<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Danny Bednar, PhD on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Danny Bednar, PhD on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@danny-bednar?source=rss-df03e0b08461------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 07:15:52 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@danny-bednar/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Wrestling’s Hart Family: A Reading Guide]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/geekculture/wrestlings-hart-family-a-reading-guide-724d84abcc4b?source=rss-df03e0b08461------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/724d84abcc4b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[wwe]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[books]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[canada]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[wrestling]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[review]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Danny Bednar, PhD]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 20 Jan 2024 18:54:47 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-02-04T16:10:44.391Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>It’s no exaggeration to say that some of the most important chapters in professional wrestling history come from the Hart family. Reflecting this, their legacy has been covered in no-less than ten books. This is a quick reading guide to anyone else diving into the Hart family literary canon.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*V6IGS8jYyHZLRRtHEq5a6A.jpeg" /><figcaption>The Hart Family literary canon (D. Bednar, 2024).</figcaption></figure><h4>WHO ARE THE HARTS?</h4><p>The Hart professional wrestling dynasty started in the late-1940s when Stu Hart began wrestling in New York City in early heydays of the “sport”. At the time, professional wrestling was just about to enter a golden age of popularity as the ease of lighting and filming wrestling made it a top choice for television networks looking to fill timeslots. In turn, post-war middle class audiences made it one of the most popular shows on TV throughout much of the 1950s.</p><p>Stu, who was born outside of Saskatoon, was never as famous an in-ring performer as some of his contemporaries, such as Gorgeous George or Buddy Rogers. This may be attributable to Stu leaving New York before wrestling truly exploded in popularity in the mid 1950s. By 1952 he had moved moved to back to Canada to start a wrestling company of his own.</p><p>Stu was already well known north of the border, especially in Western Canada. Growing up in Edmonton he was a legitimately skilled amateur wrestler and Canadian national champion who would have went to the Olympics if not for World War II.</p><p>Like any wrestling territory, Stu’s company (which would eventually be based in Calgary and known as Stampede Wrestling) experienced ebbs and flows throughout it’s existence. After losing a critical TV timeslot, Stampede Wrestling and Stu’s growing family came into hard times by the late 1960s. As a result, Stu and his wife Helen would raise their 12 kids in poverty.</p><p>By the late 1970s Stu’s sons (of which he had 8) were beginning to wrestle for Stampede. By the early 1980s, three of them: Bruce, Keith, and Bret were top performers in the promotion. Supporting Stu’s kids was a roster of emerging superstars; several of which married into the Hart family. These included The Dynamite Kid, Davey Boy Smith (who married Stu’s daughter Diana), and Jim Neidhart (who married Stu’s daughter Ellie).</p><p>In the early 1980s, wrestling had found new popularity, driven largely by the World Wrestling Federation (WWF) and it’s presence on network television in the United States. With a strong roster, a new TV deal, and a rebirth of pro wrestling as a popular form of entertainment, Stampede Wrestling stars gained fame among a generation of fans in Canada and beyond.</p><p>Growth aside, Stampede Wrestling’s days were numbered. The same WWF that had bolstered wrestling’s popularity across North America was now buying out smaller wrestling companies and taking over their TV spots, touring locations, and top performers. In 1984 Stu Hart sold Stampede Wresting to the WWF. With the territory went four of its top performers: Jim Neidhart, The Dynamite Kid (Tom Billington), Davey Boy Smith, and Bret Hart.</p><p>While Davey Boy Smith and Dynamite Kid, as the British Bulldogs, would gain international fame first, it was Bret Hart who would go on to have the most success at the international level. Between 1992 and 1997 Bret was a critical talent for the WWF, helping to carry the company though a disastrous financial period in the mid-1990s when the aging-out of 1980’s ‘Hulkamaniacs’ led to a lull in wrestling’s popularity.</p><p>After an acrimonious split with the WWF in which he was double crossed by management, Bret’s career ended in 2000 while working for second-rate World Championship Wrestling (WCW) (itself soon to be bought by the WWF). Throughout his career Bret leveraged his popularity to boost the careers of several of his family members, such as Neidhart and Davey Boy Smith. Undoubtedly, the most talented person to benefit from Bret’s popularity though was his own youngest brother Owen Hart. Through a storyline feud with his bigger brother, Owen rose to international fame in his own right by the mid-90s.</p><p>Sadly, in May of 1999, Owen died in a stunt gone-wrong in which he was to descend to the ring from the rafters of an arena. As a result of poor planning on the WWF’s side and inexperienced stunt coordinators, Owen fell to his death in front of a live audience of more than 16,000 people. Thankfully, the fall was not shown on television. It occurred as Owen was getting ready, and before cameras got the cue to turn to the rafters. The television audience were watching a pre-taped interview when the accident occurred.</p><p>The aftermath of Owen’s death led to a sort-of Hart civil war throughout the 2000s. At the core of the dispute was that some family members (namely Owen’s widow Martha and Bret) wanted the WWF to face legal consequences for their role in Owen’s death. On the other side were those who thought it was unfathomable to take the biggest wrestling company in world to court when multiple members of the extended family were still working in the business. It was during this period in which all the books detailed here were written.</p><h4>BOOKS BY HARTS</h4><blockquote><strong><em>Under the Mat: Inside Wrestling’s Greatest Family (2001). Diana Hart &amp; Kirstie McLellan. H. B. Fenn &amp; Company.</em></strong></blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/256/1*ViafSZVtDxFxyEmf-x7JqA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Under the Mat (Fenn Publishing, 2001).</figcaption></figure><p>Because I’m going chronologically, unfortunately this book has to be first. Intended as a history of the Hart family from the youngest daughter’s perspective, it’s fair to suggest that this book shouldn’t even be considered part of the family’s historical canon. Shortly after release, <em>Under the Ma</em>t was recalled by the publisher because Martha Hart (Owen’s widow) threatened legal action in response to the book’s harmful and inaccurate descriptions of her family.</p><p>While Martha is indeed the target of some vile comments, others, namely Davey Boy Smith, Jim Neidhart, Smith Hart, and Ben Bassarab face far more damning descriptions and accusations (including Diana’s graphic descriptions of sexual assault by her then husband Davey Boy Smith). Because of this, <em>Under the Mat</em> takes on a complicated legacy in Hart, and wrestling, history.</p><p>The book can mostly be taken as fiction given that almost everyone in the family has suggested as much. Even Diana has distanced herself from it since it’s publication. Bret and others have also stated that Stu did not write the forward. They suspect it was written by Diana and passed off as Stu’s writing.</p><p>In the aftermath of the book’s retraction, Diana Hart suggested that co-author Kristie McLellan was responsible for the fabrications and exaggerations in the book. McLellan denied this and has gone on to have a successful writing career in the world of hockey autobiographies. Her partnerships with people such as Wayne Gretzky and hockey broadcaster Ron MacLean indicate that she likely has the credibility to avoid exaggeration for the sake of controversy.</p><p>With the book being over two decades old, out of print, and long since abandoned by both authors, it exists now as more of an artifact than a document. Reading it as any kind of reliable account of events is almost impossible. At the same time, given their nature, some of Diana’s accusations cannot not be brushed aside. However, because the accused parties are no longer with us, it doesn’t appear anyone is too interested in further examining the accusations.</p><blockquote><strong><em>Broken Harts: The Life and Death of Owen Hart (2002). Martha Hart &amp; Eric Francis. Key Porter Books.</em></strong></blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/264/1*52oRqrNibtkK1lpc_nqZMQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Broken Harts (M. Evans &amp; Co., 2002).</figcaption></figure><p>Before the the Vice documentary series <em>Dark Side of the Ring</em> featured Martha Hart in their “<em>The Last Days of Owen Hart</em>” episode, insights on the accident and subsequent lawsuit that followed Owen’s death were limited mostly to this book. The reasons Martha stayed out of the wrestling world are made clear in <em>Broken Harts</em>. Martha is not a wrestling fan, she did not grow up around wrestling and was not interested in getting any more involved than she needed to be.</p><p>Like the <em>Dark Side of the Rin</em>g episode, <em>Broken Harts</em> makes it clear that for his family, Owen’s legacy is about more than wrestling. Martha Hart and Eric Francis’ writing emphasizes the heart ache and loss experienced by the family. Personal tragedy is the core of the book more-so than the loss of a great talent and performer. Though his accomplishments and exceptional in-ring skill are referenced throughout, the story focuses more on Owen the person than Owen the performer.</p><p>The book was written at a time when Martha was still grieving and working through the catastrophic changes that had happened in her life. While not coming off anywhere near as aggressive or angry as Diana Hart in <em>Under the Mat</em>, <em>Broken Harts </em>still contains a fair amount of raw emotion. About half the book is dedicated to Owen’s death and the legal battle between Martha and the WWF (including the disgusting story of the WWF suing her, the widow, as a legal counter tactic).</p><p>Upon completing the book, most reasonable readers will agree that Owen’s death was the result of mass negligence. Even if her arguments are painted with emotion and (understandable) personal bias, the facts presented (many of which are verifiable through additional research) make it clear that the approach taken to setting up the stunt that killed Owen was not a safe one.</p><p>This is the most definitive look at Owen Hart’s personal life we will ever get. While his siblings could, and have, added important insights into Owen’s childhood and wrestling career, no future book would be able to claim authority on Owen Hart the person over-and-beyond <em>Broken Harts</em>.</p><blockquote><strong><em>Hitman: My Real Life in the Cartoon World of Wrestling (2007). Bret Hart. Vintage Canada.</em></strong></blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/235/1*1TnapZbvYr51NBsNeiO4Zw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Hitman (Grand Central Publishers, 2009).</figcaption></figure><p>It shouldn’t be a surprise that the Hart family’s most famous member happens to provide the most interesting and wide-spanning entry in the family’s literary lore with <em>Hitman</em>. Written as a straight-forward autobiography, Bret’s book is considered among the greatest wrestling books ever. While no co-author is listed, professional editors probably helped craft the story, which lacks the errors and amateur style evident in most of the other books in this reading guide.</p><p>Though widely respected in the wrestling community, if Bret is guilty of anything it’s an almost super-human level of self-confidence. It’s hard to blame him for maintaining such strong self-belief though. It was that confidence that helped him not only emerge as the dominant personality in a chaotic family of 11 siblings, but also rise to fame in the WWF at a time when steroid-induced muscle freaks took up most of the TV time.</p><p>In the preface, the Hitman hints that the reader is in store for a brutally honest, warts and all, history of his career. Implying that perhaps his memoirs could wobble his status of Canadian hero and clean-cut good guy. While indeed revealing, Bret overestimates the degree to which people bought into his squeaky clean mid-90s good guy image. For the most part, the details shared don’t harm the Hitman’s image. By all accounts Bret was pretty responsible when it came to sex and drugs (especially compared to many of his co-workers). Bret does admit that he was not faithful to his first wife. This is indeed his, self-admitted, biggest failure. But beyond that, nothing in the book is of moral question or beyond what most good-looking young people would do with a little bit of fame and money.</p><p>While revealing the Hitman as evidently human, Bret’s book also recounts the hard work and “I’ll show you” attitude that fostered one of the greatest careers in pro-wrestling history. Because Bret’s career spans the 1980s wrestling boom and late 1990s ‘Attitude’ era (led by Stone Cold Steve Austin), his autobiography is essential reading for all wrestling fans.</p><blockquote><strong><em>Straight from the Heart (2011). Bruce Hart. ECW Press.</em></strong></blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/263/1*RVYMqMiucHCFvYh801xIew.png" /><figcaption>Straight from the Hart (ECW Press, 2011).</figcaption></figure><p>Given their carny roots and a chaotic childhood household, the Hart family has a fair share of eccentrics in the brood. Though not the oddest of the group (that honor probably belongs to the eldest - Smith Hart) Bruce’s idiosyncrasies have long entertained wrestling fans. That being said, the awkwardness that is so apparent in his interviews isn’t really present in his writing. Surprisingly, Bruce writes confidently and effectively about his life.</p><p>Coming a few years after the swath of Hart books mentioned above, Bruce doesn’t add too much to the timeline that wasn’t already discussed in previous works. At times his accounts diverge greatly from others, but that is his prerogative and many of us have no way of truly disputing that Bruce isn’t indeed telling the truth.</p><p>Where the book might lose readers is Bruce’s not-so-subtle jealously towards Bret as well as his insults toward everyone in the family other than Owen and his parents. A key part of Bruce’s story is his apparent bitterness at not being sent to the WWF as part of the sale of Stampede Wrestling. In some ways, Bruce then takes on a sort of tragic figure in Hart history as sympathetic readers could see how the shadows cast by his brothers’ successes have unfairly dimmed his role in the family’s story.</p><p>At the end of the day, <em>Straight From the Hart</em> is less new revelations and more so, ‘what does the second-eldest Hart think about things we already know about’. It’s a helpful read to understand the dynamics of the family from a certain point of a view, but I am not sure it’s where anyone should start.</p><h4>HONOURABLE MENTIONS: ESSENTIAL BOOKS ABOUT HARTS &amp; STAMPEDE WRESTLING (NOT WRITTEN BY HARTS)</h4><blockquote><strong><em>Stu Hart: Lord of the Ring (2002). Marsha Erb. </em>ECW Press.</strong></blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/317/1*98f7MH7YaocrNtPRfNp70Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>Lord of the Ring (ECW Press, 2002).</figcaption></figure><p>Published after his wife Helen passed away and shortly before Stu himself would pass away in 2003, Marsha Erb’s book could be considered the definitive (so far) work on Stu Hart. Erb wrote the book with the support of the Hart family and evidently interviewed Stu, Helen, and Hart children Bruce, Ross, Elle, and Keith among others. About 30% of the book focuses on Stu’s youth, 30% on his days running Stampede Wrestling, 30% on his family, and a 10% on Bret’s departure from the WWF, Owen’s death, and Helen’s passing.</p><p>In the Hart civil war that emerged in the aftermath of Owen’s death, Erb seems firmly in the camp of Bruce, Elle, and Diana (i.e. don’t sue the WWF). Erb does cover the family’s reaction to Diana’s book (which was the only other Hart book out at the time), and, in no uncertain terms, confirms the suspicions that Stu himself did not write the forward and was not aware, or supportive, of the content of <em>Under the Mat</em>.</p><p>Though the book starts with an insightful view of the Hart House in the days immediately after Owen’s death, the book’s biggest contribution to Hart family history is its focus on Stu’s youth and his almost unbelievable journey from Saskatchewan to Edmonton to New York City and finally, to Calgary. While not a biography with the sort of academic rigor that someone like Stu Hart deserves (there aren’t even sources or references listed at the end), the fact that it was written in partnership with Stu and the family makes it an important read in any effort to learn about the Harts.</p><blockquote><strong><em>Pain and Passion: The History of Stampede Wrestling, 2nd Ed. (2007), by Heath McCoy</em></strong></blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/258/1*-_eWPWXbNl-1jTLC9LQ31g.png" /><figcaption>Pain and Passion (ECW Press, 2007).</figcaption></figure><p>The most thoroughly researched book on this list, <em>Pain and Passion </em>is the sweeping third party account that the Stampede Wrestling territory deserves. McCoy, a Calgary sportswriter, is largely deferential to the Harts as it seems his connections (if mostly professional) limit any criticism. Nonetheless, a ‘puff piece’ this is not. It also, arguably, makes <em>Lord of the Ring</em> somewhat obsolete. McCoy summarizes the key points from Erb’s book effectively enough for readers to skip the previous entry all together.</p><p>Being the only book on this list that isn’t explicitly about a Hart,<em> Pain and Passion </em>fills in gaps left by others about the business of Stampede Wrestling and the presence of characters like Archie the Stomper, Andre the Giant, and Abdullah the Butcher in the lives of the Harts.</p><p>Its wider lens than other books in this guide adds key context to the core Hart story that unfolded from the 1940s through the 1990s. It’s a must read if you are interested in the history of pro-wrestling in Canada and a mostly fresh third-party view of the Harts.</p><h4><strong>BOOKS WORTH EXPLORING BUT NOT CRITICAL TO THE HART FAMILY STORY</strong></h4><p><em>Pure Dynamite: The Price You Pay For Wrestling Stardom</em>, (1999) by Tom Billington and Alison Coleman.</p><p><em>Ring of Hell: The Story of Chris Benoit &amp; The Fall of the Pro Wrestling Industry,</em> (2008) by Matthew Randazzo V.</p><p><em>Crazy Like A Fox: The Definitive Chronicle of Brian Pillman 20 Years Later,</em> (2017) by Liam O’Rourke.</p><p><em>Dynamite &amp; Davey: The Explosive Lives of the British Bulldogs</em>, (2022) by Steven Bell.</p><h4>THE RANKINGS</h4><ol><li><strong>Hitman by Bret Hart</strong> — As I mentioned above, this is the best written and the most interesting read. If you’re starting a Hart family binge, you have to start with the family’s most famous wrestling son.</li><li><strong>Pain &amp; Passion by Heat McCoy</strong> — What Bret’s book might lack in objectivity, <em>Pain and Passion </em>mostly fills in. Not a totally distanced view of the family, but well researched and expansive enough that the context for Bret, Stu, and Owen’s lives, among others, are better understood.</li><li><strong>Broken Harts by Martha Hart</strong> — The most important story in Hart family history. The only reason this isn’t higher is that it is largely focused (rightfully so) on Owen and his life with Martha rather than on Owen as a wrestler or the wider Hart family. Essential reading for wrestling fans, but not as expansive as the two books above it on this list.</li><li><strong>Lord of the Ring by Martha Erb </strong>— As an amateur writer myself, I can see a fellow dilatant a mile away. Erb’s book is helpful in understanding Stu, but it lacks the polish of McCoy, who’s subsequent <em>Pain &amp; Passion </em>made Erb’s book mostly expendable. It’s also out of print and hard to find.</li><li><strong>Straight From the Hart by Bruce Hart</strong> — Bruce legitimately brought innovative ideas to wrestling and was an eye witness to a critical time of pro-wrestling history. For completists, its definitely worth a read. But like all the books by Hart siblings, it requires an understanding that every event has multiple interpretations. Here, readers must decide if the author is a reliable narrator.</li><li><strong>Under the Mat by Diana Hart </strong>— Speaking of unreliable narrators. This book can only be described as either a morbid curiosity, or a reflection of great pain and mental anguish. I don’t recommend it, but I also know that the Streisand Effect is in full play here and every fan of the Hart family rushed to read it the second it was removed from shelves.</li></ol><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=724d84abcc4b" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/geekculture/wrestlings-hart-family-a-reading-guide-724d84abcc4b">Wrestling’s Hart Family: A Reading Guide</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/geekculture">Geek Culture</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What’s It Like To Be In The Metallica Snake Pit on the M72 Tour?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/curious/whats-it-like-to-be-in-the-metallica-snake-pit-on-the-m72-tour-7b41faaffdd8?source=rss-df03e0b08461------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7b41faaffdd8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[concerts]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pop-culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[metallica]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[metal]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Danny Bednar, PhD]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 27 Aug 2023 14:42:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-02-22T03:31:43.057Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>When the idea to have a ‘pit’ of fans in the middle of Metallica’s stage was first used for the band’s ‘Black Album’ tours in the early 90s, opportunities for tickets were through fan club lotteries only. This meant that for decades, the fabled Metallica ‘Snake Pit’ was the dwelling solely of the devoted and extremely lucky.</p><p>Today, things have changed. Money gets you in. Combined with a much larger Snake Pit, thousands of Metallica fans are about to experience it for the first time. So what’s it like?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*X1hCEEVzwIqB3UyX0BQ6Zw.jpeg" /><figcaption>The Original Snake Pit (Image: Metallica.com)</figcaption></figure><p>On Friday August 11th and Sunday August 13th 2023, I had the pleasure of being inside the Snake Pit for two consecutive Metallica shows. How was it? Was it worth the money (about $1000 USD)? Would I do it again?</p><p>My take away is that, everything Metallica could control was amazing. Their show was incredible, and from that stand point alone it was worth every digital cent. On the other hand, there were a few things I wish I knew ahead of time that, oddly, were not communicated in the multitude of pre-show emails I received.</p><p>I wrote this article to share my experiences in the hope that fellow members of the Metallica family will have a smoother experience than I did. As indicated above, this is the first time that access to the Snake Pit was made for sale, and likely the first time that a new generation of fans will have access to it. I myself was one of those people experiencing it for the first time.</p><p>But as I was preparing for the show I didn’t find a ton of helpful info on what to expect. Admittedly, I’m not a Reddit or Metallica Forums guy and being largely unfamiliar with the users, I didn’t want to scroll through forums. I wanted one concise article answering a few basic questions.</p><p>So for others looking for an article clearly articulating what to expect from the Snake Pit experience, and answering some questions, here you are (you’ll have to excuse a brief ‘tangent city’ about the security staff in Montreal).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Acd8t_AL7PFeuZ2S33OkUA.jpeg" /><figcaption>In bright colors to make them easy for security to see…logistics! (Image: D.Bednar)</figcaption></figure><p>If you have a Snake Pit Pass, it came either with a “Nothing Else Matters Experience” or “Moth Into Flame Experience” package. Everything I talk about is included in the Nothing Else Matters Package, so it will be of some help to those package holders even if most Snake Pit entrants are Moth Into Flame ticket holders. There are also useful tidbits for those with general floor tickets.</p><p><strong>Question 1: How does the ‘priority merch stand access’ work?</strong></p><p>It’s a nice idea for a perk with the Snake Pit pass, but it ain’t much really. At least not in Montreal. It’s a line to the side of the regular merch stand. In theory, it is helpful, but I don’t think there was anyone checking for passes, so it was the same wait time. Overall, not a big deal.</p><p>However, one of the shirts I got is hilariously misprinted with the logo off center. I didn’t notice until I got home Friday night. At Sunday’s show I noticed that some people had the misprint, others didn’t. Oops.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*6VwK4yrNp1V4SqLTPKy15w.jpeg" /><figcaption>Who would ever buy those bootleg shirts in the parking lot when you can get an official one like this for only twice the price (image: D.Bednar)</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Question 2: What’s the deal with the ‘Pre-Show Black Box Lounge’?</strong></p><p>The lounge is pretty cool. It’s a draped-off section of the arena basement with catering, Metallica memorabilia, some old instruments you can play (the best part), two bars, and a bathroom. In Montreal there was sushi, some pasta salad, lots of desserts, and cool album cover mini-cupcakes. Two ladies who seemed like they had no idea what they were doing ran a short trivia contest. I won a hat for knowing which song had <em>Flamenco</em> as it’s working title.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YPcrapK5frQAI2AbeD6Nbw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Damn right I ate the St. Anger cupcake, show some respect. (Image: D. Bednar)</figcaption></figure><p>What I found odd about the lounge was the absence of staff, information, and overall customer service of any kind. Whatever staff were there only wore plain black with no indication of whether they worked for either Metallica or the venue. At first, some people didn’t know if you could touch the instruments as no one was around to provide background or instructions.</p><p>Ideally, there should probably be an info booth (there is plenty of room) or, at the very least, staff shirts. I know it seems kinda lame, but honestly it was weird. I probably could have went the entire two shows without interacting with any staff had I not sought them out to ask how to get to the Snake Pit. Speaking of which.</p><p><strong>Question 3: How do you actually get into the Snake P</strong>it?</p><p>Great question, I thought this would be included in every pre-show email I got, but alas, it wasn’t. Worse, everyone at the show seemed to have no idea either. When I asked staff in the black box lounge, it turned out they weren’t Metallica staff, they were local, and they just said “you go to the floor, it’s on the floor”….thanks.</p><p>I went to the floor, did two laps around the stage (as Pantera came out) and found nothing but a sea of people all the way around. When I asked security working the floor, most of them had no idea what I was talking about (yes it was Montreal, but I speak fluent French and English). I found one guy who knew what the Snake Pit was, but he became very angry that I was asking him about it. He walked me over to one section and exasperatedly pointed to the mass of people watching Pantera and said “it’s in there, you go there”…cool. It was a mass of people, 100 or more thick.</p><p>This shit sandwich continued through all of Pantera, as me and several other Snake Pit fans began asking more security staff how to actually get into the Snake Pit. We all reasoned that if we had to fight through a 100-person-deep floor crowd, it would kind of defeat the purpose….so something must be fucked up.</p><p>This lasted for an hour…people were mad, I was no exception. Eventually Pantera finished and security cleared a path using a big tall fence so that the band could leave. After some arguing, and the support of one of the security team members working the Pit itself, we were let in via that fenced path. The only causality being not getting to watch Pantera (my second favourite band).</p><p>So what the fuck happened? Well it turns out that security is supposed to keep a path to the Snake Pit entrance clear, through the crowd, at all times. As Buzz McCallister might say, <em>les incompitents</em> who worked the show did not know this on night 1 and just let the crowd fill-out the floor around the stage.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*oxkHO6iiXym2pymMMqcXhw.jpeg" /><figcaption>The mythical path to the Snake Pit on Night 2, presumably after the security team learned their lesson (Image: D. Bednar)</figcaption></figure><p>So, how do you actually get into the Snake Pit when things are working as they are supposed to? Here is what I would have put in a pre-show email that whichever company Metallica hired to run show logistics did not.</p><ul><li><em>Access to the Snake Pit is directly from the general admission floor, there is no separate or secluded entrance from elsewhere in the stadium.</em></li><li><em>On the general admission floor, there are two entrances to the Snake Pit, across form one another, under the highest points of the circular stage.</em></li><li><em>Security at the venue has been instructed to maintain a path through the crowd to at least one of the entrances throughout the opening acts and until Metallica takes the stage.</em></li><li><em>The Snake Pit can be accessed in-between acts after equipment has been removed, but the departure of the previous act, removal of equipment, and security of the performers is primary. You may have to wait until these are complete until you can enter the Snake Pit in-between acts.</em></li></ul><p><strong>Question 4: What is in the Snake Pit? Bar? Bathroom?</strong></p><p>There is nothing in the Snake Pit, it’s just a circle. But if access is cleared as it should be, it’s not a problem. You can come and go for drinks and bathroom as you need during the openers. Not sure how it works during Metallica, I never left at that point.</p><p><strong>Question 5: Is it hard to get to the front of the crowd? Do you have to line up hours ahead of time?</strong></p><p>Of note, the height of the stage from the Snake Pit varies. At two points it is about waist high, at other parts it is about 4–6 feet high. Above the entrances it is about 7 feet high (the guys tended to stand above the entrances for pyro songs, I suspect James was being extra careful during Fade, given the city…).</p><p>What’s nice about the Snake Pit is that there is no gap between the front of the crowd and the stage. If you’ve been near the stage at more recent arena and stadium concerts, the trend has been an increasing distance from the crowd to the stage (COVID?). These days, at a typical major show, there is almost always a 4–6 feet gap between the rail and the stage. Not so in the Snake Pit. So you if you do end up at the front, the guys are right on top of you, like a small venue.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*qg_Qg6KR47yDEW4fMbNb2g.jpeg" /><figcaption>A smiling James addresses the crowd (Image: D. Bednar)</figcaption></figure><p>On Sunday I was lucky enough to be right at the stage where it is waist high. This cemented that the cost was worth it, but even if I hadn’t gotten to the front, the Snake Pit experience (assuming all logistics go well) would have still been well worth it.</p><p>To get to the front I didn’t line up early or anything, I arrived in the pit after the last opener (Five Finger Death Punch) and still ended up along the stage through the normal movement of people. I never needed to be physically aggressive or anything like that, I was polite and simply took whatever space was given to me. If people left for the bathroom and came back I recognized them and gave them back their space. This may not be the case everywhere, but we had a good group in Montreal.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*TaWun2gG3fCbnFrc3sWEKw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Rob close-up from the front of the Snake Pit (Image: D. Bednar)</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Question 6: How does the circular stage work for Viewing?</strong></p><p>If you are in the Snake Pit, or on the general floor, I believe the best spots are near Lars’ drum kits. The band tend to gather around him rather frequently. Lars’ drums move throughout the show to four equidistant portions of the circle. Some people in the Snake Pit chose to follow a mix of either Lars or James. The way people moved in the Snake Pit was like water being tilted in a shallow container (well…with some sticking to the sides). I did a bit of this on night 1, but once I found myself at the front on night 2, I stuck to my spot.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*XKgaFeX3WeuykVqFO0myFA.jpeg" /><figcaption>The stage set up with fans. Lars’ kit will move to four different sections throughout the show (Image: Metallica.com)</figcaption></figure><p>When you’re right at the front, the circular stage is a bit of feast and famine. Though ‘famine’ is a strong word. There were only a few instances where no band members came to our section for a song or two. It’s certainly not a problem because you’ll be looking left at James and Rob, then turn right and all of a sudden Kirk is ripping a solo 5 inches from your face. With the circle stage, they can just sneak up on you sometimes.</p><p>The best part of the Snake Pit is that when the band isn’t 3–4 feet (or inches) from you, they are, at worst, maybe 50 feet away? When I stayed on one edge of the Snake Pit and watched someone at the furthest point from me it was as if I was on the general floor and maybe 30 or so people back. So worst case scenario in the Snake Pit, you’re always much closer than most people on the floor.</p><p><strong>Question 7: Does the band face away from you all concert?</strong></p><p>Nope. If anything, I would say they look disproportionality into the Snake Pit given that 95% of the crowd is on the outside. There were entire songs where James sung towards the Pit. Ultimately, I guess we shouldn’t be surprised. The band has had this arrangement, on and off, for over 30 years, so they’ve got their movements down.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*7PTi06ETaSqkny6F_vqIyA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Kirk doing his portion of the One intro right front of us (Image: D.Bednar)</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Question 8: How crowded is the Snake Pit? Is it Rowdy?</strong></p><p>So rumor has it that the <a href="https://www.rollingstone.com/music/music-news/metallica-lars-ulrich-snake-pit-1234732994/">current Snake Pit holds between 1000 and 1200 people</a>. I would say even at it’s fullest it was not overly crowded. However, watching some videos from the European leg of the M72 Tour, it looked a lot more full over there. Maybe Montreal was just light? As far as I know it was sold out? So all I can say is that in my experience, as someone who hates large crowds and being cramped, I never felt uncomfortable.</p><p>As with any concert experience, individual experience will vary. Sometimes there are those aggressive dudes imposing themselves on others via force, sometimes you luck out and get a good orderly group around you (as I mostly had).</p><p>Metallica is no exception when it comes to asshole fans who are reckless or aggressive on the floor. I’m sure they have the same proportion of jackass fans as any other major act (don’t get me started on the over-zealous collectors who will dive with reckless abandon for a guitar pick).</p><p>All this to say, the Pit was quite comfortable. There were also a fair amount of kids. Overall a safe environment and a good time had by all.</p><p><strong>Question 9: What is the Sound Like?</strong></p><p>The sound in the Snake Pit is no different than the sound on the general floor. I suspect sound will vary on the M72 tour depending on the stadium. At the Olympic Stadium in Montreal, the bass echo was at times overpowering. For Pantera, it largely overwhelmed the higher tones. For Metallica is was better, but I would be curious what more casual fans might have thought of the sound. The brains on us diehards know the songs so well our ears probably seek out the familiar higher tones, even if faint. I don’t know, just a guess as to why I didn’t really mind the sound. I am, however, in no way an unbiased observer in this matter.</p><p><strong>Conclusion: Is the Snake Pit Worth It?</strong></p><p>Despite the useless staff in Montreal, the Snake Pit was absolutely worth it. While there are things the Metallica team should adjust to make the experience better for everyone, I would absolutely do the Snake Pit again (note: I am not wealthy).</p><p>As far as everything the band controls, it couldn’t be any better. Lots of Metallica’s recent business decisions can be criticized, but there is no doubting that when they are in control, they do everything they can do to show they care about their fans. The Snake Pit experience is no different.</p><p>Also, when else could you do this with one of Rob’s old bases?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*rjXHoAO4MZ9L5flF2u3u1Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>Slappin da bass (Image: D.Bednar, 2023)</figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7b41faaffdd8" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/curious/whats-it-like-to-be-in-the-metallica-snake-pit-on-the-m72-tour-7b41faaffdd8">What’s It Like To Be In The Metallica Snake Pit on the M72 Tour?</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/curious">Curious</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Building Provincial Rosters of NHL Players and Why ‘Sub-National’ Tournaments Would be Way More…]]></title>
            <link>https://danny-bednar.medium.com/building-provincial-rosters-of-nhl-players-and-why-sub-national-tournaments-would-be-way-more-ac4a1cdbf279?source=rss-df03e0b08461------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ac4a1cdbf279</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[canada]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hockey]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nhl]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sports]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[olympics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Danny Bednar, PhD]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 10 Jan 2022 01:44:24 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-01-10T02:49:32.288Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Building Provincial Rosters of NHL Players and Why ‘Sub-National’ Tournaments Would be Way More Fun than a World Cup of Hockey</h3><p>So the NHL wants a best-on-best tournament? Screw international hockey, lets see some intranational best-on-best. Team B.C vs. Team Ontario, Team Michigan vs. Team Westcoast…oh the possibilities…</p><p><em>Danny Bednar is an author and professional geographer with a PhD from Western University. By day he works for the Canadian Space Agency, by night he writes about music, space exploration, and hockey.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/757/1*rKw-aNv0iCKdgf15Zh6Y6Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>Once upon a time, some dude with a beard said “hey play for this”, and teams from cities and provinces far and wide heeded his call (Image: Public Domain).</figcaption></figure><p>In December 2021 we learned that the NHL would not be allowing it’s players to go to the 2022 Olympic Games. While this isn’t surprising, it leaves a hole in many hockey hearts. The draw of the Olympics is several fold. The most obvious is that sports fans love seeing ‘super teams’ and, in hockey, the fantasy line combinations that manifest. So-called “best-on-best” also (somewhat) settles debates and (usually) makes for phenomenal hockey. Finally, if you derive personal joy from some notion of hockey being “our game” then I suppose the Olympics are another dose for your nationalist kick. Whatever our reasons, a lot of us look forward to best-on-best.</p><p>In the absence of a best-on-best Olympic hockey tournament in 2022, solutions are abound to be fantasized about. One clear option is an NHL-hosted World Cup played in a bubble city or within one country. But a World Cup of NHLers leaves a lot of good players on the shelf, in multiple ways so to speak. It leaves a lot of good Canadian and American players off teams because of limited rosters spots. In another way, it is secondly flawed as it also leaves a lot of great European players out who are not playing in the NHL. The NHL tried to address the first issue with its 2016 World Cup (i.e. Gary’s Fake Olympics), and one thing we all seemed to learn was that arbitrarily lumping together young players hurt the concept of international “best-on-best” (I’m sure Team USA could have used Austin Matthews…).</p><p>International competition is also kinda old-fashioned and, frankly, a bit over-emphasized from a competition perspective given the discrepancies in popularity and populations across countries. Should we periodically find out which country has the best roster of hockey players at a given time? Sure, let the Olympics do that every four years. But if the NHL isn’t going to the Olympics (even if it were) why duplicate the international model if the distribution of NHLers by nationality is nowhere near even numbers? Maybe we need to remember that countries aren’t the only geographic way to divide players.</p><p>What if the NHL hosted multiple tournaments of sub-national/regional teams? Curling does it, and so does hockey at various levels up to junior. In Canada this would mean finally settling some age-old debates over provincial supremacy. I’m also suspect that Minnesota and Michigan hockey fans would love to see a best on best game between the State of Hockey and the home of Hockeytown. European NHLers could easily be divided by regions as well (as simple as East, West, and North) and added to the U.S. tournament. In fact you could have an 8 team tournament with U.S and European teams (MI, MN, MA, U.S. West Coast, U.S. East Coast, Scandanavia, Western Europe, Eastern Europe), with the winner playing whoever comes out on top of a Canadian provincial tournament (see below).</p><p>For argument’s sake I have expanded upon the scenario by which the NHL did something like this in an August-September timeframe (just before training camp). In this case I have focused on the Canadian example only (sorry, eh), but it gets the point across that the scale of geographical division is malleable. So let’s take a look at the potential fun to be had with a long-fabled best-on-best Canadian provincial tournament.</p><h3><strong>CASE IN POINT: THE CANADA CUP OF HOCKEY 2022</strong></h3><p>Which province has the most, or best, NHLers? It’s not a rare Google search, and <a href="http://www.downgoesbrown.com/2019/07/putting-together-team-ontario-roster.html">others have written on the topic</a>. But a list of full rosters is much less discussed (nevermind how a full tournament might shake out). While the idea seems frivolous now, it’s not that out-of-step with the origins of hockey in North America.</p><p>Over 100 years ago, before the NHL got started, hockey was all about teams representing cities and provinces, battling one another for bragging rights (sometimes funded by <a href="https://www.heritagetrust.on.ca/en/pages/our-stories/exhibits/snapshots-of-ontarios-sport-heritage/connection-between-community-geography-and-sport/the-renfrew-millionaires">cartoonish local mining barons</a>). When a a certain Governor General had the idea to award the winning team a trophy, the Stanley Cup was born as a tool to ‘unite the country through sport’.</p><p>So, what would this ‘Canada Cup’ 2022 (not to be confused with the tournament last held in 1991) best-on-best provincial tournament look like? And how fun would it be?</p><p>To keep things even and easy, lets make it a simple 8 team tournament, with teams from B.C., Alberta, Saskatchewan, Manitoba and Quebec respectively. To add some depth to the Martimes, we will combine Nova Scotia, New Brunskwick, Newfoundland and Labradour, and Prince Edward Island. To represent the Territories (Northwest Terrioties, Yukon, Nunavut) Dylan Cozens, the only current NHLer from a Canadian Territory, will be added to the combined ‘Team Maritimes and Territories’ (you can imagine better names if you would like).</p><p>That puts us at 6 teams. To round out the tournament, two Ontario teams are necessary because, as of midway through the 2021–2022 NHL season, Ontario has more than 3 times as many players to play an NHL game this season (181) then the next province (Quebec has 51).</p><p>How does one divide Ontario into 2? Well surely the most entertaining option is to create a team for the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_municipalities_in_the_Greater_Toronto_Area">Greater Toronto Area</a> (Team Toronto), and have ‘Team Ontario’ represent the rest of the province (having lived in Ontario for the past decade+, it seems like these are two distinct places anyhow).</p><p>In developing the rosters below, I assigned players based on their NHL.com birthplaces (I’m not sure Max Domi spent much time in Winnipeg, but oh well). In reality players could opt to play in provinces where they actually grew up. Additionally, I only included players currently on NHL contracts, as if it were a tournament being put on by the NHL (hence no junior/college stars or KHLers).</p><p>I didn’t include extras, and so built a standard 23 player roster. We can assume there would be extras (as with the Olympics), but sorting through AHL player bios for the Maritime &amp; Territories team convinced me to let imaginations take over on who the extra, non-roster, players might be. That being said, for most of the teams I noted some players left off the rosters.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*sr9vV5_JBojecfZgMJH7ug.png" /></figure><p>With an 8 team tournament, the pools are easy enough:</p><blockquote><strong>Western Pool: </strong>Team B.C., Team Alberta, Team Saskatchewan, Team Manitoba</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Eastern Pool: </strong>Team Quebec, Team Ontario, Team Toronto, Team Maritimes &amp; Territories.</blockquote><p>Each pool would play a round robin amongst themselves and a basic 8 team, single elimination, tournament would follow.</p><p>Using <a href="https://www.capfriendly.com/">CapFrindly.com</a>’s wonderful Armchair GM tool, here are the provincial squads based on the first half(ish) of the 2021–2022 season. Don’t read too much into the line combos or depth chart placement. I did my best. but trying to craft the perfect lines for a tournament that doesn&#39;t actually exist would be an exercise in futility.</p><h3>Team British Columbia</h3><blockquote>Captain: Jamie Benn</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/718/1*fVUS2P55Qg1TMpxF4JANQg.png" /></figure><p>Despite being well over the NHL salary cap ($90+million), Team B.C. doesn’t have the roster depth that we will see later with the two Ontario teams, nor maybe even Quebec . Speaking of Quebec, Team B.C. fans would experience something familiar to Montrealers for this tournament; the fate of the team hanging largely on the play of Carey Price (if he’s healthy). A resurgent Ryan Johansen tops out an otherwise okay top six. Led by a former Art Ross Trophy winner in Jamie Benn, B.C. wouldn’t be a surefire favourite to win it all, but certainly no bottom feeder.</p><p><em>Potential Additions: D. Hunt (F-NYR), K. Turris (F-EDM), D. Coghaln (D-VGK), Schutlz, J. (D-WSH), M. Jones (G-PHI).</em></p><h3>Team Alberta</h3><blockquote>Captain: Brayden Point</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/714/1*DI74qwBPQ0iWmKxD4-geOA.png" /></figure><p>Only one sneaky IR placement away from being a cap compliant NHL team, Alberta hosts a high-skill team with a former Hart Trophy winner (Hall) and future many-time Norris winner (Makar). Another team that suffers from comparative depth (wait till we get to the Ontario teams), Team Alberta would nonetheless be very competitive in the round robin and would likely battle it out with B.C. to finish first in the Western Pool. Two game-breakers in hypothetical captain Point and wunderkind Makar would have opposing defensemen on edge at all times. Only a steady performance from Carter Hart would be needed for AB to take their pool.</p><p><em>Potential Additions: J. Beagle (F-ARI), C. Rowney (F-DET), C. Soucy (D-SEA), T. Smith (D-NJD), A. Dell (G-SJ).</em></p><h3><em>Team Saskatchewan</em></h3><blockquote>Captain: Ryan Getzlaf</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/714/1*myRUQVx2h0bHrvtQvmtN-A.png" /></figure><p>Coming in well under the NHL salary cap, Saskatchewan might be the biggest underdog in the tournament if not for their prairie province sibling having major issues in net (see Manitoba next). Nothing flashy on paper, the SK roster doesn&#39;t have a single major award winner, yet hosts a Cup winning goalie in what might be the team’s position of strength. While Hotlby isn’t what he used to be, his recent resurgence in Dallas, and Kuemper’s reliable play over the past few seasons on terrible Coyotes teams, give SK the potential to land a big upset or two. Led by an aging Getzlaf, SK could be the Finland of the tournament, a scrappy but skilled squad looking to steal a few 2–1 games on the back of timely goaltending and good defensive structure.</p><p><em>Potential Additions: R. Johnson (F-CHI), D. Tokarski (G-BUF)</em></p><h3><em>Team Manitoba</em></h3><blockquote>Captain: Jonathon Toews</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/715/1*O9WoRVj-UeQZK2iB311NQw.png" /></figure><p>Led by another superstar from the 2010’s, Manitoba has a lot of cup rings thanks to Toews and Keith. Nonetheless, this team made up mostly of Winnipegers is undoubtedly short on high-end skill. Not hosting the potential goaltending stability that Saskatchewan has, MB might be a favorite choice to finish last in the entire tournament. That being said, the defense is solid enough to potentially shut things down and win some low-event hockey. We know Toews thrives in tournament play, perhaps a fountain of youth miracle, and a prime Mark Stone on his wing, could will this team to something.</p><p><em>Potential Additions: B. McCartney (F-ARI), W. Kalynuk (D-CHI), C. Addison (D-MIN), J. Hofer (G-STL).</em></p><h3>Team Ontario</h3><blockquote><em>Captain: Alex Pietrangelo</em></blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/719/1*jEkq6ysW1k4uERq3SPo5oQ.png" /></figure><p>Our first superteam. Indicated not only by its combined wages blowing past the NHL salary cap (&gt;$113M), but also the depth chart. Claude Giroux as potentially a fourth line centre? Ryan Ellis and Cam Fowler as a potential ‘bottom pair’ (though one could argue Nurse and Doughty are a more apt 5–6)? Even if you don’t agree with my line-up decisions (to be expected) whomever is coaching Team Ontario is sitting some skilled players. While the goaltending is solid (as least as of the 2021–2022 campaign), and the defense is all-star quality, the one potential weakness could be pure goal-scorers. Sure there is offensive talent aplenty, but I’m not sure sure who is singlehandedly taking over the game when this team needs a goal or two against tough D from B.C., Toronto, or Quebec.</p><p><em>Potential Additions: M. Smith (G-EDM), M. Weegar (D-FLA), B. Montour (D-FLA), J. McCann (F-SEA), A. Henrique (F-ANA).</em></p><h3>TEAM TORONTO</h3><blockquote>Captain: Connor McDavid</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/716/1*_tZSABsv6mQE2fDdiWTQXg.png" /></figure><p>Looking at the forwards, you might think this team is a lock to win the tournament…hen you got to the defense. While it’s a lot of quality names on the back-end, it surely doesn’t match the expectations set by the wealth of offensive talent up front. Given the region’s population, there are surprisingly few high-end defensemen from the Greater Toronto Area (GTA) playing in the NHL right now. That being said, it probably doesn&#39;t matter. This forward group would do all sorts of damage and this top six, in any order, is the best in the tournament. It’s worth noting that in this scenario I have TO opting to take 8 defensemen and 13 forwards. If they need, Subban can play up, but McDavid can surely eat the minutes if they fall short a forward. One final note: A team based out of Toronto with both Tom Wilson and Jordan Binnington? Not only would TO be a favorite to win it, they’re a lock to play villain throughout the tournament.</p><p><em>Potential Additions: S. Wedgewood (G-ARI), E. Bouchard (D-EDM), T. Seguin (F-DAL), T. Toffoli (F-MTL), J. Bailey (F-NYI).</em></p><h3>TEAM QUEBEC</h3><blockquote>Captain: Patrice Bergeron</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/712/1*1nT8fniahCJm774nLgaYcA.png" /></figure><p>If they can get past their local media, this team has quite the potential. Pretty well-balanced up front and flush with good-two way defensive forwards. While the back end isn’t necessarily the best in the tournament, Marc-Andre Fleury should be comfortable behind old pal Kris Letang. With Danault, Gourde, Bergeron, and Huberdeau, QC might have the tournament&#39;s best penalty kill. If any weakness is evident, its, again, perhaps the lack of pure finishing talent. Probably not the most high scoring team, but a potential kryptonite to the front-loaded Ontario teams.</p><p><em>Potential Additions: Z. Fucale (G-WAS), J. Lauzon (D-SEA), M. Vlasic (D-SJS), A. Beauvillier (F-NYI), A. Barre-Boulet (F-TBL), A. Lafreniere (F-NYR), F. Gaudreau (F-MIN)</em></p><h3>TEAM MARITIMES &amp; TERRITORIES</h3><blockquote>Captain: Sidney Crosby</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/718/1*LCzB-5LV60EpnHcgZTUxMQ.png" /></figure><p>Say all you want about a lack of depth, despite having only $48M in NHL salaries on the squad Team Maritimes and Territories has a first line as good as it gets. While COVID may have robbed us of seeing Crosby centre Marchand and Bergeron for an ‘even more perfection line’, Nova Scotia alone provides one of the best top lines you could imagine. Pay no attention to the fact that 3 of the defensemen on this roster haven’t played an NHL game this season, Maritimes and Territories would be the fun scrappy underdogs of the tournament. It wouldn’t necessarily be a one-line team either. Even without splitting Crosby and Mackinnon, the young second line of Cozens, Newhook, and Mercer could give opposing teams fits, just as the youngsters of Team North America did in the NHL’s 2016 World Cup. Playing perfect foe to the big city bullies in their Pool, this squad taking on Team TO would make for extremely entertaining hockey</p><h3>WHO WINS?</h3><p>On paper, Team Toronto looks like the favorite. Nonetheless, There is more parity here than I expected, and having crafted the rosters, I actually think this would be a far more competitive tournament than first thought. Splitting TO from the rest of Ontario helpfully robs both teams of key players. TO ends up surprisingly ‘good but not great’ on the backend, while Ontario looses the absurd forward depth it would have otherwise. It’s safe to assume that B.C. or Alberta would come out of the West (I say AB), but the East is probably too close to call (though TO should be favs).</p><p>Of course, in a single elimination tournament, anything can happen. I think everyone would get a kick out of a Cinderella tournament from Team Maritimes &amp; Territories, and the potential media narratives around a questionable Tom Wilson hit or Binnington quote ahead of a Team Ontario vs. Team Quebec game would have Canadian hockey writers across the country salivating to put out content.</p><p>While normally, I would admit this is a dumb, or at least an unrealistic, idea. In a COVID world, it’s less dumb than a lot of thing’s we’ve actually seen in the past two years. Hey… and if we can’t get fans in the stands, maybe the NHL could do a Pay Per View model to generate revenue…I kid…I think… (ESPN+, GameCenter…?)</p><p>The NHL is getting creative in generating revenue and maybe, just maybe, there are others like me who think international best-on-best should be left to the Olympics or IIHF (especially since so many great European players aren’t in the NHL).</p><p>Of course having practically every NHL player on one team or another wouldn’t be as ‘best’ as some best-on-best purists might want in a tournament, but I mean…isn’t the NHL always kinda best-on-best anyways? And when it comes to international hockey, with the exception of team Canada, it’s not like every player in the Olympic hockey tournament is an NHL all-star. In fact many of them would be below NHL quality (yes, even with the NHL going). If Canada beats Finland in the World Cup does ESPN and many of its viewers really care? What if Team West Coast, led by Auston Matthews, upset team Scandanavia or Team Ontario? That’s a ratings spike.</p><p>In the end, there is no shortage of ways to divide the world’s best players for the sake of a hockey tournament (or for the sake or revenue generation, the actual driver of these tournaments). Sure countries are fun, but that’s been done. If borders are in the way, who needs ‘em! Lets kick-off NHL training camps in 2022 by finding out if some scrappy prairie kids can upset the big city boys from the GTA.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ac4a1cdbf279" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Metallica — The $24.95 Book (Review)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/curious/metallica-the-24-95-book-review-58a1f55a539b?source=rss-df03e0b08461------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/58a1f55a539b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[book-review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[books]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[heavy-metal]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[metallica]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Danny Bednar, PhD]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 18 Aug 2021 15:40:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-08-18T20:43:07.353Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Metallica — The $24.95 Book (Review)</h3><p><em>What’s left to be written about the biggest metal band of all time? Seasoned writer Ben Apatoff hopes enough to justify his new book. As a Metallica die hard, I&#39;m keen to agree, but who else should read the cheekily named $24.95 Book?</em></p><blockquote>Title: <a href="http://backbeatbooks.com/books/9781493061341">Metallica: The $24.95 Book</a></blockquote><blockquote>Author: <a href="https://twitter.com/Bapatoff">Ben Apatoff</a></blockquote><blockquote>Released: August 15, 2021 (Backbeat Books)</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*qSWe7u9ltdjD3FMGBr-PVw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Cover for Metallica: The $24.95 Book by Ben Apatoff (2021) (Image: Backbeat Books/Getty Images).</figcaption></figure><p><em>Danny Bednar is Canada’s second greatest geographer of outer space, an amateur (wannabe?) heavy metal musicologist, and part-time Assistant Professor in the Department of Geography and the Environment at Western University. He spends his days saving the world at the Canadian Space Agency and is an author with Mango Publishers. All views are his own.</em></p><p>As somebody who wants to one day drop all this space stuff and become a metal writer, I’ll admit to a sense of jealously when I see someone putting out a book about my favorite band.</p><p>Beyond jealously, the other thought that strikes me when I see a new Metallica book is “good luck”. Writing a book about any band as big as Metallica is rife with the challenge of balancing respect, and even fandom, with credibility as a researcher and writer.</p><p>In facing the dual challenges of being prejudged by my jealously, and addressing one of the biggest musical acts of past forty years, writer Ben Apatoff does well.</p><p>Apatoff won me over early, not necessarily though the evidence of his fandom, but more so by what I have called in previous book reviews (and countless assignment comments) “evidence of effective research”. No doubt the author’s fandom of Metallica is apparent. Thankfully though, Apatoff doesn’t let this tilt his version of the bands place in popular culture toward an unprofessional lovefest.</p><h3>Metallica in the 21st Century</h3><p>In my sub-title I facetiously asked <em>“what’s left to be written about Metallica?”</em> I’ll admit, like the Beatles, U2, The Stones, and Kiss (among others) it’s possible there is absolutely nothing new to write about how the band formed, their influences, their albums, or even their brushes with evening news stories, be it Napster or co-causing a riot in Montreal. (Tangent: Could you imagine trying to write a Beatles book? “Uhh, the Beatles yes, from Liverpool, the once port city of the Titanic. This book will explore the Beatles through the lens of the great oceanliners in history”).</p><p>While nothing new may be left to write <em>about</em> Metallica’s history, Apatoff’s book reveals two valuable responses to such a question. First, Metallica is, knock on wood, far from done. There are albums to come, tours to undertake, personalities to grow, and, surely, more experiments to try (playing in Marvel movie? releasing an album with Billie Eilish? Signing more artists to their record label? Playing in space?!?!?). With every passing year, their history gains new wrinkles and adds retroactive potential to exploring their past. Given there hasn’t been a major Metalli-book in about a decade, Apatoff had a good reason to provide one.</p><p>Beyond their ongoing career, Apatoff (especially in the first few chapters) reveals one more reality left to mine for curious Metalli-writers. <em>The world around Metallica has changed. </em>MeToo, Trumpism, climate change, growing global inequality, and a rapidly transforming media landscape of instant streaming and social media, among just a few, have placed Metallica in a world unrecognizable from 1981, 1991, 2001, or even 2011.</p><p>Don’t let this scare you into thinking the $24.95 Book is series of weak-take articles in the tone of <em>“It’s Time to Rethink Metallica’s Frayed Ends of Sanity and It’s Problematic Portrayal of Mental Health”</em>. No, there is none of that, in fact Apatoff mentions very few of the issues I did above. But there is, probably for the first time in a Metallica book, explicit recognition of the discomfort that can come from some of the misogyny and homophobia in Metallica’s past.</p><p>Apatoff doesn’t go about calling members homophobes (Lars had that under raps in the Playboy interview) or writing scathing 20/20 accounts of how past Metallica fans, members, or friends have acted in interviews. Nonetheless, in a welcomed change, Apatoff writes as, dare I say, a modern Metallica fan. Praising the band and their history, but not stepping back into morals of the past to do so. Lord knows every Metallica fan with a conscience cringes at the thought of ever again having to sit through the roadie scenes from <em>A Year and a Half in the Life of Metallica</em>.</p><h3>Metallica: The 83 Cent Chapters</h3><p>The 269 page book is broken down into thirty short, very digestible, and very easy to read chapters focused on one band member, album, or pop-culture intersection at a time (movies, books, fashion, religion, etc…).</p><p>Before these chapters, the book begins with an insightful foreword by music journalist and ethnomusicology <a href="https://twitter.com/Lainad">Laina Dawes</a> author of <a href="https://www.bazillionpoints.com/books/black-women-in-heavy-metal/">What Are You Doing Here? A Black Woman’s Life and Liberation in Heavy Metal</a>. The forward has a much more academic tone to it than the rest of the book (to be expected from a professional ethnomusicologist), but it’s hardly the unreadable jargon one would expect from a still-in-the-tower academic (I’m allowed to say that cause I escaped). Instead, Dawes’ forward is an honest, experience-driven, take on Metallica’s cultural relevance. The writing is grounded in what is clearly a dense knowledge of the metal world and Metallica. I don’t want to take the thunder from the forward, which deserves to stand on its own, but the core thesis that Metallica <em>IS</em> a political band is a well-argued point.</p><p>The main text reads as a mix between Metallica reference book, mini-biography collection, and combined listicles. For better or worse this separates the book from other recent publications on the subject. For anti-listicle snobs this may be a turnoff. I, nonetheless, thought it worked well as fellow fan saying “if you haven’t already, go check these things out” (I also believe that lists are legitimate, even if overused, means of storytelling). Apatoff doesn’t try to arbitrarily rank things in his lists, he’s just telling you what he found in his research, which sometimes, is all that a good researcher need to do.</p><p>Highlights from the rest of the book include, for me, the chapters on Cliff Burton and Jason Newsted respectively. Though neither are necessarily under-discussed in Metalli-literature, both chapters are welcomed immersions into distinct periods of the Metallica family. Apatoff’s skill as a music writer is his ability to alternate between discussing topics with the ever-presence of their Metallica connection as well as on their own as distinct, non-Metallica, entities. In short, Apatoff gives topics and subjects room to exist as more than footnotes in the Metallica story, offering them autonomy while never lulling the reader into forgetting that this is a book about a heavy metal band.</p><p>Additional praise should be offered to the second chapter that covers the bands that influenced Metallica. While nothing Earth-shatteringly new, it is a a must-read accessible history lesson for any serious Metal buff. For me it is on par with the work of criminally under-appreciated metal historian <a href="http://www.martinpopoff.com/html/bookslist.html">Martin Popoff</a>.</p><p>With 26 years served in the Metallica Family, I can say (confirm?) that Apatoff’s fandom of the band appears to follow a traditional arc. The first 4 albums are metal masterpieces while the band’s fifth album (the Black Album) is (for better or worst) a commercial breakthrough. Load is a disappointment, Reload and St. Anger aren’t good, but Death Magnetic and Hardwired are both welcomed return to forms (also Lulu sucks).</p><p>For diehards, this could be the biggest (only) disappointment, as it is a tale as old as time, and one many of us are sick of hearing (though we don&#39;t necessarily want “St. Anger is better than you think” hot takes if you don’t truly mean it). In the $24.95 case, the ramification of this approach is that records after the Black Album are not given a song-by-song breakdown. For those looking for new insights into Fixxxer, The Unnamed Feeling, or End of the Line, you may have to return to Chris Ingham’s respectable <em>Metallica: The Stories Behind the Songs</em>.</p><p>The only other note of aggravation might be Apatoff’s repeating of the not quite accurate “they sued their fans” line. <a href="https://metalupyourpodcast.simplecast.com/episodes/episode-148-metallica-vs-napster-grAWLR1f">Awkshually, they sued a start-up</a> backed by a bunch of scummy venture capitalists, they never sued individual users. Sorry…I had to. But, other than the Napster nitpick, I didn’t note any obvious errors or research fauxpas. There is a typo on pg. 163 (“Lars wanted TO show”), but my first book had about 7 typos and an entire quote in Farsi that was mistranslated at the printers, so who the fuck am I to be holier than thou.</p><p>Overall, the book should sit well with a variety of audiences. Given that it’s built off of secondary sources (something I support as a means of equity in research), the book doesn&#39;t provide any headline-spawning bombshells. It’s strength is it’s writing, its format (short, punchy chapters), and the good research behind it. Ultimately, it’s like a combination of <a href="https://twitter.com/williamirwin38">William Irwin’s</a> <a href="https://www.wiley.com/en-gb/Metallica+and+Philosophy%3A+A+Crash+Course+in+Brain+Surgery-p-9781405163484"><em>Metallica and Philosophy</em></a> and the aforementioned <em>Metallica: </em>The <em>Stories Behind the Songs</em> by Chris Ingham.</p><h3>Who Should Read This?</h3><p>I believe every book has an audience. My approximation of the ‘musthavedness’ of this book for various groups is as follows:</p><blockquote><strong>Metallica diehards</strong> = Must own (only you can catch all the lyrical Easter eggs planted within!).</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Casual Metallica fan</strong>= Get it next time you’re looking for a good read.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Fans of metal history</strong> = Get it when you have the disposal cash.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Popular Music History Buff</strong> = Get it when you see it, or gift it to a Metallica fan you know and then borrow it after they read it.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>“ Muhhh, they haven’t been good since Justice” People</strong> = You wont like it, but, honestly, do you like anything anymore?</blockquote><blockquote><strong>If you like short music essays that connect to pop-culture</strong> = Worth grabbing from your local library (or asking them to get it in, they will #SupportLibraries)</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Someone married to a Metallica mega-fan, or otherwise affected by Metallica fandom in their life </strong>= Honestly this is probably the best resource you could get to understand the nutter you’ve married, or is your best friend, or family member, etc... It provides all the background you need as quickly and painlessly as possible, but is also entertaining and is not JUST about Metallica. It’s like reading thirty fun Medium articles that collectively explain so much about your Metalli-infected loved one.</blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=58a1f55a539b" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/curious/metallica-the-24-95-book-review-58a1f55a539b">Metallica — The $24.95 Book (Review)</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/curious">Curious</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What if Metallica’s Load & Reload Were One Album (Part II) — The Best Possible Answer?]]></title>
            <link>https://danny-bednar.medium.com/the-canon-of-heavy-metal-what-if-load-reload-were-one-album-part-ii-the-best-possible-answer-54f75fe8bd9e?source=rss-df03e0b08461------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/54f75fe8bd9e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[metallica]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pop-culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[metal]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[rock]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Danny Bednar, PhD]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 04 Jun 2021 15:13:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-08-18T01:11:43.881Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>What if Metallica’s Load &amp; Reload Were One Album (Part II) — The Best Possible Answer?</h3><p>After almost 25 years of mixing and matching Metallica’s mid-90s albums, can we use the evidence at hand to put the discussion to bed?</p><p>Note: This is Part II of a discussion of <em>Load</em> and <em>Reload</em>, as part of the 25th anniversary of Load’s release. For a primer on the history of the two records and a discussion on why some <em>Metallica</em> fans are obsessed with this question please see <a href="https://danny-bednar.medium.com/the-canon-of-heavy-metal-what-if-load-reload-were-one-album-part-i-why-do-we-care-b0cb8ba0e605">Part I</a>.</p><p><em>Danny Bednar is Canada’s second best geographer of outer space, an amateur heavy metal musicologist, and part-time Assistant Professor in the Department of Geography and the Environment at Western University. He works a 9–5 at the Canadian Space Agency and is an author with Mango Publishers. All views are his own.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/609/1*nz2h0ZQzpcxkwHD8paqzbQ.png" /><figcaption>The Covers for Metallica’s Load and Reload (Andres Seranno/Blackened Records)</figcaption></figure><p>All of us in the ‘Metallica Family’ have our favorite 12 or 13 tracks from <em>Load</em> and <em>Reload</em>. Indeed, <a href="https://www.reddit.com/r/Metallica/comments/47pu23/if_load_and_reload_were_combined_into_one_album/">discussion boards</a> (including the <a href="https://forums.metallica.com/t/what-if-load-and-reload-were-combined-as-one-album/1507/51">official Metallica forums</a>) are full of such lists. But what about Metallica themselves?</p><p>Well we could just ask them, but Metallica fans know that it’s quite unlikely that the guys themselves would provide such a playlist to answer our queries. As I explained in Part I, whether its the mix their 1988 album <em>…And Justice For All</em>, the attempt at commercialism on the song<em> Escape</em> way back in 1984, or the lack of solos on the entire <em>St. Anger </em>album, the answer to “what if” questions from Metallica has always remained the same: “it felt right at the time”.</p><p>With that being the case, any hope of a ‘Metallica approved’ answer as to which songs would have made the cut back in 1996, if the band opted instead for a single album, is essentially out of the question (at least very unlikely).</p><p>Never fear, the last 25 years have provided many clues as to what might have happened if Metallica themselves had created their own single masterpiece album with the over 2.5 hours of material they wrote between 1995 and 1997.</p><p>While there are other such discussions, this effort will be focused only on an evidence-based effort to create an alternative reality where Metallica themselves, in 1996, opted for one album instead of two.</p><p>Let me be clear though. I’m happy they didn’t do this. I love both albums, they are quintessential to my upbringing and even if I had a Doc Brown modified <em>DeLorean</em> on hand, I wouldn’t change anything. But that’s not what being an amateur, wanna-be, heavy metal musicologist is all about. I’ve always wondered about the band’s own ideas ideas on the material, and I know I’m not alone.</p><p>So let’s look at available information and see if we can estimate, once and for all (?), what that mythical single album would have looked like had the boys been stricken, in 1996, with a sudden urge to edit themselves down to a single CD-length endeavor.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*O1a6jEw6MEbHVzlCqtfUGQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>The back cover of Load’s vinyl re-release featuring the track listing and the Metallica ‘ninja star’ logo that dominated the period (Anton Corbijn/EM Ventures/Blackened Records).</figcaption></figure><h3>Alternate Timeline</h3><blockquote>“all the basic tracks for Load and Reload were cut between May of ’95 and November of ’95…Most of them were developed between the Fall of ’95 and the Spring of ’96. We had a meeting in January of ’96 where we decided that Load was not going to be a double album: until that meeting, Load was to all intents and purposes a double album with 27 songs on it…at that point we’d been in the studio for 9 months and had been working on the songs for 16 months, so there was a potential burn-out at the end of hte tunnel. We (also) got the chance to do Lollapalooza and we wanted to do that. We realized that by doing that we would not have time to finish the 27 songs, so we took these 13–14 songs that were the furthest along. The other fact that played into separating the songs into two records, was that I was very adamant that we would have two records which would balance out with each other, not be an A record and a B record” (Ulrich in the bands fan club magazine So What, 1997).</blockquote><p>The real timeline for the creation of both albums, which varies across a few interviews (as Lars’ recollections above diverge a bit from the <a href="https://danny-bednar.medium.com/the-canon-of-heavy-metal-what-if-load-reload-were-one-album-part-i-why-do-we-care-b0cb8ba0e605">band’s website</a>), is generally as follows:</p><blockquote>Late 1994 to Early 1995 — Load/Reload demos created in Lars’ basement</blockquote><blockquote>Early 1995 to Early 1996 — Studio recording of “basic tracks” for Load/Reload material</blockquote><blockquote>Early 1996 to Summer 1996 — Separate album decision, Load material is finalized, mastered and prepared for released, Metallica plays scattered promotional shows.</blockquote><blockquote>Summer 1996 to Summer 1997 — Load is released, Metallica play Lollapalooza and go on European and North American Pour Touring Me tour.</blockquote><blockquote>Summer 1997 to Winter 1997 — Songs for Reload are completed in studio, mastered and released</blockquote><p>We don’t know exactly which songs were worked with last in the real timeline. So, it can be fuzzy to know when the band could have had a good enough idea, in our alternate timeline, to look at all 27 and say “these are the ones we like best”. We do have hints via demos and documentary footage from the time that Reload tracks <em>Low Man’s Lyric</em>, <em>Fixxxer</em>, and <em>The Memory Remains</em>, among others, existed, in some form, as early as 1995. According to <em>Chris Ingham</em>, in <em>Metallica: The Stories Behind the Songs</em>, Metallica had all of the songs recorded in demo from by the summer of 1995. But in reality a Reload song like <em>Attitude</em> may have only taken shape in Simmer 1997.</p><p>So, lets make this an alternate reality where instead of getting out of the studio for a full World tour in the second half of 1996 and early 1997, Metallica only step out briefly to do Lollapalooza, then return in Fall 96 to finalize Load (now made up material from both prime-universe Load and Reload). Got it? Essentially, in this alternate timeline, Reload disappears and Load swallows it’s favored parts, existing temporally in-between the prime-universe release dates of the two albums.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*2ajYwIrCLvHqnLzJoeKMKg.png" /><figcaption>All we’re doing is bending space-time to create an alternate timeline, what could go wrong… (Universal Pictures/Blackened Records)</figcaption></figure><h3>Settling the Debate (?): What if Metallica Themselves Had Cut It Down to One Album in 1996?</h3><p>So, how do we figure out what are the favored parts of each album? The first major metric will be <strong>which songs were chosen as singles</strong>. Metallica is a hands-on band, and while they may take label and producer input when selecting singles, even at their most commercially friendly, they are fiercely protective of their content and how it is released. With singles automatically included, readers who are Metallica diehards already know eight songs that will be on the list (sorry!).</p><p>The second metric will be <strong>which songs have been played live most</strong>. For this we will have the help of Metallica’s official site <a href="https://www.metallica.com/songs/">Metallica.com</a> and their immensely helpful <em>Songs and Lyrics</em> section which includes live performance data. In keeping with the ‘it felt right at the time’ mantra of the band, we will also privilege songs that were played live immediately after release versus those that found setlist life in subsequent years. This helps provide more sense of what ‘1996 Metallica’ thought of the material.</p><p>Barring we can ask Metallica directly, these are the best proxies for identifying the band’s opinion of their own material and just how the filtration process would have played out 25 years ago. Barring some intrepid journalist corners them with the question, track lists in hand, its safe to assume this may be the closest we’ll get to knowing what the mythical dragon of a single mid-nineties Metallica CD would have looked like.</p><p>So lets go. For each track included there will be a brief breakdown and some live performance stats to flesh out the metrics for its inclusion. We’ll ignore track order for now and just go by their existing order on Load and Reload respectively.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/685/1*pfWqvRolu_ZkNIKVRz2c3g.jpeg" /><figcaption>The back cover of Reload on CD, featuring the track listing and concert images that make up the entirety of the inside booklet (Anton Corbijn/EM Ventures/Blackened Records).</figcaption></figure><h3>Load ‘97</h3><ol><li><strong>Ain’t My Bitch (5:04)</strong></li></ol><p>A moderate tempo cruncher that kicks off Load, a truly heavy track to welcome Metallica fans back after 5 years of studio album silence. Overall, a nice addition of heaviness to an album called ‘not heavy enough’ by detractors. <em>Kirk Hammett’s</em> new and improved style of even more wah is bolstered by a slide solo. Ain’t My Bitch reveals to listeners, straight from the get go, the first person lyrics that will dominate Load and Reload. A marked change in direction from the mostly third party-inspired, mythical, stories of songs off past albums.</p><p><em>Inclusion Metrics: </em>Never released as a single, it nonetheless deserves to be included for its presence on the <em>Poor Touring Me</em> tour that supported Load and was the source of the band’s live concert home video <em>Cunning Stunts</em>. It’s the third most played song live from Load (174 performances), and it’s choice for the immediate supporting tours indicate it was in favor with the band. Additionally, its presence as Track 1 is worth consideration. A vote of confidence from the band that they trusted this tune to welcome new and returning listeners.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FTkXq9SGWO38%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DTkXq9SGWO38&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FTkXq9SGWO38%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/dcb895f92148f119b6c1a430a07b1198/href">https://medium.com/media/dcb895f92148f119b6c1a430a07b1198/href</a></iframe><p><strong>2. Until it Sleeps (4:28)</strong></p><p>Rarely, if ever, referred to as a ballad, <em>Until it Sleep</em> is a sort-of-ballad that mimics parts of the traditional Metalliballads (<em>Fade To Black</em>, <em>Sanitarium</em>, and <em>One</em>), just without the second movement grandeur of those tracks. A personal lyrical message from Hetfield regarding his mother’s cancer, it is far beyond anything that came before in terms of emotional depth. Also features the creepy/cool/weird and even ‘controversial’, make-up laden, Christianity-commenting, video.</p><p><em>Inclusion Metrics:</em> Debut single from the new album, its clear the band were comfortable with this as indicative of their new direction. Second most performed song live from the album (242) and included on both Cunning Stunts and the 1999 concert film/album with the <em>San Francisco Symphony Orchestra</em>, <em>S&amp;M</em>. Common awards show and TV appearance tune at the time and even dusted off for 1999 <em>Billboard Music Awards</em> to promote then-upcoming S&amp;M CD release.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FeRV9uPr4Dz4%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DeRV9uPr4Dz4&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FeRV9uPr4Dz4%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/c0ef6ff5566d742687b3bafce2fc9b46/href">https://medium.com/media/c0ef6ff5566d742687b3bafce2fc9b46/href</a></iframe><p><strong>3. King Nothing (5:30)</strong></p><p>Partly sharing an E minor home key with its spiritual, and structural, predecessor <em>Enter Sandman</em>, <em>King Nothing</em> is another heavy track in the same mid-tempo (you’re gonna hear “mid-tempo a lot) kind of way as the global phenomena that came before it. One of the tracks regularly singled out in “____________ is good but the rest of the stuff on that album sucks!” arguments from Load/Reload haters. Just how much King Nothing is a doppelganger of Enter Sandman was the subject of a wonderful video by <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2RFJmHlOsh4">Mike the Music Snob</a>, which also acts as fun accessible entry into some basic music theory. Another single, it has a relatively generic video of the boys playing in snow and James doing weird rap things with his hands. Was to be performed at the<em> MTV Europe Awards</em>, but legend goes the boys were told rather rudely not to swear, and so went a different direction…playing the <em>Misfits</em>’ ‘<em>Last Caress</em>’ and <em>Anti Nowhere League’s</em> ‘<em>So What</em>’.</p><p><em>Inclusion Metrics:</em> Released as Load’s final single, it is the most performed song from Load (356). Appears on Cunning Stunts, but omitted for big showcases on S&amp;M or <em>IMAX</em> concert films <em>Through the Never</em> and <em>S&amp;M2</em>. Has seen live performances on recent tours and other than <em>Fue</em>l, may be the most well known track from the two albums.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FV5j8lz4oD4Q&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DV5j8lz4oD4Q&amp;image=http%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FV5j8lz4oD4Q%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/2db4c0b7739fb218e69d5d46dee32f7a/href">https://medium.com/media/2db4c0b7739fb218e69d5d46dee32f7a/href</a></iframe><p><strong>4. Hero of the Day (4:22)</strong></p><p>The album’s ballad? Not quite…but the only Metallica song that stays in a major key throughout. <em>Hero of the Day</em> is structured around one of the oldest riffs James had laying around before the 1995 recording sessions began. Among the heaviest choruses across the two albums, it builds to a crescendo that probably features one of Hetfield’s biggest vocal challenges since “going soft” on <em>Nothing Else Matters</em>. Speaking of going soft, a subtle cello is nestled within the mix, which, <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hNYNaaGYcUQ"><em>MetalliGeek</em></a><em> Andriy Vasylenko</em> points out, is part of the relatively large number of layered and hidden tracks on <em>Bob Rock</em> era Metallica recordings.</p><p><em>Inclusion Metric:</em> Released as Load’s second single it features Metallica’s most pop-culture savvy video (a rare endeavor into pop culture commentary from them). Down the list as sixth of ten (nine really as Mama Said has only been performed by James at charity and TV events) songs performed live from Load, but included on Cunning Stunts and for major spotlight on S&amp;M. Holding the fourth spot on the album conventionally used for epic ballads of the past (Fade to Black, Sanitarium, One, Unforgiven), Metallica clearly felt strongly about this tune.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FCBJey2dkiAI&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DCBJey2dkiAI&amp;image=http%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FCBJey2dkiAI%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/6defd74286c0d5d52a212b9859fc8815/href">https://medium.com/media/6defd74286c0d5d52a212b9859fc8815/href</a></iframe><p><strong>5. Bleeding Me (8:18)</strong></p><p>A song much more similar in structure to conventional ballads, <em>Bleeding Me</em> has the clean intro, distorted choruses, and the epic finale Metallica fans expect from the form. Nestled in the mix is an electric organ that adds to the ambience of this track which could easily fit in on Reload. The song closes out Side 1 of the album…. at least on the dying medium that was cassette at the time. Given the vinyl revival, it can now also be referred to the close of the first record of Load and undoubtedly the mid-way marker. Fun fact, the track may or may not include bongos…as Ulrich responded ‘yes there are bongos in Bleeding Me” in a fan Q&amp;A. Problem is, the guys tended to joke around with their answers lot in fan club Q&amp;As, and the bongos aren’t immediately apparent to many listeners. Perhaps a new article is needed, “25 Years Later: Are There Bongos on Bleeding Me?”</p><p><em>Inclusion Metrics: </em>Not technically released as a single, it did receive scattered radio play in the late 90s. More tellingly, it was included for a definitive version on S&amp;M. Debate may rise, but it holds fourth spot on the list of most performed live songs from Load (161) and is a fan favorite amongst a certain vintage of Metallica fans (not that fan favoritism is a metric, sorry). Surprisingly included for the <em>Woodstock 99</em> setlist in front of a hostile (though not to Metallica) crowd. Has seen sporadic setlist life since the turn of the Millennium. Surprisingly (?) left off S&amp;M 2, but is regularly included on acoustic charity sets, including the official 2019 <em>Helping Hands</em> concert released on vinyl. Speaking of Helping Hands…</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2F_7GDn7NmGIs%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3D_7GDn7NmGIs&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2F_7GDn7NmGIs%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/f3c3baa5bf3222c0709abeea9a361116/href">https://medium.com/media/f3c3baa5bf3222c0709abeea9a361116/href</a></iframe><p><strong>6. Wasting My Hate (3:57)</strong></p><p>For long-time, fans wondered where this track had disappeared to, then there was a collective sigh of relief when it was unexpectedly included in the pandemic lockdown concert for the band’s <em>All Within My Hands</em> charity in November of 2020. A fast(er) tempo song that brings back the rage of <em>Ride the Lightning</em> and <em>Master of Puppets</em>, it lacks any galloping or thrash beats to be justifiably called a thrashy song. Nonetheless, something for “oldschool” haters to add to their “that one isn’t bad” list. The fastest song on Load, and perhaps behind only Fuel for fastest across both albums, the track was apparently inspired by a story relayed to James by one of his idols, <em>Waylon Jennings</em>.</p><p><em>Inclusion Metric: </em>Performed regularly on Poor Touring Me gigs immediately following the release of Load, it was shelved for all but a few special appearances between 1997 and 2020 (played once each in 2004 and 2011). The fifth most performed song from Load (101), it is included because of its appearance on the tour immediately supporting Load, indicating that, at the time, it was a favorite of the band (even if only to perform live) and would have likely made the cut for a single CD. Nonetheless, a track that may be, just perhaps, open to debate.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FqhKFxrMi9ho%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DqhKFxrMi9ho&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FqhKFxrMi9ho%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/37869fe1c1ba2929a211a9c33f54c490/href">https://medium.com/media/37869fe1c1ba2929a211a9c33f54c490/href</a></iframe><p><strong>7. Mama Said (5:20)</strong></p><p><em>Mama Said</em> is, musically speaking, the Nothing Else Matters of Load. It is equally shocking sonically when compared to the band’s previous efforts (including Nothing Else Matters) and is a deeply personal song from James. What it definitely does not share in common with Nothing Else Matters is that most people have never heard it. That being said, I suspect there are a healthy amount of Mama Said fans in the Metallica Family. Far more personal than Nothing Else Matters, the song seemingly has Hetfield (who indeed “left home at an early age”) lamenting the lost opportunity to reconcile with his mother before her death. A first hearing of front-and center mixed steely G chord strummed in the chorus, with undeniable country twang, has probably never been matched in terms of shock value from the band. Little did we know, deep within the mix, concealed by the twang of it all, was a forbearer to the St. Anger snare.</p><p>Inclusion Metric: It was released as as single. There’s a video for it. James loves Waylon Jennings and old school country/southern rock, and in 1996, with alcohol-blurred inter-personal relations, and no <em>Phil Towle</em> around, ‘Papa Het’ got what ‘Papa Het’ wanted. Though, accounts are also that he never intended this as a Metallica song, just a personal doodle. Even if there was reluctance from other band members, it likely wasn’t fellow shot-caller Ulrich, who at the time was obsessed with <em>Oasis</em> and their gigantic hit <em>Wonderwall</em>. According to the band’s website, the song has only ever been performed live twice, both in November 1995, when James played it for TV programs in the U.K. and Sweden respectively. However, we do know Hetfield has played it solo at various charity events. Going back to the decisions that may have been in 1996, we can imagine the logic. The last time James wore his heart on his sleeve in a ballad…it connected with millions of fans, why wouldn’t it again?</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2F4FKYsUEuvIo%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3D4FKYsUEuvIo&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2F4FKYsUEuvIo%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/4b68dd81ccc1a2c163ac61490c9d7b34/href">https://medium.com/media/4b68dd81ccc1a2c163ac61490c9d7b34/href</a></iframe><p><strong>8. Fuel (4:30)</strong></p><p>Is it fair to call this a thrash song played at .75 speed (maybe .5)? <em>Fuel</em> is one of the most famous not-Enter Sandman songs ever created by Metallica. Featuring, arguably, the catchiest solo across the two albums, As an album opener, Fuel, and its iconic intro, doesn’t quite set the sonic table for the rest of Reload. Nonetheless, the song is a beloved blend of both sides of Metallica and its flame-thrower live performances are a highlight for all generations of the Metallica Family in attendance at any given concert.</p><p><em>Inclusion Metrics:</em> By far the most peformed song from either album, clocking in at 513 performances. That puts Fuel about 150 ahead of any other Load/Reload song and into classics territory. As of the COVID-19 Pandemic, it was tied for 20th most performed song by the band, impressive given the song came out 16 years into their career. But live performances aren’t the only thing in Fuel’s corner, it was of course released as a single and was a regular selection for awards shows, and <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sxzeoTtDXVE">promotional TV appearances</a> at the time. It also gains an additional boost for being an album opener and being included on the Pour Touring Me setlist before it had been releasd.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FPvF9PAxe5Ng&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DPvF9PAxe5Ng&amp;image=http%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FPvF9PAxe5Ng%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/d98b22c9dbeaeee39c18db3acaaf8e77/href">https://medium.com/media/d98b22c9dbeaeee39c18db3acaaf8e77/href</a></iframe><p><strong>9. The Memory Remains (4:39)</strong></p><p>A mostly radio-friendly single for Metallica…with perhaps the exception of the creepy guest vocal performance. The track has some groove to it, symbolized by James’ typical shoulder swinging motions during performances and the <em>When the Levee Breaks </em>beat Lars uses for the verses. <em>The Memory Remains</em> features the ultra-rare instance of someone not in Metallica performing on a studio track. That honor goes to English folk icon <em>Marianne Faithfu</em>l who provides haunting vocals post-chorus and at the end the song. Harkening back to their classic 1983 ballad Fade to Black, the song drops lyrical references and even repeats one of Fade’s key riffs. Live, the song gains new life, with the Metallica family filling in for Faithfull.</p><p><em>Inclusion Metrics: </em>While Load is more often considered the stronger album with more ‘classics’, it is Reload that has the two most performed songs from either album. Memory Remains ranks second after Fuel and has earned high-profile spots on both S&amp;M albums. Also, it was the debut lead-single from Reload and came out a week before the album. It was even chosen as a single ahead of the mighty Fuel, which wouldn’t get the promotional push for another 7 months.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FRDN4awrpPQQ%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DRDN4awrpPQQ&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FRDN4awrpPQQ%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/bae7ac6788d00f97ff2f2fa4d16b7026/href">https://medium.com/media/bae7ac6788d00f97ff2f2fa4d16b7026/href</a></iframe><p><strong>10. Devil’s Dance (5:19)</strong></p><p>The first four albums of Metallica’s career weren’t necessarily brimming with direct references to the signature doomy-gloomy riff metal of their <em>Black Sabbath</em> heroes. The reason of course was that the thrash that Metallica helped invent was at least one, if not two, periods of heavy metal evolution removed from Sabbath’s genre-solidifying early albums. Load and Reload, however, are filled with instances that reveal many more of the influences Metallica grew up with outside of the New Wave of British Heavy Metal (NWOBHM) bands that directly influenced their first thrash period. Now, Sabbathian gets thrown around a lot in music writing, probably about as much as “Wagernian” (which really needs to be used only by the Wagner experts), but if you’ll permit me just a few more instances, I, like others have, will suggest that Devils Dance is the most Sabbathy of Metallica’s Sabbthy songs. Devil’s Dance isn’t quite a doom-metal song, but its certainly got the vibe.</p><p><em>Inclusion Criteria:</em> Never released as a single, it’s spot rests perilously on its live performances proximal to Reload’s release and inclusion on the original S&amp;M. It has been performed 44 times live, that puts it fourth on Reload, but really, after Fuel (515) and Memory Remains (293) all the other Reload tracks are fighting for setlist scraps. It hasn’t appeared live since 2008 but was a regular(ish) live song on the 97–98 Reload promotional tour (<em>Poor Re-Touring Me</em>). However, additional points could be argued for being selected way back in the Summer of ‘95 as one of the two ‘new songs’ to be played on <em>Escape From The Studio</em> shows. Inclusion-wise, it lands in a grey area, perhaps Japanese version exclusive song or single B-side type territory. Either way, its far ahead of most tracks on Reload in considering 1996 Metallica’s hypothetical decisions.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FqgFiu2TB1CE%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DqgFiu2TB1CE&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FqgFiu2TB1CE%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/f67e3696a3b6d299557a196bebac7a8a/href">https://medium.com/media/f67e3696a3b6d299557a196bebac7a8a/href</a></iframe><p><strong>11. The Unforgiven II (6:36)</strong></p><p>Sequel songs are kind of gimmicky, and up until this point Metallica was not much of a gimmicky band. That would change in the following years with a covers album, an album with a symphony orchestra, and a song for a movie soundtrack. All well-done artistic endeavors that paid-off, but gimmicky nonetheless (I see you ‘<em>I Disappear</em>’ haters, c’mon relax). A completely different track to it’s predecessor, <em>Unforgiven II</em> has a country twang and reverts to the conventional light verse/heavy chorus structure that the original flipped upside down. The chord progression remains roughly the same as original but is now tuned a half-step down. A few melodic phrases are re-used throughout, especially in the finale, and James’ lyrics create multiple references to the original, advancing the story with punny wit…too. The track was written in early 1995 and could have been included on Load, but was the only ’95 track intentionally kept for Reload in order to provide more room between the original and the sequel.</p><p><em>Inclusion Criteria: </em>This one gets in on being a single. But if it wasn’t a single, things would be interesting regarding it’s inclusion. It should be included in such alterative timeline, right? As we arrive back in 1995 in our DeLorean we might say that since there is an <em>Unforgiven III</em> (on 2008’s <em>Death Magnetic</em>) there kind of needs to be an Unforgiven II…but 96 Metallica didn’t know that! The perils of time travel. Live, this sequel, and second single off the album, has still only seen the stage 6 times.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FG-Bn_kD6QN4%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DG-Bn_kD6QN4&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FG-Bn_kD6QN4%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/a05c28982e4275ce8bc46882c967dc01/href">https://medium.com/media/a05c28982e4275ce8bc46882c967dc01/href</a></iframe><p><strong>12. Better Than You (5:22)</strong></p><p>One of the most radio-friendly songs the band ever wrote…it ironically is never played on the radio. The song has the kind of plodding crunch of <em>Sad But True</em> but is slightly faster and features an underrated solo by Mr. Hammett. A particularity simple song, there are really no more than 3 riffs across its playtime. The tune is a rare instance of a Metallica song trying to grab you with an earworm hook (“better than you gah, gah gah gah) rather than musical inventiveness or complexity. Also noteworthy for the particularly upbeat vocal presentation in the verses by Hetfield, a bit of an outlier in his delivery across the Metallica discography.</p><p><em>Inclusion Criteria: </em>The <em>Grammys</em> and Metallica go way back, all the way back to 1989 when flutey folk-rock act <em>Jethro Tull</em> beat them out in the inaugural year of the “Best Hard Rock/Metal Performance” category. Amongst Metallica fans that would be the first story that comes to mind when asked about the band’s history with the Grammys. The second would likely be the fun trivia fact that underdog, never played live, <em>Better Than You</em> won Best Metal Performance in 1999 (third place in Grammy infamy would be the the dead mic<em> </em>fuck-up from the band’s performance with <em>Lady Gaga</em>). Better Than You was released as the last single of the Load/Reload era. By the time it was awarded the trophy in February of ‘99, the band had already released a covers album (<em>Garage Inc</em>) and were prepping to record their collaboration with the San Francisco Symphony Orchestra (S&amp;M). Gets in on being a single.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2F-liIu9mQEZA%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3D-liIu9mQEZA&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2F-liIu9mQEZA%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/714739695156904b570d0c7ff6c63c4b/href">https://medium.com/media/714739695156904b570d0c7ff6c63c4b/href</a></iframe><p><strong>13. Low Man’s Lyric (7:36)</strong></p><p>Two straight-up ballads on one CD would have been a lot, but in this era, Metallica were more than willing to take risks. A Reload song that goes all the way back to the 1995 demos, <em>Low Man’s Lyric</em> is a slightly more depressing song, sonically, than Mama Said (despite it not sharing the same lyrical weight). Noteworthy for the presence of a hurdy gurdy, it is another instance of a guest musician on Reload. The droning hurdy gurdy line was provided by <em>David Miles</em>, or as Hetfield referred to him on TV appearances “the hurdy gurdy guy”. The first studio track on a Metallica album not to clearly feature some section of the song with distorted guitar (it’s close but I’m quite sure those chords on the bridge are just heavily reverbed). It’s layered and panning electric and acoustic guitars make the song truly a joy to listen through headphones, highlighting that both Load and Reload are wonderfully mixed. Also features the return of Lars ‘the Tambourine Guy’ Ulrich from Nothing Else Matters.</p><p><em>Inclusion Metrics: </em>Not a single, but prominent on the Poor Re-Touring Me setlist in support of Reload. Performed 65 times in total, including on national TV and Radio broadcasts, such as a live spot on Virgin Radio four days before the album dropped. Even with Load backlash fresh, Metallica, and James specifically, was not shying away from featuring their ‘softer’ songs in primetime spots. Hasn’t seen setlist daylight since 1998, the song is prime for a comeback anytime, especially given the increasing amount of acoustic shows making up Metallica’s increasing charity activities.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FkaroPU8hfB0%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DkaroPU8hfB0&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FkaroPU8hfB0%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/9c97bba11f7b9013122f057b7c88b30e/href">https://medium.com/media/9c97bba11f7b9013122f057b7c88b30e/href</a></iframe><p><strong>Honorable Mention— The Outlaw Torn (10:48)</strong></p><p>As we’re about to see, our alternate timeline Load ’97 is now full (it’s at 71:00, the real Load was capped at 78:59 which was the maximum capacity of a CD in 1996). However, long time fans might be wondering where a certain Load album closer has gone off too. Outlaw Torn cannot fit onto the hypothetical Load ’97, but it still deserves mention and perhaps goading by us time travelers to the 1996 version of the band to either cut the extended jam session that ends the song or use it as a B-Side to one of the singles (something Metallica typically reserves for covers). As we’ll see, it’s the only remaining track that really deserves consideration for the final 7:59 left on the CD (ironically, the 8:00 mark is pretty much exactly where the extended jam session starts….).</p><p>As for the song itself, in the real timeline, it was the track that had to bite the bullet in order for Load to fit on a CD. For this purpose, Outlaw Torn had some of its original jam-session ending snipped (it was originally 10:48 in length, but was cut to a breezy 9:52). A track quite symphonic in structure (even if only having three movements), it has a surprisingly optimistic four note interval that hooks its main riff. The track harkens back to Metallica’s 70s influences, bands like Black Sabbath, <em>Blue Oyster Cult</em>, and <em>Led Zeppelin</em> who often had 8+ minute songs that lumbered towards bluesy jams. The full jam session was restored for the Memory Remains single “b-side”.</p><p><em>B-Side Inclusion Metrics: </em>Hyped by Lars as a grand epic upon Load’s release, the track never saw live play until the two concerts just before the first S&amp;M album was filmed/recorded in 1999. The track had mostly random appearances since, including one orphaned performance on the St. Anger tour. It was dusted off again for S&amp;M 2 (also getting a dress rehearsal on the show just before the filmed S&amp;M 2 concerts). The track’s celebration by Lars upon its release, and its inclusion as one of only two tracks from Load/Reload to be showcased on both S&amp;Ms earns its spot as an honourable mention. Debate is justified, it can potentially be included in place of Low Man’s Lyric, Devil’s Dance, or Wasting My Hate. Ultimately however, aside from S&amp;M, Outlaw Torn has seen very limited live play. Only 12 times total, with 5 of these taking place a decade after it’s release. It was only performed four times on the tour promoting Reload. Sorry Outlaw.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FVs8pt9aK4mc%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DVs8pt9aK4mc&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FVs8pt9aK4mc%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/175f15cfb99516236ee40eb61cdc30d5/href">https://medium.com/media/175f15cfb99516236ee40eb61cdc30d5/href</a></iframe><p><strong>Results</strong></p><p>What we’re left with is actually quite serendipitous. Load ’97 is made up of 7 tracks off of Load (Side 1) and 6 tracks off of Reload (Side 2). I had originally considered devising a track order, but the balance that emerged when just keeping the tracks in their place looks reasonable. Each opener (Ain’t My Bitch/Fuel) remains an opener for their respective side, and, though odd, each side is balanced-out by ending with a ballad (what do you know, Lars was right, the albums are balanced!). As for what we’ve lost, again, the only track that I think deserves consideration to be included as something that would have survived a tightened 1996 Metalli-filter (based on metrics or otherwise) is The Outlaw Torn. The rest are pretty comfortably in a different league (a good league, but just a lower league).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*O9AX6TUusW6IN13tQmAs-A.png" /><figcaption>Data for Load and Reload via Metallica.com (Danny Bednar)</figcaption></figure><p><strong>It May Be What the Evidence Tells Us, But It’s Not What Felt Right At The Time</strong></p><p>So this is it. The best secondary estimation we can make as to what an alternate timeline 1996 Metallica would have chosen for a single album. Of course, the ultimate answers lay with James, Lars, Kirk, and Jason, but again, don’t hold your breath.</p><p>At 71 minutes, the alternate timeline Load ’97 constructed here would still be a lot of music to digest, but perhaps more densely packed with “killer” for casuals and diehards alike to respond favorably to.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0oDyBC-dmRw0iBinQ6s4qA.jpeg" /><figcaption>The alternate timeline track listing for Load ’97. he results, and perils, of messing with altering what is already done via time travel. Evidently, I am not a graphic artist (Anton Corbijn/Blackened Records/Danny Bednar)</figcaption></figure><p>While many of us have always taken for granted that the two track lists could be mixed and matched, listening to each over and over for the past month has revealed quite distinct tonal and acoustic vibes for each album. The more I researched and wrote this article, the more I began to see each album quite distinctly from the other. We’ve always known Load was the boogie-woogie album and Reload was the darker one, maybe we should start taking those distinctions more seriously.</p><p>Further, diehard or casual, we have to ask what we’ve lost, what Biff getting his hands on the sports almanac has done to the fabric of space time (full disclosure, I’m a <em>Ronnie</em> fan).</p><p>As for what 1995, 1996, and 1997 versions of Metallica did in reality, they crafted two superb metal albums of exactly what they wanted (as they always do). As a result they bent expectations and, ever since, have had many of us bending space-time in our minds in pursuit of satisfying “what ifs?”.</p><p>While Load ’97 is a interesting academic-y adventure in pop-musicology and fandom, for better or worse (I vote better) it never happened. In reality we have the luxury of two albums of Metallica studio material rather than one. Why?</p><p>Do I really have to say it again?…Because it felt right at the time.</p><p>Sources:</p><p>Become the Knight, (2019). <em>Enter Sandman vs. King Nothing</em> (Metallica) Mike the Music Snob. Youtube. <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2RFJmHlOsh4">Oct 11, 2019</a>.</p><p>Chirazi, S. (ed). (2004). <em>Metallica: So What! The Good, The Mad, and The Ugly</em>. Broadway Books, New York, NY. 288 pp.</p><p>Foxtel Networks, (1997). <em>Metallica: Reload Album Interviews</em>. Accessed via: <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7YR0WE-oL1U&amp;t=2s">metfan4l at Youtube</a>.</p><p>Guitar World, (1997). <em>James Hetfield and Kirk Hammett of Metallica Discuss Reload</em>. <a href="https://www.guitarworld.com/gw-archive/archive-james-hetfield-and-kirk-hammett-metallica-discuss-their-1997-album-re-load">Accessed via Online articles.</a></p><p>Harper, S. (2017). <em>Heavy is the Crown: Metallica Interviewed</em>. Clash (online). <a href="https://www.clashmusic.com/features/heavy-is-the-crown-metallica-interviewed">Nov. 22, 2017</a>.</p><p>Ingham, C. (2019). <em>Metallica: The Stories Behind the Songs</em>. Carlton Books. London, U.K. 208 pp.</p><p>Metallica, (2021). <em>Band Timeline</em>. <a href="https://www.metallica.com/band-timeline.html">Metallica.com</a></p><p>Metallica, (2021). <em>Songs &amp; Lyrics</em>. <a href="https://www.metallica.com/songs/">Metallica.com</a></p><p>Trunk, E. (2020). <em>Lars Ulrich/Robert DeLeo</em>. Trunk Nation Podcast. <a href="https://www.podcastone.com/episode/ET---Lars-Ulrich-/-Robert-DeLeo">Aug, 5, 2020</a>.</p><p>Vasylenko, A. (2021). <em>52 Cool Hidden Things in Metallica Songs</em>. Youtube. <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hNYNaaGYcUQ">May 31, 2021</a>.</p><p>Wells, C. &amp; Luck, E. (2017). <em>Metal Up Your Podcast 26: Load</em>. Youtube. <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=glvlqXw2Ux8&amp;t=3420s&amp;ab_channel=metalupyourpodcastmetalupyourpodcast">June 12, 2017</a>.</p><p>Wells, C. &amp; Luck, E. (2019). <em>Metal Up Your Podcast 118: 1996, A Year In The Life of Metallica.</em> Youtube, <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PNPz1FszgZk">April 30, 2019</a>.</p><p>Wells, C. &amp; Luck, E. (2019). <em>Metal Up Your Podcast 123: 1997, A Year In The Life of Metallica</em>. Youtube. <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XZVMO8UTALU">June 11, 2019</a>.</p><p>Wells, C., Luck, E. &amp; Moak, P. (2019). <em>Metal Up Your Podcast 128, Unload w/ Paul Moak</em>. Youtube. June 18, 2019.</p><p>Wiederhon, J. (2017). <em>Five Things You Didn’t Know About Metallica’s Reload</em>. Revolver Magazine (online), <a href="https://www.revolvermag.com/music/5-things-you-didnt-know-about-metallicas-reload">Nov. 17, 2017</a>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=54f75fe8bd9e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What if Metallica’s Load & Reload Were One Album (Part I) — Why Do We Care?]]></title>
            <link>https://danny-bednar.medium.com/the-canon-of-heavy-metal-what-if-load-reload-were-one-album-part-i-why-do-we-care-b0cb8ba0e605?source=rss-df03e0b08461------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b0cb8ba0e605</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[metallica]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[metal]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pop-culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[heavy-metal]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Danny Bednar, PhD]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 04 Jun 2021 13:30:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-01-27T02:56:59.431Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>What if Metallica’s Load &amp; Reload Were One Album (Part I): Why Do We Care?</h3><p>Twenty-five years later, why do Metallica’s <em>Load</em> and <em>Reload</em> continue to fuel so many “what if?” discussions?</p><p><em>Danny Bednar is Canada’s second greatest geographer of outer space, an amateur heavy metal musicologist, and part-time Assistant Professor in the Department of Geography and the Environment at Western University. He works a 9–5 at the Canadian Space Agency and is an author with Mango Publishers. All views are his own.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/609/1*nz2h0ZQzpcxkwHD8paqzbQ.png" /><figcaption>Covers for Load (1996) and Reload (1997) (credit: Andres Serrano/Blackened Records)</figcaption></figure><p>“What if…”.</p><p>All fans have ‘what ifs’ for the discographies of their favorite bands. For the last 25(ish) years one “what if” has persisted in the heavy metal, and more specifically the <em>Metallica</em>, community. What if the band had edited the material that made up <em>Load</em> (1996) and <em>Reload</em> (1997) into one (masterpiece) album?</p><p>With Load celebrating it’s 25th anniversary we’re likely to see more of these discussions between now and Reload’s own anniversary in 2022. While they’re all in good fun, and a right of fandom, it becomes curious, why do we fans do this? What is role of these fantasy track listings?</p><p>While this phenomena happens with many ‘sibling albums’, it’s not always a matter of two albums being released in close proximity. Note that Metallica’s debut album <em>Kill ’Em All</em> (1983) and their sophomore effort <em>Ride the Lightening</em> (1984) came out closer to one another (12 months) than did Load and Reload (17 months). Yet, live medleys aside, there aren’t threads upon threads of “What if Kill and Ride were one album?”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*jQQjnDJ4xcu36l4pK4nO8Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>Metallica as kings of the underground thrash movement in 1984 (unknown fan pic, creative commons)</figcaption></figure><p>The lack of similar discussions around Kill ’Em All and Ride the Lightening reveals that the entertaining <a href="https://skulfurinn.medium.com/motherload-how-load-and-reload-could-have-been-one-great-album-3344d4f42a11">Motherload</a>/<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eneUwSiy-HM">Unload</a>/Overload discussions are perhaps more than just fan playlist and fantasy curation. The most common reason given is that Load and Reload were recorded at the same time. But, as we’ll see, that’s not entirely true. Recording history aside, is there maybe more to this impulse?</p><p>Maybe something about being music fans, something about the two albums themselves, as well as something about Metallica’s history, provide some additional insight into the reasons behind this popular alternate-metal-history endeavor.</p><h3>The History of Load and Reload</h3><p>After a three year tour supporting their self-titled, globally successful, 1991 album <em>Metallica</em> (AKA the <em>Black Album</em>, AKA 16x platinum in the U.S.), and an appearance at <em>Woodstock ’94</em>, Metallica were ready to begin work on a follow-up. Having amassed a considerable amount of rough material, the band entered the studio in February ‘95 to record what they thought could become a double album.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Zj-8pEff-rRoxtphRakK4g.jpeg" /><figcaption>Metallica at the peak of their Black Album ‘kings of metal’ popularity, playing in front of an estimated 500,000 fans in Moscow (credit: Dublin, A. 1992 via Kerrang)</figcaption></figure><p>By January 1996, after 11 months in the studio, they come to the decision to polish off the 13 most-complete tracks for release that summer. The rest of the material would be reserved for a follow-up album sometime in 1997. The decision against going with the originally intended double album was a combination of factors. One of these was an offer to headline Lollapalooza in the summer of 1996. In recent interviews, drummer <em>Lars Ulrich</em> has also indicated that the two albums approach nixed an additional requirement off their recording deal with label <em>Elektra</em>. Last but not least, a double album is a lot of work and it had already been 5 years since their last album. In <em>Martin Popoff‘s</em> <em>Metallica: The Complete Illustrated History</em>, front man <em>James Hetfield</em> explains it as simply as follows:</p><blockquote>“We were more than nine months into the recording and we weren’t even done half of the songs…we realized it was just too much to do. Too much to swallow” (Hetifled in Popoff, 2013).</blockquote><p>When Metallica and their new sound finally emerged from the studio, they shook the metal community even more than the “selling out” of the Black Album had five years earlier (this was a band accused of being “sell-outs” as early as their second album).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*StvNQqYsfAs55uXTnlmLFg.jpeg" /><figcaption>The “new” Metallica of 1996 from the inside booklet of Load (Credits: Anton Corbijn/EM Ventures/Blackened Records)</figcaption></figure><p>Featuring a cover by artist <em>Andres Serrano</em> that depicted semen and blood squeezed between two plates of glass , Load was released June 4, 1996. The album was surrounded by controversy even before its release. The (early) internet fan ‘backlash’’ to the album was put into motion by negative reactions to the moody video for Load’s lead single <em>Until it Sleeps</em> and magazine photo shoots which featured Ulrich and guitarist <em>Kirk Hammett</em> wearing (gasp!) eye shadow. On top of it all, they had (gasp again!) cut their hair, adopted a mid-tempo bluesy sound, and joined the mega-popular, <em>MTV</em>-hyped, alternative music festival <em>Lollapalooza</em>. Metallica, the former thrash gods of the underground, had apparently let the success of the Black Album get to their heads.</p><p>The backlash from metalheads of yore didn’t hurt the album commercially. It debuted at Number 1 around the World and has since been certified 5x Platinum in the United States. For the rest of 1996, and first portion of 1997, Metallica would tour Europe and North America promoting Load and reassuring fans they were still very much metal with a relentless set list made up largely of old school fan favorites.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*juty6cqMFth_7ahMdryIwA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Anton Corbijn/EM Ventures/Blackened Records</figcaption></figure><p>Retuning to the studio in the summer of 1997, Metallica finished the half-complete songs they had left behind a year earlier. Making clear in interviews that these were not “left-overs”, the band reassured already-weary fans that these were simply songs they hadn’t gotten to finalizing before the decision to release Load and go on tour. On the song selection process for Load versus Reload, bassist <em>Jason Newsted</em> broke it down as follows in a 1997 in a discussion with <em>Channel V</em> Australia:</p><blockquote>So what happens is you pick and say ‘this song has guitar’ ‘this song has bass’ ‘this one has some vocals’, ‘this one has lyrics written’, ‘this one is this far along’ ‘this one is this far along’. ‘K, there’s 12 or 13 we can finish’. ‘These ones over here, this has only got a drum track, this has only got that, these are gonna have to wait’. That’s exactly as simply as it was, there was not any kind of ‘A here’ ‘B here’, worse [or] better (Newsted to Channel V, 1997).</blockquote><p>Just how much work was done in 1997 to whip what would become the Reload tracks into shape has been a recurring topic in Metallica fan circles. Within this debate rests part of the justification for the assumption that Load and Reload songs can be mixed-and-matched, since they all come from the same recording sessions. Indeed, demo recordings from 1995 provide evidence that the following Reload songs existed in mostly fleshed-out form when Metallica completed Load: <em>Devil’s Dance</em>, <em>Fixxxer</em>, <em>Low Man’s Lyric</em>, <em>Carpe Diem Baby</em>, <em>Unforgiven II</em>, and <em>The Memory Remains</em>. On the other hand, much of the rest of the songs have no identifiable timelines (<em>Bad Seed</em> was jammed throughout the Load tour, so we know it existed as an idea before 1997).</p><p>Most accounts, including form Ulrich himself, are that all 27 songs from Load and Reload existed as rough sketches to some degree as early as the summer 1995. Answering this very question, Hetfield however had the following to say about how much “work” was done to the demos when the band returned to the studio in 1997.</p><blockquote>Living with these songs for two years, the four of us came back with very different ideas of what they should evolve into. The good news was that we still liked them, and we wanted to put them out. But we wanted to come up with some newer sounds. We had recorded guitar tracks for a lot of these songs already, but they sounded a little dull; so we re-did them . We really stretched the limits of what a guitar and amp can do, which was fun (Hetfield in an interview for the December 1997 issue of Guitar World).</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*FZV8IP_yzKhIccWFmgJ2qQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Inside art for Reload (Credits: Anton Corbijn/EM Ventures/Blackened Records)</figcaption></figure><p>Reload, like its predecessor, would debut at number 1 and go on to be certified 3x platinum in the United States. Despite being painted by many as a softening of Metallica’s sound and image, the two albums are among Metallica’s darkest in lyrics and sonic tones. While Load is a far more bluesy album, it’s downtuned crunch is as heavy as many of the songs on the Black Album. Meanwhile, the album’s lyrical themes of mass shootings and cancerous death are more realistic, and mature, takes on life’s dark side than the band had done on their previous efforts. For its part, Reload is the more ‘experimental’ of the two, with “gloomy” an adequate descriptor for the track list as a whole (spare opener Fuel). Reload has perhaps been best summarized, by Popoff, as having “recurring doomy, bluesy, <em>Alice in Chains</em>-like vibes”.</p><p>Today Load and Reload have found a comfortable spot in the hearts of many in the ‘Metallica Family’. Load was an entry point for a ton of younger Metallica fans, and the presence of radio hits from the two, like <em>King Nothing</em> and <em>Fuel</em>, next to 8os standards <em>One</em> and <em>For Whom the Bell Tolls</em> blurs the lines of Metallica eras to many new and casual fans.</p><p>For diehards there is both love and disinterest laser focused onto various points of the two albums. Because of their recording history, fans have often operated on the assumption that the two are essentially a split double album. As a result, one debate has raged: what if instead of 2.5 hours of shocking new mid-tempo, doomy blues-metal, the band put out one single album of “the best stuff”.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*pEzfP9CyWrMfvKCEYOgNGw.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Why Is This A Common Discussion Among Metallica Fans?</h3><p>I am not the first Metallica fan to consider the hypothetical singular CD made up from the Load/Reload material. As mentioned, the topic has been well-trodden in forums and threads across the internet. This also isn’t unique to Metallica, it happens anytime a band releases <a href="https://www.loudersound.com/features/hey-guns-n-roses-we-ve-fixed-use-your-illusion">two albums close together</a> or even just a <a href="https://www.reddit.com/r/beatles/comments/p87ck/how_would_you_arrange_the_white_album_into_one_lp/">standard double album</a>. But beyond their proximity, are there maybe other driving forces behind these “What if?” questions and revisionist track listings? Why do we fans get obsessed with hypothetical re-workings of a band’s past catalogue.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*Mvy-S1c061DSQBGmtb8BhQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Credits: Anton Corbijn/EM Ventures/Blackened Records</figcaption></figure><h3>Filller?</h3><p>First, and not specific to Metallica, is the notion of “filler”. Rooted mostly in the history of vinyl and 1970s ‘album-oriented rock’ (AOR), filler, as a concept, emerged in the 60s when the music industry shifted from singles to full albums as the primary means of releasing music. “Filler” was the term adopted for all the seemingly mediocre, or downright bad, songs recorded in order to fill out a full album that might only have one or two hits the label was actually interested in (even the artist could sometimes feel they had produced junk for the sake of filling the record). Today, the idea of filler thrives on those of us who grew up on physical media and memories of the ‘perfect album’ that required no skipping.</p><p>In the vinyl era, filler manifested physically. It meant having to get up to move the needle past a dull track. For cassette and CD kids, those precious filler-free albums meant that tossing a single CD in your car or backpack would guarantee as much exciting music as possible with the least space. This concept, even in the era of streaming, persists today. As we chase that mythical skip-free dragon, anything on a new release that gets in our way adopts the dreaded moniker of ‘filler’.</p><p>For Zoomers and younger Millennials, this may seem weird. The idea of filler is less of an discussion point these days. For example, I don’t foresee future <em>Taylor Swift</em> fans debating the merits had Taylor edited <em>Folklore</em> and <em>Evermore</em> into a single release. In the streaming era, it’s really not an issue how much material artists release, people will listen to what they want. Additionally, for many consumers, music has become what some call “audio wallpaper”, with listening a far more passive, playlist driven, experience than days of yore. With this, the idea of full albums as a listening experience is fading to history. But, this was not yet reality in the CD-era of 1996–1997.</p><p>While Metallica at the time of Load’s release had dabbled in long albums (the two albums before Load were both over an hour), they were not known for allowing so much material through their revered Metalli-filter. By most accounts, including their own, Metallica are perfectionists in the studio (so much so that they have only released 10 albums in 40 years of existence). The <em>A Year and Half in the Life of Metallica</em> documentary that articles the making of the ‘Black Album’ showed the Metalli-filter in action. Essentially, James Hetfield and Lars Ulrich battling each other, along with producer <em>Bob Rock</em>, in a fight for artistic supremacy. The result being that anything at risk of being ‘filler’ was left on the cutting room floor.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*lBMQPRCsY4YJhllNDGn9xQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Credits: Anton Corbijn/EM Ventures/Blackened Records</figcaption></figure><p>Similarly, in discussions about the making of <em>…And Justice For All</em>, Lars and James have emphasized the overly-perfectionist nature of their (old) creative process. Recognition of this hyper-perfectionism was one reason for creative directions chosen on 2003’s <em>St. Anger</em>, an album known in Metallica fan circles as even less-edited that Load and Reload.</p><p>When it comes to album length, the result of the Hetfield/Ulrich Metalli-filter is as follows:</p><blockquote>Kill ’Em All (1983) 51:20</blockquote><blockquote>Ride the Lightning (1984) 47:25</blockquote><blockquote>Master of Puppets (1986) 54:47</blockquote><blockquote>…And Justice for All (1988) 65:24</blockquote><blockquote>Metallica/Black Album (1991) 62:40</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Load (1996) 78:59</strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>Reload (1997) 76:02</strong></blockquote><blockquote>St. Anger (2003) 75:04</blockquote><blockquote>Death Magnetic (2008) 74:46</blockquote><blockquote>Hardwired…To Self-Destruct (2016) 77:42</blockquote><p>For many music fans, long (hour plus) albums are a red flag for the dreaded ‘filler’. And while the perfectionist Metalli-filter has developed larger holes over the past two decades, it was certainly strange for Metallica fans at the time of Load and Reload, among all the other changes, to feel like there was potentially “filler” on a studio album from the band. It seems fair to suggest that two very long albums in such a short period was the precipice for feelings among some fans that Load and Reload were ‘some killer, much filler’.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*y3yZwMJ6-_DtYRWCIchhYA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Credits: Anton Corbijn/EM Ventures/Blackened Records</figcaption></figure><p>As for modern threads on Load/Reload combinations, most discussions seem to be driven by those of us who forged our musical interest long before mp3s or streaming. Having grown up in an era where music was housed on physical media and the listening experienced was less tailored and more connected (for better or worse) to physical media, every song matters. We grew up in a time where If you only owned 10–15 albums total, or you only brought two or three albums to play on your Walkman during a road trip, you couldn’t afford to pack an album where you only like 3 of 14 songs. Recalling our physical-media constrained lifestyles, we continue to consider, and even argue, these mythical, filler free, perfect album dragons with our fellow pre-streaming kin.</p><h3>When is a Record Done?</h3><p>The second reason I will propose for this phenomena, and related to the previous, is the very long and very awkward length of both Load and Reload. Also rooted in the vinyl and AOR eras is the idea that a the perfect rock/pop record should be a brisk 45 or so minutes. However, Load and Reload, each, and depending on the medium, stray pretty damn close to double-album length. With so much material, fans are bound to consider ideas of ‘fatigue’ when trying to take in and connect to so many songs. Looking at the jewel cases on our shelves, we inevitably consider, ‘what would I think of this era of the band’s catalogue if it was only the 12 songs I love most?’</p><p>In the 2004 documentary <em>Metallica: Some Kind of Monster</em>, Lars Ulrich lays awkwardly on a couch, below a high priced painting, philosophizing on the nature of creating art. Before being interrupted by one of his kids, we get a strange insight into Lars’ thoughts at the time on art and deciding how long things should be.</p><blockquote>“Where are the starting points and where are the end points, you know what I mean? When is a song done? What the fuck does that mean anyway, done? When is a record done? You know when, where, does a record start, where does it end? Um where does the process begin, where does the process end. All that type of stuff you know what I mean…it’s really interesting…yes sweetie? (Ulrich, 2004, Some Kind of Monster).</blockquote><p>Streaming be-damned, and Lars’ musings be damned, among many music fans there remains ideas of exactly “how long an album should be”, and no small part of the heavy metal/Metallica family is made up of such vintage mindsets.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*D0m8pWATMpTV1KYx2O7ZiA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Credits: Anton Corbijn/EM Ventures/Blackened Records</figcaption></figure><p>Because they came out smack-dab in the middle of the CD era they are never really considered double albums, but in many ways Load and Reload are each double albums crammed onto a single CD. Had they been released a decade earlier they would have easily been double vinyl records. Just look at the length of Load and Reload compared to some classic vinyl era double albums:</p><blockquote>Exile on Main Street (Rolling Stones) 67:07</blockquote><blockquote>Tommy (The Who) 75:15</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Reload (1997) 76:02</strong></blockquote><blockquote>Goodbye Yellow Brick Road (Elton John) 76:20</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Load (1996) 78:59</strong></blockquote><blockquote>The Wall (Pink Floyd) 81:08</blockquote><blockquote>Physical Graffiti (Led Zeppelin) 82:59</blockquote><blockquote>White Album (The Beatles) 93:33</blockquote><p>Indeed, today their vinyl pressings are doubles, and perhaps for those with a vinyl mindset of ‘how long albums should be’, this is the correct way of thinking of them, as two separate double albums.</p><p>But in the CD age, they were not doubles. By the mid-90’s double albums became even bigger, as we can see by some of the most popular double CDs released in the timespan of the two albums in question:</p><blockquote><strong>1997 Reload (1997) 76:02</strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>1996 Load (1996) 78:59</strong></blockquote><blockquote>1997 Life After Death (Notorious B.I.G.) 120:39</blockquote><blockquote>1996 Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness (Smashing Pumpkins) 121:39</blockquote><blockquote>1996 All Eyez on Me (2Pac)132:20</blockquote><p>So, while undoubtedly double vinyl’s, neither Load nor Reload were true double CDs. Nonetheless, the length of each album still puts them in awkward territory of neither a true double CD, nor really a single CD.</p><p>Comparing them to the highest selling single CDs of their respective CD-era years we see how awkwardly long each is as a stand alone CD by a major artist.</p><blockquote>1996 Spice (Spice Girls) 39:56…a true outlier and in Reign in Blood territory of brisk (yeah I just compared the Spice Girls to Slayer)</blockquote><blockquote>1995 Jagged Little Pill (Alanis Morissette) 57:23</blockquote><blockquote>1995 Tragic Kingdom (No Doubt) 59:38</blockquote><blockquote>1997 Pop (U2) 60:09</blockquote><blockquote>1996 Razorblade Suitcase (Bush) 61:43</blockquote><blockquote>1997 Nine Lives(Aerosmith0 62:54</blockquote><blockquote>1997 Share My World (Mary J. Blige) 65:15</blockquote><blockquote><strong>1997 Reload (1997) 76:02</strong></blockquote><blockquote>Ænima (Tool) 77:18</blockquote><blockquote>No Way Out (Puff Daddy) 77:52</blockquote><blockquote><strong>1996 Load (1996) 78:59</strong></blockquote><p>Along with <em>Tool</em> and <em>Puff Daddy</em>, Metallica were pushing the limits of what the single CD format could hold. But unlike Tool and Puff Daddy, Metallica recorded two such medium-pushing albums at (mostly) the same time. With way more material than a single CD, or even any major artist’s double CD, Metallica ended up with the ‘sibling albums’ approach, spreading two individual monster releases apart by 17 months.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*09cUh53S1M27pIxZiY7Bpw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Credits: Anton Corbijn/EM Ventures/Blackened Records</figcaption></figure><p>Oddly, there was actually recent precedent for breaking up more than 2.5 hours of studio material into separate, but related, albums. Metallica’s tour mates from several years earlier, <em>Guns N’ Roses</em>, fueled by <em>Axl Rose’s</em> growing desire for epic grandeur, released two equally long albums recorded at the same time. Though instead of several months or a year apart, GnR opted for releasing both giants on the same day, essentially making it an unofficial double album. Below we can see the combined lengths of these giant sibling albums compared to some of the longest double CD albums from major artists at the time.</p><blockquote>1997 Life After Death (Notorious B.I.G.) 120:39</blockquote><blockquote>1996 Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness (Smashing Pumpkins) 121:39</blockquote><blockquote>1996 All Eyez on Me (2Pac)132:20</blockquote><blockquote><strong>1991 Use Your Illusions I + Use Your Illusions II (Guns N’ Roses) 152:04</strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>1996/1997 Load + Reload (Metallica) 155:01</strong></blockquote><p>So, Load and Reload are indeed…freaks. They are way longer than most single CDs from their era. Yet, each of them is shorter than any double CD from their era, while both of them combined is way longer than any double CD. They’re just weird.</p><p>Comparatively, Guns N’ Roses were the only fellow mainstream rock/hard rock/metal band to release such massive (length wise) albums to the market within such short order during the CD era. As a major act, and certainly as a major metal act, Metallica is essentially alone in recording 155 minutes of new material in the same batch of (all be it scattered) lengthy studio sessions and then releasing it all to the public in the span of 17 months.</p><p>The result? A contributing factor in our need to ask “what if?”. With a band as good as Metallica, we know that in 155 minutes of material there is bound to be 60 minutes (or whatever our personal concept of an album is) of pure metal gold.</p><p>Maybe if we more often thought of both Load and Reload as double albums in their own right, the discussion would move to “purifying” Load or Reload on their own rather than combining them. On the other hand, had they each been brisk 45 minute-long single CDs, maybe this discussion wouldn’t arise at all. But the way it is, we can’t help ourselves. The sheer amount of music and the number of tracks (27) means we can come up with seemingly endless permutations of a 13 track album (20,058,300 to be exact, or 124,903,451,312,640,000 if we consider possible track order permutations).</p><h3>“It Felt Right At the Time”</h3><p>The third reason proposed as to why fans take on this alterative album narrative so often is the first to be somewhat specific to Metallica. It is the reluctance of the band themselves to ever really reimagine or hypothesize about things that are already done.</p><p>Personally, I admire this and have used the band’s “it felt right at the time” mantra to feel a sense of confidence in my own past decisions. And for a generation of consumers who saw how the <em>Star Wars Special Editions</em> kick-started an endless devolution of digitally enhanced remixed/reimagined products, it is comforting to know that, aside from some basic re-mastering, Ride the Lightning will always be Ride the Lightning.</p><p>Metallica fans know therefore that it’s quite unlikely the guys themselves would provide such a playlist to answer our queries about what could have been. Metallica is, historically, not a band to dwell on the past (sometimes to their own detriment). When it comes to their careers, Metallica tend to focus entirely on what’s next. With this attitude, the band’s two major decision makers, and founders, Ulrich and Hetfield, have always had the same response when asked “what if” questions.</p><blockquote>I’m proud of all of those decisions because I know at that time, they were the truth and it was the instinctive and the right thing to do. And then, 20 years later, it’s like, ‘Well, how would that have sounded if the snare was on?’, or, ‘How would that have sounded if we did two instead of four?’. I don’t know — but I don’t really think about it, to be honest with you, other than when I’m confronted with it in interviews. And I wouldn’t change a thing about the past. Of course, how far are you gonna push that? Of course, yes, bus accidents and things like that, of course. But the point of what I’m saying is I just don’t spend a lot of time sitting there, going, ‘Well, if we hadn’t done that,’ and, ‘If we did this instead…’. “I’m just always too busy about what we’re doing next, and that’s just my MO. And I think all of us in Metallica generally operate like that. So we’re just always excited about the next thing, the next thing, the next record. (Ulrich on Trunk Nation, Aug 5, 2020).</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*GGaFuu0ap5JbXm3d3tWoxA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Credits: Anton Corbijn/EM Ventures/Blackened Records</figcaption></figure><p>For his part, Hetfield has also equally turned to the “it felt right at the time” refrain in discussing past decisions. Speaking to the Columbus Dispatch in 2008, Hetfield had this to say about decision making and his lyrics on 2008’s <em>Death Magnetic</em> as a newly sober lyricist:</p><blockquote>“Yeah, there are a lot of armchair managers that think they know what’s best for Metallica. They over-think everything: ‘Why did they do this?’ ‘Well, now that he’s sober, now that they’re happy, he’s going to write some happy (stuff) and it’s all going to be over.’ We’re the happiest we’ve ever been and we’re coming out with Death Magnetic? I don’t know, no one knows. It just felt right” (Hetfield in 2008 to the Columbus Dispatch).</blockquote><p>Whether its the mix on …And Justice For All, the attempt at commercialism on the song <em>Escape</em> way back in 1984, or the lack of solos on St. Anger, the answer has always remained the same.</p><p>With such anti-revisionist beliefs driving the band, any hope of a ‘Metallica approved’ paired-down Load/Reload’ playlist is likely out of the question. Instead, fans are left to their own devices in wondering how the Metalli-filter might have been applied to Load and Reload material had things been different in 1996.</p><h3>The “Perfect Album” as Alternate History and Self-Defense</h3><p>The final reason, and second specific to Metallica, is the place of Load and Reload in the band’s historical timeline. Load and Reload aren’t just two albums released close together. They are two massive shifts in direction released close together. They are also two critical jumping-on points for 90s kids and jumping off points for some 80s kids. With these factors comes a battle for the soul of the material that makes up these two albums.</p><p>Should all the ‘soft’ songs be cut so that its one hard 60 minute album of faster-tempo metal and less of a deviation from past albums? Or, should Metallica have leaned into the blues-metal and Sabbathy sounds to release a 60 minute record of all mid-tempo crunch? The permutations are many, and with millions of Metallica fans, many with different views of what mid-90s Metallica “should” or “could” have been, the desire to craft Load and Reload to our own personal histories is infinitely tempting.</p><p>Ironically, while diehard Metallica fans are the ones advancing this discussion, it is also us who identify with, and love, some of the deepest tracks. One would think this type of “only the best” desire would be more a concern for casual fans of the band. While many of us are diehards of at least one or more bands to the extent that we entertain ourselves by crafting alternate timelines, we are also casual fans to countless other bands that we know much less about. When I buy the record of a band I like, but am not deeply connected to, I reasonably hope that the record plays front to back without me going “uhhh I don’t like this one”. But even if I feel there is “filler”, I’m not gonna start considering alternate track listings.</p><p>So why, if we Fifth Members and deep-cut lovers are the ones who love the so-called ‘filler’, are we also exploring their erasure from history? Recalling the factors just mentioned, please entertain me for a paragraph or two of psycho-analytical bullshit…</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*mbm9MYPVPeOPAt2U_t5xmg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Credits: Anton Corbijn/EM Ventures/Blackened Records</figcaption></figure><p>Perhaps among many of us, the alternative reality where Load and Reload were distilled to their purist form is one were Metallica makes a critically revered and fan-adored impact on the musical world of 1996/1997 and we, as devoted fans, are vindicated in our commitment to the band. In this alternate reality we aren’t pre-emptively taking defensive postures when Load and Reload come up in metal environments. Perhaps, in this alternative reality, we don’t have to worry about the strawman metal-hipster who only wears indie-label band shirts and provides their intrepid analysis that Metallica “hasn’t been good since Justice”.</p><p>Maybe because so many of us Millennials were impressionable and sensitive teenagers when Load and Reload came out, we were socially cornered into being insecure about our place in the confusing and frustrating metal community. As young Metallica fans in the 90s we entered metal fandom against the better wishes of the incumbent 20-something and 30-something ‘cool’ bangers who told us we weren’t true metal heads because we listened to “sellouts” like Metallica. Maybe these alternative histories help us imagine a world where our heroes are never criticized.</p><p>Maybe…but maybe we also just really like to make playlists…it reminds us of mix tapes.</p><h3>Why Do We Care?</h3><p>I do hope we are at least open to the idea that there be more behind our pop-culture revisionist desires, whether its Metallica or anything else. Analysis aside though, I think many of us enjoy pop-culture revisionism as a genuine form of intra-community entertainment and fandom sharing. Whether we make ‘best of’ playlists or enjoy the full Load and Reload albums in all their gloomy glory, at the end of the day, its all in good fun. Filler, fatigue, revisionism, or sensitivity, 1996 or 2021, loving these albums, and embracing everything on them, just feels right.</p><h3><strong>Sources:</strong></h3><p>Beck, A. (2008). <em>Metallica’s James Hetfield Talks 25 Years After his Band’s First Record</em>. Columbus Dispatch Online. <a href="https://www.dispatch.com/article/20081027/news/310279676">Oct 30, 2008</a>.</p><p>Berlinger, J. &amp; Sinofsky, B. (2004). <em>Metallica: Some Kind of Monster</em>. IFC Films. 141 mins.</p><p>Chirazi, S. (ed). (2004).<em> Metallica: So What! The Good, The Mad, and The Ugly.</em> Broadway Books, New York, NY. 288 pp.</p><p>Dublin, A. (1992). <em>A Year And A Half in the Life of Metallica.</em> Elektra Entrainment. 236 Minutes.</p><p>Foxtel Networks, (1997). <em>Metallica: Reload Album Interviews</em>. Accessed via: <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7YR0WE-oL1U&amp;t=2s">metfan4l at Youtube</a>.</p><p>Guitar World, (1997). <em>James Hetfield and Kirk Hammett of Metallica Discuss Reload</em>. <a href="https://www.guitarworld.com/gw-archive/archive-james-hetfield-and-kirk-hammett-metallica-discuss-their-1997-album-re-load">Accessed via Online articles.</a></p><p>Harper, S. (2017). <em>Heavy is the Crown: Metallica Interviewed</em>. Clash (online). <a href="https://www.clashmusic.com/features/heavy-is-the-crown-metallica-interviewed">Nov. 22, 2017</a>.</p><p>Ingham, C. (2019). <em>Metallica: The Stories Behind the Songs.</em> Carlton Books. London, U.K. 208 pp.</p><p>Metallica, (1996). <em>Fan Cam #1</em>. Accessed Online via: m<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J55FpcTD3ow">etfan4</a>l (The Making of Load) on Youtube.</p><p>Metallica, (2021). <em>Band Timeline</em>. <a href="https://www.metallica.com/band-timeline.html">Metallica.com</a></p><p>Metallica, (2021). <em>Songs &amp; Lyrics</em>. <a href="https://www.metallica.com/songs/">Metallica.com</a></p><p>Popoff, M. (2013).<em> Metallica: The Complete Illustrated History</em>. Voyageur Press. Minneapolis, MN. 191 pp.</p><p>Sigurdsson, S. (2020). <em>MotherLoad: How Load and ReLoad Could Have Been One Great Album</em>. Medium. <a href="https://skulfurinn.medium.com/motherload-how-load-and-reload-could-have-been-one-great-album-3344d4f42a11">Jan 20, 2020</a></p><p>Trunk, E. (2020). <em>Lars Ulrich/Robert DeLeo</em>. Trunk Nation Podcast. <a href="https://www.podcastone.com/episode/ET---Lars-Ulrich-/-Robert-DeLeo">Aug, 5, 2020</a>.</p><p>Wells, C &amp; Luck, E. (2019). <em>Metal Up Your Podcast 117: 1995, A Year In The Life of Metallica</em>, YouTube, <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T5H3jCZeMZ8&amp;ab_channel=metalupyourpodcastmetalupyourpodcast">April 30, 2019</a>.</p><p>Wells, C. &amp; Luck, E. (2019). <em>Metal Up Your Podcast 118: 1996, A Year In The Life of Metallica</em>, Youtube, <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PNPz1FszgZk">April 30, 2019</a>.</p><p>Wells, C. &amp; Luck, E. (2019). <em>Metal Up Your Podcast 123: 1997, A Year In The Life of Metallica</em>. Youtube. <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XZVMO8UTALU">June 11, 2019</a>.</p><p>Wiederhon, J. (2017). <em>Five Things You Didn’t Know About Metallica’s Reload</em>. Revolver Magazine (online), <a href="https://www.revolvermag.com/music/5-things-you-didnt-know-about-metallicas-reload">Nov. 17, 2017</a>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b0cb8ba0e605" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Geography of Space Exploration: For All Humankind]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/curious/the-geography-of-space-exploration-for-all-humankind-475f8927a673?source=rss-df03e0b08461------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/475f8927a673</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Danny Bednar, PhD]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 18 Mar 2021 21:57:35 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-07-13T20:22:36.182Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>The following is the entire first chapter of For All Humankind by Tanya Harrison &amp; Danny Bednar. The book is </em><a href="https://mango.bz/books/for-all-humankind-by-tanya-harrison-and-danny-bednar-781-b"><em>available now online</em></a><em> and in book stores everywhere.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ktvYSbfi0P198XJu4YO_sA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Elly rests on a cot in a makeshift hospital after being liberated from the main camp at Dachau (Art: Ray Brisendine)</figcaption></figure><p>Lying in bed staring up at the stone ceiling of the St. Ottilien Monastery, fatigued, exhausted, and still recovering from the most horrible of atrocities, Elly was torn between emotions. A part of him was relieved and felt safe for the first time in years. The other part of him was intensely angry and overcome with hatred.</p><p>It was the spring of 1945. Elly Gotz was seventeen and recuperating in a makeshift hospital near the town of Geltendorf in the south of Germany. Looking up from his bed, he saw a three hundred-year-old stone ceiling held up by old wooden arches. The monastery was a cold place, made up of the hard surfaces of stone floors and wood benches. The wheeled-in hospital cots were the only softness, and the first comfort, Elly and most other recovering people there had felt in years.</p><p>The long halls of the monastery housed dozens of other weakened men, women, and children. All had just been rescued from the main Nazi concentration camp at Dachau, Germany. Among these men was Elly’s father, a fifty-four year- old Lithuanian man who now barely weighed his own age in pounds. Elly himself only weighed about seventy pounds and often struggled to lift his emaciated body from the bed. When he did have the strength, he would walk the stone stairs of the monastery to exercise and rebuild what muscle he could.</p><p>Most days, if he wasn’t exploring the grassy surroundings of the monastery, Elly was with his father and the other survivors in their shared room. Echoed voices from vibrant Conversations filled the long stone halls: German, Polish, Hebrew, Yiddish, and Russian, among others.</p><p>Like everyone there, Elly had been rescued from the darkest of situations. His body saved from the slave labour and starving conditions that would have taken his life eventually, his mind saved from the constant presence of death and the thought that, at any moment, he or his father could be killed.</p><p>While the physical torture of the Holocaust was over, Elly’s mind remained in a dark place. He was full of hate for those who had done such horrible things to him and millions of other Jewish people across Europe. By the end of World War II, over fifteen million people had been killed by the Nazi regime. Six million of these were European Jews, singled out for genocide by the Nazis and murdered in mass killings at concentration camps as part of the Holocaust — what the Jewish community now calls the <em>Shoah</em>.</p><p>Slowly gaining back their strength, Elly and his father spent much time trying to find Elly’s mother and the rest of the family. Day after day they were sending frantic letters to the Red Cross. As he wrote each letter, Elly wondered: Could he ever live a meaningful life? Was he to be forever full of hate for the people who had done this?</p><p>At night, when he couldn’t sleep, he thought about the hate that had begun to overwhelm him. He knew the entire rest of his life would be defined by how he chose to let this hatred affect him. He had a choice to make.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/526/1*vKsYfWHteyQyRnEnDgehTw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Elly in Kovno Ghetto in 1944 teaching younger students basic metal work. Gotz and his entire family were in the ghetto for two years before being transported and separated, at concertation camps in Poland (Image: elltgotz.com).</figcaption></figure><p>Four years later, Elly was in Johannesburg, South Africa, studying to become an electrical engineer at Witwatersrand (Wits) University. To do so he had left home, and his parents, in Rhodesia (known today as Zimbabwe). Despite the difficulty of being away from family after enduring so much to be reunited, the 21 year-old was thrilled to be out in the world and attending university learning about two of his favorite subjects: physics and engineering.</p><p>For Elly, the best part of university was being surrounded by other people interested in science. He and his friends would come to class early to talk about everything happening in the world. At the time, major scientific fields were undergoing a revolution. Albert Einstein’s theories were still new and being hotly tested and debated in physics lectures around the world. The computer chip had only recently been invented and was paving the way forward beyond the primitive technology of World War II, and engineers in America and Russia were successfully launching rockets high enough to pierce the atmosphere and into space.</p><p>Elly would walk to class among Johannesburg’s worldfamous Jacaranda trees that gave the Wits University campus a bright purple hue amongst the otherwise green landscape. As beautiful as the Wits campus was, his gaze was never limited to just the greenery. Whenever a plane flew overhead, Elly would stop. He would try to see if he could tell what kind it was. He was absolutely fascinated by flight. Before the war, his dream had been to become a pilot, to control a machine in the air and leave the ground behind.</p><p>After the war, things felt a bit different. Becoming a pilot didn’t seem realistic. First and foremost, Elly wanted an education. He decided to become an engineer, and his talents made him well-suited to chase this goal. He loved to create new ways of doing things, to invent machines to solve problems, and to question old beliefs. In short, he was a born inventor, able to think differently than others his age and always curious if things could be done a new way. This habit of questioning things didn’t always do Elly favors.</p><p>One semester, when his class was learning about the makeup of waveforms, Elly doubted his professor’s claim that an irregular wave can be broken into an endless number of regular sine waves. The professor proceeded to schedule a lesson specifically to prove that the theory was correct. That day Elly happened to be late, arriving a few minutes into the lecture. As he walked into the lab, he immediately heard the professor say, “There he is, the doubting Thomas” — an old nickname for people who are skeptical by nature.</p><p>After the professor successfully proved the nature of irregular waves, Elly would have to put up with being called “doubting Thomas” for a few more years. But he wasn’t bothered by his reputation for being curious and questioning. He knew his curiosity drove his desire and ability to learn. Eventually it paid off. In 1952, Elly graduated from Wits University with a degree in electrical engineering. After graduation he moved back to Rhodesia to reunite with his parents. At that time, the economy there was far from booming. Unable to find a job as an engineer, Elly put his degree to work and opened a radio repair shop. His people skills and technical know-how led to success, and he eventually opened a recording studio. In these years Elly met his wife, Esme, and had three children.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/504/1*KEKwl2QB_2WSWtDVklMkZw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Elly’s 1952 graduation photo from Witwatersrand University. Johannesburg, South Africa where he earned a degree in engineering (image: ellygotz.com)</figcaption></figure><p>When the opportunity presented itself, Elly moved back to South Africa to open and operate a plastics factory. Sadly, South Africa in the 1950s brought new scenes of horror to Elly’s life. Racism was everywhere. Many of the white people of South Africa treated black Africans as second class, lesser humans. Elly had seen it before. He worried what would happen to his children if his family remained there, not wanting them to grow up surrounded by racism and the violence that follows it.</p><p>Because of the atmosphere in South Africa, Elly and his wife knew it was time to leave. Nothing good could come from being surrounded by so much hate, and as a recent immigrant Elly was powerless to stop it. In search of a better life for their children, he and his wife moved their family to Toronto, Canada.</p><p>They arrived in Toronto in 1964, where they bought a bungalow in the suburbs. Elly joined his brothers-in-law in operating a plastics factory in the industrial heart of the city. Canada was different from the other places he had lived, and the adjustment for his family was at times a challenge. But moving to North America came with perks as well. Elly noticed that the Canadian newspapers were full of news about NASA and spaceflight.</p><p>The engineer in him wanted to know everything — how NASA built the spacecraft, how they designed the fuel pumps, how they balanced such huge machines…everything. At the same time, Elly had never let go of his childhood dream. The aspiring pilot in him wanted to know what it felt like to sit on a rocket and launch into outer space.</p><p>In time, Elly became very successful in Toronto. His drive to learn, invent, and try new things soon paid off, presenting him with rewarding experiences and allowing him to support hundreds of people by providing them with well-paying jobs at his factory. He was also able to save for his children’s education, knowing they wouldn’t have the same difficulty he did getting high school diplomas or going to college.</p><p>Eventually, Elly and his family became Canadian citizens. He had lived in Lithuania, Germany, Norway, Rhodesia, South Africa, and now Canada. So, while he was now a proud Canadian, Elly Gotz was truly a citizen of the world. Ultimately, though, what mattered to him was not national identity or pride, but that he and his family were safe and happy. For this, Elly loved Canada. He became an active community member, volunteer, and a member of his synagogue. In the decade that followed, as a generation matured that had never experienced the Holocaust (including his own children), Elly began speaking publicly about the horrors of the Holocaust. Through his own story he would impress upon countless children the danger of one simple feeling: hate.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*uN1-cfS1w9Y0dFmlgf3gpg.jpeg" /><figcaption>All these years later,Elly Gotz speaking to students more than 70 years after liberation (image: ellygotz.com).</figcaption></figure><p>It was a hot Sunday in July. Elly’s home was empty. The kids were at their cottage by the lake with Esme. He spent most of the day doing a mix of reading, fixing things around the house, and working in the yard. It was an incredibly warm day in Toronto — with the humidity it felt nearly 30°C (about 86°F) all afternoon. After a few hours in the garden, it was about four o’clock. The summer sun was unrelenting, even as its angle was starting to allow for more shade behind the house. It was time for a break. To cool himself down during the day, Elly would make his way into the basement. While the basement was significantly cooler than the rest of the house, there was another reason he wanted to go down there.</p><p>Today was the day that NASA would be landing on the Moon, and the family’s brand new color TV was in the basement. Elly needed to keep checking in to see how the mission was progressing. He sat on the green basement couch and put his glass of water on the wooden coffee table in front of him. As condensation quickly formed around the outside of the glass, he turned on the TV.</p><p>The TV’s sound came on before the cathode ray screen had time to warm up and show a picture. Elly could hear newscasters describe the status of the mission. When the screen turned on, he saw that they were describing the landing procedure over images of NASA’s mission control room in Houston. He had gone downstairs just in time. The lunar landing was imminent. Neil Armstrong and Buzz Aldrin were on a descending flight path, taking them closer and closer to the lunar surface, with each kilometer they traveled like a plane coming in for landing. They would soon land at their target in the Mare Tranquillitatis region, just above the Moon’s equator on the side facing Earth (the same side of the moon always faces Earth).</p><p>In that moment, Elly actually began to feel a bit nervous. With a background in electrical engineering, he knew how many points of failure there were in a machine as complex as the Lunar Module. Just one circuit failure or blown transistor and the astronauts might not be able to land. The entire event would be a disaster and two men would be marooned to die in space. With the sun’s beams still blasting through the narrow basement windows, Elly listened to the voice of the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation (CBC) news anchor explaining that there would be no video of the actual landing.</p><p>The TV cameras could only be turned on and connected to Earth once they were safely on the moon’s surface. The screen cut to a countdown clock and animation of the Lunar Module. Elly leaned forward and listened closely, cautiously, as the live audio from the astronauts played over a cartoon animation of the spacecraft descending. He could hear Buzz Aldrin speaking with ground control in Houston, as well as to Armstrong, who was piloting the LEM. Buzz was reading out numbers from the computer, rattling off how high they still were above the surface and how much fuel was remaining. The power of those computers Buzz was reading from was unimaginable to Elly — they were the best of the best and were designed specifically to help humans fly in this strange environment on the Moon. He grew jumpier as he started thinking about the hundreds of transistors and circuits that must be operating at full capacity. After all, in his time running factories and radio repair stores, he had seen hundreds, if not thousands, of blown fuses, corroded connections, and faulty components.</p><p>Knowing the nature of machines, he couldn’t help but be tense. He grabbed his glass of water, the ice cubes mostly melted away by now, and took another sip, hoping for the best. As nervous as he was, the aspiring pilot and adventurer was still alive in Elly. This side of him wasn’t nervous at all, but actually jealous. What did it feel like to see the Moon’s surface coming increasingly closer to you? How did it feel to fly with no atmosphere? With no resistance, did it feel like the spacecraft wanted to drop like a stone? Could the astronauts feel the thrust of the descent engine? Every push of the navigation thrusters? What would they do if the main descent engine failed? The Lunar Module was like a single engine aircraft, with no backup plan if things went wrong. If an airplane experiences engine failure on Earth, pilots can glide to a safe landing thanks to atmospheric lift. But the moon has no atmosphere — if the engine failed, the Lunar Module would immediately plummet to the surface and crash.</p><p>Just as he continued to think about all of the possible electrical risks, mechanical risks, and flight risks, Elly heard Neil Armstrong interrupt a brief period of silence: “Houston, Tranquility Base here. The Eagle has landed.”</p><p>They had done it. Finally able to relax, he leaned back into the couch and smiled. Forty-one years old, father of three, and a citizen of the world, Elly Gotz had one simple reaction: “Wow, what a moment!” Two astronauts had piloted a spacecraft to the surface of the Moon while he listened live back on Earth. It was about 4:15 in the afternoon. The CBC newscaster informed the audience that it would be another few hours until Neil and Buzz exited the Lunar Module to explore the surface. Elly watched for a few minutes more, then finished his water, which had no ice cubes remaining, and went back upstairs. He’d initially had planned to do a few more things around the yard, but admitted defeat when he realized he was simply too excited. It was a beautiful day, and the most exciting thing he had ever seen on TV had just happened. The kitchen upstairs was lit up with sunlight, the shine reflecting Elly’s mood perfectly.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*0KsHyS5cT2BADNFErUErAA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Arguably, the most famous image of the twentieth century. This picture of Buzz Aldrin was taken by Neil Armstrong, who played photographer for much of the Apollo 11 mission (Image: NASA).</figcaption></figure><p>Deciding he was indeed far too excited to go pull weeds from the garden or take on any other type of chore, he instead picked up the phone and started calling family members. He was ecstatic, but had no one to talk to in an empty house. He absolutely had to talk to somebody about what had just happened. He wanted to share what he had just seen, to talk about how amazing it was, and, ever the engineer, to make sure people appreciated the magnificence of the machinery.</p><p>Elly had spent years fixing radios and all sorts of other electronic devices. While radios are complex machines, they were nothing compared to what NASA had built to go to the Moon. Maybe, he thought, people who aren’t engineers can’t fully appreciate the technological immensity of what NASA engineers accomplished today. A machine can be very stubborn when it doesn’t want to work. Did people who didn’t work with machines understand how incredible it was to use them to land on the Moon? It takes great engineers to design a machine that absolutely cannot fail during its one and only opportunity to work.</p><p>Calling his friends and family, his voice was beaming with pride and excitement. Elly made sure to emphasize the amazing nature of the landing, insisting people appreciate the mastery of machines that NASA had just shown. For the next few hours he regaled as many people as he could over the phone with everything he knew about the space program (and engineering). As evening approached, it was starting to cool off outside. The humidity was relenting too, at least a bit, and the sun was past the horizon. Only a slight bit of light still pierced the air. It was setting up to be a calm, warm, summer night.</p><p>Having made his last phone call, Elly got ready to watch more of the mission. He went to the kitchen to make a sandwich, pour another glass of water, and look through the pantry for some snacks to satisfy his sweet tooth. Sadly, most of the good stuff had been packed up with the kids to go to the cottage. But, he finally spotted potato chips and chocolates — the perfect snack foods to relax downstairs with and watch history be made.</p><p>With no wind or rain outside, the streets were quiet on this Sunday night. The only sound in the house came from the TV. Elly wondered: was everyone else inside doing the same thing he was? He could see the Moon through the short basement windows above him. It wasn’t a Full Moon, barely at Third Quarter phase, but it seemed particularly bright. Inside, he sat on the couch and ate his sandwich as he listened to the newscasters of the CBC discuss what kind of preparations the astronauts were undertaking. By now it was nearly eleven o’clock at night.</p><p>Then, an image came on the TV. It was the side of the lunar lander. Elly had seen the craft dozens of times in the newspaper and during the news coverage of the Apollo 9 and 10 missions. But now it was sitting on the ground, a vantage point of the craft he hadn’t seen before. That was because this was a live feed of the lunar module on the surface of the Moon. The news anchor confirmed what he was seeing. A small camera connected to a long arm on the side of the lander had been extended and turned on. The Lunar Module wasn’t alone. Viewers could see Apollo 11 Commander Neil Armstrong holding onto the ladder along the side of the spacecraft, ready to step down at any moment. The image wasn’t very good, even for TV standards at the time — it was black and white and seemed faint. But that didn’t matter.</p><p>Live video from the Moon was beaming into Elly’s basement. That feat alone, being able to transmit a live signal to Earth from the surface of the Moon, was surreal in the moment. After a brief conversation between Armstrong and Houston, which viewers were allowed to listen in on, the young man from Ohio, two years younger than Elly, began making his way further down the lander. Armstrong was stepping feetfirst down the ladder that connected the Lunar Module crew cabin to the ground. He even tested being able to jump back up the ladder.</p><p>Ever the engineer, Elly was worrying again. There he sat in the basement of his family home, surrounded by pictures of his loved ones on the walls and the serene silence of the suburban neighborhood outside. He was nearly 400,000 kilometers away from these men on the Moon. They had traveled there on the biggest rocket ever built, and landed using the most advanced computers ever created. All of it had gone according to plan, but Elly worried about one last part.</p><p>While living in South Africa, he operated a sound recording studio. He knew the task of sending a television transmission from the moon must have been incredibly complex. The transistors, the power source for the reception dishes, the wiring in the camera…his mind never left engineer mode. What a terrible shame it would be if they went all the way there, accomplished this incredible feat, and nobody back on Earth got to see it because of a blown fuse.</p><p>All these worries immediately washed away as Elly saw that the television feed only needed to hold on for a few seconds more. “I’m going to step off the LEM now.” Armstrong was standing on the base of one of the Lunar Module’s feet and was about to put the first human footprint on another world.</p><p>“That’s one small step for man, one giant leap for mankind.”</p><p>Looking at a person standing on the Moon, he thought: “Beautiful.” That is all Elly thought. “Beautiful.” For Elly, Armstrong’s words could not have been more perfect. This was an accomplishment for all humankind. We had done it. We had set a seemingly impossible goal, filled with obstacles of every kind, and we had succeeded. There were scientific questions about the lunar environment, engineering challenges around how to build the machines, and innumerable human factors to overcome. Who could fly these machines? Was it worth the risk? Could three astronauts function properly for the duration of the mission? All of these challenges — scientific, engineering, and human — didn’t matter now to Elly or anyone else.</p><p>Humanity had just made one giant leap.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*vO8ZIvZRwleCINV5_Msgrg.jpeg" /><figcaption>The cover of one of Canada’s national newspapers the day after (image: tayloronhistory.com)</figcaption></figure><p>The atmosphere the next day on the floor of Elly’s plastics factory felt like he was back on campus with his university friends. Everyone was talking about what had happened on TV the night before. Elly in particular was singing the praises of NASA all over again and talking to everyone about the amazing event. He went around asking every worker in the building if they had seen it.</p><p>One employee replied, “Did I see what?”</p><p>“They went to the Moon in a giant rocket!” Elly responded in shock.</p><p>Apparently he still had some people to convert when it came to admiring spaceflight. Of course, when Elly’s family returned from the cottage, he had a new audience to tell all about NASA’s Moon landing. They were used to it by now. When he was reading the newspaper every morning, he would often talk at length about the incredible machinery involved in landing on the Moon. And as a Holocaust survivor, he was also always quick to point out to his wife any time the news mentioned chief US rocket engineer Wernher von Braun, whom the American government had snapped up from Germany after the war.</p><p>“Look! The Nazis terrorized poor London for years with their rockets, now von Braun is helping the Americans go to the moon!”</p><p>Elly knew all too well that von Braun had used slave labor at concentration camps to build his rockets during the war; von Braun was the only part of the Space Race he didn’t like reading about.</p><p>Over time, Elly’s family would grow accustomed to his fascination with machines and flight. They had to. Fulfilling a childhood dream, he eventually got his pilot’s license and his own plane. He flew his family around in a small single-engine airplane, taking them on vacations across Canada and the United States. While flying a small aircraft is always dangerous, the family trusted Elly. They knew he thought through every single risk and was prepared to deal with each one, mechanical or human. Calculating risk and knowing the details of his machines were things Elly always took seriously. His understanding of both risk and machines certainly paid off. On one particular family vacation to the east coast of Canada, he landed with his family in Moncton, New Brunswick, to spend the day. After walking through the streets and sightseeing, he prepared to fly the family to the next stop for the night. There was a chance for severe weather, but it wasn’t meant to arrive for several hours, and Elly figured he could fly low to avoid it in the unlikely event that the storm moved in earlier than forecasted.</p><p>Shortly after taking off from Moncton airport, Elly couldn’t see a thing. Rain covered his windshield. The clouds had moved in rapidly — three hours earlier than forecasted. The conditions were what pilots called instrument weather, where you fly entirely based on the readouts of the plane’s instruments. Unfortunately, Elly didn’t have an instrument license, and his family was onboard. It was a horrifying scenario.</p><p>But Elly kept calm. He knew his plane, and he knew he couldn’t panic. He thought to himself, if you panic now, you’re all dead.</p><p>Elly contacted the Moncton airport tower by radio and requested help to return to the runway. Air traffic control directed him to turn a precise number of degrees using his compass. Elly had no problem with the directions, he was intimately familiar with his airplane’s instruments. From there they coached him to about 3,000 feet altitude and told him to fly level. He was only to descend when they said so. But even at that altitude, he still couldn’t see a thing. After several minutes of nerve-racking flight through dense clouds and rain, he heard the voice over the radio tell him to begin to descend at a particular rate. As he emerged beneath the blanket of clouds, through the continuing rain on the windshield, he could see the runway lights. He was right on track for a perfect landing.</p><p>From this experience, Elly learned that he didn’t panic in dangerous situations. He would have made a fine astronaut. With some encouragement from Esme, Elly decided to get his instrument rating.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*rWU-6WlSfZXwAuMzNnnchw.jpeg" /><figcaption>The cover of Elly’s memoir, Flights of Spirit, <a href="https://secondstorypress.ca/azrieli/flights-of-spirit">available online</a> and in bookstores everywhere (Image: secondstroypress.com)</figcaption></figure><p>Even fifty years later, Elly still sometimes looks up at the Moon and smiles, thinking, We’ve been up there! In so many ways, his life has paralleled the space age. When he was born, the earliest liquid fuel rockets — tiny versions of what would one day go to the Moon — were just being invented. When he graduated from university, he was learning about the first rockets to fly beyond Earth’s atmosphere. When he moved to Canada, humans were landing on the Moon. And as he celebrated his ninetieth birthday, he was reading online articles about amazing little rovers on the surface of Mars. He even got a little bit closer to becoming an astronaut when, at the age of ninety, he jumped out of an airplane (with a parachute) to celebrate the 150th anniversary of Canada, his adopted home. Falling through the sky, he proved you’re never too old to explore and take risks.</p><p>Elly has seen the worst of humanity, and, in some ways, the best. He is constantly reminded of how ingenious humanity can be: landing rovers on Mars, sending spacecraft to Pluto, and orbiting the Earth every day in the International Space Station — all wonders of human ingenuity. However, Elly also reminds himself, and others, how stupid we can be when we focus on the wrong things. When we choose the wrong emotions to motivate us. When we hate. Elly knows firsthand how hate drives so many of our bad decisions. Hate blinds us. Hate makes us stupid. No one has ever accomplished important things fueled by hate. No one has landed a rover on Mars fueled by hate. No one has lived in space for a year fueled by hate. Hate is worthless. All the good of humankind, all the accomplishments of science and engineering throughout history, came from people who turned away from animosity.</p><p>When Elly Gotz saw humans walk on the Moon, it was about more than the technology. It was about what getting there meant to humanity. Two decades after the First World War, humanity started a second. But two decades after the Second World War, there was no third. Despite the fact that the use of weapons and technologies from World War II could have easily led to another horrendous global conflict. Thankfully, instead of instruments of war, humanity used the rockets and computers of World War II to orbit the Earth and land on the Moon. Humanity had taken its ingenuity and moved in a better direction.</p><p>Because of this, twenty-four years after lying full of hate in a hospital bed, Elly saw humanity walk on the Moon. As he did so, he was sitting in a beautiful home filled with pictures of his loved ones, a picture-perfect life built through love. For Elly, the moon landing will always represent what happens when you turn away from hate. He knows better than anyone that only when you give up hate can you truly start to live.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*WyIL2bcLM_sR-s4EpNdQFA.jpeg" /><figcaption>You’re never too old to take calculated risks, Elly Gotz flies through the air at age 89 (Image: ellygotz.com)</figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=475f8927a673" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/curious/the-geography-of-space-exploration-for-all-humankind-475f8927a673">The Geography of Space Exploration: For All Humankind</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/curious">Curious</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Geography of Space Exploration: The Search for Life on Mars (Book Review)]]></title>
            <link>https://danny-bednar.medium.com/the-geography-of-space-exploration-the-search-for-life-on-mars-book-review-585ca07d59e6?source=rss-df03e0b08461------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/585ca07d59e6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[book-review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mars]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[space]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[space-exploration]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Danny Bednar, PhD]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 18 Mar 2021 20:44:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-05-07T22:46:00.566Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Howell &amp; Booth’s book serves as an anthology of personal Martian stories, revealing that behind the search for life on Mars lay entirely Earthly processes. If you’re looking to really brush up on the science of Mars and the search for life it is a must read.</em></p><p><strong><em>Danny Bednar, </em></strong><em>PhD, is Canada’s second-best geographer of space and an Assistant Professor in the Department of Geography at Western University. He works 9 to 5 at the Canadian Space Agency and is an author with Mango Publishers. All views are his own.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/598/1*eQWZvyc9CnycNxsfeguuTg.jpeg" /><figcaption>The Search for Life on Mars by Elizabeth Howell and Nicholas Booth (Arcade, 2020) available now from you local independent book store (Image: Simon &amp; Schuster)</figcaption></figure><p>Whether there is, or ever has been, life on Mars remains a pressing question in planetary science. However, the reason as to why one might care about this question may vary.</p><p>For myself, and perhaps others with no theological inclinations, the question is largely an existential and scientific one. Knowing if there is, or ever has been, life on Mars would serve as an important bit of information in understanding the evolution of the solar system and just how much of a fluke life’s presence on Earth is.</p><p>Necessarily, a question that follows from this line of inquiry is whether discovered Martian life would be entirely indigenous to Mars, indicating a sort of second ‘genesis’ event in which the spark of life emerged twice in one solar system (that’s a Star Trek reference, not a Christianity reference). Conversely, if Martian life ever existed, there is the possibility that it was/is a relative of Earthly life, born of the same processes that created life here and somehow spread from one planet to another.</p><p>For starry eyed dreamers and escapist Mark-Watney-larpers, the question of life on Mars is a bit more practical. If there is, or ever has been, life on Mars, it’s discovery may hold clues as to how humans could potentially stay there for a few weeks/months at a time in the distant future. If there is life on Mars right now, it is likely reliant on some form of yet-unidentified energy or stored hydrocarbons. Both of which would be necessary for humans to not die shortly after landing on the hellhole that is the Red Planet.</p><p>Regardless of why you care <em>if</em> there is life on Mars, you are beholden to rovers currently on the planet’s surface, the satellites sent to orbit it, and most critically, the humans back on Earth that operate and interpret the results from these machines. At the end of the day, it will be these humans, and their interpretations, that answer the question of life on Mars.</p><p>Like all science, the search for life on Mars is neither as objective nor as definitive as popular social discourse implies. The answer to this question relies fundamentally on interpretations.</p><p>Enter Elizabeth Howell and Nicolas Booth’s new book: <em>The Search for Life on Mars: The Greatest Detective Story of All Time</em>. Part planetary science textbook, part anthology of biographies, the book is a wonderful historical, and present-day, analysis of Martian science. The book’s strength comes from the access the writers had to experts involved in Martian exploration as well as a significant amount of archival research.</p><p>Audience wise, I would suggest this book for experienced space readers or casual space fans looking to really challenge and sharpen their Martian knowledge. It is not necessarily an <em>introduction</em> to Mars science as there are a few things you may need to look-up (I certainly had to). But the book’s depth should be seen as a strength rather than a weakness.</p><p>Building robots to search for life on a planet 2,500,000 kilometers away isn’t easy. Any interested readers owe it to themselves to learn about about these things with a degree of rigor representative of the challenge. I was keen to take on the challenge of brushing up on, and adding to, my Martian knowledge, Howell and Booth’s book offers ample opportunities.</p><p>As I often do, I approached the book as an educator. I teach about space exploration at the university level and am always interested in new sources to provide my students. As I’ve said, T<em>he Search for Life on Mars </em>has an anthology feel to it, perfect for myself and other instructors looking for topic- or event-specific readings that tell a confined story within the chapter. That being said, the book does flow as there are natural narrative links between most of the chapters. For those further interested, a detailed breakdown is below. I have included just a sample of the dearth of information from each chapter as a sort of appetizer for those looking to greatly expand their Martian knowledge.</p><p><em>The Search For Life on Mars</em> by Elizabeth Howell and Nicholas Booth is available now from your local independent book store and wherever good books are sold.</p><p><strong>The Search For Life on Mars: Chapter by Chapter</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*18Rl4E1mjttYHiusOWxzXg.jpeg" /><figcaption>A portrait of landing sites on Mars and the NASA missions that call them home. These robots, and their kin orbiting high above the Red Planet, are one half of the key characters in the Search for Life on Mars (Image: NASA)</figcaption></figure><p><em>Chapter 1: Frozen in Time </em>explores the nature of the Martian climate, it’s poles, and the question of subsurface ice/CO2. The chapter doesn’t focus too much on any one mission, with references to <em>Mars Global Surveyo</em>r (1996–2006), the <em>Phoenix</em> lander (2007–2008), and the failed <em>Mars Polar Lander</em> (2000).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*blyfoiCxK6p7CD6CHdkwCQ.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>Chapter 2: Inside Out</em> is, pardon the pun, an fun dig into the inside of Mars and one of the newest robots on its surface. Essentially a chapter about the recent NASA <em>Insight</em> mission (2018-Present) and a fascinating exploration of the nature of ‘Mars quakes’. The chapter outlines the mysteries surrounding where exactly seismic activity is coming from and how it might be created given there are no plate tectonics on Mars. The extent to which Insight is detecting seismic activity is astonishing. Mars is noisier than the Insight team expected it to be. Among the many mysteries sprinkled throughout the book, Insight contributes a puzzling relationship between subsurface activity and the time of day, suggesting perhaps that solar energy is affecting sub-surface ice, creating shifts and slips that register on the incredibly sensitive instruments onboard. Time will tell.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-AtHMWPaHtjuAE-_kvM6zA.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>Chapter 3: Curiosity</em> is, shockingly, about NASA’s <em>Curiosity</em> rover (2012-Present). Though, its about more than that. The chapter also explores the location where <em>Curiosity</em> landed, <em>Gale Crater. Curiosity</em>’s landing site is a giant crater with a mountain in its middle that was at some point, in the distant past, filled with water. The chapter is a wonderful recounting of the challenges of landing on Mars and the tricks needed to get it done (for example, turning off all receiving capabilities on the rover/spacecraft as it descends to the surface so that the automated landing system doesn&#39;t pick up any errant signals).</p><p>This chapter really signals where the book shifts its focus towards the humanity behind Martian robots as the chapter includes an excellent immersion into the operations room for Curiosity. While I’ve never sat in on active planetary missions, I have been a part of analogue (practice) rover missions and indeed the dynamic of mission control is incredibly fun and stimulating (though probably a bit more stressful when real). From explaining how virtual reality tech is being applied to immerse rover operates in the Martian environment to shining a light on the way differences of opinion influence rover operations (such as where the chlorine may on Mars be and how it got there) Chapter 3 really starts to show the true moral of the book: behind every robot is a team of humans.</p><p>All the missions we send to Mars are not only operated by humans. Robots will never tell us if there was life on Mars, we’ll have to decide that amongst ourselves based on the data.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*B-zK3YP5fxi8E5syl_nIkw.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>Chapter 4: Road to Utopia</em> (<em>Viking Program</em> and the History of JPL) is the chapter I, IMHO, would have kicked off the book with. It is part history, part biography, and maintains the thread of exploration, personality, and mystery that the story is structured around. One of my favorite chapters, it’s historical accounts do well to avoid space-race clichés overtrodden by most space writers. Howell and Booth instead focus on capturing the feeling of being at JPL during the <em>Viking</em> era (1975–1980) and just how much things have changed.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xWBty7xm_2dXx5VIfHoSTw.jpeg" /><figcaption>A Mock-up of the Mars Viking Langer back on Earth (NASA/JPL)</figcaption></figure><p>Chapter 5: The Measure of Mars (<em>Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter</em> &amp; Phoenix Lander). Another wonderful historical chapter, the authors paint the long and winding road that was the emergence of new Mars missions after the dark decade of space exploration in the 1980s. The chapter also brilliantly outlines something key to understanding all space exploration, the evolution of camera systems and how they are designed. A largely underdiscussed aspect of space exploration, I truly commend Howell and Booth for taking on, and brilliant narrativizing, the history of these instruments and their development for space missions.</p><p>Not only do Howell and Booth provide a much needed story of why cameras designed for Mars came along, they intertwine these developments with Martian science, namely the identification of Hematite on the surface. On Earth, hematite is typically found where there is, or was, water.</p><p>From the perspective of a geochemist, areas of Mars that are rich in hematite are good candidates to have once been covered in water. Where there was water, they may have been life. With these observations in hand, Chapter 5 provides background on the evolution of the now famous “follow the water” logic that has directed a fleet of Mars rovers since the turn of the century.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*vBnkt-EKA2fsqzqvfTaCQQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>An artists conception of the Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter (MRO) which arrived at the Red Planet in 2006 (image: NASA/JPL)</figcaption></figure><p>Chapter 6: The Pathfinder (<em>Pathfinder</em> &amp; <em>Sojourner</em>). The most personal chapter in the book, it centers on space exploration trailblazer Donna Shirley and her work on the Mars <em>Pathfinder </em>mission (1996–1997) as well as its accompanying rover <em>Sojourner</em>. Given that chess is all the rage this year, readers might be fascinated to learn the story of the little rover that could had a CPU modelled on the IBM Deep Blue computer that defeated chess champion Gary Kasparov in 1997.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5Csa467R64n5vGdQ0DkCnw.jpeg" /><figcaption>An artists mega-90s depiction of the the Pathfinder lander and its accompanying rover Sojourner (Image: NASA/JPL)</figcaption></figure><p>Chapter 7: Waterworld. No one mission is particularly the feature here, but the <em>Mars Reconnaissance Orbite</em>r (MRO) (2005-present) might come closest. The ever fascinating question (at least for planetary science nerds) is where did Mars’ water go?</p><p>Up ? Indeed, it could have evaporated upwards into the atmosphere and then into space as the Red Planet looses its gases to space due to a lack of magnetic shielding.</p><p>Down? Possibly, some people are brave enough to suggest that tons and tons of it (literally) seeped below the surface and froze in place as large sub-surface ice deposits…we’ll see.</p><p>Around? Sure, we know Mars has polar ice caps, but just how much of their makeup is the result of the planet’s atmosphere condensing at the poles and precipitating down as snow into giant ice caps?</p><p>No one knows…</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0sXkHgJldVIVhnh-F0xn3w.jpeg" /><figcaption>Artists interpretation of what an ancient Jezero Crater on Mars could have looked like. Hypothesis of a lake filled crater with inlet and outlets was a defining facto in this crater’s choice as landing site for NASA’s Perseverance Rover in 2021 (Image: NASA/JPL)</figcaption></figure><p>Chapter 8: Claims. Again moving away form a singular mission focus (though <em>Viking</em> gets a fair share of attention) Howell and Booth turn the history of extraordinary claims of extraordinary evidence. Martian canals have been a oft-treaded area of discussion, so the authors do well to use them as a point of entry into the wider topic of past claims of life on Mars. A strong candidate to be a course reading due to its quick summary of major events.</p><p>The issues in this chapter are always important for geographers and our concepts of place making. The Mars canals were an imprint of society that people wanted to see, they were based on loose evidence that was poorly interpreted but nonetheless excited a lot of people. To this very day, hypothesis of grandeur and artists renditions of cities on Mars, equally false and equally fictitious, still excite people. Why?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*6addabcAH9o0ssrQ9UVIxw.gif" /><figcaption>An image from Viking 1 showing a trench dug by the lander’s scoop. The results of on-the-spot experiment to search for signs of life in the scooped was interpreted to have been positive by a small minority. The ongoing discussion that has evolved reinforces the personal reality of science. It’s all about people and interpretation.</figcaption></figure><p>Chapter 9: Reactions. Press sensationalism meets scientific uncertainty with the usual result…aliens! The ever intriguing tale of a meteorite that was found in Antarctica, this little black rock underwent nearly every test in the world after a few geochemist suggested there were features consistent with biogenic (life) processes. NASA held a press conference with Bill Clinton, the news media yelled aliens. Calamity ensued.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/750/1*ETjI5cmCxwvaSQ6dIMlztQ.gif" /><figcaption>An extremely enhanced zoom of a microscope scan of the meteorite from Antarctic known as ALH84001. The rock is hypothesized to have been thrown of Mars by a giant asteroid impact long ago and have eventually landed on Earth. The features within have been considered as possibly, potentially, theoretically consistent with known Earthly geochemical processes that create similar, but not identical, features (Image: NASA)</figcaption></figure><p>Chapter 10: Signatures (<em>Perseverance</em>). A late chapter that really reflects the heart of the book. Howell and Booth are kind and respectful to their human subjects, portraying them honestly and positively as keen nerds living a dream. Exploring the then-future mission <em>Perseverance</em> (2021-Present), the chapter contains a factual traunch of information that alone justifies the cover price. Dissecting Percy the Rover’s instruments one by one, there are gems of info along the way, including the fact that NASA’s latest rover, while designed to be the first stage of a sample return mission to bring Martian rocks to Earth, is itself a sample return mission...to Mars.</p><p>Yup, Perseverance has onboard it a piece of Mars.</p><p>How? Like <em>ALH84001</em>, the <em>Sayh al Uhaymir</em> meteorite landed on Earth after being blasted off of Mars sometime in the distant past, likely a few million years ago. After more than a decade of analysis confirming it came from Mars, pieces of <em>Sayh al Uhaymir</em> have been placed onboard as calibration targets for one of the Rover’s instruments (SHERLOC). Since the rover team knows exactly what the meteorite is made of (they checked before packing it), they can be confident that SHERLOC is “dialed in” if it sends back the right info.</p><p>But why a Martian meteorite? The meteorite is known the to have the specific wavelengths of light that will reflect off of most Martian material now surrounding Percy. The expected similarities in results from the onboard meteorite and the local environment make the precious package an ideal calibration target (Mars rocks have some unique-ish spectral signals…i.e. reflections).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*oVQduNN8FxD-zgqUDSGW8A.jpeg" /><figcaption>Artist depiction of the European Space Agency’s Rosalind Franklin Rover expected to land on Mar in the Summer of 2023 (Image: ESA)</figcaption></figure><p>Chapter 11: Return to Sender (Sample Return and Future Missions). Everyone is getting in on the Mars science party. While half a ton of Martian material is estimated to land on Earth each year in the form of meteorites, in no uncertain terms, that is not the good stuff. We need primo-quality Mars samples to answer whether there was ever any life on Mars.</p><p>Targeting this, Perseverance will collect samples of Martian soil and rocks and then stash the, in sampling tubes for a future rover that will grab the samples and put them in a return capsule. It’s hoped that said future mission would bring home about 500 grams of pristine Martian material (unbothered by flying naked through space or being exposed to Earth’s atmosphere). This is expected to happen sometime between now and the distant future in which humans might land on Mars. If I were a betting man, I’d guess robotic sample return in the 2030s, and anywhere from 2050 to 2090 for a fully successful human mission.</p><p>In the meantime we can look forward to the ongoing adventures of a fleet of new rovers and orbiters heading to Mars. <em>Perseverance</em> is already there today, as we speak, unfurling its instrument suite and wandering the desert. More rovers will follow. So, pick up the book, learn all about it and, like the rest of us in the space science community, wait patiently, knowledge in hand, that something big could be discovered any day now.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*NXwLDQCpOkPxY5ZeOECDMw.png" /><figcaption>NASA’s newest rover on Mars, Perseverance, shown here descending to the surface from its delivery vehicle. Perseverance will collect samples and place them in an undetermined location for a future mission to collect (Image: NASA/JPL)</figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=585ca07d59e6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Geography of Space Exploration: Space 5.0 — The Ethics Era]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/geekculture/the-geography-of-space-exploration-space-5-0-the-ethics-era-32303928c072?source=rss-df03e0b08461------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/32303928c072</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Danny Bednar, PhD]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 18 Mar 2021 13:30:39 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-03-23T07:01:22.949Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>The Geography of Space Exploration: Space 5.0 — The Ethics Era</h3><p><em>The following is a discussion piece for #Space2090, an undergraduate course on Space Exploration in the Department of Geography and the Environment at Western University. It is open to others in order to collect comments below for the students and I to discuss. We will discuss the piece and any well thought-out responses in class, as well as the week’s readings, and students’ own conceptions of the evolution of human-space activities.</em></p><p><strong><em>Danny Bednar, </em></strong><em>PhD, is Canada’s second-best geographer of outer space and Assistant Professor in the Department of Geography at Western University in Ontario, Canada. He is also an analyst with the CSA and an author with Mango Publishers. All views are his own.</em></p><p>In November of 1980, an obscure New York magazine called FUTURE had a headline across its cover “Space Activism: A Growing National Movement?”. The article was a general piece on the emergence of what many now call ‘space advocacy’. Back then, at least according to the magazine and most since these homogenous ‘space advocates’ were largely Apollo-era Cold Warriors who advanced arguments around the trickle-down logic of spin-off technologies and the colonial-nationalist prestige of “us beating them”. The world has changed a lot, so has the space community.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Frf-xFcD0DjDLLqlserFUA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Not many people know Carl Sagan had Force Lightning.</figcaption></figure><p>I’ve always hated the term ‘space advocate’, it is inaccurate, (few people interested in space formally advocate for it) and it is overly-homogenous, even monolithic, in its application. Space is a big place with lots going on. It means many different things to many different people.</p><p>So lets do away with the term “space advocate” it carries too much confusing potential with more formalized positions like ‘lobbyist’ and has become muddled to the point of uselessness. In the context of this discussion piece, I will use the term ‘actor’ instead. In governance studies, we are all actors; entities moving about our daily lives who’s interactions with other actors shape the social landscape, or ‘network’ (also note that it’s a two way street of influence). There are even some approaches in the social sciences that ascribe actor ‘status’ to inanimate objects (Actor-Network Theory). I wont go there. But, broadly the notion of actors and networks is important in understanding the modern space age.</p><p>You don’t have to be a registered lobbyist or political campaign member to be influencing the social and political network in which you exist, we all do it with every social interaction we undertake. As recent movements against structural inequality and racism and in advancement of diversity, equity, and inclusion have tried to bring to the forefront: everything we do matters. Simply existing as actors in a society has an impact on our networks (to varying degrees), subsequently that “network” (society) acts back on us and others.</p><p>What does it mean to say “everything we do matters” It is to say that everything you do, every action, has ethical and political ramifications. This is because of the networks of which we are a part of and the reality that we live in an interconnected society with other humans. No one is an ethical or political island. Each action can support or resist processes that either cause harm or advance justice. Those lamenting this social reality and the “politicization of everything” via refer-madness-like woke panic are simply people’s whose ideals are so aligned with dominant political perspectives that they truly believe they are being apolitical in their daily actions. For a social scientist nothing is apolitical.</p><p>The result of this is a governance lens of critical engagement, the need to carefully explore both our actions as actors and the networks with which we willingly engage for their ethical entanglements. To carry on your daily life, to exist socially, is to act upon the network and have the network act on you. We must also recognize that structural oppression and inequality means many of us have very little influence on large parts of our networks and that our societal networks are heterogenous conglomerates of both oppressors and liberators. We exists as actors nonetheless, with, at least some, influence via legitimization or complacency regarding our connections (among other means).</p><p>Now lets think about how this matters to space exploration (or broader human-space engagements). Historically, we can think of space activities as emerging alongside various conceptions of human processes over the past century. One of these conceptions over the last decade has been a branded characterization of space activities as falling within eras labeled ‘Space 1.0’ through ‘Space 4.0’ (you will recall that we have seen other conceptions in our readings on space law and policy). Vaguely,<a href="https://www.esa.int/About_Us/Ministerial_Council_2016/What_is_space_4.0"> this has been described as the followin</a>g:</p><p><em>“The first era of space, ‘Space 1.0’, can be considered to be the early study of astronomy (and even astrology). The next era, ‘Space 2.0’, came about with spacefaring nations engaging in a space race that led to the Apollo Moon landings. The third era, ‘Space 3.0’, with the conception of the International Space Station, showed that we understood and valued space as the next frontier for cooperation and exploitation…Space 4.0 era, a time when space is evolving from being the preserve of the governments of a few spacefaring nations to a situation in which there is the increased number of diverse space actors around the world, including the emergence of private companies, participation with academia, industry and citizens, digitalisation and global interaction.”</em></p><p>But what has been less discussed in the conception of these eras, if they are indeed meaningful labels we wish to accept, is the ramification of such expansion of space activities and inclusion of actors with broader values. The expansion inherent to Space 4.0 fostered what I will argue is the central point of space 5.0. Space 5.0 is surely an equally subjective brand for a societal arrangement, but one I would argue is usefully reflective of the emergence of new space actors focused on ethical entanglements as guide to their engagement in the space network.</p><p><strong>Space 5.0 The Ethics Era</strong></p><p>As commentators pointing to Space 4.0 have argued, space activities have diversified (though I wouldn’t necessarily use that word…). For this discussion, lets then focus on what comes with said ‘diversification’. With the expansion of space activities comes plurality and diversity of experiences at levels never seen before in the community of previously nationalist-focused, generationally selfish, space-interested actors that dominated the 20th Century.</p><p>Though, to be fair, it’s also not the case that the network of space activities was entirely homogenous in the past. More so, eras 1.0 through to, and including, 4.0, were so dominantly overrun, and defined, by particular life experiences and aspiring apolitical perspectives that recent influxes of new values are indeed striking. Yes, the contributors of the Whole Earth Catalogue and the Apollo resistance movement, among others, were there, but they have been largely space-washed from history.</p><p>This is why <em>Space 5.0 is distinguishable as a new era</em> of <em>explicit</em> diversity of experience and ethical considerations in relation to processes taking place in, or related to, outer space. It has meant the discursive maturation of “space” from a monolithic concept of most space activities being equal, to the more explicit categorization of <em>kinds</em> of space activities reflective of a more advanced network of political, social, historical, and cultural relations between actors (i.e. its not all the same, we’re not all the same).</p><p>Is this entirely new? Again, no, of course not. But neither was Space 4.0. Governance scholars like myself snickered when people claimed that New Public Management was somehow new…in the year 2010, just because it was happening in the space sector. The political economy arrangements of space 4.0 have been the dominant governance mode in North America and Europe since the end of World War 2, they are not new. These arrangements were simply packaged as a brand in the space community to reflect changing power dynamics and interests. So, like Space 4.0, Space 5.0 too isn’t actually new, its just become more accurate as a brand because it is undeniable that new actors entering the space network are shaped by critical self-reflection and cultural moments unique from past “eras”.</p><p>***</p><p>The question of Space 5.0 is then: what<em> kind</em> of entangled actors do we want to be in this old/new environment? What ethical considerations should drive our interests and relations? Why do we care about things that happen in space? What do we want to happen? What are the daily, local, social, cultural, and moral ramifications of our space interests? Not all space activities are created equally, so what <em>kind</em> of space actors do we want to be?</p><p>There is a growing group of people thinking this way; many of <a href="https://spacegeneration.org/projects/ehr">whom I have had the immense privilege to work with</a> over the past few years as this whole thing has bubbled under. These people are why Space 5.0 is the <em>Ethics Era. </em>A new era of space activity driven by an emerging generation of diverse, self-critical, <em>selective</em> space actors fostering networks of ethically minded global citizens committed to a sustainable and equitable future on Earth for <em>all</em> humans.</p><p>Do you agree or disagree? Does labelling “space eras” make any sense? What kind of space actor are you? What do you support? What networks of space activity do you want, or not want, to be a part of? Please reply respectfully in the comments section below.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=32303928c072" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/geekculture/the-geography-of-space-exploration-space-5-0-the-ethics-era-32303928c072">The Geography of Space Exploration: Space 5.0 — The Ethics Era</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/geekculture">Geek Culture</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Geography of Space Exploration: The Vinyl Frontier (Book Review)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/curious/the-geography-of-space-exploration-the-vinyl-frontier-book-review-5be5978d39e4?source=rss-df03e0b08461------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5be5978d39e4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[books]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[space-exploration]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[space]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Danny Bednar, PhD]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 12 Sep 2020 13:02:17 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-09-23T14:09:56.329Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>A mix-tape for all of humanity, love affairs, space probes destined for the interstellar void, and a tight deadline. Jonathon Scott’s story of the Voyager Golden Records is an effective time warp, with doubled edged food for thought that leaves a positive imprint of its subjects and events for the reader.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*EGC8vYagxsoNimbMkqPT6g.jpeg" /><figcaption>The Vinyl Frontier (2019) by Jonathan Scott. Bloomsbury Sigma. Available at your local independent book store and from <a href="https://www.bloomsbury.com/us/the-vinyl-frontier-9781472956132/">Bloomsbury.com</a></figcaption></figure><p>There are seemingly endless ways to look at the Voyager Golden Record and wonder what exactly it is an artifact of. As Jonathan Scott recounts in <em>Vinyl Frontier: The Story of the Voyager Golden Record,</em> confronted with the topic, people vary from inspiration to ambivalence, and even to annoyance or disgust. Personally, as someone who’s PhD included a focus on governance and considerations of public and ethical legitimacy in policy, aspects of the Golden Record story horrify that tiny bit of too-serious academic hiding deep inside me. A group of scientists led by academic elites making decisions for all of humankind, with no democratic oversight, the horrid technocracy of it all!</p><p>However, the majority of my psyche, and likely other readers’, will either not have those intuitions or simply see the task for what it was. An <em>ad hoc</em> effort to do something genuinely well-intended by a group of enthusiasts swept up by their passions. At the same time, (that serious academic is rearing) the technocracy is there, and the elitism and western bias cannot be avoided. But, really, that just adds to the perfect imperfection of the Golden Record.</p><h4>The Voyager Golden Records</h4><p>In 1977, NASA launched two probes towards the outer solar system. By this time, the Apollo program was long-complete, having had its final Moon landing in 1972. The so-called “space race” was over, and space agencies had shifted their focus.</p><p>Russia was mastering Low Earth Orbit (the space nearest to Earth) with their new <em>Soyuz</em> program, a remarkable human spaceflight system that endures today as the most reliable and safest human spaceflight system ever built. With their prowess in human spaceflight, the Russians would go on to build the world’s first major space station (<em>Mir</em>) in the 1980s. The Americans, on the other hand, had mostly turned towards our planetary neighbors for the remainder of the 1970s. In 1975 they launched a pair of missions to Mars called <em>Viking 1</em> and <em>Viking 2</em>, each consisting of a both a lander and an orbiter.</p><p>Building off of the infrastructure from previous programs called <em>Pioneer</em> and <em>Mariner</em>, NASA also built the two probes named <em>Voyager 1</em> and <em>Voyager 2; each </em>would explore the gas giants in more detail than ever before. As luck would have it, if they hurried, they could take advantage of a rare alignment and catch glimpses of all four: Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus, and Neptune.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*TmbqlXsqb9sUwlQFPPwRlg.jpeg" /><figcaption>NASA’s retro poster for what became known as the Voyager Grand Tour, two spacecraft, four planets and a half-dozen moons (Image: NASA/JPL)</figcaption></figure><p>As the trajectories were developed it was realized that the Voyagers would be on a path out of the Solar System, they would be travelling fast enough to totally escape the Sun’s gravity and sail into interstellar nothingness; the vast distance between solar systems.</p><p>While its entirely likely that no human-like creature will be alive when the Voyagers reach other solar systems, the probes themselves could act as a sort of <em>message in a bottle</em> from humanity. With this in mind, the Voyager team decided to send along a communique with the probe for the unlikely event that a future being encountered this strange object sailing through space. What became of this idea was the <em>Voyager Golden Record</em>, and its conception is where Jonathan Scott’s book picks up.</p><p><strong>The Ultimate Mix Tape</strong></p><p>Scott starts our journey by recounting a mix tape he once made for a girl he had hooked up with named Beth (by this time he was old enough to know that any inclusion of the <em>Kiss</em> song <em>Beth</em> would be morally reprehensible). It’s apparent that Scott lives outside the space bubble, and thank god for that. A music lover and accomplished writer he brings a good distance to the story and its cast of characters. By the end of the first few chapters, you recognize the author as a savvy Gen-X-er who isn’t interested in taking the reader on the dreaded trope of a “science is cool” narrative, but instead a personally-tinged, but journalistically (in the good way) rigorous trip though a frantic ‘making of’ tale.</p><p>From my position, the single best thing about <em>Vinyl Frontier</em> is that it begs interesting questions from the reader. For example, some the first ones I have scribbled in my own notes are:</p><p><em>“dick, but no vulva?”</em></p><p><em>“Is sending messages into space a big deal?”</em></p><p>That first reaction is in relation to the book’s retelling of the “scandalous” nature of etched plaques onboard Pioneers 10 and 11. Space probes I mentioned earlier that were launched a few years before the Voyager program (both Pioneers were eventually surpassed by the faster travelling Voyagers). In this instance a plaque onboard the Pioneers featuring sketches of naked humans that did not include any indication of the vulva, despite having lines to outline a penis and scrotum. This brief glimpses of the sexist ideals passing as norms of the time provides background for an issue that emerges again in the Voyager story.</p><p>The second note is a nagging one for me throughout the story. Are messages into space a big deal? In the event they are found, yes, they will be a very, very, big deal. But the odds of them ever being found are infinitesimally small. Nonetheless, does the potential impact, however unlikely, mean these messages should be carefully crafted in the public realm? It’s a question I don’t really have a definitive answer for. Scott doesn&#39;t wade into these waters too explicitly, but does point to perspectives that champion the <em>ad hoc</em> nature as being much quicker than any democratic process could have been.</p><p>This question of how the record should have been crafted begs both its political legitimacy as well as its cultural legitimacy in “representing Earth”. Scott often mentions the impossibility of the task, nothing that<a href="https://slate.com/technology/2020/01/sonar-music-aliens-meti-seti.html">there would always be bias</a>. Modern scholars would no doubt point to the western elitist interpretation of ‘world music’ included on the record and social scientist like myself have to refrain from scoffing a the technocratic hubris of the entire operation. Again, the Voyager Golden Record is far from a perfect representation of Earth, but it is perhaps a perfect representation of human imperfection.</p><p><strong>The Golden Record Clique and a Missed Opportunity</strong></p><p>The record was put together by a team of about 12–15 people, depending on how you count. The main contributors on the musical side of the operation were Jon Lomberg and Timothy Ferris, with inputs from the rest of the team: Frank Drake, Ann Druyan, and Linda Salzman-Sagan. And of course, Carl Sagan holding veto power as producer. A definitive (from the creators themselves) account of the making-of process is available in the book <em>Murmurs of Earth: The Voyager Interstellar Record</em>, written by the team in the immediate aftermath of the album’s release to the cosmos.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/421/1*QIsB7KUYByGp2vOsfy8qmw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Murmurs of Earth, the definitive inside account of the Voyager Golden Record, to which Scott’s book isnow, IMHO, a necessary companion (Image: Random House)</figcaption></figure><p>I wont belabour the point of the ever-long debate over whether the record would be more legitimate if it had been done more openly (the clique kept it mostly hush hush). And one does have to concede that, especially with the tight timelines, its hard to imagine the record getting done so quickly via more-official channels. So let’s leave be what is done. The record was made the way it was, with a small group from a narrow selection of fields reaching out to select friends and colleagues and, on the down-low, putting together a mix tape to represent humanity. Even accepting the clique approach though, I still have one last quarrel, not with Scott, but with the record making process. I can’t help notice one missing figure from the time. Where the hell is Leonard Bernstein?</p><p>If you’ll allow me a short(-ish) digression, it is to me, worthwhile to point out a significant missed opportunity here. The record was being put together in the mid 1970s, by this time Leonard Bernstein was a world famous conductor, T.V. personality, and accomplished classical composer (he also created West Side Story, the greatest American musical of it’s time). He had also recorded a ground breaking series of <em>Young People’s Concerts </em>throughout the 1960’s and rose to household status as a skilled translator of musical history and theory outside of snobbish concert halls. Around the time of the Golden Record project, Bernstein was recording his Harvard Lectures, slightly more advanced discussions of musical theory also renowned for their clarity in dealing with such difficult topics.</p><p>With all due respect to famed science communicators, Bernstein could have taught circles around other figures in popular communication. Every teacher, musical or otherwise, should watch his <em>Young People’s Concerts</em> to observe how he slowly introduces simple ideas, puts them on top of each other, and eventually combines them for a full understanding of their complex whole. Selecting specific pieces of the <em>Western Classical Traditional</em> to represent the genre (which admittedly the Golden Record team may have given too much groove space) would have been ideal for Bernstein’s inputs. Similarly, in communicating the Voyager program and the Golden Record to popular audiences, Bernstein would have been an invaluable asset.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*9-pZJq-TXn7Eyz1XfNhTRQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Lenny in the midst of teaching in one of his later TV specials (Image: CBS)</figcaption></figure><p>A fair question to ask when considering this fantasy pairing however is ‘what would Lenny have thought of the whole project?’ It’s hard to say, one music theorist friend of mine suggested that perhaps Lenny might not have been too comfortable with the idea of choosing some composers over others (could he possibly have left out his beloved Mahler?). It does make sense that for someone as immersed in western classical history as Bernstein, the ‘greatest hits of Earth’ approach the clique took just wouldn&#39;t have flown.</p><p>There are four composers of the <a href="https://voyager.jpl.nasa.gov/golden-record/whats-on-the-record/music/">Western Classical Tradition on the Record</a>: Bach, Mozart, Beethoven, and Stravinsky. With broad enough strokes, this does cover most major eras of western classical music. Bach was born in 1685, Mozart 1756, Beethoven 1770, and Stravinsky would have recently passed in 1971. Would Bernstein have been comfortable with Bach having 3 pieces while none of the rest of the Baroque period is covered? Interestingly, Mozart ends up representing western opera over Verdi or (thankfully) Wagner (The musical world’s von Bruan…or is that R. Strauss). Beethoven gets two pieces but there is a pretty significant gap as we run into Stravinsky’s 20th century <em>Rite of Sprin</em>g, a piece that oddly represents ballet on the record (though its easy to forget the Rite is somehow meant to be danced to…).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/1*sqq-aCqKfv8QN3hjR9eE9g.jpeg" /><figcaption>Familiar to audiences from Disney’s Dino-Apocalyptic sequence from the first Fantasia, Stravinsky’s rhythmic Rite of Spring made its way onto the Voyager Golden Record (Image: Disney)</figcaption></figure><p>Perhaps foremost, we can guess one gripe Bernstein might have had, his beloved romantic era isn’t truly represented. Beethoven may or may not count as a romantic, but the 5th Symphony and 13th String Quartet are not listed too often as representative of the era. Tchaikovsky, Brahms, Chopin, Liszt, Dvorak, and Mahler are all snubbed. With seven pieces reserved for western classical music, it would be fair to presume that Romanticism (perhaps the most popular classical era for 20th century listeners) would get strong representation. But fair enough, Bach is the master among masters, so his three selections are perhaps well earned.</p><p>Surprisingly, I wasn&#39;t able to dig up anything from interviews, biographies, or Bernstein’s own writings in which he talks about the Golden Record. To me it is striking, the biggest classical music celebrity in America appears to have never crossed paths, at least not on the record, with this venture to communicate music to alien civilizations. And maybe that’s it, re-read the sentence before this; “communicating music to aliens” does sound kinda ridiculous. Maybe Bernstein just wasn’t interested. But knowing the history of classical music’s diminished presence in western popular culture over the 20th century, it kinda sucks that the one person who was able to bring it into North American homes so brilliantly, in a charismatic and more confident way than Sagan did for planetary science, was never involved. Who knows, maybe Bernstein and Sagan’s respective egos would have clashed irreconcilably. Though, if you can work with <em>Glenn Gould</em> you can certainly work with Carl Sagan. Nevertheless, its certainly fun to imagine Lenny battling it out with Sagan over the need to have the sonata form represented.</p><p>The last part of this digression will be to point out an interesting decision the Golden Record team made. In the discussions to select the record’s musical playlist (there were also spoken pieces and encoded images), the team decided to leave out a sort of introduction to musical theory that would have been presented using only mathematics and known psychical laws of the universe. At one point, Jon Lomberg suggested introducing basic musical theory through single tones and the nested semi-tones within; then introducing octaves, fifths, thirds, harmony, and eventually even melody and rhythm.</p><p>Sagan apparently nixed the idea due to time restrictions on the record. Sagan may have been right, but I personally would have been willing to cut some of the classical and jazz pieces. Even better, the entire segment of greetings from world leaders could have been cut as they are surely gibberish compared to musical language that may be universal in its application. With Sagan being a physicist, its surprises me this idea didn’t get further than a single suggestion.</p><p>So here we are, my digression is over. But that’s one of the funny things about Scott’s book and the record itself. When you read the account of the team putting it together, you recognize that they couldn’t win. Nothing they chose could have pleased me and every other pseudo-music critic. Yet at the same time, its almost impossible to read about the project and avoid thinking “no, not that! This should be on instead!”.</p><p><strong>Aliens or Humans</strong></p><p>Enough musing about Leonard Bernstein, back to Scott’s actual book. Throughout the story the question organically arises, guided effectively by the author, is this a communication for aliens or just future (even current) humans? Its a good question. There is the possibility (perhaps as likely as aliens finding it) that a distant Earth/human civilization finds it before anyone else. If this Earthly civilization is, say, 100 thousand or 1 million years from now (hell it could be a billion years from now), it is possible that no trace of this current human civilization will exist (with the exception of a few select pieces of space junk that have orbits lucky enough not to decay into the Sun or other bodies). While Voyager isn’t coming back, some slick future humans (would they even be humans?) might develop technology capable of catching up to, and nabbing, Voyager. This indeed was the notion put forward by science fiction author <em>Robert Heinlein </em>who, in a fascinating letter to Sagan, also presented the plain fact that most humans wouldn’t be able to decipher what the team was doing, nevermind aliens.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/733/1*82AydTjQQjxd8i8jZVAgdA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Directions to Earth and instructions on how to use the record. Make sense? (Image: NASA/JPL)</figcaption></figure><p>What are the bloody odds that <em>a</em>) this is found <em>b</em>) the aliens figure out how to use it, and <em>c</em>) they come even close to interpreting it. Well <em>c</em> and <em>b</em> rely on <em>a</em>, and <em>a</em> is the lowest likelihood. As a whole, all three happening together is probably beyond any meaningful statistical representation (<a href="https://www.seti.org/drake-equation-index">Drake Equation</a> be damned). The biggest challenge is whether the aliens will know that much of the noise the record is playing is meant to be translated from sound waves into pixels, and thereby images. From a human perspective, there is a pretty healthy community that has developed amateur means of deciphering the Golden Record’s encoded images using various techniques. For example, a team at The Verge was able to use <a href="https://www.theverge.com/2018/10/30/18037984/golden-record-nasa-image-decode-voyager-1-2#:~:text=Their%20journey%20started%20in%201977,songs%2C%20and%20images%20from%20Earth.">basic computer coding </a>to do so. But much of these attempts begin with the known assumptions about senses and communication (something <em>Heinlein </em>warned Sagan extraterrestrials may not have even remotely similar concepts of) and knowledge of the fact that the various symbols on the record’s casing (see image above) represent different mathematical or physical constants acting as a sort of Rosetta Stone instruction manual. Because of all this, i<a href="https://www.discovermagazine.com/the-sciences/will-aliens-understand-voyagers-golden-record">t has indeed been suggested that aliens might not stand a chance with the thing.</a></p><p><strong>We Send in Peace?</strong></p><p>The Voyager Golden Record purposefully left out humanity&#39;s shortcomings. There are no images of nuclear explosions or sounds of gunfire, and none of the songs are political pieces about, say, racism or poverty. It also includes over 50 messages from United Nations representatives about humanity reaching out in peace. This more than anything on the record is a almost entirely a symbolic gesture for contemporary purposes (though I suppose it could show aliens we have various ways of speaking).</p><p>One of my notes next to the discussion of the flowery and beautifully positive language recorded by UN representatives is <em>“ha! aliens will see right through this”</em>. What I mean is that in the event that <em>a</em>, <em>b</em>, and <em>c </em>all come together, our alien bottle-message recipients may chose to come visit us and find they’ve been honeypotted.</p><p>Imagine a civilization that stumbled on the Voyager’s signal and went and nabbed the thing right now. Also imagine that after decoding the record they can somehow come see us near-instantly. Tragically, they would not find a world aligned with the flowery messages of peace and love sent their way. They would see gross global inequality, environmental decay, and enough bloodshed in one day to let them know the trailer for planet Earth wasn’t exactly honest. In this sense the Voyager Golden Record is another reminder to the space exploration community: don’t just talk to the talk about ‘progress’, walk the walk.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*x24naGZewq3y9a85rQdxMw.jpeg" /><figcaption>“ We strive to live in peace with the peoples of the whole world” Nice try humans, you still got lots of growing up to do (Image: 20th Century Fox/Disney)</figcaption></figure><p>These are the kinds of scenarios you end up running through you head with this book, it is about both common things we can all relate to like funding, tight schedules, and romance (oh yes there is a love story) as well as existential questions about the nature of the universe, our cosmic loneliness, and the futility of it all. Intellectually, it is a wide-ranging book and I congratulate Scott on covering everything from the urbane to the philosophical with cleverness and enticing prose (even if he called Mozart German and seems to like Beethoven&#39;s Cavatina a little too much…it’s not <em>THAT</em> good).</p><p><strong>A Hearty Goodbye and a Parting Challenge</strong></p><p>Scott leaves us with endearing portraits of the later lives of his cast of characters as well as a nice conclusion to the love story that bubbles underneath throughout the book. Of course, in following up the lives of his main characters, there is tragedy. But this doesn’t affect the overall positive experience of reading the book. If you love both music and space exploration, this is must-read. If you like just one of those things, I would still argue strongly that it’s worth your time.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*JtOW6YmtgNeJrX3gSeQkwA.jpeg" /><figcaption>The ultimate mix tape? A lost art, an idea we have handed over to algorithms. Go ahead try. Make a mix to represent even just yourself, not even all of humanity. What would you chose? (Image: Pexels.com)</figcaption></figure><p><em>Vinyl Frontier</em> leaves us with a challenge: using 1970’s technology, try to search out the materials for a Golden Record-type playlist. So, no internet or rapid communication with experts and peers. This parting challenge really does provide empathy for the Golden Record team. Even made today, the project would land far short of any sort of unanimous sense of representation. But try doing it in the mid 70’s, where correspondence with experts could take weeks, phone numbers were difficult to find, and there was no centralized medium for researching every single topic on the planet. Given the technology of the time, the project was bound to be profoundly limited in representing whatever it intended to represent. Therefore, the Voyager Golden Record team deserves praise for pulling off what is still a good record (like <em>Bad</em> good, but not <em>Thriller</em> great). At the same time, praise should be given to Jonathon Scott for a fun and thought-provoking account of the weirdest album ever produced.</p><p><em>Danny Bednar, PhD, is an Assistant Professor in the Department of Geography and Environment at Western University in Canada where he teaches about space exploration. He is also an analyst at the Canadian Space Agency and the co-author of For All Humankind: The Untold Stories of How the Moon Landing Inspired the World. All views are his own.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5be5978d39e4" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/curious/the-geography-of-space-exploration-the-vinyl-frontier-book-review-5be5978d39e4">The Geography of Space Exploration: The Vinyl Frontier (Book Review)</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/curious">Curious</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>