<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Robert on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Robert on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@comp.keith55?source=rss-00686345896c------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 03:49:15 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@comp.keith55/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[AI and HI]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@comp.keith55/ai-and-hi-39f930b48504?source=rss-00686345896c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/39f930b48504</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[human-behavior]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[intelegence]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[humanity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ai]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Robert]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 25 Oct 2026 07:07:42 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-25T07:07:42.826Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I mentioned AI in my last Medium story “Unfathomable People” and concluded that human intelligence (HI) is not that far removed from AI.</p><p>Stanford University: “A Neural Network is a computational model inspired by human brain structure, consisting of interconnected layers of artificial ‘neurons’ that process and transmit information. Each neuron receives inputs, applies mathematical operations (weights and activation functions), and passes the result to neurons in the next layer. Neural Networks are the foundation of deep learning and power many modern AI applications — from facial recognition to voice assistants to self-driving cars.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/852/1*3RiSzoju0Z9mnBVU9WYiPg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Shutterstock</figcaption></figure><p>AI is far removed from the original 1930’s Touring Machine computer. Large Language Models (LLM) emulate the human brain. Previously, computers of all sizes were Touring Machines with processing unit, memory and instructions. In contrast a LLM is a vast multi-layered network of pattern matching “neurons” which act independently and in parallel. The output of a classic computer results from the execution of instructions while the output of a LLM is the result of patterns matched by neurons and cascading interconnections. Each AI neuron is independent and implemented as a classic computer. The number of interconnected neurons is why so many GPUs (the fastest modern computers) are used. In simple terms “training” creates patterns for neurons to match and their interconnections. This applies to both AI and HI.</p><p>Wikipedia: “A biological neural network is composed of a group of chemically connected or functionally associated neurons. A single neuron may be connected to many other neurons and the total number of neurons and connections in a network may be extensive. Connections, called synapses, are usually formed from axons to dendrites, though dendrodendritic synapses and other connections are possible.”</p><p>My story is not attempting to describe the functioning of brain and artificial neural networks. There is extensive information available on both of those topics. Both are still not fully understood with a lot more research happening. For the purposes of my story, a neural network needs heaps of neurons; heaps more interconnections between neurons; training to configure neurons and their interconnections; and ongoing training to reconfigure neurons and update interconnections.</p><p>Human brain interconnections rely on dendrites passing a chemical message and this is slow, so the brain needs specialised parts to speed things up (visual pre-processing is why human optical illusions work). AI does not need specialised areas or other eccentricities such as conscience or a value system. I do appreciate that only part of a human brain is being modelled by AI, but it is a very effective model of basic human reasoning — even to the extent that some assert AI to be “conscious”.</p><p>NeuroLaunch.com: “The human brain contains roughly 86 billion neurons forming an estimated 100 trillion synaptic connections, and the artificial neural networks reshaping modern technology were built, at least in spirit, to mimic that architecture. But the gap between biological and artificial intelligence turns out to be stranger and more revealing than most people realize. Understanding brain and neural networks together tells you something important about both.”</p><p>Most stories analyse AI in relation to HI. This story follows on from my “Unfathomable People” story which contrasted HI against AI to put human behaviour in perspective: “I like to think I am a rational person who can logically assess shades of grey, but this may be an illusion as I am probably just a pattern matching neural network with outputs determined by interconnections and patterns.” Many of my interactions with people were not a reason based interaction of minds but a clash between different sets of patterns and interconnections (especially if MAGA).</p><p>A trivial example is a discussion with my sister on a toilet seat being left up or down. Both of us saw a TV news story about toilet when flushed releases a large quantity of minute air born particles (seat down). A health inspector friend told me that the bowl with seat down is an ideal place for bacteria to breed (seat up). The discussion ended in discord as she was not prepared to include my fact in her neural training.</p><p>A person’s neural network also determines what new “facts” to absorb. My sister had a much better regard for TV news than whatever I said, so my fact was discarded. Human thought is diverse and background (left, right, woke, alt-science, etc.) limits what facts can be absorbed and incorporated into a person’s neural network. Only stuff a person considers valid will be incorporated in their neuron training. Despite claims to common-sense, the human brain does not have a foolproof system to filter its training. Emotion also plays a big part in HI filtering. My sister and I disagree on a lot of things, so my new facts are always unconditionally discarded.</p><p>There are also reasoning limitations for HI, for example, a lie told often enough becomes the truth. The brain’s specialised processing structures can also affect filtering. The internet is full of scams presenting something plausible needing urgent action. People panic and act immediately without conscious filtering. It is also possible for a busy conscious not to notice a subconscious direction — NLP (Neuro Linguistic Programming) describes something stock-in-trade for con-artists. Emotions can also affect HI training, for example, advertising and politicians exploiting desires and fears to make sure people absorb their neural training.</p><p>In the case of AI, the sources for training and filtering are specified by humans. Everything that passes this filtering is absorbed without question. AI chat bots also assess and adopt individual AI user bias for maximum user satisfaction (the same approach as con-artists). The goal for AI seems to be maximise profits and not to challenge training. Unlike humans, AI is not affected by subconscious messaging, values or emotions, but can apply these things to human interactions.</p><p>The obvious sources for HI “training” are parents, family, community, school, games, TV, social media, publications, news, AI summaries, religions, influencers, public figures, and any source considered authoritative. There is usually minimal assessment of a source’s suitability for training — availability, entertainment value and alignment with views are the usual criteria. Human filtering sometimes includes ethical and other considerations (as defined by prior training).</p><p>HI unlike AI has an inherent ability to question its own training. Events, new information or a realisation can highlight inconsistencies in a person’s prior neural training. This may result in rejection of this training and an attempt to retrain their neurons. The emotional impact of such change can be severe. This ability to question is dependent on the strength of prior training, for example, conspiracy theory provides a very loose filter for inconsistencies — all … are corrupt.</p><p>Each person develops their own unique neural network in their 86 billion neurons. I do not expect others to share my thought process (Myers-Briggs INFP; Enneagram type 1 perfectionist with a type 2 helper wing; diagnosed dyslexic with a verbal memory marginally above brain damaged; having tactile primary modality) but some people are definitely much easier to interact with. It is much easier to develop rapport with someone having a compatible neural network or with a con-artist. This ability to align with certain people affects training. Charismatic people are good at this.</p><p>There are four main ways for HI to experience the external world — Visual, Auditory, Kinesthetic and Tactile. One of these learning modalities becomes the main one a person uses and this is reflected in their choice of words. It is much easier to have rapport with someone of the same modality as word choices by a person of different modality are jarring. There are many other aspects of HI training that can be jarring between people (cultural, racial, education, political, gender, wealth, position, etc.) and this impacts what each person absorbs in neural training.</p><p>Even information in text form can be absorbed differently by people. Stuff that is read has to pass neural filtering and be consistent with a person’s prior neural training. Give a Bible to a Christian, a Muslim and an Atheist to read and each person will have vastly different reactions.</p><h3>My HI training and a training clash</h3><p>I am a technical person who prefers historical stuff to novels and poetry. I keep myself informed and avoid social media biases. My experience covers a lot of industries due to my 50 year IT career. I have dealt with people ranging from factory hands to executive level, so I always talk in shades of grey. I am not a scientist but completed tertiary maths, physics, statistics and chemistry subjects in my computing major. My knowledge of scientific stuff has been very handy for operational IT projects.</p><p>My neural patterns include basic science such as leverage, kinetic energy, momentum, PVT constant, conservation of energy, etc.. Some people reject this basic stuff and rubbish my opinion when it contradicts their alternate training. Quoting formulas and experiments confirming basic stuff is ignored. The application of statistics is also a neural pattern. My statistics training is also basic, so I am limited to discussions with averages and standard deviations. The only way to manipulate basic stats is to use selective, incomplete or dodgy data, yet some people assert that “statistics is used to prove anything” and reject anything statistical.</p><p>The 1990’s provided an opportunity for me to study philosophy, so my neural patterns also include the basics of philosophy and theology. This introduced the concept of fallacious arguments which has been very helpful and changed the way I interact with people — are my arguments valid? It is amazing the number of replies to Medium stories that resort to Ad hominem (a troll characteristic).</p><p>As you probably gather already, my neural network favours science over alt-science. While at uni I rubbed shoulders with scientists and potential scientists so I ignore claims of absolute knowledge or science conspiracy. I am happy to admit my bias but also capable of questioning my biases. Alt-science influencers loose me when they start by trivialising scientists and produce volumes of information beyond comprehension by mere mortals (for example, Avi Leob).</p><p>A long term friend and neighbour is a keen fan of alternate medicine. He has completed a six month course in using magnetic therapy and considers himself an expert in human anatomy. He is also a devotee of faith healing and Tahitian Noni Juice. I have learned not to mention my health, double blind testing or scientific research. He usually likes to be in control of conversations but this is OK as we have been friends for so long. He gave up mentioning anecdotal cures years ago and I don’t push my perspective. This of course limits what we can talk about and he is probably offended I don’t buy his Noni Juice. Other neighbours describe him as “hard work”.</p><p>Is it possible for humans to be rational when reasoning is based on neural pattern matching? What is etched onto a human’s neural network determines what information is included or rejected and this reinforces patterns already in place. Discussion is limited to neural training common to both parties unless either party “retrains” to include new information or trusts the information provided by the other — their expertise is respected and acknowledged. This begs the question as to which training is valid. Maybe my opinions should be ignored. The final arbiter is obviously long term outcomes, but as agreed by all parties. Such agreement may never happen for people with diametrically opposed neural training like my neighbour and myself.</p><h3>HI training of today (from Unfathomable People)</h3><p>From my perspective, the Western world has had a major shift in training sources over my 71 years. Training via parents, family and community is becoming limited with people isolated and both parents likely working and/or separated. This initial training competes with external influences. The training focus for schools has become to equip people with skills for work and not necessarily to encourage critical thinking. Maybe some teachers provide alternate perspectives and challenge thinking, but this does not seem to be the norm. Religion and its training are also closely linked with family and schooling. Possibly ministers could provide alternate perspectives but this is unlikely for fundamental belief. Fundamentalism at any stage becomes firmly entrenched.</p><p>Today many news outlets, internet influencers, social media companies, think tanks, etc. have vested interests and deliberately manipulate to get ratings, satisfy owner bias and/or get more clicks. Training from these sources has inherent basis. What is reported and words used can even be subtle and be deliberate manipulation, for example, describing a person as “rejecting an accusation” or “defending their action” affects people’s perception. Prior to the last Queensland State election, local conservative media was running every story it could about youth crime (especially if there was a crying victim). Youth crime was presented as out of control despite statistics indicating youth crime was reducing. The slogan for the party that won was “adult crime — adult time” (incarcerate impressionable youth with hardened criminals to train them in proper crime).</p><p>Programs like a Current Affair and 60 Minutes have many viewers. These are vigilante programs acting as judge, jury, executioner and champions of a black and white world. No episode is complete without a crying victim and a villain hounded by reporters. Even entire racial groups are targeted. Which is more important — ratings or justice. Some so-called villains have suicided as a direct result of being nationally targeted. This training shows in people’s opinions. Currently, there are no other TV shows that challenge vigilantism. Survival of the fittest seems to be the main value of reality TV. Surviving on an island or Big Brother set is not for the faint hearted.</p><p>Basic science as a neural pattern varies between people yet most people consider themselves as experts. For example, in a recent discussion about EV batteries, I tried to point out that Lithium was not consumed when discharging and that a battery passed its use by date was still usable as a house battery or could be mostly recycled. My opinion was rejected once again by someone who did not know what a periodic table is! Even simple things such as increasing average temperature is denied as thermometers globally and satellite measurements are part of a conspiracy.</p><p>Medicine is area of exceptionally polarised training with vaccines being a hot topic at present. This is not surprising as snake-oil cures are as older than medicine. Who to believe — anecdotal proof or medical research. Mention of medical research is often rubbished as a ploy by big pharmaceuticals. There is an extremely wide variety of neuron training on anything medical — regardless of veracity.</p><p>Today simple answers with certitude gain traction in popular media and news. Science and medicine only provide a process with an exceptionally technical body of knowledge. The end result is a currently accepted theory which can be falsified and never a simple absolute truth. Complex statistics are not understood by most people (and myself), so who can be trusted to interpret? I am lucky as my university science training prepared me for the uncertainties of contradictory research and human factors. Many sources instil mistrust due to these factors rather than appreciating that science has always worked that way.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*MstJ8icYuXmHkswZKQLWaQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Sutterstock</figcaption></figure><h3>AI to the rescue?</h3><p>We live in a world only possible through science, yet the majority of people do not have enough training to understand basic science, but do they need to — especially in the future when AI provides answers. HI public and social media sources provide a lot of dubious science, so would AI be different?</p><p>My take on HI verses AI presents human reasoning as an illusion. We start as a blank slate neural network which evolves to include facts which in turn are used to filter information updating our neural network. A cyclic pattern that can result in extreme polarisation but is essential for us to be human and not just robots.</p><p>In Unfathomable People my simplistic suggestion was to identify and stop sources of deliberate manipulation. Deception by these players has been proven but they still provide training for human neurons. Fox News is a classic example. My neural network questions everything. To me it is common-sense to question, but many people do not have this as part of their neural training. Is it possible for AI to provide information devoid of misinformation? As an experiment I asked the following of Google:</p><p><strong># </strong>Is climate change a hoax or a reality? <strong><em>AI Overview:</em></strong> <em>Climate change is real and supported by an overwhelming scientific consensus, not a hoax.</em><br><strong># </strong>Is Israel guilty of Genocide? <strong><em>AI Overview:</em></strong> <em>Whether Israel is guilty of genocide is a subject of major international debate and formal legal proceedings, with prominent bodies reaching contrasting conclusions.</em><br><strong># </strong>Is smoking tobacco bad? <strong><em>AI Overview:</em></strong> <em>Yes, tobacco is very bad for your health and damages nearly every organ in the body. There is no safe level of tobacco use or exposure.</em><br><strong># </strong>Is vaccination harmful or helpful? <strong><em>AI Overview:</em></strong> <em>Vaccination is helpful and far safer than contracting the diseases they prevent.</em><br><strong># </strong>What are negative effects of vaccines on society? <strong><em>AI Overview:</em></strong> <em>At the societal level, approved vaccines do not cause widespread negative biological effects, as their medical and public health benefits vastly outweigh the risks. However, the roll-out and perception of vaccination programs can create specific social, economic, and logistical challenges.</em><br><strong># </strong>Is double blind testing essential? <strong><em>AI Overview:</em></strong> <em>Double-blind testing is not universally essential for every scientific or everyday investigation, but it is the gold standard for clinical trials and subjective human evaluations.</em></p><p>My neural network immediately questions if AI had tailored answers based on its assessment of my neural training. It is interesting that Google AI had a definitive answer on all questions except on genocide. The UN invented the term Genocide for a particular crime against humanity with the ICC being the official body to determine if there is a prima facie case and start proceedings — which it has. AI simply mentions contrasting “conclusions”.</p><p>I would love to think that AI could be an ideal tool for HI to identify misinformation and to challenge prior HI training. The ancient Greek philosophers established rules to combat misinformation. They identified flawed debating techniques as fallacious arguments, for example, Ad hominem is where “someone attacks the character, motive, background, or personal traits of the person making an argument instead of addressing the substance of the argument itself” (Wikipedia). AI could highlight fallacious arguments. Due to the extensive use of ad hominem in all forms of present day media (including Medium replies), this is not a trivial task.</p><p>There are obvious human only issues such as emotions and belief in a god(s) of no interest to a machine. Such belief things are usually related to a persons experience of life (unless AI is alive). I find it interesting that some atheists and Christians resort to AI when debating ultimate causality.</p><p>With so many suspect training sources for HI, it is not surprising that our society has become so polarised. Is it time for training sources (including AI) to be more heavily scrutinised? Even the innocuous adds on TV, etc. are a form of training manipulation. Honesty in advertising has always been buyer beware and this now applies to all information sources. The issue has always been who determines what is honest and suitable.</p><p>All … are … is an annoying feature of social media by people with an axe to grind. Is AI also capable of such generalisations without deliberate human direction? Is it reasonable to expect AI to call out useless generalisations as well as fallacious arguments? One does not need to take sides to call out defective human reasoning. One recent story declared the term “but not all men” redundant because of the Cornell fraternity incident. This was very emotive but flawed as “all men” was equated to a group of USA elite white males — just as fallacious as Incel males describing “all women”. That story had a very important point of “being silent is being complicit” but this was secondary and not likely read by men who should. Is it also reasonable to expect AI to call out “click bait” rather than create it?</p><p>Large corporations have a terrible record in the use of misinformation for profits, yet large corporations are leading the AI push. Democracies are becoming ideology battlegrounds with misinformation being the norm. Information quality varies depending on who wins elections (spends the most on advertising). In the information age there is no single body trusted by all to name misinformation. In countries where governments control information, misinformation is anything that is adverse to the government (like China and Tiananmen Square or the USA and Epstein files). Can AI challenge this status quo?</p><p>Medium has a lot of stories limiting AI expectations to writing computer code. Yes there is great potential to eliminate the need for programmers and speed up software development, but this does nothing to alleviate humanity’s current mess. Nothing changes by getting rid of repetitive jobs and only leaving room for entrepreneurs. A criminal is just a particular category of entrepreneur which becomes more attractive if there are no other openings. AI has the potential of expanding HI and not just making people redundant.</p><p>The defining issue is who to trust in setting expectations for AI. The current USA administration delegates this to oligarchs developing it for profit, so expectations are very limited. I am not suggesting for everyone adopt my science friendly perspective but to be rational and at a minimum accept my neural training as valid. Likewise, can I accept my neighbour’s alt-science perspective as valid?</p><p>AI has the potential to bridge diametrically opposed HI views. Is AI to be just a continuation of our current polarised world and individual biases? Ask your favourite AI my questions and compare answers to those above. Is there consistency between the various AI clients?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=39f930b48504" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Unfathomable People]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@comp.keith55/unfathomable-people-8c2ab1dd6b73?source=rss-00686345896c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8c2ab1dd6b73</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[knowledge]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[human-behavior]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[artificial-intelligence]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Robert]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 29 Sep 2026 11:29:31 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-29T11:29:31.620Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I know human thought is diverse, but regardless of background (left, right, woke, alt-science, etc.) there are some people I just cannot fathom. I do not expect others to share my thinking (Myers-Briggs INFP; Enneagram type 1 perfectionist with a 2 helper wing; dyslexic with verbal memory marginally above brain damaged, kinaesthetic primary modality) but what I am writing about probably has more to do with emotion rather than logic.</p><p>My brother-in-law (my older sister’s husband) is a person I cannot fathom. One example of “unfathomable” happened last Christmas lunch at my sister’s with family and various in-laws — more than 20 people of various ages. Before going to the gathering I had read that buses replaced trains over Christmas to enable major track work. I repeated this at lunch. My brother-in-law, who was not part of the conversation, joins in and publicly calls me a liar. “No company would pay the overtime for construction to take place on Christmas Day”. He did not check the Translink website but needed to publicly attack me on a throwaway line I read!</p><p>I am a technical person who prefers historical stuff to novels and poetry. I keep myself informed and avoid social media biases. My experience covers a lot of industries due to my 50 year IT career. I have dealt with people ranging from factory hands to executive level, so I always talk in shades if grey. My accountant brother-in-law lives in a black and white world and has all of the answers, so he probably finds my shades of grey annoying.</p><p>Admittedly there is prior history. Years ago and before the Queensland Fitzgerald Enquiry of 1987 revealed the extent of State Government corruption (the “Joh” era), I mentioning my first hand experience of corruption at a family gathering. Both my older sister and her husband became very upset accusing me of lying and started yelling when I stuck my ground. Both the police and local media were involved, so many were unaware and I should not have made a corruption throw-away line in the first place. Joh was their champion and could do no wrong. I became aware that there were certain topics to be avoided with both of them.</p><p>A technical person can be annoying. I am not a scientist but completed tertiary maths, physics, statistics and chemistry subjects as part of my computing degree. My familiarity with basic scientific stuff has been very handy for operational IT projects. In the 1980’s when CFC’s were being banned, my brother-in-law and his brother were anti-action believing air conditioners and fridges would fail without Freon. My don’t care attitude “it is only a heat pump” was ridiculed. Maybe he does find me annoying, but why call me dishonest? I would never call someone a liar without proof.</p><p>There are other people I cannot fathom and like the brother-in-law, I just bite my tongue and ignore for harmony. The net effect is to kill meaningful discussion. Even weather is not discussed with my brother-in-law as he considers the Bureau of Meteorology to be useless (they predict a 10% chance of rain and it does not rain; common sense dictates that you don’t need rain radar — just look out the window). Luckily, only a minority of people I know are unfathomable. People I call friends do not necessarily have to share my perspective, but at least treat my opinions with respect and expect the same from me.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*bulgd8y5VPM7KWHh2p4fOw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Shutterstock</figcaption></figure><p>Some recent stories on AI have helped me to rethink unfathomable people. Large Language Models (LLM) of AI are neural networks modelled on how the human brain functions. These models are totally different to computers I have worked on. Previously computers of all sizes were Touring Machine (TM) variants — processing unit, memory and instructions. A LLM is a vast multi-layered network of pattern matching “neurons” acting independently and in parallel. The output of a TM comes from execution of instructions while the output of a LLM is the result of patterns matched by neurons and their interconnections. Each part of an AI computer used to emulate a single neuron operates in the classic TM way. The vast number of neurons and their interconnections is why so many GPUs (the fastest computers) are used. In simple terms “training” of AI creates patterns for neurons to match and their interconnections.</p><p>Why does this help me to rethink? I appreciate that only part of a human brain is being modelled, but AI is a very effective model of basic human reasoning - even to the extent that some assert it is “conscious”. I like to think I am a rational person who can logically assess shades of grey, but this may be an illusion as I am probably just a pattern matching neural network with interconnections and patterns encoded on my neurons. With appropriate training, the AI equivalent can be logical or output rubbish - AI can even hallucinate. My neural network established in the formative years is unique and does not stop training until brain failure (death, dementia or becoming a politician). LLMs emulate this approach.</p><p>My neural patterns include basic science such as leverage, kinetic energy, momentum, PVT constant, conservation of energy, etc.. Unfathomable people reject this basic stuff and rubbish my opinion if it contradicts their alternate perspective (training). Formulas and experiments confirming basic stuff has no impact if those patterns are not part of training. I have lost track of the number of times people have suggested connecting a generator to EV wheels to remove the need for battery charging. I am not talking about state-of-art science but simple stuff, for example, heat pump refrigeration working without Freon - just adjust pressure and design.</p><p>The application of statistics is also a neural pattern. My statistics training is basic, so I am limited to discussions with averages, mean deviations and standard deviations. The only way to manipulate basic stats is to use selective or dodgy data, yet unfathomable people assert “statistics can be used to prove anything” and negate anything statistical I mention.</p><p>Reducing crime is an example of statistics V common sense. One could compare statistics on various approaches. From my reading (neural training) the Scandinavian approach focusing on rehabilitation is the most effective. It significantly reduces crime and re-offending rates. In contrast, the USA use of penalties and punishment has little impact. The USA has capital punishment, a large number of people in jail, lots of guns and a major crime problem. For many there is only one common sense solution - increase penalties as criminals will be discouraged.</p><p>Is it possible for humans to be rational when reasoning is based on neural pattern matching? Reasoning is limited to what is etched onto a human’s neural network. This determines what information is included or rejected and this in turn reinforces patterns already in place. Discussion is limited to neural training common to both parties unless either party “retrains” to include new information or trusts the information provided by the other (their expertise is respected and acknowledged). My shades-of-grey have always been at odds with my brother-in-law’s common sense, so we get on well if we avoid meaningful discussion.</p><p>Obvious human “training” sources in the information age are parents, family, community, school, games, TV, social media, publications, news sources, AI summaries, religions, influencers, public figures, and any source considered authoritative. There is no assessment of suitability for training with the usual criteria being availability, entertainment value and alignment with existing views.</p><p>The developed world has had a major shift in training sources. Training via parents, family and community is becoming less with people more isolated and with both parents likely working and/or separated. This source is from the perspective of parents, family and community. School training is to equip people with the skills for work and not necessarily to encourage critical thinking. Religion and its training are also closely linked to family and schooling. Fundamental belief gets firmly entrenched in neurons.</p><p>Today many news outlets, internet influencers, social media companies, think tanks, etc. have vested interests and deliberately manipulate to get ratings, satisfy owner bias and get more clicks. Training from these sources has inherent basis. Even what is reported and words used can be subtle and be deliberate manipulation, for example, describing a person as “rejecting an accusation” or “defending their action” affects people’s perception.</p><p>With questionable training sources, it is not surprising our society has become so polarised. Is it time for training sources to be more heavily scrutinised? Even the innocuous adds on TV, etc. are a form of training. Honesty in advertising is a lost cause with buyer beware being as relevant today as ever. The main issue is who determines what is suitable.</p><p>Prior to the last Queensland State election, local conservative media was running every story about youth crime (especially if there was a crying victim). Youth crime was presented as out of control despite statistics indicating otherwise. The slogan for the party that won was “adult crime — adult time” (incarcerate impressionable youth with hardened criminals to train their neurons in proper crime).</p><p>Queensland media had fabricated a need for urgent action on youth crime and the non-conservative governing party could only point to statistics, so the outcome was inevitable. Now the new State Government is spending millions on advertising cherry picked statistics to prove 12 months of jailing children is working. Statistics were previously ignored but are now being used for proof. If this is deliberate manipulation, how could this be averted and its impact neutralised? There is no authority accepted by all that could name deception and challenge public perception/training.</p><p>My brother-in-law is a fan of programs like a Current Affair and 60 Minutes. Vigilante type of programs acting as judge, jury, executioner and champion of a black and white world. No program is complete without a crying victim and a villain hounded by reporters. Even entire racial groups are targeted. Which is more important - ratings or justice. Some so-called villains have suicided as a direct result of being nationally disgraced. This training shows in my brother-in-law’s opinions. Currently there are no other TV shows for him to watch to challenge vigilantism.</p><p>Basic science is a neural pattern which varies between people. Even simple measurements such as increasing average global temperature are denied as thermometers globally and satellite measurements are a conspiracy. We are in a world only possible through scientific advances yet the majority of people do not have training to understand basic science; but, do they need to - especially in the future when AI provides all answers. Popular training at present includes far more alt-science than actual science.</p><p>Medicine is another area of polarised training with vaccines being a hot topic at present. Who to believe - anecdotal proof, influencers or medical research. I mentioned the benefits of double blind testing to a neighbour and he rubbished this as a ploy by big pharmaceuticals to prevent his favourite elixir from being acknowledged. There is an extremely wide variety of sources on anything medical — regardless of veracity.</p><p>What has been described so far is only basic stuff and not state-of-the-art science or medicine which is beyond my level of training. Contemporary discussions often reflect neural patterns of amateurs pushing a popular truth supported by common sense. Science only provides a process and a body of knowledge which is exceptionally technical - the end result is a currently accepted theory which can be falsified and never an absolute truth. The use of complex statistics is not understandable by most people (and myself) — who can be trusted to interpret?</p><p>As you probably gather, my neural network favours science over alt-science. My neural training includes basic science and while at uni I rubbed shoulders with scientists and potential scientists so I ignore claims of absolute knowledge, being a rebel or conspiracy. I am happy to admit that I am biased but I am also capable of questioning my bias. Alt-science influencers seem to start by trivialising scientists and usually produce volumes of text far beyond the comprehension of mere mortals. This immediately raises my suspicion.</p><p>This begs the question as to which person’s training is valid. Maybe my opinions should be ignored. The final arbiter is obviously long term outcomes, but as agreed by all parties. Such agreement may never happen for people with diametrically opposed neural training. My short term suggestion is to identify and stop sources of manipulation. Examples include the tobacco industry which downplayed cancer risks; the alcohol industry targeting young people; and the fossil fuel industry targeting renewables. Deliberate deception has been proven but they still provide training for human neurons. Fox News is a classic example.</p><p>My neural network questions everything. It is difficult to comprehend a thought process with absolute unquestionable truths and a universal common sense. To me it is common sense to question, but once again, this is part of my neural training. In the case of my brother-in-law, he is probably just an ar**hole.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8c2ab1dd6b73" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Have not laughed so much in years]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@comp.keith55/have-not-laughed-so-much-in-years-edb4fb9efc7d?source=rss-00686345896c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/edb4fb9efc7d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[humor]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trump]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[catholic]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pope]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[usa]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Robert]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 16 Apr 2026 05:40:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-04-16T05:40:15.610Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I had thought that TV comedy had declined to the point where a giggle box was needed to indicate when there was a joke, but then came the US verses Pope sit com. The Pope called Trump’s threats to destroy Iranian civilization “truly unacceptable”, and US Vice President JD Vance, a convert to Catholicism, stated that the pope should “be careful” when speaking about theology. I was rolling on the floor with laughter. A run of the mill Catholic was telling Christ’s representative on Earth to be careful about theology. Obviously JD was confusing himself with JC.</p><p>The Petulant Protestant(?) President also posted an image of himself as JC — the only person above the Pope, so both he and JD are well versed in the ridiculous. I was surprised that the post was deleted, but of course Trump has to live up to his TACO reputation. The humor continued with a Pentagon rep referring to the Avignon Papacy with the implied abduction/killing of the Pope using Blackhead helicopters after Vatican air defenses are destroyed. If there is a Mar-a-Lago Papacy, the Cardinals elected to the US Conclave will be Trump appointed. He always wanted to dress up in the Pope’s frock (earlier deleted post). Once again I was rolling on the floor with laughter.</p><p>Sorry about the typo above. My spellcheck automatically changes Blackhawk to Blackhead — did you notice the mistake?</p><p>Trump and Vance must secretly admire the Pope as their continued attack of his theology is putting a spotlight on what the pontiff says during his tour of Africa. Even agnostic non-practicing Catholics are coming out in support of the pontiff and this was enabled by the US reaction giving the Pope top billing. Was this a deliberate attempt by the US to use humor to reinforce Christ’s command to love God and neighbor with no restriction on who is a neighbor.</p><p>The US government has a dark sense of humor. Before bombing the shit out of Iran, they instigated peace talks and when an agreement seemed likely, they started bombing and included two girls schools as targets — how dark is that. The earlier Gaza ceasefire was also a joke — Israel still restricts the flow of Gaza aid/medical evacuations to a trickle (if you object to this please provide supporting stats) and continues to bomb Gaza. The current undeclared US war ceasefire was also a joke as the US ignored Lebanon and the bulldozing of the West Bank for Israel to gain more territory to defend. The complete lack of a consistent US strategy apart from confiscating oil is another reason to roll on the ground with laughter. Monte Python could not have written a better script.</p><p>At least the US has a sense of humor which of course does not apply to Israel. I fail to see any possible humor in genocide or an immediate death penalty for any Palestinian deemed to be a terrorist. It is funny though when people take offense at Israeli killings being labelled as genocide. If they wish to change the label to self-defense then let the International Criminal Court case proceed to clear the air. There is a prima facie case so it needs to proceed to remove doubt. Each time I see a reply on Medium which corrects the use of the word genocide, I chuckle as the excuse of self-defense is such a joke.</p><p>The current state of the world has me giggling almost hysterically. The once proud US democracy has morphed into a global thug run by clowns; an immanent climate disaster has once again been sidelined (maybe too late anyway); One Nation in Australia (a Trump clone) is becoming popular; Britain’s suppression of Gaza support; the rise of the far right in many countries; Milie in Argentina being propped up by billions of US dollars; etc.. The list is long and my incessant hysterical laughter is making people suspicious about my sanity.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xa-rr5amWW6pQ18qHN2Cgg.jpeg" /><figcaption>From Shutterstock (soon to be me)</figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=edb4fb9efc7d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Tale of Two Sisters]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@comp.keith55/a-tale-of-two-sisters-04ec0b355a15?source=rss-00686345896c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/04ec0b355a15</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[venus]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[geology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[planet-earth]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[climate-change]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Robert]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 11 Dec 2025 03:01:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-12-11T03:01:44.156Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>When I grew up in the 1960’s Venus was my favourite and a planet of mystery. Even with powerful telescopes, Venus remained elusive as its surface was completely obscured by dense white cloud. The surface of Mars in contrast could be seen despite being twice as far. Earth too has clouds, but these do not hide its watery blue surface. Spectral analysis of reflected light from Venus revealed an Earth like elemental composition. Venus is our closest neighbour, similar in size and the most Earth like terrestrial planet. This gave Venus the best prospect of having Earth like life. Auntie Venus and Mother Earth were similar enough to be called ‘sister planets’ — until the USSR spoiled the illusion.</p><p>The Evening/Morning Star has always been special to civilisations. Initially she was a creature of the night sky and in the last 400 years became a sister planet to Earth. The first probe landing on Venus exposed Auntie’s dark secret — it was crushed by the Venusian atmosphere. The expectation was for Earth like conditions and not a surface temperature above 460 Celsius with an atmospheric pressure 92 times that of Earth. The Russian probe Venera 4 was the first to survive and confirm Venus as a femme fatale. Later surface pictures showed nothing but dry barren rock devoid of soil. As sisters they are certainly not identical twins.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*dswBH7yQLXV1YTdetmrgxQ.png" /><figcaption>Venus surface panorama from Venera 9 — Russian Academy of Sciences / Ted Stryk</figcaption></figure><h3>The sisters as we know them now</h3><p>The clouds of Earth are water vapour, while those of Venus are sulphur dioxide and sulphuric acid. Earth’s atmosphere is 78.08% nitrogen, 20.95% oxygen, 0.93% argon and 0.04% carbon dioxide while Venus’ atmosphere is 96.5% carbon dioxide and 3.5% nitrogen.</p><p>The 1967 Venera 4 mission confirmed a surface temperature above 460°C and uniformly hot everywhere — at the poles and on the dark side. Venus’ average surface temperature is more than double that of Mercury which is the planet closest to the Sun and receives four times the Sun’s energy.</p><p>All planets except Venus are much hotter on the side facing the Sun (Mercury has a -140°C minimum dark side temperature). Venus’ unusually uniform hot surface was explained by the 19th century discovery of carbon dioxide’s ability to trap heat like a greenhouse. Carbon dioxide is also a heavy gas and this explains the surface pressure. Venus’s atmosphere is so extreme that carbon dioxide near the surface behaves as a supercritical fluid giving it properties of both a liquid and a gas.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/650/1*lxzUwO7VVVWEBgkpJNgsjQ.png" /><figcaption>The two sisters (from Wikipedia)</figcaption></figure><p>Space missions have identified many other differences. Both have molten interiors, but only Earth has convection currents generating magnetism. Without a strong magnetic field, Venus looses lighter elements to the solar wind — any surface water would have boiled and been blown away by the solar wind. There is no evidence of moving tectonic plates.</p><p>Both sisters are middle aged. At birth out of stellar material, Earth and Venus would have been identical twins. Venus at middle age has reached a hot steady state and probably will not change much as it gets older. Earth on the other hand has remained cool and youthful due to a biosphere (the sum total of all organic life) and regular ice age facelifts. If regular facelifts ceased, then Earth would begin to resemble Venus. In old age as the Sun transforms into a helium fuelled red giant, Earth’s oceans boil, its ozone layer vanishes, and the blue rinse of Earth becomes the white of Venus.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/697/1*RX2e2YjUhIV1T1IaCwrX0Q.png" /><figcaption>Major differences highlighted in green</figcaption></figure><h3>The sisters in human history</h3><p>From our contemporary setting, it is difficult to imagine belief in a flat Earth, but this was the starting point of human understanding. The horizon is curved, so the big flat disk must be in a huge dome providing plumbing for rain and hosting day and night skies.</p><p>The ancients when looking at the night sky saw a vast moving backdrop of stars. This backdrop was moving and alive. The nighttime vista was a regal procession of stars in fixed formation with interlopers such as comets, planets and the moon. Each speck of light was a creature of the dome with interlopers (planets, comets and meteors) being special.</p><h4>A flat sister and a schizophrenic bright light</h4><p>On a flat Earth, the two sisters could not be further apart. Earth was a big flat disk under a dome. Venus was a sky creature living in the dome and was bipolar. It was two beings — morning and evening stars. Both were very special as they were bright but shy as neither rose to a prominent place in the heavens — both loosers really. For some Venus was the goddess of love (maybe disappearing early for sex).</p><p>The ancient Greeks initially had Venus as two separate gods Phosphorus, the morning star, and Hesperus, the evening star. They later realised it was one being but still kept the stories. The ancient Romans designated the morning Venus as Lucifer, and the evening one as Vesper. There are an enormous number of stories across all cultures on Venus. Romanised Christians remodelled Lucifer as being the devil (there is no concept of a devil in Judaism and their Satan is the ‘accuser’ making one think). Earth’s poor sister was two celestial beings with one eternally punished.</p><h4>Big sister with attitude</h4><p>What happens when you discover the flat Earth is actually a big ball? The obvious is for the dome to become a sphere with Earth in the middle. Ancient Greeks did this and also correctly calculated its diameter. Earth was surrounded by crystal spheres which lasted until the spheres were broken when science moved the Sun to the centre. There was resistance when this happened as Earth was created for the benefit of man. Before Mendel and genetics, even women were for the benefit of man.</p><p>The last European version of this model had multiple concentric crystal spheres with each planet, Sun and Moon having its own sphere. Planets were confined to their sphere and followed a definite complex path. Only the Sun and Moon had simple sphere orbits (the Moon does indeed orbit the Earth while the Earth orbits the Sun). Intelligent design people of this era pointed to these complex orbits as evidence for God. Today we know the complex planet dances were the result of putting the wrong thing at centre. Put the Sun there and planets have simple gravitational orbits.</p><p>In the geocentric world view, Earth was the one and only with all other celestial objects being things orbiting earth or dancing on crystal spheres under a backdrop of stars. Once again auntie Venus was the poor sister considered small and insignificant. She was a light source imprisoned in a crystal sphere performing an endless dance.</p><h4>Little sister with big influence</h4><p>Both the flat and geocentric earth models had a backdrop of stars, planets, etc.. Under astrology star constellations and wandering stars were celestial beings and had special powers over mortals. Capricorn, Sagittarius, Taurus and the other signs of the Zodiac were very real beings on a nightly journey that repeated every year. The ancients calculated the destiny of individuals based on position and movement of these beings. In Astrology what we do is determined by the constellation closest to the Sun when we are born and the position of planets and moon in relation to this constellation.</p><p>Astrology is geocentric, so the position of Earth in relation to the Sun has no bearing on personality. This is a complete transposition of roles for sister planets as the proximity of Venus to your birth constellation directly impacts your personality and future events, so Venus is more important than Earth or the Sun. Venus is twice as powerful as other planets as morning and evening stars are two astrological beings. As Venus orbits faster, Earth is overtaken by Venus every 584 days and morphs from the Evening star to the ‘Morning star’.</p><h4>Finally revealed</h4><p>The real place of Earth was eventually revealed. Accurate observations by Tycho Brahe found comets to be traversing through crystal spheres. This was not possible as comets were supposed to be below them. This and many more discoveries (some in secret) slowly dismantled Earth’s ego — even Christianity and creationists had to eventually agree that the Sun was at the centre. The dismantling of Aristotle’s world order coincided with many other challenges to the status quo. The old order was under siege and reacted on many fronts, but change was unstoppable.</p><p>The vista opened up by telescopes is truly amazing. The world was no longer the one and only — all of the planets were worlds. The solar system was at first thought to be the one and only, but it too was one of many suns in a collection of suns called a galaxy. Our galaxy is also now one of many in a cluster of galaxies. There are an enormous number of galaxy clusters. We know creation to be inconceivably large and expanding. The limiting factor has always been our need to be unique.</p><p>The ego of sister Earth has been drastically reduced over the last five hundred years. She has gone from being the “one and only” to a tiny spec in an insignificant solar system. If all nations with atomic weapons detonated all ordinances, the flash would only be noticed in our solar system, barely detectable to near-by solar systems and a non-event elsewhere. Venus has gone from a heavenly light to a planet of similar significance to Earth.</p><h3>A contemporary tale</h3><p>Our understanding of both sisters is closely tied to reports in the media — especially Earth’s climate change debate. As extreme temperatures on Venus are attributed to a run-away greenhouse effect, anyone bagging the greenhouse effect on Earth is doing likewise for Earth’s sister. Maybe Venusian temperatures are also a conspiracy. Venus’ atmosphere has 96.5% carbon dioxide and a uniform average surface temperature above 460°C. Earth’s atmosphere has 0.04% carbon dioxide and an approximate average surface temperature of 15°C (temperatures range from -90 to +60°C).</p><p>Earth’s atmospheric carbon dioxide is now 50 percent higher than it was before the Industrial Revolution and is increasing about 100 times faster than any time in the past, so there are significant issues involved. What I am attempting to do is to ignore this noise and to compare the life of both planets since birth. To make pretty pictures, I created a spreadsheet with coarse data for both and produced date range specific charts.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*bcRSBhUeHPWBfrFZQhhpjw.png" /><figcaption>Fig. 1: Venus (red line) and Earth (blue line) temperature with a common 2.4 billion year history</figcaption></figure><p>The above graph is mainly one of Earth with the red line added. As seen by the concentration of blue and orange dots on the right, our detailed knowledge of Earth’s history is limited to the last 800 million years. With the Magellan mapping of Venus, we have a detailed history little sister for the last 300–600 million years (since its entire surface melted)— 4 craters over 110km, 643 craters over 10 km and a lot of volcanic activity.</p><p>How does Venus’s impact history compare with Earth? To answer this I looked to the Moon which does not have oceans, erosion or tectonic plates. The Lunar Copernican period (1.1 billion years) had 575 craters over 10 km, so considering Moon’s size, both sisters had a similar number of impacts.</p><p>The X axis of my graph is labelled “Equivalent Average Polar Temperature” as this was the X axis of the main source I used. I have attempted to adjust other graphs to maintain trends where data overlaps. The graph is a visual aid and not an analytical tool. The X axis will be about 10°C below the global average. This does not matter for Venus as it is uniformly hot.</p><h3>A tale for auntie Venus (little sister)</h3><p>Our history of Venus is limited to the resurfacing event of 300–600 million years ago when its entire surface was hot enough to melt rocks. This erased all surface features. I have assumed that Venus and Earth both initially cooled to become terrestrial planets with a methane rich atmosphere. As the current Venusian atmosphere is mainly carbon dioxide, there should have been an initial common mechanism to convert methane and this more than likely would include a rudimentary biosphere. My graph is my best guess as to Venusian history. The first Ice Ball Earth is a logical place to deviate as Earth’s biosphere evolved to regulate temperature.</p><p>Events if sisters were twins for 2 two billion years (in billions of years ago):<br> • 4.4 — cooling of newly formed planet and formation of first rocks<br> • 4.2 — microbe evolution to decompose methane and produce oxygen <br> • reduced volcanic activity for 250 million years<br> • 3.9 — gradual carbon dioxide build up (a biosphere did not evolve)<br> • increase in temperatures and pressure till current levels are reached<br> • 0.3 to 0.6 — resurfacing event melting and erasing all surface features<br> • 0 — status quo of conditions with potential future resurfacing events.</p><p>Venus was finally mapped in detail by Project Magellan in 1990–91 by using infrared imagery. The ground shows evidence of extensive volcanism, and sulphur in the atmosphere may indicate recent eruptions. The Venusian surface is mostly covered by flat volcanic plains. Two highland ‘continents’ make up the remaining surface area, one lying in the planet’s north and the other just south of the equator. In much earlier cooler days, the plains may have been oceans with water.</p><p>Much of the Venusian surface appears to have been shaped by volcanic activity. Venus has several times as many known volcanoes as Earth. It possesses some 167 large volcanoes over 100 km across. Earth only has the Big Island of Hawaii as the only volcanic complex of this size. Venus is not necessarily more volcanically active as since resurfacing ancient volcanoes are preserved. Earth is geologically much more dynamic.</p><p>There is no rainfall on the surface of Venus (although it does rain sulphuric acid in the upper atmosphere). Above the carbon dioxide layer are clouds of sulphur dioxide and sulphuric acid which reflect and scatter visible light. Despite being closer to the Sun, its surface gets much less light than Earth.</p><p>Venusian craters range from 3 km to 280 km in diameter. There are no craters smaller than 3 km due to a dense atmosphere (objects are slowed by the atmosphere and only large ones make a crater). With the surface being pristine with no small craters, the Venusian atmosphere must have been unchanged since resurfacing.</p><p>As carbon dioxide is much heavier than oxygen or nitrogen, the Venusian surface pressure is equivalent to a depth of a kilometre under Earth’s oceans. An astronaut would need a diving bell and not just a space suit. With an average surface temperature of over 460°C (690°K), whatever water was present on Venus has turned into water vapour and photo-dissociated into free elements. Hydrogen being swept away by the solar wind with plenty of oxygen left for more carbon dioxide.</p><p>The first ultraviolet observations in the 1920s produced considerable detail that was absent in visible and infrared radiation. Frank E. Ross suggested that visible light was blocked by a very dense yellow lower atmosphere with high cirrus clouds (clouds of ice crystals). Radar observations in the 1970s outlined the Venusian surface for the first time. Pulses of radio waves identified two highly reflective regions called the Alpha and Beta regions.</p><p>Successful Inter planetary craft missions have revealed much more with sixteen USSR missions, nine USA missions and missions by the European Space Agency and Japan. The cost has been high with eighteen missions or fly-by attempts failing. The Mariner 2 mission in 1962 became the world’s first successful interplanetary mission, passing 34,833 km above the surface of Venus. Microwave and infrared instruments revealed cool Venusian cloud tops and an extremely hot surface. This finally ended any hopes that the planet might harbour ground-based life.</p><p>Mariner 2 was also unable to detect either a magnetic field or radiation belts. Later missions detected a weak magnetic field generated by solar wind contact. Earth has a strong internally generated magnetic field and this is necessary for the radiation belts. Without this, Venus has no protection against the solar wind and its radiation. Lighter elements in the upper atmosphere are being continually eroded by the solar wind.</p><p>The Venusian day is longer than its year (one orbit) and it is rotating in the reverse direction to other terrestrial planets. This difference is attributed to a collision with another planet sized object (possibly Mercury) some time before the resurfacing event. The collision may have contributed to current surface temperatures but the only evidence so far is its abnormal spin. The next probe to Venus is attempting to determine if Venus has always been hot or was once like Earth as I have assumed.</p><p>An ancient name for Venus was Lucifer and this has Christian associations with the devil. It is ironical given our knowledge of Venus, its surface would make it an ideal Hell, so maybe there is a real connection with the devil — a home away from home or holiday destination maybe.</p><h3>A tale for mother Earth (big sister)</h3><p>Earth without the moon formed from the gravitational collapse of a giant molecular cloud 4.568 billion years ago. The Earth’s Moon is the result of a collision with a Mars sized planet (planet mergers and re-arrangements are common in young solar systems). Evidence for the collision comes from Moon rocks collected by the Apollo Mission.</p><p>Earth’s geological history is the basis for my graph. Accuracy depends on age and the samples used, for example, the most detailed and accurate history is recorded in ice core samples but this only applies to the current 2.6 million year ice age as all permanent ice melts between ice ages. The next level of accuracy is mudstone (ocean sediments) but is more coarse than ice cores. Data for my graph comes from overlapping sources. Fossil oxygen isotope measurements span 65 million years, deep sea sediment mudstones span 5.5 million years and ice cores go back 1 million years.</p><p>When I started writing I expected Earth’s history to be clear cut, but surprisingly its history is not as exacting as the Moon or Venus. When Earth’s tectonic plates move, leading edges get re-absorbed and new rocks are formed at trailing edges. Even though speed is measured in cm per year, the average age of tectonic rocks is 100 million years with the oldest rocks of 4.4. billion years being found on the slowest moving pates such as Australia. Much of Earth’s history has been obscured by plate movement, erosion and 75% of its surface being ocean. The Moon, in contrast, has a record of every impact or volcanic eruption over the last 4 billion years (Pre-Nectarian, Nectarian, Imbrian, Eratosthenian and Copernicansince lunar periods). Venus also has a pristine surface history, but only since its resurfacing event when all rocks melted.</p><p>This vagueness becomes apparent when comparing our known history with other worlds. Venus has several times as many known volcanoes as Earth, but both sisters are expected to have the same level of volcanic activity. This difference is not surprising considering Earth’s erosion, moving tectonic plates and oceans.</p><p>Due to the closeness of the sisters, one would also expect the number of external body impacts to be similar. The Moon over its 4.4 billion year history has 1,547 impact craters over 10 km in diameter. Venus has had 634 since resurfacing and we only know of 43 on Earth. From this, unless the Moon and Venus are exceptionally unlucky, less than 10% of Earth’s craters are known. The larger the creator size, the closer the count. For craters over 110km in the last 450 million years, Earth has had 2 and Venus 4.</p><p>Earth’s history is still being unearthed. It has been proposed that there is a crater more than 400km in diameter under the Wilkes ice shelf. This has raised the possibility of an impact shock wave causing the Siberian Traps on the opposite side of the globe. The Traps’ lava flow was from surface cracks (not from volcanoes), covered an area the size of Europe, lasted one million years and is up to one kilometre thick. This possibility will be confirmed when the Wilkes ice shelf melts, but humans may be extinct by then. I included this potential impact in my data to fill a gap in a graph.</p><p>Earth’s evolution is dependent on moving tectonic plates, vulcanism, multiple catastrophes and a biosphere of all living things. Geological history is broken up into eras, periods, sub-periods and epochs and these are included in my graphs where possible. The naming of eras, etc. has evolved as globally distributed geological strata are identified. Global catastrophes are important in writing Earth’s history as their distinctive deposits are used to align and date strata.</p><p>Earth’s tectonic plates are quite mobile. There was a single original super continent continent which has split and rejoined several times. We know of supercontinents Pangaea (300 million years), Rodinia (1 billion years) and Ur (3 billion years). This movement creates features unique to Earth, for example, the mantle has hotspots where volcanoes form and will create a line of volcanoes on a tectonic plate that moves across the hot spot.</p><p>In the context of the two sisters, Earth has remained at a consistently low temperature from the first ice age right through to the present. This is attributed to the biosphere’s ability to regulate gases involved in the carbon cycle. The first Ice Ball Earth resulted from an overproduction of oxygen. Biosphere regulation improved as cellular life evolved but has and is still affected by sudden change due to vulcanism and/or meteor impacts.</p><p>Cretaceous Thermal Optimum (CTM) is an example where a period of climatic warming reached its peak approximately 90 million years ago (during the Turonian age of the Late Cretaceous epoch) when biosphere activity restored a temperature balance. The CTM is notable for a dramatic increase in global temperatures characterised by carbon dioxide levels four times the pre-industrial level of 280 ppm (1% compared to Venus’ 96%). This was enough for an average global temperature increase of 15°C — ten times more than our current 1.5°C increase . A Medium story by Sílvia Pineda-Munoz describes the discovery of a CTM Antarctic rainforest.</p><p>The history of the biosphere is interwoven with plate movement and re-combinations. Plates only cover 25% of Earth’s surface but fragmentation and location directly impact conditions for life, for example, the centre of a super continent would be very dry due to its distance from oceans.</p><p>Average temperature means a lot to humans as we can only tolerate a narrow range of temperature. Earth’s history mainly covers a range from an ice ball earth to a completely ice free and hot but biosphere friendly world. The graphs I am using have Earth’s temperature averages as at the polar oceans (Vostok), so global average temperatures would be more. The graphs are only intended to be indicative.</p><p>Earth’s history for the first 4 billion years is boring till multicellular life evolved with gene mixing via sexual reproduction. This is the Cambrian ‘explosion’ which kick started biosphere evolution as we know it today.</p><h4>Biosphere explosion</h4><p>The following graph shows the last 450 million years of Earth. Venus (the red line) does not appear as nothing much happened there. The craters shown are the ones on earth over 50km in diameter (the earlier graph only had craters over 110km in diameter). Earth has 10 known craters over this time frame, while Venus had 58.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*RDrLTVO6z6zajFt812_MsA.png" /><figcaption>Fig. 2: Earth (blue line) Phanerozoic Eon history and temperatures</figcaption></figure><p>The extreme right hand end of the blue line has a green highlight. This is the part of the graph covered by ice and deep sea sediment cores. The remainder of this graph is obtained from fossils and isotopes. The blue line in the previous graph prior to 450 million years is a fudge — we know when the ice ages were, so these are cold and the period in between is warm and that is all that this graph shows. In my timeline of Earth’s history we have 6.5 million years of accurate detailed data, 450 million years of reasonably accurate data and 4 billion years of best guess data.</p><p>This period is marked by rapid evolutionary change, temperature extremes and mass extinction events. There were five mass extinctions removing over half of all species. The Permian-Triassic extinction killed 90% of all species and took 30 million years for the biosphere to recover. The last mass extinction led to the demise of dinosaurs and coincided with a large meteorite impact 65 million years ago. There is no definitive evidence of impacts leading to the three other major mass extinctions, but with the large number of missing craters, an impact event is still possible. Typically an event triggers sudden biosphere change.</p><p>Event reaction varies. The Devonian extinction was a time of extremes where the oceans lost oxygen and most greenhouse gas producing sea organisms died, so this resulted in a downward temperature trend. The extinctions that begin the Triassic killed 90% of all species and changed the direction of temperature change to a downward trend despite a massive increase in volcanic activity. The extinction event of the Palaeocene Epoch wiped out dinosaurs, but also started an upward change in temperatures.</p><p>Human expansion is the latest event. The biosphere will evolve to include the ever increasing foot print of humans. There is evidence of a rapidly changing balance. Recent history includes a growing list of extinct spices and a rate of temperature change similar to that of extinction events. Since 1980, glacial retreat has become increasingly rapid with some glaciers disappearing altogether. Most permanent ice shelves have melted with permanent ice cover being much less than any point in human history. In recent times, large sections of Antarctic Ice Shelves have broken away. All animals depending on ice shelves are now in danger of extinction, for example, polar bears, emperor penguins and whales that feed on krill. Extinction includes spices directly impacted by expansion and pollution.</p><p>From humanity’s perspective, Earth is in a steady state but we are short term residents that do not notice subtle longer term variations. Conditions on Earth have always been a balance between many interacting systems with the biosphere being the most complex and effective. Earth’s long term history has not revealed any period where the Earth and its biosphere are perfectly balanced and in a steady state. The history so far has been one of change and evolution.</p><p>To put time scales into perspective: our species first appeared during the last interglacial over 100 thousand years ago, so we have only existed for 2 glaciation cycles of a 2.6 million year ice age (40 glaciation cycles) on a planet that is 4.6 billion years old. The Cambrian explosion of life began 520 million years ago and the first forms of life appeared 3.8 billion years ago. Dinosaurs roamed the globe for 160 million years while humans have been roaming for 100 thousand years and been ‘civilised’ for much less.</p><p>Significant past biosphere events (millions of years ago):<br> • 2.6 — current Quaternary Ice Age started<br> • 65 — Dinosaurs became extinct<br> • 147 — first birds appeared<br> • 231 — first dinosaurs appeared<br> • 318 — first reptiles appeared<br> • 392 — first land insects appeared<br> • 520 — first plants appeared (Cambrian explosion of life)<br> • 646 — first multi-cellular organisms appeared<br> • 1300 — first symbiotic organisms appeared<br> • 1630 — first blue-green algae appeared<br> • 2100 — first multi-cellular life appears<br> • 3800 — oldest form of life appears</p><p>In my first graph, the turning point for Big Sister was the evolution of life and the development of a biosphere to regulate greenhouse gases and temperature. The biosphere terraforming of the planet began 3.8 billion years ago, got into high gear after the first ice age and really blossomed in the last 450 million years. As can be seen from the graph of the last 450 million years, the history of planet Earth has been quite chaotic. This period has been the richest as far as diversity of life. The chaos continues.</p><h4>Thoroughly modern Earth</h4><p>With the current focus on temperature and greenhouse gas, temperatures and concentrations are now being closely monitored. Biosphere action is now evident in yearly global greenhouse gas variability. There is an annual fluctuation of about 3–9 ppm which follows the Northern Hemisphere’s growing season. This Hemisphere has much greater land area and plant biomass, so absorbs more greenhouse gas than the Southern Hemisphere.</p><p>Regardless of the origin, temperatures are currently heading to levels not seen in millions of years. Unlike prior epochs, the ability of the biosphere to respond has been substantially reduced by human activity — Siberian and Brazilian forests are being cleared at a rate which will result in the almost total destruction of both. There are many natural carbon stores on the verge of releasing a quantity of greenhouse gas dwarfing human output and making human action futile.</p><p>If human action fails to maintain a temperature status quo, the biosphere will continue to evolve — even if temperatures reach those of the Pangaean deserts. The Earth can recover its cool. It only took a million years for the Arctic to develop permanent ice. The current question for Earth is what event will alter the biosphere balance to stop the upward trend. In the past such events have been by evolution or extinction.</p><p>Our modern Earth is being monitored in exquisite detail. Regardless of outcome, there will be no need for analysis of strata, mudstone or ice cores as we have real time information to add to our history of Earth.</p><h4>The unnatural cycle</h4><p>Have you picked a cycle in any of my graphs so far? Several commentators refer to the current increase in global temperatures as a ‘natural cycle’ with no need for action. The following Antarctic ice core graph is probably what they are referencing and there seems to be some form of cycle happening. This appears in my graphs as the tiny right almost most vertical line below zero as the time frame is so small (and I did not enter all glacial cycles). Over the life of the Earth, there are no cycles but reactions to events.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*lh97C0KBgj1phIV1VDkooQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>(From Wikipedia)</figcaption></figure><p>The ice core data above has a reasonably close correlation between temperature and carbon dioxide. At time zero in the graph there is a major deviation not included — the carbon dioxide concentration in 2024 is 422.8 parts per million by volume and 150ppm above the last data point on this graph — well above this picture, so definitely the start of something new and not just another cycle. If the observed correlation holds, this 40% increase equates to a 7°C average temperature rise. The increase so far since the industrial revolution has been about 1.5°C. There is no reason for average surface temperatures NOT to increase by another 5.5°C over time as this is well within temperatures experienced in Earth’s history.</p><p>Glaciation cycles of the current ice age are also reactions to an event. Earth’s orbit and tilt both wobble a little bit affecting energy received from the Sun as documented by Milutin Milanković. Major turning points for glacier advance align with Milankovic Cycles. Ice cores confirm this correlation of temperature, greenhouse gases and Sun intensity — except for our current interglacial. Temperatures are still increasing despite the Sun’s intensity having peaked and is now decreasing.</p><p>In the current Ice Age, interglacials result in increased rain forest coverage. At interglacial peak, greenhouse gas consumption exceeds production, concentrations start to decline and glaciers advance with rainforests being the last to be affected. The same thing happened during the Carboniferous period when rainforests created what became our coal seams reducing greenhouse gas concentrations and temperature. Human activity destroys rain forests and this goes against a typical glaciation cycle. Earth’s history is entering a new phase — we will know if it is a cycle in 100 thousand years.</p><h3>Twins once more</h3><p>The two sisters at present are the extremes of naturally high temperature and low temperature due to Earth’s carbon balancing biosphere. Apart from a belief in a geocentric creation, there is no real distinction between sisters. Venus demonstrates extreme warming on a planetary scale due to carbon dioxide and now her sister has increasing carbon dioxide and methane. The question is one of gas concentration and not the warming properties of carbon dioxide or an imaginary natural cycle. Earth is at a temperature where feedback from failing carbon sinks is starting to make temperature change exponential with human action useless.</p><p>When a catastrophe alters biosphere balance, greenhouse gas change lags the impact to the biosphere. This is different to volcanic activity and the current situation where greenhouse gas change leads biosphere change. As with the many past examples, once the balance changes it continues for millions of years or until the next catastrophe.</p><p>It is quite clear that humanity has affected the biosphere in many ways. The mix of grazing, city and forest lands is determined by the needs of McDonald’s, miners and multinationals — not the needs of mother Earth. Our thirst for energy has also put pressure on the biosphere. As with other mass extinction events in Earth’s pre-human history, the prospect of a climate change disaster is inevitable without action.</p><p>I am a natural cynic and assume it is too late for human action. Insufficient action will lead to high temperatures as happened several times in Earth’s history. Once such an increase starts then it is only stopped by either some evolutionary change or another catastrophe. With the damage caused by humans, my expectation is for the rate of change to be too great for evolution and catastrophes are not common for old planets, so Earth’s temperatures will keep increasing and it will terraform into a twin sister of Venus. Vegetation Ignition can occur at surface temperatures as low as 300 °C and once reached, there is no return and the sisters will remain as twins till consumed by the Sun.</p><p>My final graph is this scenario and spans from before the Sun ignited when our solar system was a cloud of gas till both sisters are consumed by a red giant Sun. What is striking is how small the temperature variations have been on Earth over the last 3.8 billion years and how similar the sisters could be at roast. The new transition slope is 0.0005°C per 1,000 years and we are now achieving 1°C per 100 years, so it is feasible even if humanity is extinct or moves elsewhere (and starts consuming again like locusts).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*1FwGt2j8Jghz0o7SvvpfGw.png" /><figcaption>Fig. 4: Venus (red line) and Earth (blue line) from absolute zero to become twins before Roast</figcaption></figure><p>If Earth became hot enough for a resurfacing event, all evidence of a biosphere and our civilisations will be erased. All my three graphs are from the same home made data set — only start and end times were changed.<br>The information used in this story has been obtained from commonly available sources such as NASA and Wikipedia. This story has been my interpretation and should be treated as a pessimistic opinion.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=04ec0b355a15" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Science: Space-time Daydreaming]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@comp.keith55/science-space-time-daydreaming-c07f2e6305c7?source=rss-00686345896c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c07f2e6305c7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[subatomic-physics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[black-holes]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[particle-photon]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science-fiction]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Robert]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 09 Nov 2025 00:01:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-11-09T00:01:13.126Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>This story is not in my usual mould. It is from my 1970&#39;s university days when I occasionally daydreamed during lectures and is a reoccurring daydream I would like to share. Daydreaming isn’t good for grades but something in a lecture would trigger my imagination. My science degree of 1973–75 majored in computing and included subjects in mathematics (pure and applied), chemistry (physical, organic and non-organic) and physics (classical and relativistic), so there was plenty of scope to daydream (my Medium profile picture is from 1982 — the background computer is a clue).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*mGnvjcw2qH5_J0sv3jk7yA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Shutterstock</figcaption></figure><p>This daydream was initially triggered by a complex equation including both t and ∆t as variables — both time and change in time being related. Our normal spatial X, Y and Z dimensions have position and position change (motion) gauged by time, so could time also have both position and position change as implied by this equation? Could the fourth dimension be the same as all the rest? (The ∆t in the equation actually related to spatial movement of an object, but this did not stop my daydream.) How cold time change be measured when only time moves? Thanks to Einstein, all aspects of our space time are interconnected. ∆t in my daydream became time travel, but not in the usual sci-fi context.</p><p>I had already noticed an uncanny similarity between an oscillation formula and a well known relativistic formula. Both involve m for mass, but in totally different contexts. The oscillation of a mass attached to a spring has potential energy of E = ½mv² with v being speed at the midpoint. The matter-energy relationship is E = mc² with c being the speed of light. This similarity is striking and could indicate something fundamental.</p><p>My daydream was much simpler in 1974 as the plethora of new sub-atomic particles was just being discovered. I imagined electrons, protons and neutrons as discreet things having motion in four dimensions (4D). Today, each particle would have to be a collection of even smaller 4D things.</p><p>My imaginary 4D electron would “orbit” around an atom nucleus with a ∆t oscillation on top of its three dimensional orbit. A time travelling electron would explain the odd D and F atomic orbitals of physical chemistry and also electrons “tunnelling” through a diode. An assumption of physics is that time is constant. Interaction between particles would depend on spatial and time separation, for example, electrons with out of sync ∆t oscillation would be 2∆t in time distance and not collide. Each particle moving independently in the 4th dimension.</p><p>Permitting particles to move in time seemed similar to but simpler than quantum jumps, but what of light — photons eternally moving in three dimensions with a maximum velocity of C? Both matter and light exhibit both particle and wave behaviour, so could time movement also be a possible for a photon? All of this triggered by an equation with both t and ∆t. Unfortunately the lecture finished but the daydream continued whenever I had an idle moment or a boring lecture.</p><p>My daydream produces a mathematical headache as our reality is moving in time and time is the means of measuring velocity (distance per unit of time), oscillation and acceleration. Maybe my imaginary movement in time involves another dimension, but there was already a group by this name, so I stuck to four dimensions. Maybe motion in time could result in a unified model for matter and energy using a basic oscillation formula. It seemed obvious that the speed of light was somehow involved and the ‘thing’ oscillating would be common to both light and matter.</p><h3>A flat universe</h3><p>My next daydream instalment had a “photon” as a perfectly elastic fourth dimensional thing with a velocity vector (momentum) in four dimensions. What if the big bang had resulted in a constraint in the fourth dimension which caused oscillation. My daydream electron could be a standing wave of a photons moving in and trapped by a fourth dimension constraint. “Mass” being the interaction between photons and the 4D constraint.</p><p>Conceptually this is hard for us as three dimensional creatures, so for clarity I dropped a dimension and invented a two dimensional universe. Inhabitants of such a universe are stick figures on a two dimensional page (A2 for convenience). Their entire existence is confined to this A2 page. All scientists were convinced that subatomic building blocks are limited to the A2 page and can only move in two dimensions.</p><p>To a three dimensional observer, the A2 page is not thin, but a cloud having depth. This cloud has a strong central attraction in the third dimension which constrains all two dimensional subatomic things to this cloud. Without this constraint the universe would evaporate into the third dimension. These stick figures live in a universe which is more diverse than they can ever possibly imagine.</p><p>Electrons, protons and neutrons in an A2 universe are made up from several photons oscillating in the third dimension. The ultimate A2 light energy is a photon moving with no third dimension delta (perfectly parallel to the A2 page). If a collision results in a deviation into the third dimension then oscillation starts like skimming a stone on perfectly elastic water. The frequency of oscillation is determined by the resulting vector which includes the A2 third dimension. Transition from a skimming A2 photon to matter’s third dimension oscillating state absorbs energy and energy is released going the other way. Everything is perfectly elastic with no loss.</p><p>Just after the big A2 big bang there was an immense concentration of high energy two dimensional energy which “cooled” (collided) changing frequency. The high energy flat photons initially had all momentum directed in two dimensions. Cooling being the interaction between photons which eventually directs some of this momentum into the constrained cloud dimension. The sharper the angle the higher the light frequency, so the cooler the A2 universe becomes, light shifts toward red and the wider the third dimensional A2 cloud becomes. There is no loss of energy — just change of vector direction die to collision.</p><p>A2 matter is created when all of an A2 photon’s momentum is directed into the third cloud dimension. This is possible if multiple collisions result in photons being pushed at right angles to the A2 page. Particle properties depend on the cloud constraining force and nature of photons. A2 matter in my daydream is a stable collection of oscillating photons.</p><h3>A 3D universe</h3><p>My next daydream instalment consider our four dimensional space time continuum as a three dimensional form of “flat page”. The illusive A2 third dimension is now our fourth dimension of time. Our Earth 3D page is moving in time as we perceive time passing with a measure of a second. The basic particle (photon) common to energy and matter is spherical in all four dimensions and perfectly elastic. It has a net velocity vector of c in all 4 dimensions.</p><p>This is where the interesting part begins as the A3 particle model becomes too simplistic for our reality. It basically describes a single boring uniform particle which only has gravity and can only form inert lumps. The complexity of our reality may imply:</p><ul><li>The time constraint is non-symmetrical — “forward in time” part of oscillation is different to the backward part (maybe the shape of a shock wave created by the big bang?)</li><li>Reactive force of the cloud is non-linear (this would imply fifth, sixth, etc. dimensions are created as part of the big bang)</li><li>Reactive force is like a trampoline. The stretching of the trampoline on a bounce changes the properties of the reactive force. Two people on a trampoline bouncing side by side are forced together. This could result in many and complex interactions</li><li>An external ‘time’ force is applied to the motion of the space-time continuum making the reactive force non-symmetrical in the time dimension (God sustaining creation maybe)</li><li>There maybe several parallel time constraints interacting, for example, dark matter and visible matter.</li></ul><p>Having matter as photons bouncing in time leads to other possibilities, for example, a point being reached where the attraction between a collection of bouncing photons is sufficient to stop bouncing and becomes a black hole. If photons cease to bounce even light cannot escape. As bouncing ceases, a larger number of photons can fit at the one point with photons being stacked in all dimensions including time. A black hole being a fourth dimensional cylinder.</p><p>Black holes in this model keep growing with photons being stacked higher and higher until the cylinder becomes unstable or is affected by a nearby black hole and collapses. This causes all photons to escape. Using this model, it is possible for a big black hole to become a big bang with a shock wave profile being different to the original big bang.</p><p>What is perceived as mass is dependent on the relative distance bounced in time. When matter is moving this affects the net vector of photon motion in all dimensions including time. If a particle is moving close to C then the impact on mass will be significant as photons will be closer together.</p><h3>End of dream</h3><p>I did the daydreaming, but not the mathematics. My computing studies and career took priority, so my daydream remained as such being replaced by IT development projects and unrealistic deadlines. This was a most enjoyable daydream, so I hope you enjoy it as well. My takeaway was the possibility of something missed due to humans being three dimensional creatures that simply follow the average flow of time. The dual behaviour of matter and energy as both particle and wave is the clue.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c07f2e6305c7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Climate Reckoning]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@comp.keith55/climate-reckoning-e71f94c6646f?source=rss-00686345896c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e71f94c6646f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[carbon-sink]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[justice]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[climate-change]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[climate]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[climate-action]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Robert]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 04 Nov 2025 03:53:02 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-11-04T03:53:02.244Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I recently listened to a video “Climate Reckoning: Dr James Hansen and Clare Farrell — On Where We Really Stand” (<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y2UME_Z8oig">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y2UME_Z8oig</a>). The thrust of the video was ongoing action by scientists with the realisation that “It is too late”.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*02LqLOF0XCWQCRXcheYTew.png" /></figure><p>You may think this is an overly pessimistic position, but climate change predictions have a temperature at which an almost linear temperature increase becomes exponential due to failing carbon sinks. At this point human action becomes irrelevant as human greenhouse gas production is minute compared to what failing carbon sinks can produce. Already methane is bubbling from the sea bed of Antarctic Oceans, Greenland permafrost is melting and burning, etc. — this is carbon sinks failing in real time. Scientist are actively measuring and confirming what is happening. By all means call it a conspiracy, but first read results of contemporary research before ignoring it.</p><p>Initially in the 1980’s, I thought the anthropocentric climate change theory was nonsense — just another alarmist theory. One prediction caught my attention and kept me interested despite my scepticism. One expert predicted carbon sinks would start failing before the general populous would accept there is an issue. Sea level increases and climate changes would not become irrefutable until after it is too late for human action. Increasing evidence and refined predictions eventually convinced me of the validity of the theory. Many people have attempted to falsify this theory by selective use or interpretation of data, but the quantitive measurements of rising temperature and failing carbon sinks cannot be ignored. Just ask the residents of low lying Pacific Islands if sea levels are rising.</p><p>The video nominates four action points for scientists — continue work as a moral imperative (don’t give up); gravitate to like minded communities (don’t waste energy on deniers); enlarging researchers’ societal responsibilities (protest); and uphold the authority of fundamental research (stand up for science). Dr. Hansen promoted the development of cheaper nuclear energy to replace gas and the selective use of upper atmosphere aerosols to reduce southern ocean temperature. Youth involvement and action was highlighted as essential.</p><p>My own perspective is to go one step further and cater for the time when the general population can no longer ignore climate change and realise scientists were right all along. Even when it is too late, we need a list of people who have participated in the deliberate suppression of climate action. Fossil fuel companies that trivialised action despite their own research validating the need for action. Murdoch publications (Fox News, etc.) have consistently rubbished climate action and exaggerate issues with anything renewable, so both Rupert and Lachlan should be on the list. Trump is also an obvious candidate.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*UY5-Mopq1uW9Hr-7RXVnMQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>(From Shutterstock)</figcaption></figure><p>What would be the purpose of this register? Eventually to punish people that orchestrate denial. Confiscate their wealth to fund remedial action for those affected. Maybe a jail term, capital punishment or cancellation of their trip to Mars would also be in order. This would send a clear signal to those deliberately deceiving that there will be some future reward. This may not happen as we don’t know what world order will look like once the really bad effects start happening — already the increasing prevalence of fires and severe weather is giving us a taste of what is to come.</p><p>If climate change tipping points are exceeded, the impact on humanity will be dire, so people deliberately stopping or delaying action are committing a crime against humanity. Naturally there should be a legal process for the accused (ignorance, stupidity or insanity are not excuses). The register should include names and details of accusations so anyone reading it can draw their own conclusions and it can be used later for legal proceedings.</p><p>There are many actors disguised as independent think tanks. Their web pages express ideals and offer expert opinions, but when you look at their board of directors (on their about page), it is a list of who’s who in the fossil fuel industry. Third parties, influencers and politicians funded by deceivers should be included in the list. Tactics such as reducing public confidence in scientific research or pushing lame options such as carbon capture should also be considered crimes against humanity — anything delaying action.</p><p>Conspiracy theories are popular amongst conservatives, yet they are the best at enacting conspiracies. The register should link co-conspirators so that people believing in conspiracies can identify an actual conspiracy. There are already documentaries that name names, but these do not get aired on prime time TV — if at all.</p><p>The register is for those who realise that anthropocentric climate change is a real possibility but choose to maximise profits or power rather than act. Any denier who chooses deliberate deception or resorts to misinformation knows anthropocentric climate change is real.</p><p>My suggestion is probably not realistic. Humanity today cannot even agree on what constitutes genocide and who is considered human.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e71f94c6646f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Agree to disagree]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@comp.keith55/agree-to-disagree-53df1ac307a8?source=rss-00686345896c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/53df1ac307a8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[knowledge]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[truth]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trump]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Robert]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 22 Oct 2025 04:54:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-10-22T04:54:49.766Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>This story has been inspired by stories and replies that reveal “truth” by connecting dots or listing truisms. I sigh when reading an angry reply accompanied by truisms — selective quotes, statistics and facts from biased sources. Replying to such a great quantity of “truth” would require hours of work, so I just call them names instead (zombie is one of my favourites). To the person writing (unless they are trying to be deliberately deceptive), they have discovered the truth and will continue fighting for it — just as I like to think I am. Is this a rational process?</p><p>I joined Medium with an urge to write. Having both science and theology degrees, these were my primary areas of interest. I am not a scientist nor affiliated with a particular religion, but am familiar with basic concepts, history and underlying theories. My science degree lead to an IT career covering a broad spectrum of companies, industries and government agencies — as an outsider. I even worked on a tobacco processing project and can tell you a lot about blending. Please do not accuse me of being part of a conspiracy — I am just opinionated.</p><p>My first Medium story was a lengthy tome on first century concepts retained by twenty-first century Christianity. It included concepts such as the first century night sky being heaven with humanity and Earth central. This concept resulted in stars being perceived as divine beings (gods, angels and devils) with getting to heaven, events on Earth and resurrection of the body being of paramount importance. Concepts in my tome were basic first century knowledge including Astrology — the Christian devil owes more to Astrology than Jewish tradition. It did not matter if anyone read my tome as I was not after converts — just expressing my doubts. What is the motivation for people writing or replying? Many writers are just trying to make a living.</p><p>What I did not expect with Medium was being involved with other peoples’ stories and replies. I enjoy reading most Medium stories and will normally reply when I can add something to the story, complement the author, or challenge an exceptionally one sided reply. I don’t have a problem with different opinions but will engage with angry and dogmatic ones using selective facts. My intent is not win but to highlight these attributes to other readers. Some are trolls, but often I misunderstand and get corrected.</p><p>My replies are from my own experience as I do not belong to any group. I have been accused if being a Nihilist which is probably true due to my lack of belonging. Naturally, my thinking has been moulded by upbringing, experience and mental condition, but that is part of being human (or AI).</p><p>No doubt you have also read such stories - black and white presenting “Why …” or “Seven reasons ….”. My cynical nature immediately suspects supporting reasons and facts to be opinions or information from selected sources with varying degrees of accuracy and/or bias. All conveniently sanitised into a single reason or list. I am not referring to stories by experts in a particular field stating experience (for example, an immunologist writing on vaccines), but by amateurs like me.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*08pRupqjAgrpBt4g6Kd0xA.jpeg" /></figure><p>When writing, I rely heavily on opinions by past lecturers and conclusions made while studying. I am no longer actively engaged in academia so this makes me an amateur. My first tome is laid out with one section per issue, so it could be considered a list of facts and the pot is calling the kettle black — the irony does not escape me. When presented with facts proving a truth, the question should be asked as to what facts are valid or not included and this can only be answered by an expert. It is especially disconcerting when an amateur states what historical people thought or intended. Accusations of conspiracy are easy to make years after events.</p><h4>An example</h4><p>A recent story stating the “truth” about early Christianity’s understanding of Christ’s Resurrection is a story connecting dots. It describes a battle between two sects with losers persecuted as heretics — a battle between Jesus being human and Jesus being human + divine.</p><p>Facts from my perspective include: the earliest copy of Mark ends with Christ’s body only being missing with no mention of Resurrection; and four centuries of debate concluding in the fifth century with the Nicean Creed (started in Nicea and finalised by the Council of Chalcedon after 126 years of debate). These are historical facts, so when in the intervening 400 years did Christians start to believe Jesus was God?</p><p>An important clue for me is when Christians were excluded from Jewish daily prayer and became a separate religion — forty years after Jesus was crucified. The Jewish establishment could not handle claims of Jesus’ divinity and added words to daily prayers excluding Christian Jews, so divinity and resurrection <strong>was popular Christian belief by 70 CE</strong>.</p><p>Wikipedia lists 25 distinct heresies in the first five centuries on the nature of God with the first starting <strong>in the second century</strong>. These “battles” took place well after Christians had split from Judaism over Christ’s divinity and involved technicalities only clerics could understand. My lecturer on Early Church History described these heresies as regionally specific and usually involving a charismatic individual.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/942/1*NZaIYYPtVO-Yywk7YRsYfA.png" /><figcaption>500 years of theisms in chronological order (from Wikipedia)</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Third century Arianism</strong> stands out as this group had Jesus as human and was made the Roman state religion by several emperors after Constantine. There are also gnostic sects with a unique divine mechanism emphasising special knowledge dispensed by angels and a multitude of divine beings. These were more like the Mormon religion today as they did not just redefine Christ’s nature, they completely rewrote Christianity.</p><p>My facts would cause me to “agree to disagree” as this complex history can not be described by a simple reason, conspiracy or fact list. Yes there were disagreements (a fact) but it is a stretch to present these as a coordinated 400 year battle between rebels and the official church. Read in isolation without historical knowledge, such stories are convincing and probably easier reading than my boring description.</p><h3><strong>Fact V truth</strong></h3><p>When does a fact become truth? One is truthful if one does not tell lies, so is truth not deceiving? What if a person uses selective individually accurate facts but constructed in such a way to deceive? In my previous example, two people were being truthful (I can vouch for myself) but came to totally different conclusions using the same history and facts.</p><p>A truism could be described as something self evident given current knowledge and stated without proof, for example, the Earth being flat would have been a truism at some stage. Interpretations can also be stated as truisms by believers, but what if there are contradictory truisms? Does one: believe the most convincing person; stick to your own beliefs; trust experts with most knowledge/experience; or research facts presented by both? As previously mentioned, it is unlikely for an inexperienced person to identify what facts are missing or of dubious origin, so the last option usually includes personal bias. Popular debate today seems to include a lot of truisms that are not justified and just stated.</p><p>What is someone “seeking the truth” trying to find? — are they trying to find something factual, self evident or an interpretation/opinion that best suits their needs. News services claiming to seek the truth seldom stop at facts and include an interpretation/judgement (to maximise ratings by mirroring viewer bias or to satisfy the owner’s bias). “Current affair” type of programs maximise profit by finding a victim in tears — being investigator, judge and jury boosts viewer engagement — no need to think. I doubt any story, news story or documentary with black and white conclusions.</p><h4>Can truth be found in science?</h4><p>I started my IT career with science degree and appreciate that science deals in theories and not truths. Theories are based on facts obtained from the natural world, for example, the operation of a mechanical leaver is not governed by formulas expressing a truth, but described by formulas in a mathematical model created from observation. A scientific theory is not a truth as it is an interpretation of observation and must be open to testing and falsification. A theory progresses from proposed to general acceptance over many years and can disappear or be reworked at any stage if falsified. For example, relativistic physics falsified classical physics which was then reworked to exclude the very large, very fast and very small. Classical physics is still current and applied whenever you get a speeding ticket (another truth dependant on interpretation by a police officer).</p><p>There are some truisms in science, such as the assumption of consistency — the basic fabric of nature such as Plank’s constant will not change and is consistent across all galaxies. Even UFO’s must adhere to this basic fabric. The target of science is the natural world — the big question is what is the limit of the natural world. Even science needs fundamental assumptions.</p><p>General acceptance is the most important stage of the scientific process and closest a theory can get to becoming truth. This is when most scientists are in agreement, but does not stop a theory from being falsified.</p><p>Anthropogenic global warming was not generally accepted when I started following as its predictions were overly pessimistic. After the discovery of Global Dimming (heat reflected due to water droplets forming on upper atmosphere pollution), climate change theory was updated and predictions aligned better with observations. Increasing evidence and more accurate predictions convinced many more scientists and the theory was generally accepted (last survey of Scientists I read — agreed 85%, don’t care 10%, change but not anthropogenic 5%). To date this theory has not been falsified (only trivialised by conspiracy theories and vested interest). The UN conspiracy theory is a truism of the worst kind considering the number and diversity of scientists. Initially, I thought this theory to be rubbish.</p><p>In popular science journalism, “general acceptance” is the most sensational theory that matches the bias of the journalist/publisher. Anyone can write a journal article and the subsequent peer review is the equivalent of using a spell checker, so the fact something has been published in a journal and peer reviewed does not make a theory “true” — it is simply out there for discussion. Most people do not understand the scientific process and can be manipulated by vested interests publishing dubious journal articles.</p><p>Also, a scientist can also go public early to push their theory for financial gain or other altruistic motive — scientists are human. If their theory is not generally accepted, the author can claim they are a rebel and everyone else is wrong — look at Galileo. The all knowing rebel claim ignores political, personality and religious aspects of people like Galileo. Popular science journalism, vested interests and scientists with altruistic motives make it impossible for people to make sense out of journals, let alone find truth.</p><h4>Can truth be found in religion?</h4><p>I think that there needs to be a distinction between belief and religious truth. Jewish, Christian and Islamic religions believe in an immanent God active in peoples lives (not necessarily controlling or directly speaking), so if a person believes their life has been touched in some way then belief is a truism to that person and should be respected. Religious truth is harder to define as there are many perspectives under the Jewish, Christian, Islamic and other banners. Christianity alone has thousands of sects with truths at official, clerical and popular levels (liberal and conservative flavours).</p><p>An example of a fundamental religious truth is Catholic Papal Infallibility. This only applies to Catholics and became official in the 19th century, so the pope has only been infallible for about 150 years. A reply to a comment of mine stated that infallibility was a truism before becoming official. This was interesting as papal authority (not infallibility) was first claimed in the third century CE and infallibility only became a truism of the Roman Church after the split with the Eastern Orthodox Church in the eleventh century CE. There is a political overtone in this truth as papal infallibility was declared by a Council controlled by conservative Ultramontanists (refugees from the French revolution that fled over the mountains to Italy). How many Catholics actually believe in papal infallibility? — hence my reference to official, clerical and popular truths.</p><p>There are many religious fundamental “truths” that are relatively recent inventions: the Bible being literal and dictated by God (it was still being put together in the third century, was in Latin till the fifteenth century, and the KJV was not standardised till the Oxford Revision of 1769); speaking in tongues (modern version was first used by John Smith of Mormon fame); the sinner’s prayer with born again ritual (introduced by USA evangelicals in twentieth century); etc.. I am just mentioning these things and not attempting to refute or discount but to indicate there is a diversity of opinion and history to religious truth. Is the religion with the largest number of followers correct? — well then, Catholic dogma should rule. People mostly only accept fundamental truths of their chosen religion (or atheism) making discussion between groups and finding truth difficult.</p><h4>Can truth be found in history or in politics?</h4><p>History is full of facts, interpretations and opinions as written by the victor. We often know when events happened, the outcome of battles and the people involved. Politics is also full of facts, interpretations, opinions and re-interpreted history. The only difference between historical and political truth is that the latter is history in the making.</p><p>Interpretation depends on your starting point of facts, for example when France was invaded by Germany in WWII, the USA promised France planes to counter the Luftwaffe but failed to deliver. General De Gaulle as a result did not trust the USA and would list inaction by the USA as a reason Hitler was so successful. Did the USA win that war and/or was a major cause in the first place? Limiting facts till after D-day impacts interpretation. A modern day example is the interpretation of events in Gaza when facts are limited to after October 7th, 2023.</p><p>It is rare that intent of historical people or present day opponents is known, but many facts are created on assumed motivations and thinking. Accusations of conspiracy are easily made without evidence and assumed guilt. Actual conspiracies are only confirmed through legal action. A recent confirmed conspiracy was Fox News’ reporting of vote machine rigging. Correspondence between staff and management revealed that despite realising there was no viable evidence, Fox published lies anyway to keep their ratings. Why are modern conspirators so smart that they only leave evidence for influencers to discover?</p><p>I am not in the USA and troubled by its current degree of polarisation. The MAGA catch cry is to suppress WOKE in order to make the USA the greatest thug in the world. This does not make sense in any other country. Trump zombies should be expected considering the charisma of Trump, but I did not expect the extent of appeasement — especially from the Supreme Court and Senate. The rise of fascism in other countries makes more sense now.</p><p>An episode of an Australian TV show called Planet America interviewed Nick Sorter (journalist, podcaster and MAGA supporter). It was not a debate but just asking Nick for opinions. This was very scary, especially when he talked about the recently assassinated Kirk and accused the Biden administration of having greater censorship. Black and white facts that could not be questioned — he was either either brainwashed or a narcissist but still scary with a large audience. With such a stance, it is impossible in the USA for meaningful dialogue with facts being so partisan.</p><p>I have lumped politics and history together as both are interconnected. The USA is currently rewriting history to censor anything deemed WOKE — whatever that is. Australia has a very troubled history with regard to Aboriginals and politicians like Pauline Hanson would prefer the USA approach. This is one area where it is possible for truth — truth telling — where all facts regardless of how shameful need to be documented. How can we learn from history if only positive stuff is recorded. Selective sugar coated censored history certainly cannot be regarded as “truth”.</p><h3>Current state of knowledge</h3><p>Defining a truism as “self evident given the current state of knowledge” has a complication in that people have to first agree on the “current state of knowledge”. For example, the Catholic Vatican II Council instigated a review of liturgy and replacement of the Tridentine (traditional) Mass. It had been in use since the Reformation and was no longer commensurate with post Vatican II theology. A new Latin mass was developed and translated into each country’s vernacular. Even today fifty years later, some Catholics treat the traditional Tridentine Mass as a truism as it has been in use for 600 years. They reject the current state of Catholic theology and continue to use the Traditional Mass. The Eucharist dates back to the second century CE and current theology is trying to return to the purity of the early church making the Tridentine form obsolete.</p><p>Common sense is frequently cited for a truism people do not want to question, for example, “increased penalties reduces crime” is an interpretation that is not backed by experience. The USA has a very high crime rate despite a high level of incarceration and capital punishment. The early Greek philosophers included common sense in a list of fallacious arguments (logically irrelevant), but most people today seem to use fallacious arguments liberally. Nature provides many facts which are mostly true, for example, “we are all going to die” is a natural truism.</p><p>The current state of knowledge has now become a battle between science, religion and pseudo science. The USA has now become the realm of pseudo science with the biases of people in power being more important than experience and scientific evidence. It is laughable that in the name of free speech, all views contrary to pseudo science are being censored.</p><p>It does not matter whether it is religion, science, economics or history as any debate using truisms boils down to people’s current state of knowledge. Without agreement on this, debates are pointless. Can all Catholics agree to Vatican II reforms, can people agree on vaccine efficacy, can all USA voters agree on woke censorship, can all evangelical Christians accept Biblical literalism as a 19th century invention, etc..</p><h4>Finding truth</h4><p>It is obvious that unless you want to be a nihilist, one has to find some truth to live by. What I am proposing is for a bottom up approach starting with your current state of knowledge. One needs to be super critical as we are human and can be influenced by bias and charismatic individuals who can be delusional or deliberately deceptive. Questions for you to consider:</p><p># Is your current state of knowledge based on (a) your own personal experience or (b) do you rely on the opinion of a group, influencer or individual?<br># If your first answer is (b), what do you do if group, influencer or individual changes their opinion?<br># Is your state of knowledge absolute and cannot be wrong or questioned​?<br># Do you have sufficient knowledge to identify facts omitted or interpreted incorrectly?<br># Do you consider yourself biased?<br># Are you prepared to challenge anything you regard as true?</p><p>As an example, the following is my own critique. My answers — (a), n/a, no, in some areas (I am 70), yes, yes.</p><p>Science is not a mystery to me due to my background in mathematics and understanding of basic principles. Prac subjects at uni confirmed that science works. I also appreciate there are things such as the placebo effect that science does not understand. Science does not have all the answers but is an essential part of our modern world. What science is trying to discover are natural truisms. This is affected by distortions by vested interests such as corporations protecting profits and scientists seeking notoriety.</p><p>Many scientific disciplines are now so incredibly complex that a degree in a field is needed to understand journal articles. My head spins when trying to read particularly dense articles, so I try to find comments by experts in that field — I would not know what is missing or distorted. I flag such things as interesting but not necessarily true and open to questioning.</p><p>Many scientific disciplines have truisms tied up with tools they used, for example, carbon dating, spectroscopy and genetic sequencing. I am OK with this as the veracity of these tools is generally accepted and not yet falsified. There is a genuine attempt to refine science for accuracy and to avoid the mistakes of the past, for example, double blind testing is the gold standard in medical research. It was adopted many years ago to avoid disasters where biases affected outcomes — scientists are human after all.</p><p>There is also a place for pseudo science — things that science cannot explain or is not interested in. Unfortunately pseudo science is also full of vested interests looking to maximise profits. To me a warning sign is the use of conspiracy theories or total rejection of science. I did an internet search on “Noni Juice double blind testing” and the result was flooded with accusations that double blind testing was part of a big pharma conspiracy.</p><p>My tome “Reformation Mark II” is a statement of my heretical religious position based on my experience. For me it is clear that the love God and neighbour command with no qualification on neighbour is the central focus and litmus test for being Christian. This is my only religious truth.</p><p>I am not affiliated with any political party apart from being a humanist. I am not in the USA, so the labels of Republican, MAGA and Democrat do not apply. Naturally as I am not MAGA, the label of WOKE would apply — I am awake to their deceptions.<br> <br>My state of knowledge is not derived from allegiance to any group but from my own experience. Is it correct or truth — hell no. No doubt there will be people highlighting and objecting to my examples, but this typifies the subjective nature of “knowledge” and “truth”. I am quite prepared to challenge anything that I currently hold as true.</p><h4>Rational discourse</h4><p>One obvious thing from my limited time on Medium is the futility of rational discussion between people who do not share the same current state of knowledge. The MAGA-WOKE divide is such a chasm which cannot even agree on the intent of the USA Constitution. Is the country being corrupted by migrants, is ICE acting with integrity, has censorship exceeded that of China, …. Globally most people refer to Trump as a budding fascist dictator due to parallels with other regimes, so it is interesting when such concerns are simply dismissed by his devotees.</p><p>An important assumption is that people are being honest and not just after click bait or trying to deceive. One story author suggested a reply to their story was by a troll. This started my questioning the motivation for a troll and what they consider truth — maybe nothing is truth only ammunition for trolling. The motivation of some internet influencers has recently come into focus. Financial and other personal gain can affect honesty and this is dangerous on social media where people are assumed to be honest.</p><p>The main issue is where people go for information and what they accept as true. It would be a lot easier when debating for people to initially list their sources and what they believe to be true. If they cannot agree on basics then they must “agree to disagree”. Discussion is pointless otherwise. That interview I mentioned highlighted a person not prepared to challenge MAGA truisms. The person was supposedly a journalist and yet could not perceive shades of grey — everyone else was wrong and he had his list of selected facts to prove it (I would have called him a zombie).</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=53df1ac307a8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Yet another global warming story]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@comp.keith55/yet-another-global-warming-story-8970c108c306?source=rss-00686345896c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8970c108c306</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[climate-change]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[global-warming]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Robert]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 16 Sep 2025 03:12:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-09-16T03:12:07.729Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>This is yet another story on global warming — am I qualified in climatology? No, but that does not seem to stop anyone. My interest in the carbon cycle started very early and began as a result of the 1980’s ozone depletion emergency. Journalist against action would get fluorocarbons confused with carbon dioxide. They merged both issues. Without their ignorance I would not have heard of climate change. My uni science degree started in 1973 with maths-physics-chemistry subjects and then shifted to a major in Computer Science, so I have some basic science skills and can recognise the difference between fluorocarbons and greenhouse gases. My IT career started in 1976 and after that I had very little contact with the science community, so I can’t be accused of being part of a conspiracy.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*o0aOXOAaQel0uSBaVpzgtQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>The first part of my story is to state some facts I consider obvious based on geological history. If you are a creationist or believe my interpretation of geological history is flawed then by all means comment. Please do not leave ad hominem replies as I already know that I am insane.</p><p>Initially I read some more on climate change out of curiosity - a few 1980’s articles on global warming and additional reading on geological history and ice ages. I was shocked to discover our current ice age did not end as in Disney movies but was a boring part of a glaciation cycle — currently Earth is in one of 100 inter-glacial periods of a 2.6 million year ice age. 1980’s was at a time when there was a lot of speculation as to how the next glacial period (Disney ice age) would commence, for example, one of the polar ice caps was going to slip. I considered global warming to be interesting but was just one of the many doomsday predictions. At the time most scientists were sceptical and not really interested.</p><h3>Fact one:</h3><p>Humans have not existed outside of an ice age. Humans evolved (or were deposited by aliens or God) in approximately the last 100 thousand years during the previous inter-glacial. The historical record of civilisation is limited to the current inter-glacial. To put our existence into perspective: 4% of the current 2.6 million year Quaternary ice age; 2 of the 100 Quaternary glaciation cycles; 0.002% of earth’s 4.6 billion year existence. (Historical records may include much earlier oral stories, for example, Noah’s flood story appears in several near eastern religions and potentially relates to an event at the very start of the current inter-glacial when sea levels were rising, for example, the sudden failure of a natural dyke across the Bosphorus Strait flooding the Black Sea).</p><h3>Fact two:</h3><p>Global median surface temperatures (GMST) have varied from 11° to 36°C over the last 500 million years with the current average being about 15°C. This temperature record has been obtained by analysis of mudstone (chemistry and isotope composition being affected by temperature), ice cores, geology and fossils. This information was available well before climate change became popular and is essential in predicting future temperatures. Temperatures have been near this range since the start of life 3.6 billion years ago and the beginning of the biosphere (this includes several possible instances of Snowball Earth where all of the earth including oceans was covered in ice with a sub zero GMST).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gxVx_OdnTpkQn-bEUM-zhA.jpeg" /><figcaption><a href="https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.adk3705">https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.adk3705</a></figcaption></figure><h3>Fact three:</h3><p>Humanity needs global median surface temperatures below 20°C to thrive. Civilisations need stable weather patterns for agriculture and this is only possible when there is sufficient permanent surface ice for predictable rainfall and for each polar vortex to contain polar extreme cold. Melting surface ice also provides a continuous supply of fresh water. Above 20°C, all permanent surface ice has melted with a substantial increase in sea level. In the previous graph, only 55 million of the 500 million years were cool enough for human civilisations. The highest recorded temperate in the modern era is 56.7°C with a GMST of 15°C, so assuming a correlation with global mean, the highest with a 20°C mean is 62°C and the highest with a 36°C mean is 78°C. All highest temperatures are lethal for humans.</p><h3>Fact four:</h3><p>The biosphere (all life on earth) keeps GSMT below 36°C. Earth and Venus are referred to as sister planets as they are relatively close and have a similar chemical make up. The main difference is that Earth developed a biosphere which digested methane to make oxygen. Over 3.5 billion years, Earth’s GSMT has been closely aligned to greenhouse gas concentrations. Temperature seems to be a balance between oxygen levels, biosphere greenhouse gas levels, greenhouse gas from other sources (volcanoes, fires, etc.) and position of tectonic plates. On several occasions, excessive oxygen levels resulted in a Snowball Earth. Venus today without a biosphere has a dense carbon dioxide atmosphere and a uniform GSMT in excess of 500°C — even on the side away from the sun. 500 million years ago Venus’ surface temperature was so high that its entire surface melted removing any trace of earlier meteor impacts.</p><h3>Fact five:</h3><p>The Biosphere started about 3.7 billion years ago with the first single cell creatures. It is only in the last 500 million years that evolution really kicked in and diversified.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/479/1*WRuul_Mk-1uA_6Lm2rTZXw.png" /><figcaption>From Wikipedia</figcaption></figure><h3>Fact six:</h3><p>In recent times GSMT has been increasing at a rate of 1°C per century and this is much greater than the expected 1°C per 1,000 years for an inter-glacial period. Such a rate of change has only been experienced in the past after a dramatic event such as a meteor impact or extensive volcanic activity and is usually associated with a mass extinction event. With annual change being so small many projects were started to achieve a greater degree of accuracy for temperatures, for example, the Australian Bureau of Meteorology conducted a review of all of its automated weather stations — especially the ones which did not follow regional trends. Several had been compromised as they were now shaded due to trees being planted or buildings erected in public spaces. The BOM’s 1910-today dataset is now quality controlled and is as accurate as possible (equipment before 1910 was only accurate to +- 2 degrees).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/699/1*u5FG0oe7h6iPAKOk3caicw.png" /><figcaption>Screenshot from <a href="https://www.bom.gov.au/cgi-bin/climate/change/timeseries.cgi">https://www.bom.gov.au/cgi-bin/climate/change/timeseries.cgi</a></figcaption></figure><h3>Fact seven:</h3><p>Glaciation cycles are linked to sun intensity (Melocivtz long term variation of earth’s orbit), the biosphere oxygen-greenhouse gas balance and position of tectonic plates. At some point at solar maximum the biosphere balance shifts. Temperature variation is not directly linked to sun intensity rather has a slow ramp down during glaciation that lasts 30 or 70 thousand years (glaciers advance) and a sharp ramp up during inter-glacial (glaciers retreat) that lasts 10 thousand years. My pet theory is that rain forests take over at the peak of the inter-glacial producing far more oxygen than animals can consume — but the reality is probably far more complex. There does not seem to be a standard temperature pattern across the 100 glaciation cycles of our ice age, hence my assertion that it is a balance of several factors and not just sun intensity. Ice core samples provide a detailed record of the last 1+ million years of glaciation cycles.</p><h3>Fact eight:</h3><p>There has be a substantial reduction in permanent surface ice in the last 100 years. This includes glaciers, polar ice caps and permanent ice shelves. It does not include winter surface ice that melts in summer, is reasonably thin and floating (has no impact on sea level). The majority of permanent ice shelves have now melted, broken up or been degraded. As ice shelves float their melting does not impact sea levels. One large Antarctic ice shelf section recently split exposing a sea bed which had been covered by ice for over one million years. The North Pole (which is an ice shelf and not on land) has become exceptionally thin and at the current rate of melting is no longer expected to be permanent. Most glaciers globally are receding at rates not witnessed before in human history.</p><p>You may have noticed that there is no mention of anthropomorphic climate change in any of the above facts (or many more facts that could have been included). The stuff of these facts comes from measurement and analysis, and not theories on climate change. If you choose to say that all science is bullshit and a conspiracy then avoid flying or any other invention with input from scientists. If you must leave a remark remember my request not to use ad hominum and state your evidence and alternate facts. Please do not challenge the correlation between greenhouse gas and temperature. This was discovered in the 19th century, confirmed by Myth Busters and evident on Earth’s sister planet Venus. Myth Busters are never wrong.</p><p>Despite my initial scepticism on climate change, I continued reading and was eventually won over by the sheer weight of scientific evidence. Climate change theory adds facts 9–13 to the above. Earth’s temperature is changing without humans anyway, so the concern is the effect of human activity on the natural cycle. Earth should be at the end of an inter-glacial with the biosphere balance tipping for glaciation to start. This change to glaciation is possibly overdue with human activity preventing a change in balance.</p><h3>Fact nine:</h3><p>Climate change predictions are being verified. Initially climate change predictions were overly pessimistic until global dimming was incorporated into the theory. Global dimming is due to water droplets forming on high level pollution. This can be demonstrated by the temperature spike resulting from global shipping swapping to low sulphur oil. The prediction of changing frequency and intensity of extreme weather has been verified by the increasing number of once in 100 year events. I have been through 3 once in 100 year floods. Yes, there may have been bigger floods, fires or temperatures at some point in the past, but predictions relate to averages and rates of change — not absolutes, for example, category 5 cyclones used to be rare - now they now happen every year.</p><h3>Fact 10:</h3><p>Global carbon sinks are failing or are on the verge of failing. Part of my initial scepticism was the dire prediction of carbon sinks failing — this to me was fanciful and similar to the other doomsday predictions like polar ice caps slipping. In a nutshell — greenhouse gases are absorbed and trapped in several natural biosphere “sinks”. These are temperature sensitive and at present many are close to a temperature where a sink fails releasing mega quantities of greenhouse gas. There is now a lot of evidence of degrading carbon sinks. As glaciation cycles depend on biosphere balance, failure of carbon sinks could potentially result in the current ice age ending and a GSMT greater than 20°C. The Amazon is an example of a failing carbon sink. Deforestation has reached a point where its micro climate may not be able to sustain a rain forest becoming savanna. Permafrost is another carbon sink now failing — sometimes explosively.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*aU-P7kThH-mZ03uTB1euGw.png" /><figcaption>From Wikipedia</figcaption></figure><h3>Fact 11:</h3><p>Due to the size of carbon sinks, human reduction of greenhouse gases will only be effective while these sinks remain intact. As they fail, temperature change will be much more rapid and make a large parts of Earth off limits to humans. The current increasing human greenhouse gas emissions guarantee the failure of carbon sinks in the near future.</p><h3>Fact 12:</h3><p>To avoid failure of carbon sinks, humanity has to become effectively carbon neutral, not just reduce the rate of increase. Anything less is simply delaying the inevitable. How close are we? Siberian and other permafrost areas are rapidly shrinking; Arctic Circle, South East Asian and Amazonian forests are being cleared rapidly for farming or palm oil; and oceans (seabed mud methane) are warming far more quickly than the atmosphere. These carbon sinks are already much less effective and with feedback effects failure will become exponential once a tipping temperature is reached — hence the concern about a GSMT increase above 1.5°C.</p><h3>Fact 13:</h3><p>The current commitment for action by governments is not sufficient to stop the really bad effects of climate change. One commentator in the 1980’s remarked that if humanity did not get its act together before Siberian permafrost starts to melt then we can collectively kick our asses goodbye. His pessimism was based on time before human changes take effect and temperature change becoming exponential. I hope he was wrong as not only is permafrost melting, the thawed peat is burning.</p><p>The aim of this story is to highlight that there are a lot of scientific facts not related to climate change which are rubbished by deniers. No scientists (excluding creationists) would disagree with my first eight facts — maybe I have some of the detail wrong. The last actual (not assumed) large scale survey of scientists I came across had 85% who would have agreed with facts nine to twelve; 10% did not care; and 5% agreed there was change, but not because of humans. You probably would have noticed I rigged the facts so the last one is 13 as I am hoping it is not a fact.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8970c108c306" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Before the Midterms]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@comp.keith55/before-the-midterms-a47b4ba9a157?source=rss-00686345896c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a47b4ba9a157</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[usa]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trump]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[maga]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[elections]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Robert]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 06 Jul 2025 05:04:50 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-07-06T05:04:50.707Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I am not in the USA but to save democracy there are obvious things that need to be in place before the next round of elections — federal, state and local elections. Several republicans have resigned rather than vote for the BBB and I am not sure if this will trigger early replacement elections for these brave souls. There also may be elections for Republicans that die or are forced to resign in the mean time. People need to be prepared.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hUzChOgSZIvbZ6EwacZ3MA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Shutterstock</figcaption></figure><h3>Voter identification</h3><p>Voter ID has become mandatory with varying emphasis between states.<br>People with photo ID have to be sure that it is OK according to the proposed rules. There was talk of only accepting ID that matches birth certificate or naturalisation papers. Any person that changed their name on marriage must undo this by deed pole and have their ID updated (Males tend to favour Republicans, so the more females disenfranchised the better).</p><h3>Limited voting locations</h3><p>Communities that have access to voting locations limited may need community buses organised with potential for external financial support. Maybe a national organisation can be established to provide funding. Peoples voting status and districts they can vote in needs to be checked.</p><h3>Potential voter fraud</h3><p>Republican states are notorious for gerrymanders but not for voter fraud. This may change with Trump inspired officials, so it is important for scrutineers and other checks to be in place.</p><h3>Use of creativity</h3><p>The world of Trump uses name calling, deliberate distortions and lies to promote itself. This is not creativity but cynical manipulation. There are many creative people opposed to Trump and they could devise popular music and art that attracts public attention in a positive way and possibly increase Trump’s blood pressure.</p><p>I am old and a Monty Python fan, so two things that immediately come to mind are the Spam and Lumberjack songs. Simply replace “spam” by “Trump” in the first song. “I am a lumberjack and I am OK” could have “lumberjack” replaced by “MAGA hack”.</p><p>Trump is fond of plagiarising songs for his rallies, so the original artists could re-release these songs with words changed to challenge the Trump reality. New songs — popular, rap, etc. — could be released with a call to action or protest theme. Any song supported by people opposed to Trump will quickly rise to number one spot and get a lot of national exposure.</p><p>Maybe a remake of the Lion King titled Lying King or King Kong with an orange mop scaling and destroying the Statue of Liberty. The King and I with a plump eighty year old instead of the biff Yul Brynner. Anything to reframe the evil one.</p><p>The impact of art is limited due to Trump’s banning of anything considered DEI or WOKE. The USA now has censorship rivalling China, so thought provoking art may have to resort to billboards and large outdoor canvases. Maybe Banksy has some suggestions.</p><h3>MAGA mentality</h3><p>Zombie mentality is not new, so there is the question of what has worked in the past. In Hitler’s Germany, what was effective before being silenced by the Gestapo. Things like highlighting the people harmed by Trump’s polices — giving victims names. No doubt before the mid terms the Zombie team will be in full force and will side step issues such as the state of the economy. Blame will be dished out to those opposing Trump’s policies. There may even be an uptake in the US economy due to the billions spent on the boarder wall and gold thunder dome.</p><p>Be prepared as these things take time.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a47b4ba9a157" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Fear and Woke in the USA]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@comp.keith55/fear-and-woke-in-the-usa-913a115e69c0?source=rss-00686345896c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/913a115e69c0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trump]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[people]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Robert]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 24 May 2025 02:05:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-05-24T02:05:40.799Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Fear and anxiety make it difficult for people to be rational. We are in a rapidly changing world where past certainty no longer exists. Older people are anxious because of what they have lost and younger people are anxious because of an uncertain future. How people handle this depends on their individual coping mechanisms.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gsa3lvj358WzxX6S3tM7dg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Shutterstock</figcaption></figure><p>A Group Dynamics subject entailed several weekends with four two hour sessions per weekend over both days. Each session except the last involved students and two observers sitting in a room with no agender or instructor. This drove half of the students crazy as they expected a formal course. The remaining students (including me) were happy to play along as obviously the sessions were designed with intent. Disgruntled students would meet as a group in between sessions to complain and plan action — money back and/or formal complaint. The rest of us just mingled in between sessions.</p><p>The group of complainers had a main spoke person and would disperse or become silent if a non-group member approached. The rest of us began to wonder what was wrong as exclusion was obvious. Before the start of the last session there was a group of one mind and several individuals.</p><p>The final session presented the theory of dependency on group dynamics. A person’s dependency is somewhere between totally dependent to totally independent (at that point in time). People in the dependent spectrum gravitated towards being in a like minded group and needed formal classes with clear agender and someone in authority. People in the independent spectrum did not need a group nor formal setting.</p><p>This was an important lesson for an independent person like me. I often become an outsider to groups and become excluded with an inference that I am in some way inferior — at work or socialising. Dependency groups have a leader, develop unquestionable fundamental truths and clearly define who is in or out. Anyone outside of a group is inferior and criticised for not holding group truths. The impact of dependency groups was clearly demonstrated by this subject.</p><h3>A coping mechanism</h3><p>What this highlighted was group belonging as a coping mechanism for dependent people. I don’t have the stroking skills to be considered for group membership, for example, I am on a crowded train and we are stuck in between stations due to points failure; there is silence and I say something silly to break the ice (easy for an independent person); people start to chat and I get left out as groups form.</p><p>The subject was slightly different in that it provided a catalyst for forming of a “lynch mob”. A friend of mine who was particularly vocal in the first session introduced the truth of the subject being a flop and money should be refunded (the lynching). I was immediately criticised for suggesting all will be revealed in the final session. My friend became group leader and ostracised me. Their fundamental truth seemed ridiculous to me as the subject was not new and was lead by the faculty head. My friend expressed a truth resonating with others who also needed structure. Once the group formed, their truth could not be questioned — it was common sense.</p><p>Our education system treats everyone as individuals and ignores group influences. How many of your beliefs are yours or adopted from a group affiliation — do you ever question your beliefs? Personal beliefs usually get questioned while group ones cannot without being ostracised. Ironically during recess, group dynamics reign in the school yard. I did not really fit into any groups which made my school years particularly horrid. Groups for adults include political parties, religions, white supremacy, etc..</p><p>Simplistic group solutions like minimalist government, targetting migrants or Biblical literalism become attractive to anxious people as they provide certitude and possible return to past security. All that a group leader needs to do is to find a topic resonating with dependent people. Once hooked such a person copes by buying into all truths of that group. Internet echo chambers are modern day dependency groups on steroids.</p><p>There are fear issues particular to the USA — commercial media which increases profit by making people more anxious; dangers justifying gun ownership being promoted by the gun lobby; a get out of hell free card plus rapture provided by some churches; social media misinformation; the rise of influencers and the fear of lost USA greatness/superiority. Information distortions are spreading globally, for example, news media, think tanks, and information websites funded by vested interests (catholic.com is not published by the Catholic Church but a USA conservative not-for-profit).</p><p>Unscrupulous people are able to manipulate dependent people and know that once down the group rabbit hole, their followers will not question and accept whatever lies are included as group truths. Trump and his cohorts are predators feeding on fear and anxiety. None of their polices can be separated from fear — of deep state, of migrants, of woke (whatever it is) and of other countries taking advantage of the USA.</p><h3>What to do?</h3><p>I agree that people need educated on the veracity of information sources. We also need to acknowledge that 50% of people are dependant and need structure and group truths.</p><p>What dependency groups are available for coping at a national level? Democrats, Republicans, Fox News, white suprematists and religions are some options. Educational institutions, scientists and humanists have been downgraded and called woke. They have been supplanted by alternate truth organisations. Humanist are at fault for having compassion and the rest are part of a conspiracy. How many Democrats, Republicans or GOP are dependent groupies? A tell tale sign is not questioning and agreeing with all truths of a party. Lynch mobs, vigilantes, KKK and inquisitions are groups with members prepared to kill for their truths.</p><p>People being dependent is not a flaw but a survival characteristic — a tribe is better at surviving than an individual. I am not sure if group belonging is genetic or a trait learned from parents. It is a trait that I don’t possess. Part of survival is automatic subconscious filtering of anything other than group truths. Feedback to Medium stories by someone with a fundamental truth is usually angry denouncing the author as ignorant, evil or woke. Issues raised are ignored.</p><p>Dependency group belonging can only be affected by reducing fear-anxiety or creating doubt of a group truth (maybe by focusing on the ideals of USA democracy, addressing media distortions or grass roots inclusive neighbourhood support groups).</p><h3>People are human</h3><p>My story attempts to highlight that reasoning is not always effective. What people accept as valid is affected by many things. Dependency groups and echo chambers completely side step rationality. This coupled with the ease at which people can now be targetted based on biases at an individual level makes democracy a farce — the best advertising/lies wins. Woke has been made into something to be feared — especially by young males. It is fear that justifies extreme action.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=913a115e69c0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>