<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Craig Gibson on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Craig Gibson on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@craiggibson_52135?source=rss-e0c91a418e15------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 23:15:06 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@craiggibson_52135/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[My Confession of Faith]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@craiggibson_52135/my-confession-of-faith-e79f7303b9a9?source=rss-e0c91a418e15------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e79f7303b9a9</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Craig Gibson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 29 Jun 2024 13:41:36 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-06-29T22:38:55.670Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Craig Gibson</em></p><p><em>June 29, 2024</em></p><p><em>From time to time, I take stock of my faith and, with shallow breath and trembling hands, tentatively attempt to summarize my beliefs to the best of my ability. The following statements should be viewed only as my current understanding achieved through my own wrestling with God and His Word, and not some final expression of “Truth”. I, with St. Paul, am the chief of sinners, but still God by His grace calls even me to “work out my salvation with fear and trembling” (Philippians 2:12).</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*UxPHybHV81qBDiNhJrsN4w@2x.jpeg" /></figure><p>I believe that:</p><ul><li>“God is the one coming as the future rushes upon us; he is life rather than release from life. His very identity is set by what he does in time.” (Robert Jenson, <em>A Large Catechism </em>(Delhi, NY: ALPB, 1991. p. 8)</li><li>“God, according to all the Scriptures, is above all the great Speaker; he is his own Word, and never relates to others by mere force, but always by personal address. That he creates something new means that he expands the field of his conversation…. That he creates, means that Father, Son and Spirit among themselves mention others than themselves: they speak together of … the great sea beasts, and so there are the great sea beasts for them to discuss. God converses the world into being.” (Robert Jenson, <em>A Large Catechism</em>, Delhi, NY: ALPB, 1991. pp. 21–22)</li><li>the Church rightly may call Mary <em>theotokos</em> — Mother of God and God-bearer — since she gave birth to Jesus, who is truly God made flesh, and she is indeed “full of grace” (Luke 1:30) because of her faith in God; however, this does not place her above the other people of God, who are also full of grace because of their own faith in God</li><li>humans are by nature “bent”, inverted in on themselves and focused on Self rather than on God and others. That is, our original sin originating</li><li>We are truly free only to the extent that we are turned towards God rather than towards ourselves. Freedom is always freedom “for another” and as such has one direction and one direction only. That is the direction of the Son, whose way is towards God and others.</li><li>“The eternal ‘pre-’ of Christ’s existence, which is identical with the ‘pre-’ of predestination, occurs also within time…. Thus — to put it in the most strenuous possible context — to the penitent’s question, ‘But how do I know I am among the elect?’ the confessor’s right answer must be, ‘You know because I am about to absolve you, and my doing that is God’s eternal act of decision about you’…. A right doctrine of individual predestination is precisely a doctrine about what happens to and for individuals when they encounter Christ in his gospel: that the judgment they then hear is nothing less than God’s eternal act of decision.” (Robert W. Jenson, <em>Systematic Theology, Vol. 2</em>, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1999. pp. 177–78)</li><li>Israel was God’s chosen people through whom the Chosen One, the Messiah, came into the world. Israel’s vocation from God was to be a light to the nations, and God truly dwelt with Israel in the Tabernacle and then in the Temple until the Babylonian Exile</li><li>Jesus of Nazareth is the Messiah and new Temple in whom the fullness of God dwells, and He perfectly fulfilled Israel’s vocation. God still has a purpose for Israel as His chosen people, but the Church is the Body of Christ and the Temple of God on earth until the Messiah’s Second Coming.</li><li>biblical faith is covenant, believing loyalty to the God of Genesis (Creation), Exodus (Liberation), and Jesus of Nazereth (New Creation)</li><li>salvation is eternal life in God (<em>theosis</em>) — including, freedom from slavery to Sin and Death, forgiveness of sins, regeneration into new life, restoration of body and soul, and communion with God — and can only be found in union with our Lord Jesus Christ</li><li>man can do no good works which will earn him salvation, but his works only earn him damnation because, apart from the grace of God, all naturally will live apart from God</li><li>union with Christ can only be realized and maintained by the grace of God through a living biblical faith renewed daily as we seek repentance and forgiveness and to live in accordance with our baptismal vows</li><li>a person is baptized with the Holy Spirit upon his or her confession of faith in Jesus Christ as Lord and belief in his or her heart that Christ is the Son of God (Romans 10:9)</li><li>the Holy Spirit, our Comforter, Counselor, and Advocator before God the Father, comes to dwell in the heart of every believer, whose body becomes a living temple of God</li><li>“The Spirit is the Power of the End, God as his own and our Fulfillment rushing upon us” (Robert Jenson, <em>A Large Catechism</em>, Delhi, NY: ALPB, 1991. p. 30). The Holy Spirit is God’s power of new creation that is the end (<em>teleos</em>) to which creation was made. The Spirit is this power rushing into this age.</li><li>the grace of God is to be understood relationally, realized through the immediacy of the Holy Spirit; therefore, grace cannot be understood to be a “created substance” that can be channeled or used to “irresistibly draw the elect”</li><li>faith is a child-like reliance upon God, yet also consists of right belief and works of love which flow from obedience to the Father and the power of the Holy Spirit</li><li>God knows all before anything comes to pass, ruling all things by His sovereign and perfect will, yet the Scriptures consistently call upon men and women to choose between Life and Death, Blessings and Cursings</li><li>the saints of God are elect because we are in Jesus Christ, the Elected One of God the Father</li><li>the saints of God are not to despair of our salvation, for we know that so long as we are in Christ Jesus, we are saved and that we shall persevere through the saving power of God</li><li>through Christ, men and women may at last aspire to God’s calling to live our purpose, fulfilling our humanity and the Law of Love</li><li>Jesus is the ultimate answer to Cain’s question to God in the Book of Genesis: “Am I my brother’s keeper?”</li><li>the saints of God cooperate with God in the work of His Kingdom while we live our days, working out what God works in — seeking to save the lost, proclaiming liberty to the captive, clothing and feeding the poor, caring for the widow and the orphan, and standing for justice and mercy</li><li>salvation must be viewed eschatologically: God offers salvation to all men and women and truly desires them to come to a saving knowledge of the Lord Jesus Christ, so it can be rightly said that the Son of God died for all men</li><li>there will come a day when the body of every man, woman, and child shall be resurrected, and the Lord Jesus Christ will physically return to earth to judge the living and the dead</li><li>the final event of our life with God will be our being taken fully into his own life (Robert W. Jenson, “For Us He was Made Man”)</li><li>Biblical justice is restorative. Biblical righteousness is relational. In the End, God will put all things right and “all sad things will become untrue” (J.R.R. Tolkien).</li><li>Jesus said “I will make all things new! NOT “I will make all new things.”</li><li>the “doors of Hell will be shut from the inside”, (<em>The Great Divorce</em>, C. S. Lewis) that is, those who chose to live outside of God in this life shall remain outside of God in the age to come, the just judgment of God respecting the lived choice of the individual</li><li>it is good and right to pray for justice, but it is also good and right to pray that God will in the End realize His desire that all people would be saved (1 Timothy 2:4)</li><li>the Spirit blows where He wills, yet God works primarily through the Church, the whole people of God across space and time as the Body of Christ, equipped with the gifts of God, the power of the Holy Spirit, and the commandment to spread the Gospel of Christ to the ends of the earth</li><li>To be human is to be in relation; to be a sinner is to pursue relationlessness. The Church, therefore, should be viewed as the body of people who are “called out” — “out of the world, yes, but also out of ourselves”! To be included in the church is to be among those “who live <em>excurvatus ex se</em>, finding … ourselves in Christ and in one another”.</li><li>the Church truly possesses the keys to the Kingdom of God, so whatever it binds on Earth shall be bound in Heaven and whatever it looses on Earth shall be loosed in Heaven (Matthew 16:19)</li><li>the keys to the Kingdom are exercised as the Gospel of Christ is spread and when the people of God are the salt of the earth and the light of the world, leading us to declare, the Good News announcing that God’s Kingdom is here comes through the Church</li><li>the Church can be found where the people of God gather to preach the Word of God and rightly administer the Sacraments of God</li><li>the gathering of the local body of believers is the fullest and most immediate expression of the catholicity of the Church, yet the local church does not demarcate the boundary of God’s Church, as the local churches of God may gather and organize into synods, dioceses, conventions, and councils, as they may think necessary and proper</li><li>Jesus Christ is the head of each local church and all churches are united in the Holy Spirit</li><li>the grace of God is not confined to this ordinance or that, but God’s grace is ubiquitous so that we might rightly speak of sacramental living without descending into sacerdotal belief</li><li>through our sacramental living, the children of God may rightly speak of a sacramental theology that is centered around commitment to Jesus Christ and the mystery of life in God</li><li>performing the sacramental mystery can give grace to ground us in the living of the mystery so long as the performing does not replace the living</li><li>“heaven has “gates,” that is, stipulable places in creation that specifically locate that boundary from which the Lord moves toward us. No doubt the firmament, through a door into which the seer John looked, was one such gate. But Bethel, geographically marked by Jacob’s stone, was a gate of heaven, and then the temple was the gate of heaven. For Christians, the gate is the body of Christ, that is, the church is the gate for the world, and the Eucharist is the gate for the church.” (Robert W. Jenson, “For Us He was Made Man”)</li><li>“‘Sanctification’ … is often misunderstood as a progress, kicked off, as it were, by baptism. This has obviously to be false. Baptism initiates into the life which God’s three persons, Father, Son and Spirit, live among themselves; what would we progress to from that? Rather, sanctification is the continual return to baptism…. Baptism is always there as a fact in my past; I can always, as Luther said, ‘creep’ back to it and begin anew” (Robert Jenson, <em>A Large Catechism</em>, Delhi, NY: ALPB, 1991. p. 50)</li><li>baptism into the Triune God is the doorway into the life of God and the Church, signifying our death and resurrection with Christ and ordaining us into the priesthood of all believers</li><li>baptism is no “mere symbol” but truly does what it says, committing the life of the one who is baptized to Christ as Lord, bringing the life of the Spirit into the baptized, committing the Church to the life of the baptized, and demarcating the adoption by God of the baptized as His child</li><li>“baptism for us, not for God, constitutes the end of all judgment about our place in the Body of Christ” (David Guthrie)</li><li>baptism by immersion most fully captures the meaning of what transpires during baptism without invalidating other modes of baptism commonly practiced in the orthodox Christian tradition</li><li>traditions which baptize infants focus on the grace of God available for all of humanity and the inclusion of the children of believers in the New Covenant of our Lord</li><li>baptism is most rightly practiced on believers who have publicly professed faith in Jesus Christ as Lord, and infant baptism artificially separates baptism from personal profession of faith</li><li>baptism affects our regeneration as we look back upon that objective act in our day-to-day struggles to conform to the Christ, daily recalling our baptismal vows to die to sin and to rise to new life in the power of the Holy Spirit</li><li>not all who are saved will be baptized, but when we come to Christ we are commanded to follow Him in baptism, publicly professing Him as Lord and committing to follow Him in a brand new kind of life</li><li>communion is the gathering of a local body of believers to share the bread and the fruit of the vine in remembrance of what Christ did for us</li><li>“The eucharistic event, as a movement from absence to presence, is as such a movement from chaos to order, darkness to light, death to life. It is an inventive, ordering event on the same plane as the act of creation, though its actual results are largely withheld from our view.” (Douglas Farrow, <em>Ascension and Ecclesia: On the Significance of the Doctrine of the Ascension for Ecclesiology and Christian Cosmology</em>, Edinburgh: T&amp;T Clark, 1999. p. 5.)</li><li>the Lord Jesus Christ is truly present among His believers during communion and His grace is truly received by those who eat and drink in faith and love</li><li>the memory resurrected by participation in communion is what ties us to the events of the past so that we might have hope for what God will do in the future</li><li>the Church of God cannot be artificially divided, but the priesthood of all believers is the guiding principle of life in the Church</li><li>it is good and right for those who hear the call of God to become ministers of the Gospel to dedicate their lives to full-time ministry in service of God and His people</li><li>each person is individually competent to stand before God, to pray, to confess sins, to make supplication, to give thanksgiving and praise, and to walk with Christ in all that they do</li><li>the veneration of icons is not a violation of the Second Commandment so long as it is not the image that is worshipped</li><li>God should be worshipped in truth and in spirit (John 4:24), in reverence and thanksgiving, and should include singing, prayer, administration of the Sacraments, and the preaching of the Word of God</li><li>the worship of God should be done in an orderly manner and the liturgy of the Church is an excellent means to accomplish this end, so long as the Church remembers that the liturgy was made for man, not man for the liturgy</li><li>men and women are both equal in Christ and nothing prevents women from fully participating in the life of the Church</li><li>the man is head of the household and will be held accountable by God for the spiritual formation and development of his wife and family</li><li>the Bible is the story of God’s work to restore humanity and Creation and is wholly inspired by God, pointing humanity to His Son, Jesus Christ</li><li><em>sola scriptura</em> is a right doctrine which frees the Church of God from the tyranny of the Magesterium, but the Scriptures belong to the Church and can only be rightly interpreted by the Church through the illumination of the Holy Spirit and within the framework of the apostolic faith (<em>regula fidei</em>) as has been handed down by our fathers</li><li>it is good and profitable for churches to express their beliefs and doctrines in confessions of faith so long as the confession that Jesus is Lord is the only one used to bind the conscience of believers</li><li>the Apostles Creed and Nicene Creed are the most universal expressions of the apostolic faith (<em>regula</em> <em>fidei</em>) that define the boundaries of the orthodox Christian faith</li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e79f7303b9a9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Thoughts on Evolution]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@craiggibson_52135/thoughts-on-evolution-c15c96a82968?source=rss-e0c91a418e15------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c15c96a82968</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[scientific-theories]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[évolution]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Craig Gibson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 28 Apr 2024 15:10:22 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-04-28T15:52:02.776Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Craig Gibson</em></p><p>I’ve received a handful of requests to recap my current thoughts or opinions on the subject of evolution.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*_yHNzWnoJHQnIkL1dY1RZw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Charles Darwin’s 1837 sketch, his first diagram of an evolutionary tree from his First Notebook on Transmutation of Species (1837). Image from Wikimedia Commons.</figcaption></figure><p>I am not a scientist, but I have been educated in the sciences, so I understand the basics. Is this enough to entitle me to an opinion on the topic of evolution? Some will obviously say no, but I will leave the question for the reader to discern and decide. Either way, the opinions are mine and impact no one but me. But as they say, opinions are like noses — everybody has one.</p><p>Broadly speaking, there are, perhaps, two sides of science. The first is the scientific method: a hypothesis is formed on the basis of observations in the natural world or lab, tests are run and the results analyzed, the hypothesis is confirmed, modified or rejected accordingly. The second is scientific theory: a systematic explanation of some aspect of the natural world, with which predictions about that aspect of the world can be made and tested.</p><p>In response to a Tucker Carlson quote, I flippantly posted a claim on Twitter that there is a lot of evidence for microevolution but no evidence for macroevolution. In that post, there were for me two more fundamental and serious concerns at play:</p><ol><li>Though it’s part of the theory of evolution, microevolution is not just a scientific theory. Variations within species, adaptations driven by environment and circumstance, natural selection, inheritance have all been observed and are not debated, to my knowledge. This is evidence. Fact.</li><li>Though it’s part of the theory of evolution, macroevolution is more metaphysical than biological (or even geological). The “tree of life” that biologists have reconstructed from the fossil record and genetic markers (in DNA) is not based on direct observation (one biological family of animals turning into another — a mouse to a moose or a horse to a human) but on inference and assumptions. Even more challenging, there is absolutely no evidence that life “sprung” (evolved?) from non-life or that more complex, multi-celled systems can evolve from single-celled organisms. (Perhaps we will discover such evidence one day.)</li></ol><p>When I was challenged regarding my claim that there is no evidence of macroevolution (“There are mountains of evidence!” “Read a book!!”), the few helpful responses I received posted scientific papers. The following is one of them that I am choosing to interact with it because of its accessible writing and clarity on the subject. I believe I kept an open mind as I read through the paper three times over 4 days. The following is my response / interaction with the paper (all direct quotes are from the paper itself).</p><p><a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6428117/#:~:text=These%20successions%20in%20the%20fossil,in%20the%20past%20billion%20years">https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6428117/#:~:text=These%20successions%20in%20the%20fossil,in%20the%20past%20billion%20years</a></p><p>This is a good article, and some might be shocked to find that I agree with a majority of it! The paper’s explanation of the scientific method and scientific theory is clear and straightforward. The definitions of the terms microevolution and macroevolution were helpful.</p><p>The paper’s explanation of microevolution: “Genetic modifications are encountered in the resistant strains; thus, evolution is a fact (Gould, 1981). Mutation, migration, natural selection, and genetic drift are the evolutionary forces that drive genetic changes of natural populations from one generation to the next. This is known among biologists as microevolution.”</p><p>The paper’s explanation of macroevolution: “One pivotal example is the succession in the fossil record. This evolution, namely, macroevolution, explains the larger evolutionary picture that is the appearance of the greater groups, such as the evolution of mammals, insects, and plants.”</p><p>The article also clearly spelled out the processes that drive evolution. “Many of the same evolutionary processes that drive microevolution also drive macroevolution, namely natural selection, mutation, migration, and genetic drift. A lineage will tend to diversify if it has adaptations that increase survival and reproductive abilities compared to other species. This advantage will tend to increase population size and the geographical distribution of the ancestral species that will more likely speciate into two descendant species. Hence, according to this view, macroevolution is microevolution on a larger scale (Zimmer, 2001), with biological speciation as the only additional process (Russo <em>et al.</em>, 2016).”</p><p>I had considered speciation within the microevolutionary rubric — one species of bird becomes another; or wolves are domesticated and bred into dogs. Same biological family, but different species. But speciation within the macroevolution scale? That implies that we have evidence that speciation over time drives change at the biological family level and higher, but the article does not lay out any such direct evidence.</p><p>The article concedes as much: “The fact that we observe biological species with interbreeding members and reproductive isolation between species is compatible with both separate creation and macroevolution.” However, the article goes on to claim that what we see in the fossil record and genetic similarities among “reproductively isolated species” are what we would see if “many speciation events generated the vast biological diversity from a single common ancestor”. But why would we would not expect to see the same under separate creation as well?</p><p>The best the article can assert is that a series of microevolutionary changes over millions of years by definition leads to macroevolution. But this is my entire point — the claim by macroevolutionary theory that all of life on earth came from a single common ancestor is a leap of logic, an assumption, an a priori claim. Other explanations are possible for what we see in genetics and in the fossil record, but at this point, we would enter into the realm of the metaphysical, philosophical or conjectural.</p><p>The article also seems to hand wave an explanation for the Cambrian Explosion, the explosion of life we see in the fossil record at the onset of the Cambrian Era. “Other fossil record patterns are well explained by macroevolution. For instance, why do we find a major increase in mammalian fossil diversity only after the disappearance of non-avian dinosaurs approximately 65 million years ago? The same pattern is observed in the fossil record of birds. Macroevolution explains this well, as the extinction of dinosaurs eliminated competition, and the surviving ancestral mammals were able to increase in number and diversified through speciation, generating more species of their kind.”</p><p>Ok, but I go back to one of my original questions about macroevolutionary theory — has it actually been proven through direct evidence (testing or observation) that one biological family can evolve into another?</p><p>Is macroevolution a possible explanation of what we see around us? Certainly! Has it been definitively proven? Nope. We have a set of educated guesses, inferences, and disconnected data around which a story has been constructed. It’s not (and pardon the pun) grounded in direct evidence the same way as the theory of gravity or the theory of relativity are. And that is OK! It’s the best explanation that <em>science</em> has. Just don’t tell me it has been definitively proven with direct evidence or that it must logically follow from the direct evidence we do have at the microevolutionary scale.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c15c96a82968" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Theory of Constitutional Interpretation: The Governance Imperative]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@craiggibson_52135/a-theory-of-constitutional-interpretation-the-governance-imperative-6f4687a0c9ec?source=rss-e0c91a418e15------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6f4687a0c9ec</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[abortion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[judicial-review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[political-theory]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[us-constitution]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fourteenth-amendment]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Craig Gibson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 22 May 2023 16:42:36 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-05-23T06:18:51.395Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>by Craig Gibson &amp; Kelly French<br>May 2008</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*f0O-7HAzfEK-Go-tqEAMPg.png" /><figcaption>What is justice?</figcaption></figure><p>Few issues have divided Americans like abortion. The questions of whether society should allow abortions and under which circumstances haunt even people who seem convinced of their position. Norma McCorvey, represented as “Roe” in the infamous case <em>Roe v. Wade</em>, has become an out-spoken advocate of the pro-life position in the years since the Supreme Court’s decision which ruled state laws banning abortions to be unconstitutional. Justice Blackmun, the author of the <em>Roe v. Wade</em> decision, struggled with the Court’s appropriate response to the case and acknowledged the emotional sensitivity in the published opinion. That people of good conscience change their positions regarding abortion or put forward opinions filled with emotional uncertainty and angst should be evidence that there is something deeper at work than simple “Absolute Truth” or “Unerring Right.” Rather than leading us to prophecy the downfall of a society that would “kill innocent children” by allowing abortion or lamenting the oppressive manner of a state which would forever force victimized women to birth unwanted babies, the doubt engendered within us and among us by the questions of abortion should serve as evidence of our humanity and serve notice that hubris is not something that only inflicts those with whom we disagree.</p><p><strong>Principles in Conflict</strong></p><p>Abortion is a difficult issue for the very reason that there is no easy answer. There are real reasons why a woman would want the option of having an abortion: her health might be at risk if she carries the baby to term or gives birth to the baby; perhaps she is the victim of rape or incest; maybe she does not have the financial, emotional or psychological means of enduring a pregnancy or raising a baby. Who should get to choose if a woman in any of these situations gets to have an abortion? Is it the woman because she has to live with the decision? Will the baby’s father have any say in the decision if he is willing to live with the decision? Should the State have any say in the decision so that the baby will have a chance to live with the decision?</p><p>These questions bring into focus the conflicting interests and rights which are involved in the debate our society is having over abortion. On the one hand, society has an interest in protecting the lives of all its citizens, especially the weakest among us, the unborn. On the other hand, pregnant women have health and privacy concerns which must be respected — and protected — by society. Deciding, as a society, where to draw the line becomes the challenge. Where should the Law be in respect to these two competing interests? A manifestation of our hubris is that we expect answers to every question we ask even if that which we ask is unknowable. If we are interested in being right, we want to have answers to our questions written in stone. If we want to be fair, we have to keep asking the questions and be prepared for the answers to change.</p><p>And it is typically because we are more interested in being right than we are in being fair that we enter into such an emotionally-charged atmosphere when it comes to the abortion debate. It is the premise of this paper that abortion is so heated and divisive because we have forgotten the First Principles upon which our Constitution was founded: the Constitution and courts decide what is fair, which we shall propose covers issues of governance; the Legislature (acting for the People) decides what is right, which we shall propose covers issues of morality.</p><p>When the Framers were writing the Constitution, they were not interested in a document which would dictate the moral fabric of the new American nation. There is a need in man to know truth absolutely, to have a certainty to life and living. Throughout our history, humans have sought to understand and apply the fundamental truths which govern his world (the transcendent), but he is by nature limited in his ability to understand and apply these fundamental truths because of his limited senses and experience (the immanent). Man can only know as far as his physical world can confirm. So as long as we recognize the fact that there is a world wider and deeper than man’s experience, we have to accept the fact that there is some portion of fundamental (or absolute) truth that is unknowable. We can know certain truths that are timeless given who we are in the world, but we can’t absolutely know all that is beyond us.</p><p>Yet humanity has struggled in accepting this limitation and constantly tries to establish society in a manner which balances and integrates both the transcendent and immanent realms. But rather than finding balance and integration, man has swung from one extreme to the other. The brilliance of the Constitution is that it shines a guiding beacon to lead mankind past the rocky shoals of its own hubris and towards calmer waters where they might find a system that is self-regulating in governing man’s inclination to these two extremes. We can find the key to this self-regulation in the downfall of the ancient and medieval civilizations. The Greeks and, by extension, the Romans, tried to control the divine by trying to control Reason, while Medieval Europe tried to control the human by trying to speak for God through the Church. First, control by the State, and then control by the Church. But where was the human in all of this? If the Greeks and the Romans tried to rule what was right by what was reasonable and fair (as defined by the State), then the Medievals tried to rule what was reasonable and fair by what was right (as defined by the Church). In both instances, the questions of morality (what is right?) and judgment (what is fair?) were collapsed into one another.</p><p>The truth of the matter is that when it comes to matters of moral principles, there are more different interpretations of those principles than there are people alive. Just ask Martin Luther. He didn’t nail his 95 Theses to the door of the Wittenburg Church without feeling that strongly. Conversely Luther was excommunicated because the Catholic Church felt just as strongly in its position. But it was the same principles on which they disagreed. All involved were learned and intelligent: Luther deeply believed the Church needed reform, and the Church’s position was not capricious. Neither side can be demonized, which we have a tendency to do.</p><p>So the question becomes, “How do we resolve the dilemma when good people disagree?” Might we embody rules that govern behavior between people who disagree? Without resolving the question of who gets to pick the rules the question becomes upon what should those rules be based. The hitch is that if you ask the Catholic Church the same question, the rules are to be based on canon. If you ask Luther, the rules are to be based on scripture alone. There is disagreement as to where ultimate authority lies — in other words, the governing imperative. By separating the moral from the governing imperative, you can establish a framework that doesn’t raise the problems that Luther ran into with the Church. The moral authority is no longer bound to the governing imperative.</p><p>It would seem, then, that a government which could separate these two functions (deciding what is right and deciding what is fair) might have a chance to create a society which could avoid the transcendent and immanent extremes of the past. It is our contention that this is what the Fathers of the new American nation — following Enlightenment principles and political philosphy — accomplished in establishing an independent judiciary charged with interpreting the Constitution. Viewing the Constitution as a contract among the people of our society, the Framers ensconced into it — not in an individual or even a group of individuals — the responsibility of setting where each question will be decided. In other words, decisions of fairness were written into the Constitution itself. While you can legislate anything you want based on the moral values of the People, the Framers established a system of checks and balances in a document to be sure one group could not run roughshod over another.</p><p><strong>The Will of the Governed (or The Government We Deserve)</strong></p><p>The Framers wrote the Constitution to set up a structure in which the American people could decide issues of morality while respecting the rights of the individual. We know from other societies what happens without a sound constitutional framework: dictatorship or war.</p><p>The outrage expressed by the different parties over “activist judges” usually involves a case where a judge declared something unconstitutional. While that’s not new, there is a set of decisions that have something in common to cause the outrage. What seems to cause the most outcry are issues decided by the courts that seek to resolve debates over public morality. The Constitution simply is not concerned with weighing in on moral questions, and any judicial excursion into questions of rightness is inappropriate. Same-sex marriage, access to pornography, and abortion are morality debates which the courts have recently inserted themselves. Civil rights is one that is a close equivalent, except there is a constitutional basis in the 14th and 15th Amendments (passed after the Civil War to outlaw slavery and guarantee equal protection to Black Americans) upon which the courts could base their rulings.</p><p>Let us map out the different states of a possible issue and the type of legislation represented by each state:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*w3YjSJBzEUWFoTJG_zlC8g.png" /><figcaption>types of issues truth table</figcaption></figure><p>In this, we find a theory of governance.</p><p>We can follow the history of the “separate but equal” doctrine to see how understandings and perceptions of society can change regarding an issue, and how society’s changing attitudes can impact a Supreme Court operating within the bounds of constitutional jurisprudence. The 14th and 15th Amendments were passed in the immediate aftermath of the Civil War, in the midst of Reconstruction. Many southern states approved the two amendments as conditions for readmission into the Union, so there were large swaths of society that were not ready to treat their fellow Black Americans as equals. Consequently, many state legislatures in the South passed the infamous Jim Crow laws. Congress felt the Jim Crow laws were not right (Stage 2 laws) and passed the Civil Rights Act of 1875, but the Supreme Court invalidated much of this Act, claiming that the 14th Amendment didn’t protect against discrimination perpetrated by private entities. After Reconstruction and the return of southern representatives and senators to Congress, congressional interest turned to other matters. When the constitutionality of the southern states’ Jim Crow laws was challenged before the Supreme Court in the mid 1890’s, the Court issued its famous <em>Plessy</em> decision, upholding the state laws as constitutional.</p><p>We believe the Court acted erroneously in <em>Plessy</em> because the Constitution had been amended, in the form of the 14th and 15th Amendments, to define as unfair any form of racial discrimination. The legislatures of the country should not have been able to define segregation as morally sound because the Constitution had removed it from the competence of the moral arena and turned racial equality into a question of fair application of power. Nevertheless, the Court did rule the way it did, so it becomes an interesting study in the progression of an issue from Stage 1 to Stage 4.</p><p>When laws are passed at the state or federal level, courts do not give their assent or approval. So unless a specific case is brought before a court challenging the constitutionality of a law, the law is considered to be valid legislation. The legislative branch has deemed an issue, segregation in this case, to be right, or moral. However, when people who feel wronged by the law, they have the right to bring suit before the state or federal courts to challenge the fairness (i.e., constitutionality) of the law and seek relief from the law. This was the case with the Jim Crow laws of the South, and the issue worked its way through the court system, culminating in the Supreme Court’s <em>Plessy</em> decision of 1896. The Court validated the South’s Jim Crow laws as a fair application of state power, leaving the matter as a Stage 1 issue. There was an alignment of opinion regarding segregation among the state legislatures, the Supreme Court, and the people (as represented then by the super-majority white population). And the fact that the Court was a party to this alignment is the problem; the Court ruled in <em>Plessy</em> to settle a question of morality, rather than to deal with what the Constitution actually said.</p><p>Nevertheless, the opinion of much of society changed over the first fifty years of the twentieth century. Experiences in World War I, the Great Depression, World War II, and the Cold War worked on the nation’s psyche, exposing a fundamental hypocrisy between the words of the Declaration of Independence (“all men are created equal”) and the way in which Black Americans were treated. Enough of the population had changed their views of equality by the 1950’s that a significant majority of America saw segregation as morally wrong and unfair. While many whites in the South viewed segregation as the natural order of the world, most of America as a whole agitated for change, and a critical mass had been achieved. Society had reached the point to where it viewed segregation as a Stage 4 issue. The Supreme Court acted in 1954 (in <em>Brown v Board of Education of Topeka</em>) to declare segregation as unconstitutional, but it was too late.</p><p>For a Stage 4 issue, the people demand action. Generally, Congress and the courts are release valves for issues that are in Stage 4, and if one of them acts, the demands of the people will be satisfied and stability is restored. However, if both branches ignore the issue long enough, it will only be a matter of time before something will trigger a reaction among the populace to affect change. For slavery, it was the Civil War; for segregation, it was the Civil Rights Movement.</p><p>The Founders understood the governance imperative enough to know that these situations can and would occur and that mechanisms are needed to resolve the tension between the people and the state — the ying and yang of the governance imperative. While the system of checks and balances is normally associated with the balance of power between branches, the genius of the Founders was that they also instituted mechanisms to help keep the balance between the people and the state. The forces that build up between the people and the state are considered in the structure that the Constitution lays out. Checks and balances treat the system but not the disease, which is the tension between the government and the people. This tension will always be there, but the goal is to balance it out. It’s in the nature of man and the nature of governing. To understand the governance imperative is to understand the relationship between the governed and those who govern.</p><p><strong>Tipping the Scales</strong></p><p>The modern-day imbalance began with the 1965 Supreme Court ruling in <em>Griswold v Connecticut</em> that set forth the sanctity of marriage and ruled state bans on birth control as unconstitutional because of a right to privacy within a marriage. The courts have increasingly inserted themselves into the role of deciding questions of morality, of seeking to answer for society the constant question: What is right? With its 1972 ruling in <em>Roe v Wade</em> that struck down state bans on abortion, the Court structurally changed where the debate over abortion could happen, tossing it out of the legislative frying pan into the Constitutional fire. Up to that point, state legislatures were engaged in the debate over the morality of allowing abortions and under which circumstances they were appropriate. In <em>Roe v Wade</em> the Supreme Court upset the balance between the moral imperative, the realm of the People, and the governing imperative, the realm of the structure of government itself. The Supreme Court acted before the abortion issue was ripe, a majority of the justices feeling that the issue was in Stage 4 long enough among enough people that the time had come to act to release the public pressure. The Court issued a sweeping ruling to resolve the moral question of abortion for the entire nation, making law and creating constitutional rights out of whole cloth.</p><p>Once you separate the legislative, executive, and judicial branches of government, you make some people unhappy because they do not get to dictate and/or enforce what is right for the rest of society. Through the ratification and continued support for our Constitution, Americans have decided that we would rather have a State that values fairness over rightness. We are primarily concerned with robust processes and institutions to guide us in our debates and disagreements, even if our processes and institutions are slow or inefficient. That is, we engage in politics to resolve our differences.</p><p>Although we have grown to distrust politics in our day and time, the debates and compromises to which our politics lead us are exactly what it means to value fairness over rightness. We are betting that if everyone is treated equally and has a voice, then the right will be the natural, unavoidable result, even if it takes longer than some would like to realize it. This is about valuing the stuff of humanity — doubting and questioning and listening — over simple theories of “absolute knowledge” which have failed humanity time and again. In attempting to describe a system of government we must always remember that humans are fallible, but our nature provides a richness without which our existence would be empty and mechanical. To be human is to laugh with them and cry with them; to take the depths of irrationality along with the triumphs of thought and will. No certainties can relieve us of our responsibility to engage in this fully human quest. Even if we don’t find the complete answer to absolute truth and apply it to our society in a perfect manner, there is value in encouraging the magic of politics, which works to bring all interested parties together to talk and compromise and, through our legislatures, forge a solution with which the whole of society can live.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6f4687a0c9ec" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Can We Trust a God that Calls for Death and Destruction?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@craiggibson_52135/can-we-trust-a-god-that-calls-for-death-and-destruction-32d62836dd45?source=rss-e0c91a418e15------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/32d62836dd45</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[biblical-justice]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[joshua]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[greg-boyd]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jesus]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bible]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Craig Gibson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 24 Feb 2023 17:53:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-12-29T13:56:31.627Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Craig Gibson &amp; Amber Robidou</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*iAv4AZ0EZZAiCOTkhYQmnw.png" /><figcaption>Joshua commands the Sun to stand still. Drawing by Gustave Dore, published in an 1885 Bible. (Image credit: Public domain)</figcaption></figure><p><strong><em>Author’s Note: </em></strong><em>Divine violence in the Bible is a topic with which believers rightly wrestle. The ideas and conclusions offered here are tentative based on our own wrestling, prayers, and study of the biblical text, but we limit our observations to the treatment of the Canaanites as depicted in the book of Joshua. For a more comprehensive treatment of this topic, see Dr. Dan Hawk’s book “Violence of the Biblical God: Canonical Narrative and Christian Faith”.</em></p><p>Many people want to use God’s commands for violence in the Old Testament as proof that the God of the Bible is a monster, and because of this, the Bible can easily be set aside as nothing more than hypocritical superstition or as cruel justification for “religious wars”.</p><p>Many other people who are believers honestly struggle with God’s commands for violence and are not sure what to do with them in light of the Cross. The common approach is to just ignore these parts of the Word of God or relegate them to spiritual lessons for individual believers or the Church.</p><p>What do we do with this tension? How can we trust<em> that</em> story?</p><p>These are important questions. However, a more pertinent question would be one that moves us out of how we feel and into exploration of what the Bible is trying to teach us. <em>What does the Bible do with this tension?</em></p><p>In this paper, we explore God’s commands in Deuteronomy and Joshua to take possession of the Promised Land as an example of God commanding violence. Going on faith that the Word of God says what it means, we also look at what more might be at play here than the simple characterization that God is commanding violence.</p><p>Among 21st century Western evangelical circles, there is a growing tendency to want to (what I call) “manage the Text.” Something in the Bible — such as in Deuteronomy 7:2 when God commands Moses to “utterly destroy” (NKJV) the Canaanite peoples when they move into the Promised Land — makes us all feel sick to the stomach. The God who preached peace and non-violence in the person of Jesus is commanding genocide in the Old Testament?</p><p>Leading theologians who are Bible-professing Christians have proposed that we can assume Moses misunderstood God’s commands to “utterly destroy”. They argue that the God who took all violence upon Himself on the Cross would not command violence among His creatures. In his book, <em>The Crucifixion of the Warrior God,</em> Greg Boyd writes: “[A]ccording to the biblical narrative, Moses was the only one who received the [“utterly destroy”] command directly from Yahweh.” [p. 924, Vol 2] Boyd continues –</p><blockquote>To embrace this [conquest] narrative as a straightforward account of what God told Moses he wanted his people to do is to grant that people are sometimes justified engaging in genocide simply because a trusted authority claims God told them that this was his will. Even apart from other considerations, the disastrous consequences this precedent has had throughout history arguably provides sufficient reason to reject it. I contend that obedience to Christ, to say nothing of the basic moral intuition of morally healthy people, should lead us to the conviction that we should never, under any circumstances, consider ourselves justified obeying someone’s command to exterminate entire populations because this person claims God told them we were supposed to do so.</blockquote><blockquote>… I would argue that Moses’s claim that Yahweh told him to command the Israelites to mercilessly annihilate entire people-groups is antithetical to the message of the cross, which, we must remember, includes Jesus and Paul’s commands to love enemies and to refrain from all violence (Matt 5:44–45; Rom 12:14–21). And in this light, I do not see how we can avoid the conclusion that the “show no mercy” command that Moses allegedly received from Yahweh was not, in fact, a bona fide command from Yahweh. If anything, one could argue on the authority of the apostle Paul that we should rather place it “under God’s curse.”</blockquote><blockquote>Even more importantly, it is only when we consider this aspect of the conquest narrative to be “cursed” that we can begin to see how it bears witness to the crucified Christ. For only when we stop trying to defend this narrative and instead resolve to read this narrative with the “magic eye” of a cross-informed faith that we can begin to discern “what else is going on” in this narrative. Stated otherwise, so long as we believe that God might actually be capable of commanding genocide, thereby indicating that we do not fully trust the revelation of God on the cross, we will not be able to see how the genocidal portrait of God bears witness to the cross. [pp. 925–926, Vol 2]</blockquote><p>In his book, Boyd builds a case for what he calls a “Cruciform Hermeneutic”, arguing that commands by God to “utterly destroy” the Canaanites have to be interpreted in light of what Jesus does on the Cross when He accommodates the fallen state of humanity by taking on the curse we had under the judgment of God.</p><blockquote>“[O]n the cross, God stooped to accommodate our fallen state by bearing our sin and our curse, thereby taking on an appearance that reflects the ugliness of our sin and our curse…. Since the cross reveals what God is truly like, and thus what God was like when he “breathed” the written witness to his covenantal faithfulness, I submit that we should read this witness expecting to find God sometimes stooping to bear the sin and curse of his people and to therefore assume a literary appearance that reflects the ugliness of his people’s sin and curse. (Boyd, p. 634, vol 2)</blockquote><p>God only <em>appears</em> to be engaged in violence in the Old Testament because violence is all we see.</p><p>Few orthodox Christians would argue with the need to interpret all of Scripture through Christ’s saving work on the Cross, but can we really follow Boyd to the logical endpoints that he advocates and still honor the integrity of the whole of the Bible as the inspired Word of God? The unveiling of God’s revelation over time adds to the commands and concepts and images that God communicates throughout the Old Testament. Our understanding of God unfolds through relationship over time. The Cross adds depths and dimensionality and divine context to what has gone before. Given that, it would seem that viewing some parts of the Old Testament as fundamentally untrue, as Boyd seems to propose, undermines the very ground upon which the Cross is erected.</p><p>In the Book of Joshua itself, this idea to “utterly destroy” shows up 14 times in conjunction with Israel’s campaigns in the land of Canaan! Are we obligated to place the entire Book of Joshua “under God’s curse”? If so, this approach uses Scripture to place Scripture “under God’s curse.” Does this not seem ironically twisted?</p><p>Add to this question the fact that Joshua <strong><em>must</em></strong> have been on Mt. Sinai with Moses. He goes up the Mountain with Moses in Exodus 24:9–11. And Joshua was with Moses when he was coming down the Mountain with the Tablets in Exodus 32:16–18. Joshua was Moses’ right hand man. Is it reasonable to assume that Joshua would not have been witness to God’s commands to Moses for the conquest of Canaan, especially given that Joshua would be appointed to lead Israel in that very conquest?</p><p>This is just one line of weird questioning that can open up when we try to “manage the Text.” Like a slippery eel, we find the Text won’t quite allow itself to be managed and the resulting problems leave us with questions more strange than the ones we started with.</p><p>Rather than trying to “manage the Text”, let us look at God’s command to “utterly destroy” and allow the Text to speak for itself.</p><p><strong><em>What did “utterly destroy…” actually mean to the ancients?</em></strong></p><p>Let’s look again at Deuteronomy 7:2, but this time let’s use the English Standard Version. As Moses is preparing the people of Israel for entry into the Promised Land, he gives them God’s instructions for how to deal with the Canaanites in the first five verses of Deuteronomy 7:</p><blockquote>“When the LORD your God brings you into the land that you are entering to take possession of it, and clears away many nations before you, the Hittites, the Girgashites, the Amorites, the Canaanites, the Perizzites, the Hivites, and the Jebusites, seven nations more numerous and mightier than you, and when the LORD your God gives them over to you, and you defeat them, <strong>then you must devote them to complete destruction</strong>. You shall make no covenant with them and show no mercy to them. You shall not intermarry with them, giving your daughters to their sons or taking their daughters for your sons, for they would turn away your sons from following me, to serve other gods. Then the anger of the LORD would be kindled against you, and he would destroy you quickly. But thus shall you deal with them: you shall break down their altars and dash in pieces their pillars and chop down their Asherim and burn their carved images with fire.</blockquote><p>“you must devote them to complete destruction.” This rendering of verse 2 given by the ESV might seem more obtuse than the “utterly destroy” translation provided by the NKJV. To shed light on what is going on here, we need to look at the original Hebrew. From the Interlinear Bible:</p><blockquote>חָרַם ḥâram; a primitive root; to seclude; specifically (by a ban) to devote to religious uses (especially destruction); physical and reflexive, to be blunt as to the nose: — make accursed, consecrate, (utterly) destroy, devote, forfeit, have a flat nose, utterly (slay, make away).</blockquote><p>There is undoubtedly an aspect of destruction in ḥâram (I will transliterate as he<em>rem),</em> but notice there is also a strangely adjacent idea at play here — consecration. Consecration is to “make or declare something sacred” (Ox<em>ford Dictionary).</em> This correlates to the biblical idea of holiness, to be set apart for God. The Hebrew word for this is qa<em>dash —</em> “Be holy for I am holy” (Leviticus 19:2). And while consecration is not the exact opposite of destruction, “to make accursed” is (to desecrate, to blemish), and that is also part of the definition of he<em>rem. </em>It’s like there is in this one Hebrew word an action (devotion to God / set aside for God) and a choice of outcome (consecrated / spotless OR accursed / blemished).</p><p>Most English Bible translations understandably assume the “destruction” outcome because of the war context of the Book of Joshua, but the truth is this same word is used throughout Joshua in the context of conquerings of the land AND consecrations on the altar. There seems to be a connection to the idea of holiness, either positive or negative — a devotion to separation from God OR devoted only to God, and this devotion seems to be irreversible and permanent. <em>Herem</em> that results in being fully devoted to God’s desires or <em>herem</em> that results in being fully devoted to our own desires.</p><p>As Moses continues his last sermons to the Israelites “in the plains of Moab by the Jordan at Jericho” (Numbers 36:13), he reiterates <strong>WHY</strong> God is so concerned about Israel consecrating the land and people as they enter in and settle Canaan. Deuteronomy 12:2–4:</p><blockquote>You shall tear down all the places where the nations whom you shall dispossess served their gods, on the high mountains and on the hills and under every green tree. You shall tear down their altars and dash in pieces their pillars and burn their Asherim with fire. You shall chop down the carved images of their gods and destroy their name out of that place. You shall not worship the LORD your God in that way.</blockquote><p>Remember that Israel came out of 400 years of slavery in Egypt and has just experienced 40 years of desert wanderings, with God teaching them who He is and testing them so that they might know (Hebrew <em>yada, </em>which means “to experience”) Him. God was teaching them how to be His people. There was a very real danger that Israel would go into the Promised Land only to backslide into the ways of Egypt. So the Promised Land needs to be cleansed, cleared out of practices and perspectives that would take Israel’s eyes off of God. Israel needed a clean land, a fresh start. A new creation.</p><p>Hold that thought — a new creation. We’ll come back to that.</p><p><strong><em>What about the people already there?</em></strong></p><p>But first, what about the Canaanites? It’s all well and good that God has marked out a land for Israel and that they need a land free from past influences, but the Canaanites were real people. And they are living in this land that God promised to Abraham and his descendants. Why should the Canaanites lose their home?</p><p>To find the Bible’s answer to that question, we need to go all the way back to the Beginning. To Genesis. Genesis 6 to be precise:</p><blockquote>When man began to multiply on the face of the land and daughters were born to them, the <strong>sons of God</strong> saw that the daughters of man were attractive. And they took as their wives any they chose. Then the LORD said, “My Spirit shall not abide in man forever, for he is flesh: his days shall be 120 years.” <strong>The Nephilim</strong> were on the earth in those days, <strong>and also afterward</strong>, when the sons of God came in to the daughters of man and they bore children to them. These were the mighty men who were of old, the men of renown.</blockquote><blockquote>The LORD saw that the wickedness of man was great in the earth, and that every intention of the thoughts of his heart was only evil continually. And the LORD regretted that he had made man on the earth, and it grieved him to his heart. So the LORD said, “I will blot out man whom I have created from the face of the land, man and animals and creeping things and birds of the heavens, for I am sorry that I have made them.” But Noah found favor in the eyes of the LORD.</blockquote><blockquote>These are the generations of Noah. Noah was a righteous man, <strong>blameless</strong> in his generation. Noah walked with God. And Noah had three sons, Shem, Ham, and Japheth.</blockquote><p>Two observations from this passage:</p><p>1. In verses 1–4 of Genesis 6, we learn that “sons of God” came to the “daughter of man” (<em>adam</em>) and they had children — the Nephilim, “mighty men of old”. There are many theories about what exactly is going on here, but several prominent Church fathers like Justin Martyr, Eusebius, Clement of Alexandria, and Origen believed the “sons of God” were fallen angels — demons. The Nephilim are equally mysterious given the Bible’s lack of commentary on them. But we know they survived the Flood (“[they] were on the earth in those days, and also afterward”), and the reconnaissance party that Moses sent into the Promised Land in Numbers 13 reported seeing giants in the land — “and all the people that we saw in it are of great height. And there we saw the Nephilim (the sons of Anak, who come from the Nephilim), and we seemed to ourselves like grasshoppers, and so we seemed to them.” (Number 13:33)</p><p>2. In verse 10 of Genesis 6, Noah is called “a righteous man, blameless.” The Hebrew word for “blameless” is important. Again from the Interlinear Bible:</p><blockquote>תָּמִים ṯâmîym; from 8552; entire (literally, figuratively or morally); also (as noun) integrity, truth: — without blemish, complete, full, perfect, sincerely (-ity), sound, without spot, undefiled, upright(-ly), whole.</blockquote><p>The earth has become so wicked and people are so bent on evil that God “regretted that He had made man on the earth.” (Gen 6:6) But one man, Noah, is <em>tamim</em> (my transliteration), complete, perfect, full, without blemish. So God partners with Noah to send warnings to the people of the earth to repent of their wicked ways and turn to God. God longed for people to become more holy, devoted to consecration to Him. When they do not heed the call, they choose the other side of that coin and are devoted to destruction. They choose death over life in God, who is the only source of life. God sends the Flood, saving Noah and his family and the animals through the ark.</p><p>It is interesting to note that Moses calls the people of Israel to be <em>tamim</em> before God in Deuteronomy 18:13: “You shall be <strong>blameless</strong> before the LORD your God, for these nations, which you are about to dispossess, listen to fortune-tellers and to diviners. But as for you, the LORD your God has not allowed you to do this.”</p><p>With this background, we can come back to Deuteronomy to understand the context of <em>herem</em>. In addition to Deuteronomy 7, Moses repeats in Deuteronomy 20:16–18 the accusation against the Canaanites and the need to protect the Israelites from their evil practices:</p><blockquote>But in the cities of these peoples that the LORD your God is giving you for an inheritance, you shall save alive nothing that breathes, but you shall devote them to complete destruction, the Hittites and the Amorites, the Canaanites and the Perizzites, the Hivites and the Jebusites, as the LORD your God has commanded, that they <strong>may not teach you to do according to all their abominable practices that they have done for their gods</strong>, and so you sin against the LORD your God. (<em>bolded text added by authors</em>)</blockquote><p>It is well documented in history that the peoples of Canaan practiced some of the most brutal rituals in the entire Ancient Near East — sexual exploitation in fertility cults and child sacrifice to Baal their deity. <em>Vulnerable women and children were being sacrificed for the needs of the powerful!</em> Widows and orphans, in the language of the Old Testament. The very people that God has just spent the five books of the Torah commanding — pleading — Moses to care of and provide for.</p><p>So the Canaanites are not some innocent people minding their own business. In Genesis 15:16, God said that the “sin of the Amorites has not yet reached its full measure.” God saw the Amorites’ depravity and labeled their wickedness as not yet “full.” In the meantime, they completely wasted their time of grace, and continued to “fill up” their measure of sin. Fast forward to Joshua, their time is up and their sin is of full degree. Now, with the Israelites on the eastern bank of the Jordan River — much like in the days before the Flood — the time for judgment has come.</p><p>And in Leviticus 18:24–25, God pronounces judgment! “Do not make yourselves unclean by any of these things, for by all these the nations I am driving out before you have become unclean, and the land became unclean, so that I punished its iniquity, and the land vomited out its inhabitants.”</p><p><strong><em>The flood of God’s people</em></strong></p><p>There are interesting parallels between the people on the earth in the days of Noah and the Canaanites in the Promised Land in the days of Moses and Joshua. God judges the wickedness of both peoples and there are giants in the land. It is in the aftermath of the Genesis Flood that Noah curses Canaan, his grandson (Genesis 9:20–25). It is the people of Canaan that stand cursed before God in the Book of Joshua.</p><p>But if we are going to adopt the imagery of the cleansing Flood bringing judgment to a wicked people, where is Noah? Where is the call to repentance? Where is the ark?</p><p>Oh wait! There <strong><em>is</em></strong> an ark! The ark of the covenant is mentioned 14 times in these 17 verses in Joshua 3. The ark parts the waters of the Jordan (also a callback to the Exodus) for the people of Israel to cross. God’s people, who are called to be <em>tamim</em> just like Noah, are saved from the Flood waters by the ark.</p><p>There is also a call to repentance. The new reconnaissance party (<em>tamim</em> where Moses’ recon party had proven faithless and cowardly) is saved by Rahab, who professes faith in the God of Israel, becoming <em>tamim</em>. We see her and her family saved as well!</p><p>Joshua 6 then recounts the fall of Jericho as the people of Israel march around the city walls for seven days resulting in the felling of Jericho’s walls and the armies of Israel rushing in to destroy the people and city structures. This is flood language! (The seven trumpets of ram’s horns is also an interesting foreshadowing of the seventh seal of judgment in Revelation.)</p><p>Earlier we considered the idea that the Promised Land needed to be cleansed for the people of Israel and likened this to a new creation. We also find new creation language in Joshua 6! Seven days marching around Jericho and seven times on the seventh day brings us back to the seven days of creation in Genesis 1 (completion — “it is finished” / “it is good”). God is consecrating the land as the new Eden, just as He consecrated — set apart, <em>herem</em> — the creation (land) for Adam and Eve in the Garden. The waters receded and dry land “appeared.” God’s presence establishes the order and boundaries of creation — everything in its place and every system needed for life to thrive.</p><p>Given the view that the entire conquest of the Land is a new act of creation, we can now see the role that the Canaanites play in the story. In Deuteronomy 2 and 3, various Canaanite tribes, including the Emites and Anakites, are described as giants comparable to the Nephilim. In ancient Hebrew cosmology, giants embody the themes of spiritual rebellion and human corruption. (The Nephilim narrative critiques ancient Near Eastern myths that glorified warrior-kings as divine or semi-divine.) So God is working a new act of creation — clearing out the agents of chaos to make space for His people. This is the same pattern of creation as we see in Genesis 1, except the giants / Canaanites represent chaos rather than the waters of the deep.</p><p>This provides the context for us to look at Joshua 6:21: “Then they <strong>devoted all in the city to destruction</strong>, both men and women, young and old, oxen, sheep, and donkeys, with the edge of the sword.”</p><p>There it is again — <em>herem</em>. The same call to devotion of … consecration or destruction, life or death, blessing or cursing. Those that turned to God were saved. Those that turned away from Him were destroyed. But how can the outcome of <em>herem</em> (consecration or destruction) be known before the <strong><em>action </em></strong>of devotion takes place in time? The word that God commanded to the Israelites marching into the land was <em>herem</em>. Israel could not have known the outcome before the devotion took place. And maybe herein is a key that will unlock this whole ball of wax.</p><p><strong><em>The interpretive key of Deuteronomy 32</em></strong></p><p>So what decided which way <em>herem</em> went for the object of the devotion?</p><p>Deuteronomy 32 contains a Song that God commanded Moses to write. This Song foretells Israel’s future failure to maintain its commitment and devotion to God. God tells us the purpose of the Song of Moses in Deuteronomy 31:19–22 — to serve as a witness to future generations of Israelites when they turn their collective backs on God.</p><p>Prophesying Israel’s future failures to live up their covenant commitments, God calls the Israelites blemished in verse 5 of Deuteronomy 32. One more time to the Interlinear Bible:</p><blockquote>מאוּם m’ûm; usually מוּם muwm; as if passive participle from an unused root probably meaning to stain; a blemish (physically or morally): — blemish, blot, spot.</blockquote><p>So when they turn away from God and His ways, the Israelites are called <em>mum</em> (with blemish) — the opposite of <em>tamim. </em>But Moses called Israel to be <em>tamim</em> before God in Deuteronomy 18:13, the same term that Genesis uses to describe Noah. In verse 4 of chapter 32, interestingly, “the Rock” — (God but also what will be used by the New Testament authors as reference to Christ in 1 Cor 3:11; 1 Cor 10:1–12; Eph 2:20–22) is called <em>tamim</em> (He who is spotless and without blemish — 1 Peter 3:17–19).</p><p>Given that Israel turns <em>mum</em>, God says in 32:20 that “I will hide my face from them;… for they are a perverse generation.” God withdraws His holy presence, His hedge of protection. Evil is unrestrained, and judgment rushes in. When God withdraws His protection, chaos and disorder — evil — flood in. Anything submitted to this is no longer consecrated — set apart — so it is destroyed. Just like Jericho and the Canaanites, the people of Israel are still objects of <em>herem</em> (devotion), but because they are not spotless (<em>tamim</em>), they cannot be consecrated for God and so will be destroyed. Because they are blemished (<em>mum</em> — unholy, not set apart), God’s presence has been withdrawn. Just like the Canaanites in Joshua.</p><p>So Deuteronomy 32 shows us what decided the outcome of <em>herem</em> — the <em>tamim</em> or <em>mum</em> of the object of devotion before God. The command for <em>herem</em> when taking possession of the Promised Land would look the same to the Israelites. Is it possible that God called them to “<em>herem</em> consecrate” the peoples of Canaan but because of their own faithlessness to God — because of their fear of chariots and horses (the backbone military power of the imperial powers around them) — Israel assumed “<em>herem</em> destroy”? What if Israel’s call was to enter the land non-violently and trust in God to deliver the land over to them His way, rather than through the force of arms? God is the only One who can judge <em>tamim</em> or <em>mum</em>. God was calling Israel to devote the Canaanites to Him. The fate of the Canaanites would still have been left to the Just Judge, but Israel would have been innocent of bloodshed. We will never know because Israel did it their own way. God’s judgment still came, but the Israelites took up their arms and literally took matters into their own hands, and as a result, the Bible records the blood that is on their hands. (Just as the blood of our neighbors is on <em>all</em> of our hands!)</p><p>Just like in Genesis 1, God’s presence was rushing in to the land of Canaan in an act of new creation to make space for His people. And just like in the Garden, His people turned their backs on the command of God and chose to go their own way. God withdraws His presence. Rather than being a blessing to the nations (Genesis 12:3), Israel in their stiff-neckedness became a vehicle of cursing and destruction!</p><p>But God says in Deuteronomy 32:36 — “For the LORD will vindicate his people and have compassion on his servants.” Out of those that remain His servants — His remnant — One who is completely faithful — <em>tamim</em> — will rise up for God and deliver His people. And continuing in verse 43:</p><blockquote>“Rejoice with him, O heavens;</blockquote><blockquote>bow down to him, all gods,</blockquote><blockquote>for he avenges the blood of his children</blockquote><blockquote>and takes vengeance on his adversaries.</blockquote><blockquote>He repays those who hate him</blockquote><blockquote>and cleanses his people’s land.”</blockquote><p>In the “fullness of time” (Galatians 4:4), the Servant of God will rise up and declare “It is finished” — complete, <em>tamim</em>. He takes our <em>herem</em> judgment to Himself, and because of the One who is <em>tamim</em> for us, those in Him no longer need fear the <em>herem</em> judgment of God. They know they are <em>herem </em>consecrated before a just and holy God.</p><p>Perhaps Greg Boyd isn’t far off after all with his theory that God takes on the appearance of our sin and curse when we view the Story through the prism of the Cross, but we would turn the prism of the Cross around to view the Text through an adjacent angle to see the spaces God creates amidst the judgments and the ways that God finds us there. Even the judgments of <em>mum</em> are good news from this view of the Cross!</p><p><strong><em>And so…</em></strong></p><p>After all of this analysis, we see that judgment, such as that seen in Joshua, is very real and necessary. We cannot shy away from the Bible’s call that judgment comes. In fact, we need to look no further than the 1930–40s Nazi Germany to realize that we would not want to live in a world without divine judgment. But Jesus also says that we have to love God and love people. No matter what else Joshua is about, it is about loving people. THAT is the tension that most of us feel with Joshua — how do we resolve Jesus’ call to love people (which He says is what the Torah was about all along — “I have come to fulfill Torah”) and God’s (apparent) commands for violence in Joshua?</p><p>We have seen through our analysis of <em>herem</em> that God was calling for judgment and for Israel to be His instrument of judgment, but that He might not have been calling for violence. And going back to Boyd’s interpretative principle that Christians must see all of Scripture through the lens of the Cross, we are left with the key to resolving the tension that has been set up — the Cross itself. We are to love people and let God deal with the judgment of people because we know that He ultimately takes that judgment Himself on the Cross.</p><p>He never leaves us or forsakes us. And <em>that</em> is a Story we can trust!</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=32d62836dd45" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>