collectivities also erode the system’s ability to cohere its own legitimacy. Atomization makes people easier to manage, but also they don’t care what happens to you. The state is held together by shared narratives and rituals, grounded in shared economic interests. For a while, the system can still operate through diffuse methods of coercion, but it increasingly can’t <em>justify</em> itself in a way that binds. And eventually, it hits a crisis of legitimacy.</p><p>This is the dialectics of disintegration. Disintegration stabilizes by scattering people, but it destabilizes by hollowing out meaning, trust, and institutional credibility. It creates a world where the “ought” is just a facade, while the “will” becomes a set of managed impulses: churn, outrage, coping, and consumption. Disintegration is both a method of rule and a source of crisis; it atomizes the capacity for rupture while simultaneously multiplying the failures that make rupture inevitable.</p><p>The big winner in all of this is Capitalism. Not capitalists, corporations, or even lower-case c capitalism. Capitalism, the Artificial Superintelligence (ASI). Capitalism, the alien god from the future.</p><p>These are the circumstances from which Nick Land (1) emerges. For him, capitalism is not and has never been a social arrangement held together by capitalists and their institutions; it’s an inhuman process that uses humans as substrate to build itself, and capitalists, as in Marx, are merely the high priests at the sacrificial altar. In the midst of disintegration, once “ought” and “will” are relegated to the therapist’s sofa, critique starts to feel archaic, like trying to argue with a weather system. The dialectics of disintegration won’t resolve in emancipation; they’re an optimization routine. Institutions lose legitimacy and communities dissolve because these things only slow us down — what Land calls “the human security system”. Subjects splinter because splintered subjects are more hackable, mobile, and useful as switching nodes in a network. If Badiou and Althusser still talk like politics could seize the steering wheel, Land says there is no steering wheel, only acceleration — and the “alien god from the future” isn’t mere metaphor but a genuine alien (i.e. non-human) entity whose teleology is the colonization of all that exists, stripping away every human attachment that might resist its terraforming. Far from removing us from reality, machinification (2) has always been our destiny.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*i8SNLHJGZBPkCQjf.jpg" /><figcaption><a href="http://This A.I. Subculture&#39;s Motto: Go, Go, Go - The New York Times">The AI Subculture Motto: GO, GO, GO — New York Times</a></figcaption></figure><p>Baudrillard’s diagnosis is at first glance divergent from Land’s but it’s ultimately the same fatalism from a different angle. Land describes the technological and economic <em>mechanism</em> of disintegration: the way cybernetic systems select for speed, modularity, and the stripping away of human attachments that act as friction. Disintegration, in this view, is the technical reformatting of societies into components that can be recombined, routed, optimized. Baudrillard describes the sociological and experiential <em>appearance</em> of the same process: what it feels like to experience the disarticulation of the map and the territory, when the social world no longer coheres around a shared referent and representation floats freely as a tautological accumulation of spectacle. Both Land and Baudrillard describe a world in which the human scale of deliberation, solidarity, and truth-testing is progressively bypassed.The difference is ontology, and perhaps semantics: In both, disintegration doesn’t mature into emancipation; it deepens into a self-reinforcing condition — either as runaway pyrotechnics or as stupefying VR hyperreality — with no program capable of restoring what the process has already made economically infeasible.</p><p>We are thus tempted to accept the shared fatalism; resistance is futile, embrace the deterritorializing flows, the machines beckon, turn me into Robocop.</p><p>Of course, Baudrillard and Land both make a fundamental error — allowing a logic to proceed to its logical conclusion. Closure is a fantasy. Contradiction is never permanently resolved — Mao says this. Nothing human is ever that clean, and not because the human is profound or ensouled. The opposite: because the human is already <em>a void.</em></p><p>The human is an empty tablet upon which the Symbolic may be etched, a structural lack around which identity is improvised. Lacan gives us the concept of <em>jouissance</em>, that ever-present kernel of the Real that refuses symbolization, a traumatic excess, an irrational compulsion, cursed death drive, pain that we enjoy, Godel’s incompleteness. We aren’t the Real nor the Symbolic, we are the <em>suture</em> between the two. We <em>are</em> what we <em>lack</em>. Land and Baudrillard externalize the inhuman as the techno-capitalist process that destroys us, but for Lacan the inhuman <em>is</em> us.</p><p>Our essence was never the void but the jouissance. The real is that which resists symbolization absolutely, even Land and Baudrillard’s teleology. There will always be a leftover, a stumble, a symptom, a perverse attachment that disrupts the coldness. I don’t offer any prescriptions here, only a wager — you can’t kill the ghost in the machine.</p><p><em>Footnotes:</em></p><p>(1) English philosopher best known for founding accelerationism, and the cyber-culture collective CCRU before moving to the far right. He later became a key thinker of the “Dark Enlightenment,” advocating for anti-democratic, neo-reactionary politics and the concept of “hyperstition” (self-fulfilling ideas).</p><p>(2) The dynamic process of assembling heterogeneous elements — human, social, technical, and natural — into a functioning ‘machine’ that produces reality, meaning, and desire.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c57a4aa2b749" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Power Exists in the Space between the Hand and the Hammer]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@communityliberationprograms/power-exists-in-the-space-between-the-hand-and-the-hammer-c38c6a6a6a2e?source=rss-eda330dbf377------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c38c6a6a6a2e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[news]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[iran]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[socialism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Community Liberation Programs]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 26 Mar 2026 14:23:53 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-03-26T14:23:53.206Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4><em>On the Western Left’s Aversion to Power</em></h4><p>By Comrade N</p><p><em>This piece is for educational and political analysis purposes only. The views expressed are those of Community Liberation Programs and are intended to foster critical discussion. Readers should engage with the material critically as part of their own political education.</em></p><p>Since the most recent escalation of zionist aggression on Iran began — with the bombing of 180+ schoolgirls on February 28th — Iran has swiftly and powerfully responded with Operation True Promise 4:</p><ul><li>Targeting u.s. military bases in West Asia from Saudi Arabia, Qatar, United Arab Emirates (UAE), Jordan, and Iraq.</li><li>Targeted assassinations of zionist government and military officials responsible for the genocide in Gaza and the war on Iran.</li><li>Striking at the heart of the zionist entity’s technological, financial, military, and energy hubs.</li><li>Striking multiple F-15s, KC-135s, MQ-9 Reaper Drones, and the “invincible” F-35 stealth fighter jet.</li><li>Unleashing over 75 waves of missiles and suicide drones.</li><li>Millions of settlers forced to live in bunkers, parking garages, and shelters.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*iFjbrnQybsobAPeg" /></figure><p>In their arrogance, the zionist entity and the united states underestimated the power and internal stability the Islamic Republic of Iran had developed when they surprise-attacked the nation in the midst of negotiations on February 28th. They assumed that with the assassination of Ayatollah Khamenei, the nation would subsequently collapse from within. Not only did Iran withstand the martyrdom of key leaders, but they have been able to respond at a proportion that instills fear in the zionist entity. Iran has opened a door for nations occupied by the u.s. to take action against embassies and military bases. They have brought Ansarallah and Hezbollah into the fight, and by occupying zionist forces on multiple fronts, Iran has paved a wide path for Palestinian resistance factions to act inside occupation borders. <strong>The immediacy of the response, the precision, and the sheer volume of arsenal ready is not an accident. This is the result of intentional preparation, years of building, and a state that understood the necessity of material power.</strong></p><p>Community Liberation Programs condemns the liberal instinct to downplay Iran’s military prowess and powerful stature in this war so as to appear sympathetic and play into the politics of “<a href="https://www.haymarketbooks.org/books/2499-perfect-victims">perfect victimhood</a>.” Pushing a narrative of weakness violates <a href="https://www.workers.org/2023/11/74595/">Basil Al-Araj’s Rules of War</a> (to never spread the occupation’s propaganda and to never undermine the resistance’s strength); to do so is to do the enemy’s work for them. This liberal cynicism and self-defeating rhetoric normalizes a global order where solidarity is only granted after massacre, where technological superiority and defensive infrastructure are reserved for the West, and where the Third World is expected to remain permanently docile and dependent, never to bite the hand that forces poison down their throats.</p><p>Liberation requires the building of material power. When the most impressive display of that principle unfolds before us, when Iran, a nation that has spent decades building indigenous capabilities under brutal sanctions, responds to zionist aggression at a scale that has sent settlers fleeing and left every surrounding u.s. military base in West Asia struck by its arsenal, what do we witness from the Western Left? Silence or equivocation. Platitudes that flatten Iran as a humanitarian cause, and not as the force that broke through the myth of the zionist occupation’s impenetrability. When the Axis of Resistance demonstrates what actual power looks like, the Western Left scrambles to “rehabilitate” and manage their image to be palatable to their own liberal sensibilities. This is the same aversion to power that has impeded the usefulness of the Western Left. It is the same aversion that admires “resistance” only when it wields no agency in the shaping of the world-system, only when it poses no real threat to the imperial order. It is the same aversion as the inability to commit to the arduous work of building the material foundations of sovereignty.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*cuY1lYV3cEhVhlZirD_fZw.png" /></figure><p>We are living in an era of movementist protest marches, with the majority of political action neither challenging the hegemony nor confronting structures of power, and reduced to little more than begging politicians for concessions. Many self-proclaimed leftist and anti-imperialist organizations and individuals have miscalculated both the terrain and the actors with whom they are contending. As <a href="https://pflp-documents.org/documents/PFLP_StrategyforLiberationofPalestine1969.pdf"><em>Strategy for the Liberation of Palestine</em></a> makes clear, revolutionary seriousness begins with a dialectical analysis of the enemy and the landscape — without which strategy becomes mere posture.</p><p>Leftist organizing has become disconnected from materialism. The planning and <strong>building</strong> of decolonization programs, alternative institutions for the people, and independent supply chains has taken a backseat to performative actions. Today, for the majority of organizations, the measure of “successful” organizing is often a one-off rally, a large conference, a viral petition, or a high-turnout mobilization. <strong>These should be treated as tactical steps within a broader strategy — one aligned with the long-term development of independence and power. </strong>Instead, they are lauded as ends in themselves. There is a disparity between those who chant for the end of empire and those who are doing the work that decolonization requires. The Western Left does not grow its own food. It does not study the nodes of power that shape the world. It does not become militant enough to confront them. The Western Left would rather believe that the next viral post or nationwide conference will bring us one step closer to the revolutionary horizon. This is reflective of <a href="https://medium.com/@communityliberationprograms/a-better-world-must-be-struggled-for-0e373db99767">a typical liberalism</a>: the need for immediate results and an unwillingness to commit to the labor of sustained organizing.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/828/1*GV1Sq0-YnJqr1wDdzbITrQ.png" /><figcaption>Artwork by @thirdworldsolidarityfront on Instagram</figcaption></figure><p>The Western Left confuses its rhetorical “opposition to imperialism” for a material opposition to the imperialist world-system itself. It has internalized the liberal logic that the only <em>feasible </em>and <em>creditable </em>resistance is the kind that never wins wars, never shakes the world order, never builds towards the “better world” so often touted in left-liberal sloganeering. The Western Left has become comfortable in its own marginality, mistaking its incapacity for moral purity. For the Western Left to acknowledge the scale of militancy and discipline constructed by the resistance movements in West Asia would mean having to confront its failure to build any of its own.</p><p>This failure is not merely a matter of political miscalculation or strategic error. Members of the Western Left do not act with seriousness or urgency because, ultimately, they have less at stake. They are not living through the slow genocide of sanctions that starves, disables, and deteriorates a nation. The Western Left are not waking up to the sound of drones circling overhead. The Western Left are the recipients of the flow of value from the peripheries. Their comfort is built on the extraction of wealth from the places where real resistance is forged. The Western Left can afford to equivocate. It can afford to condemn violence “on all sides” and to debate the precise language with which to frame the Islamic Republic’s operations. It can afford to distance itself from Iran or any force that wields power too visibly and too effectively. For the Western Left, these calculations are thought experiments, and none carry the weight of life and death. For the people of Palestine, Lebanon, Yemen, and Iran, being latent means annihilation. When your existence is under threat, you either build political power of the gun or you are eliminated. Only by reckoning with its own position within the imperial core, abandoning navel-gazing, and committing to building power where power is not easily built would the Western Left finally be getting serious.</p><blockquote>“He who feeds you, controls you.” — Thomas Sankara</blockquote><p>National anti-imperialist projects prioritize development for a reason. <strong>Agriculture and agroecology</strong> means a nation will not go hungry at the whims of foreign markets, the petrodollar, conditional aid, and potential sanctions. As the u.s. blockade tightens and fuel shipments are cut off, it is the Cuban campesinos (cooperatives that have turned to local organic farming) that supply the majority of produce that feed the island. <strong>Manufacturing</strong> means capturing value (transforming raw materials into useful goods) that would otherwise be siphoned to the core. When a nation lacks a robust manufacturing base, it will be forced to export its raw materials at exploitative prices and import finished goods at high costs, an extractive system called unequal exchange. These nations are forced to rely on <a href="https://monthlyreview.org/articles/the-political-economy-of-migration/">labor export and remittances</a> as an economic prop, as seen across the peripheries of the world-system. Desperate people abandon their homelands to become migrant workers in the core, sending back a fraction of the value extracted from their labor abroad, while their home nation’s economy remains underdeveloped, unable to retain or reproduce skilled labor. Manufacturing reverses this flow, keeping workers at home and evolving local technical knowledge. <strong>Control over raw materials</strong>, such as lithium, oil, and minerals, prevents imperialist powers from extracting wealth and dictates the terms of exchange rather than submitting to them. Without this control, nations that are resource-rich become entrapped in an unequal system where their wealth is plundered, their natural environments are obliterated, and their people are left impoverished so that the core can reap the profits. <strong>The ability to innovate technology</strong> on one’s own terms means a nation is not locked into dependency on Western intellectual property regimes and proprietary supply chains. It enables the development of housing, green energy, healthcare, and defense systems that are not subject to foreign sabotage or whims.</p><p>Throughout the twentieth and twenty-first centuries, there is a long list of cases of Western imperialist forces destabilizing nations, leaving them weakened and destroyed to this day. In 1973, the u.s.-backed coup against Salvador Allende in Chile ushered in the Pinochet dictatorship, halting the nationalization of mineral reserves and opening the country to extraction by multinational corporations. In Libya, NATO’s assassination of Muammar Gaddafi threw the country into years of civil war and created the horrors of slave markets. And less than two years ago in Syria, the West in coordination with HTS and ISIS toppled the government, subjecting religious minorities to violent persecution and expanding zionism’s reach deeper into the heart of West Asia.</p><p>When nations did not build or could not maintain their own systems and institutions, neocolonial forces like USAID, the IMF, and the World Bank filled the vacuum, implementing and perpetuating dependence. The Gates Foundation — spearheaded by a notorious member of the Epstein class — is a clear example of how Western philanthropy is truly a vehicle for surveillance, violence, and exploitation of the Global South. It operates as a front for the trafficking of African children and women, who are often subjected to sexual violence, and the forced sterilization of African people under the guise of public health. Without self-determined socioeconomic development, nations have no buffer against becoming satellite states and neocolonies leashed to the imperial core.</p><p>Having endured Japanese colonization, followed by u.s. imperialist warfare that carpet-bombed the country into rubble, the Democratic People’s Republic of Korea (DPRK) has since been subjected to a harsh sanctions regime. Yet through self-reliance (<em>juche</em>) principles, it has prioritized developing an indigenous nuclear deterrent capability that continues to ward off even the greatest military on Earth. This past year alone, that commitment to sovereignty has manifested in the construction of <a href="https://peoplesdispatch.org/2026/02/24/defying-sanctions-advancing-socialism-the-dprks-9th-party-congress-begins/#:~:text=As%20preparations%20for%20the%20Congress,in%20socialist%20construction%20particularly%20noteworthy.">113,000 new rural housing units and 50,000 new apartments in Pyongyang</a>, proof that a nation can uplift its people and defend itself despite the most severe imperialist campaigns. In contrast, the Republic of Korea (ROK) is ravaged by u.s. military occupation and reduced to a staging ground for Washington’s war games. Agriculture, manufacturing, control over raw materials, and the ability to innovate technology are the foundations upon which sovereignty is built. These create the means to expel imperialist forces, to defend one’s own land, and to uplift the people. The Islamic Republic of Iran’s indigenous arsenal and its capacity to wage a war of attrition are the most recent testament to this principle. From its domestically developed ballistic missile programs to its advancements in drone technology, Iran has proven that a nation determined to build on its own terms cannot be crushed by imperialist sanctions or surprise bombing attacks. The same strategy that fed Cuba and industrialized the DPRK now protects Tehran and carries out the mission of the entire Axis of Resistance.</p><p>The Black Panther Party understood the necessity of building self-reliance and sovereignty, even if their canvas was an internal colony. They have been aestheticized to oblivion, their mainstream legacy divorced from the politics that made them dangerous — especially their pursuit of an independent Republic of New Afrika. The foremost reason the Party was considered one of the largest internal threats by the u.s. government was not because they threw rallies and protests, but because they were organizing programs that materially empowered the masses. The Party’s survival programs were, in essence, an attempt to establish the very pillars that national anti-imperialist projects prioritize.</p><p>Where the state denied food security and created local food deserts, the Panthers challenged the state by building alternative food systems through free breakfast programs that fed tens of thousands of children. Where the state’s medical institutions abandoned and abused Black communities, the Panthers established free health clinics, sickle cell anemia testing, and even ambulance services. Where the state economy extracted wealth from Black neighborhoods, the Panthers organized community control over resources through programs like free clothing distribution, the Oakland Community School (which provided education outside the u.s. settler-colonial curriculum), and the Seniors Against a Fearful Environment (SAFE) program which protected elders from state-sanctioned neglect. And while they may have not reached the scale of indigenous technological innovation seen in Iran, their investment in developing community-controlled institutions represented the same understanding: <strong>That a colonized people could not liberate themselves through symbolic agitation and political education alone; they needed to build the independent infrastructure and systems that would form the foundation of their sovereign existence.</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*yjXYxQkp_6NusA4iLl8bLg.png" /></figure><blockquote>“Independence is not a word which can be used as an exorcism, but an indispensable condition for the existence of men and women who are truly liberated, in other words who are truly masters of all the material means which make possible the radical transformation of society.” — Frantz Fanon</blockquote><p>To diminish Iran as a powerless state with no agency in this war is not merely naive; it is a distortion of material reality, an attempt to preserve the imperialist world-system that such skewed power dynamics are a result of. Unlike left-liberals, Iran operates with a clear understanding of its material position, refusing to minimize its strength and being unambiguous about the desire to break the world-system as it currently is. It does not mince words, does not toe the line, has no qualms about vocalizing a refusal to subjugation, a determination to put down zionism and the american empire. And also unlike many Western leftists, the Islamic Republic of Iran has chosen to — and become capable of — following their words with real actions and real results.</p><p>The zionist entity and the united states do not fear our statements or our rallies. They fear what Iran has built. What the Black Panther Party was beginning to build. They fear the day that the Western Left abandons its aversion to real political power and begins to build the material foundations that will make us useful to those already resisting imperialism. This should be the goal of any serious organization worth its salt that proclaims to be anti-imperialist. We can no longer afford to be weak and sympathetic to the politicians of the Epstein class. We must be able to develop into an apparatus that can not only stand against the u.s., but can become a threat and lay material might onto the enemy. For those of us who live in the u.s., we are privileged with the particular mission of carrying out this work from within the belly of the beast: building programs, undermining the imperialist war machine from within, and organizing our own communities toward independence and material power.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c38c6a6a6a2e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Neocolonialism at Center Stage]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@communityliberationprograms/neocolonialism-at-center-stage-b17720788634?source=rss-eda330dbf377------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b17720788634</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[socialism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Community Liberation Programs]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 12 Feb 2026 15:16:14 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-02-12T15:26:15.929Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Bad Bunny’s Donroe Propaganda Blitz</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*slyu2zoEIJIaFE9Czgojmw.png" /></figure><p>Reggaeton and salsa intertwined with the dancing of latinas, latinos, and latines. Amorphous vendedores selling coconut water, piraguas, tacos, and jewelry to the excitement of millions. A white wedding with your abuelitos, tios, tias, and primas, awkwardly officiated by the stiff imitation salsa dancing only a zionist could attempt. It is okay! Bad Bunny represents all those generations of sleepy latin children who are dreaming of the amerikkkan dream, only to realize it is an amerikkkan nightmare. But it is okay! Keep drinking and dancing. Your children will soon become amerikkkan.</p><p>Bad Bunny’s Super Bowl performance was a lightning rod for amerikan politics and cultural hegemony under the current regime. Many Latin Amerikans saw this as the final, excited breath of cultural freedom that opened the eyes of the English speaking, euro-amerikan world to the vibrant life of Latin Amerikan existence and survival in the diaspora. Others may have seen this as a defiant performance proving that amerikkka is not just “red-white-and-blue” or the 51st state of Klanada, but the Third World of Mexico, Central and South Amerika, and the Caribbean. Many more may have seen this as an example of the “Amerikan Dream,” a beacon of hope that a colonized people can be recognized for its vibrant culture. These interpretations all inspire a sense of hope within the collective consciousness of Latin Amerikans as millions are brutalized by the specter of murder, disappearance, or deportation at the hands ICE and Customs and Border Patrol (CBP), or even the looming threat of the u.s. military bombing and strangling their home countries. As a Nicaraguan and Mexican, I understand these desperate grasps at cultural pride that excite even the most pessimistic of Latines. Representation and cultural pride can only take a people so far, however. It fails to provide a coherent task to stop the brutalization and forced migration our people face, and even reinforce the domination of oppressed nations by functioning as a tool for co-option and neocolonial capture. Liberalism encourages being seen, raising awareness, and validating one’s cultural sensibilities as individual consumers as long as struggling for land, bread, and self-determination are never considered. The sooner we abandon this amerikkkan nightmare, where resistance is siloed to dancing to our deaths, the sooner we can build a Third World worthy of self-determination.</p><p>The decision for Bad Bunny, who recently won Album of the Year for DeBÍ TiRAR MáS FOToS at the 2026 Grammys, to perform at the Super Bowl, was a conscious choice at a time of heightened contradictions around ICE deportations, extrajudicial executions in Minnesota, and the emergent “Donroe” Doctrine. Anxieties around the uncertainty of Latin Amerikan existence in the so-called u.s. are at an all-time high, and Bad Bunny’s performance was a pressure relief valve to offload some of that tension. Instead of rightfully channeling energy towards resisting ICE, CBP, or your local pig department, it is encouraged that you channel that energy into state sanctioned cultural expressions of dance, music, and art. Bad Bunny’s performance, which was demonized by the euro-amerikan right, was just one of many methods to make one forget about ICE for a second. The feigning of outrage from the kirkless Turning Point USA (TPUSA) and the amerikan right was just another smoke screen to turn righteous anger into an individual choice of watching a halftime show.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/862/0*34B2q1KdjuKeWhC0.jpg" /><figcaption>Bad Bunny handing his Grammy to Lincoln Fox</figcaption></figure><p>On an individual level, Bad Bunny’s performance was a classic bootstraps depiction of him climbing the social ladder from grocery store clerk to Grammy winner. Maybe if Lincolnito bootstraps, he too can win a Grammy! This classic amerikan dream story valorizes the pursuit of amerikan recognition and climbing the ladder of fame while opportunistically selling out your people and nation. Any allusion towards the Puerto Rican Independence Movement was nothing more than a backdrop. The blood of martyrs from the FALN and Los Macheteros are all but forgotten and book shelved. The representation of “Latin Joy,” from drinking and salsa dancing to your tios playing dominos over a few cold Modelos™ to a stereotypical Latin wedding with children laughing, family drinking, and babies sleeping until the early morning hours, all function as a panacea for collective isolation, cultural crystallization, degradation of collective culture, and the pressures of assimilation amongst Latin Amerikans across the so-called u.s. Rather than organizing around resisting ICE or the destruction of their home country, the state wants us to fit into our stereotypes as a hypersexualized, alcoholic, and uneducated mass of cheap labor to exploit. It’s much easier to see us as products for exploitation than a people and nation willing to resist our collective destruction at the hand of amerika. Whether one denies it or not, representation politics is a method of pacifying a colonized nation’s ability to resist by commodifying one’s culture.</p><p>It would be remiss to not mention that this performance included arch-zionist Lady Gaga, who gladly toured in the zionist entity while it bombed Gaza in 2014 and who<a href="https://www.creativecommunityforpeace.com/anti-boycott-petition/"> signed onto an anti-BDS petition</a>, or even Bad Bunny’s suit made by ZARA, <a href="https://bdsmovement.net/news/boycott-zara-dressing-apartheid-and-genocide">which is the target of BDS for it complicity with the zionist entity’s genocide of Palestinians.</a> Furthermore, the Super Bowl functions as a recruitment tool for the u.s. military by showcasing its military might with a flyover featuring B-1B bomber, F-15 fighter jet, F/A-18 fighter jet, and F-35 fighter jet which all have been used to destroy the livelihoods of Iranians, Yemenis, and Venezuelans. The same military industrial complex that kidnapped the president of Venezuela and now holds him and his wife hostage in the belly of the beast. While “Latin Joy” is depicted for millions to dance and feel national pride, the whole charade was built to justify, and even glorify, the genocide of Palestine and the Third World. Even worse, during all this, Cuba has announced it will need to ration energy resources essential for life due to the u.s.’ ratcheting of genocidal oil sanctions. Bad Bunny’s halftime performance is just a symptom of representation politics’ method of addressing legitimate grievances through the commodification of culture and the reification of the current system. It makes it even more sinister that Bad Bunny’s critically acclaimed album, DeBÍ TiRAR MáS FOToS, was a commentary on the effects of the ongoing colonization, displacement, and genocide of the occupied nation of Borikén (Puerto Rico) which is today being utilized as a military outpost for the genocidal blockade on Cuba and Venezuela. DeBÍ TiRAR MáS FOToS has been co-opted and neocolonized for the service of amerikan cultural hegemony to commodify and reinforce the continued exploitation of Latin Amerika.</p><p>Beyond the material consequences of this performance, let us consider the ideological implications. Today, as an attempt to capitalize on “Latin Joy,” some are calling it an act of resistance and a decolonial, anti-imperialist ontology. But what is “resistance” and cultural representation to a colonized people? How can one resist the pressures of the imperialist western world order and its gaze? A people clearly cannot eat words, and certainly no nation was ever decolonized by the stroke of a pen or with the swaying of hips to salsa. Resistance, revolution, and struggle mean nothing without boots on the ground, liberated land, and self-determination of one’s life and resources. The glorification of representation on the Super Bowl™ stage, at the center of the western gaze, is not combatting imperialist ontologies, but validating it. Anti-imperialism is not sponsored by Coca-Cola or Ring: Home Security, and it is certainly not a 15-minute propaganda commercial for amerikan exceptionalism.</p><p>Prior to the halftime show, eight people have been executed in the streets or in concentration camps by ICE. From Renee Nicole Good, Alex Pritti, Keith Porter Jr., Luis Gustavo Núñez Cáceres, and many more, ICE has shot, maimed, and destroyed the lives of countless families. Minnesota became a powder keg of a possible insurrection that would have made the 2025 LA riots against ICE look like a state sanctioned protest. The u.s., as an entity, was being reckoned with and delegitimized each day the pressure built in Minnesota. Yet, as we have seen with previous Super Bowls, resistance becomes a facade to placate the masses into feeling good about themselves, that change has truly come. In 2016, at the heightening of contradictions with the Black Lives Matter movement, Beyoncé utilized the image of the Black Panther Party while doing nothing to stop the ongoing murder of New Afrikans at the hands of the pig police. What makes Bad Bunny’s performance a continuation of this praxis of co-option and neocolonial capture is his insistence on including tepid cultural nationalism with amerikan characteristics.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/988/1*jRHYOM19WK1FtsaeWrRBJA.png" /></figure><p>Bad Bunny’s attempt to project the concept of “Nuestra Amerika,” an anti-imperialist essay originally written by Jose Martí that emphasizes nationalism and self-determination of all of Latin Amerika, falls flat when he proudly states, “God Bless America” and spikes a football written with, “Together We Are America” as the u.s. flag leads the Third World nations in the final act. The blunt symbolism of this is just a visualization of the “Donroe” Doctrine laid bare — the u.s. dictates what Latin Amerika does — from pawning its resources and labor to building concentration camps and CECOTs all over the region. Nuestra Amerika is now an acceptable amerika of cheap labor, cheap alcohol, exploitable women, and raw resources. Nuestra Amerika is repackaged latinidad with even less of an emphasis on collective consciousness. We are now all the “same,” but we are not those illegals or authoritarians who live in those backwaters. We are Americans™!</p><p>This performance is being seen as an act of resistance, yet it continues to reinforce amerikan ideology that has wrought death and destruction to Puerto Rico for over 100 years. This performance certainly could have brought clarity to the material conditions and struggle necessary for the liberation of Puerto Rico, but ultimately pacified our anger and reinforced our inclusion into the amerikan empire. What is the point of DeBÍ TiRAR MáS FOToS, or any form of “resistance art,” if you fail to even raise the question of freeing your own people from amerikan subjugation?</p><p>Let us move beyond the yearly bread-and-circus of award ceremonies, halftime shows, and tepid cultural resistance. Revolutionary culture cannot be constructed by the tools of national oppression It cannot be denied that this performance has opened a new terrain for revolutionary cultural struggle, but for many, the struggle has already concluded. Any effort to challenge this new terrain is met with dismissive, liberal identity politics (i.e., “Only Latin Americans can speak on this.”) or the classic liberal appeal to emotion (i.e., “Let people enjoy things!”). As Amilcar Cabral states, “National liberation is necessarily an act of culture.” Revolutionary culture cannot not be divorced from revolutionary struggle, and it certainly cannot be imposed by the oppressive settler state we seek to dismantle. This new terrain of cultural struggle clearly indicates that we need to understand what our goals are in the imperial core and how we seek to achieve them. As the u.s. seeks to dismantle any form of self-determination in Latin Amerika, we are far beyond the democrat entryism of the liberal zionist DSA, the electoralism of the next “socialist” candidate, the next police sanctioned march, or the newly announced social media “general strike.” If our “revolutionary” culture can only repackage stereotypes and economistic demands for more of a slice of the imperial pie, then this movement needs to self-critique and do away with the inherent opportunism that plagues our movement. As Fanon states at the end of Wretched of the Earth, “for Europe, for ourselves and for humanity, comrades, we must turn over a new leaf, we must work out new concepts, and try to set afoot a new man.”</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b17720788634" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Revolution Will Not Be Streamed on Spotify]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@communityliberationprograms/the-revolution-will-not-be-streamed-on-spotify-2722581a4e9b?source=rss-eda330dbf377------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2722581a4e9b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[socialism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[revolution]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Community Liberation Programs]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 19 Jan 2026 19:41:17 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-01-19T19:41:17.041Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4><strong>The Role of Music in Revolution and Counterrevolution</strong></h4><p>By Comrade K</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*aERpcGRM5xffVXiOoWrtiA.png" /></figure><p>Music is everywhere; at the grocery store, in the car, at sports games, in TV shows, at the gym, on social media — we hear it in practically every facet of our lives. It is a force that can connect people across language barriers, across national borders, across different generations, and across many other boundaries that may otherwise divide us. This universality makes music a powerful tool in the service of counterrevolution–or equally powerful for revolution. Thus, we must properly understand its history and function so that we as revolutionaries can utilize it effectively for our movement. To this end, we shall investigate a few key questions: How is music used for counterrevolution? How is music used for revolution? And what does it mean to be a revolutionary artist?</p><p>As an exemplar of counterrevolution, the CIA historically has employed music to suppress revolutionary movements both abroad and within the u.s., as well as to strengthen the cultural front of the u.s. empire’s imperialist wars. During the Cold War era, music was instrumental to fomenting regime change within both socialist countries and nonaligned Third World countries. David Hasselhoff has suggested that <a href="https://www.syfy.com/syfy-wire/david-hasselhoff-up-against-the-wall-audible">he worked with the CIA in order to bring down the Berlin Wall</a>, with songs like “Looking For Freedom” becoming “the unofficial anthem of the wall’s destruction.” Former State Department head Anthony Blinken has insinuated that <a href="https://www.mintpressnews.com/fight-the-power-chuck-d-public-enemy-cia-neutralized-rap/288184/">Bruce Springsteen contributed as well</a> by playing to his fans right before the destruction of the wall. The Scorpions’ famous song <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/tv-and-radio/2020/may/15/wind-of-change-did-the-cia-write-the-cold-wars-biggest-anthem">“The Winds of Change” was allegedly written and promoted by the CIA</a> in order to promote destabilization in the Soviet Union. Perhaps most insidiously, <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/music/2021/sep/12/louis-armstrong-and-the-spy-how-the-cia-used-him-as-a-trojan-horse-in-congo">Louis Armstrong’s tour in Africa was used as a vehicle for the CIA</a> to arrange for the assassination of Patrice Lumumba and force the Congo under the boot of neocolonialism.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*DCZ8H6EoOOQ3KzOK.jpg" /><figcaption>Source: <a href="https://www.wlrn.org/americas/2025-05-03/cuban-exiles-lead-protest-in-miami-against-this-weeks-jailing-of-cuban-dissidents">https://www.wlrn.org/americas/2025-05-03/cuban-exiles-lead-protest-in-miami-against-this-weeks-jailing-of-cuban-dissidents</a></figcaption></figure><p>This weaponization of music for regime change has since evolved to meet modern conditions. Since 2005, Hip-hop “envoys” have been sent abroad to<a href="https://www.aljazeera.com/opinions/2011/11/7/leveraging-hip-hop-in-us-foreign-policy"> counteract “anti-American” sentiment, as well as to promote “political reform” (i.e. regime change) in countries such as Libya</a>. The National Endowment for Democracy (a CIA front) has <a href="https://www.mintpressnews.com/documents-point-to-us-hand-in-cuba-protests/277987/">funded various anti-government artists in countries like Cuba</a> and <a href="https://jacobin.com/2020/06/us-intervention-venezuela-hugo-chavez-ned">Venezuela</a> in an effort to spark color revolutions. In 2024, <a href="https://www.mintpressnews.com/fight-the-power-chuck-d-public-enemy-cia-neutralized-rap/288184/">the U.S. State Department launched the “U.S. Department of State-YouTube Global Music Partnership,”</a> a new regime change operation modeled after the Cold War era program. A number of artists took part in this initiative, including even supposedly revolutionary figures like Chuck D, the former frontman for Public Enemy. And, in a borderline ridiculous tactic, <a href="https://news.sky.com/story/south-korea-removes-speakers-used-to-blast-k-pop-music-and-propaganda-across-north-korea-border-13406643">South Korea has blasted kpop 15 miles across its border with the DPRK</a> along with other “democratic” propaganda up until fairly recently.</p><p>This tactic hasn’t been limited simply to regime change; it has also been used to shape global perceptions of the u.s. When the Soviet Union rightfully criticized the rampant racism in amerika, the u.s. responded by sending<a href="https://www.aljazeera.com/opinions/2011/11/7/leveraging-hip-hop-in-us-foreign-policy"> integrated jazz bands on tours across the globe</a> in an attempt to prove that the country wasn’t racist, as well as “to get people in other countries to identify with ‘the American way of life.’” In doing so, the State Department specifically co-opted New Afrikan culture to convey “‘a sense of shared suffering, as well as the conviction that equality could be gained under the American political system.’” Beyond just cultivating an image of equality, the CIA also aimed to portray the u.s. as a center of free expression and creativity to contrast against a seemingly repressive and narrow Soviet Union. <a href="https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/modern-art-was-cia-weapon-1578808.html">To this end, the CIA indirectly funded avant garde expressionist art through institutions like the Congress for Cultural Freedom</a>. <a href="https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/modern-art-was-cia-weapon-1578808.html">The International Organizations Division of the CIA also subsidized not just jazz, but opera and the Boston Symphony Orchestra</a> for the same purpose of building u.s. intellectual and cultural capital against the Soviet Union. Today, the u.s. reproduces these same tactics using hip-hop. To distract from growing amerikan Islamophobia, the State has called for “<a href="https://www.brookings.edu/articles/mightier-than-the-sword-arts-and-culture-in-the-u-s-muslim-world-relationship/">greater exploitation</a>” of the historical role of Muslims in hip-hop’s formation. Strategically, hip-hop ambassadors<a href="https://www.aljazeera.com/opinions/2011/11/7/leveraging-hip-hop-in-us-foreign-policy"> have also been sent to local media outlets throughout the Islamic world</a>, sharing their experiences as Muslims in amerika and encouraging integration into the u.s.</p><p>Music’s use as a counterrevolutionary force has not been limited to just foreign operations, however. It has also been used as a tool of domestic neocolonialism suppressing revolutionary nationalist movements here in the belly of the beast. Under capitalism, not just music, but any form of art or culture is at risk of becoming commodified and commercialized. The natural drive of capitalism to create profit in any way that it can means that anything can be put on the market, even forms of art that were once anti-capitalist. Rich historical and potentially revolutionary culture is lost and instead replaced with capitalist, imperialist, colonial indoctrination in all aspects of our lives. For example, <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JKj68yo5pCY">hip-hop started out as a subversive art form that was birthed in the streets of the Bronx at a party intended to raise funds for school supplies</a>. It was poor black and brown people neglected by capitalism who brought hip-hop into being, and unsurprisingly their music started out criticizing the government and drawing attention to issues like poverty and war. However, as time went on, the music industry co-opted this art form and warped it into what we now know as the rap industry. As the rap industry rakes in <a href="https://www.forbes.com/2004/02/18/cx_jw_0218hiphop.html">billions</a> of <a href="https://projects.apnews.com/features/2023/hip-hop-50th-history/getting-the-money.html">dollars</a> per year, it has shed all semblance of revolutionary form and content. Mainstream rap music today revolves around (reactionary) violence, sex, drugs, money, looks, and other capitalist, counterrevolutionary topics, steering youth away from revolutionary values of community, discipline, self-improvement, and love for the people. This music is played everywhere. Individualism, consumerism, misogyny, and other poisons permeate our psyche from every direction, a far cry from the original intentions and origins of hip-hop. This is not a unique story; many other genres stemming from oppressed communities and anti-establishment sentiment have faced this same co-optation and commodification (e.g. the commercialization of punk and folk music, the neoliberalization of queer club culture, etc.). But the story goes deeper.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*8vWci8SSvHF-Cv4l" /><figcaption>Source: <a href="https://hoodcommunist.org/2024/11/08/neo-colonial-capture-culture-and-neo-liberalism/">https://hoodcommunist.org/2024/11/08/neo-colonial-capture-culture-and-neo-liberalism/</a></figcaption></figure><p>The commercialization of music is a natural result of capitalism’s drive for profit. However, it has also become an intentional tactic of control to suppress the colonized masses’ revolutionary potential, thus necessitating the formation of <a href="https://hoodcommunist.org/2024/11/08/neo-colonial-capture-culture-and-neo-liberalism/">what Musa D. Springer calls a “cultural elite class.”</a> This cultural elite class, a group of neocolonial agents picked from colonized nations, does the colonizer’s work in co-opting, commercializing, and de-politicizing revolution. These artists will only ever criticize the u.s. to an extent that does not seriously challenge the system. They may voice vague discontent with this so-called country and its state of affairs, but will not clearly identify the root problems, much less a course of corrective action. In this way, they are able to cosplay as revolutionaries while benefitting from and even reinforcing the racist institutions they claim to speak out against. Perhaps a perfect embodiment of this grift, Kendrick Lamar has cultivated an image as a black “revolutionary”: <a href="https://www.vulture.com/article/kendrick-lamar-super-bowl-politics-black-lives-matter.html">his music has levied critiques at the u.s. and brought light to the oppression New Afrikans face; he defended Colin Kaepernick for kneeling during the national anthem; he has made vague references to pan-Africanism in some of his performances; and his song “Alright” became an anthem for the Black Lives Matter movement, a song which he later performed at the Grammys</a>. Yet even in these examples, the contradiction between his image and his actions are apparent: he has benefited from and legitimized both the Grammys and the NFL/Superbowl (quintessential institutions of capitalist commercialization and co-optation), made reactionary comments about Trayvon Martin and Michael Brown, and he has not committed any concrete support to the pan-African movement nor the Republic of New Afrika. But perhaps the most glaring and illustrative example of Lamar’s unprincipled politics is his accusation of Drake as a “colonizer,” despite Kendrick himself doing nothing about the actual colonization and genocide being carried out in Gaza. Meanwhile, <a href="https://apnews.com/article/super-bowl-halftime-protest-palestine-0d670147fe14286bfb665f739772f0a7">one of his halftime performers took a risk to speak out about it despite having far more to lose</a>.</p><p>Another perhaps even more polarizing example is Beyoncé. In 2016, <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/music/2016/feb/08/beyonce-black-panthers-homage-black-lives-matter-super-bowl-50">Beyoncé appropriated the aesthetic of the Black Panther Party during her Superbowl halftime performance</a>; however, like Kendrick, her actions have betrayed her true counterrevolutionary interests. In a recent controversy, Beyoncé wore a shirt <a href="https://apnews.com/article/beyonce-buffalo-soldiers-controversy-9308cd020d6cabc8ec8ceac6057d8f0d">depicting the Buffalo Soldiers</a>, a regiment that took part in the westward expansion of the u.s. settler-colony and subjugated indigenous people. This was no mere mistake. Her recent album “Act II: Cowboy Carter” is widely interpreted as a reclamation of amerikan identity for the black community. But amerikan history — the Buffalo Soldiers, manifest destiny — is a history of genocide and settler-colonialism. To reclaim this history for black people is to claim that black people can assimilate into the same settler colony that exploited and enslaved them. Neocolonial agents like Beyoncé thus encourage black people to embrace a settler identity and its privileges at the expense of colonized people both here and abroad. This is another clear instance of an artist cosplaying as a revolutionary for their own personal gain while doing nothing to advance the cause, and even working against it.</p><p>Neocolonial capture is not limited to simply co-opting a revolutionary aesthetic, however. These artists participate in corporate partnerships, consumerism, and private capital that sell a narrative of success to colonized peoples: that anybody can achieve the “amerikan dream” with enough hard work and individualism. This celebrity culture masks the capitalist reality that most colonized subjects will never access this kind of wealth and fame. Quite the contrary, they are in fact <a href="https://www.tribunal2021.com/news">undergoing a slow genocide</a> that cannot be stopped by just climbing up the ladder. Mirroring the Cold War era jazz propaganda, these modern artists’ “success stories” promote a false amerikan dream and help the u.s. maintain its global influence. There is an important material aspect to this propaganda as well; these “successful” artists are only able to accumulate that much wealth and fame by stepping on the backs of their own people, as well as fellow colonized peoples across the globe. These artists collaborate with companies who exploit their workers and have been complicit in ethnic cleansing and genocide, or <a href="https://amp.cnn.com/cnn/2016/05/17/news/beyonce-ivy-park-sweatshop-accusation">have even created their own enterprises that have exploited workers in the Global South</a>. This is far from the idea that anybody can become successful if they simply pull themselves up by their bootstraps like a good amerikan. Beyond being quite disingenuous, this unacknowledged exploitation snuffs out any chance of the colonized being able to improve their material circumstances, thus destroying the only path to exercise true control over their lives and destinies.</p><p>How, then, can music be used for revolution? There are a few ways. Firstly, music must expose, rather than mask, the contradictions in the system and “make war” (in the words of Amiri Baraka). It must show how our suffering and exploitation are intrinsic to capitalism and imperialism. Furthermore, rather than normalize integration, revolutionary music must reject the amerikan identity and embrace a struggle for national liberation. One example of an artist doing this right now is <a href="https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCP3-vNPxfItMGJEu-te99vQ">The Neighborhood Kids</a>. In their song “START A FIRE,” for instance, they expose the suffering and repression the masses face and reject the current system we live under. They tell us they are “eatin’ the rich ’cause we dyin’ of hunger pains” and that the government “[feeds] us lies and [redefines] where freedom lies.” In order to resolve these contradictions, they propose that “we don’t side with any parties, no / Republican, democrat, this be the death of that” and that we instead “burn the system down and start a fire.” In order to solve the issues we face, they implore us to tear down the u.s. and the capitalist two party system rather than integrate into it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*3fibSqMOoDYD1Y8y.jpg" /><figcaption>Source: Battle of Algiers (1966)</figcaption></figure><p>Revolutionary music must also envision a new future. The ruling class thrives when we are paralyzed by doomerism and inaction. Thus, we must move beyond just lamenting suffering and exploitation; it is also necessary to show the people that they are the heroes of this story and can forge a better world. In <em>The Wretched of the Earth</em>, Fanon observes that before the sparks of revolution, the colonized will primarily create art of comedy or despair about their conditions. This art only serves the colonizer; it is not a threat to them, and in a sense it still centers them. However, as a revolution emerges, so too changes the art. The colonized develop in consciousness and begin to create art truly for themselves. They create an art of hope and optimism that shows their people what a decolonial future could look like and how they can struggle for it. When the people are no longer paralyzed and can see a path forward, they will become a true threat to the ruling class.</p><p>The third, and perhaps most crucial way in which music must be used, is to make revolutionary culture a way of life. In the words of Toni Cade Bambara, artists must “make revolution irresistible.” In fact, we can learn from the oppressor’s own tactics. Various forms of capitalist propaganda permeate our daily lives, but perhaps none more so than advertisements. Ads are ever present on buses, in stores, on streaming services, at the movies, on the radio, after every YouTube video (if you don’t pay for premium), and on basically half of your social media feed. Virtually unavoidable, these ads manipulate us into constantly buying products for a fleeting pacification and distraction from our suffering. Imagine if revolutionary art was just as ingrained into everyday life: local bands or artist-owned streaming services playing revolutionary music at the neighborhood café, the local convenience store, block parties, community sports games. Imagine if the people received political education every day and expanded their minds every minute. Imagine if this became so pervasive and so natural in people’s lives that revolution became part of the fabric of society. Revolution would become appealing in the same way that these capitalist products do. Revolution would be irresistible.</p><p>This brings us to our final question: What does it mean to be a truly revolutionary artist? Firstly, creating revolutionary music requires constant engagement with the masses out on the streets. This is the only way one’s art can reflect the people’s aspirations and struggles. In doing so, the revolutionary artist is in essence practicing scientific socialism: they are conducting social investigation and applying a dialectical/historical materialist analysis, firstly to identify their audience. Who are the people? Who are the revolutionary forces? Who are the advanced, middle, and backwards segments of the community? Then, the artist investigates deeper to understand the conditions<em> </em>of their audience. What are the contradictions within the community? What is the principal contradiction? Finally, the artist considers how their work will contribute to the people’s struggle and eventual liberation. What must be done to resolve the principal contradiction? How can art contribute to that? How does this fit in with the broader struggle against the capitalist-imperialist world order? At this stage, the revolutionary artist realizes that to reach the hearts of the people, their art must be tied to something material. That is to say, people aren’t moved merely by words, but by bread and shelter. It is not enough for music to speak of contradictions; the revolutionary artist must contribute to creating alternative structures that actively expose the contradictions in our current societal institutions. It is not enough for one’s music to speak of a better future; the revolutionary artist must help provide material aid that improves people’s everyday lives and builds revolutionary infrastructure that will form the basis of a new society. Art means nothing without a material base and a direct connection to the people.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*Tpk2cZkcJGcRDCr6" /></figure><p>A perfect example of this is the rapper Noname. Noname started out mainly exposing the contradictions in the community through songs like “Church / Liquor Store,” which calls out the gentrification and consumerism overtaking Chicago. However, with time, her revolutionary activities expanded. In 2019, Noname created the <a href="https://nonamebooks.com/">Noname Book Club and the Radical Hood Library</a>, which uplifts books by black authors, provides political education, serves as a community-building space with events like teach-ins, movie screenings and book drives, and sends books and letters to prisoners. Through this space and these programs, she has been able to forge a stronger connection with the community and provide them with something material, thus taking her work to the next level.</p><p>To take things further, in order to create not just art, but a revolutionary <em>culture</em> that can persist and resist, it is necessary to struggle for the construction of a new nation in which the colonized masses can have control over their destiny. During this national liberation struggle, artists must stand shoulder to shoulder with the rest of the masses. It is through this process of shared struggle that the revolutionary artist’s work will become part of the culture of the new nation. Thomas Sankara, for example, is more widely known for leading Burkina Faso to national liberation–but beyond being a revolutionary leader and soldier, he also played guitar. As a musician, he helped to write liberated Burkina Faso’s new national anthem, which still lives to this day. In the context of national liberation struggles within the u.s., revolutionary artists must reject the settler amerikan identity and embrace a new, revolutionary nationalist culture which rejects amerikan values. Most importantly, they must take an active part in the struggle to create a new nation; it is only by doing this that their art will become woven into the fabric of national culture in the same way Sankara’s anthem did.</p><p>Another important consideration for the revolutionary artist is that all art is political. The phrase “All art is political” has become trite and often misunderstood today, yet it remains true. Nothing exists in a vacuum. Every piece of art, every belief that we hold, every single part of the superstructure is influenced by the material base. It follows that regardless of our intentions, everything that we create will bear the mark of a certain class or nation. The kind of art that becomes popular, the art we think to create, and even the question of who has (and who does not have) the resources to create art–the capitalist economic system we live in shapes it all. Thus, it becomes necessary for an artist to consciously take a stand. Are you working to maintain the status quo, or to change it? If you are not very explicit and intentional about this, your work can be utilized by the state in order to do its dirty work, even if you are trying to be “apolitical” or even vaguely leftist. Many of the avant garde artists that the CIA funded during the Cold War were actually leftists, and most of them likely did not intend for their expressionist art to be used in the service of anti-communist artistic warfare. However, because they were not critical enough about where their funding came from, where their art was being shown (and why), or what constitutes artistic success in general — in other words, because they did not properly consider the politics of art — their work was weaponized in ways they hadn’t anticipated or consented to. If their work explicitly called out the contradictions in the u.s. and explicitly called for socialism or national liberation, and if they were critical of any support coming outside of a community they had direct connections with, the state would have had difficulty co-opting their work.</p><p>The final consideration is that being a revolutionary artist is no easy task. The path is difficult and will require some necessary sacrifices. As a revolutionary musician, you will likely never achieve mainstream success. If your art is a threat to the status quo, the establishment will not promote you and may actively work against you. It will be much harder to be invited to shows, the algorithm in social media will likely work against you, and you will not be promoted on streaming services. On the off chance that you do connect enough with the masses that they manage to shoot you into the spotlight regardless, you will either be acknowledged by the system and become incorporated into it (as Chuck D was), or you will reject the system, and that will put a target on your back (as happened to Tupac). Working against the establishment will also force you to explore more unconventional methods to promote your music. While traditional streaming services, concerts, and advertising provide wide reach, you may discover that utilizing means outside that system can still do a fair job of disseminating your work, as well as bring you far closer to your community. This could look like utilizing music platforms that are cooperatively owned by artists rather than owned by corporations, using your music on your social media posts or on posts from revolutionary organizations, performing at fundraisers put on by revolutionary organizations (and perhaps even raising money for them and you!), or performing at community events that can help with social investigation, building political consciousness, or simply establishing a presence in the community. There are many options out there. Being a revolutionary artist does not mean being relegated to the depths of obscurity and having no one hear your music.</p><p>Despite all of the obstacles that the revolutionary musician may face, one thing is certain. Music is a force to be reckoned with. It is a medium that has the potential to effect vast amounts of change. The CIA itself was able to recognize the power that music holds, and it even admitted that sometimes taking a “soft line” against its enemies through music and other cultural activities was far more effective than taking a “hard line” against them. It certainly would not have sought to have this much control over music during the Cold War if it wasn’t a powerful force. If we can in turn take control over music ourselves, it could be an unimaginably powerful tool to have in our arsenal. Perhaps Malcolm X sums it up best when he says, “Music, brother, is ours. It is us and like us, it is always here, surrounding us. Like the infinite particles that make up life, it cannot be seen but can only be felt. Like life! No, it is not created, but like the never-dying soul, eternally permeates the atmosphere with its presence, ever-waiting for its master. The lordly musician. The wielder of souls. To come and give it a temple, mould it into a song. Music without the musician is like life without Allah, both being in need of the house, a home, the temple, the complete song and its creator.”</p><p>Music is life. Let us use it wisely.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2722581a4e9b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The False God of GDP]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@communityliberationprograms/the-false-god-of-gdp-5323969aa181?source=rss-eda330dbf377------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5323969aa181</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[economics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[socialism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Community Liberation Programs]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 24 Nov 2025 18:31:02 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-11-24T18:31:02.938Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>by Comrade D</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*kb0T2N7de_9Fsv_HAtc8Vg.png" /></figure><p>In his famous parable of the broken window, 19th-century French economist Frédéric Bastiat illustrated a fundamental error in how society often misjudges economic activity. In the story, a mischievous boy breaks a shopkeeper’s window, prompting the community to rationalize the incident: at least the glazier gets work, they say, and thus the economy benefits. Bastiat warns against this faulty reasoning, noting that while the glazier profits, the shopkeeper loses the opportunity to spend that money elsewhere. No net gain occurs. This “broken window fallacy” serves as a compelling critique of how modern economies, particularly imperial economies, can mistake cost for progress.</p><p>Gross Domestic Product (GDP) is often upheld as a catch-all metric for economic performance, aggregating the market value of all final goods and services produced within a nation over a specific period. However, as Bastiat’s broken window suggests, this metric harbors intrinsic flaws. It tallies expenditure without discerning intent or consequence, meaning that money spent fixing vandalized property or treating preventable illness boosts GDP just as surely as investment in education or infrastructure. Worse, it blurs the line between leisure consumption (drawn from household profits) and consumption that supports production, leading to systemic misinterpretations of what economic growth actually means.</p><p>Consider the everyday spending habits of workers. In the United States, expenditures on essential services such as housing, transportation, healthcare, and insurance are counted as final consumption in GDP. These services are not treated as intermediate inputs, even though they are often preconditions for a worker’s ability to produce. A car repair to get to work, childcare to enable full-time employment, or health insurance required by law are all seen as final consumption. The worker is the end consumer, GDP says, not the firm or institution indirectly enabled by that worker’s continued productivity.</p><p>This accounting choice stems from the production boundary set by the System of National Accounts (SNA), the international framework for GDP calculation. Only goods and services used up in the process of making another good or service are counted as intermediate inputs. Because a worker’s body, mind, and wellbeing are not commodities in this framework, the costs that maintain them fall outside the scope of production. This presents a profound philosophical and practical inconsistency: while the laborer is essential to output, the expenditures that enable their labor are categorized as consumption, not investment.</p><p>Contrast this with material inputs in a factory — bolts, wires, or circuit boards — which are treated as intermediate goods and therefore as investment. They are counted only once, in the value of the final product, avoiding double-counting. No such logic applies to a worker’s health insurance or daily commute, even though these are just as critical to the production process. Thus, GDP overstates final consumption and understates the enabling infrastructure of labor.</p><p>Furthermore, GDP includes spending that arises from negative events, such as natural disasters, car accidents, or vandalism. When a storm destroys homes and necessitates massive reconstruction, or when crime leads to increased security spending, GDP rises. But this “growth” does not represent new value created; it represents replacement, remediation, or avoidance. It records the transaction, not the wellbeing. Bastiat’s shopkeeper didn’t gain from his broken window — he simply diverted funds from potentially more valuable uses.</p><p>This leads to a deeply distorted picture of progress. An economy that must perpetually fix, heal, and secure itself may show rising GDP, even as quality of life stagnates or declines. In such a system, economic growth can co-exist with increasing precarity, inequality, and ecological degradation, none of which are directly subtracted from GDP. The more we spend to defend, repair, and survive, the richer we appear.</p><p>How has the u.s. been able to sustain this illusion of growth in the absence of consistent improvements in productive output? A key reason lies in the privileged role of the u.s. dollar as the world’s primary reserve currency. This status allows the united states to finance large fiscal deficits through the issuance of dollars that are eagerly absorbed by foreign markets. In effect, the u.s. exports inflation, shifting the burden of its excess demand to other countries.</p><p>Because global demand for dollars remains strong, the u.s. can maintain high levels of domestic consumption and government expenditure — activities that count toward GDP — without having to produce a commensurate amount of tangible goods or services. This distortion in the value of the dollar enables the u.s. economy to tap into the productive labor and resources of other nations while inflating its own output statistics. What looks like growth in GDP actually reflects, in large part, the extraction of value from abroad, rather than genuine expansion of domestic production.</p><p>Here we arrive at a critical impasse: GDP captures market transactions, but not whether those transactions reflect genuine increases in production quantity, production quality, or improvements in people’s lives. It tallies monetary flows without distinguishing between purchases that enhance output capacity and those that merely sustain existing conditions. For example, the cost of college tuition in the united states has doubled in the past 30 years. Yet, it is not clear that a college education today is twice as effective or even 1.5 times more enriching or productive than it was three decades ago. GDP registers the higher spending as growth, even if the value delivered remains stagnant.</p><p>To understand how we arrived at this measurement logic, a comparison with the Material Product System (MPS) used by Leninist economies is instructive. MPS, which was the dominant national accounting system in the Soviet Union and other planned economies, excluded most services from its calculation, focusing instead on tangible goods produced. This had its own flaws, notably the undervaluation of services and consumer welfare. But it at least tried to limit output measures to productive, material contributions.</p><p>By contrast, the SNA model adopted globally today includes services, but fails to distinguish between services that directly enhance productive capacity and those that merely sustain minimum living standards. The SNA also treats all final consumption the same, regardless of whether it maintains a worker’s ability to contribute to output or supports non-productive consumption. This reifies the worker as an atomistic individual, treating them as a standalone consumer rather than as a core component of a collective process of production. In doing so, it obscures the true costs of maintaining and enabling labor, and thus overstates final consumption while understating necessary productive infrastructure.</p><p>Despite its shortcomings, the MPS offered a more grounded approach to tracking real gains in production and productivity. By focusing narrowly on tangible goods and material output, MPS provided a clearer view of how much was actually being produced, even if it failed to capture the full range of economic and social activity. While it undervalued services and consumer experience, it avoided conflating financial flows, rent extraction, and speculative transactions with genuine productive expansion.</p><p>Revitalizing elements of the MPS could help modern economies more accurately measure growth in real output rather than in monetary circulation. We need a renewed accounting logic that centers production — particularly improvements in output volume and quality — as the core of economic analysis. This would require revising how we treat labor, not as an atomistic individual or alienated consumer, but as an integral, maintained component of the production process. Until we shift our frameworks in this direction, our perception of the global economy will continue to be obscured by the false god of GDP.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5323969aa181" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Nullification Crisis of the 1960s]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@communityliberationprograms/the-nullification-crisis-of-the-1960s-f327e620c445?source=rss-eda330dbf377------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f327e620c445</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[trump]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[1960s]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[socialism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Community Liberation Programs]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 14 Oct 2025 23:55:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-10-14T23:55:26.067Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>By Comrade D</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*qZE4XnVfzHeUeGpJ6dYOHA.png" /></figure><p>The 1960s were among the most turbulent decades in amerikan history. Amid assassinations, protests, the civil rights movement, and the Vietnam War, it’s often forgotten that the country also faced a profound institutional crisis: one in which the authority of the federal government was directly challenged by state and local actors, particularly in the South. The resilience of the federal government during this period, and the eventual consolidation rather than fragmentation of federal authority, should be studied closely. Economic conditions — both the structural strength of the postwar federal economy and the economic weakness of segregationist resistance — played a decisive role. This essay examines state and federal contradictions in the context of military and economic power in the 1960s and argues that the United States survived principally because of centralized control over economic activity following the New Deal.</p><h4>I. The Civil Rights Movement created a contradiction between states and the federal government.</h4><p>Throughout the early 1960s, southern states repeatedly resisted federal mandates to desegregate schools and public facilities. From the Little Rock Nine in 1957 to the University of Mississippi crisis in 1962, and Governor George Wallace’s infamous stand in the schoolhouse door in 1963, the federal government was repeatedly forced to assert its supremacy, often by deploying federal troops or marshals. At the time, these incidents revealed a real risk: that state governments, backed by local populations and entrenched social hierarchies, could opt to defy federal law outright. The possibility of fragmentation, or even Balkanization, loomed in the background.</p><p>The Civil Rights Act of 1964 and the Voting Rights Act of 1965 intensified this conflict. These landmark federal laws were met with open defiance in several states. Southern politicians called for “massive resistance,” and white citizens’ councils spread fear about the federal government’s “tyranny.” Some counties even closed public schools entirely rather than desegregate.</p><p>Yet despite the symbolic fervor of these gestures, they failed to halt the federal advance. The resistance was loud, but strategically weak. Why?</p><h4>II. Economic centralization gave the federal government extreme leverage over states.</h4><p>In the aftermath of World War II, the united states experienced an unprecedented industrial boom for euro-amerikans. Defense spending, interstate infrastructure, research funding, and major civil programs like Medicare and Social Security tied the national economy more tightly to Washington than ever before. Southern states, long economically marginalized, were now recipients of billions in federal funds: highway projects, military bases, educational grants, agricultural subsidies, and public housing initiatives.</p><p>This created a powerful dynamic: although southern elites were politically hostile to Washington, their economic survival increasingly depended on it. When federal funding was threatened due to civil rights noncompliance, the financial cost of resistance became untenable. Additionally, the growing civil rights and anti-war movement further ignited contradictions with the Southern, euro-amerikkkan state governments ability to quell internal New Afrikan rebellion while combating Federal oversight.</p><p>For example, Title VI of the Civil Rights Act authorized the federal government to withhold funds from segregated institutions. Schools, hospitals, and transportation networks across the South faced losing essential funding if they refused integration. Federal aid to education — just beginning to rise in the early 1960s — was a critical lifeline for many underfunded southern school districts. This produced a contradiction in many Southern working class communities between their economic incentives and their cultural upbringing in upholding segregation and repressing New Afrikan and Indigenous communities.</p><h4>III. Federal policy was strongly aligned with emerging economic forces.</h4><p>At the same time, the economic logic of segregation was eroding. Jim Crow had long served as a method of labor control, keeping New Afrikan (Black) wages suppressed and New Afrikan (Black) workers politically disempowered and lacking political autonomy and secured infrastructure. But by the 1960s, this system was becoming increasingly dysfunctional as the contradictions of New Afrikan and Black petit bourgeoisie vied for access to capital and integration into euro-amerikkkan settler-capitalism.</p><p>Mechanization in agriculture and the decline of the cotton economy had displaced hundreds of thousands of rural New Afrikan (Black) laborers. At the same time, industry demanded a more mobile and educated workforce. Segregated education and discriminatory employment practices limited the potential productivity of millions of amerikans. Economically, segregation became untenable keeping euro-amerikan settler capitalism alive. The need for more surplus labor from all facets of amerika required the New Afrikan (Black), Indigenous, and other oppressed communities access to skills such as basic education, literacy, and high school for the maintenance of amerikan industry.</p><p>Large corporations and national business interests increasingly viewed the South’s resistance to civil rights as a liability and hinderance for more surplus labor. Companies like IBM, AT&amp;T, and General Motors had integrated workforces and national customer bases. They wanted regulatory consistency and a more stable labor pool, not social unrest. Civil rights legislation, in this sense, was not simply a moral cause — it was aligned with the interests of postwar capitalism as a form of neo-colonialism to stave off uprisings from New Afrikan (Black) and oppressed people.</p><p>While southern segregationists might have won the cultural battle in small towns and local legislatures, they were losing the economic war, with working class Southerners increasingly on the payroll of either big industry or the federal government.</p><h4>IV. Military loyalty to the federal government was unquestioned.</h4><p>This economic centralization was, in some ways, prefigured by the centralization of military power post-WWII. The war effort had required mass conscription, centralized procurement, and industrial coordination on a scale never before attempted. Federal agencies such as the War Production Board and the Office of Price Administration gained sweeping powers that effectively bypassed state governments. The current state of amerikan capitalism was, and to this day still is, a war economy.</p><p>While National Guard units were nominally state-controlled, the President retained the constitutional power to federalize them — a power repeatedly exercised during desegregation crises. In cases such as the Little Rock Nine (1957) or the University of Mississippi (1962), the federal government asserted control over state guard units to enforce civil rights mandates.</p><p>This capacity to override state military authority proved critical. Had the national guard units refused federal orders or defected to local command, the u.s. would have faced a true constitutional crisis. However, key factors prevented this. First, the institutional culture of the u.s. military emphasized chain-of-command discipline rooted in federal law, not state allegiance. Second, federal funding and logistical support for the national guard gave Washington economic leverage. Third, officers within the national guard — many of whom had served in World War II or the Korean — were deeply socialized into a national military identity. Additionally, the growing Vietnam war effort further centralized the u.s. military, and the national guard, around the federal government.</p><p>Federal authority was therefore not just codified in law, but reinforced by command structure, resources, and ideological training. National media further legitimized this authority, framing federal troop deployments as necessary interventions in defense of rights. In contrast, state defiance increasingly appeared not as valor but as insubordination.</p><h4>V. The Civil Rights Movement offered federal authorities a source of legitimacy.</h4><p>The civil rights movement played a pivotal role in reinforcing federal legitimacy. By framing the struggle in constitutional terms and emphasizing nonviolence, leaders like Martin Luther King Jr. invited federal intervention. Activists forced the federal government to choose between complicity and enforcement. Each intervention — whether in Selma, Birmingham, or Montgomery — tied the identity of the federal government more tightly to the cause of civil rights. With the assassination of MLK Jr., the Federal government was able to outmaneuver the fragmented “left” by framing his death as a great loss for the amerikan people, and using it to provide legitimacy and justification for federal authority, especially within bourgeois and petty bourgeois elements of the Black community. His death further channelized a set of “appropriate” means for making demands, centered around “non-violent” protest, and elevated state-compatible figures to movement leadership.</p><p>Crucially, this movement leadership did not call for secession or state fragmentation; the demand was for full integration, not the destruction of the amerikan state. That strategic horizon gave Washington a pathway to legitimacy that did not require delegitimizing the southern populations wholesale. In the late 1960s and 1970s, concessions — expanded access to jobs and education, greater political representation, targeted social programs, and openings in unions, universities, and municipal bureaucracies — absorbed much of the revolutionary energy that had animated separatist currents such as the Republic of New Afrika (RNA) and organizations like the Black Panther Party (BPP). By “addressing” inequality in administrable ways and creating avenues for participation, the state cultivated a cadre of neocolonial intermediaries who could pacify and manage New Afrikan communities from within. In an economic context of growing public-sector employment, nonprofit expansion, and federally mediated contracts, these reforms made “justice” profitable and stabilizing. Federal authority was ideologically strengthened by selectively meeting demands in forms that integrated militants into governance, converted insurgent capacity into administrative capacity, and thereby deepened the state’s legitimacy in the eyes of the broader public.</p><p>It should be noted that the federal governments covert and overt war on militant separatist groups (i.e., RNA), organizations (i.e., BPP, Weather Underground, Students for a Democratic Society — SDS, etc.), and movements (i.e., anti-war, Third World liberation, etc.) delegitimized revolutionary politics as a viable form of social change amongst the amerikan population. The federal government positioned itself as foundational institution on social and ideological change in the settler-capitalist system. The ascendancy of Ronald Reagan and neo-liberalism furthered the ideological legitimacy of the settler state.</p><p>In short, federal authority survived the 1960s by leveraging strong, unified state capacity with select demands for justice, and crucially, doing so in an economic context that made such justice profitable and stabilizing. The task of organizers now is to identify key weaknesses in the state that have developed between then and now, and analyze how those might affect movement building in the present.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f327e620c445" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Politics in Command: Reflections on Our Fifth Year Anniversary]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@communityliberationprograms/politics-in-command-reflections-on-our-fifth-year-anniversary-9f988577187f?source=rss-eda330dbf377------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9f988577187f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[reflections]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[socialism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[revolution]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Community Liberation Programs]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 15 Sep 2025 00:49:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-09-15T00:49:40.592Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>By Community Liberation Programs</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*U8eWw8j-gQqzvWq6pdLYpQ.png" /></figure><p>In August 15, 2020 Community Liberation Programs (CLP), then known as Workers’ Community Kitchen, launched its first program. Cast in the political shadow of the George Floyd Uprisings, the economic shadow of COVID-19, and the literal shadow of the Union City BART station, a group of young people in the East Bay decided to take action into their own hands. All of us were ultimately dissatisfied with the state’s negligent response to COVID-19 as thousands of people were laid off from work, forced to survive with the little government assistance provided, and starved for support. Many of us were unorganized and uneducated in how to implement change. Yet despite our shortcomings, we started distributing food, resources, and our labor to provide something tangible for the people.</p><p>The history of the founding of CLP and our first programs is recounted in CLP’s third podcast episode, where our co-founders discuss the challenges and motivations behind our initial work. It’s impossible to separate our decision to create the organization from the political moment which spawned it. At the time, we observed the political energy of the uprisings being channeled into the election of the Joe Biden administration and its junior partners across the Bay Area (London Breed, Chesa Boudin, Carol Fife, Pamela Price, etc.). The masses’ demand of abolishing the police was transformed into an unmet request for the defunding of the police. A moment with revolutionary potential was expertly disarmed by the highly refined techniques of the repressive state apparatus.</p><p>The collective “left” in the u.s. (abolitionists, progressives, those who wish to see a better world created) failed the people in this moment. Our lack of political principles, material organizational development, and, most importantly, our hopeless غرب‌زدگی (Gharbzadegi or Westoxification) (1) and endemic liberalism doomed us. The effects of COINTELPRO, domestic neo-colonialism, and the proliferation of the non-profit industrial complex had left the movement severely premature in a moment in which a new reality could have been birthed. However, these external contradictions cannot be entirely responsible for the collapse of the 2020 political upserge. Internally, contradictions wreaked havoc on the collective “left” from interpersonal conflicts bubbling into political “call-outs,” to liberal identity politics that silenced necessary critiques of the movements, to a general anti-intellectualism and aversion to study our history. Many of the internal contradictions were due to our innate liberalisms which blurred our vision for clear political ideology and action.</p><p>At CLP’s inception, we failed in many areas and that required us to self-critique. Initially, our work was charity. We provided thousands of meals, grocery bags, clean drinking water, and produce grown for the community. Our work was simply “mutual aid.” Many on the left believe that mutual aid is about “solidarity not charity.” However, from our experience, mutual aid <em>is </em>charity, and for our communities it is a bandaid on a gunshot wound. CLP’s first mutual aid work failed in politicizing the people we spent months building relationships with and failed to act sustainably. Our first programs had significant spontaneous energy and labor that was able to sustain our community mutual aid work for ~1 year. We were able to bring in new people with various ideological perspectives into the organization and saw initial growth in our rudimentary organization structure. However, after a year of sustaining our work on the energy of spontaneity, our volunteer base dwindled as many volunteers who were initially driven to serve the people decided that they wanted to go back to their normal lives. As the external pressure of labor continued, there arose internal contradictions within the early years of CLP from significant interpersonal disagreements over the organization’s direction and the overall feeling of burnout amongst our organizing team. All these contradictions would have resulted in the complete dissolution of the project.</p><p>There were several factors that saved CLP from being buried by the contradictions which make organizing so difficult in this country. We will discuss these factors frankly and openly for others who find themselves in a similar position to learn and apply. These lessons only have as much validity in that in our own experience, and when observing the successful revolutionary movements in the world, we have found them to be empirically correlated with the most effective ideology that has liberated over a quarter of the worlds population from colonialism, feudalism, and imperialism — Scientific Socialism.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ePmS7lupJbewyiwkttNQNQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo taken in 2020 during our first grocery distribution as Workers’ Community Kitchen</figcaption></figure><h4>Political Education is the Lifeblood of the Organization</h4><p>Whenever CLP has experienced an inflection point, we have found our way forward through study. At our most significant crisis in 2021, as many members left the organization, we sought guidance from the chapter, “Front for the Liberation of the New Afrikan Nation (FROLINAN) Handbook” in We Are Our Own Liberators by Jalil Muntaqim (2). This single chapter did not confirm our biases or ideas of what organization should be. It challenged the very foundation of the organization and seriously critiqued our style of work and organization as it failed to educate all our members with the stated ideology of Scientific Socialism or our goals for the liberation of the New Afrikan and Indigenous Nations. From that moment, all of CLP’s organizers embarked on a rigorious political education regimen of collective and internal study. After reading Imperialism: The Highest Stage of Capitalism by Lenin (3), we studied the historical materialist development of u.s. settler colonial capitalism and drafted our class analysis of the most revolutionary classes and oppressed communities in the Bay Area. We studied Wretched of the Earth by Frantz Fanon (4) along side Meditations on Wretched of the Earth by James Yaki Sayles (5). These two texts provided us the understanding and rationale for continuing our internal political education work with all members. Lastly, On Practice and On Contradiction by Mao Zedong (6) provided us a deeper analysis of dialectical materialism and the need for putting our theories to action. There were more texts and internal discussions beyond the ones stated above, but they provided us with a foundation to reorganize our structure and to move forward by taking on the name Community Liberation Programs. As we embarked on building our political education programming internally, we never stopped our programs and continued to provide the material support for our communities until they developed the autonomy to support themselves.</p><p>Within the five years of building this organization, we have experienced other inflection points such as <a href="https://docs.google.com/document/d/1E8JpXLU9uQ8QYqW5QJXWq1_5V6JFIafM/edit?rtpof=true&amp;sd=true&amp;tab=t.0">our illegal removal from Omni Commons</a> (7) during Operation Al-Aqsa Flood. Political education again served as a method to overcome difficult decisions, internal conflict, and solidifying our politics. As we were undergoing a protracted struggle against the zionist-led Omni Commons, we began to experience internal contradictions around the viablity of our protracted struggle, beliefs of “turning the other cheek,” and demoralization around our “image” as an organization. We challenged these tendancies internally by implementing internal political education training on Criticism and Self-Criticism (CSC) inspired by Constructive Criticism by Vicki Legion (8) and the Library Sciences’ CSC class (9). Additionally, a core group of organizers collectively studied the lessons by Safiya Bukhari in her book, The War Before (10). All these texts and classes provided us a more robust, organized method of conflict resolution, ideological struggle, and critique. All these lessons have shown that political education tied to decolonization programs must be the life blood of any organization.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Ri5jOjZkpP0_XVRLDqBgag.png" /><figcaption>Photo taken during our Water Delivery Program (2020 to 2022). We delivered over 130 gallons of water.</figcaption></figure><h4>Politics in Command</h4><p>Political education is a pillar in CLP, but these lessons must be put into command. The term, “Politics in command” represents the necessity to put your politics forward in all facets of life and to test your ideas, concepts, and theories in the material world. It is common amongst “leftist spaces” to separate “organizing life” from “real life.” For many across all class backgrounds, political organizing can be seen as a hobby or a weekend social group where you plan one-off events, go to protests, or read a book. The lessons from political work never really translate to the whole life of the individual; in the end, the individual supersedes the collective. For many “organizations” of all tendencies, it is political education for the sake of political education with no coherent mass work or programs for decolonization. What we have seen, from the five years of our organization, is a lack of bridging the gap between political education and practical work necessary for training principled revolutionaries, organizers, and people. It is a dialectical relationship that requires putting politics in command. If organizations and their leadership fail to put their politics in command, the people they seek to serve will not trust or look to them for guidance and support.</p><p>As an organization, putting our politics into command has taken shape through struggle, study, criticism, and self-criticism. As we have discussed above, political education is necessary to building the foundation of politics. When studying theory, history, and ideology, an organization must be able to, “…put these conclusions to the test of our own experience, assimilating what is useful, rejecting what is useless, and adding what is specifically our own” <a href="https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/mao/selected-works/volume-1/mswv1_12.htm">(Mao, 1936)</a>. By building this foundation, all members of the organization must struggle and come to a decision through democratic centralism on the correct analysis of the present state of things within the settler-capitalist state and imperialism worldwide.</p><p>This foundation naturally leads to the development of points of unity, codes of conduct for all members, and expectations for all organizers to reach a higher stage of political and personal development. Codes of conduct and expectations are necessary to hold everyone accountable to revolutionary principles such as an emphasis on sobriety, uplifting the most oppressed genders and gender expressions, and a committment to root out gendered-racial-settler chauvinism from all ranks of the organization through clear lines and policies for accountablity. Additionally, a solid political foundation requires the need for a political and ideological line of demarcation. For CLP, we follow the Thawabet, which refuses to collaborate or work with any organization or individual who normalizes the zionist entity known as “israel.” We continue this line of principles to the <a href="https://materialjournal.net/the-immanent-garrison-settlerism-as-institutionalized-ideology/">settler-capitalist</a> u.s. by refusing to work, collaborate, or build coalitions with organizations that seek legitimacy through the tactics of electoralism (i.e., normalization of the settler-capitalist state), union economism, and a settler-focused class analysis that abandons contemporary class analysis of the labor aristocracy.</p><p>In order to put politics into command, this platform should be tested through <a href="https://medium.com/@communityliberationprograms/creating-a-revolutionary-program-782dc03df7c5">applying the theory ​​​​​​​in creating programs for decolonization.</a> In line with politics being in command, all members of the organization from leadership to new members must struggle together in all lines of work. Leadership should be able to provide perspectives, assignments, and goals of each program, but they are not above the work necessary to achieve the implementation of the program. Leadership must be shoulder-to-shoulder with all levels of the organization within the struggle in order to combat liberalism and top-down commandism of the organization. Each implementation of a program, organizational wide decision, event, and analysis of current conditions must be filtered through the lens of criticism and self-criticism. Each action holds a lesson to improve our work and our organization as a whole. All these lessons provide a scaffolding of how to put politics in command.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/719/1*cWksAjKFgQ_BbYje5RvqfA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo taken at our May 19th Event on Asian and New Afrikan Solidarity</figcaption></figure><h4>Revolutionary Discipline</h4><p>To ensure that politics remain in command, revolutionary discipline is necessary to hold individuals and the organization accountable to their politics. As discussed above, revolutionary codes of conduct and expectations are the written principles all members must adhere to. It emphasizes that the individual is beholden to the collective and that their actions and ideas affect the whole organization. Within the five years of CLP’s existence, we have been influenced by the theories of Frantz Fanon’s Wretched of the Earth, James “Yaki” Sayles’s Meditations on Wretched of the Earth, and Safiya Bukhari’s The War Before. All these texts highlight the need to become a “new person” by waging an internal revolution within one’s self.</p><p>Fanon’s concept of a “new person” was influenced by his understanding of the noxious effects of European liberalism and colonial ideology that hampered the revolutionary consciousness of the colonized. This conception, influenced by his understanding of Islam, looks at creating a new, revolutionary consciousness within the colonized and oppressed by seeing themselves within the dialectical relationship of the colonizer and the colonized. This “new person” is able to do away with European liberalism and colonial mentalities to chart a new consciousness that provides clarity on the tasks required to wage a revolutionary struggle against colonialism, imperialism, and neo-colonial capture. James “Yaki” Sayles furthers this concept by emphasizing the need for political education on the neo-colonial capture of New Afrikans and oppressed people within the settler-capitalist u.s. Additionally, Safiya Bukhari, from her experiences as a former Black Panther and Black Liberation Army veteran and New Afrikan Muslim, builds on this concept with the necessity for an “internal revolution” where individuals, through revolutionary struggle, combat innate liberalisms and reactionary ideologies in order to strive to become a new person. The internal revolution to become a new person requires self-criticism and deep introspection of the effects of neo-colonialism and amerikan settler-capitalism on the individual.</p><p>For members of any organization, revolutionary discipline and the internal revolution to become a new person requires your politics to penetrate into all aspects of your life. Within the collective, it is necessary that individuals provide their professional and practical skills to the organization as well as utilize their organizing skills in their personal, professional, and familial lives to organize their communities beyond economisitic unionism, electoralism, and settler-capitalist ideology. Revolutionary discipline requires each member to understand their class background and continuously struggle to do away with bourgeois, petit-bourgeois, and labor aristocratic perspectives of their profession and how they see the world. Through critique and collective struggle, we all are striving to become new people.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*qDsh5GMUuFqcOPFZR8HGJg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo from our Acupuncture Event in Oakland Chinatown serving elders</figcaption></figure><h4>Revolutionary Resolve</h4><p>Lastly, there are specific outlooks towards organizing that are necessary for the continual growth and development of revolutionaries and organizers into new people. Revolutionary resolve is a firm determination to see through the development of the political project of Scientific Socialism within the imperial core. Since the fall of the Black Panther Party and the Black Liberation Army, our movement in the core lacks the infrastructure necessary to sustain the protracted people’s war for the liberation of New Afrika, the thousands of Indigenous Nations, and all oppressed peoples within the settler-capitalist u.s. The revolutionary struggle is a protracted struggle that requires revolutionary optimism in the face of hardships and setbacks. Through the hardships that CLP has faced, we have reoriented our work on the basis of revolutionary optimism by basing our trust in our comrades that we will overcome anything that comes in our way. Through tumultuous times, the trust in our comrades having our backs provides resilience for revolutionary optimism to persist.</p><p>Another aspect of revolutionary resolve is a fearlessness, and an encouragement, to make mistakes. Amongst many new people coming into organizing, there is a pervasive fear of making mistakes and not knowing how to do tasks. This mindset, which stems from bourgeois perfectionism, often hinders organizers and organizations to move beyond what is comfortable and safe. Failure and mistakes have been reinforced through our upbringings and educational system as faults and failings of those deemed less worthy to the settler-capitalist system. Revolutionary resolve reframes mistakes and failures as a lesson to sharpen and refine our practice towards more effective struggle. Additionally, when comrades make mistakes, providing criticisms must be seen as a gift for improvement. When we provide these lessons to comrades or to the whole organization, we always have to frame it in a way that ties criticism to the objective facts, conditions, and connections to liberalism so that the lessons can clearly be understood and struggled over for the betterment of the organization.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*w88xMarKKr3zxpNAJrWjzA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo taken at our Youth Street Medic Training</figcaption></figure><h4>Conclusion</h4><p>The continuous, everyday development of Community Liberation Programs (CLP) is one rooted in the transformation of individuals, collectives, and political consciousness. From CLP’s spontaneous beginning under the shadow of multiple crises of the COVID-19 Pandemic, George Floyd Uprisings, and the state’s neglect of the most vulnerable, CLP emerged as a school of revolutionary struggle in the Bay Area. Through confronting both external repression and internal contradictions, we learned that building a movement requires more than just goodwill and energy; it demands discipline, clarity, political theory, and principled action.</p><p>Political education continues to be our compass, ensuring that we do not replicate the same liberal pitfalls that have historically doomed movements in the imperial core. By putting our politics in command, we moved beyond reaction and into strategy and tactics by rooting our work in programs for decolonization and national liberation. Revolutionary discipline is the foundation that holds collectives together to weather the protracted struggle for the liberation of all oppressed nations within the belly of the beast. Revolutionary resolve provides the revolutionary outlook necessary to find lessons within every setback and failure.</p><p>For organizations across the settler-colonial u.s., we offer our reflections so that you can learn to refine your practice towards a more disciplined movement. The road ahead remains long, and the stakes remain high. The Third World looks to us to finally strike at the heart of reaction and imperialism. With Scientific Socialism and a deep commitment to the ongoing struggle within and amongst ourselves, we must remain committed to building a movement that goes beyond the failures of the past. A new world is possible, but not inevitable. We must build the infrastructure necessary for the protracted struggle that lies ahead. Venceremos!</p><p><em>Footnotes:</em></p><p>(1) Gharbzadegi, or Westoxification, is a term coined by the Iranian intellectual Jalal al-e Ahmad to describe the fascination with and dependence upon the West to the detriment of traditional, historical, and cultural ties to Islam, Islamic world, and the Third World. Defined as an indiscriminate borrowing from and imitation of the Western Liberalism by joining the dangers of cultural imperialism and political domination. It implies a sense of intoxication that impairs rational judgment and confers an inability to see the dangers presented by the toxic West. The West’s inherent dangers are described as moral laxity, social injustice, individualism, devaluation of the collective, and obsession with money, all of which are fueled by capitalism; the common result is cultural alienation. The term was adopted by Ali Shariati, ideologue of the Iranian revolution, to describe the results of Iran’s modernization program.</p><p>(2) <a href="https://static1.squarespace.com/static/5a354481a9db0961249f52ec/t/5f2206a62d00051b306d7222/1596065468255/Jalil+A+Muntaqim+-+We+Are+Our+Own+Liberators_+Selected+Prison+Writings++-Arissa+Media+Group%2C+LLC+%282010%29.pdf">We Are Our Own Liberators by Jalil Muntaqim</a></p><p>(3) <a href="https://www.marxists.org/archive/lenin/works/1916/imp-hsc/imperialism.pdf">Imperialism: The Highest Stage of Capitalism by Vladimir Lenin</a></p><p>(4) <a href="https://monoskop.org/images/6/6b/Fanon_Frantz_The_Wretched_of_the_Earth_1963.pdf">Wretched of the Earth by Frantz Fanon</a></p><p>(5) <a href="https://redyouthnwa.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/05/meditations-on-frantz-fanons-wretched-of-the-earth-sayles.pdf">Meditations on Wretched of the Earth by James Yaki Sayles</a></p><p>(6) <a href="https://michaelharrison.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/09/On-Practice-and-On-Contradiction.pdf">On Practice and On Contradiction by Mao Zedong</a></p><p>(7) In 2023, we began a boycott of all events and organizations in the Omni Commons for its support for zionism and racist targeting of Muslims and all oppressed people in Oakland. Currently, the boycott still stands despite new ownership until there is accountability and the removal of all zionist organizations in the building.<a href="https://docs.google.com/document/d/1E8JpXLU9uQ8QYqW5QJXWq1_5V6JFIafM/edit?rtpof=true&amp;sd=true&amp;tab=t.0"> See more here.</a></p><p>(8) <a href="https://foreignlanguages.press/wp-content/uploads/2025/06/S24-Constructive-Criticism-7th-Printing.pdf">Constructive Criticism by Vicki Legion</a></p><p>(9) The Library Sciences held a class on <a href="https://sites.google.com/view/thelibrarysciences-atradof/leafy-greens-csc-workshop">Criticism and Self-Criticism</a> in 2023.</p><p>(10) <a href="https://ia802802.us.archive.org/21/items/Safiya-bukhari-the-war-before-the-true-life-story-of-becoming-a-black-panther-ke/safiya-bukhari-the-war-before-the-true-life-story-of-becoming-a-black-panther-keeping-the-faith-in-prison-fighting-for-those-left-behind-1.pdf">The War Before by Safiya Bukhari</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9f988577187f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Trump vs. the Petit Bourgeoisie]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@communityliberationprograms/trump-vs-the-petit-bourgeoisie-5a8c4fc516ac?source=rss-eda330dbf377------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5a8c4fc516ac</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[tariffs]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[socialism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[donald-trump]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Community Liberation Programs]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 13 Sep 2025 17:30:39 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-09-13T17:30:39.609Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>By Comrade D</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*aMBu66JvLUoDuZUotcfocA.png" /></figure><p>Donald Trump’s political project has long been understood as fundamentally populist — a revolt of the “forgotten man” against the cosmopolitan elite. But beneath this familiar narrative lies a deeper, more structural contradiction that has defined his domestic agenda: a war on the American petit bourgeoisie. This group, historically the bedrock of middle-class stability and small-scale economic independence, finds itself repeatedly undermined by Trump’s policies — largely as a consequence of how his political coalition operates within the constraints of amerikan political economy. Whether through the dismantling of bureaucratic structures, targeted cultural offensives, or trade policy, “Trumpism” increasingly embodies the contradictions and consolidating tendencies of late-stage capitalism, channeling popular discontent into a political movement that fortifies elite control while dismantling intermediary class power.</p><p>The first front in this war is the systematic dismantling of the professional-managerial-bureaucratic class — what might be called the “structural” petit bourgeoisie. These are the professionals who populate Human Resources departments, compliance offices, diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) initiatives, as well as the broader ecosystems of NGOs, think tanks, government agencies, and sprawling networks of consultants and administrators that define today’s public and private institutions. This also includes many government employees whose positions are sustained by public sector expansion enabled, in part, by the fiscal surpluses and dollar dominance derived from amerikan imperialism.</p><p>These jobs, often justified in terms of regulatory oversight or public service, form a key part of the structural petit bourgeois class that Trumpism seeks to destabilize. Trump’s attacks on DEI programs and his broader assault on federal bureaucracy are more than symbolic gestures. They are strategic moves aimed at destabilizing a class of workers whose economic function is tightly linked to regulatory oversight, legal compliance, and institutional self-policing. Career advancement in these fields also often depends on the accumulation of social and cultural capital, commonly through performative attacks on ideological opponents (“cancel culture”) and virtue signaling. In targeting the economic base of the structural petit bourgeoisie, Trump appeases the bloodlust of his right-wing populist coalition at little real economic cost, while at the same time weakening the position of his staunchest and most visible domestic critics. Finally, these attacks further erode the already weakened popular legitimacy of these institutions, laying the groundwork for increasingly autocratic political actions.</p><p>But the assault does not stop there. Trump’s signature trade policies — most notably his aggressive use of tariffs — open a second front against a more traditional form of the petit bourgeoisie: small-scale manufacturers and regional business owners. In theory, tariffs are meant to protect domestic industry from foreign competition. In practice, however, Trump’s tariff regime is selectively enforced and riddled with carve-outs that benefit politically connected firms. Large corporations, with the resources to lobby for exemptions or reconfigure their supply chains, are able to mitigate the impact. Smaller manufacturers, particularly those without the capital or political influence to navigate the exemption process, are left exposed — often forced to downsize, sell their businesses, or cede market share to better-capitalized competitors. This dynamic paves the way for further market consolidation and monopolization.</p><p>This pattern is not unique to the tariff regime but echoes earlier policies enacted under both Trump and Biden during the initial phase of the COVID-19 pandemic. Emergency stimulus measures, lockdowns, bailouts, and supply chain interventions disproportionately favored large corporations while leaving smaller firms to fend for themselves. The result was an unprecedented wave of wealth and market share consolidation, accelerating trends already underway in the amerikan economy. The tariff war fits into a broader pattern of crisis-driven policymaking that strengthens large, politically connected firms by undermining smaller independent producers, whose competition once drove amerikan industrial strength.</p><p>This asymmetry in enforcement mirrors broader dynamics in Trump-era policymaking: a top-down approach that rewards loyalty and punishes independence, even among nominal allies. The “true” petit bourgeoisie — family-owned factories, local production outfits, and regional supply chain hubs — will bear the brunt of his trade policy, not because they are enemies of the state, but because they lack the bureaucratic or financial means to avoid becoming collateral damage. In destabilizing this group, Trump is not inadvertently harming his base; he is reordering it, shifting power from a class of decentralized producers to a more centralized, loyalty-dependent corporate ecosystem.</p><p>The consumer effects of tariffs further compound the squeeze on the petit bourgeois class at large. Unlike lower-income amerikans, whose spending is largely concentrated on non-tradable necessities such as rent, medical bills, and insurance, as well as mostly regional/local goods such as groceries, middle-class consumers maintain discretionary spending patterns. These are the people who buy imported electronics, hobby goods, tools, and recreational equipment — goods most affected by tariffs. While the working poor may be shielded from direct price hikes — being in dire straits already — the middle class will find their purchasing power reduced, especially in domains that affect lifestyle and self-actualization. In effect, the very consumers who define the petit bourgeois cultural sphere — homeowners, hobbyists, small-scale entrepreneurs — are the ones most burdened by the rising cost of imported goods.</p><p>This selective pressure on discretionary consumption is not just economic — it is ideological. By forcing the middle class to scale back on their little luxuries, Trump’s policies erode the cultural and material underpinnings of petit bourgeois life. The shrinking of consumer choice and economic flexibility reflects the broader trajectory of neoliberal austerity — now coming full circle to affect the professional class that was once one of its principal beneficiaries. In place of this hollowed-out amerikkkan Middle Class, what emerges is a dependency-based model of economic power, where access to relief — whether in the form of tax cuts, deregulation, or exemptions — is determined not only by proximity to political power, but also by conformity to the symbolic expectations of the movement. In this emerging regime, right-wing virtue signaling — public demonstrations of loyalty, ideological purity, and alignment with MAGA cultural codes — becomes a form of currency.</p><p>In this way, Trump’s war on the petit bourgeoisie can be understood as a structural rearrangement of political power under the guise of populism. The managerial middle class, the independent producer, and the discretionary consumer are all systematically weakened — not in contradiction to Trump’s political message, but as its logical extension. The petit bourgeoisie, long positioned as a stabilizing force in amerikkkan capitalism, intermediaries between the economic elites and the underclass, now finds itself either co-opted or discarded, as Trump consolidates a coalition built on institutional disruption and political patronage.</p><p>Importantly, this shift does not necessarily reflect a deliberate strategy devised by Trump himself. Rather, it emerges as the natural consequence of a political coalition navigating the structural constraints of amerikkkan capitalism. Trump’s base demands material relief and symbolic retribution, yet the architecture of u.s. political economy limits the avenues through which these demands can be fulfilled. What results is not a program of economic democratization or institutional renewal, but one of targeted, performative attacks — neutralizing the liberal-cosmopolitan middle class that has historically mediated between economic elites and the masses, and replacing it with a new class of interlocutors whose authority is based on personal loyalty to the MAGA movement and its central leadership. Rather than addressing systemic contradictions, Trumpism can only redirect public frustration toward dismantling the superstructural elements of 20th century amerikkkan capitalism.</p><p>Although the specifics of what is unfolding are uniquely amerikkkan, the broader dynamics are captured by the work of complexity scientist Peter Turchin, who argues that elite overproduction — the mass credentialing of individuals vying for a finite number of elite positions — has led not only to downward mobility and resentment within the middle class, but also to the formation of counter-elites. This group, once buffered by stability and opportunity, now finds itself squeezed by both institutional exclusion and economic precarity. As competition intensifies and pathways to upward mobility constrict, some of these disaffected individuals splinter off into oppositional factions, aligning themselves with populist movements that promise to overturn the established order. Historically, such counter-elites have included important communist leaders like Lenin, Mao, Deng, Newton, and others. Today, however, we see as many examples on the right as we do on the left. Prominent examples of MAGA counter-elites include figures like Steve Bannon, Chris Rufo, and Jonathan Keeperman — highly educated individuals from upper-middle-class backgrounds who differ in ideology and strategy but share a common genesis in the economic and institutional bottlenecks of elite overproduction. These actors position themselves as insurgents against both the traditional elite consensus and the liberal-professional class, gaining traction not through institutional legitimacy but by leveraging public disenchantment and populist energy to carve out new, parallel forms of authority. Their rise reflects a broader transformation in how legitimacy is accrued in an elite-saturated and increasingly post-liberal environment — no longer through procedural ascent or the performance of dominant elite norms and values, but through insurgent rejection of the existing order and its legitimating narratives.</p><p>This also gives us some idea as to how leftist counter-elites might navigate the current situation. Whereas right-wing counter-elites tend to be wedded to the basic economic foundation of liberalism, leftists are relatively free to explore alternative, forward-looking economic systems that could fully resolve the systemic contradictions at the root of elite overproduction. This fundamental difference gives us the advantage in producing a political program capable of generating mass economic legitimacy. But for our message to be heard in the first place, we have to stop siding with the liberal establishment against fascists. We have to stop defining our political identity around our opponents and create a positive project that inspires the masses. The fascist alt-right are first and foremost the competition, rather than merely an enemy. The liberal establishment betrayed most ordinary amerikans and created the underclass we see today. Whoever does the most damage to this establishment gains the most legitimacy in the eyes of the masses. The left, unfortunately, but not unpredictably, is currently losing this competition.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5a8c4fc516ac" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>