<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Craig Hannaway on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Craig Hannaway on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@craighannaway?source=rss-1069a25e8612------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 08:46:28 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@craighannaway/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On the Virgin Birth]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@craighannaway/on-the-virgin-birth-9f0c1973bef3?source=rss-1069a25e8612------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9f0c1973bef3</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Craig Hannaway]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 13 Nov 2024 16:47:22 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-11-13T16:47:22.108Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*O_UWhUbsB9T-tAurLPazGg.jpeg" /></figure><p>In the landscape of truth, there is no equal exchange. This is a truth that the new atheists, and indeed many secular intellectuals, get wrong. It is as if they view truth as if it were a level, open plain, upon which each true thing stands, each one being of equal height and viewable from any point upon the plain. But truth is better seen as a landscape with a very variegated topography. It has mountains, valleys, shores and islands as well as open plains. No doubt the sciences can be described as the shining cities of the plain, with reflected light from their rationalistic citadels glittering in the eyes of the TV professors, but science should also acknowledge its blighted forests, deserts and poisoned lakes.</p><p>The religious truth of the Virgin Birth of Jesus Christ is far from there, standing like a crag in pale sunlight on the flank of a far-off mountain.</p><p>In other words, the Virgin Birth means a great deal within its religious context, and very little outside of it. It can even be a matter for derision and contempt, as was Christ himself. Religious truths look utterly absurd from the plain of materialistic rationalism, though we should remember that the reverse also sometimes obtains. That the universe has a first cause is surely a rational conclusion, even if the rationalists themselves scorn it. Science asks us to believe an absurdity in this context: that once there was Nothing Nowhere No Time, and in a tiny fraction of an eye blink, <em>tendentia omnia ex nihil, </em>Everything Somewhere Sometime happened, for no other reason than that Nothing Nowhere No Time has within it a natural tendency to explode into universes. In other words, for physicists, the universe was made by the Great Somehow. As Terence McKenna said, modern theoretical physics is based on the principle, ‘Give me the first miracle and I’ll explain the rest.’</p><p>Conversely, the Virgin Birth could be seen from the plain as a very unlikely but theoretically-possible fact. Scientific views on parthenogenesis have changed somewhat. In the 1990s a three-year old boy was discovered to be a partial virgin birth, with paternal chromosomes in his skin but not in the leucocytes of his blood.</p><p>But even if virgin birth could be demonstrated experimentally, this kind of truth, the truth of the plain, would still be irrelevent, for the truth of the Virgin Birth resonates with many kind of meanings, but not that one.</p><p>It shows us that Christ did not belong to his earthly father, as everyone did in those days, even if his DNA could be shown to have originated in the normal way. It isolates and transfigures the nursing couple, mother and child, in a spiritual place of their own, thereby massively elevating the moral status of mothers with babies ever after. Perhaps this needed to be done as a matter of humanity’s survival — we know the Greeks sometimes exposed their children, and there is evidence to show the Carthaginians sometimes threw newborns into a fire in a pagan ritual. It seems that humanity has devoted a lot of effort to trying to end itself even as it reproduces itself. Therefore, we are the inheritors, beneficiaries and even products of the transfigured status of the nursing couple portrayed by the Virgin and Child.</p><p>Perhaps all I am saying is that there are all kinds of truths that we needed to survive, and without all kinds of truths we might not be here. As with truths so with people. We should resist genetic manipulation of embryos because (in the phrase that Wittgenstein found so beautiful) it takes all kinds of people to make a world.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9f0c1973bef3" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Year of Eating Less]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@craighannaway/a-year-of-eating-less-f4cc9a378de9?source=rss-1069a25e8612------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f4cc9a378de9</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Craig Hannaway]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 05 Jan 2022 14:08:09 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-11-13T16:19:11.429Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>A Year of Eating Less</p><p>by Giarc M. Tubraig</p><p>It was a good time for a new project. The first Lockdown was over two months old. I normally work from home when I’m not in the shop, except for borough council meetings, and our family business was on-ice in the Furlough scheme, so there were no devastating changes for us. Unlike many of the parents I hear on Radio 4, I enjoy having the children at home instead of school. I did not feel they were missing out much as they are resourceful, and it gave me more time to learn German with the younger one. If I had any faith in the current school system I might have felt differently.</p><p>In fact, I was enjoying the Lockdown. Long dog walks listening to audiobooks and no boring meetings; leisurely cooking and leisurely eating; the quietness of the streets. However, there was no doubt that I was getting fat. Before Lockdown, I had occasionally weighed myself on the machine in the little room in the doctor’s surgery where the blood pressure monitor is also kept. Usually I was 94 or 95 kg (I am 5 feet 9 inches). In Lockdown I could no longer use that little room, and we did not yet have bathroom scales, but the size of my stomach was definitely increasing, so I must have been pushing 100kg.</p><p>. One adapts to one’s weight, usually without noticing. Putting out a hand to the banister as one descends the stairs or walking more slowly uphill and attributing the dragged down feeling to tiredness or age. But it is harder to rationalize the visual evidence.</p><p>I don’t know where the idea came from, other than the mirror. I have given up or reduced other habits like smoking and drinking alcohol at various times in the past, but somehow eating less was not something I ever gave any thought to. I certainly like food, and our family business is in food and catering. So I don’t know when I first entertained the idea, but once I had I felt I knew straight away how to avoid early, guaranteed failure. The trick would be to stay ahead of the storm.</p><p>The Maelstrom</p><p>I have long been aware of the permanent storm going on inside me. This is where the three vectors of my ego, my desires and my fears collide and produce a lovely vortex of guilt. I call it the maelstrom. The maelstrom is always trying to outrun me and suck me in, and often does. As I get older though I am getting better at climbing out again and staying ahead of it most of the time. I have learned that one thing sure to throw me straight into the maelstrom is any attempt at personal or moral improvement. The slightest lapse in the program goes straight to wounded pride and then into the vortex of guilt. Once there, the project is doomed because it is only a matter of time before I throw off the guilt by throwing off the attempt to make an improved version of me. On 29 May 2020 I wrote in my diary:</p><p>“Ok, let’s get it straight from the start. Eating less is not going to make me a more virtuous person. I do not believe in confusing morality with health. I will just be a thinner sinner.</p><p>This is important to write down, because if I succumb to thinking eating less will make me good, my efforts will fall into the usual maelstrom of ego, desire and guilt. I have also decided not to weigh myself. I know I am overweight, more so since Lockdown. If I do I will become obsessed with the numbers. This is simply an experiment in eating less, its effects and how it feels.”</p><p>At the end of this entry I added: “I need to give it a year”.</p><p>. I think I knew, even as I wrote this, that calling it an experiment was a bit of a cover story. There is bound to be vanity involved in wanting to lose weight. However, calling it an experiment gave me enough motivation and structure to get started.</p><p>. In the entry for “experiment”, the Chambers Dictionary has:</p><p>.</p><p>“Something done to test a theory or to discover something unknown; a trial; experience (obsolete) … to carry out an experiment or trial; to search by trial … to make trial of …”</p><p>I think my intention in calling eating less an experiment covered both testing a theory and discovering something unknown, especially the question of whether I had it in me to do it. To this extent the experiment made trial of me, though this was an aspect I needed to downplay at the beginning in order to stay out of the maelstrom. But the obsolete sense of experiment as experience is suggestive, both in its being obsolescent – how could it be forgotten that an experiment is an experience in itself (not merely a destination), and also in its reminding us that our experiences can be experimental. This seems like an idea very much against the spirit of our times, or at least of what we called our times before the pandemic.</p><p>On Wisdom and Washing Up</p><p>From my diary:</p><p>“I’ve been eating less for three weeks now, having smaller meals, no seconds and nothing between meals except cups of tea. For the most part it has been easier than I thought it would be and I do feel better. Whatever combinations of chemicals the body releases to make you feel better are certainly working.</p><p>I was amazed at how quickly my stomach shrank, not the belly yet of course, I mean on the inside. After only 4 or 5 days I felt during dinner I couldn’t eat my usual amount if I’d wanted to. But this feeling is not constant. After a couple of weeks I began to feel ravenous, especially late at night. I took comfort from the words of the Indian spiritual leader Sadghuru, who claims many illnesses can be avoided or improved by going to bed hungry.</p><p>The worst time in the first week was mid-afternoon, when I was hit by low blood sugar effects like weakness and bad mood. Of course, I do not know what my blood sugar level is at these times. I am not diabetic so don’t have to keep a check on it. In popular culture we attribute these crashes to low blood sugar without any medical knowledge. But they stopped after the first week so, though I always thought they were due to lack of food, perhaps a better way to think of them is as a kind of food hangover from eating too much.”</p><p>Clearly, I thought I’d invented the idea of the food hangover, but I see on the internet that it is a term already in use. It defines the same symptoms as a hangover caused by alcohol, but in this case caused by eating an unaccustomed amount f fatty, sugary, salty or starchy food. I think I meant something different by food hangover; that eating a large amount regularly makes the blood sugar go up and down in waves of large amplitude, leading to bad-mood, light-headedness and the shakes if you miss a meal or leave too long a gap between them. I don’t know if there is any medical truth in this, though it would help to explain the absence, or rarity, of these symptoms even though I am eating a lot less. It is a long time since I have popped into a shop to get a bar of chocolate to keep me going.</p><p>I also notice the sudden appearance of Sadghuru in my diary in this extract. I might not have come across him or the other late-night YouTube gurus, as I all them, if it hadn’t been for the pandemic.</p><p>Staying in the house as we were required to do, apart from food shopping and dog walks, I found myself drifting into a different routine. It must have occurred to me that my customary casual domestic ways would not be good for family life in a lockdown, so I started doing the lion’s share of the household washing-up. Our dishwasher had broken a while before and, deciding that it needed too much looking after to save much labour (I always felt I had to wash the dishes first or they clog up the machine), I got rid of it and turned the space it had occupied into a much more useful cupboard.</p><p>Most nights I would be the last one up, after reading or playing Assassin’s Creed Odyssey, and would be washing up at 1.00a.m. or 1.30a.m. For entertainment I would play YouTube videos on my phone, placed on the coffee machine near the sink. This is how I came across the late-night gurus, as I call them, who helped to distract me from what was often the hungriest part of the day. My gateway guru into this unusual corner of YouTube’s vast archive was Alan Watts. I had read some of his books on Zen when I was in my 20s and found them very engaging. Watts was a middle-class English intellectual who started his career as an Episcopal priest in the USA, but he had always been very interested in Buddhism and was deeply read in Asian religious literature. After a scandal in which both Watts and his wife had affairs with students, Watts lost his position and left the clergy, becoming a scholar and writer on Eastern philosophy and religion, especially Zen, Taoism, Buddhism and Hinduism. In his later years he lived, and sometimes gave talks, on a houseboat in Sausalito, California. Watts was also an alcoholic who said to a friend towards the end of his life that he hated himself when he was sober. In his talks, he described himself as a “spiritual entertainer”.</p><p>I had read his books but never heard his voice. Notwithstanding the tediousness of its “stars” and “influencers”, YouTube and its contributors have done a service to humanity in this regard. After listening to several of his talks, it occurred to me I was listening to the best public speaker I had ever heard. The clarity of his associations of ideas, the natural flow of his expression, the sense of a full human being speaking and the qualities of his mind make him a wonderful lecturer. Public speaking is something I’m quite good at myself, but I know a master when I hear one. His gifts easily survive the occasional talk when he sounds like he has had a good drink as well as his smoker’s cough. His talks form quite a large archive on YouTube; once you play one of them many others are listed underneath, though, annoyingly, some of them have had supposedly inspirational music added in the background, to make him sound like the profound guru he never claimed to be. It is also worth noting that the titles of the videos are created by whoever uploaded them, not by Watts himself. Sometimes they do not summarise the content very well.</p><p>To give one example, there is a YouTube video of a public lecture (audio only) entitled “Why the Urge to Improve” but which Watts himelf calls “Mind over Mind”. He begins by stating his intention to exlore issues of control of the mind from different points of view. In scientific terms he calls it “the problem of feedback”. In Western theological terms, this translates into the problem of how to follow the will of God when the will of Man is perverse. How can we get Divine Grace if we are so wholly selfish? Then, in terms of Eastern philospophy, this becomes the question of how to abandon one’s desire when the desire to abandon desire is itself desire. How to transform the mind to get it beyond the vicious circle of this predicament: if I want to be a better member of the human race, “I” will need to improve “me”. He comments, “A lot of people get baptised, and it doesn’t always take”. He then goes on to describe a technique of watching your own thoughts, without judgement. “But can you watch the watcher”, he asks, since the watcher is itself a thought. He uses a brilliant analogy: when the police go into a building on the ground floor to catch the robbers, the robbers move one floor up. Likewise, when you try to abolish the ego, the ego moves itself into “the higher self”. For example, we may congratulate ourselves on being more tolerant towards others with different views than they are to us, but this is just another form of one-upmanship. Watts asks, “You see how that game is going to work?” He gives us a little dialogue:</p><p>So – how do we not do that?</p><p>Why do you want to know?</p><p>I’d be better that way.</p><p>Why do you want to be better?</p><p>He reaches the devastating conclusion:</p><p>“The reason why you want to be better is the reason why you aren’t”.</p><p>He follows this with a very striking image:</p><p>“Kindly let me help you or you’ll drown, said the monkey, putting the fish safely up a tree.”</p><p>From here he widens the scope into political and scientific issues which are still very hot topics half a century later. He says that for the previous century (century and a half now) the Anglo-Saxon West has been on a “rampage” to improve the world, (“You’d better be democratic or we’ll shoot you”)and that for the most part the rest of the world hates us for it. If only he had lived to see the rampages of Blair and Bush. He tells us about his invitation to a conference on the potential genetic manipulation of humans, where he is asked the best way to ensure future human beings have the most desirable qualities. He conjures up the nightmare image of “a plague of saints” trying to improve the world catastrophically. He then takes his argument back into history, reminding us that the Spanish Inquisition was looked upon as positively as cancer treatment is today, because anything was justifiable in order to save someone’s immortal soul.</p><p>. Clearly, the central problem here is the problem of successful intervention. With hindsight, I can see how this talk influenced my attitude towards the start of this experiment when I said to myself, “Eating less is not going to make me a more virtuous person. I do not believe in confusing morality with health. I will just be a thinner sinner”. In other words, it is fine to experiment on yourself but not to imagine you are improving some essential quality or aspect of yourself. In Watts’ words, do not put the fish up the tree, or allow the robbers to keep going up to the next floor.</p><p>. This concern – this form of caution – is out of kilter with our times. Self-improvement is big business. The UK diet industry alone is worth £2 billion a year. The global figure is £200 billion. According to the British Heart Foundation, 55% of adults in the UK try to lose weight each year. There is the Paleo Diet, the Vegan Diet, Low Carb Diets, the Dukan Diet, the Ultra Low Fat Diet, The Atkins Diet, the HCG Diet, the Zone Diet, and Intermittent Fasting, to name but a few. According to the British Heart Foundation website, the average number of days most people stick to a new diet is 19. It recommends avoiding several of the more extreme diets due to their potential health consequences. The Juice Diet can cause anaemia and lack of calcium in the bones; the Raw Paleo Diet increases the risks of osteoporosis and coronary heart disease through higher cholesterol; Sugar Free Diets also risk osteoporosis, anaemia and constipation; Single Food Diets encourage water and muscle loss rather than fat loss, and Food Combining Diets are useless and make blood sugar control more difficult. As well as the potential negative health effects, the evidence must surely be in now that these extreme diets do not work for most people, and that there is more than a little cruelty involved in their promotion.</p><p>. This is perhaps made worse by the use of moralism within the diet industry. Nowhere is this clearer than in the organisation Weight Watchers, where foods are described as having a specific number of “syns”, pronounced the same as “sins”, a telling pun if ever there was one.</p><p>Weight Watchers Classic Range Cottage Pie, 3.5 Syns</p><p>. Weight Watchers Classic Range Chicken Hotpot, 4 Syns</p><p>. Weight Watchers Classic Range Shepherd’s Pie, 4 Syns</p><p>. Weight Watchers Classic Range Spaghetti Bolognese, 5 Syns</p><p>Perhaps part of the attractiveness of these famous diets is that they appear to provide a complete scheme, a definitive and comprehensive way of sorting out the problem. Perhaps this is only one way in which we are susceptible to the simplicities of complete schemes. Conspiracy theories spread on social media have captured many. They also appear to provide a comfortingly comprehensive answer, however unpleasant its contents. Some people seem increasingly unable or unwilling to bear the puzzling, bewildering, enigmatic nature of life.</p><p>I know a woman, a family friend, for example; an educated woman in her fifties who has fallen for some of the worst. Though she was always eccentric, and her parenting sometimes bizarre, I had thought I knew her better until I saw her Facebook posts sharing the views of crazies like David Icke on the pandemic. I tried to introduce her to some of Icke’s other views, such as that the world is run by a conspiracy of giant lizards, but she only became resentful and asked my missus to get me to stop. It was as if she felt that any opinions counter to her own were more dangerous to her health than the Covid virus. She is firmly convinced that Trump really won the election and the pandemic has been invented to benefit a shadowy elite conspiracy and says she has lost friends over her posts.</p><p>I quickly gave up trying to persuade her as I didn’t want to make things awkward for my missus. I tried to tell myself she was always moving from one slightly batty idea to another so it wouldn’t last. But her idiocy made me angry after I saw on the news the anti-Lockdown protestors outside St Thomas’ hospital in London. Their chanting could be heard by the dying patients inside.</p><p>In the end I thought it best just to unfriend her on Facebook so I wouldn’t see her posts. With luck her handcart will lose a wheel before she gets to Hell.</p><p>. If I could I would show her a short video on YouTube, featuring Josiah Thompson, author of Six Seconds in Dallas, on the technical details of the Kennedy assassination. The video was made by the New York Times Errol Morris and is entitled The Umbrella Man. November 22nd 1963, the day JFK was murdered, was a bright and windy day, but photos and footage show one of the figures standing closest to Kennedy’s limousine, on the pavement, just as the first bullet is fired, is wearing a long, black overcoat and holding an open black umbrella high above his head. Naturally, this man became the subject of many conspiracy theories, some of them outlandish. Was he secretly signalling to the assassins? Was he a secret service agent involved in the plot? There was even a book arguing that he himself was the assassin. However, in 1978, the “umbrella man”, as Thompson dubbed him, came forward to testify to the House Committee on Assassinations in Congress. His name was Louie Steven Witt and his reason for being in Dealy Plaza on that day, he explained, was to make a protest; not against JFK himself, but against the Kennedy family, specifically against Kennedy’s father, who was the US ambassador to Britain (“ambassador to the Court of Saint James”) before World War Two. The umbrella was there to represent British Prime Minister Neville Chamberlain, who famously often carried one and which became a symbol of Chamberlain’s policy of appeasement toward Adolf Hitler’s military aggressions in Europe. Chamberlain’s strategy was energetically supported by Kennedy senior, and the raised umbrella had been used as a visual protest about the Kennedy family before that day. If JFK had seen Mr Witt and his umbrella, he would probably have understood its significance, though it would have one of the last things he did understand.</p><p>. In the YouTube video, Thompson concludes from this very obscure act of protest:</p><p>. “If you have any fact which you think is really sinister, right, is really obviously a fact that can only point to some sinister underpinnings, hey, forget it man, because you can never, on your own, think up all the non-sinister, perfectly-valid expectations for that fact. A cautionary tale.”</p><p>In the slightly less deadly world of commercial diets there are also cautionary tales. We want to find that total scheme that will sort us out for good but can never be sure we won’t try to appease our own consciences by deluding ourselves. The attempts of the industry to persuade us of the guilt-free efficiency of their products does seem to have a sinister side, even though we are willing, false-naïve participants in the conspiracy. Indeed, our very weight itself may be a kind of visual protest about our collusion with the total answer, with its evasions and appeasements.</p><p>The Total Diet</p><p>Yet there was such. complete scheme of eating, in an important experiment with far-reaching consequences. The Minnesota Starvation Experiment (or Semi-Starvation or Starvation-Recovery experiment) was a unique large-scale project carried out at the University of Minnesota from November 1944 to December 1945. The background to the experiment was the US Government’s awareness of the semi-starvation of much of the population of Europe as the end of the Second World War approached, with the associated problems of how best to intervene to try to provide a diet that would help the maximum number of people recover. The experiment was designed to determine the physical and psychological effects of a diet, during the starvation phase, of no more than 1500 calories per day, together with the best recovery strategy. 36 white men, all of them conscientious objectors and volunteers from the Civilian Public Service organisation, were housed in a temporary building in a football stadium. During the first control period of 12 weeks they were fed 3,200 calories per day, which was then suddenly cut in half to 1,560 calories per day for the following 24 weeks, (though the diet of each man was adjusted to achieve a uniform 25% total weight loss). The diet itself was intended to reproduce as closely as possible that of semi-starved Europe; mainly bread, root vegetables and macaroni. After almost six-months of semi-starvation the men were fed one of four tightly-controlled rehabilitation diets with different amounts of calories, proteins and supplements. For the final eight weeks intake was unrestricted but recorded. During the period of the experiment the men were also given tasks to perform, including walking 22 miles each week and keeping a diary, and were regularly physically examined and mentally tested.</p><p>. Basically, they fell apart. Along with many physical effects, the subjects experienced emotional stress and depression, hysteria and hypochondria. The rehab phase was the hardest. One man cut off three fingers of his hand with an axe but didn’t know if he had done it deliberately or not. Obviously, they became obsessed with food, but they also showed little interest in sex, became withdrawn, couldn’t concentrate, comprehend or make judgements. Their temperature, breathing rate and heart rate all reduced. Many of them never regained a comfortable relationship with food.</p><p>. The significance of this experiment for today only appears when one considers that many, currently well-known diets are based on only 1200 calories per day, 360 less than the Minnesota Experiment. Try Googling the phrase “1200 calorie diet” and it quickly becomes clear that a vast number of people, mainly women, regularly attempt a diet that has been scientifically proven to produce short and long term physical and psychological damage. In an article on Buzzfeed (Jan 15, 2021), reporter Scaachi Koul comments:</p><p>“Most [women] learned the magic 1,200 number in middle or high school, carrying on with the diet until their twenties or thirties. They hoped to lose weight; instead, they felt faint all the time, were ravenous when it was time to eat, and binged when they couldn’t take it anymore. They perpetually felt guilty for whatever food choices they made … Diet culture is pernicious, and the 1,200-calorie diet is so ubiquitous that it feels almost ridiculous to ask if anyone’d tried it … Every woman of every generation in my family has attempted this diet, from my 65-year-old mother to my 30-year-old cousins.”</p><p>Clearly, anyone who managed to sustain this diet for a prolonged period of time would have poor physical and mental health. Perhaps some of the guilt described is produced by the diet itself, as well as the failure to continue with it.</p><p>. From my diary:</p><p>“6 July. Not a great day yesterday, felt tired and hungry most of the day. Went to a bbq at S’s in the afternoon then nothing [to eat] for the rest of the day. Aches and pains, got into the bath but wasn’t comfortable so got out again.</p><p>20 July. Going through a phase of feeling not exactly hungry but empty and stretched. Noticeably thinner in the mirror … on some days, episodes of light-headedness …</p><p>21 July. I have discovered that my recent bad breath, particularly horrible when wearing a mask, is caused by eating less and losing weight. The liver runs out of carbs to burn so starts burning fat, which it turns into chemicals called ketones. They get into the blood and the breath.</p><p>. I’ve also had a bit of insomnia which can also be attributed to eating less.</p><p>. Things I have learnt so far:</p><ol><li>Not eating between meals is the keystone to losing weight, especially between dinner and bed.5</li><li>2. You need to eat enough, otherwise the body and mind gradually come under greater strain.</li></ol><p>3 August. I weighed myself. Estimating from the last time I was weighed at the doctors’, I have lost around 10kg.”</p><p>I think it was useful during this initially difficult period that I had already read about the Minnesota Starvation Experiment. It gave a context within which to place my own experience.</p><p>. Some of my diary entries are a little strange: at one point a disturbingly egotistical voice appears:</p><p>“7 Sept I recoil from the morning’s metallic quality. Apparently, we must always defer to some other bastard. Then I got up for some tea. 83.3 on the scales, slightly more than yesterday. What is the solution to losing weight? One must put aside convention and allow oneself to be weird. I am not the man next door.”</p><p>I find it hard to recognise this strange, disconnected and rather superior person as me, though it is me.</p><p>I had initially decided not to weigh myself, but my daughter had by this point put a set of scales in the bathroom, so I began to use them. Inevitably, I became preoccupied with the daily figure.</p><p>. However, it was not all difficulty during this period. I started practicing a simple meditation technique, after waking and before going to sleep. I tried to count my breaths up to 100 and back down to zero (not back to one, intriguingly; I like zero). I had tried this before, occasionally, but could rarely get beyond ten breaths before my mind wandered off and the counting was forgotten. But now I started to get better at it. My mind still wandered but it was in the higher numbers now and on a good day I could quickly bring it back. Sometimes I counted in French to make myself concentrate a bit more through the effort of trying to remember French numbers. After several weeks of this I sometimes found myself, especially in the count back down to zero, entering a blissful state in which relaxation and a sense of well-being filled my body. The feeling started somewhere in the middle of my abdomen and spread out through my limbs. It did not happen every time and I tried to be strict with myself in not assuming it would beforehand. I have no idea if it is connected with weight loss or eating less.</p><p>. One of my late-night, washing-up gurus is quite dismissive about meditation. His name was Jiddu Krishnamurti. Picked out as a young boy by the Theosophist movement at the turn of the Twentieth Century, then trained to be something they called the Great World Teacher, he eventually disassociated himself from the whole project and disbanded the organisation created to support him. However, to the end of his long life he gave talks in many different settings, from open-air gatherings in India to Western halls and conferences, representing no one but himself. He also possessed the most haunting face you will ever see in a YouTube video. The consensus of the other washing-up gurus is that he was the real thing, an enlightened being, but that, because he insisted that we should all simply enquire into truth without the need for any kind of ritualistic practice such as mantras or meditation, he never succeeded in enlightening anyone else. It is not that the other gentlemen believe that such practices create enlightenment in themselves (whatever that is), but that they are a necessary starting point for most people. If you watch the films made of Krishnamurti’s talks, you can see him often feeling he was failing to communicate with his audience. His usual method as he got older was to answer questions from members of the audience. He often insists that it doesn’t matter what opinion “the speaker” (himself) holds, but that he and his audience should “inquire” into the question together. On occasion, after unfolding his own thinking to the audience two or three different ways and finding that they still do not understand, he gets frustrated (reminding me of Jesus berating his disciples for their denseness). For some reason it always makes me smile when he tells the audience off for not getting it. He looks quite upset that he cannot communicate his understanding to the rest of us.</p><p>. I can’t say I fully understand him either, though many of his inquiries lead me to a place where understanding is often beside the point, which may well be the point. His central theme seems to be that we think in images and should not mistake these images for reality; and that if we can stop explaining ourselves to ourselves in images, then we can perceive, and live in, truth. “Draw no conclusions”, he says.</p><p>I think it is a good idea to take what I can from my late-night gurus without trying to emulate them in any way. For example, Krishnamurti sometimes tells his audience that he doesn’t read books, asking them, “Why do you read so many books?”. Well, I have no intention of giving up the pleasures of reading in order to become more enlightened. I will confine myself into “inquiring” into eating less.</p><p>Osho is another YouTube guru we should take with caution, though here the reservations are of a different nature. When I first saw him online, I knew nothing about the violent history of his cult. As an individual speaker I found him profound and convincing. Many of the things he says are among the simplest and most beautiful things I have heard. Also, his irreverent and occasionally combative persona give him a surprising edge of comedy, almost like a stand-up at times. A Google search of Osho quotes brings up some of his pearls, such as:</p><p>. “A man who is 100% sane is dead.”</p><p>This echoes some sentences by the great child psychoanalyst Donald Winnicott, who believed:</p><p>“It’s a poor thing to be sane, and that after much practice he had learned to be a little insane.”</p><p>Osho also gave a very simple definition of mysticism:</p><p>. “You are the goal. You are the way. You are the light. You are the whole. That is the meaning. when we say, “You are holy”.”</p><p>So, after such wonderful words and such n impressive persona, it was a shock to watch the recent Netflix documentary, Wild, Wild, Country, about Osho’s attempt to set up a community of his followers in rural Oregon in the 1980s. With all his wisdom it is hard to understand how he and his followers ever thought the US authorities would allow them to draft in their own voters to take over the town, almost get control of a county, and then seek to sway the entire state after they met with official opposition. Of course, the authorities intervened, of course, the FBI got involved, and in response Osho’s followers bought a large number of guns and became combat-trained, which was never going to help the situation. In the end they arrested him, and probably meant to kill him by poisoning, though presumably today they would have put him in Guantanamo Bay.</p><p>. Even with the benefit of hindsight, and with the most generous judgement of Osho’s integrity, he caused a lot of unnecessary suffering. Mass poisoning is not a great advert for your guru, even if they are out to get him. There was also a curious kind of naivety in attempting to pull the thing off. It was as if Osho did at first really believe that US democracy was a pure, unassailable thing; otherwise he surely would not have assumed that he and his followers could manipulate it to secure their mad ranch.</p><p>. So get you gone, Osho, though with blessings on your head.</p><p>Without doubt the most useful habit I acquired during this year of eating less was the meditation technique of counting one’s breaths, described earlier. If I can get to 100 breaths and back without losing the plot, it almost always works, whether I need to slow things down in the morning or to get to sleep at night.</p><p>What I now know</p><p>In the end, I lost 15kg in a year and reached a plateau at 81 kg that I never got past. In science, experimentation is supposed to lead to clear results. So perhaps it is better to take-up Krishnamurti’s word and say that I have inquired into eating less. The results of an inquiry can perhaps be allowed to be less easily measurable than an experiment.</p><p>. I wonder if we tend to keep our fat because we know insensibly that, in making a change, we ourselves are likely to be changed and that such change is not predictable, even if the adverts for diets and the thin pundit tell us we will certainly be happier and more fulfilled if we are thinner. I can say I am happier to some extent, thanks to the physical pleasures of being lighter, such as walking with more of a spring in my step and looking better in the mirror. Near strangers I have barely exchanged words with have come up to me in the street to tell me how much better I am looking.</p><p>. My circumstances have also changed in ways I couldn’t have predicted. I am still a borough councillor, but no longer a Labour one, having been expelled from the Party. As a supporter of Jeremy Corbyn in a party where most of the MPs and staff were determined to get rid of him, and the members who voted for him, I’ve always known they would be looking for an opportunity to get shot of me. So I gave them that which they sought. With two tweets saying I could not support the new leader Keir Starmer’s decision to take a candidate out of one election race and push him into another, ensuring, as I pointed out, that we would lose both elections, I was instantly thrown out by email. I had also thrown my own hat in the ring, only to discover there was no ring in which to throw it; the choice of candidate had been made on high.</p><p>. Afterwards, I decided not to appeal it. It has merely made it clear to me how much my efforts as a member, campaigner, councillor and Cabinet member were worth to the party: nothing.</p><p>. I am also no longer hanging around on the fringes of academia, having gained my PhD in Classics at Durham in my early 40s and hoping it would lead to some kind of job. It was just another line to dangle upon, so I work in our family deli/café, fulfil my roles on the council and write things like this at home in my little office in the attic. I am renovating a room in our shop building, to create an office for my missus. I helped create a holiday let on the top floor. I serve coffee and food. I sell cheese. I do the washing up (this you know already). I write poems, fiction, non-fiction, record audiobooks and receive tiny royalties every month. I walk the dogs and feed the cat. I am the main taxi number for my children. I cook. I explore charity shops. I read works in Ancient Greek and Latin, very slowly, and French a tiny bit quicker. I teach a little German to my youngest. A life.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f4cc9a378de9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“Find some time in your day to relax”, and other useless advice.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@craighannaway/find-some-time-in-your-day-to-relax-and-other-useless-advice-473a3cc34c17?source=rss-1069a25e8612------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/473a3cc34c17</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Craig Hannaway]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 22 Jul 2021 10:55:03 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-07-22T10:56:01.499Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>“Find some time in your day to relax”, and other useless advice.</p><p>For four years I was in the Cabinet in Redcar and Cleveland Council as Lead Member for Children’s Social Services and Education. On the various boards and committees I sat on there were many presentations of data about children’s health and well-being. One day we were looking at a large number of data categories for children from across the Tees area; for example obesity, breast-feeding rates, missed hospital appointments, missed vaccinations, school attendance, etc. It occurred to me that, though these were all presented as separate issues, they all affected the same significant minority of families across Teesside. The highest priority was surely not how to break down their problems into categories and rates, but how to help them. I began to wonder if there is an inherent inertia and even political bias in the injunction to “keep staring at the data” as one speaker advised us to do. Whose interest was served by constantly presenting numbers rather than people. Why so many boxes and so few case studies?</p><p>. This was also around the time I first read the work of Professor Michael Marmot on the health inequalities caused by social inequality and poverty, and I also attended a lecture by Professor Ted Schrecker at Durham University, entitled “Lifestyle Drift”. This refers to the tendency of official government and government-commissioned reports on health to begin broadly, describing how the health of the population is affected by deprivation, but then, often only a few ppages later, the focus shifts entirely to individual life-style choices. Prof. Schrecker gave us an example of why focusing on individual choice does not work. He said, “If you are a single mother holding down two or even three part-time jobs, you are much more likely to smoke than someone with an easier life because nicotine has psycho-active properties which help you keep going when you are exhausted.” This being the case, printing a leaflet about stress and putting it in a GP surgery, exhorting patients to “find some time in your day to relax” is worse than useless.</p><p>. This policy coincided with changes in the NHS (when are there not changes in the NHS?). The new buzz-phrase was “self-care”, which meant in summary that healthy people would keep themselves healthy and those with long-term health conditions would manage their own illnesses. This approach purported to be better for the health of the nation and would mean less money need be spent on the NHS. One document we were presented with had a section on “how to move on from your long-term illness”. This way of putting it really helped to show that the intention behind self-care was to make health and illness a personal, moral issue. To have a long-term illness which refuses to behave itself then becomes a moral failing. Not only is this idea immoral in itself; it is also based on a very shallow understanding of human beings. Any government policy which is designed to throw citizens into the maelstrom of guilt is bound to fail, as it is only a matter of time before the failure to meet unrealistic demands dooms the project.</p><p>. A few years ago I accompanied a friend to one of her chemotherapy sessions. She was a former nurse herself, and during our conversation as she was receiving treatment she asked, rhetorically, “When did we start blaming people for their own illnesses?”. It was an emotional statement; she was incredulous. No doubt this partly reflected what she was going through at the time, but it is also a very good question. Though its answer, or answers, are too large for this essay, in began to gain ground in the second half of the 1980s and was part of the viral brutality which has infected everything from government and corporate business to schools and colleges, the BBC (Birtism), party politics and even NHS management practices.</p><p>. Yet most members of the South Tees Health and Wellbeing Board, when I was on it, saw no problem with “self-care” when it was presented to us. Even the GPs present thought it was a good idea. Their reaction reminded me of what Prof. Schrecker told us: how for some reason doctors and other medical professionals (though not nurses) tend to resist the truths of health inequalities in society. He related how he was once invited to lecture at a medical school, but after his talk on health inequalities he was never invited back. His view was that medical doctors tend to reject the social sciences as being not scientific enough.</p><p>. Surely it is not hard to see how disastrous a policy based on “self-care” would be for the health of the population and therefore for the NHS budget. For example, there are an estimated twenty thousand people with undiagnosed raised blood-pressure just in Teesside. Under “self-care” these people are still assumed to be healthy, as their raised bp would only be diagnosed if they were already being treated for a condition. Their task would therefore be to remain healthy by making the right lifestyle choices. Yet, as we still do not fully understand the relationship between blood-pressure and lifestyle, (especially the extent to which factors such as genetics and stress play a role), there is great risk in this laissez-faire approach. The moral failure of individuals to make the right choices still results in huge costs for the NHS, and therefore for taxpayers, if the raised bp leads to many heart attacks and strokes. When we factor-in the difficulty for many of making the approved lifestyle choices in a time of increasing inequality (“make some time in your day to relax”), it would seem that we are courting social and financial disaster for the sake of being able to divide people into the deserving and undeserving sick.</p><p>. I think the inability of many of my fellow board members to agree with me on this is thanks to the general lifestyle drift. There is a settled view amongst many intelligent people that health is mainly about individual choice. It did not matter how much evidence I cited, I was seen as eccentric, or worse; Political. This is the answer to how we came to blame people for their own illnesses; if the Book of Job were written today, Job’s comforters would blame his boils on his lifestyle choices.</p><p>. Without in any way questioning our need for a really effective ambulance service, there enough evidence to show that some people who phone 999 for an ambulance do not need, physically, an emergency response. There is no doubt, however, that they are in a terrible state. A typical example would be an elderly person living alone who feels ill, and whose loneliness and anxiety has elevated their symptoms into panic and mortal dread. This should not be surprising; we are social and psychological beings after all.</p><p>. Possible responses to this issue require some investment, of course, though a general reduction of inequality is not relevant in this particular case, as it is in many others. As an example of what can be done, there was an experimental project in Teesside entitled “Cohort 32” which placed a number of social services key workers in the emergency services call centre, so that they were immediately available to respond to callers who were in distress but did not need a blue-light service.</p><p>. When I was briefed on this project by the excellent Public Health Director, Edward Kayunga, I chased more information about it but could never find out why the arrangement was never made permanent. After all, here was a practical arrangement which addressed a particular social problem with some success, and which could also save public money.</p><p>. It sometimes feels as if this country has become a place where good ideas go to die. Addressing our social problems, including health issues like loneliness, as well as physical issues like smoking and obesity, is much less expensive in the long run than dismissing them.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=473a3cc34c17" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>