<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by BitFinance on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by BitFinance on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@contact_90709?source=rss-3a9552a53168------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 08:08:25 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@contact_90709/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Rise of Financial Oligarchy: — And How Blockchain Can End the Inequity]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@contact_90709/the-rise-of-financial-oligarchy-and-how-blockchain-can-end-the-inequity-c537860b1ca2?source=rss-3a9552a53168------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c537860b1ca2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[finance]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[blockchain]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[financial-inclusion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[financial]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[crowdfunding]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[BitFinance]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 05 Nov 2018 16:55:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-11-05T16:55:40.303Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>The Rise of Financial Oligarchy: — And How Blockchain Can End the Inequity</h3><p>Author: Eli M Blatt, PhD Founder and CEO of BitFinance</p><p><strong>A Financial Oligarchy</strong></p><p>Within the blockchain community, the phrase “Democratizing Finance” is increasingly popular yet almost universally conflated with the decentralization of finance. They are <em>not</em> the same thing, however. A billionaire being able to have a million dollars on a Trezor hardware wallet in their pocket is not the same thing as leveling the financial playing field as it relates to building wealth.</p><p>Although the trend towards the decentralization of assets has disrupted traditional finance in a myriad of ways, the real promise of blockchain lies in its ability to provide equal <em>access</em> to assets</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3obN2Is4n6d1K_MoEAikiA.png" /></figure><p>— not simply change where they are custodied. Since the invention of currency, it is access to the loans and investments that build wealth that has been centralized. The highest-yield investments and lowest-rate financing have since before feudal times only been available to the wealthy. Today, this problem is perhaps most acutely embodied by the $15T alternative investment market that is legally accessible to fewer than 90% of Americans for regulatory reasons, and in practice available to only 5% of not just US investors but worldwide. This has created a financial oligarchy, as access to some of the top-performing and often least volatile investments, which generally do not correlate with the stock market, are available only to the wealthy. But now with the advent of blockchain tokenomics — specifically tokenization, smart contracts and token capitalization — we are at a unique moment in history where access to the highest-performing investments and lowest cost of capital can be fairly and fearlessly democratized.</p><p>To understand what the Democratization of Finance really entails, it is important to understand the history behind the current inequity, as well as how blockchain technology and economics can remedy it. The barriers are two-fold:</p><ol><li>Legislative</li><li>Administrative</li></ol><p>The net result is high costs for the public sale of registered securities, and high costs for the administration of private investments sold as exempt securities.</p><p><strong>The Rise of Reg D: Well Intentioned Regulations Gone Wrong</strong></p><p>The root cause of unequal access to alternative investments traces back to the Black Friday and the Securities Act of 1933 which followed in its wake. The Securities Act required that any security sold to the public be registered with the SEC. Rather than a review of the merits of the security, this was a process of providing “full and fair disclosure” of all the risks associated with the investment. But the act included a caveat: a security could be exempt from registration if it was not subject to a “public offering” — a term which surprisingly was left undefined. Nearly 50 years later, in 1980, the SEC introduced the concept of a qualified investor — someone with income exceeding $200K per year or possessing at least $1M in investable assets, not including the value of their home. Under Regulation D introduced at that time, a security that was not publicly marketed could be sold under exemption to the Securities Act only to accredited investors.</p><p>Given that the legal costs for preparing the disclosures required to register a security for a public offering pursuant to the Securities Act can be in excess of $1M for an S1 registration with the SEC, it is generally only large mutual funds which seek registration — funds which are typically comprised of publicly traded securities, not alternatives — along with companies seeking to IPO — not individual investment funds. Most fund managers forgo registration and instead opt to sell their funds only to accredited investors under Reg. D. As a result, given the limit on the number of investors (99 under SEC Reg. D 506(c) exemption) and amount of investment permitted in exempt funds ($150M under a 3c1 exemption to the Investment Company Act of 1940), typically only accredited and well-connected investors and institutions who are able to meet large minimums and long lockups have the access, wherewithal, and temperament to take advantage of these powerful wealth-creating vehicles.</p><p>The bitter irony to all of this is that the cause of high registration costs is not government fees, but the cost of creating exhaustive disclosures. Though these disclosures ostensibly protect investors, the reality is that in all likelihood nobody actually reads or is able to fully understand these disclosures besides the lawyers and regulators themselves. What percent of mutual fund investors — or purchasers of individual corporate equities, do you suppose has read the disclosures for those securities…? Adding insult to injury, the logic underlying the accredited investor exemption is that those with more money or income are sufficiently savvy to make investment decisions with fewer disclosures, whereas the less well-off are not.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*0EKqQYIV7MjxjxM3" /></figure><p>The net result is that over 90% of Americans — everyone with less than $1M in investable assets or $200,000 in income — have been legally prohibited from participating in the vast majority of alternative investments as a result of well-intentioned but ultimately misguided regulations.</p><p><strong>The True Cost of Fund Administration</strong></p><p>While non-accredited investors are prohibited de jure from participating in alternative investment funds, as a practical matter, even most accredited investors are de facto excluded. This is because of both the cost of fund administration and the effects of Reg D funds being limited to 99 investors.</p><p>Administering investment funds remains a largely outsourced and manual endeavor. Most alternative investment funds are held together by proverbial duct tape, sold to investors via a combination of email and hard contracts, and are administered by outsourced companies whose employees punch numbers into spreadsheets on centralized ledgers that are printed quarterly to PDFs with no value-added tools for fund managers or investors. More significantly, minimum fees for outsourced fund administration from the market leader are $72K per year up to $100M in assets under management, thereafter increasing to usually 25 basis of the administered amount.</p><p>Given these high minimum administration costs and the 99-investor limit, fund managers are effectively forced to set high minimum investment amounts for their funds. Minimums are never less than $100K, and for the better funds, $250–500K is not uncommon. Given that the accredited investors have a mean net worth of $2.4M (which includes equity in their home), and that the mode is significantly closer to $1M, these limits preclude even most accredited investors from meaningfully participating in alternative asset funds.</p><p>The net result is that fewer than 5% of Americans are either legally allowed to invest in alternative investment funds or able to meet the minimums required to do so in a meaningful, diversified manner.</p><p><strong>How the Blockchain can Balance the Scales</strong></p><p>The rise of blockchain technology presents a unique opportunity to balance the scales for the first time in history. There are two ways in which the technology itself, as well as the tokenomic models and means of capitalization it enables, can disrupt the status quo.</p><p>Historically, investment companies, investment advisors, and funds have had one primary means of monetization — fees for assets under management — and one means of capitalizing — direct investment into fund inventory. The blockchain changes the equation. Firstly, blockchain investment companies can issue tokens as a non-dilutive means of raising capital. These funds can be used to fund the regulatory compliance needed to register funds for public offering. In this way, investors can effectively crowd-fund the creation of publicly-offered alternative investment products in a way never before possible. Furthermore, with the proper tokenomic models in place, investment companies can create additional revenue streams that can help offset investor fees and fund both regulatory compliance and administration costs.</p><p>With regard to fund administration, the blockchain offers an opportunity to disrupt the current state of fund management. Presently, 90% of all back-end fund management is administered by one company. The companies selling fund administration services to fund managers are in fact licensing the back end administration platform and serving as re-sellers and servicers. Making matters worse, the back-end technology is extremely outdated, and only just very recently went cloud-based, adopting 20 year old technology principles. Besides this technological limitation, and the added cost of having a middleman administrator, the fundamental nature of blockchain technology means that the root cause of the need for arms-length administration — namely limitation of liability and plausible deniability of any malfeasance in fund management — can be eschewed. This is because administering funds on the blockchain would mean that records would be transparent yet anonymous, as well as indelible and immutable by virtue of being decentralized. For all these reasons, it is a foregone conclusion that the status quo of fund administration will be disrupted by blockchain technology, which will enable lower-cost fund and more secure fund administration able to scale to a mass market.</p><p>BitFinance, a robo-investment platform for institutional-grade alternative assets, is utilizing both blockchain technology and economics in order to expand access to the $15T alternative market to the 95% of investors currently unable to participate, thereby massively expanding the global market for alternatives. We do this by innovating an all-new revenue model for a financial services company by:</p><ol><li>Capitalizing through a series of token sales to fund not only our platform development but also regulatory compliance to make our diversified alternative investment products available to investors of all classes.</li><li>Development of our patent pending smart contract-based Smart Fund Protocol™ to provide a scalable and low-cost fund administration architecture with lower minimum fees for funds that can also drive revenue via our B2B Smart Fund Service that will make this technology available to third-party funds.</li><li>Revenue and monetization driven by not only investor and Smart Fund Service fees but also our tokenomics.</li><li>And our status as a Public Benefit Corporation, which enables us to operate our investment platform as a Public Good for low fees offset by revenue from our other revenue streams.</li></ol><p>By leveraging these new technological, economic and legislative innovations, BitFinance is taking advantage of many of the same disruptive market forces that previously enabled online investment brokers like eTrade and subsequently robo-advisors like Betterment to rapidly scale to a global network of retail investors. In doing so, we intend to make alternative investments available to all classes of investors, thereby remedying a longstanding inequity in the investment world and properly Democratizing Finance.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c537860b1ca2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Fraud in Finance: Who Watches the Watchmen?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/bitfinance-inc/fraud-in-finance-who-watches-the-watchmen-5a44ff4e5d65?source=rss-3a9552a53168------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5a44ff4e5d65</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[altcoins]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sec]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hedge-funds]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[blockchain]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tokenization]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[BitFinance]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 07 Aug 2018 17:03:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-09-13T18:01:21.156Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Fraud in Finance: Who Watches the Watchmen? — How Smart Contract Fund Administration Can End Fraud in the Financial Services</h3><p>Lead Author: Eli M Blatt, PhD. Founder and CEO of BitFinance, PBC</p><p>Contributing Authors: Michael Conn, Martin Folb, Volodymyr Katanskyi, Karma Slomianski</p><p><strong>From Hieroglyphics to Stock Certificates</strong></p><p>Since the invention of hieroglyphics, fraud has been an inherent danger in financial transactions. The earliest transactions involved a direct exchange of hard assets — a goat for a bear hide, for example, or subsequently a goat for three bronze coins. With the advent of written means to record and represent information and with it value abstractly came the possibility of misrepresenting one side of an exchange: a goat for the promise of three coins — three coins the buyer might not actually have had despite their promise.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/360/1*VsjpFjnycbrnXnUyNRzxqA.png" /></figure><p>From this basic potential hidden asymmetry in trading goods and services for the promise of future currency, goods, or services, an entire universe of potential financial fraud was born. Fast forward to the modern era of finance, in particular the world of securities, and both the incentive and ability to commit fraud matured to their full potential. This modern era actually began over 400 years ago, with the sale of the very first stock certificates. The Dutch East India Trading Company is widely credited with inventing stock. In fact, the very term ‘stock’ was originally a literal reference to the rights to actual stock (e.g. goods such as tea) on the ships of the East India Trading Company. By abstracting the physical goods into certificates, the East India Trading Company effectively generalized the same process that ultimately was used<br>to make currencies not made from precious materials.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/360/1*xDSea_b6-Md8g4rOskDQKw.png" /></figure><p>Instead of physically needing to own the goods on the ship, one could simply own a stock ‘certificate’ that represented a claim against the Company for a pro-rata share of the stock on its ships. And so the security was born, and with it, the earliest forms of stock manipulation. No sooner than these first stocks were created than a stock market was created in the Netherlands, and with it the earliest instances of stock futures, stock options, short selling, bear raids,<br>debt-equity swaps, and other speculative instruments. Financial fraud has been a reality ever since: securities sold and profits promised, and in some cases given, that are illusory. In all cases, the fraud is made possible by the fact that the purchaser of a security has limited visibility into the assets backing the claim against the issuer represented by a security — or the fact that the nature or extent of these assets can be misrepresented with no reliable means of effectively auditing their veracity.</p><p><strong>Enter the Ponzi</strong></p><p>Looking at the history of modern financial fraud, we see that this pattern of misrepresenting the assets backing a security or dividends thereon has played out over and over again. The modern era of finance is perhaps best characterized by the advent of managed financial products vs. simply the ownership and trading of certificates representing underlying hard assets. In a managed financial product, an investor contributes capital to a venture and in return is promised a pro-rata return on their invested capital. In competing to attract investors, investment advisors and companies have an inherent motive to over-promise, even over-deliver, returns. The latter, in which the investment company pays out investors more than their pro-rata shares actually entitle them to in order to drive continued investment, is best known as the “Ponzi Scheme”.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/360/1*VS69q1rI4XkLXJPYU7DZAw.png" /></figure><p>The Ponzi Scheme is named after Charles Ponzi, an italian investor who moved to the United States in 1920. Although he was not the first to conduct this type of fraud, when his scheme collapsed, it left investors with millions of dollars in losses, earning him sufficient notoriety to have the dubious honor of having this type of fraud named after him. The grift is a simple one: investors are promised and given high returns on their investments, which in turn garners substantial additional investment as the word gets out about the profitability of the investment. But there’s a catch. The investment returns are illusory; in fact, the returns are powered by the new investment capital coming in, and thus the scheme is only viable so long as the fund is growing. In fact, the returns of initial investors are only made possible by new investors infusing additional capital. Once new investment capital slows, the whole scheme invariably collapses.</p><p>This type of scheme has unfolded myriad times since. Perhaps the largest and most well-known instance of this type of fraud was perpetrated by Bernard Madoff. A well-respected financier, Madoff solicited investment from thousands of investors, both individuals and institutional investors, by promising high returns, and using the influx of new capital to deliver them when needed, though mostly the returns were on paper, as investors were<br>incentivized to let their returns compound. Ultimately, the scheme collapsed at the onset of the financial collapse in 2008, when investors requested return of capital in excess of $7B when he had less than $300M available to pay out. When he was ultimately caught in December 2008 and charged with 11 counts of fraud, money laundering, perjury, and theft, his asset management fund was revealed, in fact, to be a massive Ponzi scheme. Madoff ended up having liabilities of approximately $65B and was sentenced to 150 years in prison with restitution of $17B. He and his two sons were sent to prison, where one of them committed suicide, as allegedly did 3 investors who were victims of Madoff’s scam. The human cost aside, the sheer scale of the financial losses suffered by investors made Madoff’s ponzi scheme the largest financial fraud ever committed in history.</p><p><strong>The Common Thread</strong></p><p>While Ponzi schemes are well known in part as a result of Madoff’s spectacular execution thereof, there are many other types of fraud, and in some cases it’s not even known what the exact nature or mechanism of the<br>fraud was.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/360/1*x6OlTdeZzrYTx5wZyhqtKg.png" /></figure><p>What all cases of financial fraud have in common, however, is that they are enabled by an asymmetry between promised or delivered returns and the actual underlying assets or dividends that are able to support those returns. What makes this asymmetry possible is that the investment companies’ ledgers — their tabulations of of funds coming in, growth, and dividends — is centralized and private, and thus able to be tampered with. This is precisely<br>what happened with the Enron scandal, in which Enron claimed illusory profits based on the market value instead of the book value of its assets; for example, it would record projected profits of a new power plant on their books, even if the subsequent actual profits did not materialize. Because the transactions comprising their books were centralized, non-transparent, and able to be manipulated by so-called mark-to-market accounting, this type of fraud was ultimately relatively easy to effectuate, even if ultimately hard to sustain in the long run.</p><p>Two recent examples of where lack of transparency in the delivery of profits to investors led to massive market losses are BitConnect and Davor Coin — perhaps the two largest cryptocurrency-related frauds, which combined<br>cost investors billions of dollars in losses. The common thread with both of these schemes, as with Madoff’s fraud, was that investors were promised and to some extent given significant financial returns without any transparency<br>into the underlying profit driver supporting those profits. Both companies had been offering as much as 40% returns per month. But because substantial incentives were in place to keep investors rolling profits back into their<br>investment principle, the companies were able to sustain the appearance of substantial profits without actually having to pay them out. Once the cryptocurrency market sputtered and many investors did decide to pull out<br>profits, however, both schemes collapsed, effectively in the same way Madoff’s did. The result for BitConnect was that the token price dropped from over $400 to under $0.50, wiping out over $2B in market cap overnight.<br>Likewise Davor coin went from a coin price over $100 to under $1, causing investors more than $1B in losses.</p><p><strong>Who Watches the Watchmen?</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/360/1*peLfxXgMkfpqWmlQ_o8mbA.png" /></figure><p>The vulnerability that enabled these notorious cases of fraud in both the traditional and cryptocurrency markets was a lack of adequate oversight and<br>transparency. Investment companies are charged with watching over and reporting the performance of investors’ capital, but who watches the<br>watchmen? In all these cases, there was limited if any oversight of the centralized accounting ledgers that in the case of Madoff and Enron were<br>all-too-easily manipulated; in the case of BitConnect and Davor coin, there was no oversight at all.</p><p>The latter cases are particularly interesting, because they happened within the blockchain space. Arguably the single most defining and revolutionary feature of blockchain technology is its decentralized, transparent and immutable ledger architecture. This makes it rather ironic that the two largest frauds in the space were propagated precisely because they relied on centralized, non-transparent, and manipulable ledgers. Whereas traditional markets rely on third-party oversight and auditing to watch the watchmen, in blockchain, the<br>watchmen’s actions watch themselves, in a manner of speaking, and are directly, immutably observable by any and all. Whereas third-party oversight is sporadic, manual, and often signals a problem only months or years later when the auditor severs ties with the investment company, blockchain-based auditing happens automatically in real-time with full transparency to all parties involved, making it nearly impossible to sustain fraud for any length of time.</p><p>The implication of this is that blockchain technology, if properly implemented within the financial services, holds the promise of forever preventing a financial fraud from manipulation, falsification, or non-reporting of financial<br>transactions or performance. Given this potential, it is not unreasonable to argue that given the proper asset reporting and management protocol, no investor should ever again invest in a fund or security that is not administered using blockchain technology — specifically via the use of smart contracts.</p><p><strong>Smart Fund Protocol</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/360/1*dzNwxkdXAwjZlrqcyxlQlw.png" /></figure><p>BitFinance has created just such a fund administration protocol and is in the process of launching it with a live investment fund. It’s called the Smart Fund ProtocolTM. This Protocol is a guaranteed fraud-proof retail investment platform featuring a blockchain-based immutable ledger of all investor portfolio and underlying fund activity, with a fully integrated, easy to use, public investment interface. This protocol will become a new standard for retail investment.</p><p><strong>Asset Bridge</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/360/1*4gUp-cpGP2v4duW-7Lx1-A.png" /></figure><p>The Smart Fund Protocol sits atop the BitFinance Asset BridgeTM, a proprietary technical implementation of the relationships between four key entities: Investors, Portfolios, Funds and Assets. The goal of the Asset Bridge is to manage, monitor, secure, validate and store every transaction securely on the Blockchain. This means that Investors can rebuild and retrace their entire portfolio history with BitFinance in a fully and auditable manner. The use of asynchronous digital messaging ensures that any changes are guaranteed to be recorded on an immutable, transparent blockchain ledger. This prevents any possibility of fraudulent reporting.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0Odt08IvAvMXhDdzhbeJGg.png" /></figure><p>Figure 1: BitFinance Smart Fund Protocol</p><p><strong>Hybrid Ledger</strong></p><p>All movements of assets and dividends, whether they be in currency, private or public funds, stocks or bonds will be recorded on the blockchain using a proprietary data structure called Hybrid LedgerTM. Using Hybrid Ledger,<br>all changes in fund membership, fund movement, dividends paid, as well as asset composition will be recorded in both ledgers via smart contracts, creating a fully transparent, fully immutable, decentralized fund reporting<br>and investor management system.</p><p>Beyond its own investment platform, BitFinance intends as part of its Mission as a Public Benefit Corporation to offer this Protocol as an API fee-for-service B2B offering to other investment funds in order to help protect investors from fraud. Once all transactions within and between funds, assets, investors and their portfolios can be recorded on blockchain in a decentralized, transparent and immutable way via the use of smart contracts, this will invariably become a global standard. As such, going forward no investor should ever again consider investing in a fund that does not use such a protocol to protect them from fraud.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5a44ff4e5d65" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/bitfinance-inc/fraud-in-finance-who-watches-the-watchmen-5a44ff4e5d65">Fraud in Finance: Who Watches the Watchmen?</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/bitfinance-inc">BitFinance PBC</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Welcome to the Carnival — A Primer on Token Classifications in the Current Global Regulatory…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/bitfinance-inc/welcome-to-the-carnival-a-primer-on-token-classifications-in-the-current-global-regulatory-8b12bd197042?source=rss-3a9552a53168------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8b12bd197042</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[altcoins]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[blockchain]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hedge-funds]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tokenization]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sec]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[BitFinance]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 12 Jul 2018 18:19:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-09-04T19:41:29.021Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Welcome to the Carnival — A Primer on Token Classifications in the Current Global Regulatory Environment</h3><p>Author: Eli M Blatt, PhD. Founder and CEO of BitFinance, PBC and Whitepaper Consultant at Blockchainpr.io</p><p><strong>Coin Confusion</strong></p><p>There is widespread misconception that regulations for the offer and sale of cryptocurrencies are as yet either non-existent or else ill-defined. In fact, while the regulatory landscape regarding cryptocurrencies and token sales specifically is beginning to shift globally and new regulations are being formulated and codified, the most relevant regulations in the U.S. and abroad affecting cryptocurrencies and tokens are securities and tax laws, which have existed for nearly 100 years. For those who understand developing international standards around the legal treatment of tokens and are positioned to capitalize thereon, the regulatory landscape is quickly becoming less of a hazard and more of an opportunity. That said, perhaps the single biggest area of Fear Uncertainty and Doubt (“FUD”) in the international ICO landscape is a general misunderstanding of the difference between token types within and between international jurisdictions.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/360/1*eEOxIyDsVBk4P8a-8YESTw.png" /></figure><p><strong>Utility, Payment, and Security Tokens</strong></p><p>There is a trend across exchanges for investors and traders to treat all coins as equities, even though many are patently not equities, as they do not render the holder a shareholder of the issuing entity, and even though in many cases the coins are explicitly positioned as not being securities by virtue of having a utility. But having a utility, at least in the United States, is not relevant to whether a token is considered a security; and internationally, whether or not a utility token is, in fact, a security depends on when that utility is available relative to when the token is issued. Utility aside, being a security does not make a token an equity — though being an equity does make a token a security. Simple, right? Taking a step back from tokens and differences in classification across international jurisdictions, let’s look at what securities and equities are in principle and how they relate to tokens that have a putative utility which ostensibly renders them neither a security or equity.</p><p>Broadly speaking, the term “security” refers to any investment product that 1) can be exchanged for value and 2) involves exposure to risk in the form of loss of value. Additionally, securities must be readily transferable between two parties, and the owner must be subject to the loss of some or all of the invested principal. Key attributes of a security are thus transferability, the expectation of gain, and the potential for loss.</p><p>An equity is generally any security representing an ownership interest, a right to distribution, and/or a right to liquidation in the issuing entity, whether private or publicly traded. Thus, all equities are by definition securities, but not all securities are equities. These two financial instruments, securities and equities, are well established and there exists little confusion or discrepancy across international jurisdictions on their classification, whether in tokenized or paper incarnations.</p><p>But what about a utility token? This is a somewhat new classification and it’s where things begin to get nuanced. This is because it’s increasingly clear not only in the United States (where the expectation of gain alone on the part of the purchaser is enough to render a utility token a security — more on that below) but also abroad that simply having an ostensible utility does not mean a token will not be deemed a security. If a token is sold as a utility token without complying with securities regulations but is subsequently construed by a regulatory body to be a security, the issuer may be subjected to civil liability, rescission, fines and criminal prosecution. And the token will likely also be delisted from current exchanges, which are not registered to exchange securities.</p><p>To help delineate the classifications, consider by analogy a scenario where the tokens will not be used for a digital product, but rather for going to a Carnival — an experience most of us can relate to.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/360/1*Han3GG6-7I8d0nPpceZ94w.png" /></figure><p><strong>Utility tokens</strong> are your ticket to the Carnival, meaning they get you access to the Carnival grounds. Inside the Carnival, some rides and attractions may be included as part of admission, and of course while inside the park you get to explore and have fun with your friends. But these tokens don’t enable you to play all the games or go on all the rides, and you don’t get free food either — or a chance to win a giant teddy bear — you just get to enter the Carnival. Your entrance ticket is not exchangeable for goods or services, just access to the Carnival, and although it is transferable, it does not have the potential for principal loss. Through this analogy, it is clear how a properly structured utility token that provides access to a platform or network will not be considered a security (at least in jurisdictions outside the United States, more on this below).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/360/1*WzKQsuh2alVTOjCu__rTJw.png" /></figure><p><strong>Payment tokens </strong>allow you to buy goods and services inside the carnival for effective cash value; they are the Carnival’s transactional currency<strong>.</strong> If you want to take full advantage of all the attractions inside the Carnival — play the games, take the rides, eat the food, win a teddy bear — you need these separate payment tokens that can be effectively redeemed for cash value. It’s the effective cash value of the tokens and the fact that more tokens are redeemable for goods and services that renders them payment tokens. Since the value of the tokens doesn’t change — the same number of tokens is always required to take a ride or buy food — there is no expectation of gain and no potential for principal loss, and so payment tokens do not qualify as securities.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/360/1*7ts_neF37XbfSqh8QeAOQg.png" /></figure><p><strong>Security tokens</strong> are a way to actually invest in the Carnival and become a beneficial owner<em>.</em>If, after a day of paying admission to the park with a utility token and paying for games and rides with payment tokens, you decide you like the Carnival so much you want to actually own an interest in the park itself and potentially receive dividends if it’s profitable, you can find the owner and buy an ownership stake in the Carnival in the form of either a security token or any other traditional equity interest. Because this token is transferable and investors have the potential to either gain or lose money holding it, it is a security. And because the token represents interests in an enterprise, giving the issuer a claim against the principal and profit of the Carnival, it’s not just a security but an equity token.</p><p>Simple, right? Not quite, as Carnivals in different states are subject to different requirements. Because officials don’t want charlatans stealing people’s money and having the games rigged so people can never get their prizes, there are laws in every state around gaming and gaming commissions that regulate whether and how one can run these Carnivals. If you want to open your Carnival in Los Angeles, there are all kinds of permits, security, bonds, insurance, regulatory hurdles and approvals that are required and it could take a year to clear the regulatory hurdles (e.g., Public Health Department, Franchise Tax Board, California Gambling Control Commission and local permits), but if you want to open the Carnival in Cody, Wyoming, you might simply have to pull a permit from the Department of Agriculture, choose a location and be able to get your Carnival up and running in a month.</p><p>To bring the analogy back full circle to ICOs, consider BitFinance, which is launching an online investment platform at bitfinance.com where retail investors will be able to purchase institutional-grade alternative investments. BitFinance will issue BFA, a utility access token that unlocks access on the investment platform to BitFinance’s funds by asset class. But to actually make an investment in the funds, users need to purchase their interests in the funds using BFI, a payment token used to purchase BitFinance investment products; the fact that the token is exchangeable and that the holder can gain or lose money in the process renders it a security. And then, finally, in order to enable its users to become shareholders, BitFinance will issue BFE, a corporate equity token, which likewise is considered a security.</p><p>But this platform will be available to ICO investors worldwide. This creates a wrinkle because just as Wyoming and California have different regulatory standards around Carnivals, so do different international jurisdictions have differing regulations around securities and tokens. The main issue that arises in evaluating token sales across international jurisdictions is whether a token marketed as a “utility token” will in fact not ultimately be deemed a security in some or all international jurisdictions. And given exchanges’ recent positions to defer to classification as a security if a token is offered in any jurisdiction as a security, this issue becomes all the more critical.</p><p>This brings us to an important distinction that must be considered when evaluating the international regulatory landscape: namely that, compared to many other international jurisdictions, the United States follows a different standard for determining whether something is a security or not.</p><p><strong>International Regulatory Landscape</strong></p><p>The United States, by virtue of a nearly Century old law, evaluates tokens using a different standard than most of the international community. Outside the United States, there are increasingly clear signs that the international community will adopt Swiss law around token classification. That being said, the U.S. is still perceived to be one of the most advanced and secure financial markets in the world.</p><p>The legal test in the United States for determining whether a transaction is a “security” is the “Howey Test,” which resulted from the 1946 Supreme Court decision in SEC v. W.J. Howey Co., 328 U.S. 293, 298–99 (1946). Under Howey, an “investment contract” is deemed a “security” as used in the provisions of § 2(1) of the Securities Act of 1933 (“the Act”) and registration or an applicable exemption is required under the Act, when a “contract, transaction or scheme whereby a person invests his money in a common enterprise and is led to expect profit solely from the efforts of the promoter or a third party.”</p><p>Since the Howey ruling, courts have broken the Howey test into four prongs to determine whether a transaction is a security, as follows:</p><p>1. Does there exist an investment of money?</p><p>2. Does there exist a common enterprise?</p><p>3. Does there exist an expectation of profit?</p><p>4. Is the expectation of profit solely from the efforts of others?</p><p>While many issuers of utility tokens have argued that the tokens represent the sale of goods or services, the expectation of gain among buyers, most of whom are purchasing the tokens at a discount, means that those tokens would be deemed to be securities. As a consequence, the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has provided a strong indication via recent subpoenas that any Simple Agreements for Future Tokens (SAFTs), ICOs or token issuances, whether labeled a utility, currency or equity, will be deemed by the SEC to be “securities”. As SEC chairman Jay Clayton stated plainly: “every ICO I’ve seen is a security”.</p><p>The basis for classifying utility tokens, as well as the SAFTs and more recently RATEs (Real Agreements for Tokens and Equity) by which most have been sold to investors to date, as non-equity securities in the U.S. is that under the Howey test (1) the tokens do not yet exist and therefore the SAFT is being construed as a “futures contract”, and (2) there is an expectation of profit from speculation that the tokens will go up in value and betradable. It is this second criteria where the United States appears to diverge from the rest of the international community.</p><p>There are numerous of jurisdictions (e.g., Japan, Estonia, Singapore, and Switzerland) where a true utility token would not be deemed a security simply because of a purchaser’s expectation of gain. By analogy, if one were to buy a car, an art piece, a bottle of wine, or a concert ticket with the expectation of selling said property at a profit, it would generally not be considered a security. However, if the property did not yet exist and the good itself had not yet been delivered, but rather there was a token representing the good or a promise of future utility not currently available, then there would be a high probability that the token would be deemed a security in most jurisdictions. In the United States, however, the mere fact that almost all tokens are sold at a discount creates a prima facie case that the investor expects a gain and therefore assumes that the token will be deemed a security under United States Law.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/360/1*1xNNScl8f-uLvifwdKMxHg.png" /></figure><p>The distinction of whether the token exists when it is sold, whether the goods or services exist at the time it is issued, and whether the purchase of the token is primarily driven by access to the service or the purchase of the good vs. as an investment is becoming determinative of its classification in foreign jurisdictions. The relevant laws that may be applied are the banking legislation for any deposit-taking activity; the securities legislation for tokens classified as securities; the anti-money laundering legislation for any activity of a financial intermediary for AML purposes; and the collective investment schemes legislation for any fund management or related activity. The issue of whether or not a token will be deemed a security is delineated in the most recent regulatory guidance from the Swiss Financial Market Supervisory Authority (FINMA). FINMA’s guidance assists in determining how to structure the sale of tokens and coins in Switzerland and is indicative of the regulatory trend in many other jurisdictions.</p><p>FINMA classified tokens in 3 classes:</p><ol><li><strong>Payment tokens or cryptocurrencies</strong> are intended only as means of payment for acquiring goods or services and that do not give rise to any claims against the issuer. To the extent that a token does not constitute a digital representation of any rights of token holders that are exercisable against the issuer but instead are designed to be used as a means of transacting payment, it would not qualify as securities under FINMA guidelines.</li><li><strong>Utility tokens</strong> provide access rights to a digital application or service. An important caveat to this definition provided by FINMA is that the utility provided by the token must be available at the time the token is issued; if the token promises a future utility that does not exist at the time of issuance, the token would be considered to have an investment purpose and thus would be deemed a security under FINMA guidelines. Less clear under FINMA guidelines is the extent of the utility promised by a token that has to be available at the time of issuance in order to not be deemed a security. For example, a token that provides access to a Beta platform that does not afford the full future utility promised by the token could potentially be deemed a security. Whether or not the utility afforded by a token at the time of issuance is sufficient for the token to not be deemed to have an investment purpose and thus be deemed a security can be discussed with FINMA.</li><li><strong>Asset tokens</strong> represent an asset, a debt or equity claim against the issuer or a third party. This includes tokens that represent pro-rata rights to an underlying commodity, equity, or revenue. All asset tokens will be deemed securities under FINMA guidelines by virtue of their digital representation of equity interests in an underlying asset.</li><li>Tokens may also take a <strong>hybrid form</strong> by including elements of more than one category, for example an asset token that can be used as a transactional currency would be deemed a security by virtue of being an asset token, regardless of its use as a payment token.</li></ol><p><strong>The Rise of Security Tokens</strong></p><p>While much talk is made in the United States and abroad regarding ‘security tokens’ and so called STO (Security Token Offerings), the Swiss guidelines lay out a very different schema, effectively classifying asset tokens as equity tokens and treating the matter of whether a token is a security as a function of whether it represents effectively a futures contract or not. There is arguably a prevalent misnomer in discussions of STOs whereby tokens being called security tokens should arguably be called equity tokens or asset tokens; the terms are often inappropriately used interchangeably. This is because a utility token can be a security — as arguably could be a payment token if it were solely used to purchase securities. In fact, the term ‘security token’ relates less to the payment, utility, or asset-backed nature of a token than it does to how the token will be classified and regulated by international agencies; namely whether it will be deemed to be a security or not, regardless of the token’s ostensible use or value, and whether or not as a result that token can be traded on existing exchanges.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/360/1*7ts_neF37XbfSqh8QeAOQg.png" /></figure><p>The exchanges now operating worldwide are utility token exchanges; they are not regulated in a manner that permits them to exchange securities. This is one big reason for recent investor trepidation around investing in utility tokens that could ultimately be deemed to be securities based on their having been sold prior to issuance or issued prior to having an active network to which they offer access; besides potentially running the issuers afoul of international regulations, the tokens could find themselves delisted from utility token exchanges likewise worried about running afoul of international securities laws. The oncoming wave of security token exchanges such as t0 are regulated to exchange securities, just as traditional stock exchanges are. And since a token that is issued explicitly as a security has no less international legal ambiguity than any other type of security, this means that so-called security tokens (whether the token has a utility or is used as a means of payment or to represent a digital claim to an underlying asset) can be sold and exchanged on those exchanges without any of the FUD that currently plagues utility tokens. This is the reason for the incredible amount of excitement and anticipation surrounding security tokens.</p><p><strong>The Path Forward</strong></p><p>Using the Swiss guidelines as a harbinger, recent developments in the regulatory environment entail that for a utility token to not be deemed a security — at least outside of the United States — the utility afforded by the token must be available at the time the token is issued. This also means that the legal trend worldwide is to deem SAFTs as securities. If the network to which the token provides access is not yet active at the time of its sale, or if in any other salient way the token represents a promise of a future utility as opposed to a presently available one, the token or SAFT promising a future token will likely be deemed a security in every jurisdiction worldwide.</p><p>Given this regulatory landscape, it seems that the best strategy for an ICO today where the ICO is funding the development of a product, service, or platform to which the token will provide access (as opposed to an existing product or service that offers an ICO to access it) is to conduct a traditional equity round of financing separate and apart from any token sale, and then use the proceeds of the equity round to build the network, product or service.</p><p>The next step would be to mint the tokens offshore as a utility token sale with real and existing tokens that have immediate access to a real platform with tangible value. This, under Swiss law, would be a utility token and not be deemed a security. After proving the model offshore, the issuer of the token can seek a no action letter from the SEC and, if obtained, bring the network and token sale onshore as a utility rather than as a security. Alternatively, United States investors can be excluded in the ICO, or else the token can be issued as an exempt Security under SEC Reg.D 505(c), limiting the U.S. raise to 99 accredited investors and up to $150M.</p><p>If a company issues a token that will potentially be deemed a security under Swiss guidelines, exchanges that operate outside of the U.S. jurisdictions won’t allow the tokens on their exchanges, because they want to be able to openly sell the token without violating securities law. And investors that want to purchase tokens tradable on an exchange outside of the U.S. within the next 6 months likely won’t invest for that same reason. Since at present there are no security token exchanges operating, let alone any trading velocity for security tokens, it is not an ideal time to launch a security token.</p><p>So, if a company wants to issue a token that can be listed on exchanges and have trading velocity, value and volume in the next 6 months, they pretty much need to issue a token that is unambiguously not a security under FINMA guidelines and to sell the tokens in jurisdictions with clear guidance deeming that the token is not a security.</p><p>All of these distinctions demonstrate how important it is for issuers of tokens to carefully consider how their token will be classified with regards to securities law, and which jurisdictions will provide the most favorable tax, securities and consumer protection treatment for their offerings.</p><p><strong>To summarize:</strong></p><ol><li>In the United States, the SEC has provided guidance that the expectation of gain upon exchange of the token by an investor renders both tokens and their purchase contract (especially a futures contract such as a SAFT), a security, regardless of any putative utility.</li><li>In foreign jurisdictions, Swiss Law appears to be setting the standard for distinguishing between three token types:</li><li><strong>Payment tokens</strong> are tokens used purely for transactional purposes and do not represent any rights by the holder against the issuer.</li><li><strong>Utility tokens</strong> must be deliverable at the time of sale and have a utility at the time of the token launch — not be a promise of future utility — in order to not be deemed securities despite their putative utility.</li><li><strong>Asset tokens</strong> represent an ownership interest or right in or against the issuer resulting in a potential for gain or loss and will as a result be prima facie deemed securities.</li><li>Both Payment and Utility tokens could be deemed to be securities regardless of their transactional nature or utility value if they are effectively deemed to represent a futures contract.</li><li>When planning a token offering for a:</li><li>Utility token: Make sure the utility granted by the token is available at the time the token is issued.</li><li>Realize that if you are selling the promise of a token (e.g. a SAFT) or of a future utility not active at the time the token is issued, it will be deemed a security regardless of the token’s putative utility.</li><li>If launching a token for an as-yet-to-be-developed network, consider raising an equity round to fund development of the platform prior to issuing the token.</li><li><strong>Security token:</strong> Beware of more strenuous international regulation around compliance for securities, as well as the fact that there is at present no significant or secondary market for security tokens given the lack of security token exchanges.</li><li>Recognize that there is at present no significant secondary market for security tokens given the lack of security token exchanges.</li><li>Note SEC Rule 144 and Section 4(a)(7) which require a 12-month lockup prior to public sales with the potential for resale to other accredited investors after three months.</li><li>Take into account the ability of US token holders to resell to foreign investors or potentially soon to US investors on ATS exchanges without a lockup period.</li></ol><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8b12bd197042" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/bitfinance-inc/welcome-to-the-carnival-a-primer-on-token-classifications-in-the-current-global-regulatory-8b12bd197042">Welcome to the Carnival — A Primer on Token Classifications in the Current Global Regulatory…</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/bitfinance-inc">BitFinance PBC</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Welcome to the Carnival — A Primer on Token Classifications in the Current Global Regulatory…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@contact_90709/welcome-to-the-carnival-a-primer-on-token-classifications-in-the-current-global-regulatory-60b5d09afbf1?source=rss-3a9552a53168------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/60b5d09afbf1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[sec]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hedge-funds]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[blockchain]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[BitFinance]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 12 Jul 2018 17:56:02 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-07-12T17:56:02.045Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Welcome to the Carnival — A Primer on Token Classifications in the Current Global Regulatory Environment</h3><p>Author: Eli M Blatt, PhD. Founder and CEO of BitFinance, PBC and Whitepaper Consultant at Blockchainpr.io</p><p><strong>Coin Confusion</strong></p><p>There is widespread misconception that regulations for the offer and sale of cryptocurrencies are as yet either non-existent or else ill-defined. In fact, while the regulatory landscape regarding cryptocurrencies and token sales specifically is beginning to shift globally and new regulations are being formulated and codified, the most relevant regulations in the U.S. and abroad affecting cryptocurrencies and tokens are securities and tax laws, which have existed for nearly 100 years. For those who understand developing international standards around the legal treatment of tokens and are positioned to capitalize thereon, the regulatory landscape is quickly becoming less of a hazard and more of an opportunity. That said, perhaps the single biggest area of Fear Uncertainty and Doubt (“FUD”) in the international ICO landscape is a general misunderstanding of the difference between token types within and between international jurisdictions.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*GOdYJVwh24w59WlGM72K5g.png" /></figure><p><strong>Utility, Payment, and Security Tokens</strong></p><p>There is a trend across exchanges for investors and traders to treat all coins as equities, even though many are patently not equities, as they do not render the holder a shareholder of the issuing entity, and even though in many cases the coins are explicitly positioned as not being securities by virtue of having a utility. But having a utility, at least in the United States, is not relevant to whether a token is considered a security; and internationally, whether or not a utility token is, in fact, a security depends on when that utility is available relative to when the token is issued. Utility aside, being a security does not make a token an equity — though being an equity does make a token a security. Simple, right? Taking a step back from tokens and differences in classification across international jurisdictions, let’s look at what securities and equities are in principle and how they relate to tokens that have a putative utility which ostensibly renders them neither a security or equity.</p><p>Broadly speaking, the term “security” refers to any investment product that 1) can be exchanged for value and 2) involves exposure to risk in the form of loss of value. Additionally, securities must be readily transferable between two parties, and the owner must be subject to the loss of some or all of the invested principal. Key attributes of a security are thus transferability, the expectation of gain, and the potential for loss.</p><p>An equity is generally any security representing an ownership interest, a right to distribution, and/or a right to liquidation in the issuing entity, whether private or publicly traded. Thus, all equities are by definition securities, but not all securities are equities. These two financial instruments, securities and equities, are well established and there exists little confusion or discrepancy across international jurisdictions on their classification, whether in tokenized or paper incarnations.</p><p>But what about a utility token? This is a somewhat new classification and it’s where things begin to get nuanced. This is because it’s increasingly clear not only in the United States (where the expectation of gain alone on the part of the purchaser is enough to render a utility token a security — more on that below) but also abroad that simply having an ostensible utility does not mean a token will not be deemed a security. If a token is sold as a utility token without complying with securities regulations but is subsequently construed by a regulatory body to be a security, the issuer may be subjected to civil liability, rescission, fines and criminal prosecution. And the token will likely also be delisted from current exchanges, which are not registered to exchange securities.</p><p>To help delineate the classifications, consider by analogy a scenario where the tokens will not be used for a digital product, but rather for going to a Carnival — an experience most of us can relate to.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*JNmWRb1w8eKHryH8KcxEgQ.png" /></figure><p><strong>Utility tokens</strong> are your ticket to the Carnival, meaning they get you access to the Carnival grounds. Inside the Carnival, some rides and attractions may be included as part of admission, and of course while inside the park you get to explore and have fun with your friends. But these tokens don’t enable you to play all the games or go on all the rides, and you don’t get free food either — or a chance to win a giant teddy bear — you just get to enter the Carnival. Your entrance ticket is not exchangeable for goods or services, just access to the Carnival, and although it is transferable, it does not have the potential for principal loss. Through this analogy, it is clear how a properly structured utility token that provides access to a platform or network will not be considered a security (at least in jurisdictions outside the United States, more on this below).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-xrvMMl9LO1jefp28L-Log.png" /></figure><p><strong>Payment tokens </strong>allow you to buy goods and services inside the carnival for effective cash value; they are the Carnival’s transactional currency<strong>.</strong> If you want to take full advantage of all the attractions inside the Carnival — play the games, take the rides, eat the food, win a teddy bear — you need these separate payment tokens that can be effectively redeemed for cash value. It’s the effective cash value of the tokens and the fact that more tokens are redeemable for goods and services that renders them payment tokens. Since the value of the tokens doesn’t change — the same number of tokens is always required to take a ride or buy food — there is no expectation of gain and no potential for principal loss, and so payment tokens do not qualify as securities.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xSiK-L24fo65nldjlRvyCg.png" /></figure><p><strong>Security tokens</strong> are a way to actually invest in the Carnival and become a beneficial owner<em>.</em> If, after a day of paying admission to the park with a utility token and paying for games and rides with payment tokens, you decide you like the Carnival so much you want to actually own an interest in the park itself and potentially receive dividends if it’s profitable, you can find the owner and buy an ownership stake in the Carnival in the form of either a security token or any other traditional equity interest. Because this token is transferable and investors have the potential to either gain or lose money holding it, it is a security. And because the token represents interests in an enterprise, giving the issuer a claim against the principal and profit of the Carnival, it’s not just a security but an equity token.</p><p>Simple, right? Not quite, as Carnivals in different states are subject to different requirements. Because officials don’t want charlatans stealing people’s money and having the games rigged so people can never get their prizes, there are laws in every state around gaming and gaming commissions that regulate whether and how one can run these Carnivals. If you want to open your Carnival in Los Angeles, there are all kinds of permits, security, bonds, insurance, regulatory hurdles and approvals that are required and it could take a year to clear the regulatory hurdles (e.g., Public Health Department, Franchise Tax Board, California Gambling Control Commission and local permits), but if you want to open the Carnival in Cody, Wyoming, you might simply have to pull a permit from the Department of Agriculture, choose a location and be able to get your Carnival up and running in a month.</p><p>To bring the analogy back full circle to ICOs, consider BitFinance, which is launching an online investment platform at bitfinance.com where retail investors will be able to purchase institutional-grade alternative investments. BitFinance will issue BFA, a utility access token that unlocks access on the investment platform to BitFinance’s funds by asset class. But to actually make an investment in the funds, users need to purchase their interests in the funds using BFI, a payment token used to purchase BitFinance investment products; the fact that the token is exchangeable and that the holder can gain or lose money in the process renders it a security. And then, finally, in order to enable its users to become shareholders, BitFinance will issue BFE, a corporate equity token, which likewise is considered a security.</p><p>But this platform will be available to ICO investors worldwide. This creates a wrinkle because just as Wyoming and California have different regulatory standards around Carnivals, so do different international jurisdictions have differing regulations around securities and tokens. The main issue that arises in evaluating token sales across international jurisdictions is whether a token marketed as a “utility token” will in fact not ultimately be deemed a security in some or all international jurisdictions. And given exchanges’ recent positions to defer to classification as a security if a token is offered in any jurisdiction as a security, this issue becomes all the more critical.</p><p>This brings us to an important distinction that must be considered when evaluating the international regulatory landscape: namely that, compared to many other international jurisdictions, the United States follows a different standard for determining whether something is a security or not.</p><p><strong>International Regulatory Landscape</strong></p><p>The United States, by virtue of a nearly Century old law, evaluates tokens using a different standard than most of the international community. Outside the United States, there are increasingly clear signs that the international community will adopt Swiss law around token classification. That being said, the U.S. is still perceived to be one of the most advanced and secure financial markets in the world.</p><p>The legal test in the United States for determining whether a transaction is a “security” is the “Howey Test,” which resulted from the 1946 Supreme Court decision in SEC v. W.J. Howey Co., 328 U.S. 293, 298–99 (1946). Under Howey, an “investment contract” is deemed a “security” as used in the provisions of § 2(1) of the Securities Act of 1933 (“the Act”) and registration or an applicable exemption is required under the Act, when a “contract, transaction or scheme whereby a person invests his money in a common enterprise and is led to expect profit solely from the efforts of the promoter or a third party.”</p><p>Since the Howey ruling, courts have broken the Howey test into four prongs to determine whether a transaction is a security, as follows:</p><p>1. Does there exist an investment of money?</p><p>2. Does there exist a common enterprise?</p><p>3. Does there exist an expectation of profit?</p><p>4. Is the expectation of profit solely from the efforts of others?</p><p>While many issuers of utility tokens have argued that the tokens represent the sale of goods or services, the expectation of gain among buyers, most of whom are purchasing the tokens at a discount, means that those tokens would be deemed to be securities. As a consequence, the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has provided a strong indication via recent subpoenas that any Simple Agreements for Future Tokens (SAFTs), ICOs or token issuances, whether labeled a utility, currency or equity, will be deemed by the SEC to be “securities”. As SEC chairman Jay Clayton stated plainly: “every ICO I’ve seen is a security”.</p><p>The basis for classifying utility tokens, as well as the SAFTs and more recently RATEs (Real Agreements for Tokens and Equity) by which most have been sold to investors to date, as non-equity securities in the U.S. is that under the Howey test (1) the tokens do not yet exist and therefore the SAFT is being construed as a “futures contract”, and (2) there is an expectation of profit from speculation that the tokens will go up in value and betradable. It is this second criteria where the United States appears to diverge from the rest of the international community.</p><p>There are numerous of jurisdictions (e.g., Japan, Estonia, Singapore, and Switzerland) where a true utility token would not be deemed a security simply because of a purchaser’s expectation of gain. By analogy, if one were to buy a car, an art piece, a bottle of wine, or a concert ticket with the expectation of selling said property at a profit, it would generally not be considered a security. However, if the property did not yet exist and the good itself had not yet been delivered, but rather there was a token representing the good or a promise of future utility not currently available, then there would be a high probability that the token would be deemed a security in most jurisdictions. In the United States, however, the mere fact that almost all tokens are sold at a discount creates a prima facie case that the investor expects a gain and therefore assumes that the token will be deemed a security under United States Law.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ye85e7lMO_qswgyZSVaX3Q.png" /></figure><p>The distinction of whether the token exists when it is sold, whether the goods or services exist at the time it is issued, and whether the purchase of the token is primarily driven by access to the service or the purchase of the good vs. as an investment is becoming determinative of its classification in foreign jurisdictions. The relevant laws that may be applied are the banking legislation for any deposit-taking activity; the securities legislation for tokens classified as securities; the anti-money laundering legislation for any activity of a financial intermediary for AML purposes; and the collective investment schemes legislation for any fund management or related activity. The issue of whether or not a token will be deemed a security is delineated in the most recent regulatory guidance from the Swiss Financial Market Supervisory Authority (FINMA). FINMA’s guidance assists in determining how to structure the sale of tokens and coins in Switzerland and is indicative of the regulatory trend in many other jurisdictions.</p><p>FINMA classified tokens in 3 classes:</p><ol><li><strong>Payment tokens or cryptocurrencies</strong> are intended only as means of payment for acquiring goods or services and that do not give rise to any claims against the issuer. To the extent that a token does not constitute a digital representation of any rights of token holders that are exercisable against the issuer but instead are designed to be used as a means of transacting payment, it would not qualify as securities under FINMA guidelines.</li><li><strong>Utility tokens</strong> provide access rights to a digital application or service. An important caveat to this definition provided by FINMA is that the utility provided by the token must be available at the time the token is issued; if the token promises a future utility that does not exist at the time of issuance, the token would be considered to have an investment purpose and thus would be deemed a security under FINMA guidelines. Less clear under FINMA guidelines is the extent of the utility promised by a token that has to be available at the time of issuance in order to not be deemed a security. For example, a token that provides access to a Beta platform that does not afford the full future utility promised by the token could potentially be deemed a security. Whether or not the utility afforded by a token at the time of issuance is sufficient for the token to not be deemed to have an investment purpose and thus be deemed a security can be discussed with FINMA.</li><li><strong>Asset tokens</strong> represent an asset, a debt or equity claim against the issuer or a third party. This includes tokens that represent pro-rata rights to an underlying commodity, equity, or revenue. All asset tokens will be deemed securities under FINMA guidelines by virtue of their digital representation of equity interests in an underlying asset.</li><li>Tokens may also take a <strong>hybrid form</strong> by including elements of more than one category, for example an asset token that can be used as a transactional currency would be deemed a security by virtue of being an asset token, regardless of its use as a payment token.</li></ol><p><strong>The Rise of Security Tokens</strong></p><p>While much talk is made in the United States and abroad regarding ‘security tokens’ and so called STO (Security Token Offerings), the Swiss guidelines lay out a very different schema, effectively classifying asset tokens as equity tokens and treating the matter of whether a token is a security as a function of whether it represents effectively a futures contract or not. There is arguably a prevalent misnomer in discussions of STOs whereby tokens being called security tokens should arguably be called equity tokens or asset tokens; the terms are often inappropriately used interchangeably. This is because a utility token can be a security — as arguably could be a payment token if it were solely used to purchase securities. In fact, the term ‘security token’ relates less to the payment, utility, or asset-backed nature of a token than it does to how the token will be classified and regulated by international agencies; namely whether it will be deemed to be a security or not, regardless of the token’s ostensible use or value, and whether or not as a result that token can be traded on existing exchanges.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xSiK-L24fo65nldjlRvyCg.png" /></figure><p>The exchanges now operating worldwide are utility token exchanges; they are not regulated in a manner that permits them to exchange securities. This is one big reason for recent investor trepidation around investing in utility tokens that could ultimately be deemed to be securities based on their having been sold prior to issuance or issued prior to having an active network to which they offer access; besides potentially running the issuers afoul of international regulations, the tokens could find themselves delisted from utility token exchanges likewise worried about running afoul of international securities laws. The oncoming wave of security token exchanges such as t0 are regulated to exchange securities, just as traditional stock exchanges are. And since a token that is issued explicitly as a security has no less international legal ambiguity than any other type of security, this means that so-called security tokens (whether the token has a utility or is used as a means of payment or to represent a digital claim to an underlying asset) can be sold and exchanged on those exchanges without any of the FUD that currently plagues utility tokens. This is the reason for the incredible amount of excitement and anticipation surrounding security tokens.</p><p><strong>The Path Forward</strong></p><p>Using the Swiss guidelines as a harbinger, recent developments in the regulatory environment entail that for a utility token to not be deemed a security — at least outside of the United States — the utility afforded by the token must be available at the time the token is issued. This also means that the legal trend worldwide is to deem SAFTs as securities. If the network to which the token provides access is not yet active at the time of its sale, or if in any other salient way the token represents a promise of a future utility as opposed to a presently available one, the token or SAFT promising a future token will likely be deemed a security in every jurisdiction worldwide.</p><p>Given this regulatory landscape, it seems that the best strategy for an ICO today where the ICO is funding the development of a product, service, or platform to which the token will provide access (as opposed to an existing product or service that offers an ICO to access it) is to conduct a traditional equity round of financing separate and apart from any token sale, and then use the proceeds of the equity round to build the network, product or service.</p><p>The next step would be to mint the tokens offshore as a utility token sale with real and existing tokens that have immediate access to a real platform with tangible value. This, under Swiss law, would be a utility token and not be deemed a security. After proving the model offshore, the issuer of the token can seek a no action letter from the SEC and, if obtained, bring the network and token sale onshore as a utility rather than as a security. Alternatively, United States investors can be excluded in the ICO, or else the token can be issued as an exempt Security under SEC Reg.D 505(c), limiting the U.S. raise to 99 accredited investors and up to $150M.</p><p>If a company issues a token that will potentially be deemed a security under Swiss guidelines, exchanges that operate outside of the U.S. jurisdictions won’t allow the tokens on their exchanges, because they want to be able to openly sell the token without violating securities law. And investors that want to purchase tokens tradable on an exchange outside of the U.S. within the next 6 months likely won’t invest for that same reason. Since at present there are no security token exchanges operating, let alone any trading velocity for security tokens, it is not an ideal time to launch a security token.</p><p>So, if a company wants to issue a token that can be listed on exchanges and have trading velocity, value and volume in the next 6 months, they pretty much need to issue a token that is unambiguously not a security under FINMA guidelines and to sell the tokens in jurisdictions with clear guidance deeming that the token is not a security.</p><p>All of these distinctions demonstrate how important it is for issuers of tokens to carefully consider how their token will be classified with regards to securities law, and which jurisdictions will provide the most favorable tax, securities and consumer protection treatment for their offerings.</p><p>To summarize:</p><ol><li>In the United States, the SEC has provided guidance that the expectation of gain upon exchange of the token by an investor renders both tokens and their purchase contract (especially a futures contract such as a SAFT), a security, regardless of any putative utility.</li><li>In foreign jurisdictions, Swiss Law appears to be setting the standard for distinguishing between three token types:</li><li><strong>Payment tokens</strong> are tokens used purely for transactional purposes and do not represent any rights by the holder against the issuer.</li><li><strong>Utility tokens</strong> must be deliverable at the time of sale and have a utility at the time of the token launch — not be a promise of future utility — in order to not be deemed securities despite their putative utility.</li><li><strong>Asset tokens</strong> represent an ownership interest or right in or against the issuer resulting in a potential for gain or loss and will as a result be prima facie deemed securities.</li><li>Both Payment and Utility tokens could be deemed to be securities regardless of their transactional nature or utility value if they are effectively deemed to represent a futures contract.</li><li>When planning a token offering for a:</li><li>Utility token: Make sure the utility granted by the token is available at the time the token is issued.</li><li>Realize that if you are selling the promise of a token (e.g. a SAFT) or of a future utility not active at the time the token is issued, it will be deemed a security regardless of the token’s putative utility.</li><li>If launching a token for an as-yet-to-be-developed network, consider raising an equity round to fund development of the platform prior to issuing the token.</li><li>Security token: Beware of more strenuous international regulation around compliance for securities, as well as the fact that there is at present no significant ICO or secondary market for security tokens given the lack of security token exchanges.</li></ol><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=60b5d09afbf1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>