<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Conner Johnston on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Conner Johnston on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@connerjohnston?source=rss-84f33af0b11c------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 23:49:35 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@connerjohnston/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Race]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@connerjohnston/the-race-37617f1bf5de?source=rss-84f33af0b11c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/37617f1bf5de</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[fiction]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Conner Johnston]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 17 Oct 2025 21:28:39 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-10-17T21:28:39.467Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*sIdHIq8Hm35Rssr4dydgtA.png" /><figcaption>Image made with the help of Chat GPT 5</figcaption></figure><p>The forest echoed with hundreds of hooves padding desperately on the soft late-spring ground. Breaking twigs and heavy breathing added to the din of exertion as a torrent of amber bodies hurriedly navigated around thick trunks, through overflowing streams, and towards glory. No competing sounds could be heard as if all other flora and fauna collectively held their breath in anticipation. Even the typically chatty birds were quietly watching the racers from their perches above.</p><p>Roger was, from a mix of effort and fortune, the set of hooves in front of the racing herd galloping through the dense forest. He had passed the final deer who had started ahead of him on the last curve of the narrow and serpentine trail. This deer looked even more exhausted than the others Roger had passed, taking quick raspy breaths without pause.</p><p>Yet, even given his envious position, Roger still cursed silently to himself as he sped through the forest. He cursed the wet winter that softened the ground his hooves kept slipping on. He cursed the pack that felt more awkward than normal and kept shifting on his slight back. And he cursed Josie who was inexplicably closing in on him.</p><p>He had stolen a quick glance behind him when he moved into first and spotted her through the thick underbrush only one bend away. This image had immediately quashed any triumphant feelings. She was the racer immediately behind him now, a truly confounding circumstance given how much further behind she had started.</p><p>Roger needed to get out of the twisting forest, that’s when he could lose her. And to his great relief the trees were finally beginning to thin. He could now see the village’s outskirts through the spindly trunks of the smaller trees lining the edges of the forest. Ignoring the pain in his back and the exhaustion everywhere, he implored his legs to push his body beyond the limit he hit some time ago, promising every muscle the end was near. And so with an explosive burst, he leapt from the moist, loose earth of the forest trail onto the compact, dry streets of the village where his hooves immediately gained more purchase.</p><p>But relief was again illusory as Roger soon after heard more hooves leaving the forest. Josie must have been only a few body lengths behind, but he couldn’t even spend the time to look back and confirm. “More!” he told himself as he started his sprint through the village’s outskirts.</p><p>Even in his extreme exhaustion and frustration he was aware of his current surroundings. Constant attention was required to avoid the occasional potholes and cracks common on Laggards’ Lane, the outskirts’ main road. He also could not ignore the dilapidated houses and vacant lots serving as tangible reminders for the importance of today. Roger always replayed the memory of the first time his parents drove him through this neighborhood, his dad’s deep tenor saying plainly: “Pity them, help them, but do not become them.”</p><p>He could not let him down. Not after coming so far, not after all he sacrificed to be in this position, not after finally being first, the dream his dad could never achieve, but one his parents expected of him, an expectation even he thought was wildly unrealistic. But he was so close now and had no intention of letting even Josie, his best friend, spoil that dream, even if her victory would be historic. This was his day of triumph.</p><p>Roger now heard her quick and methodical breaths pulling nearly even with him. He could not understand it. Josie’s agility in the forest was always impressive, but the village was his domain, where he could pull away from his competitors. And yet, inexplicably, she not only wasn’t falling back but kept gaining on him while his legs were at their breaking point.</p><p>He was now at least in his own neighborhood, close to the city center; the end was near. And his neighborhood had pristine streets without potholes so he could move his concentration fully to maximizing his legs’ effort. The neighborhood’s well-maintained lawns and houses also served as a different reminder, one of what he could lose.</p><p>Then it mercifully came. The final stretch. After they sprinted by the tall brick facade of City Hall, the wrought iron fence enclosing their school’s grounds, and then made a hard left on Victors’ Road, the immense grandstands came into view lining the right side of the final stretch, across from City Park where the large temporary race scoreboard now stood. The grandstands were packed with every villager waving flags with their family’s crest, cheering on their family’s racer. And he could see the antler arch over the start and finish line with the village’s motto at the arch’s apex becoming more legible with every desperate stride, a motto all young fawns memorized: “Fortune smiles on tireless hooves.”</p><p>Josie was now in his periphery, even with him. They had only a dozen or so strides to the end but he was utterly and completely depleted. He had nothing left, all he could do was fall across the finish line, stretching his nose and breaking the finish’s threshold in a final desperate act.</p><p>Then he crumpled, a heaving mass on the track’s rough surface. All thoughts but one left his mind: breathe. He did not care if he was trampled by other racers. He did not care that his skin was likely bloody under his pack’s straps. He did not care if he had won. He did not care about his family’s pride or scorn. He could only focus on his lungs’ complaints, giving them the air they needed to keep him alive, which at that moment seemed like a precarious task.</p><p>But slowly, painfully slowly, with each desperate breath his field of consciousness expanded. Roger could feel his tired, strained body, the muscles’ angry protests quieting from a scream to a yell. Then he could feel the rough track surface on his right side and the cool breeze on his left, the moist spring air turning from foe to friend. He could also now hear other heaving bodies collapsing around him. Then he heard the crowd.</p><p>Something was wrong. The cheering had abruptly quieted. This forced him to open his left eye cautiously and to his relief he could see the scoreboard without having to move any more muscles. It took his left eye a few seconds to focus on the scoreboard at the strange angle, but as soon as it became legible he sat bolt upright.</p><p>It couldn’t be right. He must be delirious from the race. Not the fact Josie had indeed beat him, though by fractions of a second. After taking a few more seconds to confirm his initial impressions, the incoming results were clear: most gazelles were finishing much higher than they started and most deer were finishing far lower than their start. And Josie seemed to have made the largest gain from her starting position than any other gazelle, and likely any racer in history, regardless of species. The only reason it seemed Roger had moved up to second is that Josie was the only gazelle who started within 20 spots of him. This realization must have been the silencing force choking the crowd’s cheers.</p><p>But then silence morphed to anger as many villagers began yelling while pointing violently at the scoreboard.</p><p>Roger looked around for Josie and saw her just a few lengths ahead of him, with a few other incapacitated racers between them. She was regaining her balance on uncertain legs and also staring at the scoreboard. She then turned around towards Roger, her face inscrutably passive. Their eyes connected. A brief look of confusion flashed away from her face landing on a small smile, and then a soft chuckle.</p><p>All Roger had the energy to do was eek out a bare whisper, but with a biting intensity, “What did you do?”</p><p>Roger stood in front of his house’s front door with head down and eyes closed, delaying his entry. With the untied race pack loosely slung over his back, he stood extraordinarily weary on weakened legs from a long, final practice before the race in two days. A moment of pause always did him well, and this brief respite was one of the few moments Roger got to himself. Between Coach Marv pushing his muscles to the brink and his family pushing his nerves to the brink, Roger had little time to stress by himself.</p><p>With a last deep breath, he opened his eyes, turned the door’s handle, and entered.</p><p>The smell of his mom’s famous acorn tacos immediately welcomed his senses. A brief memory of a night before his first junior race came to mind, his mother soothing his nerves with food, reminding him juniors had no consequences. Those were the days Roger thought.</p><p>“Hi honey, food’s ready.” His mom was just walking from the kitchen into the dining room with plates of food. Roger threw his pack down in the mudroom with a soft thud and wearily followed his mom into the dining room, his stomach starting to gurgle its excitement.</p><p>“How’d practice go?” Roger’s dad asked, wasting no time with his interrogation. His dad was sitting at the head of the oak dining table to the right of where Roger sat down slowly and gingerly, not to further strain his exhausted muscles. His younger brother and sister were opposite him, already inhaling the food their mom had just put in front of them. Roger’s mother sat to his left, at the other end of the table from his dad. Roger was surrounded on all sides like a helpless victim in front of an inquisition.</p><p>“Fine.” Roger halfheartedly offered.</p><p>“Marv had a different view,” his dad quickly responded.</p><p>Roger was silent, methodically eating through his first taco, wanting to focus on the food for just a second longer before having to acknowledge the statement as a question.</p><p>His dad continued, with a slight shaking of his head. “He says you’re still not listening to him on his strategy for the forest.”</p><p>Roger swallowed his bite and said into his taco without looking up, “Marv is old and batshit crazy.” Ignoring his siblings’ snickers and his mom’s glare, Roger followed up, “And I am listening to him. Spent three hours doing nothing but listening to him explaining in detail how lazy I am.” Roger ended by looking at his dad pleadingly.</p><p>“I know you’re working hard Rog, but we’re paying him too much for you to not use his strategy. We need you to move up to afford him, among others things.”</p><p>Roger’s dad wasn’t angry, he rarely got angry. But his concern was evident.</p><p>Roger’s dad had been one of the fastest deer in the village. And though his trunk had a few extra pounds and his fur was becoming lighter from age, you could still see the impressive outline of his formidable leg muscles, the legs that were responsible for moving the family from 17th to 4th in just three years, where Roger would start in two days. Roger could almost feel the weight of his dad’s reputation in his race pack whenever he was on the track, a constant reminder throughout the race, and life, of the hefty expectations he carried.</p><p>Roger’s dad added after finishing another bite of food, “Especially this year.”</p><p>“You think the measure will pass tomorrow Daddy?” Roger’s sister, the youngest of the family, also had concern etched throughout her tiny face.</p><p>“I don’t know honey, probably not but you never know and Roger has to be prepared for everything.”</p><p>Roger’s brother interjected, “We talked about the measure in class today, and learned about the race’s history. It’s sad those gazelles were forced to race with heavier packs. Why’d the First Deers make them do it?”</p><p>Roger’s mom made eye-contact with Roger’s dad before saying softly, “It’s complicated honey. But you don’t need to worry about that right now, eat up, you need to grow big and strong so you’re ready to race for this family when your brother heads off to school. Speaking of which, we should be hearing back from schools next week. All of your hard work will be paying off soon, Rog. Finishing in the top-three will make sure your brother and sister can join you at Savanna U, which you will certainly get into. And finishing first, I can’t even dream yet, but that would guarantee we could finally move to First Street. I’ve been dreaming of a house there since I was a kid.” Roger’s mom paused wistfully, briefly lost in thought. A woman who could have raced in her own right, she was a fierce competitor, and this translated to the support and confidence she poured into Roger. Back from her reverie, she continued, “There will be a lot to celebrate soon, we’re so proud of you hun.” His mother leaned over and added a soft touch on Roger’s shoulder with a loving smile.</p><p>Roger enjoyed talking about colleges and real estate even less than he liked talking about the race. His family seemed oblivious to his predilections.</p><p>“Yes, we have full faith in you. You’re a Greene. You were still learning your first year and last year was a fluke. This is your year.” Roger’s dad finally smiled and patted Roger on the shoulder too as he got up to put away his empty plate.</p><p>“Go Bucks!” Shouted his younger brother, “It’s so cool you might be training with Flash Hopkins at the U. Wish I could.”</p><p>Roger’s dad returned to the table to pick up everyone’s now empty plates and said to Roger’s brother, “You’ll be starting with Marv next week, and he taught Flash everything he knows. Won’t be long until you’ll be the family’s racer, and as your mom said, maybe starting from first next year if all goes well this week.” Roger’s dad winked at Roger with an attempt at a reassuring smile.</p><p>All Roger could muster with a full mouth and avoiding his parents’ gaze was a feeble, “uhhuh. First.”</p><p>“How you feelin’?” Roger’s voice was muffled by his locker as he was digging through its detritus. Even the harsh artificial light from the school’s hallway couldn’t pierce the jungle inside his locker. And his mind was just as cluttered, he could not remember whether he even brought it to school with him today, even though he had arrived just minutes ago. The possibility it was lying on his bedroom floor was becoming increasingly likely.</p><p>“‘Bout?” Josie said casually. She was leaning against the locker next to his, inspecting some dirt under her front hoof to pass the time, waiting for him to get his book so they could get to first period.</p><p>Roger’s confusion from her response made him momentarily pause the futile search. His question seemed unambiguous. Everyone racing for their family tomorrow should have only had one thing on their mind, and this one thing was making everyone anxious, he could see it as his classmates walked through the school’s halls, their typical masks of confidence cracking at the edges with nervous side glances and uneven breathing. This was also true for Roger, as the race anxiety was certainly the source of his absentmindedness.</p><p>But then Roger remembered tonight’s race committee meeting, and he felt like a bad friend not realizing how much the vote could impact her personally.</p><p>“Tomorrow. My family’s really stressin’ me out. And not just about the race. Can’t even get through this week without them reminding me that apps come back next week or looking at new houses. It’s not like I don’t have enough on my mind already. And they expect me to move to first.” He had finally given up on the search for his missing book, closed his locker, and turned to face Josie.</p><p>“Only got three spots to go, are you certain you don’t want to trade me starts? Your family, and the entire village, would be even more impressed if you win from 17th. Just imagine the glory Rog, you’d be in the history books.” She ended with an elbow to his ribs and a wry smile.</p><p>Josie often joked about their respective start positions, but Roger suspected it really grated her. It was just easier for them to not directly address how he started at 4th position when he became the family’s racer two years ago and though he didn’t drop a position, he hadn’t moved up. Whereas she moved her family from 24th to 17th in the same span, making her the first gazelle to finish in the top 20 and consequently, the only gazelle scheduled to start in the top 20 tomorrow. That is, if the measure didn’t pass.</p><p>“So you don’t think it’s gonna pass tonight? Sounds like the vote might be close, thanks to your uncle’s campaigning.” Roger responded, ignoring Josie’s comment.</p><p>“I’ve learned to not get my hopes up, even with this half-measure. James still wishes he could have gone with the original plan but it was hard enough to convince Commissioner West to bring this watered-down version to the race committee. Worthless group of spineless buffaloes.” Josie ignored Roger’s raised eyebrows at the crass insult and continued, “Anyways, my job is to race, and I intend to do just that tomorrow. You finally ready for class? Or do you need me to send in a search and rescue team to help?”</p><p>“I’m giving up, I’m sure Ms. Cassidy will give racers some grace for being a little forgetful. And I can’t be the only one that won’t particularly care about Grazing Studies today. Hey, screw you scat head.”</p><p>As Roger and Josie had turned to leave for class a large deer, bigger than Roger’s dad in both girth and mass, shouldered Josie into the lockers as he walked past. The hulking deer turned around as he was walking away and said, “hey ‘zelle, how’s the effort to cheat going? Couldn’t get into the top-10 by yourself, you needed to steal spots from deers?” A group of other deer snickered around this one.</p><p>Without missing a beat Josie replied forcefully, “You couldn’t beat me if you had rockets attached to that fat ass Dwight. What are you so scared of? How slow you are finally being exposed?”</p><p>Dwight was a member of one of the oldest families in the village, tracing back to its founding, long before the Pack Equalization Movement. His family also typically finished and started towards the front of the race. Dwight inherited spot 5 a few years ago but had slipped his family back to 9 over those years, where he’d start tomorrow barring the measure passing.</p><p>Dwight also had one redeeming quality in making unintentionally entertaining faces. His face was a clear window into what his mind was thinking, and it was not the quickest of minds. Like watching a Rube Goldberg machine, one could see the haphazard and confused inner workings of his thought process. And right now, from Josie’s retort, Dwight was going from startled, to offended, to angry. Which would have been more entertaining if Dwight hadn’t stopped walking away and instead approached Josie in slow deliberate steps and pushed his hoof into her chest.</p><p>“I’m going to kick your ass so hard tomorrow, your family is going to regret ever thinking ‘zelles can compete on the same level, and I intend to prove it on the track.”</p><p>“And even if you start 9th, I’m going to show you how slow and fat your ass really is, no matter what I do.” Josie, though substantially smaller and leaner than Dwight, was not backing down, which did not surprise Roger. At least Josie still had her two menacing horns while Dwight was still regrowing his antlers from the winter shed. A remnant of the race’s speciesist past was that it occurred in spring, when the deer were even lighter and more agile without their antlers.</p><p>Roger wanted to intervene but he knew Josie had to show herself and the world she could and would do anything anybody else could, and Josie would never forgive him if he didn’t let her. So when she pushed her hoof into Dwight’s chest, Roger became concerned this was reaching a point of no return for the stubborn competitors.</p><p>But fate intervened and the bell rang, breaking the spell of the herd gathered around the two and a flurry of students rushed to class. Dwight gave Josie one last look before walking away.</p><p>Josie watched Dwight walk away without blinking, moving, or saying anything until he was out of sight. She then relaxed ever so slightly and looked at Roger, visibly more tired than she was moments ago.</p><p>Roger spoke first, “Wanna just ditch? I could use some fresh air and a coffee to clear my mind. And our Grazing quiz isn’t until next week, we can catch up later.”</p><p>She took a deep breath and responded, “Yeah, I could use a break. Let’s do it.”</p><p>The air was still cool as the two walked to coffee. Though it had not rained for a couple days, the mild spring temperature kept the moisture in the air and in the soil underhoof. The magnolia trees dotting downtown were also blooming with an optimism Roger found annoying in light of his stress. He told himself he would finally be allowed to enjoy spring tomorrow after the race.</p><p>Roger and Josie entered the coffee shop after walking around the grandstands being constructed just in front of the shops lining Victors’ Road, opposite the tree and pond filled park where they could also see the scoreboard being erected. As they entered, the smell of freshly brewed coffee immediately calmed Roger’s senses. They both ordered, avoiding eye contact with any adults in case a roving school official was present, and grabbed their favorite seats in the back of the shop where they could still see Victors’ Road through the partially constructed grandstands.</p><p>The starting stretch already had all of the families’ flags where their respective racers would start tomorrow. Because the shop was towards the beginning of Victors’ Road, Roger could not make out his and Josie’s family flags further down, nearer to the antler arch at the end of Victors’ Road, before the road turned into the race’s track leading not far beyond into the dense forest. The flags closest to him moved rhythmically from being tossed excitedly in the cool spring breeze, as if they had started their own pre-race warm up. He wondered absentmindedly whose job it was to put the flags up, and that they must have assumed tonight’s vote would not result in having to take them all down.</p><p>After a long moment of silence where the friends slowly took sips of their drinks, both lost in their own thoughts, Josie broke the spell saying, “do you think it’s fair?”</p><p>“What?” The only response that came to his mind after a brief pause.</p><p>“This.” Josie swept her right front hoof across the view of the start to indicate the race.</p><p>He paused longer to contemplate the complicated question.</p><p>“Of course it isn’t.” He said, shaking his head slightly for emphasis.</p><p>“Why?” she pressed.</p><p>He paused even longer and considered all the pressure his family had put him under, Marv’s rants, his constant tiredness, the need to win rations for his family, and his future. And all he wanted to do was sit quietly by himself and read his comic books.</p><p>Roger finally said, “It’s not fair because my dad’s expecting me to not only keep our family’s top 5 spot, but to end first. My mom is constantly reminding me what’s at stake, how I need to go to a good school, and how first place rations would help pay for it, or for a new house, or for my siblings’ schooling. I barely sleep at night, and when I do sleep, I dream about the track and how I can run it faster. I feel a breakdown is around every corner but I have to push all emotions away because my family is depending on me. And I didn’t ask for any of this. I much rather be doing really anything else, but I have no choice. So no, it’s not fair.”</p><p>Roger had never shared these feelings with anyone for fear of humiliation. Racers were expected to be hardened competitors, with no concerns but winning. Getting this out felt both good and made him angry, a rage emitting from somewhere he imagined his soul resided. But he could not name exactly the target of his anger. It certainly wasn’t Josie. Though now looking at her, Roger thought she may think that to be the case. She had started crying quietly into her drink and looked up at him, tears slowly rolling down her narrow cheeks. This was certainly something he’d never seen her do in all their years of friendship, and so he was lost for how to react and just stared dumbly at her.</p><p>After a long pause Josie looked up at Roger with resolve in her watering eyes. “Don’t you think everyone is under that pressure? Have you thought at all what it’s like for me, or any other gazelle? Dwight, you, every deer likes to talk about what’s fair to them. But how is it fair that I start 17th? I’m faster than you Rog, I hate to say it, but it’s true. I’m certainly faster than Dwight and everyone else in the top 10. And how about the other gazelles? More of them should be in the top 20 just by pure numbers, and yet most gazelles start after position 70. That’s seven-zero. Look at all the flags at this end — do you even recognize these families? They all live in the outskirts on or near Laggards Lane, and are mostly gazelle families.</p><p>“Either you believe gazelles are naturally slower, which I know you don’t, or there’s something fundamentally wrong. But the system makes even families like yours, who start towards the top and who have the most power and responsibility to change it, are distracted by keeping up with the Joneses, sending their kids to the most expensive schools and buying a bigger house, while many gazelles are concerned about paying rent and feeding their children. And if even you can’t see that, my best friend who I know deep down believes in species equality, what possible hope do we have of changing the system?”</p><p>Josie’s voice started to get broken up by deep breaths and light sobs while she was talking, and other customers started to take notice of the students in the corner. Josie seemed unfazed by the attention, who now stared at Roger with pleading eyes, searching for some response in his face.</p><p>“Well, I don’t know about faster than me,” he said with a small smile, trying to inject some levity into the tense situation. When that didn’t faze her, he continued.</p><p>“I don’t know what to say Jos. It sucks, it really does. Especially for you. I know how hard you work. But I work hard too, and what has that gotten me? And even if I wanted to do something about the race, what could I do? I’m just one deer. This race has been going on long before me, and will be going on long after us.”</p><p>Josie replied with quiet force, “Anything, Roger. Do anything. Just don’t do nothing. I gotta go, I guess I’ll have to do it without you.”</p><p>Josie got up to leave. Roger grabbed her arm and she stared at him, her eyes now red. He tried to give her a smile and say something reassuring but tore her arm away and left. He sat in silence for a few minutes, turning over her words in his head, unsure how he felt. He was angry, at no one and everyone. Why couldn’t he just enjoy his life? Why did he always have to compete, compete, compete? This wasn’t like the old days where families had to work every waking hour to just survive. His village certainly had enough for everyone who worked for it, yet Josie was right, some still struggled to eat.</p><p>He couldn’t finish his thought because he noticed a teacher approaching the coffee shop and realized it was almost second period. He definitely couldn’t skip his math class if he wanted to be ready for the engineering program at the U. Roger threw away his coffee cup, exited the shop into the still cool but warming mid-morning air, and headed back to the school even more tired than when he entered the first time that day, something he hadn’t thought was possible.</p><p>The room was crowded as the last of the day’s orange light filtered through the tinted windows. The hundred or so seats were not nearly enough for the crowd of at least double that. It seemed to Roger like the entire village was present for the vote — deer and gazelles of all ages were crammed into City Hall, with most attendees having to stand against the back walls or in the aisles throughout the meeting. Active racers were guaranteed a seat so Roger and his family had been sitting towards the middle on the left side of the room. But Roger hadn’t seen Josie or her family all night. They had to be there but the standing-room-only crowd made it difficult for him to see everyone present.</p><p>Roger had a clear view of at least one family: Dwight’s. Dwight’s dad served as the chair of the Scales Subcommittee, overseeing the racer weigh-in process. Since the passing of the Pack Equalization Amendment requiring racers to weigh the same during the race, all racers must weigh-in before the race and add or remove weights from their race pack until they are at race weight. Dwight’s dad oversees this process and maintains the scales at their house between races. Because of Dwight’s dad’s position his family sat closer to the front, a few rows ahead of Roger. Dwight’s large head was also generally hard to miss.</p><p>Village members had been addressing the race committee on the measure. An old deer, one older and somehow even more grizzled than Marv, was then rambling on into the microphone in the front row aisle facing the committee members. Roger prayed silently to himself that this would be the last speaker, he still needed to do his pre-race stretching before trying to get some much needed sleep tonight and the uncomfortable City Hall chairs were not helping his muscles.</p><p>“In closing, this is plain and simple speciesist. The proposed modifications for a mass start would disproportionately hurt one species in order to benefit another. Families would lose the advantage they have accrued over generations of hard work. I moved my family into the top 20, where my grandson will start tomorrow, ahead of over a hundred other racers. But with this misguided measure, he would be forced to start with everyone, completely erasing his hard work, his dad’s hard work, my hard work, and everyone else in our family that got us here. This is true for some gazelle families, but many more deer families will be hurt. This clearly violates the amendment to the village’s charter explicitly outlawing specieism, especially in the race.</p><p>“I understand and empathize with the underlying motivation. It was a travesty what happened so many years ago, when gazelles had to race with heavier packs, but nobody here was alive then and specieism no longer exists. Until this proposal. The way to stop discrimination on the basis of species is to stop discriminating on the basis of species.”</p><p>There was raucous applause from some of the deer in the audience. Dwight’s dad stood up and whistled his approval, clapping harder than any other deer. Most of the speakers had been against the measure so Dwight’s dad was getting some exercise in all the standing up he had been doing. Dwight though seemed surprisingly less engaged than his father. He clapped, but Roger could tell it was halfhearted. And the back of his head was not giving any clues to his inner thoughts. Maybe Dwight was already getting mentally ready for the race Roger thought to himself.</p><p>The chair said, “Thank you, Robert T. Our last speaker on the measure is Josie M.”</p><p>Roger’s head snapped to the dais. He had no idea she was planning to speak, she had made no mention of it that morning at coffee. A feeling of terror began to crawl up his skin, coming to rest in his throat. He was confident nothing could come out of his mouth were it him at the microphone. And she was already getting so much negative attention from from her uncle’s efforts, Roger could not understand why she would risk even more scorn.</p><p>Josie walked slowly and deliberately from her hidden position in the standing crowd in the back up to the microphone in the front. The murmuring and chattering from the prior speaker ceased to an uneasy quiet.</p><p>Josie cleared her throat and spoke slowly and clearly into the microphone, the emotion from this morning replaced with steely resolve. “Thank you Chair Jones. With all due respect to my uncle, I speak tonight in opposition to his proposed measure.” The quiet was broken and she had to pause to allow the muffled conversations of confusion bubbling up throughout the overcrowded room to end.</p><p>She finally continued, “My family has been in this village since its founding. My great-great-grandad laid some of the bricks in these walls. My great uncle James Sr. was a leader in the Pack Equalization Movement, and was the first gazelle to move his family into the top 50 after the Pack Equalization Amendment was passed. I feel I have continued my family’s history by personally excelling in the race. So, I embody both the inequity of the past and the promise of the future.</p><p>“But tonight, I would like to say the strongest feeling I have is that I am tired. I am so tired of having to talk about this. I did not choose to be me. I did not choose to be the subject of all of your whispers. Nor did I choose to be on your pedestals. I did not choose to start 24th last year or to start 17th this year. I did not choose any of this. These are the results of choices made by others. My only choice has been to work hard for my family. As many of my peers have done as well. But nobody in this village can challenge how hard I work. Day in and day out I am out on the training grounds before everyone else. And yet, this is not enough for you. My effort is not enough for you to see what’s wrong. To feel in your soul the pain that I do when I have to line up behind dozens of others that have not worked as hard as me. To know I have to work twice as hard to be in the same spot as someone working half as hard as me.</p><p>“And many supporters of this measure would assume a mass start would fix the problem. But that only covers it up. The main aspects of this measure have been whittled down to be just palatable enough to make it to tonight’s vote. So, even if it does pass, it will not address the underlying problem: the history that weighs down so many in this village like an anchor, or more precisely, like a heavy pack. Even if we have a mass start, many who show up tomorrow will still have not started from the same place. The training, coaching, and other resources and support are dependent on the rations, and many come from families with decades of lower rations for speciesist reasons. Ignoring this history is like ignoring the rot infecting a tree. Just trimming some leaves is not enough.</p><p>“Yet the opposers to this proposal do not draw my ire as much as those in this village who do nothing. Who tell me in the streets you’re rooting for me. Those that feel putting banners on their houses supporting this proposal is all they need to do, that allows them to sleep well at night with dreams they are helping achieve equality. If you really fought for what you believed there would be no race. There would be real sacrifice. This village would truly support each other regardless of privileged starts inherited through a family. Where all basic needs are met, not based on ability, or through inheritance, or with prejudice.</p><p>“So I oppose this proposal because it pretends justice will be served, and I know nothing else will be done after it. Instead of equalizing our village, it merely entrenches the historical inequity that pervades this village. The only way to stop discrimination on the basis of species is to stop pretending discrimination on the basis of species doesn’t exist. There are too many here who think all was made fair after the equalization amendment, or actively choose to ignore reality. But just stopping the fire didn’t also rebuild the house. And I am done waiting for you all to wake up.”</p><p>When she finished the room was silent. All that could be heard was her hooves lightly clacking as she slowly walked out of the room. Then the low murmur of conspiratorial whispers began and the chair had to bang his gavel to quiet everyone. Roger did not need to be quieted, it was the second time in a day Josie had stunned him into silence.</p><p>The chair then said, “With no more speakers, the committee will now take the vote.”</p><p>It wasn’t even close. The measure failed to pass with the committee voting 7–2 against. Nobody seemed surprised, but that did not matter to the opponents of the measure as they loudly clapped and hooted their approval. Dwight’s dad again led the charge with a seemingly even more subdued Dwight not even clapping this time. After the cheers calmed down the crowd of villagers began shuffling out of City Hall.</p><p>Roger couldn’t concern himself with Dwight’s mentality when conflict reigned in his own mind. Roger could not deny a modicum of relief sat in a dark corner of his heart. He would start 4th tomorrow and did not have to worry about having to beat over a hundred others at the same time. Even if he ran a horrible race it was nearly impossible for him to finish outside of the top 10. And Josie’s opposition to the measure permitted him to briefly think this was okay. But the falsity of this belief was clear, and only redoubled with the shame he ignored from the morning that now rapidly ate away any sense of comfort. He knew Josie was right, even that dark corner couldn’t conceal the truth. But there was nothing he could do now, even if he wanted to, it was too late. The race was just mere hours away now and, he reminded himself assuringly, he was just one deer.</p><p>“Next!” The race official’s yell indicated she was losing her patience.</p><p>The line of agitated bodies bobbing back and forth moved slightly forward. Being towards the back of the weigh-in line granted Roger a clear view of the collective anxiety of the racers that would start behind him. They were lined up in reverse race order on the other side of Victors’ Road from the grandstands, under the shadow of the now built scoreboard, heading towards the scale near the antler arch. The racers mostly had headphones and warmup attire on, looking like they were heading into battle. Expressionless faces attempting to subdue cerebral demons.</p><p>Roger was also getting into his race headspace by working through his series of meditations and race visualizations, without getting distracted by the routine frustrations of the racers weighing in at the front, many having to put additional weights in their packs. He also tried to ignore the desire to talk with Josie, who he could see 13 racers ahead of him. It would be against race customs to chat with anyone, even friends.</p><p>Roger also didn’t know what he could say. His body and soul were exhausted. Tossing and turning all night, his thoughts bounced from vignettes of him practicing parts of the track, to Josie’s red and crying face, to Dwight’s laughing sneer, to his parents loving but concerned gazes, back to the track and his race strategy. And in this merry-go-round of anxiety he had practiced a few versions of conversations with Josie. None of them ended well. He typically started with “I’m sorry,” but this always led to questions of what he was sorry for, and what he could do about it. Questions he did not have answers to.</p><p>When seeing the real Josie in person, Roger felt loss for words for the first time in their friendship. Through his sleepless night he understood something had shifted yesterday, a small chasm had opened up between them. They were now living on different lands, and the terrain between was unexplored.</p><p>Maybe the chasm was always there and Roger just didn’t notice, or didn’t want to notice. Maybe Josie had always known the separateness of their worlds and Roger’s obliviousness to it.</p><p>But this was yet another puzzle he had to wait to solve until after the race. Right now he needed to get his mind back on track, literally. He had put too much time in training over the last year, a year that started with him barely holding on to his current position, something Marv and his dad constantly reminded him of. And too much was riding on him to move up this year.</p><p>He instinctively looked towards the stands and after a few moments, found his family sitting even to where he’d be starting. All held their little flags with the Greene family’s crest — green ivy wrapped around golden antlers on a yellow background. His siblings were on the edge of their seats, excitedly bouncing up and down and playing sword fight with the flags, oblivious to the importance of his performance on their future. His mother smiling proudly waving her flag to the beat of the pre-race music playing through nearby speakers. And his dad was talking animatedly with Josie’s dad, a tall and slender gazelle with impending horns, likely debating race strategy as they often did. He was holding a flag with Josie’s family crest — silver scales with a deer hoof in one and a gazelle hoof in another weighing the same, all on a purple background.</p><p>The race official waved Roger forward, it was now his turn to weigh-in, but seeing his family only made the swirling in his head pick up speed. He had to stop it. He could not control anybody else but him. As the official put in his start number into the scale and he stood on it with his pack, he girded himself with determination. All he could do was try his best to win, and that’s what he would do. Not for his family or anybody else, but for himself, even if seeing his dad’s proud smile if he finished first would be a life accomplishment. After the race official added some weight pellets to his pack to get him to the equalized race weight, Roger stepped off the scale with a new resolve.</p><p>As Roger walked the short distance from weigh-in to his start position, he felt lighter. Racing wasn’t that complicated — whoever was the fastest was the fastest. He certainly sympathized with Josie, his best friend who he could see stretching 13 spots away. There were only deer starting in front of her, and that was hard to ignore. But everything she said was for others to worry about. His job was to race, and he planned on doing just that.</p><p>Roger slung his race pack on and adjusted the straps to make sure the weight was tight against his back and well distributed. Feeling the pack’s weight he temporarily lost his feeling of lightness as he had to again suppress the dark corner of his heart that briefly wished for the days deers didn’t have to be the same weight, especially as he gave one last look to his family. They were all now concentrated on the track as the final racers got to their spots. Everyone noticed when he looked up and they in unison started waving their flags. Roger could hear his dad yell the family motto, “Mean, Lean, and Greene!” Roger smiled and inclined his head in acknowledgement, the lightness in his body fading even more.</p><p>The starting announcement then came over the loudspeaker.</p><p>“Racers to your marks.”</p><p>All background noise faded from Roger’s attention as he narrowed his focus on the race track ahead and listened for the announcers next words. Even in this brief space he couldn’t stop his mind from doing one more loop — parents’ expectations, race strategy on the first turn, Josie’s frustration, race strategy on the next turn. But with one final deep breath, he was able to settle his resolve — no matter what, he was going to win.</p><p>“Go!”</p><p>“What did you do?” Roger pleaded with Josie again between deep breaths he was still taking to recover on weakened legs. Roger had said it a second time with a little more heat and anger than the first time. He stared at his closest friend as more racers collapsed between them, someone he thought he knew better than anyone else until yesterday. Though she still had a faint grin of amusement, the exhaustion in her body and soul was evident to him, and mirrored his own exhaustion. But he could not understand why she would do this.</p><p>Actually, the answer was obvious as his tired brain remembered snippets of her speech from last night, and their conversation at the coffee shop, and all the other occasions she discussed the race.</p><p>The bigger mystery then became how she could have done this. How could she have possibly made race results for gazelles and deer so differently.</p><p>Josie looked at Roger with her hint of joy sliding to resolve as she began to speak. But just as she opened her mouth, she stopped and looked behind him, her expression slowly becoming more serious.</p><p>Roger looked over his shoulder towards the stands. The realization that gazelles were over performing and deers were underperforming had worked its way through the entire crowd like a repugnant smell. Some were now standing up, pointing at the scoreboard while yelling, and others started to move from their seats in the grandstands down onto the track. Dwight’s dad was one of the first bounding on the track towards Roger and Josie. That’s when Roger noticed Dwight was one of the bodies lying on the ground not far from Josie. His only movements were large, rapid breaths. Dwight’s dad bent down over Dwight’s prone body to check his well-being, talking to him quietly. Josie and Roger both watched him intently.</p><p>Dwight’s dad then turned toward Josie and bellowed, “This is your fault. What did you do to him?!”</p><p>Josie was caught off guard and could only issue a soft, breathless stammer, “I didn’t do anything.” Then she took another deep breath, added more emphatically, and almost as if answering Roger’s questions at the same time: “but win.”</p><p>“Buffalo shit!” he retorted.</p><p>Dwight’s dad was much bigger than her, and he stood up as tall as possible as he walked away from his incapacitated son towards Josie, pointing an accusatory hoof. Though smaller and exhausted, Josie still had her fighting spirit, and a pair of horns she again looked ready to use for the second time in less than a day against the same family.</p><p>A group of other deer who had been checking on their family members now started forming around Josie and Dwight’s dad, and they all looked to be of the same mind.</p><p>Roger moved closer to the group and as he did he realized he still had his pack on. He unbuckled it, slid it off his back, and a thought instantly materialized, exploding in his mind like a firecracker. It all made sense. How the race was manipulated. Why it was done. What it proved. And the ending conclusion of the train of thought being how he had been wrong. Oh so wrong. The firecracker had blown away all illusions of his innocence.</p><p>He stood there dazed and confused, his tired body, mind, and soul processing the profound realizations and what he could do. Roger looked around for Josie’s dad or any other gazelles that could lend support but he could not see anyone through the crowd of enclosing deer.</p><p>Roger had to act. He was left without alternatives. Even if he was just one deer, he had no other choice.</p><p>Roger closed his eyes, took a few more deep breaths, mustered up what little strength remained, and pushed himself through the crowd to stand in front of Dwight’s dad just as he was starting to advance closer to Josie. Roger stared at him, took one more deep breath, and said as loudly as he could, “It was Dwight.”</p><p>Roger quickly looked over his shoulder at Josie, who did not look surprised and who kept her eyes on Dwight’s dad. Roger assumed she had already figured it out and this knowledge was the source of her now absent mirth.</p><p>Dwight’s dad was only temporarily stunned,“Nonsense. Stop trying to protect your little friend Greene. We all know she’s been trying to mess with the race.”</p><p>Roger turned back around towards Dwight’s dad and continued, “I just now put it together when I was taking off my pack. I was so distracted by my race preparations that I didn’t notice I had to put extra weight in my pack, more than I should have needed even though the scale said I was at race weight. And I remember many other deer seeming frustrated they had to too. This is why all the deer are more exhausted than normal, and ran slower races. I’m guessing the scale was messed with to appear lighter when deer race numbers were inputted, so our packs were heavier during the race. But there’s no way Josie could have tampered with it, the race scales are protected by the chair of the Scales Subcommittee. That’s you.”</p><p>The older deer finally stopped his advancement towards Josie to process these words. Dwight’s trait of clearly showing his thought processes must have been inherited from his dad as the father’s face showed mental calculations being performed morphing his face from one of anger to one of confusion, and then one of unpleasantly coming to terms with distasteful news. He then looked in his son’s direction, who was now blocked by the crowd.</p><p>The crowd around them had also grown to include some gazelles and everyone had started angrily murmuring after Roger’s accusations.</p><p>After a long pause, Dwight’s dad said, “Even if someone other than me could access the scale, why would anybody, especially my son, purposefully make it harder for deer? He’s nearly dead!”</p><p>Roger, gaining confidence and strength in equal measures responded, “I dunno for sure, but I’m guessing you and him believe deer would have still beaten gazelles in the past if you were the ones with the extra weight, so why do gazelles complain so much? I think he wanted to prove that theory right, once and for all, especially after last night. I noticed he was unusually quiet at the meeting, bet he was angry at even having to be there and formulated a plan. But it didn’t go quite as planned, did it? I can sympathize. If I’m being honest, I’ve had to suppress some similar thoughts because all of this is not my fault — I didn’t design the race, I didn’t force gazelles to wear heavier packs decades ago, I’m not a speciesist. But today proved I can no longer ignore the race is unfair today because it was unfair then. Advantages and disadvantages were solidified. I still benefit now and that benefit makes it my responsibility to help fix it. It took until right now, nearly dying out there with a heavier pack, for me to fully learn that lesson. I’m not sure where we go from now, but the race clearly must change.”</p><p>Roger took a deep breath of relief, an even heavier weight than his pack seemed lifted off his back. Before he could muster even more courage to turn and look at Josie, she walked slowly past Roger and approached Dwight’s dad and said directly to his face, “Thwarted by your own prejudice, how perfect. I have some ideas on what we do now, and most of them involve your dumb son starting far behind me.”</p><p>“Ain’t no way that’s happening honey. I’m calling a meeting of the race committee to plan a race redo, which is clearly called for in the bylaws.” A little of Dwight’s dad’s fight came back to him.</p><p>Then a weak voice spoke. “Dad, stop.”</p><p>All heads turned to Dwight, who had just worked himself through the crowd to stand beside his dad. His body language still showed his typical arrogant defiance, but his hard edges seemed softened, standing hunched and wobbling slightly, and still trying to get full control of his breath.</p><p>“I’m sorry ... I didn’t think this would happen” he said looking at his dad speaking quieter than normal with a breathless rasp.</p><p>Dwight then said louder, as if trying to address the entire crowd that had been growing restless: “but she was being so … so annoying, I just needed to shut her up. I know y’all felt the same way, even if you didn’t say anything.” Dwight’s facial expressions showed a brief hint of his old pompousness, then with a slow turn back into tired resignation, he faced just his dad again.</p><p>“But that … that sucked. I’ve never tried so hard at this stupid thing, and I was passed by ... them. I dunno what we should do now, I know I’m still faster but I’m done fighting this stupid fight, I want us to win fair and square, whatever that requires.” Dwight then turned slowly to face Josie, uncertain on his legs, and said, “You’re still annoying, but maybe not as dumb as I thought.” Dwight gave her a quick nod and walked through crowd, away from the track.</p><p>Dwight’s dad looked angrier than before, but then the fight slowly drained from him too and he appeared more like his weary son. He gave one last look at Roger and Josie and said, “This isn’t over.” He then pushed his way through the crowd to follow his son.</p><p>The crowd around the group started to dissipate as families turned to help their still recovering racers off the track on uneasy legs.</p><p>It then was just Roger and Josie left standing there, still watching where Dwight and his dad disappearing into the crowd. Roger wanted to say something but the words were still stuck in his throat. Josie then spotted her dad and walked to him, who gave her a big embrace. He could hear him say, “Good job honey, proud of you.”</p><p>Roger finally mustered up the last bit of courage and walked up to the pair. Josie’s dad whispered something else in her ear and she turned around. Her dad getting a sense of what was coming gave the two some privacy and walked over to Roger’s dad who had just appeared, both likely wanting to debate the day’s news.</p><p>Josie turned around and looked at Roger expectantly, but the words were even harder for him to say now.</p><p>Josie finally said, “Spit it out Greene.”</p><p>He then said the two hardest words he had said that day, “I’m sorry.”</p><p>She thought for a second, then with a smile said, “Better late than never.”</p><p>The fall air was a welcomed change. The rains had not yet started in earnest so the ground was still firm from the warm summer they’d had. Much to Roger’s appreciation during training sessions, this left the forest track more like the village streets than the mush he had to run through last time. This was the only change that may be easier.</p><p>Standing on Victors’ Road, Roger was in a more difficult position in many ways. Physically, he still had his antlers, requiring a change in strategy not even Marv had experience with. He also had college right around the corner. Not something he had allowed himself to get fully stressed about due to the events leading to today’s race.</p><p>Most importantly was the change evident to Roger as he looked down Victors’ Road at the over hundred racers starting ahead of him. The dark corner of his soul nagged again on whether the right decisions were made over the last half-year, giving up the second start position for this crazy seven-year experiment. But Josie had sacrificed even more, yet again. This was the least he could do. He also couldn’t pass up the opportunity to shut her up as she had not stopped reminding him she had beaten him. And if Roger pointed out his pack had been heavier all she would say is, “that sounds so unfair, poor Roger” in a mocking tone.</p><p>Right on cue he heard Josie yell from a little distance behind him, “Ready to lose to me again, chump?”</p><p>Roger turned around and tried yelling seriously, “Not gunna happen.” But his stern face cracked and the friends exchanged a quick smile before getting back into the race mentality.</p><p>Roger took one more glance at the stands and immediately found his family, with his mom and siblings waving their flags while Roger’s and Josie’s dads were in deep conversation again, likely debating what their children agreed to. There was a lot of debating happening in Roger’s household as of late.</p><p>“Racers to your marks!”</p><p>Who knows, maybe next year his brother would be running through an archway with the new town motto he and Josie proposed to the council: “Privilege is the burden.” But that’s another concern for later. Roger dug in his hooves, narrowed his eyes, took a deep breath, and listened. This time, he’d really win.</p><p>“Go!”</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=37617f1bf5de" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Children’s Book for Trump’s America: Loyalty!]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@connerjohnston/a-childrens-book-for-trump-s-america-loyalty-dd3d851ccadc?source=rss-84f33af0b11c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/dd3d851ccadc</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[loyalty]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fascism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[democracy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[satire]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trump]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Conner Johnston]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 12 Feb 2025 20:50:28 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-02-13T18:46:01.997Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>One parent’s effort to help teach kids (and adults) the only value that matters now for success.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_euFz592Hs0KL3eC99amcg.jpeg" /><figcaption>AI Image Generated with DALL-E</figcaption></figure><p>What a time we live in! I, like many, are having whiplash trying to adjust to this new reality where the constitution is just a suggestion, diversity causes planes to crash, and Gaza will be the next Florida. As the parent of a two-year old I’m having a particularly hard time figuring out how to prepare my child for the future. The kids books I have been reading him seem woefully inadequate now in instilling the correct values. Honesty? Sharing? Love? If you want to succeed in this world, as many in Trump’s cabinet can attest, those values won’t get you far. Unquestioned loyalty is now the golden ticket.</p><p>In striving to be a good parent, I have written a kids book for this new reality. Maybe it can also help your little citizen, or even you, succeed in Trump’s America!</p><p>Hello children, gather ‘round,<br>Have you learned what’s right and sound?<br>Being kind and always sharing,<br>Helping others, love, and caring?<br>Being honest, speaking true?<br>Is this what all good kids should do?</p><p>Well forget all that, throw it away!<br>Those virtues won’t help you today.<br>Kindness, truth, protect the meek?<br>Those values make you look so weak!<br>Here’s the simple path to victory:<br>Ignore all values, devote loyalty!</p><p>For we’ve a leader strong and tall,<br>Who promises to help us all.<br>As long as you follow this one key rule,<br>No, not tell the truth or try in school,<br>All you need is to bend a knee,<br>Swear your soul and show loyalty!</p><p>See, JD wrote a book about the poor,<br>Called our leader Hitler, what a snore!<br>Then wanted power, didn’t know how<br>Easy, to get VP he just took a bow<br>Loyalty made all of his wrongs right<br>Dedicated, he’s now, to our leader’s might!</p><p>Pete wanted secretary of defense<br>But his dark past made others tense<br>Problems drinking and mean to women<br>No experience with budgets or leadin’<br>But none of that got in his way<br>Loyalty got him the job, hooray!</p><p>RFK’s brain has worms and crazy views<br>Thinks science and vaccines are fake news<br>But wanted to lead the agency of health<br>No qualifications, only family name and wealth<br>Quit prez race and endorsed, that’s the key<br>He then achieved his dreams with loyalty!</p><p>Poor Elon was not rich enough<br>Hated competition, tried to show he’s tough<br>Bought Twitter to distort the story<br>But how could he achieve real lasting glory?<br>To get richer and do his Nazi thing,<br>He knew the trick: just kiss the ring!</p><p>Even Christians understand the game<br>Christ used love for the poor and the lame<br>But Christians want power to impose their will<br>Focus on abortions, think gays aren’t chill<br><a href="https://medium.com/@connerjohnston/faith-and-politics-at-a-crossroads-b8d1eeb3aa33">They ignored all of our leader’s hate and spite<br>And told their flock: vote for him, he’s alright!</a></p><p>Many others have gotten a clue<br>Devoting loyalty will only help you<br>Mayor of New York committing crime<br>Insurrectionists serving their time<br>The entire Republican party being his tool<br>Values are dumb, unquestioned loyalty’s cool!</p><p>So listen up kids, don’t miss this lesson<br>Don’t have values, I’m not messin’<br>Being kind, caring, giving others your love<br>That’s old news, give those the shove<br>There’s only one way now to not be a chump<br>Worship at the altar of our dear leader Trump!</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=dd3d851ccadc" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Faith and Politics at a Crossroads]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@connerjohnston/faith-and-politics-at-a-crossroads-b8d1eeb3aa33?source=rss-84f33af0b11c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b8d1eeb3aa33</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[christianity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[spirituality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[faith]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Conner Johnston]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 18 Oct 2024 21:50:09 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-10-22T20:13:39.569Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*7a1VxWZtgMlGWQIm_XNrNw.jpeg" /><figcaption>AI Image Generated with DALL-E</figcaption></figure><h4><em>Another liberal Christian reexamines their faith in the era of Trump.</em></h4><p>“Bill Clinton wants to kill babies” was my takeaway from my parent’s debate over the 1996 election. My ten-year old brain may have not fully understood the nuances of the discussion, but I clearly remember my parents’ incredulity of each others’ intended vote. Politics and religion may not mix for some, but the two subjects were unavoidable in my household. My parents are passionate about their beliefs and they passed on that passion to their children. We were raised to lead with our heart, serve others, and think for ourselves.</p><p>My faith and politics are core to my identity to this day. At least since college, my Christian faith has been the motivation to serve others and my progressive politics was the means to do so. I went to church and attended Obama rallies. I went to Bible study and campaigned for marriage equality. I prayed before marching against police brutality. And through this all I have been keenly aware many American Cristians do not share my politics. That had not matter to me because I was leading with my heart, serving others, and thinking for myself.</p><p>Unfortunately he changed this. He being the one that has changed many things in this country — Donald J. Trump. His concurrent embrace and subversion of Christian values, while still garnering massive Christian support, has forced me to reevaluate my identities and ask a very difficult questions: Have I been misguided in trying to render consistent inconsistent ideologies?</p><p>This writing is a means to process this reevaluation. It is not to convince, or persuade, or advocate. I need to write to process, and this likely will only be read by six or so people, all who I’ll see at Christmas. But it might also help you. You who are pondering the same questions, or you who believe I am an abomination, or somewhere in between. Either way, I hope my story can play a small part in an important conversation.</p><h4><strong>Seeds of Faith</strong></h4><p>My faith journey began before I was born. My paternal grandparents were contemporaries of Billy Graham, having attended the evangelical epicenter Wheaton College shortly after him. In the early 1950s, my grandparents took their evangelicalism across the ocean to start the first foreign branch of the youth-focused organization Young Life, <a href="https://www.jeunesse-ardente.org/association#h.su7u5x8koppt">building a camp nestled in the French Alps</a>. My father consequently grew up in a missionary home in Lyon, helping maintain and run the camp while learning Christian teachings alongside the French youth.</p><p>My own youth was steeped in this evangelical tradition. Young Life, Calvary Chapel, Bible study. I accepted Christ as my savior in elementary school, I must have been around six years old. I imagined a spectral Jesus began hovering over me, watching my every move like a loving but stern imaginary friend. I vividly remember sensing Jesus’s disappointment over my shoulder when, shortly after accepting him into my heart, I resorted to using force against a friend in a jungle gym-based disagreement.</p><p>My faith in adolescence was more an execution of a routine than true acceptance. In high school, I attended church and my church’s youth group most weeks. I prayed every night before bed and before I stepped onto the baseball or football field. Christianity was the background music of my life, it was the water I swam in. Something ever present and fundamental but not the center of focus, so I had no reason to examine it critically. That was until I leapt from the nest.</p><p>College is stereotypically a time for self-discovery for good reason. Often beyond the reach of the parental gravitational pull, amongst other free floating bodies, one has the freedom and kinetic energy to form into new shapes, experiment with new identities, and reexamine old ones. When I had escaped to college several states away from home, I found my ambivalent personal religious interest was no match to the overwhelmingly more interesting identities that first year of college can offer, such as socialite. I didn’t go to church, I didn’t often pray, I didn’t read the Bible. If pressed during this year I would have still said I was a Christian, but I was only a Christian in the sense a deflated balloon is still technically a balloon.</p><p>My religious ambivalence changed when I became acquainted with depression. I started noticing something was off after my first year of college ended. By the time I returned to school for my second year, a black hole had opened up in my chest and I was being pulled inward. An emotional breakdown could and did happen at any time — in the shower, on the way to class, often while lying in bed trying to sleep — and my constant mental ruminations left little room for other thoughts.</p><p>In an act of extreme desperation I sat at my dorm room desk one morning after a fitful night’s sleep and flipped through the childhood Bible I still had, eagerly searching its pages for some mental salve. I eventually came across a passage that would quite literally change my life: <a href="https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Matthew%2025%3A31-46&amp;version=NIV">Matthew 25:31–46</a>, The Sheep and the Goats. This passage describes how God will split humanity into two groups and those on his right are the righteous because: “I was hungry and you gave me something to eat, I was thirsty and you gave me something to drink, I was a stranger and you invited me in, I needed clothes and you clothed me, I was sick and you looked after me, I was in prison and you came to visit me.’” The righteous are confused, asking when they did such things for God. “The King will reply, ‘Truly I tell you, whatever you did for one of the least of these brothers and sisters of mine, you did for me.’ ”</p><p>An embarrassingly obvious truth became immediately apparent: I was wasting my privilege. I was certainly not the least of these. I had grown up in an upper-middle class family living most of my adolescence in a slice of heaven called Park City, UT. And among many other benefits, my parents were paying for college, after a year of which I had little to show for it except mediocre grades and exceptional hangovers. This, I realized, was also the root cause of my despondency. My internal gyroscope was going haywire without direction or ambition.</p><p>This verse provided more than a slap in the face, it provided a solution: service to the least of these. So began two concurrent journeys in faith and politics.</p><h4><strong>Growing in Faith</strong></h4><p>For the first time in my life I was hungry to intentionally grow my faith. I had never experienced such a true moment of inspiration, an inspiration I felt to my core was divinely inspired. Everything had clicked into place beyond all logical explanations. It all made sense only through God. I was in a dark place, lost without a light, and a light shown when I needed it most, a light emanating from Him.</p><p>My faith was not immediately resolute. I did not quite feel like opening my dorm window and proclaiming the good news to any student ambling by, or even to my own roommates. But something undeniable had started to stubbornly grow. The seed of Christianity planted in me long ago was sprouting in earnest for the first time in my life, and I wanted to tenderly water and care for the seedling under my own volition. I found a church I attended most Sundays and started to build relationships at that church, something I had never done without parental persistence. I even occasionally attended my school’s Campus Crusades for Christ some Wednesday nights, something that originally had the same odds of me doing as running naked through my school’s quad; both seemed just as vulnerable and exposing.</p><p>My spiritual progress was solidified in committing my life to Christ. One Sunday, after a particularly moving message, the pastor asked anyone feeling moved to devote their lives to Christ to come up to the front. The quiet, prodding feeling in my soul told me to do so. So I did. To my mortification, I got up, walked up to the front of the church, and kneeled down in front of the cross. I closed my eyes, opened my heart, and prayed. Prayed for guidance. Prayed for forgiveness. Prayed God would use me for His purpose. I felt peace in my heart and wrote in my journal: “This is a big day, first step to being who I’m supposed to be.”</p><p>This was much more profound and meaningful than accepting Christ in my heart as a child. Knowing all of what it entailed, I had supplanted myself to a higher power and accepted the consequences of that decision. It was a profound experience that fundamentally quieted my overactive analytical brain and opened my heart to have real conversations with God. What does it mean to lead a life serving Him? What does it mean to be a Christian? What does it mean to love the least of these among us? My faith had become a core identity.</p><p>My faith has waxed and waned since then due the profound and the mundane — moves, family losses, job changes, infertility, the pandemic. Sometimes too busy or too happy to be overly concerned about my soul. Other times deeply focused on what matters. But through this all, since that moment in college, my faith has been there as an anchor and a guidepost. A common theme in my journal entries since then is a desire to be closer to God, and work for His purpose. Christ was no longer an imaginary friend, but a real and trusted advisor acting as a wellspring of hope I’d pray often to for guidance.</p><p>My faith grew especially strong when I found a true church home. The pastors practiced what they preached in serving the least among us through various programs and practices. And I became a member of a small group of like minded souls from this church. Those who were chafed by strict religious upbringing that conflicted with their understanding of Christ’s love. This group helped me through life’s ups and downs, and most importantly through any crisis of faith. My faith had never been so strong than with this tight-knit community.</p><p>The church and small group also helped me not feel alone in how I acted out God’s love on important social and political issues. The Black Lives Matter and rainbow “All Means All” flags outside the church was the bait that hooked me because, while I was growing my faith, politics had also become core to my identity.</p><h4><strong>Growing in Politics</strong></h4><p>My adolescent ambivalence also extended to politics. But much like religion, my parents had also planted the seed for political engagement, and this seed too was waiting for water. When I looked around for the best way to help the least of these among us with eyes and heart opened from my divine experience, the first answer that came to mind was fighting for political change because of its potential scale for impact.</p><p>The first question was how. How best can I use politics to serve the least among us? I saw the problem as one of opportunity. I was given every opportunity to live a healthy and happy life (love, food, shelter, healthcare, education), whereas the least among us rarely are. Either from where they start in life or bad luck throughout, the poor, sick, and imprisoned are often victims of a lack of opportunity to succeed due to forces outside of their control. If we are all equal in the eyes of God, unequal opportunity is a moral failing. This is not to make sure everyone is equal in every way, I realized that’s not possible nor realistic, but that everyone has equal <em>opportunity</em> for health and happiness, regardless of the vagaries of life that can upend and ruin anyone, especially those starting from a deficit.</p><p>The best way I could see to provide this equal opportunity was through government support. Capitalism has benefits, but left unchecked it is blind to where people start and the external forces disrupting their opportunity. So I saw it as the government’s responsibility to provide social programs that benefit everyone, but especially the least of these by filling in critical gaps (e.g. medicare, welfare, food stamps, minimum wage, universal healthcare, universal childcare, universal basic income).</p><p>Removing barriers to equal opportunity also seemed just as important as providing benefits to equalize opportunity. This includes limiting the impact of bias against immutable traits such as race, gender identity, and sexual orientation. These traits are also outside the realm of choice, and yet access to equal opportunity often is hampered by having the wrong combination of these traits. So I believed that programs eliminating bias and redressing past harms, such as affirmative action and complete and equal rights for the LGBTQ+ community, would also best serve the least of these.</p><p>With this political understanding rooted in my Christian faith I jumped head first into politics after my spiritual epiphany, just as I did in strengthening my faith. I co-founded my school’s Students for Barack Obama chapter, was voted president of my school’s Democratic club, elected a delegate of the California Democratic Party, and worked for political consultants while in college. I was so driven by the certainty of my identities that when I graduated, I worked on a congressional campaign instead of directly using the engineering degree I worked hard to earn (after my mediocre freshman year). After that campaign I went to law school because I saw that as the best means to understand how to change the system for the least of these. I later used that degree to help start a political tech software company serving left-leaning campaigns.</p><p>I do more than just politics to express my faith in action, volunteer and serve on several non-profit boards for example, but politics has been the main tool I have used to put my Christian values into practice.</p><p>With my faith and political identities maturing, my internal guidance system was locked in and humming. Since that time in college these two identities have served as the pillars of my life. I had purpose, drive, and heart that steered me through challenging times and towards serving others.</p><p>This was until Donald Trump.</p><h4><strong>Faith and Politics Collide</strong></h4><p>The combination of my faith and political views never felt mainstream. Since solidifying my core identities in college, I believed most who shared my faith had different political proclivities. At least this was the historical reality presented to me. Since the Moral Majority swept in Ronald Reagan over the Sunday-school-teaching Jimmy Carter, good Christians were Republicans. I heard someone say this exact phrase in church. And this was still the mainstream story when I became of voting age with Bible-quoting George W. Bush. There were some liberal Christians — many Christians of color, some politicians like <a href="https://x.com/ewarren/status/1232503545120935936">Elizabeth Warren</a>, those going to my church. But I always felt we were the exception, not the rule.</p><p>Being in the apparent minority didn’t worry me. I felt confident in how I was acting out my faith through my political activities. It is also truly impossible to say with any certainty any given policy or political stance is “Christian.” It degrades the complex and utterly transcendent nature of faith in Christ to force it into the narrow and morally ambiguous box of political activity. The tail of politics should not wag the dog of faith. So I gave the benefit of the doubt to those I did not agree with politically but who shared my faith by assuming they were acting out their faith too, we just disagreed on the most effective means.</p><p>This pollyannaish view changed for me when Donald Trump ran for president. Throughout his political career, I watched Trump attempt to strengthen Christians’ relationship with conservative ideology, or more specifically, <em>his</em> ideology. His <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2024/09/trump-rally-prayers/679152/">rallies begin with prayers from pastors for Trump to deliver us from the evils</a> of the current administration. Trump has his <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/article/2024/may/06/trump-bible-review">own line of bibles</a>. He gets photo ops in <a href="https://www.vanityfair.com/style/2017/07/donald-trump-oval-office-prayer-circle-explained">prayer circles</a>. He has prompted the <a href="https://www.npr.org/2020/06/01/867532070/trumps-unannounced-church-visit-angers-church-officials">tear gassing of peaceful protestors to get a photo in front of a church</a>. He <a href="https://www.reuters.com/world/us/trump-tells-christians-they-wont-have-vote-after-this-election-2024-07-27/">told Christians that if they vote for him this year, “in four years, you don’t have to vote again</a>.”</p><p>Trump seems to see Christians as core to his support, and the numbers back this up. I did a little research and in 2016, <a href="https://www.pewresearch.org/politics/2018/08/09/an-examination-of-the-2016-electorate-based-on-validated-voters/">according to Pew Research</a>, American Protestants voted for Trump over Clinton 56% to 39% and Catholics did so by a 52% to 44% margin, with white Evangelicals being the biggest support: 77% to 16%. For example Promise Keepers, a once apolitical group for men seeking Christian fellowship (and a group I have been a part of with my dad), <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2024/08/11/us/promise-keepers-evangelical-christians.html">has made a sharp turn right to advocating for Trump</a>. No political candidate in my life seems so reliant on tying his political success to being preferred by Christians, especially evangelical christians, the tradition I was raised within.</p><p>Trump’s appeal to other Christians causes me great consternation and confusion. I do not claim to be perfect by any stretch of the imagination. And I try my best to not pass judgment on anyone else; I take casting stones seriously. But when someone so clearly ties themselves to the religion I practice, which forms a core part of my identity, and harnesses the power of others of my faith by claiming to further the religion’s ends, their morality and intentions seem fair for inspection.</p><p>Under the weakest of microscopes Trump falls far short of any understanding I have of decency, let alone Christian values and love of the least among us. The criminal behavior, adultery, routine denigration of immigrants striving for a better life, frequent advocacy for political violence, and constant and unending manipulation of truth is just a limited list of his transgressions.</p><p>What is most alarming to me is Trump’s facade of faith. Trump seems so clearly a false prophet, draping himself in the trappings of Christianity for his own personal benefit. When <a href="https://www.foxnews.com/video/6354217269112">recently asked about his relationship with God and how he prays</a>, he only discussed how he does “very well with the Evangelicals” without answering the basic question on faith. And <a href="https://www.c-span.org/video/?c4624981/asked-god-forgiveness">when asked if he’s ever sought God’s forgiveness</a>, he eventually answered, “I don’t bring God into that picture.” Is this not THE picture to bring God into? A recognition of our failings as human beings and the need for His forgiveness?</p><p>I pray daily for love and compassion of all, but it’s hard to suppress and hide my disdain for a man that appears to me to be invoking Christian faith purely for political gain.</p><p>Many Christian supporters seem to be aware of his shortcomings, and maybe even his inauthentic faith. A <a href="https://www.newsweek.com/donald-trump-kamala-harris-poll-christian-religious-beliefs-voters-1957548">recent poll suggests</a> “many white evangelicals have adopted a worldview that prioritizes political goals over traditional religious values.” This is a disappointing means-justifying-the-ends mentality. Or, as I have heard put, an imperfect vessel theory: Trump may not be perfect, or anything close to it, but he is a vessel for carrying the Christian message and furthering Christian values, <a href="https://www.vox.com/identities/2018/3/5/16796892/trump-cyrus-christian-right-bible-cbn-evangelical-propaganda">much like King Cyrus</a>. He does this by, for example, appointing the judges that overturned Roe v. Wade and generally standing up against perceived anti-Christian sentiment.</p><p>The imperfect vessel is poisoning the well and making me question my own faith. Faith is acted out in many ways big and small — silent prayers, charitable acts, loving hugs — but also casting a vote. Political support does not definitively define anyone’s moral character, and no political candidate or party is perfect, all are far from it so voting often requires disappointing your higher values and settling for who is least bad. But many Christians’ support of Trump is not begrudging, but rather enthusiastic by publicly acting as Trump being the Christian choice, God’s choice. The result is that, when Trump seems to me to be so fundamentally undermining Christian values for his own ends, how can I not be forced to ask one very unsettling question: Has my faith been misguided?</p><h4><strong>Reevaluating My Faith</strong></h4><p>The apparent disconnect between my identities can no longer be ignored. Though my faith has grown substantially, and earnestly, I have done so by ignoring certain contradictions between how I understand the world and apparent tenets of my Christian faith. Contradictions that have been laid bare by the ardent political preferences of many other Christians. I have thus started the long but important journey of reexamining my core identities, which has resulted in suppressed questions bubbling up to the surface. Reconcilable conflict is now appearing irreconcilable.</p><p>LGBTQ+ rights is the epitome of this dilemma. Sexual preference and gender identity not being a choice is a deeply, deeply held belief of mine based on numerous personal experiences and intense reflection. And I believe strongly supporting these rights is a Christian value because it both supports love in all of its expressions and it loves individuals for how God made them. Many Christians believe Old Testament verses undermine my perspective but I’ve subconsciously ignored these verses and focused on Christ’s core message of love. Now I must ask myself: Have I been delusional thinking my pro-LGBTQ+ stance is consistent with my Christian faith? Is it possible to reconcile that which seems obviously true in reality to what is obviously not true in the Bible? Can I really ignore all the other Christians who think I’m wrong?</p><p>Things begin to unravel further if I pull on this thread. Basic, non-political issues start surfacing too. I am also a strong believer in science, including evolution. The creation story always seemed an obvious allegory to me. Same with Noah’s Arc, of which there’s zero scientific evidence two pairs of every animal suddenly migrated from the Middle East to all stretches of the world a few thousand years ago after a world-submerging flood. But again, is it possible to reconcile that which seems obviously true in reality to what is obviously not true in the Bible? Can I really ignore all the other Christians who think I’m wrong?</p><p>Even the genesis of my faith is opening itself to examination. When I was lost in college looking for answers, would I have first turned to the Quran, Torah, Bhagavad Gita, Tao Te Ching, or Aristotle’s Metaphysics instead of the Bible had I been raised differently? And because I was raised Christian, did I find it a convenient vehicle to further my views on how we should act to one another in political and social realms?</p><p>My evangelical upbringing never required answering these questions because I was given the Truth, not a means to question it. And my religious metamorphosis was a heartfelt experience, not one requiring a theological investigation. I didn’t need to impose the intellectual rigor I had done in my school studies because it felt right in my heart. But should we not apply both heart and mind to something as profound as faith?</p><p>I cannot blame Trump entirely. He just loosened a lid that likely had been working its way off for a while. But it’s a can of worms I can no longer ignore. Large swaths of Christians believe in a fundamentally different worldview than me even though we read the same Bible and worship the same God. The result has been a fundamental questioning of my faith. If I am to chastise others for their application of faith, I must truly inspect my faith, and test its limits.</p><h4><strong>At a Crossroads</strong></h4><p>So here I sit once again unmoored, with identities in flux. Just as I had in college. This time is different though. My heart is more open, and I understand more what it means to act in love. My mind must be more open now too. Open to the chance I’ve been misguided.</p><p>The irony of all of this is I may not have followed my own advice. I once wrote an article titled “<a href="https://medium.com/@connerjohnston/confidently-misguided-why-our-convictions-can-lead-us-astray-183231b3196c">The Problem with Convictions: You May be Wrong</a>.” It argues that given our fallible brain and its many biases, what can seem like established truth could be anything but. I do apply that mentality in my own life to individual issues sprouting out of my core beliefs. I have not applied that to my core beliefs yet, to the soil from which my convictions sprout.</p><p>Even though I grew up in the church, spent countless hours reading and discussing biblical passages, my experience and understanding of the Bible, of spirituality, of life generally is cosmically narrow. Faith is, in the end, a personal and heartfelt experience. But if there is a God, He gave us a brain to reason, and ignoring the world around us is unreasonable. And not examining beliefs core to who we are while assuming we have all the answers is worse.</p><p>To this end I have created a plan to expand my perspective and understanding. Going back to school in a way. Instead of just reaching for one book from one religion, I will reach for many books from many spiritual perspectives. Instead of attending one type of church I will attend many. Instead of seeking counsel only from Christians, I will seek counsel from anyone willing to provide it. I owe it to myself and my community to fully understand how best to act in the world.</p><p>I have already begun this process and made the exceedingly difficult choice to take leave from my church. A church that has been my spiritual home for over six years. But the church started considering whether it wanted to disaffiliate from its international church (United Methodist Church) over its anti-LGBTQ+ stances and other issues. Through this process I intimately learned the downsides of being a part of a large bureaucratic institution, so removed from the ultimate authorities that could dictate what was or was not done in my church. So, as I told my pastors, I believe not having my church “as a safety net will require me to take true ownership of my own path, and allow me to wander wholly untethered, with both the benefits and risks it entails.”</p><p>Trump’s role in my personal journey cannot be ignored, but it should not be overstated. He has given us all stark choices, advocating a vision divergent from prior expectations, breaking the mold in many ways. Ways I personally see largely undermine Christian values, yet many other Christians disagree with me. To believe this disagreement is new is naive and likely should have prompted earlier self-reflection. I suppose I should thank Trump in this regard.</p><p>There is already some evidence I am not alone. Christians throughout the U.S. are reckoning with their beliefs and the impact they have in this country and the world. Younger generations are leaving churches in droves, <a href="https://www.americansurveycenter.org/newsletter/young-women-are-leaving-church-in-unprecedented-numbers/">especially young women</a>. The reasons are many, <a href="https://time.com/6693016/americas-less-religious-politics-to-blame/">but the seeming unbreakable alignment with conservative politics is one culprit</a>.</p><p>As I stand at this crossroads of my own reckoning, I know my journey is far from over. I do not know what the future holds for me and my faith, but I do know that I do not have all the answers, and I never will. Perhaps that’s the true takeaway from this writing, a realization the journey will never be over, and we must be open to continual revaluation of our core beliefs in order to hold them honestly. So, with that, I guess I’ll see you at the next crossroads.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b8d1eeb3aa33" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Progressive Argument For Kamala Harris]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@connerjohnston/a-progressive-argument-for-kamala-harris-9925a8ac955b?source=rss-84f33af0b11c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9925a8ac955b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[donald-trump]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[elections]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[kamala-harris]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[voting]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Conner Johnston]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 18 Oct 2024 21:48:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-06-10T16:10:58.054Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*GIpbowsxAzpUKZJnEPG8FA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by Gage Skidmore <a href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/2.0/">CC by 2.0</a></figcaption></figure><h4><em>It’s more than being a lesser of two evils.</em></h4><p>Progressives have not gotten many wins lately. There was a brief period in 2020 when people marched against police killings, anti-racist books were top-sellers, and Bernie Sanders was leading in the Democratic primary. But then moderate Democrats rallied around “safe” Joe Biden, people took down their Black Lives Matter signs, and diversity and inclusion training became controversial.</p><p>This election may appear to not provide much hope. Many people will vote for a convicted felon whose policies only benefit him and his billionaire friends. And to counteract that Democrats have nominated, without a primary process, another seeming moderate. All the while our weaponry kills thousands of innocent lives, our education and health-care systems are still a joke, and our climate disaster is getting worse. The world is literally on fire and Democrats cannot help themselves from running to the center while Republicans seem to unabashedly embrace radically far right ideas and policies.</p><p>Yet, despite this all, I am enthusiastically supporting Kamala Harris, and you should too. You have likely heard the lesser of two evils argument, and that certainly plays a role in the calculations. Politics is rarely ever about voting for your favorite candidate and instead settling for the best available option. But my pitch is more than that. I think supporting Harris is a recognition that the country is in a state of turmoil and whether we like it or not, a lot of Americans do not support our values — <strong>yet</strong>. This can change but it is up to us to change opinions, and not voting for Harris will only undermine the hard work ahead of us.</p><p>Harris is not a progressive candidate. There can really be no debate about that. She is, however, as liberal as national politics allows. I like to think of there being a speed limit on how fast the country can move forward on any given issue. A candidate cannot exceed this limit in the district they are running in or they are unelectable. They will get pulled over, to hopefully not strain the metaphor. This is Bernie’s problem. His policies match the speed limit of Vermont but was too progressive for even the Democratic Party nationally.</p><p>Citizens, not politicians, are responsible for changing these speed limits. Civil Rights is a key example. Civil rights legislation was not nationally palatable until MLK led a national movement to make it palatable. Politicians were not on the forefront of these issues, especially national politicians, until public sentiment changed. Same with marriage equality. People forget Obama wasn’t even for marriage equality when he first ran. Then there was a sea change led by citizen activists while he was in office and he “evolved” on the topic. One of the most liberal (if not progressive) and popular presidents in recent history couldn’t exceed the speed limit of a now popular issue. Politicians ride waves, they don’t make them.</p><p>This is true now on many progressive issues. See: Israel. Many progressives are hesitant to vote for Harris because she is not saying or doing enough to end Israel’s mass killing of innocent Palestinians. Ignoring the merits of the position or my personal perspective, this is clearly not what most Americans think. Americans have been<a href="https://news.gallup.com/poll/1639/middle-east.aspx"> historically supportive of Israel</a> by wide margins and are <a href="https://news.gallup.com/poll/646955/disapproval-israeli-action-gaza-eases-slightly.aspx">very mixed on Israel’s military response to the October 7</a> terrorist attack. But <a href="https://www.pewresearch.org/2024/03/21/majority-in-u-s-say-israel-has-valid-reasons-for-fighting-fewer-say-the-same-about-hamas/">most are disengaged</a> and only “half can correctly report that more Palestinians than Israelis have died since the war’s start.” This seems true even in the Democratic party as two progressive Democratic congresspersons, Cori Bush and Jamaal Bowman, who are critical of Israel <a href="https://www.npr.org/2024/08/06/nx-s1-5064639/missouri-congresswoman-cori-bush-faces-a-primary-challenger-backed-by-pro-israel-groups">lost their primaries largely on this issue</a>. I suspect the situation is worse in battleground states.</p><p>Expecting Kamala Harris to be progressive is expecting her to be unelectable. If an issue isn’t even popular in Democratic districts, how can we expect Harris to win on the issue nationally? The electoral college favors Republicans, as seen by the last two Democratic presidential candidates who won the national vote but not the electoral college. And, may I remind you, Harris is a mixed-race woman from California with a unique name. If you are progressive, you must understand the baggage it entails being a public figure with her background. So Harris’s campaign is starting from a meaningful electoral deficit. To demand she take unpopular positions is demanding she lose.</p><p>Even with these headwinds Harris still has indicated an openness to progressive policies. This is evidenced most clearly in her selection of Tim Walz, a bonafide progressive, over more moderate and likely electorally beneficial VP picks. She also stands by progressive tax policies, wants to “expand[] and strengthen[] the Affordable Care Act,” and protect reproductive freedoms, <a href="https://kamalaharris.com/issues/">among other left-leaning policies</a>. It certainly hasn’t been as far as many progressives demand, but again, she can only push the speed limit so much.</p><p>Harris is certainly far better than Trump, and this is a critical fact. If you are somebody that has read this far I need not spend the full time detailing every single reason why Trump is a danger to this country. He stands against every progressive value by supporting regressive taxation, elimination of basic rights, denigration of immigrants striving for a better life, and embrace of tyrants. He is also certainly more supportive of Israel, <a href="https://foreignpolicy.com/2022/10/19/trump-pro-israel-truth-social-netanyahu-abraham-accords/">arguably being the most pro-Israel president in histroy</a>. This is in addition to the criminal behavior (<strong>he is a convicted felon</strong>), frequent advocacy for political violence, history of sexual assault, and constant and unending manipulation of truth. This is just a limited list of his transgressions, I cannot possibly detail every single one here but a<a href="https://www.mcsweeneys.net/articles/the-complete-listing-atrocities-1-1-056"> group of writers compiled this list</a> “of Trump’s cruelties, collusions, and crimes” up through the end of his term, which totals <strong>1,056</strong>. Please scan through that if you need a refresher on why Trump = bad.</p><p>The result of a second Trump presidency would be the same as the first, but worse. More conservative judges and Supreme Court justices taking a century instead of decades to roll back. Meaningful digression on climate policy when climate disasters are only getting worse as we get closer to the point of no return. Disinformation and alternative realities will march us closer to a 1984 dystopia. Women’s rights, LGBTQ+ rights, and minority rights generally will not only not be a priority, but be actively opposed. A more experienced and embittered Trump could also fundamentally undermine our democratic process to the point JD Vance is guaranteed to win the 2028 election. I could go on, but I think you get the bleak point. Allowing another Trump presidency would be throwing gasoline on a fire.</p><p>These are our two democratic choices in November. Either we vote for Harris or support Trump. Harris is at least open to progressive policies whereas Trump is, to say the least, not. And not voting for Harris is necessarily a benefit to Trump because as progressives, we would never be a Trump voter. Same with a vote for a third party candidate. They cannot win this election, they simply cannot. This is a mathematical certainty. So, it is a zero sum game between these two candidates. Whether we wish this to be the reality or not cannot change this reality right now. And given the closeness of this election, progressives abandoning Harris could be the difference.</p><p>We have other choices outside of the presidential election. We can support progressive congressional and state candidates, both are offices many progressives hold and provide an important platform for these ideas. We can help national candidates who are poised for the next presidential primary (I’m still holding out hope for an Elizabeth Warren presidency). We can even help and support a third-party gain traction and try to get to national relevance in the next election. The only other option is revolution, to be blunt and a little glib. Either we work to improve the system or we overthrow it (which, to be clear, I do not advocate for). Not voting or voting for a third party this November will not get the results we want.</p><p>The real work is changing public opinion, increasing the speed limit so to speak. This creates the environment to help get candidates elected who will codify progressive policies. But this is hard, slow, grinding work. It spans decades, not just the months leading up to an election. And it requires patience. As <a href="https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0745670/characters/nm0000640">the great President Bartlet once said</a>: “Change comes in excruciating increments for those who want it. You’re trying to move mountains. It takes lifetimes.” But that is the best way to create lasting change. Public opinion has changed in the past, and there is evidence it is changing now on issues like Israel’s military response likely due to the hard work of citizens on the ground, from protestors to one-on-one conversations. Maybe one day this could include a third-party.</p><p>So all is not lost! Yes, political realities can be a bummer, such as the reality that nearly half of voters will choose an anti-democratic demagogue and the straight-jacket of the two party system. But I still believe the moral arc of the universe bends towards justice. History has proven this true time and time again. The arc just doesn’t bend by politicians who must be elected to have any power. It bends by citizens working hard with each other for what is right. This creates the fertile ground for change. Another Trump presidency will only poison the ground and make change significantly harder. So please, please join me in voting Kamala Harris for president while continuing the hard work of fighting for justice.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9925a8ac955b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Is my pride flag enough?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@connerjohnston/is-my-pride-flag-enough-c83521897fba?source=rss-84f33af0b11c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c83521897fba</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[lgbtq]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[activism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[transgender]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pride]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Conner Johnston]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 04 Jun 2023 20:43:54 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-06-04T21:58:57.583Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*Ahc1i3SpZ4EWocVN" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@briellefrench?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Brielle French</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>When we bought our house it was one of my goals to utilize its flagpole holder. The tiny piece of metal affixed to the front side of our porch’s beam beckoned me to put something in its little grasp. Like a car’s bumper, flags can declare the personality and values of the house’s inhabitants. With flags my neighbors show their patriotism, support their sports teams, express political views, and one neighbor proudly declares their allegiance to <a href="https://gameofthrones.fandom.com/wiki/House_Stark">House Stark</a>.</p><p>I had ambitions to extol my values with flags, because displaying a flag can make it seem that you’re having an impact. When Russia invaded Ukraine, there were Ukrainian flags everywhere. People yearned to act in reaction to the immense tragedy of thousands of innocent lives being needlessly taken. We couldn’t grab a grenade launcher, hop on a plane, and join the frontlines even if we wanted to. So with social media posts, bumper stickers, t-shirts, ribbons, and flags we showed our solidarity with the Ukrainian people.</p><p>The problem with solidarity by itself is that it can sometimes only make those showing it feel any better. Many thousands donated money to NGOs supporting refugees and providing crucial aid, and I’m sure this did and is making a meaningful impact in the lives of embattled Ukrainians. But the Ukrainians huddled in Mariupol weren’t put at less risk because I waved a Ukrainian flag; Putin was certainly not any less tyrannical. Without action, flags and similar displays by themselves can become sympathy theater.</p><p>This may be the case with the <a href="https://www.hrc.org/resources/lgbtq-pride-flags">pride flag</a> I wave every June. I was especially excited to proudly declare my support for the LGBTQ+ community with a pride flag. This is in part due to me, like many straight allies, foolishly not believing Proposition 8 could pass in California in 2008, which did pass and made heterosexual marriage exclusively recognized in California’s constitution. After that I woke up and joined marches, volunteered for allied candidates, proudly worked for the judge that signed the order overturning Proposition 8, and waved a pride flag whenever possible. But since the Supreme Court’s 2015 ruling in <a href="https://www.oyez.org/cases/2014/14-556"><em>Obergefell v. Hodges</em></a>, which found the fundamental right to marry applied to same-sex couples, my activism became dormant once again and I have been content to just put up my pride flag yearly to show solidarity. But not solidarity with a struggling class, solidarity in a victory. We won, love reigns!</p><p>My belief equality had been achieved was plainly ignoring reality. The current reality is the LGBTQ+ community is under attack, and that has never not been the case. As <a href="https://www.hrc.org/press-releases/roundup-of-anti-lgbtq-legislation-advancing-in-states-across-the-country">The Human Rights Campaign notes</a>, “[t]here have been more anti-LGBTQ+ bills introduced in state houses this year than in each of the previous five years.” This includes laws barring Americans from getting medically necessary care; millions of children cannot discuss queer issues in school to better understand who they are; <a href="https://www.nbcnews.com/nbc-out/out-politics-and-policy/half-2022s-challenged-books-lgbtq-themes-rcna81324">books are being banned</a>; <a href="https://apnews.com/article/zooey-zephyr-transgender-montana-house-updates-3054b6bed9ac04920249e6302821e130#:~:text=(AP)%20%E2%80%94%20Montana%20Republicans%20barred,their%20efforts%20to%20silence%20her.">voices are being silenced</a>; fear mongering around drag has infected <a href="https://www.abc10.com/article/entertainment/television/programs/to-the-point/youth-drag-show-canceled-roseville/103-eaa7d68c-396f-4846-870c-48ef40141b71">communities everywhere, even in California</a>; and some worry the Supreme Court’s ruling overturning <em>Roe v. Wade</em> could put <a href="https://abcnews.go.com/Politics/supreme-court-opens-door-overturning-rights-contraceptives-sex/story?id=85639162">marriage equality at risk again</a>.</p><p>Ignoring this reality is a result, and core benefit, of my privilege. Being straight and <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cisgender">cisgender</a>, I get to choose whether to recognize ongoing discrimination against the LGBTQ+ community because whether I recognize it or not, it won’t affect me personally. Much like being an American grants me the choice whether to ignore the ongoing horror in Ukraine because my personal safety is not at risk whether I choose to act or not. I had the privilege to not believe Proposition 8 would pass because whether or not I could marry the person I love was never at issue. My rights were not at risk. I get the choice of whether to label empathy for others as “woke” and avoid any self-reflection on how my behavior and attitudes affect others. Whether I do or do not decide to act, society will continue to move forward without detriment to me. Inaction and ambivalence have little personal consequence.</p><p>My pride flag may have unintentionally become a display of this privilege. Putting it up on my flagpole is the only proactive measure I’ve recently taken to support LGBTQ+ rights even though much more is needed. The flag is not hurting anybody. But I am surrounded by a diversity of people throughout the sexual- and gender-identity spectrums and my immediate community celebrates these differences. My flag is not planted in hostile territory, helping to open hearts or provide solace. And the bubble of acceptance I live in obscures the reality that LGBTQ+ community is being targeted now with intense ferocity, especially the trans community. I have chosen, purposefully or not, to believe my flag of solidarity is doing enough and ignore the continued battle for fundamental rights that never stopped.</p><p>But this year will be different. This year I am actively choosing engagement because I must. Equality was never achieved and it won’t be unless allies step it up. And I call on anyone else who this resonates with to join me. This doesn’t necessarily require marching or protesting, lesser forms of activism are impactful. Donating is an easy and effective means of empowering those directly doing the hard work. Of course also vote for representatives that choose to support and not degrade the LGBTQ+ community. And if you live in a state passing oppressive laws, call or write your legislators. Even being an advocate in your own network and a supportive listener to those you know who may be struggling can make a difference. <a href="https://reports.hrc.org/being-an-lgbtq-ally?_ga=2.121041678.78183949.1685375793-1425161072.1685203019">Educate yourself </a>on how to be a better ally and do your own research to find what resonates with you on how to do the work.</p><p>I’m committing to act in at least three ways: (1) donating — to advocacy organizations (<a href="http://give.hrc.org/">Human Rights Campaign</a>, <a href="https://support.lambdalegal.org/site/Donation2;jsessionid=00000000.app30130a?df_id=6680&amp;mfc_pref=T&amp;6680.donation=form1&amp;NONCE_TOKEN=D3311163DF16F06EEA5520010BAF90B5">Lamda Legal</a>) as well as a summer camp for <a href="https://www.thecampindigo.org/">transgender and non-binary youth</a>; (2) writing to my friends and family explaining why this issue is so important to me; and (3) yes, displaying my flag, because I like it, and it will also now serve as a reminder of the work still to do.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c83521897fba" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Problem With Convictions: You May be Wrong]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@connerjohnston/confidently-misguided-why-our-convictions-can-lead-us-astray-183231b3196c?source=rss-84f33af0b11c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/183231b3196c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[elections]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[law]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[opinion]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Conner Johnston]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 04 Jun 2022 00:03:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-06-07T00:25:26.956Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*dyiRCwl5ELyDVz2ROngoEg.jpeg" /></figure><h3>The Problem with Convictions: You May be Wrong</h3><p>Few things are more praised than standing by your convictions. Holding strong beliefs or opinions is deeply ingrained in us as a desirable character trait. Historical figures (e.g. MLK, Gandhi, American revolutionists) and fictional characters (e.g. Atticus Finch, Luke Skywalker, <a href="https://youtu.be/Nj61hQhTwW0?t=84">William Thatcher</a>) are driven into us as role models to stand for what is “right,” even if it means personal harm. So we lionize and attempt to emulate those who brace against naysayers and conformists, those willing to protest, march, and fight for what they believe in.</p><p>This obsession with conviction motivates many of us to feel it is our duty to stake firm positions on every important issue. We fail our heroes if we lack conviction. And today there is no shortage of important issues to have strong opinions on: epidemiology, economic policy, foreign policy, racial justice, sexuality, constitutional law, climate change, election integrity, gun rights, abortion . . . the list goes on.</p><p>To truly understand an important issue, however, takes a lot of work and time. Some people spend their entire lives becoming an expert in one single area. So given life’s demands, most of us simply cannot fit in the work necessary to really know what we’re talking about with unwavering confidence on so many topics, especially ones that are rapidly evolving. You may be a better person than me, but I certainly do not have the time necessary to become a true expert on the ever changing spread of COVID-19, economic implications of inflation and how to fight it, military strategy in Eastern Europe, the constitutional right to privacy, and appropriate firearm legislation. Yet, many people have resolutely strong opinions on all of these issues and more, and will tell you about them, emphatically.</p><p>A lack of expertise is not fatal to our ability to hold strong beliefs because mental biases allow us to think our opinions are well founded and justified. Three biases are particularly effective today: team identity, confirmation bias, and an aversion to uncertainty.</p><p>We rely heavily on the opinions of those on our “team.” Instead of doing the work necessary to truly understand an issue, we look around at what our team believes and strongly adopt that position without much additional work. This is most evident within our political teams since we are a deeply polarized country and this polarization often drives our thinking. In fact, <a href="https://news.stanford.edu/2017/08/31/political-party-identities-stronger-race-religion/">political affiliation is a better indicator of beliefs than other personal characteristics</a>. We also adopt the opinions of those on our other teams, such as those who share our religion or cultural identities (which often overlap with political identities).</p><p><a href="https://www.britannica.com/science/confirmation-bias">Confirmation bias</a> serves as a flawed gatekeeper. Instead of considering information that challenges our beliefs (or our team’s beliefs), our brains seek out information that confirms our opinions and ignores or discounts contrary information, thus further solidifying them unjustifiably. Have you ever gotten a rush of satisfaction when you’re reading something that proves you’re right? Or read something that conflicts with your position and immediately started thinking of all the ways it was wrong? That’s confirmation bias at work.</p><p>Finally, we <a href="https://www.newyorker.com/tech/annals-of-technology/why-we-need-answers">crave certainty and are uncomfortable with ambiguity</a>. We want to see the world in black and white, with no gray area. This can force an unnatural dichotomy of “I am right, they are wrong,” without a middle ground. Or force an unwarranted belief that a right and wrong answer exists. Need for certainty along with a team mentality and confirmation bias is a potent mix that can make us think our team is right all the time. The absurdity of this is hopefully plain.</p><p>The <a href="https://www.verywellmind.com/an-overview-of-the-dunning-kruger-effect-4160740">Dunning-Kruger effect</a> exhibits the result of these and other mental biases. This is the phenomenon that those with little knowledge on a topic feel more confident in their position, whereas experts in that topic know they have much more to learn. Think of the armchair quarterback: usually the fan with the least understanding of the complexities of the sport will feel most entitled to question coaches’ and players’ ability to execute a winning strategy. And it isn’t based on IQ or intelligence — we are all susceptible to this. The Dunning-Kruger effect has been proven <a href="https://twitter.com/AdamMGrant/status/967407804763000832?s=20&amp;t=9oZ7vUCcIDeqgeWb_iWYuA">over and over again</a> and even has a curve, with an aptly named “Mount Stupid.” So if you read all of the above and said, “None of this applies to me,” you may be an unknowing resident of said mountain.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0PZW00gIkp18zUJZ72Xqew.png" /></figure><p>These mental shortcuts, along with others, means we cannot trust our convictions without question. They can allow us to be certain of our correctness when our true knowledge is an inch deep, and make us unwilling to <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2017/03/this-article-wont-change-your-mind/519093/">rethink our positions even in the face of overwhelming contrary evidence. It has been said: “A man with a conviction is a hard man to change.”</a></p><p>It is imperative we recognize our cognitive limitations. There is too much hate and anger spent protecting questionable convictions. And for those fortunate enough to live in democratic societies, it is our duty to recognize our fallibility. Healthy democracies require a well-informed population, but an uninformed or misguided population is susceptible to electing overly confident people who promise easy answers to complex problems. We are actively degrading our public institutions when we hold questionable convictions built on stale or even false knowledge and elect people who do the same.</p><p>Now for the more difficult question: How can we do better if our own minds are part of the problem? I freely admit one thing I am not an expert on is cognitive biases (I highly recommend <a href="https://adamgrant.net/book/think-again/">Adam Grant’s book Think Again as a starter</a>). But as an attorney I like to think of my convictions with the legal standards of proof. Every belief I hold cannot be justified beyond a reasonable doubt, the highest standard the law employs. This is the standard we convict people of crimes, and sentence them to death. Do I really have enough information on, say, economic policy that rises to that level? Probably not. Most of my beliefs, instead, are actually at the level of preponderance of the evidence, which is basically just above 50% certainty. At this level I can still hold the belief, but I must recognize it rests on shaky ground and be open to changing my mind with new evidence.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/976/1*AfyWsYnP1jQJlY5ytFrnpg.png" /></figure><p>We can and should hold strong beliefs as there are many important things worth fighting for. I believe beyond a reasonable doubt, for example, that climate change is real and of the utmost importance. I believe this at the highest level of proof because I have spent years reading, thinking, and talking to others about the topic. I am still open minded about the possibility of being wrong, but I see that possibility as remote.</p><p>The problem is that we tend to act with conviction that all our beliefs are supported at the highest level of certainty, even if the belief is only supported by something we heard someone on our team say, or read one post from the same source we always read. This level of conviction is unjustified in many cases. And even at the highest level, there must still be some room for a little doubt that can never be eliminated. Beyond a reasonable doubt does not mean beyond all doubt.</p><p>So the first and necessary step is recognizing the very real possibility we may be wrong, or at least not totally correct, even if our mental biases make us think otherwise. Recognize we are all humans and it is not only silly, but harmful to hold such strong convictions on so many issues. This is the only way to be more “right.” It is also necessary to being a better citizen and a better human being.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=183231b3196c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Zen of Losing]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@connerjohnston/the-zen-of-losing-1ecf38014af?source=rss-84f33af0b11c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1ecf38014af</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[sports]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[athletics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mindfulness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mental-health]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[meditation]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Conner Johnston]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 10 Jan 2022 01:46:05 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-01-10T01:46:05.347Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*7GqUgsEFEWziqAIXZHsh0A.png" /></figure><h4>A miserable sports fan finds peace through loss.</h4><p>Frustration and disappointment are old friends to any sports fan. We emotionally invest in our teams, chasing the elation a win brings. But when half of teams lose most of their games and even above average teams lose a third of the time, the typical sports fan will routinely experience the anguish of defeat. And yet millions of people willingly put themselves through this emotional roller coaster as if we are part of one large masochistic cult.</p><p>I am no exception. As an ardent supporter of the Baltimore Orioles and the Sacramento Kings, <a href="https://www.espn.com/nfl/story/_/id/24367000/the-top-25-most-miserable-fan-bases-professional-sports">two teams historically disinclined towards winning</a>, I occupy a lonely position in a Venn diagram of miserable fandom. Even so, like most fans, I would never stop rooting for my teams. When we support our teams we feel a part of something bigger than ourselves, no matter how badly our teams are doing. Though many find sports a waste of time, many find passion, excitement, and a sense of community through the unpredictable drama of sports.</p><p>Still, sports are insignificant in the grand scheme of life. At the core, sports are a form of entertainment, a means of distraction. Distractions are needed every once in a while, but we can’t avoid reality forever. This is especially true today with so many historically significant events demanding our attention and energy. I promise, unless you (unwisely) bet your life savings, your team losing a game, or even a championship, will not result in any real harm to you or society at large. There is always the next game, the next season, or, God forbid, you giving up being a sports fan altogether.</p><p>Getting this perspective, however, is not easy because the emotional experience is real. I still get a sharp pang of disappointment thinking about the Orioles’ last playoff game in 2016 that ended in an extra-inning loss. That pain was visceral, as real as a punch in the stomach. The existential insignificance of the cause does not diminish the reality of the pain.</p><p>So what is a sports fan to do? Unless you become the worst kind of fan (fair weather or bandwagon), your life will be continually filled with superfluous pain.</p><p>Enter mindfulness. <a href="https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/basics/mindfulness">Mindfulness</a> is the practice of being fully aware of the present moment, noticing but not judging emotions and thoughts, helping one gain perspective of what is real and important. Mindfulness is widely advocated by <a href="https://www.mayoclinic.org/healthy-lifestyle/consumer-health/in-depth/mindfulness-exercises/art-20046356">mental health experts</a> as a scientifically proven method to help alleviate stress, anxiety, and depression. I started practicing mindfulness over seven years ago and it has been immensely helpful through law school, challenging jobs, personal loss, and a global pandemic. (If you do not yet have a mindfulness practice, downloading <a href="https://www.mindful.org/free-mindfulness-apps-worthy-of-your-attention/">one of these free apps</a> is a great place to start.)</p><p>Mindfulness has also helped me gain perspective in my sports fandom, and even turned watching games into a form of meditation. During a stressful game, or after a soul-crushing defeat, I have a choice. I can get angry, frustrated, and despondent, cursing the day Cal Ripken Jr. made me an Orioles fan and have my day ruined. Or I can pause, notice the emotions as just energy, recognize the source as insignificant, and focus my attention elsewhere.</p><p>This makes watching sports a perfect opportunity to practice mindfulness because of the intense emotional states associated with being a sports fan. And like <a href="https://youtu.be/fhrNgXJ__n8">Neo in the Matrix practicing kung fu in the simulated room</a>, there is no real harm that can come from your team losing, even if you get emotionally knocked around.</p><p>Instead of bemoaning every loss, I can now find some gratitude in the no-risk opportunity to practice mindfulness. I can also recognize and put in perspective the joy of winning, the reason so many of us are sports fans. Like any other emotion, happiness and joy are just energy that we attach the label of “good” to. In the (rare) instance one of my teams win, I can recognize and enjoy the feeling of happiness, while at the same time recognize its fleeting nature and the knowledge frustration may be elicited next game.</p><p>By practicing mindfulness during games you are also able to more easily gain perspective in other areas of life. Most day-to-day experiences simply do not warrant the emotional energy and mental bandwidth that we give them. From minor annoyances (e.g. someone cutting you in line) to other distractions (e.g. social media rabbit holes), our attention and emotions are pirated far too often and sometimes with severe consequences.</p><p>A mindful perspective is hard without practice. Regularly meditating quietly is certainly good and necessary. But practicing mindfulness while your team is tied in the bottom of the ninth provides you a no-risk simulation of real-world emotional tumult. Pausing and remembering that you will not experience lasting harm if the ball doesn’t goes over the fence (or the ball doesn’t go in the hoop, or the ball doesn’t go into the net) will not only provide you the perspective you need immediately after the game, regardless of the outcome, but will help you to lay a strong mindful foundation for when you get off your lucky couch and head into the real world. Because you can still experience peace even if you are the most miserable fan.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1ecf38014af" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Taking Law School Exams]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@connerjohnston/taking-law-school-exams-20f5febf6cec?source=rss-84f33af0b11c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/20f5febf6cec</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[law-school-tips]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lawyers]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[legal-education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[law]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[law-school]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Conner Johnston]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 30 Nov 2021 16:43:50 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-11-30T16:43:50.374Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Ju_2oPht3qTjDazjupWFaQ.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>This article on how to take law school tests is part of a series about how to succeed in law school and all articles in the series can be accessed in the list “</em><a href="https://bit.ly/Legally_Prepared"><em>Legally Prepared</em></a><em>.”</em></p><p>You have <a href="https://medium.com/@connerjohnston/an-engineers-guide-to-law-school-part-1-the-law-and-your-outline-a27a96e0578f">prepared for your law school classes</a>, you have <a href="https://medium.com/@connerjohnston/an-engineers-guide-to-law-school-part-1-the-law-and-your-outline-a27a96e0578f">drafted your outline</a>, and you have <a href="https://medium.com/@connerjohnston/studying-for-law-school-exams-7c00a3479282">studied for the test</a>, now it is time to put it all together and crush the test. As with all other aspects of law school, there are numerous successful approaches to test taking. I describe here how I took tests that proved quite effective for me in the hopes you can either employ this method too or modify it in your own way.</p><p>Good luck!</p><p>(1) <em>Write Out Skeleton Outline</em></p><p>This first step is only for closed book tests, where you cannot bring materials into the exam. For these, you will have to memorize all the legal rules before the test. (I explain how to do this in detail <a href="https://medium.com/@connerjohnston/studying-for-law-school-exams-7c00a3479282">in this article</a>.) As part of the memorization process, memorizing a very brief skeleton outline of just the rule names will be immensely helpful to issue spot during a stressful exam, especially one where you will have to write out dozens of rules from memory. I recommend doing a final skeleton write out immediately before the test so it is fresh in your mind. As soon as the test starts, write out the skeleton outline for later use.</p><p>(2) <em>Read the Prompt</em></p><p>Law school tests typically consist of a hypothetical fact-pattern and then a prompt. I always read the question before reading the fact pattern. The facts can take a long time to go through in detail so it is helpful to limit the number of times you have to read through the facts and ensure you’re making the most of each pass. Reading the prompt first will allow you to know what you are looking for and how to evaluate the facts.</p><p>There are several types of prompts, including to “discuss fully all applicable legal rules,” “explain which position you think is more persuasive,” apply only one type of law (like common law), or only address one law in depth. (<a href="https://lawprofessors.typepad.com/files/conlaw3.obama.1996.fall.pdf">You can see here</a>, as an example, former president Obama’s Constitutional Law exams.) Each prompt will require a slightly different strategy but the most common test form is to ask you to discuss all applicable legal rules. This is because it is the type of test most common on bar exams, and passing the bar is one of the main goals of law school. This article focuses on this type of exam, though my test approach still applies to the other forms.</p><p>(3) <em>Issue Spot</em></p><p>Issue spotting is a necessary step for all tests, but especially for tests requiring you to address all legal rules. Issue spotting means finding all relevant legal issues triggered by the facts or facts that are relevant to the prompt. This is probably the most important aspect of the test. Missing an issue will lose you all points associated with that issue.</p><p>To issue spot effectively, read through the fact-pattern one time completely after reading the prompt, underline important facts, and note in the margin any issues that you think may apply to the given facts. For example, in a criminal law test, if someone is killed, you will underline any important facts leading up to the killing: Are there any facts of provocation? Are there facts showing an intent to kill? Was there anybody else involved? Then write in the margins any murder or manslaughter crimes that might apply.</p><p>After the first pass through the facts review your outline to make sure no other issues might apply. If it is open book, scan your written outline’s table of contents and maybe the appendix (see <a href="https://medium.com/@connerjohnston/an-engineers-guide-to-law-school-part-1-the-law-and-your-outline-a27a96e0578f">this article on making your outline</a> and <a href="https://medium.com/@connerjohnston/studying-for-law-school-exams-7c00a3479282">this article for how to prepare your outline for tests</a>.) If it’s a closed book exam, scan the skeleton outline you wrote out at the beginning of the test. You should have a big filter here and take your time — pause on each rule and run through the facts in your mind to see if any rule or legal issue could apply, and include an issue even if the issue is not a perfect fit. As long as there are facts that could lead to a rational discussion the issue should be discussed if you have time.</p><p>(4) <em>Outline Response</em></p><p>Before writing you should outline your response based on the issues you spotted. This can be a simple list of all the issues you spotted organized from the issue that is most likely applicable to the least likely applicable. You may also have to make sub issues if the rule has a lot of elements and there is one or two elements that will require significant discussion.</p><p>All of this work so far should take a significant portion of your allotted time, probably 15%-25% depending on the complexity of the fact pattern. You will hear other students typing away much sooner than this, making your anxiety-level rise. I promise you, making sure every issue is spotted and preparing your outline is the best guarantee to a good grade. Even if you run out of time at the end, just writing out “I noticed this could be an issue but did not have time to analyze it” should get you more points than outright missing it.</p><p>(5) <em>Draft Response</em></p><p>You are now, finally, ready to draft your response. Just like any writing in your legal research and writing class, these responses should strictly follow <a href="https://medium.com/@connerjohnston/an-engineers-guide-to-law-school-part-1-the-law-and-your-outline-a27a96e0578f">the IRAC structure</a>, unless the prompt indicates otherwise. So, start each section with a basic issue summary, e.g. “Bob may have breached his contract with Jane.” Then write out the applicable rule, either from memory or from your outline if the test is open book. You only need to write out the portion of the rule that is relevant, so no need to show how much you remember of one particular treatise’s thoughts on the law if it is not applicable to the facts or prompt, this will be impressive but a waste of time.</p><p>Next analyze each element of the rule to determine whether it was violated based on the facts given. This is where you will get the most points and how much to analyze will vary. Sometimes only one element of a long rule will be in question, sometimes the issue is a unique subset of the main rule. For issues that are clearly in contention, I found analyzing both sides was helpful in making sure you have looked at the issue from all angles. For example, in a contracts exam, if there are facts suggesting a breach of contract, analyze how the facts could indicate a breach did occur and then analyze how the facts could indicate a breach did not occur. There rarely is a question with a clear answer, so this can help you figure out how to ultimately conclude while at the same time providing a complete analysis. What matters is how you analyze it, not necessarily getting the “right” answer. And for any of the elements that are not in contention, I would just say, for example, “I see no issue with consideration for this contract.” This way you provide a complete analysis of the rule while focusing on the elements in contention.</p><p>Lastly, make sure to always include a conclusion that is responsive to the prompt. This should state whether the law was violated or if someone was liable and a very brief summary why.</p><p>Overall, writing as much as I could in an organized fashion was the best strategy for me. You get points for addressing all correct issues, but rarely do you lose points for mentioning something not relevant. So a strategy of employing a wide net and addressing all possible issues, if you have the time, is often the safest way to guarantee the most points. But make sure the professor will not dock points for irrelevant discussions before you employ this approach and make sure you do not run out of time to address core issues more in-depth.</p><p>(6) <em>Final Scan</em></p><p>Once you have answered all the questions and addressed all of the issues, do a final scan through the facts to make sure you didn’t miss an issue or didn’t address an important fact in your analysis. Again, even if you only have a few minutes left, spotting an issue you forgot to address and flagging that for your professor should get you some points.</p><p>Now you can breathe… until it is time for the next test!</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=20f5febf6cec" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Studying for Law School Exams]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@connerjohnston/studying-for-law-school-exams-7c00a3479282?source=rss-84f33af0b11c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7c00a3479282</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[lawyers]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[legal-education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[law-school]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[law-school-tips]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[law]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Conner Johnston]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 16 Nov 2021 01:12:05 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-11-30T15:21:38.252Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*SjbApeL_XV1dL4huWjyn4Q.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>This article covers the importance of law school tests and how to prepare for them. This is part of a series about how to succeed in law school and all articles in the series can be accessed in the list “</em><a href="https://bit.ly/Legally_Prepared"><em>Legally Prepared</em></a><em>.”</em></p><p>Law school exams test your mettle as much as your legal knowledge. They can cover an entire semester’s worth of material and you may have four or five of them within a couple-week period. They also matter a lot, often being the entire grade for a class. And if that wasn’t enough pressure, they are graded on a curve. You are competing directly against your fellow classmates for just a handful of A’s.</p><p>Doing well on exams, especially first year exams, can also have an outsized impact on your future legal career. Getting a coveted 1L summer position relies heavily on your first semester’s grades. A lot of firms, especially Big Law firms (the most lucrative legal positions) will interview for 2L summer associate positions at the end of the 1L summer, when your resume will largely depend on your 1L grades and 1L summer experience. These summer associate positions often turn into job offers for after graduation. And if you want to transfer to another law school after your first year to better position yourself for a legal position, this too will rely on 1L grades. So, it is not hyperbole to say your eventual legal career can be heavily impacted by 1L grades. (I will discuss summer associate interviews, legal careers generally, and transferring in later articles.)</p><p>Of course you can have a very successful career regardless of grades. But if you are spending three years of your life and likely thousands of dollars, if not hundreds of thousands, to get your law degree, it behooves you to make the most of your investment. Doing well on tests is a fundamental way to get returns on that investment.</p><p>Now for the chaser: anyone can do well if they are prepared. But preparation takes organization and commitment. I developed my own method of preparation for finals that proved very successful for me, helping me finish in the 10% at a top-15 law school. Though there are infinite ways to study, I hope showing you my methods will help you find a successful process that works for you. As long as you have a plan for understanding, absorbing, and applying the material, you can crush law school exams.</p><p>My process for studying was: (1) finalize outlines, (2) write out rules, (3) memorize outlines (for closed book tests), and (4) take practice tests.</p><p><em>1. Finalize Outlines</em></p><p>You must first make your outlines correct and lean. Your outline is the core of your test prep. (To brush up on how to make a good outline, check out the <a href="https://bit.ly/Guide_Part_1">first article in this series</a>.) Before getting into the weeds of studying, you should go through each section of all your outlines with a fine-toothed comb hunting for (1) material you added from the readings that your professor did not cover in class, and (2) material you don’t understand. Eliminate the first and follow up with the second.</p><p>Waiting until finals to understand the material is not advisable. It is much easier to do this throughout the semester and reserve your study time to practicing how to apply the knowledge. But don’t panic if there is still material you do not understand. Set aside time at the beginning of finals prep, 2–3 weeks before your first final, to review your notes, talk with fellow classmates, and most helpfully, meet with your professor about any difficult topics. Taking advantage of your professor’s office hours is the best way to understand the material in the manner they want you to for the test, and it might also provide an opportunity for the professor to tip their hand on what is and is not on the exam.</p><p>Finalizing your outlines is <em>critical</em>. Your outline is the foundation for every remaining step and an erroneous or unnecessarily verbose outline will waste time and worse, lead to errors on the test.</p><p>For open book tests, you should also make your outline structured so it is easy to find any rule or issue during the time-crunch of the test. This can include creating a table of contents with pages for all sections and subsections, an index of all major words, and a table of legal authorities (statutes and cases), which can all be easily created in most word processors. With these tools you can quickly find the relevant rules to write out and apply during the test.</p><p><em>2. Write Out Rules</em></p><p>My next step was to write out all the rules in my outlines in plain English. When you’re outlining, you should be using shorthand and condensed sentences to conserve space and reduce the rules to their essence. But when you take the test, you will be tasked with writing these out in full sentences in proper legal analysis. This should not be done for the first time on a test.</p><p>Writing out the rules will also help the rules sink in. Something happens in your brain when you have to go from an outline to writing it out into an actual sentence. It becomes less abstract, more concrete in its meaning. You will also quickly see if you actually understand what the words in your outline mean, not just in theory, but in practice. Don’t be surprised if you have to go back to step one while writing out a rule you thought you understood but realize you need to seek further clarification.</p><p>I also recommend writing out your outline section by section in a way that requires you to fully process its meaning. I did this by reading one entire section of my outline and then covering or hiding the outline and writing out what I just read into a new document. This semi-memorization really helped drive the concepts deeper into my brain and made them more accessible for issue spotting (described below).</p><p>You will not need to write out every single detail of every rule for each exam question; only write out what is relevant to the facts and the prompt. But knowing all the nuances will help guarantee you are positioned to get the most points possible on every exam question.</p><p><em>3. Memorize Outline</em></p><p>Memorization is only needed for closed book tests. Though it won’t hurt for open book tests, this step takes time, time better spent practicing if you do not need to memorize. In closed book tests, you will not be permitted to bring in any materials and will have to memorize <em>every single rule</em> in your outline.</p><p>My memorization technique was to do a write out without looking at my outline. When doing your first write out, the prior step, you read the outline first then write it out on a blank page. With a memorization write out, you try to write out each section from what you remember after the initial write out and then look at your outline to see if you missed anything important. You will invariably miss things the first pass so write out what you missed to focus your brain on those difficult rules, and then try to do the entire section again from memory. Only move on to the next section after you can do the entire section from memory.</p><p>Memorization is a slow process, it took at least a full day or so for me to memorize each outline. But this was the best way I found to make hundreds of rules stick in a short time and for me to be able to write them out quickly on the test, which is an absolute necessity for closed book tests.</p><p>Another key to memorizing for me was creating and memorizing what I called a skeleton outline. Think of this like a table of contents, a bare-bones outline of just the section names and the names of all the rules within each section. This helped me issue spot during the test (discussed in the next article) and helped trigger the rule language in my mind during the stress of the test. So after my memorization outline, I would memorize a skeleton outline and write this out from memory constantly before the test, at least 5–6 times, so that I could get it written out during the test in a minute or so.</p><p><em>4. Practice Tests</em></p><p>The last step is to practice, practice, practice. Understanding and memorizing rules will only get you so far. You must be able to spot which rules apply and then apply the rules correctly to do well on tests. The best way to do this is with practice tests taken under real test conditions. (Again, see the next article for how to take tests.)</p><p>You must first find relevant tests. Often there will be a repository of tests from past classes at your school, both from your professor and other professors in the same subject matter. You might even be able to find online practice tests from other schools. Tests from your professor will be the closest to what you can expect on your actual final, so I would save these for last. Take the practice exams from your professor after you get a feel for applying the rules from your outline or memory on real questions using other professors’ exams, this way you are most prepared for your professor’s testing style immediately before taking their test.</p><p>Reserve two days before the final to only take practice tests. Since you should be doing them while timed, they could take a couple hours for each test. After each test, review the answer to see if you missed any issues or wrote out any rules incorrectly. If there is no answer sheet, skim through your outline to see if any rule could have applied.</p><p>This is also a good opportunity to work with other classmates you trust to compare responses and see if they found issues you missed. Though you are competing against everyone, studying only alone can be mentally draining and studying with others generally only made me better (and more sane).</p><p><em>Creating a Study Schedule</em></p><p>As you can tell, there is a lot to do to prepare for each test. Making sure you accomplish each of these steps for each exam within a few weeks requires extreme organization and frankly, a lot of effort. This is, I think, the real value of law school. Studying for tests was the best preparation for real-world legal practice, much more so than the actual material. Regardless of what you do with your law degree, being organized and committed to completing a complex task is a very valuable skill.</p><p>There are a myriad of ways to organize your study schedule. I mapped out all the above tasks I needed to accomplish for each class and assigned them to the days before each test. I also reserved the days leading up to each exam for doing practice tests for that class so that the subject matter was fresh in my mind for the test the next day.</p><p>Below is the study schedule for my exams for the spring of my 1L year.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/697/0*XBRh6vTlr-LIBXM_" /></figure><p><em>Closing</em></p><p>Law school tests are very important and very difficult. If you break apart the tasks into smaller parts you can not only do well, but do great, putting your legal career on a firm foundation.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7c00a3479282" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How to Create a Law School Outline]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@connerjohnston/an-engineers-guide-to-law-school-part-1-the-law-and-your-outline-a27a96e0578f?source=rss-84f33af0b11c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a27a96e0578f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[law-school]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[law-school-tips]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[law]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[legal-education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lawyers]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Conner Johnston]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 09 Aug 2021 00:22:14 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-11-16T01:28:14.557Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*DvFPaeJ5K8GOXIsbC2TaPA.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>This article covers what you learn in law school and how to create your outline, the key to success. This is part of a series about how to succeed in law school and all articles in the series can be accessed in the list “</em><a href="https://bit.ly/Legally_Prepared"><em>Legally Prepared</em></a><em>.”</em></p><p>The first couple years of law school cover the foundational legal rules. Unfortunately for law students, there are hundreds of foundational legal rules, and these rules often have subrules. Further, each subject matter class will have a final at the end of the semester requiring you to read fact patterns, discern the relevant legal rule(s) that may apply, and then apply the rules to these fact patterns. You are also limited by time and are graded on the curve, meaning only a few people will get As and most people will get Bs and Cs. Simply understanding the material may not be enough if everyone else does as good or better. Thus, the goal before finals is to (1) know and understand all the legal rules, and (2) be able apply them as quickly as possible.</p><p>The key to achieving both of these goals is having a thorough, accurate, and brief outline for each class. An outline is a succinct summary of all the rules in a given glass organized by subject. It does not matter whether the final is an open book or closed book test. If it is open book, you can have your outline with you and literally copy down the rule statements from that. If it is closed book, you must memorize your outline before the test. In either scenario a solid outline will be critically important.</p><p>A good law school outline is worth its weight in gold. But you should <strong><em>never</em></strong> buy or borrow someone else’s outline, other than to make sure your outline is not missing anything. I cannot overemphasize how important it is to create your own outline. The process of creating your outline is the secret sauce to making sure you understand the rules and how to apply them in a way that makes sense to you, which will likely be different than your classmates or the generic outlines you can find online. You may think you have the answers walking into a final, but I promise you will have no idea how to use it if you didn’t write out and organize the rules yourself.</p><p><strong>What is the Law?</strong></p><p>Before we get to how to create an outline, we must first answer the important question, What do you learn in law school? More simply, What is the “law”? There are many esoteric answers that you will explore in depth throughout your law school career. But the nuts and bolts way I think about it is that laws are to legal studies as equations are to mathematical-based studies.</p><p>Legal analysis is not too dissimilar from mathematical analysis. In math and related studies we learn equations and how to apply them in different situations. For example, a basic physics equation is F = ma — force equals mass times acceleration. If a physics problem provides the mass and acceleration of an object, we know to apply this equation and solve for force.</p><p>Laws are like equations and the facts of the case are the inputs. For example, in your first-year torts class you will study negligence. The basic elements (e.g. formula) of negligence are: (1) a duty, (2) a breach of that duty, (3) causation for the injury, and (4) damages from the injury. On your torts final you may be tasked with analyzing a fact pattern, realize that negligence may apply, and then analyze whether each element of negligence is met. Much like a mathematical problem, we need to know the correct rule to apply and then apply the variables to the rule to discern whether a legal rule was violated.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/474/1*6XT272YT4D0cv_cp4ECfnw.png" /></figure><p>Legal solutions are written out in a manner also paralleling mathematical solutions, just using more words. Legal issues are analyzed under the structure abbreviated IRAC:</p><ul><li><strong>I</strong>ssue: what is the legal issue to be analyzed?<br>Did the driver of car A commit negligence when she hit car B?</li><li><strong>R</strong>ule: What is the relevant legal rule(s) to be applied?<br>Negligence requires a duty, a breach of that duty, causation for the injury, and damages from that injury.</li><li><strong>A</strong>nalysis: Was the legal rule violated?<br>The driver was not negligent because she did not cause the accident, she was hit from behind by another driver first.</li><li><strong>C</strong>onclusion: Short summary.<br>Therefore, the driver was not negligent because she did not cause the accident.</li></ul><p>Like showing your work in solving a mathematical equation, legal analysis is at its core a straightforward methodical process. There is certainly a difference between good legal analysis and bad legal analysis, a difference learned throughout law school and your legal career. But successful legal analysis hinges on simply knowing the right rule to apply and applying it correctly.</p><p><strong>Creating Your Outline</strong></p><p>Preparing the outline is really the hardest and most time-consuming part of law school. Each subject covers dozens of complex legal rules that are not always intuitive. And you could have up to four subject matter classes a semester, so this means possibly four finals in less than two weeks covering hundreds of legal rules. If it was not clear already, you cannot procrastinate in law school. If you are only putting together your outline right before finals, you are too late.</p><p>Good news though: if I can do well, you can do well. It is entirely possible to not only know, but understand and memorize all of this information. It just requires a bit of hard work and a methodical plan that breaks all of the information into manageable pieces throughout the semester. The adage of how to eat an elephant absolutely applies here — take it one bite at a time.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*dzkMwMPZMH2kaBlEgWn5OQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Law school is not unlike scaling a mountain: you get to the peak by following a good route one step at a time.</figcaption></figure><p>I broke up creating my outline into three steps — preparing for each class, taking notes during class, and then updating my outline after class.</p><p><em>A. Before Class</em></p><p>A typical law school class meeting will go over a few cases covering one or more rules. Professors will expect you to have a good understanding of the rules going into each class. To do this you should do three things before class: (1) read the assigned cases, (2) summarize the cases, focusing on the rule(s) described and how they were applied, and (3) add the legal rule(s) to your outline.</p><p>An example would be helpful. A case most 1Ls will read in their constitutional law class is <a href="https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/518/515/#tab-opinion-1959927">United States v. Virginia, 518 U.S. 515 (1996)</a>, which deals with gender discrimination under the Equal Protection Clause. Read the case yourself and try to outline the basic facts, the legal rule announced, and how the rule was applied to the facts. Here is what I created that you can compare to:</p><p>United States v. Virginia (1996)</p><ul><li>Facts: The Virginia Military Institute was a public, single sex school. The barring of women was predicated on the reasons that single-sex education provides important educational benefits and the unique approach would have to be modified to admit women.</li><li>Rule: Gender discrimination warrants “heightened scrutiny” (aka intermediate scrutiny) and these laws must have an “exceedingly persuasive justification” that is “substantially related to an important government purpose.”</li><li>Analysis: The Court found that neither of the interests provided had an exceedingly persuasive justification. Even if most women couldn’t handle the program does not mean all can’t meet the standard — not all men could. The creation of a women’s institute would not provide the same opportunities as a graduate of the VMI. Therefore, this policy was not valid.</li></ul><p>It takes practice to get good at reading cases and understanding the rules announced. Older cases are especially hard because the language utilized is more opaque, and unfortunately most foundational cases covered in 1L classes are older. US v. Virginia is on the easier side because the opinion uses preamble language to signify the relevant rule — “to summarize.” Below is the relevant case excerpt that announces the legal rule employed:</p><p>“To summarize the Court’s current directions for cases of official classification based on gender: Focusing on the differential treatment or denial of opportunity for which relief is sought, the reviewing court must determine whether the proffered justification is ‘exceedingly persuasive.’ . . . The State must show ‘at least that the [challenged] classification serves “important governmental objectives and that the discriminatory means employed” are “substantially related to the achievement of those objectives.” ’ ”</p><p>Now you would incorporate this rule into your outline before class. Below is one way you could do so, which would be within the section regarding the Equal Protection Clause (<a href="https://bit.ly/Equal_Protection_Outline">you can see this entire section in my constitutional law outline here</a>). But again, you must organize it in a way that makes the most sense to you.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/590/1*zaOfmSwPnt7bY5KAYnzmEA.png" /></figure><p><em>B. During Class</em></p><p>Classes help confirm and/or modify your understanding of the rules. They are also an opportunity for terror. The <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XL0-CFvJDHo">Socratic Method</a> can be a daunting experience — being called on in front of your classmates to answer a difficult question takes time to get used to (if you ever do). With your case summaries in hand, you can at least be certain you will have something of value to contribute if called on.</p><p>While in class, take copious notes, especially on things you missed in the cases and points emphasized by the professor. I recommend asking each professor whether they would be OK with you recording classes for note taking purposes. If you are given the green light, in most word-processing applications (like Microsoft Word), you can record while taking notes and when you go back to your notes and click on a sentence, it will play the portion of the lecture recorded during that note. Rehearing a complex or confusing issue in the professor’s words is quite helpful when reviewing your notes.</p><p><em>C. After Class</em></p><p>Whether or not you are able to record lectures, you must review your notes after class and modify your outline to correct any misunderstandings, fill in any missing pieces, and note any points emphasized by the professor. I usually waited to do this until a chapter or section was completed so I could update an entire section of my outline at one time, stringing together multiple classes into one coherent picture. For the example above, I would wait to review your notes until you have covered all of the equal protection chapters so you can see how the various issues fit together.</p><p>This is a step a lot of law students don’t take, instead waiting until finals to clean up their outlines. It will be an advantage for you if you do not wait. There is just not enough time to get a complete picture of all areas of every class between the end of classes and finals. This period should be spent memorizing your outline if the test is closed book, and applying the legal rules to practice hypotheticals regardless of the format of the tests.</p><p><strong>Summary</strong></p><p>Law school is in large part about understanding and applying legal rules. Like mathematical equations, legal analysis is a formulaic process of inputting facts to the legal rules to get an output of whether a legal rule was violated. To set yourself up for success, you need to create an outline for each class of the relevant laws derived from the cases assigned in each class meeting. To do this, you should:</p><ol><li>Read all cases before each class and add rules to your outline.</li><li>Take notes during class, especially on issues you were unsure of or what is emphasized by the professor, and</li><li>Update your outline after class based on your notes from the relevant classes, usually in a block of classes covering one section.</li></ol><p>All of this will take time, but it will be time well spent. While other students will be stressing out before finals putting their outlines together, you will have time to prepare for the actual test, which is what matters most for grades, and which I will be discussing in the next part.</p><p>Good luck!</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a27a96e0578f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>