<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by David Tyler on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by David Tyler on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@davidtyler258?source=rss-1a6164dd1449------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 04:52:37 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@davidtyler258/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Zone]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@davidtyler258/the-zone-18f1f1760163?source=rss-1a6164dd1449------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/18f1f1760163</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[australia]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[satire]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[civil-liberties]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[military]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[David Tyler]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 20:00:30 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-11-18T01:52:10.917Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/440/0*Yq8P-zpebM2JVBT7" /></figure><p><em>Labor’s Defence Legislation Amendment (Accelerating Capability and Protecting Bases) Bill 2026 cleared the House in three sitting days and is now before the Senate. It hands Defence sweeping new powers. The minister can switch off state laws and declare security zones, some of which move with a convoy. Defence officials and private contractors can stop and detain people. Entering a special zone without permission can mean seven years’ jail.</em> <em>Such a situation demands a Clarke and Dawe response.</em> <em>Dawe’s questions come from the bill. Clarke plays the Assistant Minister for Defence. He keeps one eye on the studio cameras. With gratitude to John Clarke and Bryan Dawe.</em></p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> Assistant Minister, thanks for your time.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Good evening, Bryan. Is that a phone in your top pocket?</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> It is.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Leave it there, my good fellow. For your own protection.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> Now, this new Defence bill. Accelerating Capability and Protecting Bases.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Marvellous title. Accelerating and protecting, simultaneously. Like driving with the handbrake on, only faster.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> What’s it for?</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Drones, Bryan. Horrid, little buzzing things. Over our bases. Modern threats demand modern laws.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> So it’s a drone bill.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Among other things. Land. Buildings. Sea. Sky. Moving vehicles.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> That’s a lot of drone.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Very versatile things, drones.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> And the minister can switch off state and territory laws?</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Only the ones that would get in the way.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> Which ones?</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Good heavens, Bryan. If we listed them, people would know which ones they were.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> And the zones?</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Permanent, temporary, mobile and special. Something for everyone. The mobile ones travel with the convoy. You could be outside a servo in Horsham with a pie and a snot block, a truck goes past, and suddenly you’re in a Defence Security Zone.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> A what?</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> A snot block, Bryan. That’s Horsham for vanilla slice. The pie’s fine. Just don’t photograph it.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> The pie?</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> The truck. Two years.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> And if I’m just standing there?</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> In a special zone? Seven. You simply exist in the wrong place.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> Critics say it’s really about protesters.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> These laws are not about protesters. They’re about people present without authorisation. Often in groups. Frequently holding signs.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> That’s protesters.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Do be careful with that P-word, Bryan. This is the ABC. You don’t want to stir up Senator Alston, do you?</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> Senator Alston? Is he still with us?</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Very much so, Bryan. And his spirit lives on at the ABC. Just ask Antoinette. Besides, it’s another P-word. You need prior clearance from the Envoy.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> Which P-word?</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> I couldn’t possibly say, Bryan. Not without clearance.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> Who keeps an eye on all this?</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> The anti-corruption commission can go in any time it likes. With the minister’s say-so. Very courteous system. Nobody barges in.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> Is that it?</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Not at all. We’ve adopted the Lord Nelson navigation system. Have you heard about Nelson putting the telescope to his blind eye?</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> I have, yes.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> It’s a corker. Signal goes up telling him to stop, he says he sees no signal, and on he goes. That’s our Defence oversight model. Long before Scott Morrison got his AUKUS caucused. The ABC might do a series about it.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> A series?</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Well, a mini-series, anyway.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> And if I’m detained, do I get a lawyer?</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> No, you don’t have any right to a lawyer. This is Australia, Bryan.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> And habeas corpus?</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Not suspended, Bryan. Just stored somewhere very secure.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> Where?</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Can’t tell you. It’s in a zone.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> Assistant Minister, thanks for your time.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Pleasure. Oh, Bryan. That phone in your top pocket. Is it on?</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> I suppose it is.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Then it’s been recording. Since we started. In my zone.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> Your zone?</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Mobile special zone, Bryan. Goes wherever I go. Zone. Wham. Bam. Slam. Thank you, Uncle Sam.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> Can I go now?</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Of course, Bryan. Mind the convoy on your way out. And if you’re passing through Horsham, grab us a snot block, would you? You can’t miss the bakery. Opposite the Italian joint. Shop here before the day goes in neon.</p><p><em>The provisions Dawe puts to Clarke are on the record: </em><a href="https://www.deepcutnews.com/p/labors-insane-defence-bill-could"><em>the bill and its rushed passage</em></a><em>, </em><a href="https://www.defence.gov.au/sites/default/files/2026-10/Defence-Security-Zone-Framework-frequently-asked-questions.pdf"><em>the four kinds of zone, mobile ones included</em></a><em>, </em><a href="https://independentaustralia.net/article-display/aukus-bill-hands-sweeping-powers-to-defence-minister,21768"><em>the two and seven year penalties and the minister’s say-so over investigators</em></a><em>, and </em><a href="https://www.canberratimes.com.au/story/9387498/richard-marles-defence-bill-sparks-war-preparation-fears/"><em>the unlisted laws, the drones and “not about protesters”</em></a><em>. Clarke’s answers are satire.</em> <em>A tribute to John Clarke (1948 to 2017), whose method this borrows and whose genius it cannot. With thanks to Bryan Dawe.</em> <em>The Clarke and Dawe format and characters remain the work and property of John Clarke (Roderick Willows Pty Ltd) and Bryan Dawe. This sketch is an independent homage, written and published by Urban Wronski, and is not affiliated with or endorsed by them.</em></p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://urbanwronski.com/2026/11/18/the-zone-clarke-and-dawe-defence-bill/"><em>http://urbanwronski.com</em></a><em> on November 17, 2026.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=18f1f1760163" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Lock Up the Hungry]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@davidtyler258/lock-up-the-hungry-b2655bea0696?source=rss-1a6164dd1449------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b2655bea0696</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[inequality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[food-insecurity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[australia]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cost-of-living]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[David Tyler]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 16 Nov 2026 08:00:53 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-11-17T03:28:52.218Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/440/0*vHGjfFmg6WWPFNos" /></figure><p>Every day since December, police and Protective Services Officers have patrolled <a href="https://www.police.vic.gov.au/shopping-centre-patrols-boosted-during-school-holidays">four of Victoria’s biggest shopping centres, in rotation</a>. Highpoint. Fountain Gate. Northland. Southland. Five more besides. A high-visibility operation, they say, designed to reassure shoppers and deter offenders.</p><p>They call it Operation Pulse. Heartbeat was already taken, by a nostalgic television series about community policing. Perhaps we should check our own pulse if we imagine that armed men and women in uniform are any kind of answer to hunger.</p><p>By August, Operation Pulse had made <a href="https://www.police.vic.gov.au/victoria-police-pso-resources-bolstered-and-operation-pulse-expanded">1,766 arrests and laid 3,562 charges</a>. Just over half were for shop theft.</p><p>Coles’ head office is at <a href="https://announcements.asx.com.au/asxpdf/20260825/pdf/0735cc17cb83rn.pdf">800 Toorak Road, Hawthorn East</a>. No PSO patrols it.</p><p>Victoria recorded <a href="https://www.channelnews.com.au/victorian-retail-theft-hits-record-high-with-102-offences-a-day/">37,398 thefts from retail stores</a> in the year to June, a record. Who is doing the stealing? Not the gangs of the Herald Sun’s imagination. When the theft boom began, Victoria Police found <a href="https://www.newcastleherald.com.au/story/8669147/cost-of-living-high-interest-rates-drive-retail-theft/">half the shoplifters were first-timers</a>, and blamed the cost of living. The Crime Statistics Agency’s chief statistician says shoplifting is <a href="https://inkl.com/news/six-graphs-reveal-the-true-state-of-crime-in-victoria-and-who-s-behind-it">led by adults in their thirties</a>. <a href="https://www.data.vic.gov.au/updated-crime-statistics-and-bail-data-0">Youth offending is falling. Adult offending is rising.</a></p><p>Some are career criminals. Police have caught prolific thieves and people carrying weapons. Good. Retail workers are entitled to a safe workplace. Nobody disputes that.</p><p>But most shoplifting is not the work of organised criminal empires. Some of it is committed by people standing at the self-service checkout, being informed by a disembodied voice that there is an unexpected item in the bagging area. Increasingly, the unexpected item is something they cannot afford.</p><p>The <a href="https://reports.foodbank.org.au/foodbank-hunger-report-2026/">Foodbank Hunger Report 2026</a> puts the national food insecurity rate at one in three households, 3.6 million households in all. <a href="https://www.foodbank.org.au/hunger-report-2026-media-release/">Among renters it is one in two.</a> Among households with children it is nearly one in two. Food insecurity among households with part-time or casual workers has reached 42 percent. Almost half of food-insecure households say embarrassment or shame keeps them from asking for help.</p><p>Shame, but not a PSO, follows them out of the shop.</p><p>I know something about school breakfast programs. Some years ago, I volunteered for a term at a local primary school on the wrong side of the tracks. The best part of the experience was helping serve breakfast. Half the school would turn up for a free feed. I also worked alongside the kids in the kitchen garden. There was something rather satisfying about watching children grow food and helping them understand where breakfast came from.</p><p>There is something utterly unforgettable about the look on a youngster’s face when you give her what may be her only meal of the day. It is something beyond mere gratitude. Something that reaches into a place we are all equipped at birth with: the instinct to care for one another.</p><p>It is difficult to reconcile that simple human instinct with a society increasingly organised around the opposite principle: everything has a price, everybody is a customer, and even the roof over your head is an opportunity for someone else to extract a little more.</p><p>Who told us we had to build an economy in which everything is a negotiable transaction, except the price of being poor?</p><p>Both the breakfast program and the garden have since disappeared. Locals tell me the funding was cut. I haven’t established precisely why they closed. But cutting funding doesn’t cut a young child’s hunger. It merely removes one place where that hunger was being answered.</p><p>I grew up in New Zealand, where <a href="https://teara.govt.nz/en/food-and-beverage-manufacturing/page-6">governments subsidised bread and milk for decades</a>. The wheat and flour industry was regulated to keep the price of a standard loaf affordable. The retail price of liquid milk was similarly supported by government subsidy. These were deliberate cost-of-living policies, not charitable handouts. The underlying proposition was that basic food should remain within reach of ordinary households.</p><p>The <a href="https://globalizationandhealth.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/1744-8603-5-1/tables/1">milk subsidy ended in 1985</a>. The Wheat Board, which had set the price of a loaf since 1936, <a href="https://www.legislation.govt.nz/secondary-legislation/pco-drafted/1986/351/en/latest/">followed in 1987</a>, during the great market-liberalisation experiment.</p><p>Perhaps that seems impossibly quaint now. But there was a time when governments considered the affordability of bread and milk a legitimate responsibility of government, rather than leaving families to negotiate the supermarket checkout with whatever happened to be left in their wallets.</p><p>Tony Abbott has a different theory. As employment minister in 2001 he <a href="https://www.greenleft.org.au/2001/457/ten-reasons-why-tony-abbott-wrong-about-poverty">told Four Corners</a> that poverty can’t be abolished, because “poverty in part is a function of individual behaviour”. Drinking. Gambling. As prime minister in 2015 he called life in a remote Aboriginal community <a href="https://www.indailysa.com.au/news/archive/2015/03/11/abbott-sparks-anger-aboriginal-lifestyle-choices">a lifestyle choice</a> the taxpayer shouldn’t have to subsidise. He is now <a href="https://www.abc.net.au/listen/programs/pm/abbott-elected-liberal-party-president/106739522">federal president of the Liberal Party</a>.</p><p>He was answered at the time. <a href="https://www.greenleft.org.au/2001/457/ten-reasons-why-tony-abbott-wrong-about-poverty">Green Left Weekly</a> pointed out that low wages were a major cause of poverty, and an underrated one, and that the working poor were a growing class. That was twenty-five years ago. This year Foodbank found <a href="https://www.foodbank.org.au/hunger-report-2026-media-release/">more than a third of middle-income households</a> going short of food. They are not drinking the grocery money. They are earning it, and it isn’t enough.</p><p>Greg Jericho, the Australia Institute’s chief economist, has the better answer: <a href="https://australiainstitute.org.au/post/poverty-is-a-policy-choice-it-is-time-for-the-government-to-choose-better/">poverty is a policy choice</a>. Governments are not innocent bystanders to it.</p><p>Melbourne’s median weekly rent for a house or unit is <a href="https://tenantsvic.org.au/news/well-call-on-parties-to-commit-to-existing-renter-protections/">around $600</a>. Victoria’s unemployment rate has been running at <a href="https://www.abs.gov.au/statistics/labour/employment-and-unemployment/labour-force-australia/latest-release">about five percent</a>. This is the precariat state: the renter, the casual, the gig worker, the young, the mortgaged fringe, the regional town where the last mill shut years ago.</p><p>Lock up the hungry.</p><p>Now the other side of the checkout.</p><p>In March last year, <a href="https://thedailyaus.com.au/economics/coles-and-woolworths-not-accused-of-price-gouging-in-major-inquiry">the ACCC found</a> that Coles and Woolworths operate in an oligopolistic market, rank among the most profitable supermarket businesses in the world, and had increased their product margins while grocery prices climbed. Some of those price increases <a href="https://afgc.org.au/?p=3001">went straight to profit</a>. The ACCC never said price gouging. It didn’t need to.</p><p>In August, Coles reported a full-year statutory profit of <a href="https://insidefmcg.com.au/2026/08/25/coles-fy26-profit-climbs-as-liquor-falters-and-job-cuts-loom/">$1.09 billion</a>. That was after setting aside $235 million following a Federal Court judgment concerning the underpayment of its own staff. Its dividend to shareholders <a href="https://thenightly.com.au/business/markets/asx-reporting-season-all-the-latest-news-from-companies-releasing-financial-results-to-the-market-today-c-22771134">increased by 13 percent</a>.</p><p>Woolworths made <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/business/2026/aug/26/woolworths-profit-ooshies-collectables">$1.138 billion, up from $963 million</a>. Its chief executive, Amanda Bardwell, told reporters shoppers had moved into a <a href="https://thenightly.com.au/business/bargain-hunting-behaviour-now-entrenched-among-woolworths-shoppers-says-amanda-bardwell-c-22777581">“new reality of entrenched value-seeking”</a>.</p><p>Value-seeking. That’s what a supermarket calls it when you can’t afford the food.</p><p>The Federal Court found that the two chains had failed to keep proper records of the hours worked by <a href="https://leglobal.law/2025/09/23/australia-set-off-not-cure-all-in-massive-woolworths-coles-underpayment/">nearly 30,000 salaried staff</a>. The bill to put it right is <a href="https://www.bdo.com.au/en-au/insights/advisory/articles/australia-s-largest-underpayment-case-what-you-need-to-know-now">heading for $1 billion</a>. Woolworths’ then chief executive, Brad Banducci, had denied that the scandal was <a href="https://www.inkl.com/news/woolworths-has-begun-paying-back-millions-in-unpaid-wages-shareholders-told">“wage theft”</a>.</p><p>When the groceries go missing, it’s a crime wave. When the wages go missing, it’s an underpayment. One gets Operation Pulse. The other gets a line in the annual report headed “significant items”.</p><p>Lock up the hungry.</p><p>Who speaks for the worker at the register? Start with the man who used to stand at one.</p><p>On his first full day as premier, Ben Carroll <a href="https://www.premier.vic.gov.au/site-4/labor-has-zero-tolerance-violence-against-workers">went to Kmart</a>. Not to shop. For the backdrop. He <a href="https://aapnews.aap.com.au/news/from-kmart-to-premier-ben-carroll-s-political-rise">started there at fourteen</a> and joined the Shoppies. Now he stood beside the state secretary of the shop assistants’ union, the SDA, and announced orders to ban abusive customers from the store.</p><p>Fair enough. Nobody should cop a spray at the register. Nor should a young casual worker be expected to endure threats or abuse as part of the job.</p><p>But ask the register what else it remembers.</p><p>In 2016, a Coles worker named Duncan Hart <a href="https://www.thenewdaily.com.au/news/2016/05/31/fair-work-commission-rule-coles">took his employer and his own union to the Fair Work Commission</a>. The SDA had signed off on a deal covering 77,000 Coles workers. The Commission found that it left a substantial number of them worse off than the award. On his own roster, Hart was <a href="https://www.inkl.com/news/coles-workplace-agreement-rejected-by-fair-work-commission">up to $2,504 a year behind</a>.</p><p>Out of those fights came <a href="https://greenleft.org.au/2026/1460/analysis/stand-raffwu-oppose-vic-labors-anti-association-bill">a small union run by young retail workers</a>. Two weeks after Carroll took the premiership, his government <a href="https://www.premier.vic.gov.au/stopping-workers-being-scammed-and-stamping-out-hate">introduced a bill</a> to allow Consumer Affairs to wind it up. It sailed through the lower house in sixteen days. It stalled in the upper house and <a href="https://www.legislation.vic.gov.au/bills/associations-incorporation-reform-amendment-bill-2026">died there</a> when Parliament was dissolved for the election.</p><p>The shop. The shop’s union. The party. All on the same side of the counter.</p><p>Lock up the hungry.</p><p>Now ask the parties what they would do.</p><p>Labor’s answer is already on patrol. <a href="https://www.premier.vic.gov.au/sites/default/files/2026-03/260301-Police-Operation-To-Put-PSOs-In-Shopping-Centres-Extended.pdf">“We have new solutions to keep you safe,”</a> then premier Jacinta Allan announced in March, “with PSOs in shopping centres, violence reduction in our schools, and Adult Time in the law.”</p><p>Carroll has funded <a href="https://www.premier.vic.gov.au/more-psos-more-place-more-often">150 more PSOs</a> and extended Operation Pulse, with patrols reaching further into suburban shopping strips.</p><p>The Liberals want to outbid them. A year ago, Brad Battin promised, <a href="https://www.sheppnews.com.au/?p=287252">“My government will put PSOs into shopping malls.”</a> Jess Wilson’s <a href="https://ourplan.au/">plan</a> promises PSOs back at 119 stations, with 200 more recruited. This month she promised to <a href="https://www.abc.net.au/news/2026-11-01/victorian-election-pledges-one-month-countdown/107332070">fast-track the same orders</a> Carroll announced at Kmart.</p><p>One Nation promises Victoria will become <a href="https://www.newcastleherald.com.au/story/9361894/real-change-election-pledge-for-one-nation/">Australia’s toughest state on crime</a>. It <a href="https://thenightly.com.au/politics/victoria-one-nation-state-leader-warren-pickering-pledges-open-books-despite-costings-secrecy-c-23102130">won’t say what that costs</a>.</p><p>Do I hear 250?</p><p>Count the guards. Then count the policies on the price of bread.</p><p>Only the Greens have asked the Parliamentary Budget Office to <a href="https://greens.org.au/vic/news/media-release/fastest-rent-hikes-australia-show-why-victoria-needs-rent-caps-saving">cost a rent freeze</a>. The major parties are arguing over who can put more uniforms between the hungry and the shelves.</p><p>Not one of them proposes to post a PSO at 800 Toorak Road.</p><p>A uniform can intervene in a theft. It cannot make the rent affordable, turn casual employment into secure work or put breakfast on a child’s table.</p><p>Hunger is certain, and no sentence has ever cured it. A woman who steals nappies because the rent took the nappy money will steal them again next month. The rent will still be $600.</p><p>Now the public purse, which pays for the guards and could pay for the bread.</p><p>There is money in Victoria. There is always money in Victoria. The interesting question is who gets to spend it, who gets to waste it, and who gets told there isn’t enough.</p><p>The royal commission into the Big Build spent its <a href="https://thenightly.com.au/australia/victoria/victorian-big-build-royal-commission-opens-on-an-embarrassing-note-for-labor-government-c-23135604">first week of evidence on one level crossing</a>: Gap Road, Sunbury. It examined a CFMEU stoppage there in June 2022 and the meeting that followed at union headquarters. Ben Carroll had promised that <a href="https://www.narrominenewsonline.com.au/story/9334423/nothing-left-off-limits-in-big-build-royal-commission/">nothing would be off limits</a>.</p><p>The commission heard that briefings prepared for the minister, Jacinta Allan, warned that paying the union’s rates for traffic management across the Big Build would cost <a href="https://abc.net.au/news/2026-11-14/big-build-cfmeu-royal-commission-gap-road-hearings/107385614">well over $400 million</a>. That is the bill for minding the gap. Nobody has yet been asked who ordered it. Even fewer will be asked how we are going to pay for it.</p><p>It heard that a senior Rail Projects Victoria official, Peter Wilkinson, received <a href="https://www.wellingtontimes.com.au/story/9391178/builders-warned-over-cfmeu-by-ex-premiers-office/">“feedback from the minister’s office”</a> through the then chief executive, Evan Tattersall: if the rail alliance, John Holland and CPB, couldn’t handle the industrials in Victoria, it couldn’t expect any more state work. Wilkinson took that to mean Allan’s office. He passed the message to the alliance manager, Joe Aygur.</p><p>Aygur’s evidence was consistent on the substance. He recalled being told of <a href="https://www.abc.net.au/news/2026-11-11/big-build-royal-commission-hears-allegations-of-cfmeu-pressure-/107374712">a view in government, from the minister’s office</a>. A former union organiser, Paul Tzimas, separately recalled his colleague Joe Myles telling the builders that the union had a “direct line” to Allan’s office. Myles is also alleged to have said the union’s influence could cost them future work, <a href="https://www.wellingtontimes.com.au/story/9391178/builders-warned-over-cfmeu-by-ex-premiers-office/">the Airport Rail Link included</a>.</p><p>On the evidence so far, the message that brought the alliance to heel was important enough to travel through two layers of senior public servants and into a commercial decision worth millions of dollars. Yet somehow it left no fingerprint. No note. No email. No name. The pivotal meeting of 7 June 2022 left no reliable record of what was agreed. When the government’s own delivery authority handed over its notebook on the stoppage, <a href="https://abc.net.au/news/2026-11-14/big-build-cfmeu-royal-commission-gap-road-hearings/107385614">the pages were blacked out</a>. Convenient. The commission still has to find whose hand, if any, wrote it.</p><p>Fair pay is not in dispute. What is in dispute is whether union mates got better rates through avenues of access unavailable to other labour sources.</p><p>Allan <a href="https://www.theage.com.au/politics/victoria/bend-the-knee-rail-alliance-told-make-peace-with-union-or-never-work-in-melbourne-again-20261113-p61dwn.html">has denied</a> seeking to pressure the alliance to give way to the union. <a href="https://www.theage.com.au/politics/victoria/do-deal-or-lose-work-minister-s-office-freeze-out-threat-to-builder-over-union-disputes-20261110-p61d09.html">Her spokesman says</a> she will answer whatever questions the commission puts to her. The allegations remain allegations, and the commission has yet to determine what happened.</p><p>On Monday the commission did not sit. It was reading documents the government had handed over late. The premier who promised that nothing would be off limits <a href="https://www.theage.com.au/politics/victoria/premier-angry-documents-withheld-from-commission-as-minister-denies-briefing-claims-20261116-p61egr.html">says he is angry</a>.</p><p>The report is due on <a href="https://theconversation.com/what-we-learnt-on-the-first-day-of-victorias-big-build-royal-commission-292673">20 August 2027</a>. The election is on 28 November 2026.</p><p>Robert Redlich, the former IBAC commissioner, says the commission must <a href="https://www.abc.net.au/news/2026-07-29/victoria-royal-commission-construction-big-build-ben-carroll/106972514">start where the problems started</a>. In August, he and Deborah Glass, the former ombudsman, <a href="https://www.theage.com.au/politics/victoria/integrity-experts-urge-royal-commission-to-look-beyond-crooks-to-deeper-problem-20260821-p60qdk.html">urged it to look beyond the crooks on site</a> to the government’s own failures. No proper business case. No consultation. No transparency. Their absence, they said, “contributed to the risk of corruption and misconduct”.</p><p>Take the Suburban Rail Loop. Labor took it to the 2018 election and won. A mandate, its defenders say.</p><p>“We won elections, for Chrissake,” one Labor insider told <a href="https://www.themonthly.com.au/november-2026/essays/deep-valley">Dr Margaret Simons</a>.</p><p>Glass, who <a href="https://www.ombudsman.vic.gov.au/our-impact/news/creeping-politicisation-of-public-sector-a-reality-in-victoria-ombudsman/">examined the loop as ombudsman</a>, asks what kind of mandate it is “when the public didn’t know the key facts”. It was conceived in secret, without a business case. Simons calls it grey corruption: not criminal, not in the public interest.</p><p>Where there is corruption, Glass says, there is always a loser. In Victoria it is the public purse.</p><p>Transurban <a href="https://www.theage.com.au/politics/victoria/integrity-experts-urge-royal-commission-to-look-beyond-crooks-to-deeper-problem-20260821-p60qdk.html">pitched the West Gate Tunnel</a> in 2015 at $5 billion, with no cost to the state. It cost $10 billion, and Victoria paid $4 billion of it. The North East Link was costed at $10 billion. Its projected cost has since risen to $26 billion.</p><p>Every billion borrowed for a blowout carries interest. What the state then finds for a food bank, a rent subsidy or a public house is a choice, and Victoria’s governments have made theirs.</p><p>Canberra, which <a href="https://michaelwest.com.au/david-littleproud-co-balancing-the-budget-like-a-74-scout-jamboree-raffle/">issues the currency</a>, could fill the gap tomorrow. That is a choice too.</p><p>The purse is held in trust. The hungry hold the first claim on it. It is not a party’s to rifle.</p><p>Now count everyone who had no say in 2022.</p><p>More than one eligible Victorian in a hundred <a href="https://www.parliament.vic.gov.au/news/general-news/voting-begins/">wasn’t on the roll</a>. One enrolled voter in eight didn’t vote, <a href="https://parliament.vic.gov.au/4ac97d/contentassets/635f48542714461cb587013aad2ab765/emc-60-01_conduct-of-the-2022-vic-state-election_vol-1.pdf">the lowest turnout since 1945</a>. <a href="https://www.vec.vic.gov.au/about-us/publications/annual-reports/selections/victorian-state-election-2022">One ballot in eighteen was informal</a>, with the rate highest in the northern and western suburbs.</p><p>Put together, nearly one eligible Victorian in five, about 800,000 people, cast no vote that counted. Those missing from the electoral process were <a href="https://theconversation.com/renters-hold-the-key-to-low-voter-turn-out-at-federal-elections-120494">disproportionately young and renting</a>. Some had simply moved house and dropped off the roll.</p><p>Labor won <a href="https://new.parliament.vic.gov.au/49c714/globalassets/images/news/library-papers/2023_2_the2022victorianstateelection_rp.pdf">56 of 88 seats that year on 37 percent of the primary vote</a>.</p><p>So every party chases the voter who still turns up and still counts: older, mortgaged, frightened of the shopping centre car park. Yet Millennials and Gen Z are now <a href="https://www.mudgeeguardian.com.au/story/8949501/">nearly half the national electorate</a>. Every party can count.</p><p>The PSO vote turns up. The hungry, mostly, don’t.</p><p>And those who do turn up?</p><p>In Prahran and Caulfield, Labor is running <a href="https://www.portnews.com.au/story/9389609/unforgivable-greens-cry-labor-preference-hypocrisy/">an open ticket</a>. It asks for a 1 and says nothing about who comes next. After months of warning about a Liberal and One Nation government, it will not tell its own voters to put a Green ahead of a Liberal.</p><p>The Greens’ leader called it unforgivable. A voter in Prahran could be forgiven for asking what a Labor vote is for.</p><p>A precariat that does turn up to vote for more of this is a mob of turkeys voting for Christmas.</p><p>Don’t blame the turkeys. Both parties that can form government are offering them Christmas.</p><p>Lock up the hungry, then. Lock up every one of them.</p><p>The bread will still be dear.</p><p><em>Part 3 of 3 on the Victorian election. Part 1: </em><a href="https://urbanwronski.com/2026/11/13/witch-ditch-born-to-rule-itch-allan-labor/"><em>The Witch, the Ditch and the Born to Rule Itch</em></a><em>. Part 2: </em><a href="https://urbanwronski.com/2026/11/15/law-and-order-by-mail-jess-wilson/"><em>Law and Order by Mail</em></a><em>.</em></p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://urbanwronski.com/2026/11/16/lock-up-the-hungry/"><em>http://urbanwronski.com</em></a><em> on November 16, 2026.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b2655bea0696" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Personal Adviser Nobody Asked For]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@davidtyler258/the-personal-adviser-nobody-asked-for-208ab2d7310d?source=rss-1a6164dd1449------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/208ab2d7310d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[david-farley]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[clarke-and-dawe]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[satire]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pauline-hanson]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[David Tyler]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 04 Nov 2026 13:00:19 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-11-05T05:42:37.427Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/440/0*tDqiGwZvFx-hj10K" /></figure><p><em>With gratitude to John Clarke and Bryan Dawe. Clarke plays a senior official in the Prime Minister’s office with responsibility for parliamentary staffing. He has a stack of envelopes.</em></p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> Thanks for your time.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Pleasure, Bryan. Would you like an adviser?</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> No thanks.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Suit yourself. The offer’s there.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> On Monday the 26th of October the Prime Minister wrote to the One Nation MP David Farley.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Lovely letter, Bryan. Beautifully set out. Helvetica.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> Helvetica?</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Swiss font, Bryan. Strictly neutral. Discreet. Almost gnomic.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> It gave him a Personal Adviser 3, paid up to $200,000.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Effective immediately. We don’t muck around. It’s the quick and the very dead in Canberra.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> He didn’t ask for one.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> That’s the beauty of it. Most people have to ask.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> Pauline Hanson has been asking.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Has she?</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> She wrote to the Prime Minister on the 4th of February.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> We got that one.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> And on the 11th of August.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Got that one too. They’re both in a very safe place. She hasn’t written another, has she?</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> No. She’s had no reply.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Well, you can’t go handing out staff to just anyone and his dog who asks, Bryan. Where would it end? We’ve got a subsidised staff cafeteria to run, you know. They call it the Trough.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> One Nation says it has 0.83 staff per parliamentarian. Labor has 4.09.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> That’s right. Allocated strictly on need.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> Who decides the need?</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> The Prime Minister.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> How does he decide?</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> He looks at the whole person, Bryan.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> Murray Watt says One Nation wants staff based on how it’s going in the opinion polls.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Disgraceful. Staff go on seats, Bryan. Not polls.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> One Nation is ahead of Labor in Newspoll.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Which is exactly why we go on seats.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> The Prime Minister has met Mr Farley privately several times in recent weeks.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Getting to know him. Pastoral care. Property portfolios and super don’t just grow themselves, Bryan. Ask anyone on the frontbench.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> One Nation says the Prime Minister started those meetings.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Well, someone had to. He’s new to this caper, Bryan. Granted, Dave’s got a bit of wealth in assets, but when it comes to the politics of the Trough, he’s a total ingénu.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> One Nation says senior ministers then raised grant money for the Murray Darling Basin.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> The Sustainable Communities Program. Terrific program.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> Mr Farley’s electorate is in the Murray Darling Basin.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Is it? Isn’t he a lucky fella, then.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> The day after the letter, the government announced $50 million in Murray Darling grants.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Completely separate, Bryan. Another day. Another dollar.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> Before that it gave $14.5 million to a rice cake factory in Leeton.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Rice cakes? Ever had one of those sticky rice cakes? Export quality, sticky, Bryan. Wonderful product.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> Leeton is in Mr Farley’s electorate.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Is it? Gee, he’s a lucky fella, Bryan. Some blokes have all the luck.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> A minister says Pauline Hanson is jumping at shadows.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Quite right. There are no shadows, Bryan. It’s all done in broad daylight. On embossed letterhead. Cream wove, Bryan. Top quality. Heavy-duty special-occasion stationery.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> Why Mr Farley?</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Very experienced man. Ran a big cattle company.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> He was a member of the New South Wales Nationals from 2015 to 2020.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Say that again?</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> The New South Wales Nationals.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> The National Party of New South Wales. The oxymoron? You don’t know how funny that sounds. But all jokes aside, and you know it’s all dags and gags at the Nationals, the funny bone of Australian politics, we’ve all been up the old Faraway Tree. We can’t hold that against him.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> He was a financial member for five years.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> But did he know he was a member?</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> He let it lapse in 2020.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Easy done.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> He applied to join the Labor Party.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> He didn’t, did he? You are having me on.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> Labor knocked him back.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> We had a lot on at the time.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> In 2023 he gave $100 to Labor’s campaign in the Aston by-election.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> And we won Aston, Bryan. That’s the sort of return we like to see.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> He praised the independent he later ran against.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Open mind.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> He said shopping around for a party was like going to the gym.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Except you don’t sniff another member’s chair when you go to the gym. But that was Troy Buswell. And you do realise we’re talking about WA?</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> It was a staffer’s chair.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Still, a man has to keep himself fit, in and out of modern politics.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> In August he walked into a meeting of Liberal backbenchers.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Easy mistake. All those doors look the same.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> On the way out he said, “I could see myself sitting here.”</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Far-sighted Farley, they call him.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> He’s in One Nation.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> At the moment, yes.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> He told Insiders One Nation’s migration plan was “not too different” from Labor’s.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> See? He gets it.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> He said he’d display three flags in his office.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Very inclusive.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> Then he said there was “one flag that unites every Australian.”</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Flexible, Bryan. You can’t put a price on that.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> You put $200,000 on it.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Up to, Bryan. Up to $200,000.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> Mr Farley turned it down.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Well, we don’t muck around, Bryan. Farley’s the one who’s fart-arsing around. Too big for his utes.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> He called it unsolicited.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Lovely word.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> On Sunday the 1st of November Murray Watt said the government was responding to a request Mr Farley made.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> That’s right.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> Mr Farley says he never asked.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> He asked by not asking, Bryan. We’re very attentive. We pick these things up.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> So which is it? Requested or unsolicited?</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Both, Bryan. That’s what makes it a Personal Adviser 3.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> Mr Farley also said it was a staffer he needs.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Need, Bryan. I told you. Strictly on need.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> He said he didn’t want to end up in something like the Marrickville Golf Club grant.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Lovely club. Very working class.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> It got $6 million.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Through a very rigorous process.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> It was invitation only.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Which is very rigorous. You just can’t rock on up.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> The Prime Minister is an honorary member.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> He didn’t know, Bryan.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> He said the money would stop raw sewage going into the Cooks River.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Very important river. Huge environmental significance.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> Officials told Senate Estimates the grant had nothing to do with sewage.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> And the Prime Minister has since clarified that.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> He said, “it was not correct.”</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Which is correct.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> Barnaby Joyce got the same position when he joined One Nation.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Standard welcome pack, Bryan. Lanyard, parking spot, Personal Adviser 3. And the beer mug, the Toby jug in the shape of the leader in a burqa, and a plaque that says you can’t take the piss out of Pauline.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> On the 15th of October One Nation tried to send its staffing bill to a Senate inquiry.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> We couldn’t support that.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> Labor, the Greens and the Coalition all voted against it.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Rare show of unity, Bryan. Tells you how important the principle is.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> What principle?</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> That the Prime Minister decides.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> Murray Watt says One Nation is controlled by unelected, shadowy figures.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Shocking, Bryan. Shocking.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> Who advises the Prime Minister on staffing?</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> I do, Bryan.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> Were you elected?</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Not as such. But I’m not shadowy. I’m on embossed letterhead. That’s top-shelf stationery, Bryan. And boss cocky.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> Thanks for your time.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Pleasure. Here, Bryan. What are you on at the moment?</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> I’m not leaving the ABC.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Nobody said anything about leaving. Could you see yourself sitting here?</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> Where?</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Here. Nice chair. Two hundred thousand. Effective immediately.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> I didn’t ask.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> That’s the beauty of it, Bryan. We’ll put you down as a request.</p><p><em>A tribute to John Clarke (1948 to 2017), whose method this borrows and whose genius it cannot. With thanks to Bryan Dawe.</em> <em>The Clarke and Dawe format and characters remain the work and property of John Clarke (Roderick Willows Pty Ltd) and Bryan Dawe. This sketch is an independent homage, written and published by Urban Wronski, and is not affiliated with or endorsed by them.</em></p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://urbanwronski.com/2026/11/05/personal-adviser-nobody-asked-for-clarke-and-dawe/"><em>http://urbanwronski.com</em></a><em> on November 4, 2026.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=208ab2d7310d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Copy, Paste, Cut]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@davidtyler258/copy-paste-cut-f8b8e2a10b31?source=rss-1a6164dd1449------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f8b8e2a10b31</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[algorithms]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[automated-assessment]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[aged-care]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ndis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[integrated-assmt-tool]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[David Tyler]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 01 Nov 2026 09:29:53 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-11-01T10:23:33.315Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/440/0*oh238pL0wPjE-h9G" /></figure><p><em>“The aged care algorithm left a woman close to death and baffled the department that built it. The same department is now installing its match in the NDIS.”</em></p><p>“Basically a copy and paste.”</p><p>Those are the words of a top mandarin who sat through the government’s confidential briefing on its new NDIS budget tool. Not a Greens senator. Not an advocate with a placard. A public servant. Rick Morton got them on the record, and broke the story, in <a href="https://www.thesaturdaypaper.com.au/news/health/2026/10/31/exclusive-confidential-briefing-reveals-ndis-copy-and-paste">The Saturday Paper</a> on 31 October.</p><p>The catastrophic error being assiduously copied is the Integrated Assessment Tool, the algorithm that has decided since November 2025 how much help an older Australian gets to stay in their own home. Or not.</p><p>Commonwealth Ombudsman Iain Anderson published his verdict on it on 26 October. It reads like a coroner’s preliminary.</p><p>The machine’s decisions, he found, cannot be overridden by a human, “even if they are clinically inappropriate”. The emphasis is his.</p><p>Assessors were told otherwise. So was the public. Up to the eve of the new Act, the department kept assuring both that a person could step in. The law it had written gave nobody that power.</p><p>The department, Anderson found, “did not, and may still not, understand key components of the legal framework it created”. It was not even sure what law it had been asked to write.</p><p>The secretary, Blair Comley, puts it down to “the misunderstanding within the department”. A misunderstanding, in this case, with the force of law.</p><p>The assessors did win one concession. During the trials, the ombudsman notes, they told the department that writing their own notes was “very important”. So they got a box for notes. The algorithm never opens it. Whatever goes in “is not considered by the algorithm”.</p><p>Picture the nurse at your kitchen table. She writes that you can’t get up from the chair without two goes at it. She writes that the pill organiser is a week out of order. Every word goes into the box.</p><p>The box goes nowhere.</p><p>Copy.</p><p>One case sits in the report like a stone. An older woman could not do without a nurse or carer calling in to give her vital medication. The machine filed her under medium priority. She ended up in hospital and very nearly died, so slow was the response to her need.</p><p>Paste.</p><p>Now the NDIS. From 1 April 2027, a bit of commedia dell’arte worthy of Dario Fo, the “Reasonable and Necessary Budget Method”, starts setting disability budgets. Once it has spoken, nobody on the public payroll will be able to change its answer either.</p><p>Not even the tribunal. <a href="https://michaelwest.com.au/i-cannot-the-black-box-algorithm-deciding-funding-for-the-disabled/">Michael West Media reports</a> that the Administrative Review Tribunal changed 73 percent of the NDIS decisions it finalised in 2024–25. Under the new Act it can only send you back to the same machine for another go.</p><p>Nobody gets a word in. Your own doctors and therapists, your family, friends, the people who actually know you, the ones keeping you alive, can write what they like. The formula is built to ditch their reports at the door. And beware. Your nearest and dearest, a supportive family could cost you dearly. Officials who have seen the draft rules told Morton they mandate “discounting” wherever the rules detect “24/7 family care”.</p><p>If your family is home, the machine books them as staff. Unpaid. Unrostered. Never off sick.</p><p>The questionnaire that feeds the formula is called I-CAN. Sam Arnold, an academic in Western Sydney University’s psychology school, helped develop it. Writing with the campaigner George Taleporos, Arnold now says he is “concerned” by the “apparent diminution” of clinical judgement. A GP’s letter can go unread.</p><p>When a “client’s” needs are tangled, or shift from week to week, they argue, a clinician’s report is “not a luxury”. It is “a safeguard”.</p><p>The man who helped build the instrument is warning you about the xerox machine it has been bolted to.</p><p>Copy. Paste.</p><p>The official charge sheet reads consistency and transparency. Nobody would be singled out, the department’s salesman assured the states. Every budget would be “worked out in the same way”.</p><p>A Victorian official interrupted. “Why don’t you just say this is about saving money?”</p><p>Nobody said it. Nobody needed to. The budget papers say it for them.</p><p>The NDIS package is meant to claw back $37.8 billion in four years, and something like $170 billion inside a decade. By the Grattan Institute’s count, that one package supplies about 60 percent of all the savings and reprioritisations in the May budget.</p><p>Aged care has been pulling its weight too. Talk about taut, trim and terrific.</p><p>In 2025–26 the government spent $1.4 billion less on aged care than it had budgeted. The Final Budget Outcome blames “provider capacity constraints”, which is Treasury for not enough carers. The deficit came in $6 billion better than forecast. Finance Minister Katy Gallagher felt she should spell it out to the press: “This really relates to a few programs spending less, so in aged care, PBS, across the childcare system.”</p><p>In the same year, 6,436 people died waiting for the home care the government had assessed them as needing. That is up 34 percent on the year before. The two figures are not strictly comparable: Support at Home replaced the old home care packages in November 2025.</p><p>The caveat is true. It does not make the number smaller.</p><p>The deficit improved. So it goes.</p><p>When home care fails, the bill turns up in a state hospital bed. <a href="https://www.theweeklysource.com.au/tasmania-and-south-australia-see-stranded-patients-waiting-for-aged-care-hit-new-highs/">South Australia spent $123.7 million last year</a> caring for older patients stranded in hospital waiting for aged care: $1,318 a day each, against about $320 a day for an aged care bed. Queensland has taken to the airwaves and the papers to tell Canberra so. The NDIS plan plays the same game on a different ledger: the states are expected to rebuild the disability services they wound down when the scheme arrived.</p><p>Then there is the consultation. It is a pea and thimble act.</p><p>Canberra invited people with disability to say how the budget rules ought to work. But the rules were already written. In early October Leo Hardiman, a former senior lawyer at the Australian Government Solicitor and now with consultancy SPA Australia, took the states through them.</p><p>SPA is being paid $948,000 for his legal work.</p><p>Seven days later, the window for public comment shut. The public never saw a word of the draft. You were invited to guess which thimble hid the pea. The pea was in Canberra’s pocket all along.</p><p>The department’s answer is that the NDIS Amendment Act 2026 lets computers handle only “limited administrative functions, such as payments and claims or how a participant’s plan is organised”.</p><p>Watch the hands. A person’s budget is how their plan is organised. Calling the machine that sets it an administrative function is bare-faced equivocation. By the same logic a guillotine is a hat adjustment.</p><p>Both machines answer to one minister, Mark Butler, and one department. Butler holds the two portfolios the way a liquidator holds both sets of books. Tight in the scrum. Roy and HG would call it the squirrel grip.</p><p>In May, a po-faced Butler told The Australian’s The Front podcast that the lessons of Robodebt were “front of mind”. The government would be careful, he said, to make sure “that humans are always in the loop in making important decisions”.</p><p>In the aged care loop, the ombudsman found, “a human decision-maker does not decide” who qualifies or how urgent their need is. The machine does. The human is in the loop. The loop is closed.</p><p>The ombudsman also found the aged care tool fails Recommendations 17.1 and 17.2 of the Robodebt Royal Commission, the ones on transparency in automated decisions. Labor called that royal commission.</p><p>Parliament tried to fix the aged care machine. In July the Senate passed Anne Ruston’s bill to restore human override, with only Labor voting against. Labor’s majority killed it in the House. In August the Senate called for the tool to be scrapped altogether.</p><p>The ombudsman’s first recommendation was a law letting assessors put their own judgement in place of the machine’s. The department’s reply form offers three boxes: Accepted (in principle), Not accepted, Noted. It ticked Noted.</p><p>What Parliament got instead, <a href="https://www.theweeklysource.com.au/first-nations-aged-care-commissioner-and-iat-escalation-pathway-become-law-with-expiry-date/">on 15 October, with Coalition votes</a>, was the government’s “escalation pathway”. From January 2027, hard cases go back up to the department whose machine got them wrong. The pathway comes with a sunset clause: it covers decisions made only until the end of 2027. For the NDIS, nothing at all.</p><p>I know a man who has met this machine. He is 78, lives in Western Victoria and stands high in his community. I have known him all my life.</p><p>He appealed his assessment. Forty-five days later, an email arrived. It was signed by no one, only by a Review of Decisions Section. It promised to write again with the outcome. Then it explained what happens if it doesn’t. If no decision reaches him within ninety days, the reviewer “is taken to affirm” the original decision. It did not mention the Administrative Review Tribunal, the one door the law leaves open.</p><p>Silence is the decision. Nobody has to sign it. A reviewer who reviews nothing is taken to agree. It is the system in its purest form: a refusal with no author.</p><p>At the side-show of Senate estimates, a public servant can take you on notice and put you on hold, forever. Taken on notice. Taken to affirm. It is the orchestrated hold music of an ever more autocratic and remote mandarin prefecture in a Phrygian cap.</p><p>A state official put it to Morton plainly. “They can’t say they weren’t warned.”</p><p>They were warned by the ombudsman. They were warned by the Senate, twice. They were warned by the states in their own briefing, and by the academic whose questionnaire they bought. They were warned by 6,436 empty chairs.</p><p>Copy. Paste.</p><p>Call it what it is. This was never copy and paste.</p><p>It was cut.</p><p>The department promises a “root cause analysis”. It need not look far. Its secretary has already written down the finding.</p><p>“The Government decided in 2024.”</p><p><em>This column stands on Rick Morton’s reporting, “Exclusive: Confidential briefing reveals NDIS copy and paste”, in The Saturday Paper of 31 October 2026. He broke the story. “Basically a copy and paste” are the words of the official he interviewed, and every quotation from the October briefing comes from his reporting, used here with full attribution for comment and satire. The ombudsman’s findings are from the ombudsman’s own report, Katy Gallagher’s words from the Treasury transcript. Further reporting from Michael West Media and The Weekly SOURCE is linked in the text. The jokes, and the anger, are mine. Read Morton in full. Better still, subscribe.</em></p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://urbanwronski.com/2026/11/01/copy-paste-cut/"><em>http://urbanwronski.com</em></a><em> on November 1, 2026.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f8b8e2a10b31" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[One Nation, Three Shareholders]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@davidtyler258/one-nation-three-shareholders-36eff7a073c8?source=rss-1a6164dd1449------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/36eff7a073c8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[australian-politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[one-nation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[political-donations]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pauline-hanson]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tony-abbott]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[David Tyler]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 20 Oct 2026 21:00:16 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-21T00:25:07.981Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/439/0*zKJqlpQ4brQ7C09h" /></figure><p><em>This is the second part of a series. A note of candour: part one promised the mining paddock. In researching and fact-checking this instalment, the author found the Two Davids needed a part of their own. Hugh Morgan, Mabo and the miners’ money come in part three. First, the men who built the shed.</em></p><h3>Nobody’s Business</h3><p>In the winter of 1998 a Liberal MP rose in the House of Representatives to warn the nation about a liar. Two liars, in fact. Or three, if you count Tony, as he did, to Kerry O’Brien on the ABC 17 May 2010.</p><p>“I say in this parliament that Oldfield and Ettridge are chronic and habitual liars,” Tony Abbott told the adjournment debate on 1 July 1998.</p><p>One of the liars had been his chief adviser.</p><p>Abbott had more.</p><p>“The puppet master might have withdrawn behind the curtains, but he is clearly still pulling the strings.” David Oldfield, he said, was “using Pauline Hanson as his personal Trojan horse to enter the Senate.”</p><p>Then Abbott read into Hansard a line from the other David, as reported in The Australian. Why could One Nation’s members not see the party’s membership details? David Ettridge had the answer.</p><p>“It’s nobody’s business but ours.”</p><p>Nobody’s business. Remember the phrase. One Nation was built on it.</p><p>Much of what follows was said in the House, under privilege, by a man who had hired one of them. Weigh it accordingly. Then weigh what the courts and the cheques say.</p><h3>The Two Davids</h3><p>Part one showed a party assembled by a Liberal staffer, a marketing man and a mailing list. Sheer genius. No Allen key required. Meet the assembly crew.</p><p>David Oldfield was a Manly man. He ran a diving shop, sat on Manly Council from 1991 and joined Tony Abbott’s staff in April 1994, soon after Abbott won Warringah. He rose to be Abbott’s chief adviser. In 1995 he stood as the Liberal candidate for the state seat of Manly and lost to an independent by 243 votes.</p><p>Wouldn’t it rot your socks?</p><p>Two hundred and forty-three votes. Australian politics can turn on a dime.</p><p>David Ettridge was a different kettle of flathead. Born in Adelaide in 1945, though exactly where nobody seems able to say, he sold himself as a marketing man. Ask where the money came from, and the story slips through your fingers. In 1998 World Vision’s name came up. “I did not receive any money from World Vision,” Ettridge told the Australian Financial Review. World Vision, he said, had contracted with a company called Global Communications. He was merely “an overseas principal”. The owner was “Mr Ross Boland who is an expatriate living in Vanuatu.”</p><p>Abbott’s office rang World Vision. Yes, it had paid Global Communications, which Abbott called Ettridge’s company. Every cheque had gone to PO Box 775 in Manly. “World Vision did not send cheques to Vanuatu,” Abbott said. He asked the corporate regulator to investigate whether the Vanuatu company was “a device to get around Australian bankruptcy law”. I can find no record that anything came of it.</p><p>Every age gets the impresario it deserves. Ours came with a post office box in Manly and a principal in Vanuatu, and he sold a woman from an Ipswich fish and chip shop to eighteen thousand people who never once got to see the books.</p><p>Ettridge knew how to persuade strangers to part with money for a cause they would never control. It is a knack that serves people well at the top in the land of Oz: in politics, society and the corporate boardroom.</p><p>Oldfield brought the politics. Ettridge brought the till. Hanson brought the face, the voice, and two words that captured a nation: “Please explain.” Has any party ever been so profoundly well-endowed at birth?</p><p>Peter Archer, once a One Nation organiser in New South Wales, summed up the division of labour. Abbott quoted him: “Oldfield is in it for power, Ettridge is in it for money and Hanson is in it for ego.”</p><p>That is not my verdict. It is the verdict of a man who ran one of their branches.</p><h3>A Club With No Members</h3><p>Groucho Marx famously opined that he would not join any club that would have him as a member. It’s a gag you can hear him trying on at the Pearly Gates. One Nation solved Groucho’s dilemma. Everyone was welcome but no-one was ever really a member.</p><p>Under Ettridge, a crew set up about 350 branches and signed up about 18,000 members. Members of what, exactly, kept lawyers busy for six years. On paper, as Hansard records for 2 July 1998, the party’s management committee had “complete and total control”. It had three members: Hanson, Ettridge and Oldfield. Behind it stood One Nation Ltd, a company with three directors and five members. Everyone else was an affiliate who paid fees and had no role.</p><p>Branch office holders had to sign a “pledge of loyalty” and an undated resignation letter. The letters were not decorative. Six members had already been removed with them.</p><p>The faithful paid their subs. They letterboxed. They sat in draughty halls from Gympie to the Hunter Valley. They thought they had joined a people’s movement. They had joined a customer base.</p><p>It’s nobody’s business but ours.</p><h3>Follow the Subs</h3><p>The price of admission was modest. The Queensland Court of Appeal later set out the tiers. Full membership cost “of the order of $40/$50”. For $5 you could become a “Pauline Hanson One Nation supporter”, with no voting rights at all.</p><p>Five dollars and no vote. In a democracy the vote comes free. One Nation charged you for its absence.</p><p>The seed money was small. By his own account, Bruce Whiteside’s support movement had about 6,000 members, 40 branches and some $12,000 in the kitty by February 1997, the month it was taken over.</p><p>The harvest was not. After One Nation’s eleven seats in June 1998, Queensland paid Hanson, as the party’s agent, $225,000 on 2 September and another $274,000 three weeks later. Close to half a million dollars of public money. After the federal election in October, the Australian Electoral Commission paid One Nation just over $3 million, at $1.62 a vote.</p><p>Who minded the till? Not the members. Abbott also quoted the superbly named Ted Bricks, a former Queensland treasurer of the party who had resigned over its accounts. Bricks told the Sydney Morning Herald that donations of $5,000 and $7,000 had gone unreceipted, into “associated” accounts he could not identify. The financial records, he said, were “virtually non-existent”.</p><p>Abbott went further: Ettridge, he said, stood to collect 12.5 percent of any federal public funding. True or not, the members had no way of finding out.</p><p>The battlers bought the badges. The taxpayers bought the campaigns. Three people held the cash register.</p><h3>Official Charge, Real Offence</h3><p>Someone at last blew the whistle. In August 1999 the Queensland Supreme Court found One Nation had been wrongly registered: the names on its registration list belonged to the support movement, not the party.</p><p>In August 2003 a jury convicted Hanson and Ettridge of electoral fraud. Chief Judge Patsy Wolfe sentenced each of them to three years in jail, with no recommendation for parole. Hanson had been convicted, too, of dishonestly obtaining close to $500,000 in electoral funding.</p><p>They served eleven weeks. In November the Court of Appeal quashed both convictions and they walked free. The appeal judges found that the people on the list had more probably joined both the party and the support movement.</p><p>Ettridge says police had advised the prosecutors that no offence had been committed. Whatever the truth of that, the appeal court found the Crown could not prove its case.</p><p>Fair enough. Acquit them.</p><p>But look at what the acquittal leaves standing. The real offence was never illegal. It was the design. A party that sold memberships without a vote for $5, and memberships with one for $50 in an outfit where three people held “complete and total control”, is not a crime. No. It is a business model.</p><p>It’s nobody’s business but ours.</p><h3>Closing Time</h3><p>Business partnerships can end very badly. This one erupted like the front bar of an Oodnadatta pub at closing time, in the middle of a long, hot dry.</p><p>In February 1999 five of One Nation’s eleven Queensland MPs walked out, in protest at the executive’s iron grip and the influence of fringe far-right groups. They didn’t come back. In December they formed a party of their own. On 14 January 2000 Ettridge resigned all his posts, citing business opportunities in Asia. How did he keep a straight face? Asia is a big place.</p><p>Six days later police raided One Nation’s offices in Queensland and New South Wales.</p><p>Oldfield lasted until October 2000. Hanson accused him of abusing his authority, usurping power and setting up alternative parties under his control. When she had him expelled, Oldfield then proceeded to set up an alternative party under his control, “One Nation NSW”. Worse. In 2002 he registered it with the New South Wales Electoral Commission. Hanson’s own party could no longer use its name at state elections there.</p><p>He had not just learned the trade. He kept the shopfront. And the cash register.</p><h3>Where Are They Now</h3><p>Oldfield served out his term in the New South Wales upper house and moved into talkback radio. 2GB hired him in 2007. By 2009 he was Sydney’s top-rated overnight voice. 2GB let him go in 2010. 2UE took him on and suspended him three days later over a riff about asylum seekers: “We’ll turn on the electric fences, we’ll stop them from coming.”</p><p>In his memoir, Before You Judge Me, he wrote tenderly of the woman whose party he built: “I felt Pauline was never up to the job and failed miserably day after day.”</p><p>Ettridge went to jail with Hanson, came out with her, and spent years trying to get his money back. He paid for his own defence on the understanding that One Nation would repay him. It never did. In 2017 he told the ABC he had put a $150,000 claim to the party. The party rejected it and asked him to stop contacting it. Cease and desist. The case, he says, cost him his house.</p><p>His verdict on his old partner: “she is out of her depth, doesn’t really understand what she’s doing and how to do it.” The party, he said, had become “a Pauline Hanson dictatorship”.</p><p>Spare a thought for the man who once demanded pledges of loyalty from branch office holders. He has since learned what loyalty is worth in One Nation.</p><p>Ettridge did not stay out of politics. In 2014 AAP reported that Clive Palmer had sought him out at a Palmer United Party rally in an Adelaide hotel and floated a role in South Australia. Ettridge was by then a member of Palmer’s party. “Nothing bigger than a state role,” he said. The man who built a party for a fish and chip shop owner had found his way to one owned by a mining magnate.</p><h3>Payback</h3><p>In April 2013 Ettridge sued Tony Abbott for $1.5 million in the Queensland Supreme Court. He alleged Abbott had acted unlawfully in 1998 by backing the litigation that brought One Nation down. Abbott, then five months from becoming prime minister, told Canberra radio: “This is just a bit of payback.”</p><p>Ettridge also served papers on two of Abbott’s associates from the Australians for Honest Politics trust. By July he had withdrawn the Brisbane action, saying he would restart it in the Federal Court. No ruling has been reported.</p><p>Those two associates deserve a closer look.</p><p>Peter Coleman was a former Liberal MP, a former editor of Quadrant and the father-in-law of Peter Costello. Ettridge identified him as the man who wrote the trust’s cheques. Coleman later explained his motive in The Australian: “I saw One Nation as a threat not so much to civilisation as to the Coalition.”</p><p>Not so much to civilisation? Funny man.</p><p>Trevor Kennedy, a former Packer executive, gave the trust $10,000. His verdict on Hanson: “a great menace to this country, but a crook as well.”</p><p>The Court of Appeal disagreed with Mr Kennedy on the second count. On the first, history is still taking witness statements.</p><h3>Who Holds the Keys</h3><p>Here is the thread back to part one.</p><p>The establishment did not bring down One Nation to protect anyone from racism. Coleman said as much. It brought One Nation down to protect the Coalition’s vote. John “Children Overboard” Howard kept the tune anyway.</p><p>The template outlived its founders. A party owned by a handful. Funded by people who get no say. Led by someone who answers to no branch. In 1997 the money came from battlers paying their subs. In 2026 it comes from Hancock men in half-million-dollar lots, and a plane.</p><p>Ettridge built a machine that takes money from people who will never control it. Thirty years on, it takes money from people who have no need to.</p><p>Three people held the keys in 1997. Two were shown the door. One still has them.</p><p>“It’s nobody’s business but ours,” said David Ettridge.</p><p>He was half right. It was always a business.</p><p>But it was never ours.</p><p><em>Coming in part three: the paddock. In October 1992 a mining chief warned that Mabo had put property rights at risk “throughout the whole community”. Four years later, a woman from an Ipswich fish and chip shop rose in Parliament to sing the same tune. Who taught it to her, and who has been paying for the encore ever since?</em></p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://urbanwronski.com/2026/10/21/one-nation-three-shareholders/"><em>http://urbanwronski.com</em></a><em> on October 20, 2026.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=36eff7a073c8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Nobody Planted Pauline]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@davidtyler258/nobody-planted-pauline-d8ba7c433be1?source=rss-1a6164dd1449------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d8ba7c433be1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[hancock-prospecting]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gina-rinehart]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[advance]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pauline-hanson]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[one-nation]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[David Tyler]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 20 Oct 2026 04:01:16 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-20T08:26:59.753Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/440/0*GCLwh1ewqtospcT9" /></figure><p>On 2 March 1996, the voters of Oxley unfolded a ballot paper that was already out of date. Beside the name Pauline Hanson, former Ipswich councillor and co-owner of a fish and chip shop in Silkstone, it printed the word Liberal. By then she was nothing of the kind. The party had dumped her weeks earlier, but nominations had closed, and the paper stayed as printed.</p><p>It is the sort of curious accident that draws conspiracy theorists like blowflies to a long drop in summer. Yet Hanson’s rise was no plot. It was something more ordinary, and in the end more damning.</p><p>The Liberals had disendorsed her over a letter to the editor of The Queensland Times. In it she dismissed black deaths in custody, accused governments of creating racism and complained that Aboriginal people had it too easy. She also rehashed the front-bar myth about how little “Aboriginal blood” ran in the veins of those living high on the hog of government largesse. It is a gibe as risible, and as despicable, as the one about refugees handed houses by a grateful government counting on their votes. Votes they are not eligible to cast.</p><p>Oxley was Labor’s. It had been Bill Hayden’s seat for 27 years, and Labor had held it without a break since 1961. Hanson took it with 48.6 percent of the primary vote on a swing of nineteen percent. The “White Queen”, as David Marr would later call the MP whose career rests on racism, was on her way to Canberra.</p><p>See an invisible hand? A notorious racist is disendorsed just late enough to keep the brand on the ballot, then wins the one Queensland seat Labor could not lose. Cui bono, as our learned silks will say. Who benefits?</p><p>It is a fair question. It is not an answer. Cui bono is where an investigation starts, not where it ends. Reasoning backwards from a beneficiary to a plot is the oldest dodge in the conspiracy game: it happened, someone gained, therefore someone arranged it. It is motive mistaken for method, in a trench coat.</p><p>It’s not that late disendorsements rare. The Australia Institute counts them as part and parcel of our elections: dump a candidate once nominations have closed and your party’s name stays on the paper regardless, like the sauce stain on your shirt after a democracy sausage. Hanson was one of five independents elected that year, many of them refugees from a major party.</p><p>So which legend needs a cold shower? It runs like this: a plain-speaking Ipswich mum, armed with nothing but common sense and a vat of hot fat, built a political party with her own two hands. To serve other battlers. It is a good story, with the smell of vinegar and newsprint about it, and it has served her for thirty years.</p><p>But Hanson had a lot of help. And an abundance of funds from right wing sources. She still does.</p><p>Even “her” shop had a co-owner. The fish and chips came from Marsden’s Seafood, run through a company she shared with her business partner, Morrie Marsden, who went on to work on her 1996 campaign. In the legend, nobody mentions the sign over the door.</p><p>Within days of her win, Graeme Campbell, the maverick Western Australian MP Labor had just expelled, sent her one of his own staffers. John Pasquarelli became her adviser and press secretary, and has since claimed he wrote her maiden speech. She sacked her helper in December 1996, by which time, Green Left Weekly reported, he had been assembling a Hanson Senate ticket stacked with Campbell’s Australia First, Australians Against Further Immigration and the Australian League of Rights.</p><p>The League needed no invitation. In October 1996 its leader, Eric Butler, pledged Hanson “all possible support”, and the League paid to print and distribute tens of thousands of copies of her maiden speech.</p><p>That same month came the grassroots. Bruce Whiteside, a Gold Coast campaigner against Japanese investment and a former candidate for the far-right Confederate Action Party, founded the Pauline Hanson Support Movement. Branches sprang up across Queensland. Real people paid real subscriptions.</p><p>Enter the two Davids.</p><p>David Oldfield was a Manly councillor and a Liberal who had missed out on preselection. When he met Hanson he was working for Tony Abbott, and while still on Abbott’s payroll he began to build her a party. His partner in the venture was David Ettridge, a pro fundraiser whose career includes UNICEF and World Vision.</p><p>Early in 1997, as the University of Queensland’s archive records it, Hanson and her two advisers took over the Support Movement, expelled Whiteside and used its membership list to register a party. Pauline Hanson’s One Nation was launched at Ipswich on 11 April 1997.</p><p>The party itself had exactly three members: Hanson, Ettridge and Oldfield. The thousands who believed they had joined a people’s movement belonged to something else entirely. They paid the subs; three people held the keys.</p><p>Oldfield says that had he won Liberal preselection for Manly, he would never have met Hanson, and her party would not exist. Of the woman whose party he built, he later wrote:</p><p>“I felt Pauline was never up to the job and failed miserably day after day.”</p><p>Nobody planted Pauline Hanson. She was assembled, by a Liberal staffer, a charity fundraiser and a mailing list commandeered from the far right.</p><p>And for a while the kit worked. In June 1998 One Nation won eleven seats in the Queensland parliament with almost a quarter of the vote. The major parties panicked. If the Liberals had ever wanted her in Canberra, they now had an odd way of showing it.</p><p>Abbott’s former staffer had built the party; Abbott now set out to tear it down. In 1998 he set up a trust he called, with a straight face, Australians for Honest Politics. This is the same Tony Abbott who would later tell Kerry O’Brien that only his “carefully prepared scripted remarks” should be taken as “gospel truth”. The trust raised close to $100,000 from twelve donors Abbott declined to name, and its job, in his own words, was to fund court cases against One Nation. One donor was later outed: Harold Clough, West Australian construction magnate, Liberal donor and board member of the Institute of Public Affairs.</p><p>By the federal election of October 1998, two years after her maiden speech, the map had moved under her feet. A redistribution had split Oxley in two. Its Brisbane end stayed a seat that leant hard to Labor, while most of Hanson’s rural heartland beyond Ipswich went into a new seat, Blair. She turned down a likely Senate seat and chanced her arm there.</p><p>Labor, the Liberals and the Nationals all preferenced each other ahead of her. Hanson won 36 percent of the primary vote to the Liberal Cameron Thompson’s 21.7. Thompson ran third, overtook Labor on National preferences, then overtook Hanson on Labor’s. She was out on her ear.</p><p>Abbott was not finished. His lawyers backed a One Nation dissident, Terry Sharples, in a challenge to the party’s registration, and the Supreme Court of Queensland found One Nation had been fraudulently registered using the Support Movement’s list.</p><p>In August 2003 Hanson and Ettridge were convicted of electoral fraud and jailed for three years.</p><p>In November the Court of Appeal quashed both convictions. Hanson had served eleven weeks. She walked out of prison a martyr. The Martyrdom of Pauline has paid dividends ever since.</p><p>So throw the charge out of court. The establishment, with an IPA board member among its paymasters, spent its money ending her career, not launching it. Nobody planted Pauline Hanson.</p><p>But acquit the conspiracy and something worse walks out of the courtroom. To find it, you have to go back a decade before she was sown, to a paddock the mining lobby had been ploughing since 1985.</p><p>Part 2 follows Wednesday.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://urbanwronski.com/2026/10/20/nobody-planted-pauline/"><em>http://urbanwronski.com</em></a><em> on October 20, 2026.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d8ba7c433be1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Going Down: Australia’s Dutch Auction of Its Humanity]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@davidtyler258/going-down-australias-dutch-auction-of-its-humanity-a9f62937f399?source=rss-1a6164dd1449------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a9f62937f399</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[one-nation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[refugees]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[australian-politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[migration]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[asylum-seekers]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[David Tyler]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 10 Oct 2026 22:31:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-10T22:31:04.516Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*MR_eVMmB6TmCPeu0ohZouA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Going, going gone. (Illustration generated with Gemini)</figcaption></figure><p><em>Labor, the Coalition and One Nation are calling the migrant intake down like lots on a falling clock. Nobody at the podium will ask what we owe the people on the block.</em></p><p>Daylight saving robbed us of an hour last Sunday, on the pretext of productivity and against sound evidence. When the clocks were stretched for the Sydney Olympics in 2000, economists Ryan Kellogg and Hendrik Wolff found it had <a href="https://cepr.org/voxeu/columns/does-daylight-saving-time-save-electricity">no effect on overall electricity consumption</a>. An LSE study that followed 30,000 people for three decades found the spring switch brings <a href="https://www.lse.ac.uk/research/research-for-the-world/health/end-daylight-saving-time">worse sleep, more heart attacks and a less productive Monday</a>.</p><p>Canberra has found a bolder use for the clock. It is winding it back to the good old days of Tampa, “illegals” and boat-stopping. So, of course, the May budget <a href="https://asrc.org.au/2026/05/13/federal-budget-2026-27-explainer/">cut $9.4 million from the Human Rights Commission</a>.</p><p>Other savings flow on. In Stop the Boats 2.0, no boats are needed. Just a Dutch auction of our humanity.</p><p>At the Aalsmeer flower auction outside Amsterdam, the clock runs backwards. Beneath harsh neon lights, damp green stems bead the air with peppery scent; crates of tulips crowd the floor, their petals still cool from the night. The price starts high and falls. Buyers lean over their buttons, eyes flicking from the descending numbers to the blooms.</p><p>Speed is everything: hesitate, and someone else gets the bunch; or the tulip wilts and is worthless.</p><p>Australian politics has borrowed that clock. The lot on offer is people.</p><p>You wouldn’t know it from the carefully choreographed corporate media narrative: the Murdoch empire is always quick to beat the anti-immigration drum, so readily do we all fall into march in step.</p><p>It is by no means confined to Murdoch, however, nor to either of our major political parties.</p><p>What is preposterous about the “debate” is its premise: that our humanity is a lever, and the only question is how hard to pull it. Student and skilled numbers, it is true, are set by policy. But our duty to others is not ours to auction. People who flee persecution and reach us are owed a hearing and safety.</p><p>That duty is the floor, and it is what the bidders are cutting through.</p><p>It does not help that the whole show opens in the shadow of the Trump regime’s ICE, or that our talkback is infested with the same pernicious talk of “illegals”, a species invented for dog-whistling. <a href="https://www.asyluminsight.com/refugees-convention">Seeking asylum is not illegal</a>. The Migration Act does label anyone without a valid visa an “unlawful non-citizen”. Parliament can make a thing lawful. It cannot make it moral. And that is before we reach the cruelty of offshore detention.</p><p>Labor opened the bidding. <a href="https://thenightly.com.au/australia/coalition-immigration-policy-what-angus-taylors-migration-cuts-mean-for-you-c-22975122">Treasury forecasts</a> net overseas migration of 245,000 in 2026–27, falling to 225,000 in 2027–28. The <a href="https://www.abs.gov.au/media-centre/media-releases/australias-population-grows-14-march-2026">Australian Bureau of Statistics</a> puts the year to March at 292,100, down from 309,500 the year before. The record, <a href="https://thenightly.com.au/politics/angus-taylor-announces-coalition-plan-to-slash-net-overseas-migration-to-100000-c-22972876">547,300 in 2023</a>, is long gone.</p><p>That is a real cut. It was made quietly, which in this market counts against it.</p><p>One Nation stopped the clock first. On 14 September Pauline Hanson promised <a href="https://www.thenewdaily.com.au/opinion/2026/09/14/one-nation-migration-policy">three years of net-negative migration</a>, more than 750,000 temporary visas gone, then a ceiling of 130,000. International students and the <a href="https://region.com.au/?p=999048">families of skilled workers</a> would carry most of it. Hanson blamed <a href="https://www.timeshighereducation.com/node/744946">“the Labor-Liberal political cartel”</a>.</p><p>She was taking aim at the Labor-Liberal duopoly, even if “cartel” is the wrong word. Her point will not be lost on anyone. She knows the duopoly from the inside. In 1996 the Liberals <a href="https://nit.com.au/10-09-2026/26414/thirty-years-of-aunty-pauline">disendorsed her in Oxley</a> over a letter attacking Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people, too late to reprint the ballot papers.</p><p>She won the seat with “Liberal” still printed beside her name.</p><p>Thirty years on, the party that dumped her is photocopying her homework.</p><p>The fine print is worse than the headline. The <a href="https://www.thenewdaily.com.au/opinion/2026/09/14/one-nation-migration-policy">80,000 people</a> One Nation says are here “illegally” would get three months to leave. Stay longer and they face “immigration enforcement” and a ban on ever coming back. No migrant at all could come from a country on the government’s do-not-travel list.</p><p>There are twenty-six. They include Ukraine, Venezuela, Palestine and Lebanon.</p><p>The day after Hanson’s announcement, the Coalition’s immigration spokesman, Jonathon Duniam, said he would <a href="https://www.indailysa.com.au/news/just-in/2026/09/15/one-nation-dismisses-wrecking-ball-threat-from-negative-migration">not be copying One Nation’s homework</a>.</p><p>Do I hear lower?</p><p>Three weeks later Angus “Watergate” Taylor handed that homework in. On 6 October the current Opposition Leader announced net migration of <a href="https://www.thenewdaily.com.au/news/politics/australian-politics/2026/10/06/coalition-migration-overhail">100,000 a year for two years</a>, rising to 160,000 by year four. About 650,000 temporary visa holders would go. Humanitarian places would halve to 10,000. International student enrolments would fall to 240,000 and the temporary graduate visa would be abolished, <a href="https://theprint.in/world/australian-opposition-party-vows-biggest-cut-to-immigration-in-countrys-history/3062825/">Reuters reported</a>. Like One Nation, the Coalition would make applicants <a href="https://www.indailysa.com.au/news/just-in/2026/10/06/graduates-targeted-in-radical-migration-overhaul-plan">leave the country to lodge a new visa</a>. Back in April it had already promised a list of <a href="https://thedailyaus.com.au/news/coalition-proposed-immigration-policy-crackdown">“safe” countries whose citizens could not apply for protection at all</a>.</p><p>Taylor called it <a href="https://theprint.in/world/australian-opposition-party-vows-biggest-cut-to-immigration-in-countrys-history/3062825/">“the biggest cut to immigration in the history of this country.”</a></p><p>Hanson said he had turned up <a href="https://www.indailysa.com.au/news/just-in/2026/10/06/graduates-targeted-in-radical-migration-overhaul-plan">“waving a photocopy of One Nation’s immigration policy.”</a></p><p>Not every lot goes under the hammer. Members of foreign forces covered by a status of forces agreement, and their civilian staff, are <a href="https://legislation.gov.au/F2023L00125/asmade/2023-02-20/es/original/pdf">taken to be granted a visa “by operation of law”</a>. No form, no fee, no queue. In May the government <a href="https://www.legislation.gov.au/F2026L00501/asmade/text">updated Australia’s visiting forces rules</a> for troops from Papua New Guinea and the United Kingdom. The student who wants to stay on must leave the country to ask.</p><p>On Sunrise the next morning Taylor was asked whether officials would be knocking on doors, and whether this was an ICE squad. <a href="https://thenightly.com.au/politics/angus-taylor-grilled-over-ice-squad-as-coalition-unveils-plan-to-slash-migration-and-deport-visa-overstayers-c-22978183">“Well, it’s not about that,”</a> he said. “We’re using existing agencies to do their jobs. The Federal Police, Border Force, ASIO.”</p><p>Do I hear lower?</p><p>The official charge against the migrant is pressure. Taylor read out the charge sheet at his launch: pressure on <a href="https://www.thenewdaily.com.au/news/politics/australian-politics/2026/10/06/coalition-migration-overhail">“roads, schools, infrastructure and housing.”</a></p><p>The real offence is visibility. She is the vulnerable young woman, exhausted by working double shifts, with the delivery bag on the 86 tram. He is the third applicant in the queue at the Footscray rental inspection, holding a folder of payslips. They are easy to see. A planning scheme is not.</p><p>Charity begins at home, so let’s start with housing. In his May budget reply, Angus Taylor promised to cap net migration at the number of homes completed. Abul Rizvi, a former Immigration department deputy secretary, points out that the Migration Act contains <a href="https://independentaustralia.net/politics/politics-display/why-angus-taylor-s-migration-cap-doesnt-add-up,21087">no power to cap net migration at all</a>.</p><p>Visas can be capped. People movements cannot. Legal and business publisher <a href="https://www.mondaq.com/australia/work-visas/1810640/coalition-budget-reply-cut-migration-to-align-with-housing-and-restrict-welfare">Mondaq</a> notes that tying intake to housing completions could raise migration rather than lower it.</p><p>Shadow housing minister Andrew Bragg blows his bags: net migration, he blathers, is <a href="https://thenightly.com.au/australia/net-overseas-migration-and-population-growth-slow-to-four-year-low-in-early-2026--c-22882864">well above the 170,000 annual completions</a>. That assumes every arrival is a household. Silvia Salazar of the Bankwest Curtin Economics Centre says most temporary migrants <a href="https://westernindependent.com.au/2026/05/15/angus-beef-with-immigration/">share houses with a lot of people</a>.</p><p>It also assumes every Australian can afford to make rent. In 2021, an estimated <a href="https://mercyfoundation.com.au/?p=6117">7,325 Australian women aged 55 and over</a> were experiencing homelessness; the number forced to live in their cars is not known nationally.</p><p>Six students in a three-bedroom weatherboard in Mascot are not six dwellings.</p><p>The logical error here is to confuse things that happen at the same time, contiguity, with causation. Rents rose while the planes landed, therefore the planes raised the rents. The student in the share house did not write the negative gearing rules. She did not zone the suburbs or let twenty years of supply fall behind.</p><p>She arrived during an acute and distressing housing shortage, helped hugely by negative gearing and by the capital gains tax discount a Liberal government under John Howard enacted in 1999.</p><p>Before we know it, “standards”, the first resort of scoundrels, is back on talkback. In April, Taylor said migrant numbers were <a href="https://www.edenmagnet.com.au/story/9233289/coalition-targets-bad-country-migrants-in-values-test/">“too high” and standards “too low.”</a></p><p>Asked which countries produced the bad ones, he named Iran and declined to name another. This week he put it plainly: <a href="https://thenightly.com.au/politics/angus-taylor-grilled-over-ice-squad-as-coalition-unveils-plan-to-slash-migration-and-deport-visa-overstayers-c-22978183">“We can’t have people coming to this country who don’t believe what we believe in.”</a></p><p>This fallacy is equivocation. “Standards” enters stage right impugning visa integrity, the checking of documents and the policing of dodgy colleges. It exits smearing the character of the people holding the visas. Nothing is argued. The word is simply slid across the stage.</p><p>Do I hear lower?</p><p>None of the bidders dares ask the auctioneer the obvious question. Who does the work?</p><p>Unemployment was <a href="https://www.abs.gov.au/media-centre/media-releases/unemployment-rate-rises-46-august">4.6 percent in August</a>, with participation at 67.1 percent. Job vacancies stood at <a href="https://www.abs.gov.au/media-centre/media-releases/job-vacancies-fall-again-august-2026">325,000</a>. Natural increase added <a href="https://www.abs.gov.au/media-centre/media-releases/australias-population-grows-14-march-2026">100,600 people</a> in the year to March; migration added 292,100. Australian women had <a href="https://sbs.com.au/news/article/australia-population-hit-28-million-milestone/zn2gaiifg">1.48 babies each in 2024</a>, a record low.</p><p>The cradle is not rocking the payroll.</p><p>Higher learning has long been flogged like any other commodity. Nobody is even shocked any more. Universities Australia counts international education as a <a href="https://universitiesaustralia.edu.au/media-item/student-numbers-steady-but-policy-settings-holding-australia-back/">$55 billion export sector supporting 250,000 jobs</a>. Its chief executive, Luke Sheehy, calls the contest <a href="https://www.timeshighereducation.com/node/744946">“a political race to the bottom on international students.”</a> No government would treat iron ore as a lot to be knocked down for applause.</p><p>The party of the bean-counters, the self-proclaimed “better economic managers”, has yet to produce a price list. The Coalition <a href="https://www.indailysa.com.au/news/just-in/2026/10/06/graduates-targeted-in-radical-migration-overhaul-plan">will not release costings</a> until closer to the 2028 election, once the government it wants to replace has supplied the forecasts. It claims a budget gain of about $260 million on estimates it will not disclose.</p><p>There is a history here, if Taylor could only hear it. Rizvi has shown that the post-pandemic surge ran hot on settings a Morrison government put in place before May 2022.</p><p><a href="https://independentaustralia.net/politics/politics-display/angus-taylor-disowns-coalition-policies-behind-202223-migration-surge,20693">Students and working holidaymakers</a>, plus a tight labour market, drove net migration past 500,000. The man calling the clock down helped build the spike he now rails against.</p><p>All of that is true. All of it is also a price.</p><p>The business lobby, the vice-chancellors and the economists answer the bidders in the bidders’ own currency. Nurses. Export dollars. Taxpayers for an ageing country. It is the right answer to the wrong question.</p><p>It still values a human being by what she is worth to us. A refugee is not a skills shortage. What we owe her does not depend on whether she can lift a frail man from his bed at three in the morning.</p><p>Australia <a href="https://www.thenewdaily.com.au/news/national/2014/01/21/australia-marks-60-years-refugee-convention">signed up to the Refugee Convention in 1954</a>. Article 33 forbids sending a refugee back to a place where her life or freedom is threatened. Article 31 forbids punishing her for how she got here. <a href="https://www.un.org/en/about-us/universal-declaration-of-human-rights">Article 14 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights</a> says everyone has the right to seek asylum from persecution. These are <a href="https://www.asyluminsight.com/refugees-convention">obligations</a>, not lots. We would owe them if we had never signed.</p><p>UNHCR counted <a href="https://amesnews.com.au/lead-story/human-displacement-remains-at-record-levels-unhcr-report/">117.8 million people forcibly displaced</a> at the end of 2025, 41.6 million of them refugees. Resettlement places fell sharply from 188,000 in 2024 as the Trump regime simply walked away.</p><p>Into that, the Coalition proposes to halve Australia’s humanitarian intake to 10,000. Labor promised 27,000 places in its platform and the latest budget <a href="https://asrc.org.au/2026/05/13/federal-budget-2026-27-explainer/">does not deliver them</a>, the Asylum Seeker Resource Centre notes. One Nation would bar entry from Ukraine and Palestine.</p><p>Offshore processing is in its fourteenth year. The forward estimates set aside <a href="https://asrc.org.au/2026/05/13/federal-budget-2026-27-explainer/">$1.8 billion over four years</a> to keep it going: at least $5.8 million a head each year, by the ASRC’s arithmetic.</p><p>A woman held there told a Senate inquiry this year: <a href="https://asrc.org.au/2026/05/05/senate-inquiry-into-offshore-processing/">“I have no trust in the police, or the accommodation providers or anyone responsible for them.”</a></p><p>Labor has paid Nauru <a href="https://thenightly.com.au/politics/tony-burkes-nauru-deportation-deal-sparks-outrage-from-refugee-advocates-c-19854257">$408 million up front</a>, and $70 million a year, to take non-citizens it wants gone.</p><p>“Anyone who doesn’t have a valid visa should leave the country,” Tony Burke said. In May the High Court unanimously upheld one removal under the deal. Yet it also <a href="https://www.hrlc.org.au/?p=7042">left open whether arguments framed differently</a> could show such removals are punishment, and so unconstitutional, the Human Rights Law Centre notes. A law that has survived one challenge has not been proved just.</p><p>Nobody at the podium is bidding to protect the floor. They are bidding through it.</p><p>Rents are high. It’s no Daily Mail fiction. The 7.42 from Sunbury is full.</p><p>What the grievance needs is a scapegoat, and our corporate media are in it like a rat up a drainpipe.</p><p>A decade of not building enough homes has no face. A care sector that relies on casual, part-time workers on temporary visas has no face. Universities pushed onto fee income by funding cuts have no face. The arrival has a face, and a name that is hard to pronounce on talkback.</p><p>Each policy concession ratifies the premise. Labor trims to look responsible. The Coalition halves to look serious. One Nation goes below zero to look pure.</p><p>Nobody asks the two questions that would stop the clock. How many nurses, carers and chippies do we need? And what do we owe the people knocking at the door who are none of those things?</p><p>At Aalsmeer the clock stops when someone buys. Here it stops when someone wins.</p><p>Do I hear lower.</p><p>On Nauru this fortnight, <a href="https://asrc.org.au/2026/05/13/federal-budget-2026-27-explainer/">about a hundred people</a> will each be paid $260. Canberra will not say how many.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a9f62937f399" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Eighty to One: The Greens, the Press Gallery and the Wrong Race]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@davidtyler258/eighty-to-one-the-greens-the-press-gallery-and-the-wrong-race-a0441c510ab4?source=rss-1a6164dd1449------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a0441c510ab4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[the-greens]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[media-bias]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[David Tyler]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 02 Oct 2026 12:33:45 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-02T13:22:02.863Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/439/0*ui51Hwp4PsCEGjxQ" /></figure><p>The Greens have a new leader. The press gallery has a new roughie. The field has been called to the post and the commentators are already in the box.</p><p>And they’re racing.</p><p>That is how we call politics.</p><p>With the race that stops a nation only a couple of pension cheques away, it is timely to reflect. Every contest is called from the stand: who led at the turn, who is weakening in the straight, who has drifted in the betting. A budget, a party-room ballot and an election campaign all come home in the same breathless monotone.</p><p>It is a strange old habit, Possums. We just will not give up our view of politics as a horse race.</p><p>We gave the world the secret ballot. We built preferential voting and two houses of parliament, one of them expressly designed not to behave like the other. We have independents, crossbenchers, preference flows and governments that occasionally discover a majority in one chamber is not ownership of the Parliament.</p><p>Yet the moment the little TV camera lights start winking, the whole thing becomes first past the post. The favourite is in front, the roughie is out the back, and the rest is colour commentary.</p><p>On Wednesday the Greens ran their own race. Larissa Waters stood down as leader because, in her words, her “ <a href="https://www.abc.net.au/news/2026-09-30/federal-politics-greens-announce-new-leader-david-shoebridge/107211108">health is getting worse</a>”. We wish her well. The leadership, meanwhile, normally settled by consensus, went to a ballot. David Shoebridge polled <a href="https://thenightly.com.au/politics/greens-elect-david-shoebridge-a-new-party-leader-after-larissa-waters-steps-down-c-22946254">six, Mehreen Faruqi three and Sarah Hanson-Young two</a>. After preferences, Shoebridge won seven to four.</p><p>The whip, Nick McKim, then did something <a href="https://www.abc.net.au/news/2026-09-30/federal-politics-greens-announce-new-leader-david-shoebridge/107211108">rare for the Greens</a>, who normally just stick to announcing the new leader’s name. McKim read out the numbers. A result. A count. A photograph.</p><p>The Greens had printed their own photo finish and pinned it to the board.</p><p>Seventy-eight years ago, Flemington did the same.</p><p>The 1948 Melbourne Cup was the <a href="https://www.vrc.com.au/latest-news/picture-perfect">first decided by the photo-finish camera</a>, newly installed at the course. The horse in front, by half a head, was Rimfire, and Rimfire was not supposed to be there.</p><p>He was six years old. His form was poor. He looked crook on the eve of race day. He started at 80 to 1.</p><p>Rimfire’s jockey, Ray Neville, was just a kid. Teenagers hadn’t been invented. A <a href="https://www.stockjournal.com.au/story/5742528/imagine-a-15yo-jockey-riding-a-melbourne-cup-winner-it-happened/">fifteen-year-old apprentice from Birchip</a>, a day shy of sixteen, who had held his licence for eight weeks. He got the ride because he could make the weight. The trainer kept it from him until race day. No point keeping the lad awake all night.</p><p>Neville used to tell his children that as he came round the last bend “ <a href="https://www.stockjournal.com.au/story/5742528/imagine-a-15yo-jockey-riding-a-melbourne-cup-winner-it-happened/">he just went for it</a> “. Down the straight, Rimfire held off Dark Marne under Jack Thompson, one of the finest jockeys in the country. Thompson was certain he had won.</p><p>Then the camera spoke. What a boil-over.</p><p>Rimfire. The boy.</p><p>A perfect metaphor for Australian political journalism? The trouble is not that the gallery loves a horse race. The trouble is that it keeps calling the wrong one.</p><h3>THE FORM GUIDE</h3><p>Start with the weights. At the 2025 election the Greens lost three of their four lower-house seats, Adam Bandt’s Melbourne among them. Last Green standing, Elizabeth Watson-Brown in Ryan, said that it “ <a href="https://thenightly.com.au/politics/elizabeth-watson-brown-sole-greens-mp-claims-victory-says-it-might-be-a-bit-lonely-c-18679575">might be a bit lonely</a> “. One seat. Minor party. The handicapper has spoken.</p><p>Except the same election produced an inconvenient truth. The Greens’ national primary vote was <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/news/ng-interactive/2025/jun/02/what-went-wrong-for-the-greens-in-the-australian-election">12.22 per cent</a>, almost exactly the 12.25 per cent of 2022. The vote did not collapse. It was simply spread across the map in a way that returned almost no seats. One voter in eight. One seat in a hundred and fifty.</p><p>Then there is the Senate. The Greens came out of 2025 with eleven senators, enough for Labor and the Greens together to pass whatever they could agree on. Dorinda Cox <a href="https://www.thenewdaily.com.au/news/politics/australian-politics/2025/06/03/dorinda-cox-defects-greens">crossed to Labor</a>, and they are now ten.</p><p>Ten senators and one member. Call them minor if you like. Just don’t confuse minor with immaterial.</p><h3>THE VACUUM</h3><p>Shoebridge says the Greens are here to replace Labor. Longer odds than Rimfire, says the form guide, and the gallery reaches instinctively for the sports pages. Nobody read the next sentence.</p><p>“ <a href="https://www.abc.net.au/news/2026-09-30/federal-politics-greens-announce-new-leader-david-shoebridge/107211108">We’re here to fill the vacuum that has been left by the Labor Party rushing to the right.</a> “</p><p>That was the sentence to lead with, because it is the only part of the claim that needs no odds at all. The vacuum is real: Labor has been hollowing out for forty years. It began with the Accord, when the party of the shop floor learned to speak fluent Business Council. It continued through privatisation, casualisation and a submarine pact that, in the words of <em>Australian Foreign Affairs</em>, “ <a href="https://www.australianforeignaffairs.com/articles/extract/2023/11/extract-no-daylight">became bipartisan policy literally overnight</a> “.</p><p>Every time Labor moved right, somebody was left standing in the paddock. Some of them now vote Green. Others, as Shoebridge also argued, have <a href="https://au.news.yahoo.com/greens-leadership-hopefuls-vow-replace-225401619.html">wandered off towards One Nation</a>.</p><p>So why must the Greens replace Labor before we treat them as significant? That is not how the system works. A party does not need the Lodge to change what the Lodge can do. It needs votes, leverage, issues a government cannot ignore, and sometimes nothing more than the nerve to stand in the doorway.</p><h3>THE RACE NOBODY CALLS</h3><p>Consider the veterans. The Albanese Government proposed a $5,000 annual cap on allied health services for veterans, due to start in July 2027. Veterans called it a <a href="https://www.canberratimes.com.au/story/9331992/death-sentence-veterans-call-for-cap-to-be-scrapped/">death sentence</a>. Shoebridge and Jacqui Lambie got a bill through the Senate to stop any such cap being imposed. In September, Veterans’ Affairs Minister Matt Keogh took the cap “ <a href="https://www.thenewdaily.com.au/news/national/2026/09/17/backdown-veteran-health-cap">off the table</a> “.</p><p>Lambie, the Coalition and the veterans’ groups can all claim a share of that. Politics is full of people arriving at the winning post carrying their own saddle.</p><p>Which is precisely the point. The government has 94 members in the House and the Greens have one. The government has <a href="https://www.thenewdaily.com.au/news/politics/australian-politics/2026/05/14/tas-senator-joins-labor">30 senators</a> and the Greens have ten. And still the government cannot simply do as it likes.</p><p>The Greens matter without winning government. They matter precisely because they are not the government.</p><p>That is the race the form guide doesn’t print.</p><h3>THE PRESS GALLERY’S FAVOURITE HORSE</h3><p>Now to our corporate cartel of political horse callers.</p><p>The same horses. The same barriers. The same track. The same serene certainty that the most important thing in politics happened yesterday afternoon in a party room.</p><p>So a change of leader becomes a race. Who had the numbers? Who is disappointed? Who will Labor fear? Who will One Nation exploit?</p><p>The Nightly had the new leader “ <a href="https://thenightly.com.au/politics/greens-leader-david-shoebridge-branches-out-as-party-turns-over-new-leaf-after-larissa-waters-departure-c-22950985">branching out</a> “ as the party “turns over new leaf”. The puns were in the mounting yard before the ink was dry.</p><p>And the Greens are scratched before the barriers, as they always are.</p><p>Lose a seat? Finished.<br>Lose a leader? Finished.<br>Too radical? Finished.<br>Help Labor? Finished.</p><p>Their internal disputes prove dysfunction. Their deals with Labor prove capture. Their refusal to deal proves they are unserious. Their Senate leverage is obstruction, their losses are extinction and their persistence is an annoyance. Whatever happens, the horse stays a roughie.</p><p>Meanwhile, down the back, almost unnoticed, are the questions that matter. Why does one voter in eight keep backing this party? Why do governments keep negotiating with it? Why do its policies, once dismissed as mung-bean sandal-wearing lunacy, keep turning up in Labor legislation?</p><p>Ask how a hard cap on the gross emissions of the country’s biggest polluters, 140 million tonnes a year and falling, ended up in Labor’s own Safeguard Mechanism in 2023. It was the <a href="https://thenewdaily.com.au/news/politics/australian-politics/2023/03/27/greens-deal-climate-safeguard">price of Greens votes in the Senate</a>.</p><p>Those questions make poor television. So the leadership race gets the camera, and the political class gathers around the tote board to discuss the tote board.</p><p>The gallery’s question is always: can they win?</p><p>The better question is: what happens because they are running?</p><h3>THE .22</h3><p>A rimfire cartridge is a .22. The rabbit gun. Small bore and unpretentious, the sort of firearm that lived behind the farmhouse door because the world occasionally required a rabbit to be dealt with and nobody needed a consultant’s strategic review to do it.</p><p>Shoebridge is one of the loudest critics of AUKUS. The Greens oppose the nuclear-submarine project outright. So here they are, a .22 in a contest with a fleet of submarines due some time in the 2030s.</p><p>Small things can still hit what they are aimed at. Farmers never kept the .22 to win a naval engagement. They kept it because it did one job well.</p><p>Parties have jobs too. Governments govern. Oppositions oppose. Senators scrutinise, bargain, obstruct and, now and then, force a government into retreat. A functioning democracy does not need every party in the chamber to be a government in waiting. It needs forces in the chamber that governments have to reckon with.</p><h3>ASK THE CAMERA</h3><p>In 1948 the camera was meant to settle an argument. Instead it became part of the legend. Thompson could not believe he had lost. The crowd could scarcely believe it either. The camera did not care. It showed what happened.</p><p>That is all the Greens are owed by political journalism. A camera.</p><p>Look at the vote. Look at the Senate. Look at the legislation, the amendments, the negotiations. Look at where they have used their leverage and where they have squandered it. Then decide what kind of animal it is.</p><p>There is a fair case that the Greens have problems. Internal divisions. Lost seats. A vote that is geographically inefficient. A leadership ballot that has just exposed an argument about the party’s own democracy, with Faruqi warning that “ <a href="https://www.abc.net.au/news/2026-09-30/federal-politics-greens-announce-new-leader-david-shoebridge/107211108">without a member vote, we cannot call ourselves a grassroots party</a> “.</p><p>Replacing Labor may be a long shot. That is for the voters to settle, not a columnist, a bookie or a panel show.</p><p>But the opposite error is lazier. Assume a party cannot form government and therefore does not matter, and you have misunderstood the machinery entirely. The Greens may not even be entered in the Cup. They are running another race: over what governments can pass, what they can dodge, which arguments become respectable and which interests get challenged.</p><p>Less glamorous. Considerably more important.</p><h3>THE SADDLE</h3><p>Ray Neville collected <a href="https://www.katherinetimes.com.au/story/5725442/katherine-resident-reflects-on-fathers-historic-melbourne-cup-win/">£25 for winning the 1948 Melbourne Cup</a>. Enough for a new suit and a saddle.</p><p>Then somebody stole the saddle.</p><p>Win the Melbourne Cup at 80 to 1 and somebody nicks the bloody saddle.</p><p>Neville rode until 1968 and spent years afterwards issuing barrier certificates. This year Birchip <a href="https://arr.news/2026/03/26/birchip-silo-art-reaches-finish-post/">painted his story across its silos</a>.</p><p>The Cup is run on Tuesday 3 November. The camera will be there. So will the gallery, and so will the bookies. And somewhere down the track will be a horse everyone has already written off.</p><p>They said 80 to 1.</p><p>Ask the camera.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://urbanwronski.com/2026/10/02/eighty-to-one/"><em>http://urbanwronski.com</em></a><em> on October 2, 2026.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a0441c510ab4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Australia’s West Bank Abdication: The Comfort of Complicity]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@davidtyler258/australias-west-bank-abdication-the-comfort-of-complicity-792a8dfbfafe?source=rss-1a6164dd1449------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/792a8dfbfafe</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[senator-penny-wong]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[israeli-settlements]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[west-bank-palestine]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[australian-politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[David Tyler]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 29 Sep 2026 08:06:21 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-29T10:46:43.695Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/439/0*qQlHqaA5DeBHd9cD" /></figure><p><em>Twelve nations put a price on Israel’s illegal settlements. Canberra sat at the table for months, then remembered it had a Security Council seat to win.</em></p><p>Do we have principles?</p><p>Strutting what it sees as the high moral ground of the world stage, Australia is wont to pose as the honest broker, champion of the underdog and even warden of the mystical rules-based order, a form of words that rivals the Nicene Creed for opacity and is chanted with the same glazed piety, loudest by those least inclined to live by it.</p><p>Hypocrisy? If we don’t like our principles, as Groucho almost said, we have others.</p><p>This month twelve nations put their names to trade sanctions on Israel’s illegal settlements in the West Bank: the UK, France, Canada, Denmark, Finland, Iceland, Ireland, Norway, Poland, Portugal, Spain and Sweden.</p><p><a href="https://www.abc.net.au/news/2026-09-19/uk-west-bank-sanctions-bloc-expected-australia-to-join/107159388">Four diplomatic sources told the ABC</a> that Australia stayed in the talks until close to the end. One EU official had seen an earlier draft with Australia written in.</p><p>Whether Canberra ever agreed to be there, nobody will say.</p><p>Then the pens came out and Australia remembered a pressing engagement elsewhere.</p><p>Two EU officials were “surprised”. Another was “disappointed”. A Nordic official said Canberra had “missed an opportunity”.</p><p>That is how you talk about a mate who didn’t show.</p><p>We are not so much walking back our stance against illegal settlements as not walking the talk at all.</p><p>Before we go there, let’s look at what hides behind the benign euphemism of the word settlement.</p><h3>What the word hides</h3><p>The settlements are Israeli civilian towns built on land Israel captured in 1967.</p><p><a href="https://ihl-databases.icrc.org/en/ihl-treaties/gciv-1949/article-49">Article 49(6) of the Fourth Geneva Convention</a> forbids an occupying power to move its own civilians into the territory it occupies. In July 2024 the <a href="https://www.icj-cij.org/case/186">International Court of Justice</a> found the occupation itself unlawful and said the settlements must be evacuated.</p><p>Some settlements are cities with shopping malls and council rates. Others are one caravan, one flag and a flock of sheep on a hilltop.</p><p>Both do the same job.</p><p>Take Ras Ein al-Auja, a Bedouin village in the Jordan Valley. This is innovation. Who needs a bulldozer?</p><p>In late December 2025 settlers set up an outpost beside it. They ploughed the village land, tore up the road and cut the power cables. They blocked the canal and the grazing grounds.</p><p>They drove their herds to people’s doorsteps and gathered in groups at night.</p><p>On 8 January, 26 households, more than 100 people, left in a single day, <a href="https://www.972mag.com/ras-ein-al-auja-erasure-jordan-valley/">+972 Magazine reports</a>.</p><p>“They threatened to kill us, chased us, beat us,” said Abu Taleb al-Omari, 75. “In the end, they said they would slaughter us here if we didn’t leave.”</p><p>Muhammad Eshaq Rashid, 55: “I’ve never cried in my life until today.”</p><p>The settlers’ parting words, as one resident recalls them: “You lost. Wherever you go, we’ll come.”</p><p>Ras Ein al-Auja is not an aberration.</p><p><a href="https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/research/2026/06/israel-west-bank-ethnic-cleansing/">Amnesty International</a> counts 117 herding and Bedouin communities fully or partly driven out between January 2023 and April 2026. That is 5,910 people. Of 363 unauthorised outposts, 212 went up under the present government.</p><p>Then the suburbs.</p><p>Ma’ale Adumim is a city of red roofs and ring roads a short drive east of Jerusalem. Between the two lies an empty ridge the planners call E1.</p><p>On 19 August the Netanyahu government <a href="https://www.timesofisrael.com/government-opens-bidding-to-build-1200-homes-in-controversial-e1-settlement-project/">opened a tender for 1,234 homes</a> there. Bids close on 19 October, eight days before Israel goes to the polls.</p><p>That ridge is the last gap joining the northern and southern West Bank. Build on it and a Palestinian state comes in two pieces with Israeli housing in between.</p><p>Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich puts it plainly: E1 “practically erases the two-state delusion.”</p><p>Smotrich needs no interpreter.</p><p>On 9 April the government <a href="https://www.timesofisrael.com/government-formally-approves-34-new-settlements-as-it-acts-to-deepen-hold-on-west-bank/">approved 34 new settlements</a> in one sitting, 103 since it took office. The new homes, he promised, would have “lights on and running water.”</p><p>Ten days later he cut the ribbon at Sa-Nur, a settlement Israel itself evacuated in 2005, and <a href="https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2026/4/19/israeli-ministers-celebrate-re-establishment-of-sa-nur-west-bank-settlement">called the day</a> “burying the idea of a Palestinian state.”</p><p>Some 700,000 settlers now live in the West Bank and East Jerusalem.</p><p>That is the enterprise the twelve set out to squeeze. That is what Australia declined to touch.</p><h3>The official excuse</h3><p>Naturally, we have a few pressing practical constraints. And ample precedent.</p><p>Our sure pair of hands turns into Butterfingers whenever Washington frowns. Gutlessness alone can do that to any US butler pretending to be a middle power. Or vice-versatility. Integrity fatigue?</p><p>Yet even industrial-strength Canberran hypocrisy is tested when it invokes pragmatism to weasel out of a principled agreement.</p><p>Wait. Make that talk of an agreement.</p><p>Then the foghorn of vacuity.</p><p>A blanket import ban, <a href="https://www.abc.net.au/news/2026-09-19/uk-west-bank-sanctions-bloc-expected-australia-to-join/107159388">says the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade</a>, presents “practical challenges, including how to ensure they do not inadvertently harm Palestinian businesses, workers and livelihoods.”</p><p>Penny Wong told the Senate that Australia would pursue “further targeted measures in coordination with international partners.”</p><p>Which measures. Against whom. By when. The Senate was not told. Neither were we.</p><p>A touch of the reverse Robin Hood. We won’t tax the people taking Palestinian land, out of tender concern for the Palestinians whose land is being taken.</p><p>No-one’s buying the government guff.</p><p>The British package was never only a blanket ban. When London announced it, <a href="https://www.abc.net.au/news/2026-09-09/australia-not-joining-israel-west-bank-sanction/107132396">the ABC reported</a> that it included action “against specific companies and individuals who provide services such as construction, infrastructure, financing, or real estate for settlement expansion.”</p><p>Targeted measures. The very thing Canberra says it prefers. They were on the table. Canberra left them there.</p><p>And the targeted measures we already have?</p><p>In June 2025 Australia joined Britain, Canada, New Zealand and Norway in <a href="https://www.foreignminister.gov.au/minister/penny-wong/media-release/joint-statement-foreign-ministers-australia-canada-new-zealand-norway-and-united-kingdom-measures-targeting-itamar-ben-gvir-and-bezalel-smotrich">sanctioning Itamar Ben-Gvir and Bezalel Smotrich</a>. Good.</p><p>Now look at what that leaves. We sanction the man who runs the settlement project, then decline to touch the project.</p><p>The foreign policy equivalent of thoughts and prayers.</p><p>Wong is not confused about the stakes. <a href="https://www.abc.net.au/news/2026-09-09/australia-not-joining-israel-west-bank-sanction/107132396">She has said</a> that settlement growth, E1 and “flagrant settler violence” are “extinguishing the possibility of a two-state solution.”</p><p>The Foreign Minister has read the death notice. She is still deciding on flowers.</p><p>Nor is the law in doubt. The ICJ told every state to refrain from aid or assistance in maintaining the occupation, and to take steps to prevent trade or investment relations that help keep it going.</p><p>Trade relations. The Court named the lever. Twelve nations have pulled it.</p><h3>The domestic alibi</h3><p>So why walk? The ABC’s sources point home.</p><p>On <a href="https://www.abc.net.au/news/2026-08-26/bondi-antisemitism-social-cohesion-royal-commission-final-day/107077244">14 December 2025</a>, gunmen killed 15 people at a Hanukkah celebration at Bondi Beach. That was antisemitic terror and the grief is real.</p><p>A royal commission followed. Its report is due on 18 December.</p><p>Several diplomats told the ABC that the pressure on Albanese since Bondi may have shaped Canberra’s decision.</p><p>Here is what the government will not say.</p><p>Jewish Australians are not the Israeli cabinet. A Hanukkah gathering on Bondi Beach is not a caravan on a hilltop in the Jordan Valley. A tariff on settlement goods is not an act against a faith.</p><p>Treat it as one and you accept the settlers’ own case: that the settlements belong to every Jew, everywhere.</p><p>Plenty of Jewish Australians see the difference. The Jewish Council of Australia, a progressive group sharply critical of Israeli government policy, wants settlement goods banned.</p><p>“Once again,” <a href="https://www.portnews.com.au/story/9347041/australia-taking-safe-approach-on-israeli-goods-ban/">said its executive officer Bart Shteinman</a>, “Australia is at the back of the pack when it comes to upholding our international law obligations.”</p><p>Jewish Australians call for the ban. The government cites Jewish Australians as its reason to refuse it.</p><p>Canberra is choosing which Jews to hear.</p><p>In London, Ed Miliband announced Britain’s measures and was promptly called antisemitic. Miliband is Jewish, <a href="https://www.crikey.com.au/2026/09/25/australia-west-bank-sanctions-israel-palestine-security-council/">as Rachel Withers notes in Crikey</a>.</p><p>A charge that fits everyone is no guide to policy.</p><h3>The seat</h3><p>Withers offers a further motive.</p><p>Australia wants a seat on the <a href="https://www.abc.net.au/news/2026-09-20/australia-bids-seat-united-nations-security-council/107173870">UN Security Council</a> for 2029 and 2030. The ballot falls in mid-2028, and a win needs some 128 votes.</p><p>Days after the walkout, the bid was launched under the slogan “We listen. We partner. We protect.” The government, Withers suggests, is keeping its powder dry.</p><p>Count the room.</p><p>In September 2024, <a href="https://www.abc.net.au/news/2024-09-19/un-general-assembly-votes-on-israel-palestinian-occupation/104368946">124 nations voted</a> in the General Assembly to give Israel twelve months to end the occupation. Australia abstained.</p><p>That is almost exactly the majority Canberra now needs. Those are the voters. They watched us abstain then. They watched us walk out now.</p><p>Launching the bid, Wong said: “A safer world is one governed by rules, not power and force alone.”</p><p>So the government passed up a chance to uphold international law to improve its odds of a seat on the body charged with upholding it.</p><p>This is not pragmatism. It is farce.</p><h3>The receipts</h3><p>Then there is what we do, as distinct from what we decline to do.</p><p>“We are not supplying weapons to Israel,” says Defence Minister Richard Marles.</p><p>Yet the ABC found that <a href="https://www.abc.net.au/news/2025-08-14/australia-defence-export-permits-to-israel-gaza-war/105628320">31 of the 35 active defence export permits</a> for Israel cleared after review fall under Part 1 of the Defence and Strategic Goods List: items designed for military use.</p><p>Parts for the F-35, the jet Israel flies over Gaza, <a href="https://www.abc.net.au/news/2025-10-06/f-35-jet-fighter-supply-chain-israel-gaza-weapons-transfers/105783858">move through Australian supply chains</a>.</p><p>“Parts of weapons are weapons,” said Greens senator David Shoebridge.</p><p>The habit is old. In January 2014, asked whether the settlements breach international law, Foreign Minister Julie Bishop <a href="https://www.timesofisrael.com/australia-fm-dont-call-settlements-illegal-under-international-law/">replied</a>: “I would like to see which international law has declared them illegal.”</p><p>Ten years later the ICJ showed her.</p><p>We talk like a principled middle power. When it costs something, we act like a client state.</p><h3>The test</h3><p>The test for Canberra is simple and it is public.</p><p>Name the companies. Name the banks. Name the builders on E1.</p><p>Tell us whether Australian super funds hold a single dollar of settlement construction, and what happens to it. Give a date.</p><p>If the targeted measures are real, show them. If they stay unnamed, the explanation is exactly what it looks like.</p><p>In Ras Ein al-Auja, 26 households packed up and left in a single day.</p><p>In Canberra, the government couldn’t find a pen.</p><p>We listen. We partner. We protect ourselves.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://urbanwronski.com/2026/09/29/australia-west-bank-abdication-comfort-of-complicity/"><em>http://urbanwronski.com</em></a><em> on September 29, 2026.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=792a8dfbfafe" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Appropriate Time]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@davidtyler258/the-appropriate-time-df528fb2a6dd?source=rss-1a6164dd1449------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/df528fb2a6dd</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[west-bank]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[oz-foreign-policy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[israel-palestine]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[clarke-and-dawe]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[David Tyler]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 25 Sep 2026 12:17:22 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-26T07:30:19.427Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/440/0*sBb7yVvTRJoEiE8I" /></figure><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> Thanks for your time.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Good to be here.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> You’re a senior government spokesman on the Middle East.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> I am. I’m across the whole region. Well, not across it. Near it.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> Twelve countries have signed a statement on trade with Israeli settlements in the West Bank.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> They have, and we congratulate them. Terrific effort.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> Australia didn’t sign.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> No, but we were very much part of the process.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> Which part?</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> The early part. We were there right through the part before the signing. That’s the most important part. Anyone can sign.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> Why didn’t Australia sign?</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Practical challenges.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> What were they?</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Well, the main one was the signing.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> The Foreign Minister said the government was worried about unintended consequences for Australian businesses, for Palestinians and for Israelis.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> That’s right. We’re worried about everybody.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> In that order.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> It’s alphabetical.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> It isn’t.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> It is in the Australian alphabet. A for Australian. You start at home.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> The Palestinian Authority supported the ban.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> And we have enormous respect for that.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> So why not do it?</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Because it might hurt Palestinians.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> They asked for it.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Exactly. And that’s what worries us. People ask for all sorts of things. You can’t just go around giving people what they ask for. Where would it end?</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> Israel is offering settlement companies up to 200,000 shekels each to find new markets.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Well, there you go. They’ve got it in hand.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> Israel’s ambassador called Australia’s decision “a wise decision.”</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Very gratifying. You don’t get that kind of feedback from everybody.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> The Palestinian Authority didn’t say that.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> No, well, they’re not across the detail.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> The government says it is pursuing targeted measures instead.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Very targeted. Extremely targeted.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> What’s the target?</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Illegal settlements and settler violence.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> And the measures?</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> That’s the second half. You don’t rush the second half. You get the target right first, then the measures. Otherwise you’re just measuring things.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> When will we know what they are?</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Not at this time.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> When?</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> No, that’s the when. “At this time” is the time. We’re just not doing it then.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> So when will you do it?</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> At a time that isn’t this one.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> Which one?</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> A later one. They’re very reliable, later times. There’s always another one coming.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> The International Court of Justice says states must take steps to prevent trade or investment relations that help maintain the illegal situation.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> And we are taking steps.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> What steps?</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Backward, mainly, at this stage. You need a run-up.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> Apartments in West Bank settlements have been marketed to investors at events in Sydney and Melbourne.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Have they? Whereabouts?</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> Ma’ale Adumim. Efrat. The Gush Etzion bloc.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> No, whereabouts in Sydney?</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> Does that matter?</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> It matters to the investor. Location, location. That’s the whole problem with the West Bank. Everybody wants the location.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> The Prime Minister has launched Australia’s bid for a seat on the Security Council.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> He has. “We listen. We partner. We protect.”</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> Who do we listen to?</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Everybody. That’s the listening.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> The Palestinian Authority asked for the ban.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> And we heard them. Beautifully. You could have heard a pin drop.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> We partner.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> With everybody.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> The twelve countries were our partners.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Right up until they did something. Then they were doing something, and we were partnering.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> We protect.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> That’s where we’re very strong.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> Protect who?</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Australian businesses, Palestinians and Israelis.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> In that order.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Alphabetical.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> Bids for the E1 settlement tender close on the fifth of October.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> That’s very soon.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> Will Australia act before then?</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> I can say this. Australia will take decisive action at the appropriate time.</p><p><strong>DAWE:</strong> Thanks for your time.</p><p><strong>CLARKE:</strong> Any time. Well. Not this one.</p><p><em>The facts Dawe puts to Clarke are on the record: </em><a href="https://www.abc.net.au/news/2026-09-19/uk-west-bank-sanctions-bloc-expected-australia-to-join/107159388"><em>the late withdrawal</em></a><em>, </em><a href="https://www.abc.net.au/news/2026-09-09/australia-not-joining-israel-west-bank-sanction/107132396"><em>the Minister’s order of concern</em></a><em>, </em><a href="https://publish.pearlsandirritations.com/australia-says-a-settlement-trade-ban-could-hurt-palestinians-the-palestinian-authority-wants-one/"><em>the Palestinian Authority’s support</em></a><em>, </em><a href="https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2026/9/24/israel-offers-cash-to-firms-hit-by-trade-ban-europe-dithers-on-new-rules"><em>the shekel grants</em></a><em>, </em><a href="https://michaelwest.com.au/israel-lobby-sells-stolen-palestinian-land-to-australian-investors/"><em>the Sydney and Melbourne property events</em></a><em>, </em><a href="https://www.hrw.org/news/2025/02/04/ban-eu-trade-and-business-israels-illegal-settlements-occupied-palestinian"><em>the ICJ’s words</em></a><em> and </em><a href="https://ir-amim.org.il/en/publication/e1-settlement-tender-slated-to-open-for-bids-on-august-5-2026/"><em>the E1 closing date</em></a><em>. Clarke’s answers are satire. The long version, prompted by the admirable work in Rachel Withers’ </em><a href="https://www.crikey.com.au/2026/09/25/australia-west-bank-sanctions-israel-palestine-security-council/"><em>typically intrepid analysis in Crikey</em></a><em>, follows.</em></p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://urbanwronski.com/2026/09/25/the-appropriate-time-clarke-and-dawe-west-bank-settlements/"><em>http://urbanwronski.com</em></a><em> on September 25, 2026.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=df528fb2a6dd" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>