<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Charlie Warzel on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Charlie Warzel on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@cwarzel?source=rss-1b0b4ee5ae6------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 13:26:43 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@cwarzel/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“A Honeypot For Assholes”: Inside Twitter’s 10-Year Failure To Stop Harassment]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/twitter-harassment/a-honeypot-for-assholes-inside-twitters-10-year-failure-to-stop-harassment-b394e4b18a89?source=rss-1b0b4ee5ae6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b394e4b18a89</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[tech]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[twitter]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[buzzfeed-news]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-media]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Charlie Warzel]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 15 Nov 2016 20:48:19 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-11-15T20:48:19.369Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>For nearly its entire existence, Twitter has not just tolerated abuse and hate speech, it’s virtually been optimized to accommodate it. With public backlash at an all-time high and growth stagnating, what is the platform that declared itself “the free speech wing of the free speech party” to do? BuzzFeed News talks to the people who’ve been trying to figure this out for a decade.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*LdhTyi5q-v0UejesR4htvQ.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>On May 22, 2008,</strong> Ariel Waldman ran out of options. Waldman, then a community manager and blogger, had signed up for Twitter in March 2007 and in months had become one of the platform’s 100 most followed accounts. She was, by her own account, “<a href="http://arielwaldman.com/2008/05/22/twitter-refuses-to-uphold-terms-of-service/">addicted</a>” to the service.</p><p>But soon after, the abuse began — for no reason other than that Waldman was a woman writing articles that occasionally touched on sex and technology. In June 2007, a stalker posted some of her private information in a string of threatening tweets. Waldman contacted Twitter, which banned the user in question from the public timeline. But over the next eight months, the targeted abuse and stalking intensified. By March 2008, exhausted and disillusioned by a torrent of tweets calling her a “cunt” and a “whore” and publicizing personal information like her email address, Waldman reached out to Twitter again, this time to the company’s CEO, Jack Dorsey. After a series of phone calls to the company went nowhere, Dorsey and Twitter went silent. So in May, Waldman <a href="http://arielwaldman.com/2008/05/22/twitter-refuses-to-uphold-terms-of-service/">went public</a>, detailing her ordeal in a blog post, which caught fire in media circles.</p><p>Twitter, then still a startup, was fresh off a buzzy SXSW debut, and Waldman’s post was an unfamiliar bit of bad press, depicting Dorsey in particular as an unsympathetic, even cowardly, chief executive. “Jack explained that they’re scared to ban someone because they’re scared if it turned into a lawsuit that they are too small of a company to handle it,” Waldman wrote. While Twitter founder Biz Stone <a href="http://www.wired.com/2008/05/tweeter-takes-o/">issued a formal acknowledgment</a> of the problem, arguing that “<a href="http://getsatisfaction.com/twitter/topics/what_is_twitters_stance_toward_abuse">Twitter is a communication utility, not a mediator of content</a>,” Dorsey was silent. Co-founder Ev Williams was more critical, <a href="https://twitter.com/ev/statuses/817807577">posting tweets</a> that cast doubt on Waldman’s claims and <a href="http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2008/05/twitters-controversy-over-terms-of-service/">halfheartedly apologizing</a> with a simple “our bad.” Waldman was crushed. “Prior to my coming out, I had great relationships with them and considered some of them my friends,” Waldman told BuzzFeed News this month of the fallout. “I took it very personally. It sucked.”</p><p>More than eight years after Waldman’s ordeal, harassment on Twitter is rampant — so much so that it has become <a href="http://www.getlittlebird.com/blog/data-62-of-the-people-donald-trump-rted-this-week-follow-multiple-white-supremacist-accounts">a primary destination</a> for <a href="http://womenactionmedia.org/cms/assets/uploads/2015/05/wam-twitter-abuse-report.pdf">trolls</a> and <a href="http://www.alternet.org/unbelievable-harassment-black-women-face-daily-twitter">hate groups</a>. So much so that its CEO declared, “<a href="http://www.theverge.com/2015/2/4/7982099/twitter-ceo-sent-memo-taking-personal-responsibility-for-the">We suck at dealing with abuse and trolls on the platform and we’ve sucked at it for years</a>.” So much so that <a href="https://uk.news.yahoo.com/news/adele-quits-twitter-newborn-son-receives-death-threats-103514469.html">numerous</a> <a href="http://money.cnn.com/2016/06/08/media/new-york-times-jon-weisman-twitter/">high-profile</a> <a href="http://www.essence.com/2016/08/08/normani-kordei-quits-twitter-racist-abuse">users</a> <a href="http://www.people.com/article/iggy-azalea-quits-twitter-cellulite-criticism">have</a> <a href="http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/news/lena-dunham-quits-twitter-828129">quit</a> <a href="http://www.newsweek.com/ghostbusters-star-leslie-jones-quits-twitter-amid-racist-abuse-481684">the</a> <a href="http://www.nydailynews.com/news/national/columnist-quits-social-media-threats-rape-5-year-old-article-1.2728374">service</a>, citing it as an unsafe space. Today, Twitter is a well-known hunting ground for women and people of color, who are targeted by neo-Nazis, racists, misogynists, and trolls, often just for showing up. Just this summer, actor Leslie Jones was driven off Twitter after a <a href="http://fusion.net/story/327103/leslie-jones-twitter-racism/">barrage of racist comments and death threats</a>, only to return after a personal reassurance from Dorsey himself. Last week, Normani Kordei of the pop group Fifth Harmony also stepped away from the service after suffering years of “<a href="http://www.usatoday.com/story/life/entertainthis/2016/08/08/fifth-harmony-normani-kordei-driven-off-twittern-racist-abuse/88392496/">horrific and racially charged</a>” tweets. Despite its integral role in popular culture and in social justice initiatives from the Arab Spring to Black Lives Matter, Twitter is as infamous today for being as toxic as it is famous for being revolutionary. <a href="https://www.buzzfeed.com/charliewarzel/sources-twitter-ceo-dick-costolo-secretly-censored-abusive-r">And unless you’re a celebrity — or, as it turns out, the president of the United States of America — good luck getting help.</a></p><p>According to 10 high-level former employees, the social network’s long history with abuse has been fraught with inaction and organizational disarray. Taken together, these interviews tell the story of a company that’s been ill-equipped to handle harassment since its beginnings. Fenced in by an abiding commitment to free speech above all else and a unique product that makes moderation difficult and trolling almost effortless, Twitter has, over a chaotic first decade marked by shifting business priorities and institutional confusion, allowed abuse and harassment to continue to grow as a chronic problem and perpetual secondary internal priority. On Twitter, abuse is not just a bug, but — to use the Silicon Valley term of art — a fundamental feature.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/0*Chnexq2pGMXIINxs.jpg" /><figcaption>Ariel Davis / BuzzFeed News</figcaption></figure><p><strong>If you want</strong> to fully understand Twitter’s abuse problem, a good place to start is at Google, years before the first tweet was ever sent. While working at Blogger, the wildly popular Google-owned publishing tool, Ev Williams, Biz Stone, and Jason Goldman — all of whom went on to found or work at Twitter — were faced with what now feels like a familiar predicament.</p><p>Like Twitter, Blogger had grown quickly as a broadcast tool, becoming home to a wide spectrum of voices, no small number of which were loud and obnoxious and objectionable. But rather than censor the unsavory blogs, Williams and company saw an opportunity to build a platform committed to free expression and the democratic spirit of the internet. That decision was fought internally, pitting Goldman against Sheryl Sandberg, at the time head of Google AdWords, in what <a href="https://www.buzzfeed.com/robf4/the-silent-partner?utm_term=.ragXL9wagJ#.yayV5n7EeG">Goldman called</a> “a straight-up turf war.”</p><p>Goldman won. Working with Alexander Macgillivray, a die-hard free speech advocate who was then a Google attorney, Blogger made a core principle of the universal right to publish, despite outside criticism. “We don’t get involved in adjudicating whether something is libel or slander,” Goldman <a href="http://www.forbes.com/forbes/2005/1114/128.html">told <em>Forbes</em></a> in 2005. The passage that followed reads like it could be written about Twitter today: “In squabbles between anonymous bloggers and victims Google sides with the attackers, refusing to turn over any information unless a judge orders it to open up. ‘We’ll do it if we believe we are required to by law,’ [Goldman] says.”</p><p>Less than a year later, when Williams and Stone founded Twitter along with Dorsey, they brought along Goldman and continued largely where they’d left off. “We worked hard at the outset of Twitter to maintain freedom of speech with clear limits,” Stone told BuzzFeed News in a recent email. “This stemmed from my time at Google working on the same issues with Blogger.” But as Waldman’s case exemplifies, even early on, Twitter’s “freedom of speech with clear limits” found critics who saw those limits as opaque and arbitrary.</p><p>And while Blogger’s free speech problems were novel, small-scale, and often abstract, Twitter’s follower model and public reply system proved thornier to manage. There’s a big difference between people saying hurtful things on the easily moderated comment section of a hard-to-find blog and people showing up in your mentions spewing hate speech. “The product quirks were secondary … to free speech,” one former employee said of the company’s early days. “The Blogger brain trust’s thinking was set in stone by the time they became Twitter Inc.”</p><p>In the summer of 2009, the company’s values were validated when Twitter was lauded for its role in giving voice to Iranian election protesters. By the time the <a href="http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/discussion/2009/06/17/DI2009061702232.html">State Department asked Twitter</a> to delay scheduled maintenance on its servers in order to keep protest communication lines open during the election, Twitter’s reputation as a powerful broadcast tool was solidified. Just weeks later, the company hired Macgillivray away from Google as its first general counsel.</p><blockquote><em>“What was once lauded as a virtue has now become the company’s Achilles’ heel.”</em></blockquote><p>“Here you have a great, influential lawyer who philosophically believed you don’t shut down a platform because of controversial speech,” one former employee who worked during Macgillivray’s tenure told BuzzFeed News. “That ethos was bought into by everyone in the company. Hard.” 2011 brought the Arab Spring and more international acclaim for Twitter as a platform for revolutionaries. That same year, Twitter <a href="http://www.fastcompany.com/1716100/why-twitter-was-only-company-challenge-secret-wikileaks-subpoena">fought secret government order to provide user information for WikiLeaks</a>. According to a source, Macgillivray and Stone spent months working on a blog post that would be published during the WikiLeaks controversy, titled “The Tweets Must Flow.” It was Twitter’s boldest commitment to free speech to date. “There are Tweets that we do remove, such as illegal Tweets and spam,” the post read. “However, we make efforts to keep these exceptions narrow so they may serve to prove a broader and more important rule — we strive not to remove Tweets on the basis of their content.” Not long after, Twitter executives began publicly touting that “Twitter is the free speech wing of the free speech party,” a phrase sources attribute to Macgillivray.</p><p>This maximalist approach to free speech was integral to Twitter’s rise, but quickly created the conditions for abuse. Unlike Facebook and Instagram, which <a href="http://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2015/03/16/facebook-explains-what-it-bans-and-why/">have always banned content</a> and have never positioned themselves as platforms for free speech, Twitter has made an ideology out of protecting its most objectionable users. That ethos also made it a beacon for the internet’s most vitriolic personalities, who take particular delight in abusing those who use Twitter for their jobs. This spring, the <em>Just Not Sports</em> podcast posted video of <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9tU-D-m2JY8">sports fans reading</a> a sampling of the hateful tweets that the sportswriters Sarah Spain and Julie DiCaro received while writing and reporting. The video amassed over 3.5 million views on YouTube. Its message: This level of depravity is commonplace on Twitter.</p><p>“What was once lauded as a virtue has now become the company’s Achilles’ heel — it’s the axis around which all this shit with harassment rotates,” a former senior employee told BuzzFeed News. Nearly all former employees BuzzFeed News spoke to in the course of reporting this story said the same thing. “The whole ‘free speech wing of the free speech party’ thing — that’s not a slogan, that’s deeply, deeply embedded in the DNA of the company,” Twitter’s former head of news, Vivian Schiller, said. “The people that run Twitter … are not stupid. They understand that this toxicity can kill them, but how do you draw the line? Where do you draw the line? I would actually challenge anyone to identify a perfect solution. But it feels to a certain extent that it’s led to paralysis.”</p><p>A senior engineer who left the company before its 2013 IPO echoed Schiller’s point. “You have this opposition between defending the user’s experience and not shutting down speech all while there’s this big, toxic mass of people that are abusing,” the source said. “That tension has now, I think, in the past few years, flipped on its head. It’s clear something needs to be done.”</p><p>Looking back on Twitter’s early years, multiple former senior employees cite Twitter’s disproportionately white, male leadership — a frequent, factual critique of Silicon Valley’s biggest and most influential tech companies — as creating an environment where building tools to combat harassment was a secondary concern. “The original sin is a homogenous leadership,” one former senior employee told BuzzFeed News. “This is part of what exacerbated the abuse problem for sure — because they were often tone-deaf to the concern of users in the outside world, meaning women and people of color.”</p><blockquote><em>“The original sin is a homogenous leadership.”</em></blockquote><p><strong>Talk to enough</strong> Twitter insiders and one thing becomes painfully evident: The company’s understanding of its platform hasn’t always been clear to employees, even at senior levels — a problem that has made it difficult to understand how to police harassment. One source recalls that, when asked, Jack Dorsey refused to answer exactly what kind of tool Twitter <em>was.</em> “He said, ‘Twitter brings you closer,’” the former employee recalled. “And I said, ‘To what?’ and he replied, ‘Our users always finish that sentence for us.’ And to me, I thought, <em>Well, it’s going to be really difficult to set policy in place if we can’t define what this thing is</em>.”</p><p>Internally, employees have long raised questions about whether Twitter was a media company — a broadcast platform that should be governed by content standards and practices similar to a a television network — or a piece of the internet’s infrastructure, like an ISP, that should remain open and free.</p><p>“If Twitter is the pulse of the planet, then you’re in the realm of Verizon,” one former senior employee said. “And you don’t tell Verizon that they have to police the words and topics coming in over their phone lines. I think part of what exacerbated the abuse issue for so long is that there’s an absence of a clear thesis from Twitter.”</p><p>To hear former employees tell it, the better part of Twitter’s corporate history is defined by a seemingly unending set of problems, from keeping the servers running in the early days (Twitter’s service disruptions were so frequent, its ‘Fail Whale’ error page became famous) to IPO fundraising to a sharp pivot to mobile. “There were literally always other fires to put out, always growth targets being missed and execs leaving,” one former employee told BuzzFeed News. One source described the internal culture as “never once tranquil” and another said it was “intense, chaotic, and morale-draining, despite working with some of the best people I’ve known.”</p><blockquote><em>“They had the ability to step up and be a leader in this space — to be proactive instead of reactive. That they haven’t done that is beyond me.”</em></blockquote><p>All the while, the abuse intensified and the public began to take notice. In 2013, Caroline Criado-Perez launched a campaign to put Jane Austen on UK currency and quickly became the target of more than <a href="http://www.theage.com.au/digital-life/digital-life-news/twitter-criticised-for-failing-to-respond-to-caroline-criadoperez-rape-threats-20130729-2qu8d.html">50 rape threats per hour</a> — which forced Twitter to roll out a “report abuse” feature for individual tweets. The feature came roughly six years into the company’s history and more than five years after Waldman’s ordeal. “It feels like, not only did they have opportunities early on to tackle this, but they had the ability to step up and be a leader in this space — to be proactive instead of reactive,” Waldman said. “That they haven’t done that is beyond me and it’s reckless.”</p><p>Around that time, high-profile harassment cases became a weekly, if not daily, occurrence, especially in the UK. Sinéad O’Connor was driven off the service in 2011; she later told the <em>Daily Mail</em> she was “<a href="http://www.dailymail.co.uk/tvshowbiz/article-2060495/Sinead-OConnor-quits-Twitter-followers-took-stories-sex-seriously.html">getting too much abuse</a>.” <em>Downton Abbey</em> actor Lily James quit after she became the target of hundreds of hateful tweets about her appearance. Actor Matt Lucas had to shut down his account after trolls wouldn’t stop harassing him after the death of his partner.</p><p>In the US, stories of Twitter harassment of women, people of color, and religious minorities appeared with increasing frequency, coming to a head in August 2014, when Robin Williams’ daughter Zelda was forced to quit Twitter after trolls flooded her mentions with photoshopped images of her recently deceased father. Williams’ departure from Twitter went viral and prompted Twitter’s Trust and Safety head, Del Harvey, to condemn the attacks. “We will not tolerate abuse of this nature,” she said, noting that the company would work to find policy fixes to prevent cases like Williams’.</p><p>It was also around this time that Twitter began broadcasting grisly ISIS beheadings and Gamergate’s multipronged misogynist harassment campaign toward female gamers. Harvey’s team rolled out more streamlined forms for reporting abuse, dispensing with its cumbersome nine-part questionnaire and adding back-end flagging tools for Twitter’s Trust and Safety team. One month later, Anita Sarkeesian, a feminist writer and video game critic, took to her Tumblr page and posted 157 of examples of misogyny, gendered insults, victim blaming, incitement to suicide, and rape and death threats she’d received in a recent six-day stretch on Twitter. Despite the overtures from Twitter, the trolls were winning.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/0*WaQCx6QlrMXt5X3B.jpg" /><figcaption>Ariel Davis / BuzzFeed News</figcaption></figure><p><strong>On October 25, 2013,</strong> Twitter released video of its IPO roadshow presentation to Wall Street underwriters. The 37-minute pitch, which resembles a grainy Skype session crossed with a PowerPoint presentation, features a well-dressed Dick Costolo (then Twitter’s CEO) in front of a blue background, staring down the barrel of the lens. “We think we’ve only scratched the surface of everything we think Twitter can become,” Costolo said unblinkingly into the camera. “There are over 2.4 billion connected people worldwide and over 230 million users on Twitter — we are less than 10% penetrated across the globe.” The implied logic: Twitter intends to connect the world and grow exponentially in the process.</p><p>That didn’t happen. Twitter’s lead-up to its public offering and subsequent lackluster Wall Street performance did, however, create a laundry list of new challenges that, according to some former employees, kneecapped Twitter’s product. “Leading up to IPO, it was all about revenue growth, from CEO on down,” a former member of Twitter’s product team told BuzzFeed News. “All investments went into revenue, and I know definitely that the consumer product suffered. Forget abuse — I don’t think we did anything with core consumer at that time, and I think that’s somewhat justified if the goal is going public,” the source said.</p><p>And if Twitter was far from tranquil before the IPO, it only became less so after. Though the company was bringing in considerable revenue, the fear of disappointing Wall Street with stagnant user numbers led Costolo and the executive team to reshuffle Twitter’s priorities again and again, according to multiple senior sources who worked closely with Costolo during this time. According to those sources, Costolo and the company’s newly hired banker turned CFO, Anthony Noto, were so reactive strategically that employees began referring internally to them as the company’s “ad-hocracy.”</p><blockquote><em>“If there’s a trash fire burning in your front yard, saying you don’t want to call the fire department because you don’t want to get the house wet is not really a sensical thing.”</em></blockquote><p>Nowhere was this felt more than on Twitter’s product team, the part of the company in charge of developing, testing, and rolling out new user features for Twitter across mobile and the web. “We had this area of intense, shifting focus in every area of the company around almost every issue other than abuse,” one former product team member said.” The result was that since 2010, Twitter has had seven heads of product (eight if you count Dorsey’s brief interim tenure in early 2016), with five of those job changes coming since 2014. “There were like four VPs of product during my time on the team … just never any continuity at all,” one former team member said. “There’s a lot of jokes you can say about the length of tenure of product heads,” another former employee said. “That lack of continuity means it’s difficult to get stuff done.”</p><p>“Finding a product solution for abuse was like looking for a moonshot,” another former employee said. “But NASA wouldn’t have put a person on the moon if between ’59 and ’69 there were seven heads of NASA.”</p><p>Sources inside the company in the years after Twitter’s IPO also said that product decisions were often scrapped or never advanced out of initial tests if they were thought to inhibit user growth. “I did see a lot of decisions being made in terms of growth when it came to how to handle abuse, which I get,” former engineering manager Leslie Miley told BuzzFeed News. “But on the other side, if there’s a trash fire burning in your front yard, saying you don’t want to call the fire department because you don’t want to get the house wet is not really a sensical thing.”</p><p>Miley — who was helping to roll out two-factor password authentication for the platform — described lobbying for a year to require all Twitter employees to enable two-factor for their own Twitter accounts. “I was adamant that there was no good reason not to do this, because who’s a bigger target for a Twitter hack than a Twitter employee,” he recalled. But Miley’s pleas went unheeded inside the executive branch, who worried the product was too hard for employees to use and might stop many inside the company from tweeting. “I was like, ‘Uh, what better way to fix that than deploying it to thousands and getting their input,’” Miley said. “But they said, ‘It’s still too hard to use and we want our people using the product.’” Shortly after Miley gave up on convincing company leadership to safeguard their accounts, Noto’s Twitter <a href="http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-02-10/twitter-cfo-anthony-noto-s-account-appears-to-have-been-hacked">account was hacked</a>.</p><p>Many former employees cite the stagnation of Twitter’s product team as a chief reason for the rise in harassment after 2012. “I think product has failed users,” one former senior employee told BuzzFeed News. Part of what makes Twitter so powerful is its ability to level the communication field; tweets from a non-famous, little-followed user, are, in theory, just as easy to surface as a celebrity’s. Simply, Twitter is built differently than most social networks. Two accounts don’t have to follow each other to interact, and once a tweet is out in the world, the original tweeter doesn’t have the ability to moderate responses, like they might on an Instagram or Facebook comment. This unique design is responsible for some of Twitter’s most revolutionary and serendipitous moments; it’s also perfect for abuse.</p><p>“For years, it allowed this equal footing, where a troll you didn’t follow and your best friend who you follow and interact with all the time were given equal weight, and that’s crazy,” a former senior employee said. “Seriously, if you were an alien and you came down to look at this thing, you’d say, ‘Oh, the product was basically built for maximum ease of trolling.’ Like, they must have built this <em>for</em> trolls.”</p><p>Employees close to the product team echoed these frustrations. “There are easy anti-abuse ideas that product managers brought up like 10 times — like, when you open any famous person tweet, the first reply you see should be somebody the tweeter follows, not just a rando,” one former employee said. “We talked about this idea five years ago — that’s an eternity in tech — and they’re not executed, and that does not give me hope that they think about this problem.”</p><p>Or, as one former employee said, “product inaction created a honeypot for assholes.”</p><blockquote><em>“Product inaction created a honeypot for assholes.”</em></blockquote><p>Sarah Hagi, an identity-focused writer who is perhaps best known for coining the phrase “Carry yourself with the confidence of a mediocre white man,” told BuzzFeed News she has been subject to intense abuse on Twitter since she started writing professionally. Hagi said that the harassment centered on her is mostly for being black, Muslim, and female — “any variation of me being a crazy Muslim animal or being a disgusting oppressed Muslim woman,” she said. “When I first started getting abusive comments, which would be anywhere from people insulting aspects of my identity to sending me photos of female genital mutilation, I would respond, but I quickly learned that makes it worse. Now, I either block or mute right away and try to not pay any attention.” The abuse can manifest in the form of an isolated response after a seemingly innocuous tweet; other times, it comes from a mob of accounts set upon her by a single troll with a large following. “I think because nothing really has changed with how Twitter deals with harassers, it has gotten worse,” she said. “They know nothing really will happen to them, so they continue doing whatever they want. “</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/0*68wOpzsz1JCEx-9u.jpg" /><figcaption>Ariel Davis / BuzzFeed News</figcaption></figure><p><strong>In 2015, <em>Guardian</em></strong> columnist Lindy West <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/society/2015/feb/02/what-happened-confronted-cruellest-troll-lindy-west">wrote about</a> her years-long experience with Twitter harassment. In response, Dick Costolo wrote his leaked “we suck at dealing with abuse” staff memo. At the time, employees inside Twitter thought the attention — and the memo — might provide some motivation to improve the product, but little changed once the media maelstrom shifted its focus. “There would be pressure after high-profile abuse that was getting press,” one former employee said. “But it was mostly, ‘Well, if we fix this problem this way it won’t happen again.’ And that’s too reactive — it felt like firefighting rather than asking, ‘How do we prevent fires?’”</p><p>Nearly all the former employees BuzzFeed News spoke to praised Harvey’s Trust and Safety team for its commitment to curbing harassment, but suggested that failures on the product side left it hamstrung. “They were on the front lines working with users and trying so hard,” a former senior employee said, “but getting caught in a rock and a hard place between what the stated mission of the company was and the resources available to create that environment.”</p><blockquote><em>“If Twitter had people in the room who’d been abused on the internet when they were creating the company, I can assure you the service would be different.”</em></blockquote><p>They were also limited by a workforce that multiple former employees say fundamentally didn’t understand what abuse looks and feels like. “The decision-makers were not people who got abuse and didn’t understand that it’s not about content, it’s about context,” Miley said. “If Twitter had people in the room who’d been abused on the internet — meaning not just straight, white males — when they were creating the company, I can assure you the service would be different.” A 2015 Women, Action, and the Media <a href="http://www.cjr.org/analysis/twitter_harassment_by_the_numbers.php">study revealed that</a>, as of 2014, Twitter’s leadership was 79% male and 72% white.</p><p>Miley was adamant about finding a proactive engineering solution for Twitter’s troll problem, but he said he consistently came up against opposition from a product team that favored content-based filters (preventing abusive tweets based on keywords) over context-based prevention (identifying and stopping harassment based on the accounts involved and the subject matter). In one instance, Miley argued to the company’s product safety team that a filtering algorithm for the keyword “cunt” was too broad and would censor accounts (in the UK, the word can be used as a slang term of endearment). “If you try to focus on keywords and the number of blocks and unfollows, you’ll end up with an algorithm or bot that doesn’t have the level of precision you need.”</p><p>Numerous former employees described Twitter’s approach to harassment as mimicking the company’s approach to fighting spam. “The focus on the engineering side was first on the spam problem, and it was a much more visible thing for more users than user safety and abuse problems,” a former employee familiar with the product team said. Miley echoed this: “Spam is a solved problem — we know how to detect and filter that. If you approach abuse like spam, you’ll never put a dent in abuse.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/0*xUy5AN8krRRwkzut.jpg" /><figcaption>Ariel Davis / BuzzFeed News</figcaption></figure><p><strong>According to former</strong> employees, the external pressures — stagnant growth, media scrutiny, and constant personnel shifts — even created fissures in Twitter’s once rock-solid free speech defense. Shortly after news broke that Zelda Williams was leaving Twitter, Costolo was getting DMs and texts from Hollywood agents at firms like CAA, threatening to pull their high-profile celebrity clients off Twitter if Costolo didn’t stop harassment. Costolo scrambled, ordering teams to delete offending accounts and tweets. Weeks later, when a rash of beheading videos appeared, Costolo gave similar takedown orders, causing Twitter’s free speech advocates, Gabriel Stricker and Vijaya Gadde, to call an emergency policy meeting.</p><p>Inside the meeting, attended by Costolo, Stricker, Gadde, and product head Kevin Weil (now Instagram’s product lead) and first reported by BuzzFeed News, tensions rose as Costolo’s desire to build a more palatable network that was marketable and ultimately attractive to new users clashed with Stricker and Gadde’s desire for radically free expression.</p><p>“You really think we should have videos of people being murdered?” someone who attended the meeting recalls Costolo arguing, while Stricker reportedly compared Costolo’s takedown of undesirable content to deleting the Zapruder film after objections from the Kennedy family. Ultimately, the meeting ended with the group deciding to carve out policy exceptions to keep up grisly content for newsworthiness, according to one person present. Though Stricker and Gadde won, one source described a frustrated Costolo leaving in disagreement. “I think if you guys have your way the only people using Twitter will be ISIS and the ACLU,” Costolo said, according to this person.</p><p>“I think the pressure over user growth totally exacerbated Dick’s decision-making at this time,” the source told BuzzFeed News. “Looking back, it’s that ongoing part of the ad-hocracy — we can’t have big policy precedents being set by one person for one small scenario when nobody’s watching. Meanwhile, we have teams also talking with Russian and Turkish dictators asking us to censor the platform for them and we’re telling them to fuck off. There’s no continuity.”</p><p>But, according to sources, Costolo continued making censorship decisions for celebrities — sometimes in secret. In the middle of 2015, Costolo and Noto, frustrated that Reddit had become the internet’s go-to destination for celebrity Q&amp;A sessions, made a push via Twitter’s media team to facilitate more live town-hall discussions with influential users. In May 2015, after the company secured an #AskPOTUS Q&amp;A with President Obama, Costolo secretly ordered the media partnerships team inside Twitter to use an algorithm to filter all tweets directed at the president for abusive language.</p><p>According to one source, the algorithm was fed thousands of examples of abusive and harassing language in order to block vitriolic tweets. Another source said the media partnerships team also manually censored tweets, noting that Twitter’s public quality filtering algorithms were inconsistent. Participants in the #AskPOTUS town hall were never informed that tweets would be censored, and two sources told BuzzFeed News that the decision to filter was kept from specific senior company employees, for fear they would object to the decision.</p><p>Another source alleges that Twitter also deployed the censoring algorithm for a Q&amp;A with Caitlyn Jenner. “This was another example of trying to woo celebs and show that you can have civilized conversations without the hate even if you’re a high-profile person,” one former employee said. “But it’s another example of a double standard — we’ll protect our celebrities, while the average user is out there subject to all kinds of horrible things.” Costolo did not respond to multiple requests for comment.</p><p>Just a month after the Obama Q&amp;A, Costolo stepped down as CEO, retaining a seat on Twitter’s board. In an exit interview with <em>The</em> <em>Guardian</em> on June 30, 2015, he defended Twitter’s commitment to free speech. “I will say directly that I think regulation is a threat to free speech,” he said.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/0*EQA0zdAQ0Y-IJ22N.jpg" /><figcaption>Ariel Davis / BuzzFeed News</figcaption></figure><p><strong>The Jenner and</strong> Obama incidents weren’t the only time Twitter’s seeming double standard for celebrities and non-celebrities was thrown into relief. This July, when <em>Ghostbusters</em> actor and <em>Saturday Night Live</em> cast member Leslie Jones was subject to a cascade of racist and sexist harassment led by conservative blogger Milo Yiannopoulos, Jones quit the service. Twitter’s current CEO, Jack Dorsey, reached out to Jones and, <a href="http://www.vulture.com/2016/07/leslie-jones-discusses-her-twitter-trolls.html?mid=twitter_vulture">following a conversation</a>, permanently banned Yiannopoulos. Jones returned, but Twitter’s process for handling high-profile instances like Jones’ remains opaque.</p><p>And a simple Twitter search for “harassment” turns up dozens of frustrated non-celebrity users, many of whom experience daily threats and abuse, and almost none of whom have a direct line to Dorsey. One tweet from author and writer Jessica Valenti <a href="https://twitter.com/JessicaValenti/status/758347430765232128">suggested</a> that the trolls were unfazed by Twitter’s ban. “This morning I woke up to a rape and death threat directed at my 5 year old daughter. That this is part of my work life is unacceptable,” it read.</p><p>Last month, during the company’s most recent earnings call, Dorsey made a familiar declaration, vowing to combat abuse in the coming months. “No one deserves to be the target of abuse on Twitter,” Dorsey <a href="http://variety.com/2016/digital/news/twitter-ceo-jack-dorsey-user-abuse-1201823778/">said</a>. “And we need to do better.” Former employees are skeptical at best. “I think any time you have a change in leadership, the priorities shift a bit,” Miley, who left Twitter early in 2016, told BuzzFeed News. “When Dick left and Jack came on there was a lot of jockeying on what are the priorities are for Twitter, and I think the focus dropped off of abuse,” he said. Another source was concerned that Dorsey’s other day job — as CEO of Square — might make solving harassment more difficult. “Jack is wonderful and truly cares deeply about harassment, but as a part-time CEO, it’s really difficult to keep the pressure on,” the source said. “He’s incredible, but at least on the Twitter side, the company needs 1,000% focus.”</p><p>As always, there’s hope from executives that Twitter will make things right. In February, Twitter formed a <a href="https://techcrunch.com/2016/02/09/twitter-forms-a-trust-safety-council-to-balance-abuse-vs-free-speech/">Trust and Safety Council</a>, with more than 40 partners, including Anita Sarkeesian, to provide product and policy input. Co-founder Biz Stone told BuzzFeed News that, behind the scenes under Dorsey, “Twitter is working hard, and making progress in this space.” And he added that Twitter needs to evolve with the times: “No employee should ever be in the position of having to decide, subjectively, what qualifies as free speech and what does not. A strong constitution goes a long way here.” A former senior executive suggested that Twitter has new plans in the works, and that he has even mocked up comprehensive product solutions to combat abuse, which have been given to Dorsey.</p><p>Others suggest that forthcoming changes, while necessary, might be too little, too late. “If tomorrow Twitter implemented a set of super reasonable reforms, it would rightly suffer the criticism that, while this is great, it took too long,” a former senior employee told BuzzFeed News. “The longer you wait to take steps, the better the fixes need to be. It’s like, ‘Awesome! But it took took you 10 years. What’s wrong with you people?’”</p><p>When reached for comment, a Twitter spokesperson emailed the following statement: “Safety on Twitter is a top priority for us. No one deserves to be subjected to abuse online and our rules prohibit inciting or engaging in abuse or harassment.”</p><p><strong>Eight years after</strong> her blog post, Ariel Waldman, the first public case of Twitter harassment, has moved on. Waldman chose not to quit Twitter, opting to endure the trolls and slurs in favor of its benefits.</p><blockquote><em>“It feels like so much work to use Twitter, and that should be a real red flag.”</em></blockquote><p>But things have grown worse. In the last two weeks she was barraged with dozens of abusive tweets after she posted a photo of herself wearing a headscarf she bought for an upcoming trip to Iran. “Within seconds I had a deluge of people tweeting the most racist stuff at me — it was bordering on murderous,” she said. So she deleted the tweet, blocked dozens of users, and posted the photo to Instagram, where she isn’t harassed. A few days ago Waldman tweeted about an upcoming NASA grant and the tweet was seized upon by neo-Nazis advocating for the genocide of all people of color.</p><p>Waldman, like every single one of the dozen people interviewed for this story, stressed that she loved Twitter; that when it works as it should, it’s empowering, exciting, even life-changing. But, like almost every participant in this story, Waldman’s voice grew tired while making excuses for Twitter’s shortcomings. “I mean, the thing is that it’s just getting to that point where it’s become such an exhausting service to use,” she said with a heavy sigh. “That blocking 20 awful people every day has to be a part of my logistical reality — even when I’m not seeking abuse out. It’s just — it feels like so much work to use Twitter, and that should be a real red flag. They’ve clearly showed they don’t want to make abuse a priority.</p><p>“It’s like, who would reasonably want to use a service that does this to you?”</p><p><a href="https://www.buzzfeed.com/"><strong>Check out more articles on BuzzFeed.com!</strong></a></p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://www.buzzfeed.com/charliewarzel/a-honeypot-for-assholes-inside-twitters-10-year-failure-to-s"><em>www.buzzfeed.com</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b394e4b18a89" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/twitter-harassment/a-honeypot-for-assholes-inside-twitters-10-year-failure-to-stop-harassment-b394e4b18a89">“A Honeypot For Assholes”: Inside Twitter’s 10-Year Failure To Stop Harassment</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/twitter-harassment">Twitter Harassment</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[FiveThirtyHate: Meet The Trump Movement’s Post-Truth, Post-Math Anti-Nate Silver]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/buzzfeed-collections/fivethirtyhate-meet-the-trump-movements-post-truth-post-math-anti-nate-silver-906076169d11?source=rss-1b0b4ee5ae6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/906076169d11</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[bf-collections]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[2016-election]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[donald-trump]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Charlie Warzel]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 26 Oct 2016 01:10:22 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-10-26T01:10:22.381Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*uKsi22U-PLCWFl_Ddsbngw.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>BuzzFeed News; YourVoice Radio</em></figcaption></figure><h4>As the final weeks of the presidential campaign devolve into accusations of conspiracy and fraud, the most talked-about Trump supporter might be a poll-hating Twitter pundit who has no official role with the campaign. Bill Mitchell is here to win the ground game in our hearts.</h4><p><strong>On March 9, 2016</strong>, Mitt Romney was sitting on one of Jimmy Kimmel’s purple crushed-velvet chairs just trying to be a good sport. “This one’s from a Trump supporter,” Kimmel said as Romney accepted a stack of note cards full of PG-13 tweets calling the former Republican presidential nominee a loser. Through a pained smile, Romney read the contents of the card for the audience at home: “Donald Trump is trying to pull America back from the brink and freakin’ Mitt Romney is playing with matches in the bathroom.” Romney paused a beat, flashing a tired Jim Halpert-esque smile to the camera that’s all but become our national facial expression this election cycle, and shook his head. “I’m not touching that, I’ll tell you that.”</p><p>The bit dredged up a few nostalgic laughs and would make the rounds the next day on cable news. But the real effect was felt 3,000 miles away in a house in suburban Charlotte, North Carolina, in the Twitter mentions of a 56-year-old executive recruiter named Bill Mitchell. It had been Mitchell’s tweet that Romney read aloud, and though it was after midnight on the East Coast, his phone lit up as his 20,000 followers giddily tweeted him; the Kimmel shout-out was, as the Donald might put it, “big league.” It didn’t matter that the segment was as much about laughing at the impotent vitriol of the anonymous tweeters as it was at Romney; for Mitchell, the bit was proof of concept: It was fine if people were laughing at him as long they were paying attention.</p><p>Seven months later, Bill Mitchell — or @mitchellvii, as he’s known on Twitter — has more than quadrupled his audience. Tweeting an average of 270 times per day, he has arguably become Donald Trump’s most unrelenting social media surrogate. Despite Trump’s leaked tax returns and sexual assault allegations, Mitchell isn’t just unwavering in his support, but increasingly certain of his candidate’s chances, gunslinging 140-character projections like this one into the world every few minutes:</p><h3>Bill Mitchell on Twitter</h3><p>Trump has a 100% chance of winning in November.</p><p>Mitchell has become this cycle’s mascot for a specific strain of poll-unskewing, conspiracy-theorist Trump supporter — earnest enough in his mistrust of modern electoral data and disdain for basic math that <a href="https://twitter.com/search?q=bill%20mitchell%20parody%20account&amp;src=typd">many have suspected</a> @mitchellvii is perhaps a parody account. A few of his greatest hits:</p><ul><li><a href="https://twitter.com/mitchellvii/status/772460287572185088">“You notice how close Trump stands to this black man as he listens to him? No racist would ever do that.”</a></li><li><a href="https://twitter.com/mitchellvii/status/782341495063994368">“If you think about it, Hillary putting women into ‘baskets’ may be one of the most sexist things ever said in a political campaign.”</a></li><li><a href="https://twitter.com/ChrisCJackson/status/784383701165670400">“Trump’s groundgame isn’t in a computer, it’s in our hearts”</a></li><li><a href="https://twitter.com/mitchellvii/status/762497721831874561">“Imagine polls don’t exist. Show me evidence Hillary is winning?”</a></li><li><a href="https://twitter.com/mitchellvii/status/784828630933368832">“Jesus was perfect and the media of his day had him crucified.”</a></li></ul><p>But Bill Mitchell is no performance artist and, should you meet him, he’ll tell you that unprompted. “Oh, people think this is a parody account? Well, I have 90,000 followers and a blue check, so explain that,” he told me over a recent Skype interview. (Mitchell wouldn’t do in-person interviews for “security reasons,” suggesting “there are those on Team Hillary who do not wish me well.”) Where many of Trump’s most visible surrogates appear worn down, hateful, or actual card-carrying bigots, @mitchellvii is an eternal optimist, hardly ever curses, and stays largely away from the language of the alt-right.</p><p>And as Trump continues to distance himself from his party and even his advisers, his increasingly paranoid message is beginning to sound like one long @mitchellvii tweetstorm. But unlike Trump’s operatives and surrogates, Mitchell has no campaign ties and no professional reputation to lose. He’s just a guy tweeting from his home office and, arguably, the only person alive who will come out of the 2016 presidential campaign better than he started it.</p><blockquote><em>“Oh, people think this is a parody account? Well, I have 90,000 followers and a blue check, so explain that.”</em></blockquote><p><strong>Glancing at his</strong> Twitter bio page, you’d think Bill Mitchell has been around the conservative talk pundit scene for ages. His face is long, with a head of well-styled silver hair and an intense jawline and bushy eyebrows that arch at a cartoonish pitch. Alongside his headshot, his bio boasts that his show, <em>YourVoice™ Radio</em>, is “a number one political talk show.” No matter that the show is hosted on a DIY podcasting platform and has only a few thousand listeners per episode. “Everyone seemed to assume he was some sort of somebody — like, a longtime local radio guy or whatever,” one reporter told me when I asked if he knew where Mitchell came from.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/625/1*V1_LJK_DBObsnrpS--XHPQ.png" /><figcaption>Mitchell’s radio show, which streams on YouTube.</figcaption></figure><p>In truth, Mitchell’s only qualification seems to be that he just started tweeting a lot. “I’ve always been clever with words,” he said. “As a recruiter, I make my living as a communicator. I’m good with word images and painting pictures with a short phrase here and there that people can relate to.” When asked how much time he spends crafting his tweets, he dismissed the idea that there’s too much forethought. “I’m just firing the thoughts out as I come to them. I have an interesting take, you see. I delve into the internals and really tell people what’s going on and it’s given me some fame.”</p><blockquote><em>“I’m good with word images.”</em></blockquote><p>Mitchell believes he’s been able to tap into a powerful demographic of disenfranchised, underrepresented voters who feel the country is on the wrong track and in need of a savior. “These are the people who call into Rush Limbaugh who hold on the line and never get on the air. My tweets caught on because I was saying out loud and using my talent for words to say what they wanted.” According to Mitchell, he’s averaging 40,000 retweets and 10 million Twitter impressions each day.</p><p>Mitchell’s appeal makes sense — he’s one of them. Like his audience, he’s quick to indulge a good conspiracy theory and subscribes to a media diet free of “mainstream bias,” reading Breitbart, <em>Conservative Treehouse</em>, <em>DC Whispers</em>, the <em>Gateway Pundit</em>, and the occasional Drudge article. He doesn’t check mainstream sites and networks like CNN or MSNBC because “it’s all spin to me.” For a growing number of Americans who’ve defined themselves online by adding “Deplorable” to their Twitter handle, @mitchellvii is a beacon in a growing storm of bad news — a kind of post-truth, post-math Nate Silver. For everyone else, the account is an almost anthropological look at Trumpism at its most simple-minded.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/990/1*8SftPfwrTZcd7NfqUXwFWA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Mitchell’s executive recruiting business website.</figcaption></figure><p><strong>When we spoke,</strong> Mitchell was fighting off a nasty flu he’d picked up around the same time that leaked footage from <em>Access Hollywood</em> showed Trump bragging about groping and kissing women. But rather than let it sideline him, Mitchell saw his fever and laryngitis as a kind of divine test. “They say that opportunity knocks at inopportune times and that’s why so many people don’t live out their dreams,” Mitchell told me. “I won’t lie to you, this is fun. I’m on a mission.”</p><p>To hear Mitchell tell it, that mission started around the time he was 10 years old, putting up signs in his neighborhood for Nixon. He’s a lifelong Republican but didn’t find the spark until he watched Ross Perot run as an independent presidential candidate in 1992. For Mitchell, who’s run his own business for decades, the idea of a businessman in the White House just seemed to make sense. And in June 2015, he got his wish with Donald Trump. “Around then I was an armchair quarterback with only 100 Twitter followers,” he said. “But when he decided to run, that’s when I decided to jump in.”</p><p>Traces of Mitchell’s online presence from before he took his Trump oath of allegiance reveal an exceedingly average middle-aged man. He’s unmarried and has no kids. He graduated of the University of Maryland in 1982 and now runs an executive recruiting business, ExecutiveDecision.biz, which touts his “bold, pro-active style” that “empowers clients to acquire the finest staff on target, on time, every time.” His Yahoo Answers profile, stretching back more than a decade, paints a fuller picture. Across hundreds of questions and answers, Mitchell reveals a successful recovery from colon cancer, a frequent desire for feedback on whether or not to color his graying hair, and endless mundane curiosities ranging from the silly (<a href="https://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20070114170033AAuw0Ej">“Why do Jack Russell owners all look like the [<em>sic</em>] want to kill themselves?” “</a><a href="https://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20061222155500AAMg0Cl">Would a bumble bee the size of a man be able to fly?”</a>) to the more existential (<a href="https://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20070105051630AAygHc2">“What is intuition and how often is it correct?”</a> <a href="https://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20100111055116AAxtOjG">“Why don’t they create a condom that covers just the top inch of your penis?”)</a>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/680/1*QXY_NhbU7nTwv9ywlT1k-Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>Screenshots of Mitchell’s Yahoo! Answers activity.</figcaption></figure><p>When he talks about polls, Mitchell’s friendly voice lowers considerably to the cadence of a condescending Little League coach. Mitchell’s take is that the polls are skewed to further silence Trump and the silent majority as a result of oversampling and overweighting Democrats. Get him going on the subject and he’ll argue that scientifically random polls conducted via landlines aren’t actually scientific or random, given the response rates; that the margins of error and small sample size tend to disqualify the national polls; and that major media polls don’t take into account built-in bias and key X factors — a favorite of Mitchell’s is “enthusiasm,” which Mitchell often calculates via tweets, yard signs, and rally sizes (Trump’s are YUGE, while Hillary struggles to put together a crowd of 200, he contends).</p><h3>Brendan Nyhan on Twitter</h3><p>I will say it again: If Bill Mitchell didn&#39;t exist, people who teach stats &amp;amp; surveys would have to invent him. Approaching performance art. https://t.co/x2il49STqf</p><p>While in previous years this contempt for math would be roundly dismissed by all except the far fringes, today Mitchell’s message is inexplicably of the moment, casting the armchair tweeter in a different light. In a perfect world, Mitchell said, he would like to see polls abolished altogether — although he believes unscientific polls conducted via survey embeds on sites like the Drudge Report do a decent job capturing that elusive metric of <em>enthusiasm</em>. “If you arrived here from Mars today and you didn’t speak English but you saw Trump every single day of the week at these rallies — he’s dominating online, he’s dominating yard signs and rallies and all the physical things we can see. You’d think, <em>This guy is winning</em>. If it were up to me I’d make polling illegal. This is just my dream world.”</p><blockquote><em>“The prize for the dumbest motherfucker on the internet goes to Bill Mitchell. This is a guy who’s proud of the fact that he doesn’t understand math.”</em></blockquote><p>Pollsters and political operatives seem to agree that he’s living on a different plane of existence.</p><p>“The prize for the dumbest motherfucker on the internet — and there’s lots of competition this cycle — goes to Bill Mitchell, who’s way out ahead of the field,” Republican strategist Rick Wilson said when I asked him about Mitchell’s brand of punditry. “In the course of my 20-year career I’ve commissioned hundreds of surveys, from presidential polling to state house races,” Wilson said, through intermittent, heavy sighs. “I’ve consumed a lot of polling, and this is a guy who’s proud of the fact that he doesn’t understand math.”</p><p>Pollster Frank Luntz routinely takes shots at Mitchell on Twitter, calling into question Mitchell’s basic understanding of statistics. When Mitchell infamously tweeted this summer, “imagine polls don’t exist. Show me evidence Hilary is winning?” <em>FiveThirtyEight</em>’s Nate Silver had a laugh at his expense, <a href="https://twitter.com/natesilver538/status/762649765687365633">tweeting</a>, “Imagine there’s no polls/ It’s easy if you try/ No Pew or Quinnipiac/ On crowd size we rely.” Both Luntz and Silver did not respond to multiple requests to comment on Mitchell’s polling views.</p><p>Republican pollster Kristen Soltis Anderson — who recently had Mitchell’s “groundgame is in our hearts” tweet <a href="https://www.instagram.com/p/BLrO2x7BLHO/">made into a ceramic coffee mug</a> — is perhaps as charitable toward Mitchell as any statistician could possibly be. For her part, she understands the skepticism, driven by historical and recent polling misses like the Brexit vote. “He says in 140 characters the most absolutely perfect nonsense that anyone with any understanding can dismantle entirely,” Anderson said. “But we’re living in a post-fact environment. And If you don’t like the polls, having somebody who tells you they’re wrong makes you feel good.”</p><h3>Frank Luntz on Twitter</h3><p>Honestly surprised I didn&#39;t see @MitchellVII mentioned in here. https://t.co/rGryy5b28t</p><p>Becoming the laughingstock of the Washington establishment does not appear to trouble Mitchell. “I’m making all the right enemies,” he said. “You know you’ve made it on Twitter when famous people are trolling you. Frank Luntz trolls me all the time and I enjoy when they troll me. I enjoy the battle of wits.”</p><blockquote><em>“I’m making all the right enemies.”</em></blockquote><p><strong>Despite Mitchell’s</strong> <strong>retweet-happy</strong> followers, his influence, even inside the Trump-supporting fringe conservative media sphere, is unclear. Before starting his homemade podcast, Mitchell was a frequent guest on the <em>Wayne Dupree Show</em>, a conservative podcast with a Cleveland AM radio following. Mitchell left the show abruptly under mysterious circumstances. (He has tweeted the departure was friendly and that he wanted to strike out on his own; Dupree didn’t wish to comment on the departure.)</p><p>Though he’s been retweeted three or four times by Trump himself, Mitchell claims he has no direct contact with the campaign and that no money has ever changed hands in return for his tens of thousands of on-message tweets. He suggested he’s in touch with a number of individuals close to the campaign and believes that the distance is “by design, so that I can remain an independent voice.” But one conservative media source suggested that Mitchell’s outsider status might have more to do with ego issues.</p><p>“He thought he was going to be in charge of a Trump group in North Carolina months ago, and when he got there, he found out he wasn’t and left, deciding not to be a part,” a source said. Mitchell plays this down, alleging that he volunteered to run social media for the campaign in North Carolina but quit after a few weeks, deciding his personal account was more helpful to the campaign. Still, one source believes there’s tension between Mitchell and the campaign, explaining that earlier this year, Trump’s adviser and social media director Dan Scavino unfollowed Mitchell after an incessant series of Twitter direct messages filled with “pointers about how wrong they were doing social media.” Mitchell, for his part denies any bad blood or spat with Scavino. Scavino did not respond to multiple requests for comment.</p><p>But what’s in it for Mitchell? He says that the work that goes into his radio show and constant tweeting “hasn’t come without considerable personal financial cost.” Still, he claims he hasn’t given thought to what could come after Election Day. “I have friends on TV who say when all’s said and done I should pursue this. I have people who now, before they go on TV, they contact me and say, ‘This is what we’re talking about — what should I say?’ and I give them zingers.” Though Mitchell wouldn’t reveal the identities of his TV friends, his podcast show has hosted, among others, Trump surrogate Katrina Pierson and conservative activist James O’Keefe.</p><p>But Mitchell’s influence is considerable — earlier this year, the MIT Media Lab listed him as <a href="https://medium.com/mit-media-lab/who-s-influencing-election-2016-8bed68ddecc3">the 26th-most influential Twitter account</a> of this election cycle (the highest-ranked non-politician or journalist), between Lindsey Graham and Megyn Kelly. But neither a politician with the constant pressure to win elections nor a journalist bound by network standards and practices, Mitchell appears to have very little at stake. He is free to tout conspiracy theories that Clinton cheated in the debates with elaborate signals and teleprompters or that polls are an irresponsible way to take the pulse of an electorate.</p><p>“Trump has been caused, in large part, by a daily war against reality, waged not just by people at Fox News, but the Breitbarts of the world and random talk radio hosts like Bill Mitchell,” former Obama speechwriter Jon Favreau told me. “Information and media consumption is so diffuse now, you have all these people on the right feeding other voters lies and alternative realities on a daily basis, and Bill is one of those people.”</p><p>Mitchell, for his part, is not worried about being wrong. After all, while the so-called experts dismissed Trump’s chances throughout the primaries, Mitchell was predicting landslide defeats with his gut, which he says is his guide. “It’s better to have tried and given it 100% than to sit back and worry about it,” he said. “I do what I think is right every day and say what I believe.”</p><p><strong>Mitchell’s first</strong> <strong>big</strong> post-election opportunity may come immediately, should Hillary Clinton win — a scenario Mitchell refused to entertain without multiple assurances that this was speculative and very unlikely. “If, hypothetically, she can win, my predisposition will be that there’s cheating involved,” he said, without any hesitation. It’s the same supposition that Trump is now pushing at rallies, foreshadowing a conspiracy-driven media war between the mainstream and the Trump truthers on which someone like Mitchell could hang his post-election reputation.</p><blockquote><em>“He’s like this fascist Jack Handey.”</em></blockquote><p>Some, like Rick Wilson, aren’t so sure that Mitchell’s schtick has staying power. “I think guys like Mitchell are cultish in ways we haven’t seen in American political life in a long time,” he said. “I think they’re going to be stunned when they lose, shocked it’s happening, and not be able to handle it. And I think it’s gonna be hard to have Trumpism without Trump.”</p><p>It’s hard to say how much of Mitchell’s current popularity is derived from fans desperate for confirmation bias who’re hoovering up his analysis as gospel and what percentage comes from an incredulous faction who <a href="https://twitter.com/search?q=bill%20mitchell%20parody&amp;src=typd">can’t believe he’s real.</a> “He’s like this fascist Jack Handey,” one reporter told me. Of course, as Trump’s rhetoric grows darker and begins to border on inciting revolution, Mitchell’s mainstream appeal as the butt of a sarcastic retweet joke may be waning.</p><h3>Bill Mitchell on Twitter</h3><p>You notice how close Trump stands to this black man as he listens to him? No racist would ever do that.</p><p>In an election season that has become increasingly destructive and depleting, it’s been a good 18 months for Bill Mitchell; he seems almost energized by the deepening partisan divide and vitriol, which will come in handy during a potential Clinton administration. Regardless of what happens, he will wake up on Nov. 9 in a position he couldn’t have imagined last year.</p><p>“If Trump wins this election, my reputation stands to blow up. I’ve been there since the beginning — one of the few guys who never wavered,” Mitchell said defiantly before pausing a beat and sounding a bit like the Donald himself. “And, you know, if Trump doesn’t win, then maybe I’ll fade away and be the guy I was before all this. And hey, that’s not so bad. I had a great life going here.” ●</p><p><em>This story was updated to include Mitchell’s denial of the reports of bad blood between Trump social media manager Dan Scavino and Mitchell.</em></p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://www.buzzfeed.com/charliewarzel/meet-the-trump-movements-post-truth-post-math-anti-nate-silv?utm_term=.hv5xm4OR3"><em>www.buzzfeed.com</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=906076169d11" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/buzzfeed-collections/fivethirtyhate-meet-the-trump-movements-post-truth-post-math-anti-nate-silver-906076169d11">FiveThirtyHate: Meet The Trump Movement’s Post-Truth, Post-Math Anti-Nate Silver</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/buzzfeed-collections">BuzzFeed Collections</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[proof of life [death]]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/deadblog-blogdead-deathblog/proof-of-life-death-bccd37773471?source=rss-1b0b4ee5ae6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/bccd37773471</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Charlie Warzel]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 17 May 2013 19:49:05 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2013-05-17T19:49:05.411Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/401/0*KkhwJSbaT4U1bhfC.png" /></figure><p>QED.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=bccd37773471" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/deadblog-blogdead-deathblog/proof-of-life-death-bccd37773471">proof of life [death]</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/deadblog-blogdead-deathblog">deadblog blogDead DeAtHbLoG</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>