<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Censored on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Censored on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@cyruscylinder48?source=rss-6d84b70473ca------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 23:30:21 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@cyruscylinder48/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Genocide through the Looking Glass]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@cyruscylinder48/genocide-through-the-looking-glass-20cfe6b2f3db?source=rss-6d84b70473ca------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/20cfe6b2f3db</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[media]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[war]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Censored]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 06 Jun 2026 09:26:47 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-06-06T09:26:47.401Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/907/1*twCfd5ah1CKi7Y9NhuWfKA.png" /></figure><p>In addition to the previous entry, “Genocide Through the Looking Glass”, this blog is meant to bring you, the readers, the true speeches and words of victims, aggressors and politicians during the Gujarat Riots. The previous piece was meant to highlight the themes of <em>Final Solution (2004)</em> and how it was able to validate its claim about the 2004 Riots being either state-sponsored or at the least, not contained by the authorities due to malintent, not incompetence. For the sake of brevity and conciseness we could not include the chilling dialogue of the documentary despite its notable influence on us.</p><p>This piece contains excerpts from the documentary which impacted us the most. Going in a chronological order, let these speeches push you to watch this insightful documentary which provides a contemporary source on one of the blurriest, most contentious and most violent periods of post-colonial Indian history.</p><p><em>*When quoting, we do not use the subtitles in the documentary as they are not completely accurate to the dialogue that is spoken in Hindi. Direct subtitles for quoting are used only for speech in Gujarati as neither of us speak the language.</em></p><p><em>**Furthermore, this blog mentions violence, rape, mutilation, murder and massacres while covering the Gujarat Riots. If you feel uncomfortable with such material, please read based on your discretion or read our other blogs which do not mention such events.</em></p><h3>Lens #1: Through Children</h3><p>This is the thread which ties all aspects of the documentary together. For this reason, the documentary starts and ends with this interview of Ijaz — a child in senior kindergarten whose family was attacked in the Chamanpura attack. The narrator sits down with this traumatized child who is unencumbered by the civilities and masks used by the adults in the documentary. Ijaz does not have any reason to lie or soften the gory details in his memory and such complex thoughts do not cross his mind. Hence, this is the purest insight into the mind of someone who faced unimaginable violence against their own family.</p><p>– — — — –</p><p>The transcript of the opening scene is as follows:</p><p><em>Ijaz: </em>After the burning in Chamanpura, I came here.They killed everybody.</p><p><em>Interviewer: </em>Did you see anything</p><p><em>Ijaz: </em>Yes</p><p><em>Interviewer:</em> What did you see?</p><p><em>Ijaz:</em> They attacked people with swords. They attacked my grandfather and aunt. My father went to save my grandfather, they cut his fingers. They stabbed (<em>sabko kata tha</em>) everyone. They stripped the women before killing them</p><p><em>Interviewer:</em> In front of you?</p><p><em>Ijaz:</em> Yes, even my aunt. They didn’t strip the men</p><p><em>Interviewer:</em> Who did this?</p><p><em>Ijaz:</em> Those Hindu people who came.</p><p>This forthrightness in tone and description is brought back in the closing scenes in the documentary, when the interview with Ijaz resumes. The transcript goes as follows:</p><p><em>Interviewer:</em> What will you grow up to be?</p><p><em>Ijaz: </em>A soldier. Then I’ll burn them!<br><em>Interviewer:</em> Who?</p><p><em>Ijaz: </em>Hindus</p><p><em>Interviewer:</em> Why?</p><p><em>Ijaz:</em> Because they did the same</p><p><em>Interviewer:</em> Why do you want to do bad things like them?</p><p><em>Ijaz:</em> I’ll definitely kill them</p><p><em>Interviewer:</em> Why?</p><p><em>Ijaz:</em> I won’t spare them</p><p><em>Interviewer:</em> Are all Hindus bad</p><p><em>Ijaz:</em> They all use bad words (slurs)</p><p><em>Interviewer: </em>What kind of bad words?</p><p><em>Ijaz:</em> I don’t use bad words.</p><p><em>Interviewer:</em> I am Hindu too… So do I seem bad to you?</p><p><em>Ijaz: </em>No</p><p><em>Interviewer: </em>So when you become a soldier, will you spare me?</p><p><em>Ijaz: [Pauses] </em>Yes, I will spare you. I won’t burn anyone. I’ll only kill Hindus</p><p><em>Interviewer: </em>But I am also a Hindu</p><p><em>Ijaz: </em>No you aren’t one.</p><p><em>Interviewer: </em>Do I not seem Hindu?</p><p><em>Ijaz: [Shakes head]</em></p><p><em>Interviewer:</em> Then what do I seem like?</p><p><em>Ijaz:</em> You seem like a Muslim</p><p>– — — — –</p><p>We circle back to the child who, having seen violence is now motivated to be violent in the future. While this idea of retribution can be attributed to the fact that Ijaz is child, most adults in this documentary follow this idea, whether it be those Hindutva supporters who support and partake in the killings of Muslims to ‘avenge’ Godhra victims or the terrorists who attacked the Akshardham temple. Ijaz is the only one who does not hide this under grand ideas of “justice” and “national identity”, but highlights the simplistic and rudimentary view of violence and revenge. This closing interview shows how the violence is not contained to the 3 days of riots, but creates generational waves and leaves behind the Terror Trail (The title of the third section of the documentary).</p><p>Furthermore, this highlights a very important aspect of violence- dehumanization and generalization. Ijaz believes that all Hindus are bad due to the violence committed against his family. However, when the interviewer asks whether Ijaz would kill him due to him being Hindu, first Ijaz says he will not kill him and then later says that he does not seem Hindu but rather Muslim- likely due to Ijaz not being able to comprehend the fact that a Hindu man is being considerate to him and holding a dialogue. Similarly, in real life we see how people dehumanize entire communities and enact collective punishment in the form of revenge. This repeated in the Gujarat Riots where muslims were massacred after the Godhra Train Burning. The cause of the train burning down is contentious with some believing that it was done by Muslims and others believing that it was an internal fire caused by kerosene stoves. Even if the theory about Muslims burning down the train compartment were true (which is arguable) — would that justify this genocide? This same thinking led to the unilateral mass murder and rape of innocent men, women and children.</p><p>Therefore, this conversation with Ijaz was chosen to open and close the documentary. Hearing these words come out of the mouth of a 6 year old is one of the most impactful parts of this documentary- a must-watch for all people aiming to understand the roots of violence and terrorism.</p><h3>Lens #2: Through Narrators and Narratives</h3><p>This scene is meant to highlight the power of media narratives and propaganda. Furthermore, it shows rationalization and communal thinking and how that leads to violence and the suppression of victims. This scene flips back and forth from a female victim of the Naroda Patiya massacre and the daughters of a man with an alias <em>Bhawani</em> who was jailed for communal violence and alleged to have partook in violence against Kausar Bano. The Kausar Bano case is especially gruesome and I suggest skipping the next paragraph if you are sensitive to violence and gore.</p><p>One of the women recounts the murder of Kausar Bano in the Naroda Patiya massacre, a woman who was pregnant. She says, “Kausar, standing next to me, was pregnant. Her womb was split open, the fetus impaled.” Moreover, the woman mentions, “Women who tried to escape the fire were molested..some of them clamped [women’s] mouths, some of them took off their clothes.”</p><p>– — — — –</p><p>The transcript of the scene goes as follows:</p><p><em>Youngest Daughter of Bhawani</em>: Our names have been dragged into this, our name is in the entire world! My brother and father, 52 with such grown up daughters, both him and my brother, a lawyer, are in jail… We gave [Victims? Muslims? They were very vague in this claim] food and shelter now for the world we are kingpins. Accusing your savior- how is it just? Who will save you again?</p><p><em>Another Female Relative of Bhawani</em>: I don’t know why they wrote about us. We have no enmity, no quarrels.. My father was in no politics no BJP or congress no politics.</p><p><em>Youngest Daughter of Bhawani</em>: My father’s alias was Bhawani as he worshipped the goddess Bhawani</p><p><em>[Switch to the interview from the victim]</em></p><p><em>Female Victim:</em> Bhawani had a white can filled with kerosene and he splashed it, they shouted slogans before setting fire. My son’s pants were taken off before Bhawani and his son threw him into the fire. They stabbed me but the dagger fell off. My son said, “Mummy run! They will kill you!” Even on fire he thought of me…Kausar, standing next to me, was pregnant. Her womb was split open, ,the fetus impaled. That’s Bhawani for you.”</p><p><em>[Switch to his Youngest Daughter’s Interview Again]</em></p><p><em>Youngest Daughter of Bhawani:</em> You say there were rapes! Nothing happened, all the women are safe in the society behind. Police came at midnight and escorted them to the Shah Alam relief camp.</p><p><em>Interviewer</em>: Why are there so many lies?</p><p><em>Youngest Daughter:</em> Only God knows why they are lying.</p><p><em>Interviewer:</em> Kausar Bano — did it happen?</p><p>Youngest Daughter: No, whatever has been written in the papers is untrue. <em>[She says this after believing everything written about the Godhra train burnings and the role of Muslims which is still debated and questionable]</em></p><p>The contrast in the dialogue between the victims and the family of the alleged aggressor is shown not only in tone but also reflects the disconnect between the narratives of the Gujarat Riots. It should be noted again that the daughter of the alleged aggressor <em>Bhawani</em> only believed newspapers when they supported the narrative she agreed with (the victimization of Hindus by Muslims) but called the news of large-scale abuse and attacks on women during the Gujarat Riots fake. This selective belief shows that people may only believe the information that agrees with them due to confirmation bias and additionally shows the impacts of this selective belief which is aggression and political polarization and extremism. Furthermore, these divides make people lose all sympathy for suffering if it occurs “on the other side”.</p><h3>Lens #3: Through Graveyards</h3><p>This excerpt not only talks about the brutality faced by women during the Gujarat genocide but also fulfills the 5th criteria of genocide, ““Imposing measures intended to prevent births within the group” and while there were no legal measures taken to prevent childbirth in the Muslim community in Gujarat, this manifested in extreme violence against women and girls, with widespread systematic mass rapes and mutilation of women. Most women in their interviews mention being raped or being forced to watch their female relatives be stripped or raped. This is also shown in the massacre of pregnant women specifically which shows a deliberate prevention of births in the ethnic group.</p><p>The quotes of the grave managers go as follows:<br><em> I cut 3 umbilical cords myself, they were pregnant with babies inside…. Lets not talk about the ladies… There were scratch marks on their bodies. You’d lose your head if you saw the wounds on their breasts.”</em></p><p>Moreover, it was stated later in the documentary as well that many women had objects inserted into their genetalia, there was widespread gangrape and that the statistics of rape were widely innacurate due to families not wishing to report such events to the police so that their daughters could ‘still seem suitable for marriage’</p><p>The sheer brutality of this genocide on women is hence highlighted in this documentary despite not being formally recognized as a criteria for genocide by the definition shown in the movie. This aspect only emboldens the claims of the documentary in <em>Part 1: Pride and Genocide</em> that this genocide was misnomered as a ‘riot’.</p><h3>Lens #4: Through Families</h3><p>The title of this documentary, ‘Final Solution, is a clear reference to the genocidal Holocaust conducted by Nazi Germany. The application of this term to the Gujarat Riots shows that the creators of this documentary were trying to convey to the audience that the Gujarat Riots were a genocide which was aided by the state or abetted due to the state’s fascist nature. However, this is merely an inference that can be drawn from the allusion to Nazi Germany and the contents of this documentary which signal to fascism and genocide.</p><p>A direct connection to the documentary is found in the interview with the husband of a victim of the Godhra Train Burning, however. The thesis of the third section of the documentary, <em>Terror Trail,</em> is summed up by the husband of <em>Jyotiben Panchal,</em> a woman who had died in the S-6 Compartment of the<em> </em>Sabarmati Express.</p><p>Interviewer: What is the <em>final solution </em>to the Hindu-Muslim problem in Gujarat?</p><p>Mr. Panchal<em> (promptly): </em>This has no solution if it remains like this. A small group of people engineer this amongst Hindus and Muslims, some people keep stoking it for personal profits.</p><p>This answer illustrates an important facet of the debate surrounding the Gujarat Riots. Even the family of the victims of the Godhra Train Burning, the rallying cries for massacring maniacs, did not wish for violence or vengeance. Rather, this tragedy was weaponized by Hindutva mobs to persecute an entire community. This weaponization is not only shown in the riots, but also in the fact that <em>(As per the documentary) </em>the picture of Jyotiben Panchal was placed in the VHP Headquarters despite her non-affiliation with the party or its intense Hindutva stance. This was done without the consent of the family and displayed the utilization of victims for furthering an agenda rather than genuine care.</p><h3>Lens #5: Through Politicians and Policemen</h3><p>After reading and watching all these excerpts, I expect you to be as stunned or aghast as me. However, this does not begin to cover the impact of this documentary, an impact only heightened by the sprinklings of quotes from prominent politicians and police officers.</p><p>The people who would be most familiar with the on-ground realities of the genocide would be the police. Given that they do not serve elected posts, we would expect them to be more objective and stern. Hence, it is heart-wrenching to listen to the experiences of victims where they had interacted with the police and instead of safety, were met with disdain or distaste. In this instance, even institutions such as the police were hurt by political agendas. An example of this would be a woman in Patiya recounting her memory of the Naroda Patiya massacre.</p><p>Woman:<em> “</em>We begged the gun-toting police <em>— ‘Sir, let our innocent kids go’</em>, and the cop replied, ‘<em>What innocent kids? Sisterf*****s we have no orders to save you! You’ll die today’ … </em>They said,<em> ‘Go to Naroda, you’ll get help’</em>, and when we started walking we saw the mob”.</p><p>The police led the woman and her children into the Naroda Patiya massacre where this woman was brutally burnt. It is impossible for them to not have noticed the mob. If not intentional this was certainly incompetent and led to the woman and her family’s current condition.</p><p>Furthermore, there are some quotes made by Hindutva politicians which were contemporaneous to the Riots. They create the greatest sense of whiplash in this documentary because it frames Hindus as victims of violence or suppression by other religious groups. It forces the audience to grapple with the fact that the realities we have viewed over the course of this documentary have fallen on deaf ears for the most powerful people in our nation. Fallen on the deaf ears of those who have been chosen by the people, for the people.</p><p><em>“Christian imperialism will destroy Hindu culture and suppress them”</em> — VHP politician Acharya Dharmendra.</p><p><em>“[Muslims] think their religion is the greatest! They want to prevail at all times!” — </em>Prahlad Shastri, a local Hindutva leader who is followed up by-</p><p><em>“Muslims are fanatics, many extremists among them!” — </em>Ghanshyam Joshi, another Hindutva leader.</p><p>It can be noticed that Hindutva practitioners and politicians do not often address the victims of the riot, but rather parrot their own causes or tragedies. Many complain about accusations of ‘rape’ or murder’ by victims, claiming these to be fake. However, as viewers, after watching countless men, women and children talk about the abuse they faced — while they are wrapped in plaster or standing over the graves of their family — it becomes hard to believe these politicians. Some other local officials were also named by grave managers, the Kalol relief camp organizer and a female victim earlier in the documentary.</p><p><em>“I lost 10 members of my family, he (signals to friend) lost 19… They were burnt, hacked and killed in front of us. The police removed the names of the main culprits who were part of the Bajrang Dal and VHP. Nothing has happened till now, half have been arrested and half of the main people from VHP roam free. The main culprits like Bharat Rajput, Bharat Teli, Atul Vais, corporator Jagrup Singh, Megh Singh, Chunnilal Prajapati.”</em></p><p>– Grave Manager</p><p><em>“Owner of Khodiad Paan- Vijay Thakur is the main accused. Police say he is absconding but he runs his business openly.”</em></p><p>– Kalol Relief Camp Organizer</p><p><em>“They have not caught anyone even though I named everyone…</em></p><p><em>The police don’t do a thing.”</em></p><p>– A woman who fled Delol village, when recounting how she was knocked unconscious and raped by the members of the mob</p><p>This not only signals incompetency from the state, but rather an intentional and blatant disregard for justice for the victims. This documentary hence moves on from trying to show a Genocide, and settles on showing a State-sponsored Genocide, or a genocide which could only prosper and flourish due to the state’s complicity and complacency.</p><p>This excerpt broke the chronological order in which I wished to present this documentary to you. However, I believe that this deviation was helpful to show you that this genocide and the horrors mentioned in the tiny snippets of conversation I could show were entirely preventable. This documentary should reshape how you approach tragedies in the future and should compel you to look deeper because finally, it all comes down to excerpt 5, <em>From Politicians and Policemen.</em></p><p>I would like to conclude with a final quote from this documentary. It is important to note that the Gujarat Genocide was contemporaneous to the Gaurav Yatra, Modi’s election campaign in Gujarat prior to the 2003 Gujarat State elections. This campaign focused on ameliorating Gujarat’s reputation and an excerpt from Narenda Modi’s speech from the Yatra goes as follows -</p><p><em>“This is a conspiracy to defame Gujarat. The BJP has resolved to fight it. They may try a million times to malign Gujarat, but I’ve decided to bring out the truth boldly.”</em></p><p>A ‘conspiracy’.</p><p>The genocide was framed as a ‘conspiracy’.</p><p>The discussion about a systematic massacre of an entire community was a ‘conspiracy’ as per our current Prime Minister for 12 years.</p><p><em>Conspiracy</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=20cfe6b2f3db" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Anatomy of a Genocide]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@cyruscylinder48/anatomy-of-a-genocide-27a7b29fad6c?source=rss-6d84b70473ca------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/27a7b29fad6c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[india]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[media]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[government]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[movies]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Censored]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 31 May 2026 11:26:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-05-31T18:47:01.712Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/801/1*KoYoYKER6qa7EmLTuHIyWQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>DISCLAIMER:</p><p><em>*When quoting, we do not use the subtitles in the documentary as they are not completely accurate to the dialogue that is spoken in Hindi. Direct subtitles for quoting are used only for speech in Gujarati as neither of us speak the language.</em></p><p><em>**Furthermore, this blog mentions violence, rape, mutilation, murder and massacres while covering the Gujarat Riots. If you feel uncomfortable with such material, please read based on your discretion or read our other blogs which do not mention such events.</em></p><p>The narratives about the Gujarat “Riots” have been in constant turmoil and conflict with each other. They contradict each other to such an extent that they effectively become two different fables: one of genocide, and the other of defamation and overexaggeration of atrocities. The only commonality left standing is claims of “misrepresentation”- that the other side has twisted and contorted reality into something unrecognizable.</p><p>These, however, have been recorded through reports, public press statements, newspaper editorials and electoral campaigns. It stands to reason that a documentary which interacts with the victims, aggressors, bystanders and political atmosphere of the Riots would be the most accurate source to understand the microcosm. Moreover, if authorities wish for the truth to come out and to stop misinterpretation- one would assume that they would be eager to see such a documentary be broadcasted to the entire nation, right?</p><p>Following the Godhra Train Burning, mass riots unfolded over the next three days. <em>The Final Solution (2004)</em> shows us interviews of victims which describe, in detail, the physical and psychological torture inflicted upon them due to these riots. The government’s official toll states that 790 Muslims and 254 Hindus were killed, 2500 injured and 223 missing. Figures stated by the report made by the UK Government used in the <em>BBC</em> Documentary about Modi (<em>India: The Modi Question (2023)</em> is also banned in India) show that the violence was underreported, and at least 2000 people were killed with 138000 internal refugees with over a 100,000 of them being Muslims. Mass systematic violence and gang rape against women were committed, mass graves were unearthed and 273 dargahs and 241 mosques were demolished.</p><p>The 2004 documentary ‘<em>Final Solution</em>’ proves otherwise. <em>Final Solution (2004) </em>is a documentary made by<em> Rakesh Sharma</em> and calls itself a <em>‘study of the politics of hate’</em>, a title it rightfully bestows upon itself as it shows us in-depth interview with not only victims and their story but also the ideology of perpetrators, police and the Hindu denizens of Gujarat. It is uploaded for free on Youtube by <em>Citizens for Justice</em> <em>and Peace</em> and<em> Ejaz Shaikh (A longer version, 3.5 hours long).</em></p><p>It garnered praise for its unflinching journalism and it won 15 awards, both domestic and international, despite not being allowed to be submitted to the <em>Mumbai International Film Festival. </em>However, upon release in 2004 it was banned by the <em>CBFC </em>over fears that it would ignite communalist violence. It was only cleared for release when the <em>UPA (United Progressive Alliance, led by the Congress)</em> government came into power in October 2004.</p><p>It is divided into four parts; <em>Pride and Genocide (55 minutes), The Terror Trail (55 minutes), Hate Mandate (55 minutes) </em>and <em>Hope and Despair (47 minutes). </em>The parts are divided chronologically and comprise of interviews, political speeches, footage of destroyed sites and text shown on screen which contextualises each section</p><h3>Part 1: Pride and Genocide</h3><p>The<em> ‘Pride’</em> in the title of the first part- <em>Pride and Genocide</em> refers to the <em>Gaurav Yatra</em> (<em>transl. Journey of Pride</em>) started by the then <em>Gujarat Chief Minister Narenda Modi </em>as a response to the widespread criticism of the Gujarat government and police’s incompetence during the Gujarat riots and the human rights violations committed during the riot. The documentary then displays the text:</p><p><em>Genocide: (Source- UN Convention on Genocide)</em></p><p><em>Means any of the following acts committed with the intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national ,ethnic, racial or religious group as such:</em></p><ul><li><em>Killing members of the group</em></li><li><em>Causing serious mental or bodily harm to the members</em></li><li><em>Deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part</em></li></ul><p>Hence, this part has a dual focus; one section of interviews of Muslim victims in relief camps, discussing the riots and violence inflicted upon them. They talk about their family members, their burnt homes and how the police were not only unhelpful but ignored the pleas and complaints of victims. The experiences and figures highlighted by the victims clearly fulfill the criteria of genocide shown by the documentary. The other section of this part focuses on the people attending the <em>Gaurav Yatra </em>and the speeches by <em>Narendra Mod</em>i. Hence showing both the pride and genocide in the state.</p><p>The first section of this part validates the claim that this was a state-sponsored genocide. The first criteria of <em>‘killing members of the group’</em> is not only continuously re-emphasized by the interviews of victims who mention all the members of their family lost but also the fact that official government estimates have been continuously debunked as being too little. The documentary states, “Excerpts from <em>Concerned Citizens Tribunal </em>report: “Officially about 91000 refugees fled to relief camps but independent surveys put the number at 1,74,000. Over 75,000 people fled elsewhere.” The interviewer then asks, “Many dead bodies to be found?”, to which the Kalol Relief Camp organiser states, “65 Muslims died in <em>Kalol,</em> 43 dead bodies still have not been found. So the number exceeds government claims, like here 43 out of 65 missing. Imagine other places.”</p><p>The second criteria of causing both mental and physical harm to the members is the one most validated by this section. An example would be a woman who outlines the tragedy of the survivors while wiping tears, stating how many members different families lost and how many families now only have one surviving member. She says, “No food or water for 3 days; people were forced to drink urine. “Babies crying of hunger, mobs hurled children into fires. I still get nightmares. They’ve finished off generations.”</p><p>There is also a series of victims who mention how people were lit on fire with a different woman who says, “ They surrounded 200–300 of us and poured petrol and kerosene over us. People were set on fire. A kid was in flames. I doused the fire and threw him over a wall. I fell among the heap of burning people when trying to save a kid. My legs and arm got burnt; people on top got completely burnt and died. It was so hot I thought I’d die anyway either in the fire or out of panic. 6 members of my family have died, 4 injured. I can’t sleep when I think of them. My kids died in front of me; how can I deal with it even if I get justice? I’ve lost everything. The government can give us money but we can never be compensated.”</p><p>Not only do these accounts show the physical violence perpetrated by the mobs, but also the mental harm inflicted upon those who had to watch their own family and children be tortured and killed before them. Many accounts highlight recurring nightmares and sleeplessness, a perpetually tormented mind which validates the second criteria for genocide</p><p>The third criteria is the deliberate creation of the group’s condition of life, calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part. This is highlighted by the display of police and state negligence, the disregard for victims and lack of support for refugee camps along with the medical treatment of victims. The documentary states, “ For weeks, the government adamantly refused to even recognise the existence of refugees. It denied relief assistance- water, food, medical aid, sanitation. The story of Gujarat today is of enforced ghettoisation”. These quotes are taken from the report by the <em>CCT</em> shown in the documentary. This shows the clear disregard for the victims.</p><p>While not in the documentary, another criteria of genocide is, “Imposing measures intended to prevent births within the group” and while there were no legal measures taken to prevent childbirth in the Muslim community in Gujarat, this manifested in extreme violence against women and girls, with widespread systematic mass rapes and mutilation of women. Most women in their interviews mention being raped or being forced to watch their female relatives be stripped or raped. One of the women recounts the murder of Kausar Bano in the Naroda Patiya massacre, a woman who was pregnant.</p><p>She says, “Kausar, standing next to me, was pregnant. Her womb was split open, the fetus impaled.” Moreover, the woman mentions, “Women who tried to escape the fire were molested..some of them clamped [women’s] mouths, some of them took off their clothes.”</p><p>Hence, this section in the movie apparently aims to shows how the violence in Gujarat in 2002 was not a mere series of riots but rather a cold-blooded genocide. Furthermore, it sheds light on how this genocide was not stopped by the state adequately and the ignorance of the government <em>(whether intentional or unintentional)</em> further aided and abetted one of the worst periods of violence in post-colonial Indian history. Not only is this ignorance shown in the treatment of refugees and the ignorance of the state police, it is also reflected by the sentiment of <em>Modi’s</em> speeches in the <em>Gaurav Yatra</em> who says, “This is a conspiracy to defame Gujarat. The BJP has resolved to fight it. They may try a million times to malign Gujarat, but I’ve decided to bring out the truth boldly.”</p><p>In fact, the truth shown by the documentary is that a genocide was committed in 2002 Gujarat and state and police negligence further heightened the extent of this genocide. Gujarat was not being ‘defamed’ via a conspiracy and the violence and testimonies in this documentary prove that.</p><h3>Part 2: Terror Trail</h3><p>The<em> Terror Trail </em>traces the chronology of the attacks, visiting the <em>Gulbarg Society</em> and <em>Mr. Ehsan Jafri’s</em> house first. It also visits the family of those who died in the Godhra train burning, the inciting incident of the riot. It, hence, follows the supposed ‘terror trail’ and how one event led to the other. The coverage of the riots is then followed by the attack on the Akshardham temple where the letters on the bodies of the terrorists claimed it was revenge for the Naroda Patiya massacre during the riots. While not part of the 2002 Gujarat riots, it is still included to highlight how acts of violence inspire each other, creating a vicious cycle of communalism and supposed ‘vengeance’. It also includes more political speeches by Hindutva leaders like <em>Praveen Togadia </em>of the<em> Vishwa Hindu Parishad</em>,<em> Narendra Modi </em>etcetera and how they supposedly used the Godhra Train burning and the Akshardham terrorist attack to their political advantage.</p><p>The thesis of this section of the documentary is summed up by the husband of <em>Jyotiben Panchal,</em> a woman who had died in the S-6 Compartment of the<em> Sabarmati Express</em>. The interviewer asks, “What is the final solution to the Hindu-Muslim problem in Gujarat?”, and <em>Mr. Panchal </em>promptly answers, “This has no solution if it remains like this. A small group of people engineer this amongst Hindus and Muslims, some people keep stoking it for personal profits.”</p><p>This section is undoubtedly the core of the documentary, not only because the title of the documentary originates from the interview in this section but also because the theory of cyclical violence is displayed by the documentary by its editing. The documentary flips back and forth from Hindutva rallies to interviews with riot victims to show how the anger created by Hindutva leaders leads to violence which makes Hindutva supporters feel empowered– leading them to attend more Hindutva rallies, stoking more anger and continuing the cycle.</p><h3>Part 3: Hate Mandate</h3><p>The penultimate section of the documentary, Hate Mandate starts with the following text displayed on the screen:</p><p><em>Model code of conduct for political parties/candidates</em></p><p><em>* No party or candidate shall indulge in any activity which may aggravate existing differences or create mutual hatred or cause tension between different castes and communities, religious or linguistic</em></p><p><em>* There shall be no appeal to caste or communal feelings for securing votes.</em></p><p><em>(Source: Election Commission of India)</em></p><p>This is immediately contrasted by this entire section which focuses on Hindutva rallies and supporters, who in their speeches and interviews villainize Muslims, promote anti-secularism and Hindu hegemonies. It, unlike other sections, has no interviews with victims of the Gujarat riots, but rather interviews those who use the riots in their speeches as political tools for the upcoming election and those who have been accused of participating in the riots. All those accused vehemently deny the claims, saying that they have been falsely blamed. The other new feature is the portrayal of Congress as the former two sections only showed Hindutva parties. The Hindutva leaders in this section continuously defame Sonia Gandhi for being Christian and fear-monger that the Congress winning will lead to Muslims ruling over Hindus.</p><p>Though only Sonia Gandhi’s speech mentions topics besides religion including electricity and water provision, pension and unemployment, BJP still goes on to win the election. While Sonia Gandhi talks about the harmfulness of using religion to foster hate and violence, Congress loses the elections. This is stark due to the state just having gone through a religious genocide and yet, would not promote a pery that stated that religion should not be used to foster hate and violence, rather the state shouild focus on social welfare. However, the party which used religion as its main talking points with the diction of being under attack, won. Hence the documentary uses this contrast to show that the Hate Mandate, ‘stoking the embers of hate’, is how politicians win public support.</p><h3>Part 4: Hope and Despair</h3><p>The final section of the documentary, Hope and Despair starts with text defining the word ‘Ghetto’ which is</p><p><em>(i) A quarter of a city in which Jews were formerly required to live</em></p><p><em>(ii) A quarter of a city in which members of a minority group live especially because of social, legal or economic pressure.</em></p><p>This section of the documentary hence focuses on the current living conditions of all victims of the riots and even Muslims who were not attacked but were still driven out of their homes. It illustrated the squalor in which Muslims have been forced into, how they have lost houses, have had to move their children to other schools, how their business have been failing etcetera. It starts with two areas divided by barbed wire, the Jehapura-Vejalpur border separating Hindus and Muslims. They interview both Hindu and Muslims living in that area, talking about how there have been conflicts and how they could start riots.</p><p>It also shows the syllabus of Gujarat state Schools, where social studies includes studying Hindu Mythology like the Ramayana, a Higher Level English exam paper of Class XII, Gujarat asked students to join the sentences, “There are two solutions. One of them is the Nazi solution. If you don’t like people, kill them, segregate them. Then strut up and down. Proclaim that you are the salt of the earth.” as part of a grammar exercise and that a class X social studies textbook had a chapter that hails, ‘Hitler, the supremo’! It states, “ Hitler lent dignity and prestige to the German government. He instilled a spirit of adventure in the common people.”</p><p>Why were they emphasizing the portrayal of Nazism and Hitler in Gujarat so heavily and introducing this section with a word strongly associated with the condition of the Jewish community during World War II?</p><p>It seems as though the intention behind this is to show the fascist undertones of the Hindutva movement, especially the comparison of the living conditions of Muslims after what many claim to be a state-sponsored genocide to the living conditions of the Jewish community after World War II, both facing religious based discrimination and nationalistic vitriol from the dominant majority group. The Hindutva movement, especially in Gujarat 2002 supposedly emulated many features of fascist states; populist nationalism, power derived from propaganda and misinformation, constant self-victimization, pointing to a common enemy, fixation on national security and murder of eminent opposition leaders.</p><p>An example of the last feature would be Mr. Ehsan Jafri who was a popular Congress MP murdered by a mob during the riots, and Dr. J S Bandukwala who was the president of the People’s Union of Civil Liberties (PUCL) and was connected to many secular organisations. Dr. Bandukwala, while giving a speech to the RSS (Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh) told them that the country can either go ahead with Savarkar’s (Veer Savarkar, the leader of the Hindutva ideology and ideological leader of the RSS) vision or Gandhi’s but only Gandhi’s approach will strengthen the nation. He said this 12 hours before the Godhra train burning and despite his and PUCL’s immediate condemnation, his house was the first house to be attacked in Baroda on 28th February. On February 29th, even in the presence of two police guards who actually instructed the rioters to enter their house from the back, a mob of 200 people ransacked his house.</p><p>This section shows the ‘Hope’ of Hindus in Gujarat who were ecstatic over BJP’s victory as they believed it would lead to Hindu domination of Gujarat, as if that was not the case already. The reason for their happiness is ‘Despair’. The ‘despair’ of the Muslim community whom they think is being rightfully punished and the ‘despair’ that Hindutva leaders spread before the elections, saying that not only Muslim but also Christian imperialism will destroy Hindu culture and suppress them (a claim made by VHP politician Acharya Dharmendra during a rally).</p><h3>Conclusion</h3><p>How should a movie such as <em>Final Solution (2004)</em> be viewed? The logical structure of this documentary clearly led viewers to infer certain views on the contentious Gujarat Riots, a majority of which are anti-government and show how government negligence or even inflammatory speeches led to the violence. However, it did not distort any footage or mess with chronology, the inflammatory speeches did take place during the riots and these are the brutal stories of victims. Hence, it is a reflection of reality even though it makes a stance which does not support authority.</p><p>However, should that be a condition for screening? Should truth and awareness not be enough for a documentary about one of the most contentious periods of Indian history? In our opinion, this documentary has provided one of the most in-depth and understanding platforms for victims to share their stories and victims should never be silenced because this silence is dangerous. When we ignore victims, we ignore history and we allow people to flout accountability.</p><p>The banning of this documentary was a grievous mistake, one that indicates the prioritization of zealots and violent insurgents more than hapless, ignored victims. If one wishes to learn about the Gujarat Riots outside the barriers of bureaucratic reports- <em>Final Solution is a must-watch.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=27a7b29fad6c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Conversions]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@cyruscylinder48/conversions-1e352d796b56?source=rss-6d84b70473ca------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1e352d796b56</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[movies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[censorship]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bollywood]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[media]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gandhi]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Censored]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 31 Mar 2026 13:32:36 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-03-31T13:32:36.514Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Papilio Buddha (2013)</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xq05pc9WhesGal6Rr3xFSw.jpeg" /></figure><p>When non-Indians are asked about their knowledge of India, they may only note that Mahatma Gandhi is the ‘Father of the Nation’, and that India is a nation with a Hindu majority. Gandhi is often viewed as a paragon of justice and morality due to his secularist and anti-colonial stance. However, most people remain unaware about his position on the Hindu caste system, specifically the subjugation of lower caste communities.</p><p>You would expect Indians to be more perceptive about the state of their nation. However, perceptiveness largely depends on media consumption, and the media diet of Indians has been made intentionally limited in a way which does not question the public worship of Gandhi or the religious diversity shaped in response to the caste system. An example of this would be the ban on <em>Papilio Buddha (2013)</em>, a movie by Jayan K. Cherian which was meant to shed light on discrimination against Dalits (a lower-caste community) and why some choose to undergo two conversions:</p><blockquote>A conversion from Gandhian Ideology to Ambedkarism</blockquote><blockquote>A conversion from Hinduism to Buddhism</blockquote><p>These divergences from mainstream discourse about Indian religiopolitical identity should ideally be discussed more often, as these conversions are the consequence of years of institutional discrimination and would widen the perspectives of many citizens. This movie challenges your perceptions about Gandhi and Hinduism in the same way discrimination against Dalits has challenged their perception about the same topics. For this reason, this movie was a nominee for Best Feature Film at the Berlin International Film Festival and Athens International Film and Video festival, and the recipient of the Special Jury Award at the Kerala State Film Festival.</p><p>It unfortunately did not receive the same adoration from the Indian Central Board of Film Certification (CBFC). <em>Papilio Buddha, </em>was banned upon release in 2013 by the CBFC. After appeals to move towards the release of this movie, the Film Certification Appellate Tribunal ordered for 50 cuts to be made to the movie, after which it was released with an A certificate. Specifically, a speech by Ambedkar which criticized Gandhi’s limiting views on Dalit rights had to be muted.</p><p>However, the film centred around the sexual violence Dalit women faced, the police brutality Dalit communities underwent and the brutal denial of land rights for Dalits. The aim of the movie was to show how this continuous oppression of Dalit communities led to a harsh critique of Gandhian <em>satyagraha</em> and alleged hypocrisy. Without showing criticism of Gandhi and the shift to Ambedkarism and Buddhist transformation, this movie would lose its backbone and conclusion. This would effectively shatter the mirror it held up to reality. In fact, the ‘Papilio Buddha’ itself is a symbol of transformation, and if the supposed ‘denigration’ of Gandhi was removed from this film, the cause of transformation would be wiped away.</p><p>This piece aims to explore the context behind the religiopolitical conversions displayed in the movie and hopefully convince you, our readers, to watch this movie and challenge your perceptions about the history we learn.</p><h4>Conversions: Gandhian to Ambedkarite Ideology</h4><p>Ambedkar and Gandhi are two figures who cannot be separated from the discourse of the Indian Independence Movement. They presented two different images however. While Ambedkar focused on Dalit rights and advocacy through a complete abolition of the caste system, Gandhi proposed a more temperate view which did not want to abolish the caste system but rather, ‘reform’ it while maintaining occupational heredity. The latter was, clearly, not tolerated by the lower caste communities who have been forced to be manual labourers and subjugated to upper-caste oppressors. Therefore, while most may consider Gandhi a paragon of justice and the ‘Father of India’, viewing his ideology from the lens of the Dalit community shows why a significant portion of the lower-caste community gravitates away from his exclusionary perspective and converts to Ambedkarism.</p><p>This conflict between Ambedkarite and Gandhian ideology is shown in <em>Papilio Buddha </em>through the struggle between the Dalits residing in Meparra (forest land) and the local governmental authorities. The latter gradually shifted to Ambedkarite ideology as they witness acts of casteism such as the police brutality against Shankaran and the rape of Manjushree, two Dalit individuals belonging to the Meparra district. Local government officers preach about Gandhian ideology and non-violence, ignoring the mass protests about Manjusree’s rape and focusing on displacing the marginalized communities.</p><p>The end of this movie shows both ideologies in conflict directly: as the politicians who preach Gandhian ideology come to evict the Dalit community in Meppara who burn an effigy of Gandhi. This culminates in the police violently beating the entire community and causing all the Dalits to be displaced: the supposedly peaceful party now becoming full-fledged aggressors. This shows the movie&#39;s attempt to diminish Gandhianism and expose its ‘hypocrisy’ in the eyes of the Dalit community and the filmmakers.</p><p>Furthermore, this critique is seen in the Dalit characters quoting Ambedkar, stating, “As Dr. Ambedkar said about Gandhi&#39;s fasting in Yerwada jail in 1932, ‘Satyagraha is a foul and filthy act, It is the most corrosive act’”, and later, “We are not anybody&#39;s Harijans!” which is a rebellion against the term given to Dalits by Gandhi. The fast this quote refers to is Gandhi’s protest against the British’s attempt to reserve electorate seats for lower-caste citizens which ultimately led to the signing of the Poona Pact to protect the political rights of Dalits and lower caste communities (signed by Ambedkar most notably, who supported reservations for lower-caste citizens). Gandhi’s opposition to this protection of rights is the matter being criticized in this quote, an important piece of historical context which explains the shift to Ambedkarism in Dalit communities.</p><p>Hence, the film does present a critique of Gandhian ideology. However, this denigration can be called into question when it is used as a primary cause for a ban. The opposition is framed as an ultimate consequence of continuous institutional casteism and how casteism has been carried out with impunity. With this perspective in mind, denigration becomes a mere form of protest against years of brutality. Therefore, while we may not dispute the harsh disavowal of Gandhian ideology in this movie, we must evaluate the impact of banning a movie for merely criticizing a historical figure and thereby silencing the views of an already marginalized community.</p><h4>Conversions: Hinduism to Buddhism</h4><p>The conversion from Hinduism to Buddhism cannot be separated from the conversion from Gandhian Ideology to Ambedkarism. This is especially prominent given that Ambedkar led the largest religious conversion from Hinduism to Buddhism on October 14th, 1956 where he launched the Navayana (Neo-Buddhist) movement, converted to Buddhism alongside 500,000 Dalits approximately. The religiopolitical beliefs of Ambedkarism are intrinsically linked, therefore.</p><p>This facet is highlighted in <em>Papilio Buddha (2013)</em> where Dalit leaders in the Meppara district state, “High caste Indian leaders including Gandhi were cheating Dalits. We should recognize that Hinduism, the religion of oppressors, and its Sanathana Dharma were sharp weapons in the hands of Gandhi against Dalits. We hereby declare that we are giving up Hinduism and its caste.” This quote is important as it shows the importance of religion in Dalit rebellion, and shows the intrinsic conflict between Ambedkarism and Gandhianism while explaining the phenomena of Buddhist conversions in Dalit communities.</p><p>In real life, an estimated 3 million Dalits converted to Buddhism at Ambedkar’s 50th deeksha, and these conversions are enthusiastic celebrations of their national hero. As per the 2011 Census, 90% of Indian Buddhists are Dalit converts, a number which has continued to grow at Ambedkar Purnimas across Northwestern India.</p><p>Therefore, this movie aims to show how Dalit communities have shifted their religious beliefs in accordance with their political beliefs and how the conflict between Ambedkarism and Gandhian ideology extends beyond mere discourse and bleeds into self-preservation. The two conversions that many Dalits choose to undergo are intrinsically linked and instead of silencing them and the cause for non-mainstream shifts, we should ideally be recognizing the plights of Dalit communities and broader perspectives on our ‘national heroes’.</p><h4>Conclusion</h4><p>At Censored, the issue of Dalit rights and liberation is a topic that is close to our hearts. Our first article was on <em>Santosh</em> which dissected the ignorance that Dalits face in India and the overlooking of violence committed against lower-caste communities. <em>Papilio Buddha</em> builds upon this framework by expanding upon how some Dalit communities choose to resist this systematic oppression and challenge mainstream perspectives. It challenges mainstream political ideology and sparks discourse about freedom fighters in a way <em>Santosh</em> had not explored, and this in-depth discussion might be what the modern Indian media diet requires to critically evaluate our personal beliefs and perceptions of anti-Dalit discrimination.</p><p>This is not meant to question the validity of the ban imposed by the CBFC, but rather assess its impact on the movie’s message and why an undermining of the message may wipe away the intrinsic value of the movie itself. This does not aim to challenge the government, but rather look at <em>Papilio Buddha</em> and recognize the importance of critiquing figures and institutions no matter how popular they may be. We hope you, the readers, have been encouraged to watch this beautiful movie and broaden your perspectives on Gandhi, Ambedkarism, Hinduism and Buddhism.</p><h4>Works Used</h4><p>Alexander, Princy. “‘Papilio Buddha’ Turns 10 Surviving a Blanket Ban, Over 50 Cuts, and an ‘A’ Certificate.” “Papilio Buddha” Turns 10 Surviving a Blanket Ban, Over 50 Cuts, and an “A” Certificate, 5 Sept. 2023, <a href="http://www.onmanorama.com/entertainment/entertainment-news/2023/09/05/papilio-buddha-jayan-k-cherian-movie-central-board-of-film-certification-ten-years.html">www.onmanorama.com/entertainment/entertainment-news/2023/09/05/papilio-buddha-jayan-k-cherian-movie-central-board-of-film-certification-ten-years.html</a>.</p><p>Basu, Swaraj. “THE POONA PACT AND THE ISSUE OF DALIT REPRESENTATION.” <em>Proceedings of the Indian History Congress</em>, vol. 61, 2000, pp. 986–98. <em>JSTOR</em>, <a href="http://www.jstor.org/stable/44148174.">http://www.jstor.org/stable/44148174.</a> Accessed 19 Mar. 2026.</p><p>Dr. Parvesh Kumar, et al (2024), Impact of Gandhi’s Activism on Dalit Empowerment: Unravelling Complexity and Progress, Educational Administration: Theory and Practice, 30(5), 14133–14139</p><p>Doi: 10.53555/kuey.v30i5.6309</p><p>Pennu, Inji. “Indian Censor Board Restricts Papilio Buddha, a Gandhi Critic Movie.” Global Voices, 12 Mar. 2013, <a href="http://globalvoices.org/2013/03/12/indian-censor-board-restricts-papilio-buddha-a-gandhi-critic-movie">globalvoices.org/2013/03/12/indian-censor-board-restricts-papilio-buddha-a-gandhi-critic-movie</a></p><p>Raj, Sony Jalarajan, et al. “Dissent and Displacement of Subalternity in Malayalam Cinema: A Cultural Analysis of Papilio Buddha by Jayan K. Cherian.” Journal of Creative Communications, vol. 11, no. 2, June 2016, pp. 183–95, doi:10.1177/0973258616644814.</p><p>Tnn. “30 Lakh Dalits Convert to Buddhism.” The Times of India, 9 Nov. 2006, <a href="http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/30-lakh-dalits-convert-to-buddhism/articleshow/386924.cms">timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/30-lakh-dalits-convert-to-buddhism/articleshow/386924.cms</a>.</p><p>Wankhede, Vaibhav, and Vaibhav Wankhede. “Why Dalit Conversion to Buddhism Hasn’T Taken off, and How It Still Can.” ThePrint, 27 Apr. 2025, <a href="http://theprint.in/opinion/why-dalit-conversion-to-buddhism-hasnt-taken-off-and-how-it-still-can/2604784">theprint.in/opinion/why-dalit-conversion-to-buddhism-hasnt-taken-off-and-how-it-still-can/2604784</a>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1e352d796b56" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Unmirrored Realities]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@cyruscylinder48/unmirrored-realities-3f1e3711e83e?source=rss-6d84b70473ca------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3f1e3711e83e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[movies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lgbtq]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[transgender]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bollywood]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-justice]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Censored]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 08 Feb 2026 16:35:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-02-08T16:35:57.948Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*M24eaVPg6GqjXG1nQrdmbw.png" /></figure><p><em>Pink Mirror</em>, or <em>Gulabi Aaina</em>, follows two drag queens Bibbo and Shabbo. The two drag queens compete against a western gay teenager to win the affections of a handsome, straight man Samir. The film humorously portrays the Indian gay landscape and showcases the bonds between drag queens in India who form unique, non-patriarchal families. The film uses song, dance and drama to explore issues plaguing the LGBTQ community, such as HIV/AIDS.</p><p>The film was banned from 2003 to 2017 for being “vulgar and too intimate for the Indian audience”(Gandhi, 2026). Despite being banned in India for 14 long years, the movie was immensely popular globally and won multiple awards.</p><p>But why was it that this movie was too vulgar and intimate for India? There are no sexual scenes or any scenes involving nudity, so what is it exactly that made this movie so vulgar and intimate? To understand the answer to these questions, we must first understand the portrayal of drag queens and transgender individuals in Bollywood.</p><h3><em>Portrayal of Drag Queens and Transgender Individuals in Bollywood</em></h3><p>Bollywood consistently portrays transgender people and drag queens as either comedic relief or villains.</p><p>Since the golden age of Bollywood(ranging from the mid 1950s to the mid 1960s), drag queens and transgender individuals have been the butt of every joke. In the song “Mere angane mein”, from the movie <em>Lawaaris(1981)</em>, Amitabh Bachchan dresses as a woman, who can be mistaken for a eunuch. Another example is the movie <em>Rafoo Chakkar(1975)</em>, a popular comedy film where the main characters cross-dress. Since then, not much has changed in commercial films. For example, in the movie <em>Dream Girl(2019)</em>, the main character once more cross-dresses for comedic purposes. Another recent example is the movie <em>Laxmii(2020)</em> in which Akshay Kumar, who plays the role of the man, gets possessed by a female ghost and starts acting feminine. “ Not only does this film perpetuate gender stereotypes but reinstates the idea that transwomen are basically men dressed in feminine clothes, who act effeminate.”(Jana, 2021) These are just a few examples of Bollywood Movies using LGBTQ+ individuals for entertainment, comedic or performance purposes.</p><p>In addition to being used for amusement, LGBTQ+ individuals are often demonised in Bollywood movies. For example, in the movie <em>Sadak(1991)</em>, the character Maharani is a transwoman. In this movie, she is depicted as an evil brothel owner who tortures and traffics young women. Furthermore, “films like <em>‘Kya Kool Hain Hum‘</em>, <em>‘Partner’, ‘.Style</em>’, and many more feature such horrific stereotypes of trans women as sexually predatory”(Banerjee).</p><p>Another popular trope in Bollywood is where a man gets romantically involved with a transgender woman without knowing she is transgender and later is disgusted and claims it is fraud. Some examples of this are the movie <em>Masti(2004)</em>, and the tv show <em>Patni Patni Aur Panga.</em> These films and series depict transgender women as frauds and act as if not disclosing your gender is an act of betrayal. Media like this just reinforces the idea that transgender people are anomalies and not worthy of normal experiences, like going on dates, or getting married.</p><p>Moreover, it is interesting to note that, more often than not, it is cisgender people who are cast in these roles. While there are a few Bollywood movies that claim to create awareness for transgender individuals, such as <em>Chandigarh Kare Aashiqui(2021) </em>and <em>Bhool Bhulaiyaa 3(2024)</em>, it is still cisgender people who play transgender roles. This only further shows how in a heteronormative, patriarchal society, there is no space for LGBTQ+ individuals, even in movies that are supposedly telling their story. Not only is transsexual representation in Bollywood stereotypical and minimal, it seems like it is only acceptable for cisgender people to perform drag in the media. Hence, the voices of the LGBTQ+ community are unheard of in Bollywood.</p><h3>Why <em>Pink Mirror</em> is so important</h3><p><em>Pink Mirror</em> is a major breakthrough in Bollywood as one of the few movies actually using drag queens in a movie raising awareness about the LGBTQ+ community. Unlike most other Bollywood movies, the drag queens are not the objects of comedy or the villains. While it is still a comedy movie, <em>Pink Mirror</em> does not make jokes at the expense of transsexual identities or the LGBTQ+ community.</p><p>Transgender individuals have been and continue to be discriminated against in India. They are often victims of abuse and violence — “A sampled survey shows an overwhelming eighty percent of the sample had experienced sexual assault and 37% reported repeat victimization-assault during both childhood and adulthood”(Kapil, 2025). Despite being such an empowering movie, <em>Pink Mirror</em> was still banned in India for 14 years while movies that depicted transsexual people as a joke continued to be streamed freely across the nation. This trend in Bollywood is just another method of discrimination against transsexuals. Moreover, the fact that <em>Pink Mirror</em> was described as “vulgar” and “too intimate for the Indian audience”(though it did not have any nude or sexual scenes) just further showcases how the heteronormative and patriarchal societal norms present in the CBFC and Bollywood villainise queer and third-gender identities. This is also noted by Harjant Gill in his paper <em>‘Censorship and Ethnographic Film: Confronting State Bureaucracies, Cultural Regulation, and Institutionalized Homophobia in India.</em>’: “rather then serving its citizens, bureaucracies such as the CBFC deploy antiquated colonial-era notions and morally-loaded legal concepts of “obscenity” and “vulgarity” to advance the nationalist, paternalist, heteronormative agendas and ideologies of the nation state.”</p><p>The media plays a major role in society as it has great power in influencing people. When movies and series which portray transsexuals as jokes, villains, hypersexual creatures, and frauds become popular, the audience often start viewing transsexuals as the same. This is why it is important to talk about and watch movies like <em>Pink Mirror</em>. To empower and create awareness for the LGBTQ+ community, we must be able to recognise what is wrong with their representation in Bollywood and push people to create and watch movies like <em>Pink Mirror.</em></p><h3><strong>Reference List</strong></h3><p>Banerjee, Rohini. “How Bollywood’s Representation of Transgender People Is Downright Horrifying.” <em>Youth Ki Awaaz</em>, May 2016, <a href="http://www.youthkiawaaz.com/2016/05/bollywood-transgender-representation/">www.youthkiawaaz.com/2016/05/bollywood-transgender-representation/.</a> Accessed 5 Feb. 2026.</p><p>Gandhi, Forum. ““Gulabi Aaina” Makes It to Netflix after 14 Long Years.” <em>DNA India</em>, 2026, <a href="http://www.dnaindia.com/lifestyle/report-gulabi-aaina-makes-it-to-netflix-after-14-long-years-2291270.">www.dnaindia.com/lifestyle/report-gulabi-aaina-makes-it-to-netflix-after-14-long-years-2291270.</a> Accessed 2 Feb. 2026.</p><p>Gill, Harjant. “Censorship and Ethnographic Film: Confronting State Bureaucracies, Cultural Regulation, and Institutionalized Homophobia in India.” <em>Academia.edu</em>, 29 May 2017, <a href="http://www.academia.edu/33242202/Censorship_and_Ethnographic_Film_Confronting_State_Bureaucracies_Cultural_Regulation_and_Institutionalized_Homophobia_in_India.">www.academia.edu/33242202/Censorship_and_Ethnographic_Film_Confronting_State_Bureaucracies_Cultural_Regulation_and_Institutionalized_Homophobia_in_India.</a> Accessed 8 Feb. 2026.</p><p>Gope, Dr. Piyali, et al. “A Queer Perspective on the Development of LGBTQ+ Representations in Bollywood Films.” <em>American Journal of Psychiatric Rehabilitation</em>, 13 Mar. 2025, <a href="https://doi.org/10.69980/ajpr.v28i3.418.">https://doi.org/10.69980/ajpr.v28i3.418.</a> Accessed 18 July 2025.</p><p>Gupta, Saagar, and Sridhar Rangayan. “Gulabi Aaina.” <em>IMDb</em>, 28 Apr. 2016, <a href="http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0386499/">www.imdb.com/title/tt0386499/.</a> Accessed 5 Feb. 2026.</p><p>Jana, Sourika. “Why Is Bollywood’s Portrayal of the Transgender Community Problematic?​ — Pratisandhi.” <em>Pratisandhi</em>, 15 Nov. 2021, <a href="http://www.pratisandhi.com/whats-wrong-with-the-trans-representation-in-bollywood/">www.pratisandhi.com/whats-wrong-with-the-trans-representation-in-bollywood/.</a> Accessed 5 Feb. 2026.</p><p>Kapil. “Sexual Assault against Transgender: The Definitional Void and the Absurdity of Indian Penal Provisions.” <em>Livelaw.in</em>, Live Law, Mar. 2025, <a href="http://www.livelaw.in/lawschool/articles/sexual-assault-against-transgenders-and-indian-criminal-laws-285326.">www.livelaw.in/lawschool/articles/sexual-assault-against-transgenders-and-indian-criminal-laws-285326.</a> Accessed 5 Feb. 2026.</p><p>Roy, Spandita. “Screening the “Other”: An Analysis of Transgender Representation in the Hindi Mainstream Cinema.” <em>IOSR Journal of Humanities and Social Science (IOSR-JHSS</em>, vol. 30, 2025, pp. 55–99, <a href="http://www.iosrjournals.org/iosr-jhss/papers/Vol.30-Issue6/Ser-4/H3006045599.pdf,">www.iosrjournals.org/iosr-jhss/papers/Vol.30-Issue6/Ser-4/H3006045599.pdf,</a> <a href="https://doi.org/10.9790/0837-3006045599.">https://doi.org/10.9790/0837-3006045599.</a> Accessed 5 Feb. 2026.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3f1e3711e83e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Double, Double, Toil and Trouble]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@cyruscylinder48/double-double-toil-and-trouble-0699d247f0a3?source=rss-6d84b70473ca------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/0699d247f0a3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[sikkim]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[censorship]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[satyajit-ray]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[movies]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Censored]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 05 Jan 2026 14:09:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-01-05T14:09:52.715Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Sikkim- 1971</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*WQPuDqD15xwfJlUmgCxYJw.png" /></figure><h3>Satyajit Ray</h3><p>Satyajit Ray is the only Indian Filmmaker to be awarded an Honorary Academy Award from the Academy of Motion Arts and Sciences (Bharat, Etv, 2025) — a testament to his legacy in not only Indian but also World Cinema and his distinguished style within the Indian Film Industry. The Academy cited Ray’s “profound humanitarian outlook” (Academy Awards Acceptance Speeches, 2019) , a pivotal aspect of his filmography which is reflected in his Apu Trilogy which shows the struggles of poverty, family deaths and the woes of growing up. This contrasted starkly with the concurrent style in Bollywood which was intensely melodramatic and grandiose- the backbone of <em>masala </em>films (A History of Hindi Cinema: The 1950s, 2025). Satyajit Ray brought in the Indian New Age — a form of cinema based on socio-economic realities, class struggles, discrimination and the subjugation of marginalized communities. Satyajit Ray’s movies garnered praise in international film festivals and even domestically with Indira Gandhi, the former Indian Prime Minister, having a special friendship with the filmmaker and supported Ray’s movies and endeavours (Cherian, 2019) . With this fame, he was recruited by Palden Thondup Namgyal, the last Chogyal of Sovereign Sikkim, to film the documentary <em>Sikkim (1971) </em>(ETimes.In, 2022).</p><h3>Sikkim <em>(1971) </em>and the<em> Initial Ban</em></h3><p>As someone who has recently viewed <em>Sikkim (1971)</em>, the feature that stands out most is the cinematography of the documentary and the monotonous narration. The cinematography is static and slow, with zoom outs and a focus on only a few subjects at a time. It is a slow and meditative movie, which does not attempt to influence the viewer through stylistic choices but rather delivers a full picture of Sikkim’s state without any bias pervading the narration or display of information.</p><p>However, the main goal of the movie was not to be a realistic, grounded documentary of the everyday lives of the population- but rather a promotional film for tourism for the precarious nation sandwiched between India and China- two evergrowing threats to its sovereignty (Bhaumik, 2010). Subsequently, this documentary was banned in Sikkim by the Chogyal due to its portrayal of the wealth gap in Sikkim and the conditions of the extreme poor. This infuriated the Sikkim’s royal family who immediately closed circulation of the film. However, this is the entry of the intentionality of Satyajit Ray’s filmmaking. While the cinematography is still slow and static- the socioeconomic realities of the country are shown when the documentary continuously cuts back and forth from the poor eating the scraps to the grandiose new year celebration.</p><p>Sikkim was a feudalist monarchy pre-annexation and the king (Chogyal meaning <em>“Rightful Monarch”</em>) was the owner of all land which he could give and take back per his discretion. Furthermore, the landlords determined by the Chogyal often exploited peasants by forcing them into unpaid labour (such as carrying loads) and were subject to punishments if they did not engage in labour. Poor peasants in debt could also be imprisoned or forced into manual unpaid labour. The wealth gap was hence defined in terms of owning land as land was the main means of production in the feudal Sikkimese kingdom. As Sikkim grew in population due to the influx of Nepalese immigrants, the wealth gap between the richest and poorest sections of society only grew as more peasants became landless and subjugated to forced labour (Bhutia, 2021).</p><p>This predicament was a hard sell to tourists, only amplified by Satyajit Ray’s realistic, humanistic portrayal of the widespread poverty and depreciating living conditions that would have further worsened its image. This is, however, no different from Satyajit Ray’s other movies and is not politically motivated for or against Sikkim, but rather for the people. Therefore this movie was banned in the Kingdom of Sikkim.</p><h3>Introduction of Sikkim’s secession to India</h3><p>Sikkim was established as a protectorate state of Britain, a status carried forward post-British rule where Sikkim became a protectorate under India in 1950 under the Indo-Sikkimese Treaty of 1950 (About Sikkim — Sikkim Tourism). This meant that the defence, international relations and “territorial integrity” (and public infrastructure to some extent) of Sikkim will be under the control of the government of India and all internal affairs will be under the administration of the Sikkimese authority. As outlined above, there was a large wealth gap pervading the country as well as a feudal, autocratic authority governing the state. Furthermore, voting rights in Sikkim were skewed to give power to Bhutia and Lepcha communities by equating 6 votes by Nepali immigrants to one vote from those communities (“How Sikkim Became the 22nd State of India.”<em>, </em>2018<em>)</em>. Due to this autocratic rule and the weakness of democracy in Sikkim, there were multiple anti-monarchy protests in 1973 aiming for the strengthening the voice of elected officials (Sethi, 2015). This led to the creation of 8th May Agreements i..e.,- the Tripartite Solution which led to the creation of a Sikkimese Legislative Assembly, Executive Council and a Chief Executive. Subsequently general elections were held in 1974 where the pro-Chogyal party only won 1 seat out of 32, whereas the other 31 were one by the ardently anti-monarchy party — Sikkim Congress. The pro-monarchy party Sikkim National Party formed an Anti-india stance and claimed collusion between the Sikkim Congress and the government of India as a form of encroachment on Sikkim’s sovereignty. While these may be unfounded, it is true that Sikkim was slowly being absorbed into India which was signalled by the 1974 decision to make Sikkim an associate nation of India and bring Sikkimese officials into Indian parliament (The Spokesman-Review — Google News Archive Search) and make both the countries intrinsically intertwined such that India becomes an annexer. Tensions between India and the Chogyal and his supporters continued to rise after the creation of this article, leading to violence and the deployment of Indian troops in Sikkim (“How Sikkim Became the 22nd State of India.”, 2018). During this chaos, the National Assembly passed a resolution to abolish the Chogyal and a merger with India on April 10th 1975. 4 days later, a referendum was conducted (Rai, 2017) with a 63% voter turnout. Out of this, 97% of voters elected to join India. This led to Sikkim becoming the 22nd State of the Indian Union on May 16th, 1975 (Banka, 2022).</p><h3>Reason for Ban in India</h3><p>While the Sikkimese monarchical regime ended in 1975, the decision to ban <em>Sikkim (1971)</em>, did not end as India also chose to ban the documentary. However, this was not due to the subject matter of the film but rather the fact that the imagery of people prostrating to the Chogyal was antithetical to the idea of democratic governments (Maji, 2017). Ray himself noted that this was not a coherent reason to ban the movie. It can be inferred, that the reason for the ban may be derived from the tension in the atmosphere after the immensely controversial annexation, as many allege that the plebiscite was rigged and that there was great support for the Chogyal (a disputed historical claim which has not been proved definitively). Hence, this ban could be used to prevent the resurgence of nostalgia for the old regime and for independence. This is only an inference derived from the fact that there have been multiple historical movies portraying subjects prostrating or kneeling in front of historical rulers such as Mughal-e-Azam (1960) which was not banned, and was largely popular. Furthermore, the movie was not banned in India in 1971 despite the fact that it being made by Satyajit Ray would have led to widespread circulation in the country.</p><h3>A Timeless Tale</h3><p>While the theme of widening wealth gaps pervades the fabric of modern Indian society, the issue most relevant to the modern North-East in relation to <em>Sikkim (1971)</em>, is the restriction of information and suppression of socioeconomic struggles. Furthermore, the threat to sovereignty that Sikkim faced strikingly mirrors the current governance of the North East under the Central Government’s thumb and the lack of autonomy given to tribes. Consecutively, working on the above inference regarding the censorship of <em>Sikkim (1971) </em>in India to prevent sentiments of Sikkimese independence — suppression of pro-independence movements or any material which incites such feelings is a pattern repeated in modern North-eastern history.</p><p>In regards to the restriction of information and suppression of socioeconomic struggles in the North-east, continuous internet bans have been imposed across multiple states such as Manipur, Assam, Tripura and Meghalaya during times of conflict and state-wide protests (Nazmi, 2019). There have also been multiple insurgencies in North-eastern states for autonomy and even independence such as the 1940s Naga Insurgency, 1960s-70s Mizo National Front and the United Liberation Front of Assam in the 1980s which have been met with military action from the central government (Pathak, 2025). The attempt to stop pro-independent sentiment in Sikkim from forming is considered the alleged reason for the ban of the documentary — a supposed case of suppression of the North-east from the centre, which echoes throughout history.</p><h3>Bibliography</h3><p>Bharat, Etv. “Satyajit Ray Birth Anniversary: How the Oscar-Winning Director Inspired Spielberg, Scorsese, Coppola and More.” <em>ETV Bharat News</em>, 2 May 2025, <a href="http://www.etvbharat.com/en/!entertainment/satyajit-ray-birth-anniversary-how-the-oscar-winning-director-inspired-steven-spielberg-martin-scorsese-francis-ford-coppola-and-more-enn25050201016">www.etvbharat.com/en/!entertainment/satyajit-ray-birth-anniversary-how-the-oscar-winning-director-inspired-steven-spielberg-martin-scorsese-francis-ford-coppola-and-more-enn25050201016</a>.</p><p>“Academy Awards Acceptance Speeches — Search Results | Margaret Herrick Library | Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences.” <em>Copyright © 2019 Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences</em>, <a href="http://aaspeechesdb.oscars.org/link/064%E2%80%9324">aaspeechesdb.oscars.org/link/064–24</a>.</p><p>A History of Hindi Cinema: The 1950s.” <em>AV Club</em>, 20 Feb. 2025,</p><p><a href="http://www.avclub.com/history-of-hindi-cinema-1950s">www.avclub.com/history-of-hindi-cinema-1950s</a>.</p><p>Cherian, V. K. “Satyajit Ray and His Two Powerful Female Patrons.” <em>The Indian Express</em>, 2 May 2019, <a href="http://indianexpress.com/article/entertainment/bollywood/satyajit-ray-death-anniversary-powerful-female-patrons-5684433">indianexpress.com/article/entertainment/bollywood/satyajit-ray-death-anniversary-powerful-female-patrons-5684433</a></p><p>ETimes.In. “Even Satyajit Ray Couldn’t Escape Censorship, the Untold Story of His Once-banned Documentary ‘Sikkim.’” <em>The Times of India</em>, 2 May 2022, <a href="http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/entertainment/bengali/movies/news/even-satyajit-ray-couldnt-escape-censorship-the-unheard-story-of-his-once-banned-sikkim/photostory/91255179.cms?picid=91255363">timesofindia.indiatimes.com/entertainment/bengali/movies/news/even-satyajit-ray-couldnt-escape-censorship-the-unheard-story-of-his-once-banned-sikkim/photostory/91255179.cms?picid=91255363</a>.</p><p>Bhaumik, Subir. “Ban on Satyajit Ray Film Lifted.” <em>BBC News</em>, 17 Sept. 2010, <a href="http://www.bbc.com/news/world-south-asia-11345987">www.bbc.com/news/world-south-asia-11345987</a>.</p><p>Bhutia, Samten Doma. “Emergence of Feudal Mode of Production in Sikkim (1642–1890).” <em>Sikkim University</em>, thesis, 2021.</p><p><em>About Sikkim — Sikkim Tourism</em>. <a href="http://sikkimtourism.gov.in/Public/ExperienceSikkim/history">sikkimtourism.gov.in/Public/ExperienceSikkim/history</a>.</p><p>“How Sikkim Became the 22nd State of India.” <em>NewsClick</em>, 2018, <a href="http://www.newsclick.in/how-sikkim-became-22nd-state-india#:~:text=So%20what%20were%20the%20events,disparity%20soon%20led%20to%20protests">www.newsclick.in/how-sikkim-became-22nd-state-india#:~:text=So%20what%20were%20the%20events,disparity%20soon%20led%20to%20protests</a>.</p><p>Sethi, Sunil. “Did India Have a Right to Annex Sikkim in 1975?” <em>India Today</em>, 18 Feb. 2015, <a href="http://www.indiatoday.in/magazine/cover-story/story/19780430-did-india-have-a-right-to-annex-sikkim-in-1975-818651-2015-02-18">www.indiatoday.in/magazine/cover-story/story/19780430-did-india-have-a-right-to-annex-sikkim-in-1975-818651-2015-02-18</a>.</p><p><em>The Spokesman-Review — Google News Archive Search</em>. <a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20190821135735/https://news.google.com/newspapers?nid=1314&amp;dat=19740905&amp;id=vR5OAAAAIBAJ&amp;sjid=NO0DAAAAIBAJ&amp;pg=7242,1915999">web.archive.org/web/20190821135735/https://news.google.com/newspapers?nid=1314&amp;dat=19740905&amp;id=vR5OAAAAIBAJ&amp;sjid=NO0DAAAAIBAJ&amp;pg=7242,1915999</a>.</p><p>“How Sikkim Became the 22nd State of India.” <em>NewsClick</em>, 2018, <a href="http://www.newsclick.in/how-sikkim-became-22nd-state-india#:~:text=So%20what%20were%20the%20events,disparity%20soon%20led%20to%20protests">www.newsclick.in/how-sikkim-became-22nd-state-india#:~:text=So%20what%20were%20the%20events,disparity%20soon%20led%20to%20protests</a>.</p><p>Rai, Bishwas Mani. “Merger of Sikkim and Politics of Development.” <em>Sikkim University</em>, edited by Amit Kumar Gupta, Feb. 2017.</p><p>Banka, Neha. “Explained: How Sikkim Became a Part of India.” <em>The Indian Express</em>, 17 May 2022, <a href="http://indianexpress.com/article/explained/explained-sikkim-history-culture-became-a-part-of-india-7920790">indianexpress.com/article/explained/explained-sikkim-history-culture-became-a-part-of-india-7920790</a>.</p><p>Maji, Shyamasri. “Reading the ‘Facts’ in Satyajit Ray’s Documentary Films: A Critical Overview.” <em>DOC Online — Revista Digital De Cinema Documentário</em>, no. 21, Mar. 2017, pp. 147–65, doi:10.20287/doc.d21.ar5.</p><p>Nazmi, By Shadab. <em>Why India Shuts Down the Internet More Than Any Other Democracy</em>. 19 Dec. 2019, <a href="http://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-50819905">www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-50819905</a>.</p><p>Pathak, Vivek. “Peacebuilding and conflict in the Northeast.” International Journal of Sociology and Political Science, 8th July 2025 <a href="https://www.sociologyjournal.in/assets/archives/2025/vol7issue3/7032.pdf">https://www.sociologyjournal.in/assets/archives/2025/vol7issue3/7032.pdf</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=0699d247f0a3" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Great Indian Copaganda]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@cyruscylinder48/great-indian-copaganda-3ccdce9df8db?source=rss-6d84b70473ca------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3ccdce9df8db</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[movıe]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[police]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[islamophobia]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[censorship]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[casteism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Censored]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 01 Jun 2025 12:30:17 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-08-09T15:47:58.469Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*GEQVllK0zctN2TXgG9Uk4w.png" /></figure><p>Violence is constantly utilised as a weapon to continue the oppression of marginalised communities. According to the<a href="https://www.overcomingviolence.org/en/resources/campaigns/women-against-violence/now-we-%20are-fearless/dalit-fact-sheet.html"> Dalit fact sheet</a>, 13 Dalits are murdered each week, 5 Dalit homes are burnt each week, 6 Dalit people are kidnapped or abducted each week and 21 Dalit women raped each week.</p><p>It is important for us to recognise the horrific reality and struggles of the oppressed so that we can fight against it and take a step towards equality. The movie ‘<em>Santosh’ </em>attempts to do this.</p><p>The critically acclaimed and award-winning movie <em>‘Santosh’ (2024)</em> was banned from screening in India by the Central Board of Film Certification(CBFC). It follows the titular character <em>‘Santosh’ (Shahana Goswami)</em> as her husband who was a police officer is killed in a communal riot in the fictional state of ‘Chirag Pradesh’. The ‘compassionate appointment’ scheme allows the government to employ dependent family members of a public servant who dies in service or cannot work on medical grounds. Hence, Santosh becomes a police officer and starts working on a case about the rape and murder of a Dalit girl.</p><p>The ensuing narrative explores the hegemonic structures in Indian society which allow privileged ‘upper-caste’ members to flout responsibility and perpetrate violence while also allowing police officers the right to torture, abuse and kill suspects with little evidence. Moreover, it explores the victimisation of the Dalit and Muslim community in India. It also explores workplace misogyny and hence, dissects the caste, religion and gender based discriminatory practices interwoven in the fabric of Indian society.</p><p>The themes of this movie are succinctly expressed by the charismatic police chief <em>Sharma (Sunita Rajwar)</em> in this comment,</p><p><em>“There are two types of untouchables in this country. Those who no one wants to touch, and those who can’t be touched.”</em></p><p>The film does not shy away from the brutal realities of the cultural landscape of India and its commentary rings truer now than ever due to the rise in Islamophobia and casteism since the election of a far-right, Hindutva government in 2014.</p><h4>Why was it banned?</h4><p>According to the <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/world/2025/mar/26/santosh-film-blocked-india-police-brutality-cannes#:~:text=Internationally%20acclaimed%20film%20Santosh%20blocked%20in%20India%20over%20portrayal%20of%20police%20brutality,-This%20article%20is&amp;text=Indian%20film%20censors%20have%20blocked,in%20the%20Indian%20police%20force">Guardian</a>, Indian film censors blocked the release of <em>Santosh</em> because of its negative portrayal of the police. Due to <em>Santosh</em>’s depiction of misogyny, Islamophobia and violence in the Indian police force, the CBFC demanded cuts be made to the movie before its release. However, Sandhya Suri, the director of the movie, refused to do so as, “it was just too difficult to make those cuts and have a film that still made sense, let alone stayed true to its vision.”</p><p>According to <a href="https://prsindia.org/billtrack/the-cinematograph-amendment-bill-2023">The Cinematograph (Amendment) Bill, 2023</a> the CBFC may subject films to modifications/deletions or may refuse exhibition of a film. But why is it that the board only required ‘<em>Santosh’ </em>to make certain cuts to the film? According to Suri, the CBFC’s concerns were shocking, “because I didn’t feel that these issues were particularly new to Indian cinema or hadn’t been raised before by other films.”</p><p>The themes and events depicted in ‘<em>Santosh’ </em>are not new to the Indian audience, instead they are the sad reality of countless people in India. What’s more is that we have seen violence exhibited by the police force in multiple bollywood movies throughout the years. What is different about <em>Santosh </em>that caused the CBFC to request such radical cuts? Is it the lack of a macho hero? Is it because there is no attractive heroine to play the damsel in distress? Is it because instead of celebrating the flaws of the Indian police force, ‘<em>Santosh’</em> criticizes them? To understand the banning of <em>‘Santosh’</em>, we must understand the fundamental differences between <em>‘Santosh’</em> and an ordinary Bollywood cop movie.</p><h4>Comparison to the Bollywood Cop Universe</h4><p>In ‘<em>Simmba’ (2018)</em>, the titular hero of the movie ‘<em>Simmba’</em> engages in corruption and bribery as a police officer. He helps a prominent gangster in return for higher bribes. The brothers of this gangster deal illicit substances and use children as their mules. This is noticed by Aakruti, a woman who Simmba sees as a sister. She tries to take action against these gangsters but is caught and brutally raped. She is taken to the hospital where Simmba stays by her bedside as she dies. Simmba realises that the brothers of the gangster he aided were Aakruti’s rapists and hence fakes a police encounter with them so that he can claim he killed them in self defence. This is verified as self-defence by Bajirao Singham <em>(Ajay Devgan)</em>, the hero of the popular movie franchise: <em>‘Singham’</em>.</p><p>The most famous Indian action movies in the previous decades have all had Muslim characters as their main villains, most of them portraying terrorists such as ‘<em>Sooryavanshi’ (2021) , ‘Ek Tha Tiger’ Trilogy, ‘Fighter’ (2024), ‘Pathaan’ (2023) </em>and<em> ‘War’ (2019).</em> Furthermore, Simmba shows the corruption in the law enforcement system of India, but this movie does not address the systemic reasons for this corruption. It does not solve this corruption but rather only shows the transformation of Simmba; one corrupt cop. Moreover, the ramifications of Simmba’s corruption are not fully fleshed out, and he is shown as a charismatic, likeable character despite his corrupt practices. He helps high profile gangsters — those with power, and as a byproduct harms underprivileged children — those who are powerless. Yet he is the hero because he changed in the end? Singham knows about Simmba’s corruption but does not hold him accountable because he wants Simmba’s case to be a warning to people who may assault women in the future. This is undeniably well-intentioned, but does it not speak to the ease with which police officers can flout accountability and unbiased judgements?</p><p><em>‘Santosh’</em> dismantles these formulas. It places more emphasis on the direct effects of bias and corruption compared to the personal growth of the heroine. <em>‘Santosh’</em> shows the direct effects of police corruption and bias. The male dominated police department initially mocks Devika’s concerned father, making light-hearted jests akin to the joking manner of Simmba and other ‘charismatic’ action heroes. The disregard of Devika’s case is a byproduct of casteist and misogynistic biases of the police. A young innocent Muslim boy is murdered by Santosh in the investigation as a byproduct of Islamophobic police bias. The police continued to torture the boy as they were unsatisfied with his answers. The progressive increase in the brutality of Saleem’s treatment reflects police brutality so often shown as ‘noble’ and ‘righteous’ in movies like ‘<em>Simmba’</em>. No justice is served and Santosh is let go, unpunished for killing Saleem. However, the audience does not view this as a happy ending for our heroine, but a grim reflection of our reality.</p><p>Ordinary Bollywood cop movies do not recognise casteist, religious or gender based divides. These divides just serve as characterisation, with Muslim villains (usually terrorists) and weak, vulnerable women which need protection provided by the larger than life macho male leads who engage in ‘righteous’ violence to serve justice.</p><p><em>‘Santosh’</em> recognises these divides and shows their devastating effect in the real world. It takes out the glitz and glamour of Bollywood and shows the results of police chasing down muslim ‘villains’, shows the police’s treatment of vulnerable women, shows the effect of violence and brutality in police investigations and shows the effect of caste on delivering ‘justice’. However, Santosh does not deliver justice. By showing these effects, <em>‘Santosh’</em> is able to create a landscape which closely and uncomfortably reflects the reality of Indian society. It reaches the conclusion — if the hierarchical systems dividing society by caste, religion and sex persist, no true justice can be served. Hence, the movie that is banned is not the one promoting police brutality, the one with implicit misogyny and Islamophobia , but the one condemning these discriminatory practices and the government structures which allow them to flourish.</p><h4>Reaction from Viewers</h4><p><em>‘Santosh’ (2024)</em> was the official submission by the United Kingdom for the Academy Award for Best Feature Film. It was nominated for a BAFTA award as well and has already won 5 awards. It was received with thunderous applause by both critics and audiences.</p><p>However, there was a negative reaction towards the movie specifically due to its discussion of institutionalised Islamophobia, casteism and sexism. Many negative reviewers have touted the movie as an anti-nationalist and anti-Hindu propaganda film fuelled by anti-Indian western sentiments.</p><p>For example — In his 1-star review <em>Manik Ghoshal</em> states, “A totally anti-Hindu film” as the filmmakers, “intend to throw muck on Hindus alone.”Furthermore, the reviewer <em>Black Kaizer </em>repeatedly uses ‘apparently’ in their review to suggest that it is somehow unrealistic for police officers to target minority groups such as Muslims and for upper-caste members of society to abuse their power despite the countless statistics showing that this is the case.<em> ‘Santosh’ (2024) </em>showcases how Islamophobia and casteism weaken the pursuit of justice and shield guilty parties. It shows the targeting of Muslims. However, it never states that this is the fault of Hindus or Hinduism. It does not state that the inequity in Indian society was constructed by Hinduism but rather, that this inequity favors Hindus in India. <em>‘Santosh’</em> (2024) is a movie about Islamophobia and casteism in government institutions, so why did reviewers leave the theatre thinking it was ‘Anti Hindu’?</p><p>The answer lies in the ideology of these reviewers which conflates Hinduism with the government of India, showing that they believe that the government of India is, or rather should be wholly Hindu. Hence, a critique of government structures must be an attack on the morality of Hindus. This is spelled out by <em>Manik Ghoshal </em>again in his review where he states that the filmmakers intend on, “Keeping the Hindus divided for election purpose, so that a pan Hinduism party can’t come to power.” How does a movie critiquing the government stop Hindus and Hindu influence? Moreover, India is meant to be a secular state, as stated clearly by the Preamble to the Indian Constitution. Hence, stating that a ‘pan-Hinduism party’ meaning a party which only represents Hindu values should come to power is showing the Hindu Nationalist ideology of the reviewers. The party that they have obliquely referred to is the BJP who they have tried to distance from the critique in the movie by stating that, “The society portrayed is probably pre-independence British Raj days or Congress rule of ‘Divide Hindus and Rule’ days.” They are implying that there is no possibility of inequality flourishing under the BJP rule, even stretching as far back as to the British Raj. However it has been a decade under the BJP and religiously motivated attacks against Dalits and Muslims have only increased such as Cow lynchings. Furthermore, ‘<em>Santosh’ (2024)</em> takes place in the fictional town of ‘Chirag Pradesh’ where no party has been mentioned. Hence, reviewers immediately jumping to defend the BJP and Hindu ideology which were not mentioned or insulted shows the Hindu Nationalist ideology of reviewers who conflate government structures with Hindu structures.</p><p>Other reviewers state the Western ‘Liberal’ bias of the filmmakers is prevalent in the movie because the filmmakers are, “trying to set a selective truth as a blanket reality about India,” as<em> Deepak </em>stated in his 1-star review. He states that these are, “selective one sided ills of society.” Reviewers have continuously tried to state that the movie disregards discrimination against Hindus by Muslims who are apparently, “the real problem.” These reviewers have missed the entire point of the movie which aims to show the struggles of Muslims and Dalits in India. The discrimination against Muslims and Dalit is a fact, proven time and time again. It is not the imagination of Western liberals, it’s the reality of marginalised communities. To reiterate, the movie does not deny the fact that Hindus can be discriminated against because this movie is not about discrimination of Hindus. Moreover, it is a fact that in Indian hegemonic systems, specifically North Indian hegemonic systems which is where ‘Chirag Pradesh’ is set, have upper-caste Hindus at the top. This is not a contestable claim, but rather the reality of North Indian society. Judging the movie by this metric is not only unfair but shows the Hindu-centric mindset of the reviewers who cannot look past their ideological lens to recognise the suffering of others. Moreover, these reviewers have used the fact that <em>Santosh</em> does not address Hindu discrimination to be blatantly Islamophobic. The phrase, “the real problem” was taken from the review b<em>y </em><a href="https://www.youtube.com/@vEDANAMS"><em>@vEDANAMS</em></a> who stated that,“I am not saying there was no problem in the past but these movie makers don’t show the real problem which is Islam and muslims all over the world.” Why did they have to state, “in the past”? It is because they think Islamophobia is not a problem in modern day India despite evidence of it still existing. ‘The real problem’ is not only blatantly Islamophobic but it also shows that the reviewer does not believe that casteism and Islamophobia are real problems. Furthermore, another reviewer states that, “The narrative was good until it focused on topic and then it’s shifted to foreshadowing Muslim/Hindu terror on weaker people”. The narrative was not about Muslim/Hindu terror on weaker people, it was about terror on Muslims and Dalits who have been systemically weakened by upper-caste members. This movie does not aim to villainise Hindus, it aims to show the victimization of Muslims and Dalits and most reviewers who have missed that point have a blatantly Hindu Nationalist mindset.</p><p>The Islamophobia of these viewers blinds them to the tragedy of Devika’s rape. The only time viewers mention Devika’s rape and death is when they claim that it was a, “cheap and very easy” way to get, “recognition and success” (quotes from<em> @vEDANAMS</em>). The lack of acknowledgment of Devika’s rape is similar to<em> ‘Simmba’ (2018)</em> in which Aakruti’s rape is a mere tool for Simmba’s character development. Hence, it is also mentioned sparingly by viewers who instead wish to rave about how Ranveer Singh and Sara Ali Khan’s pairing looks, “wonderful” and how the movie is a, “well packaged mass masala”.(Quotes from <em>everything is awesome</em>). The catalyst of ‘<em>Santosh’ (2024)</em> is Devika’s rape and the movie places immense focus on her death and the struggles of marginalised communities compared to ‘<em>Simmba’ (2018)</em>, which uses these struggles as a backdrop. Hence, Hindu nationalist viewers are more aggravated by<em> ‘Santosh’ (2024).</em></p><p>This might be a vocal minority as this movie was banned by India. However, even in the limited pool of viewers, if there are these many Islamophobic and ignorant Hindu nationalists, it is a cause for concern. It indicates how common Islamophobia has become in Indian society where an ordinary citizen cites the, “real problem” as muslims. Almost all negative reviews of ‘<em>Santosh’</em> fall into the category of Islamophobia and Hindu Nationalism which are strong held beliefs of the BJP government which operates the Ministry of Information and Broadcasting under which the CBFC is a statutory body.</p><h4>Verdict</h4><p>In 2019, 60% of the deaths in police custody, documented by <a href="https://www.uncat.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/06/INDIATORTURE2019.pdf">NCAT</a>, belonged to poor and marginalised communities. According to the <a href="https://www.commoncause.in/wotadmin/upload/SPIR%20_%202025a.pdf">Status of Policing in India Report 2025</a>, in Delhi, Rajasthan, Maharashtra, Gujarat, Jharkhand, Madhya Pradesh, Assam, Karnataka, West Bengal, and Odisha more than 50% of police personnel believe Muslims are naturally prone to committing crimes to great extent or to some extent. The same report also states, “more than 70% of the police personnel believe that police should be allowed to use force without any fear”. Furthermore, the study also found that, “one-fourth of the police personnel would prefer to solve a case by any means rather than strictly follow legal procedures”. All the data at hand leads one to the conclusion that the Indian police force is ignorant and has clear prejudices against marginalised communities. Moreover, the data clearly states that most of the Indian police force don’t believe in adhering to proper procedures and are, instead, inclined to use torture when dealing with potential suspects. So why is it that movies such as <em>Santosh</em> that question these harmful beliefs are denied release, but movies like <em>Singham</em>, <em>Simmba</em> and <em>Sooryavanshi</em> that glorify the police force’s wrongdoings are celebrated? Why is it that Hindu Nationalists feel attacked by the movie? One can only infer that it is because they do not see anything wrong with the injustices shown in the movie. It is a cause of concern that the depiction of the struggles of minorities can elicit such an angry response from people. If you have a problem with the criticism of a structure that continues to oppress and discriminate against minorities then what you want is privilege not justice and you are part of the problem.</p><p>The ban of <em>Santosh</em> raises concerns not only about the actions of the Indian police force but also about the government of India. Despite there being constitutional safeguards against the discrimination of anyone based on caste, gender or religion, it is evident that it is not effective. Censorship of such movies only contributes to the oppression and discrimination faced by marginalized communities in India, like Dalits and Muslims. The government cannot claim to be fair and just while banning movies like ‘<em>Santosh’.</em> The outrage and discomfort portrayed by the CBFC and some viewers only reinforces <em>Santosh’</em>s message that casteism and Islamophobia are still rampant in India. That is why it is important that movies like ‘<em>Santosh’</em>, which bring attention to the struggles faced by different communities in India, are released in Indian cinema.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3ccdce9df8db" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>