<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Socialists for Pritzker on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Socialists for Pritzker on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@crazydogspirit?source=rss-cbef9396978e------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 09:48:14 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@crazydogspirit/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[2020 and Liberalism, Ultraleftism, and Mass Action]]></title>
            <link>https://crazydogspirit.medium.com/2020-and-liberalism-ultraleftism-and-mass-action-8a53ca2f6c60?source=rss-cbef9396978e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8a53ca2f6c60</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Socialists for Pritzker]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 06 Jan 2021 06:22:17 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-01-06T06:49:45.026Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Forewarning- I have made it most of my life not reading things, and I intend to keep that up until I die. If you read this piece and think “wow, this guy has not read X’, then you are right.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*H3hTjXPVAwlFE3sPkKUzrg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Kids like these memes still</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Post-Bernie Malaise</strong></p><p>The mood of the left has gone from swagger to despondent in the past year. Following leftists on social media you will find people trying to helpfully remind everyone else about how pathetically powerless we are, and how nobody can face reality. The question repeated is “where do we go from here?” where ‘we’ is sometimes ambiguous about whether it includes the person asking it, or if they are just trying to spectate the left, and are not the least bit impressed with your performance so far.</p><p>The question also usually has 2 different concerns bundled up in it. One part of the question is actually “what is the next big thing?” What can I tune in to and maybe even participate in, assuming it’s a good fit for my personal brand? Is there an emoji I can add in to my username, or a hashtag in to my bio? The thing that will finally be the moment of history I’ve been looking for?</p><p>But there is also another part of the question that does seem even more odd to me: simply what are we supposed to be doing now?</p><p>Before the Bernie campaign ended, even those most enchanted with his possible win claimed to understand that a victory would likely be a bit of a fluke- and that he would be a President fighting an establishment the left was otherwise not ready to take on. We needed to rapidly expand union membership and militancy. We needed more and more left politicians across the levels of government, ready to take over the Democratic party or split to our own party. We would need to mobilize his millions of supporters out in to the streets to agitate for his agenda. This was accepted work ahead of the left as of roughly March 2nd, 2020. It was also the accepted work in 2019, 2018, and…well if there were times before that it was probably accepted then. But since Bernie’s Super Tuesday loss, or at least since his concession at the end of March, that accepted wisdom seems gone. That wisdom was replaced with exhortations for a need to reflect and post-mortem his loss, almost all of which has obsessed with campaign rhetoric or the loyalty of his staff to the greater socialist project.</p><p>It’s difficult to mark when we are at a point of closure to reflect. Much thinking prior to the General Election would have spoken ominously about the collapse of the Republican party and the formation of a new Democratic super-party populated by a mass migration of reasonable Republicans (the Haliburton Democrats, as they were called). I am glad personally I didn’t write that! But perhaps with the new year we can attempt some reflection.</p><p><strong>Liberalism, Ultraleftism, and Mass Action</strong></p><p>As a modern day thinker, I studiously avoid actually reading the source material for an article I’ve opened. After all, it’ll either be relevant enough to the article I’m reading that the author will highlight the important passages for me, or it’s tangential enough that I can just read the critique and be on my way. I will still respect you, reader, if you take this approach.</p><p>That said, I encourage everyone to actually go read Peter Camejo’s <a href="https://www.marxists.org/archive/camejo/1970/ultraleftismormassaction.htm">Liberalism, Ultraleftism, and Mass Action</a> before going further. My sales pitch is that it is short (maybe a 10 minute read, possibly shorter than this piece), mostly devoid of left jargon, and very fun. If nothing else, you will walk away thinking about how great of a poster Camejo would have been if he were with us today on Twitter. A small taste:</p><blockquote><em>This is the key thing to understand about the ultraleftists. The actions they propose are not aimed at the American people; they’re aimed at those who have already radicalized. They know beforehand that masses of people won’t respond to the tactics they propose.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>They have not only given up on the masses but really have contempt for them. Because on top of all this do you know what else the ultralefts propose? They call for a general strike! They get up and say, “General Strike.” Only they don’t have the slightest hope whatsoever that it will come off.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Every last one of them who raises his hand to vote for a general strike knows it’s not going to happen. So what the hell do they raise their hands for? Because it’s part of the game. They play games, they play revolution, because they have no hope.</em></blockquote><p>The speech is a reflection on current events in 1970- and I think most people will have the basic familiarity to follow that context: the war in Vietnam coming to an end, and the anti-war and civil rights protests of the prior several years being the big concerns. A decent chunk of the speech is concerned with a large student strike in May 1970- which I think you can just accept as “a big protest” for the purposes of reading, but a little more detail <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Student_strike_of_1970">at Wikipedia</a> if you need it. A small section dives in to the 1968 Dem convention, and a spat Camejo has with other individuals like Tom Hayden. If you have issues navigating those few sentences- just assume Camejo is a leftist you like on Twitter, and Hayden is someone who says they’re a leftist but you and I know they’re actually a sellout.</p><p>Now, if you’re reading <strong>Liberalism…</strong> for the first time, or even re-reading it now, I think you’ll be struck with how present the entire piece feels. How did those boomers know what our problems were like?! It’s wild. He’s talking about a mass protest, and we had one too! He’s talking about how the establishment tried to limit and divide that protest using gimmicky class and race rhetoric to isolate it. Remember MSNBC doing that in May?!</p><blockquote><em>What did they say in the newspapers? “It’s terrible. America is divided. We have to come back together.” And then they started saying, “It’s too bad that our children are this way.” You see, it’s just the kiddies. It’s the generation gap. On television they say to the workers, “You’re older, and this strike isn’t for you. It’s just our kids, and we’ve got to try to understand them.”</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Or, “It’s a white strike. It has nothing to do with Black people. And it certainly has nothing to do with unions or workers!” That’s the general campaign they put on.</em></blockquote><p>Or his comments on Nixon’s decision on Cambodia and Vietnam. A system that seems to be responding to something, but not really yielding power or even admitting to what the pressure point was. The same obtuse machine we bang our heads against (maybe).</p><p>I think the reader will also instantly recognize his targets in discussing Liberalism and Ultraleftism. Camejo’s liberalism are more or less the Libs we know and love today. A convenient overlap! Ultraleftists may be a bit more controversial to spot. I think at times in online discourse, Marxist-Leninists and Maoists can get tagged as ULs, and certainly nobody on the left is going to self identify with Camejo’s definition- a liberal who’s having a panic attack. But I think you can see a recent trend of Ultraleftism in the past year for sure, growing even more after Bernie’s defeat in the primary. Calls for more radical, immediate, and often performative actions that end up being dead-on-arrival campaigns. The effort in February to organize a yellow-vest movement to ensure party delegates didn’t steal the nomination from Bernie on the convention floor. The March and April efforts to organize a left exit from the Democratic party and rally to Howie Hawkins. A summer tweeting about general strikes, and talking with certainty about how millions of unemployed and evicted people would be in the streets soon to join with BLM protestors.</p><p>But you can also recognize the trends of Mass Action that Camejo outlines in our recent history. Our efforts to organize to the local or community issues, and weave that together to a larger mass movement. Attempts to support and connect Anti-ICE protests and BLM to larger anti-capitalist struggles. Work to try and reinvigorate union efforts where we can find them. Getting people in motion.</p><blockquote><em>That is the big difference between the perspective of the ultralefts and our perspective, because we do want a general strike. We do want a real strike. We do believe you can win the workers, so therefore we don’t just raise our hands in games, we raise our hands for what really can be done, for what can begin to move masses of people.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>The independent mass action concept does not just mean demonstrations against the war. It’s a general strategy with many aspects to it.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>One aspect is to build a mass independent Black political party. It also means, for instance, organizing to mobilize masses of women against the institutions, social norms and practices that are used to oppress them. It’s a strategy that calls for doing things like building the Chicano Raza Unida Party, which is growing in the Southwest.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>This is the concept of getting people into motion, into action. Not talking down to them, but organizing actions which are able to give expression to the mass opposition to the policies of the ruling class, at the level of understanding that people have reached about what’s happening in this society. It’s the concept of bringing masses into motion, but at all times keeping the movement independent of the ruling class.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Now, what is the best way we can implement this orientation at this point? We follow a general organizational type strategy which is simply this. You get the issues around which people are moving against the government and create a unified movement around them, in order to maximize the numbers that will come into motion.</em></blockquote><p>I would say this was at least the high level strategy of DSA and much of the Berniecrat left since 2016. But 2020 has clearly shaken some faith. And perhaps rightfully so.</p><p><strong>2020- the year of Mass Action</strong></p><p>2020 saw the culmination of two campaigns in both the Bernie 2020 Presidential run as well as the Summer BLM protests- both of which I would identify as milestones on a Mass Action approach. Maybe readers will question that either of those campaigns are clear and good examples of Mass Action as Camejo describes it. I already have to hedge my language- in a sense I’d like to call each a Mass Action given their size…but Camejo’s term is a larger orientation to work and not a description for one campaign. Milestones isn’t part of Camejo’s terms, but I think it helps fit them in to the big picture. Also, I’ve seen pushback to calling the BLM protests a campaign- which is fair. It was in part a reactive event and goals were not clearly defined in advance. That said, I’d argue that just like the Bernie campaign, organizers had been working for several years in communities to prepare for such a moment, and as the uprising happened they quickly stepped in to help shape it.</p><p>That said, we should appreciate the scope of the effort and participation each had.</p><p>DSA and others spent a large amount of their time after Bernie’s 2016 loss indirectly laying the groundwork for his next Presidential campaign- dedicated M4A issues campaigns across the country, electing Berniecrat politicians at the state and even national level, finding what avenues it could to support teachers unions looking to strike or individual workers looking to organize a union, or working in solidarity with Women, Black, and Latino activists on programs. The campaign itself and Bernie’s unique credibility among the left drew these strings together almost immediately, and (rightly) boasted itself the grassroots campaign of 2020. One million people signed up to volunteer for Bernie by April 2019, and while certainly only a fraction of that number did volunteer to a great extent, the output of their effort was massive. Thousands bussed in and out of Iowa and New Hampshire alone to knock hundreds of thousands of doors. Millions of phones banked. $200,000,000 raised off small donors before the end. If you could build a time machine and send these numbers back to Camejo he’d probably think you were pulling his leg.</p><p>But in the end, the centrist candidates belatedly and quite clownishly coalesced around a fatigued old man who had the most inroads with older Black voters and White moderates, and in the course of <em>effectively a long weekend</em> put an end to Bernie 2020. Biden was gracious in victory, letting some Bernie aligned reps meet with centrists on a number of issues focus groups, producing platform recommendations that Biden presumably flushed down a toilet after use.</p><p>In the following months, the left stumbled itself into a second moment. The murder of George Floyd sparked protests in Minnesota that grew to engulf not only the US but even spread internationally. In July, <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/07/03/us/george-floyd-protests-crowd-size.html">the estimates ranged from 15 Million to 25 Million participants</a> in the protests, and protests sustained throughout the entire summer. As I noted above this event was reactive to the moment, but an army of BLM organizers who had cut their teeth in 2014/2015 and spent the last several years organizing further proved up to the task of marshalling and steering much of these efforts. Again sending these numbers back to Camejo and he would definitely know you were just joking. 20 Million?!</p><p>But after 4 months, what did we have to show for it? Several dozen more videos of cops brutalizing people. A few more dead. Police and their unions relatively untouched, a few politicians who made obvious shell games of their 2021 budgets to pretend to cater to the movement. A Democratic presidential candidate who derided the movement and promised $300M to cops once elected. Here in Chicago, our new Mayor who ran on being serious about police oversight reform offered a very straightforward “fuck you” to the protestors and left alder-people demanding a reduction in CPD’s budget.</p><p>In a way, the end of the BLM protests also included an extra blow. Electoral campaigns are subject to the whims and power of a hostile party, that’s simply an accepted risk for all the left’s efforts there. But street action is supposed to be as level a playing field as you can get, the fallback for when your more intricate plans fail, and the absolute expression of “the people won’t take it anymore.” The ultraleft did not get their unemployed marches or eviction actions, but even if they do finally come in January or February, shouldn’t we assume they will run aground as well?</p><p>Some obvious similarities that is driving our discontent:</p><ol><li>Neither campaign was without prelude, both had groundwork laid directly or indirectly over 4–5 years</li><li>Both campaigns, in terms of performance, were about as well executed as you can hope for. Neither flawless, but both better managed than a most video game releases these days</li><li>Despite the prep work, size, and execution, neither seemed to build clear and significant power for the left, nor did they deliver meaningful concessions from the establishment.</li></ol><p>Some participants will react and note that each built new organizers, and radicalized people, and moved opinion polls on issues such as M4A and Defund. All I’ll accept as true. But I doubt you truly feel satisfied with those outcomes, and with no obvious future ‘milestone’ in sight, commitment to the strategy is a bit of an act of faith.</p><p><strong>Reflections</strong></p><p>I think we need to be frank that the past year does not generate new faith in the Mass Action approach. I suspect the turns towards both despair and ultraleftism are being driven by an unspoken fear that Mass Action is not the answer, and there isn’t some obvious next strategy to move to. However, I think generally DSA and most of the organized Berniecrat left are still on the path of Mass Action- and we need to be clear and direct on selling people that this course of action is still not only the best of bad options, but that there are meaningful victories to be had.</p><p>An immediate response that comes up in the wake of the 2020 campaigns is simply “we need more”. We need to be more organized, we need to be larger. What if DSA had 200,000 members? What if 1,000,000 more people listened to Chapo Trap House? The assessment is not absurd, but I think people need to be careful when deploying that analysis; I don’t think there’s a political movement or ideology people encounter today that doesn’t claim its failures arise from it not being done at a big enough scale, for long enough. Skeptics are right to worry they’re being sold a line if they start hearing that. Also, these lines rarely seem to get specific about the where or how of getting bigger. And if you think about my numbers above, in some areas it’s hard to imagine getting bigger for those milestone campaigns. I could imagine another Bernie campaign that increases the number of volunteers, maybe, but I could only imagine Bernie pulling that off…and it’s clear this is the end of the road for his Presidential hopes. BUT also I cannot imagine the multiples of $200M that would need to be raised to both manage the kind of field organization we dreamed of, and also to combat the negative media people like Mike Bloomberg were able to buy in just a few months. Does $500M for a campaign sound possible? $1B?</p><p>The BLM numbers seem equally daunting in terms of “more”. It’s hard to account for what drove people to protests, and almost impossible to imagine we can promise to bring out 20M people again, let alone 30M or 40M or more. At best we can just hope things get really bad, and that the real badness of things gets people out. After all, that’s how this is supposed to work?</p><p>We weren’t organized enough. Does the audience know for sure what that means at this point? We weren’t militant enough. Outside of a lot of complaining on police radio some nights, it sure seemed like cops had more and more reserves of violence left in them. We didn’t read enough theory. Which theory did we need?</p><p>There’s a need for a positive and specific defense of Mass Action, and what we missed or what we learned. I can try to lay out a few possible thoughts but I warn people- just as much as I am ill read, I am also a limited and inexperienced organizer. If you listed the all the DSA members from best organizer to worst, I would likely come in around #84,998. At most, take below as points for better people to explain why they’re wrong.</p><p>One: we should be honest that our work from 2016 thru 2019 was itself still very limited and based on inexperience, and perhaps overread our accomplishments up to that point. One area here is our attempts to reconnect to Unions. There is a lot of great work being done by Union organizers and labor activists- but I think the larger Berniecrat movement may have convinced itself that so many unions endorsing Bernie spoke to a larger awakening and commitment than was (or is) really there. I think people began to think the Teachers Strikes of 2018 reflected a larger appetite for labor action across other trades that wasn’t there…or even that the Teachers Strikes themselves implied a consistent level of radicalism among teachers that’s maybe only present in a few locals like Chicago Teachers Union right now.</p><p>Two: our limited and disorganized approach to media means an uphill battle in defining ourselves versus being defined by the establishment. The insurgent left media that took off in podcasts and on YouTube in 2016 has to be appreciated in at least partly helping to keep younger Dems overwhelmingly pro-Bernie through 2019 and 2020, but it failed to have any voice in the legacy mass media channels of Cable News, Radio, or Newspapers that dominate with +50 audiences. And with the recent ‘Force the Vote’ campaign, we see the risks of a more or less unaccountable insurgent media that begins to believe it itself is a mass organization.</p><p>Three: We still struggle to articulate our successes- in particular our ability to get and then use power to deliver results for people. We are very good at showing people that things are bad. That we have some ideas on why it’s bad. That we have some policies you the voter will very much like. BUT why trust us? Did we ever get results? How are we not just the naïve doofuses the establishment has painted us as for decades? How do you convince people to participate in processes and institutions that have largely screwed them over (or they believe screwed them over) for most of their lives, just on a promise? You need either an incredible bond with them, or some tangible results.</p><p>Four: we need to better articulate what is meant by organized, and why we are not there yet. I think there’s general acknowledgement that there is a larger disorganized left that floats around, and perhaps confuse media consumption or social media participation as organization. Usually that’s contrasted with the organized DSA member, but we all know it’s perfectly possible to be a DSA member and not organized. And often left victories that clearly have to do with good leadership, good strategy, or leverage of power are attributed as ‘organizing victories’, which muddies the water. Centralizers have a vision of increased organization, do we need to go that route?</p><p>Five: this is not so much an observation on the past- but we will need to explicitly define the left coalition in a post-Bernie world, and put effort in to a visible strategic process. I think the desire in late spring for Bernie to effectively keep his campaign organization running reflects the anxiety in doing this- so long as we all operated under the Bernie masthead we could avoid certain conflicts that will eventually come up between unions, NGOs, and mass organizations.</p><p>Even a sympathetic reader may find the above points less than compelling, and I’m certainly in no position to direct the fixes. But I think we can at least articulate the frustration people are feeling without trying to dive in to the minutia of recent work, and miss the forest for the trees.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8a53ca2f6c60" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Marxist Electoral Theory]]></title>
            <link>https://crazydogspirit.medium.com/marxist-electoral-theory-3629abc6348e?source=rss-cbef9396978e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3629abc6348e</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Socialists for Pritzker]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 13 Apr 2020 18:33:03 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-04-13T18:33:03.133Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/576/1*u8eCmNZCinsC936GFktojw.jpeg" /><figcaption><a href="https://www.hubcityspokes.com/front-page-slideshow-news-petal/petal-mayor-marx-will-not-seek-re-election-2021">Marx will not seek re-election in 2021 …</a></figcaption></figure><p>As the Bernie post-mortems continue to pour in from good faith interlocutors, the term “Marxist Electoral Theory” has started to appear. <a href="https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2020/4/10/21214970/bernie-sanders-2020-lost-class-socialism?utm_campaign=zackbeauchamp&amp;utm_content=chorus&amp;utm_medium=social&amp;utm_source=twitter">Zach Beauchamp produced one in Vox</a> that annoyed everyone over the weekend, and <a href="https://washingtonmonthly.com/2020/04/11/leftist-policy-didnt-lose-marxist-electoral-theory-did/">David Atkins also produced one</a> that I don’t think anyone will bother to read. To be clear- I skimmed the start of Zach’s and got bored, and later saw a funny section from Sean Mcellwee. Maybe there’s something smart in either of those pieces, but I took a guess that it’s mostly just twitter args re-purposed to web-magazine articles, and I don’t need to re-read stuff like that. <a href="https://twitter.com/peterjgowan/status/1249720444887891970?s=20">Peter Gowan</a> and a handful of socialists have put some effort to explain what Marxist theory actually means, but I just want to try and cut to what people like Zach and David are really trying to get, even though they seem to not have the words.</p><p><strong>We’re talking about ‘getting votes’ theory (Campaign Strategy)</strong></p><p>These pieces usually start from and focus on a Bernie campaign speech line of “we will bring millions of new people in to the voting process.” Anyone is free to look up what electoral theory means on Wikipedia, and I think you’ll see it’s not the term they mean to use here. Electoral Theory, though, sounds very serious and smart and the kind of thing you’d learn in grad school, so I get why they use the term.</p><p>In reality, they’re just looking to talk about how a candidate gets enough votes to win an election. <a href="https://twitter.com/floridalease/status/1249715112656732167?s=20">@flordalease informed me that this is called “campaign strategy”,</a> and it sure seems like that’s the right term here. Maybe ‘campaign strategy’ isn’t as impressive a term though? Also it’d make the proclamations seem less serious. After all, campaigns fail all the time. In fact, at least ½ of all candidates lose their elections, according to one study. Usually we don’t say everyone’s campaign strategy has been proven wrong when they lose elections, or we would be down to no campaign strategies by now.</p><p>But back to Sanders- the issue seems to be particularly around the millions of new voters point.</p><p><strong>Was Bernie’s plan to ‘bring in millions of non-voters’?</strong></p><p>I think this is a bit contentious. He certainly said it in campaign speeches, which are the most real thing I can imagine.</p><p>On the other hand, it might be helpful to consider what his campaign was actually doing. Bernie’s rallies seemed geared towards a younger, general audience- musical acts, younger activists and popular supporters like AOC, a ‘concert-like’ atmosphere. His digital operations were well funded and considered top-of-class, and despite the success of both parties leveraging email fundraising strategies to raise money from older voters, I guess we chalk this up as another youth-targeting effort.</p><p>Sanders’ TV media was relatively in line with non-marxist-electoral-theory campaigns though. The ads were generally positive, straight-forward, and targeted towards a ‘regular’ political commercial audience. If anyone was trying for the “Marxist theory” in this space, it was Steyer and Bloomberg, both noted comrades. Both sunk hundreds of millions to make sure no corner of the TV media market did not get asked to vote for them.</p><p>But most central to the Bernie campaign was his volunteer effort- the on the ground organizers, the door knockers, the phone callers, the texters. This is where the campaign spent, and this was the particularly unique component of the Sanders campaign as an actual operation. And here the argument hits a wall. All of these person-to-person outreach activities were built off of VAN. VAN’s database is of registered voters, and the local organizers prioritized registered Democrats as first targets for any area. And as any volunteer can tell you- the older, more affluent voters were the easiest to get in front of. Simply put- Bernie’s wholesale volunteer effort was targeted towards existing Democrats, particularly older ones.</p><p>Also, Bernie’s endorsement strategy seems a counter-point. Bernie’s focus on union and grass-roots political implies people already engaged with politics. And while some orgs like Sunrise are predominantly younger activists, Democracy for America and Progressive Democrats for America are old W Bush era hold-overs. I understand to some people the only endorsement Bernie got was Joe Rogan, but I’d encourage political journalists to check out a Wikipedia page on this topic.</p><p>Futher, if we loop back to the material reality of campaign rhetoric- we should probably also discuss another one of <a href="https://twitter.com/BernieSanders/status/1232127501826129921?s=20">Bernie’s refrain</a>:</p><p><em>Is raising the minimum wage to $15/hour radical?</em></p><p><em>Is making sure kids can get a higher education radical?</em></p><p><em>Is making health care a right like every other major country radical? Is addressing the existential threat of climate change radical?</em></p><p><em>The American people don’t think so.</em></p><p>I remember Bernie saying this to an audience of Fox News, but also to MSNBC audiences and Dem debate and townhall audiences.</p><p>Was Bernie’s campaign strategy to bring in millions of new voters who believed the above, to counter the existing Democratic voters who do not agree with it? Or was his campaign strategy to convince existing Democratic voters that his policies are good and they all agree with and like them, so they should vote for him? In the realm of campaign rhetoric, it seems Bernie Sanders was committing a logical fallacy. Perhaps Jake Tapper should have called him out on that.</p><p><strong>What was Bernie’s plan? Did it work? <em>(Convince Dems to support his policies, and it seems like yes?)</em></strong></p><p>So, did Bernie’s campaign strategy work?</p><p>Since we’re sitting here with Joe Biden as the presumptive nominee, it didn’t.</p><p>HOWEVER (I saw, turning around quickly to surprise you), there does seem to be something there. As unrewarding as “defined the debate” victories feel, it should be remarked that at least part of the reason Dem voters went with Biden is due to the fact that they generally assume all Democratic candidates have the same politics and policies. You might even say that pushing that type of thinking is one of the purposes of websites like Vox, where the belief that ‘everyone wants universal coverage, there’s just a disagreement on how to get there’ is carved in granite above Ezra Kline’s bed. Centrist and progressive media spent quite a lot of energy convincing people that Joe Biden’s platform would be in fact the most progressive platform in history (beating out Hillary 2016!), and how unfair it was for Sunrise Movement to give Joe’s climate plan an F, or how exit polls in states Bernie lost still showed overwhelming support for M4A really doesn’t mean anything…</p><p>In short, to help Biden win, the party had to present Joe Biden as not really all that different from Bernie. If Biden is basically just the same as Bernie, then I guess Bernie’s strategy both did not work AND did work?</p><p>Also as an aside- even on the terms of Zach and David’s complaint, the argument that Bernie did not bring in millions of new and young voters seems specious. You can argue it was not enough to overcome other voting blocks, but even in this ‘disastrous’ 2020 campaign, Bernie was the overwhelming choice of young voters, independent voters, and first-time primary voters. Add in to these numbers the young first-time voters who came out for him in 2016 and then again in 2020, and it sure seems like he brought in millions of new voters. My guess is the argument against this is had Bernie not run, these people simply would have shown up voted for someone else in the primaries? Their innate voter-ness would have brought them to the polls?</p><p><strong>What’s the non-Marxist plan for getting votes?</strong></p><p>But if all that is the Bernie campaign strategy, what was every other candidate’s strategy? Will someone articulate Biden’s? Or Warren’s?</p><p>Someone can try to argue an answer to this, but I take it that the only other strategy on the table, at least at a state and national level, is the one of the <a href="https://newrepublic.com/article/83086/democratic-leadership-council-requiem-dlc">Democratic Leadership Council</a>, <a href="https://theweek.com/articles/700846/democrats-stop-listening-rahm-emanuel">Rahm Emmanuel</a>, and <a href="https://www.reddit.com/r/SandersForPresident/comments/5q7r0a/for_every_bluecollar_democrat_we_lose_in_western/">Hillary Clinton</a>: Keep Black voter turnout high, keep the lefties in line, and increase your share of White suburban voters. Or, to focus on the delta, bring in suburban Republicans.</p><p><strong>Does it work?</strong></p><p>Others have hammered this point enough, and I think you can tell from the list above that no, it doesn’t work. Instead, Dem fortures have mostly shifted due to wave elections and responses to economic downturns. And even then, their Presidential victories have relied on an unprecedented conservative third party campaign, and a generational political talent being in the right place at the right time.</p><p>Leftists go over these points a lot, as well as how all these strategies have made the party incapable of passing their stated preferred policies, and provide bi-partisan cover to pass Republican policies, so I won’t re-hash that here.</p><p><strong>Does ‘getting votes’ matter? (yes, obviously)</strong></p><p>But one point that I think is less focused on, is the overall need for a better vote-getting strategy <em>if </em>we are committed to the current system, which centrists and progressives are.</p><p>In the run-up to the 2018 mid-terms, smart people noted that the <a href="https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2018/3/27/17144198/gerrymandering-brennan-center-report-midterms-democrats-house-2018">Democrats could have won the popular vote by 10 points overall and still not taken the House</a>. <a href="https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/2020-election/how-trump-could-lose-5-million-votes-still-win-2020-n1031601">Trump could lose the popular vote this year by 5 million and still win the Electoral College</a>. And let’s not even get in to the obstacles of re-taking the Senate.</p><p>Democrats will be quick to point out this is due to gerrymandering and the Electoral College and the general absurdities of the Constitution. Agreed!</p><p>Dems may also point to 2016 and say their loss was really down to ~100,000 voters in 3 states. Also Agreed!</p><p>But is there a plan to do more than narrowly win 1 branch of government and squat on it in hopes of holding back the tide of conservative policy? Is there a plan to actually become a party that is in charge of government?</p><p>There is no strategy being presented to deal with this. The courts have been set for a generation thanks to Mitch McConnell, and the only chance for a Constitutional Convention would be if Republicans permitted it.</p><p>Unless centrists want to start talking about marching on Washington and barricading government buildings, the only path forward is to radically change the dynamics of the electorate. If you cannot offer that, then we are all in a managed retreat. The Biden 2020 campaign is just grabbing on to another piece of flotsam until the 2022 Republican wave retakes the House, and they squat until they can yet against win a Presidential election and begin passing their full agenda again.</p><p>To be a dominant political party, the Democrats would need to turn out 75–80M voters in Presidential election years, and probably +60M in midterms. The centrist strategy to pick up those extra 10M voters? Try and capture some marginal members of the other, smaller, better organized party.</p><p><strong>What are the actual implications of the non-marxist plan?</strong></p><p>Furthermore, there’s a rather dark side to the centrist campaign strategy. Based on being stuck around Democratic politics and pundits for several years, it seems like these beliefs now structure party thinking:</p><p>· Interest in voting is not universal, pursuing voter enfranchisement is mostly performative</p><p>· Interest in voting is not driven by policy or politics</p><p>· What makes people eventually become voters is not known</p><p>· Spending time trying to turn non-voters to voters is useless</p><p>· Youth voters do not matter, either in the election they are voting in now or in terms of the party’s future</p><p>· Trying to get infrequent voters to vote regularly is useful, and done through yelling at them</p><p>· Self-IDed Independent voters are…?</p><p>These don’t seem like healthy political thoughts. In fact they seem more anti-electoral than the Socialists’ who just lost.</p><p><strong>In Conclusion</strong></p><p>To close out, I’ll simply renew my call for some think pieces on what Elizabeth Warren’s campaign strategy was, and whether it was obliterated by the 2020 primary. What was Pete Buttigeig’s, and was it obliterated? Kamala Harris?</p><p>Finally, what is Joe Biden’s? Is it in trouble? This morning, <a href="https://twitter.com/Nate_Cohn/status/1249675353586622465?s=20">Nate Cohn dropped a piece about Biden’s early polling numbers</a>, and there sure seem to be some familiar points coming out of it. Quotes:</p><p>· National polls show virtually no change among white voters with or without college degree over the last four years.</p><p>· Trump’s persistent strength among white voters without a degree means his relative advantage in the white, working class battleground states persists as well.</p><p>· Biden’s declining strength among nonwhite voters as a whole is the growing non-black share of nonwhite voters. Non-black nonwhite voters (Hisp/Asian, etc) tend to be more competitive than black voters and are a larger share of new registrants</p><p>· Monmouth recently showed Republicans likeliest to say they were almost certain to vote. CNN has far more GOPers saying they’re very enthusiastic about voting</p><p>But I’m sure it’s nothing to worry about.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3629abc6348e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Thoughts on a Bernie 2020 Post-Mortem (Twitter Arguments)]]></title>
            <link>https://crazydogspirit.medium.com/thoughts-on-a-bernie-2020-post-mortem-twitter-arguments-3f48e2347958?source=rss-cbef9396978e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3f48e2347958</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Socialists for Pritzker]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 08 Apr 2020 20:29:27 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-04-08T20:29:27.613Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Thoughts on a Bernie 2020 Post-Mortem (Twitter Arguments)</p><p>With every professional stuck in quarantine and needing to take their minds off of the death swallowing the country, there’s sudden need for the fun and relaxing pastime of arguing about politics. The last few days have been focused on demanding a post-mortem of the Bernie Sanders campaign (note: this was drafted the day before Bernie decided to end his campaign, and I’m not in the mood to re-write much), mostly coming from entirely good faith people like Vox writers and the people who bought the Big Structural Bailey balloon.</p><p>Below isn’t meant to be a complete post-mortem, in part because I’m not that smart. But I am seeing some points floating about that seem fundamentally wrong, and I’d like to squash them in hopes that good analysis eventually comes about. My particular frustration is a lot of these arguments seem to rely on forgetting facts as they were only 2 months ago. So let’s go:</p><p><strong>Bernie only had a plan to win a third of the voters</strong></p><p>This seems pretty silly on its face. Joe Biden spent 8 months in the lead in 2019 at ~30% of the polls, and nobody seemed to wonder if he had a plan to win the other 70% of the party. In fact even now there doesn’t seem to be much concern about how he’ll win the remaining 35–40% of the party going in to the GE. Why?</p><p>That’s because Joe’s plan to unite the party (then and now) is the same as Bernie’s plan was: win the primary. And the plan to win the primary was to win Iowa, and then New Hampshire, and then Nevada, and then maybe South Carolina, and then win a lot of states on Super Tuesday. At some point the fact that a candidate has won a lot of primaries, has high favorability among the party, and is running a functioning campaign has usually meant the party comes together.</p><p>If this plan wouldn’t work for Bernie, it seems like it might not work for Joe, either? And if that plan isn’t working, it would be because there’s a real fracture within the party that has been festering for years now. Maybe someone should look in to this.</p><p><strong>Bernie needed to be meaner to Biden</strong></p><p>This is an arg coming from the left, and my question every time I see it is- when? When was this supposed to happen? Was it supposed to happen in 2019 when nobody was paying attention, the field was full, and Castro, Booker, and Harris all bombed out trying this? Was it supposed to happen after Super Tuesday, when it was clear older Dems were just going to accept whatever baggage they got with Biden? Or maybe it could have happened in February, when Biden checked out after Iowa and everyone was worrying about Buttigieg in New Hampshire and Bloomberg after that?</p><p>There was a brief moment I think when ‘taking on Biden’ could have been deployed- the last 2 weeks before the Iowa Caucus. Sadly, for some reason Bernie had to deal with some very absurd sexism claims at that exact moment. I wish I could identify how that came about or who was responsible for that. Unrelated, this was also supposed to be the moment that Elizabeth Warren was going to make hay about Biden’s awful work for banks on bankruptcy legislation. Also this oddly didn’t happen. Not sure why.</p><p>But even with that foul up, Biden crashed and burned in Iowa. And in New Hampshire. People were amazed at how David Sirota had managed to do that mostly through twitter, and voters in both states seemed to recognize that Biden was not doing well, personally. Biden “fell back” to South Carolina, and in reality mostly disappeared for 2 weeks.</p><p>Another problem I have with this argument is that those offering it usually also believe that Dem institutions and media- particularly cable news- was opposed to Bernie. I think if you believe this, then I don’t know how much the particular rhetoric of Bernie matters when you can’t control what gets passed along to the audience you need to reach? Biden seemed to be hurt in Iowa because reporters decided to actually ask Biden questions. In South Carolina, they stopped doing that. Before the 3/17 primaries, Joe went in to a 2-hour debate and repeatedly lied about and obfuscated his record on Social Security, Bankruptcy, and the Iraq War. What was the coverage after that?</p><p>This generally just strikes me as West Wing speeches but for left-Twitter.</p><p><strong>Bernie needed to emphasize that he could beat Trump more</strong></p><p>This also seems like a strange arg to me, since “Bernie beats Trump” was pretty well integrated in to all the campaign’s volunteer materials several weeks before Iowa, and in terms of ads/media it was about as prominent a point as any other campaign except Bloomberg’s, and only then because of the volume of ads Bloomberg was putting out.</p><p>This also feels like it conflicts with any take that says institutions and media was an obstacle for Bernie. Biden’s campaign message was something along the lines of “I’ll beat Trump like a drum” going in to Iowa. The only reason I know this is because campaign reporters posted it on Twitter. I certainly don’t know if anyone nationally got that message, because Biden did not have a particularly large ad spend thru Super Tuesday. So how did voters decide Biden could beat Trump? I guess through earned media, although even there I’m a bit dubious. But if Biden’s electability case didn’t come from his campaign- and in fact his campaign up to SC was signaling it couldn’t beat Trump- then what’s the way in which Bernie could signal it? Maybe he should have lost Iowa and New Hampshire.</p><p><strong>Bernie’s team needed a plan to deal with the center coalescing around 1 candidate</strong></p><p>Oh how everyone’s tune has changed! Again only I seem to remember the crazy days of January, when everyone was demanding that every candidate drop out!</p><p>This gets floated as an open ended question of sorts, and I’m not really sure what people expect as an answer. Maybe it would have been helpful for people to understand exactly how old and affluent the primary voter usually is, to understand the uphill battle Bernie was going to face.</p><p>But also, I think it’s important to remember that the ‘coalesce around Biden’ plan wasn’t really guaranteed to work. Bloomberg was still running on Super Tuesday, and there was a chance he could have split the center vote more than Sanders/Warren did theirs (I certainly did not expect Warren to perform as well as she did in Texas, by the way). Also, Biden wasn’t exactly the top choice of older voters for most of the campaign- they generally wanted someone younger, which is why at times Buttigeig, Klobuchar, and Harris seemed to hold on to a chuck of that center vote. The fact that the plan worked was itself a bit of a miracle.</p><p>This question reads like “what’s your plan if your opponent throws a successful hail mary at the end of the 4th quarter?” You lose the game.</p><p><strong>Old Suburban Moderates &amp; Institutions</strong></p><p>I think at this point it’s clear I’m mostly sympathetic to the outside-forces analysis, that party and media institutions were so firmly against Sanders it hamstrung his ability to extend his coalition further to an extent nobody had predicted. The question you have to grapple with is really- how could Bernie have captured a much larger chunk of the +45 voters? If he had managed to secure above 40% of those voters, as opposed to the ~25% he seems to have, I believe the numbers- regardless of voter race or gender or anything else- play out that he stays in the lead in delegates.</p><p>There’s 2 ways to look at this I think- bottom-up and top-down.</p><p>The bottom-up approach is to ask was Bernie’s voter outreach able to get in front of enough of these voters, and make the case? This is I think the uncomfortable question for the campaign- because building the bottom-up volunteer door-knocking and phone-banking campaign was where the Sanders’ campaign money went to in large part. In fact a lot of us took pride in the number of hours we spent volunteering for Bernie, how many doors we knocked and how many calls we made before Iowa. In theory, these efforts should have put volunteers in front of these exact voters, more so than unregistered &amp; independent voters, young voters who move around or are out of the house, or lower income voters with tenuous housing situations. The campaign itself has data here it needs to consider, but it would seem either this method did not get in front of enough voters ever, or the case they made wasn’t strong enough, or something else. At least, if you take this approach.</p><p>The top-down approach is to assume that these voters are locked in to the kind of ‘electability consideration” loop that <a href="https://newrepublic.com/article/153723/democrats-created-electability-monster">Alex Pareene discussed in his New Republic article</a> months back. In this case, no amount of doors knocked or the perfect volunteer script mattered- these voters are just waiting for signals from some authority on high. The recent Gallup poll on media trust also seems to lend credibility to this (and also, I’ll note, create a lot of concern for the General Election, where Independent voters matter a whole lot more).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/720/1*FPWhtb8rFiwGQPwfO5DE5A.png" /></figure><p>Is there something Bernie could have done to perform better with those voters, assuming they’re reliant on institutional signals that they can/should vote for someone? Off the top of my head, he had to do things that would make institutional Dem party powers either more receptive to him or at least less hostile. Some things that could have worked:</p><p>· Not run in 2016</p><p>· Make a very big deal of “joining” the Democratic party</p><p>· Kissing Nancy Pelosi and Chuck Schumer on the lips</p><p>· Applauding Trump’s SoTUs</p><p>· Stop advocating for M4A, and a handful of other programs</p><p>· Not run in 2020</p><p>I don’t know if any of these would have actually worked though. I do know that it would have meant he either would not have had his current voting bloc, or he would have disenchanted that bloc well before February.</p><p><strong>One Idea</strong></p><p>So this all feels hopeless.</p><p>But there is one non-ridiculous suggestion I’d make on what Bernie could have done. He could have not spent as much on field work as he did, and instead backed a big money truck up to MSNBC, CNN, and a few other institutions, and bought their friendship…or at least their silence. I don’t know if June/July of 2019 would have been too late a point to start that work, and I don’t know if he would have just ended up in a bidding war against Bloomberg, Steyer, and a number of PACs, but that at least seems like the most direct answer to improving performance among older Dem voters.</p><p>More generally, if you want to compete in the Democratic primary, you will need to disrupt, neutralize, or replace these institutions that can drive voter preference away from you. Since I think this could be read as “post more”, be nicer to the writers at Vox, or trying to do Adbusters culture jamming, I’ll try to be a bit more specific:</p><p>· The Democrats do not have any direct control over mass media institutions, it’s important to remember that. Cable news, radio, and local TV and newsprint are owned and managed by Republicans. The party has been happy to leverage these as their media outlets, and the average Dem voter has been subjected to a weekly cycle of celebrating news media as heroes and then complaining about that same media for “failing” to cover Trump correctly.</p><p>· The closest the Democrats have to in-house media is the Pod Save network and similar projects from ex-Obamaites…with Pod Save clocking in at 1.5 million listeners an episode.</p><p>· Meanwhile, the left has been slowly piecing together a media infrastructure over the past few years. Its reach is even more limited, and frustrations with the Bernie campaign likely risk its expansion, but it is there.</p><p>A few weeks back, Nathan Robinson of Current Affairs floated the idea of a left cable new channel. Everyone mostly laughed at the idea because no Twitter leftist is going to start watching cable news. But if your goal is to get in front of older Dems, it’s not the worst suggestion. Sam Seder’s long belief that there’s an audience still out there in radio for liberal/left programming also is worth exploring. As Steve Harvey used to say, act like a socialist but think like a capitalist.</p><p><strong>Some other, miscellaneous points in lieu of a conclusion</strong></p><p>· Despite what idiots would like to tell you, building a voting bloc that’s still holding at about 35% even when the primary seems as over as it does right now, is an accomplishment. If Libertarians managed to do this in the Republican party, we’d never hear the end of it. Evangelicals made their entrance in to the Republican party with less as well, and now they basically run the country. There’s an entire section that could be in here about how ridiculous I find the “Bernie regressed from 2016” arguments, but I suspect this piece is already too long.</p><p>· That being said, leftists should not assume this will hold together or somehow simply age-replace the older conservative Dems. Demographics is Destiny thinking has poisoned the Democratic party for years, and leftists should not start drinking the kool-aid. Whatever this coalition is, it’s going to take work to keep it going.</p><p>· There will be a lot of pressure to declare the left’s electoral project over and dead now. I can assure you most of those voices are both dumb and your enemy in this fight. The history of the left as a whole is about running in to walls, and usually standing in front of a firing squad for trying. Getting owned online by people with globe emojis for a few weeks is a pretty small consequence of failing. There’s probably another whole piece for someone to write about the current state of labor-organizing and labor-radicalizing, community organizing, and so on. These are all projects worth pursuing, but nobody has yet figured out the magical of programmatic organizing that regularly brings about socialism.</p><p>· <em>Actually</em> there are two well documented route to communism: get your country savaged in a World War, or get your country colonized by a distant and brutal imperial power. Anyone interested in these should hit me up :)</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3f48e2347958" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>