<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Daniel Smith-Rowsey on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Daniel Smith-Rowsey on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@danielsmithrowsey?source=rss-eebf3c706f43------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 19:56:32 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@danielsmithrowsey/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[If It’s Big Enough, No One Can Be Held Accountable For It]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@danielsmithrowsey/if-its-big-enough-no-one-can-be-held-accountable-for-it-7bf8f481c6c5?source=rss-eebf3c706f43------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7bf8f481c6c5</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[financial-crisis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pandemic]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[covid19]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[accountability]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[coronavirus]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Daniel Smith-Rowsey]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 27 Mar 2020 18:33:19 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-03-27T18:33:19.766Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/420/1*thrPyEOCXl4K3HvY-Mab1A.png" /></figure><p>The Trump administration surprised many liberals and Democrats by betting that whenever it “reopens” America, it will not be held responsible for any COVID-19 deaths that occur afterward. The White House seems to be betting that the executive branch can “play” the pandemic in much the same way that the rest of America’s institutions “play” any other society-wide problem — accepting credit for any success while denying blame for any failure. Liberals might be less surprised by this if they recalled that large institutions’ lack of accountability is the dominant trend of the first two decades of the 21st century. Size matters; if everyone has been part of something, no one can ever be blamed for that thing. “Too big to fail” isn’t just for Wall Street; it’s for <em>every</em> situation and institution that has insinuated itself into American life. And it’s also relatively new.</p><p>This may come as a surprise to younger readers, but back in the 1990s, institutions were often held accountable for bad practices. That decade began with banks being held responsible for predatory lending practices (ending the “S&amp;L scandal”). Israel and Palestine signed the Oslo accords in 1993, indicating mutual accountability. The National Rifle Association advocated gun control, signing on to the assault weapons ban as part of the crime bill of 1994. Afterward, crime rates plunged throughout America, most visibly in New York City and especially Times Square, which went from undignified to Disneyfied. Pharmaceutical companies became bound by new and real regulations, even as tobacco companies became poster children for corporate accountability, as was well known by the time of the Al Pacino film <em>The Insider</em> (1999). At the same time, PG&amp;E became poster children for public environmental accountability, as was well known by the time of the Julia Roberts film <em>Erin Brockovich</em> (2000). Meanwhile, the federal government successfully pursued an anti-trust case against America’s most profitable company, Microsoft. Oh, and did I mention that President Bill Clinton and Speaker Newt Gingrich worked together to bring the national deficit from more than $1,000,000,000,000 (that’s a trillion dollars) to $0? In short, problems got solved. Maybe not everyone was happy with every result, but large-scale malfeasance often led to salutary consequences.</p><p>Not only do we not solve problems anymore, but we use the size of problems as the reason no one can solve them. Partly this is because of the red-state-blue-state rhetorical division which began in November 2000, whereby both major political parties fund-raise based on charging the other party with a lack of accountability…that never comes. But it’s more than that. In one sense, when America’s banks offered way too many unrealistic mid-2000s loans and mortgages to low-income borrowers, the banks were following a home-ownership-promoting President, George W. Bush, who had very successfully promoted unaccountability in everything from deficit spending to ignoring Osama Bin Laden to fighting in Iraq under false pretenses to Abu Ghraib to Guantanamo to pollution deregulation to Hurricane Katrina. But in another sense, the banks were simply following larger trends in unaccountability, from the Catholic Church’s pedophilia scandal to Israel’s eschewing of the Oslo accords to Major League Baseball’s widespread steroid use to the NRA’s new embrace of assault weapons to Silicon Valley’s rewriting of the monopoly rules that brought down Bill Gates (allowing Google to buy YouTube, Apple to dominate MP3 players, etc).</p><p>The key history of the financial crisis is Andrew Ross Sorkin’s book “Too Big to Fail,” but many people missed Sorkin’s key takeaway: it’s not only the sheer size (or market value) of the company, but rather its insinuation into American lives. 80% of restaurants fail during their first year, but McDonald’s and Starbucks always do fine. Any local car dealership may go out of business, but Detroit’s Big Three car companies cannot suffer serious consequences because of their associated employees throughout the country. A gun dealer might fold up shop, but suicides and massacres will continue unabated because the weapon industry plays hardball (and gets great free advertising from Hollywood). A given surveillance company might close forever, but Silicon Valley will keep gathering and monetizing all of our “Big Data” and surveilling us. <em>Breaking Bad</em>’s Walter White can fritter away his life, but Big Pharma can’t fail because — all these things considered — we’re now addicted to opioids.</p><p>Accountability is always for a few fall guys, or what Bush once called, in the context of Abu Ghraib, “a few bad apples.” And so the old white male pooh-bahs of banks, Baseball, the Big Three, Big Pharma, Big Data, and the Bush administration sit around smoke-filled rooms toasting their successes and complaining about their yachts. As Paul Krugman observed long ago, they rigged the game so that it’s heads they win, tails we lose. In the 90s<em>,</em> people talked about the next Big Tobacco, the next industry that Americans would no longer tolerate. Nobody talks that way anymore. Banks make ridiculous loans, crime festers, guns proliferate, opioids destroy, climate change worsens, the deficit explodes, and no one can quite be held accountable for any of it exactly because everyone has in some way contributed to it. America is an apartment building run by landlords who insinuate themselves into every single aspect of their tenants’ lives while refusing to make the slightest of repairs.</p><p>Sure, two decades of unaccountability has generated some discontent with untouchable large institutions, as seen in the populism that powered Bernie Sanders and Donald Trump, as well as in #blacklivesmatter and #metoo. But somehow this never quite translates to defenestration of leaders. Show me one police department that changed captains because of Black Lives Matter. Sure, #metoo brought down Harvey Weinstein and probably Jeff Epstein, but look at how depraved those two men were. Anyone who has finished Ronan Farrow’s #1 bestseller “Catch and Kill” is well aware that most predators have escaped accountability, not least because of powerful institutions that Americans aren’t ready to give up, like NBC News.</p><p>This is the full and all-important context of President Trump’s (non)response to the pandemic. Perhaps one of Trump’s key advisers noticed that in some strange way, the ubiquity of COVID-19 resembles the ubiquity of guns, crime, racism, surveillance, persecution of religion, rape culture, predatory loans, and so many other things that are everybody’s fault and, therefore, nobody’s fault. In the 21st century, systematic problems equate to systematic unaccountability. Liberals ask: but <em>how</em> can the GOP let millions of Americans die? The answer: because the GOP and Fox News will point to various liberal governors’ responses as evidence that the pandemic was liberals’ fault. You heard it here first.</p><p>Even without coronavirus, Trump and the GOP are too big to fail. (In 1964 and 1984, a major candidate could lose 44 or more states; that cannot happen now when at least 40 states are locked for one of the two major parties, leaving ten or less “in play.”) Trump’s 2016 strategy was to present himself as the guy turning the page from an old corrupt era. His 2020 strategy, whether he knows it or not, is to prolong into a third decade the great era of unaccountability. We will have to see if the pandemic motivates Americans to <em>really</em> turn the page on two decades of public neglect, and finally hold large institutions and their leaders accountable.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7bf8f481c6c5" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Love In The Time of Corona]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@danielsmithrowsey/love-in-the-time-of-corona-b7cd4759cbf5?source=rss-eebf3c706f43------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b7cd4759cbf5</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[autism-spectrum-disorder]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[garcía-márquez]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[coronavirus]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[autism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Daniel Smith-Rowsey]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 12 Mar 2020 17:31:30 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-03-12T17:36:18.294Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*UGgKhGn6YytsbOHnEozCWw.jpeg" /></figure><p>I love Gabriel Garcia-Marquez’s book “Love in the Time of Cholera” (an Oprah Book Club selection), although this is about a different kind of love. I’m only borrowing Gabo’s title, not the plot, no never the plot. Gabo’s too deep, I’m too shallow. My usual words have felt particularly hollow of late, what with all of our combined fears about the coronavirus. I mean, with everything else, what’s one severely autistic kid more or less?</p><p>I hear comparisons to Katrina (August-September 2005). I hear comparisons to H1N1 (2002) and Ebola (2010, 2014). But those don’t quite capture this moment. What I don’t hear, but what I feel, is the financial and part-existential crisis of September and October 2008. I’m not comparing stock market valuation here. I’m comparing the feeling of impending doom, the feeling of “hey, what if all THIS that a month ago was so important…what if all THIS just went away? What then?”</p><p>If everything stops, who to help first? Besides the actual victims and medical workers, who’s hurting most from a new era of “social distancing”? This week I saw a New York Times headline essentially saying “Feel Sorry For Airbnb Hosts.” As an Airbnb host, I’m guessing there are a <em>lot</em> of other professions that this pandemic is hitting harder, including restaurant workers, hotel workers, airline workers, airport workers, independent contractors, drivers, event planners, theater workers, personal trainers, home healthcare providers, social workers, bartenders, and about 400 jobs I haven’t thought of. We can’t imagine how this affects everyone at the margins; we can’t imagine changed margins.</p><p>For all our metrics and expertise, we’re still missing a lot. Facebook, Google, and Amazon know everything I say and do, how to do my job, my medical and every other kind of history, and that of almost every other American…and yet FB, G, and A still don’t know if a hypothetical Biden candidacy will have better odds of defeating Trump if it appeals to Bernie-level progressives OR McCain-level moderates. And yet FB, G, and A still don’t know how to best protect us in a pandemic. Thanks for everything, and thanks for nothing.</p><p>If we remember March 2020, I hope we remember that odd existential dread that drove us inside, where we were even <em>more</em> likely to stare at screens all day. (You know, like the one you’re reading this on.) Social media is in some ways less healthy than a coronavirus, exacerbating our worst tendencies and partisanship and need to blame people. Like you, I probably don’t yet have the virus, but I AM sick and tired of yet another 21st-century American problem that is everyone’s fault and no one’s fault (global warming, gun violence, medical costs, student debt, et cetera) and therefore the powers-that-be can and will defer accountability AGAIN. But if we don’t blame, if we spiritually hold together while holed up in our houses, what do we do? Watch the news and stream movies about pandemics? That <em>may</em> not exactly be helping us either.</p><p>Leaving the house is almost worse. You can feel the “I’m normal, are you?” looks on faces. It’s like movies and shows, but it isn’t. It’s like some scenes in <em>The Walking Dead</em>, but not really. Some strangers are still offering hands. (What. The. Fork?! Get that grubby germ paw away from me!) Life is still happening, but everything is in quotation marks. I was at my neurotypical kid’s school for the first half hour of class on Tuesday, as parents and aides looked at each other with a certain wary savvy.</p><p>Or maybe we’re all just feeling the constant feeling of…wait, where did that itch come from? Did I just feel an urge to cough because of phlegm or some other reason? Am I achier than usual or is that just normal? Whoa, phantom pain! Wait, it went away. Or did it? Ahhhhhhhhhhhh</p><p>Humanity may yet benefit from this pandemic, in the sense of smaller carbon footprints or greater urgency for better health care or in other ways. If we do benefit, it certainly won’t be because of anything you read or heard from any single person, me included. It’ll be because of a concatenation of calamities and conversations. I hope these at least continue online. What if this thing not only puts us in our houses but also cuts off all electricity? It’s one thing to be disabled, quite another to be dis-cabled. Here’s hoping Andrew Yang’s best robots will keep the lights on. Here’s hoping this pandemic eventually makes a great new Dick Wolf spinoff series called <em>Law &amp; Hoarder</em>.</p><p>Joking aside, this thing could get a lot worse, could potentially exert an unimaginable leveling effect on our population of elder people, like a mini-<em>Logan’s Run</em>. The news from Tom Hanks makes me imagine a world in which we look back fondly on the day Max Von Sydow died, remembering when it seemed novel for a 90-year-old celebrity to suddenly pass.</p><p>Ah, Max Von Sydow. He brought unexpected humor to melodramatic films and unexpected gravitas to funny films (<em>Strange Brew</em>, anyone?). There’s a line of his that has been ricocheting through my head ever since I started my blog. It’s from Ingmar Bergman’s one and only movie in English, sometimes called <em>The Touch</em>, sometimes called <em>Beroringen</em>. Von Sydow loses his wife’s (Bibi Andersson’s) affections to a Holocaust survivor (Elliott Gould). At a certain point, Von Sydow blurts in frustration at Andersson, “Suffering cannot go on and on! There has to be an end to it!” He may have meant mourning the Holocaust, or he may have meant other sufferings seen in the film. He most certainly was not talking about raising a severely autistic child.</p><p>But that’s how I’ve chosen to hear it. Suffering cannot go on and on…and yet, it does. Maybe another analogy is like a dripping faucet, or motorcycles that pass under your window. Somehow, after years of possible acclimatization, they can still cause at least some degree of suffering. So for nearly ten years, I’ve found myself disagreeing with Von Sydow, at least in my mind. Suffering can go on. And coronavirus? Maybe that’s just one more thing that can go on and on. Maybe that’s just another new normal that we never should have normalized.</p><p>They say that the sick are more vulnerable in a time of coronavirus, but I don’t believe my Dar is that kind of sick. I doubt he’s more susceptible than anyone else. On the other hand, what about his schoolmates in a place where every student has severe special needs? Maybe that’s why they called us on Monday that he “seemed a little warm” and “was tired.” As a courtesy, we picked him up right away, but the minute he got home we saw he was neither warm nor tired. And that pickup made us miss watching the quarantined cruise ship arrive in Oakland! Oh well.</p><p>If Dar does get the virus, I’ll be looking at the bright side. I suspect he and we will survive it, and build up immunity, and do our part to help our community be immune.</p><p>I find myself hugging and kissing him more lately. Just a feeling, I guess.</p><p>Last week, Dar had his “triennial” IEP. You might have thought I’d have been preparing you for this for months! Triennial! Once every three years! Wowowow!</p><p>For us, the day of a triennial is just another day that ends in Y (or, in our case, “why??”). “The good news is that Dar still qualifies for services!” Right. Duh. Love to all my marginal-case peeps out there, but Dar ain’t no marginal case.</p><p>The news is that he has regressed in some areas, improved in others. Whoop de woo.</p><p>At some point I may provide more details about Dar’s triennial. At some point I may get excited about my birthday this Saturday. But right now, does any of that really matter, with the world spinning off its axis?</p><p>Maybe we can all get around to those things we’ve always said we wanted more time for. For example, reading dense authors like Gabriel Garcia-Marquez. To finish this post, here’s a paragraph from “Love in the Time of Cholera”:</p><p>“Independence from Spain and then the abolition of slavery precipitated the conditions of honorable decadence in which Dr. Juvenal Urbino had been born and raised. The great old families sank into their ruined palaces in silence. Along the rough cobbled streets that had served so well in surprise attacks and buccaneer landings, weeds hung from the balconies and opened cracks in the whitewashed walls of even the best-kept mansions, and the only signs of life at two o’clock in the afternoon were languid piano exercises played in the dim light of siesta. Indoors, in the cool bedrooms saturated with incense, women protected themselves from the sun as if it were a shameful infection, and even at early Mass they hid their faces in their mantillas. Their love affairs were slow and difficult and were often disturbed by sinister omens, and life seemed interminable. At nightfall, at the oppressive moment of transition, a storm of carnivorous mosquitoes rose out of the swamps, and a tender breath of human shit, warm and sad, stirred the certainty of death in the depths of one’s soul.”</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b7cd4759cbf5" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[OK, Wokade]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@danielsmithrowsey/ok-wokade-624daa60e3e2?source=rss-eebf3c706f43------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/624daa60e3e2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[woke]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[america]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[political-correctness]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Daniel Smith-Rowsey]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 20 Dec 2019 14:56:53 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-12-23T16:34:41.103Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*nLparE0W_jJpwg97d6M2qA.png" /></figure><p>During the 2010s, we lived through ten fateful years of irreversible, steadily accelerating climate change, causing us to lose millions of species, probably forever. We progressed ten years toward the singularity while wondering if we were already living in a simulation. We absentmindedly browsed a lot of Instagram and YouTube as America’s richest people accrued a far greater percentage of American economic gains than they had in any other decade. We continued to fight a barely authorized, unfairly metastasized war on terror in some places, sometimes ignoring refugee crises from the same places. We handed over our future, our faith in the American Dream, certainly our privacy, and much else to Google, Apple, Facebook, and Amazon. We lived our first full decade with smartphones on our persons at all time, potential future cancer be damned. We saw superheroes, franchises, and streaming take over Hollywood and much of our dreams. A deeper dive into any and all of those topics could make a decent summary of the 2010s, but this isn’t that summary; this is about what Matthew Yglesias calls <a href="https://www.vox.com/2019/3/22/18259865/great-awokening-white-liberals-race-polling-trump-2020">The Great Awokening</a>, or the decade of getting woke, or, for simplicity’s sake, the “wokade.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*6VB0YpTM6ySyo1kiHMhRqg.png" /></figure><p>America’s change from 2009 to now may be most noticeable in the world of sports, which once prided itself on being “non-political” (notwithstanding exceptions like Muhammed Ali). Before 2010, no one in America’s four major sports was “out.” Before 2010, athletes were very, very rarely stigmatized for domestic violence or for prejudicial slurs. Before 2010, there was barely a conversation about transgender athletes competing in women’s sports. Before 2010, the pay disparity between the (always-winning) U.S. Women’s Soccer Team and the (always-losing) U.S. Men’s Soccer Team was barely mentioned. We’ve changed, not just amongst liberals and not just on social media, and much of that change is good. That should be, among other things, a comfort.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*oijdRe4ECkWbfi38qJkIxQ.png" /></figure><p>In November 2008, a majority of Californians voted to make same-sex marriage illegal. In 2009, Entertainment Weekly speculated about an all-female <em>Ghostbusters</em> by asking, “wouldn’t we all love to see how [Megan Fox] would look in that brown jumpsuit?” Before 2010, stand-up comedians and right-wing politicians regularly appeared on college campuses without cancellations or incidents. Through 2012, America’s major divas — Beyoncé, Katy Perry, Taylor Swift, Carrie Underwood, Alicia Keys, Kelly Clarkson — steadfastly refused to answer “yes” to the question “are you a feminist?” During Obama’s first term, the amount of famous celebrities talking about systematic police brutality was roughly zero.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*oDbu3EkcI0OJIeaMPuYWIQ.png" /></figure><p>The 2010s was many things, but politically and culturally, it was the decade of getting “woke.” Of course this term is now problematic, as are other terms; us “allies” aren’t supposed to be merely “virtue signaling.” Nonetheless, this piece sides with people like Damon Young in <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2019/11/29/opinion/woke-impeachment-trump.html">The New York Times</a> that “woke” is ultimately a reasonable term for what was once called “conscious,” and is not the same as “politically correct.” The American increase in so-called “political correctness” is often cited as a determinative factor in the election of President Donald Trump, but it is also the case that Trump himself, and his supporters, invoke their victimhood status, shame the “racist” (situationally defined), police language, and call for safe spaces. Their adoption of “politically correct” discursive devices demonstrates how far the “woke” goalposts have moved since 2010, even as Trump’s depredations should prompt a discussion about how much the goalpost move was “worth it.” In order to have that discussion, what follows is the story of the #wokade.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*l9B4Mvmi-mOEtR-TaPUsZw.png" /></figure><p>CONSIDER the achievements of wokeness, multiculturalism, and political correctness since January 1, 2010: #blacklivesmatter, increased diversity and pluralism in every aspect of media and politics, the legal sanctification of same-sex marriage, the mainstreaming of feminism and terms like “rape culture,” vastly increased visibility and acceptance of transgender persons, revised human resources policies that among other things reject a “boys will be boys” attitude, and an intolerance for hate speech that wasn’t evident in the first years of the millennium, when terms like “safe spaces,” “microaggressions,” and “triggering” were mostly known only to the world of psychological therapy. (Trigger warning: this little thinkpiece discusses trigger warnings and other triggers and warnings.)</p><p>That list is <em>already</em> problematic for some conservatives and some liberals, the latter of whom define “getting woke” as a matter of respect for persons and new guidelines of discourse (to their critics, “speech codes”) and <em>not</em> necessarily related to the achievements of non-cishet-white-males. However, colleges in the 2010s did not stop at mandating new “speech codes”; they paired such changes with examples of acceptable speech in the form of long overdue inclusion of voices of women and persons of color in the curriculum.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ju8z7uaH25Z3YoZEjobRDg.png" /></figure><p>Call it multiculturalism, which goes beyond simply having token faces of women and persons of color in a given group: multiculturalism <em>actively</em> values a wide panoply of cultures, races, religions, genders, and traditions. “Valuing,” while certainly the correct term, sends an inevitable and unfortunate message to others that they are not as valued. The less valued aren’t <em>only</em> white cishet (cisgender/hetero, i.e. identifying as heterosexual and as your biological gender) males: Christians, the aged, and the obese have felt excluded from many efforts toward inclusion. Cultural and academic celebration of non-white-male-hetero-normative cultures leads directly to greater “political correctness”; studies show that people to speak and behave more sensitively when around persons of dissimilar backgrounds to them. (The opposite is also true: people are more likely to speak <em>less</em> sensitively around their closest peers, as evidenced by anti-pluralists who, in the 2010s, clustered around reddit and 4chan.)</p><p>Multiculturalism and political correctness are mutually reinforcing tendencies that, in the 2010s, woke up (much of) America to white cishet male privilege. Some would argue that this happened at the cost of electing an uber-white man who built a campaign, and then a Presidency, on reactionary resentment, on a feeling that white Christians were the <em>real</em> persecuted victims. Some liberals will question whether mere <em>culture</em> (and not, say, deep pre-existing prejudice) could have influenced so many voters in 2016. Many of the same liberals <em>also</em> insist that Russian malefactors swung the 2016 election without guns or hacking of voting machines, but purely through cultural influence.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*2S5bTa0AjjGe2pYJWB-jwg.png" /></figure><p>Calling the 2010s a decade of “waking up” carries an unfortunate implication that America was asleep before 2010. Wokeness didn’t begin when Erykah Badu coined the term “woke” in 2008, or when Barack Hussein Obama was elected President later that year, though we can now see those developments as crucial. Over the centuries, some Americans, like Helen Keller, have been able to face our country’s savagery, colonialism, misogyny, and systematic inequalities; some haven’t. The term “political correctness” began as an academic in-joke about jargon in the 1960s, and continued that way through the 1970s and 1980s even as it began to reference changes that took years to informally permeate the discourse, e.g. from “fireman” to “firefighter” or “Oriental” to “Asian.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*TG9xCq_ZoZLHlakqf9Eh1w.png" /></figure><p>One pivot point was the December 1990 cover of <em>Newsweek</em> that summarized years of campus debates with “THOUGHT POLICE” and “Is This the New Enlightenment — or the New McCarthyism?” (Almost thirty years later, this remains a recurrent framing.) President Bush lambasted PC in a 1992 speech; ABC premiered the show “Politically Incorrect” in 1993. Widening cultural debates about PC coincided with the profusion of academic Ethnic Studies and Women’s Studies departments as well as strident new representations from non-white-males — from hip-hop to African-American-centered TV shows to anti-AIDS activism to <em>Dances with Wolves</em> to Anita Hill prompting mainstream awareness of sexual harassment.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*TfM0DZhA7HvNmL-cObkaow.png" /></figure><p>Political correctness and multiculturalism receded in the late 1990s, best evidenced by a culture that equated young female sexuality with freedom, e.g. Monica Lewinsky, Britney Spears, creepy magazine covers, <em>American Pie</em>. That was America’s status quo on September 11, 2001, the day of a cataclysm followed by many conservatives asking “Why do they hate us?” and “If you’re not with us, you’re against us.” Conservatives suddenly favored an active government by distinguishing terrorism from other problems that caused more deaths in 2001 (e.g, guns, cancer, drugs, drunk driving) because terrorism threatened Americans <em>as</em> Americans. In other words, group <em>identity</em> trumped rational argument.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3pUsruVPKPt_aj5Ze5P6Xg.png" /></figure><p>If conservatives had an underappreciated role in bringing back identity politics before 2010, liberals had an underappreciated role in undermining, or expanding, what Stephen Colbert called “truthiness.” Before 2010, before shows like <em>Glee</em> dramatized it for Fox audiences, Oprah Winfrey acolytes and allies of the LGBT asserted that people have a “right to live their truth.” While the larger, non-partisan internet began to situate feelings on a par with facts (accounting for the term “the feels”), a few leading academics deserve credit for joining truthiness to a new campus-based Manichaeism that asserted that whatever doesn’t kill you makes you weaker. In other words, facts had to be kept out of classrooms if said facts would offend even one student. As a broad generalization, then, by 2010, identity politics was promoted by the right only to be co-opted with smashing effectiveness by the left, while feelings trumping facts were promoted by the left only to be co-opted with smashing effectiveness by the right.</p><p>Before the deep dive into the #wokade, one more paragraph of key antecedents to the 2010s: the hundreds of brown bodies floating dead through New Orleans after Hurricane Katrina, proving that racism was by no means over in America; the 2008 financial meltdown, which increased insecurity, victimhood, and finger-pointing amongst all Americans; the rise of social media, especially Twitter, which had a salutary “permanence” effect (<em>maybe I shouldn’t threaten people here?</em>), a salubrious “flattening” effect (<em>Any avatar can be any race or gender! Same with stars, look, they’re just like us!</em>) and a salacious “gotcha!” effect (<em>look at stars/people saying stupid stuff!</em>); and the first year of the Obama administration, which included the “beer summit” (after a white police officer arrested a black scholar for opening his own front door, which Obama called a “stupid thing to do”) and Obama’s surprising win of the Nobel Peace Prize. In the wake of these latter two cultural moments, it was rare to find an American who did not blame either Obama, the Nobel Prize Committee, or the white officer in question. As the 2010s began, a crucial contingent of voters came to feel that Obama promoted or exemplified “special treatment” for African-Americans at the expense of whites.</p><p>It’s been a decade, hasn’t it? This is the decade it was.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*nLparE0W_jJpwg97d6M2qA.png" /></figure><p><strong>The most important event of 2010 was</strong> the year-long conflict between conservative activists and President Obama, and the growing perception that the conflict was racialized. One should have been able to criticize President Obama without being called racist; 2010 was the year that became particularly difficult. But who made it about race first? That’s tricky.</p><p>In the middle of the worst financial crisis since the Great Depression, the new president’s grace period had lasted exactly one month. Obama was inaugurated on January 20, 2009. On February 19, 2009, CNBC’s Rick Santelli took to the floor of the Chicago Mercantile Exchange and called for a new tea party reminiscent of those tax-fighting Bostonians of 1773, saying, among other things,</p><blockquote>This is America! How many of you people want to pay for your neighbor’s mortgage that has an extra bathroom and can’t pay their bills? Raise their hand…President Obama, are you listening?</blockquote><p>A year later, partly thanks to generous funding from the Koch Brothers, the Tea Party was a mature movement acting like a scrappy underdog. The Tea Party’s anti-debt, anti-government-spending gatherings were a little, well, raucous and chaotic, and that meant that a few bigots were bound to appear bearing questionable signs (say, Obama made to appear like Heath Ledger’s Joker). Tea Party members found that the media tended to focus on these few deplorables, and generally tried to remove them or their signs from meetings. Many chapters avoided social issues entirely, while others, like one supported by Glenn Beck, worked against illegal immigration. Yet even under the best of circumstances, rhetoric like Santelli’s and the generalized “let’s take our country back” seemed…<em>coded</em> to some.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*CHxUQKg1amBnGJ9K45y1qw.png" /></figure><p>It turned out that 2010 came down to one month. In mid-April of 2010, <em>Newsweek</em> and <em>The</em> <em>New York Times</em>published a couple of polls of Tea Party supporters versus Tea Party opponents. In separate questions, pollsters asked respondents if they found black people hardworking, intelligent, and trustworthy. Respective results, pro-Tea Party versus anti-Tea Party: 35% to 55%, 45% to 59%, and 41% to 57%. The former group’s percentages soared over the latter group’s, however, when asked if it was true that immigrants take jobs from people living here.</p><p>On the one hand, these statistics suggest that conservatives were already slightly more racist than liberals, which shouldn’t come as an enormous shock. On the other hand, looking at these statistics in 2019 doesn’t speak well for liberals or the Democratic Party. Less than 60% of Tea Party opponents found black people hardworking, intelligent, or trustworthy? Ouch. Let’s face it, we didn’t deserve the equanimity and calm grace of President Obama. Let’s face it, almost everyone is biased. Let’s face it, the temptations of social media may have been too great; extreme views drive clicks.</p><p>Maybe the long-dying <em>Newsweek</em> (but still elite-read) needed the clicks. <em>Newsweek</em>’s headline in mid-April 2010 read “New Poll Finds Tea Partiers Have More Racist Attitudes.” Liberals like Paul Krugman in <em>The</em> <em>New York Times</em> started writing about racial bias in Tea Party politics.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/612/1*RmzjpVO18EXaRL7tzOXKhw.jpeg" /></figure><p>The what-ifs can be painful. Would 2010 have been different if Hillary Clinton were President? Or John McCain? Or Colin Powell (had he run and won as a Republican)? What if Obama hadn’t named the Affordable Care Act as his first priority during America’s worst economic climate since the 1930s? At a certain point, we have to stop the what-ifs and say, look, Obama was indeed our first African-American President, he said and did what he said and did, and he didn’t say or do what he didn’t say or do. And what he did in May was…explosive.</p><p>A few weeks after the racialized polls, President Obama had a message for some private dinner guests. Unlike the video of Mitt Romney’s “47%” comments two years later, the words of Obama’s speech were long delayed, and not revealed until after the next election, in a book by Kenneth T. Walsh that came out in February 2011. Walsh revealed that at the dinner, Obama said “race was probably a key component in the rising opposition to his presidency from conservatives, especially right-wing activists in the anti-incumbent ‘Tea Party’ movement that was then surging across the country.” Walsh says Obama told his guests that there was little he could do other than “be as effective and empathetic a president as possible for all Americans.” Indeed, in eight years as President, Obama never suggested he was the leader of black America…even though, by default, his words carried far more authority than the people who had once donned that mantle (Jesse Jackson, Al Sharpton). Many black people seemed to support Obama almost by default…which some Tea Partiers (like Joe Walsh) found very frustrating.</p><p>One of the many problems with accusations of prejudice is they tend to lead to counter-accusations of prejudice, and after a certain amount of finger-pointing at the margins, after the passage of the Affordable Care Act in March, 2010 was the year that a critical mass of Americans on <em>both</em> sides “made it about race.” By the end of the year, “Where’s the Birth Certificate?” billboards were up all over America.</p><p>Counter-intuitively, if the Tea Party <em>did</em> “make it about race,” they may have ultimately done liberals a favor. Centuries of systematic oppression, structural inequalities, white privilege, and mental colonization aren’t exactly easy to overcome, and we certainly hadn’t overcome them by 2010…but the emotional fires of 2010 got large numbers of Americans closer to naming these problems, and naming is at least part of solving.</p><p>When Kenneth T. Walsh’s book was published in February 2011, Fox’s headline about it read “Obama Says Tea Party is Racist in New Book.” Mostly wrong, but the fire was lit, and it wouldn’t be doused for two more months.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*6VB0YpTM6ySyo1kiHMhRqg.png" /></figure><p><strong>2011 came down to one week</strong>. Let’s start with “The Office.” (Yes, “The Office.”) Based on the British show of the same name, “The Office” was about a small-town small-office paper company headed by Michael Scott (Steve Carell), who in every episode said things that were cringe-worthy at best, deeply problematic at worst. He was little better than a grown-up Eric Cartman. One could almost make the case that Michael’s antics from 2005 (the show’s debut) to 2009 should have been part of my earlier prologue to the 2010s, making America more aware of inappropriate workplace behavior. And yet…very, very few (perhaps no) woke liberals tweeted at “The Office” or NBC to say that Michael had crossed some kind of line. Somehow, most liberals understood that Michael was ignorant, not hateful. And then, on Thursday, April 28, 2011, on the 148th episode of “The Office,” Pam watched as Michael boarded an airplane and rose into the sky, never to be seen again. (Like another person did in another April about two millennia ago?) “The Office” continued, but Michael didn’t. A similarly unifying figure, Oprah Winfrey, concluded her incredibly influential show a month later. With the departures of Michael and Oprah, liberals began to treat anyone who talked like Michael as hateful and unforgivable.</p><p>The day before Michael’s flight, on Wednesday, April 27, after months and months of public pressure, President Obama finally released his “long form” birth certificate. The spectacle of the “birther” campaign was sordid and disturbing; when had any President had to prove where he was born? Were we meant to think that Barack Obama’s birth announcement in a Honolulu newspaper was faked, or part of a long con that began in 1961? Our friends of color reminded us that the campaign wasn’t particularly surprising to them; they had often been asked to “prove” things. (“So, when you applied to this school, did you…you know…I mean…?”)</p><p>Opponents said that birthers meant to “otherize” Obama by associating him with Africa, Islam, Hawaii, or some inscrutable combination. Birthers responded by insisting that the question had nothing to do with race, and with a description ready for those who called them racist: racist. (What else?) On the one hand, Obama’s smackdown of the birthers might have been interpreted as a triumph for the reality-based community; on the other hand, his dignifying a question from online conspiracists showed how far they could go.</p><p>Obama’s timing was interesting, and not because of “The Office.” Obama might have squelched the birther rumors months before. On April 27, he knew a closely guarded secret: that Navy SEALs were days from a raid on a Pakistani compound that supposedly harbored Osama Bin Laden. (The SEALs were waiting for a moonless night that wouldn’t happen until May 1.) The most important ten-year manhunt in American history was hopefully about to come to an end…but only if no one tipped off Pakistan’s government beforehand. Did Obama lower himself to responding to birthers precisely to make Pakistan’s leaders think that he was distracted?</p><p>Obama knew that the annual White House Correspondents Dinner was scheduled for that Saturday, April 30. Obama planned to follow custom and attend; he also knew that Donald Trump was scheduled to attend. There were many birthers, but Trump had been the only one appearing on Fox promising that he had sent investigators to Hawaii; he said they had come up with “very interesting” “facts.” The outcome of the SEALs mission was uncertain, but Obama could almost certainly provoke a little bit of fun at the dinner that would include himself, Trump, and people whose job it was to report “very interesting facts.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4cyNW4DHcx46fYBx7KZTdw.jpeg" /></figure><p>The video of the April 30 dinner may become one of the most studied videos of the century. No bystander would guess that Obama knew about the crucial Osama mission coming to a climax half a world away; indeed, Obama had to make sure to appear casual and collected, and did, as he said:</p><blockquote>Donald Trump is here tonight. Now I know that he’s taken some flak lately. But no one is happier — no one is prouder — to put this birth certificate matter to rest than The Donald. And that’s because he can finally get back to focusing on the issues that matter: Like, did we fake the moon landing? What really happened in Roswell? And where are Biggie and Tupac? All kidding aside, obviously we all know about your credentials and breadth of experience. For example … no seriously, just recently, in an episode of <em>Celebrity Apprentice</em>, at the steakhouse, the men’s cooking team did not impress the judges from Omaha Steaks. And there was a lot of blame to go around, but you, Mr. Trump, recognized that the real problem was a lack of leadership, and so ultimately you didn’t blame Lil Jon or Meat Loaf, you fired Gary Busey. And these are the kinds of decisions that would keep me up at night. Well handled, sir. Well handled. Say what you will about Mr. Trump, he certainly would bring some change to the White House.</blockquote><p>The video clearly shows Trump failing to laugh along with these jibes. Many would later say that Trump’s presidency, which seems specifically and often capriciously based on reversing the policies of its predecessor (in a way that few other presidencies have been), at the expense of the health of millions, was revenge for these two minutes of (mediocre) comedy.</p><p>In Spring of 2011, America had been waiting for revenge on Osama bin Laden for almost ten years. (At one point, President Bush publicly claimed that finding Bin Laden didn’t really matter; privately, Bush’s family never stopped doing business with Bin Laden’s associates.) When it finally happened on Sunday, May 1, the White House saw something other than the previous night’s room of awkwardly chuckling journalists: it saw people outside its gates, on Lafayette Square, cheering and celebrating and waving American flags.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/760/1*bXb7uYmfwfZnP7pbk5VVag.jpeg" /></figure><p>On that particular May Day, the president of the party of labor probably assured his (narrow) re-election in 2012. As he had with TARP and ACA, Obama had proved that while Republicans talk about problems, Democrats solve them. Almost as important, in five days he seemed to have settled the “othering” question. He put his long-form birth certificate online. He killed Osama bin Laden. What else was he supposed to do, dress like Uncle Sam and shoot a machine gun into the ceiling of the Senate, like Terry Crews in <em>Idiocracy</em>? In a less partisan and less racialized America, this week might have also settled the question of white people working for black people. Clearly, if an African-American can effectively delegate the killing of the villain who destroyed the World Trade Center, there’s no Fortune 500 company s/he can’t run.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*oijdRe4ECkWbfi38qJkIxQ.png" /></figure><p><strong>The most important event of 2012</strong> <strong>was </strong>the day in May that President Obama, prodded by his white friend’s (Joe Biden) foot-in-mouth disease, announced that he favored same-sex marriage. Obama had been claiming for years that his views on same-sex marriage were “evolving,” and indeed this May 9 pronouncement didn’t happen in a vacuum. Many things had contributed to the “evolution,” not least the LGBT community’s staunch support of President Obama. Culturally, there was everything from Lady Gaga’s “Born This Way” to the rise of <em>The Ellen DeGeneres Show</em> to the top daytime show (after Oprah’s retirement in 2011; many remembered Obama’s dancing with Ellen in 2008) to David Stern fining the leader of the NBA Champion L.A. Lakers, Kobe Bryant, $100,000 for using “faggot” as a slur.</p><p>There was also Obama’s desire to avoid anything like a repeat of the passage of Proposition 8 in 2008 in California, which (temporarily) ended same-sex marriage in California. Here at the end of 2019, at the end of the #wokade, it seems almost impossible that 11 short years ago, a majority of Californians (Californians!) voted to deny gay couples the right to marry. Prop 8 <em>had</em> been soundly losing in phone polls. And it might well have lost…if someone other than the first African-American president was on the ballot. Studies have been inconclusive, but the smart money says that an overwhelming surge of black voters to the California polls also brought out a certain, well, homophobia. We’re not supposed to talk about this now, but the makers of late-80s classic documentaries like <em>Tongues Untied</em> and <em>Paris is Burning</em> well know (and well dramatized) that the black community manifested decades of hostility to the gay community. Maybe <em>only</em> an African-American President could have reconciled these decades of tensions.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/424/1*MXTC48lvMVrMVSx39JoJVg.jpeg" /></figure><p>As when Obama authorized the assault on Bin Laden’s compound, the President knew that he was taking a serious risk by supporting same-sex marriage. How did he know he wouldn’t capsize his 2012 campaign? Obama may have known that openly homophobic rhetoric wasn’t playing well on the permanent notoriety that was Twitter. He may have seen upside for his voters, who may have needed reminding that he was still fighting for human and civil rights. He may have said to himself, more than he could have in 2010, “Is the economy doing well enough for this? Hope so.” On May 9, 2012, Obama essentially completed the coalition of the #woke. (Although transgender rights would take longer.) Spokespeople for GLAAD and the NAACP could now appear on CNN without (much) fear of hypocrisy or contradicting each other. This was most certainly a good thing…with consequences.</p><p>Obama’s re-election in November 2012 made his same-sex marriage turnaround into a watershed for at least two other reasons. One was that it proved to half of America that you <em>could</em> move the goalposts on wokeness. You could evolve in the direction of more compassion and more humanity, and hope/feel that America would evolve with you. A <em>lot</em> of other goalposts would move in the next seven years. (Also, would Jason Collins and Michael Sam have become gay black trailblazers in professional sports? Maybe. But I doubt it.)</p><p>Two, the turnaround may have lost the Democrats middle America. Perhaps not in 2012, partly because Mitt Romney is a Mormon, but afterward, after the “elites” in DC (read: The Supreme Court), prompted by Obama, struck down the Defense of Marriage Act in 2013 and affirmed same-sex marriage in 2015. For decades, really centuries, Christians have been fundraising based on blatantly homophobic rhetoric. Studies done during the November 2012 election showed that a majority of Romney voters believed Obama not to be Christian. A majority! This false canard is a testament to the power of fake news (e.g. getting information from reddit), to be sure, but it seems unlikely without the twin barrels of birtherism and same-sex marriage advocacy.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/590/1*EE344M8HyaFdwECFJnH9aA.png" /></figure><p>White bigots in the Heartland and the South tended to have at least one thing in common with the black people they knew: an otherizing of the LGBT. On a sunny day in May, Obama took that away. Obama was right to do it, but the backlash would be a whole lot of wrong.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*oDbu3EkcI0OJIeaMPuYWIQ.png" /></figure><p><strong>The most important event of 2013</strong> <strong>occurred</strong> in October. You may not have read Greg Lukianoff and Jonathan Haidt’s book “The Coddling of the American Mind,” but you’re probably aware of Lukianoff and Haidt’s subjects of expertise: trigger warnings, microaggressions, safe spaces, and disinvitations. If you noticed that these terms became ubiquitous only recently, you’re right; Lukianoff and Haidt identify a particular incident as the pivotal turning point toward our current era.</p><p>In 2013, Brown University invited New York City Police Commissioner Raymond Kelly for its Noah Krieger ’93 Memorial Lecture, described as “an annual lecture by a prominent individual who has made distinguished contributions to public service.” For centuries, Brown University has hosted guest speakers of every political and ideological stripe; in his life prior to October 2013, Kelly had given speeches on dozens of campuses. However, that week before Halloween, the University and the Commissioner saw things that scared them silly.</p><p>Context is important. Many Brown students knew Raymond Kelly, at least by reputation; he had led the NYPD’s breakup of Occupy Wall Street protests in 2011 and 2012. Occupy Wall Street was its own watershed of intersectionality, where college students of all stripes gathered with elders to express and flesh out a litany of anti-prejudice, anti-elite, anti-capitalist concerns. Well known as the most liberal of Ivy League schools, Brown was well represented at OWS. Brown students prided and pride themselves on pushing the boundaries of social justice and watching other universities follow.</p><p>On July 13, 2013, a Florida jury acquitted George Zimmerman in the shooting death of Trayvon Martin. Alicia Garza, Patrisse Cullors, and Opal Tometi chose that day to announce Black Lives Matter, a new organization that, among other things, asked white people to examine their own roles in reducing police brutality. On July 16, President Obama publicly suggested that New York Commissioner Raymond Kelly should be the next head of the Department of Homeland Security. Days later, a consortium of Muslim groups published an open letter to the President which read, in part, “Commissioner Kelly’s legacy in New York is synonymous with divisive, harmful, and ineffective policing that promotes stereotypes and profiling.” Kelly, who is white, reacted a few days later with an editorial in which he said that NYC police practices, including the notorious “stop and frisk” protocol, have led to “7,383 lives saved…largely the lives of men of color.”</p><p>Perhaps few Brown undergrads heard of BLM or the Kelly flap in July. Just as they began their semester, however, every student heard about Miley Cyrus “twerking” alongside Robin Thicke at the MTV Video Music Awards on August 26. Their one-time Disney role-model probably thought she was merely shedding her good-girl image, comparable to Britney Spears’ kissing Madonna at the VMAs ten years before. A thousand takeaways begged to differ, and to very much over-summarize them: white people, don’t be culturally callous, and instead, try to be cultural allies.</p><p>On October 17, Obama announced that an African-American, Jeh Johnson, would become the new DHS chief (instead of his first pick, Ray Kelly). That same day, a famous Brown alumnus emailed his public concern over the selection of Ray Kelly to their prestigious lecture series. Within days, students working with various liberal Providence organizations began to meet, and on October 24, they presented Brown U. a petition with three demands: transparency in the process that selected Kelly, the donation of any honorarium to groups fighting racial profiling and police brutality, and the canceling of the lecture. Brown’s administration, citing free speech and the exchange of ideas, did not budge.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/970/1*iFGuFPvkU-akCw_AtgKvnA.jpeg" /></figure><p>On the night of October 28, Brown’s (mostly white) students held a vigil honoring victims of racial profiling and police brutality. On October 29, as Commissioner Ray Kelly arrived, about 100 students gathered outside the lecture hall with signs and chants, including, “No Justice, No Peace, No Ray(cist) Police.” As Kelly attempted to deliver his lecture, students repeatedly shouted over the voices of administrators and Kelly. After about 22 minutes, administrators canceled the event and cleared the room.</p><p>The next day, Brown president Christina Paxson called the event “a sad day for the Brown community.” She organized a forum that very evening, attended by about 600 students, to discuss what sorts of speakers would be welcome to lecture at Brown in the future. Terms that had been floating around psychology and academia for years, like trigger warnings and safe spaces, were deployed here as suggestions for new protocols that would resonate across Brown, across academia, and ultimately across America.</p><p>Students had been protesting speakers for decades, especially conservative ones. Students had reported high rates of depression for a while, though this increased during the 21st century. For Lukianoff and Haidt, what changed during that late October was the intertwining of social justice with the language of mental health. They posit that there was something unusual about the 18-year-olds who entered college in the Fall of 2013. Why? Maybe because they were six when 9/11 happened; maybe Sandy Hook in December 2012 revisited that trauma; maybe the American Dream was derailed by Iraq and the 2008 meltdown; maybe the problem was with the ubiquity of iPhones, starting when these kids were about 12, or Instagram when they were about 16. Whatever the exact explanation, the undergraduate Class of 2017 was perceived to be a uniquely fragile class, needing protection from…well, everything.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/618/1*oHyIBf2oBApvtxF_YwENpw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Lukianoff and Haidt published a widely read <em>Atlantic</em> article about what they call coddling through “vindictive protectiveness” in 2015 (Obama cited it approvingly), and then later in a book dedicated to debunking what they call the three great Untruths: 1. What doesn’t kill you makes you weaker. 2. Always trust your feelings. 3. Life is a battle between good people and evil people. But the un-untruth is, Lukianoff and Haidt are fighting a losing battle. Universities can’t stop playing what they call the “offendedness sweepstakes,” and censoring or de-platforming or disinviting persons or ideas that might offend (where offend = traumatize) even one student. And because this is the era of social media, and there’s a right-wing media ecosystem that requires fresh grist for its mill, these university-bound controversies have a way of metastasizing into the larger media. Little by little, Fortune 500 companies implement some of the newly progressive language or codes or policies.</p><p>No doubt, some of these changes are more than welcome. At other times, saying “can we talk about microaggressions?” is seen as a microaggression. Sometimes, being anything less than 100% woke means being called racist, and that has become a profoundly problematic binary. What happened to the middle ground of “ignorant,” like Michael Scott?</p><p>On the one hand, Brown sophomores who participated in the Ray Kelly protest of October 2013 should be proud. Their many, many subsequent efforts at social justice and language policing reverberated through universities and the wider world. In just one example, during that month that they graduated in 2016, President Obama ordered schools to provide trans-friendly bathrooms to students. (11 states counter-sued.) On the other hand, conservative media reported (with some justification) that this change was the only change Hillary Clinton stood for. Donald Trump was elected president that November.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*l9B4Mvmi-mOEtR-TaPUsZw.png" /></figure><p><strong>The most important events of 2014</strong> <strong>happened</strong> during the long dog-days-of-summer weekend of August 14–17. These were the pivotal days of the Ferguson protests and the Gamergate scandal, although they deserve to be understood in a much larger context.</p><p>In Ferguson, a suburb of St. Louis, Missouri, on Saturday, August 9, 2014, Michael Brown, a black 18-year-old, was shot to death by white 28-year-old officer Darren Wilson. Wilson was responding to a convenience store’s report of a robbery and assault; according to Wilson, Brown attempted to take Wilson’s weapon, and in the struggle, the weapon fired and wounded Brown, who fled. According to Wilson, Wilson chased after Brown, who at some point charged him, and it was then that Wilson shot and killed Brown. Eyewitnesses said that in that moment, Brown had his hands raised, and was saying “Don’t shoot.”</p><p>A makeshift memorial was erected to Brown that very evening; some reported that police vehicles crushed the memorial. The next evening, August 10, after a peaceful candlelight vigil, voices became heated, about 150 officers appeared in riot gear, and some property sustained damage, including police cars and businesses. This continued and escalated over the next few nights. Some protestors held up their hands while others threw bottles; police used tear gas and smoke bombs to disperse the crowds. On August 13, two reporters for major newspapers were arrested; at least two others were tear-gassed and shot at with rubber bullets; and a SWAT team was caught on tape dismantling a news crew’s camera equipment. Despite the video evidence, Tom Jackson, Ferguson’s white police chief, denied “suppression of the media.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/992/1*ePPQEm0MbXk1Jkxm27b68g.jpeg" /></figure><p>On Thursday, August 14, Missouri Senator Claire McCaskill met with protestors and told the press that “militarization of the police escalated the protestors’ response.” President Obama said that there was “no excuse for police to use excessive force against peaceful protests, or to throw protestors in jail for lawfully exercising their First Amendment rights. And here, in the United States of America, police should not be bullying or arresting journalists who are just trying to do their jobs and report to the American people on what they see on the ground.”</p><p>These were fateful words. In the short term, they amounted to a win for the protestors; the Ferguson Police released the officer’s name, and Missouri’s governor announced a new, African-American-led police presence. The longer term was a stickier wicket. On Friday, August 15, protestors continued “in an almost celebratory manner” but after a few hours of guarded police presence, rioters broke into a liquor store and a few other places. After a long weekend of curfews, resistance, and SWAT-like tactics, the governor called in the National Guard.</p><p>Senator McCaskill’s return to national headlines reminded some that she had only held her Senate seat because, in 2012, her Republican opponent Todd Akin had said that women don’t usually get pregnant from “legitimate rape.” As McCaskill’s face appeared on America’s TV screens on Friday, August 15, an angry man composed a 9,425-word jeremiad that attempted its own sort of “legitimate rape” or at least a legitimating of a type of abuse of women. Eron Gjoni, upon breaking up with game designer Zoe Quinn, posted a screed that screenshotted many of Quinn’s private emails, texts, and IMs, in an apparent effort to both go viral and prompt a doxing of Quinn.</p><p>This effort succeeded. Video game users on Reddit and 4chan began to threaten Quinn and her family members. Quinn’s private information was exposed, including real nude photos and fake photos of her head photoshopped onto porn stars. New chat rooms were created to discuss the best way to ruin her life or fantasize about killing her, and some posters seized on Gjoni’s point that Quinn had slept with a writer for a review site (named Nathan Grayson) to suggest that Quinn slept with gaming journalists in exchange for good reviews. Never mind that Grayson had never reviewed any of Quinn’s games. When other gamers came to Quinn’s defense, especially self-identifying women, they were likewise targeted by doxers, who proudly hashtagged their assaults #gamergate.</p><p>Many of America’s major civil-rights events have been, at their core, protests of white police harming black citizens in a manner that police do not harm white people. Ferguson’s protestors weren’t worried only about Brown; they were protesting systemic abuse that clearly hadn’t improved despite an African-American president.</p><p>The 2012 death of Trayvon Martin was barely mentioned by the media for days after it happened; the women who founded Black Lives Matter on the day in 2013 (July 13) that Martin’s killer was acquitted were determined to improve community reaction time to such tragedies. Though Black Lives Matter had existed for 13 months, most Americans didn’t learn of it until Ferguson, when it defended African-American-caused property damage from the weekend of August 16 and 17. On August 18, President Obama dispatched Attorney General Eric Holder to Missouri to oversee a truce. On August 21, after the African-American Holder met with most of the relevant leaders and Brown’s family, the situation de-escalated, and the National Guard were asked to leave.</p><p>The federal government seemed to ignore Gamergate in August and September, and the online situation suffered from the lack of attention. As the false narrative of reviewer-designer collusion continued, #gamergaters turned their targeting ire to women who called attention to inherent and structural sexism in the video game industry. On August 24, Sarkeesian released the latest episode of her online series Tropes vs. Women in Video Games, and received rape and death threats. When her home address was leaked, she had to flee her home. Something similar happened to Brianna Wu, a game developer.</p><p>Women have been harassed online for as long as people have been online. Chat boards, anonymous posters, and message boards doxxed users for years before that word existed. As Whitney Phillips put it, “The energy and ideology of this movement weren’t new but Gamergate was when the movement evolved and the monster grew a voice box. All the anger, all the toxicity and fear of being replaced by a culture more focused on social justice — it all came together in a spectacularly awful way.” Online bullying either proved that free speech was still free, or defended avatars that looked and moved like Barbie dolls come to life, or a bit of both.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/562/1*8Uf0Bi8-dORHqIeJmUx2bA.jpeg" /></figure><p>In mid-October, Sarkeesian canceled a planned speech at Utah State University because of three anonymous threats, one of which warned that “a Montreal Massacre style attack will be carried out against the attendees, as well as the students and staff at the nearby Women’s Center” (This referred to a 1989 incident in which a mass shooter had mowed down 14 female college students while shouting “you’re all a bunch of f*ing feminists!”) Sarkeesian’s cancellation drew national attention and the FBI to Gamergate…but the FBI never found any of the suspects.</p><p>Also in mid-October, anti-feminist Gamergaters persuaded Intel, a company valued at $158 billion, to pull its advertising from a gaming magazine called Gamasutra because the latter was critical of anti-feminists. In response, a rather perspicacious Deadspin writer named Kyle Wagner wrote,</p><blockquote>And this is the key to understanding Gamergate: There actually is a real conflict here, something like the one perceived by the Tea Partier waving her placard about the socialist Muslim Kenyan usurper in the White House. There is a reason why, in all the Gamergate rhetoric, you hear the echoes of every other social war staged in the last 30 years: <em>overly politically correct, social-justice warriors, the media elite, gamers are not a monolith</em>. There is also a reason why so much of the rhetoric amounts to a vigorous argument that <em>Being a gamer doesn’t mean you’re sexist, racist, and stupid</em> — a claim no one is making. Co-opting the language and posture of grievance is how members of a privileged class express their belief that the way they live shouldn’t have to change, that their opponents are hypocrites and perhaps even the real oppressors. This is how you get St. Louisans sincerely explaining that Ferguson protestors are the real racists, and how you end up with an organized group of precisely the same video game enthusiasts to whom an entire industry is catering honestly believing that they’re an oppressed minority. From this kind of ideological fortification, you can stage absolutely whatever campaigns you deem necessary.</blockquote><p>And they surrrrrrrre did. It didn’t help that the (so-called) social-justice warriors fighting abuse online and in police protocol didn’t have one obvious clear villain and instead tried to score points through hashtags. 2014 was the year that anti-feminists on 4chan began to pose as women and/or women of color in making hashtags like #endfathersday and #whitescantberaped go viral; real feminists called attention to these #fakehashtags. Ferguson’s war of hashtags got a lot more national press: #blacklivesmatter versus #alllivesmatter and #bluelivesmatter.</p><p>The fuller woke response to the #alllivesmatter and #bluelivesmatter is represented by, oh, let’s say the Unitarian Church: “To say that Black lives matter is not to say that other lives do not; indeed, it is quite the reverse — it is to recognize that all lives do matter, and to acknowledge that African Americans are often targeted unfairly and that our society is not yet so advanced as to have become truly color blind.” The woke way of explaining Gamergate to the many who found it hard to understand is represented by Charlie Warzel calling Gamergate “a leaderless harassment campaign to preserve white male internet culture, disguised as a referendum on journalism ethics and political correctness,” the latter of which is said to be running amok. Somehow, somewhere between #leanin and #notallmen and the conversation around the Ray Rice video and some of the first regular mainstream use of the phrase “toxic masculinity,” there was a perceived feminist overreach.</p><p>Or maybe it’s just that in 2014, American swing voters didn’t seem ready for nuance beyond hashtags. Or perhaps they weren’t really ready for a systemic critique that partly implicated them. ¿Por que no los dos?</p><p>Recall now Obama’s statement during the heart of Ferguson (mid-August 2014) that there was “no excuse for police to use excessive force against peaceful protests, or to throw protestors in jail for lawfully exercising their First Amendment rights.” His supporters found these comments anodyne, no more than Bush or Reagan might have said. For way, way too many guests on Fox News, however, this was “proof” that “Obama hates cops.” They fed it into a narrative that went from the “humiliated” white cop at the “beer summit” to Obama’s 2012 statement “If I had a son, he’d look like” the slain Trayvon Martin to Ferguson. Was this a preposterous exaggeration of the statements of an obviously pro-police president? Of course. Did that matter? Of course not. Combine that with ostensible feminist overreach represented by the Gamergate scandal, and in November, Republicans maintained the House and recaptured the Senate, with fateful consequences for the Supreme Court and the larger republic.</p><p>Ferguson and Gamergate hardly ended the day after Election Day. On November 24, a Ferguson grand jury chose not to indict Wilson, and a new round of large protests ensued. CNN reported that protests had erupted in 170 cities nationwide, from Boston to Los Angeles. Ferguson became something of a cause celebre, from LeBron James’ T-shirt that said “HANDS UP DON’T SHOOT” to the Common/John Legend song “Glory” (for the new film <em>Selma</em>) that won an Oscar in February.</p><p>In April 2015, Fergusonians took to the street once again after Freddie Gray was found dead in Baltimore. The protestors were agitating for a very specific reform: on-officer body cameras. Less than three weeks before Michael Brown’s death, the video of the NYPD choking Eric Garner to death had gone viral. As protestors and eyewitnesses endlessly argues with police over what really happened in the final seconds of Brown’s life, mandatory police-worn cameras started to make more and more sense.</p><p>So, victory for social justice, right? Uh, no, not exactly. Instead, a whole industry cropped up to confront both Black Lives Matter and online feminists, led by Breitbart, which routinely called BLM some kind of “terrorist” organization for failing to strongly condemn the protestor-led crimes at Ferguson protests, or for failing to strongly condemn ongoing black-on-black violence in Chicago, or whatever. Breitbart may have been even worse to anti-Gamergaters, giving people like Milo Yanniopoulous a way to build a career by saying things like “feminism is cancer.” As we move into the 2020s, the knowing hashtag is #everythingisgamergate, meaning that, as Wagner basically predicted, Breitbart/Gamergate tactics are to online war what Sun Tzu’s The Art of War is to military-fought war. The co-editor of Breitbart was a self-described “agent of chaos” named Steve Bannon, who would become the first person hired for the White House by President-elect Donald Trump.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ju8z7uaH25Z3YoZEjobRDg.png" /></figure><p><strong>2015 came down to one extraordinary week</strong>, or even just four days. On Monday, June 15, a suddenly notorious white woman passing as African-American, Rachel Dolezal, resigned from her leadership position at the NAACP. On Tuesday, June 16, reality-TV star Donald Trump descended an escalator and announced his bid for the Presidency while denouncing Mexico for “sending us” “drugs,” “criminals,” and “rapists.” On Wednesday, June 17, an idiot massacred nine black churchgoers in Charleston, an event that was, the next morning, repurposed as a call to end conspicuous displays of Confederate flags.</p><p>This week of world-changing news was necessarily preceded by a slow news week, one in which two white nationalists plotted different roads to infamy even as Rachel Dolezal was becoming (in)famous. On Wednesday, June 10, a Spokane TV station interviewed Dolezal, the elected president of the local NAACP chapter, about hate crimes in Eastern Washington over the previous year. The reporter asked Dolezal about a recent Facebook post where she suggested that an African-American man pictured with her was her father; Dolezal at first said that he was, then said that the question was inappropriate. The next day, two local reporters published “Black Like Me?” which said that Dolezal “made claims in the media and elsewhere about her ethnicity, race and background that are contradicted by her biological parents.” Dolezal’s parents provided a photo of their blonde, blue-eyed, fair-skinned daughter, and over the weekend almost every news station in the United States ran this photo side-by-side with the 2015 version of “passing” Dolezal. By any objective measure, Dolezal’s 2015 skin appeared darker than, just to pick a random example, Klay Thompson’s. (Many Americans watched Thompson that week in the NBA Finals, co-leading the Golden State Warriors to their first championship in 40 years; Thompson’s father Mychal was an obviously African-American champion with the L.A. Lakers.)</p><p>Some argued that Dolezal had committed cultural appropriation and fraud, while others felt that Dolezal’s asserted identity should be respected. Many couldn’t get past the mendacity, others the blackface. One Washington Post writer called her behavior “white guilt played to its end.” A scholar named Samantha Allen condemned her as she wrote, “Rachel Dolezal seems determined to appropriate not just blackness but the rhetoric of transgender identity as well.”</p><p>Unfortunately for Rachel Dolezal, sometimes timing is an issue. The decade’s most important issue, ahem, magazine, was the June 2015 Vanity Fair that introduced the world to Ms. Caitlyn Jenner. Fans of <em>Keeping Up with the Kardashians</em> knew that the parent formerly known as Bruce had been undergoing treatments, but this was when Caitlyn first announced her name and boldly presented to the world as a woman. (Many also noticed that Caitlyn was the first woman over 60 to appear on this magazine’s cover.) On some level, Jenner’s transition and triumph wasn’t only about the transgender, or the famous; it was about living your truth and your best life even if others can’t accept you. It was about refusing to accept society’s definition of who you are and embracing who <em>you</em> know you really are.</p><p>And…on a weekend when that Vanity Fair was sitting around America’s waiting rooms, the news of Rachel couldn’t help but disrupt Caitlyn’s narrative. As a white person, could you refuse to accept society’s definition of the white person that you are? Are you allowed to front black identity?</p><p>Conservatives seized on the news. If being African-American was as bad as Black Lives Matter suggested, then why were white women pretending to be black? After the story blew up over the weekend, Dolezal quit the NAACP on Monday, June 15. On Tuesday, June 16, on The Today Show, she told Matt Lauer (of all people) that she long ago chose not to correct people who called her biracial, and that her appearance was “not some freak, Birth of a Nation, mockery blackface performance.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/992/1*Q3MCCAdADynnyEe6xZeFOA.jpeg" /></figure><p>On any other week, the Dolezal story would have preoccupied five days of morning show airtime. Instead, a showman showed up later that same Tuesday, looking imperiously down from his own descending escalator. Donald Trump’s prepared remarks said nothing untoward about Mexicans, but the very first day of his presidential campaign proved that prepared remarks were more like guidelines. Among many other things never spoken by any serious contender for the White House, Trump said,</p><blockquote>When Mexico sends its people, they’re not sending their best. They’re not sending you. They’re not sending you. They’re sending people that have lots of problems, and they’re bringing those problems with us. They’re bringing drugs. They’re bringing crime. They’re rapists. And some, I assume, are good people. But I speak to border guards and they tell us what we’re getting. And it only makes common sense. It only makes common sense. They’re sending us not the right people. It’s coming from more than Mexico. It’s coming from all over South and Latin America, and it’s coming probably — probably — from the Middle East. But we don’t know. Because we have no protection and we have no competence, we don’t know what’s happening. And it’s got to stop and it’s got to stop fast.</blockquote><p>Where to begin? Trump didn’t speak to any border guards. Mexico doesn’t “send” anyone; individual free people apply for asylum or a green card or citizenship. “It’s coming”: what’s “it”? Wrong people? Trump elides different kinds of brown people together here, hoping that his target audience won’t be able to distinguish Manuel from Moammar. This indiscriminate discrimination became foundational.</p><p>He also spoke perhaps the most vicious racial slur of any politician of the last half-century. He said that immigrants from Mexico are “bringing drugs. They’re bringing crime. They’re rapists.” Not since George Wallace in 1968 had any major American politician — never mind one running for President — uttered such vile hatred. Based just on that, his campaign should have been over on the day it began.</p><p>Tuesday and Wednesday, Trump’s speech and Rachel Dolezal competed for attention on the evening shows of Fox, CNN, and MSNBC. On one level there was a lot of “did you ever think you’d see the day?” kind of incredulity. Another question was who we were and who we wanted to be in the summer of 2015. What if there were ten more Dolezals or The Donalds? (We would later learn those two persons are <em>sui generis</em>.)</p><p>And then…as reports came in from Charleston, South Carolina at about 9pm on Wednesday, June 17, the smiles came right off of the anchors’ faces. A 21-year-old white supremacist shot and killed nine African-American people at Emanuel African Methodist Episcopal Church while shouting racist statements such as, “I have to do it. You rape our women and you’re taking over our country. And you have to go.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/748/1*bxPEN-Xl4iEWu3fMzzjeBg.png" /></figure><p>Americans woke up on Thursday, June 18, to three things: news of the white supremacist’s manhunt and capture (being white, he was taken alive), his racist manifesto including a photo of him next to a Confederate flag, and Ta-Nehisi Coates’ new <em>Atlantic</em> piece, “Take Down the Confederate Flag — Now.” In June of 2015, Ta-Nehisi Coates had emerged as America’s best public intellectual. His game-changing book, “Between the World and Me,” actually wasn’t even out yet (it dropped July 14), but it had been excerpted, with the excerpts as rapturously received as his other <em>Atlantic</em> pieces. Americans were (and are) accustomed to post-massacre protocol: hand-wringing about gun control, thoughts and prayers, promises to look into mental health, and a slow, weeklong dissipation of concern. What Americans were <em>not</em> accustomed to was Coates’ sudden post-Charleston call for government buildings to bring down any and all Confederate flags. That Thursday, #woke America took its marching orders from Coates with the same efficiency that elected Republicans take their marching orders from Fox News. Many statehouses and websites and “The Dukes of Hazzard” removed their Old Glorys. The sudden crusade to take down Dixie flags turned out to be the last extended story covered by Jon Stewart before he left “The Daily Show.”</p><p>As a then-new musical on Broadway called <em>Hamilton</em> had it (Lin-Manuel Miranda quoting Isaac Newton), “Every action has an equal opposite reaction.” In many ways, the 2008 election of Barack Obama was a reaction to the disastrous presidency of George W. Bush, and many of the events in these timelines and recaps might be described as “equal opposite reactions” to Obama, or to events that reacted to him. In mid-June 2015, a killer white supremacist’s manifesto went viral, propagating above all the idea that whites are the <em>real</em> victims in 2015 America.</p><p>Look at all the statistics about income, education, health, wealth: whites are not the victims. So where could this 21-year-old straight white male assassin have gathered this idea? Maybe from a college culture, particularly strident since 2013, which lionized victims and advocated for every group that <em>wasn’t</em> straight white males? That week, the toxic fame of Rachel Dolezal and Donald Trump also bolstered white victimhood.</p><p>Thus Ta-Nehisi Coates’ call for a final Confederate surrender, almost 150 years to the day after Juneteenth, wasn’t exactly out of nowhere. It was an equal opposite reaction. But these reactions bring problems, as Newton or Miranda might have told you. Coates’ call led to some kind of equal opposite reaction.</p><p>Cultural appropriation, microaggressions, disinvitations, and trigger warnings became known quantities in 2013, but other than some outlandish Fox News sequences, they didn’t really threaten the status quo. Ferguson and Gamergate suggested more systemic problems with America, but if you were white and didn’t follow the news or spend a lot of time playing video games, you could tune those out.</p><p>In 2015, woke America came for the Confederate flags, and succeeded in making them about as well-liked as swastikas. Few Americans are intensely attached to the Confederacy or as racist as the idiot who massacred the churchgoers. Hundreds of thousands of liberals had attended Tom Petty concerts in the 1990s, mostly without thinking that the Confederate flag in the background really <em>meant</em> much of anything. (No one has ever called Petty a racist.) But the massacre and Coates’ call to action was a very visible turning point — one could literally see the flags coming down. That implied “what’s next?”, beyond statues. Evolution was as real as Obama had suggested in 2012 with his turnaround on same-sex marriage. (A week after Coates’ column, the Supreme Court made same-sex marriage legal in all fifty states.) What else from our younger, Petty-concert days would now be canceled, called out, disinvited?</p><p>In July 2015, the highest-paid pundits asserted that the 2016 election would be fought like other elections, on issues of taxes, war, government, entitlements, and the usual. They were all wrong. 2016 would be a culture war. The forces of progress combined with the forces of political correctness had become, to conservatives, virtually indistinguishable. They wanted a person to “fight back,” and they found him in a showman who came down an escalator. And most of the people ready to segue from the first black President to the first female President would be blindsided by this culture war’s 2016 outcome.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*2S5bTa0AjjGe2pYJWB-jwg.png" /></figure><p><strong>2016 came down to the election </strong>of Donald Trump over Hillary Clinton in November. For many Americans, this was understood as revenge against cancel culture, wokeness, and social-justice warriors; for many more, the election felt like a death in the family. If Hillary Clinton had been elected President, history books written a century hence might have summarized the decade as a time when America looked itself in the mirror, realized white men hadn’t been doing such a great job, and then hired first a black man and then a woman to run the country. But that’s not our story. The story of the wokade, and particularly the 2016 chapter, is closer to a video game in which the female avatar has to fend off bigger and bigger male-coded monsters, culminating in her challenging some kind of uber-sexist, avowedly pussy-grabbing gorgon…but then the gorgon wins.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/992/1*-oQmK1kdr6MmmtSenk9vKg.jpeg" /></figure><p>When 2016 began, smart money said Republicans would never actually make Donald Trump their nominee. But in this century, partisanship is strong while the parties themselves are weak and vulnerable to demagoguery. Of course, every commentator uses Trump’s victory as evidence that proves their little theory, but I still say: we have to take seriously the possibility that if the wokade hadn’t happened, Republicans would have nominated Jeb Bush or Marco Rubio. Let me contradict what you would think from casual reports, and ask you to consider the possibility that Americans <em>had been</em> paying attention to the events in these timelines here. As I explained in the introduction, Americans have long been watching the mutually reinforcing increase of multiculturalism and political correctness.</p><p>I ask you to take seriously the possibility that the rise of voracious news reader Trump was a reaction to The Affordable Care Act, <em>Avatar</em>, The Tea Party, Elena Kagan, SB1070, <em>The Princess and the Frog</em>, Laura Schlessinger, <em>Glee</em>, Shirley Sherrod, <em>Modern Family</em>, the “Ground Zero Mosque,” Terry Jones, the “Don’t Ask Don’t Tell” repeal, Gabby Giffords, The Arab Spring, Nikki Haley, “Born This Way,” Kobe Bryant, Obama’s birth certificate, the end of <em>Oprah</em> and the rise of <em>Ellen</em>, Miles Morales, Dominique Strauss-Kahn, <em>The Help</em>, Occupy Wall Street, Herman Cain, Linsanity, Trayvon Martin and George Zimmerman, <em>The Hunger Games</em>, Instagram, white supremacist shootings, Michael Strahan, Todd Akin, Mindy Kaling, Mitt Romney, Kendrick Lamar, <em>Django Unchained</em>, a browner and more female Congress, Kanye West and Kim Kardashian, the end of DOMA and the legalization of same-sex marriage, the “Harlem Shake,” Pope Francis, “Lean In,” Jay-Z and Beyoncé, Jason Collins, Paula Deen, Edward Snowden, the 2013 immigration reform bill, Miley Cyrus, Nina Davuluri, <em>12 Years a Slave</em>, microaggressions/trigger warnings/safe spaces, LeBron James, <em>SNL</em> and <em>Star Wars</em>’s fan-demanded diversity, Stephen Colbert, cultural appropriation, Donald Sterling, Serena Williams, Cliven Bundy, Michael Sam, #notallmen, Laverne Cox, Eric Garner and Michael Brown, #blacklivesmatter, Gamergate, Malala Yousefzai, #oscarssowhite, Trevor Noah, Caitlyn Jenner, Rachel Dolezal, sentiment against Confederate flags and statues and some Halloween costumes, Bill Cosby, the San Bernadino shooting, J.K. Rowling, the Flint water crisis, Erin Andrews, Harriet Tubman on $20s, the Orlando shooting, “Hamilton,” the Dallas protests, the distaff <em>Ghostbusters</em>, Colin Kaepernick, and the National Museum of African-American History. If it helps, think of a similar list of events you could probably make from 1963–1968 as a reason why Richard Nixon was elected President. Many of the items on this list were good and/or long overdue. But for the Michael Scotts of America, it was a lot.</p><p>Maybe if it wasn’t for social media, a brutal recession, and a Fox News-led campaign to otherize Barack Obama, this list wouldn’t have convinced America’s Michael Scotts to see themselves as victims…but we can’t “what-if” all day. Those are the things that happened. I ask you to take seriously the possibility that the Michaels of America (and the white women who love them) voted against being made irrelevant to America’s narrative, and/or being canceled as they’d seen happen to nobodies with the wrong online prom dress or like Justine Sacco (in late 2013, she had tweeted “I’m going to Africa, hope I don’t get AIDS!”) Perhaps conservative voters turned to Trump precisely because he was the most stridently against cancel culture. All 17 Republican candidates for the 2016 nomination were nominally opposed to “political correctness,” but only Trump actually had the page about it on his website. Only Trump reliably and outrageously pushed an incendiary envelope every week in 2016, apparently delighting in offending women, black people, Mexican-Americans, the disabled, veterans, Gold Star families, Muslim-Americans, non-binary persons, Jews, and more.</p><p>Woke America, including many journalists, saw the anti-PC, anti-multiculturalism attitude seducing the Republican base, but convinced itself that there was no way anti-wokeness could ever bring the country together. As Trump’s anti-SJW crusading resulted in the worst-reviewed national convention of our time, as Trump “lost” all three debates, the media couldn’t help but exude a smug incredulity: this guy is supposed to win an electoral majority? We know, we know, we know: Clinton actually won by three million votes, and besides, Russian President Vladimir Putin helped Trump. As Pete Buttigieg would later say, in the context of understanding heartland voters, Trump shouldn’t have been able to come within a cheater’s chance of the White House. Somehow the Democratic Party had failed to make the case that it was truly concerned with improving American lives, and I ask you to consider the notion that this failure <em>cannot</em> be separated from wokeness’s increasingly greater stridence during the Obama administration.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/936/1*VknaQzxbzPaCRIKr7o355Q.jpeg" /></figure><p>Liberals should take absolutely no comfort in thinking that the anti-woke are mostly Putin-bots or some kind of rump minority doomed to demographic oblivion. Instead, the second week of November 2016 (should have) carried a very, very difficult lesson for liberal and centrist Americans: You’re Doing It Wrong. If you are an American and one of your goals is to live in a gradually more inclusive and progressive society, if you’re to the left of, say, Senator Susan Collins, then somehow, <strong><em>You’re Doing It Wrong</em></strong>. Think about it: all the social media, all the driving from place to place, all the recipe-sharing, all the child-rearing, all the mindfulness, all the reading, all the working, all the applications, all the donations…and you and we still failed to convince half of non-Californian American voters that, God save us, Donald J. Trump was not in their best interests. For this failure we will be punished by a deeply entrenched, deeply conservative judiciary for generations to come. In a sense, the rise of Trump is a 9/11 of all of our makings. If a fairer, better America is a goal, then the election of Trump should be deeply sobering, and a warning NOT to do things as one has done them pre-2016. Sadly, it’s obvious that not everyone has bothered to heed that warning.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*TG9xCq_ZoZLHlakqf9Eh1w.png" /></figure><p><strong>The most important event of 2017 was</strong> the surge of the #metoo movement. So far, outside of Gamergate, women haven’t figured prominently in this mini-narrative of the 2010s, a point that tracks with the way women were and are taken for granted by male America…until it gets in trouble, of course. But women would have had their own #wokade in the 2010s even if #metoo hadn’t become the <em>thing</em> it became in 2017, a thing that has made some people ask, would we have had #metoo without Trump? Instead we should ask if we would have had #metoo without feminists achieving gradual victories throughout the 2010s, from the mainstreaming of certain terms (e.g. rape culture, male gaze, trigger warnings) to Sheryl Sandberg’s “Lean In” to the stigmatization of pop-culture objectification (e.g. #whatwereyouwearing, #survivorprivilege, #youoksis, and #notbuyingit, the latter of which stopped certain kinds of Bud Light and Carls Jr. ads).</p><p>In 2008, Hillary Clinton avoided mentioning her womanhood; eight years of small, steady feminist victories later, Clinton embraced her status as a woman and a feminist leader in 2016. Her election loss may have been a strangely freeing event for many feminists, who were suddenly (culturally) free to support other female leaders without Clinton’s decades of baggage. One day after Trump’s inauguration, the Women’s March in January 2017 became America’s largest act of civil disobedience, and it represented (inaugurated?) a post-Hillary, more diffuse, more intersectional, more-all-over-the-place, more 2010s-attuned feminism. Maybe #metoo needed Trump because maybe #metoo needed the Women’s March which needed Trump, but the full body of what became the Women’s March came from the many skin cells of female-led accomplishments throughout the century.</p><p>That said, #metoo was a watershed, almost as much of a <em>Hamilton</em>ian “world turned upside down” as Trump’s election had been. Consequences! Finally, consequences. And victims believed! Finally, victims believed. Not often enough, but a lot more than anyone would have thought possible during the pussy-grabbing normalization of 2016. As mentioned, <em>Hamilton</em> includes the lyric “every action has its equal opposite reaction,” and the eventual range of #metoo probably had something to do with the range of frustration with Trump’s misogynistic impunity. In some strange way, if Trump had faced real consequences for his behavior, other famous men might not have faced many post-#metoo consequences for their behavior. On the other hand, not every principle is transitive; the very fact of Trump in the Oval Office affirmed that not everyone deserves the jobs they have.</p><p>Three people who do deserve their jobs are Jodi Kantor and Megan Twohey, working for <em>The</em> <em>New York Times</em>, and Ronan Farrow, working for NBC and then the <em>New Yorker</em>. They began their research into Harvey Weinstein before November 2016. In a time of re-tweeting and aggregate content providers, the three were throwbacks, given the budget to do actual credible journalism. When their Weinstein stories were released in early October 2017, when America learned that one of Hollywood’s biggest moguls was a serial predator and probable rapist, two unprecedented things happened: one, Weinstein was expelled from the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences (who aren’t a formal jury, and don’t have to apply some legal standard), and two, everyone on the post-Breitbart “right” immediately agreed that <em>The New York Times</em> was telling the truth. If #metoo hadn’t blown up, just this one latter aspect had the potential to radically shift American discourse.</p><p>Après leur, le déluge. On October 15, Alyssa Milano (of all people) tweeted probably the most consequential tweet of the decade: “If all the women who have ever been sexually harassed or assaulted wrote ‘Me Too’ as a status, then we give people a sense of the magnitude of the problem.” And people did, and other similar threads popped up, to the point of millions of harassed women standing in solidarity with Milano, finally realizing a goal that Tarana Burke had when she coined the #metoo hashtag a decade earlier. If Trump’s election caused any misgivings about cancel culture, #metoo brought it back with a vengeance. With Weinstein out and Kevin Spacey outed as a comparable predator, with Bill Cosby in court and Bill O’Reilly forceably retired, the #metoo social-media earthquake suggested that there was a very large, even multi-partisan constituency for many, many more consequences.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*oaCHpOaxPpRVRxic035o6g.png" /></figure><p>Before 2017 was over, many A-list figures were accused of inappropriate harassment, and in many cases, these accusations led to firings or changes to media rollouts. Some of the more famous and/or powerful of the accused were Ben Affleck, Casey Affleck, Mario Batali, David Blaine, Louis C.K., Andy Dick, Mark Halperin, Dustin Hoffman, Garrison Keillor, R Kelly, Harry Knowles, Matt Lauer, John Lasseter, Larry Nassar, Jeremy Piven, Roman Polanski, Brett Ratner, Charlie Rose, Bryan Singer, Russell Simmons, Jeffrey Tambor, and Jann Wenner. Reactions and repercussions widely varied; in some cases, genuine contrition seemed to suffice, while in other cases, creepy men were indefinitely “canceled.” Notably, Democrat Al Franken became one of the about five people in American history to peremptorily resign a Senate seat (in his case, over what many considered a joke photo) and a week later, Democrat Doug Jones barely beat credibly accused pedophile Roy Moore in a special December election for a Senate seat in ruby-red Alabama. The fates of Franken and Moore were unimaginable without #metoo.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Tj0a9nxN9REHEIJuKJOJAg.jpeg" /></figure><p>The larger point was a larger conversation. Prior to #metoo, historically, victims of sexual assault were usually given the benefit of the doubt only when the victims were young white women and the accused were black men; #metoo helped change the negative racialization of assault claims. Sexual harassment and sexual assault had obviously been in the news before, identified as systemic problems in the Catholic Church, the U.S. military, and American universities, among other institutions, but the #metoo movement seemed to augur a more generalized willingness to give female victims the benefit of the doubt. Of course, some people would claim this went too far and ask about road maps for redemption, while others insisted that the career alterations of a few powerful people failed to address systematic harassment in working-class America and around the world. Sure. Nonetheless, after #metoo, one felt the earth shifting.</p><p>11 months later, a clash over Supreme Court nominee Brett Kavanaugh was a kind of acid test of how far, or if, #metoo had really shifted the political goalposts. Democrats almost had to double down on being the party that believes women and believes in character deal-breakers, while Republicans almost gleefully doubled down on being the party that believes in harassment and slander of “good people” who tend to be privileged white conservative men. The Kavanaugh hearings wound up as an early Christmas gift to Republicans, who used them to publicize their “victimhood,” hold the Senate, and tip the balance of the Supreme Court. They also probably deepened America’s partisan cleave, a sense that America was now living two entirely different narratives.</p><p>So, after Kavanaugh, could one say that the country had ridden out the #metoo wave, and piggish men in at least half of the country could proceed with business as usual? Not quite. Almost every corporation could still be effectively shamed. Some accused harassers proceeded with comebacks, but many didn’t. Although some liberals derided Trump’s Secretary of Labor Alexander Acosta for saying in 2019 that the climate had changed from the settlement he’d negotiated for Jeffrey Epstein ten years earlier, Acosta had a point. And #metoo was one reason Epstein literally didn’t survive the 2010s.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*TfM0DZhA7HvNmL-cObkaow.png" /></figure><p><strong>The most important story of 2018</strong> <strong>was</strong> the Trump administration policy of separating asylum-seeking families at the U.S.-Mexico border. The popular outrage against this policy came to a head in June 2018, three years to the day after Trump descended a Trump Tower escalator to announce, one, his bid for President, and two, “When Mexico sends its people…They’re bringing drugs. They’re bringing crime. They’re rapists. And some, I assume, are good people.” When even Trump’s staunchest Republican allies privately told him that he couldn’t simply keep separating asylum-seeking refugee parents from children, on June 20, 2018, President Trump reversed his assertion that an executive order couldn’t fix the problem, and signed an executive order ending family separations at the border. In another administration, this might have been a definitive pivot; in this one, it was more of a feint. America’s policy of separating, incarcerating, losing, and sometimes killing brown refugee children had a long history before and after June 20, 2018, but this <em>was</em> the year that America came to accept such heartless cruelty as the new normal.</p><p>President George W. Bush announced a “zero tolerance” approach for illegal immigrants, but often made exceptions. President Obama, trying to curry favor with conservatives, became known as the “Deporter in Chief,” a title he could still claim three years into a Trump administration that deported fewer immigrants than he had. Obama considered a policy of separating asylum-seeking parents from their kids, but never formally adopted it, and in cases where families were separated, Obama’s DHS/ICE made sure to reunite families within 21 days.</p><p>During its first year, DHS Secretary John Kelly confirmed, then denied, that the Trump administration was considering family separation as a potential deterrent. In June 2017, Trump ended the Family Case Management Program, an Obama initiative that kept mothers and their children out of detention. In 2018, Americans would learn that at least 700 children, 100 of them under the age of 4, were separated from their parents just in October 2017. After conflicting reports throughout 2017, new DHS Secretary was called before Congress in January 2018, where she refused to rule out family separation. In response, more than 200 family-welfare organizations signed a public letter warning that prolonged family separation would traumatize innocent children for life.</p><p>Perhaps hoping to cut through the clutter, on April 6, 2018, Attorney General Jeff Sessions announced a new sort of “zero-tolerance policy for all offenses” related to entering the United States illegally, implying that the misdemeanor of illegal entry would now be prosecuted something like a capital crime, presumably excusing policies like family separation. On May 7, 2018, Sessions said, “If you’re smuggling a child, then we’re going to prosecute you, and that child will be separated from you, probably, as required by law.” And yet multiple accounts, including direct testimony from detained migrants to Congress, revealed that even lawful asylum-seeking families were being separated. On Sunday, June 17, three years to the day after a white supremacist massacred churchgoing African-Americans in Charleston, Senator Susan Collins said that Secretary Nielsen had testified that lawful asylum-seeking families would not be separated, and yet, continued Collins, “there are numerous credible media accounts showing that exactly is happening, and the administration needs to put an end to that right off.” Later that day, in a clear response, Secretary Nielsen tweeted, “We do not have a policy of separating families at the border. Period.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/599/1*aOQ35-y-6Le5g3jBbmoWsw.png" /></figure><p>The next two days were a media maelstrom, not least because of Trump defenders’ incoherence. They and Trump often said that Obama had had the same policy, which wasn’t true, but even if it were true, why keep that one protocol in place while making a big show out of reversing almost all of Obama’s other policies? If the point was deterrence, why not own it? Did Republicans support separation of law-abiding families, or not? (Most Americans absolutely opposed it, although a majority of polled Republicans supported it.) At some point that week, Trump got the message that the separation of lawful families was hurting his other border goals, like building the Wall, and on June 20 he issued an executive order that halted the policy…or did he?</p><p>June 20 should have been the beginning of border-policy accountability; instead, it was the end. Very few of the <em>hundreds</em> of separated families were ever reunited, and July made it clear that the Trump administration never had any plans or spreadsheets or preserved data to facilitate reunions. Wild theories about state-endorsed black-market adoptions began to seem as credible as any other explanation. Democrats used “there are kids in cages!” as a 2018 talking point, which was a slight exaggeration; in fact the holding facilities were closer to the sort of military-ish barracks that many American kids would recognize from overnight camping. Still, would you want to be in a camp indefinitely, away from your parents, with minimal meals, aluminum blankets, and no temperature regulation during Texas’ scorching summers and frigid winters?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*XL0dVY6-9pFk_QrXkpeyXA.jpeg" /></figure><p>That fall, a caravan of migrants made its way to the US border, a fact that was so heavily demagogued by the Fox News-led blogosphere that liberals accused conservatives of paying the migrants. As the war-fleeing Guatemalans and Hondurans made their way north through Mexico to the United States, one saw hints that Americans might begin to distinguish between people from, and American policies toward, different Latin American countries. Maybe we could distinguish between the very few border-crossers and the much higher percentage of visa-overstayers who had entered legally through airports. Maybe we could attempt a productive conversation about immigration compromises…but no. A brown mass was coming over the southern border, scarcely more human (or less dangerous) than a cancer from the south of the body, and politically correct liberals had made America powerless to stop it. Certainly, Trump could hardly be expected to do more than bully our Southern neighbors.</p><p>Actually, the November elections suggested that few non-conservatives really “bought” this narrative when Democrats flipped forty House seats. Nonetheless, the fact that most conservatives “bought” this narrative was shocking enough. In the distant past of, say, 2014, evangelical Christians were on record as helping strangers. Asylum centers were packed with congregations offering assistance, perhaps hoping to bring a few new converts into the laity. That was still true in 2018, but the services were mostly held by Catholics and Baptists; charitable evangelicals were getting harder and harder to find. Maybe, possibly, the combination of the #wokade and Trump’s combative reaction to it had alienated them from helping brown people. If so, evangelicals, like conservatives more generally, appeared to be trading short-term “gain” for long-term losses. Think of the moral authority of George Takei, who was a boy in an American-run concentration camp. Now, multiply that authority by thousands, twenty years from now.</p><p>In 2019, several facts were confirmed by the Trump administration, among them that at least 1,712 children were separated from their families before Sessions’ “zero-tolerance” announcement, and that at least 700 more children were separated from their families <em>after</em> the June 20 executive order. Did Donald Trump personally direct the circumvention of his own orders? That has never been made clear. What is clear is that somehow, someway, during the summer of 2018, even liberal Americans accustomed themselves to the vast mistreatment of brown people near our Southern border, including the separation of at least 3000 children from their families. In this and in other areas, the woke found genuine, often unexpected, heartbreaking limits.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3pUsruVPKPt_aj5Ze5P6Xg.png" /></figure><p><strong>The most important events of 2019 came</strong> in the dead of winter, during about a month from mid-January to mid-February: the comeuppance of the woke and reconciliation with the less woke. These were the weeks of the concluded government shutdown over the Wall, the viral video of the clash of Indigenous People and Covington Catholic kids, the alleged assault on Jussie Smollett, the blackface/sexual assault crisis in Virginia’s statehouse, the boycotted Grammy Awards, and what became the <em>Bohemian Rhapsody/Green Book</em> Oscars. Taken together, the events incorporated many of the larger themes of the decade: immigration, abortion, race, religion, gender, sexuality, sexual harassment, hate crimes, attacking children, confronting the past, and the battle over purple states. By the time of Abraham Lincoln’s 210thbirthday on February 12th, 2019, we had seen surprising evidence of how and why his divided house was having so much trouble standing…and the spirit of forgiveness and cognitive dissonance that would probably be needed to preserve it.</p><p>Before January 18, it seemed that January would be defined by the government shutdown that, on January 12, officially became America’s longest-ever closure. On December 22, President Trump, understanding the record numbers of women and POC that were coming to Washington, played the last card in his hand before the House flipped to Democrats: he closed the government until Democrats agreed to fund his long-promised Wall at the Southern border. Democrats, independents, and even some Republicans read the polls and understood the issue to be a loser for Trump and “borderline racist” against Latinos (if you get my meaning). By January 18, it was clear that Trump would have to cave, and he did on January 25; by that time, probably to Trump’s relief, America was talking about something else.</p><p>The Lincoln Memorial events of January 18, 2019, have been told and retold and re-re-told to serve different agendas; summarizing them here is difficult, because one’s perception of the events’ chronology alters one’s perception of the events. As the symbol and gathering place of our wonderful country, Washington D.C. welcomes groups of all stripes, implying that we can live together in harmony and, perhaps, find unexpected commonalities. On that Friday, D.C. hosted both an Indigenous People’s March and March for Life, each meant to raise awareness of entirely different things (respectively, injustices to Native Americans and resistance to abortion). Once, we weren’t a country where your support of an Indigenous People’s March or your support of a March For Life predicted your opinion on dozens of other issues and predicted your reaction to what you perceived as abuse of your “side” but…now we are.</p><p>As the cold afternoon wound down, the marchers dissipated, including a large group of Covington Catholic High School boys (it’s an all-male school) wearing “Make America Great Again” hats. Although many didn’t know this when they first heard of the incident, as the kids waited for their charter bus to arrive, nearby Black Hebrew Israelites taunted them with racial slurs. When conservatives complain that white men are blamed for everything now, liberals usually laugh; liberals do NOT usually mention the fringe members of the Black Hebrew Israelites who stand on street corners and actively, loudly, blame white men for slavery and oppression. Unlike your support for indigenous rights or laws against abortion, support for Black Hebrew Israelites is <em>not</em> neatly mapped onto American political schisms; on that day, they were an X-factor that was also a fuse as they, according to video, taunted the students as “a bunch of incest babies,” future “school shooters,” “dirty ass little crackers,” and the sorts that “give faggots rights.” When a black man confronted them, they called him a coon; when a woman confronted them, they demanded to speak to her husband.</p><p>Defensively, the Kentucky schoolkids chanted their school spirit songs, including their school’s version of a Maori haka. Nathan Phillips, a member of the Omaha tribe and participant in the indigenous march, listened to the chants and conflict for several minutes until, he later explained, he felt compelled to step in to ease the escalating tensions. Imposing themselves into the scene, Phillips and other Native Americans played drums (of peace, one assumes) and sang an inter-tribal song. For a while, the teenage boys sang along (in their white way), but tensions arose, and at some point several of the boys encircled Phillips, and the day’s initial viral video was captured as Phillips chanted into the smiling (smirking?) face of a MAGA-hat-wearing boy named Nicholas Sandmann, who later explained that his expression meant “that I was not going to become angry, intimidated or be provoked into a larger confrontation.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/421/1*kcZ6rQA6JoTLXo6hqWq7gg.jpeg" /></figure><p>There were a lot of later explanations, and there were a lot of later later explanations of the earlier explanations. Many of these were from prominent left-wing tweeters and (if you must) social-justice warriors who regretted their first reactions, like Kathy Griffin and Jim Carrey, as well as media sources, including Vulture (“I just want these [Covington kids] to die”), CNN (“some [kids] can also be punched in the face”), <em>The Washington Post</em>, and <em>The New York Times</em>, the latter publishing the headline “Boys in ‘Make America Great Again’ Hats Mob Native Elder at Indigenous Peoples March.” The 24-hour-news-and-outrage cycle clashed with the era of YouTube-boosted, teen-encouraged, Fourth-Amendment-breaching ubiquitous surveillance, and of course the latter won. Liberals avoided besmirching black Jews while attacking <em>Catholics</em>, perhaps forgetting that Latino and Irish Catholics are (were) some of their staunchest allies, not to be lumped in with evangelicals who could and did gleefully exploit the confusion.</p><p>Call it <em>Rashomon</em> in real time; as events became clearer over that Martin Luther King Day weekend, some changed their opinions, while others clung harder to their pre-existing biases. The most famous image, of Sandmann and Phillips almost nose to nose, came from a video by Guam resident Kaya Taitano, who claimed to have heard the Covington boys shouting “build the wall.” No video of this chant was ever found. Many prominent liberals fell back on comparing MAGA hats to Nazi symbols, but even if that were true, SJWs had become quite the snowflakes since defending the Supreme Court’s Skokie decision to allow Nazis to display their foolishness through marches. Worse, some online activists doxxed the students, to the point where Covington Catholic High closed for a day.</p><p>And then…it happened again. Well, not exactly: on January 29, B-list <em>Empire</em> actor Jussie Smollett, who is an out, gay African-American, appeared before Chicago police wearing a noose, explaining that he had been attacked by two white men who were “yelling out racial and homophobic slurs” and who “poured an unknown chemical substance on” him and beat him “about the face with their hands.” Media pundits, as well as figures as impressive as Shonda Rhimes, Viola Davis, Ava Duvernay, Kamala Harris, and Cory Booker, tweeted messages of support for Smollett and horror at what was done to him.</p><p>The Chicago Police Department was already America’s most criticized police force because of recurrent gang violence. Slowly, the CPD realized it had been duped. Smollett had paid two Nigerian-American brothers to stage an attack on him, apparently to bring attention to the genuine problem of racist and homophobic hate crimes. Instead, Smollett achieved something like the opposite, giving conservatives a bludgeon with which to beat back hate crime concerns.</p><p>In two famous incidents within two weeks, conservatives were able to claim liberal hypocrisy, right-wing victimhood, and even their own suddenly famous teenagers, 11 months after tragedy and talent turned a few liberal students at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High into major media figures, causing not a few major influencers to sigh that the young will save us, as though no young people ever wore MAGA hats. The timing was auspicious for the activist right: on the second anniversary of the Women’s March, on the 46th anniversary of Roe vs. Wade, with a new Catholic justice beginning on the Supreme Court, the “pro-lifers” could consolidate Catholics and martyrdom as they readied for their first realistic chance to repeal Roe. (A century ago, Catholics and Jews on the Supreme Court were unthinkable; with the ascension of Kavanaugh, the Court became nothing <em>but</em> Catholics and Jews.)</p><p>The wokade can’t be understood without understanding the war over abortion. As conservatives feel victimized by many of the developments in the paragraphs above, their fundraising can always fall back on liberals supposedly slaughtering thousands of babies. (For millennia, frustrated men have taken out frustrations on women.) “Replacement theory” becomes palpable argument; conservatives can argue that liberals care more about brown kids coming over the border than white kids in utero. In this environment, every little slight becomes magnified, and every little measure becomes justified.</p><p>On January 30, the Democratic governor of Virginia was asked to explain his state’s proposed legislation on abortion, and replied, “the infant would be resuscitated if that’s what the mother and the family desired, and then a discussion would ensue between the physicians and the mother.” Conservative news organizations decided that these comments endorsed infanticide, and some of the most ardent activists decided to dig for doxx-worthy dirt on this heretofore obscure governor. Two days later, on February 1, every American national news organization published a newly unearthed image from Virginia Governor Ralph Northam’s 1984 medical school yearbook of two men — one in blackface, one wearing a Ku Klux Klan hood. In one sense, these sorts of revelations are the definition of bad faith — conservatives deploy wokeness and “cancel culture” against its liberal proponents. In another sense, these sorts of revelations are the definition of faith, faith in a conservative God that wouldst smite its enemies. Within a day, another yearbook photo was unearthed, this from 1981, showing Northam’s nickname was “Coonman.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/760/1*q9bk2n-WcGKJg-pCJBGavQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>On February 3, the Patriots beat the Rams in Atlanta in Super Bowl LIII. The next day, for the first time since white supremacists marched in Charlottesville in August 2017, the eyes of America turned to the Old Dominion. Ralph Northam became America’s most famous governor amidst bipartisan calls for him to resign and morning-talk-show-led conversations about when blackface was ever acceptable and what sort of actions should be forgivable. More than a few liberals seemed readier to defend a (then) 25-year-old medical student in blackface and a 36-year-old gay black actor who’d faked a hate crime than a 16-year-old smiling white boy in a MAGA hat.</p><p>Lieutenant Governor Justin Fairfax, also a Democrat, notified his family that he was ready to step in as governor if and when Northam resigned. And then, on February 3, a right-wing site revealed that a Scripps professor named Vanessa Tyson had accused Fairfax of sexual assault in 2004. Fairfax called the encounter consensual and blamed the story on an anonymous supporter of Northam. (A more organized right wing might have held the revelation until Northam had resigned.) On February 6, Tyson, a Democrat, came forward with details of her allegations. Also on February 6, Democrat Mark Herring, Virginia’s Attorney General, admitted to wearing blackface (as part of a costume of Kurtis Blow) while a 19-year-old student at University of Virginia. Of Virginia’s three top elected officials, one was black, and two were white men who had pretended to be black. Northam apologized for appearing in the photo, mentioned he’d also impersonated Michael Jackson in the 1980s, then reversed himself and claimed he wasn’t in the photo.</p><p>Virginia’s Constitution made clear the line of succession to governor: lieutenant governor, attorney general, then Speaker of the State House, who was in this case a Republican named Kirk Cox, who told the press, “I have never been in blackface, unequivocal.” On February 7, CNN published a <em>very</em> partial list of non-canceled celebrities who had worn blackface, a list that included Drake, Robert Downey Jr., Joni Mitchell, Jimmy Fallon, Jimmy Kimmel, Julianne Hough, Billy Crystal, Sarah Silverman, Gene Wilder, and Ted Danson. On February 8, a second woman, Meredith Watson, came forward to say that Fairfax had raped her in 2000 when both were students at Duke University. Once the primary battleground of the Civil War, Virginia was suddenly the primary battleground in the culture wars.</p><p>This echoed what was then happening in the entertainment industry. The Grammy Awards, the music industry’s top honors, had a long history of sidelining hip-hop and black artists more generally in favor of more vanilla artists. This came to a tipping point with the results in 2018, with several artists making clear that they wouldn’t return in 2019. On February 7, 2019, Ariana Grande joined, among others, Kendrick Lamar, Drake, and Childish Gambino (who would become the first major Grammy winner of the decade not to attend) in boycotting the awards that would take place that Sunday; Grande tweeted that Grammys producer Ken Ehrlich was lying about the date being “too late for her to pull something together,” saying that instead her “creativity &amp; self expression was stifled by” Ehrlich. Was it time for woke America to cancel the Grammys? Well…that Sunday, February 10, host Alicia Keys clearly wanted to suggest otherwise, using her opening monologue to bring to the stage no less than Jennifer Lopez, Lady Gaga, Jada Pinkett Smith, and (!) Michelle Obama. Keys struck an empathetic tone with the skeptical as she beatifically said “I got you”; did she really, though?</p><p>In a sense, the same question was being asked of <em>Bohemian Rhapsody</em> and <em>Green Book</em>, multiple Oscar nominees on their way to dominating the 91st Academy Awards. We often hear laments that Hollywood is afraid to invest in anything but pre-branded franchises; here were two original hits that…weren’t exactly getting love on Twitter, and not only because of their mediocre Rotten Tomatoes scores. By February, <em>Bohemian Rhapsody</em> was history’s highest-grossing biopic, but did it get that way by portraying its bisexual lead, Freddie Mercury, as good when he romanced females and bad when he romanced men? Also, the film was directed by Bryan Singer, who was supposed to be canceled over alleged sexual assaults of <em>minors</em>. Nothing about <em>Green Book</em> was quite that problematic, but every word of the script could have been written fifty years before; it was an old-school road-trip-buddy-comedy (somewhat) true story, about a working-class white driver and his famous black employer learning life lessons from each other in 1962. <em>Green Book</em>was, as Mark Harris wrote, “a <em>but also</em> movie, a <em>both sides</em> movie” that skirted near White Savior and Magical Negro tropes…tropes that audiences and Oscar voters probably never heard of, as the Academy made clear when it awarded <em>Green Book</em> Best Picture on February 24. Mahershala Ali, already the first Muslim American to win an Oscar, won his second for <em>Green Book</em> on the same night that Rami Malek became the first Egyptian-American to win an Oscar, for playing LGBT icon Freddie Mercury…wasn’t that woke enough?</p><p>In other words, from mid-January to mid-February, woke liberals fought with other liberals and apologized to conservatives, and it was in that context that Virginia’s political crisis slowly eased. If the Democratic Party were truly run by Twitter or its most radical members (as the President claims it is), all three of Virginia’s top Democrats — Northam, Fairfax, and Herring — would have been as canceled as MySpace. However, no one could <em>force</em> Northam or Herring to resign; blackface is not a statutory crime. (If it were, sunblock and makeup would be a lot more regulated.) On the other hand, assault <em>is</em> a crime, and one Virginia Democrat, Patrick Hope, threatened to begin impeachment proceedings against Fairfax…only to back off after the Party sat down with him. Considering the history of black men suffering false accusations of assault, considering that blackface was historically used by whites to declare their superiority to such accusations, how would it look if two white men with a history of blackface kept their jobs while the one black man was forced from his? White liberals had been “more woke” than black liberals for a few years now (see the link below), but this was the first time elected Democrats used that piece of data as a lifeline, pointing to the higher percentages of black people that wanted Northam to keep his job. Black pundits said black people had a history of being more practical.</p><p>Realpolitick met realhistory, and the result was the status quo. No one resigned. Later in 2019, at least three photos emerged of Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau in blackface; Trudeau promptly apologized, and weeks later, won re-election. Not long after, in November 2019, Democrats swept the Virginia statehouse, ending Virginia’s status as a purple state and putting Virginia firmly in Democratic control. What did we learn, or re-learn, from Virginia’s leaders, liberal and conservative doxxers, know-it-all pundits, Jussie Smollett, Drake, Kaya Taitano, Alicia Keys, Ariana Grande, Mahershala Ali, Rami Malek, the kids of Coventry Catholic, the Black Hebrew Israelites, the Indigenous March, and the ongoing war over abortion?</p><p>An honest appraisal would say that we learned, or re-learned, that human beings are messy. We were reminded that two things can be true at the same time, that a single person can do wrong and right things. Virginian Thomas Jefferson kept and abused slaves <em>but also</em> changed the world for the better when he wrote “All men are created equal” and created the University of Virginia in Charlottesville. There, in the <em>second</em>-most important event of 2017 (after #metoo), a “Unite the Right” rally was organized to protect statues of men like Jefferson, occasioning a leftist opposition campaign that included Heather Heyer, who was killed. President Trump was vilified as a Nazi appeaser for saying there were good people on both sides, but (and it pains me to admit this) he actually had a point: some of the statue-defenders were not unrepentant racists. Some of them were closer to Justine Sacco or Condoleeza Rice or Michael Scott from “The Office,” more ignorant than hateful. (However, next time they <em>really</em> shouldn’t march with racists and anti-Semites.)</p><p>If you haven’t read Yascha Mounk’s <em>Atlantic</em> article <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2018/10/large-majorities-dislike-political-correctness/572581/">about the woke versus the resentful, you should</a>. Because the data from a yearslong study is in, and “Among the general population, a full 80 percent believe that ‘political correctness is a problem in our country.’” And this isn’t just people telling pollsters “I don’t like PC”; this is half of Latinos saying that people are too sensitive to how Muslims are treated, this is two in five black people saying that current immigration is bad for America, and much more. Just (re)read it after you finish the next paragraph.</p><p>Three months after the incendiary “Unite the Right” rally, Ralph Northam was elected governor partly in a spirit of reconciliation. Did Northam betray that trust in February 2019, during University of Virginia’s bicentennial year? Maybe. Nicholas Sandmann and Nathan Phillips and Jussie Smollett and Ariana Grande reminded us that narratives can be misleading. Justin Trudeau wore blackface and misled Canada <em>but also</em> built the most diverse cabinet in Canada’s history and fights for human rights; the woke have few more powerful allies. 2019 affirmed the need for a certain degree of cognitive dissonance, which means maintaining two contradictory ideas at the same time. Cancel culture is populist and often helpful, because a lot of canceled people can be easily replaced by more enlightened people. But let’s end the narrative of the wokade this way: cancel culture must ultimately be partly decoupled from the sort of wokeness that plans on ultimately distinguishing between the truly racist and the merely ignorant.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=624daa60e3e2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Privacy Is The New Smoking]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@danielsmithrowsey/privacy-is-the-new-smoking-b6c56e9f6e81?source=rss-eebf3c706f43------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b6c56e9f6e81</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[accountability]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[democrats]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[transparency]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[privacy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Daniel Smith-Rowsey]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 18 Apr 2019 04:58:35 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-04-18T04:58:35.802Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Privacy is the new smoking.</p><p>Which means that transparency and accountability are the new non-smoking.</p><p>Which means that most of the media about politics fails to understand current politics, much less predict what’s going to happen in 2020. I am writing this to help them.</p><p>One can see this in recent coverage of Beto O’Rourke. Many polls have him ranked a close third behind Joe Biden and Bernie Sanders, which is rather remarkable considering their much, much larger name recognition. 99 out of 100 TV-level journalists will tell you that’s because of O’Rourke’s white male privilege.</p><p>I want to tell you a different story. During his failed campaign for Ted Cruz’s Senate seat, O’Rourke used a sort of radical transparency that’s very familiar to young social-media-savvy oversharers, but had been mostly unknown to most politicians. And…I believe enough people are responding to make a difference in the polls. And…to make a difference in the eventual 2020 result. Transparency is the new not-smoking.</p><p>This is very hard for me to write. I’ve been advocating for more privacy for most of this decade. I’ve been showing my undergrads <em>Citizenfour </em>for five years now; that’s the Oscar-winning documentary about Edward Snowden revealing to America that the U.S. government systematically violates most of its citizens’ Fourth Amendment rights.</p><p>I noticed that the <em>New York Times</em> recently devoted a few columns to something it calls <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/opinion/internet-privacy-project.html">The Privacy Project</a>. Awwwwwww, these columnists are super-adorable. I’ve made all their arguments and a lot more in a regular lecture that explains in excruciating detail 26 things under threat of transparency that we desperately need to keep private. Here’s a very very rudimentary summary (I notice my students remember information better in letter format):</p><p>A. Attorney-client privilege B. Bathrooms C. Coitus/copulation</p><p>D. Doctor-patient privilege E. Education records F. Financial records</p><p>G. Governmental secrets H. Hiring/firing criteria I. Internet browser history</p><p>J. Jokes online K. Kid nudity (e.g. at beach) L. Location-based services</p><p>M. Medical information N. Narcotic history O. Overexposure of kids</p><p>P. Porn/onanism choices Q. Questionable choices R. Romantic choices/plans</p><p>S. Salary information T. Therapist discussions U. Undisclosed hiding places</p><p>V. Votes/voting W. Witness protection X. X-punging from the record</p><p>Y. Your family/personal secrets Z. Zippers-down nudity</p><p>Let me tell you how my students have been reacting to my 26 pleas for privacy for more than five years now: yawwwwwn. Sure, that could be my fault. But consider for a <em>moment </em>the possibility that my students are representing the new generation when they say they really don’t care about privacy. And that they have good reasons for trust issues.</p><p>So…I’m surrendering to them, or at least trying to see it from their perspective, and I encourage the <em>New York Times </em>writers to do something similar. I haven’t given up on the Fourth Amendment or on fighting for those 26 things but…it’s time to acknowledge that privacy to them is like smoking sections were to us 30 years ago. I mean, it’s not that we won’t preserve some, somewhere, somehow. But…remember how we (born before 1980) grew up accepting, yet not accepting, smoking sections as a front for toxicity? They’ve grown up seeing privacy as a rather similar (af)front.</p><p>Why? Well, perhaps the most important and least partisan societal trend since 2000 is the demystification and deglamorization of elites. In the 20th century, politicians, network anchors, business leaders, A-list actors, and almost any “expert” who appeared on TV maintained a certain mystique. Who were we to question anyone who, say, appeared on Oprah? And if you did question them, before 2000, you had no instantly available community to confirm your skepticism of mainstream values. Now that you have that community, along with the fact that everyone googles their maladies and overshares on YouTube or a reality show or social media, the very notion of expertise isn’t what it was. How smart could these famous people be? They look and sound just like us. They make typos and bad jokes just like us.</p><p>Skepticism of expertise, of course, has been reinforced by this century’s record of elites and technocrats and experts. How’d they do on 9/11? How about Hurricane Katrina? What about the 2008 financial crisis? How were they at predicting the 2016 election? Ronald Reagan once famously said that the nine most terrifying words in the English language were “I’m from the government and I’m here to help.” But that needs updating. The new most terrifying nine words are “I’m rich or anointed, trust me, I got this.”</p><p>Partly because of so many systemic failures through 2008, transparency-accountability is happening whether high-earning people like it or not. It’s the Yelp-ification of everything. It’s happening on Uber and Lyft, where drivers and passengers rate each other. It’s happening on Airbnb, where renters and guests rate each other. It’s happening in colleges, on ratemyprofessor.com and other places. It’s happening with the increasing ubiquity of drones and of cameras in all kinds of places, including on police officers. All this bottom-up accountability eventually exerts itself against the one percent. Eventually the question becomes: why can we hold drivers, renters, professors, plumbers, carpenters, restaurant employees, and cops accountable, but not the one-percent? Why are they worth so much more, anyway?</p><p>Again, it’s a mistake to see the push against privacy as partisan. The push toward same-sex marriage was driven by partisan energy; this isn’t that. People of all political persuasions are increasingly against privacy because elites from both major parties have failed again and again. When it <em>seems </em>as though anyone on youtube or reality TV could do better…sorry for this cliché, but that’s how you get Trump.</p><p>Oh, I’ve repeatedly warned my undergrads about the dangers of the big tech companies knowing everything about them. But I believe the notion of GAFA (Google, Apple, Facebook, Amazon) mining and monetizing all their data isn’t exactly what bothers them…it’s more that they should be able to mine and monetize it too. They know perfectly well that GAFA and every other Fortune 500 company are in the process of replacing them with AI-enabled robots; is it really fair, they ask, that those robots are enabled to make intellectual connections that normal people are prevented from making?</p><p>Most elite journalists and pundits don’t think or write much about anti-elitism or privacy or transparency. Gee, I wonder why? Most don’t see how big and non-partisan this cultural shift really is. And when some of them do, as with the <em>New York Times </em>privacy project, well, they sound as atavistic as one of my lectures. I appreciate the support but…at this point they’re fighting for smoking sections. It’s a noble fight, in its way. It’s properly libertarian. But it also would have been crazy in 2000 (or now) to support the overtly pro-smoking candidate.</p><p>So…when my friends talk about the virtues of this or that Democratic nominee, I just think: who’s going to show his or her taxes? Who’s going to reveal all their donors? Who’s going to post online all of their grades? Who’s going to have the least to worry about when Trump <em>again </em>threatens to publish a “tell-all” book? I am hoping it’ll be more candidates than just Beto. The mainstream press has at least realized that Trump’s level of depravity means that this will be something like the 1976 election. But that same press has failed to remember that James Carter won that election by telling America, “I will never lie to you.”</p><p>Metaphorically speaking, in 2020 Trump will be a candidate with a cigarette in his mouth. The cigarette will be his insistence on privacy — about his taxes, frauds, side deals, non-recorded conversations with Putin, etc. The Dem on the other side of the stage can’t be someone with another metaphorical cigarette.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b6c56e9f6e81" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Raceschach Test: What’s Between Woke and Racist?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@danielsmithrowsey/raceschach-test-whats-between-woke-and-racist-8ab2a93aedfe?source=rss-eebf3c706f43------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8ab2a93aedfe</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[native-americans]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[maga]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[covington]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lincoln-memorial]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Daniel Smith-Rowsey]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 22 Jan 2019 14:33:05 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-01-22T14:33:05.426Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Abortion. School choice. Indigenous People. Black Hebrews. Building the wall. Martin Luther King. MAGA hats. Veterans’ issues. <em>Vietnam </em>veterans’ issues. Religious persecution. <em>Catholic </em>persecution. Gun control.</p><p>It’s not easy to condense so many important topics into a one-minute viral video, but that’s exactly what happened last weekend…in real time. In this decade, when have so many issues, and differing perspectives on them, been found on any video outside of a Ryan Murphy show? If you don’t know that name, Ryan Murphy is one of Netflix’s highest-paid employees, the creative force behind <em>Glee, American Horror Story, American Crime Story</em>(<em>O.J. Simpson</em>and <em>Gianni Versace</em>), and <em>Pose</em>. Perhaps the most important takeaway of any Ryan Murphy show is: everyone has their reasons. Few people are strictly evil.</p><p>In 2018 Murphy used Gianni Versace’s name to shine a brighter light on the man who killed him in cold blood, a bisexual serial killer named Andrew Cunanan. For this, Murphy’s show has been the darling of the awards circuit, including Emmys and some Golden Globes two weeks ago. Is anyone accusing Murphy of not being woke enough? Or of acting in bad faith? If so, I haven’t seen it. We understand that Murphy activates our empathy (even) for those with whom we don’t normally empathize.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FYuV7Cu8ADyc%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DYuV7Cu8ADyc&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FYuV7Cu8ADyc%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/88f6bf0c3a518271d24075e921fe72e7/href">https://medium.com/media/88f6bf0c3a518271d24075e921fe72e7/href</a></iframe><p>Remember that when you consider your takeaways from the Covington-Phillips viral video of Martin Luther King Jr. weekend 2019, which also happens to be the 46thanniversary of the Roe vs. Wade decision, which <em>also </em>happens to be the weekend of the Indigenous People’s March <em>and </em>the 3rd annual Women’s March. First question: how are so many people willing to march in such frigid weather? Were they all relying on global warming? (Okay, that’s one issue too far.)</p><p>If you don’t know what happened, or aren’t sure, a good place to start is with <a href="https://twitter.com/lisasharper/status/1087174914673655809">this</a> explanation by a self-identified liberal, Lisa Sharon Harper. According to her, the Black Hebrews say incendiary things to the (mostly) white Catholic teens, who start chanting school slogans, and Native American Nathan Phillips tries to defuse the situation with his own chants and drum, and some of the teens behave inappropriately to him, his fellow Native Americans, and to the Black Hebrews. Sure.</p><p>I have seen Harper’s thread cited as evidence against <em>The New York Times </em>“both-sides”-ing the incident. But I agree with every word Harper wrote, and I still have a problem with the way many liberals reacted to this, including close friends of mine who were motivated to write letters to the school’s principal. I don’t doubt my friends’ good intentions, and I don’t doubt that these kids might have done better if they’d have handled this differently. But…there have been way too many liberals who have projected onto these kids an evil and menace that they never evinced. For example, how many said that the kids said “Build the wall!”? The videos provide no evidence of that.</p><p>Although some conservatives are accusing Nathan Phillips of performing the role of a professional instigator, I believe he provides a welcome perspective, and as someone who teaches the movie <em>Reel Injun </em>every semester, I can tell you that we need more famous Native Americans. To me, Phillips’ comparison of these Catholic students to his experiences in Vietnam rings true. But…</p><p>Ever heard of Charlie Kirk? He’s an asshat who carries water for anything Donald Trump does, and I only followed him (<strong>back</strong>) on Twitter because I like hearing perspectives beyond my own liberal bubble. Every single time I’ve commented to him (look it up), I’ve excoriated his hypocrisy and slime. But…Charlie Kirk makes a solid point <a href="https://twitter.com/charliekirk11/status/1087420048560467968">here</a> when he says “the same media who told us not to critique Parkland students are doxxing 16 years olds for doing absolutely nothing wrong.” We could quibble with “nothing wrong,” but if you’re one of the millions who “liked” any social-media post that told conservatives to “stop attacking children” (or similar) when those children were activist Parkland students, and then you turned around and attacked these Covington kids…yeah, you’re an enormous hypocrite. Don’t stop reading this post!…we still need you.</p><p>I realize that some (not many) of my liberal friends haven’t attacked the kids, saving their ammunition for the supervisors and teachers and parents. That’s more legitimate. But I do feel that many people (of all partisan persuasions) jumped to conclusions before seeing more of the story. I saw many conservatives, like Rich Lowry and S.E. Cupp, apologize. I haven’t seen too many liberals apologize; instead they’re doubling down by, for example, comparing MAGA hats to swastikas in terms of being inherently aggressive/intolerant. I’ll say this: if you can point to some pre-2019 post where you made such a comparison, then I’ll respect that you see it that way. If not, that’s a convenient ethical retcon, which doesn’t go well with saying, “uhhh…okay but I was still right all along.”</p><p>We liberals have to be aware of the perception of moving goalposts. Ten years ago, “blacks” called each other “blacks” (go back and read <em>anything </em>written then) but now it’s insensitive to say “blacks” instead of “black people.” President Obama and Hillary Clinton opposed same-sex marriage in 2012. Even in the relatively simple matter of finding an Oscar host, it feels like standards of political correctness have changed from when Chris Rock hosted the show…three years ago. I don’t see “PC” as changing the rules, I see us getting better as a society, but I think we all benefit by noticing that for some, it feels like rule-changing.</p><p>Looking at these Covington kids in the videos, yes, I see a lot of white boys marching to control women’s bodies. Yes, I see them chanting along with a Native American in a way that might be called culturally inappropriate. (There’s no heavy tomahawk-chops; just a lot of painfully Caucasian hip-hop movements.) Yes, I see them responding to a black Hebrew asking if they have “any n****s” with “yeah, we have one!” Yes, I see their MAGA hats. And I can say with some confidence that all of their teachers and parents grew up in a world where none of that was remotely inappropriate…no matter where they were raised. Ideally, should we bring these kids into the present? YES! Is attacking them the best way to do it? I doubt it! Instead of eviscerating these kids, we ought to be looking for ways to persuade them to do better in the future. They’re children!</p><p>Joe Walsh is a Tea Party conservative and, as of recently, a #nevertrumper. He wants a wall. He hates gun control. He’s against the ACA. Outside of Trump, he and I really don’t agree on anything. But now I’m really going to get people mad at me when I say that I think Walsh is right about what Martin Luther King would have said.</p><p>He <a href="https://twitter.com/WalshFreedom/status/1087363299493232640">writes</a>: “King would not have instantly condemned those white school kids from Kentucky. He would’ve preached patience, He would’ve worked to get ALL sides to fully understand what happened. He would’ve worked to bring ALL sides together.”</p><p>I realize a-holes like me and Walsh shouldn’t white-splain MLK, especially on MLK Day, but Walsh’s opinion rings true to me.</p><p>I wonder what MLK would have said during the Brett Kavanaugh hearings? In many ways, this Covington episode feels like a sort of mini-Kavanaugh, in that we keep coming back to the entitled, smarmy behavior of white male teens. As with that episode, I believe that many attackers <em>and </em>defenders are writing without really checking their inherent biases. And some are simply writing in bad faith, including other tweets from Charlie Kirk…yeah, after that one tweet, he went back to his usual trolling.</p><p>Personally, I’m looking for a teachable moment. I’m looking for anyone to look at this situation and say words to the effect of “We’re all still Americans and there is so much more that unites us than divides us.” And also, they’re kids!</p><p>I mean, do we really want to maintain this cold civil war? I don’t. I want to move forward with most other Americans. And I believe there’s something between “woke” and “racist,” something between “woke” and “sexist.” I believe the correct word is probably “ignorant,” and that both extremes need to start using it a lot more often. One of the geniuses of applying Jordan Peele’s “Sunken Place” metaphor to black people who seem to be drinking too much white Kool-Aid (say, Kanye West, or Ben Carson, or whoever), is that you can’t really come back from “Uncle Tom.” You can come back from a Sunken Place. We need a way for the Covington kids, and their attackers, to come back.</p><p>To mix metaphors, with Brett Kavanaugh, the Covington kids, and too many other episodes, these Rorschach Tests are becoming nails for way too many people…nails that need hammers. If you bring your anti-racism hammer, or your anti-anti-racism hammer, to too many situations, everything becomes a nail.</p><p>Myself very much included, we all need to work harder to find the humanity of (almost) everyone. It’s what Ryan Murphy would do.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8ab2a93aedfe" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The People Who Hate the New Best Popular Film Oscar Will Like It in Five Years]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@danielsmithrowsey/the-people-who-hate-the-new-best-popular-film-oscar-will-like-it-in-five-years-5084d417d15f?source=rss-eebf3c706f43------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5084d417d15f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[best-popular-film]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[blockbusters]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[oscars]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[academy-awards]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[movies]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Daniel Smith-Rowsey]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 13 Aug 2018 17:02:19 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-08-13T17:02:19.271Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>My take on a potential new Best Popular Film Oscar is a little different than most of what I’ve been reading.</p><p>If AMPAS is doing this to improve ratings, it won’t work. Ratings are way down for every award show, including ones that are almost exclusively stars partying (looking at you, Grammys and Golden Globes). The streaming generation simply doesn’t care, so AMPAS may as well stop trying to cater to them. (Alternatively, if the show needs to be three hours long, how about two hours of streaming-only “premium” content, streamed for an extra fee, just before the main broadcast? Bring out the host in a T-shirt and give out the “lesser” awards and Governor’s awards. Real fans will love it.) But I digress.</p><p>I don’t think a promised Best Popular Film Oscar will improve ratings, but I don’t think it’s going to hurt the Oscars either. I think some of the harshest critics may have forgotten the nature of AMPAS. Even if they do permit some franchise films to become Best Popular Film nominees, those films are unlikely to win (unless they’re as excellent as <em>Black Panther</em>).</p><p>Who will win this new Oscar? Look at the recent history.</p><p>It’s actually not that hard to guess what films would have won the Best Popular Film Oscar if the award had begun at the same time as the last big rule change (2011). Oscar pundits well understand that a Best Picture nomination helps you win in any other category. Let’s say you’re <em>Call Me By Your Name </em>and you’re the only Best Picture nominee nominated for Best Adapted Screenplay; that gives you an excellent chance of winning Best Adapted Screenplay. This goes for Foreign Language Film, for Animated Film, for Cinematography…for anything up to and including a hypothetical Best Popular Film category. It’s not exactly a huge leap to imagine the highest-grossing Best Picture nominee in each year of this decade squaring off against non-Picture-nominated, pre-fab blockbusters like the Marvel and Lucasfilm movies. In this hypothetical, what would have been the likely last seven Best Popular Film winners?</p><p><em>The Help</em></p><p><em>Lincoln</em></p><p><em>Gravity</em></p><p><em>American Sniper</em></p><p><em>The Martian</em></p><p><em>Hidden Figures</em></p><p><em>Dunkirk</em></p><p>…this doesn’t exactly reward mediocrity. If anything, it gives out Oscars to films that, in many cases, critics and voters (and I) were sad to see go home without a big award.</p><p>Generally, more Oscars has meant more good. I have great sympathy for those who say that the Oscars need other awards, such as Best Casting or Best Stunt Work. This new award wouldn’t have been my first choice either. But I don’t hate the idea. AMPAS remains AMPAS, which means they’re not going to be giving the award to <em>The Meg</em>.</p><p>David Sims in the Atlantic raised the specter of popular movies like <em>Dunkirk </em>or <em>Get Out </em>missing out on Best Picture nods because of the new category. But like all of us, he’s only guessing. My guess is that movies like those will get Best Picture nods <em>and </em>Best Popular Film nods. But then, the argument goes, the Popular Film nomination reduces the chances of <em>Dunkirk</em>, <em>Get Out</em>, or any of the movies on my list to win Best Picture. This may well be true. But it might be time to acknowledge that AMPAS is unlikely to have given Best Picture to the $100million grosser anyway. The new award formally acknowledges what was before only tacitly acknowledged: the split personality of the Academy (art film/blockbuster), a split where the art film always eventually dominates.</p><p>Tom Bruggeman, among others, hates the idea. Bruggeman says that baseball teams don’t play for two different types of World Series titles. I get that, but I don’t think the Best Blockbuster will really be considered comparable to Best Picture. One way you’ll know is that Best Blockbuster will only have five nominees, while Best Picture swaggers around the room as the only category with more than five. The new award will be more comparable to Best Foreign Language Film or Best Animated Film. Somehow we all got used to those.</p><p>Actually, considering Pixar films often do best with critics AND the box office, I see some interesting future jockeying between Best Animated Film, Best Popular Film, and Best Picture. But leave that for another time.</p><p>When writers at <em>The Atlantic</em> and <em>Vulture</em> argue against this new award, they’re careful not to actually name any films that they think should be, or should have been, excluded. I know exactly why they do that, but they’d make a better case if they came out, by name, against some of the recent $100million grossers that the Academy excluded from Best Picture. I dare them to say: “hey, maybe <em>Bridesmaids, Gone Girl, Straight Outta Compton, Creed, Inside Out, Star Wars: The Force Awakens</em>, and <em>Wonder Woman</em>didn’t deserve Best Picture nominations.” Nobody wants to invite the retribution of such a statement — including the Academy. Get it yet? When you take it movie by movie, nobody wants to remove, say, <em>Fences </em>from a previous Best Picture lineup. This new award doesn’t shut off possibilities, it just opens up new ones, and in five years I think even the haters will be happier. They would have been happier if movies from <em>Gone Girl</em>to <em>Wonder Woman </em>had had Best Popular Film nods.</p><p>Another way to fix this problem might be abandon the preferential ballot and go back to the system of 2009 and 2010, which included blockbusters like <em>District 9, Up, Inception</em>, and <em>Toy Story 3 </em>in Best Picture. However, those films had next to no chance of actually winning BP (though the BP noms set the Pixar films on a glide path to winning Best Animated, which is part of my point), so I still think this new award has potential to make more people happier.</p><p>The name stinks. I think Best Blockbuster will ultimately make more sense. Then nominees can be based purely on budget or box office without Best Picture being slighted.</p><p>I understand that people are casting a wary eye on this because it’s happening during the same year as <em>Black Panther</em>. Actually two wary eyes: some people say the new award prevents Disney/Marvel from winning the Best Picture it might have gotten, others say Disney/ABC just arranged for themselves to get an award — and not only this year, but in perpetuity, considering the studio is kinda running the blockbuster game now. To the first, I say cheyeah right. Loved <em>BP</em>, it ain’t winning BP. To the second, I say, well, sure, BP may win BPF. But the last time Disney seemed to create an award for itself (back in 2001 when Best Animated Film began), it took them four years to actually win it, and then only with Pixar’s help.</p><p>I’ve been particularly amused by amateur armchair opinions about the larger reasons why Hollywood doesn’t make blockbusters for adults anymore. If you’ve read this far, perhaps you’d like to know, or be reminded of, the REAL history. Back in the 1950s and 1960s, when half of current Oscar voters grew up, there was no stigma attached to blockbusters; the best actors happily did them. The stigma was against B-films or heavily genre-bound films. This stigma included <em>Star Wars </em>in 1977; it’s why theater actor James Earl Jones didn’t want his name in the credits, and one reason why <em>Annie Hall </em>beat <em>Star Wars</em> for Best Picture.</p><p>What people often forget now is that the stigma remained in effect in the 1980s and 1990s. The highest-paid actors mostly didn’t want to do effects-driven films; this includes Tom Hanks, Tom Cruise, Mel Gibson, John Travolta, Robin Williams, Jodie Foster, Julia Roberts, Brad Pitt, and Denzel Washington. Most of the scripts circulating around Hollywood in the 1990s were written with people like that in mind (or “attached”), and most of them had nothing to do with sequels or franchises. Stars ran Hollywood in the 1990s; the top ones were paid “20-over-20” meaning $20 million per film or 20% of the gross, whichever was higher. No one gets that deal anymore. Why?</p><p>The short answer is YOU. Basically, the $20 million-earning stars made movies for grownups, and grownups didn’t show up. One or two bombs were always expected in a star’s career, but by 2005 bombs had happened time after time with every single $20 million star. The old model simply wasn’t sustainable.</p><p>By then, a new model had presented itself: digital-effects-driven films with pre-existing literary fanbases that preferred “right for the part” actors (which saved the studios money on casting). The <em>Lord of the Rings</em>trilogy, the <em>Harry Potter</em>films, <em>X-Men</em>, and <em>Spider-Man</em>(yes, the latter two are technically from “literature”) were game-changers. Because YOU showed up for those, and not for <em>Bicentennial Man </em>or <em>The Majestic </em>or <em>The Terminal </em>or whatever, the town shifted.</p><p>Yet AMPAS remains AMPAS, and its biases remain its biases. Again, it’s a bit of a split personality. I’ve been amused by people, mostly fanboys, saying that the Oscars don’t recognize popular films. Sure they do. At least in the nomination phase, at least for “below the line” awards. But that’s not enough for some. They like to forget that <em>Avatar, Gravity, </em>and <em>Mad Max: Fury Road </em>were very popular films that won the MOST Oscars during their respective years. Still, the perception of bias is not wrong. Many voters more or less agree with the tastes of people like Meryl Streep, Leonardo DiCaprio, Nicole Kidman, and Sean Penn, meaning dramas by great directors that will (or might) still seem great fifty years from now. Voters like Streep have been accommodating blockbusters for a while now, and this is just their latest accommodation. Maybe, in the end, this new award is simply not that big of a deal.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5084d417d15f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Between Ta-Nehisi Coates and Kanye West and Me]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@danielsmithrowsey/between-ta-nehisi-coates-and-kanye-west-and-me-18d8074253f1?source=rss-eebf3c706f43------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/18d8074253f1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[kanye-west]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[political-correctness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[blacklivesmatter]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[freedom]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ta-nehisi-coates]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Daniel Smith-Rowsey]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 11 May 2018 17:46:35 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-05-11T17:50:58.373Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/300/0*TBnRF8C38eqA7nCm.jpg" /></figure><p><a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/entertainment/archive/2018/05/im-not-black-im-kanye/559763/">“I’m Not Black, I’m Kanye”</a>, about Kanye West “lending his imprimatur…to the racist rhetoric of the conservative movement,” is yet another tour-de-force essay by America’s premier public intellectual. I deeply appreciate how Ta-Nehisi Coates offers so much more than he really needs to, how he opens windows and doors that shine profound light on seemingly ancillary subjects. In this case, those subjects include the pre-internet era of having to see something to believe it <em>and </em>Coates’ current, oddly alienating stardom that began in 2015. But does Coates want to reach anyone besides people (like me) who are in his pre-existing fan base?</p><p>Coates writes that Kanye West wants freedom — defined as white freedom. In his most quoted condemnation:</p><blockquote><em>West calls his struggle the right to be a “free thinker,” and he is, indeed, championing a kind of freedom — a white freedom, freedom without consequence, freedom without criticism, freedom to be proud and ignorant; freedom to profit off a people in one moment and abandon them in the next; a Stand Your Ground freedom, freedom without responsibility, without hard memory…</em></blockquote><p>Sorry, but Coates’ full jeremiad leaves out a lot of “hard memory” about hip-hop history and the more recent, Coates-influenced past. If Coates were just another rapper dropping rhymes about West, I’d be fine with him cutting a few corners, but Coates is a little too long-winded, and influential, to leave out as much as he did. The freedom West seeks is only nominally or usually or typically white freedom. In fact, West valorizes the same freedom that other black figureheads have historically had, as well as a newer freedom from the more recent monolithic dictates of political correctness. Coates’ history leaves out those earlier black icons as well as Coates’ role in the new PC. A more honest essay would have not only revealed Coates’ current and third-grade insecurities (kudos, though, because that was brilliantly done), but also moved beyond preaching to Coates’ choir. We need that if we — Trump haters and Trump voters — are ever going to take things like this West-Trump episode and move forward together as Americans.</p><p>So here’s my supplementary corrective to Coates’ piece. Obviously you’ll have read “I’m Not Black, I’m Kanye” before reading this, but it will also help if you are familiar with more of Coates’ work, if not his masterful book <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Between-World-Me-Ta-Nehisi-Coates/dp/0812993543/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&amp;qid=1525716546&amp;sr=8-1&amp;keywords=between+the+world+and+me"><em>Between the World and Me</em></a><em> </em>then at least essays like <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2017/01/my-president-was-black/508793/">“My President Was Black”</a>and <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2017/10/the-first-white-president-ta-nehisi-coates/537909/">“The First White President” </a>and/or many of the others collected in his book <a href="https://www.amazon.com/We-Were-Eight-Years-Power/dp/0399590560/ref=sr_1_2?ie=UTF8&amp;qid=1525796785&amp;sr=8-2&amp;keywords=ta-nehisi+coates+between+the+world+and+me"><em>We Were Eight Years in Power</em></a>.</p><p>In his latest essay, Coates takes us on a journey from 1982, when Michael Jackson was “God” (six times Coates calls him God with a capital G), through he and Kanye West’s childhood seeing the space shuttle Challenger explode between original airings of <em>The Cosby Show</em>, to…well, he sort of fast-forwards to September 2001, “mere days before the Twin Towers fell,” when Coates finally saw the clip of Jackson’s most famous moonwalk, culminating in the fateful day, 9/11, that the Towers and <em>The Blueprint</em>(Jay-Z’s album produced partly by West) simultaneously dropped. Well, he writes that in September 2001 his “theme music” included four somewhat conscious hip-hop songs from the mid-1990s; he writes of his gratitude that Twitter wasn’t around then, “because Lord knows how many times I would have told you hip-hop was dead, and Lord knows how many times I would have said ‘Incarcerated Scarfaces’ [1995] was the peak of civilization.” But when he heard Kanye with Jay-Z, he felt “back in communion with something that I felt had been lost,” namely a sense of slave ancestry in hip-hop.</p><p>I find Coates’ religious language — “Lord knows,” capital-G God, “in communion” — highly significant. Coates would hardly be the only American to have turned to faith in the immediate aftermath of September 11. Coates has admitted his atheism, but he treats Jackson and West as some kind of deities — he writes here of West’s “parishioners.” In an interview with Michael Eric Dyson, <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/outlook/ta-nehisi-coates-on-education-religion-and-obama/2017/10/13/adc054c6-ae84-11e7-be94-fabb0f1e9ffb_story.html?utm_term=.9609b30e2d34">Coates says</a>, “I don’t know how you grow up black in this country and not have tremendous respect for the church, even though I was raised outside of it. So even as I articulate my beliefs, I try to be really respectful.”</p><p>And yet…this West-Trump episode is all about perceived disrespect, and it’s hard not to feel that Coates’ words, in his latest essay and in other places, have exacerbated disrespect between the black community and conservatives. Coates offers lip service to respecting black churches, but he doesn’t even try to offer the same to predominantly white churches. If we’re choosing to talk about gods and Gods, let’s recognize that everyone is genuflecting toward a higher power.</p><p>Back in September 2001, both before and after the 11th, the black community and conservatives shared many of the same values. A lot of this related to religion, which was often Christian, but sometimes even Muslim. Obviously, we can’t pretend that black people and Christian conservatives were ever as close as, let’s say, feminists and <em>Ms.</em>Magazine. There were plenty of nodes of disagreement, but it was not as polarized as it is now. When black people and Christian conservatives did agree, the emphasis was on the one and only God, family, tradition, and independence from a suspicious federal government.</p><p>Many black leaders then extolled a sort of religious freedom from the state that Coates is now labeling as “white.” Louis Farrakhan was arguably one of them. I get that a lot of that freedom was cishet-male-coded, and tied to women and Jews and gay people being routinely disparaged or at least made to feel inferior, and I laud Coates for trying to get past that, but that makes him leave out a lot. For example, Coates could have written about West’s wife and the long history of black men mating with women lighter than “manila folders” (Coates’ words); perhaps Coates didn’t want to fuel certain corners of the internet by going down the rabbit hole of Kim Kardashian’s ethnicity. Instead, Coates’ thesis is that West (is a God who) wants to be white, as Michael Jackson did. But a child molester like Jackson is a little too easy a target; we all understand that he disgraced himself. Coates wouldn’t dare extend that thesis a few years forward to the best artist of the <em>Cosby Show </em>years, Prince, because confronting all the ways in which Prince was “a black god dying to be white” would have lost Coates most of his pre-existing base. Was Prince’s freedom really “white freedom”? No; Prince was simply declaring himself free of anything but his own muse.</p><p>And Coates certainly can’t mention the band, N.W.A., that came along to redefine hardcore blackness, and along the way, make Kanye’s career possible. You know, the band that sang “We all said <em>fuck you bitch </em>and kept going”? I could write a piece as long as Coates’ piece consisting of only misogynistic/homophobic/anti-Asian/anti-Semitic quotes from N.W.A., and Coates well knows it. Public Enemy had its own issues as seen in “She Watch Channel Zero,” the embrace of Farrakhan, and Professor Griff’s anti-Semitism (Griff was ejected from the group for it; however, in 2013, Chuck D made sure Griff was part of the group induction into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame). Were Ice Cube and Chuck D championing white freedom? I thought they were just declaring themselves free thinkers.</p><p>Isn’t Raekwon, the narrator of Coates’ favorite song ever, “Incarcerated Scarfaces,” calling himself the black Trump, or at least enjoying the idea of it? Is it possible that Kanye is allying himself with Trump as part of trying to re-establish, or at least connect to, pre-politically correct hip-hop? By writing about West as the best of old-school and new-school, and by invoking yet denuding Golden Age hip-hop, Coates loses track of West’s real motivations in his alliance with Trump.</p><p>I know highly paid people on TV who would look at the black church’s, and hip-hop’s, former traditionalism (read: misogyny, homophobia, anti-Semitism) and say that black people have wisely moved on and grown up. That may be, but if so, that has also had the consequence of growing black people <em>apart </em>from a large section of America. Because nobody, least of all Coates, recognizes this breakup for what it was, the hurt feelings continue to fester. Basically, Christian conservatives look at black churchgoers and hip-hop lovers and say, “We thought you were with us on some things. What happened?” Instead of reacting like Coates and responding that the change in black consciousness was some kind of natural or inevitable evolution, we might try actually answering the question. Ask any doctor: you can’t solve the problem if you can’t name the problem.</p><p>No doubt, President Obama changed the game, but as with Trump, the feelings that made his presidency possible preceded him. The real history of political correctness is waiting to be written (by some scholar braver than I), but when it is, it will be clear that the movement blazed bright in the late 1980s and early 1990s, but then, around the time of the first O.J. Simpson trial and Newt Gingrich’s Contract with America and the ascent of the all-white, gay-bashing <em>Friends </em>to America’s #1 show, America had backlashed, and would remain backlashed for about another decade. Almost everyone, including black people, opposed same-sex marriage; if women’s sexuality was expressed as Britney Spears or Monica Lewinsky did it, this was celebrated as freedom; and almost everyone looked the other way on disproportionate incarceration of, and police brutalism toward, black people.</p><p>I believe this to-be-written history will show that the new political correctness and minority inclusion (they’re related, but not the same thing) began around the time Kanye West said “George Bush doesn’t care about black people” during a telethon to help victims of Hurricane Katrina. Bush’s autobiography would cite this as the low point of his presidency — not the hurricane, not his failed response, not the 1200-plus mostly brown dead people, but West’s hurtful remarks. Hadn’t Bush appointed Colin Powell and Condoleeza Rice to historic positions? I know what you’re thinking: if West was angry about how the GOP treated black people, how does that jibe with his current bromance with Trump? Well, it’s complicated! Trump was angry at the Bush administration, too.</p><p>(After years in which the GOP had slavishly followed Grover Norquist’s idea that he wanted to shrink government to the size where he could drown it in the bathtub…the GOP left a city full of black people to drown as though in a bathtub. Any other country would have had armed forces ready to help…but our military, the world’s largest, was bogged down in an unwinnable, ill-advised war in Iraq. And Hurricane Katrina forced an African-American diaspora all over the South, warping that region’s politics.)</p><p>More than anything, the takeaway from Katrina was <em>this isn’t working</em>. However complacent you may have been about politics, whatever instincts 9/11 may have reinforced, you didn’t see hundreds of dead black bodies floating past rooftops, left to rot in the sun, and think: <em>nope, no changes needed here</em>.</p><p>The year following Hurricane Katrina brought Ice Cube and his trade-the-races show <a href="https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0494185/">“Black.White.,”</a><em>Survivor </em>and its four tribes sorted by race, Tyra Banks’ show sending black people out in whiteface, Dr. Phil putting a white person in a black family for two days to “cure” his racism, Jon Stewart hiring his first non-white correspondents, introduced as “Senior Black Correspondent” (Larry Wilmore) and “Senior Muslim Correspondent” (Aasif Mandvi), as well as Oprah Winfrey showing <a href="http://www.oprah.com/oprahshow/skin-deep/all">her audience</a> how she’d look as a white person. Were all these people “championing white freedom” in Coates’ language? None of these would occur without griping from Coates or his fans today. But I’d say we wouldn’t have arrived in this PC era without these and many other such experiments from 2006 — Katrina showed that something about race relations and justice wasn’t working.</p><p>Social media was another key driver of the change. If George W. Bush had had a marvelous presidency, with no lies, no secrets, no covert torture — who knows? Maybe we’d all still be on MySpace. But Bush gave opacity such a bad name, it’s no wonder people flocked from the pseudonymous-ish MySpace to the all-transparent-all-the-time Facebook and Twitter (and eventually Instagram). It turns out that when people know that their grandmother or mother or sister is going to read their public comments, they say things like “shut up fag” a little less. (This is the secret reason, despite 2018 revelations, that we’re not leaving Facebook; it makes people more grandma-friendly versions of themselves.) And when people know that their tweet will last in cyberspace forever, most of them, though not Donald Trump, do some healthy self-policing. And as they do, they carp on others who don’t, and virtue-signaling becomes a never-ending spiral…well before Obama became President, we got through several months of celebrity-shaming people like Mel Gibson, Paula Deen, Don Imus, Michael Richards, Brett Ratner, and various athletes who used the sort of homophobic/sexist/racist/ableist language that none of them would dare use now.</p><p>I linger on Katrina and social media because I think it’s a little too easy for Coates and many of his supporters to think: Obama got elected, a bunch of racists freaked out, they vocally blame political correctness but they’re really racist, and because of that we’re stuck with Trump, and further stuck with a few anti-anti-Trumpers like Kanye who wind up betraying their race. More people on the so-called “left” and “right” need to know that’s not exactly what happened. Obama, not unlike Trump eight years later, was a symptom of the zeitgeist as much as a cause. That said, yes, Obama’s presence may have accelerated some of the PC era in a way that a John McCain presidency would not have. And that’s a good thing: it led to Black Lives Matter, legal same-sex marriage, and strides that every feminist conference had acknowledged well before #metoo. But it also led to overreach.</p><p>Before I explain what I mean by overreach, let’s summarize: Coates’ history, as magnificently as it portrays the pre-internet era, could be a little less selective. But to really put Kanye West’s latest apostasy in full context, we would do well to address Coates’ gloss on more recent events. I’m grateful to Coates for lingering on the stardom that, he says, began for him in the summer of 2015 with the release of <em>Between the World and Me</em>. That summer turned out to be quite the pivot point in American history. Same-sex marriage finally became the official law of the land…long overdue. But like Andrew Sullivan, I question that being followed with the strident agitation for every kind of transgender rights — including the immediate labeling as racist Obama’s 2011-era statements on the LGBTQ community. Summer 2015 is when #gamergate reached a sort of détente, but disenfranchised males got angrier about using their, uh, “free speech.” Also in summer 2015, Jon Stewart retired, which meant that liberals lost a trusted voice that could (and did) call out liberal excesses of politically correctness. Donald Trump descended an escalator to start a campaign for the presidency…and went off script by disparaging unnamed Mexicans as criminals and rapists. <em>Straight Outta Compton </em>was released in theaters, presenting the denuded version of N.W.A.’s story with barely any misogyny or homophobia or anti-Semitism…and the movie was a huge hit. The PC version of N.W.A.’s story was told as though it was just the right thing to do — we could no longer afford to see Cube and Dre and Eazy-E as the iconoclasts they were. Meanwhile in 2015, liberals continued disinviting speakers to campuses, stigmatizing the phrase “you guys,” excoriating people for posting photos of themselves petting dolphins, and declaring a list of microaggressions <em>to be </em>a microaggression.</p><p>The day after Trump’s escalator descent, an idiot named Dylaan Roof opened fire on nine parishioners in Charleston, killing nine black people. Absolutely nothing can excuse that terrible crime and I personally hope Roof and anyone who supports him rots in hell. But then, the day <em>after </em>the day after Trump’s descent, something almost unprecedented happened. Ta-Nehisi Coates wrote <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2015/06/take-down-the-confederate-flag-now/396290/">“Take Down the Confederate Flag — Now” </a>for the Atlantic. It began “Last night, Dylann Roof walked into a Charleston church, sat for an hour, and then killed nine people. Roof’s crime cannot be divorced from the ideology of white supremacy which long animated his state nor from its potent symbol — the Confederate flag.” Never say public intellectuals have no effect on the real world; with this article, Coates inspired liberals to adopt a brand-new cause. It’s not like Black Lives Matter had been calling for the removal of Confederate Flags; it’s not like people have reacted to that van-massacring misogynist in Toronto by calling for the Equal Rights Amendment.</p><p>I think we should consider the possibility that PC may have jumped the shark a little bit in that summer. More equal treatment for marginalized groups, yes. But the proud overreaches of disinvitations, stigmatizations and microaggressions? Saying that a horrible massacre’s outcome should be symbol removal? Leading to the agitating of the removal of Confederate-hero statues? I personally agree with removing Confederate flags and statues, but I don’t call people who disagree racists. Especially since prior to 2015, almost no one had an opinion on them one way or another. In 2013, when Kanye West decided to wear a Confederate flag, everyone rolled their eyes and moved on.</p><p>Most of my liberal friends don’t roll eyes anymore; they declare everyone either #woke or racist. The PC environment has become over-stifling and even counter-productive to liberal interests, as noted this week in the <em>New York Times </em><a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2018/05/08/opinion/intellectual-dark-web.html">here</a> and <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2018/05/08/opinion/economy-trump-election.html?rref=collection%2Fbyline%2Fdavid-leonhardt&amp;action=click&amp;contentCollection=undefined&amp;region=stream&amp;module=stream_unit&amp;version=latest&amp;contentPlacement=4&amp;pgtype=collection">here</a> and <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2018/05/11/opinion/intellectual-dark-web-red-pilled.html">here</a>, and the <em>Washington Post </em><a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/post-partisan/wp/2018/05/10/what-is-the-greatest-threat-to-free-speech-on-campus/?utm_term=.5351342e50e2">here</a>. What those articles don’t quite say, but should, is that our discourse needs more middle ground, if only to label some people “ignorant” or “needs work” instead of maintaining this woke/racist binary. Living in PC America is now comparable to you playing a video game that you thought you could master (like every other game), where the goalposts keep moving even as the game gaslights you into thinking the game was always meant to be never-ending.</p><p>What do I mean by that? Let’s imagine that some PC person objects to Bari Weiss’s phrase in the <em>New York Times </em>“Intellectual Dark Web” (linked) by saying that the un-PC intellectuals she discusses are adopting “dark” in an Other-ized, forbidden sense that serves to maintain white-black asymmetrical power relations. (Is that a crazy hypothetical? Did anyone object to “you guys” ten years ago?) Would anyone on the left object? It’s unlikely. So now the goalposts have moved again: you’re <em>now </em>not allowed to say “dark” the way you did growing up. In this particular case, I’d nip that change in the bud very effectively by noting that Ta-Nehisi Coates, of all people, uses “dark” in precisely that unenlightened way twice during “I’m Not Kanye, I’m Black.” (F5 it yourself.)</p><p>Ta-Nehisi Coates has been one of the main people leading all black people to Team Woke; his little spat with a different West, Cornel West (who called him out for lionizing Obama while ignoring Obama’s imperialism), only proved that most black persons in the media are on Coates’ side. In academia, <em>Between the World and Me</em>has to be the most-added-to-a-syllabus text of the decade. Yet I would fight for his right to use “dark,” and any other word, without running afoul of the shame police.</p><p>This is a very long way of saying that freedom from societal expectations and political correctness is not, or should not be, the same as “white freedom.” It may simply be iconoclasm or what some call “free thinking.” Kanye West has the right to be an iconoclast without the monolithic left, led by Coates, slamming him. We have to somehow work our way out of several binaries, including woke/racist, and anti-Trump/pro-Trump. We have to stop giving right-wingers excuses to believe this cartoon is right.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/300/0*5a4B2zHr_DG61w5X.png" /></figure><p>All that very much said, I agree that it’s concerning that West has vaunted his own failure to read books and specifically lent his credibility (such as it is) to the Trump Administration. Coates is not wrong when he writes that West’s statements have become part of“the propaganda that justifies voter suppression, and feeds police brutality, and minimizes the murder of Heather Heyer.” However, he knew that all of his allies would have agreed with that. I’d like him to expand his pulpit past his usual parishioners. I’d like him to say something less incendiary about white freedom, acknowledging that non-Michael Jackson artists like Ice Cube and Chuck D have sometimes had a freedom that transcended racial binaries. I’d prefer he condemn West in language that leaves open the possibility that West could do something outside helping or hurting black people. In a way, Coates is the latest Cosby, in the sense of shaming the black community for bringing down black standards. Well before we all learned what a monster Cosby is, Dyson and Coates (in the interview cited above) were agreeing with each other that Cosby and Obama have spent too much time policing the behavior of black people. Et tu, Ta-Nehisi?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=18d8074253f1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Avengers: Infinity War: The Missing Scene]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@danielsmithrowsey/avengers-infinity-war-the-missing-scene-a20e7bb6ff15?source=rss-eebf3c706f43------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a20e7bb6ff15</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[marvel-cinematic-universe]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[avengers]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[movies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marvel]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[infinity-war]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Daniel Smith-Rowsey]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 30 Apr 2018 16:59:53 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-04-30T16:59:53.115Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>SPOILERS, SPOILERS, SPOILERS</p><p>First I’m a huge superhero geek, a mega-fan of both the comics growing up <em>and </em>the last ten years of Marvel movies. You guys, <em>Avengers: Infinity War </em>was…so close to greatness. It’s a terrific Guardians of the Galaxy movie. It’s a worthy Thor follow-up to <em>Ragnarok</em>. It’s a mostly splendid Iron Man-Doctor Strange-Spider-Man team-up (I would have given Spidey one or two more exuberant wisecracks in his scenes with Thanos, but that’s a minor quibble). And Thanos easily joins Loki and Killmonger on the Mount Rushmore of MCU villains. As a general thing, Marvel proved with this film that more is often more. They came so close, like <em>almost </em>getting a gauntlet off a hand.</p><p>But…somebody got a little lost in the third Avengers movie, and I’m afraid it was the core Avengers, especially Captain America. I almost wondered if directors Joe and Anthony Russo, having cut their teeth on the second and third <em>Captain America </em>movies, felt they didn’t want to show favoritism by focusing too much on Steve Rogers. But that’s like ignoring your kid at his own birthday party. Cap is Cap, the Avengers’ leader. He needed more than a few smoldering looks.</p><p>Even in a movie this over-stuffed, or perhaps <em>especially </em>in one that gave this much motivation to Thanos, Quill, Thor, Stark, Strange, and even Bruce Banner, Captain America needed a real arc, and so did the Blacks, namely Widow and Panther. A related problem is that Steve Rogers and T’Challa and Natasha were saddled with the least plausible storyline of the film: of course they would have destroyed that overgrown toaster (called the Vision) rather than risk the lives of trillions! And…the balance of the movie needed just a little more time on Earth, ideally in a nice large planning room, before Act Three; I realize the Guardians and Thor have established cosmic-ness, but I was getting spacesick-ness. I know the Russos couldn’t have realized <em>Black Panther </em>would make $700 million domestic, but they needed to respect Wakanda and its main characters just a <em>little </em>bit more.</p><p>The thing is, they could have solved everything with <em>one more </em>tiny little scene. Yes, I realize the movie was already 17 hours long. But one war-planning scene (replacing the shorter one that’s in the film) could have taken this film from <em>Batman Begins </em>to <em>The Dark Knight</em>. It would have been worth it. Honestly, they ought to shoot it for the DVD. (I realize it may not exist because it would need 12 of the single-card-credited actors, and maybe they never got that many in one place at one time, a feat that would be even harder now. Still, they should.) One tiny little Wakanda War Planning Room Scene. You know, filmed with a lot of dollying cameras swirling around heads. And it might go a <em>little </em>something like…wait.</p><p>First, a two-sentence set-up: after those two aliens attack Vision and Scarlet Witch, after they’re thwarted by other Avengers, just before they leave, they say words to the effect of “We’ll be back with an army.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/300/0*z-wRX0kYQ1DqP-3k.jpg" /></figure><p>Later in the film, as pictured, Black Panther and Okoye greet the Avengers who have flown into Wakanda (Medium.com hates Courier font and centering text, so I apologize for the way this looks).</p><pre>CUT TO:</pre><pre>WAKANDA WAR PLANNING ROOM. Assembled and seated around a massive table: T’CHALLA, CAPTAIN AMERICA, BLACK WIDOW, BRUCE BANNER, FALCON, RHODEY, OKOYE, M’BAKU, SHURI, VISION, SCARLET WITCH, BUCKY, and high-ranking Wakandans.</pre><pre><em>Scene begins with closeup of a hologram projection of the City of Wakanda, including the force field that surrounds it.</em></pre><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/300/1*9XBRYpR92Ihkjn7buHesQw.png" /></figure><pre>T’CHALLA</pre><pre>Their army is likely to mount this flank.</pre><pre>CAPTAIN AMERICA</pre><pre>In that case, I want the Avengers lined up like this…</pre><pre><em>A hand wipes away the hologram projection. Camera reveals the hand to belong to Shuri.</em></pre><pre>SHURI</pre><pre>Wait a minute. The most powerful and murderous monster in the universe is looking for this stone, and you brought it here?</pre><pre><em>Finally we see the entire room, which sits stunned for a moment.</em></pre><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/300/1*krOrQWI4yA9pLBK0XJNV6Q.png" /></figure><pre>BLACK WIDOW</pre><pre>We know it’s a big ask.</pre><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/300/0*0zyTt6vKp2JQkQDs.jpg" /></figure><pre>SHURI</pre><pre>This is not our fight.</pre><pre>(eyes indicating Vision)</pre><pre>He doesn’t belong here. He has to go. Now.</pre><pre>OKOYE</pre><pre>(to Captain America)</pre><pre>Do you not command your own regiment, Captain?</pre><pre>CAPTAIN AMERICA</pre><pre>The title is more of an honorific.</pre><pre>OKOYE</pre><pre>(to Rhodey)</pre><pre>Surely you command your own battalion, Colonel Rhodes?</pre><pre>RHODEY</pre><pre>I’m actually AWOL right now.</pre><pre>SHURI</pre><pre><em>Colonel</em> Rhodes? Yet you take orders from this captain?</pre><pre>RHODEY</pre><pre>(half-smile)</pre><pre>He’s pretty good at what he does.</pre><pre>BLACK WIDOW</pre><pre>We’re technically fugitives as much as Bucky. Any army that helps us risks isolation from the international community.</pre><pre>T’CHALLA</pre><pre>(on Shuri’s look)</pre><pre>What else is new?</pre><pre>M’BAKU</pre><pre>This is not the issue. You say this Vision is a robot, yes?</pre><pre>BRUCE BANNER</pre><pre>He started that way, but…</pre><pre>SCARLET WITCH</pre><pre>He’s a living being.</pre><pre>M’BAKU</pre><pre>He’s an A.I. that has achieved consciousness?</pre><pre>SCARLET WITCH</pre><pre>He’s much more than that!</pre><pre>M’BAKU</pre><pre>(standing)</pre><pre>We must destroy the stone.</pre><pre>SCARLET WITCH</pre><pre>(standing, her hands set aglow)</pre><pre>Don’t even think about it.</pre><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/300/0*xE-MKs_-MjopHZGk.jpg" /></figure><pre>T’CHALLA</pre><pre>Stand down, M’Baku.</pre><pre>CAPTAIN AMERICA</pre><pre>Stand down, Wanda. And turn your hands, uh, off.</pre><pre>BLACK WIDOW</pre><pre>M’Baku, you could destroy Vision and still not destroy the stone.</pre><pre>BRUCE BANNER</pre><pre>We only know one way to destroy it.</pre><pre>M’BAKU</pre><pre>And what is that?</pre><pre><em>M’Baku looks as the Avengers all look at Wanda. He frowns.</em></pre><pre>M’BAKU</pre><pre>I can try.</pre><pre>T&#39;CHALLA</pre><pre>Brother, we need him.</pre><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/300/0*-_mYNV0QRazdn1c2.jpg" /></figure><pre>VISION</pre><pre>I am bait. That&#39;s what I am, bait.</pre><pre>CAPTAIN AMERICA</pre><pre>Well, you&#39;re also pretty good with your stone in a fight. I found that out the hard way.</pre><pre>BLACK WIDOW</pre><pre>Thanos would come to Earth anyway, we just wouldn’t know where.</pre><pre>BRUCE BANNER</pre><pre>He was destroying half the populations of other worlds even before he had any stones.</pre><pre>(He reaches for Black Widow’s hand as he speaks; she pulls it away.)</pre><pre>He used those creatures we saw in New York six years ago. The stones just make it easier.</pre><pre><em>On T’Challa’s look, M’Baku warily sits.</em></pre><pre>BUCKY</pre><pre>Stone or not, someone, somewhere has to defend the Earth from genocide.</pre><pre><em>The Scarlet Witch sits.</em></pre><pre>RHODEY</pre><pre>Someone has to be the tip of the spear.</pre><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/300/0*COPh_Cxer5oc9T3u.jpg" /></figure><pre>SHURI</pre><pre>Not us. Not this city.</pre><pre>FALCON</pre><pre>Could we maybe move the Vision to Antarctica or something? Away from this amazing place?</pre><pre>SCARLET WITCH</pre><pre>You’ve been in Wakanda for thirty minutes!</pre><pre>FALCON</pre><pre>Long enough to not want it to end up like Sokovia.</pre><pre><em>Black Widow looks hard at Falcon. Her eyes flit accusingly between him and Shuri.</em></pre><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/300/0*zC7GHeYi1VPeNZtk.jpg" /></figure><pre>OKOYE</pre><pre>I cannot move my troops that quickly. And we cannot move the force field, or build another one in time. This one will work against much of their army.</pre><pre>SHURI</pre><pre>(to Okoye)</pre><pre>Since when did you defend the outside world?</pre><pre>OKOYE</pre><pre>Someone has to be the tip of the spear.</pre><pre>SHURI</pre><pre>(stands)</pre><pre>You just want a fight.</pre><pre>CAPTAIN AMERICA</pre><pre>I don’t. But I’m asking you not to walk away from this one. Back in my day, we said this is for all the marbles.</pre><pre>M’BAKU</pre><pre>(also stands)</pre><pre>T’Challa, this is your final decision?</pre><pre>T’CHALLA</pre><pre>I need you, brother.</pre><pre>M’BAKU</pre><pre>We’re not brothers.</pre><pre><em>M’Baku leaves with two lieutenants.</em></pre><pre>SHURI</pre><pre>T’Challa, brother, you have only recently inherited a throne, a position that I might have taken, a regency that kept our home safe for centuries. You want to throw that home away?</pre><pre>T’CHALLA</pre><pre>I do not think we will, sister. I have seen this man in battle. <br>(A look at Captain America.) <br>I trust him.</pre><pre>SHURI</pre><pre>I don’t.</pre><pre><em>Shuri leaves. Falcon stands and leaves, to Avengers’ astonished looks.</em></pre><pre><em>Everyone kind of looks at everyone.</em></pre><pre>CAPTAIN AMERICA</pre><pre>(stiffening his spine)</pre><pre>Can you bring back the hologram?</pre><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/300/0*ivMPdXnyuEszQ1pA.jpg" /></figure><p>Later, the battle goes similarly, but with these differences:</p><p>Vision and Scarlet Witch are on the field, kicking ass. No scene with Shuri trying to escavate stone from Vision.</p><p>At some point, Shuri (controlling drones) and Falcon show up out of nowhere.</p><p>Perhaps on radios:</p><pre>RHODEY</pre><pre>What did you tell her?</pre><pre>FALCON</pre><pre>You mean what did we tell each other? I’ll tell you later.</pre><p>At some desperate moment (post-force-field, pre-Thor), in a vignette reminiscent of scenes from <em>Lord of the Rings</em>, M’Baku’s battalion shows up.</p><p>Everything seems much more poignant because stakes are higher for both the city and for Captain America. The final shot of Cap near Natasha and Thor, realizing that his choices have lost half the universe, hits us with a far fuller force.</p><p>Just an idea.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a20e7bb6ff15" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Let’s Make Wayne LaPierre as Famous as David Hogg and Emma Gonzalez]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@danielsmithrowsey/lets-make-wayne-lapierre-as-famous-as-david-hogg-and-emma-gonzalez-3778dcda138b?source=rss-eebf3c706f43------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3778dcda138b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[nra]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[florida]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[guns]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[wayne-lapierre]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gun-control]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Daniel Smith-Rowsey]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 28 Mar 2018 23:01:45 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-03-28T23:01:45.592Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/275/0*P8pUsAs06K5Z4z5w.jpg" /></figure><p>In the current conversation about weapon legislation, I hope we can all agree that it’s rather astonishing that so many are <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-intersect/wp/2018/03/25/a-fake-photo-of-emma-gonzalez-went-viral-on-the-far-right-where-parkland-teens-are-villains/?utm_term=.e464e0b8566b">openly attacking</a> children, for several reasons. First, the National Rifle Association knows when to shut up, as it did right after the Orlando shooting and the Las Vegas shooting. It could have let the March for our Lives just happen, and then go back to controlling the narrative a week later. But no, the NRA and its acolytes had to make up shit about teenagers.</p><p>Second, attacking minors means you’ve already lost. Can you imagine pro-bully organizations attacking <a href="http://deadline.com/2017/12/keaton-jones-chris-evans-mark-ruffalo-bullied-tennessee-facebook-video-1202223902/">this</a> kid for faking it? Can you imagine Catholic priests attacking children that were molested in the church? Wait, actually, that did happen. And proved that the priests lost.</p><p>Third, if these kids are simply being used and indoctrinated (this line of thinking attacks the kids’ ability to think for themselves), just wondering, does the right also use and indoctrinate kids, or is that only a left-wing thing? Oh, right, no one will ever answer that.</p><p>Fourth, what happened to debating an argument on the merits? Can you oppose a message but leave the messenger alone? Can you disagree with a person’s point of view without vilifying that person? Why not just respond “The second amendment guarantees my right and everyone else’s right to own guns as a bulwark against tyranny” or likewise?</p><p>I think we know the answer: personal attacks have been working for the right for a long time. And I often hear supposedly disinterested people say that people opposing conservatives need to “beat them at their own game.” And that brings me to my main point today. I’m hearing a lot of people — I saw many of them at the March for our Lives — vilifying the NRA. I am not hearing a lot of people — didn’t see one sign — mentioning their leader, Wayne LaPierre.</p><p>You see, there was a time when the National Rifle Association wasn’t this bad. This time was as recent as the 1990s, when LaPierre wasn’t their President. In 1995, LaPierre, as merely the NRA’s executive vice-president, wrote a fundraising letter describing federal agents as “jack-booted government thugs” who wear “Nazi bucket helmets and black storm trooper uniforms to attack law-abiding citizens.” This caused former President George H.W. Bush to resign his membership, and that in turn caused LaPierre to apologize for painting law-enforcement officials with too broad a brush.</p><p>For the next seven years or so, the NRA seemed to content itself with squelching any federal funds used to study gun violence. Of course this wasn’t great — if guns are so safe, why not study them? — but the NRA weren’t even close to the super-villains they have now become.</p><p>What changed? In two words, Wayne LaPierre. He became president of the NRA in 2003 and spent the next two years turning the place into The Island of Dr. Evil.</p><p>Maybe a few other things changed. 9/11 happened. As an prompt to changes in the gun debate, you could see 9/11 both ways: on the one hand, perhaps fear of invasion proved more people needed more guns; on the other hand, perhaps our willingness to circumvent the Constitution to catch terrorists proved that the Constitution wasn’t really as inflexible as the NRA had suggested.</p><p>New Jersey seemed to take the second lesson when it passed Assembly Bill 700, also called the New Jersey Childproof Handgun Law, on December 23, 2002. It said, “The amended bill specifies that three years after it is determined that personalized handguns are available for retail purposes, it will be illegal for any registered or licensed firearms manufacturer or dealer to transport, sell, expose for sale, possess for sale, assign or transfer any handgun unless that handgun is a personalized handgun.”</p><p>Around the same time, Michael Moore’s <em>Bowling for Columbine</em> was becoming the highest-grossing documentary film of all time (a record that Moore would himself eclipse with another film two years later), earning about $58 million on a $4 million budget and, in March 2003, winning the Oscar for Best Picture. In 1989, Michael Moore enjoyed a huge breakthrough with <em>Roger and Me</em>, but his 1990s films saw steadily diminishing returns; almost no one saw <em>The Big One</em> (1997), his last pre-<em>Columbine</em> film. But <em>Columbine</em> struck a real chord — no one ever again called that school shooting “Littleton,” nor Moore a has-been.</p><p><em>Bowling for Columbine</em> was also famous, or infamous, for ending with Moore’s on-camera confrontation of then-NRA President Charlton Heston arguably in the obvious throes of Alzheimer’s. The NRA said Moore was wrong to air the footage, and perhaps it was right.</p><p>Whether because of Heston’s publicized weakness or for other reasons, when LaPierre took over the NRA around the time of Moore’s Oscar win, he approached the job as though he was Rambo seeking to re-litigate Vietnam. New Jersey’s smart-gun law was first on the dock, and here is where LaPierre re-invented the term “evil genius” for the 21st century. LaPierre told everyone on the NRA’s email list, including every Republican politician, that the law was an existential threat to firearm ownership, and that if even one smartgun was allowed in one state (say, Alaska), it would trigger New Jersey’s law and…leave New Jerseyans defenseless? LaPierre’s language made it sound like it would leave all of America defenseless. Personalized guns are available all over Europe, but somehow, LaPierre has successfully prevented them from being legally sold in the United States for 15 years now. The law has entirely backfired. Not sure Heston could or would have pulled that off.</p><p>LaPierre’s next move was to make sure that the 1994 assault weapons ban really did expire in 2004 as scheduled. After LaPierre raised a big stink, Congress and Democratic Presidential candidate John Kerry backed off any attempt at re-authorization or even slight amendments. Bye bye assault weapon ban, hello thousands more deaths. This stopped being your daddy’s NRA.</p><p>LaPierre probably didn’t need for the NRA to endorse a Presidential candidate for the first time, but they did anyway — George Bush, of course. This was some next-level evil genius: by now, LaPierre knew that his “jack-booted” rhetoric worked better, and that gun sales went up, when Democrats became President. So in a perverse way, Bush’s win was a loss for them…</p><p>…but it was a loss they determined to make into a win by further tilting the playing field in a way that the 1990s’ NRA never would have considered. In early 2005 Congress passed the Protection of Lawful Commerce Act (what a name!), which exempted the gun industry from class-action lawsuits. Tobacco and cars and bad food and stock derivatives could and can still be sued on the industrial level, but gun manufacturers and retailers cannot. They’re the only industry to get this kind of legal exemption. Suck on that Charlton Heston!</p><p>But LaPierre wasn’t done. Got to have a new goal to keep money flowing in. And LaPierre achieved two huge new goals in 2008. One was seeing Barack Obama elected. (He’s coming for your guns! Buy them now quick!) The other was keeping people like Obama quiet while he inched <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/District_of_Columbia_v._Heller">District of Columbia vs. Heller</a> over the finish line. As long as Bush had to win in 2004, that meant two new Supreme Court justices, and that in turn meant that those two had to be, <em>had to be</em> pressed to prove their gun-rights bona fides. Can’t let that fail to be a conservative litmus test! The Heller decision found, for the first time, that handguns counted as “arms” under the Second Amendment, and also that the government couldn’t restrict them as it had been doing. It was as big a victory as the NRA ever lodged…until four years later.</p><p>How the hell did America not do something about guns after 20 six-year-olds were murdered in an hour in a Connecticut elementary school? When huge majorities (including of NRA members!) support stricter background checks? Again, LaPierre is an evil genius. Somehow, many believe(d) Sandy Hook was a hoax. Somehow, LaPierre convinced America, or at least enough politicians, that the best thing to do was nothing.</p><p>I sometimes wonder what really goes on at NRA supervisor meetings. I picture something like this:</p><p>LaPierre: “Okay, thoughts and prayers worked on Newtown, just barely. But I’m getting a little worried that after the next Newtown, that whole ‘Doing Nothing Is Not an Option’ meme might gain more steam. What else do we have?”</p><p>Minion: “Well, if we have to look like we’re doing something, how about arming teachers?”</p><p>LaPierre: “Great idea, perfect. Wait for me to play that card, it’s only if I think we’re desperate.”</p><p>Minion: “The thing is, there’s no science behind it. It’s not like we can point to any studies.”</p><p>LaPierre: “Some teachers are armed though.”</p><p>Minion: “Not enough for a study. Well, I guess we can float that nonsense about how most gun crimes happen in gun-free zones.”</p><p>LaPierre: “Right. But wait on that too. With any luck, by the time we need that, we’ll have either a Republican President or a Republican Congress. We’ve paid for them and I expect to get what we paid for.”</p><p>Minion: “Good point!”</p><p>The bottom line: how much more should America accept of this cowardly man, Wayne LaPierre, and how much more should he be allowed to extol the immovability of the Second Amendment while constantly moving the goalposts around it?</p><p>What do Barack Obama and Donald Trump have in common? Not a lot, but I believe they were both elected because of a majority of Americans’ desire to Get On With It. To move on from the past. (That’s why Obama’s 2016 endorsement of Clinton was so odd; eight years before, he had said we had to move on from her.) I believe most Americans realize that this country made a lot of mistakes in 2003–05 (*cough*Iraq*cough*housing bubble*cough*torture*).</p><p>Outside of Jay-Z and Beyoncé and LaPierre, I can’t think of anyone from 2003–05 who is running America now. Outside of Jay-Z and Beyoncé (one <em>always</em> makes exceptions for Jay-Z and Beyoncé) I can’t think of anyone running America then who anyone <em>wants</em> running America now.</p><p>So why are we still clinging to LaPierre? We gave up on Mike Myers. Why do we still need Dr. Evil?</p><p>Make LaPierre as famous as Emma Gonzalez.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3778dcda138b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[George Soros Confesses: I Made Up #metoo to Get Donald Trump]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@danielsmithrowsey/george-soros-confesses-i-made-up-metoo-to-get-donald-trump-9124e42977b2?source=rss-eebf3c706f43------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9124e42977b2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[donald-trump]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[metoo]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[george-soros]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[feminism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Daniel Smith-Rowsey]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 12 Mar 2018 17:26:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-03-12T17:26:32.753Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/300/0*1Hgw3jvkFedQKGLP.jpg" /></figure><p>Hi, George Soros here. Have you noticed how well my fake, heavily financed #metoo campaign is going? How it’s almost brought down Donald Trump! I love it.</p><p>I know Trump isn’t impeached quite yet, but I got to take a little victory lap here. Nobody realizes my genius. First I made up a whole story about Harvey Weinstein and fed it to a few of my stooges in <em>The New Yorker </em>and<em> The New York Times</em>. My assistant was like, you’re never going to get Trump voters to believe anything printed by those #FakeNews liberals! But I knew better. If an article slams a Democrat, conservatives eat it up like free French fries.</p><p>So yeah, I had to make it look like I was throwing a few of my liberal friends under the bus, like Weinstein, Matt Lauer, Charlie Rose, James Franco, Russell Simmons, Casey Affleck, Aziz Ansari. There had to be consequences, or more accurately, what <em>looked like</em> consequences. Before I released the story on Al Franken, I made sure I had one of my liberal tools in Minnesota’s on-deck circle. Before I released the story on Kevin Spacey I checked with Ridley Scott to be sure he had enough time to film the actor he’d wanted in the first place. It had to look real, right? It had to look like: “we will replace you.” It had to look like “we will take your legacy like we took down these Confederate statues.”</p><p>But I’ve got all of these sinners on sinecures. They’ll all be back. I’ve paid the L.A.P.D. handsomely, have you noticed how nobody has yet been arrested? All me.</p><p>All to get to Trump. Well, him and Steven Wynn and Roy Moore. Did you know those guys are innocent?</p><p>I saw what no one else could see: if I paid off the right people here and there, including paying Alyssa Milano to steal Tarana Burke’s #metoo idea, I could make it look like victims are finally getting their say. Like the tables are turning!</p><p>They’re not turning. This is all just a ruse to get Trump out of office.</p><p>See, I knew about Stormy Daniels about a week after the election. She came to me wondering how much I would pay her to rip up her NDA so she could blab about Trump. And you know, I thought about it. But I also knew that he would just call her a liar, like the 18 women who accused him of sexual misconduct. And I knew people would believe him. I don’t just mean the 30% of Americans who would believe Trump if he said he built the Eiffel Tower. I mean more like 50% or 55% of Americans would believe him. When powerless women accuse powerful men of shit in this country, we (even women!) believe the powerful men. Look at my pal Woody Allen.</p><p>Or, I should say, we <em>did</em>. I thought to myself, how do I get people to believe victims? I was stumped about this for months. Then I was watching the Taylor Swift trial, and I realized that if Hollywood had some piece of shit who had victimized a bunch of white actresses, people would <em>believe</em> those women. I mean, they’ve been on red carpets wearing $10,000 dresses! So I went looking for a powerful Hollywood piece of shit and a few of the more pliable reporters on my payroll. Weinstein turned out to be a gift. And he loves me because I’m keeping the cops away from him while he’s in, ahem, “rehab.”</p><p>The whole idea was to make this victim-believing movement <em>appear</em> non-partisan. That’s why we needed to sacrifice a few Dems, like Franken and John Conyers. Let ’em go, that’s how we get a blue wave in November.</p><p>If this was a year ago, Stormy Daniels would have been Paula Jonesed by now. But thanks to this phony #metoo movement I started, the press has to believe her. Maybe she’s even telling the truth. Maybe all these broads are telling the truth! Not like I care. I just want that salacious drip-drip-drip of irresistible stories. If you thought Hillary’s emails distracted the press, you ain’t seen nothin’ yet.</p><p>I know, I know, it’s hard to believe that a <em>man</em> is responsible for this “female-led” sea change in feminism and morality and corporate culture and what a judge and jury would find acceptable. Or…is it? Come on, let’s face it, you know behind every successful woman is a good man. And behind every woman and every man is me, George Soros. It ain’t #metoo, it’s #me. You know this!</p><p>You know what? While I’m at it, I should probably reveal to you that I’m the one behind this newly successful gun control movement too. Moms Take Action? Mike Bloomberg? The Brady Campaign? They had years, and what the hell did they ever do with them?</p><p>Of course I didn’t actually send that shooter to the Parkland School. I mean, not that you can prove. What I <em>did</em> do was call those kids right afterward, you know who, Emma Gonzalez and Cameron Lasky and David Hogg (my crisis actor!). I promised them major bucks if they made some major speeches. And they knew it would work and I knew it would work because of this whole new victim-believing thing. You think Sandy Hook moms didn’t say the same shit these kids are now saying? Of course they did! But back in 2012 they didn’t have a #metoo, victim-believing movement at their back. So back then, the press moved on.</p><p>Not now. Not the press that I shitcanned Matt Lauer and Charlie Rose right out of. (Don’t worry Matt and Charlie. I got you!)</p><p>I got to say, being George Soros is pretty sweet right about now. I mean, yeah, I’m light a few bucks, but when I think of the globalist illuminati I control…</p><p>Pretty sweet.</p><p>Oh, and if Trump is reading this email? Donald, is that you? Quick message for you:</p><p>You’re fired!</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9124e42977b2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>