<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Dena Huisman on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Dena Huisman on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@denahuisman_76178?source=rss-93260e7268d1------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 05:20:43 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@denahuisman_76178/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Social Support and Minding Your Own Business]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@denahuisman_76178/social-support-and-minding-your-own-business-fae6818646d7?source=rss-93260e7268d1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fae6818646d7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[chronic-illness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[stigma-and-discrimination]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-support]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[diabetes]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Dena Huisman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 29 Jun 2025 20:17:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-06-29T23:14:34.332Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>How to be a better person by letting people live their lives.</h4><p>I wrote <a href="https://www.routledge.com/Social-Power-and-Communicating-Social-Support-How-Stigma-and-Marginalization/Huisman/p/book/9780367699390">my book on social power and social support</a> because I knew things like stigma and marginalization were important factors in how people communicate support to people in various contexts.</p><p>Stigma is when a person has an identity (visible or invisible) that society deems untrustworthy or blameworthy. For example, I wrote in my book about how people with certain illnesses are ostracized, shamed, and blamed for their illness (e.g., HIV, lung cancer) because they are perceived to have caused it and/or because of fear that they might spread it.</p><p>Marginalization is when people are de-centered in public frameworks of experience and identity, such as when their cultural experiences are not taken into consideration when society makes judgments, laws, or norms. For example, work culture in the United States tends to privilege Christian holidays for paid time off, not considering how other religious calendars might impact a staff member’s ability to work. No one gets a paid day off for Muslim or Jewish holidays. Their holidays are de-centered in our culture, and their experiences are marginalized from the larger, Christian-dominate cultural norms.</p><p>All that to say, I am always on the lookout for how I might improve my social support for people regardless of their stigmatized or marginalized identities. How can I be aware of my own internalized biases so that I can root them out and do better? Sometimes I learn by observing my own interactions, but I also learn by watching other people’s interactions and evaluating how they make me and others feel. I had such an opportunity a week ago.</p><p>My friend and I were excited to attend a multi-performer 80s rock concert. It was the music of our childhood, including the amazing Rick Springfield as the main star. What could be better than <em>Jessie’s Girl</em> with a few thousand fellow music fans? I’m happy to report that our hopes were achieved. The show was a start-to-finish delight.</p><p>Before the show, however, was something else altogether. The venue has a no-bag policy, so I grabbed my phone and wallet to put in my pocket. My friend has type-1 diabetes, which requires her to carry insulin, glucose pills, and a few other essentials in case of emergency. It’s a serious illness requiring constant vigilance and preparation. She carries these essentials in a small bag, and the venue said that medical bags were an exception to the general policy.</p><p>We weren’t even out of the parking lot when a staff member called out that she couldn’t bring her bag in. And okay. An employee’s job is ensuring the guests have a good experience, and walking back to the car from the gate would be inconvenient. Sure, there were signs everywhere that told us “no bags,” but it can’t hurt to say something. My friend and I discussed how it felt a little conspicuous to carry a bag and have it commented on, but alas. He was trying to be helpful.</p><p>Then a few minutes later, we were approaching the venue area and a random woman calls out, somewhat judgmentally, “You can’t take that bag in there!” My friend said it was a medical bag. The lady just kind of shrugged and walked on. This one hurt a bit. My friend mentioned feeling uncomfortable about people noticing her for something she didn’t want to be noticed for.</p><p>Then it happened again. This time another staff member. When my friend said it was a medical bag, the staff member inappropriately said, “What for??” again with a tone of disbelief and judgment. My friend said it was for diabetes, though later said she wished she had said, “None of your business, lady.” Which I would have LOVED.</p><p>Then we got to the security point to enter the venue. It’s reasonable that the employee needed to know it was a medical bag. By this point, my friend was feeling ashamed and embarrassed, so she gave a preemptory, “I have a medical bag. And a glucose monitor that might set off the scanners.” The employee did not ask questions, searched the bag as per requirements, and sent us on our way.</p><p>And that’s when the really annoying lady came along. First, she hounds the employee about the no-bag policy. After he said it was just the policy, the lady loudly and aggressively said, “Well, you let HER in with a bag! Why does SHE get to have a bag, but I can’t?!?”</p><p>Within 10 minutes, my friend’s vital medical necessities drew attention <em>four times</em> that she did not want and did not deserve. While some of them were kind and patient enough (though still uncomfortable for her), the people who decided to call her out who had no business in her business was deeply unsettling. It wasn’t happening to me personally, but my empathetic heart was so angry alongside my friend for this pattern of rude and embarrassing behavior. She just wanted to go to a concert, have a fun evening, and not be called out for being different or having a need that others don’t have. She felt stigmatized, and I understood why.</p><p>She and I have had conversations about how hard in general it is to have a chronic illness. She has to make a thousand little decisions every day as she manages her insulin, considers food options, responds to her monitor’s various beeps. She has had supplies stolen from her mailbox. She has had her driver’s license suspended because a doctor didn’t do her due diligence around an issue related to the illness (long story — and very aggravating story). As a self-employed woman, she has to constantly worry that insurance will no longer be easy to get if the government messes with the ACA. To buy supplies. That literally keep her alive.</p><p>It’s not fair. She deserves an easy life. But that’s not her reality. And being stigmatized in public for it is salt in the wound. When people make the decision to call her out for having a bag that she needs to ensure her health and safety, it just feels crappy. It feels embarrassing. It makes her feel small and like she doesn’t belong to the community.</p><p>Each person in that lineup of commenters probably thought, “I was just trying to be helpful,” or “She just needs to lighten up.” I can assure you that each of these comments were not isolated incidents, but part of a long litany of experiences that accumulate over time to reinforce the idea that she isn’t “normal” or “like everyone else.” After a while, it all just drains her, it beats her down. It creates moral injuries that never have time to heal before the next one hits. This happens to everyone who faces stigmatization and marginalization.</p><p>And I’ve been thinking a lot about it in the week since the show. About how everyday interactions have the power to uplift and validate the lived experiences of our fellow humans, or to make them feel ostracized, stigmatized, and less than. How can I ensure that I am not participating in the act of challenging someone’s sense of belonging to my world, my community? What little actions might I be doing that adds to the perpetually unhealed wound of being seen as an outsider? And how can I stop those actions?</p><blockquote>Maya Angelou said, “Do the best you can until you know better. Then when you know better, do better.”</blockquote><p>So I ask you, how can you examine your current “best you can” to learn how you can do even better? For starters: mind your business. Just that. Just mind. Your. Business. If you see someone carrying a bag at a bag-free venue, consider whether you need to be the bag police. Whether it’s necessary for you to call it out, or if that’s the job of the security staff. Consider whether it’s possible the person has a reason for the bag that you can’t see. Imagine how you would feel to be called out by a stranger if you had an accommodation you needed to stay alive.</p><p>If you see someone parked in an accessible spot get out of their car and walk, is it your job to police them? Can you imagine that they may have a chronic condition that makes walking harder, making the accessible spot a life saver? Can you just leave it alone and let that person live their life? Sure, it’s possible that they are abusing the accessible spot — and if they are, they’re an asshole. But you’re not the asshole police. And you risk being the asshole needing policing if you harass someone who needs that spot.</p><blockquote>Mind. Your. Business.</blockquote><p>People live complications you can’t even begin to see, hear, or understand. Give them the good grace to live those complications without the added burden of justifying their situation to you. A stranger. Who doesn’t need to know. Support them by letting them live in peace.</p><p>Make it your motto: I will mind. My own. Business.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fae6818646d7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Building Connections to Broken Hearts: Helping People Face The Trauma of Mass Firings]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@denahuisman_76178/building-connections-to-broken-hearts-helping-people-face-the-trauma-of-mass-firings-2c6d2c5b246b?source=rss-93260e7268d1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2c6d2c5b246b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[tech-layoffs-2025]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-support]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Dena Huisman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 04 Jun 2025 13:58:02 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-06-04T13:58:02.833Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>There’s a documentary on HBO Max (formerly Max, formerly HBO Max) about the comedian, George Carlin. Someone who loved him said that his turn toward angry diatribe comedy late in life happened because he had become angry and disillusioned by society. But more importantly, that anger and disillusionment was rooted in his deep <em>love</em> for humanity.</p><p>There is something profoundly relatable to me there. I have both depression (I don’t care about anything) and anxiety (I care about everything way too much). It’s a constant ping-pong battle in my head. I often wondered why I have such a pessimistic view of the world while also wanting so much to make the world safer, better, more just for people. I realized it was possible that my anger and pessimism was a (semi-conscious) response to the hurt and sadness I witness in the world. A kind of protection layer to cover up my soft, nougatty center.</p><p>A couple weeks back, I spent two days at a conference that was attended by a lot of technologists who <em>used to</em> work for the Federal Government until DOGE came along and casually belittled them before firing them. The stated plan by officials was “to put them into trauma.” So it wasn’t a mistake to hurt them and break their lives apart. It was the goal. THE GOAL. Of adult human beings. To put other human beings into trauma.</p><p>As I met these folks and listened to their stories, I was reminded of both my pessimism (humans who would do this to other humans are evil and always have been) and my nougat (my god, these poor human souls — I have to help them). At lunch with a few fellow attendees, we started talking about my social support research and a woman who had been fired said,</p><blockquote><em>“You should write an article about how to support people going through these firings.”</em></blockquote><p>I have some hesitation about doing so as I am not directly affected by these layoffs. I’m only a very angry citizen. But given my past academic research on social support communication, I thought I could write a few general tips for thinking about how to support federal workers under this pressure. It’s something that uses my nougat to balance my rage and despair. Win-win.</p><p>First off, what is social support? Simply, it’s the way we communicate and/or enact practices or behaviors that assist someone else in a time of struggle. These struggles can be simple everyday kinds of things as well as the more seismic struggles like being fired by people wanting to cause you trauma. Most people think they are good at social support. Most people also think they have a good support system. But a looooot of research shows that actual, enacted support doesn’t really offer all that much help. Why, you ask?</p><p>Well. I am not omniscient, and I have not seen every instance of support communication gone awry. But the academic literature suggests that support goes wonky because a person offers support they would want instead of support the recipient wants.</p><blockquote><strong><em>Little known fact: people aren’t all the same.</em></strong></blockquote><p>So when support is offered that’s comfy for the person offering, there’s a pretty significant risk that the recipient will (at best) be grateful but unhelped or (at worst) be hurt or offended.</p><p>But it doesn’t have to be this way! You don’t have to be the friend who offers middling support. Your friend is hurting because the people in power decided to be assholes. Let me offer some tips for you on helping them cope with the assholery.</p><h4>Dena’s Super Hot Tips to Providing Effective Social Support for Federal Workers Stuck in a Crap Situation</h4><p>One of the most basic forms of advice I give people about offering support is not to offer advice. YES. I hear it. Yes, I know.</p><blockquote><strong><em>But I really do think “do not offer advice” is the best advice</em></strong><em>. </em><strong><em>Sometimes a good paradox will set you up for success.</em></strong></blockquote><p>In general, people only want advice when they <em>ask</em> for advice. And when someone has been through a traumatic event like a mass firing rooted in cruelty that dismisses both their work and their humanity, they probably won’t want advice. And if they do, they’ll ask for it.</p><p>Instead of advice, consider the other forms of support:</p><p><strong>Emotional support: </strong>This kind of support is rooted around helping a person navigate, process, and handle their complicated emotions around what has happened. Try asking them if they want to talk about how they’re feeling. If they want to talk about it, if they don’t want to talk about it. If they want to be distracted from the emotions they’re feeling about it. Ask if you can offer any kind of solace, and if not, what else can you do to validate and help them in their current emotional state. The key is not to dictate to them how you are going to support them emotionally. Instead, tell them you’re ready to hear their emotions and go with whatever will be helpful to them (even if that helpful is, “I just want to be alone”).</p><p><em>Major caveat alert:</em> only do this if you’re actually willing to do the hard work that follows. It can add sorrow to sorrow if you say you want to help them emotionally but then you shut down when their emotions make you uncomfortable. If you can’t handle raw emotion, don’t offer to help them emotionally. You have to be really ready for anything, maybe even your own tears of solidarity. If you can’t, try another form of support, such as:</p><p><strong>Tangible support:</strong> This kind of support is more material in nature, including activities, physical or financial assistance, help with errands, providing transportation, editing job application materials. Anything that provides a direct service to someone. When you’ve lost your job, there are lots of really practical parts of your life that are impacted. You’ve lost income. You’ve lost a sense of direction for your day-to-day schedule. You’ve lost co-workers that you used to share a cup of coffee with. Offering tangible support can provide a (temporary) feeling of normalcy as well as potentially helping keep them afloat while they figure out what’s next.</p><p>As with emotional support, every person will have a different answer for what tangible support would be helpful. So instead of telling the person what you’re going to do for them, ask what you can do for them. If they aren’t sure but seem receptive to help, then maybe offer some suggestions, but don’t be mad if they reject them all. You are there to help, not guilt them into accepting your help. If they say they can’t think of anything in the moment, ask if you can reach out again in a few days. The thing is, when you’re in a hard time, you not only don’t know what you need, you also don’t always have the energy to ask for help. So a friend who can just check in periodically with offers of tangible support can be a lifeline. As long as “no” is accepted — every time, without offence. You might also sneak it in with a casual, “I am going to the grocery store near you. Anything I can pick up and drop off for you?” Or “I’m going to be in your area tomorrow, need help with any errands or anything?” “Can I pick you up for a cup of coffee this afternoon after my doctor’s appointment?” By making it feel like something already tied to your day, your friend may feel more comfortable accepting help. Because let’s face it: asking for and needing help can feel yuck. Do what you can to make the yuck less yucky.</p><p><em>Major caveat: </em>Do not offer tangible support and then withdraw it because it’s too hard. If you have particular limitations, it’s best to lay that out in advance. Don’t have the time to drive someone during the day? Make sure you make that clear. Are you struggling financially, too? You can find a way to say, “Hey, you know I don’t have a lot of cash right now, either, but I can offer help in this way instead.” Being upfront about what you can do will help your struggling friend know what to ask for and when to ask someone else.</p><p><strong>Network support:</strong> Network support is the act of making a person feel included in a group and linking people to others with common interests and goals. In the case of job loss, this can include interpersonal belonging. Someone who’s going through a lot may often be kind of a downer. Invite them anyway and allow them space to be who they are in this current struggle. Let them know you really want to stay connected. Also, be conscious of how much money it costs to go to events in public. How can you organize events for a social group that is affordable even for someone being extra careful with money? Offer to buy them a cup of coffee or beer (though be aware of the risks of appearing to pity them). Invite them to your place for a movie with snacks.</p><p>In addition to the more interpersonal inclusion, think about whether you have any professional networking connections you can make. We all know the truism that finding a job is a whole lot about who you know. And who your friends know. If you can facilitate an introduction to someone who may have either job leads or some solid input on how to find relevant work, give your friend the nod. If your friend is struggling to pay for dues to an important professional organization, help them find resources to pay or offer to help pay if you’re able. Where relevant, offer to go with them to professional events in your community so that it feels less intimidating. Then be their hype person as you mingle. “My friend, here, is looking for work, and let me tell you about their skills in _____.”</p><p><em>Major caveat: </em>Make sure you’re both on board for the networking that’s about to happen. Don’t spring people on people. Do some pre-planning with both parties so they know that the introduction is welcome.</p><p><strong>The Bigger Picture:</strong> You may have noticed a bit of a trend. But just in case you didn’t, let me spell it out. The key to success in offering any kind of social support is to consider three things: the task, the individuals, and your relationship to one another.</p><ol><li>The <strong>task</strong> in this case is helping a friend after a job loss that was sudden and cruel.</li><li>The <strong>individuals</strong> are you (the supporter) and them (the supportee). Each of you brings a particular personality with particular personal and social histories. Recognize that what works for you as an individual may not be great for them as an individual. Make your support centered around them. If you don’t know what they need from you, ask them. If it feels awkward, just start a discussion and see if you can suss it out. Ask other people who know them if they have thoughts on how the supportee might like to be supported.</li><li>The <strong>relationship</strong> is all about taking into consideration your specific history with this person, including how long you’ve known them, in what capacity, and with what anticipated future. If you’ve been friends for 25 years, that’s very different from knowing them since last fall. The trust is different, the common knowledge will be less, the intensity of support required or desired may vary tremendously. Just be conscious of that and offer support that feels natural to who you are together.</li></ol><p>This is a time of great sorrow for a lot of people. So many people. It’s going to take a long time for this trauma to feel manageable. Know that supporting a friend facing this mass mess is a long game. It’s not a one-and-done situation, it’s a ride-or-die situation. It’s being ready, willing, and able to be there for them through a range of emotions, needs, and next steps. What will work one day, will definitely not work next month. You have to be nimble and you have to communicate. A LOT.</p><blockquote><strong><em>Pay attention, ask gentle questions, stay calm even when it feels like your friend is being unreasonable or hurtful. Do this because you recognize that trauma speaks in many different voices with the same voice.</em></strong></blockquote><p>Unreasonable and hurtful may not be intended, or it may just be stress or trauma venting. Your job is to say, “It’s okay. I’m here for you.”</p><p>And then…be there for them.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2c6d2c5b246b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[From UX healthcare researcher to UX healthcare research participant]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/design-bootcamp/what-am-i-an-ethnographer-edfd757094eb?source=rss-93260e7268d1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/edfd757094eb</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[patient-experience]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ux]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[healthcare]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Dena Huisman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 12 Feb 2025 20:19:10 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-03-18T20:42:14.844Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Building empathy with patients to improve healthcare experiences is my job. But when I had my own health crisis, that empathy ramped up a notch. Here’s what I learned about being a patient in a digital healthcare environment.</p><figure><img alt="A dog wrapped in a white blanket, suggesting illness and recovery." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Mdzb1LP_lY-WZt8DxZsHXw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Image by <a href="https://www.freepik.com/free-photo/shiba-inu-dog-relaxing-bed_28474797.htm#fromView=search&amp;page=1&amp;position=0&amp;uuid=1c81728d-39d3-4e09-bdf6-0a5507adbec3&amp;query=sick+dog">Freepik</a></figcaption></figure><p>I had foot surgery and was diagnosed with cancer all within a month. Here’s what it taught me about B2B sales….</p><p>JK. I am not that kind of LinkedIn poster who can turn tragedy into a lesson about corporate life. And I’m not here to tell you there’s an “upside” to having cancer. There isn’t. It sucks. Do. Not. Recommend.</p><p>To boot (pun intended), I had the foot surgery mere hours before my cancer journey suddenly began, so for the first two months of cancer diagnosis and treatment, I also was navigating life in a splint followed by a boot and crutches. I will not be marking 2024 as a banner year for health excellence.</p><p>As a professional in Healthcare UX, though, I did use the whole experience as an opportunity for a little ethnographic research into what it’s like to be a patient managing a thousand appointments with a million new medical vocabulary words. And as a researcher, what good is gathering the information without sharing my findings in the hopes of building some valuable insights for improved user experience?</p><p>So, here are some things I learned about experience design while being a patient for two simultaneous serious medical processes. I will first provide some examples of my experiences, followed by experience opportunities for healthcare systems to consider.</p><blockquote><em>A couple quick caveats first</em>:</blockquote><blockquote>— These recommendations are simply the thoughts of a patient with some insider knowledge of healthcare — <strong>they are not fully formed actionable insights!</strong></blockquote><blockquote>— I am a remote employee, so the place <strong>where I got care is not the same health system where I work</strong>. This means you should not look up my employer and assume I mean them. It also means I wasn’t biased by being an employee of where I was doing my “ethnography.”</blockquote><blockquote>— In corporate speak: All <strong>opinions expressed below are my own</strong> and are in no way connected to/speaking about my employer. Whom I like, BTW!</blockquote><h3><strong>Experience 1: Bad communication is bad healthcare</strong></h3><p>The day before foot surgery, I had my regularly scheduled breast cancer screening appointment. As I was being driven home from that foot surgery, I found out via a healthcare portal message that I was scheduled for a diagnostic ultrasound five days later. I knew from past experience that diagnostic test meant they found something, but it was hours later that I got a phone call explaining what was going on, around the same time that a test result showed up on my portal. Even if I hadn’t been in a post-anesthesia haze, this piecemeal discovery that I might have cancer would have been anxiety producing. No one should have made that appointment without a doctor first explaining to me what was happening or giving me time to read a test result (at a minimum). That it was the same day as my surgery wasn’t anyone’s fault, but it added so much stress to an already stressful day.</p><p>When the ultrasound couldn’t find the concerning spot, I was told to return a few weeks later to have an MRI needle biopsy. And that’s when communication went from bad to worse. Portal messaging from the MRI department indicated that I should contact my doctor to get a prescription sedative if I had concerns about being in an MRI tube for an hour or two. I did have concerns, so my primary doctor gave me a low-dose valium and told me to take it 30–60 minutes before the procedure. As a rule follower, I took it right before I checked in for the procedure, only to be told 10 minutes later that I had to go home because I couldn’t sign the consent form (that I didn’t know about) if I had already taken the valium (that wouldn’t even start kicking in for another 20 minutes).<br> <br> After having arranged a ride and hobbled in with my impaired foot — to find out if I had cancer — I was told to leave for reasons I could not have known or predicted. It was devastating. I was told by staff that this wasn’t the first time they’d had to reschedule, meaning they knew the procedure communication was causing problems. My cancer specialist got me in a few days later, and the staff was extremely ingratiating — they knew they screwed up, they knew I was incensed. But it was too late. The sour experience made the whole thing an agony, and delayed my diagnosis, even by a few days.</p><p>Then, once the biopsy was over, the radiologist said, “Ok. So now we see what the surgeon says about the other spot.” Excuse me? The other spot? I have two spots that might be cancer? I had not been told there were two, and further, it meant that I needed another MRI needle biopsy, meaning I had to go through the whole thing again a few weeks later. Meaning I knew I had cancer for weeks while I waited to find out if I had MORE cancer. Which I did. All told, from the moment of finding out I needed diagnostics to finding out I had two tumors was a full month of multiple appointments, miscommunication, and anxiety.</p><p>Lastly, during all the cancer diagnosis chaos, I was managing my foot surgery recuperation. At the appointment where I exchanged the splint for a boot, I was told by a nurse that I was <em>legally </em>not allowed to drive at all with my boot, even though it was on my left (non-driving) foot. Three weeks after that, I had a check-up appointment where another provider said I could absolutely drive, but to be cautious and not take long-distance trips. I spent the three weeks between those appointments having to arrange rides to every appointment and store visit when I hadn’t needed to at all. I was extremely frustrated to find out that I had been so strictly warned of something that wasn’t even a real thing.</p><h4>Opportunities:</h4><p>— It is wildly difficult to ensure that every communication protocol is exactly aligned. However, when there are significant consequences — such as a delay in care and diagnosis as with my first biopsy consent form — patients are left feeling angry and scared. When the health topic is cancer, triple that anger, and add a dose of anxiety. When the appointments are additionally difficult by mobility and transportation struggles, you have a recipe for disaster. Not every communication gap will involve so many barriers, but you can’t predict the multiplying complicators that come with a simple misunderstanding. So you have to prepare for them. Designers and healthcare teams should work together to find out what barriers patients experience and what communication gaps impact successful delivery of healthcare. Conduct research with patients to find out how they experience the process and what frustrations they have that can be remedied in future.</p><p>— Having an appointment added to my calendar before I even knew there was anything wrong with my breast cancer screening left me confused and panicked. This flow of information was extremely stressful and panic inducing. The fact that I had just come out of major surgery when it happened just made it all worse. Making sure patients have information in an order that facilitates understanding can relieve stress and allow them to prepare for what they need to do to follow health protocol. Schedule follow-up appointments only after a patient has the opportunity to learn why they are being asked to come back in. Work with staff to ensure there is a portal communication protocol that ensures an appropriate flow of information from clinic/lab, to provider, to patient. Every time.</p><h3><strong>Experience 2: My portal, my frenemy</strong></h3><p>For most of my life, I went to the doctor a few times a year for my annual wellness check and a few little odds and ends. My electronic health portal was just an app on my phone that I used sometimes.<br> <br> Then suddenly last fall, the portal became an app I used daily. Appointment set up, appointment reminders, test results, after visit summaries, letters, billing statements, messages. On the one hand, I knew I can change notification settings; on the other, when I’m juggling two major health issues, can I trust myself not to need notifications? Let alone figure out how to change settings? Here are some examples of how the portal added stress.</p><p>First off, appointments. The day I visited radiation oncology, we made a plan for four weeks of daily treatments. I went home, ready to start so I could be ready to be done. And then, my phone started vibrating. “New appointment” alert. “New appointment” alert. “New appointment” alert. One, for each. And every. Appointment. Buzz. Buzz. Buzz. They came in every two minutes or so. Buzz. Buzz. Buzz. <br> <br> And while that was annoying, it was nothing to the daily “Reminder to check in for your upcoming appointment.” Each day, I had to go into the portal and go through the same three screens: contact person, medication list (and which pharmacy to use), known allergies. Every. Day. I started off doing several at once, but I caught up quickly and then they would only release one new date at a time. If I had multiple appointments on the same day, even in the same clinic, I had to go through the process for each. And every. Visit. <br> <br> By the end, even if something had changed in my information, I probably wouldn’t have thought to update because I was just so blind to what it was even asking me. I just scrolled and clicked, scrolled and clicked, scrolled and clicked, then submit.</p><p>Second, reminder notifications and updates were inconsistent throughout the process. Some departments sent me a portal message to remind me of the upcoming appointment. I’d get a notification that I had a new message on my portal, which often led to panic because I thought that meant my doctor was telling me something was wrong. It turns out, it was just that I had a PT appointment the next day. This on top of my notification for e-check in for the same appointment. Other times, I’d get a text message to confirm my appointment requiring a yes/no response. Sometimes I got neither and just had to keep tabs on my calendar (and obsessive rechecking my portal visit lists to be sure I wasn’t forgetting something). Having different processes for different departments added chaos and uncertainty to my life while juggling anywhere from 5–10 appointments each week.</p><p>Results. Then there are all the results and letters and labs. All the information is there in the portal, but it can be confusing to know what is where and what it all means. I would get notifications, “You have a new test result.” Text notifications provide a link, which opens the portal in my mobile browser rather than my app. Meaning, the link is useless to me. So, I open the app and then had to dig for what I want. Sometimes it was under Test Results, sometimes I misunderstood and it was actually under Letters. Sometimes it showed up on the home page after I logged in; sometimes it didn’t. <br> <br> The law requires hospitals to release results as soon as they are available, regardless of whether a doctor has reviewed them. There’s no easy way around that, and I’m not sure there should be. We have a right to our medical information. The downside is that I (being anxious, and a nerd) cannot help myself from trying to read the jargony language of a pathology report, to figure out which little spot on the image is a cancerous tumor waiting to kill me. And being anxious and a nerd, I also can’t help myself from looking everything up on Dr. Google. It’s not my doctor’s or portal’s fault that I am what I am. But it’s definitely a cursed gift to have all that information and insufficient knowledge to make any meaning of it. Not to mention a confusing organizational experience while navigating the app.</p><p>As an example, when getting my first biopsy report, I saw the word “invasive” ductal carcinoma. The word invasive made my whole body curl into itself. It was invasive! I was going to die! It’s already everywhere! Wellllllll. No, actually. It simply means that the cancer that originated in the milk ducts had escaped out of said ducts and into the larger breast tissue. It’s by far the most common biopsy result; few breast cancers are detected while only contained in the ducts. What if there were links available that I could click to better understand what “invasive” meant in this case? Similarly, my cancer cells were grade 2. In my head, I thought that meant I was at stage 2. Certainly not a death sentence, but something serious. But it turns out grade 2 cells is not the same thing as stage 2 cancer and I was actually stage 1. But I don’t know that. I’ve never had cancer before!<br> <br>Fortunately, my cancer specialist is amazing, and she cleared it all up at our consultation. But that was later, after I’d had time to get my affairs in order, make sure my life insurance beneficiaries were up to date, and I had found a new home for my elderly dog. (I’m kind of exaggerating. Kind of.)</p><h4>Opportunities</h4><p>— I know there are constraints on the possibilities of this, as has been <a href="https://medium.com/@wardandrews/healthcare-ux-4-common-problems-with-patient-portals-aede4e40fa1a">noted by others</a>, but I can’t help wonder if there are ways to group e-check ins. Where you can opt in for one check in to count for a week’s worth of appointments, or at least a day’s worth of appointments. When a person, such as me, sometimes had as many as 10 appointments in a week, it is so onerous as to be maddening. When you’re already going mad because you have cancer and you can’t walk because your stupid foot is recovering from surgery, each drip drip drip of annoyance becomes a reason for rage. How can this process be streamlined to make it <a href="https://medium.com/design-bootcamp/5-major-challenges-in-healthcare-ux-design-and-how-to-overcome-them-f0366a6fbef8">emotionally and tangibly easier</a> for those in serious health crises?</p><p>— While I acknowledge the legal constraints to many workable solutions for report release, are there ways of building in reliable explanations to complex terminology? A linked glossary to complicated terms that patients can click to learn more about — a glossary that is not Dr. Google? A standard report that can be auto-generated that is written in simpler English, with the caveat that patients should consult with their providers for more detailed analysis? Perhaps <a href="https://medium.com/@thealiendesign/improving-healthcare-ux-key-strategies-and-best-practices-d2f6d2159159">virtual chatbots</a> in the portal could help answer some basic questions for patients? The NIH recently published <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK602381/">Chatbots in Health Care: Connecting Patients to Information</a>, which offers some ideas on how this might be helpful to patients like me.</p><p>— Is there a way to give patients a kind of alarm bell rating system alongside a test result? For example, before starting tamoxifen (post-cancer treatment to reduce recurrence), I had to have blood work done. Results showed my insulin levels were sky high. I panicked (hi! I have anxiety!), but it turns out that this was simply the result of having a non-fasting blood test. If there was a way to build that into the lab report instead of me doing a panicked Dr. Google consult, it would have been great. I was lucky my medical oncologist wrote me a message shortly after to confirm what Dr. Google had said. No need to panic: it was just that bread you ate for lunch.</p><h3><strong>Experience 3: My portal, my doctor’s frenemy?</strong></h3><p>As I said, I work in healthcare UX. I know that portal messaging can be both a wonderful gift for providers and a source of overload at times. While doctors want to take good care of patients however they can, responding to messages in their inbox on top of caring for patients in clinic can be daunting. Very understandably daunting. <a href="https://www.fiercehealthcare.com/tech/industry-voices-want-to-improve-patient-experience-start-by-meeting-patients-where-they-spend">Burnout has been tied to administrative work</a>, <a href="https://www.ama-assn.org/practice-management/digital/what-s-adding-doctor-burnout-check-your-patient-portal-inbox">including patient messaging</a>.</p><p>As a patient, though, it’s pretty great. As I was dealing with reduced mobility, it was a gift to be able to ask a few quick questions to my providers without having to find a ride or walk in on crutches. As I recovered from my lumpectomy, I could send photos to inquire about some allergic reactions I was experiencing to get input on how to relieve itching. (Though sending selfie photos of my scabby breast was a little embarrassing and awkward.)</p><p>Because I work in healthcare, I tried to be <a href="https://www.ama-assn.org/practice-management/digital/what-doctors-wish-patients-knew-about-using-patient-portal">conscious of sending messages only for very quick and simple things</a>, or to inquire whether something necessitated an appointment. Additionally, I was working with a whole team, so if I sent to the wrong person, they were awesome at forwarding to a different person who could help me. But even just those simple things really saved me a lot of stress of time and transportation while I dealt with multiple health concerns at once.</p><h4>Opportunities:</h4><p>— No real solutions here, but I do really want healthcare UXers to consider how we can continue offering the messaging service that helps patients so much while not causing additional stressors to providers. Are there ways we can better communicate to patients how and when to use messaging vs. a call or appointment? At my health system, there are billable messaging visit options for messages that require more than a minimal, simple response. While patients might struggle to understand why they should pay for a text-based consultation, it does establish that some messaging requires more effort from providers than a simple reply. What else can designers do to bridge the gap between patient needs and provider stress? And what about patients who are either tech averse or don’t have access to tech that allows them to use portals? Are there ways we can provide the same kind of convenient answers to simple questions without necessitating a smart phone or computer?</p><h3><strong>Example 4: Just tell me where I’m going</strong></h3><p>My foot surgery was scheduled in “the blue building.” Which was fine, except that I didn’t know which building <em>was</em> the blue building, and the maps available on the hospital website did not designate the campus by building color. So, I was left to wonder where on earth I was supposed to go at 5:00 in the morning to have my heel bone sawed down (yes).</p><p>Because I was in the hospital the day before surgery (for the ill-fated breast cancer screening), I was able to ask the hospital help desk. They had a paper map. A paper map that also didn’t show the building color code. They had to circle it on the map to show me which it was. Because there was no other way to tell which was the blue building. ARGH.</p><p>The morning of surgery, my friend and I found the building and parking across the street. But there also was no indication outside that this was “the blue building”. It had an actual name. An actual name that was nowhere in my pre-op information packet. So yeah. Okay.</p><p>Then, I had an orthopedic follow-up appointment one afternoon for my foot. The primary hospital ramp was full, so I had to drive to the secondary ramp. A bit of a problem given I was walking in a boot and it was further away. MORE of a problem that the elevator in that ramp was very poorly marked and (once I finally found it) down about a dozen stairs. Stairs that were hard for me to navigate in a boot — and would be impossible for someone to navigate in a wheelchair. Oh, and the directions for getting back into the building with the elevator after my appointment was non-existent. The way I got out was not accessible for getting in. So I had to backtrack in my boot and slowly walk through a high-traffic area to find a door that would take me to the elevator.</p><h4>Opportunities:</h4><p>— <a href="https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4287692/">Wayfinding in healthcare is particularly complicated</a> when the healthcare system includes multiple buildings, floors, and locations. Assume your patients don’t know where anything is. Give them multiple places and opportunities to understand how your hospital campus works. At a minimum, provide thorough mapping and direction options on the website, and maybe even in the portal. Consider also linking that website information on any portal, texting, and/or email messaging. Provide paper copies of maps with any pre-op appointments. Provide labels both inside and outside buildings that correspond directly to the information in the patient materials. Repetition is the spice of wayfinding life.</p><p>— Then, be sure that <a href="https://www.ada.gov/resources/medical-care-mobility/">accessibility is easily accessible</a>. I have long known about and advocated for increased accessibility in public spaces. But I’ll be honest. I didn’t recognize just how inaccessible some accessible resources can be until I needed them. Little steps feel like big steps when you’re in a boot. Having the orthopedics office alllll the way at the end of the hallway when the patients are very often people with mobility issues? Maybe not ideal. Limited parking availability close to the clinic? Not super awesome, especially when accessibility in that far away ramp is dismal. As healthcare systems, we need to be at the forefront of ensuring patients can get where they need to be as smoothly and barrier-free as possible. Every little improvement can make a world of difference to a patient who is already going through a lot just being a patient.</p><h3><strong>Example 5: The good is GOOD</strong></h3><p>I want to stress that I made it through all of it, and I am now returned to health (so far as I know). I also want to add that I had some truly amazing experiences over this whole process. Here are some great things that happened that I want all healthcare systems to emulate.</p><p>First, the support staff. The receptionists at the cancer center I went to were the kindest, sweetest, most amazing people. And that is what you need when you’re going somewhere because you have cancer. Similarly, the receptionist at the radiation office knew my name on day two and treated me like a friend each day I entered. That personal, friendly touch is the world. I’m so grateful.</p><p>When the whole needle biopsy MRI snafu happened, there were several techs and staff members who went out of their way to make it up to me, and while I was still pretty grumpy about the whole thing, their kindness and acknowledgement of my frustration was really important and meaningful.</p><p>The medical staff, including surgeons and oncologists, were just stellar. They got to understand my sarcastic, jokey side pretty quickly and embraced it as a communication style with care and sensitivity. They answered all my questions, even when I repeated them. My radiation oncologist told me I was “very special,” which made me feel….well, “very special.” The radiation therapists were my hype team every morning, asking about my dog, commenting on my cool new shoes, telling me as much as I wanted to know about the process of having radiation blasted into my body. So much so that on the last day of treatment, I was actually a little sad because it meant not seeing my radiation buddies anymore — I even brought them chocolate and flowers to thank them for making me feel so nice while doing something so awful. They were that special to me.</p><p>As a former communication studies professor, it is no surprise to me that my good experiences were those moments of interpersonal connection, of genuine empathy and good spirits. My <a href="https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/0030222820961231?casa_token=9TrivMvDhPoAAAAA%3AYP-uCrTejmm_ixODEa3AR8Z5tdUmJx3nQAWo662F5iBi34YkoMIK25VnJtKn3XgUywcoOnIF6qApXw">research in academia</a> focused on empathy in social support communication, and I consistently found that person-centered, individually focused communication is the key to helping people cope with stressors. That’s what healthcare boils down to, really. All our designs have to emulate all our goals for interpersonal warmth and value. How can we think about technology design as a kind of interpersonal connection? A way to bring together the humanity of a hospital system with the humanity of each and every patient who uses our tools and visits our clinics?</p><p>Healthcare in the U.S. is not in an ideal shape. Lots of factors make it harder to be the care providers we want to be. That just makes it all the more important that we as experience researchers and designers work with clinical staff to ensure we are making the best of a lot of hard positions.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=edfd757094eb" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/design-bootcamp/what-am-i-an-ethnographer-edfd757094eb">From UX healthcare researcher to UX healthcare research participant</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/design-bootcamp">Bootcamp</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Woman in Search of Professional Development Must Be in Want of a Spreadsheet]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@denahuisman_76178/a-woman-in-search-of-professional-development-must-be-in-want-of-a-spreadsheet-04d4b405cc4f?source=rss-93260e7268d1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/04d4b405cc4f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[spreadsheets]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[research-reports]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ux-research-portfolio]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ux-research]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Dena Huisman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 17 May 2024 21:58:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-05-17T23:06:50.546Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CjOAlv54DYldoeYS_ZAKqQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Image by <a href="https://www.freepik.com/author/racool-studio">racool-studio</a> on Freepik</figcaption></figure><p>In academia, I had a handy dandy software package that organized how I organized my work. As a user experience professional, I will gladly say that the software stank. It wasn’t user friendly at all. BUT! It did give me a built-in structure for keeping track of my productivity. And I was required to use it for tenure and post-tenure reviews, so being self-driven wasn’t a required skill.</p><p>Now that I’m in a non-academic workspace, I have had to make a million little adjustments (see my <a href="https://medium.com/@denahuisman_76178/new-year-who-dis-what-i-learned-in-my-first-year-out-of-academia-and-into-industry-d0d74bf6293a">prior essay</a> for a lot more on that). One of the biggies is finding a way to keep track of the work I do without having an organizationally mandated method or application. Self-driven? Here I come.</p><p>I was lucky to have an amazing mentor in my first contract job, Kayla, who helped me set up a plan to keep track of projects that I did on her team. This allowed me to build my first portfolio for the big wild world of job interviews. Since taking my first full-time industry position, I’ve taken Kayla’s advice and made a spreadsheet plan that works for the expanded responsibilities in my world.</p><p>Given the nature of things, it didn’t feel right to include real projects I have done at my current job, so I created a <a href="https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Vy1HamljykBzkBq84uNrmULSQvhwnSL4lEUb-WWNwWE/edit?usp=sharing">nerdtastic spreadsheet</a> of my fictional time working for Hertfordshire Consulting. Those who share my love of Jane Austen will understand my little jokes. That’s your bonus, my nerdy friends. You. Are. Welcome.</p><p>To the rest of you who are not so fortunate to have read Pride &amp; Prejudice at least 10 times (or to have watched the 1995 miniseries at least as many times), I hope you’ll still find value in the structure of the document. Below, I’ll talk a little bit about what each column is meant to do for my ongoing professional development and maintenance of portfolio-ready data. While the content is fictional, the structure is 100% factual to my real-life record keeping.</p><p>Tangent: In the document, sheets 2 (Courses Taken) and 3 (Presentations Attended) are pretty straightforward. They are simply examples from my real list of activities. Every time I attend a lecture or workshop and complete a course, I enter the vital information to my spreadsheet. This allows me to talk about them as needed, as well as to remember the key learnings from each.</p><p>But yes. The <a href="https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Vy1HamljykBzkBq84uNrmULSQvhwnSL4lEUb-WWNwWE/edit?usp=sharing">project sheet</a>. Let’s chat briefly about that. Capital, capital (Sir Lucas, 1813).</p><p>I start with the <strong>Department</strong>(s) and <strong>Stakeholder</strong> cells, listing whom I worked with on the project. Pretty basic stuff. I err on the side of being more inclusive of stakeholders than may be necessary, including minor players as well as the key ones. This makes it easier for future me to connect with someone from the project, even if there have been job changes, etc. I fill these cells the moment I’m assigned a project.</p><p>Then I list <strong>Dates</strong> just so I can readily demonstrate how often I’m juggling multiple tasks and how much time I invest in a project. It’s nice that I can show both quick turnaround efficiency as well as long-term dedication to a sizable project.</p><p>By including all the <strong>Methods</strong> I use, I’m able to remember the range of skills I have. In my Notion database, I use tags for these. That way I can search by each tag to see how I’ve used a method in multiple contexts. This is nice to show that I know when to use which method, as well as the versatility a method can provide. It is also nice when you expect an employer to focus on a particular type of method(s) in an interview— you can quickly review what you can chat with them about. If you use Excel, you can do a Find and get what you need as well. Excel is like Mr. Collins. Good enough for some, but certainly not anyone’s ideal.</p><p>In the <strong>Partners</strong> cell, I include teammates and other fellow researchers and designers. Distinct from stakeholders, these are the people in the weeds with me, most often members of my team. In real life, a few times I’ve partnered with researchers in other departments (e.g., marketing), and their names go in here as well. This is nice for the purpose of showing that I play well with others, but it also helps me in case I need peer feedback for a new job, letters of recommendation, etc.</p><p>The <strong>Project Summary</strong> is another one I try to fill in upon being assigned a project. It will likely change (sometimes dramatically) by the end of the project, but having my initial thoughts written down helps me determine what I know, don’t know, and need to ask before I even get started. If I can’t offer a preliminary summary, I need to work on getting more information to establish myself on the right footing.</p><p>The <strong>Project Impact</strong> is the big kid of the spreadsheet. Sometimes I’ll add a little bit in here before the project is complete, but the bulk of this cell is filled in after I complete the data analysis have the presentation materials put together. This is a high-level description of key insights, action steps, and larger outcomes. This will turn into meat and potatoes of a portfolio project, so it is worth it to me to spend time on it as soon as I can upon study completion. I want it down when it’s fresh. I don’t feel the need to do extensive detail since that will be in the linked <strong>Presentation Materials</strong> (see a few cells over).</p><p>The next cell can be filled out early on as well. It lists any <strong>Connections to Prior Projects</strong> that inform the current one. I like this because it makes it easy for me to show how my work has legs over time, as well as how I can draw complicated connections across research projects. I try to be detailed in what insights in prior work inform current research questions and decisions.</p><p>The last one is another big component of what becomes a portfolio project. I always want to highlight how I continue my <strong>Professional Development</strong>. While I hope my courses and presentations attended demonstrate my ongoing love of learning, showing the application of my learning <em>in situ</em> can make a way bigger impact on employers. I include UX-specific learning as well as broader professional growth stuff (stakeholder communication, conflict management, etc), so that I can demonstrate a well rounded growth pattern.</p><p>The last few cells are mostly just housekeeping details. Having a link to presentation materials saves me the effort of digging later, and having the presentation date ensures I can go back to find the calendar event in case I need to find the recording, names of attendees, etc.</p><p>I would say that each row requires at least one hour total of work over the course of a project. Sometime more, sometimes less. Given it is spread out over the project, it doesn’t feel like a burden, especially compared to the gains I make in keeping a fresh portfolio. It has the additional perk of letting me see in a concise way that I am doing good, meaningful work. As a person who sometimes doubts herself, my spreadsheet serves as a confidence booster. And who couldn’t use that?</p><p>Reach out if you have questions or want to discuss your own project portfolio file. I’m always happy to chat.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=04d4b405cc4f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[New Year, who dis? What I learned in my first year out of academia and into industry]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@denahuisman_76178/new-year-who-dis-what-i-learned-in-my-first-year-out-of-academia-and-into-industry-d0d74bf6293a?source=rss-93260e7268d1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d0d74bf6293a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[leaving-academia]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[career-transitions]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[post-academia]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[work-life-balance]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Dena Huisman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 31 Jan 2024 21:34:02 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-02-01T02:25:14.542Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*6S-J_Nq_8dUQT-rrDwrDeQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Image by <a href="https://www.freepik.com/author/vecstock">vecstock</a> on Freepik</figcaption></figure><p>One year ago, I began my first official, full-time, non-contract job in UX.</p><p>One year ago!</p><p>At the time, I knew it was a seismic leap to leave academia, my professional home for 15 years. Once you got that sweet, sweet tenured job, you weren’t supposed to leave. You were not cut out for anything BUT that. You had no transferrable skills to “the real world” (i.e., Corporate America™).</p><p>But here I was, getting a new computer (a Windows machine even — I mean…what?), going to a corporate orientation meeting, learning new HR systems, and like…working 8–5 M-F. Like a normie. EVEN IN THE SUMMER!</p><p>It was all very scary, especially to a person like me who dreads change and lives in constant certainty that all my prior successes have just been the result of me hiding my abject stupidity and failures from everyone. Everyone has a talent — mine is not having any.</p><p>The person who started that job in January 2023 has learned a few things and done some growing. In my <a href="https://medium.com/after-academia/i-had-coffee-with-a-colleague-friend-one-day-and-i-said-i-think-im-done-9d5bbb52e5e6">prior post</a>, I talked about the process I went through to get my first non-academic job. This post is about what happened once I did, in the hopes that it might also help people facing this transition period from professor to…whatever “not professor” means to them.</p><p>So sit back and learn from my lack of talent that I’m hoping you won’t notice. Muahaha.</p><h3>You know stuff.</h3><p>One of the things I had to detox myself from was the idea that no one would care about my mamby pamby academic research and teaching knowledge. I was starting from scratch in this new job. All new skills, all new responsibilities.<br> <br>And yes. I had a lot of new skills to learn, and my responsibilities looked really different in my industry job. But the reality is that these new things were only new-ish. My academic research on social support turns out to be deeply useful for human-centered research and design practices. My experience doing and teaching public speaking is particularly relevant to delivering research reports and facilitating workshops. Understanding human communication patterns helps me develop thoughtful interview protocol with patients and staff.<br> <br>It’s important to start looking for those connections while you look for a non-academic job, but it has been equally (more??) important during the actual debut into industry. Keep your ears open for ways you can utilize those knowledge sets. For example, I’m helping a colleague lead a group book discussion based on my teaching experience. I’m helping another group with in-depth interviews on a sensitive subject because of my expertise in support and social stigma. When we plan team workshops, I use my knowledge of instructional design to offer ideas for keeping participants engaged. I use my critical theory background to analyze our projects to ensure we are being socially just in our work (fortunately, I have rock star teammates who share these ideals).</p><blockquote>Be thoughtful and deliberate about how you might find connections between your research passions and your non-academic role.</blockquote><p>Reach out to other teams, organizational leadership, and anyone else who might be interested in learning more from you. Want to host a Lunch and Learn? Great. Want to volunteer to write something for the corporate newsletter? Why not? If you see a place to bring things up in a meeting — that won’t make you sound like an insufferable prig — go for it. <br> <br>The important thing is that you do it with genuine curiosity, lack of pomposity, and a clear plan for explaining why it is directly relevant to your company’s purposes and goals. Don’t pontificate for pontification’s sake. Do it to improve the company and the people you work with.<br> <br>And whatever you do, don’t force feed anyone with your academic conference paper presentation style. Oh, lord. Don’t do that. These are conversations, not attempts to prove to your grad-school nemesis that you really are smarter than they are. Because of course you are. Like it was ever even a contest. Psh.</p><h3>Rethink making an impact.</h3><p>One of the hardest things I’ve had to deal with in the transition was not putting my identity into my job. Academia sometimes keeps you in check by reminding you that your job is Who You Are. You’re an educator. You’re an elite. You’re an ACADEMIC. So you work nights and weekends, you watch TV looking for examples for class, you spend countless hours perfecting that class lecture, you write write write for the journal article that you won’t get paid for and three people will read (if you’re lucky). Because it’s just Who You Are. <br> <br> Now, my job is the thing I do for a salary. Yes, I enjoy it. I find it satisfying and interesting, and I feel like it makes a positive difference. I’m grateful for it! But it’s not who I am. <br> <br>Who am I now? I’m the person who works during the day at a fun job and then spends her evenings reading about things she chooses to learn about. Who is learning to draw and hand letter. Who is getting really good at guitar because she has more time to practice now. Who is volunteering for a pet shelter because she has time to. It turns out that having a distinct work-self divide is healthy.<br> <br>I won’t lie. There are times when I have a hard time seeing this division in a positive way. I was so invested in my academic job as vocation that seeing any job as “just” an occupation sometimes feels empty. But then I remember the fun I’m having in my life beyond work, and I’m building ways to make my life more meaningful through personal and community adventures. <br> <br>I also think about the fact that I’m now nearly completely weaned off my antidepressants. I’m enjoying my life, not just living my life for work. My current job does not ask me to invest too much of my identity in it; it doesn’t imply that I can never do enough “for the students/organization.” I’m never asked to sacrifice what I know to be good pedagogy/practice for the bottom line. I don’t have colleagues who are disastrously underpaid (I still see you, adjuncts and teaching professors). <br> <br>As you navigate the transition, give yourself permission to explore new hobbies and interests that you denied yourself in your academic life because “I should be working on teaching/research/committee work.”</p><blockquote>Allow yourself to find your humanitarian nature and passion for making the world better in new and celebratory ways. Meet new people, try new acts of service. Be a person.</blockquote><p>Remember this: if you think academia is the only/best way to provide a service to the world (inside or outside of work), what are you really saying about EVERYONE ELSE? That they are less impactful or humanitarian than you are? Is that really what you want to argue?</p><h3>Keep a list, and check it twice.</h3><p>In my academic career, I routinely entered my committees, courses, conference presentations, etc. into our faculty profile software. Once entered, I probably never looked at it again until it was time for promotion or post-tenure review. <br> <br>In my post-academic life, I do things differently. There’s no organizational requirement to have a work history portfolio — annual/post-tenure reviews and promotions aren’t determined by a group of strangers who need elaborate reports to determine a stranger’s worthiness. However, I still choose to keep thorough records of my accomplishments so that when it comes time for those annual reviews and promotions, I can remember and highlight my achievements in full.<br> <br>I have three tables. The first lists each of my research projects, when they happened, who the key stakeholders and team collaborators were, what the research questions were and what methods I used to answer them, what the outcomes were (often including a link to the report deck I created), and what impact they had on the organization. The impact statement usually comes well after the project is complete, so it would be smart to make a note to follow up several months later with whoever can help me determine how the work made a difference. Note to self: start doing that.<br> <br>I start the project row in my table the moment I’m assigned to it. And I routinely go in and add any updates I can so that it is fresh as I go. Because I’m used to the “never enough” panic of academia, I use this table to record mywork AND to keep myself in check. Ok, Dena, you think you’re not doing enough? Let’s see what the table says. Oh. You’ve completed three projects this quarter. Maybe you can chill the heck out and accept your success for once. <br> <br>The second table I create lists all the non-research projects I take on at work, big or small. That book club discussion I helped facilitate goes there. Other little odds and ends can be plopped in there, too. It’s not that I expect big congratulations for them, but I do want my employer to know I am value-added! I have a broad range of skills and a can-do team focus that I use to make my organization better. Go me!<br> <br>The third table is a list of professional development work I’ve done. Given I’m newer to UX than my teammates, I have invested a significant amount of time in online courses and seminars that give me insight on growing my skills and career in UX. My list for 2023 includes more than 30 events, courses, master courses, and seminars I attended, when I attended them, what the subject was, and a brief discussion of what I learned from it. You can also add professionally related books you’ve read. Note to self: start doing this, too.<br> <br>Again, this is partly to demonstrate to my manager that I am working hard to develop and improve, but it’s also to remind myself in times of stress that I am doing a lot and working hard to do even better.</p><blockquote>The key for these tables is OUTCOME. It’s not just that I did stuff (which, frankly was the primary function of my tenure file); it’s that I did stuff for a reason and with a tangible outcome of success and professional growth.</blockquote><h3>The Rat Race is what you make of it.</h3><p>I’ve mentioned already that academia is not always great at acknowledging faculty accomplishments. That’s not sour grapes talking — it’s just not the nature of academia. You do a lot of your work alone, so no one sees it. There are a LOT of you, segregated into colleges and departments. There are sometimes ego battles that make acknowldedgments more into boxing matches for finite resources (okay, maybe that’s a little bit of sour grapes). <br> <br>I have found in my industry job that acknowledgments and little everyday accolades are much more common. I was startled by them at first and struggled to believe or understand them. And, of course, my lack of self-confidence certainly played a role there. But I’m learning (slowly) that these are normal and wonderful little nuggets of nice that I can hold and use to build myself up. <br> <br>When something goes well for me and/or my whole team, I take more time to be happy about them, to accept and offer celebratory messages. To feel good that the little successes are part of the big successes. That teamwork really is pretty fantastic when everyone around you truly does want what’s best for all of us, not just themselves.<br> <br>While “the rat race” is real, I have not found it to be <em>more </em>intense in industry than I did in academia. In many ways, I find it <em>less</em> intense, or at least less fanatical. For the first time in my career, I feel like I’m truly part of a group effort, where we push each other to the next success. The resources are to be shared, not grabbed for. Despite all I was told, industry can be kinder than higher ed.</p><blockquote>Find you a company that treats you like mine, and then lean into it. Lean into valuing yourself, your abilities, your contributions, and your worth. Let go of the scarce-resource mentality that academia sometimes culls. Let yourself be successful in ways that fulfill you. Be the rat you want to be, so to speak.</blockquote><p>After my <a href="https://medium.com/after-academia/i-had-coffee-with-a-colleague-friend-one-day-and-i-said-i-think-im-done-9d5bbb52e5e6">last post</a> about the transition process, I had a lot of people reach out via LinkedIn who are in various stages of thinking about leaving, acting on it, and even being successful in doing it! This tells me a couple things: first, that academia has some work to do if they want to retain strong faculty. But that’s a whoooole other discussion. Second, it tells me that folks need help because it’s a complicated process.</p><p>If that’s you, <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/dena-huisman/">reach out</a>. Like I said earlier, find your way to make a difference in the world that isn’t just through your job. For me, providing a little help to folks thinking of this transition is one of my ways of doing just that.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d0d74bf6293a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Leaving the Academy: How I Transitioned into Industry at Mid-Career and How You Can, Too]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/after-academia/i-had-coffee-with-a-colleague-friend-one-day-and-i-said-i-think-im-done-9d5bbb52e5e6?source=rss-93260e7268d1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9d5bbb52e5e6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[user-experience]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mid-career-transition]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[career-transitions]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[leaving-academia]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Dena Huisman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 18 Sep 2023 15:10:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-09-18T21:34:18.718Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="A solitary person walks along a desert path toward mountains." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CxEu26XMxWjga_2hKjYl_Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>Image by wirestock on Freepik</figcaption></figure><p>I had coffee with a colleague friend one day, and I said, “I think I’m done. I don’t think I can do this anymore without completely sacrificing my mental health.” She said, “You know what? Me, too. Let’s look for opportunities to get out.”</p><p>After 11 years of college and 15 years as a tenure-track/tenured and promoted professor, I had it made. I was about to go up for promotion to Full Professor, I had a solid relationship with my students, and I was serving in several leadership positions on committees and in my department. I was finishing up a book on my research topic, and it was going well.</p><p>So why wasn’t I happy? Why didn’t I feel as fulfilled as my annual tenure review report made it seem?</p><p>The answer hit me after a fall-semester sabbatical in 2021. I had suffered from depression for a long time. During my sabbatical semester, I felt the depression fog lift. I was sure that this sabbatical was exactly what I needed to go back to campus in spring, refreshed, ready, full of motivation and energy.</p><p>However, within a month of returning to campus, all that momentum was gone, and I was in as deep of a depression spiral as I had ever been. The light switched on; for all my love of teaching and being with students, the broader frustrations of university life were a major root cause of my emotional problems. The low pay (new faculty were coming in making only a couple thousand less than me after 15 years due to salary compression). The constant increase in workload (we need you on this committee, that committee, this project, that event planning group) with little recognition for the hard work, financial or otherwise. I was the director of my department’s general education course, and I saw just how underpaid non-tenured instructors were by the system of low-paying and inconsistent gig work they were hired under. It bothered me more and more that my colleagues were barely staying financially afloat, and I knew there was nothing I could do to change it, let alone the other things that were making me unhappy.</p><p>A year after that chat over coffee in early 2022, I got my first full-time non-academic job in January 2023. A grad school friend asked me to write a blog for her university on the process I took, and this essay is the result. It is only <em>my</em> path — there are lots of ways to go about it — but I hope these tips might be helpful to others looking to make the same leap.</p><p><strong>Finding a new career. </strong>The first thing I had to do was figure out what the heck I could do beyond being a professor. The academy has a way of making you believe that your skillset can only be applied to higher ed. And industry has a way of backing that claim up. But the truth is, a lot of what I did as a professor could readily be applied to a variety of industry roles. I was lucky that my friend who also decided to leave knew about user experience (UX) research, and she convinced me that I had a skillset that would be a great fit in that field. After doing some reading and research on that career, I agreed with her. I also researched instructional design, grant writing, and a few other options before settling into UX research. <strong><em>The time I spent looking into all my career options via social media and books gave me the baseline for all the actions I took after.</em></strong> Being thoughtful about how you see your skills, how they sound and feel like other jobs, is time well spent. Be honest but optimistic about what you’re capable of as you read job descriptions.</p><p><strong>Networking. </strong>Ugh. The dreaded part, at least for an introvert like me. But what I learned through doing it is that people expect it and are almost always happy to help in some way. When I decided to start looking for another career, I sparked up my LinkedIn page, adding impact-based content (see number 3 in the next post for more on this), and started looking for content creators who matched my interests. I followed individuals with jobs I thought sounded cool, and I introduced myself when the moment seemed right. I looked for groups and organizations that matched what I was looking for. I signed up for LinkedIn Premium so I could take a few UX courses (I’m not sure how strongly to recommend this because the price is substantial, but you do you).</p><p>I also looked out for connections I already had that were either in positions/fields of interest or who worked for companies I was interested in working for. Everyone I reached out to was gracious enough to give me some time by answering questions, offering resources to look at, and providing insight on building myself into a non-academic professional. Each one gave me one step toward success. I connected with former students, grad school colleagues, and people in my community.</p><p>There was some trick to navigating this because I wasn’t eager to have everyone in my university know I was looking to leave. <strong><em>You will have to navigate for yourself the balance between building networks and keeping your information private. </em></strong>It will depend on the security of your employment as well as your personal comfort with risk. But ultimately, at least some networking will need to be done because, as in academia, finding a job is 30% hard work and 70% networking and referrals. (Caveat: I made that percentage up, but it’s probably fairly accurate.)</p><p><strong>Hiring a resume writer.</strong> Once I knew the career I was interested in, I had to start applying. With a resume. Eek. Academic CVs are a beast of another nature from standard resumes. My CV was 20-pages long and listed every class, paper, conference presentation, and committee I ever touched. I knew that corporate resumes were a two-page max situation; I also knew I was NOT up to the task of whittling all those pages down, so I hired a resume writing service to help me. It was amusing to hear the resume writer ask, “So….do you have a shorter version of this CV that we can start from?” No, sir. I do not.</p><p>So, with some probable despair and plans to ask for a pay raise, he got started and quite successfully reduced my 20-year work experience into a two-page document that focused on <em>impact</em> instead of quantity. How my research impacted the community and classroom. How my leadership in our general education class impacted the success of students and my department. He also turned my academic vocabulary into industry speak, using action verbs and outcome language. Being the Director of the Basic Course turned into being a staff manager; being a course designer translated to instructional design. The writer knew I was looking for UX research roles and so he made as many connections to that vocabulary as he could — and then I filled in the rest.</p><p>The main takeaway here is that <strong><em>in industry, a laundry list of tasks or accomplishments will never be enough to get you an interview. You have to focus on how your work made a tangible difference</em></strong>. Think about assessments you did in the classroom that highlight how students acquired new knowledge or skills. How did your work on a committee impact campus curriculum, finances, or employee satisfaction? How did your research make a meaningful change in your community? Did you do any consulting or community outreach? That will sell you more than just the number of classes you taught or committees you served on.</p><p><strong>Take a chance on your future.</strong> A grad school friend had been out of academia for almost ten years and was working in a UX career in California. He was one of the people I reached out to during my early networking phase. He was so gracious to connect me with others he knew who might have tips and/or opportunities for me. One of those connections was yet another former academic who worked for a large tech company. That person connected me to someone in the company looking to hire a contract worker to do usability research.</p><p>The thought of taking a six-month contract position after having a long and stable career for 15 years felt like a huge risk. I talked to my risk-averse dad about it, and he told me I had a way of always landing on my feet because I worked hard and made things happen for myself. This contract, he said, was another opportunity to show what I can do. So I said yes to the opportunity and became a UX researcher for real! I know everyone has a different financial situation, and for some the risk might be too high. However, if you can swing it, taking one or a couple of contract jobs can be a way to build experience. And fun fact: my six-month contract job paid <em>more</em> per month than my academic job. And included health benefits!</p><p>The big takeaway here is this: <strong><em>the transition for you may not be a seamless leap from full-time job to full-time job. It might look like a step (or three) backwards or to the side</em></strong>. But those steps will build the momentum to get you back ahead if you can persevere and keep building those networks.</p><p><strong>Grab every opportunity you see and look for even more. </strong>The contract position turned out to be the single greatest working experience I have ever had. The people I worked with, including my direct manager and folks on other teams, were nonstop supportive of me and my work. I was given the tools I needed to start and then the freedom I wanted to build and grow the skills I would need in my new career.</p><p>When I started this new position, I put myself into the mindset that I was a student again and the job was like an applied graduate classroom. My colleagues were my professors, and my manager the department chair. I interviewed them about their jobs, I asked them to look over my work, I sought advice on how they would approach a research script. I attended their sessions to learn how they develop readouts. When I made mistakes, I listened to their critiques with a humble mindset and tried to avoid feeling stung and embarrassed. (This was sometimes easier than others!). Academics have a reputation as arrogant know-it-alls; <strong><em>I wanted to show them I don’t fit that stereotype, but I also genuinely knew I had a LOT to learn about an industry research role.</em></strong></p><p><strong>Document everything.</strong> My contract role manager was as organized as she was smart. She encouraged me to build a table of each project I completed, including a variety of data points that would showcase my growing skills. My table included study goals, research questions, method justification, key findings, and impact overviews. As I worked on a study, I filled out a new column of information on the process in real time. When it came time to develop a research portfolio for permanent position interviews, I had an extensive list of projects to pull from that required no panicked “what did I do on that one??” It was all there, ready to be elaborated on. It made job presentations easier and also helped me build confidence in how much I had grown over the six months.</p><p>I also kept a list of how I was blending my academic skills with my growing industry skills in UX so that I could fluidly speak to that in interviews. If I wanted to show that my academic career was relevant to the new space, I had to find the vocabulary and applications to do so. <strong><em>By listing those things as I realized them, I was ready to answer anything in an interview.</em></strong></p><p><strong>Prepare for the long haul.</strong> The hardest part of the process was the waiting game. It’s easy to fall into the trap of thinking that you are a shoe-in for jobs because you know you have the skills, experience, and energy for the job. But be prepared that most industry folks don’t see years of education as working experience or skill building. The perception is that graduate school and even being a professor isn’t “real life,” and so you might be looked over for jobs that you are well suited for. It’s a bummer, but it’s a reality that many employers see you as either over- or under-qualified just because of those degrees. You will have to accept a lot of rejection for a lot of reasons.</p><p>If you can find some volunteer or freelance work that can build the bridge from academia to industry, take them…and then highlight the heck out of them. It will show that you have all that experience, skills, and abilities to step into the non-academic space and thrive. Post on LinkedIn what you’re doing, add it to your resume, ask for recommendations/referrals from these folks, ask them to post those recommendations on LinkedIn. <strong><em>Just keep building the narrative of your strengths in whatever form you can.</em></strong> Eventually, an employer will see the potential in you and give you a chance to shine.</p><p>For me, after what felt like hundreds of no’s, I was contacted by a local health system that was looking to grow its UX team. I was in the right place at the right time, and I had the record to demonstrate that I was a risk worth taking. I’ve been there since January 2023, and I continue to grow.</p><p>The long and short of it is that transitioning out of academia is a commitment: of time, of energy, of humility, and of selling yourself. I never found a shortcut, but if you do — let me know! It requires persistence and patience and a tolerance for hearing a lot of No’s before you get to the big YES. If you’re thinking of making this switch and want some help, reach out. I’m on LinkedIn at <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/dena-huisman/">https://www.linkedin.com/in/dena-huisman/</a>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9d5bbb52e5e6" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/after-academia/i-had-coffee-with-a-colleague-friend-one-day-and-i-said-i-think-im-done-9d5bbb52e5e6">Leaving the Academy: How I Transitioned into Industry at Mid-Career and How You Can, Too</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/after-academia">After Academia</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Three Principles of Ethical Research That UX Can Take From Academia]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/indeed-design/three-principles-of-ethical-research-that-ux-can-take-from-academia-2560f19609c5?source=rss-93260e7268d1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2560f19609c5</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[research-ethics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[product-research]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[user-testing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[user-experience]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[user-research]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Dena Huisman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 08 Feb 2023 15:36:35 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-03-10T14:55:40.200Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>3 Principles of Ethical Research That UX Can Take From Academia</h3><h4>Product users and research teams can both benefit from these techniques.</h4><figure><img alt="A hand upholds the center of a scale weighing two plates of sparkling thumbs-up tokens." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*DXsUKUbghC4nkMzH0aA_uQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>I cut my teeth as a researcher in an academic world. Since switching to UX research, I’ve been impressed by how dedicated UX researchers are to treating users with care and ethical concern, much like the researchers I met in academia. One of the highlights of working in the field is the diligent focus on the user and thoughtfulness about research topics and structures that most researchers share.</p><p>The good news is that there are proven approaches that any UX researcher can use to help make sure their studies are as ethical as possible. In academia, researchers use a straightforward system of checks and protocols that UX can easily adopt. Here, I want to share some of those techniques. It’s my personal opinion that these practices can help <a href="https://indeed.design/article/how-to-build-a-user-research-program/">UX researchers</a> ensure that their good intentions match the satisfaction, safety, and accessibility needs of their users. Read on to learn why, and how to implement them.</p><h3>What is ethical research?</h3><p>Let’s talk history first. <a href="https://www.hhs.gov/ohrp/regulations-and-policy/belmont-report/index.html">The Belmont Report</a>, published in 1979, was the first national effort to outline the basic principles of ethical standards in federally-funded research. It stemmed from some highly publicized ethical breaches made by scientists in pursuit of knowledge (for example, <a href="https://www.cdc.gov/tuskegee/timeline.htm">Tuskegee</a>, <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2015/01/rethinking-one-of-psychologys-most-infamous-experiments/384913/">Milgram’s authority study</a>, and others). Those principles — respect for persons, beneficence, and justice — are the standards in academic and governmental research.</p><p>Around the same time the Belmont Report was published, the International Chamber of Commerce used those same principles to develop a <a href="https://iccwbo.org/publication/iccesomar-international-code-on-market-and-social-research/">modified code of ethics</a> for market research. Sure, the scope of their work in market research is different from the more academic and federally funded research of the Belmont Report. But together, these reports provide useful context to build on current UX research ethics practices and procedures.</p><h3>Research principle 1: Respect people</h3><p>The Belmont Report established two factors that comprise the notion of respect for persons. First, individuals have the right to autonomy. Second, they have the right to protection from harm as autonomous agents.</p><h4>Give informed consent</h4><p>It’s easy to assume that participants know what they’re getting into when we recruit them to participate in our studies. We tell them a little about what they will be doing, and maybe we tell them they can leave if they want. But researchers can also take a bit more time to consider ensuring participants know exactly what they’re being asked to do, how their information will be used, who will see their information, and how they can withdraw from the study whenever they like.</p><p><a href="https://indeed.design/article/why-former-academics-make-great-ux-pros">Academic researchers</a> are expected to go over an official consent document with participants. Created by the Institutional Review Board, this document outlines participants’ rights, whom they can contact about questions that arise after the study is complete, what potential risks there are (if any), and what benefits they may receive from participating.</p><p>This may feel like an overstatement to UX researchers, but in practice it doesn’t have to be burdensome. Here’s what it can look like:</p><ul><li><strong>Before each study begins, outline the purpose of the study with your research team</strong> in an accessible document for participants. Clearly describe the potential risks (if any) of participating in the study. Include the contact information of the research lead or someone who can answer questions about their participation and highlight their rights as a participant. Perhaps most importantly, explain how their information and identity will be used and protected throughout the study and results report.</li><li><strong>At the beginning of any moderated study, ensure participants understand what to expect.</strong> Give participants an informed consent document, but take a few minutes to review the document with them line by line, too. Demonstrate to them that this isn’t just a signature form. It also clarifies your commitment to them as people and participants. This principle also is recommended by David Travis and Philip Hodgson in their book, <a href="https://uxresearchbook.com/">Think Like a UX Researcher</a>.</li><li><strong>Use language your participants can understand.</strong> Make sure it’s written in everyday language. In other words, don’t include research or industry-specific jargon. If you’re unsure whether the participants understand what they’re signing, ask them to repeat it back to you in their own words. Be sure to ask them what questions they have, and give them some time to think about whether they do.</li></ul><p>These steps might add a few minutes to an already packed testing schedule, but the payoff is in the trust you build with participants and their sense of security and equity in the process.</p><h4>Protect users’ privacy</h4><p>Help participants understand that the interviewer and their research team may not be the only people who see, hear, or read their responses. Other stakeholders, blog audiences, and conference attendees may also get access to their information. Even when anonymous, participants have the right to know who might later see or hear their interview during discussion of the study’s results. If you aren’t sure where all the information might end up, let them know the range of possibilities. The <a href="https://iccwbo.org/publication/iccesomar-international-code-on-market-and-social-research/">ICC research ethics</a> document further adds that explicit consent must be obtained if there is the potential of a participant’s identity being used. As an extra layer of care, I recommend taking these steps even if their identity will be inferred.</p><h3>Research principle 2: Do the most good and least harm</h3><p>Beyond the common respect for research participants, the Belmont Report suggests that the research must meet standards above the simple obligation to do no harm. Additionally, researchers should do all they can to maximize benefits and minimize harm. This one, too, may seem like an overstatement for UX research. The odds of doing harm are very low. We’re asking questions — not subjecting participants to psychological or medical procedures, or asking them to talk about personal experiences that trigger personal trauma. Still, the more trust we build in our participants and the more value we offer them, the more willing and able they are to give us their best insights.</p><h4>Maximize the benefits</h4><p>One great thing about UX research is the practice of compensating participants for their time with money or other tangible benefits. In academia, all I had to offer was a nice “thank you” at the end of an interview. But beyond the benefit of some cold, hard cash, UX researchers should consider highlighting for participants that their efforts will benefit all customers who will have a better experience thanks to them. People generally want to know they’re making the world a better place, no matter how niche. Stress what they stand to gain by working with you now on making an app easier to use. This is another way to help them see that their time doing these tests or interviews is helpful.</p><p><em>Is this article helpful? </em><a href="https://indeed.design/signup/"><em>Subscribe</em></a><em> to get occasional emails with new stories like it.</em></p><h4>Minimize the harm</h4><p>It’s difficult to define harm in a concise, clear way. Harm is possible in the course of our everyday lives, which may or may not be distinct from potential harms that arise while participating in a research study. How can we avoid either over- or understating risks of harm that participants may experience during our research projects? We aren’t likely to have a significant risk of harm beyond some participant frustration or embarrassment if our product isn’t very usable or if they can’t figure something out about the process or product.</p><p>To minimize the risk of harm, UX research teams can put plans and protocols in place should some aspect of a study hurt a participant or present some kind of danger to the study itself — either central or peripheral.</p><p>Once, while observing a virtual interview, a UX researcher friend of mine realized that the participant was having some kind of mental break from reality. The participant was saying nonsensical things, making comments unrelated to the topic of the interview, and began spiraling into conspiracy theories and talk about aliens. As a researcher, it’s easy to freeze at that moment, unsure whether to continue the interview as if nothing was happening or stop and figure out how to help the participant. Being virtual meant there was no physical risk to the researcher, but that wasn’t the case for the participant. What are the ethical and moral responsibilities of researchers to handle these kinds of situations? What are some steps we can take if a participant becomes unwell or exhibits unsafe behavior (to themselves or the researchers) during a test?</p><p>While it’s impossible to plan for every possible situation, thinking through how to respond to complications can ensure that both you and your participants are as safe as possible should that rare need arise. What would you do if your participant seemed to be in a physical or mental crisis? What steps would you take if a participant became angry or brought a weapon to the study? What procedures can you have in place to call for security or EMTs if the primary researcher is not able to do so? How can you ensure your participants know you will do your best to keep them safe?</p><p>Additionally, it might be a good practice to end studies by debriefing with the participant to ensure they feel comfortable with what they’ve contributed, and that any emotional responses they had to the product or process didn’t cause harm to their wellbeing. This kind of communication can build goodwill by demonstrating the company and researchers’ care for their participants.</p><h3>Research principle 3: Practice inclusivity to foster justice</h3><p>The last pillar of the Belmont Report focuses on how researchers can consider the needs of the population as a whole alongside the particular needs of groups who traditionally face marginalization or systemic bias and hate. In fact, one of the primary motivations behind the report was increased public awareness of the lack of care for social justice in significant research projects of the 20th century and before.</p><p><a href="https://www.cdc.gov/tuskegee/timeline.htm">The Tuskegee Study</a> is the infamous study that told Black men that they were being treated for “bad blood,” when in fact they were being monitored for and in some cases infected with syphilis. The goal of that research was to understand the progression of the disease, even though penicillin was an already known cure for syphilis. A less well-known study from 1939 at the <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2003/03/16/magazine/the-stuttering-doctor-s-monster-study.html">University of Iowa</a> taught orphaned children to stutter to discover whether speaking impediments could be taught and learned. They could, and the long-term implications were dire. These are just two examples.</p><p>The Belmont Report laid the groundwork for today’s understanding of research involving vulnerable populations. Under the guidance of these ethical principles, researchers must follow particularly stringent protocol guidelines to study children and adults who are not cognitively capable of understanding or providing consent to a study. Prisoners are also considered a vulnerable population due to the risk of coercion to participate for particular favors or benefits that may not serve the prisoner’s best interests.</p><p>Sure, UX research isn’t required to meet additional hurdles to study various populations, but by attending to some of these issues voluntarily, we can make sure our participants are well treated in our work.</p><h4>Take greater care with young minds</h4><p>Many apps, games, and other online tools target children, and properly understanding the usability of these tools must take that audience into account. When working with individuals under 18, UX researchers should work with parents or guardians to ensure that both they and their children fully understand the purpose and practice of the study. By talking to both parties at the same time about the study, researchers can ensure maximum comfort that minor participants will be treated ethically throughout the study. Depending on the study’s purpose, it might even be reasonable to allow the parent to stay in the room during the study.</p><h4>Account for cognitive complexities</h4><p>In UX research, we wouldn’t ask someone to participate in a study if we knew they were incapable of fully understanding and consenting to our research. Yet, as my friend’s example demonstrates, participants may not arrive cognitively or emotionally ready to participate. With all of these vague potentials and without obvious means of prevention, what’s a UX researcher to do?</p><ul><li><strong>Proceed with caution.</strong> Here’s another reason to review the informed consent form with more intentionality, as well as asking participants to rearticulate the primary aspects in their own words. Make sure you can gauge their ability to fully understand what they’re about to do in the study. If there are concerns, it’s worth your time to carefully explain again. If you sense there may be some impairment, there’s good reason to slow down and identify the root concern. While you don’t want to offend anyone by turning them away without completing the study, it might be reasonable to award their promised incentive and offer a pre-planned message for why the study needs to be terminated.</li><li><strong>UX teams can put a protocol of care in place</strong> if a participant experiences an emotional or mental break. What would the team do if emergency help was needed, if a participant threatened to harm themselves or others, or if something in the study triggers a trauma response? Given the range of topics and experiences that can trigger deep emotional reactions, it’s impossible to predict this happening, but far from unlikely that it might.</li></ul><h3>Ethics makes sense for users and business</h3><p>Engaging in research with humans is a fascinating and fruitful endeavor, whether in academic environments, governmental agency settings, or in industry UX research. As consumers, we face the frustration of interacting with products that have not clearly been tested for usability. As designers and researchers, we value the input that participants provide to make our products better.</p><p>We also share a common goal of wanting to treat participants with care and respect. The ideas here won’t create a new culture of ethics in UX research, but I hope they expand and solidify the culture that already exists to ensure that future participants receive as much protection and safety as possible.</p><p><em>Stay in touch. </em><a href="https://medium.com/indeed-design"><em>Follow our publication</em></a><em> on Medium and </em><a href="https://indeed.design/signup"><em>Subscribe to our newsletter</em></a><em> to get occasional emails about new articles. Learn about Indeed’s user experience team at </em><a href="http://indeed.design/"><em>indeed.design</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2560f19609c5" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/indeed-design/three-principles-of-ethical-research-that-ux-can-take-from-academia-2560f19609c5">Three Principles of Ethical Research That UX Can Take From Academia</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/indeed-design">Indeed Design</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>