<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Daniel Noah Moses on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Daniel Noah Moses on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@danielmoses36?source=rss-dbf020efe563------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 05:34:43 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@danielmoses36/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The World Cup, Hannah Arendt, and Mahmoud Darwish in Gaza: “The Banality of Evil”]]></title>
            <link>https://danielmoses36.medium.com/the-world-cup-hannah-arendt-and-mahmoud-darwish-in-gaza-the-banality-of-evil-8753809a878e?source=rss-dbf020efe563------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8753809a878e</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Daniel Noah Moses]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 20 Jul 2026 23:01:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-07-26T02:51:57.672Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*kqZeORcPyn097LeyGeS1AA.jpeg" /><figcaption>The Global Stone Project in Berlin by German artist Wolfgang von Schwarzenfeld,</figcaption></figure><p>I read recently in <em>The New York Times </em>about an Israeli airstrike that killed a sixty-five year old Palestinian aid worker by the name of Mohammed al-Waheidi. He was in Gaza, in a car, on his way to watch the Argentina-Egypt World Cup game at a friend’s house <em>“when he was hit by the Israeli strike, according to his son, Fawaz, 22.”</em></p><p>Waheidi worked for the Egyptian Committee in Gaza. According to the article, <em>“in addition to facilitating deliveries of humanitarian aid, the committee helps resolve disputes between families, and was organizing World Cup watch parties around Gaza over the past few weeks”</em></p><p><em>“The younger Mr. al-Waheidi said in a telephone interview that he was told on Tuesday evening that an airstrike had killed a person with his last name. He frantically tried calling his father, but a stranger answered the phone and said only that someone had been wounded.”</em></p><p><em>“He said he then raced to the hospital, where he identified a bloodied body as belonging to his father.”</em></p><p><em>“‘I was totally stunned,’” he said. ‘He was such a good man.’”</em></p><p>The son says that his father, a former teacher for the Palestinian Authority — which Hamas fought against and pushed out of Gaza — was a supporter of peace with Israel.</p><p>The son <em>“also said that Hamas had arrested and tortured his father before the Oct. 7, 2023, attack because of his opposition to the group.”</em></p><p><em>“‘He was persecuted by them,’” he [the son] said of Hamas” </em>(The article, published on July 9th, 2026, is by Adam Rasgon, reporting from Jerusalem, and Abu Bakr Bashir reporting from Sheffield, England).</p><p>I read this article over my morning coffee in upstate New York. Since then, I’ve been thinking about the violent death of a man who was looking forward to watching a soccer game with a friend but was killed for no good reason by the overwhelming military machine of a state at perpetual war — an asymmetrical war in which innocent civilians, including children, keep dying.</p><p>As I read this article, Hannah Arendt came to my mind.</p><p>A German Jew, in 1933 Arendt was imprisoned briefly by the Gestapo for doing research about antisemitism. She fled to France. There, she worked for Youth Aliyah helping Jewish children in Europe escape to Mandatory Palestine. Just before the Nazis invaded France, Arendt was imprisoned by the French as an “enemy alien.” After the Nazi invasion of France, she and her second husband, Heinrich Blücher, made their way to Portugal and escaped by ship to America.</p><p>Years later, from April to December, 1961, Arendt, by then a political theorist, a thinker, a writer, of rare insight, attended the trial of Adolph Eichmann in Jerusalem. She observed Eichmann, a man behind the systematic slaughter of millions of people — murder at industrial scale. She listened to victims, to witnesses, to experts. What struck her most was how normal he seemed. He was decent to his family and those in his immediate circles. He was not a sadist: instead, he was a practiced bureaucrat.</p><p>According to Arendt, Eichmann was “not stupid.” But he was “simply, genuinely, completely incapable of thinking from the standpoint of anybody else.” She said that “he spoke exclusively in cliches. . . .in officialese. . . .he was surrounded by stock phrases that insulated him entirely from reality. . .” To put this another way, Eichmann was able to play a key role in the mass murder of millions because he had stopped thinking.</p><p>This is what what Arendt meant by the “banality of evil.”</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2F6OJDSs_6eAQ%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fshorts%2F6OJDSs_6eAQ%3Fsi%3DI0sziXgL0nvndr49&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2F6OJDSs_6eAQ%2Fhq2.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/590b6b7cf10825f0d4fdda7be79abcdf/href">https://medium.com/media/590b6b7cf10825f0d4fdda7be79abcdf/href</a></iframe><p>Arendt agreed with the court’s decision to hang Eichmann. But she believed it drew the wrong lesson from the trial. The lesson, she argued, was NOT about “eternal persecution of the Jews.”</p><p>“What it actually revealed,” she said, “was something universal and therefore more terrifying. That ordinary men functioning within ordinary institutions can perpetuate extraordinary evil, not by becoming monsters, but by ceasing to think. This is the question that Jerusalem left open, not how do we punish the guilty, but how does an entire civilization produce men for whom obedience replaces conscience. How do we guard against that. Eichmann is dead. But the conditions that made Eichmann possible — the bureaucracy, the language rules, the relief of personal judgment — those are not gone. They are never far away.”</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2F0KKksicILvk%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fshorts%2F0KKksicILvk%3Ffeature%3Dshare&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2F0KKksicILvk%2Fhq2.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/6043e0eaa5e365aceb9fe69012520622/href">https://medium.com/media/6043e0eaa5e365aceb9fe69012520622/href</a></iframe><p>According to <em>The New York Times</em> article about the death of Mohammed al-Waheidi: <em>“The Israeli military said it had struck a Hamas militant in the attack on Tuesday in northern Gaza, but did not identify that person or say whether they had been killed. It said in a statement that it was aware of ‘the claim that uninvolved civilians were harmed as a result of the strike’ and ‘regrets any harm’ to such people.”</em></p><p>I once took a course on Jewish ethics in Jerusalem with the philosopher of Jewish thought Moshe Halbertal who, from what I understand, played a role in the composition of the IDF’s code of conduct. I will not forget his graceful explication of The Rambam’s <em>Eight Chapters</em>, an introduction to <em>Pirkei Avot</em> (<em>Ethics of The Fathers).</em></p><p>The IDF’s code of conduct, “The Spirit of the IDF,” claims to be built upon four pillars: the third one is the commitment to treat all human beings with dignity, no matter their “identity.”</p><p>The Nazis did not articulate this kind of commitment. Such language never emerged from the lips of Adolph Eichmann.</p><p>But when it comes to Mohammed al-Waheidi’s death, the unknown IDF spokepeople and those with whom they work do not live by the third pillar of the IDF’s code of conduct.</p><p>By failing to acknowledge the death of Mohammed al-Waheid, by failing to name the man whom they killed, by using vague words such as “harm,” the individuals in The IDF insulate themselves from the impact of their actions. They distance themselves, and the audience they want to reach, from what the system they are a part of is doing to others day after day.</p><p>They do not mention Mohammed al-Waheid’s name. They do not mention his death. They do not encourage anybody else to think about him. They make him invisible.</p><p>The core lesson of the Eichmann trial is not about primordial hatred of Jews (though we must not ignore the persistence and troubling resurgence of antisemitism). It is about what people with power in the nodes of modern bureaucracy do to other human beings without thinking while oblivious bystanders go about their everyday routines.</p><p>The talk of “harm” instead of the killing of a specific human being sets off alarm bells.</p><p>I say this as a Jew with love and empathy for my Israeli Jewish family members, friends, and former colleagues. I say this as an American acutely aware of the American military machine blowing up boats off the coast of Venezuela and bombing an elementary school in Iran. I say this with awareness of the banality of evil rampant across the American bureaucracy. Think of ICE. Think of the inept and cruel demolition of USAID’s public health programs and of public health inside American borders. Think of the gutting of life-saving science, of environmental protections, and of measures to engage with climate change. American policy makers in the Trump administration are wrapping themselves up in cliches as they look away from the suffering they inflict and the damage they do. The damage is everywhere.</p><p>Arendt and her husband were able to escape to America. But America is different this time around.</p><p>Mohammed al-Waheid’s son: <em>“said he did not want anyone to use his father’s killing for more violence.”</em></p><p><em>“What we need is peace,” he said. ‘May God have mercy on my father.’”</em></p><p>Donald Trump and Bibi Netanyahu are dragging the countries they lead to an abyss. Trump and his minions do NOT speak for me. On multiple fronts, I oppose what my government is doing. <strong>I want to see more Israeli Jews oppose their government. I want to hear louder Israeli Jewish voices crying out for basic humanity.</strong></p><p>When I’ve posted on FB about my opposition to the brutality of Netanyahu’s government, I’ve gotten enraged pushback from former Israeli Jewish colleagues (mostly from The Ministry of Education). They’ve called me a “self-hating Jew.” One of them, a kibbutznik, a woman of The Left, once a self-described peace activist, told me she doesn’t care what happens to the people of Gaza.</p><p>I have a sense of the depths of the October 7th trauma. I understand what happens when people are afraid, how they often shut down, how they go to their corners. I understand: it’s easier to turn away.</p><p>But I also know Israeli Jews, Palestinian citizens of Israel/Arab Israelis, and Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza, along with supporters on all sides, who still see one another as human beings deserving of basic human rights — decent shelter, clean water, enough healthy food, medical care, security, freedom, dignity. I know people who, even as the flames climb higher, keep their hearts open to “the other.” I’m talking about individuals who after a while stop seeing “the other” and instead just see a dear friend.</p><p>For over twenty five years, I’ve worked across lines of conflict. For eleven, I lived in Jerusalem. Sometimes, I feel that whatever my colleagues and I were able to accomplish has gone up in smoke. Other times, I’m filled with hope and gratitude because I have experienced what is possible.</p><p>In June of 2017, a group of us gathered for a creative retreat in the desert. From that gathering, we organized a concert in New York City. I’ve lost faith in the organization that funded us. But I’ve kept my faith in the people. One of those people, the multi-talented creative force, the courageous, kind, beautiful, Mira Awad, brought her friends together to sing and record a song that Hannah Arendt would appreciate, a song that Adolph Eichmann would not understand. This song — so full of the “moral imagination,” based on a poem by the Palestinian poet Mahmoud Darwish — is called “Think of Others.”</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FpXIW6uEbZGQ%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DpXIW6uEbZGQ&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FpXIW6uEbZGQ%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/7bebf4128a9b8b1c2df2befba68bff08/href">https://medium.com/media/7bebf4128a9b8b1c2df2befba68bff08/href</a></iframe><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8753809a878e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Common Denominator is Human Rights: The Rise of The Jewish Left]]></title>
            <link>https://danielmoses36.medium.com/the-rise-of-the-jewish-left-60d9ff048093?source=rss-dbf020efe563------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/60d9ff048093</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[us-politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[israel]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hope]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[palestine]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Daniel Noah Moses]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 26 Feb 2026 15:15:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-22T15:19:37.941Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*a4NNk5FYaMQNNDpJRAv1-g.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>Prelude</em></p><p>March 4th, 2026</p><p>I posted the essay below a few days before Trump and Netanyahu started their war against Iran (on Saturday, February 28th, 2026). What I wrote is now relevant in new ways. Blinded by hubris, Trump and Netanyahu are inflicting unnecessary death, suffering, and destruction, while putting the Iranian people, their own peoples, The people of the broader Middle East, and the world, in unnecessary danger. We’re at another precipice.</p><p><em>What to Do</em></p><p>February 26th, 2026</p><p>The news about what’s happening in The United States, and in Israel/Palestine, and what reverberates from these places, is relentless. The devastation feels overwhelming. I find myself in a continual state of loss. And there are is just so much incessant talking, such constant distracting noise. I’m writing now because I have something useful to share.</p><p>Earlier this month, Thursday, February 12th, 2026, I attended The Conference on The Jewish Left at Boston University. The day far surpassed my expectations. I was one of about five hundred people gathered in person: from what I hear, additional thousands joined remotely. The conference was a call to build coalitions across the Left, across the schism of “Zionism” around values of human rights, of community, of kindness, of justice and democracy.</p><p>Jewish people who care about Jewish issues, Americans of all backgrounds who feel outraged about what’s happening in Israel/Palestine, and the U.S. role there, everybody who opposes Donald Trump and his minions, could learn from what took place at this conference.</p><p>During the opening keynote session, in conversation with the discussant, historian Marjorie Field, Peter Beinart, journalist and political commentator, spoke of the “idolatry” of nationalism–the state as an object of worship. The state, he argued, has conditional value: human life has unconditional value. To articulate his own evolving perspective, he contrasted it with a recent talk that Brett Stephens of <em>The New York Times </em>gave at the 92nd Street Y. In Stephens’s framing, defensive and defiant, Jews were betrayed after October 7th by people on the Left and must stop looking for approval from old allies. Instead, they (we) must stand on their (on our) own.</p><p>In contrast, Beinart, an observant Jew, a child of South African immigrants, a self-described cultural Zionist, an outspoken critic of Israel, offered a vision of solidarity with the marginalized, the suffering, and the oppressed. He spoke about his latest book, <em>Being Jewish after The Destruction of Gaza: A Reckoning</em>. He argued for Jews, specifically American Jews, playing an active role in a broad movement for human rights–which includes at its heart standing with Palestinians.</p><p><em>Coalition Building and Culture-Making</em></p><p>For me, two of the talks, one by Dove Kent, the other by Arielle Angel, framed the potential of the conference along with its intrinsic tensions. “This is fundamentally a different country now,” said Kent, former director of Jews for Racial &amp; Economic Justice and co-founder of Tzedek Lab. ”The political map is being redrawn. . . .The people have moved. The organizations have not.” In this, she sees a “tremendous opportunity.” As she put it, “Minneapolis is showing us the way.”</p><p>Kent argued for the construction of a broad Left/Liberal coalition including liberal and left Zionists and anti-Zionists. “We absolutely need each other,” she said. “Zionist/Anti-Zionist is not where the wedge should be. . . .Zionism is like a non-word. . . .The word itself is not useful for us when we want to build coalition.” Instead, she argued for forming coalitions around the common denominator of human rights.</p><p>Kent made a helpful distinction between “coalition” and “caucus.” In politics, victory depends upon the construction of winning coalitions of people who, whatever their disagreements, unite around common values and goals. Caucuses are tighter circles where the likeminded go for community, for meaning and purpose, for support. When together, members of a caucus–an organization, an institution, a house of workshop, an informal initiative–feel comfortable. In contrast, coalitions have the tendency to make the people who join them feel uncomfortable. Coalitions and caucasus serve different purposes. Both, Kent argued, are necessary.</p><p>While Kent spoke as a political strategist, Arielle Angel, Editor-in-Chief of <em>Jewish Currents, </em>spoke as a representative of the rising “anti-Zionist left community.” Her tone, sharp and confrontational, was different from Kent’s, as are her goals–as is her role. She focused on what she called a crisis of Jewish culture and on the role of artists. As the moving force behind a magazine playing an important role in a cultural renaissance of American Jews, such a focus makes good sense. Angel said: “we need to make what is going on on our side so beautiful, so real.” She said: “don’t reach out to liberal Zionists” but “welcome them when they come.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*yQACCjj6qfIcpO0OpjY2Hw.jpeg" /></figure><p>I embrace Kent’s analysis and arguments about strategy. At the conference, she made a strong case for why Americans, Jews, people of all backgrounds, from across a liberal/left spectrum must join together in opposition to what Trump and Netanyahu embody, how we must build coalitions to resist the concentrated wealth and power; the systems that put narrow profit for the few over the well-being of the many; the forces of authoritarianism, of fascism, of blood and soil nationalism, whatever its guise. She articulated so well so much of what I’ve been thinking about and trying to say.</p><p>Those of us who oppose what Trump and Netanyahu embody must learn from history. Between the World Wars, except for the brief existence of The Popular Front, instead of uniting against the fascists, people on The Left in Europe were at each other’s throats. The conflicts and the aggressive brutality within The Left weakened opposition to Fascism–with devastating consequence (for example, take a look at Alain Brossat and Sylvia Klingberg, <em>Revolutionary Yiddishland: A History of Jewish Radicalism, </em>translated by David Fernbach).</p><p>To build a winning coalition, we need more of the civic minded courage of good neighbors that we’ve seen in Minneapolis. Sectarian purity tests and canceling are counter-productive and dangerous. To build a meaningful, successful, coalition, we need sustained outreach. We need accessible language. We need to build relationships with people who are different from us, who might have different opinions on a range of things, but who share basic values–who have open hearts and minds and eyes to see, who are human to one another in a world increasingly ruled by machines.</p><p><em>Coalition and Caucus: Circles of Community</em></p><p>What I’m saying is true for Americans of all “identities.” The movement to oppose the allied forces of Trump and Netanyahu must, in the words that Jesse Jackson used decades ago, be a “rainbow coalition.” While all American citizens share responsibility for what the American government makes possible in Gaza and, more broadly, in Israel Palestine–American Jews, Jewish Americans, citizens of The Babylon of our age, bear particular responsibility for the destruction done in our name.</p><p>My friend Mohammed, who is from Gaza and whose house was destroyed by Israeli bombs, often tells me that only American Jews can stop what Israel is inflicting on The Palestinian People. I don’t completely agree with him (among other things, I think he discounts the strength of right wing Christian support for Netanyahu’s Israel, represented, for example, by the current American ambassador to Israel, Mike Huckabee). But I understand and appreciate what he means. I agree with Mohammed that “legacy” Jewish organizations have failed. Claims to “stand with Israel” no matter what is complicity with crimes against humanity and even genocide.</p><p>Those of us in the States who oppose Trump know that he does not define us or The United States of America. Israel and Palestine are also internally diverse. Legacy Jewish institutions rely on the financial support from wealthy donors whose reflexive support of Netanyahu’s Israel does not represent the range of American Jewish or Israeli opinion. These donors and the institutions dependent upon them do their own kind of canceling: they exclude voices of dissent; they limit and distort the conversation; they use their money to influence elections, to defeat even candidates who identify as pro-Israel but want to put conditions on U.S. government support (for example, look at what AIPAC did to defeat Tom Malinowski’s campaign for a congressional seat in New Jersey in February 2026).</p><p>Visceral disagreements about the Israeli response to October 7th is tearing apart synagogues, Jewish communities, Jewish institutions, even Jewish families. The Palestinian solidarity movement on college campuses at the end of The Biden administration which captured national attention was filled with young Jewish Americans/American Jews. When she ran for President, Vice-President Harris had an opportunity to bring such people into her tent. For the sake of such a coalition, she could have included Palestinian Americans on stage at the Democratic Convention in Chicago alongside Rachel Goldberg-Polin and Jon Polin, the American-Israeli parents of hostage Hersh Goldberg-Polin. This is what the Palestinian solidarity activists wanted. The Harris-Walz campaign had the opportunity to welcome the request with empathy and grace, and, by doing so, to enlarge their coalition. They failed.</p><p>Their failure dampened support for the Harris-Walz campaign among Palestinian solidarity activists and their supporters, and among Arab and Muslim Americans–some of whom stayed away from the voting booth, others who voted for Trump.</p><p>Such dynamics long predate October 7th. Those who identify as left wing Zionists have been marginalized; those who identify as anti-Zionist have been excluded. Such exclusion encouraged the excluded who are committed Jews to create Jewish alternatives. During my eleven years living in Jerusalem, from 2006 to 2017, I spent a lot of time with rabbinical students, students of Jewish education, young rabbis, and rising leaders of the American Jewish community. I took them to meet Palestinians; I took them on listening tours of the West Bank. I taught and facilitated the conflict among American Jews about Israel/Palestine. Through this work, I accompanied people learning from their experiences on the ground; I felt the heartbreak, the growth, and the sense of new possibilities.</p><p>Listening to Angel’s talk, I got a panoramic view of those same outlines in the distance but more fully articulated and with greater sweep. I caught a glimpse of an American Jewish future, an American Jewish culture, an American Jewish ecosystem of institutions and organizations that will look very different from today. This is coming from young people who care deeply about Jewish culture, Jewish practice, Jewish communal life. Thick old lines between the anti-religious left and the religious have largely vanished. Young American Jews, many who identify as anti-Zionist, are turning to their Ashkenazi and Sephardic diasporic roots. In their search for models, they are going back to the first decades of the twentieth-century in search of Jewish alternatives to Zionism. They’re singing in Yiddish and Ladino, immersing themselves in Jewish mysticism, and taking books about the Bundists off the shelves. They’re reimagining ideals and visions that were incinerated in the Nazi death camps, and then obscured when The State of Israel rose from the ashes. Such alternatives did not disappear. They are growing again.</p><p><em>Priorities and Visions</em></p><p>The immediate political coalition building <em>and</em> the longer term cultural building that I’m talking about here will reconfigure American Jewish life, and thus American life more broadly. What’s happening on The Jewish Left–allied with diverse movements of American citizens working for human rights and justice–offers a compelling model for Americans of all backgrounds. Whatever our “identities,” we have the opportunity to explore the cultural richness of our traditions, while working in overlapping communities of friends and neighbors, of caucasuses and coalitions.</p><p>Building successful coalitions–a victorious movement–will not be easy. For example, I support organizations such as Combatants for Peace, The Bereaved Family Forum, Standing Together, and The Jerusalem Youth Chorus. These organizations, and others like them, are dedicated to joint work with Jewish Israelis and Palestinians (sometimes from inside pre-1967 Israel, sometimes from Jerusalem, sometimes from the West Bank and Gaza): the people in these organizations and their supporters build trust as part of a joint struggle for a future where all of the people on The Land will flourish with equality (one state, two state, a federation, something never seen before, whatever the political arrangements will be).</p><p>These organizations are attacked from the right for being too critical of Israeli policies, and from the left because we’re ready to engage with an unusually diverse range of people, because we coexist with difference on principle, because we don’t abide by BDS directives, because our ranks include Israelis and Americans who identify as Zionist.</p><p>After attending the Conference on The Jewish Left, I feel invigorated to try harder where ever I see the potential for coalition building based on common commitment to human rights. I’m writing here to argue that you, that others, do the same.</p><p>We in the United States, in Israel/Palestine, on this planet, live in a time of shattering danger and possibility. In The United States, the concentration of wealth, the insane drive for profit at the expense of life, the corruption at the highest levels of government and across society, are staggering. The American promise of a multi-ethnic, multi-racial democracy is at a breaking point. The accumulated rot of decades threatens to take the whole thing down. An authoritarian, fascist, take-over is unfolding before our eyes. A parallel take-over with its own character is unfolding in Israel.</p><p>But these take-overs are NOT inevitable. We, the people–a wonderfully diverse coalition of human beings–are fighting back. What we do as good neighbors, as Americans, as Jewish people, matters here in the States — and it matters in Israel/Palestine. This is the work of politics–of coalition and movement building. It is the work of culture. We have immediate challenges to confront; there are other things in motion that those of us alive now will not live long enough to see. To loosely paraphrase the <em>Ethics of The Fathers</em>, it’s not up to you, to me, to us, to finish this work. But we are not free to ignore what needs doing. After the Conference on the Jewish Left closing reception, I walked into that wintry February night filled with hope, something I haven’t felt much of in a while.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*LVQJviTGPVoYLPbqbE-2Fw.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>Appendix</em></p><p>The American Jewish establishment is finally waking up to new and growing American Jewish realities. For example, For the Sake of Argument, an initiative that organizes intra-Jewish dialogue about Israel/Palestine has recently started reaching out to anti-Zionist Jews.</p><p><a href="https://ejewishphilanthropy.com/fearing-growing-rifts-over-israel-for-the-sake-of-argument-looks-to-understand-anti-zionists/">https://ejewishphilanthropy.com/fearing-growing-rifts-over-israel-for-the-sake-of-argument-looks-to-understand-anti-zionists/</a></p><p>The Conference on The Jewish Left is sparking interest in Israel. Below is an article about the conference that appeared in <em>Haaretz </em>(if you don’t subscribe to <em>Haaretz</em>, you won’t be able to see the full text):</p><p><a href="https://www.haaretz.com/jewish/2026-02-20/ty-article-magazine/.premium/beyond-zionism-after-gaza-the-american-jewish-left-rethinks-jewish-identity/0000019c-6c87-d631-a3de-7d8f79be0000">https://www.haaretz.com/jewish/2026-02-20/ty-article-magazine/.premium/beyond-zionism-after-gaza-the-american-jewish-left-rethinks-jewish-identity/0000019c-6c87-d631-a3de-7d8f79be0000</a></p><p>I haven’t posted on <em>Medium</em> lately but I did publish an essay in <em>Jewschool </em>about my friendship with Mohammed, a close friend and colleague from Gaza, and our failed efforts to support peace, human rights, and a shared future for Palestinians and Israelis.</p><p><a href="https://jewschool.com/those-penguins-and-those-kids-from-gaza-man-is-wolf-to-man-174581">https://jewschool.com/those-penguins-and-those-kids-from-gaza-man-is-wolf-to-man-174581</a></p><p>I also recently published a scholarly article integrating the work of Jurgen Habermas, a great theorist of dialogue, and what I’ve learned from 25 years working on the ground across lines of conflict (including eleven years living in Jerusalem).</p><p><a href="https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-3-032-01118-3_7">https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-3-032-01118-3_7</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=60d9ff048093" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Voices from a War Zone: Reflections on The Encompass Trust Tour]]></title>
            <link>https://danielmoses36.medium.com/voices-from-a-war-zone-reflections-on-the-encompass-trust-tour-8afb7463af27?source=rss-dbf020efe563------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8afb7463af27</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Daniel Noah Moses]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 02 Sep 2025 18:34:39 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-07-23T01:11:50.987Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/proxy/1*-Yd40IqhOhBtFWO0Uym92g.jpeg" /></figure><p>The Encompass Trust Voices from a War Zone Tour ended in the early afternoon of Sunday, July 13th, over egg sandwiches at a picnic table with a lake in view. We were nine people — seven brave Palestinians and Jewish-Israelis in their twenties — and two older people, myself included. Early in the tour, I wrote here on <em>Medium </em>to say I would write again after (see: <a href="https://medium.com/@danielmoses36/voices-from-a-war-zone-five-young-palestinians-and-israelis-talk-of-their-experiences-on-the-422b30331ea6">https://medium.com/@danielmoses36/voices-from-a-war-zone-five-young-palestinians-and-israelis-talk-of-their-experiences-on-the-422b30331ea6</a>). But I keep procrastinating. When I sit down to write, I get out a few sentences and then stop. I doom scroll the news. I walk — in the woods and in cities — as much as possible. I keep reflecting on the tour: being together, what we accomplished, what we learned, where we could have done better, what might be helpful to share. Here goes.</p><p>This tour was made possible by Encompass Trust, a non-profit based in England created by the family of Daniel Braden, a young man of 28 who was killed in the 2002 Bali terrorist bombing.</p><p>The Encompass Trust mission is: “to facilitate a collaborative space for young Israelis and Palestinians to work towards peace and justice by challenging the status quo, confronting divides, and exploring non-violent alternatives to addressing the conflict. We believe that the violence in Israel Palestine can best be solved through dialogue and education which addresses the root causes of the conflict, encourages honesty, and promotes equality and empathy” (for more information, see <a href="https://encompasstrust.org.uk/">https://encompasstrust.org.uk/</a>).</p><p><em>What a mission to pursue these days.</em> When I moved to Jerusalem in the fall of 2006, the young people from our tour were in elementary school. A Jewish extremist had killed Yitzhak Rabin. Hamas had been blowing up buses. The Oslo Accords were in shambles. The Second Intifada was a fresh wound. The Israeli military Occupation continued; the settlements kept growing. Forced separation of the peoples was reshaping realities. But I joined hundreds of Palestinians, Israelis, and internationals at a peace conference in Anatalya, Turkey; we met regularly in Jerusalem and in the hills outside of Bethlehem. People like me criss-crossed the Green Line with money for projects. Things were bad but we still hoped that we could build momentum. On different levels of hell, people today live in a nightmare.</p><p>The young people of the tour left home for the tour in late June. The region was in flames. Gaza was a bombed out wasteland. Millions of people were suffering, tens of thousands were dying, including the few hostages left. The Israeli government and extreme settlers were tightening the noose around the north of the West Bank where the Palestinians of our group are from. Israel and Iran were launching missiles at one another. Israelis were huddled in bomb shelters. Ben Gurion airport was shut down, so the Israelis and Palestinians flew out together out of Amman.</p><p>They arrived to catch The United States of America during a time of vicious greed, encroaching despotism, and chaos — where the systems that so many of us until recently took for granted are in free fall.</p><p>Four members of our group — two of the Palestinians, two of the Jewish Israelis — spent a week as participants in Project Common Bond, a program established after 9/11 for people from around the world who have lost loved ones to political violence (two others did this program in a previous year).</p><p>We met for the first time as our group of nine at a hotel by Logan Airport. We drove the next day past Revolutionary War battlefields, past signs for “No King’s Day,” along rivers, through mountains. We stopped at a farm stand for freshly picked raspberries. We drove to New York’s Capital District, where I live. After three days there, we drove to the Berkshires, to Vermont, to The Pioneer Valley of Massachusetts, and finally to Portland, Maine.</p><p>We gave public presentations — at a church, at a senior citizens’ community, on a farm, at a synagogue, at a university; we engaged in back and forth questions with our audiences. We met with people informally. Sometimes local people hosted us in their homes. We had our share of internal conflict parallel to the public dialogue. The chasms of experiences and truths among us didn’t vanish. The young people used words that shocked and hurt one another. The violence and suffering followed us: home was never far away. Once we stopped on the side of the road to let tempers cool down. We also laughed together and stayed up late. We cooked meals for one another. We ordered take-out Korean. We got to share two large SUV’s, an ever growing playlist, and memories that go against the grain of what is normal.</p><p>The tour organizers, Karen and I, were under no illusions about the immediate power of dialogue and education against the torrent of undifferentiated fear and hatred. Still, we wanted to model a tangible way to engage in non-violent meaningful conflict while being human together. Being together, we lived an alternate reality of what could be.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/proxy/1*a0PYaOTnvtXoAkfLC57vIw.png" /></figure><p>We wanted to embody this model for people here in the States— audiences willing to listen even when such listening is shocking and painful. We wanted to inspire dialogue across lines of significant difference at a time when public interest in “Israel,” in “Palestine,” in “Gaza,” in “the conflict,” the “ethnic cleansing,” the “humanitarian catastrophe,” and/or “the genocide” is more segmented than ever before. To put this another way, we wanted to encourage empathy, curiosity — and action.</p><p>What’s happening “there” is happening in different ways in The United States. “Here” and “there” are intermingled realities. American public opinion matters (though our president is ignorant and erratic and our government has become a dangerous mess). When it comes to public opinion around Israel and Palestine, American Jews have a particular role to play.</p><p>We organized the tour as allies of organizations such as Combatants for Peace that do joint work with Palestinians and Israelis, as part of a coalition of people in the region, in the U.S., within the Jewish community, and around the world, who agree on essential things–human rights, the equal value of human life, the dignity of all people, that there is no viable military solution to the situation in Israel and Palestine, that the fate of Palestinians and Israelis are intertwined. We pushed back at extremes to support a future where Israelis and Palestinians share The Land on terms of equality.</p><p>In our promotional material, we chose our words carefully with a big tent in mind. Such language made it possible for us to reach an unusually diverse range of individuals with strong opinions and loyalties. The president of the local Jewish federation in New York’s Capital District, attended our public event in Albany, as did a number of local elected officials, including our local congressman, Paul Tonko, who offered opening remarks of support and stayed to the end. Throughout the tour, Palestinian solidarity activists, including a few members of JVP (Jewish Voice For Peace), attended even though we were outside of their comfort zones and not their usual scene.</p><p>At the same time, we lost an undetermined number of self-identified supporters of Israel who dismissed us as too “Lefty,” and Palestinian solidarity activists, including JVP members and others on the Left, because we do not follow the BDS line. Before the events, Palestinian solidarity activists whom we invited wanted to know why our posters didn’t use words such as “the genocide.” They wanted to know how we could organize such an event and not be in explicit solidarity with the Palestinian cause as defined by them (I’ll write more about this another time).</p><p>I asked one JVP member why only a few from that organization came to our event out of the many invited. “I welcome nuance and complexity; I want to hear different opinions and perspectives,” he said. “A lot of people just want to know where to stand.”</p><p>What the brave young people shared at our public events (and day-to-day within our group) was devastating.</p><p>One young Palestinian woman spoke of how Israeli army snipers shot her father to death when he stepped out on the porch one night to light a cigarette when her mother was pregnant with her.</p><p>Another young Palestinian woman spoke about how close she lives to the beach, how she can smell the sea but cannot get there because of the checkpoints.</p><p>One of the young Israeli women spoke of her friend, a kind, talented musician in his twenties, one of the last of the hostages left alive in Gaza. She spoke of herself as a representative of an Israel that many from outside might not see much of these days.</p><p>An American-Israeli woman spoke of what inspired her to move to Israel, her love for the place and the people, and how, when she “made Aliyah,” she made a commitment to work for equality, justice and peace.</p><p>The Palestinian-Israeli mental health counselor spoke of his experiences with a young man in Gaza who was later killed.</p><p>Two members of our group who did not speak in public shared stories privately that immersed me in the tragedy of how everyday lives are thwarted by forces that seem out of control.</p><p>At the public events, members of our group said things that disturbed audience members, most immediately, of course, the stories of their lives, the rawness of their pain, but also unexpected responses to questions. For example, when an older white man, probably Jewish, in Vermont, asked about a future peace process, one of the young Palestinian woman positioned the return of the Palestinian refugees as a first step.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/proxy/1*nLCIe9gmAy7lJRWrJ13HPQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>After the formal part of that evening in Vermont, an Israeli woman in her fifties walked over to me. “I want to tell you something,” she said. “There wasn’t enough balance. You told about the Palestinian suffering, which is true. I know it is true. But the young Israelis didn’t say enough. One of them is American anyway and she grew up here. I grew up with Palestinians in the house. My family has fought for peace. I want peace. I hate what is happening. But your presentations were one-sided. I could have spoken about my family and our stories and our stories are not unusual. It’s different from the Palestinians. But if you want to understand what’s happening, you need to understand how we, the Israelis, are suffering, too.”</p><p>I acknowledged what this woman said to me. “Yes,” I said, “I hear you. I’m sure that you could have added so much to the conversation. At the same time, I think you would agree that it’s impossible to provide the ‘full story’ in an evening. I don’t even know what that would mean. The young people spoke for themselves. As a group, we left out many things. I wish that I had done more framing to help the audience know what to expect. Our goal here was to create an opportunity that barely exist anywhere. We want this to be a chance to learn for the young presenters and for the audience. We are a work in progress. Tonight was a snapshot of larger processes and possibilities. I hope you see that. Let’s see what can grow.”</p><p>This woman and I hugged goodbye.</p><p>The well coiffed, well preserved, American Jewish woman from Vermont who helped us so much — with publicity, to find a venue and a place to stay — had a more extreme reaction to that evening: she was enraged. She claimed I had deceived her — that our group was pro-Palestinian, anti-Israeli, and not about peace. She said that we had upset and disturbed the people of her community. In the days that followed, she sent text messages filled with accusations. She demanded to know why the Palestinian citizen of Israel didn’t mention his citizenship. She told me that we should not have done the tour until everything was “ready,” until we had the “right balance.” I offered to meet with her and anybody else from her community in person to answer questions and continue the conversation. After going back and forth by text, she said she doesn’t want to hear anything from me ever again.</p><p>The day after our event in Vermont, this same woman called the rabbi of our next venue, Temple Israel, in Greenfield, Massachusetts, to warn that our group was dangerous.</p><p>On the way to Greenfield, the young Palestinian women of the tour worried about doing an event in a synagogue. But the rabbi of Temple Israel, and that whole community, welcomed us warmly to the packed room of over one hundred people in the synagogue basement. Audience members asked difficult questions — but the tone was completely different from what it had been in Vermont. Our group and the local community shared a late dinner. Members of the shul hosted our group in pairs for the night. The next day, we gathered to enjoy a picnic brunch together. We said goodbye like newfound friends.</p><p>When I ask myself why the experiences in Vermont and Greenfield were so different, I see answers. First, in Greenfield, and at every other venue except for Vermont, we benefitted from earned trust and relationship. I’ve built relationships in those communities. I knew our hosts. In The Capital District, my friends and neighbors with deep roots in the area hosted us for brunch: they worked the public event; they reached out to our local representatives; they contributed to the community dinner; they turned that visit into the success that it turned out to be. In Portland, Maine, a dear friend, a deeply trusted person in that community, hosted us and did the outreach for our public event. I know that community, too; I’ve been a regular visitor for twenty years. Vermont was the exception. For me, it was a black box. The venue, the audience members — all of this came from the woman who got so upset after. A mutual friend introduced us by text and e-mail and this woman offered to help. Before the early afternoon of the day of the event, we had never met or even spoken on the phone.</p><p>This well coiffed woman’s response, I believe, was a reaction of existential fear. Such fear can motivate harsh defense against perceived threats — even when such perceived threats are true experiences and authentic information that challenge the safety of old narratives.</p><p>To put this another way, her response was a defense mechanism. The casualties in Gaza, the dead children, the extreme suffering, the devastation of a whole society, is overwhelming.</p><p>The difference in the responses from the woman in Vermont and the people of Greenfield, I would argue, is also a difference of ethos, a difference in approach and attitude. It is about a generosity of spirit and everyday courage that can take a lifetime to cultivate. Thankfully, we met many people on the ground with such spirit and such open hearts.</p><p>At our last public event in Portland, Maine, I shared more on a personal level than I had done before. For most of the last twenty five years, I’ve worked across lines of conflict as a convener, as a “neutral” party. But now. as an American Jew, my “identity” has come to the fore.</p><p>I spoke that evening in Portland about how my father’s parents were Yiddish and Hungarian speaking Jews from what is now Romania, how their family was decimated by the Holocaust, how my grandmother’s brother escaped to Israel. I spoke about how growing up, I visited him and his second wife. Both of them had lost their previous spouses and children in the concentration camps. He spent years in the forest living off insects and whatever else he could find. When I finished the meat and potatoes on my plate, she immediately piled on more. For them, Israel was the safe place, the haven, the miracle: for them, it meant going home.</p><p>“Israel” is not not one thing. It’s a brutal occupying power led by fanatics committing war crimes at the minimum. It’s a country of unsustainable contradictions where an oppressive right-wing is gaining power across society. It’s also an extremely diverse, pluralistic, society with such richness of culture, wonderful in countless ways, with people living in separate bubbles that seldom touch. What I love about Israel still exists, though such things are more difficult to remember now, and so much of what I love about Israel, and whom I love, is under threat.</p><p>An American Jewish cousin of mine told me recently that he doesn’t trust “them.” But “Palestinians” and “Palestine” are not one thing either.</p><p>Palestine, too, is culturally rich, diverse, and changing quickly. I love the hospitality of Palestinians, the kindness that I’ve experienced. I love and respect my Palestinian friends, their love of their land, their determination and strength, their visions of the future. I love the regional differences and layers of history. There are Palestinians with roots in The Gulf, in sub-Saharan Africa, in the Balkans, and even India. There are Palestinans who claim descent from Greek speakers, and others who claim descent from the Crusaders. There are Palestinians, even today, who in private claim Jewish roots. There are Palestinians who claim descent from the ancient Caananites. I feel the kind of trust in Palestinians that enables me to walk around East Jerusalem, Ramallah or Bethlehem late at night and to visit my friends in Hebron, Tulkarem, and Jenin. I love so much of what I’ve experienced in Palestine, though, there,— so, so, so, much has been destroyed.</p><p>I cannot separate out my love of “Israel” and my love of “Palestine,” even as Israeli Jews and Palestinians appear to be locked in a death embrace.</p><p>I have Israeli friends out in the street protesting. My Palestinian friends are adamant that their government does not represent them. For Americans who oppose Trump, this should be easy to understand.</p><p>I believe that the only way out of the death embrace is for people on the ground — Israelis and Palestinians like the brave young people whom I accompanied on tour — to figure out just ways to live together and share the land while upholding the values I’ve been talking about here. This begins, of course, within the context of vast inequalities of power. For better and for worse, people from outside are key players in the struggle for the future of Israel/Palestine. My experiences on this tour affirmed my belief that to be effective, those of us who live outside benefit from moving beyond the likeminded — to listen to voices from the ground like the brave young people, while engaging beyond our immediate circles.</p><p>American Jews who care about the fate of Israeli Jews have a sixth sense for survival. This includes those strongly opposed to everything that Bibi Netanyahu represents. Palestinian solidarity activists sometimes stoke the worst fears of people with the potential to become allies; more specifically, I’m talking about people who might consider themselves to be “left-wing” or “liberal” Zionists.</p><p>Palestinian solidarity activists at least sometimes dehumanize Israelis. They stand with Palestinians but close themselves off to realities on the ground, and to potential allies — assuming that it’s possible to agree on the core values I’ve articulated here.</p><p>The challenge is to look for ways to meet human needs — to build a coalition with people who agree on what I would argue are the most critical things, to transcend our differences in order to oppose the hateful destructive forces wielding power now. If we don’t do that — we will lose to the authoritarians, whether in Trump’s gaudy formation or the formation of the blood and soil fanaticism of Netanyahu, Smotrich, and Ben Gvr.</p><p>Not long ago, I listened to a Christian Palestinian solidarity activist talk about the people around Jesus and their culture on the Land while avoiding all reference to the Jewish context. This was a notable feat but it wasn’t helpful. Both Palestinians and Jews have legitmate claims to be indigenous. Our family trees are mingled. And neither people are going anywhere (unless through unspeakable violence).</p><p>No indigenous claim can excuse Israel’s murder of innocents, including children and journalists, the intentional starvation, the continued human rights abuses, the devastation of Gaza, the brutality of Occupation. I have given up earlier objections to the word “genocide.”</p><p><em>We need to stop this war. We need to get humanitarian aid to the Palestinians in Gaza now. The international community must do all it can to avert a cascading catastrophe that has the potential to get even worse than it already is. We must free the remaining hostages. We, as Americans must do all that we can to oppose the corrupt alliance between Netanyahu and Trump. We must chart a path to a viable future for both Israelis and Palestinians, a path that members of our tour — with all of their differences and disagreements— embodied.</em></p><p>Our Encompass Trust tour — those nine days together — was an effort to do what I believe needs doing “there” and “here” on a massive scale. Building a big tent, creating opportunities for dialogue across a spectrum, listening, building relationships, is part of creating a coalition, a movement, or set of related movements. This is not the only thing to do; it’s not the only strategy. But it is significant. Disagree with me on the details, on what I’ve included here or what I’ve left out. If you agree with me on my basic argument — how can we join forces? How can we “scale up.” The title of a favorite book reminds me: “we make the road by walking.” I see a long road ahead.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/proxy/1*iwe4OfTSyYf_YFTr9ev9GA.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>This tour made an impact through legacy media: we were featured by WAMC, the main public radio station for much of upstate New York, western Massachusetts, southern Vermont, and parts of Connecticut. We were featured in </em>The Bennington Banner <em>and other Vermont media outlets owned by Vermont News and Media LLC. Daniel Yalowitz, one of our Greenfield hosts, published an essay as part of his regular column in </em>The Greenfield Recorder <em>and other related local newspapers covering the Pioneer Valley.</em></p><p><a href="https://www.wamc.org/news/2025-07-07/young-palestinians-and-israelis-tour-the-northeast-as-war-in-gaza-rages-on">https://www.wamc.org/news/2025-07-07/young-palestinians-and-israelis-tour-the-northeast-as-war-in-gaza-rages-on</a></p><p>Vermont:<a href="https://www.wamc.org/news/2025-07-07/young-palestinians-and-israelis-tour-the-northeast-as-war-in-gaza-rages-on">https://www.wamc.org/news/2025-07-07/young-palestinians-and-israelis-tour-the-northeast-as-war-in-gaza-rages-on</a></p><p><a href="https://www.benningtonbanner.com/local-news/young-palestinians-israelis-share-their-pain-and-hopes/article_2b0957bc-2aab-4f65-b1de-52e74b9e11ae.html">Young Palestinians, Israelis share their pain and hopes</a></p><p>Daniel Yalowitz: <a href="https://www.recorder.com/Columnist-62444430">https://www.recorder.com/Columnist-62444430</a></p><p><em>Please note: The Palestinian participants asked us to avoid using their names in public, and that no photographs be taken where they could be identified. I’ve followed their wishes here, which is why the only photo I include of the group is from the back.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/proxy/1*9dtVRx_tcN93pV_jFQIfZg.jpeg" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8afb7463af27" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Voices from a War Zone: Five Young Palestinians and Israelis Talk of Their Experiences on the…]]></title>
            <link>https://danielmoses36.medium.com/voices-from-a-war-zone-five-young-palestinians-and-israelis-talk-of-their-experiences-on-the-422b30331ea6?source=rss-dbf020efe563------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/422b30331ea6</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Daniel Noah Moses]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 06 Jul 2025 04:03:29 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-07-18T08:42:37.411Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Voices from a War Zone: Five Young Palestinians and Israelis Talk of Their Experiences on the Ground</h3><p>It’s late on Saturday night, July 5th, 2025. Yesterday I drove alone on back roads in a monstrous SUV rental from my home in a ramshackle small city on the Hudson River with such good bones, through the luscious mountains and farmland of upstate New York, Vermont, New Hampshire, and Massachusetts, to a hotel next to Logan Airport to meet a group of young Palestinians and Israelis who still nourish hope that the future for the people in the land they call home can be different from the tragic suffering, violence, and brutality, of the status quo.</p><p>This morning, I drove back in the opposite direction, again on back roads, this time in a crowded vehicle, that same rented SUV, part of a caravan of uncommonly courageous human beings. We drove through Lexington and Concord, birthplace of the American Revolution. Later, we stopped at a farmstand for freshly picked local strawberries. The air condition was blasting and a diverse medley of music played.</p><p>Tomorrow, we’re off to a brunch of 40 people — my neighbors — who have organized to welcome these courageous young people. This brunch will be the kick-off for a weeklong trip that we are making from Albany, New York to Portland, Maine.</p><p>Below I’m pasting a few of the posters for the public events that we’ve organized. <em>If you are near any of these locations — you would be very welcome to join us.</em></p><p>In the next days and weeks, or at least by August, when I have time, I’ll write about this trip. I’ll write about why we did it, what we, what I, wanted to accomplish, and how things turned out. This trip — so easy to criticize, so difficult to describe— is happening thanks to support from an organization called Encompass Trust, based in London, its long serving manager, Karen, and the hard work of good people who appear out of nowhere when called. “Thank you for giving us a chance to do something,” they say.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*a0PYaOTnvtXoAkfLC57vIw.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*PVxMeIj6DvkTqu2T5U-pRA.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*A4ANON72Uvfi8HPtq2vBOw.jpeg" /></figure><p>With gratitude and anticipation,</p><p>Daniel</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=422b30331ea6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Stop The Insanity: Peace Among Israelis and Palestinians Remains The Best Option]]></title>
            <link>https://danielmoses36.medium.com/please-stop-the-cruelty-and-insanity-peace-among-israelis-and-palestinians-remains-the-best-option-bbdacabdd5b3?source=rss-dbf020efe563------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/bbdacabdd5b3</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Daniel Noah Moses]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 05 Feb 2025 20:07:29 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-07-23T01:09:31.300Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*i_KhIGbysms-OGCSQXmtiA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Following the news these days feels like taking one gut punch after the next. Donald Trump, Elon Musk, and Benjamin Netanyahu are three people causing almost inconceivable suffering and damage. They are able to cause so much harm because “we” do not stop them. The question I struggle with: how can those of us who believe in basic humanity — in kindness, in equal rights, in human rights, in the rights of all people to live in security and peace — organize to stop this cruelty and chaos? How can we check the hubris of these individuals and their minions who have so much power and yet are so careless, so uncaring — and in many ways so dangerously ignorant. The best I’ve come up with so far is that those of us who share the values I’ve outlined need to wake up and organize across our own differences. We might disagree on countless specifics — but such differences are nothing compared to what we are up against. If any of you have concrete ideas, please share.</p><p>To get into one critical detail — if even attempted, Trump’s vision for Gaza, Netanyahu’s vision for Gaza, would be catastrophic for Palestinians, yes — but for Israelis and Americans, too. Netanyahu’s vision for victory is a recipe for long-term mutual destruction. According to Netanyahu, Trump is Israel’s greatest friend. But the two of them together are enemies of a viable human future for both Palestinians and Israelis. Together, they are creating a nightmare for Palestinians yes, but for Israelis, too.</p><p>The powerful now will not always be so powerful. Look at the geography and demographics of the region. Ethnic cleansing in Gaza, the disproportional violence wielded by Israel today, will only fan the flames of fear and rage and bring about the inevitable blowback.</p><p>The fates of Palestinians and Israelis are intertwined. Whether we are “in the region” or love its people from afar, we must burst the bubbles of dehumanization, misinformation, disinformation, and misleading partial information. We must do what we can to put out the flames of rage, hatred, and violence, or they will consume us all.</p><p>I just spent almost a week with Palestinian friends in Columbus, Ohio. I’m now in the midst of preparations for a family bat mitzvah in Pittsburgh. I love people on both “sides” of this conflict. I have spent 25 years working across lines of conflict, eleven years in Jerusalem. I understand from first-hand experience the barriers and obstacles. At the same time, I know that it is possible to live together in peace. I see beyond “the sides” to good people who just want to live their lives.</p><p>Democracy and peace are related. If enough people actively work toward peace — we can achieve it. Working toward peace is part of regaining agency in our own lives. Without democracy, we will be ruled by overseers who do not have our interests at heart. These overseers are already wreaking devastating havoc.</p><p>As crazy at it might sound today, the best hopes for Israelis, for Palestinians, for the region, for all of us who feel the reverberations of what happens “over there” — remain steps toward mutual recognition, respect, and PEACE. Human rights and PEACE. Exchange the hostages and the prisoners. PEACE. PEACE. At least a modicum of justice. PEACE. PEACE. Look at one another. Learn about one another. Explore a range of sources. Think for yourself. Engage with one another. Our fates are intertwined. PEACE. PEACE. PEACE. I understand why it might sound crazy. But peace is the most viable future, and by far the most enjoyable. PEACE. PEACE. If you want to try peace in baby steps, do that while you keep safe. But take at least the risk of those baby steps. PEACE. PEACE. PEACE. Peace is what we pray for in Judaism, in Christianity, and in Islam. It’s what we of diverse beliefs dedicate ourselves to building. Peace unto you. Peace unto you. Peace unto me. Peace unto us.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=bbdacabdd5b3" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Reflections on What We from Outside Can Do for Palestinians and Israelis Now]]></title>
            <link>https://danielmoses36.medium.com/do-the-people-have-the-power-reflections-e209d0225ccb?source=rss-dbf020efe563------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e209d0225ccb</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[hope]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[palestine]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[israel]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[community-engagement]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[israel-palestine-conflict]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Daniel Noah Moses]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 07 Feb 2024 19:02:16 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-05-22T02:20:36.555Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*IgKhORA3_Pirn6dPDV__Aw.png" /><figcaption>The Dead Sea (Image property of Deb Bicknell, Maria Ireland Creamer, or Ajay Noronha).</figcaption></figure><p>I spoke to my friend Mohammed several times during the last days of January while he was in Cairo with family members who recently escaped Gaza. The family is from Shijaeya, an impoverished, religiously conservative neighborhood in the north, by the border with Israel. Mohammed and his wife and part of the family now live in Ohio, while most of the rest remain in Gaza. On October 7th, his wife was visiting their adult son, his wife and their children; an adult daughter, her husband, and their children; siblings, nieces, nephews, cousins, and friends — when the Hamas terrorist attacks and the violent Israeli reaction erupted, and all of them were thrust into a nightmare. With their neighbors, they fled south.</p><p>They lived through intense Israeli bombing and the ground invasion. For months, they sheltered together in a cramped apartment. Mohammed’s daughter-in-law gave birth at a hospital in Gaza. They didn’t have fuel for a car so she and her husband, Mohammed’s third son, rode to the hospital on a cart pulled by a donkey. Now Mohammed’s wife, the two adult children who had been living in Gaza, along their spouses and children, are in Cairo. Mohammed has helped them rent an unfurnished apartment and buy furniture and appliances. They don’t know when they’ll be able to go home. When I call Mohammed, he directs his phone’s camera so that I can see everybody. It’s a crowded apartment of uprooted, severely traumatized, people. I can see the fatigue and bewilderment in their sunken eyes. Two of his grand daughters, between nine and eleven, with dark hair and brown eyes, shyly wave.</p><p>Then Mohammed turns his camera to show the face of a young woman in her early twenties. I’ll call her Alia. A neighbor of Mohammed and his family back in Gaza, she’s been studying medicine at an Egyptian university. We met in the spring of 2015 when she was about eleven. Mohammed and his wife were living in Gaza back then. I was living in Jerusalem. In response to the destruction of the neighborhood during the previous summer’s bombings, the family established a community center on the ground floor of their family compound. They offered daily classes on art, storytelling, study skills, life skills. In the spring of 2015, Mohammed brought a group of twelve kids from this community center from Gaza to Jerusalem. I welcomed them outside of the Jerusalem Hotel, a few blocks from Damascus Gate. Together we shared a falafal lunch in The Old City. After a visit to The Al Aqsa Compound, we went together to a spring camp at the Murad Hotel in the hills outside of Bethlehem to spent four or five days with Palestinian kids and educators from across Jerusalem and the West Bank. I spent a lot of my time with those kids from Shijaeya. I was the first foreigner they had ever met, the first non-Muslim, the first Jew, the first American. They would gather around me in the dining room to ask questions and practice their English. Alia was more talkative than the others. She told me then that she wanted to be a doctor. She and the other kids also talked a lot about animals. It turned out that none of them had ever been to a zoo.</p><p>They asked if they could go, so on the day of departure, before a late lunch at Shwarma King, a local fast food place, and the bus ride home, Mohammed and I made a detour and stopped at the Jerusalem zoo. It’s an experience that I will never forget — those penguins, elephants, and chimpanzees, and the exuberant joy of those kids from Shijaeya.</p><p>A few years later, I got to know Alia’s mother when she was a participant in a week-long workshop that I helped to organize on “trauma awareness and resilience” again in the hills outside of Bethlehem. She wore a hijab and a long dress that went from her neck to her ankles. She was full of the same kind of energy and determination that I noticed in her daughter. Not long after this workshop, I spent part of a summer with Alia, by then a high school student; since then, we’ve been in touch sporadically. Until that recent visit with Mohammed and his family in Cairo, I had not seen or talked with her in a long time.</p><p>Alia tells me that her parents and siblings are stuck in Gaza. She’s had no phone contact with them for days. The cellphone coverage isn’t working. Her grandmother — her father’s mother — died because she wasn’t able to get access to necessary medications. “There are a lot of people in Gaza dying like that,” she explains.</p><p>Alia has no money for school. Everything is precarious and uncertain.</p><p>“I just want the war to stop,” she says.</p><p>I speak in turn with Mohammed and his oldest son, who is visiting from America to be with his family and to volunteer helping Palestinians from Gaza who have escaped to Egypt.</p><p>“They are grateful for every little thing. They have nothing.” I can hear the pain in his voice: the depths of what people in Gaza are going through hits me with a terrible force.</p><p>Meanwhile, on my various social media feeds, I follow the fate of the Israel hostages and with what’s happening with Israeli Jewish friends and relatives who have children in the Israeli army or who are themselves in the army. They are on the ground in Gaza. They are in tanks. They are interrogating Palestinians. In the posted photographs, I see their sunken eyes of exhaustion along with the expression of other things that I cannot easily name.</p><p>I ask an Israeli friend — a dedicated advocate for dialogue and peace — if there is any hope, and she leaves her response in a recorded voice message. “Ah, Daniel,” she says. “What a question. . . .Just, just, just education. Everything else is shit.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*soBQXrxF5v5wW52UDzwHoQ.png" /><figcaption>View from Shimoni Street in Jerusalem (Image property of Ajay Noronha).</figcaption></figure><p>But education can take a long time. A few weeks after the October 7th Hamas terrorist attacks, I went to a demonstration near where I live in upstate New York to join calls for a ceasefire. When I arrived, people were holding signs that said: “From the River to The Sea, Palestine Will be Free” and chanting slogans against “The Zionist Enemy.” A dehumanizing hatred permeated the air. People were screaming. Instead of joining the protestors, I walked away.</p><p>The way most of us think about “sides” in this conflict does not shed enough light on what is happening. Large categories of “us” and “them” often obscure more than they clarify. In the 1990’s, there was an acrimonious debate in Israel between leaders such as Yitzhak Rabin who believed that Palestinians and Israelis must figure out a way to share the land and those like Netanyahu who ratcheted up extremist rhetoric against the peace process. It was in this context that an Israeli Jewish terrorist killed Rabin, while Hamas blew up buses, killed Israeli civilians, created an atmosphere of fear, and helped to decimate the prospects for peace.</p><p>There are leaders on both “sides” who have done everything they can to stop the two peoples from living side by side on terms of respect and equality. Netanyahu and his extremist government are making Hamas, and what Hamas represents, stronger. <em>In their drive for exclusive control over the land, Netanyahu and his allies, Hamas and their allies, extremists, blind to “the other,” are mirror images of one another</em>. They both promise catastrophe.</p><p>According to Mohammed, what I wrote above is not exactly true. He says that there are leaders within Hamas — which, of course, has its own internal dynamics — who are far more open to peace than Netanyahu and his extremist allies. Mohammed reminds me of the “Hudna” (long-term ceasefire) that Hamas proposed in the past. This is worth exploring another time (as I write these words, in early February, 2024, Hamas has agreed to a 135 day ceasefire; let’s see how Netanyahu’s government responds). Meanwhile, Mohammed tells me often that American Jews like me have a particularly critical role to play in making a ceasefire happen and in advocating for a more peaceful and just future for both Palestinians and Israelis. I agree. At the same time, the extent to which Americans of all backgrounds can articulate calls for a ceasefire along with calls for a peace process that recognizes the needs of both Palestinians and Israelis — the more powerful our voices could be. But there is a dangerous myopia almost everywhere I look.</p><p>From what I can tell, most Israelis have drawn what I believe to be the wrong conclusions from the October 7th attacks. Although they don’t trust Netanyahu or his government, they have thrown their fate in with deluded extremists and lost sight of larger horizons. The Hamas terrorist attacks hit Jewish Israelis at their most vulnerable. It conjured up their worst nightmares. Israeli hostages remain in Gaza; some are dying while the fighting continues. Jewish Israelis are in reactive mode; the country, which was already being torn apart from within, is shaken to its core. They feel themselves to be under existential threat — which is understandable. They are a traumatized people with good reason to be concerned about their security. But the war that this Israeli government is waging is making Israelis less safe. Over the long haul, it is putting them in greater danger. Israeli television news, their Facebook and Instagram feeds, their WhatsApp threads, do NOT show them the suffering of the Palestinians. Israelis of all ideological backgrounds are focused on their own survival, their own trauma, usually with surprisingly little understanding of the scale of death, suffering, and destruction, being inflicted in their name.</p><p>Meanwhile, those in solidarity with Palestinians who erase Israel’s existence, along with the experiences, fears, and hopes, of Israelis, strengthen an “either or” mentality that is deeply counterproductive: they strenghten the extremists on both sides. <em>They might as well donate to Netanyahu’s political campaign. </em>I believe that the two peoples must figure out a way to live together on terms of equality — or suffer unfathomable violence for generations to come.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*h49AFxlzNSlv1EY4ztXZAw.jpeg" /><figcaption>View of Dome of the Rock, part of the Al Aqsa Mosque Compound, and Jerusalem (Image property of Deb Bicknell, Maria Ireland Creamer, or Ajay Noronha).</figcaption></figure><p>The time for a ceasefire is <em>now. </em>Palestinians in Gaza need massive and immediate humanitarian aid and, when it is again possible, infusions of support to help them rebuild. The attention of the world is on Gaza. The ground is unstable. The rifts between Netanyahu’s government and the Biden administration are becoming increasingly clear. Arab leaders of countries that have established ties with Israel want to maintain and even strengthen such ties. But to do this, they demand movement toward a Palestinian state. The rage and fear in the region is rising. Israelis’ use of the power they have to fan the rising hatred and fear around them will have severe consequences. It is in the interests of Israeli Jews, and of Palestinians, to lower this flame.</p><p>Since leaving my full-time position as a people-to-people peace builder — on the road and on the ground — and moving to upstate New York during the worst of the Pandemic, I’ve helped to establish a small group of American Jews who meet every other week on a Zoom call to discuss Israel/Palestine. The original idea was to include the widest possible range of voices. In the wake of October 7th, our more right-wing members stopped coming. We now span the spectrum from self-identified liberal Zionist supporters of J-Street to supporters of activists such as Miko Peled who are explicitly anti-Zionist, to others less certain in their beliefs but able to maintain an unusually large scope of empathy, openness, and intellectual curiosity. Alongside this bi-weekly group, I’ve been getting to know younger activists in their twenties, thirties, and forties, usually Jewish, who are involved with The Democratic Socialists of America and Jewish Voice for Peace. One of these activists invited me to join that October demonstration for a ceasefire.</p><p>A few months later, on New Year’s Day, this same activist invited me to join a march calling for a ceasefire organized by a Japanese Buddhist nun who lives in the area. People carried a range of different signs with variations on calls for a ceasefire. Veterans of the American military were a notable presence. I didn’t see anything like “from the river to the sea.” There was nothing targeting “the Zionist enemy.” We stopped at an Islamic Center, at two churches, and at a synagogue. Several on the march carried Palestinian flags; nobody carried an Israeli flag, though I did see posters with illustrated Palestinian flags alongside “Stars of David,” the star featured on the Israeli flag. One of the organizers, a Jewish woman in her thirties, said privately to another person on the march that if somebody had been carrying an Israeli flag, she would have told that person to leave. The march included songs for peace in a variety of traditions. It finished at a community center without any public flare-ups.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/750/1*LQrVrVKx0By7ZHFCgiV2DA.png" /><figcaption>January 1st march in Troy, New York (Image property of Daniel Noah Moses).</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/750/1*fQ1F3BYmU5tMo51w0or9lA.jpeg" /><figcaption>January 1st 2024 March in Troy, New York (Image property of Daniel Noah Moses).</figcaption></figure><p>I mentioned this march to my bi-weekly Jewish dialogue group and asked why none of them were there. What followed were a set of conversations about our common sense of dislocation, a shared feeling that we are standing in a precarious middle, a “no mans land,” with people attacking from all sides.</p><p>A member of the group asked if he could join a demonstration with a sign that said “Zionists for a Ceasefire.”</p><p>“No,” another member of the group responded. “You definitely can’t do that.”</p><p>Somebody else suggested that instead of mentioning Zionism, people could follow her brother’s example: he goes to demonstrations with a sign that says “Jews for a Ceasefire.” One member of our group, a progressive activist in her seventies, spoke of how she can no longer talk with many of her progressive friends. She explained that they have no empathy at all for Israelis and no understanding. They only see a colonial oppressor and don’t want to explore a more complex reality. “They don’t want to know about my experiences or perspectives as a Jewish person with family in Israel,” she said. “And they don’t seem to care.”</p><p>Several members of the group expressed concern about finding themselves in “activist spaces” where they would not feel welcome or comfortable, or able to share. At the same time, they do not feel comfortable in the establishment Jewish community with its embrace of a narrow Israeli perspective and lack of attention to Palestinian suffering. Members of the group want to add their voices to a call for a ceasefire — along with calls for the revival of a peace process. A few of us agreed to check out the small protests happening daily in the area. We also talked about what we agreed is a hardening on the Liberal/Left end of the spectrum, often with a generational cast.</p><p>In broad brush strokes, on one “side” are Jewish supporters of J-Street, often self-identified “Left-wing Zionists,” as well as many Americans of all backgrounds who want Israelis and Palestinians to thrive, and who see an independent Palestine alongside Israel as a way to make that happen. They would probably be open to a confederation or one state if that is what Israelis and Palestinians on the ground decide through a process with integrity. Such people are often open to a range of perspectives and to “dialogue.” They are likely to be older — in their forties and beyond, many in their sixties and seventies. On “the other side,” are those who often view Israel’s existence as illegitimate. They talk a lot about “settler colonialism” and view the conflict as part of an “intersectional” worldwide struggle against oppression. They are often, but not always, B.D.S. supporters. At least a noticeable number of them speak openly about the defeat of Israel and its replacement by Palestine.</p><p>If they are Jewish, they are likely to be part of Jewish Voice for Peace. If they are not Jewish, they might be part of a whole range of Palestinian solidarity organizations. They are often younger; the most active among them seem to be in their twenties and thirties. From what I can tell, they often see dialogue as useless. Activists from this side of the spectrum recently organized an event at a local library near me featuring the “anti-Zionist” activist Miko Peled. Several members of our bi-weekly group attended. They were open to what Peled had to say — but deeply disappointed by the experience. There was no real discussion, no real exchange of perspectives. When an Israeli woman tried to speak respectfully, the moderator shut her down.</p><p>I understand the urgency for political action on behalf of Palestinians. At the same time, it is unclear to me how those who envision a one-state solution, a replacement of “Israel” with “Palestine,” expect Israelis and Palestinians to build a common future if they block interaction between them (I’m talking here specifically about the boycott of dialogue related initiatives). I find this lack of clarity, combined with what I’ve seen at protests, troubling.</p><p>Those who view Israel as an exclusively colonial project, who refuse to acknowledge a Jewish peoplehood or a legitimate Jewish historical rooted connection to Israel/Palestine, might demand that Israeli Jews leave Israel/Palestine and find homes in Europe, North America, or somewhere else. If the conflict continues to spiral, it is possible that a substantial number of Jewish Israelis professionals, the well educated, those in high tech — could emigrate. This would accelerate demographic changes in Israel and change the character of the country: it would become less prosperous, more narrowly religious, more bellicose, less liberal, more narrowly nationalistic, less European, more Middle Eastern. But the Jews of Israel are NOT the French in Algeria. Palestinians and their supporters who think this are making a dangerous mistake.</p><p>Those who flatten the Jews of Israel into just another group of imperialists miss the narratives at the heart of the Christian and Islamic traditions built around an Israelite/Jewish presence as a people in The Land. They unfairly distort the historical record (much like many on “the other side” do). They ignore a central component of how Israeli Jews — and many Jews in the diaspora — view themselves.</p><p>They also fail to see the reality of the mixed-upness of Jews and Palestinians — which contains possibilities for a shared future. I know Christian Palestinians who trace their families back to Greek speakers in the centuries before the Islamic conquest. I know others from Bethlehem whose families arrived from Sicily with the Crusades. I know Palestinians with roots in the Balkans, in India, and in the Arabian Peninsula. I know Palestinians who can trace Jewish ancestors back only a few generations. There are Palestinians in the the south of the West Bank who until recently lit candles on Friday night. I know Jewish-Israelis from Morocco, Tunisia, Syria, Iraq, and Yemen who grew up speaking Arabic and listening to Arabic music. Baghdad was once full of Jewish musicians. I know Jewish-Israelis who are tenth generation Jerusalemites. I know a Jewish-Israeli woman from Cairo who left with her parents in the early 1950’ under pressure from the Egyptian government; her mother’s sisters converted to Islam and Christianity, married, and stayed in Cairo. The Israeli and Egyptian sides of the family visit one another and stay in touch. Modern Hebrew is full of Arabic. Palestinian citizens of Israel mix Hebrew with their Arabic. Old Palestinian men on the streets of Jerusalem selling used things still shout out in Yiddish. Such anecdotes are a sample of tidbits that hint at the hopeful narratives beneath the surface. Jews and Palestinians are clearly related. Put a group of random Americans in a room with a diverse group of Palestinians and Israelis and the Americans would struggle to figure out who was who.</p><p>Alongside all of this, though, are the brute facts of power. The multi-faceted control of Israeli Jews over Palestinians is pervasive. This oppression takes different forms. The Occupation of the West Bank — which has become even harsher under Netanyahu’s current government — is a life-sucking labyrinth of dehumanization, intense inequalities, and unnecessary human suffering. Netanyahu and his allies continue to make the situation worse. They build settlements deep in the West Bank and then pour resources into the security apparatus to protect the people whom they have placed there in the first place. They create the conditions for the escalation of conflict, complain when there is conflict — often instigated by extremist Jewish Israeli “settlers”— and then use this as a pretext for increasing their pressure on the Palestinian collective neck.</p><p>They cut Palestinian communities off from one another. They control the movement of Palestinians within the West Bank and between the West Bank and the outside world. They control access to water and other essential resources. Without going into further detail, they destroy the basics of what Palestinians need to build their own healthy society.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*mglLtDPdY9-wfa-3yPqyhw.png" /><figcaption>(Image property of Deb Bicknell, Maria Ireland Creamer, or Ajay Noronha).</figcaption></figure><p>The Israeli control over Gaza even after Ariel Sharon’s “disengagement” is a different kind of oppression which until October 7th continued alongside Netanyahu’s indirect support of Hamas. Netanyahu facilitated the flow of money to Hamas because he saw Hamas’s presence in Gaza as a way to separate Palestinians from one another — which made it easier for him to claim that there was no Palestinian partner and thus could be no peace process. The Palestinians of Jerusalem, conquered in 1967, have their own liminal status and challenges that I’ll save for another time.</p><p>Palestinian citizens of Israel/Arab Israelis juggle one of the most complex identities imaginable. At its best, at its most inclusive, Israel has offered its Arab/Palestinian citizens opportunities for human flourishing, economic betterment, and social integration. You can see examples of such success in Israeli hospitals. But as Israeli society has become increasingly illiberal, less inclusive, more narrowly nationalistic, such successes have become harder to come by. The great writer Sayed Kashua — a Palestinian citizen of Israel who writes in Hebrew, one of the most important voices around when it comes to understanding Israeli society and “the conflict” — is one casualty of what I’m talking about. He dedicated his life to an inclusive Israel where people like himself and his family could belong and contribute on terms of equality. But after trying so hard, he found life in Israel unbearable. He now lives in the States.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/750/1*WWxGUktH-WVe7uCFsyFiHQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>A fence in South Portland, Maine (Image property of Daniel Noah Moses).</figcaption></figure><p>I find comfort in the fact that Kashua is still a relatively young man, and that his story remains unfinished, as does the story of Israel, of Palestine, of Israelis and Palestinians. I’ve struggled to write something helpful here but am left in a haze of futility with small hopes and glimmers of possibility. In the last months, I’ve focused at a local level — which, in my case, is upstate New York. I’m building trust, strengthening relationships, and the capacity for both dialogue and action, which, for me must grow together. Two specific kinds of action speak to me personally during these dark times.</p><p>First, I am doing what I can to encourage a dialogue between members of my local Jewish community across the spectrum from self-described Left wing Zionists who want a two-state solution to those who march for Palestinian solidarity. This dialogue is for the sake of action, for enlarging the circle, for becoming more effective. I am organizing one-to-one meetings with a range of activists. Soon I’ll arrange a small gathering at my house to talk, to get to know one another, to build trust. At some point, I might enlarge the circle to include more right-wing Jews. For now, I am focused on organizing for a ceasefire, so I’m sticking with those who, whatever their differences, want that, too.</p><p>Second, I’m trying to work across communities — specifically Arab-Americans and Muslim Americans in my area who have their own connections to Palestine and the larger Middle East. One of the woman in the bi-weekly dialogue group has worked with a group of Jewish and Muslim women. She is meeting with a few of them in the upcoming days to see if they might be interested in a larger meeting to get to know one another and explore how we might work together. I offered to have everybody over at my house. We’ll see what unfolds.</p><p>In the scheme of things, this is not much. For me, it feels radically insufficient. But doing this kind of voluntary community work, while financially supporting organizations and people I care about, and trying to write, is what I can manage now. I hope that what I’ve written here resonates with others and that together our various small-scale efforts will make the kinds of impact that we want to see.</p><p>If I sound naive, remember that I have a tangible sense of the challenges based on experience. I have a sense of the fear, hatred, and rage, engulfing the region. I am <strong>not </strong>optimistic. There are no automatic levers to pull; there are no buttons to push to make the situation better. But I have also experienced solid grounds for hope. Hope, unlike optimism, makes room for the tragic; it acknowledges that failure is also possible. What I’m talking about requires an almost overwhelming amount of work. This work becomes less overwhelming when the circles of people involved keeps growing — when everyday people do their part.</p><p>My hope is that what I’m describing might be one example of a movement of everyday people that grows until it has visible impact. To be as effective as possible, I want to see more inclusive demonstrations that call for: a ceasefire; an end to the massive Israeli military attacks in Gaza; an exchange of the Israeli hostages for Palestinian prisoners; ample international aid for the people of Gaza to rebuild their homes and communities; security for both Israelis and Palestinians; and a tenacious, sustained, international effort to bring Israelis and Palestinians to the table again. If the Israeli and Palestinian leadership has to change to make this happen — which is more than probable — let it be so ASAP. If a full exchange of Israeli hostages for Palestinian prisoners in Israeli prisons exchange takes place, one of the Palestinian prisoners released would be Marwan Barghouti, the most popular Palestinian leader alive. I don’t put my faith in any leaders without them earning it. But from the little I know of him, perhaps he can play a significant role in bringing both Palestinians and Israelis back to more hopeful possibilities.</p><p>My key point is that the necessary transformations of the situation in Israel/Palestine must include a combination of forces from “below.” The challenge is how to develop related movements of people who disagree on essential points but share enough to work together in order to achieve their common objectives — a ceasefire, massive aid for the people of Gaza, the exchange of Israeli hostages for Palestinian prisoners, steps toward peace and justice, along with a more human, a more hopeful future, for both Palestinians and Israelis.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/750/1*ZNPtv3sggdl_hCuLjSO6LQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Maize and friends on the beach in Maine in November 2023 (Image property of Daniel Noah Moses).</figcaption></figure><p>Depending on one’s interests and values there are, of course, many different organizations, and many different ways, to support Palestinians and Israelis. For those interested, here are four organizations that spark the imagination, build trust and community, transform realities, and build a shared future for both peoples that I believe are worth checking out:</p><p>1.) Combatants For Peace: <a href="https://cfpeace.org/">https://cfpeace.org/</a></p><p>2.) Standing Together: <a href="https://www.standing-together.org/en">https://www.standing-together.org/en</a></p><p>3.) Land for All: <a href="https://www.alandforall.org/">https://www.alandforall.org/</a></p><p>4.) AllMEP: <a href="https://www.allmep.org/">https://www.allmep.org/</a></p><p>I welcome your ideas, your feedback, your questions, regarding what I’ve written here. When it comes to the Israeli/Palestinian conflict — like so much else in this precarious moment of human existence — each of us has a chance to make at least a small difference. This is what I constantly tell myself. The pervading sense of powerlessness and disconnection — the fog of our atomized society, our atomized existence — can make this difficult to see. Things remain dark. Nothing is certain. But small differences can add up, and such beliefs get me through the day. In this, I know. I am not alone.</p><p>I’ll leave off with Patti Smith and a whole group of people singing “The People Have the Power.” This video gives me a lift. May it do the same for you.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2Fy6Wz3i_BYUc&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3Dy6Wz3i_BYUc&amp;image=http%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2Fy6Wz3i_BYUc%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/28f51e90027c393541b679c858856c74/href">https://medium.com/media/28f51e90027c393541b679c858856c74/href</a></iframe><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e209d0225ccb" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Urgent Notes of a Failed Peace Builder: Israel and Palestine]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/urgent-notes-of-a-failed-peace-builder-israel-and/urgent-notes-of-failed-peace-builder-63a5659c3848?source=rss-dbf020efe563------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/63a5659c3848</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[hamas-vs-israel]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[israel-palestine-conflict]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[palestine]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[palestine-and-israel]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[israel]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Daniel Noah Moses]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 21 Oct 2023 23:11:50 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-06-26T16:42:30.445Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*871wg3rz7ZIZvQhuimYGXg.jpeg" /><figcaption>The sea from the Tel Aviv/Jaffa Promenade.</figcaption></figure><p>“Maybe we should give up,” my friend Mohammed tells me on the phone. He is a Palestinian educator from Gaza and a lifelong peace builder. For a time, he was a Hebrew teacher in Gaza. After escaping Gaza during the violent summer of 2014 and staying with me for a little while, he moved as much of his family as possible to Ohio. It’s now October 2023 and his wife is in Gaza visiting those who remain. She and those remaining children and grandchildren are among the many who have fled their homes to escape Israeli bombs. Their niece and her family have already been killed. Again, Mohammed says: “we have have failed, haven’t we.”</p><p>“Yes,” I agree. “We have failed.”</p><p>The current unprecedented violence between Hamas and Israel — the intensity of the human suffering — is painful in a particular way for those of us who know and love people on “both sides,” especially if we have worked from the heart to support Israelis and Palestinians in building a more humane, more peaceful, more just, future. I say this as a Jew, as an American, as a human being, as somebody whose family was decimated in The Holocaust, and as a failed peace builder.</p><p>I understand that whatever I say about the recent Hamas terrorist attacks or the Israeli bombings and destruction of Gaza will be incomplete and provoke pushback; nobody can encompass what is happening in a few words. With this in mind, I ask you, wherever you stand, whatever your perspective, if you are sick of this violence and human suffering and want to stop it — please hear me out. There is <em>no </em>military solution to the Palestinian-Israeli conflict — unless one favors the total annihilation of “the other.” <em>As long as Israeli Jewish human beings and Palestinian human beings exist in The Land, their fates will be intertwined.</em></p><p>I think of Mohammed’s wife and family in Gaza. I think of my Israeli cousins, friends, and former colleagues called up for reserve duty. A niece of my cousin and the son of my friend’s son have been killed already. I think of my visits with Israelis in the communities that border Gaza. I remember one Jewish Israeli woman in particular. After sitting in her living room, she took us to a place at the edge of her community in sight of Gaza where she had created an art project with symbols of peace as a message to the people of Gaza. I think of a Palestinian friend, a school principal, who lives in Gaza. She wrote to me a few days ago: she received a warning from the IDF at 3:00 in the morning to evacuate her family from their apartment. I think of a Jewish Israeli friend who spent so much of the last year protesting Netanyahu’s proposed changes to The Israeli Supreme Court, and another friend, an Jewish Israeli educator in her seventies who has dedicated her life to dialogue and cross-cultural understanding. She wrote to me on Facebook: “broken hearts and broken dreams.” I think of a Palestinian-American friend of mine who left a message a few days ago. She runs a program for Palestinian and Israeli youth leaders (they’ve cancelled their programs for the foreseeable future in light of what’s happening). She told of a video she saw on social media of a young Israeli soldier by a fence on the border with Gaza. There was a Palestinian flag in the fence. The young soldier took the flag out and started to fold it — which triggered a bomb. Body parts flew everywhere. “I’m just shattered about it. Shattered,” she said.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*h1xxXjB69BS1iwWviYVoVw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Outside of Ramallah.</figcaption></figure><p>I think of the Palestinians and Israelis whom I have worked with for years — educators, community leaders, artists, high school and university students — who showed themselves to be uncommonly courageous: they dared to imagine a future different from what we see around us now. Together we lived “as life could be.” They stepped outside of their “comfort zones” to meet with “the other.” They listened to perspectives and stories that are deeply painful to hear. They spoke their own truths when they could have been on vacation with their families. They argued; they cried; sometimes they became despondent but they kept trying. Sometimes they cooked together. Sometimes we sat around the fire at night. Upon returning home, they created projects in their own communities and across lines of conflict. They took time out of their busy lives to try to make a difference. I have a sense of what is possible. But I’ll leave such stories for another time. What matters at this moment is that like me, they have failed. <em>We have failed.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*c0s3mRZIGpAnp7Z_UovQIA.jpeg" /><figcaption>The promenade between Tel Aviv and Jaffa.</figcaption></figure><p>Still, our failure must be seen in context. In a recent op-ed, Thomas Friedman explains why the Israeli government often responds with such disproportionate violence. As Friedman puts it, Israel is essentially saying: ‘you will not outcrazy us out of this neighborhood’ (October 14th, <em>NYT</em>). He makes an analogy between the Israeli response to Hezbollah’s killing and kidnapping of Israeli soldiers in 2006 and the current situation between Israel and Hamas. This analogy leaves out far too much of what those of us who want to inspire hope for a more humane, more just, more peaceful future, for both Israelis and Palestinians, need to understand.</p><p>I spent the summer of 2006 at the Seeds of Peace International Peace Camp on Pleasant Lake in Maine with Palestinian and Israeli educators who were human to one another — courageous even as the violence escalated back home. Later that year, I moved to Jerusalem. During my eleven years living there, I went back and forth across The Green Line. I visited Palestinian and Israeli schools and community centers. I shared lunch in the hills outside of Hebron with Palestinian friends and shabbat dinner the same evening in West Jerusalem with Jewish family or friends. My colleagues and I organized workshops for educators, we supported educators to do their own projects, we created a range of public events that now seem almost utopian, such as a monthly “Seeds Cafe” held alternatively at the American Colony Hotel in East Jerusalem, and the YMCA in West Jerusalem for hundreds of Israelis, Palestinians, and internationals. In the fall of 2006, I participated in a peace conference in Antalya, Turkey, again with hundreds. Such events don’t happen anymore. We felt that the situation was terrible. The prospects for any kind of meaningful peace were retreating fast. More than ten years had already passed since Rabin’s assassination by a Jewish extremist who wanted to stop The Oslo Peace process. Netanyahu, the most vocal opponent of a mutually agreed upon peace between Israelis and Palestinians had already served his first stint as Prime Minister. Arafat, Barak, and Clinton had already failed to come to an agreement. The Second Intifada had already weakened what was left of the Israeli “peace camp.” Arafat, a disappointing leader, had died. Hamas had already come to power. And yet, looking back to 2006, those times were imbued with bits of hope that have since been vaporized — a direct result of the decisions of political leaders. At least Israeli and Palestinian leaders continued to meet. There were still public efforts to negotiate, to come to some kind of mutual agreement. Under Netanyahu’s leadership — all of this this has stopped.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8TPNtBN0p_-Eo7inzGxghA.jpeg" /><figcaption>An Israeli checkpoint.</figcaption></figure><p>There are many forces that have brought Israelis and Palestinians to where they are now. Netanyahu’s policies are a core factor. And as the ones who hold disproportionate power, Israelis possess a particular responsibility. My friend Ilana Sumka, a Jewish peace activist, used to say that Jewish Israelis must choose among three things: democracy, the land, and being a Jewish state. It is possible to have two of these but impossible to have all three. Netanyahu and his allies have chosen to sacrifice democracy in order to keep the land even as they impose their own narrow vision of what it means to be Jewish. The efforts of Netanyahu’s current government to weaken the Supreme Court is part of its effort to entrench the Israeli Occupation of The West Bank. Under Netanyahu, the Israeli government supports settlements deep in the West Bank. It then sends soldiers to defend these settlements and monitor checkpoints — which puts these young people in danger and stretches resources to achieve goals that the majority of Israeli Jews would reject if they believed that peace is possible. The government’s focus on settlements in the West Bank draws resources and attention away from the borders with Gaza and Lebanon. The Occupation of The West Bank, and Israeli policies toward Palestinians in East Jerusalem and in Gaza, take an almost unimaginable toll on Palestinians (I realize that my last sentence does not do enough to reflect the complexities of the status of East Jerusalem; I’ll leave that for another time). Less visibly, in different ways, such policies take a terrible toll on Israelis, too. The rule of Israelis over Palestinians is corrosive, in different ways, to both Palestinians and Israelis and to their respective societies. Netanyahu has encouraged the split between Hamas in Gaza and the Palestinian Authority in the West Bank because this split weakens the Palestinians and makes it easier for him to say that there is no Palestinian partner. For all of these years, Hamas’s rule in Gaza has played to Netanyahu’s political interests. He offered a mirage: that Israel could ensure long-term security through massive military superiority, the entrenchment of the Occupation of The West Bank, the encirclement of Gaza, deals with autocratic Arab regimes, and the bypassing of the Palestinians. He created an illusion for Israelis — that they could live their lives in comfort while ignoring the suffering of the Palestinians and the drastic inequalities imposed in their name.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_oIAnYG8rUuieXAOYUWzkg.jpeg" /><figcaption>View from Shimoni Street in West Jerusalem (Image property of Ajay Noronha).</figcaption></figure><p>During the escalation of violence in the summer of 2014, my friend Mohammed escaped to the States and stayed with me in the bungalow we used to share each summer on the shores of Pleasant Lake. While there, he met a woman named Orly who grew up in Nahal Oz, in Israel, on the other side of the Gaza border, in walking distance from Mohammed’s neighborhood. The two of them cried together. They stayed in touch. We met this past March for brunch at Orly’s house in suburban Boston. They are in regular touch now even through the current storm.</p><p><strong>Netanyahu and his vision have failed. Israel cannot keep all of the land, a Jewish state, and democracy. The current situation where Israel rules over the Palestinians is unjust and unsustainable. I understand the existential fears of Jewish Israelis, and of Jews around the world, about Israel’s survival. But what Netanyahu has been doing for decades is the opposite of what he claims: he has made Israeli Jews, and Jews around the world, less secure. The question remains what it has been for decades — how to distill and multiply the trust that Mohammed and Orly share, how to encourage a human connection at a scale that makes a political difference, how to transform public opinion so that enough people on both sides advocate for a future where both peoples flourish with security on terms of equality. This is the same challenge that existed during the early days of The Oslo Peace Process — how to somehow convey to the broadest possible public of Palestinians, Israelis and their supporters that Palestinians and Israelis are NOT monolithic blocs and that a more humane, more just, more peaceful future is possible. Israel and Palestine are not homogenous entities that make appearances on the “world stage.” “They” are human beings and not animals, and they are internally diverse. The view of each side as a monolithic bloc and the polarization that comes with it makes it almost impossible to see that what is “pro-Palestinian” in the deepest sense is also “pro-Israeli.” This is the challenge of strengthening and enlarging the circles of the sane, kind, well meaning people on “both sides” who are ready to figure out how to share the land, while marginalizing the extremes.</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*jkWfNCY9iTFEXETNcAIO_w.jpeg" /><figcaption>Outside of the Jaffa Gate, Old City of Jerusalem.</figcaption></figure><p>This challenge has become far more difficult in the midst of forced separation, a continued Occupation, a fractured and corrupted media landscape, and accumulating layers of fear, hatred, and rage. Palestinians and Israelis used to interact on a regular basis. Across The West Bank, you will find Palestinian men in their fifties and sixties who speak Hebrew fluently because they used to work with Israelis. You will find older Jewish Israelis from Arab countries who speak Arabic. Israelis and Palestinians used to watch the same handful of television stations. Now they are separated physically from one another and in their own media bubbles. They draw from different stories and different facts. They inhabit radically different realities even if they live within shouting distance.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*NVaEa4IMpJzsgbu5O-_Lbw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Outside of Damascus Gate, Old City of Jerusalem.</figcaption></figure><p>Meanwhile, in this precarious moment, Netanyahu has continued to empower Israeli extremists. He is taking Israelis and Palestinians, along with the rest of us, to a catastrophe with the potential to escalate in ways that keep me up at night and make me shiver to think about. Yes, Israel has the right to defend its people. But the scale of the suffering in Gaza that the Israeli attacks on Hamas, and the forced uprooting of people, inflict on innocent women, men, and children, is devastating. It is not defensible if one believes in human rights and the equal value of human life. People in Gaza need basic necessities. Israel is inflicting collective punishment. It is enflaming the fear, the anger, and the hatred. It is like pouring kerosene in a forest with a lot of dry wood. It is making everybody in the region — including the Israelis — less secure. What is happening now threatens to spread in all directions. It will reverberate for generations. At the same time, the inadequate efforts of The Biden administration to stop Palestinian deaths, to express sympathy for Palestinian deaths and Palestinian suffering, and to get humanitarian aid to Gaza, is shaking whatever confidence that many Arab/Muslim-Americans, and young progressives, including young progressive Jews, had in Biden’s America. This is reverberating, too. The conflict “over there” is “here.” I spoke the other day to a Palestinian American friend. ”I’m worried about what’s going to happen in this country,” he said.</p><p><em>To those in the thick of the violence, I offer prayers for your safety and an end to the violence that will beget more violence.</em> I am mostly at a loss. I am not under any illusions about peace in any real sense anytime soon. Like most, I feel helpless. I search out others like me who feel broken by what is happening. I cling to hope that enough of us who care about people on both sides, or are open to caring about people on both sides, can be human to one another and figure out how to move away from this precipice.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*lqrxMJ1ptgHudQ4ysvqgWg.jpeg" /><figcaption>The Monastery of Temptation outside of Jericho (image property of Maria Ireland Creamer).</figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=63a5659c3848" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/urgent-notes-of-a-failed-peace-builder-israel-and/urgent-notes-of-failed-peace-builder-63a5659c3848">Urgent Notes of a Failed Peace Builder: Israel and Palestine</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/urgent-notes-of-a-failed-peace-builder-israel-and">Urgent Notes of a Failed Peace builder: Israel and Palestine</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[No Place for Socrates: Seeds of Peace, Hannah Arendt, and the Importance of Thinking]]></title>
            <link>https://danielmoses36.medium.com/no-place-for-socrates-seeds-of-peace-hannah-arendt-and-the-importance-of-thinking-b54b4c9b631c?source=rss-dbf020efe563------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b54b4c9b631c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[israel-palestine-conflict]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hopes-and-fears]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[conflict]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[democracy-in-america]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dialogue]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Daniel Noah Moses]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 13 Apr 2022 22:04:41 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-08-08T02:07:05.297Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Ohu1hN-WbptBSUNnqJ3Jkg.jpeg" /><figcaption>At Ali Abu Awad’s place near the Rami Levy in Gush Etzion (Images property of Deborah E. Bicknell Consulting Services LLC, Ajay Noronha, or Daniel Noah Moses).</figcaption></figure><p><em>“We were a nation in thrall to our own stupidity. What passed for politics now was just dramaturgy. Sow conflict, promise consequence. Perhaps Plato wasn’t wrong to warn us about a city overrun with storytellers” </em>(Ayad Akhtar, <em>Homeland Elegies</em>).</p><p><em>“With the theatricality, the entertainment value, the marketing of life is complete, we will find ourselves living not in a nation but in a consortium of industries, and wholly unintelligible to ourselves except for what we see as through a screen darkly”</em> (Toni Morrison, quoted in <em>Homeland Elegies</em>).</p><p>I</p><p>In the midst of disorienting conflicts and social breakdown around the world, including the United States of America, it’s difficult to find language for what’s happening or practical ideas for what to do if we want something different. I’ve written what follows as a sketch in the hopes of being at least a bit helpful in this regard.</p><p>From the summer of 2004 until May of 2021, I worked with an organization, Seeds of Peace, that was built around the promise of “dialogue.” During these last years, the organization has struggled again with ruptures and radical transitions. Many who put their heart into the organization, like me, have left. Multiple reasons exist for such turbulence. But at least one is resoundingly relevant beyond the story of a single relatively small non-profit and the dedicated, hard working, individuals who tried to navigate the conflicts that engulfed us. To put it simply, Seeds of Peace, though dedicated to dialogue, faltered in its commitment to, and capacity for, dialogue. Such failure is understandable — and worth delving into as similar underlying forces wreak havoc at a larger, far more dangerous scale.<a href="#_edn1">i</a></p><p>What I’ve written here is my effort to make sense of my own experiences. At the same time, I’ve tried to capture a set of larger perspectives and experiences for the institutional memory of Seeds of Peace and for “the record.” The people I worked with on the ground have no heirs within the organization: the roots have been cut. Finally, though I have no illusions about the challenge of getting people to read a relatively long piece such as this, I’ve written to reach a broader audience for whom, unfortunately, the story I recount might resonate. I do not claim to have the full story — only part of it. You, the reader, will see that I have strong emotions to express, so it’s worth emphasizing that though I harbor no expectations, I hope to encourage dialogue — which I know would be difficult and can only happen when the moment is right.</p><p>In all of this, I find myself turning to Hannah Arendt. A German Jewish refugee, Arendt’s experience of The Eichmann trial in Jerusalem led to her writing on thinking which she left unfinished at her death. For me, in her <em>thinking</em> about <em>thinking</em> Arendt illuminates the critical role of dialogue and what is at stake when opportunities to practice dialogue — to practice thinking — collapse.<a href="#_edn2">ii</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*oOTNuIkm_RVHx8fygtjksQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>The Acropolis in Athens (Images property of Deborah E. Bicknell Consulting Services LLC, Ajay Noronha, or Daniel Noah Moses).</figcaption></figure><p>II</p><p>Seeds of Peace got its start in the summer of 1993, just before the signing of The Oslo Peace Accords. In September of that year, the Palestinians, Israelis, Jordanians, and Americans from the first Seeds of Peace Camp — high school students and accompanying educators — were present on The White House Lawn for the actual signing. As a poster child for the peace process, the organization embodied hopes for a new Middle East.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/750/1*i-ag7r-7ML-zxTLzr4TAJA.jpeg" /><figcaption>“Pines dock” at camp (Images property of Deborah E. Bicknell Consulting Services LLC, Ajay Noronha, or Daniel Noah Moses).</figcaption></figure><p>The Seeds of Peace Camp on the shores of Pleasant Lake in Otisfield, Maine, was amazing for the unusual range of human beings who made the place their temporary home. On the first day of each camp session, after she asked everybody to call her by her first name, Bobbie Gottschalk, the organization’s beloved co-founder, put it beautifully. Camp, she would say, is a chance “to experience life the way it could be.” From arrival day when disoriented Seeds and the “Delegation Leaders” (“DL’s”), got off the buses to a raucous musical welcome, they inhabited an all encompassing micro-community of possibilities that appeared briefly before vanishing, only to appear again after a regular interval of time.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_GYXYpDToqDeNImgJtHtDQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Erez checkpoint (Images property of Deborah E. Bicknell Consulting Services LLC, Ajay Noronha, or Daniel Noah Moses).</figcaption></figure><p>At camp you could find people who in their everyday lives inhabited worlds separated by both physical and metaphorical walls: Palestinians and Israelis who had lost loved ones in “the conflict;” Palestinians who had spent years as political prisoners of the Israelis and their relatives, along with Israelis who had been prison guards; people from West Bank settlements, from nearby refugee camps, from suburban Tel Aviv, from the American School of Gaza where the elite of Gaza sent their children, and from Shijaeya, an impoverished and religiously conservative Gaza neighborhood. You could find Jewish Israelis with roots in Egypt, Morocco, and Iraq, those whose grandparents escaped Europe, and those who traced themselves back 10 generations in Jerusalem. You could find Palestinians whose ancestors came from Sicily with the Crusades, others with roots in Arabia, in Lebanon, or Sub-Saharan Africa, in the Balkans, or even India, and others who traced long lines of ancestors going back to the Greek, Jewish, and Canaanite past; Bedouin and Druze Israelis whose fathers served in the Israeli army; Afghan girls who were not allowed to play sports at home; a range of Indian and Pakistani Seeds and educators that barely touched the rich diversity of the subcontinent; American born children of refugees from Somalia, Rwanda and South Sudan; teenagers from small towns in rural Maine, and teenagers of privilege from The Upper East Side. You could find kids and educators who vacationed at ski resorts in Switzerland and those who, until the trip to camp, had never been on an airplane; Black Lives Matter activists and former police officers; Egyptian supporters of the Mubarak regime, and people who took to the streets of Cairo to bring that regime down.</p><p>To make camp happen, Seeds of Peace had to earn and keep the trust of an unusually wide range of parents, educators, and communities. The camp, and the organization as a whole, was like an oasis in the desert where people from warring tribes could meet. It was constantly in danger of being destroyed. Adults back home worried at multiple levels about safety — about “brainwashing,” that the organization was pro-Zionist or Left wing pro-Palestinian, or that it was imposing what parents and educators from more traditional communities considered unsavory, immoral, American ways.</p><p>To address such concerns, Seeds of Peace established relationships at the highest levels of official authority. While allied organizations worked at the grassroots level with relatively narrow elements of society, Seeds of Peace gained access to the mainstream. In those early years, the organization partnered with the Israeli and Palestinian Ministries of Education, which selected their respective delegations and prepared “their” Seeds. In Egypt, the organization established a relationship with the Mubareks along with a network of private schools; in Jordan, it was members of The Royal Family and a network of private schools. In the United States, it was the Clintons and everything they represented — a business friendly center left of elites from “the best schools” adapted for the afterglow of Ronald Reagan, when government was in retreat and “neo-liberalism,” “globalization,” “the market,” reigned supreme.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hphoVq6mJmtQHQYfsTnMdw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Barbed wire and growing things (Images property of Deborah E. Bicknell Consulting Services LLC, Ajay Noronha, or Daniel Noah Moses).</figcaption></figure><p>John Wallach was a man inclined to an emphatic yes. When Palestinian and Israeli Seeds requested follow-up programs “in the region,” people such as Ned Lazarus, a former counselor living in Jerusalem at the time, took the initiative.<a href="#_edn3">iii</a> When funding became available to expand into North Africa or selected Gulf States, to establish new programs in The Balkans, Cyprus, India, Pakistan, Afghanistan, or Maine, or later, in the aftermath of 9/11, for Americans and Arabs from selected countries, the organization embraced such opportunities.</p><p>As the organization grew, camp remained central. Whether Seeds came to camp as part of an official delegation or one more informally arranged, it was the “Delegation Leaders,” the “DL’s” who did the work of selection, preparation, and care for the kids to and from camp. When the organization started, they arrived as chaperones. Barbara Zasloff, a psychologist from suburban Philadelphia, saw the potential in a parallel dialogue based experiential program for adults, which is what she created. Later she hired me.</p><p>I first heard about Seeds of Peace while standing on line outside of the pantomime theater in Yerevan, Armenia, after I interrupted the couple in front of me because I found their conversation fascinating. One of them, Bella, had been the arts and crafts counselor at camp. At the time, I was a “Civic Education Project Fellow” teaching history and American studies at two universities in Yerevan. But the work that moved me most turned out to be bringing together university students and young academics from Armenia, Azerbaijan, Georgia, and other newly independent republics, across the lines of conflict that had emerged with the break-up of the Soviet Union. After moving back to the States in September of 2002 to teach social theory at Harvard University, I contacted Seeds of Peace. In the summer of 2004, I started working at camp with the “Delegation Leaders.” While the Seeds were featured as embodiments of an inspiring future in promotional literature and at fundraising events,<strong> t</strong>he DL’s and the educators they reached in their communities were already in positions of influence. If Seeds of Peace were a greenhouse for public spheres, the DL’s were in positions to cultivate environments for seeds — not just “the Seeds” — to flourish even in the midst of terrible storms.</p><p>On arrival day, while most of the camp staff focused on the Seeds, our small team of facilitators and coordinators welcomed the new group of dazed DL’s to their temporary home. We sat with them while Bobbie gave her welcoming speech. We transported the luggage in golf carts and guided the DL’s to their respective cabins with screened in porches facing the lake. We pointed out the fire pit, where smoking was permitted and adults gathered to talk, tell stories, and sing. We invited them inside “The DL Hut” — a long one room white cottage with plywood walls and floors, art projects covering the walls and doors and hanging from the ceiling, further from the lake, facing the main road that ran through camp, that served as the center of life for us.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/750/1*qNy6vs41cv-OVg5HTi6ZRg.jpeg" /><figcaption>The DL House/Educator Hut at camp (Images property of Deborah E. Bicknell Consulting Services LLC, Ajay Noronha, or Daniel Noah Moses).</figcaption></figure><p>The newcomers often used their profession to deflect attention from themselves. “We want tools to teach skills to our students,” they would insist. “We’re here for the kids.” My team members and I would say, first, take a breath; then we invite you to have your own direct experiences with “those people” who celebrate as heroes those you consider villains, who call day what you call night. Be human beings first. You cannot teach dialogue without first experiencing it.</p><p>When I hear that older people cannot change, I shake my head for I’ve experienced, to my core, what can happen when adults who live their lives carrying the responsibilities of work and family suddenly have a chance to take a breath, to sit by the lake and listen; when they find the bandwidth for themselves. I’ve experienced what happens when wildly different human beings are thrown together and provided structured ways to express themselves and build community — what can spontaneously happen when they are offered a chance to play.</p><p>At our best, we created the possibility for people to truly get to know one another and share of themselves; for surprising new human relationship; for a reinvigorated sense of possibility, belonging and trust, usually accompanied, in a variety of different ways, by a desire to continue what had started to grow.</p><p>At our best, we practiced and, as much as possible, embodied, “kindness” and “imagination.” I’m talking about “the sociological imagination” that enables people to better understand the context in which they live and the social forces acting upon them in order to strengthen the capacities to shape their individual and common lives. I’m talking about “the moral imagination,” which, as the peace builder John Paul Lederach put it, “requires the capacity to imagine ourselves in a web of relationships that includes our enemies<strong>; </strong>the ability to sustain a paradoxical curiosity that embraces complexity without reliance on dualistic polarity; the fundamental belief in and pursuit of the creative act; and the acceptance of the inherent risk of stepping into the mystery of the unknown that lies beyond the far too familiar landscape of violence.”<a href="#_edn4">iv</a></p><p>At the center of the camp, a few steps from the large bell that rang between activities, there was a place by the garden that contained sacred memories. Among the stone benches was one with words from a favorite song of John Wallach’s, “last night I had the strangest dream. I dreamed the world had all agreed to put an end to war.” There was a stone bench for the victims of 9/11. And there was a stone bench in honor of Asel, a Palestinian-Israeli/Palestinian citizen of Israel/Arab-Israeli Seed who was killed by Israeli police while wearing his green Seeds of Peace shirt. On Asel’s bench were etched words by the poet Rumi:</p><p><em>Out beyond ideas of wrongdoing and right doing,<br> there is a field. I’ll meet you there.</em></p><p>If you stand by this stone bench and look out, with “The Big Hall” to the left and the lake to the right, you can see painted in bold letters on the side of a building: “This Is the Field.”</p><p>III</p><p>But Rabin was assassinated. The ebullience of the Oslo Peace Process faded. The Second Intifada started in September of 2000. The attacks on 9/11 killed thousands and shook Americans out of our complacency, at least briefly. John Wallach died of cancer in July of 2002.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*vzrJj7db-_oEYbHZeuWfEg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Barbed wire (Images property of Deborah E. Bicknell Consulting Services LLC, Ajay Noronha, or Daniel Noah Moses).</figcaption></figure><p>My first summer with Seeds of Peace, 2004, coincided with organizational turmoil in the wake of Wallach’s death. After working at camp for three summers, in the fall of 2006, I went full-time to be the point person for a set of USAID funded projects and moved to Jerusalem. The organizational turmoil continued, along with multiple leadership turn-overs within the space of a few years. Already, I noticed a pattern. People placed in power fired dedicated long-time staff members or made it impossible for them to stay. The leadership of the organization, executive staff and board, did not listen well. People who loved the organization often ended up alienated from it. There was little trust or consistency. To do my work, I turned to a small but growing network of colleagues and friends: DL’s whom I had gotten to know at camp, educators, artists, and other people with light in their eyes, human beings who just showed up. They worked on part-time contracts or as volunteers. They came back year after year. What united us was that we were human to one another and that we did things with all our full hearts.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*mA9OOl-vugSJSbLN-Ybmbw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Jaffa Road, West Jerusalem (Images property of Deborah E. Bicknell Consulting Services LLC, Ajay Noronha, or Daniel Noah Moses).</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*LtiQXkscSHCMy01KxGrOTg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Damascus Gate, East Jerusalem (Images property of Deborah E. Bicknell Consulting Services LLC, Ajay Noronha, or Daniel Noah Moses).</figcaption></figure><p>After I moved to Jerusalem, I was constantly on the move. DL’s invited me into their homes, their schools and community centers; they introduced me to their families, friends, and colleagues. I would walk from a meeting over Arabic coffee with Palestinian colleagues in Bethlehem through the checkpoint to a meeting over coffee “afukh” with Israeli colleagues on Emek Refaim (the main thorough fare of West Jerusalem’s “German Colony”). One afternoon, I could be sitting in a home in a Palestinian refugee camp on the way to Hebron or at an art workshop with Palestinian educators at a community center in Tulkarem. The next day, I could be at a workshop for Israeli educators in Netanya, at a school in Sderot, on the border with Gaza, with informal educators at the Israeli Ministry of Education offices in Petah Tikvah,” at a Shabbat meal with observant Jewish family or friends, or at an event for musicians and other artists in Jaffa. Less regularly, you could find me in Amman, Cairo, or Mumbai, in Dexter, Maine, in Portland, Maine, in New York City, at a cross-border workshop in Wadi Rum, or on the shores of the Dead Sea.</p><p>In Israel/Palestine, the physical barriers and the emotional geography combine to generate a labyrinth of human realities that seldom touch. Instead of “the conflict,” there is a spectrum of conflicts. Through the work, I developed a sense of the disparate needs. I realized that instead of moving directly to the conflicts that grab headlines, it was most helpful to start closer to home.<strong> </strong>Through the years, I learned that though the realities of Israel/Palestine operate at a heightened intensity, similar dynamics exist everywhere.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*nSt-Yji1TmLRP_xdhe1gYQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>View from the Tayelet Haas Promenade in Jerusalem (Images property of Deborah E. Bicknell Consulting Services LLC, Ajay Noronha, or Daniel Noah Moses).</figcaption></figure><p>Everywhere I went, it was educators, artists,and community leaders who opened the doors: I saw the potential that could grow by building trust with them, by cultivating ecosystems of community. But these social contexts and their potential were difficult to see at camp with the inspiring teenagers in their green t-shirts against an idylic background that obscured the realities from which they came.</p><p>Once I was sitting at the Jerusalem Hotel, around the corner from Damascus Gate in Jerusalem with my friend Mohammed and a group of high school students he had accompanied from Gaza. Most of the kids were from The American School of Gaza, a private school, and most of the girls from that school were “uncovered” (they did not wear a hijab). But one boy, who went to a different school, was from an impoverished strictly devout Muslim family. To show me, Mohammed covered his face with his hands, leaving only his eyes visible. “His mom,” he explained, “is like this.”</p><p>Although he didn’t use these specific words, Mohammed explained that the boy was freaking out. He had never been in the company of unrelated girls of his own age and the fact that they were not wearing hijab made him intensely uncomfortable and judgmental. “I’m trying to explain to him that everybody is different, that God people made everybody different, and that that’s okay. It’s important to accept that people are different.”</p><p>When we brought together Palestinian educators from Gaza, the West Bank and Jerusalem for a workshop in Jericho or in the hills outside of Bethlehem, it was usually the first time that participants in their twenties, thirties, even forties, had ever met counterparts from other parts of Palestine. The joy of such meetings is difficult to convey.</p><p>Israelis don’t face the same barriers and constraints that Palestinians do. They can drive easily from the north to the south of the country (though the country itself is like an island surrounded by a hostile sea). But they suffer difficulties of a different kind. They live as members of separate “tribes” distinguished by religion, ethnic identity, religious observance, politics, and geography. The barriers between these tribes are reinforced by the educational systems. External threats help to keep a fractious society together. But the situation is precarious and often volatile.</p><p>Most Jewish Israelis know very little about the Palestinians over whom they rule. Israeli law forbids Israeli citizens from entering areas designated as “Area A” of the West Bank, which includes where most Palestinians live. Once an Israeli peace activist at a workshop held at a resort on the Israeli coast said to me: “you know, I don’t come to these Seeds of Peace events to meet Palestinians. I have many Palestinian friends and I drive all the time to meet them in the West Bank — in Area A. I come to your events to meet the Israeli mainstream, the Jewish Israelis who won’t go where I go because they are afraid or don’t want to break the law. I want to talk to these people because they don’t know what is being done in their name.”</p><p>A Palestinian DL from a village outside of Bethlehem who had spent years as a political prisoner in an Israeli prison once explained to a Board member that to create a more peaceful and just future it was not enough to bring together a small group of selected Palestinians and Israelis. He emphasized that we had to turn our attention inside communities and deepen the work with educators and community leaders. The board member, articulating the common board perspective, said no: we support the Seeds and do cross-border work.</p><p>The end of that initial USAID funding coincided with the Great Recession of 2008. For several years, I went “part-time” and scraped by in Jerusalem. Then money for programming returned in drips from government sources and philanthropic gifts even as the situation between Israelis and Palestinians kept getting worse.</p><p>For a growing number of Palestinians and their supporters, dialogue was a counterproductive distraction that drew attention away from resistance. Dialogue was part of “normalization,” the idea that by interacting with members of the oppressing group who are not in explicit solidarity resisting Occupation, Palestinians strengthen a brutal status quo. As the situation deteriorated, Seeds of Peace became one of the most visible embodiments of “normalization.” My close colleagues and I argued that engaging in dialogue is not normal — and is a powerful way to resist the status quo. But this kind of argument was increasingly rejected, even by Palestinians who went out of their way to shop at Israeli shopping malls and box stores.</p><p>The summer of 2014 was a turning point. I was in Jerusalem when Palestinians affiliated with Hamas kidnapped three Jewish Israeli teenagers in Gush Etzion, a settlement bloc in the south of the West Bank. Soon after, while at a regional summer camp for Palestinian children in Jenin, Israeli military forces entered The Occupied Territories. As Israel and Hamas fell back into their cruelly disproportionate dance, I was on the phone regularly with Mohammed, who was home in Shijaeya, Gaza, where the bombs were falling hard. There was tear gas in the air at the Qalandia checkpoint between Jerusalem and Ramallah. On the outskirts of Jerusalem, we passed missiles from Gaza on fire on the side of the road. When the sirens went off, I huddled in bomb shelters with my Israeli neighbors and sat around Shabbat tables with despondent family and friends.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*S_ey590x9QUuGNkp1rRetg.jpeg" /><figcaption>View from my old apartment on Shimoni Street in Jerusalem (Images property of Deborah E. Bicknell Consulting Services LLC, Ajay Noronha, or Daniel Noah Moses).</figcaption></figure><p>That summer, the entire Palestinian delegation arrived at camp wearing black t-shirts. Two of the Palestinian DL’s, including the head DL, both of whom I knew well, took me aside to explain.</p><p>After difficult conversations in Ramallah with the Palestinian Seeds of Peace community, they had decided to go to camp — but with conditions. First, they would wear the black t-shirts instead of the usual Seeds of Peace shirts. Second, they were at camp to resist Occupation. They wanted to eliminate “fun” activities, anything that smacked of “normalization,” and focus on dialogue. Third, they insisted on a camp wide event commemorating the people of Gaza who had died and honoring those who were suffering, particularly the Seeds and DL’s from Gaza who had not been able to make it to camp.</p><p>I called Wil Smith, the beloved associate camp director, who drove his golf cart to where the two Palestinian DL’s and I were standing by the camp store on the main road that went through camp. Wil listened carefully. He and the Palestinian DL’s agreed on enough for the Palestinian DL’s to move forward with the session. Later, in DL dialogue, the other DL’s, most notably, the Israelis, worked actively to listen. In the following weeks, I witnessed small acts of courage that went unnoticed by the larger organization but which made a significant difference for the overall success of that gut wrenching summer.</p><p>The way I saw it, <em>this</em> was the time to turn to our friends, colleagues, and allies in the communities — to support them in the ways they needed, dedicate resources for them, and work together. But instead, the organization put its energy into GATHER, a new high profile initiative originally concentrated on “social entrepreneurship” that was launched with lavish events by the Dead Sea in Jordan, in Jericho, and in Tel Aviv. These events, along with the fellowships they were part of, singled out a handful of people for the limelight, while creating an illusion of resources that did not exist for the people on the ground where the flames were burning away whatever remained of hope.<a href="#_edn5">v</a></p><p>During my first years in Jerusalem, the USAID Cooperative Agreement that I managed supported monthly “Seed Cafes” in Jerusalem that drew audiences of hundreds of Palestinians, Israelis, and internationals. We regularly organized cross-border workshops in Jordan with substantial groups of Palestinian, Jordanian, Egyptian, Israeli, and American educators. By the time I moved back to the States in 2017, memories of such events had become bittersweet figments of a bygone time (with the exception of one incredible artists’ retreat in the desert). Meanwhile, as the flames of conflict in America kept climbing, the organization dramatically expanded American programs where a community based multi-generational model existed, thanks to Tim Wilson, founding camp director and guiding spirit in Maine (the anomalous success of Seeds of Peace Maine was possible because of Tim’s strong presence over decades and because for so long Maine was considered a low priority largely misunderstood and ignored by decision makers in New York; Maine’s success was not replicated).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*JKbMKz8RT3T-GfOAp_Tn8g.jpeg" /><figcaption>Wadi Rum, Jordan, Lawrence of Arabia’s base of operations during the Arab Revolt of 1917–1918 (Images property of Deborah E. Bicknell Consulting Services LLC, Ajay Noronha, or Daniel Noah Moses).</figcaption></figure><p>In my experience, during those last years leading up to the Global Pandemic, before Seeds of Peace imploded, regionally based staff members who disagreed with one another on fundamental issues avoided dialogue while doing what they could to achieve their goals through favored access to those at the New York headquarters who possessed greater authority. People with rank who spoke loudest against oppression used their power to silence those with whom they disagreed. By controlling information flows and structures of conversation, they lifted up selected voices while excluding others in ways that distorted the decision making process. The most privileged individuals from oppressed groups — for example, young, well-travelled, “cosmopolitan,” Palestinians with Israeli citizenship or Jerusalem identity cards — excluded those more harshly oppressed, for example older Palestinian educators and community leaders from Gaza and the north and south of the West Bank with Palestinian ID’s who, in general, are more religious, traditional, and socially conservative, more representative of their societies, and less sure of themselves in English or fluent in “progressive” discourse. Board members exhibited the unreflective hubris that often accompanies great wealth, relied on incomplete and distorted information, and just did not pay attention. Board members and staff leadership failed over the course of many years to recognize the importance of relationships on the ground in the communities where we worked, to listen, to build and maintain trust, to follow through or support those who were nurturing such trust. A lack of shared agreement around vision among staff members, board members, and the constituents we served, along with consistent failure to create the conditions for meaningful dialogue, created an impossible situation. Things came to a head in January 2020, just before lockdown. I stayed for another year and a half, through the first part of the Global Pandemic, until I became convinced, contrary to my fondest hope, that there wouldn’t be significant efforts to mend relationships or rebuild anytime soon.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*RN0e99usNCI1uOOVKvBVNQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Wadi Rum, Jordan (Images property of Deborah E. Bicknell Consulting Services LLC, Ajay Noronha, or Daniel Noah Moses).</figcaption></figure><p>IV</p><p>Jess Rohan, the author of an article about Seeds of Peace that appeared recently in <em>The Jewish Currents</em>, was a counselor at camp in the summer of 2014. The people whom she relied upon as sources are former counselors and summer facilitators, former or current full-time staff members, who are often also older Seeds themselves. Their voices matter. But what they say is part of a larger conversation that also requires the voices of people whom they excluded.</p><p>Rohan writes about Seeds of Peace staff members who wanted to move from what they called “co-existence” to what they called “co-resistance.” She quotes Greg Barker, a lead facilitator for the Seeds, on “building solidarity” in oppressed groups and on power and oppression; she quotes him naming the problem between Israelis and Palestinians as a problem of “settler colonialism.” All of this is part of a larger argument that the organization must reconfigure dialogue as a definite precursor to specific forms of “action,” and that this “action,” and “co-resistance” is what really counts.<a href="#_edn6">vi</a></p><p>Towards the end of the article, though, Rohan leads the reader to a surprising place — and puts her finger on the heart of a predicament that has vital consequences. In closing, she writes: “yet even some alumni calling for structural change at Seeds of Peace said they’re grappling with the paradox that the camp was a catalyst for developing their understanding of power structures in the first place. The alumnus who criticized the program for making Israeli campers complacent acknowledged the difficulty of her position. ‘I was introduced to this whole culture at Seeds,’ she said. ‘My best friends in the world are from there.” A bit earlier in the piece Rohan quotes an older American Seed saying: “‘The fundamental question is, how can you do co-resistance work while also bringing people to the table who aren’t already on board?’”<a href="#_edn7">vii</a></p><p>Yes. <em>Here is the rub.</em></p><p>I admired the passion and youthful energy of my action oriented former colleagues. But as they assumed authority in the organization, I became concerned. At staff meetings and retreats, they dominated conversations and displayed limited patience when it came to people with substantially different points of view. And they ignored people on the ground — particularly the DL’s and other educators. They did not show interest in engaging across lines of difference with people in their own communities. They displayed limited attention or interest in dialogue.</p><p>Palestinian DL’s from the West Bank and Gaza — people who had put their hearts into Seeds of Peace — often called to ask me what was going on. They spoke about “the Jerusalem office” as if it were a foreign entity. When I asked if the Palestinian staff members were in touch with them, the DL’s consistently said no.</p><p>On the Israeli side, this dynamic was reflected in the 2018 organizational decision to break with the Israeli Ministry of Education. What struck me was not the decision itself, but its implementation — which was transactional, exclusionary, and disrespectful. I was the only staff member to meet with the key Israeli DL’s — many of whom had put their hearts into the organization since the 1990’s.</p><p>Not long after, in that last summer of 2019, the organizational leadership asked me to invite key DL’s from across the network for a special “design” session to outline how they envisioned the role of educators in relationship to Seeds of Peace. For three-weeks we worked day and night. The DL’s articulated a set of requests and invitations addressed to the organizational leadership. But the organizational leadership didn’t respond or show any indication of authentic engagement. This took place as the staff members whom Rohan relies upon were advocating for “a world without oppression.” <a href="#_edn8">viii</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/720/1*dOqDXr7EKRapRNdxL4T_uA.jpeg" /><figcaption>A path in northern Greece (Images property of Deborah E. Bicknell Consulting Services LLC, Ajay Noronha, or Daniel Noah Moses).</figcaption></figure><p>I couldn’t help noticing the contrast between a vision of “a world without oppression” and an<strong> </strong>invitation to metaphorically walk together. I don’t think that my former colleagues stopped to consider that for many devout people from a variety of religious backgrounds to talk as if human beings can end all oppression on our own is hubris of the most dangerous kind — that framing the mission of the organization in such a way shuts down dialogue. It assumes (or imposes) a given that is not shared.</p><p>For the most vocal “action oriented” staff members, this vision “of a world without oppression” also meant that the organization — which exists through the financial support of capitalists — had to become explicitly anti-capitalist. When an impressive young African-American social entrepreneur applied for The GATHER Fellowship, one of my former colleagues argued that as a capitalist, this applicant was an agent of “oppression” and thus should not be considered.</p><p>Instead of creating a welcoming environment for a broad range of people and an open-ended educational experience, my action oriented former colleagues seemed to approach dialogue with teenagers as if they were working with a group of committed left-wing organizers. Instead of encouraging participants to “suspend conclusions,” they rushed to judgment. Instead of encouraging participants to exercise their imaginations, they advocated for a single comprehensive framework.<a href="#_edn9">ix</a></p><p>At camp orientations and staff retreats, I empathized with the feelings they expressed. But I was put off how scripted the conversations often felt; by the tight boundaries around what was considered acceptable; by an over-sensitivity that made it difficult to be honest; by how the identity of a person often mattered more than what they had to say.</p><p>There was a sameness of language, an inflexibility, a righteousness, an unthinkingness, that felt too close to indoctrination. My action oriented former colleagues named things, categorized reality, shaped the content of dialogue, in ways that from my perspective, even when I was in silent agreement with specific points, stifled real difference and got in the way of the kind of <em>thinking</em> that I’m talking about.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*H99QraLBVFcDZc5A_NlELw.jpeg" /><figcaption>13th Lake, North River, New York. For me, this photograph embodies winter, the hibernation of so many growing things. It is also a center for The Fig Tree Alliance, a new initiated of friends and colleagues (Images property of Deborah E. Bicknell Consulting Services LLC, Ajay Noronha, or Daniel Noah Moses).</figcaption></figure><p>What a contrast there was between my action oriented former colleagues and my former colleagues on the admin/finance team. During visits to the New York office, I used to love visiting my admin/finance team colleagues in their back room. A diverse group of people from all over the world, they were filled with questions and ideas about the work we were doing and about life, and always open to talk.</p><p>I am <strong><em>not</em></strong><em> </em>making a blanket argument here against the rising discourse of race and gender, for religion, or for capitalism, or against Barker’s claim regarding “settler colonialism” as the root of the Palestinian-Israeli conflict. I agree that talk alone is not enough. What I’m arguing against is how my action oriented former colleagues treated other people, how they approached learning, and how they conflated what I view as a core distinction and thus did violence to values that I care deeply about.</p><p>I agree that at a certain level all education is political. I would never claim that dialogue based experiential learning replaces the need for political action. I believe deeply in political action — participation in the electoral process, organizing in and across communities, demonstrating in the street, even, if necessary, taking to the barricades.</p><p>But I believe that it is also critical to distinguish between education into a democratic ethos, an ethos of imagination, social awareness, critical thinking, empathy, kindness and respect, and advocacy for specific political agendas. It matters how individual human beings in a society with democratic aspirations are educated and prepared. The capacity to listen matters. What and whom citizens turn to for authority matters. How we engage with difference matters. How we engage with evidence, how we form opinions — how we make up and how we change own own minds — matters. Whom we care about and how we treat others matters, too.<a href="#_edn10">x</a></p><p>The best antidote to tyranny and disinformation is a healthy citizenry composed of virtuous individuals who think for themselves while staying true to a set of common values regarding human rights and human flourishing. When people don’t get enough practice as autonomous thinkers, they will be easily manipulated. When people are atomized and frustrated, they will turn to demagogues and dangerous myths. They will “escape from freedom” to authoritarian and totalitarian alternatives that offer easily digested answers along with convenient “others” to fear and hate.</p><p>Different approaches to social transformation will resonate with different people at different moments. Alongside the tension between “co-resistance” and enlarging the circle, dialogue opportunities and action in solidarity with a particular cause or people can be complementary. Although dialogue alone is not enough, people need opportunities to step back, to think, to reflect, to learn. The success of any form of “co-resistance” depends upon enlarging the circle — on reaching the crowds.</p><p>There is a rich spectrum of possible dialogue, multiple strategies available for distinct audiences and various moments in time. What made the Seeds of Peace work so well was that we brought together such an unusual range of people and offered them direct experience of what life could be: this included an unusual abundance of focused time to build relationships and trust.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-RPJGqOCcGmoWZITFd32ng.jpeg" /><figcaption>Images property of Deborah E. Bicknell Consulting Services LLC, Ajay Noronha, or Daniel Noah Moses.</figcaption></figure><p>In contrast, in action oriented partisan spaces, there is often a pervasive sense of scarcity. There are never enough resources or enough time. Ideological commitments are often accompanied by a thinning out of perspectives and opinions. It can become difficult for individuals to ask questions or dissent. Lack of engagement with intellectual diversity can lead to the atrophy of what enables people to fundamentally disagree — and grow.</p><p>In their certainty about being right, my action oriented former colleagues trampled on that field beyond right and wrong. They violated an epistemological humility essential for dialogue across lines of conflict as well as education for self-government in a diverse society. Context matters. Audience matters. Pacing matters. The unconvinced are far less likely to participate in something offered by committed partisans of any one side. It’s difficult to engage in dialogue while holding up the tent. In my experience, the large tents for the broadest range of partisans, the curious, the unconvinced, the skeptical, are best tended by those who live by Rumi’s words instead of the urge for immediate “co-resistance.”</p><p>By closing the circle, my action oriented former colleagues lost sight of the critical role that Seeds of Peace had been playing in a larger ecology. By combining things that require separate care, they limited the potential for future allies. By imposing a discourse, particularly, but not exclusively, on high school students, and by conflating opportunities for dialogue with totalizing action against all oppression, they intervened in complex learning processes and relationships that require more flexibility and nuance, more attention to the audience, more discipline, more patience, and more time. In their impatience, my action oriented former colleagues severely damaged the very thing that did so much to make them who they are.</p><p>V</p><p>To be clear, I don’t believe that my youthful action oriented former colleagues possess ultimate responsibility for what happened to Seeds of Peace. At critical moments, Seeds of Peace offered (and probably still does) precious opportunities for human connection, affirmation, self-reflection, self-expression, exploration, and growth. But in the end it is directed behind closed doors by a small group of individuals with power and money within a context of enormous concentrations of wealth, vast inequalities, and the assumptions and social conditioning prevalent at Davos or on The Upper East Side.<a href="#_edn11">xi</a> Throughout my time with the organization, decision makers regularly imposed decisions from above based on very limited understanding. Distracted by what was shiny and well packaged, they often snuffed out promising work. Too often, they treated relationships as purely transactional. Like oblivious gardeners, they regularly cut roots and did damage to intricate networks of life.<a href="#_edn12">xii</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/750/1*VoBfBFiqUHtSvZ4-Bw5oAA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Images property of Deborah E. Bicknell Consulting Services LLC, Ajay Noronha, or Daniel Noah Moses.</figcaption></figure><p>Throughout my time with the organization, I experienced waves of new organizational charts, strategic processes, and protocols imposed from above. As I was leaving, though the characters were different, the pattern remained uncomfortably familiar. To the constant rhetoric of “empowerment” was added “community,” even as the organization continued to disempower constituents, break trust, neglect relationships, and leave unresolved conflicts and tensions to fester. <a href="#_edn13">xiii</a></p><p>In saying this, I don’t intend to say anything surprising or controversial. Seeds of Peace reflects what is true at a larger scale. Americans still enjoy the inherited benefits of institutions, laws, values, and practices, that are part of a democratic experiment unprecedented in the history of humankind (which I cherish). But trust in American institutions, public and private, have eroded for good reason. Institutions and systems have been corrupted by moneyed interests, as has science itself. Opportunities for meaningful interaction with fellow citizens, for meaningful participation in our work lives, our government, our communities, have been hollowed out over generations before our eyes.</p><p>As a general rule, schools prepare students for a status quo of drastic inequalities and social realities that have overwhelmed human scale. This is a world of relentless monitoring and evaluation in order to predict, control, and standardize outcomes. This is a world of algorithms, rotating buzzwords, public relations, marketing, and bureaucratic forms. In pursuit of funding, dedicated staff members of non-profits such as Seeds of Peace, like Amazon employees, medical professionals and scientists, are forced to navigate mind numbing systems with demands for relentless reporting that sap the imagination and drain away energy and attention from the human core of the work. Although I believe that teachers do the sacred work of preparing the next generation, today they, too, are regularly treated like cogs in a machine. Those of us alive on this planet today inhabit systems flooded by data and corrupted by money where wisdom and the moral imagination are in short supply.<a href="#_edn14">xiv</a></p><p>By extrapolating from my experiences with Seeds of Peace, I get a sense of why the United States failed so miserably in Iraq and Afghanistan. Both Seeds of Peace and the American government pay lip service to the same set of inspiring ideals. The distance between such ideals and the realities only make for a harder fall.</p><p>I dedicated myself to Seeds of Peace because I believed we were creating a small counter-culture of human relationships, of imagination, of thinking, in the midst of the systemic brutality of modern life where bureaucratic thoughtlessness dominates. In a different way, I too, was naïve. I am proud of the work that I was able to do with my wonderful friends and colleagues on the ground. I have deep love and appreciation for them and how they took (and take) time out of their busy lives to make a difference. I mourn how things at Seeds of Peace turned out for so many of us. As I look forward, I’m left with questions. What can we learn that might prepare us for what lies ahead? How might Seeds of Peace live up to its potential? How do we, in our various different contexts, with our various visions and projects, do better this time?</p><p>Hannah Arendt experienced Germany’s transition from a fledgling democracy to a totalitarian regime within a matter of years. She barely escaped the Nazis and spent a good portion of her life stateless. Years later, when she tried to explain how Adolph Eichmann, the mastermind behind The Holocaust, was able to do what he did, she found that he possessed the “thoughtlessness” of a bureaucrat. He pulled the levers and pushed the buttons in a cold tautly bound system. He didn’t really think about what he was doing. The source of his cruelty was uncaring lack of attention to the impact of his decisions. The “othering” of the targeted people along with the bureaucratic distance between decisions and their impact made his unthinkingness easier, of course.</p><p>“Unthinking men,” wrote Arendt, “are like sleepwalkers.”<a href="#_edn15">[xv]</a> She grounded her thinking on thinking in the human wonder over existence, over being alive and self-aware. For her, such thinking is integrated with feeling and emerges from the depths of being. In tracing various paths from this initial contemplation of existence and self-hood, she expanded on the practice, the process, of thinking as an internal dialogue with oneself that extends outward to others.</p><p>When she turned to a model for thinking, she contrasted Plato and his intellectual descendants with Socrates. Where Plato offered “Truth” with a capital “T,” a blueprint, an action plan, a set of prearranged categories, for the good society, Socrates asked questions. He was, said Arendt, a “gadfly,” a “midwife,” an “electric ray.” She pointed out that he did not claim access to the truth or wisdom. He was not a philosopher for “he teaches nothing and has nothing to teach.” Instead, he devoted himself to getting a relatively small circle of men in ancient Athens to get into the practice of thinking — to wake up.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/750/1*zhnk2H5S18pBPMw0CR13tg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Closing evening for educators at camp (Images property of Deborah E. Bicknell Consulting Services LLC, Ajay Noronha, or Daniel Noah Moses).</figcaption></figure><p>People who are awake won’t be swayed easily by efforts to control them. Once they have real practice thinking, the likelihood is that they will keep thinking. Thinking will become part of who they are. Like Socrates, they will get out of the cave and into the community. Like Socrates, they will engage in dialogue in the public square.</p><p>To strengthen the capacity for thinking means getting uncomfortable and disturbing what was previously taken for granted. It means education that is open-ended, not a predetermined step in an organizing strategy. Such practices of thinking require dialogue with oneself and with “the other.” They take attention, commitment, and constant practice. They are practices of self-care and freedom.<a href="#_edn16">xvi</a></p><p>An organization built around dialogue and community cannot thrive or reach its potential if it constantly alienates people who gave their hearts to it. Talking together, feeling together, thinking together, engaging with one another across lines of radical difference, is not the end of anything. But it is a start.</p><p>The kind of work that I’ve been talking about grows from trust and commitment. Success depends upon the freely chosen commitment of people over time — on a continuity, a deepening, an enlargement, of relationships. This practice of dialogue, of “peace-building,” of “conflict transformation,” of “transformative education,” of “dialogue based experiential education,” of “the moral imagination,” of freedom itself, starts with self-care and the self in community and moves outward toward increasingly distant “others.” It is based on a faith that, like all faith, remains unproven: if given the opportunity, human beings can learn from one another and grow in ways that surprise even ourselves; that we can be simultaneously rooted and citizens of the world; that given the appropriate conditions, empathy, combined with the force of the better argument, the fuller picture of realities and needs, will, over the longer run, win out.<a href="#_edn17">xvii</a></p><p>This kind of work, I believe, is an essential contribution, a service, similar to that which Socrates rendered to his fellow citizens — who eventually sentenced him to death.<a href="#_ednref17">xvii</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/750/1*C1OJJ9ZGQzQqJO_xyXvHkw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Acadia National Park (Images property of Deborah E. Bicknell Consulting Services LLC, Ajay Noronha, or Daniel Noah Moses).</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Endnotes:</strong></p><p>i When I left my position with Seeds of Peace in May of 2021, I signed an agreement with the organization that gave me explicit permission to publicly articulate what I’ve learned through my work. This essay is part of that effort. I dedicate the essay to the wonderful, dedicated, educators, artists, community leaders, and supporters with whom I’ve worked with over these years (those who are named here and those who are not). It’s difficult to find the words to express my gratitude to the members of the 2019 Seeds of Peace “design session” and to my dear friends and colleagues who worked so hard, with kindness and imagination, to build community and create experiences that touched people’s lives: Deb Bicknell, Mohammed Isleem, Meenakshi Chaabra, Pious Ali, Ajay Noronha, Karen Abuzant, Ismail Mukbil, Haya Shapira, Sulaiman Khatib, Oraib Waari, Islam Manasra, Iddo Felsenthal, Steven and Linda Brion-Meisels, Tareq Maassarani, Peggy Smith, Inessa Shishmanyan, Maria Ireland, Doc Miller, Barbara O’Brien, Aaron Shneyer, Ami Yares, Micah Hendler, Mira Awad, Hanoch Piven, Arnon Naor, Nabil Kayali, Steve Schuit, Marsha Greenberg, Helen Sturgis-Bright, Amany Shenouda, Molly Josephs, Yousef Bashir, Jill Diamond, Lisa Santiago, Muzhda Ghulam, James Ford, Nishat Alikhan, Fatma Fouad, Allyson Bachta, Hannah Morin, and Rachel Brophy; for the GATHER team that I loved being a part of during my last years with the organization; for the admin/finance team, for many colleagues across departments whom I deeply appreciate (again, this list is incomplete and inadequate as an expression of my respect and gratitude). I send a special shout out to Margie and Jim Arsham and the home hospitality hosts, to the Bath boaters who welcomed us in Maine each summer session, and to Anne Germanacos, for their deeply appreciated support. I thank Celia Kutz, Deb Bicknell, Ned Lazarus, Kevin Brosnan, and John Summers for reading drafts of this essay and offering critical feedback. Whatever faults remain are mine alone. I thank my family and my old friends who put up so long with my single-minded focus. I look forward to continuing in new ways with family, friends, and colleagues as we “make the road by walking.”</p><p><a href="#_ednref2">ii</a> See Hannah Arendt. <em>The Life of the Mind</em>: New York: Harcourt, Inc., 1977.</p><p><a href="#_ednref3">iii</a> In a recent article about Seeds of Peace, Lazarus is quoted as saying: “’We [in the peace field] don’t have illusions that this somehow by itself can end the occupation or end violence — reality is much larger than what we’re able to do,’ he cautioned. “Yet on the individual level, the organization seems to have left a mark.” See Jess Rohan. “All Talk,” <em>Jewish Currents</em> (Spring 2021), p. 21.</p><p><a href="#_ednref4">iv</a> The American sociologist, C. Wright Mills coined the term “the sociological imagination.” For Lederach’s quotation, see John Paul Lederach. <em>The Moral Imagination: The Art and Soul of Building Peace</em>. Oxford, MA: Oxford University Press, 2005. I’ll include the specific pages for this quotation when I again get my hands on a hard copy of the book.</p><p><a href="#_ednref5">v</a> I later very much enjoyed working with GATHER because my colleagues and the Fellows were wonderful but my larger point remains. With all that made them wonderful — within a healthier organization, with greater attention to relationships and community, greater coordination and integration with work on the ground, and sustained follow-through, we could have done so much more.</p><p><a href="#_ednref6">vi</a> Rohan, p. 26.</p><p><a href="#_ednref7">vii</a> Ibid, pp. 24–25.</p><p><a href="#_ednref8">viii</a> For what turned out to be the final DL art project, the DL’s left a painting on the wall of a road and people walking with the words: “we make the road by walking.”</p><p><a href="#_ednref9">ix</a> As the philosopher John Dewey puts it, “<em>. . </em>.the most important factor in the training of good mental habits consists in acquiring the attitude of suspended conclusion, and in mastering the various methods of searching for new materials to corroborate or to refute the first suggestions that occur. To maintain the state of doubt and to carry on systematic and protracted inquiry — these are the essentials of thinking.” See John Dewey. <em>How We Think</em>. Mineola, New York: Dover Publications, 1997 [1910], pp. 12–13.</p><p><a href="#_ednref10">x</a> In the last years, I have worked with my friend Keren Ketko Ayali, an Israeli teacher, teacher trainer, scholar, and advocate of “activist pedagogy” as she finishes her doctorate on this topic. Working with her raises questions for me about how to approach civic education, how to encourage student engagement and activism without imposing particular political agendas. There is much more to be said here, much more to explore and talk about.</p><p><a href="#_ednref11">xi</a> See Anand Giridharadas. <em>Winners Take All: The Elite Charade of Changing the World</em>. New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 2018.</p><p><a href="#_ednref12">xii</a> While recently finishing a book about the role of fungi in the complexities of the ecosystems of the planet we call home, I had insight into how much damage human beings do to both the natural and social ecosystems that sustain us. See Merlin Sheldrake. <em>Entangled Life: How Fungi Make Our Worlds, Change Our Minds &amp; Shape Our Futures.</em> New York: Random House, 2020.</p><p>xiii For example, see Sami Al Jundi and Jen Marlowe. <em>The Hour of Sunlight: One Palestinian’s Journey from Prisoner to Peacemaker. </em>New York: Bold Type Books, 2011. The book covers events that took place before I went full-time with Seeds of Peace, so I know of them second and third hand. But I can recount what I witnessed first-hand where the organization treated staff members in ways similar to how Sami Al Jundi was treated.</p><p><a href="#_ednref14">xiv</a> For a powerful analysis of the mind-numbing bureaucratic work common today even as so much work is done with machines, see David Graeber<em>. Bullshit Jobs: A Theory.</em> New York: Simon and Schuster, 2018.</p><p><a href="#_ednref15">xv</a> Arendt, p. 191.</p><p><a href="#_ednref16">xvi</a> My references to self-care and freedom are references to the work of the twentieth-century thinker Michel Foucault. When I started with Seeds of Peace back in 2004, I was immersed in the work of the German philosopher Jurgen Habermas. I viewed Seeds of Peace as a “Habermasian experiment.” Foucault and Habermas are often seen as opponents. But I’ve come to see how much the later Foucault complements the work of Habermas — particularly Foucault’s writings about “care for the self” and his essay, “What is Enlightenment?”</p><p><a href="#_ednref17">xvii</a> I find the ideal of “rooted cosmopolitanism,” which I’ve borrowed from the philosopher Kwame Anthony Appiah to be very helpful when approaching questions of identity. From my perspective, Appiah is one of the most insightful writers on such subjects. For example, see Kwame Anthony Appiah. <em>The Ethics of Identity</em>. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press, 2005; <em>Cosmopolitanism: Ethics in a World of Strangers</em>. New York: W.W. Norton &amp; Company, 2010; and <em>The Lies that Bind: Rethinking Identity</em>. New York: Liveright Publishing Company, 2018. I also find the philosopher Martha Nussbaum’s particularly helpful — for her work on the role of the emotions, on the role of the liberal arts and the fine arts, on the critical role of dialogue, and for how she writes about human flourishing. Here’s a recent talk that she gave where she touches on themes at the heart of what I’ve written in this essay. Like Mary, the fictional professor in Homeland Elegies, Nussbaum talks of the “aggressive othering” and “apocalyptic thinking” that has made it increasingly difficult in recent years to engage in dialogue across lines of difference. See<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u-lk7pnoHYk">:</a> <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u-lk7pnoHYk">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u-lk7pnoHYk</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*IWxDn4Gg508mys4-1PGI6A.jpeg" /><figcaption>13th Lake in spring (Images property of Deborah E. Bicknell Consulting Services LLC, Ajay Noronha, or Daniel Noah Moses).</figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b54b4c9b631c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Sulaiman Khatib, “The Moral Imagination,” and What We Need Now]]></title>
            <link>https://danielmoses36.medium.com/sulaiman-khatib-the-moral-imagination-and-what-we-need-now-69f3dc1c2ec?source=rss-dbf020efe563------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/69f3dc1c2ec</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[peace]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[stories-and-culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[israel-palestine-conflict]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[justice]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[book-review]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Daniel Noah Moses]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 24 Jul 2021 23:46:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-10-14T01:37:07.461Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0gfNG4pf93uZiJSkdwrVrQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>photograph by Maria Ireland</figcaption></figure><p><em>“Transcending violence is forged by the capacity to generate, mobilize and build the moral imagination. . . .stated simply, the moral imagination requires the capacity to imagine ourselves in a web of relationships that includes our enemies</em><strong><em>; </em></strong><em>the ability to sustain a paradoxical curiosity that embraces complexity without reliance on dualistic polarity; the fundamental belief in and pursuit of the creative act; and the acceptance of the inherent risk of stepping into the mystery of the unknown that lies beyond the far too familiar landscape of violence” (John Paul Lederach, The Moral Imagination: The Art and Soul of Building Peace, 2005).</em></p><p>Before he turned fifteen, my friend Sulaiman Khatib — “Souli” — stabbed an Israeli soldier and was put into an Israeli prison for ten years. As one of the founders of Combatants for Peace, today he works with Palestinians and Israelis who have exchanged weapons for tools of non-violent social transformation. I’ve been thinking a lot about Souli as I follow the relentless conflict and social turbulence in The Middle East and the United States and finish a recently published book, <strong><em>in this place together: A Palestinian’s Journey to Collective Liberation,</em></strong> about his life.</p><p>Souli grew up in Hizma, a Palestinian village near what some consider expanding Israeli neighborhoods of a “unified” Jerusalem and others consider “settlements” because they are built on lands that Israel conquered in 1967. Years after Souli got out of prison, the Israeli government seized Ta’mira, part of his family’s land, to build “The Wall”/“The Security Fence.” While tending to the olive trees before the land was placed out of reach, his father suffered a heart attack from which he never recovered. Like his father, Souli is deeply rooted in the land. At the same time, he has learned to travel unfathomable distances while staying in the same physical place.</p><p>Now a man in his late forties with tightly coiled black hair, Souli keeps his facial hair scruffy, wears faded shirts with holes in them, and rolls up the bottoms of his faded jeans. There’s something unusually graceful about how he holds himself and he moves with a sense of freedom that one rarely sees among “grown-ups.” When speaking English, he peppers his words with Arabic and Hebrew. I’ve seen him take a flute from his pocket and play. At an artists’ retreat in the desert of Mitzpe Ramon in June of 2017, I watched as an ultra-Orthodox Jewish man in his sixties, grey-bearded, in a dark suit, a black kippah on his head, wrapped Souli in a bear hug.</p><p>In their book, Souli and his co-author Penina Eilberg-Schwarz tell the story of Souli’s life before prison, in prison, and in the decades after his release. It’s a story of imagination, empathy, courage and growth — a story of hope in yet another moment of despair.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*37V_O-JweMECLADjVg-7mg.png" /></figure><p>I have a close relationship to such despair. For eleven years — 2006 to 2017 — I lived in Jerusalem. For more than twenty, I’ve worked with educators, artists, community leaders, university students, and youth from across lines of conflict in the Middle East, South Asia, the Caucasus, Europe, and the United States. I have felt levels of connection across chasms of experience and perspective and had moments of clarity and “collective effervescence” that inspire me with hope at least on a small scale. But the basis for such hope can feel like droplets in a river flowing in the contrary direction. In this context, I see Souli as somebody who has achieved something exceptionally rare — which happens to be at the root of peace-building, of “conflict transformation,” of “leadership,” of successful democratic civic engagement, of social movements in the spirit of Martin Luther King Jr. that transfigure the texture of human life along with social, political, and individual possibilities.</p><p>To put this another way, Souli embodies a bundle of values, practices, capacities, that compose “the moral imagination.” You can see this in how he interacts with people — for example, with Israelis at checkpoints, in dialogue circles, and on panel discussions. You can see it in how he engages with the infighting in his own society and across the overlapping circles of people who work in different, sometimes contradictory, ways, on behalf of Palestinians. You can see it in how he approaches the past in all of its complexity, what he sees on the horizon, and how he is moving ahead.</p><p>Jewish-Israelis and Palestinians inhabit the same land but in parallel realities that seldom touch. Even in the city of Jerusalem, they live in different cities. Take ten different kinds of tours of Jerusalem and you’ll find yourself in ten different universes. Across the region, the extremes of emotional geography trump physical distance. At the Cave of the Patriarchs in Hebron— also known to Jews as The Cave of the Double Tombs and to Muslims as the Sanctuary of Ibrahim/Abraham — Palestinians and Israelis (Jews, Muslims, Christians) visit the graves of revered common ancestors like estranged relatives who can barely stomach the presence of “the other.”</p><p>For Palestinians navigating checkpoints, walls, and the bureaucratic controls of the Israeli State, Jewish-Israelis are the occupiers, the oppressors. For Jewish-Israelis, Palestinians are another enemy in a long line of enemies stretching back thousands of years, and the battle against them is yet another battle in a familiar series of battles to survive.</p><p>Most Jewish Israelis experienced the missiles that Hamas launched in May as part of an undifferentiated war against them. They could not see the escalation of violence, which took place during the Islamic holy days of Ramadan and the Eid, as it looked from “the other side.” During the holidays, Palestinian Muslims in Jerusalem usually gather at The Old City’s Damascus Gate; this year Israeli police prevented them. In the weeks before Hamas launched missiles, Palestinian families in Sheikh Jarrah, a neighborhood in Jerusalem just below French Hill, faced eviction from their homes based on lopsided laws that favor Jews at the expense of Palestinians. Of course, I completely condemn Hamas launching missiles. At the same time, if one wants to understand the dynamics on the ground it’s critical to examine what Israelis are usually oblivious to — the realities that Palestinians who live so close by confront. Too often Israelis are blind to their own power, the inequalities between them and the Palestinians, the impact their government’s policy has on Palestinian lives. Israeli media does not consistently cover how right-wing Jewish groups with the support of the Israeli government continually expand control, extract resources, and inflict suffering on Palestinians in ways that are relentless and palpably unfair.</p><p>In their weakness, The Palestinians possess something that Jewish Israelis crave: the power of recognition. When Palestinian leaders like Hanan Ashrawi call Israel a “Western colonial enterprise” and “the remnants of Western colonialism,” they imply that, like the French in Algeria, Israel will vanish. To many Jews, this understandably conjures up fears of annihilation — of being driven to the sea. When Palestinians argue that Jews are “only” a religion and deny a Jewish peoplehood, they deny what Jewish Israelis need to feel safe and to feel that there is a partner on “the other side.” In his strength, Souli has developed a rare capacity for generosity that enables him to make room for Jewish connection to the land and Jewish history in the land. By doing this, he opens up space for the future. In their book, Penina touches on how, for some, Souli has strayed too far from his roots. From what I have experienced, though, no matter how much time Souli spends in city coffee shops, no matter how far his mode of existence or ways of thinking wander from mainstream Palestinian models, his strength derives from how deeply rooted he is in who he is, how he has grown and how he keeps growing. His strength is based in how he is both rooted <em>and</em> a citizen of the world.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*rx1oU7I7RJk7ocnGjWAXQw.jpeg" /><figcaption>photograph by Ajay Noronha</figcaption></figure><p>Souli’s strength coupled with his intellectual curiosity (desire to understand) inspire him to explore where most Palestinians, most Israelis, most people, don’t go. Once, several years ago, at his request, we went together to Masada. He has told me about Palestinian families in the south of the West Bank that light candles on Friday night. We have shared stories of Palestinian friends who know of Jewish ancestors just a few generations back. He often talks about the common culture that he shares with Israeli Jews whose families come from Arab countries. Trained as an historian, I’ve shared my perspective on that craft (which walks a delicate line between science and poetry). We’ve explored ways to enlarge and shift “narratives.”</p><p>The past is not “history.” The past includes everything that has ever happened; it exists as an incomprehensible infinity. People in societies, in communities, “make” history by selecting and taking care of particular facts, specific memories, while letting others swirl along. History is what people make of the past — what they make from the past. Patriotic narratives use neat categories and clean lines to keep people focused in particular ways. They brush aside or cover up the messiness — the complexity — of the past. If we look there are always underground narratives in the corners, in hidden places, in the origins of words and place names, in borrowed melodies, in shared foods, in old habits and rituals, in conversations with people about what they heard around the kitchen table growing up. The land has stories to tell, too. These underground narratives with their “mixed-upness,” their complexity, has potential, I believe, to challenge the neat platitudes of mass produced history that separates “us” from “them.” This messiness that I’m talking about has the potential, I believe, to encourage the moral imagination. One memory continually returns to me from when I was living in Jerusalem and Souli and Penina were working on their book and he invited me and my colleague Maria to meet them in Battir, a Palestinian village in the hills outside of Bethlehem.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3uF6D11zjerU6_t06XAbIQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>photograph by Maria Ireland</figcaption></figure><p>I had already visited the nearby settlement of Betar a few years before and got the connection. Betar is named after the village where, under the rebel leader Bar Kochba, the Jews took their last stand against the Romans about sixty years after the destruction of The Second Temple, a hundred and thirty years or so into “The Common Era” (known in the Christian calendar, which has become the “secular” calendar for human beings today on this planet, as A.D., “the year of Our Lord”). The residents of today’s Betar are large ultra-Orthodox Jewish families being priced out of Jerusalem. As Betar grows, it expands into the land of the Palestinian villages below.</p><p>The Palestinian village of Battir is built into the side of a nearby mountain with breathtaking views of the old train tracks winding through the valley between Jaffa/Tel Aviv and Jerusalem. Battir — not nearby Betar — is on the actual site of the ancient village of Betar where Bar Kokhba and his army fought the Romans in that final battle.</p><p>Souli’s visit to Battir that day was part of a larger quest to explore Jewish roots in the land. He is fascinated by traces of Jewish history, traces of Jewish practices, remnants of culture rooted in the land once known as Canaan, a land that the Jews and Palestinians of today still unequally share.</p><p>Walking in Battir, one is transported back to a quieter time. The cultivated land is terraced and organized by the placement of stones. Old stones have been stacked in various configurations, abandoned, and rebuilt, for generations. As we walked up and down the village that day, Souli pointed out the ancient irrigation system that allotted each farmer water in a fair and systematic way.</p><p>According to historians, in the summer of 135 C.E. the Roman armies laid siege to Betar. The siege eventually ended in a blood soaked battle. According to some sources, after the Roman victory, The Emperor Hadrian was presented with Bar Kokhba’s severed head.</p><p>Things did not end well for Bar Kokhba or his army, just as they did not end well for those last Jewish fighters at Masada. For centuries Jews of the Diaspora more or less ignored such defeats in favor of stories and traditions that make a portable Jewish peoplehood possible. In contrast, Israelis have amplified the voices of those in Jewish history who fought violently to their deaths to keep the land. For most Diaspora Jews, Bar Kokhba has been a minor historical figure passed over quickly, if at all, but in Israel, he is a great national hero of armed resistance. His name is everywhere. My first apartment on French Hill in Jerusalem overlooking the Jordan Valley was on Bar Kokhba Street. Israelis built the new Betar where they did for a reason; the settlement is spreading out according to plan.</p><p>Yet walking with Souli that day in Battir, we saw outlines of refreshing possibilities. “The people here, beyond the politics, they are filled with stories,” he told me, smiling. “Some of them feel related to these ancient ruins. Just imagine that back in the days of Bar Kokhba some Jews hid in the caves after the Roman beat them. They stayed and had children. . .”</p><p>Whether this specific story about survivors of a battle almost two thousand years ago is accurate is besides the point. Underground narratives certainly exist with potential as the foundation for a shared future liberated from the constraints, suffering, and injustices of the status quo. Today Battir and Betar exist as neighbors at least in geographical terms. The fates of Jewish Israelis and Palestinians (Israeli citizens, those in Jerusalem, Gaza, and The West Bank) are intertwined. I believe with conviction that Souli points in the right direction and that the book he and Penina have written is very much worth reading — especially now: with striking changes taking place in Israel and Palestine; as dangerous clowns and charlatans compete for the limelight across our planet; as true courage has become so difficult to notice; as meaningful communication across lines of difference has become increasingly rare. In his love for a diverse range of people on “both sides,” in his love for the land, in his exercise of “the moral imagination,” Souli encompasses larger, richer, more inclusive, more just, narratives of the past and visions for the future. His message — relevant far beyond the Palestinian-Israeli conflict — is illuminated by the flames of our age when a disturbing number of people ignore or actively reject what he stands for. I hope this book will be translated into Arabic and Hebrew. I hope it will reach a large North American audience. <em>If only those of us who celebrate his achievement could distill and distribute what Sulaiman Khatib has learned so far in his life— we’d be getting somewhere.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=69f3dc1c2ec" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Suggestion for Those Wondering How The United States of America Can Flourish, or Even Survive…]]></title>
            <link>https://danielmoses36.medium.com/a-suggestion-for-those-wondering-how-the-united-states-of-america-can-flourish-or-even-survive-4605505125c2?source=rss-dbf020efe563------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4605505125c2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[conflict]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[partisan-divide]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[biden-vs-trump]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[covid-19-crisis]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Daniel Noah Moses]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 01 Feb 2021 15:54:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-07-24T16:01:33.116Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong><em>A Suggestion for Those Wondering How The United States of America Will Flourish, or Even Survive, if We Can Barely Talk to One Another</em></strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/750/1*wM_V6gqDWX4cOU5gPrXE7w.jpeg" /><figcaption>13th Lake, North River, New York</figcaption></figure><p>Even as President Biden calls for unity, decency, and the pursuit of the common good, the public square in the country he leads remains a devastated mess. It has become so difficult to engage with people who have fundamentally different opinions on issues close to the heart. It has become infuriating. It has become so painful to engage with “those people” who repel you, who scare you, who believe that what you call day is night, who celebrate as heroes those you consider villains, who spout what you consider absurdities or gross violations of common sense. Engagement with “the other” can also be beautiful. It can be deeply transformative. But that takes courage and imagination. It takes work.</p><p>For the last twenty years, I’ve worked to bring together people across lines of conflict — Arabs and Israelis, Indians, Pakistanis and Afghans, Turkish and Greek Cypriots, Armenians, Azerbaijanis, and Turks, and others traumatized by violence and fear of “the other.” Now the social turbulence and breakdown of trust in the United States has turned this country, too, into a conflict zone.</p><p>Like peoples in conflict abroad, Americans inhabit separate worlds that draw on different sources of information and opposing pictures of reality, some of which are contaminated by high levels of distortion and untruth. Divided into market segments, the analytics of our lives are tracked, consolidated, and manipulated with precise fine-tuning in ways that add fire to misunderstanding. The survival of self-government is in doubt. In this context, I offer a suggestion.</p><p>Congress recently passed the Nita M. Lowey Middle East Partnership for Peace Act, which will distribute $250 million over five years to initiatives that support Palestinians and Israelis in building a better future. As John Lyndon, the executive director of The Alliance for Middle East Peace (ALLMEP), the organization that lobbied for the passage of this act, explains: “with Israelis and Palestinians more polarized than ever, this Fund can radically scale programs designed to upend that reality, creating the relationships, movements and leaders that any just and equitable peace depends upon.” If the Federal government can do this overseas — why not at home, where similar dynamics are at play?</p><p>In this spirit, I propose a national fund to support tangible projects on the ground that bring together Americans from across the spectrum of race, ethnicity, class, religion, geography, and worldview; integrate these projects with facilitated opportunities to get to know one another, to inspire curiosity and connection, to build trust, to develop a larger stock of shared reality, to practice the skills necessary to engage meaningfully across our various divides.</p><p>I envision the federal government’s role as a catalyst — setting the tone, creating a framework for funding, providing consistent support. The initiative and effort must come from citizens across society. Those who have unusual sway over the opinions of others share a particular responsibility. At this moment, decision makers in media and social media companies play a pivotal role. In different ways, so do educators, activists, religious leaders, community leaders, business leaders, scientific authorities, journalists and pundits, elected officials, famous musicians, stars of the small and big screens, best-selling authors, sports figures, artists who have an audience, young people with a following on social media, and other “influencers.” Groups of people form networks based on common identity or interest, on location, on relationship and trust. Success depends upon earning the trust of a small number of committed individuals who are nodes of the various networks which, from a different angle, form public spheres, social eco-systems, and communities.</p><p>Most of my work overseas has focused on educators, artists, and university students. I’ve also worked with social entrepreneurs and activists, and with people doing a diverse set of projects — stewarding shared natural resources, transforming the culture of hospitals, reforming government, producing children’s television programming. As the lead on a set of programs for Palestinian and Israeli educators funded by USAID, I saw how people working across lines of conflict need consistent and steady support from government leaders. With the Biden administration it looks like those of us doing similar work in the United States could have what we lacked in The Middle East.</p><p>Education is at the heart of what I’m proposing. Too many Americans understandably feel themselves at the mercy of forces beyond their control. We live within rationalized bureaucratic systems that pay lip service to values of democracy while doing so much to undermine them. For educators to carry out what I would like to ask them to do, they must get a taste of what it is to be part of a reflective, democratic, learning community. Meanwhile, we must commit at all levels of government and society to making media literacy, science literacy, and civic education priorities at the elementary, secondary, and university level, and through a range of highly accessible public outreach initiatives for adults of all ages. For American self-government to survive, citizens must have a chance to practice active listening, to ask questions, to enlarge our scope of empathy, to interrogate sources, to exercise our imaginations, to think critically, to become comfortable with uncertainty, complexity, and nuance.</p><p>I understand that my argument here might seem unrealistic in the midst of a global pandemic that so severely restricts sociability. But there are ways around this. For the short-term, we can work remotely; at the same time, with the help of public libraries, schools, universities, museums, local governments, local non-profits, media outlets, and business leaders, we can engage safely in person until it becomes possible to meet once again in the ways that so many of us miss.</p><p>Conflict is intrinsic to human existence. What matters is how people handle it. The goal of bringing together Americans from across lines of conflict is to nurture relationships that make room for healthier conflict, while weeding out distortions and untruths. It is about strengthening the capacity to continue even when things get tough. I don’t want to distract from the political battles that will be waged. I’m arguing that we, members of this society, citizens of this republic — the broadest possible “we” — must make a real effort to raise the quality of relationship, of discussion, of <em>learning.</em> I’m arguing that we must improve<em> </em>the practices and systems around the formation of public opinion (which is what learning looks like in the aggregate). I’m arguing for expanding the broad middle in all directions while staying clear-eyed and firm about what is out of bounds.</p><p>Americans must, of course, address the global pandemic along with pressing systemic issues: the climate crisis; racial inequalities; inequalities of wealth, resources, and opportunity; the regulation of social media; the “re-embedding” of the market to be in synch with the values of equality and justice embodied by the American promise. But none of this is possible if fellow citizens cannot even talk things through.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4605505125c2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>