<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Derek Dintzner on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Derek Dintzner on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@ddintzner?source=rss-11f79233cfa6------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 01:20:35 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@ddintzner/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The 1980s Were Not a Play-It-Safe Decade: 10 American Action and Sci-Fi Films That Prove It]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ddintzner/the-1980s-were-not-a-play-it-safe-decade-10-american-action-and-sci-fi-films-that-prove-it-6e80fa059b92?source=rss-11f79233cfa6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6e80fa059b92</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[movies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[1980s]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[film-criticism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[film]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[action-movies]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Derek Dintzner]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 16 Nov 2026 07:41:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-11-17T16:02:22.289Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Steven Soderbergh and Quentin Tarantino call the ’80s a play-it-safe decade. The genre they’d point to as proof, mainstream action and sci-fi, says otherwise.</em></p><p><strong>The 1980s were not a play-it-safe decade.</strong> Two of the defining voices of 1990s independent film say they were. Soderbergh told <em>The Telegraph</em> that his debut, <em>Sex, Lies, and Videotape</em>, arrived at “the end of the worst decade of the American cinema.” Tarantino, in <em>Cinema Speculation</em>, calls the ’80s a “play-it-safe decade,” worse even than the ’50s, and blames self-censorship: filmmakers watering down their own ideas before a studio ever had to ask.</p><p>There’s a real industrial story behind that: The New Hollywood auteurs gave way to conglomerate ownership, and the decade filled up with high-concept comedies, assembly-line sequels and disposable action. But judging a decade by its filler is a trap. The 1970s had its own bloated disaster movies and early sequelitis, with weak follow-ups like <em>Jaws 2</em> and <em>Exorcist II: The Heretic</em>. But shouldn’t every era should be defined by its peaks?</p><p>And Tarantino’s own account has a wrinkle because he carves out a short list of exceptions: Lynch, Verhoeven, Abel Ferrara, Terry Gilliam, De Palma and Cronenberg. So the argument isn’t whether the ’80s had daring filmmakers. It’s whether they were exceptions or something closer to the rule. I think they were closer to the rule, and the best evidence is in the genre both men would call the most corporate: mainstream action and science fiction. These ten films are arguably the best that genre has produced. They have stood the test of time, and they remain the template for action films today.</p><p>Each of these ten American action films is judged on three tests:</p><ul><li><strong>It took a risk.</strong> A real tonal or commercial gamble inside a major release.</li><li><strong>It set a template.</strong> Later films spent years remixing it.</li><li><strong>It still works.</strong> Clear staging, tight storytelling, nothing wasted.</li></ul><p>Here they are in release order.</p><h3>The Ten</h3><h3>1. The Empire Strikes Back (1980)</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5Dn2IlImMu78mvubivmNpQ.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Proves: Tarantino says ’80s films were turned into morality plays. The biggest film of 1980 ended in defeat.</strong></p><p><strong>The risk.</strong> After the 1977 original, the safe move was a victory lap. Irvin Kershner and George Lucas split the heroes apart for most of the runtime, froze Han in carbonite, took Luke’s hand and gave him the worst news of his life. Then they ended it unresolved. Lucas financed the film himself, so no studio note was going to soften it.</p><p><strong>The craft.</strong> Kershner lets quiet scenes breathe between set pieces and cross-cuts between separate storylines so the dread builds in parallel. The Battle of Hoth scatters the cast instead of resetting them.</p><p><strong>Why it holds up.</strong> Every scene is character driven. The drama comes from character, not spectacle: Luke’s training, Han and Leia’s capture, the Vader reveal. Nothing resets after a set piece, so the stakes carry forward and it still plays as a tragedy.</p><h3>2. Raiders of the Lost Ark (1981)</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-KFpybpy7WBmlKer1Gcelg.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Proves: Tarantino says every ’80s character had to be likeable. Indiana Jones is a mercenary grave-robber whom his adversary Belloq calls his own reflection.</strong></p><p><strong>The risk.</strong> Indiana Jones is a mercenary grave-robber who improvises, gets hurt and is often one step behind. In the climax he doesn’t beat the villains. He and Marion survive by shutting their eyes while the Ark does the work.</p><p><strong>The craft.</strong> Spielberg and cinematographer Douglas Slocombe stage the whole film with that clarity, not just the action. The opening temple, the truck chase and the fight at the flying wing are shot in high-contrast shadow with clear geography and steady escalation. But so are the classroom scene, the meeting with the government agents and Indy packing a suitcase as Brody arrives, where blocking and economy tell the story.</p><p><strong>Why it holds up.</strong> The stunts feel physical, the pacing never lets up and John Williams’s score drives the energy, so the action reads as real and believable. When you always know where everyone is, the cutting can be fast without ever being confusing. That clarity is the quality much later action cinema traded away for speed.</p><h3>3. First Blood (1982)</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Eb4DPJ0LVFbHAbGM5GkJvQ.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Proves: Tarantino says flawed ’80s heroes were redeemed by the last 20 minutes. Rambo ends in a breakdown, not redemption.</strong></p><p><strong>The risk.</strong> Ted Kotcheff’s film is about a traumatized Vietnam veteran hounded by a small-town sheriff. The enemy is American, and the single death in the film is a fall, not a showdown. It ends with Rambo breaking down over what the war did to him and how the country abandoned its soldiers.</p><p><strong>The craft.</strong> At 93 minutes it communicates Rambo’s isolation through terrain, framing and silence. The speeches are saved for the end, where they land.</p><p><strong>Why it holds up.</strong> The sequels turned him into a muscle action figure. The original is the uncomfortable one. The revenge Rambo takes at the end comes from an emotionally bruised place, not as a simple revenge fantasy release, and the film stays tightly focused on one man’s damage.</p><h3>4. Conan the Barbarian (1982)</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*s_ocyEHcf5L4riQHAmIZLw.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Proves: Tarantino says ’80s studios blocked anything overtly violent. Universal released a very hard R-rated comic-book epic.</strong></p><p><strong>The risk.</strong> John Milius made a very hard R-rated, grim meditation on vengeance, grief and fanaticism, with long stretches carried by Basil Poledouris’s score instead of dialogue. James Earl Jones’s Thulsa Doom plays less like a cartoon villain than a charismatic cult leader. It took a pulp and comic-book hero and kept him rooted in his graphic, violent world instead of softening him for an easier PG rating.</p><p><strong>The craft.</strong> Wide compositions, deliberate pacing and score-driven montage build a world the audience is trusted to sit inside.</p><p><strong>Why it holds up.</strong> It never winks. Plenty of later fantasy interrupts its own atmosphere with nervous jokes and over-explained lore. <em>Conan</em> commits.</p><h3>5. The Terminator (1984)</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*sdq99AxInyJEydw1T1ABdw.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Proves: With its bleak vision of nuclear annihilation, ruthless police station massacre, and downbeat ending where Sarah drives into a coming storm, it rejects every safe studio convention of the decade.</strong></p><p><strong>The risk.</strong> James Cameron fused time-travel sci-fi with the stalking rhythm of a slasher. Instead of softening the edges to court a broader audience, he made Arnold Schwarzenegger’s T-800 an expressionless, unstoppable killing machine who slaughters an entire police station after a single deadpan line delivered without a wink to the audience.</p><p><strong>The craft: </strong>A $6 million B-movie could be pure dread. Exposition all delivered in a gritty, neon-soaked, working-class Los Angeles car chase scene.</p><p><strong>Why it holds up: <em>The Terminator</em> has aged better than its own big-budget sequels and later sci-fi imitators because every scene serves a single, relentless forward momentum with zero narrative fat.</strong></p><h3>6. Aliens (1986)</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*FpgUSY1zSuwl6Td333fflA.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Proves: Tarantino says ’80s filmmakers abandoned the ‘70s’ unflinching look at social ills. Aliens shows overconfident American firepower collapsing, a clear Vietnam echo.</strong></p><p><strong>The risk.</strong> Turning Ridley Scott’s haunted house into a war movie could have been a louder retread. Cameron anchors it in Ripley’s trauma and in motherhood, and the colonial marines’ swagger collapses within minutes of first contact.</p><p><strong>The craft.</strong> The film spends its first stretch building characters and mapping the colony. When the fighting starts, you know every corridor, barricade and who is standing where.</p><p><strong>Why it holds up.</strong> It’s masterfully told, blending sci-fi, horror and action so that no single genre takes over. The real villain is Burke, the Weyland-Yutani executive willing to use Ripley and a child as incubators, so the spectacle carries an argument about corporate greed.</p><h3>7. Lethal Weapon (1987)</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*XCaHLmOZll70LmloOV7_5g.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Proves: Tarantino says ’80s cinema avoided complex, complicated leads. Lethal Weapon introduces its hero with a gun in his mouth.</strong></p><p><strong>The risk.</strong> Shane Black’s script and Richard Donner’s direction give Martin Riggs a loaded Beretta, a dead wife and a death wish. The comedy arrives afterward, in his friction with Roger Murtaugh, and it never erases what we’ve seen.</p><p><strong>The craft.</strong> Humor and action come out of character. Murtaugh’s family gives the film a counterweight, and the partnership becomes Riggs’s reason to keep going. The villains are ex-military operatives running a heroin ring.</p><p><strong>Why it holds up.</strong> The emotional center is real. Later buddy-cop films kept the banter and dropped the pain.</p><h3>8. Predator (1987)</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*qSvX4vb95PoYelykc5QwPg.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Proves: Tarantino says ’80s films ended in happy endings. Predator kills off the entire commando squad.</strong></p><p><strong>The risk.</strong> John McTiernan opens like every commando movie of the moment: elite squad, enormous guns, one-liners. He lets you enjoy it, then makes the firepower useless. By the third act Dutch survives with mud, fire and traps, and the dialogue nearly disappears.</p><p><strong>The craft.</strong> Tight control of point of view and jungle geography. The final duel is told almost entirely through blocking and suspense.</p><p><strong>Why it holds up.</strong> The monster is never over-explained. It stays primal because the film trusts the hunt to do the work.</p><h3>9. RoboCop (1987)</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*UlRrNoVHQNQzsNRITMc16A.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Proves: Tarantino says daring ’80s films were punished. RoboCop made over four times its budget.</strong></p><p><strong>The risk.</strong> Orion put Paul Verhoeven’s film into theaters in July 1987. It targets privatized policing, TV news and Reagan-era deregulation, and it stages Murphy’s death with brutal, near-religious weight. Verhoeven has said the ratings board rejected it eight times before it got an R. Tarantino counts Verhoeven among his exceptions, but this was a studio summer release, not a festival film.</p><p><strong>The craft.</strong> The satire does plot work. Media breaks and boardroom scenes drive the story, and then Murphy visits his old house and the jokes give way to real grief.</p><p><strong>Why it holds up.</strong> Tonal conviction. It’s crude on purpose, never careless, and the sincerity under the satire is why it still bites.</p><h3>10. Die Hard (1988)</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*SL-QYYeSt-f_3XXSWv1ZvA.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Proves: Soderbergh calls the ’80s the worst decade. He studied McTiernan to learn how to stage action for Haywire.</strong></p><p><strong>The risk.</strong> John McClane bleeds, is outgunned and has a marriage in trouble. Hans Gruber is a smart, charming thief posing as a terrorist, which turns the usual villain playbook inside out.</p><p><strong>The craft.</strong> McTiernan maps Nakatomi Plaza so clearly that the audience solves the tactical puzzle alongside McClane: floors, elevator shafts, detonators, weapons. Each space is set up as a tool or a threat before it’s used: the roof, the elevator shaft, the ducts and the unfinished floor. Cross-cutting between McClane, Gruber’s crew and the police outside keeps everyone’s position clear.</p><p><strong>Why it holds up.</strong> It became the template: one ordinary person trapped in a contained space against a superior, organized force, a premise still pitched as “Die Hard on a ___.” The engine is the hero. While Schwarzenegger and Stallone defined the era’s invincible action star, McClane limps, cuts his feet on glass and doubts himself, and that vulnerability makes the stakes feel real. Plenty of imitators copied the premise. Few copied the geography.</p><h3>The One That Got Away</h3><p>The first film I wanted on this list was George Miller’s <em>The Road Warrior</em> (1981). It most certainly belongs here, and it’s one of my personal favorites. A near-wordless loner, a ruined world, a convoy chase that still sets the standard for practical vehicle stunt work, and a hero who ends the film as a drifter, not a savior. But it’s Australian, and this list is about American films, so it sits just outside the frame.</p><p>It also points to something bigger. The ’80s weren’t only a great decade for American action. Around the world, filmmakers were pushing the genre in new directions: Miller in Australia, John Woo and Jackie Chan in Hong Kong, Katsuhiro Otomo’s <em>Akira</em> in Japan. Taken together, the decade gave us much of the vocabulary that action cinema still speaks.</p><p>Soderbergh himself leans on that decade’s craft. Preparing <em>Haywire</em>, he said he studied Spielberg, Cameron, McTiernan and Fincher because they stage action so you always know where you are. In 2014 he stripped <em>Raiders of the Lost Ark</em> of its color and dialogue to study its staging. None of that makes him wrong about the filler. It does make the verdict harder to hold at full volume.</p><h3>Bonus: Five Indie Films That Got There First</h3><p>Soderbergh’s story is that his 1989 debut opened the door for American independent film. These five were already through it.</p><h3>1. Stranger Than Paradise (1984)</h3><p><strong>Proves: an American indie style existed years before Sundance made it a brand.</strong> Jim Jarmusch shot it for roughly $100,000 on leftover black-and-white film stock, in long locked-off takes separated by black leader. It follows three drifters across New York, Cleveland and Florida, finds deadpan poetry in dead air, and won the Caméra d’Or at Cannes.</p><h3>2. Blood Simple (1984)</h3><p><strong>Proves: a debut feature could reinvent noir on investor money.</strong> Joel and Ethan Coen raised the budget from private investors in Minnesota and Texas. The plot is a chain of fatal misunderstandings in which no character ever has the full picture, and the suspense lives in dripping faucets, ceiling fans and one agonizing burial scene.</p><h3>3. Blue Velvet (1986)</h3><p><strong>Proves: a producer-financed film could tear the Reagan-era postcard open.</strong> Dino De Laurentiis’s company financed it after <em>Dune</em>, and Lynch took a cut in salary and budget to get final cut. The severed ear in a sunlit field leads into Frank Booth and a hypnotic nightmare under the suburban surface. Tarantino lists Lynch among his exceptions, and this is why.</p><h3>4. Drugstore Cowboy (1989)</h3><p><strong>Proves: an addiction drama didn’t need to moralize.</strong> After his micro-budget debut <em>Mala Noche</em> (1986), Gus Van Sant followed a crew robbing pharmacies across the Pacific Northwest in 1971, with Matt Dillon at the center. It neither romanticizes nor condemns them, and the dreamlike flourishes mirror their altered states without sensationalizing.</p><h3>5. Do the Right Thing (1989)</h3><p><strong>Proves: 1989 had a bolder American film than the one that won Cannes.</strong> Spike Lee, building on <em>She’s Gotta Have It</em> (1986), set one Brooklyn block on the hottest day of the summer and let a dispute over wall photos escalate into a riot. The film uses Dutch angles, direct-to-camera monologues and competing quotes from Martin Luther King Jr. and Malcolm X, and it refuses to let the viewer off the hook. It was released by Universal that summer. At Cannes it lost the Palme d’Or to <em>Sex, Lies, and Videotape</em>.</p><p><strong>Call the decade corporate. Call it uneven. But please don’t call it safe.</strong></p><h3>Sources</h3><ul><li><a href="https://faroutmagazine.co.uk/worst-decade-history-american-cinema-according-to-steven-soderbergh/">Soderbergh on the “worst decade” (Far Out, quoting <em>The Telegraph</em>), with Tarantino’s “play-it-safe” line</a></li><li><a href="https://faroutmagazine.co.uk/quentin-tarantino-names-only-uncompromising-directors-1980s/">Tarantino’s six exceptions and his self-censorship argument (Far Out)</a></li><li><a href="https://avclub.com/steven-soderbergh-1798229391">Soderbergh on studying Spielberg, Cameron and McTiernan for <em>Haywire</em> (The A.V. Club)</a></li><li><a href="https://time.com/3420178/steven-soderbergh-raiders-of-the-lost-ark">Soderbergh’s black-and-white, dialogue-free <em>Raiders</em> (Time)</a></li><li><a href="https://www.mentalfloss.com/article/65229/halt-citizen-15-facts-about-robocop"><em>RoboCop</em> and the MPAA, eight rejections per Verhoeven (Mental Floss)</a></li><li><a href="https://www.melonfarmers.co.uk/bbfc_cuts_robocop.htm"><em>RoboCop</em> earning over four times its budget (Melon Farmers)</a></li><li><a href="https://mentalfloss.com/article/56440/20-colorful-facts-about-blue-velvet"><em>Blue Velvet</em> financing and Lynch’s final-cut deal (Mental Floss)</a></li><li><a href="https://nzherald.co.nz/entertainment/a-film-career-built-on-videotape-sex-and-lies-too/LLJMZOFLSB3D2XDAKMUZEXNFJM"><em>Sex, Lies, and Videotape</em> beating <em>Do the Right Thing</em> at Cannes (NZ Herald)</a></li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6e80fa059b92" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Without Style, How Would the Substance Hold Up?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ddintzner/without-style-how-would-the-substance-hold-up-b01504d7d7eb?source=rss-11f79233cfa6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b01504d7d7eb</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[cinema]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[personal-essay]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[film]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[michael-mann]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[film-criticism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Derek Dintzner]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 14 Sep 2026 23:28:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-18T03:19:41.823Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Following a Trail of Cinematic Sensory Memories</strong></p><figure><img alt="Editorial collage of torn film stills, a 2026 *Variety* article about *Manhunter*, 1986 newspaper clippings and theater listings, and MTV and surveillance imagery. A red dashed path connects *Variety* to the circled 9:50 showtime and ends at a *Manhunter* advertisement, tracing the essay’s investigation." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*to18jvi2rP_iRpGrCX-ByQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Collage illustration by Author</figcaption></figure><h3><strong>01 — That’s Not the Review I Remember</strong></h3><blockquote><em>“It’s a movie I never get tired of seeing because it speaks to me.”</em></blockquote><p><strong>That was the line that jumped off the page. </strong>Others followed: “favorite thriller of all time” and “couldn’t get enough of its look and atmosphere.” They were from <a href="https://variety.com/2026/film/columns/manhunter-the-final-cut-the-greatest-thriller-of-our-time-1236815424/"><em>Variety</em>’s July 18, 2026 article</a> on <em>Manhunter</em>’s 40th-anniversary release. Owen Gleiberman couldn’t stop praising it. I can’t blame him; it has been one of my favorite films of the 1980s for decades. But when did <em>Manhunter </em>become this critically celebrated?</p><p>And yes, I love reading film critics — the precision of their attention, the arguments they build, and the record they leave of how a film met its moment. A review can preserve more than one person’s judgment. It can reveal what audiences expected, which cultural influences were being welcomed or resisted, what anxieties a period was working through, and what kinds of film language the period was prepared to recognize.</p><p>That curiosity is what sent me back to the reviews of <em>Manhunter</em>. This isn’t how I remember the critics writing about it: my memory of the critical reaction was something much less enthusiastic — somewhere in the orbit of too much style and not enough underneath. After forty years, though, I couldn’t remember their exact words — only the general attitude.</p><p>My memory of seeing <em>Manhunter </em>in the theater is much clearer, mostly because it happened by pure chance. I wanted to see<em> The Fly</em>, which opened that same mid-August weekend. We couldn’t get in — not because it was sold out, but because it was rated R, which can be troublesome when you’re fourteen. Somehow, ten minutes later, we were across the street watching <em>Manhunter </em>instead.</p><p>After forty years, I was curious how much of this I was actually remembering correctly, particularly that old review. I knew the weekend it opened — August 15, 1986 — so I started searching the Springfield newspaper archive.</p><figure><img alt="August 15, 1986 newspaper page showing The Fly review and ads for Manhunter and A Fine Mess at Palace Cinema." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*kb5tz0_RXa7mAX1NuKr3eg.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Springfield Daily News </strong>Friday, August 15, 1986: <em>The Fly</em> gets four stars. <em>Manhunter</em> is already playing across the street, but no review yet.</figcaption></figure><p>The first thing that caught my attention wasn’t <em>Manhunter</em> at all; it wasn’t even included in Friday’s paper. It was <em>The Fly</em>. Four stars. I remembered that. Somehow, some genius had made a four-star remake of <em>The Fly</em>, and I had to see it. At fourteen, a gory horror movie getting four stars felt almost unbelievable. I already loved movies like <em>The Thing </em>and <em>An American Werewolf in London</em> — not that I would have called them “body horror” then — and my impression was that critics simply didn’t embrace those kinds of movies the way I did. They spoke directly to my imagination as a young teenager.</p><p>So we tried buying tickets to <em>The Fly</em> and told the cashier we were eighteen. Right. That was going to work. This was at the Showcase Cinemas in West Springfield, Massachusetts, where the movies in that particular 1–4 section were all rated R that night. We were probably profiled the moment we walked through the glass doors. Our parents had already dropped us off and weren’t coming back for about two hours, so going home wasn’t really Plan B. It was a weekday late in August, summer almost over, with school starting in a few days.</p><figure><img alt="Newspaper movie listings with The Fly at 9:40 and Manhunter and A Fine Mess at 9:50 circled in red." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*QyMCXOlp-Ql0f_rV8N9KfQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong><em>Plan B, still sitting in the newspaper forty years later.</em></strong><em> </em>The Fly<em> at 9:40. </em>Manhunter<em> and </em>A Fine Mess<em> at 9:50. </em><strong>Springfield Daily News</strong></figcaption></figure><p>The listings gave us another option. <em>Manhunter</em> started ten minutes after <em>The Fly</em>, and <em>A Fine Mess </em>— the PG movie we could actually buy tickets for — started at exactly the same time. Both were at the Palace, across Riverdale Street from the Showcase. The Palace was a two-screen movie house and we knew how the ticket and concession setup worked. The individual screen doors weren’t watched nearly as tightly as they were at the Showcase, so if we could buy a ticket, we could probably get into <em>Manhunter</em>. We had used this technique before.</p><figure><img alt="Exterior of the Palace 1–2, a glass-fronted modernist cinema beneath a zigzag roof and green rooftop sign." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*G9KA3zx5OnoL-5Zzl75GsQ.png" /><figcaption><strong>The Palace 1–2.</strong> Across Riverdale Street from Showcase Cinemas West Springfield. Opened in 1968 by E.M. Loew Theatres, the Palace began as a 1,000-seat, single-screen theater before Sack Theatres twinned the auditorium in the mid-1970s. It closed in 2002 and was demolished in 2006.</figcaption></figure><p>There was still a gamble: what if we got caught and actually had to watch <em>A Fine Mess</em>? That sounded bad to us forty years ago and, ugh, it still sounds bad today. But <em>Manhunter </em>itself sounded interesting. I liked thrillers, I watched Miami Vice and thought it was okay, and this was from the guy behind it. So we sprinted across, bought tickets to <em>A Fine Mess</em>, went down the ramp and turned through the unpoliced <em>Manhunter </em>door. There were only a handful of people in the theater, but we made it in while the previews were still finishing.</p><p>The funny thing is that none of this was why I had opened the archive; those memories were already pretty strong. I was really looking for the old <em>Manhunter </em>review. I thought it would be in Friday’s paper alongside <em>The Fly</em>, but I had to move ahead to Saturday, August 16. Once I found it there, I remembered that the paper tended to push the more so-so reviews to the next day. Richard Freedman gave the movie two stars under the headline “‘Manhunter’ Fails as Thriller.” Reading it again, it was much closer to the criticism I remembered. The style wasn’t something Freedman overlooked; it was part of what he didn’t like about the movie.</p><figure><img alt="Top of Richard Freedman’s two-star Manhunter review beneath the headline ‘Manhunter Fails as Thriller.’" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*BBLiJ9RAFBJ4V_NoU-7HEg.png" /><figcaption><strong>Springfield Daily News </strong>Saturday, August 16, 1986: Richard Freedman review “‘Manhunter’ Fails as Thriller.”</figcaption></figure><p>What I remember feeling about <em>Manhunter </em>is that it didn’t simply look different, although it certainly did. There was dread throughout the film and some genuinely scary moments — the wheelchair sequence especially — but there was also a grounded distance I wasn’t used to. I had seen <em>Aliens</em> only a few weeks earlier. That was rated R too, but it told its story in a way that spoke directly to fourteen-year-old me. <em>Manhunter </em>felt more adult, not because of the rating, but because of the way it expected me to watch it.</p><h3>02 — Professionals at Work</h3><p>One thing that stood out was watching professionals work through the procedures. The movie didn’t stop to explain every step or turn every discovery into melodrama. Graham studies photographs, videotapes, crime scenes and evidence. People speak in professional shorthand, wait for information, test ideas and work through problems. This was years before CSI made that kind of forensic procedure part of popular television grammar, and here were blue laboratory lights, scientists working alongside detectives, infrared revealing writing beneath felt-tip pen. At fourteen, all of this was new to me, and I was fascinated by the process itself.</p><p>Two scenes in particular stayed with me after that first viewing. One was Lecktor being handed a wired telephone in his cell to speak with his lawyer. Mann gives the exchange an unusual amount of procedural detail: the guard has Lecktor turn around, unlocks the cell and carefully follows the security routine for passing the phone inside. We watch all these precautions being taken around someone they clearly understand is dangerous, and Lecktor still finds an opening. He gets the foil from a stick of gum and uses it to manipulate the phone connection, eventually getting the access he needs to start tracking down Graham’s home address. There’s no chase or big dramatic payoff; it’s a very intelligent and dangerous person solving a practical problem step by step.</p><figure><img alt="Two frames show Hannibal Lecktor behind white bars and a hand using foil to manipulate the wired telephone connection." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*o88JVaEgLHILkDhhuu58tA.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Manhunter </strong>(1986). Telephone sequence</figcaption></figure><p>The other was Graham’s “You’ve seen these films” realization, probably the most intense emotional response I had to anything in the movie. The scene begins with tense banter between Graham and Crawford, arguing about stopping for the evening. Then Graham happens to catch a quick frame of a padlock on the television. He starts following the thought, slowly and methodically talking himself through what he’s seeing. Only then does the music begin to fade in. As the pieces start connecting, it builds with him until Graham finally understands what Dolarhyde had seen and how the two families were connected. I remember the hairs on my arms standing up. The realization, the gradual arrival of the music and Graham suddenly understanding what he’d been looking for are all part of the same memory for me.</p><figure><img alt="Split frame pairs a grainy television close-up of a padlock with Will Graham reacting to his discovery." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*6tpV3wb-We-hDBDYvkYfVQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Manhunter </strong>(1986). “A padlock. That’s why the bolt cutter.” Detective Graham realizes the crucial connection that puts the “You’ve seen these films” sequence in motion.</figcaption></figure><p>What strikes me now is how little music there actually is in the two scenes I remembered most clearly from a movie that was so often described as “MTV.” Lecktor’s telephone sequence plays entirely through procedure and sound. No music. The home-video realization scene begins without music too. <strong>The music wasn’t constant. It was surgical.</strong></p><p>Those were the two scenes I was already thinking about on the car ride home: one because I was fascinated by the intelligence of the procedure, the other because of the emotional rush of the realization.</p><p>My memories of <em>Manhunter</em> also fragment across all that white — modern white. White rooms. White walls. White light. Glass. Those strong geometric compositions.</p><figure><img alt="Nine-frame collage of stark white rooms, geometric architecture, investigators at work and Graham imagining a victim in bed." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*oDcfi_M3vSqU2b_wbfAdxA.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Manhunter</strong> (1986)</figcaption></figure><p>Many of those spaces weren’t futuristic sets at all. Mann was finding them in Atlanta — the High Museum of Art, the Woodruff Arts Center, the Marriott Marquis, the Westin Peachtree Plaza — and using real architecture to create a movie that could look strangely unreal. I eventually went to college in Atlanta, so forty years later my memories of the film and my own experience of some of those places blur together a little. But that first impression remains: the world felt real even when it looked strangely unreal.</p><figure><img alt="Upward view through the Marriott Marquis atrium, with curving balconies, a glass elevator, hanging sculpture and wall of greenery." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4YXzpocGLYshTYhhx1IE3w.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Manhunter </strong>(1986). The Marriott Marquis Atlanta served as Graham’s hotel.</figcaption></figure><p>Those details and places help create a world that keeps me revisiting the film as both a teenager and as an adult today. It can feel measured, professional and almost emotionally distant, then become intensely expressive without announcing that it has changed modes. You can tell how much the work is affecting Graham, but the movie doesn’t punctuate it in the usual ways.</p><p>Mann described Graham as someone “trapped, stuck to some degree in madness and nightmare.” In the same period he said something that seems almost contradictory to everything I remembered about those real locations and procedures: “It bores me to present the events of the story in a realist style.” He followed that with, “My aim is to exteriorize the spiritual in the Expressionist manner.”</p><blockquote>“<strong>It bores me to present the events of the story in a realist style…My aim is to exteriorize the spiritual in the Expressionist manner.” — Michael Mann</strong></blockquote><p>That’s not how I remember the movie feeling as a teenager — real locations, real procedures, people doing actual work. But watching it now, maybe reality and expression aren’t opposites at all. It reminds me of something basic in color theory: put a saturated color against something muted or gray and the color can appear even more intense. You haven’t necessarily changed the color; you’ve changed what surrounds it.</p><p>Maybe Mann is doing something similar. The procedure, real locations and professional behavior establish a grounded baseline, while the more expressive choices seem to pull us closer to Graham’s inner experience. The realism isn’t necessarily competing with the Expressionism; it may be giving it contrast. That becomes especially clear in the way Mann handles violence.</p><h3>03— What We Don’t See — and How We Finally See It</h3><p>For a movie about a serial killer, <em>Manhunter</em> shows surprisingly little of what Dolarhyde actually does. Starting with the opening, we follow the beam of a flashlight upstairs until it settles on a woman asleep beside her husband. She wakes, disoriented by the light in her eyes, but she hasn’t even had time to understand what she’s waking up to.</p><p>Later, Graham stands in the house and reconstructs what happened in the master bedroom that now looks like a grotesque Jackson Pollock painting. He speaks flatly into his tape recorder: “Direction and velocity of bloodstains on the east wall indicate arterial spray… Even with his throat cut, Mr. Leeds tried to fight because the intruder was moving to the children’s room.”</p><figure><img alt="Will Graham, dressed in black, stands against a pale bedroom wall beside a small vase of white flowers." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xQy-hhz7yftP-gJt6cTYtg.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Manhunter </strong>(1986). Leeds master bedroom crime scene.</figcaption></figure><p>What he’s describing is horrifying, but the scene remains distanced and measured. Mann doesn’t underline it with an unnecessary musical beat or a flashback showing us exactly what happened.</p><p>Eventually, though, we do see what Dolarhyde did: the crime-scene photographs.</p><p>Graham is on a commercial flight at twilight, studying the case. Watching the scene again now, what strikes me first is how physical the flight feels. There’s the constant hiss of pressurized air circulating through the cabin, the engine rattle underneath it, and slight irregular movement that feels like the mild turbulence of a real flight. Seat backs, windows, overhead compartments and other passengers keep getting into the compositions. It’s cramped. The changing light outside remains visible.</p><p><strong>I remember the airplane feeling different even at fourteen. It felt like an actual flight rather than a movie set.</strong></p><p>Years later, I came across the story of how Mann filmed it. Producer Jon Landau recalled Mann insisting there was “no faking the hum and ambience of a real flight.” Mann wanted that grounded reality badly enough to shoot guerrilla-style on an actual commercial flight.</p><figure><img alt="Four-frame collage shows a commercial airplane cabin, Graham reviewing family photographs and a large boat engine hoisted above a sailboat." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*eobHvwiozovEr0_2u6GhdA.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Manhunter </strong>(1986). Interiors shot aboard a real commercial flight, not a set. Graham’s dream takes hold.</figcaption></figure><p>As Graham studies photographs of the two families clipped to his evidence folder, that grounded reality begins to give way. The cramped cabin opens into blue sky. An engine hangs overhead. Molly appears completely out of focus. Graham is suddenly on a boat. Kitaro’s “Seiun” replaces the hiss and rattle of the airplane.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FPmPfU0-3o5o%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DPmPfU0-3o5o&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FPmPfU0-3o5o%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/f04c75c202eaf23a7aa6282ca0d0e466/href">https://medium.com/media/f04c75c202eaf23a7aa6282ca0d0e466/href</a></iframe><p>But the flight never completely disappears. Mann cuts back to the twilight outside the window, then Graham asleep in his seat, before returning to Molly. The real flight and Graham’s dream seem to bleed into each other.</p><figure><img alt="Dreamlike four-frame montage of Molly walking through tropical greenery and along a dock, Graham on a sailboat and asleep on the airplane." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8eTndKbD1MikwES_UAiMGA.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Manhunter </strong>(1986)</figcaption></figure><p>Then something intrudes. As the dream moves back and forth between close-ups of Molly and Graham, Mann suddenly cuts through a series of close-ups from the crime-scene photographs. <strong>The music breaks and the cabin air returns.</strong> For a moment, the images feel as if they might still belong to Graham — as if the case has broken into the safe place he had retreated to.</p><figure><img alt="Four-frame montage contrasts close-ups of Graham and Molly with bloodstained crime-scene photographs and a young girl seated on the airplane." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*os93wKambzyYqlbjSglIYg.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Manhunter </strong>(1986)</figcaption></figure><p>Only then does Mann pull back and show us what we’re actually looking at: the photographs lying open in Graham’s folder on the cabin tray. A shot of the girl beside him establishes a new point of view. She screams, eventually waking Graham, and her mother calls frantically for the stewardess. Underneath her voice there’s an almost perfect rise in the engine sound. It’s still plausible aircraft noise, but for a moment the environment itself seems to join her panic.</p><figure><img alt="Split-screen close-ups show a woman holding a child in the airplane cabin and Graham waking in the adjacent seat." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*yQo0CepzaW-2y08XMN25_A.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Manhunter </strong>(1986)</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Mann doesn’t always have to leave reality to become expressive. Sometimes he turns up what’s already there.</strong></p><p>But the airplane sequence isn’t an isolated flourish. As Graham gets closer to understanding Dolarhyde, Mann pushes that expressionism much further.</p><p>When Graham returns to that master bedroom with an additional insight, he begins to see something that wasn’t there before. The victim appears alive on the bed, looking back at him, and her eyes suddenly glow like two points of light. “In the silver mirrors of your eyes,” Graham says to himself as he slips further into the mind of the Tooth Fairy. There’s an eerie silence to the scene, with almost nothing on the soundtrack except Graham’s own voice.</p><figure><img alt="Four views show Graham entering a stark white bedroom and imagining Mrs. Leeds alive beneath white sheets." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*DU-J_kAjfcY5xjoL-XgMfA.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Manhunter </strong>(1986). Graham begins to see something that isn’t physically there.</figcaption></figure><p>What follows makes that scene even stronger. Mann takes us almost directly from Graham slipping into Dolarhyde’s mind to Dolarhyde himself sitting outside Reba’s house, but almost everything about the atmosphere changes. Dolarhyde watches Reba with a coworker outside her door, and what he’s actually seeing begins to slip into what he imagines he’s seeing. He imagines the man touching Reba, imagines the attraction between them, and his desire for her becomes tangled with jealousy. All of it unfolds to “Strong as I Am,” pushing the scene even further into his emotional state.</p><figure><img alt="Four-frame night sequence shows Dolarhyde watching from a dark car and imagining Reba with another man." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*eEB8FI7Wpcvmd245E_7qHw.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Manhunter </strong>(1986). Dolarhyde sees something that isn’t physically there either.</figcaption></figure><p>The scenes look and sound almost completely different, but they’re doing something remarkably similar. Graham is beginning to see through Dolarhyde’s eyes; a moment later, we’re seeing through Dolarhyde’s.</p><p>Seen together, Mann’s description of wanting to ‘exteriorize the spiritual’ isn’t a contradiction anymore — it’s the same color-theory idea, applied to feeling instead of light. Graham’s ability to understand Dolarhyde is the narrative, and as he gets further inside his mind, the movie’s images seem capable of going there with him.</p><h3>04 — What Did MTV Actually Look Like in 1986?</h3><p>There was one problem with the trail I had started following. Freedman never actually called <em>Manhunter </em>“MTV.” Somewhere along the way I had folded that into my memory of the criticism around the movie. So I started looking at other reviews and coverage from the time. That’s where the language started to shift. On opening day, <em>Los Angeles Times</em> critic Sheila Benson connected the film directly to <em>Miami Vice</em>. She liked parts of it — especially Lektor, Dolarhyde and Reba — but thought the soundtrack could overwhelm the action. Her final concern was blunt:</p><blockquote>“style has overrun content”<br> — Sheila Benson, Los Angeles Times, August 15, 1986</blockquote><p>That was much closer to the criticism I had been carrying around in my head. Paul Attanasio in <em>The Washington Post</em> saw many of the same qualities and responded very differently. He called <em>Manhunter </em>“gory and gorgeous,” praised its electronic music and visual design, and then wrote something that hardly sounds like it came from 1986:</p><blockquote>“form is content in Manhunter.”<br> — Paul Attanasio, The Washington Post, August 1986</blockquote><p><em>The New York Times</em> review from that same opening weekend went even further.</p><p>Reading Walter Goodman’s review now, I had another version of the same experience. He wasn’t missing the things I remembered about <em>Manhunter</em>. If anything, he was identifying them pretty clearly. He wrote that the movie could “work on your senses” and called it, at its best, a “snappy police procedural.” But the odd camera angles, fancy lighting and crashing music were something else. To Goodman, they kept diverting attention away from the story until, as he put it, you could see the “gimmicks in the magician’s bag.”</p><figure><img alt="New York Times review clipping titled ‘Screen: Manhunter,’ with Walter Goodman criticizing the film’s angles, lighting and music." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/946/1*zfMdBcdEQvEJkHk7SkhUog.png" /><figcaption><strong>NY Times </strong>August 15, 1986, Section C, Page 6</figcaption></figure><p>What struck me wasn’t that Goodman had somehow failed to see what Mann was doing. He saw much of it. He even separated Graham’s eventual breakthrough from any psychological affinity with Dolarhyde, crediting it instead to “intelligent deduction.” But after spending all this time looking again at the procedure, the airplane, the white bedroom and Graham slipping into the mind of the Tooth Fairy, that separation stands out to me much more now.</p><p>The music is interesting too. Benson worried the soundtrack could overwhelm the action; Goodman noticed it too. But going back through the film, I was becoming more aware of how selectively Mann actually uses it. The two scenes I remembered most clearly from that first viewing were built largely without it. Lecktor’s telephone sequence has none. Graham’s home-video breakthrough begins without it, and the music only starts to emerge once his deduction is already underway. Even for a movie so frequently associated with MTV, <em>Manhunter</em> largely avoids one of the most familiar clichés of 1980s filmmaking: the song-driven montage.</p><p>Those qualities didn’t suddenly appear in <em>Manhunter</em> as its reputation grew. They were right there in 1986, and Goodman saw many of them. <strong>What changed was how those qualities were understood.</strong> The lighting, the music, the unusual relationship between realism and expression — things that could once be treated as distractions from the thriller — are now among the reasons the film is celebrated.</p><p>That language wasn’t confined to <em>Manhunter</em>, either. The same argument was already following Mann through <em>Miami Vice</em>; NBC’s Brandon Tartikoff had pushed back on criticism of the show as having “too much reliance on style and not enough on substance.”</p><figure><img alt="Four images from the Miami Vice opening credits: neon logo, a horse race, a Rolls-Royce grille and pink flamingos." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*U1zl5pesIzFhO15XxsG7LQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Miami Vice</strong> 1984–1989</figcaption></figure><p>Two weeks after <em>Manhunter</em> opened, a <em>Los Angeles Times</em> commentary described <em>Miami Vice</em> as operating under an “MTV throb.” When <em>Manhunter</em> reached home video in early 1987, the same paper described its “MTV-style visuals” as part of the <em>Miami Vice</em> connection.</p><p>Okay. So MTV really was part of the vocabulary around Mann’s work. Just not in the Freedman review I had started with. <strong>But what exactly did “MTV” mean in 1986?</strong></p><p>For a reader who didn’t live through the 1980s, the comparison may not mean much at all. MTV had only been on the air for five years when <em>Manhunter</em> opened, but by the summer of 1986 its influence on youth culture was enormous. Music videos had become a place where music, photography, fashion, advertising, editing, animation and short-form filmmaking could collide in a few minutes.</p><p><strong>And there wasn’t one MTV look.</strong></p><figure><img alt="Grid of nine MTV station logos rendered with different colors, patterns and hand-drawn textures." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Tmpbo6qKdlkUP6moVcl4Hw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Even MTV’s station IDs refused to settle on a single look. The logo stayed; almost everything around it could change.</figcaption></figure><p>Peter Gabriel’s “Sledgehammer,” released that year, is almost the pure abstract version of the idea: stop-motion, Claymation, practical effects, bodies and objects transforming according to rhythm and visual association. Conventional dramatic continuity is barely the point. Directed by Stephen R. Johnson, with animation from Aardman and the Brothers Quay, it brought very different traditions of stop-motion and experimental animation into something suddenly playing in heavy rotation on MTV.</p><figure><img alt="Six-frame Sledgehammer collage combines Peter Gabriel close-ups, stop-motion food, animation and dancing plucked chickens." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*G9shvwb1wZtrrVB5Ac6w8A.jpeg" /><figcaption>Peter Gabriel, “Sledgehammer” (1986). One song, assembled from an almost absurd variety of visual techniques.</figcaption></figure><p>Then look at Madonna’s “Papa Don’t Preach,” the number-one song in America during August 1986. Almost the opposite approach. The video builds a compact dramatic narrative around the song: a young woman, her father, her boyfriend, pregnancy, conflict, reconciliation. The staging and photography feel much closer to conventional mid-’80s television drama than to what people may now imagine when they hear “MTV style.”</p><figure><img alt="Six-frame Papa Don’t Preach collage shows Madonna by the waterfront, riding with her boyfriend, confronting her father and dancing against black." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*nZ4BDF9iSc-M9a82w_oBYA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Madonna, “Papa Don’t Preach” (1986). Almost the opposite approach: character, location and a compact dramatic narrative.</figcaption></figure><p>Both were MTV. Which made the label less useful as a description of a particular look — and more interesting as a description of an approach. What had music video taught filmmakers they could do with music and images? Maybe that was closer to what people were reacting to in <em>Manhunter</em>: not simply a movie that looked like a music video, but one where music, image, editing, color, sound and design were all part of the expression. Maybe the critics weren’t wrong to see MTV. They were recognizing a new expressive relationship between music and image — and a generation already learning how to read it. Mann himself sounded frustrated by the shorthand. In a 1987 interview he said some <em>Manhunter </em>reviews were basically reviews of the second season of Miami Vice.</p><blockquote>“To me, there’s film form and there’s film content, and one complements the other.”<br> — Michael Mann, Los Angeles Times, 1987</blockquote><p>He went on to make the distinction even clearer: style becomes gratuitous when it isn’t doing something to tell the story. That seems remarkably close to the question I had backed into forty years later. Maybe “style over substance” wasn’t describing two separate things at all. Maybe the real question was whether the form was carrying part of the substance. And of course Mann wasn’t developing that language in isolation.</p><h3>05 — <strong>The Advertising Connection</strong></h3><p>By this point, curiosity had turned this into something of a research project. That wasn’t really the plan. I’d started by looking for an old <em>Manhunter </em>review because I remembered it differently, and now I was digging into Mann’s background, old interviews, commercials, music videos and other filmmakers who seemed to keep turning up along the same trail. Apparently I was investigating this now. Some of Mann’s background was already familiar to me. He was from Chicago, but studied film in London and came up through advertising before returning to the United States. I couldn’t have told you exactly where I’d first read that; it was one of those pieces of film history I’d picked up years ago and apparently held onto.</p><figure><img alt="Black-and-white photograph of a young Michael Mann holding a cigarette while seated among other London Film School students." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*c_GDzpCc8YYVUtxspMhi_Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>Michael Mann at the London Film School, 1967. Image source: <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2022/07/20/magazine/michael-mann-ferrari-heat-2.html"><em>The New York Times Magazine</em>, July 20, 2022</a>.</figcaption></figure><p>There was probably a personal reason it stuck. I was briefly a film major at Syracuse, which meant plenty of nights watching movies and debating them afterward. Somewhere in all of that, I had become familiar with a group of directors I remembered as coming out of the British advertising world around the same period: Ridley Scott, Tony Scott, Alan Parker and Adrian Lyne.</p><p>Working in advertising teaches you pretty quickly that a thirty-second commercial may be thirty seconds long, but that doesn’t mean you have thirty seconds of someone’s attention. The most successful ones find ways to communicate almost immediately — through an image, a piece of music, an edit, an atmosphere — sometimes before you’ve even processed exactly what you’re seeing.</p><figure><img alt="Four black-and-white frames from Ridley Scott’s Radiant detergent commercial show a woman dancing, a man dressing and a box of washing powder." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/696/1*cLO5Xh9h285Ek9wFVuNCzw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Radiant Commercial 1968 — The ad featured Ridley Scott’s signature visual traits — meticulous composition, realistic texture, and high-contrast lighting.</figcaption></figure><p>And maybe that’s why the old criticism interests me differently now. When someone says a movie looks “too much like a commercial,” what exactly are we dismissing? The ability to communicate through images? Through music? Through design? Those aren’t necessarily things sitting on top of a story. They’re some of the tools filmmakers have for telling it. The British advertising directors were arriving in features with years of practice using those tools under extreme time constraints, and that visual economy became part of a film language audiences would eventually become very accustomed to reading.</p><p>Ridley Scott is an obvious place to look. <em>Alien</em> and <em>Blade Runner</em> are now almost too established as examples, but what’s worth noting here isn’t simply how extraordinary those worlds look. It’s how <strong>lived-in</strong> they feel. In <em>Alien</em>, Scott gives the crew ordinary reality before anything extraordinary happens. They complain about pay, worry about their shares, deal with hierarchy and repairs, eat together and bring office politics with them into space. Even the much more overtly designed world of <em>Blade Runner</em> feels accumulated from lived-in details rather than assembled simply to look futuristic.</p><figure><img alt="Nostromo crew members eat together around a cluttered white table beneath the ship’s industrial fixtures." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*JD7cENOxZeeccIXkipCbww.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong><em>Alien</em> </strong>(1979). Lived-in details.</figcaption></figure><p>Tony Scott belongs in this conversation because <em>Top Gun</em> opened in May 1986, the same summer as <em>Manhunter</em>, and became a massive box-office success. There are strands of the same DNA in both films. Top Gun is remembered for sunsets, music, slow motion, montage and highly controlled imagery, but underneath that polish is an enormous investment in the physical world being filmed: real aircraft, real carriers and equipment, authentic gear and research into that environment. The imagery, sound and music work together, but they have something tangible underneath them. That’s the same instinct behind Mann insisting on a real commercial flight for the airplane sequence in <em>Manhunter</em>. The scale is completely different, but the instinct is familiar: get the physical reality right, then stylize it.</p><figure><img alt="Two naval aircraft fly low over a sunlit ocean beneath a gold-and-gray clouded sky." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*bAubVv4mANOgvvqL1pDxdA.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Top Gun</strong> (1986)</figcaption></figure><p>Adrian Lyne takes those instincts somewhere else. <em>Flashdance</em> may be an even easier place to understand where the “looks like MTV” criticism came from. The whole movie is beautifully photographed, but the dance sequences at Mawby’s push that visual language particularly far. It makes almost no sense if you stop to think about it. It’s supposedly a working-class Pittsburgh bar, yet Alex and the other dancers somehow perform on elaborate sets with theatrical lighting, costumes and choreography. The moment someone steps onto that stage, Lyne seems perfectly willing to leave the reality of the bar behind and let the expression of the moment take over.</p><figure><img alt="Four-frame Flashdance collage shows Mawby’s neon sign, Alex dancing against tiled walls, a Pittsburgh street and the water-chair performance." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Q-O50xb52F3M1CDYCIUBaQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Flashdance </strong>(1983)</figcaption></figure><p>Like <em>Top Gun</em>, audiences embraced the movie immediately. “Flashdance… What a Feeling” became a massive hit on the radio, and the music video carried those same images out of the theater and into heavy MTV rotation. The movie, the song and those images became almost impossible to separate. And <em>Flashdance </em>wasn’t the first film to do that. Just a few years earlier, <em>Fame </em>had sent its own title song out into the culture, becoming a major hit independent of the movie. That film was directed by Alan Parker.</p><p><em>Fame</em>, <em>Midnight Express</em>, and <em>Mississippi Burning</em> are the films most associated with Alan Parker. But <em>Angel Heart</em> is the film that I remember.</p><h3>06 — The Parts Between the Plot</h3><p>Angel Heart’s reputation on release wasn’t about atmosphere or immersion. It was about the controversy. Once I rented it, though, it became one of those movies that stayed in rotation through high school. Part of the appeal was simply following the investigation — Harry Angel moving from place to place, talking to people and following leads — but it was also the cumulative effect of spending two hours inside that world.</p><p>Even the mundane details of the investigation lingered. For example, I remember the melting snow in some ways as much as I remember parts of the plot.</p><figure><img alt="Four-frame winter montage shows Harry Angel walking through dirty snow, shoes pressing into slush and wet 1950s New York streets." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*JlxywzxdXjCncKdmOT0Xcw.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Angel Heart</strong> (1987). Slush as texture. Physical details made the 1950s setting feel lived-in rather than dressed for the period.</figcaption></figure><p>New Orleans stayed with me in a different way, which is strange considering I’ve never actually been there. What I remember isn’t the familiar shorthand I would have associated with the city — Bourbon Street, Mardi Gras, the landmarks that usually tell you immediately where a movie has taken you. Parker seems to scrub most of that away. What remains are smaller details that made the city feel less like an image of New Orleans I’d seen somewhere else and more like a specific place at a specific moment in time — somewhere Harry was actually moving through in the 1950s.</p><figure><img alt="Four-frame New Orleans montage includes street musicians, a red streetcar, Harry Angel walking downtown and a crowd gathered in shallow water." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-j12kxy580meEcVMWyDy9Q.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Angel Heart</strong> (1987). Some of these scenes so much part of the plot as they’re simply part of the city Harry is moving through.</figcaption></figure><p>Another lead takes him into a club, but Parker doesn’t cut straight to the questioning. We stay with Angel while he watches the man perform a song, and only afterward does he approach him. Music is almost impossible to separate from all of this. Sometimes Parker scores Angel’s movement through the city; here, the music is already part of the place when he arrives. The investigation has to move through it too.</p><figure><img alt="Two frames show Toots Sweet singing and playing guitar in a smoky club while Harry Angel listens from the audience." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*MJuQpsCNmgoYyAgsMWAzLw.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Angel Heart </strong>(1987). Toots Sweet played by real-life blues musician Brownie McGhee.</figcaption></figure><p><em>Angel Heart</em> has much bigger images than these: the voodoo ritual, the nightmare sex scene, the murders. Those are probably the scenes you’d pull out if you were making a trailer, but they’re not what sustained the movie for me. I wanted to stay inside all of it — the investigation, the travel, the music, the ordinary moments between the major ones. The investigation becomes a way of traveling through the world.</p><p>And maybe that’s part of why I always found myself watching Angel Heart so many times. The world works best in sequence: New York into New Orleans, one lead into another, one place into the next. The texture between the scenes is part of the experience.</p><h3>07 — <strong>Parker Was Worried About the Snow Too</strong></h3><blockquote>“To be somewhere that smells right as well as looks right somehow helps to make the ‘make-believe’ believable.”<br>- Alan Parker, on Angel Heart</blockquote><p>I found that line in Parker’s production notes for <em>Angel Heart</em>. The notes are full of the kind of physical detail I’d been noticing in the movie. Parker describes looking at dozens of locations, searching for places that could convincingly become 1955 New York and New Orleans. Buildings, streets, interiors, weather — the period had to exist beyond costumes and props. Even the snow was something he had to contend with. As the New York shoot continued, the winter conditions changed. The snow melted and became dirtier. Watching the movie now, I think that messiness is part of why those streets stuck with me. It feels authentic — the opposite of the perfectly art-directed snow I was used to seeing in movies.</p><figure><img alt="Alan Parker gestures beside Mickey Rourke and a crew member on a wintry, partially cleared New York location." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-BaPSm8MpYLHsM8fyFiotg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Alan Parker on location with Mickey Rourke during the filming of <strong><em>Angel Heart</em>.</strong> The production required 78 different locations, all of which had to feel authentic to 1955. Source: Alan Parker’s official website, <a href="https://alanparker.com/film/angel-heart/making/">“Angel Heart: The Making of the Film, Beat by Beat.”</a></figcaption></figure><p>The physical details make it feel lived-in and rooted in an exact moment in time, while the supernatural remains fragmented and mysterious, leaving your imagination to fill in what the movie never completely explains. It’s a rich enough world to get lost in, and maybe that’s part of what kept inviting me back.</p><p>The closer I looked at these filmmakers, the stranger that old “style over substance” shorthand became. Underneath so much of the style was an almost obsessive attention to physical reality: procedure, ordinary behavior, real locations, weather, machinery, sound. The style is what I noticed first. But what stayed with me seems to have been grounded in something authentic.</p><h3>08— Cult Movies, Context and What We Return To</h3><blockquote>“I’m a big fan of Alan Parker’s Angel Heart.” — Christopher Nolan</blockquote><p><em>Angel Heart</em> is still generally described as a cult film. <em>Manhunter </em>had carried that description for years. So did <em>Blade Runner</em>. So what do I mean by a cult film? <strong>For me, a cult film creates a world that invites repeated viewing, even while the film itself sits outside general audience tastes.</strong></p><p>That repeated viewing can happen for all kinds of reasons. Camp. Transgression. Irony. Even the pleasure of something being spectacularly bad. That’s not really what I’m following here.</p><p><em>Top Gun</em> isn’t a cult film, but <em>The Hunger</em> is. Tony Scott directed both, and they share many of the same ingredients: highly controlled imagery, music doing enormous expressive work, atmosphere, montage, beautiful people, heightened environments, a strong sense of design. But <em>Top Gun</em> landed directly in the middle of popular culture. <em>The Hunger</em> didn’t.</p><p>But <em>The Hunger</em> didn’t simply disappear after audiences rejected it. The goth subculture embraced the film almost immediately through home video and late-night cable. Its opening sequence, with Bauhaus performing “Bela Lugosi’s Dead” inside that smoky, cage-lined nightclub, strongly resonated with the UK and US goth scenes. The clothes, music, lighting, makeup and erotic melancholy weren’t just things people tolerated while waiting for the story; they were part of what people were returning to. Alternative club, fashion and music scenes absorbed pieces of its visual language even while the movie itself remained far outside the mainstream.</p><p>Within a few years, commercial failure had started turning into cult reputation. Mainstream critical reassessment took much longer. A film that had often been dismissed as an exercise in style gradually began to be discussed in terms of Tony Scott’s formal experimentation, its treatment of desire and addiction, and the very high-fashion, music-video imagery that had once made it easy to dismiss.</p><figure><img alt="Blue-lit four-frame collage shows elegant figures in sunglasses, behind a glowing grid and seated together in shadowed interiors." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*k5C2P1LhnO8Aa8PH7XvLuA.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>The Hunger</strong> (1983)</figcaption></figure><p>The visual language itself wasn’t necessarily the dividing line. The same filmmaker could work with related tools and produce one movie audiences embraced immediately and another that seemed to need time. And style alone obviously isn’t enough. Almost every filmmaker I’m talking about has movies where those same instincts simply don’t come together, no matter how beautifully made they are. What interests me are the films where they do — and why some of them seemed to reveal what they were doing more slowly. Maybe that’s because so much of their appeal lives in atmosphere, texture and the experience of returning to their worlds.</p><p>And that repeated access mattered. Home video and cable didn’t just keep the movie available; they gave people a way to live with it.</p><p>I had <em>Blade Runner</em> on VHS in the eighties too. I wouldn’t have called that revisiting a movie then. I just wanted to play it again. Revisit is the word I would use now, because now I have some awareness of what I’m returning to. Back then, I only knew that I wanted to experience the movie again.</p><figure><img alt="Two *Blade Runner* frames show Deckard reading beneath neon signs and J. F. Sebastian’s shadowed apartment, crowded with mechanical toys, decaying theater props and mannequins." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ySBWDGzNSbGcOAkzqTPGfg.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Blade Runner </strong>(1982). Two spaces dense with detail, suggesting a world that continues beyond the frame.</figcaption></figure><p>And again, it was the world as much as the story. <em>Blade Runner</em> gives you the feeling that Los Angeles keeps going somewhere beyond the edges of the frame. There are fragments everywhere — languages, advertisements, crowded streets, buildings, people and technologies whose histories aren’t explained to you. You only see pieces of them, but that’s enough for your imagination to start filling in everything you don’t see. The world feels larger than the movie can contain.</p><p>But repeat viewing is only part of the story. There was another question I wanted to understand about <em>Angel Heart</em>: what did the movie look like to the culture when it first arrived? I’d already named the controversy as what I remembered most — not the snow, New Orleans or Trevor Jones’s score. In February 1987, Angel Heart was fighting an X rating — years before the NC-17 rating existed, X was the only category above R, and by the mid-1980s it had become so closely associated with pornography that mainstream newspapers and video chains often refused to carry X-rated films at all. The MPAA upheld it through multiple appeals before Parker cut roughly ten seconds from the sex scene between Mickey Rourke and Lisa Bonet and the film received an R. And Bonet wasn’t simply another young actress in the movie. She was Denise Huxtable from ‘The Cosby Show’, one of the biggest television shows in America. Contemporary coverage repeatedly framed the controversy through the collision between that image and what she was doing in <em>Angel Heart</em>.</p><figure><img alt="Newspaper clipping with a large portrait of Lisa Bonet above the headline ‘Bonet’s Angel Heartache,’ discussing the film’s rating controversy." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*cXD0PlaVLEgJ7dxdkQkyBQ.png" /><figcaption><strong>The Los Angeles Times </strong>Thu, Feb 26, 1987 | Calendar Section VI page 1</figcaption></figure><p>Looking at the page now, I’m struck by how completely Lisa Bonet’s photograph dominates the first page of the Calendar section. The article itself gets only five full paragraphs before directing the reader to an inside page to finish it. For coverage ostensibly about an X-rating controversy, the editorial emphasis is hard to miss.</p><p>Then I found Richard Freedman again. A year after reviewing <em>Manhunter</em>, he reviewed <em>Angel Heart</em>.</p><figure><img alt="Richard Freedman’s Angel Heart review clipping beneath the headline ‘Angel Heart: More Style Than Substance.’" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*AC_d_spzmm1qNLHb6z9Rtw.png" /><figcaption><strong>Springfield Daily News</strong> Friday, March 06, 1987 page 20</figcaption></figure><p>There was that phrase again : “More Style Than Substance”. But the conversation around this movie was otherwise very different. <em>Manhunter </em>had sent me into Miami Vice, MTV and the visual language of 1986.<em> Angel Heart</em> arrived carrying an X-rating battle, Lisa Bonet, ‘The Cosby Show’, sex, voodoo and the occult. Sheila Benson’s Los Angeles Times review was responding to something else again. She described the film’s “cumulative atmosphere” as the thing building its sense of doom, singling out Trevor Jones’s score, the turning fans, elevators, half-closed doors and blood. Almost forty years later, the X-rating battle and Bonet’s relationship to ‘The Cosby Show’ belong to a very specific cultural moment. They tell me a lot about how <em>Angel Heart</em> entered the culture in 1987. They don’t tell me much about why I’m still thinking about it now. So what survived?</p><p><strong>Influence is one answer.</strong></p><blockquote>“In terms of Memento, Alan Parker films such as Angel Heart and The Wall, which use very interesting editing techniques such as a fractured narrative, were a big influence.”<br>- Christopher Nolan</blockquote><p>Nolan wasn’t talking about the X rating or the controversy around Lisa Bonet. He was talking about filmmaking — the way Parker fractured narrative and moved through a character’s thoughts without losing the audience. And Nolan’s connection to this trail doesn’t stop with Parker. He has described Ridley Scott as a formative influence and <em>Blade Runner </em>as a film he was obsessive about. In a Directors Guild interview, he described what stayed with him about it: the feeling that “there was this whole world outside the frame of the scene.” That sounded familiar — the same impulse, just carried by different filmmakers now. And his admiration wasn’t limited to the editing. In that later conversation with Ryan Coogler, Nolan called Parker a “huge craftsman” with a “wonderful ear for music.” That feels closer to what had stayed with me about <em>Angel Heart</em> in the first place.</p><figure><img alt="Christopher Nolan and Ryan Coogler sit in black chairs speaking into microphones beneath a projected SinnersMovie banner." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-tWW6e13E8Mr5q6IOwvV2w.png" /><figcaption><strong>Sinners </strong>FYC | Ryan Coogler and Christopher Nolan bring up Angel Heart’s influence. December 2025. <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g7FxNEDDf50&amp;t=66s">Watch Interview</a></figcaption></figure><h3>09 — Eggers, and a Movie I Wasn’t Expecting</h3><p>Which made me wonder who is doing something like that now — putting that much attention into the physical details of a world. The sets, costumes, objects, atmosphere. Robert Eggers obviously comes to mind. His films can be obsessive about those things. Not just how a period looks, but the materials, language, clothing, architecture, tools and rituals that belong there. After Parker talking about a location needing to “smell right as well as look right,” Eggers felt like a pretty natural place for my mind to go. I like Eggers’ films, but once or twice is usually enough for me. Then, while reading about <em>Nosferatu</em>, I came across Eggers talking about <em>Batman Returns</em>. That I wasn’t expecting.</p><blockquote>“I threw on Batman Returns and, like, snowy, gothic, atmosphere of that movie is … shockingly similar to a lot of the stuff we were doing here.”<br>- Robert Eggers, discussing Nosferatu</blockquote><p>The funny part is that Eggers said he hadn’t really considered the similarity while making <em>Nosferatu</em>. He noticed it later, watching <em>Batman Returns</em> on a flight. Even Wayne Manor suddenly reminded him of the manor they had created for his own film. <em>Batman Returns</em> was a movie I did go back to — much more than Burton’s first <em>Batman</em>. That made the comparison a little stranger.<strong> </strong>Eggers builds worlds through an almost obsessive pursuit of historical and physical authenticity. <em>Batman Returns</em> does almost the opposite.</p><p>Gotham isn’t pretending to be a real city. The world is artificial and doesn’t seem particularly embarrassed about it. And yet Eggers recognized something from that world inside <em>Nosferatu</em>.</p><figure><img alt="A sixteen-frame comparison grid pairs visual echoes from *Batman Returns* and *Nosferatu*: snowy Gothic mansions, gates, ballrooms, blue-lit architecture, ominous close-ups and bodies in snow." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*T8KavIcNITr7U9hR6adfjw.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Batman Returns</strong> (1992 )| <strong>Nosferatu</strong> (2024) | <strong>Batman Returns</strong> (1992 )| <strong>Nosferatu</strong> (2024)</figcaption></figure><p>So maybe I had been leaning too heavily on the importance of realism.</p><h3>10 — More Completely Burton</h3><p>It’s probably worth backing up here. Today we all know what Tim Burton means: “Burtonesque.” His visual language has been copied, parodied and remixed so many times that it’s easy to forget how genuinely strange — and wonderfully refreshing — it felt in the late eighties.</p><p>Seeing <em>Beetlejuice</em> in the theater was the first time I really became familiar with his world. The characters were a huge part of that. Burton’s exaggerated shapes and silhouettes seemed to begin with the drawings themselves, and then extend outward through makeup, costumes and props into the physical world around them. The crooked sets, strange proportions, black-and-white patterns, miniature work and stop motion all seemed to belong to that same imagination. Even the afterlife had its own bureaucracy. None of it was particularly interested in looking real, but it all belonged together. There was something wonderfully physical about the artificiality. You could almost feel the world being constructed in front of you.</p><figure><img alt="Composite of Tim Burton Beetlejuice sketches showing football players, afterlife figures, distorted expressions and a long-limbed winged creature." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*eazJk_atXUhGQhN9O36Qpg.png" /><figcaption>Tim Burton character designs and sequence sketches for <strong><em>Beetlejuice</em> </strong>(1988). Composite assembled from images reproduced in <strong><em>The Art of Tim Burton</em></strong> (Steeles Publishing, 2009).</figcaption></figure><p>That’s what made Eggers leading me back to Burton so unexpected. Parker had been searching for locations that could convincingly become 1955, worrying about melting snow and whether a place could almost smell right. Eggers builds worlds through an obsessive pursuit of historical and physical authenticity. Burton could begin with a crooked drawing and make the physical world conform to it. The methods could hardly be more different.</p><p>So when <em>Batman </em>arrived in 1989, I was actually a little disappointed. The movie certainly looked different from other comic-book movies at the time, but I remember wondering where some of the weirdness and fun I had loved in <em>Beetlejuice </em>had gone. I wasn’t much of a comic-book fan, so I wasn’t waiting for Burton to disappear into Batman. I wanted to see what version Batman might become inside a Burton world.</p><figure><img alt="Three frames show Chris Elliott wearing a Batman cap and shirt on Letterman, ending with a Bat-logo displayed on his forehead." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*7VOpNU5HKbEIzovsHC6-4Q.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Batmania, June 1989.</strong> Chris Elliott satirizes the saturation surrounding <em>Batman</em> on <em>Late Night with David Letterman</em>, eventually revealing a Bat-logo supposedly carved into his forehead. Video still from <a href="https://youtu.be/FjC4j7Mj5bA?t=1991">archival footage compiled on YouTube, 33:11</a>.</figcaption></figure><p>That’s probably why I remember responding so much more strongly to <em>Batman Returns</em>. I haven’t actually watched it in something like thirty years, which may make it a more interesting test of what survives. I remember liking it much more than the first Batman. What remains most clearly is the eccentric character design, Danny Elfman’s heroic but haunted score, and that strange collision of Christmas and Halloween. In my memory, it plays almost like an Expressionist fairy tale mixed with toy-pop imagery. It felt much closer to the Burton I had been waiting for.</p><p>And that brings me back to Eggers. A filmmaker I associate with obsessive historical authenticity watches <em>Batman Returns</em> decades later and recognizes its snowy Gothic atmosphere inside his own work. Burton’s Gotham isn’t pretending to be a real city. It’s theatrical, exaggerated and openly artificial. But it belongs together.</p><p>So how grounded does a world really need to be for me to want to go back? Does it even need to be grounded at all?</p><p>Nolan had his own way of talking about this. He described being blown away by <em>Alien </em>and <em>Blade Runner</em> when he was young because of the worlds they created, and talked about wanting a film to have its own “particular geography” — somewhere that can completely immerse you for a couple of hours. I like that phrase. Particular geography. <em>Manhunter </em>has it. <em>Alien </em>has it. <em>Blade Runner</em> has it. <em>Angel Heart </em>has it. And Burton’s worlds, however artificial they may be, have it too. Maybe that was closer to what I was trying to describe.</p><h3>11— Builders of Worlds</h3><blockquote>“Let me start by saying there are filmmakers who are the builders of worlds. It’s not a long list, and we know who a lot of them are.”<br>- Steven Spielberg</blockquote><p>This was March 2024. <em>Dune: Part Two</em> had just opened, and Spielberg was talking with Denis Villeneuve for the DGA’s Director’s Cut podcast. Spielberg started naming names: Méliès, Disney, Kubrick, George Lucas, Ray Harryhausen, Fellini, Tim Burton, Wes Anderson, Peter Jackson, James Cameron, Christopher Nolan, Ridley Scott, Guillermo del Toro. It’s an interesting list, especially after where I’d just landed with Burton. These aren’t all filmmakers building imaginary planets or fantasy worlds. Fellini is on there. Wes Anderson is on there. Burton is on there. Ridley Scott is on there. The worlds they create don’t all have the same relationship with reality. And some of those worlds I’m much more likely to revisit than others. So even “world-building” doesn’t quite answer what I’ve been trying to figure out.</p><p>And then, because of <em>Dune: Part Two</em>, Spielberg added Villeneuve to the list. I remember reading about that conversation at the time and thinking: Villeneuve belonged on that list before <em>Dune</em>. For me, he’d already done it with <em>Sicario</em>.</p><p><em>Sicario</em> isn’t the kind of movie we usually think of when we hear “world-building.” Villeneuve didn’t invent a planet. Arizona exists. Juárez exists. The border exists. And yet <em>Sicario</em> gives me one of the most complete cinematic worlds of the 2010s.</p><p><strong>So what exactly had Villeneuve built?</strong></p><h3>12 — Entering Sicario</h3><p>We enter <em>Sicario </em>through Kate Macer’s eyes, and much of the geography she moves through is liminal — places between destinations, jurisdictions and even versions of the law. They feel cut off from ordinary civilian life, even when they’re sitting right beside it. The places are real and recognizable. But as Kate moves through them, they begin to feel like they belong specifically to <em>Sicario</em>. How does Villeneuve do that? I remember my own reaction to the film pretty clearly. I liked it the first time I watched it, but the next day I wanted to see it again. Then I watched it a third time with my wife — all within the same 48-hour rental window. I’ve lost count of how many times I’ve seen it since. It’s become one of my favorite films to revisit from the last decade. And it wasn’t because I wanted to get back to the action or violence. If anything, what kept pulling me back was the world around those moments — the atmosphere, the movement through spaces, the sound, the surveillance, the desert, the strange procedural detail of it all. Which brings me back to the question: how does Villeneuve make these real and recognizable places feel so specifically like <em>Sicario</em>?</p><figure><img alt="Five law-enforcement officials seated around a conference table look toward Kate from her point of view." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*WeJd7HCd6XcAyrbwy7eAKg.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Sicario </strong>(2015). Kate’s point of view.</figcaption></figure><p>The Juárez sequence is a good place to look. Villeneuve spends an extraordinary amount of time establishing the geography before anything actually happens: the convoy formation, the roads, the border infrastructure, the traffic, the police presence, the bodies hanging from the overpass, the way the operators scan cars and intersections, even the warning about what happens if the convoy gets stuck. The convoy has been moving with such controlled momentum that when traffic finally brings it to a stop at the border, the change in rhythm becomes part of the tension. By the time somebody identifies a threat, we’ve spent enough time learning how these people move through this space that we can begin recognizing the danger ourselves. Is the procedure itself becoming part of the suspense?</p><figure><img alt="A long convoy of Mexican federal police trucks carrying armed officers travels through a sunlit Juárez street." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*bBIx4A8H9aLPdqtK7ISGJQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Sicario </strong>(2015). The road into Juárez.</figcaption></figure><p>And underneath all of this is Jóhann Jóhannsson’s score. I don’t hear it simply as tense music. It feels industrial, mechanical — this constant sense of something moving underneath the geography. Essential to all of this is how Villeneuve and Roger Deakins keep changing the way we’re allowed to see this world.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FD6uwPL3oXeI%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DD6uwPL3oXeI&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FD6uwPL3oXeI%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/0e695fc5cd93bb4774f9293f8e9c1ad4/href">https://medium.com/media/0e695fc5cd93bb4774f9293f8e9c1ad4/href</a></iframe><p>From the ground, the convoy is procedural. From the air, the landscape starts becoming abstract. The bank security-camera footage reduces the image to functional surveillance, but it also gives the film another texture — and a certain menace, because we’re aware that someone else is watching that footage. Later, night vision and thermal imaging take over entirely. By the tunnel sequence, even the way we’re permitted to see belongs to the people who operate in this world. And I think that’s where those institutional layers start to matter. The FBI, CIA, Delta operators, state and local police, and Mexican authorities all occupy the same physical geography, but they aren’t necessarily operating under the same rules. Kate is moving through all of it with us. And eventually the movie does something revealing: it moves beyond her. Alejandro continues into a part of this world where Kate no longer belongs, and the film goes with him.</p><blockquote>“Denis and I thought, ‘this has to be another world,’ it’s key to Emily’s character. It’s got to be totally alien to her experience.”<br>- Roger Deakins</blockquote><figure><img alt="Four-part Sicario collage compares aerial desert imagery, thermal imaging, black-and-white bank surveillance and green night vision." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ruBPWhz212MAdlD1OYflMw.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Sicario </strong>(2015). Different technologies create different forms of abstraction.</figcaption></figure><p>And even the night-vision and thermal imagery came out of taking that world seriously. Deakins’ reasoning was surprisingly practical: if these operators need enhancement systems because it’s too dark to see, why would the movie suddenly give us beautifully lit “moonlight” photography where we can see everything? The thermal material was shot with an actual thermal camera, while the night vision used an enhancer on the lens. The technology isn’t just a visual effect; it determines the perspective we’re allowed to have.</p><p>There was that word again: <em>world</em>. Not an invented one this time. A real one, transformed through controlled perspective.</p><h3>13 — Why I Keep Returning to <em>The Viewing?</em></h3><p>Okay, at this point you might be asking: do I watch anything that isn’t at least ten years old? Am I like, just sitting around watching TCM all day? Well, lately I’ve really enjoyed returning to the strange little worlds of Panos Cosmatos.</p><p>I’ve seen <em>Mandy</em>, and I like <em>Mandy</em>. It is unmistakably Cosmatos, but I don’t find myself wanting to watch it over and over. <em>The Viewing</em> is different. I’ve gone back to it several times, which apparently means I’m still not done with my own question: why?</p><p>And if I was looking for a contemporary example of what I meant by a cult film, Cosmatos seems like a pretty good place to look. I have a hard time imagining <em>The Viewing</em> ever drifting very far into mainstream tastes.</p><p>The first time I watched it, I was completely consumed by the atmosphere while still waiting for the horror to finally unleash itself. I wasn’t thinking about what was behind a door; we didn’t even know there was a door yet. What pulled me in was the room itself and the strange evening unfolding inside it. The technology, furniture, clothes, drugs, performances, music and sound design all seem to belong to the same dream of 1979. Even the way people speak and pause around one another feels tuned to that world.</p><figure><img alt="Nine-frame amber-lit collage shows guests in a circular room, glowing wall switches, liquor being poured and a close-up of a mechanical lens." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*DB-wLF903gM8Mjh86Dl4bQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>The Viewing</strong> (2022)</figcaption></figure><p>What keeps bringing me back isn’t simply that all of those elements are consistent. It’s the trance state they create together. The pacing is slow, the performances are measured, the music and sound seem to hover around the room, and even the conversation has a hypnotic quality. I just wanted to stay in that room.</p><p>The trance eventually becomes part of the narrative itself. When the creature inside Lassiter’s prized meteor finally reveals itself, it emits an overwhelming, deafening frequency that seems to trap everyone in a collective paralysis. Targ says, “It’s drawing me into a trance.” Which is a pretty good description of where the episode had already put me.</p><figure><img alt="Targ raises one hand toward the camera while his face and clothing are submerged in deep red light." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*TLJeKh6r9cnN3Ntrj690RQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>The Viewing</strong> (2022). Targ: “It’s drawing me into a trance.”</figcaption></figure><p>That changes how I think about the shorter format too. I don’t think <em>The Viewing</em> works for me simply because it’s only about an hour long. The hour helps because Cosmatos can sustain this concentrated state without having to keep expanding the world into something larger. We spend most of the episode in that room, surrounded by the same people, objects, sounds and rhythms, and by the time the spell is finally broken, the experience is nearly over.</p><p>I know what happens now. I know where the evening is going and what eventually comes through that door. The suspense of waiting for the horror to unleash itself can’t work on me exactly the way it did the first time. But the atmosphere can still put me back into that state. That’s what survives the repeat viewing, and why I still want to go back to that room.</p><h3>14 — <strong>Cinematic</strong> <strong>Sensory Memories</strong></h3><p>Looking back at the trail I’d been following, something else was becoming pretty obvious. Fragments of a cramped airplane cabin and the constant hiss of pressurized air. The sight and sound of shoes pushing through dirty, melting snow on a 1950s street. Catwoman’s strange, stitched-together character design. A low mechanical pulse underneath a convoy moving toward the U.S.-Mexico border. The somewhat grainy black-and-white image of a blonde woman captured by a bank security camera. The amber glow of a room that feels like a dream taking place in 1979. These weren’t really memories of plot. The bank footage in <em>Sicario</em> works that way. The woman they call the “Smurfette” barely exists for us outside the surveillance system. The only clear view we get of her is from the side and wide, captured in somewhat grainy black-and-white security footage.</p><figure><img alt="Grainy black-and-white surveillance view of a blonde woman seen from behind at a bank counter." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Z6_4n7vqHnhTPCEkvRLSHg.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Sicario </strong>(2015). “Smurfette,” seen in a tight surveillance shot from Matt Graver’s POV.</figcaption></figure><p>Other glimpses are distant, small, or buried within a grid of multiple camera feeds. Even the way Villeneuve presents her is already fragmented. And that’s more or less how I remember her: blonde hair, a partial figure, a nickname, the black-and-white texture of the security footage. My memory isn’t preserving a complete scene or even a complete character. It’s preserving the fragments the movie gave me.</p><figure><img alt="Black-and-white surveillance collage shows wide bank-counter feeds and a body lying on pavement behind a parked car." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*KVgdbVolbbFBeMhJgUTm6A.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Sicario </strong>(2015). The wider bank-surveillance views never clearly identify the target.</figcaption></figure><p>And yet this is one of the scenes that has stayed with me most clearly from <em>Sicario</em>. Not the larger action sequences. Not even the ending. This strange little fragment of surveillance footage. Why that? Maybe this is where sensory memory comes into it. I’ve been using that phrase in my head for a while now — sensory memory. Then I looked up what “sensory memory” actually means. And, scientifically, I was using the term wrong. Sensory memory in psychology is extremely brief — the immediate trace of sensory information after the stimulus is gone. What I’m talking about happens years or decades later. These details are closer to long-term episodic or autobiographical memory, where sensory impressions can remain part of a remembered experience. That distinction actually helped. I’m not trying to invent a new medical category. “Cinematic sensory memories” is just my phrase for the fragments of a movie that seem to survive in memory as sensations: a sound, weather, architecture, movement, music, light, a room. The strange thing is that when I think about the movies I’ve returned to for years, memory doesn’t seem particularly interested in preserving their biggest moments. It preserves atmosphere.</p><p>Cinematic sensory memory doesn’t necessarily preserve spectacle. Sometimes it preserves texture.</p><p>That may be why the word atmosphere keeps following me through this essay. “Atmospheric” can sound like faint praise — as though atmosphere is something laid over the real movie. But in these films atmosphere is made from place, sound, music, behavior, weather, architecture, light, movement and duration. Those aren’t necessarily things sitting outside the substance. They are part of how the story becomes an experience. And the more I followed those fragments, the harder it became to separate them from what I thought the movie was “about.” Which brings me back to the phrase that started all of this.</p><h3>15 — Style Is the Substance</h3><blockquote>“‘Manhunter’ Fails as Thriller…favors gorgeous picture-postcard sunsets over the kind of sheer terror a movie like this ought to provoke.” — Richard Freedman, Daily News, August 16, 1986</blockquote><p>I had gone looking at the reviews of <em>Manhunter </em>from forty years ago because I wanted to understand what had changed. How could a film be criticized for qualities that, four decades later, are often part of what people celebrate about it? Too slick. Too designed. Too empty. The comparisons to advertising and MTV kept appearing around films from this period, and after everything I’d gone through, those criticisms started to look less like isolated reactions to individual movies and more like something connected to the moment in which they were being reviewed.</p><p>Reading it now, Freedman’s wording carries an expectation I didn’t catch as a kid — “the kind of sheer terror a movie like this ought to provoke.” Ought to. He wasn’t missing Mann’s sunsets or the way the film was designed; he was looking directly at those choices and questioning whether they belonged in the thriller he expected <em>Manhunter </em>to be. Forty years later, the sunsets haven’t changed. The context around them has.</p><figure><img alt="Lower portion of Richard Freedman’s Manhunter review, with the criticism of its ‘picture-postcard sunsets’ highlighted in red." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*MEx49bH4UAcjpUiy7DUScw.png" /><figcaption><strong>Springfield Daily News </strong>Saturday, August 16, 1986: Richard Freedman review “‘Manhunter’ Fails as Thriller.”</figcaption></figure><p>Almost halfway between that 1986 review and where we are now, I found another marker. In 2007, director Phil Joanou told <em>The New York Times</em> there was “zero stigma” attached to making commercials and, if anything, an element of prestige. He said a commercial reel was sometimes the first thing a studio chief wanted to see. The article pointed to Ridley Scott, who had started in commercials before moving into features, as evidence.</p><p>That was almost twenty years ago now, and roughly halfway between <em>Manhunter </em>and this essay. It doesn’t prove that the critical suspicion of commercial aesthetics had disappeared. Joanou was talking about how the filmmaking industry viewed directors who made commercials, while critics had often been reacting to the influence of commercial aesthetics on feature films. Those aren’t quite the same thing. In 1986, the language of commercials and MTV could be used to describe what was supposedly wrong with a movie. By 2007, the commercial reel itself could be one of the first things a studio chief wanted to see.</p><p>And now we’re another twenty years farther down the road. The filmmakers and films we kept running into along the way didn’t lose the qualities that once made them easy to describe as slick, commercial, MTV-influenced or overly designed. If anything, many of those qualities are now central to why the work is remembered. Maybe we did change. Or maybe the way we learned to watch these films did.</p><p>That became part of my curiosity here. Reading these films against the criticism surrounding them helps me understand not only how their reputations changed, but how the culture around them changed as well. The suspicion of advertising and MTV aesthetics, the boundaries drawn between form and content, and the later elevation of “world-building” all belong to that history. Freedman’s review matters to me because it gives me something exact to think against: a different account of what <em>Manhunter</em> was doing, written while the film was still new. What I am doing now is film criticism too — entering that continuing conversation from another moment in time.</p><p>That brings me back to the sensory memories that kept surfacing while I was writing this: the cramped airplane cabin and its air-pressure hiss; the crunch and slush of melting snow in a 1950s New York street; a grainy black-and-white security image that gives us only a distant, partial view of a woman; a piece of music, a room, a movement, a texture. These aren’t necessarily the biggest scenes or the moments a plot summary would tell me are most important. They’re fragments, but they’re also what survived.</p><p>The image, the sound, the music, the atmosphere, the texture of a place. <strong>Style is the substance.</strong></p><p>Maybe the simplest test is the one that kept revealing itself through all of this. Think about a movie you already know. You know the story, the ending, the surprises. There’s nothing left to discover in that sense, and yet every so often you want to go back.</p><p>What movie do you still go back to just to be there again?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b01504d7d7eb" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[From Portrait Painters to Prompt Engineers: What Students Should Study in an Age of AI?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ddintzner/from-portrait-painters-to-prompt-engineers-creative-disruption-then-and-now-f04d75be09f5?source=rss-11f79233cfa6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f04d75be09f5</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[future-of-work]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[history-of-art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[creative-economy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[photography]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ai-art]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Derek Dintzner]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 03 May 2026 05:47:53 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-05-04T06:13:37.291Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="The student stands in the center, slightly backlit, facing forward with subtle uncertainty. Left path: traditional art studio (easels, oil paintings, warm lighting, classical tools) Right path: modern tech workspace (multiple monitors, code, AI-generated images, cool blue lighting)" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*SLPgkxhhh_EYnv3rR2iplA.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>From craft to code to AI — the path forward is no longer linear.</em></figcaption></figure><h3>A Question That Feels New — But Isn’t</h3><p>What should you study when the skills you’re learning might be automated before you graduate?</p><p>This is no longer a theoretical question. Working at the intersection of creative and technology in advertising, I see these shifts play out in real time across both disciplines. AI systems can already generate images, assist with coding, and perform tasks that once defined entry-level roles in both creative and technical fields. The uncertainty isn’t whether these careers will exist — it’s whether the version being taught today will still hold economic value by the time students enter the workforce. For years, the advice was relatively clear: learn to code, or develop a craft that could translate into production work. That clarity is beginning to erode as the tools improve faster than the systems designed to teach them.</p><p>This moment feels unprecedented, but it isn’t. In the late nineteenth century, a similar shift reshaped one of the most reliable creative professions of its time. Portrait painting — once a steady commercial path for skilled artists — was disrupted by the rise of photography. By the 1880s, photography had become faster, cheaper, and “good enough” for most people. What had once required hours or days of skilled labor could suddenly be done in minutes. The impact was immediate and uneven. A significant number of lower- and mid-tier portrait painters — those serving a growing middle class — lost their economic footing in a relatively short period of time.</p><p>At the time, the anxiety was palpable. Artists and critics openly questioned whether painting had a future at all. The concern was not just artistic, but economic: what happens when the skill you’ve trained for is no longer needed? Painting did not disappear, but the profession changed. The most celebrated artists endured, while the commercial layer beneath them — the space where technical skill alone had once been enough to sustain a career — was compressed.</p><h3>When Education Lags the Market</h3><p>Importantly, this disruption did not eliminate art education. It reshaped it.</p><p>While photography did not immediately dismantle academic art training, it quietly undermined one of its central purposes: the production of realistic likeness. As the commercial demand for portrait painting declined, art education began to shift away from strict representational mastery toward experimentation, perception, and eventually design. This transition becomes more visible in the early twentieth century with institutions like the Bauhaus, which deprioritized traditional fine art hierarchies in favor of integrating art with technology and industry. Photography, once peripheral, was gradually incorporated into the curriculum — not as a replacement for painting, but as part of a broader redefinition of visual practice tied to modern life and commercial application.</p><p>A similar recalibration is underway today. Students pursuing degrees in computer science or commercial art face a comparable uncertainty: the foundational skills they are taught may be partially automated by the time they enter the workforce. As in the late nineteenth century, the question is not whether education will persist, but whether its focus can evolve quickly enough to remain aligned with a rapidly shifting technological landscape.</p><p>This lag between technological change and educational adaptation is not new. For years, C++ was widely taught as an introductory language in computer science programs, even as the industry shifted toward more accessible languages like Python. That transition arguably should have happened much earlier, but academia tends to evolve slowly, constrained by curriculum inertia and institutional timelines. The result is familiar: students are often trained in foundations that no longer map cleanly to how work is actually being done. AI is accelerating this gap. What once took decades to shift may now change within a few years — making the central question harder to ignore: what exactly are students preparing for?</p><h3>Where Value Moves Next</h3><p>A similar pattern is unfolding today, but at a much faster pace. AI systems can now generate images, assist with software development, and produce usable outputs in seconds. Tasks that once required hours of skilled execution can be completed almost instantly. As with photography, the pressure is felt most acutely at the production level. Roles built on speed, repetition, and technical competence are becoming more compressed, particularly at the entry point to these professions.</p><p>This is where the anxiety becomes familiar. Students considering degrees in computer science or commercial art are confronting a version of the same question portrait painters faced in the 1880s: what happens if the thing I’m being trained to do is no longer the thing people need?</p><p>The historical pattern suggests that the field does not disappear — but the entry point shifts.</p><p>The shift is already visible. The work itself has not disappeared, but the boundaries between roles are becoming less defined. Tasks that once required specialized execution can now be generated, iterated, and refined with tools. As a result, value is moving upstream — toward deciding what to make, why it matters, and how to shape the output into something meaningful.</p><p>The lesson from the rise of photography is not that new technology destroys entire fields; it redistributes value within them, often quickly and unevenly. Portrait painters were not replaced wholesale, but a significant portion of their profession lost its economic foundation in a relatively short time. A similar compression is now unfolding across both creative and technical disciplines. AI is not eliminating the need for artists or engineers, but it is reducing the economic value of routine production skills that once served as entry points into those careers.</p><p>This does not make fields like computer science or commercial art obsolete, but it does change what it means to study them. The more durable advantage may lie in the ability to move between disciplines — to combine technical fluency with creative direction, to understand systems while shaping outcomes, and to apply judgment in ways that tools cannot easily replicate.</p><p>The real risk is not choosing the wrong major. It is choosing a version of that major that assumes the future will look like the past.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f04d75be09f5" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>