<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by CRWStrategy Ethnic Media on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by CRWStrategy Ethnic Media on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@crwstrategy?source=rss-b9dd790fd35b------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 12:19:59 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@crwstrategy/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Words Matter: Affirmative Action and Chinese Americans]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@crwstrategy/words-matter-affirmative-action-and-chinese-americans-45a5c12b7d73?source=rss-b9dd790fd35b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/45a5c12b7d73</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[affirmative-action]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[prop-16]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[14th-amendment]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[asian-american]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[chinese-american]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[CRWStrategy Ethnic Media]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 13 Oct 2020 13:58:16 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-10-13T16:53:42.879Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>By Steven Chen, Founding Partner, CRW Strategy</em></p><p>The 14th Amendment, intended to prevent laws that discriminate against people of color, stated that any law must treat all ethnic groups equally. Unfortunately, due to its wording, it can and has been used by some people to fight efforts intended to help people of color. But we still need affirmative action.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/620/1*lRMdGmab376oT_37xIY28w.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Editor’s note: </strong>In 2014, many first-generation immigrants from mainland China mounted a fierce campaign against a California statewide measure to restore race-conscious admissions in public colleges and universities. Since then, they have viewed affirmative action as the Sword of Damocles aimed at Chinese Americans and have embarked on a long battle against policies that take race into account. So, what is affirmative action and what does it really mean for Chinese Americans? This article was originally <a href="https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/xDoGEJ5DzUzR3wDLye26qg">published in Chinese </a>and the translation is below.</p><p><strong>Is the United States a country in which everyone is born equal?</strong></p><p>In 1776, the U.S. Declaration of Independence solemnly declared that “all men are created equal” as a founding principle of the new nation that would become the United States of America. However, for a very long time, people were not at all treated equally. Take voting rights as an example. In 1870, one hundred years after the birth of our nation, the 15th Amendment finally granted Black men the right to vote. Even so, governments at multiple levels in the United States continued to use various tactics to disqualify the voting rights of Black people. Women, including White women, had to wait another seventy years for voting rights to be conferred by the 19th Amendment, enacted in 1920.</p><p>Maybe, when the founding fathers of the United States penned “all men are created equal,” they were really thinking of White males. However, words matter. It is this magnificent phrase “all men are created equal” that has allowed the United States to go forth on the road of achieving equality for all. However, this road has been long and treacherous; many people even paid the price of equality with their lives. To this day, the United States is still far from being a country where no one faces discrimination.</p><p>To understand where we are now, we need to go back even farther. After Columbus discovered the New World, many White settlers from Europe began to colonize the Americas. After hundreds of years of colonization and wars, the Native American population was decimated, and North America became dominated by White people. Meanwhile, the United States trafficked a large number of African people to the United States as slaves both before and after the founding of the nation. However, slavery as a system directly contradicted widely held norms of human rights at that time. Further, the United States had declared that everyone should be equal. By 1804, the northern states of the U.S. had abolished slavery, but southern states still firmly defended the practice, relying on the labor of Black enslaved peoples for their plantation-based economy. Tensions between the North and South intensified, leading to the outbreak of an unprecedented, bloody Civil War in 1861. Over the course of just four years, more than 600,000 people were killed in the midst of war, accounting for 2% of the population at that time.</p><p>Soon after Union victory which brought the end of the Civil War, the United States passed the Thirteenth (abolition of slavery), Fourteenth (civil rights and equal protection) and Fifteenth (voting rights for all men) Amendments to the Constitution. Although aimed at the rights and interests of recently liberated Black Americans, due to language the law used, these constitutional amendments also cover other people of color. Among them, the Fourteenth Amendment, adopted in 1868, contained an Equal Protection Clause, stating that all persons, regardless of race, should be treated equally by the law. Therefore, the Fourteenth Amendment has become the most important law in the United States against racial discrimination.</p><p><strong>The Fourteenth Amendment Sidelined, Black Americans Subordinate Again</strong></p><p>After the Civil War, enslaved people in the South were liberated, becoming free men and women. Under the jurisdiction of the Union during the Reconstruction era, Black people in the South could own land and farms and they gained the right to vote. Some Black Americans won elections and became lawmakers. The three amendments passed at that time further protected the rights of Black people, dramatically changing their overall political and economic status, especially for those in the South. But these fundamental improvements did not last long, as the federal government soon compromised and withdrew from control over the southern states. The Southern states ended the period known as Reconstruction and many passed state and local laws mandating racial segregation and supporting discrimination known as “Jim Crow” laws. These laws allowed White political and social dominance in the South for generations. In the North, selective enforcement of the law institutionalized racial inequality as well.</p><p>To circumvent the constraints of the constitutional amendments, and in some ways following the lead of Northern states, Southern states passed many laws that did not mention race explicitly but were designed to disadvantage and applied selectively against Black people. For example, some required that citizens must pass a literacy test to qualify to vote, unless their grandfather held the right to vote (“grandfather clauses”). Although such a regulation did not explicitly prevent Black Americans from voting, it had the effect of nullifying the right to vote for the vast majority of Black people, due to the fact that not many Black people were educated at the time and no Black people had grandfathers who had held the right to vote. Other laws stipulated that people who did not have the right to vote were prohibited from serving as jurors, which disqualified the vast majority of Black people from being jurors.</p><p>Legal segregation and Jim Crow laws clearly violate the Fourteenth Amendment. However, in 1896, the Supreme Court ruled that “separate but equal” facilities did not violate the Fourteenth Amendment, legalizing policies of racial segregation such as disallowing people of color from sharing schools and other public facilities with whites. Black people and other people of color had once again become subordinates and the 14th Amendment failed to provide protection against racial discrimination.</p><p><strong>The Civil Rights Movement</strong></p><p>World War II was an important turning point for African Americans. Wartime efforts required a tremendous amount of manpower for both frontline soldiers and military industries back home. To encourage people of different ethnicities to participate, President Roosevelt signed Executive Order 8802 in 1941, prohibiting racial discrimination in the defense industry. During that time, a series of anti-racial discrimination policies were introduced, leading to a large number of Black Americans participating in military service for the nation. Before World War II, there were only about 4,000 Black soldiers in the United States. By the end of the war, the number of Black soldiers had increased to 1.2 million.</p><p>World War II ended in 1945. After defeating fascist powers, the most racial discriminatory regimes in the world, Black soldiers returned home to severe discrimination, despite their service to this country. These Black soldiers later became an important force in the civil rights movement, which would last for more than ten years from 1954 to 1968.</p><p>The most famous leader of the Civil Rights movement is Dr. Martin Luther King. This movement also received strong support from people of other ethnicities pursuing equitable treatment and justice in the U.S., including Whites, Jews, and Asian Americans, and others.</p><p>In 1954, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in <em>Brown v. Board of Education of Topeka</em> that the doctrine of “separate but equal” violated the Fourteenth Amendment, restoring the amendment’s power against racial discrimination. Following this huge victory, many pro-segregation laws and regulations were abolished. At last, Black people and other people of color could legally attend the same schools, share the same beaches and swimming pools with White people, and no longer be forced to sit at the back of buses. The Civil Rights Act of 1964 and the Voting Rights Act of 1965 overturned the remaining overtly racially discriminatory laws.</p><p>To this day, different levels of governments in the United States can no longer adopt laws that discriminate between different ethnic groups. On the surface, Black Americans and other people of color have the same rights as Whites under law. But this does not reflect reality, because a law that does not explicitly mention ethnicity can still favor or disfavor different ethnic groups. Many of these laws still exist today. Such laws are often detrimental to the people of color because those laws are normally written and approved by White people.</p><p><strong>The Origin of Affirmative Action</strong></p><p>In addition to laws more covertly disadvantage groups that have historically faced discrimination, people of color in the United States face two other major challenges. The first is that many people, Whites and even people of color, hold deeply ingrained prejudice against people of color, whether malicious or subconscious in intent. When people who hold racial biases, including unconscious biases, lead companies, schools, and government agencies, it is often difficult for people of color to be admitted, hired, and promoted. Second, historical discrimination and disenfranchisement has had harmful, long term effects on the socioeconomic position of people of color, which create competitive disadvantages compared with Whites.</p><p>Three major barriers to success for the majority of the people of color, even after the repeal of overtly racially discriminatory laws, remain: laws that advantage Whites over non-Whites, even if not overtly; deeply rooted prejudices; and competitive disadvantages that have accumulated over time.</p><p>The marginalization of people of color is a threat to the stability and advancement of the country at large. The United States needs to do something to address this issue. But there is a dilemma. The 14th Amendment, intended to prevent laws that discriminate <em>against </em>people of color, by clearly stating that any law must treat all ethnic groups equally, can also be interpreted to prohibit laws aimed at <em>helping </em>people of color.</p><p>In the 1960s, the United States government enacted policies and guidelines to address racial and gender discrimination in the form of Executive Orders. These policies aimed to ensure that disadvantaged groups truly had opportunities to participate fully in U.S. social, economic and civic life. The most famous of these are Executive Order №10925, signed by President Kennedy in 1961, and Executive Order №11246, signed by President Johnson in 1965. Later, many states issued similar administrative orders. Together, these kinds of policies and guidelines are referred to as “affirmative action.” Affirmative action means taking concrete, proactive steps to fight against racial and gender discrimination and to help disadvantaged racial and gender groups if needed. The official Chinese translation of “affirmative action” is “Equal Rights Law,” because it helps improve the chances of fair treatment for disadvantaged groups, including ethnic Chinese Americans.</p><p>President Kennedy’s Executive Order is instructive. It states that federal contractors should “take affirmative action to ensure that applicants are employed, and that employees are treated during employment, without regard to their race, color, religion, sex or national origin.” The key phrase here is “taking affirmative (proactive) action.” Taking proactive steps requires understanding the context of an individual’s ethnicity, gender, etc. to ensure that they are not discriminated against. In some cases, taking concrete and proactive action means providing training and other assistance to women and people of color to better ensure that they will be able to compete with others. On its face, affirmative action could be read to violate the principle of equal treatment of all races required by the Fourteenth Amendment. Therefore, affirmative action has been challenged by opponents since the very beginning.</p><p><strong>The Impact of Affirmative Action on Different Groups</strong></p><p>The implementation of affirmative action has brought great improvement for women and minorities. Government agencies, schools, and even private companies have begun to seriously consider whether they have intentionally or unintentionally discriminated against qualified women and minorities. The government has also launched training programs targeting women and minorities. Through years of hard work and more robust support from public policies, minorities and women have emerged in many fields originally dominated by White males.</p><p>Chinese Americans have benefited from affirmative action greatly. When the affirmative action was implemented, Chinese Americans had just emerged from the shadow of the Chinese Exclusion Act, which passed in 1882 and was not repealed until 1943. During the period of the Chinese Exclusion Act, Chinese Americans were among the most discriminated against ethnic groups in the US. As a result, they were largely engaged in occupations such as working in laundries, Chinese restaurants, and as domestic servants. For those who were lucky enough to enter and graduate from elite colleges, it was often difficult to find jobs related to their professional training and many ended up in the same occupational niches as less educated Chinese Americans.</p><p>Since the implementation of affirmative action, job opportunities in the professional sector, including in engineering, medicine, law, science, government, and universities became available to Chinese Americans. That is why older generations of Chinese Americans strongly support affirmative action programs. Established in 1969, Chinese for Affirmative Action is one of the many organizations that supports affirmative action.</p><p>Thanks to affirmative action, the proportion of ethnic minorities and women in universities and various jobs has increased significantly. It may appear to some that White males were the victims of affirmative action. But this is not necessarily true since the rise of minorities and women has also led to an overall expansion of the economy. This creates more opportunities for White males as well.</p><p>Affirmative action has the potential of providing an upward channel for all ethnic groups, genders, and classes in the United States, laying the foundation for the stability and progress of American society. For that reason, many states in the United States have implemented affirmative action.</p><p>However, there are still many people who believe that affirmative action is unfair. They have been working hard to eliminate affirmative action policies completely or to reduce the scope and the degree to which affirmative action can be implemented</p><p>For example, in <em>University of California v. Bakke</em> in 1978, the Supreme Court ruling maintained the legitimacy of affirmative action, but it outlawed the use of racial quotas, which means that no upper or lower numerical limits can be set for any racial group in education and employment.</p><p>After several Supreme Court decisions, the scope and methods by which affirmative action is allowed have been severely restricted, and its effectiveness has been gradually reduced as a result. However, to this day, affirmative action still plays an important role in the United States, and most states and many institutions and private companies continue to implement it.</p><p><strong>California’s Proposition 209</strong></p><p>In 1996, about thirty years after affirmative action was introduced, the status of women and minorities in California had greatly improved. Ethnic and gender diversity in various fields in California was showing good momentum. For example, the proportion of students who were ethnic minorities at University of California, Berkeley had reached 64.4%, and the proportion of Asians was as high as 39.6% in 1996.</p><p>At that time, some people felt that the dominance of White men was undermined. California State University anthropologist Glynn Custred and Tom Wood, another academic, proposed the California Civil Rights Initiative, later known as Proposition 209 (“Prop 209”). California’s Prop 209 “prohibits the state from discriminate against or grant preferential treatment on the basis of race, sex, color, ethnicity, or national origin in the operation of public employment, public education, and public contracting”. Therefore, Prop 209 banned the use of affirmative action involving race or gender in California. It basically asserted that women and people of color have to compete with White men on their own, even if they are facing implicit racial and gender discrimination. On the surface, Prop 209 seems to be fair to everyone. However, its real purpose was to prohibit policies that would benefit women and people of color.</p><p>Prop 209 passed, with 54.55% of voters in favor and 45.45% against. Exit polls conducted by the Los Angeles Times showed that 61% of Asians, 74% of Black people, 76% of Latinos, and 52% of women opposed Prop 209 at the time.</p><p>The impact of Prop 209 to Asian Americans in public employment and public education is difficult to quantify, because during the decades before and after 1996, a large number of highly educated Asians immigrated to the U.S. and settled in California. Their skill sets made them very competitive in universities and knowledge-based professions. They also invested heavily in their children’s education which made their children very competitive in college admission as well. Just as significantly, the total population of Asian Americans in California grew rapidly during this period. Due to these factors, after the passage of Prop 209, Asian Americans were able to maintain high representation in public employment and public education. Attributing the high proportion of Asian Americans in these two areas to the passage of Prop 209 is not supported by empirical evidence. In terms of government contracting, Asian Americans have been hit hard like other minorities.</p><p><strong>California’s SCA-5 and ACA5/Prop16</strong></p><p>In order to mitigate the negative impact of Prop 209 on minorities and women, California has introduced a series of policies. For example, one such policy guaranteed that the top 9% of students in each high school are eligible to attend the University of California. Also, more efforts have been made to consider the socio-economic characteristics of applicants in public college admissions. However, these measures cannot fully compensate for the adverse effects of Prop 209 on minorities and women.</p><p>In 2012, California Senator Edward Hernandez and others proposed Senate Constitutional Amendment 5 (SCA-5), intended to introduce a referendum for Californians to decide whether or not to restore affirmative action in California’s public universities. When the news reached first-generation immigrants from mainland China in 2014, it caused an uproar. Many Chinese immigrants believed that the passage of SCA-5 would severely restrict opportunities for their children to attend a good university, shattering the hopes they had placed in their children’s futures. Therefore, they launched a strong opposition to SCA-5 by exerting tremendous pressure on state legislators, especially Chinese American legislators. They forced some to drop their support of SCA-5. As a result, SCA-5 was withdrawn from a vote in the Assembly after passing in the CA Senate.</p><p>In January 2019, a member of the California State Assembly, Dr. Shirley Weber, and others proposed Assembly Constitutional Amendment 5 (ACA-5), which would allow California voters to vote on a repeal of the ban on affirmative action. This once again prompted tremendous opposition from many first-generation immigrants from China. Unlike SCA-5, ACA-5 covers not only public education, but also public employment and government contracting, which has broadened its range of supporters. In the California State Legislature debate on ACA-5, Black, Latino, Native American, Asian American, Jewish, and female elected representatives expressed their strong support of ACA-5. Equally important is that the timing of the legislative vote coincided with the critical moment of attention to the Black Lives Matter movement in the wake of the tragic death of George Floyd. Recognizing that we must address the issue of continued discrimination against African Americans and Latinos — and the costs of remaining passive in the face of evidence systemic racism — a majority of state representatives voted “yes,” allowing ACA-5 to appear on the 2020 ballot in the form of Proposition 16.</p><p>If Prop 16 passes, California will once again be able consider race, gender, color, ethnicity, and country of origin in public employment, public education, and government contracts just like 42 other states. In other words, California would fully restore affirmative action as a tool against racial inequality.</p><p><strong>Isn’t considering Race Racial Discrimination?</strong></p><p>The Chinese translation of “racial discrimination” is “zhong zu qi shi” (种族歧视), which is a very negative term. In Chinese, it refers to people or the government looking down upon, hating or rejecting people of a certain racial background. It is a very negative term because it is only used to describe the actions that the advantaged racial groups use to disadvantage racial groups and make the life of those disadvantaged racial groups even harder. People in China would not call the policy which is intended to help disadvantaged ethnic minorities a zhong zu qi shi (racial discrimination) policy. Unfortunately, the term “racial discrimination” or “reverse racial discrimination” is often used by English speaking opponents of affirmative action programs to describe the assumed negative effects of such policies on advantaged groups. This creates a dilemma for the people in the U.S. who want to help disadvantaged groups. If they support the consideration of race in policies in the hope to aid those who are disadvantaged, they are often accused of “racial discrimination” or even worse, called racists.</p><p>The 14th Amendment prohibits laws which differentiate explicitly between racial groups, even when this differentiation is meant to address systemic racism. This has made it very difficult for disadvantaged groups to overcome obstacles and rise up.</p><p>Affirmative action is meant to address this legal dilemma. Affirmative action does not refer to a single policy, but a collection of bureaucratic mandates, directives, and laws which provide policies and guideance to address implicit racial and gender discrimination by allowing government entities to consider race and gender in a very limited way, and in conjunction with other important factors. With any affirmative action programs, race can never be used as the only or most important factor in determining an outcome. The purpose of affirmative action is to realize the claim that all people are born equal.</p><p><strong>Does Affirmative Action Lead to Racial Quotas?</strong></p><p>One reason many Chinese Americans strongly oppose affirmative action is that they believe affirmative action is a quota system, meaning, various positions will be reserved for different ethnic groups based on their representation in the general population. If that is the case, opportunities for Chinese Americans and Asian Americans would be severely limited in certain contexts, such as higher education in selective colleges and universities where they are well “over-represented”.</p><p>The idea that affirmative action is synonymous with racial quotas is prevalent in both Chinese American communities and more generally. There are many reasons for this misunderstanding. One reason is misinformation, including some people intentionally or unintentionally promoting misinformation. Another reason is that some features of affirmative action might lead some to assume it will develop into a quota system. The legal rationale for affirmative action is diversity. But, these policies are also important because they help to realize the idea of human equality with the understanding that racism and sexism have created conditions under which equality is difficult to achieve without affirmative and explicit recognition of that fact. When affirmative action was first implemented, there were indeed some institutions that reserved positions specifically for people of color. For example, the University of California, Davis School of Medicine reserved a small number of admissions spots specifically for people of color. In 1978, the Supreme Court ruled that it could not set quotas for any ethnic groups, nor could it impose upper or lower limits for any ethnic groups. That is, the Supreme Court outlawed racial quotas in1978. For decades, colleges and universities have practiced affirmative action with the understanding that racial quotas cannot be included as part of any permissible program and will be ruled unconstitutional if they choose to do so.</p><p>The implementation of affirmative action will indeed rely on data about the relative proportion of different racial and ethnic groups as part of assessment and planning. Some people have used this gathering of data as the proof that affirmative action is associated with proportional representation by race. However, the purpose of analyzing ethnic proportions is simply to identify where there may be lack of diversity. In reality, lack of representation for certain ethnic groups in an area is not necessarily due to racial discrimination by college admission officers. It could be due other facts, such as racial discrimination in K-12 education. Affirmative action is not a tool that can fix all aspects of inequality in the educational system. Society as a whole needs to address the fundamental root causes of racial inequality. Affirmative action remains just one tool.</p><p><strong>Is Affirmative Action Specifically aimed at Asian Americans?</strong></p><p>Another reason why some Chinese Americans strongly oppose affirmative action is that they somehow believe that if other racial groups gain any ground, it will be at the cost of Asian Americans only, or even worse, at the cost of Chinese Americans only.</p><p>It is true that Asian Americans, including Chinese Americans have greatly improved our status over the last sixty years. However, we have to remember that we started at a very low point. White males are still holding the largest piece of the economic and political pie today. As an analogy — if Asian Americans could only have chicken bones prior to affirmative action, we now have chicken wings, at best. Chicken drumsticks and breasts which contain the largest chunk of the meat are still in the hands of White males.</p><p>Yes, the proportion of Chinese Americans in some universities and in certain industries are relatively high compared with our total population. Due to the very low general population, the pie we hold is still very small. It makes no sense to assume that members of other racial groups are eyeing the small pie in our hand.</p><p><strong>Does Affirmative Action Conflict with Dr. Martin Luther King’s Dream?</strong></p><p>Some people continue to use Martin Luther King’s statement that his children should not be judged by their skin color to argue against affirmative action. The original words of Dr. King were: “I have a dream that my four little children will one day live in a nation where they will not be judged by the color of their skin but by the content of their character.” If you only look at the words, this statement indeed can be interpreted as Dr. King’s objection to consider race as a fact. However, we need to understand the context of the era in which Dr. King delivered this famous speech in 1963. At that time, people of color had suffered for decades under segregation and were discriminated against by many white Americans. Dr. King’s speech expresses hope that one day, people of color in the United States would no longer be oppressed.</p><p>Dr. King’s statement should not be used to suggest that he was against helping people of color and disadvantaged groups. If Dr. King were still alive today, and even if African Americans were no longer a disadvantaged ethnic group, I believe that Dr. King would support efforts to help other disadvantaged ethnic groups.</p><p>The purpose of affirmative action is to help disadvantaged groups so that they can have a chance to succeed. Isn’t this what Dr. King dreamed of</p><p>In July of this year, Martin Luther King’s daughter Bernice A. King announced her support of Prop 16 and endorsed the return of affirmative action to California. She said in a tweet: “I endorse Prop16. This bill will help women and people of color create a more prosperous future. This is consistent with my father’s dream.”</p><p><strong>The Special Plight of Chinese Americans and How we can Overcome It</strong></p><p>Affirmative action is an important tool for underprivileged groups, such as people of color and women, striving for universal equity. Before the implementation of affirmative action, ethnic Chinese in the U.S. lagged behind the White population in almost every area. At that time, affirmative action was very beneficial to Chinese Americans. Today, Chinese Americans as a whole have made great progress in terms of educational attainment and in certain occupations. In these respects, affirmative action may not help Chinese Americans as much as in the past and may even have a negative impact in certain areas where we have made the greatest strides. This explains why some Chinese Americans are against affirmative action.</p><p>Affirmative action has been implemented in the United States for more than half a century, and there have always been voices of opposition. However, no other ethnic group has registered such strong and vocal opposition then Chinese Americans, not even White males. Why?</p><p>There are many reasons contributing to this phenomenon. Lack of understanding of affirmative action and the echo chamber effect of Chinese social media are two superficial reasons. However, these superficial reasons should not overshadow one deeper reason, that is, the first-generation immigrants from mainland China do have a unique situation.</p><p>During the last thirty years, a million or so people came to the U.S. from mainland China. Many of them came here to obtain advanced degrees or high-tech jobs. They usually had obtained bachelor’s degrees from top universities in China before arrival in the U.S. They truly believe that going to the most prestigious universities is the key to their success. That is why they are laser-focused on a handful of elite universities that they consider most desirable for their children. Also, they are concentrated in a relatively narrow set of industries in terms of their own career path and their children’s career path. The result is a relatively high proportion of Chinese Americans in highly selective universities and in certain professions. If ethnic quotas were indeed instituted, Chinese Americans would be impacted greatly. This is why the specter of quotas is so effective in creating fears around affirmative action. To make things worse, it seems that many Chinese Americans do not think they have many other good opportunities beyond these select colleges and career paths.</p><p>Other ethnic groups are in better situations. For example, White people have advantages in almost every aspect, so naturally they are not too worried. Jewish people in America have already crossed this hurdle long ago. Indian Americans have made great inroads in many areas, such as in politics and higher management in large high-tech companies. Chinese Americans who were born in America or coming from Taiwan, Hong Kong have also diversified their career interests and the choice of their children’s colleges. Only the first generation of Chinese from the mainland are still deeply stuck in this predicament, which is similar to 150 years ago when most Chinese in America were railway workers. Once the railway was completed, they would face a huge crisis.</p><p>Perhaps the narrow pathway to success they have walked explains why in the last six years, first-generation immigrants from mainland China are really the most vocal force in the battle against affirmative action. However, I think this approach may not pay off for two reasons. First, affirmative action cannot and should not lead to racial quotas given the Supreme Court’s consistent rulings in this area. Second, we, the first-generation immigrants from mainland China have to understand that no racial or ethnic group can dominate a set of industries or one set of universities. Even if we successfully blocked ACA 5/Prop 16, there will be other efforts to increase diversity in higher education and in industries. Racial diversity is here to stay. So, rather than focus our energies on resisting these efforts, Chinese Americans should diversify our own pathways like other groups. This does not mean lowering our dreams and aspirations. It means we are moving into and exploring a broader range of excellent colleges and career possibilities.</p><p>For two hundred years, Chinese Americans have endured enormous challenges. Although there is economic polarization in our community, as a group we have experienced a great deal of upward mobility. In the past, Chinese laborers worked in the gold mines of the West and did backbreaking labor building railways, serving as launderers, or working in domestic service. Today, the majority of Chinese Americans have found success in terms of both education and occupation. I am sure that we and our next generation will overcome barriers and be successful in every area our passion leads us to. Affirmative action may be the tool which can help us in this endeavor.</p><p><a href="https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/xDoGEJ5DzUzR3wDLye26qg"><strong>CHINESE TRANSLATION</strong></a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=45a5c12b7d73" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Can Asian Americans win the Real Fight for more Educational Resources?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@crwstrategy/can-asian-americans-win-the-real-fight-for-more-educational-resources-1331452d5d9a?source=rss-b9dd790fd35b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1331452d5d9a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[chinese-immigrants]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[harvard]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[affirmative-action]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[asian-american]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[CRWStrategy Ethnic Media]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 01 Nov 2018 19:59:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-11-02T11:51:55.534Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Can Asian Americans Win the Real Fight for more Educational Resources?</h3><p>Expanding opportunity requires targeting our political energy beyond a zero-sum strategy and affirmative action</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*Kf1WqgwZrrapVsFaTRLyBQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Yale University, New Haven, CT. Photo credit, Steven Chen</figcaption></figure><p>By Steven Chen, Founding Partner, crwstrategy.com</p><p>Since 2012, from California to New York, from Berkeley to Boston, many first-generation immigrants from mainland China have joined the fight against race-based affirmative action in hopes of obtaining more education resources. Can we really win the fight for more education resources that way?</p><p>I, too, am an immigrant from mainland China. When people first see me, they think they know me. It is true that I am a “typical” Chinese immigrant in many respects. I arrived here from China thirty years ago to pursue a graduate degree. I am a technology specialist who lives in a Los Angeles suburb. Many assume they know me and my values. But they do not. Few would know that I am an environmentalist and that I help clean our local beach every month along with my fellow Chinese Americans. Many would believe that I care deeply about the education of my own children, because they see my face and assume that I am a “Tiger parent” devoted to ensuring my children have the best education. They are right about this, but they also don’t see all of me. I do not only care about the education of my own children. For years now, I have been working in the Chinese immigrant community and with leading Asian American organizations to expand access to quality education for not only the children of Asian Americans, but for all children. This, I believe, should be a fundamental goal for all of us.</p><p><strong>How Asian Americans won the fight for education resources in the past?</strong></p><p>Because education plays such an important role in individual success, educational resources have been closely guarded by dominant groups. Throughout the history of this country, disadvantaged groups have had to fight for their share of education resources.</p><p>As a result of the fight by disadvantaged groups and the implementation of affirmative action policies in the 1960&#39;s, the country witnessed a dramatic increase of women and racial minorities in higher education. Asian Americans were big winners of this fight. However, Asian Americans didn’t win this fight alone. More importantly, this fight was not fought in a zero-sum way. The increase of women and racial minority students was accompanied by an increase of all students, including white American students.</p><p><strong>What is limiting Asian Americans from increasing their shares in top colleges today?</strong></p><p>Fast forward to the 1990&#39;s, when Asian Americans were already “over represented” in many top colleges. Some began to assume that race-based affirmative action hurts Asian Americans. The argument is that if a college makes efforts to recruit students from underrepresented racial groups, those admissions will come at the expense of Asian American students. The flip-side of this faulty logic is that if race-based affirmative action is banned, the share of Asian Americans in colleges will increase dramatically.</p><p>However, the reality does not match with this argument. After affirmative action in public colleges was banned in California as the result of a statewide ballot vote in 1996, the percentage of Asian Americans in the University of California campuses remained flat. At the same time, elite private colleges nationwide have maintained race-conscious policies and seen the percentage of Asian American students keep rising. The most significant rise in Asian American admissions at Harvard occurred after the Obama administration issued guidance on how to apply affirmative action in the U.S. education system.</p><p>How do we explain this? College admissions are complicated.</p><p>The academic rating (via standardized test scores and high school grades) is one of the strongest areas for most Asian American applicants as a whole. However, academic achievement is only one of the criteria highly-selective colleges consider. Top colleges are looking for a variety of talents, including leadership, special skills, and the unique application of passion in their recruits. Asian American applicants look more like other groups when it comes to these talents, and so they do not reap the same rewards when a variety of talents are recognized, compared with academic scores alone. There is no formula based on academic scores for getting in top colleges. However, the fact that Asian Americans are three to four times “over represented” relative to their proportions in the population in many top colleges suggests that Asian American applicants are not just test-takers. They are excellent in many other areas too.</p><p>The drive for racial diversity is another factor preventing one or two racial groups from monopolizing enrollment at highly-selective colleges. In a multiethnic country, many institutions, such as top colleges, value racial diversity. They want diverse representation in their institutions to attract the best talents and ideas from all people. Diversity is one of the major reasons highly-selective colleges are able to stay on top. Elite colleges also have the responsibility to produce leaders of all racial backgrounds. If race-conscious admissions are outlawed, colleges will most likely not abandon their efforts to foster racial diversity. After affirmative action was banned in California, public universities in California instituted plans such as the “Eligibility in the Local Context (ELC)” criteria to try to improve racial diversity. Recently, some top colleges around the country ended SAT/ACT tests scores as part of their application requirements. Many people believe that these changes are meant to provide more flexibility in maintaining racial diversity.</p><p>Race-based affirmative action is intended to increase diversity through the recruitment of qualified applicants from underrepresented racial groups, not to penalize overrepresented racial groups. So, the existence of race-based affirmative action is important to seriously underrepresented racial groups, including some Asian American subgroups, while the negative impact to overrepresented racial groups, such as Chinese Americans should be minimal. This is especially true given the fact that the Supreme Court has ruled that race-based affirmative action can only be used in a very limited way. Quotas and bonus points based on race are not allowed.</p><p>Racial discrimination and stereotyping against Asian Americans do exist in this country, especially after we graduate from colleges and enter the real world. We need race-based affirmative action to fight racial discrimination against Asian Americans in college and beyond.</p><p><strong>How can Asian Americans win the real fight for more education resources?</strong></p><p>America is still far away from an ideal colorblind society. Different racial groups will fight for educational resources. Universities, especially top universities, will strive for racial diversity as long as racial inequalities exist. Today, Asian Americans are flourishing in the U.S. education system.</p><p>Given this context, how can Asian Americans win the fight for more education resources?</p><p>The battle against reinstating affirmative action in California’s public universities in 2012 and the fight against New York City’s effort to increase diversity at elite public high schools this year can be viewed as some Asian Americans trying to defend their claims on education resources. The complaints filed against elite colleges might be seen as offensive battles by some Asian Americans trying to expand their already high shares at elite colleges. Those battles, defensive or offensive, are zero-sum battles because they include no real effort to expand educational opportunity for all.</p><p>After six years of fighting over race-conscious admissions, there is no meaningful increase in the share of Asian Americans in selective institutions. Why? There is just not much room left for Asian Americans to gain when resources are not expanding.</p><p>Over the past 30 years, an infusion of well-educated immigrants from Asian countries has flowed into the U.S. They have helped America build a world-class high-tech industry. They contribute taxes and enhance the communities in which they live. Since quality education led to their success, they want the same for their children. This creates an extraordinary demand for excellent educational opportunities. Unfortunately, this higher demand is not adequately met. This is the root cause of the problem we see today.</p><p>To meet this higher demand for quality education, Asian Americans should push for more public and private investment in high education.</p><p>After the financial crisis in 2008, the state of California reduced funding for higher education. Due to dramatic budget cuts, many University of California campuses had to admit more out-of-state and international students who could pay full tuition to meet costs. That had a huge impact on in-state applicants, including growing number of Asian Americans, in California. It explains why the battle for and against a proposal to reinstate race-conscious admissions in 2012 was so fierce. Other states have similar issues, too. We Asian Americans should lead the campaign to demand that lawmakers provide more funding for higher education so that children of all racial backgrounds can access a quality education and thrive.</p><p>Growing numbers of highly qualified applicants, including Asian American students, also increased competition at the nation’s elite private colleges. Students of all racial backgrounds have to work extremely hard to gain a coveted admission slot at highly-selective colleges. The admission rate at some of these institutions is as low as 5%. We should urge elite colleges to fulfill their educational missions by investing in the infrastructure and resources necessary to increase capacity and the numbers of students of all racial backgrounds they enroll, rather than fighting legal battles over the status quo.</p><p>Last, there are many “Asian American Native American Pacific Islander Serving Institutions” in the United States. Institutions with this designation are included within federally designated Minority Serving Institution (MSI) programs, which serve low-income students of our communities. Asian Americans should show full support to those institutions. We should also seriously consider building and leading Asian-American-serving flagship colleges, similar to those established by other groups in the past. These colleges will attract top talents from all racial backgrounds.</p><p>We can truly win the fight for more education resources if we turn our growing political and economic power to expanding educational opportunities for our children and the children of others.</p><p>I would like to end this essay with a positive note to my fellow Asian American parents.</p><p>While not perfect, the U.S. maintains its leadership in higher education. Asian Americans are doing well in the U.S. education system. We demonstrate soaring rates of educational attainment, even in the current context of limited resources. Colleges love our children. In my Chinese American circle, almost all of our children attended excellent colleges. My own children have had incredible educational opportunities at highly-ranked colleges, too. For this, we are grateful.</p><p>There are challenges ahead. However, I am sure Asian Americans can and will work with others to win over more education resources for our children and the children of others.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1331452d5d9a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[An Elephant in a China Shop]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@crwstrategy/an-elephant-in-a-china-shop-d69c6fccf944?source=rss-b9dd790fd35b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d69c6fccf944</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[civil-rights]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[affirmative-action]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[asian-american]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ethnic-media]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[CRWStrategy Ethnic Media]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 05 Mar 2018 22:01:14 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-03-11T19:57:42.807Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>How Chinese immigrants are changing ethnic politics today</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zloL0mkEim33x3gu2yDfOA.jpeg" /></figure><p>By Steven Chen, Founding Partner, crwstrategy.com</p><p>In 1979, the United States and the People’s Republic of China resumed diplomatic relationships. Since then, several million people from China have come to the United States to study and work, and many have stayed. Today, these immigrants from mainland China form the largest group of Chinese Americans in the United States, outnumbering earlier waves of Chinese immigrants from Hong Kong, Taiwan, and elsewhere.</p><p>For much of their period of settlement, particularly from the 1980s through early 2000s, this group was not particularly active or even visible in mainstream U.S. politics. This changed dramatically in 2014, when legislators in California proposed Senate Constitutional Amendment 5 (SCA-5), a measure that would allow voters to restore affirmative action through a state constitutional amendment. Since then, this group has continued their efforts on other policies they believe would harm the ability of their children to access higher education, such as affirmative action and efforts to disaggregate Asian American data. Some acvitists have gone even further, opposing immigrant legalization and sanctuary jurisdiction policies.</p><p>These efforts have been quite effective. Activists mobilized by Chinese social media killed SCA5, stopped sanctuary jurisdiction efforts in states like Maryland, and have helped to undermine affirmative action and effectively opposed efforts to collect data by Asian national-origin group. These are all key agenda items for the traditional civil rights community. What is behind this phenomenon and how should political leaders respond?</p><p>SCA5 as a Catalyst</p><p>In 1996, California passed Proposition 209. It prohibits state governmental institutions from considering race, sex, or ethnicity, in the areas of public employment, public contracting, and public education. It was intended to nullify race-based affirmative action in those areas.</p><p>In 2012, California state senator Edward Hernandez introduced SCA5 (California Senate Constitutional Amendment №5). The bill would have put on the ballot a proposition that allows state institutions of higher education to use race, gender, and ethnicity as a few of a many factors considered in public college admissions. The opponents of SCA5 erroneously claimed that SCA5 would lead to higher education quotas based on the racial make-up of the state population. To be specific, some people claimed that the proportion of Asian American students at UC Berkeley would be reduced from around 50% to 15% to match its population in California.</p><p>When rumors about quotas on Asian American admissions broke out on a then newly-formed social media platform, WeChat, Chinese immigrants, the primary users of that platform, panicked. The majority of this group graduated from elite colleges in China. They expected that their children would continue in the tradition of attending elite educational institutions in the U.S. They believed their dreams would be crushed if schools like UC Berkeley were to put a cap on Asian American admissions, as unfounded rumors seemed to suggest. That is why they demonstrated up and down the state of California, from Sacramento to San Diego. They sent protesters to hearings and stormed the offices of legislators. And WeChat provided a powerful tool for them to organize and mobilize around these actions.</p><p>What is WeChat?</p><p>WeChat has and continues to play a critical role in the dramatic political rise of this group. It is a social media platform developed by the Chinese company Tencent in 2011 and is widely used by the people in China and first-generation Chinese immigrants elsewhere. People use WeChat to form “private” groups around common interests, such as hobbies, political issues, alumni connections, and events. Groups are created and managed by owners who set the tone for the group. One group can have up to five hundred members, and a passionate person can join several hundred groups. As such, a single person can have direct access to tens of thousands people. WeChat can be used as a low cost and effective tool to share information, even spread rumors and promote propaganda.</p><p>WeChat is also a powerful mobilization tool; it can quickly spread word of an upcoming event and collect names of participants through a process called “Jie Long” (Solitaire). Jie Long has the effect of encouraging and even compelling people to sign up. Each time a person adds his/her name on the list, that person will notify their participation to the entire group. As more sign-up, others are encouraged to join the growing crowd of participants, and with the addition of each name, the event is advertised to a larger and larger group of people.</p><p>However, what really sets WeChat apart from other social media platforms is that WeChat participants are dominated by one largely homogeneous demographic, first-generation immigrants from mainland China. That means people in the WeChat world can make derogatory comments or post true or fabricated stories about other racial or religious communities with no defense from those targeted groups. Over time, people using WeChat could develop very negative opinions about those being targeted. WeChat is both an effective community-building space and a tool for creating fear, and sometimes very negative views of different racial and religious groups.</p><p>WeChat — A Virtual Chinatown</p><p>Historically, due to formal and informal discrimination and forced segregation, Chinese in America lived and worked in ethnic enclaves called Chinatowns. There were many negative perceptions about “Chinatowns” and its residents, in large part due to stereotypes and lack of interaction. However, it remains true that the people in traditional Chinatowns were disconnected from the rest of the country. They spoke Chinese and read Chinese newspapers for information. They did not have a great deal of consistent interaction with people outside, and vice versa.</p><p>When the first wave of immigrants from the People’s Republic of China arrived in 1980, the United States appeared much more open and much friendlier towards people of color compared to the pre-Civil Rights movement era. New Chinese immigrants were able to study at elite and flagship universities, live in the suburbs, and work at big companies outside of an ethnic enclave. They had opportunities to integrate into American society in important ways from the start. However, as WeChat becomes the dominant social media platform for new immigrants from mainland China, it is creating an virtual wall around Chinese immigrant communities.</p><p>In WeChat, almost everything is communicated in Chinese. Information from the mainstream media has to be translated into Chinese in order to be effectively propagated in the WeChat world. The accuracy of information is sometimes lost due to inaccurate translation or intentional distortion. Since almost everything shared in the WeChat world is in Chinese, the political leaders and organizations working in mainstream U.S. politics have little idea about what is going on in the WeChat world. Thus, WeChat has become a virtual Chinatown. It has isolated first-generation immigrants from mainland China from the rest of country and the broader range of political views. That is not good for the people in the WeChat world.</p><p>Knowing the problem of isolation WeChat has created, some people in the WeChat world are eager to connect the WeChat world to mainstream America and to expand the marketplace of ideas to which immigrant Chinese Americans are exposed. They encourage political leaders and established organizations to reach out to the WeChat world. Unfortunately, this effort has been in vain so far. The WeChat world is increasingly drifting away from mainstream America. Today, from a political standpoint, the WeChat community is very different from the rest of the Chinese American community, and even more so from the rest of Asian American community.</p><p>An Elephant in a China Shop</p><p>There are about two million first generation immigrants from P.R. China. If you only count the number of votes, this group has limited political power. However, thanks to WeChat, this group can mobilize disproportionately high numbers of people to fight against policies they feel threatened by. For example, they were able to send more than 800 people to a hearing about collecting detailed, disaggregated data on Asian Americans in the state of Massachusetts in January of 2018 to voice their opposition. Proponents, including many Asian Americans, have long argued that these detailed data are critical for addressing the needs of less well-off Asian American groups, such as Cambodians and Hmong. However, many people, mobilized on WeChat, drove several hours or flew across the country to Boston because they heard rumors that the collection of detailed, national origin data would somehow disadvantage or stigmatize Chinese Americans. Such direct actions necessarily entail major personal sacrifices. If Chinese immigrant opponents of the bill didn’t genuinely feel threatened by the policy, they probably would not take part in these political actions. There was little engagement with this group by mainstream Asian American civil rights organizations supporting the bill prior to the hearing.</p><p>There is an elephant in a China shop. If it feels threatened, whether in real or imaginary ways, it will act forcefully and cause trouble for everyone, including itself.</p><p>Policy makers and advocacy groups need to be mindful of the interests and mentality of this group when formulating policies. If the policy is perceived to hurt or disadvantage this group, we will see a powerful reaction from them. Even a well-intended policy needs to be explained carefully and respectfully to this group, or political opponents could twist the narrative and convince this group that the policy is meant to hurt them.</p><p>The people in this group are interested in making a positive contribution to U.S. life and are excited to be participating in U.S. politics. In daily life, they work as engineers, doctors, scientists, and business people. They volunteer for civic projects, such as beach clean-ups and helping the homeless. They are reasonable people, too. If interested parties are willing to reach out to the WeChat world to better understand their political hopes and fears, and to show that their ideas are valued and respected, hearts and minds can be won.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d69c6fccf944" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>